Agenda packet, second session — Malibu City Council, June 26, 2023 (part 3 of 3)

_____________________
Exhibit A

PRIOR YEAR ADJUSTMENTS
Year Ended June 30, Factor Amount
1991* 1.04220421 -
1992 1.04140000 6,733,751
1993 0.99360000 6,690,655
1994** 1.05185280 8,994,353
1995 1.00206450 9,012,922
1996 1.05453040 9,504,400
1997 1.04837472 9,964,173
1998 1.06041177 10,566,126
1999 1.05764325 11,175,192
2000 1.05993420 11,844,968
2001 1.08330066 12,831,662
2002 1.09976400 14,111,800
2003 1.00655235 14,204,265
2004 1.04509665 14,844,830
2005 1.05252648 15,624,577
2006 1.06502068 16,640,498
2007 1.04770888 17,434,398
2008 1.05171824 18,336,074
2009 1.05186894 19,287,147
2010 1.01525580 19,581,388
2011 0.98268918 19,242,418
2012 1.02899538 19,800,359
2013 1.04164326 20,624,911
2014 1.05845328 21,830,505
2015 1.00548206 21,950,181
2016 1.04671324 22,975,545
2017 1.06265645 24,415,111
2018 1.04281033 25,460,330
2019 1.04198717 26,529,337
2020 1.03839615 27,547,961
2021 1.03615897 28,544,067
2022 1.05085047 29,995,546
2023 1.07023005 32,102,135
CALCULATION OF FACTOR FOR FISCAL YEAR 2023-24
Per Capita Change in Cost of Living 4.44%
Population Change -0.21
Per Capita Change converted to a ratio 1.0444
Population Change converted to a ratio 0.9979
Calculation of factor (1.0444 x 0.9979) 1.04220676
FISCAL YEAR 2023-24 ESTABLISHED LIMIT $33,457,062
Population adjustment figures per California Department of Finance Price Factor and Population information.

Inflation adjustment is based on the California Department of Finance figures used specifically to determine changes in the appropriation limit.
* The City's base year is the first year of full operations. The period ended June 30, 1991 was not a full fiscal year. ** The Base Limit for June 30, 1994 was increased to $8,550,962 pursuant to results of a voter approved increase.

City of Malibu
Calculation of Appropriations Limit
Fiscal Year 2023-24
Resolution No. 23-31

Page 3 of 4 ends

_____________________
Exhibit B
Proceeds of Taxes
(Subject to
Limitation)
Non-Proceeds of
Taxes
(Not Subject to
Limitation)
Discretionary:

Property Taxes 17,946,000 $ - $
Documentary Transfer Tax 1,358,000 -
Utility Users Tax 2,500,000 -
Transient Occupancy Tax 9,500,000 -
City Franchise Fees - 750,000
Sales and Use Tax 8,400,000 -
Parking Tax 600,000 -
Alarm Permit Fees - 30,000
Film Permit Fees - 450,000
Parking Citations - 1,500,000
Motor Vehicle In-Lieu Fees 15,000 -
Vehicle Impound Fees - 75,000
Interest Earnings - 2,529,000
City Hall Use Fees - 20,000
Adopt-A-Storm Drain Fee - -
All Other Revenue - 32,500
Total Discretionary Taxes 40,319,000 5,386,500
Non-Discretionary:

Building Permits - 1,221,000
Coastal Development Permits - -
Building Plan Check Fee - 1,895,000
Geo Soils Engineering Fee - 1,000,000
Environmental Health Review Fee - 550,000
Code Enforcement Investigation Fee - 80,000
OWTS Fees - -
Planning Review Fee - 1,200,000
Public Works Project Review Fee - 375,000
WQMP Fee - 35,000
False Alarm Service Charge - 12,000
Passport Fees - -
Recreation Service Fees - 631,500
Legacy Park - 1,792,534
Civic Center Wastewater Treatment Facility - 2,332,000
American Rescue Plan - -
FEMA/OES Reimbursements - 2,164,090
LA County EWMP Reimbursement - -
All Other Fees - 2,175,478
Total Use and Service Fees - 15,463,602
City of Malibu
Calculation of Proceeds of Taxes Fiscal Year 2023-24
Revenue Sources
Resolution No. 23-31

Page 4 of 4 ends

_____________________
Restricted Revenues:

State Gas Tax 316,286 -
Community Development Block Grant - 66,000
Slide Assessment District Maintenance - 514,876
Parkland Development Fees - 25,000
Art in Public Places - 1,000
Solidwaste Management Surcharge - 145,500
Traffic Safety Fines and Forfeitures - 210,000
Proposition A and C Traffic 603,009 -
Grants - 13,001,509
Measure R 201,129 -
Measure M 233,746 -
Measure W 420,000 -
RMRA (SB1) 280,471 -
Air Quality Management District - 20,000
Law Enforcement Grants - 165,000
Total Restricted Revenue 2,054,641 14,148,885
Total - All Revenue Sources $ 34,998,987 42,373,641 $
Total Appropriations Subject to Limit
Estimated Tax Proceeds for FY 2023-24 42,373,641
Exclusions (see below) (14,012,448)
Appropriations Subject to Limitation $ 28,361,193
Established Limit FY 2023-24 $ 33,457,062
(Over)/Under Limit 5,095,869
Excluded Appropriations:

Certain costs are not subject to the Appropriations Limit including but not limited to debt service, qualified capital outlay, and the costs of complying with a federal mandate.

The following are excluded from the Appropriations Subject to Limitation:

Federal Mandates
Federal Clean Water Act 1,565,297 $
Qualified Capital Outlay
City Hall Leashold Improvements 375,000 $
Malibu Bluffs Park Improvements 327,472
Capital Improvements Projects 8,560,528
Qualified Debt Service
City Hall Land Acquisition 1,503,225 $
Trancas Field Acquisition 590,550
Land Acquisition (Heathercliff, etc.) 1,090,376
Total Exclusions 14,012,448 $
ATTACHMENT 4
RESOLUTION NO. 23-32

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MALIBU

APPROVING THE AUTHORIZED POSITIONS AND SALARY RANGES FOR FISCAL YEAR 2023-2024 AND THE DEPUTY PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTORMAINTENANCE AND OPERATIONS DIVISION, AND ENGINEERING

TECHNICIAN JOB SPECIFICATIONS
The City Council of the City of Malibu does hereby find, order and resolve as follows:

SECTION 1. The City Council has reviewed the Authorized Positions and Salary Ranges for Fiscal Year 2023-2024 as set forth in Exhibit A.

SECTION 2. The Authorized Positions and Salary Ranges for Fiscal Year 2023-2024 incorporated herein by this reference are hereby approved.

SECTION 3. The City Manager has the authority to increase a salary range as needed for authorized positions that are required to be on call for emergency services by a maximum of three percent.

SECTION 4. The Job Specifications for Deputy Public Works Director-Maintenance and Operations Division, and Engineering Technician, as set forth in Exhibit B, are hereby approved.

SECTION 5. This resolution shall become effective on July 1, 2023.

SECTION 6. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions.

PASSED, APPROVED, and ADOPTED this 26th day of June, 2023. _____________________________
BRUCE SILVERSTEIN, Mayor
ATTEST:
__________________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________________
TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 2 of 16 ends

_____________________

EXHIBIT A

CITY OF MALIBU

AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL
PROPOSED FOR FY 2023-24
2022-23 2022-23 2023-24
Adopted Amended Proposed

MANAGEMENT & ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
City Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Assistant City Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Deputy City Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Assistant to the City Manager 0.00 0.00 0.00
Executive Assistant 1.00 1.00 1.00
City Clerk 1.00 1.00 1.00
Assistant City Clerk 0.00 1.00 1.00
Deputy City Clerk 2.00 1.00 1.00
Human Resources Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Human Resources Analyst 1.00 1.00 1.00
Human Resources Technician 1.00 1.00 1.00
Media Information Officer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Media Analyst 1.00 1.00 1.00
Media Technician 1.00 1.00 1.00
Graphic Artist 1.00 1.00 1.00
Finance Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Financial Analyst 0.00 1.00 1.00
Grants Analyst 1.00 1.00 1.00
Accounting Technician 1.00 0.00 1.00
Sr. Accounting Clerk 1.00 1.00 0.00
Accounting Clerk 1.00 1.00 1.00
Information Systems Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Information Systems Administrator 0.00 0.00 1.00
Information Systems Analyst 1.00 1.00 1.00
Information Systems Technician 1.00 1.00 1.00
Sr. PW Maintenance Worker 1.00 1.00 1.00
Sr. Office Assistant 1.00 0.00 0.00
Office Assistant 0.00 0.00 1.00
Office Assistant/Receptionist 1.00 2.00 1.00
Total 25.00 25.00 26.00

PUBLIC SAFETY
Public Safety Director 1.00 1.00 1.00
Public Safety Manager 0.00 0.00 0.00
Fire Safety Liaison (Part-Time) 1.50 1.50 1.50
Public Safety Liaison 1.00 1.00 1.00
Emergency Services Coordinator 1.00 1.00 1.00
Public Safety Specialist 0.00 0.00 0.00
Resolution No. 23-32

Page 3 of 16 ends

_____________________
Total 4.50 4.50 4.50

ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
ESD Director/Building Official 1.00 1.00 1.00
ESD Manager/Deputy Building Official 0.00 0.00 0.00
Senior Civil Engineer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Associate Civil Engineer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Supervising Inspector 1.00 1.00 1.00
Sr. Building Inspector 1.00 1.00 1.00
Building Inspector 2.00 2.00 2.00
Principal Permit Technician 1.00 1.00 1.00
Sr. Permit Services Technician 1.00 1.00 1.00
Permit Services Technician 2.00 2.00 2.00
Environmental Health Administrator 1.00 1.00 1.00
Wastewater Man. Program Specialist 1.00 1.00 1.00
Environmental Programs Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Senior Environmental Programs Coordinator 1.00 1.00 0.00 Environmental Program Coordinator 1.00 1.00 1.00
Environmental Sustainability Analyst 1.00 1.00 2.00
Administrative Analyst 0.00 0.00 0.00
Sr. Administrative Assistant 0.00 1.00 1.00
Administrative Assistant 1.00 1.00 1.00
Sr. Office Assistant 0.00 1.00 1.00
Office Assistant 2.00 1.00 1.00
Total 20.00 21.00 21.00

PLANNING DEPARTMENT
Planning Director 1.00 1.00 1.00
Assistant Planning Director 1.00 1.00 1.00
Development Services Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Principal Planner 1.00 1.00 2.00
Senior Planner 2.00 3.00 3.00
Associate Planner 3.00 2.00 3.00
Assistant Planner 4.00 3.00 4.00
Planning Technician 4.00 5.00 4.00
Code Enforcement Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Senior Code Enforcement Officer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Code Enforcement Officer 2.00 2.00 2.00
Administrative Analyst 0.00 0.00 1.00
Administrative Assistant 2.00 2.00 2.00
Senior Office Assistant 0.00 0.00 1.00
Office Assistant 2.00 2.00 1.00
Planning Intern (Two Half-time) 1.00 1.00 1.00
Total 26.00 26.00 29.00
Resolution No. 23-32

Page 4 of 16 ends

_____________________

PUBLIC WORKS
Public Works Director/City Engineer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Assistant Public Works Director/City
Engineer

1.00 1.00 1.00
Public Works Superintendent 2.00 2.00 2.00
Senior Civil Engineer 1.00 1.00 1.00
Associate Civil Engineer 2.00 1.00 2.00
Assistant Civil Engineer 2.00 3.00 2.00
Public Works Inspector 1.00 1.00 1.00
Administrative Analyst 0.00 0.00 1.00
Sr. Administrative Assistant 1.00 1.00 0.00
Administrative Assistant 1.00 1.00 1.00
Total 12.00 12.00 12.00

COMMUNITY SERVICES
Community Services Director 1.00 1.00 1.00
Community Services Deputy Director 1.00 1.00 1.00
Recreation Manager 1.00 1.00 1.00
Recreation Supervisor 1.00 1.00 1.00
Recreation Coordinator 3.00 3.00 3.00
Parks Supervisor 1.00 1.00 1.00
Senior Parks Maintenance Worker 1.00 1.00 1.00
Parks Maintenance Worker 0.00 0.00 0.00
Administrative Assistant 1.00 1.00 1.00
Pool Manager (Part-time) 1.12 1.12 1.95
Lifeguards (Part-time) 2.51 2.51 2.30
Recreation Assistants (Part-time) 9.16 9.16 8.02
Recreation Assistants - Skate Park (Part-time) 0.22 0.22 0.23 Media Assistant (Part-time) 0.26 0.26 0.19
Total 23.27 23.27 22.69
TOTAL EMPLOYEES 110.77 111.77 115.19

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 5 of 16 ends

_____________________

CITY OF MALIBU AUTHORIZED POSITIONS AND SALARY RANGES
FY 2023-2024
Classification Salary Range
City Manager 235,000
Assistant City Manager 182,117 237,621
Deputy City Manager 178,692 233,154
Environmental Sustainability Director/Building Official 173,485 226,361 Public Works Director/City Engineer 173,485 226,361
Community Services Director 161,286 210,442
Planning Director 161,286 210,442
Public Safety Director 161,286 210,442
Assistant Public Works Director/Asst City Engineer 139,332 181,798 Community Services Deputy Director 139,332 181,798
Environmental Sustainability Manager/Dep Building Official 139,332 181,798 Assistant Planning Director 139,332 181,798
Finance/Accounting Manager 135,931 177,358
City Clerk 126,372 164,888
Permit Services Manager 126,372 164,888
Senior Civil Engineer 126,372 164,888
Environmental Programs Manager 122,825 160,259
Public Safety Manager 122,818 160,250
Public Works Superintendent 122,818 160,250
Code Enforcement Manager 120,357 157,040
Development and Operations Manager 120,357 157,040
Information Systems Manager 120,357 157,040
Associate Civil Engineer 109,161 142,429
Environmental Health Administrator 109,161 142,429
Human Resources Manager 109,161 142,429
Information Systems Administrator 109,161 142,429
Principal Planner 109,161 142,429
Assistant City Clerk 104,415 136,236
Assistant to the City Manager 104,415 136,236
Senior Planner 104,415 136,236
Recreation Manager 102,361 133,559
Certified Plans Examiner 99,448 129,756
Senior Environmental Programs Coordinator 96,593 126,033 Senior Administrative Analyst 96,593 126,033
Supervising Building Inspector 96,593 126,033
Assistant Civil Engineer 94,303 123,043
Executive Assistant 91,676 119,615
Environmental Programs Coordinator 89,809 117,179
Environmental Sustainability Analyst 89,809 117,179
Financial Analyst 89,809 117,179
Resolution No. 23-32

Page 6 of 16 ends

_____________________
Associate Planner 89,603 116,911
Fire Safety Liaison 89,006 116,131
Public Safety Liaison 89,006 116,131
Media Information Officer 89,006 116,131
Recreation Supervisor 89,006 116,131
Parks Supervisor 87,778 114,531
Senior Building Inspector 87,618 114,322
Senior Code Enforcement Officer 87,617 114,321
Senior Public Works Inspector 87,507 114,178
Emergency Services Coordinator 85,948 112,142
Administrative Analyst 83,443 108,873
Grants Analyst 83,443 108,873
Human Resources Analyst 83,443 108,873
Information Systems Analyst 83,443 108,873
Media Analyst 83,443 108,873
Senior Accounting Technician 78,955 103,019
Principal Permit Technician 77,400 100,989
Senior Recreation Coordinator 77,400 100,989
Assistant Planner 76,370 99,647
Building Inspector 75,694 98,764
Code Enforcement Officer 75,694 98,764
Deputy City Clerk 75,694 98,764
Environmental Programs Specialist 75,317 98,271
Wastewater Management Program Specialist 75,317 98,271
Public Works Inspector 73,884 96,404
Senior Parks Maintenance Worker 73,281 95,614
Planning Technician 72,091 94,062
Senior Administrative Assistant 72,091 94,062
Senior Media Technician 72,091 94,062
Senior Permit Services Technician 72,091 94,062
Senior Public Works Maintenance Worker 72,091 94,062
Recreation Coordinator 70,367 91,813
Accounting Technician 68,659 89,584
Human Resources Technician 68,152 88,923
Administrative Assistant 63,386 82,705
Parks Maintenance Worker 63,386 82,705
Public Works Maintenance Worker 63,386 82,705
Information Systems Technician 62,268 81,245
Graphic Artist 62,268 81,245
Media Technician 62,268 81,245
Permit Services Technician 62,268 81,245
Records Management Specialist 59,513 77,651
Public Safety Specialist 59,513 77,651
Resolution No. 23-32

Page 7 of 16 ends

_____________________
Wastewater Management Program Analyst 59,362 77,452
Senior Accounting Clerk 57,888 75,532
Senior Office Assistant 55,145 71,952
Accounting Clerk 54,211 70,731
Office Assistant 47,626 62,141
Pool Manager 42,137 54,978
Part-Time Positions - Hourly Rates
Fire Safety Liaison (Part-time) 42.80 55.83
Recreation Assistants I (Part-time) 17.74 23.14
Recreation Assistants II (Part-time) 21.05 27.46
Media Assistant (Part-time) 21.05 27.46
Office Assistant (Part-time) 19.34 25.22
Parks Maintenance Assistant (Part-time) 17.74 23.14
Pool Manager (Part-time) 20.27 26.46
Lifeguards (Part-time) 17.74 23.14
Intern (Part-time) 17.74 23.14
Student Intern 16.90 22.05

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 8 of 16 ends

_____________________

EXHIBIT B

CITY OF MALIBU

DEPUTY PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR

MAINTENANCE AND OPERATIONS DIVISION
Class Description
March 2023
FLSA: Exempt

DEFINITION
Under general direction, plans, organizes, manages, and directs the activities for the Maintenance and Operations Division within the Public Works Department, supervises technical staff and subordinate personnel in the planning and implementation of division functions including streets, storm drainage, wastewater and stormwater treatment plants, and traffic signals; organizes and manages the construction management of City projects, assists in coordinating assigned activities with other City departments, divisions, outside agencies, and the public; fosters cooperative working relationships among City departments, divisions, and with intergovernmental and regulatory agencies and various public and private groups; provides highly responsible and complex professional assistance to the Public Works Director/City Engineer in areas of expertise; and performs related work as required.

SUPERVISION RECEIVED AND EXERCISED
General supervision is provided by the Public Works Director/City Engineer. Technical or functional supervision may be received from the Assistant Public Works Director/Assistant City Engineer. Direct and indirect supervision of supervisory, technical and office personnel assigned to the Public Works Maintenance and Operations Division.

CLASS CHARACTERISTICS
This is a mid-management classification in the Public Works Department. The incumbent oversees, directs, and participates in the operations, maintenance, and repair of the City’s streets, storm drainage, wastewater and stormwater treatment plants, and traffic signals, including development and implementation of short- and long-term repair and replacement capital projects, administration and compliance with Federal, State, and local regulations pertaining to the operation wastewater, recycled water, streets and drainage systems, and provides professional-level support to the Public Works Director/City Engineer in a variety of areas. Successful performance of the work requires an extensive professional background in Public Works construction as well as skill in coordinating construction management activities for City projects. Responsibilities include performing and directing many of the department’s day-to-day administrative functions. This class is distinguished from the Public Works Director/City Engineer in that the latter has overall management responsibility for all public works programs, functions, and activities, and for developing, implementing, and interpreting public policy. An incumbent allocated to this job class must possess exceptional organizational and communication skills as well as extensive knowledge related to the operation, maintenance, and construction programs necessary to support the Public Works Department.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 9 of 16 ends

_____________________
EXAMPLES OF ESSENTIAL JOB FUNCTIONS (Illustrative Only) Management reserves the right to add, modify, change, or rescind the work assignments of different positions and to make reasonable accommodations so that qualified employees can perform the essential functions of the job.
 Collaborates with the Director and assists in the planning, organization, and direction of activities of operation and maintenance functions within the Department of Public Works.  Assumes management responsibility for all operations and maintenance functions and activities of the City’s infrastructure and facilities, including streets, traffic signals, storm drains and drainage systems, wastewater collection system, wastewater and stormwater treatment plant, and recycled water treatment and distribution system operation, maintenance, and repair.  Assumes management responsibility for Public Works vehicle fleet maintenance, and vehicle replacement.
 Participates in the development and implementation of goals, objectives, policies, and priorities for assigned service areas, programs, and operations; recommends and administers policies and procedures.
 Monitors and evaluates the efficiency and effectiveness of service delivery methods and procedures; recommends, within division and departmental policy, appropriate service, and staffing levels.
 Assists the Director in planning, organizing, and directing the Department in the fiscal and administrative activities of the assigned divisions of the Public Works Department.  Assists the Director in the development and administration of the annual budget; forecasts funds needed for staffing, equipment, materials, and supplies; monitors and approves expenditures; makes adjustments.
 Assists the Director in planning, organization, and direction of the Department in construction, maintenance, and repair of City-owned and operated facilities.  Prepares agenda items and makes public presentations to the City Council, Public Works and Public Safety Commissions, and other advisory committees administered by the Department.  Assists with the preparation of operating and capital improvement budgets and control of expenditures, including the preparation of long-term maintenance management models.  Supervises and assists subordinate supervisors in the operations and maintenance of City infrastructure, particularly streets, traffic, wastewater, and storm drainage systems; establish long-range plans and goals.
 Selects, trains, motivates, and evaluates assigned personnel; provides or coordinates staff training; works with employees on performance issues; responds to staff questions and concerns; makes disciplinary action recommendations to the Director.  Coordinates Departmental activities with other department staff and outside agencies and organizations; provides staff assistance to the Public Works Director/City Engineer; prepares and presents staff reports and other necessary correspondence.  Participates in the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) planning activities; provides input into the conceptual design of engineering projects; manages the construction management and inspection activities related to CIP projects.
 Meets and confers with contractors, engineers, a variety of outside agencies, and the general public in acquiring information and coordinating matters related to the City’s streets, traffic signals, storm drainage, wastewater collection system, recycled water distribution system, wastewater and stormwater treatment plants, and related facilities.  May serve as acting Director in the absence of the Public Works Director/City Engineer.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 10 of 16 ends

_____________________
 Performs related tasks as required.

QUALIFICATIONS
Knowledge of:
 Organizational and management practices as applied to analysis and evaluation of departmental programs, policies, procedures, organizational structure, and operational needs.  Principles of project planning, development, coordination, and direction for operations functions and services.
 Principles and practices of municipal budget preparation, monitoring, and administration.  Principles, practices, equipment, and methods used in public works maintenance, construction, and operations work.
 Federal, state, and local laws specifications, rules, and regulations relating to the functions and operations of the department.
 General knowledge of principles and practices of management necessary to plan, analyze, develop, evaluate, and direct the diverse and complex activities of major departmental programs, including organizing, budgeting, staff development, and supervision.  Principles, practices, methods and techniques of public administration and management; federal, state, local laws specifications, and rules and regulations relating to construction and maintenance of public works facilities.
 Principles and practices utilized in the planning and construction of major capital improvement projects.
 Principles, practices, methods and techniques of public administration and management.  Operations, plans, policies, procedures, rules, and regulations common to local government.  Principles of supervision, training, management, and public works administration.  Principles of budget preparation and expenditure control.  Principles and practices of public administration labor relations and public personnel management.
 Principles and practices as applied to the field of operating and maintaining the city infrastructure.
 Technical, legal, and financial issues related to the conduct of municipal public works program.  National Pollution Discharge Elimination Systems (NPDES) permitting and compliance.  Methods of preparing designs, plans, specifications, estimates, reports, and recommendations relating to proposed public works projects.
 Procedures, materials, equipment, and methods used in all areas of public works activities.  Administrative principles and practices, including goal setting, program development, implementation, and evaluation, and supervision of staff.  Public agency budgetary, contract administration, administrative practices, and general principles of risk management related to the functions of the assigned area.  Organizational and management practices as applied to the analysis and evaluation of projects, programs, policies, procedures, and operational needs; principles and practices of municipal government administration.
 Principles and practices of public works program development, maintenance, and management in a municipal setting.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 11 of 16 ends

_____________________
 Federal, State, and local laws, regulatory codes, ordinances, and procedures relevant to assigned area of responsibility.
 Principles and practices of employee supervision, including work planning, assignment, review and evaluation, and the training of staff in work procedures.

Skill in:
 Interpreting and applying various state statutes, ordinances, and codes that pertain to public work functions to ensure that activities are carried out in accordance with the law.  Planning, organizing, and directing the budget, construction, and maintenance of public works projects. Interpreting and applying pertinent laws, rules, and regulations.  Evaluating divisional policy and program practices, defining problem areas, developing, and directing the implementation of policy decisions and practices to improve divisional operations.  Overseeing and coordinating the activities of a number of sections within the Department.  Assisting with the preparation of departmental operating and capital improvement budgets and control budget expenditures.
 Reviewing and interpreting cost estimates.
 Performing a variety of technical research and preparing reports of findings.  Record keeping principles and procedures.

Ability to:
 Direct, control, and evaluate a group of subordinates and maintain consistency with program objectives and standards of the department.
 Initiate, plan, organize, evaluate, and coordinate work assignments with a minimum of direction and control.
 Prepare and enforce department procedures relating to personnel, training, budget, and organization.
 Understand and interpret to others the aims, concepts, principles, and practices of public works engineering and the operations.
 Communicate and interact with personnel at all organizational levels.  Instruct, persuade, negotiate, and motivate individuals with diverse backgrounds and business interests.
 Effectively represent the Department before the Council, Council Committees, boards, commissions, public agencies, and private groups.
 Prepare clear and concise written reports and develop appropriate recommendations.  Effectively manage assigned areas of the departmental program.  Establish and maintain cooperative relationships with those contacted during the course of work.  Manage a large staff of field, office, professional and technical staff.

Education and Experience:

Any combination of training and experience that would provide the required knowledge, skills, and abilities is qualifying. A typical way to obtain the required qualifications would be:

Education: A bachelor’s degree from an accredited college or university with a major in civil engineering, business or public administration, or a closely related field.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 12 of 16 ends

_____________________
Substitution: Additional qualifying experience may be substituted for the education on a year-for-year basis.

Experience: At least eight (8) years of progressively responsible work experience performing a variety of public works construction, mechanics, and/or infrastructure repair and maintenance to include at least five (5) years of supervisory and/or management responsibilities.

License:

Must possess and maintain a valid California class C driver license and have a satisfactory driving record.

PHYSICAL DEMANDS
Position requires sitting, standing, walking on level and slippery surfaces, reaching, twisting, turning, bending, stooping, crouching, grasping, and making repetitive hand movement in the performance of daily duties. The position also requires both near and far vision when inspecting work and operating assigned equipment. The need to lift, carry, and push tools, equipment, and supplies weighing 25 pounds or more is also required. Additionally, the incumbent may work outdoors in all weather conditions, including wet, hot, and cold. The incumbent may use cleaning and lubricating chemicals, which may expose the employee to fumes, dust, and air contaminants, and may be exposed to mechanical hazards. The nature of the work may also require the incumbent to drive motorized vehicles, work in heavy vehicle traffic conditions, and often work with constant interruptions. The incumbent may be required to respond to afterhours emergency call outs and perform routine standby duties.

Some of these requirements may be accommodated for otherwise qualified individuals requiring and requesting such accommodations.

ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS
Employees work in an office environment with moderate noise levels, controlled temperature conditions and no direct exposure to hazardous physical substances. Employees may interact with upset staff and/or public and private representatives in interpreting and enforcing departmental policies and procedures.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 13 of 16 ends

_____________________

CITY OF MALIBU

ENGINEERING TECHNICIAN
Class Description
April 2023
FLSA: Non-Exempt

DEFINITION
Under direct supervision, performs a variety of technical paraprofessional and support related activities in the Public Works Department; maintains project files and engineering records; conducts field surveys and minor inspections; prepares engineering related exhibits using specialized software and maintains related databases; receives and reviews a variety of City permits for completeness; researches engineering topics and prepares reports; performs engineering calculations; provides technical information to the public; and performs a variety of technical tasks related to an assigned area of responsibility.

CLASS CHARACTERISTICS
This classification performs a variety of civil engineering tasks and duties in support of the Public Works Department which requires the application of fundamental engineering knowledge, skills, and abilities.

The work has technical aspects, requiring the interpretation and application of policies, procedures and regulations and involves frequent contact with the public.

EXAMPLES OF ESSENTIAL JOB FUNCTIONS (Illustrative Only) Management reserves the right to add, modify, change, or rescind the work assignments of different positions and to make reasonable accommodations so that qualified employees can perform the essential functions of the job.
 Assists in the preparation/distribution of engineering plans and specifications; coordinates required advertising for bids, reviews construction bids, and makes recommendations based on review of bids, competency of vendors and selection criteria.  Assists in the review of private development plans for compliance with codes regulations and standards; assesses adequacy of applications for permits, determines completeness of submittals and recommends conditions of approval.
 Performs basic design and drafting duties in connection with streets, storm drains, traffic engineering and other projects.
 Reviews applications for encroachment, transportation, street vendors, special events and other Public Works related permits and may issue routine permits.  Researches and provides technical assistance and information to the public and responds to inquiries from contractors, developers, property owners, staff, and the general public.  Creates engineering exhibits using specialized software.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 14 of 16 ends

_____________________
 Organizes and compiles data and maintains computer databases.  Organizes, maintains, and updates department records, tracking lists, permit records and engineering plans.
 Calculates the amount of fees, and deposits necessary to issue related development permits, processes/maintains bonds for acceptance/release, and tracks deposit amounts.  Performs engineering records research on a variety of topics, such as right of way, easements, and property ownership.
 Assists in the preparation of plans, specifications, and estimates pertaining to the construction, maintenance, operation of a variety of engineering, land development and capital improvement projects.
 Performs basic design and drafting duties in connection with streets, storm drains, utilities, and other projects; prepares exhibits using computer aided design software.  Assists in interagency coordination such as securing encroachment permits from other agencies.  Performs field inspections related to permits, capital improvement projects, and maintenance items including signs, sidewalks, curbs, and gutters and other public improvement condition assessments.
 Responds to inquiries from developers, contractors, and the general public regarding City requirements relative to the construction, alteration, and maintenance of public works facilities.  Utilizes GIS applications to develop and maintain asset management system data collection and work management and inventory reporting.
 Performs related tasks as required.

QUALIFICATIONS
Knowledge of:
 Civil Engineering principles and practices in a municipal setting.  Basic design and construction practices of streets, underground facilities, and related public works infrastructure.
 Drafting, surveying techniques and practices.
 Engineering plans, maps, legal descriptions, title reports, local codes, and ordinances.  Engineering mathematics, geometry, and trigonometry.
 General knowledge of Caltrans Traffic and Design manuals, the MUTCD, and Watch handbook.  Engineering plan types, review practices, and permit filings and approval procedures.  Applicable Federal, State, and local laws, codes, and regulations.  Principles and practices of record keeping.
 Modern office procedures, methods, and computer equipment including personal hardware/software (Word, Excel, Access, etc., AutoCAD, GIS, and other specialized engineering software).
 Technical report writing practices/procedures.
 Techniques for providing a high level of customer services by effectively dealing with the public, vendors, contractors, and City staff.
 English usage, grammar, spelling, vocabulary, and punctuation.

Skill in:
 Preparing a variety of plans, specifications, maps, cost estimates, and technical engineering reports.

Resolution No. 23-32

Page 15 of 16 ends

_____________________
 Preparing and updating maps and engineering documents related to City infrastructure.  Organizing, filing, and maintaining engineering records.  Making and recording accurate field engineering observations.  Preparing clear and concise reports, correspondence, policies, procedures, and other written materials.
 Organizing and prioritizing tasks to meet deadlines.
 Accurately performing moderately complex mathematical calculations.  Communicating clearly and concisely, both oral, and in writing.  Using tact, initiative, and appropriate judgment within established policy, procedural and legal guidelines.

Ability to:
 Read, interpret, understand, and prepare engineering plans, specifications, and subdivision maps.  Perform responsible technical engineering support work with accuracy with established timeframes.
 Establish and maintain effective working relationships with those contacted in the course of duty.  Follow oral and written instructions.
 Communicate complex technical information, orally, and in writing to contractors, developers, property owners, employees, consultants, other government agency representatives, City officials and the general public.
 Operate a personal computer, use productivity and specialized engineering software, including spreadsheets, GIS, and AutoCAD.

Education and Experience:

Any combination of training and experience that would provide the required knowledge, skills and abilities is qualifying. A typical way to obtain the required qualifications would be:

Equivalent to graduation from high school. College level coursework in engineering or a related field is desirable. Three (3) years of experience of previous experience in civil engineering, construction, or related industries. Experience in dealing with the public and working in a public agency setting is desirable.

License:

Must possess and maintain a valid California class C driver license and have a satisfactory driving record.

PHYSICAL DEMANDS
Must possess mobility to work in a standard office setting and use standard office equipment, including a computer; to inspect various City infrastructure and development sites, including climbing ladders, stairs and other temporary or construction access points, attend meetings and to operate a motor vehicle; vision to read printed materials and a computer screen and make inspections; and hearing and speech to communicate in person, before groups and over the telephone. The job may involve field inspection work requiring frequent walking to inspection site areas to monitor performance and to identify problems or hazards. Finger dexterity is needed to access, enter, and retrieve data using a computer keyboard or Resolution No. 23-32

Page 16 of 16 ends

_____________________
calculator and to operate standard office equipment. Positions in this classification occasionally bend, stoop, kneel, reach, climb, push, and pull drawers open and closed to retrieve and file information. Positions in this classification occasionally lift, move, and carry objects that typically weigh up to 40 pounds.

WORKING CONDITIONS
May be required to work on evenings, weekends, and holidays. Participates in an after-hours emergency response program for on-call and callback assignments.

ATTACHMENT 5
RESOLUTION NO. 23-33

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MALIBU

ESTABLISHING THE CITY PAYS THE EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE

PORTION OF CALPERS RETIREMENT CONTRIBUTION FOR CLASSIC
MEMBERS AND RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 14-66.

The City Council of the City of Malibu does hereby find, order and resolve as follows:

SECTION 1. The City participates in the CalPERS Retirement System.

SECTION 2. CalPERS has established different contribution rates for employees hired prior to January 1, 2013 (Classic Members) and for employees hired after January 1, 2013 (Public Employees’ Pension Reform Act (PEPRA) Members).

SECTION 3. Each year, CalPERS provides the City with a contribution rate for the upcoming fiscal year for the Employer and Employee rates. The Employer rate fluctuates on an annual basis.

SECTION 4. This resolution establishes that the combined Employer and Employee rate for Classic Member employees will be paid by the City.

SECTION 5. The City will continue to be responsible for the Employer Rate for all employees and PEPRA Member employees will continue to be responsible for the Employee Rate.

SECTION 6. Resolution No. 14-66 is hereby rescinded.

SECTION 7. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions.

PASSED, APPROVED, and ADOPTED this 26th day of June 2023. _____________________________
BRUCE SILVERSTEIN, Mayor
ATTEST:
__________________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________________
TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney
ATTACHMENT 6
RESOLUTION NO. 23-34

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MALIBU
AMENDING PERSONNEL SYSTEM RULES SECTION 3 OF RESOLUTION NO. 15-08
The City Council of the City of Malibu does hereby find, order and resolve as follows:

SECTION 1. On January 21, 2015, the Personnel System Rules were adopted by the City Council by Resolution No. 15-08.

SECTION 2. Section 24.2 of RULE XXIV of the Personnel System Rules established pension plan contribution rates.

SECTION 3. The City of Malibu hereby amends 24.2 of RULE XXIV of the Personnel System Rules as follows:

RULE XXIV. PENSION PLAN

24.2 Contribution Rates
A. Classic Members. The City offers a 2% at 55 formula for miscellaneous members with a one-year highest average of compensation being used as the base for the formula for employees who were employed before January 1, 2013 (Classic Members). The minimum retirement age is 50. The City pays the employer and employee portion of retirement contribution. The City does not contribute to Social Security.

B. Public Employees Pension Reform Act (PEPRA). PEPRA establishes a set formula for employees hired after January 1, 2013, by the City who are not eligible for reciprocity with another California public retirement system or who have had a break in service of employment greater than six months with a CalPERS agency (New Members) of 2% at age 62. Full benefits reach 2.5% at age 67. New Members pay the employee portion. Minimum retirement age is

52. SECTION 4. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions.

Resolution No. 23-34

Page 2 of 2 ends

_____________________
PASSED, APPROVED, and ADOPTED this 26th day of June 2023. _____________________________
BRUCE SILVERSTEIN, Mayor
ATTEST:
__________________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________________
TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney

Page 1 of 2 ends

Agenda Item # 4.B.

Council Agenda Report
To: Mayor Silverstein and the Honorable Members of the City Council Prepared by: Tracey Rossine, Environmental Programs Manager Reviewed by: Yolanda Bundy, Environmental Sustainability Director Approved by: Steve McClary, City Manager
Date prepared: June 7, 2023 Meeting date: June 26, 2023 Subject: Collection of Fees for the Implementation of the California Integrated Waste Management Act within the Malibu Garbage Disposal District RECOMMENDED ACTION: 1) Conduct the public hearing; and 2) Adopt Resolution No. 23-35 authorizing collection on the County Tax Roll of a fee from residential and commercial premises for the cost of preparing, adopting and implementing the City’s Source Reduction and Recycling Element and Household Hazardous Waste Element imposed by Resolution No. 03-30.

FISCAL IMPACT: These fees will generate approximately $17,980 to the Solid Waste Management Fund (207-0000-3434-00). This action does not increase the fee imposed and collected on the subject properties. Revenue in the amount of $17,500 was included in the Proposed Budget for FY 2023-24.

WORK PLAN: This item was not included in the Adopted Work Plan for FY 2022-23.

This is part of normal staff operations.

DISCUSSION: In 1993, the City Council approved a policy for the reduction and diversion of solid waste from local landfills in conjunction with the requirements of the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989, also called AB 939. In order to fund the costs of the City’s waste reduction and recycling program, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 93-169, establishing fees of $0.60 per single-family household per month, $0.50 per cubic yard disposed per commercial site per month, and $7.20 per single-family household within the Malibu Garbage Disposal District (MGDD) per year, for all properties within city limits. The resolution authorized the City to collect this fee and delegated the solid waste hauling companies to assess this fee in conjunction with the cost for solid waste collection services.

City Council Meeting
06-26-23
Item

4.B.

Page 2 of 2 ends

Agenda Item # 4.B.

Solid waste collection for portions of Malibu within the MGDD is administered by the County of Los Angeles, which assesses properties directly for hauling and disposal costs on an annual basis. Property owners in this district pay the fee authorized by Resolution No. 93-169 to the City, plus the County’s administrative fee through the County Assessor’s Office tax roll. Customers outside of this district pay the solid waste fee directly to their hauler, who then reimburses the City on a quarterly basis.

In June 2003, two public meetings were held to inform the community of this process.

Staff received no objections to the collection of the fee in this manner and City Council adopted Resolution No. 03-30, authorizing this fee to be assessed on the tax rolls annually. This process is now repeated every new fiscal year as required by the County.

The fees for the MGDD must be placed on the property tax rolls for FY 2023-24 by August 10, 2023. Resolution No. 23-35 authorizes the County to collect the fees along with the property tax. The total to be collected is detailed in Attachment 3, subject to any minor parcel adjustments by the County Assessor. Residents outside the MGDD will continue to pay their fee directly to the hauler.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Resolution No. 23-35

2. Notice of Public Hearing

3. Malibu Garbage Disposal District Report of Parcels
Attachment 1
RESOLUTION NO. 23-35

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MALIBU

AUTHORIZING COLLECTION ON THE COUNTY TAX ROLL OF A FEE

FROM RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL PREMISES FOR THE COST OF PREPARING, ADOPTING AND IMPLEMENTING THE CITY’S SOURCE

REDUCTION AND RECYCLING ELEMENT AND HOUSEHOLD
HAZARDOUS WASTE ELEMENT IMPOSED BY RESOLUTION NO. 03-30 The City Council of the City of Malibu does hereby find, order and resolve as follows:

SECTION 1. Recitals.

A. On July 26, 1993, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 93-169 imposing a fee on the collection of solid waste for preparing, adopting and implementing the City’s source reduction and recycling element and household hazardous waste element.

B. On July 14, 2003, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 03-30 authorizing the collection of the fee imposed by Resolution 93-169 on the County tax roll.

C. The City Council desires to collect the fee of $7.20, plus the County’s $0.25 administrative fee per unit on the County tax roll as authorized by California Health and Safety Code Section 5473, and Resolution Nos. 93-169 and 03-30.

D. Section 8.32.370.B. of the Malibu Municipal Code expressly authorizes collection of the fee in this manner.

E. On June 26, 2023, a duly noticed public hearing was held relating to the continued collection of the Fee on the tax rolls, at which time the City Council heard and considered public comment.

F. This resolution does not increase the amount of the fee imposed and collected on the subject properties during the prior fiscal year.

SECTION 2. Pursuant to the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 [Public Resources Code Section 40000, et seq., (Act)], the City is obligated to prepare, adopt, and implement a Source Reduction and Recycling Element and a Household Hazardous Waste Element (Elements)
SECTION 3. Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 41901, the City Council is authorized to impose a fee (Fee) on the collection of solid waste from all residential and commercial premises in the City in amounts sufficient to pay the costs of preparing, adopting, and implementing the element. The Fee was approved and imposed by way of Resolution No. 93-169.

SECTION 4. The City Council hereby finds that notice of the time and place of the public hearing regarding the proposed assessment has been given as required.

Resolution No. 23-35

Page 2 of 2 ends

_____________________
SECTION 5. The City Council, by the requisite two-thirds vote of its membership, hereby elects and approves collection of the Fee imposed by Resolution No. 93-169 on the County tax roll, including an additional administrative charge of $.25 per parcel, on each of the parcels. The Council hereby approves the Malibu Garbage Disposal District Report of Parcels contemplated by Health and Safety Code Section 5473, containing a description of each parcel of real property receiving solid waste services and the amount of the Fee for each parcel computed in accordance with Resolution No. 93-169.

SECTION 6. The Fee shall be collected by the County Tax Collector at the same time and in the same manner and together with City and County property taxes and shall constitute a lien on the parcels from which it is due.

SECTION 7. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions.

PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 26th day of June 2023. _____________________________
BRUCE SILVERSTEIN, Mayor
ATTEST:
_____________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
_____________________________
TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney
Attachment 2

NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING

CITY OF MALIBU

CITY COUNCIL
The Malibu City Council will hold a public hearing on MONDAY, June 26, 2023, at 6:30 p.m. on the item listed below in the Council Chambers at Malibu City Hall, located at 23825 Stuart Ranch Road, Malibu, CA, and via teleconference.

Public comment can be submitted ahead of the public hearing to [email protected] for inclusion in the public record. To view and participate during the public hearing, please review the meeting agenda posted at MalibuCity.org/AgendaCenter and follow the directions for public participation.

COLLECTION OF SOLID WASTE FEES WITHIN THE MALIBU GARBAGE DISTRICT IF YOU CHALLENGE THE CITY COUNCIL’S ACTION IN COURT, YOU MAY BE LIMITED TO

RAISING ONLY THOSE ISSUES RAISED AT THE PUBLIC HEARING DESCRIBED IN THIS

NOTICE, OR OTHERWISE HELD BY THE CITY, OR IN WRITTEN CORRESPONDENCE DELIVERED TO THE CITY, EITHER AT OR PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC HEARING.

If there are any questions regarding this notice, please contact Environmental Sustainability Director Bundy at (310) 456-2489, ext. 229. Copies of all related documents can be reviewed by any interested person at City Hall during regular business hours. Oral and written comments may be presented to the City Council on, or before, the date of the meeting. _______________________________
Yolanda Bundy, Environmental Sustainability Director
Publish Date: June 15, 2023 and June 22, 2023
Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4449001007 18856 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001008 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449001009 18850 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001010 18842 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001011 18834 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001012 18830 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001013 18824 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001014 18814 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001015 18808 TOPANGA BEACH DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449001016 18820 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4449001018 18862 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001019 18862 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001020 18860 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001022 18878 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449001024 18888 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449001026 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002009 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002021 18970 PACIFIC COAST HWY 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449002022 18980 PACIFIC COAST HWY 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449002040 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002041 18964 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449002042 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002043 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002044 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002046 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002047 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002048 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002049 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002050 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002051 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002052 18914 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449002053 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002054 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002055 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449002056 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 1 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4449003005 19112 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003017 19042 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003018 19044 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003019 19046 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003056 19130 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 8 $57.60 $0.25 $57.85 4449003057 19126 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003058 19124 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003059 19118 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003060 19110 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003061 19108 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003062 19100 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003063 19068 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003064 19064 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003065 19062 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003066 19056 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003067 19054 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003068 19052 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449003069 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003070 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003071 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003072 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003073 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003074 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003075 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003076 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003077 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449003078 19014 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004001 19260 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004002 19256 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004003 19252 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449004046 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449004047 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449004048 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449004049 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449004056 19204 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004058 19158 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 2 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4449004060 19150 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449004063 19140 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005009 19324 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005013 19310 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005014 19308 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005015 19306 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005016 19302 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005017 19300 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005018 19264 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449005019 19320 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4449006001 19562 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007001 19728 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007002 19722 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007003 19718 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007004 19710 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007005 19706 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007006 19702 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007007 19688 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007008 19640 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007009 19632 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449007010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449007011 19620 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008001 19858 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008002 19854 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008003 19850 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449008004 19848 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0002MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449008005 19846 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449008006 19834 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4449008007 19830 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008008 19824 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008009 19820 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449008010 19816 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449008011 19812 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008012 19768 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008013 19750 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449008014 19742 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4449008015 19734 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 3 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4449009006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449010004 19453 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449010007 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449010009 19419 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4449010010 19355 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4449010011 19433 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449012003 20109 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449012004 20085 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449013002 20400 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013003 20402 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013004 20404 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013005 20507 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013006 20505 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013007 20503 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013008 20509 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013009 20431 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013011 20529 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449013012 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4449013016 20415 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015004 20860 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015009 20826 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015010 20734 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015011 20776 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015012 20721 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015013 20693 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015014 20743 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015015 20765 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015016 20771 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015017 20773 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015018 20781 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015019 20779 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015020 20777 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015022 20730 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449015023 20832 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4449016007 03651 MCANANY WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450001024 20000 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 4 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450001025 19958 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001026 19954 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450001027 19950 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450001031 19936 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450001032 19932 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001033 19926 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001034 19922 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001035 19916 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001036 19912 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450001037 19906 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001038 19902 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001041 20010 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450001042 20006 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450001044 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450001045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450002037 20136 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002038 20132 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002039 20124 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4450002040 20120 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4450002041 20112 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002042 20108 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002043 20102 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002044 20062 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002045 20058 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002046 20054 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002047 20048 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002048 20044 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002049 20038 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450002050 20032 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002051 20026 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002052 20020 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450002053 20016 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003010 20228 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003011 20224 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003012 20222 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003013 20218 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003014 20214 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 5 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450003015 20212 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450003016 20202 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4450003017 20152 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450003018 20140 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450004028 20422 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450004029 20356 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4450004030 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450004031 20330 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4450004032 20320 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4450004033 20314 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450004034 20308 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4450004035 20300 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4450004036 20288 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450005024 20550 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450005040 20620 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450005041 20542 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005042 20536 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005043 20534 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005046 20438 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005047 20436 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005048 20466 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005049 20464 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005050 20462 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005051 20460 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005052 20454 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005053 20452 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005054 20450 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005055 20448 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005056 20446 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005057 20444 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005058 20612 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005059 20610 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005060 20604 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005061 20602 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005062 20560 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005063 20558 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005064 20526 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 6 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450005065 20524 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005066 20532 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005067 20530 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005068 20540 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005069 20538 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005070 20522 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005071 20520 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005072 20458 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005073 20456 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005074 20616 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005075 20614 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005076 20600 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005077 20562 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005078 20556 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005079 20554 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005080 20548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005081 20546 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005082 20608 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005083 20606 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005084 20442 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005085 20440 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450005086 20516 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006037 20630 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006038 20644 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450006039 20648 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450006041 20700 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4450006042 20710 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 10 $72.00 $0.25 $72.25 4450006044 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006045 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006046 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY 00004-15MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006047 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006048 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY 00006-22MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006049 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 7-23MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006050 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0008MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006051 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY 00009-17MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006052 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 10MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006053 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 7 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450006054 20638 PACIFIC COAST HWY 00012-21MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006055 20624 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006064 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006065 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 02MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006066 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006067 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006068 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006069 20718 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450006070 20656 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 10 $72.00 $0.25 $72.25 4450007018 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450007019 20759 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007020 20747 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 12 $86.40 $0.25 $86.65 4450007021 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450007022 20717 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007023 20705 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007024 20812 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007025 20810 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450007026 20806 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO AMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450007027 20802 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007029 20762 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007030 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450007031 20752 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007032 20748 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007033 20742 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007034 20738 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4450007037 20722 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007039 20766 PACIFIC COAST HWY BMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007040 20770 PACIFIC COAST HWY AMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007042 20726 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450007043 20732 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008034 20816 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008035 20820 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008036 20826 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008037 20828 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008038 20830 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008039 20832 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008040 20836 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 8 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450008041 20838 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008042 20840 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450008043 20842 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450008044 20848 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008045 20852 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450008046 20858 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008047 20862 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008048 20866 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450008049 20900 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008050 20906 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008051 20910 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450008052 20914 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008053 20920 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008054 20928 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450008055 20932 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009015 20940 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009016 20942 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450009018 20954 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009019 20958 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450009020 20962 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009021 20966 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450009022 21000 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009023 21006 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009024 21010 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009025 21016 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009026 21022 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009027 21026 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009028 21030 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009029 21036 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009030 21036 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009032 20944 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450009033 20946 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010017 21048 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450010018 21056 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010019 21062 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010021 21070 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450010022 21100 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65

Page 9 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450010023 21106 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010024 21110 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010025 21116 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010026 21122 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4450010027 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450010028 21150 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4450010030 21064 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450010031 21066 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450011024 20054 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011025 20110 ROCKPORT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011027 20178 ROCKPORT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011028 20121 ROCKPORT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011031 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450011034 20220 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011035 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450011036 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450011037 20252 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011038 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450011041 20130 ROCKPORT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011042 20202 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450011043 20173 ROCKPORT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012022 20464 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012023 20458 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012024 20454 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012025 20452 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012026 20450 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012027 20444 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012028 20279 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012029 20283 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012030 20282 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012031 20276 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012032 20272 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012033 20270 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012034 20260 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012036 20269 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012037 20259 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 10 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450012038 20474 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012039 20484 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450012040 20494 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013058 20249 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013059 20239 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013060 20229 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013061 20219 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013062 20205 INLAND LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013063 20206 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013064 20218 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013067 20246 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013068 20243 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013069 20241 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013070 20235 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013071 20223 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013072 20207 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013073 20324 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013074 20404 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013075 20412 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013076 20414 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013077 20418 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013078 20426 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013079 20434 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013080 20436 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013081 20440 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013082 20247 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013083 20245 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450013084 20238 PIEDRA CHICA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014062 20407 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014063 20419 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014065 20358 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014066 20380 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014067 20395 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014068 20385 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014069 20375 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014070 20365 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014071 20355 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 11 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450014072 20345 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014073 20325 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014074 20309 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014075 20290 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014076 20310 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014077 20330 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014078 20340 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450014079 20350 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015016 20495 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015018 20475 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015019 20455 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015020 20435 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015021 20470 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015023 20494 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015024 20491 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015025 20481 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015026 20471 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015027 20425 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015028 20413 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015029 20405 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015030 20364 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015031 20374 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015032 20384 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015033 20394 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015034 20434 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015035 20418 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015036 20406 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015037 03812 SEAMOOR DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015038 03810 SEAMOOR DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450015040 03800 SEAMOOR DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015041 03801 SEAMOOR DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015042 03811 SEAMOOR DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015043 20521 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015044 20531 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015045 20541 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015046 20545 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 12 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450015047 20520 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015048 20490 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015049 20470 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015050 20468 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015051 20485 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450015052 20480 ROYAL STONE DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016009 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450016010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450016011 20542 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016012 20540 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016013 20538 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016014 20536 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016017 20522 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016018 20514 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016019 20504 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450016023 20534 ROCA CHICA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017008 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450017009 20797 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017011 20790 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017012 20782 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017014 20676 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017015 20674 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017016 20672 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017017 20670 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017018 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450017021 20678 ROCKPOINT ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450017022 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450017023 20700 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018013 20520 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018014 20540 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018015 20548 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018016 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450018017 20585 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018018 20595 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018019 20564 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018020 20566 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018021 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 13 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450018022 20616 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018023 20544 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450018025 20433 SEABOARD RD MALIBU 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019021 20520 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019022 20525 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019023 20533 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019024 20537 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019025 20549 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019026 20632 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019027 20644 BIG ROCK DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019028 20568 PINNACLE WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019029 20555 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019030 20565 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019031 20573 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019032 20512 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019033 20572 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450019034 20556 LITTLE ROCK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020022 20645 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020025 20771 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020026 20753 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020027 20749 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020028 20737 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020029 20754 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020030 20786 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020031 20799 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450020032 20795 COOL OAK WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021043 20706 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021044 20725 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021045 20651 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021046 20649 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021047 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450021048 20643 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021049 20647 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021050 20677 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021051 20653 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021052 20756 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450021053 20743 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 14 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450021054 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450021055 20706 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450022047 20755 SEABOARD RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450022049 20762 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450022051 20765 ROCKPOINT WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450022052 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450024036 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450024037 20967 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450024038 21003 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450024039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450024040 21027 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025034 03923 SIERKS WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025035 03915 SIERKS WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025036 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450025037 03909 SIERKS WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025038 03966 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025039 03950 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450025040 03948 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025041 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450025042 03938 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025043 03932 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450025044 03918 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 22 $158.40 $0.25 $158.65 4450025045 03910 SIERKS WAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026067 21160 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026068 21132 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026070 21108 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026071 21100 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026072 21070 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026073 21066 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026074 21056 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026075 21036 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026076 03908 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026077 03900 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4450026078 03872 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4450026079 03864 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4450026081 03768 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026082 03806 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 15 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450026084 03760 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026089 03766 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026092 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450026093 03740 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026094 03764 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026095 21114 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450026096 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450026097 03860 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450027011 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450027012 21119 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027013 21021 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027014 21025 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027015 21023 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027016 21017 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027017 20963 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027018 20977 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450027019 20991 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450028027 20966 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450028028 20990 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029018 20810 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4450029020 20704 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029022 20654 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029023 20642 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029024 20626 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029025 20607 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029026 20629 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029027 20635 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029028 20645 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029029 20729 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029032 20750 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029033 20734 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029034 20732 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029035 20730 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029036 20728 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029037 20706 LAS FLORES MESA DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 16 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4450029040 20731 EAGLEPASS DR MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4450029041 20740 LAS FLORES MESA DRIVE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001004 21400 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001005 21368 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001006 21366 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001007 21360 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001008 21358 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001009 21348 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001010 21344 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001011 21340 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001012 21336 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001013 21332 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001014 21330 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001015 21324 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001016 21322 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001017 21316 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001018 21314 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001019 21310 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001020 21306 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001021 21300 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001022 21250 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001023 21246 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001024 21244 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001025 21240 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001026 21236 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001029 21216 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451001030 21228 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001031 21226 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001032 21224 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001033 21222 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001034 21220 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001035 21218 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001036 21214 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001037 21212 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001038 21210 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001039 21208 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001040 21206 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 17 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451001041 21202 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451001042 21200 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002006 21606 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002007 21602 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002008 21562 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002009 21558 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002010 21554 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002011 21550 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002012 21546 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002013 21544 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002014 21540 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002017 21528 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002018 21520 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002019 21516 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002020 21510 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002021 21506 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002022 21500 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002023 21468 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002024 21462 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002025 21460 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002026 21434 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4451002027 21424 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002028 21422 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002029 21416 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002030 21414 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002031 21408 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002032 21404 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451002033 21536 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003020 21660 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003021 21658 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003022 21650 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451003023 21644 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003024 21640 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003025 21634 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003026 21632 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451003027 21628 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003028 21624 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 18 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451003031 21614 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451003032 21622 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004010 21920 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004011 21916 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004012 21910 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004013 21906 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004014 21900 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004015 21854 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004016 21848 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004017 21844 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004018 21840 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004019 21836 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004020 21830 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004021 21822 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004022 21818 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004023 21812 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004024 21808 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004026 21756 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004027 21750 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004028 21746 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451004032 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451005007 22102 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005008 22070 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005009 22068 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005010 22062 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005011 22058 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005012 22050 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005013 22048 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005016 22038 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005017 22030 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005018 22028 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005019 22024 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005020 22020 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005021 22012 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005024 21970 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005027 21950 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005028 21942 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 19 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451005029 21938 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005030 21934 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005031 21932 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005032 21928 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005033 21922 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005034 22040 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451005035 21958 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006012 22258 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006013 22254 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006014 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451006015 22244 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006016 22240 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006017 22234 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006022 22202 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006023 22170 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006024 22164 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006025 22160 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006026 22150 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006027 22148 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451006035 22108 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006038 22140 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451006039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451006041 22210 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007001 22585 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007002 22575 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007003 22561 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451007004 22545 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007005 22531 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007006 22511 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007007 22509 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007008 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451007009 03849 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007012 22007 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007013 22029 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007014 22041 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451007015 22053 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45

Page 20 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451007018 22003 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007020 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007021 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007022 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007023 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007024 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007025 22065 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY 6MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007026 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 07MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007027 22065 PACIFIC COAST HWY 8MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451007028 22001 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451008001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451008002 22253 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4451008003 22241 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451008004 22235 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451008005 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451008007 22203 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451008008 22165 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451008009 22159 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 8 $57.60 $0.25 $57.85 4451008010 22147 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 8 $57.60 $0.25 $57.85 4451008014 22227 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451008015 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451008016 22261 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451008017 22125 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 10 $72.00 $0.25 $72.25 4451008018 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451009016 03821 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009017 21930 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009018 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451009019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451009022 21956 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009023 22002 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009024 22042 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009025 22062 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009026 22080 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009028 22420 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009029 22456 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009030 22476 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009031 22516 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 21 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451009032 22540 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009033 22560 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009034 22576 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009037 22350 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009038 22202 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009039 22250 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451009045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451010002 03859 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451010009 21999 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451010010 21967 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451010015 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451010016 03853 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451010018 03873 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451010019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451010020 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011003 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011005 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011007 03900 CARBON CANYON MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011011 03989 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011018 03367 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011019 03359 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011020 03343 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011021 03341 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011022 03345 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011028 03339 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011031 03337 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011032 03305 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011033 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011035 03287 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011036 03279 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011037 21605 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011038 21607 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011040 21613 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 22 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451011041 03235 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011042 03233 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011050 03903 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011051 21647 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011052 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011053 03909 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011054 03919 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011055 21665 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011056 03939 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011063 21488 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011064 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011065 03900 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011066 03910 VILLA COSTERA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011067 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011068 21500 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011069 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011070 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011071 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451011073 03229 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011074 03227 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011075 03347 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451011076 03231 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012013 03705 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012014 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012015 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012016 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012017 03709 CARBON CANYON MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012018 03711 CARBON CANYON ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012021 22251 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012022 22223 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012023 22201 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012024 22165 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012025 22139 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012026 22105 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012027 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 23 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451012028 22035 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012031 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012032 21965 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012033 22451 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012035 22407 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012036 22355 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012037 22349 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012038 22329 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012040 22313 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012041 22031 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012042 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451012043 22271 CARBON MESA ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012044 22281 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451012045 22291 CARBON MESA RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013002 03712 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013013 3083 1/2 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013016 03085 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013021 03203 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013023 03211 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013024 03714 CARBON CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013025 03045 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013026 03095 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013027 03083 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013028 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451013030 03079 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013031 03081 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013032 03077 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451013034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014044 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014045 21544 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014046 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014047 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014048 21566 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014049 21570 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014050 21569 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 24 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451014051 21580 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014052 21588 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014053 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014063 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014064 21587 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014065 21583 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014066 21577 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014067 21571 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014068 21565 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014069 21561 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014074 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014076 21551 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014077 21547 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014078 21609 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014079 21601 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014080 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014081 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451014082 21617 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451014083 21623 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015015 03413 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015016 03375 RAMBLA PACIFICO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015021 21472 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015022 21472 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015024 21454 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015025 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015027 21434 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015028 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015029 03949 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015030 03947 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015031 21426 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015032 21420 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015033 21410 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015034 03840 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015035 03897 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015036 03889 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015037 03885 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 25 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451015038 03881 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015039 03851 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015041 03832 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015042 03824 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015043 03820 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015045 03812 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015048 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015050 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015051 03801 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015053 03823 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015054 03833 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015055 21401 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015058 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015059 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015060 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015061 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015062 21437 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015063 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015064 21455 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015065 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015071 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015072 21497 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015073 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015074 21501 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015078 21471 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015079 21409 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015082 21463 CALLE DEL BARCO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015083 03433 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015085 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015086 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451015087 03849 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451015088 03816 PASEO HIDALGO ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016001 03320 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016002 03327 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016007 03220 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016008 03240 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016009 03237 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 26 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451016010 03255 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016011 03270 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016015 03286 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016016 21535 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016020 21500 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016021 03294 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016022 03222 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016023 21531 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016024 21415 DEERPATH LANE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016025 21511 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016027 03217 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016030 03112 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016033 03140 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451016036 03205 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016037 21424 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016038 21412 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016039 21501 DEERPATH LN MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016040 21425 DEERPATH LANE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016043 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451016044 03180 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016049 03179 SUMAC RIDGE RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016055 21533 DEERPATH LANE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451016056 21515 DEERPATH LANE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017014 21537 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017015 21543 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017016 21549 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017017 21555 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017018 21559 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017019 21563 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017020 21603 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017021 21609 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017022 21613 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017023 21619 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017024 21625 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017025 21629 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017026 21633 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 27 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451017027 21641 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017028 21649 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017029 21657 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017030 21663 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017031 21701 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017032 21711 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017033 21715 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017036 21634 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017037 21628 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017038 21612 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017039 21604 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017040 21590 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017041 21584 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017042 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451017043 21566 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017044 21550 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017045 21540 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017046 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451017047 21532 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017048 21525 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017049 21531 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451017050 21642 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018005 03880 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018006 03884 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018007 03890 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018008 03898 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018009 03900 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018010 03908 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018011 03916 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018012 03922 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018013 03930 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018014 03936 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018015 03942 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018020 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018021 21421 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018022 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018023 21407 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 28 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451018024 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018025 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018026 21389 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018027 21385 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018028 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018030 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018031 21446 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018032 21458 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018033 21466 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018034 21470 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018037 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018038 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018039 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018040 21536 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018042 03950 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018043 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451018044 03958 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018045 21463 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451018046 21533 PASEO SERRA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451019023 03709 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451019036 03713 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451020001 03850 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451020002 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451020003 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451020008 03927 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451020009 03931 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451020010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451020011 03945 LAS FLORES CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451020012 21201 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451020013 21201 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451021001 21217 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451021002 21229 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451021005 21235 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451021006 21247 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451021007 03931 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451021010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451021011 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 29 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451022001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022002 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022003 03865 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022004 03863 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022008 03868 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022009 03870 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022010 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022011 21369 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022014 21349 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022015 21341 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451022016 21335 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451022017 21331 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022020 21351 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 7 $50.40 $0.25 $50.65 4451022022 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022023 03833 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022024 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022025 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022027 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022028 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022032 03816 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022033 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022034 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022035 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022036 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022037 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022038 03850 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022039 03854 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022040 03858 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022041 03864 RAMBLA ORIENTA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022042 21323 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4451022043 21337 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4451022044 21344 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022045 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451022046 21350 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4451022048 21356 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451022050 21361 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05

Page 30 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451022051 21362 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451022052 21368 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4451022053 21370 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022054 21371 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 7 $50.40 $0.25 $50.65 4451022057 21355 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4451022059 21323 RAMBLA VISTA NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022060 21323 RAMBLA VISTA NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022061 03861 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022062 03859 RAMBLA PACIFICO MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451022063 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451023022 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451023023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451023024 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451023025 21415 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023026 21419 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023027 21423 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023028 21429 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023029 21433 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023030 21439 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023031 21443 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023032 21469 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023033 21501 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023034 21507 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023035 21513 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023036 21519 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023037 21490 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023038 21484 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023039 21476 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023040 21465 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023041 21466 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023042 21461 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023043 21460 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023044 21453 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023045 21452 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023046 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4451023047 21442 PASEO PORTOLA ST MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023050 21410 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 31 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4451023051 21400 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023052 21390 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023053 21384 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4451023054 21420 RAMBLA VISTA MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001006 22360 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001007 22350 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001011 22322 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001018 22314 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001019 22338 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001020 22368 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452001021 22310 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002005 22420 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002014 22470 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002015 22400 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002016 22426 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002017 22432 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002018 22440 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002019 22446 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002020 22416 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452002021 22466 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003002 22648 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 10 $72.00 $0.25 $72.25 4452003011 22600 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003016 22514 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452003017 22506 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003027 22660 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 15 $108.00 $0.25 $108.25 4452003028 22640 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 7 $50.40 $0.25 $50.65 4452003029 22616 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003030 22524 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452003032 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003033 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003034 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0102MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003035 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0103MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003036 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0104MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003037 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY 105MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003038 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0108MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003039 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003040 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0111MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 32 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452003041 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 10MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003042 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 11MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003043 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003044 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0203MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003045 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 14MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003046 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0205MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003047 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 16MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003048 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003049 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003050 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003051 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 20MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003052 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 21MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003053 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 22MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003054 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0302MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003055 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 24MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003056 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0304MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003057 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0305MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003058 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 27MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003059 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003060 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0308MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003061 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0310MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003062 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0311MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003063 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0314MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003064 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 33MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003065 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0402MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003066 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0403MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003067 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY 0404MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003068 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0405MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003069 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0406MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003070 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 39MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003071 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0408MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003072 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY UNIT 41MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003073 22548 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003075 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003076 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003077 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0003MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003078 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 33 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452003079 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003080 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 6MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003081 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0007MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003082 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0008MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003083 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 9MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003084 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0010MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003085 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 11MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003086 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0012MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003087 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 14MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003088 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 15MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003089 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0016MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003090 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0017MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003091 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0018MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003092 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 19MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003093 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 20MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003094 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 21MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003095 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 22MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003096 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0023MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003097 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 0024MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003098 22626 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 25MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003100 22630 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003101 22630 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003102 22630 PACIFIC COAST HWY NO 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452003103 22630 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004022 22828 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452004025 22816 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452004027 22852 PACIFIC COAST HWY APT 000AMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452004028 22844 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452004029 22838 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4452004030 22832 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452004032 22800 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452004033 22772 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452004034 22762 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452004035 22752 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452004038 22706 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004040 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452004042 22706 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45

Page 34 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452004043 22810 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452004044 22806 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4452004047 22820 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004048 22822 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004049 22824 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004050 22826 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004056 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY DMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004057 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY CMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004058 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY BMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004059 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY AMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004060 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY FMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004061 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004062 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY GMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004063 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY JMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004064 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY KMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004065 22766 PACIFIC COAST HWY LMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004066 22664 PACIFIC COAST HWY 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004067 22664 PACIFIC COAST HWY 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004068 22664 PACIFIC COAST HWY 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004069 22664 PACIFIC COAST HWY 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452004070 22716 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452005001 23038 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005002 23034 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005004 23018 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005018 23030 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452005020 22860 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 12 $86.40 $0.25 $86.65 4452005022 23022 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452005024 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452005025 23006 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452005029 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452005030 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452005031 22878 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452007002 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452007003 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25
4452008014 23318 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 35 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452008016 23316 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008017 23314 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008018 23406 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008019 23402 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008020 23360 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008021 23356 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008022 23354 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008023 23350 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008024 23346 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008025 00112 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008026 23338 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008027 23334 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008028 23330 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452008030 23324 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009015 23456 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009016 23418 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009017 23416 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009018 23438 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009019 23440 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009020 23450 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009021 23446 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009022 23444 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009023 23430 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009024 23426 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009025 23422 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009026 23414 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452009027 23410 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010002 23501 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010003 23457 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010005 23449 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010008 23425 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010009 23435 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010010 23405 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010011 23403 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010012 23401 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010017 23325 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010019 23505 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 36 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452010022 23457 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010023 23337 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010024 23331 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010027 23445 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010028 23431 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010029 23441 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010031 23351 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452010032 23349 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452019001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452019002 23033 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452019003 23017 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452019004 22969 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452019005 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452019008 22931 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4452019009 22941 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452019010 22935 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452019011 22917 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452020031 22853 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452020097 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452021002 22837 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452021004 22821 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452021006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452021007 22821 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452021008 22809 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452021009 22775 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452022003 22669 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452022004 22619 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452022005 22653 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452022006 22625 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452022007 22661 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452022010 22729 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452022013 22751 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452022014 22761 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452022015 22725 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4452022017 22741 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452023001 22535 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452023002 22541 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25

Page 37 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4452023003 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452023004 22601 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452023007 22525 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452023009 22483 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452023010 22467 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452023011 22455 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 8 $57.60 $0.25 $57.85 4452023012 22445 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4452023013 22449 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452023015 22605 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452023016 22611 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4452023017 22523 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4452024001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452024002 22377 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4452024005 22333 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452024006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4452024012 22343 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452024013 22347 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452024015 22357 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4452024016 22351 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4458001002 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458001003 23664 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458001006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25
4458001007 23644 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458001008 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25
4458002003 23709 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002004 23705 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002006 23687 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002008 23681 MALIBU COLONY DRIVE MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002010 23673 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002011 23667 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002014 23661 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002017 23713 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458002018 23730 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4458002019 23700 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4458002020 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458002021 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458003001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 38 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458003004 23641 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003007 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458003008 23629 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003009 23623 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003012 23601 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003013 23567 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003014 23561 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003015 23555 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003017 23543 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003018 23533 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003019 23531 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003020 00077 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003021 23517 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003022 23515 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003023 23511 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003024 23543 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003025 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458003026 23615 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003027 23611 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003028 23655 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003029 23649 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458003030 23639 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004031 23460 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004032 23500 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004033 23506 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004034 23510 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004035 23512 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004036 23516 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004037 23520 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004038 23524 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004039 23526 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004040 23530 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004041 23536 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004042 23538 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004043 23544 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004044 00070 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004045 23554 MALIBU RD NO 68MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 39 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458004046 23556 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004047 23560 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004048 23562 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004049 23566 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004050 23570 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004051 23600 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004052 23604 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004053 23608 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004054 23610 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458004055 23614 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005021 23700 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005022 23684 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005023 23678 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005024 23674 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005025 23672 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005026 23668 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005027 23664 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005028 23660 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005029 23654 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005030 23652 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005031 23648 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005032 23644 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005033 23640 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005034 23634 MALIBU COLONY RD #50MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005035 23632 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005036 23630 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005037 23626 MALIBU COLONY RD # 53MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005038 23622 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005039 23620 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458005040 23618 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006022 23808 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006023 23800 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006024 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458006025 23768 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006026 23764 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006027 23762 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006028 23758 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 40 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458006029 23754 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006030 23752 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006031 23750 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006032 23746 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006033 23740 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006034 23736 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006035 23730 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006036 23720 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006037 23716 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006038 23712 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006040 23708 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458006041 23704 MALIBU COLONY RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007015 23864 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007016 23858 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007017 23910 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007018 23900 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007019 23872 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007020 23868 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007021 23850 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007022 23844 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007023 23834 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007024 23832 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007025 23826 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007026 23822 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007027 23816 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458007028 23812 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008001 23956 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008002 23952 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008003 23950 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008013 23936 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008014 23930 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008015 23926 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008016 23920 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008017 23916 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458008018 23940 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009001 24056 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009002 24052 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 41 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458009003 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458009005 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458009006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458009007 24024 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009008 24018 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009009 24016 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009012 24000 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009013 23962 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458009014 24008 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010001 24172 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010002 24166 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010003 24154 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010004 24150 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010005 24146 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010006 24142 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010007 24138 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010008 24134 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010009 24132 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010010 24128 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010011 24124 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010012 24120 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010015 24058 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010016 24102 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010017 24108 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010018 24116 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010019 24112 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458010020 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458011001 24208 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011002 24212 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011003 24216 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011004 24222 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011005 24228 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011006 24230 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011007 24236 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011008 24246 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011009 24254 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011010 24266 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 42 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458011011 24300 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011012 24314 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011013 24320 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011018 24348 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011019 24352 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011020 24358 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011021 24380 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011022 24402 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011023 24408 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011024 24414 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011025 24420 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011028 24436 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011029 24444 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011030 24450 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011031 24456 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011032 24330 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458011033 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458012001 24460 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012002 24466 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012003 24470 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012004 24476 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012005 24508 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012006 24514 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012007 24518 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012008 24524 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012009 24528 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012010 24534 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012011 24538 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012012 24542 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012013 24548 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012014 24554 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012017 24604 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012018 24608 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012019 24612 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012020 24616 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012021 24620 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012022 24626 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 43 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458012023 24632 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012024 24638 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012025 24644 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012028 24680 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012029 24700 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012030 24702 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012031 24708 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012032 24712 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012033 24654 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012035 24560 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458012036 24572 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458013002 24742 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013003 24748 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013004 24752 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013005 24758 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013006 24762 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013007 24802 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013008 24806 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013009 24814 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013010 24818 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013011 24822 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013012 24826 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013013 24832 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013014 24836 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013015 24844 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013016 24848 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013017 24854 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013018 24858 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013019 24864 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013020 24902 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013021 24908 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013022 24912 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013023 24916 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013024 24920 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013025 24928 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013026 24932 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 44 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458013027 24936 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013030 24942 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013031 24948 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013032 24956 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013033 24958 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013034 25000 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013035 25002 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013036 25004 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013037 25006 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013038 25022 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013041 25036 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013042 25042 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013043 25030 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458013044 25026 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018010 24157 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018011 24109 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018012 24111 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018013 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018020 24031 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018021 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018022 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018026 24001 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458018027 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018028 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018029 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018030 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018031 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458018032 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05
4458018033 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05
4458019003 23907 MALIBU RD MALIBU 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458019008 23614 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458019009 23670 PACIFIC COAST HWY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4458019010 23841 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 18 $129.60 $0.25 $129.85 4458021013 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4458027023 03625 WINTER CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4458027024 03625 WINTER CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027025 03625 WINTER CANYON RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 45 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4458027036 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027037 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027038 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027039 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027042 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 6MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027043 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 7MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027044 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 8MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027045 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 9MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027046 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 10MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027047 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 11MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027048 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 12MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027049 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 13MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027050 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 14MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027051 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 15MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027052 03601 VISTA PACIFICA UNIT 16MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027055 03601 VISTA PACIFICA 17MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4458027056 03601 VISTA PACIFICA 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459012001 25103 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459012002 25113 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459012003 25119 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459012004 25129 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459012005 25135 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459012006 25143 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459012007 25147 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459012008 25157 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459012009 25159 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459012010 25165 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4459013001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459013002 25307 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459013003 25301 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459013004 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459013005 25265 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459013010 25253 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459013011 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459013019 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459013021 25200 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459013022 25205 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 46 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4459013023 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459013024 25225 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014001 25315 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014002 25321 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014003 25325 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014004 25331 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014005 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459014006 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459014009 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459014010 25377 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014011 25377 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014012 25411 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014013 25423 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014014 25429 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014018 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459014021 25447 MALIBU ROAD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459014022 25439 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015001 25102 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4459015002 25110 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015003 25116 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015009 25150 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459015010 25154 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459015011 25160 MALIBU RD UNIT BMALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459015012 25164 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459015015 25206 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459015016 25212 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459015017 25216 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459015018 25144 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015020 25134 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 6 $43.20 $0.25 $43.45 4459015023 25120 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015024 25122 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015025 25124 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015026 25126 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015028 25200 MALIBU RD 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015029 25200 MALIBU RD 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015030 25200 MALIBU RD NO 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015031 25200 MALIBU RD 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 47 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4459015032 25200 MALIBU RD 5MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459015033 25200 MALIBU RD 6MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016001 0 0 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45
4459016002 25228 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4459016003 25234 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459016004 25236 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016005 25240 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459016006 25250 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016007 25252 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016008 25256 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4459016009 25260 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459016010 25266 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459016012 25302 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016013 25306 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016014 25308 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 2 $14.40 $0.25 $14.65 4459016015 25316 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459016016 25322 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016017 25328 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459016018 25330 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 3 $21.60 $0.25 $21.85 4459016020 25272 MALIBU RD NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459016021 25274 MALIBU RD NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017002 25342 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017003 25346 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017004 25350 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459017005 25360 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017006 25362 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 5 $36.00 $0.25 $36.25 4459017011 25406 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459017012 25410 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459017013 25416 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017015 25426 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459017016 25432 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017017 25438 MALIBU RD APT 0001MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017018 25442 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 4 $28.80 $0.25 $29.05 4459017019 25338 MALIBU RD NO 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017020 25338 MALIBU RD NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017021 25338 MALIBU RD NO 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017022 25338 MALIBU RD NO 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45

Page 48 of 49 ends

Malibu 203.59 Recycling Fee
PARCEL HOUSE STREET CITY STATE ZIP Code Units CITY SOLID

WASTE FEE
COUNTY

ADMIN FEE

TOTAL FEE
4459017024 25376 MALIBU RD UNIT 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017025 25376 MALIBU RD UNIT 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017026 25376 MALIBU RD UNIT 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017027 25376 MALIBU RD UNIT 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017030 25370 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017031 25372 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017032 25370 1/2 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017033 25372 1/2 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017034 25422 MALIBU RD 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017035 25422 MALIBU RD NO 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017036 25404 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017037 25402 MALIBU RD MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017039 25366 MALIBU ROAD 1MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017040 25366 MALIBU ROAD 2MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017041 25366 MALIBU ROAD 3MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 4459017042 25366 MALIBU ROAD 4MALIBU CA 90265 MALIBU CA 90265 1 $7.20 $0.25 $7.45 Grand Total $17,980.00

Page 49 of 49 ends

Page 1 of 4 ends

Agenda Item # 4.C.

Council Agenda Report
To: Mayor Silverstein and the Honorable Members of the City Council Prepared by: Richard Mollica, Planning Director
Approved by: Steve McClary, City Manager
Date prepared: June 16, 2023 Meeting date: June 26, 2023 Subject: Consideration of Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006 (Sea View Hotel Project)
RECOMMENDED ACTION: 1) After the City Attorney reads the title of the ordinance, introduce on first reading Ordinance No. 508 (Attachment 1), an ordinance of the City of Malibu amending Local Coastal Program Amendment (LCPA) No. 16-006 as adopted by Ordinance No. 491 pursuant to the conditional certification action taken by the California Coastal Commission (CCC) on February 8, 2023 in order to obtain final certification of the submitted LCPA application to amend the Local Coastal Program Land Use Map to revise the zoning designation from Commercial General to Commercial Visitor Serving-2, amend the Local Implementation Plan (LIP) and to create a new Sea View Hotel Overlay District with associated development standards, including the proposed floor area ratio of 0.52 for the public benefits provided by the project for 22741 and 22729 Pacific Coast Highway, and finding the action to require no further environmental review and/or to be exempt from such review under the California environmental quality act; 2) Direct staff to schedule a second reading and adoption of Ordinance No. 508 for the July 10, 2022 Regular City Council meeting; and 3) Direct staff to notify the CCC when the LCPA has been adopted.

FISCAL IMPACT: As described in the Council’s September 13, 2021, staff report, the applicant for LCPA No. 16-006 and associated Coastal Development Permit (CDP) No. 17-086 would contribute a fee of $110,000, in-lieu of providing six lower cost accommodations. The City would be able to transfer these funds to a public agency, nonprofit organization, or private entity after entering a Memorandum of Understanding or other contractual agreement that requires use of the funds for construction of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone area of Los Angeles County or Ventura County and which requires that the accommodations remain lower cost. However, the transfer of funds is not required, and the funds could be deposited into the General Fund Undesignated Reserve. In addition to the LCPA and CDP, associated Development Agreement No. 21-001 stipulated that the City Council Meeting
06-26-23
Item

4.C.
1

Page 2 of 4 ends

Agenda Item # 4.C.
applicant would also contribute $800,000 to the City for public benefits at the time the construction permits are issued for the associated project. Pursuant to General Plan Section 1.5.0, public benefits shall include physical improvements dedicated and reserved for public use, including, but not limited to, open space, wetlands, trails and walkways, parks, athletic fields, and civic or public buildings (such as senior centers, youth facilities, city hall, etc.). These funds would total $910,000 and must be deposited into a General Fund Designated Reserve for a public benefit purpose. In 2021, the applicant forecasted that the project would generate over $1.0 million in Transient Occupancy Tax revenue annually; however, this projection was not confirmed by staff at the time as nightly room rates or the occupancy projections were unknown.

The CCC’s actions on February 8, 2023, modified the LCPA and included additional financial contributions associated with the project. As further described in this report, CCC’s Modification 3 to the LCPA included an $800,000 fee to be paid by agreement between the CCC, and the applicant to fund new lower cost overnight visitor accommodations elsewhere in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone. The CCC described that the payment could be directed toward a public project to implement affordable visitor-serving accommodations in the area. In addition, the CCC described a commitment made by the applicant to provide $250,000 to a nonprofit organization that provides free surf lessons and transportation to beaches in the Malibu area for children in underserved communities in the general Los Angeles area. These additional fees totaling $1,050,000, would be submitted directly to the CCC and Los Courage Camps per the CCC’s proposed modifications.

In total, the applicant will be contributing $1,960,000.

WORK PLAN: This item was not included in the Work Plan for Fiscal Year 2022-2023.

BACKGROUND: On April 24, 2023, the Council took no action other than to direct staff to work with the applicant and the CCC to see if action can be taken that would potentially make the LCPA acceptable to the Council. On May 22, 2023, the Council made a motion directing staff to bring back a report on the status and provide the Council an opportunity to provide direction. On June 12, 2023, the Council discussed the LCPA and directed staff to bring the LCPA back at the June 26, 2023, Regular City Council meeting with an ordinance to allow the Council the ability to consider accepting the modified Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006.

In addition, on June 15, 2023, City Staff meet with the applicant’s attorney and CCC staff including the Executive Director and Local Director and staff to discuss the City’s concerns regarding the CCC modifications to the LCPA. In particular, the City expressed its concern that the additional mitigation fees required as part of the certification of the LCPA by the CCC allocated those fees without input from the City, and were designated in the CCC 2

Page 3 of 4 ends

Agenda Item # 4.C.
staff report for the LCPA to be used by the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA) for a camping project in Ramirez Canyon just outside of the City.

The CCC staff listened to the City’s concerns and expressed an openness to other projects but the CCC has a strong preference to put the funds to immediate use to fund a lower cost project with overnight accommodations in the general area of the City. City Staff reiterated the request that the CCC consider allowing the City to be part of the decisionmaking process and also inquired if there was an opportunity for the City to present a proposal to the CCC for the utilization of the fees collected. CCC staff stated that they would consider the City’s request and follow up with City staff at a later date.

In response to the City’s concerns about the upcoming August 8, 2023, deadline for acceptance of the updated LCPA, CCC staff offered the opportunity for the City to request an extension. Per CCC staff, requests come in the form of a letter that requests an extension of time, for a period not to exceed one year from August 8, 2023, pursuant to Coastal Act Section 30517 and CCR Section 13535(c). CCC staff explained that the extension request would need to be made in time for them to draft an agenda report and present the request at the July CCC hearing. Should the Council decide to pursue an extension and provide that direction to staff, staff will submit a request to the CCC.

A draft ordinance reflecting the modifications adopted by the CCC can be found in Attachment 1 of this report. An analysis of the modifications adopted by the CCC is contained in the April 24, 2023, agenda report that is attached to this report (Attachment 2). Included as well for the Council’s benefit is a redline version of the City’s LCPA (Attachment 3) and the February 8, 2023, CCC agenda report and attachments (Attachment 4) However, it should be noted that in addition to holding a hearing to amend the ordinance related to the modified LCPA, Staff will schedule additional hearings to conduct the first and second readings of an ordinance to amend the zone text amendment (ZTA) that was processed to provide consistency between the Malibu Municipal Code (MMC) and LIP. Per the City’s MMC, a 21-day public notice is required, and that noticing requirement could not be achieved given that staff was provided direction on this matter on June 12, 2023. The amended ZTA will be brought back at a later date should the Council adopt the changes to the LCPA.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: The City Council has analyzed the amended LCPA herein and makes the following findings. Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.9, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) does not apply to activities and approvals by the City as necessary for the preparation and adoption of an LCP Amendment. This application is for an amendment to the LCP, which must be certified by the CCC before it takes effect. On February 8, 2023, the CCC took action to conditionally certify the City’s LCP Amendment as previously adopted by Ordinance No. 491, with amendments (CCC LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2). The City Council has analyzed the amendments and 3

Page 4 of 4 ends

Agenda Item # 4.C.
finds that the activities and approvals are necessary by the City for the adoption of the LCP Amendment in order to obtain final certification of the LCP Amendment by the CCC.

Further, the proposed City Council actions, including without limitation, direction to prepare an Ordinance were adequately covered in Initial Study (IS) No. 21-001 and Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) No. 21-001 for the Sea View Hotel (SCH #2012041087), adopted by the City Council on September 13, 2021 (Resolution No. 21-45). The proposed City Council actions are not a separate “project” for CEQA purposes but rather a subsequent discretionary action related to a previously approved project (CEQA Guidelines § 15378(c)). Additionally, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, and based on the review of the entire record, including without limitation, the IS/MND, the City Council finds that the proposed actions do not require further environmental review as: 1) no substantial changes are proposed to the project and no substantial changes have occurred that require major revisions to the IS/MND due to the involvement of new significant environmental effects or an increase in severity of previously identified significant effects; and 2) no new information of substantial importance has come to light that shows the project will have one or more significant effects not discussed in the IS/MND. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines §15162(b), the City Council finds and recommends that no further analysis or environmental documentation is necessary.

Accordingly, the proposed City Council actions are merely a step toward furtherance of the original project for which environmental review was performed, no supplemental or subsequent CEQA has been triggered, and no further environmental review is required.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Ordinance No. 508

2. CC Staff Report without Attachments, April 24, 2023

3. CCC Modifications to City LCPA (redlined version)

4. CCC Staff Report and Attachments, February 8, 2023
4 ATTACHMENT 1
ORDINANCE NO. 508

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF MALIBU AMENDING LOCAL
COASTAL PROGRAM AMENDMENT NO. 16-006 AS ADOPTED BY
ORDINANCE NO. 491 PURSUANT TO THE CONDITIONAL

CERTIFICATION ACTION TAKEN BY THE CALIFORNIA COASTAL
COMMISSION ON FEBRUARY 8, 2023 IN ORDER TO OBTAIN FINAL

CERTIFICATION OF THE SUBMITTED LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAM

AMENDMENT APPLICATION TO AMEND THE LOCAL COASTAL

PROGRAM LAND USE MAP TO REVISE THE ZONING DESIGNATION
FROM COMMERCIAL GENERAL TO COMMERCIAL VISITOR SERVING2, AMEND THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AND TO CREATE A

NEW SEAVIEW HOTEL OVERLAY DISTRICT WITH ASSOCIATED

DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, INCLUDING THE PROPOSED FLOOR
AREA RATIO OF 0.52 FOR THE PUBLIC BENEFITS PROVIDED BY THE PROJECT FOR 22741 AND 22729 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY (GREY GRANITE, LLC; LAS TUNAS BEACH, LLC; AND SEA VIEW TERRACE, LLC); AND FINDING THE ACTION TO REQUIRE NO FURTHER

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND/OR TO BE EXEMPT FROM SUCH

REVIEW UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
The City Council of the City of Malibu does ordain as follows:

SECTION 1. Findings.

A. On September 13, 2021, the City Council adopted Ordinance No. 491 approving Local Coastal Program (LCP) Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, and Development Agreement No. 21-001 to amend the LCP Land Use Map and Malibu Municipal Code (MMC) Zoning Map to revise the zoning designation from Commercial General to Commercial Visitor Serving-2, amend the LCP Local Implementation Plan (LIP) and MMC and to create a new Seaview Hotel Overlay District with associated development standards, including the proposed floor area ratio of 0.52 for the public benefits provided by the project for 22741 and 22729 Pacific Coast Highway (PCH).

B. On February 8, 2023, the California Coastal Commission (CCC) took action to conditionally certify the City’s LCP Amendment for Ordinance No. 491, with amendments (CCC LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2).

C. On April 24, 2023, the City Council received a status update regarding the LCPA, reviewed the CCC’s amendments for conditional certification and considered staff’s requests to either prepare an ordinance to accept the modified LCPA or prepare a resolution to withdraw the City’s submitted LCPA with the City Council’s stated findings. The City Council took no action and directed staff to work with the applicant for the Seaview Hotel LCP Amendment and the CCC to see if action could be taken that would potentially make the LCP Amendment acceptable to the City Council.
5 Ordinance No. 508

Page 2 of 9 ends

__________________
D. On May 22, 2023, the City Council made a motion to bring back the LCP Amendment to receive a report on the status and provide the City Council an opportunity to provide direction.

E. On June 12, 2023, the City Council received a status update regarding the LCP Amendment and directed staff to prepare an ordinance accepting the modified LCP Amendment.

F. On June 15, 2023, a Notice of City Council Public Hearing was published in a newspaper of general circulation within the City of Malibu indicating that the City Council would hold a public hearing on June 26, 2023 to consider the proposed Ordinance amending LCP Amendment No. 16-006 (Exhibits A, B and C) as adopted by Ordinance No. 491 pursuant to the conditional certification action taken by the CCC on February 8, 2023 in order to obtain final certification of LCP Amendment No. 16-006.

G. On June 26, 2023, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing on the proposed Ordinance amending LCP Amendment No. 16-006 (Exhibits A, B and C) as adopted by Ordinance No. 491, reviewed and considered written reports, public testimony, and related information. In addition, the Council introduced on first reading and adopted the Ordinance.

SECTION 2. Environmental Review.

The City Council has analyzed the amended LCPA herein and makes the following findings. Pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21080.9, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) does not apply to activities and approvals by the City as necessary for the preparation and adoption of an LCP Amendment. This application is for an amendment to the LCP, which must be certified by the CCC before it takes effect. On February 8, 2023, the CCC took action to conditionally certify the City’s LCP Amendment as previously adopted by Ordinance No. 491, with amendments (CCC LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2). The City Council has analyzed the amendments and finds that the activities and approvals are necessary by the City for the adoption of the LCP Amendment in order to obtain final certification of the LCP Amendment by the CCC.

Further, the proposed City Council actions, including without limitation, direction to prepare an Ordinance was adequately covered in Initial Study (IS) No. 21-001 and Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) No. 21-001 for the Sea View Hotel (SCH #2012041087), adopted by the City Council on September 13, 2021 (Resolution No. 21-45). The proposed City Council actions are not a separate “project” for CEQA purposes but rather a subsequent discretionary action related to a previously approved project (CEQA Guidelines § 15378(c)). Additionally, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, and based on the review of the entire record, including without limitation, the IS/MND, the City Council finds that the proposed actions do not require further environmental review as: 1) no substantial changes are proposed to the project and no substantial changes have occurred that require major revisions to the IS/MND due to the involvement of new significant environmental effects or an increase in severity of previously identified significant effects; and 2) no new information of substantial importance has come to light that shows the project will have one or more significant effects not discussed in the IS/MND. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines §15162(b), the City Council finds and recommends that no further analysis or 6 Ordinance No. 508

Page 3 of 9 ends

__________________
environmental documentation is necessary. Accordingly, the proposed City Council actions are merely a step toward furtherance of the original project for which environmental review was performed, no supplemental or subsequent CEQA has been triggered, and no further environmental review is required.

SECTION 3. Acknowledgement of CCC’s Resolution of Certification and Findings.

The City of Malibu hereby acknowledges receipt of the CCC’s Resolution of Certification of City of Malibu LCP Amendment No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project), including suggested modifications therein.

The City Council concurs with the CCC’s finding that the LCP Amendment, as modified, will accommodate a hotel use in a manner that protects coastal resources, ensures internal consistency with the City’s certified LCP and is consistent with, and will carry out, the policies of the City’s certified LCP Land Use Plan (LUP).

SECTION 4. LCP Amendments.

A. That the title of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) (Exhibit A) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

3.4.6 Sea View Hotel Overlay District (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017)
B. That Subsections B and C of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Exhibit A) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

No changes to Subsection A.

B. Description of Area Subject to LIP Section 3.4.6. The provisions of this section shall apply to the Project Site, a 51,776 square foot (1.19 acre) site, comprised of two parcels, currently identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway (Los Angeles County Assessor Parcel Numbers 4452-022-010 and 4452-022-017) in the Sea View Hotel Overlay District map.

C. Applicability. The Commercial Development Standards contained in LIP Section 3.8, as well as other applicable certified LCP policies and provision shall apply, unless specifically modified by this section.

C. That Subsection D of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) (Exhibit A) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:
7 Ordinance No. 508

Page 4 of 9 ends

__________________
D. Development Agreement. Pursuant to a Development Agreement between the property owner and the City of Malibu, the allowable Floor to Area Ratio (FAR) is increased from 0.15 to 0.52 if the applicant contributes $800,000 to the City for public benefits and amenities, to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use.

D. That the following new subsection be added to LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) (Exhibit A), which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

E. Overnight Visitor-Serving Accommodations
NOTE: In addition to the requirements of LIP Section 12.10 regarding providing a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations, the owner of the Sea View Hotel Site as of the date of the Coastal Commission’s action on LCP Amendment No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (“Applicant”) has agreed to enter into an agreement with the Coastal Commission to fund an associated escrow account, thereby committing to pay an in-lieu fee to another entity acceptable to the Executive Director of the Coastal Commission for use in developing lower cost visitor accommodations, to be released upon Applicant’s securing of entitlements to develop the site consistent with development standards of the Sea View Hotel Overlay District below.

E. That Subsection E of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) (Exhibit A) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

F. Development Standards.

YARDS/SETBACKS No changes

PROJECTIONS INTO YARDS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.5.3(B) apply with the
following additional provision:
• Access and exit stairs required by the Fire
Department, and existing retaining walls may
project without limit into required side yards.

SITE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA
Maximum Floor Area Ratio (F.A.R.) No changes
8 Ordinance No. 508

Page 5 of 9 ends

__________________
Minimum Onsite Landscaping The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel landscaping criteria are as
follows:

A minimum of 8,977 square feet of landscaping at
ground level. Additionally, there shall be a minimum of 2,528.6 square feet of plants in planters on the southerly seaward areas of the various decks.

Minimum Onsite Open Space The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel open space criteria are as
follows:

HEIGHT
Maximum Height Projections The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(1) shall not apply.

The Sea View Hotel height requirements are as follow:
• New structures which have sloping roofs that slope
less than 25% shall be no higher than 24 feet
above the natural grade or finished grade,
whichever results in a lower building height,
excluding basements.
• New structures which have sloping roofs that slope
25%, or more, shall be no higher than 28 feet above
the natural grade or finished grade, whichever
results in a lower building height, excluding
basements. Areas such as elevator shafts in order to
comply with ADA laws, the wooden deck above the
existing tile rooftop deck, the fire exit stairs required by the Fire Department, the safety railing around
the decks, and the sound wall as described in the
Mitigated Negative Declaration are excluded from
the referenced height restrictions. Seven-foot
overhangs to eliminate sun from hitting south facing
windows are excluded from the height standards.
9 Ordinance No. 508

Page 6 of 9 ends

__________________

PARKING AND ACCESS
Parking Requirements The provisions of LIP Sections 3.14.2 and 3.14.3 shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel parking requirements are as
follows:
• 1.5 parking spaces per hotel room.
• 1 space for each, per-shift employee
• 1 space for each 100 square feet of gross floor area
used for consumption of food or beverages.
• 1 space for each 5 fixed seats, or for every 35
square feet of assembly area where there are no
fixed seats in meeting rooms or other assembly
areas.

Parking Location No changes
Layout and Paving The provisions of LIP Section 3.14.5 are modified or shall not apply as follows:
• The provision of LIP Section 3.14.5(D)(5) shall not
apply. Tire stops are not required for valet parking spaces. • The provisions of LIP Sections 3.14.5(C) and (E) shall not apply.

MONUMENT SIGN AND GENERAL SIGN REQUIREMENTS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.15.6 are modified or
shall not apply as follows:
• The provisions of LIP Section 3.15.6(A)(2)(d)(iii)
shall not apply.
• Two signs shall be permitted, each sign shall be a
maximum of 48 square feet, and a maximum height
of 6 feet, excluding the base area supporting the
sign. One monument sign and one building sign
shall be permitted.
• One address monument sign shall be permitted up
to a maximum of 16 square feet, excluding the base
area supporting the sign. There shall be no
setbacks required from rights of way or property
lines for monument signs.
10 Ordinance No. 508

Page 7 of 9 ends

__________________
F. That Subsection F of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) (Exhibit A) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

G. PERMITTED USES
The following permitted, conditionally permitted, and prohibited uses shall apply to the Sea View Hotel Overlay District. Permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are a component of the hotel development are subject to the custom development standards of this Sea View Hotel Overlay District. Permitted or conditionally permitted uses that are not a component of the hotel development are subject to all applicable policies and provisions of the certified LCP, including the Commercial Development Standards in LIP Section 3.8. a. Permitted Uses: The uses and structures permitted within Sea View Hotel Overlay District are as follows:
i. All uses permitted in the Commercial Visitor Serving-2, (CV-2), land use zoning district, as specified in the LCP.
ii. Restaurants that are open to the general public.

No changes to iii. through xiv.

No changes to Subsection b.
c. Conditionally Permitted Uses. The following uses may be permitted subject to additionally obtaining a Conditional Use Permit in accordance with the requirements of the MMC:
i. All conditionally permitted uses in the Commercial Visitor Serving-2, (CV-2), land use zoning district, as specified in the LCP.

No changes to ii through x.

G. That the LIP Zoning Map (Exhibit B) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:

Depict the Sea View Hotel Overlay District site as two parcels and add corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017).

H. That the Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map (Exhibit B) be modified as follows, which amends the proposed regulations included in Ordinance No. 491, as recommended by the CCC:
11 Ordinance No. 508

Page 8 of 9 ends

__________________
Depict the Sea View Hotel Overlay District site as two parcels and add corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) to differentiate which parcels are subject to the Sea View Hotel Overlay District.

SECTION 5. Submittal to California Coastal Commission.

The City Council hereby directs staff to submit the Ordinance modifying Ordinance No. 491 to the CCC in order to obtain final certification of the Sea View Hotel LCP Amendment.

SECTION 6. Effective Date.

Upon adoption, the Ordinance will be submitted to the CCC for certification as an LCP Amendment. The Ordinance will take effect and be in force on the date that the CCC takes action to unconditionally certify the LCP Amendment.

SECTION 6. Severability.

If any section, subsection, provision, sentence, clause, phrase or word of this Ordinance is for any reason held to be illegal or otherwise invalid by any court of competent jurisdiction, such invalidity shall be severable, and shall not affect or impair any remaining section, subsection, provision, sentence, clause, phrase or word included within this Ordinance, it being the intent of the City that the remainder of this Ordinance shall be and shall remain in full force and effect, valid, and enforceable.

SECTION 7. Certification.

The City Clerk shall certify the passage and adoption of this Ordinance and enter it into the book of original ordinances.

PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this ___ day of June, 2023. ____________________________
BRUCE SILVERSTEIN, Mayor
ATTEST:
__________________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
Date: _______________________
12 Ordinance No. 508

Page 9 of 9 ends

__________________
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________________
TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney
13

Page 1 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

Council Agenda Report
To: Mayor Silverstein and the Honorable Members of the City Council Prepared by: Richard Mollica, Planning Director
Approved by: Steve McClary, City Manager
Date prepared: April 10, 2023 Meeting date: April 24, 2023 Subject: Update Regarding Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006 (Sea View Hotel Project)
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Receive a status update regarding City Local Coastal Program Amendment (LCPA) No. 16-006 for the Sea View Hotel Project LCPA submittal, review the California Coastal Commission (CCC) approved LCPA as modified on February 8, 2023 (LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2), and provide direction on the following:
1) The Council’s position on the LCPA as modified by the CCC and a determination if the modifications made by the CCC are generally consistent with the City’s LCPA as adopted on September 13, 2021, or that the modifications substantially deviate from the LCPA; and
2) Preparation of an Ordinance to accept the modified LCPA; or 3) Preparation of a Resolution to withdrawal the City’s submitted LCPA with the Council’s stated findings.

Should the Council desire to change the modified LCPA, the Council would need to withdraw and resubmit the amendment as a new LCPA.

FISCAL IMPACT: As described in the Council’s September 13, 2021, staff report, the applicant for LCPA No. 16-006 and associated Coastal Development Permit (CDP) No. 17-086 would contribute a fee of $110,000, in-lieu of providing six low-cost visitor accommodations. The City would be able to transfer these funds to a public agency, nonprofit organization, or private entity after entering a Memorandum of Understanding or other contractual agreement that requires use of the funds for construction of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone area of Los Angeles County or Ventura County and which requires that the accommodations remain lower cost. However, the transfer of funds is not required, and the funds could be deposited into the General Fund Undesignated Reserve. In addition to City Council Meeting
04-24-23
Item

6.B.
1 ATTACHMENT 2
14

Page 2 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.
the LCPA and CDP, associated Development Agreement No. 21-001 stipulated that the applicant would also contribute $800,000 to the City for public benefits at the time the construction permits are issued for the associated project. Pursuant to General Plan Section 1.5.0, public benefits shall include physical improvements dedicated and reserved for public use, including, but not limited to, open space, wetlands, trails and walkways, parks, athletic fields, and civic or public buildings (such as senior centers, youth facilities, city hall, etc.). These funds would total $910,000 and must be deposited into a General Fund Designated Reserve for a public benefit purpose. In 2021, the applicant forecasted that the project would generate over $1.0 million in Transient Occupancy Tax revenue annually; however, this projection was not confirmed by staff at the time as nightly room rates or the occupancy projections were unknown.

In total, the applicant will be contributing $1,960,000.

WORK PLAN: This item was not included in the Work Plan for Fiscal Year 2022-2023.

BACKGROUND: On September 13, 2021, the Council amended its LCP to change the land use and zoning designation of two adjacent commercially developed parcels identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) (APN: 4452-022-010) and 22741 PCH (APN: 4452-022-017), from Community Commercial (CC) to Commercial Visitor Serving Two (CV-2) on the LCP Land Use Plan (LUP) Land Use Map and LCP Local Implementation Plan (LIP) Zoning Map. These two parcels together comprise approximately 1.18 acres of land known as the Sea View Hotel Site.

The LIP amendment proposed the creation of a new overlay district (the Sea View Hotel Overlay District) to accommodate the construction of a new 39-room hotel with associated amenities at 22729 and 22741 PCH. The overlay map would be added to the LIP Zoning Maps and would apply use restrictions and development standards over the properties.

The CC land use and zoning designation is intended to provide the community's residentserving needs, including uses such as restaurants, banks, offices, and retail. Hotel use is 2 15

Page 3 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.
not permitted in the CC zone and is only permitted within the CV-2 zone. To accommodate the proposed hotel development, the City determined that the properties needed to be rezoned from CC to CV-2 as part of the LCPA.

At the September 2021 meeting, the Council approved the LCPA and submitted the LCPA application to the CCC on November 15, 2021. The LCPA submittal was deemed complete by CCC staff and filed on March 21, 2022, for a hearing. At its June 2022 CCC meeting, the CCC extended the 90 working-day time limit to act on the LCPA for a period not to exceed one year from the original deadline of July 28, 2022.

DISCUSSION: On February 8, 2023, the CCC declined to approve the LCPA as approved by the City; however, the CCC conditionally approved the LCPA subject to the City Council approving the particular modifications required by the CCC. Because the LCPA was modified by the CCC, the LCPA must come back to the Council for consideration. The Council has until August 8, 2023, six months following CCC’s action, to either accept the modified LCPA or withdraw the LCPA. If the Council does not act within six months, the LCPA would not become effective.

If the Council accepts the modified LCPA, the Council will need to adopt an Ordinance at a future meeting since the modifications affect the LIP portion of the LCP. If adopted, the Ordinance would be transmitted to the CCC Executive Director for a final determination that the Council’s acceptance is consistent with the CCC’s action in February 2023. In this scenario, the modified LCPA would only become final when the CCC Executive Director reports its determination to the CCC at its next regularly scheduled meeting after receipt of the City’s Ordinance. Once reported, the LCPA becomes effective and is part of the City’s LCP.

If the Council does not accept the modified LCPA within six months of the CCC’s action, then the LCPA would remain uncertified and would not become effective. The Council has two options to not accept the modifications: 1) adopt a Resolution to formally withdraw the LCPA with the Council’s stated findings as to why the Council is not able to move forward with the LCPA modifications; or 2) allow the LCPA process to expire by not taking action within six months.

Should the Council choose to decline to accept the changes, the applicant could request that the Council submit a modified LCPA to address the CCC concerns. As the CCC has already taken action on the LCPA, modifications are no longer an option unless resubmitted as a new application.

The CCC’s approval of the amendment included seven suggested modifications (Attachments 1 and 2). These are summarized as follows:
3 16

Page 4 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

Suggested Modification 1: Adds the corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) to LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) and a minor typo edit referencing LIP Section 3.8.

Suggested Modification 2: Adds clarifying language to LIP Section 3.4.5(D) (Development Agreement) to require the applicant to contribute $800,000 to the City to be used for public benefits and amenities.

Suggested Modification 3: Adds a new subsection to LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) as follows:

CCC explained that Modification 3 was added to note an agreement made between the CCC and the property owner regarding payment of the $800,000 fee is in addition to the existing LCP requirements regarding the development of luxury overnight accommodations. CCC clarified that the purposes of the fee would be to fund new lower cost overnight visitor accommodations elsewhere in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone. As part of the agreement with the CCC, the property owner funded an escrow account that would be released once the owner secures entitlements to development the hotel and said entitlements are no longer subject to challenge. The CCC described the payment could be directed toward an identified, potential public project to implement affordable visitor-serving accommodations – a planned campground on a

23.71-acre site (Lauber Smith Property) acquired by the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA). The site is located outside of City limits in unincorporated Los Angeles County and adjacent to Ramirez Canyon Park. If proposed, portions of the property could be developed as a campground with flame-less facilities (tent pad sites, including ADA accessible tent pad sites) and visitor-serving improvements (parking, restrooms, and picnic areas) to serve the general public as well as underserved and foster youth programs of MRCA. However, CCC staff provides additional clarification in an Appendix to its February 2023 report (Attachment 2) that “no specific project for the in lieu 4 17

Page 5 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.
fee is called out in the Commission’s suggested modification, and it remains uncertain if the mitigation fee will go towards a campground project in Ramirez Canyon or to some other project.”
In addition to the in-lieu fee, the CCC explained that the property owner also committed to and entered into a contract to provide $250,000 to a nonprofit organization called “Los Courage Camps” to further its work providing free surf lessons and transportation to beaches in the Malibu area for children in underserved communities in the general Los Angeles area. The CCC explained that the additional $250,000 will increase equitable public access and recreation opportunities, furthering the goals of the Coastal Act and LCP with regard to access and environmental justice.

Note that the above amounts are in addition to a City-in lieu fee payment of $110,000 to provide lower cost overnight accommodations onsite or offsite. This in-lieu fee was required as part of the City’s previous approval of CDP No. 17-086 on September 13, 2021, for construction of the Sea View Hotel project. As part of the CDP, the City included Special Condition 34 requiring the $110,000 payment. The CCC explained that the City’s in-lieu fee option has not kept pace with the cost of providing lower cost accommodations in the coastal zone and is too low in comparison to the in-lieu mitigation fee that the CCC has required in recent past actions for new hotel development along the coast. CCC’s staff report provides its rationale and analysis to support the added $800,000 in-lieu fee in addition to the City’s $110,000 in-lieu fee.

On January 27, 2023, City staff provided comments to CCC staff regarding Suggested Modification 3 and requested that the $800,000 not be used to fund camping in high fire severity zones or in Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Areas (ESHA). CCC disagreed with City staff’s request for the following reasons:
 Camping is a form of lower-cost overnight visitor accommodations.  The entire City is within the Very High Fire Severity Zone (VHFSZ).  Requiring any camping to be situated outside of the VHFSZ would effectively preclude any new camping from being located within the City or the adjacent unincorporated Santa Monica Mountains.
 If the CCC were to restrict camping in the VHFSZ, this type of restriction would directly conflict with the lower cost overnight visitor accommodations in-lieu mitigation fee, policies and goals of the City’s LCP which is to assist in funding affordable overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone.
 Any new camping development will trigger a CDP to be reviewed by either the City or Los Angeles County depending on the location.
 Both the City’s LCP and Los Angeles County’s LCP require new development to minimize risks to life and property in fire hazard areas and also require the protection of areas designated as ESHA and require new development in areas 5 18

Page 6 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.
adjacent to ESHA to be sited and designed to prevent impacts which would significantly degrade those areas.

Suggested Modification 4: Adds language to LIP Section 3.4.6(F) (Development Standards) to clarify which LCP standard a proposed visitor-serving commercial development standard is intended to replace or supplement, as applicable (e.g., projections into yards, landscaping, open space, height projections, parking, and layout and paving). CCC explained that since many of the proposed development standards for visitor serving commercial development reflect the requirements that are currently contained in the LCP, but do not reflect all of them, it is important to provide clarification regarding the applicability of standards in order to ensure internal consistency and adequacy in carrying out the policies of the Land Use Plan.

Suggested Modification 5: Adds language to LIP Section 3.4.6(G) (Permitted Uses) that reads:

Permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are a component of the hotel development are subject to the custom development standards of the Sea View Hotel Overlay District. Permitted or conditionally permitted uses that are not a component of the hotel development are subject to all applicable policies and provisions of the certified LCP, including the Commercial Development Standards in LIP Section 3.8.

CCC explained this modification will ensure that all other permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are not associated with hotel development cannot be developed with the modified hotel-specific development standards under the overlay district and, therefore, will ensure that new development will not have significant adverse effects, either individually or cumulatively, on coastal resources. Other minor clarifications are incorporated into this section to avoid ambiguity (e.g., deleted reference to design standards and restaurant parking, and clarification on conditional use permits being required in addition for conditionally permitted uses).

Suggested Modification 6: Adds the corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) to the proposed LIP Section 3.4.6 Sea View Hotel Overlay District text and Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map.

Suggested Modification 7: Modifies the LIP Zoning Map to depict the Sea View Hotel Overlay District site as two parcels APN 4452-002-010 and 4452-022-017.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: The proposed City Council actions, including without limitation, direction to prepare an Ordinance or Resolution was adequately covered in Initial Study (IS) No. 21-001 and Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) No. 21-001 for the 6 19

Page 7 of 7 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

Sea View Hotel (SCH #2012041087), adopted by the City Council on September 13, 2021 (Resolution No. 21-45). The proposed City Council actions are not a separate “project” for CEQA purposes but is a subsequent discretionary action related to a previously approved project (CEQA Guidelines § 15378(c)). Additionally, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15162, and based on the review of the entire record, including without limitation, the IS/MND, the City Council finds that the proposed actions do not require further environmental review as: 1) no substantial changes are proposed to the project and no substantial changes have occurred that require major revisions to the IS/MND due to the involvement of new significant environmental effects or an increase in severity of previously identified significant effects; and 2) no new information of substantial importance has come to light that shows the project will have one or more significant effects not discussed in the IS/MND. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines §15162(b), the City Council finds and recommends that no further analysis or environmental documentation is necessary. Accordingly, the proposed City Council actions are merely a step-in furtherance of the original project for which environmental review was performed and no supplemental or subsequent CEQA has been triggered, and no further environmental review is required.

CONCLUSION: Staff requests Council to provide direction on next steps regarding the LCPA. If the Council accepts the modified LCPA, staff will return with an Ordinance to accept the modified LCPA. If the Council does not accept the modified LCPA, staff could return with a Resolution to withdraw the LCPA with the Council’s stated findings if so directed.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. CCC Modifications to City LCPA (redlined version)

2. CCC Staff Report and Attachments, February 8, 2023
7 20
City LCPA No. 16-006
CCC LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2
ATTACHMENT 3
CCC Modifications to City LCPA – February 8, 2023
(City text in straight type; CCC edits in strikethrough and underline) LIP Chapter 3.4 is amended to add Section 3.4.6 as follows:

3.4.6 Sea View Hotel Overlay District (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452- 022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) A. Purpose. The provisions of this section provide custom development criteria and uses for the development of the Sea View Hotel project, as referred to in the Sea View Hotel Development Agreement, a commercial, visitor-serving, transient lodging accommodation development. These include maximum density and intensity standards, including floor area ratios for commercial use not to exceed the maximum floor area ratio allowed pursuant to the LUP where public benefits and amenities are provided as part of the project, development standards, including heights, lot coverage, setbacks and open space requirements.

B. Description of Area Subject to LIP Section 3.4.6. The provisions of this section shall apply to the Project Site, a 51,776 square foot (1.19 acre) site parcel, comprised of two merged parcels, currently identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway (Los Angeles County Assessor Parcel Numbers 4452-022-010 and 4452-022-017) in the Sea View Hotel Overlay District map.

C. Applicability. The Commercial Development Standards contained in LIP Section

3. 18, as well as other applicable certified LCP policies and provision shall apply, unless specifically modified by this section.

D. Development Agreement. Pursuant to a Development Agreement between the property owner and the City of Malibu, the allowable Floor to Area Ratio (FAR) is increased from 0.15 to 0.52 if . Tthe applicant will contributes $800,000 to the City for public benefits and amenities, to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use.

YARDS/SETBACKS. The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(2) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel yards/setbacks requirements are as follow:

Minimum Front Yard Setback 16% of lot depth
Minimum Rear Yard Setback 15% of lot depth
Minimum Side Yard Setback
(West)
15% of lot width
Minimum Side Yard Setback
(East)
12 feet
Minimum Side Yard Setback
(Cumulative)
None

PROJECTIONS INTO YARDS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.5.3(B) apply with
the is modified as followings additional provision:
• Access and exit stairs required by the Fire
Department, and existing retaining walls may
project without limit into required side yards.

SITE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA
Maximum Floor Area Ratio
(F.A.R.)
The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(a) shall
not apply. The Sea View Hotel site development
criteria are as follow:
• The gross square footage of all buildings shall
be limited to a maximum FAR of 0.52 of the
lot area (excluding any street rights of way).

Floor area excludes access hallways and
storage areas created by excavation into the
hillside and not visible from Pacific Coast
Highway or any other public area not to
exceed 386 square feet.

Minimum Onsite Landscaping The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel landscaping criteria
are as follows:

A minimum of 8,977 square feet of landscaping at
ground level. Additionally, there shall be a
minimum of 2,528.6 square feet of plants in
planters on the southerly seaward areas of the
various decks.

Minimum Onsite Open Space The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel open space criteria
are as follows:

A minimum of 1,313.8 square feet of private
recreational area at ground level and first level
reception area and 21,494 square feet at guest deck
patios, not already included in landscape area, are
required.
9 22
HEIGHT
Maximum Height Projections The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(1) shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel height requirements
are as follow:
• New structures which have sloping roofs that
slope less than 25% shall be no higher than 24
feet above the existing natural grade or
finished grade, whichever results in a lower
building height, excluding basements
• New structures which have sloping roofs that
slope 25%, or more, shall be no higher than
28 feet above the existing natural grade or
finished grade, whichever results in a lower
building height, excluding basements. Areas
such as elevator shafts in order to comply
with ADA laws, the wooden deck above the
existing tile rooftop deck, the fire exit stairs
required by the Fire Department, the safety
railing around the decks, and the sound wall
as described in the Mitigated Negative
Declaration are excluded from the referenced
height restrictions. Seven-foot overhangs to
eliminate sun from hitting south facing
windows are excluded from the height
standards.

Parking Location The provision of LIP Section 3.14.5(A)(2) is modified as follows:
• Required parking may be located in the
required front yard setback.
1023
Layout and Paving The provisions of LIP Section 3.14.5 are modified or shall not apply as follows:
• The provision of LIP Section 3.14.5(D)(5)
shall not apply. Tire stops are not required for
valet parking spaces.
• The provisions of LIP Sections 3.14.5(C) and
(E) shall not apply.
• The landscaped areas and the parking plan
shown on the Sea View Hotel plans are an
integral part of the proposed hotel and are
acceptable within the overlay district.

MONUMENT SIGN AND GENERAL SIGN REQUIREMENTS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.15.6 are modified
or shall not apply as follows:
• The provisions of LIP Section

3.15.6(A)(2)(d)(iii) shall not apply.
• Two signs shall be permitted, each sign shall
be a maximum of 48 square feet, and a
maximum height of 6 feet, excluding the base
area supporting the sign. One monument sign
and one building sign shall be permitted.
• One address monument sign shall be
permitted up to a maximum of 16 square feet,
excluding the base area supporting the sign.
• There shall be no setbacks required from
rights of way or property lines for monument
signs.

F. G. PERMITTED USES
The following permitted, conditionally permitted, and prohibited uses and design standards are as follows:shall apply to the Sea View Hotel Overlay District. Permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are a component of the hotel development are subject to the custom development standards of this Sea View Hotel Overlay District.

Permitted or conditionally permitted uses that are not a component of the hotel development are subject to all applicable policies and provisions of the certified LCP, including the Commercial Development Standards in LIP Section 3.8. a. Permitted Uses: The uses and structures permitted within Sea View Hotel Overlay District are as follows:
i. All uses permitted in the Commercial Visitor Serving-2, (CV-2), land use zoning district, as specified in the LCP.
ii. Restaurants that are open to the general public will require one parking space for every 100 square feet of serving area.
1124
iii. Retail store which sells beach towels, chairs, sunscreen, hats, bathing suits, food items, and other items that may be desired by hotel guests. iv. Electric car charging stations.
v. Private lockers available to guests for storage of recreational equipment including, but not limited to surfboards, boogie boards, beach towels, umbrellas, and chairs.
vi. Residential accommodations for a full-time onsite property manager to ensure that all hotel rules are followed at all times.
vii. Medical offices.
viii. Special events for public congregations or entertainment, which are temporary in nature.
ix. Spas, including, but not limited to, steam rooms, lockers, bathrooms. x. Salons.
xi. Gyms with physical fitness training equipment.
xii. Guest rooms with private decks, rooftop deck; rooftop decks are restricted to hotel guests unless used for special events.
xiii. General office use including, but not limited to the reception office. xiv. Other uses determined by the Planning Director to be of a similar nature to uses permitted in this district and the uses referenced above. b. Prohibited Uses. The following uses are specifically prohibited:
i. Fast food restaurants with drive-thru facilities.
ii. Liquor stores (stand-alone).
iii. Adult book stores.
iv. Hazardous waste facilities.
v. Gas stations.
c. Conditionally Permitted Uses. The following uses may be permitted subject to additionally obtaining a Conditional Use Permit in accordance with the requirements of the MMC:
i. All conditionally permitted uses in the Commercial Visitor Serving-2, (CV2), land use zoning district, as specified in the LCP. ii. Cocktail lounges, ancillary to restaurant use.
iii. Nursery schools and daycare facilities.
iv. Veterinary hospitals.
v. Churches, temples, mosques and other places of worship. vi. Hand car washing and detailing, except when the vehicles are owned by a guest of the hotel.
vii. Wireless telecommunications antennae and facilities. viii. Emergency communication and service facilities.
ix. Cultural and artistic uses (museums, galleries, and performing arts studios). x. Sale or onsite consumption of alcoholic beverages
1225
City LCPA No. 16-006
CCC LCPA No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2
ATTACHMENT 1
Modify the Zoning Map to depict the Sea View Hotel project site as two parcels. 22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-002-010 & 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452- 022-017
1326
Modify the Sea View Hotel Overlay District Figure to depict the Sea View Hotel project site as two parcels and add addresses to depict which parcels are subject to the overlay. 1427
STATE OF CALIFORNIA – NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION

SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT OFFICE
89 SOUTH CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 200
VENTURA, CA 93001
(805) 585-1800
W11a
DATE: January 26, 2023
TO: Commissioners and Interested Persons
FROM: Steve Hudson, District Director
Barbara Carey, District Manager
Deanna Christensen, District Supervisor
Denise Gonzalez, Coastal Program Analyst
SUBJECT: City of Malibu Local Coastal Program Amendment No. LCP-4-MAL-21- 0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project) for February 8, 2023 Commission Meeting

SUMMARY OF STAFF RECOMMENDATION
The City of Malibu’s (“City”) proposed Local Coastal Program (LCP) Amendment No. LCP4-MAL-21-0073-2 consists of changes to the Land Use Plan (LUP) and Local Implementation Plan (LIP) portions of its certified LCP. Staff recommends that the Commission, after public hearing, approve the proposed LUP amendment as submitted.

The proposed LUP amendment is consistent with and meets the requirements of the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. Commission staff further recommends that the Commission deny the proposed LIP amendment as submitted and approve the proposed LIP amendment with seven suggested modifications. The modifications are necessary to ensure the proposed LIP amendment conforms with, and is adequate to carry out, the provisions of the certified LUP, as amended. The motions to accomplish these recommendations are found on Pages 7-9 of this staff report.

The City is requesting an amendment to modify the land use and zoning designation of two parcels at 22741 Pacific Coast Highway (APN: 4452-022-017) and 22729 Pacific Coast Highway (APN: 4452-022-010) from Community Commercial (CC) to Commercial Visitor Serving-Two (CV-2) on the LUP Land Use Map and LIP Zoning Map. These two parcels, which are owned variously by three property owners, together comprise approximately 1.18 acres of land known as the Sea View Hotel Site (“subject site”). The amendment further proposes the creation of a new overlay district (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) with special development standards to facilitate the development of a new 39-room luxury hotel.

The amendment also includes increasing the development’s allowable Floor Area Ratio (FAR) beyond what is permitted under the existing LCP, which triggers the need for a Development Agreement to be approved through an LCP amendment certified by the Coastal Commission pursuant to LIP Section 3.8(A)(5). Therefore, the proposed amendment also includes the approval of a Development Agreement between the City and the property owners to increase the maximum allowable FAR from 0.15 to 0.52 in conjunction with a payment of $800,000 to the City to be expended as the City Council 1528
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
2 determines to be an appropriate use.

The standard of review for the changes to the Land Use Plan is whether the amendment meets the requirements of and is consistent with the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. The standard of review for the proposed changes to the Local Implementation Plan is whether the amendment conforms with and is adequate to carry out the provisions of the Land Use Plan portion of the certified City of Malibu LCP as amended.

The amendment request is project-specific to allow for the construction of a new 39-room luxury hotel on the subject site. The proposed overlay map will be added to the LIP Zoning Maps and the proposed overlay text will apply use restrictions and development standards over the property. The proposed overlay site is currently zoned Community Commercial, which does not allow hotels as a permitted use. Hotel use is only permitted within Commercial Visitor Serving Two. Therefore, to accommodate the proposed hotel development, the City proposes to change the land use and zoning designation of the subject site from CC to CV-2.

Visitor-serving commercial development, including overnight accommodations, is considered a priority use under the Coastal Act and the Malibu LCP and is given priority over other land uses such as general commercial or residential development. The subject site is located on the landward side of Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) in a commercial area of the City, approximately one-third mile east of the Malibu Pier and Civic Center area. The site is developed with existing commercial buildings and associated surface parking areas.

Properties in the immediate vicinity are zoned CC, CV-1, and CV-2 and are developed with commercial structures and uses, including hotels such as the Malibu Beach Inn and Nobu Ryokan and several restaurants. Further north, there is an area of hillside residential development.

Visitor-serving commercial uses provide greater public benefit than community commercial uses because they are designed to serve a larger segment of the population that can take advantage of and enjoy the use of the property, and such uses support visitors to the coast.

All future development on the subject site will need to support the visitor-serving nature of the area, be consistent with the allowable uses under the Commercial Visitor Serving land use designation and be consistent with the policies and provisions of the certified LCP. The site is appropriate for visitor-serving commercial use, for instance, the proposed hotel development. The proposed LUP amendment to change the land use designation to CV-2, as submitted, is consistent with Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act.

The key issue raised by this amendment request is the adequate provision of lower-cost visitor-serving overnight accommodations. In this case, no existing lower-cost rooms are being demolished or replaced since the proposed hotel project does not include the demolition of an existing lower-cost hotel or motel. However, this is a project-specific request to allow a new 39-room luxury hotel at the site and the proposal raises an issue of whether the project specific LCP amendment is consistent with the Coastal Act and LCP policies to ensure that proposed visitor-accommodation facilities in the coastal zone include lower-cost accommodations. Under the City’s LCP, if a property owner proposes to build new overnight luxury accommodations, LUP Policy 2.35 and LIP Section 12.10 allow for the payment of an in-lieu fee of $10,419 (and adjusted for inflation) applied to fifteen percent (15%) of the total number of new rooms built on a property as a mechanism to ensure 1629
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
3 compliance with the objectives of Section 30213 and 30222 of the Coastal Act and Policies

2.33, 2.34, 2.36 and 2.37 of the Malibu LCP. However, recognizing that the LCP’s required base in-lieu mitigation fee of $10,419 is too low in comparison to the in-lieu mitigation fee per required lower-cost room (not provided onsite) that the Commission has required in recent past actions for new hotel development along the coast, the property owners have offered to pay a total in-lieu mitigation fee of $800,000 (or approximately $133,000 per room applied to 15% of the new 39 luxury hotel rooms) to assist in funding affordable overnight accommodations elsewhere in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone.

However, because the property owners did not propose the $800,000 mitigation fee as part of its underlying coastal development permit applications to the City, this proposed fee is not reflected in the proposed LCP amendment request.

To provide an effective alternative mechanism for the hotel project proponent to provide a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations through an up-to-date in-lieu mitigation fee as required by the Commission in recent Commission’s actions, the property owners and the Commission staff have worked cooperatively to reach an agreement on a mechanism whereby the property owners have agreed to provide an $800,000 in-lieu fee to an appropriate third party entity through an escrow account for use in developing low-cost visitor serving overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone. These escrow funds would be released once the owners secure entitlements to develop the site with a hotel use and those entitlements are no longer subject to challenge.

The owners have also agreed to deliver in escrow a Declaration of Covenants, to be recorded upon effective certification of this LCP amendment. Once the Declaration of Covenants is recorded, the obligation for payment of the $800,000 in-lieu fee runs with the land and is binding on any future owners. This provision provides extra assurances that the lack of provision for lower cost overnight accommodations with a new luxury hotel development will be mitigated even if the current property owners decide not to pursue the project. As such, the agreement is structured to provide the Commission with the assurance of payment of the fee, which represents an opportunity to provide lower cost visitor-serving accommodations elsewhere near the project area. And using an escrow arrangement provides the property owners assurance that the required fee will only be transferred upon securing final entitlements for the hotel development. In order to ensure that the proposed amendment will provide a component of lower cost visitor-serving overnight accommodations in the Coastal Zone through an up-to-date in-lieu mitigation fee, Staff is recommending a suggested modification to note the agreement between the Coastal Commission and the property owners regarding payment of the fee is in addition to the existing LCP requirements regarding the development of luxury overnight accommodations.

The LCP amendment includes creation of a new overlay district (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) with special development standards to facilitate the development of a new 39-room luxury hotel. The coastal development permit for the hotel development within the overlay district site has already been approved by the City of Malibu, conditioned to not be effective until certification of the subject LCP amendment. As such, Commission staff have conducted a project-level review of the proposed development and recommend adopting suggested modifications to the proposed overlay district development standards to ensure consistency with the relevant policies and provisions of the LCP. The remaining 1730
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
4 modifications are minor clarifications to LIP text and figures that further the intent and implementation of the LCP and to avoid ambiguity.

For the reasons described in this report, Staff recommends that the Commission find that the proposed LUP amendment is consistent with and meets the requirements of the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act, and find the proposed LIP amendment, only if modified as suggested, is consistent with and adequate to carry out the applicable policies of the certified LUP as amended.
1831
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
5 Table of Contents
I. PROCEDURAL OVERVIEW................................................................................ 6 A. Standard of Review............................................................................................................ 6 B. Procedural Requirements................................................................................................... 6 C. Public Participation............................................................................................................. 7 II. STAFF RECOMMENDATION, MOTION, AND RESOLUTION FOR THE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT ................................................................................... 7 A. APPROVAL OF THE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT AS SUBMITTED ......................... 7 III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION, MOTIONS, AND RESOLUTIONS FOR THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AMENDMENT .............................................. 8 A. DENIAL OF THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AS SUBMITTED............................. 8 B. APPROVAL OF THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AMENDMENT WITH SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS ....................................................................................... 8 IV. SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS ON THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AMENDMENT...................................................................................................... 9 V. FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL OF THE LUP AMENDMENT AS SUBMITTED,

DENIAL OF THE LIP AMENDMENT AS SUBMITTED, AND APPROVAL OF THE LIP AMENDMENT IF MODIFIED AS SUGGESTED..................................13 A. Amendment Description and Background........................................................................14 B. Public Access and Recreation..........................................................................................16 C. New Development and LCP Administration .....................................................................29 D. California Environmental Quality Act ................................................................................33 Exhibits
Exhibit 1 – Proposed LIP Amendment Text Changes in Strikethrough/Underline Exhibit 2 – Proposed Land Use and Zoning Map Change
Exhibit 3 – Proposed Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map Exhibit 4 – Proposed Development Agreement
Exhibit 5 – Vicinity Map
Exhibit 6 – Aerial View of the Subject Parcels
Exhibit 7 – Parcel Map
Exhibit 8 – Overall Site Plan for Sea View Hotel Project 1932
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
6 I. PROCEDURAL OVERVIEW
A. Standard of Review
The Coastal Act provides:

The Commission shall certify a land use plan, or amendments thereto, if it finds that a land use plan meets the requirements of, and is in conformity with, the policies of Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 30200) … (Section 30512(c)) The local government shall submit to the Commission the zoning ordinances, zoning district maps, and, where necessary, other implementing actions that are required pursuant to this chapter…(Section 30513)
…The Commission may only reject zoning ordinances, zoning district maps, or other implementing actions on the grounds that they do not conform with, or are inadequate to carry out, the provisions of the certified land use plan. If the Commission rejects the zoning ordinances, zoning district maps, or other implementing actions, it shall give written notice of the rejection, specifying the provisions of the land use plan with which the rejected zoning ordinances do not conform, or which it finds will not be adequately carried out together with its reasons for the action taken…(Section 30513)
The Commission may suggest modifications in the rejected zoning ordinances, zoning district maps, or other implementing actions, which, if adopted by the local government and transmitted to the commission, shall be deemed approved upon confirmation by the executive director...(Section 30513) Any proposed amendments to a certified local coastal program shall be submitted to, and processed by, the commission in accordance with the applicable procedures and time limits specified in Sections 30512 and 30513… (Section 30514(b)) Pursuant to Section 30512(c), the standard of review that the Commission utilizes in reviewing the adequacy of the proposed amendment to the City’s certified land use plan (LUP) is whether the proposed amendment is consistent with, and meets the requirements of, the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. The standard of review for the proposed amendment to the City’s certified local implementation plan (LIP), pursuant to Sections 30513 and 30514(b) of the Coastal Act, is whether the proposed amendment is in conformance with, and adequate to carry out, the provisions of the LUP portion of the City’s certified local coastal program (LCP).

B. Procedural Requirements
If the Commission certifies the LCP amendment as submitted, no further City Council action will be necessary pursuant to Section 13544(b)(2) of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. Should the Commission deny the LCP Amendment, as submitted, without suggested modifications, no further action is required by either the Commission or the City 2033
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
7 Council, and the LCP amendment is not effective, pursuant to Section 13542(f). Should the Commission deny the LCP Amendment, as submitted, but then approve it with suggested modifications, then the City Council may consider accepting the suggested modifications and submitting them by resolution to the Executive Director for a determination that the City Council’s acceptance is consistent with the Commission's action. In that scenario, pursuant to Section 13544(c) of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, the modified LCP Amendment will become final when the Executive Director reports the determination that the local government's action is legally adequate to the Commission at its next regularly scheduled public meeting. If the City Council does not accept the suggested modifications within six months of the Commission’s action, then the LCP amendment remains uncertified and not effective.

C. Public Participation
Section 30503 of the Coastal Act requires public input in the preparation, approval, certification, and amendment of any LCP. The City held public hearings on this amendment and received oral and written comments regarding the proposed changes from concerned parties and members of the public. The hearings were duly noticed, consistent with the provisions of Section 13515 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. Notice of the Coastal Commission’s consideration of the subject amendment has been distributed to all known interested parties.

II. STAFF RECOMMENDATION, MOTION, AND RESOLUTION

FOR THE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT
Following public hearing, staff recommends the Commission adopt the following resolution and findings. The appropriate motion to introduce the resolution and a staff recommendation is provided.

A. APPROVAL OF THE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT AS SUBMITTED MOTION I:

I move that the Commission certify Land Use Plan Amendment No. LCP-4-MAL-21- 0073-2 as submitted by the City of Malibu.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO CERTIFY:

Staff recommends a YES vote. Passage of this motion will result in certification of the Land Use Plan amendment as submitted and the adoption of the following resolution and findings. The motion passes only by an affirmative vote of a majority of the appointed Commissioners.

RESOLUTION TO CERTIFY THE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT AS SUBMITTED:

The Commission hereby certifies the City of Malibu Land Use Plan Amendment No. LCP2134 LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
8 4-MAL-21-0073-2 as submitted by the City of Malibu and adopts the findings set forth below on the grounds that the amendment will meet the requirements of and be in conformity with the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. Certification of the Land Use Plan amendment complies with the California Environmental Quality Act because either 1) feasible mitigation measures and/or alternatives have been incorporated to substantially lessen any significant adverse effects of the land use plan on the environment, or 2) there are no further feasible alternatives or mitigation measures which could substantially lessen any significant adverse impact which the Land Use Plan amendment may have on the environment.

III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION, MOTIONS, AND

RESOLUTIONS FOR THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN

AMENDMENT
Following public hearing, staff recommends the Commission adopt the following resolutions and findings. The appropriate motion to introduce the resolution and a staff recommendation is provided prior to each resolution.

A. DENIAL OF THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AS SUBMITTED MOTION I:

I move that the Commission reject Local Implementation Plan Amendment No. LCP4-MAL-21-0073-2 as submitted by the City of Malibu.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION OF DENIAL:

Staff recommends a YES vote. Passage of this motion will result in denial of the Implementation Plan Amendment as submitted and adoption of the following resolution and findings. The motion passes only by an affirmative vote of a majority of the appointed Commissioners.

RESOLUTION TO DENY AS SUBMITTED:

The Commission hereby denies certification of the Local Implementation Plan Amendment No. LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 as submitted by the City of Malibu and adopts the findings set forth below on the grounds that the Local Implementation Plan Amendment, as submitted, does not conform with, and is inadequate to carry out, the provisions of the certified Land Use Plan. Certification of the Local Implementation Plan Amendment would not meet the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act, as there are feasible alternatives and mitigation measures that would substantially lessen the significant adverse impacts on the environment that will result from certification of the local implementation plan amendment as submitted.

B. APPROVAL OF THE LOCAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AMENDMENT

WITH SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS
2235
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
9 MOTION II:

I move that the Commission certify Local Implementation Plan Amendment No. LCP4-MAL-21-0073-2 for the City of Malibu if it is modified as suggested in this staff report.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO CERTIFY WITH SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS:

Staff recommends a YES vote. Passage of this motion will result in certification of the local implementation plan amendment with suggested modifications and adoption of the following resolution and findings. The motion passes only by an affirmative vote of a majority of the appointed Commissioners.

RESOLUTION TO CERTIFY WITH SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS:

The Commission hereby certifies the Local Implementation Plan Amendment No. LCP-4- MAL-21-0073-2 for the City of Malibu, if modified as suggested, and adopts the findings set forth below on grounds that the local implementation plan amendment with the suggested modifications will meet the requirements of and be in conformity with the policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. Certification of the land use plan amendment, if modified as suggested, complies with the California Environmental Quality Act, because either 1) feasible mitigation measures and/or alternatives have been incorporated to substantially lessen the any significant adverse effects of the land use plan amendment on the environment, or 2) there are no further feasible alternatives or mitigation measures that would substantially lessen any significant adverse impacts which the local implementation plan amendment may have on the environment.

IV.SUGGESTED MODIFICATIONS ON THE LOCAL

IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AMENDMENT
The staff recommends the Commission certify the proposed LIP amendment, with seven suggested modifications as shown below. Existing language of the certified Local Implementation Plan is shown in straight type. Language proposed to be added by the City of Malibu in this amendment is shown in underlined. Language proposed to be deleted by the City of Malibu in this amendment is shown as strikethrough. Language recommended by Commission staff to be inserted is shown in double underlined. Language recommended by Commission staff to be deleted is shown in double strikethrough.

Suggested Modification No. 1
LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District), and subsection B and C of LIP Section

3.4.6 shall be modified as follows:

3.4.6 Sea View Hotel Overlay District (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017)
2336
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
10 …
B. Description of Area Subject to LIP Section 3.4.6. The provisions of this section shall apply to the Project Site, a 51,776 square foot (1.19 acre) site, parcel, comprised of two merged parcels, currently identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway (Los Angeles County Assessor Parcel Numbers 4452-022-010 and 4452-022-017) in the Sea View Hotel Overlay District map.

C. Applicability. The Commercial Development Standards contained in LIP Section

3.18, as well as other applicable certified LCP policies and provision shall apply, unless specifically modified by this section.

Suggested Modification No. 2
Subsection D of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) shall be modified as follows:

D. Development Agreement. Pursuant to a Development Agreement between the property owner and the City of Malibu, the allowable Floor to Area Ratio (FAR) is increased from 0.15 to 0.52 if. Tthe applicant will contributes $800,000 to the City for public benefits and amenities, to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use.

Suggested Modification No. 3
The following subsection shall be added to LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District):

LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (“Applicant”) has agreed to enter into an agreement with the Coastal Commission to fund an associated escrow account, thereby committing to pay an in-lieu fee to another entity acceptable to the Executive Director of the Coastal Commission for use in developing lower cost visitor accommodations, to be released upon Applicant’s securing of entitlements to develop the site consistent with development standards of the Sea View Hotel Overlay District below.

Suggested Modification No. 4
Subsection E of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) shall be modified as follows:

EF. Development Standards.
2437
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
11 …

PROJECTIONS INTO YARDS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.5.3(B) apply with the
is modified as following s additional provision:
• Access and exit stairs required by the Fire
Department, and existing retaining walls may
project without limit into required side yards.

SITE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA
…
Minimum Onsite
Landscaping
The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not
apply. The Sea View Hotel landscaping criteria are as
follows:

A minimum of 8,977 square feet of landscaping at
ground level. Additionally, there shall be a minimum
of 2,528.6 square feet of plants in planters on the
southerly seaward areas of the various decks.

Minimum Onsite Open
Space
The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)(b) shall not
apply. The Sea View Hotel open space criteria are as
follows:

HEIGHT
Maximum Height
Projections
The provisions of LIP Section 3.8(A)(1) shall not
apply. The Sea View Hotel height requirements are
as follow:
• New structures which have sloping roofs that
slope less than 25% shall be no higher than 24
feet above the existing natural grade or finished
grade, whichever results in a lower building
height, excluding basements
• New structures which have sloping roofs that
slope 25%, or more, shall be no higher than 28
feet above the existing natural grade or finished
grade, whichever results in a lower building
height, excluding basements. Areas such as
elevator shafts in order to comply with ADA laws,
the wooden deck above the existing tile rooftop
2538
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
12 deck, the fire exit stairs required by the Fire
Department, the safety railing around the decks,
and the sound wall as described in the Mitigated
Negative Declaration are excluded from the
referenced height restrictions. Seven-foot
overhangs to eliminate sun from hitting south
facing windows are excluded from the height
standards.

PARKING AND ACCESS
Parking Requirements The provisions of LIP Sections 3.14.2 and 3.14.3 shall not apply. The Sea View Hotel parking requirements
are as follows:
• 1.5 parking spaces per hotel room.
• 1 space for each, per-shift employee (15-full time
employees per shift – 15 spaces)
• 1 space for each 100 square feet of gross floor
area used for consumption of food or beverages,
or public recreation areas.
• 1 space for each 5 fixed seats, or for every 35
square feet of assembly area where there are no
fixed seats in meeting rooms or other assembly
areas.
…
Layout and Paving The provisions of LIP Section 3.14.5 are modified or shall not apply as follows:
…
• The landscaped areas and the parking plan
shown on the Sea View Hotel plans are an
integral part of the proposed hotel and are
acceptable within the overlay district.

MONUMENT SIGN AND GENERAL SIGN REQUIREMENTS
The provisions of LIP Section 3.15.6 are modified or
shall not apply as follows:
• The provisions of LIP Section 3.15.6(A)(2)(d)(iii)
shall not apply.
…
Suggested Modification No. 5
Subsection F of LIP Section 3.4.6 (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) shall be modified as 2639
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
13 follows:

FG. PERMITTED USES
The following permitted, conditionally permitted, and prohibited uses and design standards are as follows: shall apply to the Sea View Hotel Overlay District. Permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are a component of the hotel development are subject to the custom development standards of this Sea View Hotel Overlay District.

Suggested Modification No. 6
Modify the Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map (attached as Exhibit 3 of this staff report) to depict the Sea View Hotel Overlay District site as two parcels and add corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) to differentiate which parcels are subject to the Sea View Hotel Overlay District.

Suggested Modification No. 7
Modify the LIP Zoning Map (attached as Exhibit 2 of this staff report) to depict the Sea View Hotel Overlay District site as two parcels APN 4452-002-010 and 4452-022-017.

V. FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL OF THE LUP AMENDMENT AS

SUBMITTED, DENIAL OF THE LIP AMENDMENT AS

SUBMITTED, AND APPROVAL OF THE LIP AMENDMENT IF

MODIFIED AS SUGGESTED
2740
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
14 The following findings support the Commission’s certification of the proposed Land Use Plan amendment as submitted, the Commission’s denial of the proposed Local Implementation Plan amendment as submitted, and approval of the Local Implementation Plan Amendment if modified as suggested (detailed in Section IV. Suggested Modifications above).

The Commission hereby finds and declares as follows:

A. Amendment Description and Background
The City of Malibu (“City”) is requesting an amendment to the Land Use Plan (LUP) and Local Implementation Plan (LIP) portions of its certified LCP to change the land use and zoning designation of two adjacent commercially developed parcels identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) (APN: 4452-022-010) and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway (APN: 4452-022-017), from Community Commercial (CC) to Commercial Visitor Serving Two (CV-2) on the LUP Land Use Map and LIP Zoning Map. These two parcels together comprise approximately 1.18 acres of land known as the Sea View Hotel Site (“subject site”).

The LIP amendment further proposes the creation of a new overlay district (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) to accommodate the construction of a new 39-room hotel with associated amenities on the subject site (22729 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway). The proposed overlay map will be added to the LIP Zoning Maps (Exhibit 2) and will apply use restrictions and development standards over the property. The proposed overlay site is currently zoned Community Commercial and contains existing development consisting of commercial buildings and associated parking areas. The Community Commercial (CC) land use and zoning designation is intended to provide the community's resident-serving needs, including uses such as restaurants, banks, offices, and retail. Hotel use is not permitted in the CC zone and is only permitted within the Commercial Visitor Serving Two (CV-2) zone. To accommodate the proposed hotel development, the City determined that the subject site needed to be rezoned from CC to CV-2.

Additionally, the proposed hotel project seeks to remodel and convert one of the existing commercial buildings (which is currently non-conforming in regard to height and floor area ratio) located on the subject site at 22741 PCH. It proposes an allowable floor area ratio greater than currently allowed under the commercial development standards of the City’s LCP. The existing FAR for the existing development on 22741 PCH is 0.46. Therefore, the City determined that a new overlay district with specific development standards (maximum density, including floor area ratios for commercial use, heights, lot coverage, open space requirements, setbacks, and parking and sign requirements) is needed to accommodate some of the as-built existing development (which would remain on the subject site), as well as modifying some of the development standards related to parking, parking locations, maximum allowable floor area ratio to accommodate the proposed hotel development.

Development Agreement
Pursuant to the certified Malibu LCP, increasing the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) beyond what is allowed under the LCP, which is proposed in the overlay district development standards, 2841
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
15 triggers the need for a development agreement to be approved through an LCP amendment certified by the Coastal Commission (LIP Section 3.8(A)(5)). Therefore, the proposed amendment also includes the approval of a Development Agreement between the City and property owners that sets forth the terms of the agreement regarding the eventual development of the subject site, including allowable uses, development standards, and maximum allowable floor area ratio (FAR). The development agreement also details the applicant’s ability to develop a new hotel with an increased allowable floor area ratio from 0.15 to 0.52 in conjunction with a payment of $800,000 to the City to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use. The Development Agreement is discussed in greater detail in Subsection B (New Development and Cumulative Impacts) below.

The full text of the City’s proposed changes to the LCP is included as Exhibits 1-3 of this report.

On August 13, 2021, before the City’s August 19, 2021, City Council hearing, Commission staff emailed City staff with regarding the proposed LIP Amendment. Furthermore, Commission staff has met with City staff to discuss the proposed amendment, and staff has provided the suggested modifications to the City’s planning staff. However, the City staff has not indicated whether or not they are supportive of the suggested modifications. In addition, Commission staff has coordinated closely with the property owners to reach an agreement on a mechanism whereby the property owners have agreed to provide an in-lieu fee for use in developing low-cost visitor serving overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone.

The City of Malibu submitted the subject LCP Amendment to the Commission on November 15, 2021. The amendment submittal was deemed complete by Commission staff and filed on March 21, 2022. At its June 2022 Commission meeting, the Commission extended the 90 working-day time limit to act on the LCP amendment for a period not to exceed one year from the original deadline of July 28, 2022.

Background and Sea View Hotel Project Description
The subject “Sea View Hotel” property is comprised of two parcels (22729 and 22741 PCH) and is at the base of a steep hillside to the north (Exhibit 6). The site is located on the landward side of PCH in a commercial area of the City, approximately one-third mile east of the Malibu Pier and Civic Center area. Further north, there is an area of hillside residential development. The site is developed with an existing 15,392 square foot, four-level office building (still operating today with business tenants) and an associated 9,500 square foot parking area containing 60 parking spaces (22741 PCH), and a 1,000 square foot building, two canopies, and surface parking for a gas station use that operated until 2005. Due to the steep hillside, the office building was constructed in a stepped fashion, such that each level is located higher up and stepped into the hillside. As such, the height of the existing commercial/office building varies from 26.5 feet to 48 feet above the existing grade and up to 25 to 40 feet higher in elevation than 22729 PCH.

The subject Sea View Hotel property owners propose merging the two parcels associated 2942
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
16 with the proposed overlay district and constructing a new 39-room luxury hotel, including remodeling the existing commercial building that would remain in place. An Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration were prepared and adopted for the project by the City pursuant to CEQA. The City has also approved the coastal development permit for the lot merger and hotel development. However, the coastal development permit was conditioned by the City to only be effective after certification of the subject LCP amendment.

Notwithstanding the requirements of Malibu LIP Section 13.16 that a Final Local Action Notice be submitted to the Commission within seven days of City action, the Final Local Action Notice, in this case, has never been submitted to the Commission. Therefore, the approved CDP related to this site is not final. Specifically, the City approved the following:

On September 13, 2021, the City approved Demolition Permit No. 20-019, Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Conditional Use Permit No. 21-001, and Lot Merger No. 20-002 to merge the two subject parcels (22741 and 22729 PCH), demolish the existing gas station, and construct a new four-story, 26,734 square foot, 39-room hotel involving the remodel of an existing four-story, commercial building, and construction of a new two-story, 11,342 square foot addition with a basement. The project includes a restaurant/bar, spa, rooftop deck, swimming pool, new surface parking lot, hardscape and landscaping, grading, retaining wall, utilities, and an upgrade and expansion of the existing onsite wastewater treatment system.

Pursuant to Special Condition 34 of the CDP, the applicant/property owner is required to pay a fee of $110,000 to the City in-lieu of providing lower cost overnight accommodations.

On September 13, 2021, the City approved the subject LCP amendment to modify the land use and zoning designation of two subject parcels from Community Commercial to Commercial Visitor Serving-Two, a new overlay district with special development standards to facilitate the development of a hotel, and a Development Agreement to allow an increase in allowable floor area from 0.15 to 0.52. The City also adopted Initial Study No. 21-001, Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program No. 21-001 for the project.

B. Public Access and Recreation
A core goal of the Coastal Act is to protect the public’s ability to recreate in and enjoy the coastal zone, particularly for coastal visitors not fortunate enough to live by the shoreline.

The Coastal Act’s access and recreation policies provide significant direction regarding protecting existing public recreational access opportunities and ensuring that such access opportunities are provided and maximized. Specifically, Coastal Act Section 30210 requires that maximum public access and recreation opportunities be provided, stating:

In carrying out the requirement of Section 4 of Article X of the California Constitution, maximum access, which shall be conspicuously posted, and recreational opportunities shall be provided for all the people consistent with public safety needs and the need to protect public rights, rights of private property owners, and natural resource areas from overuse.
3043
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
17 Similarly, the Coastal Act requires that overnight accommodations, particularly lower-cost accommodations, be protected and encouraged as a means of providing public recreation access to the coast.

Section 30213 of the Coastal Act states:

Lower cost visitor and recreational facilities shall be protected, encouraged, and, where feasible, provided. Development providing public recreational opportunities are preferred.

The commission shall not: (1) require that overnight room rentals be fixed at an amount certain for any privately owned and operated hotel, motel, or other similar visitor-serving facility located on either public or private lands; or (2) establish or approve any method for the identification of low or moderate income persons for the purpose of determining eligibility for overnight room rentals in any such facilities.

Furthermore, Coastal Act Section 30222 places a higher priority on the provision of visitorserving uses designed to enhance public opportunities for coastal recreation over residential, industrial, or general commercial uses.

Section 30222 of the Coastal Act states:

The use of private lands suitable for visitor-serving commercial recreational facilities designed to enhance public opportunities for coastal recreation shall have priority over private residential general commercial development, but not over agriculture or coastal-dependent industry.

The Coastal Act policies above have been incorporated in their entirety into the certified Land Use Plan. The Malibu LCP also contains several additional policies to ensure the protection of public access and overnight accommodations.

The following Land Use Plan (LUP) policies are applicable in this case:

Land Use Plan Policy 2.1 states:

The shoreline, parklands, beaches and trails located within the City provide a wide range of recreational opportunities in natural settings which include hiking, equestrian activities, bicycling, camping, educational study, picnicking, and coastal access. These recreational opportunities shall be protected, and where feasible, expanded or enhanced as a resource of regional, state and national importance.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.25 states:

New development shall provide off-street parking sufficient to serve the approved use in order to minimize impacts to public street parking available for coastal access and recreation.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.33 states:
3144
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
18 Priority shall be given to the development of visitor-serving and commercial recreational facilities designed to enhance public opportunities for coastal recreation.

On land designated for visitor-serving commercial and/or recreational facilities, priority shall be given to such use over private residential or general commercial development. New visitor-serving uses shall not displace existing low-cost visitorserving uses unless an equivalent replacement is provided.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.34 states:

Existing, lower cost visitor-serving and recreational facilities, including overnight accommodations, shall be protected to the maximum feasible extent. New lower cost visitor and recreational facilities, including overnight accommodations, shall be encouraged and provided, where designated on the LUP Map. Priority shall be given to developments that include public recreational opportunities. New or expanded facilities shall be sited and designed to minimize impacts to environmentally sensitive habitat areas and visual resources.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.35 states:

New development of luxury overnight visitor-serving accommodations shall be designed to provide for a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations (e.g., campground, RV park, hostel, or lower cost hotel/motel). The lower-cost visitor accommodations may be provided on-site, off-site, or through payment of an in-lieu fee into a fund to subsidize the construction of lower-cost overnight facilities in the Malibu-Santa Monica Mountains Coastal Zone area of Los Angeles County or Ventura County. The applicant shall be required to provide lower-cost overnight accommodations consisting of 15 percent of the number of luxury overnight accommodations that are approved.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.36 states:

Coastal recreational and visitor serving uses and opportunities, especially lower cost opportunities, shall be protected, encouraged, and where feasible, provided by both public and private means. Removal or conversion of existing lower cost opportunities shall be prohibited unless the use will be replaced with another offering comparable visitor serving or recreational opportunities.

Land Use Plan Policy 2.37 states:

Priority shall be given to the development of visitor-serving commercial and/or recreational uses that complement public recreation areas or supply recreational opportunities not currently available in public parks or beaches. Visitor-serving commercial and/or recreational uses may be located near public parks and recreational areas only if the scale and intensity of the visitor-serving commercial recreational uses is compatible with the character of the nearby parkland and all applicable provisions of the LCP.

Land Use Plan Policy 5.11 states:
3245
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
19 Recreational development and commercial visitor-serving facilities shall have priority over non-coastal dependent uses. All uses shall be consistent with protection of public access and ESHA.

In addition, the following Local Implementation Plan (LIP) sections are specifically applicable in this case:

LIP Section 12.10 (New Luxury Overnight Accommodations), in relevant part, states:

A. The City may approve new luxury overnight visitor accommodations if the evidence shows and the City finds, that the project provides a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations, such as a campground, RV park, hostel, or lower cost hotel or motel rooms. The lower cost overnight accommodations may be provided, either onsite, offsite, or through payment of an in-lieu fee to the City for deposit into a fund to subsidize the construction of lower cost overnight facilities in the Malibu-Santa Monica Mountains Coastal Zone area of Los Angeles County or Ventura County. The applicant shall be required to provide lower cost overnight accommodations consisting of fifteen (15) percent of the number of luxury overnight accommodations that are approved. Luxury overnight accommodations shall be defined as the point at which the cost of an overnight room exceeds 120 percent of the median cost of an overnight room for all overnight accommodations in the City of Malibu.

B. If the applicant chooses the in-lieu fee option, the project approval shall be conditioned to require that, prior to issuance of the coastal development permit, the applicant shall pay the required in-lieu fee to the City. The amount of the inlieu fee shall be $10,419 per required unit of lower cost overnight accommodations, plus an additional amount for inflation from January 2000 to the date of approval of the coastal development permit. If the City completes a fee study to determine the appropriate in-lieu fee, which provides the necessary mitigation, the in-lieu fee requirement may be revised accordingly.

Visitor-Serving Lands
Visitor-serving commercial development is considered a priority use under the Coastal Act and the Malibu LCP, and is given priority over other non-coastal dependent development.

In order to ensure that new development is located in areas able to accommodate it and where it will not have significant cumulative impacts on coastal resources, as required by the Coastal Act and Malibu LCP, it is necessary for the LCP to designate the appropriate location, density, and intensity for different kinds of development. Such designations must also take into account the requirements of other applicable policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act and the Malibu LUP, including public access, recreation, land and marine resources, and scenic and visual quality.

The City is requesting an amendment to the LUP and LIP portions of its certified LCP to change the land use and zoning designation of two adjacent commercially developed 3346
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
20 parcels identified as 22729 Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway from Community Commercial (CC) to Commercial Visitor Serving Two (CV-2) on the LUP Land Use Map and LIP Zoning Map. These two parcels together comprise approximately

1.18 acres of land known as the Sea View Hotel Site (“subject site”). The subject site contains existing development consisting of commercial buildings and surface and covered parking. The City has stated that the proposed LUP/Zoning Map change is intended to accommodate the development of a new 39-room luxury hotel.

The Community Commercial (CC) designation is intended to provide for the residentserving needs of the community, similar to the types of uses allowed in the neighborhood serving commercial developments but on parcels of land more suitable for concentrated commercial activity. Uses that are allowed in the CC land use designation include, but are not limited to, small retail stores, salons and bookstores, restaurants, offices, financial institutions, medical clinics, service stations, health care facilities, offices, and public open space and recreation. The maximum Floor to Area Ratio (FAR) for CC development is

0.15. The maximum FAR may be increased to a maximum of 0.20, where public benefits and amenities are provided as part of the project.

The Commercial Visitor Serving (CV) designation provides for visitor serving uses such as hotels and restaurants that are designed to be consistent with the rural character and natural environmental setting, as well public open space and recreation uses. Additionally, CV designations are divided into two levels of intensity. Hotels are only permitted in CV-2 designations, the highest intensity designation. The maximum Floor to Area Ratio (FAR) for CV development is 0.15. The maximum FAR may be increased to a maximum of 0.25, where public benefits and amenities are provided as part of the project.

The subject site is located on the landward side of PCH in a commercial area of the City, approximately one-third mile east of the Malibu Pier and Civic Center area. Properties in the immediate vicinity are zoned CC, CV-1, and CV-2 and are developed with commercial structures and uses, including hotels such as the Malibu Beach Inn and Nobu Ryokan, and several restaurants. Further north, there is an area of hillside residential development. The site is near parks, public beaches, accessways, and trails/bikeways where public access and recreation is available to visitors. For these reasons, the site is appropriate for visitorserving commercial use, such as the proposed hotel development. Consistent with Coastal Act Section 30222, and LUP Policies 2.33, 2.36, and 5.11, which state that priority shall be given to the development of visitor-serving and commercial recreational facilities designed to enhance public opportunities for coastal recreation, the proposed land use/zoning change from community commercial to visitor serving commercial will ensure that visitor serving uses are prioritized on the subject sites. Visitor-serving commercial uses provide greater public benefit than community commercial uses because they serve a larger segment of the population who can take advantage of and enjoy the use of the property, and such uses support visitors to the coast. All future development of the subject site will need to support the visitor-serving nature of the area, be consistent with the allowable uses under the CV land use designation/zone, and be consistent with the policies and provisions of the certified LCP.

Lower Cost Overnight Accommodations
3447
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
21 These Coastal Act and LCP policies make clear that public recreational access, particularly as it relates to the specific needs of the visiting public, is of critical importance and must be protected and maximized. Overnight accommodations are necessary for providing public access and recreational opportunities for the many visitors that live further from the coast, including those from inland areas, where a coastal trip may require a lengthy car, train, or bus ride. For many low and moderate-income visitors, lower-cost overnight accommodations are essential to being able to access the California coast at all. These access issues are perhaps more apparent than ever now and more critical as they relate to overnight accommodations, as coastal visitors are increasingly priced out of the overnight accommodations market, particularly impacting low and middle-income households, communities of color, and many young people.1
Specifically, Section 30213 of the Coastal Act provides for the protection and provision of lower cost visitor and recreational facilities. Visitor-serving commercial development is considered a priority use under the Coastal Act, and, pursuant to public access policies of the Coastal Act, the Commission has the responsibility to ensure that a range of affordable facilities be provided in new development along the coast, including overnight accommodation options.

Furthermore, given the limited availability of overnight accommodations in Malibu, access issues also raise environmental justice concerns. Under Section 30604 of the Coastal Act, “[w]hen acting on a coastal development permit, the issuing agency, or the Commission on appeal, may consider environmental justice, or the equitable distribution of environmental benefits throughout the state.” As defined in Section 30107.3 (a) of the Coastal Act, “environmental justice” means “the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of people of all races, cultures, incomes and national origins, with respect to the development, adoption, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.” Thus, environmental justice considerations are relevant to the Commission’s review.

Overview of Malibu’s Overnight Accommodations
Demand for overnight accommodations is especially high in the City of Malibu because of its proximity to the coast and historical reputation as a popular coastal community. The City lies entirely within the Coastal Zone and extends approximately 26 miles from the Ventura County Line to Topanga Canyon Boulevard on the east. The beaches of Malibu are worldfamous tourist destinations for millions of visitors annually from foreign countries, all 50 states of the U.S., as well as for residents of cities and towns throughout California. In addition, the Santa Monica Mountains area within and adjacent to the City provides an extensive network of public trails that traverse and connect Federal, State, and County parklands and a system of heavily used historic trails on private land. Overall, a wide variety of recreational opportunities exist in the area, including hiking, biking, horseback riding, camping, fishing, picnicking, nature study, surfing, diving, and swimming. Public access to and along the shoreline and trails and the provision of public recreational opportunities and visitor-serving facilities such as campgrounds, hotels, and motels have 1 See “Explore the Coast Overnight: An Assessment of Lower-Cost Coastal Accommodations” by the California Coastal Conservancy (March 2019) and California Coastal Commission Public Workshop Staff Report on Lower-Cost Visitor-Serving Accommodations (October 2016).
3548
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
22 historically been a critical and controversial issue in Malibu.

Despite being a significant visitor-serving destination, there are limited facilities within the City that offer overnight accommodations for visitors within its 21 miles of coastline. There are six hotels (The M Malibu, The Surfrider, Malibu Beach Inn, Malibu County Inn, The Native, and Nobu Ryokan) within the City, containing a total of 130 rooms. Additionally, the City contains one Recreational Vehicle (RV) park (Malibu RV Park), which includes 142 RV sites and 35 tent camping sites. Although there are several hotels and motels in other cities surrounding Malibu, the approximate 21 miles of Malibu coastline is only serviced by approximately 130 hotel rooms, 142 RV sites, 35 tent sites, and the City’s existing shortterm rental stock.

Trends in Coastal Overnight Accommodations
The Commission has approved new hotel developments along the coastline as high-priority visitor-serving facilities, however, high room rates can render these visitor-serving hotels exclusive2. The Commission has required mitigation for the use of land that would have otherwise been available for lower-cost and visitor-serving facilities. The Commission has also approved projects and LCP amendments requiring the development of overnight accommodations with facilities that serve a range of incomes. In past actions, where the development proposed has not provided for a range of affordability on-site, the Commission had required offsite mitigation, in the form of payment of an in-lieu mitigation fee to fund construction of lower-cost overnight accommodations, e.g., hostels, recreational vehicle (RV) parks, campgrounds, etc.

In November 2016, the Commission staff presented a comprehensive study of lower-cost visitor accommodations eliminated from the coastal zone since 19893. The study considered six cost categories ranging from “economy” to “luxury” and found that 24,720 total economy rooms had been lost, while only 11,247 rooms of the higher cost categories had been lost since 19894. These survey results indicate that nearly 70% of all hotel rooms eliminated from the coastal zone from 1989 to 2016 were economy rooms, whereas less than 10% of the rooms lost were in the upscale and luxury categories. Of the hotels that are being developed, a greater number of hotels offer high-cost accommodations. The remaining moderate and lower-cost hotels in the coastal zone typically constitute older structures that become less economically viable as time passes. It is often more lucrative for developers to replace these older structures with higher-cost accommodations. Such trends have thus made it difficult for visitors with limited financial means to access the coast; many of these visitors travel from inland locations and cannot easily make the trip to the coast and back home again in a single day.

Although statewide demand for lower-cost accommodations in the coastal zone is difficult 2 Explore the Coast Overnight- An Assessment of Lower Cost Accommodations, published by State Coastal Conservancy on January 8, 2019.
3 Ref. Public Workshop: Lower Cost Visitor Serving Accommodations, published by Commission staff on October 26, 2016.
4 Ref. Public Workshop: Lower Cost Visitor Serving Accommodations, published by Commission staff on October 26, 2016.
3649
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
23 to quantify, there is no question that low-cost hotels, camping, and hostel opportunities are in high demand in coastal areas and that there is an ongoing need to provide more lowercost opportunities along California’s coast. In a Coastal Conservancy-commissioned survey conducted in 2017, an assessment of lower-cost overnight accommodations found that “respondents cited financial concerns as the primary reason they do not stay overnight at the coast. Over 45% of Californians said that overnight accommodations at the coast were inconvenient or unaffordable.”5
Sea View Hotel Project-Specific LCP Amendment
The amendment request is project-specific to allow for the construction of a new 39-room luxury hotel on the subject site with changes to the land use and zoning designation to permit the construction of new overnight luxury accommodations and a new overlay district with special development standards to facilitate the development of a hotel.

As stated above, in light of current trends in coastal overnight accommodations, the Commission is increasingly concerned with the challenge of providing lower-cost overnight accommodations consistent with the Coastal Act. Although low-cost overnight facilities are not currently developed on the subject site, the proposed change in both the land use and zoning designation and the proposed overlay district would accommodate the development of a luxury hotel that may not include a component of lower cost overnight accommodations. As the trend continues to build upscale and luxury hotel development on land that is designated for hotel/motel development, persons of low and moderate incomes will make up fewer of the guests staying in the City of Malibu’s coastal zone. By forcing this economic group to lodge elsewhere, there will be a direct impact on public access to the beach and coastal recreational areas within the area. With the loss of potential low-cost lodging facilities, a large segment of the state’s population will be excluded from overnight stays within this coastal area. Therefore, by protecting and providing low-cost lodging for the price-sensitive visitor, a larger segment of the population will have a greater opportunity to enjoy access to the beach area through overnight stays along or near the coast.

Furthermore, access to coastal recreational facilities, such as the beaches, harbor, piers, and other coastal points of interest, are also enhanced when there are overnight lodging facilities that serve a broader segment of the population.

The certified Malibu LCP also contains policies and provisions for the protection of lowercost overnight accommodations, outlined above. Specifically, LUP Policy 2.33 prioritizes the development of visitor-serving commercial recreational facilities that enhance public opportunities for coastal recreation over private residential or general commercial development. LUP Policy 2.36 protects existing, lower cost visitor serving facilities and encourages the development of new lower cost facilities. LUP Policy 2.35 requires that new development of overnight visitor-serving accommodations include a component of lower cost facilities or provide mitigation in the form of an in-lieu fee to help subsidize the construction of lower cost facilities.

Furthermore, LUP Policy 2.35 and LIP Section 12.10 state that the City may approve new 5 Explore the Coast Overnight- An Assessment of Lower Cost Accommodations, published by State Coastal Conservancy on January 8, 2019.
3750
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
24 luxury overnight visitor accommodations if the evidence shows and the City finds, that the project provides a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations, such as a campground, RV park, hostel, or lower cost hotel or motel rooms. Furthermore, LIP Section

12.10 states that lower cost overnight accommodations may be provided, either onsite, offsite, or through payment of an in-lieu fee to the City for deposit into a fund to subsidize the construction of lower cost overnight facilities in the Malibu-Santa Monica Mountains Coastal Zone area of Los Angeles County or Ventura County. The applicant shall be required to provide lower cost overnight accommodations consisting of fifteen percent of the total number of approved luxury overnight accommodations. If instead the applicant chooses the in-lieu fee option, the project approval shall be conditioned to require the applicant to pay an in-lieu fee to the City of $10,419 per required unit of lower cost overnight accommodations, plus an additional amount for inflation from January 2000 to the date of approval of the CDP. In this case, fifteen percent of the proposed 39 luxury overnight accommodations/rooms equates to 5.85 lower cost overnight accommodations/rooms required to be provided under the LCP.

As stated above, the City has already approved the coastal development permit (CDP No. 17-086) for the subject hotel development and conditioned the CDP to require the property owners to pay a fee of $110,000 to the City in-lieu of providing lower cost overnight accommodations (Special Condition No. 34). The property owners agreed to contribute an in-lieu fee to the City of $17,671.22 per 6 rooms for a total of $106,027.32 ($10,419 plus inflation using the California Department of Industrial Relations CPI Increase 2000-2020 equates to $17,671). Therefore, the City approval of the CDP for the hotel development provides for this in-lieu fee to offset the loss of low-cost overnight accommodations opportunities.

In this case, no existing lower-cost rooms are being demolished or replaced since the proposed project related to the subject LCP amendment does not include demolishing an existing lower-cost hotel or motel. However, the project raises an issue of whether the project specific LCP amendment is consistent with the Coastal Act’s and LCP’s policies to ensure that proposed visitor-accommodation facilities in the coastal zone include lower-cost rooms.

As stated above, the preferred method to ensure consistency with Coastal Act sections 30213 and 30222 is the provision of new lower-cost rooms on or near the project site.

However, the City’s LCP (LIP Section 12.10) allows for lower cost overnight accommodations to be provided, either onsite, offsite, or through payment of an in-lieu fee to the City for deposit into a fund to subsidize the construction of lower cost overnight facilities. In this case, the property owners decided to provide lower cost overnight accommodations through payment of an in-lieu fee to the City.

However, the City’s LCP in-lieu fee option of $10,419 per required unit of lower cost overnight accommodations, plus an additional amount for inflation, has not kept pace with the cost of providing lower cost accommodations in the coastal zone and is therefore too low in comparison to the in-lieu mitigation fee per required lower-cost room (not provided onsite) that the Commission has required in recent past actions for new hotel development along the coast, which is discussed in more detail below. 3851
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
25 In-Lieu Mitigation Fee
In 2014, following Commissioner questions regarding the adequacy of the in-lieu fee for lower-cost accommodations at Commission hearings, Hostelling International provided an updated report representing the true construction costs of a new hostel, which stated that new construction costs approximately $42,120 per hostel bed without the cost of land acquisition. In order to verify this information, the Commission consulted Maurice Robinson & Associates. Robinson concurred with the figures and stated: “This lends itself to a twotiered Index for a representative cost to develop low-cost lodging statewide. The $42,120 per bed estimate for the structure can be indexed on an annual basis, either by CPI (Consumer Price Index) or, alternatively, with a more construction industry-specific index such as the Turner Building Cost Index.”
The Turner Building Cost Index is used widely by federal and state governments to measure costs in the non-residential building construction market in the United States.6 Robinson further expanded on the cost of providing motel or hotel rooms rather than hostel beds and estimated:
“These new motel rooms would likely cost nearly $100,000 per room to develop (excluding land), which is more than twice the cost of a hostel bed, mostly due to the fact that motels require approximately twice the gross square footage per person than hostels.”
A standard hotel or motel room (250 sq. ft. average) represents a much larger space than a single hostel bed. The cost of constructing new low-cost hotel rooms with new lower-cost hotel/motel rooms is significantly higher than replacing them with hostel beds. Following this information and suggestion, the Commission required new high cost hotel projects and projects that eliminated existing lower-cost overnight accommodations to pay an in-lieu mitigation fee of $100,000 per required lower-cost room not provided onsite.7 This requirement was based on information provided in 2015. However, when considering the approximate 27% increase in the Turner Building Cost Index in the last seven years (likely related to inflation and other factors), the estimated cost of constructing a lower-cost hotel or motel room has increased from $100,000 per room to $127,000 per room.8 Robinson also recommended that land costs be calculated separately from construction costs in the in-lieu mitigation fee. It is important to note that in-lieu mitigation fees are often accepted and used by many public and non-profit organizations. The in-lieu fees provide funding to public agencies and non-profit organizations, including California State Parks, Mountains Recreation and Authority, and Hostelling International, for the provision of lowercost overnight visitor accommodations within or near the coastal zone. These lower-cost overnight visitor accommodations include, but are not limited to, RV park sites, hostel accommodations, campgrounds, cabins, and lower-cost hotel or motel accommodations. 6 The Turner Building Cost Index is used widely by federal and state governments to measure costs in the nonresidential building construction market in the United States. (Ref. https://www.turnerconstruction.com/cost-index) 7 Ref. CDP 5-18-0872 (Sunshine Enterprises, LP), CDP 5-20-0181 (B&J Capital Group Investments) 8 The Turner Building Cost Index was 943 for 2015 and 1199 for 2021. 1199 – 943 = 256 / 943 = 0.27 * 100% = 27% increase
3952
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
26 These agencies and organizations often already own land and require solely construction funds. As such, the mitigation fee of $127,000 per lower-cost hotel room does not include land costs. Maurice Robinson & Associates addresses the widely varying cost of land acquisition:
“The range in land costs might be as great as from $100/sf to $600/sf in Los Angeles County’s Coastal Zone. For a 10,000 sf parcel of land, the total land costs could be anywhere from $1 million to $6 million—a huge range. This variability in the price of land dwarfs the cost of providing the hostel improvements[.] …This illustrates the need for the Commission to find alternative, lower-cost ways to acquire the land replacement low-cost lodging. As examples, the proposed hostels could be built on land owned by the following non-private-sector types of entities:
- Public agencies, such as State Parks, which have similar social goals; - Non-profit organizations, which may not require a market-level rate of return; or - Quasi-public agencies, such as Port Districts, but leased at a below-market rate.

Indeed, while the cost to construct the hostel building would be expected to remain fairly constant throughout the State, the land costs could vary dramatically in each case.”
Here, a mitigation fee including the cost of land acquisition is unnecessary because the mitigation funds proposed by the applicant would be directed to a third party entity acceptable to the Executive Director of the Coastal Commission that has land available for providing lower-cost visitor amenities in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone, with the intention that such projects do not require the purchase of land.

As indicated above, the property owners propose the construction of 39 luxury overnight accommodations and has volunteered to pay a fee of $110,000 to the City in-lieu of providing lower cost overnight accommodations onsite or offsite. In addition, the property owners, in consultation with Commission staff, have offered to pay an in-lieu mitigation fee of $800,000 ($133,000 per room) to assist in funding affordable overnight accommodations elsewhere in the Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone. The fee proposed by the property owners is consistent with the in-lieu mitigation fee per required lower-cost room that the Commission has required in recent past actions9 for new hotel development along the coast and is significantly more than the fee required by the City ($110,000).

The property owners, in consultation with Commission staff, have identified a potential public project to which to direct the $800,000 fee to implement affordable visitor-serving accommodations. In May 2020, the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (“MRCA”) acquired the 23.71-acre Lauber Smith Property in the Santa Monica Mountains for a mix of habitat conservation, open space, and public access and recreation uses. The property is about 9 miles northwest of the subject “Sea View Hotel” site, within the coastal zone of unincorporated Los Angeles County, adjacent to Ramirez Canyon Park, and just outside Malibu city limits. In particular, MRCA’s goal is, in part, to develop campground 9 Ref. CDP A-5-VEN-21-0011 (Wynkoop Properties, LLC); CDP 5-18-0872 (Shore Hotel) 4053
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
27 facilities, including flame-less facilities (tent pad sites, including ADA accessible tent pad sites) and visitor-serving improvements (parking, restrooms, and picnic areas) on portions of the property to serve the general public as well as underserved and foster youth programs of MRCA. The use of these funds in this manner would be consistent with LUP Policies 2.33, 2.34, 2.36, and 2.37 to create or protect visitor serving and recreational uses.

Because the property owners did not propose the $800,000 mitigation fee as part of its underlying coastal development permit applications to the City, this proposed fee is not reflected in the proposed LCP amendment request.

To provide an effective mechanism for the project proponent to provide a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations through an up-to-date in-lieu mitigation fee required by the Commission in recent actions, the property owners and the Commission staff have worked cooperatively to reach an agreement on a mechanism whereby the property owners have entered into an agreement with the Coastal Commission and funded an associated escrow account, thereby committing to pay an $800,000 in-lieu fee for use in developing lower cost visitor accommodations, to be released once the owner secures entitlements to develop the site with a hotel use and those entitlements are no longer subject to challenge. Commission staff, in consultation with MRCA, have identified a potential public project to which to direct the $800,000 fee in this case (new camping at the Lauber Smith Property adjacent to Ramirez Canyon,) that is in close proximity to the subject site and will provide a greater range of low-cost camping experiences for a more diverse ability range of the public.

The escrow agreement also provides for the delivery into escrow of a Declaration of Covenants by the current property owners, to be recorded upon effective certification of the LCP amendment. If the conditions for recordation of the Declaration of Covenants are met, the obligation for payment of the $800,000 in-lieu fee runs with the land and is binding on any future owners, so that the mitigation will be secured whenever a hotel project eventually proceeds, even if the specific project covered by the City’s existing CDP does not ultimately come to fruition and the escrow funds are returned. This provision thus provides extra assurances that the lack of provision for lower cost overnight accommodations with a new luxury hotel development will be mitigated even if the current property owners decide not to pursue the hotel project. As such, the agreement is structured to provide the Commission with assurance of payment of the fee, which is necessary to provide a component of lower cost overnight visitor accommodations through an up-to-date in-lieu mitigation fee. Using an escrow arrangement assures the property owners that the required fee will only be transferred upon securing final entitlements for the planned development beyond legal challenge.

The Commission is requiring Suggested Modification Three (3) to note the agreement between the Coastal Commission and the property owners regarding payment of the fee is in addition to the existing LCP requirements regarding the development of luxury overnight accommodations. The purpose of the fee would be to fund new lower cost overnight visitor accommodations elsewhere in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone.

In addition to the in-lieu fee proposed to provide a component of lower cost overnight 4154
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
28 accommodations, the property owners have also committed to and entered into a contract to provide $250,000 to a nonprofit organization called “Los Courage Camps” to further its work providing free surf lessons and transportation to beaches in the Malibu area for children in underserved communities in the general Los Angeles area. The organization’s website states that: “Los Courage Camps’ mission is to teach the diverse children of Los Angeles who have never experienced the ocean how to surf and consequently connect them with their courage, potential, inner strength, and leadership”. The property owners state that the proposed funding will provide for a large bus and driver, lunches, towels, wetsuits, surfboards, surfing instructors, and a grant writer (to seek additional grant funding). While the provision of this proposed funding does not directly provide lower cost overnight accommodations, it will increase equitable public access and recreation opportunities, furthering the goals of the Coastal Act and LCP with regard to access and environmental justice.

Sea View Hotel Overlay District
The LIP portion of the City’s amendment request proposes to create a new overlay district (Sea View Hotel Overlay District), which will apply use restrictions and development standards over the subject site. The proposed Sea View Hotel project involves the construction of a new four-story, 26,734 square foot, 39-room luxury hotel involving the remodel of an existing four-story, non-conforming commercial building (non-conforming in regards to the building height and square footage/floor area ratio), and construction of a new two-story, 11,342 square foot addition with a basement. The new Sea View Hotel overlay district has been tailored to accommodate the proposed Sea View Hotel development project. One of the proposed Sea View Hotel overlay development standards is a reduction in the required parking for hotel development at the subject site (1.5 parking spaces per hotel room instead of 2 spaces per hotel room). LUP Policy 2.25 requires that new development provide sufficient off-street parking to serve the approved use in order to minimize impacts to public street parking available for coastal access and recreation.

Reductions in parking standards have the potential to affect public access. In this case, although the proposed overlay standard includes a reduction in the required parking for hotel development, this reduction will only apply within this overlay district, and the City determined that the reduced parking standard provides sufficient off-street parking to serve the proposed hotel development and would not result in any adverse impacts to public street parking available for coastal access and recreation consistent with LUP Policy 2.25.

Conclusion
For the reasons stated above, the Commission finds that the proposed LUP amendment to change the land use designation of the subject property from Community Commercial (CC) to Commercial Visitor Serving Two (CV-2), as submitted, will give priority to visitor serving commercial recreation uses and is therefore consistent with the Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act.

As discussed in detail above, the City’s certified Land Use Plan (LUP) goal is to preserve coastal access, including the provision of lower cost overnight accommodations within the City’s Coastal Zone. If modified as suggested, the LIP amendment to rezone the subject 4255
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
29 property and add a zoning overlay will give priority to visitor serving commercial recreation uses and ensure that a component of lower cost overnight accommodations will be provided. For the reasons stated above, the Commission finds that, if modified as suggested, the LIP amendment conforms with and will be adequate to carry out the applicable policies of the certified Land Use Plan.

C. New Development and LCP Administration
The following Local Implementation Plan (LIP) sections are specifically applicable in this case:

LIP Section 3.8(A)(5) (Site Development Criteria), in relevant part, states:
(a) The gross square footage of all buildings on a given parcel shall be limited to a maximum Floor Area Ratio (F.A.R) of 0.15, or 15% of the lot area (excluding any street rights of way). Additional gross square footage may be approved, up to the maximum allowed for the parcel under the Land Use Plan provided the increase complies with the provisions of Section e and/or f below, where applicable. …
(f) Additional Square Footage. The City Council shall have the authority to approve additional square footage for commercial development, except with the Civic Center area, as provided in Section 3.8(A)(5) of the Malibu LIP, where the applicant has offered to the City public benefits and amenities in connection with a project subject to a Development Agreement processed pursuant to Section

13.28 of the Malibu LIP.
…
Sea View Hotel Overlay District
The LIP portion of the City’s amendment request proposes to change the zoning designation of the site from CC to CV-2, and to create a new overlay district (Sea View Hotel Overlay District) to accommodate the construction of a new 39-room hotel with associated amenities on the subject site (22729 PCH and 22741 PCH).

The associated Sea View Hotel project involves the construction of a new four-story, 26,734 square foot, 39-room luxury hotel involving the remodel of an existing four-story, non-conforming commercial building (non-conforming in regards to the building height and square footage/floor area ratio), and construction of a new two-story, 11,342 square foot addition with a basement. Additionally, the proposed hotel development proposes an allowable floor area ratio greater than currently allowed under the commercial development standards of the City’s LCP. Therefore, the City determined that a new overlay district with specific development standards (maximum density, including floor area ratios for commercial use, heights, lot coverage, open space requirements, setbacks, and parking and sign requirements) is needed to accommodate some of the as-built existing development, as well as modifying some of the development standards related to parking, parking locations, and an increase in the maximum allowable floor area ratio. 4356
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
30 The new Sea View Hotel overlay district has been tailored to accommodate the proposed Sea View Hotel development project. Permitted uses and development standards have been customized for the overlay area, including heights, lot coverage, setbacks, signage requirements, and landscape/open space requirements. The permitted uses allowed under the proposed overlay district include all uses permitted in the Commercial Visitor Serving-2 land use/zoning designation (which includes uses allowed in other commercial land use designations (Commercial Neighborhood, Community Commercial, and Commercial General)), and uses typically associated with hotel development (such as restaurants, spas, guest rooms, gym, etc.). The intent of allowing the permitted and conditionally permitted uses of the CV-2 land use designation is to accommodate a situation in which the proposed hotel development project is never constructed, and the existing office and commercial development onsite (currently permitted under the Community Commercial designation) can remain conforming and permitted under the overlay district.

However, the proposed amendment would allow non-hotel related uses permitted under the CV-2 land use designation to be developed on the subject property using the development standards under the proposed overlay district instead of the existing commercial development standards that would normally apply. For example, a new restaurant or medical office could be constructed on the subject site using the modified setbacks or modified building height standards of the overlay district that are tailored for a hotel development, and this could result in potential adverse individual and cumulative impacts on coastal resources. Therefore, Suggested Modification Five (5) adds clarifying language that the proposed “permitted, conditionally permitted uses that are a component of the hotel development are subject to the custom development standards of the overlay district, and that permitted or conditionally permitted uses that are not a component of the hotel development are subject to all applicable policies and provisions of the certified LCP, including the Commercial Development Standards in LIP Section 3.8.” This will ensure that all other permitted and conditionally permitted uses that are not associated with hotel development cannot be developed with the modified hotel-specific development standards under the overlay district and, therefore, will ensure that new development will not have significant adverse effects, either individually or cumulatively, on coastal resources.

As previously discussed, the City has already approved the coastal development permit for the proposed hotel, which is conditioned to not be effective until certification of the subject LCP amendment. Therefore, Commission staff has had the opportunity to analyze the specifics of the approved development in relation to the development standards proposed in the LCP amendment. Although the individual coastal development permit that the City approved is not a part of this LCP amendment, the Commission must analyze whether the specific development standards proposed in the LIP for the overlay district are adequate to ensure the development is consistent with the policies and provisions of the LUP related to the protection of coastal resources.

As discussed previously, the Commission finds that the proposed intensity of visitor serving commercial development on the property is consistent with the area's character and with the adjacent development and land uses. LIP Section 3.8(A)(5) limits the allowable square footage for commercial development to the maximum Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of 0.15 of the lot area. As part of the proposed development standards for the hotel development, and 4457
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
31 discussed in greater detail below, the City has proposed a larger FAR for the subject site than would otherwise be allowed by strict application of Section 3.8(A)(5) of the LIP. The allowable 0.15 FAR for the two parcels (22741 and 22729 PCH) is 7,750.05 square feet.

The existing commercial building at 22741 PCH is legally non-conforming with a FAR of

0.46 (15,392 square feet). The FAR standard proposed in the subject LCP amendment request would increase the allowed FAR to a maximum of 0.52 (26,866.84 square feet).

Since the approved development would also need to comply with all other resource protection provisions of the LCP, such as scenic resources and setbacks, the proposed deviations from the existing standard of the LCP would not result in any adverse impacts to coastal resources.

Since many of the proposed development standards for visitor serving commercial development reflect the requirements that are currently contained in the LCP but do not reflect all of them, it is important to provide clarification regarding the applicability of standards in order to ensure internal consistency and adequacy in carrying out the policies of the Land Use Plan. Therefore, Suggested Modification Four (4) to proposed LIP Section 3.4.6 (E) (Development Standards)) is required to clarify which LCP standard a proposed visitor-serving commercial development standard is intended to replace or supplement, as applicable. All other applicable standards in the certified LCP would apply, such as those related to hazards and geologic stability, public access, land divisions, water quality, and scenic resources.

Development Agreement and Public Benefits
Pursuant to the certified Malibu LCP, increasing the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) beyond what is allowed under the LCP, as in this case, triggers the need for a development agreement to be approved through an LCP amendment certified by the Coastal Commission (LIP Section

3.8(A)(5)). Therefore, the LIP amendment also includes the approval of a Development Agreement between the City and the property owners to allow an increase in allowable floor area ratio (FAR) from 0.15 to 0.52 in conjunction with a payment to the City. As previously mentioned, a maximum floor area ratio (FAR) of 0.15 is permitted under the certified LCP, except that the project FAR may be increased if public benefits and amenities are provided. The project site is included as part of a proposed development subject to a Development Agreement approved under an LCP amendment certified by the Coastal Commission.

California Government Code Sections 65864-65869.5 authorizes any city, county, or city and county, to enter into a development agreement with any person having a legal or equitable interest in real property for the development of property owned by that entity. A development agreement specifies the permitted uses of the property, the density or intensity of use, the maximum height and size of proposed buildings, and provisions for reservation or dedication of land for public purposes. According to Government Code Section 65865.2, the development agreement “…may include conditions, terms, restrictions, and requirements for subsequent discretionary actions, provided that such conditions, terms, restrictions, and requirements for subsequent discretionary actions shall not prevent the development of the land for the uses and to density or intensity of development set forth in the agreement. The agreement may provide that construction shall 4558
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
32 be commenced within a specified time and that the project or any phase thereof be completed within a specified time. The agreement may also include terms and conditions relating to applicant financing of necessary public facilities and subsequent reimbursement over time.” Government Code Section 65866 states further that, “[u]nless otherwise provided by the development agreement, rules, regulations, and official policies governing permitted uses of the land, governing density, and governing design, improvement, and construction standards and specifications, applicable to the development of the property subject to a development agreement, shall be those rules, regulations, and official policies in force at the time of execution of the agreement. A development agreement shall not prevent a city, county, or city and county, in subsequent actions applicable to the property, from applying new rules, regulations, and policies which do not conflict with those rules, regulations, and policies applicable to the property as set forth herein, nor shall a development agreement prevent a city, county, or city and county from denying or conditionally approving any subsequent development project application on the basis of such existing or new rules, regulations, and policies.” However, pursuant to Section 65869, “…[a] development agreement shall not be applicable to any development project located in an area for which a local coastal program is required to be prepared and certified pursuant to the requirements of Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code, unless: (1) the required local coastal program has been certified as required by such provisions prior to the date on which the development agreement is entered into, or (2) in the event that the required local coastal program has not been certified, the California Coastal Commission approves such development agreement by formal commission action.” Since the City of Malibu has a certified local coastal program, the approval of a development agreement does not require the approval of a coastal development permit by the Commission. Rather, as required by Malibu LIP Section 13.28, development agreements are processed as amendments to the LCP. In this case, the subject LCP amendment request includes the approval of the Sea View Hotel Development Agreement.

The Development Agreement between the City and the property owners sets forth the terms of the agreement regarding the eventual development of the subject site, including allowable uses, development standards, and maximum allowable floor area ratio (FAR).

The development agreement also details the applicant’s ability to develop a new hotel with an increased allowable floor area ratio from 0.15 to 0.52 in conjunction with a payment of $800,000 to the City to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use.

Although the City has formalized a 0.52 FAR with a payment of $800,000 to the City through a Development Agreement with the property owners for the subject site, the City has also chosen to effectuate the 0.52 FAR in the required LCP amendment by incorporating the 0.52 FAR as a development standard under the new overlay district. The Development Agreement approved by the City is not incorporated into the proposed LCP amendment language in full. Instead, the proposed new overlay district designation reflects the allowable uses, density, and development standards agreed upon in the Development Agreement.
4659
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
33 The proposed overlay district density standard (proposed LIP Section 3.4.5(D)) only requires that pursuant to a Development Agreement between the property owners and the City of Malibu, the allowable FAR is increased from 0.15 to 0.52 if the applicant contributes $800,000 to be expended as the City Council determines to be an appropriate use. Yet, the proposed language does not specifically require the contribution to be used for public benefits or amenities, as required by LIP Section 3.8(A)(5) (Site Development Criteria). In order to ensure that the public benefits associated with the increased FAR for the subject site are incorporated into the LCP, Suggested Modification Two (2) adds clarifying language to proposed LIP Section 3.4.5(D) to require the applicant to contribute $800,000 to the City to be used for public benefits and amenities.

LCP Administration
Several proposed revisions relate to the administration of the LCP. Suggested Modifications One (1), Four (4), Six (6), and Seven (7) include minor modifications to the proposed overlay district amendment language necessary to ensure consistency with the LCP, such as correcting typos, adding the corresponding addresses and assessor parcel numbers (22729 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-010 and 22741 Pacific Coast Highway/APN 4452-022-017) to the proposed LIP Section 3.4.6 Sea View Hotel Overlay District text and Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map, and making minor clarifications that further the intent and implementation of the LCP and that avoid ambiguity.

In conclusion, the proposed Sea View Hotel Overlay District and associated development standards in the proposed LIP amendment, as suggested to be modified herein, will accommodate a hotel use, and will do so in a manner that protects coastal resources, ensures internal LCP consistency, and is consistent with the LUP policies. Thus, the Commission finds that only as modified will the proposed LIP amendment conform with and be adequate to carry out the policies of the certified Land Use Plan.

D. California Environmental Quality Act
Section 21080.9 of the California Public Resources Code—within the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA)—exempts local governments from the requirement of preparing an environmental impact report (EIR) in connection with its activities and approvals necessary for the preparation and adoption of a local coastal program.

Instead, the CEQA responsibilities are assigned to the Coastal Commission; however, the Commission's LCP review and approval program has been found by the Resources Agency to be functionally equivalent to the EIR process. Thus, under CEQA Section 21080.5, the Commission is not obligated to prepare an EIR for each LCP action.

Nevertheless, the Commission is required, in approving an LCP submittal, to find that the approval of the proposed LCP, as amended, does conform with CEQA provisions, including the requirement in CEQA section 21080.5(d)(2)(A) that the amended LCP will not be approved or adopted as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures available which would substantially lessen any significant adverse impact which the activity may have on the environment. 14 C.C.R. §§ 13540(f) and 13555(b). 4760
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
34 The City’s LCP amendment consists of a Land Use Plan amendment and Local Implementation Plan amendment.

The Land Use Plan amendment has been found to be in conformance with Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act. As discussed above, the Local Implementation Plan amendment is not in conformance with and is not adequate to carry out the Land Use Plan as amended. With the incorporation of the suggested modifications, the Local Implementation Plan amendment is in conformity with the Land Use Plan as amended. The suggested modifications minimize or mitigate any potentially significant environmental impacts of the LCP amendment. If modified as suggested, the Commission finds that approval of the LCP amendment will not result in significant adverse environmental impacts within the meaning of the California Environmental Quality Act.

The Commission finds that for the reasons discussed in this report if the LCP amendment is modified as suggested, there are no additional feasible alternatives, feasible alternatives, or feasible mitigation measures available that could substantially reduce any adverse environmental impacts. The Commission further finds that the proposed LCP amendment, if modified as suggested, is consistent with Section 21080.5(d)(2)(A) of the Public Resources Code.
4861
STATE OF CALIFORNIA—NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT 89 SOUTH CALIFORNIA ST., SUITE 200
VENTURA, CA 93001
(805) 585-1800
W11a
City of Malibu LCP Amendment
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
February 8, 2023
Exhibits
Table of Contents
Exhibit 1 – Proposed LIP Amendment Text Changes in Strikethrough/Underline Exhibit 2 – Proposed Land Use and Zoning Map Change
Exhibit 3 – Proposed Sea View Hotel Overlay District Map Exhibit 4 – Proposed Development Agreement
Exhibit 5 – Vicinity Map
Exhibit 6 – Aerial View of the Subject Parcels
Exhibit 7 – Parcel Map
Exhibit 8 – Overall Site Plan for Sea View Hotel Project 4962

STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION

SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT OFFICE
89 SOUTH CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 200
VENTURA, CA 93001-2801
VOICE (805) 585-1800
FAX (805) 641-1732
W11a
LCP-4-MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project)
February 8, 2023

APPENDIX
5063
2 APPENDIX 1 - Substantive File Documents
Certified City of Malibu Local Coastal Plan;
Malibu Planning Commission Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, Development Agreement No. 21-001, Lot Merger No. 20-002, Demolition Permit No. 20-19, Initial Study No. 21-001, and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, dated June 24, 2021; Malibu City Council Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, Development Agreement No. 21-001, Lot Merger No. 20-002, Demolition Permit No. 20-19, Initial Study No. 21-001, and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, dated July 29, 2021; Malibu City Council Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, Development Agreement No. 21-001, Lot Merger No. 20-002, Demolition Permit No. 20-19, Initial Study No. 21-001, and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, dated July 29, 2021; Malibu City Council Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, Development Agreement No. 21-001, Lot Merger No. 20-002, Demolition Permit No. 20-19, Initial Study No. 21-001, and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, dated August 11, 2021; Malibu City Council Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Coastal Development Permit No. 17-086, Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, Development Agreement No. 21-001, Lot Merger No. 20-002, Demolition Permit No. 20-19, Initial Study No. 21-001, and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001, dated August 25, 2021; Malibu City Council Agenda Report and Associated Documents for Ordinance No. 491 for Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 16-006, Zoning Map Amendment No. 17-002, Zoning Text Amendment No. 20-001, and Development Agreement No. 21-001, dated September 15, 2021;
City of Malibu Resolution No. 21-45;
City of Malibu Resolution No. 21-46;
City of Malibu Ordinance No. 491;
Initial Study No. 21-001 and Mitigated Negative Declaration No. 21-001 (IS/MND); 5164
3 “Explore the Coast Overnight: An Assessment of Lower-Cost Coastal Accommodations” by the California Coastal Conservancy (March 2019);
California Coastal Commission Public Workshop Staff Report on Lower-Cost VisitorServing Accommodations (October 2016); Coastal Development Permit No. 5-18-0872 (Sunshine Enterprises, LP); Coastal Development Permit No. 5-20-0181 (B&J Capital Group Investments); Coastal Development Permit No. A-5-VEN-21-0011 (Wynkoop Properties, LLC); Coastal Development Permit No. 5-18-0872 (Shore Hotel)
5265

STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION

CORRESPONDENCE
5366

STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOM, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION

SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT OFFICE
89 S. CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 200
VENTURA, CA 93001
(805) 585-1800
W11a

ADDENDUM
February 7, 2023
TO: Coastal Commissioners and Interested Parties
FROM: South Central Coast District Staff
SUBJECT: Addendum to Item W11a, City of Malibu LCP Amendment No. LCP-4- MAL-21-0073-2 (Sea View Hotel Project) For the Commission Meeting of Wednesday, February 8, 2023
The purpose of this addendum is to: 1) add a link to Appendix A, Substantive File Documents; and 2) attach correspondence received to date and provide a response to certain correspondence. The correspondence letters are available in the Correspondence tab for this item on the Commission’s website.

I. APPENDIX A – SUBSTANTIVE FILE DOCUMENTS

On page 5, after the Table of Contents, add Appendix A (Substantive File Documents) with link as follows:
https://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2023/2/W11a/W11a-2-2023-appendix.pdf II. CORRESPONDENCE RECEIVED, STAFF’S RESPONSE TO

CORRESPONDENCE
a. On January 27, 2023, after the publication of the January 26, 2023 staff report, staff received comments from the City’s planning department regarding Suggested Modification No. 3. The City’s staff comment stated, “Our only comment based on your last correspondence was is if is possible to condition the money collected as an in-lieu fee for affordable overnight accommodations to not be used to fund camping in high fire severity zones or in ESHA areas.” Specifically, the City staff requested that Commission staff condition the lower cost overnight visitor accommodations in-lieu mitigation fee of $800,000 (which is being implemented through an escrow agreement between Commission staff and the property owners) not to fund camping located within high fire severity zones or Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Areas (ESHA).
5467
2 Generally, the Santa Monica Mountains are considered to be a high fire hazard severity zone. The entire City of Malibu is within territory designated by the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (“CAL FIRE”) as a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone (VHFHSZ). Therefore, requiring any new camping (a form of lower-cost overnight visitor accommodations) to be sited outside high fire severity zones would effectively preclude any new camping from being located within the City or adjacent unincorporated Santa Monica Mountains. This restriction would directly conflict with the lower cost overnight visitor accommodations in-lieu mitigation fee and policies and goals of the Malibu Local Coastal Program (LCP), which is to assist in funding affordable overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone.

In addition, any new camping within the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone will trigger the need for a coastal development permit. At that time, the respective permitting authority (City of Malibu or Los Angeles County) must review a proposed camping project in a manner that is consistent with the policies and provisions of their respective Local Coastal Programs (City of Malibu LCP or Santa Monica Mountains LCP). Both the City of Malibu LCP and Santa Monica Mountains LCP require new development to minimize risks to life and property in fire hazard areas and also require the protection of areas designated as ESHA and require new development in areas adjacent to ESHA to be sited and designed to prevent impacts which would significantly degrade those areas.

For these reasons, the Commission staff disagrees with the City’s requested modification to condition the in-lieu mitigation fee for affordable overnight accommodations not to fund camping located within high fire severity zones or Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Areas (ESHA).
b. Correspondence dated February 3, 2023, was submitted by Marshall A. Camp, of Hueston Hennigan LLP, on behalf of Mani Brothers Real Estate Group, Mani MBI (DE), LLC, and affiliated companies (collectively, the “Mani Brothers”), that own properties in the vicinity of the proposed Sea View Hotel, including the Malibu Beach Inn at 22878 Pacific Coast Highway (PCH), the former Hertz lot at 22853 PCH, and the multifamily properties at 22640 and 22648 PCH, which are located approximately 500 feet from the proposed Sea View Hotel. This letter is available under the correspondence tab. This letter urges the Commission to deny the LCP amendment due to alleged inconsistencies with the Coastal Act and the Malibu LCP and because of alleged non-compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”).

Specifically, the letter expresses opposition to the proposed LCP amendment raising concerns that the proposed increase in maximum Floor to Area ratio under the proposed overlay district is inconsistent with the City’s LCP and claims the amendment results in “spot zoning.” In response, Commission staff notes that these issues are addressed in Sections V (Findings for Approval of the LUP Amendment as Submitted, Denial of the LIP Amendment as Submitted, and Approval of the LIP Amendment if Modified as Suggested) of the January 26, 2023, staff report. 5568
3 In addition, the letter claims that the January 26, 2023 staff report fails to demonstrate CEQA compliance. However, as discussed in the January 26, 2023 staff report, the City completed its CEQA review prior to submitting the subject LCP amendment to the Commission for review. Before adopting the Mitigated Negative Determination (MND) for the Sea View Hotel Project, the City Council considered the MND and all the comments received during the public review process. Based on the record, including the initial study and the comments received, which were included as part of the City’s LCP Amendment submittal and can be found under Appendix A – Substantive File Documents for the January 26, 2023 staff report, the City Council determined that there would be no significant environmental impacts with the implementation of specific mitigation measures. The City Council also determined that the project does not have the potential to cause significant adverse impacts to the environment.

The commenter claims that the staff report’s statements regarding CEQA in Section D of that report are “conclusory” and that the Commission has failed to comply with CEQA. This is incorrect. The entire staff report constitutes the Commission’s CEQAequivalent document under its certified regulatory program. The Commission, as with certain other state agencies, has a certified regulatory program under CEQA.

Public Res. Code § 21085.5; 14 Cal. Code Regs. § 15252. Documents prepared by certified programs, such as the Commission’s staff reports, are considered the functional equivalent of documents that CEQA would otherwise require.1 As part of its certified program, the Commission reviews a proposal to determine if there are feasible mitigation measures, or feasible alternatives, that would substantially lessen any significant adverse effect on the proposed development.

The Commission’s review of the proposed LCP amendment built off of the City’s record, including the Initial Study and MND, which the City submitted to the Commission. Moreover, the Commission may rely on environmental documents prepared by the City that are part of the City’s LCP submission.2 In this case, the City prepared an extensive record, provided for public notice and comment, and determined that there would be no significant environmental impacts with the implementation of specific mitigation measures. The City also evaluated alternatives to the project and additional mitigation measures. Commission staff has reviewed the City’s record as part of the Commission’s review of the City’s LCP amendment submittal.

As noted in the staff report, Commission staff is suggesting several modifications to the City’s proposed LCP Amendment, including an in lieu mitigation fee for low-cost overnight accommodations. To the extent that potential impacts to public access and recreation may be considered environmental impacts under CEQA, the Commission is specifying a feasible mitigation measure and an alternative mechanism to provide a component of lower cost overnight accommodations.

Specifically, the Commission’s suggested modification would reflect the agreement by the property owners to provide a $800,000 in lieu fee for the development of lowcost overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal 1 Mountain Lion Found. v. Fish & Game Com., 16 Cal. 4th 105, 113 (1997). 2 See Ross v. Coastal Com., 199 Cal. App. 4th 900 (2011). 5669
4 zone. The Commission has met its CEQA obligations under its certified regulatory program.

Finally, the commenter argues that the Commission is required to consider the “environmental impacts of the campground project in Ramirez Canyon” under CEQA. This is also incorrect. As an initial matter, no specific project for the in lieu fee is called out in the Commission’s suggested modification, and it remains uncertain if the mitigation fee will go towards a campground project in Ramirez Canyon or to some other project. Likewise, although the commenter claims that this project will usher in other citywide growth through other City-approved projects, this is speculative and does not require CEQA analysis in the context of this proposed LCP amendment.

In addition, as part of its review of this proposed LCP Amendment for the Sea View Hotel overlay district, the Commission is not required to evaluate the impacts of a future project when that project would have a different proponent, would serve a different purposes, or can be implemented independently,3 as would be the case with any low-cost, visitor-serving development funded by the in lieu fee (or with any unrelated project). Thus, the Commission’s review of the proposed LCP amendment complies with CEQA.
c. Correspondence has been received from Norman R. Haynie on behalf of the Sea View Hotel Project Site property owners on January 31, 2023. The correspondence supports the staff recommendation for the subject LCP amendment and includes a project rendering for the related Sea View Hotel Project. This letter is available under the correspondence tab.
d. Correspondence has been received from the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA) on February 6, 2023. The correspondence supports the staff’s recommendation of an in-lieu mitigation fee of $800,000 to assist in funding affordable overnight accommodations in the Malibu/Santa Monica Mountains coastal zone. This letter is available under the correspondence tab. 3 Aptos Council v. City of Santa Cruz, 10 Cal. App. 5th 266, 280 (2017). 5770

Malibu City CouncilJune 26, 2023

Malibu City Council
June 26, 2023