Richmond City Council
November 1, 2022

Exhibit 2 - Garbage Lien Resolution
-------------------------
I certify that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the Council of the City of Richmond, California at a regular meeting thereof held November 1, 2022 by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTENTIONS:

ABSENT:

Clerk of the City of Richmond

(SEAL)

Approved:

Mayor

Approved as to form:

City Attorney

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 1 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4053600575
TAYLOR MALIKAH C 2698 LONGVIEW DR 2698 LONGVIEW DR 22/05 369.08 45.00 414.08 RICHMOND CA 94806
4053810760
TEJADA CARLOS A 2346 HIGHGATE DR 2346 HIGHGATE DR 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94806
4054700473
CHEUNG MUAN CHOY 2445 GROVEVIEW CT 2445 GROVEVIEW CT 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055500096
LEWIS RISHA L 3958 SELMI GRV 3958 SELMI GRV 22/05 363.02 45.00 408.02 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055600052
HARRISON CLAUDE E III & AUDREY 753 ROCK ROSE WAY 753 ROCK ROSE WAY 22/05 232.72 45.00 277.72 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055700365
DEERING JAHCOREE 1204 COSMOS CT 1204 COSMOS CT 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056500368
KHOURCHECH NADIR TRE 1136 ARROWHEAD CT 1136 ARROWHEAD CT 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056600432
BENOIT SCHIRRELL ANN 5345 EAGLE CT 5345 EAGLE CT 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056600762
ZEITER MATTHEW M 5017 MATCH CT 5017 MATCH CT 22/05 367.79 45.00 412.79 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056800016
PATEL SAILESH & FALGUNIBIN 5660 VISTA DR 5660 VISTA DR 22/05 366.68 45.00 411.68 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080330154
SINGLETON MICHELLE 617 GRIFFIN DR 617 GRIFFIN DR 22/05 368.40 45.00 413.40 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 2 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4080430020
HALES SYLVANIA PO BOX 6884 3916 JENKINS WAY 22/05 368.22 45.00 413.22 SAN PABLO CA 94806
4080430160
RANDLE SHIRLEY J 604 JOHNSON DR 604 JOHNSON DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080430186
DAGLOW PATRICIA L 612 JOHNSON DR 612 JOHNSON DR 22/05 352.60 45.00 397.60 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140310022
EASILEY CARL L JR 2934 GROOM DR 2934 GROOM DR 22/05 299.52 45.00 344.52 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140320013
FORD JANICE G 2940 MULLENS DR 2940 MULLENS DR 22/05 294.36 45.00 339.36 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140520141
GARCIA JUAN 2980 MC KENZIE DR 2980 MC KENZIE DR 22/05 121.36 45.00 166.36 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140710098
BOYD TERRENCE O 3141 JO ANN DR 3141 JO ANN DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140940109
MAHARAJ ROSHILLA & SHIV 2944 MOYERS RD 2944 MOYERS RD 22/05 385.01 45.00 430.01 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140950025
URIARTEAVILES JULIO ALFONSO 3004 MOYERS RD 3004 MOYERS RD 22/05 369.88 45.00 414.88 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141420234
WANDRICK JURENE TRE 2541 DUKE AVE 2541 DUKE AVE 22/05 493.86 45.00 538.86 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142210121
RODRIGUEZ JORGE 3011 WISWALL DR 3011 WISWALL DR 22/05 353.50 45.00 398.50 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 3 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4142310053
NEGRETE VERONICA 3017 COLETTE DR 3017 COLETTE DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142520057
JOHNSON MODISTINE 3019 BARKLEY DR 3019 BARKLEY DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142530114
YOUNG BARBARA C TRE 2900 BARKLEY DR 2900 BARKLEY DR 22/05 382.62 45.00 427.62 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142710112
STARKS WELDON C SR & ADA M 3040 BELFAST WAY 3040 BELFAST WAY 22/05 397.63 45.00 442.63 RICHMOND CA 94806
4143210153
MBAYE PENDA 4070 MOZART DR 4070 MOZART DR 22/05 367.51 45.00 412.51 RICHMOND CA 94803
4191950023
MAHMOUD ADEL M JR 6305 JERILYNN AVE 6305 JERILYNN AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94806
4202020188
MARTINEZ SAMUEL 7 CANARY LN 7 CANARY LN 22/05 368.02 45.00 413.02 RICHMOND CA 94803
4262910047
DUNCAN DOROTHY MARIE 861 PARKSIDE DR 861 PARKSIDE DR 22/05 276.47 45.00 321.47 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263210330
TRAYLOR BARRY 1009 VIEW DR 1009 VIEW DR 22/05 367.79 45.00 412.79 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263220289
GARCIA JOSE N & VIRGINIA H 1080 PARKSIDE DR 1080 PARKSIDE DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263520068
BELL TAMI A 1201 GREENWAY DR 1201 GREENWAY DR 22/05 351.44 45.00 396.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 4 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4263530141
HENDERSON WILLIAM FRANKLIN TRE 1208 GREENWAY DR 1208 GREENWAY DR 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263610091
RICHARDSON JEROME & WANDA W 1291 PARKWAY DR 1291 PARKWAY DR 22/05 367.97 45.00 412.97 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263620116
PRINGLE KIRA NICOLE PO BOX 1032 1201 PARKWAY CT 22/05 201.18 45.00 246.18 PINOLE CA 94564
4263710354
BLUITT ANDRE M & CLAIRE E 1317 PARK CENTRAL CT 1317 PARK CENTRAL CT 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311000808
KUO CHENG SHIANG 1510 BONITA RD 2905 SALVINO CT 22/05 367.54 45.00 412.54 SAN PABLO CA 94806
4311530036
GALVEZ WILLIAM D 4465 FRAN WAY 4465 FRAN WAY 22/05 1,352.81 45.00 1,397.81 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311620225
WILLIAMS SUZANNE D 4595 FRAN WAY 4595 FRAN WAY 22/05 693.86 45.00 738.86 RICHMOND CA 94803
4312900428
TORRES ARTURO & ELSA 2 WILDWOOD CT 2 WILDWOOD CT 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
4313520175
LION PROPERTY GROUP LLC 3506 RIDGEWOOD CT 3801 PAINTED PONY RD 22/05 935.54 45.00 980.54 FAIRFIELD CA 94534
4313920243
JIANG CHING-YI & YU-CHUN TRE 113 S SONRISA ST 3700 BLACK FEATHER DR 22/05 354.65 45.00 399.65 MOUNTAIN HOUSE CA 95391
4333610048
SUDDUTH TRENT & CHERYL 5 POWDER BOWL CT 5 POWDER BOWL CT 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 5 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4334030030
POURMOHAMAD HOUSHANG TRE 1105 SILVER BELT DR 1105 SILVER BELT DR 22/05 975.89 45.00 1,020.89 RICHMOND CA 94803
4352240057
REYNAGA EDUARDO 2168 LA MIRADA DR 2168 LA MIRADA DR 22/05 223.01 45.00 268.01 RICHMOND CA 94803
4352920047
FUSTON MICHAEL & JACQUELINE 2249 BRISTLECONE DR 2249 BRISTLECONE DR 22/05 385.15 45.00 430.15 RICHMOND CA 94803
4353100011
GARCIA MIGUEL 5497 ALLISON LN 5497 ALLISON LN 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94803
5070200042
PAULDING JOHN TRE 5648 BURLINGAME AVE 5648 BURLINGAME AVE 22/05 189.73 45.00 234.73 RICHMOND CA 94804
5070600019
BROWN TEYA R 1700 MENDOCINO ST 1700 MENDOCINO ST 22/05 300.34 45.00 345.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5080510166
GREEN GEORJENA MCDANIEL 1338 MONTEREY ST 1338 MONTEREY ST 22/05 382.45 45.00 427.45 RICHMOND CA 94804
5081600024
MCDONALD RACHEL 1407 MONTEREY ST 1407 MONTEREY ST 22/05 688.69 45.00 733.69 RICHMOND CA 94804
5082210161
HOWARD YOLANDA M 1640 MARIPOSA ST 1640 MARIPOSA ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5092100105
JOHNSON DELORES A 1059 S 55TH ST 1059 S 55TH ST 22/05 340.33 45.00 385.33 RICHMOND CA 94804
5092300325
HENDRIX BOBBY L & PAMELA J TRE 5020 FLEMING AVE 5020 FLEMING AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 6 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5093100161
HENDERSON RHODNEY DEWAINE SR 819 S 49TH ST 819 S 49TH ST 22/05 383.34 45.00 428.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093300019
BLACKMORE CLARK L 4616 CYPRESS AVE 4616 CYPRESS AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093500014
HARTWELL JOSEPHINE TRE 2813 CENTER AVE 929 S 46TH ST 22/05 353.52 45.00 398.52 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093500220
HELUSHKA HUSSAN FAMILY TRUST PO BOX 1847 928 S 45TH ST 22/05 263.27 45.00 308.27 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5093600236
LAND VIEW LLC 216 DANTLEY WAY 910 CARLSON BLVD 22/05 253.38 45.00 298.38 WALNUT CREEK CA 94598
5094000055
HENDERSON RHODNEY & SUNDRA 805 S 41ST ST 805 S 41ST ST 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94804
5100810588
MARTINEZ SANDRA Y TRE 5200 VAN FLEET AVE 5200 VAN FLEET AVE 22/05 300.34 45.00 345.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130210148
ALFARO PATRICIA 2707 OHIO AVE 2707 OHIO AVE 22/05 75.78 45.00 120.78 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130210213
GONZALEZ SALVADOR 2132 COSTA AVE 2827 OHIO AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5130320186
CORONA RAFAEL M 825 ELM DR 2916 OHIO AVE 22/05 456.79 45.00 501.79 RODEO CA 94572
5130340168
ANDREWS CHAD 136 S 31ST ST 136 S 31ST ST 22/05 734.87 45.00 779.87 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 7 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5130360190
FOKUS INVESTMENTS INC 94 GLENWOOD 3136 FLORIDA AVE 22/05 639.04 45.00 684.04 HERCULES CA 94547
5130520199
JONES STEVEN 3529 WALLER AVE 3529 WALLER AVE 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130620015
BLACKMORE CLARK L SR 271 S 39TH ST 271 S 39TH ST 22/05 367.61 45.00 412.61 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130740136
BARBER RODERICK 123 S 39TH ST 123 S 39TH ST 22/05 356.62 45.00 401.62 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130760142
WONG SUN SHUI 923 CENTRAL AVE 161 S 41ST ST 22/05 357.79 45.00 402.79 ALAMEDA CA 94501
5131010174
BYNUM HENRY ALLEN 4429 FLORIDA AVE 4429 FLORIDA AVE 22/05 302.26 45.00 347.26 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131110057
ROBINSON APRIL L 255 S 43RD ST 255 S 43RD ST 22/05 723.10 45.00 768.10 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131200148
WAFER ODESSA 264 S 44TH ST 264 S 44TH ST 22/05 167.84 45.00 212.84 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131200155
MEADOWS ANNIE RUTH 270 S 44TH ST 270 S 44TH ST 22/05 253.23 45.00 298.23 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131320086
WILLIAMS MATTIE M 4415 OVEREND AVE 4415 OVEREND AVE 22/05 608.94 45.00 653.94 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131320268
DAVENPORT EDDIE L & BARBARA J 4340 TAFT AVE 4340 TAFT AVE 22/05 46.59 45.00 91.59 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 8 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5131510306
RUIZ RUBEN D 415 S 38TH ST 415 S 38TH ST 22/05 300.54 45.00 345.54 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131630039
JUNIEL CASSANDRA 380 S 34TH ST 380 S 34TH ST 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94804
5132930073
BARRETT MARION D 4610 ESCUELA CT 4610 ESCUELA CT 22/05 50.62 45.00 95.62 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133810100
BROOKS-WRIGHT ANN F 263 S 47TH ST 263 S 47TH ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133850049
BROWN NANCY 4611 OVEREND AVE 4611 OVEREND AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133950138
PERRY PATRICIA 4911 FRAY AVE 4911 FRAY AVE 22/05 367.60 45.00 412.60 RICHMOND CA 94804
5134020030
CLEMENT DESIREE TRE 740 DEVILS DROP CT 727 S 45TH ST 22/05 367.74 45.00 412.74 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5141620061
MACIAS PEDRO O & ANGELICA 557 17TH ST 557 17TH ST 22/05 366.06 45.00 411.06 RICHMOND CA 94801
5141800275
PINEDA JENIFER Z 552 18TH ST 552 18TH ST 22/05 74.59 45.00 119.59 RICHMOND CA 94801
5142200160
LOPEZ EDITH ARENAS 2211 BARRETT AVE 2211 BARRETT AVE 22/05 404.87 45.00 449.87 RICHMOND CA 94801
5142700060
MCKINNEY CLEVELAND W TRE 621 20TH ST 621 20TH ST 22/05 365.80 45.00 410.80 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 9 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5142900249
SUAREZ PEDRO 1709 ROOSEVELT AVE 1709 ROOSEVELT AVE 22/05 267.31 45.00 312.31 RICHMOND CA 94801
5150600186
BIERLEIN BRANDON M 612 26TH ST 612 26TH ST 22/05 369.49 45.00 414.49 RICHMOND CA 94804
5152920186
ZULFIGAR ASHER H 5958 WESTVIEW PL 242 25TH ST A&B 22/05 266.95 45.00 311.95 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5154110109
ZAPATA JUAN VICTOR GOBEA 2835 BISSELL AVE 2835 BISSELL AVE 22/05 183.89 45.00 228.89 RICHMOND CA 94804
5154120074
WOOD JOHN C & TRACY L 131 29TH ST 131 29TH ST 22/05 302.16 45.00 347.16 RICHMOND CA 94804
5171900060
HUNTER PEARL L 611 32ND ST 427 38TH ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5172500026
FIELDS ROBERT 319 WILSON AVE 319 WILSON AVE 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94805
5180500166
JOHNSON CHERYL RENEE TRE 668 WILSON AVE 668 WILSON AVE 22/05 358.51 45.00 403.51 RICHMOND CA 94805
5181500108
GARDNER JONATHAN M 3511 CERRITO AVE 3511 CERRITO AVE 22/05 694.28 45.00 739.28 RICHMOND CA 94805
5182400266
WHITNEY CORINNA 634 30TH ST 634 30TH ST 22/05 458.09 45.00 503.09 RICHMOND CA 94804
5182600154
MORRIS MARGARET 3219 ROOSEVELT AVE 3219 ROOSEVELT AVE 22/05 289.82 45.00 334.82 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 10 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5182900059
BUSH JOYCE 637 36TH ST 637 36TH ST 22/05 366.77 45.00 411.77 RICHMOND CA 94805
5190500073
PRIMUS RUBY L 685 AMADOR ST 685 AMADOR ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94805
5192100195
SHAREEF INTISAR TRE 558 MC LAUGHLIN ST 558 MC LAUGHLIN ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94805
5192200219
BRUNN JOAN TRACY 560 KEY BLVD 560 KEY BLVD 22/05 188.89 45.00 233.89 RICHMOND CA 94805
5192310257
HANSON SARAH 508 DIMM ST 508 DIMM ST 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230410184
BARAGHANI MOHAMMAD SEYED M TRE 4924 BUCKBOARD WAY 12654 SAN PABLO AVE 22/05 262.01 45.00 307.01 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5230440165
MILLER JERRY 5229 SOLANO AVE 5229 SOLANO AVE 22/05 383.34 45.00 428.34 RICHMOND CA 94805
5241800241
HU YAN 15 MCCORMICK RD 3633 GARVIN AVE 22/05 669.11 45.00 714.11 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5242300019
MALDONADO SANDRA 772 39TH ST 772 39TH ST 22/05 300.34 45.00 345.34 RICHMOND CA 94805
5242300126
ATTA SARDAR M PO BOX 5233 3911 SOLANO AVE 22/05 189.01 45.00 234.01 RICHMOND CA 94805
5242300167
HONDA GARY S & JANIS K 756 39TH ST 756 39TH ST 22/05 382.62 45.00 427.62 RICHMOND CA 94805
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 11 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5260110084
BINGHAM COLLETTE 3421 TULARE AVE 3421 TULARE AVE 22/05 354.23 45.00 399.23 RICHMOND CA 94804
5262300196
VILLANUEA JUAN & MARIA P 2929 LOWELL AVE 2929 LOWELL AVE 22/05 370.75 45.00 415.75 RICHMOND CA 94804
5263000092
PEREZ RAMON 2866 TULARE AVE 2866 TULARE AVE 22/05 357.61 45.00 402.61 RICHMOND CA 94804
5270220170
UNLIMITED DEVELOPMENT LLC PO BOX 4471 2363 EMERIC AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 VALLEJO CA 94590
5272000240
BRIGGS GARY & EMMA 2415 HUMPHREY AVE 2415 HUMPHREY AVE 22/05 693.86 45.00 738.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5272100016
CHAO SAMUEL & THIM K 2600 LOWELL AVE 2600 LOWELL AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5280900092
LEDEZMA ESTANISLAO 2379 LINCOLN AVE 2379 LINCOLN AVE 22/05 69.87 45.00 114.87 RICHMOND CA 94804
5281700046
SAPP CHAKISSIA B TRE 2455 HANSON DR 2334 ESMOND AVE 22/05 129.06 45.00 174.06 FAIRFIELD CA 94533
5281700095
WARD AARON E PO BOX 464 2366 ESMOND AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RODEO CA 94572
5281800093
HERRERA-MCDONOUGH IRENE 1341 MARTIN LUTHER KING JR WAY 2522 ESMOND AVE 22/05 668.93 45.00 713.93 BERKELEY CA 94709
5281900299
STEVENS JANICE J 2601 GAYNOR AVE 2601 GAYNOR AVE 22/05 368.41 45.00 413.41 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 12 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5282100154
DE SANZ MIGUEL TRE 830 ERNEST DR 2875 GARVIN AVE 22/05 374.69 45.00 419.69 SONOMA CA 95476
5283200029
OROZCO GUSTAVO 728 26TH ST 728 26TH ST 22/05 353.32 45.00 398.32 RICHMOND CA 94804
5283600038
JACKSON RUBY 2322 DOWNER AVE 2322 DOWNER AVE 22/05 380.75 45.00 425.75 RICHMOND CA 94804
5283700010
SINDICICH BETTY J TRE 2323 GRANT AVE 2323 GRANT AVE 22/05 355.08 45.00 400.08 RICHMOND CA 94804
5290300069
BROWN PORSCHEA M 1602 LINCOLN AVE 1602 LINCOLN AVE 22/05 540.08 45.00 585.08 RICHMOND CA 94801
5291100120
TURNER BARBARA JEAN 1833 LINDEN ST 861 15TH ST 22/05 735.31 45.00 780.31 OAKLAND CA 94607
5291300290
GUO MEI 63 ONONDAGA AVE 1415 GARVIN AVE 22/05 337.22 45.00 382.22 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112
5291500154
HARLEY ARNOLD D EST OF 1743 GARVIN AVE 1743 GARVIN AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5291800117
ESPARZA MARIA 2213 BURBECK AVE 2213 BURBECK AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5292520045
VALDIVIA JAVIER G & SANDRA J 707 FALCON CT 745 17TH ST 22/05 695.56 45.00 740.56 RICHMOND CA 94806
5292620324
MORSHED FAWAZ 1734 WOOD PL 1734 WOOD PL 22/05 375.65 45.00 420.65 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 13 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5301000179
FRANCIS MICHELLE 1827 RHEEM AVE 1827 RHEEM AVE 22/05 353.23 45.00 398.23 RICHMOND CA 94801
5301500178
LOVE PAMELA S PO BOX 2005 1515 DUNN AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94802
5301700125
ALLEN SIDNEY JR 1415 HELLINGS AVE 1415 HELLINGS AVE 22/05 501.22 45.00 546.22 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302600183
GUTIERREZ ANA T 1421 COALINGA AVE 1421 COALINGA AVE 22/05 366.56 45.00 411.56 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302700207
REED BERNADINE 1331 VISALIA AVE 1331 VISALIA AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5303400112
CHAMBERS LARRY & BREZELL W 2202 VISALIA AVE 2202 VISALIA AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5303400187
ESPERANZA LEONISIO 2135 LINCOLN AVE 2135 LINCOLN AVE 22/05 471.85 45.00 516.85 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340120046
HUNTER DARROLL 632 3RD ST 938 7TH ST 22/05 37.60 45.00 82.60 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340220234
ROBINSON VELMA LILLIAN TRE PO BOX 277 877 7TH ST 22/05 353.23 45.00 398.23 SAN LEANDRO CA 94577
5340720324
ALMENDARES MARIO A 796 7TH ST 796 7TH ST 22/05 366.66 45.00 411.66 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340810299
MERCADO MAURILIO JR 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 787 7TH ST 22/05 382.62 45.00 427.62 PINOLE CA 94564
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 14 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5341320124
FERGUSON LANDON T & GLADYS M 687 9TH ST 687 9TH ST 22/05 325.25 45.00 370.25 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341520095
GOMEZ ASCENCION 645 13TH ST 645 13TH ST 22/05 711.90 45.00 756.90 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341720190
COLEMAN LUCY G 629 12TH ST 629 12TH ST 22/05 675.30 45.00 720.30 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341810181
CLARK ANNA BELL TRE 640 9TH ST 640 9TH ST 22/05 362.10 45.00 407.10 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341910064
ARELLANO ALFONSO 659 8TH ST 659 8TH ST 22/05 367.70 45.00 412.70 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341920063
YOUNG RENEE FOWLER 735 RIPLEY AVE 733 RIPLEY AVE 22/05 734.87 45.00 779.87 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342010229
LOPEZ ABIGAIL E 511 RIPLEY AVE 511 RIPLEY AVE 22/05 373.12 45.00 418.12 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342210142
BARRIENTOS MANUEL & VILMA 215 RIPLEY AVE 215 RIPLEY AVE 22/05 358.52 45.00 403.52 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342920047
MERCADO MAURILIO JR 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 526 4TH ST 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 PINOLE CA 94564
5342920146
MAZARIEGOS ANACLETO C 311 RIPLEY AVE 578 4TH ST 22/05 382.67 45.00 427.67 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343010145
ARGUETA MARIA VILMA 527 6TH ST 527 6TH ST 22/05 188.69 45.00 233.69 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 15 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5380500081
LOBATO JOHNNY DAVID 457 3RD ST 457 3RD ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5380600139
OROZCO FERNANDO & CLAUDIA 433 4TH ST 433 4TH ST 22/05 384.34 45.00 429.34 RICHMOND CA 94801
5380800200
MENDEZ YASMIN 432 5TH ST 432 5TH ST 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382000262
RUANO LEON 246 3RD ST 246 3RD ST 22/05 676.18 45.00 721.18 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382310240
HARRIS ALBERT R 267 7TH ST 267 7TH ST 22/05 694.44 45.00 739.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382700184
HERRERA CARLOS 126 9TH ST 126 9TH ST 22/05 366.56 45.00 411.56 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382900271
ROBINSON L C 160 6TH ST 160 6TH ST 22/05 693.86 45.00 738.86 RICHMOND CA 94801
5383000071
ROBINSON L C & AUDREY B 160 6TH ST 151 6TH ST 22/05 444.49 45.00 489.49 RICHMOND CA 94801
5383100111
ZHANG YANTING 123 5TH ST 123 5TH ST 22/05 366.76 45.00 411.76 RICHMOND CA 94801
5383200234
LAU PUI NI BEVERLY 23 SAM MUN TSAI RD 122 3RD ST 22/05 379.72 45.00 424.72 TAI PO NT CHINA CA 999077
5383500120
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 126 CHANSLOR AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 16 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5383500195
PAVALOVSKY ALEX 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 19 2ND ST 22/05 638.74 45.00 683.74 PINOLE CA 94564
5384300082
HAWKINS LOUISE 920 CHANSLOR AVE 920 CHANSLOR AVE 22/05 407.74 45.00 452.74 RICHMOND CA 94801
5401400121
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 231 15TH ST 22/05 369.07 45.00 414.07 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
5401600076
HAMON MATTIE M 251 17TH ST 251 17TH ST 22/05 367.61 45.00 412.61 RICHMOND CA 94801
5401600258
KATAYANAGI NATALIE H 250 16TH ST 250 16TH ST 22/05 367.72 45.00 412.72 RICHMOND CA 94801
5402700263
ROBINSON ANGELA R 146 12TH ST 146 12TH ST 22/05 344.09 45.00 389.09 RICHMOND CA 94801
5403200024
LEUNG HONG WAH PO BOX 20306 1210 CHANSLOR AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 SAN JOSE CA 95160
5403600124
HUDSON JULIA L PO BOX 1683 1637 OHIO AVE 22/05 373.54 45.00 418.54 RICHMOND CA 94802
5404800970
LEE GARRETT 1859 GREENWICH ST 326 MARINA WAY 22/05 367.51 45.00 412.51 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94123
5404801101
POLK CRYSTAL S 427 METRO WALK WAY 427 METRO WALK WAY 22/05 358.63 45.00 403.63 RICHMOND CA 94801
5404801234
GILLIAM KEVIN A 453 METRO WALK WAY 453 METRO WALK WAY 22/05 357.61 45.00 402.61 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 17 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5440100195
MFGEM LLC PO BOX 9250 118 S 11TH ST 22/05 411.35 45.00 456.35 VALLEJO CA 94591
5440210093
WALKER CAROLYN J 151 S 13TH ST 151 S 13TH ST 22/05 694.66 45.00 739.66 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440310190
WARD ROBBIE 126 MARINA WAY S 118 MARINA WAY S 22/05 368.44 45.00 413.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440410065
CRUZ JUAN 122 S 17TH ST 122 S 17TH ST 22/05 352.50 45.00 397.50 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440420031
BATON TOMMIE 128 S 18TH ST 128 S 18TH ST 22/05 353.23 45.00 398.23 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440810074
WORMER JOSEPH VAN 200 S 19TH ST 200 S 19TH ST 22/05 368.53 45.00 413.53 RICHMOND CA 94804
5441000154
MENDOZA GUSTAVO 244 S 16TH ST 244 S 16TH ST 22/05 338.30 45.00 383.30 RICHMOND CA 94804
5441410130
SANCHEZ ANTONIA 357 S 15TH ST 357 S 15TH ST 22/05 695.52 45.00 740.52 RICHMOND CA 94804
5441500096
REGGIE HAUL ENTERPRISES INC PO BOX 5148 353 S 17TH ST 22/05 383.10 45.00 428.10 RICHMOND CA 94805
5442020201
WILLIAMS OLLIE MAE PO BOX 1895 2009 CUTTING BLVD 22/05 353.51 45.00 398.51 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5490200499
BRESLIN KENNETH A TRE 3405 MORAGA BLVD 2621 MAINE AVE 22/05 706.39 45.00 751.39 LAFAYETTE CA 94549
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 18 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5490310058
CLARK SHAKEYA 330 S 23RD ST 330 S 23RD ST 22/05 274.86 45.00 319.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490320040
MEIERO ELISEO 2416 MAINE AVE 2416 MAINE AVE 22/05 364.70 45.00 409.70 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490320206
ZANCANARO MARIO & SHAMICA 350 S 24TH ST 350 S 24TH ST 22/05 694.73 45.00 739.73 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490420212
HOPKINS HELEN M 2622 MAINE AVE 2622 MAINE AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490420238
MCCRAY BOBBIE 2621 VIRGINIA AVE 2621 VIRGINIA AVE 22/05 693.86 45.00 738.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490910261
ALCARAZ RICARDO 446 S 25TH ST 446 S 25TH ST 22/05 383.41 45.00 428.41 RICHMOND CA 94804
5491400171
MCCRAY CORA LEE 2423 FOOTHILL AVE 2423 FOOTHILL AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5491920038
GUERRERO DULEY CARLOS 546 S 29TH ST 546 S 29TH ST 22/05 391.52 45.00 436.52 RICHMOND CA 94804
5492020200
BENTON JANICE 2901 CHAVEZ LN 2901 CHAVEZ LN 22/05 303.34 45.00 348.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5492300024
ADDISON ATHENA 632 S 30TH ST 632 S 30TH ST 22/05 351.18 45.00 396.18 RICHMOND CA 94804
5501200165
RUSSELL RALPH J 269 S 3RD ST 269 S 3RD ST 22/05 325.25 45.00 370.25 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 19 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5501410012
KAZAKU AURELIYA 4 LA MESA CT 326 OHIO AVE 22/05 425.90 45.00 470.90 BURLINGAME CA 94010
5501910052
HENRIQUEZ YONI 300 S 5TH ST 300 S 5TH ST 22/05 362.36 45.00 407.36 RICHMOND CA 94804
5502010225
FUENTES JANIRA NICOLE 528 FLORIDA AVE 528 FLORIDA AVE 22/05 391.68 45.00 436.68 RICHMOND CA 94804
5503100033
RUN IT LLC 392 MORAGA WAY 918 MAINE AVE 22/05 676.63 45.00 721.63 ORINDA CA 94563
5503100116
YEPEZ RODOLFO J 350 S 9TH ST 350 S 9TH ST 22/05 371.03 45.00 416.03 RICHMOND CA 94804
5503310129
WALLACE ELAINE 134 HARBOUR WAY S 901 FLORIDA AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94804
5582710066
UNLIMITED DEVELOPMENT LLC PO BOX 4471 519 TEWKSBURY AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 VALLEJO CA 94590
5582920152
UNLIMITED DEVELOPMENT LLC PO BOX 4471 429 W RICHMOND AVE 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 VALLEJO CA 94590
5611720052
MALDONADO CARLOS & VICTORIA 10 SNOWDRIFT CT 250 GERTRUDE AVE 22/05 167.44 45.00 212.44 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5611810432
PANG DAVID HO 480 4TH AVE 513 GERTRUDE AVE 22/05 369.08 45.00 414.08 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94118
5611910364
MUSLIM MISSION CENTER 1321 KELSEY ST 511 DUBOCE AVE 22/05 716.74 45.00 761.74 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 20 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5611910372
HOLDEN EZELL EST OF 1343 KELSEY ST 1343 KELSEY ST 22/05 367.44 45.00 412.44 RICHMOND CA 94801
5612620046
GARCIA ELIZABETH 127 BEECHNUT DR 1328 CHERRY ST 22/05 154.87 45.00 199.87 HERCULES CA 94547
4054700440
HENDERSON YVONNE D 2523 TREESIDE WAY 2523 TREESIDE WAY 22/06 372.79 45.00 417.79 RICHMOND CA 94806
4054700648
TURNER KIMBERLY A 3425 SUNLEAF WAY 3425 SUNLEAF WAY 22/06 372.12 45.00 417.12 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055500708
GAITHER BRIAN & PEARLINA 625 ROCK ROSE WAY 625 ROCK ROSE WAY 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055600110
LEE CHING-TING 743 ROCK ROSE WAY 743 ROCK ROSE WAY 22/06 373.33 45.00 418.33 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055600649
MONTGOMERY RAY 764 ROCK ROSE WAY 764 ROCK ROSE WAY 22/06 694.76 45.00 739.76 RICHMOND CA 94806
4055700084
JOHNSON ORLANDO 809 POPPY CT 809 POPPY CT 22/06 694.55 45.00 739.55 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056500392
WELLS ANTOINETTE J 1135 ARROWHEAD CT 1135 ARROWHEAD CT 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056600499
BAGAGA AISSATA 5335 GALLERY CT 5335 GALLERY CT 22/06 368.11 45.00 413.11 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056601349
HE XIAO FENG 5301 BIRDIE CT 5301 BIRDIE CT 22/06 317.77 45.00 362.77 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 21 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4056901244
OYETAYO OLUWAPELUMI SOLOMON 1130 SUMMER LN 1130 SUMMER LN 22/06 390.80 45.00 435.80 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056901533
LI PING 756 GATEVIEW AVE 1720 SUMMER LN 22/06 99.12 45.00 144.12 ALBANY CA 94706
4080110028
BAYARSAIKHAN TSENGUUN 4504 MC GLOTHEN WAY 4504 MC GLOTHEN WAY 22/06 387.89 45.00 432.89 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080120019
PINEDA CINDY NOEMI 4300 JENKINS WAY 4300 JENKINS WAY 22/06 445.90 45.00 490.90 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080120233
RANDLE SHIRLEY J 604 JOHNSON DR 712 BANKS DR 22/06 356.88 45.00 401.88 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080310057
CAMARENA MELVIN & MITRA D 5476 GREENRIDGE RD 4116 MC GLOTHEN WAY 22/06 522.05 45.00 567.05 CASTRO VALLEY CA 94552
4080340096
DOTSON MARY LEE EST OF 7700 EDGEWATER DR STE 710 4109 JENKINS WAY 22/06 358.96 45.00 403.96 OAKLAND CA 94621
4080430277
HEAD GWENODLYN 2786 JO ANN DR 808 JOHNSON DR 22/06 373.48 45.00 418.48 SAN PABLO CA 94806
4080540216
SANTOS JUAN CARLOS BARRIOS 158 SHENANDOAH PL 704 HARRISON DR 22/06 117.43 45.00 162.43 SAN RAFAEL CA 94903
4140430077
CHILTON GWENDOLYN A 3110 ERLA WAY 3110 ERLA WAY 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140510068
BLAND JOHN A JR & DEBORAH K 2945 MC KENZIE DR 2945 MC KENZIE DR 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 22 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4140710049
WILLIAMS BOBBY J & SHIRLEY L 3122 JO ANN DR 3122 JO ANN DR 22/06 701.09 45.00 746.09 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140940026
RIVERA TIRSO & BETH 2914 MOYERS RD 2914 MOYERS RD 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141100141
IBAY ERIC 2751 JO ANN DR 2751 JO ANN DR 22/06 303.26 45.00 348.26 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141220139
ANDERSON FREDDIE JR 2852 LOYOLA AVE 2852 LOYOLA AVE 22/06 171.20 45.00 216.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141420226
KENNEY RODERICK 2545 DUKE AVE 2545 DUKE AVE 22/06 328.03 45.00 373.03 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141440117
DICKEY CONNOR 2540 MOYERS RD 2540 MOYERS RD 22/06 321.02 45.00 366.02 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141720062
SWARTZ TANIA 2723 BARNARD ST 2723 BARNARD ST 22/06 358.75 45.00 403.75 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141730053
SALINAS JUAN A & DELIA M 2742 BARNARD ST 2742 BARNARD ST 22/06 157.38 45.00 202.38 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142540089
GHATTAS NADER 3009 HULL DR 3009 HULL DR 22/06 694.76 45.00 739.76 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142710070
BROWN LESLIE 3066 BELFAST WAY 3066 BELFAST WAY 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94806
4191940271
NAIK PRIYA 6309 MONTE CRESTA AVE 6309 MONTE CRESTA AVE 22/06 371.17 45.00 416.17 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 23 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4252620036
SHAW CURTIS J & IRMA P 4192 FRAN WAY 4192 FRAN WAY 22/06 700.58 45.00 745.58 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263210470
PROPERTY SOLUTION & INVESTMENT 1017 VIEW DR 1017 VIEW DR 22/06 270.76 45.00 315.76 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263220644
SALEEMI CHUDHARY M 1004 VIEW DR 1004 VIEW DR 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263420855
PRIDGEN THOMAS A 32 GREENVIEW LN 32 GREENVIEW LN 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94803
4263530174
LADZEKPO MAWULI 1222 PARKWAY DR 1222 PARKWAY DR 22/06 357.61 45.00 402.61 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311510012
GOOCH TODD 2984 DESERET DR 2984 DESERET DR 22/06 289.69 45.00 334.69 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311710018
PAGNUTTI MARGERY 4682 VALLEY VIEW RD 4682 VALLEY VIEW RD 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311730123
ASANTE KOFI 3005 DE ANZA DR 3005 DE ANZA DR 22/06 467.05 45.00 512.05 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311730479
GREEN DEVON & YVETTE 3218 MAY RD 3218 MAY RD 22/06 300.74 45.00 345.74 RICHMOND CA 94803
4311930228
FILARSKI KEVIN L & CARLA ANN 4464 SANTA RITA RD 3120 DESERET DR 22/06 395.82 45.00 440.82 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
4312130117
ZADNEPROVSKAIA LANA 3322 CLEARFIELD AVE 3322 CLEARFIELD AVE 22/06 386.21 45.00 431.21 RICHMOND CA 94803
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 24 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4313020341
ANDREWS BONITA D 3435 FLEETWOOD DR 3435 FLEETWOOD DR 22/06 398.86 45.00 443.86 RICHMOND CA 94803
4313810055
ROBINSON BENJAMIN 3641 BLACK FEATHER DR 3641 BLACK FEATHER DR 22/06 455.78 45.00 500.78 RICHMOND CA 94803
4321920300
CHANG LI-LI 5536 CABRILLO NORTE 5536 CABRILLO NORTE 22/06 238.54 45.00 283.54 RICHMOND CA 94803
4333610105
FANG WEINU 14 POWDER BOWL CT 14 POWDER BOWL CT 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94803
4333610204
SORIANO AGNES R 5377 HEAVENLY RIDGE LN 5377 HEAVENLY RIDGE LN 22/06 49.58 45.00 94.58 RICHMOND CA 94803
4351600103
HUANG GEORGE GE 6208 BAYWOOD DR 6208 BAYWOOD DR 22/06 377.76 45.00 422.76 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5070800031
BATES BARBARA A 2014 CARLSON BLVD 2014 CARLSON BLVD 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5070800072
NELSON JAY DOUGLAS 14905 DUBLIN AVE 6026 PLUMAS AVE 22/06 371.08 45.00 416.08 GARDENA CA 90249
5080300048
SMITH JERLYN EST OF 2070 N BROADWAY UNIT 201 5328 GATELY AVE 22/06 371.24 45.00 416.24 WALNUT CREEK CA 94597
5081800186
MALBROUGH STERLING G & SANDRA 5121 TEHAMA AVE 5121 TEHAMA AVE 22/06 303.24 45.00 348.24 RICHMOND CA 94804
5081920034
BROOKS JAMES & THEA DIANE 1511 SAN JOAQUIN ST 1511 SAN JOAQUIN ST 22/06 386.80 45.00 431.80 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 25 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5081920133
PATTIYAGE RAYMOND 1546 OSCAR ST 1546 OSCAR ST 22/06 367.54 45.00 412.54 RICHMOND CA 94804
5082000059
BARAJAS JORGE 1310 BERKELEY WAY #2 5200 TEHAMA AVE 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 BERKELEY CA 94702
5082220103
WONG ZACHARY C 42 MARINA LAKES DR 5621 BURLINGAME AVE 22/06 228.40 45.00 273.40 RICHMOND CA 94804
5082920090
ANDERSON RONALD A & ELLIE O 1661 SAN BENITO ST 1661 SAN BENITO ST 22/06 373.28 45.00 418.28 RICHMOND CA 94804
5092300093
LAURENT GWENDOLYN JUNE EST OF 5127 GATELY AVE 5127 GATELY AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5092600112
BATTISTE HUEY P & GLORIA L 5212 CREELY AVE 5212 CREELY AVE 22/06 356.88 45.00 401.88 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093000031
ANDREWS MITCHELL SCOTT 818 S 49TH ST 818 S 49TH ST 22/06 357.48 45.00 402.48 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093100401
KEOBOUNHEUNG NOUKANH 4729 CYPRESS AVE 4729 CYPRESS AVE 22/06 690.16 45.00 735.16 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093200334
ALHUZAIBI NAJI N 814 S 45TH ST 814 S 45TH ST 22/06 364.86 45.00 409.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093200359
HARRIS EUCILLE 826 S 45TH ST 826 S 45TH ST 22/06 370.90 45.00 415.90 RICHMOND CA 94804
5093600178
CHAN KOO MEE HLAN TRE 4246 CALLAN BLVD 942 CARLSON BLVD 22/06 319.18 45.00 364.18 DALY CITY CA 94015
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 26 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5100700029
STG 5327 JACUZZI LLC 1304 SOUTHPOINT BLVD STE 250 5327 JACUZZI ST 22/06 75.52 45.00 120.52 PETALUMA CA 94954
5101230034
CORTESE MARGARET F TRE 6000 SACRAMENTO AVE 6000 SACRAMENTO AVE 22/06 405.00 45.00 450.00 RICHMOND CA 94804
5101530011
ESCOVEDO ANGELA TRE 961 SONOMA ST 5434 SACRAMENTO AVE 22/06 267.54 45.00 312.54 RICHMOND CA 94805
5130210072
ALHUZAIBI NAJI NORMAN MOHSEN 800 CARLSON BLVD 2607 OHIO AVE 22/06 1,367.50 45.00 1,412.50 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130330136
BRIZUELA MAURICIO A LOPEZ 3128 OHIO AVE 3128 OHIO AVE 22/06 387.70 45.00 432.70 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130340127
JACKSON GLORIA D TRE 3128 CENTER AVE 3128 CENTER AVE 22/06 140.72 45.00 185.72 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130430050
CORBETT ANTRELL ORAIVON 3535 OHIO AVE 3535 OHIO AVE 22/06 371.17 45.00 416.17 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130440018
MARQUEZ DANIEL PENA 126 S 35TH ST 126 S 35TH ST 22/06 385.91 45.00 430.91 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130440190
MASON THELMA 3531 CENTER AVE 3531 CENTER AVE 22/06 371.74 45.00 416.74 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130480212
LYLES WILLIAM & BRENDA 144 S 35TH ST 144 S 35TH ST 22/06 341.71 45.00 386.71 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130540247
PEARCE MICHAEL L & EMAGER 6145 BROADWAY 3411 WALL AVE 22/06 722.38 45.00 767.38 OAKLAND CA 94618
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 27 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5130710071
VEGA MARIA G 3803 OHIO AVE 3803 OHIO AVE 22/06 375.00 45.00 420.00 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130730095
GOODWIN ANNA BELL 3954 OHIO AVE 3954 OHIO AVE 22/06 412.76 45.00 457.76 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130820201
STEVENSON ELLA MAE 110 S 42ND ST 110 S 42ND ST 22/06 328.56 45.00 373.56 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130830119
HOWARD MICHAEL A 103 S 42ND ST 103 S 42ND ST 22/06 368.11 45.00 413.11 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131010059
MILLER GLORIOUS M TRE EST OF 2818 CARLSON BLVD 4304 CENTER AVE 22/06 302.47 45.00 347.47 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131110040
ABRAHAM-ELVIN JACQUELYN 3009 COLETTE DR 265 S 43RD ST 22/06 395.69 45.00 440.69 RICHMOND CA 94806
5131330168
VAUGHN GLORIA J 4225 TAFT AVE 4225 TAFT AVE 22/06 371.38 45.00 416.38 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131420258
MELANCON JOSEPH C JR & JOANNE 312 S 39TH ST 312 S 39TH ST 22/06 371.42 45.00 416.42 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131520073
AREBALO NELIDA 404 S 36TH ST 404 S 36TH ST 22/06 368.90 45.00 413.90 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131520263
VAZQUEZ RUBEN 377 S 37TH ST 377 S 37TH ST 22/06 212.90 45.00 257.90 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131610189
OWENS BERTH JR & EVELYN 2915 BIRMINGHAM DR 3321 CUTTING BLVD 22/06 678.03 45.00 723.03 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 28 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5131630203
BEAL LINDA JEAN 405 S 35TH ST 405 S 35TH ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131630286
ZAIDI MURTAZA TRE 6200 TEHAMA AVE 375 BECK ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5132360057
NANCE THATCHER P JR 118 CARMEL ST 621 S 52ND ST 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5132360149
HOWARD KEENAN PO BOX 374 616 S 49TH ST 22/06 355.87 45.00 400.87 RODEO CA 94572
5132940056
HOUGHTON HAROLD TRE 4734 CUTTING BLVD 4734 CUTTING BLVD 22/06 356.87 45.00 401.87 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133160423
MURPHY JAMES TRE 850 WHITE RIVER DR 4528 OVEREND AVE 22/06 387.10 45.00 432.10 PROSPER TX 75078
5133160522
SHRESTHA RAJU KUMAR & NIRMALA 4710 OVEREND AVE 4710 OVEREND AVE 22/06 370.21 45.00 415.21 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133810142
LOGGINS ALICE 239 S 47TH ST 239 S 47TH ST 22/06 372.67 45.00 417.67 RICHMOND CA 94804
5133990357
WARD VICKI L TRE 1837 TARRAGON DR 4721 HERSHEY CT 22/06 395.69 45.00 440.69 BRENTWOOD CA 94513
5134030419
DUCRE MORRIS & DORIS 4400 BELL AVE 4400 BELL AVE 22/06 1,151.40 45.00 1,196.40 RICHMOND CA 94804
5141100106
ROYTMAN LAURA 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD #126 445 22ND ST 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 SAN PABLO CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 29 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5141200252
LINHART ROBERT R 1171 MUNICH ST 400 20TH ST 22/06 5,837.65 45.00 5,882.65 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112
5141900117
PEDROZA FAUSTINA 500 YGNACIO VALLEY RD STE 170 535 20TH ST 22/06 1,689.46 45.00 1,734.46 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596
5142500098
WONG YIEN MING & SIM CHEN 923 CENTRAL AVE 611 21ST ST 22/06 401.81 45.00 446.81 ALAMEDA CA 94501
5143000015
CHEN MICHAEL GONG 1600 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 1600 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 22/06 342.02 45.00 387.02 RICHMOND CA 94801
5143200136
WILLIAMS JESSICA 118 BUSS AVE 650 14TH ST 22/06 1,055.80 45.00 1,100.80 VALLEJO CA 94590
5150300019
CALDERON SARAH 637 25TH ST 637 25TH ST 22/06 341.71 45.00 386.71 RICHMOND CA 94804
5151700209
GRACE EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CH 2369 BARRETT AVE 2369 BARRETT AVE 22/06 2,116.12 45.00 2,161.12 RICHMOND CA 94804
5153110084
HO KEE MAN & WANG YING 40845 CALIDO PL 180 24TH ST 22/06 107.46 45.00 152.46 FREMONT CA 94539
5153200034
VANEK DAVID M & PATRICIA A 1027 BELL LN 132 23RD ST 22/06 405.18 45.00 450.18 NAPA CA 94558
5153310130
RAMIREZ-SALAZAR LESDIA 2436 CHANSLOR AVE 2436 CHANSLOR AVE 22/06 372.49 45.00 417.49 RICHMOND CA 94804
5160100235
GARDIZI HAIDER M 2921 BARRETT AVE 2921 BARRETT AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 30 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5160800099
RUIZ DAYSI M 214 HEARTWOOD DR 3613 BARRETT AVE 22/06 353.85 45.00 398.85 OAKLEY CA 94561
5162200082
PHO JOSEPH & MAY K TRE 3602 BISSELL AVE 3602 BISSELL AVE 22/06 372.29 45.00 417.29 RICHMOND CA 94805
5171500183
WELCH ROBERT G 458 41ST ST 456 41ST ST 22/06 675.79 45.00 720.79 RICHMOND CA 94805
5172720251
TRACY TRADE LLC 4724 MACDONALD AVE 4724 MACDONALD AVE 22/06 3,712.07 45.00 3,757.07 RICHMOND CA 94805
5181400135
HERNANDEZ RICARDO O & CECILIA 728 35TH ST 728 35TH ST 22/06 697.96 45.00 742.96 RICHMOND CA 94805
5183600161
PUIM RENE TRE 606 42ND ST 606 42ND ST 22/06 328.56 45.00 373.56 RICHMOND CA 94805
5190400225
ATTARAN MOHAMMAD MEHDI PO BOX 6036 687 HUMBOLDT ST 22/06 388.51 45.00 433.51 ALBANY CA 94706
5200100013
HANSEN LAWRENCE R 5601 DOREMUS AVE 5601 DOREMUS AVE 22/06 356.59 45.00 401.59 RICHMOND CA 94805
5201220026
BOUNTHAVHY CHANH 5616 MARIN AVE 5616 MARIN AVE 22/06 370.97 45.00 415.97 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230130014
SOBERANES JUAN 1064 LASSEN ST 1064 LASSEN ST 22/06 372.01 45.00 417.01 SAN PABLO CA 94805
5230340019
SMITH RAYMOND D PO BOX 150 5200 ESMOND AVE 22/06 371.22 45.00 416.22 ORINDA CA 94563
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 31 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5240200237
MOORE BRYAN C EST OF 1140 KING ST 972 37TH ST 22/06 327.07 45.00 372.07 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5240400167
SAETANE CHANH & CHENG K 907 36TH ST 907 36TH ST 22/06 388.12 45.00 433.12 RICHMOND CA 94805
5241900157
BROWN RAYALDO & VANETTA 3701 GARVIN AVE 3701 GARVIN AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94805
5262400210
TORRES-GARCIA CARLOS 2911 HUMPHREY AVE 2911 HUMPHREY AVE 22/06 385.26 45.00 430.26 RICHMOND CA 94804
5262600132
WOLF WILLIAM W & BARBARA D 3109 MCBRYDE AVE 3109 MCBRYDE AVE 22/06 351.71 45.00 396.71 RICHMOND CA 94804
5263220179
WORTHINGTON NELL V 2845 MORAN AVE 2845 MORAN AVE 22/06 372.90 45.00 417.90 RICHMOND CA 94804
5270710014
RODRIGUEZ CARLOS G 1540 26TH ST 1540 26TH ST 22/06 431.21 45.00 476.21 RICHMOND CA 94806
5271110024
MEJIA EVER ANIBEL ALAS 248 15TH ST APT 3 1332 24TH ST 22/06 27.85 45.00 72.85 RICHMOND CA 94801
5271700154
NG LAWRENCE H PO BOX 1893 2525 LOWELL AVE 22/06 121.20 45.00 166.20 LAFAYETTE CA 94549
5271900093
ROSAS BERNARDO & CONCEPCION 154 DAISY CT 2342 LOWELL AVE 22/06 1,367.26 45.00 1,412.26 HERCULES CA 94547
5280200147
PENADO JOSE FRANCISCO TRE 1715 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 2535 ANDRADE AVE 22/06 986.50 45.00 1,031.50 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 32 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5280700062
RIDGE PATRICK 2436 ANDRADE AVE 2436 ANDRADE AVE 22/06 251.93 45.00 296.93 RICHMOND CA 94804
5280900118
DOBASHI AHMED 3480 RIDGEWOOD WAY 2363 LINCOLN AVE A 22/06 683.42 45.00 728.42 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5281100064
WATKINS DAVID L & ALEXANDRA 2704 MCBRYDE AVE 2704 MCBRYDE AVE 22/06 368.11 45.00 413.11 RICHMOND CA 94804
5281200237
LEE STEVEN B 2811 LINCOLN AVE 2811 LINCOLN AVE 22/06 371.16 45.00 416.16 RICHMOND CA 94804
5282300184
LEE AUDRY 430 RAMSELL ST 2525 GARVIN AVE 22/06 372.01 45.00 417.01 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94132
5283100088
SPENCER RICHARD SR & HILDA 2640 CLINTON AVE 2640 CLINTON AVE 22/06 364.86 45.00 409.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5283300076
FERNANDEZ HERCULANO 1923 16TH ST 2540 DOWNER AVE 22/06 371.50 45.00 416.50 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5283600251
HOU HONG MEI 1541A IRVING ST 2354 DOWNER AVE 22/06 742.57 45.00 787.57 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94122
5290600278
NAVARRO EDGAR VILLA 2011 ESMOND AVE 2011 ESMOND AVE 22/06 218.80 45.00 263.80 RICHMOND CA 94801
5290900082
URIARTE JESUS A 1758 ESMOND AVE 1758 ESMOND AVE 22/06 372.68 45.00 417.68 RICHMOND CA 94801
5291100070
SZWANEK JUDY 1334 ESMOND AVE 1334 ESMOND AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 33 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5292300273
PAVLOVSKY NATALY 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD 126 1335 BURBECK AVE 22/06 1,014.65 45.00 1,059.65 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5292620167
DOMINO CAROL PO BOX 880932 1740 BURBECK AVE 22/06 371.22 45.00 416.22 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94188
5292620282
PENADO JOSE FRANCISCO TRE 1715 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 1715 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 22/06 210.19 45.00 255.19 RICHMOND CA 94801
5292810024
WILLIS RALPH & MARILYN 10 KITTIWAKE RD 2022 BURBECK AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 ORINDA CA 94563
5292820171
ANICAMA MARIO ANTHONY TRE 700 21ST ST 700 21ST ST 22/06 303.48 45.00 348.48 RICHMOND CA 94801
5292820189
AYALA FRANCISCO 706 21ST ST 706 21ST ST 22/06 363.65 45.00 408.65 RICHMOND CA 94801
5300900189
PACAS ANA M 1721 RHEEM AVE 1721 RHEEM AVE 22/06 388.43 45.00 433.43 RICHMOND CA 94801
5301800032
MIRANDA JUAN 1518 DUNN AVE 1518 DUNN AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302500102
WILLIAMS OSCAR C SR 1628 HELLINGS AVE 1628 HELLINGS AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302800122
DELGADO FERMIN & ALICE M 1419 LINCOLN AVE 1419 LINCOLN AVE 22/06 435.98 45.00 480.98 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340110161
PAVLOVSKY ALEX 3220 BLUME DR STE 281 617 LINCOLN AVE 22/06 742.37 45.00 787.37 SAN PABLO CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 34 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5340220242
ALHUZAIBI NOMAN 800 CARLSON BLVD 800 6TH ST 22/06 1,013.66 45.00 1,058.66 RICHMOND CA 94804
5340230209
PAVLOVSKY NATALYA 123 FEY DR 857 8TH ST 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 BURLINGAME CA 94010
5340310068
MOORE EARLIE M 237 N GRANT ST 852 8TH ST 22/06 357.00 45.00 402.00 SAN MATEO CA 94401
5340820371
MEJIA THOMAS 745 6TH ST 745 6TH ST 22/06 372.25 45.00 417.25 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341020013
PAVLOVSKY ALEX 3220 BLUME DR STE 281 676 2ND ST 22/06 2,789.20 45.00 2,834.20 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5341020112
BELL ALLEGRA LUCINDA TRE 679 3RD ST 679 3RD ST 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341310109
CASTRO JOSE L 681 8TH ST 681 8TH ST 22/06 226.48 45.00 271.48 RICHMOND CA 94801
5341320041
MERCADO MAURILIO JR 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 684 8TH ST 22/06 371.80 45.00 416.80 PINOLE CA 94564
5342010211
MENDEZ ELADIO 513 RIPLEY AVE 513 RIPLEY AVE 22/06 278.70 45.00 323.70 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342110045
SMITH JOEY D 620 4TH ST 620 4TH ST 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342210324
HOLLAND YVETTE 229 RIPLEY AVE 229 RIPLEY AVE 22/06 267.95 45.00 312.95 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 35 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5342220034
TRAYNOR JAMES L 659 2ND ST 659 2ND ST 22/06 328.26 45.00 373.26 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343020086
PHILLIPS JOSHUA D 546 5TH ST 546 5TH ST 22/06 279.12 45.00 324.12 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343140231
JACKSON RUTH M 571 8TH ST 567 7TH ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343300116
HUNG ROBERT WAI LEUNG TRE 136 ARDMORE WAY 566 9TH ST 22/06 703.12 45.00 748.12 BENICIA CA 94510
5343300272
GARCIA ROSENDO & LIDUVINA 571 HARBOUR WAY 571 HARBOUR WAY 22/06 301.54 45.00 346.54 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343400247
DOBASHI AIED S 2222 62ND AVE 564 HARBOUR WAY 22/06 2,472.31 45.00 2,517.31 OAKLAND CA 94605
5343600044
HENLINE DARYL ALBAN 1228 ROOSEVELT AVE 1228 ROOSEVELT AVE 22/06 138.29 45.00 183.29 RICHMOND CA 94801
5380500297
REYES RUBEN C 460 2ND ST 460 2ND ST 22/06 397.96 45.00 442.96 RICHMOND CA 94801
5380500305
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 210 BARRETT AVE 22/06 1,212.70 45.00 1,257.70 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
5380600048
ROYTMAN LEON 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD #126 316 BARRETT AVE 22/06 1,381.80 45.00 1,426.80 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5381810349
CRUZ JOSE ANTONIO 235 2ND ST 235 2ND ST 22/06 371.27 45.00 416.27 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 36 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5381900132
CHAVARRIA ANGELINA 227 3RD ST 227 3RD ST 22/06 341.51 45.00 386.51 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382000205
CRUZ MARIA D TRE 230 2ND ST 220 3RD ST 22/06 723.07 45.00 768.07 RICHMOND CA 94801
5382100153
MERCADO MAGDA Z 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 421 BISSELL AVE 22/06 448.08 45.00 493.08 PINOLE CA 94564
5382310018
CHAVEZ JAIME & ENA A 277 8TH ST 277 8TH ST 22/06 302.90 45.00 347.90 RICHMOND CA 94801
5383500377
ROYTMAN LAURA 2643 APPIAN WAY STE K 10 1ST ST 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 PINOLE CA 94564
5383500401
ROYTMAN LAURA 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD 126 3 2ND ST 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5403400053
FUENTES VALENTE N 1173 INGERSON AVE 1420 CHANSLOR AVE 22/06 102.28 45.00 147.28 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94124
5403500258
BUFORD NAILAH 1424 CONTRA COSTA AVE 1501 OHIO AVE 22/06 2,197.64 45.00 2,242.64 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5403500290
ACOSTA ANTONIO & ROSE L 10 15TH ST 10 15TH ST 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 RICHMOND CA 94801
5403800120
BRADFORD BARBARA J 1829 OHIO AVE 1829 OHIO AVE 22/06 368.11 45.00 413.11 RICHMOND CA 94804
5403800229
JACKSON RUTH M 571 8TH ST 1800 CHANSLOR AVE 22/06 2,107.57 45.00 2,152.57 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 37 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5404000084
TEASLEY CHERYL LYNN 4509 BELL CT 2037 OHIO AVE 22/06 723.43 45.00 768.43 RICHMOND CA 94804
5404100066
ROYTMAN LAURA 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD 126 2209 OHIO AVE 22/06 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5404800889
THIONGANE DAOUDA 1414 NEVIN PLZ 1414 NEVIN PLZ 22/06 395.38 45.00 440.38 RICHMOND CA 94801
5404801028
CONWAY TYLER ANTHONY 1235 CARRISON ST APT 4 312 MARINA WAY 22/06 371.17 45.00 416.17 BERKELEY CA 94702
5440100062
GUTIERREZ LORENA 137 S 12TH ST 131 S 12TH ST 22/06 1,179.47 45.00 1,224.47 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440310182
WARD ROBBIE 126 MARINA WAY S 126 MARINA WAY S 22/06 305.86 45.00 350.86 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440410131
CATAMOUNT PROPERTIES 2018 LLC 2015 MANHATTAN BEACH BLVD #100 117 S 18TH ST 22/06 370.90 45.00 415.90 REDONDO BEACH CA 90278
5440520079
WINBUSH SHARON ANN 120 S 20TH ST 120 S 20TH ST 22/06 372.22 45.00 417.22 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440520186
CASTILLO ANGEL 2027 FLORIDA AVE 2027 FLORIDA AVE 22/06 294.88 45.00 339.88 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440720034
ROLLINS RUBY M 220 S 22ND ST 228 S 22ND ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5440910114
HOSKINS BETTY LOUISE TRE 1700 FLORIDA AVE 1700 FLORIDA AVE 22/06 371.39 45.00 416.39 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 38 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5441410072
NEALS TODD ANTHONY 1005 AILEEN ST 321 S 15TH ST 22/06 700.61 45.00 745.61 OAKLAND CA 94608
5441620167
MOORE GUY 1817 VIRGINIA AVE 1817 VIRGINIA AVE 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94804
5441920021
GABRIEL DARRIN 1791 HARMONY WAY 440 S 22ND ST 22/06 1,367.12 45.00 1,412.12 PITTSBURG CA 94565
5442320155
ROYTMAN LEON 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD #126 432 MARINA WAY S 22/06 1,367.02 45.00 1,412.02 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5442710140
CUMMINGS ROBIN R 505 S 16TH ST 505 S 16TH ST 22/06 702.32 45.00 747.32 RICHMOND CA 94804
5442810163
TORRES GLORIA ISABEL TORRES 1701 POTRERO AVE 1701 POTRERO AVE 22/06 289.70 45.00 334.70 RICHMOND CA 94804
5443010037
MORRIS GLORIA A 530 S 21ST ST 530 S 21ST ST 22/06 356.88 45.00 401.88 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490200424
SPEARS DENISE M 2533 MAINE AVE 2533 MAINE AVE 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490620043
RODAS GLENDY 434 S 29TH ST 434 S 29TH ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5490720124
PRECIADO SAMUEL 446 SPRING ST 446 SPRING ST 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94804
5491010046
GRAY PETER T 403 S 24TH ST 403 S 24TH ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 39 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5491020136
DICKEY JACQUES A 430 S 24TH ST 430 S 24TH ST 22/06 341.71 45.00 386.71 RICHMOND CA 94804
5491500111
GONZALEZ REFUGIO 533 S 28TH ST 533 S 28TH ST 22/06 369.91 45.00 414.91 RICHMOND CA 94804
5491910062
ROYTMAN LEON 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD #126 2816 CUTTING BLVD 22/06 1,366.56 45.00 1,411.56 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5491920038
GUERRERO DULEY CARLOS 546 S 29TH ST 546 S 29TH ST 22/06 361.21 45.00 406.21 RICHMOND CA 94804
5492010078
KONG QUE 2930 DOMINGO AVE #186 671 S 29TH ST 22/06 683.02 45.00 728.02 BERKELEY CA 94705
5492020275
TILLMAN DANIELLE 2912 BONDS LN 2912 BONDS LN 22/06 373.28 45.00 418.28 RICHMOND CA 94804
5501920085
NELSON CLAUDIA S 334 S 6TH ST 334 S 6TH ST 22/06 702.49 45.00 747.49 RICHMOND CA 94804
5501920234
DELEON ABIGAIL ROELI 321 S 7TH ST 321 S 7TH ST 22/06 368.11 45.00 413.11 RICHMOND CA 94804
5502010043
CREER PRISCILLA A 210 S 5TH ST 210 S 5TH ST 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 RICHMOND CA 94804
5502420192
MARTINEZ VICTOR MANUEL 335 S 9TH ST 335 S 9TH ST 22/06 371.12 45.00 416.12 RICHMOND CA 94804
5582230065
CABELLA STEVEN L 737 OCEAN AVE 737 OCEAN AVE 22/06 213.27 45.00 258.27 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 40 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5582730064
MCCABE MARK A EST OF 442 GOLDEN GATE AVE 442 GOLDEN GATE AVE 22/06 303.25 45.00 348.25 RICHMOND CA 94801
5608301783
MARCELO KATRINA P 1608 WRIGHT AVE 1608 WRIGHT AVE 22/06 341.71 45.00 386.71 RICHMOND CA 94804
5611520221
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 237 VERNON AVE 22/06 371.20 45.00 416.20 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
4056000070
OGUAMALAM SUSSAN MMA 3312 PARK RIDGE DR 3312 PARK RIDGE DR 22/07 435.21 45.00 480.21 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080340047
DAGLOW STANLEY V 4209 JENKINS WAY 4209 JENKINS WAY 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140330079
HUANG LIANG 2970 GROOM DR 3086 BARKLEY DR 22/07 387.61 45.00 432.61 SAN PABLO CA 94806
4140510043
LEON MICHELLE ROSE & JORGE G 2939 MC KENZIE DR 2939 MC KENZIE DR 22/07 26.54 45.00 71.54 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140610017
VALDEZ BENITA G 3147 MOYERS RD 3147 MOYERS RD 22/07 380.46 45.00 425.46 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140710072
TORRES-GARCIA ARTURO 3140 JO ANN DR 3140 JO ANN DR 22/07 367.87 45.00 412.87 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142610296
WEBSTER LAMONT & TREESINEU 2913 CANTERBURY DR 2913 CANTERBURY DR 22/07 256.39 45.00 301.39 RICHMOND CA 94806
4191950080
CHARLES CAROLYN G TRE 6329 JERILYNN AVE 6329 JERILYNN AVE 22/07 129.19 45.00 174.19 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 41 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4263410112
SHARMA SNEHLATA TRE 2275 OAK HILLS DR 1144 PARKRIDGE DR 22/07 369.29 45.00 414.29 PITTSBURG CA 94565
4311830113
KOEHLER M FRANCIE 3121 SHELDON DR 3121 SHELDON DR 22/07 430.85 45.00 475.85 RICHMOND CA 94803
4322100159
CHAU VICTORIA THUY LE 5329 WOODGATE CT 5329 WOODGATE CT 22/07 329.27 45.00 374.27 RICHMOND CA 94803
4334100221
HOLDER DAVID SPENCER 5753 AMEND RD 5753 AMEND RD 22/07 34.63 45.00 79.63 RICHMOND CA 94803
5081110065
DEMARINIS FRANCO W 1360 SANTA CLARA ST 1360 SANTA CLARA ST 22/07 165.34 45.00 210.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5081120155
ASAMI DONALD Y TRE 1955 PINE ST 1328 MERCED ST 22/07 31.86 45.00 76.86 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94109
5092920148
ABANGAN BARBARA TRE 5125 CYPRESS AVE 5125 CYPRESS AVE 22/07 372.05 45.00 417.05 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131310285
DAVIS JAYNA 420 S 41ST ST 420 S 41ST ST 22/07 1,013.66 45.00 1,058.66 RICHMOND CA 94804
5131640061
JACKSON GLORIA D TRE 3128 CENTER AVE 315 S 35TH ST 22/07 1,012.45 45.00 1,057.45 RICHMOND CA 94804
5134030203
SHRESTHA RAJENDRA P THAPA 815 S 55TH ST 4209 POTRERO AVE 22/07 71.60 45.00 116.60 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5141000132
LEVINE MAX 1442A WALNUT ST 410 22ND ST 22/07 625.93 45.00 670.93 BERKELEY CA 94709
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 42 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5141700038
BUENROSTRO RAUL GALVAN 1710 ROOSEVELT AVE 1710 ROOSEVELT AVE 22/07 25.01 45.00 70.01 RICHMOND CA 94801
5142300028
MARCADIER ALINE X 635 23RD ST 635 23RD ST 22/07 828.95 45.00 873.95 RICHMOND CA 94804
5142300259
SUCHIL BENIGNO & MARIA D 636 22ND ST 636 22ND ST 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94801
5151000105
BROWN ANTHONY E & VIKKI ANN 2821 ROOSEVELT AVE 2821 ROOSEVELT AVE 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94804
5154300049
PAK MIRANDA YU CHING 5460 SADDLEBACK CT 2729 BARRETT AVE 22/07 386.72 45.00 431.72 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5161100044
WADLEY DOUGLAS 2858 CONIFER DR 465 35TH ST 22/07 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 FAIRFIELD CA 94533
5161710032
ANGUIANO JUANITA 2928 NEVIN AVE 2928 NEVIN AVE 22/07 767.16 45.00 812.16 RICHMOND CA 94804
5161810188
KANG JOHN SHIN 3131 MACDONALD AVE 3131 MACDONALD AVE 22/07 1,616.66 45.00 1,661.66 RICHMOND CA 94804
5182900224
MCMAHAN DANA 624 35TH ST 624 35TH ST 22/07 370.99 45.00 415.99 RICHMOND CA 94805
5190700251
CIANCIMINO SUZANNE 688 KERN ST 688 KERN ST 22/07 61.83 45.00 106.83 RICHMOND CA 94805
5192800141
SHERPA ANG NGIMA 417 KEY BLVD 417 KEY BLVD 22/07 206.93 45.00 251.93 RICHMOND CA 94805
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 43 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5230340092
PEARCE EMAGER 6145 BROADWAY 849 HUMBOLDT ST 22/07 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 OAKLAND CA 94618
5281610039
ZUNIGA JAVIER MARIO LEON 2330 LINCOLN AVE 2330 LINCOLN AVE 22/07 214.34 45.00 259.34 RICHMOND CA 94804
5281700061
NAVARRO FRANCISCO 2344 ESMOND AVE 2344 ESMOND AVE 22/07 70.21 45.00 115.21 RICHMOND CA 94804
5283600301
SALAZAR GUSTAVO 8 10TH ST 2329 CLINTON AVE 22/07 40.38 45.00 85.38 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103
5290300176
HERNANDEZ LUIS FRANCISCO C 1511 ESMOND AVE 1511 ESMOND AVE 22/07 204.35 45.00 249.35 RICHMOND CA 94801
5290500031
AREVALO RAQUEL MARGARITA 1818 LINCOLN AVE 1818 LINCOLN AVE 22/07 375.17 45.00 420.17 RICHMOND CA 94801
5290700318
DOBASHI NAGI 14277 MARACAIBO RD 845 23RD ST 22/07 99.38 45.00 144.38 SAN LEANDRO CA 94577
5291300324
LINHART ROBERT R 1171 MUNICH ST 1341 GARVIN AVE 22/07 3,002.47 45.00 3,047.47 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112
5292900056
GOSWAMI ASHOK K & RAKSHA R 710 TURQUOISE DR 705 23RD ST 22/07 2,647.17 45.00 2,692.17 HERCULES CA 94547
5302500136
MARTINEZ JOSE ANGEL & MARIA M 1611 COALINGA AVE 1611 COALINGA AVE 22/07 374.12 45.00 419.12 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302700116
DELGADO CRISPIN & ROSA 1400 COALINGA AVE 1400 COALINGA AVE 22/07 360.35 45.00 405.35 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 44 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5340320026
ESCOBAR GUMERCINDO J GARCIA 880 9TH ST 880 9TH ST 22/07 353.39 45.00 398.39 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340320299
VILLASENOR JESSE 815 10TH ST 815 10TH ST 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94801
5342120275
MEJIA KAREN JACQUELINE 45 ALAMO AVE 317 RIPLEY AVE 22/07 389.71 45.00 434.71 RICHMOND CA 94801
5343400239
DOBASHI AHMED S 3480 RIDGEWOOD WAY 544 HARBOUR WAY 22/07 3,653.63 45.00 3,698.63 RICHMOND CA 94806
5380600196
KAUR BEERA TRE 2817 E CASTLE PINES TER 315 NEVIN AVE 22/07 288.77 45.00 333.77 DUBLIN CA 94568
5383500088
VARO-REAL INVESTMENTS INC 617 W TULARE AVE 106 CHANSLOR AVE 22/07 337.88 45.00 382.88 VISALIA CA 93277
5402200207
ONWUKA JOHNNY K 1705 CHANSLOR AVE 1705 CHANSLOR AVE 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94801
5403000101
ANDRADE PATRICIA 15 11TH ST 15 11TH ST 22/07 344.59 45.00 389.59 RICHMOND CA 94801
5403200016
BROWN SYLVETTA 1204 CHANSLOR AVE 1204 CHANSLOR AVE 22/07 231.58 45.00 276.58 RICHMOND CA 94801
5404700014
ZHENG ZHONG XIAN 725 HURON AVE 1601 LIVINGSTON LN 22/07 49.50 45.00 94.50 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112
5441310074
GO HOMES PROP SOLUTIONS LLC 4730 S FORT APACHE RD STE 300 335 S 13TH ST 22/07 368.90 45.00 413.90 LAS VEGAS NV 89147
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 45 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5441420188
SLIPPER KEITH PO BOX 60352 324 S 15TH ST 22/07 596.41 45.00 641.41 PALO ALTO CA 94306
5441610069
LASALLE DEBBIE A TRE 5248 SCHOOL ST 310 S 17TH ST 22/07 110.95 45.00 155.95 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5490710232
LINSY NORMAN H & GERALDINE 331 AVALON CIR 457 SPRING ST 22/07 144.59 45.00 189.59 PITTSBURG CA 94565
5492020291
AUSTIN TAMARA 2932 BONDS LN 2932 BONDS LN 22/07 350.95 45.00 395.95 RICHMOND CA 94804
5500620058
FIRST REPUBLIC REAL ESTATE 1436 2ND ST STE 257 30 W OHIO AVE 22/07 405.18 45.00 450.18 NAPA CA 94559
5501200272
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 222 FLORIDA AVE 22/07 345.38 45.00 390.38 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
5501510290
PAVLOVSKY NATALY 2934 HILLTOP MALL RD 126 216 S 3RD ST 22/07 1,367.74 45.00 1,412.74 SAN PABLO CA 94806
5503200189
GONZALEZ HECTOR 229 HARBOUR WAY S 229 HARBOUR WAY S 22/07 49.32 45.00 94.32 RICHMOND CA 94804
5603100529
ASSADI MARIO S TRE 1003 CANAL BLVD 1003 CANAL BLVD 22/07 650.54 45.00 695.54 RICHMOND CA 94804
5603900134
CENTRAL SPUR PROPERTIES 1300 S 51ST ST 2700 RYDIN RD 22/07 5,509.43 45.00 5,554.43 RICHMOND CA 94804
5607900577
OMOREGIE OROBOSA N 704 JETTY DR 704 JETTY DR 22/07 332.29 45.00 377.29 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 46 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5611920017
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 316 DUBOCE AVE 22/07 337.88 45.00 382.88 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
4056600069
LISING JAVEL V 5411 SANDY CT 5411 SANDY CT 22/08 175.69 45.00 220.69 RICHMOND CA 94806
4056900410
GAUNA ERLINDA 1521 SUMMER LN 1521 SUMMER LN 22/08 357.30 45.00 402.30 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080120118
GORDON JILLIAN 4504 JENKINS WAY 4504 JENKINS WAY 22/08 46.97 45.00 91.97 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080220033
OVERTON RUBY C 4405 MC GLOTHEN WAY 4405 MC GLOTHEN WAY 22/08 670.85 45.00 715.85 RICHMOND CA 94806
4080320254
CEDENO JORGE LUIS MURATALLA 4100 JENKINS WAY 4100 JENKINS WAY 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140330095
YANG XIAO LING 3094 BARKLEY DR 3094 BARKLEY DR 22/08 403.14 45.00 448.14 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140430143
GARTRELL ALONZO R III 2927 GROOM DR 2927 GROOM DR 22/08 136.68 45.00 181.68 RICHMOND CA 94806
4140720048
OLDAN ERICK JOHN 3067 JO ANN DR 3067 JO ANN DR 22/08 38.16 45.00 83.16 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141210247
YAMAMOTO MARK H 2605 MARQUETTE CT 2605 MARQUETTE CT 22/08 334.01 45.00 379.01 RICHMOND CA 94806
4141510075
ROSALES HUGO R 2571 MOYERS RD 2571 MOYERS RD 22/08 353.52 45.00 398.52 RICHMOND CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 47 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4142340019
DUNN HENRY A & FLODA S 2806 WISWALL DR 2806 WISWALL DR 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 RICHMOND CA 94806
4142710153
JONES JOYCE M 5205 PROSPECT RD STE 135 2808 ERIN CT 22/08 343.64 45.00 388.64 SAN JOSE CA 95129
4142720319
HUDSON HENRY Z & ZETTA F 2720 GROOM DR 2720 GROOM DR 22/08 302.07 45.00 347.07 RICHMOND CA 94806
4311930202
ROSSON ROBERT L 3115 KEITH DR 3115 KEITH DR 22/08 64.43 45.00 109.43 RICHMOND CA 94803
4321420079
ELDRIDGE ANGELA & JAWAN 5400 HACKNEY LN 5400 HACKNEY LN 22/08 655.03 45.00 700.03 RICHMOND CA 94803
4322010101
FREEMAN VALJEAN 487 DOHRMANN LN 112 WOODSTOCK CT 22/08 165.66 45.00 210.66 PINOLE CA 94564
4333610162
MCKETHEN SHARON M TRE 5357 HEAVENLY RIDGE LN 5357 HEAVENLY RIDGE LN 22/08 167.95 45.00 212.95 RICHMOND CA 94803
5070600316
RANGANATHAN DEEPA 1906 MENDOCINO ST 1906 MENDOCINO ST 22/08 48.07 45.00 93.07 RICHMOND CA 94804
5070900187
ROSS PAULA JOAN 1934 SANTA CLARA ST 1934 SANTA CLARA ST 22/08 211.87 45.00 256.87 RICHMOND CA 94804
5080610164
ROWELL EDWARD A 1356 MONTEREY ST 1356 MONTEREY ST 22/08 596.45 45.00 641.45 RICHMOND CA 94804
5080820086
GUILLEN FRANCISCO M & SARAH L 1325 MARIPOSA ST 1325 MARIPOSA ST 22/08 259.42 45.00 304.42 RICHMOND CA 94804
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 48 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5101320223
HILLEARY CODY 5823 SACRAMENTO AVE 5823 SACRAMENTO AVE 22/08 262.90 45.00 307.90 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130310260
SMITH A L & BABE 3101 OHIO AVE 3101 OHIO AVE 22/08 5,550.65 45.00 5,595.65 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130520074
CLAIBORNE CATHERINE TRE 235 S 42ND ST 3536 FLORIDA AVE 22/08 209.89 45.00 254.89 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130830168
MEMBRENO CARLOS 137 S 42ND ST 137 S 42ND ST 22/08 389.18 45.00 434.18 RICHMOND CA 94804
5130920324
ZHANG YANTING 270 EL NIDO RD 4232 OHIO AVE 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 PORTOLA VALLEY CA 94028
5131310376
LEVELTEN LLC 2010 CROW CANYON PL STE 100 4216 OVEREND AVE 22/08 470.51 45.00 515.51 SAN RAMON CA 94583
5140700120
PERATA LLOYD D TRE 402 MILL RD 2017 MACDONALD AVE 22/08 5,274.22 45.00 5,319.22 MARTINEZ CA 94553
5140900076
HASAN DONALD H PO BOX 183 2229 MACDONALD AVE 22/08 2,197.64 45.00 2,242.64 RICHMOND CA 94808
5142200186
ALHUZAIBI NOMAN 800 CARLSON BLVD 516 22ND ST 22/08 1,013.66 45.00 1,058.66 RICHMOND CA 94804
5142400232
DAVIES COLIN C 622 21ST ST 622 21ST ST 22/08 63.23 45.00 108.23 RICHMOND CA 94801
5152200076
WLK REALTY LLC 15501 SAN PABLO AVE STE G328 417 28TH ST 22/08 745.70 45.00 790.70 SAN PABLO CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 49 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5153200034
VANEK DAVID M & PATRICIA A 1027 BELL LN 132 23RD ST 22/08 1,210.73 45.00 1,255.73 NAPA CA 94558
5153320113
RUBIO CARLOS E & ANGELA Y 55 MURDOCK ST 55 MURDOCK ST 22/08 781.31 45.00 826.31 RICHMOND CA 94804
5173200287
4040 RICHMOND LLC 6933 SHADY LAKE LN 4040 MACDONALD AVE 22/08 284.78 45.00 329.78 GRANITE BAY CA 95746
5180400052
XUE RONG 1485 GREAT HERON DR 12545 SAN PABLO AVE 22/08 405.18 45.00 450.18 SANTA ROSA CA 95409
5201000386
YOUNG CLARA JEAN TRE EST OF 704 COURTLAND AVE 704 COURTLAND AVE 22/08 303.90 45.00 348.90 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230320128
GUTIERREZ NELLY 827 LASSEN ST 827 LASSEN ST 22/08 267.16 45.00 312.16 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230540063
LOPEZ LUDMYRNA 730 VENTURA ST 730 VENTURA ST 22/08 372.25 45.00 417.25 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230920232
MORENO ALFONSO 960 AMADOR ST 960 AMADOR ST 22/08 210.20 45.00 255.20 RICHMOND CA 94805
5230940115
ABDALLAH NAEM H & KIFAYA 5627 ESMOND AVE 5627 ESMOND AVE 22/08 333.19 45.00 378.19 RICHMOND CA 94805
5282500031
KEOMANEE KHANH 5471 CERRO SUR 2318 GARVIN AVE 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 EL SOBRANTE CA 94803
5291500121
OCHOA RAUL 1771 GARVIN AVE 1771 GARVIN AVE 22/08 405.13 45.00 450.13 RICHMOND CA 94801
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 50 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5291920105
PUMARICA EDDIE 2113 BURBECK AVE 2113 BURBECK AVE 22/08 186.73 45.00 231.73 RICHMOND CA 94801
5300900205
RAMIREZ GUILLERMO 1705 RHEEM AVE 1705 RHEEM AVE 22/08 732.35 45.00 777.35 RICHMOND CA 94801
5302800072
PAYSINGER LORENE TRE PO BOX 2863 1400 VISALIA AVE 22/08 710.70 45.00 755.70 RICHMOND CA 94802
5302800080
PAYSINGER LORENE TRE 2320 ALVA AVE 1404 VISALIA AVE 22/08 694.94 45.00 739.94 EL CERRITO CA 94530
5340220093
SOLORZANO DARLING S 830 6TH ST 830 6TH ST 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 RICHMOND CA 94801
5340310175
MUTUKU ELIJAH 829 9TH ST 829 9TH ST 22/08 97.27 45.00 142.27 RICHMOND CA 94801
5344010086
PRECIADO JUAN PEREZ 1101 BARRETT AVE 1101 BARRETT AVE 22/08 167.95 45.00 212.95 RICHMOND CA 94801
5380700277
BROWN MARY T TRE 241 STARLING WAY 456 4TH ST 22/08 357.47 45.00 402.47 HERCULES CA 94547
5381810232
CRUZ JOSE ANTONIO 230 2ND ST 111 BISSELL AVE 22/08 357.47 45.00 402.47 RICHMOND CA 94801
5383000030
508 BISSELL AVENUE LLC 1547 PALOS VERDES MALL 508 BISSELL AVE 22/08 1,670.45 45.00 1,715.45 WALNUT CREEK CA 94597
5401700124
ORTEZ JORGE A TRE 439 F ST 223 18TH ST 22/08 355.63 45.00 400.63 COLMA CA 94014
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 51 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5401900179
TEALER WILLIAM H & JESSIE TRE 45 SCOTIA AVE 129 ESPEE AVE 22/08 226.78 45.00 271.78 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94124
5402700115
HU YU 454 LAS GALLINAS AVE STE 211 139 13TH ST 22/08 675.79 45.00 720.79 SAN RAFAEL CA 94903
5402700305
SINGH RAJESHWAR PO BOX 3111 164 12TH ST 22/08 357.40 45.00 402.40 SAN LEANDRO CA 94578
5403700221
ANSON ELVIS W 30 17TH ST 30 17TH ST 22/08 375.32 45.00 420.32 RICHMOND CA 94801
5440820115
BYES XAVIER D & KAREN 5269 VENUS DR 200 S 20TH ST 22/08 372.82 45.00 417.82 FAIRFIELD CA 94534
5442120118
BROWN MARY T TRE 241 STARLING WAY 437 S 19TH ST 22/08 1,351.55 45.00 1,396.55 HERCULES CA 94547
5502320145
BARAJAS LUIS A 813 MAINE AVE 813 MAINE AVE 22/08 372.95 45.00 417.95 RICHMOND CA 94804
5608001045
REHMAN IRFAN 2202 MARITIME WAY 2202 MARITIME WAY 22/08 363.97 45.00 408.97 RICHMOND CA 94804
5611510230
HOLIMAN NANCY TRE 228 S 33RD ST 220 SANFORD AVE 22/08 709.96 45.00 754.96 RICHMOND CA 94804
5611910034
GASPAR ALEJANDRO MORA 332 ALAMO AVE 332 ALAMO AVE 22/08 57.98 45.00 102.98 RICHMOND CA 94801
5612210087
MORALES GONZALO RIGOBERTO 900 RANDY LN 608 SANFORD AVE 22/08 347.47 45.00 392.47 SAN PABLO CA 94806
Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

Prog: BIDIV556 Page: 52 Date: 10/05/22 PRELIMINARY LIEN LISTS User: JW60420 Time: 8:32:49 HEARING DATES PRELIMINARY LIEN LIST NO CONSOLIDATION 10/2022

Levy Code: HR

As Of 10/05/22
Service RSS City
Owners Name Billing Address Service Address Thru Charges Charge Total Due ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CONTROL TOTALS . . . 561 Records 279,706.04 25,245.00 304,951.04 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Exhibit 3 - Garbage Preliminary Lien List

November 1, 2022

Finance Department

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

Nickie Mastay, Deputy City Manager
Delmy Cuellar, Director of Finance
Mubeen Qader, Budget Administrator

Subject:

Investment and Cash Balance Report, and Monthly
Overtime Reports for the Month of September 2022
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

City staff is requesting that the City Council receive the City’s Investment and Cash Balance Report and monthly
Overtime Reports for the month of September 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

RECEIVE the City’s Investment and Cash Balance
Report and monthly Overtime Reports for the month of
September 2022 – Finance Department (Delmy Cuellar
510-620-6790/Mubeen Qadar 412-2077).

DISCUSSION:

The Investment and Cash Balance Report is a monthly report of the City’s pooled cash balance. The Portfolio Management Report represents the monthly bank balances, along with market balances of permitted investments according to the City’s Investment Policy. Investment in the Local Agency Investment Fund (LAIF), money market, agency AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
bonds, certificates of deposits, and corporate notes are all allowable and permitted according to the FY 2022-2023 Investment Policy.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Investment and Cash Balance Report for September 2022 Attachment 2 – Overtime Report for September 2022
Attachment 3 – Overtime Public Safety Report for September 2022

City of Richmond
FY2022-23
Overtime Report
PERIOD 3, SEPTEMBER 2022
25% Threshold

ORIGINAL TRANFRS REVISED AVAILABLE PCT

APPROP ADJSTMTS BUDGET YTD EXPENDED BUDGET USED

GENERAL FUND
Summary
400031 OVERTIME/General 1,179,856 500 1,180,356 439,410 740,946 37% 400032 OVERTIME/Sworn 9,499,934 9,499,934 2,404,970 7,094,964 25% TOTAL GENERAL FUND 10,679,790 500 10,680,290 2,844,380 7,835,910 27% By Department
13 CITY MANAGER
400031 OVERTIME/General 2,500 2,500 2,500 0% 14 CITY CLERK
400031 OVERTIME/General 20,000 20,000 4,432 15,568 22% 17 FINANCE -
400031 OVERTIME/General 6,400 6,400 22,671 (16,271) 354% 18 HUMAN RESOURCES -
400031 OVERTIME/General 174 (174) 100% 19 POLICE
400031 OVERTIME/General 813,874 813,874 262,713 551,161 32% 400032 OVERTIME/Sworn 5,165,435 5,165,435 1,100,916 4,064,519 21% TOTAL POLICE 5,979,309 5,979,309 1,363,629 4,615,680 23% 20 FIRE
400031 OVERTIME/General - - 136 (136) 100% 400032 OVERTIME/Sworn 4,334,499 4,334,499 1,304,054 3,030,445 30% TOTAL FIRE 4,334,499 4,334,499 1,304,190 3,030,309 30% -
23 PUBLIC WORKS & ENGINEERING SVCS
400031 OVERTIME/General 320,432 320,432 135,383 185,049 42% 24 LIBRARY
400031 OVERTIME/General - - 1,291 (1,291) 100% -
25 COMMUNITY SERVICES
400031 OVERTIME/General 16,650 500 17,150 12,559 4,591 73% -

City of Richmond
FY2022-23
Overtime Report
25% Threshold

ORIGINAL TRANFRS REVISED AVAILABLE PCT

APPROP ADJSTMTS BUDGET YTD EXPENDED BUDGET USED
36 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM - -
400031 OVERTIME/General - - 50 (50) 100% TOTAL GENERAL FUND 10,679,790 500 10,680,290 2,844,380 7,835,910 27%

NON-GENERAL FUND
By Fund
1012 HILLTOP LANDSCAPE MAINT DIST
400031 OVERTIME/General 15,515 - 15,515 6,092 9,423 39% 1015 MARINA BAY LNDSCP & LIGHT DIST
400031 OVERTIME/General 25,300 25,300 11,245 14,055 44% 1018 RENT CONTROL
400031 OVERTIME/General - 138 (138) 100% 1050 CR-PLANNING & BUILDING
400031 OVERTIME/General 9,500 9,500 9,500 0% 1055 ENCROACHMENT SVCS
400031 OVERTIME/General 8,000 8,000 3,496 4,504 44% 4003 WASTEWATER
400031 OVERTIME/General 8,100 8,100 8,100 0% 4404 RHA-NEVIN PLAZA
400031 OVERTIME/General 15,000 15,000 7,058 7,942 47% 4405 RHA-NYSTROM VILLAGE
400031 OVERTIME/General 10,000 10,000 5,382 4,618 54% 4501 RHA-CENTRAL OFFICE COST CTR
400031 OVERTIME/General - 148 (148) 100% 5001 INSURANCE RESERVES
400031 OVERTIME/General - 163 (163) 100% TOTAL NON-GENERAL FUNDS 91,415 - 91,415 33,721 57,694 37%

City of Richmond
Public Safety Sworn Overtime
Fund: 0001 - General Fund
Period 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Average
Month July August September October November December January February March April May June YTD YTD Remaining Monthly Target % 8% 17% 25% 33% 42% 50% 58% 67% 75% 83% 92% 100% Total $ Total % Budget Expense

ORIGINAL
BUDGET

REVISED
BUDGET
FY2017-18 Overtime - Sworn 3,169,000 3,169,000 569,194 440,670 445,282 459,402 452,278 396,762 322,524 497,979 455,202 554,449 509,368 466,567 5,569,677 175.8% (2,400,677) 464,139.77 FY2018-19 Overtime - Sworn 3,433,019 3,433,019 482,143 537,369 655,866 437,794 524,577 430,398 367,322 512,595 422,587 497,767 536,209 505,966 5,910,593 172.2% (2,477,574) 492,549.39 FY2019-20 Overtime - Sworn 5,165,435 5,165,435 473,963 469,392 491,205 509,931 449,751 473,935 390,897 498,501 501,383 479,696 560,031 439,159 5,737,844 111.1% (572,409) 478,153.64 FY2020-21 Overtime - Sworn 5,165,435 3,533,043 275,202 246,822 296,775 382,618 306,787 278,293 205,529 303,631 307,092 357,284 323,537 368,366 3,651,936 103.4% (118,893) 304,328.00 FY2021-22 Overtime - Sworn 5,165,434 5,165,434 358,067 389,828 472,454 417,698 322,193 301,011 240,070 323,173 309,207 327,424 301,721 360,540 4,123,386 79.8% 1,042,048 343,615.51 FY2022-23 Overtime - Sworn 5,165,435 5,165,435 365,627 345,212 390,077 1,100,916 21.3% 4,064,519 366,971.92 FY2017-18 Overtime - Sworn 2,486,914 2,486,914 268,465 345,174 291,221 359,542 367,182 310,508 336,315 176,449 132,298 196,306 203,912 166,108 3,153,480 126.8% (666,566) 262,789.99 FY2018-19 Overtime - Sworn 2,509,914 2,509,914 257,785 245,946 179,272 171,370 219,937 204,997 261,780 216,596 196,343 310,702 220,368 275,966 2,761,062 110.0% (251,148) 230,088.48 FY2019-20 Overtime - Sworn 4,334,499 2,509,914 295,166 277,886 286,016 300,083 332,654 382,084 347,492 328,467 350,709 302,505 264,571 325,335 3,792,969 151.1% (1,283,055) 316,080.74 FY2020-21 Overtime - Sworn 4,334,499 3,193,165 398,678 380,282 417,982 393,922 267,819 345,928 341,403 305,081 172,961 261,923 263,518 286,039 3,835,537 120.1% (642,372) 319,628.08 FY2021-22 Overtime - Sworn 3,629,097 4,334,499 334,236 434,974 358,578 358,251 352,789 327,832 427,404 396,618 297,215 351,463 715,688 429,890 4,784,938 110.4% (450,439) 398,744.82 FY2022-23 Overtime - Sworn 4,334,499 4,334,499 444,959 444,457 414,638 1,304,054 30.1% 3,030,445 434,684.72 FY2022-23 TOTAL 9,499,934 9,499,934 810,586 789,669 804,715 - - - - - - - - - 2,404,970 25.3% 7,094,964 801,656.64

BUDGET ACTUALS TOTAL

POLICEFIRE

November 1, 2022

Library and Community Services

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

LaShonda White, Interim Director of Community Services
Ranjana Maharaj, Deputy Director-Community Services-
Recreation
Jene Levine-Snipes, Development Project Manager
Stephany Ny, Program Analyst
Tetteh Kisseh, Recreation Supervisor

SUBJECT:

State of California Department of Parks and Recreation
Outdoor Equity Grant Program Funds for the Youth
Outdoors Richmond Program
FINANCIAL IMPACT: These actions do not create any direct cost or liability to the City’s General Fund. The actions contemplated here would generate a one-time grant that does not have to be repaid. These funds would be administered by the
Community Services Department in accordance with
State of California Department of Parks and Recreation
rules and regulations. The Community Services
Department will adjust its budget accordingly and set up a fund for this program (10651051-334351-25G12)

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

September 14, 2021

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

City staff is requesting City Council to approve a
resolution to ACCEPT and APPROPRIATE grant funds in
the amount of $700,000 from the State of California
Department of Parks and Recreation Outdoor Equity
Grant Program Funds for the Youth Outdoors Richmond
Program
AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
RECOMMENDED ACTION:

ADOPT a resolution to ACCEPT and APPROPRIATE
grant funds in the amount of $700,000 from the State of California Department State of Parks and Recreation
Outdoor Equity Grant Program Funds for the Youth
Outdoors Richmond Program – Library and Community
Services department (LaShonda White/Jene Levine-
Snipes 510-307-8132).

DISCUSSION:

Youth Outdoors Richmond Program is a combination of volunteer work, activities, and field trips designed specifically for Richmond youth and their extended families and friends. Program participants will experience activities in the community and local and regional natural area trips and activities for both education and self-discovery, as well as nature exploration.

On September 14, 2021, City of Richmond staff submitted the application for the Youth Outdoors Richmond Program. On May 27, 2022, the City was awarded the Outdoor Equity Grant funds for the Youth Outdoors Richmond program. The program must begin by December 1, 2022.

City staff is requesting City Council to adopt the resolution to accept and appropriate the grant funds and adjust the FY 2022-2023 revenues and expenditures by $700,000.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Resolution
Attachment 2 – Youth Outdoor Richmond Award Letter

ATTACHMENT 1

RESOLUTION NO._____________________

RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF

RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA FOR AUTHORIZATION TO ACCEPT AND

APPROPRIATE THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMEN T OF PARKS AND

RECREATION OUTDOOR EQUITY GRANT PROGRAM FUNDS IN AN
AMOUNT NOT T O EXCEED $ 700,000 FOR THE YOUTH OUTDOORS

RICHMOND PROGRAM

WHEREAS, the State of California Department of Parks and Recreation (“State”) requested proposals (“NOFA”) on June 1, 2021 for the California Department of Parks and Recreation Outdoor Equity Grant funds to benefit low income residents or communities of California; and

WHEREAS, the City of Richmond, as a municipal corporation and a charter city, applied and was awarded the Outdoor Equity Grant for the Youth Outdoors Richmond program; and

WHEREAS, the City of Richmond has received and accepted the Agenda Report regarding this Resolution.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE I T RESOLVED THAT the City Council of the City of Richmond finds the above recitals accurate and have s erved together with the Agenda Report as the basis for the findings and approvals set forth in this Resolution.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the City of Richmond hereby agrees to use the Outdoor Equity Grant funds for eligible activities in the manner presented in the application as approved by the State and in accordance with Program Regulations.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the City Council authorizes the City Manager or their designee to execute in the name of the City of Richmond, the Grant Agreement, and all other documents required by the State for participation in the Outdoor Equity Grant Program, and any amendments thereto and accept and appropriate the grant funds.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the Members of the City Council of the City of Richmond at a regular meeting held on November 1, 2022 by the following vote:

ATTACHMENT 1

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTENTION:

____________________________
Clerk of the City of Richmond

(SEAL)

Approved:

__________________
Mayor

Approved as to form:

_________________
City Attorney

November 1, 2022

Library and Community Services

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

Diana Lopez, Deputy Director of Community Services –
Library
Christopher Larsen, Librarian II
SUBJECT:

Authorize the Purchase of 35 Refurbished Laptops from
Tech Exchange for Library Patron Use, in Partial
Fulfillment of a Federal Communications Commission
Emergency Connectivity Fund Award.

FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no impact to the General Fund. The computer purchases will be reimbursed from the grant award.

Account String: 10545055-400601-24G11

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

June 7, 2022

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

The Richmond Public Library applied for and was
awarded funding from the Federal Communications
Commission Emergency Connectivity Fund for the
purchase of 35 laptops for patron use. Tech Exchange
submitted a quote for 35 refurbished devices that was
within the grant budget. City staff seeks approval for the purchase of these laptops.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

APPROVE the purchase of 35 Dell Latitude e5470
laptops from Tech Exchange, for a total purchase price of $12,492.70 – Library and Community Services
Department (Diana Lopez/Christopher Larsen 510-620-
5524).

AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
DISCUSSION:

In August 2021, the Richmond Public Library (Library) applied for Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Emergency Connectivity Fund (ECF) monies to purchase additional Internet-connectivity devices for patron use. On June 7, 2022, the City Council approved a resolution to accept and appropriate any ECF monies awarded, and subsequently, the FCC notified the Library of awarded amounts, which included $12,500 for the purchase of 35 laptops.

City staff have worked to identify a vendor able to supply 35 devices within the budgeted amount of $350 per device. Tech Exchange provided a quote for 35 refurbished Dell Latitude e5470 laptops for a total cost of $12,492.70 (Attachment 1).

This was the lowest quote received and the only within budget. The City’s Information Technology (IT) Department approved an IT Authorization Form for the purchase (Attachment 2).

For this service, and by the terms of the ECF grant, these devices are for circulation outside of Library buildings. Due to the characteristics of circulation outside the Library, and the observed pattern of use of the existing five laptops, these additional laptops are expected to have a relatively short service life, likely requiring replacement after one to two years. Dell has provided quotes for refurbished laptops in excess of $600 per device and new laptops of $776 - $1,054 per device ($27,160 - $36,890). In purchasing refurbished laptops from Tech Exchange, the Library endeavors to provide patrons with suitably advanced computers at a fiscally responsible cost. Given the expected use of the devices, regulating the cost-per-device relative to the rated performance of the computer will allow the Library to replace devices as needed while maintaining a sustainable lending program. Tech Exchange provides the laptops with a one-year warranty on hardware and a three-month warranty on the battery.

The Library will separately purchase licenses for software for these computers, an expense that is excluded from the ECF grant. At minimum, Library laptops are supplied with Microsoft Office, antivirus software, and software that maintains the hard drive for multiple users.

Tech Exchange is a fiscally-sponsored project of the Oakland Public Education Fund, a 501(c)3 nonprofit. In 2020, City staff worked with Tech Exchange to arrange the donation of five laptops for lending to Library patrons. Tech Exchange has distributed refurbished laptops to Richmond Promise participants at the Main Library.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Quote
Attachment 2 – IT Authorization

Richmond Public Library
Estimate expires on August 31, 2022
Estimate #000014
August 19, 2022
Customer
Christopher Larsen
Richmond Public Library
[email protected]
325 Civic Center Plaza
Richmond , CA 94804
Message
Item:

Dell Latitude 14” E5470 Windows 10
● 6th Gen Intel Dual Core i5 - 6300U

2.4 Ghz
● 256 GB mSATA Solid State Drive
8 GB DDR4, USB 3.0, VGA, HDMI
connector
● Windows 10 Pro Installed
We look forward to working with you.

Dell Latitude e5470 $12,250.00
($350.00 ea.) × 35
Discount (7.5%) -$918.75
Subtotal $11,331.25
Oakland Sales Tax $1,161.45
Tech Exchange

Tech Exchange
[email protected]
+1 (510) 866-2260
© 2022 Block, Inc.

All rights reserved.

Square Privacy Policy | Security
Total $12,492.70

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Support of Women’s Rights in Iran
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Women in Iran are systematically subjected to violation of their human rights, especially their sexual rights, as
exemplified by the murder of Mahsa Amini, along with
other women protesting her death, by the Islamic
Republic of Iran’s security forces.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: ADOPT a resolution firmly supporting the immediate release of all women’s rights defenders and prisoners of conscience in the Islamic Republic of Iran, condemning
the brutal murder of Mahsa Amini, and asking for the
immediate cessation of human rights abuses against the
Iranian people - Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-
620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Many Iranian women’s rights defenders, including Nasrin Sotoudeh, have been imprisoned and tortured for being defenders of human rights in the Islamic Republic of AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
Iran, and many demonstrators are currently being subjected to such treatment, including imprisonment as a result of their nonviolent struggle for justice, dignity, and equality.

The City of Richmond strongly supports human rights and women’s rights, stands in solidarity with the Iranian community, both in Richmond and Iran, and celebrates our Iranian community and culture that adds to our city’s rich diversity and culture. The City of Richmond affirms its support of human rights in Iran, including equal rights for women, the LGBTQ+ community, and minorities, and the end of discrimination against women and targeted religious, nonreligious, and cultural minorities.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Resolution

RESOLUTION NO. XX-22

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF WOMEN’S RIGHTS IN IRAN
______________________________________________________________________________

WHEREAS, women in Iran are systematically subjected to violation of their human rights, especially their sexual rights, as exemplified by the murder of Mahsa Amini, along with other women protesting her death, by the Islamic Republic of Iran’s security forces; and

WHEREAS, many Iranian women’s rights defenders, including Nasrin Sotoudeh, have been imprisoned and tortured for being defenders of human rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran, and many demonstrators are currently being subjected to such treatment, including imprisonment as a result of their nonviolent struggle for justice, dignity, and equality; and

WHEREAS, the City of Richmond strongly supports human rights and women’s rights, stands in solidarity with the Iranian community, both in Richmond and Iran , and celebrates our Iranian community and culture that adds to our city’s rich diversity and culture; and

WHEREAS, the City of Richmond affirms its support of human rights in Iran, including equal rights for women, the LGBTQ+ community, and minorities, a nd the end of discrimination against women and targeted religious, nonreligious, and cultural minorities.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Richmond City Council firmly supports the immediate release of all women’s rights defenders and prisoners of conscience in the Islamic Republic of Iran, condemns the brutal murder of Mahsa Amini, and asks for the immediate cessation of human rights abuses against the Iranian people.

********

I certify that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the Council of the City of Richmond at a regular meeting thereof held __________ by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTENTIONS:

ABSENT:

CLERK OF THE CITY OF RICHMOND
(SEAL)

Approved:

Mayor

Approved as to form:

City Attorney

State of California }
County of Contra Costa : ss.

City of Richmond }

I certify that the foregoing is a true copy of Resolution No. XX-XX, finally passed and adopted by the Council of the City of Richmond at a regular meeting held on __________.

Pamela Christian, Clerk of the City of Richmond

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Extra Mile Day – November 1, 2022
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

In November of 2009, Shawn Anderson recognized Extra
Mile Day to find a unique way to tie cities and towns
across the United States together in celebrating the
selflessness of millions of individuals who “go the extra mile” to make our communities better.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: PROCLAMATION declaring November 1, 2022, as Extra Mile Day in the City of Richmond – Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

The City of Richmond acknowledges that a special vibrancy exists when its community members collectively “go the extra mile” in personal effort, volunteerism, and service AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
and encourages them to maximize their personal contribution by giving of themselves wholeheartedly and with total effort, commitment, and conviction.

Richmond is a community that chooses to shine a light on and celebrate individuals and organizations who “go the extra mile” in order to make a difference and lift up fellow community members, whether through reducing illegal dumping, beautifying our parks and streets, providing artistic, educational and recreational activities, and so much more.

Richmond acknowledges the mission of Extra Mile America to create 550 Extra Mile cities in the United States, is proud to be one of those cities in 2022, and encourages community members to take the Extra Mile Pledge at www.extramileamerica.org.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Proclamation

CITY OF RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA

P R O C L A M A T I O N

Declaring November 1, 2022 as Extra Mile Day

WHEREAS, in November of 2009, Shawn Anderson recognized Extra Mile Day to find a unique way to tie cities and towns across the United States together in celebrating the selflessness of millions of individuals who “go the extra mile” to make our communities better; and

WHEREAS, the City of Richmond acknowledges that a special vibrancy exists when its community members collectively “go the extra mile” in personal e ffort, volunteerism, and service and encourages them to maximize their personal contribution by giving of themselves wholeheartedly and with total effort, commitment, and conviction; and

WHEREAS, Richmond is a community that chooses to shine a light on and celebrate individuals and organizations who “go the extra mile” in order to make a difference and lift u p fellow community members, whether through reducing illegal dumping, beautifying our parks and streets, providing artistic, educational and recreational activities, and so much more; and

WHEREAS, Richmond acknowledges the mission of Extra Mile America to create 550 Extra Mile cities in the United States, is proud to be one of those cities in 202 2, and encourages community members to take the Extra Mile Pledge at www.extramileamerica.org.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Richmond City Council do es hereby declare November 1, 2022, as Extra Mile Day in the City of Richmond and urges community members to not only “go the extra mile” in their own lives, but to acknowledge all those who are inspirational in their efforts and commitment to make our community a better place.

___________________________
Mayor Tom Butt
City of Richmond, California
November 1, 2022

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Family Court Awareness Month – November 2022
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

In 2020, Tina Swithin, founder of One Mom’s Battle, and Sandra Ross of the California Protective Parents
Association recognized Family Court Awareness Month
to shine a spotlight on systemic issues that are placing children in harm’s way.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: PROCLAMATION declaring November 2022 as Family Court Awareness Month in the City of Richmond –
Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Top advocates in the family court system joined forces to honor hundreds of children who have been reported as murdered by parents in family court cases, creating the Family Court Awareness Month Committee (FCAMC) to increase awareness of the AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
importance of a family court system that prioritizes child safety and acts in the best interest of children.

FCAMC’s mission is to highlight the importance of empirically-based education and training on domestic violence and child abuse, including emotional, psychological, physical, and sexual abuse as well as childhood trauma, coercive control, and post separation abuse for judges and all professionals working on cases within the family court system. FCAMC’s mission is also to highlight the importance of using scientifically valid, evidence-based treatment programs and services that are proven in terms of safety, effectiveness, and therapeutic value. FCAMC’s mission is also to educate judges and other family court professionals on evidence-based, peer-reviewed research, which is a critical component to making decisions that are truly in the best interest of children.

FCAMC’s mission is fueled by the desire to create awareness and change in the family court system for the conservatively estimated 58,000 children a year ordered into unsupervised contact with abusive parents, while honoring the hundreds of children who have been reported as murdered during visitation with a dangerous parent.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Proclamation

CITY OF RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA

P R O C L A M A T I O N

Declaring November 2022 as Family Court Awareness Month

WHEREAS, in 2020, Tina Swithin , founder of One Mom’s Battle, and Sandra Ross of the California Protective Parents Association recognized Family Court Awareness Month to shine a spotlight on systemic issues that are placing children in harm’s way; and

WHEREAS, top advocates in the family court system joined forces to honor hundreds of children who have been reported as murdered by parents in family court cases, creating the Family Court Awareness Month Committee (FCAMC) to increase awareness o f the importance of a family court system that prioritizes child safety and acts in the best interest of children; and

WHEREAS, FCAMC’s mission is to highlight the importance of empirically -based education and training on domestic violence and child abuse, including emotio nal, psychological, physical, and sexual abuse as well as childhood trauma, coercive control, and post separation abuse for judges and all professionals working on cases within the family court system; and

WHEREAS, FCAMC’s mission is also to highlight the importance of using scientifically valid, evidence-based treatment programs and services that are proven in terms of safety, effectiveness, and therapeutic value; and

WHEREAS, FCAMC’s mission is also to educate judges and other family court professionals on evidence-based, peer-reviewed research, which is a critical component to making decisions that are truly in the best interest of children; and

WHEREAS, FCAMC’s mission is fueled by the desire to create awareness and change in the family court system for the conservatively estimated 58,000 children a year ordered into unsupervised contact with abusive parents, while honoring the hundreds of children who have been reported as murdered during visitation with a dangerous parent.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Richmond City Council do es hereby declare November 2022 as Family Court Awareness Month in the City of Richmond and urges community members to support their local communities' efforts to prevent the harm of children in the hands of family members and to honor and value the lives of children.

___________________________
Mayor Tom Butt
City of Richmond, California
November 1, 2022

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Design Review Board Appointment
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Leah Marthinsen is applying for Seat #2 on the Design
Review Board, left vacant after the previous volunteer
resigned.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: APPOINT Leah Marthinsen, Design Review Board, Seat #2, Unexpired Term Expires March 17, 2023 - Mayor’s
Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Leah Marthinsen is an architect and project manager at Harley Ellis Devereaux. In their professional career, Leah focuses on projects that serve the public, from schools to community centers, to parks. Leah has seen directly how good design can contribute AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
meaningfully to the success of these projects, whether large or small, and the Design Review Board process is a big part of that. Leah would like to contribute to the community that they live in.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Leah Marthinsen’s Application

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Commission on Aging Reappointment
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Naomi Williams’ term on the Commission on Aging
expired on May 19, 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Naomi Williams, Commission on Aging, Seat #9, Term Expires May 19, 2026 - Mayor’s Office
(Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Naomi Williams is retired and interested in fun, friends, outings, and learning about new people and experiences.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Naomi Williams’ Application
AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Community Police Review Commission Reappointment FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Yenny Garcia’s term on the Community Police Review
Commission expires tonight, November 1, 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Yenny Garcia, Community Police Review Commission, Seat #4, Term Expires November 1, 2025 -
Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Yenny Garcia is an administrative analyst for the Contra Costa Youth Service Bureau.

Yenny serves as a board member of Bay Area Girls and is a member of the Richmond Rotary Club, Richmond Kiwanis Club, and Rich City Rollers. Yenny volunteers with Urban Tilth and The Latina Center, previously serving on the board of directors and as assistant executive director. Yenny serves as the chair of the Community Police Review Commission (CPRC). Yenny has been able to positively work with City staff, the Richmond Police Department, and other commissioners to improve the relationship between our community and the Richmond Police Department. Yenny would love to AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
continue working and supporting the CPRC in serving our Richmond community and being that bridge to bring us closer together.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Yenny Garcia’s Application

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Fund for Children and Youth Oversight Board
Reappointment
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Katherine Lee’s term on the Fund for Children and Youth Oversight Board expired on December 2, 2021.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Katherine Lee, Fund for Children and Youth Oversight Board, Seat #2, Term Expires December 2,
2023 - Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Katherine Lee is a Richmond Youth Organizer for the Asian Pacific Environmental Network. As a young person who grew up in Richmond, Katherine knows where resources for youth are lacking. Katherine hears the concerns of the youth who they AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
work with and where they feel they would like more support from their city. Back when Measures E and K were just being petitioned to get on the ballot, Katherine remembers working with RYSE Center youth who were so passionate about having more funding towards youth resources for libraries, mental health counseling, and outdoor activities.

Katherine owes it to the young people of Richmond who are just like them to be their voice.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Katherine Lee’s Application

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Housing Advisory Commission Reappointments
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Y’Anad Burrell and Dena Nelson’s terms on the Housing
Advisory Commission expire tonight, November 1, 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Y’Anad Burrell, Housing Advisory Commission, Seat #1, Term Expires November 1, 2024;
Dena Nelson, Housing Advisory Commission, Seat #2,
Term Expires November 1, 2024 - Mayor’s Office (Mayor
Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Y’Anad Burrell is self-employed in the field of public relations and serves as a board member for the Richmond Chamber of Commerce. Y’Anad has been and continues to be an advocate of health and housing equity for marginalized communities. The AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
Housing Advisory Commission allows Y’Anad an opportunity to continue those volunteer efforts.

Dena Nelson is a health policy analyst for the US Department of Health and Human Services’ Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and volunteers with the Richmond Our Power Coalition and Bend the Arc Bay Area. Dena is interested in improving public housing in Richmond and ensuring that decisions regarding the Richmond Housing Authority’s management of public housing as well as asset repositioning prioritize the best interest of current and future potential tenants. Dena also wants to ensure that the RHA is accountable in their financial management, a challenging area in the past.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Y’Anad Burrell’s Application
Attachment 2 – Dena Nelson’s Application

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Recreation and Parks Commission Reappointments FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Joey Smith, Allison Blakeley, and Maryn Hurlbut’s terms on the Recreation and Parks Commission expired
October 26, 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Joey Smith, Recreation and Parks Commission, Seat #4, Term Expires October 26, 2025;
Allison Blakeley, Recreation and Parks Commission,
Seat #7, Term Expires October 26, 2025; Maryn Hurlbut,
Recreation and Parks Commission, Seat #8, Term
Expires October 26, 2025 – Mayor’s Office (Mayor Tom
Butt 510-620-6503).

AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
DISCUSSION:

Joey Smith is a water conservation technician for the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD). Joey volunteers with the Black Women Organized for Political Action's State Board and Richmond / Contra Costa County Chapter, Richmond Rainbow Pride, EBMUD’s Community Leaders, United Nations Association of the USA, American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees Local 2019, Soka Gakkai International and USA, The Barony, Asian Pacific Employees Association, and Black Employee Network. Joey is interested in further strengthening their engagement with their adopted home of the City of Richmond by continuing their dedication on the Recreation and Parks Commission in serving as an advisory liaison to the Richmond City Council on the behalf of the Richmond community.

Allison Blakeley is a violinist with the Monterey Symphony and Symphony Silicon Valley. Allison volunteers with the Berkeley Piano Club, Oakland Museum Women’s Board White Elephant Sale, Musicians’ Union Local 6’s Area Wide Casual Wage Scale Committee and Annual Picnic and Barbecue Committee, Monterey Symphony’s Players’ Committee and Negotiation Committee and Delegate to the Regional Orchestra Players’ Association, ROPA’s Equity, Diversion, and Inclusion Committee, El Sobrante Municipal Advisory Council’s Subcommittee on Illegal Dumping, and the El Sobrante Homelessness Forum. Allison has been serving on the Recreation and Parks Commission since the beginning of 2020, has learned a lot, thinks they are fulfilling a useful function, is getting more familiar with the community as well as their colleagues on the commission, and wishes to continue as they believe they are getting better at it as they learn how to do it. Allison has been elected secretary, has just recently started to learn how to fulfill that function, and would like to continue.

Maryn Hurlbut is retired and volunteers with the Richmond Tennis Association, the Point Richmond Neighborhood Council, and the Hurlbut Benevolent Foundation. Maryn wishes to continue to serve on the Recreation and Parks Commission that they have contributed to over the last six years, help the people of Richmond, and improve all communities in Richmond.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Joey Smith’s Application
Attachment 2 – Allison Blakeley’s Application
Attachment 3 – Maryn Hurlbut’s Application

X

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM: Tom Butt, Mayor

SUBJECT: Youth Council Reappointment
FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

N/A

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Gabrielle Stevenson’s term on the Youth Council expired on October 1, 2022.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: REAPPOINT Gabrielle Stevenson, Youth Council, Seat #5, Term Expires October 1, 2023 – Mayor’s Office
(Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503).

DISCUSSION:

Gabrielle Stevenson graduated from Salesian College Preparatory in June and is attending California State University, Los Angeles. Gabrielle would like to continue their service on the Youth Council.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Gabrielle Stevenson’s Application
AGENDA
REPORT

Youth Council

November 1, 2022

Mayor's Office

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Members of the City Council
FROM:

Mayor Tom Butt

Subject:

Veterans Day 2022
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

The Richmond City Council has designated Veterans
Day as an official City of Richmond holiday.

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

The City Council will not meet on November 8, the
Tuesday immediately prior to Veterans Day, November
11, so this is being agendized a week prior.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

ADOPT a resolution honoring Veterans Day – Mayor’s
Office (Mayor Tom Butt 510-620-6503)

DISCUSSION:

In past years, the City Council has recognized Veterans Day with resolutions and presentations, but that practice has not been followed for several years and should be revived.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Resolution of the City Council of the City of Richmond California Honoring Veterans on Veterans Day 2022
AGENDA
REPORT

RESOLUTION NO. XX-22

RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA HONORING VETERANS ON NOVEMBER 11, VETERANS DAY 2022

WHEREAS, at the 11th hour on the 11th day of the 11th month of 1918, Germany signed an armistice agreement with the United States of America and its allies to end World War I; and WHEREAS, in 1938, the United States Congress declared the 11th of November in each year a legal holiday to be dedicated to the cause of world peace celebrated as “Armistice Day” to honor veterans of World War I; and
WHEREAS, in 1954, Congress recognized the American Armed Forces that fought bravely in World War II and during the aggression in Korea and honored them by changing “Armistice Day” to “Veterans Day”; and
WHEREAS, 38 U.S.C. § 101(2) provides: The term "veteran" means a person who served in the active military, naval, or air service, and who was discharged or released therefrom under conditions other than dishonorable; and,
WHEREAS, Richmond’s VFW Post 8399, named after the 761st Tank Battalion1, has been reestablished at the Veteran’s Memorial Hall at 968 23rd Street in Richmond; and, WHEREAS, the Richmond City Council recognizes that Veterans Day is a celebration intended to honor those who have served in the Armed Forces of the United States of America for their patriotism, love of country, and willingness to serve and sacrifice for the common good and has designated Veterans Day as an official City of Richmond holiday; and WHEREAS, many residents of Richmond, City of Richmond employees and three City Council members have served in the Armed Forces of the United States of America.

NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RICHMOND: On this Veterans Day 2022, we honor the many residents of Richmond, City of Richmond employees and three City Council members who have served in the Armed Forces of the United States of America.

**********************

I certify that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the Council of the City of Richmond at a regular meeting thereof held November 1, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTENTIONS:

ABSENT:

PAMELA CHRISTIAN

CLERK OF THE CITY OF RICHMOND
(SEAL)

1 The 761st Tank Battalion was a separate tank battalion of the United States Army during World War II. The 761st was made up primarily of African-American soldiers, who by War Department policy were not permitted to serve alongside white troops; the U.S. military did not officially desegregate until after World War II. Wikipedia. The commander of the Richmond Post 8399 761st Tank Battalion Post, is James Hill, 510/334-7968.

Approved:

THOMAS K. BUTT
Mayor

Approved as to form:

DAVE ALESHIRE
City Attorney

State of California }
County of Contra Costa : ss.

City of Richmond }

I certify that the foregoing is a true copy of Resolution No. XX-22, finally passed and adopted by the City Council of the City of Richmond at a regular meeting held on November 1, 2022.

Pamela Christian, Clerk of the City of Richmond

November 1, 2022

Public Works

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

Nickie Mastay, Deputy City Manager
Hugo Mendoza, Abatement Superintendent
Gabino Arredondo, Project Manager
Samantha Carr, Environmental Manager
Stephanie Ny, Associate Administrative Analyst

SUBJECT:

Dump Day Event Agreement
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The State of California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) will reimburse the City of Richmond, Public
Works Department, Abatement Division up to $25,000 for
Dump Day events.

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

The State of California Department of Transportation
(Caltrans), as part of the Clean California initiative, is partnering with City of Richmond to support
neighborhood dumpster days for residents. City staff is requesting that the City Council approve the agreement
with Caltrans and appropriate $25,000 in funds that will be reimbursed to the Public Works Department,
Abatement Division.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

APPROVE the Dump Day Event Agreement with
Caltrans; and ACCEPT and APPROPRIATE $25,000 of
funds to be reimbursed to the City of Richmond’s Public Works Department, Abatement Division – Public Works
(Nickie Mastay/Hugo Mendoza 510-231-3030).

AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
DISCUSSION:

The State of California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), as part of the Clean California initiative, is partnering with City of Richmond to support free neighborhood dumpster days (Dump Days) for residents. Caltrans will reimburse the Public Works Department, Abatement Division up to $25,000 for labor, equipment, materials, supplies, and/or dumping fees expended for Dump Days.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Dump Day Event Agreement

DUMP DAY EVENT AGREEMENT

THIS AGREEMENT is made this __________ day of ______________, 20__, by and between the State of California, acting by and through the Department of Transportation, hereinafter referred to as CALTRANS; and the City of Richmond, hereinafter referred to as “LOCAL AGENCY”; and collectively referred to as “PARTIES.”

The Clean California initiative is a multiyear clean-up effort led by CALTRANS to keep roads and waterways free of litter, create thousands of jobs, and transform state and local public spaces through beautification efforts. As part of the litter collection component, CALTRANS is proposing free dump day events where the public can dispose of household waste safely and properly for free (Dump Day events).

CALTRANS and LOCAL AGENCY, agree to provide free Dump Day events for LOCAL AGENCY’s residents as part of the Clean California initiative.

PARTIES are authorized to enter into a cooperative agreement for improvements to the State Highway System per the California Streets and Highways Code, Sections 114 and 130.

PARTIES MUTALLY AGREE TO DO THE FOLLOWING:

1. PARTIES shall publicize Dump Day events by informing the public that they may

dispose of certain household waste items safely and properly for free, at the following locations and dates:

• October 22, 2022, at the Fairmede-Hilltop Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

• November 5, 2022, at the Laurel Park Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

• November 19, 2022, at the Marina Bay Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

Dates and times in the locations identified above is to be determined and mutually agreed upon in writing (sample attached as Exhibit A) by authorized representatives of the PARTIES.

2. CALTRANS agrees to reimburse the LOCAL AGENCY 100% (hundred percent) of cost for, including but not limited to labor, equipment, materials, supplies, and/or dumping fees expended for Dump Day events (Dump Day Costs) up to the maximum Contract Sum stated in this Agreement.

3. CALTRANS has agreed to reimburse LOCAL AGENCY, an amount not to exceed $25,000.00 to fulfill its obligations under this AGREEMENT.

4. CALTRANS’ obligations under this AGREEMENT are subject to the appropriation of resources by the Legislature and the State Budget Act authority.

5. Based on the amount of trash collected during the Dump Day events, LOCAL AGENCY shall send its invoices to CALTRANS within 45 days of the Dump Day event for the latter’s share of the Dump Day Costs.

6. LOCAL AGENCY shall send invoices to the Caltrans District Clean CA District 04 Coordinator. The itemized invoice shall contain the following:

(a) STATE’s Clean California Program Code: CLEANCADMP;
(b) AGREEMENT number;
(c) Date(s) of services;
(d) Location of services;
(e) Number of hours and hourly rates;
(f) Receipts for trash disposal;
(g) Receipts for equipment, materials, and supplies; and (h) LOCAL AGENCY’s Performance Report that includes tonnage and/or cubic yard measurement of litter/debris disposed.

CALTRANS
Byron Lim, Program Manager
111 Grand Avenue
Oakland, CA 94612
Mobile Phone: 510.908.2592
Email: [email protected]

LOCAL AGENCY contact is the following:

Hugo Mendoza, Abatement Superintendent
City of Richmond
13th Street
Richmond, CA 94801
Office Phone: 510.231.3030
Mobile Phone: 510.778.0695
Fax Number: 510.231.3013
Email: [email protected]

7. Upon review and approval of invoice by the District Clean California Coordinator, CALTRANS shall pay LOCAL AGENCY within forty-five (45) calendar days of receipt

of invoices. Payment will be made in accordance with the CA Prompt Payment Act, and within the time specified in Chapter 4.5, sections 927-927.13 of the Government Code.

8. When publicizing the Dump Day events, PARTIES shall inform the public that no hazardous materials will be accepted at the Transfer Stations/Landfills. However, if LOCAL AGENCY accepts hazardous materials, it shall do so at its own risk and responsibility and CALTRANS shall not pay disposal fees for such hazardous material.

9. Participating members of the public will be responsible for legally transporting waste to the Dump Day events.

10. LOCAL AGENCY shall provide the necessary equipment, tools, personal protective equipment, materials, supplies and products necessary to perform the services under this AGREEMENT including refuse intake inspection by staff qualified to identify hazardous materials, transportation, loading and unloading, and handling of Dump Day refuse.

11. CALTRANS does not accept nor take any responsibility for generation of any waste streams, including hazardous materials, associated with the Dump Day event(s).

12. All services performed by LOCAL AGENCY pursuant to this AGREEMENT are intended to be performed in accordance with all applicable Federal, State and LOCAL AGENCY laws, ordinances, and regulations. In case of a conflict between Federal, State and LOCAL AGENCY laws, ordinances, or regulations, the order of precedence applicability of these laws shall be Federal, State and then LOCAL AGENCY laws and regulations, respectively.

13. The total amount CALTRANS will reimburse to LOCAL AGENCY pursuant to this AGREEMENT shall not exceed $38,000.00 (“Contract Sum”). Costs incurred by LOCAL AGENCY for PROJECT work under this AGREEMENT in excess of the Contract Sum will be borne by LOCAL AGENCY. It is understood and agreed that this AGREEMENT fund limit is an estimate, and that CALTRANS will only reimburse the actual cost of services rendered as authorized by the CALTRANS Contract Manager or designee at or below the fund limitation amount set forth in this AGREEMENT.

14. This AGREEMENT may only be amended or modified by mutual written agreement of the PARTIES.

15. This AGREEMENT will end on June 30, 2024. This AGREEMENT may be terminated by the PARTIES upon mutual written agreement. In the event of a termination CALTRANS will reimburse LOCAL AGENCY all allowable, authorized, and non- cancelable obligations and costs incurred by LOCAL AGENCY prior to the termination.

16. Neither CALTRANS nor any officer or employee thereof is responsible for any injury, damage, or liability occurring by reason of anything done or omitted to be done by LOCAL AGENCY, its contractors, sub-contractors, general public, and/or its agents under or in connection with any work (including hazardous materials), authority, or jurisdiction conferred upon LOCAL AGENCY under this AGREEMENT. It is understood and agreed that LOCAL AGENCY, to the extent permitted by law will

defend, indemnify, and save harmless CALTRANS and all of its officers and employees from all claims, suits, or actions of every name, kind, and description brought forth under, but not limited to, tortious, contractual, inverse condemnation, or other theories and assertions of liability occurring by reason of anything done or omitted to be done by LOCAL AGENCY, its contractors, sub-contractors, general public, and/or its agents under this AGREEMENT. PARTIES will continue to work together to plan future events.

PARTIES are authorized to enter into this AGREEMENT and have delegated to the undersigned the authority to execute this AGREEMENT on behalf of the respective agencies and hereby covenant to have followed all the necessary legal requirements to validly execute this AGREEMENT. By signing below, the PARTIES each expressly agree to execute this AGREEMENT electronically.

____________________ __________ ____________________ __________ LEAH BUDU, P.E. Date THOMAS K. BUTT Date
Deputy District Director Maintenance Mayor
Caltrans District 04 City of Richmond

EXHIBIT A

DUMP DAY Locations and Schedule

• October 22, 2022, at the Fairmede-Hilltop Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

• November 5, 2022, at the Laurel Park Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

• November 19, 2022, at the Marina Bay Neighborhood located in Richmond, California.

____________________ __________ ____________________ __________ LEAH BUDU, P.E. Date THOMAS K. BUTT Date
Deputy District Director Maintenance Mayor
Caltrans District 04 City of Richmond

November 1, 2022

Human Resources

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

Sharrone Taylor, Interim Director of Human Resources

SUBJECT:

Report on Police and Fire Department Recruitment
FINANCIAL IMPACT: none

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

none

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Municipal Resource Group (MRG) will present a status
update on the Police and Fire recruitment efforts.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

RECEIVE a status report on the police department and
fire department recruitment efforts – Human Resources
(Sharrone Taylor 620-6803). This item was continued
from the October 25, 2022, meeting.

DISCUSSION:

A PowerPoint Presentation will be provided by Municipal Resource Group (MRG) and Human Resources department staff members.

DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

None
AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022

Rent Program

DATE: November 1, 2022
TO: Mayor Butt and Members of the City Council
FROM:

Nicolas Traylor, Executive Director, Richmond Rent
Program

Subject:

2019-20/2020-21 Rent Program Annual Report
FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact related to receiving this informational report.

PREVIOUS COUNCIL
ACTION:

None

STATEMENT OF THE
ISSUE:

Section 11.100.060(e)(6) of the Fair Rent, Just Cause for Eviction, and Homeowner Protection Ordinance (Rent
Board Powers and Duties) requires the Rent Board to
report annually to the City Council on the status of rental housing covered by the Rent Ordinance.

RECOMMENDED ACTION:

RECEIVE the 2019-20/2020-21 Rent Program Annual
Report infographic video - Richmond Rent Program
(Nicolas Traylor 510-620-6564). This item was
continued from the October 25, 2022, meeting.

DISCUSSION:

Background
AGENDA
REPORT

November 1, 2022
Section 11.100.060(e)(6) of the Fair Rent, Just Cause for Eviction, and Homeowner Protection Ordinance (Rent Board Powers and Duties) requires the Rent Board to report annually to the City Council on the status of rental housing covered by the Rent Ordinance. At a minimum, the report must include a summary of the number of notices served, the basis upon which they were served, the amount of rent increases, and the addresses for which they were served.

Contents of the 2019-20/ 2020-21 Annual Report
The 2019-20/ 2020-21 Annual Report achieves its mandate of providing the City Council with an update on Richmond’s rental housing stock, while providing additional contextual information about the Rent Program and its activities during the 2019-20/ 2020-21 fiscal year.

More specifically, the infographic video report includes the following sections:
discussion of the Rent Program’s mission and the connection between health and housing

filed with the Rent Program

-20/2020-21 fiscal years
DOCUMENTS ATTACHED:

Attachment 1 – Annual Report Fiscal Years 2019-20 and 2020-21

Housing AffordabilityCommunity Stability

CITY OF

RICHMOND
RENT

PROGRAM

FISCAL YEARS
2019-2020 & 2020-2021

ANNUAL REPORT
Healthy Housing
Edited by Monica Bejarano-
Rent Program Services Analyst Page 602 of 625
Facebook: @richmondrentprogram
Instagram: richmond_rent_program
www.richmondrent.org
Follow us online:
"This program (Rent Program) not only has helped
several families facing financial hardship, but our
property as well... We are now confident that our
residents' concerns of losing their home have ceased."
- Richmond Property Manager
"From the initial conversation onward, every team
member (Rent Program staff) was knowledgeable and
empathetic. I didn’t feel like just a number in their
system; I was treated with kindness and respect.

...yet your team has empowered me, and most
importantly, had my back and made me feel
supported.

Without a doubt, I would have been homeless 18
months ago if not for this program (Rent Program)
and the incredible folks who run it!"
- Richmond Tenant

STAFF, INTERNS &

BOARDMEMBERS

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Nicolas Traylor, Executive Director
Fred Tran, Deputy Director
Charles Oshinuga, Staff Attorney
Palomar Sanchez, Staff Attorney
Paul Cohen, Hearing Examiner
Monica Bejarano, Services Analyst
Cynthia Shaw, Administrative Analyst
Ramona Howell, Administrative Aide
Moises Serrano, Administrative Aide
Christopher Villalta, Administrative Student Intern
Abraham Gonzalez, Administrative Student Intern
Rent Program Staff
Former Staff
Paige Roosa, Deputy Director
Magaly Chavez, Rent Program Services Analyst
Philip Verma, Rent Program Services Analyst
Vickie Medina, Rent Program Services Analyst
Sarah Schaff, Administrative Student Intern
Erika Foster, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Johana Gurdian, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Madeline Rivas, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Raghavendra Gupta, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Han Chang, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Gabby Arreola, UC Berkeley PSI Intern
Rent Board
Virginia Finlay, Chair
Shiva Mishek, Vice Chair
Alana Grice Conner, Boardmember
Michael Vasilas, Boardmember
Carol Johnson, Boardmember
Rent Program staff members
(during 2019-2021)

My name is Nicolas Traylor and I am the Executive Director of the Richmond Rent Program. I am also a long-time Richmond resident and community member. I report to the 5 member Richmond Rent Board, who are appointed by the Mayor and City Council.

The Rent Board governs and oversees the Rent Program, it's budget and the promulgating of Rent Board policy through regulations and resolutions. Since the inception of the Rent Program in 2017, the 5 member Rent Board has adopted 148 regulations and 4 resolutions to clarify the intent of the Fair Rent, Just Cause for Eviction and Homeowner Protection Ordinance (hereafter "Rent Ordinance"). The Rent Board has also successfully adopted 4 annual Rent Program budgets, establishing and overseeing an agency that has reached high levels of compliance, while balancing each years budget with modest reserves. Little did we know that soon after finding stability as an agency, the COVID-19 pandemic hit.

The COVID-19 pandemic has demonstrated the intrinsic connection between housing stability, financial stability, community stability and health. In the best of times, housing stability is tenuous in our beautiful Bay Area. Numerous scientific studies have linked negative health effects with housing insecurity. These turbulent times have stressed our system, making a structure of support for those affected by unstable housing all the more prescient.

During the COVID-19 pandemic the Rent Program has been the hub of vital information for the community, empowering landlords and tenants to know their rights by disseminating up-to-date information on the unprecedented changes in various local and state eviction and rent increase moratoria.

This annual report sheds light on an important fact: housing stability is a public health issue. By actively enforcing the Rent Ordinance, the Rent Program plays a vital role in the community in protecting the physical and mental health of Richmond residents.

Finally, this annual report disseminates useful information about the Rent Ordinance, Richmond’s rental housing stock, rent increase and eviction data, and Rent Program finances.

LETTER FROM

THE DIRECTOR
Nicolas Traylor
Executive Director

Since the spring of 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on the financial, physical, and mental well-being of everyone around the world. Millions of renters have struggled and continue to struggle to pay rent due to loss of income caused by the pandemic, increased out-of-pocket expenses, lost childcare, among a multitude of other reasons directly related to the pandemic (Airgood-Obrycki, W. et al., 2021). In an effort to slow the spread of the COVID-19 virus and therefore save lives, governments at all levels have instituted policies to stabilize housing and stem displacement.

Studies have shown that housing instability is detrimental to one's health. People who face housing instability are more likely to experience poor health in comparison to those who have housing stability (Taylor, 2018). Housing stability is a cross-sector force that links financial security, academic performance, job performance, and psychological and physiological well-being.

Laws such as the Richmond Rent Ordinance, the City of Richmond's eviction moratorium (Urgency Ordinance), Contra Costa County's rent increase and eviction moratorium and the state's eviction moratorium (COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act of 2020) have all played a role in slowing the potential spread of the COVID-19 virus. These protections have been especially important in Richmond, which historically has had higher rates of eviction compared to surrounding cities.

WHAT THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
HAS REVEALED: HOUSING STABILITY

IS A PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUE
The mission of the Rent Ordinance is to promote neighborhood and community stability, healthy housing, and affordability for Richmond tenants through the regulating of those landlord/tenant matters that reasonably relate to rents and evictions, while maintaining a landlord’s right to a fair return.

Our
mission
Housing
instability
is bad for
your health
2

Reduced homelessness and overcrowding which lead to negative health outcomes for individuals and the community, including the spread of the COVID-19 virus (Ehran, D et al., 2016).

Financial predictability for tenants, similar to the financial predictability experienced by homeowners on fixed-term mortgages, allowing tenants to better plan financially for the future.

Higher academic performance for children: Studies have shown that housing stability leads to higher academic performance (Currier, E et al., 2018).

Reduced psychological and physiological stress: Studies have shown that housing insecurity leads to higher levels of psychological and physiological stress, increasing cortisol levels in the body weakening the immune system (David et al., 2014).

Tenants who have housing stability are more likely to assert their right to fit and habitable housing because they know they cannot be legally evicted for complaining about habitability problems. Tenants are also aware they have recourse to compel the landlord to make repairs by filing a Rent Adjustment Petition to reduce their rent until habitability problems are corrected.

Outside of the immediate health benefits associated with staying housed, there are many other societal benefits to stable, healthy and affordable housing. Among those benefits are:

WHAT THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
HAS REVEALED: HOUSING

STABILITY IS A PUBLIC HEALTH

ISSUE (CONTINUED)
3 A safer and
healthier
community
Housing
Stability is good
for your health
More financial
security for
Tenants
Better
academic
performance,
less
delinquency
and improved
mental and
physical health
Healthier and
more habitable
rental housing
stock
Rent
Stabilization
Eviction
Protections
Housing
Affordability
Financial
Stability
Community
Stability

POSITIVEPOSITIVEPOSITIVEHEALTHHEALTHHEALTHOUTCOMESOUTCOMESOUTCOMES The positive
impact of
housing
stability on
health
outcomes
visualized

One of the Rent Program's primary goals is to protect the health of our community by actively enforcing the Rent Ordinance. Active enforcement means actively reaching out to and educating both landlords and tenants regarding their respective rights and responsibilities under the Rent Ordinance. Getting the landlord and tenant on the same page about their rent-control and eviction protection rights, is the most effective way to enforce the Rent Ordinance.

What does
active
enforcement
mean?
4 Active
Enforcement of the
Rent OrdinanceTenancyRegistration RentAdjustmentPetitions CommunityEducation
The Maximum
Allowable Rent for
each rent-controlled
unit is calculated
based on information
submitted by
landlords and
tenants.

Tenants and
landlords can enforce
their rights through
the Rent Adjustment
Petition process.

Enforcement starts with education. Tenants and landlords who understand their rights and responsibilities are more likely to comply with the law.

RENT ORDINANCE

ENFORCEMENT
(1) Property Enrollment and Tenancy Registration
(2) Counseling, Mediation, and Community Education
(3) Rent Adjustment Petition Process
Active enforcement of the Rent Ordinance has three major components:

5 PROTECTING THE HEALTH OF OUR

COMMUNITY THROUGH ACTIVE

ENFORCEMENT OF THE RENT

ORDINANCE
To ensure that both landlords and tenants are on the same page regarding how much rent can be charged, the Rent Program maintains a database of rent-controlled tenancies and the Maximum Allowable Rent associated with those tenancies.

Property Enrollment & Tenancy Registration
Outreach and education starts with gathering accurate data on rental properties, tenancies and lawful rent levels in Richmond. Having worked diligently the past four years to gather data on rental properties and rents, Rent Program staff are able to better track lawful rent levels and inform both landlords and tenants of the maximum rent that could be charged for that rent-controlled unit.

Landlords and tenants can actively assert and enforce their rights through the rent adjustment petition process.

The Rent Adjustment Petition Process
The Rent Ordinance provides recourse to compel habitable, healthy housing, and an incentive to invest in maintaining rental properties. This is achieved through the Rent Adjustment Petition process. Landlords who invest in maintaining or improving their properties can elect to file a "Fair Return" petition to increase the rent beyond the annual cost-of-living increase. Tenants, on the other hand, who are living with substandard conditions or who experience a decrease in habitability, usable space, or housing services can file a petition to decrease rent until repairs are made or services restored. A rent reduction petition is an effective means to compel timely repairs.

Rent Program Services Analysts ("Housing Counselors") assist community members with a wide range of issues pertaining to the Rent Ordinance. During the pandemic, our services have never been more vital.

Counseling, Mediation & Community Education
Housing Counseling: Rent Program Services Analysts provide community members with individualized counseling sessions on issues related to the Rent Ordinance and associated state laws.

Rent Program Webinar by Services Analyst,
Monica Bejarano
Legal Services: As part of our community education and outreach, the Rent Program contracts with the Eviction Defense Center and Bay Area Legal Aid to refer community members to legal assistance and representation necessary to assert their rights.

Mediation: Often landlord and tenant disputes are complex and may benefit from the assistance of mediation. This option presents a great opportunity to avoid tenant and landlord legal disputes and reach a compromise and/or negotiate a resolution to their issues.

Property Enrollment & Tenancy Registration
6 BY THE NUMBERS
FISCAL YEAR 2019-2020 & 2020-2021
Data Source: Richmond Rent Program, July 1, 2019-June 30, 2021 1,111
Property
Enrollment packets
mailed
FY 2019-2020: 723
FY 2020-2021: 388
For a total:
673
Properties
Enrolled
FY 2019-2020: 552
FY 2020-2021: 121
For a total:
2,494
Consultations with
Billing &
Registration
staff
FY 2019-2020: 1,040
FY 2020-2021: 1,454
For a total:
9,670
Counseling sessions
conducted
FY 2019-2020: 4,369
FY 2020-2021: 5,301
For a total:
574
Community
Workshop
particiants
FY 2019-2020: 258
FY 2020-2021: 316
For a total:
218
Households referred
to legal services
FY 2019-2020: 95
FY 2020-2021: 123
For a total:
20 Mediations held
between tenants
and landlords
FY 2019-2020: 11
FY 2020-2021: 9
For a total:
937
Consultations with
the Hearings Unit
Coordinator
FY 2019-2020: 457
FY 2020-2021: 480
For a total:
41 Settlement
Agreements
reached
FY 2019-2020: 24
FY 2020-2021: 17
For a total:
13 Individual rent
decreases
ordered
FY 2019-2020: 6
FY 2020-2021: 7
For a total:
7 Individual rent
increases
ordered
FY 2019-2020: 4
FY 2020-2021: 3
For a total:

Counseling, Mediation, & Community Outreach
The Rent Adjustment Petition Process

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Rent Program has been the hub of information for landlords and tenants who want to understand their rights under local, state and federal moratoria. With many tenants and landlords experiencing financial distress caused by the pandemic, the need for Rent Program services, especially around evictions and non-payment of rent, has never been more important. 7ENFORCEMENT THROUGH OUTREACH:

THE RENT PROGRAM’S RESPONSE TO THE
COVID-19 PANDEMIC”
The Rent Program has
adopted internal policies to
assist landlords facing
financial hardship due to
the COVID-19 Pandemic
Landlords facing financial hardship due to the pandemic may request a deferral of the Rental Housing Fee or request a payment plan. Over $142,644 dollars in late fees were waived since the inception of the Rent Program. During the pandemic, $116,962 of late fees were waived including situations where the landlord was facing financial hardship because their tenants were not paying rent.

The Rent Program
spearheaded the
development of the first
rent assistance program
dedicated solely to
Richmond landlords and
tenants
The Rent Program is the
hub of information for
Richmond landlords and
tenants regarding
pandemic related laws and
rent assistance
20 online educational webinars
Rent Program staff developed a comprehensive fact sheet on state and local rental laws
Continue to provide housing counseling remotely, in-person (starting June 21, 2021), and via Zoom
Development of an online appointment system making it easier to secure a counseling appointment with Rent Program staff
Instructional webinar on how to apply for rent assistance through the California Rent Relief Program
Creation of the "Rent Assistance Resources" web page
A post card sent to all Richmond residents informing them of rent assistance resources and eviction moratoria
Over 800 courtesy compliance letters were sent to landlords and tenants regarding eviction moratoria, which was triggered by each termination of tenancy notice filed with the Rent Program (as required by the Rent Ordinance) Rent Program efforts to educate and serve the community during the pandemic include (but are not limited to):

Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Rent Program met with City officials and began discussions about the potential creation of a rent assistance program for Richmond residents. Those discussions led to the creation of a rent assistance program. Launched after the shelter- in-place took effect, the coalition engages over 90 cross-sector stakeholders, including community partners, non-profits, and the City of Richmond. This coalition has raised and disbursed over $150,000 dollars to Richmond landlords and tenants.

FACTS ABOUT RICHMOND'S RENTAL
HOUSING STOCK:
8 COUNTERING THE FALSE NARRATIVE THAT THE RENT

ORDINANCE HAS LED TO A LOSS OF RENTAL UNITS
The Fiscal Year 2017-2018 Rental Housing Fee Study and the Rent Program first fee study indicate that there were 24,797 Rental Units in Richmond based on data from the County Assessor's Office in 2017. In comparison, the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Fee Study reports that there were as of the date of May 2020, 17,684 Rental Units in Richmond based on the Rent Program's database.

Does this mean Richmond lost 7,113 Rental Units between 2017-2020? The owner didn't know about the Homeowners Tax Exemption The owner doesn't qualify for the Homeowner Tax Exemption because they don't live in the property as their primary residence, but they use the property for another purpose besides renting it for residential purposes (i.e. Second/Vacation home, storage, work studio, etc.) In short, no. Richmond did not lose over 7,000 Rental Units between 2017-2020. Instead, between 2017 and 2020, staff members investigated and refined the database of suspected Rental Units to identify only those units that are truly rented. The Fiscal Year 2016-17 and Fiscal Year 2017-18 Fee Studies utilized data provided by the Contra Costa County Assessor’s Office to identify suspected Rental Units. While County Assessor data may be used to arrive at an estimated number of total rental units, it cannot produce an exact figure. Nevertheless, County Assessor data was the best and most readily available data at the time of the Fiscal Year 2016-17 and Fiscal Year 2017-18 Fee Study. One assumption used to identify suspected Rental Units included that all housing units in the City for which there were no Homeowner’s Tax Exemption on file were rentals. This assumption substantially overestimated the number of Rental Units in Richmond. Staff members heard from community members that there are a number of reasons why an owner might not have claimed the Homeowner’s Tax Exemption, but not used their property as a rental. These reasons include:

So then what is the reason for the discrepancy? How did the estimate of close to 25,000 Rental Units in 2017 decrease to less than 18,000 in 2020? County Assessor data was used to create a very rough estimate of suspected Rental Units. In 2017, staff members collaborated with the City's IT Department to construct the Program's (and City's) first comprehensive database of Rental Units. Using the County Assessor data, cross- checked against data from the City's Rental Inspection Program, showed many units as Homeowner Exempt. Approximately 23,500 units were estimated to have been rented.

In late 2017, staff members mailed invoices to owners of these 23,500 suspected Rental Units.

Approximately 4,087 suspected Rental Units were determined to be exempt based on feedback from owners. They explained that their units were either owner occupied or used for some other purpose. This left approximately 19,413 suspected Rental Units.

Between 2018 and 2020, owners of more than 1,500 units in the Rent Program's database of suspected Rental Units contacted the Rent Program upon receipt of a Rental Housing Fee Invoice to claim their unit(s) as inapplicable to the Rent Ordinance. Reasons included (a) owner occupancy or rental by a non-paying family member, (b) properties not offered for rent or used for another purpose, (c) otherwise not applicable due to location outside City boundaries or property comprised by a vacant lot erroneously added to the initial database. Page 612 of 625

THE FACTS ABOUT RICHMOND'S
RENTAL HOUSING STOCK: 9

COUNTERING THE FALSE NARRATIVE THAT THE RENT ORDINANCE HAS LED TO A

LOSS OF RENTAL UNITS (CONTINUED)
As of May 2020, the latest estimate of Rental Units in the City totaled 17,684. As of June 2021, approximately 3,200 new Rental Units were discovered and added to the Rent Program's database, bring the total number of rental units to approximately 20,910. This number will continue to fluctuate as properties (single family homes and condominiums in particular) are bought and sold, rented by one owner, or owner-occupied.

How many Rental Units in Richmond are estimated to have actually been removed from the rental market between 2017-2021?
Rent Program records indicate that between the Rent Program's establishment in 2017 and the end of the 2020-2021 Fiscal Year in June 2021, 190 units have been withdrawn from the rental market pursuant to the Ellis Act and 51 units have been removed from the rental market due to Owner Move-In, for a total of 241 units removed from Richmond's rental market.

RENTAL

HOUSING BY
THE

NUMBERS
Governmentally-
Subsidized
Units
(included in the count
of Partially Covered
Units)
11,914 4,337
Total
Partially
Covered
Units**
(Just Cause eviction
protections only)
8,996
Fully
Covered
Units*
(rent control &
Just Cause)
An increase of
1,481 in FY 2021-22
An increase of
1,706 in FY 2021-22
(As of June 2021)
*Fully covered units are those Rental Units that are subject to both Rent Control and Just Cause for Eviction Protections. Multi-unit properties constructed with permits on or before February 1, 1995. **Partially covered units are those Rental Units are subject to Just Cause for Eviction Protections only. Subsidized Units, including Section 8 Tenancies; Properties with one dwelling unit on one parcel; Condominiums; Post February 1, 1995 new construction with permits and certificate of occupancy (i.e., permits are final and unit is fit for residential habitation).

IMPORTANT FACTS ABOUT THE RENT
PROGRAM AND RENT ORDINANCE 10
67 Funding for the Rent Program is independent from and not tied to the General Fund The Rent Ordinance provides protections for homeowners
The Rent Program is an agency independent from the City of Richmond Section 11.100.060(l) of the Rent Ordinance provides that the Rent Board shall finance its reasonable and necessary expenses by charging Landlords annual registration fees in amounts deemed reasonable by the Rent Board. Under Section 50076 of the California Government Code, fees charged for any service or regulatory activity must not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service. To ensure this requirement is satisfied, the Rent Board conducts an annual fee study. The Rental Housing Fee is adopted by the City Council and paid by Landlords to finance the Program's reasonable and necessary expenses.

The Rent Ordinance carves out protections for single family homeowners who rent out rooms in their house or rent out permitted Accessory Dwelling Units. If a homeowner shares a kitchen and or bath with a tenant, they are not subject to rent control or the requirement to have Just Cause to evict. This protection was put in the law as an incentive for single family homeowners to construct newly permitted rental units and to encourage the legalization of the many un-permitted backyard and in-law dwelling units.

In accordance with Section 11.100.060(m) of the Rent Ordinance, the Rent Board and Rent Program function as integral parts of the City of Richmond, but exercise powers and duties under the Ordinance independent from the City Council, City Manager, and City Attorney, except by request of the Rent Board. To illustrate this concept, the Board, for example, adopts its own annual operating budget and hires an Executive Director who reports to the Board and not the City Manager.

Landlords have a constitutionally protected right to a Fair Return.

The Maintenance of Net Operating Income Petition process evaluates a Landlord’s assertion that they are not receiving a Fair Return and if so demonstrated, grants a Landlord a rent increase in an amount determined necessary to provide that Landlord a Fair Return. The courts have consistently upheld the constitutionality of the Maintenance of Net Operating Income process.

Landlords who are not in compliance with the Rent Ordinance may be prohibited from raising rents (for Controlled Rental Units only) or terminating tenancies Tenants may use a Landlord's non-compliance with the Rent Ordinance as a defense to an eviction lawsuit. To be in compliance with the Rent Ordinance and Rent Board Regulations, landlords must enroll their rental properties with the Rent Program, pay the Rental Housing Fee, and follow the eviction and rent increase noticing requirements. Landlords of rent controlled properties may be prohibited from raising the rent if they are not in compliance with the Rent Ordinance.

There are special noticing requirements for Landlords
One of the key ways that the Rent Program monitors rents and evictions and enforces the Rent Ordinance is through special noticing requirements. Landlords of Controlled Rental Units must submit to the Rent Program copies of rent increase notices within 10 business days upon service of the tenant. Landlords of rental units that are covered by the requirement to have Just Cause to evict, must submit copies of any notice of termination of tenancy to the Rent Program within 2 business days of having served the tenant. Rent increases that are above the Maximum Allowable Rent (rent ceiling) and termination of tenancy notices that are not incompliance with the requirement to have "Just Cause" to evict, result in the landlord and tenant receiving a special mailing providing information to them of their rights and responsibilities under applicable local and state law. Failure on the part of the Landlord to adhere to the noticing requirements can be used by a Tenant as a defense to an eviction lawsuit.

RENTAL HOUSING PROFILE

AFFORDABLE HOUSING
Over 20% of Richmond’s rental housing stock is considered “affordable housing." This includes approximately 2,925 units built with Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC), 789 units that receive HUD Project-Based Rental Assistance, and 1,215 with Housing Choice Vouchers from the local Housing Authority. Many units are under multiple affordable housing programs. For example, over half the city's LIHTC units also receive HUD subsidies.

In accordance with Rent Board Regulation 202, affordable housing is exempt from rent control but subject to Just Cause for eviction protections, and associated relocation payment requirements. Tenants and landlords of affordable housing can seek assistance from the Rent Program with eviction issues, receive Rent Program referrals for legal assistance from the Eviction Defense Center and Bay Area Legal Aid, and request mediation to resolve conflicts. In February 2019, the Rent Board reached an agreement with affordable housing providers and adopted a resolution limiting rent increases in certain LIHTC units to 5% annually to better protect low-income residents in these developments.

There are 26 affordable housing developments in Richmond. The map and key below show the names and locations of these developments. They are clustered in the south and west of the city, as well as in the Hilltop area to the north. 11 Affordable Housing
Developments in Richmond
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021 2325
24 26

Between March 2020-September 2020, pursuant to the City of Richmond Emergency Order, owners of properties with more than one dwelling unit built before February 1, 1995, (including LIHTC properties) could not increase the rent on residential rental units. Thereafter, between October 2020-September 2021, landlords of rent-controlled properties were prohibited from increasing rents pursuant to the Contra Costa County Urgency Ordinance. These moratoriums on rent increases significantly reduced the number of rent increase notices filed with the Rent Program.

Prior to the pandemic, in Fiscal Year 2018-19 (July 1, 2018- June 30, 2019) there were 2,476 rent increase notices filed with the Rent Program. Both Fiscal Year 2019-20 (July 1, 2019 –June 30, 2020) and Fiscal Year 2020-21 we saw significant decreases in notices filed. In 2019-20, there were 939 rent increase notices filed (a 62% decrease compared to the prior fiscal year). In Fiscal Year 2020-21, only 233 rent increase notices were filed (a 90.5% decrease compared to the prior fiscal year). This precipitous drop in rent increase notices submitted to the Rent Program is a direct result of local and county wide moratoriums on rent increases. After the rent increase moratorium went into effect, any notice of rent increase filed with the Rent Program resulted in both the landlord and tenant receiving a courtesy compliance letter informing both parties of the prohibition on increasing the rent.
12NOTICES OF RENT INCREASE
FISCAL YEARS 2019-2020 & 2020-2021

ANALYSIS
1,172
FY 2019-2020: 939
FY 2020-2021: 233
For a total:

FY 2019-2020: $50
FY 2020-2021: $39
Median new rent for
rent-controlled
units
FY 2019-2020: $1,550
FY 2020-2021: $1,400
Median rent
increase for rent-
controlled units
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021 Authorized rent
increases for 2019
is 3.5% and for
2020 is 2.9%
The median rent
increase for rent-
controlled units
decreased between
Fiscal Years 2019-
2020 and 2020-
2021
The economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, experienced in both Fiscal Years 2019-20 and 2020-21, resulted in a small drop in the Consumer Price Index (cost-of-living). The median rent increase for rent controlled units in fiscal year 2019-20 dropped by $6 compared to the Fiscal Year 2018-19 and in 2020-21, a decrease of $16 compared to Fiscal Year 2018-19. Despite both of these decreases in median rent increases, many households still struggled to pay rent due to the negative financial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.The median new
rent for rent-
controlled units
also decreased in
both Fiscal Year
2019-2020 and
2020-2021
Based on the information submitted to the Rent Program, the median new rent for rent controlled units was $1,550 in fiscal year 2019-20 (a $6 decrease compared to the previous fiscal year) and $1,400 for Fiscal Year 2020-21 (a $119 decrease compared to Fiscal Year 2019-20). This amount reflects data for rent-controlled units only.

Rent Increase
Notices Filed with
the Rent Program

In March of 2021, the Richmond City Council adopted Urgency Ordinance 02-21, establishing a temporary moratorium on certain evictions of residential tenants in Richmond through the state of local emergency and sixty (60) days thereafter. The Urgency Ordinance prohibits evicting a tenant or requiring a tenant to vacate or representing to a tenant that the tenant is required to move out by law, notwithstanding a landlord’s right to evict for: (1) nuisance that poses an imminent health or safety threat; (2) failure to pay rent that came due between March 1, 2020 and September 30, 2021, pursuant the COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act and; (3) for withdrawal of the rental unit from the rental market pursuant the Ellis Act.

The City of Richmond Urgency Ordinance led to a decrease in the number of certain Just Cause evictions other than non-payment of rent, such as Owner Move-In evictions and an overall decrease of all termination of tenancy notices filed that were other than non-payment of rent. In the year prior to the pandemic (FY 2018-2019), there were 148 Just Cause termination of tenancies notices filed other than non-payment of rent. In 2019-20 there were 94 Just Cause notices of termination of tenancy filed other than non- payment of rent with the Rent Program, a 36.5% decease (data referenced on page 14). In Fiscal Year 2020-21 there were 97 Just Cause notices of termination of tenancy other than non-payment of rent filed with the Rent Program. There was a notable increase in nuisance and breach of lease notices of termination of tenancy filed during Fiscal Year 2020-21 compared to Fiscal Year 2019-20.

NOTICES OF TERMINATION OF TENANCY
FISCAL YEARS 2019-2020 & 2020-2021

ANALYSIS
13 Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021 Richmond’s
Moratorium on
Certain Types of
Terminations of
Tenancies Led to
a Decrease in
Certain Types of
Just Cause
Terminations of
Tenancies
Appendix 2- Map of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed FY 2020-2021 on page 19 Administrative Student Intern, Abraham Gonzales, processing Termination of Tenancy Notices submitted to the Rent Program.

Appendix 1- Map of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed FY 2019-2020 on page 18

0 100 200 300 400 500
Nonpayment of Rent
Breach of Lease
Nuisance
Owner move-In
Failure to Give Access
Withdrawal from the Rental Market (Ellis Act)
Temporarily Vacate due to Substantial Repairs
Temporary Tenancy
0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000
Nonpayment of Rent
Breach of Lease
Nuisance
Owner move-In
Failure to Give Access
Withdrawal from the Rental Market (Ellis Act)
Temporarily Vacate due to Substantial Repairs
Temporary Tenancy
14 Total of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed with the Rent Program in FY 2020-2021
47 35
13 0
1 1
0 444
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021

NOTICES OF TERMINATION OF TENANCY
FISCAL YEARS 2019-2020 & 2020-2021

BY THE NUMBERS
Total of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed with the
Rent Program in FY 2019-2020
30 20
32 1
9 2
0 1,831

JULY-19
AUG-19
SEPT-19
OCT-19
NOV-19
DEC-19
JAN-2020
FEB-2020
MARCH-2020
APR-2020
MAY-2020
JUN-2020
JUL-2020
AUG-2020
SEPT-2020
OCT-2020
NOV-2020
DEC-2020
JAN-2021
FEB-2021
MARCH-2021
APR-2021
MAY-2021
JUNE-2021
300
200
100
0 15
444
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021

NOTICES OF TERMINATION OF TENANCY
NON-PAYMENT OF RENT 2019-2021

ANALYSIS
Non-payment of Rent Termination of Tenancy Noticed Filed FY 2019-2021
Local and State
Eviction
Moratoriums
resulted in a
significant drop
of termination
of tenancy
notices
concerning
nonpayment of
rent
In both Fiscal Years 2019-20 and 2020-21, approximately 92% of notices of termination of tenancy filed with the Rent Program were for nonpayment of rent. While this percentage trends similar to past fiscal years, the overall number of non-payment termination of tenancy notices submitted decreased significantly. In fact, between June of 2019 and February 2020 (pre-pandemic), the total number of non-payment of rent termination of tenancy notices filed was 1,656. During the COVID-19 pandemic (between March 2020 and June of 2021), 619 non-payment of rent termination of tenancy notices were filed, which is a total decrease of 62.62%.

The significant decrease in termination of tenancy for nonpayment of rent was clearly the connected to the COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act, which prohibited evictions for non-payment of rent for tenants who have experienced financial hardship due to the COVID-19 pandemic (with the caveat that the tenant pays 25% of any rent due between September 1, 2020-September 30, 2021). 114
214
196
223
283
208
232
186
143
26 5 1 00 5
108
10 64
28 104
44 29
49 3

Personnel Costs77.6%
Legal Costs8.6%Cost Pool & Risk Management8.2%Services & Supplies4.7% $2.26 million in actual expenses
$2.71 million in Rental Housing Fee revenue collected

92.6% compliance rate
$441 thousandcontributed to the Agency's operating
reserves*

FISCAL YEAR
2019-2020

FINANCIAL

SUMMARY
$2.50 millionin budgeted expenses
16 IT Expenses

0.9%
*At fiscal year-end the Program maintains a net surplus of operating reserve in the fund balance primarily due to staff vacancies. The reserve will remain to accommodate for potential deficits in future years from reduced compliance and collections. The Program will continue to monitor the rental market and adjust staffing and non-personal expenses accordingly. $425 thousand in budgeted reserves (17% per GFOA)
$2.92 milliontotal budget revenue

Personnel Costs79.2%
Legal Costs8.5%Cost Pool & Risk Management8.2%Services & Supplies4.1%

FISCAL YEAR
2020-2021

FINANCIAL

SUMMARY
$2.48 millionin budgeted expenses
$2.14 million in actual expenses
$2.80 million in Rental Housing Fee revenue collected

96.5% compliance rate
17 $653 thousandcontributed to the Agency's operating
reserves*
*At fiscal year-end the Program maintains a net surplus of operating reserve in the fund balance primarily due to staff vacancies. The reserve will remain to accommodate for potential deficits in future years from reduce compliance and collections. The Program will continue to monitor the rental market and adjust staffing and non-personal expenses accordingly. $421 thousand in budgeted reserves (17% per GFOA)
$2.90 milliontotal budget revenue

APPENDIX 1 18
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021 Map of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed FY 2019-2020

Map of Termination of Tenancy Notices Filed FY 2020-2021 APPENDIX 2 19
Data source: Richmond Rent Program, 2021; City of Richmond, 2021

Airgood-Obrycki, W., Demers, B., Green, S., Herbery, C., Hermann, A., Luberoff, D., & Wedeen S. (2021).

Renters' Responses to Financial Stress During the Pandemic. Cambridge: Joint Center for Housing Studies. Retrieved from
https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/research/files/harvard_jchs_renter_responses_c ovid_airgood-obrycki_etal_2021.pdf.

Chew, A., & Treuhaft, S. (2019). Our Homes, Our Future: how rent control can build stable, healthy communities. PolicyLink. Retrieved from
https://www.policylink.org/sites/default/files/OurHomesOurFuture_Web_08-02-19.pdf Currier, Erin et al. (2018). American Families Face a Growing Rent Burden: High Housing Costs Threaten Financial Security and Put Homeownership out of Reach for Many. Pew Charitable Trusts. Retrie from https://www.pewtrusts.org/-/media/assets/2018/04/rent-burden_report_v2.pdf David L. Stern, Andrea K. Blanch, Ph.D., and Sarah M. Steverman. Impact of Toxic Stress on Individuals and Communities: A Review of the literature. Mental Health America. (September, 2014). Retrieved from Los Angeles: Economic Roundtable. Retrieved from
https://www.mentalhealthamerica.net/sites/default/files/Impact%20of%20Toxic%20Stress%20on% 20Individuals%20and%20Communities-A%20Review%20of%20the%20Literature.pdf.

Ehran Dohler et al., "Supportive Housing Helps Vulnerable People Live and Thrive in the Community." Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (May, 2016). Retrieved from https://www.cbpp.org/research/housing/supportive-housing-helps-vulnerable-people-live-and- thrive-in-the-community.

Rothstein, R. (2017). The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America.

Liveright.

Solomon M., and Baldassari, E. (2021). "More Than 500 Bay Area Residents Have Been Evicted During Pandemic, Despite Protections." KQED. Retrieved from
https://www.kqed.org/news/11856817/more-than-500-bay-area-residents-have-been-evicted- during-the-pandemic-despite-protections
Taylor, L. (2018). Housing And Health: An Overview Of The Literature. Health Affairs. Retrieved from https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20180313.396577/full

REFERENCES
20

This report was created in accordance with Section 11.100.060(e)(6) of the Richmond Fair Rent, Just Cause for Eviction, and Homeowner Protection Ordinance, which requires the Rent Board to report annually to the City Council of the City of Richmond on the status of rental housing covered by the Ordinance.

City of Richmond Rent Program
440 Civic Center Plaza, Suite 200
Richmond, CA 94804
(510) 234-RENT [7368]
www.richmondrent.org
Housing AffordabilityCommunity StabilityHealthy Housing