Cities Index.
Agenda packet

San Dimas City Council
November 9, 2026

Document
Agenda packet
Meeting
November 9, 2026
Body
San Dimas City Council
Pages
4,100,554
Original file
133.1 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on sandimasca.primegov.com. That file is the official record.

Ordinance 1326 Page 3
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. Nevertheless, the element does mention the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.

NOW, THEREFORE, the CITY COUNCIL of the CITY OF SAN DIMAS, California, does ordain as follows:

SECTION 1. ADOPTION. Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05, amending the City of San Dimas Municipal Code Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation Ordinance to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within specific plans, with the exception of certain open space, scenic, slope, and conservation easements, Homeowner Association (HOA) common areas, and/or HOA maintained areas and associated clean-up items, as set forth in Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein and hereby adopted.

SECTION 2. SEVERABILITY. If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this Ordinance is, for any reason, held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance. The City Council hereby declares that it would have adopted this Ordinance and each section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion thereof be declared invalid or unconstitutional.

SECTION 3. CEQA DETERMINATION. The City Council hereby finds and determines that is can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that this ordinance may have a significant adverse effect on the environment. Thus, the adoption of this ordinance is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the CEQA Guidelines.

SECTION 4. EFFECTIVE DATE AND PUBLICATION. This Ordinance shall take effect 30 days after its final passage. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Ordinance and cause the same to be posted at the duly designated posting places within the City and published once within 15 days after passage and adoption as may be required by law in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of San Dimas hereby designated for that purpose; or, in the alternative, the City Clerk may cause to be published a summary of this Ordinance and certified copy of the text of this Ordinance shall be posted in the Office of the City Clerk five days prior to the date of adoption of this Ordinance; and, within 15 days after adoption, the City Clerk shall cause to be published, the aforementioned summary and shall post a certified copy of this Ordinance, together with the vote for and against the same, in the Office of the City Clerk.

Page 288 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 4
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of San Dimas this 9th day of November, 2026, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:
__________________________________
Emmett G. Badar, Mayor
ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________ ___________________________
Debra Black, City Clerk Jeff Malawy, City Attorney

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) §

CITY OF SAN DIMAS )
I, DEBRA BLACK, CITY CLERK of the City of San Dimas, do hereby certify that Ordinance 1326 was introduced at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of San Dimas on the 9th day of November, 2026, and thereafter passed, approved and adopted at a regular meeting of said City Council held on the Xth day of X, 202X.
___________________________
Debra Black, City Clerk

Page 289 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 5
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
Exhibit A
*New text changes are in Blue and Underlined
*Deleted text is in Red and Strikethrough
Title 18. Zoning
CHAPTER 18.162. TREE PRESERVATION
§ 18.162.010. Purpose.

The purpose of this chapter is to preserve and protect the mature significant trees, as well as other trees which are determined to be desirable, growing within the city.

Such trees are natural aesthetic resources which help define the character of the city and are worthy of protection in order to preserve the natural environment and to protect the city's native plant life heritage for the benefit of all citizens.

Mature significant trees, and other desirable trees, are unique because of their size and beauty, and their abundance adds distinction and character to the natural beauty of the community.

It is pertinent to the welfare and safety of all citizens of the city that such trees be protected from indiscriminate cutting or removal, for conservation purposes, as well as for the preservation of the natural beauty which such trees lend to the city.

It is the intent of this chapter that the design concerns of a development should address preservation of the most desirable and significant of the existing healthy trees and the developer is encouraged to utilize creative land planning techniques to achieve this goal. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.020. Definitions.

For purposes of this chapter the following definitions shall apply:

Mature Significant Tree. A mature significant tree shall refer to any tree within the city of an oak genus which measures eight inches or more in trunk diameter and/or any other species of trees which measure ten inches or more in trunk diameter and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches. The trunk diameter shall be measured at a point thirty-six fifty-four inches above the ground at the base of the tree. "Remove" includes any act which will cause a mature significant tree to die, including but not limited to acts which inflict damage upon the root system or other parts of the tree by fire, cutting, application of toxic substances, operation of equipment or machinery, or by changing the natural grade of land by excavation or filling the drip line area around the trunk. "Undeveloped property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to any parcel or parcels of land which does not contain physical man-made improvements, and may be improved in conformance with the applicable development standards of the zoning classification where the property is located. Undeveloped property shall also refer to any parcel or parcels of land which may or may not contain improvements and on which development applications including, but not limited to, development plan review, variance, zone change and subdivision, have been submitted.

Page 290 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 6
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
"Developed property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to property which has been improved with structures, buildings, surface materials, landscaping and similar improvements in accordance with all city ordinances.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.030. Permits required—Undeveloped property.

A tree removal permit is required. No issuance of any grading or building permits or commencement of work shall be allowed on undeveloped property prior to the approval of a permit. No mature significant tree which conforms to the standards and definitions of this chapter shall be removed or relocated without obtaining the written approval of the director of development services community development. An application to remove or relocate a mature significant tree shall include the following information as determined as necessary by the director of development services community development:

A. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s); B. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species, trunk diameter, height, tree spread, drip line, and health; C. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included; D. A written technical report from a certified arborist regarding proposed trees, when necessary;
E. Any other information as deemed necessary by the director of development services community development;
F. The application shall be accompanied by a fee in an amount as established by resolution of the city council;
G. The planning division, the director of community development or their designee, or the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply;
H. Where possible, application shall be submitted with the development application and should be in conjunction with a tree preservation maintenance agreement. An application for a permit, variance, zone change or tentative map for a subdivision, including a minor land division and/or a proposed development plan shall be concurrently filed with an application for a tree removal permit as set forth in accordance with this chapter. (Ord. 1165 § 1, 2006)
§ 18.162.040. Review required—Developed property.

Mature significant trees may be removed from developed property with the approval of the planning division or director of community development or the planning commission subject to the following procedures:

Page 291 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 7
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
A. Requests to remove or relocate up to, but not exceeding, three mature significant trees may be approved administratively by the planning division pursuant to the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species, and trunk diameter, height, tree spread, drip line, and health;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

4. Action by the planning division is subject to findings provided for in Section 18.162.070 of this chapter;

5. When, in the sole opinion of the planning division director of community development, circumstances are such that removal of three or fewer trees might have an adverse impact on other properties in the area of the proposed tree removal, the planning division director of community development may refer the matter to the planning commission director of community development.

B. Requests to remove or relocate more than three mature significant trees may be approved by the director of community development. The director may, upon a determination that the request could be incompatible with or have an adverse effect on the existing and surrounding property, require that the tree permit application be reviewed by the planning commission. When making a decision, the director shall consider the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species and trunk diameter;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

4. Action by the director of community development is subject to findings provided for in Section 18.162.070 of this chapter.

C. The planning division, and the director of community development, and the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply.
(Ord. 1165 § 2, 2006)
§ 18.162.060. Conditions imposed.

An approval to remove or relocate mature significant trees by the final decision making body director of community development or the planning commission are subject to conditions of approval as deemed necessary to implement the provisions of this chapter including, but not limited to:

Page 292 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 8
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
A. Tree relocation and/or two for one replacement with minimum fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. The two for one replacement ratio may be reduced as determined by the final decision making body, if a minimum of one of the following additional findings are made:

1. The reduced replacement requirement is consistent with the purposes of this chapter.

2. The tree(s) in question are located where the impact of the tree removal on the community is limited (such as trees in a generally flat portion of the rear yard of a single-family house that are deemed to have less public benefit).

3. The property in question has an adequate number of existing trees therefore a reduced replacement ratio is appropriate.

B. When on-site features, project constraints, and/or other considerations exist which prevent reasonable on-site relocation, relocation to an approved off-site location shall be permitted.

C. If said conditions are imposed, the owner will be responsible for all replacement and relocated trees for a minimum period of two years for single-family residential properties and in perpetuity for multi-family and non-residential developments. If during this time the tree(s) is (are) declared unhealthy by a certified arborist as set forth in Section 18.162.090, the diseased trees shall be removed and replaced at the cost of the applicant, as set forth in Section 18.162.100.

D. A maintenance agreement shall be submitted by the applicant and established for each replaced and relocated tree. The maintenance agreement and maintenance responsibility shall be transferred with the sale of the property if title to the property is transferred within the specified maintenance period.
(Ord. 1165 § 4, 2006)
§ 18.162.070. Required findings.

The granting of a permit for the removal or relocation of mature significant trees shall be subject to a minimum of one of the following findings as they pertain to the specific property:

A. The condition of the mature significant tree(s) with respect to disease, danger of falling, proximity to existing or proposed structures, and interference with utility services warrant removal of the tree;
B. It is reasonable to remove the tree because of its continued existence at the location prevents the reasonable development of the subject property; C. Removal of the tree will not create a negative impact on the topography of the land, erosion, soil retention, and will not contribute to the diversion or increased flow of surface waters;
D. Based on the number of trees in the neighborhood on surrounding properties or on the site, and the effect of tree removal upon enjoyment of the residents and the general public, and on property values in the area;

Page 293 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 9
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
E. The tree removal is consistent with good forestry practices, such as the number of healthy trees which a given parcel of land will support.
(Ord. 1165 § 5, 2006)
§ 18.162.080. Exceptions.

All trees should be protected, but there are a few cases where this chapter does not apply and they are as follows:

A. Trees located on single-family zoned properties or single-family properties within specific plans, and are not within open space, scenic, slope, or conservation easements as designated in this Code, homeowner association common areas, and/or homeowner association maintained areas;
A. B. Trees planted, grown, and/or held for sale by licensed nurseries and/or tree farms or the removal or transplanting of such trees pursuant to the operation of licensed nursery and/or tree farm;
B. C. Trees within existing or proposed public right-of-way where their removal or relocation is necessary to obtain adequate line-of-site distances as required by the city engineer; C. D. Trees which, in the opinion of the city engineer, will cause damage to existing public improvements;
D. E. Trees which require maintenance or removal action for the protection of existing electrical power or communication lines or other property of a public utility; E. F. Trees damaged by thunderstorms, windstorms, flood, earthquakes, fire, widespread organic disease or insect infestation, or other natural disasters and determined to be dangerous by a peace officer, fireman, civil defense official or code enforcement officer in their official capacity;
F. G. Minor trimming and/or pruning of trees on developed property within the scope of typical and reasonable tree maintenance;
G. H. Trees declared to be dead, diseased or dying, subject to the requirements of Section

18.162.090 and which were not planted as a requirement of a development project; H. I. Fruit trees, including citrus, plum, nectarine, cherry, apricot, peach, pear, pomegranate, persimmon, loquat, fig, avocado and other species determined similar by the director of development services. community development;
J. Palm trees;
K. Trees determined by Los Angeles County Fire Department or the insurer of the subject property to be a fire/failure concern and are required to be removed as documented by either entity; and
L. Trees in accordance with California Public Resources Code § 4291(a)(1)(A), Zone 0 (the area extending zero to five feet from a structure) for the purpose of complying with applicable California defensible-space and wildfire-safety provisions and requirements.

Page 294 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 10
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990; Ord. 1165 § 6, 2006)
§ 18.162.090. Verification of dead, diseased or dying trees.

The health of any mature significant tree declared to be dead, diseased or dying shall, prior to removal, be verified by a written report of a certified arborist, horticulturist or other qualified person.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.100. Tree maintenance.

The careful management of trees has become an ever increasing factor in the health and care of mature significant trees. When mature significant trees are located on designated scenic or open space areas, the owner of the property shall be exempt from this section. When mature significant trees are located on developed property, whether remaining trees, relocated trees, or new trees planted to replace those removed, the owner of the property shall maintain the trees to preserve and protect their health in accordance with the following measures:

A. The maintenance of trees standing upon private property shall be the responsibility of the owner(s) of those properties.

B. Trees shall be pruned, treated and maintained in such a fashion that the trees will be free of various damage, pests, disease and dead branches. The trees shall be in good biological and aesthetic condition.

C. Where applicable, a bond or cash deposit as determined by the director of development services community development shall be furnished by the developer for the management and protection of each existing, replanted or relocated tree(s). Said bond or cash deposit shall be refunded upon the successful completion of a tree maintenance program as required by the director of development services community development.

D. Any tree removal and/or replacement permit granted by the planning division director of community development pursuant to Section 18.162.040 and the director of community development planning commission pursuant to Section 18.162.040 shall include a condition requiring an objectively observable maintenance and care program to be initiated to insure the continued health and care of mature significant tree(s) on the property. Such program shall specify length of maintenance program, maintenance plan and method of inspection. Said tree maintenance program and plan is not required of the applicant when trees are to be relocated to an approved off-site location pursuant to the provisions of this chapter.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990; Ord. 1165 § 7, 2006)
§ 18.162.110. Protection of existing trees.

Care shall be exercised by all individuals, developers and contractors working near mature significant trees to be preserved so that no damage occurs to the trees. All construction shall preserve and protect the health of trees to remain in place, to be relocated, and new trees planted to replace those removed and any trees adjacent to the subject property in accordance with the following measures:

Page 295 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 11
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
A. All trees to be saved shall be enclosed by an appropriate construction barrier, such as chain link fence or other means acceptable to the director of development services community development, prior to the issuance of any grading or building or building permit and prior to commencement of work. Fences are to remain in place during all phases of construction and may not be removed without the written consent of the director of development services community development, until construction is complete; B. Any tree which is adjacent to the subject property and may be potentially impacted by persons or activity on the subject property shall be protected pursuant to the provisions of Section 18.162.110. It shall be the responsibility of the agent of the subject property to obtain the written permission from adjacent property owners prior to action for the protection of trees on adjacent property as required by Section 18.162.110; C. No substantial disruption or removal of the structural or absorptive roots of any tree shall be performed;
D. No fill material shall be placed within the drip line of any tree; E. No construction, including structures and walls, that disrupts the root system shall be permitted. As a guideline, no cutting of roots should occur within the drip line of the tree as measured at ground level. Actual setbacks may vary to meet the needs of individual tree species as determined by an arborist or landscape architect. Where some root removal is necessary, the tree crown may require thinning to prevent wind damage; F. Topping and/or severe pruning of trees that results in significant damage to the tree to the point that reasonable future growth may be limited, as determined by a Certified Arborist, shall constitute a tree removal and is subject to the penalties outlined in Section

18.162.130; and
G. The director of development services community development may impose such additional measures determined necessary to preserve and protect the health of trees to remain on site.
(Ord. 1165 § 8, 2006)
§ 18.162.120. Appeals.

Appeals shall be in accordance with Chapter 18.212 of this title. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.130. Penalties.

Violation of any provision of this chapter, or of any provision of any permit issued pursuant to this chapter shall be a misdemeanor punishable as follows:

A. Fines shall be set forth in accordance with Section 1.12.010 of this code. Each tree removed in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate offense.

B. As set forth in Section 18.162.010, it is the intent of this chapter to preserve to the greatest extent possible those trees which have contributed to the beauty of the city and the welfare of its residents. It is therefore the expressed intent of the city council that, to the extent legally permissible, upon conviction of any person pursuant to subsection A of this section,

Page 296 ends

Ordinance 1326 Page 12
MCTA 23-05 - Tree Preservation Ordinance
in lieu of incarceration, conditions of probation be placed upon such violator requiring the replacement of each tree removed in violation of this chapter with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than a twenty-four inch box size, or other replacement of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater. The number, size and location of the equivalent replacement tree shall be determined by the director of development services community development. For the purpose of this section, a suitable location may include an off-site location.

C. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no development permit of any kind, including but not limited to, any building permit or certificate of occupancy, shall be issued for any lot on which one or more trees have been removed in violation of the provisions of this chapter, or any permit issued pursuant to this chapter, unless and until the owner of such lot has replaced each such tree, to an on-site or off-site location pursuant to the provisions of this section, with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than twenty-four inch box size, or of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater, or provided security satisfactory to the director of development services community development that such trees will be planted at such time as determined by the director of community development. (Ord. 1165 § 9, 2006)

Page 297 ends

Agenda Item Staff Report
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council
For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
From: Brad McKinney, City Manager
Prepared by: Yasmin Dabbous, Assistant Planner
Subject: Introduce Ordinance 1326, a City-initiated Municipal Code Text Amendment of Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation Ordinance to Exempt Single-family Zoned Properties and Single-family Properties within a Specific Plan, with the Exception of Areas Owned or Managed by Homeowner’s Associations (HOA), and Areas Located within Certain Open Space, Scenic/Slope Easements and Conservation Areas, and Associated Clean-up Item.
____________________________________________________________________________

SUMMARY
On July 20, 2023, the Planning Commission considered an applicant-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance to exempt Specific Plan 11 (SP-11) from certain requirements.

The Commission denied the request but directed Staff to return with comprehensive updates to the Ordinance.

On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Ordinance with several changes. This included, but was not limited to, review authority, protected tree list, replacement ratio, and relocating the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13. The Commission voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment with specific directions to Staff.

On April 23, 2024, the City Council directed Staff to schedule a study session meeting to discuss private trees and provide input for discussion.

At the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the text amendment to exempt all single-family properties from the Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items.

At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission recommended approval of Resolution PC-1696, including the recommendation of three (3) additional items. These items include a revised review authority, the preservation of front-yard areas, and the non-exempting of Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties from the Ordinance.

RECOMMENDATION
ATTACHMENT 2

Page 298 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 2 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
Staff and the Planning Commission recommend the City Council read by title and introduce Ordinance 1326, approving Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 exempting single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan, with the exception of areas owned or managed by homeowner’s associations (HOA), and areas located within certain open space, scenic/slope easements and conservation areas, and associated clean-up item.

GOVERNMENT CODE §84308 APPLIES:
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
No

FISCAL IMPACT
Application Fee and Administrative Citation revenues will be reduced with the approval of exempting single-family properties, as specified, from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

BACKGROUND
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under two (2) separate chapters of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC) as follows:

1. Chapter 13.36, Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median, parkway, planting easement or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department.

2. Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees, located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department.

This Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) solely proposes modifications to Chapter 18.162, which deals with specific provisions, authorities, and enforcement procedures relating to preservation of trees located in private property.

The Tree Preservation Ordinance was originally adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Ordinance does not address public trees, as those are regulated under a separate Ordinance and under the review of the Park and Recreation Department. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight (8) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or any other species of trees which measure ten (10) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight (38) inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four (4) inches. The trunk diameter measurement must be measured at a point thirty-six (36) inches above the ground at the base of the tree. The Ordinance also exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception of these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.

The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. At the time of drafting this report, requests to remove up to three (3) trees must be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four (4) or more trees requires approval by the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB). The application fee for a Tree Permit Application for up to three (3)

Page 299 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 3 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
trees is $300, and the fee for the review of four (4) or more trees is $500. Approved applications are subject to an up to, two-for-one (2:1) replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if the reduced replacement ratio is consistent with the purpose of the Ordinance, removal of the protected tree will have a minimal impact on the community or if the subject site has an adequate number of existing trees.

On July 20, 2023, the Planning Commission considered an applicant-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance, Chapter 18.162 of the SDMC to exempt Specific Plan No. 11 (SP-11) from some requirements of the Ordinance, and other amendments related to review procedures, and replacement requirements that would only be applicable to SP-11. Specific Plan No. 11 encompasses the Via Verde Ridge Homeowner’s Association and consists of 262 single-family residences within a total of 262-acres of hillside land. The Commission denied the applicant request to exempt SP-11 from the requirements of the Tree Preservation Ordinance but directed Staff to return to the Commission with City-wide amendments to the Ordinance as a whole.

On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance, Chapter 18.162 of the SDMC to remove DPRB review authority, create a protected tree list, reduce the replacement ratio for tree removal violations, remove replacement requirements for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger or removal of trees required by the Fire Department, remove the arborist report submittal requirement, revise findings, and move the Tree Preservation Ordinance from Title 18 Zoning to Title 13 Civic Facilities to change the implementation responsibilities of the Ordinance from the Community Development Department to the Parks and Recreation Department, and various associated code clean-up items. The Commission voted against moving the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13 and for creating a tree exemption list, and voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment to Chapter

18.162 as follows:
• Remove DPRB review authority and allow Staff to review and approve all tree removals, regardless of the number of trees proposed for removal. • Change replacement requirement to one-to-one (1:1) if 24-inch box tree(s) is planted or two-to-one (2:1) if 15-gallon tree(s) is planted.
• Create two levels of protection:
o Oak trees, and any other trees Staff proposes, will need to make findings to support removal.
o All other trees with a ten (10) inch diameter or greater can be removed without any findings as long as they replace them. In this situation, the Director of Community Development can reduce the replacement ratio if there is not enough space to replant trees.
• Do not require replacement trees for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger, and removal of trees required by the Fire Department.
• Explore relaxing the Ordinance for backyard trees.
• Do not require an arborist report for dead, diseased or dying trees, unless applicant disagrees with Director's determination.
• Revise tree removal findings to make them clear and objective. • Change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54- inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards. • Revise the penalty section of the Ordinance.

Page 300 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 4 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
After receiving direction from the Commission, Staff started the process to amend the Tree Ordinance. This consisted of researching other cities and the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) to identify best practices, and consulting with the City’s arborist.

On April 23, 2024, the City Council heard a discussion about fines related to community trees.

The Council also discussed processes, fees and fines related to private trees. After much discussion, the Council directed Staff to schedule a study session to discuss private trees and provided input for discussion. Some of the items that were mentioned during the discussion, included, but were not limited to:
• Explore reducing or removing the Tree Permit Application fee for single-family property applications.
• Reconsider enforcement of the Ordinance to include single-family front yards only. • Create an exemption list for private trees (removal without permits/fees):
o Exempt tree species to consider: Eucalyptus, Tree of Heaven, Queen Palm, White Ash, etc.
o If exemption list is created, consider creating a protected list. • In situations where a four-to-one (4:1) replacement is required, it may not be an appropriate solution, as space and maintenance are a factor. • The Tree Ordinance should be easy to follow and not burden residents. • Creation of a tree fund. This would be funded by residents who remove trees but do not have room for required replacement, which would allow other residents to plant trees at no expense to them.

At the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the text amendment to exempt all single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items.

At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission unanimously voted (5-0) to recommend approval of Resolution PC-1696 to the City Council (see Attachment 2). The recommendation to City Council also included three (3) additional items. These items include a revised review authority, the preservation of front-yard areas, and the non-exempting of Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties from the Ordinance. These items are further discussed in the next section of this report. This staff report summarizes the proposed changes to the Ordinance, as specifically requested by the City Council.

DISCUSSION/ANALYSIS
Following the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff worked to address the Council's main objective of exempting single-family zoned properties from the Ordinance. While working on making this revision, several concerns arose regarding environmental review and code consistency. Items such as conservation easements and biologically sensitive areas in the City were discussed with the hired environmental consultant (Psomas). Following much discussion and per the direction of Psomas, Staff included specific language in the text amendment to preserve and protect sensitive biological areas and ensure consistency throughout the code. The proposed language found in Ordinance 1326 (Attachment 1) is as follows:

Page 301 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 5 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025

18.162.080 Exceptions.

All trees should be protected, but there are a few cases where this chapter does not apply, and they are as follows:

A. Trees located within the boundaries of single-family zoned properties or single-family properties designated within a specific plan, with the exception of the following. a. Trees located within homeowners’ association (1) common areas, (2) open space, (3) scenic easements, (4) slope easements, and/or (5) maintained areas; and b. Trees located in a single-family property within (1) open space, (2) scenic easements and/or (3) slope easements.

As mentioned, the City hired Psomas to assist as the environmental consultant for the project.

Psomas determined that exempting all single-family properties and not protecting the areas listed in the Ordinance would require additional CEQA review. The consultant noted this would potentially entail a quantitative analysis, biological studies, and mapping services which would span over the duration of months to prepare, most likely in the format of a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND). The consultant provided that the estimated cost proposal for the prospective MND would be approximately $75,000. The consultant acknowledged that this estimate is very preliminary and does not include all associated costs. This estimate would likely increase given the magnitude of the project scope. However, Psomas found that by protecting these conservation areas, there is substantial evidence to support a Notice of Exemption (NOE) for the proposed MCTA and would not require additional mitigation measures. The findings are further discussed in the Notice of Exemption Memorandum, as provided by the consultant in Attachment 3.

The specific language in the proposed text amendment was included to ensure that further environmental review would not be required, while still accomplishing City Council’s main objective of exempting single-family zoned properties. In this case, most single-family zoned properties will be exempt from the Ordinance with limitations on properties located within the noted areas of the text amendment. Single-family properties within conservation areas, as listed, are permitted to remove trees within the developable areas of the lot, however trees in areas of the lot within these specified limitations will require a permit for removal.

In addition, the language proposed in the Ordinance ensures that the Tree Preservation Ordinance is consistent with protected areas listed in various Specific Plans that call out conservation regions. For example, open space areas are addressed in Specific Plan No. 7 (SP-7), where the code specifically outlines focusing on the physical characteristics and the integration of surrounding urban and open space uses. If the preservation of these areas is not included in the Code amendment, the Tree Ordinance would then be in conflict with SP-7 and other Specific Plans that include protection of sensitive areas.

Note that the continued preservation of these specific areas does not deem that trees located within these boundaries are ineligible for removal, but rather that they will have to follow the same protocol that has been in place and apply for a Tree Permit Application. Additionally, Staff would like to note that in the future, if an individual or group would like to request a code amendment to remove or revise the listed conservation areas, an applicant-initiated MCTA can be applied for, and the applicant would incur all related costs pertaining to CEQA review.

Page 302 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 6 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
Associated Code Clean-up Item
The code currently reads “Director of Development Services”, which is a position that no longer exists within the City; therefore, Staff corrected the title to read “Director of Community Development” throughout the Tree Preservation Ordinance. Note that Staff is currently working on a comprehensive code text amendment update that would address this clean-up throughout the entire code for consistency.

Planning Commission Recommendations
At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission unanimously voted (5-0) to recommend approval of Resolution PC-1696 to the City Council, with recommendation of the three (3) additional items outlined below:

The Planning Commission recommended revising the review authority to not include the purview of Planning Commission for any Tree Permit Application. At the time of the Planning Commission meeting on April 17, 2025, requests to remove up to three (3) trees would have to be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four (4) or more trees required approval by DPRB. With the recent removal of DPRB from the code (MCTA 24-11), as heard and approved by City Council on May 13, 2025, the listed review authority was reassigned so requests to remove up to three (3) trees were reviewed/approved administratively by the Planning Staff, while the removal of four (4) or more trees required approval by the Director of Community Development. The Planning Commission recommended that review authority be reassigned so that Staff and the Director of Community Development process all Tree Permit Applications, regardless of the number of trees. It was noted that this would promote overall streamlining and reduced fees for residents. This recommendation has already been addressed independently and incorporated in the recent approval of MCTA 24-11. The recommendation of the Planning Commission and the approved amendment of City Council are consistent with one another. In the case that an application is determined to be sensitive or political in nature, the Director can escalate the review to the Planning Commission as deemed necessary.

As discussed in the Planning Commission meeting minutes (see Attachment 2), the Planning Commission determined that although direction was provided to exempt all single-family properties from the Ordinance, residential front-yard areas should remain preserved under the Ordinance. After discussion, the Commission determined that residential front-yards impact the visual appearance of the neighborhood and should be maintained with mature trees that do not pose a concern to welfare, safety and/or health of the residents. This recommendation would be applicable to any tree that is fifteen (15) inches or greater in diameter (measured at 54-inches above the ground at the base of the tree) and located within a front-yard area, regardless of tree species. This recommendation involves revising the definition of “Mature Significant Tree” to incorporate a revised method of measuring trunk diameter to coincide with general industry standards. The proposed trunk diameter threshold size was determined by Commissioners, as they considered it to be large and sufficient enough in size for necessary protection. The Commission believes the removal of healthy trees in these areas can impact the overall character of single-family residential zones.

Lastly, during the discussion of the Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) properties, the Planning Commission recommended that this zone not be exempt from the Tree Ordinance. They recommend that the SF-H zone continue to be required to receive approval of a Tree Permit Application for the removal of any applicable tree pursuant to the Ordinance. This was determined on the basis that these areas were designated to ensure development blends with the natural

Page 303 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 7 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
setting of the terrain when viewed from neighboring areas and other parts of the City. It encourages development of safe, comfortable residential areas where residents can enjoy views and a natural setting. This zone encompasses a total of 126 properties as depicted in Figures 1 through 3, not including Via Verde Park, which would be under the purview of Chapter 13.36, Community Tree Management, administered by the Parks and Recreation Department for City-owned trees located within any park.

Figure 1: SF-H Properties along Oakengate Drive
Figure 2: SF-H Properties along S. Walnut Avenue

Page 304 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 8 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
Figure 3: SF-H Properties along Terrebonne Avenue

ALTERNATIVES
There are no alternatives proposed for this request; however, the City Council can provide Staff direction to revise the Ordinance to incorporate the Planning Commission’s recommendations.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
As previously mentioned, the City hired Psomas to review the proposed code text amendment and provide additional CEQA services. As provided in the Notice of Exemption Memorandum and Notice of Exemption (Attachments 3 and 4), Psomas found that according to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. They found that the project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow property owners of single-family zoned properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. Therefore, as the Project would result in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the amendments are programmatic in nature. Furthermore, any subsequent tree removals initiated by private property owners would be done according to the updated requirements, thereby limiting any potential impacts. These municipal code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed

Page 305 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment - Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 9 For the Meeting of May 27, 2025
in the City. This founded substantial evidence to support a Notice of Exemption (Attachment 4) for the provided code amendment.

Respectfully submitted,
Yasmin Dabbous
Assistant Planner
Attachments:

1. Ordinance 1326

2. Planning Commission Staff Report and Minutes - April 17, 2025

3. Psomas Notice of Exemption Memorandum

4. Psomas CEQA Notice of Exemption

5. General Plan Land Use Element Exhibit II-4.1 Map

Page 306 ends

ORDINANCE 1326

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS, COUNTY OF

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING MUNICIPAL CODE TEXT AMENDMENT 23-05, A REQUEST TO AMEND TITLE 18, CHAPTER 18.162 TREE PRESERVATION

ORDINANCE TO EXEMPT SINGLE-FAMILY ZONED PROPERTIES AND SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTIES WITHIN A SPECIFIC PLAN, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF AREAS OWNED OR MANAGED BY HOMEOWNER’S ASSOCIATION (HOA), AND

AREAS LOCATED WITHIN CERTAIN OPEN SPACE, SCENIC/SLOPE EASEMENTS AND CONSERVATION AREAS, AND ASSOCIATED CLEAN-UP ITEM.

WHEREAS, an Amendment to the San Dimas Municipal Code has been duly initiated by the Planning Commission on September 21, 2023; and WHEREAS, the Amendment is described as Municipal Code Text Amendment 23- 05, an amendment to Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation Ordinance to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan, with the exception of areas owned or managed by homeowner’s association (HOA), and areas located within certain open space, scenic/slope easements and conservation areas, and associated clean-up item; and
WHEREAS, the Amendment would affect the area City-wide; and WHEREAS, the City Council held a study session on November 12, 2024, to discuss the possible amendments to the Tree Ordinance and at the end of the discussion, the Council directed Staff to return with changes to the Ordinance that would exempt single-family zoned properties; and
WHEREAS, on April 17, 2025, the Planning Commission heard evidence and voted 5-0 to recommend approval of Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 with additional recommendations to the City Council; and
WHEREAS, notice was duly given of the public hearing on the matter and that public hearing was held on May 27, 2025, at the hour of 7:00 p.m., with all testimony received being made a part of the public record; and
WHEREAS, all requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act and the City’s Environmental Guidelines have been met for the consideration of whether the project will have a significant effect on the environment. According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The proposed amendments consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow property owners of single-family zoned properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. Therefore, as the amendments would not actually include any tree removals, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the amendments are programmatic in nature. Furthermore, the amendments would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City

Page 307 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 2
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the evidence received at the hearing, and for the reasons discussed by the members of the City Council at the hearing, the City Council now finds as follows:

A. The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment will not adversely affect adjoining properties as to value, precedent or be detrimental to the area.

The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment is intended to exempt single-family properties from the provisions of the Tree Ordinance. The proposed amendments will not adversely or foreseeably affect property values, establish foreseeable negative precedents, or result in foreseeable detrimental impacts to the community. The proposed amendment, in contrast, aims to establish more flexible standards and procedure leniency for the residents of the City. This amendment reduces the overall time and cost expenditure of homeowners by eliminating the additional procedural steps and review process currently mandated by the Tree Ordinance. This Municipal Code Text Amendment focuses on single-family zoned properties which are not as heavily landscaped as multifamily residential and non-residential developments, including all public developments such as parks and parkways. This protects a large number of existing mature trees in the City, minimizing the direct or indirect physical change in the environment.

B. The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment will further the public health, safety and general welfare.

The proposed Municipal Code Amendment advances the general welfare of San Dimas residents by refining the review process to exempt single-family properties from the application and permitting procedures currently set forth in the Tree Preservation Ordinance, while continuously protecting trees in sensitive areas on single-family lots. This amendment establishes a more streamlined process for homeowners seeking to remove trees within the confines of their single-family zoned properties (excluding certain provisions). This streamlined approach is considerate of the general public health, safety and welfare of the San Dimas community.

C. The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment is consistent with the General Plan.

The proposed amendment is aligned with Policy Statement 1.4.3 of the Safety Element within the General Plan. The policy intends to restrict the use of flammable materials and provide additional setbacks in fire hazard zones. The Los Angeles County Fire Prevention Unit oversees proper defensible space surrounding a residence, this amendment would potentially reduce the total number of trees found throughout the High Fire Severity Zone of the City, further protecting the general welfare and safety of residents.

The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment would apply to trees situated within single-family properties. The City’s Land Use Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation.

Nevertheless, the element does mention the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

Page 308 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 3
As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.

NOW, THEREFORE, the CITY COUNCIL of the CITY OF SAN DIMAS, California, does ordain as follows:

SECTION 1. ADOPTION. Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05, amending the City of San Dimas Municipal Code Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation Ordinance to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan, with the exception of areas owned or managed by homeowner’s association (HOA), and areas located within certain open space, scenic/slope easements and conservation areas, and associated clean-up item, as set forth in Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein and hereby adopted.

SECTION 2. SEVERABILITY. If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this Ordinance is, for any reason, held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance. The City Council hereby declares that it would have adopted this Ordinance and each section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion thereof be declared invalid or unconstitutional.

SECTION 3. CEQA DETERMINATION. The City Council hereby finds and determines that is can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that this ordinance may have a significant adverse effect on the environment. Thus, the adoption of this ordinance is exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the CEQA Guidelines.

SECTION 4. EFFECTIVE DATE AND PUBLICATION. This Ordinance shall take effect 30 days after its final passage. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Ordinance and cause the same to be posted at the duly designated posting places within the City and published once within 15 days after passage and adoption as may be required by law in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of San Dimas hereby designated for that purpose; or, in the alternative, the City Clerk may cause to be published a summary of this Ordinance and certified copy of the text of this Ordinance shall be posted in the Office of the City Clerk five days prior to the date of adoption of this Ordinance; and, within 15 days after adoption, the City Clerk shall cause to be published, the aforementioned summary and shall post a certified copy of this Ordinance, together with the vote for and against the same, in the Office of the City Clerk.

Page 309 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 4
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of San Dimas this 27th day of May, 2025, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:
__________________________________
Emmett G. Badar, Mayor
ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________ ___________________________
Debra Black, City Clerk Jeff Malawy, City Attorney

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES )§

CITY OF SAN DIMAS )
I, Debra Black, City Clerk of the City of San Dimas, do hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of Ordinance 1326 was introduced at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of San Dimas on the 27th day of May, 2025, and thereafter passed, approved and adopted at a regular meeting of said City Council held on the 10th day of June, 2025. It has been published and posted pursuant to law. ___________________________
Debra Black, City Clerk

Page 310 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 5
Exhibit A
*New text changes are in Blue and Underlined
*Deleted text is in Red and Strikethrough
Title 18. Zoning
Chapter 18.162. TREE PRESERVATION
§ 18.162.010. Purpose.

The purpose of this chapter is to preserve and protect the mature significant trees, as well as other trees which are determined to be desirable, growing within the city.

Such trees are natural aesthetic resources which help define the character of the city and are worthy of protection in order to preserve the natural environment and to protect the city's native plant life heritage for the benefit of all citizens.

Mature significant trees, and other desirable trees, are unique because of their size and beauty, and their abundance adds distinction and character to the natural beauty of the community.

It is pertinent to the welfare and safety of all citizens of the city that such trees be protected from indiscriminate cutting or removal, for conservation purposes, as well as for the preservation of the natural beauty which such trees lend to the city.

It is the intent of this chapter that the design concerns of a development should address preservation of the most desirable and significant of the existing healthy trees and the developer is encouraged to utilize creative land planning techniques to achieve this goal. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.020. Definitions.

For purposes of this chapter the following definitions shall apply:

Mature Significant Tree. A mature significant tree shall refer to any tree within the city of an oak genus which measures eight inches or more in trunk diameter and/or any other species of trees which measure ten inches or more in trunk diameter and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches. The trunk diameter shall be measured at a point thirty-six inches above the ground at the base of the tree. "Remove" includes any act which will cause a mature significant tree to die, including but not limited to acts which inflict damage upon the root system or other parts of the tree by fire, cutting, application of toxic substances, operation of equipment or machinery, or by changing the natural grade of land by excavation or filling the drip line area around the trunk.

Page 311 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 6
"Undeveloped property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to any parcel or parcels of land which does not contain physical man-made improvements, and may be improved in conformance with the applicable development standards of the zoning classification where the property is located. Undeveloped property shall also refer to any parcel or parcels of land which may or may not contain improvements and on which development applications including, but not limited to, development plan review, variance, zone change and subdivision, have been submitted.
"Developed property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to property which has been improved with structures, buildings, surface materials, landscaping and similar improvements in accordance with all city ordinances.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.030. Permits required—Undeveloped property.

A tree removal permit is required. No issuance of any grading or building permits or commencement of work shall be allowed on undeveloped property prior to the approval of a permit. No mature significant tree which conforms to the standards and definitions of this chapter shall be removed or relocated without obtaining the written approval of the director of development services community development. An application to remove or relocate a mature significant tree shall include the following information as determined as necessary by the director of development services community development:

A. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s); B. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species, trunk diameter, height, tree spread, drip line, and health;
C. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included; D. A written technical report from a certified arborist regarding proposed trees, when necessary;
E. Any other information as deemed necessary by the director of development services community development;
F. The application shall be accompanied by a fee in an amount as established by resolution of the city council;
G. The planning division, the director of community development or their designee, or the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply; H. Where possible, application shall be submitted with the development application and should be in conjunction with a tree preservation maintenance agreement. An application for a permit, variance, zone change or tentative map for a subdivision, including a minor land division and/or a proposed development plan shall be

Page 312 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 7
concurrently filed with an application for a tree removal permit as set forth in accordance with this chapter.
(Ord. 1165 § 1, 2006)
§ 18.162.040. Review required—Developed property.

Mature significant trees may be removed from developed property with the approval of the director of development services community development or the planning commission subject to the following procedures:

A. Requests to remove or relocate up to, but not exceeding, three mature significant trees may be approved administratively by the planning division pursuant to the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species and trunk diameter;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

4. Action by the planning division is subject to findings provided for in Section

18.162.070 of this chapter;

5. When, in the sole opinion of the director of development services community development, circumstances are such that removal of three or fewer trees might have an adverse impact on other properties in the area of the proposed tree removal, the director of development services community development may refer the matter to the planning commission.

B. Requests to remove or relocate more than three mature significant trees may be approved by the director of community development. The director may, upon a determination that the request could be incompatible with or have an adverse effect on the existing and surrounding property, require that the tree permit application be reviewed by the planning commission. When making a decision, the director shall consider the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species and trunk diameter;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

Page 313 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 8

4. Action by the director of development services community development is subject to findings provided for in Section 18.162.070 of this chapter.

C. The director of community development, and the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply.
(Ord. 1165 § 2, 2006)
§ 18.162.060. Conditions imposed.

An approval to remove or relocate mature significant trees by the director of development services community development or the planning commission are subject to conditions of approval as deemed necessary to implement the provisions of this chapter including, but not limited to:

A. Tree relocation and/or two for one replacement with minimum fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. The two for one replacement ratio may be reduced as determined by the final decision making body, if a minimum of one of the following additional findings are made:

1. The reduced replacement requirement is consistent with the purposes of this chapter.

2. The tree(s) in question are located where the impact of the tree removal on the community is limited (such as trees in a generally flat portion of the rear yard of a single-family house that are deemed to have less public benefit).

3. The property in question has an adequate number of existing trees therefore a reduced replacement ratio is appropriate.

B. When on-site features, project constraints, and/or other considerations exist which prevent reasonable on-site relocation, relocation to an approved off-site location shall be permitted.

C. If said conditions are imposed, the owner will be responsible for all replacement and relocated trees for a minimum period of two years. If during this time the tree(s) is (are) declared unhealthy by a certified arborist as set forth in Section 18.162.090, the diseased trees shall be removed and replaced at the cost of the applicant, as set forth in Section 18.162.100.

D. A maintenance agreement shall be submitted by the applicant and established for each replaced and relocated tree. The maintenance agreement and maintenance responsibility shall be transferred with the sale of the property if title to the property is transferred within the specified maintenance period. (Ord. 1165 § 4, 2006)
§ 18.162.070. Required findings.

Page 314 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 9
The granting of a permit for the removal or relocation of mature significant trees shall be subject to a minimum of one of the following findings as they pertain to the specific property:

A. The condition of the mature significant tree(s) with respect to disease, danger of falling, proximity to existing or proposed structures, and interference with utility services warrant removal of the tree;
B. It is reasonable to remove the tree because of its continued existence at the location prevents the reasonable development of the subject property; C. Removal of the tree will not create a negative impact on the topography of the land, erosion, soil retention, and will not contribute to the diversion or increased flow of surface waters;
D. Based on the number of trees in the neighborhood on surrounding properties or on the site, and the effect of tree removal upon enjoyment of the residents and the general public, and on property values in the area;
E. The tree removal is consistent with good forestry practices, such as the number of healthy trees which a given parcel of land will support. (Ord. 1165 § 5, 2006)
§ 18.162.080. Exceptions.

All trees should be protected, but there are a few cases where this chapter does not apply and they are as follows:

A. Trees located within the boundaries of single-family zoned properties or single-family properties designated within a specific plan, with the exception of the following;
a. Trees located within homeowner’s association (1) common areas, (2) open space, (3) scenic easements, (4) slope easements, (5) maintained areas; and
b. Trees located on a single-family lot within (1) open space, (2) scenic easements or (3) slope easements;
A. B. Trees planted, grown, and/or held for sale by licensed nurseries and/or tree farms or the removal or transplanting of such trees pursuant to the operation of licensed nursery and/or tree farm;
B. C. Trees within existing or proposed public right-of-way where their removal or relocation is necessary to obtain adequate line-of-site distances as required by the city engineer;
C. D. Trees which, in the opinion of the city engineer, will cause damage to existing public improvements;
D. E. Trees which require maintenance or removal action for the protection of existing electrical power or communication lines or other property of a public utility;

Page 315 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 10
E. F. Trees damaged by thunderstorms, windstorms, flood, earthquakes, fire, widespread organic disease or insect infestation, or other natural disasters and determined to be dangerous by a peace officer, fireman, civil defense official or code enforcement officer in their official capacity;
F. G. Minor trimming and/or pruning of trees on developed property within the scope of typical and reasonable tree maintenance;
G. H. Trees declared to be dead, diseased or dying, subject to the requirements of Section 18.162.090;
H. I. Fruit trees, including citrus, plum, nectarine, cherry, apricot, peach, pear, pomegranate, persimmon, loquat, fig, avocado and other species determined similar by the director of development services community development. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990; Ord. 1165 § 6, 2006)
§ 18.162.090. Verification of dead, diseased or dying trees.

The health of any mature significant tree declared to be dead, diseased or dying shall, prior to removal, be verified by a written report of a certified arborist, horticulturist or other qualified person.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.100. Tree maintenance.

The careful management of trees has become an ever increasing factor in the health and care of mature significant trees. When mature significant trees are located on designated scenic or open space areas, the owner of the property shall be exempt from this section.

When mature significant trees are located on developed property, whether remaining trees, relocated trees, or new trees planted to replace those removed, the owner of the property shall maintain the trees to preserve and protect their health in accordance with the following measures:

A. The maintenance of trees standing upon private property shall be the responsibility of the owner(s) of those properties.

B. Trees shall be pruned, treated and maintained in such a fashion that the trees will be free of various damage, pests, disease and dead branches. The trees shall be in good biological and aesthetic condition.

C. Where applicable, a bond or cash deposit as determined by the director of development services community development shall be furnished by the developer for the management and protection of each existing, replanted or relocated tree(s).

Said bond or cash deposit shall be refunded upon the successful completion of a tree maintenance program as required by the director of development services community development.

D. Any tree removal and/or replacement permit granted by the director of development services community development pursuant to Section 18.162.040 and the planning commission pursuant to Section 18.162.040 shall include a condition requiring an objectively observable maintenance and care program to be

Page 316 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 11
initiated to insure the continued health and care of mature significant tree(s) on the property. Such program shall specify length of maintenance program, maintenance plan and method of inspection. Said tree maintenance program and plan is not required of the applicant when trees are to be relocated to an approved off-site location pursuant to the provisions of this chapter. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990; Ord. 1165 § 7, 2006)
§ 18.162.110. Protection of existing trees.

Care shall be exercised by all individuals, developers and contractors working near mature significant trees to be preserved so that no damage occurs to the trees. All construction shall preserve and protect the health of trees to remain in place, to be relocated, and new trees planted to replace those removed and any trees adjacent to the subject property in accordance with the following measures:

A. All trees to be saved shall be enclosed by an appropriate construction barrier, such as chain link fence or other means acceptable to the director of development services community development, prior to the issuance of any grading or building or building permit and prior to commencement of work. Fences are to remain in place during all phases of construction and may not be removed without the written consent of the director of development services community development, until construction is complete;
B. Any tree which is adjacent to the subject property and may be potentially impacted by persons or activity on the subject property shall be protected pursuant to the provisions of Section 18.162.110. It shall be the responsibility of the agent of the subject property to obtain the written permission from adjacent property owners prior to action for the protection of trees on adjacent property as required by Section 18.162.110;
C. No substantial disruption or removal of the structural or absorptive roots of any tree shall be performed;
D. No fill material shall be placed within the drip line of any tree; E. No construction, including structures and walls, that disrupts the root system shall be permitted. As a guideline, no cutting of roots should occur within the drip line of the tree as measured at ground level. Actual setbacks may vary to meet the needs of individual tree species as determined by an arborist or landscape architect.

Where some root removal is necessary, the tree crown may require thinning to prevent wind damage;
F. Topping and/or severe pruning of trees that results in significant damage to the tree to the point that reasonable future growth may be limited, as determined by a Certified Arborist, shall constitute a tree removal and is subject to the penalties outlined in Section 18.162.130; and
G. The director of development services community development may impose such additional measures determined necessary to preserve and protect the health of trees to remain on site.

Page 317 ends

Ordinance 1326
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 12
(Ord. 1165 § 8, 2006)
§ 18.162.120. Appeals.

Appeals shall be in accordance with Chapter 18.212 of this title. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.130. Penalties.

Violation of any provision of this chapter, or of any provision of any permit issued pursuant to this chapter shall be a misdemeanor punishable as follows:

A. Fines shall be set forth in accordance with Section 1.12.010 of this code. Each tree removed in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate offense.

B. As set forth in Section 18.162.010, it is the intent of this chapter to preserve to the greatest extent possible those trees which have contributed to the beauty of the city and the welfare of its residents. It is therefore the expressed intent of the city council that, to the extent legally permissible, upon conviction of any person pursuant to subsection A of this section, in lieu of incarceration, conditions of probation be placed upon such violator requiring the replacement of each tree removed in violation of this chapter with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than a twenty-four inch box size, or other replacement of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater. The number, size and location of the equivalent replacement tree shall be determined by the director of development services community development. For the purpose of this section, a suitable location may include an off-site location.

C. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no development permit of any kind, including but not limited to, any building permit or certificate of occupancy, shall be issued for any lot on which one or more trees have been removed in violation of the provisions of this chapter, or any permit issued pursuant to this chapter, unless and until the owner of such lot has replaced each such tree, to an on-site or off-site location pursuant to the provisions of this section, with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than twenty-four inch box size, or of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater, or provided security satisfactory to the director of development services community development that such trees will be planted at such time as determined by the director.
(Ord. 1165 § 9, 2006)

Page 318 ends

Agenda Item Staff Report
To: Honorable Chair and Members of Planning Commission
For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
From: Luis Torrico, Director of Community Development
Prepared by: Yasmin Dabbous, Assistant Planner
Subject: Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05, Consideration and discussion of a Municipal Code Text Amendment to amend Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from the Ordinance and associated clean-up items.
____________________________________________________________________________

SUMMARY
At the November 12, 2024 City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the municipal code text amendment to exempt single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items. This Staff Report summarizes the proposed changes to the Ordinance, as requested by City Council.

RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Planning Commission adopt Resolution PC-1696, recommending approval to the City Council of Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05.

GOVERNMENT CODE §84308 APPLIES:
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
No

FISCAL IMPACT
Application Fee and Administrative Citation revenues will be reduced with the approval of exempting single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

BACKGROUND
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under two separate chapters of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC). (1) Chapter 13.36, Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median,

Page 319 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 2 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
parkway, planting easement or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department. (2) Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees, located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department. This Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) solely proposes modifications to Chapter 18.162, which deals with specific provisions, authorities, and enforcement procedures relating to preservation of trees located in private property.

The Tree Preservation Ordinance was originally adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Ordinance does not address any public trees that are found within a separate Ordinance and under the review of the Park and Recreation Department. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight (8) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or any other species of trees which measure ten (10) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight (38) inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four (4) inches. The trunk diameter measurement must be measured at a point thirty-six (36) inches above the ground at the base of the tree. The Ordinance also exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.

The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. Requests to remove up to three (3) trees may be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four (4) or more trees requires approval by the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB). The application fee for a Tree Removal Permit for up to three (3) trees is $300, and the fee for the review of four (4) or more trees is $500. Approved tree removal applications are subject to a two-for-one replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if the reduced replacement ratio is consistent with the purpose of the Ordinance, removal of the protected tree will have a minimal impact on the community or if the subject site has an adequate number of existing trees.

Per San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC) Section 18.208, changes to the Code must be initiated by the City Council, Planning Commission or an applicant. The initiation request must first be approved before an application for a Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) can be submitted or processed.

On July 20, 2023, the Planning Commission considered an applicant-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance, Chapter 18.162 of the SDMC to exempt Specific Plan 11 (SP-11) from some requirements of the ordinance, and other amendments related to review procedures, and replacement requirements that would only be applicable to SP-11. Specific Plan 11, encompasses the Via Verde Ridge Homeowner’s Association and consists of 262 single-family residences within a total of 262-acres of hillside land. The Commission denied the applicant request to exempt SP-11 from the requirements of the Tree Preservation Ordinance but directed Staff to come back to the Commission with City-wide amendments to the Ordinance as a whole.

On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance, Chapter 18.162 of the SDMC to remove the Development Plan Review Board’s review authority, create a protected tree list, reduce the replacement ratio for tree removal violations, remove replacement requirements for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger or removal of trees required by the Fire Department, remove the arborist report submittal

Page 320 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 3 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
requirement, revise findings, and move the Tree Preservation Ordinance from Title 18 Zoning to Title 13 Civic Facilities to change the implementation responsibilities of the Ordinance from the Community Development Department to the Parks and Recreation Department, and various associated code clean-up items. The Commission voted against moving the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13 and for creating a tree exemption list, and voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment to Chapter 18.162 as follows:
• Remove the Development Plan Review Board’s (DPRB) review authority and allow Staff to review and approve all tree removals, regardless of the number of trees proposed for removal.
• Change replacement requirement to 1:1 if 24-inch box tree(s) is planted or 2:1 if 15-gallon tree(s) is planted.
• Create two levels of protection:
o Oak trees, and any other trees staff proposes, will need to make findings to support removal.
o All other trees with a 10-inch diameter or greater can be removed without any findings as long as they replace them. In this situation, the Director of Community Development can reduce the replacement ratio if there is not enough space to replant trees.
• Do not require replacement trees for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger, and removal of trees required by the Fire Department.
• Explore relaxing the Ordinance for backyard trees.
• Do not require an arborist report for dead, diseased or dying trees, unless applicant disagrees with Director's determination.
• Revise tree removal findings to make them clear and objective. • Change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54- inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards. • Revise the penalty section of the Ordinance.

After receiving direction from the Commission, Staff started the process to amend the Tree Ordinance. This consisted of researching other cities and the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) to identify best practices, and consulting with the City’s arborist.

On April 23, 2024, the City Council heard a discussion about fines related to community trees.

The Council also discussed processes, fees and fines related to private trees. After much discussion, the Council directed Staff to schedule a study session to discuss private trees and provided input for discussion. Some of the items that were mentioned during the discussion, included, but were not limited to:
• Explore reducing or removing the Tree Removal Permit Application fee for single-family property applications.
• Reconsider enforcement of Ordinance to include single-family front yards only. • Create an exemption list for private trees (removal without permits/fees):
o Exempt tree species to consider: Eucalyptus, Tree of Heaven, Queen Palm, White Ash, etc.
o If exemption list is created, consider creating a protected list. • In situations where a 4:1 replacement is required, it may not be an appropriate solution, as space and maintenance are a factor.
• The Tree Ordinance should be easy to follow and not burden residents.

Page 321 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 4 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
• Creation of a tree fund, funded by residents who remove trees but do not have room for required replacement, that would allow other residents to plant trees at no expense to them.

At the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the Municipal Code Text Amendment to exempt all single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items (see Attachment 2). This Staff Report summarizes the proposed changes to the Ordinance, as specifically requested by City Council.

DISCUSSION/ANALYSIS
Following the City Council study session, staff focused on addressing the City Council’s main objective of exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Ordinance and incorporating associated clean-up related items such as exempting trees on single family properties but still protecting the following trees:
a. Trees located within homeowner’s association (1) common areas, (2) open space, (3) scenic easements, (4) slope easements, or (5) maintained areas; and b. Trees located on a single-family lot within (1) open space, (2) scenic easements or (3) slope easements;
There are a number of HOA and hillside residential properties that have large lots with sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property but are non-developable and intended to be kept as natural areas. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed MCTA. In addition, there are certain City properties/communities where a portion of the residents’ lot is landscaped and maintained by the HOA, these areas would also remain as protected areas.

However, any other tree(s) located outside of these listed categories would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and fee.

Another item the City Council requested Staff to address is if certain tree species had protection granted by other agencies. Staff concluded that there is no outside agency that enforces the protection of endangered or classified tree species (i.e. Oaks). The enforcement responsibility would be up to the individual local jurisdiction. Certain agencies will only protect trees in designated protected areas within their jurisdiction. Staff did not amend the Tree Ordinance to incorporate a protected tree species list at this time, however, if directed, Staff has provided a recommendation in the issues/concerns section of this report.

Associated Code Clean-up Item
The code currently reads “Director of Development Services” which no longer exists so staff corrected the title to read “Director of Community Development”. Note that Staff is currently working on a comprehensive code text amendment update that would address this clean-up throughout the entire code for consistency.

Issues/Concerns
During the research phase of this MCTA, Staff found several inconsistencies in the Tree Ordinance that may cause confusion to residents as well as Staff. At this time, Staff has provided the following recommendations to alleviate the concerns that are not addressed in the MCTA. The

Page 322 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 5 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
following information outlines these changes. Planning Staff is requesting the Planning Commission to provide additional direction for the Ordinance update. • In the process of researching outside agencies’ direction, Staff found that the Planning Commission could consider incorporating a comprehensive protected tree list that includes native and locally significant tree types. Creating a species list will assist in preserving and conserving other unidentified sensitive areas in the City. This includes the line of Oak trees found along the centerline of the City and called out in the General Plan Land Use Element Exhibit II-4.1 (see Attachment 3). After comprehensive review, Staff would recommend the following tree types:
o Oaks,
o Sycamores,
o Black Walnuts,
o Camphor,
o California Redwood, and
o Pine species (limited).
• Based on general arboricultural standards, the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken is defined at 54-inches. Staff recommends revising the definition of “Mature Significant Tree” within the Tree Ordinance to accurately reflect arboricultural standards. The code can be amended to change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54-inches for consistency. • The current Ordinance does not address trees located in miscellaneous areas found throughout the City. Staff is requesting direction on keeping these areas protected:
o Single-Family Hillside (SF-H): The single-family hillside zone is intended to provide for the development of safe, comfortable residential areas where residents can enjoy views and a natural setting. Development in this zone is meant to blend with the natural setting when viewed from neighboring areas and other parts of the City.

Staff recommends that these areas remain subject to the Tree Ordinance to ensure that the intended topographic character of the zone is maintained and protected.

This zone encompasses a total of 90 properties as depicted in Figures 1 – 3.

Figure 1 – SF-H Properties along Oakengate Drive

Page 323 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 6 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025
Figure 2 – SF-H Properties along S. Walnut Avenue
Figure 3 – SF-H Properties along Terrebonne Avenue

Page 324 ends

Municipal Code Text Amendment – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 7 For the Meeting of April 17, 2025

ALTERNATIVES
Planning Commission is able to provide Staff with additional direction or alternatives relevant to the provided report and discussion.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Pursuant to CEQA guidelines Section 15061 (b)(3), CEQA does not apply to this item because there is no potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Therefore, no additional environmental review is needed at this time.

During the environmental review process of the project, the City hired an outside consultant (PSOMAS) to review the proposed code text amendment and provide additional CEQA services.

According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance. Therefore, as the Project would result in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. Furthermore, any subsequent tree removals initiated by private property owners would be done according to the updated requirements, thereby limiting any potential impacts. Lastly, these municipal code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City. This founded substantial evidence to support a Notice of Exemption for the provided MCTA. Attachment 4 is the completed Notice of Exemption Memorandum as provided by the consultants.

Respectfully submitted,
Yasmin Dabbous
Assistant Planner
Attachments:

1. Resolution PC-1696

2. City Council Study Session Staff Report (Dated November 12, 2024)

3. General Plan Land Use Element Exhibit II-4.1

4. Notice of Exemption Memorandum - PSOMAS

Page 325 ends

RESOLUTION PC-1696

A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF

SAN DIMAS, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, RECOMMENDING TO THE

CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF MUNICIPAL CODE TEXT
AMENDMENT 23-05, A REQUEST TO AMEND TITLE 18, CHAPTER

18.162 TREE PRESERVATION TO EXEMPT SINGLE-FAMILY ZONED

PROPERTIES AND SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTIES WITHIN A

SPECIFIC PLAN FROM THE ORDINANCE AND ASSOCIATED CLEAN-
UP ITEMS.

WHEREAS, an Amendment to the San Dimas Municipal Code has been duly initiated by the Planning Commission on September 21, 2023; and WHEREAS, the City Council held a study session on November 12, 2024, to discuss the possible amendments to the Tree Ordinance and at the end of the discussion, the Council directed staff to bring back an ordinance that would exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from Tree Ordinances.

WHEREAS, the Amendment is described as Municipal Code Text Amendment 23- 05, to amend the City of San Dimas Tree Preservation Ordinance, Title 18, Chapter 18.162 of the San Dimas Municipal Code to exempt single-family zoned properties and single- family properties within a specific plan from the ordinance and associated clean-up items; and
WHEREAS, the Amendment would affect the area City wide; and WHEREAS, notice was duly given of the public hearing on the matter and that public hearing was held on April 17, 2025, at the hour of 6:00 p.m., with all testimony received being made a part of the public record; and
WHEREAS, all requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act and the City's Environmental Guidelines have been met for the consideration of whether the project will have a significant effect on the environment.

NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the evidence received at the hearing, and for the reasons discussed by the Commissioners at the hearing, the Planning Commission now finds as follows:

A. The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment will not adversely affect adjoining properties as to value, precedent or be detrimental to the area.

The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment is intended to exempt single- family properties from the provisions of the Tree Ordinance. The proposed amendments will not adversely or foreseeably affect property values, establish foreseeable negative precedents, or result in foreseeable detrimental impacts to the community. The proposed amendment, in contrast, aims to establish more flexible standards and procedure leniency for the residents of the City. This amendment reduces the overall time and cost expenditure of homeowners by eliminating the additional procedural steps and review process currently mandated by the Tree Ordinance. This Municipal Code Text Amendment focuses on single-

Page 326 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 2
family zoned properties which are not as heavily landscaped as multifamily residential and non-residential developments, including all public developments such as parks and parkways. This protects a large number of existing mature trees in the City, minimizing the direct or indirect physical change in the environment.

The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment will further the public health, safety and general welfare.

The proposed Municipal Code Amendment advances the general welfare of San Dimas residents by refining the review process to exempt single-family properties from the application and permitting procedures currently set forth in the Tree Preservation Ordinance, while continuously protecting trees in sensitive areas on single-family lots. This amendment establishes a more streamlined process for homeowners seeking to remove trees within the confines of their single-family zoned properties (excluding certain provisions). This streamlined approach is considerate of the general public health, safety and welfare of the San Dimas community.

C. The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment is consistent with the General Plan.

The proposed amendment is aligned with Policy Statement 1.4.3 of the Safety Element within the General Plan. The policy intends to restrict the use of flammable materials and provide additional setbacks in fire hazard zones. Many trees on residential lots are planted within ten (10) feet of a property structure, which has been determined by the Los Angeles County Fire Prevention Unit to be too close for a proper defensible space surrounding a residence. This amendment would potentially reduce the total number of trees found throughout the High Fire Severity Zone of the City, further protecting the general welfare and safety of residents.

The proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment would apply to trees situated within single-family properties. The City's Land Use Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation.

Nevertheless, the element does mention the City's Tree Preservation Ordinance.

As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, PURSUANT TO THE ABOVE FINDINGS, that the Planning Commission recommends to the City Council approval of Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 as set forth in attached Exhibit A:

Page 327 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05

Page 3 ends

PASSED, APPROVED and ADOPTED, the 17th day of April, 2025 by the following vote:

AYES: 5
NOES: 0
ABSENT: 0
ABSTAIN: 0
DaBrett
David A. Bratt, Chairman
San Dimas Planning Commission
ATTEST:

Kimberly Neustice, Senior Management Analyst

Page 328 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 4
Exhibit A
*New text changes are in Blue and Underlined
*Deleted text is in Red and Strikethrough
Title 18. Zoning
Chapter 18.162. TREE PRESERVATION
§ 18.162.010. Purpose.

The purpose of this chapter is to preserve and protect the mature significant trees, as well as other trees which are determined to be desirable, growing within the city.

Such trees are natural aesthetic resources which help define the character of the city and are worthy of protection in order to preserve the natural environment and to protect the city's native plant life heritage for the benefit of all citizens.

Mature significant trees, and other desirable trees, are unique because of their size and beauty, and their abundance adds distinction and character to the natural beauty of the community.

It is pertinent to the welfare and safety of all citizens of the city that such trees be protected from indiscriminate cutting or removal, for conservation purposes, as well as for the preservation of the natural beauty which such trees lend to the city.

It is the intent of this chapter that the design concerns of a development should address preservation of the most desirable and significant of the existing healthy trees and the developer is encouraged to utilize creative land planning techniques to achieve this goal. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.020. Definitions.

For purposes of this chapter the following definitions shall apply:

Mature Significant Tree. A mature significant tree shall refer to any tree within the city of speak genues ich messes eighties or me in in traineer arora lon tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches. The trunk diameter shall be measured at a point thirty-six inches above the ground at the base of the tree. "Remove" includes any act which will cause a mature significant tree to die, including but not limited to acts which inflict damage upon the root system or other parts of the tree by fire, cutting, application of toxic substances, operation of equipment or machinery, or by changing the natural grade of land by excavation or filling the drip line area around the trunk.
"Undeveloped property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to any parcel or parcels of land which does not contain physical man-made improvements, and may be improved in conformance with the applicable development standards of the zoning classification where the property is located. Undeveloped property shall also refer to any parcel or

Page 329 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 5
parcels of land which may or may not contain improvements and on which development applications including, but not limited to, development plan review board, variance, zone change and subdivision, have been submitted.
"Developed property," for the purposes of this chapter, refers to property which has been improved with structures, buildings, surface materials, landscaping and similar improvements in accordance with all city ordinances.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.030. Permits required—Undeveloped property.

A tree removal permit is required. No issuance of any grading or building permits or commencement of work shall be allowed on undeveloped property prior to the approval of a permit. No mature significant tree which conforms to the standards and definitions of this chapter shall be removed or relocated without obtaining the written approval of the director of development services community development. An application to remove or relocate a mature significant tree shall include the following information as determined as necessary by the director of development services community development:

A. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s); B. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species, trunk diameter, height, tree spread, drip line, and health;
C. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included; D. A written technical report from a certified arborist regarding proposed trees, when necessary;
E. Any other information as deemed necessary by the director of development services community development;
F. The application shall be accompanied by a fee in an amount as established by resolution of the city council;
G. The development plan review board, and the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply;
H. Where possible, application shall be submitted with the development application and should be in coniunction with a tree preservation maintenance agreement. An application for a permit, variance, zone change or tentative map for a subdivision, including a minor land division and/or a proposed development plan shall be concurrently filed with an application for a tree removal permit as set forth in accordance with this chapter.
(Ord. 1165 § 1, 2006)

Page 330 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 6
§ 18.162.040. Review required-Developed property.

Mature significant trees may be removed from developed property with the approval of the director of development services community development or development plan review board, subject to the following procedures:

A. Requests to remove or relocate up to, but not exceeding, three mature significant trees may be approved by the director of development services community development pursuant to the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(s);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species and trunk diameter;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

4. Action by the director of development services community development is subject to findings provided for in Section 18.162.070 of this chapter;

5. When, in the sole opinion of the director of development services community development, circumstances are such that removal of three or fewer trees might have an adverse impact on other properties in the area of the proposed tree removal, the director of development services community development may refer the matter to the development plan review board.

B. Requests to remove or relocate more than three mature significant trees may be approved by the development review board pursuant to the following information:

1. A written statement indicating the reason for the removal or relocation of tree(S);

2. The location of all trees on the site, including those to be removed, shall be identified on a plan or map indicating species and trunk diameter;

3. Photographs of the proposed trees to be removed or relocated shall be included;

4. Action by the director of development services-community development is subject to findings provided for in Section 18.162.070 of this chapter.

C. The development plan review board, and the planning commission as applicable, may determine that trees on the project site not defined as mature significant trees by Section 18.162.020(A) are desirable to retain. In such case, the provisions of this chapter shall apply.
(Ord. 1165 § 2, 2006)

Page 331 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 7
§ 18.162.060. Conditions imposed.

An approval to remove or relocate mature significant trees by the director of development services community development or the development plan review board are subject to conditions of approval as deemed necessary to implement the provisions of this chapter including, but not limited to:

A. Tree relocation and/or two for one replacement with minimum fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. The two for one replacement ratio may be reduced as determined by the final decision making body, if a minimum of one of the following additional findings are made:

1. The reduced replacement requirement is consistent with the purposes of this chapter.

2. The tree(s) in question are located where the impact of the tree removal on the community is limited (such as trees in a generally flat portion of the rear yard of a single-family house that are deemed to have less public benefit.

3. The property in question has an adequate number of existing trees therefore a reduced replacement ratio is appropriate.

B. When on-site features, project constraints, and/or other considerations exist which prevent reasonable on-site relocation, relocation to an approved off-site location shall be permitted.

C. If said conditions are imposed, the owner will be responsible for all replacement and relocated trees for a minimum period of two years. If during this time the tree(s) is (are) declared unhealthy by a certified arborist as set forth in Section 18.162.090, the diseased trees shall be removed and replaced at the cost of the applicant, as set forth in Section 18.162.100.

D. A maintenance agreement shall be submitted by the applicant and established for each replaced and relocated tree. The maintenance agreement and maintenance responsibility shall be transferred with the sale of the property if title to the property is transferred within the specified maintenance period. (Ord. 1165 § 4, 2006)
§ 18.162.070. Required findings.

The granting of a permit for the removal or relocation of mature significant trees shall be subject to a minimum of one of the following findings as they pertain to the specific property:

A. The condition of the mature significant tree(s) with respect to disease, danger of falling, proximity to existing or proposed structures, and interference with utility services warrant removal of the tree;
B. It is reasonable to remove the tree because of its continued existence at the location prevents the reasonable development of the subject property;

Page 332 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 8
C. Removal of the tree will not create a negative impact on the topography of the land, erosion, soil retention, and will not contribute to the diversion or increased flow of surface waters;
D. Based on the number of trees in the neighborhood on surrounding properties or on the site, and the effect of tree removal upon enjoyment of the residents and the general public, and on property values in the area;
E. The tree removal is consistent with good forestry practices, such as the number of healthy trees which a given parcel of land will support. (Ord. 1165 § 5, 2006)
§ 18.162.080. Exceptions.

All trees should be protected, but there are a few cases where this chapter does not apply and they are as follows:

A. Trees located within the boundaries of single-family zoned properties or single- family properties designated within a specific plan, with the exception of the following;
a. Trees located within homeowner's association (1) common areas, (2) open space, (3) scenic easements, (4) slope easements, (5) maintained areas; b. Trees located on a single-family lot within (1) open space, (2) scenic easements or (3) slope easements;
A.B Trees planted, grown, and/or held for sale by licensed nurseries and/or tree farms or the removal or transplanting of such trees pursuant to the operation of licensed nursery and/or tree farm;
B.C Trees within existing or proposed public right-of-way where their removal or relocation is necessary to obtain adequate line-of-site distances as required by the city engineer;
C.D. Trees which, in the opinion of the city engineer, will cause damage to existing public improvements;
Đ.E. Trees which require maintenance or removal action for the protection of existing electrical power or communication lines or other property of a public utility; E.F Trees damaged by thunderstorms, windstorms, flood, earthquakes, fire, widespread organic disease or insect infestation, or other natural disasters and determined to be dangerous by a peace officer, fireman, civil defense official or code enforcement officer in their official capacity;
F.G. Minor trimming and/or pruning of trees on developed property within the scope of typical and reasonable tree maintenance;
G.H Trees declared to be dead, diseased or dying, subject to the requirements of Section 18.162.090;

Page 333 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 9
H. Fruit trees, including citrus, plum, nectarine, cherry, apricot, peach, pear, pomegranate, persimmon, loquat, fig, avocado and other species determined similar by the director of development services community development. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990; Ord. 1165 § 6, 2006)
§ 18.162.090. Verification of dead, diseased or dying trees.

The health of any mature significant tree declared to be dead, diseased or dying shall, prior to removal, be verified by a written report of a certified arborist, horticulturist or other qualified person.
(Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.100. Tree maintenance.

The careful management of trees has become an ever increasing factor in the health and care of mature significant trees. When mature significant trees are located on designated scenic or open space areas, the owner of the property shall be exempt from this section.

When mature significant trees are located on developed property, whether remaining trees, relocated trees, or new trees planted to replace those removed, the owner of the property shall maintain the trees to preserve and protect their health in accordance with the following measures:

A. The maintenance of trees standing upon private property shall be the responsibility of the owners) of those properties.

B. Trees shall be pruned, treated and maintained in such a fashion that the trees will be free of various damage, pests, disease and dead branches. The trees shall be in good biological and aesthetic condition.

C. Where applicable, a bond or cash deposit as determined by the director of development services community development shall be furnished by the developer for the management and protection of each existing, replanted or relocated tree(s).

Said bond or cash deposit shall be refunded upon the successful completion of a tree maintenance program as required by the director of development services community development.

D. Any tree removal and/or replacement permit granted by the director of development services community development pursuant to Section 18.162.030 and the development plan review board pursuant to Section 18.162.050 shall include a condition requiring an objectively observable maintenance and care program to be initiated to insure the continued health and care of mature significant tree(s) on the property. Such program shall specify length of maintenance program, maintenance plan and method of inspection. Said tree maintenance program and plan is not required of the applicant when trees are to be relocated to an approved off-site location pursuant to the provisions of this chapter. § 18.162.110. Protection of existing trees.

Care shall be exercised by all individuals, developers and contractors working near mature significant trees to be preserved so that no damage occurs to the trees. All construction

Page 334 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 10
shall preserve and protect the health of trees to remain in place, to be relocated, and new trees planted to replace those removed and any trees adjacent to the subject property in accordance with the following measures:

A. All trees to be saved shall be enclosed by an appropriate construction barrier, such as chain link fence or other means acceptable to the director of development services community development, prior to the issuance of any grading or building or building permit and prior to commencement of work. Fences are to remain in place during all phases of construction and may not be removed without the written consent of the director of development services_community development, until construction is complete;
B. Any tree which is adjacent to the subject property and may be potentially impacted by persons or activity on the subject property shall be protected pursuant to the provisions of Section 18.162.110. It shall be the responsibility of the agent of the subject property to obtain the written permission from adjacent property owners prior to action for the protection of trees on adjacent property as required by Section 18.162.110;
C. No substantial disruption or removal of the structural or absorptive roots of any tree shall be performed;
D. No fill material shall be placed within the drip line of any tree; E. No construction, including structures and walls, that disrupts the root system shall be permitted. As a guideline, no cutting of roots should occur within the drip line of the tree as measured at ground level. Actual setbacks may vary to meet the needs of individual tree species as determined by an arborist or landscape architect.

Where some root removal is necessary, the tree crown may require thinning to prevent wind damage;
F. Topping and/or severe pruning of trees that results in significant damage to the tree to the point that reasonable future growth may be limited, as determined by a Certified Arborist, shall constitute a tree removal and is subject to the penalties outlined in Section 18.162.130; and
G. The director of development services community development may impose such additional measures determined necessary to preserve and protect the health of trees to remain on site.
(Ord. 1165 § 8, 2006)
§ 18.162.120. Appeals.

Appeals shall be in accordance with Chapter 18.212 of this title. (Ord. 913 § 1 (Exh. A), 1990)
§ 18.162.130. Penalties.

Violation of any provision of this chapter, or of any provision of any permit issued pursuant to this chapter shall be a misdemeanor punishable as follows:

Page 335 ends

Resolution PC-1696
Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05 Page 11
A. Fines shall be set forth in accordance with Section 1.12.010 of this code. Each tree removed in violation of this chapter shall constitute a separate offense.

B. As set forth in Section 18.162.010, it is the intent of this chapter to preserve to the greatest extent possible those trees which have contributed to the beauty of the city and the welfare of its residents. It is therefore the expressed intent of the city council that, to the extent legally permissible, upon conviction of any person pursuant to subsection A of this section, in lieu of incarceration, conditions of probation be placed upon such violator requiring the replacement of each tree removed in violation of this chapter with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than a twenty-four inch box size, or other replacement of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater. The number, size and location of the equivalent replacement tree shall be determined by the director of development services community development. For the purpose of this section, a suitable location may include an off-site location.

C. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no development permit of any kind, including but not limited to, any building permit or certificate of occupancy, shall be issued for any lot on which one or more trees have been removed in violation of the provisions of this chapter, or any permit issued pursuant to this chapter, unless and until the owner of such lot has replaced each such tree, to an on-site or off- site location pursuant to the provisions of this section, with up to four trees of a similar species of not less than twenty-four inch box size, or of equivalent value and size, whichever is greater, or provided security satisfactory to the director of development services community development that such trees will be planted at such time as determined by the director.
(Ord. 1165 § 9, 2006)

Page 336 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS

PLANNING COMMISSION

MINUTES
Regularly Scheduled Meeting
Thursday, April 17, 2025, at 6:00 p.m.
245 East Bonita Avenue, City Council Chamber

PRESENT
Chairman David Bratt
Vice-Chairman John Davis
Commissioner Margie Green
Commissioner James Shirley
Commissioner Doran Barnes
Planning Manager Marco Espinoza
Assistant Planner Yasmin Dabbous
Senior Management Analyst Kimberly Neustice

CALL TO ORDER AND FLAG SALUTE
Commissioner Bratt called the regular meeting of the Planning Commission to order at 6:00 p.m. and Commissioner Green led the flag salute.

CONSENT CALENDAR
CC 1. Approval of Revised February 20, 2025 minutes.

CC 2. Approval of March 20, 2025 minutes.

MOTION: Moved by Commissioner Green, seconded by Vice-Chairman Davis to approve the consent calendar. Motion carried 5-0.

PUBLIC HEARING
PH 1. Municipal Code Text Amendment 25-01, Consideration and discussion of a City-initiated Municipal Code Text Amendment of Title 18-Chapter 18.40 Affordable Housing Overlay Zone, deleting Affordable Housing Overlay Zone No. 2 (AHO-2)
Staff is requesting that the Planning Commission continue the item until the next regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting of May 15, 2025. Staff found that a portion of the overlay zone will need to remain due to the Housing overlay zone for the Grove Station/Village Walk area. It has to do with minimum and maximum density levels and if the overlay zone is removed, this could be seen as down zoning. Staff will revise the report and ordinance and re-notice for the next meeting.

Page 337 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 2
April 17, 2025
RESOLUTION PC-1694

A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SAN

DIMAS, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF MUNICIPAL CODE TEXT AMENDMENT 25-01, WHICH AMENDS TITLE 18 – ZONING, CHAPTER 18.40 AFFORDABLE HOUSING OVERLAY ZONE, TO REMOVE AFFORDABE HOUSING OVERLAY ZONE 2 FROM THE CHAPTER.

MOTION: Moved by Commissioner Barnes, seconded by Commissioner Shirley to continue the public hearing to the next regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting of May 15, 2025.

Motion carries 5-0.

PH 2. Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05, Consideration and discussion of a Municipal Code Text Amendment to amend Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from the Ordinance and associated clean-up items.

Staff report presented by Assistant Planner Dabbous recommending Planning Commission approve Resolution PC-1696 recommending City Council adopt Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05. A revised environmental memo from the consultant, Psomas was put on the dais for the Commissioners review.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that the Commission previously made several suggestions for modifications to the tree ordinance and asked if Staff presented their suggestions to the City Council.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated no, that when the ordinance was presented at the City Council Study Session, the Council only discussed removing the requirements from the single-family areas, but they didn’t discuss any other items at that time.

Vice-Chairman Davis asked if Staff wanted the Commission to give the recommendations again for City Council to consider when this MCTA goes for Council consideration.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that it was up to the Commission if they wanted to make recommendations to City Council but they were pretty clear that the only recommendation they considered was exempting single-family areas from the ordinance.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that there were a few recommendations that the Commission felt were important.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that on page 4 of the Psomas memo it does mention the recommendations made previously by the Planning Commission.

Page 338 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 3
April 17, 2025
Vice-Chairman Davis asked if this new ordinance would trigger an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) to remove Homeowner Association (HOA) trees.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated no, an EIR would not be required.

Commissioner Barnes stated that generally this Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) seems fine but he would like to discuss the items being changed. He asked if accessory dwelling units (ADUs) would be considered part of the single-family lot exemption.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that yes, ADU’s are considered single-family and would be exempt.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that he would like to discuss if the Commission wants to exempt every tree, or if they would like to have some trees protected from this exemption, and have those protected tree removals considered more closely. He stated that for significant trees, Commission should at least understand why the owner wants to remove the tree and he has a concern about people cutting down major oak trees. He would like to try and encourage the City Council to consider significant trees at least in the front yard, not to be exempt so it can be understood why the owners want these trees removed.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that Psomas did recommend native trees, predominantly oak trees, not be subject to the exemption. The biologist that prepared the list stated that oak trees are considered rare but not endangered and are protected based more on the location, such as in State Parks. Since San Dimas is a local jurisdiction the City can regulate the types of trees more than State or County areas. The Black Walnut trees can be removed from the list if Commission would like. It might make it easier for the public if the ordinance states that the list of trees are protected no matter the size of the tree.

Commissioner Barnes stated that the proposal’s purpose is to exempt all tree removals on single-family lots and it seems to get complicated when calling out protected or significant trees. The easiest thing would be to say it’s your property, you can do what you’d like.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that City Council’s direction was to exempt all trees but the environmental review by Psomas suggested that trees, at least in conservation areas, should be protected.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that he is ok with protecting trees in conservation areas. He has a scenic easement on his property and he understands why you would want to protect trees in these areas. He stated he is also ok with the list of protected trees.

Chairman Bratt opened public hearing.

No communications were made.

Chairman Bratt closed public hearing.

Page 339 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 4
April 17, 2025
Planning Manager Espinoza stated that the text for the amendment is on page 45 of the agenda, Item A, under 18.162, and it addresses the environmental concern when it comes to protecting trees in common areas, open space, scenic easements, slopes and maintained areas. All these properties would still be exempt in the developable areas and the protected trees would only apply to the areas just mentioned. There is also an area in the city zoned as Single-Family Hillside that have conservation overlays on them. Those lots would not be part of the recommended single-family exemption but could still apply for a tree removal permit.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that in his HOA, unless it’s on their actual property, it’s considered common area and asked if these trees in the HOA area would require City approval.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated yes.

Chairman Bratt stated that whatever they do in the back yard is fine with him but to exempt all trees on a single-family property, including the front yard, shouldn’t be done because in his opinion some trees should stay. He disagrees that front yard trees should be part of a blanket exemption. The way he interprets this, the City Council wants to exempt any tree on a single-family lot and he opposes that, and suggests that if it’s in the front yard it should be reviewed. Perhaps there are good reasons to remove the tree but it should be up to Staff to consider it as part of an application.

Vice-Chairman Davis agreed that if the tree type is on the Psomas list and meets the requirements, they should not be exempt and should go through the tree removal application process.

Commissioner Green agreed stating it makes sense to her as well.

Commissioner Shirley asked for confirmation that if one of the trees on Psomas list is in the front yard of a single-family property, would have to go through the tree removal application process.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that was correct.

Commissioner Barnes stated if his neighbors just decided to chop down five mature trees, that would change the landscape view of the neighborhood. He feels that this should be part of a discussion before just allowing them to remove significant trees, native or not. Any large mature tree being removed should be considered by Staff before just allowing them to remove them under the exemption.

Commissioner Shirley asked if the residents have had a chance to share their thoughts on this matter.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that today’s public hearing was the opportunity. The agenda was posted on the agenda boards, on the City website and we published a public hearing notice in the newspaper to try to encourage the public to attend.

Page 340 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 5
April 17, 2025
Commissioner Barnes stated he feels we should make it as simple as possible. He wanted to remove a tree a while ago and the process seemed complicated and there was a question if he needed an arborist report. He feels that the process should definitely be streamlined but there should be some kind of input and review for the significant trees. He asked if the MCTA was to go forward and single-family lots are exempt, are they subject to a replacement ratio.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated if the trees were covered under the exemption they could be removed without notifying the City and there is no replacement ratio. Right now, Staff reviews applications and they have to write findings as to why the trees are ok for removal which would no longer be done under the single-family exemption.

Vice-Chairman Davis suggests that there should be a review process for significant trees.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that the Commission would have to come up with a recommendation as to what determines if it is a significant tree. An eight-inch or ten-inch diameter is rather small to consider a significant tree. Under this code amendment the measurement would now be taken at fifty-four inches from the ground instead of the previous thirty-six inches.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated if someone is going to rip out a significant tree, it really doesn’t do any good to put a box tree in its place because it won’t look the same. He feels that they should get a permit to remove a significant tree in the front yard, but a replacement tree should not be required.

Should a conclusion be made that removing a tree would change the look of the neighborhood, it would be appropriate for Staff to deny a permit.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that City Council is going to expect explanations for Planning Commission’s recommendations if they decide to require some trees in the single-family area be permitted for removal. The next change on this MCTA is changing the replacement ratio from either one (1) twenty-four-inch box or two (2) fifteen-gallon trees. This would also apply to commercial areas.

Vice-Chairman Davis asked what happens if the site is over saturated with trees.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated the modification states “up to” and can be reduced as needed.

These are part of Planning Commission’s previous comments on the MCTA and staff would like to know if the Commission still wants Staff to bring these items up to the City Council when it moves forward. All of these recommendations from Planning Commission were presented to City Council at the study session but the Council did not discuss the items.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that he would like to keep this replacement ratio recommendation. He also stated that he wanted to go over Item #1 which deals with who will review tree removal permits.

Less than four tree removals is a Staff level review and four or more is Planning Commission. He states Item #2 can stay.

Commissioner Barnes stated that it’s up to replacement ratio. What’s written now seems very prescriptive and he feels that it should be written differently.

Page 341 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 6
April 17, 2025
Chairman Bratt stated the wording should not say “up to 1”, but should be changed to “at the discretion of staff”.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated Staff will rewrite this portion to say “up to, but at the discretion of Staff”. That way Staff can be flexible if the lot already has several trees and adding another one would over saturate the lot. The concern he has is that City Council is not going to listen to all of these recommendations and that they will go back to only reviewing the single-family areas for exemption of tree permits. If Planning Commission is going to focus on something, maybe focus on the replacement ratio and the significant tree requirements.

Vice-Chairman Davis asked if an arborist report will be required for tree removals that have to go through the permit process.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that it wouldn’t be required anymore for single-family, however, it could be required for HOA’s and commercial areas. If it’s obvious to Staff that the trees are dead, Staff won’t require a report but if Staff feels it’s still alive, the applicant would be directed to get an arborist report.

Vice-Chairman Davis asked to clarify if City Council is proposing to leave the ordinance the way it is, but to exempt single-family lots from the tree removal ordinance. Planning Commission recommended other changes to the code but it seems like City Council wouldn’t be open to incorporating additional changes at this time.

Planning Manager Espinoza stated that was the indication he received at the City Council Study Session.

Chairman Bratt felt that the Planning Commission should only make recommendations about single-family lots back to the City Council. He stated that the two recommendations that the Planning Commission should forward to City Council are the requirement for significant trees and that front yard trees should not be exempt from the ordinance.

Vice-Chairman Davis stated that the Commission can recommend that all trees on single-family lots are exempt except any trees in the front yard above a certain size. What is that size? He feels it should be more than a ten-inch diameter but less than a twenty-four-inch diameter and measured at fifty-four inches from the ground.

Chairman Bratt recommended a fifteen-inch diameter.

Vice-Chairman Davis reiterated that any trees in the back yard can fall under the single-family exemption but any tree in the front yard with a fifteen-inch diameter as measured from fifty-four inches from the ground should be subject to the tree removal permit process and reviewed by Staff since these trees could have a significant impact on the landscape of the neighborhood after removal.

Page 342 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 7
April 17, 2025
Commissioner Barnes stated that if you have a home that has a tree that meet these requirements, you probably bought the home knowing that this tree existed and there are owners that might buy the lot because of these mature trees.

RESOLUTION PC-1696

A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SAN

DIMAS, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF MUNICIPAL CODE TEXT AMENDMENT 23-05, A REQUEST TO AMEND TITLE 18, CHAPTER 18.162 TREE PRESERVATION TO EXEMPT

SINGLE-FAMILY ZONED PROPERTIES AND SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTIES WITHIN A SPECIFIC PLAN FROM THE ORDINANCE AND ASSOCIATED CLEAN-UP ITEMS.

MOTION: Moved by Vice-Chairman Davis, seconded by Commissioner Green to approve Resolution PC-1696 recommending City Council adopt MCTA 23-05 with the following modifications:
• All tree removal applications should be reviewed at Staff level. • Exempt tree removals from-single family properties except for mature trees, of any species, in the front yard that are fifteen-inch or more in diameter as measured from fifty-four inches from the ground, which will be subject to the tree removal permit process. • Require that Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) properties remain protected under the Tree Preservation Ordinance and not exempt.

Motion carried 5-0.

ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
a. Community Development Department
Planning Manager Espinoza gives an update:
• There will be two items for the May Planning Commission meeting. b. Members of the Audience
No communications were made.
c. Planning Commission
Vice-Chairman Davis asked about the Forestry property. Planning Manager Espinoza stated that we have received two different proposals from the owner. The one they would like to build is a one-hundred sixty-one-unit townhome development. The other proposal that they submitted does include two to three story townhomes and some five story apartments in the back. If they

Page 343 ends

Planning Commission Minutes Page 8
April 17, 2025
under build this site, we would have to update the housing element to relocate the reduced number of homes from this site either to a new site or to an existing identified site.

Commissioner Green asked about movement on the development on Walnut. Planning Manager Espinoza stated that they are moving very slowly but they are still moving forward.

ADJOURNMENT
MOTION: Commissioner Green moved, seconded by Commissioner Shirley. Motion carried 5-

0. The meeting adjourned at 7:27 p.m. to the regular Planning Commission Meeting scheduled for Thursday May 15, 2025.
________________________________
David A. Bratt, Chairman
San Dimas Planning Commission
ATTEST:
_______________________
Kimberly Neustice
Senior Management Analyst
Approved: May 15, 2025

Page 344 ends

5 Hutton Centre Drive, Suite 300 • Santa Ana, CA 92707 • T: 714.751.7373

MEMORANDUM
April 17, 2025
To: From:

Luis Torrico
Director of Community Development
City of San Dimas
Bryan Hamilton
Jennifer Marks
Psomas
Subject: Substantial Evidence for Notice of Exemption for the Proposed Amendment to the City of San Dimas Chapter 18.162 Tree Ordinance, MCTA 23-05 The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) was signed into law in 1970. The California Environmental Quality Act is a statue that requires state and local agencies to identify potential significant effects a “project” may have on the environment and any feasible mitigation that may be implemented to avoid or mitigate those impacts. A “project” is defined in Section 21065, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as an activity which may cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and consists of any of the following: an activity directly undertaken by any public agency; an activity undertaken by a person which is supported, in whole or in part, through contracts, grants, subsidies, loans, or other forms of assistance from one or more public agencies; or, an activity that involves the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement for use by one or more public agencies. A “significant effect on the environment” is defined in Section 21068 Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as a substantial, or potentially substantial, adverse change in the environment. Furthermore, the government agency which has the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project which may have a significant effect upon the environment is defined as the “lead agency” in Section 21067, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code.

CEQA applies in situations where a governmental agency can use its judgment in deciding whether and how to carry out or approve a project. A project subject to such judgmental controls is called a “discretionary project.” Where the law requires a governmental agency to act on a project in a set way without allowing the agency to use its own judgment, the project is called “ministerial,” and CEQA does not apply. Once an application for a project is deemed complete, a lead agency must first determine whether an activity is subject to CEQA before conducting an initial study. An activity is not subject to CEQA if: the activity does not involve the exercise of discretionary powers by a public agency; the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment; or the activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378.

Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, a Notice of Exemption (NOE) may be filed if the City of San Dimas, in its capacity as the Lead Agency, determines that a proposed action or project is exempt from CEQA. According to the CEQA Guidelines, a NOE must contain the following information:
• A description of the proposed action or project;

Page 345 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 2 ends

Psomas
• A finding that the proposed action or project is exempt, including a citation of the State CEQA Guidelines section or statute under which the project is found to be exempt; and, • A brief statement in support of the finding.
• The Lead Agency authorized the preparation of this Notice of Exemption This report was prepared in accordance with Section 21000 (et seq) - Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code and Section 15000 (et seq), Article 1, Chapter 3, Division 6, Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It is important to note that CEQA is not a process that determines whether or not a project should be approved and no recommendations can be made as to whether or not a lead agency should approve or deny a project application.

SECTION 15061 – REVIEW FOR EXEMPTION
Section 15061(b)(3) – Common Sense Exemption
Section 15061(B)(3), the Common Sense Exemption, of the 2025 CEQA Guidelines applies to the proposed revision to the City of San Dimas’ Community Tree Ordinance Project (Project or proposed Project). Section 15061 outlines the process for determining whether or not a project would be exempt from CEQA. This process is detailed in Section 15061(B), provided below:
(b) A project is exempt from CEQA if:
(1) The project is exempt by statute (see, e.g. Article 18, commencing with Section 15260).
(2) The project is exempt pursuant to a categorical exemption (see Article 19, commencing with Section 15300) and the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2. (3) The activity is covered by the commonsense exemption that CEQA applies only to projects which have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is not subject to CEQA.
(4) The project will be rejected or disapproved by a public agency. (See Section 15270(b)).
(5) The project is exempt pursuant to the provisions of Article 12.5 of this Chapter.

According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance, under most conditions, as described below in the Project Description. Therefore, as the Project would result

Page 346 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 3 ends

Psomas
in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. These Municipal Code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Background
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under Chapters 13.36 and 18.162 of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC), respectively. Chapter 13.36 - Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median, parkway, planting easement, or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department. Meanwhile, Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department.

The City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance was adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or any other species of trees which measure 10 inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of 38 inches or more (the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches). The Ordinance exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception of these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.

The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. Requests to remove up to three trees may be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four or more trees requires approval by the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB). The application fee for a Tree Removal Permit for up to three trees is $300, while the fee for the review of four or more trees is $500. Approved tree removal applications are subject to a two-for-one replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if the reduced replacement ratio is consistent with the purpose of the Ordinance, removal of the protected tree will have a minimal impact on the community or if the subject site has an adequate number of existing trees.

On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance to remove the Development Plan Review Board’s review authority, create a protected tree list, reduce the replacement ratio for tree removal violations, remove replacement requirements for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger or removal of trees required by the Fire Department, remove the arborist report submittal requirement, revise findings, move the Tree Preservation Ordinance from Title 18 Zoning to Title 13 Civic Facilities to

Page 347 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 4 ends

Psomas
change the implementation responsibilities of the Ordinance to the Parks and Recreation Department, and various associated code clean-up items. The Commission voted against moving the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13 and for creating a tree exemption list, and voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment to Chapter 18.162 as follows:
• Remove the Development Plan Review Board’s (DPRB) review authority and allow City Staff to review and approve all tree removals, regardless of the number of trees proposed for removal.
• Change replacement requirement to 1:1 if 24-inch box tree(s) is planted or 2:1 if 15- gallon tree(s) is planted.
• Create two levels of protection:
• Oak tree, and any other tree staff proposes, will need to make findings to remove.
• All other trees with a 10-inch diameter or greater can be removed without any findings as long as they replace them. In this situation, the Director of Community Development can reduce the replacement ratio if there is not enough space to replant trees.
• Do not require replacement trees for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger, and removal of trees required by the Fire Department.
• Explore relaxing the Ordinance for backyard trees.
• Do not require arborist report for dead, diseased or dying tree, unless applicant disagrees with Director's determination.
• Revise tree removal findings to make them clear and objective. • Change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54-inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards. • Revise the penalty section of the Ordinance.

On April 23, 2024, the City Council heard a discussion about fines related to community trees.

The Council also discussed processes, fees and fines related to private trees. After much discussion, the Council directed City staff to schedule a study session to discuss private trees and provided input for discussion. Some of the items that were mentioned during the discussion, included, but were not limited to:
• Explore reducing or removing the Tree Removal Permit Application fee for single-family property applications.
• Reconsider enforcement of Ordinance for single-family front yards only. • Create an exemption list for private trees (can be removed without permits/fees):
• Exempt tree species to consider: Eucalyptus, Tree of Heaven, Queen Palm, White Ash, etc.

Page 348 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 5 ends

Psomas
• If exemption list is created, consider creating protected list. • In situations where 4:1 replacement is required, it may not be an appropriate solution, as space and maintenance are a factor.
• The Tree Ordinance should be easy to follow and not burden residents. • Creation of a tree fund, funded by residents who remove trees but do not have room for required replacement, that would allow other residents to plant trees at no expense to them.

During the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff was directed to revise the Municipal Code Text Amendment to exempt single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items. The proposed changes to the Ordinance, as specifically requested by City Council, are described in the next section.

Proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment
Following the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff focused on addressing the City Council’s main objective of exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Preservation Ordinance, while still protecting the following trees:
• Trees located within common areas, open space, scenic easements, slope easements, or areas maintained by a Homeowner’s Association (HOA); and • Trees located on a single-family property within designated open space area, scenic easement, or slope easement.

The City contains numerous hillside residential properties as well as properties governed by a homeowners association (HOA). These properties contain sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property in question but are restricted from development in order to be kept as natural open space. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment. In addition, there are certain properties/communities within the City where a portion of the owners’ parcel is landscaped and maintained by an HOA, thus viewed as a common area tree. These areas would continue to remain protected areas. Nevertheless, any other tree(s) located outside of the categories mentioned above would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and associated fee.

REVIEW OF CITY OF SAN DIMAS GENERAL PLAN LAND USE MAP AND GUIDELINES The proposed Project would apply to trees situated within single-family properties. The City published its General Plan in 1991, one year after the passage of the Tree Preservation Ordinance. The City’s Land Use Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. Nevertheless, the Element does mention the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance (City of San Dimas 1991). As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.

Page 349 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 6 ends

Psomas
REVIEW OF 15300.2–EXCEPTIONS CRITERIA
Location: Classes 3, 4, 5, 6, and 11 are qualified by consideration of where the project is to be located – a project that is ordinarily insignificant in its impact on the environment may, in a particularly sensitive environment, be significant. Therefore, these classes are considered to apply to all instances, except where the project may impact on an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern where designated, precisely mapped, and officially adopted pursuant to law by federal, state, or local agencies.

The Project is not considered under Classes 3, 4, 5, 6 or 11. Therefore, this exception is not applicable to Common Sense Exemptions. Nevertheless, the Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, the Project would not result in any direct impacts. Subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would be required to adhere to the requirements outlined in the updated Ordinance, ensuring that none of the trees identified above and in the proposed Text Amendment are removed. As a result, a significant impact would not be created based on the location of future actions under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance; conversely, impacts would be avoided based on the locations identified as allowable areas for tree removal.

Cumulative Impacts: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any direct impacts.

The City’s consideration of native and sensitive trees, including those within designated conservation areas, would preclude a significant impact related to loss of native and locally important species throughout single-family properties located within the City. In addition, the City has prepared a Community Forest Management Plan dated June 27, 2023 with the intention of protecting existing City trees, implementing public education programs, and expanding the City’s inventory of trees within viable, vacant sites along city streets, at city facilities and in city parks (City of San Dimas 2023). Additionally, because the trees allowed for removal under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would primarily consist of individual trees within private property. As a result, cumulative biological impacts are not considered to be significant. Meanwhile, cumulative air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would not be significant either. As stated above, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of a diverse selection of trees within City owned property. The expansion of the City’s tree inventory would offset the small loss of carbon sequestration resulting from the removal of trees within private, single-family properties.

As a result, no significant cumulative impacts would occur.

Significant Effects (unusual circumstances): The Project would not have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances, as demonstrated by the discussion below.

Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties, the Project would not induce any development. As a result, no air

Page 350 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 7 ends

Psomas
quality or greenhouse gas emissions would occur. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in negligible emissions. It is important to note that these emissions would be too small to quantify and would be well below the regional and local thresholds established by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD). As stated above, while the ordinance may result in a small loss of carbon sequestration, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of more trees within City-owned properties. Therefore, no impacts with respect to air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would occur.

Biological Resources: The following analysis focuses on trees that are native to the City of San Dimas: coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia), canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis), San Gabriel oak (Quercus durata var. gabrielensis), Nuttall's scrub oak (Quercus dumosa), Engelmann oak (Quercus engelmannii), interior live oak (Quercus wislizeni); western sycamore (Platanus racemosa), southern California black walnut (Juglans californica); knobcone pine (Pinus attenuata), Coulter pine (Pinus coulteri), and Bishop pine (Pinus muricata) 1 . Of these
species, the following species are considered special status: southern California black walnut (California Rare Plant Rank [CRPR] 4.22), San Gabriel oak (CRPR 4.22), Nuttall’s scrub oak (CRPR 1B.13), and Engelmann oak (CRPR 4.22) (CDFW 2025a). Additionally, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) considers the following woodland vegetation types to be sensitive natural communities: western sycamore woodlands (Platanus racemosa alliances), California walnut groves (Juglans californica alliances), and Coulter pine woodland and forests (Pinus coulteri alliances) (CDFW 2025b).

The Significant Ecological Area (SEA) Program was established to help conserve the genetic and physical diversity within Los Angeles County by designating biological resource areas capable of sustaining themselves into the future. SEAs are places where the County deems it important to balance between development and conservation of fragile resources such as streams, woodlands, and Threatened or Endangered species and their habitats. There are two SEAs within the City of San Dimas: the East San Gabriel Valley SEA (i.e., Walnut Creek, Bonelli Regional Park/Puddingstone Reservoir, and various open spaces referred to as the Walnut Islands) and San Dimas Canyon/San Antonio Wash SEA. Both of these SEAs include important oak and walnut woodland habitats. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.

There are a number of HOA-governed and designated hillside residential properties that have large lots with sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property but are non-developable and intended to be kept as natural areas. Many of these 1 This list of pine trees includes those that are known to occur along the southern edge of the Angeles National Forest.
2 CRPR 4.2: Species that are considered of limited distribution and are considered fairly threatened in California (20– 80% of occurrences threatened; moderate degree and immediacy of threat). 3 CRPR 1B.1: Species that are considered Rare, Threatened, or Endangered throughout their range and are considered seriously threatened in California (over 80% of occurrences threatened; high degree and immediacy of threat).

Page 351 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 8 ends

Psomas
conservation overlays include oak and walnut woodlands. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.

The current staff report recommends that single family residences be exempted from applying for a tree permit for the removal of trees on their lot. While single individuals of the protected tree species (as defined by the ordinance) listed above could be present on an individual lot, individuals within developed areas are more likely to have been planted as landscaping during development than to be remnant native individual trees. These individual trees, whether planted or remnant native individuals, are within small fragments of habitat (i.e., single family lots), isolated from larger areas of naturally occurring woodlands and habitat areas, and would not be expected to be naturally reproducing. The change in the municipal code text amendment would not require a tree removal permit for individual trees within single family lots, and could result in the loss of tree individuals, including species on the protected species list. However, since these individual trees are not contributing to sustaining natural woodland areas, the loss of these isolated individual trees would not affect the viability of the larger areas of native woodlands (described above within SEAs and hillside areas/conservation overlays) that provide higher quality woodland habitat. Therefore, the loss of trees resulting from the municipal code text amendment, as currently proposed (applying to only single family lots), would be considered less than significant.

The remaining species recommended as protected trees in the current staff report, camphor and California redwood, are not native to the City of San Dimas. There are also several species of pine trees that have been planted as ornamentals in southern California. These species are not considered special status, as individuals or as woodlands. Therefore, the loss of individuals of these tree species would not be considered a significant impact.

All trees, including native and non-native trees, could provide habitat for nesting birds and raptors; however, compliance with standard protective measures to avoid impacts on nesting birds/raptors would be required.

Geology: The Project would not result in the development of housing or other habitable structures that would expose people to risks associated with seismic shaking, ground failure, landslides, or other geotechnical issues present in Southern California. The Project consists of text amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

Water Quality: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to water quality, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, the Project’s implementation would not alter drainage patterns within hillside areas, as the removal of trees from these areas would be precluded under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance.

Page 352 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 9 ends

Psomas
Noise: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. The Project would not induce any development as the Project is programmatic in nature. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in the generation of temporary noise associated with the use of chainsaws. It is important to note that this noise would be temporary and tree removal would be required to adhere to all applicable City noise regulations.

Utilities and Public Services: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments and is programmatic in nature. The Project does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography that would result in impacts on any public services or utilities. Nevertheless, green waste generated during the subsequent removal of trees must be removed and properly disposed of pursuant to all applicable local and State requirements.

Scenic Highways: The Project would not result in damage to scenic resources. The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts on scenic highways or scenic resources, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, according to the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), there are no officially designated State scenic highway in the City (Caltrans 2025). As a result, no impacts would occur.

Hazardous Waste Site: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties (parcels that are typically not associated with hazardous waste sites), the Project would not induce any development, especially development on properties that are included on a list of hazardous materials sites. As a result, no impacts would occur.

Historical Resources: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to historic resources, including neighborhoods, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. As a result, no impacts would occur.

Page 353 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 10 ends

Psomas

REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2025a (January). Special Vascular Plants, Bryophytes, and Lichens List. Sacramento, CA: CDFW, Natural Heritage Division. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=109383&inline. ———. 2025b (February 27). California Natural Communities List. Natural Communities List Arranged Alphabetically by Life Form (PDF). Sacramento, CA: CDFW Biogeographic Data Branch. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=153398&inline.

California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). 2025 (April 8, last accessed). State Scenic Highway Map. Sacramento, CA: Caltrans.
https://caltrans.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=465dfd3d807c46cc8 e8057116f1aacaa.

City of San Dimas. 2023 (June 27, last revised). Community Forest Management Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City.
https://files.sandimasca.gov/Document_Center/Department/Parks%20&%20Recreation/ Community%20Forest%20Management%20Plan%20%20Amended%206.27.2023.pdf ——. 1991 (April 8, last accessed). City of San Dimas General Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City. https://sandimasca.gov/departments/community_development/planning_division/general _plan/general_plan_sections.php.

Page 354 ends

Revised 2011
Notice of Exemption Appendix E
To: Office of Planning and Research From: City of San Dimas P.O. Box 3044, Room 113 245 E. Bonita Avenue
Sacramento, CA 95812-3044 San Dimas, CA 91773
County Clerk
County of: Los Angeles
12400 Imperial Hwy
Norwalk, CA 90650
Project Title: Proposed Amendment to the City of San Dimas Chapter 18.162 Tree Ordinance, MCTA 23-05 Project Applicant: City of San Dimas
Project Location – Specific:

The Project would take place on various single-family lots located throughout the City of San Dimas.

Project Location – City: San Dimas Project Location – County: Los Angeles Description of Nature, Purpose and Beneficiaries of Project:

The Project involves revision to the City of San Dimas Community Tree Ordinance, exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Preservation Ordinance. The City contains numerous hillside residential properties as well as properties governed by a homeowners association (HOA). These properties contain sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property in question but are restricted from development in order to be kept as natural open space. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment. In addition, there are certain properties/communities within the City where a portion of the owners’ parcel is landscaped and maintained by an HOA, thus viewed as a common area tree. These areas would continue to remain protected areas. Nevertheless, any other tree(s) located outside of the categories mentioned above would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and associated fee.

Name of Public Agency Approving Project: City of San Dimas Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: City of San Dimas Exempt Status: (check one):

Ministerial (Sec. 21080(b)(1); 15268);
Declared Emergency (Sec. 21080(b)(3); 15269(a));
Emergency Project (Sec. 21080(b)(4); 15269(b)(c));
Categorical Exemption. State type and section number: Section 15061(B)(3) Common Sense Exemption Statutory Exemptions. State code number:

Reasons why project is exempt:

According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance, under most conditions. The Project would result in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, therefore it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. Any subsequent tree removals initiated by private property owners would be done according to the updated requirements described below, thereby limiting any potential impacts.

These Municipal Code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City.

Lead Agency
Contact Person: Luis Torrico Area Code/Telephone/Extension: 909-394-6208 If filed by applicant:

1. Attach certified document of exemption finding.

2. Has a Notice of Exemption been filed by the public agency approving the project? Yes No Signature: Date: Title:

Signed by Lead Agency Signed by Applicant
Authority cited: Sections 2103 and 21110, Public Resources Code. Date Received for filing at OPR:

Reference: Sections 21108, 21152, and 21152.1, Public Resources Code.

Page 355 ends

CITY Or GENERAL
CALIFORN R088 PLAN
LEGEND
- CITY LIMITS LINE
The map shows conservation areas considered
sensitive environmental regions outlined in the
General Plan, Land Use Element Exhibit II-4.1. The
two highlighted areas running through the City are
predominantly made up of concentrated groves of
Coast Live Oaks. With the proposed exemption of
the single-family zoned properties from the Tree
Preservation Ordinance, these Oaks would not be
protected would be allowed to be removed without
any review.
70 ALL ATE

PARTONES E
Antone Myse
CYPRESS IT.
==
EXHIBIT П-4.1

COMMUNITY DEYELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
CONSULTANTS: CASTANEDNTAKATA ASSOCIATES
II-52 Page 356 - 524

CITY COUNCIL MEETING

ACTION MINUTES
SAN
DIMAS MAY 27, 2025, 7: 00 PM
1960 REGULAR MEETING
Council Members Present: Mayor Emmett Badar, Mayor Pro Tem Eric Nakano, Councilmember Rachel Bratakos, Councilmember Ryan A. Vienna, Councilmember Eric Weber Staff: City Manager Brad McKinney, Assistant City Manager Travis Sais, Director of Public Works Shari Garwick, Director of Administrative Services Michael O' Brien, Director of Community Development Luis Torrico, Director of Parks and Recreation Scott Wasserman, City Attorney Jeff Malawy, City Clerk Debra Black, Planning Manager Marco Espinoza, Yasmin Dabbous Assistant Planner, Associate Engineer Brandon Slater, Sr. Management Analyst Anissa Livas Call to Order: 7: 07 P. M.

CONSENT ITEMS COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Adopt Resolution 2025- 23, Approving MOTION: Motion/ seconded by Certain Demands for the Warrant Councilmember Weber/Councilmember Register of May 30, 2025, in the amount Vienna approve the consent calendar. Motion of $ 265, 550. 44. carried 5- 0.

2. Approve Minutes of the May 13, 2025,
City Council Meeting Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,

3. Receive and File the April 2025 Weber
Investment Report No: None

4. Approve Resolution 2025- 24, Absent: None
Establishing the 2025- 26 Appropriations Abstain: None
Limit Calculation

5. Adopt Ordinance 1323, Establishing
Chapter 5. 120 — Film Permit
Requirements

6. Adopt Ordinance 1324 to Approve
Municipal Code Text Amendment 24- 11,
A Request to Amend the City of San
Dimas Municipal Code as Necessary to
Eliminate the Development Plan Review
Board.

7. Approve Resolution 2025- 30, Authorizing
an Amendment to the Memorandum of
Agreement with the San Gabriel Valley
Council of Governments for Public Safety
Funds

8. Award of Construction Contract 2025- 02
City Hall Pitched Roof Replacement to

Page 357 ends

Approve City Council Minutes of the May 27, 2025 Council Meeting Page 2 For the Meeting of June 10, 2025
WC Construction Services in an Amount
not to Exceed $ 485, 329. 24 for the
Necessary Repairs and Reroofing of the
East and West Pitched Roofs. Approve
an Overall Project Budget of $ 510, 329. 24
to Include Construction and Engineering,
and a 10% Contingency.

9. Renewal of Traffic Engineering Services
for a Two- year Term for Fiscal Year
2025- 26 and Fiscal Year 2026- 27 with
AGA Engineers Inc. in an Amount not to
Exceed $ 160, 000

10. Approve a Letter to the San Gabriel
Valley Legislative Caucus Requesting
Support for the San Gabriel Valley
Mosquito and Vector Control District' s
Pursuit of State Funding to Address
Public Health Risks Following the 2025
Eaton Fire.

HOUSING AUTHORITY COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Award Construction Contact 2025- 05 MOTION: Motion/ seconded by Charter Oak Mobile Home Estates North Councilmember Vienna/ Councilmember Property Wall to Bedrock Group, Inc. in Bratakos approve the recommendation the Amount of $ 1, 038, 040. 00. Authorize a provided by staff. Motion carried 5- 0.

Total Project Budget of $ 1, 318, 040 and
Approve Related Budget Amendments. Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna, Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None

PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Introduce Ordinance 1326, Consideration Speaker # 1 Via Verde resident expressed of a City -initiated Municipal Code Text concern with overgrowth of trees in her area.

Amendment of Title 18, Chapter 18. 162
Tree Preservation Ordinance to Exempt Council direction:

Single- family Zoned Properties and
Single- family Properties within a Specific 1. Continue the public hearing Plan, with the Exception of Areas Owned
or Managed by Homeowner' s 2. Schedule a study session to further Associations ( HOA), and Areas Located discuss the tree preservation ordinance within Certain Open Space, Scenic/ Slope
Easements and Conservation Areas, and 3. Request a presentation from the fire Associated Clean- up Item. department about the Zone Zero initiative before the study session

4. Have staff prepare a detailed table
comparing current and proposed regulations
for single- family homeowners and HOA
properties

Page 358 ends

Approve City Council Minutes of the May 27, 2025 Council Meeting Page 3 For the Meeting of June 10, 2025

5. Explore the Planning Commission' s
recommendations, including potential
protections for front yard trees and specific
tree species

2. Presentation of Compliance with No public comments were provided on this Assembly Bill 2561 / Government Code item.

Section 3502. 3 - Staff Vacancies and the
City' s Recruitment and Retention Efforts MOTION: Motion/ seconded by to Comply with New Legal Obligations Councilmember Weber/ Councilmember Vienna to receive and file. Motion carried 5- 0.

3. Adopt Resolution 2025- 25 Setting the
City -Wide Landscape Parcel Tax for
Fiscal Year 2025- 2026

4. Adopt Resolution 2025- 27 Confirming the
Assessment for Open Space
Maintenance District No. 1 ( Tract 32818,
Boulevard)
No public comments were provided on this
item.

MOTION: Motion/ seconded by
Councilmember Vienna/ Councilmember
Bratakos to approve Resolution 2025- 25,
O.Ption 1 with increase. Motion carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
o® None

Absent: None
Abstain: None
Speaker # 1 expressed concern with safety
and tree maintenance on this district.

Speaker # 2 Kathy Began expressed concern
with tree maintenance on the east side of Via
Verde Ave.

Councilmember Vienna requested and it was
supported by Mayor Pro Tem Nakano a
report of service dates in this district.

MOTION: Motion/ seconded by
Councilmember Bratakos/ Councilmember
Vienna approve the Resolution 2025- 27,
Option 1 with increase. Motion carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None

Page 359 ends

Approve City Council Minutes of the May 27, 2025 Council Meeting Page 4 For the Meeting of June 10, 2025

5. Adopt Resolution 2025- 29 Confirming No public comments were provided on this Assessment for Open Space item.

Maintenance District No. 1, Annexation
No. 3 ( Tract 32841, Northwoods) Mayor Pro Tern Nakano requested that a notice of expiration be provided to the
residents in this district when the City
required maintenance sunsets.

MOTION: Motion/ seconded by
Councilmember Bratakos/ Councilmember
Vienna to approve the Resolution 2025- 29.

Motion carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None
Recessed: 9: 13 p. m.

Reconvened: 9: 23 p. m.

OTHER BUSINESS ITEMS COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Discussion of the Potential Conversion of First Motion:

Tennis Courts into Pickleball Courts at
Lone Hill Park and the San Dimas Sports Motion by Councilmember Vienna second by Plex. Councilmember Bratakos to appropriate
funding and move forward with placing the
current appropriation towards the Sports Plex
location. Motion carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None
Second Motion:

Motion by Councilmember Vienna second by
Mayor Pro Tern Nakano to consider
appropriating funding and moving forward
with a second pickleball court at Lone Hill
Park. The motion failed with a vote of 2- 3.

Yes: Bratakos, Nakano
No: Badar, Vienna, Weber

Absent: None
Abstain: None
Third Motion:

Page 360 ends

Approve City Council Minutes of the May 27, 2025 Council Meeting For the Meeting of June 10, 2025

2. Introduce Ordinance 1325, Updating the
Fire Hazard Severity Zones ( FHSZ)
pursuant to Government Code Section
51178 and the California Fire Code

CITY REPORTS
a. City Manager
b. City A
c. Members of the City Council
Reports on Meetings Attended AB 1234
G. C. § 53232. 3( d))

CITY COUNCIL REQUESTS FOR

FUTURE ITEMS

CLOSED SESSION ITEMS

1. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR

NEGOTIATORS
Gov. Code section 54957. 6
Agency designated representatives: Brad
McKinney, City Manager; Travis Sais,
Assistant City Manager; Michael O' Brien,
Director of Administrative Services,
Stephanie Luu, Human Resources
Manager; Jeff Malawy, City Attorney;
Colin Tanner, Labor Counsel.

Employee organization: International
Brotherhood of Teamsters, Local 911

Page 5 ends

Motion by Councilmember Vienna second by
Councilmember Weber directing staff to bring
back a proposal for a second pickleball court,
evaluating site suitability and distances from
residents at all parks with tennis courts.

Motion carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None
MOTION: Motion/ seconded by
Councilmember Weber/ Councilmember
Vienna to introduce Ordinance 1325. Motion
carried 5- 0.

Yes: Badar, Bratakos, Nakano, Vienna,
Weber
No: None

Absent: None
Abstain: None

COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS
City Manager McKinney announced LA
County Bonelli Park is currently closed for a
transformer replacement. The current time
frame for closure is 6- 8 weeks.

None.

Councilmember Vienna, Councilmember
Bratakos, Councilmember Weber, Mayor Pro
Tern Nakano and Mayor attended the
California Contract Cities Conference.

COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS
None.

COMMENTS/ RECOMMENDATIONS
Following the closed sessions, the City
Attorney made a public announcement as
follows: The City Council met and discussed
the closed session items listed on the
agenda. The City Council gave direction to
staff, but no reportable action was taken.

Page 361 ends

Approve City Council Minutes of the May 27, 2025 Council Meeting Page 6 For the Meeting of June 10, 2025
representing General, Professional, and
Managerial employees.

2. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR

NEGOTIATORS
Gov. Code section 54957. 6
Agency designated representatives: Brad
McKinney, City Manager; Jeff Malawy,
City Attorney; Colin Tanner, Labor
Counsel.

Unrepresented employees: Executive
Group, and Confidential Group.

Adjourned: 11: 20 P. M.

I, Debra Black, City Clerk attest that these minutes are accurate and reflective of the actions taken by the City Council.

Debra Black, City Clerk

Page 362 ends

5 Hutton Centre Drive, Suite 300 • Santa Ana, CA 92707 • T: 714.751.7373

MEMORANDUM
April 17, 2025
To: From:

Luis Torrico
Director of Community Development
City of San Dimas
Bryan Hamilton
Jennifer Marks
Psomas
Subject: Substantial Evidence for Notice of Exemption for the Proposed Amendment to the City of San Dimas Chapter 18.162 Tree Ordinance, MCTA 23-05 The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) was signed into law in 1970. The California Environmental Quality Act is a statue that requires state and local agencies to identify potential significant effects a “project” may have on the environment and any feasible mitigation that may be implemented to avoid or mitigate those impacts. A “project” is defined in Section 21065, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as an activity which may cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and consists of any of the following: an activity directly undertaken by any public agency; an activity undertaken by a person which is supported, in whole or in part, through contracts, grants, subsidies, loans, or other forms of assistance from one or more public agencies; or, an activity that involves the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement for use by one or more public agencies. A “significant effect on the environment” is defined in Section 21068 Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as a substantial, or potentially substantial, adverse change in the environment. Furthermore, the government agency which has the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project which may have a significant effect upon the environment is defined as the “lead agency” in Section 21067, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code.

CEQA applies in situations where a governmental agency can use its judgment in deciding whether and how to carry out or approve a project. A project subject to such judgmental controls is called a “discretionary project.” Where the law requires a governmental agency to act on a project in a set way without allowing the agency to use its own judgment, the project is called “ministerial,” and CEQA does not apply. Once an application for a project is deemed complete, a lead agency must first determine whether an activity is subject to CEQA before conducting an initial study. An activity is not subject to CEQA if: the activity does not involve the exercise of discretionary powers by a public agency; the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment; or the activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378.

Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, a Notice of Exemption (NOE) may be filed if the City of San Dimas, in its capacity as the Lead Agency, determines that a proposed action or project is exempt from CEQA. According to the CEQA Guidelines, a NOE must contain the following information:
• A description of the proposed action or project;
ATTACHMENT 3

Page 363 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 2 ends

Psomas
• A finding that the proposed action or project is exempt, including a citation of the State CEQA Guidelines section or statute under which the project is found to be exempt; and, • A brief statement in support of the finding.
• The Lead Agency authorized the preparation of this Notice of Exemption This report was prepared in accordance with Section 21000 (et seq) - Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code and Section 15000 (et seq), Article 1, Chapter 3, Division 6, Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It is important to note that CEQA is not a process that determines whether or not a project should be approved and no recommendations can be made as to whether or not a lead agency should approve or deny a project application.

SECTION 15061 – REVIEW FOR EXEMPTION
Section 15061(b)(3) – Common Sense Exemption
Section 15061(B)(3), the Common Sense Exemption, of the 2025 CEQA Guidelines applies to the proposed revision to the City of San Dimas’ Community Tree Ordinance Project (Project or proposed Project). Section 15061 outlines the process for determining whether or not a project would be exempt from CEQA. This process is detailed in Section 15061(B), provided below:
(b) A project is exempt from CEQA if:
(1) The project is exempt by statute (see, e.g. Article 18, commencing with Section 15260).
(2) The project is exempt pursuant to a categorical exemption (see Article 19, commencing with Section 15300) and the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2. (3) The activity is covered by the commonsense exemption that CEQA applies only to projects which have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is not subject to CEQA.
(4) The project will be rejected or disapproved by a public agency. (See Section 15270(b)).
(5) The project is exempt pursuant to the provisions of Article 12.5 of this Chapter.

According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance, under most conditions, as described below in the Project Description. Therefore, as the Project would result

Page 364 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 3 ends

Psomas
in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. These Municipal Code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Background
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under Chapters 13.36 and 18.162 of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC), respectively. Chapter 13.36 - Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median, parkway, planting easement, or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department. Meanwhile, Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department.

The City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance was adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or any other species of trees which measure 10 inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of 38 inches or more (the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches). The Ordinance exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception of these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.

The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. Requests to remove up to three trees may be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four or more trees requires approval by the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB). The application fee for a Tree Removal Permit for up to three trees is $300, while the fee for the review of four or more trees is $500. Approved tree removal applications are subject to a two-for-one replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if the reduced replacement ratio is consistent with the purpose of the Ordinance, removal of the protected tree will have a minimal impact on the community or if the subject site has an adequate number of existing trees.

On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance to remove the Development Plan Review Board’s review authority, create a protected tree list, reduce the replacement ratio for tree removal violations, remove replacement requirements for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger or removal of trees required by the Fire Department, remove the arborist report submittal requirement, revise findings, move the Tree Preservation Ordinance from Title 18 Zoning to Title 13 Civic Facilities to

Page 365 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 4 ends

Psomas
change the implementation responsibilities of the Ordinance to the Parks and Recreation Department, and various associated code clean-up items. The Commission voted against moving the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13 and for creating a tree exemption list, and voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment to Chapter 18.162 as follows:
• Remove the Development Plan Review Board’s (DPRB) review authority and allow City Staff to review and approve all tree removals, regardless of the number of trees proposed for removal.
• Change replacement requirement to 1:1 if 24-inch box tree(s) is planted or 2:1 if 15- gallon tree(s) is planted.
• Create two levels of protection:
• Oak tree, and any other tree staff proposes, will need to make findings to remove.
• All other trees with a 10-inch diameter or greater can be removed without any findings as long as they replace them. In this situation, the Director of Community Development can reduce the replacement ratio if there is not enough space to replant trees.
• Do not require replacement trees for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger, and removal of trees required by the Fire Department.
• Explore relaxing the Ordinance for backyard trees.
• Do not require arborist report for dead, diseased or dying tree, unless applicant disagrees with Director's determination.
• Revise tree removal findings to make them clear and objective. • Change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54-inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards. • Revise the penalty section of the Ordinance.

On April 23, 2024, the City Council heard a discussion about fines related to community trees.

The Council also discussed processes, fees and fines related to private trees. After much discussion, the Council directed City staff to schedule a study session to discuss private trees and provided input for discussion. Some of the items that were mentioned during the discussion, included, but were not limited to:
• Explore reducing or removing the Tree Removal Permit Application fee for single-family property applications.
• Reconsider enforcement of Ordinance for single-family front yards only. • Create an exemption list for private trees (can be removed without permits/fees):
• Exempt tree species to consider: Eucalyptus, Tree of Heaven, Queen Palm, White Ash, etc.

Page 366 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 5 ends

Psomas
• If exemption list is created, consider creating protected list. • In situations where 4:1 replacement is required, it may not be an appropriate solution, as space and maintenance are a factor.
• The Tree Ordinance should be easy to follow and not burden residents. • Creation of a tree fund, funded by residents who remove trees but do not have room for required replacement, that would allow other residents to plant trees at no expense to them.

During the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff was directed to revise the Municipal Code Text Amendment to exempt single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items. The proposed changes to the Ordinance, as specifically requested by City Council, are described in the next section.

Proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment
Following the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff focused on addressing the City Council’s main objective of exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Preservation Ordinance, while still protecting the following trees:
• Trees located within common areas, open space, scenic easements, slope easements, or areas maintained by a Homeowner’s Association (HOA); and • Trees located on a single-family property within designated open space area, scenic easement, or slope easement.

The City contains numerous hillside residential properties as well as properties governed by a homeowners association (HOA). These properties contain sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property in question but are restricted from development in order to be kept as natural open space. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment. In addition, there are certain properties/communities within the City where a portion of the owners’ parcel is landscaped and maintained by an HOA, thus viewed as a common area tree. These areas would continue to remain protected areas. Nevertheless, any other tree(s) located outside of the categories mentioned above would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and associated fee.

REVIEW OF CITY OF SAN DIMAS GENERAL PLAN LAND USE MAP AND GUIDELINES The proposed Project would apply to trees situated within single-family properties. The City published its General Plan in 1991, one year after the passage of the Tree Preservation Ordinance. The City’s Land Use Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. Nevertheless, the Element does mention the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance (City of San Dimas 1991). As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.

Page 367 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 6 ends

Psomas
REVIEW OF 15300.2–EXCEPTIONS CRITERIA
Location: Classes 3, 4, 5, 6, and 11 are qualified by consideration of where the project is to be located – a project that is ordinarily insignificant in its impact on the environment may, in a particularly sensitive environment, be significant. Therefore, these classes are considered to apply to all instances, except where the project may impact on an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern where designated, precisely mapped, and officially adopted pursuant to law by federal, state, or local agencies.

The Project is not considered under Classes 3, 4, 5, 6 or 11. Therefore, this exception is not applicable to Common Sense Exemptions. Nevertheless, the Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, the Project would not result in any direct impacts. Subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would be required to adhere to the requirements outlined in the updated Ordinance, ensuring that none of the trees identified above and in the proposed Text Amendment are removed. As a result, a significant impact would not be created based on the location of future actions under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance; conversely, impacts would be avoided based on the locations identified as allowable areas for tree removal.

Cumulative Impacts: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any direct impacts.

The City’s consideration of native and sensitive trees, including those within designated conservation areas, would preclude a significant impact related to loss of native and locally important species throughout single-family properties located within the City. In addition, the City has prepared a Community Forest Management Plan dated June 27, 2023 with the intention of protecting existing City trees, implementing public education programs, and expanding the City’s inventory of trees within viable, vacant sites along city streets, at city facilities and in city parks (City of San Dimas 2023). Additionally, because the trees allowed for removal under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would primarily consist of individual trees within private property. As a result, cumulative biological impacts are not considered to be significant. Meanwhile, cumulative air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would not be significant either. As stated above, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of a diverse selection of trees within City owned property. The expansion of the City’s tree inventory would offset the small loss of carbon sequestration resulting from the removal of trees within private, single-family properties.

As a result, no significant cumulative impacts would occur.

Significant Effects (unusual circumstances): The Project would not have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances, as demonstrated by the discussion below.

Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties, the Project would not induce any development. As a result, no air

Page 368 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 7 ends

Psomas
quality or greenhouse gas emissions would occur. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in negligible emissions. It is important to note that these emissions would be too small to quantify and would be well below the regional and local thresholds established by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD). As stated above, while the ordinance may result in a small loss of carbon sequestration, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of more trees within City-owned properties. Therefore, no impacts with respect to air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would occur.

Biological Resources: The following analysis focuses on trees that are native to the City of San Dimas: coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia), canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis), San Gabriel oak (Quercus durata var. gabrielensis), Nuttall's scrub oak (Quercus dumosa), Engelmann oak (Quercus engelmannii), interior live oak (Quercus wislizeni); western sycamore (Platanus racemosa), southern California black walnut (Juglans californica); knobcone pine (Pinus attenuata), Coulter pine (Pinus coulteri), and Bishop pine (Pinus muricata) 1 . Of these
species, the following species are considered special status: southern California black walnut (California Rare Plant Rank [CRPR] 4.22), San Gabriel oak (CRPR 4.22), Nuttall’s scrub oak (CRPR 1B.13), and Engelmann oak (CRPR 4.22) (CDFW 2025a). Additionally, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) considers the following woodland vegetation types to be sensitive natural communities: western sycamore woodlands (Platanus racemosa alliances), California walnut groves (Juglans californica alliances), and Coulter pine woodland and forests (Pinus coulteri alliances) (CDFW 2025b).

The Significant Ecological Area (SEA) Program was established to help conserve the genetic and physical diversity within Los Angeles County by designating biological resource areas capable of sustaining themselves into the future. SEAs are places where the County deems it important to balance between development and conservation of fragile resources such as streams, woodlands, and Threatened or Endangered species and their habitats. There are two SEAs within the City of San Dimas: the East San Gabriel Valley SEA (i.e., Walnut Creek, Bonelli Regional Park/Puddingstone Reservoir, and various open spaces referred to as the Walnut Islands) and San Dimas Canyon/San Antonio Wash SEA. Both of these SEAs include important oak and walnut woodland habitats. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.

There are a number of HOA-governed and designated hillside residential properties that have large lots with sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property but are non-developable and intended to be kept as natural areas. Many of these 1 This list of pine trees includes those that are known to occur along the southern edge of the Angeles National Forest.
2 CRPR 4.2: Species that are considered of limited distribution and are considered fairly threatened in California (20– 80% of occurrences threatened; moderate degree and immediacy of threat). 3 CRPR 1B.1: Species that are considered Rare, Threatened, or Endangered throughout their range and are considered seriously threatened in California (over 80% of occurrences threatened; high degree and immediacy of threat).

Page 369 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 8 ends

Psomas
conservation overlays include oak and walnut woodlands. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.

The current staff report recommends that single family residences be exempted from applying for a tree permit for the removal of trees on their lot. While single individuals of the protected tree species (as defined by the ordinance) listed above could be present on an individual lot, individuals within developed areas are more likely to have been planted as landscaping during development than to be remnant native individual trees. These individual trees, whether planted or remnant native individuals, are within small fragments of habitat (i.e., single family lots), isolated from larger areas of naturally occurring woodlands and habitat areas, and would not be expected to be naturally reproducing. The change in the municipal code text amendment would not require a tree removal permit for individual trees within single family lots, and could result in the loss of tree individuals, including species on the protected species list. However, since these individual trees are not contributing to sustaining natural woodland areas, the loss of these isolated individual trees would not affect the viability of the larger areas of native woodlands (described above within SEAs and hillside areas/conservation overlays) that provide higher quality woodland habitat. Therefore, the loss of trees resulting from the municipal code text amendment, as currently proposed (applying to only single family lots), would be considered less than significant.

The remaining species recommended as protected trees in the current staff report, camphor and California redwood, are not native to the City of San Dimas. There are also several species of pine trees that have been planted as ornamentals in southern California. These species are not considered special status, as individuals or as woodlands. Therefore, the loss of individuals of these tree species would not be considered a significant impact.

All trees, including native and non-native trees, could provide habitat for nesting birds and raptors; however, compliance with standard protective measures to avoid impacts on nesting birds/raptors would be required.

Geology: The Project would not result in the development of housing or other habitable structures that would expose people to risks associated with seismic shaking, ground failure, landslides, or other geotechnical issues present in Southern California. The Project consists of text amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

Water Quality: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to water quality, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, the Project’s implementation would not alter drainage patterns within hillside areas, as the removal of trees from these areas would be precluded under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance.

Page 370 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 9 ends

Psomas
Noise: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. The Project would not induce any development as the Project is programmatic in nature. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in the generation of temporary noise associated with the use of chainsaws. It is important to note that this noise would be temporary and tree removal would be required to adhere to all applicable City noise regulations.

Utilities and Public Services: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments and is programmatic in nature. The Project does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography that would result in impacts on any public services or utilities. Nevertheless, green waste generated during the subsequent removal of trees must be removed and properly disposed of pursuant to all applicable local and State requirements.

Scenic Highways: The Project would not result in damage to scenic resources. The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts on scenic highways or scenic resources, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, according to the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), there are no officially designated State scenic highway in the City (Caltrans 2025). As a result, no impacts would occur.

Hazardous Waste Site: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties (parcels that are typically not associated with hazardous waste sites), the Project would not induce any development, especially development on properties that are included on a list of hazardous materials sites. As a result, no impacts would occur.

Historical Resources: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to historic resources, including neighborhoods, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. As a result, no impacts would occur.

Page 371 ends

Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025

Page 10 ends

Psomas

REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2025a (January). Special Vascular Plants, Bryophytes, and Lichens List. Sacramento, CA: CDFW, Natural Heritage Division. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=109383&inline. ———. 2025b (February 27). California Natural Communities List. Natural Communities List Arranged Alphabetically by Life Form (PDF). Sacramento, CA: CDFW Biogeographic Data Branch. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=153398&inline.

California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). 2025 (April 8, last accessed). State Scenic Highway Map. Sacramento, CA: Caltrans.
https://caltrans.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=465dfd3d807c46cc8 e8057116f1aacaa.

City of San Dimas. 2023 (June 27, last revised). Community Forest Management Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City.
https://files.sandimasca.gov/Document_Center/Department/Parks%20&%20Recreation/ Community%20Forest%20Management%20Plan%20%20Amended%206.27.2023.pdf ——. 1991 (April 8, last accessed). City of San Dimas General Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City. https://sandimasca.gov/departments/community_development/planning_division/general _plan/general_plan_sections.php.

Page 372 ends

Revised 2011
Notice of Exemption Appendix E
To: Office of Planning and Research From: City of San Dimas P.O. Box 3044, Room 113 245 E. Bonita Avenue
Sacramento, CA 95812-3044 San Dimas, CA 91773
County Clerk
County of: Los Angeles
12400 Imperial Hwy
Norwalk, CA 90650
Project Title: Proposed Amendment to the City of San Dimas Chapter 18.162 Tree Ordinance, MCTA 23-05 Project Applicant: City of San Dimas
Project Location – Specific:

The Project would take place on various single-family lots located throughout the City of San Dimas.

Project Location – City: San Dimas Project Location – County: Los Angeles Description of Nature, Purpose and Beneficiaries of Project:

The Project involves revision to the City of San Dimas Community Tree Ordinance, exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Preservation Ordinance. The City contains numerous hillside residential properties as well as properties governed by a homeowners association (HOA). These properties contain sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property in question but are restricted from development in order to be kept as natural open space. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment. In addition, there are certain properties/communities within the City where a portion of the owners’ parcel is landscaped and maintained by an HOA, thus viewed as a common area tree. These areas would continue to remain protected areas. Nevertheless, any other tree(s) located outside of the categories mentioned above would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and associated fee.

Name of Public Agency Approving Project: City of San Dimas Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: City of San Dimas Exempt Status: (check one):

Ministerial (Sec. 21080(b)(1); 15268);
Declared Emergency (Sec. 21080(b)(3); 15269(a));
Emergency Project (Sec. 21080(b)(4); 15269(b)(c));
Categorical Exemption. State type and section number: Section 15061(B)(3) Common Sense Exemption Statutory Exemptions. State code number:

Reasons why project is exempt:

According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance, under most conditions. The Project would result in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, therefore it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. Any subsequent tree removals initiated by private property owners would be done according to the updated requirements described below, thereby limiting any potential impacts.

These Municipal Code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City.

Lead Agency
Contact Person: Luis Torrico Area Code/Telephone/Extension: 909-394-6208 If filed by applicant:

1. Attach certified document of exemption finding.

2. Has a Notice of Exemption been filed by the public agency approving the project? Yes No Signature: Date: Title:

Signed by Lead Agency Signed by Applicant
Authority cited: Sections 2103 and 21110, Public Resources Code. Date Received for filing at OPR:

Reference: Sections 21108, 21152, and 21152.1, Public Resources Code.

ATTACHMENT 4

Page 373 ends

City of San Dimas
Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) Zoned Properties
ATTACHMENT 5

Page 374 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
City Council Special Meeting
November 9, 2026
Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) 23-05
Amend Tree Preservation Ordinance to Exempt Single-Family Zoned Properties and Single-Family Properties within Specific Plans, with the Exception of Certain Open Space, Scenic, Slope, or Conservation Easements, Homeowner Association (HOA) Common Areas, and/or HOA Maintained Areas and Associated Clean-Up Items.

This project is Categorically Exempt under CEQA guidelines, Title 14, Article 5 Preliminary Review of Projects and Conduct of Initial Study, Section 15061(B)(3), Common Sense Exemption.

ATTACHMENT 6

Page 375 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Background
• MCTA initiated in 2023.
• Discussed and considered at 5 prior PC and CC meetings, with the addition of most recent meetings below.
• May 27, 2025 (City Council)
– Staff instructed to explore a preservation list and front-yard protections. – Requested presentation on defensible space and Zone 0 legislation. • May 26, 2026 (City Council)
– Public presentation provided by the Los Angeles County Fire Department.

Page 376 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
“Trees located on single-family zoned properties
or single-family properties within specific plans,
and are not within open space, scenic, slope, or
conservation easements as designated in this
Code, homeowner association common areas,
and/or homeowner association maintained area;”

Page 377 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
• “Trees determined by Los Angeles County Fire
Department or the insurer of the subject
property to be a fire/failure concern and are
required to be removed as documented by
either entity; and”
• “Trees in accordance with California Public
Resources Code § 4291(a)(1)(A), Zone 0 (the
area extending zero to five feet from a
structure) for the purpose of complying with
applicable California defensible-space and
wildfire-safety provisions and requirements.”
1 2
3 1
2 3

Page 378 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis

1. Preservation of front-yards:
– Determined front-yards impact visual
appearance of neighborhoods and should
be maintained.
– Protect any tree 15 inches or greater in
diameter, regardless of species.

2. Not exempting SF-H properties:
– Determined these areas were designated
to ensure development blends with the
natural terrain.
– 100 total properties impacted.
1 2
1 2

Page 379 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
SF-H Properties Reference Map

Page 380 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
• Comprehensive list of native trees:
– Coast live oak;
– Scrub oak;
– Canyon live oak;
– San Gabriel oak;
– Nuttall's scrub oak;
– Engelmann oak;
– Interior live oak;
– Western sycamore;
– Southern California black walnut;
– Knobcone pine;
– Coulter pine; and
– Bishop pine.
• Generalized to:
– Oak (any genus);
– Western Sycamore;
– Southern California black walnut; and
– Pine (any genus).

Page 381 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Associated Clean-up Items
• Revise titles from “Development Services” to “Community Development”. • Update references to correct review authority.
• Ensure language for submittal requirements matches throughout the Chapter. • Clarify prolonged maintenance of replacement trees for property types. • Exempt palm trees to be consistent with current City practice and policy. • Trunk diameter to be measured from 54 inches above ground level instead of 36 inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards.

Page 382 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Recommendation
Staff and Planning Commission recommend the City Council:

1.Read by title and introduce Ordinance 1326, approving MCTA 23-05.

2.Find that this project is Categorically Exempt under CEQA guidelines, Title 14, Article 5 Preliminary Review of Projects and Conduct of Initial Study, Section 15061(B)(3), Common Sense Exemption.

Page 383 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Zone 0 Diagram

Page 384 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
(1) Single-Family Property Open Space
– Example: 1568 Calle Cristina

Page 385 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
(5) HOA Maintained Areas
– Example: 960 Calle Frondosa
– Via Verde Tract 31117 HOA

Page 386 ends

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Discussion/Analysis
(3) HOA Scenic Easements
– Example: Via Verde Ridge HOA

Page 387 ends

SAN
DIMAS
Code Consistency California
1960
GRADED ARÉA REQUIRED

FOR PARK/SCHOOL SITE FEATURES PLAN

ARK/SCHOOL SI

ISUAL BUFFE

ELISTING TREES

PRESERVED
EXISTING 100 FOOT
CUT SLOPE HOMES SET 1000 FEET
'ROM PUENTE & VIA VERDE

ERSECTION, BUM DE DO ADE

DAYLIGHT FILL (NO

VISIBLE FILL SLOPES

EXISTING BERM
TREES

EXISTING CANYON

PRESERVEN - BERM

MAJOR GRADED BANK REQUIRE
- OPEN SPACE FOR SAN DIMAS AVE
SLOPE

SLOPING

MANE SISAVED EMANANTY
PARCEL E EXHIBIT 3
Via Verde Development Company 196388- 524
CITY OF SAN DIMAS Specific Plan No. 7 (SP-7)

CITY OF SAN DIMAS
Code Consistency
Specific Plan No. 4 (SP-4)

Page 389 ends

Agenda Item Staff Report
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
From: Brad McKinney, City Manager
Prepared by: Lauren Marshall, Sr. Management Analyst
Subject: Adopt Resolution 2026-70 Adopting the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project
____________________________________________________________________________

SUMMARY
The Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project (Project) will capture and infiltrate stormwater to improve water quality and groundwater recharge while enhancing park amenities. Staff recommends that the City Council adopt a resolution (Attachment 1) approving the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) (Attachment 2), then approve the conceptual design (Attachment 3). Construction funding has not been secured. The final design, specific improvements, and construction timeline will depend on the funding awarded.

RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the City Council:

1. Adopt Resolution 2026-70 (Attachment 1) entitled, “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS APPROVING AND ADOPTING AN INITIAL

STUDY AND MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION (MND) AND MITIGATION

MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR THE LONE HILL PARK REGIONAL WATERSHED MANAGEMENT PROGRAM PROJECT LOCATED AT 500 NORTH SHELLMAN AVENUE;” and

2. Approve the conceptual design for the Project, with the final design and specific improvements contingent on construction funding.

GOVERNMENT CODE §84308 APPLIES:
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
No

Page 390 ends

Adopt the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project Page 2
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026

FISCAL IMPACT
Adoption of the IS/MND and MMRP has no additional fiscal impact. Preparation of the Initial Study and environmental documentation was included in CWE’s $700,140 design contract, funded by Regional Safe Clean Water (SCW) Funds. Construction is estimated to cost approximately $15 million; funding has not been secured at this time.

BACKGROUND
Los Angeles County's Safe, Clean Water Program (SCW Program), funded through Measure W, provides funding for stormwater projects that improve water quality and support compliance with state and federal stormwater regulations. Under the Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) Permit, cities must implement measures, including stormwater infrastructure projects, to reduce pollutants entering local waterways and demonstrate progress toward meeting water quality standards. The Lone Hill Park Project was selected for Regional SCW Program funding to support these regional water quality objectives.

On October 13, 2020, the City Council approved a letter supporting the Lone Hill Park Stormwater Project for the Upper San Gabriel River Watershed Steering Committee. In September 2021, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors awarded $900,000 in Regional SCW Funds for project design. On June 11, 2024, the City Council awarded the design contract to CWE. The Council previously reviewed a preliminary design concept when approving the grant funding agreement.

The Parks & Recreation Commission reviewed the Project and provided feedback on public outreach efforts in November 2024, September 2025, and September 2026.

Lone Hill Park, at 500 North Shellman Avenue, is a 9-acre community park on the west side of San Dimas. Existing amenities include softball fields, tennis and basketball courts, playground equipment, and a parking lot. The park is bounded by Gladstone Elementary School to the north, residential properties to the east, Juanita Avenue to the south, and Shellman Avenue to the west (Figure 1).

Page 391 ends

Adopt the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project Page 3
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Figure 1 – Aerial view of Lone Hill Park
The Project will install a regional stormwater capture and infiltration system beneath the park and improve surface amenities. The system will capture runoff from approximately 335 acres in San Dimas and Glendora, approximately 73 percent of which is in San Dimas. Gravity flow will divert runoff from existing storm drains to an expanded underground system for capture, treatment, and infiltration, preserving the park surface for recreational and community use.

The expanded system has a maximum design diversion rate of approximately 28 cubic feet per second and a calculated 24-hour storm capacity of approximately 12 acre-feet. It will reduce runoff and pollutant loads discharged to downstream receiving waters and recharge groundwater in the Main San Gabriel Basin.

Modeling of the amended Project estimates reductions of approximately 93 percent in runoff volume, 97 percent in zinc loads, and 96 percent in copper loads.

The Project’s goals are to:
• Improve local and downstream water quality by capturing, treating, and infiltrating stormwater runoff and reducing pollutant loads.
• Increase groundwater recharge and support local water supply within the Main San Gabriel Basin.
• Support the City’s Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permit compliance and the East San Gabriel Valley Watershed Management Group’s stormwater capture and water quality goals.

Page 392 ends

Adopt the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project Page 4
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
• Enhance recreational opportunities and accessibility while restoring and improving park space.
• Increase native and drought-tolerant vegetation.
• Preserve recreational use by locating stormwater infrastructure underground.

DISCUSSION/ANALYSIS
Staff recommends adopting the IS/MND and approving the MMRP before approving the conceptual design. Although environmental adoption typically accompanies final design approval, staff recommends conceptual design approval at this stage because construction funding remains pending. Completing the design and environmental documentation will support applications for construction funding and help the Project proceed once funding is secured.

Conceptual Design and Public Outreach
City staff presented the evolving conceptual design at community events to gather feedback on proposed amenities and the park layout:
• Holiday Extravaganza – December 6, 2025
• Marchant Park Outreach Event – March 21, 2026
• San Dimas Farmers Market – June 10, 2026
The conceptual design includes the following amenities based on public input (Attachment 3):
• Fort-themed playground (Attachment 4)
• Interpretive and educational signage highlighting butterflies, water conservation, native landscaping, and stormwater management
• Full-size basketball court
• Pickleball courts
• New parking area
• Walking paths
• Butterfly garden
• Low-water-use landscaping
• Additional shade trees
Staff shared the design with approximately 400 residents. Feedback was generally favorable, with most residents looking forward to the park enhancements. The design combines these improvements with the Project’s primary purpose of improving water quality and groundwater recharge.

At its September 15, 2026, meeting, the Parks & Recreation Commission supported the conceptual design and acknowledged that the final design and construction timeline will depend on the availability and amount of construction funding.

Page 393 ends

Adopt the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project Page 5
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026

ALTERNATIVES
The City Council may defer adoption of the IS/MND and approval of the conceptual design.

Deferral would delay implementation of a project that supports MS4 permit compliance and could require updated environmental documentation at additional cost. The current review is grant-funded; future review costs could reduce funds available for park improvements.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The City prepared a Draft IS/MND under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to evaluate the Project’s potential environmental impacts. The Initial Study found that all potentially significant impacts could be mitigated to a less-than-significant level, supporting adoption of an MND rather than preparation of an Environmental Impact Report.

The Draft IS/MND was available for public review from March 4 through April 3, 2026, pursuant to State CEQA Guidelines Section 15105(b). The Notice of Intent to adopt the IS/MND was published, recorded with the Office of Planning and Research and the Los Angeles County Recorder’s Office, circulated to interested parties, and posted on the City’s website with the Draft IS/MND and technical appendices. Hard copies were available at the Public Works Counter at City Hall, 245 East Bonita Avenue. The City also submitted a Notice of Completion and the Draft IS/MND to the State Clearinghouse for review by relevant state agencies. The State Clearinghouse assigned number 2026021076.

The City received comments during the public review period from:
• Joseph Jamoralin, California Department of Transportation: General requirements are reflected in the MND and associated mitigation measures. • Patricia Horsley, Los Angeles County Sanitation District: A utility identified in the Project area is being addressed through design coordination.

The City conducted tribal consultation under Assembly Bill 52 and Public Resources Code Section 21080.3.1. Notification letters were sent to nine tribes on September 4, 2025. The Gabrielino Band of Mission Indians – Kizh Nation participated in consultation, and tribal monitoring mitigation measures were incorporated into the IS/MND based on its feedback.

The Final IS/MND includes the MMRP and a separate document containing public comments and responses. The comments required no changes to the Draft IS/MND. The Final IS/MND identifies no new or substantially more severe impacts than those analyzed in the draft; therefore, recirculation is not required under State CEQA Guidelines Section 15073.5.

Under State CEQA Guidelines Section 15074, the City Council must consider the Final IS/MND, which must reflect the City’s independent judgment and analysis, before approving the Project.

The City must adopt the IS/MND and approve the MMRP before project approval. Following approval, the City must file a Notice of Determination with the County Clerk within five working days and send a copy of the filed notice to the State Clearinghouse.

The public hearing for the IS/MND was noticed in the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin on October 20, 2026, and November 3, 2026.

Page 394 ends

Adopt the Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and Approval of the Conceptual Design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project Page 6
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Respectfully submitted,
Lauren Marshall
Sr. Management Analyst
Attachments:

1. Resolution 2026-70

2. Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration

3. Conceptual Design Rendering

4. Proposed Playground Equipment

5. November 9, 2026, Public Notice Comment Letter

6. Response to Comment Letter

Page 395 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
RESOLUTION 2026-70

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS,

COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, ADOPTING THE MITIGATED NEGATIVE

DECLARATION AND MITIGATED MONITORING AND REPORTING

PROGRAM FOR THE LONE HILL PARK REGIONAL WATERSHED

MANAGEMENT PROGRAM PROJECT PURSUANT TO THE CALIFORNIA
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT OF 1970, AS AMENDED FOR LONE HILL PARK LOCATED AT 500 NORTH SHELLMAN AVENUE.

WHEREAS, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code, § 21000 et seq.), the State CEQA Guidelines (California Code of Regulations, title 14, § 15000 et seq.), and City of San Dimas’s Local CEQA Guidelines (collectively, “CEQA”), the City of San Dimas is the lead agency for the proposed Project; and
WHEREAS, on June 11, 2024, the City Council of the San Dimas approved the preparation of the design for the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project consisting of the diversion to capture, treat, and infiltrate runoff from a 335-acre catchment; and
WHEREAS, in March 2026, in compliance with CEQA, an Initial Study (IS) was prepared for the Project which determined the Project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment and that a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) finding is appropriate; and WHEREAS, the City provided copies of the Initial Study and MND to the public and the State Clearinghouse for a review and comment period beginning on March 4, 2026, and ending on April 3, 2026, pursuant to State CEQA Guidelines section 15073, during which time the City received two (2) comment letters; and
WHEREAS, the City gave notice of its intent to adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration to (a) the public pursuant to Section 15072(b) of the CEQA Guidelines, (b) individuals and organizations, if any, that previously submitted written requests for notice pursuant to Section 15072(b) of the CEQA Guidelines, (c) responsible and trustee and other agencies with jurisdiction over resources that will be affected by the Proposed Project pursuant to Section 15073(c) of the CEQA Guidelines, and (d) the Clerk of the County of Los Angeles pursuant to Section 15072(a) of the CEQA Guidelines; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with State CEQA Guidelines section 15073(e) the City provided written notice to all public agencies that commented on the proposed MND of the public hearing to be held on the Project for which the MND was prepared; and WHEREAS, on November 9, 2026, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing as prescribed by law and considered public testimony and evidence and recommendations presented by staff related to the proposed Project and the MND for the Project; and WHEREAS, all the requirements of the Public Resources Code, the State CEQA Guidelines, and the City’s Local CEQA Guidelines have been satisfied by the City in connection with the preparation of the MND, which is sufficiently detailed so that all of the potentially significant environmental effects of the Project, as well as feasible mitigation measures, have been adequately evaluated; and

Page 396 ends

Resolution 2026-70 Page 2
Adopt MND for Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Program Management Program November 9, 2026
WHEREAS, the MND prepared in connection with the Project sufficiently analyzes the feasible mitigation measures necessary to avoid or substantially lessen the Project’s potentially significant environmental impacts; and
WHEREAS, the findings and conclusions made by the City Council in this Resolution are based upon the oral and written evidence presented as well as the entirety of the administrative record for the Project, which is incorporated herein by this reference. The findings are not based solely on the information provided in this Resolution; and WHEREAS, prior to taking action, the City Council has heard, been presented with, reviewed, and considered all of the information and data in the administrative record, including but not limited to the Initial Study, MND, MMRP, and all oral and written evidence presented to it during all meetings and hearings; and
WHEREAS, the MND, reflects the independent judgment of the City and is deemed adequate for purposes of making decisions on the merits of the Project; and WHEREAS, no comments made in the public hearing conducted by the City Council, and no additional information submitted to the City Council, have produced substantial new information requiring substantial revisions that would trigger recirculation of the MND or additional environmental review of the project under State CEQA Guidelines section 15073.5; and WHEREAS, all other legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of San Dimas does hereby resolve that:

SECTION 1. RECITALS. The City Council hereby finds that the recitals set forth above are true and correct and are incorporated herein as substantive findings of this Resolution.

SECTION 2. COMPLIANCE WITH THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT. As the decision-making body for the Project, the City Council has reviewed and considered the information contained in the MND, Initial Study, administrative record, and all other written and oral evidence presented to the City for the Project, on file with the City and available for review at 245 East Bonita Avenue. Based on the City Council’s independent review and analysis, the City Council finds that the MND Initial Study, and administrative record contain a complete and accurate reporting of the environmental impacts associated with the Project, and that the MND has been completed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code, § 21000 et seq.; “CEQA”), the State CEQA Guidelines (California Code of Regulations, title 14, § 15000 et seq.), and the City’s Local CEQA Guidelines.

SECTION 3. FINDINGS ON ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS. Based on the whole record before it, including the MND, Initial Study, the administrative record, and all other written and oral evidence presented to the City Council, the City Council finds that all environmental impacts of the Project are either less than significant or no impact as outlined in the MND, and the Initial Study. The City Council further finds that there is no substantial evidence in the administrative record supporting a fair argument that the Project may result in any significant environmental impacts. The City Council finds that the MND, contains a complete, objective, and accurate reporting of the environmental impacts associated with the Project and reflects the independent judgment and analysis of the City. No new significant environmental effects have been identified

Page 397 ends

Resolution 2026-70 Page 3
Adopt MND for Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Program Management Program November 9, 2026
in the Final MND and no changes made to the MND constitute substantial revisions requiring recirculation under State CEQA Guidelines section 15073.5. The changes reflected in the Errata merely clarify and amplify the project description. (State CEQA Guidelines, section 15073.5(c)(4).)]
SECTION 4. ADOPTION OF THE MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION. The City hereby approved and adopts the MND, which is hereby attached to this Resolution as Exhibit “A”.

SECTION 5. ADOPTION OF THE MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM. In accordance with the Public Resources Code section 21081.6, the City Council hereby adopts the MMRP, which is hereby attached to this Resolution as Exhibit “B”. In the event of any inconsistencies between the Mitigation measures as set forth in the MND and the MMRP, the MMRP shall control.

SECTION 6. LOCATION AND CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS. The documents and materials associated with the Project and the MND that constitute the record of proceedings on which these findings are based are located at 245 East Bonita Avenue.

SECTION 7. NOTICE OF DETERMINATION. The City Council hereby directs staff to prepare and file a Notice of Determination with the Los Angeles County Clerk and the State Clearinghouse within five (5) working days of the approval of the proposed Project.

PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 9th day of November, 2026. ____________________________________
Emmett G. Badar, Mayor
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Debra Black, City Clerk

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) §

CITY OF SAN DIMAS )
I, DEBRA BLACK, CITY CLERK of the City of San Dimas, California, do hereby certify that Resolution 2026-70 was duly adopted and passed at a regular meeting of the San Dimas City Council on the 9th, day of November, 2026 by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Debra Black, City Clerk

Page 398 ends

```
Initial Study and Mitigated
Negative Declaration
City of San Dimas
Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed
Management Program Project
1561 E. Orangethorpe Avenue, Suite 240
Fullerton, California 92831
TEL (714) 526-7500 | FAX (714) 526-7004
www.cwecorp.com
ATTACHMENT 2

Page 399 ends

Initial Study and
Mitigated Negative Declaration
Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management
Program Project
Prepared for:

City of San Dimas
245 E. Bonita Avenue
San Dimas, California 91773
TEL (909) 394-6240
Prepared by:
1561 E. Orangethorpe Avenue, Suite 240
Fullerton, California, 92831
TEL (714) 526-7500 | FAX (714) 526-7004 | www.cwecorp.com May 2026

Page 400 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- i -
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS.................................................................................................................. i LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................................................................................ii LIST OF TABLES..........................................................................................................................ii ACRONYMS................................................................................................................................iii

1. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 1

1.1 PURPOSE AND DOCUMENT ORGANIZATION....................................................................................1

1.2 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS ..........................................................................................................1

2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION .................................................................................................. 2

2.1 PROJECT LOCATION...............................................................................................................3

3. INITIAL STUDY/ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST.............................................................. 5

3.1 AESTHETICS........................................................................................................................8

3.2 AGRICULTURE AND FORESTRY RESOURCES ................................................................................. 10

3.3 AIR QUALITY..................................................................................................................... 12

3.4 BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES....................................................................................................... 15

3.5 CULTURAL RESOURCES ......................................................................................................... 18

3.6 ENERGY........................................................................................................................... 20

3.7 GEOLOGY AND SOILS ........................................................................................................... 21

3.8 GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS ................................................................................................ 24

3.9 HAZARDS AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS ..................................................................................... 25

3.10 HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY ....................................................................................... 27

3.11 LAND USE AND PLANNING .................................................................................................. 29

3.12 MINERAL RESOURCES ....................................................................................................... 30

3.13 NOISE.......................................................................................................................... 31

3.14 POPULATION AND HOUSING ................................................................................................ 37

3.15 PUBLIC SERVICES ............................................................................................................ 38

3.16 RECREATION .................................................................................................................. 40

3.17 TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC ................................................................................................ 41

3.18 TRIBAL CULTURAL RESOURCES ............................................................................................ 43

3.19 UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS......................................................................................... 47

3.20 WILDFIRE ..................................................................................................................... 49

3.21 MANDATORY FINDINGS OF SIGNIFICANCE ............................................................................... 50

4. REFERENCES.................................................................................................................. 52

Page 401 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- ii -
Appendices
Appendix A Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Plan
List of Figures
Figure 2-1 Project Concept.............................................................................................................3 Figure 2-2 Project Location ............................................................................................................4 Figure 3-1 Noise Measurement Locations ....................................................................................... 32 List of Tables
Table 3-1 Daily Emissions for Construction of the Project................................................................. 13 Table 3-2 Greenhouse Gas Emissions for Project ............................................................................ 24 Table 3-3 Noise Assessment Results.............................................................................................. 32 Table 3-4 City of San Dimas Land Use Guidelines for Exterior Noise................................................... 33 Table 3-5 Construction Equipment Noise Emission Levels ................................................................. 33 Table 3-6 Construction Equipment Vibration Reference Levels.......................................................... 36

Page 402 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- iii -
Acronyms
AQMP Air Quality Management Plan
BI Bond Issue
BMP Best Management Practice
CCR California Code of Regulations
CDFW California Department of Fish and Wildlife
CEQA California Environmental Quality Act
CO Carbon Monoxide
CRHR California Register of Historic Resources
dBA Maximum A-Weighted Decibels
EIR Environmental Impact Report
ESGR East San Gabriel River
ESGV East San Gabriel Valley
FEMA Federal Emergency Management Agency
FHWA Federal Highway Administration
FMMP Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program
GHG Greenhouse Gas
IPaC Information for Planning and Conservation
IS/MND Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
LACFCD Los Angeles County Flood Control District
LARWQCB Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board MLD Most Likely Descendant
MRZ Mineral Resource Zone
MT Metric Tons
NAAQS National Ambient Air Quality Standards
NAHC National American Heritage Commission
NOx Nitrogen Oxides
PM Particulate Matter
PPV Peak Particle Velocity
SCAB South Coast Air Basin
SCAQMD South Coast Air Quality Management District
SCIC South Coastal Information Center
SMARA Surface Mining and Reclamation Act of 1975
SOx Sulfur Oxides
USACE United States Army Corps of Engineers
USFWS United States Fish and Wildlife Services
WEAP Worker Environmental Awareness Program
WMG Watershed Management Group
WMP Watershed Management Program

Page 403 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 1 -

1. Introduction
This California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) has been prepared on behalf of the City of San Dimas (City) to identify potential site-specific environmental constraints associated with the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program (WMP) Project (Project) located at 500 N. Shellman Avenue in the City of San Dimas. This document has been prepared in accordance with CEQA (Public Resources Code §21000 et seq.), and the State CEQA Guidelines (Title 14, California Code of Regulations (CCR) §15000 et seq).

This IS/MND is an informational document intended for use by the City and members of the general public as a preliminary analysis to determine if there is substantial evidence that the Project may have significant effects on the environment. If site-specific environmental constraints are found to potentially have a significant effect on the environment, with mitigation, a site-specific Environmental Impact Report (EIR) should be prepared; otherwise, the lead agency may adopt a negative declaration or MND. This IS/MND was compiled for the City with the assistance of CWE. The City is serving as the Lead Agency for the proposed Project pursuant to CEQA §21067 and CEQA Guidelines Article 4 and §15367. “Lead Agency” refers to the public agency that has the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a Project.

1.1 Purpose and Document Organization
The purpose of this document is to evaluate the potential environmental effects of the proposed Project.

Mitigation measures, if required, have been incorporated into the Project to eliminate potential significant impacts or reduce them to a less-than-significant level.

This IS/MND is organized as follows:
 Section 1 – Introduction
 Section 2 – Project Description
 Section 3 – Initial Study/Environmental Checklist
 Section 4 – References

1.2 Summary of Findings
The CEQA Appendix G Environmental (Initial Study) Checklist is included in Section 3. The Initial Study Checklist identifies potential environmental impacts, by sections, and provides a brief discussion of each impact resulting from implementation of the proposed Project. Each response confirmed as applicable in the environmental checklist is discussed and supported with sufficient data and analysis as necessary. As appropriate, each section has discussion that describes and identifies specific impacts anticipated with project implementation.

Page 404 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 2 -

2. Project Description
The Project is being implemented by the City to address the East San Gabriel River (ESGR) watershed’s limiting pollutants (metals [zinc] and bacteria) associated with San Dimas Wash. The City is a participant in the East San Gabriel Valley (ESGV) Watershed Management Group (WMG), which is composed of the Cities of Claremont, La Verne, Pomona, and San Dimas. The ESGV WMG developed the ESGR WMP, which identified projects to improve water quality. The Project was identified in the WMP. The stormwater management improvements include the installation of a storm drain diversion system, associated piping, pretreatment system, flow meter, actuated valve, and subsurface infiltration system.

This Project aims to capture, treat, and infiltrate stormwater runoff from approximately 335 acres of various land uses within the cities of San Dimas and Glendora, all of which are tributary to the storm drain on Gladstone Street (Bond Issue [BI] 1121). The infiltration system is proposed to be located in the northeastern section of Lone Hill Park, east of the existing tennis courts. Runoff will be diverted from the existing Los Angeles County Flood Control District (LACFCD) storm drain in Gladstone Street (BI 1121) via a newly designed gravity-driven diversion pipe to be constructed along Shellman Avenue.

Diverted runoff will be pretreated before being conveyed into a subsurface infiltration system.

Once the subsurface infiltration system reaches capacity, an actuated valve will close, preventing further diversion of stormwater. The Project’s goal is to capture, treat, and infiltrate approximately 12 acre-feet of wet-weather runoff tributary to the Gladstone Street Storm Drain (BI 1121) per storm event. The conceptual layout of the Project is included as Figure 2-1.

In addition to its stormwater management objectives, the City is committed to maximizing community benefits through the Project. These benefits include providing new recreational opportunities, enhancing park space, and integrating community feedback into the Project design.

The Project goals are summarized as follows:
 Increase water supply through groundwater recharge
 Enhance water quality
 Maximize community benefits
 Minimize disruption to residents and local businesses  Incorporate community-based input

Page 405 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 3 -
Figure 2-1 Project Concept

2.1 Project Location
The proposed Project will be located in the City of San Dimas, within Los Angeles County, California. The City of San Dimas is situated in the eastern San Gabriel Valley region of Los Angeles County. The project site is at Lone Hill Park, located at 500 N. Shellman Ave, as depicted in Figure 2-2. Lone Hill Park is a 9-acre multipurpose recreational facility located on the western side of the City. The park serves as a community resource, offering various amenities, including a softball field, tennis and basketball courts, playground equipment, and parking facilities.

Page 406 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 4 -
Figure 2-2 Project Location

Page 407 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 5 -

3. Initial Study/Environmental Checklist
Environmental Checklist Form

1. Project Title: Lone Hill Park Regional WMP Project

2. Lead Agency Name
and Address:

City of San Dimas
245 E. Bonita Avenue, San Dimas, California 91773

3. Contact Person
and Phone
Number:

Lauren Marshall
Senior Management Analyst
(909) 394-6240 (Office)

4. Project Location: Lone Hill Park, City of San Dimas, California

5. Project Sponsor’s
Name and
Address:

City of San Dimas
245 E. Bonita Avenue, San Dimas, California 91773

6. General Plan
Designation:

Public Open Space

7. Zoning: Public Open Space

8. Description of
Project:

The City of San Dimas plans to capture, treat, and infiltrate stormwater runoff from San Dimas and Glendora, improving water quality in the Gladstone Street Storm Drain (BI 1121) and San Dimas Wash. The Project will enhance park infrastructure with features like a stormwater infiltration system, inclusive playground, demonstration garden, and permeable paving in the new parking lot, focusing on sustainability and cost-effective solutions in collaboration with the City to meet community needs.

9. Surrounding land
uses and setting:

Residential/School

10. Other public
agencies whose
approval is
required:

LACFCD
City of Glendora

11. Have California
Native American
tribes traditionally
and culturally
affiliated with the
project area
requested
consultation
pursuant to Public
Resources Code
section 21080.3.1?
If so, has
consultation
begun?a
The City of San Dimas sent out notification letters on September 4, 2025, to the Cahuilla Band of Indians, Gabrielino Band of Mission Indians – Kizh Nation, Gabrielino/Tongva San Gabriel Band of Mission Indians, Gabrielino Tongva Indians of California Tribal Council, Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, Gabrielino-Tongva Tribe, San Manuel Band of Mission Indians, Santa Rosa Band of Cahuilla Indians, and Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians, pursuant to Assembly Bill 52 and Public Resources Code Section 21080.3.1.
a. Conducting consultation early in the CEQA process allows tribal governments, lead agencies, and project proponents to discuss the level of environmental review, identify and address potential adverse impacts to tribal cultural resources, and reduce the potential for delay and conflict in the environmental review process. (See Public Resources Code section 21083.3.2.) Information may also be available from the California Native American Heritage Commission’s Sacred Lands File per Public Resources Code

Page 408 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 6 -
section 5097.96 and the California Historical Resources Information System administered by the California Office of Historic Preservation. Please also note that Public Resources Code section 21082.3(c) contains provisions specific to confidentiality.

The environmental factors checked below would be potentially affected by this project, involving at least one impact that is a "Potentially Significant Impact" as indicated by the checklist on the following pages.

Aesthetics Agriculture and Forestry
Resources Air Quality
Biological Resources Cultural Resources Energy
Geology / Soils Greenhouse Gas Emissions Hazards & Hazardous Materials
Hydrology / Water Quality Land Use / Planning Mineral Resources Noise Population / Housing Public Services
Recreation Transportation Tribal Cultural Resources
Utilities/Service Systems Wildfire Mandatory Findings of Significance

Page 409 ends
Page 410 ends

California Environmental Quality Act
City of San Dimas
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
On the basis of this initial evaluation:

I find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the environment, and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared
I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because revisions in the project have been made by or agreed to by the project proponent. A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.

I find that the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on the environment, and an ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required.

I find that the proposed project MAY have a "potentially significant impact" or "potentially significant unless mitigated" impact on the environment, but at least one effect 1) has been adequately analyzed in an earlier document pursuant to applicable legal standards, and 2) has been addressed by mitigation measures based on the earlier analysis as described on attached sheets. An ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required, but it must analyze only the effects that remain to be addressed.

I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment, because all potentially significant effects (a) have been analyzed adequately in an earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION pursuant to applicable standards, and (b) have been avoided or mitigated pursuant to that earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION, including revisions or mitigation measures that are imposed upon the proposed project, nothing further is required.

Marshaes May 14, 2026
Signature Date
- 7-

Page 4100554 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 8 -

3.1 Aesthetics
Would the project:

Environmental Issue
Potentially
Significant
Impact
Less Than
Significant
with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Less Than
Significant
Impact
No
Impact
a) Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic
vista? X
b) Substantially damage scenic resources, including,
but not limited to, trees, rock outcroppings, and
historic buildings within a state scenic highway?
X
c) In non-urbanized areas, substantially degrade
the existing visual character or quality public views
of the site and its surroundings? (Public views are
those that are experienced from a publicly
accessible vantage point). If the project is in an
urbanized area, would the project conflict with
applicable zoning and other regulations governing
scenic quality?
X
d) Create a new source of substantial light or glare
which would adversely affect day or nighttime views
in the area?
X
Discussion:
a) The City of San Dimas does not designate any scenic vistas according to the City’s General Plan. The project site is already developed and situated within an urbanized area. Construction of the Project will involve temporary ground disturbance activities. During construction, the presence of construction equipment and materials may be visible from public vantage points; however, these activities will not significantly impact any scenic views or vistas. Once the construction is complete, the project site will retain similar above-ground amenities and will not obstruct any existing views or vistas. Therefore, the project is not anticipated to have a substantial adverse impact on scenic vistas, and no further impacts are expected.
b) The Project is not located within or adjacent to any designated scenic resources. According to the California Department of Transportation Scenic Highways Program Database, there are no designated state scenic highways located near the Project. Additionally, the City’s General Plan specifies that no scenic highway corridors are aligned with the project site. The proposed site does not contain any rock outcroppings or formations. While there are existing trees on the site, they will be incorporated into the project’s landscaping plan. As a result, there will be no impacts to trees, rock outcroppings, or state scenic highways. Therefore, no significant impacts to scenic resources are anticipated.

Page 411 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 9 -
c) The Project is located within an urbanized area. Construction activities associated with the project will require the use of construction equipment and the storage of materials on-site, which will introduce temporary contrasting features into the visual landscape. These features may include demolition debris, excavated areas, stockpiled soils, and other materials generated and stored during construction. However, these visual disturbances will be temporary, and once construction is completed, the proposed infrastructure will enhance the aesthetic quality of the park facilities. As a result, impacts to the visual character of the site will be temporary and less than significant. d) The Project site is already situated within an urbanized area, predominantly surrounded by residential land uses. Existing sources of light, such as those from the parking lot and sports facilities, contribute to nighttime illumination. The Project will introduce new sources of amenity (pickleball) and emergency lighting, but these sources are not considered sources of substantial light or glare.

Therefore, no adverse impacts to daytime or nighttime views are anticipated.

Page 412 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 10 -

3.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources
Would the project:

Environmental Issue
Potentially
Significant
Impact
Less Than
Significant
with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Less Than
Significant
Impact
No
Impact
a) Convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or
Farmland of Statewide Importance (Farmland), as
shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the
Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program (FMMP)
of the California Resources Agency, to non-agricultural use? X
b) Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use,
or a Williamson Act contract? X
c) Conflict with existing zoning for, or cause
rezoning of, forest land (as defined in Public
Resources Code section 12220(g)), timberland (as
defined by Public Resources Code section 4526), or
timberland zoned Timberland Production (as
defined by Government Code section 51104(g))?
X
d) Result in the loss of forest land or conversion of
forest land to non-forest use? X
e) Involve other changes in the existing
environment which, due to their location or nature,
could result in conversion of Farmland, to non-agricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use?X Discussion:
a) According to the State of California Department of Conservation FMMP, the Project site is not located in an area designated as Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance.

Therefore, there is no impact to farmland or agricultural resources. b) The City of San Dimas is located within Los Angeles County, which is participating in the 2023 California Williamson Act. However, the project site is not zoned for agricultural use. Consequently, there is no anticipated impact from this designation.
c) The Project location area has no forest trees or areas designated for timberland. The Project is located in an urban environment with land zoned for public open space land use and surrounded by areas of residential land use. The Project will not conflict with existing zoning of forest land, timberland, or timberland zoned Timberland Production. Therefore, there is no anticipated impact.

Page 413 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 11 -
d) As discussed above, the Project is not located in forest land, so there will be no loss or conversion of forest land. Therefore, there is no impact.
e) The project site is not located on land designated for agricultural use and will not result in the conversion of farmland to non-agricultural use or forest land to non-forest use. Therefore, no impacts are anticipated.

Page 414 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 12 -

3.3 Air Quality
Would the project:

Environmental Issue
Potentially
Significant
Impact
Less Than
Significant
with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Less Than
Significant
Impact
No
Impact
a) Conflict with or obstruct implementation of the
applicable air quality plan? X
b) Result in a cumulatively considerable net
increase of any criteria pollutant for which the
project region is non-attainment under an
applicable federal or state ambient air quality
standard?
X
c) Expose sensitive receptors to substantial
pollutant concentrations? X
d) Result in other emissions (such as those leading
to odors) adversely affecting a substantial number
of people?
X
Discussion:
a) The City of San Dimas is located within the South Coast Air Basin (SCAB), which is bound by the San Gabriel, San Bernardino, and San Jacinto Mountains to the north and east, and the Pacific Ocean to the south and west. The air quality in the SCAB is managed by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD). The SCAB has a history of recorded air quality violations and is an area where both state and federal ambient air quality standards are exceeded, and therefore, is subject to the 2022 Air Quality Management Plan (AQMP). The 2022 AQMP includes integrated strategies and control measures needed to meet National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS).

Construction will conform with the requirements of the 2022 AQMP and will use the strategies in the AQMP during all phases of construction. The Project will result in temporary impacts to air quality due to the construction activities, and will therefore have a less than significant impact with the 2022 AQMP.
b) The Project is located in the SCAB, which is a non-attainment area for respirable fine particulate matter (PM) 2.5 (PM2.5), Lead, and Ozone. The SCAB is a designated attainment area for all other criteria pollutants. The SCAQMD has established Regional Significance Thresholds for each criteria pollutant. Potential air emissions were calculated using the CalEEMod, Version 2022.1.1.28, a model used to quantify air impacts from land use projects located throughout California. Table 3-1 shows the daily emissions rate for unmitigated construction during the summer, in comparison to the Regional Significance Thresholds.

Page 415 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 13 -
Table 3-1 Daily Emissions for Construction of the Project Pollutant NOx PM10 PM2.5 SOx CO
Maximum Emissions rate (lbs/day) 14.9 2.15a 0.79b 0.03c 16.1 Mass Daily Thresholds (lbs/day) 100 150 55 150 550
Exceed Threshold? No No No No No
a PM10 total modeled emissions
b PM2.5 total modeled emissions c
SO2 modeled emissions
The Project is not expected to result in a measurable long-term increase in air pollutant emissions.

After construction, the Project will have minimal vehicle trips to the sites for inspection and maintenance procedures. Therefore, impacts would be considered less than significant. c) Certain residents, such as the very young, the elderly and those suffering from certain illnesses or disabilities, are particularly sensitive to air pollution and are considered sensitive receptors. The sensitive receptors of concern are Gladstone Elementary School, directly north of the project site at 1314 W. Gladstone Street, San Dimas, CA 91771, Willow Elementary School approximately 0.3 miles west at 1427 Willow Avenue, Glendora, CA 91740, Dove Day School, 0.6 miles southeast at 908 W. Arrow Highway, San Dimas, CA 91773, Arrow Montessori School of San Dimas, 0.6 miles east at 818 W. Gladstone Street, San Dimas, CA 91773, Arrow High School, 0.7 miles west at 1505 S. Sunflower Avenue, Glendora, CA 91740, and the residential areas surrounding the park, especially along N. Shellman Avenue, W. Juanita Avenue, and N. Jansen Avenue. However, the proposed Project will not exceed the Regional Significance Threshold of criteria pollutants; therefore, the proposed Project will have a less than significant impact on nearby sensitive receptors with mitigation measure AIR-1.
d) Project construction equipment and activities, including diesel exhaust emissions, could generate odors. There may be situations where construction activity odors would be noticeable by persons working at or visiting nearby facilities, but these odors would not be unfamiliar or objectionable. In addition, these odors would be temporary and would dissipate rapidly from the source with an increase in distance. There are no long-term odors anticipated from the construction of the Project.

Because there may be short-term odors as a result from the temporary construction of the Project, impacts will be less than significant.

Mitigation Measures:

AIR-1 – Pursuant to Rule 403 of the SCAQMD, the following dust minimizing measures shall be implemented:
 City of San Dimas and its designees shall comply with all applicable SCAQMD Rules and Regulations, including Rule 403 ensuring the cleanup of construction-related dirt on approach routes to the site. Rule 403 prohibits the release of fugitive dust emissions from any active operation, open storage pile or disturbed surface area visible beyond the property line of the emission source.
 City of San Dimas and its designees shall comply with all SCAQMD established minimum requirements for construction activities to reduce fugitive dust and PM10 emissions.

Page 416 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 14 -
 Adequate water techniques shall be employed to mitigate the impact of construction-related dust particulates. Portions of the site that are undergoing surface earth moving operations shall be dewatered such that a crust will be formed on the ground surface, and then watered again at the end of each day. Site watering shall be performed as necessary to mitigate blowing dust.  Grading operations shall be suspended during first stage ozone episodes or when winds exceed 25 mph. A high wind response plan shall be formulated for enhanced dust control if winds are forecast to exceed 25 mph in any upcoming 24-hour period.  Any construction equipment using direct internal combustion engines shall use a diesel fuel with a maximum of 0.05 percent sulfur and four-degree retard.  Construction operations affecting roadways within the project area including detour routes, shall be scheduled by implementing traffic hours and shall minimize obstruction of through traffic lanes.
 The engines of idling trucks or heavy equipment shall be turned off if the expected duration of idling exceeds five minutes.
 On-site heavy equipment used during grading and construction shall be equipped with diesel particulate filters unless it is demonstrated that such equipment is not available, or its use is not cost-competitive.
 All haul trucks leaving or entering the site shall be covered or have at least two feet of freeboard.  Any on-site stockpiles of debris, dirt or other dusty material shall be covered or watered twice daily.
 Any site access points within 30 minutes of any visible dirt deposition on any public right-of-way shall be mechanically or manually swept.

Page 417 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 15 -

3.4 Biological Resources
Would the project:

Environmental Issue
Potentially
Significant
Impact
Less Than
Significant
with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Less Than
Significant
Impact
No
Impact
a) Have a substantial adverse effect, either directly
or through habitat modifications, on any species
identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or regional plans, policies, or
regulations, or by the California Department of Fish
and Wildlife or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
X
b) Have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian
habitat or other sensitive natural community
identified in local or regional plans, policies,
regulations or by the California Department of Fish
and Wildlife or US Fish and Wildlife Service?
X
c) Have a substantial adverse effect on state or
federally protected wetlands (including, but not
limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc.) through
direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or
other means?
X
d) Interfere substantially with the movement of any
native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species
or with established native resident or migratory
wildlife corridors, or impede the use of native
wildlife nursery sites?
X
e) Conflict with any local policies or ordinances
protecting biological resources, such as a tree
preservation policy or ordinance?
X
f) Conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat
Conservation Plan, Natural Community Conservation
Plan, or other approved local, regional, or state
habitat conservation plan?
X
Discussion:
a) Based on a report generated by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Information for Planning and Conservation (IPaC), seven federally listed endangered species have a potential to be present in the area: Coastal California Gnatcatcher, Least Bell’s Vireo, Southwestern Pond Turtle, Western Spadefoot, Monarch Butterfly, Nevin’s Barberry, and Slender-horned Spineflower, however no critical habitat overlaps or is designated within the project area for the species above. The Project is located

Page 418 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 16 -
in an urbanized area, it is unlikely that suitable habitat exists for any of these species. The Project will implement various mitigation measures, including pre-construction species surveys and protective actions if special-status species are discovered during construction. Additionally, the Project will incorporate native vegetation, improving local habitat for surrounding species. With the inclusion of Mitigation Measures BIO-1 through BIO-3, the impact on sensitive, special-status, or listed species is expected to be less than significant.
b) The proposed Project will be constructed within open space and public facilities zoning districts, as identified by the City’s General Plan. According to the National Wetlands Inventory, as mapped by the USFWS, the Project is not located within riparian areas, and therefore, there will be no impact on riparian habitats or other sensitive natural communities. Additionally, the surrounding areas have been fully urbanized and developed, so no significant impacts are anticipated. c) Wetlands, as defined by the federal Clean Water Act, refer to areas that are flooded or saturated by surface water or groundwater at a frequency and duration sufficient to support vegetation adapted to life in saturated soils. These areas include swamps, marshes, streams, lakes, and bogs. There are no wetlands, vernal pools, or similar features on the proposed project site. Best Management Practices (BMPs) will be implemented throughout the construction phase to prevent erosion and control dust. During dry weather, flows are expected to be minimal and will be captured by the stormwater management system. During wet weather, the flows intercepted by the Project will not result in significant hydrological impacts. According to the National Wetlands Inventory, the project site is not located within wetland areas, so no impact on wetlands is anticipated. d) The proposed Project is situated in a densely urbanized area, specifically on an established park and public facilities site. It is anticipated that the Project will have minimal impact on local wildlife movement or nurseries. While the site includes several trees, the urban environment suggests they are unlikely to provide suitable habitat or nesting sites for migratory birds, as defined by the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) Code, Section 3513 et seq. However, while the likelihood of nesting is low, it is still possible for birds to nest in the area. Project activities could result in the mortality or injury of nestlings, as well as the temporary or long-term loss of suitable foraging habitat.

Given the heavily urbanized nature of the area and the presence of ornamental trees, there is potential for these trees to provide habitat for nesting birds. Construction activities may disturb nesting habitats; therefore, with the implementation of Mitigation Measures BIO-1 through BIO-3, the project’s impacts on nesting birds will be less than significant. e) The proposed Project will comply with the City’s Tree Protection and Preservation Ordinance.

Although some trees are proposed to be removed, all significant mature trees will be protected.

Therefore, no impact to existing tree preservation policies or ordinance is anticipated. f) The Project will not conflict with any adopted conservation plan. The Project aligns with the City’s General Plan Goals OS-3 (providing park and recreational facilities to adequately serve residents), OS-6 (providing access to public open space), and OS-7 (providing a variety of recreational activities). Therefore, no conflicts with conservation plans are anticipated.

Page 419 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 17 -
Mitigation Measures:

BIO-1 – Prior to ground-disturbing activities in areas that could support sensitive biological resources, a habitat assessment shall be conducted by a qualified biologist to determine the potential for special-status wildlife species to occur within affected areas, including areas directly or indirectly impacted by construction or operation of the BMPs. If a special-status wildlife species is found, pre-construction surveys of proposed work zones should be conducted 14 days prior to construction. Areas, including construction areas, staging areas, and right-of-ways, should be staked, flagged, fenced, or otherwise clearly delineated to restrict the limits of construction to the minimum necessary near areas that may support special-status wildlife species with special-status wildlife species; if avoidance is not possible, the City of San Dimas should consult with the appropriate regulating agency (USACE/USFWS/CDFW) to determine a strategy for compliance with the Endangered Species Act, California Fish and Wildlife Code, or other regulations supporting special-status species. The City of San Dimas will work together with those regulating agencies to determine appropriate impact minimization measures and compensation for any permanent impacts due to the Project. If no breeding and nesting birds and/or raptors are found, then construction may proceed as scheduled with no additional monitoring or measured required.

BIO-2 – To protect nesting birds that may occur on site or adjacent to the Project boundary, no construction shall occur from February 1 through September 15, as early as January 1 for some raptors, unless a qualified biologist completes a survey for nesting bird activity within a 500-foot radius of the construction site. The nesting bird surveys shall be conducted at appropriate nesting times and concentrate on potential roosting or perch sites. The City of San Dimas should require surveys be conducted by a qualified biologist no more than 7 days prior to the beginning of any Project-related activity likely to impact raptors and migratory songbirds, for the entire Project site. If Project activities are delayed or suspended for more than 7 days during the breeding season, the surveys shall be repeated. If nesting raptors and migratory songbirds are identified, the following minimum no-disturbance buffers shall be implemented: 300 feet around active passerine (perching birds and songbirds) nests, 500 feet around active non-listed raptor nests and 0.5 mile around active listed bird nests. These buffers shall be maintained until the breeding season has ended or until a qualified biologist has determined that the birds have fledged and are no longer reliant upon the nest or parental care for survival. The qualified biologist may authorize construction activities to proceed during the nesting season, including modified avoidance buffers or work restrictions, if, in their professional judgement, the proposed activities will not result in take, nest abandonment, or disturbance as defined under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. Such determinations shall be based on observed nesting behavior, distance to work activities, species tolerance, and current site condition. Any sensitive and special status species data documented by the Project shall be submitted to the California Natural Diversity Database with all applicable data fields filled out. The City of San Dimas and/or a designee will notify the CDFW once submitted.

BIO-3 – The Project shall implement BMPs to prevent erosion and the discharge of sediment and pollutants into drainages during Project activities. BMPs shall be monitored and repaired, if necessary, to ensure maximum erosion, sediment, and pollution control. The Project proponent shall prohibit the use of erosion control materials potentially harmful to fish and wildlife species, such as mono-filament netting (erosion control matting) or similar material. All fiber rolls, straw wattles, and/or hay bales utilized within and adjacent to the Project site shall be free of nonnative plant materials. Fiber rolls or erosion control mesh shall be made of loose-weave mesh that is not fused at the intersections of the weave, such as jute, or coconut (coir) fiber, or other products without welded weaves.

Page 420 ends

City of San Dimas California Environmental Quality Act
Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
- 18 -

3.5 Cultural Resources
Would the project:

Environmental Issue
Potentially
Significant
Impact
Less Than
Significant
with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Less Than
Significant
Impact
No
Impact
a) Cause a substantial adverse change in the
significance of a historical resource pursuant to §
15064.5?
X
b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the
significance of an archaeological resource pursuant
to § 15064.5?
X
c) Disturb any human remains, including those
interred outside of dedicated cemeteries? X
Discussion:
a) A Cultural Resource Assessment was conducted by LSA Associates, Inc. in January 2025. A records search of the surrounding areas via the South Coastal Information Center (SCIC) at San Diego State University included a 0.25-mile buffer of the project location. Data from the SCIC indicated that there have been three previous cultural resources studies conducted within a 0.25-mile radius.

These studies comprised two commercial building surveys and a construction monitoring of a commercial building, none of which included any portion of the project area. None of the cultural resources have been documented within the project area, including prehistoric and historic-period built-environmental resources.

Additional research consisting of a review of historic-period maps and aerial photographs did not show any trace of the historic-period transit corridor within the project area. Although the route of a historic-period transit corridor may have once transected the northern portion of the project area, mapping of such 19th-century historic routes that never became roads was and is approximate. This route was superseded by later roads and obliterated by agriculture, the construction of Shellman Avenue, Gladstone Street, and surrounding development. No other resources were documented within 0.25-mile of the project site.

A field survey was not conducted due to the project area being completely obscured by roadway, sidewalks, and development, and therefore, there is no potential for in situ cultural resources on the surface.
b) See discussion above in part a). However, if during construction any archaeological remains are found, all construction will cease until qualified personnel can identify the remains and mitigate the findings. Impacts are anticipated to be less than significant with incorporating mitigation measures CUL-1, through CUL-3.

Page 421 ends
← All documents from this meeting