CITY COUNCIL
Anthony Tave, Mayor
Devin T. Murphy, Mayor Pro Tem
Maureen Toms, Council Member
Cameron Sasai, Council Member
Norma Martínez-Rubin, Council Member
PINOLE CITY COUNCIL
MEETING AGENDA
November 3, 2026
5:30 PM
Attend in Person: PINOLE CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 2131 PEAR STREET OR
Attend VIA ZOOM TELECONFERENCE – Details provided below How to Submit Public Comments:
In Person:
Attend meeting at the Pinole City Council Chambers, fill out a yellow public comment card and submit it to the City Clerk.
Via Zoom:
Members of the public may submit a live remote public comment via Zoom video conferencing. Download the Zoom mobile app from the Apple Appstore or Google Play. If you are using a desktop computer, you can test your connection to Zoom by clicking here. Zoom also allows you to join the meeting by phone.
From a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone or Android:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89335000272
Webinar ID: 893 3500 0272
By phone: +1 (669) 900-6833 or +1 (253) 215-8782 or +1 (346) 248-7799 • Speakers will be asked to provide their name and city of residence, although providing this is not required for participation.
• Each speaker will be afforded up to 3 minutes to speak (subject to modification by the Mayor) • Speakers will be muted until their opportunity to provide public comment.
When the Mayor opens the comment period for the item you wish to speak on, please use the “raise hand” feature (or press *9 if connecting via telephone) which will alert staff that you have a comment to provide and press *6 to unmute. To comment with your video enabled, please let the City Clerk know you would like to turn your camera on once you are called to speak.
Written Comments:
All comments received before 3:00 pm the day of the meeting will be posted on the City’s website on the agenda page (Agenda Page Link) and provided to the City Council prior to the meeting. Written comments will not be read aloud during the meeting. Email comments to [email protected] Please indicate which item on the agenda you are commenting on in the subject line of your email.
City Council
Agenda - November 3, 2026
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH THE MEETING
LIVE ON CHANNEL 30 AND CHANNEL 1070. Meetings are broadcast again the following week on channels 30 and 1070 (previously channel 26). The Pinole Community TV program schedule is published on the City’s website at www.Pinole.gov/PCTV.
VIDEO-STREAMED LIVE ON THE CITY’S WEBSITE, www.Pinole.gov/PCTV. Meeting videos remain archived on the site for five (5) years. Pinole Community TV can also be streamed live from Roku, Apple TV, or Amazon Fire.
TEMPORARY NOTICE: Some Comcast subscribers may also be able to see PCTV Government Media programming on Channel 30 while we work through an FCC must-carry requirement.
If none of these options are available to you, or you need assistance with public comment, please contact the City Clerk, Heather Bell-Spears at (510) 724-8928 or [email protected].
Americans With Disabilities Act: In compliance with the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, if you need special assistance to participate in a City Meeting or you need a copy of the agenda, or the agenda packet in an appropriate alternative format, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at (510) 724-8928. Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting or time when services are needed will assist the City staff in assuring that reasonable arrangements can be made to provide accessibility to the meeting or service.
Note: Staff reports are available for inspection on the City Website at www.pinole.gov. You may also contact the City Clerk via e-mail at [email protected].
Ralph M. Brown Act. Gov. Code § 54950. In enacting this chapter, the Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and the other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people's business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies, which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.
City Council
Agenda - November 3, 2026
1. CALL TO ORDER & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE IN HONOR OF THE US MILITARY TROOPS
2. LAND ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Before we begin, we would like to acknowledge the Ohlone people, who are the traditional custodians of this land. We pay our respects to the Ohlone elders, past, present, and future, who call this place, Ohlone Land, the land that Pinole sits upon, their home. We are proud to continue their tradition of coming together and growing as a community. We thank the Ohlone community for their stewardship and support, and we look forward to strengthening our ties as we continue our relationship of mutual respect and understanding.
3. ROLL CALL, CITY CLERK’S REPORT & STATEMENT OF CONFLICT An official who has a conflict must, prior to consideration of the decision: (1) publicly identify in detail the financial interest that causes the conflict; (2) recuse himself /herself from discussing and voting on the matter; and (3) leave the room until after the decision has been made, Cal. Gov't Code § 87105.
4. CONVENE TO A CLOSED SESSION
Citizens may address the Council regarding a Closed Session item prior to the Council adjourning into the Closed Session, by first providing a speaker card to the City Clerk.
A. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL—ANTICIPATED LITIGATION Gov. Code § 54956.9(d)(2) or (d)(3)
Number of Potential Cases: 1
B. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS
Gov. Code § 54957.6
Agency designated representatives: City Manager, Naomi Kelly and Human Resources Director, Stacy Shell
Employee organization: AFSCME local 512
5. RECONVENE IN OPEN SESSION TO ANNOUNCE RESULTS OF CLOSED SESSION
6. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (Public Comments)
Citizens may speak under any item not listed on the Agenda. The time limit is 3 minutes and is subject to modification by the Mayor. Individuals may not share or offer time to another speaker. Pursuant to provisions of the Brown Act, no action may be taken on a matter unless it is listed on the agenda, or unless certain emergency or special circumstances exist. The City Council may direct staff to investigate and/or schedule certain matters for consideration at a future Council meeting. PLEASE SEE THE COVERSHEET OF THE
AGENDA FOR INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENTS
7. REPORTS & COMMUNICATIONS
A. Mayor Report
1. Announcements
B. Mayoral & Council Appointments
C. City Council Committee Reports & Communications
D. Council Requests for Future Agenda Items
City Council
Agenda - November 3, 2026
E. City Manager Report / Department Staff
F. City Attorney Report
8. RECOGNITIONS / PRESENTATIONS / COMMUNITY EVENTS
A. Proclamations
1. World Town Planning Day
2. National Native American Heritage Month
3. Sikh American Awareness and Appreciation Month
B. Presentations
1. Republic Services Update
2. Community Services Events Update by Maria Picazo
3. Public Works Updates by Matt Brown
9. CONSENT CALENDAR
All matters under the Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and noncontroversial. These items will be enacted by one motion and without discussion. If, however, any interested party or Council member(s) wishes to comment on an item, they may do so before action is taken on the Consent Calendar. Following comments, if a Council member wishes to discuss an item, it will be removed from the Consent Calendar and taken up in order after adoption of the Consent Calendar.
A. Approve the Minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting on October 20, 2026.
B. Receive the October 17, 2026 – October 30, 2026, List of Warrants in the Amount of $2,027,786.16 and the October 23, 2026 Payroll in the Amount of $584,088.30.
C. Approve the City of Pinole Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Fiona Epps, Andrew Haber)
D. Adoption of a Resolution Upholding the Appeal and Granting an 18-Month Extension of Entitlements (CUP 23-05 & DR 23-12) for Pinole Shores II – 836–848 San Pablo Avenue Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen)
10. PUBLIC HEARINGS
Citizens wishing to speak regarding a Public Hearing item should fill out a speaker card prior to the completion of the presentation, by first providing a speaker card to the City Clerk. An official who engaged in an ex parte communication that is the subject of a Public Hearing must disclose the communication on the record prior to the start of the Public Hearing.
A. Public Hearing and Approval of Energy Services Contract for Installation of LED Lighting Upgrades at City Hall (2131 Pear St./APN: 401163004) and Pinole Public Safety Building (880 Tennent Ave/APN: 401164003), and Authorization for City Manager to Execute Agreement Action: Conduct a Public Hearing and Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
City Council
Agenda - November 3, 2026
B. Public Hearing and PG&E On-Bill Financing Approval for LED Lighting Retrofit at Pinole City Hall (2131 Pear St./APN: 401163004) and Pinole Public Safety Building (880 Tennent Ave/APN: 401164003), and Authorization for City Manager to Execute Documentation Action:
Conduct a Public Hearing and Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
C. Public Hearing and Approval of a Single-Source Energy Services Contract with Providence Water Heaters to Replace Aging Gas Water Heaters with Heat Pump Water Heaters at the Pinole Senior Center (2500 Charles Ave/APN: 401182012) and Pinole Swim Center (2450 Simas Ave/ APN: 360332023) (Gov. Code §4217) Action: Conduct a Public Hearing and Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
11. OLD BUSINESS
A. None
12. NEW BUSINESS
A. None
13. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (Continued from Item 6) (Public Comments) Open only to members of the public who did not speak under the first Citizens to Be Heard, Agenda Item 6 Citizens may speak under any item not listed on the Agenda. The time limit is 3 minutes for City Council items and is subject to modification by the Mayor. Individuals may not share or offer time to another speaker.
Pursuant to provisions of the Brown Act, no action may be taken on a matter unless it is listed on the agenda, or unless certain emergency or special circumstances exist. The City Council may direct staff to investigate and/or schedule certain matters for consideration at a future meeting.
14. ADJOURNMENT to the Regular City Council Meeting of November 17, 2026 in Remembrance of Amber Swartz.
I hereby certify under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing Agenda was posted on the bulletin board at the main entrance of Pinole City Hall, 2131 Pear Street Pinole, CA, and on the City’s website, not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting date set forth on this agenda. _______________________
Heather Bell-Spears, CMC
City Clerk
POSTED: Thursday, October 29, 2026 at 4:30 pm
Republic Services,
City of Pinole Council Meeting
Presented by the Sustainability and Municipal Team
Lisa Martinez-Ronan, Sophia Damianakes, and
Arianna Aguilera
For more information and resources, visit us at
Republicservices.com/municipality/pinole-ca, email us
[email protected]
CA State Legislations
SB1383
SB54
Source Separating Waste
Recycling
Organics
Garbage
Household Hazardous Waste
Contamination Process
City of Pinole Programs and Events
Overview
SB 1383: Purpose, Goals and Partnership
• Landfilled food and organic waste emits methane,
contributing to hotter summers, more droughts and
more wildfires.
• California’s statewide effort to reduce methane by
keeping organics, food scraps and yard trimmings
out of landfills.
• Republic Services provides Pinole with organics
collection and processing.
50%
Reduction of organic waste disposal
in landfills by 2020
75%
Reduction of organic waste disposal
in landfills by 2025
20%
Rescue of currently wasted surplus
food by 2025
01 Universal Organics Collection Service
Organic collection for all residents and businesses with standardized container colors and labels.
02 Education and Outreach
30+ resources help residents and businesses sort correctly and meet SB 1383 diversion requirements.
03 Contamination Monitoring
Annual route reviews identify Pinole’s top contaminants; ongoing monitoring supports diversion and emissions targets.
04 Technical Assistance for Businesses & MFDs
Free assessments, training, presentations, service adjustments, compliance help and waiver guidance.
05 Reporting
Track participation, contamination, food recovery, procurement, compliance and costs.
SB 54: Overview and FAQ
Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act
THE PACKAGING PROBLEM
Over 50%
of California landfill material
is packaging
SIGNED INTO LAW
June 30, 2022
Governor Newsom signed
SB54 to address single-use
packaging
2032
Deadline for the packaging
requirements
PACKAGING DEADLINE
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Are there requirements for local governments?
In most cases, no — unless they are involved in producing customer education or providing services under the
agreements.
How will customers be impacted?
SB 54 aims to make recycling easier by requiring producers to make more packaging recyclable, reducing confusion
about what can be recycled.
Will public education need to be updated?
Republic Services outreach will be adjusted as needed to comply with the covered materials list and our current
Franchise Agreement.
Source Separating Waste
Organics Recycling Landfill
6 CONFIDENTIAL
RECYCLING & COMPOSTING JOURNEY
RECYCLING
1 Collecting
Materials are gathered from homes and
businesses and delivered to our
recycling center – WCRR: 101 Pittsburg
Ave, Richmond
2 Sorting
Materials are separated according to
material type
3 Processing
Recyclables are baled and ready for
transport to manufacturers
4 Manufacturing
New products are created from recycled
materials
COMPOSTING
1 Collecting
Materials are gathered from homes and
businesses and delivered to our
composting facility GBTS OMPF (1 Parr
Blvd)
2 Screening
Contaminants like plastics and trash are
removed
3 Composting
Food and yard waste become nutrient-rich soil amendment through the 60-90 day composting process
4 Distribution
Compost soil is sold to farms, donated
to schools and community gardens!
7 Household Hazardous Waste: Items & Drop-Off
Computers
Monitors
Batteries
Car batteries
Paint
Pesticides & herbicides
Solvents
Used cooking oil
Fluorescent lightbulbs
Aerosols
Pharmaceuticals
Sharps & needles
Electronics & Batteries Chemicals & Oils Other Household Items Drive-Through Drop Off for Pinole Residents
Household Hazardous Waste Facility (HHW)
101 Pittsburg Ave, Richmond
Wednesday–Saturday, 9 AM–4 PM
Closed 12–12:30 PM for lunch
Proof of residency required
1-888-412-9277
Camera Technology
Cameras are located in the hopper of the truck & a live video is taken of the customer’s container being dumped.
Examples of the most common contaminated materials are colored plastic bags, loose soft plastic packaging, etc.
A second camera takes a picture of the container to verify the correct customer for charging.
If no contamination is observed no data is stored or sent for review.
Pictures are provided to the customer by logging into their MyResource Account, or they can call customer service to review the images and request resources.
California’s SB 1383 requires jurisdictions and waste haulers to actively inspect and enforce contamination rules for recycling, trash, and organic carts. Camera technology ensures recyclables and organics can be properly & safely processed and maximizes material diverted from the landfill.
9 CONFIDENTIAL
City of Pinole Programs & Events - 2026
Pinole Pride & Juneteenth Celebration
Pinole Beautification Garden Project - Mulch
Pinole Classic Car Show
Pinole Dumpster Day
JUN
14 JUN
28 AUG
05 OCT
24 APR
18 OCT
07 Pinole Earth Day
Pinole National Night Out
10 CONFIDENTIAL
RepublicServices.Com/Municipality/Pinole-CA
Outreach Resources
Pinole Residential, Commercial & Multi-Family Service Guides Quarterly Newsletters
30+ Resources for Sorting Waste and
Accessing Programs
Rates and Facility Hours
Programs and Event Details
Service Updates
FAQs
11 CONFIDENTIAL
Request an additional recycling and/or
organics cart at no charge.
Additional carts
Request a clean replacement for each cart
once every 5 years, at no charge.
Cart exchange
Households where no occupant can
physically move carts to the curb may
request service at no additional cost.
Carry-out service
Account holders age 62 or older may
qualify for a discounted rate.
Senior discount
Natural trees collected curbside for
composting for 3 weeks starting
December 26, at no charge.
Holiday tree curbside pickup
Pinole Residential Service Programs
Food Scrap Pails
Food Scrap Pails are available at no cost
to Pinole residents for easy and
convenient source separation of organic
waste! Residents can pick up a pail at
Pinole City Hall
On-Call Collections
Two (2) on-call curbside cleanups per year
at no additional cost. Programs available
for residential customers and
apartments/condos.
12 CONFIDENTIAL
Full Program Details Available at:
RepublicServices.Com/Municipality/pinole-ca
Compost Giveaways & Bye Bye Mattress Program
Compost Giveaway
Every 1st Wednesday of the month
West County Resource Recovery
Facility (WCRR)
101 Pittsburg Ave. Richmond, CA
94801
9:00 a.m. – 4:00 p.m. (Closed
12:00 – 1:00 p.m.)
Valid Proof of Residency Required
Bye Bye Mattress Program
No-cost drop-off
Up to 3 mattresses, box springs or
futons per month for Pinole
residents
101 Pittsburg Ave., Richmond, CA
Wednesday–Saturday, 9 AM–4
PM; closed 12–12:30 PM for lunch
Valid proof of residency required
CITY OF PINOLE COMMUNITY SERVICES
Holiday Events
Update
11am-12pm | Fernandez Park
WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 11
Enjoy Pinole’s 2nd annual Veteran’s Day
Celebration with a Flag Retirement
Ceremony, veteran and community
speeches, featured performances, along
with veteran resources and information.
View event information at View event information at www.pinole.gov/events
Discover the perfect unique gift this holiday season at the Holiday Craft Fair! Shop art, jewelry, artisanal goods, and more items curated by local vendors.
HOLIDAY
CRAFT FAIR
10am-3pm | Senior Center
View event information at www.pinole.gov/events
Saturday, November 14
Special Thanks to our Sponsors
View event information at www.pinole.gov/events
Lino Amaral
Jeff Marks
David Recoder
Oliver’s
Towing
Celebrate this holiday season at Pinole’s Tree Lighting Event featuring children’s activities, cookie decorating, falling snow, delicious food trucks, a surprise visit from the Grinch, and the annual Tree Lighting Ceremony.
HOLIDAY
TREE LIGHTING
SATURDAY, DECEMBER 5
3 pm - 6 pm at Community Corner
Lighting Ceremony approximately at 5:30pm
Holiday Breakfast
Saturday, December 12
9am - 11am | Senior Center
Purchase breakfast tickets at www.pinolerec.com
Competition Categories (register for one category):
Best Holiday Theme Best Use of Lights Most Creative Display Tour Interactive Holiday Map and Vote at pinole.gov/glowpinole Community Voting Dates: December 14 - 28
Decorate your Pinole home this holiday season for Glow Pinole! Choose a competition category from the list below and register to be featured on our interactive holiday map, where the community can view, vote, and enjoy your display.
Register for Glow Pinole by December 13 at www.pinolerec.com
Register and Reserve for all
program offerings at
www.pinolerec.com
Thank you!
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
October 20, 2026
1. CALL TO ORDER & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE IN HONOR OF THE US MILITARY TROOPS
Mayor Tave called the meeting to order at 5:30 PM.
2. LAND ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Before we begin, we would like to acknowledge the Ohlone people, who are the traditional custodians of this land. We pay our respects to the Ohlone elders, past, present, and future, who call this place, Ohlone Land, the land that Pinole sits upon, their home. We are proud to continue their tradition of coming together and growing as a community. We thank the Ohlone community for their stewardship and support, and we look forward to strengthening our ties as we continue our relationship of mutual respect and understanding.
Mayor Tave read the Land Acknowledgment.
3. ROLL CALL, CITY CLERK’S REPORT & STATEMENT OF CONFLICT An official who has a conflict must, prior to consideration of the decision: (1) publicly identify in detail the financial interest that causes the conflict; (2) recuse himself /herself from discussing and voting on the matter; and (3) leave the room until after the decision has been made, Cal. Gov't Code § 87105.
Deputy City Clerk Stone read the Clerk’s Report and Statement of Conflict.
A. COUNCILMEMBERS PRESENT
Anthony Tave, Mayor
Devin T. Murphy, Mayor Pro Tem
Cameron Sasai, Council Member
Maureen Toms, Council Member
Norma Martinez-Rubin, Council Member
B. STAFF PRESENT
Naomi Kelly, City Manager
Eric Casher, City Attorney
Roxane Stone, Deputy City Clerk
4. CONVENE TO A CLOSED SESSION
Citizens may address the Council regarding a Closed Session item prior to the Council adjourning into the Closed Session, by first providing a speaker card to the City Clerk.
A. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL—ANTICIPATED LITIGATION Gov. Code § 54956.9(d)(2) or (d)(3)
Number of Potential Cases: 1
B. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS
Gov. Code § 54957.6
Agency designated representatives: City Manager, Naomi Kelly, City Attorney, Eric Casher, Human Resources Director, Stacy Shell, Finance Director, Markisha Guillory, and Gregory Ramirez, IEDA
Employee organization: AFSCME Local 1, AFSCME local 512, the Pinole Police Employees Association (PPEA), and the Management Compensation Plan (MCP).
Convened to Closed Session at 5:32 PM.
5. RECONVENE IN OPEN SESSION TO ANNOUNCE RESULTS OF CLOSED SESSION Mayor Tave reconvened the meeting in Open Session at 6:26 PM and announced no reportable action from Closed Session.
6. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (Public Comments)
Citizens may speak under any item not listed on the Agenda. The time limit is 3 minutes and is subject to modification by the Mayor. Individuals may not share or offer time to another speaker. Pursuant to provisions of the Brown Act, no action may be taken on a matter unless it is listed on the agenda, or unless certain emergency or special circumstances exist. The City Council may direct staff to investigate and/or schedule certain matters for consideration at a future Council meeting. PLEASE SEE THE
COVERSHEET OF THE AGENDA FOR INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO SUBMIT PUBLIC
COMMENTS
No speakers.
7. REPORTS & COMMUNICATIONS
A. Mayor Report
Mayor Tave gave a report.
1. Announcements
None
B. Mayoral & Council Appointments
None
C. City Council Committee Reports & Communications
Council member Martinez-Rubin gave a report.
Council member Toms gave a report.
Council member Sasai gave a report.
Mayor Pro Tem Murphy gave a report.
D. Council Requests for Future Agenda Items
Mayor Tave would like a presentation to come back to the council regarding an update on illegal dumping in the city.
Council member Sasai would like the annual proclamation list to come back to the council for review.
E. City Manager Report / Department Staff
City Manager Kelly gave a report.
F. City Attorney Report
No report.
8. RECOGNITIONS / PRESENTATIONS / COMMUNITY EVENTS
A. Proclamations
1. Fire Prevention Week
2. Breast Cancer Awareness Month
3. Pinole Players 40th Anniversary
4. Indigenous People's Day
5. Hispanic-Latinx Heritage Month
6. LGBTQ+ History Month
7. Filipino History Month
8. United Against Hate Week
9. Code Enforcement Officer Week
Mayor Tave read the proclamation titles only as there were no individuals present to receive the proclamations.
B. Presentations
1. Update from MCE on Programs and Services, and Sustainability Project Manager Presentation on Grants and Climate Action and Adaptation Plan Projects.
Kiara Donato with MCE and city staff made a presentation.
Council members had questions.
Public Speakers: Rafael Menis
2. West Contra Costa County Unified School District Update By: Superintendent, Cheryl Cotton.
Superintendent Cheryl Cotton provided a presentation. Council members asked questions.
3. California Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) presentation on Wage Theft Regulations.
Ken Lau with the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) made a presentation. Council members asked questions.
4. Appian Way Emergency Bridge Project By: Caltrans
Denise Harding of Caltrans made a presentation. Council members Council members asked questions and the questions were addressed by the presenter.
Public Works Paving Rehabilitation Project Update
.
Staff made a presentation. Council members asked questions and the questions were addressed by the presenter.
Public Speakers: Sheila Grist and Anthony Vossbrink
9. CONSENT CALENDAR
All matters under the Consent Calendar are considered to be routine and noncontroversial.
These items will be enacted by one motion and without discussion. If, however, any interested party or Council member(s) wishes to comment on an item, they may do so before action is taken on the Consent Calendar. Following comments, if a Council member wishes to discuss an item, it will be removed from the Consent Calendar and taken up in order after adoption of the Consent Calendar.
A. Approve the Minutes of the Regular City Council Meeting on September 1, 2026 and September 15, 2026.
B. Receive the September 12, 2026 – October 16, 2026, List of Warrants in the Amount of $2,232,745.36, the September 25, 2026 Payroll in the Amount of $566,004.76, and the October 9, 2026 Payroll in the Amount of $562,916.50.
C. Adopt Resolutions To Fix The Employer’s Contribution At An Equal Amount For Employees And Annuitants Under The Public Employees’ Medical And Hospital Care Act. Action: Adopt Resolutions per Staff Recommendation (Stacy Shell, Charlene Davis)
D. Adopt a resolution authorizing acceptance of $245,500 in grant funds from the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) Charge! program to install electric vehicle (EV) charging stations and designating the City Manager to execute all agreements and associated documents for receipt of funds. Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin) E. Adopt a Resolution to Accept a Single-Family Residential Water Heater Loaner Program Developed With California Energy Commission Local Government Building Decarbonization Challenge Planning Grant Funds. Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
F. Adopt a Resolution to Merge Awarded Ocean Protection Council (OPC) Sea Level Rise Planning funds for the Pinole-Hercules shoreline into a larger award for a multi-jurisdictional plan led by Contra Costa County. Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
G. Placement of Liens for Delinquent Unpaid Waste Collection Charges Falling Delinquent Between April and July 2026, Considered at an Administrative Hearing On October 1, 2026. Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Heather Bell)
H. Adopt a Resolution Reserving Marin Clean Energy (MCE) Rebates for Heat Pump Water Heater Installations at the Public Safety Building, Swim Center, and Senior Center, and Directing the City Manager to Execute All Required MCE Rebate Reservation
Documents. Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
I. Revised Purchase Price Adjustment for Sale of 2101 Pear Street (Post Office Property). Action: Adopt Resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen)
J. Adopt a Resolution Approving a Contract with Civica Law Group for Receivership Services and Authorizing the Appropriation of Reimbursable General Fund Resources. Action: Adopt resolution per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen) Public Speakers: Sheila Grist and Rafael Menis
ACTION: Motion by Council member Toms/Martinez-Rubin to approve Consent Calendar Items 9A through 9J, as shown.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
Mayor Tave called a recess at 9:20 PM. and reconvened the meeting at 9:25 PM.
10. PUBLIC HEARINGS
Citizens wishing to speak regarding a Public Hearing item should fill out a speaker card prior to the completion of the presentation, by first providing a speaker card to the City Clerk. An official who engaged in an ex parte communication that is the subject of a Public Hearing must disclose the communication on the record prior to the start of the Public Hearing.
1. User and Regulatory Fee Schedule. Action: Adopt Resolution Per Staff Recommendation (Melissa Klawuhn)
David Schroeder of Clear Source and staff made a presentation. Council members asked questions and the questions were addressed by the presenter.
ACTION: Motion by Mayor Pro Tem Murphy/Council member Toms to adopt the resolution per staff recommendation.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
2. Public Hearing and Approval of Energy Services Contract for Installation of LED Lighting Upgrades at City Hall and Public Safety Building, and Authorization for City Manager to Execute Agreement. Action: Continue to November 3, 2026 per Staff Recommendation
(Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
ACTION: Motion by Mayor Pro Tem Murphy/Council member Toms to continue the public hearing to November 3, 2026.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
3. Public Hearing and PG&E On-Bill Financing Approval for LED Lighting Retrofit at City Hall and Public Safety Building and Authorization for City Manager to Execute Documentation. Action: Continue to November 3, 2026 per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
ACTION: Motion by Council member Sasai/Mayor Pro Tem Murphy to continue the public hearing to November 3, 2026.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
4. Public Hearing and Approval of a Single-Source Energy Services Contract to Replace Aging Gas Water Heaters with Heat Pump Water Heaters at the Swim Center and Senior Center. (Gov. Code §4217) Action: Continue to November 3, 2026 per Staff Recommendation (Lilly Whalen, Kapil Amin)
ACTION: Motion by Mayor Pro Tem Murphy/Councilmember Martinez-Rubin to continue the public hearing to November 3, 2026.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
11. OLD BUSINESS
Appeal Of Planning Commission Denial of Entitlement Extension – Pinole Shores II (CUP 23-05 & DR 23-12) - 836–848 San Pablo Avenue. Action: Provide Direction (Lilly Whalen)
Staff presented the item, and the presenter addressed the Council members’ questions during the discussion.
Public Speakers; Franke Martinez and Hector Vinas
ACTION: Motion by Martinez-Rubin/Toms to support staff’s recommendation to uphold the appeal and reverse the planning commission’s August 10, 2026 denial and direct staff to prepare a resolution to grant the extension of entitlements for Pinole Shores and that it be a final extension effective November 3, 2026and to grant an additional extension of 6 months due to the delay by ConFire fora total of 18 months.
Vote: Passed 5-0
Ayes: Martinez-Rubin, Murphy, Sasai, Tave, Toms
Noes: None
Absent: None
Abstain: None
12. NEW BUSINESS
None
13. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (Continued from Item 6) (Public Comments) Open only to members of the public who did not speak under the first Citizens to Be Heard, Agenda Item 6 Citizens may speak under any item not listed on the Agenda.
The time limit is 3 minutes for City Council items and is subject to modification by the Mayor. Individuals may not share or offer time to another speaker. Pursuant to provisions of the Brown Act, no action may be taken on a matter unless it is listed on the agenda, or unless certain emergency or special circumstances exist. The City Council may direct staff to investigate and/or schedule certain matters for consideration at a future meeting.
Public Speakers: Rafael Menis and Anthony Vossbrink
14. ADJOURNMENT to the Regular City Council Meeting of November 3, 2026, in Remembrance of Amber Swartz.
The regular meeting was adjourned in memory of Amber Swartz at 10:13 PM.
I hereby certify under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing Agenda was posted on the bulletin board at the main entrance of Pinole City Hall, 2131 Pear Street Pinole, CA, and on the City’s website, not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting date set forth on this agenda.
Roxane Stone, CMC
Deputy City Clerk
APPROVED by City Council:
CITY COUNCIL
REPORT 9.C.
DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2026
TO: MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: Fiona Epps, Communications Director, 510-724-9830, [email protected] SUBJECT: APPROVE THE CITY OF PINOLE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICY
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that City Council adopt a resolution approving the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy; an administrative policy which establishes a governance structure for how City of Pinole employees use AI.
BACKGROUND
As Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies continue to evolve, many government agencies are increasingly exploring their use to support operational efficiency, enhance service delivery, and improve internal workflows. While AI can be a beneficial technology, it also poses serious risks and requires responsible governance to ensure ethical use, data privacy, equity, accuracy, and alignment with the organization’s objectives and community expectations.
In response to emerging opportunities and risks of AI, staff have developed an AI Policy. This administrative policy establishes internal guidelines, standards, and procedures that govern employee usage of AI. The policy enables the City of Pinole to use AI systems responsibly for the benefit of the community while implementing safeguards to help protect against potential harms.
The City of Pinole is a member of the GovAI Coalition, which was formed in 2023 by the City of San José and has since grown internationally. The GovAI Coalition is comprised of government members from local, state, and federal agencies united to promote responsible and purposeful AI in the public sector[i]. In developing the City’s AI Policy, staff drew upon a variety of GovAI resources and templates that have already been reviewed and vetted by GovAI committees and working groups.
Community Engagement
On February 3, 2026, staff presented an overview of the AI Policy framework to City Council.
In response, Council approved a motion to make the draft AI Policy available for review by the public, then brought back to City Council on the consent calendar for final consideration. Mayor Pro Tempore Devin Murphy, who initiated the motion, emphasized the importance of engaging the public who could help provide staff with more insight on how AI impacts the community.
Following Council’s direction, staff conducted public engagement efforts that would help shape the final policy draft. The policy was developed by the Communications and IT Departments, and has since been reviewed by the City Manager, Department Heads, Bargaining Unit
Representatives of AFSCME Local 512 and Local 1, and the City Attorney’s Office. As part of public engagement efforts, staff held meetings and had discussions with residents to address concerns and answer questions about the draft policy. Pinole residents and City of Pinole employees were also provided the opportunity to share their input through the AI Policy Survey, which was open for approximately 21 weeks, and a public workshop (hybrid format), held on September 22, 2026. After gathering input from stakeholders, staff have revised the policy with consideration to all feedback received. A final draft is attached to this staff report (see ATTACHMENT B).
[i] https://www.sanjoseca.gov/your-government/departments-offices/information-technology/ai-reviews-algorithm-register/govai-coalition
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
Currently, the AI Policy functions as an internal administrative document and does not create new programs or mandates requiring Council action. Staff presents the policy to maintain transparency regarding the City’s internal governance of AI tools.
AI Policy Survey
Method
Staff circulated the AI Policy Survey from May 18, 2026 – October 1, 2026, gathering 790 responses and 87 comments from a total of 74 participants. Despite using the same survey distribution methods as other City surveys, staff found that the AI Policy survey resulted in a lower-than-average participation rate.
The survey consisted of 6 questions, both quantitative and qualitative. Additionally, staff collected input from social media and the AI Policy Workshop, compiling all data for analysis.
The full draft of the AI Policy and a 1-page summary (see ATTACHMENT C) were made available for public review during the survey period.
Results & Discussion
The chart above shows a comparison of results for Guiding Principle Ranking and Top Areas of Concern.
In the AI Policy Survey, participants were asked to rank the city’s Guiding Principles in order of most important to least important. Respondents ranked Privacy and Security (2.65), Accuracy (3.44), Responsible Use (4.05), Transparency (4.41) and Accountability (4.44) as the top five most important guiding principles. A subsequent question asked participants to select all the areas in which they have concerns about AI technology. Survey results show that the top areas of concern related to AI technology -- Privacy and Security (53%), Ethics and societal impacts (53%), Data input/output and training models (45%), Bias and Equity (45%), Environmental Impacts (45%), and Transparency (45%) -- align closely with Guiding Principle priorities. This correlation suggests that the community places the highest value on principles that directly address its concerns.
The emphasis on Responsible Use likely reflects survey respondents’ attention to how data is handled and how the City applies AI in ways that remain ethical and socially responsible.
Survey participants’ strong value of Transparency, paired with its concerns about AI transparency, may indicate either a need for greater trust in the City’s disclosure practices or simply a desire for clear communication about how AI tools and applications are used, or a combination.
An equal number of people also noted concerns for Data input/output and training models, Bias and Equity, Environmental Impacts. This information will help guide City staff’s applications of AI technology and/or AI policy development to promote ethical awareness, proactively apply risk mitigation, support environmental sustainability and take ownership; as these foundations reflect responsible and accountable AI practices in alignment with community values.
Accuracy ranked second among guiding values, and concerns regarding Bias and Equity reinforce the community’s expectation that AI systems should produce unbiased, reliable
information that supports equitable outcomes. Finally, the fact that Privacy and Security is both the highest-ranked principle and the top concern underscores the community’s expectation that the City maintain robust policies and practices to safeguard data privacy and security.
The chart above shows the types of City services that survey respondents consider to be appropriate use cases for applied AI technology.
Survey results revealed that respondents think that Records Management is the most appropriate City service for applied AI technology, followed by License/Permit applications, Traffic Safety, Communications, and Other.
The diagram above shows the top six recurring trends found in survey comments. The numbers represent the total number of comments tagged with the trending topic.
After analyzing survey comments, staff found that while several respondents voiced opposition to AI adoption, the majority expressed support for responsible AI usage in their comments. The top six recurring trends found in survey comments (in order from most to least comment tags) were: Support for Responsible AI Use (16), Opposition to AI Adoption (14), Transparency in AI Usage (10), Human-centered Concern (10), Concerns About AI Impact on Jobs (5), and Environmental Concern (5). Staff found that the 14 comments expressing opposition to AI
adoption correspond with survey data results showing that 49% of respondents do not feel comfortable with AI technology. View the full report in ATTACHMENT D or online [link]: https://PublicInput.com/Report/2pjbbqocv0k
Conclusion
The City has collected meaningful data that will guide employee use of AI technologies in alignment with community values and for the benefit of Pinole residents. The policy was refined to incorporate public input. Additionally, staff confirmed that many of the public’s concerns were already addressed in the draft policy which reaffirmed the City’s commitment to responsible and safeguarded AI use.
Next Steps
Upon final approval of the AI Policy, staff will create a dedicated webpage where the community can learn about the development of the AI Policy, including an overview of the policy-making process and the City’s risk-assessment framework. A list of IT-approved AI applications with accompanying factsheets will be accessible, along with key documents such as the AI Policy, staff report and presentation slides, and community survey results.This work aligns closely with Pinole's strong values in transparency of AI usage.
The AI webpage will also include a dedicated vendor section outlining AI-related vendor requirements and factsheets, and staff contact information to support continued public engagement and questions.
The AI Policy will be distributed to all City employees, training materials and a training schedule will be developed. The Communications Department aims to complete staff training of the AI Policy within one month of policy implementation.
The City of Pinole treats AI as an enabling capability that supports areas such as governance, service delivery, cybersecurity, workforce capacity, and data management. The IT Division focuses on low-risk, high-value administrative tools that ease staff workload without removing human oversight or exposing sensitive data. Council will see AI integrated throughout the upcoming 2026–2031 IT Plan.
The IT Division and Communications Director will review the AI Policy quarterly to keep pace with new technologies, vendor features, regulatory changes, and updated GovAI Coalition guidance. Revisions will be approved by the City Manager and posted to the City's AI webpage. As an active GovAI Coalition member, the City will continue to use the Coalition's vetted templates and resources and share lessons learned with peer agencies. The IT Division will assess risk of existing and proposed AI tools using processes which ensure safeguards and monitoring (reference the IT AI Risk Assessment Flowchart in ATTACHMENT E). Under the policy's AI Incident Response Plan (see ATTACHMENT B, pg. 23), staff who become aware of harm caused by an AI system must report it to their supervisor and the IT Manager, who leads the AI Incident Response Team. Residents and vendors may also report concerns.
Lessons from incidents will inform future policy updates.
FISCAL IMPACT
There is no direct fiscal impact associated with receiving and filing this report. Implementation of the AI Policy will result in staff time for training, oversight, and review processes, all of which
can be absorbed into existing workloads. Any future AI-related software acquisitions, training programs, or technology enhancements would be presented to the City Council for consideration through the annual budget process or as separate agenda items if needed.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution
B. Artificial Intelligence [AI] Policy Collection
C. Summary of AI Policy
D. AI Survey Results
E. IT AI Risk Assessment Flowchart
RESOLUTION NO. 2026-XX
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PINOLE,
COUNTY OF CONTRA COSTA, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, APPROVING
THE CITY OF PINOLE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICY
WHEREAS, Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies continue to evolve rapidly, and government agencies are increasingly exploring their use to support operational efficiency, enhance service delivery, and improve internal workflows; and WHEREAS, while AI can be a beneficial technology, it also poses serious risks and requires responsible governance to ensure ethical use, data privacy, equity, accuracy, and alignment with the organization’s objectives and community expectations; and
WHEREAS, the City of Pinole is a member of the GovAI Coalition, a coalition of local, state, and federal government agencies united to promote responsible and purposeful AI in the public sector, and City staff drew upon GovAI Coalition resources and templates, already reviewed and vetted by GovAI committees and working groups, in developing the City’s AI Policy; and
WHEREAS, on February 3, 2026, staff presented an overview of the AI Policy framework to the City Council, and the City Council directed that the draft AI Policy be made available for public review and returned to the City Council for final consideration; and
WHEREAS, in response to the City Council’s direction, the City conducted an AI Policy Survey from May 18, 2026, through October 1, 2026, which gathered 790 responses and 87 comments from 74 participants, held a public workshop on September 22, 2026, and met with residents to address concerns and answer questions about the draft policy; and
WHEREAS, the draft AI Policy was developed by the Communications Department and the Information Technology Division and has been reviewed by the City Manager, Department Heads, the City’s bargaining unit representatives, and the City Attorney’s Office, and has been revised with consideration of all stakeholder and community feedback received; and
WHEREAS, the AI Policy establishes nine guiding principles for the responsible use of AI. It requires that staff use only AI tools reviewed and approved by the Information Technology Division and that employees complete annual AI training. It prohibits high-risk uses of AI, including real-time and covert biometric identification, emotion analysis,
Pinole City Council
Resolution No. 2026-XX
social scoring, and fully automated decisions without meaningful human involvement. It also sets requirements for vendors providing AI systems and establishes an AI Incident Response Plan based on the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) AI Risk Management Framework; and
WHEREAS, the AI Policy is intended to be part of an evolving governance structure, and staff will review the policy quarterly and update it as new technologies and use cases are developed; and
WHEREAS, there is no direct fiscal impact associated with the approval of the AI Policy;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Pinole does hereby approve the City of Pinole Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy, attached hereto as Attachment A.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Pinole does hereby authorize the City Manager, or designee, to implement and administer the AI Policy, including making periodic administrative updates to the policy and its attachments as new technologies, use cases, and regulatory requirements emerge, consistent with the policy’s guiding principles.
PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Pinole City Council held on the 3rd day of November 2026 by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS:
I, hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed, and adopted on this 3rd day of November 2026.
_______________________________
Heather Bell, CMC
City Clerk
City of Pinole
Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
Adopted [insert date]
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Table of Contents
Artificial Intelligence (AI Usage Policy ................................................................................... 3 Purpose ................................................................................................................................. 3 Guiding Principles .................................................................................................................. 3 Policy ..................................................................................................................................... 5 Approved AI Applications ....................................................................................................... 6 Attachments........................................................................................................................... 7 Acknowledgement.................................................................................................................. 7 Quick Reference Guide: User Rules for Generative AI.......................................................... 8 Assessing Risk in Generative AI Use Cases.......................................................................... 9 How to Assess Risk When Using Generative AI..................................................................... 9 When engaging in High-Risk Use Cases:..............................................................................10 Terms & Definitions ................................................................................................................11 Vendor Requirements for AI Systems ...................................................................................14 Vendor Contracts and Agreements .......................................................................................14 Vendor Communications.......................................................................................................14 Purchasing and Procurement Guidelines ..............................................................................15 AI System Monitoring and Accountability ..............................................................................15 Data Security and Privacy .....................................................................................................15 Meeting Recording and AI Tools Usage ................................................................................16 Ethical AI and Public Trust ....................................................................................................16 Vendor Evaluation and Continuous Improvement..................................................................16 Vendor Termination or Renewal............................................................................................17 AI FactSheet for Developers ..................................................................................................18 AI FactSheet for Third Party Service Providers ....................................................................21 AI Incident Response Plan .....................................................................................................23 Introduction ...........................................................................................................................23 Purpose ................................................................................................................................23 Scope....................................................................................................................................23 Approach...............................................................................................................................23 Definitions .............................................................................................................................24 Roles & Responsibilities........................................................................................................25 Activation Criteria..................................................................................................................25 Response Level ....................................................................................................................26
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Level 1: Low Risk ..............................................................................................................26 Level 2: Medium Risk ........................................................................................................27 Level 3: High Risk .............................................................................................................27 External Communications .....................................................................................................28 Phased Approach..................................................................................................................28
1. Preparation................................................................................................................29
2. Detection & Analysis..................................................................................................30
3. Containment ..............................................................................................................31
4. Eradication & Recovery .............................................................................................32
5. Post-incident Activity..................................................................................................32
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Artificial Intelligence (AI Usage Policy
Purpose
This policy establishes a comprehensive, yet flexible, governance structure for Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems used by, or on behalf of, the City of Pinole. This policy enables the City of Pinole to use AI systems responsibly for the benefit of the community while safeguarding against potential harms.
This document serves as part of an evolving governance structure around responsible AI usage and will be updated or replaced as experience and new information is gained.
All employees, council members, commissioners, interns and volunteers of the City of Pinole, whether permanent or temporary, are required to abide by this Policy.
Guiding Principles
These nine (9) principles describe the City of Pinole’s values with regards to how AI systems are purchased, configured, developed, operated, or maintained.
1. Human-Centered Design: AI systems are developed and deployed with a human-centered approach that evaluates AI powered services for their impact on the public.
2. Privacy & Security: Privacy is preserved in all AI systems by safeguarding Personally Identifiable Information (PII) and sensitive data from unauthorized access, disclosure, and manipulation. Submit information to Generative AI tools that is appropriate for public disclosure.
Staff are required to use City of Pinole accounts when using AI tools to conduct City of Pinole business. Staff should not use AI tools with City of Pinole accounts for personal use, or use AI tools with personal accounts for City use.
3. Accuracy: The City maintains trust with its residents and partners by providing accurate information. Review and fact check all outputs you receive from a Generative AI. Staff should review all generative AI output for accuracy, relevancy, validity, and ensure it is free from bias.
Generative AI is trained on vast amounts of data including the Internet, and therefore the output of generative AI may contain inaccuracies.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Additionally, each AI tool algorithm and dataset may include biases, and bias may result from or be triggered by the wording of Staff input.
Generative AI can produce hallucinations (false or misleading information presented as fact) in the form of text, data or images, and/or other unanticipated outputs which can put the City of Pinole at risk.
4. Transparency: The user shall be transparent in their use of AI and disclose when AI tools have contributed substantially to work product.
This can often include citing that you used AI in creating a product. See how and when to cite Generative AI in the “Citing AI” section in the "Quick Reference Guide: User Rules for Generative AI.”
Use of AI may be subject to Public Records Act (PRA) requests. Staff should not input anything that is not appropriate for public record.
5. Equity: Generative AI may reflect personal thoughts and opinions found on the Internet and could perpetuate harmful biases. Staff should be on alert for biases in the input and output. Staff should review the output for word choice, tone, and partiality or unfairness towards specific demographics.
6. Accountability: The person using AI is accountable for the content it generates. Use Generative AI with a healthy dose of skepticism. The level of caution used should correspond to the risk level of the use case (see “Assessing Risk in Generative AI Use Cases”). It is always important to verify information provided by Generative AI.
7. Responsible Use: Staff may experiment with approved AI tools responsibly after taking the required training and knowing the risks.
Staff should be aware of proprietary or Intellectual Property (IP)rights and issues during the use of AI tools. Specifically:
• AI tools may create new IP based on Staff input; IP created in the course and scope of your employment is owned by City of Pinole as your employer,
• AI tools may create IP based on third party materials provided by Staff input; this modification or derivative work may not be owned by City of Pinole and the creation may violate the third party's IP rights, and
• Modifications or derivative works might be created based on City of Pinole IP; the City of Pinole may lose IP rights if certain IP (copyrighted software, trade secrets, etc.) are provided to
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
generative AI tools (such a disclosure might also violate City of Pinole confidentiality obligations).
8. Workforce Empowerment: The use of generative AI pursuant to this Policy is intended to be a tool used by staff, not a substitute for staffing.
The use of generative AI should not replace or diminish minimum qualifications, knowledge, skills, or abilities associated with any job classifications. Staff may responsibly incorporate Generative AI into their work where it can make services better, more just, and more efficient.
9. Public Purpose: All efforts staff put forward are for the overall benefit of the community and City of Pinole as a public entity. AI tools shall be used in a way that benefits the public.
Policy
When purchasing, configuring, developing, operating, or maintaining AI systems, the City of Pinole will:
1) Uphold the Guiding Principles and follow the City’s User Rules for Generative AI Systems;
2) Conduct an AI Review to assess the potential risk of AI systems. The IT Division is responsible for coordinating review of AI systems used by the City of Pinole. Staff may only use AI tools that have been reviewed and approved by the IT Division. Additionally, staff are responsible for assessing risk of content before entering into Generative AI.
3) Obtain technical documentation about AI systems using the AI FactSheets or create equivalent documentation if internally developing the AI system. The IT Division is responsible for requiring vendors to complete the applicable AI FactSheet;
4) Require contracted vendors to comply with the Vendor Requirements for AI Systems overseen by the IT Division; and
5) In the event of an incident involving the use of the AI system, the City of Pinole will follow an Incident Response Plan as detailed in the AI Incident Response Plan. The IT Manager (or equivalent) is responsible for overseeing the security practices of AI systems used by or on behalf of City of Pinole departments. If City of Pinole staff become aware of an instance where an AI system has caused harm, staff must report the instance to their supervisor and the IT Manager.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
6) City employees are required to complete annual training on AI. IT Division is responsible for coordinating required training with HR. At minimum, staff should review annually:
• Fundamentals of AI (i.e. “What is Artificial Intelligence”) • Assessing Risk in Generative AI Use Cases
• Quick Reference Guide: User Rules for Generative AI
7) Prohibited uses of AI. Certain AI systems and usage cases are prohibited due to the sensitive nature of the information processed and severe potential risk. This includes the following prohibited purposes:
• Real-time and covert biometric identification.
• Emotion analysis, or the use of computer vision techniques to classify human facial and body movements into certain emotions or sentiment (e.g., positive, negative, neutral, happy, angry, nervous). • Decisions generated solely by automated processes, with no meaningful human involvement, that produce substantial
consequences for individuals.
• Social scoring, or the use of AI systems to track and classify individuals based on their behaviors, socioeconomic status, or personal characteristics.
• Cognitive behavioral manipulation of people or specific vulnerable groups.
• Creating AI-generated images of people for public-facing print or digital media.
Approved AI Applications
This section provides a list of AI tools/applications that have been reviewed, vetted and assessed for risk by the IT Division. These applications are the only AI tools authorized for use by City of Pinole employees:
Adobe
ArcGIS
Avanon
Canva
CivicClerk
Microsoft 365
Microsoft Copilot (generative AI)
OneTera
Peach Safety
Public Input
RingCentral
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Symbium
Telvue
Ubiquiti
Zoom
Unapproved tools (such as ChatGPT) are not allowed.
Attachments
Quick Reference Guide: User Rules for Generative AI
Assessing Risk in Generative AI Use Cases
Terms and Definitions
Vendor Requirements for AI Systems
AI Factsheet for Developers
AI Factsheet for Third Party Providers
AI Incident Response Plan
Acknowledgement
By signing below, I understand that violations of any section of the AI Policy, including failure to comply with the City of Pinole’s AI Policy may be subject to disciplinary action, up to and including termination. Infractions that violate local, state, federal or international law may be remanded to the proper authorities. ____________________________ ____________________________ Employee Name Employee Signature
Today’s Date: _____________________
Date of Hire: ______________________
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Quick Reference Guide: User Rules for Generative AI
Public Records Compliance
• Generative AI usage may be
subject to the Public Records Act.
• Prompts, outputs, and related data
may be publicly released.
Approved Tools Only
• Use only IT-approved AI tools
• Do NOT use personal accounts or
unapproved tools.
• Reference AI Policy for approved
tools or consult IT if unsure.
Copyright & Ownership
• Verify originality of AI-generated
content.
• Revise or avoid content if copyright
status is uncertain.
• Only enter information suitable for
public disclosure.
Citing AI
• Cite Generative AI when
substantial content is used
( >20%)
• Fact-check all statements and cite
credible sources.
• Example: ‘Drafted with support
from Copilot; edited and fact-checked by City staff.’
Accuracy & Fact-Checking
• Review, revise, and fact-check all
AI outputs.
• Do NOT rely on AI for finding
citations; verify sources directly.
Terms & Conditions
• City-approved tools are reviewed
for safety.
• Unapproved tools are not allowed
(i.e. ChatGPT).
Data Privacy & Opt-Out
• Opt out of data collection and
model training whenever possible.
• Do NOT include confidential or
non-public information.
High-Risk Use Cases
• Ensure tone and language align
with City values.
• Consider risk of information breach
and risk of adverse impact
Prohibited Uses
• Real-time or covert biometric identification.
• Emotion analysis or sentiment classification of human facial or body movements.
• Fully automated decisions without human oversight.
• Social scoring or cognitive behavioral manipulation.
• AI-generated images of people.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Assessing Risk in Generative AI Use Cases
How to Assess Risk When Using Generative AI
Risk is the exposure to potential danger, harm or loss. Depending on the situation, the City could be exposed to varying degrees of risk when employees use Generative AI.
The risk presented by Generative AI tools varies by use case, with the risk spectrum ranging from mid-risk to high-risk to intolerable risk.
Generative AI risk is determined by two key factors:
1. Risk of information breach: the potential harm if the information exchanged with a Generative AI is released to an unintended audience. This can include entering the following types of information into Generative AI:
• Personally Identifiable Information (PII);
• Sensitive records; or
• Confidential business information.
DO NOT input confidential or non-public information in Generative AI. PII is a target for attackers in data breaches therefore is a prohibited risk.
Any information entered into Generative AI may be subject to the Public Records Act. If you wouldn’t share the information in a public forum, don’t share it with a Generative AI.
2. Risk of adverse impact: the potential harm of using the output for a decision, task, or service. Fully automated decisions made by AI without human oversight are prohibited in the City of Pinole.
The impact can be different for different populations, therefore, should be evaluated through an equity lens. Consider potential adverse impacts to people of a certain race, age, gender identity, or disability status.
Not only can AI be biased, but it can also provide false information. In general, if Generative AI is used in relation to City processes that can alter an individual or community’s rights, freedoms, or access to services, it should be thoroughly reviewed by multiple users before any document is finalized or action is taken.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
When engaging in High-Risk Use Cases:
Keep in mind the tone and specific language in the AI output. Generative AI is trained on a global context and may not use the vocabulary or tone consistent with the City and its values. Simple examples include replacing “citizen” with “resident” in documents, and capitalizing “City” when referring to the City of Pinole. These documents, like any others, require thorough review before moving from draft to final product.
Cite verifiable sources for all facts and figures (past memos, newspapers, research papers, etc.). Microsoft Copilot or other Generative AI are not definitive sources. Facts should be accompanied by links or citations to sources that the general public could find, such as news articles or research papers. Copilot and other AI can fabricate sources if asked, so do not rely on them for finding citations either. Find sources directly and confirm they are legitimate before using.
Anything that would not be released or shared with the public should not be input into the AI. This includes information such as draft RFP requirements that should not be public yet, vendor transactions, procurement approvals, or internal City decisions.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Terms & Definitions
There are several types of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies available. The list below contains common terms and definitions related to AI, along with terms referenced in the City of Pinole AI Usage Policy.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) — a software system capable of performing tasks that typically require human intelligence, such as pattern recognition, decision-making, or language understanding, often using algorithms and neural networks to compute. i. Machine Learning (ML) — A subset of AI where systems learn from data sets to identify patterns, make decisions, and predict outcomes without being explicitly programmed for specific tasks. ii. Generative AI (GenAI) — A type of AI that creates new content such as text, images, videos, or sounds. It utilizes models such as Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) or transformer-based models like GPT.
iii. Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) — The concept of an AI system that has the capability to perform any intellectual task that a human being can do. This type of AI is considered hypothetical as it has not been achieved yet and would imply true cognitive abilities comparable to human intelligence.
Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) — A type of machine learning model that uses transformer architecture to process sequences of data and generate outputs based on pre-trained patterns. It is designed to perform generative tasks across various domains, such as text, images, or other structured data, by leveraging pre-training on large datasets and fine-tuning for specific applications.
Large Language Models (LLMs) — A type of machine learning model trained using large amounts of text data. These models learn nuanced patterns and structure of language.
Cloud — Computing resources and data processing are managed on remote servers hosted by third-party providers. When AI is involved, data is sent to these off-site systems for analysis and computation.
On-Premises — The AI system, including the necessary hardware and software, is installed and managed within the organization's own data centers or servers.
On-Device — The processing and computation of AI tasks are conducted directly on the user's local device, such as a smartphone or computer, without the need to send data to remote servers.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Hybrid — A combination of Cloud, On-Premises, and On-Device deployment models.
AI Enhanced Image — An image that has been digitally enhanced to improve its quality and clarity by AI. Enhancements may include adjustments to color, sharpness, white balance, or resolution upscaling. The enhanced image must retain all original content in a recognizable form, with no new elements added.
AI Altered Image — An image that has been modified using artificial intelligence to add, remove, or alter elements within the image. These changes go beyond simple quality enhancements.
AI Generated — Something created by a GenAI by a prompt. This includes but is not limited to: Text, Image, Video, Voice, Music, Code.
Explainability — The ability of an AI system to explain its decisions or actions in a way that is understandable to humans.
Data Privacy — The practice of safeguarding personal or sensitive information, especially when processed by AI systems.
Training Data — The dataset used to teach an AI model during the training phase, often requiring significant preprocessing and labeling.
Bias — Any systematic error introduced into AI systems during the training phase, which may lead to unfair or inaccurate outcomes. Bias can stem from the training data or the model design and needs to be monitored and mitigated.
Real-time Covert Biometric Identification — The live identification of an individual using technologies including, but not limited to, facial recognition and iris scanning, without that individual's knowledge or meaningful consent.
Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) — An approach to AI where human intervention is integrated into the AI decision-making process to validate or oversee the outcomes, especially in critical or high-stakes scenarios.
AI Risk Assessment — The process of identifying, analyzing, and mitigating risks associated with the development, deployment, and use of AI systems.
Ethical AI — The practice of developing and deploying AI systems in a manner that aligns with ethical principles, including fairness, transparency, accountability, and respect for user privacy and rights.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Sensitive Data — Any data that is not publicly available and requires protection due to its confidential nature. This includes internal documents not intended for public disclosure, as well as personal information such as Social Security Numbers, credit card details, and other identifiable or financial data.
Personally Identifiable Information (PII) — Data that can be used to distinguish or trace an individual's identity, either alone or when combined with other information, and is a target for attackers in data breaches due to its high value.
Emotion Analysis — The use of computer vision techniques to classify human facial expressions, body movement, or language into emotions or sentiment (e.g. positive, negative, neutral, happy, angry).
Social Scoring — A "Social Scoring System" refers to artificial intelligence or algorithmic systems that aggregate and interprets an individual's personal data to assign a quantifiable score or rating that ranks them against other individuals and impacts their access to services, opportunities, or societal privileges. These systems are characterized by their use of data related to behavior, preferences, interactions, financial transactions, and other personal attributes which are not directly linked to the application of the score. They can be part of a comprehensive profile that is used to make significant decisions about an individual's rights, opportunities, or social standing.
Cognitive Behavioral Manipulation — Refers to AI-driven tools or algorithms designed to influence or alter an individual's decision-making process or belief system.
These systems use psychological, behavioral, or emotional data to create targeted strategies that can manipulate thoughts, feelings, or actions, particularly focusing on vulnerable groups or individuals.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Vendor Requirements for AI Systems
This document outlines the expectations, best practices, and responsibilities for vendors providing goods or services that involve the use of AI systems in alignment with City of Pinole's policies. These guidelines ensure that vendor relationships remain transparent, effective, and compliant with ethical standards, regulations, and public interests, particularly regarding sensitive data protection.
Vendor Contracts and Agreements
i. Clear Scope of Work: Vendors must clearly define their deliverables, capabilities, and the expected outcomes for any AI-related systems and services provided. Contracts should outline AI system functions and any limitations to avoid misuse or overreach.
ii. Ownership of Data: City of Pinole retains full ownership of any data generated by or through AI systems. Vendors are prohibited from using City of Pinole's data for any purpose beyond the scope of the contract and must comply with all applicable data privacy and security regulations.
iii. Liability and Accountability: Vendors are responsible for any AI-related issues impacting City of Pinole operations. This includes system failures, security breaches, or the unintentional misuse of AI tools.
Vendors must address and resolve any AI issues promptly. iv. Compliance with Regulations: Vendors must explicitly commit to complying with all applicable local, state, and federal regulations related to sensitive data privacy, security, and AI usage (e.g., HIPAA, CLETS, CJIS, etc.). This includes data processing and ensuring AI systems are used responsibly and ethically.
Vendor Communications
i. Transparency and Clarity: Vendors are expected to communicate regularly with City of Pinole, providing updates on system performance, maintenance schedules, and new AI features or tools. Communication should be clear and easily understood by City of Pinole officials, avoiding overly technical language.
ii. Incident Reporting: Vendors are obligated to immediately report any AI system failures or breaches that could compromise City of Pinole's data or operations. Transparent and timely incident reporting is crucial to mitigate risks and ensure continuous improvement.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
iii. Support and Feedback Channels: Vendors should provide clear avenues for City of Pinole to report issues or seek support, ensuring prompt responses to inquiries or technical challenges.
Purchasing and Procurement Guidelines
AI software purchases shall adhere to the existing procurement guidelines of City of Pinole.
AI System Monitoring and Accountability
i. Performance Monitoring: City of Pinole will regularly assess the performance of AI systems to ensure that they meet the established standards and objectives outlined in the contract. Vendors must cooperate with City of Pinole in providing regular performance reports, audits, and any necessary adjustments to improve system functionality. ii. Error Management and Resolution: AI systems must be regularly tested to ensure they deliver accurate and reliable results. Vendors must provide a process for promptly identifying, reporting, and resolving errors or inaccuracies that affect the system's performance or outcomes. iii. Transparency in AI Decision-Making: Vendors must ensure that AI systems are transparent in their decision-making processes. City of Pinole must have a clear understanding of the logic, algorithms, and methodologies used by AI systems, including how they arrive at decisions or recommendations.
Data Security and Privacy
i. Data Protection: Vendors must ensure that all data processed by AI systems is protected in accordance with City of Pinole's data privacy policies. This includes adhering to encryption, access controls, and data protection laws at all levels (local, state, and federal). ii. Handling Sensitive Data: Vendors are prohibited from processing, analyzing, or storing sensitive data, such as personally identifiable information (PII), medical records, financial data, or criminal history data, unless explicitly authorized in the contract and in compliance with regulatory standards.
iii. Incident Reporting: Vendors must immediately report any breaches or security incidents that involve AI systems. This includes any accidental or unauthorized access, data leaks, or failures in the AI system that compromise sensitive data.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
iv. Data Retention and Disposal: City of Pinole will define the retention period for data processed by AI systems. Vendors must adhere to this retention period and ensure that all data is securely disposed of once it is no longer needed, in line with City of Pinole's data retention policies.
Meeting Recording and AI Tools Usage
i. Ethical Use of AI in Meetings: If AI tools are used to record or analyze meetings (e.g., transcriptions, summarization), vendors must ensure these tools comply with privacy and consent regulations. Participants must be informed and provide consent before any AI recording occurs. ii. Transparency of AI-Generated Content: City of Pinole should have access to AI-generated content, such as transcripts or analyses, and the right to review and modify them as necessary. AI tools must not create or store content without clear consent or legal basis.
Ethical AI and Public Trust
i. Public Transparency: As part of maintaining public trust, City of Pinole requires vendors to ensure that their AI systems are transparent and used in ways that do not compromise public confidence. The use of AI by City of Pinole should be clearly communicated to the public, with a focus on how AI can improve services while respecting privacy and individual rights.
ii. Ethical Use: Vendors must commit to the responsible and ethical use of AI technology, ensuring that it is deployed in ways that benefit the public and align with City of Pinole's values and priorities.
Vendor Evaluation and Continuous Improvement
i. Annual Performance Review: Vendors and AI systems will undergo an annual review to assess the effectiveness, compliance, and overall performance of the systems provided. City of Pinole will evaluate the systems based on their ability to meet contract requirements, their impact on City of Pinole operations, and customer satisfaction. ii. Continuous Improvement: City of Pinole encourages vendors to continuously improve the AI systems they provide. This includes offering updates, addressing performance issues, and identifying areas for improvement. Vendors should be proactive in proposing innovations that can enhance City of Pinole's use of AI technologies.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
iii. Vendor Feedback: City of Pinole will maintain open communication with vendors to gather feedback on AI system usage, performance, and potential enhancements. This feedback loop will help inform future system upgrades or modifications.
Vendor Termination or Renewal
i. Contract Renewal: City of Pinole will consider contract renewals based on the vendor's performance, continued compliance with City of Pinole requirements, and the effectiveness of their AI systems. The vendor's ability to meet performance standards and contribute to City of Pinole's needs will be a key factor in the renewal decision.
ii. Termination: City of Pinole reserves the right to terminate any vendor contract if the vendor fails to meet agreed-upon performance standards, regulatory compliance, or ethical guidelines. If the contract is terminated, the vendor must assist with the smooth transition of services and ensure that all City of Pinole data is handled securely.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
AI FactSheet for Developers
Please provide details regarding your artificial intelligence (AI) solution by filling out the AI FactSheet1 template below. This template was developed by the GovAI Coalition.
This AI FactSheet is for AI developers to complete. A developer is an entity that creates a standard software product or solution that is intended for many customers to use. These products may include AI systems built by the developer themselves, and/or a software solution that leverages third party AI tools within the product offering.
A service provider is an entity that guides, consults, advises, and supports agencies in navigating artificial intelligence (AI). A service provider may build custom AI solutions for a client, but does not sell the product as a standard solution to many customers on its own. If you are a service provider, please fill out the AI FactSheet for Service Providers instead.
Please contact the City of Pinole IT Department at (510) 343-5540 with questions.
To submit your AI FactSheet to the GovAI Coalition’s AI Registry, please contact [email protected] and [email protected].
Vendor Name Your “Doing business as” Name and Legal Name, if different.
Product Name Name of the AI product or suite of products.
Overview Brief summary of the AI system.
Purpose What function does the AI system perform, and for what purpose? If the system performs multiple functions, list each discretely and reference below. For features that are configurable, please describe all configuration options and default settings.
Intended Domain What domain is the AI system intended to be applied in? Training Data How was the AI system trained? What data was used? How often is data added to the training set? Was all training data legally obtained and its use fully licensed?
Test Data What data was used to test system performance? Under what conditions has the system been tested?
Model
Information
General description of the model(s) used (e.g., large language model, transformer, deep learning, supervised learning, built on an existing open source model, computer vision)
Update
procedure
In general, how often are the models updated for users? Will the user have a choice in moving to the updated model or staying on 1 The FactSheet template is heavily inspired by the IBM Research AI FactSheets 360 project.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
the current model? What documentation is available for new versions of the model?
Inputs and
Outputs
What are the inputs to the AI system? What are its outputs? What interfaces and integrations are supported?
Performance
Metrics
What are the performance metrics? What is your current level of performance on these metrics? How can the user monitor
performance when deployed?
Bias What biases does the tool exhibit and how does it manage that bias? This can include but is not limited to biases on human factors such as gender, race, socioeconomic status, disability, culture, age, or other protected classes, or biases on general factors such as a sampling bias, survivorship bias, detection bias, or observer bias.
Robustness How does the AI system handle outliers? Do overwritten decisions feed back into the system to help calibrate it in the future? Optimal
Conditions
What conditions does the model perform best under? Are there minimum requirements for the quantity of records/observations? Poor Conditions What conditions does the model perform poorly under? What are the limitations of the AI system? What kinds of errors can it make (e.g., hallucinations) and what conditions make those errors more likely?
Explanation How does the AI system explain its outputs? Are the outputs of the AI system understandable by subject matter experts, users, impacted individuals, etc.?
Data Protection List data protection frameworks you comply with (e.g., NIST 800- 53, NIST AI RMF) and certifications (e.g., SOC II, HIPAA, FERPA, CJIS).
Environmental
Impacts
This can include, but is not limited to, energy and water consumption for training and/or per use of the model, sources of energy and water for your solution, and your organization’s approach to reducing environmental impact.
For energy consumption, report in megawatt-hours (MWh).2 2 If you are unsure how to conduct energy measurements, see “A Beginner’s Guide to Power and Energy Measurement and Estimation for Computing and Machine Learning” published by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory and Intel.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
For water consumption (in thousand liters), include the type of water (i.e., drinking water or reclaimed water) used in training and deploying the model (if the on-site water usage is unknown, use "1 L/kWh" as a default value).3
4 Ongoing
Monitoring
How is the AI system monitored to identify any problems in usage? Can outputs (recommendations, predictions, etc.) be overwritten by a human, and do overwritten outputs help calibrate the system in the future?
Problems in usage can include false negatives, false positives, bias, hallucinations, and human-reported quality issues (such as poor translations or poorly generated images).
Independent
Evaluation
Have the vendors or an independent party conducted a study on the bias, accuracy, or disparate impact of the system? If yes, can the agency review the study? Include methodology and results.
This can include bias impact reports, algorithmic impact reports, or others.5
Accessibility How does your solution accommodate a variety of users, such as users with disabilities?
Responsible AI
Strategy
Please share any relevant information, links, or resources regarding your organization’s responsible AI strategy.
3 If you are unsure how to conduct water impact measurements, see “Making AI Less 'Thirsty': Uncovering and Addressing the Secret Water Footprint of AI Models” published in Communications of the ACM. 5 See “Algorithmic bias detection and mitigation: Best practices and policies to reduce consumer harms” by the Brookings Institute for an example bias impact report template.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
AI FactSheet for Third Party Service Providers
Please provide details regarding the services you provide to government organizations as they relate to artificial intelligence (AI) by filling out the AI FactSheet template below.
This template was developed by the GovAI Coalition.
This AI FactSheet is for service providers to complete. A service provider is an entity that guides, consults, advises, and supports agencies in navigating AI. A service provider may build custom AI solutions for a client, but does not sell the product as a standard solution to many customers on its own.
A developer is an entity that creates a standard software product or solution that is intended for many customers to use. These products may include AI systems built by the developer themselves, and/or a software solution that leverages third party AI tools within the product offering. If you are an AI developer, please fill out the AI FactSheet for Developers instead.
Please contact the City of Pinole IT Department at (510) 343-5540 with questions.
To submit your AI FactSheet to the GovAI Coalition’s AI Registry, please contact [email protected] and [email protected].
Vendor Name Your “Doing business as” Name and Legal Name, if different.
Contact Information Provide your website, contact email, phone number, and mailing address (optional).
Basic Information
1. Do you support the configuration or customization of third-party AI systems?
[Yes/No]
2. Do you support the implementation of third party systems that incorporate AI?
[Yes/No]
3. Do you support the technical evaluation or auditing of AI systems? [Yes/No]
4. Do you provide training for staff or residents on how to use AI? [Yes/No]
5. Are you comfortable with this information being listed on our public registry?
[Yes/No]
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Overview Provide a summary of the services you provide to government agencies.
What AI tools or systems do
you use internally to provide
your services?
• [List here (e.g., ChatGPT)]
• […]
Describe the AI tools or
systems for which you
support configuration,
customization,
implementation, evaluation,
or training.
• [List here (e.g., Azure AI Platform)]
• […]
How can customers flag
issues or concerns about
bias, discrimination, or poor
performance related to the
solutions you implement or
the services you provide?
Describe here and/or provide a link.
What regulations or other
compliance requirements are
you familiar with navigating?
• [List here (e.g., GDPR, EU AI Act, CCPA)]
• […]
Responsible AI Strategy Please share any relevant information, links, or resources regarding your organization’s responsible
AI strategy.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
AI Incident Response Plan
Introduction
The AI Incident Response Plan (IRP) serves as the first line of defense for the City of Pinole in case of an AI incident. This IRP has been created based on the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) AI Risk Management Framework6 and the Special Publication 800-61 Computer Security Incident Handling Guide7.
Incident response occurs in sequential phases, each one building upon the next. The following phases provide a foundation for an Incident Response (IR) Team to respond to and recover from an AI incident:
1. Preparation
2. Detection & Analysis
3. Containment
4. Eradication & Recovery
5. Post-incident Activity
Purpose
The purpose of this document is to prepare for and gain a fundamental understanding of the processes, responsibilities, and actions required to mitigate an AI incident. It is critical to identify and resolve incidents quickly before they escalate into a major incident with the potential to cause harm or damage to people, data, or the City of Pinole.
Scope
This IRP applies to all AI systems implemented by City of Pinole staff, contractors, and any entity operating on behalf of the City of Pinole. The AI IRP addresses continuity and recovery procedures to appropriately mitigate AI incidents.
Approach
The key points in development of the AI IRP include:
• Evaluate: Evaluate risk levels and determine the appropriate response for an AI incident, which may include obtaining senior management support. • Plan: Keep the plan simple. A well-organized, systematic, and up-to-date AI IRP that is readily available will help teams get through most situations. 6 https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework 7 https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/61/r2/final
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
• Communicate: Communicate regularly on the incident status. Provide the relevant facts as they are available, disseminate them quickly, follow up regularly, keep relevant parties informed and resolve incorrect information. • Review: Review the AI IRP at least bi-annually to ensure the documented procedures are still appropriate and that the team is equipped to respond accordingly. Ensure an after-action plan is developed and communicated, with assigned improvement opportunities.
• Test: The AI IRP should be tested with tabletop exercises at least annually. • Be flexible: The AI IRP should exhibit flexibility to meet a wide variety of situations, including modular team membership and access to the appropriate resources. External partners such as law enforcement should be involved as needed.
Definitions
The definitions in this section are based on the Responsible AI Collaborative’s AI Incident Database.8
AI Incident: An AI incident is an alleged harm or near harm event to people, property, reputation, technical integrity of the environment where an AI system is implicated, or the City of Pinole. Examples of AI incidents include an AI system providing false information, engaging in copyright infringement, generating harmful bias, AI misuses, exposing confidential or sensitive information, and posing a liability risk.
Harm: Allegations of an AI incident must be carefully scrutinized by the AI IR Team when there is a plausible argument that harm has occurred. In certain cases, this requires consultation with attorneys and executives. Types of harm include, but are not limited to:
• Harm to physical health/safety
• Psychological harm
• Financial harm
• Harm to physical property
• Harm to intangible property (e.g., IP theft, reputation damages) • Harm to social or political systems (e.g., election interference, loss of trust in authorities)
• Harm to civil liberties (e.g., unjustified imprisonment or other punishment, censorship)
8 https://incidentdatabase.ai/
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Harms do not have to be severe to meet this definition; an incident resulting in a minor, easily remedied expense or inconvenience would still be considered a harm for our purposes.
Near harm: A near harm AI incident occurs when an AI system plays an important role in a chain of events that easily could have caused harm, but some external factor kept the harm from occurring. This external factor should be independent of the AI system and should not have been put in place specifically to prevent the harm in question.
Roles & Responsibilities
AI Incident Response Team
An AI Incident Response Team is established prior to any incidents and provides a quick, effective, and orderly response to AI incidents. The AI IR Team’s mission is to address, handle, and resolve allegations of any harm caused by an AI incident.
The AI IR Team is authorized to take appropriate steps deemed necessary to contain, mitigate, or resolve an AI incident. The Team should have assigned roles and responsibilities, and a vetted incident response checklist. The Team is responsible for investigating any malfunctioning components of City of Pinole AI systems in a timely, cost-effective manner and reporting findings to management and the appropriate authorities as necessary. The AI IR Team Lead shall coordinate these investigations.
Contact Information
The AI IR Team shall include the following members:
• AI IR Team Lead: Information Technology (IT) Manager, [email protected]
• Chief Information Officer or equivalent: Communications Director, [email protected]
Other Teams as Needed
Other teams and departments shall contact, respond to, and support the AI IR Team Lead with any information relating to a suspected AI incident.
Activation Criteria
The AI IR Team Lead will determine whether the reported incident is serious enough to warrant an AI incident response. The following events responsible for causing alleged
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
harm or near harm require reporting to the AI IR Team Lead and may trigger an AI incident response:
• Declining accuracy rates; includes false positives, false negatives, true positives, and true negatives;
• Findings or suspicions of algorithmic bias;
• Failed or broken human oversight protections;
• Failure of an AI system to provide its expected outcome (i.e., system has stopped working);
• Suspected or demonstrated harm to human livelihood; or • Discovery of City of Pinole confidential data used to train any public AI model, especially in large language models or other generative AI services.
Some of these events may be connected to a broader incident that also involves cybersecurity, legal, or privacy teams. When unclear, contact both the AI IR Team Lead, the Communications Director, City Manager, and the City Attorney.
Response Level
Once an incident has been identified, the next step is to determine the level of response required based on its assessed risk and potential for harm. The City of Pinole should establish and implement a vetted risk matrix to assist with alleged AI harm. Determining the level of response is critical, as it dictates the involvement of different layers of the organization, including elected officials and internal communications teams as appropriate, as well as other external entities such as insurers, law enforcement, news media, and others. Each response level includes the following:
• Scope: An overview defining what each corresponding risk level entails. • Management Team: The departments, individuals, and stakeholders responsible for managing the resolution of the incident.
• Initial Bridge Convened: The initial communication channel(s) used to connect involved parties.
• Triggers for Escalation to the Next Level: The activation requirements to raise the risk level of an incident.
For all levels of risk, City of Pinole staff, contractors, any entity operating on behalf of the City of Pinole, residents, and external organizations may report potential AI incidents via email. The AI IR Team may use [Zoom, Microsoft Teams, and email, or appropriate tools] to resolve reports.
Level 1: Low Risk
The scope of a low-risk AI incident is relatively small, usually involving minor systems errors with limited harm or near-harm to people. Examples include reporting an AI
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
system that has a high accuracy rate but has started to output incorrect recommendations sporadically or an AI system that no longer provides a clear value to the City of Pinole. A low-risk incident does not impact any areas of human livelihood (e.g., civil rights, healthcare, employment, recreation, etc.). • Incident Management Team: AI IR Team
• Notification to: IT Manager, Department AI representative, or equivalents (if applicable)
• Initial Bridge Convened: These are routine or easily solvable incidents that do not require a bridge.
• Triggers for Escalation to the Next Level: If the impacted system impacts human livelihood, becomes increasingly inaccurate or indicates a need for sunsetting.
Level 2: Medium Risk
A medium-risk AI incident typically involves moderate levels of harm or near harm, such as those caused by periodic gaps in human oversight or frequent system errors.
Examples include an AI system that is consistently inaccurate some of the time or sporadically does not allow a human to override its output. A medium-risk incident usually impacts non-critical areas of livelihood (e.g., recreation). • Incident Management Team: AI IR Team
• Notification to: IT Manager, Communications Director, department AI representative (if applicable)
• Initial Bridge Convened: The AI IR Team Lead sends a meeting invite to all parties involved.
• Triggers for Escalation to the Next Level: If the impacted system fails to work or impacts critical areas of human livelihood.
Level 3: High Risk
A high-risk AI incident typically involves high levels of harm or near harm, such as those caused by failures in human oversight or major system errors. Examples include privacy violations, algorithmic bias and recommendations that cause harm. A high-risk incident usually includes clear evidence of suspected or demonstrated harm to critical areas of human livelihood like an individual’s civil rights, healthcare, or employment. • Incident Management Team: City Manager, AI IR Team, Police Chief, HR, Impacted Department Head, and City Attorney.
• Initial Bridge Convened: The AI IR Team Lead, or equivalent sends a meeting invite to all parties involved.
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
External Communications
Organizations may have a need to communicate with external parties throughout the course of an AI incident. External parties may include media, constituents, external subject matter experts, technology vendors, other incident response teams, and law enforcement.
Key activities to establishing an effective external communication plan include:
• Plan incident communications procedures with the City of Pinole’s Communications Department, legal, and executive teams prior to an incident occurring and understand the role of each external party. • Consult with legal and Communications Director before initiating external communications to comply with any established contractual agreements or communication protocols.
• Consider communication cadence throughout the AI incident lifecycle, rather than waiting until the incident is resolved.
• Establish the organization's communications preference: ad-hoc (e.g. human generated email), semi-automated or automated.
• Exercise caution when sharing information externally. The AI IR Team will use its discretion to publicly release information in accordance with existing City of Pinole policy.
• Determine the relevant technical information to share externally. General characteristics of the incident may be safe to publicly release, whereas information about exploited vulnerabilities may pose considerable privacy and cybersecurity risks to the City of Pinole.
Phased Approach
The AI IRP follows a phased approach in accordance with the incident response cycle from the NIST Special Publication 800-61 Computer Security Incident Handling Guide.
Each phase is discussed in more detail in the following sections.
1. Preparation
2. Detection & Analysis
3. Containment
4. Eradication & Recovery
5. Post-incident Activity
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Figure 1: Incident Response Life Cycle9
1.Preparation
The preparation phase takes place before an incident occurs. Putting more effort into preparation can help reduce the duration and difficulty of recovering from an incident.
Planning to respond to incidents involves all stakeholders with responsibilities to maintain the information system.
AI IR team members should avoid spending valuable time locating and assembling needed tools or supplies when an incident occurs by having them ready at all times.
Supplies to assist the team in the event of an incident are sometimes referred to as a “jump bag”, and should include:
• An empty notebook and writing instruments (in the event that technological systems are compromised, thorough documentation should be taken throughout an incident).
• Contact information sheet.
• At least one computing device (e.g. laptop) for any technical support needed to address an incident. This laptop should be scrubbed and all software reinstalled before it is used for another incident.
• At least one other computing device (e.g. laptop) for writing reports, reading email, and performing other duties unrelated to the hands-on incident analysis.
Having contact information available and current is essential. The City's Communication Department manages a Crisis Communications Contact List in both electronic and hard copy formats. Contact information should include:
• All members of IR team
• All contacts listed in notification
9 https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/specialpublications/nist.sp.800-61r2.pdf
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
• Personnel that might assist in handling an incident
In the event that critical systems relying on the implementation of AI become compromised, management team members are responsible for ensuring there is an alternative solution or backup system while the incident is being resolved.
Key activities during preparation include:
• Ensure incident response efforts are unified and coordinated. • Implement, document, and audit maintenance procedures for each AI system regularly to reduce the likelihood, severity, and duration of AI incidents. • Assess risk and disaster resilience to reduce the duration of AI incidents. • Follow the City’s disaster recovery plan should an AI incident require it. • Identify the potential harms of AI systems; incorporate this into the preparation processes.
• Establish a Business Continuity Plan to ensure critical infrastructure remains operational and business operations are sustained during incident response activities.
• Train responders to handle potential incidents should they arise. Assemble required tools and ensure responders know how to use them. • Conduct tabletop exercises at least annually to keep the AI IR Team and IR Plan optimized. Exercises involving simulated incidents can be beneficial in preparing the IR Team for incident handling as well as refining AI IR Plan. • Prepare and approve communications (internal, website, elected officials, and media).
Enhancing general user awareness across the City of Pinole is likely to reduce the occurrence of AI incidents. User awareness may be enhanced by the following activities:
• Create an AI awareness training program. The AI IR Team may incorporate it into the City's existing Cybersecurity and Privacy awareness training programs.
These trainings should occur at least annually.
• Ensure all users are aware of all AI and IT policies, including where current policy documents may be found.
• Share information about past AI incidents with end-users so that future occurrences may be prevented.
2. Detection & Analysis
Awareness that an AI incident has occurred can originate from different sources such as vendors, City of Pinole staff, or even residents. An AI incident shall be defined by
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
satisfying at least one of the conditions outlined in the previous section, “Activation Criteria”.
The primary outcome of the identification phase is to determine whether an event constitutes an AI incident, activate the IR plan, and begin first level notification.
When the AI IR Team Lead determines that an adverse risk exists, the AI IR Team Lead shall declare that an incident has occurred and assemble the AI IR Team to implement the IR Plan. To save all key records and begin detailed documentation, all relevant stakeholders should be involved as early as possible. This should include the City’s legal team to guide the investigation and determine the legal privilege and liability involved.
Key activities during this phase include:
• Identify, assess, and prioritize risks.
• Ensure the capacity for timely communications in support of situational awareness and operations during an AI incident.
• Provide all decision makers with decision-relevant information regarding the nature and extent of the AI incident, any cascading effects, and the status of the response.
As soon as the AI IR Team suspects that an incident has occurred, it is important to immediately start gathering all the relevant data, including the system’s AI FactSheet.
The repository for all AI incident data is called Artificial Intelligence Incident Report System (AIIRS), or equivalent and it is located in the IT server with access privilege only to the AI IR Team. Each incident is carefully documented and all related artifacts are kept for future reference.
3. Containment
After an AI incident has been identified, it is imperative to limit damage from the incident and isolate the affected components of the AI systems to prevent further damage.
Depending on the type of incident, the overall strategy for containment may vary.
Factors that help determine the containment strategy include:
• Potential damage to City of Pinole services
• Need for evidence preservation
• Service availability
• Time and resources needed to implement the strategy
• Effectiveness of the strategy (e.g., partially contains the incident, fully contains the incident)
• Duration of the solution (e.g., emergency workaround to be removed in four hours, temporary workaround to be removed in two weeks, permanent solution)
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
Evidence handling must be considered when resolving an incident. This will help in legal proceedings. In such cases, it is important to clearly document how all evidence has been preserved. In addition, evidence must be accounted at all times; whenever evidence is transferred from person to person, chain of custody documentation should detail the transaction and include each party’s signature. A detailed log should be kept for all evidence including, but not limited to, the following:
• Identifying information (location, serial number, model number, hostname, media access control (MAC) address, and IP address of a computer) • Name, title, phone number of each individual who collected or handled the evidence during the investigation
• Time and date of each occurrence of evidence handling • Locations where evidence was stored
4. Eradication & Recovery
Identify the AI incident's root cause through a detailed forensic analysis and pause the usage of affected systems. Once the threat has been contained and the initial cause has been determined, second level notification can take place.
Key activities during eradication include:
• Prioritize the stabilization of critical infrastructure functions. • Document everything, including the identified root cause of the incident. • Implement any necessary safeguards to prevent the same kind of AI incident from occurring again.
Key activities to restore affected systems according to the configurations outlined in the AI FactSheet include:
• Verify affected systems meet their original objective. • Test, validate, and approve affected systems before bringing them back into production in accordance with the City of Pinole's change management procedures.
• Allow affected systems back into use and ensure no problem remains.
5. Post-incident Activity
Document the incident and analyze how it happened so staff can learn from it and improve future response efforts. Once documentation is complete, communicate the lessons learned to relevant stakeholders involved with the incident.
Items to review include:
City of Pinole By: City Manager
Administrative Policy Approved: TBD
DRAFT
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) POLICIES
• Consider whether an additional policy could have prevented the incident. • Consider whether a procedure or policy was not followed, and then consider what could be changed to ensure that the procedure or policy is followed in the future.
• Was the incident response appropriate? How could it be improved? • Was every appropriate party informed in a timely manner? • Were the incident-response procedures detailed and did they cover the entire situation? How can they be improved?
• Have changes been made to prevent a new and similar incident? • Should any policies or procedures be updated?
• What lessons have been learned from this experience?
• Create a follow-up action plan with due dates and assignments. • What additional tools or resources are needed to detect, analyze, and mitigate future incidents?
Revised 7/20/26
Summary of the City of Pinole’s Draft Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy The City of Pinole uses Artificial Intelligence (AI) to help employees work more efficiently and serve the community.
Because AI can be helpful but also unpredictable, the City has rules to make sure it’s used safely, responsibly, and fairly.
AI can make mistakes, show bias, or misunderstand information. The policy was written to protect the public, City employees, and City information by setting clear expectations.
Key Principles Employees and Vendors Must Follow
Put people first: AI should help residents, not harm or confuse them. AI should not replace employees.
Protect privacy: Employees must not enter private or sensitive information into AI tools.
Check for accuracy: AI can be wrong or produce made‑up information (“hallucinations”), so users must double‑check everything.
Be transparent: If AI helped create something, employees must say so.
Be fair: AI can reflect harmful biases, so workers must watch for unfair language or results.
Stay accountable: Humans—not AI—are responsible for the final work product.
Use AI responsibly: Only trained staff may use approved tools and must follow all rules.
Serve the public: AI must always be used in ways that help the community.
What the City Requires:
• Employees may only use AI tools that have
been reviewed and approved by the IT Division.
• Employees must assess risks before entering
information into an AI system.
• Vendors must follow City rules when providing
AI-related services.
• If something goes wrong or AI causes harm,
staff must report it immediately.
• Employees must take yearly AI training.
Things AI Is Not Allowed to Do:
To protect people, the City prohibits certain uses of AI, including:
• Real‑time or secret facial recognition
• Trying to read emotions from people’s faces or
body language
• Major decisions made entirely by AI without
human involvement
• Ranking people based on behavior or personal
traits (“social scoring”)
• Manipulating or tricking people
• Creating AI‑generated images of real people for
City use
Approved AI Tools
The City currently utilizes pre-approved AI tools and platforms such as Adobe, Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365, ArcGIS, Canva, Claude, RingCentral, Public Input, Ubiquiti, Peach Safety, OneTera, Symbium, and Zoom.
Consequences
Employees must follow the City’s adopted AI Policy. Violating the Policy can result in disciplinary action, up to and including termination, and serious violations may be reported to law enforcement.
Artificial Intelligence Policy
Project Engagement
VIEWS
1,405
PARTICIPANTS
74 RESPONSES
790
COMMENTS
87 SUBSCRIBERS
1 All participants
Share your comments, ideas or questions about the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy Draft. d All participants All Time
9 Agree 5/19/2026
7 Agree 5/19/2026
6 Agree 5/24/2026
6 Agree 5/22/2026
4 Agree 6/21/2026
1) what uses are AI proposed for? List some allowed uses and some disallowed uses. Like “use to summarize public-survey data” and “Disallow use in law enforcement.” 2) environmental impact assessment needs more depth. Don’t allow default answers like described. 3) impact of the AI on jobs and employment should be assessed and transparent. 4) public should be allowed an opt-out process to avoid using AI systems when accessing city services. 5) equity of AI solutions needs to be monitored explicitly with metrics for racist or classist outcomes. 6) review of AI summarized or generated materials should be confirmed by transparent sign-off process by an actual employee of the City. At what percentage of generated material is review and sign off required? I’d say any use should trigger review. Theoretically documents and deliverables are already reviewed anyway. 7) agree with another post that 20% AI-generated content is “substantial.” 50% is way too high.
Don't use it at all, thanks
Anything using AI to assist with anything the city does needs to be labeled as such! When I call I want a person, not an AI answering. Not a fan of AI Please, just don't.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 1/21
4 Agree 6/19/2026
4 Agree 6/11/2026
4 Agree 5/24/2026
4 Agree 5/14/2026
5/22/2026 3 Agree
5/14/2026
3 Agree 7/25/2026
3 Agree 7/7/2026
3 Agree 6/22/2026
What's not working in Pinole that would be solved by getting AI involved? Or is it just a shiny object that's mesmerizing us? I read the City of Pinole AI Policy DRAFT.
I can't find ANYTHING in it regarding what exactly it will be used for. Only what to do when it messes up. Really? I vote NO.
ABSOLUTELY NO!
If the people employed in our local government can no longer perform their duties without the assistance of an untested software that uses more energy and water than small cities, maybe we shouldn’t be using our tax dollars to pay those individuals. If there’s backlog or delays we think AI could fix, I’d rather pay a human person’s salary who will contribute to our community and pour that income back into our surrounding businesses.
When AI is used to assist the city with approved programs - ensure every usage is noted somewhere as AI or AI assisted and what percentage of the work was AI!
I’m still waiting for an exact date when AI Began being utilized in police services , police reports with actual dates of initiatioand when did AI become implemented police vehicles ? This should be public record, not just information provided to Debbie.
Hi Debbie, thank you for your questions. Someone will reach out to you soon with the answer.
DO NOT waste public funds on this when the basics are still not addressed. Adoption of this causes one to believe someone is making money on the back end. This city has urgent needs such as road repair - which is getting worse by the day. AI is still in the early stages. Even corporate entities are backing down. When you hear that corporations had to rehire people to fill the jobs that AI took over because AI made too many errors - my response is a solid NO. I will follow the city council votes and those who vote for this I will help fund the opposition candidates during the next election. Too much money went to what some would call "feel good" or "we should" policies which I am agreeable for ONLY when our basic needs are handled.
no ai
Change the whole thing to say: City of Pinole will not use AI for anything. 10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 2/21
3 Agree 5/19/2026
2 Agree 6/6/2026
2 Agree 6/5/2026
2 Agree 6/5/2026
2 Agree 5/20/2026
2 Agree 5/9/2026
1 Agree 7/28/2026
1 Agree 7/11/2026
There should be published "guard rails" and HIL (Human in the loop) testing results for anything AI generated. Also, governance to protect from self-harm.
Take care of fixing streets they are despirstely needing repairs It's great to see that a policy is being developed to ensure Generative AI is used properly. However, using it to "generate[s] accurate narratives based on information from law enforcement officers", as Peach Safety says on their website, seems dangerous. Wouldn't a better alternative be to utilize the funds to provide training for officers on improving report writing, as opposed to paying for Peach Safety, or something similar? Having guardrails are great to protect the city but not everyone will follow them.
If Chatgpt is on the prohibited list, it should not be referenced in the examples on the subsequent pages.
The list of available models seems limited and needs to be acknowledged as a fluid list since new models are continually being created and enhanced.
If you don't adopt it.. you don't have to enforce it...
The policy "Cite Generative AI when substantial content is used ( >50%)" should define substantial content as >20%.
Anything over 20% is equivalent to more than one of the 5 Pinole City Council members. I don't think something that is 49% AI should be considered on the same basis as something that is 100% human generated.
Reading level: when using AI to draft documents for release to the public, what reading level should the final product be, as not all Pinole Residents are fluent readers?
Translation: if AI is used for translation of official documents or notices, will there be a human checking to ensure the translations are accurate?
Customer Service: if AI is used as a Customer Service tool, e.g., answering questions, will there be an easy method to bypass AI and talk to a human? "Chatting" with AI can be very frustrating, particularly for those who are not computer literate or who have difficulty articulating questions clearly enough to get a correct answer.
Not all generative AI platforms are created equally - though all are likely created using stolen data. Some (few) have been created with privacy and environmental costs as a consideration. How will City of Pinole vet appropriate platforms to ensure that data is not coopted to train new AI models/to minimize environmental impacts? How can the City of Pinole create an evaluation system where generative AI is truly used as a value-add rather than a short cut/as a default? 10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 3/21
10/1/2026
9/30/2026
9/30/2026
9/30/2026
9/30/2026
9/30/2026
9/24/2026
9/5/2026
The policy should be simple. NO generative AI AT ALL, and no surveillance AI AT ALL. These companies cannot be trusted with our data and generative AI threatens the livelihoods of artists and so many others. i will not use AI in any way shape or form. it is not correct, it will make mistakes and will take a HUMAN to correct the issue. it will also take away jobs and could cost us money in the long run.
I do not believe AI has a place in administrative settings, especially when using AI will result in lack of requirement for staff to use independent thought, if they are gaining recognition for an idea when they did not actually have the original thought, or any setting where human calculation, interaction, empathy, and job security are on the line. Use of these tools remove the skills required to soulfully execute customer service and may cause undue merit to someone who knows how to look something up better than someone who actually has more skill at completing a task. It is lazy and one step closer to making our jobs obsolete; I do not approve.
I second the comment to give examples of allowed uses and restricted uses.
Would like to add that all AI created works - including emails that have been “polished” be labeled as using AI tools.
I think an AI powered robot could do a tremendously better job fixing the public road on our cul de sac (Neva Ct) than the humans you sent who did the worst job I’ve ever seen.
AI is ruining our state and our planet. We already struggle with severe droughts in California and now you want to use something unnecessary that uses massive amounts of our water instead of keeping it safe for living beings!?! These billionaires don’t care about us, but I’d hope our elected officials would, wishful thinking, I know. Protect the people, protect the animals, protect our planet!! STOP USING AI!! For Closed Captioning requirements, AI has moved these changes to a reachable service that we now provide.
Reading comments below I can see many people are not well informed by AI. AI can mean many different things and is highly contextual. AI is not going away; it's becoming more embedded in our lives.
I commend the City of Pinole for their forward thinking in creating AI governance plan. Keep the conversation going and provide opportunities for residents continue to learn about AI, how the City of Pinole will use it to create operational efficiencies and learn about true AI governance.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 4/21
8/15/2026
7/25/2026
7/25/2026
7/24/2026
If AI can "produce made-up information" and "reflect harmful biases," thus, requiring employees to watch for and double-check their work, does this not just make more work/waste time for employees? Would it not be better for employees to just do the work themselves and spend the time they would be using to "double-check" everything to instead get other things done? Employees also having to "assess risks," report when the AI does something wrong or "causes harm," and take "yearly AI training" just seems like more trouble than it's worth. So much of the draft consists of what flaws AI has, the risks in using AI, and what to do if something goes wrong. It really doesn't give much confidence in its reliability or safety.
As someone else in the comments said "If you don't adopt it...you don't have to enforce it..."! If you're so aware of just how flawed AI is, then simply do not adopt it. It was only a few years ago when generative AI wasn't a thing, and everyone was able to handle things on their own just fine!
The policy seems like a reasonable start. However since it is a general policy based on the GovAI coalition template, it is hard to make specific comments without knowing where exactly the City will be utilizing more AI. There are some parts that could use further thought:
- "> 50% content" is unclear. The policy should be more specific when AI tooling is used for editing (eg. proofreading content) vs. generation (eg. drafting 30% of a public policy). The latter is more concerning when humans are out of the loop.
- "You assume the risk when using unapproved tools." Seems odd. Unapproved tools should NOT be used. It's also inconsistent where a couple of boxes up it says to "do not use .. unapproved tools" - "Microsoft Copilot" is vague as this can refer to tools within the Office365 suite as well as general chat models which may include Anthropic, OpenAI, etc. The document also calls out "ChatGPT" as unapproved. But in this context it is not clear whether that also means OpenAI models via other tooling or specifically the ChatGPT web app (and implicitly allowing others like Claude, Gemini, etc).
- The phrase "If you wouldn’t share the information in a public forum, don’t share it with a Generative AI" is a good benchmark for privacy protection
In general, I would favor use cases where AI tooling improves efficiency and the quality of City operations while maintaining human in the loop decisions. Having AI (particularly generative AI) make decisions should be a red line Nope
Your recent little surveys have also been about cannabis and do we need more vegan restaurants in Pinole, yet you still do not have a plan for fixing the poor roads in Pinole especially Pinole Valley Road. You need to get real about the needs of this city.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 5/21
7/10/2026
6/19/2026
Under Privacy & Security your policy does not state how the city will ensure that the AI vendor does not use city provided data for their training or modeling
Under the Equity policy it states "Staff should review the output for word choice, tone, and partiality or unfairness towards specific demographics.". Which specific demographics is this referring to, and why would they get separate treatment? Should it not be applicable to all residents? Strike the word "towards specific demographics" Under Risk of adverse impact policy it states "Consider potential adverse impacts to people of a certain race, age, gender identity, or disability status." It does not define what these "certain race, age, gender identity, or disability status" are or why they would need separate treatment. This could be a violation of the Equal Protection Act, by providing unequal treatment based on immutable characteristics.
Under Transparency regarding "citing AI" it should also include citing the sources AI uses to provide it's response. An AI system might use an incorrect source to generate a response, and unless the source for the response is known, then sating "citing AI" provides no way to verify.
Your list of AI tools does not include any of the integrated AI "helpers" that are now part of search engines (not including Copilot), nor does it include any of the commercial AI services (OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI). It also does not include any AI uses for code generation or web page generation
Your document does not determine how costs will be distributed across departments, nor does it place limits on AI usage based on cost or token usage. AI use can become very expensive and hidden costs can build up quickly causing unexpected expenses.
The document does not cover Agentic AI (https://www.ibm.com/think/insights/agentic-ai#2095054955) Yes, in a productive and responsible way.
This is the future and our city should be inline where possible. 10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 6/21
6/18/2026
6/15/2026
6/7/2026
6/18/2026
6/5/2026
6/3/2026
1. Someone should be hired by the City of Pinole to lead AI in Pinole. This could potentially be a part-time or contract position, but since AI is changing so rapidly and AI use by the City of Pinole will increase, I strongly recommend hiring for this position. This position would not simply be for AI incidents or to finalize the AI Policy, but also to strategize about AI Policy in the future and Pinole's relationship with AI in the future.
2. Whatever policy Pinole adopts should mirror the regional, county, and state policies so that that there is consistency and alignment. (I am less concerned about lining up with the federal government.)
3. The ideal situation would be to house critical, sensitive information (not individual's but City data) within a secure, AI system. It would be worth looking at Open AI and Anthropic and other leading AI companies to accomplish this. Although the risks are higher, the benefits in terms of searching and using the City's own data is huge. (By the way, this is the approach that law firms are using. They have to safeguard their clients' information and data, but they need to find a way to be able to use AI on that data.)
4. There should be trainings and vendor reviews much more often, I would say every three months, because the AI world is changing fast.
5. One of the areas where Pinole could take the lead is by requiring that any data centers that power the City's AI is from an environmentally-friendly source. There are no data centers that are environmentally-friendly at scale, but there are some individual data centers that have zero environmental impact and that should be our model.
When did it start being used for police reports and in vehicles ? Was AI used to develop the AI policy model!
I was thinking about this also.
dont like AI , it great for security, however take jobs away Supportive of this policy draft.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 7/21
5/22/2026
5/22/2026
5/9/2026
5/9/2026
AI is a VERY useful tool. With the city’s budget concerns, using AI as a tool to increase efficiency is a must. Please use it in as many ways as possible, so long as a person reviews the final product to ensure it is appropriate.
Many of these proposed practices and prohibitions will limit the use, or decrease the efficiency of its use. Remove these limiting factors so the use of AI by our city increases efficiency.
The proposed practices and prohibitions are NECESSARY to ensure that AI use does not create more problems than it solves.
I just submitted a comment, and something (probably AI) put the words "Not entering raffle, thanks" in front of what I wrote.
Check for state or county policy and check if Orinda or Lafayette are doing this before wasting even more of our small city resources.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 8/21
The diagram above shows the top six recurring trends found in survey comments. The numbers represent the total number of comments tagged with the trending topic.
In your opinion, rank the City's Guiding Principles in order from most important to least important. 20 Respondents
In general, how comfortable are you with AI technology? 47 respondents 47 d t
49% Not comfortable
32% Somewhat comfortable
11% Extremely comfortable
6% Very comfortable
2% I'm not sure
18 ✔ 90%
18 ✔ 90%
19 ✔ 95%
17 ✔ 85%
18 ✔ 90%
19 ✔ 95%
17 ✔ 85%
16 ✔ 80%
17 ✔ 85%
Rank: 2.56
Rank: 3.44
Rank: 4.05
Rank: 4.41
Rank: 4.44
Rank: 4.89
Rank: 6.35
Rank: 6.56
Rank: 7.29
Privacy and Security
Accuracy
Responsible Use
Transparency
Accountability
Human-Centered Design
Equity
Public Purpose
Workforce Empowerment
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 9/21
What area(s)do you have concern with regards to AI technology? 47 Respondents
25 ✔ 53%
25 ✔ 53%
21 ✔ 45%
21 ✔ 45%
21 ✔ 45%
21 ✔ 45%
20 ✔ 43%
16 ✔ 34%
9 ✔ 19%
4 ✔ 9%
1 ✔ 2%
Privacy / security
Ethics / societal impacts
Data (i.e. input/output, data training models)
Bias / Equity
Environmental Impacts
Transparency
All of the above
Labor / workforce
Accessibility
Other
None of the above
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 10/21
Below you'll find use cases in which other cities have applied AI technology. In Pinole, what type(s) of City services do you think are appropriate use cases that can be improved or enhanced with AI technology?
41 Respondents
16 ✔ 39%
12 ✔ 29%
12 ✔ 29%
11 ✔ 27%
11 ✔ 27%
11 ✔ 27%
9 ✔ 22%
8 ✔ 20%
7 ✔ 17%
7 ✔ 17%
Records Management
License / Permit Applications
Traffic Safety
Communications
Streets / Roads Maintenance
Other
Customer Service
Sewer / Wastewater Management
Public Safety
Parks and Recreation
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 11/21
Do you want the City to offer additional opportunities for public engagement on the topic of AI usage in the City of Pinole?
46 respondents 46 d t
70% Yes
22% No
9% I don't know / I don't care
5 Agree 5/20/2026
4 Agree 6/21/2026
4 Agree 5/24/2026
3 Agree 6/22/2026
3 Agree 6/22/2026
I'm 74 years old... I don't want our city using AI until many many more bugs are worked out. We DO NOT need to be an early adopter.. this is one that we should be a follower and let others make the mistakes that we should learn from. DON'T waste our precious tax dollars... FOCUS on what's important in our community... basic street services.. the BIG elephant in the room with our sewer system...
Simply do not use it.
Let the cities residents know when you are considering AI use and allow a comment period and interpret the climate of how the citizens of Pinole feel about proposed application. Remember you work for and should be concerned for the citizens of Pinole. Treat any monies as they are your own and must be accounted for and balance - don't write checks the City of Pinole can't afford and don't do frivolous things with it! We need additional opportunities to talk some sense into whoever thinks this nonsense is a good idea.
Stop this nonsense. The solutions to our problems are in our hands. They are our hands. Adding a hallucination machine doesn’t help anything and sets a disastrous precedent that using this garbage is normal and works at all. It doesn’t, it won’t, if it did it would be bad.
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 12/21
3 Agree 5/9/2026
2 Agree 5/19/2026
1 Agree 9/19/2026
1 Agree 6/18/2026
6/22/2026 3 Agree
1 Agree 6/5/2026
1 Agree 5/9/2026
10/1/2026
9/30/2026
9/18/2026
Public engagement should be more than the 3 minute limit at council meetings. Recommend workshop with staff.
There are some Pinole Citizens like myself that actually works with AI. We know about the dangers, efforts to regulate, and do proper "AI governance." Have an open forum where we can raise concerns. Provide some feedback by those who are currently working in the industry.
Please make balancing the budget and fixing the roads your first priority. Once Pinole is a thriving city again, we can have the AI discussion.
AI is here whether we like it or not. We need to choose the AI we want - the biggest opportunity I see is in making it environmentally-friendly and providing the residents of Pinole with improvements across the board. I would like to see Pinole be cutting edge - it would attract more technology and creative workers and companies to our city! We don’t like it, and we don’t have to use it.
100% agree that we should not strive to be early adopters. Why the rush? Public engagement should mean more than the 3 minute limit at council meetings. A workshop with staff is best.
Honestly, we just want the answer to be a firm NO AI policy.
I DON'T THINK AI SHOULD HAVE A PLACE IN CITY HALL AND SHOULD BE ABOLISHED.
AI, especially under our current economic system that prioritizes making a profit over serving the people. It will only be used to displace the workforce, as we see at major tech firms, for the sake of efficiency, they say, but then CEOs will continue to make millions while workers are displaced in a horrendous job market, with other companies doing the same thing. AI can also, I believe, stunt the intellectual development of the species, as if we are going to outsource our thinking to machines instead of cultivating our own thoughts. How can we as a species hope to get better? Though I would like it if AI could help amplify our abilities, in our time now it's more of a hindrance and danger. Major tech CEO's worried about the harm of AI, the class of people who would benefit from AI are scared. So we need to stop and consider the effects AI will have on our society and put heavy regulations, or else it will be too late. 10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 13/21
9/5/2026
8/15/2026
8/15/2026
6/7/2026
6/5/2026
6/3/2026
Slow and measured adoption of AI is reasonable. It's not an all or nothing endeavor. AI is here, it's growing, and it's valuable in many ways. There's a lot of public banter that focus on a narrow portion of the AI conversation. I'm 56 years old and have dedicated personal time to learning more and understanding the topic. There are tools, resources and guidance on how to be discerning when using AI. In my opinion telling the City of Pinole "don't use AI" is like saying "no more internet." Be a part of the conversation - but be clear about what you "don't like about AI" and help shape the way it is used or not used.
OK, that was scary!!! I just finished the questions on the personal data survey. I did not have to select ANY answers because AI already knew all the answers about who I am and everything about my life. Age, marital status, income, etc, etc, etc... Made me very uncomfortable!!
Yes, we should all have an opportunity in deciding how AI will be used in Pinole. Privacy and Safety should be a #1 priority.
AI policies are going to have to adapt at lightening speed. If Pinole seeks community input every time the policy needs to be adapted, the City will fall behind very quickly.
100% agree that we should be strive to be early adopters. Why the rush? This is not a top concern for me. There are other topics which I would prefer deeper community engagement on.
Manually Connected Social Posts
No data to display...
10/1/2026
10/1/2026
I do not like AI and will not accept nor support it. It takes away jobs and cannot think faster than a human . If it makes a mistake it takes a human to correct it. Not good on all counts.
Would love to know in what capacity and the frequency of usage for the following programs are, in the interest of transparency: Adobe, Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365,
ArcGIS, Canva, Claude, RingCentral, Public Input, Ubiquiti, and Peach Safety. Listing them is great but if townspeople don’t know what it’s being used for then this is useless information. 10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 14/21
All participants
What is your age?
26 respondents
All participants All Time
26 d t
27% 45-54
19% 35-44
15% 55-64
15% 65-74
8% 15-24
8% 75-84
4% 25-34
4% Prefer not to answer
0% 85 or over
All participants
What is your gender?
25 respondents
All participants All Time
25 d t
48% Female
40% Male
8% Prefer not to answer
4% Transgender
0% Do not identify as male, female, or transgender
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 15/21
All participants
What is your race/ethnicity?
25 respondents
All participants All Time
25 d t
52% White
16% Asian
8% Black or African-American
8% Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish
8% Prefer not to answer
4% Some other race alone
4% Two or more races
0% Others
All participants
National Origin:
26 respondents
All participants All Time
26 d t
96% United States
4% Europe
0% Others
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 16/21
All participants
What is your highest formal education level?
25 respondents
All participants All Time
25 d t
36% Graduate or Professional Degree
24% Bachelor's Degree
20% Some College
8% Associate's Degree
8% Prefer not to answer
4% High School/GED
0% None
All participants
What is your marital status?
25 respondents
All participants All Time
25 d t
52% Married or Domestic Partnership
24% Never Married
16% I prefer not to answer
4% Divorced
4% Widowed
0% Separated
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 17/21
All participants
Total household income:
24 respondents
All participants All Time
24 d t
29% $68,501-$109,600
29% $150,700 or greater
17% Prefer not to answer
13% $109,601-$150,700
8% Less than $41,100
4% $41,101-$68,500
All participants
Do you have a disability?
24 respondents
All participants All Time
24 d t
79% No
13% Yes
8% Prefer not to answer
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 18/21
All participants
Are you a resident of Pinole?
25 respondents
All participants All Time
25 d t
88% Yes
12% No
All participants
How many people do you have in your household, including yourself? 22 respondents
All participants All Time
22 d t
32% 2
27% 3
27% 4
14% 1
0% Others
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 19/21
Loading more report objects...
All participants
What is your employment status?
23 respondents
All participants All Time
23 d t
52% Employed
30% Retired
9% Unemployed
9% Prefer not to answer
All participants
What is your housing situation?
23 respondents
All participants All Time
23 d t
78% I own my home
13% I rent my home
9% Prefer not to answer
0% I am unhoused
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 20/21
10/6/26, 5:19 PM City of Pinole, CA - Report Creation
https://publicinput.com/report?id=52858 21/21
Department
submits
use case to IT
IT ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) RISK ASSESSMENT FLOWCHART Is AI use allowed
under City policy?
See Prohibited Uses
NO
Reject / Revise
the request
YES
Assign Roles
(IT Lead, Dept. Owner,
Data Steward)
Initial Risk Level Assigned:
LOW / MODERATE / HIGH
STEP 1: GOVERN STEP 2: map
Define Use Case
What problem is being
solved?
Who benefits?
Identify Data
Sources
Internal / External /
Vendor
Identify Risks, i.e.
Bias
Privacy
Security
Accuracy
Public impact
Data
management
Document
Stakeholders
STEP 3: measure
Test System
Accuracy, reliability
Evaluate
Risks, i.e.
Bias
Privacy
Security
Does system meet
acceptable
thresholds?
NO
Revise / Retest
or Escalate
YES
Proceed with
deployment and
monitoring
Deploy with Controls
Human oversight,
limited access
Monitor
Performance
Logs, errors,
feedback
Incident or
issue detected?
YES
Escalate,
mitigate,
document
NO
Move to
management
phase
STEP 4: manage
Still meets City
standards?
YES
Continue monitoring
loop
END (ongoing
operations)
NO
Modify / Sunset
the system
CITY COUNCIL
REPORT 9.D.
DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2026
TO: MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: Lilly Whalen, Community Development Director, 510-724-9832, [email protected]
SUBJECT: ADOPTION OF A RESOLUTION UPHOLDING THE APPEAL AND GRANTING AN 18-MONTH EXTENSION OF ENTITLEMENTS (CUP 23-05 & DR 23-12) FOR PINOLE SHORES II – 836–848 SAN PABLO AVENUE
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the City Council adopt the attached Resolution (Attachment A):
• Upholding the appeal and reversing the Planning Commission’s August 10, 2026 denial; and • Granting an 18-month extension of entitlements for CUP 23-05 and DR 23-12, resulting in a new expiration date of May 3, 2028.
BACKGROUND
On October 20, 2026, the City Council deliberated de novo on the appeal of the Planning Commission’s August 10, 2026 denial of an entitlement extension for the Pinole Shores II project. The Council directed staff to prepare a resolution upholding the appeal and granting an 18-month extension beginning November 3, 2026.
All project background, entitlement history, and detailed analysis were included in the September 15 and October 20 staff reports and are incorporated here by reference.
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
Consistent with the City Council’s direction on October 20, 2026, the attached resolution grants a final 18-month extension of CUP 23-05 and DR 23-12. The new expiration date is May 3, 2028.
FISCAL IMPACT
There is no direct fiscal impact associated with approval of the extension. Processing costs are covered by applicant fees.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PINOLE UPHOLDING THE APPEAL AND GRANTING AN 18‑MONTH EXTENSION OF ENTITLEMENTS FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 23‑05 AND DESIGN REVIEW 23‑12 (PINOLE SHORES II), LOCATED AT 836–848 SAN PABLO AVENUE
WHEREAS, on December 20, 2021, the Applicant submitted an initial design review and parcel map application for redevelopment of the Pinole Shores II property; and
WHEREAS, on May 8, 2023, the Planning Commission approved design review and parcel map entitlements for a two‑building configuration; and WHEREAS, on November 14, 2023, the Applicant submitted a revised application proposing a single light‑industrial/wholesale distribution building; and WHEREAS, on June 10, 2024, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution 24‑02 approving Conditional Use Permit 23‑05, Design Review 23‑12, and the associated Parcel Map, establishing an entitlement expiration date of June 10, 2026; and WHEREAS, on May 8, 2026, the Applicant submitted a timely request for an extension of entitlements consistent with the requirements of Pinole Municipal Code (PMC) Section 17.10.100; and
WHEREAS, on August 10, 2026, the Planning Commission considered the request and denied the extension through adoption of Resolution 26‑08; and WHEREAS, on August 19, 2026, the Applicant filed a timely appeal of the Planning Commission’s decision; and
WHEREAS, on September 15, 2026, the City Council conducted a duly noticed de novo public hearing on the appeal, took testimony, closed the public hearing, and continued deliberations to October 20, 2026; and
WHEREAS, on October 20, 2026, the City Council deliberated on the matter and directed staff to prepare a resolution upholding the appeal and granting an 18‑month extension beginning November 3, 2026; and
WHEREAS, the City Council finds that the original findings supporting CUP 23‑05 and DR 23‑12 remain valid, that no changed circumstances prevent the ability to make such findings, and that the requirements for an entitlement extension under PMC Section
17.10.100 are satisfied.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Pinole hereby upholds the appeal of the Planning Commission’s denial and grants an eighteen‑month extension of Conditional Use Permit 23‑05 and Design Review 23‑12, with the extension commencing November 3, 2026 and expiring May 3, 2028.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this extension shall constitute the final extension of these entitlements pursuant to PMC Section 17.10.100.
PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Pinole held on the 3rd day of November, 2026, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS:
I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed, and adopted on the 3rd day of November, 2026.
___________________________________
Heather Bell-Spears, CMC
City Clerk
CITY COUNCIL
REPORT 10.A.
DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2026
TO: MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: Lilly Whalen, Community Development Director, 510-724-9832, [email protected]
Kapil Amin, Sustainability Project Manager, N/A, [email protected] SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING AND APPROVAL OF ENERGY SERVICES CONTRACT FOR INSTALLATION OF LED LIGHTING UPGRADES AT CITY HALL (2131 PEAR ST./APN: 401163004) AND PINOLE PUBLIC SAFETY BUILDING (880 TENNENT AVE/APN: 401164003), AND AUTHORIZATION FOR CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the City Council:
1. Conduct a Public Hearing pursuant to Government Code Section 4217 to consider the proposed energy services contract.
2. Adopt a Resolution (Attachment A):
o Approving a single-source Energy Services Contract with EcoGreen Solutions LLC to install LED lighting upgrades at City Hall and the Public Safety Building. o Authorizing the City Manager to execute the Contract (Attachment C) and all related documents necessary to carry out the work.
A companion staff report under a separate public hearing item addresses financing for this project under PG&E’s On-Bill Financing (OBF) Program.
BACKGROUND
In 2025, EcoGreen Solutions LLC conducted a no-cost energy assessment of municipal facilities and identified cost-effective opportunities to reduce energy consumption, including LED lighting retrofits (Attachment B). Staff has worked with EcoGreen to develop a project scope for City Hall and the Public Safety Building, which share an electrical meter and present the highest concentration of lighting-related savings.
This item requests approval of the Energy Services Contract that defines the construction scope, equipment, warranties, and delivery approach for the LED retrofit project. The related financing instrument—PG&E’s zero-interest On-Bill Financing (OBF)—is addressed under a separate staff report to maintain compliance with Government Code Section 4217 and to clearly distinguish contract approval from financing approval.
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
EcoGreen Solutions LLC
EcoGreen Solutions LLC is an energy-efficiency services provider specializing in turnkey lighting and building-performance upgrades for public agencies, educational institutions, and commercial facilities. The firm provides no-cost energy audits, project scoping, lighting design, installation services, and utility-incentive support. EcoGreen delivers full turnkey project management, including material procurement, engineering, labor, warranty administration, and assistance with zero-interest utility financing programs. The company has extensive experience supporting municipalities in reducing operating costs, modernizing facility infrastructure, and implementing long-life, low-maintenance LED technologies.
PG&E On Bill Financing
PG&E’s OBF program provides 0% interest, no-fee loans to qualifying public agencies for the installation of energy-efficiency improvements such as LED lighting, HVAC upgrades, and controls. Under OBF, the project loan is repaid directly through the agency’s monthly PG&E utility bill. Payments are structured to be offset by the energy savings generated from the installed improvements, enabling agencies to implement upgrades with no upfront capital cost and maintain a budget-neutral or cost-positive fiscal impact. The program is widely used by California cities, counties, and school districts to accelerate energy-efficiency projects and reduce operational costs while preserving General Fund resources.
Government Code Section 4217
Government Code Sections 4217.10–4217.18 allow public agencies to enter into energy services contracts without competitive bidding when the governing body determines, following a public hearing, that the cost of the proposed energy improvements is less than the anticipated energy cost savings. This statutory pathway enables agencies to implement efficiency upgrades—such as the LED lighting retrofits proposed here—expeditiously and cost-effectively when doing so serves the public interest.
To approve the contract, the City Council must make findings that:
• anticipated energy savings exceed project costs;
• the contract is in the City’s best interest; and
• single-source procurement is justified based on cost, timing, or technical considerations.
This staff report provides the basis for those findings.
Project Description
The project upgrades outdated fluorescent and incandescent fixtures with high-efficiency LED lighting at City Hall and the Public Safety Building. The scope also includes installation of occupancy sensors where appropriate to further reduce energy use. EcoGreen will provide all materials, labor, and project management, along with a 5-year parts warranty and 1-year labor warranty.
Energy Savings and Financial Performance
• Estimated monthly electricity cost savings: $1,663.71 • Estimated simple payback: 9.72 years
• Net savings: positive from Year 1
The projected energy cost savings exceed the cost of the improvements, satisfying the core requirement of Government Code §4217 for approving an energy services contract.
Environmental & Operational Benefits
• Reduced electricity consumption and greenhouse gas emissions • Lower long-term maintenance costs due to long-life LED technologies • Enhanced visibility and lighting quality in City facilities • Supports the City’s long-term energy-efficiency and building modernization goals Relationship to Financing
This agenda item seeks approval of the Energy Services Contract only. A separate companion item under public hearing items presents the PG&E On-Bill Financing (OBF) structure for Council consideration. No financing approval is requested through this staff report.
Consistency with the Climate Action & Adaptation Plan (CAAP) The LED Lighting Retrofit Project is consistent with several municipal energy and decarbonization measures adopted in the City’s CAAP:
• CIO-1 – Municipal Building Decarbonization: LED retrofits reduce facility energy demand and serve as a foundational step toward achieving the City’s 2035 decarbonization goals.
• BE-4 & CIO-1f – Transition to 100% Renewable Electricity: Reducing electricity consumption enhances the emissions reductions achieved through the City’s switch to MCE Deep Green renewable power.
• BE-1, BE-2, and BE-3 – Efficiency and Electrification of Buildings: LED retrofits lower building energy intensity and support future electrification actions. • CIO-1e – Energy-Efficiency Financing Strategies: Although financing is handled under a separate item, the project structure aligns with CAAP guidance encouraging use of innovative, cost-neutral mechanisms such as OBF.
Compliance with Government Code §4217
Based on the analysis above, Council may find:
• The anticipated cost of the energy services contract is less than the expected energy cost savings.
• Entering into the energy services contract is in the best interest of the City. • The use of a single-source provider is appropriate based on project scope, cost, timing, and technical factors.
FISCAL IMPACT
There is no fiscal impact associated with approving the Energy Services Contract alone.
Adoption of financing is addressed in a companion staff report.
The project is expected to result in cost-neutral or positive fiscal performance based on projected energy savings.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution
B. EcoGreen Solutions Presentation
C. GSA agreement with EcoGreen Solutions LLC
RESOLUTION NO. 2026-XX
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PINOLE
APPROVING AN ENERGY SERVICES CONTRACT WITH ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS
LLC FOR LED LIGHTING RETROFITS AT CITY HALL AND THE PUBLIC SAFETY
BUILDING AND MAKING FINDINGS REQUIRED UNDER GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 4217
WHEREAS, Government Code Sections 4217.10–4217.18 authorize public agencies to enter into energy service contracts without competitive bidding when, following a duly noticed public hearing, the governing body determines that the anticipated cost to the City of the energy improvements is less than the expected energy cost savings; and
WHEREAS, the City seeks to replace outdated lighting fixtures at City Hall and the Public Safety Building with high‑efficiency LED systems that will improve lighting quality, reduce electricity consumption, and lower long‑term maintenance costs; and WHEREAS, EcoGreen Solutions LLC conducted a no‑cost energy assessment of municipal facilities and has proposed a turnkey lighting retrofit project for City Hall and the Public Safety Building, including installation, materials, and warranties; and WHEREAS, the lighting retrofit project is expected to generate monthly electricity cost savings estimated at $1,663.71, with total annual savings projected to exceed the cost of the improvements over the life of the equipment; and WHEREAS, based on the analysis presented in the staff report, the anticipated energy savings associated with the LED lighting retrofit project exceed the total cost of the proposed energy services contract, as required by Government Code Section 4217.12; and
WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on October 20, 2026, in accordance with Government Code Section 4217.10 et seq., to consider the proposed energy services contract and receive public comment; and WHEREAS, the proposed LED retrofit project supports the City of Pinole’s adopted Climate Action & Adaptation Plan (CAAP) by advancing municipal building decarbonization, reducing electricity demand, and strengthening alignment with future electrification and renewable‑energy goals.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Pinole hereby resolves as follows:
SECTION 1: The recitals above are true and correct and hereby made a part of this Resolution.
SECTION 2: Government Code §4217 Findings: The City Council hereby finds and determines that:
1. The anticipated cost to the City for the LED Lighting Retrofit Project is less than the anticipated energy cost savings that will result from the improvements.
2. Entering into the energy services contract is in the best interest of the City.
3. The use of a single‑source provider (EcoGreen Solutions LLC) is appropriate due to the turnkey scope, cost‑effectiveness, technical expertise, and timely delivery of services.
SECTION 3: Approval of Energy Services Contract. The City Council hereby approves the Energy Services Contract with EcoGreen Solutions LLC for the LED Lighting Retrofit Project at City Hall and the Public Safety Building. The City Manager is authorized to execute the contract and all related documents necessary to carry out the project, including any administrative amendments that do not materially alter the terms or increase the cost of the contract.
SECTION 4: Implementation. City staff is directed to proceed with the lighting retrofit project consistent with the approved contract. Financing for this project, if any, shall be considered separately under a companion agenda item and is not approved through this Resolution.
PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Pinole held on the 3rd day of November, 2026, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS:
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS:
I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed, and adopted on the 3rd day of November, 2026.
___________________________________
Heather Bell-Spears, CMC
City Clerk
City of Pinole
EcoGreen Solutions INC.
2131 Pear Street,
Pinole, CA 94564
Prepared by:
27671 La Paz Road, Suite 100, Laguna Niguel, CA 92677
CUSTOMER INFORMATION
Customer Name
City of Pinole
Electric Service Account No.
City Hall: 527600364
Fernandez Park: 6069113784
Fire Station 74: 6317540399
Fire Station 73 & Police Department: 1196945891
Old Town Public Parking Lot 1:
Old Town Public Parking Lot 2: -
612 Tennent Ave Parking Lot: -
Beauty & Grace Salon Parking Lot: 1048223998
Guillermo Recoder Parking Lot: -
La Casita Bilingue Montessori School Parking Lot: -
Pinole Farmers Market Parking Lot: 9465139366, 4840156501 Sue’s Place Parking Lot: -
Youth Center & Playhouse: 9527530591, 7069113482, 839890612 Senior Center: 9845996180
Tiny Tots & Swim Center: 3735045069
WWTP: 1400573329
Customer Contact
Kapil Amin
Title
Sustainability Project Manager
Customer Address
City Hall: 2131 Pear St
Fernandez Park: 595 Tennent Ave
Fire Station 74: 3700 Pinole Valley Rd
Fire Station 73 & Police Department: 880 Tennent Ave
Old Town Public Parking Lot 1: 2180 Prune St
Old Town Public Parking Lot 2: 2401 San Pablo Ave
612 Tennent Ave Parking Lot: 612 Tennent Ave
Beauty & Grace Salon Parking Lot: 647 Tennent Ave
Guillermo Recoder Parking Lot: 2548 San Pablo Ave # E
La Casita Bilingue Montessori School Parking Lot: 592 Tennent Ave Pinole Farmers Market Parking Lot: 798 Fernandez Ave
Sue’s Place Parking Lot: 2265 Pear St
Playhouse: 601 Tennent Ave
Senior Center: 2500 Charles Ave
Tiny Tots & Swim Center: 2454 Simas Ave
Youth Center: 635 Tennent Ave
WWTP: 11 Tennent Ave
City, State
Pinole, CA
Telephone
510-372-0989
E-Mail
[email protected]
Phase 1: On Bill Financing
Summarized Energy Action Plan
Table 1.1 A summary of the recommendations at each site along with the related savings Location Energy Efficiency Measure
Electricity Usage Savings Cost Savings Preliminary Estimated Implementation Cost Payback Period
[kWh/yr] [$/yr] [$] [yrs]
Parking Lot - Pinole Farmers Market Upgrade existing lighting with LED lighting 2,391.00 $1,074.85 $7,648.11 7.1 Parking Lot - Beauty & Grace Salon Upgrade existing lighting with LED lighting 1,515.00 $719.63 $7,358.16 10.2 Parking Lot - Old Town Public Parking Lot
2 Upgrade existing lighting with LED lighting 1,801.00 $826.97 $7,838.07 9.5 City Hall, Fire Station 73 & Police
Department Upgrade existing lighting with LED lighting 57,704.00 $19,964.57 $194,030.05 9.7 Senior Center
Upgrade existing lighting with LED lighting 10,880.44 $4,279.59 $48,689.44 11.4 EC Motor Retrofit for Walk-in Cooler or Freezer 3,080.64 $1,211.70 $5,551.87 4.6 Total 77,372.08 $28,077.31 $271,115.70 9.66
Table 1.2. Comparison of the savings at each site Vs. the current utility bill Location
Current Electricity Usage Total Electricity
Cost
Total Electricity Usage
Savings
Percent
Electricity
Usage Savings
Total Cost Savings
Percent
Cost
Savings
[kWh/yr] [$] [kWh/yr] [%] [$] [%]
Parking Lot - Pinole Farmers Market 7,671.00 $3,480.22 2,391.00 31% $1,074.85 31% Parking Lot - Beauty & Grace Salon 2,214.00 $1,051.80 1,515.00 68% $719.63 68% Parking Lot - Old Town Public Parking
Lot 2 3,294.00 $1,512.75 1,801.00 55% $826.97 55%
City Hall, Fire Station 73 & Police
Department 624,654.00 $216,120.79 57,704.00 9% $19,964.57 9% Senior Center 145,314.00 $57,156.20 13,961.08 10% $5,491.29 10% Total 783,147 $279,321.76 77,372 10% $28,077.31 10.05%
Measures Omitted from the Energy Action Plan
Energy Action Plan for The City of Pinole
1. City Hall
HVAC – HVAC system at City Hall is currently on VFD, so there are no opportunities for energy savings for this measure.
Water Heater – No opportunities for 80-gallon unit to replace with HPWH as the savings are significantly lower than the cost of a new unit. We can provide you with the proposal if needed.
2. Fire Station 73
HVAC – The public works manager did not allow our auditor to access the roof to gather the info as he stated that a certificate will be needed for that.
3. Post Office
HVAC – The roof did not have an access point, and the facility didn’t let our auditor use the lift that they had on site.
4. Police Department
HVAC - The public works manager did not allow our auditor to access the roof to gather the info as he stated that a certificate will be needed for that.
5. Tiny Tots & Playhouse
HVAC – No HVACs at this site and no other opportunities were found
6. Swim Center
HVAC – No HVACs at this site
Pump – The pumps are already on Drives
7. Senior Center
HVAC – HVACs at this site were all single phase and small units with relatively high efficiency Note 1: No other energy-efficiency opportunities were found at other locations.
Note 2: At the time of the survey, we were not aware of the program fundings for replacing electric hot water heaters with heat pump water heaters. We are working on getting access to survey the sites for hot water heaters and will include them if applicable.
On Bill Financing - Executive Summary
Energy Action Plan for The City of Pinole
EcoGreen Solutions is pleased to present a comprehensive Energy Action Plan for the City of Pinole, focused on upgrading municipal facilities with innovative energy-efficient technologies. This plan aims to reduce energy consumption, enhance operational efficiency, and support the City’s long-term sustainability goals. EcoGreen Solutions will oversee the entire scope of work, ensuring smooth project execution, minimal disruption to City operations, and a significant return on investment.
Project Overview:
EcoGreen Solutions will implement a series of energy efficiency upgrades across key municipal facilities, including lighting, Variable Frequency Drive and ECM refrigeration. Focusing on proven technologies, we will reduce energy use, lower operating costs, and contribute to the City of Pinole’s environmental stewardship.
Key Upgrades:
1. LED Lighting Replacement
EcoGreen will upgrade outdated lighting systems in City facilities to energy-efficient LED lighting. LEDs provide superior energy efficiency, longer lifespans, and lower maintenance costs compared to traditional lighting. This upgrade will lead to significant reductions in electricity consumption, decrease ongoing maintenance expenses, and enhance the quality and consistency of lighting in municipal buildings and outdoor areas.
2. EC Motor Retrofit for Walk-in Freezer or Cooler
EcoGreen will retrofit permanent split-capacitor (PSC) motors in Walk-in Cooler units with high-efficiency EC motors that feature either integrated VFDs or smart motor controls. These new motors will reduce electricity consumption and enhance system performance by minimizing energy losses and increasing the reliability of refrigeration systems. The upgrades will also extend the lifespan of refrigeration units, reducing the need for costly repairs and replacements in the future.
3. Heat Pump Water Heater1
EcoGreen proposes to replace existing electric resistance tank water heaters with high-efficiency heat pump water heaters (HPWHs) to significantly reduce energy consumption and improve overall system 1 Please note that the water heater needs further OBF analysis and will be presented after the incentives are finalized by the utility
performance. These advanced units use heat-pump technology to move heat rather than generate it, delivering two to four times greater efficiency than standard electric tanks. The upgrade will lower electricity usage, improve hot-water reliability, and ensure more consistent performance across a range of operating conditions.
By transitioning to HPWH technology, EcoGreen will also extend the operational life of customer water-heating systems. Heat pump units experience less thermal stress and operate more efficiently, reducing wear on internal components and minimizing the likelihood of costly repairs or premature replacements. This retrofit not only supports long-term sustainability goals but also provides substantial ongoing utility savings for facility operators.
Financing Through PG&E’s On-Bill Financing (OBF)
EcoGreen will help the City of Pinole take advantage of PG&E’s On-Bill Financing (OBF) program to fund energy efficiency upgrades. This program provides zero-interest financing, enabling the City to pay for the upgrades over time using savings generated from these improvements. The OBF program guarantees that the city can implement these enhancements with no upfront capital required, while the immediate energy savings will offset the financing costs, making the project financially sustainable.
Project Outcomes:
Energy Savings: The energy efficiency upgrades are anticipated to yield significant reductions in energy consumption, resulting in lower electricity bills and a reduction in the City’s carbon footprint. Improved Operational Efficiency: By replacing outdated systems and integrating innovative technology, the city will improve the performance and reliability of its lighting and refrigeration equipment.
Sustainability and Climate Action: These upgrades are in line with the City of Pinole’s commitment to sustainability and climate action goals, aiding in the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the achievement of energy efficiency targets.
Benefits of EcoGreen Solutions:
EcoGreen Solutions is a reliable partner with extensive experience in delivering energy savings projects for municipalities. Our expertise and commitment to sustainability ensure that we provide cost-effective, high-quality solutions that yield long-term results. We will manage every phase of the project, from initial assessments and design to installation and post-project support, guaranteeing that the City of Pinole benefits from a streamlined, efficient process and exceptional outcomes.
By using PG&E’s On-Bill Financing program, EcoGreen Solutions will allow the City of Pinole to implement these energy-efficient improvements without needing upfront investment, while ensuring quick returns through significant energy savings. This strategy guarantees that the project is financially viable and sustainable, while also achieving substantial reductions in energy consumption and operational costs.
This Energy Action Plan represents a progressive step toward a more sustainable future for the City of Pinole. EcoGreen Solutions is honored to partner with the city in implementing these essential upgrades, supporting its environmental objectives and positioning the City of Pinole as a leader in energy efficiency and sustainability.
Project Scope of Work
EcoGreen will enhance the energy efficiency of multiple buildings and sites for The City of Pinole:
Parking Lot – Pinole Farmers Market
Parking Lot – Beauty & Grace Salon
Parking Lot – Old Town Public Parking Lot 2
City Hall, Fire Sation 73 & Police Department
Senior Center
The project includes replacing existing lighting with energy-efficient LED fixtures, upgrading outdated Walk-in Cooler PSC fan motors with high-efficiency EC motors, and replacing existing electric resistance water heaters with high-performance heat pump water heaters. The work will begin with a comprehensive site assessment, followed by the installation of new systems and fixtures. After installation, EcoGreen will conduct system testing to ensure optimal performance, train maintenance staff on the upgraded equipment, and responsibly dispose of all removed materials. The project aims to reduce energy consumption, lower utility costs, and enhance the environmental sustainability of the City’s public buildings. Completion timelines and budget estimates will be finalized after the initial assessment.
Site One: Parking Lot - Pinole Farmers Market
Figure 1.1. City of Pinole – Pinole Farmers Market Parking Lot, 798 Fernandez Ave, Pinole, CA 94564.
EcoGreen’s scope of work for this parking lot will include upgrading all outdated lighting to energy-efficient LED fixtures. This upgrade will not only enhance the overall lighting quality and ambiance but will also decrease energy consumption and reduce maintenance costs. Eco Green will ensure that the new LED lighting complies with local building codes and energy standards while providing a longer lifespan and improved performance.
Quote
201388
27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100 9/18/2025
Laguna Niguel, CA. 92677
[email protected]
(949) 364 - 6800
Quotes are valid for 30 days from the above date.
EGLF-TCP60-5000-UNV ext LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 11 $99.98 $1,099.78 * All quantities to be verified by owner SUBTOTAL $1,099.78 LABOR $3,148.66
SALES TAX Included
(Brackets, Wiring, Sockets, Electrician Travel, Tiewire, Screws, Lifts, Lamp Recycling / Disposal, Shipping, Package, ETC.) MISC. CHARGES $1,649.67 3rd Party QA Review $1,750.00
TOTAL PROJECT COST $7,648.11
Estimated IRS Federal Tax Deduction per 179D: $0.00
Estimated Annual Energy Savings: $1,074.85
QUOTED PRICING DOES NOT REFLECT INCOMING TARIFFS - FINAL PROJECT COST
SUBJECT TO CHANGE BY TARIFF AMOUNT DEPENDING UPON TIME OF PURCHASE AND
PROJECT APPROVAL
SIGNATURE: _________________________________________________________________________________ DATE:___________________________ WHEN SIGNED OR APPROVED BY CLIENT, THIS FORM BECOMES AN OFFICIAL ORDER AND A LEGALLY BINDING COMMITMENT SUBJECT TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS FORM. BY ACCEPTING THIS PROJECT AND MOVING FORWARD, CUSTOMER AGREES TO HAVE ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS PURCHASE AND INSTALL THE PRODUCTS LISTED ABOVE. All returned checks are subject to a $20 service charge. If customer is utilizing a utility program where they default or get disqualified post install and the pre approved utility funding is canceled, the customer is liable for the project amount in full and the terms and conditions above will need to be met. Subject to collections and or litigation. If this invoice is not paid in full when due, a 1.5% per month late charge will be imposed. In this event, customer will be liable to pay reasonable collection charge, attorney fee and court cost. Warranty to be serviced by factory (see EcoGreen Scope of Work and warranty statement provided by the factory).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Quote #
DATE
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Parking Lot - Pinole Farmers' Market
Amount
798 Fernandez Ave
Pinole, 94564 CA
Acct: 4840156969; SAID: 4840156501
Light EPN INT/
EXT DESCRIPTION QTY* Unit Price
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Community Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size - SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.45 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 201388 KWh
Saved
area light w1 mh 190 w 11 4.6 7 / 1672 parking lot 0 LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 11 11 1,430 w 68.4% 2,391.20 $1,074.85 Totals 11 Ave: 1672 w 11 1,430 w 68.4% 2,391.20 $1,074.85 1,430 Estimated Watts Saved Total Project Cost $7,648.11 Approximate Energy Savings Per Month 2,391 Estimated Annual kWh Saved Total After Rebate/Incentive Project Cost $7,648.11 Estimated Energy Savings Per Year
0.3 Estimated Avg Annual Res Powered by Savings ****Estimated Program Payback Period Yrs. 7.12 **Estimated Total Savings Over 5 Years 2 Estimated Annual CO2 Savings (MT) ** Estimated Total Savings After 10 Years - Estimated Btu Savings Per Month Estimated Energy Rebate
68.4% Estimated Average Electrical Savings Estimated IRS Tax Deduction 179D Available
14.1% Estimated ***Estimated Federal Tax Savings
7.12 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. - No Rebates, Tax Deductions or Bulb Replacement Savings Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Year
6.52 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. Fully Comprehensive^ ^^ Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Avg. Est. Life of LED Estimated Loan Payment
*** Based on IRS 179D Deduction @ 35% federal tax rate NOTE: Attached calculations do not include depreciation deduction for project cost. ****Program Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Program Rebates or Incentives) / Estimated $ Saved per Year *Payment is based on a 7.12 year loan at 0% interest OAC, actual my vary. ^Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Rebate or Incentive - Tax Savings) / (Estimated Savings Per Year + Bulb Replacement Savings Per Yr.) ** Reflects energy savings per year increasing at industry standard 6% per year + Bulb Replacement ^^Based on industry standard LED lifespan of 50,000 hrs. $98.79
$17,666.18
$0.00
$6,059.02
$14,167.36
$0.00
$0.00
$88.93
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr.
$89.57
$1,074.85
Existing Watts/
Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Parking Lot - Pinole Farmers' Market
798 Fernandez Ave
Pinole, 94564 CA
Acct: 4840156969; SAID: 4840156501
# of
Lamps
Site Two: Parking Lot – Beauty & Grace Salon
Figure 1.2. City of Pinole – Beauty & Grace Salon Parking Lot, 647 Tennent Ave, Pinole, CA 94564.
EcoGreen will retrofit the parking lot by converting every legacy light to LED technology. This modernization enhances light quality and visibility, lowers power consumption, and cuts ongoing upkeep costs. The system will fully comply with local codes and efficiency requirements and provide an extended lifespan with improved output.
Quote
201381
27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100 9/18/2025
Laguna Niguel, CA. 92677
[email protected]
(949) 364 - 6800
Quotes are valid for 30 days from the above date.
EGLF-TCP60-5000-UNV ext LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 10 $99.98 $999.80 * All quantities to be verified by owner SUBTOTAL $999.80 LABOR $3,148.66
SALES TAX Included
(Brackets, Wiring, Sockets, Electrician Travel, Tiewire, Screws, Lifts, Lamp Recycling / Disposal, Shipping, Package, ETC.) MISC. CHARGES $1,459.71 3rd Party QA Review $1,750.00
TOTAL PROJECT COST $7,358.16
Estimated IRS Federal Tax Deduction per 179D: $0.00
Estimated Annual Energy Savings: $719.63
Unit Price
QUOTED PRICING DOES NOT REFLECT INCOMING TARIFFS - FINAL PROJECT COST
SUBJECT TO CHANGE BY TARIFF AMOUNT DEPENDING UPON TIME OF PURCHASE AND
PROJECT APPROVAL
SIGNATURE: _________________________________________________________________________________ DATE:___________________________ WHEN SIGNED OR APPROVED BY CLIENT, THIS FORM BECOMES AN OFFICIAL ORDER AND A LEGALLY BINDING COMMITMENT SUBJECT TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS FORM. BY ACCEPTING THIS PROJECT AND MOVING FORWARD, CUSTOMER AGREES TO HAVE ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS PURCHASE AND INSTALL THE PRODUCTS LISTED ABOVE. All returned checks are subject to a $20 service charge. If customer is utilizing a utility program where they default or get disqualified post install and the pre approved utility funding is canceled, the customer is liable for the project amount in full and the terms and conditions above will need to be met. Subject to collections and or litigation. If this invoice is not paid in full when due, a 1.5% per month late charge will be imposed. In this event, customer will be liable to pay reasonable collection charge, attorney fee and court cost. Warranty to be serviced by factory (see EcoGreen Scope of Work and warranty statement provided by the factory).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Quote #
DATE
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Parking Lot - Beauty & Grace Salon
Amount
647 Tennent Ave
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1048223537; SAID: 1048223998
Light EPN INT/
EXT DESCRIPTION QTY*
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size - SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.48 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 201381 KWh
Saved
area light w2 MH heads 190 w 6 3 7 / 1165 parking lot 0 LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 6 6 780 w 68.4% 908.88 $431.78 area light w1 MH 190 w 4 3 7 / 1165 parking lot 0 LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 4 4 520 w 68.4% 605.92 $287.85 Totals 10 Ave: 1165 w 10 1,300 w 68.4% 1,514.80 $719.63 1,300 Estimated Watts Saved Total Project Cost $7,358.16 Approximate Energy Savings Per Month 1,515 Estimated Annual kWh Saved Total After Rebate/Incentive Project Cost $7,358.16 Estimated Energy Savings Per Year
0.2 Estimated Avg Annual Res Powered by Savings ****Estimated Program Payback Period Yrs. 9.89 **Estimated Total Savings Over 5 Years 1 Estimated Annual CO2 Savings (MT) ** Estimated Total Savings After 10 Years - Estimated Btu Savings Per Month Estimated Energy Rebate
68.4% Estimated Average Electrical Savings Estimated IRS Tax Deduction 179D Available
9.8% Estimated ***Estimated Federal Tax Savings
10.22 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. - No Rebates, Tax Deductions or Bulb Replacement Savings Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Year
9.42 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. Fully Comprehensive^ ^^ Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Avg. Est. Life of LED Estimated Loan Payment
*** Based on IRS 179D Deduction @ 35% federal tax rate NOTE: Attached calculations do not include depreciation deduction for project cost. ****Program Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Program Rebates or Incentives) / Estimated $ Saved per Year *Payment is based on a 9.89 year loan at 0% interest OAC, actual my vary. ^Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Rebate or Incentive - Tax Savings) / (Estimated Savings Per Year + Bulb Replacement Savings Per Yr.) ** Reflects energy savings per year increasing at industry standard 6% per year + Bulb Replacement ^^Based on industry standard LED lifespan of 50,000 hrs. $61.27
$22,564.53
$0.00
$4,056.63
$9,485.31
$0.00
$0.00
$59.32
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr.
$59.97
$719.63
Existing Watts/
Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Parking Lot - Beauty & Grace Salon
647 Tennent Ave
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1048223537; SAID: 1048223998
# of
Lamps
Site Three: Parking Lot – Old Town Public Parking 2
Figure 1.3. City of Pinole – Old Town Public Parking Lot, 2401 San Pablo Ave, Pinole, CA 94564.
For this parking lot, EcoGreen will replace all outdated fixtures with high-efficiency LED lighting. The upgrade will improve illumination and overall ambiance while reducing energy use and maintenance expenses. All new LEDs will be installed to meet local building codes and energy standards and deliver longer service life with dependable performance.
Quote
201394
27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100 12/1/2025
Laguna Niguel, CA. 92677
[email protected]
(949) 364 - 6800
Quotes are valid for 30 days from the above date.
EGLF-TCP60-5000-UNV ext LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 14 $99.98 $1,399.72 0 0 0 0 w 0 $0.00 $0.00
0 0 0 0 w 0 $0.00 $0.00
* All quantities to be verified by owner SUBTOTAL $1,399.72 LABOR $3,148.66
SALES TAX Included
(Brackets, Wiring, Sockets, Electrician Travel, Tiewire, Screws, Lifts, Lamp Recycling / Disposal, Shipping, Package, ETC.) MISC. CHARGES $1,539.69 3rd Party QA Review $1,750.00
TOTAL PROJECT COST $7,838.07
Estimated IRS Federal Tax Deduction per 179D: $0.00
Estimated Annual Energy Savings: $826.96
QUOTED PRICING DOES NOT REFLECT INCOMING TARIFFS - FINAL PROJECT COST
SUBJECT TO CHANGE BY TARIFF AMOUNT DEPENDING UPON TIME OF PURCHASE AND
PROJECT APPROVAL
SIGNATURE: _________________________________________________________________________________ DATE:___________________________ WHEN SIGNED OR APPROVED BY CLIENT, THIS FORM BECOMES AN OFFICIAL ORDER AND A LEGALLY BINDING COMMITMENT SUBJECT TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS FORM. BY ACCEPTING THIS PROJECT AND MOVING FORWARD, CUSTOMER AGREES TO HAVE ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS PURCHASE AND INSTALL THE PRODUCTS LISTED ABOVE. All returned checks are subject to a $20 service charge. If customer is utilizing a utility program where they default or get disqualified post install and the pre approved utility funding is canceled, the customer is liable for the project amount in full and the terms and conditions above will need to be met. Subject to collections and or litigation. If this invoice is not paid in full when due, a 1.5% per month late charge will be imposed. In this event, customer will be liable to pay reasonable collection charge, attorney fee and court cost. Warranty to be serviced by factory (see EcoGreen Scope of Work and warranty statement provided by the factory).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Quote #
DATE
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Old Town Public Parking - Lot 2
Amount
2401 San Pablo Ave.
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 9465139985; SAID: 9465139366
Light EPN INT/
EXT DESCRIPTION QTY* Unit Price
EcoGreen Sales Rep: 0 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size - SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.46 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 201394 KWh
Saved
area light w1 head 190 w 14 2.7 7 / 989 old town parking lot LED High Lumen Filament Highbay Replacement, 5000k, UNV 60 w 14 14 1,820 w 68.4% 1,800.70 $826.96 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 3rd Party QA Review 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 0 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 0 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
Totals 14 Ave: 989 w 14 1,820 w 68.4% 1,800.70 $826.96
1,820 Estimated Watts Saved Total Project Cost $7,838.07 Approximate Energy Savings Per Month 1,801 Estimated Annual kWh Saved Total After Rebate/Incentive Project Cost $7,838.07 Estimated Energy Savings Per Year
0.2 Estimated Avg Annual Res Powered by Savings ****Estimated Program Payback Period Yrs. 9.48 **Estimated Total Savings Over 5 Years 1 Estimated Annual CO2 Savings (MT) ** Estimated Total Savings After 10 Years - Estimated Btu Savings Per Month Estimated Energy Rebate
68.4% Estimated Average Electrical Savings Estimated IRS Tax Deduction 179D Available
10.6% Estimated ***Estimated Federal Tax Savings
9.48 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. - No Rebates, Tax Deductions or Bulb Replacement Savings Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Year
8.72 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. Fully Comprehensive^ ^^ Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Avg. Est. Life of LED Estimated Loan Payment
*** Based on IRS 179D Deduction @ 35% federal tax rate NOTE: Attached calculations do not include depreciation deduction for project cost. ****Program Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Program Rebates or Incentives) / Estimated $ Saved per Year *Payment is based on a 9.48 year loan at 0% interest OAC, actual my vary. ^Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Rebate or Incentive - Tax Savings) / (Estimated Savings Per Year + Bulb Replacement Savings Per Yr.) ** Reflects energy savings per year increasing at industry standard 6% per year + Bulb Replacement ^^Based on industry standard LED lifespan of 50,000 hrs. # of
Lamps
# of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Old Town Public Parking - Lot 2
2401 San Pablo Ave.
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 9465139985; SAID: 9465139366
Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr.
$68.91
$826.96
Existing Watts/
Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved $0.00
$4,661.66
$10,900.00
$0.00
$0.00
$68.16
$72.30
$36,928.43
1 Form 79-1118
Advice 5104-G/7690-E
August 2025
CALIFORNIA STATE GOVERNMENT
CUSTOMERS ON-BILL FINANCING
LOAN AGREEMENT
The undersigned customer (“Customer”) has contracted for the provision of energy efficiency/demand response equipment and services (the “Work”) which qualify for one or more of PG&E’s applicable rebate or incentive programs. Subject to the conditions (including the process for Adjustment and preconditions to funding) set forth below, Pacific Gas and Electric Company (“PG&E”) shall extend a loan (the “Loan”) to Customer in the amount of the loan balance (the “Loan Balance”) pursuant to the terms of this On-Bill Financing Loan Agreement (“Loan Agreement”) and PG&E’s rate schedules E-OBF and/or G-OBF, as applicable (the “Schedule”).
To request the Loan, Customer has submitted a completed On-Bill Financing Application and associated documentation as required by PG&E (the “Application”). Collectively the Application and this Loan Agreement (including any Adjustment hereunder) comprise the “Agreement".
1. Customer shall arrange for its Contractor, as identified at the end of this Agreement (“Contractor”), to provide the Work as described in the Application.
2. The estimated Loan Balance is set forth below. The total cost of the Work as installed, rebate/incentive for qualifying energy efficiency measures, Loan Balance, monthly payment, and loan term specified in this Loan Agreement may be adjusted, if necessary, after the Work and the post-installation inspection described in the Application and/or herein are completed (the “Adjustment”). The Adjustment will be calculated using the actual total cost of the Work, as installed, and the estimated energy savings (as described in the Application) of such Work. In no event will the Loan Balance be increased without Customer’s written consent, even if Customer is eligible for such increased Loan Balance. Moreover, in no event will the Loan Balance exceed the maximum loan amount stipulated in the Application. Customer understands that in order to be eligible for the Loan, the initial Loan Balance for Work may not fall below the minimum loan amount, nor may the payback period exceed the maximum payback period. Accordingly, if after the Adjustment, the Loan Balance falls below the minimum loan amount or if the simple payback period exceeds the program maximum payback period, each as described in the Application, PG&E shall have no obligation to extend the Loan, as the Work would not meet program requirements. The Adjustment described in this paragraph will be communicated to the Customer in writing and will automatically become part of this Loan Agreement, except that any proposed increase in the Loan Balance will only become part of this Loan Agreement upon Customer’s written consent to such increase.
3. PG&E shall have no liability in connection with, and makes no warranties, expressed or implied, regarding the Work.
The Parties acknowledge and agree that PG&E is only providing the State with financing. The Customer has independently hired contractors ("State Contractors") to perform the work on behalf of the Customer to qualify for financing. The Customer acknowledges and agrees that the State Contractors are not third party beneficiaries to this agreement between the Customer and PG&E. To the extent authorized by law and subject to appropriation of the Legislature, the Customer agrees that it will look only to State Contractors for any claims related to the installed equipment or its performance and that PG&E shall have no responsibility or liability, except for the payment of the loan proceeds, and the Customer shall indemnify PG&E for any claims made by the State Contractors against PG&E.
4. Customer represents and warrants that (a) Customer is receiving this Loan solely for Work obtained in connection with Customer’s business, and not for personal, family or household purposes; (b) Customer, if not an individual or a government agency, is duly organized, validly existing and in good standing under the laws of its state of formation, and has full power and authority to enter into this Agreement and to carry out the provisions of this Agreement. Customer is duly qualified and in good standing to do business in all jurisdictions where such qualification is required; (c) this Loan Agreement has been duly authorized by all necessary proceedings, has been duly executed and delivered by Customer and is a valid and legally binding agreement of Customer duly enforceable in accordance with its terms; (d) no consent, approval, authorization, order, registration or qualification of or with any court or regulatory authority or other governmental body having jurisdiction over Customer is required for, and the absence of which would adversely affect, the legal and valid execution and delivery of this Loan Agreement, and the performance of the transactions contemplated by this Loan Agreement; (e) the execution and delivery of this Loan Agreement by Customer hereunder and the compliance by Customer with all provisions of this Loan Agreement: (i) will not conflict with or violate any Applicable Law; and (ii) will not conflict with or result in a breach of or default under any of the terms or provisions of any loan agreement or other contract or agreement under which Customer is an obligor or by which its property is bound; and (f) all factual information furnished by Customer to PG&E in the Application and pursuant to this Agreement is true and accurate.
5. The Application must include the Federal Tax Identification Number or Social Security Number of the party who will be the recipient of the checks for the rebate/incentive or any Loan proceeds. Checks may be issued directly to the Customer or its designated Contractor or both, for the benefit of the Customer, as specified below. Customer acknowledges that PG&E will not be responsible for any tax liability imposed on the Customer or its contractor in connection with the transactions contemplated under the Agreement, whether by virtue of the Loan contemplated under the Agreement, or otherwise, and Customer shall indemnify PG&E for any tax liability imposed upon PG&E as a result of the transactions contemplated under the Agreement.
2 Form 79-1118
Advice 5104-G/7690-E
August 2025
6. Upon completion of the Work, Customer shall send a written confirmation of completion to PG&E’s On-Bill Financing Program Administrator at the address listed in Section 15. Within 60 days after receiving the confirmation, PG&E (a) will conduct a post installation inspection and project verification, including review of invoices, receipts and other documents as required by PG&E to verify the correctness of any amounts claimed by Customer; and (b) will adjust, if necessary, the total cost, incentive, Loan Balance, monthly payment, and loan term as stated above. Customer shall give PG&E reasonable access to its premises and the Work. If the Work conforms to all requirements of the Agreement and all amounts claimed by Customer as Work costs are substantiated to PG&E’s reasonable satisfaction, PG&E will issue a check (“Check”) to Customer or Contractor (as designated by Customer in Section 15) for all amounts PG&E approves for payment in accordance with the Agreement. The date of such issuance is the “Issuance Date”. If the Check is issued to Customer, Customer shall be responsible for paying any outstanding fees due to Contractor for the Work. If the Check is less than the amount due from Customer to Contractor, Customer shall be responsible for the excess due to the Contractor.
7. Customer shall repay the Loan Balance to PG&E as provided in this Loan Agreement irrespective of whether or when the Work is completed, or whether the Work is in any way defective or deficient, and whether or not the Work delivers energy efficiency savings to Customer.
8. The monthly payments will be included by PG&E on the Account's regular energy service bills, or by separate bill, in PG&E’s discretion. Regardless whether the monthly payments are included in the regular utility bill or a separate loan installment bill, the following repayment terms will apply:
a. The Customer agrees to repay to PG&E the Loan Balance in the number of payments listed below and in equal installments (with the final installment adjusted to account for rounding), by the due date set forth in each PG&E utility bill or loan installment bill rendered in connection with Customer’s account (identified by the number set forth below) (“Account”), commencing with the bill which has a due date falling at least 30 days after the Issuance Date.
b. If separate energy service bills and loan installment bills are provided, amounts due under this Loan Agreement as shown in the loan installment bill shall be deemed to be amounts due under each energy services bill to the Account, and a default under this Loan Agreement shall be treated as a default under the Account.
c. If the Customer is unable to make a full utility bill payment in a given month, payment arrangements may be made at PG&E’s discretion.
d. Any partial bill payments received for a month will be applied in equal proportion to the energy charges and the loan obligation for that month, and the Customer may be considered in default of both the energy bill and the loan installment bill.
e. Further payment details are set forth below.
9. Any notice from PG&E to Customer regarding the Program or the transactions contemplated under the Loan Agreement may be provided within a PG&E utility bill or loan installment bill, and any such notices may also be provided to Customer at the address below or to the Customer’s billing address of record in PG&E’s customer billing system from time to time, and in each case shall be effective five (5) days after they have been mailed.
10. The Loan Balance shall not bear interest.
11. Customer may, without prepayment penalty, pay the entire outstanding loan balance in one lump sum payment provided the customer first notifies PG&E by telephoning the toll free phone number (1-800-468-4743), and by sending written notice to PG&E On-Bill Financing Program Administrator at the address listed below, in advance of making the lump sum payment. Accelerated payments that are received from Customer without PG&E’s prior approval may, at PG&E’s sole discretion, be applied proportionally to subsequent energy charges and Loan repayments and PG&E shall have no obligation to apply accelerated payments exclusively to reduction of the outstanding Loan.
12. The entire outstanding Loan Balance will become immediately due and payable, and shall be paid by Customer within 30 days if:
(i) the Account is closed or terminated for any reason; (ii) Customer defaults under the Agreement; (iii) Customer sells the equipment forming part of the Work to any third party; or (iv) Customer becomes Insolvent. Customer becomes “Insolvent” if: (i) Customer is unable to pay its debts as they become due or otherwise becomes insolvent, makes a general assignment for the benefit of its creditors, or suffers or permits the appointment of a receiver for its business or assets or otherwise ceases to conduct business in the normal course; or (ii) any proceeding is commenced by or against Customer under any bankruptcy or insolvency law that is not dismissed or stayed within 45 days.
13. Customer understands that without limiting any other remedy available to PG&E against Contractor or Customer, failure to repay the Loan Balance in accordance with the terms of the Agreement could result in shut-off of utility energy service, adverse credit reporting, and collection procedures, including, without limitation, legal action.
14. If there is any conflict among the documents comprising the Agreement, the following order of priority shall apply: 1. this Loan Agreement; 2. the Application; 3. any documents attached to the Application.
3 Form 79-1118
Advice 5104-G/7690-E
August 2025
15. STATE OF CALIFORNIA REQUIREMENT
a. All Payment Obligations Subject to Appropriation
The Customer acknowledges that the cost incurred pursuant to this Loan Agreement will be part of the monthly bill for electricity use. All payment obligations and the Work replacement obligations of the Customer under this Loan Agreement or any related agreement or application is subject to appropriation by the Legislature of the State of California.
b. No Lien or Encumbrance; Subordination:
(1) Notwithstanding any other provision in this Loan Agreement – , PG&E acknowledges that nothing in this Loan Agreement shall constitute a mortgage, charge, assignment, transfer, pledge, lien or encumbrance upon either the Work or any part of the buildings, structures or related facilities in which the Work is constructed, installed or situated (collectively, the “Related Facilities”). Accordingly, PG&E agrees it will not record or file any instrument that would indicate or imply it has a security interest in the Related Facilities, including but not limited to a UCC-1. (2) In addition to the preceding paragraph (a), if this Loan Agreement were ever construed or deemed to create any such encumbrance, then: (i) this Loan Agreement shall be junior and subordinate and subject in all respects to the terms and conditions of any and all leases, and indentures related to lease revenue bonds issued by the State Public Works Board of the State of California or any other issuer of bonds on behalf of the state concerning the Related Facilities entered into in the past, the present or the future (the “Senior Security Documents”); and (ii) any term or condition of this Loan Agreement relating to any right, title or interest in the Related Facilities or other benefits derived there from shall be in all respects junior and subordinate to, and subject to the terms of, the Senior Security Documents.
4 Form 79-1118
Advice 5104-G/7690-E
August 2025
16. Loan Particulars.
This table is to be completed by PG&E
Total Cost Incentive Customer
Buy- Down
(if applicable)
Loan Balance
1 Monthly
Payment
Term 2
(months)
Number of
Payments
$ 7,838.07 $ - $ - $ 7,838.07 $ 68.16 115 115
Check Made Payable to Customer □ or Contractor □
[customer to select payment method. Note that only one check can be issued]
17. This agreement at all times shall be subject to such modifications as the California Public Utilities Commission may direct from time to time in the exercise of its jurisdiction.
Federal Tax ID or Social Security #, Customer Federal Tax ID or Social Security #, Contractor 94-6000394 80-0196823
PG&E Account # / Service Agreement #
9465139985 / 9465139366
Account Name, Customer Name, Contractor
Primary Customer Name: CITY OF PINOLE - NEAR
795 FERNANDEZ -
EcoGreen Solutions, Corey Brophy
Project ID: City of Pinole - Old Town Public Parking - Lot 2
FA ID: 016786
Customer Address (For OBF Check Delivery) Contractor Address (For OBF Check Delivery) 27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100
Laguna Niguel CA 92677
Name and Title of Authorized Representative of
.Customer
Name and Title of Authorized Representative of
.Contractor
Corey Brophy, EcoGreen Solutions
Signature of Authorized Representative of Customer
Date
ACCEPTED: Pacific Gas and Electric Company
By Date
PG&E On-Bill Financing Authorized Representative
18. Once this Agreement is effective and unless otherwise agreed to by PG&E in writing, Customer must complete the approved project they are using these funds for, including submitting all post-installation documentation requirements, within 24 months thereafter. For avoidance of doubt, Customer will not be eligible and will not receive any funding under this Agreement, if their project is not fully completed within the 24 months or as otherwise expressly agreed by PG&E. 1 The Loan Balance shall not exceed two-hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000), except where, in PG&E’s sole opinion, the opportunity for uniquely large energy savings exist, in which case the Loan Balance may exceed two-hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) but shall not exceed four million dollars ($4,000,000).
2 The loan term in months will be established by PG&E at the time of the OBF Loan Agreement initiation.
The maximum loan term shall be one hundred and twenty (120) months.
5 Form 79-1118
Advice 5104-G/7690-E
August 2025
On-Bill Financing Program (OBF)
Loan Calculation Summary Sheet
Simple project payback per meter
Customer Name: CITY OF PINOLE - NEAR 795 FERNANDEZ -
Project Number: FA ID: 016786
Calculations from:
Original
(A)
PROJECT COST FOR
MEASURES
(B)
REBATES or INCENTIVES Customer Down
Payment or Buy-Down
CUSTOMER
TOTAL LOAN
AMOUNT
(C)
CUSTOMER
AVERAGE
RATE PER kWh
(D)
CUSTOMER
AVERAGE RATE
PER Therm
(E)
ESTIMATED
ANNUAL
ENERGY
SAVINGS
(kWh)
(F)
ESTIMATED
ANNUAL GAS
SAVINGS
(Therm)
ESTIMATED
ANNUAL ENERGY
COST SAVINGS
SIMPLE
PAYBACK IN
YEARS
$ 7,838.07 $ - $ - $ 7,838.07 $ 0.46 $ - 1,800.70 - $ 826.96 9.48
PAYBACK IN MONTHS
BASED ON EXPECTED
ENERGY SAVINGS
LOAN TERM (MONTHS)
(1 month added for bill
neutrality)
CUSTOMER FIXED
MONTHLY LOAN
PAYMENT
ESTIMATED
MONTHLY
ENERGY COST
SAVINGS
114 115 $ 68.16 $ 68.91
(C) = (From utility bill) Total $ amount (12-month) / Total kWh (same 12-month) (D) = (From utility bill) Total $ amount (12-month) / Total therm (same 12-month)
Site Four: City Hall, Fire Sation 73 & Police Department Figure 1.4. City of Pinole – City Hall, Fire Sation 73 & Police Department, 2131 Pear St & 880 Tennent Ave, Pinole, CA 94564.
EcoGreen will modernize these buildings’ lighting by replacing all outdated fixtures with energy-efficient LEDs. The upgrade will elevate illumination quality and ambiance while significantly cutting energy use and maintenance costs. All new equipment will be installed to meet local building codes and energy standards, delivering longer life and stronger performance. Moreover, the electric storage water heater in the City Hall will be upgraded to a Heat Pump Water Heater to improve energy sustainability and reduce energy usage.
Quote
0 27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100 1/0/1900
Laguna Niguel, CA. 92677
[email protected]
(949) 364 - 6800
Quotes are valid for 30 days from the above date.
EGTU-TC10-4ft-3500-T8-B int 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 56 $11.97 $670.32 EGTU-TC10-4ft-5000-T8-B int 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 627 $11.97 $7,505.19 EGCL-ML18-8"-CS-UNV-REC int LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 100 $115.00 $11,500.00 EGCL-ML18-8"-CS-UNV-REC ext LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 14 $115.00 $1,610.00 EG22-SF25-4000-UNV-REC int LED Troffer 2x2,Retrofit Kit 35K, 40K, 50K, UNV, REC 17 w 55 $149.00 $8,195.00 EGTU-TS12-3ft-5000-UNV-T8-B int 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 11 $13.59 $149.49 EGTU-TC10-4ft-4000-T8-B int 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 77 $11.97 $921.69 EGWS-SL12-4000K-UNV int LED Half Moon Sconce, 4000K, UNV 12 w 5 $169.98 $849.90 EGPL-GC10.5-4000-UNV-H int LED Horizontal PL Replacement, 4000K, UNV, W? 2 Pin Adaptor 10 w 22 $23.00 $506.00 EGLN-ML20.2-2ft-CS-UNV-WRP int (Wattage Selectable 20w, 25w, 30w) LED 2' Linear Wrap Fixture,Color Selectable (3500K, 4000K, 5000K) , UNV 20.2 w 1 $195.00 $195.00 EG24-SF26-4000-UNV-REC int LED Troffer 2x4 Retrofit Kit, 3500K, 4000K, 5000K, UNV, REC 26 w 13 $149.00 $1,937.00 EGLB-ST13-4000K-UNV int LED 9in Low Bay, 4000K, UNV 13 w 1 $89.00 $89.00 EG24-SF20-4000-UNV-REC int LED Troffer 2x4 Retrofit Kit, 3500K, 4000K, 5000K, UNV, REC 20 w 2 $149.00 $298.00 EGLN-ML23.86-4ft-CS-UNV-SMT-WRP int LED 4' Linear Wrap Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 23.9 w 11 $179.00 $1,969.00 EGSL-ATG18-CCT-UNV int LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 5 $138.58 $692.90 EGLN-TCWS-CS-UNV-8FT int LED 8' Linear Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 32 w 15 $149.00 $2,235.00 EGCL-ML28-10"-CS-UNV-REC int LED 10" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, UNV,REC 28 w 12 $145.00 $1,740.00 EGED-X-X 0 Emergency Driver 0 w 55 $150.00 $8,250.00
SUBTOTAL $49,313.49
LABOR $110,052.95
SALES TAX Included
(Brackets, Wiring, Sockets, Electrician Travel, Tiewire, Screws, Lifts, Lamp Recycling / Disposal, Shipping, Package, ETC.) MISC. CHARGES $32,663.61 3rd Party QA Review $2,000.00
TOTAL PROJECT COST $194,030.05
Estimated IRS Federal Tax Deduction per 179D: $16,504.80 Estimated Annual Energy Savings: $19,964.57
SIGNATURE: _________________________________________________________________________________ DATE:___________________________ WHEN SIGNED OR APPROVED BY CLIENT, THIS FORM BECOMES AN OFFICIAL ORDER AND A LEGALLY BINDING COMMITMENT SUBJECT TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS FORM. BY ACCEPTING THIS PROJECT AND MOVING FORWARD, CUSTOMER AGREES TO HAVE ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS PURCHASE AND INSTALL THE PRODUCTS LISTED ABOVE. All returned checks are subject to a $20 service charge. If customer is utilizing a utility program where they default or get disqualified post install and the pre approved utility funding is canceled, the customer is liable for the project amount in full and the terms and conditions above will need to be met. Subject to collections and or litigation. If this invoice is not paid in full when due, a 1.5% per month late charge will be imposed. In this event, customer will be liable to pay reasonable collection charge, attorney fee and court cost. Warranty to be serviced by factory (see EcoGreen Scope of Work and warranty statement provided by the factory).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Quote #
DATE
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office Amount
2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
Light EPN INT/
EXT DESCRIPTION QTY* Unit Price
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 27,508 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.35 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 0 KWh
Saved
HVAC 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 public safety building engineering PENDING 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft linear w2 t8s 59 w 1 2 5 / 522 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) electrical room (locked) LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 1 1 41 w 69.7% 21.47 $7.43 4ft linear w2 t8s 59 w 1 4 5 / 1043 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) adult 1 LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 1 1 41 w 69.7% 42.86 $14.83 4ft linear w2 t8s 59 w 1 4 5 / 1043 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) adult 2 LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 1 1 41 w 69.7% 42.86 $14.83 4ft linear w2 t8s 59 w 1 4 5 / 1043 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) sc 1 LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 1 1 41 w 69.7% 42.86 $14.83 4ft linear w2 t8s 59 w 1 4 5 / 1043 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) 0 LED Stairwell Linear, CCT, UNV 17.9 w 1 1 41 w 69.7% 42.86 $14.83 sconce w 2 cfl 31 w 4 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor entrance lobby LED Horizontal PL Replacement, 4000K, UNV, W? 2 Pin Adaptor 20 w 4 8 44 w 35.5% 78.24 $27.07 sconce w 2 cfl 31 w 7 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor council chambers LED Horizontal PL Replacement, 4000K, UNV, W? 2 Pin Adaptor 20 w 7 14 77 w 35.5% 91.28 $31.58 2ft lin wrap w 2 t12. 56 w 1 4 5 / 1043 Pinole PD little hallway outside of server room (Wattage Selectable 20w, 25w, 30w) LED 2' Linear Wrap Fixture,Color Selectable (3500K, 4000K, 5000K) , UNV 20.2 w 1 1 36 w 63.9% 37.33 $12.92 10in can w 2 cfl 62 w 4 6 5 / 1564 fire station 73 2nd floor hallway LED 10" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, UNV,REC 28 w 4 4 136 w 54.8% 212.74 $73.61 10in can w 1 cfl 34 w 4 6 5 / 1564 fire station 73 2nd floor exercise room LED 10" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, UNV,REC 28 w 4 4 24 w 17.6% 37.54 $12.99 10in can w 2 cfl 62 w 4 6 5 / 1564 fire station 73 2nd floor living room LED 10" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, UNV,REC 28 w 4 4 136 w 54.8% 212.74 $73.61 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 9 24 7 / 8724 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) jail hallway LED 4' Linear Wrap Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 23.9 w 9 9 316 w 59.5% 2,755.76 $953.45 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 2 24 7 / 8724 public safety building stairwell LED 4' Linear Wrap Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 23.9 w 2 2 70 w 59.5% 612.39 $211.88 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 3 8 5 / 1998 city hall 1st floor mens bathroom LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 3 3 81 w 60.0% 161.81 $55.99 8in can w 2 cfl 31 w 3 6 4 / 1185 city hall 1st floor mens bathroom LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 3 3 39 w 41.9% 46.23 $16.00 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 3 8 5 / 1998 city hall 1st floor womens bathroom LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 3 3 81 w 60.0% 161.81 $55.99 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 2 8 4.5 / 1789 city hall 1st floor printer room LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 2 2 54 w 60.0% 96.61 $33.43 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 1 1 2 / 93 city hall 1st floor storage room LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 1 1 27 w 60.0% 2.52 $0.87 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 1 1 4 / 198 city hall 1st floor storage closet LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 1 1 27 w 60.0% 5.33 $1.85 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 3 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor cubicle offices LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 3 3 81 w 60.0% 163.04 $56.41 8in can w 2 cfl - 45 w 1 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 1 1 27 w 60.0% 54.35 $18.80 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 5 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor 1st floor front desk LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 5 5 135 w 60.0% 240.05 $83.05 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 4 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor hallway LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 4 4 108 w 60.0% 192.04 $66.44 8in can w 2 cfl 26 w 13 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor lobby/stairwell landing LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 13 13 104 w 30.8% 184.93 $63.98 8in can w 2 cfl 26 w 9 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor finance dept lobby LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 9 9 72 w 30.8% 128.03 $44.30 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 13 5 4 / 988 city hall first floor community room LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 13 13 351 w 60.0% 346.74 $119.97 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 2 20 7 / 7080 city hall first floor mens bathroom LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 2 2 54 w 60.0% 382.32 $132.28 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 2 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor womens bathroom LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 2 2 54 w 60.0% 64.01 $22.15 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 11 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor entrance lobby LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 11 11 297 w 60.0% 528.11 $182.72 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 6 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor lobby LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 6 6 162 w 60.0% 288.06 $99.66 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 6 3 3 / 436 city hall first floor stoeage room LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 6 6 162 w 60.0% 70.68 $24.45 8in can w 2 cfl 45 w 12 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor council chambers LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 12 12 324 w 60.0% 384.08 $132.89 9in can w 2 cfl 66 w 14 11 7 / 4100 city hall front walkway LED 8" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 18 w 14 14 672 w 72.7% 2,754.99 $953.18 lb w 1 a19 incandescent 100 w 1 1 1 / 52 Pinole PD storage closet LED 9in Low Bay, 4000K, UNV 13 w 1 1 87 w 0.0% - $0.00 2x2 w 2 t8 utube 54 w 21 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor hallway LED Troffer 2x2,Retrofit Kit 35K, 40K, 50K, UNV, REC 17 w 21 21 777 w 68.5% 1,381.62 $478.02 2x2 w 2 t8 utube 54 w 22 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor hallway LED Troffer 2x2,Retrofit Kit 35K, 40K, 50K, UNV, REC 17 w 22 22 787 w 67.8% 1,399.40 $484.17 2x2 w 2 t8 utube 54 w 6 5 4 / 988 city hall first floor community room LED Troffer 2x2,Retrofit Kit 35K, 40K, 50K, UNV, REC 17 w 6 6 222 w 68.5% 219.30 $75.88 2x2 w 2 t8 utube 54 w 6 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor hallway LED Troffer 2x2,Retrofit Kit 35K, 40K, 50K, UNV, REC 17 w 6 6 222 w 68.5% 394.75 $136.58 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room LED Troffer 2x4 Retrofit Kit, 3500K, 4000K, 5000K, UNV, REC 20 w 2 2 78 w 66.1% 341.64 $118.20 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 8 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD dispatch office LED Troffer 2x4 Retrofit Kit, 3500K, 4000K, 5000K, UNV, REC 26 w 8 8 504 w 0.0% - $0.00 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 5 24 7 / 8724 fire station 73 2nd floor hallway LED Troffer 2x4 Retrofit Kit, 3500K, 4000K, 5000K, UNV, REC 26 w 5 5 315 w 70.8% 2,747.90 $950.73 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor mens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor mens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 3ft lin w 1 t8. 0 w 1 8 5 / 1998 city hall 1st floor womens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor womens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor break room/kitchen Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor printer room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor storage closet Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 double switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor cubicle offices Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor file storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 8switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor 1st floor front desk Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor conference room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor server room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor hallway to roof access Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 1st floor electrical room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 5switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor finance dept lobby Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 double switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor cubicles Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 double switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor conference room Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 double switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor file room Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor printer room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor storage closet Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 1 3 4 / 593 city hall 2nd floor womens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office 2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
# of
Lamps
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 27,508 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.35 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 0 KWh
Saved
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office 2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
# of
Lamps
LED 3ft lin w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 1 3 4 / 593 city hall 2nd floor womens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor womens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor genderr neutral bathrpom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor city managers office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor city attorney office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor community room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor mens bathroom Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor mens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor womens bathroom Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor womens bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor stoeage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor office behind chambers Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor storage closet Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 6in can w 1 par38 0 w 28 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor council chambers Skip 0 w 28 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 5in can w 1 par38 0 w 14 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor council chambers Skip 0 w 14 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 switches 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor council chambers Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED single head pole w 1 corncob 0 w 11 12 7 / 4248 city hall around city hall Skip 0 w 11 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 8 10 5 / 2497 Pinole PD reception cubicles Skip 0 w 8 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD reception cubicles Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD server room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD community outreach office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD dispatch kitchen Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD dispatch bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD admin office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD admin conference room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD storage closet Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 2 11 5 / 2747 Pinole PD hallway Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD detective office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD detective office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD interview office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD interview office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD training office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 Pinole PD training office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 2 4 7 / 1416 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) mens restroom Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) mens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 6 12 7 / 4248 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) stairwell/end of hallway Skip 0 w 6 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) stairwell/end of hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) stairwell/end of hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) office area at top of stairwell Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) archive file room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) interview room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 corncob, 1 cfl 0 w 2 4 5 / 999 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) hallway/lobby Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) hallway/lobby Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 5 4 7 / 1416 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) hallway to armory Skip 0 w 5 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence locker Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) mens locker room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) mens locker room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin w 2 t8 retrotube 0 w 24 2 7 / 708 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) gym Skip 0 w 24 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) gym Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) armory Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 8in can w 1 a19 0 w 11 12 7 / 4248 breezeway between fire and police dept breezeway Skip 0 w 11 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED wp w 1 corncob 0 w 6 12 7 / 4248 public safety building (fire station 73) back driveway Skip 0 w 6 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 8in can w 1 a19 0 w 3 12 7 / 4248 public safety building public parking side of building Skip 0 w 3 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8 retrotube 0 w 2 4 5 / 999 post office mens restroom Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED vanity w 2 a19 0 w 1 4 5 / 999 post office mens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 27,508 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.35 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 0 KWh
Saved
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office 2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
# of
Lamps
LED 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8 retrotube 0 w 1 1 5 / 250 post office janitorial Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 0 w 2 2 3 / 291 post office office/storage room Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 3 t8 retrotube 0 w 4 9 5 / 2247 post office postmaster office Skip 0 w 4 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 0 w 1 3 5 / 749 post office womens restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 0 w 6 4 5 / 999 post office break room Skip 0 w 6 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 lb w 1 a19 incandescent 0 w 1 1 1 / 41 post office storage room above mens restroom/janitorial closet Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED all fixtures 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 post office loading dock Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8 retrotube 0 w 9 9 5 / 2247 post office PO box area Skip 0 w 9 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8 retrotube 0 w 2 9 5 / 2247 post office PO box area Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 hb w 2 cfl ppl 0 w 3 9 5 / 2247 post office retail lobby Skip 0 w 3 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED hb w 2 a19 0 w 4 12 7 / 4248 post office front overhang Skip 0 w 4 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED vanity w 2 a19 0 w 2 12 7 / 4248 post office front overhang Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED wp w 1 a19 0 w 2 12 7 / 4248 post office city hall side of building Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 unable to get on roof, no access beyond crane or scissor lift0 w 0 0 0 / 0 post office engineering Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 electrical room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 mechanical room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 server room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 5 switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 apparztus room (garage) Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 medical storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 laundry room/workshop Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 1 3 7 / 1062 fire station 73 bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 11 12 7 / 4248 police dept 1st floor lobby Skip 0 w 11 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 police dept 1st floor elevator mechanical room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 police dept 1st floor restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8 retrotube 0 w 1 4 5 / 999 police dept 1st floor restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 police dept 1st floor restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 triple switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 police dept 1st floor conference room Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 police dept 1st floor storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor workout room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor restroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor office/storage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2 triple switches 0 w 2 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom Skip 0 w 2 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor office Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor hallway Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor laundry room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 triple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor kitchen/dining room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor bathroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED 10in can w 1 a19 0 w 4 2 5 / 499 fire station 73 2nd floor bathroom Skip 0 w 4 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor mechanical room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 fire station 73 2nd floor hose bay Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 tripple switch 0 w 1 0 0 / 0 city hall first floor stoeage room Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 wp w 2 t4 halogen 90 w 5 3 4 / 593 city hall first floor council chamber hallway LED Half Moon Sconce, 4000K, UNV 12 w 5 5 390 w 0.0% - $0.00 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 1 1 2 / 93 city hall 1st floor storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 31.5 w 1 3 58 w 64.6% 5.36 $1.86 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 6 4 / 1185 city hall 1st floor break room/kitchen 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 31.5 w 4 12 230 w 64.6% 272.65 $94.33 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 1 2 2 / 187 city hall 1st floor file storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 31.5 w 1 3 58 w 64.6% 10.73 $3.71 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 4 4 / 790 city hall 1st floor conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 90.88 $31.44 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 1 1 / 41 city hall 2nd floor several room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 4.73 $1.64 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 1 / 41 city hall 1st floor electrical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 0.84 $0.29 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 4 / 198 city hall 2nd floor storage closet 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 4.05 $1.40 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 5 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor elevator/bathroom lobby 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 5 5 103 w 66.1% 182.26 $63.06 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 7 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor lobby 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 7 7 144 w 66.1% 255.16 $88.28 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 1 / 41 city hall first floor storage closet 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 0.84 $0.29 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 7 / 1460 Pinole PD dispatch bathroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 55.48 $19.20 4ft lin w 1 t12. 43 w 1 1 1 / 52 police dept 1st floor elevator mechanical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 33 w 75.6% 1.69 $0.59 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 4 6 5 / 1564 fire station 73 2nd floor bathroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 237.77 $82.27 1x4 w 2 t8. 31 w 15 6 4 / 1185 city hall first floor council chamber hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 15 15 308 w 66.1% 364.52 $126.12 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 3 10 4 / 2086 Pinole PD office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 3 6 114 w 64.4% 237.77 $82.27 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 4 / 2086 Pinole PD office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 158.51 $54.84 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 4 / 2086 Pinole PD office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 158.51 $54.84 4ft lin wrap w 2 2ft t5. 34 w 1 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) office area at top of stairwell 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 13 w 38.2% 56.94 $19.70 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 8 10 5 / 2607 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 8 16 304 w 64.4% 792.57 $274.22 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 6 3 3 / 469 fire station 73 mechanical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 6 6 123 w 66.1% 57.72 $19.97 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 5 12 7 / 4380 fire station 73 apparztus room (garage) 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 5 10 190 w 64.4% 832.20 $287.93 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 2 3 7 / 1095 fire station 73 medical storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 2 2 41 w 66.1% 44.90 $15.53 4ft lin w 2 t8. 59 w 4 5 7 / 1825 fire station 73 laundry room/workshop 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 277.40 $95.98 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 9 5 / 2346 fire station 73 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 178.33 $61.70 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 4 8 5 / 1998 city hall 1st floor mens bathroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 4 4 82 w 66.1% 163.81 $56.68
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 27,508 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.35 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 0 KWh
Saved
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office 2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
# of
Lamps
4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 3 8 5 / 1998 city hall 1st floor womens bathroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 3 3 62 w 66.1% 122.86 $42.51 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 8 4.5 / 1789 city hall 1st floor printer room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 135.97 $47.05 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 231.47 $80.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 306.73 $106.12 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 6 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor cubicle offices 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 6 18 345 w 64.6% 694.41 $240.26 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 231.47 $80.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 231.47 $80.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 231.47 $80.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 231.47 $80.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 9 4.5 / 2013 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 347.21 $120.13 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 1 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 1 3 58 w 64.6% 102.24 $35.37 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 6 9 4 / 1778 city hall 1st floor 1st floor front desk 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 6 18 345 w 64.6% 613.46 $212.25 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 1 8 4 / 1581 city hall 2nd floor hallway to roof access 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 1 3 58 w 64.6% 90.88 $31.44 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 11 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor finance dept lobby 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 11 33 633 w 64.6% 1,124.68 $389.12 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 4 12 230 w 64.6% 408.97 $141.50 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 6 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor cubicles 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 6 17 326 w 62.5% 560.71 $194.00 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 3 2 / 280 city hall 2nd floor conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 4 12 230 w 64.6% 64.37 $22.27 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 4 4 / 790 city hall 2nd floor file room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 4 11 211 w 61.4% 158.32 $54.78 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 10 4 / 1976 city hall 2nd floor printer room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 227.21 $78.61 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 3 4 / 593 city hall 2nd floor genderr neutral bathrpom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 12.15 $4.20 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor city managers office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 306.73 $106.12 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 1 / 370 city hall 2nd floor city attorney office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 42.58 $14.73 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 204.49 $70.75 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 10 4 / 1976 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 227.21 $78.61 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 10 4 / 1976 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 4 12 230 w 64.6% 454.41 $157.22 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 4 10 4 / 1976 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 4 12 230 w 64.6% 454.41 $157.22 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 204.49 $70.75 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 28.8% 30.23 $10.46 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 135.14 $46.76 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 1 9 4 / 1778 city hall 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 1 3 58 w 64.6% 102.24 $35.37 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor office behind chambers 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 204.49 $70.75 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 4 3 / 626 Pinole PD server room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 47.55 $16.45 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 3 / 626 Pinole PD server room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 23.78 $8.23 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 5 / 2607 Pinole PD community outreach office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 198.14 $68.55 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 3 7 / 1095 Pinole PD dispatch break room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 41.61 $14.40 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 3 7 / 1095 Pinole PD dispatch break room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 41.61 $14.40 4ft lin w 1 t12. 43 w 1 4 5 / 1043 Pinole PD dispatch kitchen 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 33 w 75.6% 33.89 $11.73 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 11 5 / 2868 Pinole PD admin office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 108.98 $37.70 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 4 11 5 / 2868 Pinole PD admin office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 435.91 $150.82 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 6 5 / 1564 Pinole PD admin conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 269.84 $93.36 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 13 12 5 / 3129 Pinole PD criminal investivations office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 13 26 494 w 64.4% 1,545.52 $534.72 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 5 / 3129 Pinole PD criminal investivations office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 237.77 $82.27 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 5 / 3129 Pinole PD detective office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 237.77 $82.27 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 5 / 3129 Pinole PD detective office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 237.77 $82.27 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 3 / 626 Pinole PD interview office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 23.78 $8.23 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 3 / 626 Pinole PD interview office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 23.78 $8.23 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 5 / 2607 Pinole PD training office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 198.14 $68.55 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 10 5 / 2607 Pinole PD training office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 449.73 $155.60 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) office area at top of stairwell 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 332.88 $115.17 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 3 3 / 469 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) archive file room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 17.83 $6.17 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 3 3 / 469 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) archive file room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 35.67 $12.34 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 2 3 3 / 469 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) archive file room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 35.67 $12.34 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 332.88 $115.17 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 3 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 3 6 114 w 64.4% 499.32 $172.76 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 166.44 $57.59 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 1 1 / 52 public safety building 2nd floor (police dept) interview room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 1.98 $0.69 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 5 / 2607 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 198.14 $68.55 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 10 10 5 / 2607 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) evidence locker 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 10 20 380 w 60.8% 935.97 $323.83 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 20 9 7 / 3285 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) mens locker room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 20 40 760 w 64.4% 2,496.60 $863.79 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 14 9 7 / 3285 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) mens locker room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 14 28 532 w 64.4% 1,747.62 $604.65 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 13 12 7 / 4380 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 13 26 494 w 64.4% 2,163.72 $748.61 4fr lin w 2 t8. 59 w 2 2 7 / 730 public safety building 1st floor (police dept) armory 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 55.48 $19.20 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 12 7 / 4380 fire station 73 hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 89.79 $31.07 4ft lin w 2 t8. 59 w 4 1 1 / 52 fire station 73 server room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 7.93 $2.74 4ft lin w 1 t12. 43 w 1 12 7 / 4380 fire station 73 apparztus room (garage) 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 33 w 75.6% 142.35 $49.25 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 1 4 5 / 1043 police dept 1st floor restroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 21.38 $7.40 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 16 4 3 / 626 police dept 1st floor conference room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 16 32 608 w 64.4% 380.43 $131.62 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 3 1 1 / 52 police dept 1st floor storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 3 9 173 w 64.6% 8.99 $3.11 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 9 5 / 2346 fire station 73 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 89.16 $30.85 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 9 5 / 2346 fire station 73 2nd floor workout room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 28.8% 39.89 $13.80 4ft lin w 2 t8. 59 w 1 3 5 / 782 fire station 73 2nd floor restroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 29.72 $10.28 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 6 5 / 1564 fire station 73 2nd floor office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 1 19 w 28.8% 13.30 $4.60 1x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 3 3 / 469 fire station 73 2nd floor office/storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 17.83 $6.17 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 3 3 / 469 fire station 73 2nd floor office/storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 35.67 $12.34
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Communiyt Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 27,508 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.35 /kWh
Customer Email: [email protected] 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 0 KWh
Saved
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - City Hall, Police Department, Fire Station 73 & Post Office 2131 Pear St
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 1194267547; SAID: 1196945891
# of
Lamps
2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 4 6 7 / 2190 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 332.88 $115.17 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 5 / 1043 fire station 73 2nd floor laundry room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 39.63 $13.71 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 5 9 5 / 2346 fire station 73 2nd floor kitchen/dining room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 5 10 190 w 64.4% 445.82 $154.25 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 2 3 / 313 fire station 73 2nd floor mechanical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 6.41 $2.22 2x4 w 2 t8. 59 w 2 4 7 / 1460 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 110.96 $38.39 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 4 7 / 1460 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 167.90 $58.09 2x4 w 3 t8. 89 w 2 4 7 / 1460 fire station 73 2nd floor bedroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 31.5 w 2 6 115 w 64.6% 167.90 $58.09 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 6 12 7 / 4380 fire station 73 2nd floor hose bay 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 6 12 228 w 64.4% 998.64 $345.51 4ft lin w 1 t12. 43 w 4 1 3 / 156 fire station 73 electrical room LED 8' Linear Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 32 w 2 2 108 w 62.8% 16.89 $5.85 4ft lin w 4 t8. 112 w 26 12 7 / 4380 fire station 73 apparztus room (garage) LED 8' Linear Fixture, 35K, 4K, 5K, UNV 32 w 13 13 2,496 w 85.7% 10,932.49 $3,782.48 3ft lin w 1 t8. 26 w 1 3 4 / 593 city hall 2nd floor genderr neutral bathrpom 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 1 1 14 w 53.8% 8.30 $2.87 3ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 26 w 2 20 7 / 7080 city hall first floor mens bathroom 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 2 2 28 w 53.8% 198.24 $68.59 3ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 26 w 2 20 7 / 7080 city hall first floor womens bathroom 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 2 2 28 w 53.8% 198.24 $68.59 3ft lin w 1 t8. 26 w 4 9 4 / 1778 city hall first floor lobby 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 4 4 56 w 53.8% 99.58 $34.45 3ft lin w 1 t8. 26 w 2 3 4 / 593 city hall first floor bathroom 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 2 2 28 w 53.8% 16.60 $5.74 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 0 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
Totals 925 Ave: 3288 w 911 24,507 w 66.6% 57,703.60 $19,964.57 24,507 Estimated Watts Saved Total Project Cost $194,030.05 Approximate Energy Savings Per Month 57,704 Estimated Annual kWh Saved Total After Rebate/Incentive Project Cost $194,030.05 Estimated Energy Savings Per Year
7.0 Estimated Avg Annual Res Powered by Savings ****Estimated Program Payback Period Yrs. 9.72 **Estimated Total Savings Over 5 Years 43 Estimated Annual CO2 Savings (MT) ** Estimated Total Savings After 10 Years 15,624,371 Estimated Btu Savings Per Month Estimated Energy Rebate
66.6% Estimated Average Electrical Savings Estimated IRS Tax Deduction 179D Available
10.3% Estimated ***Estimated Federal Tax Savings
9.72 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. - No Rebates, Tax Deductions or Bulb Replacement Savings Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Year
9.21 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. Fully Comprehensive^ ^^ Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Avg. Est. Life of LED Estimated Loan Payment
*** Based on IRS 179D Deduction @ 35% federal tax rate NOTE: Attached calculations do not include depreciation deduction for project cost. ****Program Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Program Rebates or Incentives) / Estimated $ Saved per Year *Payment is based on a 9.72 year loan at 0% interest OAC, actual my vary. ^Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Rebate or Incentive - Tax Savings) / (Estimated Savings Per Year + Bulb Replacement Savings Per Yr.) ** Reflects energy savings per year increasing at industry standard 6% per year + Bulb Replacement ^^Based on industry standard LED lifespan of 50,000 hrs. $468.70
$46,775.26
$5,776.68
$112,542.13
$263,148.88
$0.00
$16,504.80
$1,644.32
$1,663.71
$19,964.57
Site Five: Senior Center
Figure 1.5. City of Pinole – Senior Center, 2500 Charles Ave, Pinole, CA 94564.
EcoGreen’s scope of work will include retrofitting the facility’s walk-in coolers by replacing the existing PSC evaporator fan motors with high-efficiency electronically commutated permanent magnet (EC) motors. These EC motor retrofits provide integrated speed control to optimize airflow and energy use in response to refrigeration load, improving performance while reducing power draw and heat gain in the refrigerated space. EcoGreen will also replace outdated lighting with modern, energy-efficient LED fixtures. Together, these upgrades will improve overall energy efficiency, reduce operating costs, and enhance the building’s environmental sustainability.
Quote
201336
27671 La Paz Rd, Suite 100 11/12/2025
Laguna Niguel, CA. 92677
[email protected]
(949) 364 - 6800
Quotes are valid for 30 days from the above date.
EGMT-GW9-1/15H-OG Interior EC Motor 1/15 HP Cooler, 0 w 6 $335.00 $2,010.00 EGCT-GWCL-FCTL 0 Fan Motor Controller 0 w 3 $397.00 $1,191.00 EGTU-TS12-3ft-5000-UNV-T8-B Interior 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 12 w 6 $13.59 $81.54 EGTU-TC10-4ft-5000-T8-B Interior 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 225 $9.97 $2,243.25 EGCL-ML11-8"-CS-UNV-REC Interior LED 8" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, REC 11 w 1 $115.00 $115.00 EGTU-TC10-4ft-4000-T8-B Interior 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 6 $9.97 $59.82 EGCL-ML10-6"-CS-UNV-REC Interior LED 6" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 10 w 2 $105.00 $210.00 EGPL-GC10.5-3500-UNV-H Interior LED Horizontal PL Replacement, 3500K, UNV, w/ 2 Pin Adaptor 10 w 32 $23.00 $736.00 EGTU-TC9-2ft-5000-T8-B Interior 2' T8 LED Tube Single Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K 9 w 8 $11.49 $91.92 EGTL-LT8.7-3000-120V-WHT-H Interior LED Spot Track Lighting, 3000K, UNV, White, H-System 8.7 w 10 $197.00 $1,970.00 EGWP-ML15-CS-UNV-PH Exterior LED Wallpack, 4K, 5K, UNV, PH 15.5 w 5 $115.00 $575.00 EGCP-AL27-5000-UNV Exterior LED Canopy Light, 5000K, UNV 27 w 2 $155.00 $310.00 EGED-X-X 0 Emergency Driver 0 w 10 $150.00 $1,500.00
EGTU-TC10-4ft-3500-T8-B Interior 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 2 $9.97 $19.94 EGTU-TC10-4ft-3500-T8-B Interior 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 2 $9.97 $19.94 EGTU-ML16-2ft-5000-U-A Interior 2' U-Bend Lamp (Type B) 5000K 15.5 w 28 $29.75 $833.00 0 0 0 0 w 0 $0.00 $0.00
0 0 0 0 w 0 $0.00 $0.00
* All quantities to be verified by owner SUBTOTAL $11,966.41 LABOR $31,486.56
SALES TAX Included
(Brackets, Wiring, Sockets, Electrician Travel, Tiewire, Screws, Lifts, Lamp Recycling / Disposal, Shipping, Package, ETC.) MISC. CHARGES $8,788.34 3rd Party QA Review $2,000.00
TOTAL PROJECT COST $54,241.31
Estimated IRS Federal Tax Deduction per 179D: $4,440.60 Estimated Annual Energy Savings: $5,491.30
SIGNATURE: _________________________________________________________________________________ DATE:___________________________ WHEN SIGNED OR APPROVED BY CLIENT, THIS FORM BECOMES AN OFFICIAL ORDER AND A LEGALLY BINDING COMMITMENT SUBJECT TO THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS FORM. BY ACCEPTING THIS PROJECT AND MOVING FORWARD, CUSTOMER AGREES TO HAVE ECOGREEN SOLUTIONS PURCHASE AND INSTALL THE PRODUCTS LISTED ABOVE. All returned checks are subject to a $20 service charge. If customer is utilizing a utility program where they default or get disqualified post install and the pre approved utility funding is canceled, the customer is liable for the project amount in full and the terms and conditions above will need to be met. Subject to collections and or litigation. If this invoice is not paid in full when due, a 1.5% per month late charge will be imposed. In this event, customer will be liable to pay reasonable collection charge, attorney fee and court cost. Warranty to be serviced by factory (see EcoGreen Scope of Work and warranty statement provided by the factory).
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Quote #
DATE
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Senior Center
Amount
2500 Charles Ave
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 9840139961; SAID: 9845996180
Light EPN INT/
EXT DESCRIPTION QTY* Unit Price
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Community Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 7,401 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.39 /kWh
Customer Email: 0 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 201336 KWh
Saved
3ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 46 w 3 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center Room 113. 3' T8 LED Tube Bypass (Type B), 5000K, UNV 24 w 3 6 66 w 47.8% 164.34 $64.64 1 triple switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center Room 113. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 2 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center entrance/exit hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 189.24 $74.43 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage/mechanical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 0.84 $0.33 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage/mechanical room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t12. 72 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage/IT room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 51 w 70.8% 2.09 $0.82 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage/IT room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 2 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage/electrical room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 2 2 41 w 66.1% 1.68 $0.66 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage/electrical room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center furnace room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 0.84 $0.33 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center furnace room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 11 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center front lobby/reception 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 11 11 226 w 66.1% 561.50 $220.85 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 28 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center main lobby 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 28 28 574 w 66.1% 1,429.26 $562.17 1 quad switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center main lobby Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 8in can w 2 cfl 17 w 1 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center alcove (in front lobby) LED 8" Can Downlight,2700K,3000K,3500K,4000K,5000K, REC 11 w 1 1 6 w 35.3% 14.94 $5.88 8ft lin wrap w 2 4ft t8. 59 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage closet 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 1.56 $0.61 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage closet Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 w 1 t8. 31 w 6 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center office hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 4000K, UNV 10.5 w 6 6 123 w 66.1% 306.27 $120.46 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 2 6 1 / 246 Pinole Senior Center salon 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 18.70 $7.35 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center salon Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 3 5 / 747 Pinole Senior Center janitorial closet 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 15.31 $6.02 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center janitorial closet Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 3.5 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center administrative office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 3.5 7 133 w 59.3% 305.03 $119.98 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center administrative office Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 4 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center recreation coordinator office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 378.48 $148.87 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center recreation coordinator office Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 2 4 3 / 580 Pinole Senior Center room 103. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 44.08 $17.34 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 4 4 3 / 580 Pinole Senior Center room 103. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 88.16 $34.68 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center room 103. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 2 6 5 / 1494 Pinole Senior Center break room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 113.54 $44.66 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center break room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 4 4 3 / 580 Pinole Senior Center directors office 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 88.16 $34.68 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center directors office Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 2 3 5 / 747 Pinole Senior Center employee restroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 56.77 $22.33 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center employee restroom Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 1 8 5 / 1992 Pinole Senior Center office exit hallway 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 75.70 $29.77 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 1 4 3 / 580 Pinole Senior Center lobby to activity room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 22.04 $8.67 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center lobby to activity room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 0.84 $0.33 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 2 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage room 110. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 2 4 76 w 64.4% 3.12 $1.23 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room 110. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 4 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage room 111. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 6.23 $2.45 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room 111. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 4 4 5 / 996 Pinole Senior Center small activity room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 151.39 $59.55 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 4 4 5 / 996 Pinole Senior Center small activity room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 4 4 82 w 66.1% 81.67 $32.12 1 triple switch, 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center small activity room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t12. 72 w 1 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 51 w 70.8% 25.40 $9.99 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 10.21 $4.02 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 0.5 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center lobby for restrooms, room 100. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 0.5 1 19 w 28.8% 21.17 $8.32 8in can w 2 cfl 31 w 2 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center lobby for restrooms, room 100. LED 6" Can Downlight 2700K/3000K/3500K/4000K/5000K, 120-277V WITH 0-10V DIMMING 10 w 2 2 42 w 67.7% 104.58 $41.13 4ft lin wrap w 1 t8. 31 w 5 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center mens restroom 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 5 5 103 w 59.4% 229.08 $90.10 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center mens restroom Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4x4 w 4 t8. 112 w 14 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center room 100. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 42 w 14 56 980 w 57.1% 2,231.04 $877.53 sconce w 2 cfl 31 w 15 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center room 100. LED Horizontal PL Replacement, 3500K, UNV, w/ 2 Pin Adaptor 20 w 15 30 165 w 31.2% 361.05 $142.01 2x2 w 2 t8 utube 59 w 14 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center kitchen 2' U-Bend Lamp (Type B) 5000K 31 w 14 28 392 w 47.5% 976.08 $383.92 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center kitchen Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED vpt jelly jar w 1 a19 0 w 7 6 5 / 1494 Pinole Senior Center kitchen Skip 0 w 7 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 double switch, 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center kitchen Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 1 1 5 / 249 Pinole Senior Center janitorial closet 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 3500K, UNV 10.5 w 1 1 21 w 66.1% 5.10 $2.01 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center janitorial closet Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED vpt jelly jar w 1 a19 0 w 1 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center out of commission walk-in Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center out of commission walk-in Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 ECM's 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center out of commission walk-in EC Motor 1/15 HP Cooler, 0 w 0 - - w 13.1% 494.00 $194.30 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 1.5 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center office/storage room 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1.5 3 57 w 52.5% 23.16 $9.11 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center office/storage room Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 59 w 4 6 5 / 1494 Pinole Senior Center dishes area 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 227.09 $89.32 1 double switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center dishes area Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED vpt jelly jar w 1 a19 0 w 1 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center walk in fridge Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center walk in fridge Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 ECM's 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center walk in fridge EC Motor 1/15 HP Cooler, 0 w 0 - - w 13.1% 494.00 $194.30 LED vpt jelly jar w 1 a19 0 w 1 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center walk in freezer Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center walk in freezer Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 ECM's 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center walk in freezer Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED wrap 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room (led) Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 2ft lin wrap w 2 t8. 33 w 4 6 5 / 1494 Pinole Senior Center dishes area 2' T8 LED Tube Single Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K 18 w 4 8 60 w 45.5% 89.64 $35.26 track lighting w1 a19 40 w 10 6 5 / 1494 Pinole Senior Center gift shop LED Spot Track Lighting, 3000K, UNV, White, H-System 8.7 w 10 10 313 w 78.3% 467.62 $183.93 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 1 2 5 / 498 Pinole Senior Center storage hallway room 100. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 1 2 38 w 64.4% 18.92 $7.44 single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage hallway room 100. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 4ft lin w 1 t8. 31 w 2 1 1 / 41 Pinole Senior Center storage room in room 100. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 10.5 w 2 2 41 w 66.1% 1.68 $0.66 Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Senior Center
2500 Charles Ave
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 9840139961; SAID: 9845996180
# of
Lamps
EcoGreen Sales Rep: Andrew Guercio 0
Customer Contact: Lilly Whalen 0
Title of Contact: Community Dev. Director 0 Approx. Building Size 7,401 SF Customer Phone: 510-954-6450 0 Energy Rate $ 0.39 /kWh
Customer Email: 0 0 Interest Rate 0% 0 In Reference to Quote # 201336 KWh
Saved
Existing Operating
Hours-Day / Yr. Existing Watts/ Fix
# of
Fixtures
Watts/bulbs
Saved Room/Area Suggested Replacement Watts/Fix Usage Saved Suggested Replacements Savings
ENERGY AUDIT
EXISTING Location
Building/Zone Annual Savings # of
Fixtures
CITY OF PINOLE
City of Pinole - Senior Center
2500 Charles Ave
Pinole, CA 94564
Acct: 9840139961; SAID: 9845996180
# of
Lamps
single switch 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole Senior Center storage room in room 100. Skip 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 wp w 1 hps 66 w 3 11 7 / 4088 Pinole Senior Center building exterior LED Wallpack, 4K, 5K, UNV, PH 15.5 w 3 3 152 w 76.5% 619.40 $243.63 wp w 1 hps 66 w 2 11 7 / 4088 Pinole Senior Center building exterior LED Wallpack, 4K, 5K, UNV, PH 15.5 w 2 2 101 w 76.5% 412.93 $162.42 LED wp w 1 a19 0 w 18 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center building exterior Skip 0 w 18 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 lb w 1 hps 95 w 2 11 7 / 4088 Pinole Senior Center building exterior LED Canopy Light, 5000K, UNV 27 w 2 2 136 w 71.6% 556.03 $218.70 LED dual head pole w 2 corncob 0 w 3 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center parking lot Skip 0 w 3 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED single head pole w 1 corncob 0 w 7 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center walkway around building Skip 0 w 7 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED single head pole w 1 corncob 0 w 1 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center walkway around building Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED wp w 1 corncob 0 w 3 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center building exterior Skip 0 w 3 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 LED wp w 1 corncob 0 w 1 12 7 / 4236 Pinole Senior Center building exterior Skip 0 w 1 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 HVAC 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 Pinole senior center engineering PENDING 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 1x4 box w 2 t8. 59 w 4 10 5 / 2490 Pinole Senior Center Room 113. 4' T8 LED Tube Double Ended Bypass(Type B), 5000K, UNV 21 w 4 8 152 w 64.4% 378.48 $148.87 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 Emergency Driver 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 3rd Party QA Review 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00 ECM's 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 Cooler EC Motor 1/15 HP Cooler, 0 w 0 - - w 14.5% 494.00 $194.30 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 Fan Motor Controller 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% 532.88 $209.60 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 Fan Motor Controller 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% 532.88 $209.60 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 Fan Motor Controller 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% 532.88 $209.60 0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 0 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
0 0 w 0 0 0 / 0 0 0 0 0 w 0 - - w 0.0% - $0.00
Totals 228.5 Ave: 2888 w 228.5 5,708 w 47.9% 13,961.08 $5,491.30 5,708 Estimated Watts Saved Total Project Cost $54,241.31 Approximate Energy Savings Per Month 13,961 Estimated Annual kWh Saved Total After Rebate/Incentive Project Cost $54,241.31 Estimated Energy Savings Per Year
1.7 Estimated Avg Annual Res Powered by Savings ****Estimated Program Payback Period Yrs. 9.88 **Estimated Total Savings Over 5 Years 10 Estimated Annual CO2 Savings (MT) ** Estimated Total Savings After 10 Years - Estimated Btu Savings Per Month Estimated Energy Rebate
47.9% Estimated Average Electrical Savings Estimated IRS Tax Deduction 179D Available
10.1% Estimated ***Estimated Federal Tax Savings
9.88 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. - No Rebates, Tax Deductions or Bulb Replacement Savings Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Year
9.38 Estimated Payback Period Yrs. Fully Comprehensive^ ^^ Estimated Bulb Replacement Savings Per Avg. Est. Life of LED Estimated Loan Payment
*** Based on IRS 179D Deduction @ 35% federal tax rate NOTE: Attached calculations do not include depreciation deduction for project cost. ****Program Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Program Rebates or Incentives) / Estimated $ Saved per Year *Payment is based on a 9.88 year loan at 0% interest OAC, actual my vary. ^Payback Period Yrs. = (Total Project Cost - Available Rebate or Incentive - Tax Savings) / (Estimated Savings Per Year + Bulb Replacement Savings Per Yr.) ** Reflects energy savings per year increasing at industry standard 6% per year + Bulb Replacement ^^Based on industry standard LED lifespan of 50,000 hrs. $128.55
$90,538.32
$1,554.21
$30,954.97
$72,379.70
$0.00
$4,440.60
$452.01
$457.61
$5,491.30