2024-2026 PLANNING COMMISSIONER ABSENCES AND VOTING RECORD:
Planning
Commissioners
2024-26 Attendance
Record
No Votes Cast
Gurdian- Chair 2024- 3 absences
2025- 2 absences
2026- 0 absence (Jan.
meeting cancelled lack of
quorum)
3 No’s, 1 abstain
-14701 San Pablo Ave Bonfare CUP add General
alcohol sales (voted no to approve)
-2424 Church Lane- 12-unit apartments (voted no
to approve with added condition, moved to
continue; abstained from final approval vote)
-14501 SPA CUP Embarc (voted to deny)
Morris- Vice Chair 2024 - 0 absences
2025 - 1 absence
2026 - 0 absence (Jan.
meeting cancelled lack of
quorum)
3 No’s
-2364 Road 20 – 145 100% Affordable units
(voted no to approve)
-2424 Church Lane- 12-unit apartments (voted no
to approve; voted yes on final approval vote)
-14501 SPA CUP Embarc (voted to deny)
Jackson 2024 - 1 absence
2025 - 3 absences
2026 - 0 absence (Jan.
meeting cancelled lack of
quorum)
3 No’s
- 14701 San Pablo Ave Bonfare CUP add General
alcohol sales (voted no to approve)
- 2424 Church Lane – Voted no on the motion
to continue public hearing (wanted it approved
as recommended by staff)
- 14501 SPA CUP Embarc (voted to deny)
Owens 2024 - 2 absences
2025 - 0 absences
2026 - 0 absence (Jan.
meeting cancelled lack of
quorum)
1 No’s
-14501 SPA CUP Embarc (voted no against
denial; wanted it approved as recommended
by staff)
Feliciano 2024 - 2 absences
2025 - 5 absences
2026- 0 absence (Jan.
meeting cancelled lack of
quorum)
0 No’s, 1 abstain
-14501 SPA CUP Embarc (abstained from
vote to deny)