2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Kinson Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
CAROL TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
KENRIC TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Kenric Tam <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 3:40 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land's unrestricted fair market value. I note that the "consistent with the
purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Kenric Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
KENRIC TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
ROBERT APTEKAR Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Robert Aptekar <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 4:20 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Robert Aptekar
Scarff Way, LAH
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
ROBERT APTEKAR Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
CHERYL EVANS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Cheryl A Breetwor <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 5:27 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]> Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
CHERYL EVANS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on ci a contracted land The Willarson t provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non- agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner- initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land's unrestricted fair market value. I note that the "consistent with the purposes of the Act" cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non- Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative "public interest" finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act's objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act's own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a "compatible use" on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a "compatible use" while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act's material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee's size technically exempts it from the Brown Act's noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Cheryl Evans
Buena. Vista Drive
Cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
C OAKSON Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
-----Original Message-----
From: C Oakson <
Sent: Tuesday, Sep AM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan < [email protected]>; Kavita Tankha < [email protected]>; Stanley Mok < [email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas < [email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Sent from my iPhone
SUSAN MIRBACH Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Susan Mirbach
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 6:42 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Susan Mirbach
Eucalyptus Lane Los Altos Hills
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
SUSAN MIRBACH Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Wei Guang Wu Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Wei Guang Wu <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 7:37 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Wei Guang Wu
La Barranca Rd
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Wei Guang Wu Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada < [email protected]>
From: Denise***
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 8:00 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta lndaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Breda <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter
Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code§ 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10 year term followed by sequential one year extensions. That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the
12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Larry n Denise Del Carlo
La Barranca, LAH
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: regarding the La Barranca development proposal
From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: nicholas
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 10:01 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>;Stanley Mok<[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: regarding the La Barranca development proposal September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: regarding the La Barranca development proposal
Dear council,
I have reviewed available documentation on this project, but fundamentally it is just not the type of land from a topographical standpoint (i.e. severe slope) that should be development, even on a single family home basis, let alone multi family units.
The actual parcel sold in 2024 for practically nothing, compared to other LAH properties, because it was such an unbuildable lot. I don't think the town should encourage, or support, construction on such a property.
I'm happy to discuss in greater detail and i understand we may have some limitations, but this project site is not appropriate for housing because of the property slope and unsafe nature around the curve.
i can also support the below statement, but my concern with the project is more fundamental regarding the land.
thanks
Nicholas French
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town’s Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions. That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.
Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional-use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non-agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material-breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
nicholas french
la cresta drive
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Thanks,
Nick
Nicholas French
Broker Associate
Christie’s Sereno
1 st Street #200, Los Altos
Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Barbara Cannon Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
-----Original Message-----
From: Barbara Cannon <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 6:03 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan < [email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura < [email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas < [email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Barbara Cannon
JESSICA TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Jessica Tam <
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 12:34 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.
Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Jessica Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
JESSICA TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Eric Evans Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Eric Evans <
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 1:13 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Eric Evans
Buena Vista Drive
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Eric Evans Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
FAYE HSU Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected].
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Faye Hsu
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 10:30 AM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Faye Hsu
La Barranca Rd
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
FAYE HSU Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Michael Grady Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Michael Grady
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 1:30 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>; Michael Grady <[email protected]> Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Michael Grady
Saddle Mountain Drive
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Michael Grady Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring accurate application of the Williamson Act From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Eda Anguiano
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 1:42 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring accurate application of the Williamson Act September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town’s Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
Eda Yasmina Anguiano Chavez Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.
Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional-use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non-agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material-breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Eda Yasmina Anguiano Chavez
Saddle Mountain Dr
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Eda Yasmina Anguiano Chavez Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
JIM GEERS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:19 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Jim Geers
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 4:55 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.
Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Jim Geers
Natoma Road
cc:
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
JIM GEERS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
GRACE YEE Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford < [email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:20 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: gracey Yee <
Sent: Wednesday, September 30, 2026 3:26 PM
To: [email protected]; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaic <[email protected]>; Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]> Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 30, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:
I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.
I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:
1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.
That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.
2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.
3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.
Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for non prime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.
4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.
I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Grace Yee
Elena Road
GRACE YEE Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
Supplement to Agenda Item 3.3 – La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) – Information on the Purchase Price of the Parcel
From Jim Waschura <[email protected]>
Date Thu 10/1/2026 9:41 AM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
Cc Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Please include the following as a supplement to the La Barranca item on the Consent Calendar. ==================
This is unusual. This information is being provided as a resident supplement to this evening's meeting regarding the La Barranca item that is on the agenda as a Consent item. I am not stating any opinions or conclusions about the outcome of any agenda item. This is an effort to relay information to everyone that would otherwise take a lot of time in the meeting to convey. In July, the Planning Commission discussed mechanisms to reduce the lengths of meetings, including pre-transmittal of information via publicly viewable agenda supplements. Time for public comment is expected to be provided for everyone to have an opportunity to respond to this information.
Fellow commissioners: please do not reply to this message or discuss it with one another before the meeting, so that no Brown Act question arises. Questions can be raised at the meeting. ==================
Residents have asked why the La Barranca Road parcel sold for far less than other vacant lots in Town, and whether the Williamson Act contract explains the difference. This supplement sets out what the Santa Clara County Assessor's Office told staff about how it valued the land, what public listing records show about recent land sales, and how the parcel compares with the one sale most like it. It does not draw conclusions.
What the Assessor's Office told staff about the land value Matthew Leslie, Senior Appraiser, answered staff's questions in writing on August 28, September 9 and September 30, 2026. The points that bear on the price are these.
The land's Proposition 13 base year value was set at $800,000 as of the March 2024 purchase.
Public listing records (MLS ML81957879) show the sale price as $700,000. The Assessor's Office is not required to adopt the sale price, and it did not state what the $100,000 difference reflects.
The Assessor's Office described the value as much lower than other buildable sites in Los Altos Hills because of building concerns reported by the selling agent, which led the office to treat the site as unbuildable at the time of purchase. It later added that the land "was not completely unbuildable, it just had extra hurdles to jump compared to other properties in the area." No separate adjustment was made for the Williamson Act contract. The office stated that the value was compared to similar properties with similar building issues, so the contract "is taken
into account through the comparables that are chosen." The comparables are not disclosed to anyone other than the owner.
Recent vacant-lot sales in Los Altos Hills
The table lists vacant-lot sales of roughly one acre or more since 2022 that appear in public listing services (Redfin, Estately, Compass and brokerage sites, as of October 1, 2026). Prices and dates come from listings rather than recorded deeds and have not been independently verified. "MDA" is the Town's Maximum Development Area, the total ground area that may be covered by structures, driveways, patios and other hard surfaces; La Barranca's figure is from the June 8, 2026 staff report and the others are from listings.
Lot Acres Price Sale date MDA Site condition as listed
12243 Tepa
Way
1.65 $4,300,000 Feb 2022 ~23,276 sf Flat, creekside, plans prepared 12815 Deer
Creek Ln 2.67 $4,100,000 Mar 2022 20,338 sf Plans nearly approved, public water 0 La Barranca
Rd 1.16 $700,000 Mar 2024 7,500 sf
33% average slope, septic, Williamson
Act contract
27360 Elena Rd 1.26 $1,025,000 Jul 2024 ~9,000 sf
Gently sloped, septic, no Williamson
Act contract
21107 Natoma
Oaks Ln 1.17 $4,690,000 Listed Sep2024 17,250 sf
Mostly flat subdivision lot; sewer,
underground utilities, road and storm
drainage built
28120 Laura Ct 3.87 $5,300,000 Nov 2025 18,364 sf
Gently sloped, final map approved,
sewer and water
26737 Taaffe Rd 1.07 $4,500,000 Feb 2026 not listed not listed 27121 W
Fremont Rd 1.26 $6,500,000 Mar 2026 not listed not listed 20103 Natoma
Oaks Ln 1.03 $5,100,000 Aug 2026 not listed Same subdivision as 21107 One other vacant parcel under a Williamson Act contract, 27388 Sherlock Court (2.2 acres), is currently listed for sale at $1,498,000 after a $301,000 price reduction, about $680,000 per acre. La Barranca sold for $603,000 to $700,000 per acre, depending on whether the 1.16-acre gross area or the 1.0 acre shown in the listing is used. An asking price is not a sale and carries less weight than the sales in the table.
How appraisers select comparables
An appraisal comparable is a recent sale that shares the subject property's principal value drivers, so that the remaining differences are small enough to adjust for. For hillside land in Los Altos Hills, those drivers are the availability of sewer and other utilities, the slope and stability of the ground, the development area the Town allows, and whether plans or approvals are already in hand. The Natoma Oaks lots, and the Tepa Way, Deer Creek and Laura Court lots, were sold with sewer service, built roads and utilities, gentle or flat terrain, development areas two to three times larger than La Barranca's, and in several cases approved or nearly approved plans. The Elena Road lot is the only sale in the table that, like La Barranca, has no sewer, a development area under 10,000 square feet, and a multi-year marketing history with repeated price reductions. Readers can judge for themselves which sales inform the La Barranca price.
Similarities between La Barranca Road ($700,000) and 27360 Elena Road ($1,025,000) Both parcels are in the same area of Town, in adjacent Assessor's map books (182-05 and 182-04), and both are near enough to Interstate 280 to experience freeway noise.
They are similar in size, 1.16 acres and 1.26 acres.
Neither has sewer service; both rely on septic systems.
Both sold in 2024 after long marketing periods. La Barranca was first listed in 2019 at $1,200,000, relisted in 2021 at $1,695,000 and in 2023 at $998,000, and sold in March 2024 for $700,000.
Elena Road was first listed in 2020 at $1,900,000, was reduced several times, had two buyer contingencies fall through, and sold in July 2024 for $1,025,000.
Both are limited to a 5,000 square foot maximum floor area.
Elena Road is not under a Williamson Act contract (California Department of Conservation Williamson Act parcel data). For that parcel the Assessor's Office enrolled the sale price as the base year value (Compass listing tax data; not confirmed with the Assessor).
Differences between the two parcels
Slope. La Barranca has an average slope of 33.3 percent (June 8, 2026 staff report); Elena Road was marketed as gently sloped. The selling agent's disclosure of building difficulties at La Barranca is what the Assessor's Office cited in treating the site as unbuildable at purchase.
Driveway. The La Barranca application requests a Grading Policy Exception for driveway excavation beyond the Town's maximum cut thresholds and a variance for a driveway wider than 14 feet (agenda, item 3.3). Elena Road was marketed with site plans and septic, grading and drainage plans already prepared.
Geotechnical conditions. La Barranca lies near a mapped geotechnical hazard zone, which adds soils investigation, engineering and foundation requirements and leaves uncertainty about the buildable portion of the lot.
Development area. La Barranca's MDA is 7,500 square feet; Elena Road's is approximately 9,000 square feet.
Williamson Act contract. La Barranca has been under contract since 1972, and development requires the Town to make compatibility findings under Government Code section 51238.1. The application has been before the Commission since June 2026 and still requires City Council action.
Elena Road carries no such restriction.
The difference between the two sale prices is $325,000, and between the Assessor's two base year values is $225,000. The items above are the differences in the public record that could account for some or all of that amount.
Jim Waschura
Resident, Los Altos Hills
Item 4.1 Supplemental 7
Outlook
FW: Williamson Act - La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) - #SD25-0072 From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Thu 9/3/2026 8:38 AM
To Marco Ahumada < [email protected]>
Caution: Internal ([email protected])
INKY is learning... Safe Spam Phish More... Details FAQ Protection by INKY From: John O'Connell 4
Sent: Wednesday, September 2, 2026 2:00 PM
To: Steve Mattas <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Rajiv Patel <[email protected]>; BCC - Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Subject: Williamson Act - La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) - #SD25-0072 Site development application #SD25-0072 for APN 182-05-034, "O La Barranca Rd." proposes a residential development, to the maximum allowed under LAH zoning, and to the maximum allowed under state SB9 and ADU laws, on a property restricted by a Los Altos Hills (LAH) Williamson Act (WA) contract through Dec. 2035 or beyond.
The LAH WA contract is an enforceable restriction on use of the property, removal of which requires filing a notice of non-renewal [§51244-45].
• Assuming this occurs before the annual renewal of the 10 year contract, the property would be free of the LAH WA encumbrance by Jan. 2036.
Non-renewal status is a prerequisite for filing a petition for contract cancellation [§51280 et seq]. • This is an option under limited circumstances and requires LAH CC to make statutory findings [GC § 51282(a)] before approval of a tentative cancellation, to be reviewed by the Dept. of Conservation (DOC).
• This process requires payment of 12.5% fee based upon the unrestricted fair market value of the property.
The above application is an attempt to bypass State Law by claiming the proposed residential development is a "Compatible Use" allowed under the LAH WA contract.
Primary & secondary residences are specified in the LAH WA contract as compatible uses, and the absence of LAH "Uniform Rules" specifying compatible use criteria or limits, is being interpreted that a development upto the maximum allowed under LAH zoning and state laws is allowed by the LAH WA contract. To support this claim, some token agricultural use is proposed in the application (chickens & vegetables).
This claim is incorrect and contradictory to:
1. Article VIll, section 8 of the California Constitution.
2. The LAH WA contract intent and language.
3. State law as enforced by California's courts and the Dept. of Conservation.
Item 4.1 Supplemental 7
1. Article VIII, Section 8 of the California Constitution is the foundation of the Williamson Act - an agreement for property taxation at a preferential rate requires an exchange for a long term enforceable commitment to preserve the land in agricultural or open space use.
Article XIII, Section 8 "To promote the conservation, preservation and continued existence of open space lands, the Legislature may define open space land and shall provide that when this land is enforceably restricted, in a manner specified by the Legislature, to recreation, enjoyment of scenic beauty, use or conservation of natural resources, or production of food or fiber, it shall be valued for property tax purposes only on a basis that is consistent with its restrictions and uses."
If a LAH WA contracted property could be developed to the same extent as a non- contracted property, there would be NO ENFORCEABLE restriction, and hence the LAH WA contract would be a violation of Article VIII, Section 8 and of §51200 of Part 1, Division 1, Title 5 of the Government Code [the California Land Conservation Act of 1965].
The 1981 Supreme Court ruling [Sierra Club vs City of Hayward] focused on this core concept of the Williamson Act contract. In reversing Hayward's cancellation of a WA contract the court emphasized that the rolling 10 year commitment to restricted use, was the enforceable restriction that supported the conservation objectives of the Williamson Act and justified favorable tax treatment.
• The court further stated that if the 9 year non-renewal process could be bypassed, this would undermine the long-term conservation objectives embodied in the Williamson Act. • This ruling and subsequent Appellate court rulings forced major legislative changes to the Williamson Act, including introduction of financial penalties for material breach of compatible use [ §51250].
If a LAH WA contracted property could be developed to the same as a non-contracted property, there would be no need to initiate the 9 year cancellation process - a property could be developed at any time, without non-renewal, or cancellation.
2. The LAH WA contracts are issued in accordance with 1971 LAH CC resolution #616 [attached]. "Establishing Rules Governing the Administration of Preserves & Procedure Relating to the Implementation of the California Land Conservation Act in the Town of Los Altos Hills"
The language of LAH WA contracts does not support that a WA contracted property can be developed to the same extent as a non-WA property. To the contrary, a property that is not of sufficient size to be subdividable [under LAH §9-1.604] must be unimproved to be eligible for a LAH WA contract.
• The 1971 LAH CC resolution #616 [1971-04-19] was based upon LAH Planning Commission recommendations [PC 1971-03-08] which defined "the criteria for parcels eligibility under the Act to allow inclusion only of those parcels yet subdividable, or yet unimproved in accordance with current Town zoning ordinances." • This language states that a parcel that is not subdividable must be unimproved to be eligible for a LAH WA contract.
• Improvements are only allowed if a parcel is subdividable (LUF > 2).
Article 1 of the LAH WA contract clearly states that the contracts are SUBJECT TO CALIFORNIA LAND CONSERVATION ACT OF 1965.
This contract is entered into pursuant to Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 51200) of Part 1, Division 1, Title 5 of the Government Code, which is known as the California Land
Conservation Act of 1965. This contract is subject to all of Re bravis on amen including any amendments thereto which may hereafter be enacted.
Article 2 further states that a property under WA contract shall not be used for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purpose.
During the term of this contract, and any and all renewals thereof, the property described in Exhibit B shall not be used by Owner, or Owner's successors in interest, for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto.
A list of allowed compatible uses is provided in Exhibit A. Compatible uses, as defined in the California Land Conservation Act of 1965, must be incidental to, and supportive of the primary agricultural use.
• Compatible uses are only allowed if the property is being used for agricultural production. • Development of compatible uses are improvements and do not receive the favorable WA tax treatment.
• Misuse of 'Compatible Use' has been enforced by both the courts and the California Dept. of Conservation [see 3. Santa Clara County DoC Audit].
Resolution #616 Article 10 - Zoning Requirements further states that restrictions imposed by (LAH WA) contracts may be more restrictive than (RA) zoning requirements. • Land within an agricultural or open space preserve shall be devoted to agricultural, open space, and compatible uses as defined by the Act, and as designated by the City Council. The authorization for such uses as contained herein, and contracts entered hereunder, shall not be deemed to modify or take the place of any restrictions imposed upon the land, or any portion thereof, within the preserve by any zoning requirements. • In no event may the uses permitted by contract be less restrictive than existing zoning requirements; provided, however, that restrictions imposed by (LAH WA) contracts may be more restrictive than zoning requirements.
3. A Dept. of Conservation audit of Santa Clara County (SCC) WA contract management in 2002 found that more than 40% of SCC WA contracts were non compliant with the Act. The "Uniform Rules" for determining compatible use were introduced as part of a much broader cleanup, resulting in any properties less than statutory minimum size and/or with less than 60%-75% of the property in agricultural use, receiving Non Renewal notices from SCC.
Properties that had been over developed were subject to penalties under §51250.
The audit summary letter from the Office of State Audits dated 2002-05-29 addressed the development of single family residences as compatible use on WA contracted lots. "Section 51243(a) states that, "every contract shall ... provide for the exclusion of uses other than agriculture, and other than those compatible with agriculture uses, for the duration of the contract." As stated in an opinion of the California Attorney General (62 Op. Alty. Gen. Cal 233, dated May 11, 1979), single-family residences are only compatible with the Williamson Act if they are incidental to farming. We have referred this finding to the Department of Conservation for legal analysis to determine if the Williamson Act has been violated. Depending on its findings, the Department could seek cancellation of the contracts for the affected parcels and remittance of cancellation fees to the State. Alternatively, it could seek to have the land returned to its agricultural or open space use.
Item 4.1 Supplemental 7
The DoC letter dated 2005-03-29, Santa Clara County Williamson Act Program: Revision to Standards and Guidelines specifically addressed the issue of Compatible Use Determination:
In considering compatible uses of contracted land, it is important that the County carefully consider whether an intended "agricultural use" is actually commercial agriculture, or if it is only an after-the-fact pretext for large-lot residential uses, which are prohibited by the Williamson Act.
SCC Uniform Rules came into existence in 2006 as part of a phased "cleanup program" agreed with the various state departments. The fact that these rules did not exist prior to the audit had no bearing on the audit conclusions.
• The presence of commercial agriculture is a pre-condition to consideration of a development application on land restricted by a Williamson Act contract. • Commercial agriculture must be the primary use of the land. Other uses or development must be compatible with and ancillary to the use of the land for commercial production of agricultural commodities.
The LAH uniform rules exist, they are just not easy to find. • SCC rules permit zero compatible use of parcels of 0-3.9ac. Los Altos Hills permits no improvement on parcels with LUF<2.
• For a LAH property of >33% average slope the parcel would have to be > 3.9ac to have LUF>2.
SCC is not the only county to be audited by DOC and forced to cleanup their WA contracts, and the DoC made it clear that other counties have complied. "We once again recommend that all substandard parcels, e.g., parcels less than 10 acres of prime or 40 acres of non-prime land, be non-renewed by the County. Based upon a review of similar substandard parcel and large-lot residential issues, Kings County recently took this action." The simple facts are that the proposed residence(s) will be the primary use of the property occupying more than 30% of the parcel. All of the slopes less than 25% gradient are used by the septic leach fields, the residence(s) and the driveway. Grading exceeding 1,600cyds is required along with removal of ~10 heritage Oaks. Given the slopes in excess of 35% the total amont of agriculture is ~5%. There are many non-WA parcels in Town that have more agriculture than this but they would be ineligible for a LAH WA contract because they are developed / improved!
I respectfully submit that:
• If the Planning Commission were to allow the proposed development as "Compatible Use" on a property bound by a Williamson Act until at least January 2036, this would be an immediate and free removal of the "enforceable restriction" that has supported its preferential tax treatment for 55 years. It would be a violation of the Williamson Act, and if left under a WA contract, a violation of the California Constitution Article XIII, Section 8. • The assertion that the LAH WA contract allows the proposed residential development is incorrect. Resolution 616 - 1971 is available on laserfiche and examination of the PC and CC meeting minutes from 1971 show a clear understanding and intention. • Approval of this frivolous attempt to bypass the Non-Renewal process and avoid payment of any cancellation fees will prove costly for the Town, will have major impact on existing LAH WA contracts that have obeyed the rules, and for the applicants for the current site development.
Item 4.1 Supplemental 7
• The Town should consult the California Department of coltservatión Supplemantal? determination that this project is a WA compatible use and continue the project to a date uncertain.
I have not addressed the issue that SB9 duplex (not subdivision) developments are prohibited on WA contracted land since it is a lower order topic. I have also not addressed the SCC subdivision audit topics since they are not relevant to this application.
Thank you... John O'Connell
-- Forwarded message -_-
From: John O'Connell <[email protected]>
Date: Thu, Aug 6, 2026 at 7:55 AM
Subject: Williamson Act - La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) - #SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 To: Jim Waschura < jim. [email protected]>, Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>, Rajiv Patel <[email protected]>, Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>
Cc: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>, Jonathan Fox <[email protected]> This submission focuses on what I believe is the first and key determination the Planning Commission must make on this project: Is the proposed Residential Development a "Compatible Use" under the Los Altos Hills Williamson Act (WA) contract? The foundation of the California Land Conservation Act -1965 is Article XIII, Section 8 of the California Constitution [although it is dated 1974, it was previously XXVIII - 1966]. California Supreme court and Appellate court rulings have emphasized that a Williamson Act contract - an agreement for a property taxation at a preferential rate requires a long term enforceable commitment to preserve the land in agricultural or open space use.
Article XIII, Section 8 "To promote the conservation, preservation and continued existence of open space lands, the Legislature may define open space land and shall provide that when this land is enforceably restricted, in a manner specified by the Legislature, to recreation, enjoyment of scenic beauty, use or conservation of natural resources, or production of food or fiber, it shall be valued for property tax purposes only on a basis that is consistent with its restrictions and uses." The subject property has been under WA contract for 55 years and in open space use. The owners renewed the rolling 10 year Williamson Act contract in 2026 and have an "enforceable restriction" that limits the property's use to open space and agricultural use until the end of 2035.
The Town is being requested to make a "Compatible Use Determination" for a residential development supporting an agricultural operation that does not exist, on the property that has never been used for agriculture. Although contemplated, the current or future owners could decide not to raise chickens or grow vegetables. The proposed level of the agricultural activity is less than 5% of the property area, and is a choice, not an enforceable commitment on use of the land that justifies a preferential tax rate under Article XIII, Section 8.
The claimed "Compatible Use" is typical of most new residences being built on similar parcels that are not under Williamson Act contracts. Many properties grow vines, orchards, vegetables, plants, etc and some to a greater extent than 5%.
I applaud staff for attempting to apply 851238.1 but (1) & (2) arefust fot apyreadle enterul Compatible Use test I have found from the Dept of Conservation is Does agricultural or open- space use remain the principal use of the property?
• A new residence, an SB9 Unit, and an ADU, totalling ~6,500sf with a basement, with a total development footprint including driveways of ~10,000sf and septic leach fields of 4- 5,000sf. The development is ~30% of the parcel.
• Given the parcel average slope of 35%, a large area will be significantly steeper than 30% and required as OSE under the LAH general plan and site development codes. • Grading to accommodate the structure on the steep slopes will result in 1,600cy of cut, 220cyds of fill and export of 1,400cy from the site.
• To create the development area & leach fields 12 Heritage Oaksand several other mature trees have to be cleared for the development footprint and leach fields. • §51238.1(a)(3) The claimed compatible use will result in more than 1/2 of the contract land being removed from open-space use. and remove a significant area of wildlife habitat.
• The simple facts are that the new residence will be the primary use of the property, there will be some open space easement and possibly some agriculture but no different than exists on other non-Williamson R-A parcels.
Perhaps the clearest answer to the Primary Use question, is to consider how the property would be marketed for sale, after this site development. Would it be:
1. A Williamson Act parcel of just over an acre of wildlife habitat with farming potential and low property taxes.
2. A Private residential estate of 8,000sf on a 1ac scenic location in Los Altos Hills.
Given Williamson Act encumbered properties that have sold in the Town have been $300-700K per acre, my bet is #2. However, if a Compatible Use determination is made and the property remains under a forever Williamson act contract, it will no longer be an encumbrance and become an asset.
The 1981 Supreme Court ruling [Sierra Club vs City of Hayward] focused on the core concept of the Williamson Act contract. The local government and the landowner agree that in exchange for a long term commitment to preserve & maintain farming and to preserve & conserve open space the land owner gets a preferential tax rate. In reverseing the Haywards cancellation of a WA contract the emphasized that the rolling 10 year commitment to restricted use, was the enforceable restriction that supported the conservation objectives of the Williamson Act and justified favourable tax treatment. It further stated that contract cancellation was an extraordinary remedy, not an ordinary planning tool and if the 9 year non-renewal process could be bypassed, this would undermine the long-term conservation objectives embodied in the Williamson Act. This ruling and subsequent Appellate court rulings forced major legislative changes to the Williamson Act. Penalties for material breach of compatible use are specified in §51250.
• A development of 2,500 sf of non Compatible Use carries a penalty of 25% of the unrestricted fair market value of the affected land, plus 25% of the the offending building/improvements value for non compatible use development. This is twice the cost of cancellation plus 25% of the value of the improvements. • Considering that most WA properties are more than an order of magnitude larger than
1.16ac. 2,500sf is a small margin before big penalties.
From all parties' perspectives, it would be best to avoid an incorrect compatible use determination - where incorrect means that either the Dept of Conservation or a Court disagrees with it. In addition to the penalties the owner would face, Los Altos Hills would be doing what the after the Supreme court ruled against, not by by approving a cancellation, but by approving a Compatible use that Defeats the Purpose of the Act. An invalid Compatible Use decision would remove the enforceable restriction allowing the land to be developed, but
Item 4.1 Supplemental 7
leaving it under Williamson Act contract allowing the land to colflue obSteRlemental 7 preferential tax rate would violate the Constitution.
This property was one of the first 5 properties to enter into WA contracts. Of the 5, 3 remain under contract. One of the remaining 3 filed a notice of non renewal in 2026. In my search of Town records this is the first property to claim residential development as a compatible use. It has been done in other locations, they are easy to find by searching for WA litigation.
The process for a Williamson Act property that wants to enable residential development, is to file a notice of Non-Renewal at least 90 days prior to the automatic renewal. §51244-
45. This is a required step for a petition for contract cancellation §51282(b)(1). to be heard by the Town.
I respectfully submit that:
1. If the Planning Commission were to allow the proposed development as "Compatible Use" on a property bound by a Williamson Act until at least January 2035, this would be an immediate and free removal of the "enforceable restriction" that has supported its preferential tax treatment for 55 years. It would be a violation of the Williamson Act, and if left under a WA contract, a violation of the California Constitution Article XIlI, Section 8.
2. The assertion that the LAH WA contract allows the proposed residential development is incorrect. Resolution 616 - 1971 is available on laserfiche and examination of the PC and CC meeting minutes from 1971 show a clear understanding and intention.
3. Given the limited experience in the Town on Williamson Act topics, should you decide that this topic requires further research, that you continue this agenda item to a date uncertain and direct staff to seek guidance from the California Department of Conservation. They are specified by §51206 to advise on interpretation of Williamson Act and associated legislation.
4. The staff recommendation that the PC direct staff to submit a notice of non-renewal on this property, when there are many WA parcels in Town, may not be advisable. There are many WA issues that the Planning Commission & staff should consider before taking any action on a specific property.
Thank you... John O'Connell
E EE E
G GG G
SS SSSS SS
W WW W
O OO O
(60' -
R/W)
LA BARRANCA WAY
S 19°23'19" E
215.69'
N
44°10'57" W
216.97'
S 26°29'07" W
171.23'
S 70°36'39" W
32.00'
N 70°31'00" E
32.00'
D=40°10'06" L=98.15'
R=140.00'
N 30°21'00" E
162.04'
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
SLOPE EASEMENT
408
456
416
434
4 8
0 450
440
430
420
430
440
450
460
4 7
0 460
450
440
430
420
410
460
470
411.50TW
410.65TW
414.21TW
JP
CB
U
X
B
411.34
409.68
411.07 410.61
WV WV
WV
GA
GA
457.51
457.57TB
457.30FL
455.74
455.30FL
455.57TB 455.60
452.52 452.56TB
452.30FL
452.72
449.04
448.66FL
448.87TB 448.83
444.11
444.13TB
443.90FL
444.24
440.31
439.90FL
440.07TB
440.11
435.51
435.41TB
435.23FL
435.82
432.40
431.99FL
432.25TB 432.30
429.48 429.41TB
429.19FL
429.56
425.21
424.89FL
425.01TB
425.02
420.42
420.42TB
420.08FL
420.73
416.82 416.32FL
416.63TB
416.61
413.35
413.35TB
413.24FL 413.71
410.32
409.91FL
410.11TB
408.01
407.74TB
407.67FL
428.14
421.97
418.72
415.65
421.40
426.60
435.15
445.77
438.56
437.26
453.90
408.10
414.72
414.12
448.37
447.15
443.58
441.92
440.92
449.12
448.73
454.68
454.12
459.63
450.92
432.12
429.48
424.54
417.25
416.63
435.82
452.54
451.98
450.27
454.13
452.35
452.59
453.77
442.06
439.40
433.10
435.88
430.27
443.36
443.73
443.79
446.24
454.54
453.56
456.16 459.46
454.32
455.24
455.87
453.58
460.83
471.38
477.40
479.82
482.49
482.86
482.31
482.25
478.91
473.99
470.45
468.47
468.77
468.81 471.65
475.50
478.48
480.87
476.87
463.62
465.30
464.66
465.32
466.13
465.30
462.97
463.72
463.30
463.85
464.78
462.53
471.09
459.32
459.34
458.44
457.75
452.55
411.53
408.42
408.13
417.70 421.91
436.86
436.65
428.85
429.27
432.51
432.86
431.90
432.37
434.25
439.49
441.94
451.86
447.92
STAKE
STAKE
JP
CB
U
X
B
WV WV
WV
GA
GA
443.58
441.92
440.92
482.49
482.86
482.31
482.25
463.62
471.09
429.27
432.51
432.86
431.90
432.37
434.25
439.49
STAKE
STAKE
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
5' P.U.E.
SLOPE EASEMENT
408
456
416
434
4 8
0 450
440
430
420
430
440
450
460
4 7
0 460
450
440
430
420
410
460
470
ACCESS COVER
ACCESS COVER
AVRV
AVRV
CV
AVRV
AVRV
SP3 [5.0']
PT
[2
3 .0']
PT
[2
2 .0']
PT
[2
2 .0']
SP6 [12.0']
SP5 [5.0']
SP4 [5.0']
PT
[2
6 .0']
PT
[2
5 .0']
PT
[2
4 .0']
CP
EFFLUENT LIFT
FM
SV
1A
1B
2A
2B
10' 10'
WM
MG
EM
(N) RESIDENCE
(N) GARAGE
(N) ADU
(N) GREENHOUSE/CHICKEN
COOP
FF: 462.00'±
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
DS
CB
CB
MRO
CB
CB
BUBBLER
CB
CB
AD
AD
AD
AD
SSCO
SSCO
19.8%
10.5%
5%
13%
2%
2%
0.8%
6%
5%
(E)15%
19.8%
2.5%
2%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
1%
41 42
1%
1%
1%
1%
4 3
2 3
3 3
32 17
17 16
13 15
5 6
14 11
10 14
14 14
14 18
12 1.2%
16.3%
32 34
34 34
PROPERTY LINESSETBACK LINESEASEMENT LINEFAULT LINE PER GEOG. MAPFIRST FLOOR OUTLINEWATER LINEFENCE LINEELEC. LINEGAS LINESANITARY SEWER LINELEGENDSECOND FLOOR OUTLINEADU OUTLINESB9 OUTLINEWATER METER WM
ELECTRIC METER EM
GM GAS METER
BUILDING AREARESTRICTED AREAAGRICULTURAL USE AREAPORTABLE CHICKEN COOPSSB 9 @ BASEMENTADUNON-HERITAGE TREE REMOVALHERITAGE TREE REMOVALLIMITS OF OPEN SPACEEASEMENT 5'-0"
(P) 1ST FLOOR SETBACK
61'-3 3/4"
(P) 2ND FLOOR SETBACK
49'-2 1/4"
(P) 2ND FLOOR SETBACK
135'-0 1/4"
(P) 2ND FLOOR SETBACK
32'-0"
(P) 1ST FLOOR SETBACK
160'-10 1/2"
(P) SB 9 & 2ND FLOOR SETBACK
54'-6 3/4"
GARAGE FFE: 443.5'±BASEMENT: 444.0'±FIRST FLOOR FFE: 455.0'±
SEPTIC FIELDS
(P) 1ST FLOOR SETBACK
46'-3 3/4"
(P) SB 9 SETBACK
32'-0"
(P) SB 9 ETBACK
152'-11 1/4"
(P) 1ST FLOOR SETBACK
95'-5"
(P) ADU SETBACK
51'-3"
(P) ADU SETBACK
136'-3 3/4"
(P) ADU SETBACK
55'-5"
PATIO
100' EDGE OF FAULT SETBACK
10 0' E
D
G
E
O
F
F
A
U
L
T
S
E
T
B
AC
K
REQ. SETBACK
30'-0"
REQ. SETBACK
40'-0"
REQ. SETBACK
30'-0"
REQ. SETBACK
30'-0"
BUILDING SETBACK BUILDING SETBACK
BUILDING
SETBACK
BUILDING SETBACK
BUILDING SETBACK
EASTERLY
SETBACK
OF
FAU
LT
LIN
E
PER
G
EOLOGIC
MAP
EASTERLY
EDGE
O
F
FAU
LT
LIN
E
PER
G
EOLOGIC
MAP
WESTERLY
EDG
E
OF
FAU
LT
PER
GEOLOGIC
MAP
5' WIDE P.U.E. 5' WIDE P.U.E.
5' WIDE P.U.E.
5' WIDE P.U.E.
5' WIDE
P.U.E. 5' WIDE
P.U.E.
40' STEEP SLOPE SETBACK
SLOPE EASEMENT
4' WIDE DG
PATHWAY
TO ADU
20'-0"
10'-0" 10'-0" 20'-0"
NEAREST FIRE
HYDRANT
RETENTION
SYSTEM 20'-0"
10'-0" 10'-0" 20'-0"
SB 9 PARKING MAINHOUSE PARKING# 2
ADU PARKING
FOR REFERENCE ONLY
(SEPARATE PERMIT)
ADU FFE (LOWER FL): 444.0'±ADU FFE (UPPER FL) : 455.0'±
FOR REFERENCE ONLY
(SEPARATE PERMIT)
SB 9 FFE: 444.0'±
GREEN
HOUSE CHICKEN
COOPS
STRG
10'-0" 20'-0"
MAINHOUSE PARKING# 3
LA BARRANCA WAY
(60' - R/W)
35'-10 1/4"
13'-10"
28'-0"
LAWN
20'-0"
10'-0"
MAINHOUSE PARKING# 4
MAINHOUSE PARKING# 1
LIMITS OF
OPEN
SPACE
EASEMENT
LIMITS OF OPEN SPACE EASEMENT
M DESIGNS ARCHITECTS
384 CASTRO STREET
MOUNTAIN VIEW, CA 94041www.mdesignsarchitects.com
Email: [email protected]
Phone: 650-565-9036
Fax: 949-625-7869
1 2026-07-08 11:22:44 PM SCALE: 1/16" = 1'-0" A1.02
(P) SITE PLAN
2025.10.20
VANGALA RESIDENCE
0 LA BARRANCA RD,
LOS ALTOS HILLS, CA
94022
PLANNING PACKAGE
(P) SITE PLAN
0 8 16 32 64
LAND USE:
AGRICULTURAL AREA: 26941.70 SF (59.6%)
NET LOT AREA: 45200.47 SF (100.0%)NOTE:TREES PROPOSED FOR REMOVAL WITH A TRUNK DIAMETER OF 12 INCHES OR GREATER ARE SHOWN ON THE SITE PLAN. TREES WITH TRUNK DIAMETERS LESS THAN 12 INCHES ARE NON-HERITAGE TREES
AND MAY BE RETAINED OR REMOVED DURING CONSTRUCTION, AS
DETERMINED BY THE PROJECT ARBORIST, IN COMPLIANCE WITH
APPLICABLE CITY REGULATIONS.
B
B
B
B
B
B
Description Date
PLANNING REVIEW 2025.10.20PLANNINGRESUBMITTAL
2026.02.25
PLANNINGRESUBMITTAL
2026.07.08
C
C
C
C
Farming Operation & Business Plan at APN 182-05-034
La Barranca Rd, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
We are the owners of the above open-land property, currently operating a small farming business Scripps Farms (https://www.scrippsfarms.com). Our plan is to expand and establish a sustainable farm after moving to the above location. As the following details will show, this plan includes growing vegetable and specialty potted plants in approximately 14,379 sq. ft. as well as producing organic eggs in about 5,129 sq. ft. area.
The uniqueness of our farming plan arises from the motivation to support healthy living of the communities near and far by offering ready-to-grow-in-your-backyard potted plants and high-quality eggs. We strongly believe in the saying “we are what we eat” and our plan offers ultimate freedom to the working families in several things: choice, freshness, taste, quality, happiness and finally satisfaction of growing their own food – worry free.
Potted Plants Operation
We will grow both vegetable plants and specialty potted plants using organic seeds sourced from the highly trusted vendors across the nation (Kitazawa Seed Company and Eden Brothers). All the plants will be started in a greenhouse in propagation module trays through manual or automated seeding for germination in early December and then transplanted into gallon sized pots in open but fenced areas of the farm in early March. These potted plants will be ready for sale from mid-April. Typical vegetable plants include peppers, tomatoes and spinach. Specialty plants include curry leaf, neem, moringa and Arabian jasmine. Plants will be sold through our existing website (https://www.scrippsfarms.com), social media outreach, local events and pop-up stands. Our experience has been that the growth of this business is through word-of-mouth referrals. In 2021 (at peak COVID), our small business was able to generate sales of $831.00.
Chicken Egg Operation
We plan to raise approximately 100 chickens in mobile, wheeled coops (each ~10 x 18 sq. ft.) equipped with feeders and nest boxes. One week old chicks will be procured with special focus on egg layers that are less noisy, good egg producing and long lifespan. Our experience with Hoover Hatchery’s black sex-link hens met all these requirements. The chickens will be fed all-organic multi-grain feed in addition to the natural ground foraging. We expect a typical output of approximately 500 eggs per week and will be sold alongside the potted plants as well as in the local grocery stores through arrangement. These eggs will be marketed as a healthy, organic, high-protein choice for families.
nn
Naveen Vangala &
Shalini Tokala
Los Altos Hills, 07/07/2025
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
1 Law Offices of
Michael Patrick Durkee
1250- I Newell Avenue, Suite 156
Walnut Creek CA 94596
(510) 918-5873
[email protected]
Honorable Mayor, Vice Mayor,
and City Council
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Re: La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala, APN 182-05-034 (File Nos.
SD25-0072, VAR25-0016) – Request for Approval of Project Dear Honorable Mayor, Vice Mayor, and Town Council:
I hope you are well. This office represents Naveen Vangala and Shalini Tokala regarding their proposal, including open space uses, new agricultural uses, and residential uses, on their approximately 1.16-acre property located on La Barranca Road (“Property”). Thank you for this opportunity to present the factual and legal reasons why we respectfully submit that, under controlling law, my clients’ proposal must be approved.
A. DISCUSSION.
1. Generally.
My clients have made substantial changes to the design of their home, agriculture plan, and open space uses – at considerable time and financial expense – in direct response to the requests of the neighbors and the Planning Commission. They have done this out of respect for the Town, its residents, and their desire to act in a manner consistent with the history and practice of the community. Their proposed Home does not “upset the apple cart,” but instead conforms to the longstanding “homes in the country” policies and practices of the Town.
As discussed at length below, my clients’ proposal is consistent with the Williamson Act, the City Resolution No. 616, all Town Planning and Zoning laws, and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract (and its list of “Compatible Uses”), and does not create impacts that would compromise the agricultural or open space uses on the Property or neighboring properties. A substantial part of the Property will be put into permanent open space easement or open space restriction, and new agricultural uses.
We respectfully submit that despite all of this, my clients have been subjected to remarkably unfair treatment by the neighbors and by the Town Planning Commission. In fact, notwithstanding overwhelming evidence that my clients will pay the full market-rate property tax upon approval of their proposed Home - like everyone else - there remains a prevailing distrust that my clients are “pulling a fast one,” and that their Williamson Contract allows them to pay “reduced property taxes,” while everyone else is paying much more. Again, that is incorrect. Ironically, my clients only pay the reduced Williamson Act Tax Rate while the Property stays vacant.
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
2 Additionally, there is a widely held belief that the “lower” purchase price of this Property was a direct product of the Williamson Act Contract. Again, that is also not true. Instead, the purchase price of the Property reflected the challenging topography of the site, the presence of multiple fault zones, and the uncertainty of septic system feasibility, all of which kept the Property for sale on the market for years.
My clients’ proposal is similar to other Williamson Act properties with similar Williamson Act contracts in Los Altos Hills that have received Town approval for a home - the law demands the same equal protection and fair treatment of my clients.
My clients legally cannot be made to pay an added “cancellation fee” tax - beyond the reevaluation of their Property and Home to full market rate tax value - simply to appease the “politics” of the moment.
Requiring cancellation in trade for approval would be punitive, unfair, and unlawful.
We respectfully submit that the Planning Commission’s decision that my clients’ proposal is incompatible with the Williamson Act is without evidentiary support, is factually and legally flawed, and is more likely the product of neighborhood pressure/bullying than sound reasoning.
Simply put, as set forth in detail below, there are no factual or legal grounds supporting denial of my clients’ proposal. Controlling law - and the only substantial evidence in the record - demand the Town’s findings of Williamson Act compatibility, General Plan and Zoning consistency, and the approval of the Home.
The neighbors do not appear to “shy” from threatening suit against the Town if it approves my clients’ proposal. Good on them. We will defend any such suit. But please understand that my clients will seek judicial intervention if the Town ignores the facts and law in this case - in favor of popular sentiment - and denies my clients’ proposal. I doubt the neighbors will defend the Town from our lawsuit.
2. My Clients‘ Proposal is Compatible with the Williamson Act, and Consistent with the Town General Plan and R-A Zoning, as Required.
The Williamson Act sets forth a statutory framework that incentivizes the preservation of agricultural, open space, and recreational lands through “contracts” entered between the city or county and the landowner that exchange such preservation for a lower property tax rate.
As discussed herein, the Williamson Act provides statutory guidance, but relies on implementation through locally adopted policies and Williamson Act Contracts that must be consistent with the local Planning and Zoning exercises of the Town.
In the instant case, while the Town of Los Altos Hills never adopted local Williamson Act “Policy Guidelines” through City Ordinance, it did adopt City Resolution No. 616 addressing the Town’s Williamson Act preserves and contracts.
Contrary to the arguments posed by the neighbors and their attorney, Christopher L. Powell, Esq. - discussed below - consistency with applicable local Planning and Zoning laws is a Williamson Act requirement and not one that renders the Williamson Act contract at issue violative of the “enforceable restriction” requirements of California Constitution, Article XIII, section 8. (Discussed further below.)
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
3 Sections 8, 9, and 10 of City Resolution No. 616 expressly allow agricultural, open space, and compatible uses, and speak to the role of the General Plan and Zoning in the context of the Town’s Williamson Act contracts:
8. Criteria for Agricultural and Open Space Reserves.
. . . . consistent with the General Plan of the Town or any Element thereof. The property to be included in a preserve may be located in any zoning district shall be in agricultural use or suitable for agricultural or open space use or compatible uses.
9. Compatible Uses. Uses which are considered to be “compatible uses” (as said term is defined and used in the [Williamson] Act) include permitted uses in any zoning district as set forth in Ordinance No. 78, the Zoning Ordinance of the Town of Los Altos Hills, as amended, and which are designated in contracts entered into pursuant to the [Williamson] Act.
10. Zoning Requirements. Land within an agricultural or open space preserve shall be devoted to agricultural, open space, and compatible uses as defined by the Act, and as designated by the City Council. The authorization for such uses as contained herein, and contracts entered hereunder, shall not be deemed to modify or take the place of any restrictions imposed upon the land, or any portion thereof, within the preserve by any zoning requirements. In no event may the uses permitted by contract be less restrictive than existing zoning requirements; provided, however, that restrictions imposed by contracts may be more restrictive than zoning requirements.
City Resolution No. 616, Sections 8, 9, and 10, emphasis added.
This is what you adopted. This is your foundation. This is your bedrock. Please understand your Resolution No. 616, and your 1972 Williamson Act contract, before you decide what is and what is not compatible.
As discussed herein, and as contemplated by City Resolution No. 616 and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract at issue in this case, my clients’ proposal is consistent with the “Residential” designation in the Town’s General Plan Land Use Element and the “Residential Agricultural” (R-A) Zone, which R-A Zone not only allows the agriculture and open spaces uses proposed by my clients, but also allows the dwellings (the Home and secondary dwelling uses).
These local Planning and Zoning laws are critically important, not only because they bind the bulk of Los Altos Hills and preserve its unique, mainly low-density, single-family residential development comprising at least one acre in size, but also, as the City’s Resolution No. 616 makes clear, consistency with the Town’s Planning and Zoning authority and resulting regulations are critical to determining “compatibility” with the Williamson Act and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract.
The following discussion illuminates what those Town Planning and Zoning regulations and resulting Williamson Act requirements actually provide, and how they work together.
Before that discussion takes place, it is important to remember that - provided substantial evidence supports their decision - the Town alone determines both General Plan/Zoning consistency and Williamson Act compatibility, and the courts, employing judicial deference, look first to the Town’s interpretation of its own laws and contracts before looking elsewhere. (See, e.g., San Francisco Tomorrow v. City and County
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
4 of San Francisco (2014) 229 Cal. App. 4th 498.) Likewise, as echoed by the California Department of Conservation, the State department with jurisdiction over the Williamson Act, (paraphrasing): “from a policy perspective, the Town alone determines Williamson Act compatibility.” The 1972 Williamson Act Contract is a contract - like any other form of enforceable contract – and will be interpreted by the courts in the manner that courts review contracts (see, e.g., County of Marin v.
Assessments Appeals Bd., 64 Cal. App. 3d 325-326 (1976)) - the Town cannot unilaterally choose to deviate from its express terms or plain meaning without the consent of my clients. The record is full of substantial evidence supporting the fact that my clients’ proposal - with its agricultural uses, open space uses, residential uses, inclusion on the “Compatible Uses” list appended to the 1972 Williamson Act Contract, and absence of impacts that would compromise the agricultural or open space purposes on the Property or on neighboring properties, leads to only one conclusion: my clients’ proposal is compatible with the Williamson Act and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract and therefore must be enforced under basic legal concepts relating to “contracts.”
The 1972 Williamson Act Contract is part of a larger “agricultural preserve” in the Town. Section 2 of that 1972 Contract lists the compatible uses allowed on the Property (set forth in Exhibit A), and expressly recognizes the concept that the allowed Compatible Uses are part of the Town’s Planning and Zoning authority:
2. RESTRICTIONS ON USE OF PROPERTY
During the term of this contract . . . the property described in Exhibit B shall not be used by Owner, or Owner’s successors in interest, for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto. A list of such compatible uses is set forth in Exhibit A, attached hereto and by this reference incorporated herein. Town, by Ordinance adopted by the City Council of the Town, may . . . add to the list of compatible uses which shall be uniform throughout the agricultural preserve in which the property in Exhibit B is located; provided, however, Town may not during the term of this contract . . . without the prior written consent of Owner, remove any of the compatible uses for the subject property which are set forth in Exhibit A. The provisions of this contract and any Ordinance supplementing the list of compatible uses are not intended to limit or supersede the planning and zoning powers of Town.
Contract, Section 2, page 2, emphasis added.
In other words, the 1972 Williamson Act Contract is intended to be consistent with the Planning and Zoning authority of the Town. And, as discussed herein, that Town authority has consistently included primary and secondary residential uses on the list of “Compatible Uses” allowed by the many Williamson Act contracts the Town has executed over the years.
In this vein, the Town’s Land Use Element reflects the original ideas behind Los Altos Hills incorporating and becoming its own governing political body, including the following:
From the Green Sheets – 1956
What Kind of Community Do We Want?
. . . a wide and not over-populated community of homes in the country. . . . . . the space and right to keep animals—rabbits, chickens, dogs, sheep, cattle and horses. . . with . . . roads that are content to remain country lanes as long as
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
5 they are suitable for the residential traffic of our area. . . . . . at least one acre of land. . .
Land Use Element, Los Altos Hills General Plan, Page LU-2, emphasis added.
Similarly, the Town’s current Land Use Element provides for such uses, including my clients’ proposed uses:
GOAL 1
Maintain the semi-rural character of the community while providing for residential uses, open space, and the minimum public and private facilities and services needed to serve residents on a continuing basis.
Land Use Element, Los Altos Hills General Plan, Page LU-4, emphasis added.
In turn, this General Plan mandate of semi-rural residential uses led directly to the Property being zoned “Residential Agricultural” (R-A), which R-A Zone not only allows the agriculture and open spaces uses proposed by my clients, but also allows the primary and secondary dwelling uses.
In other words, when one understands the driving commitment of the Town since its 1950’s incorporation to “Maintain the semi-rural character of the community while providing for residential uses, open space, and the minimum public and private facilities and services needed to serve residents on a continuing basis” (Land Use Element, Los Altos Hills General Plan, Page LU-4, emphasis added), then one likewise understands the R-A Zoning, and the resultant 1972 Williamson Act Contract and its Exhibit A list of “Compatible Uses”:
1. Agriculture, including but not limited to horticulture and grazing
2. Forest preserves
3. Open space uses
4. Primary dwellings
5. Secondary dwellings
6. Churches
7. Recreational facilities
8. Nurseries
9. Private schools
10. Public utility and service uses
11. Private and commercial stables
1972 Contract, Exhibit A, page 1.
Bluntly put, the 1972 Contract expressly allows “Agriculture” and “Open Space” uses - right next to “Primary dwellings” and “Secondary dwellings” uses - right next to “Churches” and “Recreational facilities” uses - and right next to “Public utility and service uses.” They are all compatible uses under the 1972 Contract that my clients have a contractual right to: Their proposed open space, agricultural, and residential uses are all compatible with the Williamson Act, City Resolution No. 616, the 1972 Williamson Act Contract, and its list of “Compatible Uses,” and do not create impacts that would compromise the agricultural or open space purposes of the Contract on their Property or neighboring properties. As such, the Town cannot legally ignore them, or interpret them in a fashion to deny my clients’ proposal.
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
6 The neighbors disagree. Their attorney, Christopher L. Powell, Esq., has submitted two letters as of the date of this letter: the first letter from Christopher L. Powell, dated September 30, 2026 is referred to herein as the “September Powell Letter,” and the second letter from Christopher L. Powell, Esq., dated November 5, 2026 is referred to herein as the “November Powell Letter.” In both Letters, Attorney Powell explains what he believes the Williamson Act does and does not allow, what it specifically requires, and what the Department of Conservation has and has not said to City Staff. With respect to Mr. Powell and his clients, and as explained herein, the record is simply devoid of any substantial evidence that the Property, and my clients’ proposed uses of open space, agricultural, and residential uses are inconsistent with the Town of Los Altos Hills’ General Plan and Zoning, or are incompatible with the Williamson Act, The City Resolution No. 616, or the actual 1972 Williamson Act Contract.
We appreciate that Mr. Powell has conceded his original assertion in the September Powell Letter that Government Code section 51238.1(a) (of the Williamson Act) and its principles of compatibility apply in this case. Nonetheless, while we disagree with Mr. Powell’s draconian (extremely repressive) reading of those statutory provisions (“mandatory provisions” “statutory floor”) - given the remaining text of both Section 51238.1 and the Williamson Act as a whole - and his application of those statutory provisions to the facts and law of this case, we have no problem applying Government Code section 51238.1(a) to my clients’ proposal because we satisfy all of its provisions.
The following provides the actual text of Government Code section 51238.1, with our responses set forth in italicized text:
51238.1. (a) Uses approved on contracted lands shall be consistent with all of the following principles of compatibility:
(1) The use will not significantly compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves. My clients are adding agricultural uses for the first time to the Property, are preserving over 70% of the Property in open space and agricultural uses, specifically allowed by the 1972 Williamson Act Contract, and are therefore not compromising the long-term productive agricultural capability of their Property or surrounding properties.
(2) The use will not significantly displace or impair current or reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or parcels or on other contracted lands in agricultural preserves. Uses that significantly displace agricultural operations on the subject contracted parcel or parcels may be deemed compatible if they relate directly to the production of commercial agricultural products on the subject contracted parcel or parcels or neighboring lands, including activities such as harvesting, processing, or shipping. Again, my clients are ADDING commercial agricultural uses for the first time to the Property. As such, they are not displacing or impairing current or reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations on their Property or surrounding properties, and their uses “relate directly to the production of commercial agricultural products on the subject contracted parcel.”
(3) The use will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use. There are no adjacent contracted lands; the neighboring properties are all developed. My clients’ proposed uses, all of which are allowed by their 1972 Williamson Act Contracts list of compatible uses, will
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
7 not result in the “removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use.” In evaluating compatibility, a board or council shall consider the impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve or preserves. Again, there are no adjacent contracted lands; the neighboring properties are all developed. My clients’ proposed uses, all of which are allowed by their 1972 Williamson Act Contracts list of compatible uses, will not result in “impacts on noncontracted lands in the agricultural preserve or preserves.”
(b) A board or council may include in its compatible use rules or ordinance conditional uses which, without conditions or mitigations, would not be in compliance with this section. These conditional uses shall conform to the principles of compatibility set forth in subdivision (a) or, for nonprime lands only, satisfy the requirements of subdivision (c). While this provision does not technically apply to my clients’ situation, this provision reveals, as do the provisions below, that the “hard lines” of compatibility argued by Mr. Powell do not in fact exist within Section 51238.1.
(c) In applying the criteria pursuant to subdivision (a), the board or council may approve a use on nonprime land which, because of onsite or offsite impacts, would not be in compliance with paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a), provided the use is approved pursuant to a conditional use permit that shall set forth findings, based on substantial evidence in the record, demonstrating the following: While this provision does not technically apply to my clients’ situation, this provision is another example of why the “hard lines” of compatibility argued by Mr. Powell do not in fact exist within Section 51238.1.
(1) Conditions have been required for, or incorporated into, the use that mitigate or avoid those onsite and offsite impacts so as to make the use consistent with the principles set forth in paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) to the greatest extent possible while maintaining the purpose of the use. As stated above, while these provisions do not technically apply to my clients’ proposal, my clients are adding agricultural uses for the first time to the Property, are preserving over 70% of the Property in open space and commercial agricultural uses, specifically allowed by the 1972 Williamson Act Contract, and are therefore consistent with the requirements of this section because they are not compromising the long-term productive agricultural capability of their Property or surrounding properties. (2) The productive capability of the subject land has been considered as well as the extent to which the use may displace or impair agricultural operations. As stated above, while these provisions do not technically apply to my clients’ proposal, my clients are ADDING agricultural uses for the first time to the Property. As such, “The productive capability of the subject land has been considered as well as the extent to which the use may displace or impair agricultural operations” as their proposed uses are not displacing or impairing agricultural operations, but are in fact enhancing them.
(3) The use is consistent with the purposes of this chapter to preserve agricultural and open-space land or supports the continuation of agricultural uses, as defined in
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
8 Section 51205, or the use or conservation of natural resources, on the subject parcel or on other parcels in the agricultural preserve. The use of mineral resources shall comply with Section 51238.2. My clients’ proposal preserves open space uses and in fact brings commercial agricultural uses, for the first time, to the Property. (4) The use does not include a residential subdivision. No residential subdivision is proposed.
For the purposes of this section, a board or council may define nonprime land as land not defined as “prime agricultural land” pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 51201 or as land not classified as “agricultural land” pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21060.1 of the Public Resources Code. The Property is not “prime agricultural land.”
Nothing in this section shall be construed to overrule, rescind, or modify the requirements contained in Sections 51230 and 51238 related to noncontracted lands within agricultural preserves. This does not apply as my clients’ Property is contracted land.
Gov’t Code § 51238.1, emphasis of statutory text added through bold text.
In short, were the modern Willaimson Act and its modern Government Code section 51238.1(a) to apply to my clients’ 1972 Contract - as originally asserted by Mr. Powell and then later conceded - my clients’ proposal would nonetheless satisfy all of that Section’s “compatibly principles.” Again, Mr. Powell and the neighbors disagree. In the September Powell Letter, Mr. Powell argues that the presence of the Home in comparison to the agricultural and open space uses proposed on the Property unlawfully makes the Home the “primary use” and therefore incompatible; that the grading of the “oversized driveway requiring a variance” (oversized given both the steep nature of the Property and the fire-safety demands regarding the “mouth” of the driveway) somehow makes my clients’ proposal incompatible; that the NEW agricultural uses are not what he considers to be adequate “agriculture” (what he refers to as “a chicken coop and potted-plant shed”) and therefore are incompatible; and that “the permanent removal of a large share of the parcel’s vegetation and of significant trees” underscores that incompatibility. (September Powell Letter, p. 3.)
For the reasons set forth below, we submit that Mr. Powell in the September Powell Letter is mistaken on the facts and the law.
In the November Powell Letter, Mr. Powell provides similar arguments:
The Williamson Act was enacted to preserve agricultural and open-space land by restricting its use in exchange for reduced assessment. (Gov. Code, § 51220.) Land under contract “shall not be used for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto.” (Contract, ¶ 2; accord Gov. Code, § 51243.) A “compatible use” is defined as a use “determined by the county or city administering the preserve … to be compatible with the agricultural, recreational, or open-space use” of the land, and one that satisfies the statutory principles of compatibility. (Gov. Code, § 51201, subd. (e).) The statutory scheme thus contemplates that the agricultural or open-space use remains primary, and that any compatible use is subordinate and incidental to it.
A use that displaces agriculture as the principal use of the land is not “compatible,”
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
9 it is a conversion.
November Powell Letter at 3, bolded text added.
Likewise, Mr. Powell cites Section 2 of the 1972 Williamson Act Contract as supportive of his interpretation that:
. . . a compatible use must be “compatible thereto,” that is, compatible with and subordinate to “the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes.” (Contract, ¶ 2.) A development that reduces agriculture to a token chicken coop is not “compatible thereto”; it supplants the agricultural use rather than coexisting with it.
November Powell Letter at 3, bolded text added.
And after conceding that the City Attorney is correct and that the “principles of compatibility” provisions of Government Code section 51238.1(a) (which we nonetheless comply with) do not apply to the 1972 Williamson Act Contract (what he characterizes as a “narrow point”), he doubles-down on his arguments that:
. . . so even a grandfathered dwelling must remain subordinate to, and coexist with, the commercial agricultural use rather than supplant it.
November Powell Letter at 4, bolded text added.
Mr. Powell then sets forth a California Constitution-based argument that he proposes supports his continued supposition that all compatible uses set forth in the 1972 Williamson Act Contract must be “subordinate” to the agricultural uses and - now open space uses - he cites must be the dominant use (citing California Constitution, Article XIII, section 8) or the 1972 Contract is, in his words, not an “enforceable restriction” (November Powell Letter at 5). Mr. Powell argues that allowing residential development no more limited than the applicable zoning is tantamount to the 1972 Williamson Act Contract at issue here losing its “enforceable restriction” status. (Id., bolded text added.) The following responds to both the September Powell Letter and the November Powell Letter. Again, we respectfully submit that Attorney Powell is mistaken on the facts and the law.
First, Section 2 of the 1972 does NOT subordinate the compatible uses. There are no words “subordinate to” in Section 2 or in its Exhibit A. Mr. Powell has added words to a Contract that neither he nor the Town has the legal power to amend. There are simply no words of “subordination” among the “compatible uses” required by Section 2 of the 1972 Williamson Act Contract and listed in its Exhibit A.
Second, over 50 years of history underscore that the Property has not had ANY agricultural use since the execution of the 1972 Williamson Act Contract – it has always been open space. My clients are adding agricultural uses for the first time to the Property which, as described below, and despite Mr. Powell’s derivative comments to the contrary, qualify as “agricultural uses.” Third, residential use is not the primary use in my clients’ proposal - it is an expressly allowed “compatible use,” which is compatible with and complimentary to the agriculture and open space uses that actually dominate the Property: over 70% of the Property are in agricultural and open space uses. But even if it was, for the sake of argument only, the primary use, it does not mean it is incompatible. The Department of Conservation (the department with jurisdiction over the Williamson Act) has clearly stated that
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
10 agricultural use is not required to be the “primary” land use in every Williamson Act contract; other qualifying land uses may serve as the primary use depending on the specific Williamson Act contract and applicable local rules.
Again, the Town of Los Altos’ local rules are those set forth in City Resolution No. 616, the General Plan, the R-A, Zoning, and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract - all of which embrace the uses in my clients’ proposal, and none of which require agriculture to be the “primary use.” The 1972 Contract expressly provides a list of compatible uses that include agricultural, open space, primary dwelling, and secondary dwelling uses. And as shown herein, all of the uses proposed by my clients meet the principles of compatibility provisions set forth in Government Code section 51238.1 and Section 2 of the 1972 Willaimson Act Contract’s provisions regarding compatible uses. The fact that the applicable Planning and Zoning regulations include the compatible uses set forth in the 1972 Williamson Act Contract do not render the 1972 Contract an “unenforceable restriction” as opined by Mr. Powell. Mr. Powell argues that allowing residential development no more limited than the applicable zoning is tantamount to the 1972 Williamson Act Contract at issue here losing its “enforceable restriction” status. Mr. Powell is incorrect.
The Williamson Act, Resolution No. 616, and the 1972 Williamson Act Contract speak to compatibility between the Town’s Planning and Zoning practices and its Williamson Act contract practices. Each such Town Williamson Act contract is nonetheless an “enforceable restriction.” Fourth, not cited by Mr. Powell, is Government Code section 51201(b), which provides that “agricultural use” includes greenhouses. (Id.)
Fifth, Mr. Powell’s and the neighbors’ strict interpretation of “agriculture- only” or “agricultural-primary” is simply not supported by the actual text of the Williamson Act or its interpretation by the California Department of Conservation. For example, Government Code section 51205 makes clear that: “Notwithstanding any provision of this chapter [Williamson Act] to the contrary,” land devoted to recreational use, wildlife habitat, salt ponds, managed wetland areas, and even “submerged areas” may be included in an agricultural preserve, and the Town may contract with the owner for the purpose of restricting the land to recreational or open space use and uses compatible therewith “in the same manner as provided in this chapter for land devoted to agricultural use.” (Id., emphasis added.) In other words, “agricultural use” does NOT just mean “ONLY agriculture use” under the Williamson Act. Id. It includes other non-agricultural uses as well. (Id.)
Sixth, the removal of vegetation and trees is simply not a relevant topic under the Williamson Act, nor is the need for a driveway variance. Emotionally compelling, perhaps; just not relevant to Williamson Act compatibility.
Seventh, Mr. Powell argues that “agricultural use” must be the dominant use of the Property under the 1972 Contract. But without my clients’ proposal, no agricultural use will ever occur on the Property. A 54-year-old Contract, and to date, no agricultural use has ever taken place. If agricultural use is required, according to Mr. Powell, and none has ever taken place, is Mr. Powell therefore saying that the 1972 Contract is not an enforceable restriction and is therefore void? With no Contract, there is no compatibility issue to tackle. Shall we go with that?
Eighth, with respect, Mr. Powell is an advocate for his clients, the neighbors. As such, he is going to advocate for their desire: the denial of my clients’ proposal. That is what he was hired to do. But just because he says it with passion and a clever pen does not make it so.
In my opinion, instead of presenting relevant facts and law, we have emotion and distraction and quite
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
11 honestly there is some significant animosity and bullying on the part of the neighbors.
In short, the only substantial evidence in the record supports approval of my clients’ proposal – the uses proposed bring agricultural uses for the first time to the Property, continue the dominant open space character of the Property, and propose dwellings compatible with the Williamson Act, compatible with the City’s Resolution No. 616, compatible with the 1972 Williamson Act Contract to which the Town is contractually bound, and consistent with the Town’s General Plan and R-A Zoning. There is no evidence in the record to support its denial. There is only substantial evidence supporting its approval. As such, the approval of my clients’ proposal must be granted as a matter of law.
Neighborhood pressure and animosity are not a legal reason to deny my clients’ proposal, and the “arguments and opinions” that the neighbors have offered do not constitute substantial evidence nor sustainable proof in support of a denial of my clients’ proposal.
3. Fair and Equal Treatment and Contractual Protection Are Owed.
The Town’s exercise of its Planning and Zoning authority has previously led to other lands within the agricultural preserve and subject to a Williamson Act contract being approved for housing. (See, e.g., 24005 Oak Knoll Circle, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022.)
Because the law requires fair and equal treatment, because the law protects the contractual rights of my clients, because my clients’ 1972 Williamson Act Contract expressly requires consistent practices within the agricultural preserve, because my clients’ 1972 Williamson Act Contract expressly allows “primary dwellings” and “secondary dwellings” as compatible uses with “agriculture” and “open space,” and because the 1972 Contract expressly prohibits the Town from removing any of those compatible uses without owner consent, then the Town legally cannot deny the Home on compatibility grounds or subject it to a treatment/process different than, or unequal to, the approval process that the Town has provided in the past for other similarly situated properties under Williamson Act contract. Doing so would violate my clients’ equal protection and contractual rights.
Additionally, my clients legally cannot be forced to “cancel” their 1972 Contract or made to pay an added “cancellation fee” tax - beyond the reevaluation of their Property and Home to full market rate tax value that the Tax Assessor will enforce - simply to appease the “politics” of the moment. Requiring cancellation in trade for approval would be punitive, unfair, and unlawful.
In short, the Town’s action on the proposed Home in this case must be consistent with the Town’s prior actions on similarly contracted properties (within the preserve) in order to satisfy the requirements of fair and equal treatment, the contractual protections of the 1972 Williamson Act Contract, and the rules regarding cancellation.
4. My Clients Will Owe Full Market Rate Property Tax Upon Home Approval.
Despite a prevailing neighborhood belief that my clients are “pulling a fast one,” and that their Williamson Contract allows them to pay “reduced property taxes,” while everyone else is paying much more, my clients will actually pay the full market-rate property tax upon approval of their proposed Home. As the Santa Clara County Assessor has confirmed, once the Home is approved by the Town, the property tax owing will move from a Williamson Act-protected low tax to a full market rate property tax (as if the Williamson Act were no longer present).
The irony of this controversy is that the community is deprived of the full market-rate tax if the Property
Mayor, Vice Mayor, Town Council ITEM 7C, Supplement 1
La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala
November11, 2026
12 stays vacant, as the neighbors request, while it only receives the full, unrestricted market value when my clients’ proposed uses are approved.
B. CONCLUSION.
In sum, for the factual and legal reasons provided in this letter, we respectfully submit that my clients’ proposal must be approved. Neighborhood pressure is not a legal reason to deny.
Thank you for this opportunity to comment on behalf of Naveen Vangala and Shalini Tokala. Please ensure that this letter is made a part of the administrative record on this matter.
Respectfully submitted,
Michael Patrick Durkee, Esq.
Cc: City Attorney
City Clerk
City Staff
Michael J. Betz, Esq.
Naveen Vangala and Shalini Tokala
ITEM 7C, Supplement 2
Arika Miller
From: Bridget Morgan
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 11:29 PM
To: Arika Miller
Cc: Cheryl Evans; Indu Kadambi
Subject: Please post
External
Graymail Spam Phish More... FAQ Protection by INKY
Dear Los Altos Hills Elected Representatives,
I am concerned and thinking that our town has lost sight of its roots.
If nothing else, the Williamson Act debate as to the properties governed by it, sends a chill up my spine.
I encourage you five to echo your Planning Commission.
Best,
Bridget Morgan
1
TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
CITY COUNCIL SLIP SHEET
Regular Meeting of November 12, 2026
ITEM 7D: CONTINUED TO DECEMBER 14, 2026
SUBJECT: Waive first reading and introduce an ordinance establishing an administrative variance review process for electrical transformers and related electrical equipment located within required setbacks.
NOTICE: Staff is recommending that the City Council open the public hearing, take public comment, and continue the public hearing to the December 14, 2026 City Council meeting due to agenda timelines and clarity. No action will be taken on this item at the November 12, 2026 meeting.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION:
The proposed ordinance would add Section 10-2.302.1 to the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code and make related amendments so that variance requests for qualifying electrical equipment encroaching into required setbacks can be reviewed administratively through the Town’s publicly noticed Fast Track process, rather than by the Planning Commission. Eligible equipment includes transformers, utility equipment, electrical service panels, meters, disconnects, and substantially similar electrical infrastructure.
The ordinance does not change the Town’s underlying setback requirements. A variance would still be required, and all variance findings would still need to be made. To qualify, an application would have to meet all the following criteria:
• The location is required or substantially constrained by utility, code, or site conditions. • No feasible alternative location exists outside the setback. • The encroachment is the minimum necessary.
• The equipment is screened to the maximum extent practicable. • The installation creates no significant adverse impacts.
Applications that don’t meet every criterion would remain subject to standard Planning Commission variance review. The ordinance includes a sunset date of October 1, 2029. The Planning Commission reviewed the ordinance on August 6 and September 3, 2026, and recommended its adoption.
ITEM 7D
TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS November 12, 2026
Staff Report to the City Council
SUBJECT: RESOLUTION AWARDING A JANITORIAL SERVICES AGREEMENT TO
SIGNIFICANT CLEANING SERVICES IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $194,937 FOR A THREE-YEAR TERM COMMENCING JANUARY 1, 2027 FROM: WooJae Kim, PE, Public Works Director
APPROVED: Cody Einfalt, City Manager
RECOMMENDATION: That the City Council:
Adopt a resolution (Attachment 1) awarding a janitorial services agreement to Significant Cleaning Services in an amount not to exceed $194,937 for a three-year term commencing January 1, 2027.
BACKGROUND:
Based on Town records, the Town has contracted with Significant Cleaning Services for janitorial services at Town facilities since at least 2006. The original agreement provided for services on a month-to-month basis until terminated.
In 2024, the Town transitioned to annual service agreements with Significant Cleaning to formalize the contractual arrangement and establish annual pricing. The current 2026 agreement for janitorial services expires on December 31, 2026.
DISCUSSION:
Historical Janitorial Services and Expenditures
The Town's janitorial service costs have increased over time with the addition of facilities and increase in operating costs. Based on available Town financial records, the following summarizes the general expenditure history:
2009–2020: Annual janitorial expenditures increased from approximately $20,000 in 2009 to more than $36,200 in 2020. During this period, services were primarily limited to Town Hall, the Parks and Recreation Building, and Purissima Park facilities. Costs included consumable supplies such as paper products and refillable soap products. 2021: Janitorial services were expanded to include Westwind Community Barn. Additional deep-cleaning services associated with the COVID-19 pandemic also contributed to increased expenditures, bringing the annual cost to just above $50,000. 2022: Following the additional COVID-related cleaning requirements, annual expenditure returned to approximately $38,700.
2023: Once a week janitorial service was added at the Corporation Yard. In addition, service costs increased across the Town's facilities, bringing annual expenditure to approximately $54,700.
ITEM 8A
City Council Page 2
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
2024–2025: The Town entered into annual agreements with Significant Cleaning, with total expenditures being between $55,000 and $57,500 per year. 2026: Following completion of the Heritage House Upgrade project, twice-weekly janitorial services were added in October 2026. Total janitorial expenditures for 2026 are projected to be just under $60,000.
Table 1 below summarizes the annual janitorial service costs from 2024 through 2026, including the cost of consumable supplies (paper products, refillable soap products, etc.) provided and restocked by Significant Cleaning:
Table1. Janitorial Service Costs from 2024 to 2026
2024 2025 2026*
Facilities Frequence
of Service
Cost per
Month
Cost per
Year
Cost per
Month
Cost per
Year
Cost
per
Month
Cost per
Year
Town Hall 5 days per
week $1,920 $23,040 $1,950 $23,400 $2,020 $24,240
Parks & Rec
Building
2 days per
week $270 $3,240 $275 $3,300 $285 $3,420
Corporation
Yard
1 day per
week $450 $5,400 $450 $5,400 $465 $5,580
Purissima Park
Restrooms
2 days per
week $435 $5,220 $435 $5,220 $450 $5,400
Multipurpose
Room in
Purissima Park
1 day per
week $195 $2,340 $200 $2,400 $206 $2,472
Westwind
Barn
1 day per
week $430 $5,160 $430 $5,160 $445 $5,340
Heritage
House - - - - -
$250
(starting
October
2026)
$750
Subtotal $44,400 $44,880 $47,212
Consumables $9,958 $11,847 $11,900*
Carpet
Cleaning
Upon
Request
5 times
per year
$975 2 times
per year
$690 1 time $285
TOTAL $55,333 $57,417 $59,397*
*Note: 2026 costs are projected estimates.
City Council Page 3
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
Request for Proposals
Again, the 2026 annual janitorial services agreement expires on December 31, 2026. To secure competitive pricing and establish a longer-term contractual arrangement, staff issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for janitorial services at Town facilities to establish a new agreement beginning January 1, 2027. The RFP solicited proposals for an initial three-year term, with an option for the Town to extend the agreement for up to two additional years.
Establishing a multi-year agreement would provide greater cost predictability through fixed annual pricing during the initial contract term and reduce the administrative effort associated with soliciting proposals and executing agreements annually.
The general scope of work includes routine cleaning of floors and countertops, dusting, sanitizing, removing trash, and maintaining designated areas within Town facilities. The RFP also included the following supplemental services:
Carpet cleaning: Carpet cleaning at Town Hall upon request, limited to a maximum of five cleanings per year.
Window cleaning: Window cleaning once a year at Town Hall, the Parks and Recreation Building, and Heritage House.
The selected contractor is responsible for providing all labor, materials, supplies, tools, equipment, and transportation necessary to perform the required services. Cleaning schedules will be coordinated with Town Hall operations and individual facility schedules to minimize disruptions.
The RFP also established environmental requirements for cleaning products and consumable supplies. Cleaning products must be environmentally preferable where reasonably available and appropriate for their intended use. Paper products must comply with applicable State requirements, including California SB 1383 requirements for minimum postconsumer recycled content and recyclability, as applicable.
Proposal Evaluation and Selection
By the proposal submission deadline of October 26, 2026, the Town received five proposals from professional janitorial service providers.
Table 2 summarizes the proposed annual costs and supplemental service fees submitted by the five firms.
Table 2. Summary of Proposal Costs
Company Name Total per
Year
Carpet
Cleaning
Window
Cleaning Consumables Total
BERRY CLEAN $ 90,612 $1,875 $1,170 Included $ 93,657
City Council Page 4
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
IMPEC GROUP $ 50,748 $1,500 $1,210 Not included $ 53,458 KARLAS
JANITORIAL $ 63,624 $2,250 $ 610 Included $ 66,484
SIGNIFICANT
CLEANING $ 54,360 $ 1,625 $1,050 Not included $ 57,035
TRANSPACIFIC
BUILDING
MAINTENANCE
$ 63,267 $ 2,040 $455 Not included $ 65,762
Two proposers included consumable supplies in their proposed annual costs, while the remaining three excluded these items. Under the current and previous janitorial service agreements, Significant Cleaning has billed the Town separately for consumable supplies based on actual usage and facility needs.
An evaluation team consisting of Town staff reviewed and scored the proposals based on the evaluation criteria established in the RFP, which included the vendor’s experience, qualifications, and references; proposed costs; and contractor capabilities, staffing, and available resources.
Based on the evaluation, Significant Cleaning received the highest overall rating. The evaluation team's ranking of the five proposals was as follows:
1. Significant Cleaning Services LLC
2. Impec Group
3. Karlas Janitorial
4. Transpacific Building Maintenance
5. Berry Clean
Although Impec Group received the highest score in the cost category based on its lowest proposed price, Significant Cleaning received higher overall scores in the other evaluation categories, resulting in the highest overall ranking among the five proposers Significant Cleaning was established in 1987 and has 39 years of experience providing maintenance and janitorial services to public agencies and municipal utilities. The firm's proposal demonstrated substantial experience, strong references, and the operational resources necessary to meet the Town's service requirements.
In particular, Significant Cleaning offers a responsive management team to address service discrepancies, scheduling adjustments, and contract compliance matters. The company also maintains a team of on-call floating custodians to provide coverage and minimize service interruptions. For emergency situations, the company indicated that it could dispatch an emergency cleaning crew to the Town within 60 minutes, 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
City Council Page 5
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
Additionally, Significant Cleaning utilizes Green Seal-certified cleaning products, supporting the Town's efforts to use environmentally preferable cleaning materials and reduce potential impacts associated with chemical use.
With Significant Cleaning ranked highest overall by the evaluation team, staff contacted the company to negotiate pricing for consumable supplies to ensure that all anticipated annual contract expenses were incorporated into its proposal. In response, Significant Cleaning revised the fee schedule that incorporates the cost of consumable supplies into the monthly fee for each facility.
Table 3 presents the revised monthly fees, inclusive of consumable supplies, and the resulting annual not-to-exceed amount increased to $64,979.
Table 3. Significant Cleaning Proposal
Site name Cost per Month Cost per Year
Town Hall $2,480 $29,760
Parks and Recreation Building $388 $4,656
Heritage House $336 $4,032
Corporation Yard $594 $7,128
Purissima Park Restrooms $573 $6,876
Snack Shack $258 $3,096
Westwind Barn $563 $6,756
Town Hall Carpet Cleaning (up to five times) $1,625
Window Cleaning of Town Hall, Parks & Rec
Building, and Heritage House (once a year) $1,050
TOTAL $5,192 $64,979
As shown in Table 1, Significant Cleaning’s annual charges for consumable supplies between 2024 and 2026 ranged from $9,958 to around $11,900. For the proposed three-year janitorial service agreement, the annual cost for consumables will be around $8,000 based on the cost differential from the original proposal.
Compared to the 2026 janitorial services agreement, the proposed annual fee for the three-year agreement represents an approximately 9% increase. A portion of this increase is attributable to providing janitorial services at Heritage House for the full year beginning in 2027, as well as incorporating up to five annual carpet cleanings at Town Hall and annual window cleaning at Town Hall, the Parks & Recreation Building, and Heritage House into the agreement.
City Council Page 6
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
Proposed Janitorial Services Agreement
The proposed agreement with Significant Cleaning (Attachment 2) provides for an initial three-year term commencing January 1, 2027, with an option for the Town to extend the agreement for up to two additional years. The proposed annual not-to-exceed amount is $64,979, inclusive of consumable supplies. Accordingly, the total not-to-exceed amount for the initial three-year term is $194,937.
Based on the competitive procurement process and the evaluation team's assessment of the proposals, staff recommend awarding the janitorial services agreement to Significant Cleaning Services for an amount not to exceed $194,937 for the initial three-year term.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:
The proposed action is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to the applicable categorical exemption for the operation, maintenance, and minor alteration of existing public facilities (CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Class 1). The agreement provides routine janitorial and maintenance services at existing Town facilities and does not involve physical expansion or alteration of those facilities.
2026-27 CITY COUNCIL WORK PLAN:
This item is not specially identified in the 2026-27 City Council Work Plan. However, the proposed agreement supports the Town's ongoing operational needs by ensuring the continued cleanliness, maintenance, and upkeep of Town facilities.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The proposed agreement has a total not-to-exceed amount of $194,937 for the initial three-year term, equivalent to an annual not-to-exceed amount of $64,979. The annual contract costs will be allocated among the respective Town facilities and funded through the applicable budget programs, as summarized in Table 4.
Table. 4 Funding Source of Janitorial Services
Site name Cost per
Year Funding Source
Town Hall $29,760 Internal Service Fund – Town Center
Parks and Recreation Building $4,656 Internal Service Fund – Town Center Heritage House $4,032 Internal Service Fund – Town Center Corporation Yard $7,128 Internal Services Fund – Maintenance
City Council Page 7
Janitorial Services Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services November 12, 2026
Purissima Park Restrooms $6,876 General Fund – Parks
Snack Shack $3,096 General Fund- Parks
Westwind Barn $6,756 General Fund- Westwind Barn
Town Hall Carpet Cleaning (up
to five times) $1,625 Internal Service Fund – Town Center Window Cleaning of Town
Hall, Parks & Rec Bldg, and
Heritage House (once a year)
$1,050 Internal Service Fund – Town Center
TOTAL $64,979
The combined annual cost of routine janitorial services and supplemental cleaning services is $64,979, resulting in a total not-to-exceed amount of $194,937 for the initial three-year term.
The agreement also includes an option for the Town to extend the services for up to two additional years, subject to the terms and conditions of the agreement and the Town's approval.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Resolution Awarding the Janitorial Services Agreement to Significant Cleaning Services
2. Draft Agreement with Significant Cleaning Services
Report prepared by: Melissa Elian, Associate Engineer
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
AWARDING A JANITORIAL SERVICES AGREEMENT TO SIGNIFICANT CLEANING SERVICES IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $194,937 FOR A THREE-YEAR TERM COMMENCING JANUARY 1, 2027 WHEREAS, the Town of Los Altos Hills' current janitorial services agreement with Significant Cleaning Services expires on December 31, 2026; and
WHEREAS, on October 9, 2026, the Town issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for janitorial services for seven (7) Town facilities and parks; and
WHEREAS, the Town received five (5) proposals from professional janitorial services companies, and the proposals were evaluated by an evaluation team based on the criteria identified in the RFP, which included the vendor’s experience, qualifications, and references; proposed costs; and contractor capabilities, staffing, and available resources; and WHEREAS, the Town’s evaluation team determined that Significant Cleaning’s proposal best demonstrated substantial experience, positive references, and a competitive overall cost; and WHEREAS, the proposed agreement has an initial term of three (3) years, commencing January 1, 2027, with an option to extend the agreement up to two (2) additional years; and WHEREAS, the total cost for the initial three-year term is $194,937, based on an annual not-to-exceed amount of $64,979.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby awards the Janitorial Services Agreement to Significant Cleaning Services for an amount not to exceed $194,937 and authorize the City Manager to execute an agreement.
The above and foregoing Resolution was passed and adopted by the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills at a regular meeting held on the 12th day of November 2026, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
BY: _______________________________
Rajiv Bhateja, Mayor
ATTEST:
______________________________
Arika Birdsong-Miller, City Clerk
ITEM 8A, Attachment 1
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 1 of 11
CONTRACTOR SERVICES AGREEMENT BETWEEN
THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS AND
SIGNIFICANT CLEANING SERVICES, LLC
THIS AGREEMENT for janitorial services is made by and between the Town of Los Altos Hills (“Town”) and __Significant Cleaning Services, LLC_ (“Contractor”) (together referred to as the “Parties”) as of ____________, 20__ (the “Effective Date”).
Section 1. SERVICES. Subject to the terms and conditions set forth in this Agreement, Contractor shall provide to Town the services described in the Scope of Work attached as Exhibit A , and incorporated herein, at the time and place and in the manner specified therein. In the event of a conflict in or inconsistency between the terms of this Agreement and Exhibit A, the Agreement shall prevail.
1.1 Term of Services. The term of this Agreement shall begin on January 1, 2027 and shall end on December 31, 2029, with the option to extend additional two years as specified in Exhibit A. The time provided to Contractor to complete the services required by this Agreement shall not affect the Town’s right to terminate the Agreement, as referenced in Section 8.
1.2 Standard of Performance. Contractor shall perform all services required pursuant to this Agreement according to the standards observed by a competent practitioner of the profession in which Contractor is engaged.
1.3 Assignment of Personnel. Contractor shall assign only competent personnel to perform services pursuant to this Agreement. In the event that Town, in its sole discretion, at any time during the term of this Agreement, desires the reassignment of any such persons, Contractor shall, immediately upon receiving notice from Town of such desire of Town, reassign such person or persons.
1.4 Time. Contractor shall devote such time to the performance of services pursuant to this Agreement as may be reasonably necessary to meet the standard of performance provided in Section 1.1 above and to satisfy Contractor’s obligations hereunder.
Section 2. COMPENSATION. Town hereby agrees to pay Contractor a sum not to exceed $64,979 per year and not to exceed $194,937 for the term of the Agreement, notwithstanding any contrary indications that may be contained in Contractor’s proposal, for services to be performed under this Agreement. In the event of a conflict between this Agreement and Contractor’s proposal, attached as Exhibit A, regarding the amount of compensation, the Agreement shall prevail. Town shall pay Contractor for services rendered pursuant to this Agreement at the time and in the manner set forth herein. The payments specified below shall be the only payments from Town to Contractor for services rendered pursuant to this Agreement. Contractor shall submit all invoices to Town in the manner specified herein.
Except as specifically authorized by Town in writing, Contractor shall not bill Town for duplicate services performed by more than one person.
Contractor and Town acknowledge and agree that compensation paid by Town to Contractor under this Agreement is based upon Contractor’s estimated costs of providing the services required hereunder, ITEM 8A, Attachment 2
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 2 of 11 including salaries and benefits of employees and subcontractors of Contractor. Consequently, the parties further agree that compensation hereunder is intended to include the costs of contributions to any pensions and/or annuities to which Contractor and its employees, agents, and subcontractors may be eligible. Town therefore has no responsibility for such contributions beyond compensation required under this Agreement.
2.1 Invoices. Contractor shall submit invoices, not more often than once a month during the term of this Agreement, based on the cost for services performed and reimbursable costs incurred prior to the invoice date. Invoices shall contain the following information:
Invoice number and Town’s Purchase Order number for the billing; The beginning and ending dates of the billing period; and Amounts for each Scope of Work line items with a grand total for the month.
2.2 Monthly Payment. Town shall make monthly payments, based on invoices received, for services satisfactorily performed, and for authorized reimbursable costs incurred. Town shall have 30 days from the receipt of an invoice that complies with all of the requirements above to pay Contractor.
2.3 Total Payment. Town shall pay for the services to be rendered by Contractor pursuant to this Agreement. Town shall not pay any additional sum for any expense or cost whatsoever incurred by Contractor in rendering services pursuant to this Agreement.
Town shall make no payment for any extra, further, or additional service pursuant to this Agreement.
In no event shall Contractor submit any invoice for an amount in excess of the maximum amount of compensation provided above either for a task or for the entire Agreement, unless the Agreement is modified prior to the submission of such an invoice by a properly executed change order or amendment.
2.4 Payment of Taxes. Contractor is solely responsible for the payment of employment taxes incurred under this Agreement and any similar federal or state taxes.
2.5 Payment upon Termination. In the event that the Town or Contractor terminates this Agreement pursuant to Section 8, the Town shall compensate the Contractor for all outstanding costs and reimbursable expenses incurred for work satisfactorily completed as of the date of written notice of termination. Contractor shall maintain adequate logs and timesheets to verify costs incurred to that date.
2.6 Authorization to Perform Services. The Contractor is not authorized to perform any services or incur any costs whatsoever under the terms of this Agreement until receipt of authorization from the Contract Administrator.
Section 3. FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT. Except as set forth herein, Contractor shall, at its sole cost and expense, provide all facilities and equipment that may be necessary to perform the services required by this Agreement. Town shall make available to Contractor only the facilities needed for electricity and water necessary for the Scope of Work for the Town. In no event shall Town be obligated to
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 3 of 11 furnish any facility that may involve incurring any direct expense, including but not limited to computer, long-distance telephone or other communication charges, vehicles, and reproduction facilities.
Section 4. INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS. Before beginning any work under this Agreement, Contractor, at its own cost and expense, unless otherwise specified below, shall procure the types and amounts of insurance listed below against claims for injuries to persons or damages to property that may arise from or in connection with the performance of the work hereunder by the Contractor and its agents, representatives, employees, and subcontractors. Consistent with the following provisions, Contractor shall provide proof satisfactory to Town of such insurance that meets the requirements of this section and under forms of insurance satisfactory in all respects, and that such insurance is in effect prior to beginning work to the Town. Contractor shall maintain the insurance policies required by this section throughout the term of this Agreement. The cost of such insurance shall be included in the Contractor's bid. Contractor shall not allow any subcontractor to commence work on any subcontract until Contractor has obtained all insurance required herein for the subcontractor(s) and provided evidence that such insurance is in effect to Town.
Verification of the required insurance shall be submitted and made part of this Agreement prior to execution. Contractor shall maintain all required insurance listed herein for the duration of this Agreement.
4.1 Workers’ Compensation. Contractor shall, at its sole cost and expense, maintain Statutory Workers’ Compensation Insurance and Employer’s Liability Insurance for any and all persons employed directly or indirectly by Contractor. Statutory Workers’ Compensation Insurance and Employer’s Liability Insurance shall be provided with limits of not less than $1,000,000 per accident. In the alternative, Contractor may rely on a self-insurance program to meet those requirements, but only if the program of self-insurance complies fully with the provisions of the California Labor Code. Determination of whether a self-insurance program meets the standards of the Labor Code shall be solely in the discretion of the Contract Administrator. The insurer, if insurance is provided, or the Contractor, if a program of self-insurance is provided, shall waive all rights of subrogation against the Town and its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers for loss arising from work performed under this Agreement.
4.2 Commercial General and Automobile Liability Insurance.
4.2.1 General requirements. Contractor, at its own cost and expense, shall maintain commercial general and automobile liability insurance for the term of this Agreement in an amount not less than $2,000,000 per occurrence, combined single limit coverage for risks associated with the work contemplated by this Agreement. If a Commercial General Liability Insurance or an Automobile Liability form or other form with a general aggregate limit is used, either the general aggregate limit shall apply separately to the work to be performed under this Agreement or the general aggregate limit shall be at least twice the required occurrence limit. Such coverage shall include but shall not be limited to, protection against claims arising from bodily and personal injury, including death resulting therefrom, and damage to property resulting from activities contemplated under this Agreement, including the use of owned and non-owned automobiles.
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 4 of 11
4.2.2 Minimum scope of coverage. Commercial general coverage shall be at least as broad as Insurance Services Office Commercial General Liability occurrence form CG 0001 (most recent edition) covering comprehensive General Liability on an “occurrence” basis. Automobile coverage shall be at least as broad as Insurance Services Office Automobile Liability form CA 0001 (most recent edition), Code 1 (any auto). No endorsement shall be attached limiting the coverage.
4.2.3 Additional requirements. Each of the following shall be included in the insurance coverage or added as a certified endorsement to the policy:
a. The Insurance shall cover on an occurrence or an occurrence basis, and not on a claims-made basis.
b. Town, its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers are to be covered as insureds as respects: liability arising out of work or operations performed by or on behalf of the Contractor; or automobiles owned, leased, hired, or borrowed by the Contractor
c. For any claims related to this Agreement or the work hereunder, the Contractor’s insurance covered shall be primary insurance as respects the Town, its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers. Any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the Town, its officers, officials, employees, or volunteers shall be excess of the Contractor’s insurance and shall not contribute with it.
d. Each insurance policy required by this clause shall be endorsed to state that coverage shall not be canceled by either party, except after 30 days’ prior written notice has been provided to the Town.
4.3 All Policies Requirements.
4.3.1 Acceptability of insurers. All insurance required by this section is to be placed with insurers with a Bests' rating of no less than A:VII.
4.3.2 Verification of coverage. Prior to beginning any work under this Agreement, Contractor shall furnish Town with complete copies of all policies delivered to Contractor by the insurer, including complete copies of all endorsements attached to those policies. All copies of policies and endorsements shall show the signature of a person authorized by that insurer to bind coverage on its behalf. If the Town does not receive the required insurance documents prior to the Contractor beginning work, it shall not waive the Contractor’s obligation to provide them. The Town reserves the right to require complete copies of all required insurance policies at any time.
4.3.3 Deductibles and Self-Insured Retentions. Contractor shall disclose to and obtain the written approval of Town for the self-insured retentions and deductibles
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 5 of 11 before beginning any of the services or work called for by any term of this Agreement. At the option of the Town, either: the insurer shall reduce or eliminate such deductibles or self-insured retentions as respects the Town, its officers, employees, and volunteers; or the Contractor shall provide a financial guarantee satisfactory to the Town guaranteeing payment of losses and related investigations, claim administration and defense expenses.
4.3.4 Wasting Policies. No policy required by this Section 4 shall include a “wasting” policy limit (i.e. limit that is eroded by the cost of defense).
4.3.5 Waiver of Subrogation. Contractor hereby agrees to waive subrogation which any insurer or contractor may require from vendor by virtue of the payment of any loss. Contractor agrees to obtain any endorsements that may be necessary to affect this waiver of subrogation.
The Workers’ Compensation policy shall be endorsed with a waiver of subrogation in favor of the entity for all work performed by the Contractor, its employees, agents, and subcontractors.
4.3.6 Subcontractors. Contractor shall include all subcontractors as insureds under its policies or shall furnish separate certificates and endorsements for each subcontractor. All coverages for subcontractors shall be subject to all of the requirements stated herein.
4.4 Remedies. In addition to any other remedies Town may have if Contractor fails to provide or maintain any insurance policies or policy endorsements to the extent and within the time herein required, Town may, at its sole option exercise any of the following remedies, which are alternatives to other remedies Town may have and are not the exclusive remedy for Contractor’s breach:
Obtain such insurance and deduct and retain the amount of the premiums for such insurance from any sums due under the Agreement;
Order Contractor to stop work under this Agreement or withhold any payment that becomes due to Contractor hereunder, or both stop work and withhold any payment, until Contractor demonstrates compliance with the requirements hereof; and/or Terminate this Agreement.
Section 5. INDEMNIFICATION AND CONTRACTOR’S RESPONSIBILITIES.
Contractor shall indemnify, defend with counsel acceptable to Town, and hold harmless Town and its officers, officials, employees, agents and volunteers from and against any and all liability, loss, damage, claims, expenses, and costs (including without limitation, attorney’s fees and costs and fees of litigation) (collectively, “Liability”) of every nature arising out of or in connection with Contractor’s performance of the
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 6 of 11 Services or its failure to comply with any of its obligations contained in this Agreement, except such Liability caused by the sole negligence or willful misconduct of Town.
The Contractor’s obligation to defend and indemnify shall not be excused because of the Contractor’s inability to evaluate Liability or because the Contractor evaluates Liability and determines that the Contractor is not liable to the claimant. The Contractor must respond within 30 days, to the tender of any claim for defense and indemnity by the Town, unless this time has been extended by the Town. If the Contractor fails to accept or reject a tender of defense and indemnity within 30 days, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, so much of the money due the Contractor under and by virtue of this Agreement as shall reasonably be considered necessary by the Town, may be retained by the Town until disposition has been made of the claim or suit for damages, or until the Contractor accepts or rejects the tender of defense, whichever occurs first.
With respect to third party claims against the Contractor, the Contractor waives any and all rights of any type to express or implied indemnity against the Indemnitees.
In the event that Contractor or any employee, agent, or subcontractor of Contractor providing services under this Agreement is determined by a court of competent jurisdiction or the California Public Employees Retirement System (PERS) to be eligible for enrollment in PERS as an employee of Town, Contractor shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless Town for the payment of any employee and/or employer contributions for PERS benefits on behalf of Contractor or its employees, agents, or subcontractors, as well as for the payment of any penalties and interest on such contributions, which would otherwise be the responsibility of Town.
Section 6. STATUS OF CONTRACTOR.
6.1 Independent Contractor. At all times during the term of this Agreement, Contractor shall be an independent contractor and shall not be an employee of Town. Town shall have the right to control Contractor only insofar as the results of Contractor's services rendered pursuant to this Agreement and assignment of personnel pursuant to Subparagraph 1.3; however, otherwise Town shall not have the right to control the means by which Contractor accomplishes services rendered pursuant to this Agreement. Notwithstanding any other Town, state, or federal policy, rule, regulation, law, or ordinance to the contrary, Contractor and any of its employees, agents, and subcontractors providing services under this Agreement shall not qualify for or become entitled to, and hereby agree to waive any and all claims to, any compensation, benefit, or any incident of employment by Town, including but not limited to eligibility to enroll in the California Public Employees Retirement System (PERS) as an employee of Town and entitlement to any contribution to be paid by Town for employer contributions and/or employee contributions for PERS benefits.
6.2 Contractor Not an Agent. Except as Town may specify in writing, Contractor shall have no authority, express or implied, to act on behalf of Town in any capacity whatsoever as an agent. Contractor shall have no authority, express or implied, pursuant to this Agreement to bind Town to any obligation whatsoever.
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 7 of 11 Section 7. LEGAL REQUIREMENTS.
7.1 Governing Law. The laws of the State of California shall govern this Agreement.
7.2 Compliance with Applicable Laws. Contractor and any subcontractors shall comply with all laws applicable to the performance of the work hereunder.
7.3 Other Governmental Regulations. To the extent that this Agreement may be funded by fiscal assistance from another governmental entity, Contractor and any subcontractors shall comply with all applicable rules and regulations to which Town is bound by the terms of such fiscal assistance program.
7.4 Licenses and Permits. Contractor represents and warrants to Town that Contractor and its employees, agents, and any subcontractors have all licenses, permits, qualifications, and approvals of whatsoever nature that are legally required to practice their respective professions. Contractor represents and warrants to Town that Contractor and its employees, agents, any subcontractors shall, at their sole cost and expense, keep in effect at all times during the term of this Agreement any licenses, permits, and approvals that are legally required to practice their respective professions. In addition to the foregoing, Contractor and any subcontractors shall obtain and maintain during the term of this Agreement valid Business Licenses from Town.
7.5 Nondiscrimination and Equal Opportunity. Contractor shall not discriminate, on the basis of a person’s race, religion, color, national origin, age, physical or mental handicap or disability, medical condition, marital status, sex, or sexual orientation, against any employee, applicant for employment, subcontractor, bidder for a subcontract, or participant in, recipient of, or applicant for any services or programs provided by Contractor under this Agreement. Contractor shall comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, policies, rules, and requirements related to equal opportunity and nondiscrimination in employment, contracting, and the provision of any services that are the subject of this Agreement, including but not limited to the satisfaction of any positive obligations required of Contractor thereby.
Contractor shall include the provisions of this Subsection in any subcontract approved by the Contract Administrator or this Agreement.
Section 8. TERMINATION AND MODIFICATION.
8.1 Termination. Town may cancel this Agreement at any time and without cause upon written notification to Contractor.
Contractor may cancel this Agreement upon 90 days’ written notice to Town and shall include in such notice the reasons for cancellation.
In the event of termination, Contractor shall be entitled to compensation for services performed to the effective date of termination; Town, however, may condition payment of
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 8 of 11 such compensation upon Contractor delivering to Town any or all documents, photographs, computer software, video and audio tapes, and other materials provided to Contractor or prepared by or for Contractor or the Town in connection with this Agreement.
8.2 Extension. Town may, in its sole and exclusive discretion, extend the end date of this Agreement beyond that provided for in Subsection 1.1. Any such extension shall require a written amendment to this Agreement, as provided for herein. Contractor understands and agrees that, if Town grants such an extension, Town shall have no obligation to provide Contractor with compensation beyond the maximum amount provided for in this Agreement. Similarly, unless authorized by the Contract Administrator, Town shall have no obligation to reimburse Contractor for any otherwise reimbursable expenses incurred during the extension period.
8.3 Amendments. The parties may amend this Agreement only by a writing signed by all the parties.
8.4 Assignment and Subcontracting. Town and Contractor recognize and agree that this Agreement contemplates personal performance by Contractor and is based upon a determination of Contractor’s unique personal competence, experience, and specialized personal knowledge. Moreover, a substantial inducement to Town for entering into this Agreement was and is the professional reputation and competence of Contractor.
Contractor may not assign this Agreement or any interest therein without the prior written approval of the Contract Administrator. Contractor shall not subcontract any portion of the performance contemplated and provided for herein, other than to the subcontractors noted in the proposal, without prior written approval of the Contract Administrator.
8.5 Survival. All obligations arising prior to the termination of this Agreement and all provisions of this Agreement allocating liability between Town and Contractor shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
8.6 Options upon Breach by Contractor. If Contractor materially breaches any of the terms of this Agreement, Town’s remedies shall included, but not be limited to, the following:
8.6.1 Immediately terminate the Agreement;
8.6.2 Retain a different Contractor to complete the work described in Exhibit A not finished by Contractor; or
8.6.3 Charge Contractor the difference between the cost to complete the work described in Exhibit A that is unfinished at the time of breach and the amount that Town would have paid Contractor pursuant to Section 2 if Contractor had completed the work.
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 9 of 11 Section 9. KEEPING AND STATUS OF RECORDS.
9.1 Contractor’s Books and Records. Contractor shall maintain any and all ledgers, books of account, invoices, vouchers, canceled checks, and other records or documents evidencing or relating to charges for services or expenditures and disbursements charged to the Town under this Agreement for a minimum of 3 years, or for any longer period required by law, from the date of final payment to the Contractor to this Agreement.
9.2 Inspection and Audit of Records. Any records or documents that Section 9.1 of this Agreement requires Contractor to maintain shall be made available for inspection, audit, and/or copying at any time during regular business hours, upon oral or written request of the Town. Under California Government Code Section 8546.7, if the amount of public funds expended under this Agreement exceeds $10,000.00, the Agreement shall be subject to the examination and audit of the State Auditor, at the request of Town or as part of any audit of the Town, for a period of 3 years after final payment under the Agreement.
Section 10 MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS.
10.1 Attorneys’ Fees. If a party to this Agreement brings any action, including an action for declaratory relief, to enforce or interpret the provision of this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys’ fees in addition to any other relief to which that party may be entitled. The court may set such fees in the same action or in a separate action brought for that purpose.
10.2 Venue. In the event that either party brings any action against the other under this Agreement, the parties agree that trial of such action shall be vested exclusively in the state courts of California in the County of Santa Clara or in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California.
10.3 Severability. If a court of competent jurisdiction finds or rules that any provision of this Agreement is invalid, void, or unenforceable, the provisions of this Agreement not so adjudged shall remain in full force and effect. The invalidity in whole or in part of any provision of this Agreement shall not void or affect the validity of any other provision of this Agreement.
10.4 No Implied Waiver of Breach. The waiver of any breach of a specific provision of this Agreement does not constitute a waiver of any other breach of that term or any other term of this Agreement.
10.5 Successors and Assigns. The provisions of this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and shall apply to and bind the successors and assigns of the parties.
10.6 Use of Recycled Products. Contractor shall prepare and submit all reports, written studies and other printed material on recycled paper to the extent it is available at equal or less cost than virgin paper.
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 10 of 11
10.7 Conflict of Interest. Contractor may serve other clients, but none whose activities within the corporate limits of Town or whose business, regardless of location, would place Contractor in a “conflict of interest,” as that term is defined in the Political Reform Act, codified at California Government Code Section 81000 et seq.
Contractor shall not employ any Town official in the work performed pursuant to this Agreement. No officer or employee of Town shall have any financial interest in this Agreement that would violate California Government Code Sections 1090 et seq.
Contractor hereby warrants that it is not now, nor has it been in the previous 12 months, an employee, agent, appointee, or official of the Town. If Contractor was an employee, agent, appointee, or official of the Town in the previous twelve months, Contractor warrants that it did not participate in any manner in the forming of this Agreement. Contractor understands that, if this Agreement is made in violation of Government Code § 1090 et seq., the entire Agreement is void and Contractor will not be entitled to any compensation for services performed pursuant to this Agreement, including reimbursement of expenses, and Contractor will be required to reimburse the Town for any sums paid to the Contractor.
Contractor understands that, in addition to the foregoing, it may be subject to criminal prosecution for a violation of Government Code § 1090 and, if applicable, will be disqualified from holding public office in the State of California.
10.8 Solicitation. Contractor agrees not to solicit business at any meeting, focus group, or interview related to this Agreement, either orally or through any written materials.
10.9 Contract Administration. This Agreement shall be administered by WooJae Kim, Public Works Director, ("Contract Administrator"). All correspondence, communications and meetings shall be directed to or through the Contract Administrator or his or her designee.
The Contractor shall only take direction regarding the services provided under this Agreement from the Contract Administrator. Furthermore, Contractor agrees that the Contract Administrator shall be included any meeting, teleconference or written communication between any Town representative including Committee members and the Contractor. The Town may modify the Contract Administrator at any time upon providing written notice to the Contractor.
10.10 Notices. Any written notice to Contractor shall be sent to:
____________________________________________
____________________________________________
____________________________________________
Any written notice to Town shall be sent to:
Public Works Director - Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Email: [email protected]
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 11 of 11
10.11 Integration. This Agreement, including the scope of work attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibits A represents the entire and integrated agreement between Town and Contractor and supersedes all prior negotiations, representations, or agreements, either written or oral.
Exhibit A Proposal, with RFP included
10.12 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterparts, each of which shall be an original and all of which together shall constitute one agreement.
The Parties have executed this Agreement as of the Effective Date.
TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS CONTRACTOR
____________________________ ______________________________ Cody Einfalt, City Manager Significant Cleaning LLC, Eduardo Cardoza Attest:
____________________________
Arika Birdsong-Miller, City Clerk
Approved as to Form:
____________________________
, Town Attorney
Contracting Services Agreement between
Town of Los Altos Hills and Significant Cleaning Services, LLC Page 1 of 1
EXHIBIT A
SCOPE OF SERVICES
.
SIGNIFICANT
SCS LI CLEANING SERVICES
SPECIALIZING IN COMMERCIAL OFFICE CLEANING
Town of Los Altos Hills
Proposal Packet:
Janitorial Services
Still Here, Still Serving The
Significant! Bay Area Since
1987!
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Table of Contents
• Cover Page
• Table of Contents 1
• Letter of Introduction 2
• Company History and Background 3
• Mission Statement 4
• Software Used by SCS Daily 5
• Proposer's Qualifications and Experience 6
• Approach to Scope of Services 9
• Exhibit “B” 11
• Work References 13
• Exhibit “C” 14
• Evidence of Insurance 16
• DLSE Registration 18
1
148 E. Virginia Street, Suite 1 - San Jose, CA 95112 - (408) 559-5959 October 26, 2026
Town of Los Altos Hills – Public Works Department
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Letter of Introduction – RFP for Janitorial Services Dear Melissa,
Significant Cleaning Services LLC is pleased to submit our proposal to provide comprehensive janitorial services for the Town of Los Altos Hills. Established in 1987, our firm brings nearly four decades of institutional knowledge and operational stability. We have vast expertise in maintaining critical public and commercial facilities to the highest standards of sanitation, safety, and professionalism.
We fully understand that the Town of Los Altos Hills requires a highly reliable, detail-oriented janitorial partner to service its administrative, operational, and public-facing facilities. Based on our thorough review of the Request for Proposals (RFP), we understand the core scope demands seamless execution of daily, weekly, and periodic deep-cleaning tasks.
Our key qualifications include:
• 39 Years of Industry Excellence: Since 1987, we have successfully managed high-traffic, secure facilities, perfecting our operational workflows and transition processes. • Green Cleaning Practices: We exclusively utilize eco-friendly, Green Seal-certified products and advanced HEPA-filter vacuums, aligning perfectly with ACWD’s commitment to environmental sustainability.
• Proactive Communication: Our dedicated account managers are available 24/7, ensuring rapid response times and seamless adaptability to your facility's changing needs.
We are fully prepared to commit the necessary staffing, equipment, and management oversight to ensure a seamless transition and sustained excellence. Thank you for the opportunity to bid on this contract. We look forward to the possibility of a successful partnership.
Sincerely,
Eduardo Cardoza
Sr. VP of Finance
2
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Company History and Background
Headquarters/Location: 148 E Virginia St. suite 1 San Jose, CA 95112 Significant Cleaning Services (SCS) is currently an S Corporation specializing in Commercial Janitorial Cleaning and was established in 1987 by Larry and Diane Lovaglia and is still owned by the Lovaglia family to date. The current CEO is Anthony Lovaglia who joined full time in 2009.
During our 30 years in business, we have grown to one of the more competitive janitorial companies in the Greater Bay Area. We currently employ over 210 professionals and clean over three million square feet of offices, medical offices, warehouses, and R&D.
Here at Significant Cleaning Services (SCS), we take great pride in the services we provide. Our management are steady, reliable personnel that have been employed with our company for many years. We feel this is our greatest benefit to our customers, as they can rely on the continuance of the same reliable professionals for each cleaning service provided. SCS’ main line of business is a consistent split between the Janitorial Division and the Windows/Pressure Washing Division with the Maintenance Division showing growth potential. Although SCS is based in San Jose, our services are provided primarily in the Bay Areas and Northern California Peninsula. Our mission is to continue growing as a professional cleaning and maintenance organization that will continue to believe that our strongest and most important asset is the professionals that work for our organization.
The next important asset to our continued success is our relationships with our vendors and community organizations. We have built sole relationships with such organizations as Home Depot Pro, Leavitt Pacific, and Liberty Lighting. We are members of such community organizations as BOMA Silicon Valley, IFMA Silicon Valley, and continue to donate to Little Italy San Jose every year and our CEO Anthony Lovaglia is currently on the Executive Board. 3
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Mission Statement
We strongly believe that our biggest assets are our employees. We have many employees that have been with our organization for ten plus years. We believe the consistent employment of our professionals is what sets us apart. Our employees embrace our standards of conduct and understand how important our customers are to the growth and continuance of our company.
Our company provides a competitive incentive program for those full-time employees that work 30 hours minimum per week work shift.
It is our hope that you give us a chance to show you the professional cleaning Significant Cleaning Services can provide. We thank you again for your consideration of our many cleaning and maintenance services
4
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Software used by SCS daily
SCS uses BlueFolder to create and
close work orders, equipment
inventory, and detailed financial
reports. These reports include but
not limited to; cost v profit, average
equipment use and total labor used
for each job.
SCS has changed from Time Works Plus to utilize
Deputy for time keeping scheduling and day to
day communication and tasks with our employees.
Deputy is available through the Apple Store and
Google Play for our employees. Employees are
reimbursed for the use of the app; GPS geo-fencing is available to make sure employees clock in at the work location and fulfill their scheduled
shift.
SCS is available to schedule
online meetings and have direct
communication with our
customers via Microsoft Teams.
We can create our own private
team for real time communication
and schedule meetings with our
clients that will show on our
shared calendar.
5
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Proposer’s Qualifications and Experience
1) Company Qualifications, Experience and Key Personnel Significant Cleaning Services LLC is a premier commercial janitorial firm established in 1987. For 39 years, we have delivered high-quality, compliant maintenance solutions to public agencies and municipal utilities.
• Corporate Headquarters: 148 E. Virginia Street, Suite 1, San Jose, CA 95112. • Total Staff Infrastructure: 195 total employees (175 on-site custodians/supervisors; 20 administrative/safety staff).
• Organizational Divisions: Divided into Executive Leadership, Operations, Safety & Compliance, and On-Site Service Teams.
General Operational Structure & Personnel
• Direct Accountability Model: The Town of Los Altos Hills will be assigned a dedicated Account Manager as a single point of contact.
• Real-Time Oversight: Field supervisors utilize cloud-based mobile tracking software to audit and log task completion daily.
• Management Personnel: Seasoned industry veterans with extensive histories managing multi-site public agency contracts.
• Technical Personnel: In-house specialty teams trained in advanced floor care, pressure washing, and biohazard sanitation, eliminating the need for unvetted third-party subcontractors.
Since 1987, our firm has specialized in high-security, heavy-foot-traffic public complexes. We have successfully managed contracts identical in scope and complexity to the Town of Los Altos Hills for:
• Municipal Water & Utility Districts: Maintaining operations under strict environmental safety mandates.
• City & County Government Complexes: Servicing public lobbies, administrative offices, and secure facility zones.
• Critical Infrastructure & Corporate Headquarters: Delivering zero-disruption night custodial services for 24/7 facilities.
Significant Cleaning Services LLC offers unique advantages that guarantee a superior tier of service for the Town of Los Altos Hills:
6
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! • Institutional Stability: Our 39-year operating history provides an unshakeable financial and resource foundation.
• Geographic Proximity: Centralized in San Jose, our logistical lines to Los Altos Hills guarantee rapid emergency dispatch.
• Rigorous Security Compliance: All personnel undergo background vetting and are trained in complex key-custody workflows.
• Green Cleaning Expertise: We utilize 100% Green Seal-certified products to eliminate chemical runoff, protecting local water.
2) Technical Competence, Business Operations and Key Personnel Significant Cleaning Services LLC maintains an industry-low turnover rate across our 175 field employees through a structured development model:
• Top-Tier Compensation: Offering competitive hourly wages and medical benefits to attract long-term, professional staff.
• Structured Advancement: Providing clear career paths from custodian to supervisor to promote employee loyalty.
• Rigorous Training: Mandatory initial and monthly courses on OSHA safety, HAZCOM, and Green Seal procedures.
• Burnout Prevention: Utilizing automated scheduling software to balance workloads and ensure consistent service.
The following individuals are assigned to the Town of Los Altos Hills account. • Alex Reyes – Dedicated Account Manager
o Experience: 7 years of direct experience as a commercial janitorial Operations Manager.
o Expertise: Specializes in large-scale labor deployment, public agency contract compliance, and quality auditing.
• Jose Luis Gomez –Evening Supervisor
o Experience: 10+ years of supervisory experience; proudly with our firm since 2023.
o Expertise: Elite expertise in high-security utility lockup, Green Seal safety standards, and nightly crew leadership.
• Gisela Garcia – Day Time Supervisor
o Experience: 5+ years of supervisory experience; proudly with our firm since 2017.
o Expertise: Elite expertise in high-visibility tenant relations, occupied-space safety protocols, and dynamic day porter coordination.
7
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Our active portfolio proves our capability to handle diverse and complex public facilities:
• Municipal Utility Hubs: Managing facilities under strict environmental laws and secure access boundaries.
• Government Administrative Complexes: Servicing multi-building sites ranging from 40,000 to 75,000 square feet.
• High-Security Sites: Maintaining properties requiring intensive background vetting and zero-error lockup workflows.
8
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Approach to Scope of Services
Significant Cleaning Services LLC utilizes a systematic, task-driven approach to execute the requirements of the scope of work. We understand that the Town of Los Altos HIlls demands a sanitary, safe, and professional environment across administrative, public-facing, and secure operational areas.
• Service Delivery Model: We translate the Town of Los Altos HIlls Service Matrix into specific, computerized checklist routes for our nightly custodial crews. • Zones of Focus: We separate public lobbies, high-risk contamination areas (restrooms, breakrooms), and restricted administrative offices into distinct task zones to prevent cross-contamination.
• Environmental Safety: In alignment with the Town of Los Altos HIlls requirements, 100% of daily cleaners are Green Seal certified, protecting both indoor air quality and local watersheds.
• Tiered Inspections: Supervisors Gisela Garcia and Jose Luis Gomez will conduct weekly walkthroughs. Account Manager Alex Reyes performs weekly unannounced comprehensive facility audits.
• Corrective Action Protocol: Any deficiency identified by the Town of Los Altos HIlls or our internal team is logged, routed to the night crew immediately, and resolved within 2 hours.
To ensure seamless issue resolution, we provide a clear, non-automated chain of command. If a service issue arises, the Town of Los Altos HIlls management follows this direct communication pathway:
Level 1: Immediate
Gisela Garcia or Jose Luis Gomez – Day Time or Evening Supervisor Response Time: Under 15 Minutes
Scope: Daily operational issues, immediate cleaning adjustments, on-site staff routing. │
▼
Level 2: Account Manager
Alex Reyes – Dedicated Account Manager
Response Time: Under 1 hour
Scope: Discrepancy resolution, scheduling changes, contract compliance questions. │
▼
Level 3: Executive Team
9
Providing our best service to the Greater Bay since 1987! Anthony Lovaglia, CEO, will work with the Operations team.
Response Time: Same Day
Scope: Formal contract amendments, permanent staffing adjustments, emergency scaling.
We guarantee a zero-disruption transition from the incumbent provider using a structured 30- day phase-in schedule:
• Days 1–10 (Site Assessment & Security): Alex Reyes conducts facility walkthroughs, maps secure access perimeters, and coordinates background checks and badge access with the Town of Los Altos HIlls administration.
• Days 11–20 (Resource Deployment): Deliver and station all commercial equipment, Green Seal chemicals, and safety data sheets (SDS) on-site. Formulate specific route schedules.
• Days 21–30 (Staff Orientation & Dry Run): Conduct on-site safety and layout orientation for the custodial team. Execute a complete "dry run" cleaning shift under the supervision of Jose Luis Gomez.
• Day 31 (Go-Live): Seamless transition to full contract execution with zero service gaps.
With an active workforce of 175 field employees, our resource depth allows us to handle sudden absences and emergency service requests easily.
• Back-up Staffing Pool: We maintain a dedicated team of "on-call" floating custodians who are fully vetted and trained. If a regular team member calls out, a replacement is dispatched immediately, ensuring no service gaps occur at the Town of Los Altos HIlls. • 24/7 Emergency Technical Crew: We maintain a mobile rapid-response truck equipped with commercial water extractors, high-volume air movers, and specialized sanitization tools.
• Emergency Response Guarantee: In the event of an emergency our emergency crew will arrive at any of the Town of Los Altos HIlls’s facility within 60 minutes of dispatch, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.
10
EXHIBIT “B”
BUSINESS STATEMENT AND REFERENCES
This form must be completed and signed by the Contractor proposed to participate in this award. Attach additional copies of this form as required.
Company Name:
Mailing Address:
City: State: Zip:
Telephone No.:
Contact Person’s Name/Title:
Telephone No.:
Email Address:
Business License No.: City:
State: Expiration Date:
Federal ID No. or Social Security No.:
DIR Registration Number, if applicable:
Significant Cleaning Services, LLC
148 E. Virginia Street, Suite 1
San Jose CA 95112
408-559-5959
Eduardo Cardoza
408-340-4907
JS-LR-1001286256
CA
5727061210 San Jose
12/15/2026
11
Type of Organization: (Check all that apply)
□ Corporation, under the laws of the State of
□ Individual
□ Joint Venture
□ Municipal, State, or Federal
□ S Corporation
□ General Partnership
□ Limited Partnership
□ Non-Profit Corporation
□ Small Business Enterprise: A business enterprise that is independently owned and operated; organized for profit; is not dominant in its field; and meets the criteria set forth by the Small Business Administration in Title 13, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 121.
Company representative authorized to sign contracts.
Name Title Telephone
Signature Date
x
Anthony Lovaglia President
Eduardo Cardoza Sr. VP of Finance 408-340-4907
408-202-2399
10/26/2026
12
REFERENCES
Minimum three (3) references. Local and similar size contract references are preferred.
REFERENCE NO. 1
NAME OF FIRM
ADDRESS
CITY, STATE, ZIP
TELEPHONE NO.
CONTACT
PROJECT NAME
COMPLETION DATE
APPROX. COST
REFERENCE NO. 2
NAME OF FIRM
ADDRESS
CITY, STATE, ZIP
TELEPHONE NO.
CONTACT
PROJECT NAME
COMPLETION DATE
APPROX. COST
REFERENCE NO. 3
NAME OF FIRM
ADDRESS
CITY, STATE, ZIP
TELEPHONE NO.
CONTACT
PROJECT NAME
COMPLETION DATE
APPROX. COST
REFERENCE NO. 4
NAME OF FIRM
ADDRESS
CITY, STATE, ZIP
TELEPHONE NO.
CONTACT
PROJECT NAME
COMPLETION DATE
APPROX. COST
CoreSite, multiple locations San Jose/Santa Clara
55 South Market
San Jose, CA 95113
Ongoing
$815,964
Janitorial and Day Porter Services
408-918-4305
Harvest Properties
333 S. San Carlos Street
San Jose, CA 95110
510-947-1766
Andrew Breault, Property Manager
Matthew Orozco, Senior Manager
Janitorial and Day Porter Services
Ongoing
$523,496 (varies due to occupied square footage)
CBRE Cooley
3175 Hanover Street
Palo Alto, CA 94304
408-790-5488
Angie Zepeda-Castillo, Assistant Real Estate Manager
Janitorial and Day Porter Services
Ongoing
$419,000
13
EXHIBIT "C”
FEE SCHEDULE / COMPENSATION
Regular Janitorial Service:
MapIDNo Site name Address Amount per Month
S-01 LAH Town Hall 26379 Fremont Road $________________ S-02 Parks and Recreation
Building 26379 Fremont Road $________________
S-03 Heritage House 26379 Fremont Road $________________ S-04 Corporation Yard 27400 Purissima Road $________________ S-05 Purissima Park Restrooms 27500 Purissima Road $________________ S-06 Snack Shack 27500 Purissima Road $________________ S-07 Westwind Barn 27210 Altamont Road $________________ Total Amount per Month $________________
Total Amount per Year $________________
Carpet Cleaning Services – As Requested (up to five a year):
MapIDNo Site name Address Amount per Cleaning
S-01 LAH Town Hall 26379 Fremont Road $________________ Total for Up to Five (5) Cleaning Visits per Year $________________ Window Cleaning Service - Inside and Outside (once a year):
MapIDNo Site name Address Amount per Cleaning
S-01 LAH Town Hall 26379 Fremont Road $________________ S-02 Parks and Recreation
Building 26379 Fremont Road $________________
S-03 Heritage House 26379 Fremont Road $________________ Total Amount per Year $________________
325.00
1,625.00
350.00
350.00
350.00
1,050.00
2,480.00
388.00
336.00
594.00
573.00
258.00
563.00
5,192.00
62,304.00
14
PROPOSERS:
The undersigned as Proposer, declares that the only persons or parties interested in this proposal is made without collusion with any person, firm or corporation. Your signature on this document, should you be awarded the contract as defined in this RFP, signifies that you have fully read and understood this proposal and will comply with all specifications, conditions, unit prices, terms, and delivery of the proposal unless otherwise noted in the “exceptions” portion of the proposal.
Name of
Offeror (Firm): Title:
Authorized
Signature: Date:
Printed/Typed
Name:
Mailing
Address:
Phone:
City,
State,
Zip:
E-Mail: ____________________________
Significant Cleaning Services, LLC
Eduardo Cardoza
408-340-4907
[email protected]
Sr. VP of Finance
10/26/2026
148 E. Virginia Street, Suite 1
San Jose, CA 95112
15
ACORD DATE (MM/DD/YYYY)
CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE 06/01/2026
THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS
CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURERS), AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER.
IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED, the policy(ies) must have ADDITIONAL INSURED provisions or be endorsed.
If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy, certain policies may require an endorsement. A statement on this certificate does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsements).
PRODUCER NAME Micheal Bonham
Leavitt Pacific Insurance Brokers, Inc. PAC NO, Ext: (408) 288-6262 PHONE : (408) 364-8100 -MAIL [email protected]
License #0D79674 ADDRESS:
1570 The Alameda, Suite 101 INSURERS) AFFORDING COVERAGE NAIC # San Jose CA 95126 INSURERA: Employers Mutual Casualty Company 021415 INSURED INSURER B: Burlington Insurance Company 23620
Significant Cleaning Services, LLC INSURER C: Cypress Insurance Company 10855 148 E Virginia St #1 INSURER D: Palomar Excess and Surplus Insurance Company 16754 INSURERE: Travelers Casualty and Surety Company 31194
San Jose CA 95112 INSURER F:
COVERAGES CERTIFICATE NUMBER: 26 REVISION NUMBER:
HIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD INDICATE
OTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY E
ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS, EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES. *LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS. LIMITS SHOWN ARE INCLUSIVE OF AMOUNTS REQUESTED BY THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER AND MAY NOT REFLECT POLICY LIMIT AMOUNTS IN EXCESS OF THOSE REQUESTED. *Not Applicable in WY
TADDLISUBR
TYPE OF INSURANCE LINSD WD POLICY NUMBER LIMITS
X COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY EACH OCCURRENCE 1,000,000 DAMAGE TO RENTED 500,000
CLAIMS-MADE X OCCUR PREMISES (Ea occurrence)
MED EXP (Any one person) $ 10,000
BBC5901 06/01/2026 06/01/2027 PERSONAL & ADV INJURY $ 1,000,000 GEN'L AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER: GENERAL AGGREGATE $ 2,000,000 POLICY X PECT LOC PRODUCTS - COMP/OP AGG 2,000,000
JECT
OTHER:
AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY COMBINED SINGLE LIMIT 1,000,000
(Ea accident)
X ANY AUTO BODILY INJURY (Per person) $
A OWNED SCHEDULED 6E73039 06/01/2026 06/01/2027 BODILY INJURY (Per accident)
AUTOS ONLY AUTOS
HIRED NON-OWNED PROPERTY DAMAGE
AUTOS ONLY AUTOS ONLY (Per accident
UMBRELLA LIAB X OCCUR 5,000,000
EACH OCCURRENCE
X EXCESS LIAB PENDING 06/01/2026 06/01/2027 AGGREGATE 5,000,000
CLAIMS-MADE
X RETENTIONS O
WORKERS COMPENSATION X STATUTE T
AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY
ANY PROPRIETOR/PARTNER/EXECUTIVE E.L. EACH ACCIDENT 1,000,000 OFFICER/MEMBER EXCLUDED? N/ A SIWC773237 06/01/2026 06/01/2027 (Mandatory in NH) EL DISEASE - EA EMPLOYEE S 1,000,000
DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS below E.L. DISEASE - POLICY LIMIT 1,000,000 Second Layer Excess Liability PENDING 06/01/2026 06/01/2027 Limit $5M XS $5M
DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS/ LOCATIONS / VEHICLES (ACORD 101, Additional Remarks Schedule, may be attached if more space is required)
CERTIFICATE HOLDER CANCELLATION
SHOULD ANY OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE
THE EXPIRATION DATE THEREOF, NOTICE WILL BE DELIVERED IN For Information Only ACCORDANCE WITH THE POLICY PROVISIONS
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE
hidalas Care
ACORD 25 (2025/12) © 1988-2025 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved.
The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD
AGENCY CUSTOMER ID: 00006332
LOC #:
ACORD® ADDITIONAL REMARKS SCHEDULE Page of
AGENCY NAMED INSURED
Leavitt Pacific Insurance Brokers, Inc. Significant Cleaning Services, LLC
POLICY NUMBER
CARRIER NAIC CODE
EFFECTIVE DATE:
ADDITIONAL REMARKS
THIS ADDITIONAL REMARKS FORM IS A SCHEDULE TO ACORD FORM, FORM NUMBER: 25 FORM TITLE: Certificate of Liability Insurance: Notes INSR LTR:E - 3rd Party Crime, Policy #107239010, Effective 6/1/2026 - 6/1/2027, Limit/Deductible $1M/$10,000 ACORD 101(2008/01) © 2008 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved.
The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD
State ofCalifornia
Department of Industrial Relations
Division of Labor Standards Enforcement
Licensing & Registration Unit
1515 Clay Street, Ste. 1902
Oakland, CA 94612
Janitorial Services Registration
REGISTRANT WITH EMPLOYEES
Effective Date
2/13/2026
Expiration Date
2/13/2027
Significant Cleaning Services LLC
148 E. Virginia Street Suite 1
San Jose, CA 95112
Workers Compensation Insurance Expiration Date:
June 1, 2026
POST IN A CONSPICUOUSPLACE
ALTERATIONS WILL VOID THIS REGISTRATION
Branch 1. DBA N/A 148 E. Virginia Street Suite 1, San Jose, CA 95112 Registration Number:
JS-LR-1001286256
18
Town of Los Altos Hills
Public Works Department
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Request for Proposal
2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town
Facilities and Parks
Issue: October 9, 2026
Proposals Due:
October 26, 2026, at 1:00PM PDT
Pre-Proposal Meeting (Mandatory)
Thursday, October 15, 2026, at 10:00 a.m.
Contact: Melissa Elian
Phone: (650) 947-2517
Email: [email protected]
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 1
Town of Los Altos Hills
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL – 2027-2031 JANITORIAL SERVICES FOR TOWN
FACILITIES AND PARKS
1. PURPOSE
The Town of Los Altos Hills (Town) is soliciting proposals from experienced and qualified janitorial service vendors to provide scheduled and professional cleaning services at seven (7) Town properties.
The initial contract term would be three (3) years, commencing January 1, 2027, with an option to extend for two (2) additional years. The Town reserves the right to terminate the agreement at any time in accordance with the terms of the contract.
2. SCOPE OF WORK
The selected vendor (Contractor) shall furnish all labor, materials, supplies, tools, equipment, and transportation necessary to perform general janitorial services at the Town facilities and park sites listed below, in accordance with this Request for Proposals (RFP).
A. Service Locations (See Exhibit A for Site Map):
MapIDNo Site name Address
S-01 LAH Town Hall 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-02 Parks and Recreation
Building 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-03 Heritage House 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-04 Corporation Yard 27400 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills S-05 Purissima Park Restrooms 27500 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills S-06 Snack Shack 27500 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills
S-07 Westwind Barn 27210 Altamont Road Los Altos Hills
B. Regular Janitorial Services
All Contractor personnel assigned to provide janitorial services shall be properly trained and shall comply with all applicable federal, State, and local laws, regulations, and safety requirements. The
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 2
Contractor shall conduct necessary required background and security checks for employees assigned to Town facilities.
The Contractor shall use environmentally preferable cleaning and disinfecting products that are appropriate for the surfaces and facilities being serviced and comply with all applicable laws and regulations.
Regular janitorial services shall include, but are not limited to, the following:
General/All Areas
• Pick up litter; empty all trash and recycling containers; replace liners; and dispose of materials in designated receptacles.
• Vacuum all floors and entry mats, including carpeted and non-carpeted areas as appropriate. • Sweep and wet mop hard-surface floors using appropriate cleaning and disinfecting products. • Spot-clean carpets as needed using appropriate carpet-cleaning products. • Clean public counters and other frequently used surfaces. • Clean walls, partitions, and doors as needed to remove stains, marks, and spots. • Clean doors and windows.
• Clean and disinfect drinking fountains.
• Clean, sanitize, and refill dispensers, including paper towels, hand sanitizer, and soap, as applicable.
• Dust surfaces, including desks, tables, counters, windowsills, vent grills, and other dust collecting surfaces.
• Dust window blinds.
• Clean and sanitize door handles, panic-bar hardware, and other frequently touched surfaces.
Restrooms
• Clean and disinfect restroom sinks and countertops.
• Clean and sanitize toilets, urinals, partitions, and associated surfaces, including the base of each fixture.
• Sanitize restroom door handles and light switches.
• Fully stock and refill restroom dispensers, including toilet paper, paper towels, soap, and sanitary products.
• Empty restroom trash and sanitary containers and replace liners. • Replace restroom air fresheners as needed.
• Install and replace urinal splash guards on a regular basis. • Clean and sanitize showers.
Kitchen Areas
• Spot clean kitchen cabinet doors, drawers, and fronts. • Sanitize kitchen door handles and light switches.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 3
• Clean the exterior of refrigerators.
• Clean kitchen sinks.
• Spot clean kitchen walls.
• Clean kitchen drains, vents, and filters as needed.
Heritage House
In addition to the services identified above, the Contractor shall:
• Clean wood paneling, shelves, windowsills, and window frames using products appropriate for wood surfaces.
• Clean wood furniture using appropriate wood-cleaning products. • Clean hardwood floors using products specifically intended for hardwood flooring. • Clean bath mats.
C. General Service Requirements
The Contractor shall schedule and perform janitorial services in a manner that accommodates Town Hall business operations, Council and Committee meetings, public events, and other scheduled activities. The Contractor shall maintain sufficient flexibility to adjust service schedules as necessary to avoid conflicts with Town activities.
Normal Town Hall business hours are 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m., Monday through Friday. Regular and special Council and Committee meetings are held throughout the week at Town Hall, the Parks and Recreation Building, and Heritage House. Meeting schedules are available through the Town’s website (https://losaltoshillsca.portal.civicclerk.com/); however, not all meetings and public events may be posted in advance.
The Contractor shall be prepared to reschedule or adjust services upon at least 24 hours' notice from the Town, when reasonably necessary to accommodate meetings, events, facility use, or other Town activities.
D. Service Frequency
The anticipated service frequency is as follows, subject to final scheduling and adjustment by the Town:
1. Town Hall: Five days per week, Sunday through Thursday.
2. Parks and Recreation Building: Five days per week, Sunday through Thursday.
3. Heritage House: Two days per week, Sunday and Thursday.
4. Corporation Yard: One day per week, Monday, between 7:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m.
5. Purissima Park Restrooms: Two days per week, Monday and Friday.
6. Snack Shack: One day per week, Monday or Tuesday.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 4
7. Westwind Community Barn: One day per week, including the staff area, kitchen, and restroom. The service day and time shall be coordinated with the Westwind Barn concessionaire.
The Town reserves the right to modify service days and hours as reasonably necessary during the term of the Agreement.
E. Holiday Services
Services shall be provided when a holiday falls on a regularly scheduled service day, except for New Year's Day, Thanksgiving Day, Independence Day (July 4), Labor Day, Memorial Day, and Christmas Day, unless otherwise directed or approved by the Town.
F. Additional Services
Carpet Cleaning – As Requested
If authorized by the Town, Carpet cleaning services shall be provided at Town Hall on an as-requested basis, up to a maximum of 15 cleanings during the initial Agreement term, or approximately five (5) cleanings per year.
Window Cleaning – Interior and Exterior
If authorized by the Town, window cleaning services shall be provided once per year at the following locations:
• Town Hall – three cleanings during the initial three-year term. • Parks and Recreation Building – three cleanings during the initial three-year term. • Heritage House – three cleanings during the initial three-year term.
G. Self-Performance
The Contractor shall self-perform all janitorial services required under the Scope of Work.
Subcontracting of the required janitorial services is not permitted without the Town's prior written approval.
H. Facility Access and Security
The Town will provide the Contractor with keys and/or access cards necessary to perform the services. The Contractor shall acknowledge receipt of all keys and access cards and shall be responsible for their safekeeping. The Contractor shall not duplicate keys or access cards without the Town's prior written authorization.
The Contractor shall ensure that only authorized employees assigned to perform services for the Town are provided access to Town facilities. Contractor personnel shall not permit unauthorized individuals to enter areas controlled by keys, access cards, or security codes issued to the Contractor.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 5
Contractor personnel shall not disturb documents or personal property, open drawers or cabinets, use Town telephones or computers, or otherwise access or tamper with Town property except as specifically authorized and necessary to perform the services.
Contractor personnel shall be responsible for disarming the facility upon entry, as applicable, and for fully securing, locking, and arming the facility upon completion of each service visit. Facilities shall not be left unattended unless they are fully secured, locked, and armed.
Failure to properly secure a Town facility may result in corrective action, claim for damages, and termination of the services under the Agreement.
The Town will notify the Contractor when security codes or other access information are changed.
Upon expiration or termination of the Agreement, the Contractor shall immediately return all Town-issued keys, access cards, and other access devices.
I. Contractor-Furnished Equipment and Supplies
The Contractor shall furnish, maintain, and operate all equipment, tools, and materials necessary to perform the janitorial services. Equipment shall be commercial-grade and maintained in safe and proper working conditions. Required equipment includes, but is not limited to, commercial-grade vacuum cleaners, carpet-cleaning equipment, floor-scrubbing and buffing equipment, brooms, mops, cleaning brushes, towels, and related tools.
All Contractor employees shall wear uniforms that clearly identify them as employees of the Contractor and shall carry appropriate identification while performing services at Town facilities.
Cleaning products shall be environmentally preferable where reasonably available and appropriate for the intended use. Paper products furnished by the Town shall comply with applicable State requirements.
Per California's SB 1383 regulations, the Contractor must buy paper products (toilet paper, paper towels, toilet seat covers, etc.) that meet strict minimum postconsumer recycled content levels and are genuinely recyclable. The Contractor must also provide the Town with written certifications or documentation verifying both the minimum postconsumer content and unqualified recyclability requirements.
J. Reporting on Maintenance and Security Issues
The Contractor shall promptly report to the Town's Maintenance Supervisor any observed broken, damaged, malfunctioning, or vandalized equipment, fixtures, or building systems, including, but not limited to, heating and air-conditioning systems, plumbing, electrical systems, doors, and other facility components.
The Town’s Maintenance Supervisor can be reached by telephone at (650)-531-5123 or via email at [email protected].
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 6
K. Mandatory Pre-Proposal Site Visit
A mandatory pre-proposal site visit will be held at 10:00 a.m. on Thursday, October 15, 2026, at Town Hall, located at 26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, California 94022.
Prospective Proposers shall meet at Town Hall at 10:00 a.m. Town staff will then lead attendees through all seven service locations.
Attendance at the mandatory pre-proposal site visit is required for submission of a proposal.
Prospective Proposers shall sign the attendance sheet at the meeting.
L. REQUIREMENTS AND DETAILS
The Contractor must meet the following minimum qualifications to be considered:
1. The contractor will be a financially sound company primarily engaged in professional janitorial services in the State of California.
2. Preferred to have successfully completed or in contract with three (3) companies/agencies of comparable size and scope, within the past five (5) years with references provided in proposal.
3. Submit Exhibit B – Business Statement and References.
4. Submit Exhibit C – Compensation.
5. Review the Town’s standard agreement template included in Exhibit D and note any exceptions or revisions to the terms and conditions in the Proposal.
6. Meet the insurance coverage requirements in accordance with the Town’s insurance requirements in the Town’s standard agreement in Exhibit D M. PROPOSAL SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS
For the proposal to be considered responsive, the Contractor must submit all information requested in this RFP in the proposal. Failure to submit all required information, forms and documents in the proposal may result in disqualification. Proposals must be submitted on or before the closing date and time. Proposals received after the closing date and time will be considered non- responsive. It is the contractor’s responsibility to ensure that their proposal has been received by the Town.
The following information, forms and documents are to be submitted with the Proposal:
1. Company and Key Personnel Introduction: A statement to introduce the company and key personnel who will be involved in providing the services to the Town. This statement should be on company letterhead and be no longer than 5 pages, excluding Town required forms.
With this statement, the following information and documents shall be included:
- Exemptions or revisions required to the Town’s standard agreement included in Exhibit D.
- Exabit B - Business Statement and References completed. - Include copies of any required licenses or certifications.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 7
2. Services Detail Statement: A detailed scope of work or services, methodology, and frequency of services that comprehensively define and describe the individual tasks involved in performing the janitorial Services. The Services Detail Statement should be on company letterhead and be no longer than 10 pages.
3. Fee Schedule: The Contractor shall provide a Fee Schedule per the table in Exhibit C showing rates/costs for all services to be provided.
Prices/rates shall be valid for the term of the proposal contract and include all labor, equipment, materials, fees, tools and equipment, transportation, overhead, travel, profit, insurance, sales and other taxes, license, incidentals, and all other related costs necessary to meet the work requirements described in this RFP.
4. Submission of Proposal: The contractor’s proposal can be emailed to Melissa Elion-Carrillo at [email protected]. If mailed. or hand delivered, provide three hardcopies in a sealed envelope addressed to the following:
Town of Los Altos Hills – Public Works Department
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Attention: Melissa Elian-Carrillo
It is the contractor’s responsibility to confirm that the Town is in receipt of proposal by the due date and time. Late proposals will not be accepted.
N. EVALUATION PROCESS AND SELECTION CRITERIA
Selection of the Contractor will be based upon a competitive and best-value selection process. All elements of the pricing proposal will be considered including responsiveness of proposal and price.
Criteria to be evaluated shall include the following:
1. Experience, references, and past performance under a similar scope of work.
2. Cost to perform the required services stated in the Scope of Work as provided in the Fee Schedule.
3. Contractor’s capabilities and resources to complete and work on the Scope of Work.
O. REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL (RFP) AND CONTRACT AWARD TIMELINE Mandatory Job Walk/Pre-Proposal Meeting 10/15/2026 10:00 am Deadline to Submittal questions 10/21/2026
Response to Questions 10/23/2026
Submission Deadline for Proposal 10/26/2026, 1:00 p.m.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 8
P. GENERAL
Town is not committed to any course of action as a result of its issuance of this RFP and/or its receipt of a proposal from any contractor in response to it. In particular, contractors shall note that Town may:
1. Reject any proposal that does not conform to instructions and specifications which are issued herein.
2. Not accept proposals after the stated submission deadline.
3. Reject all proposals.
4. Cancel the RFP at anytime.
5. Award a contract in connection with this RFP at any time.
6. Make no award of contract.
7. Negotiate agreement terms with the awarded contractor at the Town’s discretion.
Town will not reimburse any organization for proposal preparation costs or other work performed in connection with this RFP, whether or not the contractor is awarded a contract.
Proposals (including accompanying materials) will become the property of Town. Proposals will be held in confidence to the extent permitted by law. After award of a contract or after rejection of all proposals, the proposals will be public record subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (Government Code Section 6250 et seq.). The Proposal together with copies of all documents pertaining to any award, if issued, shall be opened to public inspection.
All information submitted as a part of a Proposal will be open to public inspection (except items marked as trade secrets and considered a trade secret under the California Public Records Act) after the award has been made.
Town reserves the right to request additional information from prospective contractors prior to final selection and to consider information about a firm other than that submitted in the proposal.
Pricing shall remain firm-fixed for the first year of the Contract. Pricing for the potential subsequent years of the contract will be reviewed four months prior to the expiration date. All Proposals shall remain valid offers open for the Town acceptance for a minimum of 120 days following the RFP due date.
If any contractor response to this RFP contains trade secrets that you do not want disclosed to the public or used by the Town for any purpose other than evaluation of your approach, then mark the top of each sheet of such information with the following legend:
“CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION”
Should a request be made to Town for information that has been designated confidential by the contractor and, on the basis of that designation, Town denies the request for information, the contractor may be responsible for all legal cost, necessary to defend such action if the denial is challenged in a court of law.
RFP – 2027-2031 Janitorial Services for Town Facilities and Parks Town of Los Altos Hills Page 9
Any changes, additions, or deletions to the RFP will be in the form of a written addendum issued by Town’s Public Works Department and forwarded to all contractors. Except as stated in this provision, no person is authorized to amend or revise any part of this RFP, in any respect, either in writing or by oral statement.
Q. QUESTIONS
Contractors are responsible for reading carefully and understanding fully the terms and conditions of this RFP. Requests for clarification or additional information must be made to the Town Contact below before the deadline:
Melissa Elian-Carrillo – Associate Engineer: (650) 947-2517 Email Question to [email protected] in the Subject line of email type “FY2027-2031 Janitorial Services Question(s)”
Only written communications relative to this RFP shall be considered. It is incumbent upon contractors to verify Town is in receipt of their questions. Misinterpretation of the contract documents by the contractor shall not relieve an awarded contractor of responsibility to perform the contract.
To the extent that a question causes a change to any part of this RFP, an addendum shall be issued addressing such.
EXHIBIT “A”
TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
JANITORIAL SITE LISTING AND MAPPING
MapIDNo Site name Address
S-01 LAH Town Hall 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-02 Parks and Recreation
Building 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-03 Heritage House 26379 Fremont Road Los Altos Hills
S-04 Corporation Yard 27400 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills S-05 Purissima Park Restrooms 27500 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills S-06 Snack Shack 27500 Purissima Road Los Altos Hills
S-07 Westwind Barn 27210 Altamont Road Los Altos Hills
TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS November 12, 2026
Staff Report to the City Council
SUBJECT: OVERVIEW OF EMERGENCY PREPARDNESS ACTIVITIES AND
PROCLAMATION OF LOCAL EMERGENCY IN ANTICIPATION OF
THE 2026-27 EL NIÑO STORM SEASON
FROM: Mindy Shaine, Assistant to the City Manager
APPROVED: Cody Einfalt, City Manager
RECOMMENDATION: That the City Council:
Proclaim the existence of a local emergency in the Town of Los Altos Hills due to the anticipated threat of severe winter storm events associated with the 2026–27 El Niño season, in accordance with Section 8630 of the California Government Code and Chapter 4-1.05 of the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code.
Alternative Options:
• Defer the proclamation of a local emergency and direct staff to continue monitoring weather forecasts and resource needs, bringing the item back to Council if conditions escalate or additional authority is required.
BACKGROUND:
The Town of Los Altos Hills has a history of responding to severe winter storm events through emergency declarations and coordinated preparedness efforts.
On January 1, 2023, following a series of severe winter storms that resulted in flooding, mudslides, and property damage throughout the region, the Director of Emergency Services proclaimed a local emergency. The proclamation was subsequently ratified by the City Council in accordance with Section 8630 of the California Government Code and Chapter 4-1.05 of the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code. The Emergency Operations Center (EOC) was activated on January 4, 2023, to coordinate response activities and protect residents and property.
Additional severe storm conditions in March 2023 prompted the City Council to adopt a further proclamation of local emergency on March 16, 2023, in response to forecasts of continued atmospheric river events and associated hazards, including flooding, downed trees, and road closures. These actions occurred alongside statewide emergency proclamations issued by the Governor of California, facilitating coordination with regional, state, and federal agencies and access to available disaster assistance resources.
Since these events, the Town has continued to strengthen its emergency preparedness capabilities through the maintenance and development of its Emergency Operations Plan (EOP), ITEM 8B
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
implementation of the Standardized Emergency Management System (SEMS) and National Incident Management System (NIMS), and ongoing coordination with regional emergency management partners.
The Town's Disaster Council, established by Municipal Code, continues to provide a framework for emergency planning, preparedness, and coordination. The Town has also maintained public communication and emergency notification capabilities to support timely dissemination of information to residents.
These efforts, informed by lessons learned from previous storm responses, provide a foundation for the Town's continued preparedness and response activities.
DISCUSSION:
The anticipated El Niño conditions for the 2026–27 winter season warrant heightened attention to the Town's preparedness posture. Seasonal weather conditions may increase the potential for significant precipitation and associated hazards, including localized flooding, mudslides, downed trees, road closures, and power outages.
Given the Town's topography, hillside roadways, and potential vulnerabilities associated with severe winter weather, proactive emergency preparedness and coordination are essential to protecting residents, property, infrastructure, and essential Town operations.
A proclamation of local emergency would formally recognize the potential threat and establish the appropriate emergency management framework for the Town to address evolving conditions. It would also facilitate coordination with other governmental agencies and support the Town's ability to pursue available mutual aid and disaster assistance resources, as applicable.
What Proclaiming a Local Emergency Enables the Town to Do A proclamation of local emergency is not merely a symbolic act — it activates a specific set of legal authorities under Municipal Code Chapter 4-1 that the Town would not otherwise have. The key provisions are summarized below. Municipal Code § 4-1.05 is included as an attachment to this staff report.
Who Can Proclaim It
Under Municipal Code § 4-1.05(a)(1), the Director of Emergency Services (the City Manager) may request the City Council to proclaim the existence or threatened existence of a local emergency if the Council is in session or may issue the proclamation directly if the Council is not in session. 2 If the Director issues the proclamation, the City Council must ratify it within seven days or the proclamation shall have no further force or effect.
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
Powers Activated Upon Proclamation — § 4-1.05(d)
Upon proclamation of a local emergency, the Director of Emergency Services is empowered to exercise the following authorities:
1. Issue emergency rules and regulations — Make and issue rules and regulations on matters reasonably related to the protection of life, property, and environment as affected by the emergency; these rules must be confirmed by the City Council at the earliest practicable time.
2. Obtain and commandeer vital supplies — Obtain vital supplies, equipment, and other properties found lacking and needed for the protection of life, property, and environment, and bind the Town for the fair value thereof; if required immediately, commandeer the same for public use.
3. Require emergency services of Town staff — Require emergency services of any Town officer or employee. (Note: the additional power to command aid from community members at large applies only upon a state of war emergency or a state of emergency proclaimed by the Governor, not a local emergency alone.)
4. Requisition Town personnel and materials — Requisition necessary personnel or material of any Town department or agency.
5. Exercise full Director powers — Execute all ordinary powers as City Manager, all special powers conferred by the chapter or by resolution or the Emergency Operations Plan, and all powers conferred by any statute, agreement approved by the City Council, or other lawful authority.
Emergency Operations and Resource Needs
The Town maintains an Emergency Operations Center (EOC) that can be activated as conditions warrant to coordinate emergency response activities, facilitate interdepartmental communication, and support operational decision-making.
Staff continue to review EOC activation procedures, emergency contact information, operational assignments, and coordination protocols with regional partners, including Santa Clara County emergency management agencies, fire services, law enforcement, Valley Water, and PG&E.
The Town's preparedness activities include reviewing the availability of essential storm response resources, including sandbags, portable pumps, barricades, emergency signage, and other materials that may be needed to address storm-related impacts.
The Corporation Yard, located at 27500 Purissima Road, serves as the Town's primary sandbag distribution location. The Town also coordinates with Santa Clara County regarding the availability of additional resources to assist residents during severe weather events.
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
Community Engagement and Public Information
Public communication is a critical component of the Town's emergency preparedness strategy.
Residents are encouraged to register for Nixle and AlertSCC emergency notification systems to receive timely information regarding hazardous conditions, road closures, evacuation guidance, and other emergency notifications.
Staff will continue public outreach through the Town's website, social media channels, and other communication platforms. Outreach efforts will emphasize household preparedness, emergency notification registration, storm safety, and measures residents can take to reduce potential impacts, including clearing storm drains and preparing household emergency supplies.
Coordination with neighborhood groups and community organizations will also support information sharing and outreach to residents who may require additional assistance during severe weather events
Training, Exercises, and Volunteer Integration
The Town will continue to emphasize emergency preparedness training and coordination among Town personnel, Community Emergency Response Team (CERT) volunteers, and regional emergency response partners.
Training and exercises will support familiarity with EOC activation procedures, emergency communications, operational responsibilities, and coordination protocols.
The Town's Disaster Council, consistent with Municipal Code Section 4-1.07, provides a framework for volunteer preparedness, training, and coordination. The Town will continue working with the Los Altos Hills County Fire District, Santa Clara County Fire Department, and other regional partners to strengthen community preparedness and volunteer integration.
Preparedness Timeline
The following milestones identify preparedness activities anticipated during the 2026-27 storm season.
Timeframe Milestone/Activity
October-November
2026 Review and finalization of storm preparedness and EOC readiness November 2026 Review of storm response resources and sandbag distribution operations
December 2026 Enhanced public outreach and emergency notification messaging
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
Timeframe Milestone/Activity
December 2026 EOC readiness review and staff preparedness training January–March 2027 Anticipated peak storm season; ongoing monitoring, preparedness, and response activities
Options Analysis
Staff considered continuing existing preparedness activities without adopting a local emergency proclamation.
While the Town maintains ongoing emergency preparedness capabilities, a formal proclamation would provide an additional legal and operational framework for addressing conditions that may threaten public safety and property.
Proactive action would also facilitate coordination with regional, state, and federal agencies and position the Town to pursue available mutual aid and disaster assistance resources, subject to applicable eligibility requirements.
Given the potential impacts associated with severe winter storm conditions, staff recommends adoption of the proposed proclamation.
Stakeholder Input
Staff's recommended approach is informed by coordination with emergency management partners and Public Works. These stakeholders have emphasized the importance of early preparedness, resource coordination, effective public communication, and interagency collaboration in addressing potential storm-related impacts.
The Town's proposed proclamation is consistent with actions being taken by neighboring jurisdictions and regional agencies in anticipation of the 2026–27 El Niño storm season. San Mateo County has formally proclaimed a local emergency, and Valley Water has taken a similar emergency action. The City of San José is also scheduled to consider a local emergency proclamation at its November 10 City Council meeting. These actions demonstrate a broader regional recognition of the need for proactive preparedness, mitigation, and coordination in advance of anticipated El Niño-related storm impacts. The Town's proposed proclamation aligns Los Altos Hills with this regional preparedness posture and reinforces its commitment to protecting the community, public infrastructure, and essential services.
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:
The proposed action consists of proclaiming a local emergency in anticipation of potential severe winter storm conditions associated with the 2026–27 El Niño season. The proclamation is an administrative and governmental action intended to establish an emergency management framework and facilitate preparedness, coordination, and response activities.
The action does not approve any specific physical project or activity that would result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. Accordingly, the action does not constitute a project under Section 15378 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, and environmental review is not required.
CITY COUNCIL WORKPLAN:
The recommended action directly advances the FY 2026–27 City Council Work Plan item titled "Enhance Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness."
Proclaiming a local emergency in anticipation of potential severe winter storm conditions supports the Town's strategic priorities of protecting residents, infrastructure, and essential services from natural disasters and other emergency events.
The action also reinforces the Town's commitment to maintaining emergency preparedness capabilities, strengthening interagency coordination, and ensuring effective communication with the community.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Adoption of the proposed proclamation does not establish a specific appropriation or request approval of additional expenditures. Rather, the proclamation establishes the local emergency framework under which the City Manager, serving as Director of Emergency Services, carries out emergency management responsibilities in accordance with applicable provisions of the California Government Code, the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code, and the Town's Emergency Operations Plan.
Actual costs associated with storm preparedness, emergency response, and potential recovery activities will depend on weather conditions, operational needs, and the extent of any resulting impacts to the Town.
Such costs may include personnel time, storm response materials, equipment, emergency operations, public communications, and other activities necessary to protect residents and Town property.
Staff will monitor emergency-related costs and pursue available state and federal disaster assistance and reimbursement programs, as applicable. Should additional appropriations or
Staff Report to City Council
Proclamation of Local Emergency in Anticipation of the 2026-27 El Niño Storm Season November 12, 2026
budget adjustments become necessary, staff will address those requirements through the appropriate budget process.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Proclamation
2. Municipal Code § 4-1.05 — Powers and Duties of the Director, Assistant Director of Emergency Services, and Emergency Services Manager
ITEM 8B, Attachment 1
PROCLAMATION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF LOS ALTOS
HILLS PROCLAIMING THE EXISTENCE OF A LOCAL EMERGENCY
RELATING TO ANTICIPATED SEVERE WINTER STORMS ASSOCIATED WITH THE 2026–27 EL NIÑO SEASON
WHEREAS, Section 8630, Article 14, of the California Emergency Services Act empowers the City Council to proclaim the existence or threatened existence of a local emergency when the Town of Los Altos Hills is affected or likely to be affected by a public calamity; and WHEREAS, Chapter 4-1.05 of the Los Altos Hills Municipal Code establishes the powers and duties of the Director and Assistant Director of Emergency Services, including the responsibility to request that the City Council proclaim a local emergency when the governing body is in session; and
WHEREAS, the 2026–27 winter season is anticipated to bring El Niño-related weather conditions that may result in increased precipitation and severe winter storms throughout the San Francisco Bay Area, including Santa Clara County and the Town of Los Altos Hills; and WHEREAS, severe winter storm conditions may result in substantial rainfall, localized flooding, mudslides, debris flows, fallen trees, power outages, road closures, and other hazardous conditions that threaten public safety and property; and WHEREAS, the Town of Los Altos Hills, characterized by its hillside terrain, narrow roadways, and residential properties located in areas potentially susceptible to storm-related impacts, faces particular challenges in preparing for and responding to severe winter weather events; and WHEREAS, the Town has experienced significant impacts from previous winter storm events, including the severe storms of December 2022 and January and March 2023, which resulted in flooding, mudslides, fallen trees, roadway closures, and property damage, requiring activation of the Town's Emergency Operations Center and coordinated emergency response activities; and WHEREAS, anticipated winter storm conditions may create a threat to life and property within the Town of Los Altos Hills and may require additional services, personnel, equipment, and resources beyond those available through the Town's existing capabilities; and WHEREAS, the Town recognizes the importance of proactive emergency preparedness and coordination with regional, state, and federal agencies to protect residents, property, infrastructure, and essential Town operations; and
WHEREAS, the City Council finds that proclaiming a local emergency is warranted to establish an appropriate emergency management framework, facilitate coordination with other governmental agencies, and support the Town's ability to respond to potential injuries, property damage, and other impacts resulting from anticipated severe winter storm conditions.
Proclamation of Local Emergency
November 12, 2026
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the Town of Los Altos Hills hereby proclaims that:
1. The foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein by this reference.
2. Based on the anticipated severe winter storm conditions and the potential impacts to the Town of Los Altos Hills described above, the Town is likely to be affected by a public calamity.
3. A local emergency exists in the Town of Los Altos Hills.
4. During the existence of said local emergency, the powers, functions, and duties of the Director of Emergency Services and the Town's emergency organization shall be those prescribed by state law, local ordinance, the Town's Emergency Operations Plan, and applicable resolutions.
5. The Director of Emergency Services shall coordinate the Town's emergency preparedness and response activities and work with appropriate regional, state, and federal agencies to facilitate mutual aid, emergency assistance, and other available resources.
BE IT FURTHER PROCLAIMED that, as required by Government Code Section 8630, the City Council shall review the need for continuing the local emergency at least once every 60 days until the governing body terminates the local emergency, and shall proclaim the termination of the local emergency at the earliest possible date that conditions warrant.
BE IT FURTHER PROCLAIMED that during the existence of said local emergency, the powers, functions, and duties of the Director of Emergency Services and the Town’s emergency organization shall be those prescribed by state law, local ordinance, and resolutions.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this proclamation shall become effective immediately upon its adoption by the City Council and shall remain in effect until the City Council proclaims its termination.
Dated: November 12, 2026
Rajiv Bhateja
Mayor, Los Altos Hills