Cities Index.
Item 7 - Award of Contract to Wright Const. Engineering Corp. for Springvale & Carlson Channel Rehab Bid 22-006 & Approp. of Add. Funds

Poway City Council
April 19, 2022

Document
Item 7 - Award of Contract to Wright Const. Engineering Corp. for Springvale & Carlson Channel Rehab Bid 22-006 & Approp. of Add. Funds
Meeting
April 19, 2022
Body
Poway City Council
Pages
11
Original file
27 KB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on portal.laserfiche.com. That file is the official record.

April 19, 2022, Item #7
~' AGENDA REPORT CityofPoway
,,,.,~Till ' CITY cou NCI L
DATE:

TO:

FROM:

CONTACT:

April 19, 2022
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Robert Manis, Director of Development Services /JA
Jeff Beers, Special Projects Engineer $
(858) 668-4624 or [email protected]
SUBJECT: Award of Contract to Wright Construction Engineering Corp for the Springvale and Carlson Channel Rehabilitation Project; Bid No. 22-006 and Appropriation of Additional Funds
Summary:

This action will award a construction contract for the Springvale and Carlson Channel Rehabilitation project. Because the lowest responsible bidder exceeds the available budget, an additional appropriation is necessary in order to award the project. The project involves the rehabilitation of two stormwater channels.

Recommended Action:

It is recommended that the City Council appropriate $89,981.30 from the Drainage Fund (2310) to the Springvale and Carlson Channel Rehabilitation project (DR006) and award the contract for the Springvale and Carlson Channel Rehabilitation project to Wright Construction Engineering Corp., the lowest responsible and responsive bidder, in the amount of $218,000.00 (Attachment A).

Discussion:

The scope of work for the Springvale and Carlson Channel Rehabilitation project includes the rehabilitation of two stormwater channels. The Carlson channel scope will remove and replace various sections of channel that have been damaged by adjacent tree roots causing uplifting. The trees are to be removed as a portion of the scope of work. The Springvale channel scope of work includes construction of a concrete overlay over the asphalt concrete lining along with localized repairs. Repair of these two channels is necessary to ensure they function properly which minimizes chances of potential flooding.

The contract time for this project is 20 working days with an Engineer's Estimate of $140,000. Bids were opened on March 24, 2022. The following three bids were received:

Company Total Bid Amount
Wright Construction Engineering Corp $218,000.00
Bosco Constructors, Inc. $218,710.00
A.B. Hashmi, Inc. $275,000.00
1 of 11
April 19, 2022, Item #7
The
lowest
responsible
bid
received
by
Wright
Construction
Engineering
Corp
is
$78,000
above
the
engineer's
estimate.

The
engineer's
estimate
was
based
upon
a
recently
completed
concrete
channel
rehabilitation
project
of
similar
scope
and
size.

The
increased
bid
amount
is
likely
due
to
escalating
costs
in
material.

The
available
project
budget
is
$149,818.70
which
is
insufficient
for
the
bid
amount.

An
appropriation
of
$89,981.30
is
being
requested
to
cover
the
remaining
amount
needed
along
with
a
10%
construction
contingency.

Environmental
Review:

The
proposed
project
is
Categorically
Exempt
from
the
California
Environmental
Quality
Act
(CEQA)
as
a Class
1 Categorical
Exemption,
pursuant
to
Section
15301
of
the
CEQA
Guidelines,
in
that
the
project
involves
minor
alterations
consisting
of
replacement
of
existing
equipment.

Fiscal
Impact:

There
is
insufficient
funding
available
in
the
Springvale
and
Carlson
Channel
Rehabilitation
project
account
(DR006)
to
award
the
contract.

An
appropriation
of
$89,981.30
from
the
Drainage
Fund
(2310)
will
provide
the
necessary
funds
for
the
contract
award
along
with
a
10%
construction
contingency.

Sufficient
funds
are
available
in
the
drainage
fund
for
this
request.

After
the
contract
is
awarded,
funds
in
the
amount
of
$21,800.00
will
be
available
for
construction
contingency
should
it
be
needed
.

Public
Notification:

None. Attachments: A.

Contract
Reviewed/
Approved
By:

Assistant
City
Manager
2 of
11 Reviewed
By:

Alan
Fenstermacher
City
Attorney
Approved
By:
c~ City
Manager
April 19, 2022, Item #7
SECTION 8

CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT

CITY OF POWAY

SPRINGVALE AND CARLSON CHANNEL REHABILITATION
This Contract made and entered into this 19 day of April, 2022, by and between City of Poway, a municipal corporation of the State of California, hereinafter referred to as "City" and Wright Construction Engineering Corp., hereinafter referred to as "Contractor." The City and the Contractor, for the consideration hereinafter named, mutually agree as follows:

1. The complete Contract includes all of the Contract Documents, which are incorporated herein by this reference, and include:
a. This Contract
b. Contract Addenda
c. Contract Change Orders
d. Instructions to Bidders, Proposal Requirements and Conditions e. Contract Specifications
f. Contract Plans
g. General Condition
h. Special Conditions
i. Standard Specification for Public Works, most current edition,

2. The Contract Documents are complementary, and that which is required by one shall be as binding as if required by all.

3. Contractor shall provide and furnish all labor, materials, necessary tools, expendable equipment, and all utility and transportation services required for the following work of improvement:

Project includes the rehabilitation of two open storm drain channels in the City of Poway. The first is a concrete overlay of an existing asphalt lined channel and the second is localized concrete removal and replacement in a trapezoidal channel.

4. Contractor agrees to perform all the said work and furnish all the said materials at his own cost and expense that are necessary to construct and complete in strict conformance with Contract Documents and to the satisfaction of the City Engineer, the work hereinafter set forth in accordance with the Contract adopted by the City Council.
3 of 11 ATTACHMENT A
1 April 19, 2022, Item #7

5. City
agrees
to
pay
and
Contractor
agrees
to
accept
in
full
payment
for
performance
of
this
work
of
improvement
as
described,
the
stipulated
sum
of
$218,000.00
the
"Contract
Price."
City
agrees
to
make
progress
payments
and
final
payment
in
accordance
with
the
method
set
forth
in
the
Special
Provisions.

6. Contractor
agrees
to
commence
construction
of
the
work
provided
for
herein
within
Fifteen
(15)
Calendar
Days
after
the
date
specified
in
the
Notice
to
Proceed,
and
to
continue
diligently
in
strict
conformance
with
Contract
Documents
and
without
interruption,
and
to
complete
the
construction
thereof
within
20 Working
Days
after
the
date
specified
in
the
Notice
to
Proceed.

7. Time
is
of
the
essence
of
this
Contract,
and
it
is
agreed
that
it
would
be
impracticable
or
extremely
difficult
to
ascertain the
extent
of
actual
loss
or
damage
which
the
City
will
sustain
by
reason
of
any
delay
in
the
performance
of
this
Contract.

It
is,
therefore,
agreed
that
Contractor
will
pay
as
liquidated
damages
to
the
City
the
following
sum
of
$500.00
per
Calendar
Day,
for
each
and
every
Calendar
Days
delay
in
finishing
the
Work
in
excess
of
the
number
of
Working
Days
prescribed
above.

If
liquidated
damages
are
not
paid,
as
assessed
by
the
City,
the
City
may
deduct
the
amount
thereof
from
any
money
due
or
that
may
become
due
the
Contractor
under
this
Contract
in
addition
to
any
other
remedy
available
to
City.

By
executing
this
Contract,
Contractor
agrees
that
the
amount
of
liquidated
damages
is
reasonable
and
shall
not
constitute
a
penalty.

8. In
accordance
with
State
of
California
Senate
Bill
No.
854,
Contractor
will
maintain
and
will
require
all
subcontractors
to
maintain
valid
and
current
Department
of
Industrial
Relations
(DIR)
Public
Works
Contractor
registration
during
the
term
of
this
project.

Contractor
shall
notify
the
City
in
writing
immediately,
and
in
no
case
more
than
twenty-four
(24)
hours,
after
receiving
any
information
that
Contractor's
or
any
of
its
Subcontractor's
DIR
registration
status
has been
suspended,
revoked,
expired,
or
otherwise
changed.

9. Contractor
will
pay
, and
will
require
all
subcontractors
to
pay,
all
employees
on
said
Contract
a
salary
or
wage
at
least
equal
to
the
prevailing
salary
or
wage
established
for
such
work
as
set
forth
in
the
wage
determinations
and
wage
standards
applicable
to
this
work,
a
copy
of
which
is
on
file
in
the
office
of
the
City
Clerk
of
the
City
of
Poway.

Federal
prevailing
wage
rates
apply
for
federally
funded
projects.

Travel
and
subsistence
pay
shall
be
paid
in
accordance
with
Labor
Code
§
1773.1.

10. Contractor
shall
be
subject
to
the
penalties
in
accordance
with
Labor
Code
of
§
1775
for
each
worker
paid
(either
by
him
or
by
any
subcontractors
under
him)
less
than
the
prevailing
rate
described
above
on
the
work
provided
for
in
this
Contract.

11. Contractor
and
subcontractors
shall
comply
with
Labor
Code
§
1810
and
§
1811
which
stipulates
that
eight
hours
labor
constitutes
a
legal
day's
work,
and
§
1812
4 of
11 2
April 19, 2022, Item #7
which
stipulates
that
the
Contractor
and
subcontractors
shall
keep
an
accurate
record
showing
the
name
of
and
actual
hours
worked
each
calendar
day
and
each
calendar
week
by
each
worker
employed
by
him
in
connection
with
the
work
performed
under
the
terms
of
the
Contract.

Failure
to
comply
with
these
sections
of
the
Labor
Code
will
subject
the
Contractor
to
penalty
and
forfeiture
provisions
of
the
Labor
Code§
1813.

12. Contractor
will
comply
with
the
provisions
of
Labor
Code§
1777
.5
pertaining
to
the
employment
of
apprentices
to
the
extent
applicable
to
this
Contract.

13. Contractor,
by
executing
this
Contract,
hereby
certifies:
"I
am
aware
of
and
will
comply
with
the
Labor
Code
§
3700
by
securing
payment for
and
maintaining
in
full
force
and
effect
for
the
duration
of
the
contract,
complete
Workers'
Compensation
Insurance,
and
shall
furnish
a
Certificate
of
Insurance
to
the
City
before
execution
of
the
Contract.

The
City,
its
officers,
or
employees,
will
not
be
responsible
for
any
claims
in
law
or
equity
occasioned
by
failure
of
the
Contractor
to
comply
with
this
paragraph."
Contractor
further
agrees
to
require
all
subcontractors
to
carry
Workers'
Compensation
Insurance
as
required
by
the
Labor
Code
of
the
State
of
California.

14. Contractor shall,
concurrent
with
the
execution
of
this
Contract,
furnish
two
bonds
approved
by
the
City,
one
in
the
amount
of
One
Hundred
Percent
(100%)
of
the
Contract
Price,
to
guarantee
the
faithful
performance
of
the
work
("Performance
Bond"),
and
one
in
the
amount
of
One
Hundred
Percent
(100%)
of
the
Contract
Price
to
guarantee
payment
of
all
claims
for
labor
and
materials
furnished
("Payment
Bond").

This
Contract
shall
not
become
effective
until
such
bonds
are
supplied
to
and
approved
by
the
City.

15. a.

Contractor
shall
procure
and
maintain
at
its
own
expense,
until
completion
of
performance,
commercial
general
liability
insurance
of
not
less
than
One
Million
Dollars
($1,000,000)
combined
single
limit
per
occurrence,
and
Two
Million
Dollars
($2,000,000)
in
the aggregate,
for
bodily
injury,
personal
injury,
death,
loss
or
damage
resulting
from
the
wrongful
or
negligent
acts
by
the
Contractor
or
its
officers,
employees,
servants,
volunteers
and
agents
and
independent
contractors.

Contractor
shall
provide
insurance
on
an
occurrence,
not
claims­
made
basis.

Contractor
acknowledges
and
agrees
that,
for
purposes
of
clarification
with
the
intention
of
avoiding
gaps
in
coverage
with
any
umbrella
or
excess
insurance,
personal
and
advertising
injury
coverage
shall
be
triggered
by
an
"offense"
while
bodily
injury
and
property
damage
coverage
shall
be
triggered
by
an
"occurrence"
during
the
policy
period.
b.

Contractor
shall
further
procure
and
maintain
at
its
own
expense,
until
completion
of
performance,
commercial
vehicle
liability
insurance
covering
personal
injury
and
property
damage,
of
not
less
than
One
Million
Dollars
($1,000,000)
combined
5 of
11 3
April 19, 2022, Item #7
single
limit
per
occurrence,
and
Two
Million
Dollars
($2,000,000)
in
the aggregate,
covering
any
vehicle
utilized
by
Contractor
or
its
officers,
employees,
servants,
volunteers
and
agents
and
independent
contractors
in
performing
the
services
required
by
this
Agreement.
c.

Contractor
shall
further
procure
and
maintain
at
its
expense,
until
completion
of
performance,
workers'
compensation
insurance
providing
coverage
as
required
by
the
California
State
Workers'
Compensation
Law.

If
any
class
of
employees
employed
by
the
Contractor
pursuant
to
this
Agreement
is
not
protected
by
the
California
State
Workers'
Compensation
Law,
Contractor
shall
provide
adequate
insurance
for
the
protection
of
such
employees
to
the
satisfaction
of
the
City
. This
provision
shall not
apply
if
Contractor
has
no
employees
performing
work
under
this
Agreement.

Contractor
agrees
to
waive
its
statutory
immunity
under
any
worker's
compensation
or
similar
statute,
as
respecting
the
City,
and
to
require
any
and
all
subcontractors
and
any
other
person
or
entity
involved
with
the
Project
to
do
the
same.

Worker's
Compensation
Insurance:
o
Contractor
has
no
employees
and
is
exempt
from
workers'
compensation
requirements.
o
Contractor
carries
workers'
compensation
insurance
for
all
employees.
d.

All
policies
required
by
this
section
shall
be
secured
from
insurers
authorized
to
do
business
in
the
State
of
California
with
an
"A"
policyholder's
rating
or
better
and
a
financial
rating
of
at
least
Class
VI
I,
in
accordance
with
the
current
Best's
Ratings.
e.

Contractor
agrees
to
require
that
all
parties,
including
but
not
limited
to
subcontractors
, architects,
engineers
or
others
with
whom
Contractor
enters
into
contracts
or
whom
Contractor
hires
or
retains
pursuant
to
or
in
any
way
related
to
the
performance
of
this
Agreement,
provide
the
insurance
coverage
required
herein,
at
minimum,
and,
except
for
worker's
compensation
coverage,
name
as
additional
insureds
the
parties
to
this
Agreement.

Contractor
agrees
to
monitor
and
review
all
such
coverage
and
assumes
all
responsibility
for
ensuring
that
such
coverage
is
provided
in
conformity
with
the
requirements
of
this
Section.
f.

In
the
event
this
Agreement
is
terminated
for
any
reason
prior
to
the
completion
of
all
obligations
and
requirements
of
this
Agreement,
Contractor
agrees
to
maintain
all
coverages
required
herein
until
the
City
provides
written
authorization
to
terminate
the
coverages
following
the
City's
review
and
determination
that
all
liability
posed
under
this
Agreement
as
to
the
party
providing
insurance
has
been
eliminated.
g.

Contractor
agrees
and
acknowledges
that
if
it
fails
to
obtain
all
of
the
insurance
required
in
this
Agreement
in
accordance
with
the
requirements
herein,
or
to
obtain
and
ensure
that
the
coverage
required
herein
is
maintained
by
any
subcontractors
or
others
involved
in
any
way
with
the
Project,
Contractor
shall
be
responsible
for
any
losses,
claims,
suits,
damages,
defense
obligations,
or
liability
of
any
kind
or
6 of
11 4
April 19, 2022, Item #7
nature attributable to the City, and/or its officers, employees, servants, volunteers, agents and independent contractors, that result from such failure by Contractor.

16. a. Contractor shall provide certificates of insurance with original endorsements to the City as evidence of the insurance coverage required herein. Certificates of such insurance shall be filed with the City on or before commencement of performance of this Agreement. Current certification of insurance shall be kept on file with the City at all times until completion of performance and acceptance by the City.
b. Notwithstanding any inconsistent statement in any required insurance policies or any subsequent endorsements attached thereto, the commercial general liability and commercial vehicle liability policies shall bear endorsements whereby it is provided that the City, and its officers, employees, servants, volunteers, agents and independent contractors are named as additional insureds. Additional insureds shall be entitled to the full benefit of all insurance policies in the same manner and to the same extent as any other insureds and there shall be no limitation to the benefits conferred upon them other than policy limits to coverages. c. Contractor shall require the carriers of all required insurance policies to waive all rights of subrogation against the City, and its officers, employees, servants, volunteers, agents and independent contractors.
d. Each policy required herein must be endorsed to provide that the policy shall not be cancelled in coverage or limits (except by paid claims) unless the insurer has provided the City with 30 days prior written notice of cancellation. Contractor agrees to provide the City with 30 days written notice prior to any non-renewal or reduction in coverage or limits.
e. All insurance policies required to be provided by Contractor or any other party must be endorsed to provide that the policies shall apply on a primary and noncontributing basis in relation to any insurance or self-insurance, primary or excess, maintained or available to the City, and its officers, employees, servants, volunteers, agents and independent contractors.

17. a. Contractor shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless the City, its officers, 7 of 11
officials, agents, employees and volunteers from and against any and all claims, demands, actions, losses, damage, injuries, and liability, direct or indirect (including any and all costs and expenses in connection therewith) to the extent actually caused by the negligence of Contractor, Contractor's employees, subcontractors or independent contractors except for any such claim arising out of the negligence or willful misconduct of the City, or its officers, agents, employees or volunteers.
b. The City does not, and shall not, waive any rights that it may have against Contractor under this Section because of the acceptance by the City, or the deposit with the City, of any insurance policy or certificate required pursuant to this Agreement. The hold harmless, indemnification and duty to defend provisions of 5 April 19, 2022, Item #7
this Section shall apply regardless of whether or not said insurance policies are determined to be applicable to the claim, demand, action, damage, liability, loss, cost or expense described herein.

18. Any amendments to any of the Contract Documents, including but not limited to Contract Change Orders, must be in writing executed by the Contractor and the City. Any time an approval, time extension, or consent of the City is required under the Contract Documents, such approval, extension, or consent must be in writing in order to be effective.

19. The Contract Documents contain all of the agreements and understandings of the parties and all previous understandings, negotiations, and contracts are integrated into and superseded by this Contract.

20. In the event that any one or more of the phrases, sentences, clauses, paragraphs, or sections contained in this Contract shall be declared invalid or unenforceable by a valid judgment or decree of a court of competent jurisdiction, such invalidity or unenforceability shall not affect any of the remaining phrases, sentences, clauses, paragraphs, or sections of this Contract which are hereby declared as severable and shall be interpreted to carry out the intent of the parties hereunder.

21. The persons executing this Contract on behalf of the parties hereto warrant that they are duly authorized to execute this Contract on behalf of said parties and that, by so executing this Contract, the parties hereto are formally bound to the provisions of this Contract.

22. This Contract shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective heirs, personal representatives, successors, and assigns.

23. In performing its obligations and duties under this Contract, each party shall comply with all applicable local, state, and federal laws, regulations, rules, standards and ordinances.

24. This Contract may be executed by the parties in counterparts, which counterparts shall be construed together and have the same effect as if all of the parties had executed the same instrument.

25. After completion of the work contemplated by this Contract, Contractor shall file with the City Manager an affidavit stating that all workers and persons employed, all firms supplying materials, and all subcontractors upon the project have been paid in full, and that there are no claims outstanding against the project for either labor or materials, except certain items, if any, to be set forth in an affidavit covering disputed claims or items in connection with a Stop Notice that has been filed under the provision of the laws of the State of California.

26. All work shall be subject to inspection and testing by City and its authorized representatives during manufacture and construction and all other times and places, including, without limitation, the plans of Contractor and any of its suppliers. 8 of 11
6 April 19, 2022, Item #7
Contractor
shall
provide
all
reasonable
facilities
and
assistance
for
the
safety
and
convenience
of
inspectors.

All
inspections
and
tests
shall
be
performed
in
such
manner
as
to
not
unduly
delay
the
work.

The
Work
shall
be
subject
to final
inspection
and
acceptance
notwithstanding
any
payments
or
other
prior
inspections.

Such
final
inspection
shall
be
made
within
a
reasonable
time
after
completion
of
the
work.

27. Whenever
Contractor
has
knowledge
that
any
actual
or
potential
labor
dispute
is
delaying
or
threatens
to
delay
the
timely
performance
of
the
Contract,
Contractor
shall
immediately
give
notice
thereof,
including
all
relevant
information
with
respect
thereto,
to
City.

28. Contractor
agrees
to
contact
the
appropriate
regional
notification
center
in
accordance
with
Government
Code
Section
4216.2.

29. Contractor
shall
submit
its
detailed
plan
for
worker
protection
during
the
excavation
of
trenches
required
by
the
scope
of
the
work
in
accordance
with
Labor
Code
Section
6705.

30. a.

Contractor
shall,
without
disturbing
the
condition,
notify
City,
in
writing,
as
9 of
11 soon
as
Contractor,
or
any
of
Contractor's
subcontractors,
agents,
or
employees
have
knowledge
and
reporting
is
possible,
of
the
discovery
of
any
of
the
following
conditions:
i.

The
presence
of
any
material
that
Contractor
believes
is
hazardous
waste,
as
defined
in
Section
25117
of
the
Health
and
Safety
Code:
ii.

Subsurface
or
latent
physical
conditions
at
the
site
differing
from
those
indicated
in
the
specifications:
or
iii.

Unknown
physical
conditions
at
the
site
of
any
unusual
nature,
different
materially
for
those
ordinarily
encountered
and
generally
recognized
as
inherent
in
work
of
the
character
provided
for
in
this
Contract.
b.

Pending
a
determination
by
City
of
appropriate
action
to
be
taken,
Contractor
shall
provide
security
measures
(e.g.,
fences)
adequate
to
prevent
the
hazardous
waste
or
physical
conditions
from
causing
bodily
injury
to
any
person.
c.

City
shall
promptly
investigate
the
reported
conditions.

If
City,
through
and
in
the
exercise
of
its
sole
discretion,
determines
that
the
conditions
do
materially
differ
or
do
involve
hazardous
waste,
and
will
cause
a
decrease
or
increase
in
Contractor's
cost
of,
or
time
required
for,
performance
of
any
part
of
the
work,
then
City
shall
issue
a
change
order.
d.

In
the
event
of a
dispute
between
City
and
Contractor
as
to
whether
the
conditions
materially
differ,
or
involve
hazardous
waste,
or
cause
a
decrease
or
increase
in
Contractor's
cost
of,
or
time
required
for,
performance
of
any
part
of
the
work,
Contractor
shall not
be
excused
from
any
scheduled
completion
date,
7 April 19, 2022, Item #7
and
shall
proceed
with
all
work
to
be
performed
under
the
contract.

Contractor
shall
retain
any
and
all
rights
that
pertain
to
the
resolution
of
disputes
and
protests
between
the
parties.

31. This
Contract
is
to
be
governed
by
the
laws
of
the
State
of
California.

32. All
work
shall
be
guaranteed
for
a
period
of
one
(1)
year
from
the
date
of
acceptance
by
the
City.

Contractor
shall
promptly
make
all
needed
repairs
arising
out
of
defective
materials,
workmanship,
and
equipment.

City
is
hereby
authorized
to
make
such
repairs
if within
ten
(10)
days
after
giving
written
notice
to
Contractor,
or
its
agent,
Contractor
should
fail
to
make
or
undertake
with
due
diligence
the
aforesaid
repairs;
provided,
however,
that
in
case
of
an
emergency,
where,
in
the
opinion
of
City,
delay
would
cause
serious
loss
or
damage,
repairs
may
be
made
without
notice
being
sent
to
Contractor,
and
Contractor
shall
pay
the
costs
thereof.
(Remainder
of
page
intentionally
left
blank)
10 of
11 8
April 19, 2022, Item #7
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Contractor and the City Manager, City Clerk and City Attorney have caused the names of said parties to be affixed hereto, the day and year first above written.

Contractor's Name:

Print Name of Construction Company
By: ----------­
Signature
Print Name
Contractor information:

Address for Notices and Payments
Telephone Number: ______ _
Email: ------------
ATTEST:

Carrie Gallagher, CMC, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:

RUTAN & TUCKER, LLP
Alan Fenstermacher, City Attorney
11 of 11

CITY OF POWAY
a Municipal Corporation
Chris Hazeltine, City Manager
9

← All documents from this meeting