St. Helena City Council
April 9, 2024

City of St. Helena
Special City Council Meeting
Tuesday, April 9, 2024 @ 5:15 PM
Vintage Hall Board Room - Second Floor
465 Main Street, St. Helena

PLEASE NOTE: Any person who wishes to speak regarding an item on the agenda or make a comment under the "Oral Communication" portion of the agenda may do so, but please observe the time limit of four minutes.

The City Council meeting will be live-streamed on Comcast Channel 28 and on the City’s website.

Public comment for City Council meetings will be accepted via email to [email protected]. All public comments must be received three hours prior to the meeting. All other public comments received after the deadline will be attached to the item the next business day or soon thereafter. Public comments will not be read out loud but will be publicly available and attached to the on-line City Council agenda.

Simultaneous Spanish interpretation services during meetings can be scheduled upon request. To ensure interpreters are available, requests must be made at least 72 hours in advance by calling the Office of the City Clerk at (707) 968-2640 or emailing [email protected].

The schedule of upcoming meetings and published meeting agendas can be found on the City of St. Helena website at https://sthelena.civicweb.net/portal/.

Servicios de interpretación en español durante la reunión pueden ser solicitados por el público. Para asegurar que los intérpretes estén disponibles, los servicios tienen que ser solicitados al menos 72 horas antes de la reunión llamando a la oficina de la Secretaria de la Ciudad al (707) 968-2640 o por correo electrónico a [email protected] .

El horario de las reuniones publicadas y próximas puede ser localizado en el sitio de web de la Ciudad en https://sthelena.civicweb.net/portal/ .

Page

1. CALL TO ORDER

2. ROLL CALL
Mayor: Paul Dohring, Vice Mayor Eric Hall:, City Council Members: Anna Chouteau, Patrick Kenealy, Billy Summers

3. ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA

4. PUBLIC COMMENT:

Under California law, public comments at special meetings are limited to subjects on the agenda only. Therefore public comment will take place during consideration of the item. Each person’s comments shall be limited to 4 minutes.

5. NEW BUSINESS:

5.1. Planning Commission Applicant Interviews
Planning Commission Applicants:

1. Hector F. Lopez

2. David Prueter

3. Erin Martin
Planning Commission Application - Hector F Lopez
Planning Commission Application - David Prueter
Planning Commission Application - Erin Martin
3 - 8

6. ADJOURNMENT
The next Regular City Council meeting is scheduled for April 9, 2024, at 6:00 p.m.

This agenda was posted at City Hall, 1088 College Avenue, and at Vintage Hall, 465 Main Street, St. Helena, California on April 4, 2024.

Cindy Tzafopoulos, City Clerk
In Compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please call the City Clerk’s Office (707) 967-2792. Notification 72 hours prior to the meeting as required by Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting.

Any supplemental writings or documents distributed to a majority of the City Council regarding any item on this Agenda, after the posting of the Agenda, will be available for public review in the City Clerk’s Office located at 1088 College Avenue, St. Helena, California, during normal business hours and by appointment. In addition, such writings or documents will be made available on the City’s web site at https://sthelena.civicweb.net and will be available for public review at the respective meeting.
















 








!






"
#
$
%& 
'
()*+,,-./.0
122
# 32
'4(556578996::685
1;<=;>>?
@1AB' C*D8)E8FCG
1&&"B' ,//H+()DC)(I
JC5KC-(65DC4C5(-
-L0MH0
N
O@B' PH/HQH,RSTH.MC):85(4*C44
1U3B"@13VWBN
O@B' PL.MQ.//S/XH.Y8)I*C44
BA1VU1&&"B' +48FCGZ*D*5*E8)7
UB@[3
O\"BV&B@]' (65DC4C5(
BANUO]B"'
8)(4()FC5DC): 5685)(656578996DDCC
BANUO]AB@3313^' 
9F48_C`
"B1O@\O"1NNU]V@[' a(5DD876JCb(*ID8D+CD8a5a(:b8)5(5`)(6:C`65Ea(5DD8(::6:D65 ICCF657DEC4C5((bC(KD6cK4D8a5(::6:D657D+C)C:6`C5D:bK64`(**8)`657D8D+C 6D_dC5C)(44(5E
B&^13VO@1Ue1f["O^@&' 89F4CDC`D+C()FC5DC)g: 5685 FF)C5D6*C:+6F0_C()F)87)(9(5`bC*(9C(
h8K)5C_9(5 5685()FC5DC)65.//X-
c)89 C)IC4C_65
D+56*DK`6C:65
,LLH65D+C844C7C8cCDDC)g:(5`*6C5*C-
E
E65()FC5D)_c)89
9C)6*(56JC)
844C7C65.//L-
E
E65
5746:+c)89(5D(8:(hK568)844C7C65,LLXEC55D(DC *8K):C:6585:D)K*D685
(5(7C9C5D./,.D8./.076JC5(DD+C(:C7(:
()FC5DC)g: 56855DC)5(D685(4)(65657C5DC)E
M//*C)D6c6C`D8a(4I
*85:D)K*D685i8b:6DC:(5`(`J6:C*85D)(*D8):8c
:(cCD_J684(D685:E
O3
B""BUBW1@3BjNB"VB@B' K:D89+89CbK64`C)a6D+D+C()FC5DC): 5685c8),/_C():65 ()658K5D_E
89CK:D89
F()D9C5Da8)I65(5)(5*6:*865(*6c6*C67+D:EJC).T_C(): CkFC)6C5*Ca6D+*899C)*6(4(5`)C:6`C5D6(4*85:D)K*D685(5`a(4I657i8b:6DC:65

8)D+C)(46c8)56(0T*8K5D6C:c8)9D+C67+FCC`(6465)C:58D8D+C(4C: 8)*C8aC)bK64`65765(5)(5*6:*8D8*8K)D+8K:C:(5`+8:F6D(4:65C``657 (5`
K)CI(KFD8D+C)C7858()`C)E
OAA^@V3]V@WOUWBAB@3' (9(*8K5:C48)(5`9C5D8)D88JC)M-///(FF)C5D6*C:8cD+C,,*)(cD:K5`C)D+C ()FC5DC)g: 5685D+(D(::6:D65ICCF657D+C985D)(*Ia6D+D+C6)*4(::C:(5` a8)I+8K):650T*8K5D6C:E
"B\B"B@Bl'
(9Cm
(DD6(

``)C::m,,./hK5C(5C
+85C
K9bC)P:QmPH/HQX,.S,H0,

9(64m9(DD*Z874CD)CC*8)FE*89
"B\B"B@B<'
(9CmC(5Y64:85

``)C::m,/.M
8a`C44(5C
+85C
K9bC)P:QmPH/HQLTXST0/0

9(64m:C(5Z8ID6)C:+E*89
Agenda Item #5.1.
















 








!"#$

%%&
$$
'(')"&!
&*
+
,-

".,

-
/
&0$1
0)()12(34566)

#7
8

!"#$'393:;"..<=.

>?@ABCDEFC
GHIJKLMJIJNHOOJPQJQHRJJOSPTLUOVJLRRSWWSLPOLXVSYVKLMHNJHZZ[KSPT\ ]
$<"+
/

,#,

!#,^$"
7% .&!"

_`,$#.,. &
$!
%<
7$.a
,!!.

!#,^$a"
,#,+
$!.&$!"!
`-&="$
%7.!/
"#,%

. '((2"&!
&*
+
,-
a"
,!"
;a
&
#,!"
`7,,#,^. !"
".

!"!#$
;
!!./
 #,#$"
%,%"$,.a/

, .&
=7.$
% .&!"
b,%!#

c
dVHOSWKLMNMPQJNWOHPQSPTLUOVJNL[JHPQNJWZLPWSeS[SOKLUOVSWLRRSWWSLP\ .`&.`
&7;^-#%
77!".$
``7;#,^ .&,
a=.,$!&-=!#.,.&&

.%
7#,^`&.8
=!$#,/-#7%#,^==.&%#,^!.!"

&
^-7!#.,$$
!/;!"
=#!;-,%
&!"
f
,
&77,<
dVHOXLM[QeJKLMNTLH[gWhHWHLRRSWWSLPJN\
.a.&*a#!"!"
.!"
&=.

#!!



/
&$#,&
$
&="#,^,%%+#$#,^.,a"!=,/
==.
`7#$"
%#,
=.,$!&-=!#.,`&.8
=!$`&
$
,!
%!.-$/;.-&=#!#i
,$<
GHIJKLMZNJISLMW[KWJNIJQjLNQLKLMYMNNJPO[KWJNIJjLPHCOkGJ[JPHLRRSWWSLPLNLRRSOOJJ\EUKJWjXVSYVLPJgWh HPQULNXVHOZJNSLQLUOSRJ\

.

EWOVJNJHPKOVSPTJ[WJKLMXLM[Q[SlJMWOLYLPWSQJNXVJPNJISJXSPTKLMNHZZ[SYHOSLP\

$b9;
& ,#.,&`
,!
&`&#%

;$
7 a#!"/-#7%#,^`&.`
&7;==.&%#,^!.=.,$!&-=!#.,$!,%&%$,%
/
7#
+
#,m-7#!;`&.%-=!.+
&m-,!#!; .&7$!#,^`&.8
=!<".`
!.$
&!"
=.

#!!

!.!"
/
$!. 
;

_`
&#
,=
,%/#7#!;<$`
* 7-
,!`,#$"!"!
;"
7`a"
,a
"+
`,#$"$`
*#,^&
$#%
,!$,%
+#$#!#,^!"
#&`&.8
=!$<7..* .&a&%!.a.&*#,^$!

a#!".!"
&=.

#!!



/
&$#,=.
#,^-`a#!"
$.7-!#.,$!"!$!#$ ;/.!".-&/
-!# -7=#!;,%!"
&
$#%
,!$$

*#,^!./-#7%#,!
7 ,<
nopqrrstosouuvwstrxywvqzosxvy{vysoxyr|xyz}qr~vy~r~svstr€r~sxvy~vystx~oux{osxvyoqr sqroy|o{{qosrsvstr‚r~svwz}ƒyv„ur|pr
nwqstrqopqrrstos†‚}{tr{ƒxypstr‚v‡‚ruv„oy|
~‚zxssxypstx~oux{osxvy†vyuxyrvqvstrq„x~r†nozowwx‡xypz}|xpxsou~xpyosqrsvstx~wvqzo~vw str|osr~‚zxssr|
nou~vopqrrstosxwovxysr|†n„xuu~rqˆrvystr‰vzzx~~xvyŠ‰vzzxssrrwvq„tx{t ntoˆr~‚zxssr|stx~oux{osxvy

‹
f


=!.&
&,,%.#i

.,.`
i
&="''Œb(b5
Agenda Item #5.1.
















 








!






"
#
$
%& 
'
()*+,-./0/1
233
# 43
'5(667689::7;;796
2<=><??@
A2BC' (D7E)FGHG)
2&&"C' ,,I,(55GJ7GKH)GGH.(76HG5G6(.(57L9)67(.-1MN1 O
PAC' QQ0/0R00-1
CB2ST2&&"C' E(D7EU)FGHG)VJ(+99W*9:

TCAX4
PY"CS&CAZ' /JG();
CBOTPZC"'
GEH)967*.6*W[6HG55G*HF(5)9UG)HJ
HH9)6GJ\
CBOTPZBCA4424]' 
:U59JGE
"C2PAYP"2OOTZSAX' (76HG5G6(7;(;UG*7(5H9K6H+(H+(;F67^FG*96;7EG)(H796;L9)5(6EF;G(6E _96768WK(6HH9;G)DG96H+G5(667689::7;;796H9+G5U:(`GU5(66768 EG*7;796;H+(HH(`GH+G*+()(*HG)9L(76HG5G6(76H9*96;7EG)(H796W C&]24SPA2Ta2bX"P]A&' [/00Mc/00-\+G 67DG);7HJ9L
`)96c(*+G59)9L*7G6*G.
G*+(67*(5

6876GG)768
[/0,0c/0,Q\+G 67DG);7HJ9L
`)96*+9959L(KcdF)7;9*H9)
PBB]AS4ZSAePTeCBCA4'
G:fG).(76HG5G6(6HG)6(H796(5)EG)9LEELG559K;
"CYC"CACg'
(:Gh76E(G7LL

EE)G;;h,-11U)768H)GGH.(76HG5G6(.
-1MN1
+96G
F:fG)[;\hN0Nc//McN-00

:(75h5)G7LLV*9:*(;HW6GH
"CYC"CAC='
(:GhHGU+G65GD76

EE)G;;h/0I,U)768H)GGH.(76HG5G6(.
-1MN1
+96G
F:fG)[;\h1,Mc---c,0M-

:(75h;HGU+G6;5GD76V:(*W*9:
"CYC"CACi'
(:Gh
(j76G
68G55

EE)G;;h/,0,U)768H)GGH.(76HG5G6(.
-1MN1
+96G
F:fG)[;\hN0Nc-RQc-/RQ

:(75h:(j5(68G55VJ(+99W*9:

XCAC"2Tk]C4SPA'

$
l
$
m 
%
% n

op
nnqqrp#pl m
 33
os
tG;
up qlml%
mq %op
m

 %m
q3qv
pqnnqqs
F6EG);H(6EH+(HH+G5(667689::7;;796)GD7GK;(UU57*(H796;L9)U)9wG*H;K7H+76H+G7HJ.76*5FE768F;G UG):7H;.D()7(6*G;._96768:(U;.(6EEG;786)GD7GK9LEGDG59U:G6H(6E*96;H)F*H796W(5;9F6EG);H(6EH+(H H+G5(667689::7;;796)GD7GK;(:G6E:G6H;H9H+G9F;768 5G:G6H.xG6G)(55(6.(6Ey96768)E76(6*G
(6EU)9D7EG;)G*9::G6E(H796;H97HJ9F6*75)G8()E768H+G;GE9*F:G6H;W up rl
%v
lmo
zq{ q nnqq
ms
Agenda Item #5.1.
















 






 !

"!
#
"
$!!
"
%$"
&
!'$

$##
$!


&
!()
!
"!(!
*!$!"
$!!'
+
"$,

!
#
'&&!$!

!"
#
#
$-

'$$!"
$!.!!$!(

,
.&
!(!

(!
/!$!"
&

 $"!
$#.
$'
$!.+
012344561517789564:;983<15:8;=8;51:;4>:;<?34@A8;@4@58564BC4@5:8;@8;56:@1AA7:=15:8;134 53C41;>1==C315458564D4@589<?E;8F74>24G09C35643123445615HD?=64=E:;2564D8ID478F1;> @CD<:55:;256:@1AA7:=15:8;H8;7:;48385643F:@4H01<199:I:;2<?>:2:517@:2;15C345856:@983<1@89 564>154@CD<:554>G017@8123445615:91AA8:;54>H0F:77@43J48;564K8<<:@@:8;LK8<<:5544983F6:=6 061J4@CD<:554>56:@1AA7:=15:8;G
M
)

,$
"

"
"'#NO(PQPR
Agenda Item #5.1.
















 








!






"
#
$
%& 
'
()*+,-./0/1
233
# 43
'5(667689::7;;796
2<=><??>
@2AB'
)76
()C76
()C76
2&&"B' ,DE/76FG()H
IF.CJF5F6(.(.E1KD1
L
M@B' D0D/EK0D,D
2N4B"@24OPBL
M@B' D0DEQR1,1,
BA2ON2&&"B'
)76SF)76:()C76J*9:

NB@T4
MU"BO&B@V' /DGF();W
BALNMVB"' F5X
BALNMVAB@4424Y' 
:Z59GFH
"B2M@UM"2LLNVO@T' 9IFC+7;C9[6(6H9[F7C(59CJ
B&Y24OM@2N\2]T"MY@&' ^78+*+995.955F8F.)9XF;;796(5.9*(C796(5.9)9C+F)*+995; CCF6HFHJ5F(;F
76*5_HF
(`9)9)7F5H9XC_HG.(CF;(CCF6HFH.F8)FF(6HH(CF9XF8)FFa M4
B""BNBP2@4BbLB"OB@B' )F(C76857I768;Z(*F;X9)+_:(6;J MAAY@O4VO@PMNPBAB@4' cF();[7C+c9_C+[7C+(
7;;796J
"BUB"B@Bd'
(:Fef9F5g9CC

HH)F;;e
+96F
_:hF)^;ae

:(75e
"BUB"B@B='
(:Fe(6(5F

HH)F;;e
+96F
_:hF)^;ae

:(75e
"BUB"B@Bi'
(:Fe9[()H(*jF6

HH)F;;e
+96F
_:hF)^;ae

:(75e
TB@B"2NkYB4OM@'

$
l
$
m 
%
% n

op
nnqqrp#pl m
 33
os
cF;J
tp qlml%
mq %op
m

 %m
q3qu
pqnnqqs
CC(jF;(I755(8F(6HX9*_;J
tp rl
%u
lmo
vqw q nnqq
ms
9:(jFC+7;C9[6(;+F(5C+G(6H`9GX_5(;7C*(6hFJ
Oqp
m
 po

q
lrl
%
x
lq#q%
mrp
m
$
rolm 33
# s
Agenda Item #5.1.
















 







 



!
"#$%&&'(#'#))*+'(&,-+*%.#',*-/*-'#,-&0,-.1%&23*-2&2'*'(&45&2',*-2*-'(,2#33),/#',*-#%& '%5&#-0#//5%#'&'*'(&6&2'*+.17-*8)&0$&9"+5%'(&%#$%&&'(#':61/(&/7,-$'(&6*;6&)*8#-0 256.,'',-$'(,2#33),/#',*-:*-),-&*%*'(&%8,2&:"#.#++,;,-$.10,$,'#)2,$-#'5%&'*'(,2+*%.#2*+ '(&0#'&256.,''&09"#)2*#$%&&'(#',+#33*,-'&0:"8,))2&%<&*-'(&=*..,22,*->=*..,''&&+*%8(,/( "(#<&256.,''&0'(,2#33),/#',*-9
?
@





A BCDEFEG
Agenda Item #5.1.