APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
058 217701801 1725 SHATTUCK AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 13,476$ BESO 052 151300301 910 FOLGER AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 13,466$ CBECS 052 157307200 Telegraph Avenue Medical Office Building 3017 TELEGRAPH AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Health Care 13,459$ CBECS 057 210600104 Sierra Misco 1825 EASTSHORE HWY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 13,456$ CBECS 057 203400500 Heywood Apartments 2119 ADDISON ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 13,328$ CBECS 059 234100500 1420 SECOND ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 13,221$ CBECS 059 226000201 2110 VINE ST 94709 15k-24,999k Retail 13,185$ CBECS 057 207200600 Rodeway Inn 1461 UNIVERSITY AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Hotel/Lodging 13,057$ BESO 057 202500600 Historic Kress Bldg 2036 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Office 13,029$ BESO 060 238600101 1151 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Public Assembly 13,006$ CBECS Multiple APNs 2430 5TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Residential 13,002$ CBECS Multiple APNs 1450 4TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Residential 12,981$ CBECS 057 204600200 Former UC Press Building 2120 BERKELEY WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Office 12,971$ CBECS 056 195401000 2031 2ND ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 12,931$ CBECS Multiple APNs 1519 OXFORD ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 12,917$ BESO 056 199701801 The Kelbourne 1420 ADDISON ST 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 12,916$ CBECS 057 202901601 Oxford Court 2150 KITTREDGE ST 94720 15k-24,999k Other 12,908$ CBECS 057 202501400 Berkeley Apartments- University (Touriel) 2004 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,839$ BESO 060 235501103 1000 HARRISON ST 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 12,815$ CBECS 055 184703102 Holy Spirit Parish/Newman Hall 2700 DWIGHT WAY 94704 25k-49,999k Religious Worship 12,636$ CBECS 055 189100201 2404 FULTON ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,605$ BESO 058 218202700 Thornburg Village 1829 SPRUCE ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 12,604$ CBECS 054 176600306 2629 SEVENTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 12,541$ BESO 057 205002901 2030 DELAWARE ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 12,535$ CBECS 054 172300100 2700 SHATTUCK AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Office 12,496$ CBECS 057 202401503 The Tepping Bldg 1916 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Office 12,478$ CBECS 055 188200700 Elsmere Apartments 2321 DWIGHT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,345$ BESO 057 206101000 1717 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Other 12,302$ CBECS Multiple APNs 1849 SHATTUCK AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 12,290$ CBECS 057 208501900 1120 HEARST AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 12,269$ CBECS 057 204700201 Berkeleyan 1910 OXFORD ST 94704 25k-49,999k Residential 12,242$ BESO 058 219700702 2555 VIRGINIA ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 12,238$ CBECS 055 183101801 2309 BLAKE ST 94704 25k-49,999k Residential 12,220$ BESO 055 189300701 URSA Apartments 2124 BANCROFT WAY 94704 50k-99,999k Residential 12,215$ BESO Multiple APNs 2628 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,196$ CBECS 055 186601003 Piedmont Avenue Apartments 2437 PIEDMONT AVE 94704 25k-49,999k Residential 12,187$ BESO 053 167200400 1529 RUSSELL ST 94703 15k-24,999k Residential 12,178$ CBECS 055 185601400 2425 PROSPECT ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,091$ CBECS 057 208102100 1951 CHESTNUT ST 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 12,064$ CBECS 057 202301701 ARTech 2101 MILVIA ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 12,059$ BESO 055 186701000 2715 DWIGHT WAY 94704 25k-49,999k Residential 12,026$ BESO 055 187601100 2375 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 12,012$ CBECS 055 189500500 Channing Walk Apartments 2035 CHANNING WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,983$ BESO 053 159500903 3031 ADELINE ST 94703 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,980$ CBECS 053 159202100 2024 ASHBY AVE 94703 25k-49,999k Religious Worship 11,881$ CBECS 055 187500700 2409 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,851$ CBECS
APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
057 203300300 Roos Bros. Building 2021 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,838$ CBECS 056 194200302 800 BANCROFT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 11,814$ CBECS 058 218901000 1811 ARCH ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 11,784$ CBECS 055 186801800 2724 CHANNING WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,736$ CBECS 054 176600602 Consolidated Printer 2620 8TH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Industrial 11,659$ BESO 053 164100704 2950 7TH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 11,635$ CBECS 057 209700102 806 HEARST AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Office 11,540$ CBECS 058 219800200 1700 LE ROY AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 11,538$ CBECS 055 182501502 2621 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Retail 11,535$ CBECS 057 203300400 2020 KALA BAGAI WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,503$ CBECS 055 187000800 2701 DURANT AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,444$ CBECS 060 245200102 School of the Madeleine 1225 MILVIA ST 94709 15k-24,999k Education 11,402$ CBECS 056 196101800 The Aquatic II 814 UNIVERSITY AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,384$ BESO 058 219100103 1804 EUCLID AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,362$ CBECS 058 220300300 1735 HIGHLAND PL 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 11,336$ BESO 057 202501703 Koerber Building 2054 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Office 11,334$ CBECS 057 206200501 1743 BERKELEY WAY 94703 15k-24,999k Residential 11,320$ CBECS 055 184100600 Hillegass Apartments 2610 HILLEGASS AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,267$ BESO 054 170901300 Everest 2740 COLLEGE AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 11,238$ BESO 059 231900203 1501 EASTSHORE HWY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 11,221$ CBECS Multiple APNs 1440 4TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 11,221$ CBECS Multiple APNs 2700 SAN PABLO AVE 94702 25k-49,999k Residential 11,218$ BESO 062 291606004 645 ARLINGTON AVE 94707 15k-24,999k Residential 11,207$ CBECS 056 194500102 742 BANCROFT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 11,102$ CBECS 055 187700600 2533 DURANT AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,096$ CBECS 057 206101100 1701 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 11,078$ CBECS 053 165500404 703 HEINZ AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 11,069$ CBECS 055 184302000 2533 HILLEGASS AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 11,037$ CBECS 052 157404500 3030 REGENT ST 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 10,945$ CBECS 057 208700500 1822 SAN PABLO AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 10,918$ CBECS 057 208000800 1810 WEST ST 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 10,894$ CBECS 053 167200501 1525 RUSSELL ST 94703 15k-24,999k Residential 10,818$ CBECS Multiple APNs 2615 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,788$ CBECS 064 423600500 22 DOMINGO AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 10,784$ CBECS 057 203101100 2130 CENTER ST 94704 15k-24,999k Other 10,731$ CBECS Multiple APNs 3031 TELEGRAPH AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Office 10,678$ BESO 054 177000202 Electro Coatings 893 CARLETON ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 10,660$ CBECS 052 153300103 1708 HARMON ST 94703 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 10,605$ CBECS 057 203300101 2000 KALA BAGAI WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Other 10,566$ CBECS 055 183200701 2339 PARKER ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,537$ CBECS Multiple APNs 2634 VIRGINIA ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,536$ BESO 055 182902600 2232 BLAKE ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,519$ CBECS 055 182203000 2012 DWIGHT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,515$ CBECS 055 184300900 2540 BENVENUE AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,514$ BESO 055 183101002 2327 BLAKE ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,497$ CBECS 055 183101001 2331 BLAKE ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,495$ CBECS
APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
059 226200100 Shattuck Commons 1400 SHATTUCK AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Other 10,483$ CBECS 056 198101501 1310 UNIVERSITY AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Education 10,377$ CBECS 058 217103101 1615 M L KING JR WAY 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,331$ CBECS Multiple APNs 2725 PRINCE ST 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 10,318$ CBECS 060 238800400 1101 EIGHTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 10,313$ BESO 056 194102202 Berkeley Pump 830 BANCROFT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Other 10,313$ CBECS 057 207100200 1597 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 10,279$ CBECS Multiple APNs 1401 WALNUT ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,273$ CBECS 056 194202401 2323 FIFTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 10,267$ CBECS 058 217500800 2041 FRANCISCO ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,266$ BESO 055 187900100 2350 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 10,239$ CBECS 060 235802206 1225 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 10,189$ CBECS 058 219402200 2456 HILGARD AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,184$ CBECS 058 220000700 Hearst Avenue Apartments 2511 HEARST AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 10,134$ CBECS 060 243100300 1475 ROSE ST 94702 15k-24,999k Education 10,107$ CBECS 055 186700300 2442 PIEDMONT AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,102$ BESO 055 183301701 2609 ELLSWORTH ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 10,091$ CBECS 059 231800112 1500 2ND ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 10,088$ CBECS 058 219300700 2401 LE CONTE AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 10,063$ BESO 055 189301200 2333 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Office 10,059$ CBECS 058 219402300 2466 HILGARD AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 9,989$ CBECS 052 156801201 2629 ASHBY AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 9,958$ CBECS 056 194301001 2416 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,911$ CBECS 061 260300400 908 THE ALAMEDA 94707 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 9,910$ CBECS 055 188702201 Durant Park Apartment 2230 DURANT AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,903$ BESO 056 200600106 1640 ADDISON ST 94703 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 9,859$ BESO 055 183600401 Parker CAL Apartments 2414 PARKER ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,813$ CBECS 059 226001300 1550 WALNUT ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 9,809$ BESO 057 208500500 1970 CURTIS ST 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 9,788$ CBECS 059 231701001 1520 FOURTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,772$ CBECS 055 184002401 CVS on Telegraph 2655 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Retail 9,706$ BESO 054 177901300 2531 NINTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,705$ BESO Multiple APNs 2 PANORAMIC WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,704$ CBECS 052 141000200 3100 COLLEGE AVE 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 9,693$ CBECS 053 165100500 999 ANTHONY ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,688$ CBECS 053 166002701 Ecole Bilingue de Berkeley 1001 HEINZ AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Education 9,665$ BESO 055 186401001 2815 CHANNING WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,661$ CBECS 057 208300401 1244 HEARST AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 9,560$ CBECS 055 189902501 Channing Poolside Apartments 1930 CHANNING WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,547$ BESO 052 151400201 Howlett Machine Works 754 FOLGER AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,544$ CBECS 057 207301700 1360 BERKELEY WAY 94702 15k-24,999k Residential 9,541$ CBECS 053 164700100 Berkeley Ironworks 750 POTTER ST 94710 15k-24,999k Office 9,538$ CBECS 062 288801701 1821 CATALINA AVE 94707 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 9,531$ CBECS 057 209901706 1800 FIFTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,467$ CBECS 055 182902701 2240 BLAKE ST 94704 25k-49,999k Residential 9,459$ BESO 059 234500900 1333 SECOND ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,458$ CBECS
APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
053 169001000 2321 RUSSELL ST 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 9,379$ CBECS 057 207200200 Aiden by Best Western 1499 UNIVERSITY AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Hotel/Lodging 9,357$ BESO 058 217802401 1607 SHATTUCK AVE 94709 15k-24,999k Retail 9,352$ CBECS 058 218202100 1890 ARCH ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 9,346$ CBECS 054 177800202 Parker Plaza (North) 2550 9TH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Office 9,310$ BESO 056 194402201 2425 FOURTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,247$ CBECS 056 194900602 626 BANCROFT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,232$ BESO 056 194401801 733 DWIGHT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,161$ CBECS 055 183603100 2616 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 9,091$ BESO 056 195900901 MacKey Marine 739 ALLSTON WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 9,033$ CBECS 054 178000801 2546 SAN PABLO AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Office 8,994$ CBECS 055 183900400 2517 TELEGRAPH AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 8,903$ BESO Multiple APNs 1801 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 25k-49,999k Residential 8,792$ BESO 055 187000102 2310 PIEDMONT AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 8,782$ BESO 061 257504001 941 THE ALAMEDA 94707 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 8,775$ BESO 058 217000101 1940 VIRGINIA ST 94709 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 8,764$ CBECS 055 187001501 2736 BANCROFT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Public Assembly 8,760$ BESO 057 202301400 2115 MILVIA ST 94704 15k-24,999k Office 8,714$ CBECS 054 177900100 The Wright Institute 1000 DWIGHT WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Office 8,690$ CBECS 057 202201304 1900 ADDISON ST 94704 15k-24,999k Office 8,674$ CBECS 054 178000700 2530 SAN PABLO AVE 94702 15k-24,999k Office 8,660$ BESO 059 226703101 1930 VINE ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 8,657$ BESO Multiple APNs 2512 9TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Retail 8,612$ CBECS 059 233900600 1404 FOURTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 8,573$ CBECS 053 167400101 1640 STUART ST 94703 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 8,573$ CBECS 056 195700701 701 BANCROFT WAY 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,503$ CBECS 060 244800401 1910 BERRYMAN ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 8,495$ BESO 058 217900100 2138 CEDAR ST 94709 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 8,416$ CBECS 055 187701601 2530 BANCROFT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Retail 8,357$ CBECS 056 195400801 2013 SECONND ST 94710 25k-49,999k Residential 8,250$ BESO 054 174701100 920 PARDEE ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,097$ CBECS 053 163300109 West Berkeley Warehouse 1036 ASHBY AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,094$ CBECS 059 233900800 1414 4TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,094$ CBECS 060 238900901 1100 TENTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,076$ CBECS 056 194600800 2316 FOURTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 8,039$ CBECS 060 245504801 1385 SHATTUCK AVE 94709 25k-49,999k Residential 7,953$ BESO 055 184201700 2519 PARKER ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 7,911$ BESO 056 201102501 Lutheran Church of the Cross 1760 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 7,903$ CBECS 056 201102100 1732 UNIVERSITY AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 7,806$ BESO 055 189200101 Jodo Shinshu Center 2140 DURANT AVE 94704 25k-49,999k Office 7,772$ BESO 052 151301001 830 FOLGER AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 7,713$ CBECS 055 182801501 2211 CARLETON ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 7,651$ BESO 057 211700903 1650 6TH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 7,430$ CBECS 052 157700902 Webster Poolside Apartments 2321 WEBSTER ST 94705 15k-24,999k Residential 7,300$ BESO 058 218300203 All Souls Parish Episcopal Church 2220 CEDAR ST 94709 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 7,289$ CBECS 060 235100103 945 CAMELIA ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 7,176$ CBECS
APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
055 188500900 2300 BANCROFT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 7,168$ CBECS 059 225601801 The North Berkeley Oxford Street Apartments 1555 OXFORD ST 94709 15k-24,999k Residential 7,132$ BESO Multiple APNs University Terrace 2100 JEFFERSON AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Residential 7,031$ BESO 057 205301403 1945 MILVIA ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 6,991$ BESO 055 184600200 2640 DWIGHT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 6,987$ BESO 055 184000500 2610 REGENT ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 6,972$ BESO 060 238500907 1150 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 6,847$ CBECS 056 197902301 1122 UNIVERSITY AVE 94702 50k-99,999k Residential 6,775$ BESO 055 189801601 Stranda Apartments 2489 M L KING JR WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 6,773$ BESO 055 187401200 First Church of Christ, Scientist 2619 DWIGHT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 6,626$ BESO 056 195700102 700 ALLSTON WAY 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 6,534$ CBECS 057 202700203 Mangalam Center 2018 ALLSTON WAY 94704 25k-49,999k Public Assembly 6,363$ BESO 060 235901803 805 GILMAN ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 6,354$ CBECS 055 186400300 2308 WARRING ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 6,350$ BESO 056 196101601 801 ADDISON ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 6,037$ CBECS 059 225900101 1501 WALNUT ST 94709 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 5,870$ BESO 059 234900901 1333 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,807$ CBECS 057 202501500 2018 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 25k-49,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 5,668$ BESO 052 152801404 3271 ADELINE ST 94703 25k-49,999k Office 5,643$ BESO 053 165901605 2830 NINTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,531$ CBECS 060 238500911 1146 SIXTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,479$ CBECS 054 177901206 Berkeley Bowl Warehouse 1005 PARKER ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,396$ CBECS 055 188201901 2330 HASTE ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 5,268$ BESO 056 195700204 2220 FOURTH ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,105$ CBECS 057 210400203 Truitt and White 642 HEARST AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,072$ BESO 053 163500101 830 ASHBY AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 5,059$ CBECS 053 164400800 2929 5TH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Industrial 4,930$ BESO 055 186600700 2450 WARRING ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 4,871$ BESO 060 235401001 1049 GILMAN ST 94710 15k-24,999k Retail 4,854$ BESO 059 225303402 Western Dominican Province 2301 VINE ST 94708 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 4,518$ BESO 056 198303103 2235 SAN PABLO AVE 94702 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage 4,269$ BESO 055 184202200 2537 REGENT ST 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 4,186$ BESO 061 261200200 Hundred Acre Wood Building 1820 SOLANO AVE 94707 15k-24,999k Office 4,003$ BESO 055 188200500 2335 DWIGHT WAY 94704 15k-24,999k Residential 3,983$ BESO 060 246604600 Congregation Beth El 1301 OXFORD ST 94709 25k-49,999k Religious Worship 3,904$ BESO 055 188200100 2430 DANA ST 94704 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 3,749$ BESO 058 218101300 Spruce Street Apartments 1800 SPRUCE ST 94709 25k-49,999k Residential 3,722$ BESO 053 164401300 800 HEINZ AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Residential 3,478$ BESO 053 165500900 2850 7TH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Office 3,402$ BESO 057 202300100 Frances Shattuck Bldg 2104 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 25k-49,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 3,343$ BESO 057 202900400 2288 FULTON ST 94704 25k-49,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 2,949$ BESO 055 185304000 2425 HILLSIDE AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Hotel/Lodging 2,941$ BESO 053 163402907 Folger Murray Properties 1047 FOLGER AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Industrial 2,753$ BESO 057 202401801 1942 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 25k-49,999k Office 2,673$ BESO 056 196001203 Sierra Design 2025 FOURTH ST 94710 25k-49,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 2,627$ BESO 060 240701901 1145 GILMAN ST 94706 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 2,621$ BESO
APN Building Name (if available) Building Address Zip Code Sqft Group Property Type Category Natural Gas Tax
(First Year)
Estimation
Source
052 151400301 746 FOLGER AVE 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 2,585$ BESO 057 202700400 Dharma College 2222 HAROLD WAY 94704 25k-49,999k Education 2,512$ BESO 057 202201901 The Addison Apartments 1950 ADDISON ST 94704 50k-99,999k Residential 2,411$ BESO 054 170211800 2837 CLAREMONT BLVD 94705 15k-24,999k Religious Worship 2,293$ BESO 057 202401400 1900 UNIVERSITY AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 2,196$ BESO 057 203100900 2161 SHATTUCK AVE 94704 15k-24,999k Mixed (Residential/Commercial) 2,178$ BESO 055 187900601 Telegraph-Channing Garage and Shops 2431 CHANNING WAY 94704 100k-249,999k Retail 2,147$ BESO 056 199000404 2141 BONAR ST 94702 25k-49,999k Public Assembly 1,946$ BESO 057 210300103 1805 SECOND ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 1,631$ BESO 056 196601001 837 ADDISON ST 94710 15k-24,999k Health Care 1,584$ BESO 058 218101200 1786 SPRUCE ST 94709 25k-49,999k Residential 1,574$ BESO 052 152801300 1837 ALCATRAZ AVE 94703 15k-24,999k Public Assembly 1,290$ BESO 053 168400100 2801 ADELINE ST 94703 15k-24,999k Retail 1,109$ BESO 060 238100202 Public Storage 1120 SECOND ST 94710 50k-99,999k Warehouse and Storage 878$ BESO 059 231600103 760 JONES ST 94710 15k-24,999k Warehouse and Storage 700$ BESO 052 155700200 Telegraph Medical 3120 TELEGRAPH AVE 94705 25k-49,999k Residential 514$ BESO 060 238900801 1005 HARRISON ST 94710 15k-24,999k Industrial 313$ BESO 053 163401802 Urban Ore 927 FOLGER AVE 94710 25k-49,999k Warehouse and Storage -$ BESO
Office of the City Manager
2180 Milvia Street, Berkeley, CA 94704 ● Tel: (510) 981-7000 ● TDD: (510) 981-6903 ● Fax: (510) 981-7099 E-Mail: [email protected] Website: https://berkeleyca.gov/
INFORMATION CALENDAR
July 30, 2024
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
From: LaTanya Bellow, Interim City Manager
Submitted by: Terrance Davis, Director, Public Works
Subject: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the “Healthy City Buildings” Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
INTRODUCTION
At a special meeting on June 14, 2024, the City Council requested a report, under the provisions of California Elections Code Section 9212, on the, “Healthy City Buildings,” citizen initiative that will appear before Berkeley voters on the November 5, 2024 ballot.
The Section 9212 report, prepared in response to this request and drafted as an Off- Agenda Memo, is attached.
CURRENT SITUATION AND ITS EFFECTS
As specified in Election Code Section 9212, this report must be presented to City Council no later than 30 days after the date on which the City Clerk certified the sufficiency of the initiative petition. Council requested that this report include:
An explanation of the air quality standards proposed in this measure, and any other air quality standards applicable, including those under consideration by State or Federal government.
The technical feasibility and costs of retrofitting these buildings to apply the new air quality standards and systems.
City resources required for the ongoing monitoring and maintenance after the installation of new systems.
Staff Time related to the reporting requirements prescribed in the initiative to ensure that systems are functioning and continuously meet the required air quality standards.
BACKGROUND
Staff from the Public Works Department have provided analysis and information on the “Healthy City Buildings” Voter Initiative’s potential impacts, to the greatest extent possible given constraints on available time and resources.
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY AND CLIMATE IMPACTS
Environmental impact may vary depending on the course of action and project implementation and phasing.
Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the “Healthy City Buildings” Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot INFORMATION CALENDAR July 30, 2024
POSSIBLE FUTURE ACTION
Future action will be dependent on the outcome of this initiative at the ballot on November 5, 2024.
FISCAL IMPACTS OF POSSIBLE FUTURE ACTION
The financial implications of adopting the Healthy City Buildings Ordinance are significant. The estimated cost range for facility assessments alone is $2M - $4M, with additional hard and soft costs anticipated for system upgrades, Staff training, and ongoing maintenance. These costs must be factored into the City’s budget planning.
Unknown costs associated with tenant improvements to existing City building leases, monitoring, and building management associated with the requirements are likely to far exceed existing budget allocations for facility maintenance.
CONTACT PERSON
Terrance Davis, Director Public Works Department
Attachments:
1: July 25, 2024 Off-Agenda Memo: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
Office of the City Manager
2180 Milvia Street, Berkeley, CA 94704 ● Tel: (510) 981-7000 ● TDD: (510) 981-6903 ● Fax: (510) 981-7099 E-Mail: [email protected] Website: https://berkeleyca.gov/ July 25, 2024
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
From: LaTanya Bellow, Interim City Manager
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot Background:
Registered voters in the City of Berkeley may soon vote on a new initiative called the Healthy City Buildings Ordinance (Ordinance). This Ordinance which would require building air monitoring and filtration systems. As written, the Healthy City Buildings Ordinance would amend the Berkeley Municipal Code by adding Section 12.12 requiring the City to install and maintain air monitoring and filtration system in existing and new buildings to aid in the control of infectious aerosols. Specifically, the Ordinance would require City-owned or City-leased occupied buildings to meet the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) Standard 241-2023.
ASHRAE is a global society aimed at advancing heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) technology for the built environment and provides engineering and policy guidance on ventilation, filtration and air cleaning, air distribution, HVAC system operation.
ASHRAE Standard 241-2023 establishes minimum requirements to reduce the risk of airborne disease transmission, including SARS-COV-2 and the flu virus, in buildings.
This standard is applicable to both new and existing buildings as well as major renovations, and it sets forth comprehensive guidelines for air system design, installation, operation, and maintenance.
This brief Off Agenda Memo aims to provide an overview of pertinent issues and background to aid in examining the potential impacts of the Ordinance. Given the short turnaround time, a comprehensive analysis was not feasible; however, this memo represents the best effort under the circumstances.
July 24, 2024
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
ASHRAE Standard 241-2023 Elements
The authors of the Healthy City Buildings initiative reference ASHRAE requirements as the desirable indoor air quality standard, so it is important to briefly outline some of the key elements addressed in the Standard 241-2023.
Infection Risk Management Mode (IRMM): The standard mandates the establishment of an IRMM, activated during periods of elevated disease transmission risk. The local authorities have the jurisdiction to determine when these enhanced protections are necessary. The standard emphasizes resilience in indoor air quality control design and operations to respond to extreme circumstances effectively.
Requirements for Equivalent Clean Airflow Rate: ASHRAE 241 sets specific targets for equivalent clean airflow rates per occupant, ensuring pathogen-free air to reduce infection risks.
Use of Filtration and Air Cleaning Technology: The standard provides detailed requirements for the use of filtration and air cleaning technologies, including HEPA filters, air ionizers, and UV lights. These technologies must be implemented effectively, safely, and cost-efficiently.
Planning and Commissioning: The standard requires a building readiness plan documenting procedures for assessing and ensuring the proper functioning of HVAC systems to meet the equivalent clean air delivery standards.
Existing City Building Ventilation Standards
The California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH), better known as Cal/OSHA, is responsible for regulatory oversight of California employees through the setting and enforcing of health and safety standards. On December 15, 2022, the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board voted to adopt non-emergency COVID-19 prevention regulations. These regulations took effect on February 3, 2023, and will remain in effect for two years after the effective date, except for the record keeping subsections that will remain in effect for three years.
In compliance with State regulations, on March 2023, the City revised its adopted Covid Prevention Plan (CPP), which includes various control measure to limit the spread of airborne illness. The CPP also includes the following Engineering control measures, relative to the built environment:
For indoor locations, the City identifies and evaluates how to maximize ventilation, to the extent feasible, indoor air exchange with outdoor air by utilizing the maximum mechanical ventilation and utilizing the highest filtration efficiency compatible with the existing ventilation system. Where appropriate, portable or mounted High Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filtration units, or other air
July 24, 2024
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
cleaning systems, may be utilized to achieve increased air filtration. The City may limit ventilation with outside air when the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Air Quality Index is greater than 100 for any pollutant.
Applicable City Building Inventory
The City is responsible for maintenance of 95 facilities, not including Library facilities and facilities leased to other entities, which have not been accounted for in this analysis.
These 95 facilities include: 39 facilities in the Parks Recreation and Waterfront inventory and 56 facilities in the Public Works inventory.
Implementation Considerations
From a planning, resourcing and operational implementation point of view, Staff have identified the following considerations regarding the proposed Ordinance to implement ASHRAE Standard 241-2023:
Facility Assessments: Although the City regularly performs high level assessments to create condition reports and cost estimates to calculate general deferred infrastructure improvement needs, Staff lack the detailed baseline building condition assessment data necessary to determine the full cost and associated timeline to comply with the proposed Ordinance. An immediate detailed assessment of all City building envelopes, including windows, roofs, and door systems, HVAC filtration and ducting, hazardous materials, and electrical systems is necessary. This assessment is anticipated to take 24-36 months to complete.
Building Readiness Plans/IRMM Requirements: For effective pathogen mitigation, ASHRAE 241 recommends buildings make plans for multiple building operation modes:
o For normal operations, buildings follow their normal operating mode that meets the outdoor air ventilation requirements set by ASHRAE Standard
62.1. o During times of high-risk, buildings enter an infectious risk management mode (IRMM). The standard specifies an equivalent outdoor air ventilation rate, on a cubic feet per minute per person basis, to be used during IRMM.
This rate is to be derived from a combination of mechanically supplied outdoor air and through air filtration.
HVAC Expertise: The City currently lacks certified HVAC technicians to diagnose, repair, install, and monitor filtration systems. Thus, implementation of the Ordinance would require external contract expertise to design, construct, and monitor the system to meet the requirements and timelines outlined in the proposed Ordinance. The costs to secure contract resources are unknown. Over time, the City would need to establish HVAC certified Facilities Maintenance
July 24, 2024
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
positions to ensure required skilled labor to manage, troubleshoot, repair, and monitor the operation of systems citywide.
Staff Training: City Staff will need extensive training to manage and maintain the new air quality systems effectively. Again, the costs associated with this is unknown and will be dictated by the type of system or systems selected for implementation.
Historic City Buildings: Many City buildings, due to age and construction materials, require significant and costly improvements to their ducting systems to meet the new standards. For example, the potential presence of non-friable hazardous building materials (asbestos mixed with cement or other hard bonding materials) will add significant remediation and air quality monitoring costs to the project in addition to extending the project duration. Assessing a wider range of historic preservation options may be necessary to ensure sustainable and cost- effective solutions are selected. This would require assembling an interdepartmental team (Public Works, Building and Safety, and Planning) to work with a consultant team (historic preservationist, structural engineer, architect/contractor specializing in renovation of historic public buildings) to assess and prioritize City buildings for renovation, preservation, and/or partial or full replacement.
Leased Facilities: The proposed Ordinance requires that any building that the City leases meet the ASHRAE 241-2023 standards. As of 2024, the City leases four (4) facilities for City operations. Compliance with the Ordinance would require renegotiation of some leases to ensure that the adequate tenant improvements to the building ventilation systems can be implemented.
Compliance Timeline: Meeting the compliance timeline by January 1, 2025, is challenging, particularly for interim measures requiring operable windows and HEPA filters installation.
Potential Operational Impacts: Enacting the required measures may lead to temporary closures of some City facilities, impacting public services and operations. It is essential to assess the extent of these operational impacts to plan effectively.
Financial Estimates
The financial implications of adopting the Healthy City Buildings Ordinance are significant. The estimated cost range for facility assessments alone is $2M - $4M, with additional hard and soft costs anticipated for system upgrades, Staff training, and ongoing maintenance. These costs must be factored into the City’s budget planning.
Unknown costs associated with tenant improvements to existing City building leases,
July 24, 2024
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
monitoring, and building management associated with the requirements are likely to far exceed existing budget allocations for facility maintenance.
Required Next Steps (If Ordinance is Adopted)
Detailed Facility Assessments: Prioritize and schedule comprehensive facility assessments to determine the specific requirements and costs for each building.
Engage External Expertise: Hire certified HVAC technicians and consultants to assist with the implementation and on-going maintenance of upgraded and/or new air quality systems.
Staff training programs: Initiate Staff training programs to ensure that city personnel are equipped to manage and maintain the new systems. Budget Allocation: Allocate sufficient funding in the city budget to cover the costs of assessments, upgrades, and ongoing maintenance.
Conclusion
Implementing the Healthy City Building Ordinance, and the associated ASHRAE Standard 241 in the City of Berkeley’s facilities is essential for enhancing indoor air quality and reducing the risk of airborne disease transmission. However, this undertaking requires significant financial investment, technical expertise, and strategic planning. The outlined steps and Staff recommendations aim to ensure a safe and effective implementation process, safeguarding the health and safety of city employees and the public.
cc:
Anne Cardwell, Deputy City Manager
Tasha Tervalon, Interim Deputy City Manager
Jenny Wong, City Auditor
Farimah Brown, City Attorney
Mark Numainville, City Clerk
Matthai Chakko, Assistant to the City Manager
July 24, 2024
Re: Analysis and Response regarding the Aerosols Requirements of the 'Healthy City Buildings’ Voter Initiative on the November 5, 2024 Ballot
Communications
All communications submitted to the City Council are
public record. Communications are not published directly to the City’s website. Copies of individual communications are available for viewing at the City Clerk Department and through Records Online.
City Clerk Department
2180 Milvia Street
Berkeley, CA 94704
(510) 981-6900
Records Online
https://records.cityofberkeley.info/
To search for communications associated with a particular City Council meeting using Records Online:
1. Select Search Type = “Public – Communication Query (Keywords)”
2. From Date: Enter the date of the Council meeting
3. To Date: Enter the date of the Council meeting (this may match the From Date field)
4. Click the “Search” button
5. Communication packets matching the entered criteria will be returned
6. Click the desired file in the Results column to view the document as a PDF