Cities Index.
Agenda packet, regular meeting, first session

los_altos_hills City Council
November 12, 2026

Document
Agenda packet, regular meeting, first session
Meeting
November 12, 2026
Body
los_altos_hills City Council
Pages
647
Original file
111.1 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on losaltoshillsca.api.civicclerk.com. That file is the official record.

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
3 As noted above, the city or county may approve uses on lands that are not classified as “prime farmlands”13 that do not meet compatibility principles due to onsite or offsite impacts, as long as the use is approved pursuant to a conditional use permit with mitigating measures imposed to comply with the foregoing principles as much as possible and to maintain consistency with the statute’s agricultural preservation purposes.14 However, the city or county cannot approve a residential subdivision that constitutes an incompatible use.15 Williamson Act Contracts
A city or county may enter into a contract pursuant to the Williamson Act for a property if (1) the property is located within an agricultural preserve, and (2) if the land is “devoted to agricultural use.”16 The terms of each contract may be different to reflect the location and characteristics of the land, subject to uniform compatibility rules adopted by the city or county.17 Statutory requirements for a Williamson Act contract are summarized below.

Topic Requirements
Contract
Formation
Every contract must contain the following:18
• Land must be within agricultural preserve and devoted to agricultural use • Allow only agricultural uses and uses compatible with agricultural uses, for the duration of the contract
• Runs with the land and binds all successors to land owner Term of
Contract
Contracts must have an initial term of at least 10 years; they are then renewed automatically for an additional year on each annual anniversary date of the contract, unless notice of non-renewal is given.19 20 Uses on
Contracted
Property
City Council must adopt rules about permitted uses/compatible uses on Williamson Act contracted lands. Uses must be compatible with three Compatibility Use principles set forth above unless the City Council makes findings stating otherwise. The statute considers solar, gas, electricity, water, communication, and farm housing uses to be compatible uses.21 Commercial agriculture is also permitted by statute as discussed above.

Subdivision
of Contract
Lands
Cities and counties must deny a tentative map or parcel map application if the land is under contract, and either (1) the resulting new parcels would be too small to sustain agricultural uses, or (2) the subdivision will result in residential development that is not “incidental” to the commercial agricultural use of the land.22
13 “Prime farmland” is defined by GC §51201(c) which, in simple terms, means properties that either are on specific resource conservation/soils rating classification lists, supports food-production livestock as defined by the federal Department of Agriculture, or that reaches a certain production value per acre from fruit trees, crops, or unprocessed agricultural plant products. 14 GC §51238.1(c)(1)-(4). 15 GC §51238.1(c)(4). 16 GC §§51240, 51242. 17 Id. 18 GC §51243. 19 GC §51244(a); County of Humboldt v. McKee (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1476 (Court holding that renewal means the parties enter into a new contract every year, subject to the regulations in effect at each renewal). 20 Prior to 2009, the Open Space Subvention Act of 1971 provided local governments with an annual state subvention payment to partially cover the loss of property tax revenue from enrolling properties under Williamson Act contracts. The term of a Williamson Act contract could be reduced to 9 years for contracts currently 10 years in length or 18 years for contracts currently 20 years in length, as the case may be. It is our understanding that no subvention has been paid since 2009, and thus this provision does not currently have much relevance. See also Department of Conservation FAQ at https://www.conservation.ca.gov/dlrp/wa/Documents/Williamson%20Act%20FAQ%202024.pdf 21 GC §§51231, 51238.1, 51238. 22 GC §66474.4; Cleveland Nat’l Forest Found. v County of San Diego (2019) 37 Cal.App.5th 1021.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 415 of 647 ends

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
4 Topic Requirements
Sale or
Transfer of
Property
Williamson Act contracts are binding on all successors in interest, including annexing jurisdictions.23 Transfer of ownership to spouse, children, parent or sibling is also permitted subject to compliance with certain conditions (statutory size requirements, zoning and local rules), and if the family member agrees to operate the land consistently with the contract).24 Terminating
the Contract
Terminating
the Contract
(cont’d)

There are a couple of ways in which a Williamson Act contract can end:

Non-Renewal (most common)25
Either the city/county or the land owner can serve a Notice of Non-Renewal. The land owner must serve at least 90 days prior to the next renewal date (anniversary of the contract), the government must serve at least 60 days before the renewal date. The property owner may serve a notice of non-renewal on a portion of the land under contract. The owner may also protest the city or county’s notice of nonrenewal; the city or county may withdraw its notice at any time prior to the renewal date. If the non-renewal notice is not withdrawn, the existing contract remains in effect for the remainder of its term from execution or the last renewal, as the case may be. (Section 51246(a).)26 At the end of that time period, the contract will be terminated.

Rescission27
The Williamson Act contract is removed upon mutual agreement so that the parties can simultaneously enter into a new contract, an open-space easement agreement, or a solar use easement for that same property, or an agricultural conservation easement for another property.

Cancellation28
This option is only available to the land owner, who must file a petition for cancellation. The city council may only grant tentative approval for cancelling a contract if it finds either that (1) the cancellation is consistent with the purposes of the Williamson Act (to make this finding, the council must make additional findings of compatibility), or (2) the cancellation is in the public interest. The city council must hold a noticed public hearing to consider the cancellation and provide notice to the state and the county. The land owner must submit an alternative proposal for the property’s use, and must pay a cancellation fee calculated by the county assessor’s office before the council can give final approval on the cancellation. 23 GC §51243. 24 GC §51230.1. 25 GC §51245.
26 GC §51246(a) provides in the context in non-renewal that, “the existing contract shall remain in effect for the balance for the period remaining since the original execution or the last renewal of the contract, as the case may be.” This language is subject to interpretation in such a manner as to mean that if the original term of the contract has already expired then the remainder of the term would only be the one-year renewal period. Alternatively, the view acknowledged in some case law is that the remaining period would be for ten years as the original ten-year contract had renewed automatically every year prior to that on an annual basis. The Department of Conservation guidelines reflect the second interpretation and that interpretation is also consistent with dicta in Sierra Club vs. City of Hayward, a 1971 California appellate court decision. While we are still researching more recent case law and attorney general opinions on this issue, we do believe that the reasonable interpretation is that the notice of non-renewal commences a ten-year time period for termination of the contract. 27 GC §§51254-51256. 28 GC §§51280-51287.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 416 of 647 ends

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
5 Topic Requirements
Eminent Domain29
The land under contract may be acquired by a public agency through eminent domain. In such situations, the contract would be voided. The public agency would still be required to make certain findings in order to make public improvements on lands within agricultural preserves.

Breach of
Contract
A breach of Williamson Contract occurs when both of the following are true:
30 (1) A commercial, industrial or residential building unrelated to an agricultural or compatible use is built against local compatibility rules (excluding buildings that were constructed or that received a building permit prior to 1/1/2004; a building that only became incompatible because of a change in the law; or a state-owned building); and (2) The total area of all the building(s) exceeds 2,500 square feet.

If a potential breach is discovered, the city would need to provide notice to the landowner and hold a noticed public hearing, to provide the owner with the opportunity to cure the breach. If the breach is not cured, there will be a fine of 25% of the market value of the portion of land with the incompatible uses, plus 25% of the value of the incompatible building and improvements. These values will be determined by independent appraisal. The penalty would be secured by a lien on the property.31
Property Tax Assessment for Lands Under Contract32
Properties under Williamson Act contracts are valued based on their “capitalization of income” rather on the market value/sale of the land as taxes are normally assessed under Proposition 13. 33 Specifically, the county
assessor’s office determines the property’s annual income based on market data of how much revenue the land can generate based on the type of agricultural use being operated (for example, grazing, fruit trees, plantings), all expenditures, and any land rent if applicable.34 The net income is capitalized based on a formula comprised of interests, risk factors, property taxes, and amortization, to arrive at the parcel’s assessment value under the Williamson Act.
35 The assessor’s office compares this Williamson Act valuation against the property’s Prop 13 valuation and enroll the lowest of the two.36
Not every property under contract can fully benefit from the reduced tax assessment described above. Notably, the Williamson Act tax assessment method does not apply to any residence (including agricultural housing) on a land under contract, nor does it apply to a “home site”—an area of “reasonable size” used as a residence site on the contracted land.37 We understand that the County of Santa Clara has determined that properties that are one acre or less are treated as “homesites”. Additionally, any existing improvements and new construction on contracted lands are assessed under Prop 13 just like any other parcel not under a Williamson Act contract.38 29 GC §§51290-51295. 30 GC §51250. 31 GC §51250 (e)-(o). 32 In addition to reviewing relevant state law, staff also reached out to the Santa Clara County Assessor’s Office to confirm that the Williamson Act calculation and assessment method described in this section is accurate. The Assessor’s Office confirmed via email on August 8, 2026 to staff that this methodology description is correct. 33 Revenue and Taxation Code (RTC) §§421-423. Proposition 13 is codified at Article XIIIA of the California Constitution. 34 RTC §423. 35 RTC §423(b). 36 Per communication with the County Assessor’s Office. Also, RTC §423(d) provides that the Williamson Act valuation amount cannot exceed the valuation determined pursuant to Prop 13 provisions (i.e. how property tax is assessed for all properties not subject to a land conservation contract). 37 RTC §428. 38 RTC §§51, 70. See also Santa Clara County Assessor’s Office information at https://asr.santaclaracounty.gov/tax-savings/tax-reductions/farmers-and-ranchers Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 417 of 647 ends

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
6 In other words, “improvements” on Williamson Act lands are assessed in the same way as those on non-contracted lands without the favorable tax treatment.39

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
This section of the memo answers several questions raised during the hearing process including how the Williamson Act contract limits the use and development of a property.

Is a property under Williamson Act contract required to pursue agricultural uses or can the property owner undertake a compatible use only?
There is no specific requirement under the Williamson Act statute, but local governments may establish compatible use rules to regulate this issue. To be eligible for a Williamson Act contract, a property must be located within an agricultural preserve and be “devoted to agricultural use” which means commercial agriculture. The contract shall exclude all uses “other than agricultural, and other than those compatible with agricultural uses” for the life of the contract. Accordingly, a property under contract may only be developed with commercial agricultural uses and uses compatible therewith. However, state law does not further specify whether the property can only contain compatible uses, or whether commercial agriculture is required to be pursued with any compatible uses. As required by Government Code sections 51231 and 51238.1, the local government is tasked with establishing compatible uses and how those uses may be carried out on contracted lands.

As noted above in Footnote 5, City Council Resolution No. 616 established the procedures and requirements for creating an agricultural preserve and entering into Williamson Act contracts. Section 9 of that resolution states “uses which are considered ‘compatible’ (as defined in the Williamson Act) include permitted uses in any zoning district as set forth in Ordinance No. 78, the Zoning Ordinance of the Town of Los Altos Hills, as amended, and which are designated in contracts entered into pursuant to the Act.” This section and the resolution does not further specify additional use distribution or occupancy percentages on contract lands.

Based on our review of the statute and Resolution No. 616, it appears that if a property is restricted under contract to commercial agriculture and compatible uses, it will meet Williamson Act requirements and may carry out any of those uses permitted under the contract. Resolution No. 616 specifies that uses permitted within agricultural preserves are those allowed by the zoning code—which specifically includes residential and agriculture—and those designated under contract. This language does not specify the order in which these uses must be undertaken or whether they must proceed concurrently or separately. The resolution is consistent with the statutory text that uses within preserve areas and on contracted lands be restricted to agriculture and compatible uses. Thus, to illustrate, a property owner can execute a Williamson Act contract for a vacant property even though commercial agricultural activities have yet to take place. If the contract provides that open space uses are compatible with agriculture, that vacant parcel will continue to satisfy its contractual obligations if it remains open space even without agricultural activities. 40 The Town can resolve this statutory
ambiguity by adopting local compatible use rules to address the issue.

Does agricultural use have to be a “principal use” or “primary use” on a contracted parcel? The Williamson Act statute does not specify agriculture must be a “principal” or “primary” use generally, nor 39 Id. 40 See, for example, the County of San Luis Obispo Assessor’s Office illustrating how a 160-acre vacant dry farm property may be assessed under Williamson Act contract (https://www.slocounty.ca.gov/departments/assessor/forms-documents/assessor-s-office-pamphlets/land-conservation-act-properties-(williamson-act). Tax assessment is a separate issue from which uses or permitted uses can occur on the parcel.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 418 of 647 ends

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
7 does it require a specific percentage of agricultural uses. It also does not define what a primary or principal use means. As noted above, Resolution No. 616 also does not contain such a requirement. Thus, this question appears to be one where the Town needs to regulate how compatible uses may be carried out on contracted lands. In Los Altos Hills, the Town has not adopted any rules regarding principal/primary uses or the percentage threshold of uses on contract lands.41
We are aware that several public comments cited to a 1979 Attorney General Opinion out of Santa Clara County (62 Ops. Cal. Atty. Gen. 233) and Cleveland Nat’l Forest Found. v County of San Diego (2019) for the argument that residential uses must be “incidental” to a primary agricultural use. It is important to clarify that the Attorney General Opinion and Cleveland pertain to approval of subdivisions on Williamson Act contract lands, where Government Code section 66474.4 specifically requires the Town to deny a tentative map if the subdivision will result in residential development not incidental to the land’s commercial agricultural use.

Further, the Santa Clara County Williamson Act contract that is the subject of the Attorney General Opinion required single family dwellings be “incidental” to agriculture in order to be considered a compatible use.42 Similarly, other public comments cited to Government Code section 51250 stating that residential buildings on contracted lands cannot exceed 2,500 square feet. It is also important to clarify that Section 51250 pertains to commercial, industrial, or residential buildings that are not allowed by state law or the contract, local uniform rules or ordinance consistent with the Williamson Act, and that is unrelated to an agricultural or compatible use. This statute merely describes what constitutes a breach of contract when the type of building is not permitted by contract. It does not establish a blanket square footage standard to determine whether residential uses would be compatible. Such compatibility, again, must be established by local rules and by contract.

It should be noted that the Town may take these legal principles into account when establishing compatible use regulations, such as requiring certain uses to be incidental to commercial agriculture or to require a specific percentage of agricultural or compatible uses on contracted lands.

Does a property owner need to cancel or terminate a Williamson Act contract before developing the property?
No. Properties under contract may develop uses that are compatible with commercial agriculture, as specified in the contract, without terminating the contract. Either the Town or the property owner have the ability to serve a notice not to renew the contract, or the land owner may petition the Town to cancel the contract, but there is no requirement to do so as a condition to develop the property consistent with contract provisions.

What are the compatibility rules for Williamson Act contract properties in Los Altos Hills? Resolution No. 616 established compatible uses for agricultural and open space preserves within Los Altos Hills, as described above, which specifies that uses “designated in Williamson Act contracts” are considered compatible uses in the preserve area. The Town has not formally adopted any additional compatibility use rules for contracted lands. Thus, the compatible uses are governed on a case-by-case basis by each contract for individual properties under Williamson Act contracts. Based on staff’s review, it appears that Williamson Act contracts previously executed in Los Altos Hills all utilize the same template or similar templates stating that agriculture, open space, primary and secondary dwellings, churches, and recreational facilities are compatible 41 As set forth above, the entire Town was previously established as an agricultural preserve. The Town’s zoning code specifies that primary uses permitted in the R-A zoning district include primary dwellings and agriculture. Thus, although not directly relevant to lands under Williamson Act contracts, it is worth considering that the base agricultural preserve rules considers residential a primary use.
42 See 62 Ops. Cal. Atty. Gen. 233 footnote 2 https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/opinions/pdfs/79-309.pdf Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 419 of 647 ends

Williamson Act Overview
October 1, 2026
8 uses.

Does the County of Santa Clara compatibility rules for Williamson Act apply to Los Altos Hills? No. The Williamson Act statute provides that the city or county has the authority to establish an agricultural preserve and requires them to establish rules governing the preserve(s) as well as compatibility uses. Because the statute imposes the requirement on “cities and counties” and references the city councils and boards of supervisors making findings, the cities and counties would have to establish rules governing the preserves within their jurisdictions. Additionally, under general rules of sovereignty, city and county zoning regulations do not apply to lands within each other’s jurisdiction. With that said, the Town is not prohibited from considering the County’s rules as examples or incorporate them when adopting compatibility rules for Williamson Act contracts.

How is property tax calculated for a partially developed Williamson Act property? A concise way to describe the tax assessment is that the Williamson Act values would be calculated using land rents and other market data for different types of agricultural uses (depending on the type of use). Using this information, the County Assessor’s office would establish an income dollar figure and use that income number, plus other economic factors and capitalization, to determine what the land is worth—its assessed value—under Williamson Act contract. If the property is being used for residential (i.e. a home site), the buildings would be valued under Prop 13 rules. The Assessor’s Office then determines what the Prop 13 value of the land would be and compares said value against the Williamson Act value. The lower of the two values would be included on the tax roll. The County Assessor’s Office has confirmed by email to staff that the foregoing correctly describes the assessment method.

How is property tax calculated if the contract is not renewed? If the landowner gives notice, or if the Town gives notice and the owner does not protest, the property is to be valued thereafter as if the Williamson Act restriction has been removed from the property. If the Town gives notice and the landowner protests the Town’s action, the Williamson Act restriction continues through the first five years of nonrenewal period; i.e., it will be valued as if the notice had not been given. In the final five years of nonrenewal period, the property will be valued as if the enforceable restriction has been removed.

Does residential development on a parcel that is subject to a Williamson Act contract benefit from lower taxes under the Williamson Act?
No. Pursuant to Revenue and Taxation Code section 428, the Williamson Act tax assessment (which results in the lower tax rate) does not apply to any residence or any homesite (an area of reasonable size used as a residence site) and structures on Williamson Act parcels are still valued under Prop 13 rules. The size of a homesite utilized by the Santa Clara County Assessor’s Office is 1 acre. The Assessors’ Office communicated via email to staff that if a parcel is only 1.16 acres, the entire value of the parcel would be as a homesite and there would not be Williamson Act tax reductions.43
If you have any questions regarding the information presented in this memo, please contact Steve or Claire. 43 Email from County Assessor’s Office dated August 28, 2026.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 1

Page 420 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 421 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 422 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 423 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 424 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 425 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 6

Page 426 of 647 ends
Page 427 of 647 ends

ITEM 3.3 Attachment 5
GI PL кос!
4184845 4184845
00SG те: 528
s00л 3586 :* 528 ORD
FECH
› Esty For atte
*JAN 31 323 PH PH.1?2
CPriCiAL

NO FEE SANTA CLARA COUNTY
FOWLES
GEORGE

LAND CONSERVATION CONTRACT
Ihis 1s an agreement between the Iown of Los Altos Hille, State of California (hexeinafter called "Town"), and
Leroy M. humbard and Barbara A. Lumbard
(hereinatter called "owner").

WHErnS, Orner possessos certain 10ul property located within the Iown ..OE Los Altos Hll1a, County of Santa Clara, State of california, rhich is prasently devoted to agricultural uns and is described in Exhibit B attached hereto and made a part hereof, and
WHERBAS, the property da located in an agxicultural presoxve heretofore antablished by the Iown; and
WHEREAS, both Owner and town deere to limit the und at the propexty to agricultuxal and compatibio uses; and
WHEREAS, the parties have determined that the highest and best use 202 she property duxing the taxi of tile contriot, us any reneral aberao, alail be zor agricultural puxposas=
NOM, THEREFORE, Iown and Ornex agise as {o11omas

2. CONTIACE SUBJECT TO CALIRORNTA LAND. CONSERVATION ACE OF 1965 This contreet le miered into pursuent to Chapter ? (conneneing === section 51200) 01 Paxt 1, Divinion I, Iftle 5 of the Governaent Code, Which 19 known as the California land Convervation Act aé 1905. Inta contzact da- ouisinui to ali aé she-provfelona of enLa Act-Including St emenon enge thereto =hich may hereafter be enacted..

2. *ESTRICTION ON USE OF PROPERTY
During the ters of thie contract, and any and all enemale thereot, the property described in Exhibit & sheil not is used by omer, or omerie successore in interest, fox any puxpose other than tha prodiction of agricultural compoditles fox commercial puipcres and unes compatibie thereto.

A 11. of all such compatible unas la net forth in Fuhlbl: 4, attached herot -and by inde raterence incomparatad harain. Town. by Oxirance acopieri by 41:0-1515 JANS 1 1C72
#72.903
= Page 428 of 647
ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5

GI IPLI
e0 2096 o20
*hs City Couneil of the town, ay free time to time during the term of this contract and all renewals thereof, add to the list of compatible uses which shall be unifor throughout the agricultural preserve in which the property in Exhibit B is located; provided, howevex, Iown may not during the tera of this contract ox any renewai thereof, without the prior written consent of dunes, lemoye any of the compatible uses for the subject property which are set forth in Duhibit A. The provisions of this contract and any Ordinence supplementing the list of compatible uses are not intended to limit ox supox» sade the plarining and zoning powexs of own.

3. TERM OF CONTRACT
This contract shall becone effective on the date of execution and shall remain in full force and effect for an ititial tern of ten years. The instial texa of ten years shall be maasured comencing as of the first day ot January next succoading the date or execution It the date of execution is betweer Maxch 2 and Decerber 31. Ihe initíal tein cf ten years shall be measured commencing as of the fixst day of January of the year of execution If the date of mecution lo betveen Januazy 1 and Maxon 1. Mach aucoeeding firat day of januy isi to tsad to be the anzusi zenrai vete of thie- contract: Ihle contract ahell be xenamed on each aucceeding January 1 and one additional mar chail bo addas automationity to the lodital tore mizero notior of nonionanal to Divan da providad la paragraph 4,

4. NOTOS 02. N0
(ay It asthax party deotren in any yoat not to taron this contraot, that party asall surve aritten natios of nonzeneral upon the othex paxty in advance of the annual renewal date of this contract. Uniors such written notice of nonsenema ii served by omar as idas= 00 days pilos to the senamal data, or Si tom as Ieass so days palo= de sha =eneral diso, the canteet 7. sheil be considered renewed as provides in pazegreph a above. (b) Is esthex party sorves wiltton notice ne houreneval in any year within the time Ilatte ef (a) above, this contract chall cesain in affect I0s the balanco el the period 1 razaining since the oxiginal erecution ox the JAN:

Page 429 of 647 ends

ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5
IGI PL
1800 S096.-: 530
5c NO COMPENSATION
amer sh"11 not receive any payment from Iown in considezation of the obligations imposed undar this contract, it being recognized and agreed that the consideration for the evocution of this contract is the substantial benefit to be derived thexefrom, and the advantage that may accrue to Ownex as a result si the-effect-upon the assessed value of the pronarty an account... of the restrictions on the use of the propexty contained herein. -6.= SUCCESSORS IN INTEREST
This contract and the-restrictions imposed hexeunder shall be binding upon, and Inure to the benefit of, the successors in interest of the Ornex.

Whenever any of the property described in Exhibit B is divided, the omnex of any parcel may exercise, independent of any other omex of à portion tí the divided property, any of the iights of the orner in this contract, Including the right to give notice of nonrenewal and to petition fox cancellation.

The effect of any suck action by the orner of a parcel created by the division of land described in Echibit 8 shall not be Imputed to the omexs of the remaining parcels and shall have no situot on this contract e:it app11eu to the remining parcelo of the divided property.

7. CANORLLATION
Ihie contract ay be cancelled and a cancellation too laposed pursueat to the proviniona of the laid conservatica Act of 1965.

8. NOTICES
= All notloes required ox permitted by shit consciot, ladlusing notice of:
"e crange of saarini, shall ba in wilting and diven by personal delivery or sent by United States Mall addreses to the party intancad to be notifiad.

Notice shall be deariad given an of the dato of. delivory In porson ox so or sha sate then departed in any pert office OF ANY PORT OFFiON LE maintained by tie Unised States Governsent.
- Notice to the Town shall be addreesed:
m→ City Clerk
26375 Fresont Road
Los Altos Hilla, Calltornia 94027
Notice to Omox shall be addresead:

Han: I0t05 H
Addres: 23027 la Parranea way, Los Alias
City and State Lip Code
980-1515 JAN 31 1977

Page 430 of 647 ends

ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5

GI PL KOC
Ro 30S6:1531
- IN WITNESS WUDDOO the putties hazato hava caused into contiact to in executed: by Oner on September 27.197L and by Town on

IONN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
C Late
Mayor
TIEST:

TBD
city Ca

PRIED AS ZO PORMI
91015.15 JAN 31 972

Page 431 of 647 ends

ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5
GI PLI koc!
=-),

BXHIBIT A

LAND CONSERVATION CONTRACT

COMPATIBLE USES
Ina following is a list of land uses determined to be compatible with the agricultural use of the land subject to thie agreement:

1. Agriculture, including but not limited to horticulture and grazing
Foxeet preserves

3. Open apace uses

4. Primary dezzinos
50 secondary smellinge

6. Churches
70 recreational Zealastias
80 Nureerios.

9. Private schoole

10. Publio utiliiy and assvion unas
11- Petuate and meneratel stable
EXHIBIT A 245a15

Page 432 of 647 ends

ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5
GI PL koc
•: 9??

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

88. COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA
On this day of before me,
the undersigned. a Notary Public in and for the state of California with principal office in the County of Santa Clara, residing therein, duly commissioned and sworn.
personally appeared
nown to me tò be the
the corporation that
executed the within instrument; and known to me to be the person who executed the within instrument on behalf of the corporation therein named, and acknowledged to. me that such corporation executed the same pursuant to its By-Laws or a resolution of the Board of Directors.
• I have hereunto Bet my hand
first above written.

Rotary Fusile In and ter the
gtate of california

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF BANTA CLARA Y
on betore
the Indey nator the state of
Notar!
california with principat office in the County of Santa Clara, caulding thereia.
personally anyone and wor
Known to me
the within instrumant. and acknowledged
that they executeă the sane.
saunter it Chis certionto
wtittan.
mances 'M." MUNZELE
Foiney
#y ter Morch 4. 1978
1151515

Page 433 of 647 ends

ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5

GI IPLI
A Poley
eo0 30S6 0634

SCHEDULE C
California • County
The land referred to in this policy is situated in the saad is described 1a follows:
of Santa Clara, City of Town of /
Los Altos 1111s,
Lot 3 of Tract lio. '3924, a resubalriston in Biüin I of 2842 Fremont 11115 Unit the Map of which Tract No. 3924 va8 Pract
November 15, 1965 in Book 202 of Maps, page 22, Santa Clara County Assesson's Pancel No. 182-5-34
9231915 JAN 2: 9%
- Page 434 of 647
ITEM 2.3 Attachment 5
GI PLI 1 oci
3 -...
3 MA - 517111
- y 2:92
cas
Y• 12192: 14523510
TR. Nº 3924 EE

72.50. ELENA 1.108 As! SCA
1,633A
22 JUNIPERO *KORD OF SURVEY:

SERRA FREEWAY
4151945 JAN 311972

Page 435 of 647 ends

ITEM 3.3 Attachment 7
Outlook
Re: Williamson Act Santa Clara County
From Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]> Date Wed 9/9/2026 12:00 PM
To Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Jay.

I responded to your questions below (in-line). Hope this helps and hope to see you tomorrow.

Farl Grundy
Associate Environmental Planner
Division of Land Resource Protection
Williamson Act / CEQA
California Department of Conservation
715 P Street, MS 1904
Sacramento, CA, 95814
E: Farl. [email protected]
T: (916) 279-2535
flyl
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This communication and any files transmitted with it are intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. This message contains information, which may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information may be prohibited. Repeated e-mail transmissions cannot be guaranteed to be secured or error-free, as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete. The sender therefore does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of repeated e-mail transmissions.

From: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2026 1:59 PM
To: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Williamson Act Santa Clara County
Farl,
Per our correspondence last week, the Town is requesting guidance regarding Williamson Act (Government Code Section 51200 et seq.) compatibility, annual renewal, and nonrenewal.

Where possible, please identify the applicable Government Code provisions or Department guidance.

Page 436 of 647 ends

1. The Town is authorized to adopt and apply compatibility standalds pusualtashment 7 Government Code §§51230, 51232 - 51236. When a residential project is proposed in the Town on property that is subject to an existing Williamson Act contract, are there any additional state law requirements that the Town should consider in determining whether a proposed project is consistent with an existing Williamson Act contract? If so, please identify the additional state law requirements that apply in addition to Town adopted compatibility standards?
It is ultimately the City, and the City alone, that would determine a project's compatibility with related Williamson Act Government Code, existing Town Williamson Act rules and regulations, and any current contract provisions. However, the Town may wish to consult the following Government Code (GC) Sections.

GC Section 51250: which specifically speaks to a material breach of contract involving commercial, industrial, or residential buildings.

GC Section 51222: which speaks to the size of WA contracts.

GC section 51238.1(c)(4): which speaks to Compatibility.

GC section 66474.4(a): which speaks to subdivision.

2. Do state law provisions control the compatibility analysis, or may the Town apply its locally adopted compatibility standards and the terms of the applicable Williamson Act contract assuming they are consistent with state law?
Yes, participating jurisdictions are required to establish their own set of local rules and regulations for implementation of the Act, and those rules can and should include compatible uses which are consistent with the overarching Williamson Act related Government Codes.

3. Does State law require agricultural or commercial agricultural use to remain the primary use of Williamson Act property? If so, does the state have standards or guidelines for determining how primary use should be calculated?
Not necessarily. There are other land uses that may be considered the primary land use, and in turn, be eligible for contract. If the original contract stated that the contracted land should remain under agricultural use, and the landowner wishes to change that land use it would be up to the jurisdiction to approval the proposed land use change. If approved, the jurisdiction should rescind and reenter into a new contract stating the new required land use/s. The participating jurisdiction may require contracted landowner to submit information enabling it to determine the eligibility of the contracted land (GC Section 51247)_
GC Section 51205: speaks to different land types available for contract GC Section 51240: authority to contract
GC Section 51254: rescind and reenter

4. If the Town determines that a proposed or actual use is not compatible, what options are available to the Town? Does an incompatibility determination require issuance of a nonrenewal? Does state law provide any additional remedies the Town can impose beyond a notice of nonrenewal?
If a land use is determined to be incompatible, a jurisdiction would typically discuss that use with the landowner and either change the land use to something that is

Page 437 of 647 ends

ITEM 3.3 Attachment 7
compatible or place the property in nonrenewal. If the land use is Altaslygent 7 "material breach" the jurisdiction would proceed according to GC Section 51250.

5. If the Town were to adopt new compatibility standards, would state law allow the Town to apply those new standards at the time at the time of contract renewal or must the Town first issue a notice of non-renewal and the enter into a new contract at the end of the current contract term?
In order for the Town to implement the new compatibility standards, the town would need to rescind and reenter into new contracts; otherwise, a landowner could use GC section 51238.3 to continued compatible uses established at the time the contract was originally signed.

6. Under state law what circumstances may the Town initiate nonrenewal of a Williamson Act contract?
GC Section 51245: speaks to the notice of nonrenewal and does not place restrictions on the participating jurisdiction's ability to serve a notice of nonrenewal.

7. Under state law, what notice, timing, hearing, and other procedural requirements apply when the Town initiates nonrenewal?
GC Section 51236: removal of land from an agricultural preserve.

GC Section 51245: notice of nonrenewal.

Please let me know if you need me to clarify any of our questions.

LOS ALTOS HILIS Jay Bradford, AICP, CASp, EI, MCP
Community Development Director
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
CALIFORNIA P: 650-559-2244| F: 650-941-3160
E: [email protected]
From: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>

Page 438 of 647 ends

PNQILI
TNQOGV
XNOHOR
TNQOGV
_LIIKRL
_LIIKRL
NGPLSI
MLULGL
_LIIKRL
GPHI _LIIKRL
]ULKIL
ILOMLS
SLGQSO
ITEM 3.3 Attachment 8
Outlook
RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
From Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/9/2026 1:22 PM
To Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
It is based on houses on agricultural land in our county and takes into account zoning and setbacks. The R&T code does not specify a definite size and it is left to each county to determine the homesite size.

Sincerely,
Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 le: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org.

How was my service? Click here for survey. Thank you!
NOTICE: This email message and/or its attachments may contain information that is confidential or restricted. It is intended only for the individuals named as recipients in the message. If you are NOT an authorized recipient, you are prohibited from using, delivering, distributing, printing, copying, or disclosing the message or content to others and must delete the message from your computer. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by return mail.

From: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, August 31, 2026 1:56 PM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Thanks very much Matt!
Why does the County use a 1 acre standard for a home site? Jonathan Fox, AICP
Senior Planner
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
P: 650-559-2243 | F: 650-941-3160
E: [email protected]
Stay informed.

Take the Community Development Feedback Survey.

Schedule a Meeting with Community Development Staff

Page 439 of 647 ends

ITEM 3.3 Attachment 8
From: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Sent: Friday, August 28, 2026 11:14 AM
To: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
Hello Jonathan,
This is correct. No structures are covered under the Williamson Act and would be valued at their normal Prop 13 value. If there is a home, the county uses a 1 acre homesite for that home that is not covered under the Williamson Act. Since this parcel is only 1.16 acres, the entire value of the parcel would be as a homesite and there would no longer be any Williamson Act reduction.

Let me know if you have any further questions.

Sincerely,
Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 le: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org.

How was my service? Click here for survey. Thank you!
NOTICE: This email message and/or its attachments may contain information that is confidential or restricted. It is intended only for the individuals named as recipients in the message. If you are NOT an authorized recipient, you are prohibited from using, delivering, distributing, printing, copying, or disclosing the message or content to others and must delete the message from your computer. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by return mail.

From: Jonathan Fox < [email protected]>
Sent: Friday, August 28, 2026 11:04 AM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Good morning Matt,
Staff has reviewed tax assessment information that's available on the county assessor's website and also researching other guidelines. Our understanding is that a Williamson Act contract parcel would be assessed for tax purposes in the following manner:

The Williamson Act values would be calculated using land rents and other market data for different types of agricultural uses (depending on the type of use). Using this information, the County would establish an income dollar figure and use that income number, plus other economic factors and capitalization, to determine what the land is worth—its assessed value-under Williamson Act contract. If the property is being used for residential (i.e. a home site), the buildings would be valued under Prop 13 rules. Then the County would determine what the Prop 13 value of the land would be, and then comparing it against the Williamson Act value. The lower of the two values would be included on the tax roll.

Can you confirm this is generally consistent with the approach that County Assessor uses in assessing the property tax for Williamson Act properties? Including this La Barranca parcel (APN 182-05-034)? We are aware that Revenue and Taxation Code section 428 provides that the assessment approach for lands under open space and agricultural contracts do not apply to any residence, including any agricultural laborer housing facility, on the land

Page 440 of 647 ends

ITEM 3.3 Attachment 8
being valued or to an area of reasonable size used as a site for such a residence, büt would appreciate you can confirm this is the reason a property being used as a homesite would be assessed per its Prop 13 value.

We're looking to get a better understanding of the process in preparation for an upcoming public hearing.

Thank you,
Jonathan Fox, AICP
Senior Planner
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
P: 650-559-2243 | F: 650-941-3160
E: [email protected]
Stay informed.

Take the Community Development Feedback Survey.

Schedule a Meeting with Community Development Staff

Page 441 of 647 ends

Farming Operation & Business Plan at APN 182-05-034
La Barranca Rd, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
We are the owners of the above open-land property, currently operating a small farming business Scripps Farms (https://www.scrippsfarms.com). Our plan is to establish this farm in the greenhouse after moving to the above location. As the following details will show, this plan includes growing vegetable and specialty potted plants in approximately 14 x 21 sq. ft. of the green house.

The uniqueness of our farming plan arises from the motivation to support healthy living of the communities near and far by offering ready-to-grow-in-your-backyard potted plants and high-quality eggs. We strongly believe in the saying “we are what we eat” and our plan offers ultimate freedom to the working families in several things: choice, freshness, taste, quality, happiness and finally satisfaction of growing their own food – worry free.

Potted Plants Operation
We will grow both vegetable plants and specialty potted plants using organic seeds sourced from the highly trusted vendors across the nation (Kitazawa Seed Company and Eden Brothers). All the plants will be started in propagation module trays through manual or automated seeding for germination in early December and then transplanted into gallon sized pots in early March, all situated within the greenhouse. Typical vegetable plants include peppers, tomatoes and spinach.

Specialty plants include curry leaf, neem, moringa and Arabian jasmine. Plants will be sold online through the existing website (https://www.scrippsfarms.com).

Chicken Eggs
Chicken eggs will be a limited operation - we plan to raise a small number of chickens (no roosters) in a section of the greenhouse (14 x 14 sq. ft). Eggs will be sold online alongside the potted plants or at local grocery stores through arrangement.

No foot traffic is expected related to this operation, which will be fully managed online. nn
Naveen Vangala &
Shalini Tokala
Los Altos Hills, 07/01/2026

Page 442 of 647 ends

TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS
CALCULATIONS BY LEA & BRAZE ENGINEERING (510) 887-4086
WORKSHEET #1

CALCULATION OF AVERAGE SLOPE, LOT UNIT FACTOR (LUF)

MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT AREA (MDA), AND MAXIMUM FLOOR AREA (MFA) PROPERTY OWNER(S) Naveen Vangala
PROPERTY ADDRESS 0 La Barranca Road
CALCULATED BY G. Mejia DATE
REFERENCE MAP: Survey by MACLEOD AND ASSOCIATES Job #4823-TOPO JOB#

1. CALCULATION OF AVERAGE SLOPE (BASED ON EXISTING CONTOURS) (PAVED AREA WITHIN INGRESS/EGRESS EASEMENTS EXCLUDED FROM CALCULATIONS) GROSS AREA = 50,717.60 SQFT. = 1.164 ACRES
PAVED AREA WITHIN EASEMENT = 0.00 SQFT. = 0.000 ACRES
NET AREA = 50,717.60 SQFT. = 1.164 ACRES
A. NET AREA (An) 1.164 ACRES B. CONTOUR INTERVAL (I) 2 ft.

C. DRAWING SCALE 1'' = 16'
D. CONTOUR LENGTH WITHIN NET AREA OF LOT (An)

CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH (FEET) (FEET) (FEET) (FEET)
410 6 446 385 482 45 518
412 12 448 383 484 520
414 19 450 365 486 522
416 40 452 354 488 524
418 62 454 342 490 526
420 84 456 332 492 528
422 107 458 323 494 530
424 133 460 318 496 532
426 162 462 319 498 534
428 192 464 303 500 536
430 231 466 284 502 538
432 293 468 267 504 540
434 420 470 248 506 542
436 418 472 223 508 544
438 410 474 196 510 546
440 400 476 170 512 548
442 391 478 142 514 550
444 384 480 104 516 552
TOTAL 8,865
E. AVERAGE SLOPE WITHIN NET AREA OF LOT ##########
S= (0.0023) (2.0 FT) (8865 FT) = 35.0%
(1.164) ##########

2. CALCULATION OF LOT UNIT FACTOR (LUF)
LUF = (An){1-[0.02143(S-10)]} = 0.540

0.54 3. CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT AREA (MDA)
MDA= 7,500 SQUARE FEET

4. CALCULATION FOR MAXIMUM FLOOR AREA (MFA)
MFA= 5,000 SQUARE FEET
Note 1: If the slope is less than 10%, the LUF for the lot is equal to the net area.

Note 2: If the LUF is greater than 0.5, The MDA is 7,500ft 2 (minimum).

If the LUF is greater than, or equal to, 0.5, The MFA is 5,000ft 2 (minimum).

Note 3: If the LUF is equal to or less than .50, you will need a conditional development permit.

A variance is required for development area greater than 4,500 square feet.

A variance is required for floor area greater than 2,500 square feet.

Make an appointment with the Town Planner for further information.

TOWN USE ONLY CHECKED BY: DATE:
04/16/25
2240057

Page 443 of 647 ends

Page | 6 2022-08-01
Worksheet #2
Existing and Proposed Development Area and Floor Area
Submit with Application
Property Owner’s Name:

Property Address:

Calculated By: Date:

1. DEVELOPMENT AREA
Existing Proposed DA Credit Total
A. House and Garage from part 2.A N/A
B. Accessory Dwelling Unit from part 2.B 800
C. Accessory Building from part 2.C N/A
D. Driveway, Turnaround, and Parking
E. Patios and Walkways
F. Recreation Court N/A
G. Pool and Pool Decking
H. Decks N/A
I. Solar Panels (ground mounted)
J. Any Other Coverage
TOTALS
MDA from Worksheet #1

2. FLOOR AREA
Existing Proposed FA Credit Total
A. House and Garage
a. First Floor
b. Second Floor
c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202)
d. Garage
e. Area Over 17 ft (LAHMC 10-1.202)
f. Attic Over 7 ft (LAHMC 10-1.202)
B. Accessory Dwelling Unit (800 credit) 800
C. Accessory Buildings
a. First Floor
b. Second Floor
c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202)
d. Attic
TOTALS
MFA from Worksheet #1
Town Use Only
Checked By: Date:
793 900 Naveen Vangala 0 La Barranca Road Lea & Braze Engineering, Inc. 07-07-20264,584 0 99 1,016 0
0 0
0 0
0 2,709 546 3526 512 995000 0
0 0
0 160
0 840
361 461 4,584 793 999 2,714 549 0
0 (84) 0
188 9,742 1,698 565 0
0 549 7,495 7500 0
0 0
0 0
0 546 3526 512 0
0 0
0 0
0 999 6,376
793
4,683 793 793 900 900 Page 444 of 647

TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS

MEMORANDUM
DATE: October 1, 2026
TO: Honorable Chair and Members of the Commission
FROM: Jonathan Fox, Senior Planner
RE: Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) – File #SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 – Lands of Vangala & Tokala
Supplemental Findings Supporting Class 3 Exemption
To further support the Town’s determination that the project qualifies for a Class 3 categorical exemption under CEQA Guidelines Section 15303(a), the Town reviewed the following:
• Recent hillside approvals. Recent Town approvals for hillside projects demonstrate that similar amounts of floor area, grading, driveway widths, and tree removals are typical of hillside development in the Town and are not unusual project characteristics. • Important Farmland. The project parcel is not identified as Important Farmland on the applicable Important Farmland map.
• Sensitive habitat. No officially mapped sensitive habitat covers the project site.

Based on this review, the Town finds that the project does not involve unusual circumstances or occur within an officially mapped sensitive resource area that would preclude reliance on the Class 3 exemption under CEQA Guidelines Section 15303(a).

ITEM 3.3 Supplemental 7

Page 445 of 647 ends

Hanson Bridgett LLP
500 Capitol Mall, Suite 1500, Sacramento, CA 95814
CHRISTOPHER L. POWELL

PARTNER
DIRECT DIAL (916) 551-2804
E-MAIL [email protected]
November 5, 2026
VIA EMAIL AND U.S. MAIL
Honorable Mayor and Members of the Town Council
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, California 94022
Re: Objection to Proposed Williamson Act Compatibility Determination and Related Entitlements — Unaddressed La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala, APN 182-05-034 (File Nos. SD25-0072, VAR25-0016)
Dear Mayor and Members of the Town Council:

This firm represents Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development, which is comprised of residents of the Town of Los Altos Hills (the “Town”), in connection with the above-referenced application by the Lands of Vangala & Tokala (the “applicant”) to develop the parcel at APN 182- 05-034 on La Barranca Road (the “Property”). The matter is scheduled for the Town Council’s consideration on November 12, 2026. We write to urge the Council to (1) decline to make an affirmative Williamson Act compatibility determination for the project as proposed; (2) deny, or at a minimum defer, the requested Site Development Permit and related entitlements until the Property’s Land Conservation Contract has been lawfully cancelled in accordance with Government Code sections 51280 through 51287; and (3) decline to rely on a categorical exemption under the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) and instead undertake appropriate environmental review.

Our client does not oppose reasonable use of the Property. They ask only that the Town follow the law that governs land under a Williamson Act contract. As set out below, the proposed project (more than 6,300 square feet of residential floor area across three dwelling units, together with a driveway variance, a grading exception, and the removal of a substantial share of the parcel’s vegetation) cannot honestly be characterized as “compatible” with the Property’s continued agricultural and open-space use. Approving it under the guise of a compatibility determination would, in substance, terminate the contract without the process, findings, and fee the Williamson Act requires.

I. BACKGROUND
The Property is a 1.16-acre parcel zoned Residential-Agricultural (R-A). It has been subject to a Land Conservation Contract under the California Land Conservation Act of 1965 (the “Williamson Act” or “Act”), Government Code section 51200 et seq., since the contract was executed in 1971

Page 446 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 2 ends

and recorded in January 1972 (the “Contract”). The Contract restricts the Property, during its term and all renewals, to “the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto,” and lists the compatible uses in Exhibit A. In exchange, the owner receives a substantially reduced property-tax assessment. (Contract, ¶¶ 1–2 & Ex. A.) The applicant seeks approval of (1) a Site Development Permit to construct a 4,584-square-foot, two-story single-family residence with attached garage, a 793-square-foot attached accessory dwelling unit (“ADU”), and a 999-square-foot attached unit described as an “SB 9 unit,” together with associated hardscape and site improvements; (2) a variance to permit a driveway wider than the 14-foot maximum; (3) a grading policy exception to allow excavation exceeding the Town’s maximum cut thresholds; and (4) a Williamson Act compatibility determination. (Staff Report to the Planning Commission, Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034), File Nos. SD25- 0072 & VAR25-0016 (Sept. 3, 2026) (“Staff Report”), at 1.) The only agricultural uses proposed are a chicken coop for egg production and a shed for potted plants and vegetables. (Staff Report, at 2.)
After extensive public comment over several hearings, the Planning Commission, on October 1, 2026 (the “October 1 Hearing”), voted 3 to 1 to find that the Project is not compatible with the Williamson Act, on the ground that agriculture would not remain the primary use of the parcel.

That determination followed the Commission’s earlier direction, by a 4-0-1 vote on August 6, 2026, that staff prepare a resolution recommending denial on Williamson Act grounds. (Staff Report, at 2–3.) The matter now comes to the Town Council. The Commission’s conclusion is correct as a matter of law, and we respectfully urge the Council to adopt it.

Two developments since confirm the point. On September 17, 2026, the Town Council formed an ad hoc committee to develop Town rules for Williamson Act renewals, non-renewals, cancellations, and compatible-use and commercial-agriculture definitions, an implicit recognition that the Town presently has no such rules. And at the October 1 Hearing, Town staff and counsel reported on a meeting with the California Department of Conservation, which administers the Act at the state level. As reported at that hearing, the Department advised that, because the Town has not adopted uniform rules governing compatible uses, it was not in a position to opine that this Project is compatible, and that a parcel of roughly one acre is unlikely to be suitable for commercial agricultural use. Making a first-of-its-kind, affirmative compatibility determination for this parcel, with no Town rules in place and without the benefit of the state agency’s concurrence, would be precisely the wrong course.

Page 447 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 3 ends

II. THE PROJECT AS PROPOSED IS NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE WILLIAMSON ACT
A. The Act requires that agriculture or open space remain the primary use; compatible uses are, by definition, subordinate.

The Williamson Act was enacted to preserve agricultural and open-space land by restricting its use in exchange for reduced assessment. (Gov. Code, § 51220.) Land under contract “shall not be used for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto.” (Contract, ¶ 2; accord Gov. Code, § 51243.) A “compatible use” is defined as a use “determined by the county or city administering the preserve … to be compatible with the agricultural, recreational, or open-space use” of the land, and one that satisfies the statutory principles of compatibility. (Gov. Code, § 51201, subd. (e).) The statutory scheme thus contemplates that the agricultural or open-space use remains primary, and that any compatible use is subordinate and incidental to it. A use that displaces agriculture as the principal use of the land is not “compatible,” it is a conversion.

At the October 1 Hearing, the Town’s counsel suggested that no statute or Town regulation requires agriculture to be the primary use, and that the matter rests in the Town’s discretion to find the Exhibit A uses satisfied. That analysis is incomplete. The Contract itself supplies the governing limit: a compatible use must be “compatible thereto,” that is, compatible with and subordinate to “the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes.” (Contract, ¶

2.) A development that reduces agriculture to a token chicken coop is not “compatible thereto”; it supplants the agricultural use rather than coexisting with it. Contracts under the Williamson Act must be read to serve the Act’s purposes; they cannot override the Act’s use restrictions or nullify the constitutional requirement of an “enforceable restriction” recognized in Sierra Club v. City of Hayward (1981) 28 Cal.3d 840, 842. The Town’s Resolution No. 616 reinforces the point: to the extent it provides, as described in the record, that the uses permitted by a Land Conservation Contract may in no event be less restrictive than the Town’s zoning, a “compatibility” finding that lets the owner build what unrestricted zoning would allow would render the Contract less restrictive than zoning, not more. And as the Department of Conservation advised, without uniform Town rules the Town is not positioned to find this Project compatible in the first place.

B. Government Code section 51238.3’s exemption for enumerated uses is narrow and does not make this Project compatible.

Government Code section 51238.3 provides that the principles of compatibility in sections 51238.1 and 51238.2 do not apply to uses “expressly specified within the contract itself prior to June 7, 1994,” that constituted a “compatible use” as that term was defined when the contract was signed. Exhibit A to the 1972 Contract lists “Primary dwellings” and “Secondary dwellings,” and in 1972 a “compatible use” was simply a use the local agency determined to be compatible; the three statutory principles did not take effect until 1995. For that reason, the section 51238.1

Page 448 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 4 ends

principles do not independently govern the primary dwelling or a secondary dwelling here, and the Town’s counsel is correct on that narrow point.

That exemption, however, does not make this Project compatible, for two reasons. First, section 51238.3 removes the statutory principles; it does not rewrite the Contract, and Article 2 independently restricts the Property to agricultural production “and uses compatible thereto,” so even a grandfathered dwelling must remain subordinate to, and coexist with, the commercial agricultural use rather than supplant it. Second, a statutory carve-out from the compatibility principles cannot carve the Contract out of the Constitution; the land must still bear an “enforceable restriction” (see Section III below).

C. As applied here, the project is not “compatible thereto”: it makes residential use primary and agriculture incidental.

The project proposes more than 6,300 square feet of residential floor area, a 4,584-square-foot house, a 793-square-foot ADU, and a 999-square-foot additional unit, plus an attached garage, hardscape, an oversized driveway requiring a variance, and grading that exceeds the Town’s maximum cut thresholds and so requires a grading policy exception. (Staff Report, at 1.) Against that, the entirety of the proposed “agriculture” is a chicken coop and a potted-plant shed. (Staff Report, at 2.) According to the applicant’s own plans, the project would remove roughly 41 percent of the 1.16-acre parcel from agricultural or open-space use, leaving approximately 59 percent. (Applicant’s plans; see Staff Report, Attach. 5 [Farming Operation and Business Plan] & Attach. 6 [Worksheet 1-2].)
On these facts, agriculture plainly would not “remain the primary use of the parcel,” the very conclusion the Planning Commission reached. (Staff Report, at 3.) A backyard chicken coop and a shed of potted plants are not the principal use of a parcel dominated by a multi-unit residential compound; they are incidental to it. That inversion, residence as the primary use and agriculture as the incidental use, is not a use “compatible thereto” within the meaning of Article 2 of the Contract; it supplants the agricultural use the Contract exists to preserve. The permanent removal of a large share of the parcel’s vegetation and of significant trees to accommodate the residence, driveway, and grading only underscores the point.

III. THE CONTRACT MUST IMPOSE AN ENFORCEABLE RESTRICTION; A “COMPATIBILITY” FINDING THAT PERMITS WHAT UNRESTRICTED ZONING WOULD

ALLOW READS THE RESTRICTION OUT OF THE CONTRACT
The statutory carve-out just discussed does not resolve this matter, because it does not reach the Act’s constitutional foundation. The incompatibility of this Project is confirmed by the constitutional foundation of the Williamson Act. Preferential, use-based assessment of agricultural and open-space land is constitutionally permissible only where the land is subject to an “enforceable restriction” on its use. (Cal. Const., art. XIII, § 8.) As the California Supreme Court explained in

Page 449 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 5 ends

the decision that remains the controlling construction of the Act, “to insure that the constitutional requirement of an ‘enforceable restriction’ is met, the Legislature deliberately required a long-term commitment to agriculture or other open-space use.” (Sierra Club v. City of Hayward (1981) 28 Cal.3d 840, 842.) At the October 1 Hearing, the Town’s counsel invited a specific citation for this constitutional requirement; it is article XIII, section 8 of the California Constitution, which the Supreme Court construed in Sierra Club.

The Town’s counsel sought to set Sierra Club aside on the ground that it arose from a cancellation petition. That misreads the case. The principle we draw from Sierra Club is not a cancellation-specific holding; it is the Court’s explanation of why the Act requires a long-term, enforceable commitment to agricultural or open-space use, a requirement rooted in the Constitution and applicable to every determination the Town makes under a contract, including a compatibility determination. The factual posture of the case does not confine that principle.

It follows that a Williamson Act contract must actually restrict the use of the land for the duration of the contract. A contract that permits the owner to do precisely what unrestricted zoning would allow imposes no “enforceable restriction” at all. Here, the Project would place on this contracted parcel a residential development no more limited than what the Town’s zoning would permit on a comparable parcel subject to no Williamson Act contract: a 4,584-square-foot residence, an ADU, and a third dwelling unit, with only token agriculture. If the Town were to find that development “compatible,” the Contract would impose no meaningful restriction on the Property during its remaining term, and the preferential assessment the owner has enjoyed would rest on a restriction that exists only on paper. That result cannot be reconciled with the constitutional requirement the Supreme Court identified in Sierra Club, or with the Legislature’s deliberate choice to require a “long-term commitment to agriculture or other open-space use.” The proper interpretation of the Contract, and the one the Planning Commission reached, is that it imposes an enforceable restriction limiting the Property to agriculture and genuinely subordinate compatible uses until the Contract is no longer in force.

IV. A COMPATIBILITY DETERMINATION CANNOT BE USED TO ACCOMPLISH A DE

FACTO CANCELLATION OF THE CONTRACT
The Williamson Act provides two distinct mechanisms that bear on contracted land, and they do very different things. Nonrenewal (Gov. Code, §§ 51245–51246; Contract, ¶¶ 3–4) does not release the land from the contract’s use restrictions; it stops only the contract’s automatic annual renewal, so that the contract runs out over the balance of its remaining term, approximately nine years, while the assessed value steps up toward unrestricted value over that period. Throughout the nonrenewal wind-down, the Property remains fully subject to the restriction that it be used only for agriculture and compatible uses. Cancellation (Gov. Code, §§ 51280–51287), by contrast, is the only mechanism that terminates the contract and permits a non-agricultural use before the

Page 450 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 6 ends

term expires, and it is disfavored: it requires the Town to make the specific statutory findings prescribed by section 51282 and the landowner to pay a cancellation fee equal to 12.5 percent of the land’s unrestricted fair market value (Gov. Code, § 51283).

That distinction is decisive here, because the applicant proposes to build now, during the contract term. Nonrenewal cannot authorize that construction: even if a notice of nonrenewal were served today, the Property would remain restricted to agriculture and compatible uses for the entire balance of the term, and an estate-scale residence could not lawfully be built during that period.

The only mechanism that could authorize a conversion of this kind, one that leaves no genuine agricultural use, before the contract expires is cancellation. Nonrenewal is, at most, a predicate to one of the statutory cancellation routes (see Gov. Code, § 51282), not a substitute for it.

The record now contains important concessions on this score. The Town’s own August 6 staff report recognized that “the long-term policy objective of maintaining this property under Williamson Act should be evaluated before considering the development,” and that non-renewal is the step to take if continued enrollment is no longer appropriate. (Staff Report, at 3.) And at the October 1 Hearing, the Town’s counsel acknowledged that the Department of Conservation pointed to the non-renewal process as the remedy for a parcel the owner wishes to develop.

Those positions concede that the path forward runs through the Act’s exit provisions, not through a compatibility determination. We add only that, because the applicant seeks to build now, non-renewal alone is insufficient; cancellation, with its findings and fee, is the sole mechanism that could authorize construction before the term expires.

We do not contend that no dwelling may ever be built on this parcel; Exhibit A lists dwellings, and section 51238.3 may exempt them from the statutory principles. But a compatibility determination cannot be used to authorize a development that, in practical effect, ends the agricultural use and leaves the Property indistinguishable from unrestricted land. Approving development of this scale under the label of a “compatibility determination” would let the applicant achieve the practical result of cancellation, conversion of the Property to a residential estate, while evading the findings, fee, and public process the Act requires. The courts have long insisted that the Act’s exit provisions be strictly construed and not circumvented. (See Sierra Club v. City of Hayward (1981) 28 Cal.3d 840 [Williamson Act cancellation findings strictly construed].) A local agency cannot do indirectly, through an over-generous compatibility finding, what the statute requires be done directly, through cancellation. If the Town wishes to allow this project, the lawful path is to pursue cancellation, satisfying the section 51282 findings and paying the section 51283 fee, before any entitlement authorizing construction is granted, not to declare an estate-scale residential development “compatible” with a contract that exists to keep the land in agriculture.

Because the compatibility question is close and consequential, we further urge the Town to obtain a written technical advisory opinion from the Department of Conservation, Division of Land

Page 451 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 7 ends

Resource Protection, before acting, rather than proceeding on the staff-level discussion summarized at the October 1 Hearing. Doing so would help the Town avoid a costly error and the litigation risk that an unsupported compatibility determination would invite.

V. DENYING AN INCOMPATIBLE PROJECT IS NOT A TAKING, AND THE TOWN’S

LITIGATION EXPOSURE RUNS THE OTHER WAY
At the October 1 Hearing, the Town’s counsel suggested that denying the Project could expose the Town to a regulatory-takings claim, and could prompt a breach-of-contract action by the owner, on the reasoning that the Contract and Exhibit A list a primary dwelling and secondary dwellings. Counsel appropriately qualified the suggestion, indicating that she was not offering a risk opinion to the Town and was identifying only potential causes of action the applicant might assert. With respect, a denial on the grounds set out in this letter would be neither a taking nor a breach, and the more serious litigation risk runs the other way.

First, enforcing a restriction the owner voluntarily accepted is not a taking. The owner, and every successor, took title subject to a recorded Land Conservation Contract and has received, and continues to receive, the bargained-for benefit of substantially reduced assessment in exchange for the use restriction. (Contract, ¶ 6; Gov. Code, § 51243 [contract runs with the land and binds successors].) Requiring the owner to honor that restriction deprives the owner of nothing to which the owner is entitled, and it does not interfere with any reasonable, investment-backed expectation, the touchstone of the regulatory-takings inquiry. (See Penn Central Transportation Co. v. New York City (1978) 438 U.S. 104, 124.) An owner who holds land under a recorded Williamson Act contract cannot reasonably expect to build as though the contract did not exist.

Second, the owner retains economically viable use and multiple lawful paths forward. The Property may be used now for agriculture and genuinely compatible uses; the owner may serve a notice of nonrenewal and develop at the end of the term; or the owner may petition for cancellation under Government Code sections 51280 through 51287. Because the owner is not deprived of all economically beneficial use, there is no categorical taking (see Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council (1992) 505 U.S. 1003), and because these avenues remain open and no final decision foreclosing all development has issued, any takings claim is not ripe.

Third, the breach-of-contract theory fails for an independent reason: the Town is a party to the Contract, and declining to approve a use that is not “compatible thereto,” one that supplants rather than coexists with the agricultural use, is performance of the Contract, not a breach of it. We acknowledge that section 51238.3 exempts the enumerated dwellings from the statutory compatibility principles; but it does not entitle the owner to a development of any scale, and it does not excuse either the Contract’s own “compatible thereto” limit or the constitutional enforceable-restriction requirement. A denial grounded in those limits is neither a breach nor a taking.

Page 452 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 8 ends

Fourth, the litigation exposure runs the other way, and it is not hypothetical. If the Town makes an unsupported compatibility determination and relies on a categorical exemption, it invites a CEQA and mandamus challenge; the Town’s own counsel described the mandamus remedy at the October 1 Hearing, and members of the public stated on the record that an affirmative compatibility determination would be challenged. Approving what amounts to a cancellation without the statutory findings and fee also deprives the State of the cancellation fee the Act requires and exposes the Town to challenge for circumventing the Act. Finally, the suggestion that the Property’s assessment would rise upon development does not change the analysis:
whether and when the tax benefit ends is a matter for the county assessor and is disputed on this record; and in any event the end of the tax benefit does not convert an incompatible, estate-scale development into a compatible one, nor does it excuse compliance with the Act’s exit provisions.

The Town best protects itself by applying the Act as written, consistent with the Planning Commission’s determination.

VI. THE PROJECT DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR A CLASS 3 CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION The Staff Report proposes to find the project categorically exempt from CEQA under the Class 3 exemption for new construction of small structures. (Staff Report, at 1, 4; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15303, subd. (a).) That exemption is unavailable here for at least three reasons.

First, the Class 3 exemption authorizes “[o]ne single-family residence” outside urbanized areas, and permits “up to three single-family residences” only “[i]n urbanized areas.” (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15303, subd. (a).) Los Altos Hills is a low-density, rural-residential community, and this Property is contracted agricultural and open-space land within an agricultural preserve. A three-unit residential project on such a parcel does not fit the terms of subdivision (a).

Second, even if the exemption otherwise applied, it is barred by the exceptions in section 15300.2. The location exception withholds the Class 3 exemption where the project may affect an environmental resource of critical concern (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15300.2, subd. (a)); Williamson Act agricultural preserve land, and the significant trees the project would remove, are such resources. The unusual-circumstances exception applies where there is a reasonable possibility that the activity will have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances. (Id., § 15300.2, subd. (c); Berkeley Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1086.) The removal of roughly 41 percent of the parcel’s vegetation and of numerous significant trees, grading that exceeds the Town’s maximum cut thresholds, and a driveway that exceeds the Town’s width standard are exactly the kind of unusual circumstances that defeat a categorical exemption.

Third, CEQA independently treats the conversion of, or conflict with, Williamson Act land as a potentially significant impact. (See CEQA Guidelines, Appendix G, § II [Agriculture and Forestry Resources: whether a project would “[c]onflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a

Page 453 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
November 5, 2026

Page 9 ends

Williamson Act contract”].) Where, as here, a fair argument exists that the project will impair or effectively convert contracted agricultural land, the Town cannot lawfully rely on a categorical exemption; at a minimum, an initial study is required. We note that staff added underlined language to the draft resolution at the October 1 Hearing to address our earlier CEQA comments; that addition does not cure the defects identified here.

VII. CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, we respectfully request that the Town Council: (1) decline to make an affirmative Williamson Act compatibility determination for the Project as proposed, because the development is not “compatible thereto” under the Contract, because no enforceable restriction would remain, and because the Town has adopted no uniform rules by which compatibility could reliably be judged; (2) deny the requested Site Development Permit, variance, and grading exception, or defer any approval unless and until the Contract has been lawfully cancelled under Government Code sections 51280 through 51287, including the findings required by section 51282 and payment of the cancellation fee required by section 51283; (3) decline to rely on a Class 3 categorical exemption and instead conduct appropriate CEQA review; and (4) obtain a written technical advisory opinion from the Department of Conservation on the compatibility question before acting.

Our client appreciates the Council’s careful attention to this matter and stands ready to provide any additional information that would assist the Council. We ask that this letter be included in the administrative record for the Project.

Very truly yours,
Christopher L. Powell
Partner
cc: Steve Mattas, Esq., Alex Mog, Esq., and Amara Morrison, Esq., Town Attorneys (Redwood Public Law LLP)
Jay Bradford, Community Development Director
Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development

Page 454 of 647 ends

From:

To: BCC - Alisa Bredo; Jim Waschura; Jonathan Fox; BCC - Birgitta Indaco; Rajiv Patel Cc: Rajiv Bhateja; Linda Swan; George Tyson; kavita tankha; Stanley Mok Subject: Re: 0 La Barranca
Date: Wednesday, July 29, 2026 10:21:13 PM
July 29, 2026
Dear Planning Commission;
This is a clarification and refinement of my earlier comments from 7/28/2026.

I am writing my letter regarding File #SD25-0072 for 0 La Barranca. I appreciate the opportunity to provide additional comments and would like to clarify my concerns with more specific reference to the project details.

My intent is not to oppose development of the property, but to ensure that the proposed project is appropriately designed for the site conditions and consistent with the Town’s hillside safety and development standards.

I am particularly concerned about the proposed driveway location. Your NOTICE OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING on your stationary, mailed out to the surrounding neighborhood residents, dated 5/29/26 stated Variances to permit a driveway width exceeding the maximum 14 feet and to allow development exceeding the MAXIMUM Development Area by 548 square feet. A grading policy exception to allow excavation exceeding the maximum cut thresholds for the driveway. This is a variance. How many variances or exceptions are you asking for? The driveway appears to be located near a curve on La Barranca where visibility is limited.

This creates a potential safety issue for vehicles entering and exiting the property due to reduced sight distance and the proximity of a roadway bend. I respectfully request that the Town evaluate whether safe ingress and egress can be achieved at this location or whether the driveway should be redesigned or relocated to improve visibility and reduce conflict with through traffic.

I also have concerns regarding the extent of grading proposed for the project. The application appears to involve significant excavation and slope modification on a hillside parcel, including cut and fill operations and associated retaining structures. My concern is whether this level of disturbance could increase erosion risk, affect slope stability over time, or alter natural drainage patterns on the site.

In addition, I request careful review of the proposed drainage design to ensure that stormwater runoff will be properly managed on-site and will not increase flow toward adjacent properties or downhill areas, particularly given the steep terrain conditions.

Finally, when I refer to potential modifications, I am specifically referring to possible adjustments such as improving driveway alignment for safety, reducing grading intensity where feasible, and refining building placement to better respond to the natural topography of the site.

I respectfully ask the Planning Commission to evaluate the project as a whole and ensure that all required findings can be made before approving the requested permits, variances and exceptions as the proposed development is very close to the Town’s guideline limits and in some cases have exceeded the building codes of the Town as prior to this acquisition by the Vangalas, this property was an Open Space parcel with land that was never developed.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Page 455 of 647 ends

Larry and Denise Del Carlo
Cc: Los Altos Hills Town Council

Page 456 of 647 ends

From:

To: BCC - Birgitta Indaco; Jim Waschura; [email protected]; [email protected]; Malika Junaid Cc: Rajiv Bhateja; Planning Commission
Subject: Concern on project “Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) Date: Tuesday, July 28, 2026 8:26:38 AM
LAH Planning Commission / City Council,
As an affected neighboring property owner of 0 La
Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034), despite previous
comments and objections submitted by surrounding
property owners, our concerns remain unresolved and
continue to warrant careful consideration by the relevant authorities.

The potential impacts on neighboring properties,
community character, safety, environmental resources,
traffic, noise, and overall quality of life deserve
meaningful evaluation and response, I respectfully
request that these issues be thoroughly reviewed before any approval or further actions are taken.
1-Land Stability:

Numerous neighboring property owners have raised
concerns and provided detailed information regarding the site's steep slopes and geologic characteristics. The
parcel may be approximately one acre in size; the steep topography substantially limits its functional building area. Therefore, the site should not be evaluated in the same manner as a relatively flat amount of equivalent
acreage. Rather, the development intensity should reflect the actual constraints of the terrain and geologic
conditions to ensure long-term safety, stability, and
compatibility with the surrounding environment.

In the absence of demonstrated comparable projects with similar land conditions, we believe a more conservative development approach is warranted. A reduction in the
scale of development to a size more consistent with the

Page 457 of 647 ends

site's physical limitations would reduce the burden placed on the hillside, minimize grading and structural
interventions, lower the risk of slope instability, and better protect public safety and neighboring properties.
2-WA concern:

It has been noted that the Town of Los Altos Hills does not appear to have a clearly defined policy or guideline for addressing Williamson Act (WA) properties and related
land use decisions. The Town should carefully evaluate
the broader implications of its decision. Many properties and neighborhoods within Los Altos Hills contain
significant open space easements and may potentially
qualify for Williamson Act benefits. As a result, decisions made in this case could encourage similar requests in the future, potentially expanding participation in programs that reduce property tax assessments. This may have
long-term fiscal implications for the Town and other local public agencies that rely on property tax revenues.

Before taking any action, I respectfully request that the Town provide a clear legal and policy analysis regarding the applicability of Williamson Act requirements, establish transparent guidelines for future cases, and evaluate the potential financial impacts that such decisions may have on the community.
3-How farming activities can be managed: A poultry
operation with approximately 100 laying hens and
production of 500 eggs per week should be subject to
clear and enforceable operational standards addressing
sanitation, manure management, odor control, pest
control, biosecurity, disease prevention, and veterinary oversight. Without such regulations and ongoing
compliance monitoring, the operation may create public
health, nuisance, and compatibility concerns for
surrounding residential uses. The applicant should
demonstrate compliance with recognized poultry-management standards and provide an operations plan

Page 458 of 647 ends

addressing waste disposal, infection control, disease
reporting, and neighboring property protection.
4-Can residential /agriculture areas be doing commercial things: A chicken operation consisting of approximately 100 laying hens and producing roughly 500 eggs per week exceeds the scale of a customary residential accessory
use and exhibits characteristics of a commercial
agricultural enterprise. The operation involves ongoing agricultural production for sale, with the potential for increased traffic, deliveries, noise, odor, and operational intensity that are not typically associated with residential land uses.

We respect the time and expertise that the Planning
Commission members contribute through their volunteer
service. As neighbors who will be directly affected by this project, however, we believe it is important to bring
forward concerns and perspectives that may not have
been thoroughly examined. We are here to express our
serious concerns about this ambitious plan, which we
believe has not undergone adequate review of its
potential safety and environmental impacts.

Best Regards,
Amy Huang

Page 459 of 647 ends

From: Julie Wilker < >
Sent: Wednesday, June 3, 2026 2:31 PM
To: Planning <[email protected]>
Subject: FOR PUBLIC COMMENT File #SD25-0072
I will not be able to attend the Planning meeting for Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034), here are my comments:
- Concern that the parking of construction vehicles (worker cars/trucks, construction equipment) is well accounted for - many of us use the path opposite the construction site and would not want it blocked, especially in a low traffic visibility area of the street. This is a well used street as well so we would hope the plans minimize any "single lane" / flag person needed times as due to the traffic visibility, any construction truck usage on the street would need this for safety. Talking to the planning person, I was assured that construction parking, etc. will need to be part of the plan before permits are approved. - Concern for the excessive grading with environmental impact inspections being waived - again, I would expect the building plans to include ways to prevent environmental impacts with that much excavation and that many trees being chopped down. - Concern about such a large development receiving tax advantage due to the Williamson Act - 6500 sq ft total building seems excessive to what that act was meant to cover. Online seems to cap the covered building at 2500 sq ft without issue, though perhaps the buildings are not being submitted as part of the Williamson Act tax treatment. - No concern on the beautifully architected design
Thank you,
Julie Wilker
Cumbra Vista Ct
ITEM 3.5 ATTACHMENT 2

Page 460 of 647 ends

Welch Public Comment Planning Commission 26-0608 1
TO: LAH Planning Commission
SUBJECT: PUBLIC COMMENT Item 3.5 Planning Commission Meeting June 8, 2026 FROM: Sue Welch
DATE: June 8, 2026 _____________________________________________________________________ I respectfully request that the Planning Commission continue this item to a future meeting to provide additional time for review because of complexity of the project:
three dwelling units on a constrained parcel, excess MDA and other variances requested by the developer, details of Williamson Act contract not provided, and failure to address open space and conservation issues. Neither the public nor the Planning Commission has had time to fully review the proposal. I further recommend the Town consult with the County Department of Division of Agriculture to determine if these development plans are compatible with state law and the existing WA contract and obtain and file a Compatible Use Determination from the county.

The owners of this parcel propose to cut down 12 heritage oak trees and an unspecified number of non-heritage oaks to grow potted plants and keep chickens. Three dwelling units, (primary residence, a 2-story ADU, and an SB9 unit), a pool, and outbuildings which together would exceed the allowable MDA for the parcel are proposed, as well as other variances. Further, the parcel is under Williamson Act contract and no documentation about the contract or development limitations has been provided. Laws regarding development on Williamson Act land are complex and I recommend the town seek advice form the County and the State.

My recommendations:

1. Require open space easements on steep wooded slopes as required by Land Use Element
The site is located within an Open Space Conservation Area designated in the LAH Land Use Element that runs along the Deer Creek riparian corridor. The back (SE) portion of the parcel is a steep, heavily wooded ravine. Deer creek runs through this OSCA on adjacent parcels.

Land Use Designation 116
— The OSCA overlay is generally applied to areas of steep slopes, canyons and ravines associated with major creeks or their tributaries, as well as creek corridors and other areas of heavy vegetation that should be protected. Within these areas, special measures should be taken to conserve the natural quality of the area and to avoid environmental degradation. Residences should be placed on the most buildable portions of lands designated OSCA and

Page 461 of 647 ends

Welch Public Comment Planning Commission 26-0608 2
carefully sited so as to preserve existing trees, vegetation and wildlife habitat. /LAH Land Use Element LU-6/.

The areas along the perimeter of the parcel shown as "Vegetable Farming" appear to be on steeply sloped areas largely within the 30-ft setbacks. Most of this area is >30% slope and has mature oaks, thus it meets criteria for dedication of open space easements, which are routinely required on other steeply sloped parcels.

Land Use Element Policy 2.5. Steep slopes, canyons and ravines generally in excess of 30% slope, as well as natural swales and drainage channels, and geologic hazard areas within areas designated for residential development shall be left undisturbed and preserved in their natural condition to the maximum extent feasible. /LAH General Plan; Land Use Element pg LU-9/.

2. Review Williamson Act Documentation
Owners report this parcel has been under the Williamson Act (WA) since 1972, and owners have received tax assessments that are substantially lower than the market value of the land since that time. Please require Planning Commission to review the documentation for this WA contract, including the original contract between the previous owner and the Town and the explicit terms of the contract specifying what is and is not allowed on the parcel. In addition, the owners were required by law to submit annual or biennial reports to the Town describing the nature of their agricultural enterprise, including operations, income, and expenses. Confirm that these reports were submitted to the Town with description of how the land was being used. If they were not submitted, ask the Town to require that these reports be provided in the future—as required by law.

It is apparent from historical and current aerial photos —and the comment provided in the staff report that "The site is covered by a canopy of heritage oak trees." — that this steep (avg slope >33%), wooded parcel has not been used for agricultural since the WA contract started. However, since 1971 the state has allowed Williamson Act contracts for the purpose of protecting open space land —without a requirement for ag activity.

Review of the WA reports to the Town from this parcel should clarify how the land has been used to meet WA requirements. It is clear any open space value of the parcel will be lost by the proposed development.

3. How much development is allowed on parcels in Williamson Act contracts designated for agriculture? Is the proposed development area of >8,000 square feet of MDA and three dwelling units of MDA allowable on a WA parcel contracted for open space or for agriculture? There are restrictions for building residences and Santa Clara County has an extensive info section on development of WA parcels.

I strongly recommend the Town

Page 462 of 647 ends

Welch Public Comment Planning Commission 26-0608 3
— Review the WA contract for this parcel to identify allowed uses — Consult with the CA Department of Conservation to determine if the proposed development—that exceeds allowable MDA and clearly will displace potential agricultural and/or open space use of most of the parcel— is allowable or will result in breach of contract.
— Consult with the Santa Clara County Division of Agriculture to determine if these development plans are compatible with state law and the existing WA contract.

Obtain and file a Compatible Use Determination from the county.

Thank you for your consideration
Sue Welch
LAH resident

Page 463 of 647 ends

Outlook
Concerns on project 'Unaddressed La Barranaca Rd'
From
Date Tue 6/9/2026 9:13 AM
To Planning Commission <[email protected]> Dear Commission,
My name is and I have expressed my concerns on the following topics last night. However, for some of the questions asked to me, I did not have answers ready then. Now, I would like to follow up on that, and make sure things are properly addressed. This is a long email - not sure if it is appropriate for public read.

IF IT HAS TO BE PUBLISHED, PLEASE POST IT AS ANONYMOUS.

1. Williamson Act Compatibility.

To be qualified for Williamson Act contract, the owners have to have commercial agriculture business.

Although personally I do not think the project is qualified, I want to also voice out the concerns IF it get qualified. We need measures to ensure limited commercial activity here to uphold the quiet enjoyment right of the neighbors. Traffic, People/workers, Noise, potential pollution from machines, and Animal sanitory.

California real estate related law also have clear rules on permitted residential unit on agriculture land.

Traditionally, not the owners', but ok for 'hired workers. And yes, it has to be incidental.

2. Land Stability
One of the commissioner mentioned we can only 'follow the engineers suggestion'. I agree. However, I'd also request a thorough study and reports being shared to our neighbors. Maybe a link to document depository to the 500 m radius?
Will the project removes soil from the 'slope' of the flat area near the upper unit? Will the project remove soils next to the lower unit? Please specify the excavation sites, the volume and the risk assessment.

I am far from being an expert, so I asked Al help :)
Question

1. Is any portion of the site mapped as an ancient landslide? 2. How much cut and fill is proposed?

3. Will there be retaining walls required or built? 4. What is the calculated static FoS and seismic Fos?

5. Will it ensure safety and stability during a very wet year, we had a year of maybe 3-4 atmosphere river, especially during the construction time? 6. What earthquake acceleration was assumed? 7. Soil type and its role in stability estimation.

Geotechnical Report

Page 464 of 647 ends

Prepared by a geotechnical engineer.

Should include:
• Borings
• Laboratory testing
• Groundwater investigation
• Settlement analysis
• Slope stability analysis
Engineering Geology Report
Prepared by an engineering geologist.

Should include:
• Geologic mapping
• Fault investigation
• Landslide evaluation
• Soil and rock characterization
Fault Investigation Report
Often includes:
• Trenches
• Fault mapping
• Recommended setbacks

3. A general question on MDA MFA related.

I am wondering if the slope is considered a factor to 'limit' MDA MFA for land stability and building safety purpose? I am aware the slope degree is included in the calculation of MDA MFA, just not sure if it is for appearance factor or safty stability purposes.

The land in this discussion has a 33.3% slope, and with a significant portion of the 'flat' area on the other side of the fault which is not used other than installing the septic tank and a chicken coop/or green house. Now, that means the rest of the land must have a slope steeper than 33.3%. MDA give a general guideline I understand, but does it 'gaurantee a construction of this size is allowed?'.

Considering the steep slope, I am not sure if it is recommendable to build the big construction in the physically challenging slope area.

Well - I am learning from your professional opinions and the neighbors rely on your stewardship for a prospective future. Very appreciated.

Sincerly,

Page 465 of 647 ends

Outlook
Re: Concerns on project Unaddressed La Barranaca Rd'
From
Date Tue 6/9/2026 7:29 PM
To Planning Commission <[email protected]> Dear Commission,
A quick follow up on MDA/MFA. I am preaching to the chiore I am aware...please allow me.

1. By looking at the worksheet, this property has a 'calculated MDA' of 4155. It is 'allowed' to be 7500sf due to the policy(?) that *IF the MDA is less than 7500sf, and LUF is greater than 0.5, use 7500 sf for MDA.

Note the lot we are talking about has a LUF barely over 0.5, at 0.55.

Suggesting the land was not considered suitable for big constructions, not to mention they unable to utilize the flat area.

2. Now if we look into the details abot current development area proposed.

Note, there are credit applied to SB9 unit, ADU, and drive ways. SB9 and ADU only count for total '99 sqft' of development area after the significant discount.

In the meeting last night (6/8/2026), we were talking about chicken coop and green house that takes significant development area so that the overall exceeds MDA. It may be the '361' sf in item 1.J - Any other coverage? IT IS NOT THE CASE why they have to exceed MDA.

I would suggest Engineering and Geologist review of the project by someone independent of the town and NO conflict of interest. Better, if allow neighbors to look for creditable expert.

Thank you.
imagel.jpeg Jimage1 jpeg
Sent from my iPad
On Jun 9, 2026, at 9:13 AM, Faye HSU < [email protected] > wrote:

Page 466 of 647 ends

Outlook
Concerns on project "Unaddressed La Barranca Rd"
From
Date Sat 6/13/2026 8:22 AM
To Planning Commission < [email protected]> U 1 attachment (2 MB)
Concerns on "Unaddressed La Barranca Project". docx;
We request a reconsideration of the building plan on "Unaddressed La Barranca Rd" with the concerns on the Land Stability, quiet enjoyment environment, commercial operation, and the traffic safety.

The reasons are stated in the summary document.

Document Below

Page 467 of 647 ends

Objective
The new development plan of the ‘unaddressed La Barranca Rd’ has two major parts:
1) Building plan with a variance exceeding MDA
2) Williamson Act Compatibility
We have concerns on both parts that we seek the city planner and planning commission to give a careful evaluation.

Lastly, I hope to mention the seemingly inconsistent evaluation by city planners regarding building permits.

Page 468 of 647 ends

I. Is the development advisable, with variance to MDA?
A. Is MDA increase for This lot suitable?
Review Worksheet #1
1) This specific lot has the characters - S is 33.3%, LUF is 0.554. 2) This specific lot has calculated MDA 4155 sf, MFA 2770 sf 3) MDA and MFA are ‘allowed’ to be 7500sf, and 5000 sf,respectively 4) Another note on the worksheet: The MDA and MFA are maximums allowed…City Counncil or Planning Commission may further limit development area or floor area due to site specific constraints or site visibility.

Discussion point
1) If a lot with LUF below 0.5, the MDA MFA would not be permitted to increase. 2) City also hold a code that if a lot with S >35%, it is conditional development permit gives MDA of 2500 sf
3) This lot S = 33.3%, LUF 0.554, Both are very close to the restriction where No increase would have been allowed,but approximate to a conditioned land restricted with MDA 2500 sf.

Question:
1) Is it truly Safe to allow increase of Development to the maximum allowed, MDA to 7500 sf, and MFA to 5000 sf?
2) Is there enough historic data to support such an increase in building size is sound and safe?
3) Is there great innovation in building or geological science technology, material, engineering, to support the increase as “GOOD, IDEAL” now than before? 4) Note, the construction cannot use the only flat area of the lot due to faultline setback. .

The ‘buildable’ area Likely has S > 35%, LUF <0.5.

Had the lot come without the flat area, the city would not have agreed to have increased MDA MFA, and may stick to the 2500 sf of restriction.

Additional Request
1) Thorough report on geological and fault assessment. Mostly on FoS and reveal whether there were ancient slide
2) Independent consultant with knowledge on steep slope buildings.

Worksheet #1 attached.

Page 469 of 647 ends

MFA/MDA

Page 4 ends

WORKSHEET #1
(continued)

3. SALCULATION OF MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT AREA (MDA)
A. for S equal to or less than 10%
MDA - (LUF) (15,000) *- square feet*
B. for S greater than 10% and less than 30%
MDA - (LUF) [15,000 - 375(S - 10)] -- _ square feet*
C. for S equal to or greater than 30%
MDA = (LUF) (7,500) =_ 4155. 7500 Per * square feet*
* If the MIDA is less than 7,500 square feet (and the LUF is greater than 0.50), use 7,500 square feet for your MDA

4. CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM ELOOR AREA (MEA)
A. for S equal to or less than 10%
MRA - (LUF) * square feet**
B. for S greater than 10% and less than 30%
MPA - (LUF) [6,000 - 50(S - 10)] -. square fect**
C. for S equal to or greater than 30%
MEA - (LUF) (5,000) = 2770 5000 Per ** square feet**
* If the MFA is less than 5,000 square feet (and the LUP is greater than 0.50) use 5,000 square feet for your MFA.

NOTE: The MDA and MFA are maximums allowed by the Town Muniopal Code. The City Council or the Planning Commission may further limit development area or floor area due to site specific constraints or site visibility (see "Site Development Policy Statement").

TOWN USE ONLY CHECKED BY DATE

Page 470 of 647 ends

MEA/MDA

Page 3 ends

TOWN OF LOS ALTOS HILLS

PLANNING DEPARTMENT
26379 Fremont Road • Los Altos Hills, California 94022 • (650) 941-7222 • FAX (650) 941-3160 WORKSHEET #1

CALCULATION OF AVERAGE SLOPE, LOT UNIT FACTOR

MAKIMUM DEVELOPMENT AREA, AND MAXIMUM FLOOR ARBA
•TURN IN WIPE YOUR APPLICATION •
PROPERTY OWNER'S NAME Barbara Lumbard
PROPERTY ADDRESS La Barranca Rd APN 182-05-034
CALCULATED BY Marvin Lumbard MechanIcal Engineer DATE 5/17/21

1. CALCULATION OF AVERAGE SLOPE
A. CONTOUR LENGTH WITHIN NET AREA OF LOT (An)

CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH (INCHES) (INCHES) (INCHBS) (INCHBS)
LTOTAL
See Attached Spread Sheet
Convert inches to feet (multiply by map scale) = (L) *= 8013.43 feet B. AVERAGE SLOPE WITHIN NET AREA OF LOT
S = (0.0023) (L = contour interval L= total length of An= not acreage of An in feet contours in feet lot nearest 001

1.106 acre excluding road cut face at La Barranca
8 * (0.0023)( 2) (8013.43) -
(1.106 ) 33.3% nearest 0.1%

2. CALCULATION OF LOT UNIT FACTOR (LOO
LUF= 1.108 Acres x (1-(.02143 x (33.3-10))
LUF = (An)[1 - [0.02143(S- 10)]) * LUF =554 neareat .001

Page 471 of 647 ends

B. It is actually a much bigger development than proposed 7632 sf Review Worksheet #2
1) Please note that there is a total 2693 sqft DA credit applied for SB-9 unit, ADU and driveway. The actual ‘real’ development area is 7632 + 2693=10,325 sf. 2) Same applied to floored area, it is actually 4810+793+999= 6602 sf floored area 3) These HAS NOT included the planned chicken coop and green house yet. Including those, the development area will be likely another 1000 sf.

Question:
1) In fact, it is NOT a MDA 7500 sf development, it is actually a 10,325 sqft development + chicken coop (note they want to host 100 chickens, that will be minimally 500 sqft?) and a green house.
2) It is NOT a 4810 sf floored area development, it is actually 6,602 sf floored area 3) Question remains - for this lot, it originally would be qualified with MDA MFA 4415 sf and 2770 sf, respectively, is there precedent data support a development over 11000 sf and floored area above 6600 sf?
With comparable the land condition (Slope, soil type, earthquake zone, faultline, trees and potential atmosphere rivers 3+ times a year when building)? (I would feel much safer to build 4415 sf on a flat 8000 sf lot, than on an acre of steep slope) 4) If not, should we not do thorough research and engineering evaluation? What stopped us from a thorough evaluation?
Worksheet #2 attached.

Page 472 of 647 ends

Worksheet #2
Existing and Proposed Development Area and Floor Area
Submit with Application
Property Owner's Name: Naveen Vangala
Property Address: 0 La Barranca Road
Calculated By: Lea & Braze Engineering, Inc. Date:
10-16-2025
)EVELOPMENT AREA
Existing Proposed DA Credit
Total
.. House and Garage from part 2.A 4,711 N/A
4,711

1. Accessory Dwelling Unit from part 2.B 793
793
Accessory Building from part 2.C 999 900
99 ). Driveway, Turnaround, and Parking 2,636 1000 1,636 E. Patios and Walkways 16 767 0 783
P. Recreation Court 0 N/A

3. Pool and Pool Decking 403 0 403
H. Decks 84 (84) N/A
I. Solar Panels (ground mounted) 0 0
J. Any Other Coverage (361)
TOTALS 9,864 2693 7632
MDA from Worksheet #1 7500

FLOOR AREA
Existing Proposed FA Credit Total
A. House and Garage
a. First Floor 3526
3526
b. Second Floor
c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202) 0 607
607
d. Garage 0
578
578
e. Area Over 17 ft (LAHMC 10-1.202)
f. Attic Over 7 (LAHMC 10-1.202) E
B. Accessory Dwelling Unit (800 credit)
793 793
C. Accessory Buildings 0
a. First Floor
b. Second Floor 999 900
99 c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202)
d. Attic
TOTALS
6503
MFA from Worksheet #1 1693 4810
5000
Checked By: Town Use Only
Date:

Page | 6

Page 473 of 647 ends
Page 474 of 647 ends

C. Other concerns:
1) La Barranca Rd Traffic Safety: Driveway open is currently selected to be at a ‘turning’ spot where the views from all directions are obstructed. Is there a possible move of the driveway?
2) The plan is to install a pump to transfer waste water to the septic tanks located higher than the dwelling unit. Upon questioned by commission chair lady, their response was that the pump will be underground hence no noise.

Please confirm whether they will put a generator that creates contant noise and smell.

Page 475 of 647 ends

II. Williamson Act Compativity
A. Will it be considered a Williamson Act property?
1) There are clear guidelines from County of Santa Clara Agriculture is the primary use of the land,
A residential unit can only be incidental
2) There are California regulations on Agriculture land -mostly the size above 10 acres, or above 40 acres are two major categories.
3) California Real Estate standard for buying selling agriculture land requires owners do not primarily dwelling there, or the livable area be converted to residential. The hired workers can live on the agriculture zone.
4) Property tax assessment with Williamson Act. Because of the development value, the assessed property tax would only save on the ‘land’ value, not the building value.

B. If it is considered a Williamson Act property
1) City is expected to set clear guideline or put restrictions on how the farming activities can be managed: they would need Poultry farm sanitary practice infections disease prevention?, there need to be clear regulations on machine generated noise, air and land chemical pollution, workers background check and traffic in and out of place - it is commercial.
2) If they would have roosters? That can be very noisy too. 3) We seek city planning to ensure quiet enjoyment right for the neighbors.

Page 476 of 647 ends

III. City planner review - is it unbiased
Many residents feel and express otherwise.
“ it is not unheard of”, One of our commission members said, regarding the difficulty to obtain a permit for an outdoor hot tub, while it seems soooo easy to get over to build a big construction on a steep lot that never has construction on it with little history to support.

Page 477 of 647 ends

Suggestion:

Smaller construction -maybe at the range 2500-4000 sf (including SB9 ADU main building) + driveway, to be comparable houses on the lots with similar features. This is purposed to reduce burden on the slope, reduce risk, secure safety.

Avoid removing soil from the slope area near the 2-3 neighbors directions. Remove soil from the land facing cowden pl is preferred. If not, move dirt from other place to the lot. I have very strong concern if they dig out soil in relevant amount from the slope that linked to the flat area, closer to property of 13119 La Barranca Rd. It is a steep slope there, let’s not to cause any potential of sliding or collapsing
IF not, we would like to request a thorough evaluation of geological condition, architect condition, clear plan on heavy raining days 5-10 days, FoS, ancient slide etc etc. It has to be 360degree with depth -as we see it a high risk construction. And covering potential extreme weather and earthquake considerations.

Clear address to various concerns -
driveway /La Barranca Safety,
commercial poultry and farming
Generator for the septic tank pump?
Please share knowledge if there is comparable project (11,000 sf development on a S>33.3%, LUF at the range of 0.5-0.6, and on the Slope between higher and lower land, with faultlines) approved for a brand new construction.

We Appreciate Your Considerations,
We asked and asked, because we rely on it.

Page 478 of 647 ends
Page 479 of 647 ends

Petition Regarding Proposed Development at Unaddressed La Barranca Road To the Planning Commission
We respectfully submit this petition requesting careful review of the proposed development at Unaddressed La Barranca Road. Given the site's significant topographic, geologic, and land- use constraints, we believe additional scrutiny is warranted before approval of the proposed project.

We respectfully request that the Planning Commission:
• Reduce the Actual development area (before the 'credits' applied) in the Unaddressed La Barranca Lot from 10325+ sf to less than 6000 sf total, including everything,main dwelling unit, accessory units, pool, driveway and agriculture etc.

It is a constrained hillside site with a 33.3% average slope, a Lot Unit Factor (LUF) of 0.554, fault-related limitations, and substantial grading requirements.

Demonstrate the safety and landstability with such an intense development on similarly constrained hillside by historic data, also by technological or engineering advance.

Require comprehensive and independent geotechnical, geological, drainage, seismic, and slope-stability evaluations, including Factors of Safety (FoS), fault assessments, historic landslide investigations, groundwater analysis, and performance during prolonged heavy rainfall and extreme weather events.
• Establish clear standards and conditions to ensure that any Williamson Act agricultural operation remains compatible with neighboring residential properties and does not unreasonably impact residents' quiet enjoyment.
• Address traffic safety, driveway access, environmental impacts, many tree removal, and the operational reliability of the proposed septic pump svstem.

I. is the development advisable, with variance to MDA?
A. Is MDA increase for This lot suitable?
Review Worksheet #1
1) This specific lot has the characters - S is 33.3%, LUF is 0.554. 2) This specific lot has calculated MDA 4155 sf, MFA 2770 sf 3) MDA and MFA are 'allowed to be 7500sf, and 5000 sf,respectively 4) Another note on the worksheet: The MDA and MFA are maximums allowed... City Council or Planning Commission may further limit development area or floor area due to site specific constraints or site visibility.

Discussion point
1) If a lot with LUF below 0.5, the MDA MFA would not be permitted to increase. 2) City also hold a code that if a lot with S >35%, it is conditional development permit gives MDA of 2500 sf
3) This lot S= 33.3%, LUF 0.554, Both are very close to the restriction where No increase would have been allowed, but approximate to a conditioned land restricted with MDA 2500 sf.

Question:
1) Is it truly Safe to allow increase of Development to the maximum allowed, MDA to 7500 st, and MFA to 5000 sf?
2) Is there enough historic data to support such an increase in building size is sound and safe?
3) Is there great innovation in building or geological science technology, material, engineering, to support the increase as "GOOD, IDEAL" now than before? 4) Note, the construction cannot use the only flat area of the lot due to faultline setback..

The 'buildable" area Likely has S > 35%, LUF <0.5.

Had the lot come without the flat area, the city would not have agreed to have increased MDA MFA, and may stick to the 2500 sf of restriction.

Additional Request
1) Thorough report on geological and fault assessment. Mostly on FoS and reveal whether there were ancient slide
2) Independent consultant with knowledge on steep slope buildings.

Worksheet #1 attached.

Page 480 of 647 ends

MPA/MDA

Page 3 ends

TOWN OF LOS ALTOS BILLS

PLANNING DEPARTMENT
26379 Fremont Road • Loe Albor Hills, Calfforola 94022 • (690) 941-7222 + PAX (650) 941-3160 WORKSHEET #1

CALCULATION OF AVERAGE SLOPE, LOT UNIT FACTOR

MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT ARRA, AND MAXIMUM FLOOR ARRA
•TURN IN WITH YOUR APPLICATION •
PROPRITY OWNER'S NAME Barbara Lumbard
PROPERTY ADDRESS La Barranca Rd APN 182-05-034
CALCULATED BY Marvin Lumbard Mechanical Engineer DATE 5/17/21

1. CAT CULATION OF AVERAGE SLORE
A CONTOUR LENGTH WITHIN NET ARBA OF LOT (An)

CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH CONTOUR LENGTH

CONTOUR LENGIS
(INCHES) (INCRIES) (INCHES) (INCHES)
TOTAL
See Attached Spread Sheet
Convert inches to feet (multiply by map scale) = (L) = 8013.43 foot B. AVERAGE SLOPE WITHIN NET AREA OF LOT
8 - (0.0023) ( L) I = contour interval E= total length of Ад - not acreage of An in feet contours in feet lot nearest 001

1.106 acre excluding road cut face et La Barrance
8 - (0.0023)( 2)(8013,43) -

33.3% nearest 0.1%

1.106

2. CALCULATION OF LOT UNIT FACTOR (AND LUF: 1.108 Acres x (1-(02143 x (89,8-10)) LUR - (An)(1 - [0.02143(S - 10)]) * - LUF =1654 nearest, 001 If the average alope le loss thnn, 10%, the XXP for the lot la equal to the get an /the LUF is equal to 0.50 or loss, you will nood a Conditional Derolognit Permit, Make su appointment with B Plotting Direotor for furtber information.

Page 481 of 647 ends

MEA/MDA

Page 4 ends

WORKSHEET #1
(continued)

3. CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT AREA (MDA)
A. for S equal to or less that 10%
MDA- (LUP) (15,000) _ _ squate feet®
B. for S groater than 10% and loss then 30%
MDA - (LUP) [15,000 - 375(5 - 10) * squase feet*
C. 1 for S equal to or greater tono 30% 7500 Per*
MDA - (LUP) (7,500) -_4155 - square feot*
* IE the MIDA is less than 7,500 square foet (and the LUF is greater than 0.50), use 7,500 square feet for your MDA

4. CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM ELOOR AREA (MEA)
A. for S equal to or leas than 10%
MEA -(LUF) (6,000) -- square feet*
for & greater than 10% and loss than 30%
MFA- (LUF [6,000 - 50(6-10)) * square fect**
C. for & squal to or greater than 30% 6000 Per ** _ square fcatte MBA-(LUF (5,000) - 2770
* Be MA 1s lose than 5,000 aquare feet (and the LUP is grostet than 0.50) 150 5,000 aquare fort for ypur MEA
NOTE The MDA and MEA me manimums allowed by the Town Muniolpal Code. The Cly Coumell or the Plaming Commasion may further limit development ares or floor areg toe to site spocitio constrainta or gite vialbility (sco "Site Development Polloy Statament").

DATE

TOWN USE ONLY CORCKED SY

Page 482 of 647 ends

B. It is actually a much bigger development than proposed 7632 sf Review Worksheet #2
1) Please note that there is a total 2693 sqft DA credit applied for SB-9 unit, ADU and driveway. The actual 'real' development area is 7632 + 2693=10,325 sf. 2) Same applied to floored area, it is actually 4810+793+999= 6602 sf floored area 3) These HAS NOT included the planned chicken coop and green house yet. Including those, the development area will be likely another 1000 sf.

Question:
1) In fact, it is NOT a MDA 7500 sf development, it is actually a 10,325 sqft development+ chicken coop (note they want to host 100 chickens, that will be minimally 500 sqft?) and a green house.
2) It is NOT a 4810 sf floored area development, it is actually 6,602 sf floored area 3) Question remains - for this lot, it originally would be qualified with MDA MFA 4415 sf and 2770 sf, respectively, is there precedent data support a development over 11000 sf and floored area above 6600 sf?
With comparable the land condition (Slope, soil type, earthquake zone, faultline, trees and potential atmosphere rivers 3+ times a year when building)? (I would feel much safer to build 4415 sf on a flat 8000 sf lot, than on an acre of steep slope 4) If not, should we not do thorough research and engineering evaluation? What stopped us from a thorough evaluation?
Worksheet #2 attached.

Page 483 of 647 ends

Worksheet #2
Existing and Proposed Development Area and Floor Area
Submit with Application
Property Owner's Name: Naveen Vangala
Property Address: 0 La Barranca Road
Calculated By: Lee & Braze Enginering, Inc. Date: 10-16-2025 )EVELOPMENT AREA
Existing Proposed DA Credit Total
.. House and Garage from part 2.A 4,711 N/A 4,711
793 793 0.
i. Accessory Dwelling Unit from part 2.B.
0 999 900 99
Accessory Building from part 2.C
0 2,636 1000 1,636
). Driveway, Turnaround, and Parking
16 767 0 783

3. Patios and Walkways
N/A 0
F. Recreation Court
403 403

3. Pool and Pool Decking
84 (84) N/A
H. Decks
I. Solar Panels (ground mounted)
J. Any Other Coverage 361 (361)
461 9,864 2693 7632
TOTALS
MDA from Worksheet #1 7500

FLOOR AREA
Existing Proposed FA Credit Total
A. House and Garage
a. First Floor 3526 3526
b. Second Floor
c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202) 607 607
d. Garage 578 578
e. Area Over 17 f (LAHMC 10-1.202)
f. Attic Over 7 ft (LAHMC 10-1.202)
B. Accessory Dwelling Unit (800 credit)
793 793
C. Accessory Buildings
a. First Floor
999 900 99
b. Second Floor
c. Basement (LAHMC 10-1.202)
d. Attic
TOTALS
6503 1693 4810
MEA from Worksheet #1
5000
Town Use Only
Checked By:

Date:

Page 16 ends
Page 484 of 647 ends

C. Other concerns:
1) La Barranca Rd Traffic Safety: Driveway open is currently selected to be at a 'turning' spot where the views from all directions are obstructed. Is there a possible move of the driveway?
2) The plan is to install a pump to transfer waste water to the septic tanks located higher than the dwelling unit. Upon questioned by commission chair lady, their response was that the pump will be underground hence no noise.

Please confirm whether they will put a generator that creates contant noise and smell.

Page 485 of 647 ends

II. Williamson Act Compativity
A. Will it be considered a Williamson Act property?
1) There are clear guidelines from County of Santa Clara Agriculture is the primary use of the land,
A residential unit can only be incidental
2) There are California regulations on Agriculture land-mostly the size above 10 acres, or above 40 acres are two major categories.
3) California Real Estate standard for buying selling agriculture land requires owners do not primarily dwelling there, or the livable area be converted to residential. The hired workers can live on the agriculture zone.
4) Property tax assessment with Williamson Act. Because of the development value, the assessed property tax would only save on the 'land' value, not the building value.

B. If it is considered a Williamson Act property
1) City is expected to set clear guideline or put restrictions on how the farming activities can be managed: they would need Poultry farm sanitary practice infections disease prevention?, there need to be clear regulations on machine generated noise, air and land chemical pollution, workers background check and traffic in and out of place - it is commercial.
2) If they would have roosters? That can be very noisy too. 3) We seek city planning to ensure quiet enjoyment right for the neighbors.

Page 486 of 647 ends

Item 5.1 Supplemental 1
Outlook
Re: 0 La Barranca Septic Tank (Trees)
From Faye HSU <
Date Sun 8/2/2026 6:33 PM
Cc Planning Commission < [email protected]>; Jonathan Fox < [email protected]>; some pictures here for your reference:

1. You can see the two heritage trees to be removed in the first photo. Yet there are still other non- heritage trees at the side. I would say they are not small and are with roots

2. The trees combined provides green canopy for good looking, noise shelding, and privacy. All will be lost or compromised significantly because the septic tank. From our property, it will be a bare looking.

Maybe modify the 'want' of ADU SB9 Farming and Open Space Easement will secure our privacy, look, noise, and Heritage Oak Trees.

Thank you,
Faye
imageOjpeg image1 jpeg
Sent from my iPad
On Aug 2, 2026, at 5:54 PM, Faye HSU < [email protected] > wrote:

Page 487 of 647 ends
Page 488 of 647 ends

Item 5.1 Supplemental 2
Outlook
0 La Barranca Septic Tank
From Faye HSU ‹
Date Sun 8/2/2026 5:54 PM
To Planning Commission < [email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]> Hi Commissioners and Planners,
This is a follow up from reading the recently posted EDPC report.

In the report, it suggests the builder/applicants/architect to change the location of septic tank, if possible.

I digged into it, now I have the thoughts:

It is close to my property line, close to the precious 'flat' area of my lot. Naturally, I would against any possibility affect the future use of my land.

I am aware the LAH has 30 foot setback rule, and Santa Clara County has 10 foot setback requirement The soil is mostly clay type, please pay attention to the Perc situation. On the flat area of their lot (0 La Barranca), they have many big oak trees (heritage oak some) with big roots to interfer with the septic tank and drain, causing the leak. During the construction of the tank, motor and drainage line, the drilling and digging may loosen the dirt on my direction. In addition, with heavy use, delayed cleaning or heavy rain, the waste may 'sit' there in a hot tub like situation, and leak out. It is relatively a 'flat' area - it is still possible to run in the direction to my property if some erosion happens.

Combining soil situation and leak out potential, presence of big roots, soil stability during the construction and 'flat' vulnerable for erosion...In addition to the request in EDPC report, I see risks that directly affect the use of my land.

I would like to support EDPC review and request the applicants and Architect consider change the location of Septic tank to a more 'central' location in their lot, allowing the leach field on the 'south' slope, which is much steeper and i care less...

Architect should adopt a design approach to prevent problems from happending over the use of mitigation methods.

So change of location gives the best solution to it.

Best Regards,
Faye Hsu

Page 489 of 647 ends
Page 490 of 647 ends

Item 5.1 Supplemental 3
From:

To: Planning Commission
Subject: 0 La Barranca project concerns
Date: Monday, August 3, 2026 5:03:53 PM
We are the owners at umbra Vista Ct and have been here nearly 20 years now. Our house is not directly a ut angled facing the proposed La Barranca property.

Attached is a picture of our current views from our bedroom. We have a deck and two upper bedroom balconies that face the property. Their plans to remove such a large number of trees will obviously affect our and our neighbors' views and privacy, especially given the size and scope of their proposal.

Additionally, their justification for the Williamson Act seems very thin at best; a small chicken and/or vegetable operation paired with a large house + ADU +SB-9 unit is clearly meant to develop the properties first, and the agricultural operations are secondary. Simply look at the square footage devoted to the residence versus everything else. The owners say they operate Scripps Farms, but an examination of their website shows nothing available for sale, nor any news about farming (just about developing a blog), nor does a LinkedIn search show any association with the owner and Scripps Farms. If this operation only is in effect or ceases shortly, do the owners continue to receive the benefits of the Williamson Act? What is the enforcement mechanism? They make plenty of promises (noise from chickens, no human traffic, etc) that seem difficult to accept.

It is undeniable that the open space aspect will be lost, and that can not be undone.

Jeffrey Hung and Leigh Lien
Cumbra Vista Ct

Page 491 of 647 ends

From: John O'Connell
Sent: Thursday, August 6, 2026 7:56 AM
To: Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Rajiv Patel <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>
Cc: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Subject: Williamson Act - La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034) – #SD25-0072, VAR25-0016 This submission focuses on what I believe is the first and key determination the Planning Commission must make on this project: Is the proposed Residential Development a "Compatible Use" under the Los Altos Hills Williamson Act (WA) contract? The foundation of the California Land Conservation Act -1965 is Article XIII, Section 8 of the California Constitution [although it is dated 1974, it was previously XXVIII - 1966]. California Supreme court and Appellate court rulings have emphasized that a Williamson Act contract - an agreement for a property taxation at a preferential rate requires a long term enforceable commitment to preserve the land in agricultural or open space use.

Article.XIII?.Section.❹»To.promote.the.conservation?.preservation.and.continued.existence. of.open.space.lands?.the.Legislature.may.define.open.space.land.and.shall.provide. that when.this.land.is.enforceably.restricted?.in.a.manner.specified.by.the.Legislature?to. recreation?.enjoyment.of.scenic.beauty?.use.or.conservation.of.natural.resources?.or. production.of.food.or.fiber?.it.shall.be.valued.for.property.tax.purposes.only.on.a.basis. that.is.consistent.with.its.restrictions.and.uses¡‹
The subject property has been under WA contract for 55 years and in open space use. The owners renewed the rolling 10 year Williamson Act contract in 2026 and have an "enforceable restriction" that limits the property's use to open space and agricultural use until the end of 2035.

The Town is being requested to make a "Compatible Use Determination" for a residential development supporting an agricultural operation that does not exist, on the property that Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 492 of 647 ends

has never been used for agriculture. Although contemplated, the current or future owners could decide not to raise chickens or grow vegetables. The proposed level of the agricultural activity is less than 5% of the property area, and is a choice, not an enforceable commitment on use of the land that justifies a preferential tax rate under Article XIII, Section 8.

The claimed "Compatible Use" is typical of most new residences being built on similar parcels that are not under Williamson Act contracts. Many properties grow vines, orchards,vegetables, plants, etc and some to a greater extent than 5%.

I applaud staff for attempting to apply §51238.1 but (1) & (2) are just not applicable.

A useful Compatible Use test I have found from the Dept of Conservation is Does agricultural or open-space use remain the principal use of the property? • A new residence, an SB9 Unit, and an ADU, totalling ~6,500sf with a basement, with a total development footprint including driveways of ~10,000sf and septic leach fields of 4-5,000sf. The development is ~30% of the parcel. • Given the parcel average slope of 35%, a large area will be significantly steeper than 30% and required as OSE under the LAH general plan and site development codes. • Grading to accommodate the structure on the steep slopes will result in 1,600cy of cut, 220cyds of fill and export of 1,400cy from the site. • To create the development area & leach fields 12 Heritage Oaksand several other mature trees have to be cleared for the development footprint and leach fields. • §51238.1(a)(3) The claimed compatible use will result in more than 1/2 of the contract land being removed from open-space use. and remove a significant area of wildlife habitat.
• The simple facts are that the new residence will be the primary use of the property, there will be some open space easement and possibly some agriculture but no different than exists on other non-Williamson R-A parcels.

Perhaps the clearest answer to the Primary Use question, is to consider how the property would be marketed for sale, after this site development. Would it be:

1. A Williamson Act parcel of just over an acre of wildlife habitat with farming potential and low property taxes.

Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 493 of 647 ends

2. A Private residential estate of 8,000sf on a 1ac scenic location in Los Altos Hills.

Given Williamson Act encumbered properties that have sold in the Town have been $300- 700K per acre, my bet is #2. However, if a Compatible Use determination is made and the property remains under a forever Williamson act contract, it will no longer be an encumbrance and become an asset.

The 1981 Supreme Court ruling [Sierra.Club.vs.City.of.Hayward] focused on the core concept of the Williamson Act contract. The local government and the landowner agree that in exchange for a long term commitment to preserve & maintain farming and to preserve & conserve open space the land owner gets a preferential tax rate. In reverseing the Haywards cancellation of a WA contract the emphasized that the rolling 10 year commitment to restricted use, was the enforceable restriction that supported the conservation objectives of the Williamson Act and justified favourable tax treatment. It further stated that contract cancellation was an extraordinary remedy, not an ordinary planning tool and if the 9 year non-renewal process could be bypassed, this would undermine the long-term conservation objectives embodied in the Williamson Act. This ruling and subsequent Appellate court rulings forced major legislative changes to the Williamson Act. Penalties for material breach of compatible use are specified in §51250. • A development of 2,500 sf of non Compatible Use carries a penalty of 25% of the unrestricted fair market value of the affected land, plus 25% of the the offending building/improvements value for non compatible use development. This is twice the cost of cancellation plus 25% of the value of the improvements. • Considering that most WA properties are more than an order of magnitude larger than 1.16ac. 2,500sf is a small margin before big penalties.

From all parties' perspectives, it would be best to avoid an incorrect compatible use determination - where incorrect means that either the Dept of Conservation or a Court disagrees with it. In addition to the penalties the owner would face, Los Altos Hills would be doing what the after the Supreme court ruled against , not by by approving a cancellation, but by approving a Compatible use that Defeats the Purpose of the Act. An invalid Compatible Use decision would remove the enforceable restriction allowing the land to be developed, but leaving it under Williamson Act contract allowing the land to continue to benefit from a preferential tax rate would violate the Constitution.

Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 494 of 647 ends

This property was one of the first 5 properties to enter into WA contracts. Of the 5, 3 remain under contract. One of the remaining 3 filed a notice of non renewal in 2026. In my search of Town records this is the first property to claim residential development as a compatible use. It has been done in other locations, they are easy to find by searching for WA litigation.

The process for a Williamson Act property that wants to enable residential development, is to file a notice of Non-Renewal at least 90 days prior to the automatic renewal. §51244-45. This is a required step for a petition for contract cancellation §51282(b)(1). to be heard by the Town.

I respectfully submit that:

1. If the Planning Commission were to allow the proposed development as "Compatible Use" on a property bound by a Williamson Act until at least January 2035, this would be an immediate and free removal of the "enforceable restriction" that has supported its preferential tax treatment for 55 years. It would be a violation of the Williamson Act, and if left under a WA contract, a violation of the California Constitution Article XIII, Section 8.

2. The assertion that the LAH WA contract allows the proposed residential development is incorrect. Resolution 616 - 1971 is available on laserfiche and examination of the PC and CC meeting minutes from 1971 show a clear understanding and intention.

3. Given the limited experience in the Town on Williamson Act topics, should you decide that this topic requires further research, that you continue this agenda item to a date uncertain and direct staff to seek guidance from the California Department of Conservation. They are specified by §51206 to advise on interpretation of Williamson Act and associated legislation.

4. The staff recommendation that the PC direct staff to submit a notice of non-renewal on this property, when there are many WA parcels in Town, may not be advisable.

There are many WA issues that the Planning Commission & staff should consider before taking any action on a specific property.

Thank you. . . John O'Connell
The points below are additional pieces of information that may be useful.

Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 495 of 647 ends

SB9 & Williamson Act - A number of jurisdictions have explicit statements that "No SB 9 project is allowed on any parcel subject to a resource protection easement, open space easement or Williamson Act contract." see pg. 4. HCD also state that "Parcels located in multifamily residential, commercial, agricultural, mixed-use zones, etc., are not subject to SB 9 mandates even if they allow single-family residential uses as a permitted use." see pg.2. The SB9 govt code is a spaghetti mess and the reference is 659134,4(a)(6)(B)-(K). This tates conservation easements which are different but the link to this code from §66411.7 specifically states 65913.4 as it read on 09/16/2021. My view on this is jurisdictions would not exclude Williamson act contract without reason, and staff should be directed to get an answer. It may be a good idea to inform the applicants that the SB9 use is under study.

The LAH WA contract has been interpreted that since Primary & Secondary dwellings are a compatible use, and LAH has not defined specific "Uniform Rules" there is nothing limiting the size and scale of such development and they are allowed as specified by the rules under LAH R_A zoning.
• First the contracts clearly state ƒThis.contract.is.entered.into.pursuant.to.Chapter.❸. (commencing.with.Section.❶7866).of.Part.7?.Division.7?.Title.❶.of.the.Government.

Code?.which.is.known.as.the.California.Land.Conservation.Act.of.7❺❷❶¡.This.contract. is.subject.to.all.of.the.provisions.of.this.Act.including.any.amendments.thereto. which.may.hereafter.be.enacted¡.ƒ This means that the DOC interpretations must be considered.
• All LAH Williamson Act contracts are Governed by Resolution 661 -1971 "Establishing Rules Governing the Administration of Preserves & Procedure Relating to the Implementation of the California Land Conservation Act in the Town of Los Altos Hills"
76¡ .Zoning.Requirements¡ .Land.within.an.agricultural.or.open.space.preserve.shall.be. devoted.to.agricultural?.open.space?.and.compatible.uses.as.defined.by.the.Act?.and.as. designated.by.the.City.Council¡ .The.authorization.for.such.uses.as.contained.herein?.and. contracts.entered.hereunder?.shall.not.be.deemed.to.modify.or.take.the.place.of.any. restrictions.imposed.upon.the.land?.or.any.portion.thereof?.within.the.preserve.by.any. zoning.requirements¡.In.no.event.may.the.uses.permitted.by.contract.be.less.restrictive. than.existing.zoning.requirements·.provided?.however?.that.restrictions.imposed.by. contracts.may.be.more.restrictive.than.zoning.requirements¡ Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 496 of 647 ends

The March 8, 1971 Planning Commission motion "that the criteria for eligibility under the Act allow inclusion only of those parcels yet subdividable or yet unimproved in accordance with current Town zoning ordinances." Minutes of prior CC & PC commission meetings show that the intent was to delay the conversion and development of what large areas of natural unimproved and agricultural land into residential development. However, the parcels "yet subdividable were large lots that had a primary residence and at that time the Town allowed secondary residences. The goal was to get them to sign up and not subdivide. In the case of the yet improved parcels subdivision was not the issue, delaying development was the intention.

Item 5.1 Supplemetnal 5

Page 497 of 647 ends

To: LAH Planning Commission
SUBJECT: Public Comment for Planning Commission Meeting Aug 6, 2026 Item 5.1: 0 La Barranca Development Proposal
FROM: Sue Welch
Date: August 6, 2026
_____________________________________________________________________________ Honorable Planning Commissioners,
I urge you to continue the public hearing on this project to a later date to provide staR and Planning Commissioners opportunity to:
— Conduct a formal determination of the feasibility/legality of continuing the existing Williamson Act contract under the proposed development plan — Obtain legal advice from an attorney specializing in Williamson Act contracts The parcel has been under Williamson Act (WA) contract with the Town since 1971 (most recent enrollment date 2025 per Santa Clara County). Although the contract includes "Agriculture" among allowable uses, historic aerial photos (and mature oaks) indicate the parcel has not been used for agriculture. The previous owners met WA requirements by maintaining the parcel as open space and benefitted from decades of significantly reduced taxes. The required annual reports from the owners to the Town describing use of the land and income from the property have not been presented.

The new owners propose residential development on the parcel and a "small farming operation" to produce chicken eggs and potted plants. WA law requires that a residence built on a contracted parcel be "incidental to the agricultural or open space use". The primary use of the La Barranca parcel after the proposed development will be residential, not agricultural or open space. The proposed residential development (primary residence, patio, garage) is 7,500 sq ft (plus an additional 1,693 sq ft for ADU and SB9 units), whereas the area devoted to agriculture will be less than 300 sq ft: a 14 ft x 21 ft combined greenhouse and chicken coop (per Attachment 10). The proposed extensive residential development cannot be considered "incidental to the agricultural or open space use.

Although an open space easement (OSE) area will be dedicated over part of the slopes ≥30% on the parcel, this OSE cannot be included under WA contract because it is required as a condition of approval for development. Landowners must voluntarily restrict their land use in exchange for a tax reduction under the WA. OSEs, which the State allows the Town to routinely require to protect steep slopes and heritage oaks from development, do not —by CA law— confer a tax reduction. Thus, much of the open space area on the parcel that was under WA before the proposed build will be reduced by conversion to required open space

Page 498 of 647 ends

easement. The existing open space area under WA cannot substitute for the OSE area required as a condition of development. The WA open space area can be removed at will (next year?) by the landowner, whereas the required OSE easements must remain in perpetuity.

Santa Clara County oversees WA contracts for parcels located on unincorporated county land. The County requires that a favorable Williamson Act Compatible Use Determination must be issued before a land development application (e.g., use permit, subdivision, lot line adjustment, architectural and site approval) or building permit application may be filed. SCC Compatible Use Determination prior to submission of a development application involves:
— Determination that the contracted land proposed for development is devoted to commercial agriculture [or open space] uses
— Determination that the proposed uses and development are "compatible" with and "incidental" to the documented primary commercial production of agricultural commodities on the contracted parcel.

The Town should follow the detailed guidance the County provides on how to make such compatibility determinations.

The Town is responsible for contracting, monitoring, and enforcing WA contracts, yet has little experience and no expertise managing development on WA-contracted parcels. Even finding the contracts and records for the WA parcels proved a challenge. WA laws are complex and penalties for missteps are large. Penalties for a material breach of contract are no less than 12.5% and up to 25% of the fair market value of the land and any incompatible building and related improvements on the land-— even if the Town errs in approving development that the State finds is incompatible with the contract. I strongly recommend the Town engage a land use attorney specializing in Williamson Act contracts to assist with decisions for development on Williamson Act parcels. It is essential for the Town to make informed – and legal – decisions regarding development on these parcels to avoid potential penalties to the Town and the developer.

Thank you for your consideration and your service to the Town, Sue Welch
LAH Resident

Page 499 of 647 ends

Outlook
Request to postpone September 3 meeting regarding 0 La barranca project From Amy Huang
Date Mon 8/24/2026 11:36 AM
To Planning <[email protected]>
Cc Amy Huang <
Dear Mr. Bradford,
We acknowledge the upcoming meeting scheduled for September 3 regarding the project at 0 La barranca.

At the August 6 public meeting, a recommendation was made for the City Council to adopt a resolution. Since then, we have not been provided with any updates regarding the status of this recommendation, and, to our knowledge, the City Council has not yet adopted a resolution.

To ensure transparency and meaningful community participation, we respectfully request that the September 3 meeting be postponed until all relevant information has been clarified and communicated to all interested parties.

Thank you for your consideration. We look forward to receiving further information regarding the status of this matter.

Sincerely,
Amy Huang
Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone

Page 500 of 647 ends

Item 4.1 Supplemental 6
Outlook
FW: 0 La Barranca
From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Thu 9/3/2026 8:40 AM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
Internal ([email protected])
INKY is learning... Safe Spam Phish More... FAQ Protection by INKY From: Denise ***•
Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2026 8:14 PM
To: Jay Bradford <jbradford@ osaltoshills.ca.gov>
Subject: Re: 0 La Barranca
We as Neighbors of O La Barranca Rd project would appreciate it if the Sept 3 mtg could please be deferred to 10/1 as lots of residents will be out of town during the week of 8/30 to 9/13, which includes 9/3
Thank so kindly.

Denise Del Carlo and adjoining neighbors.

Page 501 of 647 ends

Outlook
FW: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
From: John O'Connell <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 11:58 AM
To: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>
Cc: Wilber, Monique@DOC <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Cody Einfalt <[email protected]> Subject: Re: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
Good morning Farl, see inline responses. I would like to restate that I believe most if not all Williamson Act properties in LAH have followed the contracts they have entered into, including the non renewal and in some cases, cancellation, in accordance with the intent of the act (i.e. conservation and preservation of agricultural and open space land) and with the legal statutes.

The specific problem is one problem is one parcel that had also been compliant for 55 years that changed ownership in March 2025. The new owners are claiming a site development that is clearly not compatible use, to be allowed under their contract. If the Town (LAH) had received good legal advice, this issue would not be occurring. However, it is not easy to find legal support knowledgeable in Williamson Act, it has been a very quiet area for the last decade. Your assistance on this matter is appreciated. I would still appreciate a discussion at your convenience. Thank you. . . John
I have copied the Town's Community Development Director and Town Manager.

A couple of quick questions.

Does the Town have its own local rules and regulations for implementation of the Act within the Town? If so, can you direct me to where I might find those rules? Typically, a participating jurisdiction will allow uses not related, but compatible, to agriculture or open space to be a certain percentage of the contracted land. Does the Town have a rule/regulation like this?
The Town does not have direct Uniform Rules. The two key Eligibility Criteria for a LAH Williamson Act contract were / are
Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 502 of 647 ends

1. A Parcel must be as yet not subdivided (this means that if on flat land a minimum of 2ac and in the case and would vary upto 4.5ac based upon the slope of the land).

2. A parcel must be as yet not improved (i.e. vacant).

Some of the parcels in questions are extremely small. Does the Town have a minimum size for Williamson Act (WA) contracted land within the Town?
The Town does not have a minimum size for a WA contract, the minimum size of a parcel in LAH is 1ac.

Does the Town require that landowners under contract provide evidence of commercial agricultural or open space use?
My understanding is that the SCC Assessors office sends a questionnaire to all Williamson Act contracted owners in both  unincorporated SCC and the Cities in SCC. The Assessors office forwards the questionnaire response to the relevant planning depts. I assume all owners respond accurately. I have spoken with several LAH residents that own properties under contract.

Answers to these questions will help me provide better assistance and answers to your concerns. I am also including my supervisor Monique Wilber in this email just to keep her in the loop.

Thanks,
On Tue, Sep 29, 2026 at 7:43 AM Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]> wrote:

John,
A couple of quick questions.

Does the Town have its own local rules and regulations for implementation of the Act within the Town? If so, can you direct me to where I might find those rules? Typically, a participating jurisdiction will allow uses not related, but compatible, to agriculture or open space to be a certain percentage of the contracted land. Does the Town have a rule/regulation like this?
Some of the parcels in questions are extremely small. Does the Town have a minimum size for Williamson Act (WA) contracted land within the Town?
Does the Town require that landowners under contract provide evidence of commercial agricultural or open space use?
Answers to these questions will help me provide better assistance and answers to your concerns. I am also including my supervisor Monique Wilber in this email just to keep her in the loop.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 503 of 647 ends

Thanks,
Farl Grundy
Associate Environmental Planner
Division of Land Resource Protection
Williamson Act / CEQA
California Department of Conservation
715 P Street, MS 1904
Sacramento, CA, 95814
E: [email protected]
T: (916) 279-2535
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This communication and any files transmitted with it are intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. This message contains information, which may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information may be prohibited. Repeated e-mail transmissions cannot be guaranteed to be secured or error-free, as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete. The sender therefore does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of repeated e-mail transmissions.

From: John O'Connell <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 10:36 PM
To: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>
Subject: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
You don't often get email from [email protected]. Learn why this is important Hi Farl, my apologies for not reconnecting sooner. Jay Bradfors has shared the responses and the statute citations you provided to his questions.However, the issue for Los Altos Hills (LAH) is not which statutes are relevant, but sound interpretation of the statutes. Is it possible to get 30mins to discuss the topic below. Thank you. . . John The key issue the Town is dealing with is a proposed Primary & Secondary residential development on a 1.164ac parcel that has been unimproved and under contract since Jan 1972.

The record shows that the LAH WA contracts have been recognized by the owners as "enforceable restriction". All of the properties that have exited their WA contracts have either done so via notice of non-renewal [§51245], or by filing a petition for cancellation and paying the fee specified in §51283. This is the first property to claim a development that is to the maximum allowed under LAH zoning, plus the maximum allowed under state SB9 & ADU laws to be a "Compatible Use".

Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 504 of 647 ends

Article 2 RESTRICTION ON USE OF PROPERTY of the LAH Williamson Act contract states:
"During the term of this contract, and any and all renewals thereof, the property described in Exhibit B shall not be used by Owner, or Owner's successors in interest, for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto."
Clearly if the new owner of a Williamson Act contracted property can simply claim "Compatible Use" and develop immediately - and to the same extent as a property not restricted by a Williamson Act property, there is no "enforceable restriction" that warrants the property having paid less than 5% of the taxes it would have paid in the last 55 years.

However, it also means it will continue to pay incorrect taxes for an indefinite future.

I have spoken with the SCC Assessor office, and they have advised that LAH proposed action of approving this development but leaving the property enrolled under Williamson act will result in the entire parcel being assessed as a homesite, and no portion assessed under 423 as a restricted valuation. However, they also stated that the entire property will continue to be taxed based upon the base year valuation of the restricted Williamson act parcel. Under 51282.1(a)] the base year valuation of the parcel unencumbered by the Williamson act is triggered by filing of non-renewal.

This problem extends to the property being sold upon development completion, since a Williamson act contract goes with the parcel.

Having read §51238.1(a)(1) and (2) I believe the Town is incorrectly interpreting this language and given the 25+ other WA properties in Town, an incorrect compatible use decision will result in the significant removal of other contracted land in the agricultural preserve from agricultural or open-space use [§51283(a)(3)]. A number of residents are questioning if a property developed to the maximum can have a Williamson Act contract, that they should apply for a contract!
A Compatible Use decision is effectively allowing the property to bypass both Non Renewal [§51245] and the Contract Cancellation process [§ 51280 et seq.] and develop as if it has no restrictions. Although the WA statutes provide local control of both the definitions of and determination of compatibility, does this flexibility allow decisions that as the CA Supreme Court described "defeat the purpose of the act". The exert below is from the 1981 Supreme Court ruling [Sierra Club vs City of Hayward]
In order to deny the tax benefits of the act to short term speculators and developers of urban fringe land and to insure that the constitutional requirement of an "enforceable restriction" is met, the Legislature deliberately required a long-term commitment to agriculture or other open-space use. If neither party gives timely notice to the other of a contrary intent, the contract automatically renews itself each year, tacking on an additional year to the period of restriction. And although the landowner may terminate his contract at any time by giving notice to the contracting government entity, he may not develop the land for the balance of the contractual period of restricted use. (Gov.

Code, § 51246.) fn. 5 Once the landowner serves a notice of nonrenewal, taxes on his property gradually return to the level of taxes on comparable non restricted property, as the term of restriction draws nearer to expiration. (Rev. & Tax. Code, § 426.) This may be a bit of a ramble, but I hope a discussion will help us find a solution. . . John Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 505 of 647 ends

Item 3.3 Supplemental 2
Outlook
FW: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
From: John O'Connell
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 11:58 AM
To: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>
Cc: Wilber, Monique@DOC<[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Cody Einfalt <[email protected]> Subject: Re: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
Good morning Farl, see inline responses. I would like to restate that I believe most if not all Williamson Act properties in LAH have followed the contracts they have entered into, including the non renewal and in some cases, cancellation, in accordance with the intent of the act (i.e. conservation and preservation of agricultural and open space land) and with the legal statutes.

The specific problem is one problem is one parcel that had also been compliant for 55 years that changed ownership in March 2025. The new owners are claiming a site development that is clearly not compatible use, to be allowed under their contract. If the Town (LAH) had received good legal advice, this issue would not be occurring. However, it is not easy to find legal support knowledgeable in Williamson Act, it has been a very quiet area for the last decade. Your assistance on this matter is appreciated. I would still appreciate a discussion at your convenience. Thank you... John
I have copied the Town's Community Development Director and Town Manager.

A couple of quick questions.

Does the Town have its own local rules and regulations for implementation of the Act within the Town? If so, can you direct me to where I might find those rules? Typically, a participating jurisdiction will allow uses not related, but compatible, to agriculture or open space to be a certain percentage of the contracted land. Does the Town have a rule/regulation like this?
The Town does not have direct Uniform Rules. The two key Eligibility Criteria for a LAH Williamson Act contract were / are

Page 506 of 647 ends

1. A Parcel must be as yet not subdivided (this means that if on flat land a minimum of 2ac and in the case and would vary upto 4.5ac based upon the slope of the land).

2. A parcel must be as yet not improved (i.e. vacant).

Some of the parcels in questions are extremely small. Does the Town have a minimum size for Williamson Act (WA) contracted land within the Town?
The Town does not have a minimum size for a WA contract, the minimum size of a parcel in LAH is 1ac.

Does the Town require that landowners under contract provide evidence of commercial agricultural or open space use?
My understanding is that the SCC Assessors office sends a questionnaire to all Williamson Act contracted owners in both  unincorporated SCC and the Cities in SCC. The Assessors office forwards the questionnaire response to the relevant planning depts. I assume all owners respond accurately. I have spoken with several LAH residents that own properties under contract.

Answers to these questions will help me provide better assistance and answers to your concerns. I am also including my supervisor Monique Wilber in this email just to keep her in the loop.

Thanks,
On Tue, Sep 29, 2026 at 7:43 AM Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]> wrote:

John,
A couple of quick questions.

Does the Town have its own local rules and regulations for implementation of the Act within the Town? If so, can you direct me to where I might find those rules? Typically, a participating jurisdiction will allow uses not related, but compatible, to agriculture or open space to be a certain percentage of the contracted land. Does the Town have a rule/regulation like this?
Some of the parcels in questions are extremely small. Does the Town have a minimum size for Williamson Act (WA) contracted land within the Town?
Does the Town require that landowners under contract provide evidence of commercial agricultural or open space use?
Answers to these questions will help me provide better assistance and answers to your concerns. I am also including my supervisor Monique Wilber in this email just to keep her in the loop.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 507 of 647 ends

Thanks,
Farl Grundy
Associate Environmental Planner
Division of Land Resource Protection
Williamson Act / CEQA
California Department of Conservation
715 P Street, MS 1904
Sacramento, CA, 95814
E: [email protected]
T: (916) 279-2535
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This communication and any files transmitted with it are intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. This message contains information, which may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information may be prohibited. Repeated e-mail transmissions cannot be guaranteed to be secured or error-free, as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete. The sender therefore does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of repeated e-mail transmissions.

From: John O'Connell <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 10:36 PM
To: Grundy, Farl@DOC <[email protected]>
Subject: LAH apn:18205034 Williamson Act Enquiry
You don't often get email from [email protected]. Learn why this is important Hi Farl, my apologies for not reconnecting sooner. Jay Bradfors has shared the responses and the statute citations you provided to his questions.However, the issue for Los Altos Hills (LAH) is not which statutes are relevant, but sound interpretation of the statutes. Is it possible to get 30mins to discuss the topic below. Thank you. . . John The key issue the Town is dealing with is a proposed Primary & Secondary residential development on a 1.164ac parcel that has been unimproved and under contract since Jan 1972.

The record shows that the LAH WA contracts have been recognized by the owners as "enforceable restriction". All of the properties that have exited their WA contracts have either done so via notice of non-renewal [§51245], or by filing a petition for cancellation and paying the fee specified in §51283. This is the first property to claim a development that is to the maximum allowed under LAH zoning, plus the maximum allowed under state SB9 & ADU laws to be a "Compatible Use".

Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 508 of 647 ends

Article 2 RESTRICTION ON USE OF PROPERTY of the LAH Williamson Act contract states:
"During the term of this contract, and any and all renewals thereof, the property described in Exhibit B shall not be used by Owner, or Owner's successors in interest, for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto."
Clearly if the new owner of a Williamson Act contracted property can simply claim "Compatible Use" and develop immediately - and to the same extent as a property not restricted by a Williamson Act property, there is no "enforceable restriction" that warrants the property having paid less than 5% of the taxes it would have paid in the last 55 years.

However, it also means it will continue to pay incorrect taxes for an indefinite future.

I have spoken with the SCC Assessor office, and they have advised that LAH proposed action of approving this development but leaving the property enrolled under Williamson act will result in the entire parcel being assessed as a homesite, and no portion assessed under 423 as a restricted valuation. However, they also stated that the entire property will continue to be taxed based upon the base year valuation of the restricted Williamson act parcel. Under 51282.1(a)] the base year valuation of the parcel unencumbered by the Williamson act is triggered by filing of non-renewal.

This problem extends to the property being sold upon development completion, since a Williamson act contract goes with the parcel.

Having read §51238.1(a)(1) and (2) I believe the Town is incorrectly interpreting this language and given the 25+ other WA properties in Town, an incorrect compatible use decision will result in the significant removal of other contracted land in the agricultural preserve from agricultural or open-space use [§51283(a)(3)]. A number of residents are questioning if a property developed to the maximum can have a Williamson Act contract, that they should apply for a contract!
A Compatible Use decision is effectively allowing the property to bypass both Non Renewal [§51245] and the Contract Cancellation process [§ 51280 et seq.] and develop as if it has no restrictions. Although the WA statutes provide local control of both the definitions of and determination of compatibility, does this flexibility allow decisions that as the CA Supreme Court described "defeat the purpose of the act". The exert below is from the 1981 Supreme Court ruling [Sierra Club vs City of Hayward]
In order to deny the tax benefits of the act to short term speculators and developers of urban fringe land and to insure that the constitutional requirement of an "enforceable restriction" is met, the Legislature deliberately required a long-term commitment to agriculture or other open-space use. If neither party gives timely notice to the other of a contrary intent, the contract automatically renews itself each year, tacking on an additional year to the period of restriction. And although the landowner may terminate his contract at any time by giving notice to the contracting government entity, he may not develop the land for the balance of the contractual period of restricted use. (Gov.

Code, § 51246.) fn. 5 Once the landowner serves a notice of nonrenewal, taxes on his property gradually return to the level of taxes on comparable non restricted property, as the term of restriction draws nearer to expiration. (Rev. & Tax. Code, § 426.) This may be a bit of a ramble, but I hope a discussion will help us find a solution. . . John Item 3.3 Supplemental 2

Page 509 of 647 ends

Outlook
RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
From Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 11:11 AM
To Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>

1. The base year value was set at $800,000 on 3/6/24 which was the last purchase date. It was much lower than other buildable sites in LH due to building concerns indicated by the selling agent.

2. No adjustments are made due to Williamson Act contracts. It is compared to similar properties with similar building issues. So Williamson Act is taken into account through the comparables that are chosen. The selling agent informed our office that there were several issues with the property concerning building on it that made us treat it as an unbuildable site.

3. No. Again, the BYV of the land cannot be changed due to a change in use. The land was not completely unbuildable, it just had extra hurdles to jump compared to other properties in the area.

Since you are not the owner, I cannot share what comparables we used.

Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 |e: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org
From: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, September 30, 2026 11:01 AM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]> Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Matt,
Thank you for the detailed explanation. It cleared up how the homesite value is capped by the factored base year value, and why nonrenewal or cancellation would not change the assessment for a parcel this size. We have a few follow-up questions about how the base year value itself was set.

Revenue and Taxation Code §423(d) caps the restricted valuation at the §110 or §110.1 value calculated "as though the property was not subject to an enforceable restriction in the base year." Our understanding from BOE guidance is that this unrestricted base year value is determined at each change in ownership of contract land but is not enrolled while the restricted value is lower. For APN 182-05-034:

1. What unrestricted base year value was established under §423(d) at the most recent purchase, and what is its base year date?
Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 510 of 647 ends

2. Was the purchase price adjusted to remove any discount attributable to the Williamson Act contract? Your example mentioned the parcel may have been treated as non-buildable at purchase. Was that treatment based on the contract, or on physical or regulatory conditions of the site?

3. If the base year value reflects a contract-related discount, can it still be corrected, and what time limits would apply?
We are trying to determine whether the land assessment after construction would differ from that of comparable unrestricted lots purchased around the same time, and, if so, whether the difference reflects site conditions or the contract. Thank you again for your help.

From: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, September 30, 2026 10:12 AM
To: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]> Subject: RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
The land does not get reassessed when a house is built. The homesite value becomes a component of the total Factored Base Year Value. An appraisal of 1 acre of buildable land is performed as of the date that it was last purchased and factored forward to the date of completion of the SFR.

Nothing changes about that assessment if the contract is in non-renewal. It’s just that the discount given to the non-homesite portion is lower and therefore higher in assessed value. The homesite value remains the same. If the contract is cancelled, the entire property assessed value is returned to the FBYV and it is then treated as a normal parcel.

Land is NEVER reassessed unless a change in ownership occurs. If the use of the land changes after the purchase, we cannot, by law, change its value based on the new use. Tax law locks that value in as of the date of purchase.

There is a big difference between FBYV and assessed value. For non-Williamson Act properties, the entire property is typically assessed at its FBYV unless it is on a Prop 8 decline. The assessed value of the land changes significantly but the FBYV remains the same. Putting the contract in non-renewal or cancellation never changes the FBYV, only the assessed value.

In the case where the property is only slightly larger than the 1 acre homesite, as soon as an SFR is built, the value of the homesite becomes the entire FBYV of the parcel, especially if it was treated as non-buildable when it was purchased. Therefore when non-renewal or cancellation occurs when there is a homesite involved, there will be no change to the assessed value because it is already at the FBYV.

This is uniquely the case with property at or slightly above 1 acre.

For example, the property was appraised at its fair market value as of the date of purchase but the Williamson Act restricted value is very small. Let’s say it was appraised at $800,000. Several years later, the FBYV has increased to, say, $900,000. When a home is built, the 1 acre homesite is determined by an appraisal to be $3,000,000 as of the last purchase date. The FBYV cannot support the full $3,000,000 value so the FBYV of $900,000 becomes the value of the homesite because the FBYV of the land CANNOT be changed because no change in ownership occurred.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 511 of 647 ends

This is very complicated but I have tried my best to explain it. Let me know if you have further questions.

Sincerely,
Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 |e: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org
How was my service? Click here for survey. Thank you!
NOTICE: This email message and/or its attachments may contain information that is confidential or restricted. It is intended only for the individuals named as recipients in the message. If you are NOT an authorized recipient, you are prohibited from using, delivering, distributing, printing, copying, or disclosing the message or content to others and must delete the message from your computer. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by return mail.

From: Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 10:34 PM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>; Jonathan Fox <[email protected]> Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Matt,
Sorry to keep coming back to you, but would you be able to help us with some additional questions regarding the property tax implications of the Williamson Act? For a property subject to a Williamson Act contract, how would the land be assessed for property tax purposes following development, and how would that compare to the assessment if the Williamson Act contract were first nonrenewed? Would the assessment be different if the contract were nonrenewed and then cancelled, including payment of the 12.5% cancellation fee?
My understanding is that the new improvements would generally be assessed based on their value as new construction. The question is primarily how the underlying land would be treated.

In this case, the property was purchased at a price below what comparable unrestricted, undeveloped properties in the area might otherwise command, presumably reflecting both the difficulty of developing the site and the existing Williamson Act restrictions.

Would the Proposition 13 base year value of the land generally remain tied to the value established when the property was purchased, subject to the Williamson Act assessment provisions, or could development, nonrenewal, or cancellation of the Williamson Act contract trigger a reassessment of the land?
More specifically, we are trying to understand whether there would be a meaningful long term property tax difference between these three scenarios:

1. The property remains subject to the Williamson Act contract while the permitted development is constructed.

2. The contract is nonrenewed prior to development approval.

3. The contract is nonrenewed and ultimately cancelled, with the owner paying the 12.5% cancellation fee based on the Assessor’s determination of the unrestricted fair market value of the land.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 512 of 647 ends

Would nonrenewal or cancellation itself establish a new assessed value or Proposition 13 base year value for the land, or is the unrestricted valuation used to calculate the cancellation fee separate from the property’s ongoing assessed value?
Ultimately, we are trying to determine whether one scenario could result in a significantly different ongoing land assessment and therefore a long term difference in the property taxes paid after construction.

Thank you again for helping us understand this.

From: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2026 1:22 PM
To: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
It is based on houses on agricultural land in our county and takes into account zoning and setbacks. The R&T code does not specify a definite size and it is left to each county to determine the homesite size.

Sincerely,
Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 |e: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org
How was my service? Click here for survey. Thank you!
NOTICE: This email message and/or its attachments may contain information that is confidential or restricted. It is intended only for the individuals named as recipients in the message. If you are NOT an authorized recipient, you are prohibited from using, delivering, distributing, printing, copying, or disclosing the message or content to others and must delete the message from your computer. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by return mail.

From: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, August 31, 2026 1:56 PM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Thanks very much Matt!
Why does the County use a 1 acre standard for a home site? Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 513 of 647 ends

Jonathan Fox, AICP
Senior Planner
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
P: 650-559-2243 | F: 650-941-3160
E: [email protected]
Stay informed.

Take the Community Development Feedback Survey
Schedule a Meeting with Community Development Staff
From: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Sent: Friday, August 28, 2026 11:14 AM
To: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034
Hello Jonathan,
This is correct. No structures are covered under the Williamson Act and would be valued at their normal Prop 13 value. If there is a home, the county uses a 1 acre homesite for that home that is not covered under the Williamson Act. Since this parcel is only 1.16 acres, the entire value of the parcel would be as a homesite and there would no longer be any Williamson Act reduction.

Let me know if you have any further questions.

Sincerely,
Matthew Leslie | Senior Appraiser
Santa Clara County Office of the Assessor, Neysa Fligor, Assessor 130 West Tasman Drive, San Jose, CA 95134
p: 408-299-5338 |e: [email protected]
www.sccassessor.org
How was my service? Click here for survey. Thank you!
NOTICE: This email message and/or its attachments may contain information that is confidential or restricted. It is intended only for the individuals named as recipients in the message. If you are NOT an authorized recipient, you are prohibited from using, delivering, distributing, printing, copying, or disclosing the message or content to others and must delete the message from your computer. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender by return mail.

From: Jonathan Fox <[email protected]>
Sent: Friday, August 28, 2026 11:04 AM
To: Leslie, Matt <[email protected]>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] 0 La Barranca Road / APN 182-05-034 Good morning Matt,
Staff has reviewed tax assessment information that’s available on the county assessor’s website and also researching other guidelines. Our understanding is that a Williamson Act contract parcel would be assessed for tax purposes in the following manner:

Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 514 of 647 ends

The Williamson Act values would be calculated using land rents and other market data for different types of agricultural uses (depending on the type of use). Using this information, the County would establish an income dollar figure and use that income number, plus other economic factors and capitalization, to determine what the land is worth—its assessed value—under Williamson Act contract. If the property is being used for residential (i.e. a home site), the buildings would be valued under Prop 13 rules. Then the County would determine what the Prop 13 value of the land would be, and then comparing it against the Williamson Act value. The lower of the two values would be included on the tax roll.

Can you confirm this is generally consistent with the approach that County Assessor uses in assessing the property tax for Williamson Act properties? Including this La Barranca parcel (APN 182-05-034)? We are aware that Revenue and Taxation Code section 428 provides that the assessment approach for lands under open space and agricultural contracts do not apply to any residence, including any agricultural laborer housing facility, on the land being valued or to an area of reasonable size used as a site for such a residence, but would appreciate if you can confirm this is the reason a property being used as a homesite would be assessed per its Prop 13 value.

We’re looking to get a better understanding of the process in preparation for an upcoming public hearing.

Thank you,
Jonathan Fox, AICP
Senior Planner
Town of Los Altos Hills
26379 Fremont Road, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
P: 650-559-2243 | F: 650-941-3160
E: [email protected]
Stay informed.

Take the Community Development Feedback Survey
Schedule a Meeting with Community Development Staff
Item 3.3 Supplemental 3

Page 515 of 647 ends

Hanson Bridgett LLP
500 Capitol Mall, Suite 1500, Sacramento, CA 95814
CHRISTOPHER L. POWELL

PARTNER
DIRECT DIAL (916) 551-2804
E-MAIL [email protected]
September 30, 2026
VIA EMAIL AND U.S. MAIL
Honorable Mayor and Members of the Town Council
Chair and Members of the Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
Re: Objection to Proposed Williamson Act Compatibility Determination and Related Entitlements — Unaddressed La Barranca Road, Lands of Vangala & Tokala, APN 182-05-034 (File Nos. SD25-0072, VAR25-0016)
Dear Mayor, Members of the Town Council, and Members of the Planning Commission:

This firm represents Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development, which is comprised of residents of the Town of Los Altos Hills (the “Town”), in connection with the above-referenced application by the Lands of Vangala & Tokala (the “applicant”) to develop the parcel at APN 182-05-034 on La Barranca Road (the “Property”). We write to urge the Town to (1) decline to make an affirmative Williamson Act compatibility determination for the project as proposed; (2) deny, or at a minimum defer, the requested Site Development Permit and related entitlements until the Property’s Land Conservation Contract has been lawfully cancelled in accordance with Government Code sections 51280 through 51287; and (3) decline to rely on a categorical exemption under the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) and instead undertake appropriate environmental review.

Our client does not oppose reasonable use of the Property. They ask only that the Town follow the law that governs land under a Williamson Act contract. As set out below, the project the Town staff has analyzed (more than 6,300 square feet of residential floor area across three dwelling units, together with a driveway variance, a grading exception, and the removal of a substantial share of the parcel’s vegetation) cannot honestly be characterized as “compatible” with the Property’s continued agricultural and open-space use. Approving it under the guise of a compatibility determination would, in substance, terminate the contract without the process, findings, and fee the Legislature requires.

I. BACKGROUND
The Property is a 1.16-acre parcel zoned Residential-Agricultural (R-A). It has been subject to a Land Conservation Contract under the California Land Conservation Act of 1965 (the “Williamson Act” or “Act”), Government Code section 51200 et seq., since the contract was executed in 1971 and recorded in January 1972 (the “Contract”). The Contract restricts the Property, during its term and all renewals, to “the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto,” and lists the compatible uses in Exhibit A.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 516 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
September 30, 2026

Page 2 ends

In exchange, the owner receives a substantially reduced property-tax assessment. (Contract, ¶¶ 1–2 & Ex. A.)
The applicant seeks approval of (1) a Site Development Permit to construct a 4,584-square-foot, two-story single-family residence with attached garage, a 793-square-foot attached accessory dwelling unit (“ADU”), and a 999-square-foot attached unit described as an “SB 9 unit,” together with associated hardscape and site improvements; (2) a variance to permit a driveway wider than the 14-foot maximum; (3) a grading policy exception to allow excavation exceeding the Town’s maximum cut thresholds; and (4) a Williamson Act compatibility determination. (Staff Report to the Planning Commission, Unaddressed La Barranca Road (APN 182-05-034), File Nos. SD25-0072 & VAR25-0016 (Sept. 3, 2026) (“Staff Report”), at 1.) The only agricultural uses proposed are a chicken coop for egg production and a shed for potted plants and vegetables. (Staff Report, at 2.)
On August 6, 2026, after receiving extensive public comment, the Planning Commission voted 4-0-1 (one recusal) to continue the matter and to direct staff to prepare a resolution recommending that the Town Council deny the project on the ground that the project is incompatible with the Williamson Act: “specifically, the Commission’s determination that agriculture would not remain the primary use of the parcel.” (Staff Report, at 2–3.) The Commission expressly “acknowledged that the proposed project is consistent with the uses permitted under the existing Williamson Act Contract,” yet nonetheless “determined that the project did not support a positive compatibility determination.” (Staff Report, at 3.) Our client agrees with the Commission’s conclusion, and writes to explain why it is correct as a matter of law.

II. THE PROJECT AS PROPOSED IS NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE WILLIAMSON ACT A regulation that denies an owner the economically viable use of property, or that goes “too far” in burdening property, effects a taking that the Fifth Amendment and Article I, section 19 of the California Constitution forbid without just compensation. (See Lingle v. Chevron U.S.A. Inc. (2005) 544 U.S. 528.)
A. The Act requires that agriculture or open space remain the primary use; compatible uses are, by definition, subordinate.

The Williamson Act was enacted to preserve agricultural and open-space land by restricting its use in exchange for reduced assessment. (Gov. Code, § 51220.) Land under contract “shall not be used for any purpose other than the production of agricultural commodities for commercial purposes and uses compatible thereto.” (Contract, ¶ 2; Gov. Code, § 51243.) A “compatible use” is defined as a use “determined by the county or city administering the preserve … to be compatible with the agricultural, recreational, or open-space use” of the land, and one that satisfies the statutory principles of compatibility. (Gov. Code, § 51201, subd. (e).) The statutory scheme thus contemplates that the agricultural or open-space use remains primary, and that any compatible use is subordinate and incidental to it. A use that displaces agriculture as the principal use of the land is not “compatible, rather, it is a conversion.

B. A use listed in the Contract’s Exhibit A must still independently satisfy the principles of compatibility in Government Code section 51238.1.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 517 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
September 30, 2026

Page 3 ends

We recognize that Exhibit A to the Contract lists “Primary dwellings” and “Secondary dwellings” among the enumerated compatible uses. That a dwelling appears on the list, however, does not end the inquiry. Whether a particular project is compatible turns not merely on the category of use but on whether that project satisfies the mandatory principles of compatibility set out in Government Code section 51238.1. Those principles require that an approved use:
(1) will not significantly compromise the long-term productive agricultural capability of the contracted parcel;
(2) will not significantly displace or impair current or reasonably foreseeable agricultural operations on the parcel; and
(3) will not result in the significant removal of adjacent contracted land from agricultural or open-space use.
(Gov. Code, § 51238.1, subd. (a); see also Staff Report, at 2–3 [reciting the same principles].) These principles operate as a statutory floor. While the Town may, by rule or contract, add to or make more restrictive the uses it treats as compatible (Gov. Code, § 51231; Contract, ¶ 2), it may not treat a use as compatible on terms less protective than section 51238.1 demands.

Neither the Contract’s Exhibit A nor the Town’s Resolution No. 616, which, as staff acknowledges, merely cross-references uses permitted in the R-A zone (Staff Report, at 2–3), can authorize a project that fails the section 51238.1 principles as applied to this parcel.

C. As applied here, the project fails the principles of compatibility: it makes residential use primary and agriculture incidental.

The project proposes more than 6,300 square feet of residential floor area, a 4,584-square-foot house, a 793-square-foot ADU, and a 999-square-foot additional unit, plus an attached garage, hardscape, an oversized driveway requiring a variance, and grading that exceeds the Town’s maximum cut thresholds and so requires a grading policy exception. (Staff Report, at 1.) Against that, the entirety of the proposed “agriculture” is a chicken coop and a potted-plant shed. (Staff Report, at 2.) According to the applicant’s own plans, the project would remove roughly 41 percent of the 1.16-acre parcel from agricultural or open-space use, leaving approximately 59 percent. (Applicant’s plans; see Staff Report, Attach. 5 [Farming Operation and Business Plan] & Attach. 6 [Worksheet 1-2].)
On these facts, agriculture plainly would not “remain the primary use of the parcel,” the very conclusion the Planning Commission reached. (Staff Report, at 3.) A backyard chicken coop and a shed of potted plants are not the principal use of a parcel dominated by a multi-unit residential compound; they are incidental to it. That inversion, residence as the primary use, agriculture as the incidental use, is the opposite of what the Act permits, and it “significantly compromise[s]” and “displace[s]” the parcel’s agricultural capability and operations within the meaning of section 51238.1, subdivisions (a)(1) and (a)(2). The permanent removal of a large share of the parcel’s vegetation and of significant trees to accommodate the residence, driveway, and grading only underscores the point.

We note as well that the compatibility of residential structures on contracted land has historically been understood to turn on their relationship to the agricultural operation — for example, housing for agricultural labor reasonably required by the farming use. The proposed agricultural Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 518 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
September 30, 2026

Page 4 ends

operation here (a chicken coop and potted plants) requires no year-round labor force, and the residence is not proposed as agricultural-worker housing. That confirms what the scale of the project already shows: the dwellings are the object of the project, not an accessory to farming.

III. A COMPATIBILITY DETERMINATION CANNOT BE USED TO ACCOMPLISH A DE

FACTO CANCELLATION OF THE CONTRACT
The Williamson Act provides two distinct mechanisms that bear on contracted land, and they do very different things. Nonrenewal (Gov. Code, §§ 51245–51246; Contract, ¶¶ 3–4) does not release the land from the contract’s use restrictions; it stops only the contract’s automatic annual renewal, so that the contract runs out over the balance of its remaining term: here, approximately nine years, while the assessed value steps up toward unrestricted value over that period. Throughout the nonrenewal wind-down, the Property remains fully subject to the restriction that it be used only for agriculture and compatible uses. Cancellation (Gov. Code, §§ 51280–51287), by contrast, is the only mechanism that terminates the contract and permits a non-agricultural use before the term expires, and it is disfavored: it requires the Town to make the specific statutory findings prescribed by section 51282 and the landowner to pay a cancellation fee equal to 12.5 percent of the land’s unrestricted fair market value (Gov. Code, § 51283).

That distinction is decisive here, because the applicant proposes to build now, during the contract term. Nonrenewal cannot authorize that construction: even if a notice of nonrenewal were served today, the Property would remain restricted to agriculture and compatible uses for the entire balance of the term, and an estate-scale residence could not lawfully be built during that period. The only mechanism that could authorize this Project before the contract expires is cancellation. Nonrenewal is, at most, a predicate to one of the statutory cancellation routes (see Gov. Code, § 51282), not a substitute for it. The Staff Report’s reference to nonrenewal under section 51245 (Staff Report, at 2) therefore does not answer the objection: a direction merely to initiate nonrenewal would leave the Project just as incompatible with the Contract for every year of the wind-down.

Approving development of this scale under the label of a “compatibility determination” would let the applicant achieve the practical result of cancellation, conversion of the Property to a residential estate, while retaining the Contract’s tax benefit and evading the findings, fee, and public process the Act requires. The courts have long insisted that the Act’s exit provisions be strictly construed and not circumvented. (See Sierra Club v. City of Hayward (1981) 28 Cal.3d 840 [Williamson Act cancellation findings strictly construed].) A local agency cannot do indirectly, through an over-generous compatibility finding, what the statute requires be done directly, through cancellation. If the Town wishes to allow this project, the lawful path is to pursue cancellation, satisfying the section 51282 findings and paying the section 51283 fee, before any entitlement authorizing construction is granted - not to declare an estate-scale residential development “compatible” with a contract that exists to keep the land in agriculture.

Because the compatibility question is close and consequential, we further urge the Town to request a technical advisory opinion from the California Department of Conservation, Division of Land Resource Protection, which administers the Act at the state level, before acting. Doing so would help the Town avoid a costly error and the litigation risk that an unsupported compatibility determination would invite.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 519 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
September 30, 2026

Page 5 ends

IV. THE PROJECT DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR A CLASS 3 CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION The Staff Report proposes to find the project categorically exempt from CEQA under the Class 3 exemption for new construction of small structures. (Staff Report, at 1, 4; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15303, subd. (a).) That exemption is unavailable here for at least three reasons.

First, the Class 3 exemption authorizes “[o]ne single-family residence” outside urbanized areas, and permits “up to three single-family residences” only “[i]n urbanized areas.” (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15303, subd. (a).) Los Altos Hills is a low-density, rural-residential community, and this Property is contracted agricultural and open-space land within an agricultural preserve. A three-unit residential project on such a parcel does not fit the terms of subdivision (a).

Second, even if the exemption otherwise applied, it is barred by the exceptions in section 15300.2. The location exception withholds the Class 3 exemption where the project may affect an environmental resource of critical concern (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15300.2, subd. (a)); Williamson Act agricultural preserve land, and the significant trees the project would remove, are such resources. The unusual-circumstances exception applies where there is a reasonable possibility that the activity will have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances. (Id., § 15300.2, subd. (c); Berkeley Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1086.) The removal of roughly 41 percent of the parcel’s vegetation and of numerous significant trees, grading that exceeds the Town’s maximum cut thresholds, and a driveway that exceeds the Town’s width standard are exactly the kind of unusual circumstances that defeat a categorical exemption.

Third, CEQA independently treats the conversion of, or conflict with, Williamson Act land as a potentially significant impact. (See CEQA Guidelines, Appendix G, § II [Agriculture and Forestry Resources: whether a project would “[c]onflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract”].) Where, as here, a fair argument exists that the project will impair or effectively convert contracted agricultural land, the Town cannot lawfully rely on a categorical exemption; at a minimum, an initial study is required to evaluate the project’s agricultural, biological (tree removal), and related impacts.

V. THE PROPOSED “SB 9 UNIT” RAISES ADDITIONAL ELIGIBILITY QUESTIONS THE

TOWN MUST RESOLVE
The Staff Report describes one of the three units as an “SB 9 unit.” (Staff Report, at 1.) SB 9 (Gov. Code, § 65852.21) does not apply to parcels excluded under Government Code section 65913.4, subdivision (a)(6)(B)–(K), which include prime farmland, farmland of statewide importance, and other environmentally sensitive or protected lands. Before treating any portion of this project as an SB 9 unit, the Town should confirm on the record whether the Property carries any such designation, and should also address whether an R-A parcel enrolled under a Williamson Act contract qualifies as a “single-family residential zone” eligible for SB 9 treatment, and whether a unit being approved through a discretionary Site Development Permit is properly characterized as a ministerial SB 9 unit at all. We raise these as questions the Town must answer, and reserve our client’s rights on each.

Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 520 of 647 ends

Town of Los Altos Hills
September 30, 2026

Page 6 ends

VI. CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, we respectfully request that the Town: (1) decline to make an affirmative Williamson Act compatibility determination for the project as proposed, consistent with the Planning Commission’s determination that agriculture would not remain the primary use of the parcel; (2) deny the requested Site Development Permit, variance, and grading exception, or defer any approval unless and until the Contract has been lawfully cancelled under Government Code sections 51280 through 51287, including the findings required by section 51282 and payment of the cancellation fee required by section 51283; (3) decline to rely on a Class 3 categorical exemption and instead conduct appropriate CEQA review; and (4) consider requesting a technical advisory opinion from the Department of Conservation on the compatibility question.

Our client appreciates the Town’s careful attention to this matter and stands ready to provide any additional information that would assist the Council and the Commission. We ask that this letter be included in the administrative record for the project.

Sincerely,

HANSON BRIDGETT LLP
Christopher L. Powell
Partner
cc: Citizens of Los Altos Hills for Responsible Development Steve Mattas, Esq., Town Attorney (Redwood Public Law LLP) Item 3.3 Supplemental 4

Page 521 of 647 ends

ERIC BREDO Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford < [email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:15 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Eric Bredo <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 2:44 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson [email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschu [email protected]>: Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>: Malika Juna <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter
Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act

Page 522 of 647 ends

contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10 year term followed by sequential one year extensions. That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the

12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

ERIC BREDO Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 523 of 647 ends

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Eric Bredo
Page Mill Rd
PS My property has been in a Williamson act contract for decades and I have always understood this to mean a rolling ten year obligation, meaning it always takes ten years after notifying intent (and paying higher taxes) to get out of it I believe the Town’s interpretation that this number counts down and is then repeated is completely wrong.
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Sent from my iPhone
ERIC BREDO Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 524 of 647 ends

Mark S Barchas Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:15 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Mark S Barchas <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 3:00 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 525 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Mark & Kay Barchas
Elena Rd, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney Sent from my iPhone
Mark S Barchas Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 526 of 647 ends

KK SL Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:15 PM
Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: KK SL <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 3:32 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 527 of 647 ends

KK SL Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted laha. The Willamson ada 5 provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non- agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner- initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land's unrestricted fair market value. I note that the "consistent with the purposes of the Act" cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non- Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative "public interest" finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act's objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act's own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a "compatible use" on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a "compatible use" while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act's material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee's size technically exempts it from the Brown Act's noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Carol Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
Cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney

Page 528 of 647 ends

CAROL TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:15 PM
Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Carol Tam <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 3:37 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 529 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Kinson Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
CAROL TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 530 of 647 ends

KENRIC TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Kenric Tam <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 3:40 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land's unrestricted fair market value. I note that the "consistent with the

Page 531 of 647 ends

purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Kenric Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA. 94022
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
KENRIC TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 532 of 647 ends

ROBERT APTEKAR Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Robert Aptekar <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 4:20 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 533 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Robert Aptekar
Scarff Way, LAH
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
ROBERT APTEKAR Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 534 of 647 ends

CHERYL EVANS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:16 PM
Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Cheryl A Breetwor <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 5:27 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]> Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 535 of 647 ends

CHERYL EVANS Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on ci a contracted land The Willarson t provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non- agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner- initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land's unrestricted fair market value. I note that the "consistent with the purposes of the Act" cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non- Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative "public interest" finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act's objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act's own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a "compatible use" on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a "compatible use" while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act's material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee's size technically exempts it from the Brown Act's noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Cheryl Evans
Buena. Vista Drive
Cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney

Page 536 of 647 ends

C OAKSON Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
-----Original Message-----
From: C Oakson <
Sent: Tuesday, Sep AM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan < [email protected]>; Kavita Tankha < [email protected]>; Stanley Mok < [email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas < [email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Sent from my iPhone

Page 537 of 647 ends

SUSAN MIRBACH Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Susan Mirbach
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 6:42 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 538 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Susan Mirbach
Eucalyptus Lane Los Altos Hills
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
SUSAN MIRBACH Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 539 of 647 ends

Wei Guang Wu Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Wei Guang Wu <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 7:37 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 540 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Wei Guang Wu
La Barranca Rd
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Wei Guang Wu Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 541 of 647 ends

Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada < [email protected]>
From: Denise***
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 8:00 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta lndaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Breda <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter
Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code§ 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 542 of 647 ends

contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10 year term followed by sequential one year extensions. That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the

12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 543 of 647 ends

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Larry n Denise Del Carlo
La Barranca, LAH
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Larry and Denise Del Carlo Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 544 of 647 ends

Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: regarding the La Barranca development proposal
From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: nicholas
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 10:01 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>;Stanley Mok<[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: regarding the La Barranca development proposal September 28, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: regarding the La Barranca development proposal
Dear council,
I have reviewed available documentation on this project, but fundamentally it is just not the type of land from a topographical standpoint (i.e. severe slope) that should be development, even on a single family home basis, let alone multi family units.

The actual parcel sold in 2024 for practically nothing, compared to other LAH properties, because it was such an unbuildable lot. I don't think the town should encourage, or support, construction on such a property.

I'm happy to discuss in greater detail and i understand we may have some limitations, but this project site is not appropriate for housing because of the property slope and unsafe nature around the curve.
i can also support the below statement, but my concern with the project is more fundamental regarding the land.
thanks
Nicholas French
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

Page 545 of 647 ends

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town’s Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions. That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.

Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional-use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non-agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material-breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 546 of 647 ends

nicholas french
la cresta drive
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Thanks,
Nick
Nicholas French
Broker Associate
Christie’s Sereno
1 st Street #200, Los Altos
Nicholas French Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 547 of 647 ends

Barbara Cannon Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:17 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
-----Original Message-----
From: Barbara Cannon <
Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 6:03 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan < [email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco < [email protected]>; Jim Waschura < [email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas < [email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Barbara Cannon

Page 548 of 647 ends

JESSICA TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Jessica Tam <
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 12:34 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo < [email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 549 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision.

Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Jessica Tam
Saddle Mountain Drive, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
JESSICA TAM Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 550 of 647 ends

Eric Evans Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected]>
Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Eric Evans <
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 1:13 PM
To: Rajiv Bhateja < [email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt < [email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 551 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Eric Evans
Buena Vista Drive
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
Eric Evans Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 552 of 647 ends

FAYE HSU Item 3.3 Supplemental 5
Outlook
FW: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter From Jay Bradford <[email protected].

Date Wed 9/30/2026 6:18 PM
To Marco Ahumada <[email protected]>
From: Faye Hsu
Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 10:30 AM
To: Rajiv Bhateja <[email protected]>; Linda Swan <[email protected]>; Kavita Tankha <[email protected]>; Stanley Mok <[email protected]>; George Tyson <[email protected]>; BCC - Birgitta Indaco <[email protected]>; Jim Waschura <[email protected]>; Alisa Bredo <[email protected]>; Malika Junaid <[email protected]>; [email protected]
Cc: Cody Einfalt <[email protected]>; Jay Bradford <[email protected]>; Steve Mattas <[email protected]>
Subject: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter September 29, 2026
Los Altos Hills Town Council
Los Altos Hills Planning Commission
26379 Fremont Road
Los Altos Hills, CA 94022
RE: Requiring Accurate Application of the Williamson Act in the La Barranca Matter Dear Mayor Bhateja, Vice Mayor Swan, Council Members Tyson, Tankha, and Mok, and Members of the Planning Commission:

I am writing as a resident of Los Altos Hills regarding the Williamson Act contract at the center of the La Barranca development matter, which is scheduled to return to Council at its October meeting and which may affect a property central to the Town's Housing Element.

I am asking the Council and the Planning Commission to ensure that any decisions relating to this contract are made in accordance with the actual requirements of the Williamson Act (California Land Conservation Act of 1965, Government Code § 51200 et seq.), rather than an inaccurate characterization of the law. Specifically:

1. The contract term is a rolling 10-year term, not a fixed term. Under Government Code § 51244, absent a filed Notice of Non-Renewal, a Williamson Act contract automatically renews for an additional year on each anniversary date, so the remaining term continually resets rather than counting down on a fixed schedule. It is my understanding that the Town Attorney has represented this contract as though it has a fixed initial 10-year term followed by sequential one-year extensions.

That is not an accurate description of the statute, and I ask that the Town correct any public statement, staff report, or committee discussion that relies on this mischaracterization.

Page 553 of 647 ends

2. There are only two lawful paths to development on contracted land. The Williamson Act provides exactly two mechanisms by which land under contract can become available for non-agricultural development: (a) a Notice of Non-Renewal, after which the existing contract runs its course — nine years, absent a prior non-renewal already on file — before terminating; or (b) a landowner-initiated petition for cancellation, approved by the Town only after a public hearing and the specific findings required under Government Code § 51282, with the landowner paying the statutory 12.5% cancellation fee based on the land’s unrestricted fair market value. I note that the “consistent with the purposes of the Act” cancellation finding under § 51282(b)(1) generally requires that a Notice of Non-Renewal already be on file for the land — cancellation is not normally available straight out of ordinary rolling renewal under that finding, though the alternative “public interest” finding under § 51282(c) does not carry that prerequisite and instead requires the higher showing that other public concerns substantially outweigh the Act’s objectives. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm, in writing and on the public record, which finding would apply here, and that no other mechanism will be used or entertained to allow development of this property in advance of one of these two lawful processes being completed.

3. No compatible-use process may be used to approve housing on this land, and any unauthorized construction must be enforced under the Act’s own penalty provision. Government Code § 51238.1 sets the statutory test for what qualifies as a “compatible use” on contracted land, and even its narrow conditional use exception for nonprime land expressly excludes residential subdivisions. I ask the Council and Planning Commission to confirm that no proposed housing development on this parcel will be treated as a “compatible use” while the contract remains in effect. I further ask the Town to confirm that any unauthorized, non agricultural construction on contracted land will be enforced through the Act’s material breach process under Government Code § 51250 — which carries its own 25% penalty on both the land and the building, separate from and in addition to the 12.5% voluntary cancellation fee — rather than resolved through an ordinary cancellation, which § 51250(w) does not permit.

4. The ad hoc committee should be fully transparent. I ask that the committee reviewing Williamson Act matters related to this property operate with full transparency: all meetings publicly noticed and open to the public, agendas posted in advance, and materials and minutes published, with no substantive discussion or decision-making conducted outside of a noticed public meeting — regardless of whether the committee’s size technically exempts it from the Brown Act’s noticing requirements.

I request a written response confirming how the Town intends to address each of these points, and I ask that this letter be entered into the public record for the October Council meeting on this matter.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter.

Sincerely,
Faye Hsu
La Barranca Rd
cc:

Cody Einfalt, City Manager
Jay Bradford, Community Development / Planning Director Steve Mattas, Town Attorney
FAYE HSU Item 3.3 Supplemental 5

Page 554 of 647 ends
← All documents from this meeting