ACTION:
____________________________
Clerk/Secretary
Department: Engineering Item No: C7
Prepared by:
Daniel Carns, Capital Projects Manager
Erin Adams, Administrative Programs Manager Meeting Date: November 10, 2026 Approved by:
Matt Atteberry, Acting Engineering Director
John Conley, City Manager Agenda Location: Consent Calendar S
UBJECT: CIP NO. 8403 – BREEZE HILL PHASE 1 – REJECTION OF BID PROTEST AND BIDS RE
COMMENDATION: Adopt City Council Resolution No. 2026- , rejecting the bid protest from Holder General Engineering, LLC and rejecting all bids for the Breeze Hill Phase 1 Project (CIP No. 8403).
CO
RRELATION TO CITY COUNCIL GOALS: Parks and Recreation
P
RIOR ACTION: On June 9, 2026, adopted City Council Resolution No. 2026-98 adopting a Capital Project Budget for Fiscal Years 2026/27 and 2027/28 (Vote: 5-0).
S
TATEMENT ON THE SUBJECT: Capital Improvement Project (CIP) No. 8403 includes the redevelopment of an existing City parking lot at the North County Courthouse complex into new pickleball courts. The project design and bid documents were completed, and the project was advertised thr ough OpenGov beginning September 10, 2026.
O
n October 8, 2026, the City opened bids for the project and received bids from twelve companies. Following the bid evaluation, the City issued a Notice of Intent to Award to Palm Engineering Construction Company, Inc. (Palm), the lowest apparent bidder based on the Base Bid.
O
n October 14, 2026, Holder General Engineering LLC (Holder) submitted a formal bid protest challenging the City's proposed award. The protest raises concerns regarding the evaluation of the Base Bid and bid alternates and whether the Base Bid reflects the minimum scope of work necessary to construct a complete project. However, the protest does not meet the Bid Specifications because it was not contemporaneously sent to the apparent low bidder , Palm (see Bid Specifications, Part 1, Section 20 (Bid Protests)) . As this failure renders the protest invalid and waives Holder’s right to pursue the protest further, staff recommends that the City Council reject Holder’s bid protest.
Sta
ff further determined that bid pricing was materially and negatively affected by the exclusion of bid alternates from the low bid evaluation. Although the City must incorporate one of the bid alternates to construct a complete project, the two bid alternates had been excluded from the low bid evaluation with the expectation that this would lower the City’s overall project cost . However, this approach led to less competitive pricing, including from the apparent low bidder. Vista Municipal Code (VMC) Section 3.08.040.E permits the City Council to reject all bids in its absolute discretion when doing so is in the public interest.
Therefore, staff recommends that the City Council also reject all bids pursuant to VMC Section 3.08.040.E AGENDA
REPORT
CITY COUNCIL
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
SUCCESSOR AGENCY
BUENA SANITATION DISTRICT
JOINT POWERS FINANCING AUTHORITY
Approved above recommendation, adopted City Council Resolution No. 2026-187. Vote: 5-0