DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 1 of 12
Resolution No.
COUNCIL MEETING
PROCEDURES AND PROTOCOLS
PURPOSE In General. These Council Meeting Procedures and Protocols (“Meeting Policies”) are designed to guide and facilitate the conduct of City Council meetings in an opena collegial, fair and effective manner that complies with the law . These Meeting Policies were developed using current City policies and practices, the principles and procedures set forth in Rosenberg’s Ru les of Order, Revised 2011
(“Rosenberg’s”), and recommendations for updates from City Councilmembers and City Staff.
Relationship to Rosenberg’s Rules of Order. If In the event of any ambiguity or omission in these Meeting Policies do not contain a rule or procedure that is contained in Rosenberg’s, it is the intent of the City Council that the enumerat ed procedure infull text of Rosenberg’s shallmay be referred to for guidance. Only if expressly provided by this policy shall particular provisi ons of Rosenberg’s be incorporated herein by reference. In the event of any inconsistency between these Meeting Policies and Rosenberg’s, the terms of these policiesMeeting Policies shall govern. A copy of Rosenberg’s is attached for reference.
Relationship to Other Laws . These Meeting Policies are not intended to limit the legal authority of the City Council to act on matters within its lawful jurisdiction. Accordingly, while the City Council should follow this policy, any failure to follow this policy shall not invalidate any otherwise lawful City Council acti on. These policies are also not intended to--and shall not--supersede any applicable meeting conduct or procedural requirements set forth in the City Charter and the Ralph M. Brown Act (“Brown Act”).
Applicability to Other City Boards and, Commissions. and Committees. The City Council intends for these protocolsMeeting Policies to be used not only by the City Council and , but also for all City Boards and, Commissions and Committees for the management of their public meetings.
For that purpose, any references to the “Mayor” in this policy shall be considered references to the “Chai r” for such bodies. Such bodies may adopt supplemental meeting ru les and procedures provided that they are consistent with these Meet ing Policies or otherwise required by law. Any proposed meeting policies by such bodies not consistent herewith or otherwise required by law must first be approved by the City Council.
City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
----------- - - ---- --
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 2 of 12
Resolution No.
POLICY
A. Mayor as Presiding Officer:.
1. As provided in the City Charter, the Mayor (sometime referred to herein as the “Presiding Officer”) shall preside at meetings of the City Council and have the authority to preserve order, enforce the rules of the City Council, and determine the order of business under the rules of the City Council. [Charter Sections 704 and 704.3(b) and (c)]
2. The responsibilities of the
presiding officerPresiding Officer shall
include: (a) ensuring that debate and discussion of an agenda item focuses on the item and the policy in question; (b) managing public input consistent with applicable laws and policies in a fair and consistent manner that allows the efficient conduct of City business; (c) maintaining control of communication between Councilmembers and among Council, City staff and the public; (d) maintaining public and Council decorum; and (e) assuring compliance with these Meeting Policies, including making determinations on points of order. Such determinations shall be final unless overruled by a majority of the Council.
3. The Mayor shall endeavor to facilitate discussion among Councilmembers and, in general, should defer to other
Councilmembers in the making of motions or seconds. That notwithstanding, the Mayor retains the right to fully participate in all Council debate, discussions and decision making.
4. If the Mayor is unavailable to pr eside at a Council meeting due to their absence or disability, the Vice Mayor shall assume presiding officer duties. [City Charter Section
7.5705]
B. Process for Consideration of Agendized Items:.
Council consideration of agendized items shall generally proceed as follows:
1. Mayor introduces the item.
1 2. Staff provides any comments, information, or reports, as appropriate,.
3. Questions from Councilmembers of City staff2.
3.4. Staff responses to questions.
4.5. Public testimony (in accordance with policies set
1 If an item requires a public hearing, the Mayor will also open the public hearing. 2 Note: Note: This process will be managed by the Presiding Officer. Council comments at this point should be limited to questions only. Council opinions should be reserved for deliberations following input from the public.
City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
-- -----
-
- ---------
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 3 of 12
Resolution No.
forth below)).3
5.6. Councilmembers engage in deliberations and then
take action (in accordance with the procedures and
protocols set forth below).
A.C. Public Comment on Agendized and Non-Agendized
Items.
1. In General. Consistent with the requirements of the Brown Act, members of the public will be given an opportunity to speak on each agendized item and during the public comment section of the meeting for non-agendized items. This includes closed session items and consent calendar items. Members of the public should direct their questions and comments to the City Council as a body ,
not; comments should not be addressed to any one member, to City staff or to the audience.
2. Time Limits.
[Consistent with City Council Policy 029] for
agendized items, speakers will be provided two (2) minutes to make their remarks, and for non-agendized items three (3) minutes. People in attendance
[or on-line] may elect to cede their
time to another speaker. This should be coordinated in advance through the City Clerk. No speaker may commence their remarks and cede the balance of their time. The maximum amount of time aggregated in this manner shall be ____ [twenty (20)] minutes.eight (8) minutes for agendized items, and twelve (12) minutes for non- agendized items. In circumstances where there are a large number of speakers, numerous items on the agenda yet to be heard, or items that are anticipated to be lengthy, in the interest of making sure everyone has an opportunity to speak, the Mayor may reduce the amount of time allocated to each speaker. Any such reduction shall be applied consistently to all speakers for that item.
For example, if there are more than 10 speakers, the presiding officer may propose to reduce the time for each speaker to one minute instead of two.
3. Questions of Speakers. At the conclusion of public comments, City Councilmembers may request, through the Mayor, to ask questions of a public speaker. Councilmembers shall be respectful of and not debate public speakers. Public speakers may decline to answer Council questions.
3 If the item requires a public hearing, following public testimony, and prior to Council deliberations, the public testimony portion of the public hearing shall be closed.
City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 4 of 12
Resolution No.
4.3. One Opportunity to Speak. Once a member of the public has spoken on an agenda item, except under special
circumstances (at the discretion of the Mayor,), or where rebuttal testimony is expressly authorized or required (either under the City codeCode or applicable due process laws,), that speaker shall not be afforded additional time to speak on such item.
5.4. Disruptive or Unruly Behavior Not Allowed. While the public may speak their opinions on City business, the presiding officer is authorized and required to maintain order and decorum consistent with the [City’s Behavioral Standards for Public Meetings.]applicable laws and any adopted City behavioral standards.
6.5. Special Rules for “Public Presentations” for Non-Agendized Items. PublicAny public testimony for non-agendized relating to items not on the agenda must be presented during the designated slottime for such testimony designated on the agenda (currently, entitled “Public Presentations”). Councilmembers shouldmay not deliberate or act on any matter raised during Public Presentations, although brief questions may be posed to the speaker. No substantive action may be taken on any matter raised, although for clarification. Although the matter may not be acted upon, by consensus or formal vote, the matter may be referred to City staff for follow up. InDepending upon the event that [ten (10)] or morenumber of speakers request to speak, the remaining amount of City business to be conducted on a particular topic, in addition to limiting the time for each speakerthe agenda, and other factors, the Mayor shall have the discretion to limit the total amount of time afforded speakers during the initial round of Public Presentations, and to trail a second round of Public Presentations speakers until the end of the Council meeting.
B.D. Council Discussions and Deliberations:.
1. In General. Discussion and deliberations among
Councilmembers are integral to the decision-making process.
These rules are designed to facilitate that process in
ana fair
and effective manner, and to assure every member a
reasonable and equal opportunity to be heard.
2. Procedures
a. Commencement of Deliberations. Council deliberations shall commence after the completion of public testimony. A
City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
-
------------
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 5 of 12
Resolution No.
motion for proposed action on an item is not required for Councilmember deliberations to commence. The
Councilmember seeking to commence deliberations, or to
make a statement regarding the item, shall first obtain recognition from the Mayor. Additional Councilmember
questions of City staff (or any applicant) may also be posed at this time.
b. Taking Turns: If one or more Councilmembers has already spoken, all other Councilmembers wishing to speak should first be recognized and given an opportunity to speak, before returning to those that have already spoken. To encourage the full participation of all members of the Council, no member or members should monopolize the discussion of
the questionmatter under consideration.
c. Discussions Limited to Pending Matter. Councilmembers should use their speaking time to discuss the pending
questionmatter; any extended discussiondiscussions which departsdepart from the subject matteragenda item before the Council isshall be considered out of order.
d. Through the Mayor. Councilmembers should address
comments to the Mayor (as the Presiding Officer), not
directly to other members to assist with maintaining order and civility.
3. Protocols:
a. Relevancy of Discussion.Discussions Should be On Topic and Focused. All discussion should be relevant to the issue before the City Council. Councilmembers should avoid
diversions to unrelated topics and strive to move the
discussion along. Arguments, for or against a matter,
should be stated as concisely as possible. The Mayor will preside over these matters and may intervene to minimize repeated and off-topic remarks.
b. No
personal attacksPersonal Attacks. A motion, its nature, or consequences, may be debated vigorously. However, it is never permissible to attack the motives, character, or personality of a
memberfellow Councilmember or staff,
either directly or by innuendo or implication. It is the duty of the Mayor to instantly rule out of order any Councilmember who engages in personal attacks. It is the motion, not its City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 6 of 12
Resolution No.
proposer, that is subject to debate.
c. Duty to Maintain an Open Mind. It is the responsibility of each Councilmember to maintain an open mind on all issues during discussion and deliberation.
d. Avoid Repetition. It is not necessary for all City
Councilmembers to speak or give their viewpoints if another Councilmember has already addressed their concerns.
e. Interruptions. Councilmem bers shall not interrupt or otherwise disturb the speakeranother Councilmember while they are speaking.
4. Mayor’s Duties During Discussion. The Mayor has the responsibility of managing and expediting Council discussion and deliberations.
It is the duty of the Mayor to manage
compliance with all applicable procedures and protocols, keep the subject clearly before the members,
to discourage any
extended discussion not relevant to the subject, and to restate the question whenever necessary.
C.E. Motions, Seconds and Action
In General. No motion
shallshould be taken until after public
comment is received. All motions, except nominations, require a second. The two primary categories of motions are “main motions” and “secondary motions.” A description and the procedures for these are set forth below.
Main Motion Procedures
(1) Get the Floor. A Council memberCouncilmember should seek permission of the presiding officer before making a motion.
2) State the Motion. A motion is made by a
Council
memberCouncilmember (the "maker'') stating his or her proposal.
Longer proposals can be written and read into the record.
3) Second Required. Any other Council
memberCouncilmember (including the presiding officerPresiding Officer) who supports the proposal (or who simply wishes it to be City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 7 of 12
Resolution No.
considered) may "second" the motion without first being recognized.
4) Lack of a Second. If there is no second stated
immediately, the presiding officerPresiding Officer should ask whether there is a second. If no Council MemberCouncilmember seconds the motion the mattermotion will be considered to have “failed” for lack of second and will not be considered acted upon.
5) Maker’s Right to Withdraw Motion. Prior to or during debate and discussion of a motion the maker of the motion may seek recognition from the Presiding Officer to interrupt discussions and withdraw their motion from the floor. The motion is immediately deemed withdrawn, although the presiding
officerPresiding Officer may ask the person who seconded the motion if they wish themselves to make the motion, and; any other Councilmember once properly recognized may also make the motion.
6) Discussion
. The of Seconded Motions. In general, the
maker shallof a motion that has been seconded should be the first Council member Councilmember recognized to speak on the motion if it receives a second. . The seconder shallshould be the second Council memberCouncilmember recognized to speak on the motion.
Generally Council members will, Councilmembers should speak only once with respect to a seconded motion, but there is no formal limit on the number of times a Councilmember may speak. If the presiding officerPresiding Officer or Council permits any Council memberCouncilmember to speak more than once on a motion, all Council members shall receive the same privilege. (See Council Discussion and Deliberations Procedures and Protocols, above)
7) “Friendly” Amendments. Any Councilmember may
propose a “friendly” amendment to a pending motion, whether such motion has been seconded or not. If the maker of the motion (and the second, if the motion has been seconded),
agreeagrees to
the amendment, no formal vote shall be required by the Council for such “friendly amendment” to be substituted for the original motion.
8)
Amendment Motions to Amend. Once a motion has been
seconded any Councilmember may move to amend the motion. A motion to amend seeks to retain the basic motion on the floor, but to modify it in some way. If seconded, the motion to
the amend
takes precedence over the main motion. An action on a motion to City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 8 of 12
Resolution No.
amend a motion relates only to whether to accept the proposed amendment, not on the substance of the underlying motion itself.
If the motion to amend passes, the next action in order would be to act on the original motion as amended.
9) Substitute Motions. Once a motion has been seconded any Councilmember may move to make a substationsubstitute motion. Unlike a motion to amend, the substitute motion seeks to replace the main motion with a something materially different. If seconded, the motion to the amendsubstitute a motion takes precedence over the main motion. The initial action on a substitute motion relates only on whether to accept the proposed
substitution, not on the substance of the underlying motion itself. If the motion to substitute passes, the next action in order would be to act on the substitute motion.
10) Presentation of Motion
Transcribed.by City Clerk. Prior
to any vote, the Clerk, with assistance from the City Attorney as necessary, shall transcribepresent the motion under consideration so that Council members, the public and staff have a clear understanding of what they are voting on. If the proposed action is staff’s recommendation, reference can be made to staff’s presentation or the recommendation presented on the meeting agenda. If they motion includes modifications to, or is otherwise different from, staff’s recommendation, the City Clerk shall transcribe the proposed action on the voting screen and/or read itthe motion, as practical and appropriate.
11) Action. After discussion is complete the Council will vote on the motion under consideration. A simple majority vote of the Council (four votes) will be sufficient to adopt a motion unless otherwise required by law or this policy. (For example: City Charter Section 1305 requires “five votes” to approve a budget amendment involving an appropriation of funds; Under this Policy a motion “Calling for the Question” requires a two/thirds vote (five votes for a seven member body like the City Council).
12) Multiple Motions. There can be up to three motions on the floor at the same time.
When there are two or three motions on
the floor, the vote should proceed first on the last motion that is made. (See Rosenberg’s p. 5 on the process for managing multiple motions. Such process is incorporated herein by reference.)
13 ) Failed Motions; Reconsideration. If a motion fails to City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 9 of 12
Resolution No.
receive the number of votes required, that motion fails. If further action is needed or desired, the Council may continue to deliberate and make another motion or motions until action is taken. Once the Council has approved a motion, no further discussion shall be made unless a motion is made for reconsideration under City Council Policy 042.
Secondary Motion Procedures
The Council recognizes that the following “secondary” motions may be considered while a main motion is pending. These motions shall have precedence in the order listed below. This means that a secondary motion that is higher on the list will be considered ahead of a pending secondary motion that is lower on the list:
The purpose of the allowed secondary motions is summarized in the following text
and table.
1) Fix the time
toat which to adjourn. This motion sets a
future time for continuationadjournment of the meeting. (For example, “I move that this meeting should be adjourned at midnight.”) It requires a second, is amendable and is debatable but only as to the time toat which the meeting is to be adjourned.
2) Adjourn. This motion ends the meeting or adjourns it. It can include a future date/time for reconvening the meeting but need not. If no date/time is specified, the meeting shall be adjourned to the next regularly scheduled meeting. A motion to another time. Itadjourn requires a second and is not debatable except to set the date/time to which the meeting is adjourned, if applicable. A motion to adjourn shall be in order at any time, except as follows: (a) when repeated without intervening business or discussion; (b) when made as an interruption of a member while speaking; (c) when a call for the
previous question has been
ordered; andor (d) while a vote is being taken. After all items on the agenda have been considered, the Mayor may adjourn the
meeting on her own initiative with consensus of the Council.
3) Take a recess. This motion interrupts the meeting
temporarily. It is amendable but is not debatable.
4) Raise a question of personal privilege. This motion allows a Council MemberCouncilmember to address the Council on a question of personal privilege and shall be limited to cases in which the
Council Member'sCouncilmember's integrity, character or City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 10 of 12
Resolution No.
motives are questioned or when the welfare of the Council is concerned. The maker of the motion may interrupt another speaker if the presiding officerPresiding Officer recognizes the "privilege." The motion does not require a second, is not amendable and is not debatable.
5) Motion to table/continue. This motion is used to interrupt business for more urgent business, or to defer action on a matter to a later date at the request of an applicant, City staff, or a Councilmember in order to obtain additional information. or for some other stated purpose. The later date for consideration may be specified, but need not be. A motion to table or continue an item requires a second, is not amendable and is not debatable except, in each case, with respect to any new information that is being requested and any time/date proposed for the matter to be taken up again. It shall preclude all amendments or debate of the subject under consideration. If the motion prevails, and the subject is tabledcontinued, the matter shall be re-agendized for furtherfuture consideration on the terms specified or, if no terms are specified in staff’s discretion.
6)
Previous Motion to table. A motion to table an item shall be governed be the same rules applicable to a motion to continue, above. A motion to table, in effect, constitutes an affirmative decision to take no action on item at the time. The motion may, but need not, include terms for when the item will be brought back for future consideration.
7) Calling the question. This motion "calls the question" by closing debate on the pending motion. A motion to “call for previousthe question” requires a second, is not debatable and is not amendable. It applies to all previous motions on the subject unless otherwise specified by the maker of the motion. If motion to call for previousthe question fails, debate is reopened; if a motion to call for previousthe question passes, then a vote on the pending motion is required. A motion to call for previousthe question requires a two-thirds vote of those Council members present and voting. If the Presiding Officer “calls for the question” the motion on the table shall be voted on unless a motion to “extend the debate” is made and approved as provided below.
78) Limit or extend debate. This motion limits or extends the time for the Council or any Council MemberCouncilmember to debate a motion. It requires a second, is amendable and is not debatable. The motion requires a two-thirds vote of those Council City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 11 of 12
Resolution No.
members present and voting.
9) Refer to a cityCity agency, body, committee, board,
commission or officer. This motion sends a subject to another cityCity agency, body, committee, board, commission or officer for further study and report back to Council, at which time the subject iswould be fully debated. and acted upon. It requires a second, is amendable, and is debatable only as to the propriety of referring.
TheUnless the referral relates to a matter already on the agenda, the substance of the subject being referred shall not be discussed at the time the motion to refer is made.
D.F. Decorum:. At all times during the Council meeting, the City Council shall maintain a professional and respectful tone during discussions and avoid personal attacks or disrespectful language.
Reference should be made to the City Code of Ethics and Values Behavioral Standards for Councilmembers for additional standards for behavior and decorum.
E.G. Enforcement of Rules and Appeals:. As the presiding officePresiding Officer of the meeting, the Mayor may raise points of order to address violations of meeting rules, with a right for an appeal from and make determinations regarding the
majorityapplication of rules and protocols. Such determinations, including where the City Council.Mayor is acting in their discretion, deserve deference, but are subject to the right of appeal. An appeal shall be initiated first by inquiry of a Council member, and if not resolved, by formal motion. The motion must be seconded, and is subject to debate. If approved by a majority vote of those members present and voting, the ruling of the presiding officer is reversed. Questions regarding applicable rules or questions of interpretation may be presented to the City Attorney for input or advice. The interpretations and the application of rules to meetings shall be based on (1) the legal requirements of the Brown Act, and other applicable laws (e.g., free speech and, due process requirements, federal and state procedural requirements for certain types of actions, and City’s own procedural requirements
;); (2) applicable rules and procedures set forth in
Rosenberg’s, (3) past City patterns and practices of conduct, and (4) “best practices” derived from other sources, including generally accepted practices of conduct among City Councils throughout the state.
F.H. Other Relevant Policies.
The following City Council PoliciesCity Council Policies also provide City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible
-- - --
------------
DRAFT 6.20.25
City of Santa Clara
Council Policy Manual
Created <DATE> Council Policy 054055 Page 12 of 12
Resolution No.
rules relative to the conduct of City Council meetings: 029 – Time Limits for Speakers at Council; 030 - Adding an Item on the Agenda; and 042 – Reconsideration of Council Action; and City of Santa Clara Program in Ethics & Values, Behavioral Standards for Councilmembers.
Reference:
Council Policy Approved <DATE>
City of
Santa Clara
The Center of What's Possible