RFQ AWARD RECOMMENDATION
CITY OF RIVERSIDE
Finance Department
DATE SUBMITTED: 08/06/2024
RFQ NO.
2336
RFQ TITLE
Civil Engineering Design, Traffic Engineering,
Surveying, Land Development Document Review, Environmental Services, Geotechnical Engineering, And Geotechnical Sampling And Laboratory Testing Panel
DEPARTMENT/DIVISION
Public Works
DATE RFQ OPENED
01/31/2024
PROPOSALS RECEIVED (62) INVITATIONS ISSUED (Online)
PROPOSERS CITY EVALUATION RANKING
Please see Attachment 2
RFP DESCRIPTION: The City of Riverside (“City”) is seeking professional and qualified entities or individuals (“Consultants”) to provide Professional Consulting Services to support various disciplines within the Public Works Department. The City anticipates selecting up to five (5) Consultants to provide services in the following disciplines of work: Civil Engineering Design for Street, Storm Drain, and Structural Improvements; Traffic Engineering; Surveying; Land Development Document Review; Environmental; Geotechnical Engineering; and Geotechnical Sampling and Laboratory Testing (“Professional Consulting Services”).
RFP Recommended For Award (Includes Sales Tax) 10% Surety Included Contract 10% Surety not required Purchase Order
Best Ranking Proposer Amount of Award
Please See Attachment 1
COMMENTS:
The Public Works Department has evaluated all proposals received and is requesting that an award be made to the best overall solution based on the evaluation process. The Purchasing Division concurs that the action to award is in compliance with Purchasing Resolution 24101.
Submitted by: Purchasing Manager Date:
06/24/2024
Rank # A. Civil Engineering Services Score Rank # E. GeoTechnical Sampling/Testing Score 1 IDS Group, Inc. 925.33 1 The Converse Professional Group 2 808.01 2 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 923.83 2 Geotek, Inc. 798.56 3 Proactive Engineering Consultants 921.17 3 Aragon Geotechnical, Inc. 791.13 4 HR Green Pacific, Inc.
1 916.33 4 Leighton Consulting, Inc. 777.15
5 TKE Engineering, Inc. 1 901.33 5 Atlas Technical Consultants, LLC 767.81 Rank # B. Traffic Engineering Score Rank # F. Land Surveying Score 1 Advantec Consulting Engineers, Inc. 932.17 1 Towill, Inc. 932.00 2 Iteris, Inc. 906.00 2 Psomas
1 922.67
3 AGA Engineers, Inc. 896.67 3 Westland Group, Inc. 891.83 4 Urban Crossroads, Inc. 884.17 4 Akison Engineers Inc. 890.33 5 STC Traffic, Inc. 880.67 5 VanLen Consultants 880.67
Rank # C. Environmental Services Score Rank #
G. Land Development
G. Document Review Score
1 LSA Associates, Inc. 948.33 1 CASC Engineering and Consulting 956.67 2 EPD Solutions, Inc. 899.17 1 HR Green Pacific, Inc.
1 956.67
3 Michael Baker International, Inc. 889.33 3 Hicks & Hartwick, Inc. 946.67 4 Psomas
1 885.00 4 RRG, Inc. 933.33
5 Terracon Consultants. Inc. 883.67 5 TKE Engineering, Inc. 1 928.33 Rank # D. GeoTechnical Engineering Score
1 Earth Systems Pacific 918.67
2 Twining, Inc. 902.67
3 The Converse Professional Group
2 901.00
4 Earth Mechanics, Inc. 895.33
5 Geocon West, Inc. 893.50
Footnotes
1) Consultant selected to provided services for two discplines under one Master Agreement. 2) Consultant selected to provide services separately under a Master Agreement and a PCSA.
City of Riverside, Public Works
RFQ 2336 - Professional Consultant Services Panel for Various Disciplines Final Discipline Summary for Award
ATTACHMENT 1
ATTACHMENT 2
1 IDS Group, Inc. 925.33 1 ADVANTEC Consulting Engineers, Inc. 932.17 1 LSA Associates, Inc. 948.33 2 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 923.83 2 Iteris, Inc. 906.00 2 EPD Solutions 899.17 3 Proactive Engineering Consultants 921.17 3 AGA Engineers, Inc. 896.67 3 Michael Baker International 889.33 4 HR Green Pacific, Inc. 916.33 4 Urban Crossroads, Inc. 884.17 4 Psomas 885.00 5 TKE Engineering 901.33 5 STC Traffic, Inc. 880.67 5 Terracon Consultants. Inc. 883.67 6 Michael Baker International 892.67 6 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 864.00 6 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 868.17 7 MNS Engineers 874.50 7 DKS Asssociates- Anaheim 824.33 7 Aspen Environmental Group 865.00 8 Psomas 858.83 8 Willdan Engineering 824.17 8 MNS Engineers 864.33 9 NCE 848.83 9 Fehr & Peers 823.33 9 Montrose Environmental Group 861.50 10 TAIT & Associates Inc 841.67 10 LSA Associates, Inc 822.67 10 Galvin Preservation Associates Inc. 859.17 11 Hunsaker and Associates Irvine Inc 841.00 11 Arcadis 812.67 11 Converse Consultants 807.50 12 Engineering Resources of Southern
California, Inc.
838.83 12 LG2WB Engineers, Inc 773.33 12 CAJA Environmental Services, LLC 804.33 13 Onward Engineering 833.67 13 NV,5 767.50 13 Willdan Engineering 793.33 14 NV5, Inc 827.67 14 Albert A. Webb Associates 766.83 14 Albert A. Webb Associates 785.00 15 Albert A Webb Associates 826.50 15 EPD Solutions 761.67 15 CASC Engineering and Consulting Inc. 776.67 16 IMEG Corporation 804.83 16 Transtech Engineers, Inc. 759.00 16 Leighton Consulting, Inc. 680.00 17 Willdan Engineering 798.00 17 Michael Baker International 757.83 18 Adkinson Engineers Inc 787.33 18 General Technologies and Solutions (GTS) 752.50 19 CASC Engineerring and Consulting Inc 786.17 19 HR Green Pacific, Inc. 749.50 20 Rick Engineering Company 784.17 20 TJKM Transportation Consultants 728.50 21 Arcadis 767.50 21 Rick Engineering Company 727.50
22 REC Consultants, Inc 761.00 22 TKE Engineering 673.33 23 PBLA Engineering Inc 716.33 23 Onward Engineering 666.83 1 Earth Systems 918.67 1 Converse Consultants 808.01 1 Towill, Inc. 932.00 2 Twining, Inc. 902.67 2 GeoTek 798.56 2 Psomas 922.67
3 Converse Consultants 901.00 3 Aragon Geotechnical, Inc. 791.13 3 WestLAND Group, Inc. 891.83 4 Earth Mechanics, Inc. 895.33 4 Leighton Consulting, Inc. 777.15 4 Adkison Engineers Inc. 890.30 5 Geocon 893.50 5 Atlas Technical Consultants, LLC 767.81 5 VanLen Consultants Inc. 880.67 6 GeoMat Testing Laboratories, Inc. 880.50 6 MTGL Inc. 683.23 6 Michael Baker International 854.75 7 RMA Group 878.50 7 Twining, Inc. 665.53 7 D. Woolley & Associates, Inc. 851.00 8 Terracon Consultants. Inc. 876.83 8 Willdan Engineering 655.27 8 NV5, Inc. 847.50 9 Atlas Technical Consultants, LLC 865.00 9 Fenagh Engineering and Testing 654.67 9 Rick Engineering Company 833.17 10 Willdan Engineering 855.83 10 NV5, Inc. 650.15 10 TKE Engineering 832.83 11 GeoTek 857.67 11 Geocon 647.12 11 Hunsaker and Associates Irvine Inc. 820.33 12 NV5, Inc. 846.67 12 Terracon Consultants. Inc. 636.65 12 Willdan Engineering 807.83 13 Fenagh Engineering and Testing 823.33 13 Earth Systems 624.6 13 Albert A. Webb Associates 805.33 14 Aragon Geotechnical, Inc. (DBE) 817.83 14 RMA Group 619.39 14 MNS Engineers 800.83 15 MTGL Inc. 765.00 15 GeoMat Testing Laboratories, Inc. 605.77 15 GIS Surveyors Inc. 797.50 16 IMEG Corporation 778.33
17 PBLA Engineering, Inc. 777.25
Rank # G. Land Development Document Review Evaluation
Score
18 Engineering Resources of Southern
California, Inc.
776.67
1 CASC Engineering and Consulting Inc. 956.67 19 Onward Engineering 738.50 2 HR Green Pacific, Inc. 956.67 20 CASC Engineering and Consulting Inc. 730.00 3 Hicks & Hartwick, Inc. 946.67
4 RRG Inc 933.33
5 TKE Engineering 928.33
6 Willdan Engineering 888.33
7 Rick Engineering Company 880.00
8 Michael Baker International 878.33
9 Albert A. Webb Associates 855.00
10 NV5, Inc. 846.67
11 Engineering Resources of Southern
California, Inc.
845.00
12 MNS Engineers 836.67
13 Ladayu Consulting Group 795.00
14 PBLA Engineering, Inc. 756.67
15 Transtech Engineers, Inc. 753.33
16 IMEG Corporation 751.67
17 Adkison Engineers Inc. 736.67
18 VanLen Consultants Inc. 713.33
Evaluation
ScoreF. Land Surveying
City of Riverside
RFQu 2336 - Professional Consultant Services Panel for Various Disciplines - Public Works Dept Final Evaluation Summary Scores per Discipline
Evaluation
ScoreC. Environmental Services
Rank # D. GeoTechnical Engineering Evaluation
Score Rank # E. GeoTechnical Sampling/Testing Evaluation Score Rank #
Evaluation
ScoreA. Civil Engineering ServicesRank # Rank # Evaluation ScoreB. Traffic Engineering Rank #
ATTACHMENT 2