Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$2,423 2.5@55 $10,887 11 8 7 13 39
$5,404 2.7@55 $16,898 8 9 23 40
$1,813 2.7@55 $15,210 10 9 5 13 37
$687 2@60 $9,434 9 23 32
$2,509 2@55 $13,374 9 8 10 17 44
$2,773 2.7@55 $11,548 11 10 23 44
$2,970 ($90)2.5@55 $11,264 11 8 4 15 38
$1,889 3@60 $11,544 9 8 17 34
$12,659 39.0
-9.7%-14.7%
$11,548 39.0
0.0%-14.7%
$14,292 42.0
-23.8%-23.4%
-9.2%
92 Print Date: 1/26/2022 402
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Vehicle Maintenance Supervisor 9 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Fleet Manager $8,619 $275 $8,894 $1,400 inc $21 $39 $10,354 Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton No Comparable Class
Corona Fleet Services Supervisor $7,328 $167 $7,495 $1,564 inc inc $0 $50 $9,108 Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Maintenance Manager $11,053 $11,053 $1,876 inc inc $29 $101 $13,058 Palm Springs Fleet Maintenance Manager $9,610 $481 $10,091 $2,094 inc inc $11 $119 $12,315 Redlands Fleet Services Coordinator $6,776 $72 $6,848 $913 $127 $19 $7,906 Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Fleet Management Supervisor $8,366 $4 $75 $8,445 $1,482 $45 inc $48 $10,020 RTA Maintenance Supervisor $9,711 $9,711 $1,217 $10,928 San Bernardino Equipment Maintenance Supervisor $5,912 $5,912 $1,030 inc inc $1 $10 $6,953 Sunline Deputy Chief Ops Officer - Maintenance $8,635 $25 $8,660 $1,432 $10,092 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland No Comparable Class
Beaumont Vehicle Maintenance Supervisor $6,467 $6,467 $1,675 inc inc $7 $8,149 Average $8,446 $8,568 $10,082
% +/--30.6%-32.5%-23.7%
Median $8,619 $8,660 $10,092
9 % +/--33.3%-33.9%-23.8%
75th Percenile $9,610 $9,711 $10,928
10 % +/--48.6%-50.2%-34.1%
Median Gain/Loss -0.6%10.1%
93 Print Date: 1/26/2022 403
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Vehicle Maintenance Supervisor
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Fleet Manager
Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton No Comparable Class
Corona Fleet Services Supervisor
Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Maintenance Manager
Palm Springs Fleet Maintenance Manager
Redlands Fleet Services Coordinator
Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Fleet Management Supervisor
RTA Maintenance Supervisor
San Bernardino Equipment Maintenance Supervisor
Sunline Deputy Chief Ops Officer - Maintenance
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland No Comparable Class
Beaumont Vehicle Maintenance Supervisor
Average
% +/-
Median
9 % +/-
75th Percenile
10 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$2,655 2@60 $13,008 11 8 13 32
$4,149 2.7@55 $13,257 8 9 23 40
$1,816 2%@55 $14,874 7 8 17 32
$3,374 2@60 $15,688 10 4 21 35
$1,766 2@55 $9,672 11 8 10 17 45
$2,658 2.7@55 $12,678 8 8 14 30
$970 2%@55 $11,898 9 8 20 37
$2,559 ($136)2@55 $9,376 11 8 17 35
2%@60 $10,092 4 7 25 36
$1,669 3@60 $9,818 9 8 17 34
$12,283 35.9
-25.1%-5.5%
$12,678 35.2
-29.1%-3.4%
$13,257 37.3
-35.0%-9.8%
-5.3%
94 Print Date: 1/26/2022 404
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Wastewater Collection System Worker II 6 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Wastewater Collection System Technician $4,884 $4,884 $1,400 inc $21 inc $6,305 Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton Collection System Maintenance Tech II $5,185 $42 $259 $5,486 $1,100 inc inc $13 $23 $6,622 Corona No Comparable Class
Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Palm Springs No Comparable Class
Redlands Line Maintenance Worker II $5,063 $253 $5,316 $900 $127 $19 $6,362 Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Wastewater Collection System Technician II $5,863 $7 $5,870 $1,411 $45 inc $3 $7,329 San Bernardino Sewer Maintenance Worker $4,383 $4,383 $880 inc inc $1 $8 $5,272 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Maintenance Worker $4,335 $195 $100 $4,630 $1,267 inc inc $5,897 Beaumont Wastewater Collection System Worker II $6,155 $616 $6,771 $1,675 inc inc $7 $8,453 Average $4,952 $5,095 $6,298
% +/-19.5%24.7%25.5%
Median $4,974 $5,100 $6,334
6 % +/-19.2%24.7%25.1%
75th Percenile $5,155 $5,444 $6,557
7 % +/-16.3%19.6%22.4%
Median Gain/Loss 5.5%0.4%
95 Print Date: 1/26/2022 405
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Wastewater Collection System Worker II
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Wastewater Collection System Technician
Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton Collection System Maintenance Tech II
Corona No Comparable Class
Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Palm Springs No Comparable Class
Redlands Line Maintenance Worker II
Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Wastewater Collection System Technician II
San Bernardino Sewer Maintenance Worker
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Maintenance Worker
Beaumont Wastewater Collection System Worker II
Average
% +/-
Median
6 % +/-
75th Percenile
7 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$1,504 2@60 $7,810 11 8 13 32
$1,716 2.5@55 $8,338 12 8 13 33
$1,320 2@55 $7,682 11 8 17 35
$1,863 2.7@55 $9,191 8 8 13 29
$1,897 ($57)2@55 $7,112 11 8 17 35
$2,001 ($61)2.5@55 $7,837 11 8 15 34
$1,589 3@60 $10,041 9 8 17 34
$7,995 33.1
20.4%2.7%
$7,823 33.3
22.1%2.2%
$8,213 34.8
18.2%-2.2%
-3.0%
96 Print Date: 1/26/2022 406
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Wastewater Plant Operator III 4 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning No Comparable Class
Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton Senior Wastewater Treatment Plant Op $6,987 $42 $349 $7,378 $1,100 inc inc $13 $31 $8,522 Corona Water Reclamation Operator III $7,438 $83 $7,521 $1,564 inc inc $0 $51 $9,136 Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Palm Springs No Comparable Class
Redlands Wastewater Facilities Operator III $6,303 $315 $6,618 $900 $127 $19 $7,664 Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Wastewater Plant Operator III $7,838 $8 $7,846 $1,411 $45 inc $3 $9,304 San Bernardino No Comparable Class
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland No Comparable Class
Beaumont Wastewater Plant Operator III $7,316 $732 $8,048 $1,675 inc inc $7 $9,730 Average $7,141 $7,341 $8,656
% +/-2.4%8.8%11.0%
Median $7,212 $7,449 $8,829
4 % +/-1.4%7.4%9.3%
75th Percenile $7,538 $7,602 $9,178
6 % +/--3.0%5.5%5.7%
Median Gain/Loss 6.0%1.8%
97 Print Date: 1/26/2022 407
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Wastewater Plant Operator III
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning No Comparable Class
Cathedral City No Comparable Class
Colton Senior Wastewater Treatment Plant Op
Corona Water Reclamation Operator III
Menifee No Comparable Class
Murrieta No Comparable Class
Palm Springs No Comparable Class
Redlands Wastewater Facilities Operator III
Rialto No Comparable Class
Riverside Wastewater Plant Operator III
San Bernardino No Comparable Class
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland No Comparable Class
Beaumont Wastewater Plant Operator III
Average
% +/-
Median
4 % +/-
75th Percenile
6 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$2,312 2.5@55 $10,834 12 8 13 33
$4,211 2.7@55 $13,347 8 21 29
$1,643 2@55 $9,307 11 8 17 35
$2,490 2.7@55 $11,795 8 8 13 29
$1,889 3@60 $11,619 9 8 17 34
$11,321 31.6
2.6%7.1%
$11,314 31.2
2.6%8.3%
$12,183 33.6
-4.9%1.2%
-6.6%
98 Print Date: 1/26/2022 408
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Chief of Police 12 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits
Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.POST Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Police Chief $16,350 $150 $450 $16,950 $1,667 inc $21 $39 $18,677 Cathedral City Police Chief $18,502 $2,775 $135 $925 $925 $100 $1,295 $24,658 $2,300 inc inc $80 $44 $27,082 Colton Police Chief $15,091 $70 $1,000 $16,161 $1,183 inc inc $17 $68 $17,429 Corona Chief of Police $17,805 $167 $287 $873 $19,131 $1,564 inc inc $0 $121 $20,816 Menifee Chief of Police $19,260 $83 $963 $417 $20,723 $1,800 inc inc $17 $22,540 Murrieta Police Chief $19,607 $150 $250 $655 $20,662 $1,563 $98 $40 $39 $133 $22,534 Palm Springs Police Chief $19,818 $135 $991 $20,944 $2,094 inc inc $11 $246 $23,295 Redlands Police Chief $21,693 $142 $434 $22,269 $2,706 $127 $19 $25,121 Rialto Chief of Police $20,710 $1,553 $750 $1,864 $24,877 $1,300 $137 $25 $26,339 Riverside Chief of Police $30,900 $26 $75 $31,001 $1,482 $45 inc $178 $32,706 San Bernardino Chief of Police $23,260 $79 $23,339 $1,250 inc inc $25 $41 $24,655 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Chief of Police $22,119 $553 $74 $1,991 $24,736 $1,184 inc inc $25,920 Beaumont Chief of Police $19,167 $100 $479 $19,746 $1,675 inc inc $7 $21,428 Average $20,426 $22,121 $23,926
% +/--6.6%-12.0%-11.7%
Median $19,713 $21,606 $23,975
12 % +/--2.8%-9.4%-11.9%
75th Percenile $21,800 $24,677 $26,025
12 % +/--13.7%-25.0%-21.5%
Median Gain/Loss -6.6%-2.5%
99 Print Date: 1/26/2022
409
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Chief of Police
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Police Chief
Cathedral City Police Chief
Colton Police Chief
Corona Chief of Police
Menifee Chief of Police
Murrieta Police Chief
Palm Springs Police Chief
Redlands Police Chief
Rialto Chief of Police
Riverside Chief of Police
San Bernardino Chief of Police
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Chief of Police
Beaumont Chief of Police
Average
% +/-
Median
12 % +/-
75th Percenile
12 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$3,546 2@50 $22,223 11 8 8 13 40
$8,119 ($2,220)3@55 $32,981 12 8 22 42
$3,632 3@55 $21,062 12 8 7 13 40
$10,088 ($267)3@50 $30,636 8 9 25 42
$2,674 ($915)$24,299 10 9 5 13 37
$4,410 ($1,110)3@55 $25,834 9 10 23 42
$12,379 ($595)3@55 $35,079 10 4 21 35
$13,268 3@50 $38,389 9 33 42
$14,554 ($2,485)3@50 $38,408 10 10 12 20 52
$16,076 3@50 $48,781 8 8 4 17 37
$21,117 ($698)3@55 $45,074 11 8 7 17 42
$20,709 3@55 $46,630 11 8 7 15 40
$7,859 3@50 $29,288 9 8 3 17 37
$34,116 40.8
-16.5%-9.2%
$34,030 41.0
-16.2%-9.8%
$40,074 41.9
-36.8%-12.2%
-4.3%
100 Print Date: 1/26/2022
410
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Lieutenant 11 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.POST Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Police Lieutenant $12,828 $257 $150 $225 $300 $513 $14,273 $1,400 inc $10 $39 $15,722 Cathedral City Police Commander $14,324 $140 $100 $1,003 $15,567 $2,300 inc inc $62 $34 $17,963 Colton Police Lieutenant $11,047 $75 $829 $1,105 $13,056 $1,100 inc inc $8 $14,164 Corona Police Lieutenant $13,533 $698 $287 $1,083 $15,600 $1,564 inc inc $0 $92 $17,256 Menifee Police Lieutenant $12,809 $83 $640 $333 $13,866 $1,800 inc inc $15,666 Murrieta Police Lieutenant $13,591 $150 $680 $680 $200 $454 $15,754 $1,663 $98 $40 $27 $92 $17,674 Palm Springs Police Lieutenant $13,258 $135 $265 $663 $14,321 $2,006 $80 $13 $11 $164 $16,595 Redlands No Comparable Class
Rialto Police Lieutenant $11,710 $703 $133 $878 $1,874 $750 $1,054 $17,102 $1,400 inc inc $18,502 Riverside Police Lieutenant $15,501 $26 $2,325 $200 $18,052 $1,543 inc inc $89 $15 $19,699 San Bernardino Lieutenant $14,743 $79 $450 $15,272 $1,318 inc inc $5 $16,594 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Lieutenant $11,919 $596 $74 $596 $596 $596 $14,376 $1,300 inc inc $15,676 Beaumont Police Lieutenant $14,609 $100 $365 $15,074 $1,675 inc inc $7 $16,756 Average $13,206 $15,203 $16,865
% +/-9.6%-0.9%-0.6%
Median $13,258 $15,272 $16,595
11 % +/-9.2%-1.3%1.0%
75th Percenile $13,958 $15,677 $17,818
11 % +/-4.5%-4.0%-6.3%
Median Gain/Loss -10.6%2.3%
101 Print Date: 1/26/2022
411
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Lieutenant
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Police Lieutenant
Cathedral City Police Commander
Colton Police Lieutenant
Corona Police Lieutenant
Menifee Police Lieutenant
Murrieta Police Lieutenant
Palm Springs Police Lieutenant
Redlands No Comparable Class
Rialto Police Lieutenant
Riverside Police Lieutenant
San Bernardino Lieutenant
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Lieutenant
Beaumont Police Lieutenant
Average
% +/-
Median
11 % +/-
75th Percenile
11 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$2,782 2@50 $18,505 8 8 13 29
$6,286 ($1,719)3@55 $22,530 8 18 26
$2,659 ($331)3@55 $16,492 10 8 8 13 40
$7,667 ($203)3@50 $24,720 10 24 34
$1,778 ($608)$16,836 1 9 5 20 35
$3,057 ($769)3@55 $19,961 10 5 23 38
$8,282 ($398)3@55 $24,479 4 17 21
$8,229 ($1,405)3@50 $25,326 2 10 12 32 55
$8,064 3@50 $27,764 11 8 17 36
$13,385 ($442)3@55 $29,537 11 8 7 17 42
$11,159 ($358)3@55 $26,478 8 3 15 25
$5,990 3@50 $22,746 9 8 17 34
$22,966 34.6
-1.0%-1.7%
$24,479 35.1
-7.6%-3.2%
$25,902 38.7
-13.9%-13.7%
-8.6%
102 Print Date: 1/26/2022
412
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Sergeant 12 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits
Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.POST Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Police Sergeant $10,473 $209 $150 $225 $300 $419 $11,777 $1,400 inc inc $13 $13,190 Cathedral City Police Sergeant $12,385 $140 $100 $867 $13,492 $2,300 inc inc $54 $30 $15,875 Colton Police Sergeant $9,206 $75 $552 $921 $10,754 $1,100 inc inc $8 $11,863 Corona Police Sergeant $11,086 $698 $287 $887 $12,957 $1,564 inc inc $0 $75 $14,596 Menifee Police Sergeant $10,544 $83 $527 $250 $11,405 $1,800 inc inc $13,205 Murrieta Police Sergeant $10,646 $150 $260 $520 $150 $356 $12,082 $1,663 $98 $40 $3 $20 $13,904 Palm Springs Police Sergeant $10,426 $135 $1,043 $11,604 $2,006 $80 $13 $11 $129 $13,842 Redlands Police Sergeant $9,976 $499 $267 $1,746 $12,487 $1,100 $127 $19 $13,733 Rialto Police Sergeant $9,611 $577 $133 $721 $1,538 $750 $865 $14,195 $1,400 inc inc $15,595 Riverside Police Sergeant $10,589 $26 $1,588 $200 $12,403 $1,543 inc inc $61 $15 $14,022 San Bernardino Police Sergeant $11,967 $79 $275 $12,321 $1,211 inc inc $2 $13,534 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Police Sergeant $9,873 $494 $74 $494 $494 $494 $11,921 $1,300 inc inc $13,221 Beaumont Police Sergeant $10,339 $100 $1,034 $11,473 $1,500 inc inc $7 $12,980 Average $10,565 $12,283 $13,882
% +/--2.2%-7.1%-6.9%
Median $10,509 $12,201 $13,788
12 % +/--1.6%-6.3%-6.2%
75th Percenile $10,756 $12,605 $14,166
12 % +/--4.0%-9.9%-9.1%
Median Gain/Loss -4.7%0.1%
103 Print Date: 1/26/2022
413
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Sergeant
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Police Sergeant
Cathedral City Police Sergeant
Colton Police Sergeant
Corona Police Sergeant
Menifee Police Sergeant
Murrieta Police Sergeant
Palm Springs Police Sergeant
Redlands Police Sergeant
Rialto Police Sergeant
Riverside Police Sergeant
San Bernardino Police Sergeant
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Police Sergeant
Beaumont Police Sergeant
Average
% +/-
Median
12 % +/-
75th Percenile
12 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$2,272 2@50 $15,461 7 8 13 29
$5,435 ($1,486)3@55 $19,824 8 18 26
$2,216 ($276)3@55 $13,802 10 8 13 31
$6,281 ($166)3@50 $20,711 10 24 34
$1,464 ($501)$14,168 1 9 20 30
$2,394 ($603)3@55 $15,696 12 23 35
$6,513 ($313)3@55 $20,042 10 17 27
$6,102 3@50 $19,835 2 8 15 24
$6,754 ($1,153)3@50 $21,195 2 10 12 32 55
$5,509 3@50 $19,531 11 8 17 36
$10,864 ($359)3@55 $24,039 9 8 17 34
$9,244 ($296)3@55 $22,169 8 2 15 24
$4,239 3@50 $17,220 9 8 17 34
$18,873 32.1
-9.6%5.7%
$19,829 30.7
-15.2%9.7%
$20,832 34.3
-21.0%-0.9%
-8.9%
104 Print Date: 1/26/2022
414
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Officer 12 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits
Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.POST Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Police Officer $7,982 $160 $150 $225 $300 $319 $9,136 $1,400 inc inc $13 $10,549 Cathedral City Police Officer $8,945 $140 $447 $100 $9,632 $2,400 inc inc $27 $21 $12,081 Colton Police Officer $6,958 $75 $417 $696 $8,146 $1,100 inc inc $8 $9,254 Corona Police Officer II $8,178 $552 $287 $654 $9,671 $1,564 inc inc $0 $56 $11,290 Menifee Police Officer $8,176 $83 $409 $250 $8,918 $1,800 inc inc $10,718 Murrieta Police Officer $8,228 $150 $260 $520 $150 $275 $9,583 $1,663 $98 $40 $3 $20 $11,406 Palm Springs Police Officer $8,032 $135 $803 $8,970 $2,006 $80 $13 $11 $100 $11,179 Redlands Police Officer $7,409 $370 $267 $1,297 $9,343 $1,100 $127 $19 $10,589 Rialto Police Officer $7,361 $442 $133 $552 $368 $600 $662 $10,119 $1,400 inc inc $11,519 Riverside Police Officer $8,298 $26 $1,245 $9,569 $1,543 inc inc $1 $10 $11,123 San Bernardino Police Officer $9,287 $79 $275 $9,641 $1,211 inc inc $2 $10,854 Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Police Officer $7,203 $360 $74 $360 $360 $300 $8,657 $1,300 inc inc $9,957 Beaumont Police Officer $7,687 $100 $769 $8,556 $1,500 inc inc $7 $10,063 Police OfficerAvg Average $8,005 $9,282 $10,877
% +/--4.1%-8.5%-8.1%
Median $8,104 $9,456 $10,988
12 % +/--5.4%-10.5%-9.2%
75th Percenile $8,246 $9,634 $11,319
12 % +/--7.3%-12.6%-12.5%
Median Gain/Loss -5.1%1.3%
105 Print Date: 1/26/2022
415
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Police Officer
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Police Officer
Cathedral City Police Officer
Colton Police Officer
Corona Police Officer II
Menifee Police Officer
Murrieta Police Officer
Palm Springs Police Officer
Redlands Police Officer
Rialto Police Officer
Riverside Police Officer
San Bernardino Police Officer
Temecula No Comparable Class
Upland Police Officer
Beaumont Police Officer
Police OfficerAvg Average
% +/-
Median
12 % +/-
75th Percenile
12 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$1,731 2@50 $12,280 7 8 13 29
$3,925 3@55 $16,006 8 16 24
$1,675 ($209)3@55 $10,720 10 8 13 31
$4,633 ($123)3@50 $15,801 10 24 34
$1,135 ($388)$11,465 1 9 20 30
$1,851 ($466)3@55 $12,791 12 23 35
$5,017 ($241)3@55 $15,956 10 17 27
$4,532 3@50 $15,121 2 8 15 24
$5,173 ($883)3@50 $15,808 10 32 42
$4,317 3@50 $15,440 11 8 13 32
$8,431 ($279)3@55 $19,007 9 8 17 34
$6,744 ($216)3@55 $16,485 8 15 23
$3,152 3@50 $13,215 9 8 17 34
$14,740 30.4
-11.5%10.6%
$15,621 30.7
-18.2%9.7%
$15,968 33.9
-20.8%0.2%
-9.0%
106 Print Date: 1/26/2022
416
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Transit Manager 3 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits
Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Transportation Manager $11,053 $11,053 $1,876 inc inc $29 $101 $13,058 Riverside No Comparable Class
RTA Operations Manager $11,035 $25 $11,060 $1,217 $12,277 Sunline Deputy Operations/Chief Transportation Officer $8,635 $25 $8,660 $1,432 $10,092 Beaumont Transit Manager $9,601 $9,601 $1,675 inc inc $7 $11,283 Average $10,241 $10,258 $11,809
% +/--6.7%-6.8%-4.7%
Median $11,035 $11,053 $12,277
3 % +/--14.9%-15.1%-8.8%
75th Percenile $11,044 $11,056 $12,668
4 % +/--15.0%-15.2%-12.3%
Median Gain/Loss -0.2%6.3%
107 Print Date: 1/26/2022
417
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Transit Manager
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Transportation Manager
Riverside No Comparable Class
RTA Operations Manager
Sunline Deputy Operations/Chief Transportation Officer
Beaumont Transit Manager
Average
% +/-
Median
3 % +/-
75th Percenile
4 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$1,816 2%@55 $14,874 7 8 17 32
$1,102 2%@55 $13,379 9 8 20 37
2%@60 $10,092 4 7 25 36
$2,478 3@60 $13,761 9 8 3 17 37
$12,782 35.1
7.1%5.9%
$13,379 36.0
2.8%3.6%
$14,127 36.7
-2.7%1.8%
11.6%
108 Print Date: 1/26/2022
418
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Transit Assistant 3 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Dispatcher $6,544 $6,544 $1,876 inc inc $14 $60 $8,494 Riverside No Comparable Class
RTA Transit Clerk $4,495 $4,495 $1,217 $5,712
Sunline Senior Administrative Assistant $3,735 $25 $3,760 $1,432 $5,192 Beaumont Transit Assistant - Drift
Average $4,925 $4,933 $6,466
% +/-
Median $4,495 $4,495 $5,712
3 % +/-
75th Percenile $5,519 $5,519 $7,103
3 % +/-
Median Gain/Loss
109 Print Date: 1/26/2022
419
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Transit Assistant
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning No Comparable Class
Omnitrans Dispatcher
Riverside No Comparable Class
RTA Transit Clerk
Sunline Senior Administrative Assistant
Beaumont Transit Assistant - Drift
Average
% +/-
Median
3 % +/-
75th Percenile
3 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$1,075 2%@55 $9,569 7 8 17 32
$449 2%@55 $6,161 9 8 20 37
2%@60 $5,192 4 7 25 36
$6,974 35.1
$6,161 36.0
$7,865 36.7
110 Print Date: 1/26/2022
420
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Bus Driver I 5 Cash Supplements Insurance Benefits
Survey Agency Comparable Class Range
Max.Long.Uniform Educ.
Inc.
Def.
Comp.
Ret.
Pickup
Base +
Cash Health Dental Vision Life LTD
Base +
Cash +
Ins.
Banning Bus Driver $4,233 $4,233 $1,400 inc $21 inc $5,654 Omnitrans Coach Operator $4,585 $4,585 $1,355 inc inc $14 $42 $5,996 Riverside Mini-Bus Driver $3,077 $7 $3,084 $1,411 $45 inc $3 $4,543 RTA Coach Operator $4,992 $4,992 $1,217 $6,209
Sunline Motor Coach Operator $4,146 $25 $4,171 $1,432 $5,603 Beaumont Bus Driver I $4,146 $415 $4,561 $1,675 inc inc $7 $6,243 Bus Driver IAvg Average $4,207 $4,213 $5,601
% +/--1.5%7.6%10.3%
Median $4,233 $4,233 $5,654
5 % +/--2.1%7.2%9.4%
75th Percenile $4,585 $4,585 $5,996
5 % +/--10.6%-0.5%4.0%
Median Gain/Loss 9.3%2.2%
111 Print Date: 1/26/2022
421
Item 18.
Ralph Andersen & Associates Data Effective June 2021
Beaumont
Bus Driver I
Survey Agency Comparable Class
Banning Bus Driver
Omnitrans Coach Operator
Riverside Mini-Bus Driver
RTA Coach Operator
Sunline Motor Coach Operator
Beaumont Bus Driver I
Bus Driver IAvg Average
% +/-
Median
5 % +/-
75th Percenile
5 % +/-
Retirement Benefits Leave Benefits
Emp. Ret.EE Cont
to ER Ret. Form.
Base +
Cash +
Ins. + Ret.
Hol Sick Admin Vac
Max
Total
Leave
$1,304 2@60 $6,958 11 8 13 32
$753 2%@55 $6,749 7 8 17 32
$978 2.7@55 $5,520 8 8 13 29
$499 2%@55 $6,708 9 8 20 37
2%@60 $5,603 4 7 25 36
$1,070 3@60 $7,313 9 8 17 34
$6,308 33.4
13.7%1.9%
$6,708 32.2
8.3%5.4%
$6,749 36.0
7.7%-5.9%
-1.2%
112 Print Date: 1/26/2022
422
Item 18.
423
Item 19.
424
Item 19.
425
Item 19.
426
Item 19.
427
Item 19.
428
Item 19.
429
Item 19.
430
Item 19.
431
Item 19.
432
Item 19.
433
Item 19.
434
Item 19.
Pending Litigation Against the City (does not include litigation initiated by the City)
1. Christian Lee v. City of Beaumont, Riv. Co. Sup. Ct. Case No. RIC 2003005 (Pre- Trial)
2. Charles Peters dba Pioneer Mobile Village v. City of Beaumont et. al., Riv. Co.
Sup. Ct. Case No. RIC 1707116 (Appeal)
3. Ezekwesili Iloputaife, et. al. v. City of Beaumont et. al., EDCV 21-1452-JWH(AGR) (Pleading)
4. Steven Fortier v. City of Beaumont, Riv. Co. Sup. Ct. Case No. 2105608 (Pleading)
5. Ezekwesili Iloputaife, et. al. v. City of Beaumont et. al., Riv. Co. Sup. Ct. Case No. 2105069 (Pleading)
To: City Council
From: John O. Pinkney, City Attorney
Date: February 8, 2022
Re: List of Pending Litigation Against City of Beaumont 435
Item 20.
436
Item 21.
437
Item 21.
438
Item 21.
439
Item 21.
440
Item 21.
441
Item 21.
442
Item 21.
443
Item 21.
444
Item 21.
445
Item 21.
446
Item 21.
447
Item 21.
448
Item 21.
449
Item 21.
450
Item 21.
451
Item 21.
452
Item 21.
453
Item 21.
454
Item 21.
455
Item 21.
456
Item 21.
457
Item 21.
458
Item 21.
459
Item 21.
460
Item 21.
461
Item 21.
462
Item 21.
463
Item 21.
464
Item 21.
465
Item 21.
466
Item 21.
467
Item 21.
468
Item 21.
469
Item 21.
470
Item 21.