City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024_
Vendor Dunn Edwards Paints _Evaluator Name #1
Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 Pain Prach
1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; 15 20 Ey Condores
2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
19 Wirt a Coutary
THE END.
20 Preciplis
3) price;
19 THE UTTERS
20 4) availability service 0 kmp :
16 Mators
20 5) references and past performance information (PPI) review 17 TOTAL 86
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024-
Vendor PPG Architectural Finishes, Inc Evaluator Name # , Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 DiD Nor
|I) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; 10 ITS AWERS
20 2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
STATEmENTS
18 Put or THe
20 Good Plane
3) price;
16 WITH THE TUE
/PINT 11
ROVIDIN
20 4) availability service
16 of licuuurs
20 5) references and past performance information (PPI) review went presses 17 то тає нижнин
of 3
TOTAL 77
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024_
Vendor_ East Bay Paints/Benjamin Moore Evaluator Name | #1 fu Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 pu seEsS
1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; OF THE SAlICI TONIA 16 WeRE FiLlED.
20 Ramy Corone
2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
wInt re
18 Repunto Forms
20 boss pricinth
3) price;
19 for nit Queur
Uf ntE pinT.
20 4) availability service
19 IN ALISONY WHICHE
13 THE CLOSES
our of THEs
20 RETEAEACES ARE
5) references and past performance information (PPI) review
BASED IN RICHMED
19 TOTAL 9 l
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form- Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024_
Vendor_ PPG Architectural Finishes, Inc_ Evaluator Name # 2 Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 Ad not Prede
1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; ALl Documouts
No Employmont
Application
20 2) completeness of the bid and required forms; Bid PRoposals 10 I'm hire otth
other Bids.
20 3) price; BEnJAMIN MORE
PRicos a Bit Higkor
15 than Efot Pity
20 OAKIANd/SF
4) availability service hocartions
15 Not ASEAsY ACCORS
FOR SERVICE
20 5) references and past performance information (PPI) review GaiD RiteRencos 15 But No hoch!
City of Richmondi
TOTAL 65
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form- Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024.
Vendor_ Dunn Edwards Paints _Evaluator Name # 2
Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 Did nest. Provide
1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; Job Application
20 2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
iD SER ABODE
20 PRicEs wERe the
3) price;
havest But
USED EQuivAlENt
20 4) availability service
10 But Now hocAl
20 Good feteRencor
5) references and past performance information (PPI) review 15 But No City oF
Richmand hodil
REFEReNCES
TOTAL 55
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024-
Vendor_ East Bay Paints/Benjamin Moore Evaluator Name #2 Evaluation Criteria Comments
Score
20 I) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; mects ALL 18 TERMS
VERy completivo
20 2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
20 LoweR FoR
Bangemin
MoORE PRINtS
20 SEE ABOLE,
3) price;
20 moose Prints
20 Closo hocation
4) availability service
20 Makes Rick-up
5A54
20 GReat hocal
5) references and past performance information (PPI) review 18 RePeReNco oF
dest CONtRA COStiA
school District
TOTAL 96
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024_
Vendor_ East Bay Paints/Benjamin Moore Evaluator Name #3 Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Score Comments
Points
20 19
1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; 20 20 ALLINCHAED
2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
APPLICATION
20 PRiCEs, MEA
3) price; 18
BIT HIGH BUT
ONY MEEDS
20 NEARBY FOR
4) availability service 20
PIck.UD.
20 20
15) references and past performance information (PPI) review BUGIHERS USinG THEIR РоРист.
TOTAL 91
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3, 2024-
Vendor Dunn Edwards Paints _Evaluator Name
Maxim Assigned
Evaluation Criteria um Comments
Points Score
20 1) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation; 16
AREEQUIVAIONE
NOT. WAFTISASK
for.
20 18 Missinti A
2) completeness of the bid and required forms;
BLAnK EMPLOY
Form.
20 CHEAPEST I)
13) price; 19
off BRAWD
PAinTS.
20 19 MEANENT IS. C
4) availability service DAKLAWD WITH
PELIVEnY GENTICE
20 5) references and past performance information (PPI) review 20 GREAT PEFERENCE TOTAL 92
City of Richmond RFP Evaluation Form - Paint and Painting Supplies Date: May 3,2024.
Vendor_ PPG Architectural Finishes, Inc _Evaluator Name #3 Evaluation Criteria Main Assigned Comments
Points Score
20 11 мост рлористя,
I) conformance to the terms and conditions in the solicitation;
ARE EQUIVALENT
pen THE REP
20 2) completeness of the bid and required forms; 18
amproy. Fonm
20 18 PRiCEs ARE HEM
3) price;
w/EQUIUALENT
PAinT PRODUOTS.
20 NONE LOCATIONS
4) availability service
@OAKLAND WITHY
RELIVERY SOMET
20 20 GOOD REFERENCE
5) references and past performance information (PPI) review TOTAL 92