RANKED CRITERIA
A3
Woodstreets whole
B
Minimum Change
C2
Casa Blanca kept whole
C3
Minor Change to C2
C4
Modification Wards 7&6
D BBRA
Brown/Black Redistricting
Alliance
D3
Downtown Eastside split
into separate wards
D4
Northside Reallocation
moves Northside
Neighborhood into
Ward 7
D5
Brown/Black Redistricting
Alliance modifications
How many majority minority‐wards are
there? 4 (1,5,6,7) 3 (1,6,7) 4 (1,3,6,7) 4 (1,3,6,7) 4 (1,3,6,7) 4 (1,2,3,4) 4 (1,3,4,7) **** 4 (1,3,4,7 4 (1,2,3,4) Latino CVAP majority‐minority wards
Ward 1 ‐ 55%
Ward 5 ‐ 52.2%
Ward 6 ‐ 58.3%
Ward 7 ‐ 54.5%
Ward 1 ‐ 50.6%
Ward 6 ‐ 60.9%
Ward 7 ‐ 54.5%
Ward 1 ‐ 52.5%
Ward 3 ‐ 54.3%
Ward 6 ‐ 57.2%
Ward 7 ‐ 57.1%
Ward 1 ‐ 52.5%
Ward 3 ‐ 54.3%
Ward 6 ‐ 57.2%
Ward 7 ‐ 57.1%
Ward 1 ‐ 52.5%
Ward 3 ‐ 54.2%
Ward 6 ‐ 58.6%
Ward 7 ‐ 55.9%
Ward 1 ‐ 54.7% ****
Ward 2 ‐ 50.4% ****
Ward 3 ‐ 54.2% ****
Ward 4 ‐ 60% ****
Ward 1 ‐ 56.3% ****
Ward 3 ‐ 57% ****
Ward 4 ‐ 65.7% ****
Ward 7 ‐ 50.6% ****
Ward 1 ‐ 52.9% ****
Ward 3 ‐ 53.7% ****
Ward 4 ‐ 56.7% ****
Ward 7 ‐ 54.7% ****
Ward 1 ‐ 54.5% ****
Ward 2 ‐ 50.4% ****
Ward 3 ‐ 52.2% ****
Ward 4 ‐ 63.3% ****
Are the wards relatively equal in
population? YES
YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES
Has a total deviation under 10% 8.1% 3.9% 7.0% 7.0% 5.7% 5.1% 2.7% 7.4% 7.8% Are the wards geographically
contiguous? YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES
Does the map minimize divisions of
neighborhoods and communities of
interest? *
YES NO YES YES YES YES YES YES YES
How many neighborhoods are
maintained/split? 22M/5S 14M/13S 16M/11S 17M/10S 18M/9S 18M/9S 20M/7S 20M/7S 16M/11S Are the lines easy to identify and
understand? ** YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES
Are the wards compact?*** YES YES
Wards 3 & 5 are slightly
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and maintain
COI testimony
Wards 3 & 5 are slightly
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and maintain
COI testimony
Wards 3 & 5 are slightly
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and maintain
COI testimony
Wards 4 & 6 are
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and maintain
COI testimony
Wards 1, 5 & 6 are
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts, balance
population and
maintain COI testimony
Wards 1 & 5 are slightly
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and population
balance
Wards 4 & 6 are
noncompact in order to
create
majority/minority
districts and maintain
COI testimony
**** Please refer to the published draft map to identify the location of the numbered ward, as the numbers may not correspond with the current ward numbering sequence. ***Council wards shall be drawn to encourage geographical compactness in a manner that nearby areas of population are not bypassed in favor of more distant populations. *The geographic integrity of any local neighborhood or local community of interest should be respected and included within a single ward for its effective and fair representation in a manner that minimizes its division. **Council wards should be easily identifiable and understandable by residents.
ATTACHMENT 15 - Draft Map Ranked Criteria Matrix