City of Sacramento
Personnel and Public Employees Committee Report
915 I Street, 1st Floor
Sacramento, CA 95814
www.cityofsacramento.org
File ID: 2022-01267 7/19/2022 Discussion Item 02.
Title: Review of Applicants for the Preservation Commission File ID: 2022-01267
Location: Citywide
Recommendation: 1) Conduct interviews of applicants to the Preservation Commission for Seat B:
an architectural historian with training or experience in the architectural history of Sacramento, the Sacramento region, Northern California, or the West who meets the Secretary of the Interior's qualifications for architectural historians (with preference to a city resident or owner of a business in the city) demonstrating knowledge of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code., Seat D: a licensed contractor with training or experience in restoration of historic properties (with preference to a city resident or owner of a business in the city) demonstrating knowledge of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code, and Seat F: a member representing the public at large (with preference to an individual with training or experience in historic preservation or urban planning) demonstrating knowledge of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code; 2) discuss candidates eligibility; and 3) recommend appointment to Mayor and Council unless additional discussion in a subsequent meeting is needed.
Contact: Wendy Klock-Johnson, MMC, Chief City Clerk, (916) 808-7509, wklock- [email protected], Office of the City Clerk; Sean de Courcy, Preservation Director, (916) 808-2796, [email protected], Department of Community Development Presenter: None
Attachments:
1-Description/Analysis
2-Board Details and Roster
3-Applications
Description/Analysis
Issue Detail: Prior to forwarding nominations to the Mayor for appointment, the Personnel and Public City of Sacramento Page 1 of 4
File ID: 2022-01267 7/19/2022 Discussion Item 02.
Employees Committee (Committee) conducts interviews of applicants for open board and commission positions. Traditionally the Committee conducts interviews at one meeting then makes nominations at the following meeting, however, due to the urgency of filling these seats, it is recommended that the Committee conduct interviews as well as make nominations to forward to the Mayor for appointment at this time.
Policy Considerations: None.
Economic Impacts: None.
Environmental Considerations: None.
Sustainability: None.
Commission/Committee Action: None.
Rationale for Recommendation: When a position on a City board or commission becomes available through term expiration or resignation, the Office of the City Clerk conducts a recruitment for interested parties. When the application period has closed, the Personnel and Public Employees Committee conducts interviews of the applicants and forwards nominations to the Mayor for appointment.
Financial Considerations: None.
Local Business Enterprise (LBE): None.
Background: There are six candidates applying to three seats.
VACANCY INFORMATION
Seat Description Term Term Ending
Date
Residency Incumbent
Seat B: An architectural historian
with training or experience in the
architectural history of
Sacramento, the Sacramento
region, Northern California, or the
West who meets the Secretary of
the Interior's qualifications for
architectural historians (with
preference to a city resident or
owner of a business in the city)
demonstrating knowledge of
Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties and the
California Historical Building code.
Full 12/31/2024 Required Vacant
Seat D: A licensed contractor with
training or experience in
restoration of historic properties
(with preference to a city resident
or owner of a business in the city)
demonstrating knowledge of the
Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties and the
California Historical Building code.
Partial 12/31/2023 Required Incumbent is
eligible and did
not reapply
Seat F: A member representing
the public at large (with preference
to an individual with training or
experience in the history of
Sacramento, the Sacramento
region, Northern California, or the
West who meets the Secretary of
the Interior's qualifications for
historians) demonstrating
knowledge of Secretary of the
Interior's Standards for the
Treatment of Historic Properties
and the California Historical
Building code.
Full 12/31/2024 Required Vacant
City of Sacramento Page 2 of 4
File ID: 2022-01267 7/19/2022 Discussion Item 02.Seat Description Term Term Ending Date
Residency Incumbent
Seat B: An architectural historian
with training or experience in the
architectural history of
Sacramento, the Sacramento
region, Northern California, or the
West who meets the Secretary of
the Interior's qualifications for
architectural historians (with
preference to a city resident or
owner of a business in the city)
demonstrating knowledge of
Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties and the
California Historical Building code.
Full 12/31/2024 Required Vacant
Seat D: A licensed contractor with
training or experience in
restoration of historic properties
(with preference to a city resident
or owner of a business in the city)
demonstrating knowledge of the
Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties and the
California Historical Building code.
Partial 12/31/2023 Required Incumbent is
eligible and did
not reapply
Seat F: A member representing
the public at large (with preference
to an individual with training or
experience in the history of
Sacramento, the Sacramento
region, Northern California, or the
West who meets the Secretary of
the Interior's qualifications for
historians) demonstrating
knowledge of Secretary of the
Interior's Standards for the
Treatment of Historic Properties
and the California Historical
Building code.
Full 12/31/2024 Required Vacant
SUMMARY OF APPLICANTS
City of Sacramento Page 3 of 4
File ID: 2022-01267 7/19/2022 Discussion Item 02.
Applicant Name Eligible Seat(s) District
Bruce Fay F 7
Garret Root B, F 5
Jose Esparza F 5
Joshua Montemayor F 3
Patricia Ambacher B, F 7
Sarah Jane Garrett F 3
City of Sacramento Page 4 of 4
Preservation Commission
Basic Information
Type City Appointment
Status Enabled
Vlslblllty Publlc
CrutinJ Authortty Sacramento City Code Section 2.58
Contact Information
Board Cont.Kt Name
Sean de Courcy
Board Contact Phone
(916) 808-2796
Emall
[email protected]
The commission shall: (1) Recommend to the City Council policies and programs in support of historic preservation, including the goals and policies for the general plan and updates of the preservation program; (2) Evaluate and provide comments or recommendations on proposed plans, public and private development projects, and environmental reviews that are not subject to review under this chapter, but that may potentially affect physical development and hlstorlcal preservation of the city; (3) Review and make recommendations to the State Office of Historic Preservation regarding nominations of property located within the city; (4) Assume duties assigned by the city council pursuant to the certified local government provisions of the National Historic Preservation Act; and (5) Consult with, advise, and report to the City Council annually on the commission's duties and functions.
Composition
Seat A- A licensed historical architect who meets the Secretary of the Interior's qualifications for historical architects (with preference to a city resident or owner of a business located in the city) demonstrating knowledge of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code.
Seat B-An architectural historian with training or experience in the architectural history of Sacramento, the Sacramento region, Northern California, or the West who meets the Secretary of the Interior's qualifications for architectural historians (with preference to a city resident or owner of a business in the city) demonstrating knowledge of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Hlstorlcal Building code.
Seat C- A registered structural englneer(with preference to a city resident or owner of a business In the city) demonstrating knowledge of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code.
Seat D • A licensed contractor with training or experience in restoration of historic properties {with preference to a city resident or owner of a business in the city) demonstrating knowledge of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code.
Seat E -A landscape architect, designer, or historian with training or experience in historical landscapes (with preference to a city resident or owner of a business In the city) demonstrating knowledge of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code.
Seat F-A member representing the public at large (with preference to an lndMdual with training or experience In historic preservation or urban planning) demonstrating knowledge of the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the California Historical Building code.
Seat G • A member representing the public at large (with preference to an Individual with training or experience In the history of Sacramento, the Sacramento region, Northern California, or the West who meets the Secretary of the Interior's qualifications for historians ) demonstrating knowledge of Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the Californla Hlstorlcal Building code.
Board Seats
First ''" Calculated Calculated End Appointed Term Actual Start Actual '"' Previous Position Appointed By Name Name Start Date Date Title """ Counter Date End Date Reason Member Status Sea<A Personnel and Public Allee Valanla 1/1/2020 12/31/2022 Chair 10/27/2020 10/27/2020 Valanla, � Employees Committee Allee
Seat B-Accepting Applications Personnel and Public 1/1/2022 12/31/2024 � throughjune 13,2022 Employees Committee
Seate Personnel and Public "'" MIiier 1/1/2020 12/31/2022 Board 10/27/2020 MIiier.Ryan � Employees committee Member
Seat D-Acceptlng Applications Personnel and Public William Carter 1/1/2018 12/31/2020 Board 1/1/2018 12/4/2018 throughJune 13, 2022 Employees Committee Member
SeatE Personnel and Public Daniel Herrick 1/17/2020 1/16/2023 Alternate 4/19/2022 Bowns,Caru � Employees Committee
SeatF-AcceptlngApplicatlons Personnel and Public 1/1/2022 12/31/2024 � throughJune 13, 2022 Employees committee
SeatG Personnel and Public Ma, Slavkln 1/1/2022 12/31/2024 Member 2/15/2022 2/lS/2022 Lemon, � Employees Committee David
"°""'" Appotnted By First "'" calculated calculated Tltle Appotnted Tenn Actual Start Actual '"' Prevtous Status Name ··- Start Date End Date .... Counter Date End Date Reason Member Showlng 1t o7o f7 entrles
On8Nrd2 -Powered by ClerkBase I Generated 7nt2022 @15:45:59 PM
Preservation Commission
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Applicant Date Address Contact Status
Patricia Ambacher 1/11/2022 Ward/District: District 7 Validated Jose Esparza 6/7/2022 Ward/District: District 5 Validated Bruce Fay 5/14/2022 Ward/District: District 7 Validated Sarah Jane Garrett 5/18/2022 Ward/District: District 3 Validated Joshua Montemayor 5/20/2022 Ward/District: District 3 Validated Garret Root 4/21/2022 Ward/District: District 5 Validated Patricia Ambacher
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Patricia Ambacher
1/11/2022
1/11/2023
Patricia Ambacher
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D7
Basic Information
Name
Patricia Ambacher
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
Documenting, preserving, and recognizing Sacramento’s
cultural resources is important. Equally important is an open and transparent public process for such activities. I’m interested in joining the Preservation Commission to share my enthusiasm for preserving Sacramento’s important
places. I would also like to give back to my community, and based on my personal experiences and expertise, this would be a way I could make a good contribution.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I have worked as an architectural historian/historian for 19 years in the cultural resources management and historic preservation planning fields. I have inventoried and
evaluated a variety of individual properties and districts for their potential eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places, California Register of Historical Resources, and the Sacramento Register of Historical and Cultural Resources. I have completed projects in compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, NEPA, and CEQA. My professional experience includes working at environmental and engineering consulting firms and the California Office of Historic Preservation where I was part of the staff to the State Historical Resources Commission and reviewed
nominations for the four registration programs for the
adequacy and compliance with the registration programs’ guidelines for submittal. While at the Office of Historic Preservation, I also reviewed the Evaluation of Significance of the Historic Preservation Certification Applications (Part 1s) as part of the federal historic preservation tax incentive program.
My work in Sacramento includes:
• Lead architectural historian for the City of Sacramento’s Mid-Century Survey and Context Statement where I focused on research, preparing the historic context centered on local history, Sacramento modernist architects/builders,
conducted intensive level surveys, and prepared 3 of the evaluations
• Lead architectural historian for the historic Substation A Rebuild and Relocation project
• Lead architectural historian for the Jesse Unruh Roof Replacement Project
• Lead historian for various SMUD projects
• Lead historian for the Old Sacramento State Historic Park General Development Plan and Environmental Impact
Report
• Lead historian for various Sacramento Area Flood Control Agency projects
• Lead architectural historian for various CEQA projects in Sacramento and Davis
Please list any training or education directly related to Contact Information
Ward/District
District 7
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED
the seat you are applying for.
I have a MA in History – Emphasis in Public History, and a BA in History with a minor in Anthropology, both from CSU, Sacramento. Early in my career I completed the UC Davis Continuing and Professional Education course Cultural
Resource Management: CEQA, NEPA, and Section 106. I’ve
attended workshops on cultural landscapes offered by the California Preservation Foundation. When I worked for the California Office of Historic Preservation I received training from State Parks’ legal team on the procedures for
conducting public meetings and the legal requirements for evaluating nominations presented to the State Historical Resources Committee. I’ve attended the California
Preservation Foundation’s annual conference.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I have presented sessions at the California Preservation Foundation conference and the California Council for the Promotion of History. I have provided training workshops associated with local historical societies and to the cultural resources staff of California State Parks. I have also given presentations to professional teams (e.g. environmental planners, engineers) within the various companies for which I’ve worked highlighting CEQA relating to cultural resources for the design and planning for projects. At the Office of Historic Preservation I participated in training new
commissioners on their roles/responsibilities and the
guidelines for the four registration programs.
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat B or Seat G
Jose Esparza
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Jose Esparza
6/7/2022
6/7/2023
Jose Esparza
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D5
Basic Information
Name
Jose Esparza
Contact Information
Ward/District
District 5
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
I served on the Board of Directors of Sacramento Heritage, Inc as Vice Chair and I believe that my experience as such can be of value to the Preservation Commission.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
BA in Political Science; Master in History (Chilean immigration to California during the Gold Rush); Masters in Science in Law (in progress) McGeorge School of Law
Please list any training or education directly related to the seat you are applying for.
As a historian and as a former member of Sacramento
Heritage, Inc. I assisted the Board in running the entity by making financial and procedural decisions as a City-
sponsored 501(c)3. I also assisted and helped manage the group's social media presence and it's educational goals.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I planned and executed a tour of the Poverty Ridge
neighborhood showcasing many of the properties. For
Preservation Sacramento, I assisted in working as a docent at several of their home tours and I have extensive experience conducting outreach for the Sacramento Public Library. I also serve as an active Board Member of the Odd fellows Lawn Cemetery where I have served since 2018.
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat F
Bruce Fay
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Bruce Fay
5/14/2022
5/14/2023
Bruce Fay
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D7
Basic Information
Name
Bruce Fay
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
I am very interested in assisting the City of Sacramento to develop and implement its general plan, review
development projects, and participate in the consideration of, and making recommendations regarding, historic
preservation. I've been interested in and studying
Sacramento and California history for over 25 years,
including research and other involvement in local history projects.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
Extensive career/job experience within government specific to the research, interpretation, and application of
government codes. Extensive experience working and
teaming with representatives of numerous government
agencies, private interests, and the public at large. Extensive experience dealing with sensitive issues, attending hearings, and representing large state agency. Functioned as a
contributing project team member and a lead or manager on departmental projects specific to numerous industries. Led projects involving the construction industry, tax
investigations, and workforce development, and other areas.
Extensive experience reviewing complex documents and
reports, as well as analyzing proposals, government agency recommendations, union requests, and new legislation.
Please list any training or education directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I have a Bachelor's Degree in Business Administration. As applicable to this position, I have completed, and developed or led, substantial training in subjects including but not limited to project planning and management, report
preparation, marketing/communications, application of
government codes, and analysis of new or pending
legislation.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I have conducted research and written numerous articles for two local neighborhood newspapers on a wide variety of
history subjects. Topics included the history of local railyards, local World War II victory gardens, historic street lights, local neon signage, and numerous residential and commercial
buildings of historic significance. I have also written articles on local architectural styles and architectural elements used in Sacramento homes of the 1920's through the 1950's. I was a participating researcher and writer for walking tour
brochures of significant streets and homes in several Curtis Park subdivisions. I have participated in the research for a neighborhood historic district, a single street historic district, and specific homes that have achieved or are in process of achieving historic designation.
Contact Information
Ward/District
District 7
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat F
Sarah Jane Garrett
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Sarah Jane Garrett
5/18/2022
5/18/2023
Sarah Jane Garrett
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D3
Basic Information
Name
Sarah Jane Garrett
Contact Information
Ward/District
District 3
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
I have a strong interest in history and historical preservation.
I enjoy using my lawyerly skills through public service. I would welcome the opportunity to learn more about the
history of Sacramento, after having moved here in 2017 to join the state.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I have been a property tax professional in CA for the past 7.5 years. This has included some work on applications for
historical status at the local level in Los Angeles County, as well as some experience with the Mills act.
Please list any training or education directly related to the seat you are applying for.
My bachelors in History was focused on California History.
Additionally, I am a lawyer who uses my education to
interpret the law, regulations, policy and procedures on a daily basis. I am a quick study and enjoy due diligence to ensure a decision is supported.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I've volunteered on a number of professional attorney
Boards (American Constitution Society, Los Angeles County Bar Association, etc), including having been elected to various offices in support of activities and services of the organization. I am a person who keeps my commitments.
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat F
Joshua Montemayor
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Joshua Montemayor
5/20/2022
5/20/2023
Joshua Montemayor
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D3
Basic Information
Name
Joshua Montemayor
Contact Information
Ward/District
District 3
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
I have 10 years of experience in City Planning. I went to school and studied urban and regional planning, and have a graduate degree in public administration. As such, I have extensive knowledge to make sound decisions as a member of the Preservation Commission and making
recommendations to the Planning Commission.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I have worked for multiple municipal agencies in the
Planning Department including the cities of: Folsom,
Sausalito, Pacifica, Costa Mesa, Lomita, and Bellflower. At the City of Sausalito, I was an Assistant Planner where I made formal presentations to the Historic Landmarks Board for Design Review proposals on residential properties that were 50-years or older and posed a potential historical
significance. Findings must be consistent with HLB standards and CEQA.
Please list any training or education directly related to the seat you are applying for.
Undergraduate degree (BA) in Urban Planning.
Graduate degree (MPA) in Public Administration.
Ongoing training as a City Planner via consortiums.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I currently volunteer on my HOA Board and serve as the
association's Vice President. I review proposed exterior improvements to properties within the organization and
make recommendations or request for revisions based on
the consistency with the character of the neighborhood. This includes, but not limited to, landscape improvements, paint renderings, lamp posts, mailboxes, and more.
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat F
Garret Root
City of Sacramento, CA | Generated 7/12/2022 @ 12:05 pm by OnBoard2 - Powered by ClerkBase Name
Application Date
Expiration Date
Board Member
Status
Status
Garret Root
4/21/2022
4/21/2023
Garret Root
Validated
Board Vacancies Status
Preservation Commission 3 MQ's Confirmed- D5
Basic Information
Name
Garret Root
Date of Birth
REDACTED
Please state the reason(s) you would like to serve on this legislative body.
I have an interest in sharing my experience and expertise as an architectural historian in Sacramento. I have a vested interest in historic preservation in the community and would like to be able to be a participant in the process.
Please list all of your professional experience directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I meet and exceed the Secretary of the Interior Professional Qualification Standards for History and Architectural History.
I have worked in Northern California as an Architectural Historian for 13 years of which, during the same time, lived in Sacramento. I am currently the Senior Architectural History Team Lead at SWCA. I oversee the Architectural History and Historic Preservation team in Northern California and
support our adjacent states. At my previous firms I served as the National Program Manager for Architectural History and in Senior Architectural History Capacities. I have experience working with the Secretary of the Interior Standards and historic building code while serving on the board of
Preservation Sacramento and have used it in my professional career.
Please list any training or education directly related to the seat you are applying for.
I meet and exceed the Secretary of the Interior Professional Qualification Standards for History and Architectural History.
I earned my Masters of Arts in Public History from
Sacramento State in 2011 and my Bachelor of Arts in History with a Certificate in Public History from Chico State in 2009. I have worked in Northern California as an Architectural
Historian for 13 years of which, during the same time, lived in Sacramento. I have given presentations at professional
conferences about use of digital technologies in
documenting historic resources.
Please list any additional experience, community
activities, volunteering experience, or other
qualifications that would be helpful in evaluating your application.
I have previously served on the board of Preservation
Sacramento, the local nonprofit, first for 2 years as a general board member and social media coordinator and then an
additional 2 years as the board President. In that capacity I oversaw the rebranding of the organization from the
Sacramento Old City Association to its current name,
Preservation Sacramento. I grew our online presence
through the establishment of our twitter and Instagram
accounts, in the process I documented and wrote histories of approximately 525 buildings, structures, and locations
around the city.
Please list the Seat(s) you are applying for.
Seat B
Contact Information
Ward/District
District 5
Phone
REDACTED
Email
REDACTED