Staff Report— Housing Element Implementation Project
February 10, 2025
FISCAL IMPACT
There is a cost for drafting and codifying the proposed ordinance within the Bellflower Municipal Code ('BMC”) along with publication, etc. These are already anticipated as part of the City's operations. No additional direct fiscal impact is identified. Indirectly, the proposed actions will assist the City with obtaining State and federal grants.
PUBLIC NOTICE
A Notice of Public Hearing was published in the Los Cerritos Community News newspaper on January 17, 2025. Public hearing notices were sent on January 16. 2025 to 354 property owners within the Project area and posted at City Hall. Bellflower Substation, Thompson Park, Simms Park. Caruthers Park. Brakensiek Library. and the City’s website. As of the writing of this staff report, the City has received three correspondences (Attachment C).
CE STATUS
The City reviewed the environmental impacts of the proposed Resolution and Ordinance pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code §§ 21000. et seq. 'CEQA”) and the regulations promulgated thereunder (14 Cal. Code of Regs. §§ 15000, et seq, the “CEQA Guidelines"). In accordance with CEQA and CEQA Guidelines § 15162, the City Council finds as follows:
A. Resolution No. 2204 was adopted by the City Council on January 20. 2022, approving Mitigated Negative Declaration No. MND 21—01.
B. Changing the zoning designation for the properties identified in the Resolution and Ordinance is an activity contemplated by MND 21-01.
C. This activity does not contemplate any changes which will require major revisions to MND 21-01 nor are there any substantial changes with respect to the circumstances under which MND 21-01 was undertaken.
D. There is no new information of substantial importance, which was not known and could not have been known with the exercise of reasonable diligence at the time MND 21-01 was approved.
TRIBAL CONSULTATION
Government Code §65352.3 requires local governments to contact, refer plans to, and consult with tribal organizations before making a decision to adopt or amend a general or specific plan, or to designate open space that includes Native American Cuilural Places. The tribal organizations eligible to consult have traditional lands in a local government’s jurisdiction, and are identified, upon request, by the Native American Heritage Commission (”NAHC”).
-21-
Staff Report - Housing Element Implementation Project
February 10, 2025
TRIBAL CONSULTATION ~ Continued
The City of Bellflower contacted the NAHC to obtain a list of tribes with cultural and traditional affiliations within the area encompassed by the City of Beltflower. The NAHC identified tribal representatives to be notified of the City‘s proposed General Plan Amendment, TODSP Amendment, Zone Change and Zoning Ordinance Text Amendment. The City sent letters on January 31, 2024 and February 12. 2024. One Tribe (Gabrieleiio Band of Mission indians ~ Kizh Nation) responded within the 90~clay period.
As no site disturbances were associated with the amendments, the Tribe deferred consultation until development projects are received. A 45—day notice of action letters were sent to the Tribes on December 19. 2024. No additional correspondence has been received.
TYPE OF ACTION
The recommended actions constitute a General Plan Amendment ("GPA”) that would amend the Land Use Element CLUE”) by changing the land use .map and text regulating “Mixed Use"; amend the zoning regulations to create an overlay zone for housing opportunities ("zone change” or 'ZC"); and amend regulations for the Downtown Bellflower Transit-Oriented Development Specific Plan (“TODSP“). . For the GPA, the City Council must find that the proposed GPA is in the public interest. '
o For the TODSP. the City Council must make the following findings‘:
A. That the proposed GPA promotes public health. safety, and general welfare, and serves the goals and purposes of the zoning;
8. That the proposed GPA is consistent with the goals, policies, and objectives of the General Plan; and
C. That the GPA wiit not adversely affect surrounding properties. o For the 20, the City Council must find2:
A. The proposed zoning is justified based upon changed conditions;
8. Proposed change of zone will not adversely affect adjoining property as to value or precedent, and will not be detrimental to the area; C. The change of zone will be in the interest or furtherance of public health, safety and general welfare; and
D. The 20 will not adversely affect the City’s zoning regulations as codified in the HMO.
‘BMC § 17.106.070
2BMC. § 17.104.030
-22-
Staff Report -- Housing Element Implementation Project
February 10, 2025
BACKGROUND
6 to Housing Element
The City’s Housing Element includes the requirement to accommodate Bellflower’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation ('RHNA'). Specifically, the City must implement land use regulations that encourage new housing consisting of 3.735 new residential units (1,015 very low-income units; 488 low-income units; 553 moderate income units; and 1,679 above moderate-income units). Among other things, the Housing Element includes 12 areas designated for 'Housing Opportunity” to accommodate the residential units. Four of these are located within the TODSP area: ‘
Table 1 - Housing Opportunity Areas
HOA Location
1 Rosecrans + McNab
2 Clark + Alondra
3 Clark + Park
4 Clark + Artesia
5 Bellflower + Alondra"
6 Belillower + Flora Vsta‘
7 Bellflower +Flower“
8 Bellflower + Ramona
9 Bellflower + Cedar
10 Lakewood +Artesia
11 Bellflower Station'
12 Woodruft' +Flora Vista
" Located within TODSP area
.30 TODSP
The TODSP was adopted in 2019. California law requires internal consistency within the General Plan and, also, between the General Plan and the City‘s zoning regulations.
Accordingly, the TODSP must be amended to be consistent with changes to the Housing Element.
DISCUSSION
The proposed actions are part of the City's overall efforts to implement the Housing Element. This is the first of several proposed actions to amend the BMC. .0 .r General Plan Amendment
The GPA constitutes both a text and map change to the General Plan. The text amendment will revise the General Plan Land Use Element’s "Mixed Use" category to clarify that mixed use areas may allow for residential uses, commercial uses, industrial uses, or a combination thereof within “Mixed Use” areas. The map change will amend the existing General Plan Land Use Map Designations to “MU (Mixed Use)” for certain properties located within 12 specific areas to allow mixed use or residential developments (Attachment A).
-23-
Staff Report - Housing Element Implementation Project
February 10, 2025
DISCUSSION - Continued
~20 TODSP
The TODSP was prepared to provide a critical link between the City’s General Plan. and actual development within the Specific Plan area The Housing Element increased the maximum residential densities allowed for four specified areas within the downtown area and requires expansion of the TODSP boundaries
As proposed. the TODSP would be amended to: divide the TODSP into five different Planning Areas based on varied mixed land uses and development densities and standards. Each of these Planning Areas would replace the existing overlay zones for these areas. These changes will allow the TODSP to continue allowing residential and nonresidential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements (e.g., increased maximum height).
The proposed amendments to the TODSP are:
a Expand the east and south boundaries of the TODSP and add new parcels (approximately 330 acres);
0 Change the Planning Area designations of specified parcels within the TODSP area and within the expanded TODSP areas to the “Downtown Bellflower Transit- Oriented Development Specific Plan";
. Rename the existing overlay zones (BAMU. MUTOZ-A, MUTOZ—B, MUCOZ, BVOZ and BVOZ~N) to “Planning Areas 1 through 5." A summary of the new Planning Areas is included on Subsection 3.2 of Exhibit C of Attachment B. . Eliminate the commercial allowable uses table in all zoning overlays BMC Table
17.48.040 (Town Center District - Allowable Uses) would then regulate the zoning overlays.
e Zone Change
Zone Change Case No; 20 25-01 will establish zoning overlays for certain properties located within eight specific areas to allow mixed use or residential developments (Attachment B). These changes would allow for residential densitks of 30 dwelling units per acre 40 dwelling units per acre, or 100 dwelling units per acre- depending on the location
-24.
Staff Report -- Housing Element Implementation Project
February 10, 2025
DISCUSSION - Continued
0:0 Zone Changes
Approving Zoning Ordinance Text Amendment Case No. ZOTA 25-01 will establish a regulatory framework of future development and uses for certain properties located within the 12. specific areas. including residential developments/uses that are permitted by right The changes address the following categories:
A. TODSP Amendment - to: (a) facilitate and accommodate more residential development in the T008? area to satisfy the City’s RHNA obligation; (b) address the expansion/modification of boundaries. permitted uses, and development regulations; and (c) simplify and improve the readability of the TODSP.
B. Housing Opportunity Overlay Zone (“H002”) — to add a new BMC Chapter to provide standards and incentives (e.g., higher density. reduced development standards) to develop a variety of housing development. Planning Areas A through H will address density; development standards, application requirements and review procedures under new Chapter 17.66 (Attachment 8, Exhibit B).
ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution No..25-09 (GP
8. Ordinance No.
C. Co
ousing Opportunity Area Map
501 and ZOTA 25.01)
14-D
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION: Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM: Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
SUBJECT: Consideration and possible action to approve the Minutes of January 27, 2025, Regular Meeting of the City Council.
DATE: February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
None
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Approve the January 27, 2025, Regular Meeting Minutes; or
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
ATTACHMENT
Minutes of the January 27, 2025, Regular Meeting… ................. ………………………… 2
1 o“ 01: BELLFLO
“ s a
"o ROWING TOGETk‘YFS t f t
MINUTES
CITY OF BELLFLOWER
REGULAR MEETING OF THE BELLFLOWER CITY COUNCIL
MONDAY, JANUARY 27, 2025
BELLFLOWER CITY HALL
5:00 P.M. OUTGOING MAYOR’S CEREMONY – GREEN ROOM
7:00 P.M. OPEN & CLOSED SESSIONS – COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:00 P.M. – OUTGOING MAYOR’S CEREMONY
1 CALL TO ORDER
Mayor Dunton called the Regular Meeting to order at 5:10 p.m. in the Green Room at Bellflower City Hall, 16600 Civic Center Drive, Bellflower.
2 ROLL CALL
For the record, the following Members of the City Council were present:
Mayor Ray Dunton
Mayor Pro Tem Sonny R. Santa Ines
Council Member Dan Koops
Council Member Wendi Morse
Council Member Victor A. Sanchez
3 INVOCATION
Pastor Mosheh Chanan offered the Invocation.
4 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Larry Wehage led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance.
5 PRESENTATIONS TO OUTGOING MAYOR DAN KOOPS
Mayor Dunton detailed the many accomplishments during Dan Koops’s term as Mayor and introduced a video in tribute to him from the City Council Members, professional colleagues, friends, and family.
2 OF BELLFL CS“ 0%
I. (I 0 $- ROMNO Mme
Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 5
January 27, 2025 Page 2 of 16
5 PRESENTATIONS TO OUTGOING MAYOR DAN KOOPS – Continued
In recognition of Dan Koops’s commitment and contributions to the City of Bellflower during his term as the 67th Mayor, 1) Mayor Dunton presented him with a personalized Gavel Plaque that includes the gavel with which he presided over meetings during his year as Mayor; 2) Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines presented him with a framed jersey of baseball hall of famer Dave Winfield, who was the 2024 BRAVO awards Keynote Speaker; 3) Council Member Morse presented him with a scrapbook of photos highlighting the City’s progress and developments during his year as Mayor; and 4) Council Member Sanchez presented him with a Challenge Coin display which included the coin designed to commemorate his year as Mayor.
Daniel Andalon, District Representative for Senator Bob Archuleta, 30th District, thanked Dan Koops for his exemplary leadership and presented him with a certificate of recognition.
Jeff Smith, President, Bellflower Chamber of Commerce , thanked Dan Koops for his support of the Chamber of Commerce and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Captain Dan Holguin, Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, thanked Dan Koops for his great leadership over the last year.
Julia Arce, Field Representative for Congressman Robert Garcia, 42nd District, 1) congratulated Dan Koops for his partnership and leadership; and 2) presented him with a certificate of recognition.
Hector Sosa, Mayor of Downey, and Dorothy Pemberton, Council Member, City of Downey, thanked Dan Koops for his service and presented him with a certificate of recognition.
Lauren Yokomizo, Field Representative for Janice Hahn, County Supervisor, Fourth District, congratulated Dan Koops on all of the hard work accomplished under term as Mayor and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Connie Hui, President, Bellflower Rotary Club, 1) thanked Dan Koops for his dedication and hard work which has impacted the lives of many people; and 2) presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Gabriela Ballesteros, District Director for Assembly Member Jose Solache, 62nd District, 1) thanked Dan Koops for his dedication and impact over the past year; and 2) presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Randy McConnell, Bellflower Family Lions, thanked Dan Koops for his service to the City of Bellflower and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
3 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 5
January 27, 2025 Page 3 of 16
5 PRESENTATIONS TO OUTGOING MAYOR DAN KOOPS – Continued
Jason Barnette, Kiwanis Club of Bellflower, accompanied by club members, 1) congratulated and thanked Dan Koops for giving back to the community; and 2) presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Khoi Dao, Acting Assistant Fire Chief, Los Angeles County Fire Department, 1) thanked and congratulated Dan Koops for his service and support to public safety; and 2) presented him with a certificate of recognition.
Bruce Barrows and Lynda Johnson, Council Members, City of Cerritos, 1) thanked Dan Koops for his service on behalf of Mayor Solanki and the Cerritos City Council; and 2) presented him with a book for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
David Arellano, Council Member, City of Lakewood, expressed his appreciation for Dan Koops as an example of what to strive for as a leader and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Sue Held, President, Bellflower Soroptimist Club, accompanied by club members, 1) acknowledged Dan Koops’s many years of support for the club and his service to the City; and 2) presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Brad Crihfield, Board President, Bellflower Unified School District (BUSD), accompanied by Board Member Renita Armstrong, 1) stated that BUSD appreciates Dan Koops’s partnership and visibility; 2) highlighted that the 605 All-Star Band parade exemplified the collaborative efforts of the City; and 3) presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Mariana Rios, Cerritos College Board of Trustees, Area 4, congratulated Dan Koops on his year as Mayor and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
Sophia Tse, Board Member, ABC Unified School District, 1) thanked and congratulated Dan Koops on his year as Mayor; and 2) remarked upon the success of the 605 All-Star Band parade.
Jenna Enkhorn, President, The Woman’s Club, accompanied by Shirley Meyers of the Friends of the Library, and Eden Escobedo of the Miss Bellflower Program, recognized Dan Koops for his commitment to the City of Bellflower and presented him with multiple books for donation to the Ramona Elementary School Library in his name.
4 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 5
January 27, 2025 Page 4 of 16
5 PRESENTATIONS TO OUTGOING MAYOR DAN KOOPS – Continued
Larry Wehage, Public Safety Commissioner, Bellflower Noon Lions, Bellflower Chamber of Commerce, and Southeast Los Angeles County Workforce Development Board, on behalf of all the entities he represents, acknowledged Dan Koops’s many accomplishments and dedication to the City over the years.
Former Mayor Koops 1) expressed gratitude for the honor of being recognized as the outgoing mayor, reflecting on the privilege of serving in this role and recognizing the importance of having such a strong community backing, thanking the community for their continued support; 2) acknowledged the collaboration of the City Council and emphasized how their collective efforts have made a significant difference in the City's progress; 3) praised City Manager Ryan Smoot for his leadership and the positive changes he has brought to Bellflower, and also recognized Deputy City Manager Travis Sais for his hard work and invaluable role during the transition of the new administration; 4) expressed deep appreciation for the residents of Bellflower, noting that their trust in the City Council has been vital to the City's success, such as the overwhelming support for the charter city initiative which will allow Bellflower to govern itself more independently to benefit the City for years to come; 5) acknowledged the efforts of the Chamber of Commerce and local businesses, celebrating the openings of new businesses, such as Best Buy Outlet and Cold Stone Creamery; and 6) expressed his heartfelt gratitude to his wife of 50 years, Judy, for her unwavering support and encouragement throughout his tenure as Mayor, expressing that her belief in him and constant support has been crucial to his ability to serve the City.
Recess: Without objection, Mayor Dunton recessed the meeting at 6:18 p.m., noting that the meeting would reconvene at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers to conduct the business portion of the meeting.
7:00 P.M. – OPEN SESSION & CLOSED SESSION
6 RECONVENE TO OPEN SESSION
Mayor Dunton reconvened the meeting at 7:06 p.m. in the Council Chambers at Bellflower City Hall, 16600 Civic Center Drive, Bellflower.
The following Members of the City Council responded present to roll call:
Mayor Ray Dunton
Mayor Pro Tem Sonny R. Santa Ines
Council Member Dan Koops
Council Member Wendi Morse
Council Member Victor A. Sanchez
5 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 6
January 27, 2025 Page 5 of 16
6 RECONVENE TO OPEN SESSION – Continued
Staff Participants:
Ryan Smoot, City Manager
Karl H. Berger, City Attorney
Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
Assistant City Attorney Timothy E. Campen
Len Gorecki, Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Jim DellaLonga, Director of Economic Development
Tae Rhee, Director of Finance
Travis Sais, Deputy City Manager
Jennifer Russell, Management Assistant
7-A CITY COUNCIL ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mayor Dunton provided details relative to the Bellflower Symphony Orchestra’s upcoming winter concert to be held on February 1, 2025, at the William and Jane Bristol Auditorium.
Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines provided details relative to the CR&R’s free compost giveaway to be held on February 22, 2025, at the Public Works Yard while supplies last.
Council Member Koops provided details relative to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development Block Grant Program survey which is available until February 7, 2025.
Council Member Morse provided details relative to the “Maker to Market” six-week course for local product-based merchants to be held on February 24, 2025, through March 31, 2025.
Council Member Sanchez provided details relative to the Chamber of Commerce’s next monthly morning mingle to be held on January 28, 2025.
7-B PRESENTATION: CERTIFICATE OF RECOGNITION TO FORMER CITY
ENGINEER JERRY STOCK
For the record, Former City Engineer Jerry Stock was unable to attend the meeting and the presentation was deferred to the next City Council Meeting.
8 PUBLIC COMMENTS
Cheryl Williams, resident, inquired about the status of the internet service in the City and requested any available information from the City to share with her neighbors regarding this issue.
6 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 8
January 27, 2025 Page 6 of 16
8 PUBLIC COMMENTS
At the request of City Manager Smoot, Director of Economic Development DellaLonga provided an update on the “Bellflower Connect” Program, stating that phase one of distributing modems is currently underway, with the goal of expanding to all four phases by summer as more towers are implemented in the City.
9 PUBLIC HEARINGS
None
10 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION
A Consideration and possible action to 1) read by title only, waive further reading, and adopt Urgency Ordinance No. 1438; and 2) read by title only, waive further reading, and introduce Ordinance No. 1439 – An Ordinance amending Bellflower Municipal Code Chapter 15.40 and reaffirming the City Council’s determination that the City comply with regulations promulgated by the State of California to protect public health, safety and from the devastation of uncontrolled fire incidents.
B Consideration and possible action to authorize Legislative Subpoenas be served on the Consolidated Fire Protection District of Los Angeles; and adopt Resolution No. 25-03 – A Resolution authorizing the City Clerk to issue legislative subpoenas for the purpose of determining the City Council’s legal authority to adopt the California Fire Code (Code of California Regulations, Title 24, Part 9) and authorizing the Building Official to review building plans in accordance with California Building Standards § 105.4 (Code of California Regulations, Title 24, Parts 1 and 2).
City Manager Smoot introduced the matter and asked if the City Council would like to consider Items 10-A and 10-B together as they are related. It was the consensus of the City Council to consider Items 10-A and 10-B be together.
City Attorney Berger 1) provided a verbal presentation of the Staff Report; and 2) along with City Manager Smoot, responded to Council Members’ questions.
Following brief discussion, it was moved by Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, seconded by Council Member Koops, and unanimously carried by the following roll call vote, to adopt Urgency Ordinance No. 1438 upon 4/5ths vote; read by title only, waive further reading, and introduce Ordinance No. 1439; and adopt Resolution No. 25-03:
AYES: Council Members - Morse, Sanchez, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
7 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 10-C
January 27, 2025 Page 7 of 16
10 ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION – Continued
C Consideration and possible action to 1) read by title only, waive further reading, and adopt Urgency Ordinance No. 1440; and 2) read by title only, waive further reading, and introduce Ordinance No. 1441 – An Ordinance amending Chapter 3.30 to Title 3 of the Bellflower Municipal Code entitled “Public Works Contracts” in its entirety.
City Manager Smoot introduced the item.
Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Gorecki 1) provided a verbal presentation of the Staff Report; and 2) along with City Attorney Berger and City Manager Smoot, responded to Council Members’ questions.
At the request of Council Member Sanchez, City Attorney Berger 1) explained that the charter, upon adoption, identified "classic" Public Works projects (such as streets, sidewalks, gutters, and buildings) as requiring prevailing wage; 2) clarified that the Department of Industrial Relations in California has classified other projects, such as economic development opportunities, as public projects subject to prevailing wage; and 3) noted that these regulations would specifically exclude economic development and business opportunities from prevailing wage requirements, and similarly, nuisance abatement projects, which involve fronting costs that are later reimbursed by property owners.
Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines 1) stated that during the charter discussion in the last election, a common question he received was about the benefits to the City, to which he used the example of grant funding through the Business Assistance Program; 2) provided the example of one grantee who took six months to find a contractor to accept the $10,000 contract due to the fact that contractors typically bid on larger projects and need to register with the state and Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), noting that prevailing wage requirements increase the costs by approximately 35%; and 3) thanked staff for bringing the ordinance forward, emphasizing that it aligns with the federal or state level in terms of implementing the city charter, and expressed anticipation for more ordinances to follow as the City continues to implement the charter.
Following discussion, it was moved by Council Member Koops, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, and unanimously carried by the following roll call vote, to 1) adopt Urgency Ordinance No. 1440 upon 4/5ths vote; and 2) read by title only, waive further reading, and introduce Ordinance No. 1441:
AYES: Council Members - Morse, Sanchez, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
8 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-A
January 27, 2025 Page 8 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS
A Consideration and possible action to approve salary and benefit adjustments for City Manager and City Clerk positions.
For the City Manager, the proposed adjustment for calendar year 2025 would increase salary by $10,569 for a total salary of $281,569 annually. The proposed adjustment will increase taxes and benefits by approximately $2,690.
For the City Clerk, the proposed adjustment for calendar year 2025 would increase salary by $5,463 for a total salary of $145,547 annually. The proposed adjustment will increase taxes and benefits by approximately $3,392.
City Attorney Berger 1) introduced the item and provided a brief verbal report of the Staff Report; and 2) along with Director of Finance Rhee, responded to Council Members’ questions.
For the record, City Attorney Berger, 1) clarified that the City Council had previously been provided with calculations based on a 3.4% increase, which was an error, and that it should have been a 3.9% increase; and 2) confirmed that the numbers in the current staff report reflect the corrected 3.9% increase.
Council Member Sanchez expressed his gratitude to City Manager Smoot and City Clerk Ochiqui, stating that the City Council is glad to have them, and he is pleased that the contracts would be renewed and extended.
For the record, Mayor Dunton 1) explained that the City Council reviewed and interviewed both the City Manager and City Clerk in closed session to evaluate their progress over the past year; 2) emphasized that the decision was not taken lightly, considering the workload, expectations for the future, and the salary survey results from other cities; 3) noted that the goal is to keep Bellflower competitive with other cities by adjusting salaries as needed, ensuring that the City retains a strong team and does not lose employees over salary o r benefits.
Following brief discussion, it was moved by Council Member Koops, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, and carried by the following roll call vote to 1) authorize the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 1 to the City Manager Employment Agreement (AFN 1020), in a form approved by the City Attorney; and 2) authorize the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 6 to the City Clerk’s Employment Agreement (AFN 686), in a form approved by the City Attorney:
AYES: Council Members - Morse, Sanchez, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
9 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-B
January 27, 2025 Page 9 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS – Continued
B Consideration and possible action to provide direction to the City Manager regarding the Designated Block Downtown Façade Improvement project for the storefronts located at northwest corner of Bellflower Boulevard and Oak Street, adjacent to the Edgeway Downtown Bellflower mixed-use project, and adopt Resolution No. 25-05 – A Resolution adopted pursuant to Sections II and VII(C) of the Bellflower City Charter finding that the use of and distribution of economic development funds to business and/or property owners pursuant to the Business Assistance Plan does not constitute a public subsidy requiring payment of prevailing wage in accordance with Labor Code § 1720.
For the record, Council Member Morse 1) announced that she would recuse herself from this item due to a conflict of interest, as her employer owns property within 500 feet of the subject property; and 2) left the dais and Council Chambers at 7:44 p.m.
City Manager Smoot introduced the item.
Director of Economic Development DellaLonga 1) provided a PowerPoint presentation of the Staff Report; and 2) responded to Council Members’ questions along with Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Gorecki, City Attorney Berger, and City Manager Smoot.
At the request of Mayor Dunton and Council Member Sanchez, Director DellaLonga and Assistant City Manager/Director Gorecki 1) explained that there were no bids received when the solicitation for bids was initially released, so they reached out to two contractors who had experience with similar work and received two bids for $600,000 and $680,000; 2) stated that they decided to follow up with the lower bidder to request updated pricing based on non-prevailing wage conditions; 3) clarified that this pricing only covers construction costs and does not include construction management, which is typically about 20% of the total project cost and is handled by a third-party management team contracted by the City; and 4) mentioned that this approach helped re-establish the budget for the project.
For the record, in response to project management costs, 1) Council Member Sanchez suggested the City hire a project manager position; 2) Mayor Dunton agreed with Council Member Sanchez’s suggestion, but noted that perhaps that was a separate discussion for future consideration; 3) Assistant City Manager/Director Gorecki stated that for a project of this scale, a project manager dedicated solely to that particular project would be in the City’s best interest, versus an employee with additional duties; and 4 ) City Manager Smoot confirmed that staff would explore hiring a project manager position to oversee City projects on an ongoing basis versus by-contract and as-needed.
10 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-B
January 27, 2025 Page 10 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS – Continued
B Consideration and possible action to provide direction to the City Manager regarding the Designated Block Downtown Façade Improvement project for the storefronts located at northwest corner of Bellflower Boulevard and Oak Street, adjacent to the Edgeway Downtown Bellflower mixed-use project, and adopt Resolution No. 25-05 – Continued
Council Member Koops, 1) expressed that he was initially enthusiastic about the project when it was $175,000, but his enthusiasm has waned significantly as he no longer remembers what the project entails; 2) clarified with staff that the proposed renovations involve glass fronts, new stucco, and some form of façade across the front of the building; 3) expressed the opinion that spending $850,000 on buildings the City does not own is excessive, especially for aesthetic changes; and 4) requested and received clarification from staff relative to the source of the funding for the project.
At the request of Council Member Koops, City Manager Smoot explained that 1) there is a provision in the development agreement for liquidated damages if the developer does not secure an entertainment use within a specific time frame; and 2) this provision would apply once the developer received the certificate of occupancy with a deadline for securing the entertainment use one year after the permit issuance, noting that they are currently in the middle of that time period.
For the record, 1) at the request of Mayor Dunton, Director DellaLonga provided an artist rendering of the proposed changes to the properties; and 2) Council Member Koops reiterated that he didn’t believe the cosmetic enhancements warranted the City spending $850,000, suggesting painting the buildings and replacement of the awnings could be done at much lesser cost.
Council Member Sanchez 1) pointed out that the difference between the prevailing wage bids and the others without is minimal at only about 0.9% difference and, for such a small difference, he would choose to go with prevailing wage; 2) agree d with Council Member Koops, expressing the opinion that $850,000 for the project is excessive; 3) compared the cost to building ADUs, which can be done for half that price; and 4) stated that while he was initially open to the project at $175,000, he no longer feels comfortable with the $850,000 price, regardless of it being a not-to-exceed amount.
At the request of Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, Director DellaLonga 1) explained that it took a long time to secure the necessary easements before the work could begin on the front of the buildings, which was required prior to the adoption of the charter; and 2) emphasized that the easement acquisition was the biggest time -consuming factor and resulted in the overall delay of the project.
11 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-B
January 27, 2025 Page 11 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS – Continued
B Consideration and possible action to provide direction to the City Manager regarding the Designated Block Downtown Façade Improvement project for the storefronts located at northwest corner of Bellflower Boulevard and Oak Street, adjacent to the Edgeway Downtown Bellflower mixed-use project, and adopt Resolution No. 25-05 – Continued
Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, 1) requested and received confirmation from City Attorney Berger that the City has no obligation to continue with the project and if the City abandons the easements, they would simply revert back to the private property owners; and 2) expressed disbelief at the significant increase in cost from $175,000 to $850,000.
For the record, Mayor Dunton suggested the City Council table the project and recommended staff explore “value engineering”, “value planning”, more cost-effective options, and other funding sources such as Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funding.
For the record, Council Member Sanchez recommended staff explore the “Compton Initiative” as an option to engage the community for this project through the use of the City’s Volunteer Center.
Following lengthy discussion, and without objection, it was the consensus of the City Council to refer the matter back to staff to 1) reconsider this project looking at “value planning”; 2) explore the “Compton Initiative” and utilizing the Volunteer Center to coordinate a community effort; 3) obtain a bid for painting of the facades and replacing the awnings only (no structural changes); and 4) explore other funding sources such as CDBG funds.
In response to Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines’s questions relative to the easements that were processed for this property, City Attorney Berger advised that it may be legally wiser to abandon the easements which had to be done because the City was a general law city, noting that this will require staff to re-evaluate the matter based upon the charter.
Following discussion, it was moved by Mayor Dunton, seconded by Council Member Koops, and carried by the following roll call vote to adopt Resolution No. 25-05:
AYES: Council Members - Sanchez, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
RECUSE: Council Members - Morse
For the record, Council Member Morse returned to the Council Chambers and dais at 8:19 p.m.
12 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-C
January 27, 2025 Page 12 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS – Continued
C Consideration and possible action to award contracts to Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc. and California Landscape and Design Inc., for the remediation of the nuisance abatement that exists at 17046 Bellflower Boulevard; and authorize the City Manager to execute individual contracts with Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc. and California Landscape and Design Inc., in forms approved by the City Attorney.
For the record, 1) City Manager Smoot introduced the item; 2) Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Gorecki provided a PowerPoint presentation of the Staff Report, and along with City Manager Smoot and Assistant City Attorney Campen, responded to Council Members’ questions; and 3) supplemental material was distributed to the City Council and made available to the public prior to the start of the meeting.
At the request of Council Member Morse, Assistant City Attorney Campen clarified that ironically, properties that are easily accessible attract less trespassers than properties where people can hide behind structures, noting that a letter of agency can also be used.
For the record, Council Member Sanchez 1) emphasized that there is a cost recovery process for all abatement costs, including staff time and all necessary work to address the public nuisance; 2) stated that he disagreed with the language suggesting that prevailing wage is not needed for the project and believes it should be required when performing this type of work, especially related to public nuisance issues; and 3) stated that he would be comfortable supporting the project given that the bids meet the prevailing wage requirement.
In response to comments from Council Member Sanchez relative to prevailing wage, 1) Assistant City Manager/Director Gorecki referenced the staff report, pointing out that the last section indicates that if work is being done under an emergency order for abatement, it could be deemed as non -prevailing wage; and 2) Mayor Dunton disagreed that this project should be completed with prevailing wage, as it is no longer required.
Following lengthy discussion, it was moved by Mayor Dunton, seconded by Council Member Koops to 1) direct staff to proceed as follows: move forward with the “base bid costs” (including the fence and demolition of the building) and “Alternative No. 1” pricing which would also include the additional work to create the 5-foot band around the perimeter (not including the asphalt on the east side); 2) award a contract to Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc., for the project and authorize the City Manager to execute said contract , in a form approved by the City Attorney, without prevailing wage rates; and 3) award a contract to Integrated California Landscape and Design, Inc., for the project and authorize the City Manager to execute said contract, in a form approved by the City Attorney, without prevailing wage rates. For the record, the vote was taken following additional discussion.
13 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 11-C
January 27, 2025 Page 13 of 16
11 CONSIDERATION ITEMS – Continued
C Consideration and possible action to award contracts to Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc. and California Landscape and Design Inc., for the remediation of the nuisance abatement that exists at 17046 Bellflower Boulevard; and authorize the City Manager to execute individual contracts with Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc. and California Landscape and Design Inc., in forms approved by the City Attorney.
For the record, 1) Council Member Sanchez requested the language on page 4 of the staff report be stricken from the motion: “Following the approval of the amendment to the BMC, staff will reach out to the individual contractors and request pricing adjustments based on the amended BMC language”, noting that the bids came in at prevailing wage and he was hopeful that it could be kept that way; 2) Mayor Dunton stated that he is against utilizing prevailing wage for this project; 3) City Manager Smoot clarified that with the adoption of Urgency Ordinance No. 1440 earlier in the meeting, a project of this nature is no longer subject to prevailing wage, although the City Council maintains the option make it subject to prevailing wage; 4) Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines and Council Member Koops stated that they are also in support of moving forward with the project without using prevailing wage; and 5) at the request of Council Member Morse, Assistant City Manager/Director Gorecki clarified that the prices in the staff report include prevailing wage rates, but he would go back to the contractors and ask for revised cost estimates based on non-prevailing wage rates, as this project would no longer be subject to prevailing wage following the adoption of Urgency Ordinance No. 1440.
Following additional discussion, Mayor Dunton reaffirmed his previous motion, Council Member Koops reaffirmed his second of the motion, and it carried by the following roll call vote to 1) direct staff to proceed as follows: move forward with the “base bid costs” (including the fence and demolition of the building) and “Alternative No. 1” pricing which would also include the additional work to create the 5-foot band around the perimeter (not including the asphalt on the east side); 2) award a contract to Integrated Demolition and Remediation Inc., for the project and authorize the City Manager to execute said contract , in a form approved by the City Attorney, without prevailing wage rates; and 3) award a contract to Integrated California Landscape and Design, Inc., for the project and authorize the City Manager to execute said contract, in a form approved by the City Attorney, without prevailing wage rates:
AYES: Council Members - Morse, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
NOES: Council Members - Sanchez
14 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 12
January 27, 2025 Page 14 of 16
12 CONSENT CALENDAR
It was moved by Council Member Koops, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, and carried by the following roll call vote, to approve the actions stipulated on the Consent Calendar:
AYES: Council Members - Morse, Sanchez, Santa Ines, Koops and Mayor Dunton
A Consideration and possible action to receive and file City Council Warrant Register No. 25-072, dated January 27, 2025.
Action: Received and filed Warrant Register No. 25-072.
B Consideration and possible action to receive and file City Council Treasurer’s Report for the Month of December 2024.
Action: Received and filed the Treasurer’s Report.
C Consideration and possible action to adopt Resolution No. 25-04 – A Resolution authorizing the recording of a Notice of Special Assessment for Nuisance Abatement against the owner of 9070 Artesia Boulevard (APN 7162-011-011).
Action: Adopted Resolution No. 25-04 to authorize the recording of a notice of special assessment for nuisance abatement on the owner of 9070 Artesia Boulevard.
D Consideration and possible action to waive further reading and adopt Ordinance No. 1437 – An Ordinance adding a new Section 2.28.050 to the Bellflower Municipal Code regulating uncontested municipal elections.
Action: Waived further reading and adopted Ordinance No. 1437.
E Consideration and possible action to ratify Mayor Ray Dunton’s appointment of Guy Bremer to the Planning Commission.
Action: Ratified Mayor Ray Dunton’s appointment of Guy Bremer to fill the unexpired term on the Planning Commission ending December 2026 .
F Consideration and possible action to adopt Resolution No. 25-06 – A Resolution adjusting salary and employment categories within the City Manager’s Department (Exhibit A), effective February 1, 2025.
Action: Adopted Resolution No. 25-06, approving the attached personnel and salary plan adjustments and authorizing the City Manager to implement the Plan as appropriate.
G Consideration and possible action to approve the Minutes of the December 12, 2024, Special Meeting of the City Council.
Action: Approved the December 12, 2024, Special Meeting Minutes.
15 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 13
January 27, 2025 Page 15 of 16
13 COUNCIL REPORTS
Council Member Sanchez, Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines, Council Member Koops and Mayor Dunton made various comments and reports.
Without objection, Mayor Pro Tem Santa Ines requested the meeting be adjourned in memory of Deacon Rafael “Ralph” Riera.
14 RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION
For the record, City Manager Smoot introduced the title of the Closed Session item.
There being no one from the public wishing to speak on Closed Session, without objection, Mayor Dunton recessed the Meeting at 9:07 p.m. to a Closed Session regarding:
A CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL – EXISTING LITIGATION - GOVERNMENT CODE § 54956.9(d)(1). Number of Cases: Two.
1. City of Bellflower v. 20434 South Santa Fe Ave., LLC (filed April 2, 2024) LASC Case No. 24NWCV01017.
2. City of Bellflower, et al. v. 17450 Bellflower Blvd., LLC; LASC Case No. 23NWCV03574.
For the record, 1) Council Member Koops recused on Item 14-A.1, as he owns property within 500 feet of the subject property; 2) Mayor Dunton and Council Member Morse recused on Item 14-A.2, as they have property conflicts within 500 feet of the subject property; and 3) Closed Session adjourned at 10:01 p.m.
15 RECONVENE TO OPEN SESSION
Mayor Dunton reconvened the Meeting at 10:02 p.m., with Council Member Koops absent, and announced that no reportable action was taken during Closed Session.
16 Bellflower City Council Minutes Item No. 16
January 27, 2025 Page 16 of 16
16 ADJOURNMENT
Without objection, Mayor Dunton adjourned the meeting at 10:02 p.m., in memory of Deacon Rafael “Ralph” Riera, to the next Regular Meeting of the Bellflower City Council at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, February 10, 2025.
Ray Dunton, Mayor
City of Bellflower
Attest:
Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
Approved: February 24, 2025
17 14-E
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION: Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM: Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
SUBJECT: Consideration and possible action to approve the Minutes of February 10, 2025, Joint Special Meeting of the City Council.
DATE: February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
None
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Approve the February 10, 2025, Joint Special Meeting Minutes; or
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
ATTACHMENT
Minutes of the February 10, 2025, Joint Special Meeting… ........ ………………………… 2
o“ 01: BELLFLO
“ s a
"o ROWING TOGETk‘YFS t f t
0E BELLFLO off“ IVER
0 v- ROWING TooE'V‘fl
«5 stafteport
MINUTES
CITY OF BELLFLOWER
SPECIAL JOINT MEETING OF THE
BELLFLOWER CITY COUNCIL,
BELLFLOWER FINANCING AUTHORITY,
BELLFLOWER PARKING AUTHORITY,
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION, AND
PLANNING COMMISSION
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2025, 3:00 – 5:00 P.M.
BELLFLOWER CITY HALL – COUNCIL CHAMBERS
1 Call to Order
Mayor Dunton called the Special Joint Meeting to order at 3:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers at Bellflower City Hall, 16600 Civic Center Drive, Bellflower.
2 Roll Call
For the record, the following members were present:
City Council; Bellflower Financing Authority; and
Bellflower Parking Authority
Mayor/Chair Ray Dunton
Mayor Pro Tem/Vice Chair Sonny R. Santa Ines
Council Member/Director Dan Koops
Council Member/Director Wendi Morse
Council Member/Director Victor A. Sanchez
Parks and Recreation Commission
Chair Gerrit J. Byma
Vice Chair Mitch Haack
Commissioner Sophia Partida
Planning Commission
Chair Robert Wilson
Vice Chair Christina Padilla Birkey
Commissioner Guy Bremer
Commissioner Bill Mendes
Commissioner Mariah Mott
OF BELLFL CS“ 0%
I. (I o $- ROMNO Mme
Special Joint Meeting Minutes Item No. 2 February 10, 2025 Page 2 of 4
2 Roll Call – Continued
Public Safety Commission (No Quorum)
Chair Larry Myers
Commissioner Larry Wehage
Staff Participants
Ryan Smoot, City Manager
Karl H. Berger, City Attorney
Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
Len Gorecki, Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Wangsu Lee, Interim Senior Management Analyst
Jennifer Russell, Management Assistant
Dakota Wallace, Management Assistant
Jim DellaLonga, Director of Economic Development
Karla Pineda, Management Analyst II
Annika Miyashiro-Ruiz, Senior Marketing Specialist
Anna Garan, Finance Manager
P.J. Mellana, Director of Parks and Recreation
Kristen Smith, Parks & Recreation Manager
Sergiu Todorov, IT Manager
Elizabeth Oba, Director of Planning and Building Services Rowena Genilo-Concepcion, Planning Manager
James Atkins, Senior Planner
Kathryn Brun, Assistant Planner
Jaliza Reynaga, Assistant Planner
Alan Cook, Consultant, Building Official
Ali Alvandi, Consultant, Building Division
Vanessa Alcaraz, Consultant, Building Division
Virginia Castillo Carrillo, Consultant, Building Division Walter Jones, Consultant, Building Division
Brian McNerney, Director of Public Safety
Joseph Chacon, Code Enforcement Inspector I
Sarah Ho, Public Works Manager
Kimberly Gonzalez, Public Works Coordinator
Steve Gose, Public Works Division Head - Facilities
Frank Preciado, Public Works Division Head – Inspection
Presenter – Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP
Justin A. Tamayo, Assistant City Attorney
Special Joint Meeting Minutes Item No. 2 February 10, 2025 Page 3 of 4
2 Roll Call – Continued
For the record, the following commissioners and staff participants were absent and will complete the required Ethics Training online:
Parks and Recreation Commission Margaret Romero
Parks and Recreation Commissioner Michele Worley
Public Safety Commissioner Rocio Jimenez-Sanchez
Public Safety Commissioner Marcos Garcia
Veronica Yates, Management Analyst I
Maria Porras, Management Assistant
Tae G. Rhee, Director of Finance/City Treasurer
Mazen Dudar, Consultant, Building Division
David Fawcett, Code Enforcement Supervisor
Richard Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Inspector I
William Zamora, Code Enforcement Inspector I
Esmeralda Erdelyan, Code Enforcement Inspector I
Melanie Paz, Management Analyst II
Elias Garcia, Assistant City Engineer
Leroy Baca, Public Works Division Head - Streets
3 Public Comments
There were no members of the public in attendance.
4 Local Government Ethics Training in compliance with AB 1234 for elected and appointed public officials and city management employees. The training will be conducted by Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP, the City’s legal counsel. Public participation in the training will not be allowed.
For the record, copies of the PowerPoint handout (“AB 1234 Ethics Training”) and Reference Manual (“Ethics Laws and Principles”) were provided to meeting participants and made available to the Public.
Mayor Dunton introduced Assistant City Attorney Tamayo as the training session’s presenter.
Assistant City Attorney Tamayo gave a PowerPoint slide presentation, discussed and provided examples, case studies, best practices, penalties and/or consequences of violations with regard to laws regarding personal financial gain, laws relating to claiming the perquisite of office, gov ernment transparency laws, and laws relating to fair process.
Special Joint Meeting Minutes Item No. 5 February 10, 2025 Page 4 of 4
5 Adjournment
Without objection, Mayor Dunton adjourned the Special Joint Meeting at 5:00 p.m.
BELLFLOWER CITY COUNCIL ATTEST:
BELLFLOWER FINANCING AUTHORITY
BELLFLOWER PARKING AUTHORITY
Ray Dunton, Mayor/Chair Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk/Secretary
PLANNING COMMISSION ATTEST:
Robert Wilson, Chair Elizabeth Oba, Director of
Planning and Building Services
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION ATTEST:
Gerrit J. Byma, Chair P. J. Mellana, Director of Parks and Recreation
14-F
TO:Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION:Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM:Len Gorecki, Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works Elias Garcia, City Engineer
SUBJECT:Consideration and possible action to authorize the Director of Public Works, or designee, to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to 4-way ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale Street at Cornuta Avenue and to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ control on Arthurdale Street at Ocana Avenue.
DATE:February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This action would approve and authorize the conversion of the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to 4-way ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale Street at Cornuta Avenue and the conversion of the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ control on Arthurdale Street at Ocana Avenue pursuant to Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”) Chapter 10.04.
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Authorize the Director of Public Works, or designee, to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to 4-way ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale Street at Cornuta Avenue; and 2) Convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ control on Arthurdale Street at Ocana Avenue; or
3) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
The estimated cost to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to 4-way ‘Stop’ controls is $2,500; and to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ controls is $1,500. Funds are budgeted in Account No. 010-43170-3100 (Street Maintenance Traffic Paint) and 010-43180-3100 (Street Maintenance Street Signs). -1-
0F BELLFLOI’Vs-Q
*9 Stafi'eport
Staff Report – Conversion of Existing ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale St. at Cornuta Ave. and Existing ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale St. at Ocana Ave.
February 24, 2025
DISCUSSION
As part of the City’s on-going collaboration with the neighborhood watch group in this area, a request was made for the City to consider modifying the existing stop control measures to improve traffic management and increase pedestrian safety. Specifically, the request is to install additional ‘Stop’ controls at the intersection of Arthurdale Street at Cornuta Avenue which will convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ into a 4-way (all directions) ‘Stop’. Currently, only the north and southbound approaches on Cornuta Avenue are ‘Stop’ controlled. Based upon the Traffic Engineer’s assessment of this request, staff determined that this intersection meets the criteria for conversion from the existing 2-way to 4-way ‘Stop’ controls.
The guidelines for ‘Stop’ control installations are contained within the California Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (CA MUTCD). The guidelines state that ‘Stop’ signs should be used on a less important road (minor street) that intersects with a main road because the application of the normal vehicle right-of-way rule would not be expected to provide reasonable compliance with the law. For the intersections under consideration, when the characteristics of intersecting streets are similar (both considered minor streets), both streets are in a residential neighborhood, both streets are between thirty (30) and forty (40) feet in width, and to assign right-of-way more clearly, the conversion from a 2-way ‘Stop’ to a 4-way ‘Stop’ does not require an extensive and detailed traffic engineering study.
The field assessment performed by the City Engineer confirmed that conditions, such as limited driver line-of-sight, do exist at the proposed intersection. It was also determined that the T-intersection of Arthurdale Street at Ocana Avenue, which is approximately 200 feet west of the Arthurdale/Cornuta intersection, should also be re-configured from the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls (east and west) to a 1-way ‘Stop’ control for northbound traffic on Ocana Avenue. As a result of these findings, staff proposes to install ‘Stop’ controls (stop signs, limit lines and ‘STOP’ pavement legends) as described for both locations. The proposed changes are illustrated in the attached aerial photograph.
On February 4, 2025, Public Works staff noticed the residents within the area of these intersections that this matter would be brought before the Public Safety Commission at its February 18, 2025, meeting. The City Engineer presented the request at this meeting and the Public Safety Commission recommended that the request to convert the existing ‘Stop’ controls at both intersections be forwarded to the City Council for approval. There were no members of the public in attendance at the Public Safety Commission meeting that offered either support or opposition to the item.
ATTACHMENTS
Aerial Photo ......................................................................................................................... 3 Street View Photo................................................................................................................ 4 Notification Letter to Residents ........................................................................................... 5 -2-
Printed 2/4/2025
City of Bellflower
Scale: 1 in = 50 ft
Convert Existing 2-way Stop Controls to 4-way Stop Controls on Arthurdale St. at Cornuta Ave.
Convert Existing 2-way Stop Controls to a 1-way Stop Control on Arthurdale St. at Ocana Ave.-3-
{(1 GE BELLFLOWG
C
Iamfin Jim-\Im‘flrl. fumrrt.
”0&0 WING 1005‘»;
G) > d
In In! 3
C I- O U
Conversion of Existing 2-way ‘Stop’ Controls to 4-way ‘Stop Controls’ Arthurdale Street at Cornuta Avenue
Conversion of Existing 2-way ‘Stop’ Controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ Control Arthurdale Street at Ocana Avenue
REMOVE ‘STOP’
CONTROL
REMOVE ‘STOP’
CONTROL
ADD ‘STOP’
CONTROL
ADD ‘STOP’
CONTROL
ADD ‘STOP’
CONTROL
-5-
' . of 331.1% The Clty of Bellflower 5‘“ “he
gamifies. ~flusinesxres. gu/ures. #
16600 Civic Center Drive, Bellflower, CA90706 I i ’ - h F Tel 562.804.1424 Fax 562.925.8660 www.bellflower.org 9&0m M February 4, 2025
SUBJECT: Notification of Pending Changes:
0 Conversion of Existing 2-way ‘Stop’ Controls to 4-way ‘Stop’ Controls on Arthurdale St. at Cornuta Ave.
0 Conversion of Existing 2-way ‘Stop’ Controls to a 1-way ‘Stop’ control on Arthurdale St. at Ocana Ave. '
Dear Resident/Property Owner:
This letter is to inform you of the proposed changes described below.
The City is proposing to convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to 4—way ‘Stop’ controls on Arthurdale St. at Cornuta Ave. and convert the existing 2-way ‘Stop’ controls to a 1- way ‘Stop’ control on Arthurdale St. at Ocana Ave. The proposed changes are illustrated in the attached aerial photograph.
This item will be disCussed at the City of Bellflower’s Public Safety Commission meeting on Tuesday, February 18, 2025. The meeting will be held at Bellflower City Hall in the City Council Chambers located at 16600 Civic Center Drive. The meeting will start at 7:00 pm.
You are welcome to make your concerns known to the City by contacting Elias Garcia, Interim City Engineer at (562) 804—1424, ext. 2283 prior to February 18, 2025, or by presenting them at the February 18th Public Safety Commission meeting. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
Sincerely,
en Gorecki
Asst. City Manager/Director of Public Works
Enclosure: Aerial Photograph
Ray Dnnton Sonny R. Santa Ines Dan Koops Wendi Morse Victor A. Sanchez Mayor Mayor Pro Tem Council Member Council M ember Council Member
14-G
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION: Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM: Brian McNerney, Director of Public Safety
SUBJECT: Consideration and possible action to adopt Resolution No. 25-10 – A Resolution memorializing parking lot modifications at various City-owned or controlled parking lots made by the City Manager in accordance with Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”) Chapter 10.12, and superseding Resolution No. 21-63.
DATE: February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under the authority granted to the City Manager by BMC Chapter 10.12, modifications have been made to various City-owned or controlled parking lots. Parking lots affected include Lot 1, Lot 2, Lot 3, Lot 17, and the parking structure (Lot 19).
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Adopt Resolution No. 25-10, memorializing parking lot modifications at various City- owned or controlled parking lots made by the City Manager and superseding Resolution No. 21-63, or;
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
The estimated cost to install new signage is approximately $800. Funds are budgeted in Account No. 010-43180-3100 (Street Maintenance Street Signs).
DISCUSSION
Pursuant to BMC Chapter 10.12 the City Manager can designate parking regulations in various City-owned or controlled parking lots. Modifications were made to the following lots:
• Lots 1, 2, and 3: Two-hour parking from 1 p.m. – 10 p.m., except Sundays.
1 11 of BELLFLD “P
a“!- stafteport o “OWNED mflfifiw”
6'5“ 0-,: BELLFLDWEQ
fl} $1ia‘fi'eport
Staff Report – Resolution No. 25-XX - Parking Restrictions at City-owned and Controlled Parking Lots
February 24, 2025
DISCUSSION – Continued
• Lot 17:
o The gated parking lot (former MPower lot) containing 16 spaces, two-hour parking from 7 a.m. – 6 p.m., except Sundays and no parking on Wednesday mornings, midnight – 6 a.m. and 72-hour restrictions. o Twelve parking spaces along the northern most fence line, two-hour parking from 7 a.m. – 6 p.m., except Sundays and no parking on Wednesday mornings, midnight – 6 a.m. and 72-hour restrictions.
• Parking Structure (Lot 19): No parking daily, midnight – 6 a.m., vehicles subject to tow-away if in violation.
ATTACHMENTS
Resolution No. 25-10....................................................................................................... 3 Aerial Map of Lots 1,2, and 3 (Downtown lots) ................................................................ 7 Aerial Map of Lot 17 (Former MPower lot) ...................................................................... 8 2 CITY OF BELLFLOWER
RESOLUTION NO. 25-10
A RESOLUTION MEMORIALIZING PARKING LOT MODIFICATIONS AT
VARIOUS CITY-OWNED OR CONTROLLED PARKING LOTS MADE BY
THE CITY MANAGER IN ACCORDANCE WITH BELLFLOWER
MUNICIPAL CODE (“BMC”) CHAPTER 10.12, AND SUPERSEDING
RESOLUTION NO. 21-63
THE CITY COUNCIL RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. Action. The City Council takes the following actions:
A. Parking restrictions for vehicles in parking lots owned or controlled by the City are set forth in attached Exhibit “A”, which is incorporated by reference;
B. The City Manager, or designee, is authorized to implement these restrictions in accordance with the Bellflower Municipal Code and other applicable law;
C Except as set forth in the attached Exhibit A, which is incorporated by reference, all other City owned or controlled parking lots are subject to the time limits set forth in BMC section 10.12.020.
D. To the extent that Resolution No. 21-63 (adopted November 8, 2021), and any other resolution pertaining to parking restrictions for lots owned or controlled by the City, is incorporated into this Resolution, it is superseded in its entirety.
SECTION 2. Environmental Assessment. This Resolution is exempt from further environmental review pursuant to CEQA Guidelines § 15305 (Class 5 — Minor Alterations in Land Use Limitations). The project involves a negligible expansion of use; there is only a minor change in the operation of an existing use. The project would not result in significant effects related to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality and it can be adequately served by all required utilities and public services.
SECTION 3. This Resolution does not affect any penalty, forfeiture, or liability incurred before, or preclude prosecution and imposition of penalties for any violation occurring before, this Resolution’s effective date. Any such amended part will remain in full force and effect for sustaining action or prosecuting violations occurring before the effective date of this Resolution.
SECTION 4. Limitations. The City Council’s analysis and evaluation of the project is based on the best information currently available. It is inevitable that in evaluating a project that absolute and perfect knowledge of all possible aspects of the project will not exist. One of the major limitations on analysis of the project is the City Council’s lack of knowledge of future events. In all instances, best efforts were made to form accurate assumptions. Somewhat related to this are the limitations on the City's ability to solve what are in effect regional, state, and national problems and issues. The City must work within the political framework within which it exists and with the limitations inherent in that framework.
City of Bellflower
Resolution No. 25-10
SECTION 5. Summaries of Information. All summaries of information in the findings, which precede this section, are based on the substantial evidence in the record.
The absence of any particular fact from any such summary is not an indication that a particular finding is not based in part on that fact.
SECTION 6. Severability. If any part of this Resolution or its Application is deemed invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, the City Council intends that such invalidity will not affect the effectiveness of the remaining provisions or applications and, to this end, the provisions of this Resolution are severable.
SECTION 7. Electronic Signatures. This Resolution may be executed with electronic signatures in accordance with Government Code §16.5. Such electronic signatures will be treated in all respects as having the same effect as an original signature.
SECTION 8. The Mayor, or presiding officer, is authorized to affix its signature to this Resolution signifying its adoption by the City Council of the City of Bellflower, and the City Clerk, or its duly appointed deputy, is directed to attest.
SECTION 9. Effective Date. This Resolution will become effective immediately upon adoption and will remain effective unless repealed or superseded.
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BELLFLOWER THIS 24th DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025.
________________________________
Ray Dunton, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________
Mayra Ochiqui, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Karl H. Berger, City Attorney
By:________________________________
Justin A. Tamayo, Assistant City Attorney
Attachment:
Exhibit A – Restrictions for City-owned or Controlled Parking Lots
RESOLUTION NO. 25-10 – EXHIBIT A
RESTRICTIONS FOR CITY-OWNED OR CONTROLLED PARKING LOTS
Below is a list of parking lots owned or controlled by the City, along with their associated parking regulations.
Note: All City-owned or controlled parking lots also will have the posted restriction that any vehicles parked more than 72-hours will be towed at the owner’s expense.
Lot 1: Entire City parking lot, east of Bellflower Boulevard between Oak Street and Belmont Street, and adjacent curb markings:
No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping); Two-hour parking time restrictions (1 p.m. – 10 p.m., except Sunday); Red curb marking - north side of Oak Street at Bellflower Boulevard east to the alley; and, twenty-minute parking north side of Oak Street east of Bellflower Boulevard between the two-parking lot driveways; Twenty-minute green curb marking and adjacent yellow loading zone curb marking - south side of Oak Street east of Bellflower Boulevard; and Approximately 88 feet of red curb marking on the south side of Oak Street from Adenmoor Avenue west to the first driveway.
Lot 2: Entire City parking lot, on the northeast corner of Adenmoor Avenue and Belmont Street
No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping); and Two-hour parking time restrictions (1 p.m. – 10 p.m., except Sunday).
Lot 3: Lot between Oak Street and the bike path – east of Bellflower Boulevard No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping) Two-hour parking time restrictions (1 p.m. – 10 p.m., except Sunday).
Lot 4: Lot between Belmont Street and Oak Street – west of Bellflower Boulevard No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping)
Lot 5: Lot between Belmont Street and Laurel Street – west of Bellflower Boulevard No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping
Lot 6: Lot between Flower Street and Laurel Street – west of Bellflower Boulevard No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping)
Lot 7: Lot between Walnut Street and Arkansas Street – east of Bellflower Boulevard No parking midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping); and
Two-hour parking time restrictions (7 a.m. – 6 p.m., except Sunday).
Lot 8: Lots on the south side of Artesia Boulevard – east of Bellflower Boulevard No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping)
City of Bellflower
Resolution No. 25-10 – Exhibit A
Lot 9: Palm Street Park - 9245 Palm Street
No parking 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. daily, unless authorized by the Director of Parks and Recreation, BMC 12.40
Lot 10: Ruth R. Caruthers Park – 10500 Flora Vista Street No parking 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. daily, unless authorized by the Director of Parks and Recreation, BMC 12.40
Lot 11: John S. Simms Park – 16614 S. Clark Avenue
No parking 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. daily, unless authorized by the Director of Parks and Recreation, BMC 12.40
Lot 12: T. Mayne Thompson Park – 14001 Bellflower Boulevard No parking 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. daily, unless authorized by the Director of Parks and Recreation, BMC 12.40
Lot 13: Library Gardens & Veterans Memorial – 9918 Flower Street No parking when park is closed daily (½ hour after dusk to ½ hour after dawn, BMC 12.40).
Lot 14: Flora Vista Dog Park – 9203 Flora Vista Street No parking when park is closed daily (½ hour after dusk to ½ hour after dawn, BMC 12.40)
Lot 15: Riverview Park – 10500 Somerset Boulevard
No parking when park is closed daily (½ hour after dusk to ½ hour after dawn, BMC 12.40)
Lot 16: Butterfly Garden Park – 10525 Trabuco Street
No parking when park is closed daily (½ hour after dusk to ½ hour after dawn, BMC 12.40)
Lot 17: Lot west of the United States Post Office
No parking Wednesdays, midnight to a.m. (lot sweeping); and Two-hour parking time restrictions (7 a.m. – 6 p.m., except Sunday)
Lot 18: Lots south of Bellflower City Hall and west of the Clifton M. Brakensiek Library No parking Wednesdays, midnight to 6 a.m. (lot sweeping) Two-hour parking time restrictions (7 a.m. – 4 p.m. Monday-Friday, southern portion of the lot only)
Lot 19: Downtown Bellflower Parking Structure – 16337 Bellflower Boulevard No parking daily, midnight to 6 a.m., vehicles subject to tow-away if in violation.
Flower St
Mayne St
Be
l
l
f
l
o
w
e
r
B
l
v
d
Belmont St
Oak St
Ci
v
i
c
C
e
n
t
e
r
D
r
Ad
e
n
m
o
o
r
A
v
e
{I
L
H ..
.
#3
5 1
2 ?
»
m
,
a
a?
!
.
,
A
W
it
”
?
5”
.
t
‘
.
..
.
*E
I
.E
w
Ar
.
1 4w
.
.
‘
,1: __53 "
QkfiJKm‘i M \.
h :AHC L‘ .:
Two-Hour Limit
Two-Hour Limit
City of Bellflower
Lot 17
Two-Hour Limit
8 :.
n
_
w
35 ,
12 .
3 .
“
.
fo
-
es
.
.
.
rl
h
‘
r
‘
l
v
‘b
.
.
,
fl
14-H
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION: Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM: Jim DellaLonga, Director of Economic Development
SUBJECT: Consideration and possible action to provide direction to the City Manager regarding the reallocation of unused Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Relief funds (CDBG-CV) for the updated design and sidewalk improvements of the TownCenter Gateway Plaza area located at the northeast corner of Belmont Street and Bellflower Boulevard.
DATE: February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Following completion of the youth, family, and senior citizen services program, there is approximately $307,553 in CDBG-CV funds remaining that can be reallocated towards other programs. An additional $100,000 in CDBG-CV funds previously allocated towards small business start-ups in the Belle Fleur Centre is also available as this amount was not used because of changes to the development. The total amount of CDBG-CV funds proposed for reallocation is $407,553. The Director of Economic Development (“Director”) is seeking direction from the City Council concerning the reallocation of approximately $407,533 of CDBG-CV funds for improvements to TownCenter Gateway Plaza. CDBG- CV funds must be spent by November 2026 or must be returned to the Department of Housing Urban Development (“HUD”).
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Direct the City Manager to prepare a substantial amendment to the 202 0-21 Annual Action Plan by reallocating $407,553 of CDBG-CV funds for the updated design and sidewalk improvements of the Town Center Gateway Plaza area; or
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
The remaining CDBG-CV funds of $407,553 are estimated to cover the full cost of the proposed TownCenter Gateway Plaza sidewalk improvement project.
o“ 01: BELLFLO
“ s a
"o ROWING TOGETk‘YFS t f t
Staff Report – Sidewalk Improvement
February 24, 2025
BACKGROUND
On March 27, 2020, the CARES Act became effective. It made funding available for local governments to prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19. Under the CARES Act, the City initially received $538,180 in CDBG-CV funds from HUD in the first round of CARES Act funding. On September 11, 2020, HUD announced it would be awarding nearly $2 billion in CARES Act funds (“CDBG-CV3”) to local jurisdictions, focusing on communities with higher risk of eviction. The Director was notified that the City would be receiving an additional $650,300 in CDBG-CV3 funds under this new HUD allocation. The City received a total of $1,188,480 of CDBG-CV funding.
The City allocated these funds towards programs addressing emergency residential relief, small business start-ups, food insecurity, and small business grants. Of the $1,188,480 CDBG-CV funds the City received, $780,927 were expended through various programs.
The City funded an emergency rental relief program, which assisted 42 Bellflower residents. In addition, CDBG-CV funds were also allocated to food insecurity programs including a homeless shelter meal program, which was able to assist 112 persons with food, as well as a food insecurity program which assisted 15 families with biweekly grocery pick up. The City has also allocated CDBG-CV funds to a youth/family/senior services program which was able to assist 276 low-and moderate-income Bellflower residents. Grants were also provided to small businesses.
The following table shows the CDBG-CV programs and expenditures that the City funded:
PROGRAM FUNDED
AMOUNT EXPENDED FUNDS REMAINING
Planning and Administration
(20% cap) $237,696 $237,696 $0
Emergency Housing Needs
Assistance $186,784 $181,143 $5,641
Food Insecurity Program $27,000 $24,564 $2,436
Homeless Shelter Meals
Program $30,000 $30,000 $0
Youth/Family/Senior Services $507,000 $213,024 $293,976 Business Assistance Grants $100,000 $94,500 $5,500
New Small Business Start-up
Program $100,000 $0 $100,000
Totals: $1,188,480 $780,927 $407,553
DISCUSSION
The total remaining CDBG-CV funds of $407,553 need to be reallocated and spent before November 2026.
Staff Report – Sidewalk Improvement
February 24, 2025
DISCUSSION – Continued
CDBG-CV funds can be used for a wide range of community development programs to help communities prevent, prepare for, and respond to the direct and indirect effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and to mitigate future risks. As we move away from the COVID-19 crisis it is difficult to address the negative impacts from the pandemic with the required background documentation. As such, we need to re-focus on “Preparing and Preventing” strategies for the future.
These funds can be used to create, expand, or enhance public facilities, such as improved street lighting, the redesign of public sidewalks to encourage social distancing, and physical improvements that ensure accessibility pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Funding can also be used for public rights-of-way and outdoor recreational facility improvements. As a COVID-19 tieback, this can be an effective way of creating or updating existing outdoor public spaces with ample lighting suitable for pedestrian traffic and long-term spaces designed to reduce the transmission of future COVID-19.
Working with the Director of Public Works, Economic Development s taff have identified TownCenter Gateway Plaza, the area in front of and adjacent to the kiosks on Belmont Street, as an area for a sidewalk redesign, improved lighting, and ADA improvements.
The existing improvements are 17 years old and in need of a refresh due to the elements, invasive tree roots and years of wear and tear. The Director met with a HUD representative who represented that this use of CDBG-CV funds would have a COVID- 19 tieback by enhancing the public area to encourage social distancing to prevent the spread of COVID-19.
If this direction is approved by City Council, the Director will return in a couple of months with a substantial amendment to the 2020-21 Annual Action Plan HUD requires a 30-day public comment period for a substantial amendment to the CDBG-CV funding allocation.
This reallocation will fund both the design and the construction of the improvements for TownCenter Gateway Plaza.
'fK op BELLFLO j,
staqp0 RGWINTC rt
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
ATTENTION: Ryan Smoot, City Manager
FROM: Wangsu Lee, Interim Senior Management Analyst
SUBJECT: Consideration and possible action to authorize the City Manager to execute a public health services contract with the County of Los Angeles ("County"), in a form approved by the City Attorney, for the performance of public health services by the Los Angeles County's Department of Public Health ("DPH").
DATE: February 24, 2025
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The City of Bellflower ("City") has had an ongoing contract with the County's Department of Public Health ("DPH") for public health services since September 3, 1957. Over the past year, the DPH has engaged the various cities throughout the County to which they provided services to develop an updated public health services contract. Contract No. PH -005597 ("Contract") is the result of that process. This action seeks authorization for the City Manager to execute the Contract with the County, allowing the DPH to continue providing public health services for the City. This Contract also maintains the County Health Officer as the City's Health Officer and the DPH as the City's Environmental Health Department. If the Contract is executed, it would remain effective until June 30, 2029, with ongoing automatic five-year renewals.
RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL
1) Authorize the City Manager to execute Contract No. PH -005597 (City Agreement File No. 51.99) with the County of Los Angeles, in a form approved by the City Attorney, for the performance of public health services by the Los Angeles County's Department of Public Health; or
2) Alternatively, discuss and take other action related to this item.
FISCAL IMPACT
In general, the City does not directly pay for the services provided by DPH unless we request very specific services as outlined in the contract. There is no other direct fiscal impact with respect to this item.
Staff Report — Contract with LA County Department of Public Health February 24, 2025
DISCUSSION
The City does not operate its own public health department. As a result, the City has had an ongoing public health services contract with the County since September 3, 1957. Over the past year, the Department has engaged the various cities throughout the County to which they provided services to develop an updated public health services contract. Contract No. PH -005597 is the result of those discussions and outlines the terms and conditions of this updated contract.
The contract outlines the County's provision of public health services in areas such as food safety, alcoholic beverage oversight, lead paint requirements, tobacco facility regulations, water and sewer standards, and various other areas.
Moreover, the City seeks to continue its partnership with the County for the provision of public health services, including designating the County's Health Officer as the City's Health Officer and the County's Department of Public Health as the City's Environmental Health Department. This Contract would continue the existing authorization for the County, along with the County's Health Officer to enforce State and County statutes related to Public Health, regulations and orders issued by CDPH, and the provisions of Los Angeles County Code, Title 11 and any amendments thereto, as adopted by City by ordinance or resolution, to the same extent as they are enforced in the unincorporated area of the County.
ATTACHMENT
Department of Public Health Services Contract No. PH -005597 (AFN 51.99) 3
Contract No. PH -005597
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES CONTRACT
THIS CONTRACT "Contract" is made and entered into on
by and between COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
(hereafter "County")
and CITY OF BELLFLOWER
(hereafter "City")
THIS PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES CONTRACT ("Contract") is made by and between the County of Los Angeles, hereinafter referred to as the "County", and the City of Bellflower hereinafter referred to as "City."
RECITALS:
The City desires to continue to contract with the County for the performance of public health services by the County's Department of Public Health ("Public Health"), for the County's Health Officer to act as the City's Health Officer, and for the County's Department of Public Health to serve as the City's Environmental Health Department.
The County agrees to continue performing such services on the terms and conditions set forth in this Contract.
This Contract is authorized by California Health and Safety Code Sections 101400 and 101405.
To effectuate public health services for the City, the County and its duly appointed Health Officer shall exercise the powers and duties that are conferred upon local health officers by law.
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
The County Health Officer shall fulfill the obligations and exercise the authority conferred by California Health and Safety Code Sections 101470 and 101475 within the territorial jurisdiction of the City in the performance of this Contract.
THEREFORE, THE PARTIES MUTUALLY AGREE AS FOLLOWS:
1. TERM: This Contract shall become effective upon date of execution, and replace all prior contracts for public health services between the City and County.
This contract shall continue in full force and effect until June 30, 2029. Subject to Section 7 below, this Contract shall thereafter be automatically renewed for consecutive five (5) year terms, for an indefinite period, without further action by either City or County, unless City or County terminates the Contract in the manner set forth in Section 7.
2. PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES: The County and the County's Health Officer shall observe and enforce within the territorial jurisdiction of the City all of the following:
a. Orders, quarantine, and other regulations, concerning public health, prescribed by the California Department of Public Health ("CDPH"). b. Statutes relating to public health.
c. Provisions of Los Angeles County Code, Title 11, and any amendments thereto, as adopted by City by ordinance or resolution, to the same extent as they are enforced in the unincorporated area of the County.
3. DESCRIPTION OF PUBLIC HEALTH FUNCTIONS:
a. The performance of all public health services, the standard of performance and other matters incidental to the performance of public health services and observation and enforcement of public health statutes, regulations, ordinances and CDPH orders and guidance shall be determined solely at the discretion of the County Health Officer and/or Director of County
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
Public Health. The control of County personnel under this Contract shall remain exclusively with the County.
b. The County agrees to continue to perform for the City such public health services as are authorized or mandated by state laws or regulations related to public health, to be performed by the local health officer or local enforcement agency.
i. Pursuant to California Health and Safety Code section 101045, the County shall investigate health and sanitary conditions in detention facilities operated by the City, if any. County may bill and receive payment from City for inspection and reporting services in the manner provided by Paragraph 4, subsections (g) and (h) of this Contract.
ii. For future enactments of state law or regulation, County agrees to perform public health services that impose a specific duty or obligation on the local health officer to observe or enforce. Should future state law statutory or regulatory enactment related to public health not impose a duty or obligation on the local health officer, City may request in writing that the County perform that public health service. Should County elect to perform that discretionary public health service for City, pursuant to such City request, then County may bill and receive payment from City for inspection and reporting services in the manner provided by Section 4, subsections (g) and (h) of this Contract.
c. The County agrees to continue to perform for the City such public health services as authorized or mandated by provisions of Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code, and any amendments or additions thereto, that the City has adopted via ordinance or resolution.
i. Should the County Board of Supervisors enact future provisions to or amend existing provisions of Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code, County will inform the City of the newly enacted provision or amendment via email to the City's Manager, and describe the
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
enacted new provision or amendment and the impact to the services performed under this Contract, if any.
ii. For future ordinances that may be enacted by the Board of Supervisors into Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code, in order for the County to observe and enforce that enacted ordinance within the City, the City must approve the incorporation of the identical version of that new Title 11 provision into its municipal code via ordinance or by resolution of the City Council. iii. Any future amendments to provisions of Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code that exist in the City's Municipal Code at the date of the execution of this Contract, shall be incorporated by the City into its municipal code.
d. The County shall issue public health permits and licenses to permittees located within the City and collect the fees as provided for in Los Angeles County Code, Title 8, Chapter 8.04. Such fees shall be retained by County Public Health for the benefit of County as full compensation for the services performed by the Public Health Director and County Health Officer on behalf of the City.
i. County may, from time to time, amend or alter the public health permit or license fees charged to those individuals or entities required to obtain a public health permit or license pursuant to either state statute or Los Angeles County Code, Title 8, Chapter
8.04. ii. City may not set, collect, or retain public health permit or license fees for any public health service performed by County under this Contract.
e. For the purpose of performing said functions, County shall furnish and supply all necessary labor, supervision, equipment, and supplies necessary to provide the public health services described in this Contract and as necessary to protect the public health, safety, and welfare as determined by Public Health in its sole discretion. All persons employed in
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
the performance of public health services and functions under this Contract shall be County personnel.
4. GENERAL TERMS:
a. To facilitate the performance of public health services, City and County will cooperate and assist each other to fulfill the purpose and intent of this Contract.
b. Exhibit A of this Contract, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein, shall provide the language of the City's Municipal Code, as amended, that reflects the City's specific adoption of Division 1 of Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code as of the effective date of this Contract.
Exhibit A may be revised to reflect any changes to the City's Municipal Code regarding Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code. c. All persons employed in the performance of such public health duties, functions and services for City shall be County employees or personnel and no City employee shall be supplanted by County, and no person employed by County under this Contract shall have any City pension, civil service, or any status or right.
d. The City shall not be called upon to assume any liability for the direct payment of any salary, wages or other compensation to any County personnel performing services hereunder for the City, or be liable for compensation to or required to indemnify any County employee for injury or sickness arising out of his or her employment.
e. The parties have executed an Assumption of Liability Contract approved by the Board of Supervisors on December 27, 1977, and/or a Joint Indemnity Contract approved by the Board of Supervisors on October 8, 1991. Whichever of these documents the City has signed later in time is currently in effect and hereby made a part of and incorporated into this Contract by reference. In the event that the Board of Supervisors later approves a revised Joint Indemnity Contract, and the City executes the
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
revised contract, the subsequent contract as of its effective date shall supersede the contract previously in effect between the parties hereto. f. City is not required to separately reimburse County for the performance or enforcement of any City ordinance or resolution which adopts identical provisions of Los Angeles County Code, Title 11, and its amendments. g. Should City request in writing additional public health services of the County, that are not required by statute, regulation or CDPH Order, or as provided in Title 11 of the Los Angeles County Code, the County may charge the City, at rates approved by the Board of Supervisors, an hourly rate that will reimburse the County for the costs for the provision of those specific public health services.
h. County, through its Director of Public Health, must render to City within twenty (20) calendar days after the close of each calendar month an itemized invoice which covers all extra services performed for City if such services were requested by the City in writing, during said month, and City must pay County within thirty (30) days after date of such invoice. i. If a violation of public health statutes, regulations or ordinances results in a public health hazard within the City, County will notify the City Manager in writing. If the City elects to pursue legal prosecution or abatement, City shall provide to County contact information for counsel that will represent the City or the People in any legal proceeding to abate or mitigate the public health hazard. City shall bear the full cost of such proceedings.
County may bill City on an hourly basis for time spent by County employees participating in such legal proceedings.
5. NOTICES: Notices hereunder must be in writing and may either be delivered personally or sent by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid, attention to the parties at the addresses listed below. Public Health Director, or the Director's designee, is authorized to execute all notices or demands which are required or permitted by County under this Contract.
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
Addresses and parties to be notified may be changed by providing at least ten (10) working days prior written notice to the other party.
A. Notices to County must be addressed as follows:
(1) Department of Public Health
Environmental Health — Administrative Headquarters
5050 Commerce Drive
Baldwin Park, California 91706
Attention: Director, Environmental Health
E-mail: EHAdmin a(�ph.lacounty.gov
(2) Department of Public Health
Contracts and Grants Division
5555 Ferguson Drive, 2nd Floor, Suite 210
Commerce, CA 90022
Attention: Division Director
Email: contracts-grants(a�ph.lacounty.gov
(3)
Department of Public Health
Office of the Director
Attention: Director, Public Health
313 North Figueroa Street
Los Angeles, CA 90012
Email: DPHDirector(a�ph.lacounty.gov
B. Notices to City must be addressed as follows:
(1) City of: Bellflower
Attention: City Manager
16600 Civic Center Drive
Bellflower, CA 90706
Email: [email protected]
Phone: (562) 804-1424
6. GOVERNING LAW, JURISDICTION, AND VENUE: This Contract will be governed by, and will be construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of California. City agrees and consents to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of the State of California or the United States Courthouse, Central District, Western Division, for all purposes regarding this Contract and further agrees and consents
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
that venue of any action brought under this Contract shall be exclusively in the County of Los Angeles.
7. TERMINATION FOR CONVENIENCE: The performance of services under this Contract may be terminated, with or without cause, in whole or in part, from time to time when such action is deemed by County or City to be in their own best interest. Termination of services hereunder shall be effectuated by the delivery of an advance written Notice of Termination of the entire Contract by one party to the other at least one hundred and eighty (180) calendar days prior to July 1 of the following calendar year. The termination of services may only be effective on July 1 of the calendar year, so as to assure no lapse in public health and local health officer services to the residents of City.
8. ALTERATION OF TERMS/AMENDMENTS: The body of this Contract and any Exhibits attached hereto, and documents incorporated by reference, fully expresses all understandings of the parties concerning all matters covered and shall constitute the total Contract. No addition to, or alteration of, the terms of this Contract, whether by written or verbal understanding of the parties, their officers, employees or agents, shall be valid and effective unless made in the form of a written amendment to this Contract which is formally approved and executed by the parties in the same manner as this Contract.
9. INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR STATUS: This Contract is by and between the County and City and is not intended, and shall not be construed, to create the relationship of agent, servant, employee, partnership, joint venture, or association, as between the County and City. The employees and agents of one party shall not be, or be construed to be, the employees or agents of the other party for any purpose whatsoever.
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
10. NO INTENT TO CREATE A THIRD -PARTY BENEFICIARY CONTRACT:
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Contract, the parties do not in any way intend that any person shall acquire any rights as a third -party beneficiary under this Contract.
11. VALIDITY: If any provision of this Contract or the application thereof to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the remainder of this Contract and the application of such provision to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected thereby.
12. WAIVER: No waiver by the County of any breach of any provision of this Contract shall constitute a waiver of any other breach or of such provision.
Failure of the County to enforce at any time, or from time to time, any provision of this Contract shall not be construed as a waiver thereof. The rights and remedies set forth in this paragraph shall not be exclusive and are in addition to any other rights and remedies provided by law or under this Contract. /
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles has caused this Contract to be subscribed by its Director of Public Health, and Contractor has caused this Contract to be subscribed in its behalf by its duly authorized officer, the month, day, and year first written above.
CITY OF BELLFLOWER COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
By: By:
Ryan Smoot Barbara Ferrer, Ph.D., M.P.H., M.Ed.
City Manager Director
Date: Date:
APPROVED AS TO FORM APPROVED AS TO FORM
BY THE OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY BY THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY COUNSEL KARL H. BERGER, City Attorney DAWYN R. HARRISON, County Counsel By: APPROVED AS TO CONTRACT
City Attorney ADMINISTRATION:
Department of Public Health
Date:
By:
Contracts and Grants Division
ATTEST:
MAYRA OCHIQUI, City Clerk
Date:
By:
City Clerk
Date:
(AFFIX CORPORATE SEAL HERE)
#07642:db
City of Bellflower — PH -005597
Exhibit A:
CITIES - HEALTH OFFICER - ADOPTION OF COUNTY CODE
BELLFLOWER
ADOPTION OF OUR COUNTY CODE TITLE 8 & TITLE 11
8.04.020 Adoption by Reference.
There is hereby adopted as the City Health Ordinance of the City of Bellflower, except as it is hereafter amended, Ordinance No. 7583 of the County of Los Angeles, being the Health Code of the County of Los Angeles, as amended and in effect June 1, 1974.
Three (3) copies of Ordinance No. 7583 as specified above, have been deposited with the City Clerk, and shall be at all times maintained by the Clerk for use and examination by the public. (Prior code § 11-1.2)
CITY MUNICIPAL CODE EXCLUSION OF SPECIFIC PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES None
BELLFLOWER — PH -005597
GPA, DA, DAZL, ZC 8825 Artesia Boulevard B-ITEM 13 Storage Facility-Self
West Artesia Specific Plan development and operational standards for hotels uses.Included additional land uses including hotels and extended stay hotels and established -2019 Amendment •WASP was adopted in 2007 and amended in 2011 and 2019.•
Previous Entitlements The site remains vacant.•extension. year time -eCity Council approved an additional on–May 24, 2021 •year time extension.-City Council approved a one–May 26, 2020 •Hotel was expected to generate $170,000 annually in TOT.•provided on the adjacent property (Woodspring Suites).Parking was provided onsite and through an agreement 11 spaces were •room hotel (Comfort Inn). -the construction of a 69City Council approved a Conditional Use Permit to allow –April 19, 2019 •
Proposed Project N Storage-Self–
Proposed Project Storage-Self–
Development Agreement Zone of Commercial. The GPA would change the land use designation from Commercial to Industrial.storage facilities are not consistent with the current land use designation -PA is required since selfG•standards would only be allowed on the subject site, not the entirety of the WASP.storage facility use and development -ZC is required to change the zone from WASP to DAZL. Self•Development Agreement.The allowable uses and development standards would need to be incorporated into the •storage facilities.-the proposed use and to establish specific development standards for selfDAZL is a mechanism that could allow for WASP currently does not allow for self storage facilities. •strict development or sign regulations.for otherwiseDAZL created in 2020 to allow flexibility •AmendmentLayover, Zone Change, & General Plan
CEQA.reviewenvironmentalincludinglaw,applicablewithaccordanceinprocessedbewillapplicationthereport,thisfileandreceiveCouncilCitytheShould•.15270and)4(b)(15061GuidelinesCEQAunderreviewenvironmentalreq uirenotdodeniedarethatProjects•.CEQAwithcomplytoreviewenvironmentalconductnotdidCityThe•.deniedbeprojecttherecommendedDirectortheapplication,submittedtheofreviewFollowing•
Development Agreement Terms.paymentannualperpetualdreduceAand;Citythebyaccessiblepaymentsumlumpupfronttime-oneA:ofconsiststhatstructurepaymenthybridaincludemayagreementthealternative,anAs.Structure HybridAlternative•.million125.2$.approxofsumbuyoutayields-intertestannual000,170$ofNPVtheasestablishedbeamountbuyouttheproposesApplicant.Sum)(LumpialsFinancBuyout•.paymentsperpetualremainingtheofNPVt heonbaseddeterminedbewillamountbuyoutThe.years10afteroptionbuyoutainitiatemayHoldingsGroupTerrance:OptionBuyoutInitiated-Developer.paymentsperpetualremainingtheofNPVtheonbaseddeterminedbewillamountb uyouttheexercised,If.years5afteranytimeoptionbuyoutatriggermayCityflexibility,financialprovideTo:OptionBuyoutInitiated-City:conditionsspecifictwounderoptionbuyoutsumLump.ProvisionBuyout•.generateoth erwisewouldhotelroom-69athatTOTestimatedtheoffsettoperpetuityinannually000,170$.PaymentsAnnual•
Tonight’s Recommendation completed.)be approved before environmental review is related to this item. (Note: The project cannot Alternatively, discuss and take other action 3.action; orReceive and file this report without taking 2.Deny the project application; 1.
ITEM 13.0
CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION 25-11
APPROVING THE COMMITMENT OF HOME PARTNERSHIP COMMUNITY HOUSING
DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION (CHDO) FUNDS AND HOME PARTNERSHIP
AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN (HOME -ARP) FUNDS TO A POTENTIAL PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROJECT LOCATED AT 15804 LAKEWOOD BOULEVARD;
CERTIFYING WAKELAND OPPORTUNITIES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AS A BELLFLOWER CHDO; AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE FUTURE
FUNDING AGREEMENTS AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THESE FUNDS AND THIS POTENTIAL PROJECT.
-b eq
f4wo,
Economic Development
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
15% of City's HOME Fund allocation must be set -aside for a Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) project.
CHDO Project is the development of affordable housing
$2,056,204 in CHDO funds has been accumulated as of the most recent Annual Action Plan City received HOME -ARP funds in 2022 in the amount of $1,301,749 HOME -ARP Plan approved by Council in March 2023 and by HUD in May 2023 $1,106,487 for development of affordable rental housing $195,262 (15%) for admin and planning of the development of affordable rental housing Spending deadline of September 2030
The last CHDO project with the City was the Habitat for Humanity project on Ramona Street (6 home -ownership units) that was complete in FY 2017-18 b CN W�
Economic Development
BACKGROUND
Wakeland is a nonprofit affordable housing developer
Founded in 1998
Working relationship with Mercy House since 2012, the City's service provider at the New Hope Shelter
Extensive Permanent Supportive Housing Development experience CHDO experience in other jurisdictions
67 projects
bI
Aftivo,
Economic Development
La Entrada — 64 units - Riverside, CA
�AA
The Grove — 81 units -Vista, CA
Talmadge Gateway — 60 units - Riverside, CA The Quincy — 54 units — Los Angeles, CA
DISCUSSION
DISCUSSION
Working with Wakeland for 2 Years
Were working on a site on Artesia Blvd. but had
entitlement timing issues.
Now identified 15804 Lakewood Blvd.
28,565 square feet
Just signed a purchase and sale agreement
economic ueveiopment
DISCUSSION
Approximately 50 one -bedroom units
Affordable permanent supportive housing units w/onsite wrap -around services Estimated to be a $30M project w/annual operating costs of $600,000 City's potential funding is only around 10% of the total project cost b4folveh..,f
Economic Development
FUNDING COMMITMENT
CHDO CERTIFICATION
CITY MANAGER AUTHORIZATIONS
DISCUSSION -FUNDING COMMITMENT
Two City Funding Sources
HOME-CHDO Funds - $2,056,204
HOME -ARP Funds - $1,106,485
36-Month Commitment
1$391629689
J
Provides time forWakeland to apply to various funding sources Currently proposed as a 55-Year residual receipts loan with 3% simple interest City is one of three or four funding sources
County of Los Angeles
Tax Credits
Potentially State of California
bI
AfvIvo,
Economic Development
DISCUSSION - CHDO CERTIFICATION
CHDO Certification needed to receive HOME-CHDO funds
Wakeland's CHDO entityWakeland Opportunities forAffordable Housing (WOAH) Avant Garde reviewed WOAH's CHDO application
WOAH satisfies all HUD criteria as indicated in the staff report and attached CHDO Checklist
bI
Aftivo,
Economic Development
DISCUSSION -AUTHORIZATIONS
Authorization to provide Wakeland with a ZoningVerification letter Specific to Wakeland's LA County Funding application to verify the General Plan designation and Zoning of the proposed site.
Authorization to enter into Funding Agreements for HOME-CHDO Funds and HOME -ARP Funds when appropriate
bI
AfvIvo,
Economic Development
RECOMMENDATION
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council consider:
ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 25-1 1 APPROVING THE COMMITMENT OF $2,056,204 OF HOME-CHDO FUNDS AND $1,106,487 OF HOME -ARP FUNDS TO A POTENTIAL (FUTURE) PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROJECT AT 15804 LAKEWOOD BOULEVARD; CERTIFY WAKELAND OPPORTUNITIES FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING (WOAH) AS A BELLFLOWER CHDO AS IT RELATES TO THE POTENTIAL PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROJECT; AUTHORIZE THE
CITY MANAGER TO PROVIDE WOAH A ZONING VERIFICATION LETTER, IN A
FORM APPROVED BY THE CITY ATTORNEY AND EXECUTE FUTURE HOME-CHDO
AND HOME -ARP FUNDING AGREEMENTS ONCE CONDITIONS ARE MET TO IMPLEMENT THE POTENTIAL PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROJECT; OR ALTERNATIVELY, DISCUSS AND TAKE ANOTHER ACTION RELATED TO THIS ITEM b I A fv
�V
Economic Development
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
1 1.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
3 TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND ................................................................................... 1-1
1.1 Overview .......................................................................................................................................... 1-1
1.2 Amendment to the Specific Plan ..................................................................................................... 1-1
1.3 Regional Focus On Transit-Oriented Development ......................................................................... 1-2
1.4 Purpose and Intent .......................................................................................................................... 1-6
1.5 Project Setting and Background ...................................................................................................... 1-7
1.6 Relationship to Existing Regulatory Provisions and Planning Documents……………………................1-15
1.7 Authority and Scope ...................................................................................................................... 1-21
1.8 Action Expectations ....................................................................................................................... 1-22
1.9 Specific Plan Organization ............................................................................................................. 1-22
2. VISION AND OBJECTIVES ..................................................................................................... 2-1
2.1 Vision ............................................................................................................................................... 2-1
2.2 Objectives ........................................................................................................................................ 2-3 LAND USE PLAN .................................................................................................................. 3-1 3
3.1 Objectives & Policies........................................................................................................................ 3-1
3.2 Planning Areas ................................................................................................................................. 3-2
3.3 Future Metro Transit Station ......................................................................................................... 3-10
4. ALLOWABLE USES AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS ........................................................... 4-1
4.1 Purpose ............................................................................................................................................ 4-1
4.2 Allowable Uses and Development Standards for Planning Areas ................................................... 4-1
5. MOBILITY ............................................................................................................................ 5-1
5.1 Objectives and Policies .................................................................................................................... 5-1
5.2 First-Last Mile Strategy .................................................................................................................... 5-3
5.3 Street Network ................................................................................................................................ 5-9
5.4 Bicycle Network ............................................................................................................................. 5-15
5.5 Pedestrian Environment ................................................................................................................ 5-21
5.6 Street Trees.................................................................................................................................... 5-26
5.7 Entries & Monumentation ............................................................................................................. 5-29
5.8 Green Streets ................................................................................................................................. 5-29
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
5.9 Transit Circulation .......................................................................................................................... 5-33
6. INFRASTRUCTURE ............................................................................................................... 6-1
6.1 Water ............................................................................................................................................... 6-2
6.2 Wastewater Services ........................................................................................................................ 6-5
6.3 Flood Control and Storm Drainage ................................................................................................ 6-11
6.4 Sustainable Infrastructure Recommendations .............................................................................. 6-15
6.5 Planning Area 1 .............................................................................................................................. 6-17
7. URBAN DESIGN GUIDELINES ............................................................................................... 7-1 About the Design Guidelines ............................................................................................................ 7-2 7.1 Site Design Guidelines (Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4) ......................................................................... 7-3 7.2 Building Design (Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4) .................................................................................... 7-9 7.3 Public Realm Design (Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4) .......................................................................... 7-20 7.4 Additional Design Guidelines for Planning Areas 2 and 3 .............................................................. 7-22 7.5 Design Guidelines for Planning Area 1 ........................................................................................... 7-24 7.6
8. ADMINISTRATION AND IMPLEMENTATION ......................................................................... 8-1
8.1 Specific Plan Adoption...................................................................................................................... 8-1
8.2 Municipal Code Reference ............................................................................................................... 8-1
8.3 Definitions ........................................................................................................................................ 8-1
8.4 Specific Plan Amendments ............................................................................................................... 8-2
8.5 Review and Approval Authority of the Director .............................................................................. 8-4
8.6 Project Review Process and Procedures .......................................................................................... 8-5
8.7 Provisions for Existing Improvements and Additions ...................................................................... 8-7
8.8 Environmental Review ..................................................................................................................... 8-8
8.9 Implementation Action Plan ............................................................................................................ 8-8
8.10 Potential Funding Mechanisms ...................................................................................................... 8-12
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
5 FIGURES
Figure 1.1 Original Metro WSAB Corridor .............................................................................................. 1-5 Figure 1.2 Metro WSAB Locally Preferred Alternative …………………………………………………………1-6 Figure 1.3 Local Context ......................................................................................................................... 1-9 Figure 1.4 Specific Plan Area ................................................................................................................. 1-11 Figure 1.5 General Plan Land Use ......................................................................................................... 1-19 Figure 3.1 Planning Areas ....................................................................................................................... 3-8 Figure 3.2 Zoning and Planning Areas .................................................................................................... 3-9 Figure 3.3 Conceptual Location of Transit Station ............................................................................... 3-10 Figure 4.1 Planning Area 1 Boundaries ................................................................................................... 4-3 Figure 4.2 Planning Area 1 Build-to-Zone Standards ............................................................................ 4-10 Figure 4.3 Planning Area 1 Setback Standards ..................................................................................... 4-10 Figure 4.4 Planning Area 1 Building Frontage Length ........................................................................... 4-11 Figure 4.5 Planning Area 1 Building Standards and Building Frontage Types ...................................... 4-11 Figure 4.6 Planning Area 1 Live-Work Frontage Standards .................................................................. 4-12 Figure 4.7 Planning Area 1 Parking Standards…………………………………………………………………………………..4- 13 Figure 4.8 Planning Area 1 Publicly Accessible Open Space ................................................................. 4-14 Figure 4.9 Planning Area 1 Residential Frontage Standards ................................................................. 4-27 Figure 4.10 Planning Area 1 Storefront Standards ................................................................................. 4-29 Figure 4.11 Planning Area 1 Driveway Standards ................................................................................... 4-30 Figure 4.12 Planning Areas 2 and 3 Boundaries ..................................................................................... 4-35 Figure 4.13 Planning Area 4 Boundaries ................................................................................................. 4-48 Figure 5.1 Pathways ................................................................................................................................ 5-5 Figure 5.2 Street Network ....................................................................................................................... 5-7
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
Figure 5.3 Bellflower Boulevard (Existing) ............................................................................................ 5-10 Figure 5.4 Alondra Boulevard (Existing) ................................................................................................ 5-12 Figure 5.5 Flower Street (Existing) ........................................................................................................ 5-14 Figure 5.6 Flower Street (Proposed) ..................................................................................................... 5-15 Figure 5.7 Bicycle Network .................................................................................................................... 5-17 Figure 5.8 Walking and Bike Trail (Existing) .......................................................................................... 5-20 Figure 5.9 Sidewalk Hierarchy ............................................................................................................... 5-23 Figure 5.10 Street Trees .......................................................................................................................... 5-27 Figure 5.11 Examples of Biotreatment Features ..................................................................................... 5-32 Figure 5.12 Bus Routes ........................................................................................................................... 5-35 Figure 5.13 Conceptual Design ................................................................................................................ 5-38 Figure 5.14 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design: Option 1 Plaza Level Plan........................................ 5-39 Figure 5.15 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design Option 1: Platform Level Plan .................................. 5-40 Figure 5.16 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design Option 2: Plaza Level Plan........................................ 5-41 Figure 5.17 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design Option 2: Platform Level Plan .................................. 5-42 Figure 6.1 Examples of Infrastructure Elements ..................................................................................... 6-1 Figure 6.2 Existing Water Lines ............................................................................................................... 6-3 Figure 6.3 Existing Wastewater System .................................................................................................. 6-7 Figure 6.4 Existing Wastewater System Improvement Tiers .................................................................. 6-9 Figure 6.5 Existing Storm Drains............................................................................................................ 6-13 Figure 6.6 Planning Area 1 Framework Vision Plan .............................................................................. 6-18 Figure 6.7 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Community Design .................................................................. 6-19 Figure 6.8 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Streetview Concept – Bellflower Boulevard ........................... 6-20 Figure 6.9 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Streetview Concept – Residential Sub Area ............................ 6-21 Figure 6.10 Planning Area 1 Existing Water System ................................................................................ 6-22 Figure 6.11 Planning Area 1 Existing Wastewater System ...................................................................... 6-23
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
7 Figure 6.12 Planning Area 1 Future Wastewater System ....................................................................... 6-24 Figure 7.1 Permitted Frontage by Planning Area ................................................................................. 7-10 Figure 7.2 Planning Area 1 Buffers ....................................................................................................... 7-27 Figure 7.3 Planning Area 1 Step Back Upper Floors .............................................................................. 7-29 Figure 7.4 Planning Area 1 Material Treatment at Corners .................................................................. 7-32 Figure 7.5 Planning Area 1 Building Orientation .................................................................................. 7-35 Figure 7.6 Planning Area 1Buildings with Shared Parking Areas and Driveways.................................. 7-36 Figure 7.7 Planning Area 1 Building Orientation .................................................................................. 7-38 Figure 7.8 Planning Area 1 Parking Location ........................................................................................ 7-40 Figure 7.9 Planning Area 1Residential Building Orientation................................................................. 7-49
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN |
TABLES
Table 4.1 Planning Area 1 Allowable Residential Uses .......................................................................... 4-3 Table 4.2 Planning Area 1 Residential Development Standards ............................................................ 4-5 Table 4.3 Planning Area 1 Standards for All Other Non-Residential, Including Mixed Use .................. 4-8 Table 4.4 Planning Area 1 Live-Work/Office Frontage Standards ....................................................... 4-24 Table 4.5 Planning Area 1 Residential Frontage Standards…….………………………………………………………4-26 Table 4.6 Planning Area 1 Storefront Standards .................................................................................. 4-28 Table 4.7 Allowable Uses In Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 ....................................................................... 4-36 Table 4.8 Planning Areas 2 and 3 Development Standards ................................................................. 4-38 Table 4.9 Planning Areas 2 and 3 Parking Standards ........................................................................... 4-41 Table 4.10 Planning Area 4 Development Standards ............................................................................. 4-49 Table 4.11 Planning Area 4 Parking Standards ...................................................................................... 4-53 Table 8.1 Implementation Action Plan................................................................................................... 8-9
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
…………………..
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-1
1. INTRODUCTION AND
BACKGROUND
1.1 OVERVIEW
The Downtown Bellflower Station Area Specific Plan (“Specific Plan”) provides an exciting opportunity to align the City of Bellflower’s (“City” or “Bellflower”) long-pursued goals for the downtown area with the potential benefits of the anticipated rail transit corridor—the West Santa Ana Branch Transit Corridor. This light-rail line will connect Bellflower and surrounding cities to Downtown Los Angeles to the north and Artesia to the south, and ultimately, to stations in Orange County.
Bellflower’s proximity to this transit line will provide opportunities to attract new development, encourage multimodal transportation, improve access to major employment centers, and reintroduce Downtown Bellflower as a thriving, experience-oriented district for residents and visitors.
Although the opening of the transit station is years away, the market is ready today to start embracing future transit and to revitalize Bellflower’s charming, walkable downtown that embraces its history while valuing its modern amenities. By introducing a transit station in the downtown core, Bellflower will create a setting for new high-quality residences and a range of new commercial and entertainment activity that will support and sustain a thriving downtown environment.
This Specific Plan will be used in conjunction with the Bellflower General Plan to provide more detailed design and development criteria for individual project proposals and public improvements in the project area. The Specific Plan defines an updated land use plan, development standards, mobility plan, infrastructure improvements, design guidelines, and implementation programs for any proposed project in the Specific Plan area.
1.2 AMENDMENT TO THE SPECIFIC PLAN
The City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1378 on September 23, 2019 which, among other things, approved the Specific Plan. Since then, the City approved its 6th Cycle (2021-2029) Housing Element (“Housing Element”), which was certified by the California Housing and Community Development Department (“HCD”) in 2022.
The Housing Element identifies 12 Housing Opportunity Areas (“HOA”), which if developed to the maximum densities established by the Housing Element, would accommodate the City’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation (“RHNA”) of 3,735 dwelling units during the Housing Element planning cycle.
The Specific Plan includes four of these total 12 HOAs. The Housing Element increased the maximum densities allowed for these four
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-2
HOAs. To ensure consistency with the approved Housing Element, this Specific Plan has been amended to increase the maximum densities allowed within the four HOAs and to expand the boundaries of the Specific Plan to include additional contiguous areas (approximately 5.0 acres)
It should be noted that this document will continue to be called “Specific Plan”, because this amended Specific Plan document will replace the Specific Plan document that was originally approved by the City in 2019.
1.3 REGIONAL FOCUS ON TRANSIT-ORIENTED
DEVELOPMENT
Eco-Rapid Transit Corridor is an area extending 40 miles from the City of Artesia to Hollywood Burbank Airport created to pursue development of a transit system that moves as rapidly as possible, uses grade separation as appropriate, and is environmentally friendly and energy efficient. Its development is overseen, in part, by a joint powers authority consisting of eleven members: City of Artesia, City of Bell, City of Bell Garden, City of Cudahy, City of Downey, City of Glendale, City of Huntington Park, City of Maywood, City of Paramount, City of South Gate, and Burbank-Glendale-Pasadena Airport Authority; along with supporting agencies that include Caltrans – District 7, Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro), Gateway Cities Council of Governments, Southern California Association of Governments (“SCAG”), San Fernando Valley Council of Governments and Golden State Gateway Coalition. The Eco-Rapid Transit Corridor project was adopted into the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s (“Metro”) 2009 Long Range Transportation Plan and is scheduled to be built by 2027. This corridor represents a segment of Metro’s vast and expanding operating system. The goals of the Eco- Rapid Transit Corridor include:
» Economic development/connecting people to jobs
» Maximizing neighborhood and station connectivity
» Establishing multimodal transit hubs at station locations » Enhancing opportunities for public spaces and commerce » Designing surrounding streets for people and active
transportation
» Creating affordable and accessible housing—50 percent of region’s housing growth to be built in transit-oriented development
» Managing parking effectively
1.3.1 WEST SANTA ANA BRANCH CORRIDOR
The West Santa Ana Branch (“WSAB”) Transit Corridor is the southern 20 miles of the full Eco-Rapid Corridor, running from Artesia to
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-3
Downtown Los Angeles, generally along the Pacific Electric right-of-way (“PE ROW”) shown in Figure 1.1. The project was one of the “Twenty- Eight by ‘28” Metro projects designated for potential completion by the 2028 Summer Olympic and Paralympic Games. The WSAB Transit Corridor was allocated $4 billion (in 2015 dollars) per Measure M and Metro’s Long-Range Transportation Plan (“LRTP”). The project is funded by Measures R (2008) and M (2016), which fund transit improvements through one-half cent sales taxes, and well as other local, state, and federal sources.
The “Pacific Electric Right of Way/West Santa Ana Branch Corridor Alternative Analysis Report” studied the corridor along the former Pacific Electric Railway, now owned by Metro and Orange County Transportation Authority. The corridor which originally included 14 cities and 15 proposed stations, was studied to explore the feasibility of bus rapid transit, street cars, light rail transit, or low speed maglev trains operating within the right-of-way.
The Alternative Analysis Report concluded that the West Santa Ana Branch Corridor is expected to:
» Carry up to 70,000 daily boardings by 2040
» Cost an estimated $6.5 to $6.6 billion (in 2018 dollars) in capital costs
» Create 59,000 living wage jobs during construction
» Generate $6.68 billion in economic growth over 15 to 20 years » Result in a significant reduction in the region’s carbon footprint To support future economic development around Bellflower’s station area, Metro awarded the City a Transit Oriented Development Planning Grant to prepare a specific plan for a ½-mile radius around the proposed transit station location.
1.3.2 WEST SANTA ANA BRANCH CORRIDOR ALTERNATIVE
In January 2022, Metro Board of Directors approved a 14.8-mile line called the Locally Preferred Alternative (“LPA”) that will stretch from Slauson/A Line to the Pioneer Station (Figure 1.2). This alternate project features nine stations and five parking facilities and would connect 12 cities: Artesia, Cerritos, Bellflower, Paramount, Downey, South Gate, Cudahy, Bell, Huntington Park, Vernon, unincorporated Florence-Firestone to downtown Los Angeles.
1.3.3 DOWNTOWN BELLFLOWER STATION
The proposed Bellflower Station is at Bellflower Boulevard and the PE ROW, at the northern edge of downtown Bellflower. The proposed station is consistent with the City’s long-standing transit- oriented development vision, policies, and plans for downtown. In addition, it was a historic stop on the PE West Santa Ana Branch and is
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-4
part of the City’s transportation heritage, now honored by the restored PE Depot.
Because the cities and station areas along the corridor will be much more interconnected after the rail line is built, it is important to consider the unique purposes different stations will serve in the region.
When creating this Specific Plan, the City considered the corridor-level economy and implications for demand, supply, and competition. This resulted in a groundbreaking plan that attempts to create synergy between uses along the transit line, encouraging a thriving and well- rounded regional economy.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-5
FIGURE 1.1 Original Metro WSAB Corridor
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-6
FIGURE 1.2 Metro WSAB Locally Preferred Alternative (LPA)
1.4 PURPOSE AND INTENT
The purpose of the Specific Plan is to continue guiding the future land use, mobility, and economic development in the Specific Plan area. The Specific Plan provides a regulatory framework for the downtown Bellflower area that includes customized land uses and development standards, provides expanded multimodal transportation choices, and identifies locations for future development potential. This Specific Plan serves as the zoning for the downtown Bellflower area and establishes policy guidance for land uses, development standards, and design guidelines.
Ultimately, the Specific Plan provides a collective community vision and strategy for the area that regulates land uses and design policies and standards, identifies locations for potential infill development and expanded multimodal transportation choices, and promotes a healthy lifestyle through the availability of active transportation options.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-7
1.5 PROJECT SETTING AND BACKGROUND
This section provides an overview of contextual characteristics and trends in the Specific Plan area and surrounding region. This information reflects the most-current available data and studies, including policy documents, zoning regulations, census data, market conditions, and mass transit plans and guidelines as well as input from City staff, Gateway Cities Council of Governments, and Eco-Rapid Transit.
1.5.1 HISTORY AND LOCAL CONTEXT
In its earliest days, the City—originally known as Somerset Ranch— consisted primarily of large parcels with open fields used by Dutch dairy farmers for grazing cows. When the Pacific Electric Railway opened in 1905, it linked residents of Bellflower to employment centers in Los Angeles. Landowners began to subdivide and sell one-acre farm lots as well as narrow, deep town-size lots (a neighborhood pattern that is still evident today). With the addition of the newly subdivided lots, Bellflower transitioned from a farming town to a diverse community with a thriving cultural, civic, and economic core. Consistent with nationwide trends, Bellflower’s population surged in the 1940s, households doubled in size, and homeowners with extra space, built apartment buildings on their deep, narrow lots. Today, the City of Bellflower encompasses 6.12 square miles and is populated by nearly 80,000 people.
Bellflower is one of 88 cities in Los Angeles County and is in the County’s southeast region. It is bounded by Downey to the north, Norwalk and Cerritos to the east, Lakewood to the south, and Paramount to the west. Well-positioned between four freeways—Interstate 105 (“I-105”), Interstate 605 (“I-605”), Interstate 710 (“I-710”), and State Route 91 (“SR-91”) (see Figure 1.3)—its residents, workers, and visitors have access via vehicles to and from the best destinations Los Angeles County and Orange County have to offer. Once the Eco-Rapid Corridor is complete, Bellflower passengers will have access to all these locations via the regional transit system.
Bellflower primarily consists of single-family neighborhoods, corridor commercial development, active public spaces, and local employment centers. Kaiser Permanente Medical Group is the City’s largest single employer, followed by the City of Bellflower, Golden Corral, K-Mart, Tulaphorn (McDonald’s), and Hollywood Sports Park. The Specific Plan area is in the southern part of the City (see Figure 1.3).
1.5.2 SPECIFIC PLAN LOCATION
The approximate 330-acre Specific Plan area generally covered a half- mile radius around the planned transit station, which was required by Metro and is considered a relatively reasonable walking distance, based
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-8
on U.S. research studies. The Specific Plan boundaries are illustrated in Figure 1.4 below and defined by Alondra Boulevard on the north, Flower Street on the south, Clark Avenue on the west, and Woodruff Avenue on the east, plus additional area on both sides of Bellflower Boulevard between Jefferson Street on the north and Palm Street, near SR-91,on the south. The former Pacific Electric corridor runs diagonally through the Specific Plan area from northwest to southeast. The boundary extension established with the Specific Plan amendment increased the total acreage of the Specific Plan area to approximately 330 acres.
1.5.3 EXISTING LAND USES AND URBAN DESIGN
Land use and urban design play a critical role in the creation of distinctive places and in establishing a unique identity for a community.
This section provides an overview of the form, function, aesthetic, and experiential character in the Specific Plan area.
The majority of the Specific Plan area is residential, with homes ranging in style from traditional one-story single family detached to mid-sized multifamily properties with detached garages or accessory structures.
The area is also home to several unique communities, including newly developed townhouse and mixed-use projects, mobile home communities, and large senior housing developments with full podium parking and private open space.
The Bellflower Boulevard portion (between Jefferson Street and Palm Street) of the Specific Plan area is almost exclusively commercial, and other commercial uses are located along Alondra Boulevard, and Flower Street to Palm Street (adjacent SR-91 to the south). These commercial properties are primarily one- and two-story retail shops with stucco facades, occasionally accented with brick or stone trim. Much of the storefront signage and facades along Bellflower Boulevard match the historic design aesthetic of the 1950s. Newer properties and businesses have modern facades and signage, creating a variable design character.
The Bellflower Boulevard corridor south of the PE ROW has a pedestrian-oriented atmosphere, but retail shops north of the ROW are set back from the street, with large parking lots and busy intersections.
This creates an “auto centric” feeling and provides a gradual transition to the character of the Alondra Boulevard corridor, which caters to regional drivers and high speeds while providing a mix of retail, office, and auto-related businesses. The south portion of the Boulevard, starting at Park Street includes automotive repair, auto sales, and service station uses, as well as retail and office uses. The Flower Street corridor has clusters of small, one-story retail strip centers and detached commercial properties interspersed among residential properties. Storefront facades and signage are less elaborate than the Bellflower corridor’s and lack an overall curb appeal.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-9
FIGURE 1.3 Local Context
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-10
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-11
FIGURE 1.4 Specific Plan Area
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-12
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-13
The Specific Plan area is home to Bellflower’s active Civic Center, which gives residents and visitors access to administration offices, the courthouse, and the public library. The Civic Center is also equipped with a public parking structure and surface lots. Although the surface lots and employee-designated areas of the structure are often near capacity, the majority of the parking structure is underutilized.
Additional analysis about parking utilization throughout the area can be found in Appendix C. The specific plan area does not include any school facilities but does provide a United States Post Office and several religious institutions.
The Specific Plan area benefits from three parks and a large linear open space. Library Garden is near the Civic Center and provides a place for programmed activities themed around literature and story-telling.
Pirate Park is an interactive, themed pocket park centrally located along Bellflower Boulevard, close to shopping and restaurants. John S. Simms Parks is in a residential neighborhood along the western boundary of the Specific Plan area. Simms Park provides the community with sports fields, indoor auditoriums and multi-purpose rooms, playgrounds, outdoor gym equipment, a walking trail, and picnic areas. Lastly, the large linear open space is adjacent the future light rail path and spans from the City’s easterly boundary, starting from the south end of Caruthers Park to Lakewood Boulevard to the west. The linear open space includes a bike/walk/run trail with landscaping.
1.5.4 MARKET ANALYSIS SUMMARY
In order to capitalize on the economic potential that typically accompanies transit development, the City conducted a market demand analysis in preparation for this Specific Plan (Appendix B). The market analysis, completed in 2016, provides an understanding of the market forces influencing demand for new development and redevelopment in the downtown area. The understanding of market forces, in turn, will influence the types of uses and standards for development that the Specific Plan will accommodate and regulate.
The 2016 market analysis covers commercial uses, including shopping, dining, entertainment, and office-based professional services. These are the types of activities one typically expects in a conventional downtown area. The market analysis does not cover residential development— current residential development projects and interest from developers pursuing or proposing entitlement of future residential development indicate there is current market demand and potential market demand going forward. The market analysis also does not cover industrial development—industrial uses typically require large areas of land, large facilities, and larger roadways and freeway access for trucks, development characteristics that conflict with the human-scale pedestrian-friendly character of the existing downtown area.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-14
1.5.5 RETAIL DEMAND
Currently, downtown Bellflower functions partly as a convenience goods and services district and partly as an experience-oriented district.
Many of the stores sell convenience goods or are restaurants, not unlike a typical strip center. But historic downtown Bellflower is very walkable, has a variety of dining options, and provides recreation and entertainment.
Strip centers prioritize easy auto access to quickly get in, satisfy a material need, and get out. In contrast, experience-oriented districts may not be as easily accessible by automobile because they prioritize ease and comfort of pedestrian circulation within the district. More importantly, recreation and entertainment—that is, things to do other than shopping— distinguish an experience-oriented shopping district from a convenience goods shopping center. Historic Bellflower already offers something unique and as such it is well-positioned to attract people in an experience-oriented climate.
By facilitating transit-oriented development in the downtown area, the Specific Plan can improve and augment the area’s experience value. For experience-oriented shopping, the specific plan should encourage a mix of dining and entertainment, convenience goods, and boutique-scale comparison goods retailers. Ideally, the downtown area will attract people from the transit station and provide a place for nearby workers and residents to gather, eat, and quickly buy convenience goods.
1.5.6 MARKET ANALYSIS
To capitalize on the market demand and support the continued transition of the downtown into an experience-oriented shopping district, a 2016 Market Analysis offers a number of general suggestions for the Specific Plan:
» Encourage a mix of dining and entertainment, convenience goods, and boutique-scale comparison goods retailers,
specifically focusing business attraction efforts on specialty food stores, health and personal care stores, restaurants, and bars. » Continue to improve the experience of shopping in downtown in order to expand the trade area and attract consumer spending from a larger area.
» Capitalize on the experience value of shopping and spending time in downtown and in the planned rail station to attract office-based businesses.
» Continue to provide opportunities for a variety of housing types within the specific plan area—especially adjacent to the future station area.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-15
The following recommendations included in the 2016 Market Analysis were incorporated in this Specific plan:
» Seek to accommodate up to 76,000 to 116,000 square feet of new retail building space and up to 73,000 to 92,000 square feet of new office space.
» Implement a parking management plan that maximizes existing resources, accommodates sufficient public and on-site parking for buildout development, and provides easy and comfortable pedestrian connections between parking areas and downtown businesses.
» Ensure that there are adequate plazas and public spaces for events and activities.
» Establish development standards that create and maintain a human-scale, pedestrian-friendly, architecturally attractive physical environment.
» Provide public realm improvements, including bike parking and street and pedestrian lighting, that encourage a variety of transportation options and sidewalks, street furniture, gathering spaces, and landscaping that encourage and facilitate a pleasant and relaxing experience.
In addition, the specific plan can provide a framework for implementation. Specifically, the specific plan should provide direction to:
» Form an incentive program for complementary businesses to locate in downtown, similar to the current restaurant incentive program.
» Support the establishment of a business improvement district, or similar entity, that funds and operates public relations and advertising to market downtown Bellflower to residents
throughout the subregion.
1.6 RELATIONSHIP TO EXISTING REGULATORY
PROVISIONS AND PLANNING DOCUMENTS
The Specific Plan was prepared to provide a critical link between the City’s General Plan, and actual development in the Specific Plan area. As a regulatory document, the Specific Plan implements the General Plan, and serves as the zoning thereby consolidating the land use regulations and removing development constraints within the Specific Plan area.. A detailed Existing Conditions Report is provided in Appendix A.
1.6.1 BELLFLOWER GENERAL PLAN
The City of Bellflower General Plan was adopted in 1994 as a guide for private and public development throughout the City.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-16
The Land Use Element establishes goals, policies, and implementation programs that define how new development and redevelopment will occur. Certain policies in the Land Use Element promote development in the Town Center core, striving to create a community hub where residents and visitors can come together to shop, socialize, and seek entertainment and civic services.
In 1997, Metro conducted transit studies to identify areas of opportunity for expansion. Bellflower acknowledged the potential impact of regional transit development and prioritized the goal of providing residents and businesses with convenient and viable public transportation options by: maintaining the current level of transit service provided by the City; promoting the development of a multimodal transit center with downtown redevelopment plans; and enhancing the transit system’s operations and efficiency. The General Plan anticipated the future development being considered with this Specific Plan.
1.6.1.1 LAND USE ELEMENT
The General Plan Land Use Map (see Figure 1.5) shows several land use designations in the Specific Plan area. Residential land use designations include the following: “L” Low Density Residential (0 - 6.2 DU /net AC [dwelling units per net acre]), “M” Medium Density Residential (8.7–14 DU/net AC), “H” High Density Residential (14–22 DU/net AC), “MU” Mixed-Use for both residential and non-residential uses, and “SC” Senior Citizen Housing (0–65 DU/net AC).
Within the Specific Plan area, the primary non-residential land use designation is “C” Commercial. The Commercial designation emphasize the development of major retail centers, supermarkets, personal services, and financial institutions, typically within shopping centers or along major arterial roadways. Although the Town Center land use designation is Commercial, the focus in the area is preserving and enhancing the historic character and charm of the downtown district by encouraging the development of specialty stores, restaurants, and entertainment facilities.
Additional non-residential land use designations in the Specific Plan area include Public/Quasi Public and Open Space. The Public/Quasi Public land use designations include the Bellflower Civic Center, which houses the City’s post office, health center, courthouses, library, and administrative offices; other allowed uses include public and private schools, hospitals, fire stations and museums. The Open Space designation encourages the development of public parks, utility easements, and transportation corridors. The Open Space designation is
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-17
vital to this Specific Plan, because it is utilized for the development of the forthcoming transit line along the PE ROW.
As discussed in the following section, the Housing Element increased the maximum densities in four specified areas within the downtown area and commits to expanding the Specific Plan boundaries. The underlying land use designation for these four downtown and additional expanded boundary areas is “MU” Mixed Use.
1.6.1.2 HOUSING ELEMENT
The Housing Element identifies long-term housing goals and short-term policies to facilitate housing production in the City. The Specific Plan includes four of the 12 HOAs, which are identified as: HOA 5 (Bellflower Boulevard / Alondra Boulevard), HOA 7 (Bellflower Boulevard / Flower Street), HOA 11 (Bellflower Station), and HOA 12 (Woodruff Avenue / Flora Vista Street). The Housing Element increased the maximum densities allowed for these four HOAs. To ensure consistency with the approved Housing Element, this Specific Plan has been amended to increase the maximum densities allowed within the four HOAs and to expand the boundaries of the Specific Plan to include additional contiguous areas in the City.
1.6.2 BELLFLOWER MUNICIPAL CODE (“BMC”)
The BMC identifies and defines various zones throughout the City. The BMC also provides additional zoning regulations for other areas within the Specific Plan. The Specific Plan consolidates and replaces these zoning regulations and documents that apply to the Specific Plan area.
The following discusses these particular zones and zoning documents.
1.6.2.1 EXISTING ZONING DESIGNATIONS
Consistent with the existing General Plan land use designations, the majority of the Specific Plan area is regulated by those zoning designations found in the BMC, including Low, Medium, and Multiple Residential, General Commercial, and Light Industrial.
1.6.2.2 TOWN CENTER DISTRICT DESIGNATION
The Town Center District is also considered traditional zoning and consists of traditional downtown core where buildings are typically adjacent to the sidewalk, and eclectic mix of “modern” commercial establishments that lack pedestrian amenities.
1.6.2.3 BELLFLOWER VILLAGE OVERLAY ZONE
DESIGNATION (BVOZ)
The Bellflower Village Overlay Zone (BVOZ) allows properties to be developed and operated in compliance with the standard underlying
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-18
zone or take advantage of new provisions in this overlay zone (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met.
Development within this overlay zone is optional and is voluntarily triggered by a developer. The BVOZ is centrally located in the study area and encompasses three blocks on the east side of Bellflower Boulevard between Flower Street and Arkansas Street. The area is fully developed with commercial retail uses, office, and residential land uses. The BVOZ served as a tool to create the incentive for the reuse of land within the overlay zone boundaries where conventional and traditional zoning techniques may not accomplish the goals set forth in the Town Center District.
The intent of the BVOZ was to encourage the development and redevelopment of the City’s downtown area into a creative, vital and visionary neighborhood featuring a robust mix of residential and commercial uses. The intent of this designation is to accommodate and promote traditional specialty retail uses, enhance pedestrian activities through street furniture, landscape, and hardscape amenities, promote entertainment activities, respect established traditional building designs, encourage well designed and pedestrian-oriented signage and promote inviting storefront design. Commercial retail uses are encouraged on the ground floor with offices or residential uses on upper floors. Downtown uses are intended to stimulate commerce by promoting a mixture of specialty stores, restaurants, offices, and entertainment facilities designed to attract people and enhance the pedestrian experience.
Incentives include greater building height, the ability to incorporate residential uses into the project, and/or the ability to transfer some off- street parking obligations to another location. The BVOZ requires projects to include a public open space amenity or some form of physical interface for pedestrians. These are values that the City wants to maintain and potentially expand in the Specific Plan area. The BVOZ refined the list of allowable uses previously identified in the Town Center District and modified some development standards, including minimum lot size, setbacks, and building height.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-19
FIGU RE 1.5 General Plan Land Use
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-20
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-21
1.6.2.4 BELLFLOWER VILLAGE OVERLAY ZONE-NORTH
DESIGNATION (BVOZ-N)
The Bellflower Village Overlay Zone-North (BVOZ-N) allows properties to be developed and operated in compliance with the standard underlying zone or take advantage of new provisions in this overlay zone (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met.
Development within this overlay zone is optional and is voluntarily triggered by a developer. The BVOZ-N encompasses a four-block area along Bellflower Boulevard between Flower Street to the south and the PE ROW to the north, immediately north of the BVOZ. The BVOZ-N reemphasizes many of the same principles originally articulated in the BVOZ, including a distinct focus on the pedestrian experience and creative parking strategies. It modified some development standards from the underlying standards identified in the Town Center District, including setbacks (which were reduced to zero) and building heights (two stories taller than allowed in the Town Center District, and one story taller than allowed in the BVOZ).
The existing standards and incentives also support transit-oriented development by increasing the number of allowable stories to four (and conditionally allowing up to five stories), and by allowing for multi- family residential use .
The intent of the BVOZ-N was to encourage the development and redevelopment of the City’s downtown area into a creative, vital and visionary neighborhood featuring a robust mix of residential and commercial uses. The intent of this designation is to accommodate and promote traditional specialty retail uses, enhance pedestrian activities through street furniture, landscape, and hardscape amenities, promote entertainment activities, respect established traditional building designs, encourage well designed and pedestrian-oriented signage and promote inviting storefront design. Downtown uses are intended to stimulate commerce by promoting a mixture of specialty stores, restaurants, offices, and entertainment facilities designed to attract people and enhance the pedestrian experience.
Several projects were developed by implementing this Overlay Zone, including the all-residential development at 9825 Oak Street, 16510-14 Adenmoor Avenue and a mixed-use development at 16632 Bellflower Boulevard.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-22
1.6.2.5 BELLFLOWER/ALONDRA MIXED-USE OVERLAY
ZONE DESIGNATION (BAMU)
The Bellflower/Alondra Mixed-Use Overlay Zone (BAMU) allows properties to be developed and operated in compliance with the standard underlying zone or take advantage of new provisions in this overlay zone (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met. Development within this overlay zone is optional and is voluntarily triggered by a developer. The BAMU applies to the area bounded by Alondra Boulevard to the north, the Pacific Electric rail corridor to the south, Stevens Avenue to the west, and Woodruff Avenue to the east. The BAMU is intended to provide opportunities for the development of horizontally or vertically integrated mixed-use projects near transit, along corridors, and around activity centers.
Commercial retail uses are encouraged on the ground floor, with offices or residential uses on upper floors. Residential development is also encouraged to enhance the availability of for-sale and rental housing to a variety of income levels.
Walkability and access to public transit are paramount in site design.
Multi-use projects need to be integrated into an overall project design and connected to other adjoining uses by plazas, promenades, and landscaped corridors.
The BAMU includes a “residential subarea” where the minimum residential density is 40 DU/AC.
1.6.3 BELLFLOWER-PARAMOUNT BIKE & TRAIL MASTER
PLAN
The cities of Bellflower and Paramount have recognized that bicycling is an important part of daily transportation for residents, commuters, and visitors. Together, the two cities drafted the Bellflower-Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan. The plan aims to increase transportation options, improve safety and public health, and foster a stronger sense of community by improving bikeways, intersections and crossings, bicycle parking, and wayfinding programs. When addressing approaches to multimodal connectivity, this Specific Plan will use the Bellflower- Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan to guide policy and program recommendations.
1.7 AUTHORITY AND SCOPE
This Specific Plan was prepared in conformity with Government Code §§ 65451, et seq. Together with the zoning regulations adopted by the Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”), and other applicable law, this Specific Plan sets forth the regulations for development within the various overlay zones identified by this document. The California Government Code states that a “Specific Plan shall include a statement of the relationship of the Specific Plan to the General Plan, and further,
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-21
that it may not be adopted or amended unless found to be consistent with the General Plan.” This Specific Plan document is designed to be consistent with the City of Bellflower General Plan goals and policies. An overview of the Specific Plan’s consistency with the General Plan is in Chapter 8.
In response to the Government Code, this Specific Plan provides an essential link between City of Bellflower policies and development in the Specific Plan area. Functioning as a regulatory document, the Specific Plan provides a means of implementing the City of Bellflower General Plan and detailing specific requirements and guidelines for future development in the Specific Plan area. All future development plans, tentative parcel and/or maps, or other similar entitlements must be consistent with regulations set forth in this document and with all applicable City regulations.
1.8 ACTION EXPECTATIONS
The policies, standards, and guidelines in this Specific Plan define action expectations to successfully implement the specific plan. The following terms clarify the level of commitment intended and reflect the expectation or desired outcome. The application of a term to a particular policy action is a deliberate application of its definition.
1. “Must” is mandatory;
2. “May” is permissive;
3. “May not” means not permitted to;
4. “Will” expresses a future contingency or predicts action by the City or person in the ordinary course of events, but does not signify a mandatory duty; and
5. “Should” expresses a preference or a nonbinding
recommendation.
1.9 SPECIFIC PLAN ORGANIZATION
Chapter 1—Introduction & Background
Provides a history of the project area and regional transit context while summarizing public outreach efforts and market demand analysis. It includes the Specific Plan’s purpose and intent, authority and scope, and relationship to the City of Bellflower General Plan. It identifies the specific plan area and describes an overview of existing conditions.
Chapter 2—Vision & Objectives
Reveals the community’s vision by outlining the purpose and objectives of the Specific Plan.
Chapter 3—Land Use Plan
Outlines permitted land uses, residential and nonresidential real estate forecasts, and opportunities and constraints to future development.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-22
Chapter 4—Allowable Uses and Development Standards
Presents a comprehensive set of regulations governing the use and development of land within the Specific Plan area.
Chapter 5—Mobility Plan
Details multimodal mobility improvements, future transit and pedestrian connections, and analyzes existing and future parking demand.
Chapter 6—Infrastructure Plan
Focuses on the major infrastructure systems, including storm drain, wastewater, and water, and the impact future development could have on these systems.
Chapter 7—Design Guidelines
Guides the physical design related to site configuration and building design, streetscape design, public spaces, and parking.
Chapter 8—Administration & Implementation
Explains the process for project approvals, amendments, and interpretations and identifies funding and financing mechanisms, a list of implementation actions, and anticipated phasing. Includes an analysis of General Plan consistency.
Appendix A—Existing Conditions Report
Provides an overview of existing characteristics and trends in the specific plan area, and identifies opportunities and constraints that should be addressed in the Specific Plan.
Appendix B—Market Demand Analysis
Presents a summary of the market forces influencing demand for new development and redevelopment within the project area.
Appendix C—Parking Management Plan
Provides a summary of existing parking conditions and makes recommendations for effective management of parking resources to accommodate the future parking needs within the specific plan area.
Appendix D—Town Center Design Guidelines
The Town Center Design Guidelines were adopted in 1996. This document provided methods, materials, and other guidelines to encourage the development of a unified identity for center of Bellflower.
Appendix E & Appendix F — Infrastructure Technical Report & Infrastructure Technical Report Amendment
These reports include structural Best Management Practices (BMPs) and Low Impact Development (LID) strategies.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Introduction & Background
1-21
Appendix G— City of Bellflower Parking Management Plan
Provides a summary of existing parking conditions and makes recommendations for effective management of parking resources to accommodate the future parking needs within the specific plan area.
Appendix H—Alternate Parking Management Plan
Provides a summary of existing parking conditions and makes recommendations for effective management of parking resources.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
DRAFT | SEPTEMBER 2019 43
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-1
Downtown Bellflower is the heart and hub of the community and it has only grown stronger and more vital since the opening of the Downtown Bellflower Station. It is safe, walkable, attractive, and economically thriving. It is a frequent destination for Bellflower residents and employees, as well as the thousands of transit riders passing through the station each month. The area has a unique blend of
businesses that serve local residents and attract neighboring communities eager to visit the latest shop or restaurant and stroll the boulevard. Together with its neighborhoods of new and established homes, there is a renewed sense of
community that makes Bellflower a very desirable place to live and do business in southeast Los Angeles.
Many residents have planted deep roots here, and the
established neighborhoods of Bellflower, along with the new transit station are the downtown’s anchor. Clusters of retail shops, restaurants, outdoor gathering areas, and other local- serving businesses along the downtown area create fun
places to gather with friends and family. Grown children come back to live, work, start businesses, and raise families because of their strong ties to the community and desirability of the neighborhoods.
2. VISION AND OBJECTIVES
2.1 VISION
The Specific Plan for the Downtown Bellflower Station Area begins with a vision—a vision that describes the community’s aspirations for how this historic core area will look and function in the future, especially with a light rail station providing direct and convenient access to destinations along the corridor as well as throughout Los Angeles via the Metro Rail system. Change is coming to Bellflower, not only in terms of the future transit option, but also in terms of the new market opportunities that come with it for transit-supportive residential, commercial, office, and destination-related uses. These changes are expected to take place over the next 25 years and this Specific Plan is the foundation and primary tool for implementing these changes. The vision for this highly valued area is:
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-2
The first time you enter the downtown area from either
Alondra Boulevard or the 91 Freeway, you know you have
arrived someplace special. What used to be vacant or
rundown buildings along Bellflower Boulevard have been
transformed to a thriving commercial and residential corridor that is inviting and safe to walk, cross, ride a bike, or take transit. The new transit station has been integrated into the downtown environment and works efficiently in
accommodating the parking and bus transfer needs of riders on a daily basis. Numerous plazas, paseos, pocket parks, and outdoor eating areas have sprung up as integral parts of each new development project. Improved bike facilities in the Specific Plan area connect to a citywide system of bike paths connecting schools, parks, transit, and destinations along the boulevard. These improvements also promote a healthy
lifestyle throughout the community. The improved lighting, landscaping, and signage that was once only along a short segment of Bellflower Boulevard has now been expanded in the study area to add to the appeal and enhance wayfinding.
The improvements to Bellflower Boulevard and the light rail station have created a setting for new high-quality residences in the study area. This housing has replaced aging and
obsolete buildings and added new life and activity to the street. The new housing complements the mix of uses along the corridors and is compatible with adjacent single-family homes. This new housing supports local businesses, provides a mix of densities, increases our property values, and meets the high demand for housing in our community.
Community pride is unmistakable—just attend a downtown
event, look at our neighborhoods and streets, or talk with a local business owner. Downtown Bellflower and the new
transit station is truly the heart and hub of the community.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-3
2.2 OBJECTIVES
The Vision for the Downtown Bellflower Station Area Specific Plan has been translated into a series of objectives that has guided the detailed provisions of this document. The objectives are related to land use, urban design, zoning, mobility/transit, infrastructure, and long-term implementation:
» Plan for High-Quality Transit and a Transit-Supporting Environment
» Boost the Economy and “Rediscover the Downtown”
» Extend Public Realm Improvements
» Provide for a Balanced Mix of Uses
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-4
2.2.1 PLAN FOR HIGH-QUALITY TRANSIT AND A TRANSIT-
SUPPORTING ENVIRONMENT
The Downtown Bellflower Station will be one of the stations along the West Santa Ana Branch Transit Corridor. Located along Bellflower Boulevard within the downtown area, the station will serve residents and workers in the City, connecting them to destinations in the greater Metro service area. Studies have shown that transit corridors and systems that provide direct connections to a region’s downtown or major employment centers are significantly more likely to attract new development and have higher ridership compared to transit lines that do not serve a central business district. Other factors that influence the potential for a transit-oriented development (“TOD”) include the market strength of a transit station area, the availability of appropriate opportunity sites, zoning regulations that support TOD, connectivity, and local government support. This Specific Plan addresses each of those factors and sets forth a regulatory, policy, and design framework within a half-mile radius of the station that supports transit and maximizes the economic development potential and ridership potential it brings.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-5
2.2.2 BOOST THE ECONOMY AND “REDISCOVER THE
DOWNTOWN”
A Downtown Revitalization Vision Strategy was prepared in 2003 and contained a series of specific land use and design strategies to help the downtown become a “completely original” place in southeast Los Angeles. As summarized in Chapter 1, many of its initiatives were completed. However, the Great Recession and the ending of redevelopment agencies as a local tool significantly slowed progress in revitalizing the area. Recently, several new restaurants, a residential/retail mixed-use project, and streetscape improvements have attracted new interest in the downtown. The citizens of Bellflower have been encouraged by these changes and are anxious to see empty buildings filled with new and stable businesses, and the redevelopment of underutilized sites with additional retail and housing clustered in the downtown area. Downtown Bellflower has the potential to distinguish itself as an experience-oriented district—one that prioritizes the ease and comfort of pedestrians and includes not only shopping and dining but recreation and entertainment. An objective for this Specific Plan is to facilitate transit-oriented development, which can improve and augment the area’s experience value. The Specific Plan lays the foundation, through updated regulations and economic incentives, to allow for a variety of new residential development—in the right locations—to boost demand for quality restaurants, coffee houses, grocery stores, and other food/beverage and retail venues. In addition, the Specific Plan is intended to support current and future economic programs offered by the City to increase the rate of new business formation, attract new businesses to the area, and assist in building- retrofit costs. The Specific Plan is also intended to address the struggling corridors that tie into Bellflower Boulevard. Some of the uses along Alondra Boulevard in particular are in a state of decline and need to transition to higher and better uses in the future.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-6
2.2.3 EXTEND PUBLIC REALM IMPROVEMENTS
A segment of Bellflower Boulevard between the Pacific Electric Right of Way and Flower Street was significantly upgraded with street trees and planters, widened sidewalks, seating areas, bulb-outs, and pedestrian safety features, including street lights, crosswalks, and accessible intersections. The street design calms traffic entering the downtown and sets the stage for an inviting shopping and dining environment. An objective of the Specific Plan is to identify additional street segments in the area that should be upgraded to improve connectivity to the transit station and other destinations. Improved street design is an essential ingredient to attracting new investment and ensuring that new uses will orient to and activate the street. These public realm improvements will also include concepts for entry monuments at the corners of Alondra Boulevard and Bellflower Boulevard to announce the entrance into the downtown. In addition to improvements to existing streets, the Specific Plan addresses connectivity into and around the future transit station as well as the potential for new street or pedestrian connections to Bellflower Boulevard.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
2-7
2.2.4 PROVIDE FOR A BALANCED MIX OF USES
An overarching objective of the Specific Plan is to provide for a better balance of land uses that will be supported by the current and future market. Some new local restaurants, coffee houses, and retail shops have struggled to survive over the last few years. While the City has invested in streetscape improvements, offered incentives to locate in the downtown, and created new zoning to attract development, there has been insufficient demand from existing residents and employees to sustain those uses. This Specific Plan re-examines the land use mix and provides greater flexibility for stand-alone residential projects to be built in and near the downtown. There is future demand for a wide range of housing types, including row-towns, courtyard housing, and multistory flats with above- and underground parking. And the demand for housing will continue to increase as the Eco-Rapid Line is implemented. The Specific Plan tailors the zoning to encourage new housing that will “fit” with the area, be sensitive to nearby single-family neighborhoods, and create a sustained demand for retail and services in the downtown. Along with new housing, the Specific Plan allows the potential for an increase in office demand as businesses increasingly look for locations within walkable commercial environments and near transit.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Visions and Objectives
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-1
3. LAND USE PLAN
The Specific Plan establishes a framework that will allow the City to take advantage of the economic and quality of life benefits from the future Bellflower Transit Station. This section establishes the intent of the Specific Plan’s future land use and the quality and character of new development or reuse, thus, allowing for greater flexibility for future projects to respond to the market, as the area evolves with the future inclusion of light rail. The Specific Plan also facilitates future construction of additional residential units consistent with the City’s approved 2021-2029 Housing Element and the City’s RHNA goals.
3.1 OBJECTIVES & POLICIES
The Vision and Guiding Principles established in Chapter 2 have informed the land use objectives and policies contained below. The objectives and policies are also consistent with the General Plan. The policies serve as tools to help the City achieve the specific plan vision.
The following lists the major land use objectives and policies for the Specific Plan:
OBJECTIVE 1: Create an experience-oriented district around the future Eco-Rapid Line and Downtown Bellflower that reinforces and promotes the specific plan area as a desirable and economically vital place to live, work, visit, and create businesses. » Policy 1.1: Develop and maintain a cohesive street and building design identity.
» Policy 1.2: Encourage development that offers housing, shopping, employment, and business development options for residents and visitors.
» Policy 1.3: Encourage appropriately-scaled infill and mixed-use development.
» Policy 1.4: Accommodate the development of uses that meet the needs of businesses and residents. This includes retail, dining, healthy food, recreation, entertainment, and housing options. » Policy 1.5: Accommodate growth within a half mile of the station area and commercial corridors that respects and responds to the existing scale and density of the neighborhood.
» Policy 1.6: Develop and maintain gateway elements.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-2
OBJECTIVE 2: Encourage a mix of uses in proximity to the transit station and along major streets that benefit from the economic opportunities afforded by the presence of the future Eco-Rapid Line, a vibrant Downtown, and the Bellflower Civic Center. » Policy 2.1: Consolidate and implement those zoning regulations and development-related documents that apply to the Specific Plan area, and allow for flexible standards.
» Policy 2.2: Promote Flower Street as a corridor with a mix of uses that compliments existing and future development.
» Policy 2.3: Coordinate with Metro on a public plaza and an area with shopping, employment, and housing opportunities at the future Bellflower Station.
» Policy 2.4: Scrutinize development plans that have significant impact on the City to ensure the highest quality design. » Policy 2.5: Promote the use of current and future economic tools provided by the City to assist with building-retrofit costs and establish new businesses in appropriate locations.
» Policy 2.6: Encourage the redevelopment or adaptive reuse of aging or obsolete buildings.
OBJECTIVE 3: Create a pedestrian-oriented and active public realm.
» Policy 3.1: Encourage the design of pedestrian-oriented facades and uses at street level where appropriate.
» Policy 3.2: Encourage the investment in public art.
» Policy 3.3: Coordinate with the Public Works Department and private developers on changes to the right-of-way to ensure that future streetscape and development projects include sidewalks, wayfinding signage, and pedestrian amenities that enhance the public realm.
Policy 3.4: Expand the public gathering space options through the development of the Bellflower Station Plaza and future
development opportunities.
3.2 PLANNING AREAS
The Specific Plan area is characterized by several land use and zoning designations. The Specific Plan consolidates these designations into one document and also provides flexible development and design regulations that facilitate increased residential construction, mixed-
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-3
uses, good quality design, and encourage new investment and opportunities. To accomplish this, this Specific Plan is divided into five different Planning Areas based on varied mixed land uses and development densities and standards. This Specific Plan and these Planning Areas will continue to allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. In this way, this Specific Plan and the Planning Areas afford those property owners within the Specific Plan more flexibility, since they will be able to develop either according to those design and development standards as established by the BMC, or those flexible provisions and requirements established by this Specific Plan. Again, the intent of this Specific Plan is to provide flexibility to future developers, at the same time, ensuring good quality design and more varied and marketable mixed use development. The following describes the five Planning Areas.
3.2.1 Planning Area 1
Planning Area 1 is bounded by Alondra Boulevard to the north, the Pacific Electric rail corridor to the south, Stevens Avenue to the west, and Woodruff Avenue to the east. Planning Area 1 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing underlying land use standards or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met. Planning Area 1 is intended to provide opportunities for the development of horizontally or vertically integrated mixed-use projects near transit, along corridors, and around activity centers. Commercial retail uses are encouraged on the ground floor, with offices or residential uses on upper floors. Residential development is also encouraged to enhance the availability of for-sale and rental housing to a variety of income levels.
The areas that are within Planning Area 1 include the following zones:
C-G (General Commercial), M-1 (Light Industrial), R-3 (Multiple Residential), and SCH (Senior Citizen Housing) by the BMC. As discussed, these areas can continue to be developed according to these same zoning designations, or may utilize other more flexible development and design standards if certain conditions are met.
These development and design standards are further discussed in Chapter 4. The following describes the intent of these zoning designations:
C-G (General Commercial): Intended to provide adequate areas along Bellflower’s primary corridors to serve the convenience commercial and service needs of the community and the surrounding area. This includes shopping centers with a major tenant, such as a supermarket
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-4
and/or drug store and includes ancillary activities such as retail sales, eating establishments, household goods, personal services, and financial institutions
M-1 (Light Industrial): Intended to provide for the development and establishment of base of the City. These uses include fabrication, manufacturing, assembly or processing of materials that are in processed form and which do not in their maintenance, assembly, manufacture or plant operation create smoke, gas, odor, dust, sound, vibration, soot or lighting to any degree which might be termed obnoxious or offensive to any person residing in, or conducting business in, this or any other zoning district in the City.
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Intended to provide for quality, well- designed multifamily living environments, as either condominiums or apartments. Typified by townhomes, courtyard housing and stacked- flats near transit and other services. Housing within this designation will bring people into close living arrangements, therefore, dwelling unit privacy, outdoor common and private open space, security, and overall quality design will be of the utmost importance. Density is 14- 22 du/ac.
SCH (Senior Citizen Housing): This designation represents existing senior citizen housing projects that have formerly been designated as an R-3 SCH District pursuant to Chapter 17.36 of the Bellflower Municipal Code. Density is 0-65 du/ac.
3.2.2 Planning Area 2
Planning Area 2 is located along Bellflower Boulevard, and is bounded by Rendalia Street to the north, Flora Vista Street to the west, Stevens Avenue to the east, and Pacific Avenue to the south. Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 2 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 2 area. Similar to Planning Area 1, future development within Planning Area 2 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met.
Planning Area 2 intends to provide easy access to both the transit station and Bellflower’s downtown and foster mixed-use development with high-density residential, retail and services, an outdoor plaza/dining area, and parking for the transit station.
The areas within Planning Area 2 are zoned T-C (Bellflower Town Center), C-G (General Commercial), M-1 (Light Industrial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and R-3 (Multiple Residential) by the BMC. As discussed, these areas can continue to be developed according to these same zoning designations, or may utilize other more flexible development and design standards if certain conditions are met. These development
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-5
and design standards are further discussed in Chapter 4. The following describes the intent of these zoning designations:
T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Intended to provide for the redevelopment of the City’s downtown area by allowing traditional retail storefronts that orient towards Bellflower Boulevard, and parking lots located behind. Also allows for specialty retail stores, offices, and restaurants.
C-G (General Commercial): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. M-1 (Light Industrial): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 1.
R-1 (Low Density Residential): Intended to provide an attractive, healthy and safe environment featuring single-family detached homes and complementary recreational, religious, educational and other community facilities that are the basic elements of a balanced neighborhood. Density is 0-8.7 du /ac.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Establishes a density range that supports the development of quality, well-designed detached and attached living environments as either condominium or apartments, near transit and other services. Example residential types include, but are not limited to: small-lot single-family detached homes, single- family attached homes (duplexes), garden apartments, townhouses, and courtyard housing. Density is 8.7-14 du/ac.
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. 3.2.3 Planning Area 3
Planning Area 3 is located is located between Flower Street to the north and the 91 Freeway to the south. Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 3 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 3 area.
Similar to Planning Areas 1 and 2, future development within Planning Area 3 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met. Planning Area 3 allows for joint development of residential, retail and service uses and is intended to provide convenient access to transit for residents, as well as encourage businesses that cater to fast-paced, on-the-go transit riders who are seeking convenient goods and services.
The areas within Planning Area 3 are zoned T-C (Bellflower Town Center), C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), and R-2 (Medium Density Residential) by the BMC. As discussed, these areas can continue to be developed according to these same zoning designations, or may utilize other more flexible development and design standards if certain conditions are met. These development
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-6
and design standards are further discussed in Chapter 4. The following describes the intent of these zoning designations:
T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
C-G (General Commercial): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. R-1 (Low Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
3.2.4 Planning Area 4
Planning Area 4 is located along the north and south side of Flower Street from Clark Avenue to west of Bellflower Boulevard and on the south side of Flower Street from west of Bellflower Boulevard to Woodruff Avenue. Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 4 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 4 area. Similar to Planning Areas 1, 2, and 3, future development within Planning Area 4 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Planning Area 4 is envisioned as a walkable residential and commercial corridor that provides local services and employment along with multifamily living. The standards are intended to provide a single plan that guides the incremental transition into a pedestrian-friendly environment and provides property owners a mix of uses to flexibly reinvest within the area.
The areas within Planning Area 4 are zoned C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and R-3 (Multiple Residential) by the BMC. As discussed, these areas can continue to be developed according to these same zoning designations, or may utilize other more flexible development and design standards if certain conditions are met. These development and design standards are further discussed in Chapter 4. The following describes the intent of these zoning designations:
C-G (General Commercial): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. R-1 (Low Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-7
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. 3.2.5 Planning Area 5 (BMC Zoning)
Planning Area 5 is generally located along the west, north, and central portions of the Specific Plan. Properties within Planning Area 5 are regulated by the same standards that correspond with the following standards found in the BMC: C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), R-3 (Multiple Residential), T-C (Bellflower Town Center), O-S (Open Space), P (Public Uses), and SCH (Senior Citizen Housing) zones. Development standards and further discussions for Planning Area 5 can be found in Chapter 4.
C-G (General Commercial): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. R-1 (Low Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area
1. T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 2.
O-S (Open Space): This designation is applied to the existing parks within the area as well as the Pacific Electric Right-of-Way which includes a multi-purpose trail. The intent is to recognize that open space land within the City is a limited and valuable resource which must be conserved wherever possible. This designation may also include public or quasi-public recreation centers.
P (Public Uses): This zoning includes public and/or quasi-public uses.
Intended to protect and perpetuate institutional uses maintained and operated by Federal, State, County, District, City and other public agencies. It can also include libraries, museums, and educational uses.
SCH (Senior Citizen Housing): Refer to same discussion in Planning Area 1.
Figure 3.1 presents the locations of the five Planning Areas. Figure 3.2 presents the BMC zoning designations for the Specific Plan.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-8
FIGURE 3.1 Planning Areas
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-9
FIGURE 3.2 Zoning and Planning Areas
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-10
3.3 FUTURE METRO TRANSIT STATION
As Metro continues to plan for the final location/configuration of the station and associated parking, the City has identified the northwest corner of Bellflower Boulevard and the Pacific Electric right-of-way as a preferred location. Access to the station and future residential component is a challenge given the existing development pattern.
Therefore, internal circulation would require a solution involving multiple properties. Figure 3.3 is an illustrative demonstrating the potential for a joint development project between Metro and a developer, and redevelopment of adjacent parcels.
FIGURE 3.3 Conceptual Location of Transit Station
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-11
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
3-12
Image 1 Bouleva complem
furnitur
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-1
4. ALLOWABLE USES & DEVELOPMENT
STANDARDS
4.1 PURPOSE
This chapter provides detailed regulations for development and land uses within the Specific Plan area and describes how these regulations will be used as part of the City’s review process. The development standards are intended to implement the vision and objectives as stated in Chapter 2 of this Specific Plan.
These regulations were crafted to produce the types of development and revitalization envisioned by the City through a combination of traditional and form-based regulations.
4.2 ALLOWABLE USES AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR PLANNING AREAS
This chapter presents the allowable uses and development standards applicable to the Specific Plan area.
These allowable uses and development standards supersede all provisions, standards, and requirements of the Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”) zoning regulations, except in those instances where the Specific Plan development standards remain silent. In instances where these development standards do not address specific issues or other relevant considerations, then the regulations set forth in the BMC shall apply. In the event of a conflict between the BMC and the Specific Plan, the Specific Plan takes precedence over the BMC.
The Director is authorized to provide administrative determinations regarding the Specific Plan. Such administrative determinations must be in writing and may be appealed in accord with the BMC.
The following presents the allowable uses and development standards for each Planning Area, as described in Chapter 3:
4-2
4.2.1 PLANNING AREA 1
Planning Area 1 is bounded by Alondra Boulevard to the north, the Pacific Electric rail corridor to the south, Stevens Avenue to the west, and Woodruff Avenue to the east (See Figure 4.1). Planning Area 1 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing underlying land use standards or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Planning Area 1 is intended to provide opportunities for the development of horizontally or vertically integrated mixed-use projects near transit, along corridors, and around activity centers. Commercial retail uses are encouraged on the ground floor, with offices or residential uses on upper floors. Residential development is also encouraged to enhance the availability of for-sale and rental housing to a variety of income levels.
Planning Area 1 is intended to:
» Stimulate economic development and reinvestment through design and development standards that allow property owners flexibility to adjust to market forces; » Create a pedestrian-oriented mix of uses with convenient access between area neighborhoods, housing, employment centers, public transit and retail services; » Accommodate land uses and patterns of development that can support multiple modes of transportation including public transit, bicycles, and walking that encourage and support the realization of transit-oriented development within the Specific Plan; » Facilitate well-designed new mixed-use development projects that combine residential and nonresidential uses (e.g., office, retail, business services, personal services, public spaces and uses, other community amenities, etc.) and integrate public transit opportunities to promote a better balance of jobs and housing;
» Ensure compatibility with adjacent existing single-family neighborhoods and harmonious integration with existing commercial areas;
» Encourage the development of a unique character through design standards and guidelines that encourage features (including, without limitation, landscaping, street furniture, niche or linear parks, public places, courtyards, public transportation shelters) designed to integrate the public realm with development on adjacent private property; and
» Provide additional property development opportunity while preserving existing property rights. This intent is achieved by providing additional development rights in compliance with this chapter, which property owners may exercise under certain conditions, while retaining all development rights conferred by the underlying base zone to property owners in Planning Area 1. Incentives and advantages include allowing a greater range and mix of uses and specifying more permissive dimensional specifications (including, without limitation, greater floor area ratio, lot coverage ratio, and height; reduced setbacks).
» Support transit-oriented development by increasing the number of stories allowed up to five directly across the street from the future transit station and encouraging mixed-use with residential in a vertical or stand-along configuration.
» Support future residential development along Eucalyptus Avenue and Cornuta Avenue.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-3
4-4
FIGURE 4.1 Planning Area 1 Boundaries
4.2.1.1 ALLOWABLE USES IN PLANNING AREA 1
Table 4.1 lists allowable residential uses that are permitted by right (P) in Planning Area 1. Other non- residential uses that will be allowed within Planning Area 1 are identified in the BMC as described in the following section.
TABLE 4.1 Planning Area 1 Allowable Residential Uses
LAND USE OR ACTIVITY PLANNING
AREA 1
REFERENCES/NOTES
• Residential
Home Occupations P BMC § 5.08.450
Live-Work (ground floor residential allowed on a side
street only)
P
Lofts P
Mixed-Use (ground floor residential allowed on a side
street only)
P
Multiple-Family
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-5
TABLE 4.1 Planning Area 1 Allowable Residential Uses
Attached P
Detached P
Single-Family P
Senior Housing P BMC Chapter 17.36
4.2.1.2 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR PLANNING AREA 1
As discussed, Planning Area 1 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing underlying land use standards of the BMC or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements (e.g., increased maximum height), so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential development.
4.2.1.2.1 Development Under BMC Zoning Standards
As discussed, Planning Area 1 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to either the zoning and land use standards per the BMC or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development.
The areas that are within Planning Area 1 are zoned C-G (General Commercial), M-1 (Light Industrial), R-3 (Multiple Residential), and SCH (Senior Citizen Housing) by the BMC. Again, owners can develop based on the allowable uses and zoning standards and requirements for their particular property. If this is the choice of the property owner or developer, compliance with the following standards and requirements shall be required.
C-G (General Commercial): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.44 of the BMC.
M-1 (Light Industrial): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.52 of the BMC.
R-3 (Multiple Residential Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.32 of the BMC.
SCH (Senior Citizen Housing): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter
17.36 of the BMC.
4.2.1.2.2 Development Under Specific Plan Provisions and Requirements Development can comply with the following flexible development standards and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Tables 4.2 and 4.3 provide the development density and design standards for Planning Area 1.
4-6
TABLE 4.2 Planning Area 1 Residential Development Standards
DEVELOPMENT
FEATURES
Density Standards Maximum density for residential uses expressed as dwelling units per net acre
Residential Uses1 40 du/ac
Intensity Standards Maximum floor area ratio (FAR) for nonresidential uses Nonresidential Uses Not permitted
Site Area Minimum lot area for residential uses
10,000 square feet
Height of Primary Structure Maximum permitted height for residential structures 4 stories or 50 feet, whichever is less
Yards Yard calculation are determined by the following formula Front 20 feet
Interior Side 2-story: 10 feet
3 or more stories: 15 feet
Street Side 10 feet, or 10% of lot width whichever is greater, up to 20 feet Development Features
Rear 2-story: 20 feet
3 or more stories: 25 feet
Alley N/A
Building Separation Minimum separation distance between residential structures 15 feet
Building Bulk
Building bulk requirements must comply with the standards and provisions of the “2/3” rule set forth in BMC § 17.32.100 Usable Open Space
Private Open Space 150 square feet, with a minimum dimension of 8 feet Group Open Space A minimum of 25% of the total land area
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-7
TABLE 4.2 Planning Area 1 Residential Development Standards Driveways Minimum driveway width
Minimum of 24 feet. Refer to BMC §17.88.020 for additional standards Off-Street Parking Minimum standards for off-street parking Residential Parking may be unbundled from the units to better manage available parking and to reduce housing costs for residents using transit or other means in-lieu of a private automobile.
Studio Apartment 1 space / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
1 Bedroom 1 space / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
2 Bedrooms or more 2 spaces / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
Guest .15 spaces / DU
or as determined by
the Director
Required guest parking may be transferred to
designated off-site parking locations or within non-
residential parking area on the same site pursuant
to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement
approved by the City Council
Minimum Floor Area Minimum floor area by unit type
Bachelor and single: 500 square feet
One-bedroom: 700 square feet
Two-bedroom: 900 square feet
Three-bedroom or more: 1,100 square feet
Other Standards For standards and provisions not described herein, the standards and provisions of BMC Chapter 17.32 applies
Notes:
1. Density standards are minimum standards.
Building Placement
Standards
Build-To-Zone The area between the minimum and maximum setbacks within which the principal building’s front facade (building facade line) is to be located. See “Build-to-Zone” in BMC Chapter 17.08 (Definitions). See Figure 4.2 Front (C) Maximum floor area ratio (FAR) for nonresidential uses.
4-8
TABLE 4.2 Planning Area 1 Residential Development Standards Along Alondra Blvd & Bellflower
Blvd
0 - 15 ft
Front (D)
All Other Streets 0 - 15 ft
Street Side Setback (E) 0 - 15 ft
Development Features
Setback Minimum and maximum required setbacks. See Figure 4.3 Front Setback (F)
Along Alondra Blvd & Bellflower
Blvd
0 ft (min); 15 ft (max)
Front Setback (G)
All Other Streets 0 ft (min); 15 ft (max)
Street Side Setback (H) 0 ft (min); 15 ft (max)
Interior Side Setback (2) (I) 5 ft (min); No max
Rear Setback (2) (J) 10 ft (min); No max
Building Frontage Length % of building built. See “Build-To-Zone” in BMC Chapter 17.08 (Definitions). See Figure 4.4
Within 300 ft of Street
Intersections (K)
65%
Over 300 ft from
Street Intersections (L)
50%
Building Standards See “Underground Levels” and “Mezzanines/Lofts” in BMC Chapter 17.08 (Definitions). See Figure 4.5
Number of Stories (3)
(M)
5 max
Maximum Height (3)
(N)
60 ft
Underground Levels
(O)
Allowed
Mezzanines/Lofts (4)
(P)
Allowed
• Building
Frontage Types See “Frontage Type Standards” in Section 4.7.6 (Development Regulations). See Figure 4.6
Along Alondra Blvd, Live-Work
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-9
Bellflower Blvd, Flora
Vista Street within 300
ft of Intersections (Q)
Office
Storefront
Elsewhere (R) Live-Work
Office
Residential
Storefront
TABLE 4.3 Planning Area 1 Standards For All Other Non-Residential Development, Including Mixed Use
Off-Street Parking Minimum standards for off-street parking for Non-Residential Retail 1 space / 400 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Office 1 space / 600 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Restaurant 1 space / 200 SF
1 space / 300 SF if no
eating on premises
Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Site Planning
Standards
Parking Standards See Figure 4.7 (Parking Standards)
Surface Parking (S) 20 ft min setback from front lot line; 15 ft min setback from side lot line
Garage/Tuck-Under
Parking (T)
Prohibited along front lot lines
Underground/Podium
Parking (U)
Allowed beneath building footprint
Above-Ground Parking
Structure (5) (V)
Allowed if screened from views from public right-of-way and adjacent single-family residential districts
4-10
Open Space
Standards
Publicly Accessible
Open Space
(nonresidential)
See Figure 4.8 (Open Space Standards – Publicly Accessible Open Space) 15% of net lot area
Notes:
1. Podium and underground parking is not counted toward floor area ratio (FAR).
2. For residential uses in Planning Area 1, 40 du/ac is the minimum requirement.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-11
FIGURE 4.2 Planning Area 1 Build-to-Zone Standards
FIGURE 4.3 Planning Area 1 Setback Standards
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-12
FIGURE 4.4 Planning Area 1 Building Frontage Length
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-13
FIGURE 4.5 Planning Area 1 Building Standards and Building Frontage Types
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-14
FIGURE 4.6 Planning Area 1 Live-Work Frontage Standards
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-15
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-16
FIGURE 4.7 Planning Area 1 Parking Standards
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-17
FIGURE 4.8 Planning Area 1 Publicly Accessible Open Space
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-18
4.2.1.2.3 OTHER SPECIAL STANDARDS FOR PLANNING
AREA 1
The following are other special standards that apply to development within Planning Area 1.
Senior Housing Development
Senior Housing is permitted by right and must comply with the development and design standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.36 (Senior Housing) of the BMC.
Live-Work Development
This section provides operational and compatibility standards for the development of Live-Work units. These standards are in addition to the standards for Live-Work development provided previously in this section. Live-Work units incorporate non-residential uses. Permitted non-residential Live-Work uses are restricted to permitted uses within the zone in which it is located. Live-Work uses must comply with all of the following:
A. Live-Work units must be internally accessible between the residential area and the non-residential area. The non-residential area must be directly accessible to a non-resident from the ground level via an entry/exit separated from a residential entry/exit; B. An employee of the non-residential use must reside in the dwelling unit. However, the non-residential use may have employees that do not reside within the dwelling unit;
C. Live-Work uses must observe similar operational and delivery hours and walk-in/client visits as other permitted uses within the zone in which it is located.
D. Outdoor storage is not permitted;
E. Live-Work uses cannot store or generate hazardous materials or employ hazardous processes;
F. Noise, vibration, dust, odors, fumes, smoke, heat, electrical interference or other similar nuisances from Live-Work activities cannot be perceived beyond the individual unit; and
G. Live-Work activities cannot increase pedestrian or vehicle traffic beyond that ordinarily associated with the zone in which it is located nor can it reduce the number of required off-street parking spaces available for use.
H. The nonresidential component of a Live-Work unit can only be a nonresidential use allowed within Planning Area 1, except that
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-19
certain uses are determined to be not appropriate within a residential environment and are therefore prohibited.
I. The residential component of a live-work unit can only be a residential use allowed within Planning Area 1.
J. Prohibited Uses. A Live-Work unit cannot be used for any of the following activities or similar activities as determined by the Director:
1. Adult-oriented businesses;
2. Animal care or boarding;
3. Classroom instruction (e.g., art/music lessons, tutoring, and similar uses) involving five (5) or more students at any one (1) time;
4. Commercial food preparation activities;
5. Industrial uses;
6. Vehicle maintenance or repair (e.g., body or mechanical work, including boats and recreational vehicles), vehicle detailing and painting, upholstery;
7. Storage of flammable liquids or hazardous materials beyond that normally associated with a residential use;
8. Medical and dental offices, clinics, and laboratories (not including chiropractors or counselors/psychotherapists);
9. Masseur-masseuse, massage establishments, acupressure spas, day spas, and similar uses;
10. Activities or uses that are not compatible with residential activities or that would clearly conflict with other live-work activities or the character of the surrounding neighborhood as determined by the Director; and
11. Activities or uses that would adversely affect the health or safety of live-work unit residents, because of dust, glare, heat, noise, noxious gases, odor, smoke, traffic, vibration, or other impacts, or that would be hazardous because of materials, processes, products, or wastes.
K. Site Planning and Design Standards.
1. Each Live-Work unit fronting a public right-of-way must have a pedestrian-oriented frontage that allows views into the interior of the nonresidential areas of the unit.
2. Each Live-Work unit must have a clearly identified, separate access from other live-work units within the structure or development. Access to individual units must be from common access areas, parking lots, or walkways. Access to each unit must be clearly identified to provide for emergency services.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-20
3. The living space within the Live-Work unit must be contiguous with the working space, with direct access between the two (2) areas.
L. Operational Standards.
1. No portion of a Live-Work unit can be separately sold or rented.
2. The owner or developer of a structure containing live-work units must provide written notice to all occupants, tenants, and users that the surrounding area may be subject to higher impacts associated with nonresidential uses (e.g., noise) than exist in more predominantly residential areas. Performance standards for live-work units are those applicable to
nonresidential uses allowed in the zone in which the live-work units are located.
3. All activities related to the “work” component of a live-work unit must be conducted within a completely enclosed building.
4. Up to two additional persons who do not reside in the Live- Work unit may work in the unit.
5. Client and customer visits to live-work units are allowed.
6. Parking for each Live-Work unit must be provided in compliance with BMC Chapter 17.88 (Off-Street Parking Requirements).
7. A Live-Work unit cannot be converted to either entirely residential use or entirely nonresidential use.
8. A Live-Work use may display a window or building-mounted sign up to a maximum of five percent of the building frontage area used for commercial purposes. Signs cannot be
illuminated, including neon signs.
Mixed -Use Development
This section provides operational and compatibility standards for mixed- use development. These standards are in addition to the standards provided previously in this section.
A. Operational Standards.
B. Hours of Operation. Except as otherwise provided by a conditional use permit, outdoor nonresidential uses in mixed-use projects are prohibited from operating between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. These hours may be modified through approval of a Conditional Use Permit in compliance with BMC Chapter 17.96 (Conditional Use Permits and Minor Use Permits).
C. Joint Tenants and Owners Association.
1. A joint tenants and owners association must be formed to ensure the well-being of each tenant and owner in a mixed-use project.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-21
2. The covenants, conditions and restrictions (“CC&Rs”) for such an association must be reviewed by the City Attorney and approved by the Director. The association’s CC&Rs must include the following:
a. Assignment of parking spaces per each use.
b. Identification of maintenance responsibilities for
landscaping, parking facilities, and recycling and refuse storage facilities.
c. Noise notification procedures.
d. Relationship between uses regarding association
representation.
e. Procedures for solving problems that may arise between the different types of uses or residents.
D. Loading and Unloading Activities. Where applicable, the CC&Rs of a mixed-use project must indicate the times when the loading and unloading of goods may occur on the street, provided that in no event must loading or unloading take place after 10:00 p.m. or before 7:00 a.m. on any day of the week.
E. Noise Notification.
1. Residents, whether owners or tenants, of a mixed-use development project must be notified in writing before taking up residence that they will be living in an urban type of environment and that the noise levels may be higher than a typical residential area.
2. The CC&Rs of a mixed-use project must require that the residents acknowledge their receipt of the written noise notification. Their signatures must confirm receipt and understanding of this information.
F. Fences and Walls. In addition to the regulations in Table 17.14.030 (Development Standards for C-G and M-1) in the BMC, fences and walls are subject to the following regulations:
1. Separation Wall Required. A masonry separation wall must be constructed on all property lines adjacent to any single-family residential district. Pedestrian access points are encouraged and may be allowed subject to approval of the Director. The separation wall must be six feet in height, as measured from the highest elevation of land contiguous to the wall, except in a required front setback area and in a required exterior side setback area for a corner, reverse corner or key lot, where the wall must be limited to thirty-six inches in height.
2. Other Fences and Walls. Fences and walls are allowed in any yard area subject to the following height regulations:
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-22
a. Front Yard Area. In the front yard area, the height is limited to thirty-six inches.
b. Street Side Yard. In street side yard areas, the height is limited to thirty-six inches.
c. All Other Areas. In all other areas, the height is limited to six feet, as measured from the side of the fence or wall with the highest grade.
3. Location. All perimeter fences and walls must be constructed on the property line unless a different location is permitted by the Director. No parallel wall or fence can be constructed less than five feet from an existing wall or fence, unless approved by the Director.
4. Materials.
a. Chain link fencing cannot be erected between a primary or accessory structure and a public or private street, except that chain link fencing may be used for security purposes for public utility structures and for temporary fencing needs (construction sites, special events, vacant lots). b. Barbed wire and concertina wire are prohibited, except at public utility structures.
G. Landscaping. Landscaping must comply with BMC § 17.44.070 (Landscaping).
H. Screening and Buffering—Mechanical Equipment and Trash Facilities. Mechanical and air-conditioning equipment must be screened and buffered in compliance with BMC § 17.44.100 (Mechanical Equipment—Compressors, Air Conditioning Units or Similar Machinery) and trash facilities must be screened and buffered in compliance with BMC §17.44.130 (Trash Facilities).
I. Signs. See BMC Chapter 17.68 for sign standards.
J. Sound Mitigation. Residential dwelling units must be designed to be sound attenuated against present and future project noise. New projects or new nonresidential uses in existing projects must provide an acoustical analysis report, by an acoustical engineer, describing the acoustical design features of the structure required to satisfy the exterior and interior noise standards.
K. Design Criteria.
1. A mixed-use development project must be designed and constructed to
a. Be pedestrian in its focus by:
b. Providing direct pedestrian linkages to adjacent public sidewalks.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-23
c. Creating enhanced pedestrian connections throughout the project between residential and nonresidential uses and parking areas.
d. Providing enhanced pedestrian amenities throughout the project, including seating, pedestrian area lighting, special paving, public art, water features, common open space,
directories, and similar items to create a pleasant
pedestrian experience.
e. Incorporating architectural design elements and materials that relate to a pedestrian scale.
2. Locate uses in proximity to one another without large intervening parking lots so that it is convenient for people to walk between the various uses and park their vehicles only once.
3. Create a pedestrian scale and character of development along the street by providing significant wall articulation and varying roof heights, incorporating pedestrian scale elements (e.g., doors, windows, lighting, landscaping), and locating storefronts and common open space areas (e.g., plaza, courtyard, outdoor dining) near the public sidewalk to contribute to an active street environment.
4. Consistent Use of Architectural Details and Materials.
Architectural style and use of quality materials must be compatible and consistent throughout an entire mixed-use project. However, differences in architectural details and materials may occur to differentiate between the residential and nonresidential portions of the project. The overall project design and site layout must be one that promotes a strong pedestrian environment and active street frontage. This can be accomplished by incorporating features into the project as outlined in Chapter 7.
5. Features.
a. Street Level Features. Variations in the front building plane must be incorporated through the use of varying
building setbacks, variations in wall planes, and the
inclusion of pedestrian amenities (e.g., plaza, courtyard, outdoor dining, landscaping). Long expanses of blank walls are prohibited.
b. Pedestrian-Oriented Features. At least 75 percent of the building frontage facing a public street, primary
pedestrian way, or parking lot must be devoted to
pedestrian-oriented features (e.g., storefronts, pedestrian entrances to nonresidential uses; transparent display
windows; landscaping).
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-24
c. Upper Level Features. Upper floor balconies, bays, and windows must be provided whenever opportunities exist
for these types of features.
d. Entrances. When nonresidential and residential uses are located in a vertical mixed-use structure, separate
pedestrian entrances must be provided for each use. The entrances for nonresidential uses must be designed to be visually distinct from the entrances for residential uses.
Entrances to individual residential units in a vertical mixed-use project must not be allowed along a street
frontage. Instead shared entrances to residential units located above the ground floor must be from lobbies that serve multiple units.
e. Neighborhood Interface. The design of new infill
development must be sensitive to the scale and design
characteristics of established structures in abutting
residential neighborhoods, with the objective of achieving a harmonious transition between the new development
and existing neighborhood. Consideration must be given
to factors including, without limitation, orientation of architectural features, building articulation, and exterior building treatments.
f. Lighting. Lighting must be incorporated along sidewalks or other pedestrian walkways, plazas, paseos, courtyards,
and other common open areas to enhance the pedestrian
environment and increase public safety. Lighting for
nonresidential uses must be designed, located, and
shielded to ensure that they do not adversely impact the residential uses, but must provide sufficient illumination for access and security purposes.
g. Security. Projects must be designed to minimize security risks to residents and to minimize the opportunities for vandalism and theft. This may be accomplished by:
i. Maximizing visibility to common open space areas,
internal walkways, and public sidewalks. Use
opportunities for natural surveillance to increase
visibility.
ii. Using walkways, low fences, lighting, signage, and
landscaping to clearly guide people and vehicles to
and from the proper entrances.
iii. Eliminating areas of concealment, hiding places, and dead spaces.
iv. Using lighting to improve the visibility of common
areas while enhancing the pedestrian environment.
Lighting should not be overly bright and should
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-25
provide a uniform level of light over the subject area
to eliminate dark spaces.
Outdoor Dining
This section provides standards for outdoor dining areas.
A. Public Property. Outdoor dining on public property requires approval of an encroachment permit by the Public Works Director and compliance with the standards of the Public Works
Department.
B. Private Property. Outdoor dining on private property must comply with the following standards:
1. Coordinated Design Scheme. The design and appearance of proposed improvements or furniture (e.g., tables, chairs, benches, umbrellas, planters, menu boards) to be placed in an outdoor dining area must present a coordinated theme and be compatible with the appearance and design of the primary structure, as determined by the Director.
2. Hours of Operation. Hours of operation for outdoor dining areas must coincide with those of the associated indoor restaurant.
3. Property Maintenance. The operator must maintain the outdoor dining area(s) in a neat, clean, and orderly condition at all times. This includes all tables, benches, chairs, displays, or other related furniture. An adequate number of trash
receptacles must be provided to serve the outdoor dining area.
4. Outdoor Bar Prohibited. A bar designed and/or operated to sell or dispense any alcoholic beverages must not be allowed in the outside dining area.
5. Location. Outdoor dining areas may be allowed to locate in required setback areas but must not encroach into required parking areas. They may be allowed to encroach into a public right-of-way with an approved Encroachment Permit issued by the City Engineer.
6. Noise. Amplified sound (e.g., music, television) cannot be audible beyond the lot line.
C. Review Criteria. When reviewing an application to allow outdoor dining, the reviewing authority must consider the relation of outdoor dining areas to sensitive noise receptors (e.g., hospitals, schools, and residential uses). Mitigation measures must be applied to eliminate potential impacts related to glare, light, loitering, and noise.
Frontage Standards For Various Uses
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-26
A. Live-Work/Office Fronts. A frontage that reinforces both residential and work activities that can occur in the building. The elevation of the ground floor is located at or near the grade of sidewalk to provide direct public access to the building. Entrances and windows are provided on the front of the facade to provide eyes on the street and direct sidewalk access to commercial and office uses. The front setback (if provided) may be improved with landscaping or as an extension of the public sidewalk to create a more pedestrian- friendly environment. Table 4.4 provides frontage standards for Live-Work and office frontages.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-27
TABLE 4.4 Planning Area 1 Live-Work/Office Frontage Standards FRONTAGE STANDARDS1 SEE FIGURE 4.6
A Elevation of Ground Floor The ground floor elevation must be located near the elevation of the sidewalk to minimize the need for external steps and external ADA ramps at public entrances.
B Minimum Ground Floor
Interior Height
12 feet minimum (floor-to-floor height) (commercial ready) C Ground Floor Unit
Entrances
All ground floor tenant spaces that have street frontage must have entrances on a facade fronting a street. All other ground floor uses may have a common lobby entrance along the front facade or private entrances along other facades.
Upper Floor Unit
Entrances
Entrances to upper floor units may be provided through a common lobby entrance and/or by a common entrance along a facade fronting a street.
Recessed Entrances Entrances may be recessed into the facade.
D Ground Floor Windows At least 40% of the surface area of the ground floor facade2 must be occupied by windows3.
E Upper Floor Windows At least 25% of the surface area of each upper floor facade2 must be occupied by windows3.
F Awnings and Marquees Awnings or marquees may be provided over store-front windows and entrances. Awning and marquees may project up to 6 feet from the facade and extend over the sidewalk provided that at least 8 feet of vertical clearance is provided.
G Projecting Elements
(Balconies, Roof
Overhangs, Shade
Structures, and Bay
Windows)
Projecting elements on upper floors may project 3 feet from the facade and project into the setback.
H Sidewalk and Setback
Treatment
The public sidewalk must be improved with street trees with an average spacing of 30 feet on-center and pedestrian-scaled street lights (no taller than 14 feet). If the front facade is set back from the public sidewalk, the setback must be landscaped and/or improved as an extension of the public sidewalk.
1. See Section 4.2.1.2.3 (Live-Work Development).
2. As measured by multiplying the width of the facade by the floor-to-floor height. Opening in the facade (such as entrances to parking facilities or covered outdoor hallways/entrances) must be subtracted from the surface area calculation.
3. All parts of the window (e.g., head, jamb, frame, sash, sill, muntin bars, and panes) that are visible on the elevation drawing must be included as “window” in the calculation. Portions of the window that are not visible on the elevation drawing (such as a window that is blocked by a solid balcony wall) cannot be included in the calculation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-28
B. Residential Fronts. A frontage that reinforces the residential character and use of the building. The elevation of the ground floor is elevated above the grade of the lot to provide privacy for residences by preventing direct views into the home from the sidewalk. Entrances and windows are provided on the front of the facade to provide eyes on the street and direct sidewalk access to the building. Stoops are allowed to project into the front setback to enhance entrances. The front setback is primarily improved with landscaping. Table 4.5 provides frontage standards for residential frontages.
C. Storefronts. A frontage that reinforces the commercial character and use of the ground floor of the building. The elevation of the ground floor is located at or near the grade of sidewalk to provide direct public access into the building. Large storefronts display windows are provided on the front of the facade to encourage visual access to merchandise displays and to encourage window shopping. Awnings or marquees are provided over storefront windows and entrances. The front setback (if provided) is primarily improved as an extension of the public sidewalk to create a more pedestrian-friendly environment. Table 4.6 provides frontage standards for stores and retail.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-29
Area 1 Residential Frontage Standards
DARDS1 SEE FIGURE 4.9
ound Floor The ground floor elevation must be located within 6 feet of the ground surface of the adjacent sidewalk or walkway.
nd Floor
10 feet minimum (floor-to-floor height)
nit
Entrances to ground floor units that have street frontage may be provided through a common lobby entrance and/or by private entrances from the adjacent sidewalk.
it
Entrances to upper floor units may be provided through a common lobby entrance and/or by a common entrance along a facade fronting a street. nces Entrances may be recessed into the facade.
per Floor
At least 25% of the surface area of the ground and upper floor facade (1) must be occupied by windows2.
nt Porches Stoops and front porches may be provided in front of building and unit entrances. Stoops and front porches may project up to 5 feet from the facade and project into the setback.
ments
f
de
Bay
Projecting elements on upper floors may project 3 feet from the facade and project into the setback.
etback
The public sidewalk must be improved with street trees with an average spacing of 30 feet on-center and pedestrian-scaled street lights (no taller than 14 feet). If the front facade is set back from the public sidewalk, the setback must be landscaped (excluding stoops/front porches and paved paths to building entrances).
plying the width of the facade by the floor-to-floor height. Opening in the facade (such as entrances to vered outdoor hallways/entrances) must be subtracted from the surface area calculation. w (e.g., head, jamb, frame, sash, sill, muntin bars, and panes) that are visible on the elevation drawing window” in the calculation. Portions of the window that are not visible on the elevation drawing (such ocked by a solid balcony wall) cannot be included in the calculation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-30
FIGURE 4.9 Planning Area 1 Residential Frontage Standards
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-31
g Area 1 Storefront Standards
DARDS1 SEE FIGURE 4.10
ound Floor The ground floor elevation must be located near the elevation of the sidewalk to minimize the need for external steps and external ADA ramps at public entrances.
nd Floor
15 feet minimum (floor-to-floor height)
ances All ground floor tenant spaces that have street frontage must have storefront entrances on the facade fronting a street.
es Lobby entrances to upper floor uses must be located on a facade fronting a street.
nces Storefront and lobby entrances may be recessed into the facade.
Windows At least 50% of the surface area of the ground floor facade1 must be occupied by windows2.
ndows At least 25% of the surface area of each upper floor facade1 must be occupied by windows2.
arquees Awnings or marquees are required over storefront windows and entrances. Awning and marquees may project up to 6 feet from the facade and extend over the sidewalk provided that at least 8 feet of vertical clearance is provided.
ments
de
Bay
Projecting elements on upper floors may project 3 feet from the facade and project into the setback.
etback
The public sidewalk must be improved with street trees with an average spacing of 30 feet on-center and pedestrian-scaled street lights (no taller than 14 feet). If the front facade is set back from the public sidewalk, the setback must be improved as an extension of the public sidewalk.
plying the width of the facade by the floor-to-floor height. Opening in the facade (such as entrances to vered outdoor hallways/entrances) must be subtracted from the surface area calculation. w (e.g., head, jamb, frame, sash, sill, muntin bars, and panes) that are visible on the elevation drawing window” in the calculation. Portions of the window that are not visible on the elevation drawing (such ocked by a solid balcony wall) cannot be included in the calculation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-32
FIGURE 4.10 Planning Area 1 Storefront Standards
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-33
Driveway Standards
This section will include standards for the design (width, pavement, fire access requirements) and placement (distance from intersections, line of sight standards) of driveways (Figure 4.11).
FIGURE 4.11 Planning Area 1 Driveway Standards
Required Public Space Amenities
Each project proposed within Planning Area 1 must include a public open space amenity, or some form of physical interface for the pedestrian. Such features may include, without limitation:
A. Formal Plazas. A formal plaza would be a publicly accessible open space which has a design that is influenced by classical urban planning design. A formal plaza would typically include some sort of central water fountain and/or symmetrical landscaping.
B. Urban Gardens. An urban garden can be located on the ground level, or on upper levels of a structure. Urban gardens include ornamental landscaping arranged in raised or at-grade planters or planting areas, potted plants and trees. Many times, there are
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-34
sculptures or other forms of public art that are included within the urban garden.
C. Covered Colonnades. Colonnades are linear in design and generous in depth. The intent is to provide a comfortably wide, covered pathway that is adjacent to the openings of a building. Sometimes the second floor of a building is utilized to create the “covered” element of the colonnade.
D. Sidewalk Dining. Sidewalk dining may occur wherever a sidewalk space is ample enough to accommodate dining furniture without impeding pedestrian access of the sidewalk. Sidewalk dining may be defined with a railing or planters, or be open and accessible.
E. Pedestrian Alleys and Walkways. A pedestrian alley or walkway is typically a “lane” that does not follow the alignment of a vehicular street, but provides a pedestrian access to either a public space or some other feature within the interior of a development. Pedestrian alleys or walkways must be designed in such a manner so as to be inviting to pedestrians. Therefore, issues such as lighting, security, line of sight, cleanliness and visual appeal are important considerations to a well-designed pedestrian alley or walkway.
Sometimes public art, street furniture and access to shops and public spaces are features of pedestrian alleys and walkways.
F. Direct Public Transit Connection. A direct connection to public transportation facilities, or amenities that service public transit facilities such as benches, informational kiosks, walkways, parking facilities or other similar amenities.
Signs
See BMC Chapter 17.68 for sign standards.
Publicly-Accessible Open Space
This section provides standards for publicly accessible open space areas in order to ensure a high level of pedestrian connectivity and activity between the public realm and the private realm, as defined in BMC Chapter 17.08 (Definitions).
A. Minimum Size. All new nonresidential development must provide publicly accessible open spaces as a percentage of the total development site area as indicated in Table 4.4, Planning Area 1 Development Standards.
B. Eligible Areas. Publicly accessible open space areas cannot include parking, driveway, or rear setback areas, but may include front and side setback areas provided that they are integrated into the overall design of the project.
C. Ground-Level Installation. Plazas, courtyards, or other similar publicly accessible open space areas must be installed at ground level and must be incorporated into the design of the development.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-35
D. Visibility and Accessibility. Public open space areas must be visible and accessible from the public rights-of-way to engage the interest of pedestrians and encourage public use and provide necessary measures to ensure sufficient site security and visibility (e.g., planting locations, appurtenances and lighting).
E. Landscaping and Hardscapes. A combination of landscape and hardscape materials must be used in the design of these areas and must include the following components:
1. Hardscape paving may include brick, stone, interlocking concrete pavers, textured concrete, and/or impressed
patterned concrete. Hardscape elements may include, without limitation, seating areas, potted plant materials, water features, and public art installations.
2. The balance of the open space areas must be landscaped with turf, shrubs, or groundcover, and trees. All plant materials must be in proportion to the height and mass of the building and must be permanently maintained and irrigated.
F. Minimum Height to Width Ratios. In order to achieve sunlight and air circulation in required publicly accessible open space areas, the following minimum height to width ratios must be provided:
1. Enclosed open space (i.e., open space that is enclosed on four (4) sides, such as a courtyard): 2 to 1 ratio. The required open space must have a width of at least one-half the height of the adjacent building facade (measured perpendicularly from the facade). This requirement applies to all sides of the required open space.
2. Open space that is open on one (1) or more sides: 3 to 1 ratio.
The required open space must have a width of at least one-third the height of the adjacent building facade (measured
perpendicularly from the facade). This requirement must apply to all sides of the required open space.
G. Design Configuration.
1. Sharing of the required publicly-accessible open space (“quasi- public space”) for nonresidential uses and the required common open space for residential uses, indicated in Table 4.4, Planning Area 1 Development Standards, may be allowed by the applicable review authority when it can be demonstrated that the open space will provide direct benefit to residents of the project and the general public subject to the following limitations:
a. Up to thirty (30) percent of the required open space for residential uses in a horizontal mixed-use project may be provided as quasi-public open space within the
nonresidential component of the project; or
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-36
b. Up to fifty (50) percent of the required open space for residential uses in a vertical mixed-use project may be provided as quasi-public open space within the
nonresidential component of the project.
c. The minimum dimension (length and width) of shared
common open space areas must be twenty (20) feet.
These areas must be located at grade and must be
accessible for use by the general public.
d. Quasi-public open space areas cannot include outdoor dining areas or other outdoor activity areas for exclusive use by an individual business.
e. Quasi-public open space areas are areas located on
private property and accessible to the general public.
These areas include pedestrian-oriented amenities,
including enhanced seating, lighting, paving, landscaping, public art, water features, and other similar features
deemed appropriate by the Director.
2. Publicly accessible open space areas must be located and configured as any one of the following (See Figure 4.8, Publicly Accessible Open Space)
a. Forecourt. The publicly accessible open space area is located along a recessed center section of the front facade of the building.
b. Front. The publicly accessible open space area is located along the street facing frontage of the building.
c. “L” Shaped. The publicly accessible open space area is located along the front and side of the lot.
d. Paseo or Central Courtyard. The publicly accessible open space area is located on the side of the building or along a center pedestrian paseo or courtyard.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-37
4.2.2 PLANNING AREA 2
Planning Area 2 is located along Bellflower Boulevard, and is bounded by Rendalia Street to the north, Flora Vista Street to the west, Stevens Avenue to the east, and Pacific Avenue to the south. Figure 4.12 provides the boundaries for Planning Areas 2 and 3. Planning Area 3 will be discussed in the next sections. Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 2 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 2 area.
Similar to Planning Area 1, future development within Planning Area 2 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Planning Area 2 intends to provide easy access to both the transit station and Bellflower’s downtown and foster mixed-use development with high-density residential, retail and services, an outdoor plaza/dining area, and parking for the transit station.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-38
FIGURE 4.12 Planning Areas 2 and 3 Boundaries
4.2.2.1 ALLOWABLE USES IN PLANNING AREA 2
Table 4.7 presents the residential uses that are allowable within Planning Areas 2, 3, and
4. Other allowable non-residential uses for Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 can be found in the BMC. This will be discussed in the following section.
TABLE 4.7 Allowable Residential Uses For Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 LAND USE OR ACTIVITY PLANNING AREAS 2
AND 3
PLANNING AREA
4 • Residential
Home Occupations (See BMC Sec.
5.08.450)
P P
Live-Work (ground floor residential
allowed on a side street only)
P P
Lofts P P
Mixed-Use (ground floor residential
allowed on a side street only)
P P
Mobile Homes
Multiple-Family
--- ---
Attached P* P*
Detached P* P*
Single-Family --- P*
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-39
4.2.2.2 DEVELOP
MENT
STANDARD
S FOR
PLANNING AREA 2
4.2.2.2.1 Development Under BMC Zoning Standards
Planning Area 2 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to either the zoning and land use standards per the BMC or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development.
The areas within Planning Area 2 are zoned T-C (Bellflower Town Center), C-G (General Commercial), M-1 (Light Industrial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and R-3 (Multiple Residential) by the BMC. Again, owners can develop based on these allowable uses and the zoning standards and requirements for their particular property. If this is the choice of the property owner or developer, compliance with the following standards and requirements shall be required.
T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.48 of the BMC.
C-G (General Commercial): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.44 of the BMC.
M-1 (Light Industrial): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.52 of the BMC.
R-1 (Low Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.24 of the BMC.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.28 of the BMC.
R-3 (Multiple Residential Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.32 of the BMC.
4.2.2.2.2 Development Under Specific Plan Provisions and Requirements
Development can comply with the following flexible development standards and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. The following sections describe these flexible provisions, standards, and requirements that apply to Planning Area 2. It should noted that the following tables (Tables 4.8 and 4.9) and discussions relating to flexible provisions, etc. may also Senior Housing --- ---
*More than 10 units require a CUP per
the BMC
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-40
apply to Planning Area 3 and 4, which will be discussed in the following sections.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-41
TABLE 4. 8 Planning Areas 2 and 3 - Development Standards
BUILDING PLACEMENT &
FORM MINIMUM
Building Density Density measure as dwelling units per net acr feet per dwelling unit (sq.ft./du)
Residential – Planning Area 2 40 du/ac 1, 1,000 sq.ft./du 100 Residential – Planning Area 3 No Minimum 40 d
Minimum Floor Area Minimum floor area by unit type
Bachelor and single: 500 square feet
One-bedroom: 700 square feet
Two-bedroom: 900 square feet
Three-bedroom or more: 1,100 square feet
Building Intensity Floor Area Ratio (FAR) 2
Non-Residential No Minimum
Setback Requirements (Residential & Non-Residential)
Front Abutting Bellflower Blvd. 0 ft
Front Abutting Harvard St. 10 ft
Abutting Interior Road or St. 5 ft
Abutting Rear 10 ft
Abutting Interior Property Line 5 ft
South of Harvard St
Permitted Encroachments within Setback
Areas • Walkway connections to building entrance
• Vehicular and bike access ways.
• Public art displays, fountains, planter
decorative trash receptacles, public plaza
and attractive street furnishings that creat
• Cornices, eaves, belt courses, sills, butt
fully screened mechanical equipment, o
encroach no more than four (4) inches f
width of such side yard, and may exten
front or side yard not more than thirty (30
• Awnings, canopies and arcades.
• Balconies may encroach no more than thr
Notes:
1. Additional density is permitted in accordance wit
Density Bonus.
2. See BMC Chapter 17.08.010 for a complete defini
3. Podium and underground parking is not counted
4. Greater setbacks for entry plazas, courtyards or o
be permitted, subject to the discretion of the Rev
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-42
CEMENT &
MINIMUM MAXIMUM
ments within Setback
• Outdoor dining may encroach into street-adjacent setback if a minimum 5-foot-wide clear and unobstructed sidewalk is provided.
• Outdoor dining located in the front or side of the building must be designed with either a low fence or wall, at least 40- inches high, when fronting a street. Outdoor dining located within a courtyard must also include a low fence or wall if fronting a street.
Number of stories does not include mezzanines or lofts
Residential 3 stories 7 stories
Height
10 ft 1 No Maximum
Height
12 ft 1 No Maximum
ng Frontage Measured as percent of lot width
evard 60% No maximum
Frontage Types See Section 7.3.2 for Frontage Design Guidelines evard Shopfront, Forecourt, Arcade, Terrace
Shopfront, Forecourt, Arcade, Terrace
G MINIMUM MAXIMUM
andscaping
space 15% of lot 2 No maximum
d/or Common Open
100 sf per unit No maximum
Bellflower Boulevard Sidewalk must be improved with street trees, shrubs, and street furniture consistent with streetscape in Downtown Bellflower.
Streetscape design must be coordinated with bus stops, and curb-side drop-off and pick-up zones
Notes:
1. All developments must comply with Building Codes.
2. Refer to Publicly-Accessible Open Space Standards.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-43
SITE PLANNING MINIMUM
Direct Public Transit Connection A direct pedestrian and bicycle provided to public transportation fa
that service public transit facilitie
informational kiosks, walkways, park
similar amenities.
Landscape Requirements within
Setback Areas
Setbacks abutting public rights-of-wa
alleys must be improved with
hardscape as follows:
» For ground-floor residentia
residential patios and th
must be fully landscaped.
» For ground-floor commercia
up to 80 percent of the s
paved.
» Landscape and fencing requ
7 of this document and C
BMC apply.
» Setback areas must be perm
in a neat and orderly manne
Required setbacks abutting interio
setbacks between buildings must
trees, other plantings, and walkway
hedges must comply with Chapter 7
Chapter 17.48 of the BMC.
For ground-floor residential, the area
between residential patios and the
sidewalk/walkway must be fully
landscaped.
See following Parking Standards
For ground-floor commercial or
live/work units, up to 80 percent of the
setback area may be paved.
Allowed within the buildable areas
the ground floor of all street adjacen
screened with a building space with
depth of 30 feet. Facades along the
designed with features to screen view
Landscape and fencing requirements of
Chapter 7 of this document and
Chapter 17.48 of the BMC apply.
Entrance allowed along Bellflower B
parking must be separated from reta
via separate entrance or internal
parking may also be allowed under s
the approval of an encroachment per
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-44
improvements are subject to review and approval by the Public Works Director and may require an
as 2 and 3 - Parking Standards
MINIMUM SPECIAL PROVISIONS
Parking may be unbundled from the units to better manage available parking and to reduce housing costs for residents using transit or other means in-lieu of a private automobile.
1 space / DU or as
determined by the Director
Covered
1 space / DU or as
determined by the Director
Covered
2 spaces / DU or as
determined by the Director
Covered
.15 spaces / DU
or as determined by the
Director
Required guest parking may be transferred to
designated off-site parking locations or within non-
residential parking area on the same site pursuant
to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement
approved by the City Council
1 space / 400 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to
the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement
approved by the City Council
1 space / 600 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to
the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement
approved by the City Council
1 space / 200 SF
1 space / 300 SF if no
eating on premises
Required on-site parking may be transferred to
designated off-site parking locations pursuant to
the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement
approved by the City Council
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-45
4.2.2.2.3 SPECIAL PUBLICLY ACCESSIBLE OPEN SPACE
STANDARDS FOR PLANNING AREAS 2, 3, & 4
This section provides standards for publicly accessible open space within Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 in order to ensure a high level of pedestrian connectivity and activity between the public realm and the private realm.
A. Minimum Size. All new nonresidential development must provide publicly accessible open spaces (15% of net lot area).
B. Eligible Areas. Publicly accessible open space areas must not include parking, driveway, or rear setback areas, but may include front and side setback areas if they are integrated into the overall design of the project.
C. Ground-Level Installation. Plazas, courtyards, or other similar publicly accessible open space areas must be installed at ground level and must be incorporated into the design of the development.
D. Visibility and Accessibility. Public open space areas must be visible and accessible from the public rights-of-way to engage the interest of pedestrians and encourage public use. They must also include necessary features to ensure sufficient site security and visibility (e.g., planting locations, appurtenances and lighting).
E. Landscaping and Hardscapes. A combination of landscape and hardscape materials must be used in the design of these areas and must include the following components:
1. Hardscape paving may include brick, stone, interlocking concrete pavers, textured concrete, and/or impressed
patterned concrete. Hardscape elements may include,
without limitation, seating areas, potted plant materials, water features, and public art installations.
2. All plant materials must be in proportion to the height and mass of the building and be permanently
maintained and irrigated.
F. Minimum Height to Width Ratios. To achieve sunlight and air circulation in required publicly accessible open space areas, the following minimum height to width ratios must be provided:
1. Enclosed open space (i.e., open space that is enclosed on four (4) sides, such as a courtyard): 2 to 1 ratio. The required open space must have a width of at least one-
half the height of the adjacent building facade (measured
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-46
perpendicularly from the facade). This requirement
applies to all sides of the required open space.
2. Open space that is open on one (1) or more sides: 3 to 1 ratio. The required open space must have a width of at
least one-third the height of the adjacent building facade (measured perpendicularly from the facade). This
requirement applies to all sides of the required open
space.
G. Design Configuration.
1. Sharing of the required publicly-accessible open space (“quasi-public space”) for nonresidential uses and the
required common open space for residential uses may be
allowed by the City when it can be demonstrated that
the open space will provide direct benefit to residents of the project and the general public subject to the
following limitations:
a. Up to thirty (30) percent of the required open space for residential uses in a horizontal mixed-use
project may be provided as quasi-public open space
within the nonresidential component of the project;
or
b. Up to fifty (50) percent of the required open space
for residential uses in a vertical mixed-use project
may be provided as quasi-public open space within
the nonresidential component of the project.
c. The minimum dimension (length and width) of
shared common open space areas must be twenty
(20) feet. These areas must be located at grade and
be accessible for use by the general public.
d. Quasi-public open space areas may include
common outdoor dining areas that are not used
exclusively by any individual business.
e. Quasi-public open space areas are areas located on
private property and accessible to the general
public. These areas must include pedestrian-
oriented amenities, including enhanced seating,
lighting, paving, landscaping, public art, water
features, and other similar features deemed
appropriate by the Director.
2. Publicly accessible open space areas must be located and configured as any one of the following:
a. Forecourt. The publicly accessible open space area
is located along a recessed center section of the
front facade of the building.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-47
b. Front. The publicly accessible open space area is
located along the street facing frontage of the
building as illustrated.
c. “L” Shaped. The publicly accessible open space area
is located along the front and side of the lot.
d. Paseo or Central Courtyard. The publicly accessible
open space area is located on the side of the
building or along a center pedestrian paseo or
courtyard.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-48
4.2.3 PLANNING AREA 3
Planning Area 3 is located is located between Flower Street to the north and the 91 Freeway to the south. Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 3 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 3 area. Refer to Figure 4.12 which provides the boundaries for Planning Areas 2 and 3. Similar to Planning Areas 1 and 2, future development within Planning Area 3 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met. Planning Area 3 allows for joint development of residential, retail and service uses and is intended to provide convenient access to transit for residents, as well as encourage businesses that cater to fast-paced, on-the-go transit riders who are seeking convenient goods and services.
4.2.3.1 ALLOWABLE USES IN PLANNING AREA 3
Allowable uses for Planning Area 2 can be found on Table 4.7, which presents the residential uses that are allowable within Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4. Other non-residential allowable uses for Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 can be found in the BMC. This will be discussed in the following section.
4.2.3.2 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR PLANNING
AREA 3
4.2.3.2.1 Development Under BMC Zoning Standards
Planning Area 3 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to either the zoning and land use standards per the BMC or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development.
The areas within Planning Area 3 are zoned T-C (Bellflower Town Center), C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), and R-2 (Medium Density Residential) by the BMC.
Again, owners can develop based on these allowable uses and the zoning standards and requirements for their particular property. If this is the choice of the property owner or developer, compliance with the following standards and
requirements shall be required.
T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Comply with development
standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.48 of the BMC.
C-G (General Commercial): Comply with development
standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.44 of the BMC.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-49
R-1 (Low Density Residential): Comply with development
standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.24 of the BMC.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.28 of the BMC.
4.2.3.2.2 Development Under Specific Plan Provisions
and Requirements
Development can comply with the following flexible
development standards and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Tables
4.8 and 4.9 described these flexible provisions, standards, and requirements that will apply to Planning Area 3.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-50
4.2.4 PLANNING AREA 4
Planning Area 4 is located along the north and south side of Flower Street from Clark Avenue to west of Bellflower
Boulevard and on the south side of Flower Street from west of Bellflower Boulevard to Woodruff Avenue (See Figure 4.13).
Given its proximity to the future transit station and those specific land uses that are located within the Planning Area 4 area, this Specific Plan has created specific provisions and requirements to better serve the Planning Area 4 area. Similar to Planning Areas 1, 2, and 3, future development within Planning Area 4 can allow residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to the existing zoning
designations that underlie the Planning Area or take advantage of more flexible provisions and requirements, so long as certain conditions are met, including additional residential
development. Planning Area 4 is envisioned as a walkable residential and commercial corridor that provides local services and employment along with multifamily living. The standards are intended to provide a single plan that guides the
incremental transition into a pedestrian-friendly environment and provides property owners a mix of uses to flexibly reinvest within the area.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-51
Figure 4.13 Planning Area 4 Boundaries
4.2.4.1 ALLOWABLE USES IN PLANNING AREA 4
Allowable uses for Planning Area 4 can be found on Table 4.7, which presents the residential uses that are allowable within Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4. Other non-residential allowable uses for Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 can be found in the BMC. This will be discussed in the following section.
4.2.4.2 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR PLANNING
AREA 2
4.2.4.2.1 Development Under BMC Zoning Standards
Planning Area 4 allows residential and non-residential mixed uses to be developed according to either the zoning and land use standards per the BMC or take advantage of flexible provisions and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development.
The areas within Planning Area 3 are zoned C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and R-3 (Multiple Residential) by the BMC.
Again, owners can develop based on these allowable uses and
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-52
the zoning standards and requirements for their particular property. If this is the choice of the property owner or developer, compliance with the following standards and
requirements shall be required.
C-G (General Commercial): Comply with development
standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.44 of the BMC.
R-1 (Low Density Residential): Comply with development
standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.24 of the BMC.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.28 of the BMC.
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.32 of the BMC.
4.2.4.2.2 Development Under Specific Plan Provisions
and Requirements
Development can comply with the following flexible
development standards and requirements if certain conditions are met, including additional residential development. Tables
4.10 and 4.11 described these flexible provisions, standards, and requirements that will apply to Planning Area 4.
TABLE 4.10 Planning Area 4 Development Standards
BUILDING PLACEMENT &
FORM MINIMUM MAXIMUM
Building Density Density measure as dwelling units per net acre (du/ac) and net square feet per dwelling unit (sq.ft./du)
Residential 14 du/ac 1, 3,100 sq.ft./du 22 du/ac 1, 2,000 sq.ft./du Minimum Floor Area Minimum floor area by unit type
Bachelor and single: 500 square feet
One-bedroom: 700 square feet
Two-bedroom: 900 square feet
Three-bedroom or more: 1,100 square feet
Building Intensity Floor Area Ratio (FAR) 2
Non-Residential No Minimum 0.35 FAR 3
Setback Requirements (Residential & Non-Residential)
Front Abutting Flower Blvd. west of 5 ft 15 ft 4
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-53
Bellflower Boulevard
Front Abutting Flower Blvd. east of
Bellflower Boulevard
5 ft 10 ft 4
Front Abutting Bixby Street 10 ft 20 ft
Front Abutting Ardmore Ave. and
Orchard Ave.
5 ft 15 ft
Abutting Interior Road or Drive 5 ft 15 ft
Abutting Rear Property Line, not
adjacent to single-family residential
10 ft No maximum
Abutting Rear Property Line, Adjacent
to single-family residential
20 ft No maximum
Abutting Interior Property Line 5 ft No maximum
Permitted Encroachments within
Setback Areas • Walkway connections to building entrances.
• Vehicular and bike access ways.
Notes:
1. Additional density is permitted in accordance with BMC Chapter 17.41, Density Bonus.
2. See BMC Chapter 17.08.010 for a complete definition.
3. Podium and underground parking is not counted toward FAR
4. Greater setbacks for entry plazas, courtyards or outdoor dining patios may be permitted, subject to the discretion of the Reviewing Authority.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-54
BUILDING PLACEMENT &
FORM MINIMUM MAXIMUM
Permitted Encroachments within
Setback Areas (cont.) • Public art displays, fountains, planters, outdoor seating areas, decorative trash receptacles, public plazas, or other similar amenities and attractive street furnishings that create public gathering areas.
• Cornices, eaves, belt courses, sills, buttresses, fireplaces, windows, fully screened mechanical equipment, or other similar features may encroach no more than four (4) inches for each one (1) foot of the width of such side yard, and may extend or project into a required front or side yard not more than thirty (30) inches.
• Awnings, canopies and arcades.
• Outdoor dining may encroach into street-adjacent setback if a minimum 5-foot-wide clear and unobstructed sidewalk is
provided.
• Outdoor dining located in the front or side of the building must be designed with either a low fence or wall, at least 40-inches high, when fronting a street. Outdoor dining located within a courtyard must also include a low fence or wall if fronting a street.
Building Heights Number of stories does not include mezzanines or lofts Residential and Non-Residential 3 stories 7 stories
Ground Floor Ceiling Height
– Residential
10 ft 1 No Maximum
Ground Floor Ceiling Height
– Non-Residential
12 ft 1 No Maximum
Building Width along Frontage Measured as percent of lot width Along Flower Street 60% 1 No maximum
Notes:
1. All developments must comply with Building Codes.
2. See Section 4.4.4.1 Publicly-Accessible Open Space Standards.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-55
SITE PLANNING MINIMUM MAXIMUM
Permitted Building Frontage Types See Section 7.3.2 for Frontage Design Guidelines Along Flower Street Shopfront, Forecourt, Terrace, Stoop, Porch Along All Other Streets Shopfront, Forecourt, Terrace, Stoop, Porch 1 Open Space and Landscaping
Non-residential open space 15% of lot No maximum
Residential Private and/or Common
Open Space
100 sf per unit, minimum
dimension of 8 feet (width
and length)
No maximum
Public sidewalk along Flower Street Sidewalk must be improved with street trees, shrubs, and street furniture.
Landscape Requirements within
Setback Areas
Setbacks abutting public rights-of-way, internal roads and alleys must be improved with landscaping and/or hardscape as follows:
» For ground-floor residential, the area between residential patios and the sidewalk/walkway must be fully
landscaped.
» For ground-floor commercial or live/work units, up to 80 percent of the setback area may be paved.
» Landscape and screening requirements of Chapter 7 of
this document and Chapter 17.48 of the BMC apply.
» Setback areas must be permanently maintained in a neat and orderly manner.
Required setbacks abutting interior property lines and setbacks between buildings must be landscaped with trees, other plantings, and walkways. Fences, walls, and hedges must comply with Chapter 7 of this document and Chapter 17.48 of the BMC
Parking Standards See following Parking Standards
Above Ground Parking Structure Allowed within the buildable areas of the site. The ground and upper floors of all street adjacent structures must be designed with features to screen views of vehicles.
Driveways As individual properties redevelop, driveways and vehicular access must be minimized to the greatest extent possible, consolidated driveways are encouraged along Flower Street.
Notes:
1. All public right-of-way improvements are subject to review and approval by the Public Works Director and may require an encroachment permit.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-56
TABLE 4.11 Planning Area 4 - Parking Standards
Mixed Use Corridor
Residential Parking may be unbundled from the units to better manage available parking and to reduce housing costs for residents using transit or other means in-lieu of a private automobile.
Studio Apartment 1 space / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
1 Bedroom 1 space / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
2 Bedrooms or more 2 spaces / DU or as
determined by the
Director
Covered
Guest .15 spaces / DU
or as determined by the
Director
Required guest parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations or within non-residential parking area on the same site pursuant to the provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Non-Residential
Retail 1 space / 420 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the
provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Office 1 space / 660 SF Required on-site parking may be transferred to designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the
provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
Restaurant 1 space / 200 SF
1 space / 300 SF if no
eating on premises
Required on-site parking may be transferred to
designated off-site parking locations pursuant to the
provisions of a DDA or similar agreement approved by the City Council
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-57
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Allowable Uses & Development Standards 4-58
4.2.5 PLANNING AREA 5 (BMC ZONING)
Planning Area 5 is generally located along the west, north, and central portions of the Specific Plan. Properties within Planning Area 5 are regulated by the following standards found in the BMC: C-G (General Commercial), R-1 (Low Density Residential), R-2 (Medium Density Residential), R-3 (Multiple Residential), T-C (Bellflower Town Center), O-S (Open Space), P (Public Uses), and SCH (Senior Citizen Housing) zones. All owners of properties located within Planning Area 5 are required to comply with these zoning standards.
C-G (General Commercial): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.44 of the BMC.
R-1 (Low Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.24 of the BMC.
R-2 (Medium Density Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.28 of the BMC.
R-3 (Multiple Residential): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.32 of the BMC.
T-C (Bellflower Town Center): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.48 of the BMC.
O-S (Open Space): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.64 of the BMC.
P (Public Uses): Comply with development standards and
requirements found in Chapter 17.56 of the BMC.
SCH (Senior Citizen Housing): Comply with development standards and requirements found in Chapter 17.36 of the BMC.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
DRAFT | AUGUST 2019 5-1
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-1
5. MOBILITY
This chapter describes the circulation and other improvements to public streets and open space areas needed to support transit- oriented development (TOD) within the Specific Plan area. A key component of the Specific Plan is targeted improvements to the current circulation network in order to transform it into a network that places a higher priority on the principles of transit accessibility, complete streets, and multi-modal design. The construction of a future light rail station along Bellflower Boulevard requires an assessment of pedestrian, bicycle, bus, and vehicle accessibility to and from the station area. The strategies set forth in this document are intended to provide a framework that supports both motorized and non- motorized modes of transportation together in an integrated system.
5.1 OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES
The following objectives and policies set the framework for the mobility and public realm strategy of Bellflower. They serve as guidelines and provide direction for future decision-making and development activities. The objectives and policies identified in this section were derived from input received from community members, stakeholders, and staff during the community engagement process and serve as tools to help the City reach their goals as outlined in the vision. The following lists the major mobility objectives and policies for the Specific Plan:
OBJECTIVE 1: Provide and maintain a comprehensive circulation system that improves accessibility to transit, and the safe and efficient movement of all users of the roadway.
» Policy 1.1: Implement complete streets designs that contribute to a multi-modal transportation system.
» Policy 1.2: Ensure that roadway improvements allow for easier, safer, and more efficient transit operations, as well as improved passenger safety and accessibility.
» Policy 1.3 Consult with local transit operators to provide attractive and convenient bus stops, including shade/weather protection, seats, transit information, and bus shelters where appropriate.
» Policy 1.4: Consider the interactions between bus and bicyclists and design bus stops that will help minimize conflicts. » Policy 1.5: Maintain existing on street parking when feasible.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-2
OBJECTIVE 2: Provide safe, well connected, and accessible bikeway and pedestrian network.
» Policy 2.1: Establish a connected pedestrian and bicycle network that links the Downtown Bellflower Transit Station, the Regional Bus Station, the local bus station, residential neighborhoods, local schools, and retail corridors.
» Policy 2.2: Complete bicycle infrastructure improvements that respond to the recommendations from the Bellflower-
Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan. Any recommended
improvements require City approval prior to consideration. » Policy 2.3: Establish and maintain attractive and functional sidewalks that maximize accessibility, enhance the pedestrian environment, and foster social interaction.
» Policy 2.4: Incorporate pedestrian amenities into the area around the future Bellflower Boulevard Transit station such as kiosks, benches, tables, and landscaping.
» Policy 2.5: Design bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure in accordance with federal, state, and local design standards, including ADA accessibility standards.
OBJECTIVE 3: Provide and maintain attractive mobility corridors that promote livability and sustainability.
» Policy 3.1: Extend the streetscape improvements on Bellflower Boulevard (between Flower and Mayne Streets).
» Policy 3.2 Implement streetscape features such as, street trees, landscaping, and wayfinding signage to create safer and attractive corridors particularly along Alondra Boulevard and Flower Street. Real-time signage and smart wayfinding must be promoted when feasible.
» Policy 3.3 Integrate pedestrian amenities, such as benches and public art to transform the streetscape and create public space.
» Policy 3.4: Provide gateway signage at Bellflower Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard to direct people to the transit station and downtown area.
OBJECTIVE 4: Promote efficient use of parking resources. » Policy 4.1: Establish guidelines and standards to optimize parking supply that is consistent with related City
requirements.
» Policy 4.2: Encourage and allow shared parking for new development in lieu of the provision of off-street parking spaces in a manner consistent with related City requirements. » Policy 4.3: Maintain on-street parking where feasible. Careful consideration will be given before removing on-street parking.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-3
OBJECTIVE 5: Integrate the future transit station into the urban fabric and multi-modal transportation networks.
» Policy 5.1: Coordinate with Metro on the location and construction of the future station to ensure that access and design are cohesive with the City-owned parking structure adjacent to the tracks.
» Policy 5.2: Coordinate with Metro on a joint development project at the future transit station site to enable residential, retail, and service commercial uses.
» Policy 5.3: Coordinate with Metro on the creation of a public outdoor area that serves transit users. Support the creation of space for a variety of amenities.
» Policy 5.4: Coordinate with local transit operators to provide a well-designed interchange between bus service and the future Downtown Bellflower Transit Station.
» Policy 5.5: Coordinate with Metro to incorporate existing and future pedestrian and bicycle connections to the future transit station. Enhance access with new and upgraded crosswalks.
5.2 FIRST-LAST MILE STRATEGY
In 2014, the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro) approved its First Last Mile Strategic Plan, which identifies design strategies to improve active transportation access and connections to public transit. The Specific Plan recognizes that station access is a key element in successful TOD station area planning and has identified strategies that focus on improving accessibility during the first and last miles of a transit rider’s journey. These strategies include streetscape improvements, bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure improvements, as well as signage and wayfinding improvements.
5.2.1 PATHWAYS
The Metro Pathways concept established in Metro’s First and Last Mile Strategic Plan includes a hierarchy of pathways that extend to and from a transit station and is designed to support active modes of transportation. These pathways take into consideration the existing street network, key destinations, feeder transit services, existing and planned infrastructure, existing bike and pedestrian volumes, and surrounding land uses in order to design an active transportation network that improves transit station access. The recommended pathway system (Figure 5.1 Pathways) may not correlate with the City’s traditional street classification shown in Figure 5.2 Street Network. The Metro Pathways concept is comprised of two types of pathways, pathway arterials and pathway collectors. Pathway arterials serve as the main branches of the network, while pathway collectors serve as feeder routes. How the pathways function around the
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-4
Bellflower Station may be different than their official street designation as either arterial or collector. For example, while Alondra Boulevard may be a major arterial as defined by Bellflower’s circulation element, it functions as a collector in relation to the station. Figure 5.1 illustrates the proposed Metro Pathway network surrounding the Downtown Bellflower Transit Station and includes pathway arterials, pathway collectors, existing bus stops, and key destinations.
Pathway Arterials
Pathway arterials are primary routes that extend from stations and support maximum activity for active transportation users. They are designed to accommodate high levels of active transportation and a broad range of users. They typically include design treatments such as signal and crossing improvements, wayfinding signage, and plug-in components (e.g., bike sharing). Potential design treatments are dependent on existing conditions and City priorities. Implementation will require consideration by the City of Bellflower’s Public Works Department.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
FIGURE 5.1 Pathways
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-6
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
FIGURE 5.2 Street Network
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-8
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-9
Pathway arterials should typically radiate out from a station portal in at least four directions, and extend out at a minimum of one-half mile from the station to an upper limit of three miles from the station.
Pathway arterials should also integrate the regional bikeway network at opportune points beyond the one-half mile access shed. As illustrated in Figure 5.1, the pathway arterials connecting the Downtown Bellflower Transit Station to the community include Bellflower Boulevard and Mayne Street. Because of the station’s limited access points, ingress and egress to the site will be especially important.
Pathway Collectors
Pathway collectors are routes within the station area that feed into pathway arterials, support crossing movements, and enhance general station area permeability. They work to reduce travel distances for non-motorized users by focusing on the provision of efficient access to pathway arterials. Pathway collectors include streets and routes located within the one-half mile access shed of a transit station and streets that feed into the main branch lines or pathway arterials. They typically include design considerations that improve intersections and crossings. As illustrated in Figure 5.1, pathway collectors surrounding the Downtown Bellflower Transit Station includes Alondra Boulevard to the north, Mayne Street to the west, Flower Street, Park Street, and the bike trail to the south.
5.3 STREET NETWORK
The Specific Plan provides guidance for the design of a comprehensive and context-sensitive street network to connect the Bellflower community. The Specific Plan area is characterized by a grid network, with a break in the pattern occurring where the railroad right-of-way crosses at a diagonal from north-west to south-east. Much of the street network within the Specific Plan area will remain the same in order to support new development and growth within the area. Some of the streetscape improvements implemented along Bellflower Boulevard will be extended from Mayne Street to Alondra Boulevard.
There are additional proposed improvements along key arterials within the Specific Plan area. These improvements are intended to transform the existing auto-oriented streetscape into a more sustainable, multi-modal design. The Specific Plan’s roadway and circulation network plans are described below and can be seen in Figure 5.2. The Specific Plan focuses on Bellflower Boulevard, Alondra Boulevard, Flower Street, and the bike trail because of their importance in relation to the Bellflower Station.
5.3.1 BELLFLOWER BOULEVARD
Existing Conditions
Bellflower Boulevard is classified as a secondary arterial roadway within the Specific Plan area by the General Plan Circulation Element
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-10
as it distributes traffic to smaller geographic areas, connects drivers to higher volume arterials such as Alondra Boulevard, and
accommodates trips of moderate length. However, in relation to the Bellflower Station it acts as an arterial and serves as the primary access route to and from the Bellflower Station and for people wishing to visit Downtown Bellflower. The existing boulevard is illustrated in Figure 5.3.
FIGURE 5.3 Bellflower Boulevard (Existing)
Bellflower Boulevard connects to Alondra Boulevard to the north and SR-91 to the south. It is a north-south, four-lane undivided roadway with a painted double yellow centerline, within the Specific Plan boundary. Bellflower Boulevard is well-traveled and has two lanes of travel in both directions, on-street parking, with left turn lanes at Alondra Boulevard, and no bicycle lanes. Within the Specific Plan area, Bellflower Boulevard has eight traffic signals, two pedestrian- dedicated flashing sign crossings, and one scramble intersection, meaning that all traffic signals turn red at the same time and pedestrians can move freely through the intersection (including diagonally) during the crossing period. Two bus routes travel along Bellflower Boulevard (see the Transit Network section for more information). Bellflower Boulevard is a completed Los Angeles County Traffic Signal Synchronization Program route.
Proposed Improvements
Improvements to Bellflower Boulevard are planned within the existing right-of-way. They include extending the street improvements between Mayne Street and Alondra Boulevard, as well as potential turn-outs for bus and rideshare services associated with the transit station.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-11
Since the Downtown Revitalization Vision Strategy was prepared in 2003, the City has been working on land use and design strategies to help downtown Bellflower develop its own unique sense of place. As part of these efforts significant improvements has been made along Bellflower Boulevard between Flower and the train tracks. Including new decorative traffic signal equipment, widening roads to provide exclusive turn lanes, new sidewalks and curb ramps, and decorative crosswalks. The City’s vision is that these improvements would extended along Bellflower Boulevard north to Alondra Boulevard and south to the SR-91.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-12
Extending the improvements that have already been started along Bellflower Boulevard will help create a cohesive corridor. Wider sidewalks with pedestrian amenities, such as street trees, landscaping, and lighting should be considered to enhance safety and the overall pedestrian environment.
5.3.2 ALONDRA BOULEVARD
Existing Conditions
Alondra Boulevard is a key east-west, auto-centric corridor with wide travel lanes, minimal street trees, and no bicycle lanes. It is classified as a major arterial roadway in the General Plan. It provides a high degree of mobility and access to the surrounding community. It is a main corridor for local traffic while being used as a thoroughfare for through traffic. It acts as a collector in relation to the future Bellflower Station.
Alondra Boulevard provides connectivity from the Specific Plan area to I-605 to the east and I-710 to the west. This is a heavily traveled roadway with two lanes of travel in each direction, one turning lane and on-street parking.
Alondra Boulevard, in the project vicinity, is an east-west, four-lane divided roadway with a continuous left-turn lane. The posted speed limit on Alondra Boulevard is 40 miles per hour. See Figure 5.4.
Within the Specific Plan area, there are seven traffic lights, complete with crosswalks to promote pedestrian safety. Alondra Boulevard also serves as a relatively busy corridor for public transportation and provides bus stops for four different bus routes within the Specific Plan area. Alondra Boulevard is a completed Los Angeles County Traffic Signal Synchronization Program route.
FIGURE 5.4 Alondra Boulevard (Existing)
Proposed Improvements
Improvements to Alondra Boulevard would take place within the existing right-of-way. The streetscape improvements to Alondra Boulevard should build upon those already made on Bellflower Boulevard with a focus on improvements to the pedestrian realm through added street trees, curb extensions, and bus shelters.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-13
Proposed Improvements
Improvements to Alondra Boulevard would take place within the existing right-of-way. The streetscape improvements to Alondra Boulevard should build upon those already made on Bellflower Boulevard with a focus on improvements to the pedestrian realm through added street trees, curb extensions, and bus shelters. Adding additional street trees and working within the existing right-of-way to add more pedestrian amenities and landscaping will help give Alondra Boulevard and the adjacent businesses a stronger identity and sense of place.
Proposed improvements along Alondra Boulevard include:
» Curb extensions at Alondra Boulevard at Eucalyptus Avenue. » Traffic signal replacement associated with curb extensions. » New bus shelters
See Figure 5.10 for recommended street trees and Section 5.4 for bikeway recommendations.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-14
5.3.3 FLOWER STREET
Existing Conditions
Flower Street, in the project vicinity, is an east-west, four-lane undivided roadway with a painted double yellow centerline. On-street parking is permitted on Flower Street.
Flower Street is classified as a Secondary Arterial roadway and serves to funnel traffic from local roads to the arterial network, particularly on the south side of the Specific Plan area. Flower Street intersects with Bellflower Boulevard, Woodruff Avenue, and Clark Avenue, and provides connections to the surrounding freeways and interstates.
Although not as heavily traveled as Bellflower Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard, Flower Street has two travel lanes in both directions, on- street parking, and serves only one bus route. See Figure 5.5.
FIGURE 5.5 Flower Street (Existing)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-15
Proposed Section
Flower Street was recently re-paved and all intersections brought into ADA compliance. As such, changes along Flower Street are proposed to be more minimal but may include the addition of more street trees and the eventual undergrounding of overhead utilities.
As a secondary arterial, Flower Street is envisioned as part of the expanding bicycle network within Bellflower. The proposed street sections for Flower Street is in response to the Bellflower-Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan. Although the Bicycle Master Plan proposes a Class II Bicycle Lane, this would require the removal of needed on- street parking or travel lanes. Therefore, it is proposed that Flower Street be designated a Class III Bicycle Route with shared lane markings along Flower Street from the Pacific Electric Rail Road right- of-way to the west City Boundary.
The proposed alternative, seen in Figure 5.6, would make Flower Street a designated bicycle route. Bicycles would share the existing road with vehicles, so no lane width alterations are needed. The shared-use lane is proposed along the length of Flower Street along the outside travel lane. This improvement would allow cyclists and commuters to connect into the multi-use trail that runs diagonally through Bellflower.
See Figure 5.10 for recommended street trees and Section 5.4 for bikeway recommendations.
FIGURE 5. 6 Flower Street (Proposed)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-16
5.4 BICYCLE NETWORK
Bicycling provides a sustainable solution for traveling the first and last mile to and from a transit station. While transit and bicycling are complementary modes, issues of infrastructure connectivity often impact a person’s decision to bike the first and last mile of their journey from transit. The following section describes improvements to the bicycle network to promote bicycling within the Specific Plan area.
This section describes the existing conditions of the bicycle network within the Specific Plan area including its relation to the Bellflower- Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan.
5.4.1 BICYCLE NETWORK
Figure 5.7 illustrates the level of bicycle accessibility within a half-mile radius of the Downtown Bellflower transit station. Using the station as a starting point, all possible bicycle routes were mapped based on the street grid and then consolidated into a larger catchment area or bike shed. The proposed metro line extension will be constructed on a right-of-way that is currently owned by the Pacific Electric Rail Road and partially occupied by a walking and bicycling trail (described in Section 5.4.3). This means that the existing path will need to be realigned in order to coexist with the rail line.
The existing bicycle network within the Specific Plan area consists of approximately 2.5 miles of existing bikeway infrastructure. The Specific Plan proposes to add another 2.5 miles of bikeways to the existing network as illustrated in Figure 5.7. Flower Street was selected based on the opportunities it presented to improve connectivity to the future transit station and to the regional bikeway network of neighboring cities.
Additional opportunities to expand Bellflower’s bicycle network should make sure to tie into the existing network and should maintain compatibility with the Bellflower-Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-17
FIGURE 5.7 Bicycle Network
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-18
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-19
5.4.2 BICYCLE FACILITY TYPES
Bikeways are facilities that are designated primarily for bicycle travel.
They are generally divided into the following five classes per the Bellflower-Paramount Bike & Trail Master Plan:
» Class I (Bike Path): Provides an exclusive right-of-way completely separated from the street used by motor vehicles. Designated for the exclusive use of bicycles and pedestrians with crossflow traffic minimized.
» Class II (Bike Lane): Provides a restricted on-street right-of-way.
Designated for the exclusive or semi-exclusive use of bicycles with through travel by motor vehicles or pedestrians prohibited, but with crossflows by pedestrians and motorists permitted.
Vehicle parking can be allowed to the right of a bike lane if sufficient right-of-way width exists.
» Class III (Bike Route): Provides for shared use with motor vehicles and is on-street. Designated by signs or permanent markings.
» Class III (Bike Boulevard): Provides for shared use with motor vehicles and is on-street. Designated by signs or permanent markings. It is further enhanced with traffic calming measures, bicycle wayfinding signage, and crossing improvements.
» Class IV (Separated Bikeway or Cycle Track): Provides bikeways located in or adjacent to a roadway and separated from traffic by a physical barrier such as bollards, on-street parking, or planters.
This design allows an exclusive right-of-way for bicycle travel.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-20
5.4.3 WALKING AND BIKE TRAIL
Existing Conditions
The existing bike trail is a regional amenity and the backbone of Bellflower’s bicycle network. It runs diagonally through the city along the railroad right-of-way from the San Gabriel River and the City of Cerritos to the east to the City of Paramount to the west. Because the railroad tracks form a natural barrier dividing the city, this trail is crucial to helping cyclists navigate the City. The current bike path includes a 4’ bike lane in either direction with a 2’ buffer and 6’ pedestrian sidewalk.
Vision
The existing bike trail along the Pacific Electric Rail Road right-of-way is crucial to Bellflower’s vision to plan for high-quality transit and a transit-supportive environment and the success of the bicycle network. The bicycle network is designed to intersect with the bike trail and connects in at several locations including the intersection of Flower Street and Mayne Street. If this bike trail were to be removed, it would turn the existing network into a series of bicycle segments— with large gaps between existing segments and no way to bridge the gap. Therefore, it is recommended that when the metro line is extended that it includes sufficient right-of-way that multi-use trails can be maintained for the length of the existing bike trail. An example of this approach is the new Santa Monica Extension, which includes a parallel multi-use trail for much of the route. See Figure 5.8. Additional street trees should be added along this pathway to enhance areas with more shading. Street trees will keep the path shaded and make it more welcoming and comfortable.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-21
FIGURE 5.8 Walking and Bike Trail (Existing)
5.5 PEDESTRIAN ENVIRONMENT
The quality of the pedestrian environment often impacts a person’s decision to walk or drive to an area. Adequate pedestrian infrastructure, together with appropriate land use designations, can help to activate corridors and promote pedestrian activity. This section discusses some of the existing opportunities to improve the pedestrian environment within Bellflower and to reinforce the area as a TOD district.
Sidewalks present inventive opportunities to transform streets into public spaces. In order to create a vibrant walking environment that encourages pedestrian activity, sidewalks need to be safe, connected, comfortable, accessible, and attractive. The sidewalk improvements made along Bellflower Boulevard are an example of a well-designed pedestrian environment.
Although sidewalks exist along major streets within the Specific Plan area, most sidewalks lack landscaping and shade and do not support high levels of pedestrian activity. The Specific Plan proposes a sidewalk hierarchy to establish a physical framework for sidewalk design. The sidewalk hierarchy shown in Figure 5.9 is intended to facilitate the most appropriate allocation of space that encourages people to walk as a part of their everyday routine.
The area immediately surrounding the proposed station location has a Walk Score of 79 out of 100, reflecting a very walkable area where most errands can be accomplished on foot. Walk Scores are determined by awarding points based on the distance from a particular origin to amenities in a variety of categories. Areas with amenities within a 5-minute walk are given maximum points.
Population density and road metrics such as block length and intersection density are analyzed when determining Walk Scores.
Due to the large block size on the east side of the study area, there is limited pedestrian connectivity between blocks. Barriers are present along the Bellflower bike trails where private residential fencing prevents residents of a large mobile home community and senior citizen housing development from easily accessing the multi-purpose trail.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-22
.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-23
FIGURE 5. 9 Sidewalk Hierarchy
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-24
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-25
5.5.1 SIDEWALK HIERARCHY
The sidewalk hierarchy (Figure 5.9) is designed to support varying levels of pedestrian activity. It provides more space and wider sidewalks in areas with higher pedestrian activity and where greater needs for street furniture and additional pedestrian amenities are needed and narrower sidewalks where such needs do not exist.
Sidewalks must serve a variety of competing uses. For example, the sidewalk must provide a buffer between pedestrians and the street, a buffer between pedestrians and store entrances, and serve as a thoroughfare and an amenity zone for items such as street furniture and street trees.
The sidewalk hierarchy is composed of three levels: Level 1 sidewalks, which are the widest sidewalks, should be located along pathway arterials to accommodate high levels of pedestrian activity. Level 2 sidewalks should be located along pathway collectors to accommodate moderate levels of pedestrian activity, while Level 3 sidewalks should be reserved for low-density residential streets. The various levels of the sidewalk hierarchy are defined as follows:
» Level 1: Sidewalks are the widest sidewalks within the hierarchy and should have a minimum width of ten feet when possible in order to support high pedestrian volumes and to accommodate the street trees, benches, outdoor seating, and other amenities.
Level 1 sidewalks should be located along pathway arterials and areas with higher density, mixed-use, or commercial land use development, and near the future transit station. Space allocation for Level 1 sidewalks should favor the pedestrian and store frontage to provide adequate passing space between pedestrians and to accommodate for store-front amenities such as outdoor seating within commercial or mixed-use zones. » Level 2: Sidewalks are slightly narrower in width than Level 1 sidewalks and should have a minimum width of seven feet in order to accommodate moderate levels of pedestrian activity and to accommodate some pedestrian amenities. Level 2
sidewalks should be located along pathway collectors. Space allocation for Level 2 sidewalks should favor the pedestrian and street furniture.
» Level 3: Sidewalks are the narrowest sidewalks within the hierarchy and should be located along low-density residential streets that do not carry high volumes of traffic or pedestrian activity. They should have a minimum width of five feet in order to meet American Disability Act (ADA) standards and be
accessible for all pedestrians regardless of ability. Due to its minimal width, space allocation of Level 3 sidewalks should favor clear lines of travel for pedestrians.
Figure 5.9 illustrates the suggested locations of the various sidewalk levels. The Specific Plan, however, recognizes that sidewalk design and construction often occur under constrained conditions, such as narrow
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-26
right-of-ways, utilities, grading, and topography. These are all key factors to consider when designing sidewalk improvements.
5.6 STREET TREES
Street trees serve a variety of urban design functions such as acting as a pedestrian buffer, accentuating spaces, creating a sense of enclosure, improving air quality, reduction of heat island effect by providing shade and filtered light, and improving visual aesthetics along a corridor. Street trees should be incorporated whenever possible, especially along pathway arterials. All street trees should be planted in accordance with established City planting standards.
Planting a variety of tree species insures greater resilience and continuity when facing unforeseen events such as diseases and tree pests, and adverse weather and climate.
There are some trees that have been planted along front property lines that help to provide shade for pedestrians. There are ninety-six street trees on Bellflower Boulevard from Linden Street to the 91 - Freeway and forty-four street trees on Mayne Street between Bellflower Boulevard and Clark Avenue.
The streetscape design recommendations are focused on the following roadways: Bellflower Boulevard, Alondra Boulevard, Flower Street, and Mayne Street. Special care should be taken when planting trees in areas with overhead utility lines.
In general, a consistent, well-design landscape plan for the streets can provide shade, introduce seasonal color, define the street edge, and invite pedestrian activity. The following street tree recommendations (Figure 5.10) are based on Bellflower’s Master Street Tree Master Plan with some additions.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-27
FIGURE 5.10 Street Trees
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-28
Street trees will be arranged along the sidewalk or landscape easements at intervals appropriate with street scale and canopy cover in order to provide a sense of rhythm and movement within the streetscape.
» Flowering trees and trees with seasonal color have been selected to provide a dynamic color palette. The use of color is key for creating an active landscape which denotes the passing of time and creates visual interest.
» The plant palette incorporates deciduous plant material to provide shade canopies during the warm season while allowing penetration of sunlight during the cooler months to provide a more comfortable and inviting atmosphere.
» Incorporate suspended pavement system(s) improving soil volume to support larger tree species development and improve plant health, promoting higher plant success rates. Additionally, these systems provide storm water quality management through capture, evapotranspiration and storage.
» The placement of trees and planted parkways will provide greater separation for pedestrians from the vehicle traffic, promoting the use of sidewalks by creating a more comfortable experience for pedestrians.
» The plant palette avoids trees with invasive root structures and trees that drop excessive amounts of leaf and seed pod debris.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-29
5.7 ENTRIES & MONUMENTATION
Key intersections and gateways require greater attention to detail due to their prominent locations and sensitive relationship to the public realm. Special wayfinding signage is often used to mark the entrance or direction to a particular destination. In addition, the treatment of buildings and the public realm at key locations create a landmark and establish a unique sense of identity.
Key opportunity areas exist along major corridors and entrance points in the Specific Plan area including:
» Existing wayfinding mural under SR-91
» Existing arched gateway over Laurel Street
» Future gateway feature at the southwest corner of Alondra Boulevard and Bellflower Boulevard
» Future landmark feature in the plaza of the future transit station » Future special monumentation for the Fire Museum
5.8 GREEN STREETS
The Specific Plan encourages the incorporation of sustainable landscape practices to achieve a desired visual aesthetic which includes healthy growing conditions, plant sizing, environmental sustainability in addition to contributing to the long-term development of Bellflower. The following are guidelines for undertaking green street improvements:
» The use of rain gardens, open tree grates, green roofs and pockets of open space to slow stormwater flow rates, allow natural percolation of runoff and reduce the heat island effect is encouraged.
» Use of permeable pavement to capture and treat stormwater runoff must be used when appropriate. Examples of permeable paving include porous asphalt, reinforced grass, semi-impervious concrete paving blocks, and reinforced gravel with grass. » Stormwater retention system such as rain barrels are also encouraged in order to provide for non-potable uses such as irrigation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-30
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-31
» Irrigation controllers should be programmed to operate late night and early morning to reduce evaporation.
» Plants with similar water requirements should be grouped together to utilize hydro zoning techniques. Trees should be pruned annually to maintain appearance, growth and to help develop scaffold branches to prevent toppling and storm or wind damage to specimens.
» Vegetation in a state of decline or dead plant material should be replaced. Hardscape and landscaped planters should be kept clear of weeds, leaf litter, garbage, and other debris. » The governing documents of a common interest development or property owner associations cannot prohibit or include
conditions that have the effect of prohibiting the use of low- water use plants or restricting compliance with a local water- efficient landscape ordinance or water conservation measure. » Implementation of infiltration best management practices must be strategically placed as not to cause adverse impacts to the proposed building structures. Infiltration within close proximity to foundations and footings is highly discouraged. Where high density and large building footprints occur, the locations of infiltration should be limited to select areas such as landscaping, parking lots, courtyards, plazas, and streets. Opportunities for infiltration include incorporation of underground detention systems with drywells, bioretention planters typically located within pedestrian zone landscape areas and permeable
pavement within parking areas of streets and sidewalks. » Opportunities for biotreatment features such as storm water planters and bioretention facilities are optimally located within traditional landscape areas adjacent to hardscape or buildings.
Biotreatment planters can also be located around the buildings to provide treatment of roof runoff. See Figure 5.11.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-32
FIGURE 5.11 Examples of Biotreatment Features
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-33
5.9 TRANSIT CIRCULATION
The Specific Plan area has access to a network of public transportation options. Seven bus routes, operated by Metro, the City of Bellflower, and the Cities of Long Beach and Norwalk traverse through the Specific Plan area. The closest existing rail stations (located on the Metro Green Line) are the Lakewood Boulevard and Norwalk stations, 3 and 4 miles, respectively, north of the center of the Specific Plan area. There are no direct bus routes connecting residents of the Specific Plan area to the existing Green Line stations. The Metro Blue Line is approximately eight miles west of the center of the Specific Plan area, and the Metro 127 bus line provides connections to the Compton Station and greater Metro rail system.
5.9.1 BUS NETWORK
Existing Conditions
Buses are an amenity that connect residential districts, employment centers, and transit hubs while providing an alternative to single- occupancy driving. The quality and frequency of service often effects an individual’s decision to ride transit. Bus stop amenities also help improve the bus-riding experience; these include shade elements, seating, vegetation, and real-time bus arrival information. Additionally, adequate pedestrian infrastructure at and within one-half mile or more of each stop is important to create a connection to local business and homes. The existing pedestrian hierarchy can be seen in Figure 5.9.
Within the Specific Plan area are seven bus lines that can be seen in Figure 5.12. Bellflower Bus operates two local bus services: The North Route and the South Route. These operate at one-half hour headways, the time between bus arrivals. These routes provide access to local amenities including Downtown Bellflower, the historic train depot, and Simms Park.
LA Metro operates two bus lines within the Specific Plan area. The 127 comes approximately every hour and provides access to Compton. The 128 runs at approximately forty-minute headways during peak periods and one hour off-peak. Long Beach Bus operates the 91, 92, and 93 bus routes in the area that run at twenty-minute headways and connect downtown Bellflower with Long Beach. Norwalk Bus operates Route 1 in Bellflower connecting residents to Norwalk and Rio Hondo College.
An on-board ridership survey undertaken by city staff indicated that 71% of Bellflower Bus riders were choice riders, meaning that they could have made the trip by another means. This number of riders and percentage of choice riders is likely to change with the opening of the Bellflower Station.
Proposed Improvements
To provide convenient and frequent bus service connection to the future Downtown Bellflower Transit Station, buses will be rerouted to provide direct access at the station site. Transit will also be integrated
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-34
into the future parking and multi-modal structure to the south of the station site. This will enhance the connection between the surrounding neighborhoods and the station and increase the appeal for riders who may choose to take the bus and train. One proposed improvement is a north-south serving rapid bus service along Bellflower Boulevard.
Future studies will be undertaken to determine route connections, the location of new stops, and the frequency of bus service to serve the future riders and provide connections to local amenities.
5.9.2 WEST SANTA ANA BRANCH LINE
The Bellflower Station provides an opportunity to unite the City’s goals for the downtown area with the benefits of a local connection to the future West Santa Ana Branch Transit Corridor and Metro’s extensive transit network. This light-rail line will connect Bellflower and surrounding cities to Downtown Los Angeles to the north and Artesia to the south, and ultimately, to stations in Orange County. The West Santa Ana Branch Transit Corridor was included in a list of projects accelerated by the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics and is anticipated to connect Downtown Los Angeles and Downtown Bellflower with high-quality transit in 2027.
Bellflower’s proximity to this transit line will provide opportunities to attract new development, encourage multimodal transportation, improve access to major employment centers, and reintroduce Downtown Bellflower as a thriving, experience-oriented district for residents and visitors.
Although the opening of the transit station is years away, the market is ready to start embracing future transit and to revitalize Bellflower’s charming, walkable downtown. By introducing a transit station in the downtown core, Bellflower will create a setting for new high-quality residences and a range of new commercial and entertainment activity that will support and sustain a thriving downtown environment
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
FIGURE 5.12 Bus Routes
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-36
This page intentionally left blank
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-37
5.9.3 DOWNTOWN BELLFLOWER TRANSIT STATION
A station along the West Santa Ana Branch Transit Corridor is proposed at Bellflower Boulevard and the Pacific Electric ROW, at the northern edge of Downtown Bellflower. The Downtown Bellflower Station is consistent with the City’s longstanding transit-oriented development vision, policies, and plans for Downtown. In addition, it was an historic stop on the Pacific Electric West Santa Ana Branch and is part of the City’s transportation heritage, now honored by the restored Pacific Electric Depot.
Of the fifteen proposed station locations on the Eco-Rapid line, the Downtown Bellflower Station was one of six selected as a prototype location that would receive an additional level of research. The six prototype stations each possess community settings and opportunities that best represent study corridor opportunities as a whole.
Station Design Concepts
The city commissioned studies to explore the future station location and relationship to the surrounding site. One study explored two locations for the Bellflower Station. The first station option was located above Bellflower Boulevard with entrances on both the east and west of the roadway. A second station option was located to the west of Bellflower Boulevard with a single main entrance.
Both design options promoted the improvement of pedestrian infrastructure, the integration of the bike path and bus stops, connection to the future parking and multi-modal structure to the south of the station site, and the incorporation of open space and shopping amenities. These design elements activate the station’s relationship with the vibrant Downtown Bellflower, which provides an amenity-rich streetscape to the south, and future amenities to the north recommended by this plan.
The conceptual station and site design was based on Metro standards and guidelines and the station’s relationship to the surrounding site.
Standards and guidelines considered include LACMTA Metro Rail Design Criteria – Section 6 - Architectural Revision 9 (2015), LACMTA Metro Rail Architectural Directive (2010), Federal Transit Administration: Americans with Disabilities Act: Guidance (FTA AADAG), and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 130:
Standard for Fixed Guideway Transit and Passenger Rail. These provided guidelines on station and platform sizing, station accessibility, design and material criteria, life safety, and circulation and access elements.
The visualization below (Figure 5.13) is a conceptual view looking south of the future Bellflower Station above Bellflower Boulevard and associated-transit oriented development. The station acts as a gateway to Downtown Bellflower just south of the station. The site acts as a link in the public open space network while providing amenities to commuters and residents. This visualization
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-38
demonstrates the opportunities to integrate the station into the local area along with enhanced pedestrian and open space amenities that unite the station with the transit-oriented goals of the city. Detailed assessment of pedestrian amenities is required to determine operational feasibility and effect on transportation.
Plans of the plaza and platform levels can be seen in Figures 5.14 through 5.17.
FIGURE 5.13 Conceptual Design
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-39
FIGURE 5.14 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design
Option 1: Plaza Level Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-40
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-41
wer Station Conceptual Design
Level Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-42
FIGURE 5.16 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design
Option 2: Plaza Level Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-43
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-44
FIGURE 5.17 Bellflower Station Conceptual Design
Opti
on
2:
Platf
orm
Leve
l
Plan
FIGURE 5.14
Bellf
lowe
r
Stati
on
Conc
eptu
al
Desi
gn
Opti
on
1:
Plaz
a
Leve
l Pla
Opti
on 2
:
Platf
orm
Leve
l
Plan
FIGU
RE
5.14 Bellf
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Mobility
5-45
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Land Use Plan
DRAFT | AUGUST 2019 239
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-1
6. INFRASTRUCTURE
Infrastructure and utility services such as water, wastewater, and stormwater drainage are critical elements that support the growth and change envisioned in the Specific Plan (Figure 6.1, Examples of Infrastructure Elements). The infrastructure chapter provides an overview of the existing conditions of the water, wastewater, and storm drainage systems serving the Specific Plan area, along with any recommended upgrades to accommodate future development.
FIGURE 6.1 Examples of Infrastructure Elements
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-2
6.1 WATER
The Bellflower Somerset Mutual Water Company (BSM) provides potable water within the boundary of the Specific Plan. Customer needs are served through local groundwater with supplemental quantities coming from recycled water. BSM owns roughly three quarters of the ground water supplies needed to serve its customers and leases the remainder from the City of Bellflower. Currently, most parcels within the Specific Plan area are not used as local groundwater recharge facilities. The primary groundwater production wells for the Specific Plan area are at the City Yard.
The Specific Plan area is serviced by pipes varying from four- to 48- inches. The largest pipe lines run along Woodruff Avenue, Pacific Avenue, Flora Vista Street, Bellflower Boulevard, and Alondra Boulevard. Most of the distribution pipes off the main lines are six- to ten-inches in size. Figure 6.2, Existing Water Lines, illustrates the water pipe line size and location for the Specific Plan area. The pipe lines are composed of a variety of materials including cast iron, ductile iron, and asbestos cement.
The water lines are sufficient for the current land uses in the Specific Plan area. There have been no recent improvement projects and there are no proposed improvement projects for the Specific Plan area.
Given the increase in water demand from the proposed increase in land use intensity for Planning Areas 2 and 3, it is likely that water mains would need to be upsized to provide water for both domestic use and fire protection. Proposed increases in water demands associated with the Specific Plan will need to be accounted for in future planning studies. The water provider, BSM, will need to evaluate and holistically analyze future development to decide whether water facilities require upgrades.
.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-3
FIGURE 6.2 Existing Water Lines
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-4
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-5
6.2 WASTEWATER SERVICES
Two sanitary wastewater systems exist in the Specific Plan area – local lines operated by the City of Bellflower and trunk lines operated by Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts (LACSD). The local lines are a series of primarily eight-inch gravity mains connecting to the trunk lines along Clark Avenue, Park Street, and Flora Vista Street. Figure 6.3, Existing Wastewater System, shows the location, width, and owner of the existing wastewater lines.
The City’s wastewater collection system is maintained and managed by Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts (LACSD). The collection system consists of about 99 miles of gravity wastewater lines. Wastewater is collected by City lines and conveyed to trunk lines owned and maintained by Los Angeles County Sanitation District #2, which then treats the wastewater at a regional facility. Wastewater flows from the City ultimately flow to LACSD wastewater trunk lines and are treated by either the Los Coyotes Water Reclamation Plant (WRP), or the Joint Water Pollution Control Plant (JWPCP) in Carson. The Specific Plan area sewage flows only to the JWPCP.
The Specific Plan area was included in the City of Bellflower Wastewater Master Plan (SMP) drafted in March 2007. The purpose of the SMP was to evaluate the existing wastewater collection system in the City of Bellflower, which included modeling infrastructure to determine any segments in need of improvement and propose additional
improvements for the future. The SMP notes three improvement tiers for wastewater lines across the City, based on depth of flow to diameter of pipe (d/D) ratio. These tiers correspond to priority for wastewater line improvement and correction measures, as shown in Figure 6.4, Existing Wastewater System Improvement Tiers.
Priority 1 Improvement lines are located along Alondra Boulevard, Clark Avenue and Woodruff Avenue. Priority 2 Improvement lines are on Alondra Boulevard and Clark Avenue. The City currently has no wastewater improvement projects proposed for the Specific Plan area.
In addition, there are no existing improvements required for the LACSD trunk lines or the JWPCP treatment facility.
Wastewater infrastructure in the Specific Plan area would likely need to be expanded to provide capacity for flows created by additional residential units and commercial space. There is adequate capacity in the LACSD trunk lines and the JWPCP treatment facility to allow for the proposed additional wastewater flows generated by the
implementation of the Specific Plan, however the following City lines may require improvement to accommodate future buildout. » A portion of Planning Area 2 ultimately flows north to eight- and twelve-inch lines that are designated as Priority 1 and Priority 2 improvement areas. A portion of Planning Area 2 also flows south and west and ultimately ties into the twelve- and fifteen- inch lines along Clark Avenue which are also designated as
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-6
Priority 1 and Priority 2 improvement lines. A northern portion of Planning Area 2 ties into the eight-and twenty-four-inch lines along Eucalyptus Avenue which are also designated as Priority 3 improvement lines. This same area also ties into eight- inch lines along Leahy Avenue and Blaine Avenue, which are also
designated as Priority 3 improvement lines.
» The south portion of Planning Area 2 ties into the eight- and ten- inch lines at the intersection of Bellflower Boulevard and Flower Street; a portion of the lines are also designated as Priority 3 improvement lines.
» Planning Area 3 ties into the eight- and ten-inch lines and at the intersection of Bellflower Boulevard and Flower Street; a portion of the lines are also designated as Priority 3 improvement lines. » Eastern flows from Planning Area 4 traveling to the west will pass through a Priority 3 improvement line. Western Planning Area 4 ties into eight-inch lines that are adequate. However, these lines flow in a westerly direction and tie into a Priority 2 eighteen-inch line on Clark Avenue, and may pass through a Priority 3 improvement line on Ardmore Avenue.
Improvements to lines within the Specific Plan area will be addressed through development impact fees for all new construction. New developments will be required to pay fees to the City associated with the increase in wastewater flows and connection fees imposed by LACSD. Additionally, any new development that may impact existing LACSD facilities will be subject to review and requires LACSD approval before development can continue. Potential impacts to LACSD facilities and associated LACSD review requirements and connection fees must be analyzed on a project by project basis.
.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-7
FIGURE 6.3 Existing Wastewater System
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-8
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-9
FIGURE 6. 4 Existing Wastewater System Improvement Tiers
NAP
NAP
Existing LACSD Wastewater Lines
Existing Bellflower Wastewater Lines
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-10
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-11
6.3 FLOOD CONTROL AND STORM DRAINAGE
The Specific Plan area is mostly built out with a relatively high impervious condition. During storm events, most runoff does not have the opportunity to infiltrate and recharge groundwater except areas where there are existing pervious surfaces. This results in water flowing to stormwater drainage. Recent projects, such as The Mayne Events Center/Fire Museum, implement techniques that increase perviousness and provide opportunities for infiltration.
The City of Bellflower is served by two primary drainage systems operated and maintained by the City of Bellflower and the Los Angeles County Department of Public Works (LACDPW). Stormwater flows into City of Bellflower catch basins and storm drain pipes that range from eighteen-inches to 45-inches in diameter and are primarily reinforced concrete pipe (RCP). Stormwater then flows into LACDPW drainage culverts up to 90-inches wide. Stormwater flows discharge to the Los Cerritos Channel and ultimately into San Pedro Bay, Los Alamitos Bay, and the Los Cerritos Estuary. A portion of the Specific Plan area will be treated by the Caruthers Storm Capture facility when it is completed.
The location and width of the storm drainage lines within the Specific Plan area are shown in Figure 6.5, Existing Storm Drains.
The City’s flood control is sufficient, however, LACDPW has noted that the County storm drain lines serving the Specific area have design flow capacities that are less than the 50-year frequency storm event. There are no planned improvement projects to the storm drainage system for the storm drain lines serving the Specific Plan area.
The implementation of the Specific Plan will not substantially alter the existing stormwater drainage pattern of the area and will use the existing drainage facilities within the public right of way. The City of Bellflower currently uses dry wells, tree wells, modular wetlands, bio- retention basins, and porous pavement in the downtown area.
Additional methods to decrease stormwater runoff are included in the following section, Sustainable Infrastructure Recommendations.
Additionally, the Los Angeles County Fourth-Term Municipal Separate Storm Wastewater Systems (MS4) permit requires that new development and significant redevelopment projects incorporate Low Impact Development Best Management Practices (LID BMPs), which will result in more runoff retained on-site, further reducing flows. LID BMPs address post-construction storm water runoff management and preserve a site’s predevelopment hydrology by minimizing the loss of natural hydrologic processes such as infiltration.
Infiltration is important to retain because when stormwater falls onto impervious surfaces, it cannot seep into the ground and therefore can cause flooding on roadways. Impervious roadways frequently wash stormwater runoff containing harmful pollutants into nearby water bodies, such as rivers and flood control channels, which lead directly to the ocean. These harmful pollutants include substances commonly
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-12
present on roadway surfaces, such as dirt, oil, grease, toxic chemicals, and trash, and can harm wildlife in local water bodies as well as nearby plants and vegetation. Impervious roadways can also contribute to problems with stormwater quantity. Unlike flood control measures that are designed to handle peak storm flows, LID BMPs and treatment control BMPs are designed to retain, filter or treat more frequent, low- flow runoff or the “first-flush” runoff from storm events.
LID BMP options include first prioritizing full retention infiltration systems as they provide full retention of the water volume and can also contribute to groundwater recharge in some areas. The second priority is capturing and reusing (“harvest and reuse”) stormwater on-site for either landscape irrigation or toilet flushing. Harvest and reuse BMPs are also full retention BMPs that provide additional water conservation benefits. Projects that have demonstrated they cannot infiltrate and/or harvest and reuse 100 percent of the water quality volume may manage the remaining volume through the use of biofiltration BMPs which treat stormwater and release it back into the storm drain system. .
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-13
FIGURE 6.5 Existing Storm Drains
NAP
NAP
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-14
This page intentionally left blank.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-15
6.4 SUSTAINABLE INFRASTRUCTURE
RECOMMENDATIONS
The Specific Plan recommends adopting sustainable infrastructure into new development in an effort to improve water conservation, reduce potable water usage, support green infrastructure features within the public right-of-way and reduce the environmental footprint of the City.
The following best practices and emerging trends and technologies that should be incorporated where feasible within the future redevelopment opportunities.
6.4.1 GREEN STREET FEATURES
Green streets are sustainable design features with many benefits. Green street design components include stormwater infiltration planters within parkways to treat lot runoff and roadway runoff; bulb out planters that provide traffic calming along with runoff treatment, tree boxes and light reflective paving surfaces which reduce heat island effects. Green street features should be coordinated with Public Works.
6.4.2 GRAY WATER SYSTEMS
Gray water systems collect and reuse the relatively clean waste water from showers, sinks, washing machines, and other kitchen appliances for toilet flushing or exterior landscaping, which can greatly reduce on-site potable water usage and wastewater generation fees. The process typically includes routing gray water, treating the water, and reusing the treated gray water within the building for toilet flushing or landscaping irrigation. Gray water systems are especially opportune and cost effective multifamily residential developments.
Bulb out planters provide a location
to plant trees and other plants.
Stormwater infiltration planter
between the street and sidewalk.
Bulb out planter with rainwater capture
Gray water and rainwater capture
can be reused for landscape irrigation
and toiler flushing.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-16
6.4.3 CISTERN AND REUSE SYSTEMS
Cisterns are tanks that collect runoff water from impervious areas and store the water for toilet flushing, irrigation, or other uses. Both small- and large-scale harvest and reuse systems may be feasible based on certain project types. Depending on the type of potable demand for landscape irrigation and toilet flushing of a new development of redevelopment, the implementation of a harvested rainwater BMP would provide a multi-benefit solution that could satisfy both water quality regulations and provide for a sustainable water quantity solution that would offset potable water costs. The efficiency and cost- effectiveness for harvest and reuse systems increases when combined with on-site gray water recycling systems.
6.4.4 GREEN ROOFS AND GREEN WALLS
Green roofs and green walls offer some of the most advanced ways to reduce stormwater runoff volumes and common pollutants. As open space becomes more limited within high density areas, green roofs provide a solution with many additional benefits including stormwater treatment, internal and external cooling effects for the building and aesthetic benefits, all within a shared footprint. Green roofs are most feasible when there is a sturdy building structure included in a project.
On the other hand, green walls require less structural stability and can be implemented on almost any vertical surface. Some opportunities include implementing green walls on the sides of large, above-ground parking structures. Green roof/wall design can be combined with harvest and reuse cisterns and gray water systems to provide a constant source of treated water for irrigation without increasing demands on local and regional potable water supplies.
Cisterns can be located above or below grade. Examples of green roofs and walls.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-17
6.5 PLANNING AREA 1
6.5.1 COMMUNITY DESIGN FRAMEWORK AND PUBLIC
IMPROVEMENTS PLAN
The Community Design Framework and Public Improvements Plan establishes a vision for Planning Area 1. The Community Design Framework and Public Improvements Plan provides a conceptual understanding of the overall design intent and vision for the project area to provide guidance for future project applicants. The following elements comprise the Community Design Framework and Public Improvements Plan:
A. Functional Connectivity. Planning Area 1 seeks to establish strong connections with the City’s downtown area through the establishment of a vibrant pedestrian-oriented environment, connection to existing and future planned transit options and maximizing the potential of integrated mixed-use developments that contribute to a strong local economy.
B. Physical Connectivity. Planning Area 1 promotes the
establishment of on-site and off-site amenities to further enhance pedestrian scale and function, and encourages the design of buildings and structures to enhance accessibility.
C. Framework Vision Plan. In collaboration with the residents of Bellflower, a framework Vision Plan was established for Planning Area 1. The Vision Plan describes the opportunities and constraints within Planning Area 1 and identifies the key features that influence its policies. The Vision Plan is illustrative only and may require additional approvals for use of rights-of-way. The Framework Vision Plan is shown in Figure 6.6, BAMU Framework Vision Plan.
D. Economic Development. The primary intent of Planning Area 1 is to establish a comprehensive economic development strategy that enhances opportunities for private sector investment. Land use standards, regulations and permitted uses have been developed with the expressed purpose of encouraging
investment.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-18
FIGURE 6.6 Planning Area 1 Framework Vision Plan
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-19
FIGURE 6.7 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Community Design
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-20
E. Conceptual Community Design Illustrations. In order to provide a visual depiction of the spirit and intent of Planning Area 1, conceptual illustrations have been developed. These illustrations visually describe what may result from the realization of the standards and provisions for Planning Area 1. These illustrations include:
1. Figure 6.7, Bellflower/Alondra Community Design Illustration provides a “bird’s eye” view of the Bellflower/Alondra
intersection.
2. Figure 6.8, Conceptual Streetview Concept – Bellflower Boulevard provides a street level view of prototypical mixed- use development along Bellflower Boulevard.
3. Figure 6.9, Conceptual Streetview Concept – Residential Street provides street level view of prototypical residential development along Eucalyptus Avenue.
FIGURE 6.8 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Streetview Concept – Bellflower Boulevard
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-21
FIGURE 6.9 Planning Area 1 Conceptual Streetview Concept – Residential Street
6.5.2 PLANNING AREA 1 INFRASTRUCTURE
Water and wastewater infrastructure improvements within Planning Area 1 was evaluated through the 2008 Bellflower Municipal Water System Water Master Plan and the 2007 City of Bellflower Wastewater Master Plan. As development projects are approved, required infrastructure improvements must comply with these documents.
A. Water. Planning Area 1 is currently served by an eighteen (18) inch backbone transmission main within Bellflower Boulevard, south of water Subsystem 2. The main extends along the
Bellflower Bike Path and terminates at the City yard. Other water transmission pipes ranging in size from eight (8) inches to twelve (12) inches are contained within Alondra Boulevard, Leahy Avenue, and Flora Vista Street. Existing transmission pipes are also present in Cornuta Avenue to the east of Planning Area 1 , and just east of Bellflower Boulevard intersecting with Oak Street and Belmont Street. Refer to Figure 6.10, Planning Area 1 Existing Water System.
1. Per the Bellflower Municipal Water System 2008 Water Master Plan, the primary improvement recommended within Planning Area 1 is a high capacity well at the City Yard. Other backbone and secondary transmission pipes within Planning Area 1 will remain in place and are not slated for upgrades.
Pipes within Systems 2 and 3 are anticipated to be increased from their current three (3) inch or four (4) inch sizes to six (6) inch or eight (8) inch sizes.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-22
FIGURE 6.10 Planning Area 1 Existing Water System
2. All future development projects within Planning Area 1 must comply with the 2008 Water Master Plan and its successor(s).
Refer to 6.10: Existing Water System.
B. Wastewater. Planning Area 1 is currently served by the City’s 95- mile gravity wastewater system. Tributary areas 43, 44, and 45 are located within the eastern portion, with the intersection of Bellflower Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard served primarily by existing mains within those streets. Deficiencies are identified in the City’s Wastewater Master Plan within Alondra Boulevard and Woodruff Avenue. Several lines adjacent to Alondra Boulevard and Flora Vista Street are also identified as deficient. The Master Plan confirms that the deficient reaches of wastewater mainlines are distributed throughout the City within Tributary Areas 1, 11, 28, 29, 30, 42, 44, 48, 49, 52, 59, 65, and 66. However, the most severe deficiencies occur in Tributary areas 48 and 42. Tributary area 48 is located directly east of Woodruff Avenue. Refer to Figure 6.11, Planning Area 1 Existing Wastewater System. To alleviate capacity issues, two (2) alternatives were studied that involve diverting wastewater flows to County Sanitation district trunk wastewater 18 ”
8”
Proposed High Capacity Well
Reservoir
Pump Station
BSMWC Pipes
Bellflower/Alondra
Mixed Use Overlay Boundary
BSMWC
WELL
33 BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-23
upstream of their current discharge points. Alternative 1 proposes four (4) connection points to eliminate deficiencies in McNabb Avenue south of Somerset Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard between Woodruff Avenue and McNabb Avenue. Deficiencies in Woodruff Avenue between Somerset Boulevard and Alondra
Boulevard would be reduced significantly. The four (4) connection points are as follows:
a. The west side wastewater in Woodruff Avenue at
Somerset Boulevard;
b. The east side wastewater in Woodruff Avenue at
Somerset Boulevard;
c. McNab Avenue at Somerset Boulevard;
d. Carfax Avenue at Somerset Boulevard.
FIGURE 6.11 Planning Area 1 Existing Wastewater System
Contribution District Area Number
City Sewer Trunk Sewer Bellflower/Alondra
Mixed Use Overlay Boundary
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-24
In addition to improvements listed above, a new eighteen (18) inch wastewater line would be built along Alondra Boulevard from Woodruff Avenue to Eucalyptus Avenue and connect to the CSD East Compton Boulevard relief trunk line. The diversion would take the flow from the area north of Alondra Boulevard in Area 48 and divert it to the CSD trunk line. Refer to Figure 6.12, Planning Area 1 Future Wastewater System.
FIGURE 6.12 Planning Area 1 Future Wastewater System
C. Circulation Improvements. Circulation improvements for Planning Area 1 seek to ensure that future development within the project area and the surrounding are consistent with the General Plan buildout assumptions. Hartzog & Crabill, Inc., in May, 2011 prepared a traffic impact study that recommended mitigation measures for several roadway segments that were forecasted to operate at deficient levels of service within Planning Area 1. Future development would require compliance Bl
a
i
n
e
A
v
e
.
Contribution District Area Number
New 18” VCP
City Sewer
Trunk Sewer
Bellflower/Alondra
Mixed Use Overlay Boundary
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-25
with said traffic impact study and appropriate mitigation measures.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Infrastructure
6-25
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Development Standards
7-1
7. URBAN DESIGN GUIDELINES
Design will play a crucial role in implementing the vision of creating of a transit supportive, high quality, pedestrian-friendly area. The layout of future development on infill sites, building placement and orientation, the design of public spaces, architectural character, and landscaping all contribute to the “sense of place” that is uniquely Bellflower. The design guidelines are intended to provide guidance to builders, engineers, designers, architects, city staff, and decision- makers from conceptual design to implementation. The following design principles have been established to reinforce the overall objectives of the Specific Plan:
ENCOURAGE TRANSPORTATION SUPPORTIVE DEVELOPMENT. With the future development of the new Metro station, it is essential that all new investment within the Specific Plan is transit supportive. This includes ensuring adequate land use densities, creating an inviting pedestrian environment, and providing amenities for multi-modal transportation including bicyclists, pedestrians, and transit riders.
The Specific Plan area should be designed so that pedestrians, bicyclists, and vehicles can all safely coexist. Conflict zones should be reduced, and non-vehicular traffic and circulation should be encouraged. Convenient and comfortable pedestrian paseos connecting residential, commercial, and open space uses improves pedestrian, as well as vehicular circulation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-2
CREATE VIBRANT PUBLIC PLACES. There are many
components that collectively help create a vibrant
and unique downtown. The placement of
buildings, street trees, attractive landscaping,
decorative lighting, and pedestrian scaled
amenities can all help to create a comfortable and
memorable environment. Interesting building
forms and facades can positively influence the
pedestrian experience and help in generating
pedestrian activity and increasing a sense of
security.
While the Bellflower and Alondra corridors have
historically been oriented to the automobile, it is
the people, not the cars upon which downtown
Bellflower depends. New development and
redevelopment along the Bellflower and Alondra
corridors should encourage people to stop and
utilize the spaces as opposed to just pass through.
Achievement of this principle can include human-
scale details, signage, cohesive architectural
imagery, pedestrian amenities and strong
relationships between the buildings, sidewalks
and other outdoor spaces.
PROMOTE HIGH QUALITY DESIGN. Building
materials and landscaping should be chosen
carefully for their ability to be maintained in a cost- effective manner at the same high quality as when
they were originally installed.
Buildings should also incorporate sustainable design practices. The daylighting of buildings, the use of energy efficient appliances, and incorporating permeable surfaces are some of the ways to reduce energy demand and promote resource conservation.
ABOUT THE DESIGN GUIDELINES
The design guidelines should be used in conjunction with the development standards in Chapter 4 to evaluate proposed developments. While the design guidelines promote a quality design, they are not a set of rigid requirements. They are general and illustrative in nature and are intended to encourage creativity and variety on the part of licensed designers. In some instances, one guideline may be relaxed in order to accomplish another, more important, guideline. The overall objective is to ensure that the intent and spirit of the design guidelines are followed to attain the best possible design solutions.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-3
SITE DESIGN GUIDELINES (PLANNING AREAS 2, 3,
AND 4)
Site design is an important process critical to
any development that may occur in
Bellflower. A project’s site plan will
determine how buildings are placed on a
site, where access will occur, and how
structures and spaces are located in relation
to each other and to adjacent off-site uses.
The following guidelines must be integrated
in the site design of all new projects.
Alternatives will be permitted only if the
intent of the design guideline is met as
determined by the Director.
7.2.1 BUILDING PLACEMENT AND
ORIENTATION
Building placement and orientation have a
significant impact on the way people
experience a site. Visually interesting
buildings that are oriented to the street
shape the area’s character as well as the
visitor’s experience. Locating parking behind
buildings, placing buildings closer to the
public street edge, and placing a majority of
active ground floor uses on the same
frontage all contribute to making the public
street frontage more inviting to pedestrians.
» Buildings must have a strong presence
and encourage activity along the
street frontage.
» Buildings must be oriented to the
adjacent public street or internal
street if the site contains multiple
buildings.
» When adjacent uses can mutually
benefit from connection, appropriate
linkages (e.g., common landscape
areas, building orientation, pedestrian
paseos and unfenced property lines)
are recommended. Shared drives are
highly encouraged.
Buildings are oriented toward the
street.
Open spaces provide the public with
places for activity.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-4
» Buildings may be set back from the street and alcoves provided to include small plazas, entry nooks, and outdoor café seating.
» When commercial development is adjacent to residential uses, commercial access must not front onto residential uses.
7.2.2 OUTDOOR OPEN SPACE
Outdoor places, or people places, are spaces
that extend the indoor environment to the
outdoors. They are essential components of
placemaking – contributing significantly to
the character and activity levels of a place.
These places are created through the
clustering of buildings and landscapes to
define outdoor space, plazas, or recreation
areas, and can accommodate an array of
functions including social gathering, working,
dining, leisure, and recreation.
» Common open spaces must be
designed with consideration for solar and
shade orientation, inclement weather,
public access, safety and security, ease of
maintenance, usability, and aesthetic
quality to the extent possible.
» Open space areas cannot have parking,
driveway, or right-of-way encroachments.
» Common and/or public open space
must be accessible by pedestrian pathway
from the interior of the building and along
main public walkways.
» Non-residential open space
requirements may be satisfied by outdoor
dining areas, plazas, or other usable
outdoor use, as approved by the Director
» For residential uses, private useable
open space must be contiguous to the
residential units served and screened for
privacy.
» Larger projects must contribute to and
connect with a comprehensive network of
integrated open spaces throughout the
Specific Plan area.
» Open spaces that incorporate
amenities to facilitate outdoor activities, including seating, are encouraged. » Ground surfaces in open spaces must maximize permeable surfaces. The use of permeable paving is encouraged for the reduction of stormwater Pedestrian pathway.
Landscaping elements.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-5
runoff and absorption of rainwater to the water table. Where it is not possible to provide significant permeable areas on site, collection, storage and re-use of stormwater is encouraged.
7.2.3 LANDSCAPING
Landscaping creates an environment that is
comfortable, attractive, and complements and
enhances the community as a whole while providing a
unique sense of place at the Bellflower Station and
along the Flower Street corridor. The following
landscape design guidelines are provided to ensure
quality and excellence that will add value to
surrounding community and to create a sustainable
environment through responsible design practices.
» Landscaping must be an integral component of
the overall project design. Areas not utilized by
structures, storage, paved walks, plazas,
driveways or parking must be landscaped.
» Landscaping must be maintained in a weed free
condition with a combination of trees, shrubs
and ground cover.
» Landscaping should enhance the quality of developments by framing and softening the appearance of buildings, screening undesirable views, buffering incompatible uses and providing shade.
» Landscape designs must emphasize water-efficient or drought tolerant plants.
» Vines and climbing plants on buildings, trellises, perimeter walls, and fences are encouraged, both to create an attractive appearance and to minimize graffiti.
» Landscaping along public streets must be consistent, formalized, and composed of signature plantings from the recommended street tree palette, Figure 5.10, Street Trees (Chapter 5), to create an attractive and cohesive community identity.
» Within 5 years of planting, trees along public streets must be taller than the first floor of adjacent buildings and achieve a minimum canopy of 15 feet. » Shrubs and understory plantings adjacent to the street or in medians must not exceed 18 inches at maturity.
» Trees and shrub spacing must allow for maintenance access at maturity. » Landscaping elements, such as bioswales, that absorb water runoff and provide biotreatment are encouraged where appropriate.
Landscaping adjacent to the
public way can provide shade
and enhance the pedestrian
experience.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-6
7.2.4 SITE ACCESS
Site access configuration affects the safety and experience of pedestrians, bicyclists, and those in vehicles. Well-designed access enhances interest along the public street, improves circulation, and minimizes potential conflicts.
» Pedestrian access and circulation from transit stops and public sidewalks must be prioritized in the site design.
» Site access and internal circulation must be arranged in a logical manner that promote safety, efficiency, convenience and minimize conflict between vehicles and pedestrians. Access must be designed to promote safety by providing unobstructed sight lines into the accessway from surrounding public areas and be well-lit. » Define site access entries with special paving, lighting and/or landscape treatments.
» Site plans must balance the provision of adequate vehicular access and the desire to eliminate unnecessary driveway entrances and provide shared access with other properties. The use of common or shared driveways between adjacent uses is strongly encouraged. » Driveways must be sited to avoid interfering with traffic flow along adjacent streets and located as far from intersections as possible. » Passenger pickup and drop-off areas should not interfere with on-site and off-site vehicular and pedestrian circulation.
» Pedestrian access to commercial and office sites must be provided from adjacent residential neighborhoods when appropriate.
7.2.5 PARKING
Parking configuration, placement, and access is essential to the function and vitality of a neighborhood. Visibility of parking areas has a significant impact on the character and vitality of street life. Parking areas can also provide significant opportunities to reduce environmental impacts with proper placement and landscape treatment.
Consolidated driveways and pedestrian
pathways reduce conflicts.
Photovoltaic cells provide shade and electricity. Landscaping separates walkways and provides shade.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-7
» Large surface parking areas, where cars would dominate views, must be avoided. Parking areas in front of the building is discouraged. Parking must be located at the rear and/or side of the property when feasible. Large surface parking lots must be divided into a series of small parking areas with convenient access that relates to adjacent buildings.
» Except for driveways and/or entrances required for access to parking, no parking or loading can be visible from a public street. Where visibility from a public street is unavoidable, landscaping techniques must be used to provide screening.
» A safe pedestrian path must be provided from all parking areas to the main entrances of building(s). Unobstructed visibility and clear delineations between pedestrian paths and vehicular travel aisles must be provided. The use of landscaping, walkways, and decorative hardscape to delineate pedestrian circulation is encouraged.
» For mixed-use projects, parking facilities for residential uses and commercial uses should be separated.
» Developments are encouraged to provide bicycle storage facilities such as decorative racks or lockers. Bicycle storage such as racks or lockers should be provided and be easily accessible from the street and the pedestrian routes. Bicycle storage should be easily accessible from the street, transit stops and pedestrian routes.
» The use of photovoltaic cells to cover parking areas is encouraged.
Parking Lot and Structure Landscaping
» Landscaping must be used to separate parking from buildings and to reduce the visual impact of paved surfaces. Landscaping at the base of buildings is encouraged to soften the transition between building and parking lot. » Landscaping must be used within large paved areas to reduce heat island effect. Shade trees and shade structures should be provided in parking lots to reduce the amount of heat absorbed by paved parking surfaces. Trees should achieve a shade canopy within 10 years of planting. » The landscaping and design of parking lots and structures must incorporate sustainable design features where feasible. Such features include, but are not limited to, permeable paving, bioswales, and native landscaping to prevent water runoff, reduce solar heat gain, and minimize the need for extensive maintenance.
Parking Structures
Parking structure design must be compatible with the architectural design of adjacent buildings and consistent with the overall design of a project. » The integration of retail and other uses is encouraged along the street frontage of the parking structure.
» Parking structures should be designed to provide natural surveillance into the structure, elevators, and stairs from adjacent activity, public areas, and from within the parking structure. The location of building elements and The parking structure facade is
coordinated with adjacent buildings.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-8
exterior treatments should be designed to ensure daytime and nighttime visibility.
7.2.6 SERVICE AND LOADING
» Loading, unloading, and service areas must be located and screened to minimize direct exposure to public view and reduce visual impacts. » Delivery truck unloading zones must not obstruct vehicular circulation and parking areas. Loading and service areas must be separate from the primary public access where feasible.
» Loading area location and design should prevent truck back-up maneuvers from or onto public rights-of-way or parking aisles.
» Commercial loading areas must be placed as far as possible from residential units and be completely screened from adjacent residential development.
7.2.7 SCREENING: FENCES, WALLS, AND GATES
» Walls and fences must be architecturally designed and consistent with the overall character of the site.
» Walls and fences must be kept as low as possible while performing their intended function. Walls must be kept to a minimum height to avoid a “fortress” appearance.
» Fences and walls must have an articulated design. Articulation can be created by having regularly spaced posts, changes in height, and by using different building materials at the base, posts, or the cap of the fence/wall. » The incorporation of vines on walls and fences is encouraged to reduce the heat island effect and help reduce graffiti.
7.2.8 UTILITY, STORAGE, TRASH, AND RECYCLING FACILITIES » Service areas, trash enclosures, loading facilities, mechanical and other equipment must be located and screened so that they are not visible from a public street, open space, or from the upper stories of adjacent structures. Screening devices must be compatible with the architecture, materials, and color of adjacent buildings to the extent possible. » Outdoor trash and storage areas must be covered to reduce pollution introduction.
» Refuse storage areas must be conveniently located for building users. » All rooftop mechanical systems must be enclosed to mitigate visual and noise pollutions. Rooftop equipment on flat roofs must be located and screened in such a way as to not be visible from ground level. Flat roofs must have a minimum 3-foot high decorative parapet to screen views of roof-mounted utilities.
» Fire sprinkler standpipe assemblies must be located within the interior of the building.
Vine growth on utility screen.
Trash and utility enclosures..
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-9
BUILDING DESIGN (PLANNING AREAS 2, 3, AND
4)
7.3.1 BUILDING FORM AND MASSING
Building massing is the overall shape and size of a building in terms of scale, bulkiness, and relationship to exterior spaces. Care must be taken to articulate the building to create a welcoming public realm and reduce the appearance of oppressive and monolithic building forms. The site and neighboring conditions are key to developing appropriate massing.
» Massing design must include appropriate variation in the footprint, setbacks, wall plane projections and recesses, wall height, and roof form. » Building height must be compatible with and transition from the heights of adjacent developments.
» Substantial projects must be designed to appear as several smaller buildings to provide an intimate scale. Variations in roof form, height, and profiles can be used to provide visual interest and reduce the overall mass of the building
» Architectural elements such as recessed or projecting balconies, porches or other elements that add visual interest, human scale and character to the neighborhood are encouraged. Upper floors should have varied setbacks to accommodate balconies, seating and other architectural treatments. » Massing must consider passive solar and wind orientation to maximize natural daylighting and ventilation.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-10
» Frontages
Building frontages—the portion of the building facing the primary street have been categorized by type in this Specific Plan to address the design elements that are appropriate for a building’s ground floor front facade. The street frontage environment includes any yard or setback area that extends to the street. It is an important element of urban design because it informs how a building engages the public realm and largely determines the character of the area and the quality of the pedestrian environment. At the ground floor, the frontage is typically the primary access point into a building and consequently visually reinforces a building’s “human scale.” Frontage types for Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 are shown in Figure 7.1.
FIGURE 7.1 Permitted Frontage
by Planning Area
FRONTAGE TYPES PLANNING
AREA 4
PLANNING
AREA 2 AND 3
A. Shopfront
B. Forecourt
C. Arcade
D. Terrace
E. Stoop
F. Porch
Indicates permitted frontage type. This table is comprehensive of all permitted frontage types.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-11
A. SHOPFRONT FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
A shopfront is a frontage where the building facade and entrance are at sidewalk grade and close to the pedestrian zone. Shopfronts include large areas of transparent openings and doors and are commonly equipped with cantilevered roofs or awnings. Shopfronts typically provide access directly from sidewalks and are oriented to display ground-level commercial uses.
This frontage type is typically used for commercial use. This frontage type can be used in conjunction with terrace, and or forecourt to create a more engaging street.
Examples of Shopfront Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-12
B. FORECOURT FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
A forecourt is a frontage where a portion of the building facade is recessed from the primary building facade. The forecourt may be used as an entry court and open space for residential uses, or as additional shopping or seating areas for commercial uses. Forecourts with large trees and lush landscaping offer visual and environmental variety to the urban streetscape.
This frontage type is appropriate for either residential and/or commercial uses. A combination of both uses can be achieved by using the forecourt as a residential entrance while commercial uses occupy street adjacent building space. This type can be used in conjunction with shopfronts and stoops as a transition into residential frontage.
Examples of Forecourt Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-13
C. ARCADE FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
An arcade is a frontage where the building facade is aligned close to the pedestrian zone with a colonnade recessed into the building. The colonnade supports habitable commercial or residential space above. The colonnade covering the sidewalk provides pedestrian shelter and opportunities for covered outdoor dining.
This frontage type is appropriate for the Bellflower Station area.
Examples of Arcade Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-14
D. TERRACE FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
A terrace is a frontage where the building facade is set back from the street, paseo, or open space, by an elevated open area that is paved or planted. This frontage type can effectively buffer building uses from the sidewalk.
This type is recommended for residential and commercial use as it allows for semi-private use of frontage areas.
Examples of Terrace Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-15
E. STOOP FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
A stoop is a frontage where the building facade is separated from the street, paseo, or open space, by an entrance to the elevated ground floor of the building. The entrance is usually an exterior stair and landing and may be covered.
This frontage type is recommended for ground-floor residential uses to facilitate a transition and to provide separation between an active public street and a private residence.
Examples of Stoop Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-16
F. PORCH FRONTAGE
Description
Illustrated Elevation
Porch frontage is common where the facade is set back from the right of way and a porch is appended to the facade, encroaching into the front yard. This frontage type is primarily associated with single family houses, but can be used with other building types depending on the context and design. Porches typically have a fence defining the area of the porch as well as an overhang or overhead coverage.
A fence or wall at the property line should not be used to define the private space when porches are provided.
Examples of Porch Frontage (above) Sample illustration (below)
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-17
7.3.2 FACADES AND ARTICULATION
Facades are the external building face(s) that are visible from a public street or open space; The design of facades often sets the tone for the rest of the building and the neighborhood. The design, rhythm, and composition of facades, achieved through the arrangement of surface articulation, architectural elements, and materials, provides visual cues that support navigability and mobility for pedestrians, thereby enhancing the safety, convenience, and comfort of the public realm. » Building facades must be well designed and detailed in a way that makes them appear human in scale and reduces visual mass.
Design elements may include varying materials, voids of open space, changes in plane, and vertical elements, such as pilasters.
Architectural elements and accents must be appropriate for the overall building design and form an integral part of the building. » Buildings must have a clear base, middle, and top by providing horizontal differentiating treatment. The base must visibly anchor the building to the ground and the eave or parapet must provide a visual termination of the building.
» Design features must be consistent on all elevations of a structure. Buildings must incorporate 360-degree architecture, whereby similar and complementary massing, materials, and details are incorporated into side and rear facades.
» The highest level of articulation must occur on the front facade and facades visible from publicly accessible areas. Blank walls must be avoided and cannot face onto pedestrian spaces and streets. » Facades must incorporate “human” or intimate scale
architectural details and materials, such as arches, trellises, awnings, signage, recessed entries, or transparent storefronts on lower walls.
» The use of awnings, canopies, and overhangs that fit
entrance or window openings are encouraged to provide
visual appeal and protection from the weather.
» Surface detailing cannot serve as a substitute for distinctive massing.
7.3.3 COLORS AND MATERIALS
Appropriately applied color and material choices create interest and support a sense of place in a neighborhood when combined with facade modulation. Materials must comply with Section 7.6.4.G.2.
Well designed facade articulation in combination with the use of a variety of quality materials and colors creates interest and helps define a neighborhood.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-18
» All facades and elements of the primary structure must be unified by a complimentary and consistent use of building materials, textures, and colors.
» Facade treatment materials and architectural elements must be of a good quality, durable, and weather resistant to create buildings that are long lasting and can be
adaptively reused over time.
» Color and material applications on a facade must be varied to create visual articulation and accentuate architectural details compatible with the architectural character of the building.
» Materials and colors must be used to imply form changes, particularly for entrance lobbies, massing changes, and different uses or tenants.
» Construction details must be authentic and applied with consistency.
» Recommended primary materials include glass, stucco,
insulated concrete forms, stone, and brick masonry. The use of natural and local materials is encouraged. Metal awnings are not allowed.
» Materials and technologies that minimize environmental impacts, reduce energy and resource are highly
encouraged.
» Gutters, scuppers and downspouts must be integrated
into the exterior design and not “tacked on.” These items must be finished to blend in with the background material or be integrated into the architectural design.
7.3.4 BUILDING ENTRANCES
Well positioned and identified entrances orient the building, create a welcoming public realm, and frame the character of the streetscape.
» Primary building entrances must be located along major corridors (Bellflower Boulevard and Flower Street).
» All building entrances must adhere to the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and have
direct at-grade access at ground level.
» Primary and secondary building entries, including
courtyard doors or gates used as building entries, must be attractively designed as an important architectural
feature and may include the use of architectural
features, landscaping, and lighting.
Separate entrances for retail, residential, and parking should be accessible from the sidewalk.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-19
» Rear entrances must not be more prominent than the front, primary entrance. Public rear entrances must be visible and easily located. » For mixed-use buildings, separate entrances and pedestrian accessible pathways must be provided for residential and non-residential uses.
7.3.5 CORNER DESIGN
Intersections and the corners that frame them present the opportunity to create identity and positive visual impact for the neighborhood. » Development occurring at corner locations must anchor the corner. This can be accomplished using a reverse building placement where the main building is placed on the corner or by using a prominent landscaping feature.
» Buildings at street corners must incorporate design features that highlight the intersection. These features may include architectural elements such as distinctive corner massing, vertical design elements or prominent pedestrian spaces such as plazas.
» Development occurring near the Bellflower Civic Center Plaza should complement and enhance the Plaza.
7.3.6 WINDOWS
Windows are a key architectural element for providing rhythm and scale on a facade. Windows provide a building with natural light and fresh air and frame views.
» The size of doors and windows must relate to the scale and proportions of the overall architectural style.
» Windows must maximize desirable natural lighting and air circulation. » Windows must allow building users to have “eyes on the street” for natural surveillance.
» For residential developments, windows and doors must be recessed to prevent wall surfaces from being monotonously flat.
» For commercial uses, ground level facades must have a minimum 50 percent of commercial windows to provide transparency, visual interest, and a safe and active street scene. A section of facade must not exceed 20 linear feet of blank wall.
7.3.7 ROOFS
Roof form and design are important to the overall architectural character of the building.
» Roofs and rooflines must be cohesive in design throughout a building or group of buildings, including accessory buildings. Overly complex and distracting roofs are not encouraged.
» Roof massing, materials, and design must be consistent with the desired architectural style and complimentary to adjacent structures.
Architectural design and massing
emphasizes and engages the street
corner.
Commercial and residential windows
are oriented toward the public street.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-20
» The use of light-colored roofing materials or green roofs to reflect heat and reduce cooling in buildings is encouraged.
» The use of solar panels on roofs is encouraged.
7.3.8 ARCHITECTURAL LIGHTING
» Lighting must be designed as part of the overall architectural style enhance the building’s form, colors, and materials.
» Lighting must minimize contribution to light pollution. The lighting of full facades or roofs, lights aimed directly at the sky, lights projecting off site, and exposed bulbs are discouraged.
» The latest technical and operational energy conservation concepts must be considered in lighting designs.
» Primary and secondary building entrances, vehicle entrances, driveways, parking and service areas, pedestrian entrances, walkways, and activity areas must be properly lighted to maintain a safe environment.
7.3.9 GREEN BUILDING AND SUSTAINABLE DESIGN
» Building and site design must strive to integrate sustainable practices that conserve energy and water resources, reduce waste, and reduce the effects of urban heat gain.
» Buildings must integrate passive design strategies including natural daylighting and ventilation.
» Use of Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) building components and achieving LEED certification is encouraged.
PUBLIC REALM DESIGN (PLANNING AREAS 2, 3,
AND 4)
7.4.1 STREETSCAPE DESIGN
Along with landscaping, well designed and selected streetscape elements, such as furniture and public art, contribute to the public realm by delineating paths of travel, providing places to rest and shade, and defining the character of an area by providing visual and structural continuity.
» Streetscape design elements, including street furniture and public art, must be selected to provide a cohesive environment and identifiable character. » Color and material selection that enhances a unified street furniture “look” is encouraged.
» The selection of street furniture products, including seating, planters, bollards, trash receptacles and newspaper racks, must be durable, decorative and able to withstand inclement weather.
Lighting should complement a
building’s architectural design.
Human-scaled pedestrian lighting
enhances public activity areas.
Green roofs help manage water run-
off and reduce heat gain.
Architectural design that integrates
passive design and sustainable
materials is encouraged.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-21
» Street furnishings and amenities must not obstruct pedestrian or bicycle circulation. Street furnishings cannot impede the path of travel required to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Street furniture cannot impede entry to the building or preclude applicable emergency exit requirements.
» Permanently affixed streetscape amenities must minimize impacts on water runoff.
» The street tree palette is in Section 5.6, Street Trees. » Entry and monument guidelines are in Section 5.7, Entries and Monumentation.
» Tree grates must occur along street edges and plazas where a continuous walking surface is needed. Grate sizes must be a minimum of four feet in diameter. Knockouts must be provided to enlarge the inside diameter for supporting a larger tree trunk as the tree grows.
» Tree guards must extend vertically from tree grates and serve to protect trees in highly active areas. Tree guards must be narrow and painted in a similar color and relate to other site furnishings.
7.4.2 LIGHTING
» Exterior lighting must be designed with consideration of day and nighttime activities in the area. Lighting must create a nighttime ambiance that complements the adjacent buildings and public realm and promotes a sense of safety.
» Pedestrian-scaled lighting for sidewalk and street illumination is encouraged. Lighting must enhance the pedestrian experience at night. » Lighting must be provided at regular intervals to prevent the creation of light and dark pockets.
» Light fixtures and structural supports must be architecturally compatible with the adjacent building(s).
» The latest technical and operational energy conservation concepts must be considered in lighting designs.
» Lighting cannot be animated.
» Overhead service wires or exposed conduit must not be used.
7.4.3 SIGNAGE
All development within Planning Areas 2, 3, and 4 must have a “sign program” as part of the project design. The sign program will identify the location for all signage that may be located on the building, the allowable sign materials, lighting methods and sign design. Temporary signs and banners will be included in the sign program. » At no time, can the sign program allow for signage that exceeds the standards within the Town Center District.
» “Box” signs, “canister” or “can” signs are prohibited.
Well designed and selected
streetscape elements contribute to the
public realm.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-22
» Pedestrian-oriented, non-illuminated hanging “blade” signs that either hang under a colonnade or canopy, or project from the facade of a building, will not be counted within the sign area formula that is used to calculate the maximum amount of sign area for each building.
» Pedestrian-oriented, non-illuminated hanging or projecting blade signs exceeding two square feet maximum per sign face, or two square feet for a double-faced blade sign, are prohibited.
» Franchise identifying features may only be located on the main structure.
ADDITIONAL DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR
PLANNING AREAS 2 AND 3
The following design guidelines provide specific guidance for the parcels within Planning Areas 2 and 3 in addition to design guidelines provided in sections 7.1 through 7.4 of this Specific Plan. This area requires greater attention to detail due to its prominent location and its function as a multi-modal hub for Bellflower.
Special attention to the treatment of buildings and the public realm can enhance the character of the Bellflower Station area and establish a unique sense of identity.
» Buildings must be oriented to emphasize the station area as a node of activity.
» Special architectural elements must be incorporated on buildings, such as articulated entrances, a tall first story, or prominent roof forms. » Focal points should be developed to create a defined sense of identification. Plazas, fountains, artwork, site furniture and lighting, textured and decorative pavement, universally-accessible changes in levels and vertical building features may be combined to create focal points and identity.
» Each project proposed within Planning Areas 2 and 3 must include a public open space amenity, or some form of physical interface for the pedestrian that integrates hard and soft surfaces. Such features may include, but not be limited to:
Formal Plazas. A formal plaza would be a publicly accessible open space which has a design that is influenced by classical urban planning design. A formal plaza would typically include landscaping combined with seating areas, art or water features, kiosks and other outdoor features.
Urban Gardens. An urban garden can be located on the ground level, or on upper levels of a structure. Urban gardens include ornamental landscaping arranged in raised or at-grade planters or planting areas, potted plants and trees. Many times, there are sculptures or other forms of public art that are included within the urban garden.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-23
Covered Colonnades. Colonnades are linear in design and generous in depth.
The intent is to provide a comfortably wide, covered pathway that is adjacent to the openings of a building. Sometimes the second floor of a building is utilized to create the “covered” element of the colonnade.
Sidewalk Dining. Sidewalk dining may occur wherever a sidewalk space is ample enough to accommodate dining furniture without impeding pedestrian access of the sidewalk. Sidewalk dining may be defined with a railing or planters or be open and accessible.
Pedestrian Alleys and Walkways. A pedestrian alley or walkway is typically a “lane” that does not follow the alignment of a vehicular street, but provides a pedestrian access to either a public space or some other feature within the interior of a development. Pedestrian alleys or walkways must be designed in such a manner so as to be inviting to pedestrians. Issues such as lighting, security, line of sight, cleanliness and visual appeal are important considerations to a well-designed pedestrian alley or walkway. Sometimes public art, street furniture and access to shops and public spaces are features of pedestrian alleys and walkways.
Direct Public Transit Connection. A direct connection to public transportation facilities, or amenities that service public transit facilities such as benches, informational kiosks, walkways, parking facilities or other similar amenities.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-24
DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR PLANNING AREA 1
7.6.1 PURPOSE AND INTENT
These design guidelines provide guidance on design and aesthetic components that contribute to achieving the overall vision of Planning Area 1. These guidelines provide direction for new development as well as redevelopment, remodeling and rehabilitation of existing buildings. The Design Guidelines encourage creativity and innovative design while working to ensure development with consistent and cohesive imagery that contributes to a strong sense of place.
7.6.2 USER’S GUIDE
The Design Guidelines supplement the development standards for Planning Area 1 found in Chapter 4, and provide additional design guidance.
To effectively utilize the Design Guidelines, and gain optimum understanding of the document and its purpose, the following basic process is recommended:
A. Review the common design principles below for an understanding of the general design priorities for the area.
B. Review the General Area-Wide Design Guidelines for guidance applicable to all new development, redevelopment and remodeling within Planning Area
1. C. Review the design guidelines section(s) applicable to your specific land use or development type for guidance on a range of items that will help your project contribute to the overall design of Planning Area 1.
D. Schedule a meeting with the Director to review your ideas, identify processes and requirements, ask questions, and discuss potential issues, solutions, and approaches.
E. If you have any additional questions, contact the Director.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-25
7.6.3 COMMON DESIGN PRINCIPLES
This section provides the basic framework for project design and the goals that each project is expected to achieve. New construction projects typically have greater opportunities to address the design principles more completely, while projects that involve renovations or additions to existing buildings are typically more limited in their ability to address each specific principle. For renovations or additions to existing buildings, the Design Guidelines should be followed to the greatest extent feasible based on the area and magnitude of work being conducted. For example, a facade rehabilitation project should at minimum follow guidance on architectural imagery, detailing, colors and materials. For a facade rehabilitation project, the limited area of the project may not allow for provision of new gathering spaces or other site amenities. Conversely, a project consisting of a full demolition and reconfiguration of buildings on a site should incorporate amenities, landscaping, etc. as the scope of work allows the project to integrate such items into the design.
The following common design principles contribute to encouraging compatible relationships between existing uses, proposed new uses and future development, all in an effort to help ensure that projects in Planning Area 1 are well integrated and demonstrate sensitivity to the contextual influences of the area especially in terms of building scale and architectural design. It is expected that all projects will implement the principles outlined below to the greatest extent feasible. The information in this design guidelines manual will help in achieving this goal.
A. Design Principle 1: Sustained High Quality Development. Planning Area 1 is anticipated to redevelop over an extended period of time. Development and improvements are cost-intensive and should not be thought of as temporary. Building materials and landscaping should be chosen carefully for their ability to be maintained in a cost-effective manner at the same high quality as when they were originally installed. Planning and design of buildings should consider being able to adapt to future conditions and trends.
B. Design Principle 2: Human-Scaled Development. The Bellflower and Alondra corridors have historically been oriented to the automobile. It is people, not cars, upon which Planning Area 1 depends for its success.
Development along the corridors should be inviting and scaled to its users, while acknowledging the roles of access and mobility through public transit and automobile transportation. The extension of a human-scale character throughout the corridor is a basic design principle that should be addressed by all projects. Achievement of this principle can include human-scale details, pedestrian amenities and strong relationships between the buildings, sidewalks and other outdoor spaces. See photo.
Awnings, pavement texture and
storefront windows contribute
human-scaled character.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-26
C. Design Principle 3: Sense of Place. New development and redevelopment along the Bellflower and Alondra corridors should encourage people to stop and utilize the spaces as opposed to just pass through. A large component of creating an inviting environment is promoting a sense of place by creating a defined “here.” Public gathering spaces, cohesive architectural imagery, landscaping and signage can all contribute to defining a place. See photos.
D. Design Principle 4: Development Character. Development character is achieved through the thoughtful provision and arrangement of front and side building setbacks, location of structures, plazas, courtyards, outdoor dining areas, pedestrian paseos and linkages, view corridors, landscaped areas and other details that when combined create a positive rhythm along the commercial corridors. The structures, spaces, and landscaping between them create a physical environment rhythm along Bellflower Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard. New development and redevelopment should promote a consistent and coherent rhythm of structures and open spaces along the street edge. See photo.
7.6.4 GENERAL AREA-WIDE DESIGN GUIDELINES
This section provides design guidelines applicable to all development, redevelopment and remodeling within Planning Area 1, including commercial.
A. General Design. Development design in Planning Area 1 should comply with the following:
1. Provide site access, parking and circulation that are arranged in a logical and safe manner.
2. Developments should integrate and encourage use of alternative modes of transportation, such as bicycles and buses, by providing safe, convenient and attractive facilities.
3. Buildings at street corners should incorporate design features which highlight the intersection. These features may include architectural elements such as distinctive corner massing and vertical design elements or prominent pedestrian spaces such as plazas. See photo.
4. Building location and massing should be consistent throughout the corridor to frame and define public space.
5. In larger shopping centers/commercial sites, focal points should be developed to create a defined sense of identification. Plazas, fountains, artwork, textured pavement, universally-accessible changes in pavement levels and vertical building features may be combined to create focal points and identity. See photo.
6. Site plans should balance provision of adequate vehicular access and desire to eliminate unnecessary driveway entrances and provide access points that are coordinated with other properties.
Distinctive signage and public
gathering spaces contribute to “sense
of place”
Pedestrian paseos create rhythm
along corridor and contribute to
development character
Prominent corner feature anchors
building
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-27
7. Buildings should be sited and designed so property boundaries are not emphasized. Care should be taken when addressing the interface between two adjacent properties.
8. Buildings should be oriented to create and define usable outdoor spaces.
9. Ports of buildings may be set back from the street and alcoves may be provided to include small plazas, entry nooks, and outdoor café seating.
10. Site furniture and light fixtures should reflect the same design concepts as the public right-of-way street furniture.
B. Compatibility.
1. Consider the area’s scale and character and demonstrate sensitivity to the influences of the surrounding area, especially the existing residential neighborhoods.
2. The sitting or placement of buildings should recognize the particular characteristics of the site and should relate to the surrounding built environment in pattern, function, scale and character.
3. Commercial and residential uses should be buffered from each other as much as possible. Building orientation, landscaping and increased setbacks should be used to provide adequate separation between incompatible uses. See Figure 7.2.
FIGURE 7.2 Planning Area 1 Buffers
Block wall and landscaping provide buffer between commercial and residential uses
4. When adjacent uses can mutually benefit from connection, appropriate linkages (e.g., common landscape areas, building orientation, pedestrian paseos and unfenced property lines) are recommended.
C. Continuity.
1. Continuity among buildings contributes to community identity, levels of pedestrian activity and economic vitality.
Fountain provides focal point
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-28
2. Infill buildings that are much wider than existing facades should be divided down into a series of appropriately proportioned structural bays or components.
3. Key facade elements on existing buildings (i.e., wall planes and modulation, window and door arrangements, entries, transoms, awnings and cornice treatments) should be repeated in the design of a new neighboring building.
D. Mass. In this Specific Plan, mass is considered a three-dimensional form such as a cube, box, cylinder or pyramid. The way the forms are sized directly relates to the way building elements are emphasized or de-emphasized.
Voids of open space in the forms can change their appearance and make the building more interesting and less imposing.
1. Each building should have a recognizable base, body, roof lines and entry.
2. Several smaller buildings instead of one large building should be used to provide an intimate scale.
3. Varying materials between base and body of a building can break long wall planes.
4. Changes in vertical planes break up a boxlike appearance. Vertical elements such as pilasters help create bays to give the appearance of several smaller buildings.
5. Surface detailing should not serve as a substitute for distinctive massing.
6. Massing designs may include:
a. Variation in the wall plane (projections and recesses); b. Variation in the wall height;
c. Roofs located at different levels. See photos.
7. Upper floors have varied setbacks to accommodate balconies, seating and other architectural treatments. See Figure 7.3.
8. Recessed entries and articulation in the storefront mass should be included.
9. Tall dominating structures should be broken up by creating horizontal emphasis through the use of trim, awnings, eaves or other ornamentation and by using a combination of complimentary colors.
Changes in wall plane and roofs used
to break up massing
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-29
FIGURE 7.3 Planning Area 1 Step Back Upper Floors
UNDESIRABLE BUILDING MASS DESIRABLE BUILDING MASS
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-30
E. Scale. Scale is the proportion of one object to another. “Human” or intimate scale incorporates buildings and architectural details and materials on lower walls that relate to human scale such as arches, trellises or awnings should be utilized.
1. Articulated storefronts with carefully arranged doors, windows, arches, trellises or awnings, rather than blank walls, should face onto pedestrian spaces and streets. See photo.
2. Projections and recesses are encouraged to add texture and differentiate between buildings.
F. Rhythm. Rhythm describes the relationship of the building components as well as the relationship of individual buildings to one another.
1. Rhythm should be more complex than simply the repetition of architectural details.
2. Rhythm may be expressed by changing materials and colors and also expressed by varying elements.
G. Architectural Design Elements.
1. Architectural Imagery.
a. To reduce mass and bulk, facades should be “broken” by vertical and horizontal variations in wall and roof planes, building projections, projecting ribs, reveals, balconies, doors and window bays, and similar design elements. See photo.
b. Articulate building forms and elevations to create interesting roof lines, building shapes, and patterns of shade and shadow while maintaining compatibility with surrounding buildings.
c. Design features must be consistent on all elevations of a structure.
Side and rear elevations visible from public considerations as the primary public elevation.
d. Roof materials and colors are important aspects of the overall building design. These elements should be consistent with the desired architectural style and complimentary to adjacent structures.
e. Parapets should have sufficient articulation of detail such as precast treatments, continuous banding or variety in pitch (sculpted). See photo.
f. Rooftop equipment on flat roofs should be screened and not visible from ground level. Buildings with flat or low-pitched roofs should incorporate parapets, pitched facades or architectural elements designed to screen roof-mounted mechanical equipment and be architecturally compatible with the design of the building facade.
Storefronts with awnings face
pedestrian area, contributing to
human-scaled development
Balconies, material changes, and
changes in wall planes along the
facade help reduce building mass
Parapets with precast trim are
continuous along all facades
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-31
2. Materials and Colors.
a. Limit the number of building materials used on a facade. As a general rule, use no more than two different materials (excluding glass windows) on a single facade. See photo.
b. Appropriate building materials and finishes include:
i. Stucco with a lightly textured finish such as smooth or sand; ii. Stone veneer;
iii. Wood/wood composite siding.
c. Appropriate accent or detail materials include:
i. Wrought iron;
ii. Steel;
iii. Tiles.
d. Inappropriate building materials that should be discouraged on facades include:
i. Plywood;
ii. Hardboard;
iii. Unfinished lumber;
iv. Aluminum siding;
v. Corrugated sheet metal or tin siding;
vi. Textured T-111 siding.
e. Materials and finishes should be durable and weather resistant. f. Material choice and location should minimize reflective surfaces or glare.
g. Changes in material should generally occur when there is a change in the plane of the facade. If possible, the change in material should occur on inside corners of the building. If a change is proposed along the line of a single plane, a pronounced expansion joint or trim piece should be used to define a clear separation. See Figure 7.4.
Changes in wall plane and roofs used
to break up massing
Changes in wall plane and roofs used
to break up massing
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-32
FIGURE 7.4 Planning Area 1 Material Treatment at Corners Change in materials should occur at inside corners
INAPPROPRIATE APPROPRIATE
h. Gutters, scuppers and downspouts should be integrated into the exterior design and not “tacked on.” These items should be finished to blend in with the background material or be integrated into the architectural design. See photo.
i. Color applications on a facade should generally be limited to one (1) or two (2) main colors and one (1) to two (2) accent colors that complement the main color(s) of the structure.
j. Painted building surfaces should have a matte finish. Trim work may have a glossy finish.
3. Roofs.
a. Roofs should be given design consideration and treatment consistent to that of the rest of the building exteriors. b. Roofline elements including parapet walls should be developed along all elevations.
c. Roofs and rooflines should be continuous in design throughout a building or group of buildings.
H. Lighting.
1. Exterior lighting should be designed as part of the overall architectural style of the building(s) and should highlight interesting architectural features. The lighting of full facades or roofs is discouraged.
2. Accent lighting, when provided, should complement the building color and materials.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-33
3. Light fixtures and structural supports should be architecturally compatible with the adjacent building(s).
4. Lighting fixtures with exposed bulbs should not be used.
5. The latest technical and operational energy conservation concepts should be considered in lighting designs.
6. Vehicle entrances, driveways, parking and service areas, pedestrian entrances, walkways, and activity areas should have a sufficient level of lighting to provide security and safety.
7. Lighting should be provided at regular intervals to prevent the creation of light and dark pockets.
8. Pedestrian-scaled lighting for sidewalk and street illumination is encouraged. See photos.
9. Lighting should not be animated.
10. Overhead service wires or exposed conduit should not be used.
I. Landscaping.
1. Utilize landscaping as an integral component to overall project design.
2. Landscape designs emphasizing water-efficient or drought tolerant plants are encouraged.
3. Vines and climbing plants on buildings, trellises, perimeter walls, and fences are encouraged, both to provide attractive appearance and to minimize graffiti.
4. Trees and shrubs should be selected based on their mature size and root characteristics. Plants with root systems that uplift hardscape materials should be avoided.
5. Trees and shrubs should not be planted so close together that they create maintenance problems at maturity.
J. Walls and Fences.
1. Walls and fences should be kept as low as possible while performing their intended function. Walls should be kept to a minimum height to avoid a “fortress” appearance.
2. The design of fences and walls, as well as the materials used, should be consistent with the overall development’s design.
3. Fences and walls should have an articulated design. Articulation can be created by having regularly spaced posts, changes in height and by using different building materials at the base, posts or the cap of the fence/wall. See photo.
Two types of pedestrian-scaled
lighting
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-34
4. Fences and walls should be painted to match or complement the color of the building. However, walls constructed with stone or brick may be unpainted in order to display the natural color of the materials.
5. Incorporation of vines on retaining and decorative walls to reduce the heat island effect is encouraged.
K. Green Building and Sustainable Design.
1. Materials and technologies that minimize environmental impacts, reduce energy and resource are highly encouraged.
2. Use of photovoltaic cells on roof tops, covered parking areas or integrated into building architecture is encouraged. See photos.
3. Use of Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) building components or achieving LEED certification is encouraged.
4. The use of pervious surfaces and pervious paving are encouraged.
5. Outdoor trash and storage areas should be covered to reduce pollution introduction.
6. Buildings are encouraged to utilize natural lighting whenever feasible.
7. Sweeping, vacuuming, or high pressure, low volume devices should be used on outdoor areas instead of spraying or hosing with water.
8. Landscaping should be used within large paved areas to reduce heat island effect.
Wrought-iron details enhance fence
Use of photovoltaic cells on covered
parking and awning
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-35
7.6.5 GENERAL COMMERCIAL DESIGN
GUIDELINES FOR PLANNING
AREA 1
This section provides design guidelines and
concepts that are applicable to all commercial
projects within Planning Area 1 including retail,
service, and office uses. It should also be noted
that the General Commercial guidelines found
below will be utilized for Specific Commercial Use
Guidelines subsection.
A. Site Planning and Design Details.
1. Building Siting.
a. Buildings should be oriented to face either a public street, private street or pedestrian outdoor space and provide pedestrian access from the public sidewalk. See Figure 7.5.
FIGURE 7.5 Planning Area 1 Building Orientation
Buildings are oriented to face a pedestrian outdoor space
b. Building siting and design should encourage pedestrian activity. c. When possible and appropriate, interior spaces are encouraged to extend into the outdoors, both physically and visually. This may be achieved through awnings and overhangs, outdoor dining spaces or other features.
Plaza is adjacent to and visible from
the public street
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-36
d. Service areas should not be oriented onto publicly accessible spaces.
2. Pedestrian Activity Areas.
a. Pedestrian activity areas should be visible and accessible from the public street. See photo.
b. Pedestrian activity areas should provide site amenities such as seating areas, public art, water features and other appropriate amenities that encourage pedestrian utilization.
c. Pedestrian activity areas should provide a sufficient level of shade for users. Landscaping, canopies or other methods of providing shaded areas are strongly encouraged.
B. Parking and Circulation Guidelines.
1. Site Access.
a. Site access and internal circulation should promote safety, efficiency, convenience and minimize conflict between vehicles and pedestrians.
b. The number of site access points to a parking lot should be minimized and located as far as possible from intersections. Parking lot access points should not interfere with the function of adjacent roadways. See Figure 7.6.
c. Use of common or shared driveways between adjacent uses is strongly encouraged.
FIGURE 7.6 Planning Area 1 Buildings with Shared Parking Areas and Driveways
d. When commercial development is adjacent to residential uses, commercial access should not front onto residential uses.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-37
e. Loading and service areas should be separate from the primary public access.
f. Use special paving, lighting and/or landscape treatment to define site entries.
2. Pedestrian Circulation.
a. Pedestrian access from surrounding residential neighborhoods should be provided. This access should be designed to promote safety by providing unobstructed sight lines into the access way from surrounding public areas and be well-lit.
b. Safe, convenient pedestrian links should be designed between parking areas and businesses.
c. Unobstructed visibility and clear delineations between pedestrian paths and vehicular travel aisles should be provided. Use of landscaping, walkways, and decorative hardscape to delineate pedestrian circulation is encouraged.
d. Access to transit stops should be integrated into the pedestrian circulation network.
C. Architectural Design Elements.
1. Architectural Imagery. The use of standardized “corporate” or “franchise” architectural styles is strongly discouraged. See photo.
2. Building Façades.
a. Primary building entries should provide a prominent sense of entry for easy identification. The use of architectural projections, columns, entry lobbies or other design elements are strongly encouraged.
b. The size of doors and windows should relate to the scale and proportions of the overall structure. Monumental entries that are not scaled to the pedestrian are discouraged.
c. The use of security grilles on windows is discouraged because they communicate a message of high crime and are difficult to integrate into the building design. If security grilles are necessary, they should be placed inside the building behind the window.
d. Opening composition is required.
e. Upper story window to wall ratios should be lower than the ground floor. See photo.
f. Windows on the first floor should encompass:
i. Retail uses: a minimum of fifty percent (50%) and maximum of seventy percent (70%) of the building facade.
Building design matches adjacent
development, not corporate style
Window-to-wall ratios on upper floors
are lower than on ground floor
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-38
ii. Office uses: a minimum of forty percent (40%) and a maximum of fifty percent (50%) of the building facade.
g. Shaped window frames and sills should be used and must be proportional to the window framed.
h. Public rear entrances should be visible and easily located. i. Rear entrances should not be more prominent than the front, primary entrance.
3. Storage, Refuse and Equipment Screening.
a. Storage, refuse and equipment areas should be screened from publicly accessible spaces and/or neighboring residential uses.
Landscaping and/or architectural enclosures can be used to screen these areas. See Figure 7.7.
b. Screening should be compatible with the design of adjacent architecture. Enclosures should use forms, materials and color applications similar to the primary building(s).
FIGURE 7.7 Planning Area 1 Building Orientation
Wall and landscaping screen service area from public parking area c. Refuse storage areas that are visible from upper stories of adjacent structures should provide an opaque or semi-opaque horizontal cover or screen to reduce unsightly views. The horizontal screen/cover should be integrated into the enclosure design and compatible with adjacent development. See photo.
d. Refuse storage enclosures should be located so that the doors do not interfere with landscaping and pedestrian and vehicle circulation.
e. Dimensions of refuse enclosures should not exceed the reasonable space required for anticipated uses.
Trash enclosure with trellis cover
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-39
f. Utility equipment should be located at the rear of building. When equipment is required to be located along street frontages, it should be screened from public view.
g. Rooftop equipment should be fully screened from public view by parapet walls or roof elements.
D. Landscaping.
1. General.
a. Landscaping should enhance the quality of commercial developments by framing and softening the appearance of buildings, screening undesirable views, buffering incompatible uses and providing shade.
b. The use of drought tolerant plant materials is encouraged. See photo.
c. Areas not utilized by structures, storage, paved walks, plazas, driveways or parking should be landscaped. See photo.
2. Parking Lot Landscaping.
a. Landscaping should be used to separate parking from buildings and to reduce the visual impact of paved surfaces.
b. Parking lots should be separated from the street frontage by landscape buffers and berms to reduce visual impacts.
c. Landscaping at the base of buildings is encouraged to soften the transition between building and parking lot.
3. Site Furniture.
a. Site furnishings (i.e., benches, bicycle racks, bollards, trash receptacles and newspaper racks) should be compatible with the design of adjacent buildings.
b. Site furnishings should not create pedestrian/vehicular conflicts.
Developments are encouraged to provide bicycle storage facilities such as racks or lockers. See photo.
c. Bicycle storage should be easily accessible from the street, transit stops and pedestrian routes.
Special Use Commercial Design Guidelines.
The guidelines contained in this subsection provide supplementary design guidance addressing more challenging development types. Certain types of development present design challenges that require unique solutions.
Development types in this section include:
A. Office. Office uses have physical and functional characteristics that are not typical of commercial development. Office uses are typically within multi- Drought tolerant landscaping
provides a softened parking edge and
walkways
Bicycle racks adjacent to pedestrian
walkway
Bicycle racks adjacent to pedestrian
walkway
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-40
story buildings that are larger in scale. There are fewer public entries and higher utilization of on-site parking. Within the buildings, the types of tenants are usually consistent.
1. Site Organization. Parking should not be located between the front of the building and the street. Surface parking should be located at the rear of the site or the side of the building. See Figure 7.8.
FIGURE 7.8 Planning Area 1 Parking Location
Locate parking to the side and rear of the building
2. Building Design.
a. Office development should incorporate variations in vertical and horizontal wall planes to reduce scale and massing.
b. Primary building entries should be well defined and provide a “sense of entry” for the building. Use of architectural features such as columns and awnings is encouraged. See photo.
c. Office buildings should have the primary entry visible from the public street and be accessible from pedestrian pathways or parking areas.
d. Entry lobby interiors should be well-designed and of high quality when visible from the building’s exterior.
e. Development occurring at corner locations should provide creative architectural and site design features. Art objects, plazas and other appropriate features are encouraged.
B. Drive-Through Businesses. Drive-through businesses include restaurants, banking institutions with drive-up teller/ATM access, pharmacies and other similar facilities. Drive-through businesses have additional design considerations related to on-site circulation, noise impacts and vehicular access.
Landscaping separates drive-through
from adjacent street
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-41
1. Site Organization.
a. The primary visual presence along the major street frontage should be the building, not a drive-through lane or parking.
b. Menu board speaker placement should be located to reduce excessive noise and reduce impacts to surrounding areas and should be landscaped in a manner that screens or minimizes the impacts.
Use of visual feedback systems that do not have a speaker are encouraged.
c. Drive-through lanes should accommodate vehicle stacking at the menu board and pickup windows without impacting other on-site circulation.
d. Drive-through aisles should be separated from adjacent streets and parking areas. Landscaping and/or low masonry walls should be utilized. See photo.
2. Building Design.
a. Outdoor eating areas are encouraged. Outdoor eating areas should provide details such as low walls, fountains, trellis elements, etc. b. Franchise identifying features should only be located on the main structure.
c. Exterior doors, equipment rooms, and service/employee entries should be designed with complementary architectural treatment.
C. Large Anchor Retail. Large anchor retail development is characterized by larger than average retail square footage under one roof. Large anchor retail development requires extensive parking to accommodate higher-than- average parking demand. Large anchor retail uses are often located on sites with multiple buildings of various sizes.
1. Site Organization.
a. Parking lots for large anchor retail uses are discouraged from being located entirely in front of the building. Smaller lots to the sides and/or rear of the building are encouraged.
b. The number of entrances and exits should be designed and located to avoid interfering with traffic flow along adjacent streets.
2. Building Design.
a. Exterior walls should terminate with a building cap such as a roof or cornice.
b. Distinct and interesting rooflines instead of flat roofed structures are encouraged.
Colonnades and portico used to break
up mass of building.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-42
c. Exterior wall treatments such as arcades, porticos, offset planes and colonnades should be used to break up the mass and scale of the building. See photo.
d. Design of outdoor storage or sales areas (i.e. garden centers) should be consistent with the architecture of the primary building, utilizing articulated walls or fencing to enclose the space.
3. Loading and Service Areas.
a. Loading and service areas should be located and designed to minimize direct exposure to public view. Walls or landscape screening should be used to reduce visual impacts.
b. Loading area location and design should prevent truck back-up maneuvers from or onto public rights-of-way or parking aisles.
D. Public Assembly Facility. Public assembly facilities include buildings where large groups of people gather and utilize large common spaces. These uses typically have significant on-site parking requirements and are characterized by higher profile architectural design.
1. Site Organization.
a. The location and orientation of buildings, parking lots, driveways and entries should be designed to minimize noise and traffic impacts on adjacent properties.
b. Avoid locating parking between the front of the building and the street. Parking should be located at the rear and/or side of the property.
c. Exterior spaces, plazas and courtyards should be designed to minimize noise impacts on adjacent properties.
d. Screening and buffering should be provided between places of assembly and adjacent residential uses.
2. Circulation and Parking.
a. Parking should be located in close proximity to the primary entrance. A safe pedestrian path should be provided from all parking areas to the main entrance.
b. Parking should be screened from public view by walls, landscaping or other appropriate methods.
c. Passenger pickup and drop-off areas should not interfere with on- site and off-site vehicular and pedestrian circulation.
E. Hotels and Motels. Hotels and motels are a commercial use with some residential attributes. They are often highly visible from primary roadways.
Therefore, their design has a high level of impact on the surrounding area.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-43
1. Site Organization.
a. The primary visual presence along the major street frontage should be the building and driveway approach not a parking lot. b. Delivery and service loading areas should be located toward the rear of the property and screened to minimize impacts.
c. Recreational facilities such as swimming pools should be designed to offer privacy for users and to minimize noise impacts on adjacent uses.
d. Common open space should be provided on-site.
2. Building Design.
a. Upper floors should be set back to lessen the appearance of mass or bulk.
b. For structures over two stories, access to guest rooms should be provided from interior hallways.
c. Avoid room entrances directly adjacent to parking lots or exterior walkways.
d. Walkway, stairway and balcony railings, and other similar architectural details should be consistent with the building design. e. Mechanical equipment including swimming pool equipment should be located to minimize impacts on adjacent uses and screened from public view using landscaping or architectural enclosures.
3. Parking and Circulation. A covered drop-off zone for vehicles and pedestrians independent of drive aisles should accommodate guest loading and unloading.
4. Landscaping. A five-foot minimum landscaped buffer should separate ground floor units from on-site walkways parking facilities and other on- site amenities.
F. Mixed-Use. Mixed-use projects are defined as developments that combine commercial/office and residential uses or structures on a single lot, or as components of a single development. The uses may be combined either vertically within the same structure, or spread horizontally on the site in different areas and structures.
1. Site Organization.
a. Parking facilities for residential uses and commercial uses should be separated.
b. Commercial loading areas and refuse storage facilities should be placed as far as possible from residential units and be completely screened from adjacent residential development.
Residential units above retail space
have consistent materials, but details
differentiate uses
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-44
c. Parking area lighting and security lighting for the commercial uses should be shielded so as not to spill over into residential areas.
Residential units should also be shielded from illuminated commercial signs.
d. Commercial spaces should have the primary entry visible from the public street and be accessible from pedestrian pathways or parking areas.
2. Building Design.
a. Separate entrances should be provided when residential and commercial uses are provided in the same structure.
b. The architectural imagery and use of materials should be consistent throughout the entire mixed-use project. However, differences in materials and/or architectural details should be used to differentiate the residential portion of the project from the commercial portion of the project. See photo.
c. The design of storefronts should be consistent with the design guidelines for general commercial development. The residential portion of a mixed-use project should be consistent with the design guidelines for multi-family development.
d. Transparency between the commercial spaces on the ground floor and the street is highly encouraged.
e. Building design should incorporate measures to reduce the impacts of business activities, such as noise, on residential uses. See photo.
G. Parking Structures. Parking structures provide an option to increase parking without utilizing additional land for surface parking. They can be integrated in a single building with other uses, or stand alone. Parking structure design must consider architectural compatibility, size, scale, bulk and function as it relates to adjacent buildings and overall design of a project.
1. Site Organization. Adjacent residential uses should be buffered from parking structures through building orientation, landscaping or walls.
2. Access and Circulation.
a. Complete and uninterrupted vehicle circulation should occur on all levels of the parking structure.
b. Entrances and exits should be located so that vehicles do not enter or exit onto residential streets or at busy intersections. c. Pedestrian circulation should be clearly delineated and separated from vehicular circulation. The use of landscaping, walkways and decorative paving is encouraged. See photo.
Balcony covers outdoor dining space,
providing a noise buffer
Balcony covers outdoor dining space,
providing a noise buffer
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-45
3. Security and Lighting.
a. Visibility into the structure from adjacent activity and public areas should be maximized to provide natural surveillance.
b. Locating elevators and stairs on the perimeter of the structure is highly encouraged to provide natural surveillance from exterior public areas.
c. Elevators should be located where the door and open and elevator cab should have glass facing the public view. Any glass tinting should be minimal to ensure daytime and nighttime visibility. See photo. d. Interior walls should be painted a light color to improve illumination.
4. Building Design.
a. Exterior elevations should incorporate design components and materials similar to or compatible with the primary building(s). This includes fenestration patterns, colors and materials.
b. Retail or other uses are encouraged along the exterior at the ground level of the parking structure where appropriate. See photo. c. Landscaping along the setback area is encouraged.
d. The exterior elevations of the parking structure should exhibit horizontal rather than sloping design elements.
e. Exterior elevations should be designed to minimize untreated facades.
f. All mechanical equipment and piping should be painted to match the interior of the structure.
5. Screening. All appurtenances (i.e., transformers, ventilation shafts, maintenance access, etc.) should be screened from public view.
H. Motor Vehicle Dealerships. Features of vehicle dealerships typically include outdoor storage and display of vehicles vehicle display oriented toward the street and vehicle drop off and pick up areas.
1. Site Organization.
a. Noise sources should be located and oriented away from residential properties.
b. All storage areas should be screened from view from the public right-of-way and adjacent residential areas.
2. Building Design.
a. Ancillary structures such as enclosed storage areas should be architecturally consistent with the primary building on the site. b. Service uses should be contained entirely within a building of solid construction.
Glass-backed elevator shaft and cab
Retail store lines ground floor of
parking structure
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-46
c. The access points to the service bays should not face the public right-of-way.
d. Vehicle washing areas should be designed and located so they are not visible or audible from the public right-of-way or residential areas.
3. Walls and Fences. Security fencing and perimeter walls should be decorative and consistent with the architecture of the primary buildings.
4. Other.
a. Public address systems should not be used in outdoor areas. Any public address system should confine noise within an enclosed building.
b. Compressors and other pneumatic equipment should be located on the interior of a site to minimize noise impacts on adjacent properties.
c. Storage facilities should be provided on-site for vehicles parts and potentially hazardous materials.
d. Storage facilities should be enclosed entirely within permanent buildings.
I. Service Stations and Car Washes. Service stations and car washes are intensive uses that are characterized by large volumes of vehicular traffic and expansive areas of paving that generally allow vehicles to maneuver freely. Aesthetics, traffic, use of equipment and machinery and storage are common concerns associated with these uses.
1. Site Organization.
a. Projects located at street corners should provide a strong design element to anchor the corner. This can be accomplished using a reverse building placement where the main building is placed on the corner or by using a prominent landscaping feature. See photo. b. Building elevations containing car wash openings should not face towards the public right-of-way or toward residential uses. c. Rather than adopting a standard design, elevations that are unique to the community and are not a corporate or franchise design are strongly encouraged.
2. Building Design.
a. High quality durable building materials must be used. b. Service stations and car washes should incorporate facade materials that create a textured design.
c. Reflective glossing and fluorescent surfaces are prohibited.
Corner design element at service
station
Sloped roof on pump island canopies
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-47
d. Car wash equipment must be enclosed within a permanent structure.
e. Car wash buildings must incorporate noise control measures that minimize noise generated by machinery blowers or other
mechanical equipment.
f. Pump island canopies should use a hip gable or other roof system to match the architecture of the primary buildings on the site. See photo.
g. Recessed lighting or internally illuminated canopies must be utilized to reduce glare.
3. Circulation and Parking.
a. Driveway cuts should be limited to two per site.
b. Where commercial development abuts the service station two-way vehicular access integrated with the adjacent commercial development should be provided.
c. The location of filling pumps, car washing facilities or other on-site facilities must be designed to avoid vehicle stacking or overflow onto adjacent streets.
d. Self-service facilities such as water and air or vacuuming must be located so that they do not obstruct onsite circulation. e. Separate parking areas must be provided for on-site retail. f. A fuel delivery truck unloading zone should be provided and should not obstruct vehicular circulation and parking areas.
4. Landscaping Walls and Fences.
a. Landscaping along the perimeter of the site to reduce visual impacts is encouraged.
b. Landscaped berms or hedges should be located along public streets.
J. Telecommunication Facilities. Telecommunications facilities include poles, towers, antenna support facilities and components. These facilities have special design and location considerations in order to minimize adverse visual impacts on the surrounding area.
1. Location.
a. Telecommunications facilities should be located to minimize their visibility. The use of landscaping is encouraged to screen the facility. b. Co-location of facilities is encouraged.
2. Facilities Design.
a. Telecommunications facilities integrated into the design of existing buildings is encouraged.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-48
b. Efforts should be made to conceal the facility within or behind existing architectural features.
c. Roof mounted facilities should be located and screened appropriately to limit the visual impact on the building silhouette. d. Facilities should be screened on all sides.
e. All telecommunications facilities should use materials colors and textures that blend with the natural setting and built environment.
Reflective surfaces should not be used.
f. Telecommunications facilities should be as small as possible and the minimum height necessary.
g. Applicants should consult the General Commercial Guidelines in addition to the guidelines contained within this subsection.
7.6.6 RESIDENTIAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
This section provides design guidelines and concepts applicable to residential projects within Planning Area 1.
A. Site Planning.
1. Developments should relate to the adjacent street and neighborhood context. Developments that ignore the street and create an isolated enclave are highly discouraged.
2. Developments should generally be oriented parallel to public or internal streets. See Figure 7.9.
3. Doors should be visible from the street or other public areas and windows should allow residents to have “eyes on the street” for natural surveillance.
4. Clustering of multi-family units should be a consistent site planning element. Whenever possible, buildings should be configured around courtyards, gathering areas and open spaces. See photo.
5. Pedestrian circulation should be considered when designing a multi- family development, not only within the site, but to and from the site as well.
6. Windows and entries should be placed to maximize natural surveillance of the site. Corridors should be visible from as many units as possible.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-49
FIGURE 7.9 Planning Area 1 Residential Building Orientation
Buildings are orientated parallel to street
B. Building Scale and Massing.
1. Architectural elements such as recessed or projecting balconies, porches or other elements that add visual interest, human scale and character to the neighborhood are encouraged. See photo.
2. Varied building heights are encouraged to provide visual interest and give the appearance of a collection of smaller structures. The development’s building height should create a transition from the heights of adjacent development, rather than abrupt height changes.
For example, a three-story building facade should not be located adjacent to a single-story, single-family home.
C. Building Entries.
1. Courtyard doors or gates used as building entries should be attractively designed as an important architectural feature of the building or development.
2. Individual unit entries from the exterior of the building should have a strong relationship with a fronting street, internal walkway or courtyard as appropriate to the overall siting concept. A transition area from the public space or walkway to the private dwelling unit entry such as a porch, steps or landscaped walkway, should be provided.
D. Stairs.
1. Building facades that enclose stairways should include residential-type windows to reduce the visual bulk of the stairwell and enhance safety.
Building facades enclosing elevator shafts should use architectural treatments to reduce visual mass.
2. Where prefabricated stairs are used, additional design features such as screen walls, enhanced railings or accent colors should be used to enhance appearance. The additional design features should be consistent with the overall building design.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-50
E. Building Materials and Color.
1. The development’s dwelling units, community facilities and parking structures should be unified by a consistent use of building materials, textures and colors.
2. Garages should incorporate architectural detailing, such as patterned garage doors or painted trim.
3. Carports, detached garages and accessory structures should be designed as an integral part of the development’s architecture. They should be similar in material, color, and detail to the primary building(s) of the development. See photo.
F. Roofs.
1. Roof pitches and materials should appear residential in character and should consider the prevailing roof types in the neighborhood.
2. Carport roofs should be compatible with the roof pitch and materials of the primary building(s). Avoid flat, unarticulated roofs.
3. Roofs should allow for solar panels.
G. Mechanical Equipment and Vents.
1. The following must be screened from views from publicly accessible spaces:
a. Electric and water utility meters;
b. Heating/ventilation/cooling equipment;
c. Irrigation and pool pumps;
d. Rooftop mechanical equipment;
e. Other mechanical equipment.
2. Appropriate methods of screening include fencing, landscaping, roof parapets and architectural enclosures. The design of screening devices must be compatible with the primary building(s).
3. Mechanical equipment must be located as to minimize noise impacts on residential units.
H. Outdoor Recreation and Open Space.
1. Residents should have access to usable open space for recreation and social activities. Open spaces should be conveniently located for the majority of the units.
2. Open spaces and courtyards should be designed to be as visible from as many dwelling units as possible or along main walkways.
3. Open space areas should be sheltered from the noise and traffic of adjacent streets or other incompatible uses.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-51
4. A series of connected open space areas of varying shape, appearance and usage are encouraged.
5. Open space should be configured and sized to be usable areas and not merely leftover areas.
6. Open space intended for private use should be provided adjacent to the units it serves.
7. Boundaries between private and common open spaces should be clearly defined by low walls or plant materials. See photo.
8. Outdoor recreation and open space areas should be visible from as many units as possible and from private open space areas. Direct convenient access from ground level, private open space to the communal play area is encouraged.
9. Recreation areas should be located away from public streets, parking or entry areas unless physically separated by walls, fencing or dense landscaping.
10. Hard surface areas for outdoor activities should be provided. These active recreation areas should be separated from vehicular use areas.
11. Seating areas should be provided adjacent to outdoor recreation areas.
Seating location should consider comfort factors including sun orientation, shade and wind. See photo.
I. Miscellaneous Site Elements.
1. Site Furniture.
a. Site furnishings (e.g., benches, bicycle racks, bollards, trash receptacles and newspaper racks) should be compatible with the design of adjacent buildings.
b. Site furnishings should not create pedestrian/ vehicular conflicts.
2. Refuse Storage Areas.
a. Refuse storage areas should be located within parking garages or to the rear of buildings and screened from publicly accessible areas. b. Refuse storage areas should be located conveniently close to the residential units.
c. Refuse containers should be covered.
d. Architectural enclosures should be used to enclose outdoor refuse containers.
e. The design of enclosures should be architecturally compatible with other buildings on the site, and their design should use similar forms, materials and colors.
Low wall/fencing separates private
open space from common area
Seating along common open space is
shaded by trellis
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-52
f. Refuse storage should provide an opaque or semi-opaque horizontal cover or screen to reduce unsightly views. The horizontal screen/cover should be integrated into the enclosure design and should be compatible with the adjacent development.
g. The refuse storage areas should be located so that the doors do not interfere with landscaping and pedestrian and vehicle circulation. h. Dimensions of refuse enclosures should not exceed the reasonable space required for anticipated use.
i. Mailboxes should be located in highly visible, conveniently accessible areas, per USPS requirements.
j. Incorporation of design features, such as a built frame consistent with the primary building’s architectural design, is encouraged.
J. Landscaping.
1. Use of landscaping is encouraged to define and accent specific areas such as building and parking lot entrances and the main walkways to community facilities.
2. Plant materials should be used to define the edge between public and private space, buffer adjacent uses when appropriate, and screen service areas.
K. Parking and Circulation.
1. Large surface parking areas, where cars would dominate views and increase perceived density, should be avoided. Surface parking should be divided into a series of small parking areas with convenient access that relates to adjacent dwelling units.
2. Parking areas should be located in the development’s interior and not along street frontages. Screening measures, such as landscaping and walls, should be used to minimize visual parking impacts.
3. Cross circulation between vehicles and pedestrians should be minimized. A clearly marked walkway should be provided from the parking areas to the main entrances of the buildings.
4. Access to transit stops should be integrated into the pedestrian circulation network.
5. Bicycle storage such as racks or lockers should be provided and be easily accessible from the street and the pedestrian routes.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-53
6. Sight lines from dwelling units to the parking area should be provided.
L. Lighting.
1. Light standards should be residential/pedestrian in scale and be spaced appropriately for the fixture, type of illumination and pole height. See photo.
2. Lighting in parking areas should be arranged to prevent direct glare into adjacent dwelling units.
3. When appropriate, wall-mounted lighting may be incorporated. Wall- mounted lights should be architecturally compatible and pedestrian scaled.
7.6.7 PUBLIC SPACE AND AMENITIES DESIGN GUIDELINES
This section is intended to provide design guidance on publicly accessible open spaces including walkways, plazas and courtyards, as well as site amenities or features.
A. Plazas and Courtyards.
1. A plaza or courtyard should have an articulated edge (buildings, benches, landscaping, etc.) to provide a sense of arrival.
2. Site amenities such as seating, lighting, planters, drinking fountains, distinctive paving, art work, and bicycle racks should be provided. See photo.
3. Plazas should incorporate focal points such as sculptures or water features where space permits. See photo.
4. Furniture and fixtures used in the plaza areas should complement the building architecture.
5. Soft and hard-surfaced areas should be incorporated into the overall plaza design.
6. Decorative paving used in the plaza areas should complement the paving pattern and colors used elsewhere on-site.
B. Sidewalk Dining.
1. Street furniture should be compatible with the adjacent public improvements, private structures, and building materials. The design materials and colors used for chairs, tables, lighting, and other fixtures including umbrellas and awnings should be generally consistent with both the architectural style and colors used on the building facade.
2. The street furniture cannot restrict motor vehicle sight lines.
3. The street furniture cannot impede entry to the building and must not preclude applicable emergency exit requirements.
Lighting should be pedestrian-scaled
Fountain provides focal point, art
work and seating
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-54
4. All barriers and/or surrounding outdoor dining areas should withstand inclement outdoor weather and one hundred (100) pounds of horizontal force at the top of the barricade when in their fixed positions.
5. Outdoor dining facilities should be for sit-down food and beverage service only; no stand-up service.
6. Seating (tables and chairs) should not be removed from outdoor dining areas during business hours.
7. To identify the most appropriate location(s) adjacent to the restaurant to locate outdoor dining, consider the relationship between the characteristic of the spaces and activities surrounding possible outdoor dining locations. Outdoor dining facilities must comply with Chapter 4 of this Specific Plan.
8. The use of retractable awnings or removable umbrellas is generally encouraged. See photo.
9. Awnings and umbrellas should not cover more than fifty percent (50%) of the outdoor dining area, providing patrons with a choice between sun and shade.
10. Awnings should maintain at least eight (8) feet of vertical clearance above the sidewalk level and should not exceed fifteen (15) feet in height.
11. Umbrellas should be mounted in a stable base to minimize accidental or windblown tipping over.
12. Awnings and umbrellas should be located to not interfere with street trees. See photo.
13. Umbrellas and awnings should be cleaned at least once per month.
14. Barriers surrounding outdoor dining areas should complement the facade of the building and the public realm, as well as be highly transparent (e.g., wrought iron fencing).
15. Within the outdoor dining area, especially near entrances, provide trash receptacles for use by patrons and restaurant employees to minimize litter.
16. When designing an outdoor dining area, provide appropriate lighting to create a nighttime ambience that complements the adjacent buildings and public realm.
17. Lighting should be incorporated into the facade of the building, and should complement the style of building. Lights on buildings should not be glaring to pedestrians, and should illuminate only the outdoor eating area.
Removable umbrellas are used to
shade tables, but do not interfere with
existing trees
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-55
18. Plants, trees, and flowers, when used within the outdoor dining area, should be in portable containers to promote the most flexible use of the space.
19. For potted plants, include a saucer or other suitable system to retain seepage.
C. Walls and Fences.
1. Walls and fences are generally used for security purposes, to define ownership, to mitigate nuisances such as noise, and to screen areas from public view. Walls and fences should be kept as low as possible while performing their functional purpose.
2. Landscaping should be used in combination with walls to soften otherwise blank surfaces. Vines planted on walls are strongly encouraged to hide flat wall surfaces to help reduce graffiti.
D. Lighting.
1. Pedestrian scale lighting is strongly encouraged. The style and color of lighting should be consistent with the character of a public space.
2. Bollards are intended to separate pedestrians from vehicular traffic areas and to light sidewalk surfaces. Bollard design should coordinate with other streetscape furnishings. In locations, where emergency access may be necessary, removable bollards are encouraged.
E. Site Amenities.
1. Site amenities form elements of commonality, which help to establish the identity of an area and provide comfort and interest to its users.
Individual site amenities within an area should have common features, such as color, material, and design to provide a cohesive environment and more identifiable character.
2. Refuse receptacle design should coordinate with other streetscape furnishings.
3. Pots and planters should be located where pedestrian flow will not be obstructed. See photo.
4. Pots and planters should be durable and have natural color tones that complement the adjacent structures.
5. Bicycle racks should be selected that are durable. Based on their performance, “loop racks” and “ribbon bars” are encouraged, and should be sized according to parking requirements. Bicycle racks that are sculptural or also serve as public art may be used.
6. The design of newspaper boxes should be consolidated into one rack.
The rack should be attractive on all sides and properly anchored. See photo.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Design Guidelines
7-56
7. Visual features, such as fountains, should be incorporated into public spaces to attract pedestrians.
F. Street Furniture.
1. Seating is an important amenity that should be provided throughout commercial areas.
2. The design and selection of street furniture should include considerations for the security, safety, comfort and convenience of the user.
3. Unified street furniture “look” is encouraged. The color and appearance of street furniture products should be selected to complement other design elements.
4. Where possible, furnishings should be grouped together.
5. A greater number and type of furnishings should be provided in higher- use pedestrian traffic areas. Furnishings should not obstruct pedestrian circulation.
G. Landscaping.
1. Tree grates should occur along street edges and plazas where a continuous walking surface is needed. Grate sizes should be a minimum of four feet in diameter. Knockouts should be provided to enlarge the inside diameter for supporting a larger tree trunk as the tree grows. See photo.
2. Tree guards should extend vertically from tree grates, and serve to protect trees in highly active areas. Tree guards should be narrow and painted in a similar color and relate to other site furnishings.
Tree grate
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Vision and Objectives
DRAFT | AUGUST 2019 333
ba
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-1
8. ADMINISTRATION AND
IMPLEMENTATION
8.1 SPECIFIC PLAN ADOPTION
The Bellflower Transit Oriented Development Specific Plan (the “Specific Plan”) was prepared in conformity with Government Code §§ 65451, et seq. Together with the Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”) and other applicable law, this Specific Plan sets forth the development and zoning regulations for the Specific Plan area.
8.2 MUNICIPAL CODE REFERENCE
This Specific Plan takes precedence over the BMC in the event of any conflict. This Specific Plan provides the zoning regulations and procedures for the Specific Plan Area. Any standards or regulations that are silent in this Specific Plan will revert to the BMC.
This Specific Plan provides the entire zoning for this Specific Plan area.
The entire property is zoned “TOD SP” and the applicable zoning regulations for this Specific Plan area are those set forth in this Specific Plan.
8.3 DEFINITIONS
In addition to the defined terms set forth in this Specific Plan, unless the contrary is stated or clearly appears from the context, the following definitions govern the construction of the words and phrases used in this Specific Plan. Words and phrases not defined by this chapter have the meaning set forth elsewhere in the BMC or applicable law.
The following provide definitions of terms used in this Specific Plan:
“Applicable Law”: All Federal, State and City laws including the Bellflower Municipal Code (“BMC”).
“Director”: Director of Planning and Building Services, or designee. “Façade”: The vertical surface of a building that is set parallel to a Frontage Line and facing a street.
“Frontage Line”: The property lines of a lot fronting a street or other public way, or a park, green, or paseo.
“Frontage Type”: These are prototypical arrangements of architectural and site design elements that illustrate ways in which the intended streetscape character can be achieved through design.
Appropriate degrees of privacy for adjoining buildings must be considered.
“Live-Work Unit”: A dwelling unit that incorporates non-residential uses. Permitted non-residential live/work uses are restricted to
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-2
permitted uses within the zone in which it is located. Live/Work uses must comply with all of the following:
A. Live/Work units must be internally accessible between the residential area and the non-residential area. The non-residential area must be directly accessible to a non-resident from the ground level via an entry/exit separated from a residential entry/exit; B. An employee of the non-residential use must reside in the dwelling unit. However, the non-residential use may have employees that do not reside within the dwelling unit;
C. Live/Work uses must observe similar operational and delivery hours and walk-in/client visits as other permitted uses within the zone in which it is located.
D. Outdoor storage is not permitted;
E. Live/Work uses cannot store or generate hazardous materials or employ hazardous processes;
F. Noise, vibration, dust, odors, fumes, smoke, heat, electrical interference or other similar nuisances from Live/Work activities cannot be perceived beyond the individual unit; and
G. Live/Work activities cannot increase pedestrian or vehicle traffic beyond that ordinarily associated with the zone in which it is located nor can it reduce the number of required off-street parking spaces available for use.
“Mixed-Use”: Multiple land uses and activities within the same building or the same general area.
“Planning Commission”: The Planning Commission established by BMC Chapter 2.32. The Director may, however, recommend that the City Council act as the planning agency for a project by resolution as authorized by BMC § 2.32.050. Upon adoption of such a resolution, the City Council will act as the Planning Commission for purposes of this Specific Plan.
8.4 SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENTS
The Specific Plan provisions are intended to be flexible and responsive to the needs of the City and future commercial development within the Specific Plan area. Furthermore, the Project Review (PR) Process is intended to consolidate typical City review processes and provide the City with the opportunity to ensure future commercial development proposals comply with those development and design standards contained in this Specific Plan and other relevant requirements of the City. Therefore, separate design-related approvals are not generally required. The provisions of this Specific Plan also offer interpretive flexibility to the Director that should accommodate most future development.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-3
It should be noted that this Specific Plan does provide relief for those future developments that deviate from those standards and provisions contained in this Specific Plan, including the following:
A. Amendment to any portion of the Specific Plan as initiated by the City.
B. Amendment to the text or maps.
C. Amendment in any internal Specific Plan Area boundary.
D. Amendment in standards or regulations, including landscaping and design standards.
E. Amendment that would not have a substantial adverse impact on surrounding properties.
F. Amendment that would not alter any findings contained in the environmental document prepared for the approval.
G. Amendment that would not affect the ability to meet
infrastructure and service provisions contained in the Specific Plan.
H. Amendment to design criteria such as paving treatments, architectural details and related criteria.
I. Amendment to landscape treatments, fencing, lighting, trails, and entry treatments, provided the modifications are in substantial conformance with the purpose and intent of the specified design criteria.
J. Amendment to the Specific Plan that would not significantly affect the overall design and visual quality of the area including, without limitation, the following:
» Building setback deviation – up to ten percent (10%); » Height of fence or wall deviation – up to ten percent (10%). In commercial zones, a modification of twenty percent (20%) may be allowed;
» Projections into required setbacks – up to ten percent (10%); » Building height increase – up to ten percent (10%);
» Reduction in off street parking requirement – up to ten percent (10%);
» All other dimensional or percentage limitations or requirements – up to ten percent (10%).
» Any other amendment deemed appropriate by the Director.
The Director may request additional information from the applicant in order to make the necessary findings to approve the amendment. In addition, the applicant would need to provide additional architectural enhancements or other design benefits which would provide the Director with incentive to allow the relaxation of any development
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-4
standard. The Director must make the following findings (as applicable) to approve the amendment to this Specific Plan:
A. The adjustment(s) does not change the vision or policy intent of the Specific Plan (the Vision is located in Chapter 2 and policies are included in Chapters 3 and 5 of the Specific Plan);
B. The adjustment will not produce a result that is detrimental to the neighborhood.
The decision of the Director becomes final unless appealed pursuant to the provisions of BMC Chapter 17.112 (Appeals).
8.5 REVIEW AND APPROVAL AUTHORITY OF
THE DIRECTOR
The Director has the authority to do the following:
A. Implement the Specific Plan in accordance with Applicable Law.
B. Interpret the Specific Plan. In the event that a specific use or type of use is not listed as a permitted use, the Director has authority to determine whether the proposed use is similar to a permitted use and whether the use is permitted, permitted subject to conditions, permitted as a temporary use, or prohibited. In determining “similarity,” the Director must make all of the following findings:
» The proposed use meets the intent of, and is consistent with, the goals, objectives and policies of the General Plan and the Specific Plan;
» The proposed use does not adversely impact the public health, safety and general welfare of the City’s residents; and » The proposed use shares characteristics common with and is not of greater intensity or density or does not generate more environmental impacts than those uses listed in the permitted uses section.
C. Any applicant, interested person, or public official may appeal decisions of the Director to the Planning Commission in accordance with the Specific Plan or BMC, as applicable.
D. Make technical corrections to maps, diagrams, tables, and other similar documents that may be required to reconcile the changes made by the Specific Plan with any applicable law.
E. Make the following technical amendments:
» Amendment to design criteria such as paving treatments, architectural details and related criteria.
» Amendment to landscape treatments, fencing, lighting, trails, and entry treatments, provided the modifications are in substantial
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-5
conformance with the purpose and intent of the specified design criteria.
» Amendment to design criteria such as paving treatments, architectural details and related criteria.
» Amendment to landscape treatments, fencing, lighting, trails, and entry treatments, provided the modifications are in substantial conformance with the purpose and intent of the specified design criteria.
F. Administer, interpret, and enforce all requirements of this Specific Plan, including the acceptance and processing of all land use permit applications.
G. The Director can make a Parking Determination to identify the number and location of required parking spaces in compliance with the standards and guidelines contained in this Specific Plan.
H. Approve project applications. The Project Review process and procedures are described in the next section.
I. Approve proposed additions and enlargements to existing improvements. The approval process and procedures are
described in the following section.
8.6 PROJECT REVIEW PROCESS AND
PROCEDURES
All new development projects within Planning Areas 1 through 4 are required to undergo a Project Review approval process and require review by the Director. All development projects within Planning Area 5 must comply with the underlying base zoning standards in accordance with BMC Title 17. The Project Review process provides the City with the opportunity to ensure future commercial and residential mixed-use development proposals comply with those development and other applicable law. The following describes the PR process.
8.6.1 PROJECT REVIEW PROCEDURES AND SUBMITTAL
REQUIREMENTS
The Director will review and confirm compliance of projects with this Specific Plan as follows:
A. Allowable uses and activities;
B. Site plans;
C. Building elevations/Architecture;
D. Landscaping plans;
E. Parking plans;
F. Floor plans;
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-6
G. Permanent and temporary uses and activities;
H. Hours and method of operations;
I. Business operation plan/description;
J. Photometrics Plan;
K. Master Sign Program;
L. Technical studies (i.e. parking, noise, etc.);
M. The Director can establish conditions of approval (as appropriate) with its approval.
To initiate the PR process, all project applicants must submit the following plans and materials to the Director. Plans and studies must be stamped and signed by a licensed professional. The Director must determine its completeness within 30 days. If complete, the Director will review and approve or deny the application. The Director’s determination may be appealed to the Planning Commission.
A. Project Application
B. Scaled and dimensioned site plan;
C. Scaled and dimensioned elevations showing all building exteriors on all buildings;
D. Scaled and dimensioned floor plans and building cross sections (if determined necessary by the Director);
E. Grading plan (including drainage scheme), prepared by a licensed civil engineer;
F. Complete inventory of building materials and color palette; G. Scaled and dimensioned landscape plan (including decorative hardscape);
H. Tentative Maps (if determined necessary by the Director); I. Preliminary Title Reports (if determined necessary by the Director);
J. Any detail drawings and exhibits as necessary to provide information on various project features that require specific and detailed review. Such detail drawings may include the location and design menu of signage, the project entrance and the community recreation area;
K. Photometrics Plan (if determined necessary by the Director); L. Description of operations (if determined necessary by the Director);
M. Studies (e.g. Parking) (if determined necessary by the Director).
If deemed appropriate, the Director has the ability to refer approval authority, on a case-by-case basis, to the Planning Commission and/or City Council, without the necessity of any public hearing.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-7
8.6.2 REQUIRED FINDINGS
The Director will approve the Project Review application, plans, building materials, architectural design and landscaping/hardscape design exhibits, provided the following findings are made:
A. The project is consistent with the provisions of this Specific Plan.
B. The project’s design and building architecture is complimentary and compatible with other projects within the Specific Plan area.
C. The overall project design and architecture are of high quality and innovative design, use quality construction materials, and creatively use landscape and hardscape materials in order to create a “signature” development for the City of Bellflower.
D. The project is consistent with the Bellflower General Plan.
8.7 PROVISIONS FOR EXISTING
IMPROVEMENTS AND ADDITIONS
Existing permitted improvements built in conformance to all building and zoning codes in effect at the time of construction may be maintained and repaired as currently existing and approved administratively by the Director, pursuant to the following provisions:
A. Such existing improvements and site conditions may be maintained, repainted, repaired, and landscaping upgraded without having to conform to the provisions of this Specific Plan.
B. Review and approval of such repairs and similar actions is required pursuant to the provisions of this Specific Plan.
C. All proposed additions, enlargements and improvements must conform to those development standards and design guidelines described in the Specific Plan; except additions proposed under the underlying zones must comply with the BMC.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-8
8.8 ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
At the time of the writing of this Specific Plan, there is no actual, physical development being proposed, nor are any new construction, grading, or other physical alterations to the environment being considered. The Specific Plan is a zoning-level Specific Plan document to guide and regulate future development around a future transit station and is viewed as a regulatory document to ensure practical and higher quality future development in the Specific Plan area. The Director will review all future development proposals on a case-by-case basis and will make applicable findings to ensure that all future development proposals are consistent with those standards and requirements contained in this Specific Plan document. As part of City’s review, additional CEQA documentation may be required for each future development proposal, if deemed necessary and appropriate.
8.9 IMPLEMENTATION ACTION PLAN
The following Implementation Action Plan (Table 8.1) lists the specific actions or strategies that should be taken by the City of Bellflower, in coordination with local businesses, future developers, and other agencies where appropriate. Programs and policies for some of these items are already in place and are recommended to be continued within this Study Area. The Implementation Action Plan is organized by the following topic areas:
A. Economic Development Strategies and Initiatives
B. Mobility and Streetscape Actions
C. Parking Actions
D. Housing Initiatives
For each action there is a recommended timeframe for completion, the responsible party or entity, and potential funding source(s). The timeframes are identified as follows:
» Short (1-5 years)
» Medium (5-10 years)
» Long (10 years or more)
Ongoing actions have also been identified. Actual implementation will be dependent on development activity, funding availability, and the Director resources.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-9
TABLE 8.1 Implementation Action Plan
SPECIFIC ACTIONS TIMEFRAME PRIMARY
RESPONSIBILITY
POTENTIAL
FUNDING
SOURCES
A. Commercial Uses
A.1 Complete construction of the new parking garage
on Bellflower Boulevard.
Ongoing,
expected
completion
mid-2020
Public Works
Department
Funding
secured
A.2 Promote redevelopment of key parcels within the
Study Area among developers, commercial brokers,
and the business community to spur additional
investment in older commercial properties.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City
A.3 Encourage and facilitate new dining and retail
options by aiding in site location, tenant
improvements, and permit processing.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City
A.4 Work with landlords of vacant properties to make
necessary upgrades through the Business Assistance
Program.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City
A.5 Coordinate with Metro on the final location,
design, and construction of the transit station to
achieve the urban design policies under Chapter 5,
Objective 5.
Ongoing Planning
Department,
Economic
Development
Department, and
Public Works
Department
City
A.6 Establish a Business Improvement District for the
downtown and broader area to provide a Clean & Safe
Program, Events, and Downtown Promotion. The BID
requires approval by the affected property owners of
the downtown businesses.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City
A.7 Work with the Southeast Los Angeles County
Workforce Investment Board to aid with job
placement, job training, and other services to better
align the local workforce with employer needs in
Bellflower.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City
B. Mobility and Streetscape Actions
B.1 Extend Bellflower Boulevard streetscape
improvements from Mayne Street north to Alondra
Boulevard.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Private
Development,
Metro
B.2 Extend Bellflower Boulevard streetscape
improvements from Flower Street south to Park Street.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Private
Development,
Metro
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-10
TABLE 8.1 Implementation Action Plan
SPECIFIC ACTIONS TIMEFRAME PRIMARY
RESPONSIBILITY
POTENTIAL
FUNDING
SOURCES
B.3 Encourage and facilitate the installation of bicycle facilities.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Caltrans,
Metro
B.4 Enhance crosswalks to improve pedestrian access
within the Specific Plan area.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Caltrans,
Metro
B.5 Design and construct gateway signage at Bellflower
Boulevard and Alondra Boulevard to direct people to
the transit station and downtown.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Private
Development,
Metro
B.6 Prepare a streetscape improvement plan along
Alondra Boulevard to enhance the identify of
Bellflower and call attention to the downtown.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Private
Development,
Metro
C. Parking Actions
C.1 Manage curbside parking along Bellflower
Boulevard by establishing time limits to increase
turnover and convenience to users. Enforce parking
limits.
Short Public Works
Department,
Planning
Department, and
Public Safety
City
C.2 Establish passenger loading areas along Bellflower
Boulevard or within the vicinity to accommodate
increased demand for ride-hailing services.
Medium Public Works
Department
City, Private
Development
C.3 Adopt a parking occupancy target for public
parking facilities to ensure adequate parking
availability for visitors, residents and employees.
Short City Council
C.4 Establish a system to monitor parking occupancy
regularly and recommend changes (if necessary) to
managing parking supply
Medium Public Works
Department and
Public Safety
City
C.5 Consider expanding the existing parking district as the opportunity arises through new development, in
order to continue to promote shared parking within
the area.
Long Public Works
Department
City
C.6 Coordinate with Metro to balance the parking
demands of the transit users with residents and
visitors in the Specific Plan area. Look for opportunities to share parking at the proposed transit station.
Short Public Works
Department and
Planning
Department
City
C.7 Improve signage for off-street public parking
locations and the parking structure at the Civic Center.
Long Public Works
Department
City, Metro
C.8 Continue the valet program for key locations in the downtown to address parking constraints at peak
hours.
Ongoing Economic
Development and
Public Works
Department
City
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-11
TABLE 8.1 Implementation Action Plan
SPECIFIC ACTIONS TIMEFRAME PRIMARY
RESPONSIBILITY
POTENTIAL
FUNDING
SOURCES
D. Housing Initiatives
D.1 Study inclusionary zoning best practices to
determine affordable housing policies for multifamily
housing projects.
Short Planning
Department and
Economic
Development
Department
City, AB32, SB2
D.2 Study and adopt strategies to reduce and prevent
homelessness in the Specific Plan area.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department, Public
Safety Department,
Planning
Department, and
Public Works
Department
City, AB32, SB2
D.3 Study existing density bonus regulations to
determine effectiveness and recommend updates.
Short Planning
Department and
Economic
Development
Department
City, AB32, SB2
D.4 Identify grant application priorities to fund and
support the development of affordable housing.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City, AB32, SB2
D.5 Identify and coordinate with affordable housing
developers.
Ongoing Economic
Development
Department
City, AB32, SB2
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-12
8.10 POTENTIAL FUNDING MECHANISMS
There are a number of grants, loans, and value capture funding mechanisms that could finance the infrastructure and community benefits identified in this Specific Plan. These resources are described below.
8.10.1 LOCAL TAX INCREMENT AND ASSESSMENT DISTRICTS
Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District
The Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) is a funding mechanism whose primary purpose is to finance a wide array of infrastructure projects with “communitywide significance,” including transit improvements and affordable housing. EIFDs are a California state legislation signed into law in September 2014 and further refined as a tool in 2015.
An EIFD can be established without voter approval by a city, county, or joint powers authority to fund specific infrastructure and economic development projects as outlined in the financing plan. EIFDs can leverage multiple funding streams to achieve these goals—including tax increment financing, if approved by voters, assessment revenues, fees, and other sources such as state and federal grants. EIFDs may not issue debt without a 55 percent vote of the district’s registered voters, nor can revenues be used to fund ongoing maintenance and operations. An EIFD can be established without geographic limitations on where it can be used, therefore it could be employed on a single corridor, such as Flower Street, around the new Bellflower Station, or throughout the whole Specific Plan area.
Revenues could be applied to a number of improvements including transit-oriented development, development that carries out sustainable communities’ strategies, affordable housing, and civic projects such as parks and libraries. EIFDs can furthermore finance infrastructure work including pedestrian connectivity, streetscape improvements, water and sewer infrastructure, and parking facilities.
Community Revitalization Investment Authorities
Community Revitalization Investment Authorities (CRIAs)—another funding mechanism recently passed in California to help carry out revitalization activities—share a number of similarities with EIFDs. CRIAs use tax increment to implement an economic revitalization financing plan within a defined area to construct, improve, or rehabilitate specified projects with community-wide benefits.
CRIAs may be established without voter approval after three public hearings with public support. It is governed by a board of appointed public and government representatives who can issue bonds without voter approval. A CRIA must operate within an investment area that meets the state’s criteria of a disadvantaged community based on socioeconomic, public health, and/or environmental factors. The 2017
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation
SCAG EIFD/CRIA Technical Assistance Application indicates that all or most of the Specific Plan area is eligible.
Financing can be used to fund public or private revitalization projects including infrastructure construction and repair, owner or tenant improvement loans, and affordable housing. CRIAs have an affordable housing set-aside: 25% of tax increment revenues must be used for very low, low, and moderate-income housing.
Special Assessment Districts
Special Assessment Districts can be used to fund any improvement that provides a “direct and special” benefit to the assessed property. Each property owner who receives a benefit pays a share of the costs of the improvements over a period of years. Improvements like the recommended sidewalks enhancements, street trees, lighting, art, and benches that improve connectivity, as well as safety improvements like private security, can be funded via Special Assessment, while “general” benefits like schools may not.
There are two primary challenges in establishing Special Assessment Districts, particularly for those in already developed areas. The first is that total property taxes can only increase a certain amount before new development is disadvantaged relative to properties not subject to an assessment. The second challenge is that assessment districts require a majority vote of property owners weighted by property value to pass.
All the affected properties must stand to benefit from that particular improvement, and no assessment can exceed the “reasonable cost” of its special benefit to that parcel.
Business Improvement District
A Business Improvement District (BID) is a common type of Special Assessment District that assesses business and/or property owners to fund maintenance, marketing, and other activities, including additional public services or improvements. A BID is a powerful tool for raising funds to provide enhancements to the area, but cannot be used to issue bonds.
Under the California Parking and Business Improvement Area Law of 1989 and Property and Business Improvement District Law of 1994, a district can be established via a County resolution of intent to form a BID. If a majority of property owners do not protest the resolution during a subsequent public hearing, an advisory board would be appointed. Once formed, a special assessment can be charged to commercial property or business owners for an amount proportional to the benefits they will receive.
The City and Downtown Bellflower business and property owners are in the process of forming two BIDs in the Specific Plan area along Bellflower Boulevard: one located north of Flower Street to Alondra Boulevard; and the other located south of Flower Street to Rose Street.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 8-14
Funding raised could be applied toward enhanced sanitation and cleaning as well as other streetscape and pedestrian improvements.
Landscape and Lighting Assessment District
Like a BID, a Landscape and Lighting Assessment District (LLAD) is another type of Special Assessment District that could be applied to fund new street lights and pedestrian lights, landscaping, parkways, medians, and other amenities. An LLAD requires that benefits accrue proportionately to the assessed properties. LLADs are more flexible than BIDs in that they can issue bonds and require a simple majority of property owners for formation. Commercial corridors within the Specific Plan area may consider LLADs to fund area-wide lighting and streetscape improvements.
8.10.2 REGIONAL AND STATE SOURCES OF FUNDS
Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities
The 2006 Global Warming Solutions Acts (AB 32) established a cap and trade system in California. The system establishes quarterly auctions of carbon allowances, whose proceeds are deposited into a Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund. Using revenue from this fund, the Strategic Growth Council administers the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities (AHSC) program, which funds land-use, housing, transportation, and land preservation projects to support infill and compact development that reduces greenhouse gas emissions.
Approximately $395 million in AHSC funding was announced in FY 2017–18; recipients will be announced in Summer 2019. Potential projects could include installation of new or improved pedestrian crossings, walkways, bikeways, or bus lanes, streetscape improvements, including, but not limited to the installation of lighting, signage, urban greening, street furniture, or other related amenities for pedestrians, cyclists and transit riders, traffic calming projects. Funding can also be used for the acquisition and rehabilitation of affordable housing, or the conversion of nonresidential structures to residential dwelling units.
Projects that can show the Strategic Growth Council that they reduce vehicle miles traveled by locating near transit are most competitive for funds. However, the market for carbon emissions has shown itself to be relatively unstable. Rather than trading emission allowances, companies are reducing emissions. While this is certainly beneficial to the environment, it means that the future of this funding source is uncertain.
Infrastructure State Revolving Loan Fund
The California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (I-Bank) loans money at below-market interest rates for infrastructure projects around the state. The I-Bank is the state’s general-purpose financing authority that finances public infrastructure and private development projects that promote economic development and revitalize communities.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation
Eligible project categories in Bellflower include the rehabilitation of streets, water supply and flood control, expanded public transit, and power and communications facilities. Categories also include new educational, cultural, or social facilities, as well as parks and recreational facilities.
Recent loan recipients in Southern California have included the City of San Gabriel, which borrowed $3.8 million at 3.5 percent interest to upgrade, reconstruct, and rehabilitate its public streets.
8.10.3 FEDERAL SOURCES
Economic Adjustment/Revolving Loan Fund
The Economic Development Administration, a bureau in the U.S.
Department of Commerce, administers the Economic
Adjustment/Revolving Loan Fund (RLF), which assists state and local entities in creating and implementing strategies to improve local economic conditions in areas that have experienced structural change in their economic bases.
The RLF provides capital to help small businesses and entrepreneurs expand production capabilities with gap financing. Businesses in Bellflower looking for assistance would contact the local EDA Regional Office (Pacific Coast Regional) with information on interest rates.
Maximum loans are $650,000 per borrower with terms of seven years for working capital, 15 years for fixed assets, and 20 years for real estate. Start-up firms, as well as those looking to expand, could benefit from use of this loan program.
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation
BELLFLOWER SPECIFIC PLAN | Administration and Implementation 18