San Clemente City Council
January 16, 2024

126

04/05/2017
Notice to Proceed Letter
This NTP Letter MUST be provided to the ATC approved contractor that will be performing the work.

ATC Site #: 89366 INGENU INC.

ATC Site Name: SAN CLEMENTE CA
Customer Site Name: San Clemente
Dear INGENU INC.,
American Tower is pleased to inform you that all construction prerequisites have been met and you are approved to begin construction.
 Per the schedule provided to ATC, you are scheduled to start construction on 04/03/2017.  Your NTP is valid for twelve months from the date of issuance or until the expiration of your building permit. 127
AMERICAN TOWER• CORPORATION
128
Licensor Site Name / Number: SAN CLEMENTE CA / 89366
Licensee Site Name / Number: San Clemente / US-LAX-0014C 1 ECM#41028
Rev. 02.24.09

LICENSE AGREEMENT
This LICENSE AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) is entered into as of the latter signature date hereof (“Effective Date”) by and between American Tower Management, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, with a place of business at 10 Presidential Way, Woburn, MA 01801 (“Licensor”) and Ingenu Inc., a Delaware corporation, with a place of business at 10301 Meanley Drive, San Diego, CA 92131 (“Licensee”).

I. TOWER FACILITY INFORMATION:

Site Name: SAN CLEMENTE CA
Site Number: 89366
Address and/or location of Tower Facility: 2M Northeast of San Clemente, San Clemente, CA, 92672-7521 Tower Facility Coordinates: Lat. 33-26-37.259988 N Long. 117-35-19.14 W IV. FEES & TERM:

DocuSign Envelope ID: 29BF355A-2C82-4CC0-9E9C-40584D3F30FB 129
Licensor Site Name / Number: SAN CLEMENTE CA / 89366
Licensee Site Name / Number: San Clemente / US-LAX-0014C 2 ECM#41028
Rev. 02.24.09
Initial Term: A period of five (5) years beginning on the Commencement Date. The “Commencement Date” shall be the date of Licensor’s issuance of a NTP.

Renewal Terms: Three (3) additional periods of five (5) years each.

DocuSign Envelope ID: 29BF355A-2C82-4CC0-9E9C-40584D3F30FB 130
Licensor Site Name / Number: SAN CLEMENTE CA / 89366
3 ECM#41028
Rev. 02.24.09

LICENSOR LICENSEE
American Tower Management, LLC, Ingenu Inc., a Delaware corporation a Delaware limited liability company
By: American Towers LLC, its sole member
Date: ____________________________ Date:

DocuSign Envelope ID: 29BF355A-2C82-4CC0-9E9C-40584D3F30FB March 17, 2017 March 14, 2017
131
132

LICENSE AGREEMENT
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME I NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
This LICENSE AGREEMENT ("Agreement") is entered into as of the latter signature date hereof ("Effective Date") by and between American Tower Management, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, a subsidiary of American Towers LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, with a place of business at 10 Presidential Way, Woburn, MA 01801 ("Licensor") and Google LLC, a Delaware limited liability company with a place of business at 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043 ("Licensee") pursuant to that certain letter agreement dated July 26, 2019 by and between American Towers LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of itself, its affiliates, and its subsidiaries, SpectraSite C,ommunications, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of itself, its affiliates, and its subsidiaries, and Licensee (the "Letter Agreement").

I. TOWER FACILITY INFORMATION:

Site Name: SAN CLEMENTE CA
Site Number: 89366
Address and/or location of Tower Facility: 2M Northeast of San Clemente, CA 92672-7521 Tower Facility Coordinates: Lat. 33.44368 Long. -117.58865 IV. FEES & TERM:
1 133
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME/ NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
Initial Term: A period of five (5) years beginning on the Commencement Date. The "Commencement Date" shall be June 1, 2020.

Renewal Terms: 3 additional periods of 5 years each.
134
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
[Signatures appear on next page]
3 135
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME I NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA I W13
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, each Party in consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein, and for other good and valuable consideration, intending to be legally bound, has caused this Agreement to be executed by its duly authorized representative as of the day and year written below; provided, however, that this Agreement shall not become effective as to either Party until executed by both Parties.

LICENSEE:

Google LLC, a Delaware limited liability company
Date: Date:
4 136
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA I W13
137
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
6 138
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
139
LI CENSOR SITE NAME / NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME/ NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
140
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
141
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
142
11 143
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
12 144
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
145
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
146
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
147
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
148
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
17 149
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
150
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA I W13
151
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
152
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
21 153
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
22 154
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
23 155
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
24 156
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/W13
Exhibit D
25 157
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
Appendix I
26 158
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA / W13
159
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemente CA/ W13
160
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
29 161
LICENSOR SITE NAME/ NUMBER: SAN CLEMENTE CA/ 89366
LICENSEE SITE NAME / NUMBER: ATC San Clemen'te CA/ W13
30 162
ON AIR Access I Preview Exhibit Page 1 of I
https://oaaintemal.americantower.com/OLA/faces/exhibitPage.jspx?applicationld=366659 2/12/2020 163
164
Customer/ Supplier Name: GOOGLE LLC, PO BOX 2050
PagE
165
Customers Own Site Name
Effective Termination Date
■
• -
-
A TC San -Clemente CA
' ' '
-
01-JWl-2020
PagE
166 PagE
167
C)
a. "'
New License
This New License Site Schedule (this “New License”) is executed and delivered pursuant to that certain Strategic Collocation Agreement between Licensor and Licensee, each as identified below, with an Effective Date of March 12, 2021. All terms and conditions of the Strategic Collocation Agreement are incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof for all purposes.

The following space shall be licensed on the terms indicated below:

1. Licensee's Name: DISH Wireless L.L.C., a Colorado limited liability company

2. Licensor Information:

Notice Address: American Tower Management, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company
10 Presidential Way
Woburn, MA 01801
Attn: Contracts Manager

3. Tower Information:

Licensor’s Tower Name: SAN CLEMENTE CA
Licensor’s Tower Number: 89366
Coordinates: Lat: 33.0°-26.0’-37.233N”
Lon: 117.0°-35.0’-19.213W”
Licensee’s Tower Name: LSSNA01020A
Licensee’s Tower Number: LSSNA01020A
168
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 169
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 3 170
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 4 Agreed to and Accepted by: Agreed to and Accepted by:

LICENSEE: LICENSOR:

DISH Wireless L.L.C., a Colorado limited
liability company
American Tower Management, LLC, a
Delaware limited liability company
Date: ___________________________ Date: __________________________ This New License is not effective until completed and executed by both Parties. The New License may be rescinded by either Party prior to such date.
171
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 September 5, 2023 September 8, 2023
SDM Approver
5 EXHIBIT A (to New License Site Schedule)
172
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 173
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 6 174
DocuSign Envelope ID: 24CBFFD1-4FBA-4D5A-8701-D0FC37F17167 175
176
177
178
Electronic Record and Signature Disclosure created on: 3/24/2017 2:32:30 PM Parties agreed to: Leslie S. Vartanian, Paralegal, Nathaniel Ritzenthaler, Suet Yam, Suet Yam, Dish Lease Admin 179
180
From: Murray, Emily
To: "Atamian, Adam"; Mitchell, Elizabeth A.

Cc: Lightfoot, Jonathan; Hall, Andy; Cobb, Shawn; [email protected] Subject: American Tower/San Clemente - proposed security measures Date: Thursday, January 4, 2024 11:49:45 AM
Attachments: image001.jpg
expanded metal fencing one.png
expanded metal fencing two.png
expanded metal fencing three.png
[EXTERNAL]
Hi Adam and Elizabeth,
As Bonnie has previously discussed with staff and I discussed with Elizabeth before the holidays, American Tower is willing to voluntarily implement additional measures to address site security concerns resulting from trespassing and vandalization activities at the site. These include the following:

1. Installation of motion sensor flood lights (note that this will require American Tower to separately contract for power to the site for this feature).

2. Installation of video monitoring and associated signage indicating that the site is under video surveillance, see example below (also requires separate power).

3. Replacement of the chain link fence around the equipment area with expanded metal fencing. A few pictures of this type of fencing at other facilities are attached. Expanded metal fencing deters graffiti, prevents climbing, and cannot be easily cut, but still allows a sightline into the enclosure for safety purposes.

4. Fencing of American Tower’s entire +/- one acre parcel, in addition to fencing of the equipment area.

If the City has other suggestions to address security at the site, we are open to considering such proposals. We look forward to discussing further.

Thank you,
Emily
Attachment 8
181
Emily Lane Murray Esq.

Co-Chair, Land Use, Environmental, and Natural Resources Group Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP
865 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2800, Los Angeles, CA 90017-2543 (213) 622-5555 (main)
(213) 955-5584 (direct)
(310) 775-1124 (mobile)
(213) 620-8816 (fax)
[email protected]
Allen Matkins
_____________________________________________________
Confidentiality Notice: The information contained in this electronic e-mail and any accompanying attachment(s) is intended only for the use of the intended recipient and may be confidential and/or privileged. If any reader of this communication is not the intended recipient, unauthorized use, disclosure or copying is strictly prohibited, and may be unlawful.

If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender by return e-mail, and delete the original message and all copies from your system. Thank you. 182
•
NOTICE

THIS AREA IS
UNDER 24

HOUR VIDEO

SURVEILLANCE
•
•
183
184
185
ATTACHMENT 9
The following pages contain Public Comments received for:
ϭ͘ October 17, 2023 City Council Meeting
Ϯ͘ November 8, 2023 Joint Study Session of City Council and Planning Commission
ϯ͘ December 5, 2023 City Council Meeting
ϰ͘ Public Comments received after the December 5, 2023 City Council Meeting
186
ATTACHMENT 9
October 17, 2023 City Council Meeting Public Comments
187
188

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE
Tuesday,October17,2023
City Council
Regular Meeting Minutes
5:00 p.m. - Closed Session
6:00 p.m. - Business Meeting
910 Calle Negocio
2nd Floor
San Clemente, California
www.san-clemente.org
Council Chambers
Mayor Duncan
Mayor Pro T em Knoblock
Councilmember Cabral
Councilmember Enmeier
Councilmember Loeffler
These minutes reflect the order in which items appeared on the meeting agenda and do not necessarily reflect the order in which items were actually considered.

A Regular Meeting of the San Clemente City Council was called to order by Mayor Duncan on October 17, 2023 at 5:00 p.m. in the San Clemente City Council Chambers, located at 91 O Calle Negocio, 2nd Floor, San Clemente.

PRESENT: Cabral, Enmeier, Knoblock, Loeffler and Mayor Duncan STAFF PRESENT: Andy Hall, City Manager; Elizabeth Mitchell, City Attorney; Laura Campagnolo, City Clerk; Megan Jimenez, Deputy City Clerk

CLOSED SESSION
Motion by Mayor Pro Tern Knoblock, second by Councilmember Enmeier, CARRIED 5-0, to recess to Closed Session at 5:00 p.m. to discuss the following:

CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - INITIATION OF LITIGATION Whether to initiate litigation pursuant to Government Code section 54956.9(d)(4) Number of Cases: 1
AYE:

NOE:

Cabral, Enmeier, Knoblock, Loeffler and Mayor Duncan
None
Closed Session concluded at 5:12 p.m.

BUSINESS MEETING
Council reconvened at 6:01 p.m. with all Councilmembers present.

INVOCATION
Reverend Jesse Lund, Pastor, San Clemente Presbyterian Church gave the invocation.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Ken Poczekaj led the Pledge of Allegiance .

- ---- - - -----
189
City Council Regular Meeting Minutes October 17, 2023

8. REGULATING UTILITIES WITHIN OPEN SPACE ZONING DISTRICTS This item was considered earlier in the meeting, please reference page 9 of these minutes for a summary of action.

Community Development Director Atamian narrated a PowerPoint presentation entitled "Regulating Utilities within Open Space Zoning Districts" and responded to Council inquiries. A hard copy of the presentation is on file with the City Clerk.

Amanda Q expressed concerns regarding council comments on the potential development of a battery storage facility.

Motion by Councilmember Cabral, second by Mayor Pro Tern Knoblock, CARRIED 5-0, to receive and file the Administrative Report dated October 17, 2023.

AYE:

NOE:

Cabral, Enmeier, Knoblock, Loeffler and Mayor Duncan
None
C. WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS FACILITY LOCATED AT 616 DEL DIOS This item was considered earlier in the meeting, please reference page 9 of these minutes for a summary of action.

City Planner Lightfoot narrated a PowerPoint presentation entitled "1 0C:

Wireless Communications Facility" and responded to Council inquiries. A hard copy of the presentation is on file with the City Clerk .

Michelle Wilson commented on the impacts of the American Cell Tower on property values; spoke in opposition to the placement of equipment on the tower.

David Armstrong. San Clemente, expressed concerns regarding the timing of the approval and the lack of transparency regarding the environmental impacts; spoke in opposition.

Vonnie Barnes, San Clemente, narrated a PowerPoint presentation concerning the American Cell Tower. A hard copy of the presentation is on file with the City Clerk.

Amanda Q continued the narration of the PowerPoint presentation concerning the American Cell Tower. A hard copy of the presentation is on file with the City Clerk.

Kortney Morrow, San Clemente, spoke in opposition to the American Cell Tower and any placement of equipment at the site.

Andrew Morrow, San Clemente, spoke in opposition to the American Cell Tower and any placement of equipment at the site.

190
City Council Regular Meeting Minutes October 17, 2023
Cindy Bothwell opined that the City should consider potential impacts of the American Cell Tower to residents.

Lindie O'Toole, San Clemente, spoke in opposition to the American Cell Tower and any placement of equipment at the site.

Mike Blackwell, San Clemente, opined on the American Cell Tower; spoke in opposition to the project.

Kristy Neuhausen , spoke in opposition to the American Cell Tower and any placement of equipment at the site.

Motion by Mayor Pro Tern Knoblock, second by Councilmember Loeffler, CARRIED 5-0, to receive and file the Administrative Report dated October 17, 2023.

AYE: Cabral, Enmeier, Knoblock, Loeffler and Mayor Duncan NOE: None

11. Oral Communications (Part 2)
Tony Rubolino commented on Mayor Duncan's social media posts.

12. Future Agenda Items
Public Safety Data Analysis
Mayor Duncan , with the support of Councilmember Enmeier and Councilmember Loeffler, directed the City Manager to research and evaluate the need for a 3rd party to evaluate public safety and homelessness data collected by the City's outreach workers, private security, and the Orange County Sheriffs Department to better implement the park ranger program and address resident concerns and the "hot spots" in the City.

13. Reports
A. Commissions and Committees
(1) INTERVIEWS AND APPOINTMENT OF BEACHES, PARKS AND

RECREATION COMMISSION, COASTAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND ARTS

AND CULTURE COMMITTEE MEMBERS
Council set October 30, 2023 at 6:00 p.m. as the date for Commission and Committee interviews and appointments.

B. Council Subcommittee Updates
Homeless Subcommittee
Councilmember Enmeier reported that the Homeless Subcommittee visited

191
City Council Regular Meeting Minutes October 17, 2023
Jamboree House.

C. Council Members
Carnival Colossal
Parks
Councilmember Loeffler reported on the success of the Friends of the Beaches, and Recreation Carnival Colossal and thanked staff for their efforts.

D. City Attorney
Birthday Recognition
City Attorney Mitchell wished Councilmember Cabral a belated Happy Birthday and City Manager Hall an early Happy Birthday.

E. City Manager
None.

14. Adjournment

CARRIED
Motion by Mayor Pro Tern Knoblock, second by Councilmember Enmeier, November
5-0, to adjourn at 9:43 p.m. The next Regular Meeting will be held on will
7, 2023. Closed Session will begin at 5:00 p.m.The Business Meeting Chambers,
commence at 6:00 p.m. The meeting will take place at City Hall Council located at 910 Calle Negocio, 2nd Floor, San Clemente .

AYE: Cabral, Enmeier, Knoblock, Loeffler and Mayor Duncan NOE: None
of
San Clemente, California
Page15of15
ATTACHMENT 9
November 8, 2023 Joint Study Session of City Council and Planning Commission Public Comments
192

MINUTES OF THE

JOINT STUDY SESSION

OF THE CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE

CITY COUNCIL AND PLANNING COMMISSION
November 8, 2023 @ 6:30 p.m.

San Clemente City Hall Council Chambers
910 Calle Negocio, San Clemente, CA 92673
Teleconference via www.san-clemente.org/live

CALL TO ORDER
&KDLU &RVJURYH FDOOHG WKH -RLQW 6WXG\ 6HVVLRQ RI WKH &LW\ &RXQFLO DQG 3ODQQLQJ &RPPLVVLRQRIWKH&LW\RI6DQ&OHPHQWH WRRUGHUDW
 SP7KHPHHWLQJZDVRIIHUHGLQ
SHUVRQDW7KH&LW\RI6DQ&OHPHQWH &LW\+DOO&RXQFLO&KDPEHUV &DOOH1HJRFLR6DQ
&OHPHQWH &DOLIRUQLDDQGDOVR YLDOLYHVWUHDP IURPWKH&LW\¶V<RX7XEH&KDQQHO RECESS
&KDLU&RVJURYH FDOOHGDUHFHVVDW
SPDQGUHFRQYHQHGDW
SP

ROLL CALL
&RPPLVVLRQHUV3UHVHQW
%DUWRQ&UDQGHOO
%UHQW'DYLV
6FRWW0F.KDQQ
.DUHQ3UHVFRWW
/RHIIOHU
&KDLU3UR7HP*DU\30F&DXJKDQ0'9LFH&KDLU
0 6WHYHQ&DPS
&KDLU&DPHURQ&RVJURYH
&RXQFLOPHPEHUV3UHVHQW
0DUN(QPHLHU0D\RU3UR7HP6WHYH.QREORFNDQG5LFN
/RHIIOHU
6WDII3UHVHQW
$QG\+DOO&LW\0DQDJHU
$GDP$WDPLDQ&RPPXQLW\'HYHORSPHQW'LUHFWRU
-RQDWKDQ/LJKWIRRW&LW\3ODQQHU
*HQD%XUQV'HSXW\&LW\$WWRUQH\
7DPDUD7DWLFK5HFRUGLQJ6HFUHWDU\
AGENDA
$ 2YHUYLHZRISHUPLWWLQJSURFHGXUHVIRUZLUHOHVVFRPPXQLFDWLRQVIDFLOLWLHVLQFOXGLQJ D FDVH VWXG\RIDQ H[LVWLQJWRZHUIDFLOLW\ ORFDWHG DW'HO 'LRV LQ5DQFKR6DQ &OHPHQWH
&LW\ 3ODQQHU /LJKWIRRW SUHVHQWHG D 3RZHU3RLQW RXWOLQLQJ H[LVWLQJ ZLUHOHVV FRPPXQLFDWLRQVIDFLOLWLHV
OHJDOIUDPHZRUNRQSHUPLWWLQJ
&LW\=RQLQJ UHJXODWLRQV

DQGWKH&DVH6WXG\DW'HO'LRV +HH[SODLQHGWKHPHDQLQJRIFRORFDWLRQ DRAFTP7
DPEHUV
DPEH
&LW\¶V<RX7XE &LW\¶V<
DQGUHFRQYHQHGDW
GUHFRQYH
&UDQGHOO &UDQ
%UHQW'DYLV
IOHU
&KDLU3UR7HP* IOHU
&KDLU3UR7
 6WHYHQ&DPS
&KDL  6WHYHQ&DPS
&KD
QW
0DUN(QPHLHU0D 0DUN(QP
/RHIIOHU /RHIIOH
$QG\+DOO
$GDP$
-RQD
1 $JHQGD,WHP
%


193
-I '11
I I_
Joint Planning Commission – City Council Study Session Minutes – November 8, 2023 Page 2 (PLO\0XUUD\DWWRUQH\IURPWKHODZRIILFHVRI $OOHQ0DWNLQVFRXQVHO IRU$PHULFDQ 7RZHULQWURGXFHGKHUVHOIDQGWKDQNHGWKH&RPPLVVLRQ DQG&RXQFLO IRUWKHLUWLPH 0LNH%ODFNZHOOUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQUHJDUGLQJWKHVWDELOLW\RIWKHWRZHUDQG VXJJHVWHGQRWEXLOGLQJRQDQLQYDOLGXVHRIDQDEDQGRQHGWRZHU 9RQQLH%DUQHV 5DQFKR6DQ &OHPHQWH &RPPXQLW\$VVRFLDWLRQ %RDUG3UHVLGHQW VWDWHG$PHULFDQ7RZHUVKRXOGEHSHQDOL]HGIRUYLRODWLQJWKHXVHSHUPLWIRU\HDUV 6KH H[SUHVVHG FRQFHUQ UHJDUGLQJWKH ULVN RIILUHV DQG SUHVHQWHGVOLGHV VKRZLQJ UHFHQWQHDUE\ILUHV
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
'ROO\(ULFNVRQ UHVLGHQW H[SUHVVHG FRQFHUQ ZLWKWKH SURSHUW\ EHLQJ DQ H\HVRUH FLWHG QXLVDQFH DQG OLDELOLW\ FRQFHUQV DQG UHTXHVWHG WKH IDFLOLW\ EH ORFDWHG HOVHZKHUH
7LQD-RKQVRQUHVLGHQW H[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQUHJDUGLQJSHRSOHFOLPELQJWKHWRZHUDQG WKHLPSDFWRQKRPHYDOXHV
)UD]HU0RUDQ GLVFXVVHGDUHFHQWILUHLQWKHDUHDDQGVWDWHGSODFLQJWKHWRZHULQWKH VHYHUHILUHGDQJHUDUHDZDVQHJOLJHQW
6KDZQ1HOVRQUHVLGHQWUHTXHVWHGWKHWRZHUEHUHORFDWHG %HQ6WHYHQVUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQDERXWQRLVHGDQJHUVRISHRSOHFOLPELQJ RQWKHWRZHUDQGHPLVVLRQRIUDGLDWLRQ
&KULVWLH%XQG\UHVLGHQWVWDWHGWKHWRZHUZDVXQVDIHDQGDQXLVDQFH 6X]DQD&RUWLQL+DUERU9LHZUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQZLWKWKHLQVWDOODWLRQRID ZLUHOHVV FHOO SKRQH WRZHU LQ D UHVLGHQWLDO FRPPXQLW\ 6KH GLVFXVVHG PHGLFDO HYLGHQFH RI KDUPIXO HIIHFWV RI UDGLDWLRQ DQG SURYLGHG D FRPSUHKHQVLYH VFLHQWLILF UHSRUW
DRAFTKHV
RIWKH&RQGLWL
GHTXDWH+HTXHVW GHTXDWH+H
RQV\VWHP RQV\
YLVLWHG WKH VLWH DQG VLWHG WKH
\+HUHTXHVWHG&LW\ \+HUHTXHV
GLVFXVVHG OLDELOLW\ RI VVHG OLDELOLW\ RI
QW H[SUHVVHG FRQFH QW H[SUHVVHG FRQF
G OLDELOLW\ DELOLW\ FRQFHUQV
QUHVLGHQW UH H[SUHVVH [SUHVVH
KRPHYDOXHV
VVHG
1942
Joint Planning Commission – City Council Study Session Minutes – November 8, 2023 Page 3 $QQ&DUSHQWHU+DUERU5LGJHUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQ DERXWWKHVDIHW\RIWKH WRZHUDQGXUJHGLWVUHORFDWLRQ
3HWH%UDG\UHVLGHQWFRQFXUUHGZLWKWKHIRUPHUVSHDNHUVHVSHFLDOO\0V &RUWLQL 'DYLG6FKLFNUHVLGHQWXUJHGUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHSURMHFWDQGH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQ DERXWOLDELOLW\SURSHUW\YDOXHLPSDFWVDQGKHDOWKULVNV 5XWK6SDHWKHUHVLGHQWSUHVHQWHGDSHWLWLRQRSSRVLQJWKHFHOOWRZHU -RQ6DYDV5DQFKR6DQ&OHPHQWHUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQDERXWWKHODFNRI QRWLILFDWLRQDQGODFNRIUHFRUGVRISHUPLWWLQJDQGGHYHORSPHQW /LQGVH\6SDHWKH UHVLGHQW GLVFXVVHGWKH HOHFWHGRIILFLDOV¶ REOLJDWLRQWRZDUGVWKH UHVLGHQWV¶ KHDOWK VDIHW\ DQG ZHOOEHLQJ +H XUJHG WKH &RPPLVVLRQ WR SXW WKH SURFHVVRQKROGWRHYDOXDWHFRPSOLDQFHDQGDOORZIRUDGGLWLRQDOSXEOLFLQSXW .RUQH\0RUURZUHVLGHQWGLVFXVVHGKHU
UHTXHVWWRWKH&RXQFLOWRUHPRYHWKH
WRZHU DQG VWDWHG WKH &LW\ KDG LQGLFDWHG LW ZDV QHYHU DQ DSSURYHG FHOO VLWH 6KH GLVFXVVHGWKHQXLVDQFHFUHDWHGE\WKHWRZHUDQGH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQZLWKWKHODFN RIHYLGHQFHRISURSHUSHUPLWWLQJ
1RUPDQ 0DF/HRG 'LVK :LUHOHVV 5HSUHVHQWDWLYH GLVFXVVHG WKH JRDO IRU FROODERUDWLRQ DQGLQYLWHGVWDIIWRUHDFKRXWWRKLPZLWKTXHVWLRQVRUFRQFHUQV /\QGLH2¶7RROHUHVLGHQWSUHVHQWHGLPDJHVRIZRUNWUXFNVDQGFRQVWUXFWLRQULJVLQ WKHDUHD6KHH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQDERXWKHDOWKULVNV DQGUHTXHVWHGWKH&RPPLVVLRQ IROORZWKH&LW\¶VPLVVLRQDQGFRUHYDOXHV
$PDQGD4XLQWDQLOODUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQZLWK&LW\VWDIIQRWGRLQJLWVGXH GLOLJHQFHDQGQRWEHLQJSURDFWLYHLQDOORZLQJSXEOLFLQSXW6KHGLVFXVVHGWKHQHHG IRUWUDQVSDUHQF\
0DUWLQ 'DFK UHVLGHQW VWDWHG KH KDG QRW EHHQ QRWLILHG E\ WKH &LW\ DERXW WKH LQVWDOODWLRQRI*+HXUJHGWKH&RPPLVVLRQWRILJKWIRUWKHUHVLGHQWV $QGUHZ0RURZ+DUERU9LHZUHVLGHQWH[SUHVVHGFRQFHUQZLWKKHDOWKLPSDFWV DQG KRPH YDOXHV +H XUJHG FRPSOHWLRQ RI GXH GLOLJHQFH LQFOXGLQJ UHYLHZ E\WKH)LUH 'HSDUWPHQW
(PHU\ <HFSRW UHVLGHQW H[SUHVVHG FRQFHUQ DERXW WKH LPSDFWV RI UDGLDWLRQ DQG VDIHW\RISHRSOHFOLPELQJWKHWRZHU
&KDLU&RVJURYHWKDQNHGWKHVSHDNHUVIRUVKDULQJWKHLUFRPPHQWV

DRAFTRIILFLDOV RIILF
UJHG WKH &RP UJHG WK
DOORZIRUDGGLWLRQDOS DOORZIRUDGGLW

UHTXHVWWRWKH&
WHG LW ZDV QHYHU DQ LW ZDV Q
WKHWRZHUDQGH[SUHV WKHWRZHUDQG
:LUHOHVV 5HSUHVHQ
VWDIIWRUHDFKRXW VWDIIWRUHDFKRX WRK
LGHQWSUHVHQWHGLPDJ QWSUHVHQWHGLPDJ
SUHVVHGFRQFHUQDERX SUHVVHGFRQFH
VPLVVLRQDQGFRUHY VPLVVLRQDQGFRUH
DQLOODUHVLGHQW
EHLQJSUR
1953
....-...
l''illl
"-...,., .. ....--a~··
...-.-..."-.
~ '""""
Joint Planning Commission – City Council Study Session Minutes – November 8, 2023 Page 4 &LW\0DQDJHU+DOOVWDWHGVWDIIKDGUHTXHVWHGWKHODQGORUGDQGDSSOLFDQWWROOWKHVKRW FORFNWRDOORZ WKHFRQFHUQVWREHDGGUHVVHG
7KH &RXQFLOPHPEHUV DQG &RPPLVVLRQHUV SURFHHGHG WR DVN D IHZ FODULI\LQJ TXHVWLRQV RI VWDII DQGWKH UHSUHVHQWDWLYHV RIWKH SURSHUW\ RZQHUVKLS DQG RI 'LVK :LUHOHVV
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
RIWKH6SHFWUXP$FW
,QUHVSRQVHWR&RXQFLODQG&RPPLVVLRQTXHVWLRQV&LW\3ODQQHU/LJKWIRRWQRWHGWKDW DSULRUFROORFDWLRQZDVGHQLHGGXHWRDQXQSHUPLWWHGLQFUHDVHLQKHLJKWDERYHWKH ¶KHLJKWLGHQWLILHGLQWKH&83
DSHUPLWZDVLVVXHGLQ WRUHGXFHWKHWRZHU
KHLJKW EDFNWR ¶ +H GLVFXVVHG WKH LQVSHFWLRQ SURFHVV E\ 2UDQJH &RXQW\ )LUH $XWKRULW\
2&)$

 RULJLQDO DSSURYDO E\ WKH &RXQW\ RI 2UDQJH DQG ODFN RI GRFXPHQWDWLRQ UHODWHGWREXLOGLQJSHUPLWVRYHUWKHSULRU\HDUV DQGQRWHGWKDW
SODQVVXEPLWWHGIRUWKH'LVKFROORFDWLRQLQGLFDWHGDQWHQQDHRQWKHODWWLFHWRZHU ,Q UHVSRQVH WR &RXQFLO DQG &RPPLVVLRQ LQTXLULHV 'HSXW\ &LW\ $WWRUQH\ %XUQV LQGLFDWHGWKH\KDGQRWIRXQGJURXQGVWRGHQ\WKHDSSOLFDWLRQ DQGWKDWWKH&LW\KDG JLYHQWKHRSSRUWXQLW\IRUWKHWRZHUWRFRPHLQWRFRPSOLDQFHZLWKWKHSHUPLW ,Q UHVSRQVH WR &RXQFLO DQG &RPPLVVLRQ TXHVWLRQV &RPPXQLW\ 'HYHORSPHQW 'LUHFWRU $WDPLDQ GLVFXVVHGWKHFXUUHQWFRQVWUXFWLRQDFWLYLWLHVZKLFKGLGQRWUHTXLUH SHUPLWV +H VWDWHG WKH 6KHULII¶V 'HSDUWPHQW FRXOG DVVLVW ZLWK WUHVSDVVLQJ RQ HDVHPHQWV+HVWDWHGVWDIIFRXOGPRQLWRUWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQDFWLYLW\FRQFHUQV'HSXW\ &LW\$WWRUQH\%XUQVLQGLFDWHGVKHZRXOGLQYHVWLJDWH WKHOLDELOLW\RIQXLVDQFHFOLPELQJ RQWKHWRZHU
&RXQFLOPHPEHU/RHIIOHUXUJHGWKHDSSOLFDQWWRGHWHUPLQHWKHTXHVWLRQRIFRQWLQXRXV XVHRIWKHWRZHU
&RXQFLOPHPEHU (QPHLHU HQFRXUDJHG VWDII WR SURDFWLYHO\ QRWLFH WKH UHVLGHQWV RQ VXFKLVVXHV
DRAFTKHZRXOG KHZ
KHGHVLUHWRXW KHGHVLUH
ERUDWLYHO\WRGHWHUP ERUDWLYHO\WRG
HRQWKHDSSOLFDWLRQWR HRQWKHDSSOLFDWLRQ
LVVXHV 0U 0DF/HRG
UHLWHUDWHGWKH WHUDWHGWK GD\
PPLVVLRQTXHVWLRQV VLRQTXHVWLRQV
LHGGXHWRDQXQSHUP HGGXHWRDQXQSHUP
H&83
DSHUPLWZDV H&83
DSHUP
H GLVFXVVHG WKH LQVS
RULJLQDO DSSURYDO E JLQDO DSSURYDO E
HODWHGWREXLOGLQJSHU HODWHGWREXLOG
GIRUWKH'LVKFROORFD
R &RXQFLO DQG R &RXQFLO DQG
GQRWIRXQG GQRWIRXQ
\IRU
1964
....-... ' "" --- ,,. ' ~ . . "-...,., .. ....--a~··
...-.-..."-.

I'~,.
"" "-.I .
...

Joint Planning Commission – City Council Study Session Minutes – November 8, 2023 Page 5 &KDLU &RVJURYH VXJJHVWHG WKH 3ODQQLQJ &RPPLVVLRQ UHYLHZ VRPH RI WKH &LW\¶V SURFHVVHV
&LW\ 3ODQQHU /LJKWIRRW FODULILHG WKDW VWDQGDUGV SHUWDLQLQJ WR WKH &LW\¶V VPDOO FHOO RUGLQDQFH GR QRW DSSO\ LQ WKLV FDVH LQFOXGLQJ WKH IRRW UDGLXV IRU UHVLGHQWLDO

SURSHUWLHV
7KH &RPPLVVLRQHUV DQG &RXQFLOPHPEHUV H[SUHVVHG DSSUHFLDWLRQ WR WKH

SDUWLFLSDQWV
LQGLFDWHGWKHQHHGIRUERWKWKHDSSOLFDQWDQGWKH&LW\WRFRPSO\ZLWK )HGHUDOODZV
DQGVXJJHVWHGUHGXFLQJWKHVL]HRIWKHWRZHU

ADJOURNMENT
7+(5( %(,1* 12 27+(5 %86,1(66 %()25( 7+( &200,66,21 ,7:$6 029(' %< &+$,5 &26*529( 6(&21'(' %< &+$,5 352 7(0 0&&$8*+$1 $1'81$1,0286/<$33529('72$'-2851 7+(0((7,1* $7
 30 727+(678'<6(66,212)7+(3/$11,1*&200,66,2172 %( +(/' ,13(5621 21 '(&(0%(5   $7 
 30 $7 7+( 6$1
&/(0(17( &,7< +$// &281&,/ &+$0%(56 /2&$7(' $7
 &$//(
1(*2&,26$1&/(0(17(&$
$1'7(/(&21)(5(1&($9$,/$%/(
727+(38%/,&9,$/,9(675($0)5207+(&,7<¶6<2878%(&+$11(/ 5HVSHFWIXOO\VXEPLWWHG
&DPHURQ&RVJURYH&KDLU
$WWHVW

-RQDWKDQ/LJKWIRRW&LW\3ODQQHU
DRAFT( 7+( & ( 7+
1'(' %< 1'('
29('72$'-285 29('72$'
2)7+( 2)7 3/$11,1*
5   $7 5   

&+$0%(56 /2&$ +$0%(5

$1'7(/(&2 $1'
($0)5207+(&,7 $0)5207+(&
D
&KDLU
1975
1 Atamian, Adam
From: Maria Swart
Sent: Tuesday, November 7, 2023 1:15 PM
To: [email protected]; Planning Mail
Subject: Harbor View Estates - November 8th City Council - Cell Tower comments Attachments: Notice of Cell Tower Meetings.pdf
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
Hello!
I am a Rancho San Clemente original resident. When we moved in 27 years ago we were informed of the abandoned tower site. We were told that the tower would eventually be torn down by the home builders.

I am against the installation of the antenna at 616 Del Dios tower location. Please approve the installation of the antenna at an alternate city owned site that is not in a very high fire hazard zone area and is at least 500 feet from a residential area.
The cell tower location would require a backͲup generator with fuel which would be negligent to place in a fire hazard area.
Thank you for prioritizing the quality of life and safety of the residents of Rancho San Clemente.

Sincerely,
Maria Swart
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:

From: Morgan Bomboy
Date: October 31, 2023 at 2:12:15 PM PDT
To: Christopher Swart
Subject: URGENT Harbor View Estates MeetingsͲNovember 4th and November 8th for ALL residents
ReplyͲTo: Morgan Bomboy <[email protected]>

Dear HomeownersͲplease find the document attached.

If you are aware of any neighbors not on the HOA distribution list, please ask them to email me to get them added. We also urge everyone to utilize the HOA website for important announcements as well. The HOA website is
http://myhoa.com/harborviewestates/
198
2 
Morgan Bomboy, CCAM
Senior Certified Community Association Manager
1525 East 17th Street, Suite A
Santa Ana, CA 92705
714Ͳ557Ͳ5900 x 112 * Fax: 714Ͳ619Ͳ6738
“Management Through Involvement”
IMPORTANT NOTICE: The information contained in this electronic message and/or its attachments is intended for the named recipient(s) only. The electronic message and/or its attachments may contain confidential, nonͲpublic or privileged information disclosure of which is restricted by applicable law, including the federal securities laws.If you are not an intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient(s), do not copy, distribute or rely on the information contained herein.If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately by reply and immediately delete this message and any attachments.Unless otherwise noted, any views expressed in this message and/or its attachments are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Tritz Professional Management Services or its staff.



199
1 Atamian, Adam
From: Fuentes, Candy
Sent: Thursday, November 9, 2023 8:08 AM
To: Tatich, Tamara
Subject: FW: November 8th Joint Meeting RE Telecom Permitting and Tower at 616 Del Dios _________________________________________________________ Candy Fuentes
Office Specialist I, City Clerk
City of San Clemente
910 Calle Negocio | San Clemente, CA 92673
(949) 361-8200 | [email protected]
From: Mike Blackwell 
Sent: Wednesday, November 8, 2023 8:31 PM
To: CityClerk Mail <CityClerk@sanͲclemente.org>; Atamian, Adam <AtamianA@sanͲclemente.org>; Lightfoot, Jonathan <LightfootJ@sanͲclemente.org>; M. Steven Camp <CampM@sanͲclemente.org>; Cameron Cosgrove <CosgroveC@sanͲ clemente.org>; Crandell, Barton <crandellb@sanͲclemente.org>; Davis, Brent <DavisB@sanͲclemente.org>; McCaughan, Gary <McCaughanG@sanͲclemente.org>; Scott McKhann <McKhannS@sanͲclemente.org>; Karen PrescottͲLoeffler <PrescottLoefflerK@sanͲclemente.org>; Loeffler, Rick <LoefflerR@sanͲclemente.org>; Knoblock, Steve <KnoblockS@sanͲclemente.org>; Enmeier, Mark <EnmeierM@sanͲclemente.org>; Duncan, Chris <DuncanC@sanͲ clemente.org>; Cabral, Victor <CabralV@sanͲclemente.org> Subject: November 8th Joint Meeting RE Telecom Permitting and Tower at 616 Del Dios Hello all.

As per this evenings joint meeting and commitments made by both the property owner and wireless telecom applicant, I am happy to offer my time to confer with any of you individually. Further, I am happy to meet with staff again before tomorrows scheduled meeting with the property owner and applicant to offer support based on my knowledge of this project as well as nearly three decades of experience in this area of land use and now as a subject matter expert.

By 9am tomorrow, I will be sending a brief summary of salient points as well as possible next steps that could benefit all parties.
Again, please call or email me directly as you wish.
Please do not “Respond to All”.Direct and individual communique with me is welcomed should there be any questions or comments.

Thank you,
Mike Blackwell
200
+





!





<A9B@<G6;GF4<?4J 6B@

6A05299

'@.6
%



.BHG;
#H7FBA

I8AH8
.H<G8

+4F478A4

4?<9BEA<4


)

 

$AH7?47D


A@AD34>7
#3KAD
#3KAD
&DA
*7?
AG@5;>?7?47DE
3@6
A??;EE;A@7DE A@3F:3@
";9:F8AAF
;FK
&>3@@7D
;FK
A8
)3@
>7?7@F7



3>>7
$79A5;A
)G;F7

)3@
>7?7@F7




&






G@53@E3@5>7?7@F7AD9

!@A4>A5=)E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



34D3>,E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



@?7;7D#E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



"A788>7D(E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



AE9DAH7E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



3?B?E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



#53G9:3@
E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



#5!:3@@)E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



&D7E5AFF"A788>7DE3@5>7?7@F7AD9



D3@67>>E3@5>7?7@F7AD9



3H;EE3@5>7?7@F7AD9



>;9:F8AAF<E3@5>7?7@F7AD9




%

.?/<?
)62D
@A.A2@

<:2<D;2?@
@@<06.A6<;K@
<::2;A@

%24.?16;4

A2:

 <;
A52
!<C2:/2?


6AF
<B;069
.;1

#9.;;6;4
<::6@@6<;

<6;A
&AB1F
&2@@6<;
42;1.
.;1
<;
A52
6AF

<3
&.;
92:2;A2K@


29
6<@
*6?292@@
<::B;60.A6<;@
.0696AF

A@AD34>7
#3KAD
#3KAD
&DA
*7?
AG@5;>?7?47DE
3@6
A??;EE;A@7DE
%@
47:3>8
A8
F:7

3D4AD
,;7I
EF3F7E

A?7AI@7DE
EEA5;3F;A@
R
.?/<?
)62D

"S
F:;E
A88;57
;E
EG4?;FF;@9
F:7E7
5A??7@FE
3:736
A8
F:7
$AH7?47D




A;@F
)FG6K
)7EE;A@
A8
F:7
;FK
AG@5;>
3@6
&>3@@;@9
A??;EE;A@
8AD
F:7
;FK
A8
)3@
>7?7@F7UE
R6AFS


7>
;AE
-;D7>7EE
A??G@;53F;A@

35;>;FK
&DA<75F

201
•

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









R#?<720AS
3@6
97@63
F7?


D7
R%H7DH;7I
A8
B7D?;FF;@9
BDA576GD7E
8AD
I;D7>7EE

5A??G@;53F;A@E
835;>;F;7E
;@5>G6;@9
3
53E7
EFG6K
A8
3@
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
835;>;FK
>A53F76
3F


7>
;AE
;@
(3@5:A
)3@
>7?7@F7S

*:7
&DA<75F
BDABAE76
3@6
BGDEG76
4K
?7D;53@
*AI7D
#3@397?7@F
""
R==960.;AS
;@HA>H7E
FIA
4G;>6;@9
B7D?;FEQA@7
FA
675D73E7
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
8DA?


877F
FA


877F
B7D?;F




3@6
3@AF:7D
FA
5A>>A53F7

I;D7>7EE
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
A@
F:7
FAI7D

$$
%5FA47D




97@63
(7BADF
B



E56/6A

*:7
B7D?;F
FA
675D73E7
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
I3E
;EEG76
A@
G9GEF





I:;>7
F:7
B7D?;F
FA
5A>>A53F7
@7I
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
;E
5GDD7@F>K
G@67D
D7H;7I
3E
B7D?;F






!(#


*:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
A@
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
;@5>G67E
F:D77
B3@7>
3@F7@@3E
F:D77
E75FAD
?AG@FE
E;J
D7?AF7
D36;A
G@;FE
%%(@
F:D77
435=FA435=
?AG@FE
A@7
AH7DHA>F397
BDAF75FAD
")#
3@6
A@7
:K4D;6
534>7
#
B

&7D?;F






@757EE;F3F7E
3
R-;D7>7EE
A??G@;53F;A@E

35;>;F;7ES
3BB>;53F;A@
E5D77@;@9

8AD?
BB>;53F;A@
$A
-#)




I:;5:
I3E
EG4?;FF76
4K
*AI7D
@9;@77DE

&DA87EE;A@3>E
A@
47:3>8
A8
;E:
-;D7>7EE
""
R6@5S
3@6
3BBDAH76
4K
F:7
&>3@@;@9
;H;E;A@
A@
AD
34AGF
)7BF7?47D



8AD
3
;E:
5A>>A53F;A@
A8
F:D77
@7I

;E:
B3@7>
3@F7@@3E
FA
47
388;J76
FA
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
!(#

&GDEG3@F
FA
)75F;A@

3
A8
F:7
#;66>7>3EE
*3J
(7>;78
3@6
A4
D73F;A@
5F
A8


+)
M


R&=20A?B:
0AS
8AD
835;>;F;7E
AGFE;67
A8
F:7
BG4>;5
D;9:FA8 I3K
F:7
-

3BB>;53F;A@
?GEF
47
EG4?;FF76
BD;AD
FA
3
4G;>6;@9
B7D?;F
3BB>;53F;A@
FA
7H3>G3F7
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
E
3
B3DF
A8
F:;E
BDA57EE
BB>;53@F
3>EA
EG4?;FF76
3
(36;A

D7CG7@5K
%
A?B>;3@57
@3>KE;E
F:3F
366D7EE76
F:7
A55GB3F;A@3>
3@6
BG4>;5
7JBAEGD7
>7H7>E
A8
D36;A
8D7CG7@5K
E;9@3>E
3@6
7@EGD7E
F:3F
EG5:
E;9@3>E
AB7D3F7
I;F:;@
7EF34>;E:76
D79G>3FADK
EF3@63D6E
55AD6;@9
FA
F:3F
3@3>KE;E
F:7
(
3@6
BAI7D

>7H7>E
3D7
@AF
3@F;5;B3F76
FA
7J5776
F:7

767D3>
A??G@;53F;A@E
A??;EE;A@UE

RS
7EF34>;E:76
?3J;?G?
&7D?;EE;4>7
JBAEGD7
"7H7>E
 #
8AD
F:7
7@7D3>

&G4>;5
AD
%55GB3F;A@3>
7@H;DA@?7@FE
!(#





/;8
5H<?7<A:
C8E@<G
G;4G
BE<:<A4??L
4HG;BE<M87
G;8
<AFG4??4G<BA
B9
G;8
J<E8?8FF
8DH<C@8AG
C8E@<G




J4F
9<A4?<M87
BA

H:HFG







)BG8
G;4G
G;<F
C8E@<G
;4F
ABG
588A
9<A4?<M87
4F
JBE>
GB
6B@C?8G8
G;8
+EB=86G
E8@4<AF
HA78EJ4L
*6GB58E





:8A74
-8CBEG
C






"<I8A
G;4G
G;8
9<EFG
5H<?7<A:
C8E@<G
;4F
4?E847L
588A
<FFH87
G;<F
6B@@8AG
?8GG8ESF
E898E8A68F
GB
P+EB=86GQ
4CC?L
CE<@4E<?L
GB
G;8
CBEG<BA
B9
G;8
+EB=86G
HA78E
E8I<8J
202

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









55AD6;@9
FA
F:7
%5FA47D




97@63
(7BADF
3@6
&DA<75F
B>3@E
F:7
;FK
3@6

BB>;53@F
5A@F7@6
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
CG3>;8;7E
3E
3@
7>;9;4>7
835;>;FK
8AD
EFD73?>;@76
?;@;EF7D;3>
D7H;7I
BGDEG3@F
FA
)75F;A@


A8
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
$$


(

M





+)
M


*:;E
5A@F7@F;A@
D7EFE
A@
E7H7D3>
5D;F7D;3
@3?7>K
F:3F
F:7
835;>;FK
;E
3@
7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
835;>;FK
3@6
F:3F
F:7
BDABAE76
?A6;8;53F;A@
 
6A7E
@AF

BDABAE7
3
:7;9:F
;@5D73E7
A8
?AD7
F:3@

B7D57@F
AD

877F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
:7;9:F



6A7E
@AF
BDABAE7
?AD7
F:3@
8AGD
@7I
7CG;B?7@F
534;@7FE
 
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
BD;AD

5A@6;F;A@E
A8
3BBDAH3>
3@6

6A7E
@AF
67873F
5A@573>?7@F
7>7?7@FE
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
835;>;FK

/7F
I:3F
F:7
;FK
3@6
BB>;53@F
?;EE
;E
F:7
G@6;EBGF76
835F
F:3F
F:7D7
;E
@A
$7(23(-&
6(1$+$22
% "(+(38
*:7
&DA<75F
;E
>A53F76
3F


7>
;AE
;@
(3@5:A
)3@
>7?7@F7
&$





=@AI@
3>EA
3E
);F7
$A


R&6A2S
*:7
);F7
:3E
477@
BD7H;AGE>K

9D3@F76
3
>;?;F76
A@6;F;A@3>
+E7
&7D?;F
(#
+&
$A



;@



4K

%D3@97
AG@FK
R<B;AFS
FA
F:7
?7D;53@
*7>7B:A@7
3@6
*7>79D3B:
A?B3@K
''
8AD
3@
7EF34>;E:?7@F
A8
3
R,("1.6 5$
1$+ 8
23 3(.-
(-
".--$"3(.-
6(3'
/4!+("
3$+$/'.-$
2$15("$
(-
3'$
+
$-$1 +
&1("4+341 +

(231("3;
E56/6A

1


+&2

AI7H7D
3E

E:AI@
;@
F:7
39D77?7@F
E;9@76
4K
F:7
;FK
3@6
F:7
BB>;53@F
:7D7
@7;F:7D
F:7
;FK
@AD
F:7
?7D;53@
*7>7B:A@7
3@6
*7>79D3B:
A?B3@K
FA
I:A?
F:7


+&
I3E

9D3@F76
3@6
@AD
F:7
BB>;53@F
:7D7
:3E
3@K
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
E:AI;@9
F:3F
F:7
BD7H;AGE>K
3BBDAH76
?;5DAI3H7
D7>3K
EF3F;A@
8AD
GE7
4K
F:7
?7D;53@
F7>7B:A@7
3@6
*7>79D3B:
A?B3@K
:3E
;@6776
477@
5A@F;@GAGE>K
GE76
E;@57


3@6
;E
3@
$7(23(-&

6(1$+$22
% "(+(38

&7D
F:7
,A>G@F3DK
9D77?7@F
E;9@76
47FI77@
F:7
;FK
3@6
F:7
BB>;53@F
;@
G@7
A8


F:7D7
;E
@A
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
34AGF
F:7
GE7
A8
F:7
FAI7D
;@5>G6;@9
;FE
:7;9:F
;@5D73E7
8DA?
F:7
3BBDAH76
:7;9:F
A8

877F
G@67D
F:7



+&

FA
F:7
7JF7@676
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
FAI7D
@AI363KE
47;@9


877F
E56/6A

1 G@7

,A>G@F3DK
A?B>;3@57
9D77?7@F2

AI7H7D
F:7
EF3F7?7@FE
;@
F:7
,A>G@F3DK
A?B>;3@57
9D77?7@F
3E
FA
F:7
$7(23(-&
".-3(-4.42
6(1$+$22
% "(+(38
3D7
47>;76
4K
F:7
;@CG;DK
A8
F:7
BB>;53@F
:7D7
FA
F:7
%D3@97
AG@FK
;@

FA
;@CG;D7
34AGF
F:7
EFDG5FGD7
8AD
K73DE

?
3
BDA<75F
67E;9@
7@9;@77D
IAD=;@9
I;F:
)

-;D7>7EE
""
3@6
?

FDK;@9
FA
97F
F:7
RFDG7S
366D7EE
FA
3
57>>
FAI7D
5A?BAG@6
>A53F76
A@
3
:;>>
F:7
366D7EE

:3H7
;E

#
$
A8
)3@
>7?7@F7
*:;E
;E
@AF
3
D73>
366D7EE

3@6
)

I;>>
@AF
3557BF
AGD
3BB>;53F;A@
8AD
@7I
BAI7D
G@>7EE
I7
:3H7
F:;E
'56@
.11?2@@
:3E
29B121
?7
8AD
<C2?
.
F2.?
!<
12=.?A:2;A
203

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









0<B;AF
06AF
2C2;
<A52?
=<D2?
=?<C612?@
F:3F


5.C2
0<;A.0A21 8;<D@

A52
.11?2@@
FA
A56@
0299
A<D2?
@6A2

:3H7
0.9921
52?2
/23<?2
9.@A
F2.?
A<
;<
.C.69
U?
FDK;@9
39;@
1E;52
FA
E77
?3K47
EA?7A@7
=@AIE
:AI
FA
>A53F7
F:7
366D7EE
*:7

&)
5AAD6;@3F7E
3D7







3@6

F:7
B3D57>
@G?47D
;E




&>73E7
53@
EA?7A@7
:7>B
?7
>A53F7
F:7

366D7EE
FA
F:;E
E;F7
@K
3EE;EF3@57
KAG
53@
A887D
IAG>6
47
9D73F>K
3BBD75;3F76

53@
47
D735:76
3F



AD
4K

7?3;>98D3@5;E8G>>7DFA@7@9;@77D;@95A?
*:3@=
KAG
=;@6>K


E56/6A

B

 1&(
&DA6G5F;A@
A5G?7@FE
?3;>
A@



2

*:7
EF3F7?7@F
34AH7
8DA?
F:7
BB>;53@F
;E:
;@

74DG3DK
A8

34AGF
F:7
);F7
3F

;EEG7
ECG3D7>K
D78GF7E
F:7
EF3F7?7@FE
;@
F:7
,A>G@F3DK
9D77?7@F
A8
G@7

5>3;?;@9
F:3F
F:7
*
RAB7D3F7E
3
I;D7>7EE
5A??G@;53F;A@ 835;>;FKS
3F
F:7
);F7


*:3F
*
AD
3@KA@7
5AG>6
@AF
:3H7
477@
AB7D3F;@9
3
I;D7>7EE
5A??G@;53F;A@
835;>;FK
G@67D
F:7



+&
;E
3>EA
5A@8;D?76
4K
F:7
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
F:3F
F:7



+&
I3E

8AD
3
,("1.6 5$
1$+ 8
2314"341$
I:;5:
EFDG5FGD7E
:3H7
>A@9
475A?7
A4EA>7F7
3@6
7;F:7D
67?A>;E:76
AD
E;?B>K
@AF
GE76

*:7
?;5DAI3H7
D7>3K
EKEF7?
I3E
B3DF
A8
F:7
**
"A@9
";@7E
@7FIAD=
I:;5:
;@5>G676
I;D7
3@6
534>7
5A@@75F;A@E
B;
83@
3@6
"A@9
";@7E
38;5;A@36A
AD7K
3D>EA@
7JB>3;@E
F:3F
RF:7
"A@9
";@7E
@7FIAD=
D7>3K76
3@3>A9
63F3
8DA?
A@7
:AD@
FA
3@AF:7D
I;F:
BA>3D;L3F;A@
AD
D36;A
I3H7E
FA
7JB3@6
F:7
E;9@3>
53B35;FKS
*:7;D
R)+,E;L76
T:AD@U
3@F7@@3ES
I7D7
67E;9@76
FA
8A5GE
D36;A
E;9@3>E
AGF
:AD;LA@F3>>K
FAI3D6
AF:7D
FAI7DE
3@6
47
6GD34>7
RD7E;EF3@F
FA
F:7
BD7EEGD7
I3H7
8DA?
3
@G5>73D
4>3EFS
O

%4EA>7F7
;@
FA63KUE
IAD>6
A8
8;47D
ABF;5E
E3F7>>;F7E
3@6
I;D7>7EE
;@F7D@7F
?3@K
A8
F:7
FAI7DE
:3H7
477@
F3=7@
6AI@
AD
EI3BB76
AGF
8AD
57>>G>3D
GE7
)A?7
:AI7H7D
E7DH7
3E
7?7D97@5K
435=GBE
;@
DGD3>
3D73E
@6
AF:7DE
;F
IAG>6
E77?
3D7
EA
4G;>F
;@FA
F:7
37EF:7F;5
A8
F:7;D
3EEA5;3F76
4G;>6;@9E
F:3F
AI@7DE
:3H7
E77@
@A
D73EA@
FA
D7?AH7
F:7?S



E56/6A

135=9DAG@6
;@8AD?3F;A@
34AGF
,("1.6 5$
1$+ 8
2314"341$2
3@6
**
GE7E2 55AD6;@9
FA
F:7
+&
F:7
-

I3E
3BBDAH76
8AD
3

8AAF
4K
8AAF
4G;>6;@9
3@6



.88
4?FB

//
'BA:
'<A8F
/86;AB?B:L
4A7
DH<C@8AG
?BA:?<A8F A8G

($ -*2
1

.$/ .
G;868AGE4?B99<68 6B@


204

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









3

8AAF
3@F7@@3
FAI7D
E56/6A

1+&
&7D?;F2
H7@
EA
F:7
3@F7@@3
FAI7D
5A?BA@7@F
FA63K
35FG3>>K
D735:7E


877F
;@
:7;9:F
I:7@
?73EGD76
8DA?
F:7
:;9:7EF

7J;EF;@9
3BBGDF7@3@57
388;J76
FA
F:7
FAI7D
E56/6A

1,A>G@F3DK
9D77?7@F2
$AF34>K
3E
EF3F76
73D>;7D
@7;F:7D
F:7
AG@FK
F:7
;FK
@AD
F:7
BB>;53@F
:3H7
477@
34>7
FA
>A53F7
D75AD6E
3GF:AD;L;@9
F:7
;@5D73E76
:7;9:
47KA@6
F:7

877F
AD;9;@3>>K

3BBDAH76
4K
F:7
AG@FK
!(#
A@E7CG7@F>K
F:7
;FK
67@;76
3
5A>>A53F;A@
D7CG7EF
478AD7
BB>;53@F
HA>G@F3D;>K
39D776
FA
D76G57
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
FA


877F
BGDEG3@F
FA
F:7
,A>G@F3DK
A?B>;3@57
9D77?7@F

&DA576GD3>>K
F:7
&DA<75F
3BB73D76
478AD7
F:7
;FK
AG@5;>
3E
97@63
F7?
$A



A@
%5FA47D




8AD
3
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
&DA<75FUE
67F3;>E
3@6
A8
I;D7>7EE
835;>;F;7E
97@7D3>>K
3@6
8AD
F:7
;FK
AG@5;>
FA
D757;H7
3@6
8;>7
F:7
6?;@;EFD3F;H7
(7BADF
*:7
&DA<75F
@AI
3BB73DE
478AD7
F:7
;FK
AG@5;>
&>3@@;@9
A??;EE;A@
3@6
5A??G@;FK
3E
3
53E7
EFG6K
A8
3@
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
835;>;FK
*:7
;FK
AG@5;>
&>3@@;@9
A??;EE;A@
3@6
5A??G@;FK
I;>>
47
D7H;7I;@9
F:7
B7D?;FF;@9
BDA576GD7E
8AD
I;D7>7EE
5A??G@;53F;A@E
835;>;F;7E
97@7D3>>K



@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
435=9DAG@6
;@8AD?3F;A@
34AH7
3@6
F:7
D73EA@E
@AF76
47>AI
I7
EFDA@9>K
GD97
F:7
;FK
FA
67@K
F:7
EFD73?>;@76
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
E;@57
3E
E:AI@
34AH7
;F
;E
@AF
3@
$7(23(-& 6(1$+$22
835;>;FK
3E
5A@F7?B>3F76
;@
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
3@6
8GDF:7D
4753GE7
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
6A7E
@AF
D7>;7H7
3@
397@5K
8DA?
5A@E;67D;@9
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
A8
3@K
3BBDAH3>

$AD
6A7E
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
7JBD7EE>K
AD
;@
3@K
I3K
BD77?BF
3>;8AD@;3
@H;DA@?7@F3>
'G3>;FK
5F
R'S
AD
3>;8AD@;3
EF3F7
>3I
D7CG;D7?7@FE
I:;5:
D7CG;D7
6;E5D7F;A@3DK
D7H;7I
;@
F:;E
53E7
3E
6;E5GEE76
47>AI

 '

+
&'
!
'"*%


',
"&
!"'
$(
,
&
!

I

J
!
I+
&'
!J
&(##"%'
&'%('(%
'"


%!'

!
&'%

%)
*
(!%

(&
H



+@67D

+)
M

3


?;@;EF7D;3>
AD
EFD73?>;@76
D7H;7I
3BB>;7E
A@>K
FA
F:7
R7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
835;>;F;7ES

3

"*/
#%
*%$)Q




$

$("Q$AFI;F:EF3@6;@9
E75F;A@


A8
F:7

*7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5F
A8


&G4>;5
"3I

P


AD
3@K
AF:7D

BDAH;E;A@
A8
>3I
3
)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
67@K
3@6
E:3>>
3BBDAH7
3@K
7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EF
8AD
3
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
2E6@A6;4 205

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









D6?292@@ A<D2?
AD
/.@2 @A.A6<;
F:3F
6A7E
@AF
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
5:3@97
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@



"
"

"*)
('+)*Q

AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
F:;E

EG4E75F;A@
F:7
F7D?
TT29646/92 3.0696A62@ ?2>B2@AKK
?73@E
3@K
D7CG7EF
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
2E6@A6;4 D6?292@@
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
F:3F
;@HA>H7EQ



5A>>A53F;A@
A8
@7I
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F



D7?AH3>
A8
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F
AD



D7B>357?7@F
A8
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F


?B:
36676

E
3?B>K
6;E5GEE76
3@6
E:AI@
;@
F:7
;@FDA6G5F;A@
34AH7
F:7D7
:3E
477@
@A
7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
835;>;FK
3F
F:7
);F7
G@F;>
F:7
BB>;53@F
8;>76
;FE
3BB>;53F;A@
E
EG5:
EFD73?>;@76
D7H;7I
6A7E
@AF
3BB>K
:7D7


@
366;F;A@
F:7
7J;EF;@9
3@6
K7F
343@6A@76
3@6
@A@AB7D3F;H7
FAI7D
83;>E
FA
E3F;E8K
57DF3;@
678;@;F;A@E
;@
*;F>7

)75F;A@



A8
F:7
A67
A8

767D3>
(79G>3F;A@E

-;D7>7EE

35;>;FK
#A6;8;53F;A@E
@3?7>K
F:7
FAI7D
;E
@AF
R7J;EF;@9S
8AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
F:;E
E75F;A@
3@6
F:7D78AD7
6A7E
@AF
5A@EF;FGF7
3E
3@
R7>;9;4>7
EGBBADF
EFDG5FGD7S
$$ 

(
M




EG46E
4
66;F;A@3>>K
F:7
FAI7D
I3E
3F
A@7
BA;@F
AD
3@AF:7D
78875F;H7>K
343@6A@76
3@6
@AF
;@
GE7
8AD
3
B7D;A6
A8
F;?7QF:7D74K
9;H;@9
D;E7
FA
;EEG7E
5A@57D@;@9
F:7
3BB>;534;>;FK
A8
BD7H;AGE>K
;EEG76
B7D?;FE
3@6
5GDD7@F


>;57@E77E
3@6
BB>;53@FUE
34;>;FK
FA
GF;>;L7
F:AE7
B7D?;FE
3@6
B;5=
GB
8DA?
I:7D7
BD;AD
>;57@E77E
3@6
AB7D3FADE
A8
F:7
FAI7D
>78F
A88
*:7
);F7UE
3@6
FAI7DUE
343@6A@?7@F
5A@FD;4GF7E
FA
K7F
3@AF:7D
D73EA@
I:K
F:7
&DA<75F
E:AG>6
47
:3>F76
3@6
BB>;53@F
AD67D76
FA
5A?B>7F7
@7I
BDA576GD7E
8AD
;EEG3@57
A8
3
@7I
+&
55AD6;@9
FA
)75F;A@E




4
3@6


4





*7D?E
GE76
;@
F:;E
E75F;A@
:3H7
F:7
8A>>AI;@9
?73@;@9E










 
@K
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
3E
678;@76
;@
F:;E
E75F;A@
BDAH;676
F:3F
;F
;E
2E6@A6;4 .A
F:7
A6:2
F:7
D7>7H3@F
3BB>;53F;A@
;E
8;>76
I;F:
F:7
)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
G@67D
F:;E
E75F;A@


206

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$
















5A@EFDG5F76
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
;E
2E6@A6;4
8AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
F:;E
E75F;A@
;8
;F
5.@ /22; ?2C62D21
3@6
.==?<C21 G@67D
F:7
.==960./92 G<;6;4
AD
@6A6;4 =?<02@@
AD
G@67D
3@AF:7D
)F3F7
AD
>A53>
D79G>3FADK
D7H;7I
BDA57EE
BDAH;676
F:3F
3
FAI7D
F:3F
:3E
@AF
477@
D7H;7I76
3@6
3BBDAH76
4753GE7
;F
I3E
@AF
;@
3
LA@76
3D73
I:7@
;F
I3E
4G;>F
4GF
I3E
>3I8G>>K
5A@EFDG5F76
;E
7J;EF;@9
8AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
F:;E
678;@;F;A@

!(#
7?B:
36676

@
7EE7@57
F:7
5A@EFDG5F76
FAI7D
3>F:AG9:
D7>3F76
FA
3
BDA<75F
F:3F
:36
477@
D7H;7I76
3@6
3BBDAH76
;@



;@
F:3F
F:7K
A55GBK
F:7
E3?7
);F7
;E
7@F;D7>K
E7B3D3F7
3@6
6;EF;@5F
8DA?
F:3F
3BBDAH76
4K
F:7
+&
AH7D


K73DE
39A


*:7
+&
3>>AI76
8AD
F:7
R7EF34>;E:?7@F
A8
3
?;5DAI3H7
D7>3K
EF3F;A@
;@
5A@@75F;A@
I;F:
3
BG4>;5
F7>7B:A@7
E7DH;57S
I:;5:
IAG>6

R5A@E;EF
A8
3@
3BBDAJ;?3F7

8F
4K


8F
4G;>6;@9
3@6
3


8F
3@F7@@3
FAI7DS
3@6
47
3>>AFF76
3
R:7;9:F
H3D;3@57
8AD
3@F7@@3
182DA?


8F
FA
3
?3J;?G?
A8


8FS
E56/6A

B


1+&2
/7F
355AD6;@9
FA

BB>;53@F
D7BD7E7@F3F;H7E
RF:7
FAI7D
5A?BA@7@F
A8
F:7
1- 2
;E


8F
4GF
;E

8GDF:7D
7JF7@676
FA


8F
I:7@
F:7
:7;9:F
;E
?73EGD76
8DA?
F:7
:;9:7EF
7J;EF;@9
3BBGDF7@3@57
388;J76
FA
F:7
FAI7DS
E56/6A

B

197@63
(7BADF2
@6
3E

36?;FF76
4K
F:7
AG@FK
F:7
;FK
3@6
BB>;53@F
@A
A@7
:3E
477@
34>7
FA
>A53F7
3@K
D75AD6E
I:;5:
3GF:AD;L76
F:7
7JB3@E;A@
;@
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
FAI7D
47KA@6
F:7

877F

AD;9;@3>>K
3>>AI76
!(#

E
EG5:
F:7
:7;9:F
;@5D73E7
I3E
G@3GF:AD;L76

(75A9@;L;@9
F:7
E7H7D;FK
A8
EG5:
@A@5A?B>;3@57
BB>;53@F
HA>G@F77D76
FA
3@6
6;6
D76G57
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
FAI7D
FA


877F

$7H7DF:7>7EE
F:7
FAI7D
3E
;F
EF3@6E
@AI
;E


877F
:;9:
;@
H;A>3F;A@
A8
F:7
+&
E56/6A

1;E:
-;D7>7EE
7EF35=;@9
&7D?;F2
E56/6A

BB


 1-;D7>7EE
A??G@;53F;A@E

35;>;F;7E
BB>;53F;A@
)5D77@;@9

AD?
1RBDABAE76
FAI7D
:7;9:F
I;>>
675D73E7
8DA?

U
FA
US2

GDF:7D
3E
;F
EFAA6
3F
F:7
F;?7
A8
EG4?;EE;A@
A8
F:7
3BB>;53F;A@
8AD
5A>>A53F;A@
I3E
@AF
F:7
FAI7D
F:3F
I3E
3BBDAH76
8AD
67H7>AB?7@F
;@



E
EG5:
F:7
7J;EF;@9




$G
<F
JBEG;
ABG<A:
G;4G
G;8
GBJ8E
4F
<G
FG4A7F
<F
<A
I<B?4G<BA
B9
G;8
0+
:<I8A
G;4G
G;8
.<G8

;4F
ABG
588A
@4<AG4<A87
<A
466BE74A68
J<G;
GJB
B9
G;8
G;E88
BA7<G<BAF
B9

CCEBI4?

A4@8?L
G;4G
G;8
98A687<A
4E84
58
6BI8E87
J<G;
6EHF;87
EB6>
4A7
G;8
4668FF
EB47
?847<A:
GB
G;8
.<G8
58
B<?
FHE94687
BE
GE84G87
FB
4F
GB
8?<@<A4G8
7HFG

0+
C

/;8
HA4HG;BE<M87

HF8F
4A7
I<B?4G<BAF
B9
G;8




0+
6BA7<G<BAF
4A7
F6BC8
B9
HF8
CE86?H78F
G;8
HF8
B9
FH6;




0+
9BE
4AL
CEBCBF87
46G<I<GL


207

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










835;>;FKQI:3F7H7D
;F
;EQ3E
@AF
B7D?;FF76
G@67D
F:7



+&

);?B>K
BGF
F:7




+&
:3E
477@
>A@9
H;A>3F76
3@6
475A?7
;@78875F;H7

A@E7CG7@F>K
3@6
5A@FD3DK
FA
F:7
;FKUE
BAE;F;A@
F:7
3BB>;53F;A@
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
FA
F:7
FAI7D
835;>;FK
6A7E
@AF
CG3>;8K
G@67D
)75F;A@


3E
3@
R7>;9;4>7
EGBBADF

EFDG5FGD7S
8AD
EFD73?>;@76
D7H;7I
3E
F:7
835;>;FK
I3E
@AF
3@
R7J;EF;@9S
GF;>;FK
FAI7D
3F
F:7
F;?7
A8
EG4?;EE;A@
A8
F:7
3BB>;53F;A@
8AD
5A>>A53F;A@
3E
F:7E7
F7D?E
3D7
678;@76
4K
*;F>7

)75F;A@E



4
3@6

A8
F:7
A67
A8

767D3>
(79G>3F;A@E

 '

#%"
'
&(&'!'
,

!&
'

+
&'
!

'"*%
'
%,

&$(
,
!

'
%"

!
&'%


%)
*
(!%
&'
"!



*:7
&DA<75F
83;>E
FA
E3F;E8K
735:
A8
F:7
D7CG;E;F7
5D;F7D;3
G@67D
)75F;A@
 
A8
F:7

)B75FDG?
5F
;@
AD67D
FA
388AD6
F:7
&DA<75F
EFD73?>;@76
?;@;EF7D;3>
D7H;7I
*:;E
E75F;A@
A8
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
;E
G@67DEFAA6
FA
47
A@9D7EEU
788ADF
FA
36H3@57
I;D7>7EE
E7DH;57E
35DAEE
F:7
5AG@FDK
4K
7JB76;F;@9
3@6
EFD73?>;@;@9
F:7
788;5;7@F
67B>AK?7@F
A8
3EEA5;3F76
@7FIAD=
835;>;F;7E
A@
7J;EF;@9
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
/7F
;F
6A7E
@AF
3>>AI
8AD
F:7
G@5:75=76
3@6
I3@FA@
3BBDAH3>
A8
-
E
3E
3FF7?BF76
:7D7
$$

(
(7B
$A











)B75;8;53>>K
;@
D7>7H3@F
B3DF
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
EF3F7E
3

35;>;FK
?A6;8;53F;A@E




@

7@7D3>


$AFI;F:EF3@6;@9
E75F;A@


A8
F:7
*7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5F
A8


&G4>;5
"3I




AD
3@K
AF:7D
BDAH;E;A@
A8
>3I
3
)F3F7
AD

>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
67@K
3@6
E:3>>
3BBDAH7
3@K
7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EF
8AD
3
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
F:3F
6A7E
@AF
24!23 -3( ++8
"' -&$
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@



>;9;4>7

35;>;F;7E
(7CG7EF

AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
F:;E
EG4E75F;A@
F:7
F7D?
R7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EFS
?73@E
3@K
D7CG7EF
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
F:3F
;@HA>H7EQ



5A>>A53F;A@
A8
@7I
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F

208

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$











D7?AH3>
A8
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F
AD


D7B>357?7@F
A8
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@F



BB>;534;>;FK
A8
@H;DA@?7@F3>
"3IE


$AF:;@9
;@
B3D39D3B:


E:3>>
47
5A@EFDG76
FA
D7>;7H7
F:7

A??;EE;A@
8DA?
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
F:7
$3F;A@3>
;EFAD;5

&D7E7DH3F;A@
5F 1
2
AD
F:7
$3F;A@3>
@H;DA@?7@F3>
&A>;5K
5F
A8



4

767D3>
3E7?7@FE
(;9:FEA8-3K
3@6
"73E7E









*;?7>K
A@E;67D3F;A@
A8
BB>;53F;A@E






BB>;534;>;FK
A8
@H;DA@?7@F3>
"3IE


$AF:;@9
;@
F:;E
B3D39D3B:
E:3>>
47
5A@EFDG76
FA
D7>;7H7
3@
7J75GF;H7
397@5K
A8
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
6;H;E;A@

A8
EG4F;F>7

A8
F;F>7

AD
F:7
$3F;A@3>
@H;DA@?7@F3>
&A>;5K
5F
A8




+)


7F
E7C


+)
M


7?B:3E;E
36676
"".1#


(
M




EG46
5
1R3
)F3F7
AD
>A53>

9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
67@K
3@6
E:3>>
3BBDAH7
3@K
7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EF
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
7>;9;4>7
EGBBADF
EFDG5FGD7
F:3F
6A7E
@AF
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
5:3@97
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
EFDG5FGD7S2

*:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
A@
F:7
FAI7D
;@5>G67E
3@
3DD3K
A8
5A?BA@7@FE
F:3F
FA97F:7D
I;>>
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
5:3@97
F:7
FAI7D
*:7E7
5A?BA@7@FE
;@5>G67

 F:D77
B3@7>
3@F7@@3E


 F:D77
E75FAD
?AG@FE


 E;J
((+E


 F:D77
435=FA435=
?AG@FE


 A@7
%,&
3@6


 A@7
:K4D;6
534>7


$$
97@63
(7BADF
B




209

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









>F:AG9:
F:7
&DA<75F
6A7E
@AF
8;F
@73F>K
I;F:;@
A@7
A8
F:7
8AGD
BDA@9E
A8
F:7
 3(.-6(#$

.++." 3(.-
&1$$,$-3
BDA?G>93F76
4K
F:7
-;D7>7EE
*7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
GD73G
*'
2$$



(


 3@








(56



F:7
366;F;A@
A8

F:7E7


5A?BA@7@FE
A@
F:7
7J;EF;@9

8AAF
FAI7D
5A@EF;FGF7
3
REG4EF3@F;3>
5:3@97S

A8
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
F:7
FAI7D
EA
3E
FA
@G>>;8K
F:7
3BB>;534;>;FK
A8
)75F;A@


*:;E
;E
8GDF:7D
F:7
53E7
I:7D7
3E
?7@F;A@76
3@6
E:AI76
34AH7
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
:3E
477@
;@AB7D3F;H7
8AD
675367E

>F:AG9:
;F
?3K
47
EA
F:3F
F:7
;FK
97@7D3>>K
>35=E
6;E5D7F;A@
I;F:
D7EB75F
FA
"$13 (-
5A>>A53F;A@
D7CG7EFE
I:7D7
EG5:
D7CG7EF
FDG>K
;@HA>H7E
3@
$7(23(-&
6(1$+$22
% "(+(38
3@6
I:7D7
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
?77FE
57DF3;@
D7>7H3@F
D7CG;D7?7@FE
3@6
3>F:AG9:
8767D3>
D79G>3F;A@E
?3K
>;?;F
>A53>
397@5;7EU
BAI7D
FA
5A@FDA>
EG5:
835;>;F;7E
EG5:
;E
@AF
F:7
53E7
:7D7

 '

#%"
'
&
"(
!"'

##%")
&
!
'
%

&

&(&'!'

)
!
'
'
'

#%"#"&

""'
"!


',
,

)
&
!

!'

#'&

!(
!

%
!
"'
%

-%&


+@67D
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F

+)
M

3




&&""*/
%

$,(%$#$*"
"-)Q!<A56;4
;@

B3D39D3B:


E:3>>
47
5A@EFDG76
FA
?2962C2
F:7
A??;EE;A@
8DA?
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
F:7
$3F;A@3>

;EFAD;5
&D7E7DH3F;A@
5F
AD
F:7
!.A6<;.9
;C6?<;:2;A.9 #<960F 0A
A8



?B:
36676

7D7
F:7
&DA<75FUE
6A5G?7@FE
E:AI
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
?3K
:3H7
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35FE
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
;@5>G6;@9
5D;F;53>>K
8;D7
;?B35FE
)B75;8;53>>K
F:7
&DA<75F
;E
>;EF76
3E



2/

FG4G8F
G;4G
4?G;BH:;

BA:E8FF
7<7
ABG
47BCG
G;8
!

SF
G8E@<AB?B:L
B9
PFH5FG4AG<4?

<A6E84F8
<A
F<M8Q
<A
.86G<BA

4
2/

6BAG8A7F
G;4G
G;8
CB?<6L
E84FBAF
9BE
8K6?H7<A:

9EB@
.86G<BA

4
6B??B64G<BAF
G;4G
FH5FG4AG<4??L
6;4A:8
G;8
C;LF<64?
7<@8AF<BAF
B9
4
FGEH6GHE8
4E8
6?BF8?L
4A4?B:BHF
GB
G;BF8
G;4G
4A<@4G87
G;8
!

<A
G;8
-#)(0#


)&&)
-#)(

!+'(-
4A7
FH5F8DH8AG
CEB6887<A:F
$A
?<:;G
B9
G;8
!

SF
CE<BE
9<A7<A:F
2/

58?<8I8F
<G

<F
4CCEBCE<4G8
GB
?BB>
GB
G;8
8K<FG<A:
789<A<G<BA
B9
PFH5FG4AG<4?
<A6E84F8
<A
F<M8Q
GB
78G8E@<A8
J;8G;8E
G;8
6B??B64G<BA
E8@BI4?
BE
E8C?468@8AG
B9
8DH<C@8AG
BA
4
J<E8?8FF
GBJ8E
BE
54F8
FG4G<BA
FH5FG4AG<4??L
6;4A:8F
G;8
C;LF<64?
7<@8AF<BAF
B9
G;8
HA78E?L<A:
FGEH6GHE8
J<G;<A
G;8
@84A<A:
B9
.86G<BA

4


!

-


%4A






!

-67


DHBG4G<BAF

B@<GG87 

210

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









 47;@9
@73D
3@
A;>
I7>>


 36<357@F
FA
3
I;>6>3@6
3D73
AD
@A@;DD;93F76
@3F;H7
H797F3F;A@

 >A53F76
;@
5>AE7
BDAJ;?;FK
8DA?
3
;H;E;A@
A8
%;>

3E
3@6

7AF:7D?3>

(7EAGD57E
A;> 93E
E77B
AD
>3@68;>>
D7CG;D;@9
?7F:3@7
IAD=
B>3@

 ;@HA>H;@9
;@EF3>>3F;A@
AD
D7B3;D
A8
G@67D9DAG@6
B;B;@9
AD
8;D7
67B3DF?7@F
5A@@75F;A@E
E7DH;@9
BD;H3F7
8;D7
:K6D3@F EBD;@=>7D EF3@6B;B7
EKEF7?E

 5>AE7
FA
3
6D;@=;@9 6;@;@9 D75D73F;A@
?77F;@9E FD3;@;@9 D7>;9;AGE
8G@5F;A@E
AD
AF:7D
93F:7D;@9E
;@
3
DAA?
7F5


E56/6A

B




>>
F:7
@AF76
835FE
EGBBADF
3
8;@6;@9
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
?3K
47
3
E;9@;8;53@F
8;D7
:3L3D6
8AD
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
*:;E
;@
FGD@
EGBBADFE
3
8;@6;@9
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
?3K
3>EA
53GE7
E7H7D7
36H7DE7
;?B35FE
A@
:G?3@
47;@9E


E
?7D7>K
3@
7J3?B>7
F:7
D;E=
A8
?7F:3@7
7JBAEGD7
3@6
8;D7
D;E=E
FA
:G?3@
47;@9E
:3H7
477@
I7>>
6A5G?7@F76
;@
"AE
@97>7E

3L3D6E
3@6
63@97DE
A8
?7F:3@7
93E
:3H7

477@
35=@AI>76976
4K
F:7
;FK
A8
"AE
@97>7E

;@5>G6;@9
;H;E;A@


)75



F:DAG9:




3E
I7>>
3E

G;>6;@9
A67
4AF:
A8
I:;5:
D7CG;D7
EB75;8;5
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E


3E76
A@
)A3>UE
53GF;A@

R '
!
!

'

!
&',


#7F:3@7
;E
@A@FAJ;5
3@6
5D73F7E
@A
:3L3D6
I:7@
;@:3>76
;@
>;?;F76
CG3@F;F;7E
:AI7H7D
;8
>3D97
CG3@F;F;7E
A8
@3FGD3>
93E
AD
?7F:3@7
;E
3>>AI76
FA
6;EB>357
3;D
>35=
A8
AJK97@
?3K
D7EG>F
;@
EG88A53F;A@


#7F:3@7
53@
47
8>3??34>7
I:7@
?;J76
I;F:
3;D
47FI77@
57DF3;@
5A@57@FD3F;A@E

B7D57@F
FA


B7D57@F
3@6
I:7D7
F:7D7
;E
3@
;9@;F;A@
EAGD57


)A3>
3EN
5A@6G5FE
7JF7@E;H7
E387FK
BDA9D3?E
FA
BD7H7@F
F:7
7E53B7
A8
@3FGD3>
93E
8DA?
;FE
EKEF7?
3@6
3E
3
:73>F:
3@6
E387FK
BD753GF;A@
366E
3
6;EF;@5F;H7
A6AD
FA
@3FGD3>
93E
EA
?AEF
B7AB>7
53@
73E;>K
@AF;57
;FE
BD7E7@57

8
KAG
E?7>>
3
@3FGD3>
93E
A6AD
:73D
F:7
:;EE;@9
EAG@6
A8
93E
7E53B;@9
AD
E77
AF:7D
E;9@E
A8
3
>73=
(#$
53>?
%$*
E?A=7
AD
>;9:F
3
?3F5:
53@6>7
AD
AF:7D
8>3?7
%$*
FGD@
7>75FD;53>
3BB>;3@57E
AD
>;9:FE
A@
AD
A88
AB7D3F7
 ;GGCF

JJJ ?475F BE:
7B6F
7894H?GFBHE68
CH5?<64G<BAF
BE7<A4A68F
@8G;4A86B78
BE7<A4A68AB

C79F9IEFA7885

211

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









?35:;@7DK
AD
GE7
3@K
67H;57
F:3F
5AG>6
5D73F7
3
EB3D=
##*"/
,+*
F:7
3D73
3@6
8DA?
3
E387
>A53F;A@
53>>
)A3> 3E
3F







AD
53>>


;8
F:7
63?397
D7EG>FE
;@
3
@3FGD3>
93E
>73=
F:3F
?3K
7@63@97D
>;87
AD
53GE7
4A6;>K
:3D?
AD
BDAB7DFK
63?397S




*:GE
?7F:3@7
93E
?3K
47
63@97DAGE
FA
BG4>;5
:73>F:
67B7@6;@9
A@
;FE
5A@57@FD3F;A@E
@
366;F;A@
F:7
"
;FKUE
#7F:3@7
%D6;@3@57
?7@F;A@E
34AGF
%(1$
:3L3D6E
A8
?7F:3@7
-
()
F:7D7
I3E
3
36?2
;@
F:7
.6?3.E ?2.
A8
F:7
;FK
A8
"AE
@97>7E
;@


6G7
FA
5645 C<9B:2
A8
:2A5.;2 4.@ @22=.42
F:DAG9:
5D35=E
;@
F:7
5A@5D7F7
8>AAD
A8
3
4G;>6;@9


-
()
;@
AG@5;>

;>7
$A




F:7
;FK
AG@5;>
6;D75F76
F:7

;FKUE
7B3DF?7@FE
A8
G;>6;@9
3@6
)387FK
@9;@77D;@9
3@6
&>3@@;@9
3E
I7>>
3E
F:7
:;78
"79;E>3F;H7
@3>KEF
3@6
%88;57
A8
6?;@;EFD3F;H7
3@6
(7E73D5:
)7DH;57E
FA
8AD?
3
IAD=
9DAGB
3@6
D75A??7@6
G@;8AD?
E387FK
D7CG;D7?7@FE
D793D6;@9
?7F:3@7
8AD
.99
3BAB?2
67H7>AB?7@F
F:DAG9:AGF
F:7
;FK


-
()
3
EFG6K
4K
F:7
IAD=
9DAGB
I3E
5A@6G5F76
D793D6;@9
3D73E
F:DAG9:AGF
F:7
;FK
A8
"AE
@97>7E
A<
612;A63F
.?2.@
I:7D7
EG4EGD8357
?7F:3@7
93E
?3K
47
8AG@612

GDF:7D
F:7
;FK
A8
"AE
@97>7EU
?7F:3@7
AD6;@3@57
BDAH;67E
&$-$1 +
?7F:3@7
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
3@6
2/$"(%("
?7F:3@7
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E

*:GE
G@67D
)





$("
#*
$
#*
*%$
('+(#$*)

>>
@7I
4G;>6;@9E
3@6
B3H76
3D73E
>A53F76
;@
3
#7F:3@7
0A@7
AD
#7F:3@7
G887D
0A@7
E:3>>
5A?B>K
I;F:
F:7E7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
3@6
F:7
#7F:3@7
#;F;93F;A@
)F3@63D6E
7EF34>;E:76
4K
F:7
)GB7D;@F7@67@F
A8
G;>6;@9
*:7
#7F:3@7
#;F;93F;A@
)F3@63D6E
BDAH;67
;@8AD?3F;A@
67E5D;4;@9
F:7 ;@EF3>>3F;A@
BDA576GD7E
67E;9@
B3D3?7F7DE
3@6
F7EF
BDAFA5A>E
8AD
F:7
?7F:3@7
93E
?;F;93F;A@
EKEF7?
I:;5:
3D7
@AF
E7F
8ADF:
;@
F:7
BDAH;E;A@E
A8
F:;E
6;H;E;A@

;GGCF

JJJ FB64?:4F 6B@
FG4LF498
@8G;4A88@<FF<BAF
@8G;4A84A7;84?G;4A7
F498GLNG8KG(8G;4A8

<F

ABA
GBK<6

4A7BKL:8A

@4L

E8FH?G

<A


FH99B64G<BA


212

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









*:7
"AE
@97>7E
;FKUE
?7F:3@7
AD6;@3@57
F:7@
>;EFE
@G?7DAGE
?;F;93F;A@
EF3@63D6E
;@5>G6;@9
?7F:3@7
F7EF;@9
3F
F:7
BDA<75F
E;F7E
F:3F
?GEF
47
5A?B>;76
I;F:
@
366;F;A@
F:7
#7F:3@7
%D6;@3@57
BDAH;67E
##(3(.- +
D7?76;3>
?73EGD7E

R)




*%$"
(#"
#)+()







2;2?.9
%2:216.9
2.@B?2@


@
F:7
7H7@F
F:7
5A@57@FD3F;A@
A8
?7F:3@7
93E
;@
3@K
4G;>6;@9
>A53F76
;@
3
#7F:3@7
0A@7
AD
#7F:3@7
G887D
0A@7
D735:7E
AD
7J5776E

B7D57@F
A8

F:7
?;@;?G?
5A@57@FD3F;A@
A8
93E
F:3F
I;>>
8AD?
3@
;9@;F34>7
?;JFGD7
I;F:
3;D
3F
3?4;7@F
F7?B7D3FGD7
3@6
BD7EEGD7
F:7
AI@7D
E:3>>
:;D7
3@
7@9;@77D
FA
;@H7EF;93F7
D75A??7@6
3@6
;?B>7?7@F
?;F;93F;@9
?73EGD7E
*:7E7
?73EGD7E
E:3>>
47
EG4<75F
FA
3BBDAH3>
A8
F:;E
7B3DF?7@F
3@6
F:7
;D7

7B3DF?7@F







/.;1<;21
"69
*299


@K
343@6A@76
A;>
I7>>
7@5AG@F7D76
6GD;@9
5A@EFDG5F;A@
E:3>>
47 7H3>G3F76
4K
F:7

;D7
7B3DF?7@F
3@6
?3K
47
D7CG;D76
FA
47
D7
343@6A@76
;@
355AD63@57
I;F:
3BB>;534>7
DG>7E
3@6
D79G>3F;A@E
A8
F:7
;H;E;A@
A8
%;>

3E
3@6

7AF:7D?3>
(7EAGD57E
A8
F:7
)F3F7
A8
3>;8AD@;3

G;>6;@9E
E:3>>
5A?B>K
I;F:
F:7E7
BDAH;E;A@E
3@6
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
&20A6<;




<3
A56@
<12
D56052C2?
6@
:<?2
?2@A?60A6C2S


?B:
36676

@
366;F;A@
)75F;A@




A8
F:7
G;>6;@9
A67
BDAH;67E


&





&#%'
"!
%"
"

*&

:2;121
/F
"?1
!<


33



$A
E5:AA>
:AEB;F3>
E3@;F3D;G?
AD
.@@2:/9F <00B=.;0F
E:3>>
47
I;F:;@

322A
8DA?
F:7
57@F7D
A8
F:7
A;>
I7>>
53E;@9

!<
=B/960
BA696AF
8G7>
?3@G835FGD;@9
B>3@F
AD
=B/960
BA696AF
2920A?60.9 42;2?.A6;4
?2026C6;4
AD
16@A?6/BA6<; =9.;A
E:3>>
47
>A53F76
I;F:;@

877F
8DA?
F:7
57@F7D
A8
F:7
A;>
I7>>
53E;@9

!<
/B6916;4
:<?2
A5.;


@>B.?2
322A


?



;@
3D73
.;1
A.992?
A5.;


322A
6;
52645A
E:3>>
47
7D75F76
D6A56;


322A
8DA?
F:7
57@F7D
A8
3@
A;>

I7>>
53E;@9

213

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










16@A.;02
@2=.?.A6<;
47FI77@
F:7
7JF7D;AD
I3>>
A8
F:7
4G;>6;@9
3@6
F:7
02;A2?
<3
.;
<69
D299 0.@6;4
E:3>>
47
?3;@F3;@76
I;F:
3
:AD;LA@F3>
6;EF3@57
7CG3>
FA



A6:2@
A52
/B6916;4@
52645A
BDAH;676
:AI7H7D

F:3F
F:3F
6;EF3@57
@776
@AF
7J5776

877F

*:7
4G;>6;@9
:7;9:F
8AD
F:;E

BDAH;E;A@
E:3>>
47
?73EGD76
H7DF;53>>K
8DA?
F:7
36<357@F
>AI7EF
9DAG@6
7>7H3F;A@
FA
F:7
57;>;@9
A8
F:7
FAB
EFADK

+#'
"!&
*:7
6;EF3@57
E7B3D3F;A@
?3K
47
D76G576
FA
F:7
8A>>AI;@9




877F
E7B3D3F;A@
;8
3
EA>;6

;@5:7E
F:;5=
?3EA@DK
I3>>
3@6
@A
E:ADF7D
F:3@

877F
F3>>
FA
47
5A@EFDG5F76
I;F:;@


877F
8DA?
F:7
4G;>6;@9
;@

47FI77@
F:7
A;>
I7>>
3@6
3>>
BADF;A@E
A8
F:7
4G;>6;@9




877F
;8
3@K
BADF;A@
A8
F:7
4G;>6;@9
7JF7D;AD
I3>>E
I;F:;@

877F
8DA?

F:7
57@F7D
A8
3@
A;>
I7>>
53E;@9
E:3>>
47
5A@EFDG5F76
I;F:
@A
AB7@;@9E
3@6
A@7
:AGD
8;D7
D7E;EF;H7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
I;F:
3


8AAF
:;9:
8;D7
D3F76
B3D3B7F




877F
;8
3@K
BADF;A@
A8
F:7
4G;>6;@9
7JF7D;AD
I3>>E
I;F:;@

877F
8DA?

F:7
57@F7D
A8
3@
A;>
I7>>
53E;@9
E:3>>
47
5A@EFDG5F76
I;F:
@A
AB7@;@9E
3@6
FIA:AGD
8;D7
D7E;EF;H7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
I;F:
3


8AAF
:;9:
8;D7
D3F76
B3D3B7F

*:7
BDAH;E;A@E
EB75;8;76
I;F:;@
F:;E
E75F;A@
E:3>>
@AF
3BB>K
FA
A;>
I7>>E
F:3F
:3H7
477@
343@6A@76
B7D
"#
)75F;A@




3@6
;@
355AD63@57

I;F:
F:7
3BB>;534>7
DG>7E
3@6
D79G>3F;A@E
A8
F:7
;H;E;A@
A8
%;>
3E
3@6

7AF:7D?3>
(7EAGD57E
A8
F:7
)F3F7
A8
3>;8AD@;3

*:7
5A?4;@3F;A@
A8
?7F:3@7
LA@7
3@6
@73D4K
A;>
I7>>
BD7E7@FE
3@
366;F;A@3>
:3L3D6
3@6
3@
G@GEG3>
5;D5G?EF3@57
F:3F
@776E
FA
47
BDAB7D>K
?;F;93F76
3@6
EFG6;76
*:7D7
;E
@A
D75AD6
I:7F:7D
F:7
;FK
A8
)3@
>7?7@F7
:7D7
:3E
F3=7@
;@FA
5A@E;67D3F;A@
F:7
34AH7@AF76
5A@57D@E
A8
3>>AI;@9
3
:;9:;@F7@E;H7
GE7
I;D7>7EE
835;>;FK
;@
3@
7@H;DA@?7@F3>>K
5:3>>7@976
>A53F;A@
I:;5:
?3K
53GE7
8;D7
3@6
:GDF
B7AB>7


78AD7
3BBDAH;@9
3@K
I;D7>7EE
835;>;FK
3E
BDABAE76
4K
F:7
BB>;53@F
F:7
BG4>;5
3@6
F:7
675;E;A@?3=7DE
?GEF
D757;H7
3
8G>>
$&
D7H;7I
3E
I7>>
3E
8G>>
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
34AGF
F:7
D7BADFE
F:3F
F:7
BB>;53@F
;E
D7CG;D76
FA
EG4?;F
;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA
8;D7
3@6
?7F:3@7
D7BADF
3E
@AF76
;@
F:7
E5D77@;@9
6A5G?7@F
1J:;4;F

B
2
3@6

67F7D?;@7
I:7F:7D
F:7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
3@6
AB7D3F;A@
A8
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
?3K
:3H7
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35FE
I:3F
F:AE7
;?B35FE
IAG>6
47
3@6
I:7F:7D
F:AE7
;?B35FE
53@
47
?;F;93F76
FA
;@E;9@;8;53@F
>7H7>E

214

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









@
366;F;A@
FA
F:7
7JF7@F
F:3F
F:7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
A8
F:7
I;D7>7EE
835;>;FK
;@HA>H7E
;@EF3>>3F;A@
A8
G@67D9DAG@6
B;B;@9
3E
5A@57676
4K
F:7
BB>;53@F
;@
F:7
E5D77@;@9
?3F7D;3>E
E56/6A

B


F:;E
?3K
BAE7
366;F;A@3>
:3L3D6E
;?B35FE

*:;E
;E
4753GE7
;8
F:7
&DA<75F
;E
>A53F76
I;F:;@
5>AE7
BDAJ;?;FK
FA
3@
A;>
I7>>
3@6
;@
3@
39D;5G>FGD3>>K
LA@76
3D73
;F
;E
BAEE;4>7
F:3F
F:7
EA;>
;@
F:7
&DA<75F
);F7
:3E
477@
5A@F3?;@3F76
I;F:
H3D;AGE
5:7?;53>E
3@6
B7EF;5;67E
-:;>7
EG5:
5A@F3?;@3F76
EA;>
6A7E
@AF
BAE7
3@K
;?B35F
AD
:3L3D6
FA
F:7
EGDDAG@6;@9
7@H;DA@?7@F
I;F:AGF
F:7
&DA<75F
;F
?3K
BD7E7@F
:3L3D6
5A@57D@E
3@6
7JBAE7
B7AB>7
3@6
F:7
9DAG@6I3F7DE
FA
5A@F3?;@3F;A@
6G7
FA
F:7
6;EFGD43@57
A8
5A@F3?;@3F76
EA;>E
)G5:
:3L3D6E
;?B35FE
?3K
3>EA
47
BD7E7@F
6G7
FA
F:7
FD3@EBADF3F;A@
A8
5A@F3?;@3F76
EA;>
AD
674D;E
8DA?
F:7
);F7
6GD;@9
F:7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
A8
F:7
&DA<75F

3E76
A@
AGD
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
6A5G?7@FE
D757;H76
;@
D7EBA@E7
FA
BG4>;5
D75AD6E
D7CG7EFE
F:7D7
;E
@A
7H;67@57
F:3F
EG5:
5D;F;53>
;?B35FE
FA
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@6
F:7
BG4>;5
I7D7
BDAB7D>K
D7H;7I76
G@67D
$&
3@6
F:7D7
;E
@A
D75AD6
A8
3@K
$&
67F7D?;@3F;A@
?367
8AD
F:;E
53E7
7;F:7D
E
EG5:
F:7
&DA<75FUE
3BBDAH3>E
H;A>3F7
$&
3@6
?3K
@AF
47
>793>>K
3BBDAH76
AD
EFD73?>;@76
3E
BDABAE76
I;F:AGF
BDAB7D
$&
D7H;7I

) '

#%"
'
"&
!"'
" #,
*
'

'


"%!


")%! !'
"
""'
"!
%$(
% !'&

3>;8AD@;3

AH7D@?7@F
A67
E75F;A@

3
EF3F7E


5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
E:3>>
47
3
B7D?;FF76
GE7
@AF
EG4<75F
FA
3
5;FK
AD
5AG@FK
16@0?2A6<;.?F =2?:6A
;8
;F
E3F;E8;7E
F:7
8A>>AI;@9
D7CG;D7?7@FE




*:7
0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696AF 6@ 0<;@6@A2;A
I;F:
D7CG;D7?7@FE
8AD
F:7
D6?292@@ A2920<::B;60.A6<;@
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
BGDEG3@F
FA
EG46;H;E;A@
4
A@
I:;5:
F:7
0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696AF
;E
BDABAE76


*:7
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
A@
I:;5:
F:7
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
;E
BDABAE76
D.@ @B/720A
FA
3
16@0?2A6<;.?F =2?:6A
4K
F:7
5;FK
AD
5AG@FK
.;1 .; 2;C6?<;:2;A.9 6:=.0A ?2=<?A
I3E
57DF;8;76
<?
3
;24.A6C2 1209.?.A6<;
AD
:6A64.A21 ;24.A6C2 1209.?.A6<;
I3E
36ABF76
8AD
F:7
D6?292@@ A2920<::B;60.A6<;@ 0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696AF
;@ 5A?B>;3@57
I;F:
F:7
3>;8AD@;3
@H;DA@?7@F3>
'G3>;FK
5F




1.;12
F:7
0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696AF
;@5ADBAD3F7E
?2>B6?21 215

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









:6A64.A6<; :2.@B?2@
EB75;8;76
;@
A5.A 2;C6?<;:2;A.9 6:=.0A ?2=<?A
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@
AD
?;F;93F76
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@

AH
A67
M


EG46E
3


7?B:
36676

7D7
F:7D7
;E
@A
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
34AGF
I:7F:7D
F:7



+&
I3E
7H7D
EG4<75F
FA
3

6;E5D7F;A@3DK
D7H;7I
G@67D
'
F:3F
;@HA>H76
3@
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35F
D7BADF

%
AD
3
?;F;93F76
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@
 !
AD
3
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@
!
*:7D7
;E
@A
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
F:3F
F:7
7J;EF;@9
835;>;FK
;E
3
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
AD
F:3F
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
;E
5A@E;EF7@F
I;F:
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
;@
EG46;H;E;A@
4
A8

AH7D@?7@F
A67
E75F;A@


*A
F:7
ABBAE;F7
F:7
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
FA
63F7

E:AIE
F:3F
F:7
835;>;FK
;@
B>357
:3E
@AF
7H7@
477@
3GF:AD;L76
AD
BDAB7D>K
B7D?;FF76
G@67D
F:7



+&
:3E
@AF
477@
;@
GE7
8AD
675367E
G@F;>
F:7
BB>;53@FUE
BDABAE76
GE7
;@



GDF:7D
3>;8AD@;3

AH7D@?7@F
A67
E75F;A@

4
EF3F7E

I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
I:7D7
3
@B/@2>B2;A 0<99<0.A6<; 3.0696AF
;E
3
=2?:6AA21
GE7
;<A
EG4<75F
FA
3
5;FK
AD
5AG@FK
16@0?2A6<;.?F
B7D?;F
BGDEG3@F
FA
EG46;H;E;A@
3
:B@A 0<:=9F
I;F:
F:7
8A>>AI;@9



6AF
AD
0<B;AF ?2>B6?2:2;A@
8AD
3
D6?292@@
A2920<::B;60.A6<;@ 0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696AF
F:3F
EB75;8;7E
FKB7E
A8
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
835;>;F;7E
F:3F
3D7
3>>AI76
FA
;@5>G67
3
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
AD
FKB7E
A8
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
835;>;F;7E
F:3F
3D7
3>>AI76
FA
;@5>G67
57DF3;@
FKB7E
A8
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
:7;9:F
>A53F;A@
4G>=
3@6
E;L7
A8
F:7
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
B7D57@F397 A8
F:7
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
F:3F
?3K 47
A55GB;76
4K
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
3@6
37EF:7F;5
AD
67E;9@
D7CG;D7?7@FE
8AD
F:7
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK



6AF
AD
0<B;AF ?2>B6?2:2;A@
8AD
3
BDABAE76
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
;@5>G6;@9
3@K
AF=2@
A8
0<9<0.A6<; 3.0696A62@
F:3F
?3K
47
3>>AI76
A@
3
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
:7;9:F
>A53F;A@
4G>=
3@6
E;L7
A8
3>>AI76
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
3@6
37EF:7F;5
AD
67E;9@
D7CG;D7?7@FE
8AD
3
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;FK 216

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$












&A.A2
3@6
9<0.9 ?2>B6?2:2;A@
;@5>G6;@9
F:7
42;2?.9 =9.;
3@K
3BB>;534>7
0<::B;6AF =9.;
AD
@=206360 =9.;
3@6
G<;6;4 <?16;.;02


*:7
.963<?;6. ;C6?<;:2;A.9 $B.96AF 0A
;H;E;A@

5A??7@5;@9
I;F:
)75F;A@


A8
F:7
#B/960 %2@<B?02@
<12
A5?<B45 02?A6360.A6<;
A8
3@
2;C6?<;:2;A.9 6:=.0A D7BADF
AD
.1<=A6<;
A8
3
;24.A6C2 1209.?.A6<;
AD
:6A64.A21 ;24.A6C2 1209.?.A6<;


AH
A67
M


EG46E
4

7?B:
36676

*:7D7
;E
@A
7H;67@57
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
:7D7
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
EG46;H;E;A@
4
A8

AH7D@?7@F
A67
E75F;A@


;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8

'
FA
BDAH;67
3@
(
#$
AD
$
:7D7

*:7D7
;E
@A
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
3E
FA
I:7F:7D
F:7
BDABAE76
835;>;FK
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
F:7
;FKUE
97@7D3>
B>3@
EB75;8;5
B>3@
LA@;@9
AD
AF:7D
AD6;@3@57E
3E76
A@
F:7
,A>G@F3DK
A?B>;3@57
9D77?7@F
E;9@76
4K
F:7
;FK
3@6
F:7
BB>;53@F
F:7
;FK
3BB73DE
FA
:3H7
5A@E;67D76
EA>7>K
F:7
5A@E;EF7@5K
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
I;F:
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
>A@9H;A>3F76
3@6
:7@57
;@78875F;H7



+&
;EEG76
FA
3
5A?B>7F7>K
6;887D7@F
3BB>;53@F
D3F:7D
F:3@
3@K
AF:7D
3BB>;534>7
;FK
D79G>3F;A@



"3EF

AH7D@?7@F
A67
E75F;A@

5
?3@63F7E
@AF;57
BGDEG3@F
FA

AH7D@?7@F

A67
E75F;A@



3@6
R3F
>73EF
A@7
BG4>;5
:73D;@9
A@
F:7
6;E5D7F;A@3DK
B7D?;FS
D7CG;D76
4K
)75F;A@

4
8AD
I;D7>7EE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5A>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E

*:7D7
:3E
477@
@A
EG5:
BDAB7D
@AF;57
FA
63F7
*:7
;FKUE
397@63
@AF;57
8AD
$AH7?47D



EA>7>K
BDAH;67E
8AD
3
EFG6K
E7EE;A@
D3F:7D
F:3@
BG4>;5
:73D;@9
I:7D7
7H;67@57
I;>>
47
:73D6
AD
F3=7@
FA
?3=7
3
67F7D?;@3F;A@
A@
F:7
&DA<75F
@EF736
3E
;F
3BB73DE
F:7
;FK
:3E
477@
3BBDAH;@9
H3D;AGE
B7D?;FE
8AD
F:7
&DA<75F
79
F:D77
6;E:
3@F7@@3E
AH7D
F:7
B3EF
E7H7D3>
?A@F:E
3@6
I;F:AGF
BG4>;5
D7H;7I
AD
E5DGF;@K

7D7
BB>;53@F
3@6
F:7
;FK
5A@F7@6
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
@776
A@>K
5A?B>K
I;F:
)75F;A@


K7F
;9@AD7
3>;8AD@;3UE
34AH7@AF76
5>73D
?3@63F7E
3@6
366;F;A@3>
D7CG;D7?7@FE
F:3F
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
?GEF
5A?B>K
I;F:


$AF34>K
8767D3>
>3I
6A7E
@AF
;@:;4;F
F:7
BAI7D
A8
EF3F7
AD
>A53>
397@5;7E
FA
67@K
3@
>;9;4>7

35;>;F;7E
(7CG7EF
%
3BB>;53F;A@
;@
3>>
53E7EQ;@EF736
;F
3>>AIE
EF3F7
AD
217

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










>A53>
A88;5;3>E
FA
D7CG;D7
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
A8
3@6
5ADDA4AD3F7
F:7
5A@F7@F;A@
F:3F
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
5:3@97
7J;EFE

5
 








)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
67@K
3@6

E:3>>
3BBDAH7
3@K
7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EF
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
7>;9;4>7
EGBBADF
EFDG5FGD7
F:3F
6A7E
@AF
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
5:3@97
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
EFDG5FGD7



 

 
  


 

-:7@
3@
3BB>;53@F
3EE7DFE

;@
ID;F;@9
F:3F
3
D7CG7EF
8AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
;E
5AH7D76
4K
F:;E
E75F;A@
3
)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
D7CG;D7
F:7
3BB>;53@F
FA
BDAH;67
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
AD
;@8AD?3F;A@
A@>K
FA
F:7
7JF7@F
D73EA@34>K
D7>3F76
FA
67F7D?;@;@9
I:7F:7D
F:7
D7CG7EF
?77FE
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
F:;E
E75F;A@

)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
D7CG;D7
3@
3BB>;53@F
FA
EG4?;F
3@K
AF:7D
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA 6A5G?7@F3F;A@
;@F7@676
FA
;>>GEFD3F7
F:7
@776
8AD
EG5:
I;D7>7EE 835;>;F;7E
AD
FA
<GEF;8K
F:7
4GE;@7EE
675;E;A@
FA
?A6;8K
EG5:
I;D7>7EE
835;>;F;7E



(
M




EG46
5

7?B:3E;E
36676

*A
63F7
;F
;E
G@=@AI@
I:7F:7D
3@6
FA
I:3F
7JF7@F
BB>;53@F
BDAH;676
EG88;5;7@F
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
AD
;@8AD?3F;A@
D7>3F76
FA
F:7
67F7D?;@3F;A@
A8
I:7F:7D
;FE
B7D?;F
3BB>;53F;A@E
?77F
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
A8
)75F;A@




@EF736
BB>;53@F
EG4?;FF76

F:7

(
>7FF7D
"%
8DA?
F:7
53DD;7D
3@6
FAI7D
AI@7D
E;F7
B>3@E
B:AFAE;?G>3F;A@E
(

5A?B>;3@57
3@3>KE;E
3@6
F:7
+&
BB>;53@F
:3E
83;>76
FA
BDAH;67
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
5A@57D@;@9
F:7
);F7UE
GE7
3@6
B7D?;FF;@9
:;EFADK
3@6
BDAA8
F:3F
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
5:3@97
7J;EFE
7EB75;3>>K
5A@57D@;@9
F:3F
F:7
366;F;A@
A8
F:7


5A?BA@7@FE
I;>>
EG4EF3@F;3>>K

3>F7D
F:7
E;L7
3@6
37EF:7F;5E
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
EFDG5FGD7

GDF:7D
)75F;A@

3
A8
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
678;@7E
3@

(
FA
;@5>G67
R5A>>A53F;A@

A8
@7I
FD3@E?;EE;A@
7CG;B?7@FS

+)
M


EG46
3

3@6
F:3F
;F

?3@63F7E
3BBDAH3>
;8
F:7

(
?77FE
57DF3;@
5D;F7D;3
;@
F:7


D79G>3F;A@E
$$



(
M




)75F;A@

3

BDAH;67E


$AFI;F:EF3@6;@9
E75F;A@


A8
F:7
*7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
5F
A8



&G4>;5
"3I




AD
3@K
AF:7D
BDAH;E;A@
A8
>3I
3
)F3F7
AD
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@F
?3K
@AF
67@K
3@6
E:3>>
3BBDAH7
3@K
7>;9;4>7
835;>;F;7E
D7CG7EF
8AD
3
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
3@
7J;EF;@9
I;D7>7EE
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
F:3F
6A7E
218

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










@AF
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
5:3@97
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@


+)
M


EG46
3


>F:AG9:
F:7
;FK
;E
D7CG;D76
FA
3BB>K
F:7


5D;F7D;3
;@
AD67D
FA
67F7D?;@7
I:7F:7D

F:7
&DA<75F
;E
3
@A@EG4EF3@F;3>
5:3@97
I:;5:
?GEF
47
3BBDAH76
3D4AD
,;7I

%

5A@F7@6E
F:3F
F:7
?39@;FG67
A8
F:7
5:3@97
BDABAE76
:7D7
EG88;5;7@F>K
5A@EF;FGF7E
3
REG4EF3@F;3>1
2
5:3@97
;@
F:7
B:KE;53>
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
EG5:
FAI7DS
3E
366D7EE76
BD7H;AGE>KQF:7D74K
6;ECG3>;8K;@9
;F
8DA?
)75F;A@


?;@;EF7D;3>
D7H;7I


?A@9
F:7
D7>7H3@F

(
5D;F7D;3
F:7


D7CG;D7E
F:3F
F:7
?A6;8;53F;A@
47
FA
3@

R7J;EF;@9S
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
3@6
678;@7E
F:7
F7D?
T7J;EF;@9U
3E
3
FAI7D
AD
43E7
EF3F;A@
F:3F
R:3E
477@
D7H;7I76
3@6
3BBDAH76
G@67D
F:7
3BB>;534>7
LA@;@9
AD
E;F;@9
BDA57EE
AD
G@67D
3@AF:7D
D79G>3FADK
D7H;7I
BDA57EE
E77

 (
M




EG46

4


E
?7@F;A@76
BD7H;AGE>K
F:7
FAI7D
G@67DI7@F
E7H7D3>
B7D;A6E
A8
@A@5A@8AD?;@9
GE7
@A@GE7
3@6
I3E
3BBDAH76
G@67D
B75G>;3D
5;D5G?EF3@57E
F:3F
?3K
@AF
367CG3F7>K
47
5ADDA4AD3F76
AD
835F5:75=76
3>;8AD@;3
5A>>A53F;A@
BDAH;E;A@E
3BB>K
:7D7
3@6
3D7
@AF
7JBD7EE>K
BD77?BF76
4K
8767D3>
>3I
3@6
3E
EG5:
F:7
;FK
?GEF
5A@6G5F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
A8
3@K
BDA<75F
BDABAE76

GDF:7D
F:7
;FKUE
5A?B>;3@57
I;F:

F:7
3>;8AD@;3
A67
D7CG;D7?7@FE
3@6
'
I;>>
@AF
8DGEFD3F7
AD
;?B767
F:7
3BB>;53F;A@
A8
F:7
8767D3>
>3I
*A
F:7
5A@FD3DK
EG5:
5A?B>;3@57
I;>>
A@>K
8GDF:7D
F:7
9A3>E
A8
F:7
8767D3>
>3I
;@5>G6;@9
F:3F
@AF:;@9
;@
F:7
8767D3>
D79G>3F;A@E
;@5>G6;@9
;@
F:7
)B75FDG?
5F
E:AG>6
47
5A@EFDG76
3E
D7>;7H;@9
3@
397@5KUE
6GFK
FA
5A@E;67D
F:7
BDABAE76
BDA<75FUE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@57D@E
G@67D
$&

*:7D78AD7
3B3DF
8DA?
;FE
H;A>3F;A@E
A8
F:7
8767D3>
>3I
F:7
&DA<75F
;E
3>EA
H;A>3F;@9
F:7
3BB>;534>7
EF3F7
D79G>3F;A@E
A@E7CG7@F>K
G@>7EE
3@6
G@F;>
BB>;53@F
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
F:7
3BB>;534>7
BDAH;E;A@E
A8
F:7
3>;8AD@;3

AH7D@?7@F
A67
F:7
&DA<75F
53@@AF
47

3BBDAH76
@EF736
;FE
3BBDAH3>E
?GEF
47
:3>F76
3@6
3>>
5D;F;53>
6A5G?7@F3F;A@
?GEF
47
D7H;7I76
I;F:
9D73F7D
E5DGF;@K
8AD
F:7
&DA<75FUE
5A?B>;3@57
I;F:
3>>
D7>7H3@F
5A67E
) '

#%"
'
*"(

##%")

!
)
"'
"!
"
'



"%!

!)
%"! !'
$(
',
'

 35=9DAG@6
A@57D@;@9
@H;DA@?7@F3>
?B35FE
(7BADFE
219

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









'
;E
3
3>;8AD@;3
EF3FGF7
67E;9@76
FA
;@8AD?
675;E;A@?3=7DE
3@6
F:7
BG4>;5
34AGF
F:7
BAF7@F;3>
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875FE
A8
3
BDA<75F
'
G;67>;@7E

M




EG46
3


F
;FE
5AD7
;FE
BGDBAE7
;E
FA
R;@8AD?
F:7
BG4>;5
3@6
;FE
D7EBA@E;4>7
A88;5;3>E
A8
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@E7CG7@57E
A8
F:7;D
675;E;A@E
!$%.1$
F:7K
3D7
?367S

(3(9$-2
.%
.+$3

++$8
5

. 1#
.%
4/$15(2.12





3>
6




'
6;D75FE
BG4>;5
397@5;7E
FA
3HA;6
AD
D76G57
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
63?397
I:7@
BAEE;4>7
4K
D7CG;D;@9
3>F7D@3F;H7E
AD
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
'
G;67>;@7E

M




EG46E
3


E77
3>EA

$1*$+$8
$$/
$32
5$1
3'$

8

.,,(33$$
5

. 1#
.%
.13

.,,(22(.-$12
.%
3'$

(38
.%
 *+ -#





3>BBF:




:7D738F7D

R
$1*$+8
$$/
$32S
 41$+
$(&'32
,/1.5$,$-3
22-
5
$&$-32
.%
-(5$12(38
.%

+(%.1-(




3>
6





*:7
@H;DA@?7@F3>
?B35F
(7BADF
(
E7DH7E
FA

BDAH;67
BG4>;5
397@5;7E
3@6
F:7
BG4>;5
;@
97@7D3>
I;F:
;@8AD?3F;A@
34AGF
F:7
78875F
F:3F
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
;E
>;=7>K
FA
:3H7
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@6
FA
R;67@F;8K
I3KE
F:3F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
63?397
53@
47
3HA;676
AD
E;9@;8;53@F>K
D76G576S
'
G;67>;@7E

M




EG46
3

8
F:7
BDA<75F
:3E
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
F:7
397@5K
?3K
3BBDAH7
F:7
BDA<75F
A@>K
GBA@
8;@6;@9
F:3F
;F
:3E
R7>;?;@3F76
AD
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
>7EE7@76
3>>
E;9@;8;53@F
78875FE
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
I:7D7
873E;4>7S
3@6
F:3F
3@K
G@3HA;634>7
E;9@;8;53@F
78875FE
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3D7
R3557BF34>7
6G7
FA
AH7DD;6;@9
5A@57D@ES
EB75;8;76
;@
3>;8AD@;3
&G4>;5
(7EAGD57E
A67
)75F;A@




$$
'

G;67>;@7E
MM




EG46E
4


-:;>7
F:7
5AGDFE
D7H;7I
3@
(
GE;@9
3@
T34GE7
A8
6;E5D7F;A@U
EF3@63D6
F:7
D7H;7I;@9
5AGDF
;E
@AF
FA
4-"1(3(" ++8
D7>K
A@
7H7DK
EFG6K
AD
3@3>KE;E
BD7E7@F76
4K
3
BDA<75F
BDABA@7@F
;@
EGBBADF
A8
;FE
BAE;F;A@

$1*$+$8
$$/
$32
24/1 


3>BBF:
3F
B


CGAF;@9
 41$+
$(&'32
24/1 

3>
6
3F
BB





8@


;@F7D@3>

CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76

5>73D>K
;@367CG3F7
AD
G@EGBBADF76
EFG6K
;E
7@F;F>76
FA
@A
<G6;5;3>
6787D7@57
#
D3I;@9
F:;E
>;@7
3@6
67F7D?;@;@9
I:7F:7D
F:7
(
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
'UE
;@8AD?3F;A@
6;E5>AEGD7
D7CG;D7?7@FE
BD7E7@FE
3
CG7EF;A@
A8
>3I
EG4<75F
FA
;@67B7@67@F
D7H;7I
4K
F:7
5AGDFE
($11

+4!
5

.4-38
.%
1$2-.




3>F:






 #$1
5$12(&'3

. +(3(.-
-"
5

.4-38
.%
 #$1





3>BBF:





/;8

,

"H<78?<A8F
6B7<9<87
<A
/<G?8


B9
G;8

4?<9BEA<4

B78
B9
-8:H?4G<BAF
F86G<BA



8G
F8D
4E8
E8:H?4GBEL
:H<78?<A8F
CEB@H?:4G87
5L
G;8
FG4G8
)4GHE4?
-8FBHE68F
:8A6L

9BE
G;8
<@C?8@8AG4G<BA
B9

,

+H5
-8F

B78
O

 
/;8

,

"H<78?<A8F
4E8

:<I8A
P:E84G
J8<:;G
<A
<AG8ECE8G<A:

,

8K68CG
J;8A




6?84E?L
HA4HG;BE<M87
BE

8EEBA8BHF Q

(-+
)+

#)&)!#
&

#/+,#-2
/

*-
)
#,"

#&
&# 






4? G;



 

220

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$













E
F:7

;DEF
;EFD;5F
AGDF
A8
BB73>
:3E
BD7H;AGE>K
EF3F76
BD7<G6;5;3>
34GE7
A8
6;E5D7F;A@
A55GDE
;8
F:7
83;>GD7
FA
;@5>G67
D7>7H3@F
;@8AD?3F;A@
BD75>G67E
;@8AD?76
675;E;A@?3=;@9
3@6
;@8AD?76
BG4>;5
B3DF;5;B3F;A@
F:7D74K
F:I3DF;@9
F:7
EF3FGFADK
9A3>E
A8
F:7
(
BDA57EE

$1*$+$8
$$/
$32
24/1 


3>BBF:
3F
B



;@F7D@3>
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76

*:7
BD7B3D3F;A@
3@6
5;D5G>3F;A@
A8
3@
(
;E
?AD7
F:3@
3
E7F
A8
F75:@;53>
:GD6>7E
8AD
397@5;7E
3@6
67H7>AB7DE
FA
AH7D5A?7

.,,4-(3($2
%.1


$33$1

-5(1.-,$-3
5
("',.-#






3>BBF:




CGAF;@9

(-$8 1#
1$

(3(9$-2
%.1
$2/.-2(!+$
1.63'
-"

5

(38
.%
 -"'.

.1#.5





3>F:





*:7
(UE
8G@5F;A@
;E
FA

7@EGD7
F:3F
9AH7D@?7@F
A88;5;3>E
I:A
675;67
FA
4G;>6
AD
3BBDAH7
3
BDA<75F
6A
EA
I;F:
3
8G>>
G@67DEF3@6;@9
A8
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@E7CG7@57E
3@6
7CG3>>K
;?BADF3@F
F:3F
F:7
BG4>;5
;E
3EEGD76
F:AE7
5A@E7CG7@57E
:3H7
477@
5A@E;67D76
#
AD
F:7
(
FA

E7DH7
F:7E7
9A3>E
;F
?GEF
BD7E7@F
;@8AD?3F;A@
EA
F:3F
F:7
8AD7E7734>7
;?B35FE
A8
BGDEG;@9
F:7
BDA<75F
53@
47
G@67DEFAA6
3@6
I7;9:76
3@6
F:7
BG4>;5
?GEF
47
9;H7@
3@
367CG3F7
ABBADFG@;FK
FA
5A??7@F
A@
F:3F
BD7E7@F3F;A@
478AD7
F:7
675;E;A@
FA
9A
8ADI3D6
;E
?367
#


EFDA@9
BD7EG?BF;A@
;@
83HAD
A8
D7CG;D;@9
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
;E
4G;>F
;@FA
'
*:;E
BD7EG?BF;A@
;E
D78>75F76
;@
I:3F
;E
=@AI@
3E
F:7
R83;D
3D9G?7@FS
EF3@63D6
G@67D
I:;5:
3@
(
?GEF
47
BD7B3D76
I:7@7H7D
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
F:7
D75AD6
EGBBADFE
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F:3F
3
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
4 (+

.3 -(" +
 1#$-2
.4-#
-"
5

(38
.%

-"(-(3 2




3>BBF:







1($-#2
.%
:
;
3
5
(38
.%
 86 1#





3>
6




*:7
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F7EF
EF7?E
8DA?
F:7
EF3FGFADK
?3@63F7
F:3F
3@
(
47
BD7B3D76
8AD
3@K
BDA<75F
F:3F
R?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FS
&G4
(7E
A67
M



2$$ .
(+
-"
5

(38
.%
.2
-&$+$2



3>BB
6


:7D738F7D

R.
(+S
"".1# $-2$-
5

(38
.%
 -3
.2




3>BBF:


:7D738F7D

R$-2$-S
+@67D
F:;E
F7EF
;8
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
;E
@AF
7J7?BF
3@6
?3K
53GE7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
F:7
>736
397@5K
?GEF
BD7B3D7
3@
(
&G4
(7E
A67
MM


EG46
3



'

G;67>;@7E
MM



EG46E
3


8

@
(
?3K
47
6;EB7@E76
I;F:
A@>K
;8
F:7
>736
397@5K
8;@6E
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
F:7
;@;F;3>
EFG6K
AD
7>E7I:7D7
;@
F:7
D75AD6
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
 1*$1
' 334"*
$(&'!.12
5
$1*$+$8

(38

.4-"(+




3>BBF:


@
EG5:
3
E;FG3F;A@
F:7
>736
397@5K
,423
36ABF
3
221

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@
&G4
(7E
A67
M



EG46
5

'

G;67>;@7E

MM




EG46
4




EG46
8


R);9@;8;53@F
78875F
GBA@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FS
;E
678;@76
3E
R3
EG4EF3@F;3>
AD
BAF7@F;3>>K
EG4EF3@F;3>
36H7DE7
5:3@97
;@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FS
&G4
(7E
A67
M


'

G;67>;@7E
M





BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
;8
F:7D7
;E
3
D73EA@34>7
BDA434;>;FK
F:3F
;F
I;>>
D7EG>F
;@
3
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35F
.
(+
24/1 

3>BB
6
3F
B


8@


E77
4-#231.,
5

-38
.%
$-#."(-.



3>BB
6




:7D738F7D
R4-#231.,S
8
3@K
3EB75F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K
D7EG>F
;@
3
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@
(
?GEF
47
BD7B3D76
7H7@
;8
F:7
AH7D3>>
78875F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
;E
47@78;5;3>
'

G;67>;@7E
M




EG46
4

E77

-38

 -(3 3(.-

(23
.

5

-38
.%
$1-





3>BBF:






*:;E
EF3@63D6
E7FE
3
R>AI
F:D7E:A>6S
8AD
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
 .-2.+(# 3$#
11(& 3(.-

(23
5

(38
.%
$+,





3>BBF:




$+2.-
5

-38
.%
$1-







3>BBF:



."*$3
1.3$"3.12
5

(38
.%
 "1 ,$-3.





3>BBF:






.6, -
5

(38
.%

$1*$+$8




3>BBF:





(3(9$-
"3(.-
3.
$15$
++

34#$-32
5

'.1-+$8




3>BB
6


4-#231.,
24/1 

3>BB
6
3F

B


8
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
F:7
D75AD6
EGBBADFE
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875F
F:7
>736
397@5K
?GEF
BD7B3D7
3@
(
7H7@
;8
AF:7D
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
478AD7
;F
;@6;53F7E
F:7
BDA<75F
I;>>
:3H7
@A
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
$$ $-2$-
24/1 

3>BBF:
3F
B


+$62
 -#

(5$23."*
5

(38
.%
 -

($&.





3>BBF:






3 -(2+ 42
4#4!.-
."($38
-"
5

.4-38

.%
3 -(2+ 42



3>BBF:






1$-36..#
22-
%.1
.

1(++(-&
-"
5

(38
.%

.2
-&$+$2





3>BB
6


1($-#2
.%
:
;
3


3>BB
6

'

G;67>;@7E
M



EG46
8


 35=9DAG@6
A@57D@;@9
@;F;3>
)FG6;7E
$793F;H7
75>3D3F;A@E
3@6
#;F;93F76
$793F;H7
75>3D3F;A@E

'
3@6
'

G;67>;@7E
3D7
EFD;5F
3@6
G@3?4;9GAGE
34AGF
I:7@
3@
#$
?3K
47
GE76

BG4>;5
397@5K
?GEF
BD7B3D7
3@
(
I:7@7H7D
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
EGBBADFE
3
R83;D
3D9G?7@FS
F:3F
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
R?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FS
&G4
(7E
A67
MM





'

G;67>;@7E
MM





EG46E
8






.
(+
24/1 

3>BB
6
3F
B


.,,4-(3($2
%.1


$33$1

-5(1.-,$-3
5

+(%.1-(
$2.41"$2
&$-"8




3>BBF:






EE7@F;3>>K
E:AG>6
3
>736
397@5K
47
BD7E7@F76
I;F:
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F:3F
3
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
F:7
>736
397@5K
E:3>>
BD7B3D7
3@
(
222

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









7H7@
F:AG9:
;F
?3K
3>EA
47
BD7E7@F76
I;F:
AF:7D
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
I;>>
@AF
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
'

G;67>;@7E
MM



EG46
8


E77
.

(+
24/1 

3>BB
6 3F
B

;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@E
3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76
)G4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@5>G67E
R7@AG9:
D7>7H3@F
;@8AD?3F;A@
3@6
D73EA@34>7
;@87D7@57E
8DA?
F:;E
;@8AD?3F;A@
F:3F
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
53@
47
?367
FA
EGBBADF
3
5A@5>GE;A@
7H7@
F:AG9:
AF:7D
5A@5>GE;A@E
?;9:F
3>EA
47
D735:76S
'
G;67>;@7E
M



EG46

3

*:7
83;D
3D9G?7@F
EF3@63D6
;E
3
R>AI
F:D7E:A>6S
F7EF
8AD
D7CG;D;@9
F:7
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
.
(+
24/1 

3>BB
6 3F
B


-38
 -(3 3(.-
24/1 


3>BBF:

3F
B


F
RD7CG;D7E
F:7
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
I:7D7
F:7D7
;E
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
3@K
3EB75F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
7;F:7D
;@6;H;6G3>>K
AD
5G?G>3F;H7>K
?3K
53GE7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
D793D6>7EE
A8
I:7F:7D
F:7
AH7D3>>
78875F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
;E
36H7DE7
AD
47@78;5;3>12S

-38
 -(3 3(.-
24/1 


3>BBF:
3F
B




CGAF;@9
'

G;67>;@7E
M




EG46
4


>736
397@5K
?3K
36ABF
3@

#$
A@>K
;8
RF:7D7
;E
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
I;>>
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FS
'

G;67>;@7E
M



EG46
4

H;67@57
EGBBADF;@9
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
A8
3
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35F
FD;997DE
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
D793D6>7EE
A8
I:7F:7D
F:7
D75AD6
5A@F3;@E
5A@FD3DK
7H;67@57

$ &4$
%.1
1.3$"3(.-
.%
 *+ -#<2
1"'(3$"341 +
-#
(23.1(" +
$2.41"$2
5
(38
.%
 *+ -#




3>BBF:




R-:7D7
F:7
CG7EF;A@
;E
F:7
EG88;5;7@5K
A8
F:7

7H;67@57
FA
EGBBADF
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
6787D7@57
FA
F:7
397@5KUE
67F7D?;@3F;A@
;E
@AF
3BBDABD;3F712S

-38
 -(3 3(.-
24/1 


3>BBF:
3F
B


CGAF;@9
($11

+4!

5

.4-38
.%
.-.,




3>BBF:







GDF:7D
;F
;E
F:7
6GFK
A8
F:7
>736
397@5K
@AF
F:7
BG4>;5
FA
5A@6G5F
F:7
BDAB7D
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
EFG6;7E
R*:7
397@5K
E:AG>6
@AF
47
3>>AI76
FA
:;67
47:;@6
;FE
AI@
83;>GD7
FA
93F:7D
D7>7H3@F
63F3S
4-#231.,
24/1 

3>BB
6 3F
B



R78;5;7@5;7E
;@
F:7
D75AD6
?3K
35FG3>>K
7@>3D97
F:7
E5AB7
A8
83;D
3D9G?7@F
4K
>7@6;@9
3
>A9;53>
B>3GE;4;>;FK
FA
3
I;67D
D3@97
A8
;@87D7@57ES
!(#
E77
3>EA
$-318
5
(38
.%

411($3




3>BBF:





>35=
A8
EFG6K
7@>3D97E
F:7
E5AB7
A8
F:7
83;D

3D9G?7@F
I:;5:
?3K
47
?367
43E76
A@
F:7
>;?;F76
835FE
;@
F:7
D75AD6
*:GE
D78GE3>
FA
5A?B>7F7
D75A??7@676
EFG6;7E
>AI7DE
F:7
3>D736K
>AI
F:D7E:A>6
FA
7EF34>;E:
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
*:7
5AGDF
?3K
@AF
7J7D5;E7
;FE
;@67B7@67@F
<G69?7@F
A@
F:7
A?;FF76
?3F7D;3>
4K
67F7D?;@;@9
I:7F:7D
F:7
G>F;?3F7
675;E;A@
A8
F:7
>736
397@5K
IAG>6
:3H7
477@
38875F76
:36
F:7
>3I
477@
8A>>AI76

-5(1.-,$-3 +
1.3$"3(.-

223

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









-%.1, 3(.-

$-3$1
5

+

$/3
.%
.1$2318




3>F:


;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@E

3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76
*:7
D7?76K
8AD
F:;E
678;5;7@5K
IAG>6
47
8AD
F:7
FD;3>
5AGDF
FA
;EEG7
3
ID;F
A8
?3@63F7
!(#

AF:
F:7
D7H;7I
8AD
83;>GD7
FA
8A>>AI
'UE
BDA576GD7E
3@6
F:7
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F7EF
3D7
CG7EF;A@E
A8
>3I
F:GE
F:7
67
@AHA
EF3@63D6
A8
D7H;7I
3BB>;7E
 (-$8 1#
1$

(3(9$-2
%.1
$2/.-2(!+$
1.63'
5

(38
.%
 -"'.

.1#.5





3>F:






R-:7F:7D
F:7
397@5KUE
D75AD6
5A@F3;@E
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
IAG>6
EGBBADF
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
;E
FD73F76
3E
3
CG7EF;A@
A8
>3I

.-2.+(# 3$#
11(& 3(.-

(23
24/1 


3>BBF:
3F
B



!AEF=3
3@6
0;E5:=7
&D35F;57
+@67D
F:7
@H;DA@?7@F3>
'G3>;FK
5F




6
76
3F

M



@
F:7
#$
5A@F7JF
5AGDFE
9;H7
@A
6787D7@57
FA
F:7
397@5K
*:7
397@5K
AD
F:7
5AGDF
E:AG>6
@AF
I7;9:
7JB7DF
F7EF;?A@K
AD
675;67
A@
F:7
5D76;4;>;FK
A8
EG5:
7H;67@57QF:;E
;E
F:7
(UE
D7EBA@E;4;>;FK
E
EF3F76
;@
."*$3
1.3$"3.12
5
(38
.%
 "1 ,$-3.




+@>;=7
F:7
E;FG3F;A@
I:7D7
3@
(
:3E
477@
BD7B3D76
@7;F:7D
F:7
>736
397@5K
@AD
3
5AGDF
?3K
RI7;9:S
5A@8>;5F;@9
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
FA
67F7D?;@7
I:7F:7D
3@
(
?GEF
47
BD7B3D76
;@
F:7
8;DEF
;@EF3@57

G;67>;@7E
E75F;A@



EG46;H;E;A@
8

BDAH;67E
;@
B7DF;@7@F
B3DF
;8

3
>736
397@5K
;E
BD7E7@F76
I;F:
3
83;D
3D9G?7@F
F:3F
3
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
F:7
>736
397@5K
E:3>>
BD7B3D7
3@
(
7H7@
F:AG9:
;F
?3K
3>EA
47
BD7E7@F76
I;F:
AF:7D
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
I;>>
@AF
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
*:GE
3E
+ 1$,.-3
;FE7>8

D75A9@;L76
152A@E;67D3F;A@
;E
@AF
FA
47
9;H7@
5A@FD3DK
7H;67@57
EGBBADF;@9
F:7
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@




3>BBF:





;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@E
3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76

@
53E7E
I:7D7
;F
;E
@AF
5>73D
I:7F:7D
F:7D7
;E
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
A8
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
'
?3@63F7E
7DD;@9
A@
F:7
E;67
A8
3
RBD787D7@57
8AD
D7EA>H;@9
6AG4FE
;@
83HAD
A8
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7IS
$)(
5
(38
.%
.2
-&$+$2




3>BBF:




*:7
8AD7?AEF
BD;@5;B>7
G@67D
'
;E
F:3F
F:7
"79;E>3FGD7
;@F7@676
F:7
35F
FA
47
;@F7DBD7F76
;@
EG5:
?3@@7D
3E
FA
388AD6
F:7
8G>>7EF
BAEE;4>7
BDAF75F;A@
FA
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
I;F:;@
F:7
D73EA@34>7
E5AB7
A8
F:7
EF3FGFADK
>3@9G397
1($-#2
.%
 ,,.3'
5

#
.%
4/$15(2.12




3>
6





 35=9DAG@6
A@57D@;@9
'
J7?BF;A@E

224

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









-:7D7
3
>736
397@5K
5:AAE7E
FA
6;EBAE7
A8
'
4K
3EE7DF;@9
3
'
7J7?BF;A@
;F
:3E
3
6GFK
FA
EGBBADF
;FE
'
7J7?BF;A@
8;@6;@9E
4K
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@5>G6;@9
7H;67@57
F:3F
F:7D7
3D7
@A
3BB>;534>7
7J57BF;A@E
FA
7J7?BF;A@E
*:;E
6GFK
;E
;?BAE76
4K
'
3@6
D7>3F76
53E7
>3I
'

G;67>;@7E
M



>736
397@5K
E:3>>
@AF

=@AI;@9>K
D7>73E7
3
678;5;7@F
6A5G?7@F
:AB;@9
F:3F
BG4>;5
5A??7@FE
I;>>
5ADD75F
F:7
67875FE
2$$
(3(9$-2
%.1

-5(1.-,$-3 +
$2/.-2(!(+(38
5
3 3$
$7
1$+
3'

(23
&1("4+341$

22-






3>BBF:


>736
397@5K
:3E
F:7
4GD67@
A8
67?A@EFD3F;@9
F:3F
3
BDA<75F
83>>E
I;F:;@
3
53F79AD;53>
7J7?BF;A@
3@6
?GEF
EGBBADF
F:7
67F7D?;@3F;A@
I;F:
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
"".1# 22-
%.1
1.3$"3(.-
$3"
+4$2
5

(38
.%

*( '






3>BBF:





>736
397@5K
;E
D7CG;D76
FA
5A@E;67D
7J7?BF;A@
7J57BF;A@E
I:7D7
F:7D7
;E
7H;67@57
;@
F:7
D75AD6
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?;9:F :3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35F


*:7
6GFK
FA
EGBBADF
'
3@6
7J7?BF;A@
8;@6;@9E
I;F:
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;E
3>EA
D7CG;D76
4K
F:7
A67
A8
;H;>
&DA576GD7
#
3@6
53E7
>3I
A@
36?;@;EFD3F;H7
AD
FD36;F;A@3>
ID;FE
+@67D
F:7
&
3@
34GE7
A8
6;E5D7F;A@
;E
7EF34>;E:76
;8
F:7
675;E;A@
;E
G@EGBBADF76
4K
F:7
8;@6;@9E
AD
F:7
8;@6;@9E
3D7
G@EGBBADF76
4K
F:7
7H;67@57
&
M


EG46
4
@

./ -&
22-
%.1

"$-("

.,,
5

-38
.%
.2
-&$+$2



AGD
)GBD7?7
AGDF
:7>6
F:3F
;?B>;5;F
;@
&
E75F;A@


;E
3
D7CG;D7?7@F
F:3F
F:7

397@5K
I:;5:
D7@67DE
F:7
5:3>>7@976
675;E;A@
?GEF
E7F
8ADF:
8;@6;@9E
FA
4D;697
F:7
3@3>KF;5
93B
47FI77@
F:7
D3I
7H;67@57
3@6
G>F;?3F7
675;E;A@
AD
AD67D


3>
6





;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@E
3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76
:7D738F7D
R ./ -& S
*:7
>736

397@5KUE
8;@6;@9E
?3K
47
67F7D?;@76
FA
47
EG88;5;7@F
;8
3
5AGDF
:3E
@A
FDAG4>7
G@67D
F:7
5;D5G?EF3@57E
6;E57D@;@9
F:7
3@3>KF;5
DAGF7
F:7
36?;@;EFD3F;H7
397@5K
FD3H7>76
8DA?
7H;67@57
FA
35F;A@
$23

' -#+$1

+5#
$(&'!.1'..#
22-
52

(38
.%
.2
-&$+$2





3>BBF:









;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@E
3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76

AI7H7D
R?7D7
5A@5>GEADK
8;@6;@9E
I;F:AGF
D787D7@57
FA
F:7
D75AD6
3D7
;@367CG3F7S
#
3F
B



8;@6;@9
5;FK
5AG@5;>
8;@6;@9E
5A@5>GEADK
;@
H;A>3F;A@
A8
./ -& 

GDF:7D
'
7J7?BF;A@E
?GEF
47
@3DDAI>K
5A@EFDG76
FA
355A?B>;E:
'UE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
A4<75F;H7E

+
 1,

41$ 4
$#$1 3(.-
5

+
(+#+(%$

.-2$15 3(.-

#






3>BBF:





"".1#  5$
41

1,$+
(5$1
5
.-3$1$8
$-(-24+

3$1
 - &$,$-3

(23






3>BBF:


R*:7E7
DG>7E
7@EGD7
F:3F
;@

3>>
4GF
F:7
5>73D7EF
53E7E
A8
53F79AD;53>
7J7?BF;A@E
3
BDA<75F
I;>>
47
EG4<75F
FA
EA?7
>7H7>
A8
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7IS

;@3>>K
'
BDA576GD7E
D78>75F
3
BD787D7@57
8AD
D7EA>H;@9
6AG4FE
;@
83HAD
A8
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
$$
&G4
(7E
A67
M



EG46
5
3@
(
?3K
47

225

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









6;EBAE76
A8
A@>K
;8
F:7D7
;E
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
7@F;D7
D75AD6
478AD7
F:7
>736
397@5K
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K :3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
AD
D7H;E;A@E
;@
F:7
BDA<75F
'

G;67>;@7E
MM




EG46
4

5A??A@
E7@E7

7J7?BF;A@
A@>K
I:7D7
;F
53@
47
E77@
6(3'
"$13 (-38




EG46
4

BD7B3D7
3@
(

;8
F:7
397@5K
67F7D?;@7E
F:3F
F:7D7
;E
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
3@K
3EB75F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
7;F:7D
;@6;H;6G3>>K
AD
5G?G>3F;H7>K
?3K
53GE7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
D793D6>7EE
A8
I:7F:7D
F:7
AH7D3>>
78875F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
;E
36H7DE7
AD
47@78;5;3>2



EG46
:
F:7
397@5K
?GEF
5A@E;67D
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
B3EF
5GDD7@F
3@6
BDA434>7
8GFGD7
BDA<75FE




3
@793F;H7
675>3D3F;A@
?3K
47
BD7B3D76

A@>K
;8
F:7D7
;E
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
I:A>7
D75AD6
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
AD
BDA<75F
D7H;E;A@E
IAG>6
3HA;6
F:7
78875FE
AD
?;F;93F7
F:7
78875FE
FA
3
BA;@F
I:7D7
5>73D>K
@A
E;9@;8;53@F
78875FE
IAG>6
A55GD
3@6
F:7D7
;E
@A
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
;@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
I:A>7
D75AD6
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
3E
D7H;E76
?3K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
.
(+
24/1 

3>BB
6
3F
BB


E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35FE
3D7
FA
47
;@F7DBD7F76
EA
3E
FA
388AD6
F:7
8G>>7EF
BAEE;4>7
BDAF75F;A@

 *:7
&DA<75F
#3K

3H7
);9@;8;53@F
@H;DA@?7@F3>
?B35FE


 //+(" -3
.1
3'$

(38
 (+
3.
#$04 3$+8

(2"+.2$
- +89$
-#
(3(& 3$
3'$

1.)$"3<2
$23'$3("2
,/ "32
3.
$ 1!8
$2(#$-32
.%
3'$
 1!.1
($6

23 3$2

4!#(5(2(.-

E
;F
EF3@6E
F:7
BD7H;AGE>K
B7D?;FF76
EFDG5FGD7
5A?BD;E76
3
 8AAFF3>>

4K

8AAF

FAI7D
>A53F76
DAG9:>K



877F
8DA?
F:7
@73D7EF
D7E;67@57E
3F
F:7
7@6
A8
7>
;AE
3@6
A@
>
7DDA
;@
F:7

3D4AD
,;7I
EF3F7E
EG46;H;E;A@
*:7

3D4AD
,;7I
EF3F7E

EG46;H;E;A@
:AGE7E
DAG9:>K




D7E;67@FE


B7D57@F
A8
I:A?
AI@
F:7;D
:A?7E

)7H7D3>
A8
F:7E7
D7E;67@FE
5:AE7
FA
>;H7
;@
F:;E
EG46;H;E;A@Q3@6
F:7
;FK
A8
)3@
>7?7@F7Q6G7
FA
;FE
@3FGD3>
E7FF;@9





)8KG7BBE
#4E5BE
1<8J
FG4G8F
.4A

?8@8AG8
)BI




;GGCF

A8KG7BBE 6B@
A8<:;5BE;BB7
;4E5BEI<8J8FG4G8F64F4A6?8@8AG864


226

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










*:7
5A>>A53F;A@
3@6
366;F;A@
A8


@7I
EFDG5FGD7E
BDABAE76
4K
F:7
&DA<75F
3E
I7>>
3E

F:7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
A8
3@K
3557EEADK
EFDG5FGD7E
@77676
FA
EGBBADF
F:AE7
3@6
AB7D3F7
F:7
BDABAE76
&DA<75F
I;>>
D73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>K
53GE7
E;9@;8;53@F
4G>=
3@6
:7@57
E;9@;8;53@F
37EF:7F;5
;?B35FE
FA
F:7
EGDDAG@6;@9
5A??G@;FK

*:7K
I;>>
D73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>K
5D73F7
3@
7K7EAD7
3E
5A?B3D76
I;F:
F:7
B>3;@
?7F3>
EFDG5FGD7
@AI
E:AI@
;@
F:7
E5D77@E:AF
47>AI
E77
3>EA
E56/6A

B




227

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










-:;>7
I7
:3H7
477@
G@34>7
FA
A4F3;@
3@
;?397
A8
F:7
BDABAE76
835;>;FK
3F
F:7
);F7
3
FKB;53>


835;>;FK
;?397
;E
?G5:
4G>=;7D
F:3@
F:7
7J;EF;@9
835;>;FK
@AI
3E
E:AI@
;@
F:7
;?397
47>AI

E
EG5:
F:7
BDABAE76
5A>>A53F;A@
835;>;FK
I;>>
D73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>K
:3H7
37EF:7F;5
;?B35FE
A@
F:7
EGDDAG@6;@9
7@H;DA@?7@F
;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA
AH7D


D7E;67@FE
A8
F:7
@73D4K
D7E;67@F;3>
EG46;H;E;A@

*:7E7
37EF:7F;5
;?B35FE
I;>>
47
8GDF:7D
E;9@;8;53@F
8AD
F:7
EB75;8;5
3D73
;@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
@73D4K
D;697E
9D77@7DK
3@6
@3FGD3>
H;EF3E
EGDDAG@6;@9
F:7
&DA<75F
);F7

*:7
H;EG3>>K
;@FDGE;H7
FAI7D
3@6
F:7
BDABAE76
&DA<75F
3D7
AGF
A8
5:3D35F7D
I;F:
F:7
EGDDAG@6;@9
GE7E
3@6
5A??G@;FK
3@6
F:7D78AD7
I;>>
:3H7
E;9@;8;53@F
37EF:7F;5
;?B35FE
A@E7CG7@F>K
3@
(
?GEF
47
BD7B3D76
FA
EFG6K
3@6
?;F;93F7
EG5:
;?B35FE  //+(" -3
 (+2
3.
#$04 3$+8

(2"+.2$
- +89$
-#
(3(& 3$
3'$
1.)$"3<2

(+#%(1$
,/ "32
3.
$ 1!8
$2(#$-32
.%
3'$
 1!.1

($6

23 3$2
4!#(5(2(.-

'
D7CG;D7E
F:3F
>736
397@5;7E
F:ADAG9:>K
7H3>G3F7
3@6
6;E5>AE7
F:7
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
A8
>A53F;@9
@7I
3@6
BDABAE76
67H7>AB?7@F
;@
3D73E



4F87
BA
BHE
E8I<8J
B9
7B6H@8AGF
<A
BHE
CBFF8FF<BA
G;8E8
7B8F
ABG
F88@
GB
;4I8
588A
4AL
8AI<EBA@8AG4?
E8I<8J
9BE
G;8




0+
$9
G;8E8
J4F
FH6;
8AI<EBA@8AG4?
7B6H@8AG




G;8
GLC8
4A7




4??
7B6H@8AGF
E8?4G87
GB
FH6;









9BE
G;8
8K<FG<A:
946<?<GL
CHEFH4AG
GB

4?<9BEA<4
+H5?<6
-86BE7F

6G

228

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










EGE57BF;4>7
FA
I;>68;D7E
3@6
FA
36ABF
3>>
873E;4>7
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
FA
D76G57
AD
7>;?;@3F7
F:AE7
;?B35FE


-;>68;D7E
:3H7
475A?7
3
D79G>3D
A55GDD7@57
;@
3>;8AD@;3
3@6
I;>>
9DAI
?AD7
BD7H3>7@F
3E
F:7
5>;?3F7
5D;E;E
5A@F;@G7EQ3@
3>3D?;@9
D73>;FK
5A@E;67D;@9
F:7
?39@;FG67
A8
63?397
F:3F
:3E
3>D736K
A55GDD76
*:7
EF3F7UE
I;>68;D7E
:3H7
=;>>76
DAG9:>K



B7AB>7
E;@57

3@6
67EFDAK76
AH7D


EFDG5FGD7E
E;@57



15;F3F;A@2
@6
;@

3>A@7
3>;8AD@;3
7JB7D;7@576
3
FAF3>
A8

D75AD676
I;>68;D7E
3@6
>AEF
3@
7EF;?3F76




35D7E


EFDG5FGD7E
@;@7
:G?3@
>;H7E
3@6

5AG@F>7EE
I;>6>;87
$;@7
A8
F:7

>3D97EF
I;>68;D7E
3@6
E7H7@
A8
F:7

?AEF

67EFDG5F;H7
;@
3>;8AD@;3UE
:;EFADK
:3H7
A55GDD76
;@
F:7
>3EF
675367
-:3FUE
?AD7

A8
F:7
FAB

>3D97EF
3@6

A8
F:7
?AEF
67EFDG5F;H7
:3H7
A55GDD76
A@>K
;@
F:7
>3EF
8;H7
K73DE
3@6
4GD@76
3@
3D73
F:7
E;L7
A8
A@@75F;5GF
*:AE7
8;D7E
5A>>75F;H7>K
67EFDAK76



:A?7E
4GE;@7EE7E
3@6
AF:7D
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7


*:7
D757@F
D;E7
;@
8D7CG7@5K
E;L7
3@6
E7H7D;FK
A8
F:7
EF3F7UE
I;>68;D7E
53@
47
3FFD;4GF76
@AF
A@>K
FA
9>A43>
5>;?3F7
5:3@97
97@7D3>>K
4GF
3>EA
FA
G@GEG3>
6DAG9:F
3@6
:73F
7J357D43F76
4K
5>;?3F7
5:3@97
AH7D9DAI@
8AD7EFE
53GE76
4K
675367E
A8
EG557EE8G>
8;D7
EGBBD7EE;A@
3@6
D3B;6
BABG>3F;A@
9DAIF:
3>A@9
F:7
7697E
A8
8AD7EFE
355AD6;@9
FA
+)

7A>A9;53>
)GDH7K
E5;7@F;EF
A@
!77>7K




0A>ABJA

(
#
(-

+
"#/

4?<9BEA<4
8C4EG@8AG
B9
!BE8FGEL
4A7
!<E8
+EBG86G<BA

;GGCF

JJJ 9<E8 64 :BI
<A6<78AGF


4F
B9
%4A



 



0A>ABJA
)*

+!,-

&# )+(#
#&
#+,

4?<9BEA<4
8C4EG@8AG
B9
!BE8FGEL
4A7
!<E8

+EBG86G<BA
;GGCF

JJJ 9<E8 64 :BI
@87<4
=4A7?;;
GBC

346E8F C79
4F
B9
%4A



 
0A>ABJA
)*

+!,-

&# )+(#
#&
#+,

4?<9BEA<4
8C4EG@8AG
B9
!BE8FGEL
4A7

!<E8
+EBG86G<BA
;GGCF

JJJ 9<E8 64 :BI
@87<4
G
E7;<ME
GBC

378FGEH6G<BA C79
4F
B9

%4A



 


0A>ABJA
"-3,

"#(


&# )+(#3,
.+!
)
+!
#+,
.8CG




)
.

4EG;

*5F8EI4GBEL

;GGCF

84EG;B5F8EI4GBEL A4F4 :BI
<@4:8F



J;4GF58;<A7
64?<9BEA<4FFHE:8B9?4E:89<E8F
4F
B9
%4A




6<G<A:
)*

+!,-

&# )+(#
#&
#+,

4?<9BEA<4
8C4EG@8AG
B9
!BE8FGEL
4A7
!<E8
+EBG86G<BA

;GGCF

JJJ 9<E8 64 :BI
@87<4
=4A7?;;
GBC

346E8F C79



66BE7<A:
GB
&88?8L
846;
B9
G;8
?4FG
G;E88
786478F
;4F
;47
FH5FG4AG<4??L
JBEF8
7EBH:;G
G;4A
4AL
786478
BI8E
G;8
?4FG



L84EF
EBH:;G
8K468E54G8F
9<E8F
5L
F4CC<A:
GE88F
4A7
C?4AGF
B9
@B<FGHE8
4A7
@4><A:
G;8@
84F<8E
GB
5HEA
J;<6;
<A
GHEA
477F
@BE8
5<B@4FF
< 8 
9H8?
GB
G;8
?4A7F64C8
4A7
<A6E84F8F
4
J<?79<E8SF
<AG8AF<GL
0A>ABJA
"-3,
"#(

&# )+(#3,
.+!
)
+!
#+,
.8CG




)
.

4EG;
*5F8EI4GBEL

;GGCF

84EG;B5F8EI4GBEL A4F4 :BI
<@4:8F



J;4GF58;<A764?<9BEA<4FFHE:8B9
?4E:89<E8F
4F
B9
%4A



 

229

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










AI
3@6
I:7D7
67H7>AB?7@FE
3D7
4G;>F
?3FF7DE
55AD6;@9
FA
+@;H7DE;FK
A8
A>AD36A
8;D7
75A>A9;EF
3@6
8AD?7D
7F
&DABG>E;A@
"34AD3FADK
D7E73D5:7D
$3F3E:3
)F3HDAE
R1F2:7
;@F7@E;FK
A8
F:7E7
7JFD7?7
8;D7E
5A?4;@76
I;F:
F:7
8D7CG7@5K
3@6
F:7
BDAJ;?;FK
FA
B7AB>7S
;E
7JFD7?7>K
IADDK;@9
%@7
A8
F:7
47EF
I3KE
FA
8;9:F
57DF3;@
I;>68;D7E
;E
FA
7@EGD7
@7I
5A??G@;F;7E
3D7
@AF
47;@9
4G;>F
;@
8;D7BDA@7
3D73E
AD
F:AE7
BDA<75FE

F:3F
3D7
BDABAE76
;@
8;D7BDA@7
3D73E
F:AG9:
F:7D7
3D7
3
@G?47D
A8
47EF
BD35F;57E
FA
34;67
4K
3@6
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
FA
;@5ADBAD3F7

%@
%5FA47D




3>;8AD@;3
FFAD@7K

7@7D3>
(A4
A@F3

;EEG76
F:7

$23

1 "3("$2
%.1
- +89(-&
-#
(3(& 3(-&
(+#%(1$
,/ "32
.%
$5$+./,$-3
1.)$"32

-#$1
3'$

+(%.1-(

-5(1.-,$-3 +
4 +(38
"3
R2@A
#?.0A602@SQ9G;63@57
I;F:
47EF
BD35F;57E
3@6
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
8AD
>736
397@5;7E
>A53>
9AH7D@?7@FE
3@6
67H7>AB7DE
FA
5A@E;67D
I:7@
D7H;7I;@9
AD
BDABAE;@9
BDA<75FE
;@
I;>68;D7BDA@7
7@H;DA@?7@FE
;@
AD67D
FA
5A?B>K
I;F:
'
$$ E56/6A

1

7EF
&D35F;57E2

E
BD7H;AGE>K
@AF76
4AF:
F:7
3>;8AD@;3

AH7D@?7@F
A67
8AD
A>A53F;A@

35;>;F;7E

3@6
3>EA
'
D7CG;D7
>A53>
<GD;E6;5F;A@E
5A@E;67D;@9
67H7>AB?7@F
BDA<75FE
FA
BD7B3D7
3@
(
AD
#$
;8
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
?3K
BAF7@F;3>>K
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@6
;E
@AF
AF:7DI;E7
7J7?BF
8DA?
'
5A?B>;3@57
'UE
5D;F;53>
BDA57EE
8AD
>736
397@5;7E
FA
5A?BD7:7@6
F:7
?75:3@;E?E
F:DAG9:
I:;5:
BDABAE76
67H7>AB?7@FE
I;>>
7J357D43F7
7J;EF;@9
I;>68;D7
D;E=E
3>>AIE
F:AE7
397@5;7E
FA
5A@E;67D
BDA<75F
67E;9@
873FGD7E
3>F7D@3F;H7E
3@6
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
F:3F
7@EGD7
7J;EF;@9Q3@6
@7IQ5A??G@;F;7E
3D7
BDAF75F76

*:7
'

G;67>;@7E
?3@63F7
F:3F
F:7
(
AD
#$
BDAH;67
3
43E7>;@7
A8
7J;EF;@9
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@6;F;A@EQ;@
AF:7D
IAD6E
3
67E5D;BF;A@
A8
F:7
B:KE;53>
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@6;F;A@E
;@
F:7
H;5;@;FK
A8
F:7
BDABAE76
BDA<75FQ3F
F:7
F;?7
F:7
$AF;57
A8
&D7B3D3F;A@
R!"#S
;E
BG4>;E:76
AD
AF:7DI;E7
3F
F:7
F;?7
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
3@3>KE;E
;E
BG4>;E:76
$$
'

G;67>;@7E
M




EG46
3



*:7


36H;E7E
F:3F
>736
397@5;7E
GF;>;L7
F:;E
BA;@F
;@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
BDA57EE
FA
;@5>G67
3@
3@3>KE;E
A8
AB7@
EB357
3D73E
3@6
:34;F3FE
I;F:;@
3@6
3DAG@6
F:7
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
F:3F
?3K
47
BDA@7
FA
I;>68;D7E
F:7
3D73UE
I;>68;D7
:;EFADK
F:7
CG3>;FK
3@6
CG3@F;FK
A8
8G7>E
A@
AD
@73D
F:7
BDA<75F
E;F7
3@6
A8
7J;EF;@9
3@6
3H3;>34>7
I3F7D

0A>ABJA


.&-#
#'(,#)(&
#+

"&&(!
.8CG




)
.

4EG;
*5F8EI4GBEL

;GGCF

84EG;B5F8EI4GBEL A4F4 :BI
<@4:8F



4@H?G<7<@8AF<BA4?9<E86;4??8A:8

4F
B9
%4A



 

230

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









EGBB>;7E
8AD
8;D78;9:F;@9
788ADFE
K
;@5>G6;@9
57DF3;@
67F3;>E
34AGF
F:7
7J;EF;@9
5A@6;F;A@E
3F
3@6
3DAG@6
F:7
BDA<75F
E;F7
F:3F
?3K
7J357D43F7
AD
?;@;?;L7
I;>68;D7
;?B35FE
F:7
>736
397@5K
7@EGD7E
F:3F
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
3@3>KE;E
5A@E;67DE
F:7
8G>>
E5AB7
A8
F:7
BDA<75FUE
;?B35FE

@5>G676
;@
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@F
F:3F
BDABAE76
BDA<75FE
47
355A?B3@;76
4K
3@
3@3>KE;E
A8

3@K
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875FE
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
?3K
53GE7
AD
7J357D43F7
4K
47;@9
67H7>AB76
;@
AD
4D;@9;@9
B7AB>7
;@FA
3
9;H7@
3D73
;E
3
EFG6K
A8
F:7
BAF7@F;3>
78875FE
A8
>A53F;@9
67H7>AB?7@F
;@
I;>68;D7
D;E=
3D73E
$$
'
G;67>;@7E

M





BB7@6;J


)75F;A@
..
A8
F:7
'

G;67>;@7E
36H;E7E
>736
397@5;7E

FA
67F7D?;@7
I:7F:7D
BDA<75FE
>A53F76
;@
AD
@73D
EF3F7
D7EBA@E;4;>;FK
3D73E
AD
>3@6E
5>3EE;8;76
3E
H7DK
:;9:
8;D7
:3L3D6
E7H7D;FK
LA@7E
4K
F:7
3>;8AD@;3
7B3DF?7@F
A8

AD7EFDK
3@6

;D7
&DAF75F;A@
R

%S
IAG>6

3 )G4EF3@F;3>>K
;?B3;D
3@
36ABF76
7?7D97@5K
D7EBA@E7
B>3@
AD
7?7D97@5K
7H35G3F;A@

4 G7
FA
E>AB7
BD7H3;>;@9
I;@6E
3@6
AF:7D
835FADE
7J357D43F7
I;>68;D7
D;E=E
3@6
F:7D74K
7JBAE7
BDA<75F
A55GB3@FE
FA
BA>>GF3@F
5A@57@FD3F;A@E
8DA?
3
I;>68;D7
AD
F:7
G@5A@FDA>>76
EBD736
A8
3
I;>68;D7
5 (7CG;D7
F:7
;@EF3>>3F;A@
AD
?3;@F7@3@57
A8
3EEA5;3F76
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
EG5:
3E
DA36E
8G7>
4D73=E
7?7D97@5K
I3F7D
EAGD57E
BAI7D
>;@7E
AD
AF:7D
GF;>;F;7E
F:3F
?3K
7J357D43F7
8;D7
D;E=
AD
F:3F
?3K
D7EG>F
;@
F7?BAD3DK
AD
A@9A;@9
;?B35FE
FA
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
AD

6 JBAE7
B7AB>7
AD
EFDG5FGD7E
FA
E;9@;8;53@F
D;E=E
;@5>G6;@9
6AI@E>AB7
AD
6AI@EFD73?
8>AA6;@9
AD
>3@6E>;67E
3E
3
D7EG>F
A8
DG@A88
BAEF8;D7
E>AB7
;@EF34;>;FK
AD
6D3;@397
5:3@97E

!(#

)75F;A@
.
EG4E75F;A@
9
6;D75FE
>736
397@5;7E
FA
3>EA
5A@E;67D
I:7F:7D
3
BDA<75FQ 7;F:7D
A@E;F7
AD
A88E;F7QI;>>
R7JBAE7
B7AB>7
AD
EFDG5FGD7E
7;F:7D
6;D75F>K
AD
;@6;D75F>K
FA
3
E;9@;8;53@F
D;E=
A8
>AEE
;@<GDK
AD
673F:
;@HA>H;@9
I;>6>3@6
8;D7ES
$$
'

G;67>;@7E
M




1678;@;@9
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
FA
47
5A@E;67D76
3E
RF:7
3D73
;@
I:;5:
E;9@;8;53@F
78875FE
IAG>6
A55GD
7;F:7D
6;D75F>K
AD
;@6;D75F>K
3E
3
D7EG>F
A8
F:7
BDA<75FS2
55AD6;@9
FA
F:7


>736
397@5;7E
E:AG>6
5A@E;67D
F:D77
BD;?3DK
H3D;34>7E
;@
F:7
5A@F7JF
A8
I;>68;D7
;?B35FE
F:AG9:
3@K
F:ADAG9:
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
I;>>
5A@F3;@
231

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









366;F;A@3>
5A@E;67D3F;A@E
;@
;FE
67F7D?;@3F;A@
A8
I:7F:7D
3@6
:AI
3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
?3K
7J357D43F7
I;>68;D7
D;E=E
*:7E7
H3D;34>7E
;@5>G67
BDA<75F
67@E;FK
>A53F;A@
3@6
>3@6E53B7
3@6
I3F7D
EGBB>K
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7


3 &DA<75F
7@E;FK


BDA<75FUE
67@E;FK
;@8>G7@57E
:AI
>;=7>K
3
8;D7
;E
FA
EF3DF
AD
EBD736
3@6
:AI
>;=7>K
;F
;E
F:3F
F:7
67H7>AB?7@F
3@6
;FE
A55GB3@FE
I;>>
47
;@
63@97D
E:AG>6
3
8;D7
EF3DF
7EF
&D35F;57E
B

55AD6;@9
FA
A@E7DH3F;A@
;A>A9K
@EF;FGF7
D7E73D5:
E5;7@F;EF
>7J3@6D3

)KB:3D6
&:
8;D7
EBD736
3@6
EFDG5FGD7
>AEE
3D7
?AD7
>;=7>K
FA
A55GD
;@
>AI
FA
;@F7D?76;3F767@E;FK
67H7>AB?7@FE
9;H7@
F:3F
F:7K
3D7
A8F7@
;@EG88;5;7@F>K
5A@57@FD3F76
FA
6;EDGBF
8;D7
EBD736
4K
D7?AH;@9
AD
EG4EF3@F;3>>K
8D39?7@F;@9
I;>6>3@6
H797F3F;A@
66;F;A@3>>K
355AD6;@9
FA
+@;H7DE;FK
A8
3>;8AD@;3
I;>6>;87
EB75;3>;EF
#3J

#AD;FL
F:7E7
R;EA>3F76
5>GEF7DE
A8
67H7>AB?7@F
3@6
>AI
:AGE;@9
67@E;FK
?73@
F:3F
:A?7E
3D7
7?476676
I;F:;@
3@6
?AD7
7JBAE76
FA
3
?3FD;J
A8
I;>6>3@6
H797F3F;A@12S
I:;5:
3>EA
53GE7E
3557EE;4;>;FK
;EEG7E
8AD
8;D78;9:F7DE

4 &DA<75F
"A53F;A@
;@
"3@6E53B7

AI
3
67H7>AB?7@F
BDA<75F
;E
B>3@@76
I;F:;@
3
9;H7@
>3@6E53B7
67F7D?;@7E
F:7
?39@;FG67
4K
I:;5:
;F
I;>>
;@8>G7@57
8;D7
D;E=

-;>68;D7
D;E=
;E
3>EA
;@8>G7@576
4K

.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
"
&-#/
( &.(

)

&#'-
(

).,#(!

/&)*'(-
)(

.++(-
(


+)$
-

.-.+
#+
--+(,
(

-+.
-.+
),,

+),,
"+

&# )+(#
(
,
*,



"?B54?

AI<EBA@8AG4?

;4A:8
.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
8G
4? 
).,#(!

++(!'(-
(

)
-#)(

-+'#(
-"
#%&#"))

)
).,#(!
),,

.
-)
#&
#+
(4E




+'*.
*)

;GGCF

=BHEA4?F C?BF BE:

C?BFBA8
4EG<6?8<7



=BHEA4? CBA8


4F
B9
%4A



 
F88
:8A8E4??L
.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
.&-#*&
&
&-#)(,"#*,

-0(
!--#)(

-"
#&
&(
+
(
(-+ 

(

-+.
-.+
),,
-)
#&
#+
#(

&# )+(#
(4E




(+$

!<E8




(BE<GM
(4K


8G
4? 
+(#(!
-)

)1#,-
0#-"
#&
#+



)4GHE8
1B?


$FFH8


4G

C

F88
4?FB
.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
.&-#*&
&
&-#)(,"#*,

-0(
!--#)(
-"

#&
&(
+
(
(-+ 

(

-+.
-.+
),,
-)
#&
#+
#(

&# )+(#
(4E




(+$
!<E8





.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
"2

+
)
(2
-+.
-.+,

.+(#(!
#(

&# )+(#



!E8@BAG<4

1B?

$FFH8


4G
C


(+$
!<E8

;GGCF

CH5F 8E HF:F :BI
CH5?<64G<BA




4F
B9
%4A



 




!(+&&2
(BE<GM
(4K
8G
4? 

.#&
#(!
-)

)1#,-
0#-"
#+

)''.(#-2
#,%

.
-#)(
,.+,

)+
0

/&)*'(-
#(

&# )+(#

CE


0A<I8EF<GL
B9

4?<9BEA<4

:E<6H?GHE8
4A7
)4GHE4?

-8FBHE68F
+H5?<64G<BA


;GGCF

8F6;B?4EF;<C BE:

H6
<G8@
A

@CA
.LC;4E7

?8K4A7E4
 
"2

+
)
(2
-+.
-.+,

.+(#(!
#(

&# )+(#



!E8@BAG<4
IB?


<FFH8


CC


(+$
!<E8

;GGCF

CH5F 8E HF:F :BI
CH5?<64G<BA




4F

B9
%4A



 

232

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









BDA<75F
B>357?7@F
;@
F:7
>3@6E53B7
D7>3F;H7
FA
F:3F
>A53F;A@UE
8;D7
:;EFADK
FABA9D3B:K
F:7
3?AG@F
A8
4;A8G7>
BD7E7@F
5>;?3F;5
5A@6;F;A@E
3@6
8;D7
I73F:7D
EG5:
3E
>AI
:G?;6;FK
3@6
:;9:
I;@6E
7EF
&D35F;57E
B


AD
7J3?B>7
I;>68;D7
D;E=
?3K
47

7J357D43F76
4K
>A53F;@9
3
67H7>AB?7@F
;@
3
I;@6
5ADD;6AD
;@
DG9976
F7DD3;@
AD
3FAB
EF77B
:;>>E
!(#
%@
F:7
AF:7D
:3@6
;@5ADBAD3F;@9
;@FA
F:7
67H7>AB?7@F
AD
EFD3F79;53>>K
>A53F;@9
;F
3?A@9
57DF3;@
>3@6E53B7
873FGD7E
EG5:
3E
3
>3=7
;DD;93F76
9A>8
5AGDE7
AD
AF:7D
4G887D
LA@7
5AG>6
5GD4
I;>68;D7
D;E=
*:7
A@E7DH3F;A@
;A>A9K
@EF;FGF7
;@
;FE
&3D36;E7
$3FGD73E76

;D7
(7E;>;7@57
(7BADF
A887D76
3
E5;7@F;8;5

<GEF;8;53F;A@
8AD
3
R6787@E;4>7
EB357S
LA@7
;7
-;>68;D7
(;E=
(76G5F;A@
G887DE
*%%@
3DAG@6
3
5A??G@;FK
FA
D76G57
57DF3;@
;?B35FE
3@6
5;F76
FA
57DF3;@
);7DD3
$7H363
8AAF:;>>
:A?7EU
E;F;@9
3@6
9D77@47>FE
3E
:3H;@9
A887D76
8;D7
BDAF75F;A@
6GD;@9
F:7
3?B

;D7
A8


5 -3F7D
)GBB>K
@8D3EFDG5FGD7

B3DF
8DA?
3@3>KL;@9
BDA<75F
67@E;FK
3@6
>A53F;A@
3
BDA<75FUE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
3@3>KE;E
E:AG>6
3>EA
;@5>G67
3
67F7D?;@3F;A@
A8
I:7F:7D
F:7
I3F7D
EGBB>;7E
3@6
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
;@
3
9;H7@
3D73
3D7
EG88;5;7@F
FA
366D7EE
8;D78;9:F;@9
788ADFE 6 %F:7D
A@E;67D3F;A@E

;D7
?A67>;@9
3@6
AF:7D
EB3F;3>
3@6
EF3F;EF;53>
3@3>KE7E
3D7
;?B7D3F;H7
;@
CG3@F;8K;@9
I;>68;D7
D;E=E
D7EG>F;@9
8DA?
3
67H7>AB?7@F
F:3F
366E
?AD7
B7AB>7
FA
I;>68;D7
BDA@7
3D73E
7EF
&D35F;57E
B

55AD6;@9
FA
F:7


7JB7DF
3@3>KEFE
E:AG>6
7?B>AK
8;D7



(BE<GM
(4K
8G
4? 

.#&
#(!
-)

)1#,-
0#-"
#+

)''.(#-2
#,%

.
-#)(
,.+,
)+
0

/&)*'(-
#(

&# )+(#

CE


0A<I8EF<GL
B9

4?<9BEA<4

:E<6H?GHE8
4A7
)4GHE4?

-8FBHE68F
+H5?<64G<BA


;GGCF

8F6;B?4EF;<C BE:

H6
<G8@
A

@CA 

/;8

BAF8EI4G<BA

<B?B:L
$AFG<GHG8
789<A87
2--
F
4F
MBA8F
6B@CE<F87
B9
:E88A
?4A7
HF8F

4 > 4 
:E88A58?GF
B9
C4E>?4A7
BE6;4E7F
4A7
BG;8E
?BJ
<:A<G<BAE<F>
?4A7
HF8F
6B@5<A87
J<G;
J<?7?4A7
CEBC8EG<8F
@4A4:87
9BE
9<E8
E<F>
E87H6G<BA

+
#,
-.+
,

#+
,#&#(

+)$
-
#(&
*)+-
%HA8



BAF8EI4G<BA

<B?B:L

$AFG<GHG8

;GGCF

7 >5>>7;5CE 6?BH79EBAG A8G
@87<4
E8CBEGF
9<?8F

$3+4E47<F83!<A4?3-8CBE
G39BE3+BFG<A:3*A?<A8 C79 


(BE<GM
(4K
8G
4? 

.#&
#(!
-)

)1#,-
0#-"
#+

)''.(#-2
#,%

.
-#)(
,.+,
)+
0

/&)*'(-
#(

&# )+(#

CE


0A<I8EF<GL
B9

4?<9BEA<4

:E<6H?GHE8
4A7
)4GHE4?

-8FBHE68F
+H5?<64G<BA


C


4A7
4CC8A



;GGCF

8F6;B?4EF;<C BE:

H6
<G8@
A

@CA 

233

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









?A67>E
FA
355AG@F
8AD
735:
BDA<75FUE
@G3@57E
;@
F7D?E
A8
E;F;@9
;7
FABA9D3B:K
3@6
67E;9@
7>7?7@FE
3@6
FA
355AG@F
8AD
3@
3DD3K
A8
8;D7
E57@3D;AE
;@5>G6;@9
F:AE7
8;D7E
• 9@;F76
4K
>;9:F7@;@9
AD
AF:7D
35F
A8

A6

• 9@;F76
4K
6;887D7@F
5>;?3F;5
5A@6;F;A@E

• 9@;F76
4K
G@@3FGD3>
?73@E
355;67@F
3@6
3DEA@

• %D;9;@3F;@9
8DA?
7H7DK
5A@57;H34>7
6;D75F;A@

• %D;9;@3F;@9
I;F:;@
F:7
BDA<75F
E;F7


• %D;9;@3F;@9
@73D
3@6
83D
8DA?
F:7
BDA<75F
E;F7

• )BD736
I;F:
3@6
I;F:AGF
-((E


• )BD736
I;F:
3@
3DD3K
A8
6;887D7@F
-((
FKB7E
3@6
>A53F;A@E
3@6 • J357D43F76
4K
7JFD7?7
I73F:7D
5A@6;F;A@E

*:;E
>;EF
;E
;>>GEFD3F;H7
3@6
@A@7J:3GEF;H7
3@6
E:AG>6
;@5>G67
366;F;A@3>
5:3D35F7D;EF;5E
3@6
63F3
BA;@FE
3E
>736
397@5;7E
3@6
7JB7DF
3@3>KEFE
677?
3BBDABD;3F7
3@6
@757EE3DK
EG5:
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75FUE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
;E
F:ADAG9:
I7>>D73EA@76
3@6
43E76
A@
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57

@
366;F;A@
FA
?A67>;@9
H3D;AGE
E57@3D;AE
FA
CG3@F;8K
D;E=E
F:7

@AI
7@5AGD397E

>736
397@5;7E
FA
67H7>AB
57DF3;@
F:D7E:A>6E
A8
E;9@;8;53@57
F:3F
;67@F;8K
F:7
;@5D73E7
;@
I;>68;D7
D;E=
EG88;5;7@F
FA
5A@EF;FGF7
F:7
;?B35F
3E
3
E;9@;8;53@F
AD
FA
67F7D?;@7
43E76
A@
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
3F
I:3F
F:D7E:A>6
3@
;@5D73E7
;@
I;>68;D7
D;E=
;E
@AF
5A@E;67D76
3
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35F
BBDABD;3F7
835FADE
FA
5A@E;67D
;@
F:;E
3@3>KE;E
;@5>G67
3?A@9
AF:7DE
F:7
BDA<75FUE
;?B35F
A@
;9@;F;A@
D;E=
F:7
>;=7>;:AA6
A8
8;D7
EBD736
3@6
F:7
7JF7@F
A8
7JBAEGD7
8AD
7J;EF;@9
3@6
@7I
D7E;67@FE
43E76
A@
H3D;AGE
8;D7
E57@3D;AE
7 *:7
&DA<75FUE

;D7

3L3D6E
?B35FE

7D7
F:7
&DA<75F
;E
>A53F76
3F


7>
;AE
;@
3@
3D73
F:3F
:3E
477@
67E;9@3F76
4K

F:7
3>;8AD@;3
7B3DF?7@F
A8

AD7EFDK
3@6

;D7
&DAF75F;A@UE
(1$
-#
$2.41"$

22$22,$-3
1.&1 ,
3E
3
R,7DK

;9:

;D7

3L3D6
)7H7D;FK
0A@7S
)

&-QF:7

:;9:7EF
A8
F:7
F:D77
>7H7>E
A8
:3L3D6
;@
F:7
"A53>
(7EBA@E;4;>;FK
D73E
%
$$ 

A
'-

<F
4A
<A6BECBE4G87
6<GL
HE54A
E8:<BA
4:E<6H?GHE8
?4A7
BE
CBEG<BA
B9
G;8
78F8EG
J;8E8
G;8
?B64?
:BI8EA@8AG
<F
E8FCBAF<5?8
9BE
J<?79<E8
CEBG86G<BA
234

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









#3B
A8
"

(UE
,7DK

;9:

;D7

3L3D6
)7H7D;FK
0A@7E
;@
"(
P
%D3@97

E56/6A


1)3@
>7?7@F7
,7DK

;9:
)7H7D;FK
0A@7E
#3B2
2$$
+2.

AH
A67
MM




"".1#
&G4
(7E
A67
M



*:7E7
?3BE
7H3>G3F7
:3L3D6
@AF
D;E=
3@6

F:GE
366D7EE
3
>A53F;A@UE
B:KE;53>
5A@6;F;A@E
F:3F
5A@FD;4GF7
FA
3
>;=7>;:AA6
3@6
7JB75F3F;A@
A8
8;D7
47:3H;AD
AH7D
3
57DF3;@
B7D;A6
$AF34>K
F:7E7
?3BE
6A
@AF
?73EGD7
?;F;93F;A@Q3E
EG5:
;F
;E
F:7
D7EBA@E;4;>;FK
A8
;@
F:;E
53E7
F:7
;FK
3@6 AD
AG@FK
FA
?3@63F7
F:7
;?B>7?7@F3F;A@
A8
?73EGD7E
FA
7@EGD7
F:3F
F:7
>;=7>;:AA6
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
5A@FD;4GF;@9
FA
8;D7
:3L3D6E
D7?3;@E
>AI
A@E7CG7@F>K
3@K
67H7>AB?7@F
AD
?A6;8;53F;A@
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
);F7
?GEF
47
355A?B3@;76
4K
3
F:ADAG9:
3@3>KE;E
A8
F:7
&DA<75FUE
BAF7@F;3>
8;D7
:3L3D6E
;?B35FE
E
;F
EF3@6E
@AI
3@6
43E76
A@
F:7
;@8AD?3F;A@
3H3;>34>7
F:7
&DA<75FUE
8;D7
:3L3D6E
;?B35FE
:3H7
@AF
477@
3@3>KL76

 *:7
&DA<75F
#3K
A@FD;4GF7
FA
G?G>3F;H7
?B35FE

-:;>7
F:7
"AE
@97>7E
AG@FK
D38F


>;?3F7
5F;A@
&>3@



#
;E
@AF

AB7D3F;H7
;@
F:7
%D39@7
AG@FK
;F
;E
;@8AD?3F;H7
A@E;67D;@9
F:7


&
3E
EG5:

;F
;E
IADF:
@AF;@9
;FE
35=@AI>7697?7@F
F:3F
F:7
D7>A53F;A@
3@6
5A@EFDG5F;A@
A8
@7I
EFDG5FGD7E
3EEA5;3F76
I;F:
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@
67H;57
BDA<75FE
?3K
:3H7
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
55AD6;@9
FA
F:7


&
(

GFGD7
GF;>;FK9D367
EA>3D
3@6
7>75FD;53>
FD3@E?;EE;A@
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
BDA<75FE
F:3F
5AG>6
47
835;>;F3F76
4K
F:7
D38F


&
?73EGD7E
3@6

35F;A@E
?3K
3>EA
38875F
5A??G@;53F;A@
E;9@3>E
6G7
FA
#
;@
FIA
I3KE


EA>3D
B3@7>E
3@6
F:7;D
3EEA5;3F76
FD3@E?;EE;A@
>;@7E
?3K
97@7D3F7
7>75FDA?39@7F;5
@A;E7
I:;5:
5AG>6
;@F7D87D7
I;F:
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
E7DH;57E
EG5:
3E
D363D
?;5DAI3H7
F7>7H;E;A@
3@6
D36;A
FD3@E?;EE;A@E
AD
?AD7
5A??A@>K


EA>3D
B3@7>E
IAG>6
5D73F7

B:KE;53>
A4EFDG5F;A@E
F:3F
6;EFADF
5A??G@;53F;A@E
E;9@3>E
*:7
FKB7E
A8
5A??G@;53F;A@E
EKEF7?E
F:3F
?3K
47
38875F76
;@5>G67
?;5DAI3H7
EKEF7?E
A883;D
F7>7H;E;A@
4DA3653EF
E;9@3>E
>3@6
?A4;>7
D36;A
AB7D3F;A@E
3@6
?A4;>7
F7>7B:A@7
E7DH;57E







&DA<75FE
835;>;F3F76
4K
F:7
D38F


&
IAG>6
53GE7
AD
5A@FD;4GF7
3

5G?G>3F;H7>K
5A@E;67D34>7
5A@FD;4GF;A@
FA
3
E;9@;8;53@F
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35F
D7>3F76
FA
F:7
D7>A53F;A@
AD
5A@EFDG5F;A@
A8
@7I
AD
7JB3@676
I3F7D
I3EF7I3F7D
FD73F?7@F
EFAD?I3F7D
6D3;@397
7>75FD;5
BAI7D
@3FGD3>
93E
AD
235

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









F7>75A??G@;53F;A@
835;>;F;7E
F:7
5A@EFDG5F;A@
AD
D7>A53F;A@
A8
I:;5:
5AG>6
53GE7
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875FE
?B>7?7@F3F;A@
A8
F:7
;67@F;8;76
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
IAG>6
D76G57
D7>3F76
;?B35FE
4GF
@AF
FA
3
>7EEF:3@E;9@;8;53@F
>7H7>






*7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
;@5>G67E
E?3>>
57>>
835;>;F;7E
3@6
?35DA
FAI7DE
)?3>>
57>>
835;>;F;7E
3D7
>A53F76
A@
7J;EF;@9
AD
BDABAE76
H7DF;53>
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
EG5:
3E
EFD77F>;9:FE
GF;>;FK
BA>7E
3@6
FD388;5
E;9@3>
BA>7E
;@
F:7
BG4>;5
D;9:FA8I3K
#35DA
FAI7DE
3D7
>3D97
;@67B7@67@F
EFDG5FGD7E
I;F:
F:7
E;@9>7
BGDBAE7
A8
EGBBADF;@9
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
*:7E7
F7@6
FA
47
>3D97
?A@AFAI7DE
F:3F
3D7
7;F:7D
;@
F:7
BG4>;5
D;9:FA8I3K
AD
3D7
A@
BD;H3F7
AD
BG4>;5
BDAB7DFK
$G?7DAGE
F7>75A??G@;53F;A@E
BDAH;67DE
AB7D3F7
I;F:;@
"AE
@97>7E
AG@FK
3@6
7;F:7D
E:3D7
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
AD
AI@
F:7;D
AI@
835;>;F;7E
FA
BDAH;67
57>>G>3D
E7DH;57
AG@FKI;67




&
(
?B35FE















E
EG5:
3
F:ADAG9:
&DA<75FEB75;8;5
(
?GEF
47
BD7B3D76
478AD7
F:7
&DA<75F
;@
;FE
7@F;D7FK
?3K
47
3BBDAH76


GDF:7D
EG5:
(
?GEF
EFG6K
F:7
;?B35FE
A8
3>>
F:7

3BBDAH3>E
3@6
IAD=
B7D?;FE
9D3@F76
FA
63F7
8AD
F:7
&DA<75F
3E
I7>>
3E
F:7
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35F
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
3>A@9
I;F:
D7>3F76
E;?;>3D
BDA<75FE
*A
;9@AD7
F:7E7
?3@63F7E
G@67D5GFE
F:7
"79;E>3FGD7UE
BDA?G>93F;A@
3@6
5AGDFEU
7JB3@E;A@
A8
3@6
D73EA@;@9
8AD
'

 *:7
&DA<75F
E
?BDAB7D>K
&;757?73>76
;@
,;A>3F;A@
A8
'
'
8AD4;6E
RB;757?73>S
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
A8
3
BDA<75F
3@6
?3@63F7E
F:3F
RF:7
>736
397@5K
?GEF
5A@E;67D
F:7
I:A>7
A8
3@
35F;A@
@AF
E;?B>K
;FE
5A@EF;FG7@F
B3DFE
I:7@
67F7D?;@;@9
I:7F:7D
;F
I;>>
:3H7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875FS
'

G;67>;@7E
MM




EG46
:



EG46
3
E77

(&'3'.42$
($+#

$ "'
$2"4$
5

(38
.%
 -3

149




3>BBF:






R*:7
BDA:;4;F;A@
393;@EF
B;757?73>
D7H;7I
;E
F:7
8>;B
E;67
A8
F:7
D7CG;D7?7@F
F:3F
F:7
I:A>7
A8
3
BDA<75F
47
D7H;7I76
G@67D
'
)77

G;67>;@7E
M



EG46
3S

(3F:7D
'
?3@63F7E
TF:3F
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@E;67D3F;A@E
6A
@AF
475A?7
EG4?7D976
4K
5:ABB;@9
3
>3D97
BDA<75F
;@FA
?3@K
>;FF>7
A@7EQ735:
I;F:
3
?;@;?3>
BAF7@F;3>
;?B35F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@FQI:;5:
5G?G>3F;H7>K
?3K
:3H7
6;E3EFDAGE
236

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










5A@E7CG7@57E
"
--
5

(38
.%
 -

($&.





3>BBF:


;@F7D@3>
5;F3F;A@

3@6
CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76
;887D7@F
BDA<75FE
R?3K
BDAB7D>K
G@67D9A
E7B3D3F7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
;7
@A
B;757?73>;@9
I:7@
F:7
BDA<75FE



53@
47
;?B>7?7@F76
;@67B7@67@F>KS
!(#
3F
B

CGAF;@9

--(-&
 -"'

.-2$15 -"8
5

(38
.%

$6/.13

$ "'




3>BBF:


66;F;A@3>>K
F:7
CG7EF;A@
A8
I:7F:7D
3@6

I:;5:
35F;A@E
5A@EF;FGF7
F:7
TI:A>7
A8
3@
35F;A@U
8AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
'
;E
A@7
A8
>3I
I:;5:
F:7
5AGDFE
D7H;7I
67
@AHA
43E76
A@
F:7
G@6;EBGF76
835FE
;@
F:7
D75AD6S

.,,4-(3($2
%.1


$33$1

-5(1.-,$-3
5

(38
.%
("',.-#





3>BBF:




*:7
3>;8AD@;3
)GBD7?7
AGDF
:3E
5A@5>G676
F:3F
FA
3HA;6
B;757?73>;@9
3@
397@5KUE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
A8
3
BDA<75F
G@67D
'
?GEF
366D7EE
3>>
3EB75FE
A8
3
BDA<75F
F:3F
3D7
3
RD73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>7
5A@E7CG7@57S
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
3@6
IAG>6
47
RE;9@;8;53@FS
EG5:
F:3F
R;F
I;>>
>;=7>K
5:3@97
F:7
E5AB7
AD
@3FGD7
A8
F:7
;@;F;3>
BDA<75F
AD
;FE
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
78875FES
 41$+
$(&'32
,/1.5$,$-3
22."( 3(.-
5
$&$-32
.%
3'$
-(5$12(38

.%

+(%.1-(



3>
6





GDF:7D?AD7
EA?7
5AGDFE
:3H7
5A@5>G676
F:3F

3
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
;E
B3DF
A8
3
>3D97D
BDA<75F
8AD
'
BGDBAE7E
;8
F:7
BDABAE76
BDA<75F
;E
3
R5DG5;3>
8G@5F;A@3>
7>7?7@F
A8
F:7
>3D97D
BDA<75F
EG5:
F:3F
I;F:AGF
;F
F:7
>3D97D
BDA<75F
5AG>6
@AF
BDA5776S

.,,4-(3($2
%.1


$33$1

-5(1.-,$-3
5

(38
.%
("',.-#





3>BBF:



'UE
B;757?73>;@9
BDA:;4;F;A@
EF7?E
8DA?
FIA
EAGD57EQ3
BG4>;5
397@5KUE
6GFK
FA
678;@7
F:7
BDA<75F
47;@9
7H3>G3F76
4K
F:7
I:A>7
A8
3@
35F;A@
3@6
;FE
6GFK
FA
5A@E;67D
F:7
78875FE
4AF:
;@6;H;6G3>
3@6
5A>>75F;H7
A8
3>>
35F;H;F;7E
;@HA>H76
;@
F:7
BDA<75F
&G4
(7E
A67
M



EG46
6
'

G;67>;@7E
M



EG46E
3
5
#AD7AH7D

'UE
B;757?73>;@9
BDA:;4;F;A@
EF7?E
8DA?
;FE
D7CG;D7?7@F
FA
5A@E;67D
F:7
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
3>>
B:3E76
AD
?G>F;B>7
BDA<75FE
I:;5:
3D7
B3DF
A8
F:7
E3?7
97@7D3>
G@67DF3=;@9
'

G;67>;@7E
M




AD
BGDBAE7E
A8
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE

3@3>KE;E
'
?3@63F7E
FA
5A@E;67D
F:7
;?B35FE
A8
F:7
B3EF
BD7E7@F
3@6
D73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>7
8GFGD7
BDA<75FE
'

G;67>;@7E
MM




EG46
4

BD7B3D7
3@
(

R;8
F:7
397@5K
67F7D?;@7E
F:3F
F:7D7
;E
EG4EF3@F;3>
7H;67@57
F:3F
3@K
3EB75F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
7;F:7D
;@6;H;6G3>>K
AD
5G?G>3F;H7>K
?3K
53GE7
3
E;9@;8;53@F
78875F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
D793D6>7EE
A8
I:7F:7D
F:7
AH7D3>>
78875F
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
;E
36H7DE7
AD
47@78;5;3>S



EG46
:
>736
397@5;7E
?GEF
5A@E;67D
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
B3EF
AF:7D
5GDD7@F
3@6
RBDA434>7
8GFGD7S
BDA<75FE
H7@
;8
F:7
&DA<75FUE
;?B35FE
3D7
E;9@;8;53@F
;FE
;@5D7?7@F3>
78875FE
I:7@
36676
FA
AF:7D
B3EF
BD7E7@F
3@6
BDA434>7
237

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










8GFGD7
BDA<75FE
53@
47
5G?G>3F;H7>K
E;9@;8;53@F
'
G;67>;@7E
MM



EG46

3





EG46
4




EG46
4

*:7
3>;8AD@;3
)GBD7?7
AGDF
:3E
678;@76
B;757?73>;@9
3E
5:ABB;@9
3
>3D97
BDA<75F
;@FA
?3@K
>;FF>7
A@7E
735:
I;F:
3
?;@;?3>
BAF7@F;3>
;?B35F
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
P
I:;5:
5G?G>3F;H7>K
?3K
:3H7
6;E3EFDAGE
5A@E7CG7@57E

.94-&
5
." +
&$-"8
.1, 3(.-

.,,



3>
6







CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76
*:GE
;67@F;8K;@9
3@6

EFG6K;@9
F:7
RI:A>7
A8
F:7
BDA<75FS
;E
5DG5;3>
FA
3FF3;@?7@F
A8
'UE
9A3>E
A8
BDAB7D>K
6;E5>AE;@9
3@6
?;F;93F;@9
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
T&DA<75FU
;E
9;H7@
3
4DA36
;@F7DBD7F3F;A@
;@
AD67D
FA
?3J;?;L7
BDAF75F;A@
A8
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
 -
. 04(-
 /3.1(+#+(%$
$2"4$

$-3$1
5

.4-38
.%
3 -(2+ 42




3>BBF:






H7@
I:7@
3
67H7>AB7D
A4F3;@E
3
D;9:F
FA
5A@EFDG5F
AD
:3E
5A?B>7F76
A@7
AD
?AD7
B;757E
A8
3
>3D97D
BDA<75F
F:3F
:3E
EA
83D
7H3676
8G>>
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
F:7
;FK
3@6
F:7
5AGDFE
:3H7
F:7
D;9:F
;@6776
F:7
6GFK
FA
D7?76K
F:7
IDA@9
*:;E
;@5>G67E
EFABB;@9
F:7
5:3>>7@976
;@5A?B>7F7
B3DFE
3@6
AD67D;@9
3
5A?BD7:7@E;H7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
7@F;D7
BDA<75F
GE;@9
3
5ADD75F76
BDA<75F
67E5D;BF;A@
3@6
43E7>;@7
)77
15(5

-3$1/1(2$2
-"
5
.43'

++$8
1$
+ --(-&

.,,




3>BBF:


@
15(5
3
"AE
@97>7E
67H7>AB7D
:36
3@
AH7D3>>
B>3@
FA
4G;>6

:A?7E
;@
F:7
#G>:A>>3@6
5A??G@;FK
3>A@9
-AA6EFA5=
(A36
!(#
3F
B


(3F:7D

F:3@
BD7E7@F
F:7
RI:A>7S
A8
;FE
35F;A@
3E
B3DF
A8
3@
(
AD
AF:7D
5A?BD7:7@E;H7
D7H;7I
F:7
67H7>AB7D
5:ABB76
F:7
>3D97D
BDA<75F
;@FA
B;757EQA@7
A8
8;H7
:A?7E
3@AF:7D
A8
FIA
:A?7E
3@6
3@AF:7D
A8


:A?7E
!(#
3F
BB





*:7

67H7>AB7D
F:7@
E7B3D3F7>K
BDA57EE76
735:
H;3
'
7J7?BF;A@E
AD
#$E

*:7
;FK
D75A9@;L76
F:7
67H7>AB7DUE
3FF7?BF76
5;D5G?H7@F;A@
A8
'
3@6
D7CG;D76
67H7>AB7D
FA
A4F3;@
3@
(
8AD
3

:AGE7
67H7>AB?7@F
D3F:7D
F:3@
BDA5776
;@
3

B;757?73>
?3@@7D
*:7
67H7>AB7D
EG76
F:7
;FK
3D9G;@9
393;@EF
BD7B3D3F;A@
A8
3@
(
!(#
3F
B



*:7
FD;3>
5AGDF
D7<75F76
F:7
67H7>AB7DUE
BAE;F;A@
3@6
F:7
AGDF
A8
BB73>
388;D?76
:A>6;@9
F:3F
F:7
E;9@;8;53@57
A8
3@
355GD3F7
BDA<75F
67E5D;BF;A@
;E
?3@;87EF
I:7D7
3E
:7D7
5G?G>3F;H7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
;?B35FE
?3K
47
6;E9G;E76
AD
?;@;?;L76
4K
8;>;@9
@G?7DAGE
E7D;3>
3BB>;53F;A@E
!(#
3F
B


;@F7D@3>
CGAF3F;A@E

A?;FF76

R%@7
I3K
FA
7H3>G3F7
I:;5:
35FE
3D7
B3DF
A8
3
BDA<75F
;E
FA
7J3?;@7
:AI
5>AE7>K
D7>3F76
F:7
35FE
3D7
FA
F:7
AH7D3>>
A4<75F;H7
A8
F:7
BDA<75FS

4.+4,-$

.4-38

(3(9$-2
%.1

$2/.-2(!+$
1.63'
-"
5

(38
.%
.-.1





3>BBF:




R@AF:7D

I3K
FA
B:D3E7
F:7
CG7EF;A@
A8
I:7F:7D
3
B3DF;5G>3D
35F
;E
3
EF7B
F3=7@
FAI3D6E
F:7
238

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$










35:;7H7?7@F
A8
F:7
BDABA@7@FUE
A4<75F;H7
;E
FA
3E=
I:7F:7D
F:7
35F
;E
B3DF
A8
3
5AAD6;@3F76
7@673HAD





5
3 3$
(1
$2.41"$2

#




3>BBF:




8@


CGAF3F;A@E
A?;FF76

*:7
83;>GD7
FA
3@3>KL7
F:7
I:A>7
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
3@6
F:7D74K
3>>AI
F:7
FDG7
;?B35FE
;@5>G6;@9
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
F:7
H3D;AGE
B3DFE
36676
FA97F:7D
FA
7E53B7
D7H;7I
;E
BAF7@F;3>>K
R6;E3EFDAGES
3@6
E:AG>6
@AF
47
3>>AI76

.94-&
24/1 

3>
6
3F
BB




A@E;EF7@F
I;F:
15(5
3@
(
;E
3>EA
D7CG;D76
A@
B;757?73>;@9
9DAG@6E
FA
BDAB7D>K
3@3>KL7
D79G>3FADK
F:D7E:A>6
7J57763@57E
53GE76
4K
3
BDA<75F
3BB>;53@FUE
5AAD6;@3F76
7@673HAD

AD
7J3?B>7
G@67D
'

G;67>;@7E
M




EG46

4

3
BDABAE76
:AF7>
I;F:
?AD7
F:3@


DAA?E
E:3>>
47
677?76

D79;A@3>>K 3D73
I;67
E;9@;8;53@F
*:;E
67F7D?;@3F;A@
?3K
@AF
47
BAEE;4>7
I:7D7
3
BDA<75F
;E
B;757?73>76
);?;>3D>K
G@67D
&G4>;5
(7EAGD57E
A67
M



F:7D7
3D7

@G?7DAGE
>;?;F3F;A@E
3@6
D7CG;D7?7@FE
F:3F
F:7
BDA<75F
?GEF
?77F
;@5>G6;@9
3
53B
A8
?3J;?G?

G@;FE
I:;5:
53@@AF
47
BDAB7D>K
3EE7EE76
I:7D7
3
BDA<75F
;E
B;757?73>76

'UE
B;757?73>;@9
BDA:;4;F;A@QB3DF;5G>3D>K
8AD
>3F7D
B:3E7E
AD
>3EF
35F
BDA<75F
5A?BA@7@FEQ;E
3>EA
5D;F;53>
3E
;F
D7EG>FE
;@
3@
;?BDAB7D>K
;@8>3F76
3@6
;@355GD3F7
43E7>;@7
3@6
8G@63?7@F3>>K
;@355GD3F7
R@A
BDA<75FS
3>F7D@3F;H7E
67E;9@3F;A@
I:;5:
;@
FGD@
F3;@FE
F:7
7@F;D7
'
D7H;7I





5
3 3$
(1
$2.41"$2

#




3>BBF:




GE7
A8
3@
;@8>3F76
43E7>;@7
:36
F:7
78875F
A8
G@67DEF3F;@9
F:7
;@5D73E7
A8
;?B35FE
D7CG;D;@9
D7H7DE3>
E77
3>EA
'
G;67>;@7E
MM




EG46

7





EG46
3

4AF:
F:7
R@A
BDA<75FS
3>F7D@3F;H7
3@6
F:7
43E7>;@7
5A@E;67D
F:7
7J;EF;@9
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
5A@6;F;A@E
F
;E
I7>>E7FF>76
F:3F
I;F:AGF
3@
367CG3F7
43E7>;@7
F:7
R3@3>KE;E
A8
;?B35FE
?;F;93F;A@
?73EGD7E
3@6
BDA<75F
3>F7D@3F;H7E
475A?7E
;?BAEE;4>7S

.4-38
.%
, #.1
5

+

.1 #.

.4-38
 3$1
&$-"8




3>BBF:






>F7D@3F;H7>K
7H7@
;8
H3D;AGE
B3DFE
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
3D7
EG88;5;7@F>K
E7B3D3F7
3@6
6A
@AF
5A@EF;FGF7
3
I:A>7
A8
3@
35F;A@
'
D7CG;D7E
F:3F
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
A8
F:7
BDA<75F
;@5>G67
;?B35FE
A8
F:7
B3EF
BD7E7@F
3@6
D73EA@34>K
8AD7E7734>7
8GFGD7
BDA<75FE
)77
'

G;67>;@7E
MM


EG46
3





EG46
4





EG46
4
@
835F
5AGDFE
FD73F
B;757?73>;@9
3@6
83;>GD7
FA
EFG6K
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
D7>3F76
3BBDAH3>E
3E
3>F7D@3F;H7
F:7AD;7E
 -
. 04(-
 /3.1(+#+(%$
$2"4$
$-3$1
5

.4-38
.%
3 -(2+ 42




3>BBF:





R7H7@
3EEG?;@9
F:7
E7I7D

7JB3@E;A@
I3E
E7H7D34>7
8DA?
F:7
67H7>AB?7@F
BDA<75F
F:7
(
EF;>>
6;6
@AF
5A?B>K

239

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









I;F:
'S
8AD
83;>GD7
FA
5A@E;67D
F:7;D
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
*:GE
;@
3@3>KL;@9
3
&DA<75FUE
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
;FUE
;?BADF3@F
FA
3@3>KL7
@AF
<GEF
F:7
;?B35FE
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
;FE7>8
4GF
3>EA
5A@E;67D
;?B35FE
8DA?
3>>
AF:7D
D7>3F76
BDA<75FE
3E
I7>>
H;67@57
A8
BB>;53@FUE
R5AAD6;@3F76
7@673HADS
FA
3HA;6
BDAB7D
'
D7H;7I
;E
?3@;87EF
;@
F:;E
53E7
GDD7@F>K
F:7
&DA<75F
;@HA>H7E
FIA
4G;>6;@9
B7D?;FEQA@7
FA
675D73E7
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
8DA?


877F
FA


877F
B7D?;F





3@6
3@AF:7D
FA
5A>>A53F7
I;D7>7EE
;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
A@
F:7
FAI7D
$$
%5FA47D




97@63
(7BADF
B


E56/6A

*:7
B7D?;F
FA
675D73E7
F:7
:7;9:F
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
I3E
;EEG76
A@
G9GEF




I:;>7
F:7
B7D?;F
FA
5A>>A53F7
@7I

;@8D3EFDG5FGD7
;E
5GDD7@F>K
G@67D
D7H;7I
3E
B7D?;F





!(#
&D;AD
FA
F:;E
A@

AD
34AGF
)7BF7?47D



F:7
&>3@@;@9
;H;E;A@
3BBDAH76
*AI7D
@9;@77DE

&DA87EE;A@3>E
A@
47:3>8
A8
;E:
3BB>;53F;A@
8AD
5A>>A53F;A@
A8
F:D77
@7I
;E:
B3@7>
3@F7@@3E
FA
47
388;J76
FA
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
!(#
BB>;53@F
;@
AD67D
FA
D76G57
F:7
3BB73D3@57
3@6
E7H7D;FK
A8
F:7
&DA<75FUE
;?B35FE
3@6
;FE
EG4EF3@F;3>
5:3@97
A8
F:7
6;?7@E;A@E
A8
F:7
7J;EF;@9
FAI7D
3BB>;76
F:DAG9:


>;57@E77E
8AD
3
@G?47D
A8

4G;>6;@9
3@6
5A>>A53F;A@
B7D?;FE
AH7D
F:7
5AGDE7
A8
E7H7D3>
?A@F:E
;@
H;A>3F;A@
A8
'

E
3
D7EG>F
A8
B;757?73>;@9
AD
3>F7D@3F;H7>K
F:7
83;>GD7
FA
D7H;7I
F:7
5G?G>3F;H7
;?B35FE
A8
F:7
&DA<75FUE
D7>3F76
B3DFE
AD
5A?BA@7@FE
F:7D7
;E
;@8AD?3F;A@3>
678;5;7@5K
3@6
AH7D3>>
;?BAEE;4;>;FK
FA
?73@;@98G>>K
3EE7EE
F:7
&DA<75FUE
;?B35FE
AD
7@F;F>7?7@F
FA
?;@;EF7D;3>
3BBDAH3>
3@6
3@K
'
5>73D3@57
;E
>793>>K
3@6
835FG3>>K
G@EGBBADF76
)
 "!(&
"!

*:7
&DA<75F
I;>>
:3H7
E;9@;8;53@F
;?B35FE
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@6
EGDDAG@6;@9
:G?3@
47;@9E
;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA
37EF:7F;5
8;D7
:3L3D6E
3@6
I3F7D
;?B35FE

/7F
;F
:3E
@AF
477@
EG4<75F
FA
3@K
7@H;DA@?7@F3>
D7H;7I
P
@AF
8AD
F:7


+&
@AD
@AI


@
>;9:F
A8
F:7
38AD7?7@F;A@76
5A@57D@E

3D4AD
,;7I

%
D7EB75F8G>>K
D7CG7EFE
F:3F

F:7
;FK


5A??;EE;A@
F:7
BD7B3D3F;A@
3@6
5;D5G>3F;A@
A8
3
&DA<75FEB75;8;5
@H;DA@?7@F3>
?B35F
(7BADF


AD67D
BB>;53@F
FA
D7H;E7
F:7
&DA<75F
FA
7@EGD7
;FE



/;8
5H<?7<A:
C8E@<G
G;4G
BE<:<A4??L
4HG;BE<M87
G;8
<AFG4??4G<BA
B9
G;8
J<E8?8FF
8DH<C@8AG
C8E@<G




J4F
9<A4?<M87
BA

H:HFG







)BG8
G;4G
G;<F
C8E@<G
;4F
ABG
588A
9<A4?<M87
4F
JBE>
GB
6B@C?8G8
G;8
+EB=86G
E8@4<AF
HA78EJ4L
*6GB58E





:8A74
-8CBEG
C





"<I8A
G;4G
G;8
9<EFG
5H<?7<A:
C8E@<G
;4F
4?E847L
588A
<FFH87
G;<F
6B@@8AG
?8GG8E
J<??
E898E
GB
G;8
CBEG<BA
B9
G;8
+EB=86G
J;<6;
<F
6HEE8AG?L
HA78E
E8I<8J
4F
R+EB=86G S
240

"&





"
'



!
 
!!

#
"
!

"&

$









5A@E;EF7@5K
I;F:
3>>
3BB>;534>7
>3IE
3@6
D79G>3F;A@E
;@5>G6;@9
4GF
@AF
>;?;F76
FA
EF3F7
3@6
8767D3>
D7CG;D7?7@FE
5A@57D@;@9
;?B35FE
A@
F:7
7@H;DA@?7@F
3@6
:G?3@
47;@9E


AD67D
BB>;53@F
FA
3BB>K
8AD
3
@7I
+&
;@
355AD63@57
I;F:
5GDD7@F
DG>7E
3@6
BDA576GD7E
3@6

D7CG7EF
A8
BB>;53@F
3
?GFG3>
39D77?7@F
FA
FA>>
F:7
 63K

F;?78D3?7
8AD
D7H;7I
BGDEG3@F
FA
M



5

3@6
GF;>;L7
F:3F
F;?7
FA
7@9397
;@
3

?AD7
F:ADAG9:
3@3>KE;E
A8
F:7
&DA<75F
3@6
F:7
:;EFADK
A8
GE7
A8
F:7
);F7

3D4AD
,;7I

%
IAG>6
>;=7
FA
D7;F7D3F7
F:3F
;F
6A7E
@AF
E77=
FA
BD75>G67
BB>;53@F
8DA?
?AH;@9
8ADI3D6
I;F:
;FE
BDABAE76
&DA<75F
4GF
A@>K
FA
7@EGD7
F:3F
F:7
&DA<75F
5A?B>;7E
I;F:
3>>
3BB>;534>7
DG>7E
D79G>3F;A@E
3@6
EF3@63D6E
):AG>6
F:7
;FK
:3H7
3@K
CG7EF;A@E
AD
5A@57D@E
;F
E:AG>6
877>
8D77
FA
5A@F35F
AGD
A88;57
);@57D7>K


#;F5:7>>
#
*E3;

FFAD@7K
8AD
)AGF:I7EF
#AG@F3;@

)F3F7E
(79;A@3>
AG@5;>
A8
3DB7@F7DE

AA.0521

%5FA47D




97@63
(7BADF
E56/6A


A@6;F;A@3>
+E7
&7D?;F
$A


E56/6A


,A>G@F3DK
A?B>;3@57
9D77?7@F
E56/6A


&(
&DA6G5F;A@
8DA?
F:7
;FK
&(


E56/6A


35=9DAG@6
@8AD?3F;A@
A@
#;5DAI3H7
(7>3K
)FDG5FGD7E
E56/6A

7EF35=;@9
&7D?;F
E56/6A


FFAD@7K

7@7D3>UE

G;63@57
D7
R7EF
&D35F;57E
8AD
@3>KL;@9
3@6
#;F;93F;@9
-;>68;D7
?B35FE
A8
7H7>AB?7@F
&DA<75FE
+@67D
F:7
3>;8AD@;3
@H;DA@?7@F3>
'G3>;FK
5FS
E56/6A

3@6

)3@
>7?7@F7
,7DK

;9:

;D7E

3L3D6
)7H7D;FK
0A@7E
#3B
E56/6A



241

EXHIBIT A
242
243
Meeting Date: October 17, 2023

AGENDA REPORT

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE

CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Department: Community Development
Prepared By: Jonathan Lightfoot, City Planner
Subject:

WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS FACILITY LOCATED AT 616 DEL DIOS Fiscal Impact:

None to receive and file this report.

Summary:
910 Calle Negocio
2nd Floor
San Clemente, California
www.san-clemente.org
Agenda Item: 10C
On October 3, 2023, the City Council directed staff to prepare a summary report regarding applications submitted for the modification and construction of wireless communications located at 616 Del Dios, Assessor's Parcel Number 690-552-05. American Tower Management, the applicant and owner, submitted two Building permits to: 1) decrease the height of the tower, and 2) collocate wireless infrastructure on the tower. The Building permit to reduce the height of the tower has been issued, however, the Building permit to collocate new infrastructure is currently under review by City staff. City staff is coordinating a meeting with community members to discuss the proposed project. The meeting is anticipated to occur on October 18, 2023 during a Study Session with the Planning Commission.

Background:

An existing cell facility at the subject site is operated by American Tower Management (Applicant) and was approved under a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) in 1962 by the County of Orange (Attachment 1 ). Per the CUP, the wireless communications facility was approved for an approximate 28 ft. by 58 ft. building and a 70 ft. antenna tower. Per Applicant representatives, the tower component of the wireless communications facility is 137.6 ft, but is further extended to 156 ft. when the height is measured from the highest existing appurtenance affixed to the tower.

The County, Applicant, and City have not been able to locate any records authorizing the expansion in height beyond the originally permitted height of 70' approved by the County of Orange. As a result, the City denied a collocation request in 2020, which initiated discussions between legal counsel for the Applicant and the City. The Applicant ultimately agreed to voluntarily reduce the height of the existing tower to the 70' maximum permitted by the 1962 County of Orange CUP. A Voluntary Compliance Agreement was executed on July 6, 2023 between the Applicant and the City of San Clemente to reduce the height of the existing antenna tower to the permitted height of 70' (Attachment 2). During the review of records that preceded the compliance agreement, legal counsel for the Applicant noted that the tower is still used today for the wireless transmission of telephone services. Additionally, the City approved a Building permit (B16-2650), for wireless equipment that was installed and the permit was finaled on August 28, 2017. Existing equipment still present on the tower is proposed to be removed and

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE
244
Meeting Date: October 17, 2023 Agenda Item: 10C
replaced by the equipment referenced in permit B23-2265, which is currently under review and described further in the following section.

Discussion:

Due to the public interest regarding proposed work efforts at the site and City Council's request for additional information, City staff has prepared the following summary for the two recent applications submitted for the site.

The requests by the Applicant are to: (1) decrease the height of the tower from 137' to 70' in conformance with the 1962 CUP obtained from the County of Orange, and (2) for the colocation of infrastructure on the existing tower. Proposed collocation infrastructure consists of three (3) panel antennas, three (3) sector mounts, six (6) remote radio units (RRUs), three (3) back-toback mounts, one (1) overvoltage protector (OVP), and one (1) hybrid cable. One (1) new equipment cabinet is also proposed.
• B23-1495: A building permit was issued on 08/30/2023 to reduce the height of the existing tower from 138' to 70' measured from the existing adjacent grade to the highest appurtenance affixed to the tower. This permit has not been finaled as work to complete this project is still underway.
• B23-2265: A "Wireless Communications Facilities" application screening form was submitted by Tower Engineering Professionals (applying on behalf of Dish Wireless) for a Dish collocation of three new Dish Wireless panel antennas that would be affixed to the existing tower. The submitted application is a required screening form submitted prior to a Building permit application to evaluate the proposed collocation, pursuant to Section 6409(a) of the Middle-Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act of 2012 for facilities outside of the public right-of-way. The applicant submitted a third-party produced Radio Frequency (RF) Compliance Analysis that details the occupational and public exposure levels. The analysis for this site indicated that the RF and power levels will not exceed the FCC established Maximum Permissible Exposure Levels (MPE) for the General Public or Occupational environments. The report recommended the installation of notice/informational signage at the gate entrance to the facility. The screening form was evaluated and approved by the Planning Division on 9/5/2023. The applicant subsequently applied for a Building permit on 9/14/23 for the proposed collocation. This Building permit is currently under review.

The application for modification to the above referenced tower facility, based on initial review, qualifies under Section 6409 of the Spectrum Act (47 U.S.C. § 1455(a), 47 C.F.R. § 1.6100 as an eligible facility for streamlined, ministerial review because it meets the following criteria:

1. It is an existing utility tower.

2. The proposed modification:
• Does not propose a height increase of more than 10% or 20' of the existing height, • Does not propose more than 4 new equipment cabinets,
• Complies with prior conditions of approval, and
• Does not defeat the concealment elements of the existing facility.

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE
245
Meeting Date: October 17, 2023 Agenda Item: 10C
The timeframe (also called a "shot clock") for review is 60 days for permits to be issued from the date the application is submitted or the application is "deemed approved" under federal law. Any concerns regarding the completeness of an application must be raised by City staff within 30 days of application submittal.

As part of this process, staff will continue to review plans for the submitted Building permit, B23- 2265, as required under federal law. Staff may require modifications to ensure compliance with the Municipal Code, if enforcing the Municipal Code requirements complies with federal law. City staff is pausing any issuance of building permits regarding the collocation request until staff has convened a meeting with interested members of the community. City Planning staff is coordinating a meeting with community members to discuss the proposed project. The meeting is anticipated to occur on October 18, 2023 during a Study Session with the Planning Commission.

It should be noted that the City lacks discretion with respect to collocation requests if it meets applicable requirements. Federal regulations severely limit a local agencies ability to regulate such facilities. The Telecommunication Act of 1996 expressly prohibits state or local regulations that have the effect of prohibiting the ability of any entity to provide any interstate or intrastate telecommunications service. This has been interpreted very broadly to extremely limit local authority.

Furthermore, under federal law, the City is expressly prohibited from regulating the placement, construction and modification of wireless service facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of radio frequency (RF) emissions, if the facilities comply with the Federal Communication Commission's (FCC's) regulations concerning RF emissions. The FCC guidelines incorporate maximum permitted exposure limits established by the Congressionally-chartered National Council on Radiation Protection. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has upheld the FCC guidelines setting health and safety standards on RF emissions and prohibiting local governments from considering health effects of emissions in zoning decisions. Therefore, City decision makers cannot take comments or information concerning potential health effects or other environmental effects into consideration in determining whether to approve permits for cellular facilities.

City decision makers can, however, ensure an individual or collocated wireless communications facility (WCF) will operate within the FCC standards for public exposure. In order to ensure compliance with FCC RF emission standards, the City requires verification from the Applicant that the proposed WCF will either comply with the FCC's guidelines for human exposure to RF emissions or will be categorially excluded from having to determine compliance with the guidelines per 47 CFR §1 .1307(b)(1). Information regarding potential health effects is available from the cellular providers upon request and it is also required from the FCC. During the previous City Council meeting, the topic of health effects from the proposed WCF was a large concern of the public; however, as noted above, the City is precluded from considering such effects under federal law, if the RF emissions comply with FCC standards.

Council Options:
• Receive and file the Administrative Report.
• Continue the item and direct staff to provide additional information.

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE
246
Meeting Date: October 17, 2023 Agenda Item: 10C
Environmental Review/Analysis:

Informational reports are not a "project" under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).

Furthermore, the federal process for reviewing eligible facilities requests requires applications be subject to ministerial review only. Therefore, eligible facilities are not subject to the CEQA per§ Section 21080(b )(1) of the California Public Resources Code.

Recommended Actions:

Staff Recommendation
STAFF RECOMMENDS THAT the City Council receive and fi le this report.

Attachment:

1. County of Orange Conditional Permit (CP-1021 ), dated December 12, 1962

2. Voluntary Compliance Agreement, dated July 6, 2023
Notification:

Rancho San Clemente Homeowners Association and Interested Parties.

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE
247
..
1005688+ .-..... .
rl' 10~1
• • . y1 • •
• I I llp•t • ••
•
•rica~ lfl~hone ~ T gr
W. M. W tte 1~?5 6th " ' .
• TO •• ' " ~: l th• "ata'~ \ 1.Sh~ftnt or ~ i::i trC'•~v• r•lJt ~at1on 1 J'I l:C"Qn41d lori .. 1 t.h '
~ pvbll~ t~1Bph~TI• ••Pri~• In th, Al r.enw-~1 At.rlevlt~r1l ~istr!~t.

Said station will ~Cflstst. ct m aps,ro1tlftat4 ie r,, by ~fl rt.. ~ildlnr. ,n:! 4 10 !t . .anttnnA tc.-r all 1ceatad 1u'bst~ntt~11, a• tncuc:,t.6ti ~ tl':11 at.t~c~•d FlO~ Pl lfl4te938 ta tb• alt• will ■ •1• aTI ext•tl~g ttfYat ■ ro~d Pun~!e~ n~rth1a,t•rly :\p~ro•lr,.,1111, 2 1til•1 rrctt: the C!tr ct S;:.n Cl•lllntt 1• •r.c1r •it•• ":1-,r. 9trut't"r•" ... ttl t~ en.~10,e!I b1 ~ ~ rt. eha1n ltr~ r•nc• w1~h lcck41d ,:it•• 7hcre will~ no e~il~Y••8 Gn tM in~i,es uc~pt ror reriG~i~ fllalctt•n~nre. ,i 9$,;il '.'i,r!,iz,('f fer Al"l.t•1:na! fJ'IO■ ]5 ft, to I ln3~!1:U"- (I~ 70 !'t• A.II ta <•• • • • • •\ ■ ,.., ,., ..., -•~ , , _ •• 1 h .,, ■ , ••4• 1 ,,,._ t-••-· 1 ... .,.., •••• •' ,_, .,,. .. •••••• •• ,_....,_.._. of ,4,,,a 1 ··•·< ....... ~ .... •'•• , ...... tt. ...... .,,_ ...... ,. ••••• L! , , AL : I• : t. • • '•
•
•
• . • · , . •· . • A.FPr0.d11.1it l1 2 111 l•t r.()rtl:a:.at&,.11 rrv..ra \he anJ o! Al'tnid& .S , l v .:1 I·· r [. t ,:u, Cl~hlnt e IIIIG'tei- r•~,.,,e 11' ) ,.t ~" ~ "'' a rr 1 v:.t~ To, !I • • .... .. •• • • • • •• ltr--.slh: ra~IH 1.ar>d. nat-tt.,a.a~ Qf Su Cler•nt.e - . ·- ~-- ....... _ ~
• ♦ • • 5
248

VO LUNT ARY COMPLIANCE AGREEMENT

PARTIES
This Voluntary Compliance Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into by and between American Tower Management, LLC r'ATC'') and the City of San Clemente ("City"). ATC and the City are sometimes refer.red to in this Agreement individually as "Party', and collectively as the "Parties". This Agreement !s entered into as of July~> 2023 ("Effective Date'l RECl:fALS
This Agreement is made with reference to the following:

1. A TC operates a wireless communication facility (Site No. 89366) ("Wireless Communications Facility"), located at Rancho San Clemente Trailt Rancho San Clemente, California 92672 (Al' : 690-552-05) ("Property") that was approved under a Conditional Use Permit in _1962 by the Orange County ("County,,) Planning Division, which then had jurisdictio:1 over the Property (''1962 CUP,,).

2. The 1962 CUP pennits a wireless communications facility, consisting of "an approximate 28 ft by 58 ft. building and a 70 ft. antenna tower", in connection with a public telephone service.

3. According to ATC, the tower component of the Wireless Communications Facility is 137 .6 ft. iri height, which is further extended to 156 ft. when the height is measured from the highest existing appurtenance affixed to the tower.

4. Neither the City, the County, nor ATC have been able to locate any records authorizing the expansion in height of the tower from 70 ft. to the current height. 249

5. Accordingly, because no records of any County or City approvals authorizing the expansion of the tower from 70 ft. to its current height have been located, ATC voluntarily agrees to reduce the height of the existing tower to the 70 ft, maximum identified in the 1962 CCP.

6. To the best of the City's information and knowledge, the only known violation of the 1962 CUP or applicable law with respect to the Wireless Communications Facility is the tower's height.

7. The City and ATC desire to resolve this matter.

AGREEMENT
In consideration of and in return for the promises, covenants, and agreements made herein by the Parties, the sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Partie agree as follows:

1. The above recitals are incorporated into the terms of this Agreement.

2. The height of the existing tower component of the Wireless Communications Facility will be reduced to a maximum of 70 ft., when the height is measured from the existing adjacent grade to the highest appurtenance affixed to the tower.

3. All work required to reduce the height of the tower to a maximum of 7 0 ft. shall be performed and completed by ATC, at its sole cost and expense, within 12 months from the date that a building permit is issued by the City in accordance with Section 5, below. ATC shall submit a complete application for a building permit within two (2) months of the Effective Date.

4. ATC agrees that once the height of the tower is reduced, ATC will comply with the 1962 CUP and maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with all applicable laws, inc1uding, but not limited to, the San Clemente Municipal Code and the California Building Code. This includes, but is not limited to, obtaining any necessary permits and other approvals for construction, modifications and/or uses prior to any such changes, to ensure continued compliance -2-
4S83:2S029Wi.40113 53!!.2
250
with the 1962 CUP and applicable law in effect at that time. ATC shall also maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with all applicable state and federal laws and regulations, now existing or hereinafter enacted.

5. ATC agrees, prior to commencing any work to reduce the height of the tower stipulated in this Agreement, to obtain a building permit from the City for alterations to the tower.

The City agrees to process and issue the building permit with reasonable diligence and without delay.

6. The City agrees that, following the reduction in the height of the tower, the Wireless Communications Facility will be in compliance with the 1962 CUP, and specifically that (i) the 1962 CUP is vested; (ii) the 1962 CUP does not contain an expiration date; and (iii) the 1962 CCP permits the current use of the Wireless Communications Facility for wireless telecommunication purposes; and (iv) the 1962 CUP permits a 70' tower. As a result, the City shall not require a discretionary approval, including but not limited to a new CUP or renewal of the 1962 CUP, in connection with the reduction in height and ongoing operation of the Wireless Communications Facility consistent with the 1962 CUP.

7. In contemplation of, and based on ATC's agreement to reduce the tower height in compliance with this Agreement and to maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with the law as set forth in Section 4 above, the City hereby will forego any enforcement proceedings for non-compliance related to ATC's tower prior to expiration of the deadline established in Section 3 above.

8. ATC hereby releases the City, its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives, from any and all actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of -3-
41113~02'04'1,113538.2
251
damages arising from or relating to any enforcement proceedings for non-compliance as of the expiration of the deadline established in Section 3 above (the "ATC Released Claims,,). However, this release provision does not extinguish, release, or discharge any of the obligations and rights set forth and encompassed in this Agreement. ATC shall indemnify, defend ( with counsel acceptable to City) and hold the City its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives from any and all actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of damages by any third party arising from or relating to the A TC Released Claims or this Agreement, the 1962 CUP or ATC construction, operation or maintenance of the Wireless Communications Facility, including, but not limited to, any environmental review or approval in connection therewith.

9. Effective upon ATC's completion of the work on the tower in compliance with applicable laws and as contemplated by this Agreement, the City releases A TC, its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives, from any and all known actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of damages arising from or relating to any noncompliance of ATC's tower. However, this release provision does not extinguish, release, or discharge any of the obligations and rights set forth and encompassed in this Agreement.

10. ATC also hereby specifically waives the protections of California Civil Code section 1542, which provides:

A general release does not extend to claims that the creditor or releasing party does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release and that, if known by him or her, -4-
ffl3:i5029£W01135382
252
I •.
would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor or released party.

11. As required by law, the City hereby reserves its right to enforce future violations of law relating to the Wireless Communications Facility or those violations currently unknovro., as provided by law, and seek any remedies or rights available to the City. This section is merely intended to clarify that the City is not waiving any future rights or obligations it may have under law pertaining to future occurring or currently urna1own, and therefore not contemplated, violations of law that may exist.

12. Advice of Counsel. The Parties represent that they have had the opportunity, whether or not they have chosen to do so, to discuss this Agreement with legal counsel.

13. Entire Agreement. This Agreement is the entire agreement between the Parties with respect to the ubject matter hereof and supersedes all prior and contemporaneous oral and written agreements and discussions. This Agreement may be aniended only by an agreement in writing signed by all Parties, except that a change in contact information may be made simply by sending notice to the other party.

14. Severability. Each provision of this Agreement is separate, distinct and severable from the others. If any provision is held unenforceable, the rest of the Agreement shall be enforced to the greatest extent possible.

15. Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed and interpreted in accordance with the laws of the State of California.

16. Choice of Venue. The venue for any disputes arising out of this Agreement shall be in the County of Orange. ATC waives any rights that it may have to removal under Code of Civil Procedure section 395.
-5-
48U,!1029flll.H Ml3 53 &_2
253

17. Successors and Assigns. This Agreement and all terms, conditions and obligations contained herein are binding upon and inure to the benefit of any assigns and successors-in-interest of the Parties, and each of them. Each of the Parties represents and warrants that as of the Effective Date none of the claims or causes of action being released herein have been transferred, assigned or otherwise conveyed to any other person or entity, and each of the Parties is the holder of the claims being released.

18. Force Majeure. Neither Party shall be liable for its failure or delay to perform under this Agreement (a) caused by reason of acts of God, wars, revolution, terrorism, civil commotion, or similar unlawful acts of third parties, fire, flood or other casualty, embargo, acts of government in its sovereign capacity, labor difficulties, including without limitation, strikes, slowdowns, business shutdowns, government regulations preventing performance, epidemics or pandemics preventing performance, labor or supply shortages preventing perfonnance, picketing or boycotts, .
or any other similar circumstances beyond the reasonab1e control and not involving any fault or negligence of such Party, and (b) provided that Party gives prompt notice to the other Party and makes all commercially reasonable efforts to perfonn.
[ continued on following page]
4Sl!i?i02900!MMl3 538.2
254

19. Signatures. By signing below, the Parties acknowledge that they have read understo d, and agree to all of the terms f this Agreement.

Dated: June 29, 2023 By:

Dated: June JL., 2023 By:

APPROVED AS TO FORM:

Dated: July~. 2023 By:

Dated: June _S_, 2023 By:
-7-
§8ll3~099!W~ MG5J8.2

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE

AMERICAN TOWER MANAGEME T,
LLC4/ . - Margaret R binson
Vice President Legal Operations UST
American Tower Management, LLC
Elizabeth A. Mitchel l
City Attorney for the City of San
Clemente
Emily L. Murr~{ )
Counsel to Alll&F~wer Management,
LLC

EXHIBIT B
255
256
TM I• PERMIT
MPT
i
I
257

EXHIBIT C
258
259

VO LUNT ARY COMPLIANCE AGREEMENT

PARTIES
This Voluntary Compliance Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into by and between American Tower Management, LLC r'ATC'') and the City of San Clemente ("City"). ATC and the City are sometimes refer.red to in this Agreement individually as "Party', and collectively as the "Parties". This Agreement !s entered into as of July~> 2023 ("Effective Date'l RECl:fALS
This Agreement is made with reference to the following:

1. A TC operates a wireless communication facility (Site No. 89366) ("Wireless Communications Facility"), located at Rancho San Clemente Trailt Rancho San Clemente, California 92672 (Al' : 690-552-05) ("Property") that was approved under a Conditional Use Permit in _1962 by the Orange County ("County,,) Planning Division, which then had jurisdictio:1 over the Property (''1962 CUP,,).

2. The 1962 CUP pennits a wireless communications facility, consisting of "an approximate 28 ft by 58 ft. building and a 70 ft. antenna tower", in connection with a public telephone service.

3. According to ATC, the tower component of the Wireless Communications Facility is 137 .6 ft. iri height, which is further extended to 156 ft. when the height is measured from the highest existing appurtenance affixed to the tower.

4. Neither the City, the County, nor ATC have been able to locate any records authorizing the expansion in height of the tower from 70 ft. to the current height. 260

5. Accordingly, because no records of any County or City approvals authorizing the expansion of the tower from 70 ft. to its current height have been located, ATC voluntarily agrees to reduce the height of the existing tower to the 70 ft, maximum identified in the 1962 CCP.

6. To the best of the City's information and knowledge, the only known violation of the 1962 CUP or applicable law with respect to the Wireless Communications Facility is the tower's height.

7. The City and ATC desire to resolve this matter.

AGREEMENT
In consideration of and in return for the promises, covenants, and agreements made herein by the Parties, the sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Partie agree as follows:

1. The above recitals are incorporated into the terms of this Agreement.

2. The height of the existing tower component of the Wireless Communications Facility will be reduced to a maximum of 70 ft., when the height is measured from the existing adjacent grade to the highest appurtenance affixed to the tower.

3. All work required to reduce the height of the tower to a maximum of 7 0 ft. shall be performed and completed by ATC, at its sole cost and expense, within 12 months from the date that a building permit is issued by the City in accordance with Section 5, below. ATC shall submit a complete application for a building permit within two (2) months of the Effective Date.

4. ATC agrees that once the height of the tower is reduced, ATC will comply with the 1962 CUP and maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with all applicable laws, inc1uding, but not limited to, the San Clemente Municipal Code and the California Building Code. This includes, but is not limited to, obtaining any necessary permits and other approvals for construction, modifications and/or uses prior to any such changes, to ensure continued compliance -2-
4S83:2S029Wi.40113 53!!.2
261
with the 1962 CUP and applicable law in effect at that time. ATC shall also maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with all applicable state and federal laws and regulations, now existing or hereinafter enacted.

5. ATC agrees, prior to commencing any work to reduce the height of the tower stipulated in this Agreement, to obtain a building permit from the City for alterations to the tower.

The City agrees to process and issue the building permit with reasonable diligence and without delay.

6. The City agrees that, following the reduction in the height of the tower, the Wireless Communications Facility will be in compliance with the 1962 CUP, and specifically that (i) the 1962 CUP is vested; (ii) the 1962 CUP does not contain an expiration date; and (iii) the 1962 CCP permits the current use of the Wireless Communications Facility for wireless telecommunication purposes; and (iv) the 1962 CUP permits a 70' tower. As a result, the City shall not require a discretionary approval, including but not limited to a new CUP or renewal of the 1962 CUP, in connection with the reduction in height and ongoing operation of the Wireless Communications Facility consistent with the 1962 CUP.

7. In contemplation of, and based on ATC's agreement to reduce the tower height in compliance with this Agreement and to maintain the Wireless Communications Facility in compliance with the law as set forth in Section 4 above, the City hereby will forego any enforcement proceedings for non-compliance related to ATC's tower prior to expiration of the deadline established in Section 3 above.

8. ATC hereby releases the City, its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives, from any and all actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of -3-
41113~02'04'1,113538.2
262
damages arising from or relating to any enforcement proceedings for non-compliance as of the expiration of the deadline established in Section 3 above (the "ATC Released Claims,,). However, this release provision does not extinguish, release, or discharge any of the obligations and rights set forth and encompassed in this Agreement. ATC shall indemnify, defend ( with counsel acceptable to City) and hold the City its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives from any and all actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of damages by any third party arising from or relating to the A TC Released Claims or this Agreement, the 1962 CUP or ATC construction, operation or maintenance of the Wireless Communications Facility, including, but not limited to, any environmental review or approval in connection therewith.

9. Effective upon ATC's completion of the work on the tower in compliance with applicable laws and as contemplated by this Agreement, the City releases A TC, its agents, employees, attorneys, elected officials, appointed officials and representatives, from any and all known actions, causes of action, losses, claims, demands, damages, costs, loss of use, loss of revenue, expenses, compensation and other form of damages arising from or relating to any noncompliance of ATC's tower. However, this release provision does not extinguish, release, or discharge any of the obligations and rights set forth and encompassed in this Agreement.

10. ATC also hereby specifically waives the protections of California Civil Code section 1542, which provides:

A general release does not extend to claims that the creditor or releasing party does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release and that, if known by him or her, -4-
ffl3:i5029£W01135382
263
I •.
would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor or released party.

11. As required by law, the City hereby reserves its right to enforce future violations of law relating to the Wireless Communications Facility or those violations currently unknovro., as provided by law, and seek any remedies or rights available to the City. This section is merely intended to clarify that the City is not waiving any future rights or obligations it may have under law pertaining to future occurring or currently urna1own, and therefore not contemplated, violations of law that may exist.

12. Advice of Counsel. The Parties represent that they have had the opportunity, whether or not they have chosen to do so, to discuss this Agreement with legal counsel.

13. Entire Agreement. This Agreement is the entire agreement between the Parties with respect to the ubject matter hereof and supersedes all prior and contemporaneous oral and written agreements and discussions. This Agreement may be aniended only by an agreement in writing signed by all Parties, except that a change in contact information may be made simply by sending notice to the other party.

14. Severability. Each provision of this Agreement is separate, distinct and severable from the others. If any provision is held unenforceable, the rest of the Agreement shall be enforced to the greatest extent possible.

15. Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed and interpreted in accordance with the laws of the State of California.

16. Choice of Venue. The venue for any disputes arising out of this Agreement shall be in the County of Orange. ATC waives any rights that it may have to removal under Code of Civil Procedure section 395.
-5-
48U,!1029flll.H Ml3 53 &_2
264

17. Successors and Assigns. This Agreement and all terms, conditions and obligations contained herein are binding upon and inure to the benefit of any assigns and successors-in-interest of the Parties, and each of them. Each of the Parties represents and warrants that as of the Effective Date none of the claims or causes of action being released herein have been transferred, assigned or otherwise conveyed to any other person or entity, and each of the Parties is the holder of the claims being released.

18. Force Majeure. Neither Party shall be liable for its failure or delay to perform under this Agreement (a) caused by reason of acts of God, wars, revolution, terrorism, civil commotion, or similar unlawful acts of third parties, fire, flood or other casualty, embargo, acts of government in its sovereign capacity, labor difficulties, including without limitation, strikes, slowdowns, business shutdowns, government regulations preventing performance, epidemics or pandemics preventing performance, labor or supply shortages preventing perfonnance, picketing or boycotts, .
or any other similar circumstances beyond the reasonab1e control and not involving any fault or negligence of such Party, and (b) provided that Party gives prompt notice to the other Party and makes all commercially reasonable efforts to perfonn.
[ continued on following page]
4Sl!i?i02900!MMl3 538.2
265

19. Signatures. By signing below, the Parties acknowledge that they have read understo d, and agree to all of the terms f this Agreement.

Dated: June 29, 2023 By:

Dated: June JL., 2023 By:

APPROVED AS TO FORM:

Dated: July~. 2023 By:

Dated: June _S_, 2023 By:
-7-
§8ll3~099!W~ MG5J8.2

CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE

AMERICAN TOWER MANAGEME T,
LLC4/ . - Margaret R binson
Vice President Legal Operations UST
American Tower Management, LLC
Elizabeth A. Mitchel l
City Attorney for the City of San
Clemente
Emily L. Murr~{ )
Counsel to Alll&F~wer Management,
LLC

EXHIBIT
'
266
267

ORAN GE COUNTY FI RE A UTHORI TY
Plan Submittal Criteria
COMMERCIAL projects, MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL projects
and RESIDENTIAL TRACT developments

INSTRUCTIONS
• Fill in the project/business address and provide a brief description of the scope of work and type of business operation that will take place. • Answer questions 1 through 10, read and initial items 11 and 12, then complete and sign the certification section. • If you answer: - "YES" to any part of questions 1 through 10, submit the type of plan indicated in italics to OCFA. • In some cases, other plan types not indicated herein may also be necessary depending on specific conditions or operations. • Visit www.ocfa.org for submittal information and locations. If you need assistance in filling out this form or have questions regarding requirements for review, please contact OCFA at 714-573-6108 or visit us at 1 Fire Authority Road, Irvine, CA 92602.

Address
616 Del Dios
I Suite I City
San Clemente
Project Scope/Business Description
Destack Cell Tower from 138' to 70'
YES NO
I . 0 Q Construction of a new building, a new story, or increase the footprint of an existing building? Changes to roadways, curbs, or drive aisles? Addition, relocation, or modification of fire hydrants or fences/gates? Construction within 300 feet of an active or proposed oil well? Fire Master Plan (PRJ 45)

2. I:\ 0 Property is adjacent to a wildland area or non-irrigated native vegetation? "'-' Fire Master Plan (PRJ 45); a Fuel Modificahon Plan may also be required. (PRJ 20, PRJ 24)

3. r:l!Q Located in or< 100' from a Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR) field boundary,< 300' from "'-' an oil/gas seep, or< 1000' from a landfill? Methane Work Plan. (PRJ 70)

4. ~o

5.r;ao

7. ~o
s.r;ao
Installation/modification/repair of underground piping, backflow preventers, or fire department connections serving private fire hydrant/sprinkler/standpipe systems? Underground Plan. (PR470, PR475) Drinking/dining/recreation/meetings/training/religious functions or other gatherings in a room > 750 sq.ft. (> 1,000 sq.ft. for training/adulteducation) or> 49 people? Healthcare/outpatient services for> 5 people who may be unable to immediately evacuate without assistance? Education for children (academic tutoring for ages 5+ is exempt unless classified as an E occupancy by the Building Official)? Adult/child daycare? 24-hour care/supervision? Incarceration or restraint? Hotel/apartment or residential facility with 3+ units and 3+ stories ( 3-story townhouseslrowhouses where an independent direct exit to grade is provided for dwelling are exempt)? Congregate housing/dormitories with 17+ people? High-rise structure (55+ feet to highest occupied floor level)? Architectural Plan (PR200-PR285) Installation/modification of locks delaying or preventing occupants from leaving a space or requiring use of a card, button, or similar action to open a door in the direction of exit travel? Architectural, Sprinkle,; and/or Alarm Plan depending on the occupanC) and type of device installed (PR200-PR280, PR420-PR425, PR500-PR520) Installation/modification/use of spray booths; dust collection; dry cleaning; industrial ovens/drying equipment; industrial/commercial refrigeration systems; compressed gasses; tanks for cryogenic or flammable/combustible liquids; vapor recovery; smoke control; battery back-up/charging systems (> 50 gal. electrolyte, > 1,000 lb. lithium ion); welding/brazing/soldering, open flame torches, cutting/grinding; or other similar operations? Special Equipment Plan (PR315, PR340-PR382)
Storage/use/research with flammable/combustible liquids or other chemicals? Motor vehicle/aircraft maintenance/repair? Cabinetry/woodworking/finishing facility? Chem Class & floor plan (/11/1 architectural plan if H occupancy); Special Eq11ipment Plans may be necessa, y. (PR315-PR360, PR232-PR240)

9. 0 Q Storage or merchandizing areas in excess of 500 sq. ft. where items are located higher than 12' (6' for high-hazard commodities, plastic, rubber, foam, etc.)? High-piled Storage Plan (PR330) JO. r:ll Q Cooking under a Type I commercial hood; installation or modification of a fire extinguishing system located in a "" commercial cooking hood? Hood & Duct Extinguishing System, not just the hood mechanical plan. (PR335) Initial each of the following two items indicating that you have read and understand the statement:
11 . ;::; '!:". Col l.,4112
4,W
12 Initials • Cariiae:r:-
nne :s.:.• Col -
*Sprinklers/Alarms: Consult Building/Fire Codes and ordinances to determine sprinkler/alarm requirements; if a system is required, plans shall be submitted for OCFA review. Existing buildings undergoing remodel must be evaluated by a licensed contractor to determine if modification is needed· if so, contractor shall submit plans Qrior to makinQ modifications. Fire Hazard Severity Zone: Consult maps available at building department or 6n OCFA website to aetermine if your site is located jg a fHsz syugjggs jg a fHsz may be subject to seecjal cogstryctjog regyjremegts getaueg jg csc chapter 76 or cRc B327-
 WKH EXLOGLQJ GHSDUWPHQW ZLOO GHWHUPLQH VSHFLILF UHTXLUHPHQWV , FHUWLI\ XQGHU SHQDOW\ RI SHUMXU\ XQGHU WKH ODZV RI WKH 6WDWH RI &DOLIRUQLD WKDW WKH DERYH LV WUXH

3ULQW 1DPH
&DUULDQQH &ROH 6LJQDWXUH&DUULDQQH &ROH &DUULDQQH&ROH






 
7  !. .
!



!


!. 

8 

  9:;< 

! ,6



!8  
 ;0'
.8  ,
#
  
 ,

=
!
  ,

! &
    8



 
!
;0' .8 


 +!
 




!

!
,,

!. ,

,,.  ;0' ,
  


! 

! 
;0' 
 
 !.
! ,,



!  

& 8
!
!
,,,
 ,


   ;0' .8 



268
269
Date:

Application Number:

Address:

Applicant:

Owner:

Contractor:

Project Description:

Construction Valuation:

Description

BLDG PC FEE
PlANNINGPC FEES

INVOICE / RECEIPT
City of San Clemente
910 Calle Negocio, San Clemente, CA 92673
Office: (949) 361-6100
06/08/2023
B23-1495
616DELDIOS
Carrianne Cole

TOWER, AMERICAN
MANAGEMENTINC;
TBD

ES - CELL SITE MODIFICATION
$20,000.00

FEES DUE
Account
00 l-000-34121-000-00000
00 l-000-34127-000-00000
EPRS
Amount
$224.09
SS0.00
TOTAL Fees Charged: $274.09
Payments Received: $0.00
Balance Due: ------ $274.09
Uroe I iroifalioo gf Pleo (bw:k Applimlioo An application for a permit for any proposed work shall be deemed to have been abandoned 360 days after the date of filing, unless such application has been pursued in good faith or permit has been issued; except that the Building Official is authoriZed to grant one or more extensions oftime for additional periods not exceeding 90 days each. The extension shall be requested in writing prior to expiration and justifiable cause demonstrated . la order to renew action on an application after expiration the applicant shall resubmit plans and pay a new plan check fee.

WHEN VALIDATED, THIS IS YOUR RECEIPT

PLEASE TAKE OUR CUSTOMER SURVEY
Scan our QR code or go to www.san-clemente.org/cdsurvey 270
City of San Clemente Building Permit Application
Permit#: ______ Valuation: _20_0_00_.o_o ___ _
Job Address: 616 DEL DIOS SAN CLEMENTE, CA 92672
Tract: Lot: APN: 690-681-64
Name of owner: American Tower Corp. Phone#:
-------
Address: 10 PRESIDENTAL WAY City: Woburn state: ~Zip: 01801 Email: ________________ _
Architect/Designer: ____________ Phone#: _______ _
Address: ___________ City: _____ State: ___ Zip: ___ _
Email: _________________ License#: ______ _
Engineer: Esha K. Modi Phone#: _______ _
Address: 3500 REGENCY PARKWAY, SUITE 100 City: Cary State: ~ Zip: 27518 Email: _________________ License#: _C_9_2_8_2_7 ___ _
Contractor: TBD Phone#:
--------
Address: ___________ City: _____ State: ___ Zip: ___ _
Email: License#: ______ _
Contact for Plan Review Comments
Name: camanne Cole Email: [email protected]
DESCRIPTION OF WORK: Destack a tower from 138' to 70'
SIGNATURE: _________________ DATE: ____ _
Owner: D Agent: IZ] Contractor: D ArchitecUDesigner: D
910 Calle Negocio, San Clemente CA. 92673. Office (949)361-6100

BUILDING INFORMATION
TYPE OF BUILDING: Single Family/Duplex Residential: __ ADU: __ _ Multi Family Residential: Number of Units: __ _
Mixed Use Commercial/Residential: # commercial units: # residential units:

Commercial: X other:
----------
USE OF BUILDING: Cell Tower
--------- expl: restaurant, factory, dwelling
CONSTRUCTION TYPE: Modification NUMBER OF STORIES:
---
SPRINKLERS: new: 0 Type: ____ expl: NFPA 13, 13R, 13D
ZONING: GP: _____ CUP: ______ _
HIGH FIRE SEVERITY AREA: YES: NO:

AREAS OF EXISTING BUILDINGS: indicate in square feet
Residence: __ _ Garage: __ _ Deck: __ _ Porch: __ _
Addition: Remodel: Repair: __ Demolition:

Tenant Improvement: ___ _
Pools area: __ _ Spa area: __ _
AREAS OF NEW CONSTRUCTION: indicate in square feet
Residence: __ _ Garage: __ _ Deck: __ _ Porch: __ _
Addition: Remodel: Repair: __ Demolition:

Tenant Improvement: ___ _
Pools area: __ _ Spa area:

Reviews: office use only
First submittal: ____ _ Second submittal: ____ Third submittal: ___ _ Date Due Notes:















!"
!#$

%





##&'''(&)!#**+,(',&-'!(.
/0


 1.)'-.#'#$

 2
3 435
2
3 4645.
75893:0


 ;<
=#(#'#$*>$'

 
.'*>''%

 








 

 




 











 




!"#!"$
%


&&'






 





($(%
%)  *
(+,#--!#,-.





 



<?
2 @3A4B,&'

:3 235
758,#(+$
3CC2 >,*,9$(&9(&&$B
2
>
645.
75893:
271

















!
"







#
$%$
!&$'!&%(
#$)

* *&+
,


 
-*(!%%
&)& &
./0.1/2345/6645/

 7..51.88. 9:51.88.;5.61/<6=.5,


 ><?)&@ & !#-&$

+&'-&&"












 













 
! 
"
#


#


"$
%&

'
( 

)*


&
+


 








,
&-'
.


/

$,%
&


01*
2


,1**
0345)

,&&6
&&$

7
/
" 1*3*3)1*833/
'
/6'
$
%&

7 

98:0)44;#,,2*1*3*;
<

/


 

































































!












"





















#

$
%



&'

('(&


)(*++, -
.
/
01 2
* 









!

3










4

5





"







(-
67

/

8

/

8

89
:(
;(
<9 6*

:'5==(5'=>














*

8
9


7 !
%


?3
@
@$9








/




?%
8


9



8A






































3








B






















!








C


!
D






#
55 












272
273
Site Acquisition Division
Mobile: (480) -
T o\Ner Engineering Professionals, Inc.
4710 E. Elwood St., Suite 91 Phoenix, AZ 85040
www.tepgroup.net
Thank you,
Kellie Strenme
Project Specialist
Site Acquisition Division
Mobile: (480) -
T o\Ner Engineering Professionals, Inc.
4 710 E. Elwood St., Suite 9 I Phoenix, AZ 85040
www.tepgroup.net
Planning Memorandum
0HPRUDQGXP
3ODQQLQJ'LYLVLRQ

7R
 &LW\'HSDUWPHQWV5HJLRQDO$JHQFLHV3XEOLF8WLOLW\2IILFHV8636 )URP
 6DUD7RPD6HQLRU3ODQQHU 
6XEMHFW
 $GGUHVV&RQILUPDWLRQIRU'HO'LRV&6
7KLVLVWRFRQILUPWKHDGGUHVVIRUDZLUHOHVVFRPPXQLFDWLRQIDFLOLW\DWµ'HO'LRV &6¶RQWKHVLWHEHORZ
6LWHLQIRUPDWLRQ
6LWH$VVHVVRU¶V3DUFHO1XPEHU
$31



6LWH3ODQ
,I\RXKDYHDQ\TXHVWLRQVSOHDVHFRQWDFWPHDW7RPDV#VDQFOHPHQWHRUJ 274
275
From:

Su~:

To:

Cc:

Sent:

Luaces, Ogaidla <[email protected]>
RE: Cel T0"'8r In San Clemenle
Wri!tl~ ChriSIOpher <[email protected]>
Glenn Francis <[email protected]>
March 2, 2023 11 :35 AM (UTC-05:00)
Greatl Thank you.

Have a nice dayl
Olgali Luaces
(714) 667-3278
, . .. o • 4 t le I r,t t
L PublicWork
OCSurvey
From: Wright, Christopher <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, March 2, 2023 8:33 AM
To: Luaces, Olgalidia <[email protected]> Cc: Glenn Francis <[email protected]>
subject: RE: Cell Tower in San Clemente
Attention: This email originated from outside the County of Orange. Use caution when opening attachments or links.

Use this file. Thanks.

From: Wright, Christopher
Sent: Thursday, March 2, 2023 8:32 AM
To: Luaces, Olgalldia <0lealldla Luaces@ocpw oqov com>
Cc: Glenn Francis <[email protected]>
subject: RE: Cell Tower in San Clemente
Hello 01galldia,
The address will be 620 Del Dios CS. The ·cs· Is the Sempra Identifier for "Cell Site.· An address memo is attached. This is being distributed to our agency and utility list.

From: Scott, Meredith <ScottMJ@sarxJemeote orp
Sent: Tuesday, February 28, 2023 7:41 AM
To: Luaces, Olgalidia <01ealldla I uaces@ocpw oqov com> Cc: Glenn Francis <[email protected]>; Wright, Christopher <[email protected]> SUbject: RE: Cell Tower In San Clemente
Good morning Olgalidia,
One of our Planners will be getting back to you with further details regarding this address.

Have a good day,
Meredith
Meredith Scott I City of San Clemente
AdmlnistratiYa Assls1ant I PlaMlng Di~sion 910 cane Nogoao, San Clemen•. CA 92673 949 361.8183
hl!l>~- -f8n-dol'l'8nle.prg
From: Luaces, Olgalidia <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 1:22 PM
To: Scott, Meredith <[email protected]>
Cc: Glenn Franck <afraocls@fidlertooeoeloeedoe com>
SUbJect: FW: Celi Tower in San Clemente
Hello,
I am the contact person for the County of Orange addressing. I received an Inquiry for an address for a cell tower In San Clemente. Based on the parcel number (690-552-05) provided by the applicant (cc'd on this email), this Is the j urlsdictlon of the city of San Clemente. Below is a screenshot of our landbase that shows it is not unincorporated. Applicant has attempted to apply for an address with the city and Is referred back to the County. If your records Indicate something different than what my landbase shows, please let me know so we could work together the assist the applicant.

Thank you.













&'

 


*1
 5 ! "4!$??%

+
+








(
.



0

9


(


+


1
 



(

C79


 

1




:

 D>19)
  


/
+


 



+'




 )B


 (  
(<
:1
(@9

 (

A )












(



+






(




 

+.


<
1
(@
276
City of San Clemente
, ,a~• - I I t• M 11 I
C PublicWorks
o.,; ........ o ... .t.~ ,, ... ,
*+


+

 )

+ :
















%



.
 <%.@
=!4E,
.
.
%
%> 5!4



   




*


+
+








 
'.)
< 


, 
+
.)

.)*
.)@

!
9F

B



(


( G9.0&&

9F



 HH



(







  

9 )$ E
+.



 





.G
I-(



+

(
(
( )  

 


+

)
E







)

 

(
)
 9 )



( 


 
(9 )
 1+




)9F






1




(
(

 


 
8.



$""66"=5=445?##=5!

 

1$=>!?? !?8



 

 


 %






++
(

1

9
1 
$<6!6@>=5=?"6
1

$+
+





 








277
City of San Clemente
, <I.••.' t• U a I I
L C PublicWorks
o., ~••••• .. , .... ,cc.__., ... ,
278
From: Ataman, Adam </O=EXCHANGEI..ABS/aFEXCHANGE ADMII\ISTRATIVE GROUP (FYDIBO-F23SPDLT)/CN=RECIPIENTSICN=BFAAC2DF80AC48EF8DE9A5DA3584E314- ATAMANA>
Subject: RE: RSC• Cox 5 G Antenna• An-erican T<W«S PN 690-552-05 Komey Morrow- To:

Cc: Voona Barnes ; CodeCool)iance <CodeCon'l>[email protected]>; Hal, AMy <[email protected]!J>; Sharp Sheryl Sent:
<sshar!>(!i!clrismanaQ8ffl8nlcom>: Gellardo-Daly, Cecil a <[email protected]!J>; Ferguson, Rebert <[email protected]>; Aoor&N MorrowUSA ]£Ii.ii !fa bb IJl&M HI Kortney,
The current tower Is approximately 138 feet tall, with a total height of 156 feet measured to the top of the highest existing appurtenance attached to the tower. The applicant for the current Wireless Communications Facilities Application (No. WMS23-231) is Dish Wireless, LLC. Please let me know If you have any other questions. Thanks I Sincerely,
Adam Atamian
Deputy Community Development Director/
City Planner
p: /949) 361-6196
[email protected]
~ p •H cons d« dwe....., ranm.,t ti.for• sw 11t "I th , • ma From: Kortney Morrow
Sent: Friday, July 14, 2023 1:32 PM
To: Atamian, Adam <[email protected]>
Cc: Vonne Barnes <lllllllllllliiillililllilli~; CodeCompliance <[email protected]>; Han, Andy <[email protected]>; Sharp Sheryl <[email protected]>; Gallarde>-Daly, Cecilia <Gallarde>[email protected]>; Ferguson, Robert <[email protected]>; Andrew Morrow/USA Subject: Re: RSC• Cox 5 G Antenna• American Towers PN 690-552-05 HI Adam,
can you please clarify what the current height of the tower is? Secondly, who submitted the recent application for the new 'cellular' wireless communications facility? Thank you so much for your assistance!
Kortney & Andrew Morrow
On Jul 13, 2023, at 4:53 PM, Atamian, Adam <AtarnlanA@sao-demeote orp wrote:

HIVonne,
Thank you for your correspondence about this Issue. I have conferred with City staff In the Building and Engineering Divisions to review the situation. Currently, American Tower Corporation has a pending appHcatlon to de-stack the tower to reduce the height to 70', and most recently has applied for a permit to replace the existing wireless facmtles. Neither of these permits have been issued by the City yet. As far as undergrounding of private communication lines, the California Electrical Code exempts such work from requiring permits issued by the City.

I reviewed the tract map for this area and do not see any easements llsted between the tower property and the RSC HOA-owned property between the tower and the end of Del Dlos, though there are others that appear to follow some of the access roads leading to the tower. I have attached a copy for your reference. Please note, not all easements, especially private easements the City is not party to, appear on tract maps. There may be other easements that exist which do not appear on tract maps.

Regarding what the City can do if work, not requiring permits, ls being conducted on RSC HOA property without private easement rights or HOA approval, this situation Is not enforceable by Code Compliance. I recommend you contact your legal counsel to determine what remedies you may have. If there Is unauthorized trespassing on this property, that Is an issue enforced by OCSD.

Slncerely,
Adam Atamian
Deputy Community Development Director/
Qty Planner
p: /949) 361-6196
[email protected]
Ji, •secons der the.,.., ronnaitblforepr nt ncth s wma
From: Vonne Barnes
Sent: Thursday, July 13, 2023 10:36 AM
To: Toma, Sara <IomaS@sao-demeote or.a>; Atamian, Adam <A.tamlanA@san-t;lemeote oca>; CodeCompliance <CndeCompHance@sao;:<;le:meote are> Cc: Hall, Andy <[email protected]>; Morrow Kortney ; Sharp Sheryl <[email protected]> Subject: RSC• Cox 5 G Antenna • American Towers PN 690-S52-05 RSC• Cox 5 G Antenna • American Towers PN 690-552-05
Sara Toma, Code Compliance, Adam Atamian,
Would you be so kind as to review the following and send an email rl!l)ly to this correspondence.

It is our understanding that:
• crews associated with Cox cable and American Towers are In the process of installing underground fiber optic cables under/upon property owned by RSCCA/RSCBP. Such installation encroaches upon land outside the Public ROW along Del Dios in Harbor View Estates eastward up the slope across and under PN 609 5S2-09 ( RSCCA/ RSCBP) to PN 690 552-05 (American Towers) .
• American Towers and/or Cox cable have not applied for a city permit fir installation of fibre optic cable and 5 G Antenna • American Towers and/or Cox Cable do not have a lease or easement agreement with RSCCA/RSCBP for access across PN 690-552-09 • American Towers does not have a lease or easement agreement with RSCCA/RSCBP property for access access; 279
If this Is correct, wlll you please Issue a notice to American Towers/COX to cease operations untll dty appllcaltons, lndudlng lease and easement agreements with RSCCA/RSCBP have been submitted for review and approval.

Respectf~,
Vome Barnes
RSCCA Board President
4#JM(-
5
280
CltyGIS'" --1~ PJ~JJMMAP
&,7<2)6$1&/(0(17(
:LUHOHVV&RPPXQLFDWLRQV)DFLOLWLHV$SSOLFDWLRQ6FUHHQLQJ)RUP )RUDFFRPPRGDWLRQXQGHU6HFWLRQ

D
RIWKH0LGGOH&ODVV7D[5HOLHIDQG
-RE&UHDWLRQ$FWRIIRUIDFLOLWLHVRXWVLGHRIWKHSXEOLFULJKWRIZD\ 3URMHFW$GGUHVV
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $SSOLFDQW&DUULHU
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 7KLV IRUP VHUYHV WR DVVLVW WKH &LW\ RI 6DQ &OHPHQWH LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU D SURSRVHG FROORFDWLRQ RU PRGLILFDWLRQWRDQH[LVWLQJZLUHOHVVFRPPXQLFDWLRQVIDFLOLW\TXDOLILHVDVDQHOLJLEOHIDFLOLWLHVUHTXHVWDQGRUZRXOG FDXVHDVXEVWDQWLDOFKDQJHDVGHILQHGE\WKH)&&3OHDVHVXEPLWWKHIROORZLQJ 
† &RPSOHWHG$SSOLFDWLRQ)RUP
$SSOLFDWLRQ)HH

† /HWWHURI$XWKRUL]DWLRQIURP:LUHOHVV&DUULHU
5)&RPSOLDQFH$QDO\VLV
LIDSSOLFDEOH

† 'LJLWDO&RS\RI3ODQV
SGI

† 3KRWRVLPXODWLRQVDQGRU&XUUHQW6LWH3KRWRV
 ,VWKLVDQH[LVWLQJDSSURYHGZLUHOHVVFRPPXQLFDWLRQVIDFLOLW\" ,I12VWRSILOOLQJRXWWKLVIRUP7KHSURMHFWUHTXLUHVDGLVFUHWLRQDU\SHUPLW ,I<(6OLVWSUHYLRXVDSSURYDOVIRUFHOOXODULQVWDOODWLRQVDWWKHVLWH LQFOXGHHQWLWOHPHQWDQG
EXLOGLQJSHUPLWQXPEHUV

 'HVFULEHLQGHWDLOWKHH[LVWLQJDSSURYHGIDFLOLW\,QFOXGHIDFLOLW\W\SHVL]HKHLJKWQXPEHURI H[LVWLQJDQWHQQDVH[LVWLQJHTXLSPHQWHWF
 'HVFULEHLQGHWDLOWKHSURSRVHGZLUHOHVVIDFLOLW\PRGLILFDWLRQV,QFOXGHQXPEHURIDQWHQQDVUHPRWH UDGLRXQLWVFDELQHWVDQGRUHTXLSPHQWSURSRVHGIRUUHPRYDOUHSODFHPHQWRUDGGLWLRQ  'HVFULEHWKHSURSRVHGFRQFHDOPHQWHOHPHQWVDQGRUWHFKQLTXHVDQGKRZLIDWDOOWKHSURMHFW ZRXOGDOWHUWKHH[LVWLQJFRQFHDOPHQWHOHPHQWV
† <HV †1R
2M NE of San Clemente San Clemente, CA 92672
Dish Wireless, L.L.C.
&RQGLWLRQDO3HUPLW1R&See attached for prioU CUP.

Existing wireless facility tower is 137' tall with (2) horn mounts, (1) 8' dipole, (1) omni antenna, and (2) platforms with handrails.

See scope of work on attached site plans for more details.

See scope of work on attached site plans for more details.

The proposed tower will decrease in height by 62.5'. The project will not affect the existing concealment elements.

The proposed tower height will decrease from 137' to 75'. There will be (3) panel antennas, (3) sector mounts, (6) RRUs, (3) Back to Back mounts, (1) OVP, and (1) Hybrid Cable. (1) Equipment cabinet is proposed. 281
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
282
ELIGIBLE fACILIIY CRITERIA

5. Does the project increase the facility height by 10% or more than 20 feet?

6. Does the project increase the width by more than 20 feet or protrude beyond the width of the tower at the level of the appurtenance?

7. Does the project involve the installation of four or more equipment cabinets?

8. Does the project defeat the existing concealment elements of the tower?

9. Does the project include any excavation or new ground equipment outside of the current leased/owned wireless facility area?

10. Is the project inconsistent with the original conditions of approval under which the project site was approved and developed?
Yes
□ Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
If you answered YES to any questions in this section, stop filling out this form. The project requires a discretionary permit.

AppucANJ'§ GEBIIE IG8IIAN
0No
0No
0No
0No
0No
0No
As the Applicant/Representative for the Applicant, I acknowledge that the above information and supporting documents are, to the best of my knowledge, an accurate and complete representation of the proposed project. I understand that the City of San Clemente will rely on my responses to evaluate whether to process this application in accordance with the FCC's regulations under 47 C.F.R. § 1.40001 et seq., and I acknowledge that any inaccuracies may result in the application being deemed incomplete or the request for approval pursuant to Section 6409(a) being denied.

Applicant Name: _K_e_ll_ie_S_t_r_e_m_m_e _____ _ Company: Tower Engineering Professionals E-Mail Address: [email protected] Phone No: 480 ______ _ Signature:-~-~--- _S_c~ ______ _ Date: 6-30-23

FOR CITY USE ONLY
Zoning Review No.: ____________ Submittal Date: _________ _ STAFF DETERMINATION:
□ APPROVED. This project meets criteria for review under 6409(a). A discretionary planning permit is not required for the proposed collocation/wireless facility modification. Proceed to building plan check.
□ NOT APPROVED. This project represents a "substantial change" to the existing facility, as defined by the FCC, and is not eligible for review under 6409(a). Approval of a ___________ application is required before the project may be submitted into building plan check.

Signature: ________________ _ Date: ------------ Planner Name, Title: ___________________________ _

  







 








  
 






 
  !"#!$%&'(
!)!!*






%


+


&


, 
-.



/

0, '

0
1
1


2
,
2  --

*







+

 


-
- +


 ,,



%



-,,-22
-,
0-,

-1

&
- 31
- 4"!5&)"!%&
- 




- 
 !!5&)!!%&

 











   










 !


!
"
#$%&
 

!'(
)* 

'

 

+

'
(
!,-
#%!#
#&
.#/'


*0


 

+

,1.






2 !
34

) -
)0

0


) 
)
5
!
'(
)
 !6 ( *6 (   0  + 
'
(
!,-
#%!#
#&
.##'
 

!'(
)* 

'

 

+
7

,
*







 +

,1.






2!
3
) 


0


)



6
((
3  (

8 


((
 





9(

)0 
-:$

;;#
;<0 ((-

)
00 

: 4(

)  <!
)  
)= (



)






9  
)


(-
)
)
 



0
("00 

)

0
(
00



((
)
)


( 
(- 5

)


3

 (
( 

)
(




)
)


(-)!0
5
 (5

)
) 

)00 


)
5

283















 !6 ( 

'
(
!,-
#%!#
#&

.;;"'








 








2!
3 (

5
(


!-

))

 
0 >?3

(
)

-

(

8 

#@
!-
3  (

) 0
)(

A





!
)



6
(

)= (



)
)
) 
 :(8-<3


)
(
4 )
((0




!
(
 

((


'
 ( 
)
 
0
(

)






:0-<
284
City of San Clemente
, ,a~• - I I t• M 11 I
C PublicWorks
o.,; ........ o ... .t.~ ,, ... ,
,

 




)



)8




















"(




):
"<
$

B




"
!
"
#%



   

7

,











 









6

:'0
) 5
(B )

1
 !70
 !, ( <





3C0=
( 


5

)321 

(3C





)D
D((
 
 0
( 
(
) 
)((3) .#'





)  

((
(7EF 

 0
00 



0
)
) ) (()((

(0


! 

!

!

)
00 (
)
3) 


(5

)((

)  

3) ()-


!

 3C





-
5
)
 

)
(()7 (

.&&//&$%$!

%;GG$%

(
)0 
- .$

;;#
; 

)0 

)((

) 
"

 


 



(-

00 
(3 
- )(
.:/
/<
$%$;&/-
 .







 )
5
5
(

285
City of San Clemente
, <I.••.' t• U a I I
L C PublicWorks
o., ~••••• .. , .... ,cc.__., ... ,
286
From:

Subject:

To:

Sent:

Will do!
Crockett, Katie </O=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP (FYDIBOHF23SPDL 1)/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=D12BC3D28D6E4DA79991 F9FF4E7C509F-CROCKETT, K> RE: Wireless site upgrade to PID#690-552-05- LSSNA01020A-89366 Kari Brown <[email protected]>
September 30, 2021 5:26 PM (UTC-04:00)
Katie Crockett
Associate Planner
[email protected]
(949) 361-6188
From: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, September 30, 2021 2:12 PM
To: Crockett, Katie <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Wireless site upgrade to Pl D#690-552-0S- LSSNA01020A-89366 Thank you, Katie! Let me know if I can be of any help.

Have a super rest of the week.

Kari
Kari Brown
Site Acquisition
Tower Engineering Professionals
500 East 84th Road, suite C10
Thornton, CO 80229
From: Crockett, Katie <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, September 30, 2021 3:09 PM
To: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Wireless site upgrade to Pl D#690-552-0S- LSSNA01020A-89366 Hi Kari -
I am working on this. We had previously denied modifications under 6409 for modifications as eligible facilities requests. ATM has provided us some information from their attorney which we are reviewing w ith the City Attorney's office. I will let you know as soon as I have direction on how to handle this.

Best,
Katie Crockett
Associate Planner
[email protected]
(949) 361-6188
287
From: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, September 30, 20211:22 PM
To: Crockett, Katie <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Wireless site upgrade to Pl 0#690-552-05- LSSNA01020A-89366 HI Katie,
Have you been able to find anything on this site and what my process will be to add antennas and ground equipment to this site?
Looking forward to hearing from you.

Thank you!
Kari
Kari Brown
Site Acquisition
Tower Engineering Professionals
500 East 84th Road, suite Cl0
Thornton, CO 80229
From: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2021 2:20 PM
To: 'Crockett, Katie' <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Wireless site upgrade to Pl 0#690-552-05 LSSNA01020A-89366 Hi Katie,

33.443676, -117.588670
1hl; is a bit bizarre, but I can't seem to find the AP . I did find the lat /long (see above) and I took a snip it of the area. I also put in the PID # I found:
6~552-05
Please let me know if this gets you there.
1banks,
Kari
Kari Brown
Site Acquisition
Tower Engineering Professionals
500 East 84th Road, suite ClO
Thornton, CO 80229
From: Crockett, Katie <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 20211:59 PM
To: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Wireless site upgrade to PID#690-552-05 LSSNA01020A-89366 288
Hi Kari -
Please provide an address or APN.

Katie Crockett
Associate Planner
[email protected]
(949) 361-6188
From: Kari Brown <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 202112:23 PM
To: Crockett, Katie <[email protected]>
Subject: Wireless site upgrade to Pl D#690-552-05 LSSNA01020A-89366 Hello Katy,
DISH wireless is going to be co locating equipment on this ATC tower. I have been contracted by ATC to zone and permit the site for them. We are adding 3 antennas on the tower with one coax line and a 5 x 7 platform for the cabinets within the lease space of compound. Can you please tell what the process will entail for zoning? I look forward to hearing from you.

Thank you,
Kari
Kari Brown
Site Acquisition
Tower Engineering Professionals
500 East 84th Road, suite Cl0
Thornton, CO 80229











 





 

 




 


!
 








 "#$%&'&(&)')&*+,

(-((.

 



 













 


 



/%$



*

*


01


2 (3

42&5')
677+282.)5

5 2(

!99











!

"
 

#
$%$&$'()&$



 

*

!

"+






!

"


 ,)







 
-




  
-



 










 

*

!

"
 

#
$%$&$'*)$'








!

"


 #.)









-/

  



 






0


1

1

0




2
"
 

#
$%$&$'*)$$



 

*

!

"
3

#












"


 #.)








-
 






 


1





-
2


4













5


 


678&!99$!&9:2 



6

/
 

: 

 ;



 





5



















<











  






 

-






 

















  



 






289






 

!








0


1


 

#
$%$&$'*&)99<














 








-









  



=+-




4
$>8-
2 


 


?



 


1




2;






  

6

4
:-



/
2





























 





6

:
290
City of San Clemente
, ,a~• - I I t• M 11 I
C PublicWorks
o.,; ........ o ... .t.~ ,, ... ,
#






2


 4









 

!









<




 6
<
:
7&*@,





<


<8$%&*
 






3

#















  
1 
26




, !
!.

2

3



2

#
2

:



-A
;





 B-

.

00


-A
 CC










  


-
2
)$@





 










B3DE












2 
 






2

@




2
 
2

-
2





 


 


-
2

 





2 -A








 

 



 3





)''(('7%7!**%9FF7%&

 



)78&!99$!&9





 

 


 

<














-




)6(&(:87%!79'(
)













291
City of San Clemente
, <I.••.' t• U a I I
L C PublicWorks
o., ~••••• .. , .... ,cc.__., ... ,



 












 !"

!#$
%





&'()&!&*+$&+!*'&!!!'(!(,




-



./00
12/
330/ /3/

 1/
/4
1+563,0/ /3/71
8-


 !/9
:
;#<#(#$&.#= 
,(=.((%














 




>>/?/06
03338@613
'+(00//81130/ /3/'#)<$
'&'7&'*7)(*$
3/
30A7#(#+
?.

222763,0/ /3/71
8
 




 
 
!"


!#$#%#&
'#(










 ")'*+

,

-
+ +
 . 
*
/!



0

1


1

0 
+2 
 
!"


!#$#%#&
'##

 





3"

.

.



 ")'*+

,
-
 
. 
!.1

-2
4
!.

.
+
5
 


678%
99#
%9:2
! 


6 
:  ;
. !.
5+
 .




 +

<



!.


+  !
.

/ 
!-.!

 ..
+
!


 +
/++
+/  

 


*
/!





292
City of San Clemente












0

1


 
!"


!#$#%#&
%'99<

.

.



 *+

,
-
!

+/
.!




 
 
!

+
=>-
!


!
4
!#?8

-2 
*

!
@.

! 
!.1

2;



+  +64


+:-

+
2


!
+


.
!
! +
 !.
6

+:
".
.!

2
!.
 4

















!<

 6<:
7%
AB


<
<8#$%



   
293
, ,a ~•• I I te U 1 1 I
C PublicWorks
O.•;••••• .. • O..,.t.~h•u,
,J.. IJ C
, ,a ~•• I' t• U I 1 t
C PublicWorks
O••~••••• ... o ... ec~,, ... ,
City of San Clemente
Unincorpo
Orange Co

3"


.

.

  
1
2!6
 /
B 
.
)
!23

2"2:



-C
;+/+ 
-,)00 -C! D
D

+


  
-
2'#A.

* 




3EF+



.++
+
2 * 


.2
!
A

!!2 
+2
-
2
/+ 
 +-
2
 
.
!

2 -C!

!
/+ +
 

* 3

'&&((&7$7

$9GG7$%
 


'78%
99#
%9

 
 
 <!

!

..
+


!

-


 
'6(%(:87$
79&(
!
'.

.
*
/!
/!
294


 



  


 
! "#$%

$&'"
(  
"
 
)$*$+,+
),  ),
&-.$,* $/+0


 1


 2
33
4 565 3
7 5


7666
768
65093
7 5
:
1

 ;

<
5665;

<8
65093
7 5
:
1=9



>9

+8
65093
7 5
:
1


 $
?@6A&B&*&'B2*,"
# 0*-2**(








 









 


!
"#$% &
'()#

  )#
*!
"#$% &
'


 +,
$$-
.)
$% 
/

01$1

.
2

2&
 
$

 %
$&34$$%%

%

.





 


!
"#$% &
'
 



**

)#

  )#
*!
"#$% &
'(



 
!
"#$% &
'


 +,
$$-
.)
$% 





3  %2




. 
.
$
%
 

%%



#$$$
.
53

#
#.   
 

 $
6 

$%


  ..$$

  &
"

)#

  )#
*!
"#$% &
'
 



*7



$
 $
!
"#$% &
'


 

$$-
.)
$% 
8$$

34%

.
.$$ 
 



 
&
-2


 


#

9$$ 9$$&
#
!
#.&
#
6&#
%'
 



*


)#

  )#
*!
"#$% &
'
:$
#
 
#
!
$$
&#
%'


 

$$-
.)
$% 
8$$

3% #
 # 



 

 

9

&3#6;





#$$
.)
$% &<

 #$%=0>""?
6 
$# =##4
 
%$?
 

 @
# 


 # 

)
$% &<$
.

#




$
  

.
 

#

 &A$# 
 % 
$


295


.  # 

#2
 

 &3

#

# 

% 

  . %$


.

$
$ %2
.

.#
$.
2
  



$# &
-2
&














#

9$$
 



*A


#
!
$$
&#
%


 
$$-
.)
$% 
8$$

3#$$
$
.2$

%


  
 
%$

.$$&$
$
B(3
#  

% 
;
C>
 3#6  

-
&
D

  $
 

 

9


6@
# 
  . #$$
.
=

;$
.?&3 %
  .
4 6


 


%



.





 &
#

#$$

. 
#

 
 # 

)
$% =
%$
.?&
296
City of San Clemente
"tee 1 Ro
, ,a~ • - I I t• M 11 I
C PublicWorks
o.,; ........ o ... ~~., ... ,

$

#
 # %

6
 ;


&













 A%
 
)
 =
A)?
0*E&+

) 
) A

A>*



   

:$
#



#
!
$$
&#
%

 

 
9 )6=
#2+ "

")6#

:

 $)6#


$)6#
&&&?

 

3F%
@# 
.
2. 13)8$


&
&
&3F% 
  G G


#$$
.#
%
$
# 
$$& 

36
E&

)
$% &
-


$

)1:H,.$$
## 
$# 


.
.$

.6 
&-



$%


6&E
 %
#
 
# 
6


.
6
  36#
 # 2
.
 


 
#$$
.
 &36#$$

$



6$&3F% 

%

%
2
.

.
$
#  


&-:
)#

 
&7700
"**&II0 #$%
0>""&
$
#

%
$%$
#  


 

 &A


#
#


.
$ $# &3## =77?>0"07 %$
#
!
$$
&#
%&-2
2$&
297
City of San Clemente
, <I.••.' t• U a I I
L C PublicWorks
o., ~••••• .. , .... ,cc.__., ... ,


 



  


 
! "#$%

$&'"
(  
"
 
)$*$+,+
),  ),
&-.$,* $/+0


 1


 2
33
4 565 3
7 5

 869
363:6363:6;869
<
9 4;
9
=;9
71 
 3
55$659
>659
<>833

5 55

5;9
71 


69&&*&'++2''
# 0*-2**(




 )&*

3



33
4 ;
:>

 






 






 

!
" 

#" 


!
$%
&
'(

) 

*

#

$ 




'(


+, 
%
-

 '

. " 




% /   


0-1-'

0 -
1

''



/
/



  

-#-2$

3 '

(
 

*/



452 

!
" 

#" 


!
$%
&
'(

) 

*

#

$ 




'(6#$

3 '

(


+, 
%
-

 '

)'

" 


"
7

% /
/
%
 




.
&














:75
6=



65"36555
=

5 /+* 633


9
65 3
7 5
 /&)?'
/,/;')+;)+.'

2444;
65093
7 5
;


!
" 

#" 


!
$%
&
'(
 

*/
4

27

-#-2$

3 '

(

) 

*

#

$ 




'(


* 
%
-

 '

. 
8
'



"




8&


9



 %
-

 '

:


 
'/;<=
3>>3
>?&/

 

;@
'
 ?A
-

 '

: %



/

%




  



'
 


%

/


8

'



%
'

/
% 
 '
%% %


 







298






 

!








!
" 


 

*/
4

2
>> 



$ 




'


 
%
-

 '

. 
8

%

 
'
/'
 
%
 
 B68

/'
9
C=/8&






 
"



&A




% %;9
/ %?
8'


%
@
&




'

%






 
 %

-

 '
;'
/ %?

299
City of San Clemente
, ,a~• - I I t• M 11 I
C PublicWorks
o.,; ........ o ... .t.~ ,, ... ,
* 

'
&

9








 

!








 '


-; -?
<
2D
+-
-




 =4
2


   

) 

*





$ 




'




  "-&;


+33
-&)

-&* -&

?

 

8E'
A


%
%F8-. !
!



8E'
GG

 %'
 




8
&D
-

 '








-F)H,% 


 


%%
%
&



 '&


D
'

&

%&
8
&


%
 %
8
&
/



&

8E'


'
/'

%% 




)7-




55 <4<3224
>

<4



 
'/<=
3>>3
>
7 


'
 ' 









% /
 


8

/

;5
5?=<43<>
5/'
 

$ 




'




 

300
City of San Clemente
, <I.••.' t• U a I I
L C PublicWorks
o., ~••••• .. , .... ,cc.__., ... ,
Planning Memorandum
0HPRUDQGXP
3ODQQLQJ'LYLVLRQ

7R
 &LW\'HSDUWPHQWV5HJLRQDO$JHQFLHV3XEOLF8WLOLW\2IILFHV8636 )URP
 &KULVWRSKHU:ULJKW$VVRFLDWH3ODQQHU,, 
6XEMHFW
 $GGUHVV&RQILUPDWLRQIRU'HO'LRV&6
7KLVLVWRFRQILUPWKHDGGUHVVIRUDZLUHOHVVFRPPXQLFDWLRQIDFLOLW\DWµ'HO'LRV &6¶RQWKHVLWHEHORZ
6LWHLQIRUPDWLRQ
6LWH$VVHVVRU¶V3DUFHO1XPEHU
$31



6LWH3ODQ
,I\RXKDYHDQ\TXHVWLRQVSOHDVHFRQWDFWPHDW:ULJKW&#VDQFOHPHQWHRUJ 301



 












 !"

!#$
%





&'()&!&*+$&+!*'&!!!'(!(,




-



./00
12/
330/ /3/

 1/
/4
1+563,0/ /3/71
8-


 !/9
:
;#<#(#$&.#) 
,(=.((%



  


 




 




>>/?/06
03338@613
'+(00//81130/ /3/'#)<$
'&'7&'*7)(*$
3/
30A7#(#+
?.

222763,0/ /3/71
8


 







   !" #$#%#&'#()

)
*







 !+',

-.,


/




..

"
*
*0

-1 
 


23


 3


 2*.

   !" #$#%#&'##)



 







4
!
00







 !+',

-.,


/






*0
,
03
 

  0 0


.,

5 
*
"678%
99#
%9:*  " 

**

6


:

; 
0

0,

5
.
0
 "

.

*
 <**



*
 
**
0
 .


 0 "1

,

0   


 00

.
 
 ".*


1..
.1





**


-1 




302
City of San Clemente












23


 
   !" #$#%#&%'99<


00







 ,

-.,


/





  

.1 
0
 
"





 .


*

=>

 

 "

   #?8"

 

*
-  
@0



,
03
 
; 


.



.6 "
.:



. 

 *
 
 
.
 0

  

.
*
 


0,

6*"
.:
!
0


0  0

















,
< 


6,<:
7%
A



<,<8#$%



   
303
, ,a ~•• I I te U 1 1 I
C PublicWorks
O.•;••••• .. • O..,.t.~h•u,
,J.. IJ C
, ,a ~•• I' t• U I 1 t
C PublicWorks
O••~••••• ... o ... ec~,, ... ,
City of San Clemente
Unincorpo
Orange Co

4 !


00





  
3, 6*,1 A


0
+ 4*

!
:




B*;
 

.1
.
C
/+
22, 
B
 




D
D 



.* 

 


 
'#
0,


-

  C4EF.


*
**

0.*.
.
- 
  0 
 *





*.* 




 1.
 




.



 "0

 


B
 


 "1..




 -4) 
'&&((&7$7
$9GG7$% 
*
"'78%
99#
%9)

*


 


< 
 00
.
"


**
 
" 
'6(%(:87$
79&(" 
'
00




-1 1

304
305
From:

Su~:

To:

Sent:

Luaces, Ogaidla <[email protected]>
RE: Cel T0"'8r In San Clemenle
ScOII, Meredith <[email protected]>
February 28, 20231 :17 PM (UTC-05:00)
Thanks Meredith.

Haw a nice day!
Olgali Luaces
(714) 667-3278
, PublicWork
OCSurvey
From: Scott, Meredith <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, February 28, 2023 7:41 AM
To: Luaces, Olgalidia <[email protected]> Cc: Glenn Francis <[email protected]>; Wright, Christopher <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Cell Tower in San Clemente
Attention: This email originated from outside the County of Orange. Use caution when opening attachments or links.

Good morning Olgalidia,
One of our Planners will be getting back to you with further details regarding this address.

Have a good day,
Meredith
Meredith Scott I City of San Clemente
Administrati-.e Assistant I Plannlng DIIAsion
910 cane Nogoao, San a.m.n1a, CA 92673
949.361 6183
hllD~lwww.san-<11nwn1e.org
From: Luaces, Olgalidia <Olgalldla.Luaces@)ocpw.ocgov.com> Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 1:22 PM
To: Scott, Meredith <[email protected]>
Cc: Glenn Francis <&fr;aocls@>fuHectooeoeloeedoe corn>
Subject: FW: Cell Tower in San Clemente
Hello,
I am the contact person for the County of Orange addressing. I received an inquiry for an address for a cell tower in San Clemente. Based on the parcel number (690-552--05) provided by the applicant (cc'd on this email), this Is the Jurisdiction of the city of San aemente. Below is a screenshot of our landbase that shows It is not unincorporated. Applicant has attempted to apply for an address with the city and is referred back to the County. If your records indicate something different than what my landbase shows, please let me know so we could work together the assist the applicant
Thank you.




 
 











'  ( 


  





#! "! $<<&

-
 
 -

 


 


0 
*

 0  


5 

6

 
* 
 -

   


 

  

 *  ) 
@ .6



 







7

A; 

6

+