Residential Feasibility Study and
Inclusionary Analysis
FINAL DRAFT REPORT
Prepared for:
Town of Los Altos Hills
October 30, 2026
ITEM 7B, Attachment 3
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 2 Table of Contents
TABLE OF FIGURES ...............................................................................................................................4 INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................................................................6 Report Purpose.....................................................................................................................................6 Background on Inclusionary Housing Policies....................................................................................6 Report Organization .............................................................................................................................9 FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS.............................................................................................10 Methodology ...................................................................................................................................... 10 Analysis Approach ..................................................................................................................... 10 Prototypes.................................................................................................................................. 11 Pro Forma Assumptions............................................................................................................ 13 Initial Feasibility Analysis Results..................................................................................................... 18 Trends Influencing Feasibility ................................................................................................... 18 Feasibility Findings.................................................................................................................... 20 Policy and Market Scenarios............................................................................................................ 23 Inclusionary Policy Scenarios ................................................................................................... 24 Market Scenarios ...................................................................................................................... 26 In-Lieu Fee Analysis................................................................................................................... 29 POLICY CONSIDERATIONS AND FINDINGS.................................................................................32 Inclusionary Policies in Neighboring Jurisdictions .......................................................................... 32 Other Policy Considerations.............................................................................................................. 33 Applicability of the Policy .......................................................................................................... 33 HCD Review ............................................................................................................................... 35 MTC Transit Oriented Communities Requirements................................................................. 35 State Density Bonus Law.......................................................................................................... 36 Summary of Findings and Conclusions............................................................................................ 37 Findings...................................................................................................................................... 37 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... 37 APPENDIX I: FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY ASSUMPTIONS.......................................................................40 Cost Assumptions...................................................................................................................... 40
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 3 Prototype and Revenue Assumptions...................................................................................... 42 APPENDIX II: EXAMPLE POLICY OUTCOMES AND CONSIDERATIONS FOR IMPLEMENTATION......46 Policy Outcomes Assuming No State Density Bonus .............................................................. 46 Policy Outcomes with the State Density Bonus Law............................................................... 50
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 4 Table of Figures
Figure 1: Income Limits for Santa Clara County in 2025, by Category and Household Size .................7 Figure 2: Components of Financial Feasibility: Project Value and Project Cost Components ................8 Figure 3: Potential Impact of Inclusionary Policies on Financial Feasibility.............................................8 Figure 4: Residential Prototypes Used in Inclusionary Analysis for Los Altos Hills............................... 12 Figure 5: Summary of Cost Assumptions for Ownership Housing Pro Forma....................................... 14 Figure 6: Summary of Cost Assumptions for Rental Pro Forma............................................................. 15 Figure 7: Ownership Pro Forma Market Rate Unit Revenue Assumptions............................................ 16 Figure 8: Rental Pro Forma Market Rate Revenue Assumptions .......................................................... 16 Figure 9: Maximum AMI for Income Categories vs. "Achieved AMI" Assumption for Ownership and Rental Inclusionary Units.......................................................................................................................... 17 Figure 10: Maximum Sales Price for Below Market Rate Units by Income Level and Prototype, 2025 ................................................................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 11: Market Rate Rent in Los Altos Hills vs. Achieved Monthly Rent per Unit at Required Income Level, 2025 ............................................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 12: Santa Clara County Trends in Home Values, Construction Costs, and Multifamily Rents, 2020 to 2025 ........................................................................................................................................... 19 Figure 13: Monthly Santa Clara County Home Value Index vs. National Weekly 30-Year Mortgage Rate............................................................................................................................................................ 19 Figure 14: General Market Trends in Santa Clara County for 4- and 5-Star Rental Properties, Cap Rate vs. Value per Unit ............................................................................................................................. 20 Figure 15: Pro Forma Results per Unit for Ownership Housing in Los Altos Hills................................. 21 Figure 16: Residual Land Value vs. Land Costs per Unit for Ownership Housing in Los Altos Hills without Inclusionary Policy ....................................................................................................................... 22 Figure 17: Pro Forma Results per Unit for Rental Housing in Los Altos Hills........................................ 23 Figure 18: Residual Land Value vs. Land Costs per Unit for Rental Housing in Los Altos Hills........... 23 Figure 19: Residual Land Value per Unit vs. Land Costs per Unit in Los Altos Hills with a 15 Percent Inclusionary Requirement, by Income required – Ownership Units ...................................................... 25 Figure 20: Residual Land Value per Unit vs. Land Costs per Unit in Los Altos Hills by Inclusionary Scenario – Rental Units............................................................................................................................ 26 Figure 21: Sensitivity of Residual Land Value to Market Price in Los Altos Hills – Townhomes ......... 27 Figure 22: Sensitivity of Residual Land Value to Market Price in Los Altos Hills – 5-Story Condos.... 27
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 5 Figure 23: Residual Land Value vs. Land Costs per Unit for Small Scale Rental Apartments Los Altos Hills, with Current Market Conditions vs. Range of Likely Market Outcomes....................................... 28 Figure 24: Residual Land Value vs. Land Costs per Unit for 5-Story Rental Apartments in Los Altos Hills, with Current Market Conditions vs. Range of Possible Market Outcomes .................................. 29 Figure 25: Equivalent In-Lieu Fee per Net Square Foot Corresponding to Revenue Foregone from Inclusionary Policy in Los Altos Hills, by Scenario – Ownership Units ................................................... 30 Figure 26: Equivalent In-Lieu Fee per Net Square Foot Corresponding to Revenue Foregone from Inclusionary Policy in Los Altos Hills, by Scenario – Rental Units.......................................................... 31 Figure 27: Inclusionary Requirements in Santa Clara County Jurisdictions, as of 2025..................... 33 Figure 28: Detailed Cost Assumptions for Ownership Prototypes in Los Altos Hills............................. 40 Figure 29: Detailed Cost Assumptions for Rental Prototypes in Los Altos Hills.................................... 41 Figure 30: Los Altos Hills Municipal Fee Estimates - Ownership and Rental Prototypes..................... 42 Figure 31: Market Rate Ownership Pro Forma Revenue Assumptions, Lost Altos Hills....................... 42 Figure 32: Market Rate Rent per Unit Assumptions, Los Altos Hills...................................................... 43 Figure 33: Area Median Income and Income Limits for Santa Clara County, 2025............................. 43 Figure 34: Maximum Sales Price per Unit and Average BMR Price for Townhome Prototype in Santa Clara County, by BMR Income Level, 2025............................................................................................. 44 Figure 35: Maximum Sales Price per Unit and Average BMR Price for 5-Story Condos in Santa Clara County, by Income Level, 2025................................................................................................................ 44 Figure 36: Below Market Rate Rental Revenue Assumptions in Santa Clara County, 2025............... 45 Figure 37: Example Policy Outcomes by Scenario for Ownership ......................................................... 48 Figure 38: Example Policy Outcomes by Scenario for Rental ................................................................ 49 Figure 39: Density Bonus Amount Triggered by Provision of Affordable Units, By Income Level and Share of Units in Income Category........................................................................................................... 50 Figure 40: Example Policy Outcomes Assuming Utilization of the State Density Bonus Law by Scenario for Ownership ............................................................................................................................ 51 Figure 41: Example Policy Outcomes Assuming Utilization of the State Density Bonus Law by Scenario for Rental ................................................................................................................................... 52
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 6 Introduction
REPORT PURPOSE
This report is part of a collaborative effort by six jurisdictions in Santa Clara County to analyze and potentially implement new or revised affordable housing policy tools. The participants in the study include Gilroy, Los Altos Hills, Los Gatos, Mountain View, the City of Santa Clara, and Sunnyvale.
Together, these jurisdictions have commissioned Strategic Economics to perform a Grand Nexus Study. The study includes the required analysis and recommendations for:
• Residential impact fees charged on single-family units and “missing middle” developments of fewer than 10 units
• Inclusionary affordable housing requirements and associated in-lieu fees • Commercial linkage fees charged on non-residential development The Grand Nexus Study culminated in three reports to address each of the above policies: The Residential Impact Fee Study; The Residential Feasibility Study and Inclusionary Analysis (this report); and The Commercial Linkage Fee Study. Each jurisdiction has opted into one, two, or all three components of the study.
This report focuses on inclusionary housing policies in the Town of Los Altos Hills. Los Altos Hills does not currently have an inclusionary policy. The report describes how inclusionary policies work, how policy alternatives could impact the financial feasibility of new housing development, and how Los Altos Hills could leverage a possible inclusionary housing policy to increase affordable housing production within the town. The purpose of this report is to provide context and findings for the Town to review when considering a possible inclusionary housing policy.
BACKGROUND ON INCLUSIONARY HOUSING POLICIES
Inclusionary housing policies—also called “inclusionary zoning”—require market rate housing developers to set aside a percentage of units in a residential project and offer them at below market rates as deed-restricted affordable units. California law requires rental inclusionary policies to provide for alternative means of compliance with the policy, such as by paying a fee “in-lieu” of providing on-site units or by supporting the production of affordable units in some other way (such as a land donation). Inclusionary policies capture some of the economic value generated by building market rate housing in order to subsidize the development of affordable units. Inclusionary policies are one strategy local governments can use to create mixed income developments, provided the policy is met with onsite units.
Typically, inclusionary policies designate certain income requirements that developers must meet to fulfill the affordability requirement. These income categories are based on the area median income (AMI) of a region. Rents and sales prices are set at below market rate (BMR) levels so that households pay no more than 30 percent of the targeted income level for their income category. Each year, the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) publishes income limits and standard housing income categories for every county corresponding to its AMI. Figure 1 shows the income limits for Santa Clara County in 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 7 FIGURE 1: INCOME LIMITS FOR SANTA CLARA COUNTY IN 2025, BY CATEGORY AND HOUSEHOLD SIZE Extremely
Low
Very Low Low Median Moderate
Percent of AMI: 30% 50% 80% 100% 120%
Household Size
1 $42,200 $70,350 $111,700 $136,650 $164,000
2 $48,200 $80,400 $127,650 $156,150 $187,400
3 $54,250 $90,450 $143,600 $175,700 $210,850
4 $60,250 $100,450 $159,550 $195,200 $234,250
5 $65,100 $108,500 $172,350 $210,800 $253,000
Source: CA HCD, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
INCLUSIONARY POLICIES AND FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY
Because inclusionary policies seek to leverage the activities of the private market to produce affordable housing, they are reliant on the financial feasibility of market rate housing projects. Market rate development projects are only financially feasible when the market value of the project (based on total revenue) exceeds project costs and an investment return required by capital markets. As shown in Figure 2, financial feasibility is determined by the following factors:
• Total market value is determined by the revenues generated by the project. o For ownership projects, the market value consists of the sales prices the units can obtain.
o For rental projects, the market value of the project depends on the annual revenue it will generate and the current capitalization rate, which reflects overall project investment risk relative to alternative investments.
• Total project costs include hard costs, soft costs, investment return, and land costs. o Hard costs include materials and labor associated with physical construction of the building.
o Soft costs include indirect expenses such as architecture and engineering, taxes, insurance, financing costs, and municipal fees.
o Land costs refer to the price the developer pays to acquire the land. • Investment return refers to the required financial return on investment that a project must achieve to attract developer and lender investment. For ownership projects, required return is based on the net revenues from the initial sale of units. For rental projects, required return is based on the stabilized annual operating income of the development.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 8 FIGURE 2: COMPONENTS OF FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY: PROJECT VALUE AND PROJECT COST COMPONENTS Source: Strategic Economics, 2025.
Inclusionary policies have the benefit of potentially producing affordable housing units without using public forms of subsidy, but they may impact financial feasibility by reducing the market value of the project. Because inclusionary units generate less revenue than market rate units, substituting market rate units with inclusionary units will reduce the project’s total revenue. Figure 3 visualizes this impact on the project’s overall feasibility. In this example, a new project that may be feasible with all market rate units becomes infeasible if its total value is significantly reduced when a percentage of the units are offered at below market rates. However, projects that generate an investment return that is sufficiently high to absorb a reduction in value from the inclusionary policy, while still meeting a minimum market return, will remain financially feasible.
FIGURE 3: POTENTIAL IMPACT OF INCLUSIONARY POLICIES ON FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY Source: Strategic Economics, 2025.
An effective inclusionary policy will set affordability requirements high enough that they result in substantial additional affordable units, but not so high that they prevent the feasibility of market rate housing projects altogether. Thus, the purpose of conducting a feasibility analysis is to identify an inclusionary level that that allows projects to generate enough revenue to proceed while also providing affordable units.
Land Costs
Hard Costs
Soft Costs
Market Value
Investment
Return
Land Costs
Hard Costs
Soft Costs
Market Value
Market Value
Investment
Return
All Market Rate Units Market Rate + BMR
Units
Development Costs
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 9 Financial feasibility in market rate housing projects depends upon a variety of highly dynamic factors.
Project costs can fluctuate due to changes in construction labor, materials costs, interest rates, or a variety of other factors. Similarly, a project’s revenue can fluctuate significantly based on the availability of housing supply in the local market, changes in the attractiveness of a project’s location, or other factors impacting demand in the local market. Finally, the minimum investment return can fluctuate based on external factors such as interest rates in the macro economy or trends in real estate capital markets. The Policy and Market Scenarios discussion in the next section includes an analysis of market scenarios that address these fluctuations. Additionally, updating feasibility analyses periodically can help ensure that inclusionary policies are still able to function optimally as market conditions change.
REPORT ORGANIZATION
This report summarizes the impact of potential inclusionary policies on financial feasibility for housing projects and provides context for consideration of policy options. The remainder of this report is organized in two sections:
• Section II, Financial Feasibility Analysis, describes the current market for housing development in Los Altos Hills; the potential for market rate projects to support inclusionary housing; and the sensitivity of financial feasibility to market conditions. This section also discusses the relationship between inclusionary requirements and in-lieu fee levels. • Section III, Policy Considerations and Findings section discusses inclusionary housing policies used by Los Altos Hills’ neighboring jurisdictions and other state and local policy considerations influencing the implementation of inclusionary policies. The Summary of Findings and Conclusions portion of this section summarizes the final conclusions from all prior sections for consideration by the Town of Los Altos Hills.
The report also includes two appendices:
• Appendix I: Financial Feasibility Assumptions
• Appendix II: Example Policy Outcomes and Considerations for Implementation
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 10 Financial Feasibility Analysis
Strategic Economics conducted a financial feasibility analysis to test the viability of housing products under current market conditions and test a set of inclusionary policy scenarios under a range of market conditions. This analysis evaluated both ownership and rental housing project types. The results provide context that the Town of Los Altos Hills can use to assess and potentially modify its inclusionary policy to align with the Town’s affordable housing objectives in an evolving market.
This financial feasibility analysis section includes four parts. It begins with an overview of the methodology used for the feasibility analysis, including details on the modeling approach and the types of housing tested in the analysis. This section then shows the results of the financial feasibility modeling for all housing types in Los Altos Hills—both with the existing inclusionary policy and under a variety of market and inclusionary policy scenarios. The financial feasibility analysis concludes with an overview of in-lieu fees, explaining how they are calculated and how inclusionary requirements impact in-lieu fee levels.
METHODOLOGY
Analysis Approach
Strategic Economics evaluated financial feasibility for housing projects in Los Altos Hills using a static “pro forma” model. A pro forma is a real estate finance model used to aggregate assumptions about development costs, revenue, and financing conditions to evaluate the financial feasibility of new housing projects. A static pro forma—a simplified version of pro forma that does not model developer cash flows over time—is a standard approach for supporting broadly applicable policy and planning decisions.
Applying this pro forma model to residential projects and inclusionary policies in the Los Altos Hills required three steps:
• Develop a set of residential development “prototypes” to evaluate inclusionary policies for multi-unit development across a range of product types typical of recent housing construction in Santa Clara County;
• Develop pro forma assumptions for these prototypes, including hard construction costs, soft costs, and revenue expectations for Los Altos Hills. Strategic Economics based these assumptions on market research, interviews with developers active in Santa Clara County, and other recent experience with pro forma analysis in the San Francisco Bay Area. • Use the pro forma model to test the financial performance of each prototype under a variety of market and policy scenarios.
EVALUATING FEASIBILITY
Strategic Economics measured the financial performance of each prototype using residual land value analysis. In residual land value analysis, the land cost estimate is initially taken out of the equation.
Instead, the analysis begins by estimating project market value, hard costs, and soft costs, as well as a minimum acceptable return for a typical developer pursuing the project.
This calculation requires identifying six key metrics for feasibility:
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 11 • Project Revenue is the primary indicator of market value for the project, based on expected income or sales proceeds.
o For ownership projects, this is the project’s total net sales proceeds. o For rental projects, this is the project’s annual net operating income (NOI), which is defined as the annual revenue from rent, less vacancy and operating costs. • Target Return is the level of return on investment that a project must achieve for the developer and lenders to determine that it is a worthwhile investment. o For ownership projects, this metric used is return on cost. Return on cost is the ratio of net project value to total development cost.
o For rental projects, the primary metric is yield on cost. Yield on cost is the ratio of NOI to total development cost.1
• Supportable Development Costs are the highest development cost for which the project would still be viable given project revenue and the minimum target return. o For ownership products, the supportable development cost is each project’s projected net sales proceeds, less the required return on cost.
o For rental projects, the supportable development cost is the project’s projected NOI divided by its minimum target yield on cost.
• Total Development Costs (Excluding Land) are the sum of hard construction costs, soft costs, municipal fees, financing costs, and contingency.
• Residual Land Value (RLV) is calculated by subtracting total development cost (excluding land) from supportable development cost. The residual land value that remains, therefore, represents the maximum a developer could pay for land while still achieving the minimum necessary return.
• Residual land value can be compared to Typical Land Costs to evaluate feasibility. Typical land costs are the market average costs (calculated on a per square foot basis) for a vacant property on which the housing project could be built.
A project is financially infeasible when its residual land value is less than zero. If its residual land value is greater than zero but less than the typical market value for land, the project may be feasible because land values tend to vary significantly within a market depending on a range of factors. If the residual land value is at or greater than a typical land value, it is likely to be feasible.
Prototypes
The development prototypes used in the feasibility analysis are generalized examples of new housing, representing a broad range of multi-unit housing projects typical of recent development trends in northern Santa Clara County. This study used four residential prototypes to evaluate financial feasibility. The set of prototypes in the inclusionary study overlaps with the set in the residential impact fee study, which considered small scale multi-unit as well as build-to-suit single-family homes.
The prototypes used in the Los Altos Hills’ inclusionary analysis range in density from 20 to 73 units per acre, and from three to eight stories in height. Figure 4 provides a summary of each of the five 1 For a development project to obtain financing, its yield on cost must be higher than its capitalization rate—the ratio of NOI to project value.
In other words, lenders and developers expect the completed project to be worth more than its total development costs. The relationship between yield on cost and cap rates varies based on financing conditions and perceived market risk.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 12 prototypes. This includes two ownership product types and three rental product types, as described below:
Ownership Prototypes
• Townhomes: this prototype represents a development with attached, single-family units built at a density of 20 units per acre. These units generally include between two and four-bedrooms, averaging 1,710 square feet, and are built over a private garage. • 5-Story Condos: this prototype includes four stories of for-sale flats, built at a density of 52 units per acre, over one story of podium parking and one story of parking underground. Units in this building would range from one-bedroom to four-bedrooms, for an average unit size of 1,382 square feet. This prototype includes two parking spaces per unit.
Rental Prototypes
• Small Scale Rental Apartments: this prototype is a three-story multifamily building at a density of 36 units per acre. The prototype contains a mix of studio to three-bedroom units, with an average unit size of 955 square feet. Parking is a combination of surface and tuck-under parking with two spaces per unit.
• 5-Story Rental Apartments: this prototype is a similar building type to the 5-story Condo prototype, but with smaller units and a higher residential density of 73 units per acre. This prototype includes a mix of units from studios to three-bedrooms, with an average unit size of 891 square feet. This prototype includes 1.75 parking spaces per unit.
FIGURE 4: RESIDENTIAL PROTOTYPES USED IN INCLUSIONARY ANALYSIS FOR LOS ALTOS HILLS Townhomes 5-Story
Condos
Small Scale
Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Tenure Ownership Ownership Rental Rental
Parcel Size (acres) 1.5 1.8 1.5 1.8
Number of Stories 3 5 3 5
Total Gross Square Feet 50,850 148,000 60,647 133,059
Retail Square Feet 0 0 0 0
Number of Units 30 90 54 128
Average Unit Size (square
feet) 1,710 1,382 955 891
Bedroom Types 2-BD to 4-BD 1-BD to 4-BD Studio to 3-
BD Studio to 3-BD
Units per Acre 20 51 36 73
Parking Format Private
Garages
Underground
+ Podium
Surface +
Tuck-Under
Underground
+ Podium
Residential Parking Ratio 2.00 2.00 2.00 1.75
Residential Parking
Spaces 60 180 108 224
Retail Parking Spaces 0 0 0 0
Source: Strategic Economics, 2025; Cities in Santa Clara County, 2025; CoStar, 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 13 Pro Forma Assumptions
COST AND RETURN ASSUMPTIONS
Strategic Economics estimated development costs based on interviews with developers and general contractors experienced with residential development in Santa Clara County, as well as reviews of market data and budgets for other development projects throughout the Bay Area. As noted earlier, the main cost categories for development include hard costs, soft costs, and land costs:
• Hard costs refer to the direct construction costs, such as materials and construction labor, used to physically prepare the site for development, construct the building, and perform all site work including site circulation, utilities, and landscaping. • Soft costs include all indirect expenses required to complete a development project, such as architecture, engineering, consulting, legal fees, taxes, municipal fees, and insurance. In addition to these costs, developers must account for the cost of financing a construction loan, and a contingency for unexpected expenses.
• Land costs refer to the cost of acquiring land for development. In residual land value analysis, the land cost is calculated last, as the highest land cost the developer could afford to pay and still have the project pencil. Strategic Economics also estimated “typical land costs” for each prototype to compare against the residual land value and assess feasibility. Because higher density, compact housing types such as townhomes, condominiums, and rental apartments remain untested by the market in Los Altos hills, the “typical” cost of land for the studied prototypes is more uncertain than in other markets where recent land sales for similar developments can be observed. Strategic Economics estimated land costs in Los Altos Hills by inferring from more general patterns in land values in Santa Clara County and from typical industry standard ranges in land costs as a percentage of overall project value.
Strategic Economics modeled the required investment return as follows:
• For ownership projects, required return is based on the net revenues from the initial sale of units (referred to as return on cost).
• For rental projects, required return is based on the stabilized annual operating income of the development (referred to as yield on cost).
The Townhome and Condo prototypes assume similar wood frame construction methods for the residential portions of their buildings, but the Condo prototype also includes significant added costs of above- and below-ground parking, mechanical, and utility systems. These differences translate to a higher cost of construction of $400 per residential square foot. Figure 5 provides a high-level overview of cost assumptions used to evaluate financial feasibility for ownership product types. The condo prototype also has higher construction financing costs due to its longer construction time. More detailed cost assumptions for these prototypes can be found in the Appendix, in Figure 28.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 14 FIGURE 5: SUMMARY OF COST ASSUMPTIONS FOR OWNERSHIP HOUSING PRO FORMA Unit of measure Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Land Costs per square foot $125 $125
Hard Costs
Demolition and Site Work per sq. ft. land $40 $40
Building Area Construction per gross sq. ft. $275 $400
Parking
Private Garages
N/A –
Included in
building area
Structured/Podium per space $50,000
Underground per space $80,000
Soft Costs
Arch, Eng., Consulting, Taxes, Insurance,
Legal, and Other Soft Costs
(excluding fees, contingency)
% of hard costs 18.0% 18.0%
Municipal Fees per unit $106,385 $100,404
Contingency % of hard + soft costs 5.0% 5.0%
Financing Costs % of hard + soft costs 4.2% 6.2%
Developer Return
Target Developer Return-on-cost % of total dev costs 15.0% 15.0% Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 2025.
Rental prototypes have similar differences in construction costs related to their number of stories, parking format, and inclusion of retail components. Figure 6 summarizes development costs for each of the two rental prototypes. The 5-Story Apartments cost slightly more to build than the Small Scale Apartments because of differences in height and parking format. Further, projects with smaller average unit sizes cost more to build on a square foot basis because they require a higher density of appliances, plumbing, and electrical systems. The five-story rental prototype typically also requires longer construction periods—leading to larger financing costs than those assumed for the Small Scale Apartments. Lastly, the assumption for typical land value for each prototype was based on its locational value and zoned development capacity. Further details on cost assumptions are shown in the Appendix, in Figure 29.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 15 FIGURE 6: SUMMARY OF COST ASSUMPTIONS FOR RENTAL PRO FORMA Unit of measure
Small Scale Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Land Costs
Land Costs per square foot $125 $125
Hard Costs
Demolition and Site Work per sq. ft. land $40 $40
Building Area Construction
Residential - Type V per gross sq. ft. $290 $310
Parking
Surface per space $10,000
Structured/Podium per space $50,000
Underground per space $80,000
Tuck-under per space $10,000
Soft Costs
Arch, Eng., Consulting, Taxes, Insurance, Legal,
and Other Soft Costs
(excluding fees, contingency)
% of hard costs 13.0% 13.0%
Municipal Fees per unit $75,783 $75,559
Contingency % of hard + soft costs 5.0% 5.0%
Financing
Total Financing Cost % of hard + soft costs 5.4% 6.2%
Developer Share
Developer Overhead Fee % of hard + soft costs 3.0% 3.0% Target Developer Yield-on-Cost % of total dev costs 5.5% 5.5% Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 2025.
MARKET RATE REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS
Because there are currently no compact rental or ownership developments in Los Altos Hills, there was little directly comparable market data on which to base market rents and sales price assumptions for these product types. In developing these assumptions, Strategic Economics reviewed similar developments in other parts of Santa Clara County, but actual rents and sales values in Los Altos Hills have yet to be tested by the market. The sensitivity of the feasibility results to market conditions is discussed in more detail in the next section.
Strategic Economics analyzed recent property sales data from Redfin and CoStar alongside current property listings and input from local developers to determine market rate revenue assumptions for ownership products. Because there are no examples of recent townhome or condo sales within Los Altos Hills, Strategic Economics examined townhome and condo sales prices in nearby jurisdictions and single-family home sales in Los Altos Hills to estimate sales prices for these product types within the town.
Ownership revenue assumptions are shown in Figure 7. Strategic Economics assumed that typical townhome sales prices in Los Altos Hills would range from $1.7 million for a two-bedroom unit to $2.0 million for a four-bedroom unit. Typical condo prices in Los Altos Hills were assumed to range from $1.2 million for a one-bedroom unit to $2.1 million for a four-bedroom unit. Detailed revenue assumptions for ownership projects can be found in the Appendix in Figure 31.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 16 FIGURE 7: OWNERSHIP PRO FORMA MARKET RATE UNIT REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS Unit of measure Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Average Sales Value per unit $1,880,833 $1,698,901
Marketing Expense % of Sales Price 5% 5%
Net Revenue $1,786,792 $1,613,956
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Market rate rent assumptions were derived from three sources of information. Strategic Economics analyzed current rental listings in comparable apartment projects; collected input from developers; and analyzed market trends from CoStar to identify typical rents in the area surrounding Los Altos Hills for similar rental types. Figure 8 provides a summary of revenue assumptions for each prototype, including the average monthly rent and assumptions for vacancy rate, operating costs, and capitalization rate. Capitalization rate (cap rate) refers to the ratio of net annual operating income (gross maximum rent, less vacancy and operating costs) to the project’s total market value. Strategic Economics assumed that all rental prototypes have the same vacancy, operating expense ratio, and cap rate, but average monthly rent for each prototype differs according to unit size and building format.
The units in the 5-Story Apartments are smaller than those in the Small Scale Apartments but can likely command higher rents per square foot, leading to higher average monthly rents per unit. Detailed revenue assumptions for rental projects can be found in the Appendix in Figure 32.
FIGURE 8: RENTAL PRO FORMA MARKET RATE REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS Unit of measure
Small Scale
Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Rent Assumptions
Average Unit Size Square feet 955 891
Monthly Rent per Square Foot $/sq. ft. $4.61 $4.81
Average Monthly Rent per unit $4,019 $4,310
Other Revenue Assumptions
Vacancy Rate % of Units 5% 5%
Operating Expense
% of Market Rate
Revenue 30% 30%
Capitalization Rate 4.50% 4.50%
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Apartment Websites, 2025; CoStar, 2025.
BELOW MARKET RATE REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS
Strategic Economics also modeled the below market rate (BMR) rents and sales prices associated with inclusionary units as appropriate to each inclusionary policy scenario. These units were priced at a level such that qualifying households pay no more than 30 percent of their monthly income on housing costs. To determine whether households qualify for affordable housing, HCD publishes a table for each county that lists the county’s “area median income” and household income categories based on household size. This income table (shown in the Appendix in Figure 33) delineates the maximum income that qualifies as very low-, low-, and moderate-income for each household size. The inclusionary policy designates what share of units must be provided to households in each income
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 17 range. The maximum revenue each inclusionary unit could generate is tied to the top of this range, although in practice this amount is somewhat lower than the maximum.
Expected revenues were calculated using the income limits, the assumed share of income that can be spent on housing and estimates for other monthly costs. For ownership housing, other monthly costs might include utility costs, property taxes and insurance, private mortgage insurance, and homeowners’ association (HOA) fees. For rental housing, this generally includes any utility costs not included in the rent. Because household incomes vary for households qualifying in each income category, Strategic Economics assumed that the average AMI level of qualifying households would be below the maximum allowable AMI in the income category. Figure 9 shows the assumed percentage of AMI used as an average in each income category for ownership and rental inclusionary units.
FIGURE 9: MAXIMUM AMI FOR INCOME CATEGORIES VS. "ACHIEVED AMI" ASSUMPTION FOR OWNERSHIP AND RENTAL
INCLUSIONARY UNITS
Income Category
Maximum
% of AMI
Assumed % of
AMI for
Ownership
Units
Assumed % of
AMI for Rental
Units
Moderate-Income 120% 110% 110%
Median-Income 100% 90% 90%
Low-Income 80% 70% 60%
Very Low-Income 50% N/A 50%
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025.
Note: Achieved AMI reflects the likelihood that not all households qualifying in an income category could afford a rent or sales price based on the maximum income level within an income category. The percentages used correspond with California Health and Safety Code guidance on affordable rent and sales price levels for Very Low, Low, and Moderate-Income categories.
Though market rate rents and sales prices exceed affordable rents and prices for most income categories, market rate rents are likely to be affordable to moderate-income households. Figure 10 shows achieved sales prices for BMR units as modeled in the ownership pro forma models. For most income categories and prototypes, BMR units would achieve less than one-sixth of the market rate sales price in Los Altos Hills. Figure 11 shows achieved monthly rents for BMR units compared to market rate rents. For rental prototypes, BMR units could theoretically achieve rents that are close to market rate levels for Median-Income units, and that exceed market rate rents for Moderate-Income units. However, when modeling feasibility for inclusionary policies, Strategic Economics assumed that BMR rents would be no less than the achieved rents shown in Figure 11 and no more than the market rate rent for each unit type. Figure 34 and Figure 35 in the Appendix show more details on affordable sales prices and rent calculations.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 18 FIGURE 10: MAXIMUM SALES PRICE FOR BELOW MARKET RATE UNITS BY INCOME LEVEL AND PROTOTYPE, 2025 Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Average Market Rate Price per Unit $1,880,833 $1,698,901
Below Market Sales Price per Unit (Income Level)
Low (70% Achieved AMI) $299,260 $285,259
Median (90% Achieved AMI) $426,448 $403,744
Moderate (110% Achieved AMI) $586,061 $522,229
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025; CA HCD, 2025; Redfin, 2025; Freddie Mac, 2025; Alta Housing, 2025; Ownwell, 2025.
Notes: Accounts for share of income spent on housing costs (30%), current interest rates, monthly utility costs, taxes, insurance, and HOA costs. Achieved sales price reflects likely average for units in each income category in an inclusionary project.
FIGURE 11: MARKET RATE RENT IN LOS ALTOS HILLS VS. ACHIEVED MONTHLY RENT PER UNIT AT REQUIRED INCOME LEVEL, 2025
Small Scale Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Average Market Rate Rent per Unit $4,019 $4,310
Below Market Monthly Rent per Unit (Income Level)
50% AMI (Very Low) $2,018 $1,997
60% AMI (Low) $2,371 $2,346
90% AMI (Median) $3,616 $3,576
110% AMI (Moderate) – based on calculation $4,445 $4,395 110% AMI (Moderate) Used in Model – based on market rate rent $4,019 $4,310 Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025; CA HCD, 2025.
Note: This table shows achieved monthly rent at each income level based on 30 percent of monthly income at the specified share of AMI, less a utility allowance. Because the calculated rents for 110% AMI households exceed market rate rents, market rate rents were used in the model to estimate project revenue for projects requiring moderate-income units.
INITIAL FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS RESULTS
The current feasibility outlook in Los Altos Hills is a product of both the strength of the town’s housing market and recent trends on a regional or national level that are influencing construction costs and housing demand. This section provides an overview of recent regional trends before presenting findings on ownership and rental project feasibility in Los Altos Hills.
Trends Influencing Feasibility
Home values in Santa Clara County largely kept pace with construction cost inflation over the past five years, while multifamily rent growth fell behind costs. The years 2022 and 2023 were a period of high rates of inflation throughout the national economy. As shown in Figure 12, construction costs across California rose by approximately 46 percent between 2020 and 2025. Home values in Santa Clara County increased by nearly as much (40 percent) over the same period. In comparison, Santa Clara County’s multifamily rents grew by only 27 percent over the five-year period—far less than the construction cost increases developers have experienced in the multifamily construction industry.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 19 FIGURE 12: SANTA CLARA COUNTY TRENDS IN HOME VALUES, CONSTRUCTION COSTS, AND MULTIFAMILY RENTS, 2020 TO 2025
Sources: CoStar, 2025; CA EDD, 2025; ENR, 2025; Zillow, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
Note: This chart shows the Zillow Home Value Index for Santa Clara County on an annual average basis, but doing so simplifies the monthly fluctuations in home value. For this reason, the trend shown here does not entirely match the trend shown in Figure 13, despite being based on the same data.
Santa Clara County home values increased rapidly from 2020 through mid-2022, but higher interest rates limited home value growth from late 2022 through 2025. Figure 13 shows monthly changes in the same home index for Santa Clara County shown Figure 12, and compares them to weekly fluctuations in the national 30-year mortgage rate over the past five years. This chart shows that mortgage interest rates doubled nationally, from 3.7 percent to 7.8 percent, between 2020 and 2023 and remained above 6.5 percent through mid-2025. Rising interest rates nationally moderated rising home prices in Santa Clara County, which grew by less than one percent between July of 2022 and July of 2025.
FIGURE 13: MONTHLY SANTA CLARA COUNTY HOME VALUE INDEX VS. NATIONAL WEEKLY 30-YEAR MORTGAGE RATE Sources: Freddie Mac, 2025; Zillow, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
35.0%
40.0%
45.0%
50.0%
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Cumulative % Growth Since
2020
California Construction Costs
Santa Clara County Annual
Home Value Index
Santa Clara County Annual
Multifamily Rents
-40%
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Cumulative % Change Since
Beginning of 2020
Weekly Freddie Mac 30-YR
Mortgage Rate
Monthly Zillow Home Value Index,
Santa Clara County
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 20 The value per unit of multifamily properties in Santa Clara County decreased between 2021 and 2025.
As shown in Figure 14, the average market value of four and five-star multifamily properties in Santa Clara County fell from a high of $750,000 per unit in 2021 to $570,000 in 2024, with a modest recovery for 2025 to date. Capitalization rates (which describe the ratio between a property’s annual income and its market value) increased in 2023, indicating a decline in investor confidence in multifamily investments. This decline was in response to higher interest rates at the national level and a softening of the rental market in Santa Clara County and many other parts of the San Francisco Bay Area.
FIGURE 14: GENERAL MARKET TRENDS IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY FOR 4- AND 5-STAR RENTAL PROPERTIES, CAP RATE VS. VALUE PER UNIT
Sources: CoStar, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
As a result of these recent market trends, multifamily rental projects are much less financially feasible in 2025 than they were in 2020, and ownership projects are slightly less feasible than they were in 2020. Multifamily rental project developers face much higher construction costs in 2025 than they did in 2020, with lower average market values per unit; this makes it much more difficult to develop a viable project in 2025. Ownership projects also face higher interest rates and higher construction costs in 2025 than they did in 2020. However, the market values for ownership units in Santa Clara County have mostly kept pace with construction costs over the past five years.
Feasibility Findings
The feasibility analysis results presented in this section reflect the market trends identified above. This section begins with an explanation of feasibility findings for ownership prototypes, followed by the feasibility results for rental prototypes.
FEASIBILITY OF OWNERSHIP PROTOTYPES
Both ownership prototypes are currently feasible in Los Altos Hills. Figure 15 shows the results of the pro forma analysis for both prototypes before considering any inclusionary policy scenario. Figure 16 compares the residual land value per unit for each ownership prototype with Strategic Economics’ best estimate for market land values for these prototypes in Los Altos Hills. The Townhome prototype would generate a residual land value of approximately $720,000 per unit with no inclusionary requirement.
Although the lack of market data for high density development in Los Altos Hills creates relative $650,000
$750,000
$700,000
$570,000 $570,000 $610,000
3.6% 3.4% 3.7%
4.5% 4.5% 4.4%
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Value per Unit
Cap Rate
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 21 uncertainty in this result, the residual land value exceeds the typical range of market land values in other parts of Santa Clara County. The 5-Story Condo prototype would generate a residual land value of approximately $225,000 per unit, which also exceeds the estimate for typical land costs for condo projects. Unlike the Townhome prototype, the residual land value for the 5-Story Condo prototype is more in the typical range of land costs in other parts of the County, suggesting that the performance of this product is not as strong.
FIGURE 15: PRO FORMA RESULTS PER UNIT FOR OWNERSHIP HOUSING IN LOS ALTOS HILLS Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Revenue per Unit
Gross Revenue (Average) $1,880,833 $1,698,901
Less Marketing -$94,042 -$84,945
Total Sales Proceeds $1,786,792 $1,613,956
Development Costs per Unit
Hard Costs $557,370 $812,629
Soft Costs (Excluding Fees) $100,327 $146,273
Other Municipal Fees $106,385 $100,404
Financing & Contingency $69,779 $119,693
Total Development Cost $833,860 $1,178,999
Residual Land Value per Unit
Total Sales Proceeds $1,786,792 $1,613,956
Target Return on Cost 15% 15%
Supportable Development Cost $1,553,732 $1,403,440
Total Development Cost $833,860 $1,178,999
Residual Land Value $719,872 $224,441
Feasibility (per unit)
Residual Land Value $719,872 $224,441
Typical Land Cost $272,250 $104,712
Typical Land Cost per S.F. $125 $125
Feasibility Result
Feasible: RLV exceeds land
cost
Feasible: RLV exceeds land
cost
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 22 FIGURE 16: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT FOR OWNERSHIP HOUSING IN LOS ALTOS HILLS WITHOUT
INCLUSIONARY POLICY
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
FEASIBILITY OF RENTAL PROTOTYPES
Strategic Economics found that neither of the two rental prototypes are feasible in Los Altos Hills under current market conditions. Figure 17 provides a summary of pro forma results for each prototype and Figure 18 visualizes the feasibility result. As Figure 17 shows, neither of the rental project types currently support a positive residual land value---indicating that neither rental prototype could afford to pay for land and remain feasible in Los Altos Hills. Of course, both costs and revenue projections can change as market conditions change; because development costs grew nearly 20 percent more than multifamily rents over the past five years (as shown in Figure 12) while cap rates increased (as shown in Figure 14), a multifamily project that was viable in Santa Clara County in 2020 would be challenging to develop in 2025.
$0
$100,000
$200,000
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
$700,000
$800,000
Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Residual Land Value per Unit
Residual Land Value - All Market Rate Units Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 23 FIGURE 17: PRO FORMA RESULTS PER UNIT FOR RENTAL HOUSING IN LOS ALTOS HILLS Small Scale Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Net Operating Income per Unit $31,344 $33,620
Development Costs per Unit
Hard Costs $394,097 $459,824
Soft Costs (Excluding Fees) $51,233 $59,777
Other Municipal Fees $75,783 $75,559
Financing, Contingency & Developer Overhead $60,830 $75,376 Total Development Cost $581,942 $670,536
Residual Land Value per Unit
Total Net Operating Income $31,344 $33,620
Target Yield on Cost 5.5% 5.5%
Supportable Development Cost $569,899 $611,270
Total Development Cost $581,942 $670,536
Residual Land Value -$12,043 -$59,266
Feasibility (per Unit)
Residual Land Value -$12,043 -$59,266
Typical Land Costs per Unit $151,250 $74,443
Typical Land Costs per S.F. $125 $125
Feasibility Result
Infeasible; RLV is
negative
Infeasible: RLV is
negative
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; CoStar, 2025.
FIGURE 18: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT FOR RENTAL HOUSING IN LOS ALTOS HILLS Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; CoStar, 2025.
Note: Current Policy requires 15 percent of units to be affordable, with an average income level of 100 percent of AMI. Because achieved rents are unlikely to equal the maximum allowable rent, this policy was tested assuming the project could achieve 90 percent AMI rents.
POLICY AND MARKET SCENARIOS
The previous section describes feasibility under current conditions in Los Altos Hills; this section considers alternative policies that may better align with the Town’s objectives and optimize the production of affordable units in future years. In addition, Strategic Economics recommends that local governments considering a new or updated affordable housing policy anticipate the potential impact ($100,000)
($50,000)
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
Small Scale Rental Apartments 5-Story Rental Apartments Residual Land Value
Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 24 of the policy under a range of market conditions, as it is difficult for local inclusionary ordinances to keep current with evolving market cycles.
Strategic Economics performed scenario testing to evaluate how the prototypes would perform with different inclusionary requirements and market conditions. Strategic Economics also calculated an equivalent in-lieu fee associated with each scenario. The purpose of this section is to help Los Altos Hills select inclusionary and in-lieu fee requirements that could remain relevant as market conditions change.
Inclusionary Policy Scenarios
This section describes the impact of an inclusionary policy on financial feasibility. Inclusionary policies consist of two main components: the percentage of onsite affordable units required, and the income group(s) targeted by the policy. The scenarios presented below assume an onsite inclusionary requirement of between ten and 15 percent, while testing the sensitivity of the results to different income levels. The findings and conclusions section includes a discussion of setting the percentage onsite requirement and the targeted income levels.
Strategic Economics tested the following inclusionary policy scenarios:
• Ownership:
o Scenario A: 15 Percent (all Moderate-Income)
o Scenario B: 15 Percent (all Low-Income)
o Scenario C: 15 Percent (7.5 Percent Low-Income and 7.5 Percent Moderate-Income) • Rental:
o Scenario A: 10 Percent (5 Percent Very Low-Income and 5 Percent Low-Income) o Scenario B: 15 Percent (7.5 Percent Very Low-Income and 7.5 Percent Low-Income) o Scenario C: 10 Percent (5 Percent Extremely Low-Income and 5 Percent Very Low-Income)
o Scenario D: 12 Percent (4 Percent Extremely Low-Income, 4 Percent Very Low-Income, and 4 Percent Low-Income)
SCENARIO RESULTS
The tested policy scenarios for ownership housing are financially feasible for the Townhome prototype but marginally infeasible for the 5-Story Condo prototype. Figure 19 shows the residual land value per unit for both ownership prototypes with a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (Scenario A); 15 percent low-income requirement (Scenario B); and 15 percent requirement with a mix of both incomes (Scenario C). As discussed in the methodology section (Figure 10), there is a significant gap between new market rate home values and the below market sales prices for moderate- and low-income buyers.
As a result, each policy scenario substantially reduces project revenues for both the Townhome and Condo prototypes; this is reflected in the drop in residual land values for each policy scenario compared to the result with no inclusionary requirement. However, for the Townhome prototype, each scenario still yields more than $500,000 per unit in residual land value, which is likely sufficient to
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 25 pay for land for such a project in Los Altos Hills. By contrast, the residual land value for the 5-Story Condo prototype drops below $100,000 per unit in each scenario—the estimated typical market price of land for that prototype. However, the policy scenarios may still be feasible for condominium developments if the actual land price is lower. Although townhomes are the higher-performing product type, condominium flats may still be built as part of a development project that contains a mix of product types including both horizontally attached and stacked units that may be delivered in a different building type than the 5-Story Condo prototype, which includes a parking podium at significant additional cost.
FIGURE 19: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE PER UNIT VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT IN LOS ALTOS HILLS WITH A 15 PERCENT INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENT, BY INCOME REQUIRED – OWNERSHIP UNITS Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Note: Scenario A refers to a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI). Scenario B refers to a 15 percent low-income requirement (tested at 70% AMI). Scenario C refers to a 15 percent requirement split between low-income and moderate-income.
Because the rental prototypes are infeasible under current market conditions even without an inclusionary policy, the tested inclusionary policies are unlikely to be operative until market conditions improve. Figure 20 summarizes this result. This figure illustrates that—under current conditions—rental prototypes would generate approximately $38,000 to $66,000 less residual land value per unit under the tested scenarios compared to a scenario with no requirement. However, these differences would likely change as market rate rents, development costs, and area median income change over time.
The next subsection includes findings on how changes in market conditions might support an inclusionary policy.
$555,415 $523,894 $542,436
$719,872
$78,636 $49,273 $66,587
$224,441
$0
$100,000
$200,000
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
$700,000
$800,000
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
No Requirement
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
No Requirement
Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Residual Land Value per Unit
Residual Land Value per Unit Typical Land Costs per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 26 FIGURE 20: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE PER UNIT VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT IN LOS ALTOS HILLS BY INCLUSIONARY SCENARIO – RENTAL UNITS
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; CoStar, 2025.
Note:
• Scenario A refers to a five percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a five percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario B refers to a 7.5 percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a 7.5 percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario C refers to a five percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI) and a five percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI).
• Scenario D refers to a four percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI), a four percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI), and a four percent low-income requirement (60% AMI).
Market Scenarios
This section tests the sensitivity of the feasibility results to changes in market conditions. The current pro forma results rely upon assumptions for development costs, return thresholds, sales prices, rents, and land costs which are subject to change over time. This section describes how some of the most important market factors impact the viability of inclusionary policies.
Strategic Economics tested the sensitivity of the feasibility results by varying market factors that influence revenue, while holding development costs constant. For the ownership prototypes, Strategic Economics tested a range of market prices above and below current prices. For rental prototypes, Strategic Economics evaluated a range of scenarios that includes increases and decreases in market rents combined with variations in the market capitalization rates that determine the value of development.
($49,843)
($68,743)($62,363)($65,955)
($12,043)
($103,595)
($125,760)($115,970) ($120,914)
($59,266)
($150,000)
($100,000)
($50,000)
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
Scenario D
No Requirement
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
Scenario D
No Requirement
Small Scale Rental Apartments 5-Story Rental Apartments Residual Land Value per Unit
Residual Land Value Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 27 The Townhome prototype could support any of the inclusionary requirements under current market conditions, but Scenarios B and C would become marginally infeasible with a twenty percent reduction in price. Figure 21 shows the feasibility of the Townhome prototype under various market scenarios, comparing a prototype with all market rate units to each of the inclusionary scenarios.
FIGURE 21: SENSITIVITY OF RESIDUAL LAND VALUE TO MARKET PRICE IN LOS ALTOS HILLS – TOWNHOMES Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Note: Scenario A refers to a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI). Scenario B refers to a 15 percent low-income requirement (tested at 70% AMI). Scenario C refers to a 15 percent requirement split between low-income and moderate-income.
The 5-Story Condo prototype could support all three inclusionary policy scenarios with minor increases in sales prices. This finding is illustrated in Figure 22. If the market turns out to support higher sales prices than assumed in the pro forma model, the inclusionary policy scenarios may be feasible for condo projects under current market conditions.
FIGURE 22: SENSITIVITY OF RESIDUAL LAND VALUE TO MARKET PRICE IN LOS ALTOS HILLS – 5-STORY CONDOS Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Note: Scenario A refers to a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI). Scenario B refers to a 15 percent low-income requirement (tested at 70% AMI). Scenario C refers to a 15 percent requirement split between low-income and moderate-income. $0
$200,000
$400,000
$600,000
$800,000
$1,000,000
$1,200,000
Price Decline (-20%)
Scenario
Current Market Price Growth (+10%)
Scenario
Price Growth (+20%)
Scenario
Value per Unit
RLV: All Market Rate Units RLV: Scenario A RLV: Scenario B RLV: Scenario C Typical Land Cost per Unit
-$300,000
-$200,000
-$100,000
$0
$100,000
$200,000
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
Price Decline (-20%)
Scenario
Current Market Price Growth (+10%)
Scenario
Price Growth (+20%)
Scenario
Value per Unit
RLV: All Market Rate Units RLV: Scenario A RLV: Scenario B RLV: Scenario C Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 28 While inclusionary policies would have a modest impact on the financial feasibility outcomes of rental prototypes in Los Altos Hills, it is unlikely that most apartment projects will be feasible in the near future due to broader challenges. Figure 23 shows the range of likely market outcomes for Small Scale Apartments under each inclusionary scenario. In comparison, Figure 24 shows the range of likely market outcomes for 5-Story Apartments. These figures demonstrate that 5-Story Apartments are more likely to become feasible in the future than Small Scale Apartments—particularly if no inclusionary requirement is applied to these project types. However, multifamily rental projects of all kinds face high development costs and financing challenges currently, making it unlikely that either prototype would become feasible without significant changes in market conditions.
FIGURE 23: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT FOR SMALL SCALE RENTAL APARTMENTS LOS ALTOS HILLS, WITH CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS VS. RANGE OF LIKELY MARKET OUTCOMES Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Santa Clara Housing Authority, 2025.
Note: Range of Market Outcomes refers to a range of “weak market” vs. “strong market” fluctuations from current market conditions, based on a ten percent change in in market rate rents and the typical range of cap rates observed in Santa Clara County over the past ten years.
The high end of the range of market outcomes was based on a 3.75 percent cap rate and ten percent rent increase. The low end of the range of market outcomes was based on a 5.5 percent cap rate and a ten percent rent decrease.
Note:
• Scenario A refers to a five percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a five percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario B refers to a 7.5 percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a 7.5 percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario C refers to a five percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI) and a five percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI).
• Scenario D refers to a four percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI), a four percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI), and a four percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). ($250,000)
($200,000)
($150,000)
($100,000)
($50,000)
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
Residual Land Value per Unit
Inclusionary Scenario
Range of Market Outcomes
Current Market
Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 29 FIGURE 24: RESIDUAL LAND VALUE VS. LAND COSTS PER UNIT FOR 5-STORY RENTAL APARTMENTS IN LOS ALTOS HILLS, WITH CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS VS. RANGE OF POSSIBLE MARKET OUTCOMES Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Santa Clara Housing Authority, 2025.
Note: Range of Market Outcomes refers to a range of “weak market” vs. “strong market” fluctuations from current market conditions, based on a ten percent change in in market rate rents and the typical range of cap rates observed in Santa Clara County over the past ten years.
The high end of the range of market outcomes was based on a 3.75 percent cap rate and ten percent rent increase. The low end of the range of market outcomes was based on a 5.5 percent cap rate and a ten percent rent decrease.
Note:
• Scenario A refers to a five percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a five percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario B refers to a 7.5 percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a 7.5 percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario C refers to a five percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI) and a five percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI).
• Scenario D refers to a four percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI), a four percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI), and a four percent low-income requirement (60% AMI).
In-Lieu Fee Analysis
For each policy scenario, Strategic Economics calculated the in-lieu fee that would be equivalent to the revenue lost from meeting the onsite requirement for below market rate units. This approach used the affordability gap, the difference in revenue per square foot between a project with all market rate units and a project with the required affordable units. To calculate expected revenue from affordable units, Strategic Economics used the same “achieved AMI” assumptions as discussed in Figure 9; this approach avoids creating an in-lieu fee that is less expensive than the likely cost of providing on-site units. Per square foot in-lieu fees were defined using the net residential area of each prototype. The final in-lieu fees recommended for adoption will be closely coordinated with the recommended inclusionary policy (considering the total revenue impact of both the onsite percentage and income targets), with potential adjustments to incentivize the Town’s preference for either onsite units or the collection of fee revenues.
Detailed in-lieu fee findings are summarized below.
($300,000)
($250,000)
($200,000)
($150,000)
($100,000)
($50,000)
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
Residual Land Value per Unit
Inclusionary Scenario
Range of Market Outcomes
Current Market
Typical Land Cost per Unit
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 30 • The equivalent in-lieu fees for the ownership policy scenarios are as follows (see Figure 25):
o Scenario A: $111 per square foot for townhomes or $121 per square foot for condos, for a policy that targeted moderate-income households;
o Scenario B: $132 per square foot for townhomes or $146 per square foot for condos, for a policy that targeted low-income households; and
o Scenario C: $119 per square foot for townhomes or $131 per square foot for condos, for a policy that targeted a mix of low- and moderate-income households. • The equivalent in-lieu fees for the rental policy scenarios are as follows (see Figure 26):
o Scenario A: $48 per square foot for Small Scale Apartments or $61 per square foot for 5-Story Apartments, for a ten percent requirement targeting a mix of very low- and low-income households; o Scenario B: $73 per square foot for Small Scale Apartments or $91 per square foot for 5-Story Apartments, for a 15 percent requirement targeting a mix of very low- and low-income households; o Scenario C: $55 per square foot for Small Scale Apartments or $67 per square foot for 5-Story Apartments, for a ten percent requirement targeting a mix of extremely low-and very low-income households; and o Scenario D: $59 per square foot for Small Scale Apartments or $72 per square foot for 5-Story Apartments, for a 12 percent requirement targeting a mix of extremely low- , very low-, and low-income households.
FIGURE 25: EQUIVALENT IN-LIEU FEE PER NET SQUARE FOOT CORRESPONDING TO REVENUE FOREGONE FROM INCLUSIONARY POLICY IN LOS ALTOS HILLS, BY SCENARIO – OWNERSHIP UNITS Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; HCD, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025.
Note: Scenario A refers to a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI). Scenario B refers to a 15 percent low-income requirement (tested at 70% AMI). Scenario C refers to a 15 percent requirement split between low-income and moderate-income. $111
$132
$119 $121
$146
$131
$0
$20
$40
$60
$80
$100
$120
$140
$160
Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Townhomes 5-Story Condos
In-lieu Fee per Net Square Foot
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 31 FIGURE 26: EQUIVALENT IN-LIEU FEE PER NET SQUARE FOOT CORRESPONDING TO REVENUE FOREGONE FROM INCLUSIONARY POLICY IN LOS ALTOS HILLS, BY SCENARIO – RENTAL UNITS Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; HCD, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025.
Note:
• Scenario A refers to a five percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a five percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario B refers to a 7.5 percent very low-income requirement (50% AMI) and a 7.5 percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). • Scenario C refers to a five percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI) and a five percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI).
• Scenario D refers to a four percent extremely low-income requirement (30% AMI), a four percent very-low income requirement (50% AMI), and a four percent low-income requirement (60% AMI). $48
$73
$55 $59 $61
$91
$67
$72
$0
$10
$20
$30
$40
$50
$60
$70
$80
$90
$100
Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Scenario D Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Scenario D Small Scale Rental Apartments 5-Story Rental Apartments In-Lieu Fee per Net Square Foot
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 32 Policy Considerations and Findings
This section reviews key considerations, in addition to financial feasibility, for developing inclusionary and in-lieu fee policies for Los Altos Hills. First, the section provides a summary of inclusionary policies for other peer jurisdictions in Santa Clara County. The section then outlines other key policy and legal considerations, before concluding with a summary of findings. Key considerations for implementing rules and guidelines for the chosen policy are in Appendix II.
INCLUSIONARY POLICIES IN NEIGHBORING JURISDICTIONS
Most peer jurisdictions require an onsite inclusionary percentage of 15 percent, with certain modifications tailored to smaller projects, larger projects, and/or ownership projects. Los Gatos, for example, uses a sliding scale that ranges from 10 to 20 percent onsite inclusionary depending on the size of the project. Cupertino has a 15 percent requirement for rental projects, but a higher percentage, 20 percent, for ownership projects. Like the other cities, Mountain View has a fifteen percent across-the-board requirement, except with an additional 10 percent requirement for above moderate households specifically for townhouses and rowhouses. Finally, Palo Alto has a 20 percent requirement for for-sale projects on more than five acres.
In peer cities, the inclusionary requirements for rental projects target a mix of income levels, from very low to moderate-income households. Whereas Santa Clara and Mountain View’s inclusionary policies use a weighted average approach to ensure that affordable units target 100 percent AMI and 65 percent AMI, respectively, most other jurisdictions assign percentage requirements to individual income categories. Cupertino targets very low and low-income units; Los Gatos targets moderate-income units; and Sunnyvale targets a mix of very low and low-income units. Lastly, San Jose provides rental developers with a choice: they can either target extremely low-income households, or provide a mix of very low, low, and moderate-income units.
In their inclusionary requirements for ownership projects, all peer cities except Los Gatos and Mountain View target median income or moderate-income households. Most cities require a mix of median income (targeting up to 100 percent of AMI) and moderate-income (targeting up to 120 percent of AMI) units. However, Los Gatos requires five to ten percent of ownership units to be dedicated to low-income households—half of the Town’s total inclusionary requirement. Mountain View’s policy also differs from other peer cities, but specifically for townhomes and rowhouses. For these project types, Mountain View requires ten percent of units to be set aside for above moderate-income households, which its policy defines as up to 135 percent of AMI. This brings the City’s total inclusionary requirement to 25 percent for these projects, but at a higher average AMI than other jurisdictions.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 33 FIGURE 27: INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENTS IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY JURISDICTIONS, AS OF 2025 Jurisdiction
Minimum Size
for Inclusionary
Requirement
Policy Categories Required Share of Units
Rental For-Sale
Cupertino 5 Units 9% Very Low
6% Low
10% Median
10% Moderate
Los Gatos 5 Units
5-19 Units 10% Moderate 5% Low
5% Moderate
20-100 Units 10-20% Moderate 5-10% Low
5-10% Moderate
100+ Units 20% Moderate 10% Low
10% Moderate
Mountain
View No Minimum
Townhouses &
Rowhouses 15% (Avg. 65% AMI)
15% Moderate (Avg. 100% AMI)
10% Above Moderate (Avg. 135%
AMI)
All Other
Developments 15% (Avg. 65% AMI) 15% (Avg. 100% AMI)
Palo Alto 3+ Units
Project on <5
acres Impact Fee
10% Median
5% Moderate
Project on >5
acres 20% (2/3 Median, 1/3 Moderate)
San Jose 10+ Units
Option 1 10% Extremely Low 15% Moderate
Option 2
5% Very Low
5% Low
5% Moderate
15% Moderate
City of
Santa Clara 3+ Units
<10 Units: 1 unit or in-lieu/impact fee
10+ Units 15% (Avg. 100% AMI) 15% (Avg. 100% AMI)
Sunnyvale
Rental: 3+ Units
For-Sale: 7+
Units
5% Very Low
10% Low 15% Moderate
Sources: City of Cupertino, 2025; Town of Los Gatos, 2025; City of Mountain View, 2025; City of Palo Alto, 2025; City of San Jose, 2025; City of Santa Clara, 2025; City of Sunnyvale, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
Note: some cities apply an impact fee to projects that do not meet the minimum size threshold for the inclusionary requirement.
OTHER POLICY CONSIDERATIONS
In addition to financial feasibility and the existing requirements in peer cities, this section reviews other considerations for formulating an inclusionary policy in Los Altos Hills. These considerations include the applicability of the policy; conditions for HCD review; Metropolitan Transportation Commission requirements; and State Density Bonus Law, as described below.
Applicability of the Policy
Los Altos Hills will need to define the scope of multi-unit development to which the inclusionary policy will apply. In general, the two key considerations are the potential product types and project sizes (number of units) that fall under the inclusionary ordinance. The list below summarizes conceivable
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 34 types of development to consider as Los Altos Hills develops a policy, while recognizing some of the examples listed may be inappropriate to the Town’s current market context and/or zoning.
For ownership housing:
• Condominium flats, constructed as small-scale infill, low-rise garden-style, mid-rise podium, or high-rise developments. This study tested the feasibility of a mid-rise podium building type.
• Single-family attached, including small-scale multiplexes and larger-scale townhome developments. This study tested the feasibility of a townhome development type. • Single-family detached, including small lot subdivisions or more conventional subdivisions built at a lower density. This study did not test the feasibility of any single-family detached development types. However, as explained below, this does not invalidate the scenarios and feasibility conclusions, as current zoning would result in any detached single-family developments to be proposed in a higher density form similar to the ownership scenarios tested in the study.
For rental housing, the types of development could include:
• Rental apartments constructed as small-scale infill, low-rise garden-style, mid-rise podium, or high-rise developments. This study tested the feasibility of small-scale infill building types.
• Single-family attached or detached rental units (both of these are less common). This study did not test any single-family rental development types as described above.
In addition, Los Altos Hills should consider the potential for proposals that would have streamlined approvals mandated by the Starter Home Revitalization Act (SB 684/SB 1123). The SHRA applies to subdivisions of up to 10 parcels or developments up to 10 units meeting certain criteria designed to limit the units’ market value, thereby making them accessible to more households. Even when these developments are proposed as single-family detached units, they are likely to have smaller unit sizes and lower prices than conventional subdivisions proposed at a lower density.
In general, Los Altos Hills should apply uniform policies to ownership and rental product types, respectively, unless the Town seeks to support certain development types. Most jurisdictions have different policies for ownership and rental products regardless of variation in the different building types. However, in a few cases, some jurisdictions in the San Francisco Bay Area apply inclusionary requirements that vary by housing product type, not just by tenure. For example, as shown in Figure 27, Mountain View applies an additional requirement, above its base inclusionary requirement, to townhome developments. This approach tends to reflect a jurisdiction’s strategy to capture additional value from more profitable product types and/or support, for example, denser condominium development near transit.
It is not necessary to perform a feasibility study for every variation or product type in the policy. The feasibility study analyzes a set of the most typical prototypes to give a general picture of feasibility and to bracket the impact of inclusionary policies on the variety of multi-unit developments outlined above.
If Los Altos Hills seeks to provide relief for certain product types that have not yet been tested in the market, the Town could exempt these product types from the inclusionary policy.
The Town could also adopt other alternative approaches which would be available to proposed developments to achieve feasibility, including an in-lieu fee option, ability to construct inclusionary
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 35 units in offsite locations, and the option to dedicate land in lieu of providing affordable units. The Town should also adopt “relief valve” procedures including Town authority to waive or modify inclusionary housing requirements upon applicant request and demonstration of infeasibility, and a process for Town approval of alternate means of compliance with the inclusionary housing ordinance that will help housing projects to become economically feasible.
Jurisdictions should anticipate that their adopted policy may need to be administered to development proposals that include a mix of product types. Policies that are tailored to different product types, such as having a different requirement for townhomes versus condominiums, will need clear definitions for these product types and a methodology for administering the policy on development proposals that include a mix of products. While this study analyzed condominium flats in a typical mid-rise podium building, condominiums could be delivered in other ways that improve feasibility, such as in lower-density building types with surface or tuck-under parking, and/or as part of a development that includes a mix of product types such as townhomes.
It is common to exempt or reduce the inclusionary requirement for smaller-scale projects. Although there is no standard definition of “smaller scale,” the threshold is often defined as those including approximately 10 units or fewer. Smaller scale projects do not benefit from the economies of scale of larger projects, and many local governments seek to incentivize these “missing middle” developments.
In addition, projects enabled by the Starter Home Revitalization Act are designed to support smaller scale developments that are relatively affordable by design (although not necessarily affordable to moderate-income households and below) and generate limited value for developers compared with subdivisions and other types of development that do not meet the Act’s criteria.
HCD Review
Any local inclusionary policy on rental housing may be subject to review by the California Department of Housing and Community Development if it includes a greater than 15 percent inclusionary requirement for households at income levels of 80 percent of AMI or less. Since 2017, the AB 1505 legislation (also known as the “Palmer fix”) provided for a set of conditions that could trigger HCD review, including an elevated inclusionary requirement for very low- and low-income households and failure to meet 75 percent of above moderate RHNA goals.2 Inclusionary policies under review may need to perform a feasibility study demonstrating that “the ordinance does not unduly constrain the production of housing.” The legislation does not apply to ownership housing.
MTC Transit Oriented Communities Requirements
The Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) requires compliance with its Transit Oriented Communities (TOC) policy in transit station areas for jurisdictions to be eligible and/or competitive for certain regional funding sources.3 Compliance with the TOC policy requires adoption of at least two affordable housing production policies; one option for this requirement is to adopt an inclusionary policy that meets MTC’s criteria. These criteria are as follows:
2 From January 31st, 2023 through the end of 2024 (approximately one-quarter of Los Altos Hills’ eight-year RHNA Cycle), the Town had met around 7 percent of its very low-income RHNA target; 17 percent of its low-income RHNA target; 57 percent of its moderate-income RHNA target; and 5 percent of its above moderate-income RHNA target. 3 Los Altos Hills does not currently have any transit stations that qualify for this policy.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 36 • Rental Policy: must require least 15 percent of units to be affordable, with an average income of 80% of AMI or less.
• Ownership Policy: must require least 15 percent of units to be affordable, with an average income of 120% of AMI or less.
State Density Bonus Law
The State Density Bonus Law (SDBL) allows multi-unit ownership and rental developments to build to a higher density than the maximum density allowed by zoning if affordable units are included in the project. Any affordable units provided to gain a density bonus under the program also count towards local inclusionary requirements if the units are at or below the income level required by the local policy.
Any “bonus” units enabled by the legislation do not have to be affordable. Because of this, SDBL projects commonly result in an overall project with a lower percentage of affordable units than the percentage in the local inclusionary policy. Example outcomes of the state density bonus program utilized in conjunction with a local inclusionary policy are illustrated in Appendix II: Example Policy Outcomes and Considerations for Implementation.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 37
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS
This section provides a summary of findings from the feasibility and inclusionary analyses along with conclusions that inform Los Altos Hills’ decisions regarding an inclusionary policy.
Findings
• Both ownership prototypes are currently feasible in Los Altos Hills under current market conditions.
• A 15 percent inclusionary requirement would substantially reduce project revenue for these prototypes but would remain feasible for the Townhome prototype and be marginally infeasible for the 5-Story Condo Prototype.
• Based on current market conditions, Strategic Economics found that the Small Scale Rental Apartment prototype and 5-Story Rental Apartment prototype are not currently feasible in Los Altos Hills.
• The infeasibility of the rental prototypes is a result of market conditions rather than an inclusionary requirement. In the current market and policy context, the tested inclusionary policy scenarios would have only a modest impact on apartment project revenues. The ability of future rental projects to support one of the inclusionary scenarios depends on future growth in market rents and macroeconomic conditions that better support multifamily investment.
• The ability of ownership projects to support inclusionary policies could vary based on individual project characteristics and the specific market context in Los Altos Hills.
Although broader market trends support the development of compact ownership housing in the Los Altos Hills market, this type of development is still untested in this location. The format, density, and targeted market segment for townhome or condominium development could vary from the prototypes studied, with actual developments combining aspects of each prototype and/or producing a more premium product to optimize for the specific conditions in Los Altos Hills.
Conclusions
Under the policy scenarios tested, an inclusionary policy could be applied to townhome developments without significantly constraining new development, but Los Altos Hills should still be conservative in application of inclusionary policies to ownership development. This is the case for two reasons:
• Because data informing prospective sales prices for townhomes and condos in Los Altos Hills is limited, actual sales prices are uncertain. Strategic Economics estimated sales price assumptions for the Townhome and 5-Story Condo prototypes based on sales activity of comparable housing units in neighboring jurisdictions and by evaluating Los Altos Hills’ market strength based on single-family home sales.
• While a policy that includes low-income households is likely viable, developers report that it can sometimes be difficult to qualify low-income homebuyers, particularly if other monthly costs such as HOA dues and hazard insurance represent significant costs over time. Therefore, the Town should monitor the implementation of any potential ownership policy targeted to
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 38 households that are below a moderate-income level to ensure that this policy is a practical tool for generating housing at lower income levels.
Given that Los Altos Hills remains an untested market for compact housing, and future proposals could occur in a variety of different formats and combinations, the Town should adopt a policy that applies to a broad range of product types. Although the tested inclusionary policies were more feasible for the Townhome prototype than the 5-Story Condos prototype, Los Altos Hills should apply a uniform policy across all ownership product types unless the Town’s goal is to specifically support certain types of development. While the 5-Story Condo prototype analyzed a typical mid-rise podium building, in general, condominium flats could be delivered in other ways that maximize feasibility, such as in lower-density building types with surface or tuck-under parking, and/or as part of a development that includes a mix of product types including townhomes. Similarly, the Town should include in its policy other types of ownership development, such as compact detached units that are similar in scale and density to townhomes, as well as other types of subdivisions, unless it is the specific goal of the Town to support this development format.
The Town should consider adopting an inclusionary policy for rental projects, while recognizing the policy would be unlikely to generate significant affordable units until fundamental changes in the market occur. This analysis examined inclusionary policy scenarios targeted to extremely low-, very low- and/or low-income households and found roughly similar impacts on development feasibility across the tested mixes of affordability levels and total inclusionary percentages. While current market rents are not yet high enough to spur development, Strategic Economics recommends the Town have its policy in place in advance of future changes in conditions that might support rental projects. The Town should consider re-evaluating the affordability levels in its policy if and when this occurs to ensure that its inclusionary policy is still targeting income levels that are most needed to meet the Town’s RHNA goals.
The Town should consider adopting a waiver process and option to approve alternative means of compliance in order to assist housing projects to become economically feasible. The Town should consider including options such as developer ability to construct inclusionary units in offsite locations, and the option to dedicate land in lieu of providing affordable units. The Town should also consider including Town authority to waive or modify inclusionary housing requirements upon applicant request and demonstration of infeasibility, and a process for Town approval of alternate means of compliance with the inclusionary housing ordinance that will help housing projects to become economically feasible.
The Town should consider a reduction or exemption in its requirement for smaller-scale projects. This approach would help support the feasibility of missing middle housing. Utilizing a threshold of 10 units and below for the exemption or reduction would be consistent with area best practice and would apply uniformly to all Starter Home Revitalization Act projects.
Targeting an inclusionary policy to extremely low-income households may be difficult to implement.
While policy Scenarios C and D for rental development include a requirement to provide units affordable to extremely low-income households (up to 30 percent of AMI), there are few precedents for including this income group in an inclusionary policy, and it could place significant burdens on development. Housing built for extremely low-income households is generally provided in dedicated developments that include supportive services, and developers report that it can be difficult to find households that qualify for units restricted to an extremely low-income in conventional multifamily housing. Recently, the City of San José experimented with including extremely low income units as one
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 39 of a set of options for meeting its Inclusionary Housing Ordinance. City staff report this option was seldom if ever used.
If an inclusionary policy is adopted, the Town should also adopt an equivalent in-lieu fee. The in-lieu fee rate would be determined by the inclusionary policy for ownership versus rental development. It would be possible to differentiate fees for different product types (e.g., fee rates specific to townhome and condominium product types). However, the lack of market information suggests the fee be set at the average of fees found for the Townhome and Condo prototypes. Similarly, the Town should adopt an in-lieu fee for rental projects that is the average of the fees calculated for the rental prototypes.
Strategic Economics recommends the Town implement the in-lieu fee policy in one of the following ways:
• Allow payment of the fee for smaller scale projects and when the policy results in fractional units. Allowing in-lieu fees for smaller-scale projects can provide flexibility for projects for when meeting the policy with onsite units is infeasible. For all other projects, allowing an in-lieu fee only for fractional units would help ensure that Los Altos Hills produces BMR units, without requiring the Town to manage fee revenue to create them. • Limit payment of the in-lieu fee to fractional units on small-scale projects. The inclusionary policies in some jurisdictions do not allow payment of the in-lieu fee above a certain unit threshold, instead requiring developers to round up fractional units and provide an additional BMR unit. However, this approach is not feasible for very small scale developments. State law requires jurisdictions to include some alternative means of compliance within an inclusionary policy—such as in-lieu fees, land dedication or provision of off-site units. Emphasizing on-site units, land dedication, or off-site units—as opposed to in lieu fees for large-scale projects—could help Los Altos Hills achieve production of BMR units in the short-term.
Monitor the residential market periodically and adjust the inclusionary policy as appropriate. As shown in the Policy and Market Scenarios section, the feasibility of development, and its ability to accommodate an inclusionary policy, may depend on a variety of factors. Indicators of a changing market include changes in the pace of development applications, trends in sales values and rental rates, a significant change in the California Construction Cost index, or changes in interest rates.
Jurisdictions should update the inclusionary feasibility study periodically to ensure the policy is well-suited to the current market environment.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 40 Appendix I: Financial Feasibility Assumptions
Cost Assumptions
FIGURE 28: DETAILED COST ASSUMPTIONS FOR OWNERSHIP PROTOTYPES IN LOS ALTOS HILLS Unit of measure Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Land Costs per square foot $125 $125
Hard Costs
Demolition and Site Work per sq. ft. land $40 $40
Building Area Construction
Residential - Type V per gross sq. ft. $275 $400
Parking per space
Structured/Podium per space $50,000
Underground per space $80,000
Tuck-under per space
Soft Costs
Arch, Eng & Consulting % of hard costs 5.0% 5.0%
Taxes, Insurance, Legal & Accounting % of hard costs 10.0% 10.0% Other Soft Costs % of hard costs 3.0% 3.0%
Total Soft Costs (Excluding Fees) % of hard costs 18.0% 18.0%
Municipal Fees Shown in Separate Table
Contingency % of hard + soft costs 5.0% 5.0%
Financing
Amount Financed (Loan-to-cost) % of hard + soft costs 55% 55% Average outstanding balance % of Amt Financed 55% 55%
Construction Loan Fee % of Amt Financed 1.0% 1.0%
Construction Interest (annual) 8.0% 8.0%
Term Months 18 28
Developer Return
Target Developer Return-on-cost % of total dev costs 15.0% 15.0% Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 41 FIGURE 29: DETAILED COST ASSUMPTIONS FOR RENTAL PROTOTYPES IN LOS ALTOS HILLS Unit of measure
Small Scale Rental
Apartments
5-Story Rental
Apartments
Land Costs
Land Costs per square foot $125 $125
Hard Costs
Demolition and Site Work per sq. ft. land $40 $40
Building Area Construction
Residential - Type V per gross sq. ft. $290 $310
Parking per space
Surface per space $10,000
Structured/Podium per space $50,000
Underground per space $80,000
Tuck-under per space $10,000
Soft Costs
Arch, Eng & Consulting % of hard costs 5.0% 5.0%
Taxes, Insurance, Legal & Accounting % of hard costs 5.0% 5.0% Other Soft Costs % of hard costs 3.0% 3.0%
Total Soft Costs (Excluding Fees) % of hard costs 13.0% 13.0% Municipal Fees Shown in Separate Table
Contingency % of hard + soft costs 5.0% 5.0%
Financing
Amount Financed (Loan-to-cost) % of hard + soft costs 55% 55% Average outstanding balance % of Amt Financed 55% 55%
Construction Loan Fee % of Amt Financed 1.0% 1.0%
Construction Interest (annual) 8.0% 8.0%
Term Months 24 28
Developer Share
Developer Overhead Fee % of hard + soft costs 3.0% 3.0% Target Developer Yield-on-Cost % of total dev costs 5.5% 5.5% Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025; CoStar, 2025; Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 42 FIGURE 30: LOS ALTOS HILLS MUNICIPAL FEE ESTIMATES - OWNERSHIP AND RENTAL PROTOTYPES Prototype Townhomes
Small Scale
Rental
Apartments
5-Story Condos 5-Story Rental
Apartments
Permits & Fees
Building Permit $10,641 $22,386 $202,520 $239,204
Plan Check $6,917 $14,551 $131,638 $155,483
Sewer & Water $11,236 $11,236 $337,080 $606,744
Other $37,586 $77,969 $708,221 $837,013
Total $66,381 $126,142 $1,379,459 $1,838,444
Impact Fees
Parks $54,450 $54,450 $1,317,690 $1,470,150
Schools $9,460 $17,200 $174,924 $208,626
Other $10,649 $10,649 $319,470 $575,046
Total $74,559 $82,299 $1,812,084 $2,253,822
Sources: Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
Prototype and Revenue Assumptions
FIGURE 31: MARKET RATE OWNERSHIP PRO FORMA REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS, LOST ALTOS HILLS Unit of measure Townhomes 5-Story Condos
Unit Size
1-BD sq. ft. - 900
2-BD sq. ft. 1,400 1,300
3-BD sq. ft. 1,700 1,600
4-BD sq. ft. 2,000 1,900
Average Unit Size sq. ft. 1,710 1,382
Unit Sales Value Price Share Price Share
1-BD per unit - 0% 1,200,000 10%
2-BD per unit 1,685,000 23% 1,610,000 55%
3-BD per unit 1,890,000 50% 1,950,000 30%
4-BD per unit 2,035,000 27% 2,130,000 5%
Average Sales Value
Per unit per unit $1,880,833 $1698,901
Marketing Expense % of Sales Price 5% 5%
Net Revenue $1,786,792 $1,613,956
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 43 FIGURE 32: MARKET RATE RENT PER UNIT ASSUMPTIONS, LOS ALTOS HILLS Unit of measure Small Scale Rental Apartments 5-Story Rental Apartments Residential
Unit Size
Studio square feet 550 550
1-BD square feet 750 750
2-BD square feet 1,150 1,100
3-BD square feet 1,400 1,300
Average Unit Size square feet 955 891
Unit Rents
Studio per unit $3,200 $3,400
1-BD per unit $3,500 $3,800
2-BD per unit $4,500 $5,000
3-BD per unit $5,000 $6,000
Average per unit $4,019 $4,310
Other Revenue Assumptions
Vacancy (Market Rate Units) % of Units 5% 5%
Vacancy (Below Market Rate Units) % of BMR Units 5.0% 5.0% Operating Expense % of Revenue 30% 30%
Capitalization Rate 4.50% 4.50%
Sources: CoStar, 2025; Apartment Websites, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
FIGURE 33: AREA MEDIAN INCOME AND INCOME LIMITS FOR SANTA CLARA COUNTY, 2025 People per Household 1 2 3 4 5
Bedroom Count Studio 1-BD 2-BD 3-BD 4-BD
Extremely Low $42,200 $48,200 $54,250 $60,250 $65,100
Very Low-Income $70,350 $80,400 $90,450 $100,450 $108,500 Low-Income $111,700 $127,650 $143,600 $159,550 $172,350 Median-Income $136,650 $156,150 $175,700 $195,200 $210,800 Moderate-Income $164,000 $187,400 $210,850 $234,250 $253,000 Sources: California HCD, 2025; Strategic Economics, 2025.
Note: Extremely Low-Income refers to up to 30% of AMI; Very Low-Income refers to up to 50% of AMI; Low-Income refers to up to 80% of AMI, and Moderate-Income refers to up to 120% of AMI.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 44 FIGURE 34: MAXIMUM SALES PRICE PER UNIT AND AVERAGE BMRPRICE FOR TOWNHOME PROTOTYPE IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY, BY BMR INCOME LEVEL, 2025
Unit Mix Low (70% Achieved AMI) Median (90% Achieved AMI) Moderate (110% Achieved
AMI)
Bedroom Count
One Bedroom 0%
Two Bedroom 23% $282,037 $396,748 $511,459
Three Bedroom 50% $301,139 $428,581 $556,023
Four Bedroom 27% $310,808 $448,435 $586,061
Average Price per BMR Unit $299,260 $426,448 $553,635
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025; CA HCD, 2025; Redfin, 2025; Freddie Mac, 2025; Alta Housing, 2025; Ownwell, 2025.
Notes: Accounts for share of income spent on housing costs (30%), current interest rates, monthly utility costs, taxes, insurance, and HOA costs. Achieved sales price reflects likely average for units in each income category in an inclusionary project.
FIGURE 35: MAXIMUM SALES PRICE PER UNIT AND AVERAGE BMR PRICE FOR 5-STORY CONDOS IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY, BY INCOME LEVEL, 2025
Unit Mix
Low (70% Achieved
AMI)
Median (90% Achieved
AMI)
Moderate (110% Achieved
AMI)
Bedroom Count
1-BD 10% $268,179 $370,126 $472,073
2-BD 55% $279,697 $394,408 $509,119
3-BD 30% $297,366 $424,808 $552,250
4-BD 5% $306,253 $443,880 $581,507
Average Price per BMR Unit $285,259 $403,744 $522,229
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025; CA HCD, 2025; Redfin, 2025; Freddie Mac, 2025; Alta Housing, 2025; Ownwell, 2025.
Notes: Accounts for share of income spent on housing costs (30%), current interest rates, monthly utility costs, taxes, insurance, and HOA costs. Achieved sales price reflects likely average for units in each income category in an inclusionary project.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 45 FIGURE 36: BELOW MARKET RATE RENTAL REVENUE ASSUMPTIONS IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY, 2025 Small Scale Rental Apartments 5-Story Rental Apartments Share of Units by Bedroom Count1
Studio 9% 5%
1-BD 41% 55%
2-BD 41% 35%
3-BD 9% 5%
Achieved Monthly Rent per Unit2
50% AMI (Very Low) $2,018 $1,997
60% AMI (Low) $2,371 $2,346
90% AMI (Median) $3,616 $3,576
110% AMI (Moderate) $4,445 $4,395
Monthly Operating Expenses per Unit3 $1,206 $1,293
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Santa Clara County Housing Authority, 2025; CA HCD, 2025 Notes:
1. Reflects distribution of units in prototype.
2. Based on California HCD’s 2025 table of median incomes by household size for Santa Clara County; Santa Clara County Housing Authority’s utility allowances for multifamily units; and an assumption of no more than 30 percent of income spent on housing costs. Achieved rent reflects likely average for units in each income category in an inclusionary project.
3. Operating expenses per unit based on the average operating expense per unit of a market rate unit in each prototype, based on 30 percent of average market rate rent for each unit.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 46 Appendix II: Example Policy Outcomes and
Considerations for Implementation
This Appendix illustrates how the policy scenarios analyzed in Section II might be implemented using hypothetical development examples for ownership and rental housing. The examples are intended to guide the Town’s formulation of the policy as well as its guidelines for compliance. For each inclusionary policy scenario, Strategic Economics provided several possible options for compliance with details about the resulting mix of below market rate units produced and in-lieu fees generated.
The first set of examples assume the project does not use the SDBL. Following that, Strategic Economics also included example outcomes if developers do utilize the SDBL under each inclusionary policy scenario.
Policy Outcomes Assuming No State Density Bonus
The examples below show how inclusionary units and in-lieu fees could vary depending on the rules and guidelines the Town implements for policy compliance. Figure 37 shows some example outcomes for the tested policy scenarios for an ownership project, and Figure 38 shows the same for a rental project. Possible options for compliance are described below:
• Option 1 shows the outcome if the project complies with the policy by only providing onsite units and paying no fee. When applying the onsite inclusionary percentage to the project, policy guidelines for this option should address the case when the calculation result includes fractional units. In the example in Figure 37, when the 15 percent inclusionary policy in Scenario A is applied to a project of 90 units, the calculated result is 13.5 units. In these cases, an inclusionary policy would typically round up the inclusionary requirement to the next whole number, or 14 inclusionary units in this example.
• Option 2 shows the outcome if the project complies with the policy without rounding, by providing only the whole number of units that result from the inclusionary percentage and paying an in-lieu fee on any fractional units. In the same example, the applicant would provide 13 inclusionary units and pay the in-lieu fee on the remaining
0.5 units.
• Option 3 shows the outcome if the project complies with the policy only through in-lieu fees and no onsite units. In this instance, the in-lieu fee is based on the calculated
13.5 inclusionary units.
• Although not shown in the figure, jurisdictions may allow projects to meet the obligation with any preferred mix of units or in-lieu fees as chosen by the applicant.
If Los Altos Hills prefers onsite units to fee revenues, the Town may restrict the means of compliance to Option 1 as-of-right. Strategic Economics recommends this approach particularly if the anticipated fee revenue generated from the other options is unlikely to be sufficient to leverage for affordable housing development in the near term. The examples in Figure 37 and Figure 38 show that a 90-unit development may yield between zero and $102,000 in fees if only charged on fractional units (Option 2). Complying with the policy with only fees (Option 3) might yield between $440,000 and $3 million in revenues for a 90-unit project.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 47 If Los Altos Hills pursues a policy preference for onsite units, Strategic Economics recommends the Town also provide allowances for the payment of fees or other means of compliance for smaller projects or projects with special circumstances. If the Town’s policy applies to smaller projects of fewer than 10 to 20 units, rounding up fractional units in the policy may place a significant financial burden on development. Most jurisdictions that apply an inclusionary requirement to these smaller projects allow the payment of an in-lieu fee on fractional units if the total number of units in the project falls below a certain threshold (see the analysis of neighboring jurisdictions’ policies in Figure 27). In addition, some development projects have special circumstances that might mean meeting the policy with onsite units is suboptimal. The Town could establish guidelines for alternative means of compliance, such as providing offsite units or dedicating land for affordable housing, either as-of-right or with a discretionary process.
Once the total onsite unit requirement is established, the Town should set guidelines for distributing these units to the income groups included in the policy and the unit types in the development. For example, in Figure 37, Scenario C, Option 2, the inclusionary requirement includes 13 onsite units, to be split evenly between low-income and moderate-income units, or 7.5 units for each income level.
When this calculation results in fractional units, a common approach is to allocate the units in such a way that lower income groups are given preference over higher income groups. In this example, the requirement for 13 units is satisfied by providing seven low-income units and six moderate-income units. Similar guidelines should be in place for distributing units by unit type.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 48 FIGURE 37: EXAMPLE POLICY OUTCOMES BY SCENARIO FOR OWNERSHIP Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C
Inclusionary Policy
Total Percentage Requirement 15% 15% 15%
Extremely Low-Income -- -- --
Very Low-Income -- -- --
Low-Income -- 15% 7.5%
Moderate-Income 15% -- 7.5%
Equivalent In-lieu Fee - Townhomes $111 $132 $119
Equivalent In-lieu Fee - Condos $121 $146 $131
Options for Compliance for an Example Development
Example: Townhome development consisting of 90 Units totaling 153,900 residential square feet (1,710 s.f. per unit)
Total Units in Development 90 90 90
Total Units * Total Percentage Requirement 13.5 13.5 13.5 Option 1: Provide only onsite units
Total Inclusionary Units (rounded up) 14 14 14
Extremely Low-Income -- -- --
Very Low-Income -- -- --
Low-Income -- 14 7
Moderate-Income 14 -- 7
In-lieu Fee no fee no fee no fee
Option 2: Provide onsite units and pay a fee on remaining fractional units Total Inclusionary Units (rounded down) 13 13 13
Extremely Low-Income -- -- --
Very Low-Income -- -- --
Low-Income -- 13 7
Moderate-Income 13 -- 6
In-Lieu Fee $94,905 $112,860 $101,745
In-lieu Fee Calculation:
Units Charged In-lieu Fee [a] 0.5 0.5 0.5
Average Unit s.f. in Development [b] 1,710 1,710 1,710
Number of s.f. subject to fee [c = a * b] 855 855 855
In-lieu Fee per s.f. - Townhome [d] $111 $132 $119
Total In-lieu Fee [c * d] $94,905 $112,860 $101,745
Option 3: Pay in-lieu fee only
Total Inclusionary Units none none none
In-Lieu Fee $2,562,435 $3,047,220 $2,747,115
In-lieu Fee Calculation:
Units Charged In-lieu Fee [a] 13.5 13.5 13.5
Average Unit s.f. in Development [b] 1,710 1,710 1,710
Number of s.f. subject to fee [c = a * b] 23,085 23,085 23,085 In-lieu Fee per s.f. - Townhome [d] $111 $132 $119
Total In-lieu Fee [c * d] $2,562,435 $3,047,220 $2,747,115 Source: Strategic Economics, 2026.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 49 FIGURE 38: EXAMPLE POLICY OUTCOMES BY SCENARIO FOR RENTAL Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Scenario D
Inclusionary Requirement
Total Percentage Requirement 10% 15% 10% 12%
Extremely Low-Income -- -- 5% 4%
Very Low-Income 5% 7.5% 5% 4%
Low-Income 5% 7.5% -- 4%
Moderate-Income -- -- -- --
Equivalent In-lieu Fee - Rental Apartments1 $55 $82 $61 $66 Options for Compliance for an Example Development
Example: Rental housing development consisting of 90 Units totaling 81,000 net rentable square feet (900 s.f. per unit)
Total Units in Development 90 90 90 90
Total Units * Total Percentage Requirement 9.0 13.5 9.0 10.8 Option 1: Provide only onsite units
Total Inclusionary Units (rounded up) 9 14 9 11
Extremely Low-Income -- -- 5 4
Very Low-Income 5 7 4 4
Low-Income 4 7 -- 3
Moderate-Income -- -- -- --
In-lieu Fee no fee no fee no fee no fee
Option 2: Provide onsite units and pay a fee on remaining fractional units Total Inclusionary Units (rounded down) Because there
are no
fractional
units, this
option is the
same as
Option 1.
13 Because there
are no
fractional
units, this
option is the
same as
Option 1.
10 Extremely Low-Income -- 4
Very Low-Income 7 3
Low-Income 6 3
Moderate-Income -- --
In-Lieu Fee $36,900 $47,160
In-lieu Fee Calculation:
Units Charged In-lieu Fee [a] 0.5 0.8
Average Unit s.f. in Development [b] 900 900
Number of s.f. subject to fee [c = a * b] 450 720
In-lieu Fee per s.f. - Rental Apartments [d] $82 $66
Total In-lieu Fee [c * d] $36,900 $47,160
Option 3: Pay in-lieu fee only
Total Inclusionary Units none none none none
In-lieu Fee $441,450 $996,300 $494,100 $636,660
In-lieu Fee Calculation:
Units Charged In-lieu Fee [a] 9.0 13.5 9.0 10.8
Average Unit s.f. in Development [b] 900 900 900 900
Number of s.f. subject to fee [c = a * b] 8,100 12,150 8,100 9,720 In-lieu Fee per s.f. - Rental Apartments [d] $55 $82 $61 $66 Total In-lieu Fee [c * d] $441,450 $996,300 $494,100 $636,660
1. In-lieu fee amounts are the average of the in-lieu fees calculated for the two rental prototypes in the previous section.
Source: Strategic Economics, 2026.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 50 Policy Outcomes with the State Density Bonus Law
In developing an inclusionary policy, Los Altos Hills should anticipate how residential developments might utilize the SDBL. Figure 39 shows a partial schedule of some commonly utilized density bonus allowances in the program. For example, providing 15 percent of units affordable to very low-income households triggers a 50% density bonus; providing 15 percent low-income units triggers a 27.5% bonus; and providing 15 percent moderate-income units (only applicable to ownership projects) triggers a 10 percent bonus. In addition, recent changes to state law have expanded opportunities for developments to utilize this bonus. With the passage of AB 1287 in 2024, the State created a “stackable” density bonus, allowing for market rate projects to achieve density bonuses of up to 100 percent by providing the maximum percentage of affordable units in multiple categories. Because meeting the SDBL criteria also qualifies developments for zoning incentives, concessions, and potential waivers of development standards, in addition to bonus units, some projects may utilize the program for these incentives without taking advantage of some or all of the bonus density.
FIGURE 39:DENSITY BONUS AMOUNT TRIGGERED BY PROVISION OF AFFORDABLE UNITS, BY INCOME LEVEL AND SHARE
OF UNITS IN INCOME CATEGORY
Amount of Density Bonus Triggered
Very Low-Income Units Low-Income Moderate-Income
5% of Units 20% Density Bonus None None
10% of Units 32.5% Density Bonus 20% Density Bonus 5% Density Bonus1 15% of Units 50% Density Bonus 27.5% Density Bonus 10% Density Bonus1 Sources: Meyers Nave, 2023; Strategic Economics, 2025.
Notes:
1. Applies only to ownership units
Targeting an inclusionary policy to lower-income groups could result in higher density developments and additional waivers and concessions from zoning standards in projects that utilize the state density bonus program. Figure 40 and Figure 41 show some possible outcomes if a project with maximum zoned capacity of 90 units met each inclusionary policy scenario while also taking advantage of the SDBL. In these examples, the 90-unit project allowed by zoned is considered the “base project” to which the inclusionary policy applies. Ownership developments that meet the inclusionary policy scenarios for the base project could have their allowable density increase by 10 percent for Scenario A (targeting moderate-income households) and Scenario C (targeting a mix of moderate- and low-income households). Meeting the inclusionary policy in Scenario B, which targets all low-income households, would qualify a project of a higher tier of incentives, with a density bonus of 27.5 percent.
Rental developments (Figure 41) exhibit a similar pattern with a density bonus of up to 32.5 percent in Scenario C.
Developments that voluntarily provide affordable units in excess of what is required by the inclusionary policy could qualify for a higher tier of bonus density and other incentives and concessions. Figure 40 and Figure 41 illustrate development outcomes when projects meet the minimum required by each inclusionary policy scenario. However, some developments may seek a higher level of incentives from the SDBL, leading to the production of additional market rate and affordable units.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 51 FIGURE 40: EXAMPLE POLICY OUTCOMES ASSUMING UTILIZATION OF THE STATE DENSITY BONUS LAW BY SCENARIO
FOR OWNERSHIP
Example: Townhome development with maximum of 90 units allowed by local zoning Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C
Option 1: round up to whole units (from Figure X)
Total Inclusionary Units (rounded up) 14 14 14
Extremely Low-Income -- -- --
Very Low-Income -- -- --
Low-Income -- 14 7
Moderate-Income 14 -- 7
Effective Percentage Affordable on Base Project 15.6% 15.6% 15.6% Extremely Low-Income -- -- --
Very Low-Income -- -- --
Low-Income -- 15.6% 7.8%
Moderate-Income 15.6% -- 7.8%
Density Bonus Triggered: 10% 27.5% 10%
Unit Calculations for Projects with a Density Bonus
Number of Units in the Base Project 90 90 90
Density Bonus Percent 10% 27.5% 10%
Density Bonus Units (rounded up) 9 25 9
Total Project Units, including Bonus Units 99 115 99
Total Inclusionary Units 14 14 14
Net Affordable Percentage 14.1% 12.2% 14.1%
Source: Strategic Economics, 2026.
Residential Feasibility and Inclusionary Analysis for the Town of Los Altos Hills 52 FIGURE 41: EXAMPLE POLICY OUTCOMES ASSUMING UTILIZATION OF THE STATE DENSITY BONUS LAW BY SCENARIO
FOR RENTAL
Example: Rental Apartment development with maximum of 90 units allowed by local zoning Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C Scenario D
Option 1
Total Inclusionary Units (rounded up) 9 14 9 11
Extremely Low-Income -- -- 5 4
Very Low-Income 5 7 4 4
Low-Income 4 7 -- 3
Moderate-Income -- -- -- --
Effective Percentage Affordable on Base Project 10.0% 15.6% 10.0% 12.2% Extremely Low-Income -- -- 5.6% 4.4%
Very Low-Income 5.6% 7.8% 4.4% 4.4%
Low-Income 4.4% 7.8% -- 3.3%
Moderate-Income -- -- -- --
Density Bonus Triggered: 20% 27.5% 32.5% 27.50%
Unit Calculations for Projects with a Density Bonus
Number of Units in the Base Project 90 90 90 90
Density Bonus Percent 20.0% 27.5% 32.5% 27.5%
Density Bonus Units (rounded up) 18 25 30 25
Total Project Units, including Bonus Units 108 115 120 115 Total Inclusionary Units 9 14 9 11
Net Affordable Percentage 8.3% 12.2% 7.5% 9.6%
Source: Strategic Economics, 2026.
2991 SHATTUCK AVE, #203 | BERKELEY, CA. 94705 | P: 510.647.5291| STRATEGICECONOMICS.COM
MEMORANDUM
To: Jay Bradford, Community Development Director, Town of Los Altos Hills From: Dena Belzer, Jake Cummings
Date: October 30, 2026
Project: Residential Feasibility Study and Inclusionary Analysis for Los Altos Hills Subject: Additional Policy Scenario
Memo Purpose
Los Altos Hills is one of six Santa Clara County cities participating in a consortium that retained Strategic Economics to prepare what is referred to as a Grand Nexus Study. This study provided the necessary technical analyses required to implement or revise three affordable housing policy tools.
The three tools included residential impact fees, inclusionary housing requirements and associated in-lieu fees, and commercial linkage fees. Each city could select which studies they needed based on how many of the three tools they wanted to consider adopting or revising.
Strategic Economics prepared a Residential Feasibility Study and Inclusionary Analysis report for Los Altos Hills that was completed in June 2026. The study includes an analysis of the feasibility of various inclusionary policy alternatives for the Town to consider during the adoption process for an inclusionary ordinance. The study also includes an analysis of “in-lieu fees” that would be equivalent to meeting each of the several inclusionary housing policy scenarios.
After completion of the study, the Town requested Strategic Economics to analyze one additional policy alternative that was not included in the original study. This memo includes an updated feasibility and in-lieu fee analysis that includes this additional policy alternative. A complete description of the assumptions and methodology for this analysis can be found in the Residential Inclusionary Study and Feasibility Analysis report for Los Altos Hills.
Additional Sensitivity Analysis for the Five-Story Condo Prototype As part of the feasibility analysis process, Strategic Economics tested the impact of different potential inclusionary policy scenarios on feasibility for all building and tenure prototypes included in the policy scenarios. The results from these analyses were also compared against feasibility by product type and tenure with no inclusionary requirement. Findings for the rental scenario analysis showed that all of the prototypes were infeasible even with no inclusionary requirements, indicating that the inclusionary policy was not a factor in determining project feasibility. For the ownership prototypes, the townhouse product was feasible under every scenario. However, the five-story condo prototype fell just below the residual land value feasibility threshold when requiring 15 percent inclusionary units targeting incomes at 110 percent of AMI (“Scenario A”), making this option only moderately infeasible. An additional policy (“Scenario D”) has subsequently been tested to provide the Town with a fourth policy option for the five-story condo prototype. This option would require 10 percent inclusionary units targeting an income level of 110 percent of AMI. As Figure 1 below shows, reducing the inclusionary ITEM 7B, Attachment 4
2 requirement in Scenario A by five percent (Scenario D), does push this ownership product type over the feasibility threshold.
If the City were to adopt a 10 percent inclusionary requirement targeting the 110 percent AMI income, the equivalent in-lieu fee for the 5-Story Condo prototype would be $81, as shown in Figure 2.
Figure 1: Residual Land Value Per Unit Compared to Land Costs Per Unit by Ownership Inclusionary Policy Scenario
Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
Note: Scenario A refers to a 15 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI). Scenario B refers to a 15 percent low-income requirement (tested at 70% AMI). Scenario C refers to a 15 percent requirement split between low-income and moderate-income. Scenario D refers to a 10 percent moderate-income requirement (tested at 110% AMI).
Figure 2: Equivalent In-Lieu Fee per Net Square Foot Corresponding to Revenue Foregone from Inclusionary Policy in Los Altos Hills, by Scenario – Ownership Prototypes Sources: Strategic Economics, 2025; Town of Los Altos Hills, 2025; Developer Interviews, 2025; Redfin, 2025.
August 5, 2026
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Re: Housing Element Program A-6 - Proposed Inclusionary Housing Ordinance and Aäordable Housing In-Lieu Fee Program
By E-mail: [email protected]
CC: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; Dear Town of Los Altos Hills Planning Commission,
The California Housing Defense Fund (“CalHDF”) submits this letter as a public comment concerning Item 6.4 on the agenda for the Planning Commission meeting (Discussion of Housing Element Program A-6 Proposed Inclusionary Housing Ordinance and AǸordable Housing In-Lieu Fee Program) scheduled for August 6, 2026.
First, the State Density Bonus Law (“DBL”; Gov’t. Code § 65915 et seq.) preempts provisions in local ordinances that conflict with the DBL by increasing the requirements to obtain the DBL’s beneDZits. Second, Housing Element Program A-6 mandates that the Town of Los Altos Hills (“Town”) conduct an inclusionary zoning Feasibility Study to identify appropriate inclusionary requirements that will not constrain housing production. Program A-6 also requires that the Town DZirst determine that an inclusionary housing program is economically feasible before adopting an inclusionary housing ordinance. However, the Town’s own study shows that application of the proposed ordinance would result in two rental prototypes that are infeasible under current market conditions and one ownership prototype that is marginally infeasible.
While it is laudable that the Town is considering an inclusionary zoning ordinance, the proposed ordinance has serious legal problems. The Town must address these problems before adopting the ordinance.
2201 Broadway, PH1, Oakland, CA 94612
www.calhdf.org
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
ITEM 7B, Attachment 5
The State Density Bonus Law Preempts the Town’s Proposed Ordinance The DBL governs all cities and counties. See Gov’t. Code § 65915, subd. (a)(1) (“local government shall comply with this section”). As several appellate decisions have concluded, the DBL preempts provisions in local ordinances that conflict with the DBL. See, e.g., Bankers Hill 150 v. City of San Diego (2022) 74 Cal.App.5th 755, 771 (DBL preempts any inconsistent local provisions); Schneider v. City of Los Angeles (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 549, 558 (local ordinance is preempted if it conflicts with the DBL by increasing the requirements to obtain its beneDZits); Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 1160, 1169 (local ordinance is void to the extent it requires a developer to dedicate a larger percentage of its units to aǸordable housing than the DBL requires). Furthermore, the Town’s compliance with the DBL is mandatory: if a proposed project satisDZies the terms of the DBL, then the project is entitled to take advantage of the DBL. The Town “cannot choose to forgo application of land use policies imposed by the Legislature.” Ailanto Properties, Inc. v.
City of Half Moon Bay (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 572, 595.) There is no room for cities to add their own gloss on the DBL, and attempts to do so have no eǸect.
The bottom line is this: if a proposed development project complies with the terms of the DBL, it may use the DBL. It does not matter whether the local government has nominally created additional hurdles that must be cleared before a project may use the DBL. Under state law, those nominal hurdles are void.
The Town’s proposed inclusionary ordinance would create such nominal hurdles.
The Town’s Proposed Ordinance Impermissibly Regulates Bonus Units awarded by the Density Bonus Law
The Town’s proposed ordinance establishes that all ownership and rental for residential developments shall include either “the number of inclusionary units required under Section
10.1-1804 or pay the in-lieu fee required under Section 10-1.1805, unless an alternative is proposed by the developer and approved as described in Section 10.1-1806.” Ordinance Section 10.1-1803. The proposed ordinance includes a list of exempted projects. Id. at subsection (c). However, this list of exemptions does not include “bonus” units awarded by the DBL. Id. In fact, the proposed ordinance expressly purports to apply to these bonus units:
Density Bonus Qualifying AǸordable Units. If the developer is proposing to provide aǸordable units in exchange for an increase in density, or concessions, incentives, or waivers/modiDZications of development standards pursuant to the State Density Bonus Law (Government Code Section 65915) and pursuant to Article 17 of this Chapter, those aǸordable units may count as inclusionary units provided they meet the requirements outlined in this article. When a density bonus is granted, the 2 of 6
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
inclusionary requirements of this article will apply to the entire project, including the bonus units.
Ordinance Section 10-1.1808(d)(3) (emphasis added).
In Opinion No. 24-501 (attached) issued on April 2, 2025, the Attorney General addressed the following question: “While nothing in the Density Bonus Law requires the density-bonus units to themselves qualify as aǸordable, may a city or county nevertheless impose its own aǸordable housing requirements on such units?” The Attorney General stated unequivocally:
No. A city or county may not impose aǸordable housing requirements on density-bonus units that are awarded under the Density Bonus Law because it would impermissibly conflict with the state law formula for calculating how many density-bonus units are awarded per aǸordable unit under state law. Because of this conflict, the state Density Bonus Law would preempt the contemplated local legislation.
Opinion No. 24-501 at 1 (emphasis added). As the Attorney General explained, the DBL does not provide that bonus units awarded by the DBL must be aǸordable. Instead, those bonus units are an incentive provided by the Legislature and a reward for including aǸordable units within a residential development. Accordingly, a local ordinance imposing local aǸordability requirements on bonus units conflicts with the DBL by requiring developers to include more aǸordable units within the development. Id. at 6.
Notably, the Town’s own consultant, Strategic Economics, emphasized the same point in its Feasibility Study, stating that “Any “bonus” units enabled by the {DBL} do not have to be aǸordable. Because of this, [DBL] projects commonly result in an overall project with a lower percentage of aǸordable units than the percentage in the local inclusionary policy.” Feasibility Study, p. 194 of 227 in Planning Commission’s Agenda Packet (inserts added in brackets).
The Town’s proposed Ordinance also provides: “The unit mix (i.e., the number of bedrooms per unit) of the inclusionary units shall be in the same proportion as the unit mix of the market rate units.” Ordinance Section 10-1.1804(f). In addition, “Inclusionary units must be evenly dispersed throughout a residential development project and be comparable in construction quality and exterior design to the market rate units.” Ordinance, Section 10-1.1807(a).
Such provisions DZind no support in the text of the DBL and clash with the text of the DBL, which makes no mention of the size or physical characteristics of the bonus units. As the Attorney General determined, nothing in the DBL requires the bonus units themselves to 3 of 6
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
qualify as aǸordable. Instead, “the bonus units, priced at a market rate, are intended to help oǸset the cost to the developer of building the required percentage of below-market, aǸordable units.” Opinion No. 24-501 at 3-4; see also Gov’t Code § 65917 (“In enacting this chapter it is the intent of the Legislature that the density bonus or other incentives oǸered by the city . . . pursuant to this chapter shall contribute signiDZicantly to the economic feasibility of lower income housing in proposed housing developments.” In sum, imposing the Town’s local aǸordable housing requirements on the bonus units awarded by the DBL would directly thwart the Legislature’s intent. The Town must therefore exempt the bonus units awarded by the DBL from its proposed ordinance.
The Town Failed to Determine that its Inclusionary Housing Program Is Economically Feasible
Housing Element Program A-6 mandated that the Town conduct an inclusionary zoning Feasibility Study to identify appropriate inclusionary requirements that will not constrain housing production. After participating in a multi-jurisdictional feasibility analysis process through the Santa Clara County Planning Collaborative, the Town subsequently retained Strategic Economics to prepare a Residential Feasibility Study and Inclusionary Housing Analysis (“Feasibility Study”) to evaluate the DZinancial feasibility of ownership and rental housing types in Los Altos Hills, and to assess how various inclusionary housing requirements could aǸect future development.
The Feasibility Study used four residential prototypes to evaluate DZinancial feasibility, two ownership prototypes (townhome and condo) and two rental prototypes (small-scale rental and 6-story rental). Feasibility Study, Agenda Packet, p. 171 of 227. In the Feasibility Study, Strategic Economics found that both ownership prototypes are currently feasible in Los Altos Hills before considering any inclusionary policy scenario. Id. at 180, Figure 15 at 181.
After applying inclusionary policy scenarios, however, Strategic Economics found that the tested policy scenarios for ownership housing are DZinancially feasible for the Townhome prototype, but marginally infeasible for the Condo prototype. Id. at 184, Figure 19 at 185.
Strategic Economics determined that neither of the two rental prototypes is feasible in Los Altos Hills under current market conditions. Id. at 182, Figures 17 and 18 on p. 183. Strategic Economics then concluded that because the rental prototypes are infeasible under current market conditions without an inclusionary policy, “the tested inclusionary policies are unlikely to be operative until market conditions improve.” Id. at 185, Figure 20 on p. 186.
Program A-6 also required that the Town DZirst determine that an inclusionary housing program is economically feasible before adopting an inclusionary housing ordinance. As outlined above, Strategic Economics concluded that after applying inclusionary policy scenarios, only the townhome ownership prototype would be feasible. The condo ownership prototype is marginally infeasible, and both rental prototypes would be infeasible under current market conditions even before considering an inclusionary policy. 4 of 6
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
Despite these DZindings in the Feasibility Study, the Town has proposed an inclusionary policy ordinance. Moreover, in that proposed ordinance, the Town has also required the developer of a rental project to either pay an in-lieu fee or include 7.5% of the dwelling units as low-income rental units and 7.5% of the dwelling units as very-low-income rental units.
Ordinance, Section 10-1.1804(b). This scenario results in the lowest Residual Land Value per unit among the inclusionary policy options evaluated by Strategic Economics. Id. at 186, Figure 20. Moreover, it ignores Strategic Economics’ warning that targeting an inclusionary policy to extremely low-income households may be difDZicult to implement. Id. at 196.
Strategic Economics explained that “housing built for extremely low-income households is generally provided in dedicated developments that include supportive services.” Id. As the consultant stated, “there are few precedents for including this income group in an inclusionary policy, and it could place signiDZicant burdens on development.” Id. (emphasis added).
According to Housing Element Program A-6, the purpose of the Feasibility Study was “to identify appropriate inclusionary requirements that will not constrain housing production.” Id. at 211. Given this purpose, the proposed ordinance does not comply with the mandate set out in Program A-6. In fact, the inclusionary policies in this proposed ordinance should be rejected because the ordinance will unduly constrain the production of housing.
In Opinion No. 24-501, the Attorney General pointed out that local governments could add other incentives to encourage the construction of low-income housing. As the Attorney General stated:
It is conceivable that a city or county could award more bonus units than the state law requires as a means of increasing the number of units in the development --including aǸordable ones. Indeed, the Density Bonus Law expressly allows as much and speciDZies that such additional bonus units granted by a locality are not counted in the state formula in determining a bonus.
Opinion No. 24-501 at 9-10; see Gov’t Code § 65915 (n) (“If permitted by local ordinance, nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a city . . . from granting a density bonus greater than what is described in this section for a development that meets the requirements of this section”). The Town should consider ways to increase incentives that would allow ownership or rental properties to pencil out under today’s market conditions. ⧫⧫⧫
CalHDF applauds the Town’s ongoing eǸorts to consider an appropriate inclusionary zoning ordinance. However, the Town must be careful not to attempt to illegally limit the application of the DBL through this proposed ordinance. The Town “cannot choose to forgo 5 of 6
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
application of land use policies imposed by the Legislature.” Ailanto Properties, Inc., 142 Cal.App.4th at 595. The Town should also refrain from adopting an inclusionary zoning ordinance that is not economically feasible.
CalHDF is a 501(c)(3) non-proDZit corporation whose mission includes advocating for increased access to housing for Californians at all income levels, including low-income households. You may learn more about CalHDF at www.calhdf.org.
Sincerely,
Dylan Casey
CalHDF Executive Director
James M. Lloyd
CalHDF Director of Planning and Investigations
6 of 6
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
State of California
ROB BONTA
Attorney General
_______________
OPINION
of
ROB BONTA
Attorney General
CATHERINE BIDART
Deputy Attorney General
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
No. 24-501
April 2, 2025
The HONORABLE MONIQUE LIMÓN, MEMBER OF THE STATE SENATE, has requested an opinion on a question relating to affordable housing.
QUESTION PRESENTED AND CONCLUSION
The Density Bonus Law, codified at Government Code sections 65915-65918, seeks to incentivize real estate developers to build affordable housing for rental or sale at below-market prices for households with qualifying incomes. It does so by allowing developers who include a specified amount of affordable housing units in their developments to build more housing units—referred to as “density-bonus units” or “bonus units”—than would otherwise be permitted by local regulations that limit building density. While nothing in the Density Bonus Law requires the density-bonus units to themselves qualify as affordable, may a city or county nevertheless impose its own affordable housing requirements on such units?
No. A city or county may not impose affordable housing requirements on density-bonus units that are awarded under the Density Bonus Law because it would impermissibly conflict with the state law formula for calculating how many density-bonus units are awarded per affordable unit under state law. Because of this conflict, the state Density Bonus Law would preempt the contemplated local legislation. A city or county may, however, award its own density-bonus units in addition to those awarded Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
under the Density Bonus Law and may impose affordable housing requirements on those additional units.
BACKGROUND
In 1979, the Legislature enacted the Density Bonus Law “to address the shortage of affordable housing in California.”1
Since then, the Law has been amended dozens of
times, but its goal of providing more affordable housing remains unchanged.2 To
understand this law and the question before us, it is helpful to have some familiarity with the concepts of density and affordable housing.
“Density” refers to how many units of housing may be built on a property. “Affordable” housing as relevant here refers to housing that is mandated to be restricted for rent or sale below the market rate and is restricted to households with an income at or below certain thresholds. A preliminary step in building affordable housing is obtaining necessary permits from the governing city or county. Through local regulation such as zoning ordinances and general plans, cities and counties regulate and limit the number— that is, the density—of housing units that may lawfully be built on a given property.
Indeed, state law requires each city and county to adopt a “long-term general plan” for development and requires the plan to include density standards regulating how many units may be built on a parcel of property within the city or county.3 Density standards
1 Latinos Unidos Del Valle De Napa Y Solano v. County of Napa (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 1160, 1164 (Latinos Unidos); Stats. 1979, ch. 1207, § 10, p. 4748, eff. Oct. 2, 1979. The Density Bonus Law is located within the Planning and Zoning Law. (Gov. Code, §§ 65000-66499.58; Wollmer v. City of Berkeley (2009) 179 Cal.App.4th 933, 940-941.) 2 The Legislature has also since enacted other legislation with the goal of more affordable housing in our state, including legislation sponsored by the Attorney General. (See, e.g., Stats. 2024, ch. 268 (enacting Assembly Bill 1893 to amend Housing Accountability Act provisions relating to so-called “Builder’s Remedy” that requires approval of certain affordable-housing projects); Assem. Com. on Housing and Community Development, Assem. Floor Analysis of Assem. Bill no. 1893 (2023-2024 Reg. Sess.), as amended Aug. 23, 2024, p. 4 (referring to Attorney General as sponsor); see also Stats. 2024, ch. 293 (enacting Senate Bill 1037 to create new related remedies), Senate Rules Committee, Floor Analysis of Sen. Bill no. 1037 (2023-2024 Reg. Sess.), as amended Aug. 23, 2024, p. 8 (referring to Attorney General as source).)
3 Friends of Lagoon Valley v. City of Vacaville (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 807, 815 (Friends of Lagoon Valley), citing Gov. Code, § 65300; see also Gov. Code, § 65302 (“general plan shall consist of a statement of development policies and shall include a diagram or diagrams and text setting forth objectives, principles, standards, and plan proposals”).
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
may vary within a city or county; some areas may be designated as allowing (or “zoned”) for high or medium density, and others for low density.
The Density Bonus Law overrides these local limits on density. The Law’s aim is to incentivize housing developers to build affordable housing.4 If a developer includes a
certain percentage of affordable housing in a proposed residential development, the developer may build more units on the property than a city’s or county’s local regulations would otherwise allow.5
In other words, a developer who agrees to build a certain percentage of affordable housing is rewarded under the Density Bonus Law with permission to build more residences than would otherwise be permitted by local law.6
The developer thus receives a “bonus” increase in the number, or density, of units they are allowed to build on the property (hence, the Density Bonus Law).7
Nothing in the Density Bonus Law requires the bonus units themselves to qualify as affordable, i.e., below-market.8
Instead, the bonus units, priced at a market rate, are
intended to help offset the cost to the developer of building the required percentage of 4 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (u); Friends of Lagoon Valley, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th at p. 824; Bankers Hill 150 v. City of San Diego (2022) 74 Cal.App.5th 755, 763. 5 Gov. Code, § 65915, subds. (a), (b), (f); Friends of Lagoon Valley, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th at p. 824; see Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (h)(4)(i) (defining housing development as one including at least five residential units). 6 Friends of Lagoon Valley, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th at p. 824 (“Although application of the statute can be complicated, its aim is fairly simple: When a developer agrees to construct a certain percentage of the units in a housing development for low or very low income households . . . , the city or county must grant the developer one or more itemized concessions and a ‘density bonus,’ which allows the developer to increase the density of the development by a certain percentage above the maximum allowable limit under local zoning law”).
7 See ibid.; Gov. Code, § 65915, subds. (a), (b), (f). In addition to a density bonus, a developer may elect to receive what are referred to as incentives or concessions, which may include, for example, waivers or reductions in development standards, such as setbacks or parking ratios that would otherwise be required. (Gov. Code, § 65915, subds. (a)(3)(D)(i)(lll), (b), (d), (k).) A developer may receive similar incentives or concessions for developments that include housing for seniors, transitional foster youth, veterans with disabilities, or persons experiencing homelessness, or that include child-care facilities. (Id., § 65915, subds. (b)(1)(C) & (E), (h).)
8 See Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (b)(1) (requiring density bonus when developer proposes certain percentage of affordable units “excluding any units permitted by the density bonus awarded pursuant to this section”).
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
below-market, affordable units.9
Rather than seeking “additional public subsidy” from
the taxpayer, the Density Bonus Law uses regulatory incentives to encourage developers to build more affordable housing.10
If a proposed development meets the requirements of the Density Bonus Law, the city or county is required to award a density bonus.11 In general, the density bonus grows larger as more affordable housing is included in the project, both in quantity (number of units) and degree of affordability (low income or very low income, typically measured as 80% and 50%, respectively, of a county’s median family income).12 For example, 9 Gov. Code, §§ 65915, subd. (u) (finding and declaring intent “to allow public entities to reduce or even eliminate subsidies for a particular project by allowing a developer to include more total units in a project than would otherwise be allowed by the local zoning ordinance in exchange for affordable units”), 65917 (“In enacting this chapter it is the intent of the Legislature that the density bonus or other incentives offered by the city, county, or city and county pursuant to this chapter shall contribute significantly to the economic feasibility of lower income housing in proposed housing developments. . . .”); cf. id., § 65915, subd. (d)(1) (identifying lack of cost savings for developer as reason city or county may deny developer’s requested concession or incentive). 10 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (u) (finding and declaring intent to reduce or eliminate public subsidy and “cover at least some of the financing gap of affordable housing with regulatory incentives, rather than additional public subsidy”). 11 Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at p. 1167 (“section 65915 imposes a clear and unambiguous mandatory duty on municipalities to award a density bonus when a developer agrees to dedicate a certain percentage of the overall units in a development to affordable housing”); Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (b) (“A city, county, or city and county shall grant one density bonus . . .,” emphasis added), id., § 14 (“‘[s]hall’ is mandatory”), California Correctional Peace Officers Assn. v. State Personnel Bd. (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1133, 1143 (when interpreting statutes, presumption is “shall” is mandatory). 12 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (f); Bankers Hill 150 v. City of San Diego, supra, 74 Cal.App.5th at pp. 755, 770 (“Subdivision (f) of section 65915 includes tables that prescribe a density bonus percentage, which progressively increases as a developer agrees to add a greater percentage of affordable units in the Project. The higher the percentage of affordable units, the higher the percentage of the density bonus allowing a developer to exceed the zoned density”); see Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (b)(1)(A) & (B) (defining “lower income” and “very low income” with reference to Health and Safety Code sections that adopt definitions in “Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937,” Title 42 of the United States Code, section 1437 et seq.); Megan Kirkeby, Deputy Director of the California Department of Housing and Community Development, mem.
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
including 10% low-income units yields a 20% density bonus, while 24% low-income units yields a 50% density bonus.13 Five percent very-low-income units yields a 20% bonus, while 15% very-low-income units yields a 50% density bonus.14
ANALYSIS
We are asked if a city or county may impose affordability requirements on the bonus units that are awarded under the Density Bonus Law. Specifically, when a developer has included the requisite percentage of affordable housing units in a proposed project to qualify for a density bonus under the Density Bonus Law, may a city or county require the resulting bonus units to be affordable? In short, the answer is no.
The question posed raises an issue of preemption. The Density Bonus Law governs all cities and counties.15 The California Constitution provides that “[a] county or city may make and enforce within its limits all local, police, sanitary, and other ordinances and regulations not in conflict with general laws.”16 But a local ordinance that conflicts with the Density Bonus Law is invalid.17 As the Court of Appeal has recognized, local requirements are preempted by the Density Bonus Law when they increase what a developer must do to obtain its benefits.18 As a preliminary matter, cities and counties may, and often do, require new proposed housing developments to include a certain amount of affordable housing.19 The to Interested Parties, May 9, 2024 (describing and setting forth Section 8 levels for low income and very low income), pp. 1-2, 6-14 available at https://www.hcd.ca.gov/sites /default/files/docs/grants-and-funding/income-limits-2024.pdf (as of April 2, 2025). 13 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (f)(1).
14 Id., subd. (f)(2).
15 Gov. Code, §§ 65915, subd. (a) (“When an applicant seeks a density bonus for a housing development within, or for the donation of land for housing within, the jurisdiction of a city, county, or city and county, that local government shall comply with this section. . . .”), 65918 (Density Bonus Law applies to charter cities). 16 Cal. Const., art. XI, § 7.
17 Ibid.; Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at p. 1169. 18 Schreiber v. City of Los Angeles (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 549, 558 (“A local ordinance is preempted if it conflicts with the density bonus law by increasing the requirements to obtain its benefits”); Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at p. 1169 (“To the extent the ordinance requires a developer to dedicate a larger percentage of its units to affordable housing than required by section 65915, the ordinance is void”). 19 California Building Industry Assn. v. City of San Jose (2015) 61 Cal.4th 435, 441.
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
Density Bonus Law contemplates as much, and counts those affordable units required by a city or county as affordable units proposed by a developer in determining the number of bonus units that must be awarded.20 But the Density Bonus Law does not provide that bonus units awarded pursuant to the Law must be affordable—instead, those bonus units are an incentive and a reward for including affordable units within the development.21 The question we must answer is whether imposing a local affordability requirement on the bonus units themselves would conflict with the Density Bonus Law.
We conclude that it would conflict with the Density Bonus Law by requiring the developer to include more affordable units than the formula adopted by the Legislature requires. To encourage the construction of affordable housing, the Legislature has developed a formula in which a certain amount of proposed affordable units yields a certain amount of bonus units that would not otherwise be permitted by a city or county due to local density limits.22 Put more simply, the amount of affordable units the developer initially proposes determines the amount of bonus units received. And, the amount of affordable units (pre-density bonus units) includes whatever amount a city or county may require to be affordable in proposed developments.23 In contrast, the state law does not provide that local affordability requirements apply to the bonus units awarded—rather, the bonus units are the incentive and reward for including affordable units to begin with, and presumably help offset the cost of building those affordable units.24 It has been suggested that nothing expressly prohibits applying local affordability requirements to the bonus units. But the express directive in the Law to apply such local requirements in counting the number of affordable units to pre-density-bonus units strongly implies that they apply there alone.25 The same implication arises from the 20 See fn. 23, post, and corresponding text in the body. 21 See ante, fns. 4-7 and corresponding text in the body. 22 Gov. Code, § 65915, subds. (b), (f).
23 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (o)(9)(A)(ii) (expressly stating that “total units” counting towards density bonus include units “designated to satisfy an inclusionary zoning requirement”); see id. subds. (b) (“total units” counting towards density bonus exclude density-bonus units), (f) (setting forth percentages of total units with resulting percentages of density-bonus units); see also California Building Industry Assn. v. City of San Jose, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 441 (explaining what are known as local “inclusionary” zoning and housing ordinances to require a certain percentage of affordable housing in new developments).
24 See ante, fns. 4-9, and corresponding text in the body. 25 See Gov. Code, § 65915, subds. (b) (requiring density bonus based on affordable Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
related requirement in the Law to exclude bonus units when calculating affordable units as a percentage of total units.26
In sum, we believe that applying local affordability requirements to bonus units would conflict with the state law formula of how many affordable units are required to receive the bonus units, contrary to the Legislature’s intent. We therefore conclude that local affordability requirements may not be applied to bonus units awarded under the Density Bonus Law.
The Courts of Appeal have reached similar conclusions where a local law has diminished the benefits of the Density Bonus Law.27 Of those decisions, the most relevant here arose under a county ordinance that required a certain percentage of affordable units in all new developments.28 The county did not count the affordable units it required towards a density bonus under the Density Bonus Law.29 The ordinance impermissibly required a developer to include a higher percentage of affordable units than the Density Bonus Law requires “by excluding from the target units necessary to qualify for the density bonus those units necessary to satisfy the county’s inclusionary requirement.”30 The court explained that “allowing the county to increase the minimum housing included in “total units” proposed “excluding any units permitted by the density bonus”), (o)(9)(A)(i)-(ii) (defining “total units” to count towards bonus to exclude density-bonus units, but to include units to satisfy local affordability requirements). 26 Ibid.
27 See, e.g., Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1165-1166, 1169 (concluding county ordinance was preempted by Density Bonus Law because it required new developments to include certain percentage of affordable housing but did not count those units in calculating density bonus under section 65915); California Building Industry Assn. v. City of Oceanside (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 744, 770-771 (concluding city ordinance is preempted because it excluded from exemption to city growth limit low-income and senior housing built with a density bonus, discouraging developers from proposing such housing that would otherwise qualify for bonuses). 28 Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at p. 1165.
29 Ibid. Since then, the Legislature has provided additional clarity on the issue—for example, expressly defining the “total units” of affordable units proposed (to count for calculating the density bonus) as including units designated to meet local affordability requirements. (See, e.g., Stats. 2021, ch. 340 (enacting Senate Bill 290 to add subdivision (o)(6), which is now subdivision (o)(9), to Government Code section 65915); see ante, fns. 23, 25 and corresponding text in the body (drawing upon and citing to Government Code section 65915, subdivision (o)(9).)
30 Latinos Unidos, supra, 217 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1165-1166.
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
number of affordable units required for a density bonus would conflict with subdivision (f) of section 65915, which bases the amount of density bonus on the percentage of affordable housing units in the project.”31 The ordinance placed a “greater burden on developers than is permissible under state law.”32
Here, if a city or county were to impose local affordability requirements on units awarded as a density bonus under section 65915, it would likewise place a greater burden on developers to obtain the bonus units than state law does. It would effectively require a developer to build a higher percentage of affordable units than section 65915 requires to obtain its benefits.
Some comments we received illustrated this greater burden on developers with examples. The clearest one involves a proposal to build 100 housing units, with 15 percent of them (i.e., 15 units) very-low-income units. The Density Bonus Law would award the developer a 50-percent density bonus; that is, the developer would be permitted to build 50 units more than local zoning rules would otherwise allow.33 So in this example there would be a total of 150 units: 15 very-low-income units, and the 135 market-rate units (including the 50 units awarded as a bonus). If instead the development were subject to a local requirement that 15 percent of the entire resulting 150-unit development must be very-low-income units, the project would need 23 very-low-income units (rounding up) rather than 15, to receive a bonus in the same amount of 50 units.34 The developer would have to finance and build eight more very-low-income units to get the 50-unit density bonus that the developer is otherwise entitled to receive under the state density bonus formula, thereby altering and conflicting with that formula for purposes of a preemption analysis.
Some input we received argues that the resulting increase in affordable housing units aligns with the legislative intent to create more affordable housing. Others believe that imposing local affordability requirements on bonus units awarded under the Density Bonus Law would disincentivize building affordable housing, contrary to legislative intent. It is not our role, however, to determine which approach would result in more affordable housing being built. The Legislature has determined how many affordable units to require for how much of a reward. Because a local affordability requirement on the reward would conflict with the Legislature’s determination, such a requirement is preempted.
31 Id. at pp. 1167-1168.
32 Id. at p. 1166.
33 Gov. Code, § 65915, subd. (f)(2).
34 Id., § 65915, subds. (f)(5) (directing to round up), (q) (same).
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
An advocate for a contrary conclusion cites an excerpt from a Memorandum by the Department of Housing and Community Development as support for the view that local affordability requirements may apply to density-bonus units.35 But the excerpt pertains to an entirely different statutory scheme, the Housing Element Law, and arose in the context of when affordable housing projects under that Law are “by-right” (meaning the locality must ministerially approve the project).36 Specifically, the Memorandum presented a hypothetical “shortfall” zoning scenario, where a city failed to hit prior housing element targets—an entirely different situation from density-bonus applications, where the goal is to incentivize developers to build more affordable housing units. In that “shortfall” zoning scenario, the entire number of units in the development, whether it utilizes the Density Bonus Law or not, must meet a 20 percent affordability requirement to meet the by-right provisions of the Housing Element Law.37 The Memorandum explains that to invoke the by-right provisions, 20 percent of the whole project must be affordable, and all units (even bonus units awarded under the Density Bonus Law) count in calculating the 20 percent. Nothing in the Memorandum, therefore, contradicts the judicial interpretations of the Density Bonus Law.
We emphasize that our conclusion does not preclude a city or county from imposing affordability requirements on additional bonus units awarded under local law, and not under the Density Bonus Law. It is conceivable that a city or county could award more bonus units than the state law requires as a means of increasing the number of units in the development—including affordable ones. Indeed, the Density Bonus Law expressly allows as much and specifies that such additional bonus units granted by a locality are not counted in the state formula in determining a bonus.38 Also, the Court of 35 See Department of Housing and Community Development Memorandum from Megan Kirkeby, Acting Deputy Director of the Division of Housing Policy Development, on Housing Element Site Inventory Guidebook, Government Code Section 65583.2, dated June 10, 2020, p. 38, available at https://www.hcd.ca.gov/community-development/ housing-element/docs/sites_inventory_memo_final06102020.pdf (as of April 2, 2025). 36 Id., pp. 1 (“The housing element of the general plan must include an inventory of land suitable and available for residential development to meet the locality’s regional housing need by income level. The purpose of this Guidebook is to assist jurisdictions and interested parties with the development of the site inventory analysis” and identify recent changes in relevant laws), 39 (recent changes to Housing Element Law). 37 See Gov. Code, § 65583.2, subd. (c).
38 Id., § 65915, subds. (n) (“If permitted by local ordinance, nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a city, county, or city and county from granting a density bonus greater than what is described in this section for a development that meets the Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
Appeal has determined that a locality may do so, reasoning that a greater bonus furthered the objectives of the Law.39 Should a city or county ordinance offer a developer even more density as a reward, it could impose affordability requirements on those units without affecting the Density Bonus Law’s formula for how many bonus units are awarded under state law. It would leave that formula intact because the local affordability requirements would only apply to those units awarded under local law on top of what was already awarded under the state law. As a result, there would be no preemptive conflict with the Density Bonus Law. As explained above, however, a locality may not apply affordability requirements to the bonus units awarded under the Density Bonus Law itself because it would conflict with the formula set forth in that Law. requirements of this section . . .”), (o)(9)(A)(i) (units used to calculate density bonus are referred to as “total units” and “[e]xclud[e] a unit added by a density bonus awarded pursuant to this section or any local law granting a greater density bonus”). 39 Friends of Lagoon Valley, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th at pp. 823-826.
Item 5.3 Supplemental 1
August 6, 2026
Re: August 6, 2026, Agenda Item 5.3 – Inclusionary Housing Ordinance Dear Chair Indaco and the Los Altos Hills Planning Commission:
The League of Women Voters (LWV) supports actions that increase the stock of housing and particularly affordable housing.
The LWV thanks the work staff and its consultants have done to research inclusionary housing. In light of the reports, we are concerned that the development of new multifamily housing might be constrained if the affordability conditions are set too high. We suggest that the requirements be no stricter than the minimum conditions to qualify for state density bonus (10% moderate income for homeownership, 10% low income, or 5% very low income).
The LWV also suggests that Los Altos Hills consider other ways to encourage affordable projects, such as by contributing to the funding of projects or creating attractive incentives to offset the financial impact on a developer.
Sincerely,
Susan Russell
Housing Committee Co-Chair
Los Altos-Mountain View Area LWV
C: Jay Bradford
Cody Einfalt
Item 5.3 Supplemental 2
ITEM 7B, Attachment 6
ITEM 7C
THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS November 12, 2026
Staff Report to the City Council
SUBJECT: Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) – File #SD25-0072, VAR25- 0016 – Lands of Vangala & Tokala
Consideration of: (1) Site Development Permit for the construction of a 4,584 square-foot, two-story single-family residence with attached garage (with a 793 square-foot attached Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) and a 999 square-foot attached SB 9 unit which are only subject to ministerial approval), and associated hardscape and site improvements; (2) Variance to permit a driveway width exceeding the maximum 14 feet; (3) a Grading Policy Exception to allow excavation exceeding the maximum cut thresholds for driveways; and (4) Williamson Act compatibility determination, and any potential directions for nonrenewal, as the property is subject to a Williamson Act contract for agricultural land conservation, and potential adoption of a resolution making findings to approve or to deny the proposed project.
CEQA review: Categorical Exemption per CEQA Guidelines Section 15303(a) FROM: Jay Bradford, Community Development Director
APPROVED: Cody Einfalt, City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:
That the City Council take one of the following actions:
1. Adopt a Resolution (Attachment 1) to find the proposed project categorically exempt from CEQA, determine the project is compatible with Government Code Section 51238.1 and the Williamson Act Contract for the project parcel dated January 17, 1972, and approve the Site Development Permit, Variance to allow a driveway width exceeding 14 feet, Grading Policy Exception, and associated project entitlements, subject to the revised Conditions of Approval. This option reflects the recommendation in staff reports to the Planning Commission dated August 6, September 3, and October 1, 2026. As a part of adopting this resolution, the City Council could direct staff to initiate the Williamson Act nonrenewal process pursuant to Government Code Section 512451 if it determines a contract is no longer appropriate.
2. Adopt a Resolution (Attachment 2) to deny the proposed project on the basis that the project is inconsistent with the principles of compatibility set forth in Government Code Section 51238.1 and the terms of the existing Williamson Act Contract. This option reflects the Planning Commission’s recommendation from its October 1, 2026 meeting. 1 All statutory section references in the staff report are to the Government Code, unless otherwise noted.
City Council Page 2
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
BACKGROUND
The parcel is part of Tract No. 2842, Fremont Hills Unit No. 6, which was approved by the City Council in 1961. The property consists of approximately 1.106 acres and is identified as APN 182- 05-034. Because the parcel is a vacant, undeveloped lot, it has not been assigned a street address.
As a result, the property is commonly identified by its Assessor's Parcel Number (APN 182-05- 034). According to historical aerials from Google Earth, the property appears to have remained vacant since subdivision. The parcel has a single frontage on La Barranca Road, which is public.
The site is covered by a canopy of heritage oak trees. Worksheet 1 (Attachment 14) indicates an average site slope of 33.3% and lot unit factor (LUF) of 0.554.
The property has been under a Williamson Act contract since 1972. In summary, the Williamson Act is a California law that encourages the preservation of agricultural and open-space land by allowing property owners to enter into contracts with local governments restricting development of their land. In exchange, the land is assessed based on its agricultural value rather than its market value, resulting in lower property taxes. Williamson Act have an initial10-year term which then auto renews each year. The property is currently enrolled in a 10-year contract and a nonrenewal or cancellation has not been initiated. Furthermore, the owner plans to maintain their Williamson Act-status and has incorporated their small farming business consisting of chicken farming and vegetable planting/sales into the project.
Because the property is subject to a Williamson Act contract, the project requires final action by City Council with a recommendation from the Planning Commission. The City Council is requested to act on the following:
• CEQA determination
• Findings of Compatibility with the Williamson Act
• Site Development Permit
• Variance
• Grading Policy Exception
Figure 1: APN 182-05-034 Source: LAH GIS
City Council Page 3
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
SUMMARY OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEETINGS AND PRIOR PROCEEDINGS The Planning Commission first considered the project on June 8, 2026. The Commission continued the item to allow additional review of the Williamson Act, obtain the Open Space Committee’s recommendation, which included a requirement for Open Space Easement Dedication (see Attachment 19), and allow the applicant to address site-development comments. The June 8, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 6.
At the August 6, 2026, meeting, staff recommended that the Planning Commission forward an approval recommendation to the City Council, including a finding that the project is compatible with the existing Williamson Act Contract and Government Code Section 51238.1. Staff also recommended that the City Council separately consider whether continued enrollment of the property under the Williamson Act remains appropriate. The August 6, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 5.
The August 6 revised plans eliminated the previously requested Maximum Development Area variance and removed the swimming pool from the project. It also reduced farming operations as detailed in the farming operation plans (see Attachment 20) submitted on 7/7/2025. Which included multiple 180 square foot mobile chicken coops. The updated plan following public feedback scaled the proposed plan to a 14ft x 14ft section of the existing proposed greenhouse and removed roosters from the farming plan, see Attachment 13. The remaining discretionary requests are the Site Development Permit for the single-family home (noting that the ADU and SB 9 units are reviewed separately under ministerial process), the driveway-width Variance, the Grading Policy Exception, and the Williamson Act compatibility determination.
On September 3, 2026, the Commission received additional staff report and legal analysis, continued discussion of the site-development issues, and identified specific modifications to the Conditions of Approval. The Commission then voted unanimously among the four members present to direct staff to return with a resolution to approve the project, containing the modifications identified on the record and a report regarding the Town’s consultation with the California Department of Conservation. The Commission gave direction for the approval resolution to return to the October 1, 2026 meeting on the Consent Calendar, which could be removed from consent if needed. The September 3, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 4.
In advance of the Planning Commission October 1, 2026 meeting, the City Attorney’s Office prepared and distributed a memo providing an overview of Williamson Act provisions and requirements (Attachment 7). On September 30, 2026, the Town received a letter from the law firm Hanson Bridgett on behalf of Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development objecting to a compatibility determination and approval of the project. At the meeting, the property owner/applicant provided comments stating that regulatory requirements should be applied uniformly to all residents. He cited another project in 2019 that was similarly covered by a Williamson Act contract where the Town did not conduct a similar level of analysis. The applicant also reiterated that the size of the agricultural operation was reduced to respond to neighborhood complaints during early stages of the project.
City Council Page 4
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
At the October 1 meeting, the Planning Commission removed the project item from the Consent Calendar and opened it for discussion, received public comment and deliberated on the matter.
The staff report for the October 1, 2026, Planning Commission is included as Attachment 3. At the end of deliberation, the Commission voted 3-1-1 (one no vote, one recusal) recommending that the City Council initiate non-renewal of the Williamson Act Contract and find that the proposed project is not compatible with Government Code Section 51238.1 and the existing Williamson Act contract. The Commission did not recommend approval of the project. In reaching this recommendation, planning commissioners commented that the Williamson Act contract allows the property owner to receive a tax reduction in exchange for retaining agricultural use on the property and it would appear the contract’s use of “dwellings” and “land uses” are only a technicality.
Commissioners also opined that the contract itself does not constitute compatibility rules, and the Town would have to adopt compatibility rules in order to find the project compatible with the Williamson Act. The intent of the Act was intended to protect open space and agriculture and reduce development; if a parcel under contract is allowed to develop to the same extent as a non-contracted parcel, then the intent of the Act would not be met. Commissioners also commented on the size of the parcel as inadequate for agricultural use and thus not compatible with the Act’s intent and principles.
On November 5, 2026, the Town received an additional letter from Hanson Bridgett on behalf of the citizen group, expressing additional objections to approval of the project (Attachment 16).
Responses to various arguments raised in the letter are addressed in the sections below.
WILLIAMSON ACT COMPATIBILITY AND CONTRACT ISSUES
To assist the Council with its consideration, this section summarizes the various issues regarding Williamson Act and contracted lands that have been raised by the applicant, reported on by staff, and considered by the Planning Commission.
• Determining Compatible Uses under State law and the Contract for this property As previously discussed in the prior Planning Commission reports, staff concluded that the proposed project, including the proposed residential uses, agricultural activities and open space preservation, are consistent with the principles of compatibility under Government Code Section 51238.1. Additionally, as also reported to the Planning Commission previously, the Williamson Act Contract for this project site specifically states that primary and secondary dwellings, both in plural forms, are compatible uses under the contract.
The Town’s Resolution No. 616 builds on prior ordinances establishing the town as a preserve, see attachment 9. Resolution No. 616 establishes rules governing administration of agricultural and open space preserves, which are the prerequisites to being able to offer and enter into Williamson Act contracts. Resolution No. 616 specifies uses “designated in Williamson Act contracts” are considered compatible uses in the preserve area.
Government Code section 51238.3(c)(2) states that for the purposes of the Williamson Act, “compatible uses” is considered to be expressly specified within the contract if it is specifically enumerated within the four corners of the contract.2 Per above, the contract for 2 It should be noted that at the outset, this provision is consistent with the “Four Corners” rule of contractual interpretation where, if the contract language is clear and unambiguous, courts will not be inclined to consider other materials outside a contract when interpreting its provisions. We do also note that the statute does provide, for
City Council Page 5
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
this property states residential dwellings are compatible uses on the contracted land. This information supports staff’s conclusion that the proposed project is compatible with the parcel’s contract.
At the October 1, 2026 Planning Commission meeting, the commission and public comments discussed whether the foregoing addresses compliance with the principles of compatibility under Section 51238.1, which in essence states that a proposed use is considered compatible if (a) it will not significantly compromise long-term agricultural capability of the subject parcel or other lands under contract; (b) will not significantly displace or impair agricultural operations on the subject parcel or other contracted lands; and (c) the use will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted lands from agricultural or open-space use. It should be noted that the draft Resolution for Approval (Attachment 1) contains language addressing these principles of compatibility. Namely, for example, the proposed project continues to propose agricultural activity and does not deprive the property, or other parcels in Los Altos Hills, of the ability to conduct agricultural operations. It also continues to propose open-space preservation uses and does not remove any adjacent property from proposing such use or remove them from the R-A zoning district.
The Planning Commission, during the course of its discussion, expressed counter viewpoints regarding compatibility issues. The Commission focused on the issue that agricultural use should be a “primary use” on contracted lands to fulfill the intent of the Williamson Act and contracts executed thereunder. While the Planning Commission acknowledges that the Contract states primary and secondary dwellings are compatible uses, commissioners did not feel that such designation fulfills the purposes of the Williamson Act which is to preserve agricultural lands and uses. Commissioners expressed that the Project site’s size was relatively small and even the Assessor’s Office would not recognize it as a contracted agriculture parcel. To fulfill the intent of the Act, the Project applicants should proceed with canceling the contract before undertaking development.
Commissioners also felt that because the Town does not have established compatibility rules for contracted lands, it is necessary to look to the Williamson Act compatibility principles to determine whether the Project proposes compatible use, which commissioners expressed did not support the Project being compatible with agriculture or the intent of the statute.
• Agricultural use as a “primary use” on the subject contracted project As stated above, the City Attorney provided a memo dated October 1, 2026, providing an overview of Williamson Act provisions and requirements and responding to frequently asked questions. The City Attorney’s memo reiterates that state law does not require agriculture must be a “primary” or “principal” use on contracted lands. Neither does state law define a percentage or limit where agricultural, open space, recreation, or other compatible uses must occupy a contracted land. The Williamson Act statute delegates responsibilities for establishing compatible use rules for contracted properties to local Williamson Act contracts signed on or before June 7, 1997, the compatible uses can include information from referenced documents as they existed when the contract was initially signed. Even under this language, however, Resolution No. 616 states that uses designated in a contract are considered compatible. There are no other compatibility use documents referenced in the contract for this property.
City Council Page 6
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
jurisdictions. Although the Town does not currently have a specific set of Williamson Act compatibility rules, it is not prevented from reviewing the proposed project against the current contract which specifies that residential dwellings are a compatible use.
The Planning Commission similarly expressed a different view that the agriculture use should be a primary use on the contracted property to fulfil the intent of the Williamson Act. Commissioner expressed that since the Town did not have its own compatibility rules, it does not appear to be consistent with the Act’s intent to have a contract with no limitations on the number of units. The Commission also received public comments regarding whether the proposed Project would impact agricultural uses in the surrounding properties or on non-contracted lands, which comments argues that a contracted land should not be allowed to include large residential developments as it is not consistent with the intent of the Williamson Act statute.
• Responses from the California Department of Conservation On September 9, 2026, Town staff received response email from the Department of Conservation regarding questions on Williamson Act compatibility, renewal and nonrenewal issues. The Department’s response is included as Attachment 11. In summary, the Department responses state that the Town is the ultimate deciding entity on a project’s compatibility with Williamson Act statutes, any existing Town rules and current contract provisions. The response listed several statutory provisions for reference, which were also included in the City Attorney’s memo. The Department’s response also states that there is no state law requirement for agricultural or commercial agricultural use to remain the primary use on a Williamson Act property. Attachment 11 provides additional details on these responses.
• Property Valuation and Responses from the County Assessor’s Office On August 28 and September 9, 2026, the County Assessor’s Office responded to staff inquiry explaining the tax valuation issue for the project site. In summary, the Assessor’s Office stated that pursuant to Revenue and Taxation Code section 428, and due to the site’s acreage, the subject parcel would be treated as a “homesite” and taxed at the standard property tax rate under Proposition 13 upon the property being used for a residence, and the parcel would not benefit from the reduced tax rate under the Williamson Act. The Assessor’s response is included as Attachment 12.
• State Housing Laws allowing SB 9 Units and ADUs
During the prior proceedings, some questions were raised as to whether state law would allow SB 9 units and ADUs to be constructed at this site. Staff does conclude that state law would require these units to be allowed, based on the following: (1) SB 9 requires the maximum-two-unit be permitted in a “single-family residential zone”, and the R-A zoning district is such a zone; (2) while SB 9 exempts certain “sensitive area” parcels largely similar to those set under SB 35, none of those are relevant or applicable in this case. Of those, the only potentially relevant area type is a “prime farmland or farmland of statewide importance, as defined by the federal Department of Agriculture land inventory and monitoring criteria as modified for California, and designated on the maps by the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the Department of Conservation, or land zoned or
City Council Page 7
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
designated for agricultural protection or preservation by a local ballot measure that was approved by the voters in Los Altos Hills.
The project site is not a designated agricultural protection area by the voters. There is also no evidence in the record that the site appears on Department of Conservation FMMP maps or that it meets the irrigation and soil requirements3 to qualify as prime farmland or farmland of statewide importance; and (3) likewise, ADUs are allowed in areas zoned to allow single-family and multi-family dwellings and does not exempt a specific type of property. SB 9 and ADUs are also covered under “primary and secondary dwellings” listed in the project site’s Williamson Act contract. In any event, the SB 9 and ADU proposals are not subject to a discretionary public hearing and are only considered ministerially. Staff notes that planning commissioners expressed that SB 9 and ADU allowance on contracted lands also seem to contradict the Williamson Act intent which is to preserve agricultural land with a reduced tax rate as an incentive.
• Cancellation and Non-Renewal
The Planning Commission at its October 1, 2026 meeting recommended that the Council initiate the non-renewal of the Williamson Act contract for the project parcel. There are also public comments submitted that state the contract in this case should be cancelled. As presented in the City Attorney’s October 1, 2026 memo, non-renewal and cancellation are not prerequisites to carry out compatible uses on contracted lands. The Town has the ability to initiate non-renewal at any time pursuant to state law and the contract at issues; cancellation is only available by petition from the property owner subject to City Council making findings for approval. Ultimately, the City Council retains the authority to determine whether the Town should continue the property's enrollment under the Williamson Act or initiate nonrenewal pursuant to Government Code Section 51245.
Planning Commissioners expressed that the property owners should pursue a cancellation before proceeding with development.
Additional details regarding the foregoing points are provided by the following: prior staff reports to the Planning Commission, the City Attorney’s Williamson Act Overview memo, responses from the County Assessor’s Office and Department of Conservation, Resolution No. 616, and the project site’s 1972 Williamson Act Land Conservation Contract, all included as Attachments 8 – 10, respectively.
• November 5, 2026 Letter from Hanson Bridgett on behalf of Residents The letter’s main objections are summarized below, followed by staff’s responses to each.
1. Per the Department of Conservation response, the Town is not in a position to opine on project compatibility issues because it has not adopted uniform rules governing compatible uses.
Staff response: this is not an accurate representation of the Department’s response. In the email dated September 8, 2026 containing the Department’s response, under 3 See Department of Conservation Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program https://www.conservation.ca.gov/dlrp/fmmp/Pages/prime_farmland_fmmp.aspx
City Council Page 8
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
Response #1 the Department specifically stated that the Town is the entity with final authority to determine project compatibility, including with current contract provisions.
2. The statute contemplates that agricultural or open-space uses remain primary and that any compatible use is subordinate and incidental to it. The proposed project is not compatible because it makes residential use primary and agricultural use incidental.
Staff response: As explained in the City Attorney’s October 1, 2026 memo, the statute does not contain this specific requirement. Likewise, the Department of Conservation’s September 8, 2026 email response does not state such a bright line rule. There is no statutory or contractual provision that bases compatibility on the allocation of primary and compatible uses on contracted lands. This argument also does not address the fact that primary and secondary dwellings are enumerated compatible uses in the parcel’s Williamson Act contract, and that Resolution No. 616 states “uses designated in Williamson Act contracts” are considered compatible uses within the larger agricultural preserve.
3. If the Town finds the proposed project is compatible, the Contract will not be imposing any meaningful restriction because the owner would be able to do what the R-A zoning would allow without restrictions.
Staff response: The contract for this parcel specifies that primary and secondary dwellings, as well as other uses that are present in the R-A zoning district, are compatible uses. The Town is able to determine that the proposed use is one of those enumerated in the contract, and thus compatible, without invalidating the contract. As explained in the County Assessor’s response on this parcel’s valuation issues, the property would not be taxed at reduced rates for contracted lands if the project were to be developed as a homesite. Thus, the parcel is not enjoying a benefit while undertaking a use otherwise allowed in the R-A district. The contract’s restrictions thus remain meaningful.
4. A compatibility determination would constitute a de facto cancellation of the contract by ending agricultural use on the land, making it indistinguishable from unrestricted land.
Staff response: The proposed project continues to include agricultural uses and does not propose other uses not enumerated in the Williamson Act contract as a compatible use. Thus, a finding of compatibility would be on a contractual basis and does not end the agricultural use on site.
5. The property owner voluntarily agreed to the Williamson Act contract, so the Town has discretion to reject the project without constituting a taking or breach of contract.
Staff response: the Town should base its decisions on the facts in the record. This argument does not address the fact that the contract specifies primary and secondary dwellings, both in plural form, are considered compatible uses.
City Council Page 9
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
LAND USE ENTITLEMENT REQUESTS ANALYSIS
This section summarizes the evaluation for the project’s variance and Grading Policy exception requests. Additional analysis on these items are provided in the prior staff reports to the Planning Commission, listed in Attachment 3-6.
Variance to Exceed Maximum Driveway Width
Pursuant to LAHMC Section 10-2.1102(g), driveways must comply with all applicable standards established by the Santa Clara County Fire Department, including requirements related to width, vertical clearance, grade, surface, load-bearing capacity, turning radius, turnouts, turnarounds, and emergency access. The Municipal Code further requires driveway widths to be a minimum of 12 feet and a maximum of 14 feet, excluding parking and backup areas.
Th project requests a variance from the maximum driveway width requirement to allow a driveway width of 28 feet adjacent to La Barranca Road. Beyond the first approximately 25 linear feet, the driveway complies with the code-required maximum width of 14 feet. According to the applicant, the increased width at the driveway entrance is necessary to accommodate the turning radius requirements for emergency vehicles accessing the site from La Barranca Road.
Staff supports the requested variance based on the unique physical constraints of the property. The site contains steep slopes averaging approximately 33.3%, with the frontage along La Barranca Road exhibiting even steeper grades. In addition, an active fault trace bisects the property, further limiting the available building area and site design options. The requested variance is narrowly tailored to the portion of the driveway nearest La Barranca Road and is necessary to satisfy emergency access requirements.
Grading Policy Exception to Exceed Cut and Fill Thresholds The Town’s Grading Policy limits driveway grading to a maximum of 4 feet of cut and 3 feet of fill. The policy further states that driveway cuts may be increased up to a maximum of 10 feet in areas adjacent to a garage that has been similarly lowered. The proposed project includes a Grading Policy Exception request to allow cuts exceeding 4 feet, with portions of the driveway reaching depths of up to 15 feet.
According to the project civil engineer, Lea & Braze Engineering, Inc., the additional grading is necessary to comply with the County Fire Department’s maximum driveway slope requirement of 20% for emergency vehicle access. The engineer also states that grading impacts have been minimized through the use of terracing techniques across the site.
Staff supports the requested Grading Policy Exception due to the challenging topography of the property, which has an average slope of 33.3%. In combination with the County Fire Department’s emergency access requirements, the exception is necessary to facilitate development of the project.
Although the grading exhibit identifies a maximum cut depth of 15 feet, this condition is limited to an approximately 36 square-foot area, while the majority of the exception area ranges between 4 and 8 feet of cut.
City Council Page 10
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
After discussing Williamson Act compatibility issues at its September 3, 2026 meeting, the Planning Commission expressed support for the variance and Grading Policy exception requests as a part of its direction for staff to prepare a resolution approving the project. The Planning Commission focused on the Williamson Act compatibility determination discussion at its October 1, 2026 meeting, and did not express further objections to these land use entitlement requests at that meeting.
SEPARATE CONSIDERATION BY CITY COUNCIL AD HOC COMMITTEE ON FUTURE
WILLIAMSON ACT ISSUES
The Planning Commission during the September 3, 2026 meeting directed staff to agendize a future discussion of criteria for subsequent Williamson Act participation and compatibility determinations. At its September 17, 2026 regular meeting, the City Council established a Williamson Act Ad Hoc Committee, appointing Mayor Rajiv Bhateja and Council Member George Tyson. The purpose of this committee is to review potential local regulatory and contractual issues under the Williamson Act for the future. At the October 15, 2026 meeting, the City Council authorized the committee to consult with the Land Trust Alliance to obtain an independent legal opinion on Williamson Act related issues.
It is important to emphasize that the ad hoc committee’s work is not a part of this project; the City Council's consideration at this time is limited to the subject project and the Williamson Act contract for APN 182-05-034. Similarly, the Ad Hoc Committee's broader review of the Town's future Williamson Act policies and contract execution approach is proceeding independently and is not before the City Council as part of this project review.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
If the City Council desires to approve the proposed project, it would need to make the CEQA determination prior to a decision on the project. staff evaluates the proposed project to qualify for a categorical exemption from CEQA pursuant to Section 15303. This This exemption applies to construction and location of limited numbers of new, small facilities or structures; installation of small new equipment and facilities in small structures; and the conversion of existing small structures from one use to another where only minor modifications are made in the exterior of the structure. Subdivision(a) of Section 15303 states that “one single-family residence, or a second dwelling unit in a residential zone” and “in urbanized areas, up to three single-family residences” are examples covered by this exemption. This provision applies to the construction of a single-family residence, as proposed by the Project before the Council for discretionary action. A city attorney memo providing supplemental findings supporting the exemption is included as Attachment 7.
In its November 5, 2026 letter to the Town, Hanson Bridgett on behalf of residents argues that the project does not qualify for a Class 3 categorical exemption because (1) it does not fit the parameters outlined in Section 15303(a) as the project is located in low-density, rural-residential community and on contracted agricultural and open-space land; (2) the project is barred by the “location” and “unusual circumstances” exception under CEQA Guidelines section 15300.2(a) and (c) due to removal of a significant number of trees, exceeding Town maximum grading standards, and exceeding the Town’s driveway width standard; and (3) there is a fair argument that the project
City Council Page 11
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
will impair or effectively convert contracted agricultural land, and thus under CEQA it would conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use and with a Williamson Act contract.
Staff does not conclude that these arguments change the foregoing CEQA evaluation. At the outset, it should be noted that the proposed project before the City Council for discretionary action is the single-family home development and related improvements. Other components of the project that are mandated by state law to be approved ministerially are not subject to CEQA, as CEQA review only applies to discretionary actions and not to ministerial projects. Next, with respect to Argument #1, Section 15303 specifies that the examples of the exemption listed in (a)-(f) are not exhaustive.
One single family home in a residential zone is an enumerated example of exemption under Subdivision (a). The definition of “urbanized area” under the CEQA Guidelines speak to a group of cities and does not by definition exclude Los Altos Hills; even if assuming in arguendo the Town is not within an urbanized area and that the analysis includes three dwellings, subdivision (b) of Section 15303 states that no more than four dwelling units may be constructed pursuant to this exemption. The two ministerial dwellings are also included within one structure. Thus, the project is covered by Section 15303.
With respect to Arguments #2 and #3, at the outset staff does not observe there is any evidence indicating the project would be located in a sensitive environment or may impact any “environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern”. The exception in Section 15300.2(a) provides that the Class 3 exemption apply in all instances except where “the project may impact on an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern where designated, precisely mapped, and officially adopted pursuant to law by federal, state, or local agencies” (emphasis added). There is no record of a federal, state, or locally designated and mapped hazardous or critical environmental resource at the project site. Tree removal is a common component of residential development projects in Los Altos Hills, and the Hanson Bridgett letter does not cite any source to show that trees qualify as a hazardous or critically concerning environmental resource.
Next, staff does not read the record to support a contention that there are unusual circumstances.
The proposed project consists of a single family residential development with associated improvements, which is the type of development commonly seen in Los Altos Hills. Although the project is requesting exceptions to the maximum driveway width and cut and fill thresholds, such types of requests are also common with project applications in Town. Similarly, although the project site is steeply sloped, the record does not indicate that such topography is uncommon or unusual in Los Altos Hills. In fact, there are many parcels in Town with steep slopes and other challenging topographic features. This is supported by the Supplemental Memo regarding CEQA exemption in Attachment 7.
The Hanson Bridgett letter cites Berkeley Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley for the proposition that the unusual circumstances exception applies where there is a reasonable possibility that the activity will have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances. However, in that case the California Supreme Court concluded that a project to build a 6,478 square-foot house with an attached 3,394 square-foot 10-car garage on a hillside lot with 50 percent grade slope and heavily wooded area was exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section
City Council Page 12
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
15303(a) and was not barred by the unusual circumstances exception under Section 15300.2.4 As explained in that case, the unusual circumstances exception needs to be supported by evidence showing that the project has some feature that distinguishes it from others in the exempt class, such as its size or location, or evidence showing that the project will have a significant environmental effect. It is not enough for a challenger merely to provide substantial evidence that the project may have a significant effect on the environment.5 As explained above, staff does not observe there is evidence supporting either point. On the contrary, the record shows that both the project’s zoning and contractual obligations also specifically permit residential and agricultural uses, and that the project’s location, topography, development type, and associated characteristics are common examples of development in Los Altos Hills.
Finally, staff does not observe that the project will conflict with existing agricultural zoning or with a Williamson Act contract because the property is located within the R-A district which allows both residential and agricultural uses by right, and the property’s Williamson Act contract specifically provides primary and secondary dwellings as compatible uses. For that same reason, and because the project would continue to propose agricultural uses, staff does not observe the record to show that the project would impair or effectively extinguish agricultural land.
If the City Council does not approve the proposed project, no approval or entitlement authorizing the project would be granted and further review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) is not required.
2026 CITY COUNCIL STRATEGIC PRIORITIES
The proposed project is not directly part of the Town’s 2026 City Council Strategic Priorities.
While it has some indirect relevance to Maintaining Quality of Life and Community Character and Increasing Effective Service Delivery and Governance, particularly regarding Williamson Act compatibility, agricultural land preservation, and the Town’s broader review of its Williamson Act policies, it does not directly advance the specific initiatives identified under any of the four strategic priorities. The project is primarily a property-specific development application requiring consideration of land use entitlements and Williamson Act compatibility, rather than an initiative implementing the Council’s strategic priorities.
FISCAL IMPACT
The project is not anticipated to result in a direct fiscal impact to the Town beyond the staff and consultant costs associated with processing the application and conducting the public hearing.
These costs are generally offset, in whole or in part, through application fees and deposits collected from the applicant.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Resolution Making Findings and Approving the Project
2. Resolution Making Findings and Denying the Project
3. October 1, 2026, Planning Commission Staff Report
4 Berkeley Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1086. 5 Id. at 1105.
City Council Page 13
Unaddressed La Barranca Road
November 12, 2026
4. September 3, 2026, Planning Commission Staff Report
5. August 6, 2026, Planning Commission Staff Report
6. June 8, 2026, Planning Commission Staff Report
7. Redwood Public Law memo- Overview of Williamson Act Provisions and Requirements
8. Resolution No. 616 – Establishing Rules Governing Administration of Agricultural and Open Space Preserves and Procedures Relating to Implementation of the California Land Conservation Act
9. Resolution No. 629 Establishing the Agricultural Preserve
10. 1972 Williamson Act Contract for Project Site (APN 182-05-034)
11. California Department of Conservation correspondence regarding Williamson Act compatibility, local rules, contract interpretation, nonrenewal, and related Government Code provisions (September 2026)
12. Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor correspondence regarding Williamson Act property-tax assessment and homesite valuation for APN 182-05-034 (August 2026)
13. Farming Operation and Business Plan 7/1/2026
14. Worksheet 1-2 prepared by Applicant
15. Staff Memorandum- Supplemental Findings Supporting Class 3 CEQA Exemption
16. Letter from Hanson Bridgett on behalf of Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development
17. Public Comments and Correspondences Received as of October 1, 2026
18. Project Plans – City Council only, available for public viewing at Town Hall
19. Open Space Easement exhibit 7/9/2026
20. Farming Operation and Business Plan 7/7/2025
Resolution CC _-26 Page 1
RESOLUTION CC _-26
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
MAKING FINDINGS AND APPROVING A SITE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT,
VARIANCE, AND GRADING POLICY EXCEPTION FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED IMPROVEMENTS AT APN 182-05-034, SUBJECT
TO CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
WHEREAS, on November 10, 2025, the Town of Los Altos Hills received an application for a Site Development Permit (SD25-0072) from the property owners, Naveen Vangala and Shalini Tokala (together, “Applicant”), for a new single-family residence, and associated improvements at a vacant, unaddressed parcel on La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) (“Project”); the application also proposes to construct a dwelling pursuant to Government Code section 65852.21 (SB 9) and an accessory dwelling unit pursuant to Government Code section 66314 et seq., both of which are permitted by state law and only subject to ministerial approval, and thus not before the City Council for consideration; and
WHEREAS, the Project parcel is enrolled in a Williamson Act contract pursuant to the California Land Conservation Act of 1965 (“Contract”); and
WHEREAS, the subject property contains steep slopes and an active fault trace that create physical constraints on the property and limit the feasible area for development; on February 24, 2026, the property owner, the Applicant applied for a variance to exceed the maximum driveway width and to exceed Maximum Development Area; and
WHEREAS, the Project application was processed in accordance with the applicable provisions of the California Government Code and the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code, and Town staff evaluated the Project’s consistency with the Contract to review whether the proposed uses including agricultural operations, open space preservation, noting that the Contract specifies both primary and secondary dwellings constitute compatible uses for this contracted parcel; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing on the project on June 8, 2026, and considered all evidence, testimony, written documentation, and public comments; and voted 4-01-1 (one recusal) to continue the project to a date uncertain to allow staff to provide additional information regarding the Williamson Act, obtain the Open Space Committee’s recommendations, and allow the applicant to address comments related to site development; and WHEREAS, on June 10, 2026, the Open Space Committee reviewed the project and provided a recommendation on the requirement for open space easement dedication; and WHEREAS, on July 9, 2026, the applicant submitted project revisions in response to Planning Commission received on June 8, 2026, such that the project no longer requires a Variance to exceed the Maximum Development Area; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing on August 6, 2026, during which hearing Town staff recommended that the Planning Commission forward an approval recommendation to the City Council, including a finding that the project is compatible with the existing Williamson Act Contract and Government Code Section 51238.1; and
Resolution CC _-26 Page 2
WHEREAS, on August 6, 2026, the Planning Commission voted 4-0-1 (one recusal) to continue consideration of the project to September 3, 2026, and directed staff to prepare a resolution recommending that the City Council deny the project based on Williamson Act compatibility concerns, specifically the Commission’s determination that agriculture would not remain the primary use of the parcel; and
WHEREAS, on September 3, 2026, the Planning Commission received additional staff and legal analysis, reopened discussion, voted 4-0-1 (one absent) to direct staff to return with a resolution recommending that the City Council approve the project for consideration on the October 1, 2026 Consent Calendar; and
WHEREAS, on October 1, 2026, the Planning Commission removed the item from the Consent Calendar and opened the item for discussion and public comment and after considering all evidence, testimony, written documentation, and public comments; voted 3-1-1 (one recusal) recommending that the City Council initiate non-renewal of the Williamson Act Contract and find that the proposed project is not compatible with Government Code Section 51238.1 and the existing Williamson Act contract; and
WHEREAS, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing on the project on November 12, 2026, and at the hearing considered all reports, plans, submittals, documents, testimony, legal authority and other evidence in the record; the Applicant and all interested parties were provided an opportunity to be heard at the public hearing.
NOW, THEREFORE, based on the entirety of the record before it, the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby make the findings set forth under Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein, and hereby approves the Project, including the Variance and Grading Policy Exception, subject to the conditions of approval set forth in Exhibit B, attached hereto and incorporated herein. Note: Condition No. 17 pending inclusion or removal based on Council direction on non-renewal of Williamson Act contract.
The above and foregoing Resolution was passed and adopted by the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills at a regular meeting held on the 12th day of November 2026 by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
By: ___________________________________
Rajiv Bhateja, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________________
Arika Birdsong-Miller, City Clerk
Resolution CC _-26 Page 3
EXHIBIT A
FINDINGS
Lands of Vangala & Tokala – APN 182-05-034 – File# SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 Based on the entirety of the record before it, which includes, without limitation, the California Environmental Quality Act, Public Resources Code §21000, et seq. and the CEQA Guidelines, 14 California Code of Regulations §15000, et seq. (collectively, “CEQA”); California Government Code §51200 et seq.; the Los Altos Hills General Plan; the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code; the Project application materials; the Project Williamson Act contract; all staff reports, technical reports, minutes, and public testimony submitted as part of the Planning Commission’s duly noticed June 8, August 6, September 3, October 1, 2026, public hearings and meetings; the City Council’s November 12, 2026 public hearing; and any and all other evidence (within the meaning of Public Resources Code §21080(e) and §21082.2), the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby finds as follows:
A. General and CEQA Findings.
1. All of the facts and recitals above are true, correct, incorporated herein and made a part hereof.
2. The documents and other material constituting the record for these proceedings are located at the Community Development Department for the Town of Los Altos Hills, 26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022, and in the custody of the Community Development Director.
3. The proposed Project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15303 of the CEQA Guidelines, Class 3, for New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures. This exemption applies to construction and location of limited numbers of new, small facilities or structures; installation of small new equipment and facilities in small structures; and the conversion of existing small structures from one use to another where only minor modifications are made in the exterior of the structure.
Subdivision(a) of Section 15303 states that “one single-family residence, or a second dwelling unit in a residential zone” and “in urbanized areas, up to three single-family residences” are examples covered by this exemption. Here, the Project proposal before the City Council for discretionary action consist of construction of one single-family home, associated improvements, and driveway/grading cut and fill exceptions. It should be noted that other components of the project that are mandated by state law to be approved ministerially are not subject to CEQA, as CEQA review only applies to discretionary actions and not to ministerial projects. Thus, the proposed project qualifies for an exemption under Section 15303 and its subdivision (a).
4. The City Council also finds that the “location” exception under CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2(a) does not apply to bar the application of the Class 3 exemption under Section 15303. The exception in Section 15300.2(a) provides that the Class 3 exemption apply in all instances except where “the project may impact on an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern where designated, precisely mapped, and officially adopted pursuant to law by federal, state, or local agencies”. However, there is no evidence in the record indicating the project would be located in a sensitive environment or may impact
Resolution CC _-26 Page 4
any “environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern”. There is no record of a federal, state, or locally designated and mapped hazardous or critical environmental resource at the project site. While opponents of the Project cites the amount of trees being removed as a basis for validating this exception, tree removal is a common component of residential development projects in Los Altos Hills and there is no designation or maps that would meet the exception’s requirement. This argument does not cite any source to show that trees qualify as a hazardous or critically concerning environmental resource.
5. The City Council further finds that the “unusual circumstances” exception under CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2(c) does not apply to bar the application of the Class 3 exemption under Section 15303. Section 15300.2(c) provides that “a categorical exemption shall not be used for an activity where there is a reasonable possibility that the activity will have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances.” The unusual circumstances exception needs to be supported by evidence showing that the project has some feature that distinguishes it from others in the exempt class, such as its size or location, or evidence showing that the project will have a significant environmental effect.
It is not enough for a challenger merely to provide substantial evidence that the project may have a significant effect on the environment (Berkeley Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1086, 1105).
Here, the record does not support the contention that there are unusual circumstances. The Project consists of a single family residential development with associated improvements, which is the type of development commonly seen in Los Altos Hills. Even considering the ministerial SB 9 and accessory dwelling unit (which are enclosed within one structure), such development is still common in Los Altos Hills. Although the Project is requesting exceptions to the maximum driveway width and cut and fill thresholds, such types of requests are also common with project applications in Town. Similarly, although the Project site is steeply sloped, the record does not indicate that such topography is uncommon or unusual in Los Altos Hills. In fact, there are many parcels in Town with steep slopes and other challenging topographic features. This is supported by the Supplemental Memo regarding CEQA exemption attached to the accompanying staff report. The record shows that both the project’s zoning and contractual obligations also specifically permit residential and agricultural uses, and that the project’s location, topography, development type, and associated characteristics are common examples of development in Los Altos Hills. Similarly, the record does not show that the Project will conflict with existing agricultural zoning or with a Williamson Act contract because the property is located within the R-A district which allows both residential and agricultural uses by right, and the property’s Williamson Act contract specifically provides primary and secondary dwellings as compatible uses. Thus, the City Council finds that CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2(c) does not apply.
B. Williamson Act Compatibility Findings.
1. The City Council finds that Williamson Act (Government Code (“GC”) section 51200 et seq.) authorizes cities and counties to establish “agricultural preserves” within their jurisdictions (GC 51230). Within these preserve areas, landowners may enter into long-term contracts with the city or county to voluntarily restrict their properties to agricultural and compatible uses. An agricultural preserve is an area devoted to “agricultural, recreational, or open-space uses, or any combination thereof (GC 51201(d)). “Agricultural
Resolution CC _-26 Page 5
use” means commercial agriculture where agricultural commodities are produced for commercial purposes; “open-space use” means preserving land in natural state for public enjoyment, to preserve wildlife habitat, or for salt production if the land is located within certain locations specified by statute” (GC 51201(b),(o)). On April 19, 1971, the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills adopted Resolution No. 616 establishing rules governing administration of agricultural preserves in Los Altos Hills. Under Section 9 of Resolution No. 616, uses permitted in any zoning district and designated in Williamson Act contracts are considered to be “compatible uses” within the agricultural preserve. On June 7, 1971, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 629 establishing the entire Town as an agricultural preserve under the Williamson Act. On January 17, 1972, the Town and the then-owner for the Project parcel executed a Williamson Act Contract (“Contract”). The City Council finds that the Contract was entered into between the Town and Project parcel owner in accordance with provisions and requirements of the Williamson Act.
2. The City Council finds that the proposed Project is compatible with the Contract. The Contract was executed pursuant to Government Code section 51200 et seq. and if subject to all of the provisions of the Williamson Act including any amendments thereto that may be enacted after contract execution (Section 1). The Contract provides that during its term and any and all renewals thereafter, the Project site shall not be used by the property owner or successor in interest (the Applicant) for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto (Section 2). Exhibit A attached to the Contract and incorporated therein lists all of the compatible uses under the Contract (Section 2; Exhibit A). The Town may add to this list of compatible uses during the term and renewal terms of the Contract by ordinance only and in a uniform manner throughout the agricultural preserve in which the Project parcel is located (which preserve encompasses the entire Los Altos Hills), but may not, without written consent of the property owner, remove any of the compatible uses listed in Exhibit A (Section 2).
Exhibit A to the Contract provides a list of uses “determined to be compatible with the agricultural use of the land subject to this agreement”; among those, “agriculture”, “open space uses”, “primary dwellings”, and “secondary dwellings” are listed as compatible uses.
There is no record of the Town and property owner/Applicant mutually amending or removing compatible uses from this list under the Contract.
In reviewing the relevant statutes, authorities and other documents in the record, the City Council does not find that agriculture must be the “primary use” and that other compatible uses must be “incidental”. The Williamson Act plainly permits uses other than agricultural uses to be on contracted land, and leaves it to the local government to determine compatibility rules. The Town’s Resolution No. 616 and the Williamson Act contract at issue have determined that agricultural, open space, and residential are allowed and compatible uses on the Project site. There is no state law provision to the contrary. To the extent that opponents of the Project cite to other narrower contracts, rules and regulations of other properties or other jurisdictions, including those that exist in the County of Santa Clara, there is no evidence that those contractual provisions and rules can apply to this Project. The Williamson Act contract here does not include any qualifiers for compatible uses to be “incidental” and agriculture to be “primary, and the Town cannot enforce such rules that don’t exist in the contract or in a local regulatory program.
The Project proposes to construct a single family home, a primary dwelling pursuant to Government Code section 65852.21 (“SB 9 Unit”), an accessory dwelling unit (“ADU”),
Resolution CC _-26 Page 6
and associated improvements for the home including parking. The Project seeks approval of a site development permit for the single-family home, a variance to allow a driveway width exceeding the maximum permitted 14 feet, a Grading Policy Exception to allow excavation exceeding the maximum cut thresholds for driveway. The SB 9 and ADU are only subject to ministerial review pursuant to Government Code sections 65852.21 and 66314 et seq. and are not before the City Council for discretionary action. The Project also proposes continuing vegetable farming and chicken farming for commercial sale, as presented in the Farming and Business Operations Plan included with the accompanying staff report. Finally, the Project proposes to reserve an open space easement to preserve land around three sides of the Project parcel as shown in the proposed site plan in the accompanying staff report.
Based on the foregoing Project proposals, the City Council finds that the proposed single-family residential development is a “primary dwelling” and thus is an enumerated compatible use with agricultural use under the Contract. Even if taking the SB 9 and ADU into consideration, the Contract provides for plural primary and secondary dwellings as compatible uses, which would cover those units. The City Council also finds that the vegetable and chicken farming uses constitute “agriculture” uses because the proposal is to raise chickens and vegetables and selling the products in commercial sales and thus constitutes a permitted and compatible use under the Contract. Finally, the City Council finds that the proposed open space easement would reserve the easement area in its natural state and thus preserve the characteristics of land. Preservation of natural site characteristics and land features is encouraged by the Town for public enjoyment of the semi-rural characteristics of Los Altos Hills, and a common goal for property owners in Town as a part of development. Thus, the open space easement constitutes a compatible use under the Contract. The City Council finds that the proposed Project is compatible with the Contract entered into pursuant to state law.
3. The City Council also finds that under Government Code Section 51238.3, the principles of compatibility rules under Section 51238.1 (explained below) do not apply to land uses of contracted lands in place prior to June 7, 1994, where the land use constituted a “compatible use” as that term was defined in the Williamson Act when the contract was signed. Compatible use, as defined in 1972 when the Contract was signed, is simply those uses determined by the City Council as compatible. The City Council, through adoption of Resolution No. 616 and approval of the Contract, enumerated primary and secondary dwelling, agriculture, and open space as compatible uses within the Contract document.
Thus, the City Council finds that the Project is compatible with agricultural uses under the Contract and the Williamson Act including through Section 51238.3.
4. The City Council further finds that the Project is compatible with the Williamson Act and agriculture use through the compatibility principles under Government Code section 51238.1. Section 51238.1 requires that approved uses on contracted lands must be consistent with all of the following principles of compatibility, and in evaluating compatibility the City Council is to consider the impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve. It should first be noted that the Town is the ultimate decision maker as to compatibility of uses on contracted lands and to establish rules of compatibility. The Williamson Act, under Government Code sections 51231 and 51238, specifies that it is the City Council that will adopt rules governing agricultural preserves and determine compatible uses on contracted lands. In this case, as explained in the findings above, the
Resolution CC _-26 Page 7
City Council has already determined that primary and secondary dwellings, agriculture, and open space uses to be compatible uses on this contracted parcel.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, and the for purposes of making comprehensive findings, the principles of compatibility under Section 51238.1 were examined and the Council hereby makes the findings as shown below next to each of the principles. a. The use will not significantly compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves.
The proposed Project will not significantly compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the property because it will enable agricultural activity. The
1.164-acre property is presently vacant. Based on City Council minutes dated January 17, 1972, the property has been under a Williamson Act Contract in the Town of Los Altos Hills since 1972 but there is no evidence of previous or current agricultural use on site.
There is no state or local law requiring a certain allocation of percentage of commercial agricultural and other compatible uses on contracted lands. The Contract provides for agriculture, open space, and residential uses as compatible uses. Approval of the project will enable agricultural use in the form of a small business selling potted plants and chicken eggs. These activities are consistent with the agricultural purpose of the Contract and are unlikely to impair the productive agricultural capability of the parcel or other contracted lands. The owners would germinate vegetable and specialty plants in greenhouse trays. The owners would also raise chickens in mobile, wheeled coops and rely on feed and ground foraging. These suggest a less intensive impact on long-term productive agricultural capability than more intensive farming options such as crops and livestock. According to the Project’s business plan, these farming operations are for commercial sale purposes consistent with the Act’s definition for commercial agriculture.
Approximately 30 percent of the parcel will be protected through an open space easement.
Because the easement is limited to areas consisting of steep slopes with little to no agricultural productivity, it preserves open space consistent with the purposes of the Williamson Act without significantly compromising the parcel's long-term agricultural capability. Additionally, “compatible use” is defined under Government Code section 51201 as any use determined by the county or city administering the Williamson Act preserve to be compatible with the agricultural, recreational, or open-space use of land within the preserve and subject to contract. “Compatible use” includes agricultural use, recreational use or open-space use unless the City Council specifically finds such is not compatible. Thus, based on statutory interpretation, open space preservation is already considered to be a compatible use with a property subject to the Williamson Act contract.
Additionally, the remainder of the parcel would be dedicated for a driveway, single-family home, an SB 9 unit, an accessory dwelling unit, and other accessory uses. These residential uses are allowed by right under state law as explained in the accompanying staff report to the City Council and in staff reports to the Planning Commission in the record. On site residence would allow for more capability to manage agricultural operations. Therefore, the proposed project will not compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the subject parcel or other contracted lands.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 8
b. The use will not significantly displace or impair current or reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves.
The proposed Project will not significantly displace or impair current agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or nearby contracted lands because there are no other agricultural operations on the subject parcel or nearby parcels. The proposed Project is also not likely to significantly displace or impair reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations because the proposed Project does not change the nature of land or carry out any uses not otherwise permitted by Contract and by the underlying zoning. It should be noted that the Project parcel and other surrounding parcels are all in the R-A zoning district, which in itself is an agricultural preserve and allows residential and agricultural uses by right. Depending on the features of other future projects, developing compatible uses creates an incentive for the owner to maintain the contract rather than request a cancellation or nonrenewal, thereby preserving the opportunity for future agricultural operations. The proposed operations are not of a scale that diminishes or prevents other agricultural uses or production, should they exist, nor do the proposed operations have the potential to do so.
Moreover, all adjacent properties are already developed with residential uses and are not under Williamson Act Contracts. The property proposes residential uses that are allowed by right pursuant to state housing law provisions. These uses, as allowed by the underlying zoning district, does not change other properties’ ability to pursue agricultural operations.
Therefore, the proposed Project will not significantly displace or impair current agricultural operations on the subject parcel or nearby contracted lands. c. The use will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use.
The proposed Project will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use because there are no other contracted lands nearby. As explained above, the Project does not change site characteristics or nature of zoning uses to prevent other parcels from undertaking agricultural operations or consider Williamson Act contracts. Opponents to the Project contends that this finding cannot be made precisely because there are no adjacent contracted lands; however, the Williamson Act permits property owners to enter into land conservation contracts as long as the site is within an agricultural preserve and the local jurisdiction offers the contract. To adhere to the opponent’s logic would mean that lands can only be under contract if neighboring lands are also under contract; the law does not contain such a requirement. Further, while all adjacent properties are already developed with residential uses and are not under Williamson Act contracts, should those parcel desires to change course, the underlying zoning and agricultural preserve rules would permit them to do so. Therefore, the proposed Project will have no impact on any adjacent contracted land. d. In evaluating compatibility, the council shall consider the impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve or preserves. There are no facts indicating that the proposed project would have an adverse impact on other noncontracted lands in the R-A zone.
The proposed Project would introduce new activity on the Project site compared to existing conditions, as the site is currently undeveloped and inactive. As a result, adjacent noncontracted properties would experience exposure to construction activities associated
Resolution CC _-26 Page 9
with the residential buildings, greenhouse, and other facilities supporting potted plant cultivation, as well as the ongoing operation of the proposed chicken coops.
These activities, however, are consistent with the types of uses commonly found within the R-A zoning district and consistent with undertaking enumerated compatible uses in the Project’s Contract. The construction and operation of single-family residences and agricultural or farming-related facilities are permitted within the district and are compatible with its intended character. The Project owners plan to raise a specific breed of chicken selected in part to minimize noise impacts and have prior experience operating a small-scale farming business, which indicates their ability to manage the proposed agricultural activities responsibly and with minimal effects on neighboring properties.
The proposed residential development consists of uses that are permitted by right under state law and are consistent with the purpose and intent of the R-A zoning designation, which allows both residential and agricultural uses. In addition, all construction activities would be required to comply with applicable building, safety, and noise standards established by the Town's ordinances and codes.
Accordingly, while the proposed Project would introduce new activity to the site and could result in some effects on adjacent noncontracted lands, those effects are expected to be minor and consistent with the established land use pattern and regulatory framework of the surrounding area.
C. Site Development Permit and Variance Findings.
1. With regard to the Site Development Permit (SD25-0072) and Variance (VAR25-0016) to encroach into the required 40-foot front yard setback, the City Council finds in accordance with Section 10-1.1007(2) of the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code as follows:
a. Because of exceptional or extraordinary circumstances applicable to the subject property, including size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings, the strict application of the ordinance is found to deprive the property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the vicinity and under identical zoning classifications:
The 1.164-acre vacant parcel is significantly constrained by challenging topography. The site contains steep slopes averaging 35 percent, with the frontage along La Barranca Road exhibiting much steeper grades. In addition, an active fault trace bisects the property, further limiting the available building area and site design options. b. That upon granting of the Variance, the intent and purpose of the ordinance will still be served, and the recipient of the Variance will not be granted special privileges not enjoyed by other surrounding property owners:
The requested Variance to exceed the maximum driveway width is permissible under the Municipal Code when exceptional or extraordinary circumstances are present. In this case, the intersecting drainage channels significantly constrain the developable portion of the site, resulting in only a small fraction of the overall lot being suitable for access and improvements. These physical constraints constitute an exceptional circumstance warranting relief. Furthermore, granting the Variance does not confer a special privilege,
Resolution CC _-26 Page 10
as similar Variances may be considered for other properties that experience comparable site-specific constraints.
c. That granting the Variance will not be materially detrimental to the public welfare or injurious to the property, improvements or uses within the immediate vicinity and within the same zoning district;
The requested variance will not be materially detrimental to the public welfare or injurious to nearby properties, improvements, or uses within the immediate vicinity or the R-A zoning district. The variance is limited to allowing a driveway width of 28 feet at the entrance from La Barranca Road, after which the driveway narrows to the code-compliant width of 14 feet. The increased width is necessary to accommodate emergency vehicle access and turning movements, thereby enhancing public safety rather than creating adverse impacts.
d. That the Variance will not allow a use or activity which is not expressly authorized by the Zoning Ordinance:
Grant of a Variance to exceed the maximum width for the driveway and exceed the Maximum Development Area for the property will allow for the construction of a single-family residence, swimming pool, SB 9 unit, ADU, chicken coop, and greenhouse which are permitted uses and structures in the Residential-Agriculture Zoning District. These uses, as described in the above findings, are also compatible uses enumerated in the Project site’s Wiliamson Act Contract.
D. Grading Policy Exception Findings.
The Town’s Grading Policy limits driveway grading to a maximum of 4 feet of cut and 3 feet of fill. The policy further states that driveway cuts may be increased up to a maximum of 10 feet in areas adjacent to a garage that has been similarly lowered. The proposed Project requests an exception to allow cuts exceeding 4 feet, with portions of the driveway reaching depths of up to 15 feet. the Project civil engineer states that the additional grading is necessary to comply with the Santa Clara County Fire Department’s maximum driveway slope requirement of 20 percent for emergency vehicle access. The Project engineer also states that grading impacts have been minimized through the use of terracing techniques across the site.
The City Council finds that granting of the exception is appropriate due to the challenging topography of the property, which has an average slope of 33.3 percent. In combination with the County Fire Department’s emergency access requirements, the exception is necessary to facilitate development of the project. Although the grading plan identifies a maximum cut depth of 15 feet, this condition is limited to an approximately 36 square-foot area, while the majority of the exception area ranges between 4 and 8 feet of cut. Thus, the intent of the Grading Policy remains largely preserved.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 11
Resolution CC _-26 Page 12
EXHIBIT B
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
Lands of Vangala & Tokala – APN 182-05-034 – File# SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 In the event any condition contained herein shall be found, by a court of competent jurisdiction, to be invalid for any reason, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining conditions herein.
PLANNING:
1. No other modifications to the approved plans submitted on July 9, 2026, are allowed except as otherwise first reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director or the Planning Commission, depending on the scope of the changes.
2. All conditions of approval shall be printed on plans submitted for building permit plan check.
3. The project is subject to the Town’s Construction Time Limit Ordinance (Chapter 10, Title VIII of the Municipal Code). The maximum time for completion of the project shall be set by said policy and run from date of Building Permit issuance. Any extensions to the time for completion shall be subject to said policy. Failure to complete the project in the allotted time with approved extensions may result in substantial penalties and fees per the policy.
4. As an ongoing condition of approval, the property owner shall coordinate with staff on the location of any proposed above-ground utilities (i.e. transformers). Such equipment shall comply with the standard setbacks in the R-A Zoning District.
5. Exterior finish colors of all buildings shall have a light reflectivity value of 50 or less and roof materials shall have a light reflectivity value of 40 or less, per manufacturer specifications. All color samples shall be submitted to the Community Development Department for approval at time of submittal for building plan check. All applicable structures shall be painted in conformance with the approved color(s) prior to final inspection.
6. The property owner shall remove all Stinkwort from the entire property and in the road right-of-way by manual pulling or use of herbicide by September 1st of each year until the final approval of the project.
7. Roof eaves of all structures shall not encroach into the required side and rear yard setbacks.
The roof eaves shall be shown on the site and civil plans in the construction drawings.
8. No new fencing is approved with this site development permit. Any additional or modified fencing or gates shall require review and approval by the Community Development Department with the required landscape screening plan and prior to installation.
9. All exterior lighting fixtures shall be down directed or shielded non-movable fixtures and shall not exceed 3,000 Kelvins and 600 lumens. Exterior lighting on the new residence is approved as shown on the plans. Any changes to the approved lighting plan shall be approved by the Community Development Department prior to installation. No lighting may be placed
Resolution CC _-26 Page 13
within setbacks except that a total of two lights can be located at one of the following locations; driveway or entry.
10. Standard swimming pool conditions, as applicable:
a. Lights shall be placed beneath the surface of the water in the pool or spa. b. Lights shall be placed such that light shines away from neighboring properties. c. A maximum of four lights are allowed for pools and spas combined. d. Drainage outfall structures shall be constructed and located to the satisfaction of the City Engineer.
e. Equipment shall be enclosed on all four sides for noise mitigation and screening. f. Noise from pool equipment shall not exceed 40dB at nigh time and 50dB during day time.
11. Skylights, if utilized, shall be designed and constructed to reduce emitted light (tinted or colored glass, shade, or other material). No lighting may be placed within skylight wells.
12. Fire retardant roofing (Class A) is required for all new construction.
13. All space heating and water heating systems installed in new residences, detached habitable buildings, and/or projects involving a substantial remodel shall comply with Los Altos Hills Municipal Code Sections § 8-1.6.02 and § 8-1.10.02.
14. All construction shall comply with the applicable California Green Building Standards Code, Part 11, Title 24 mandatory measures in effect at the time of building permit application. The property owner shall provide a CALGreen Residential Checklist demonstrating conformance with all applicable mandatory measures at time of building permit submittal.
15. All construction shall comply with the 2025 California Wildland Urban Interface Code.
16. Prior to building permit issuance, the property owner shall provide an acoustical analysis prepared by a qualified acoustical consultant due to the site's location within an elevated noise contour identified in the Town's General Plan Noise Element. Any recommended noise attenuation measures necessary to achieve applicable interior noise standards shall be incorporated into the building plans prior to issuance of a building permit, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Director.
17. Prior to building permit issuance, staff shall initiate the process to nonrenew the Williamson Act Contract applicable to the property pursuant to Government Code Section 51245. Staff shall prepare the Notice of Nonrenewal, schedule a public hearing before the City Council to consider the proposed nonrenewal and receive testimony from the property owner and other interested parties, and record the Notice of Nonrenewal following the City Council’s action.
18. The property owner shall grant an Open Space Easement to the Town that encompasses those portions of the property identified on the plans dated July 9, 2026. Native vegetation may be planted within the easement and irrigation, or sprinkler systems are only permitted to establish the native vegetation. The easement shall allow for installation of a ground-mounted solar panel system. The easement shall allow for installation of a septic system and leach field. The property owner shall provide legal
Resolution CC _-26 Page 14
description and plat exhibit(s) prepared by a licensed land surveyor and the Town shall prepare the grant document. The grant document shall be signed and notarized by the property owner and returned to the Town prior to building permit issuance.
19. Prior to building permit issuance, the property owner’s Geotechnical Consultant shall review and approve all geotechnical aspects of the project building and grading plans (i.e., site preparation and grading, site surface and subsurface drainage improvements, and design parameters and layouts for foundations, retaining walls, swimming pools, etc.) to ensure that their recommendations have been properly incorporated. The results of the geotechnical plan review shall be summarized by the Geotechnical Consultant in a letter and submitted to the Town prior to issuance of building permits.
20. Prior to beginning any construction or grading operation, all significant trees, particularly any heritage oak trees, are to be fenced at the drip line. The fencing shall be of a material and structure (chain-link) to clearly delineate the drip line. Town staff must inspect the fencing and the trees to be fenced prior to commencement of any grading. The property owner shall call for said inspection at least three days in advance of the inspection. The fencing must remain throughout the course of construction. No storage of equipment, vehicles or debris shall be allowed within the drip lines of these trees. Existing perimeter plantings shall be fenced and retained throughout the entire construction period.
21. After completion of rough framing or at least six (6) months prior to scheduling a final inspection, the applicant shall submit landscape screening and erosion control plans for review by the Planning Commission. The application for landscape screening and erosion control shall be accompanied by the applicable fee and deposit. The plans shall be reviewed at a noticed public hearing. Attention shall be given to plantings which will be adequate to break up the view of the new residence from surrounding properties and streets. In review of the landscape screening plan, the Committee shall ensure proposed shrubs and trees are selected such that mature growth does not negatively impact the views of adjacent properties.
All landscaping required for screening purposes and for erosion control (as determined by the City Engineer) must be installed prior to final inspection of the new residence. The landscape screening plan shall comply with Section 10-2.809 (water efficient landscaping) of the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code.
22. A landscape maintenance and water usage deposit, in an amount established by the Town’s Fee Schedule in effect at the time of approval, shall be paid to the Town prior to final inspection of the new residence. Two years after the project has been completed, the applicant shall furnish staff with the last 12 months of water usage for the property and conduct a site inspection to ensure installed landscape screening is still present and has been adequately maintained. Inadequate maintenance of installed landscape screening and/or water usage greater than the annual usage indicated on the approved parcel water budget worksheet, may result in complete forfeiture of this deposit.
23. Prior to requesting the final inspection, the property owner’s Geotechnical Consultant shall inspect, test (as needed), and approve all geotechnical aspects of the project construction.
The inspections should include, but not necessarily be limited to: site preparation and grading, site surface and subsurface drainage improvements, excavations for foundations and retaining walls prior to the placement of steel and concrete. The results of these inspections
Resolution CC _-26 Page 15
and the as-built conditions of the project shall be described by the geotechnical consultant in a letter and submitted to the Town for review prior to final project approval.
24. Prior to requesting the final inspection, a registered civil engineer or licensed land surveyor shall certify in writing and state that “the height of the new residence complies with the 27’- 0” maximum structure height, measured as the vertical distance at any point from the bottom of the crawl space or basement ceiling if excavated below natural grade, to the highest part of the structure directly above (including roof materials).” The overall structure height shall be similarly certified in writing and state that “all points of the building (including chimneys and appurtenances) lie within a thirty-five (35’) foot horizontal band based, measured from the lowest visible natural or finished grade topographical elevation of the structure along the building line and the highest topographical elevation of the roof of the structure.” The applicant shall submit the stamped and signed letter(s) to the Community Development Department prior to requesting a final inspection.
25. Prior to requesting the final inspection, a registered civil engineer or licensed land surveyor shall certify in writing and state that “the location of the new residence and roof eaves matches the location shown on the Site Development plan.” The elevation of the new residence shall be similarly certified in writing to state that “the elevation of the new residence matches the elevation and location shown on the Site Development plan.” The applicant shall submit the stamped and signed letter(s) to the Community Development Department prior to requesting a final inspection.
26. All properties shall pay School District fees to either the Los Altos School District and Mountain View Los Altos Union High School District or the Palo Alto Unified School District, as applicable, prior to permit issuance. The applicant shall take a copy of worksheet #2 to school district offices, pay the appropriate fees and provide the Town with a receipt.
27. The Applicant, project sponsor, and property owner and their heirs, successors, and assigns shall, at its sole cost and expense, indemnify, defend with counsel selected by the Town, protect, release, and hold harmless the Town, its officials (elected or appointed), officers, employees, commissions, committees, agents, consultants, representatives and volunteers, (together, “Indemnitees”), from any and all claims, actions, or proceedings arising out of or in any way relating to the processing and/or approval of this Project, the purpose of which is to attack, set aside, void, or annul the approval of this Project, inclusive of Williamson Act compatibility determinations and grant of variances and exceptions, and any environmental determination that accompanies it. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, suits, damages, judgments, costs, expenses, liens, levies, attorney fees or expert witness fees that may be asserted or incurred by any person or entity, including the applicant, third parties and the Indemnitees, arising out of or in connection with the approval of this Project, whether or not there is concurrent, passive, or active negligence on the part of the Indemnitees.
Nothing herein shall prohibit the Town from participating in the defense of any claim, action, or proceeding. The parties shall use best efforts, acting in good faith, to select mutually agreeable defense counsel. If the parties cannot reach agreement, the Town may select its own legal counsel and the Applicant agrees to pay directly, or timely reimburse on a monthly basis, the Town for all such court costs, attorney fees, and time referenced herein.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 16
28. All outstanding fees owed to the Town, including staff time spent processing this application, shall be paid in full prior to the issuance of a building permit.
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
29. Any, and all, changes to the approved Grading and Drainage plan shall first be approved by the Town Engineering Department. No grading shall take place during the grading moratorium (October 1st to April 30th) except with prior approval from the City Engineer.
Additionally, grading is not permitted within ten (10) feet of any property line.
30. An encroachment permit from the Town’s Public Works Department is required for all work conducted within the public right-of-way. No work may begin until the permit has been issued.
31. All public utility services serving the new residence shall be placed underground. Contact PG&E as soon as the building permit is issued, as the undergrounding process may take to 6-8 months.
32. All hydrant use is strictly prohibited by the Purissima Hills Water District. A permit for obtaining water for grading and construction purposes must be obtained from the Purissima Hills Water District and submitted for approval to the Town Engineering Department prior to acceptance of plans for building plan check. The permit will authorize the use of water from specific on-site or off-site water sources.
Prior To Building Plan Check
33. A set of plans which includes a septic system that has been recommended for approval by the County of Santa Clara, Department of Environmental Health shall be submitted to the Engineering Department prior to acceptance of plans for building plan check.
At Building Plan Check
34. Show the 10’ grading setback line on the Civil Plans. Revise plans at Building Plan Check.
35. Add additional heavy-duty erosion control blanket along the downstream end of the bubbler at the southerly portion of the site up to the edge of the property line.
36. Submit a Grading and Construction Operation Plan (COP) for review at building plan check.
37. Upload high-resolution, color photographs of existing roadway and pathway conditions to the Town’s Trakit system.
38. Pay the pathway fee of $10,943 for the construction of a new residence.
Prior To Final Inspection
39. The Engineer of Record shall observe the installation of the drainage system, energy dissipators, and final grading. A stamped and signed letter certifying compliance with the approved plans must be submitted prior to final inspection.
40. During the rainy season, all disturbed native soils must be protected with appropriate erosion control measures. Replanting shall be completed, as necessary, prior to final inspection.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 17
41. The property owner shall inform the Town of any damage and shall repair any damage caused by the construction of the project to pathways, private driveways, and public and private roadways prior to final inspection.
FIRE DEPARTMENT
42. Fire Sprinklers Required: An automatic residential fire sprinkler system shall be installed in all new one- and two-family dwellings.
43. Required Fire Flow: The minimum required hydrant fire flow for this project is 1,125 Gallons Per Minute (GPM) at 20 psi residual pressure. Letter received. Hydrant is capable of meeting fire flow.
44. Fire Apparatus (Engine) Access Driveway Required: Installations shall conform to Fire Department Standard Details and Specifications Sheet D-1. Driveway shall comply with the D-1 Standard. Shown on Sheet C-1.0.
45. Water Supply Requirements: Potable water supplies shall be protected from contamination caused by fire protection water supplies. It is the responsibility of the applicant and any contractors and subcontractors to contact the water purveyor supplying the site of such project, and to comply with the requirements of that purveyor. Such requirements shall be incorporated into the design of any water-based fire protection systems, and/or fire suppression water supply systems or storage containers that may be physically connected in any manner to an appliance capable of causing contamination of the potable water supply of the purveyor of record. Final approval of the system(s) under consideration will not be granted by this office until compliance with the requirements of the water purveyor of record are documented by that purveyor as having been met by the applicant(s). 2022 CFC Sec. 903.3.5 and Health and Safety Code 13114.7.
46. Address identification: New and existing buildings shall have approved address numbers, building numbers or approved building identification placed in a position that is plainly legible and visible from the street or road fronting the property. These numbers shall contrast with their background. Where required by the fire code official, address numbers shall be provided in additional approved locations to facilitate emergency response. Address numbers shall be Arabic numbers or alphabetical letters. Numbers shall be a minimum of 4 inches (101.6 mm) high with a minimum stroke width of 0.5 inch (12.7 mm). Where access is by means of a private road and the building cannot be viewed from the public way, a monument, pole or other sign or means shall be used to identify the structure. Address numbers shall be maintained. CFC Sec. 505.1.
47. Construction Site Fire Safety: All construction sites must comply with applicable provisions of the CFC Chapter 33 and our Standard Detail and Specification S1-7. Provide appropriate notations on subsequent plan submittals, as appropriate to the project. CFC Chp.
33.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 18
Resolution CC _-26 Page 1
RESOLUTION CC _-26
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
MAKING FINDINGS AND DENYING A SITE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT, VARIANCE
AND GRADING POLICY EXCEPTION FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE
AND ASSOCIATED IMPROVEMENTS AT UNADDRESSED PARCEL ON LA BARRANCA ROAD (APN 182-05-034) FOR INCOMPATIBILITY WITH THE
WILLIAMSON ACT AND LAND CONSERVATION CONTRACT
WHEREAS, on November 10, 2025, the Town of Los Altos Hills received an application for a Site Development Permit (SD25-0072) from the property owners, Naveen Vangala and Shalini Tokala (together, “Applicant”), for a new single-family residence, and associated improvements at a vacant, unaddressed parcel on La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) (“Project”); the application also proposes to construct a primary dwelling pursuant to Government Code section 65852.21 (SB 9) and an accessory dwelling unit pursuant to Government Code section 66314 et seq., both of which are permitted by right under state law and only subject to ministerial approval, and thus not before the City Council for consideration; and WHEREAS, the Project parcel is enrolled in a Williamson Act contract and is designated for agricultural land conservation pursuant to the California Land Conservation Act of 1965 (“Contract”); and
WHEREAS, the subject property contains steep slopes and an active fault trace that create physical constraints on the property and limit the feasible area for development; on February 24, 2026, the property owner, the Applicant applied for a variance to exceed the maximum driveway width and to exceed Maximum Development Area; and
WHEREAS, the Project application was processed in accordance with the applicable provisions of the California Government Code and the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code, and Town staff evaluated the Project’s consistency with the Contract to review whether the proposed uses including agricultural operations, open space preservation, noting that the Contract specifies both primary and secondary dwellings constitute compatible uses for this contracted parcel; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing on the project on June 8, 2026, and considered all evidence, testimony, written documentation, and public comments; and voted 4-01-1 (one recusal) to continue the project to a date uncertain to allow staff to provide additional information regarding the Williamson Act, obtain the Open Space Committee’s recommendations, and allow the applicant to address comments related to site development; and WHEREAS, on June 10, 2026, the Open Space Committee reviewed the project and provided a recommendation on the requirement for open space easement dedication; and WHEREAS, on July 9, 2026, the applicant submitted project revisions in response to Planning Commission received on June 8, 2026, such that the project no longer requires a Variance to exceed the Maximum Development Area; and
Resolution CC _-26 Page 2
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing on the project on August 6, 2026, during which hearing Town staff recommended that the Planning Commission forward an approval recommendation to the City Council, including a finding that the project is compatible with the existing Williamson Act Contract and Government Code Section 51238.1; and
WHEREAS, on August 6, 2026, the Planning Commission voted 4-0-1 (one recusal) to continue consideration of the project to September 3, 2026, and directed staff to prepare a resolution recommending that the City Council deny the project based on Williamson Act compatibility concerns, specifically the Commission’s determination that agriculture would not remain the primary use of the parcel; and
WHEREAS, on September 3, 2026, the Planning Commission received additional staff and legal analysis, reopened discussion, voted 4-0-1 (one absent) to direct staff to return with a resolution recommending that the City Council approve the project for consideration on the October 1, 2026 Consent Calendar; and
WHEREAS, on October 1, 2026, the Planning Commission removed the item from the Consent Calendar and opened the item for discussion and public comment and after considering all evidence, testimony, written documentation, and public comments; voted 3-1-1 (one recusal) recommending that the City Council initiate non-renewal of the Williamson Act Contract and find that the proposed project is not compatible with Government Code Section 51238.1 and the existing Williamson Act contract; and
WHEREAS, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing on the project on November 12, 2026, and at the hearing considered all reports, plans, submittals, documents, testimony, legal authority and other evidence in the record; the Applicant and all interested parties were provided an opportunity to be heard at the public hearing.
NOW, THEREFORE, based on the entirety of the record before it, the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby make the findings set forth under Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein, and hereby denies the Project.
The above and foregoing Resolution was passed and adopted by the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills at a regular meeting held on the 12th day of November 2026 by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
By: ___________________________________
Rajiv Bhateja, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________________
Arika Birdsong-Miller, City Clerk
Resolution CC _-26 Page 3
EXHIBIT A
FINDINGS
Lands of Vangala & Tokala – APN 182-05-034 – File# SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 Based on the entirety of the record before it, which includes, without limitation, the California Environmental Quality Act, Public Resources Code §21000, et seq. and the CEQA Guidelines, 14 California Code of Regulations §15000, et seq. (collectively, “CEQA”); California Government Code §51200 et seq.; the Los Altos Hills General Plan; the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code; the Project application materials; the Project Williamson Act contract; all staff reports, technical reports, minutes, and public testimony submitted as part of the Planning Commission’s duly noticed June 8, August 6, September 3, October 1, 2026, public hearings and meetings; the City Council’s November 12, 2026 public hearing; and any and all other evidence (within the meaning of Public Resources Code §21080(e) and §21082.2), the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby finds as follows:
A. General Findings.
1. All of the facts and recitals above are true, correct, incorporated herein and made a part hereof.
2. The documents and other material constituting the record for these proceedings are located at the Community Development Department for the Town of Los Altos Hills, 26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022, and in the custody of the Community Development Director.
3. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15270, CEQA does not apply to projects which a public agency rejects or disapproves. The City Council hereby finds that no environmental review or action is required for denial of the Project.
B. Williamson Act Compatibility Findings.
1. The City Council finds that the proposed Project is not consistent with the intents and purposes of the Williamson Act (Government Code section 51200 et seq.) by proposing use that are not compatible with commercial agriculture and that do not make agriculture the primary use onsite. The Williamson Act is the legislative enactment to preserve agricultural and open space land by restricting land uses in exchange for reduced property tax and valuation. The Ac specifies that every contract shall provide for the “exclusion of uses other than agricultural” and “other than those compatible with agricultural uses” for the duration of the contract. A parcel is only eligible for a Williamson Act contract if it is “devoted to agricultural use” and is located within an area designated as agricultural preserve. The intent of the Williamson Act contract is to “preserve a maximum amount of the limited supply of agricultural land” (Gov. Code section 51220(a)). It only follows, from this legislative intent, that the law and contract entered pursuant thereto are to preserve agricultural uses and ensure that agriculture remain the primary use on contracted lands.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 4
In this case, the proposed Project consists mostly of residential development and associated improvements. The Project parcel is currently vacant and does not contain any agricultural uses. The proposed farming operations only consist of a small number of chickens and vegetable planting and is not the type of commercial agriculture intended to be preserved and promoted under the Williamson Act. The Project does not focus on agricultural uses but instead facilitates the parcel to be a residential property. This is evidence by the County Assessor’s response that the entire parcel would be treated as a “homesite” due to the residential occupancy. As such, agriculture would not be the primary use on the Project site and approval of the proposed developments would defeat the purpose of the Act.
Similarly, although the proposed Project proposes an open space easement, it doesn’t appear that such easement would have the effect of preserving agricultural lands and commercial agriculture based on intent of the Act. Although the Project proposes minimal animal keeping and vegetable planting to qualify as farming operations, the construction of a single-family home over 4,000 square feet with associated improvements effectively transforms the Project site into a non-agricultural property. It cannot be said, based on the Project proposal and the record before the Council, that the Project parcel is “devoted to agricultural use” and fulfills the intent of the Williamson Act and the Contract.
Approving the Project would circumvent the intent of the Williamson Act.
2. The City Council also finds that the Project is not consistent with the principles of compatibility set forth under Government Code section 51238.1. Section 51238.1 requires that approved uses on contracted lands must be consistent with all of the following principles of compatibility, and in evaluating compatibility the City Council is to consider the impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve. It should be noted that the Town has not adopted any rules of compatibility for determining whether a particular use is compatible with Williamson Act provisions and the land conservation contract entered pursuant to that statute. Thus, the City Council would need to look to Section 51238.1 to determine whether approved uses on contracted lands are compatible with the Section 51238.1 principles.
The Section 51238.1 compatibility principles are listed below and followed by findings to each of them.
a. The use will not significantly compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves.
The City Council finds that the proposed use is not consistent with this principle of compatibility. The proposed development would establish a substantial residential presence on a 1.1-acre property subject to a Williamson Act contract originally approved in 1972 for agricultural land conservation. The project includes a 4,584-square-foot, two-story primary residence with an attached garage, a 793-square-foot attached Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), and a 999-square-foot attached SB 9 unit, together with associated hardscape, driveway, grading, and other site improvements.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 5
The Council recognizes that the proposed Project includes uses identified in the existing Williamson Act contract. However, the identification of individual uses as compatible does not, by itself, establish that the overall scale and intensity of the proposed development are consistent with the agricultural preservation objectives of the Contract. As noted above, the intense residential development and associated improvements on the property effectively transforms the parcel into a residential area with incidental agricultural operations that barely qualifies as a commercial operation. Once the residential nature of the site is developed, it is likely difficult to return the site to primarily agricultural operations (for example, the residence may need to be demolished necessitating the displacement of residents to make space) as intended by the Williamson Act Contract and statute.
The Council therefore finds that the record demonstrates approving the Project would undermine the purpose and intended restrictions of the Williamson Act by permitting residential development on contracted property to an extent comparable to that allowed on properties not subject to a Williamson Act Contract. The proposed development does not maintain agricultural use as the primary use, rendering the land not “devoted to agricultural use” contrary to statutory intent. The Project has not demonstrated that the property's agricultural preservation objectives or long-term agricultural use would be adequately maintained.
b. The use will not significantly displace or impair current or reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves.
The City Council finds that the proposed use is not consistent with this principle of compatibility.
Although the Project proposes activities constitute agricultural uses, the record shows that the agricultural component of the proposal has not been demonstrated to be of sufficient scale or intensity to maintain agriculture as the primary use of the contracted property. The substantial residential development, when considered in relation to the limited agricultural operations proposed, raises concerns regarding the property's continued ability to support current and reasonably foreseeable agricultural activities. In particular, Section 51238.1 provides that “uses that significantly displace agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or parcels may be deemed compatible if they relate directly to the production of commercial agricultural products on the subject contracted parcel or parcels or neighboring lands, including activities such as harvesting, processing, or shipping.” Here, the record shows that the proposed residential use largely replaces agricultural operations, and does not relate to commercial agricultural production. Again, as discussed above, the Project would render agricultural use incidental and instead transforms the site into a residential homesite. This is contrary to the intent of the Wiliamson Act.
The Council further finds that the implications of this development extend beyond the subject property. Allowing residential development on contracted property to an extent comparable to unrestricted residential property could establish expectations for similar development on other properties within the agricultural preserve, potentially increasing
Resolution CC _-26 Page 6
pressure on contracted lands and diminishing the distinction between contracted and noncontracted properties.
The Council further finds that, in the absence of clearly established standards and procedures for evaluating the appropriate scale and intensity of development under existing Williamson Act contracts, compatibility determinations could result in inconsistent interpretations and administration of the Act. Such inconsistency could further weaken the agricultural preservation protections intended by the Williamson Act. c. The use will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use.
The City Council finds that the proposed use is inconsistent with this principle of compatibility.
In evaluating the proposed use, the Council considered the broader implications of allowing additional residential development within the agricultural preserve, including the potential to undermine the continued agricultural and open-space use of surrounding contracted lands. The Council is further concerned that allowing residential development under the existing Williamson Act contract could weaken the agricultural preservation protections established by the Act and create additional pressure for non-agricultural uses within the agricultural preserve.
The proposed agricultural activities consist of limited vegetable farming, chicken farming for egg production, and the sale of vegetable and potted plants. Although the Applicant has also proposed preserving portions of the property through an open space easement, the record shows that the overall balance between residential development, agricultural activities, and open space preservation does not sufficiently advance the agricultural preservation purposes of the Williamson Act because it makes agricultural incidental to the other uses.
d. In evaluating compatibility, the council shall consider the impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve or preserves.
The City Council finds that the proposed use raises broader concerns regarding its potential impacts on the agricultural preserve, including the treatment of other properties subject to Williamson Act contracts and the distinction between contracted and noncontracted lands.
Allowing development on contracted property to an extent comparable to unrestricted property could undermine the purpose and effectiveness of the Williamson Act and weaken its intended agricultural preservation protections. In the absence of separately published Town compatibility guidelines, the Council is concerned that approving substantial residential development under existing Williamson Act contracts without clearly established standards for evaluating the appropriate scale and intensity of such development could lead to inconsistent compatibility determinations. The Council is further concerned that this approach could weaken the incentive and policy framework for maintaining agricultural land under Williamson Act contracts, potentially increasing
Resolution CC _-26 Page 7
pressure for residential and other non-agricultural development throughout the agricultural preserve.
Accordingly, the City Council finds that the proposed use raises substantial policy concerns regarding the treatment of both contracted and noncontracted lands, the consistent administration of Williamson Act contracts, and the long-term preservation of agricultural and open-space resources throughout the agricultural preserve.
3. The City Council further finds that each site development permit application or other land use entitlement request are evaluated on a case by case basis and analyzed based on the individual circumstances and characteristics of the project parcel that is the subject of the application. Likewise, compatibility determinations under the Williamson Act are also made on a case by case basis based on individually contracted lands, rather than blanketly across the board. Similarly, the Williamson Act provides that contracts offered to land owners within the same agricultural preserve may contain different terms to reflect differences in location and characteristics of the land and are pursuant to uniform rules adopted by the Town (Gov. Code section 51241). Thus, the Act itself contemplates that differences in parcel characteristics and site conditions would be taken into account when contracting or deciding on compatible uses. The Town has followed these review principles in reviewing the Project application and the City’s Council’s findings are based on the particular circumstances of this Project site and its use proposals. The applicant’s counsel cites 24005 Oak Knoll Circle, Los Altos Hills, as an example of the Town not treating the Project and the subject parcel in a fair and equal manner. However, in reviewing the Town’s records, the 24005 Oak Knoll Circle site is approximately 2 acres and has a 12 percent average slope; the Project site on the other hand is approximately
1.1 acres with a 33 percent average slope. When the 24005 Oak Knoll Circle project came to the Town, the project proposes to demolish and replace an existing single-family home instead of proposing new uses to unoccupied land contracted for agriculture. The 24005 Oak Knoll Circle parcel also entered into its Williamson Act contract with the County of Santa Clara as a part of a larger subdivision under county compatibility rules before it was annexed to Los Altos Hills. The Town’s contract with the Project site does not incorporate the County’s rules and compatibility determination for the Project site would need to be made based on statutory intent and compatibility principles. It therefore appears the Project site and the 24005 Knoll Circle parcel are not similarly situated and the Town has not treated the Project unfairly or unequally. Rather, the Town conducts case by case review of all site development permit applications on an individual basis; prior land use approvals on other non-Project sites does not bind the Town’s ability to independently evaluate the Project.
C. Site Development Permit, Variance, and Grading Policy Exception Findings.
As discussed in the foregoing findings, the proposed Project is located on Williamson Act contracted land and its proposed development is not compatible with the commercial agricultural uses required by statute and contract. As such, the proposed development cannot occur on the Project site due to incompatibility. The City Council finds that it need not reach review of the Site Development Permit, Variance and Grading Policy Exception requested.
Resolution CC _-26 Page 8
Town of Los Altos Hills – Planning Commission
1 TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS October 1, 2026
Staff Report to the Planning Commission
SUBJECT: Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) – File #SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 – Lands of Vangala & Tokala
Request for: (1) Site Development Permit for the construction of a 4,584 square-foot, two-story single-family residence with attached garage, a 793 square-foot attached Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), 999 square-foot attached SB 9 unit, and associated hardscape and site improvements; (2) Variance to permit a driveway width exceeding the maximum 14 feet; (3) a Grading Policy Exception to allow excavation exceeding the maximum cut thresholds for driveways; and (4) Williamson Act compatibility determination, as the property is subject to a Williamson Act contract for agricultural land conservation.
CEQA review: Categorical Exemption per Section 15303(a) FROM: Jonathan Fox, Senior Planner
APPROVED: Jay Bradford, Community Development Director
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Planning Commission adopt the resolution included as Attachment 1 recommending that the City Council:
1. Find the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15303(a) and that no exceptions pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15300.2 exist because:
a. The project will not impact an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern; b. There is no reasonable possibility the project will have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances;
c. Two of the three residential units are subject to ministerial approval and are all included within one structure;
2. Consider whether the Town should continue supporting the Williamson Act Contract for the subject property and, if the City Council determines that continued enrollment is no longer appropriate, direct staff to initiate the Williamson Act nonrenewal process pursuant to Government Code Section 51245;
3. Determine that the proposed project is compatible with the principles set forth in Government Code Section 51238.1 and with the property’s existing Williamson Act Contract; and
4. Approve the Site Development Permit, Variance to allow a driveway width exceeding 14 feet, Grading Policy Exception, and associated project entitlements, subject to the revised Conditions of Approval.
This recommendation is substantively the same as the approval recommendation presented to the Planning Commission on August 6, 2026 (Attachment 3), with the Conditions of Approval revised to reflect the Commission’s September 3, 2026 direction (Attachment 2).
BACKGROUND
The Planning Commission first considered the project on June 8, 2026. The Commission continued the item to allow additional review of the Williamson Act, obtain the Open Space Committee’s ITEM 3.3 Staff Report Revised
Town of Los Altos Hills – Planning Commission
2 recommendation, and allow the applicant to address site-development comments. The June 8, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 4.
At the August 6, 2026 meeting, staff recommended that the Planning Commission forward an approval recommendation to the City Council, including a finding that the project is compatible with the existing Williamson Act Contract and Government Code Section 51238.1. Staff also recommended that the City Council separately consider whether continued enrollment of the property under the Williamson Act remains appropriate. The August 6, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 3.
The August 6 revised plans eliminated the previously requested Maximum Development Area variance and removed the swimming pool from the project. The remaining discretionary requests are the Site Development Permit, the driveway-width Variance, the Grading Policy Exception, and the Williamson Act compatibility determination.
On September 3, 2026, the Commission received additional staff and legal analysis, reopened discussion of the site-development issues, and identified specific modifications to the Conditions of Approval. The Commission then voted unanimously among the four members present to direct staff to return with resolutions for approval containing the modifications identified on the record and a report regarding the Town’s consultation with the California Department of Conservation. The Commission understood that the item would return on the October 1 consent calendar and could be removed from consent if needed.
The September 3, 2026 staff report is included as Attachment 2.
In a separate motion, the Planning Commission directed staff to agendize a future discussion of criteria for Williamson Act participation and compatibility determinations. That policy discussion is separate from the pending application and is not part of the recommended October 1 action. The motion passed with Commissioners Indaco and Patel and Chair Waschura voting yes, Vice-Chair Bredo abstaining, and Commissioner Junaid absent.
DISCUSSION
SEPTEMBER 3, 2026 DIRECTION
The following are modifications to the Conditions of Approval as directed by the Planning Commission on September 3, 2026. These revisions are incorporated into the proposed resolution and revised Conditions of Approval in Attachment 1.
Commission Direction Revision in Attachment 1
Reduce the large skylight to 70 square feet. Revised skylight condition limits the large courtyard skylight/glazed roof area to a maximum
of 70 square feet and retains light-spill controls.
Include the Open Space Easement as a Condition
of Approval.
New condition requires execution and recordation
of the open space easement before building
permit issuance, generally consistent with the
Open Space Committee recommendation and
approved plans.
Ensure all exterior lighting is consistent with the
lighting plan and Outdoor Lighting Policy.
Exterior-lighting condition is strengthened to
require installation and ongoing maintenance
consistent with the approved lighting plan and
Town Outdoor Lighting Policy.
Install a permanent planter in front of the patio New condition requires a permanent planter/barrier configuration sufficient to prevent
ITEM 3.3 Staff Report Revised