Cities Index.
Minutes, regular meeting, third session

Bakersfield City Council
November 4, 2026

Document
Minutes, regular meeting, third session
Meeting
November 4, 2026
Body
Bakersfield City Council
Pages
223
Original file
412.7 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on pub-bakersfield.escribemeetings.com. That file is the official record.

the potential for 316,373 square feet of new retail building space in the pro-posed project to generate urban decay impacts.

For initial project submission, the proposed project included 423,292 square feet of commercial building space and 398,222 square feet of retail space that was analyzed.
1C. Methodology
Four steps make up the basic retail market analysis methodology used to as-sess the potential for urban decay impacts.

Define the Trade Area
In general terms, the trade area is the geographic area from which the retail center will draw most of its customers. Several factors affect the size and Figure 1: General Site Location
boundaries of the trade area, including the type of shopping center, location of competitive retail facilities, and visibility and access to major roads and high-ways.

The analysis considers not only the trade area for the proposed project but also the trade area for competitive facilities/districts that may be impacted by the new retail project.

Determine the Surplus/Gap Under Current Conditions
The analysis then calculates the difference between trade-area households’ consumer spending and retail sales at trade-area businesses to determine Site
'8
DI
CA43
D
afL 9
I
)
KernlRiver. Bakersfie h
. CA58
CA58
CA 43
aterBa
00 Acre—r MH ¥
CA184
FFE O- □
>119 A119 \ ,_
15 A I
WII
arkway
Park
Kern River
Oil Field
CA 58
CA 17
CA 58 Kern River
Parkway
--mi Park
CA99
• x
I
--—L
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 3 whether the market can currently support additional retail development. This is calculated for the proposed project’s trade area and the trade area for com-petitive facilities/districts.

Forecast Trade Area Growth
The analysis projects household growth in each trade area, typically five years out. This provides an assessment of the potential urban decay impacts over the short-term time frame for new retail buildings to be fully constructed and become fully occupied and operational.

Urban Decay Determination
The final step is to make a final determination of the proposed project’s poten-tial to cause urban decay impacts. 1D. Retail Types, Part 1: Convenience Goods
Generally, the goods and services that most people need on a regular basis (convenience goods and services) are close to where people live. For these regular purchases, most consumers have built up knowledge of where to go to get what they want, whether their discriminator is price and convenience (most often) or quality (on occasion). Groceries, medicines, and hair care are typical convenience goods and services. Because convenience goods and ser-vices usually have low cost margins and high sales volumes, convenience re-tailers are located throughout an area, close to concentrations of households.

Convenience-scale retail centers range from a single store to a small retail center of about 20,000 square feet. They typically have a convenience store as an anchor and draw from a trade area with about a half-mile radius.

Neighborhood-scale retail centers range from about 20,000 to 100,000 square feet in size. Pharmacies and supermarkets typically anchor neighbor-hood-scale shopping centers. The neighborhood trade area encompasses a 1½-mile radius, serving a population of up to 40,000 people within a 5- to 10-minute drive.
1E. Retail Types, Part 2: Comparison Goods
Consumers tend to compare goods across brands and across retailers for items they purchase infrequently or rarely. This habit of comparing induces re-tailers to locate near each other. It also promotes larger-scale retailers who can stock many different brands of similar products. Clothing, electronics, and furniture are quintessential comparison goods. Because comparison goods have higher cost margins and lower sales volumes and because consumers purchase these goods infrequently, comparison goods retailers tend to locate close to major transportation corridors that give access to a greater number of consumers. Table 1 describes the sizes and trade areas for the shopping cen-ter types that focus on comparison goods.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 4 ends

Table 1
Comparison Goods Shopping Center Types
Shopping Center Type Building Size Range
(sq. ft.)
Trade Area
Size
(radius in miles) Population Range
Community 100,000–450,000 3–5 40,000–150,000
Regional 300,000–900,000 8 150,000 or more
Super-regional 500,000–2 million 12 300,000 or more
Source: Beyard, Michael D. et al., Shopping Center Development Handbook, 3rd ed., Washington D.C.:

Urban Land Institute, 1999.
1F. Current Economic Conditions
The retail market is still evolving from the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, stay-at-home orders, and the subsequent round of inflation. As of the prepara-tion of this report, there were still active disagreements among economists as to whether the economy would go through a recession this year.

It is well beyond the scope of this type of analysis to prognosticate on the fu-ture trajectory of the economy. The primary focus of this analysis is current market conditions. The analysis also considers market conditions five years in the future. Bakersfield is a growing region, and if the economy slows or con-tracts, the five-year projects may take somewhat longer to materialize. How-ever, there is unlikely to be a wholesale change in the direction of the projec-tions for continued growth.

In its second quarter 2025 report on national retail trends, commercial bro-kerage CBRE Research noted that, nationally, the retail market was moderat-ing as retailers continue strategic rightsizing, despite continued strong demand for well-located, high-traffic centers. For Bakersfield, they noted that the retail availability rate was 5.9 percent, somewhat higher than the rate nationally, which was 4.9 percent.

Nevertheless, the region’s continued growth in jobs and households will keep Bakersfield attractive to national retail chains and support existing and new lo-cal independent businesses.

2. Retail Trade Areas
A trade area is the geographic area from which a retail center will draw the majority of its customers. Several factors affect the size and boundaries of the trade area, including the type of shopping center, location of competitive retail facilities, physical barriers, and visibility and access to major roads and high-ways. The radial definition of a trade area based on its scale (see the Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 5 discussion of retail markets on 3) provides the starting point for defining a trade area. As the Urban Land Institute (ULI) cautions, however, “A trade area does not lend itself to concentric circles around a potential site.”1 Different stores within a single retail center can have different trade areas. In-deed, the ability of anchor tenants to draw customers from a large trade area creates a valuable location for other retail tenants that typically draw from smaller trade areas. Market analyses conducted for specific retailers often sub-categorize the trade area into primary, secondary, and tertiary trade areas, us-ing lifestyle segmentation to provide a greater understanding of exactly where potential customers reside, to quantify how much of their spending a new store can likely capture, and to determine effective ways to communicate with these customers.

For the present level of analysis, however, we use a single aggregate trade area definition because we are analyzing total market demand for retail space, not demand for one particular tenant or one type of good or service. Further-more, at the entitlement stage, a developer will have few, if any, committed tenants. A market analysis using a tiered trade area defined for a particular tenant would shortchange the public interest in total market demand and pre-venting urban decay. 2A. Competitive Facilities
Because the proposed project qualifies as a community-scale shopping cen-ter, competitive facilities or districts are the community- and regional-scale shopping centers and areas with overlapping trade areas. The analysis identi-fied the following competitive facilities, which are show in Figure 2.

Community-Scale Shopping Centers/Areas, 3-Mile-Radius Trade Area • Bakersfield Plaza, California Ave. at the 99 Freeway
• Costco, Rosedale Hwy. at the 99 Freeway, Bakersfield
• Costco, Stine Rd. and Panama Lane, Bakersfield
• East Hills Commercial Area, Bernard St., Bakersfield
• Ming and Stine Commercial Area, Ming Ave. and Stine Rd., Bakersfield • The MarketPlace, Ming Ave., Bakersfield
• The Shops at River Walk, Stockdale Hwy., Bakersfield
• Walmart, Paso Robles Hwy, and Central Ave., Wasco
• Walmart, Tucker Rd., Tehachapi
• Walmart/Home Depot, Woolloms Ave., Delano
1 Michael D. Beyard et al., Shopping Center Development Handbook, 3rd ed. (Washington D.C.: Urban Land Institute, 1999), 46.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 6 ends

Community-Scale Shopping Centers/Areas, 5-Mile-Radius Trade Area • Gosford Village Shopping Center, Gosford and Harris Roads, Bakersfield • Northwest Promenade, Rosedale Hwy. and Coffee Ave., Bakersfield (across the street from the proposed project)
Regional-Scale Shopping Centers/Areas, 12-Mile-Radius Trade Area • Downtown Bakersfield (for simplicity, defined as the intersection of Ches-ter and Truxtun Avenues) • Valley Plaza Mall, Ming Ave. at the 99 Freeway, Bakersfield The classification of each shopping center or area reflects the size of the cen-ter or area and the types of stores.

The basic radial definition of trade areas leaves large rural expanses under-served by retail businesses. In reality, though, one of the aspects of rural liv-ing is driving much longer distance to purchase needed goods and services.

Even though the residents in Delano, Tehachapi, and Wasco have a nearby Walmart, is likely those residents regularly travel to Bakersfield to shop. The next section discusses how the trade areas are adjusted for the analysis to ac-count for some of this rural patronage.

The analysis does not directly assess the impact of the proposed project on every individual shopping center in Bakersfield. There are many convenience-scale shopping centers and many grocery store-anchored shopping centers.

However, most of the businesses in these centers do not compete directly with most of the businesses in the community- and regional-scale centers listed above. Even though individual trade areas are not defined and analyzed for each of these, the retail sales at these locations are accounted for.

To assess the potential for urban decay impacts, the analysis compares the proposed project (along with the adjacent Northwest Promenade) to the simi-lar-scale retail centers: Gosford Village Shopping Center, Downtown Bakers-field, and Valley Plaza Mall. Even though the analysis only defines a trade area for each of these, the trade area, and consequently the analysis of the potential for urban decay, includes all the shopping center and retail busi-nesses in each of the defined trade areas.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 7 Figure 2: Competitive Shopping Centers/Areas and Their Basic Trade Area Source: PlaceWorks, 2023.

I
15 Tenachapi ■f
Arvin
CA 58
I (
15 )9

A - ODSEM
66 VO
r 1 I Jeruer,l;— 7 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- — 7 t1 —--======7 rCITKIVEI W ) McFarland , _____ - / r / J I A . / y P( -19 ( _V. I CA" — m q A
-8L!
—
85 VO
J
S
<
A
-
“AS6,
ila ict
CA99
00-ATA Water
(5)
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 8 ends

2B. Proposed Project Trade Area
The proposed project alone would qualify as a community-scale shopping center. However, it should be viewed as part of the larger retail destination with the adjacent Northwest Promenade. This destination will have the size to qualify as a regional-scale shopping center, and it will likely develop a variety of retailers commensurate with a regional destination. Therefore, the analysis extends the defined trade are out eight miles to the north and to the west, which also reflects rural residents who will likely drive a longer distance.

The defined trade area is truncated to the south along Stockdale Hwy. and Westside Parkway. This reflects the competition from Gosford Village and the other community-scale shopping centers south of the Kern River. It also re-flects that natural and man-made barriers often influence where people are willing to drive to go shopping.

The trade area is also truncated to the east at the Kern River, the 99 Freeway, Airport Road, and Granite Road. Again, this reflects competition from Down-town Bakersfield and Valley Plaza Mall as well as the physical barriers of the river and major roads. Figure 3 shows the trade area defined for the proposed project. As defined, it encompasses almost 97 square miles. 2C. Gosford Village Trade Area
The trade area defined for Gosford Village is similarly extended out to eight miles to the west and south. This reflects both the lack of competitive facilities in those directions as well as the diversity of retail with the Gosford Village Trade Area. Both The Shops at River Walk and the MarketPlace have a variety of apparel stores that approaches what one might find at a conventional re-gional shopping mall. As well, there are cinemas at the MarketPlace and Bak-ersfield Plaza.

This trade area is truncated to the east at the 99 Freeway, reflecting the phys-ical boundary of the freeway and the competition at Valley Plaza Mall and Downtown Bakersfield. The trade area is also truncated to the north at the southern boundary of the trade area for the proposed project. Figure 4 shows the defined trade area boundary for Gosford Village. It includes over 122 square miles.
2D. Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall Trade Area
Downtown may not have the square footage of retail businesses nor the full variety of retail store types that characterize regional scale retail destinations.

However, it is a regional destination for a great many non-retail businesses, and those patronizing these other types of business are likely to spend some time and money while in Downtown. In contrast, Valley Plaza Mall is the Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 9 quintessential regional shopping destination. Thus, they should both be ana-lyzed with a 12-mile regional-scale trade area.

Due to the proximity of Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall, their trade areas nearly overlap. And where they do not overlap, the area is rural, with probably similar numbers of households and similarly few if any retail businesses.

Thus, the analysis uses a single-trade area to assess potential urban decay impacts. Figure 5 shows this regional trade area boundary. It encompasses over 450 square miles.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 10 ends

Figure 3: Proposed Project Trade Area
Source: PlaceWorks, 2023
J LAL -- Village A mis — CA 43 - West Ming
—-e-nerS-ar-7))) t 5S
r I
T
23 r
/
L Highgate-A
—2--------Du
)
I
• __ __IAIR NHo I7LI 25
—
2B —20
•—Dim-m
) 1 US
N \
XHm Jan, 7 ' LL
) 28 CA 43
•E dan
T M3 J CA 99
ft 311
CA 65
■
OD VJ By
*1
1 I
I
I
I!
If
—
pE Meadows .Field Airport
"River • arkway Park"Y
L&
2--=- L Bakersfield
282
—
A
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 11 Figure 4: Defined Trade Area for Gosford Village
Source: PlaceWorks, 2023.
s= 2E —Hanld 2B
i
E
DZ] Bakersfield
--- Tt • S
K
II
EW)
F
3 1
1o ll'
246
DE MME
—
LL - . H —
21 -=CA 119 CA119 i -__ J
15 /
239
CA 223
5 L
।
~A
Lt
443
F
F
1-
A 43
I
III
Highgate -=
West Ming
Village A
terrver
Parkway
—Park-River -3
arkway
-Park
2800)Acre
Water Bank
—==
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 12 ends

Figure 5: Defined Regional Trade Area for Downtown Bakersfield and Valley Plaza Mall Source: PlaceWorks, 2023.

3. Current Retail Market Demand
3A. Market Demand Generally
Retail market demand is the amount of new retail building space that spend-ing by trade area households can support. To determine demand, we use the opportunity gap/surplus. This is the difference between the amount of money that trade area households spend at each type of retail store and the amount of sales at those types of stores in the trade area. When the difference is CA 99
CA 65
CA 99
1 ■
1 ‘8
DI ]
CA 43
1 78- CA
Ker 'er Bakersfield—51
CA 58
Parkway Darwsv IdlKKern Biver "psway J
CA58 r Park ___ 11-
CA
— CA43- 800.Acre— aterBa
CA58
CA 184
—
3 119 GA 110 IT LAF 15
[
CA 99
15 CA 223 n
IF
Kern River
Oil Field
□
—
Arvi
(
____ CA99
• \
*
178
-
223
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 13 positive, it means that trade-area residents are spending more than stores are selling; thus, residents are shopping at stores outside of the trade area. This is considered to mean that there is an opportunity for existing stores to attract more customers or for new retail businesses to open. However, when the dif-ference is negative, it means that stores are attracting customers from outside of the trade area; thus, new stores would have to siphon spending away from existing stores or else attract new customers from farther away. 3A(i) Consumer Spending
We analyze spending at the household level because the household is the basic consumer unit. Each year, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) con-ducts and publishes the Consumer Expenditure Survey (CES), the primary data source for spending analyses. BLS reports the data, categorized by type of product or service.

The analysis uses spending data from Claritas, Inc., the leading national pro-vider of marketing data. Claritas starts with the basic CES data and adjusts it to reflect the particular demographics—such as household size and income— of the defined trade area. Claritas then reports the data, categorized by store type. The Claritas report also separates out telephone and internet expendi-tures from purchases at bricks-and-mortar stores. The underlying consumer spending data are provided in the Appendix in Table A-1, Table A-2, and Ta-ble A-3. 3A(ii) Average Sales Efficiency
Sales efficiency is the amount of sales generated per square foot of store floor area. The analysis uses data from the Urban Land Institute ULI) and the Inter-national Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC), as well as data from retail corpo-rations’ SEC filings and industry standards to estimate average sales effi-ciency. The sales efficiency data are adjusted for regional factors based on the most recent Economic Census.

With the MSA adjustment, the regional average sales efficiency across all re-tail store types is $362.13 per square foot. Older retail centers and stand-alone stores in the trade area probably capture a lower level of sales. New centers and the proposed project will likely capture a higher level of sales. In our calculations, however, we use the average sales efficiency to determine the total amount of retail building space, both old and new, that consumer spending can support.
3A(iii) How It Works
Simply dividing the trade area’s opportunity gap or surplus at each store type (as reported by Claritas) by the average sales efficiency determines the sup-portable square footage. Summing the results for all store types determines the market potential, or the total supportable retail building space.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 14 ends

3B. Existing Opportunity Gap/Surplus
The data Table A-1, Table A-2, and Table A-3 provide the estimated oppor-tunity gap or surplus for each type of store each trade area. However, for com-munity-scale shopping centers, it is not likely that they will capture 100 per-cent of trade-area residents’ consumer spending. Table A-4 provides assump-tions for the percentage of local consumer spending that the proposed project and the Gosford Village trade areas might expect to capture. These range from 50 percent for clothing stores to 90 percent for convenience goods, such as grocery stores. For the regional trade area, which extends beyond the city boundaries, it is reasonable to assume a full capture of trade area consumer spending.

Table 2 summarizes the estimated opportunity gap (positive data) or surplus (negative data) that could be available to support additional retail develop-ment in each of the three trade areas. Although each trade area has surplus for several retail store types, the bottom line is that there is a substantial amount of leaked spending in each trade area.

Table 2: Opportunity Gap/(Surplus) in Current Dollars by Store Type; Proposed Project Trade Area and Comparison Trade Areas; 2025 Estimate Proposed
Project
Trade Area
Gosford
Village
Trade Area
Regional
Downtown
Trade Area
Convenience Goods and Services
Food & Beverage Stores 125,800,000 128,700,000 207,000,000 Health & Personal Care Stores 39,000,000 49,700,000 32,000,000 Gasoline Stations 14,100,000 1,330,000 (327,000,000)
Miscellaneous Store Retailers 12,730,000 54,100,000 57,700,000 Subtotal 192,000,000 234,000,000 (29,800,000)
Comparison Goods and Services
Furniture & Home Furnishings Stores 6,880,000 22,200,000 62,000,000 Electronics & Appliance Stores 7,320,000 14,290,000 55,900,000 Bldg Materials, Garden Equip. & Supply (13,440,000) 31,600,000 114,900,000 Clothing & Clothing Accessories Stores 2,890,000 (2,616,000) 104,500,000 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Book & Music Stores 10,770,000 14,700,000 70,400,000 General Merchandise Stores (13,640,000) (4,560,000) 30,300,000 Subtotal 800,000 75,600,000 438,000,000
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 15 Table 2 continued
Proposed
Project
Trade Area
Gosford
Village
Trade Area
Regional
Downtown
Trade Area
Food and Drink
Drinking Places - Alcoholic Beverages 1,585,000 6,280,000 18,700,000 Full-service restaurants (4,007,000) 13,750,000 211,000,000 Limited-service restaurants (6,177,000) (51,600,000) (93,600,000) Subtotal (8,600,000) (31,560,000) 135,500,000
Total 184,000,000 278,000,000 544,000,000
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data from Claritas, the US Census Bureau Economic Census, 2017, and the US Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index and Producer Price Index. 3C. Current Market Demand
The current market demand is derived by dividing the opportunity gap or sur-plus for each store type by the average sales efficiency for that type of store.

Table 3 provides the estimated market demand for retail building space that could be supported by existing levels of consumer spending by residents in each of the trade areas.

The analysis indicates that the proposed project’s trade area could accommo-date up to 491,000 sq. ft. of additional retail building space supported by re-tail spending that currently leaks out of the trade area. Similarly, the trade area that encompasses Gosford Village and the other community-scale shop-ping centers south of the Kern River could accommodate another 864,000 square feet of retail building space, separate from the spending in the pro-posed project’s trade area.

Finally, the analysis indicates that the regional trade area, which encom-passes the proposed project trade area and the Gosford Village trade area, can accommodate 2.65 million square feet of retail building space, inclusive of the supportable space in the two trade areas. That works out to a net demand in the regional trade area of nearly 1.3 million square feet when excluding the trade areas for the proposed project and Gosford Village.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 16 ends

Table 3: Current Market Demand for Retail Development in Gross Building Square Footage; Proposed Project Trade Area and Comparison Trade Areas; 2025 Estimate
Proposed
Project
Trade Area
Gosford
Village
Trade Area
Regional
Downtown
Trade Area
Convenience Goods and Services
Food & Beverage Stores 329,000 315,000 532,000
Health & Personal Care Stores 81,700 104,100 67,100
Gasoline Stations 8,510 800 (197,100)
Miscellaneous Store Retailers 83,300 264,000 384,000
Subtotal 502,000 683,000 786,000
Comparison Goods and Services
Furniture & Home Furnishings Stores 22,000 93,500 235,200 Electronics & Appliance Stores 22,500 43,900 172,000
Bldg Materials, Garden Equip. & Supply (36,100) 78,200 287,000 Clothing & Clothing Accessories Stores 6,220 (18,590) 375,000 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Book & Music Stores 36,500 49,200 236,000 General Merchandise Stores (49,600) (21,700) 174,000
Subtotal 1,500 225,000 1,480,000
Food and Drink
Drinking Places - Alcoholic Beverages 10,450 41,400 122,900 Full-service restaurants (9,030) 31,000 474,000
Limited-service restaurants (13,920) (116,200) (211,000) Subtotal (12,490) (43,850) 386,000
Total 491,000 864,000 2,650,000
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data from Claritas, The Urban Land Institute, the International Council of Shopping Centers, and the US Census Bureau Economic Census 2017 and the US Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index and Producer Price Index.

4. Expected Growth
Bakersfield and Kern County are relatively fast growing: over the ten years from 2012 to 2022, the city’s population increased at an annual rate of 1.4 percent per year and the county’s by 0.6 percent per year, significantly higher than the statewide growth rate of 0.3 percent per year. In an era in which the retail sector continues to transform in response to the pandemic and the re-sulting economic and employment shifts, retail businesses are cautious about opening new stores. However, there is less perceived risk in opening new stores in areas that are growing and adding households.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 17 4A. Trade Area Population and Households
Similar to citywide growth, each of the three trade areas have experienced res-idential growth over the past ten years and are projected to continue growing.

Detailed data for the socioeconomic characteristics are provided in the Appen-dix, in Table A-5 for the proposed project’s trade area, Table A-6 for the Gosford Village / River Walk trade area, and Table A-7 for the Downtown / Valley Plaza Mall regional trade area. Table 4 provides data for population and the number of households for each trade area, including the portion of the Downtown / Valley Plaza Mall regional trade area that excludes the trade ar-eas for the proposed project and Gosford Village / River Walk.

Table 4: Population and Number of Households; Proposed Project Trade Area and Comparison Trade Areas; 2010 and 2020, 2025 Estimate, and 2030 Projection
Trade Area
Proposed
Project
Gosford
Village/ River
Walk
Downtown /
Valley Plaza
Mall
Downtown
less
Proposed
Project and
Gosford
Village
Population
2010 90,200 148,700 534,000 295,000
2020 103,200 180,500 601,000 317,000
10-Year Change 12,990 31,800 66,900 22,100
Annual Rate of Change 1.4% 2.0% 1.2% 0.7%
2025 Estimate 107,400 192,000 618,000 319,000
2030 Projection 108,400 194,400 627,000 324,000
Projected 5-Year Change 1,060 2,420 8,630 5,160
Projected Annual Rate of Change 0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.2%
Number of Households
2010 30,100 49,400 166,900 87,400
2020 34,000 58,500 187,800 95,300
10-Year Change 3,890 9,020 20,900 7,980
Annual Rate of Change 1.2% 1.7% 1.2% 0.9%
2025 Estimate 36,000 62,900 197,100 98,200
2030 Projection 36,700 64,300 202,000 101,100
Projected 5-Year Change 730 1,430 4,990 2,830
Projected Annual Rate of Change 0.2% 0.2% 0.3% 0.3%
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data, estimates, and projections from Esri Business Analyst.

Each of the trade areas experienced growth in population and the number of households from 2010 to 2020. Each of the trade areas is projected to Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 18 ends

continue growing over the next five years, although the rate of growth is pro-jected to slow relative to the rate over the past ten years.

Over the past ten years, the rate of growth in the proposed project’s trade area was less than that in the trade are for Gosford Village / River Walk but more than that in the regional trade area for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall. For the regional trade area, most of the growth over the past ten years occurred in the two other trade areas. However, even when excluding the population and number of households in the first two trade areas, the remainder of the re-gional trade area’s population grew at a rate of 0.7 percent per year, which was higher than the countywide and statewide population growth rates.

Over the next five years, growth in population and number of households in the proposed project’s trade area is projected to be much lower than the rates over the past ten years. The proposed project’s population and household growth is also projected to be slower than the rate of growth in the Gosford Village / River Walk trade area, the regional trade area, and the regional trade area excluding the other two trade areas.
4B. Household Income
The trade area for the proposed project has the highest average annual house-hold income among the trade areas analyzed for this report. The lowest household income is in the regional trade area for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall when the other two trade areas are removed. Table 5 provides the aver-age household income data for each of the trade areas.

Table 5: Average Annual Household Income; Proposed Project Trade Area and Comparison Trade Areas; 2025 Estimate and 2030 Projection Trade Area
Proposed
Project
Gosford
Village/ River
Walk
Downtown /
Valley Plaza
Mall
Downtown
less
Proposed
Project and
Gosford
Village
2025 Estimate 135,900 119,800 100,300 74,700
2030 Projection 148,900 131,900 110,300 82,500
5-Year Change 13,010 12,140 10,030 7,780
Total Percentage Change 9.6% 10.1% 10.0% 10.4%
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data, estimates, and projections from Esri Business Analyst.

Over the next five years, the proposed project’s trade area is projected to have the largest dollar increase in income, but, because the area has a higher in-come currently, the 5-year percentage increase, 9.6 percent, is lower than the household income in the other trade areas.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 19 4C. Market Demand Growth
The growth in households over the next five years will result in new consumer spending in each trade area and, thus, result in an increase in market de-mand for retail building space. The growth in market demand is based on the supportable square footage per household currently and the projected increase in households. Table 6 provides the projected growth in market demand for each of the trade areas.

Table 6 Five-year Increase in Market Demand for Retail Development in Gross Building Square Footage; Proposed Project Trade Area and Comparison Trade Areas; 2025 to 2030
Trade Area
Proposed
Project
Gosford
Village/ River
Walk
Downtown /
Valley Plaza
Mall
Downtown
less
Proposed
Project and
Gosford
Village
Convenience Goods and Services
Food & Beverage Stores 13,250 23,000 72,500 41,100
Health & Personal Care Stores 4,420 7,600 23,760 13,470 Gasoline Stations 1,780 3,070 9,650 5,480
Miscellaneous Store Retailers 7,140 12,280 38,400 21,800 Subtotal 26,580 46,000 144,300 81,900
Comparison Goods and Services
Furniture & Home Furnishings 2,740 4,780 15,010 8,510
Electronics & Appliance Stores 1,470 2,530 7,950 4,510
Bldg Materials, Garden Equip… 5,570 9,400 29,200 16,540 Clothing & Clothing Accessories 3,780 6,580 20,670 11,720 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Book… 1,640 2,850 8,910 5,050
General Merchandise Stores 12,760 22,100 69,500 39,400
Subtotal 27,960 48,300 151,200 85,700
Food and Drink
Drinking Places – Alcohol… 290 1,250 2,770 1,400
Full-service restaurants 940 4,010 8,810 4,460
Limited-service restaurants 1,470 6,260 13,720 6,940
Subtotal 2,700 11,510 25,300 12,790
Total 57,200 105,800 321,000 180,400
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data from Claritas, Esri Business Analyst, The Urban Land Institute, the International Council of Shopping Centers, the US Census Bureau Economic Census 2017, and US Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index and Producer Price Index.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 20 ends

With the expected household growth over the next five years, the trade area for the proposed project will likely have the least growth in market demand, 57,200 square feet. The regional trade area defined for downtown and Valley Plaza Mall is projected to have the largest five-year increase in market de-mand, 180,400 when excluding the trade areas for the proposed project and Gosford Village.
4D. Pipeline Projects
Pipeline projects are retail developments that have been entitled and are or will be under construction soon. The intent is to understand how much retail square footage will be operational and competing for consumer spending in 2030.

There are several challenges in the present case. First, there are many sites planned and zoned for retail development in the Bakersfield metropolitan area, but plans for development have not progressed or were put on hold with the economic disruptions resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. Second, re-tailers are evolving how they operate, employing what is called omni-channel retailing, which includes online sales with shipping, same-day deliveries, in-store or curbside pickup, and traditional in-store shopping and checkout. For many retailers, investments in omni-channel retailing have taken the place of most investments in new stores. Finally, the rapid increase in inflation and the increase in interest rates intended to slow inflation have fundamentally changed the calculus that went into physical and financial planning for retail development that occurred even just a year or two ago.

The following descriptions summarize the major pipeline projects that are competitive with the proposed project.
4D(i) Proposed Project Trade Area
Bakersfield Commons
Originally approved in the early 2000s, this 200-acre project was expected to included 800 apartments, a 250-room hospital and medical offices, a 300,000-square foot retail center, and industrial office space. This project has been through several iterations of vision and conceptualization. Currently a portion of the site is under development with new warehouse construction.

The original market study included this site in the inventory of pipeline pro-jects. However, It is not clear that the retail building space is on track to be built and operational in the next five years. Thus the project is not currently accounted for as a pipeline retail development in this analysis.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 21 4D(ii) Gosford Village Trade Area
West Ming Specific Plan
The West Ming Specific Plan is located within the Gosford Village trade area and the regional trade area for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall. The specific plan area includes some existing retail development (which is included in the estimate of current retail market demand in Section 3), available but unbuilt pad sites, and undeveloped areas that will be built out over time as additional plan area housing is developed. This analysis assumes that there is the poten-tial for an additional 51,400 square feet of retail building space to become operational over the next five years.

Coffee and Rosedale Commercial Retail Development Project is unlikely to compete directly with the retail businesses in the West Ming Specific Plan area.

The Ranch at Stockdale River Ranch
The Ranch is an entitled shopping center (September 2021 site plan ap-proval) for 145,300 square feet of retail building space. The project is located in the defined trade area for Gosford Village but is located in proximity to the boundary with the trade area for the proposed project (i.e., along Stockdale Highway). For the purpose of assessing potential urban decay impacts, the analysis allocates half of the Ranch retail square footage to the proposed pro-ject’s trade area and half to the trade are for Gosford Village, because retail businesses at the Ranch will draw customers from both trade areas.

Crossroads Plaza Commercial Center
The Crossroads Plaza Commercial Center is planned for the area northwest of the intersection of Gosford Road and Panama Lane. It is south of the existing Gosford Village Shopping Center. The project EIR was certified by the City in 2010 and included 786,370 square feet of retail building space. The south-ern half of the site received site plan approval from the City in 2024 for the first phase, which will provide 312,030 square feet of retail building space. 4D(iii) Regional Trade Area for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall The Crossings and Bakersfield Gateway Center
The Bakersfield Gateway Center, originally proposed with up to 800,000 square feet of retail building space, is expected to develop with about 200,000 square feet of retail. The Crossings is proposed to provide 284,800 square feet of retail building space.

It is not clear that all the retail development in these two proposed projects will be developed and operational in the next five years. Nevertheless, the scale of retail development represent a community-scale commercial center Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 22 ends

that would be on par with the proposed project, and, therefore, the analysis includes the full development potential of 484,800 square feet.

These two development sites are located within the defined regional trade area for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall but in proximity to the defined boundary of the Gosford Village trade area (i.e., the 99 freeway) and would draw customers from that trade area. The analysis allocates half of this pipe-line supply to the Gosford Village trade area. It also allocates half to the esti-mate of market demand for the regional trade area excluding the Gosford Vil-lage and the proposed project trade areas. Finally, for the overall regional trade area, the full 484,800 square feet is taken into consideration.

City Lights / East Hills Mall Redevelopment
This proposed project would redevelop the former East Hills Mall site with a new 339,393-square foot shopping center. Taken with the other retail devel-opment adjacent to and near the site, this area would qualify as a regional-scale retail area. 4E. Five-Year Pipeline Supply of New Retail Building Space Reflecting the discussion of each major project in the preceding section, Table 7 summarizes the five-year pipeline supply of new competitive retail building space that can be reasonable assumed for each trade are used in the analy-sis. For the trade area defined for the proposed project, there are no competi-tive pipeline projects expected to become operational in the next five years.

There could be an additional 1.2 million square feet of new retail in the Gosford Village/River Walk trade area, and 582,000 square feet of new retail in the regional trade area defined for downtown and Valley Plaza Mall exclud-ing the trade areas defined for the proposed project and Gosford Village.

Table 7: Five-Year Pipeline Supply of New Retail Development (GFA, sq. ft.) by Trade Area, 2025 to 2030
Proposed Shopping Center Trade Area
Proposed
Project
Gosford
Village/
River Walk
Downtown /
Valley Plaza
Mall
Downtown
less
Proposed
Project and
Gosford
Village
West Ming Specific Plan 51,400 51,400
The Ranch at Stockdale River Ranch 72,700 72,700 145,300 Crossroads Plaza Commercial Center 786,000 786,000
Bakersfield Gateway Center 242,000 484,000 242,000
City Lights/East Hills Mall 339,000 339,000
Trade Area Total 73,000 1,153,000 1,807,000 582,000
Source: PlaceWorks, 2025.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 23

5. Urban Decay Findings
Based on the foregoing analyses, Table 8 estimates, for each defined trade area, the existing unmet market demand for retail building space after devel-opment of the proposed project and the market demand for retail building space in 2030 after development of the proposed project and the pipeline supply.

Table 8: Estimated Retail Market Demand (GFA, sq. ft.) Before and After Proposed Project and Pipeline Supply by Trade Area; Existing 2025 and Projected 2030
Trade Area
Proposed
Project
Gosford
Village/
River Walk
Downtown /
Valley Plaza
Mall
Downtown
less
Proposed
Project and
Gosford
Village
Existing Unmet Market Demand 491,000 864,000 2,650,000 1,295,000 Proposed Project 316,000 316,000
Existing Residual Market Demand 175,000 864,000 2,330,000 1,295,000 5-Year Market Potential 57,200 105,800 321,000 180,400
Total 5-Year Market Demand 232,000 970,000 2,650,000 1,480,000 Pipeline Projects 73,000 1,153,000 1,807,000 582,000
Residual 5-Year Market Demand 159,070 (183,000) 850,000 893,000 Source: PlaceWorks, 2025
Notes to Table 8:

1. The existing unmet market demand is the estimated amount of retail building space that could be supported by current spending by trade area households that is spent outside of the trade area, in square feet of gross floor area, as provided in Table 3.

2. The proposed project is square footage retail building space in the proposed project (only rele-vant for the trade area defined for the proposed project and the regional trade area defined for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall) in square feet of gross floor area.

3. The existing residual market demand is the existing unmet market minus the proposed project, in square feet of gross floor area. This is a key metric in the determination of potential urban decay impacts.

4. The five-year market potential is the estimated additional amount of retail building space that could be supported by consumer spending by the projected five-year increase in households in each trade area, in square feet of gross floor area, as provided in Table 6.

5. Total five-year market demand is the existing residual market demand (estimated for 2025) plus the five-year market potential; estimated as the square feet of gross floor area in 2030.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 24 ends

6. Pipeline projects is the estimated amount of retail building space that the analysis assumes is likely to be developed and become operation by 2030, in square feet of gross floor area, as provided in Table 7.

7. The residual five-year market demand is the total five-year market demand less the pipeline projects and is the estimated amount of market demand for retail building space in 2030 after the development of the proposed project and the pipeline supply, in square feet of gross floor area.
5A. Existing Market Demand and the Proposed Project
Each of the defined trade areas currently has leaked retail spending (i.e., con-sumer spending by trade area households that occurs at businesses outside of the trade area), which could support additional retail development within the trade area. Even with development of the proposed project, the two directly af-fected trade areas would still have unmet retail development. The unmet de-mand would support another 175,00 square feet of retail building space in the trade area defined for the proposed project, and 1.3 million square feet in the regional trade area defined for Downtown and Valley Plaza Mall. The anal-ysis assumes that Stockdale Hwy. and Westside Parkway creates a boundary where residents to the north would patronize retailers in proposed project’s trade area and those to the south would patronize retailers in the Gosford Vil-lage / River Walk trade area. The later trade area currently has unmet market demand that is unlikely to be affected by the proposed project. That existing unmet market demand is estimated to be sufficient to support an additional 864,000 square feet of retail building space in that trade area. 5B. Projected Market Demand in 2030
5B(i) Proposed Project Trade Area
The Ranch at Stockdale River Ranch would be located in the Gosford Village / River Walk trade area, but the analysis assumes that it could generate half of its retail sales from residents in the proposed project’s trade area. The analysis allocated half of the Ranch’s sales to the proposed project’s trade area. With this addition and the increase in consumer spending generated by the pro-jected household growth, the analysis projects that this proposed project’s trade area would have an unmet retail demand of 159,000 square feet of re-tail building space in 2030. This is less than the 220,000 square feet of re-tail building space once envisioned for Bakersfield Commons. If retail develop-ment is to move forward there, it might need to be less square footage or it might need to become operation after 2030, when continued household growth could support more retail development.
5B(ii) Gosford Village / River Walk Trade Area
Even though the Gosford Village / River Walk trade area has current unmet re-tail demand, the projected increase in retail spending from projected house-hold growth would not be sufficient to support the potential commercial Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 25 development in this trade area if it were to all become operational by 2030.

The analysis projects that the full buildout of planned projects would exceed market demand in 2030 by 183,000 square feet of retail building space.

However, the analysis includes two pipeline projects that may not become op-erational by 2030: 484,400 square feet at the Crossings and Bakersfield Gateway Center, and 474,340 square feet at Crossroads Plaza Commercial Center (the portion that was part of the Certified EIR but has not yet gone through site plan review). Thus, the projected excess retail building space pro-jected for this trade area would occur only if both of these two projects are de-veloped and operational by 2030.

The proposed project represents an expansion of the existing retail develop-ment at Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway. The potential expansion at Crossroads Plaza Commercial Center is double the amount of retail in the pro-pose project. Thus, the proposed project would not alter the defined trade area boundary between the two trade areas, which boundary is represents the physical barriers of the Kern River and Stockdale Highway and Westside Park-way. The potential excess retail building space that could occur in the Gosford Village / River Walk trade area would exist with or without the proposed pro-ject. 5B(iii) Downtown / Valley Plaza Trade Area
The 12-mile-radius trade area for Downtown / Valley Plaza Mall is projected to have unmet market demand for retail building space in 2030 regardless if the consumer spending and retail square footage in the other two trade areas is included or excluded.
5C. Findings
The analysis indicates that the proposed project should not cause urban de-cay impacts because there would unmet market demand after developing the proposed project, currently and after five years. In the case of the Gosford Vil-lage / River Walk trade area, the projected excess of 183,000 square feet of retail building space in 2030 would be avoided if one of two potential projects does not become fully operational by 2030. Nevertheless, the proposed pro-ject would not affect the potential excess of retail building space in this trade area.

Based on these results, the analysis finds that development of the proposed project is not expected to exceed market demand and, thus, will not directly cause long-term vacancies in other competitive retail centers, leading to urban decay.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 26 ends

Appendix
The following tables provide the data used in the analysis.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 27 Table A-1: Retail Stores Opportunity Gap/Surplus; Proposed Project Trade Area; 2025 Estimate 2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Totals
Total retail trade including food and drink 2,123,982,854 1,158,111,547 965,871,307 Total retail trade 1,893,744,638 996,634,606 897,110,032 Motor Vehicle and Parts Dealers
Motor vehicle and parts dealers 428,560,742 260,978,393 167,582,350 Automobile dealers 356,299,798 186,160,561 170,139,237
New car dealers 318,253,194 166,161,720 152,091,474
Used car dealers 38,046,605 19,998,841 18,047,764
Other motor vehicle dealers 35,809,330 36,710,938 (901,608) Recreational vehicle dealers 12,848,242 26,903,393 (14,055,152) Motorcycle, boat, and other motor vehicle dealers 22,961,088 9,807,544 13,153,544 Boat dealers 8,163,291 2,019,053 6,144,238
Motorcycle, ATV, and all other motor vehicle dealers 14,797,797 7,788,491 7,009,306 Automotive parts, accessories, and tire stores 36,451,614 38,106,894 (1,655,280) Automotive parts and accessories stores 22,986,148 23,607,929 (621,781) Tire dealers 13,465,467 14,498,965 (1,033,499)
Furniture and Home Furnishings Stores
Furniture and home furnishings stores 38,816,775 22,232,481 16,584,295 Furniture stores 22,020,043 15,732,759 6,287,284
Home furnishings stores 16,796,733 6,499,721 10,297,012 Floor covering stores 8,419,874 2,677,576 5,742,297
Other home furnishings stores 8,376,859 3,822,145 4,554,714 Window treatment stores 492,417 260,931 231,486
All other home furnishings stores 7,884,442 3,561,214 4,323,228 Electronics and Appliance Stores
Electronics and appliance stores 29,824,074 15,049,044 14,775,030 Household appliance stores 6,288,961 4,697,732 1,591,229 Electronics stores 23,535,113 10,351,312 13,183,801
Bldg. Material & Garden Equipment and Supplies Dealers
Building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers 134,687,388 114,459,979 20,227,409 Building material and supplies dealers 117,653,587 103,152,295 14,501,292 Home centers 66,533,456 63,273,755 3,259,702
Paint and wallpaper stores 3,907,052 3,182,011 725,040
Hardware stores 9,813,222 5,377,458 4,435,764
Other building material dealers 37,399,857 31,319,071 6,080,786 Lawn and garden equipment and supplies stores 17,033,802 11,307,684 5,726,118 Outdoor power equipment stores 3,448,839 707,688 2,741,151 Nursery, garden center, and farm supply stores 13,584,963 10,599,997 2,984,966 Food and Beverage Stores
Food and beverage stores 271,939,576 118,909,087 153,030,489 Grocery stores 244,379,000 116,099,969 128,279,031
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 28 ends

2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Supermarkets and other grocery 234,128,303 111,107,056 123,021,247 Convenience stores 10,250,696 4,992,912 5,257,784
Specialty food stores 7,089,039 1,498,789 5,590,250
Meat markets 2,168,219 272,463 1,895,756
Fish and seafood markets 852,771 57,112 795,659
Fruit and vegetable markets 1,484,204 215,008 1,269,196 Other specialty food stores 2,583,846 954,206 1,629,639 All other specialty food stores 1,210,617 235,378 975,239 Beer, wine, and liquor stores 20,471,536 1,310,330 19,161,207 Health and Personal Care Stores
Health and personal care stores 109,717,710 59,745,030 49,972,679 Pharmacies and drug stores 94,211,566 52,045,279 42,166,287 Cosmetics, beauty supplies, and perfume stores 6,524,549 3,740,082 2,784,467 Optical goods stores 3,034,881 1,382,894 1,651,988
Other health and personal care stores 5,946,712 2,576,777 3,369,935 Food 2,103,445 1,231,102 872,343
All other health and personal care stores 3,843,267 1,345,675 2,497,592 Gasoline Stations
Gasoline stations 153,331,382 123,895,605 29,435,777
Clothing and Clothing Accessories Stores
Clothing and clothing accessories stores 92,524,100 43,374,971 49,149,129 Clothing stores 63,280,693 29,267,594 34,013,099
Men's clothing stores 2,404,048 689,697 1,714,352
Women's clothing stores 12,267,605 4,014,103 8,253,502
Children's and infants' clothing stores 2,795,616 2,245,837 549,778 Family clothing stores 37,030,699 18,923,407 18,107,292 Clothing accessories stores 3,196,768 815,667 2,381,102 Other clothing stores 5,585,957 2,578,884 3,007,073
Shoe stores 10,756,159 7,802,050 2,954,109
Jewelry, luggage, and leather goods stores 18,487,249 6,305,327 12,181,921 Jewelry stores 11,954,941 3,593,355 8,361,587
Luggage and leather goods stores 6,532,307 2,711,972 3,820,335 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Musical Instrument, & Book Stores Sporting goods, hobby, musical instrument, and book stores 30,565,826 12,152,220 18,413,606 Sporting goods, hobby, and musical instrument stores 26,923,091 11,393,851 15,529,240 Sporting goods stores 17,789,999 5,539,852 12,250,147
Hobby, toy, and game stores 7,033,252 5,005,013 2,028,239 Sewing, needlework, and piece goods stores 909,348 366,484 542,865 Musical instrument and supplies stores 1,190,492 482,504 707,988 Book stores and news dealers 3,642,735 758,369 2,884,367 Book stores 3,388,224 758,369 2,629,855
News dealers and newsstands 254,511 0 254,511
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 29 2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
General Merchandise Stores 0
General merchandise stores 240,029,603 185,618,288 54,411,315 Department stores 32,167,380 18,725,450 13,441,930
Other general merchandise stores 207,862,223 166,892,838 40,969,385 Warehouse clubs and supercenters 188,453,627 151,052,817 37,400,810 All other general merchandise stores 19,408,596 15,840,021 3,568,575 Miscellaneous Store Retailers
Miscellaneous store retailers 39,165,476 17,218,566 21,946,910 Florists 1,860,501 938,360 922,141
Office supplies, stationery, and gift stores 7,357,004 2,953,063 4,403,941 Office supplies and stationery stores 3,132,352 1,892,588 1,239,765 Gift, novelty, and souvenir stores 4,224,652 1,060,476 3,164,177 Used merchandise stores 5,756,487 2,468,207 3,288,280
Other miscellaneous store retailers 24,191,483 10,858,936 13,332,547 Pet and pet supplies stores 7,714,544 3,720,717 3,993,827 Art dealers 3,561,311 620,832 2,940,479
Manufactured 2,264,732 741,614 1,523,118
All other miscellaneous store retailers 10,650,896 5,775,773 4,875,123 Tobacco stores 3,196,273 3,040,927 155,345
All other miscellaneous store retailers 7,454,623 2,734,845 4,719,779 Non-store Retailers
Non-store retailers 324,581,983 23,000,942 301,581,042
Electronic shopping and mail-order houses 310,149,057 17,504,294 292,644,763 Vending machine operators 1,716,853 0 1,716,853
Direct selling establishments 12,716,074 5,496,647 7,219,426 Fuel dealers 7,694,434 2,534,485 5,159,949
Other direct selling establishments 5,021,638 2,962,162 2,059,476 Non-store Retailers
Food services and drinking places 230,238,216 161,476,941 68,761,275 Special food services 17,682,707 3,390,385 14,292,323
Food service contractors 13,951,627 1,965,320 11,986,306 Caterers 3,367,031 1,149,349 2,217,682
Mobile food services 364,049 275,715 88,334
Drinking places 7,203,669 3,817,607 3,386,062
Restaurants and other eating places 205,351,840 154,268,950 51,082,891 Full-service restaurants 101,575,587 54,795,189 46,780,399 Limited-service restaurants 88,037,853 85,411,563 2,626,290 Cafeterias, grill buffets, and buffets 2,244,552 3,762,041 (1,517,489) Snack and non-alcoholic beverage bars 13,493,848 10,300,157 3,193,691 Source: Claritas, Retail Market Power® - 2023 Estimates and 2028 Projections, using data from Environics Analytics | U.S. Census Bureau | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics | Data Axle. Data adjusted for inflation from annual 2023 dollars to August 2025 dollars based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), All items - old base in Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA, all urban consumers.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 30 ends

Table A-2: Retail Stores Opportunity Gap/Surplus; Gosford Village Defined Trade Area; 2025 Estimate 2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Totals
Total retail trade including food and drink 3,309,650,846 1,987,408,261 1,322,242,585 Total retail trade 2,952,065,147 1,720,515,570 1,231,549,577 Motor Vehicle and Parts Dealers
Motor vehicle and parts dealers 673,489,115 548,811,080 124,678,034 Automobile dealers 560,458,483 515,785,741 44,672,742
New car dealers 500,430,161 488,377,037 12,053,124
Used car dealers 60,028,323 27,408,704 32,619,618
Other motor vehicle dealers 57,366,668 11,200,729 46,165,939 Recreational vehicle dealers 20,711,750 5,809,280 14,902,470 Motorcycle, boat, and other motor vehicle dealers 36,654,918 5,391,449 31,263,470 Boat dealers 13,150,017 1,711,098 11,438,919
Motorcycle, ATV, and all other motor vehicle dealers 23,504,901 3,680,352 19,824,549 Automotive parts, accessories, and tire stores 55,663,963 21,824,610 33,839,353 Automotive parts and accessories stores 35,088,105 13,538,932 21,549,173 Tire dealers 20,575,858 8,285,679 12,290,179
Furniture and Home Furnishings Stores
Furniture and home furnishings stores 60,695,455 23,335,142 37,360,313 Furniture stores 34,731,046 15,098,097 19,632,948
Home furnishings stores 25,964,410 8,237,045 17,727,365 Floor covering stores 12,768,267 4,509,645 8,258,622
Other home furnishings stores 13,196,144 3,727,400 9,468,744 Window treatment stores 795,005 423,739 371,266
All other home furnishings stores 12,401,139 3,303,661 9,097,478 Electronics and Appliance Stores
Electronics and appliance stores 46,244,153 20,396,858 25,847,295 Household appliance stores 9,723,465 6,402,761 3,320,704 Electronics stores 36,520,688 13,994,097 22,526,591
Bldg. Material & Garden Equipment and Supplies Dealers
Building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers 204,506,498 121,758,337 82,748,161 Building material and supplies dealers 178,151,336 114,608,508 63,542,828 Home centers 101,047,404 70,491,633 30,555,771
Paint and wallpaper stores 6,100,305 6,190,479 (90,174) Hardware stores 14,874,736 8,400,099 6,474,637
Other building material dealers 56,128,892 29,526,297 26,602,594 Lawn and garden equipment and supplies stores 26,355,161 7,149,828 19,205,333 Outdoor power equipment stores 5,350,272 536,486 4,813,786 Nursery, garden center, and farm supply stores 21,004,889 6,613,343 14,391,547 Food and Beverage Stores
Food and beverage stores 425,317,351 254,111,246 171,206,106 Grocery stores 382,486,644 231,353,736 151,132,908
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 31 2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Supermarkets and other grocery 366,485,563 219,728,279 146,757,283 Convenience stores 16,001,080 11,625,458 4,375,622
Specialty food stores 11,106,694 10,882,647 224,047
Meat markets 3,392,447 2,133,746 1,258,701
Fish and seafood markets 1,334,985 1,159,633 175,352
Fruit and vegetable markets 2,329,181 2,156,415 172,766 Other specialty food stores 4,050,081 5,432,852 (1,382,772) All other specialty food stores 1,894,328 1,014,557 879,771 Beer, wine, and liquor stores 31,724,013 11,874,863 19,849,151 Health and Personal Care Stores
Health and personal care stores 170,050,125 103,351,052 66,699,073 Pharmacies and drug stores 146,391,750 89,462,246 56,929,504 Cosmetics, beauty supplies, and perfume stores 10,139,959 6,466,869 3,673,090 Optical goods stores 4,278,366 2,808,449 1,469,918
Other health and personal care stores 9,240,049 4,613,488 4,626,561 Food 3,269,540 2,218,158 1,051,382
All other health and personal care stores 5,970,509 2,395,330 3,575,179 Gasoline Stations
Gasoline stations 238,115,257 212,974,888 25,140,369
Clothing and Clothing Accessories Stores
Clothing and clothing accessories stores 144,957,449 75,094,639 69,862,810 Clothing stores 99,119,255 49,778,731 49,340,524
Men's clothing stores 3,771,397 1,227,123 2,544,274
Women's clothing stores 19,175,533 6,776,301 12,399,232 Children's and infants' clothing stores 4,410,680 3,646,199 764,481 Family clothing stores 58,034,872 32,532,956 25,501,916 Clothing accessories stores 5,006,305 1,427,965 3,578,340 Other clothing stores 8,720,467 4,168,186 4,552,280
Shoe stores 16,943,780 13,947,860 2,995,920
Jewelry, luggage, and leather goods stores 28,894,413 11,368,049 17,526,364 Jewelry stores 18,655,591 6,501,877 12,153,715
Luggage and leather goods stores 10,238,822 4,866,172 5,372,649 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Musical Instrument, & Book Stores Sporting goods, hobby, musical instrument, and book stores 47,840,635 21,181,619 26,659,017 Sporting goods, hobby, and musical instrument stores 42,147,921 18,643,221 23,504,701 Sporting goods stores 27,862,935 8,626,760 19,236,175
Hobby, toy, and game stores 11,020,457 7,810,544 3,209,913 Sewing, needlework, and piece goods stores 1,432,182 997,684 434,497 Musical instrument and supplies stores 1,832,348 1,208,231 624,117 Book stores and news dealers 5,692,715 2,538,398 3,154,317 Book stores 5,294,824 2,538,398 2,756,425
News dealers and newsstands 397,891 0 397,891
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 32 ends

2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
General Merchandise Stores
General merchandise stores 374,697,075 272,973,605 101,723,469 Department stores 50,436,923 29,293,099 21,143,824
Other general merchandise stores 324,260,151 243,680,505 80,579,646 Warehouse clubs and supercenters 293,950,111 219,935,832 74,014,280 All other general merchandise stores 30,310,040 23,744,674 6,565,366 Miscellaneous Store Retailers
Miscellaneous store retailers 61,177,861 29,234,253 31,943,608 Florists 2,888,054 2,482,137 405,917
Office supplies, stationery, and gift stores 11,469,512 5,131,505 6,338,008 Office supplies and stationery stores 4,893,851 3,136,787 1,757,064 Gift, novelty, and souvenir stores 6,575,661 1,994,718 4,580,944 Used merchandise stores 8,976,389 4,713,581 4,262,809
Other miscellaneous store retailers 37,843,905 16,907,032 20,936,874 Pet and pet supplies stores 12,110,532 5,728,710 6,381,822 Art dealers 5,552,837 1,153,581 4,399,257
Manufactured 3,652,223 1,316,568 2,335,655
All other miscellaneous store retailers 16,528,313 8,708,173 7,820,140 Tobacco stores 4,966,841 4,573,895 392,946
All other miscellaneous store retailers 11,561,472 4,134,277 7,427,195 Non-store Retailers
Non-store retailers 504,974,173 37,292,851 467,681,322
Electronic shopping and mail-order houses 482,651,354 27,474,732 455,176,623 Vending machine operators 2,692,467 399,219 2,293,248
Direct selling establishments 19,630,351 9,418,900 10,211,451 Fuel dealers 11,846,091 4,389,646 7,456,445
Other direct selling establishments 7,784,259 5,029,254 2,755,006 Non-store Retailers
Food services and drinking places 357,585,698 266,892,691 90,693,007 Special food services 27,472,203 4,815,436 22,656,767
Food service contractors 21,676,542 3,134,102 18,542,440 Caterers 5,230,117 1,186,912 4,043,205
Mobile food services 565,544 494,422 71,122
Drinking places 11,170,529 2,098,999 9,071,529
Restaurants and other eating places 318,942,966 259,978,255 58,964,711 Full-service restaurants 157,733,437 65,118,045 92,615,392 Limited-service restaurants 136,754,882 174,667,493 (37,912,611) Cafeterias, grill buffets, and buffets 3,486,543 4,301,698 (815,155) Snack and non-alcoholic beverage bars 20,968,106 15,891,020 5,077,085 Source: Claritas, Retail Market Power® - 2023 Estimates and 2028 Projections, using data from Environics Analytics | U.S. Census Bureau | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics | Data Axle. Data adjusted for inflation from annual 2023 dollars to August 2025 dollars based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), All items - old base in Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA, all urban consumers.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 33 Table A-3: Retail Stores Opportunity Gap/Surplus; Downtown Bakersfield and Valley Plaza Mall Defined Regional Trade Area; 2025 Estimate
2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Totals
Total retail trade including food and drink 9,403,056,025 7,407,770,826 1,995,285,199 Total retail trade 8,384,362,096 6,581,676,388 1,802,685,708 Motor Vehicle and Parts Dealers
Motor vehicle and parts dealers 1,909,919,656 1,855,087,833 54,831,822 Automobile dealers 1,587,608,548 1,564,961,106 22,647,443 New car dealers 1,417,406,825 1,389,419,678 27,987,147
Used car dealers 170,201,724 175,541,428 (5,339,704)
Other motor vehicle dealers 166,037,998 107,775,044 58,262,954 Recreational vehicle dealers 60,398,297 74,102,601 (13,704,304) Motorcycle, boat, and other motor vehicle dealers 105,639,701 33,672,444 71,967,257 Boat dealers 38,321,836 8,773,983 29,547,853
Motorcycle, ATV, and all other motor vehicle dealers 67,317,865 24,898,461 42,419,404 Automotive parts, accessories, and tire stores 156,273,109 182,351,684 (26,078,574) Automotive parts and accessories stores 98,508,258 116,537,805 (18,029,547) Tire dealers 57,764,851 65,813,878 (8,049,028)
Furniture and Home Furnishings Stores
Furniture and home furnishings stores 172,931,493 110,911,650 62,019,843 Furniture stores 98,755,371 77,857,516 20,897,855
Home furnishings stores 74,176,122 33,054,134 41,121,988 Floor covering stores 36,573,284 18,414,225 18,159,059
Other home furnishings stores 37,602,838 14,639,909 22,962,929 Window treatment stores 2,294,950 1,025,120 1,269,830
All other home furnishings stores 35,307,888 13,614,788 21,693,099 Electronics and Appliance Stores
Electronics and appliance stores 131,647,736 75,778,840 55,868,896 Household appliance stores 27,573,758 18,811,697 8,762,061 Electronics stores 104,073,978 56,967,143 47,106,835
Bldg. Material & Garden Equipment and Supplies Dealers
Building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers 574,667,671 459,769,360 114,898,311 Building material and supplies dealers 500,388,138 425,206,556 75,181,582 Home centers 284,164,365 242,205,496 41,958,869
Paint and wallpaper stores 16,962,733 24,122,128 (7,159,395) Hardware stores 41,790,068 34,117,894 7,672,174
Other building material dealers 157,470,972 124,761,038 32,709,935 Lawn and garden equipment and supplies stores 74,279,532 34,562,803 39,716,730 Outdoor power equipment stores 15,076,935 1,554,795 13,522,141 Nursery, garden center, and farm supply stores 59,202,597 33,008,008 26,194,589 Food and Beverage Stores
Food and beverage stores 1,213,124,495 1,005,879,087 207,245,408 Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 34 ends

2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
Grocery stores 1,090,678,816 938,280,597 152,398,219
Supermarkets and other grocery 1,044,967,237 899,064,545 145,902,692 Convenience stores 45,711,579 39,216,051 6,495,527
Specialty food stores 31,674,148 29,838,523 1,835,625
Meat markets 9,671,712 5,409,156 4,262,556
Fish and seafood markets 3,806,378 3,388,211 418,167
Fruit and vegetable markets 6,643,368 5,744,895 898,473 Other specialty food stores 11,552,691 15,296,261 (3,743,571) All other specialty food stores 5,400,856 3,372,380 2,028,476 Beer, wine, and liquor stores 90,771,532 37,759,967 53,011,565 Health and Personal Care Stores
Health and personal care stores 481,222,799 449,204,558 32,018,241 Pharmacies and drug stores 414,646,598 412,073,652 2,572,946 Cosmetics, beauty supplies, and perfume stores 28,713,163 18,106,322 10,606,842 Optical goods stores 11,714,806 6,476,972 5,237,834
Other health and personal care stores 26,148,231 12,547,612 13,600,620 Food 9,255,218 5,989,960 3,265,258
All other health and personal care stores 16,893,013 6,557,650 10,335,363 Gasoline Stations
Gasoline stations 679,321,407 1,006,043,805 (326,722,398) Clothing and Clothing Accessories Stores
Clothing and clothing accessories stores 412,200,102 307,744,583 104,455,519 Clothing stores 281,633,212 225,842,037 55,791,175
Men's clothing stores 10,657,110 3,423,536 7,233,575
Women's clothing stores 54,615,178 28,068,001 26,547,177 Children's and infants' clothing stores 12,498,278 12,555,958 (57,680) Family clothing stores 164,856,820 162,778,585 2,078,235 Clothing accessories stores 14,209,219 4,060,638 10,148,582 Other clothing stores 24,796,607 14,955,319 9,841,288
Shoe stores 48,329,373 44,774,807 3,554,566
Jewelry, luggage, and leather goods stores 82,237,517 37,127,740 45,109,777 Jewelry stores 53,158,351 22,914,276 30,244,074
Luggage and leather goods stores 29,079,167 14,213,465 14,865,703 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Musical Instrument, & Book Stores Sporting goods, hobby, musical instrument, and book stores 135,527,040 65,164,154 70,362,887 Sporting goods, hobby, and musical instrument stores 119,295,201 57,631,642 61,663,559 Sporting goods stores 78,748,495 27,249,311 51,499,184
Hobby, toy, and game stores 31,269,607 24,509,417 6,760,190 Sewing, needlework, and piece goods stores 4,087,129 2,665,698 1,421,431 Musical instrument and supplies stores 5,189,969 3,207,215 1,982,754 Book stores and news dealers 16,231,840 7,532,513 8,699,327 Book stores 15,098,790 6,988,898 8,109,893
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 35 2025
Demand ($)
2025 Supply
($)
Opportunity
Gap/Surplus
($)
News dealers and newsstands 1,133,050 543,615 589,435
General Merchandise Stores
General merchandise stores 1,065,463,938 1,035,119,504 30,344,434 Department stores 143,395,708 97,877,570 45,518,138
Other general merchandise stores 922,068,230 937,241,934 (15,173,704) Warehouse clubs and supercenters 835,885,369 854,130,497 (18,245,128) All other general merchandise stores 86,182,862 83,111,437 3,071,425 Miscellaneous Store Retailers
Miscellaneous store retailers 174,478,304 90,718,627 83,759,676 Florists 8,140,748 6,792,774 1,347,973
Office supplies, stationery, and gift stores 32,695,099 15,434,440 17,260,658 Office supplies and stationery stores 13,950,666 9,637,365 4,313,301 Gift, novelty, and souvenir stores 18,744,432 5,797,075 12,947,357 Used merchandise stores 25,661,250 13,620,742 12,040,507 Other miscellaneous store retailers 107,981,208 54,870,670 53,110,538 Pet and pet supplies stores 34,374,884 18,586,326 15,788,558 Art dealers 15,877,093 3,367,178 12,509,915
Manufactured 10,654,162 3,919,086 6,735,077
All other miscellaneous store retailers 47,075,068 28,998,079 18,076,989 Tobacco stores 14,276,968 15,263,823 (986,855)
All other miscellaneous store retailers 32,798,100 13,734,256 19,063,843 Non-store Retailers
Non-store retailers 1,433,857,455 120,254,387 1,313,603,068 Electronic shopping and mail-order houses 1,370,648,267 89,719,124 1,280,929,143 Vending machine operators 7,680,810 2,332,174 5,348,637 Direct selling establishments 55,528,379 28,203,090 27,325,289 Fuel dealers 33,438,788 13,027,872 20,410,916
Other direct selling establishments 22,089,591 15,175,218 6,914,373 Non-store Retailers
Food services and drinking places 1,018,693,927 826,094,438 192,599,490 Special food services 78,451,959 16,818,933 61,633,026
Food service contractors 61,968,626 10,951,144 51,017,482 Caterers 14,875,270 3,932,391 10,942,879
Mobile food services 1,608,062 1,935,398 (327,335)
Drinking places 32,172,498 13,522,135 18,650,363
Restaurants and other eating places 908,069,471 795,753,370 112,316,101 Full-service restaurants 449,638,016 239,111,601 210,526,415 Limited-service restaurants 388,888,498 482,536,732 (93,648,234) Cafeterias, grill buffets, and buffets 9,914,266 15,801,465 (5,887,200) Snack and non-alcoholic beverage bars 59,628,692 58,303,571 1,325,121 Source: Claritas, Retail Market Power® - 2023 Estimates and 2028 Projections, using data from Environics Analytics | U.S. Census Bureau | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics | Data Axle. Data adjusted for inflation from annual 2023 dollars to August 2025 dollars based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), All items - old base in Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA, all urban consumers.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 36 ends

Table A-4: Opportunity Gap/Surplus by Store Type and Capture Adjustment; Proposed Project and Comparison Trade Areas; 2025 Estimate
Store Type Capture
Adjustment
Proposed
Project
Trade Area
Gosford
Village
Trade Area
Regional
Downtown
Trade Area
Furniture & Home Furnishings Stores 6,880,101 22,186,450 62,019,843 Furniture Stores 75% 782,273 10,950,187 20,897,855
Home Furnishings Stores 75% 6,097,829 11,236,263 41,121,988 Electronics & Appliance Stores 75% 7,319,011 14,286,256 55,868,896 Bldg Materials, Garden Equip. & Supply Stores (13,444,438) 31,621,536 114,898,311 Bldg Material & Supplies Dealers 75% (14,912,105) 19,004,994 75,181,582 Lawn & Garden Equip & Supply Stores 75% 1,467,667 12,616,542 39,716,730 Food & Beverage Stores 125,836,532 128,674,370 207,245,408 Grocery Stores 90% 103,841,131 112,884,243 152,398,219
Specialty Food Stores 90% 4,881,346 (886,622) 1,835,625 Beer, Wine & Liquor Stores 90% 17,114,053 16,676,749 53,011,565 Health & Personal Care Stores 39,000,908 49,694,061 32,018,241 Gasoline Stations 14,102,639 1,328,843 (326,722,398)
Clothing & Clothing Accessories Stores 2,887,079 (2,615,915) 104,455,519 Clothing Stores 50% 2,372,752 (219,103) 55,791,175
Shoe Stores 50% (2,423,970) (5,475,970) 3,554,566
Jewelry, Luggage & Leather Goods Stores 50% 2,938,297 3,079,157 45,109,777 Sporting Goods, Hobby, Book & Music Stores 10,772,150 14,698,858 70,362,887 Sporting Goods/Hobby/Musical Instr Stores 75% 8,798,467 12,967,721 61,663,559 Book, Periodical & Music Stores 75% 1,973,683 1,731,138 8,699,327 General Merchandise Stores (13,637,931) (4,560,029) 30,344,434 Department Stores Excluding Leased Depts. 50% (2,641,760) (4,074,637) 45,518,138 Other General Merchandise Stores 75% (10,996,171) (485,392) (15,173,704) Miscellaneous Store Retailers 12,729,920 54,098,778 57,681,102 Florists 90% 736,091 117,112 1,347,973
Office Supplies, Stationery & Gift Stores 90% 3,668,240 5,191,056 17,260,658 Used Merchandise Stores 90% 2,712,631 3,365,170 12,040,507 Other Miscellaneous Store Retailers 90% 10,913,399 17,152,483 53,110,538 Auto Parts, Accessories & Tire Stores 90% (5,300,441) 28,272,957 (26,078,574) Food Services & Drinking Places (2,422,251) 20,027,570 229,176,777 Drinking Places - Alcoholic Beverages 75% 1,585,145 6,278,897 18,650,363 Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 37 Store Type Capture
Adjustment
Proposed
Project
Trade Area
Gosford
Village
Trade Area
Regional
Downtown
Trade Area
Full-service restaurants 50% (4,007,395) 13,748,673 210,526,415 Limited-service restaurants 90% (6,177,495) (51,588,099) (93,648,234) Source: PlaceWorks, 2025, using data from Claritas. Consumer spending data adjusted for inflation from annual 2023 dollars to August 2025 dollars based on the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), All items - old base in Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA, all urban consumers. Estimated retail supply data adjusted for inflation from annual 2023 dollars to August 2025 dollars based on the Producer Price Index industry data for Total retail trade industries.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 38 ends

Table A-5: Socioeconomic Characteristics; Proposed Project Trade Area; 2025 Estimate Area: 96.75 square miles
Population Summary
2010 Total Population 90,169
2020Total Population 103,156
2020 Group Quarters 660
2025 Total Population 107,381
2025 Group Quarters 493
2030 Total Population 108,436
2025-2030 Annual Rate 0.20%
2025 Total Daytime Population 109,250
Workers 51,098
Residents 58,152
Household Summary
2010Total Households 30,090
2010 Average Household Size 2.99
2020 Total Households 33,979
2020 Average Household Size 3.02
2025Total Households 35,961
2025 Average Household Size 2.97
2030Total Households 36,695
2030 Average Household Size 2.94
2025-2030 Annual Rate 0.40%
2025 Families 28,287
2025 Average Family Size 3.34
2030 Families 28,856
2030 Average Family Size 3.31
2025-2030 Growth Rate 0.4%
@2025Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Community Profile
Project Trade Area
Gesri
THE SCIENCE OF WHERE*
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 39 Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles Housing Unit Summary

24.0%

5.8%

23.4%

2.8%

22.1%

2.7%

21.2%

2.6%
Median Household Income
2025
2030
Per Capita Income
2025
2030
2025 Households by Income
Household Income Base

2.9%

3.7%

7.0%

11.6%

12.6%

21.1%
1 9.4%

16.6%
$135,879
i
©2025 Esri
$45,507
$50,382
31,946

76.0%
$113,180
$126,557
34,910

76.5%
37,662

78.8%
36,972

77.9%
35,961

5.1%
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.
2010 Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2020 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2025 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2030Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
<$15,000
$15,000 $24,999
$25,000 - $34,999
$35,000 - $49,999
$50,000 - $74,999
$75,000 - $99,999
$100,000-$149,999
$150,000 $199,999
$200,000+
Average Household Income
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 40 ends

Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2025 Affordability, Mortgage and Wealth
Housing Affordability Index 97
Percent of Income for Mortgage 24.4%
Wealth Index 117
Median Home Value
2025 $440,379
2030 $487,691
2025 Home Value
28,008

1.2%
$50,000 - $99,999 0.3%
$100,000-5149,999 0.3%
$150,000 - $199,999 0.7%
$200,000 - $249,999 1.5%
$250,000-$299,999 4.3%
$300,000-5399,999 27.3%
$400,000 - $499,999 35.8%
$500,000 - $749,999 22.8%
$750,000-$999,999 3.9%
$1,000,000 $1,499,999 1.0%
$1,500,000-$1,999,999 0.4%
$2,000,000 + 0.6%
Average Home Value $483,052
2025 Population by Sex
Males 53,299
Females 54,082
Median Age
2010 34.0
2020 36.3
2025 37.1
2030 37.8
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Total Owner Occupied Housing Units
<$50,000
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 41 Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2025 Population by Age
Total 107,381
0-4 6.1%
5-9 6.7%
10-14 7.4%
15-24 13.7%
25-34 13.2%
35-44 14.4%
45-54 13.3%
55-64 11.2%
65-74 8.7%
75-84 4.4%
85 + 1.3%
18 + 75.2%
2025 Pop 25+ by Educational Attainment
Total 71,041
Less than 9th Grade 3.5%
9th - 12th Grade, No Diploma 3.9%
High School Graduate 20.1%
GED/Alternative Credential 3.0%
Some College, No Degree 24.3%
Associate Degree 10.9%
Bachelor's Degree 21.5%
Graduate/Professional Degree 12.7%
2025 Population 15+ by Marital Status
Total 85,706
Never Married 29.8%
Married 58.4%
Widowed 4.9%
Divorced 6.9%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 42 ends

Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2020 Population by Race/Ethnicity
Total 103,156
White Alone 63.4%
Black Alone 2.6%
American Indian Alone 1.3%
Asian Alone 6.5%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.1%
Some Other Race Alone 12.3%
Two or More Races 12.3%
Hispanic Origin 28.6%
Diversity Index 73.9
2025 Population by Race/Ethnicity
Total 107,382
Wh ite Alone 59.3%
Black Alone 2.8%
American Indian Alone 1.3%
Asian Alone 7.0%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.1%
Some Other Race Alone 14.4%
Two or More Races 15.0%
Hispanic Origin 32.7%
Diversity Index 77.6
2025 Employed Pop 16+by Occupation
Total 52,666
White Collar 64.9%
Management/Business/Financial 17.3%
Professional 29.9%
Sales 6.8%
Administrative Support 10.9%
Services 16.5%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 43 Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2025 Employed Pop 16+ by Occupation
Total 52,666
Blue Collar 18.5%
Farmin g/Forestry/Fish in g 0.6%
Construction/Extraction 6.3%
Installation/Maintenance/Repair 2.8%
Production 2.5%
Transportation/Material Moving 6.4%
2025 Civilian Population 16+ in Labor Force
Civilian Population 16+ 52,666

94.7%

5.3%

9.9%

17.7%

64.4%

3.0%
15%

5.7%
5%

4.5%
2025 Employed Population 16+ by Industry
Total 49,888
Agriculture/Mining 5.4%
Construction 8.4%

4.0%

1.7%
Retail Trade 7.8%

5.5%
1%
Finance/Insurance/Real Estate 4.3%
Services 51.8%
Public Administration 10.2%
i
©2025 Esri
Manufacturing
Wholesale Trade
Population 16-24 Unemployment rate
Population 25-54 Employed
Population 25-54 Unemployment rate
Population 55-64 Employed
Population 55-64 Unemployment rate
Population 65+ Employed
Population 65+ Unemployment rate
Population 16+ Employed
Population 1 6+ Unemployment rate
Population 16-24 Employed
Transportation/Utilities
Information
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 44 ends

Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2025 Consumer Spending
Apparel & Services: Total $ $102,723,878
Average Spent $2,856.54
117
$73,183,911
Average Spent $2,035.09
114
$171,316,762
Average Spent $4,763.96
116
$297,863,995
Average Spent $8,282.97
111
$172,590,444
Average Spent $4,799.38
Spending Potential Index 116
Health Care: Total $ $314,655,222
Average Spent $8,749.90
Spending Potential Index 113
HH Furnishings & Equipment: Total $ $122,822,946
Average Spent $3,415.45
117
$43,837,158
Average Spent $1,219.02
116
$1,097,571,349
Average Spent $30,521.16
115
$147,867,991
Average Spent $4,111.90
Spending Potential Index 125
i
©2025 Esri
Spending Potential Index
Food at Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Food Away from Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Shelter: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Entertainment/Recreation: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Personal Care Products & Services: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Education: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Support Payments/Gifts in Kind: Total $
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 45 Community Profile | Project Trade Area | Area: 96.75 square miles 2025 Consumer Spending
Travel: Total $ $154,263,308
Average Spent $4,289.74
119
$55,749,425
Average Spent $1,550.27
Spending Potential Index 115
Top Tapestry Segment
Boomburbs (H2):

Learn more about this segment.
i
©2025Esri
Spending Potential Index
Vehicle Maintenance & Repairs: Total $
Data Note: Household population includes persons not residing in group quarters. Average Household Size is the household population divided by total households. Persons in families include the householder and persons related to the householder by birth, marriage, or adoption. Per Capita Income represents the income received by all persons aged 15 years and over divided by the total population.

Income represents the preceding year, expressed in current dollars. Household income includes wage and salary earnings, interest dividends, net rents, pensions, SSI and welfare payments, child support, and alimony.

Persons of Hispanic Origin may be of any race. The Diversity Index measures the probability that two people from the same area will be from different race/ethnic groups.

Consumer spending shows the amount spent on a variety of goods and services by households that reside in the area. Expenditures are shown by broad budget categories that are not mutually exclusive. Consumer spending does not equal business revenue. Total and Average Amount Spent Per Household represent annual figures. The Spending Potential Index represents the amount spent in the area relative to a national average of 100.

Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

This segment is characterized by high-earning suburban families in the South and West.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 46 ends

Table A-6: Socioeconomic Characteristics; Gosford Village / River Walk Trade Area; Estimate 2025 Area: 122.82 square miles
Population Summary
148,686
180,494
1,347
191,983
1,057
194,399

0.25%
179,538
72,820
Residents 106,718
Household Summary
2010 Total Households 49,434
2010 Average Household Size 2.99
2020Total Households 58,456
2020 Average Household Size 3.06
2025 Total Households 62,858
2025 Average Household Size 3.04
2030 Total Households 64,285
2030 Average Household Size 3.01
2025-2030 Annual Rate 0.45%
2025 Families 46,584
2025 Average Family Size 3.50
2030 Families 47,610

3.46 0.4%
©2O25Esri
2010 Total Population
2020Total Population
2020 Group Quarters
2025Total Population
2025 Group Quarters
2030Total Population
2025-2030 Annual Rate
2030 Average Family Size
2025-2030 Growth Rate
2025 Total Daytime Population
Workers
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Community Profile
Gosford / River Walk Trade Area Gesri

THE SCIENCE OF WHERE'
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 47 Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles Housing Unit Summary

36.3%

7.1%

36.4%

3.5%

34.5%

3.8%

33.3%

3.7%
Median Household Income
2025
2030
Per Capita Income
2025
2030
2025 Households by Income
Household Income Base

3.8%

5.2%

7.7%
1 7.4%

13.3%

20.8%

12.4%

13.0%
$119,789
i
©2025 Esri
$39,207
$43,609
$91,446
$101,743
62,857

6.4%
53,201

63.7%
66,757

66.7%
60,627

63.6%
65,309

65.5%
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.
2010 Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2020 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2025 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2030Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
<$15,000
$15,000 $24,999
$25,000 - $34,999
$35,000 - $49,999
$50,000 - $74,999
$75,000 - $99,999
$100,000-$149,999
$150,000 $199,999
$200,000+
Average Household Income
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 48 ends

Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2025 Affordability, Mortgage and Wealth
Housing Affordability Index 88
Percent of Income for Mortgage 26.8%
Wealth Index 96
Median Home Value
2025 $391,369
2030 $447,938
2025 Home Value
41,164

2.0%
$50,000 - $99,999 0.4%
$100,000-5149,999 0.9%
$150,000-$199,999 1.5%
$200,000 - $249,999 4.4%
$250,000-$299,999 10.5%
$300,000-5399,999 33.1%
$400,000 - $499,999 22.4%
$500,000 - $749,999 18.6%
$750,000-$999,999 3.2%
$1,000,000 $1,499,999 2.1%
$1,500,000-$1,999,999 0.4%
$2,000,000 + 0.4%
Average Home Value $446,917
2025 Population by Sex
Males 94,980
Females 97,003
Median Age
2010 31.5
2020 33.5
2025 34.7
2030 36.1
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Total Owner Occupied Housing Units
<$50,000
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 49 Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2025 Population by Age
Total 191,985
0-4 6.6%
5-9 7.0%
10-14 7.3%
15-24 13.9%
25-34 15.7%
35-44 14.6%
45-54 11.9%
55-64 9.8%
65-74 8.2%
75-84 4.1%
85 + 1.3%
18 + 74.7%
2025 Pop 25+ by Educational Attainment
Total 125,090
Less than 9th Grade 6.0%
9th - 12th Grade, No Diploma 7.1%
High School Graduate 22.6%
GED/Alternative Credential 2.9%
Some College, No Degree 22.3%
Associate Degree 9.6%
Bachelor's Degree 19.2%
Graduate/Professional Degree 10.3%
2025 Population 15+ by Marital Status
Total 151,791
Never Married 35.8%
Married 51.5%
Widowed 4.6%
Divorced 8.1%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 50 ends

Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2020 Population by Race/Ethnicity
Total 180,494
White Alone 39.6%
Black Alone 7.3%
American Indian Alone 1.6%
Asian Alone 11.8%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.2%
Some Other Race Alone 23.5%
Two or More Races 23.5%
Hispanic Origin 46.4%
Diversity Index 87.1
2025 Population by Race/Ethnicity
Total 191,982
Wh ite Alone 36.5%
Black Alone 7.3%
American Indian Alone 1.6%
Asian Alone 12.3%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.2%
Some Other Race Alone 25.4%
Two or More Races 16.7%
Hispanic Origin 49.5%
Diversity Index 87.7
2025 Employed Pop 16+by Occupation
Total 91,964
White Collar 56.7%
Management/Business/Financial 14.1%
Professional 24.3%
Sales 7.8%
Administrative Support 10.6%
Services 18.1%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 51 Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2025 Employed Pop 16+ by Occupation
Total 91,964
Blue Collar 25.2%
Farmin g/Forestry/Fish in g 1.6%
Construction/Extraction 5.3%
Installation/Maintenance/Repair 3.1%
Production 3.5%
Transportation/Material Moving 11.7%
2025 Civilian Population 16+ in Labor Force
Civilian Population 16+ 91,964

94.4%

5.6%

11.9%

12.1%

65.6%

4.3%
13%

5.0%
4%

6.7%
2025 Employed Population 16+ by Industry
Total 86,842
Agriculture/Mining 6.1%
Construction 6.2%

4.7%

2.3%
Retail Trade 10.5%

8.6%
1%
Finance/Insurance/Real Estate 4.2%
Services 49.2%
Public Administration 7.0%
i
©2025 Esri
Manufacturing
Wholesale Trade
Population 16-24 Unemployment rate
Population 25-54 Employed
Population 25-54 Unemployment rate
Population 55-64 Employed
Population 55-64 Unemployment rate
Population 65+ Employed
Population 65+ Unemployment rate
Population 16+ Employed
Population 1 6+ Unemployment rate
Population 16-24 Employed
Transportation/Utilities
Information
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 52 ends

Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2025 Consumer Spending
Apparel & Services: Total $ $161,145,474
Average Spent $2,563.64
105
$109,557,187
Average Spent $1,742.93
98 $261,682,215
Average Spent $4,163.07
101
$469,894,001
Average Spent $7,475.48
100
$272,603,191
Average Spent $4,336.81
Spending Potential Index 105
Health Care: Total $ $481,054,108
Average Spent $7,653.03
Spending Potential Index 99
HH Furnishings & Equipment: Total $ $188,566,351
Average Spent $2,999.88
103
$68,594,682
Average Spent $1,091.26
104
$1,743,957,705
Average Spent $27,744.40
104
$222,418,704
Average Spent $3,538.43
Spending Potential Index 107
i
©2025 Esri
Spending Potential Index
Food at Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Food Away from Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Shelter: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Entertainment/Recreation: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Personal Care Products & Services: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Education: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Support Payments/Gifts in Kind: Total $
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 53 Community Profile | Gosford / River Walk Trade Area | Area: 122.82 square miles 2025 Consumer Spending
Travel: Total $ $232,963,901
Average Spent $3,706.19
103
$87,446,946
Average Spent $1,391.18
Spending Potential Index 103
Top Tapestry Segment
Boomburbs (H2):

Learn more about this segment.
i
©2025Esri
Spending Potential Index
Vehicle Maintenance & Repairs: Total $
Data Note: Household population includes persons not residing in group quarters. Average Household Size is the household population divided by total households. Persons in families include the householder and persons related to the householder by birth, marriage, or adoption. Per Capita Income represents the income received by all persons aged 15 years and over divided by the total population.

Income represents the preceding year, expressed in current dollars. Household income includes wage and salary earnings, interest dividends, net rents, pensions, SSI and welfare payments, child support, and alimony.

Persons of Hispanic Origin may be of any race. The Diversity Index measures the probability that two people from the same area will be from different race/ethnic groups.

Consumer spending shows the amount spent on a variety of goods and services by households that reside in the area. Expenditures are shown by broad budget categories that are not mutually exclusive. Consumer spending does not equal business revenue. Total and Average Amount Spent Per Household represent annual figures. The Spending Potential Index represents the amount spent in the area relative to a national average of 100.

Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

This segment is characterized by high-earning suburban families in the South and West.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 54 ends

Table A-7: Socioeconomic Characteristics; Downtown Bakersfield Regional Trade Area; Estimate 2025 Rings: 12 mile radii
Population Summary 1 2 miles
2010 Total Population 534,022
2020 Total Population 600,909
2020 Group Quarters 6,404
2025 Total Population 618,388
2025 Group Quarters 5,019
2030Total Population 627,020
2025-2030 Annual Rate 0.28%
2025 Total Daytime Population 603,402
Workers 237,655
Residents 365,747
Household Summary
2010 Total Households 166,886
2010 Average Household Size 3.17
2020 Total Households 187,779
2020 Average Household Size 3.17
2025 Total Households 197,065
2025 Average Household Size 3.11
2030 Total Households 202,057
2030 Average Household Size 3.08
2025-2030 Annual Rate 0.50%
2025 Families 146,294
2025 Average Family Size 3.57
2030 Families 149,894
2030 Average Family Size 3.53
2025-2030 Growth Rate 0.5%
©2025 Esri
Community Profile
Downtown Bakersfield Gesri
THE SCIENCE OF WHERE*
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 (1) geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 55 Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii Housing Unit Summary

41.1%

8.2%

42.0%

4.0%

40.5%

4.0%

39.2%

4.0%
Median Household Income 1 2 miles
2025
2030
Per Capita Income
2025
2030
2025 Households by Income
Household Income Base

6.1%

7.3%

9.8%

17.1%

12.9%
1 7.4%

10.4%

9.3%
$100,263
i
©2025 Esri
$31,980
$35,568
181,702

58.9%
$74,908
$82,198
195,516

58.0%
210,379

60.8%
205,280

59.5%
197,064

9.7%
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.
2010 Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2020 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2025 Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
2030Total Housing Units
Owner Occupied Housing Units
Renter Occupied Housing Units
Vacant Housing Units
<$15,000
$15,000 $24,999
$25,000 - $34,999
$35,000 - $49,999
$50,000 - $74,999
$75,000 - $99,999
$100,000-$149,999
$150,000 $199,999
$200,000+
Average Household Income
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 56 ends

Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2025 Affordability, Mortgage and Wealth
Housing Affordability Index 75
Percent of Income for Mortgage 31.3%
Wealth Index 77
Median Home Value
2025 $374,446
2030 $431,367
2025 Home Value 1 2 miles
117,208

3.2%
$50,000 - $99,999 2.0%
$100,000-5149,999 3.0%
$150,000-$199,999 4.0%
$200,000 - $249,999 7.5%
$250,000-$299,999 9.6%
$300,000-5399,999 27.8%
$400,000 - $499,999 21.0%
$500,000 - $749,999 1 6.6%
$750,000-$999,999 3.0%
$1,000,000 $1,499,999 1.5%
$1,500,000-$1,999,999 0.4%
$2,000,000 + 0.5%
Average Home Value $413,341
2025 Population by Sex
Males 307,623
Females 310,765
Median Age
2010 29.9
2020 32.4
2025 33.4
2030 34.5
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Total Owner Occupied Housing Units
<$50,000
Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 57 Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2025 Population by Age 1 2 miles
Total 618,387
0-4 7.1%
5-9 7.3%
10-14 7.8%
15-24 15.2%
25-34 15.1%
35-44 13.7%
45-54 11.6%
55-64 9.8%
65-74 7.9%
75-84 3.8%
85 + 1.1%
18 + 73.0%
2025 Pop 25+ by Educational Attainment
Total 387,282
Less than 9th Grade 10.4%
9th - 12th Grade, No Diploma 9.3%
High School Graduate 24.8%
GED/Alternative Credential 3.5%
Some College, No Degree 21.1%
Associate Degree 8.6%
Bachelor's Degree 14.7%
Graduate/Professional Degree 7.6%
2025 Population 15+ by Marital Status
Total 481,291
Never Married 39.5%
Married 47.4%
Widowed 4.6%
Divorced 8.5%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 58 ends

Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2020 Population by Race/Ethnicity 12 miles
Total 600,909
White Alone 40.2%
Black Alone 5.8%
American Indian Alone 2.0%
Asian Alone 5.7%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.1%
Some Other Race Alone 29.4%
Two or More Races 29.4%
Hispanic Origin 55.1%
Diversity Index 85.7
2025 Population by Race/Ethnicity
Total 618,389
Wh ite Alone 37.4%
Black Alone 5.8%
American Indian Alone 1.9%
Asian Alone 6.1%
Pacific Islander Alone 0.1%
Some Other Race Alone 31.3%
Two or More Races 17.3%
Hispanic Origin 57.8%
Diversity Index 85.9
2025 Employed Pop 16+by Occupation
Total 277,122
White Collar 50.9%
Management/Business/Financial 12.4%
Professional 20.6%
Sales 7.7%
Administrative Support 10.1%
Services 19.2%
i
©2025 Esri
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 59 Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2025 Employed Pop 16+ by Occupation 12 miles
Total 277,122
Blue Collar 29.9%
Farmin g/Forestry/Fish in g 4.8%
Construction/Extraction 7.1%
Installation/Maintenance/Repair 3.5%
Production 3.8%
Transportation/Material Moving 10.7%
2025 Civilian Population 16+ in Labor Force
Civilian Population 16+ 277,122

92.6%

7.4%

13.4%

15.2%

62.6%

6.0%
13%

5.8%
4%

6.1%
2025 Employed Population 16+ by Industry
Total 256,548
Agriculture/Mining 9.4%
Construction 8.0%

4.6%

2.1%
Retail Trade 10.2%

7.3%
1%
Finance/Insurance/Real Estate 3.6%
Services 47.7%
Public Administration 6.0%
i
©2025 Esri
Manufacturing
Wholesale Trade
Population 16-24 Unemployment rate
Population 25-54 Employed
Population 25-54 Unemployment rate
Population 55-64 Employed
Population 55-64 Unemployment rate
Population 65+ Employed
Population 65+ Unemployment rate
Population 16+ Employed
Population 1 6+ Unemployment rate
Population 16-24 Employed
Transportation/Utilities
Information
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum

Page 60 ends

Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2025 Consumer Spending 1 2 miles
Apparel & Services: Total $ $429,049,814
Average Spent $2,177.20
89 $284,347,452
Average Spent $1,442.91
81 $686,693,497
Average Spent $3,484.60
85 $1,269,726,100
Average Spent $6,443.18
87 $730,981,655
Average Spent $3,709.34
Spending Potential Index 90
Health Care: Total $ $1,272,024,273
Average Spent $6,454.85
Spending Potential Index 83
HH Furnishings & Equipment: Total $ $495,281,709
Average Spent $2,513.29
86 $181,074,039
Average Spent $918.85
88 $4,607,743,938
Average Spent $23,381.85
88 $566,823,831
Average Spent $2,876.33
Spending Potential Index 87
i
©2025 Esri
Spending Potential Index
Food at Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Food Away from Home: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Shelter: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Entertainment/Recreation: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Personal Care Products & Services: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Education: Total $
Spending Potential Index
Support Payments/Gifts in Kind: Total $
Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Development Project Page 61 Community Profile | Downtown Bakersfield | Rings: 12 mile radii 2025 Consumer Spending 1 2 miles
Travel: Total $ $597,700,249
Average Spent $3,033.01
84 $232,501,561
Average Spent $1,179.82
Spending Potential Index 87
Shared Roots (G1):

Learn more about this segment.
i
©2025Esri
Spending Potential Index
Vehicle Maintenance & Repairs: Total $
Top Tapestry Segment
12 miles
Data Note: Household population includes persons not residing in group quarters. Average Household Size is the household population divided by total households. Persons in families include the householder and persons related to the householder by birth, marriage, or adoption. Per Capita Income represents the income received by all persons aged 15 years and over divided by the total population.

This segment is characterized by large
multigenerational households in the South
and West.

Income represents the preceding year, expressed in current dollars. Household income includes wage and salary earnings, interest dividends, net rents, pensions, SSI and welfare payments, child support, and alimony.

Persons of Hispanic Origin may be of any race. The Diversity Index measures the probability that two people from the same area will be from different race/ethnic groups.

Consumer spending shows the amount spent on a variety of goods and services by households that reside in the area. Expenditures are shown by broad budget categories that are not mutually exclusive. Consumer spending does not equal business revenue. Total and Average Amount Spent Per Household represent annual figures. The Spending Potential Index represents the amount spent in the area relative to a national average of 100.

Source: Esri forecasts for 2025 and 2030. U.S. Census 2010 and 2020 Census data converted by Esri into 2020 geography. Consumer Spending data are derived from the 2022 and 2023 Consumer Expenditure Surveys, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Appendix K
Tribal Correspondence

Kl^ley>»HOrn
March 26, 2026
To: See Attached Tribal Mailing List File: Various
RE: Senate Bill 18 Consultation – General Plan Amendment the 2026 Quarter 3 General Plan Amendment Cycle Pursuant to State of California Senate Bill (SB) 18, your tribe may request consultation with the City of Bakersfield regarding the preservation of, and/or mitigation of impacts to, California Native American cultural places in connection with the following projects. The name and address of the project applicant is the City of Bakersfield, Development Services Department, 1715 Chester Avenue, Bakersfield, California 93301. Each project is a request for an amendment to the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan Land Use Element or Circulation Element (and the City of Bakersfield Zoning Ordinance, if applicable).

General Plan Amendment (GPA) No. 23-0001
The project to be considered: The applicant proposes to change the existing land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) on approximately 46.16 acres.

Project location: Southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road.

Project Description: The Project Site is located in the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield. The Project Site is

46.16 acres and consists of one legal parcel (APN 368-010-05), which is an undeveloped L-shaped property situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway (CA-58), north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road. The Project Site is zoned M-2 (General Manufacturing), which allows the proposed commercial retail center use.

The Project involves the construction and operation of the Riverview Market, a commercial retail center, that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger anchor buildings interior to the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thru, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps. Other Project components include vehicular access and circulation improvements (both on- and off-site); surface parking areas and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; various landscape, hardscape, and lighting improvements; green space/park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility improvements. Project construction is anticipated to occur over an approximately 20-month timeframe, commencing in early 2027.

The discretionary entitlements, reviews, permits, and approvals required to implement the Project include, but are not necessarily limited to, the following:

Development Services Department
1715 Chester Avenue, Bakersfield, CA 93301
Planning: 661-326-3733 Building: 661-326-3720
FAX Planning: 661-852-2136 Building: 661-325-0266

BAKERSFIELD
THE SOUND OF Gowell inoy Belter
• General Plan Amendment (GPA) (of the land use element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan) from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) • Site Plan Review consistent with the Bakersfield Municipal Code 17.08.140. • Tentative Subdivision Map
• Comprehensive Sign Plan
• Certification of an Environmental Impact Report
Please be aware that the City is required under State law to protect the confidentiality of any information provided by your tribe concerning California Native American cultural places. Any information you provide will be kept strictly confidential and will not be divulged to the public. In accordance with SB 18, your tribe has up to 90 days from receipt of this notice to request consultation. If you wish to consult on any of these projects, please respond in writing by June 24, 2026.

Please feel free to call me at (661) 326-3673 if you have any questions or would like to discuss further.

Sincerely,

Ashley Knight
Assistant Planner
Attachment: Mailing List
Location map
Cultural Study
V
Senate Bill 18
Tribal Mailing List
Santa Rosa Rancheria
Clarence Atwell, Chair
P.O. Box 8
Lemoore, CA 93245
Kitanemuk & Yowlumne Tejon Indians
Delia Dominguez
981 N. Virginia
Covina, CA 91722
Kawaiisu Tribe
David Laughinghorse Robinson
P.O. Box 20849
Bakersfield, CA 93390
Tubatulabals of Kern Valley
Donna Begay, Tribal Chairwoman
P.O. Box 226
Lake Isabella, CA 93240
Tule River Indian Tribe
Neil Peyron, Chair
P.O. Box 589
Porterville, CA 93258
Chumash Council of Bakersfield
James R. Leon, Chair
P.O. Box 902
Bakersfield, CA 93302
Robert L. Gomez, Jr.
2619 Driller Avenue
Bakersfield, CA 93306
Tejon Indian Tribe
Octavio Escobedo III, Chair
4941 David Road
Bakersfield, CA 93307
Kern Valley Indian Council
Robert Robertson, HPO
P.O. Box 401
Weldon, CA 93283
Chalon Indian Council of Bakersfield
Attn: Audrey Alvarado
P.O. Box 902
Bakersfield, CA 93302

JET WAY

ESPRESSO DR

CAPPUCCINO
WAY

LATTE LN

SILVERLAKE DR

HOODSPORT AVE
C
O
L
VIL
L
E
AV
E

STARSIDE DR

DELBERT ST
HENRY
LN
MOXEE
CT
N
E
A
H
B
AY
D
R

CAPE FLATTERY DR

EL TORO VIEJO RD

SEABECK AVE

SUNCRISP LN

JENNA KATHRYN DR
ODESSA
CT

ICICLE CREEK DR

WOLF RIVER AVE

KENNEWICK LN

TELSTAR
AVE

LOON CT

GREENBANK
ST

COURTLAND
AVE

CRISPIN ST
PIN
K
L
A
D
Y
W
A
Y

BELMAC AVE

HENRY LN

OLEO DR

ELZWORTH ST

STEAM CT

SEAVIEW DR

COFFEE FRONTAGE RD

SHOFNER AVE

LANGLEY RD

CHESAW CT

GREENACRES DR
MAX DR

MC INTOSH WAY

RIBSTON AVE

CHATTAROY ST

BOLERO AVE

CLAY PATRICK FARR WAY EL TORO VIEJO RD

GRANITE FALLS DR
COFFEE
RD

COFFEE RD

ROSEDALE HWY ROSEDALE HWY
SI
SI
SI
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
P
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
HI

GC GC HI
SI
SI
GC
GC
HMR
LI
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
OS-P
MUC
MUC
MUC
PS
MC
MC
LR
LR LR
ER
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
HI HI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
LI
P P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
GC
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
GC
GC
LI
LR LR
LR LR
LR
HMR
OS-P
LI
LI
LI
LI
LR
LR
LR
SI

GREENACRES
PARK
Fruitvale
Junior High
School
BaseEditor_MV
0 350 700
Feet
_
GPA 23-0001

CITY OF BAKERSFIELD
GPA 23-0001
FROM: P
TO: LI
CITY
COUNTY
LEGEND
(GENERAL PLAN

LAND USE)
RR Rural Residential

2.5 gross acres/dwelling unit
ER Estate Residential
1 dwelling unit/net acre
SR Suburban Residential
≤4 dwelling units/net acre
SR/LR
County: ≤ 4 dwelling units/net acre
City: ≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LR Low Density Residential
≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LMR Low Medium Density Residential
> 4 but ≤ 10 dwelling units/net acre
HMR High Medium Density Residential
>7.26 units but
≤17.42 dwelling units/net acre
HR High Density Residential
>17.42 units but
≤72.6 dwelling units/net acre
HC Highway Commercial
GC General Commercial
MC Major Commercial
OC Office Commercial
MUC Mixed Use Commercial
LI Light Industrial
SI Service Industrial
HI Heavy Industrial
P Public Facilities
PS Public/Private Schools
PT Public Transportation Corridors
P-SW Solid Waste Facilities
OS Open Space
OS-P Parks and Recreation
OS-S Slopes exceeding 30%
R-IA Resource -
Intensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
R-EA Resource -
Extensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
80 acre min (Williamson Act)
R-MP Resource -
Minerals & Petroleum
5 acre minimum parcel size
UER Urban Estate Residential
Western Rosedale Plan

0.5 acre net minimum parcel size
WM West Ming Specific Plan
COUNTY
CITY
I
I
-----L.mm
L
L:J
|
_JA ■ r
7/S 4
J I
19 15

BAKERSFIELD
1 i
i
i
i
i
i
i
।
।
।
■
।
i
।
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i.
i
i
i
i
!
i
i
!
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
Ji
i
i

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T
Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Retail Center
City of Bakersfield, Kern County, California
Prepared for:

Jorge Estrada
Placeworks
3 MacArthur Place, Suite 1100
Santa Ana, California 92707
Prepared by:

Joseph Orozco, M.A., RPA
Contributions by Timothy Blood, M.S.

BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, California 91711
Project No. PWK2203
Data Base Information:

Type of Study: Intensive Survey
Resources Recorded: P-15-3290, PWK2203-H-1, H-4, H-5, H-6 Keywords: Bakersfield, Electrical Distribution, Electrical Transmission USGS Quadrangle: 7.5-minute Oildale (1968); California
February 14, 2025

BCRCONSULTING LLC
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R ii

MANAGEMENT SUMMARY
BCR Consulting LLC (BCR Consulting) is under contract to Placeworks to complete a Cultural Resources Assessment of the proposed Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project in the City of Bakersfield (City), Kern County, California. For the study, a cultural resources records search, additional research, intensive-level pedestrian field survey, Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC) Sacred Lands File Search, and vertebrate paleontological resources overview were conducted for the project in partial fulfillment of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). BCR Consulting initially conducted a Cultural Resources Assessment study of the project site in October 2022. In January 2025, BCR Consulting conducted a follow-up study of the project site.

The records search has revealed that 20 previous cultural resource studies have taken place, and 14 cultural resources have been identified within one half-mile of the project site.

Three of the previous studies assessed portions of the project site for cultural resources, and one resource (a historic-period refuse scatter designated P-15-3290) was previously identified within the project site boundaries. During the field survey, BCR Consulting Staff Archaeologists were unable to relocate P-15-3290. Four additional historic-period cultural resources were identified and evaluated for California Register eligibility by BCR Consulting in October 2022. During the follow-up field survey, one of the four resources recorded by BCR Consulting in 2022 (PWK2203-H-1) was in the process of being demolished, with the exception of three utility poles within the historic-period archaeological site. Each of the four resources identified within the project site are recommended not eligible for the California Register and as such are not a “historical resource” under CEQA. Therefore, no significant impact related to historical resources is anticipated and no further investigations are recommended for the proposed project unless:
• The proposed project is changed to include areas that have not been subject to this cultural resource assessment;
• Cultural materials are encountered during project activities.

The current study attempted to determine whether significant archaeological deposits were present on the proposed project site. Although none were yielded during the records search and field survey, ground-disturbing activities have the potential to reveal buried deposits not observed on the surface. Prior to the initiation of further ground-disturbing activities, field personnel should be alerted to the possibility of buried prehistoric or historic cultural deposits. In the event that field personnel encounter buried cultural materials, work in the immediate vicinity of the find should cease and a qualified archaeologist should be retained to assess the significance of the find. The qualified archaeologist should have the authority to stop or divert construction excavation as necessary. If the qualified archaeologist finds that any cultural resources present meet eligibility requirements for listing on the California Register or the National Register of Historic Places (National Register), plans for the treatment, evaluation, and mitigation of impacts to the find will need to be developed.

Prehistoric or historic cultural materials that may be encountered during ground-disturbing activities include:
• Historic-period artifacts such as glass bottles and fragments, cans, nails, ceramic and pottery fragments, and other metal objects;
• Historic-period structural or building foundations, walkways, cisterns, pipes, privies, and other structural elements;
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R iii
• Prehistoric flaked-stone artifacts and debitage (waste material), consisting of obsidian, basalt, and or cryptocrystalline silicates;
• Groundstone artifacts, including mortars, pestles, and grinding slabs; • Dark, greasy soil that may be associated with charcoal, ash, bone, shell, flaked stone, groundstone, and fire affected rocks;
• Human remains.

Findings were negative during the initial and updated Sacred Lands File searches with the NAHC. The results of the Sacred Lands File search are provided in Appendix C. The State Legislature added requirements regarding tribal cultural resources for CEQA in Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) that took effect July 1, 2015. AB 52 requires consultation with California Native American tribes and consideration of tribal cultural resources in the CEQA process.

By including tribal cultural resources early in the CEQA process, the legislature intended to ensure that local and Tribal governments, public agencies, and project proponents would have information available, early in the project planning process, to identify and address potential adverse impacts to tribal cultural resources. By taking this proactive approach, the legislature also intended to reduce the potential for delay and conflicts in the environmental review process. To help determine whether a project may have such an effect, the Public Resources Code requires a lead agency to consult with any California Native American tribe that requests consultation and is traditionally and culturally affiliated with the geographic area of a Proposed Project. Since the City will initiate and carry out the required AB52 Native American Consultation, the results of the consultation are not provided in this report.

However, this report may be used during the consultation process, and BCR Consulting staff is available to answer questions and address concerns as necessary.

According to CEQA Guidelines, projects subject to CEQA must determine whether the project would “directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological resource”. The Paleontological Overview provided in Appendix E has recommended that:

The geologic units underlying the project area are mapped primarily as alluvial fan deposits from the Holocene epoch (Smith, 1964) Holocene alluvial units are considered to be of high preservation value, but material found is unlikely to be fossil material due to the relatively modern associated dates of the deposits.

However, if development requires any substantial depth of disturbance, the likelihood of reaching Pleistocene alluvial sediments would increase. The Western Science Center does not have localities within the project area or within a 1 mile radius; however, this is likely due in part to the project’s distance from WSC.

While the presence of any fossil material is unlikely, if excavation activity disturbs deeper sediment dating to the earliest parts of the Holocene or Late Pleistocene periods, the material would be scientifically significant. Excavation activity associated with the development of the project area is unlikely to be paleontologically sensitive, but caution during development should be observed.

If human remains are encountered during any project activities, State Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5 states that no further disturbance shall occur until the County Coroner has made a determination of origin and disposition pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 5097.98. The County Coroner must be notified of the find immediately. If the F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R iv
remains are determined to be prehistoric, the Coroner will notify the NAHC, which will determine and notify a Most Likely Descendant (MLD). With the permission of the landowner or his/her authorized representative, the MLD may inspect the site of the discovery. The MLD shall complete the inspection within 48 hours of notification by the NAHC.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E H I G H W A Y A N D C O F F E E R O A D P R O J E C T iii

TABLE OF CONTENTS
MANAGEMENT SUMMARY ................................................................................................. ii INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................1 REGULATORY SETTING…………………………… ...................................…………………..1 NATURAL SETTING.............................................................................................................4 CULTURAL SETTING...........................................................................................................5 PREHISTORIC CONTEXT..............................................................................................5 HISTORY ....................................................................................................................... 5 PERSONNEL........................................................................................................................6 METHODS............................................................................................................................6 RESEARCH ....................................................................................................................6 FIELD SURVEY ..............................................................................................................7 RESULTS .............................................................................................................................7 RESEARCH ....................................................................................................................7 FIELD SURVEY ............................................................................................................. 7 SIGNIFICANCE EVALUATIONS...........................................................................................9 SIGNIFICANCE CRITERIA .............................................................................................9 EVALUATIONS .............................................................................................................10 RECOMMENDATIONS.......................................................................................................11 REFERENCES....................................................................................................................13

FIGURES
1: Project Location Map.......................................................................................................2 TABLES
A: Cultural Resources and Reports Within One Half-Mile of the Project Site........................7

APPENDICES
A: CONFIDENTIAL RESOURCE LOCATIONS/RECORD SEARCH BIBLIOGRAPHY B: DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION 523 FORMS
C: NATIVE AMERICAN HERITAGE COMMISSION SACRED LANDS FILE SEARCH D: PROJECT PHOTOGRAPHS
E: PALEONTOLOGICAL RESOURCES OVERVIEW
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 1 INTRODUCTION
BCR Consulting LLC (BCR Consulting) is under contract to Placeworks to complete a Cultural Resources Assessment of the proposed Rosedale & Coffee Road Project (project) in the City of Bakersfield (City), Kern County, California. The project occupies approximately 48 acres and is bounded by various commercial properties to the north, east, and west and an electrical substation to the south. A cultural resources records search, additional research, intensive-level pedestrian field survey, Sacred Lands File search with the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC), and paleontological overview were conducted for the project in partial fulfillment of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The project site is located in section 29, Township 29 South, Range 27 East, Mt Diablo Baseline and Meridian. It is depicted on the United States Geological Survey (USGS) Oildale, California (1968) 7.5-minute topographic quadrangles (Figure 1).

Regulatory Setting
The California Environmental Quality Act. CEQA applies to all discretionary projects undertaken or subject to approval by the state’s public agencies (California Code of Regulations 14(3), § 15002(i)). Under CEQA, “A project with an effect that may cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a historical resource is a project that may have a significant effect on the environment” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 14(3), § 15064.5(b)).

State CEQA Guidelines section 15064.5(a) defines a “historical resource” as a resource that meets one or more of the following criteria:
• Listed in, or eligible for listing in, the California Register of Historical Resources (California Register)
• Listed in a local register of historical resources (as defined at Cal. Public Res. Code § 5020.1(k))
• Identified as significant in a historical resource survey meeting the requirements of § 5024.1(g) of the Cal. Public Res. Code
• Determined to be a historical resource by a project's lead agency (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 14(3), § 15064.5(a))
A historical resource consists of “Any object, building, structure, site, area, place, record, or manuscript which a lead agency determines to be historically significant or significant in the architectural, engineering, scientific, economic, agricultural, educational, social, political, military, or cultural annals of California…Generally, a resource shall be considered by the lead agency to be ‘historically significant’ if the resource meets the criteria for listing in the California Register of Historical Resources” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 14(3), § 15064.5(a)(3)).

The significance of a historical resource is impaired when a project demolishes or materially alters in an adverse manner those physical characteristics of a historical resource that convey its historical significance and that justify its eligibility for the California Register. If an impact on a historical or archaeological resource is significant, CEQA requires feasible measures to minimize the impact (State CEQA Guidelines § 15126.4 (a)(1)). Mitigation of significant impacts must lessen or eliminate the physical impact that the project will have on the resource.

Project Location | N
<■
Bakersfield

0.25 0.5
Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin,
0 0.5 S, Intermap,
P, NRCan, Esri ANAL
ME —
0 ======---
Figure 1 Project Location Site
Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project
N
A
33--%
1 1 Kilometers
i
18 ======= eservoi
======,, 17 16
ae® i
390
wW hue
/
Water Tank
ROAD —387===-==- 398 * ;s N T
---- 2%. es.
!
Well I /
Well
O Wel. o o O
o
o o
A I
; c.

O
20 1$ ” * 397 H' O
%
•21 % t o
o o
Siphon
P 385 o • A o
i
i
“AL F Il I
t a
; : -Greenacres
Project Location
&=9o i -s
o Jl - "‘** -
il : Fruitva e.°. I"
Fo .. Tar 3932" • • • X HV • • .KT
• ' : 1—
C
Park j, ! OF e9 •
. *==, r. ■
37a o (
0000 caroKok il t • I
D
£
]
38® 29. ? 28 ICason 19 8M -i 17 A ND

SANTA FE
5 === ===9 P= a
|
#
’J30 /
29 o 0
o i • 000 *s ------ i.
ii r—• d
I O ■
Bl ROAD BRIM Hit t:t ■
I X ot
376 384 IK -Or 2
■ fl
% O.

X
/
Vicinity Map $
li
8 o
o
I
I
I
s
o
79 %
J
ii RBin@?*Laz.s
II I
II 1
S
6 ■
B
i
11 I
I
©
o
■
a
l
&Q
II
I
II
I
I
0 I
I
I
n
B
■
a
Q
§
s
Or
w
C
3 o
.8 ,.Qo
393”
TOPEKA #-

04. os. ’o
6 >
>O
I
I
I
I
I
fl
I
1 r
I
ii
a
#B
4°
“o
99 ••
Res I =
-
$
o
i
I
v - a •
n
I
II •
Re
a>
»» ।
> H ।
— Z it I
II । <

POWERPSANT
f Kst
ii
#
14+
i cw (‘OWAY ¥
i
2770. tgs
‘s
■
384
-= ===
a
1 I
II
II
N
*t.
wO
alr 1′2str
—mat w.h
eV .
%
---
Fire
|. *.st,BM 382
- ” . ■
st
30 •
2/4
t • -
. r
Siphon
======
|&
a==r- F
o
ROSEDALE •» !
Reference: ESRI; USGS Quad: Oildale, California (1968)
P aceworks BCRCONSULTING - Claremont Napa Tehachapi
LLC
www.bcrconsulting.net
909-525-7078
0 10 20
■ Miles
h (D
(
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 3 Section 5024.1 of the Cal. Public Res. Code established the California Register. Generally, a resource is considered by the lead agency to be “historically significant” if the resource meets the criteria for listing in the California Register (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 14(3), § 15064.5(a)(3)). The eligibility criteria for the California Register are similar to those of the National Register of Historic Places (National Register), and a resource that meets one or more of the eligibility criteria of the National Register will be eligible for the California Register. The California Register program encourages public recognition and protection of resources of architectural, historical, archaeological, and cultural significance, identifies historical resources for state and local planning purposes, determines eligibility for state historic preservation grant funding and affords certain protections under CEQA. Criteria for Designation:

1. Associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of local or regional history or the cultural heritage of California or the United States.

2. Associated with the lives of persons important to local, California or national history.

3. Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, region or method of construction or represents the work of a master or possesses high artistic values.

4. Has yielded, or has the potential to yield, information important to the prehistory or history of the local area, California or the nation.

In addition to meeting one or more of the above criteria, the California Register requires that sufficient time has passed since a resource’s period of significance to “obtain a scholarly perspective on the events or individuals associated with the resources.” (CCR 4852 [d][2]).

Fifty years is normally considered sufficient time for a potential historical resource, and in order that the evaluation remain valid for a minimum of five years after the date of this report, all resources older than 45 years (i.e. resources from the “historic-period”) will be evaluated for California Register listing eligibility, or CEQA significance. The California Register also requires that a resource possess integrity. This is defined as the ability for the resource to convey its significance through seven aspects: location, setting, design, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association.

Finally, CEQA requires that significant effects on unique archaeological resources be considered and addressed. CEQA defines a unique archaeological resource as any archaeological artifact, object, or site about which it can be clearly demonstrated that, without merely adding to the current body of knowledge, there is a high probability that it meets any of the following criteria:

1. Contains information needed to answer important scientific research questions and there is a demonstrable public interest in that information.

2. Has a special and particular quality such as being the oldest of its type or the best available example of its type.

3. Is directly associated with a scientifically recognized important prehistoric or historic event or person.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 4 CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.5 Appendix G includes significance criteria relative to archaeological and historical resources. These have been utilized as thresholds of significance here, and a project would have a significant environmental impact if it would:
a) cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a historical resource as defined in section 10564.5;
b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of an archaeological resource pursuant to Section 10564.5;
c) Disturb any human remains, including those interred outside of formal cemeteries.

Tribal Cultural Resources. The Legislature added requirements regarding tribal cultural resources for CEQA in Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) that took effect July 1, 2015. AB 52 requires consultation with California Native American tribes and consideration of tribal cultural resources in the CEQA process. By including tribal cultural resources early in the CEQA process, the legislature intended to ensure that local and Tribal governments, public agencies, and project proponents would have information available, early in the project planning process, to identify and address potential adverse impacts to tribal cultural resources. By taking this proactive approach, the legislature also intended to reduce the potential for delay and conflicts in the environmental review process. To help determine whether a project may have such an effect, the Public Resources Code requires a lead agency to consult with any California Native American tribe that requests consultation and is traditionally and culturally affiliated with the geographic area of a Proposed Project. Since the City will initiate and carry out the required AB52 Native American Consultation, the results of the consultation are not provided in this report. However, this report may be used during the consultation process, and BCR Consulting staff are available to answer questions and address comments as necessary.

Paleontological Resources. CEQA provides guidance relative to significant impacts on paleontological resources, indicating that a project would have a significant impact on paleontological resources if it disturbs or destroys a unique paleontological resource or site or unique geologic feature. Section 5097.5 of the California Public Resources Code specifies that any unauthorized removal of paleontological remains is a misdemeanor.

Further, California Penal Code Section 622.5 sets the penalties for damage or removal of paleontological resources. CEQA documentation prepared for projects would be required to analyze paleontological resources as a condition of the CEQA process to disclose potential impacts. Please note that as of January 2018 paleontological resources are considered in the geological rather than cultural category. Therefore, paleontological resources are not summarized in the body of this report. A paleontological overview completed by the Western Science Center is provided as Appendix E.

NATURAL SETTING
The elevation of the project site is approximately 370-380 feet above mean sea level. It is located in the eastern portion of the southern San Joaquin Valley. Local rainfall averages approximately eight inches per year, and the runoff is channeled from northeast to southwest. Most of the local vegetation currently consists of non-native seasonal grasses and Russian thistle. Prior to the introduction of large-scale agriculture and oil exploitation, F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 5 the San Joaquin River and Tulare Lake’s massive system of channels, sloughs, and tule-choked marshes defined the local ecosystem (Wallace 1978:462). As a result, the biotic character of the valley was historically much more diversified than is presently evident.

Large freshwater marshes and vast expanses of grassland supported a variety of wildlife, including grizzly bears and wolves (both locally extinct), tule elk, jackrabbits, quail, and numerous fish, rodents, reptiles and birds (Twisselmann 1967, Osborne 1992, Cogswell 1977, and Moyle 1976). Dirt roads and natural clearings have revealed homogenous soils made up of fine silts that contain very few rocks, which exhibit no evidence of prehistoric or historic cultural utility within the project site.

CULTURAL SETTING
Prehistoric Context
The project is situated within the traditional boundaries of the Southern Valley Yokuts. This prehistoric population depended heavily on the Tulare, Buena Vista, and Kern Lakes and their connecting sloughs and rivers for sustenance and transportation (Wallace 1978:448).

The local Southern Valley Yokuts, referred to as the Chuxoxi, represented one of the southernmost Yokut political units and were associated with the channels and sloughs of the Kern River delta (Wallace 1978:449; Kroeber 1925:483). Chuxoxi trade routes and rights to the delta allowed them to reap the benefits of the related perennial water sources. This enabled local populations to pursue a relatively sedentary lifestyle in an otherwise arid climate. Prehistorically, such sedentism often coincides with a village-style residential model in which residential bases remain the same or seasonal, while specialized procurement parties are deployed to more remote areas to collect specialized resources (Binford 1980, Thomas 1983). This village model has been locally supported by early ethnographers, who considered Yokuts unique in California for forming "true tribes" and for developing an unparalleled array of dialects (Kroeber 1925:474).

History
The first Europeans to establish contact with the Sothern Valley Yokuts were Spanish troops led by Captain Don Pedro Fages in pursuit of deserters. Father Francisco Garces also travelled through the San Joaquin Valley searching for an overland route from Yuma to Monterey. During his travels, Garces noted positive interactions with locals (see Smith 1939, Bailey 1984). The Mexican era (1821-1848) saw little notable cultural exchange between Mexicans and Southern Valley Yokuts, although an 1833 malaria epidemic devastated the local native population (Wallace 1978:460). The ensuing American era, punctuated by California’s annexation into the United States in 1848, resulted in overwhelming Anglo settlement and seizing of Indian lands, and disrupted any remaining prehistoric Yokut influence in the San Joaquin Valley. Mining and ranching represented the early historical focus of the San Joaquin Valley, although the region’s abundant natural water supply, mild climate, and huge tracts of arable land soon led to the successful development of agriculture. The resulting diversion of local water and skyrocketing real estate values transformed the physical and economic character of the valley, and have allowed it to remain one of the most productive agricultural regions in the world to this day (Preston 1981).

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 6 PERSONNEL
David Brunzell, M.A., RPA acted as Principal Investigator and Joseph Orozco, M.A., RPA acted as Project Manager for the current study. Mr. Brunzell meets the United States Secretary of the Interior Professional Qualification Standards for Archaeology and Architectural History. Mr. Orozco wrote the technical report with contributions from BCR Consulting Archaeology Crew Chief Tim Blood, M.S. Mr. Blood and BCR Consulting Staff Archaeologist Eduardo Guiterrez, B.A., completed the follow-up pedestrian survey on January 16, 2025. Mr. Orozco updated the Department of Park and Recreation (DPR) 523 forms. Staff from the Southern San Joaquin Valley Information Center (SSJVIC) completed the cultural resources records search.

METHODS
This work was completed pursuant to CEQA, the Public Resources Code (PRC) Chapter

2.6, Section 21083.2, and California Code of Regulations (CCR) Title 14, Chapter 3, Article 5, Section 15064.5. The work is also completed pursuant to City Development Code Article 26: Historic Preservation. The pedestrian cultural resources survey was intended to locate and document previously recorded or new cultural resources, including archaeological sites, features, isolates, and historic-period buildings, that exceed 45 years in age within defined project boundaries. The project site was examined using 15-meter transect intervals, where accessible. This study is intended to determine whether cultural resources are located within the project boundaries, whether any cultural resources are significant pursuant to the above-referenced regulations and standards, and to develop specific mitigation measures that will address potential impacts to existing or potential resources. Tasks pursued to achieve that include:
• Cultural resources records search to review the results of any studies conducted within a half-mile radius of the project boundaries;
• Additional research through various local and regional resources; • Systematic pedestrian survey of the entire accessible project site; • California Register eligibility evaluation for resources identified; • Development of recommendations and mitigation measures for cultural resources documented within the project boundaries, following CEQA; • Completion of DPR 523 forms for any discovered cultural resources.

Research
Records Search. On September 12, 2022 a records search was conducted by the SSJVIC at California State University, Bakersfield. This archival research reviewed the status of all recorded historic and prehistoric cultural resources, and survey and excavation reports completed within one half-mile of the project site. Additional resources reviewed included the National Register, the California Register, and documents and inventories published by the California Office of Historic Preservation. These include the lists of California Historical Landmarks, California Points of Historical Interest, Listing of National Register Properties, and the Inventory of Historic Structures.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 7 Field Survey
An initial intensive-level cultural resources field survey of the project site was conducted on October 19, 2022, and an updated field survey of the subject property was conducted on January 16, 2025. The surveys were conducted by walking parallel transects spaced approximately 15 meters apart across the accessible project site. Cultural Resources were recorded on DPR 523 forms. Digital photographs were taken at various points within the project site. These included overviews as well as detailed photographs of all cultural resources. Cultural resources were recorded per the California OHP Instructions for Recording Historical Resources in the field using:
• Detailed note taking for entry on DPR Forms (see Appendix B) • Hand-held Garmin Global Positioning systems for mapping purposes • Digital photographic overviews and photographs of all cultural resources (see Appendix B and D).

RESULTS
Research
Records Search. Data from the SSJVIC revealed that 20 previous cultural resources studies have taken place, and 14 cultural resources have been recorded within one half-mile of the project site. Three of the previous studies from the record search have assessed portions of the project site for cultural resources revealing that one cultural resource (a historic-period refuse scatter designated P-15-3290) has been previously recorded within its boundaries. The records search results are summarized in Table A, and a complete records search bibliography and confidential resources locations is provided in Appendix A.

Table A. Cultural Resources and Reports Within One Half-Mile of the Project Site USGS 7.5 Min
Quad Cultural Resources Within One Half-Mile of Project Site Studies W/in OneHalf-Mile Oildale (1968) P-15-560: Historic-Period Railroad
P-15-3290: Historic-Period Refuse Scatter*
P-15-3291: Historic-Period Foundation
P-15-6435: Historic-Period Building
P-15-6436: Historic-Period Building
P-15-6438: Historic-Period Building
P-15-7233: Historic-Period Structure
P-15-8110: Historic-Period Building
P-15-8111: Historic-Period Building
P-15-9109: Historic-Period Refuse Scatter
P-15-12472: Historic-Period Oil Field
P-15-13728: Historic-Period Canal
P-15-17237: Historic-Period Water Conveyance System
P-15-17753: Historic-Period Road
KE-814, 866**, 909,
1062**, 1169**,
2323, 2396, 2665,
2738, 2807, 3025,
3168, 3199, 3778,
4250, 4250A, 4311,
4448, 4524, 4547
*Within project boundaries
**Previously assessed a portion of the project site
Field Survey
On October 19, 2022 BCR Consulting Archaeological Field Director (now Project Manager) Joseph Orozco, M.A., RPA and BCR Consulting Staff Archaeologist (now Crew Chief) Tim F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 8 Blood, M.S., and BCR Consulting Staff Archaeologists Doug Kazmier, B.A., and Scott Randell, M.A. completed the first pedestrian survey. On January 16, 2025, Mr. Blood and BCR Consulting Staff Archaeologist Eduardo Gutierrez, B.S., completed the follow-up field survey. One previously recorded resource and four newly recorded historic-period resources were identified during the initial field visit, and they were all re-recorded/updated during the recent field visit. The project site has been completely disturbed by historic-period oil pumps, oil tanks, and related installations, and some recent demolition and excavation activity.

Vegetation included sparse seasonal grasses in areas that have not been subject to asphalt paving or recent demolition and excavation. Average visibility was approximately 50 percent and sediment comprised sandy silt with very few rocks. Each resource is described in detail below. Citations for this section are provided in Appendix B.

P-15-3290. This site was originally recorded as a domestic refuse site in 1991 by the Cultural Resource Facility at California State University, Bakersfield. The site contained various glass fragments, ceramics, and kitchen supplies. During the initial field survey and the updated field survey, BCR Consulting staff conducted 15-meter transects over the site.

The area has been subject to mechanical clearing and the site is presumed destroyed.

PWK2203-H-1. This resource was a historic-period, 14-acre oil well and pump site located within the grounds of the former Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. During the initial survey, the site contained four oil wells with pumping units, two 20-foot diameter oil and water storage tanks, and three wooden electrical distribution poles. All oil well pumps, and the water and oil storage tanks had been demolished and removed from the property by the time the second field visit had been completed. The oil wells were in the process of being capped during the second field visit. The southeasternmost pump and two storage tanks were installed between 1952 and 1958, and the other three pumps were installed between 1968 and 1984. Among the oil pumps were two Lufkin Conventional Pumping Units, one National Company oil pump, and one Bethlehem oil pump. At least one pump fed into the oil and water storage tanks, and it is assumed that the three pumps were associated with the former tanks on the subject property. The wooden electrical distribution poles, which are all that remained in place during the January site visit, supplied power to electric drive motors on each of the units. According to General Land Office Records, the subject property was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876. By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by PG&E and contained a PG&E power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s. The former oil pump site was located on the northern portion of the subject property and overlapped areas utilized by the PG&E plant that was demolished in 2013. By the mid-1980s through early 2000s, a Christmas tree farm was present within the boundaries of the oil pump site while it was in operation. The oil pump site continued to operate and draw oil from the Fruitvale oil reserve and was operated by DD Naturals Resources, LLC until it was recently taken offline.

PWK2203-H-4. This resource is a historic-period, 230 KV double circuit lattice steel transmission tower within the Midway-Kern 230 KV alignment. Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and it continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Midway-Kern 230 KV alignment from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower. The resource has not undergone any visible alterations between the initial and recent field visits.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 9 PWK2203-H-5. This resource is a historic-period, double circuit lattice steel transmission tower within the Kern Lerdo/Kern Oil 115 KV alignment. Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Kern Lerdo/Kern Oil 115 KV alignment from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower. The resource has not undergone any visible alterations between the initial and recent field visits.

PWK2203-H-6. This resource is a historic-period, double circuit lattice steel transmission tower shared by the Kern Oil Famoso 70 KV and Kern Live Oak 115 KV alignment. Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Kern Oil Famoso 70 KV and Kern Live Oak 115 KV alignments from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower. The resource has not undergone any visible alterations between the initial and recent field visits.

SIGNIFICANCE EVALUATIONS
During the field survey, the historic-period refuse scatter designated P-15-3290 could not be identified. It is presumed destroyed and does not merit further consideration as a potential historical resource. One historic-period, former oil well and pump site and three historic-period lattice steel transmission towers were identified during the initial survey and the follow-up survey. CEQA calls for the evaluation and recordation of historic and archaeological resources. The criteria for determining the significance of impacts to cultural resources are based on Section 15064.5 of the CEQA Guidelines and Guidelines for the Nomination of Properties to the California Register. Properties eligible for listing in the California Register and subject to review under CEQA are those meeting the criteria for listing in the California Register, or designation under a local ordinance.

Significance Criteria
California Register of Historical Resources. The California Register criteria are based on National Register criteria. For a property to be eligible for inclusion on the California Register or as a City Landmark, one or more of the following criteria must be met:

1. It is associated with the events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of local or regional history, or the cultural heritage of California or the U.S.;

2. It is associated with the lives of persons important to local, California, or U.S. history;

3. It embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, region, or method of construction, represents the work of a master, possesses high artistic values; and/or

4. It has yielded, or has the potential to yield, information important to the prehistory or history of the local area, California, or the nation.

In addition to meeting one or more of the above criteria, the California Register requires that sufficient time has passed since a resource’s period of significance to “obtain a scholarly perspective on the events or individuals associated with the resources.” (CCR 4852 [d][2]).

The California Register also requires that a resource possess integrity. This is defined as the F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 10 ability for the resource to convey its significance through seven aspects: location, setting, design, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association.

California Register Evaluations
PWK2203-H-1. Criterion 1: Although the site was connected to oil exploration and development in Kern County, the installations occurred late in this era and were regionally common. Research has not indicated a close association between these resources and any important events. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 1.

Criterion 2: Substantial research has failed to connect the subject property with the lives of persons important in California’s past. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 2. Criterion 3: The oil pumps (which were removed prior to the follow-up field survey), utility towers, and tanks lacked architectural distinction and did not display significant or unique features. They do not significantly represent the work of an important creative individual or possess high artistic values. Therefore, the subject property is not eligible under Criterion 3. Criterion 4: The subject property has not and is not likely to yield information important in prehistory or history and is therefore not eligible for listing under Criterion 4. The subject property and its former historic-age oil pumps, tanks, and utility poles are therefore recommended not eligible under any of the four criteria for listing on the California Register, and as such are not recommended historical resources under CEQA.

PWK2203-H-4. Criterion 1: Substantial research has not indicated a close association between this transmission tower and any important events. Although it is connected with electrical development and transmission in the Kern County area, a single tower does not demonstrate that connection in any significant way. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 1. Criterion 2: Substantial research has failed to connect the subject property with the lives of persons important in California’s past. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 2. Criterion 3: The transmission tower is a utilitarian structure. It lacks architectural distinction and does not display significant elements of the era during which it was constructed. Finally, the tower does not represent the work of an important creative individual or possess high artistic values. Therefore, the subject property is not eligible under Criterion 3. Criterion 4: The subject property has not and is not likely to yield information important in prehistory or history and is therefore not eligible for listing under Criterion 4. This historic-period transmission tower is therefore recommended not eligible under any of the four criteria for listing on the California Register, and as such is not recommended a historical resource under CEQA.

PWK2203-H-5. Criterion 1: Substantial research has not indicated a close association between this transmission tower and any important events. Although it is connected with electrical development and transmission in the Kern County area, a single tower does not demonstrate that connection in any significant way. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 1. Criterion 2: Substantial research has failed to connect the subject property with the lives of persons important in California’s past. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 2. Criterion 3: The transmission tower is a utilitarian structure. It lacks architectural distinction and does not display significant elements of the era during which it was constructed. Finally, the tower does not represent the work of an important creative individual or possess high artistic values. Therefore, the subject property is not eligible under Criterion 3. Criterion 4: The subject property has not and is not F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 11 likely to yield information important in prehistory or history and is therefore not eligible for listing under Criterion 4. This historic-period transmission tower is therefore recommended not eligible under any of the four criteria for listing on the California Register, and as such is not recommended a historical resource under CEQA.

PWK2203-H-6. Criterion 1: Substantial research has not indicated a close association between this transmission tower and any important events. Although it is connected with electrical development and transmission in the Kern County area, a single tower does not demonstrate that connection in any significant way. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 1. Criterion 2: Substantial research has failed to connect the subject property with the lives of persons important in California’s past. It is therefore not eligible for the California Register under Criterion 2. Criterion 3: The transmission tower is a utilitarian structure. It lacks architectural distinction and does not display significant elements of the era during which it was constructed. Finally, the tower does not represent the work of an important creative individual or possess high artistic values. Therefore, the subject property is not eligible under Criterion 3. Criterion 4: The subject property has not and is not likely to yield information important in prehistory or history and is therefore not eligible for listing under Criterion 4. This historic-period transmission tower is therefore recommended not eligible under any of the four criteria for listing on the California Register, and as such is not recommended a historical resource under CEQA.

RECOMMENDATIONS
BCR Consulting conducted a cultural resources assessment of the Rosedale & Coffee Commercial Retail Center in the City of Bakersfield, Kern County, California. Four cultural resources (all historic-period) were identified within the project site, but none are recommended eligible for the California Register. Therefore, no significant impact related to historical resources is anticipated and no further investigations are recommended unless:
• The proposed project is changed to include areas that have not been subject to this cultural resource assessment;
• Cultural materials are encountered during project activities.

The current study attempted to determine whether significant archaeological deposits were present on the proposed project site. Although none were yielded during the records search and field survey, ground-disturbing activities have the potential to reveal buried deposits not observed on the surface. Prior to the initiation of ground-disturbing activities, field personnel should be alerted to the possibility of buried prehistoric or historic cultural deposits. In the event that field personnel encounter buried cultural materials, work in the immediate vicinity of the find should cease and a qualified archaeologist should be retained to assess the significance of the find. The qualified archaeologist shall have the authority to stop or divert construction excavation as necessary. If the qualified archaeologist finds that any cultural resources present meet eligibility requirements for listing on the California Register or the National Register, plans for the treatment, evaluation, and mitigation of impacts to the find will need to be developed. Prehistoric or historic cultural materials that may be encountered during ground-disturbing activities include:
• historic-period artifacts such as glass bottles and fragments, cans, nails, ceramic and pottery fragments, and other metal objects;
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 12 • historic-period structural or building foundations, walkways, cisterns, pipes, privies, and other structural elements;
• prehistoric flaked-stone artifacts and debitage (waste material), consisting of obsidian, basalt, and or cryptocrystalline silicates;
• groundstone artifacts, including mortars, pestles, and grinding slabs; • dark, greasy soil that may be associated with charcoal, ash, bone, shell, flaked stone, groundstone, and fire affected rocks;
• human remains.

Findings were negative during the initial and updated Sacred Lands File searches with the NAHC. The results of the Sacred Lands File search are provided in Appendix C. The Legislature added requirements regarding tribal cultural resources for CEQA in Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) that took effect July 1, 2015. AB52 requires consultation with California Native American tribes and consideration of tribal cultural resources in the CEQA process.

By including tribal cultural resources early in the CEQA process, the legislature intended to ensure that local and Tribal governments, public agencies, and project proponents would have information available, early in the project planning process, to identify and address potential adverse impacts to tribal cultural resources. By taking this proactive approach, the legislature also intended to reduce the potential for delay and conflicts in the environmental review process. To help determine whether a project may have such an effect, the Public Resources Code requires a lead agency to consult with any California Native American tribe that requests consultation and is traditionally and culturally affiliated with the geographic area of a Proposed Project. Since the City will initiate and carry out the required AB52 Native American Consultation, the results of the consultation are not provided in this report.

However, this report may be used during the consultation process, and BCR Consulting staff is available to answer questions and address concerns as necessary.

According to CEQA Guidelines, projects subject to CEQA must determine whether the project would “directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological resource”. The Paleontological Overview provided in Appendix E has recommended that:

The geologic units underlying the project area are mapped primarily as alluvial fan deposits from the Holocene epoch (Smith, 1964) Holocene alluvial units are considered to be of high preservation value, but material found is unlikely to be fossil material due to the relatively modern associated dates of the deposits.

However, if development requires any substantial depth of disturbance, the likelihood of reaching Pleistocene alluvial sediments would increase. The Western Science Center does not have localities within the project area or within a 1 mile radius; however, this is likely due in part to the project’s distance from WSC.

While the presence of any fossil material is unlikely, if excavation activity disturbs deeper sediment dating to the earliest parts of the Holocene or Late Pleistocene periods, the material would be scientifically significant. Excavation activity associated with the development of the project area is unlikely to be paleontologically sensitive, but caution during development should be observed.

If human remains are encountered during any project activities, State Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5 states that no further disturbance shall occur until the County Coroner F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 13 has made a determination of origin and disposition pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 5097.98. The County Coroner must be notified of the find immediately. If the remains are determined to be prehistoric, the Coroner will notify the NAHC, which will determine and notify a Most Likely Descendant (MLD). With the permission of the landowner or his/her authorized representative, the MLD may inspect the site of the discovery. The MLD shall complete the inspection within 48 hours of notification by the NAHC.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R 14 REFERENCES
Bailey, Richard C.
1984 Heart of the Golden Empire: An Illustrated History of Bakersfield. Windsor Publications, Inc., Woodland Hills, California.

Bean, Lowell John, and Charles Smith
1978 California, edited by R.F. Heizer. Handbook of North American Indians, Vol. 8, W.C.

Sturtevant, general editor, Smithsonian Institution. Washington, D.C.

Binford, L.
1980 Willow Smoke And Dog’s Tails: Hunter-Gatherer Settlement Systems and Archaeological Site Formation. American Antiquity 45:1-17.

Cogswell, Howard L.
1977 Water Birds of California. University of California Press, Berkeley.

Kroeber, Alfred L.
1925 Handbook of the Indians of California. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin No. 78.

Washington D.C.: Smithsonian Institution. Reprinted 1976, Dover Publications.

Moyle, Peter B.
1976 Inland Fishes of California. University of California Press, Berkeley.

Osborne, Richard H.
1992 An Ethnographic Overview of the Southern Valley Yokuts. Kern County Archaeological Society Journal 3:36-65.

Preston, William L.
1981 Vanishing Landscapes. University of California Press, Berkeley Thomas, D.H.
1983 The Archaeology of Monitor Valley I: Epistemology. New York: American Museum of Natural History Anthropological Papers 58:1.

Twisselmann, Ernest C.
1967 A Flora of Kern County, California. University of San Francisco Press.

United States Geological Survey
1968 Oildale, California 7.5-minute topographic quadrangle map.

Wallace, William J.
1978 The Southern Valley Yokuts, and The Northern Valley Yokuts. In Handbook of the North American Indians, Vol. 8, California, edited by W.L. d’Azevedo, pp. 448-470.

W.C. Sturtevant, General Editor. Smithsonian Institution, Washington D.C.

Williams, Patricia, Leah Messinger, Sarah Johnson
2008 Habitats Alive! An Ecological Guide to California's Diverse Habitats. California Institute for Biodiversity, Claremont, California.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R

APPENDIX A

CULTURAL RESOURCE LOCATIONS AND RECORD SEARCH BIBLIOGRAPHY K
1 / I Well I O • 4 /
I'
44 ///
/ I. II, * Ne n’ 397
___ JL.JL” 382 395
0 •21 /
O O
/ /
J Siphon C o o •
i
ll
1 . F==
o o
T! »
il I
o
22477 I
/il
I 37 11
all J J
IL 11!
ae
-01169
J
o 5
n -o.y r te sr
JI
JI v 28
jl • * ••• • 387
==============K=-i0625da?5
—
+ +
— --.9.4/ 8%
—
7KE-00866 222
O
r H
J1
ity 2224442

9. 31
• 1K 3
: U.

I
L
N
X 1
| I I I | I I I |
0 0.1 0.2 0.4 Kilometers
—
II
■ Il
•II
al
0 LL
II
. E=
J II IEh Kll
II l

0.15 J__ l_
Project Area Reports Map
SSJV Information Center Record Search 22-347
Requester: Joseph Orozco, BCR Consulting LLC
Project Name: Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road
Project (PWK2203)
USGS 7.5'Quad(s): Oildale
County: Kern
o
V
A
/!
al
II’
ll
W
II
II
II
II
• Il
ll
II
II
II
II
/3
all”
II I
11 1
HZ

0.3 Miles
J_J
j
ir
1V II
I)
1/11
Il M
l/ll
h
IXj
1 O.

May depict confidential cultural resource locations.

Do not distribute.

Project Area
| | Record Search radius
ll.+
i
H:
k
>r
*="
------------------------------
.8. s %
X %. % %

33. A %.
s.s. . *.*7
w. y.
—
* 7
i
II
ll
II
2 11
.0 ].0o
2 rr
l>
w
II
I! r
08o
ss.

A w
• 5 Vo's.

Sa
AND BSiphen

0.075
__ 1_
JI II CALEoR
7 o
II
J
1 *11 •
I 11
IP
<>
—Wi

CALLOW A Y
AL
382 1
Fire.

P-15-006435 co.BM382 379 X"*%
• P-15-006436
P-15-006438
s
TO
T
384
i —
3 l
/ Well o
Ii, II, "
II.' 11’
20 JL JL"
— 395
o •21
P-15-017237 0 O
// D Siphon /
o o o • ni y
। II . /== R.. )o as jy’e a
II o
il I
L P-15-008110 l: Ii JO 2!' \
P-15-017753 o
Hi
H. n
n X Fruitva e o
n ROSEDALE/'.'. 1 all . 39:

Ik ir siof 394 ".E
- Till’
P-15-003291 ; ie
’V ‘Il • .ii'
== £ ■ I
P-15-009109
II _ 00000 Egs CA S 87 o ❖ g. 35. O
28 A 387 AND°: Siphon he d
81 F
in : u, I Hi : II// JI!
1 29 I!
11: u □ 16 i
11 ROAD
384
I
Q
0 0
0 11
11 11
11 co
CM
e
L
o
o
TT
II
II
II
)I
II
II!
I
I
I
C
Q
IF
IE II
Il-li
l
I
I
- “
o
2 :0
5u
Y
1 2
3 i0
’•Il
11 11*
II A
X
- II
Il-li
II
>11
fl
ll
II
II
' ll
II
II
II ll’
ll
J
441 •
11 /
I/_
*I
II il
in
11:

Hi —
ill
ili
“‘Il
• Ik
0 BM
Hi
#
ill
/ 11
ll
Hr
X il
d ii
) H
. H A II
{ 2
11 11 Refinery
II
ti
ll
I
: il
D ||.0o
ii
II
* II
' 1
।
i
•
I
h
A
/!
//
u P-15-008111 —o---
Fi l
861783
-II
it
11 /A
e
V3
w
WA\
wso1.s.

Nos. No.

A. 1

1.3. N*7/
•
y‘
/ /
/ /
H 1
H I
I J i_____
, P-15-003290
II
ll
. . POWERPLANT P-15-012472 /1g
‘w
11 !! /
°0

28.8 o
$3
N
ii %
11 II
W
IOS.
3 $25 i 05.
— /------------ 1 11
II
— 11
P-15-000560..

J
BMnmr P °>
II
II
JL
Project Area
N Record Search radius 0.075
L

I I I I I I
0 0.1 0.2 0.4 Kilometers

0.15 I 1
Resources Map
SSJV Information Center Record Search 22-347
Requester: Joseph Orozco, BCR Consulting LLC
Project Name: Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road
Project (PWK2203)
USGS 7.5'Quad(s): Oildale
County: Kern

0.3 Miles
May depict confidential cultural resource locations.

Do not distribute.
0 L J__
I CALLOWAY ’ DR Gil
8 CALLOWAY
I :

Report List
Report No. Other IDs Year Author(s) Title Affiliation Resources SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
KE-00814 1990 Archaeological Assessment of the Riverlakes Ranch Specific Plan, City of Bakersfield, Kern
County, California
Cultural Resource Facility,
California State University,
Bakersfield
NADB-R - 1140483; Parr, Robert E. 15-009855
Submitter - CRF-90-
71 KE-00866 1992 Archaeological Survey Report for the
Proposed Route Adoption Study on Highway
58, Bakersfield, Kern County, California
Cultural Resource Facility,
California State University,
Bakersfield
Parr, Robert E. and
Osborne, Richard
15-002243, 15-002503, 15-002504,
15-002694, 15-002707, 15-002874,
15-003057, 15-003058, 15-003068,
15-003069, 15-003070, 15-003071,
15-003072, 15-003073, 15-003088,
15-003090, 15-003092, 15-003093,
15-003102, 15-003103, 15-003104,
15-003105, 15-003106, 15-003107,
15-003108, 15-003109, 15-003110,
15-003111, 15-003112, 15-003113,
15-003114, 15-003115, 15-003116,
15-003117, 15-003118, 15-003150,
15-003162, 15-003282, 15-003290,
15-003291
NADB-R - 1140517;
Submitter - CRF-91-
39 KE-00909 1997 A Phase I Cultural Resourse Survey for the Proposed Calloway Road Widening and
Grade Separation Project, Kern County
California
Hudlow Cultural Resource
Associates
Hudlow, Scott M. 15-006417, 15-006418, 15-006419,
15-006420, 15-006421, 15-006422,
15-006423, 15-006424, 15-006425,
15-006426, 15-006427, 15-006428,
15-006429, 15-006430, 15-006431,
15-006432, 15-006433, 15-006434,
15-006435, 15-006436, 15-006437,
15-006438, 15-006439, 15-006440
NADB-R - 1141422
KE-01062 1978 Archaeological Report for Proposed
Greenacre Park
Schiffman, Robert Bakersfield College

Page 1 of 3 ends

Report List
Report No. Other IDs Year Author(s) Title Affiliation Resources SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
KE-01169 1991 Ongoing Fieldwork for the Buena Vista
Slough Near Lokern
California State University,
Bakersfield
Unknown 15-002243, 15-002503, 15-002504,
15-002694, 15-002707, 15-002874,
15-003057, 15-003058, 15-003068,
15-003069, 15-003070, 15-003071,
15-003072, 15-003073, 15-003088,
15-003090, 15-003092, 15-003093,
15-003102, 15-003103, 15-003104,
15-003105, 15-003106, 15-003107,
15-003108, 15-003109, 15-003110,
15-003111, 15-003112, 15-003113,
15-003114, 15-003115, 15-003116,
15-003117, 15-003118, 15-003150,
15-003162, 15-003282, 15-003290,
15-003291, 15-009033, 15-009034,
15-009035, 15-009044, 15-009045,
15-009046, 15-009049, 15-009109,
15-009316, 15-009317, 15-009788,
15-009789, 15-009861, 15-009862
KE-02323 1999 Cultural Resources Inventory Report for the AT&T Corp. Cable Upgrade Project, Los
Angeles, Kern, and San Luis Obispo
Counties, California
Jones & Stokes Associates,
Inc.

Demos-Petropoulous,
Francine, McGowan,
Dana, Scott, Barry,
O'Brien, Teresa, Norton,
Bill, and Rause, Wendy
15-008766, 15-008767, 15-008768,
15-008769, 15-008772
KE-02396 2000 Cultural Resource Survey for the Level (3) Communications Long Haul Fiber Optics
Project: Segment WS04: Sacramento to
Bakersfield
Far Western
Anthropological Research
Group, Inc.

Submitter - Project Nelson, Wendy J. 15-003029
Number 27101
KE-02665 2000 Archaeological Investigations for the 2800 Calloway Drive Cell Tower Site
Nadolski, John A. Pacific Legacy, Inc.

KE-02738 2002 SpectraSite Communications Proposed
Wireless Telecommunications Service
Facilities in Southern CA
Billat, Scott Earth Touch
KE-02807 1993 Historic Resource Evaluation Report: Tier 1, Route Adoption on Route 58 Between I-5 and
State Route 99
JRP Historical Consulting
Services
Caltrans - 06-KER- Herbert, Rand F.
58-R35.4/R52.3;
Submitter - Contract
No. 06G171
KE-03025 2005 Historical Resources Compliance Report:

Burlington Northern Santa Fe Raiway Double
Track Project (Segment 1) Jastro (MP
892.13) to Shafter (MP 905.07) in and near
the Cities of Bakersfield and Shafter, Kern
County, California
Tang, Bai "Tom", Hogan, CRM TECH
Michael, and Smallwood,
Josh
Submitter - CRM
Tech Contract #1470

Page 2 of 3 ends

Report List
Report No. Other IDs Year Author(s) Title Affiliation Resources SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
KE-03168 2005 FCC Form 621 (Section 106) Submittal
Calloway / CA-3235A - 2800 Calloway Drive,
Cellular Antenna Installation on Existing
Monopole
Billat, Lorna EarthTouch, Inc.

KE-03199 2005 A Phase I Cultural Resource Survey for a
Residential Project for JBL Commercial
Group, Bakersfield, Kern Co., CA
Hudlow Cultural Resource
Associates (Bakersfield)
Hudlow, Scott 15-012472
KE-03778 2007 Cultural Resources and Paleontological
Survey for the West Village Project in
Bakersfield, Kern County, California
Lloyd, Jay B. Applied Earthworks, Inc. 15-012881
KE-04250 2011 State Route 58 Widening Project -
Archaeological Survey Report, Kern County,
California
Far Western
Anthropological Research
Group, Inc.

Ruby, Allika, Schiffman,
Robert, Whitehouse,
John, and Helton, Kirsten
Caltrans - 6-Kern-58
PM 46.1 to PM 51.5
EA 06-0F360
KE-04250A 2011 Historic Property Survey Report for the State Route 58 Widening Project, Kern County,
California
Webb, Toni Caltrans
KE-04311 2012 A Cultural Resources Assessment for the
Cross Valley Canal to Calloway Canal Intertie
Project, Kern County, California
Three Girls and a Shovel,
LLC.

Pruett, Catherine Lewis
and Gold, Alan
Submitter - TG&S
#101205
KE-04448 2013 Cultural Resources Assessment Alon
Bakersfield Refinery Crude Flexibility Project
Bakersfield, Kern County, California
Duke, Curt Duke CRM 15-003072, 15-017554, 15-017555,
15-017556, 15-017557, 15-017558,
15-017559
KE-04524 2007 Compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act for the Friant-Kern
Canal/Cross Valley Canal Intertie
Construction Project, Kern County, California
Submitter - Tracking Fry, Susan M. Bureau of Reclamation #07-SCAO-257
KE-04547 2012 National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) Section 106 Compliance for the Cawelo
Water District (CWD) Calloway Canal Lining
Project, Kern County, California
Leigh, Anastasia Bureau of Reclamation

Page 3 of 3 ends

Primary No. Trinomial
Resource List
Other IDs Type Age Attribute codes Recorded by Reports
SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
P-15-000560 CA-KER-000560H Resource Name - Atchison,
Topeka, & Santa Fe Railroad;
Resource Name - AT&SF
Railroad; EAFB - 1;
OHP Property Number - 110736;
OTIS Resource Number - 503612
KE-00101, KE-00182, KE-00191,
KE-00209, KE-00243, KE-00283,
KE-00374, KE-00548, KE-00633,
KE-01184, KE-01993, KE-04476
Structure,
Site
Historic AH04; AH07; HP11 1977 (Sutton/Temblay);
1980 (Unknown, Greenwood and
Associates);
1988 (Patrick Haynal, Frnak Ritz,
Diane Adams, William Manley,
RECON);
1993 (Macko Archaeological
Consulting, Macko Archaeological
Consulting);
1994 (T. Wahoff, P. Eisentraut,
Dames & Moore);
1994 (Lawrence McGetrick and
Cristopher Onzol);
1995 (William Hayden, Neil Rhodes,
and Gina Zanelli, Macko
Archaeogical Consulting);
1995 (K. Lark, T. de la Garza, L.

Wear, R. Bock, M. Pittman, L.

Ramirez, M. Ryan, B. Woods, M
Hangan, A Ja, Computer Sciences
Corporation);
1996 (Marcia Kimball, Sarah
Cunkelman, BLM);
1998 (T. O'Brien, Jones and
Stokes);
1998 (T. O'Brien, Jones and
Stokes);
2000 (Dr. J. Underwood, KEA
Environmental);
2001 (Jeffrey R. Wedding, Harry
Reid Center for Environmental
Studies);
2007 (H. Puckett, Tetra Tech);
2009 (Polly Allen, JRP Historical
Consulting, LLC);
2013 (R. Kellawan, D. Martinez, L.

Daub, D. Mike, Far Western)
P-15-003290 CA-KER-003290H Resource Name - AH 1 Site Historic AH04 1991 (Peggy Murphy, Shannon KE-00866, KE-01169 Harris, Wendy Stevens, Cultural
Resource Facility, California State
University, Bakersfield)
P-15-003291 CA-KER-003291H Resource Name - AH 2 Site Historic AH04 1991 (Peggy Murphy, Shannon KE-00866, KE-01169 Harris, Wendy Stevens, Cultural
Resource Facility, California State
University, Bakersfield)

Page 1 of 3 ends

Primary No. Trinomial
Resource List
Other IDs Type Age Attribute codes Recorded by Reports
SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
P-15-006435 Resource Name - Building 19 Site Historic HP02 1997 (Scott M. Hudlow, Hudlow KE-00909 Cultural Resource Associates)
P-15-006436 Resource Name - Building 20 Building Historic HP02 1997 (Scott M. Hudlow, Hudlow KE-00909 Cultural Resource Associates)
P-15-006438 Resource Name - Building 22 Building Historic HP02 1997 (Scott M. Hudlow, Hudlow KE-00909 Cultural Resource Associates)
P-15-007233 Resource Name - Calloway
Canal;
Resource Name - JKE-022;
OTIS Resource Number -
503607;
OHP Property Number - 110729
Structure Historic HP20 1996 (Clarence Caesar); KE-05044 2009 (Steven J. Melvin, Rebecca
Flores, JRP Historical Consulting,
LLC.);
2009 (Polly S. Allen, Toni Webb,
JRP Historical Consulting, LLC.);
2016 (Jennifer Gorman, ASM
Affiliates, Inc.)
P-15-008110 OHP Property Number - 110537;
OTIS Resource Number - 503449
Building Historic HP06 1997
P-15-008111 OHP Property Number - 110538;
OTIS Resource Number - 503450
Building Historic HP02 1997
P-15-009109 IC Informal - IF-KER-765H Other Historic AH04 1991 (Peggy Murphy, Shannon KE-01169 Harris, Wendy Stevens, Cultural
Resource Facility, California State
University, Bakersfield)
P-15-012472 Resource Name - JBL-1;
Resource Name - Fruitvale Oil
Field
Structure Historic HP11 2005 (Scott M. Hudlow, Hudlow KE-03199 Cultural Resource Associates)
P-15-013728 CA-KER-007704H Resource Name - JKE-023;
Resource Name - Friant-Kern
Canal;
OHP Property Number - 163703;
National Register - BUR060525A;
OTIS Resource Number - 534628
Structure Historic HP20 1995 (Carrie Wills, Allen Estes, KE-05044 William Self Associates);
2009 (Steven J. Melvin, Rebecca
Flores, JRP Historical Consulting,
LLC.);
2016 (Jennifer Gorman, ASM
Affiliates, Inc.)

Page 2 of 3 ends

Primary No. Trinomial
Resource List
Other IDs Type Age Attribute codes Recorded by Reports
SSJVIC Record Search 22-347
P-15-017237 CA-KER-009435H Resource Name - Beardsley One Ditch;
Resource Name - SS #1;
OTIS Resource Number - 680464
KE-04511, KE-05153, KE-05235Site Historic AH06; HP11; HP20 2009 (Daniel Paul, ICF Jones & Stokes);
2013 (James J. Schmidt, June A.

Schmidt, Compass Rose
Archaeological, Inc.);
2013 (Michael H. Dice, A. Said-Abdelwahed, FirstCarbon Solutions); 2018 (R. Azpitarte, S. Escamilla, S.

Teteak, ASM Affiliates, Inc.);
2020 (Scott M. Hudlow, Hudlow
Cultural Resource Associates)
P-15-017753 Resource Name - 9031 Rosedale
Highway
Building Historic HP02; HP04 2008 (Polly Allen, JRP Historical Consulting, LLC.)

Page 3 of 3 ends

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R

APPENDIX B
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATIONS 523 FORMS
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI #
PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial
NRHP Status Code
Other Listings
Review Code Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 4 ends

P1. Other Identifier: N/A
*P2. Location:  Not for Publication  Unrestricted *a. County: Kern and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad: Oildale, California Date: 1968 T 29S; R 27E; Section 29; MDBM c. Address: N/A City: Kern Zip: 93308
d. UTM: Zone: Elevation: 370’ – 380’ AMSL
e. Other Locational Data: From California State Route 99, exit Rosedale Highway/CA-58 and proceed west for 2.75 miles. Turn south on Coffee Road for .25 miles and turn west onto the paved dirt road. *P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements: design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, boundaries) This resource is a historic-period, 14-acre oil pumping site (site) located within the grounds of the former Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. The site contains four oil pumping units, two 20’ diameter oil and water storage tanks, and three wooden electrical distribution poles. The southeasternmost pump and two storage tanks were installed between 1952 and 1958, and the other three pumps were installed between 1968 and 1984 (United States Department of Agriculture 1952, 1958, 1968, 1984). Among the oil pumps are two Lufkin Conventional Pumping Units, one National Company oil pump, and one Bethlehem oil pump. At least one pump currently feeds into the oil and water storage tanks, and it is assumed the remaining three pumps are also associated with these tanks. The wooden electrical distribution poles supply power to electric drive motors on each of the oil pumping units. According to General Land Office Records, the subject property was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876 (General Land Office 1876). By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by PG&E and contained a PG&E power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s (bakersfield.com 2022). The oil pump site is located on the northern portion of the subject property and overlapped areas utilized by the PG&E plant (United States Department of Agriculture 1952, 1968). By the mid-1980s through early 2000s, a Christmas tree farm was present within the boundaries of the oil pump site while it was in operation (Bakersfield.com 2022). The oil pump site continues to operate and draws oil from the Fruitvale oil reserve and is operated by DD Naturals Resources, LLC (California Department of Conservation 2022).
*P3b. Resource Attributes: AH10. Machinery AH15. Standing Structures P5b. Description of Photo: (View, date, accession #) Pump Site Overview, East, October 19, 2022
*P6. Date Built; Age and Source:
Historic Prehistoric Both
*P7. Owner and Address:

N/A
*P8. Recorded by:

J.Orozco, T. Blood, S. Randell, D. Kazmier
BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, CA 91711
P9. Date: 10/19/2022
*P10. Survey Type: Intensive
*P11. Report Citation: Cultural Resources Assessment of the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project, San Bernardino, California
*Attachments: NONE  Location Map Sketch Map 
Continuation Sheet Building, Structure, and Object Record Archaeological Record District Record Linear Feature Record Milling Station Record Rock Art Record
Artifact Record Photograph Record  Other (List):

DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information
P5a. Photo or Drawing (Photo required for buildings,
structures, and objects.)
€ 90°E (T) • 35.38256, -119.095741 ±4 m • 83 m
' A3 <•
W.
v
dhr g?
- -4 E IA
s
»
wt 11 ©
0)
NE SE
I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
a ARi
. PWK2203 H-1 0
Randell 42:03
(
s t
35 —
—gteSOU 112
5 I
60 ।
120
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION Trinomial

ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE RECORD

Page 2 of 4 ends

*A1. Dimensions: Approximately 14 Acres
Method of Measurement:  Paced  Taped  Visual estimate  Other: Satellite imagery Method of Determination (Check any that apply.):  Artifacts  Features  Soil  Vegetation  Topography  Cut bank  Animal burrow  Excavation  Property boundary  Other (Explain):

Reliability of Determination:  High  Medium  Low Explain:

Limitations (Check any that apply):  Restricted access  Paved/built over  Site limits incompletely defined  Disturbances  Vegetation  Other (Explain):

A2. Depth:  None  Unknown Method of Determination: Surface Survey *A3. Human Remains:  Present  Absent  Possible  Unknown (Explain):
*A4. Features (Number, briefly describe, indicate size, list associated cultural constituents, and show location of each feature on sketch map.): This site consists of a historic-period, 14-acre oil pumping site located within the grounds of the former Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. The site contains four oil pumping units, two 20’ diameter oil and water storage tanks, and three wooden electrical distribution poles. Among the oil pumps are two Lufkin Conventional Pumping Units, one National Company oil pump, and one Bethlehem oil pump. At least one pump currently feeds into the oil and water storage tanks, and it is assumed the remaining three pumps are associated with these tanks. Three historic-period, wooden poles are within the site, and each are associated with electrical distribution alignments which supply power to electric drive motors on each of the oil pumping units. *A5. Cultural Constituents (Describe and quantify artifacts, ecofacts, cultural residues, etc., not associated with features.): None. *A6. Were Specimens Collected?  No  Yes
*A7. Site Condition:  Good  Fair  Poor (Describe disturbances.):
*A8. Nearest Water (Type, distance, and direction.): The Friant-Kern Canal is located 515’ east of the site. *A9. Elevation: 370’-380’ Feet AMSL
A10. Environmental Setting (Describe culturally relevant variables such as vegetation, fauna, soils, geology, landform, slope, aspect, exposure, etc.): Vegetation in the area includes sparse dried seasonal grasses. Sediment was dry, light yellowish-brown, silty sand in portions of the project. Visibility was between 80 and 100 percent throughout the site. Disturbances include past ground disturbances related to the former PG&E Kern Power Plant have resulted in extremely compacted ground cover in select areas.

A11. Historical Information: According to General Land Office Records, the subject property was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876 (General Land Office 1876). By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by PG&E and contained a PG&E power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s (Bakersfield.com 2022). The oil pump site is located on the northern portion of the subject property and overlapped portions utilized by the PG&E plant (United States Department of Agriculture 1952, 1968). The southeasternmost pump and two storage tanks were installed between 1952 and 1958, and the other three pumps were installed between 1968 and 1984 (United States Department of Agriculture 1952, 1958, 1968, 1984). By the mid-1980s through early 2000s, a Christmas tree farm was present within the boundaries of the oil pump site while it was in operation (Bakersfield.com 2022). The oil pump site continues to operate and draws oil from the Fruitvale oil reserve and is operated by DD Naturals Resources, LLC (California Department of Conservation 2022). *A12. Age:  Prehistoric  Protohistoric  1542-1769  1769-1848  1848-1880  1880-1914  1914-1945 Post 1945  Undetermined

Describe position in regional prehistoric chronology or factual historic dates if known: See A11.

A13. Interpretations (Discuss data potential, function[s], ethnic affiliation, and other interpretations: The site appears to be one related operation. All four pumps are drawing or have drawn oil from the Fruitvale oil reserve. This material, once extracted, is stored in the 20’ diameter tanks on the site.

A14. Remarks: Because all features on the site appear to be interrelated they were recorded as one site.

A15. References (Documents, informants, maps, and other references):

California Department of Conservation. 2022. Electronic Document: https://www.conservation.ca.gov/calgem. Accessed Multiple Dates
Bakersfield.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://www.bakersfield.com/archives. Accessed Multiple Dates General Land Office 1876. BLM Records of the GLO. Electronic Document: glorecords.blm.gov. Accessed Multiple Dates The United States Department of Agriculture. 1952, 1958, 1968, 1984. Aerial Photograph of San Bernardino County. Electronic document, https://historicaerials.com/viewer, accessed Multiple dates.

A16. Photographs (List subjects, direction of view, and accession numbers): See page 1.

Original Media/Negatives Kept at: BCR Consulting. Claremont, California. *A17. Form Prepared by: Joseph Orozco, M.A., RPA Date: 10/04/22 Affiliation and Address: BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, CA, 91711
DPR 523C (1/95) *Required information
State of California-The Resources Agency
DEPARTI\ENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION

SKETCH MAP

Page 3 of 4 ends

--Drawn Bv: Joseph Orozco
Prlma,y#
HRI#
Trinomial
Resourc.e Name or #{Assigned by Reca<ler) PWK2203-H-1
•Date: 12/4/22
r
---------
1 1 I ill

I I I I
\l!l <------------------------0
------------;
------------------J i
I l!l I l
'--------------------------------------------------------1 I I I
Legend
[_-=:_J PWK2203-H-1 Boundary
(!] Oil Pump Unit
- Oil and Water Storage Tanks
I Utility Pole
DPR 523K (1195}
I I l0_ __________ _l
35 70 140
Meters
175 350 700
Feet
--Required Information
0 0
State of California - The Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION

LOCATION MAP

Page 4 of 4 ends

•Map Name: Oildale, California
,\.(...._.,,ow� . --�--=..�•-­
N o 0.25 0.5
•••c::=:::i••••- Kilometers Ao 0.5
Primary#:

HRI#:

Trinomial:
•Resource Name or #:PWK2203-H-1
•scale: 1:24,000 •oate of Map:1968
16 __ .._ __________ _ ------
I
' ..
! ---W. ... .-: ..
• •
& • ..
• • •
•
•
.. "--..� 0
·-
• • . 0 ·----
,a.·--: ..
• i!.J-----
...
•••
I
•Required Information
wl
17 390
ut “Co
Water Tank
• • •
ROAD ====% s □37 Hr 398 * T
-"5 VX- s \ •
msteosomani
Well Well
%
w 1 Well r
O •»
a
' r
- 20 4. o I r
"$ 9
“ha■ % •21 390
i O O
Siphon
385 ===-
•—he
o
I PWK2203-H-1 2 U
-===;i 4 1 ©
R
26 reenacres 1
o .■ I
: Fruitva e o
• * 393. •"
BM 382 /tOSEOALE !! ■ 81 O©
B) is 67985 : n
.1 . .. 380
W o ©
%
O 9° o
94 380
" 394
r
TOPEKA BM 17 ANO' ohon SANTA FE i Reine?un222., &t
! I:- CLitha 59" Loi {------------------- X==v=
il‘%. C
29 efinery
o $
---
-- ?m1m=t=! 8 M •• a 0. © t ° 27I •.1—E--------------- --- O it
POAO —s X Res
376 384
• I 3
1 I
o
1 Miles --
6 . pyright 20 M577 47
o
o
Fire
• Sta
D
D
z
/
i «
1 I
I
I
I
I
a
o
o ••
Os.
oYs ‘o
I
■>
o_ o
—5
o
.1
<1
3 •
V . -
I
I
o
I
K
1 0
I
I
>
V
I
a
---
Fo
“*Y
%
1 I
29?
1 ::
" It
II
I
-i
w:. t
$
|
3 a

18. .. Way1 •
I
It
II
• a
""i TN,, 000008
’ f t
•- • 379 •
...FO : "
.0 J.00
353.
>
I
~ S .cI i
CALLO^
V. «
%
28 ghn »o
.52“wP
Trailer n u
Park SC
33--
s
s
tional Geographic Scciety. i-cube
_______________—i______ ____
EEyAL 0 ?
9 sRReservoir
“ r-
/
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#
CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial

Page 1 of 1 ends

*Recorded by: T. Blood, E. Guiterrez *Date: January 27, 2025  Continuation  Update DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information
This resource was originally recorded in October of 2022 by the BCR Consulting LLC as a historic-period, 14-acre oil pump site containing four oil pumping units, two 20’ diameter oil and water storage tanks, and three wooden electrical distribution poles. BCR Consulting archaeologists revisited the site in January of 2025 and found all four oil pumping units and the oil and water storage tanks to have been removed and destroyed, leaving the three wooden electrical distribution poles as previously recorded.

Overview of The Remains of Western-most Oil Pump Overview of The Remains of Central Two Oil Pumps

Overview of The Remains of Western-most Oil Pump Overview of The Remains of Central Two Oil Pumps

Overview of The Eastern-most Utility Pole Overview of The Western-most Utility Pole PWK2203-HarUtilfyLin
-E. Gutierrez-PWK2203
-016 Jan 2025, 10:35:07
© 262°W (T) • 11 N 309432 3917537 ±9ft A 387ft
I
sw NW
210 240 300 330
S
180
W
270
© 265°W (T) ® 11 N 309364 3917515 +9ft A 397ft © 280°W (T) • 11 N 309661 3917477 ±6ft A 398ft 20 if . 1 T — f
E.

Gt
m “TP
. -
e
. is irt —
. -r-p-ed
t • ■
"—Tws, n‘ to
utulscelf wecellad ' Cees
— e H -.is "I
©281°W(T) • 11 N 309878 3917415 +13ft A 396ft
I
E
i
L--
-== --=-=== -ze
■ -= --- rfarto
■
1 vhlekesedz
uve ""
© 32°NE (T) • 11 N 309926 3917526 ±9ft A 398ft
C
taw 9
anssii
sw
1 W
270
NW N sw T NW 210 240 300 330 210 240 300 330
I I
sw T swNW T NW
210 240 300 330 210 240 300 330
I I I
5 -sam
PWK22
16 Jan 2025, 10:41:40 1
NW NE
300 330 80 120
W
270
W
270
W
270
E
90 S
180
N
0 N
0 N
0 N
0 -sU"seer
• 2
e seen , - — • • ■ ( we
O 28Q°W (T) • 11 N 309661 3917477 ±6ft A 398ft
■"M
e -==r-, A ■
—:" ■ ( we
1 -*A/t*i has
- < t.moe
nas
td
-sU"teer
AUTEs “I
r
1 a
's
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI #
PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial
NRHP Status Code
Other Listings
Review Code Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 2 ends

P1. Other Identifier: N/A
*P2. Location:  Not for Publication  Unrestricted *a. County: Kern and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad: Oildale, California Date: 1968 T 29S; R 27E; Section 29; MDBM c. Address: N/A City: Kern Zip: 93308
d. UTM: Zone: Elevation: 370’ – 380’ AMSL
e. Other Locational Data: From California State Route 99, exit Rosedale Highway/CA-58 and proceed west for 2.75 miles. Turn south on Coffee Road for .25 miles and turn west onto the paved dirt road. *P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements: design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, boundaries) This resource is a historic-period, 230 KV double circuit lattice steel transmission tower within the Midway-Kern 230 KV alignment.

According to General Land Office Records, the transmission tower is located on what was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876 (General Land Office 1876). By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) and contained a steam power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s (Bakersfield.com 2022). Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Midway-Kern 230 KV alignment from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower (Bakersfieldnow.com 2022, United States Department of Agriculture 1958).

References:

Bakersfield.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://www.bakersfield.com/archives. Accessed Multiple Dates Bakersfieldnow.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://bakersfieldnow.com/news. Accessed Multiple Dates General Land Office 1876. BLM Records of the GLO. Electronic Document: glorecords.blm.gov. Accessed Multiple Dates The United States Department of Agriculture. 1958 aerial photograph of Kern County. Electronic document, https://historicaerials.com/view, accessed multiple dates *P3b. Resource Attributes: AH15. Standing Structures
P5b. Description of Photo: (View, date, accession #) West, October 19, 2022
*P6. Date Built; Age and Source:
Historic Prehistoric Both
*P7. Owner and Address:

N/A
*P8. Recorded by:

J.Orozco, T. Blood, S. Randell, D. Kazmier
BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, CA 91711
P9. Date: 10/19/2022
*P10. Survey Type: Intensive
*P11. Report Citation: Cultural Resources Assessment of the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project, San Bernardino, California
*Attachments: NONE  Location Map Sketch Map 
Continuation Sheet Building, Structure, and Object Record Archaeological Record District Record Linear Feature Record Milling Station Record Rock Art Record
Artifact Record Photograph Record  Other (List):

DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information
P5a. Photo or Drawing (Photo required for buildings,
structures, and objects.)
O 259°W (T) • 35.38325,-119.097556 ±6 m A 81 m
a
r
7 /AW
I 7
—f d
D)
(
sw NW 210 240 300
2022,
W270
.11:0
2 gone
Water Tank -O •
Well Well
%e i )
8 !
■3
379 BM 382
—
" 384
...S
380
7 8
5T ...
1 o"
17 16
I
* 8
t
8 ,1 1
==========% "P
T •
a
“T o
. 20 .0o
21 ./ Siphon
f
•I r F VAL
0 PWK2203-H-4 Fruitvale alls 19 1
...

Bl *Y°
p.

I; “s
/
s
29 -9°
28 i. BM -i SANTA awe ---------
ND h
$1 -======o!
2=iln. t: 1
yoo
%
29 3
ootti: .
&C
====== a
384
• !*
2013 National ic iety. i
!
I
I
/ *—
I!
■
I
■
I
X
IwsO
B
33---"
Wel.
-1o7
to
": ■ iH-
—t
ht
, -i
... ".A
i i Cailo"”
s
■
s
is

1.0 “o 1
l
19 0.5

0.5 ____2026____ ________ _
1 • Kilometers
1 = Miles
a=====i
0 “41LowAY
=======
18 p====an=rm
Greenacres
. "ih sse-
-
‘s .

C
‘130
—
*s
X
0 0.25
0 r
30 •
.A/ce
N
A

Page 2 of 2 ends

*Map Name: Oildale, California *Scale: 1:24,000*Date of Map:1968 Primary #:

HRI #:

Trinomial:

State of California - The Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
LOCATION MAP CALLOWAY =======*===
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#
CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial

Page 1 of 1 ends

*Recorded by: T. Blood, E. Guiterrez *Date: January 27, 2025  Continuation  Update DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information
This resource was originally recorded in October of 2022 by the BCR Consulting LLC as a historic-period, 230 KV double circuit lattive steel transmission tower within the Midway-Kern 230 KV alignment. BCR Consulting archaeologists revisited the site in January of 2025 and found it was previously recorded.

State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI #
PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial
NRHP Status Code
Other Listings
Review Code Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 2 ends

P1. Other Identifier: N/A
*P2. Location:  Not for Publication  Unrestricted *a. County: Kern and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad: Oildale, California Date: 1968 T 29S; R 27E; Section 29; MDBM c. Address: N/A City: Kern Zip: 93308
d. UTM: Zone: Elevation: 370’ – 380’ AMSL
e. Other Locational Data: From California State Route 99, exit Rosedale Highway/CA-58 and proceed west for 2.75 miles. Turn south on Coffee Road for .25 miles and turn west onto the paved dirt road. *P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements: design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, boundaries) This resource is a historic-period, double circuit lattice steel transmission tower within the Kern Lerdo/Kern Oil 115 KV alignment.

According to General Land Office Records, the transmission tower is located on what was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876 (General Land Office 1876). By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) and contained a steam power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s (Bakersfield.com 2022). Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Kern Lerdo/Kern Oil 115 KV alignment from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower (Bakersfieldnow.com 2022, United States Department of Agriculture 1958).

References:

Bakersfield.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://www.bakersfield.com/archives. Accessed Multiple Dates Bakersfieldnow.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://bakersfieldnow.com/news. Accessed Multiple Dates General Land Office 1876. BLM Records of the GLO. Electronic Document: glorecords.blm.gov. Accessed Multiple Dates The United States Department of Agriculture. 1958 aerial photograph of Kern County. Electronic document, https://historicaerials.com/view, accessed multiple dates *P3b. Resource Attributes: AH15. Standing Structures
P5b. Description of Photo: (View, date, accession #) West, October 19, 2022
*P6. Date Built; Age and Source:
Historic Prehistoric Both
*P7. Owner and Address:

N/A
*P8. Recorded by:

J.Orozco, T. Blood, S. Randell, D. Kazmier
BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, CA 91711
P9. Date: 10/19/2022
*P10. Survey Type: Intensive
*P11. Report Citation: Cultural Resources Assessment of the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project, San Bernardino, California
*Attachments: NONE  Location Map Sketch Map 
Continuation Sheet Building, Structure, and Object Record Archaeological Record District Record Linear Feature Record Milling Station Record Rock Art Record
Artifact Record Photograph Record  Other (List):

DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information
P5a. Photo or Drawing (Photo required for buildings,
structures, and objects.)
o 258° (T) 35.383067,-119.097226 ±5 m * 78 m
f
s
I
— 1
ee
W &
fom
D) A
40) D) (O) (09
SW N’
210 240 300
W270
W203 B
19 0820
11:82
1 1
ri
y. A

0. X
-P-Ai.
:2
"====
V
O •i
**y
21 wt
I LOWAy
Siphon
1 ■ F
RWK2203-H:5.-Fruitv
IL Ron 1 s87P ===A==
Well Well
, Water Tank " e5 .

X
28 °/

AND SANTA FF
I
(; .. i
6)o ooii: ,
/
!
!Tiz
Ci
BM
“s
Ssw=”
17 t
1 1BC. %>
20 390
ii *
75*16201 8 2013 National
1 • Miles
Res1O-F
ic Society. F
I -f
l c
i: .Greenacres
rrahter Park
• Fire
...S8M 382
• - 2. . : t ee " e
N 0 0.25 0.5 1
Kilometers A0 0.5
2 09 Lill IB LIL _ 1MT1 _
2 s

Page 2 of 2 ends

Primary #:

HRI #:

Trinomial:

State of California - The Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
LOCATION MAP •....... ===

CALLOWAY

CANAL KERN
#00 (O ““=============£
$
8 • %
M . sr ds • CALLOWA **
• is
C
$ ‘O
N
O.
‘d
1 l p
A
%
AkLOMo
- f I
0'-
■
I■
/
o o
! - 1.5 7 d it
State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#
CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial

Page 1 of 1 ends

*Recorded by: T. Blood, E. Guiterrez *Date: January 27, 2025  Continuation  Update DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information
This resource was originally recorded in October of 2022 by the BCR Consulting LLC as a historic-period, double lattice steel transmission tower within th Kern Lerdo/Kern Oil 115 KV alignment. BCR Consulting archaeologists revisited the site in January of 2025 and found the site as previously recorded.

State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI #
PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial
NRHP Status Code
Other Listings
Review Code Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 2 ends

P1. Other Identifier: N/A
*P2. Location:  Not for Publication  Unrestricted *a. County: Kern and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad: Oildale, California Date: 1968 T 29S; R 27E; Section 29; MDBM c. Address: N/A City: Kern Zip: 93308
d. UTM: Zone: Elevation: 370’ – 380’ AMSL
e. Other Locational Data: From California State Route 99, exit Rosedale Highway/CA-58 and proceed west for 2.75 miles. Turn south on Coffee Road for .25 miles and turn west onto the paved dirt road. *P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements: design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, boundaries) This resource is a historic-period, double circuit lattice steel transmission tower shared by the Kern Oil Famoso 70 KV and Kern Live Oak 115 KV alignment. According to General Land Office Records, the transmission tower is located on what was once part of a land patent granted to the Southern Pacific Railroad on April 6, 1876 (General Land Office 1876). By the 1940s, the subject property was owned by Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) and contained a steam power plant which was in operation until the mid-1980s (Bakersfield.com 2022). Historic aerials indicate the transmission tower was established by 1958 and continues to operate and distribute electricity along the Kern Oil Famoso 70 KV and Kern Live Oak 115 KV alignments from the PG&E Kern substation adjacent to the tower (Bakersfieldnow.com 2022, United States Department of Agriculture 1958).

References:

Bakersfield.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://www.bakersfield.com/archives. Accessed Multiple Dates Bakersfieldnow.com. 2022. Electronic Document: https://bakersfieldnow.com/news. Accessed Multiple Dates General Land Office 1876. BLM Records of the GLO. Electronic Document: glorecords.blm.gov. Accessed Multiple Dates The United States Department of Agriculture. 1958 aerial photograph of Kern County. Electronic document, https://historicaerials.com/view, accessed multiple dates *P3b. Resource Attributes: AH15. Standing Structures
P5b. Description of Photo: (View, date, accession #) West, October 19, 2022
*P6. Date Built; Age and Source:
Historic Prehistoric Both
*P7. Owner and Address:

N/A
*P8. Recorded by:

J.Orozco, T. Blood, S. Randell, D. Kazmier
BCR Consulting LLC
Claremont, CA 91711
P9. Date: 10/19/2022
*P10. Survey Type: Intensive
*P11. Report Citation: Cultural Resources Assessment of the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project, San Bernardino, California
*Attachments: NONE  Location Map Sketch Map 
Continuation Sheet Building, Structure, and Object Record Archaeological Record District Record Linear Feature Record Milling Station Record Rock Art Record
Artifact Record Photograph Record  Other (List):

DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information
P5a. Photo or Drawing (Photo required for buildings,
structures, and objects.)
1 wros
0)

19.0 (0)
0).

NE SE
30 60 120
1 tpes
PWK2203
E
90 ..

O 84OE (T) • 35.383094, -119.097439 ±4 m A 83 m I "
Map Name: Oildale, Calffomnia
w
18 ===ar
(LOWAY
- 17 - 16
luns e
f- &
plC
8 1
ir ROAD -I
/
0 Well /
9 Wel. o O O
A< 53
O *
r
9 . "
O
© —th
CLEyAL E-s
n
52 .======
: .Greenacres
-*- • 379
,_____
r F Fyh.
0 /tost i
°
. *i - I ! ■
Trailer “9
< ii .M-V, -5s.
sPUr*=//. • *“...... . calco"") -
“o-r” 9/ 380 Cion 28 :. 384 BM 7 AND S. h
2211. ========
C3] l
8 I 30
29 5 >, SC K
8-
o
Ys
“MAAes: 3
20 37s 3
384 11 Is.7
wo
4 N 0 0.25 0.5
A 0
0 0.5
tE 2013 National
_____ —! DPR 523J (1/95)
.0:0o 2821
387
Well

29. PEKAN
=====
Fire
StBM 382
1 I
0 I
•
>
Cecg rs ph i c Sod etICuced
*Required Information
hl
00 $06
tT
it
is 3
1 • Miles
• • ::: •/00
f
M
isis
Ca,
Y
— ____ ______ _____ t a
Siphon
%
EWK2203-F6Fruitvale
33--
1 ...
................./
m-1
• Kilometers
. Water Tank
----------------
Tin"g:

C je
2 nu %
ts
**Y
«• |
—
. ..,0
---- - ---- L--ss
"Scale:1.24,000 Date of Map:1966

Page 2 of 2 ends

Primary #:

HRI #:

Trinomial:

State of California - The Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION

LOCATION MAP
etny, CaOerrg)
8 State of California ⎯ The Resources Agency Primary #
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#
CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial

Page 1 of 1 ends

*Recorded by: T. Blood, E. Guiterrez *Date: January 27, 2025  Continuation  Update DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information
This resource was originally recorded in October of 2022 by the BCR Consulting LLC as a historic-period, double circuit lattice steel transmission tower shared by the Kern Oil Famoso 70 KV and Kern Live Oak 115 KV alignment. BCR Consulting archaeologists revisited the site in January of 2025 and found the resource as previously recorded.

State of California  The Resources Agency Primary # P-15-003290 DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#
CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial CA-KER-3290H

Page 1 of 1 ends

*Recorded by: J. Orozco, T. Blood, S. Randell, D. Kazmier *Date: October 19, 2022  Continuation  Update DPR 523L (1/95) *Required information
This resource was originally recorded in November of 1991 by the Cultural Resource Facility at California State University, Bakersfield as a historic-period, domestic refuse scatter. BCR Consulting archaeologists were unsuccessful in relocating the domestic refuse scatter. This is most likey due to disturbances from the removal and installation of new electrical transmission towers within the boundaries of P-15-003290.

F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R

APPENDIX C

NATIVE AMERICAN HERITAGE COMISSION SACRED LANDS FILE SEARCH STATE OF CALIFORNIA Gavin Newsom, Governor

NATIVE AMERICAN HERITAGE COMMISSION

Page 1 of 1 ends

October 28, 2022
Joseph Orozco
BCR Consulting LLC
Via Email to: [email protected]
Re: Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project (PWK2203), Kern County Dear Mr. Orozco:

A record search of the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC) Sacred Lands File (SLF) was completed for the information you have submitted for the above referenced project. The results were negative. However, the absence of specific site information in the SLF does not indicate the absence of cultural resources in any project area. Other sources of cultural resources should also be contacted for information regarding known and recorded sites.

Attached is a list of Native American tribes who may also have knowledge of cultural resources in the project area. This list should provide a starting place in locating areas of potential adverse impact within the proposed project area. I suggest you contact all of those indicated; if they cannot supply information, they might recommend others with specific knowledge. By contacting all those listed, your organization will be better able to respond to claims of failure to consult with the appropriate tribe. If a response has not been received within two weeks of notification, the Commission requests that you follow-up with a telephone call or email to ensure that the project information has been received.

If you receive notification of change of addresses and phone numbers from tribes, please notify me. With your assistance, we can assure that our lists contain current information.

If you have any questions or need additional information, please contact me at my email address: [email protected].

Sincerely,
Cameron Vela
Cultural Resources Analyst
Attachment

CHAIRPERSON
Laura Miranda
Luiseño

VICE CHAIRPERSON
Reginald Pagaling
Chumash

SECRETARY
Sara Dutschke
Miwok

COMMISSIONER
Isaac Bojorquez
Ohlone-Costanoan

COMMISSIONER
Buffy McQuillen
Yokayo Pomo, Yuki,
Nomlaki

COMMISSIONER
Wayne Nelson
Luiseño

COMMISSIONER
Stanley Rodriguez
Kumeyaay

COMMISSIONER
[Vacant]

COMMISSIONER
[Vacant]

EXECUTIVE SECRETARY
Raymond C.

Hitchcock
Miwok/Nisenan

NAHC HEADQUARTERS
1550 Harbor Boulevard
Suite 100
West Sacramento,
California 95691
(916) 373-3710
[email protected]
NAHC.ca.gov
ERICA/
CDL‘ SI Z
4 Z lela
/O
'I "
Big Pine Paiute Tribe of Owens
Valley
Sally Manning, Environmental
Director
P. O. Box 700
Big Pine, CA, 93513
Phone: (760) 938 - 2003
[email protected]
Paiute-Shoshone
Big Pine Paiute Tribe of the
Owens Valley
James Rambeau, Chairperson
P. O. Box 700
Big Pine, CA, 93513
Phone: (760) 938 - 2003
Fax: (760) 938-2942
[email protected]
Paiute-Shoshone
Big Pine Paiute Tribe of the
Owens Valley
Danelle Gutierrez, Tribal Historic
Preservation Officer
P.O. Box 700
Big Pine, CA, 93513
Phone: (760) 938 - 2003
Fax: (760) 938-2942
[email protected]
Paiute-Shoshone
Chumash Council of
Bakersfield
Julio Quair, Chairperson
729 Texas Street
Bakersfield, CA, 93307
Phone: (661) 322 - 0121
[email protected]
Chumash
Kern Valley Indian Community
Julie Turner, Secretary
P.O. Box 1010
Lake Isabella, CA, 93240
Phone: (661) 340 - 0032
Kawaiisu
Tubatulabal
Koso
Kern Valley Indian Community
Robert Robinson, Chairperson
P.O. Box 1010
Lake Isabella, CA, 93240
Phone: (760) 378 - 2915
[email protected]
Kawaiisu
Tubatulabal
Koso
Kern Valley Indian Community
Brandy Kendricks,
30741 Foxridge Court
Tehachapi, CA, 93561
Phone: (661) 821 - 1733
[email protected]
Kawaiisu
Tubatulabal
Koso
Kitanemuk & Yowlumne Tejon
Indians
Delia Dominguez, Chairperson
115 Radio Street
Bakersfield, CA, 93305
Phone: (626) 339 - 6785
[email protected]
Kitanemuk
Southern Valley
Yokut
Santa Rosa Rancheria Tachi
Yokut Tribe
Leo Sisco, Chairperson
P.O. Box 8
Lemoore, CA, 93245
Phone: (559) 924 - 1278
Fax: (559) 924-3583
Southern Valley
Yokut
Tejon Indian Tribe
Octavio Escobedo, Chairperson
P.O. Box 640
Arvin, CA, 93203
Phone: (661) 834 - 8566
[email protected]
Kitanemuk
Tejon Indian Tribe
Colin Rambo,
P.O. Box 640
Arvin, CA, 93203
Phone: (661) 834 - 8566
[email protected]
Kitanemuk
Tubatulabals of Kern Valley
Robert Gomez, Chairperson
P.O. Box 226
Lake Isabella, CA, 93240
Phone: (760) 379 - 4590
Fax: (760) 379-4592
Tubatulabal
1 of 2
This list is current only as of the date of this document. Distribution of this list does not relieve any person of statutory responsibility as defined in Section 7050.5 of the Health and Safety Code, Section 5097.94 of the Public Resource Section 5097.98 of the Public Resources Code.

This list is only applicable for contacting local Native Americans with regard to cultural resources assessment for the proposed Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project (PWK2203), Kern County.

PROJ-2022-
006241
10/28/2022 08:03 PM
Native American Heritage Commission
Native American Contact List
Kern County
10/28/2022
Tule River Indian Tribe
Kerri Vera, Environmental
Department
P. O. Box 589
Porterville, CA, 93258
Phone: (559) 783 - 8892
Fax: (559) 783-8932
[email protected]
Yokut
Tule River Indian Tribe
Joey Garfield, Tribal Archaeologist
P. O. Box 589
Porterville, CA, 93258
Phone: (559) 783 - 8892
Fax: (559) 783-8932
[email protected]
Yokut
Tule River Indian Tribe
Neil Peyron, Chairperson
P.O. Box 589
Porterville, CA, 93258
Phone: (559) 781 - 4271
Fax: (559) 781-4610
[email protected]
Yokut
2 of 2
This list is current only as of the date of this document. Distribution of this list does not relieve any person of statutory responsibility as defined in Section 7050.5 of the Health and Safety Code, Section 5097.94 of the Public Resource Section 5097.98 of the Public Resources Code.

This list is only applicable for contacting local Native Americans with regard to cultural resources assessment for the proposed Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project (PWK2203), Kern County.

PROJ-2022-
006241
10/28/2022 08:03 PM
Native American Heritage Commission
Native American Contact List
Kern County
10/28/2022
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R

APPENDIX D

PROJECT PHOTOGRAPHS
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R Photo 1: Project Overview (View NW)
Photo 2: Project Overview (View S)
© 319ONW (T) • 11 N 309803 3917051 ±9ft ▲ 390ft
I d ; fe L AsEAini sni L... al
© 165°S (T) • 11 N 309720 3917541 ±16ft A 393ft
1 Pr II f
merae EEI ar
t
-99 F
- H.e ■ D—
■ C "Pi -ne
tor’sss P wastlaginsr e
ies
B‘e_
f.) Vebistus) 3
W NENV
240 300 330 30
• I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I B.

I
SE SW
120 150 210 240
• I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I rVC
W
270
Overview From SE Corner
-E. Gutierrez-Tr
X
N
0 s
180
It
3 E
90 PWK2203
16 Jan 2025, 09:29:55
I d
--
• ern
“.as* “a. ■
epeat
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R Photo 3: Project Overview (View E)
Photo 4: Project Overview (View E)
T
0 950E (T) ©11 N 309163 3917436 ±9ft ▲ 407ft
1 -
IT -if I I ||
‘S ESrgn
r
e
“er
‘Ast
"Ps
o monm st-eewvrt. = sse ePe y
Se er
e
- ■ . _

0. s-9f 8
9 E s
© 74°E (T) @ 11 N 309485 3917416 ±16ft A 368ft
9 ss
*s E
ywhs
caw "
go
e
a a
as
t. IK
M. n 27
— s
G Plsy & oS MS221248.“ Sragt 5s OW. fbiait
E
90 SENE
30 60 120 150
pxm
SENE
30 60 120 150
I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I I
“ouvleng
N
0 - AC
weare
E
90 s
180
per
gmelu
Alea
eliae
“I ■ -
ree

2.4 $
ss : . - g
=====
J - :
---

1..2 "our
anb
tguete
e
a
-reo.
34 -alec ., ECee . ‘-%e= —ary
-rm.
“redeD 2-5elCe
-P.) . cin-lak
-
■ tr te
a "-ey
d st.
— 3-3 =="*
pau u
r
teM . CSs Hali)
S
=====
asgr
-—24
“ . ' - , a
.o t
s
Ste
es
—-=a======oia- C (evt"tes,"
19—
2-y?) 8" —So")
ih‘'
wuse I si e
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R Photo 5: Overview of PWK2203-H-1 Oil Pump Removal and Capping Photo 6: Overview of Demolished Oil Pump (View S)
0 166°S (T) ©11 N 309825 3917467 ±22ft ▲ 395ft
,, MJ
.4.
—
--
r
0 87°E (T) • 11 N 309339 3917514 ±13ft A 396ft
N
—
■1 !
I
“emes---- eee mrese
dee --e="7 tal tes er
none 22) sts t.- 1
- ■ fg 2
‘28 e 8)
H
the
S * 40/2“2. Shen e
SE SW
120 150 210 240
• I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I ||
PWK2203-H-1 Remains Of ,
Oil Pump wle -e
-E. Gutierrez-NE SE
30 60 120 150 181
• I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I g2W5
main:
-
cj
N
0 S
180
E
90 1yuntne
E
90 7:7 -
PWK2203
16 Jan 2025, 10:46:40
Cniy nae
as
a “
|
%2
F E B R U A R Y 14 , 2 0 2 5 B C R C O N S U L T I N G

C U L T U R A L R E S O U R C E S A S S E S S M E N T

R O S E D A L E & C O F F E E C O M M E R C I A L R E T A I L C E N T E R

APPENDIX E

PALEONTOLOGICAL RESOURCES OVERVIEW
2345 Searl Parkway ♦ Hemet, CA 92543 ♦ phone 951.791.0033 ♦ fax 951.791.0032 ♦ WesternScienceCenter.org September 28th, 2022
BCR Consulting, LLC
Joseph Orozco
505 W. 8th St.

Claremont, CA 91711
Dear Mr. Orozco,
This letter presents the results of a record search conducted for the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project located in the city of Bakersfield, Kern County, CA. The project site is located south of Blue Star Memorial/Rosedale Highway, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viego Road on Township 29 South, Range 27 East on Section 29 of the Oildale (1968), CA USGS 7.5 minute quadrangle.

The geologic units underlying the project area are mapped primarily as alluvial fan deposits from the Holocene epoch (Smith, 1964) Holocene alluvial units are considered to be of high preservation value, but material found is unlikely to be fossil material due to the relatively modern associated dates of the deposits. However, if development requires any substantial depth of disturbance, the likelihood of reaching Pleistocene alluvial sediments would increase.

The Western Science Center does not have localities within the project area or within a 1 mile radius; however, this is likely due in part to the project’s distance from WSC.

While the presence of any fossil material is unlikely, if excavation activity disturbs deeper sediment dating to the earliest parts of the Holocene or Late Pleistocene periods, the material would be scientifically significant. Excavation activity associated with the development of the project area is unlikely to be paleontologically sensitive, but caution during development should be observed.

If you have any questions, or would like further information, please feel free to contact me at [email protected].

Sincerely,
Brittney Elizabeth Stoneburg, MSc
Collections Manager

WESTERN SCIENCE CENTER
C(OIUUNISANLAOUIRa]
d
1 y
T. C 8
ei D "le
cl O l
Atel
5 Ta
30 :
1s ' S
«giw
-elee 3
—
) A
a
1559 S55 /
E— y .
• 7%‘P
srsw
(l
i
Iecpuru lrs
Cy
Ae
U
.03
22 o o
CANI
B
1 /
/
— -P---- - - —P ------
■
, Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project $
Q. HRUUWVNVHe project area + 1 mile radius j
-Is Dpne0s
2 ■ MB Sucel (CoNSIPEI
■ o. igla ■ frgauemi I’".- 117 '/TE MJ ie-At
"I. eh
"GKBW7EE I
2y“l
V WTH )1 t

1.2 V
3 2
elnn (POILCIROUUNNoS
Cu33s
55% f ill
1 vudelen augseca
Ossistsosta em
1 -7 (5U
—
V IM8OMEg Tw’siga CL < I
3 w-
— r "" ) $ 2 a.
%
5 !
25 UT T WINIDsoNN
A ‘ [d
UDALS@L‘
-I- Ur, p F =;
< MOONNIDYAM 5
THIE" ■
I
tanbieellRon frllRR
X
0 ।
-
( *
J
f s r
. 3&.. (RMNgs
(
Y
t
11 1 yze
»a i
iajut F0 i
) 8 .
:1 fi
4 s
&
f.
—5E
LTE —L’elerys
-=91.
3 L -12
s
(
r
29 Y27 NC
—
Maoppnas’s Con $> aPit ) i Si
Mu—
=--» aiv..‘tlu.a.. Ye -.me - a —4
■ -23 .. , "
t Mu’
’ Surveu .. .

Google Earth '
lcsseels Nwy
“ 2 (ZA. s
*
- L.

Baks
11 OuesikiaGa
/ r lt,"5seff
s
20 A
/4l p2v sol Y
ft dlidd a e
Vierenng ce’S cnnacmn otors
y
ASSIS
1) Legend
1 Mile Radius
Q: Quaternary alluvium and marine deposits (Pliocene to Holocene) • Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Project 32MMLO "0 " P— 8 Riverview Marketplace
Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report
SCH No. 2025101507
Prepared for:

City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department
Planning Division
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Prepared by:

Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2050
Los Angeles, CA 90017
September 2026
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield September 2026
i
Table of Contents
Section 1: Introduction

1.1 Introduction.........................................................................................................................1.0-1

1.2 Organization of EIR ..............................................................................................................1.0-1

1.3 CEQA Process Summary .......................................................................................................1.0-2

1.4 Changes to the Draft EIR ......................................................................................................1.0-3 Section 2: Comments and Responses to Draft EIR

2.1 Introduction to Comments and Responses...........................................................................2.0-1 Comment Letter A1 and Responses......................................................................................2.0-3 Comment Letter A2 and Responses......................................................................................2.0-14 Comment Letter O1 and Responses .....................................................................................2.0-25 Comment Letter O2 and Responses .....................................................................................2.0-43 Comment Letter Appendix O2A Responses ........................................................................2.0-77 Comment Letter Appendix O2B Responses ........................................................................2.0-97 Comment Letter Appendix O2C Responses ........................................................................2.0-99 Comment Letter P1 and Responses......................................................................................2.0-103 Comment Letter P2 and Responses......................................................................................2.0-107 Section 3.0: Errata to the Draft EIR

3.1 Introduction to the Errata ....................................................................................................3.0-1

3.2 Changes to the Draft EIR ......................................................................................................3.0-1 List of Tables
Table 2.0-1: Comments from Public Agencies, Organizations and Individuals.................................2.0-1 Appendices
Appendix A: Unbracketed Letters
Appendix B: Revised General Biological Assessment
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 1 - Introduction City of Bakersfield September 2026

1.0-1
Section 1.0 Introduction

1.1 INTRODUCTION
The Final Environmental Impact Report (Final EIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project) has been prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and CEQA Guidelines. CEQA Guidelines Section 15132 indicates that the contents of a Final EIR shall consist of:
(a) The Draft EIR or a revision of the draft.
(b) Comments and recommendations received on the Draft EIR either verbatim or in summary. (c) A list of persons, organizations, and public agencies commenting on the Draft EIR. (d) The responses of the Lead Agency to significant environmental points raised in the review and consultation process.
(e) Any other information added by the lead agency.

The Final EIR includes all of these required components.

In accordance with Section 15088 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City of Bakersfield, as the lead agency for the proposed Project, evaluated comments received on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (Draft EIR) (State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507) and has prepared responses to the comments. Table 2.01 provides a list of all persons, organizations, and public agencies commenting on the Draft EIR. Section 2.0 includes the Responses to Comments received on the Draft EIR. It should be noted that responses to comments also result in various editorial clarifications and corrections to the original Draft EIR text. Added or modified text is shown in Section 3.0, Errata, by underlining (example) while deleted text is shown by striking (example). The additional information, corrections, and clarifications are not considered to substantively affect the conclusions of findings in the Draft EIR. This Response to Comments document is part of the Final EIR, which includes the Draft EIR pursuant to § 15132 of the State CEQA Guidelines.

Responses to comments will be sent to commenting agencies and individuals 10 days before approval of the Project. This satisfies the CEQA requirement of Public Resources Code Section 21092.5 to send responses to the public agency comments received on the Draft EIR at least 10 days prior to Project approval. This document includes responses to all written and verbal comments received on the Draft EIR.

1.2 ORGANIZATION OF EIR
This Final EIR provides the requisite information required under CEQA and is organized as follows:

Section 1.0 Introduction. This section provides an introduction to the Final EIR, including the requirements under CEQA, the organization of the document, as well as brief summary of the CEQA process activities to date.

Section 2.0 Comments and Responses. This section provides a list of public agencies, organizations, and individuals commenting on the Draft EIR, provides a copy of each written comment received, and any response required under CEQA. •
•
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 1 - Introduction City of Bakersfield September 2026

1.0-2
Section 3.0 Errata to the Draft EIR. This section details changes to the Draft EIR.

Appendix. This section includes a compilation of all the comment letters received and a revision to the General Biological Assessment prepared for the Project in underline/strikeout.

1.3 CEQA PROCESS SUMMARY
The Draft EIR is an informational document intended to inform the public and decision-makers about the environmental consequences of the Project. The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

The Project would feature new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site.

Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide a pedestrian oriented experience and provide shade. The Project would also include enhanced paving areas within small plaza areas in front of storefronts, and enhanced vehicular paving at entry points. The Project would include a detention basin on the northern portion of the Project Site that would be fenced and screened with landscaping. Near the detention basin would be a play area which would include landscaped mounds, benches, picnic tables, bike racks, and a lawn area.

Pursuant to Section 15082 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City circulated an Notice of Preparation (NOP) of the Draft EIR to State, regional, and local agencies, and members of the public for a 32-day public review period. The public review period began Friday, October 31, 2025, and concluded Monday, December 1, 2025. The purpose of the NOP was to formally notice that the City was preparing a Draft EIR for the Project, and to solicit input regarding the scope and content of the environmental information to be included in the Draft EIR. Four written comment letters were received during the scoping period.

The City also held an EIR Scoping Meeting for the Project on Thursday, November 20, 2025. The purpose of the EIR Scoping Meeting was for the City to solicit input and written comments from agencies and the public on environmental issues or alternatives they believe should be addressed in the Draft EIR. A presentation explaining the Project was provided and potential attendees were given an opportunity to provide their comments on the scope of the Draft EIR. No members of the public attended the EIR Scoping Meeting, and no comments were received at the meeting.

Draft EIR. The Draft EIR was published on July 10, 2026. The Draft EIR was circulated for a 45-day public comment period in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15105.

The Draft EIR describes the existing environmental resources on the Project Site and vicinity S, analyzes potential impacts on those resources that would or could occur upon implementation of the proposed Project, and identifies mitigation measures that could avoid or reduce the magnitude of those impacts determined to be significant.
•
•
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 1 - Introduction City of Bakersfield September 2026

1.0-3
As set forth in more detail in the Responses to Comments and Errata, none of the clarifications or amplifications set forth herein change the significance conclusions presented in the Draft EIR or substantially alter the analysis presented in the Draft EIR for public review. Furthermore, the Draft EIR circulated for public review was fully adequate under CEQA such that meaningful public review was not precluded. Thus, the clarifications provided in the Responses to Comments and Errata do not constitute significant new information that might trigger recirculation.

1.4 CHANGES TO THE DRAFT EIR
Section 3.0, Errata to the Draft EIR details the changes to the Draft EIR. Most of the changes to the Draft EIR represent clarifications to the existing content. Added or modified text is shown in Section 3.0, Errata, by underlining (example) while deleted text is shown by striking (example).

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-1
Section 2.0 Comments and Responses to Draft EIR

2.1 INTRODUCTION TO COMMENTS AND RESPONSES
Public Resources Code (PRC) Sections 21091(d) and 21092.5 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15088 govern the lead agency's responses to comments on a Draft EIR. CEQA Guidelines Section 15088(a) states that "[T]he lead agency shall evaluate comments on environmental issues received from persons who reviewed the draft EIR and shall prepare a written response. The lead agency shall respond to comments that were received during the notice comment period and any extensions and may respond to late comments." In accordance with these requirements Table 2.0-1 below provides a list of those parties that provided written comments on the Draft EIR during the public review period. In addition, one comment letter was received after the close of the public review period. Each comment document has been assigned a letter as indicated in the table.

A copy of the written comments are provided in this section and have been annotated with the assigned letter along with a number for each comment. Each comment document is followed by a written response which corresponds to the comments provided. Copies of the original comment letters are provided in Appendix FEIR-1 of this Final EIR.

Table 2.0-1: Comments from Public Agencies, Organizations and Individuals Letter Date Received Organization/Name
Agencies
A1 August 26, 2026 Julie A. Vance, Regional Manager
California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW)
1234 East Shaw Avenue
Fresno, CA 93710
A2 August 28, 2026 Mark Montelongo, Director of Policy and Government Affairs Daniel Martinez, Program Manager
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District
34946 Flyover Court
Bakersfield, CA 93308
Organizations
O1 August 19, 2026 Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D., Vice Chair
Sierra Club
P.O. Box 3357
Bakersfield, CA 93385
[email protected]
O2 August 26, 2026 Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph and Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080-7037
[email protected]
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-2
Letter Date Received Organization/Name
Individuals
P1 August 21, 2026 Brian L. Cypher
[email protected]
P2 August 24, 2026 James Davis, Vice President of Real Estate Jaco Oil Company
P.O. Box 82515
Bakersfield, CA 93308
[email protected]
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-3
Comment Letter A1
Julie A. Vance, Regional Manager
California Department of Fish and Wildlife
1234 East Shaw Avenue
Fresno, California 93710
August 26, 2026
Responses to Letter A1
Comment No. A1.1
The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) received a DEIR from the City of Bakerfield (City), as Lead Agency, for the above-referenced Project pursuant the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and CEQA Guidelines.1
Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments and recommendations regarding those activities involved in the Project that may affect California fish and wildlife.

Likewise, CDFW appreciates the opportunity to provide comments regarding those aspects of the Project that CDFW, by law, may be required to carry out or approve through the exercise of its own regulatory authority under the Fish and Game Code.

Footnotes:
1 CEQA is codified in the California Public Resources Code in section 21000 et seq. The “CEQA Guidelines” are found in Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, commencing with section 15000.

Response No. A1.1
This comment introduces the commenter and the purpose of the letter is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. No changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A1.2
CDFW is California’s Trustee Agency for fish and wildlife resources and holds those resources in trust by statute for all the people of the State (Fish & G. Code, §§ 711.7, subd. (a) & 1802; Pub. Resources Code, § 21070; CEQA Guidelines § 15386, subd. (a)). CDFW, in its trustee capacity, has jurisdiction over the conservation, protection, and management of fish, wildlife, native plants, and habitat necessary for biologically sustainable populations of those species (Id., § 1802.). Similarly, for purposes of CEQA, CDFW is charged by law to provide, as available, biological expertise during public agency environmental review efforts, focusing specifically on projects and related activities that have the potential to adversely affect fish and wildlife resources. CDFW is also submitting comments as a Responsible Agency under CEQA (Pub.

Resources Code, § 21069; CEQA Guidelines, § 15381). CDFW expects that it may need to exercise regulatory authority as provided by the Fish and Game Code. As proposed, for example, the Project may result in “take” as defined by State law of any species protected under the California Endangered Species Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-4
Act (CESA) (Fish & G. Code, § 2050 et seq.), related authorization as provided by the Fish and Game Code will be required.

Response No. A1.2
The comment outlines CDFW's regulatory role as a trustee and responsible agency and notes that CDFW may need to exercise regulatory authority as provided by the Fish and Game Code. The comment is not directed at the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. This comment is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. No changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A1.3

PROJECT DESCRIPTION SUMMARY
Proponent: DJM Capital Partners
Objective: The Project proposes to construct and operate the Riverview Marketplace; a commercialretail center located on a 46.16-acre parcel in northwestern Bakersfield.

The Project would encompass approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space and would include market, retail, and storage uses, as well as restaurants, a medical office, ahealth club, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

Other Project components would include vehicular access and circulation improvements on and off the site; surface parking and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; landscape, hardscape, and lighting features; green space and park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility upgrades.

Location: The Project site is located on approximately 46 acres in the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield. The Assessor’s ParcelNumber associated with the Project is: 368-010-05.

Timeframe: Project buildout is anticipated to occur over an approximately 20-month period, beginning in late 2026 and concluding in the second quarter of 2028.

Response No. A1.3
The commenter provided a summary of the project description as contained in the Draft EIR; the commenter does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A1.4

COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CDFW offersthe following comments and recommendations to assist the City in adequately identifying and/or mitigating the Project’s significant, or potentially significant, direct and indirect impactson fish and wildlife (biological) resources. Editorial comments or other suggestions may also be included to improve the DEIR prepared forthe Project.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-5
CDFW submitted a comment letter on December 1, 2025 (2025 NOP Letter; Attachment 1) in response to the Project’s Notice of Preparation (NOP). The 2025 NOP Letter provided recommendations to identify and mitigate the Project’s significant or potentially significant direct and indirect impacts on biological resources. Specifically, CDFW recommended mitigation measures for the State threatened and federally endangered San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica); the State threatened Swainson’s hawk (Buteo swainsoni); the State candidate western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea), and State candidate Crotch’s bumble bee (Bombus crotchii); the State Species of Special Concern American badger (Taxidea taxus) and Bakersfield legless lizard (Anniella grinnelli); and the State species of special concern and federally proposed threatened western spadefoot toad (Spea hammondii). CDFW would like to note that as of August 13, 2026, the California Fish and Game Commission approved western spadefoot toad (WESP) as a candidate for potential listing as a protected species under CESA and is in the process of publishing the Notice of Findings. As such, when the Notice of Findings is published, WESP will be a candidate under CESA and receive the same legal protection afforded to an endangered or threatened species (Fish & G. Code, §§ 2074.2 & 2085).

Based on a review of the DEIR, CDFW has concerns about the ability of some proposed mitigation measures to reduce impacts to less than significant and avoid unauthorized take for several special-status species, including San Joaquin kit fox, western burrowing owl, and Crotch’s bumble bee. CDFW also has concerns regarding the DEIR’s cumulative analysis for biological resource impacts. As such, CDFW recommends the following:

Response No. A1.4
This comment introduces the formal comments and recommendations outlined in Comments A1.5 through A1.7. Specifically, the commenter notes that some of the mitigation measures outlined in the Draft EIR may not fully reduce impacts to several special-status species, including San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF), western burrowing owl, and Crotch’s bumble bee. In response to the commenter, the additional measures outlined by CDFW in Comments A1.5 through A1.7 regarding these special-status species have been incorporated into the Final EIR, as described in the responses below.

The commenter also noted that as of August 13, 2026, the California Fish and Game Commission approved the western spadefoot toad (WESP) as a candidate for potential listing as a protocetid species under CESA and is in the process of publishing the Notice of Findings, which is the final step before receiving the same legal protection afforded to endangered or threatened species. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A1.5
San Joaquin Kit Fox
The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) is absent on the Project site based on a single general wildlife survey conducted in November 2025. It does not appear that focused SJKF surveys and analyses were completed within the Projectsite and vicinity to inform this conclusion. As a result, no species-specific mitigation measures are included in the DEIR.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-6
Asdiscussed inthe 2025 NOP Letter, Bakersfield is hometo a significant urban population of SJKF, and this population has been recorded to utilize anthropogenically altered habitats throughout the Bakersfield area (Cypher 2013). There are numerous historical and recent SJKF occurrences within the Project vicinity (CDFW 2026), including known occurrences at the Northwest Promenade Center and Lowes Home Improvement Center, as well asthe California State University, Bakersfield, whichare all in close proximity to the Project, and there isthe strong likelihood that SJKFwould den and/or forage within the Projectsite prior to, during, and after construction.

Additionally, the DEIRcontains conflicting information regarding the potential for SJKFpresence. The DEIR and General Biological Assessment (GBA) state that SJKF is not present; however, the GBA’s species list and special-status species table both note that SJKF was directly observed during surveys. CDFW strongly recommends the City further confirm and clarify within the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) whether SJKF were detected during the biological surveys that were conducted to inform the DEIR.

As discussed in the 2025 NOP Letter, given the Project’s anticipated construction activities and duration, the site’s location within urban Bakersfield, CDFW’s knowledge of the Bakersfield urban population of SJKF, the many historical and recent SJKF occurrences within the Project site and proximity, and the strong likelihood for SJKF to den and/or forage within the Project site, CDFW strongly recommends that the Project proponent consult with CDFW to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. CDFW recommends the Project proponent acquire take authorization through the acquisition of an Incidental Take Permit (ITP), pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) to comply with CESA.

CDFW also recommends the DEIR be revised to incorporate an adequate discussion and analysis of SJKF impacts, specifically evaluating the Project’s individual and cumulative impacts on SJKF denning, foraging, and movement within the Bakersfield area.

In addition to these more general recommendations, CDFW recommends incorporating the following mitigation measures within the DEIR:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 1: SJKF Preconstruction Surveys CDFW recommends assessing presence/absence of denning SJKF by conducting focused den surveys for the species prior to the initiation of Project ground disturbance activities. Specifically, CDFW recommends conducting these surveys over the entirety of the Project site no less than 14-days and no more than 30-days prior to beginning of ground and/or vegetation disturbing activities.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 2: SJKF Avoidance Buffer CDFW recommends implementing no-disturbance buffers, as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 3: SJKF Take Authorization If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in the USFWS Protocol for SJKF is not feasible, CDFW recommends that consultation with CDFW occur to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, CDFW recommends the Project proponent acquire take Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-7
authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) to comply with CESA.

Response No. A1.5
The commenter notes that the Draft EIR and accompanying General Biological Assessment (GBA) (Appendix C of the Draft EIR) concluded that suitable habitat for the SJKF is absent on the Project Site and therefore no impacts to SJKF or mitigation measures were identified in the Draft EIR. The comment notes that this finding was based on a single site survey conducted in November 2025. The commenter also notes that focused SJKF surveys were not completed for Project Site. The commenter further notes that Bakersfield is home to a significant urban population of SJKF, and numerous historical and recent SJKF occurrences have occurred within the project vicinity. Therefore, the commenter notes that there is a strong likelihood that SJKF could den and/or forage within the Project Site prior to, during, and after construction.

Based on the above, the commenter recommends that the Project proponent consult with CDFW to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If identified as needed, the commenter also recommends that the Project proponent acquire a take authorization through the acquisition of an Incidental Take Permit (ITP). The commenter also recommends that the Draft EIR be revised to incorporate adequate discussion and analysis of SJKF impacts. Further, the commenter recommends that the mitigation measures outlined in this comment be incorporated into the Draft EIR.

In response to the comment that the SJKF was determined to be absent on the Project Site and, therefore, no impact to SJKF were identified in the Draft EIR, which was based on a single site survey during the general biological assessment and analysis conducted for the Project Site by the Project biologist (Hernandez Environmental), focused SJKF surveys were not warranted based on an initial assessment that the disturbed site and distance from California Natural Diversity Database-recorded SJKF sightings made this site unsuitable for SJKF. However, additional measures (beyond those already identified in the Draft EIR) have been incorporated into an updated GBA and the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP), as detailed in the responses below, acknowledging the potential for SJFK to occur on the Project Site.

In response to the comment that additional revisions be made in the Draft EIR, the GBA and Draft EIR have been updated to provide additional discussion and analysis of potential SJKF impacts. This includes discussions that the ruderal site is within the SJKF’s urban range and that the area is considered suitable habitat and may be used for denning, foraging, or movement. The revisions have also been carried over to the errata section of the Final EIR and in response to the commenters request that the Draft EIR be revised.

In response to the commenter’s request to add additional measures (in addition to those already identified in the Draft EIR to reduce potential impacts to biological resources to less than significant) to further ensure that potential impacts to SJKF remain less than significant, the following mitigation measures have been added to the Final EIR. Mitigation Measure BIO-6 includes CDFW’s recommendation that the project applicant coordinate and consult with CDFW to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take of the SJKF.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-8
MM BIO-4: San Joaquin Kit Fox Pre-Construction Surveys. Pre-construction surveys to assess presence/absence of denning San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) shall be conducted by the qualified biologist no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days prior to the commencement of any ground disturbance and/or construction activities or any Project activity likely to impact the SJKF.

Surveys shall identify kit fox habitat features occurring on the Project Site (if any are determined to occur during the surveys) and evaluate use by SJKF and, if possible, assess the potential impacts to the kit fox by the proposed activity. If a natal/pupping den is discovered within the Project Site or within 200 feet of the Project Site boundary, the appropriate agencies (e.g., California Department of Fish and Wildlife, City of Bakersfield) shall be immediately notified and under no circumstances shall the den be disturbed or destroyed without prior authorization. If the pre-construction survey reveals an active natal pupping or new information, the Project applicant, construction contractor and biologist shall contact the appropriate agencies immediately to obtain the necessary take authorization/permit. Written results of the preconstruction surveys shall be submitted to the appropriate agencies within five (5) days after survey completion and prior to the start of ground disturbance and/or construction activities.

MM BIO-5: San Joaquin Kit Fox Avoidance Buffer. Prior to the commencement of any ground disturbing activities, the Project applicant, construction contractor and project biologist shall implement no-disturbance buffers as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites identified during the pre-construction surveys outlined in Mitigation Measure BIO-4.

MM BIO-6: San Joaquin Kit Fox Take Authorization. If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in Mitigation Measures BIO-5 are not feasible, the Project applicant and California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) shall discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, the Project applicant shall obtain take authorization from CDFW by obtaining an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081, subdivision (b), in compliance with the California Endangered Species Act.

The addition of these suggested mitigation measures is not “significant new information” requiring recirculation. Instead, the mitigation measures will insure that potential impacts to the SJKF will remain less then significant, as concluded in the Draft EIR.

Finally, the commenter stated that the Draft EIR and GBA contain conflicting information regarding the potential for SJKF presence on-site. The Draft EIR and GBA (body of the report) state that SJKF is not present; however, the appendices of the GBA note that SJKF was observed on-site. In response to this comment, there was a clerical error in the appendices of the GBA. The body of the GBA states that no was observed, which is correct; however, Appendices A and B were not updated correctly. A site visit by the biologist was conducted in November 2025, as stated in the GBA; no SJKF were sighted during the site survey. The GBA was updated to correct the references in the Appendices to be consistent with the assessment provided in the body of the GBA and is included as an appendix to the Final EIR. “[N]ew information [is] to be [deemed] ‘significant’ only if that information (1) is significantly different than what was previously circulated, and (2) tends to show that the project will have a more adverse Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-9
environmental impact than stated or implied in the previously circulated reports.” (Laurel Heights Improvement Assoc. v. The Regents of the University of Calif.California (1993)) 6 Cal.4th 1112, 1120, 1129- 1130; East Oakland Stadium Alliance v. City of Oakland (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 1226, 1265; 14 Cal. Code Regs. § 15088.5 (a).) Information that “merely clarifies or amplifies [citations] or makes insignificant modifications” does not warrant recirculation. (Gooden v. City. of Los Angeles (2024)) 106 Cal. App. 5th 1, 21, as modified on denial of reh'g (Nov. 14, 2024).) New information added to an EIR is not “significant” unless the EIR is changed in a way that deprives the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect of the project or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect (including a feasible project alternative) that the project’s proponents have declined to implement. “Significant new information” requiring recirculation include, for example, a disclosure showing that:
1) A new significant environmental impact would result from the project or from a new mitigation measure proposed to be implemented.
2) A substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance. 3) A feasible project alternative or mitigation measure considerably different from others previously analyzed would clearly lessen the environmental impacts of the project, but the project’s proponents decline to adopt it.
4) The draft EIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded. (Mountain Lion Coalition v. Fish and Game Com. (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1043)
Because none of the circumstances above apply, recirculation of the Draft EIR is not required.

Comment No. A1.6
Western Burrowing Owl
The DEIR includes mitigation measures MM BIO-1 and BIO-2 to mitigate for potential significant impacts towestern burrowing owl (BUOW). MM BIO-1and BIO-2 requires a qualified biologist to conduct surveys and implement avoidance measures following the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). CDFW concurs with these measures and recommends MM BIO-2 be modified to note that, in the event a BUOW or knownBUOW den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of anITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

Response No. A1.6
The commenter stated that it concurs with the Mitigation Measures BIO-1 and BIO-2; however, the commenter requested that Mitigation Measure BIO-2 be modified to note that in the event a BUOW or known BUOW den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-10
Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. In response to the commenter’s request, Mitigation Measures BIO-2 has been revised in the Final EIR as follows. Revisions to the mitigation measure are provided in underline text for added text.

MM BIO-2: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls. In the event a burrowing owl or known burrowing owl den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b), shall be necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

The suggested mitigation measure is not “significant new information” requiring recirculation of the Draft EIR. Instead, the mitigation measure will insure that potential impacts to the BUOW will remain less then significant, as concluded in the Draft EIR.

Comment No. A1.7
Crotch’s Bumble Bee
TheDEIRconcludesthatsuitable habitat for Crotch’s bumble bee (CBB) is absent fromthe Projectsite and nospecies-specific mitigation measures were included to avoid unauthorized take or mitigate potentially significant impacts. This conclusion is based on a single survey conducted inNovember 2025 and was not timed appropriately during the plant blooming period to adequately assess potential suitable habitat.

Additionally, no species-specific surveys were conducted during the active period of February through October (CDFW 2023). As the DEIR did not include an adequate habitat assessment or surveys for CBB, CDFWrecommendsincorporating the following mitigation measures within the DEIR:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 4: CBB Habitat Assessment CDFWrecommendsa qualified biologist conducta habitat assessment todetermine ifthe Project site and the immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include allsmallmammalburrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, dead trees, and hollow logs would need to be documented as Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-11
part of the assessment. This habitat assessment should be timed during the appropriate blooming period.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 5: CBB Surveys
If potentially suitable habitat is identified, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct focused surveysfor CBB, and their requisite habitat featuresfollowing the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species(CDFW2023).

Recommended Mitigation Measure 6: CBB Avoidance
If CBB is detected, then CDFW recommends that all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities will occur during the overwintering period (October through February), consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement Project activities and avoid take. Any detection of CBB prior to or during Project implementation warrants consultation with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 7: CBB Take Authorization If CBB is detected, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

Response No. A1.7
The commenter stated that the Draft EIR concluded that suitable habitat for Crotch’s bumble bee (CBB) is absent from the Project Site and no impacts to CBB were identified, therefore, no mitigation measures were required. The commenter stated that this conclusion was based on a single survey conducted in November 2025, which was not timed appropriately during the plant blooming period to adequately assess potential suitable habitat. The commenter also stated that the Draft EIR did not include an adequate habitat assessment or surveys for CBB. Therefore, the commenter requested that additional mitigation measures be provided in the Draft EIR.

In response to the commenter’s request to add additional measures (beyond those already identified in the Draft EIR) to further ensure that potential impacts to CBB remain less than significant, the following mitigation measures have been added to the Final EIR.

MM BIO-7. Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Habitat Assessment. Prior to the commencement of any ground-disturbing activities, the qualified biologist shall conduct an additional habitat assessment to determine if the Project Site and immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal nesting burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, and hollow logs shall be documented as part of the assessment.

MM BIO-8. Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Surveys. If potentially suitable habitat is identified during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, a qualified biologist shall conduct focused surveys for CBB and their requisite habitat features following the methodology Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-12
outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

MM BIO-9. Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Avoidance. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses shall be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities occur during the overwintering period October through February), consultation with CDFW shall be conducted to discuss how to implement the proposed project’s construction-related activities and avoid take of the CBB. Any detection of CBB prior to or during project construction shall warrant discussions with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

MM BIO-10. Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Take Authorization. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the proposed Project and avoid take of the CBB. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit, pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

The suggested mitigation measures do not constitute “significant new information” requiring recirculation of the Draft EIR. Instead, the mitigation measures will insure that potential impacts to the BUOW will remain less then significant, as concluded in the Draft EIR.

Comment No. A1.8

ENVIRONMENTAL DATA
CEQArequiresthatinformation developed in environmental impact reports and negative declarations be incorporated into a database, which may be used to make subsequent orsupplemental environmental determinations (Pub. Resources Code, § 21003, subd. (e).) Accordingly, please report any special-status species and natural communities detected during Project surveys to the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB). The CNDDB field survey form can be filled out and submitted online at the following link: https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Submitting-Data. The types of information reported to the CNDDB canbe found at the following link: https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Plants-and-Animals.

Response No. A1.8
The commenter stated that any special-status species and natural communities detected on-site during Project surveys be reported to the CNDDB; the commenter also provided a link to the CNDDB for the City’s reference. If any species or communities are identified on-site during surveys to be completed pursuant to the mitigation measures outlined in Draft EIR and Final EIR, the City of Bakersfield, in coordination with the Project applicant, construction contractor and biologist, will ensure through its development review process (which includes applicant compliance with all Project mitigation measures and conditions of approval) that any such biological resources are reported via the CNDDB. No changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-13
Comment No. A1.9

FILING FEES
The Project, as proposed, would have an impact on fish and/or wildlife, and an assessment of filing feesis necessary. Fees are payable upon filing of theNotice of Determination by the Lead Agency and serve to help defray the cost of environmental review by CDFW. Payment of the fee is required in order for the underlying project approval to be operative, vested, and final (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 14, § 753.5; Fish & G.Code, § 711.4; Pub. Resources Code, § 21089).

Response No. A1.9
The commenter outlined the necessary CDFW fees that are required to be paid at the time of filing the Notice of Determination (NOD). All necessary fees associated with filing of the NOD will be paid in accordance with CEQA and CDFW requirements. The comment does not relate to the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A1.10

CONCLUSION
CDFW appreciates the opportunity to comment on the DEIR toassist the City inidentifying and mitigating Project impacts on biological resources. More information on survey and monitoring protocols for sensitive species can be found at CDFW’s website (https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols) A Mitigation and Monitoring Program (MMRP) (Attachment 2) is included to assist the City with incorporating the recommended mitigation measures provided above. If you have any questions regarding thisletter or further coordination, please contact Evelyn Barajas-Perez, Environmental Scientist, at the address provided on this letterhead, by telephone at (805) 503-5738 or [email protected].

Response No. A1.10
The commenter provided conclusive remarks and made reference to the MMRP provided as an attachment to the comment letter; it does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.
----------------------------
Attachments:

Attachment 1 Includes a copy of the CDFW letter sent on December 1 ,2025 in response to the Notice of Preparation. Attachment 2 includes a sample Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program.

Response
These are noted for the the record and are included in Appendix A of the FEIR.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-14
Comment Letter A2
Mark Montelongo, Director of Policy and Governmental Affairs Daniel Martinez, Program Manager
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District
34946 Flyover Court
Bakersfield, CA 93308
August 28, 2026
Responses to Letter A2
Comment No. A2.1
The San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (District) hasreviewed the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) from the City of Bakersfield (City) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project. Per the DPEIR [SIC], the project consists of a 405,531 square foot commercial retail center (Project). The Project is located on the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road, in Bakersfield, CA.

The District offers the following comments at this time regarding the Project:

Response No. A2.1
This comment relates to an introduction of the Project and that the SJVAPCD provides further comments for consideration. This comment is noted and no further response or changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.2
1) Health Risk Screening/Assessment
The District reviewed the Health Risk Assessment (HRA) for the Project and have the following comment:
• Only a construction HRA was performed to evaluate health impactsfrom the Projectto nearby sensitive receptors. An operational HRA should also be performed to evaluate the health risk from the Project’s proposed gasoline station, fast food charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel from deliveries. The risk scores from the operational HRA should be combined with the construction HRA and compared to District health risk significance thresholds to confirm the significance determination presented in the DEIR.

Modifications to the HRA based on the comments listed above have the potential to cause the Project to exceed District health risk thresholds. Therefore, the District recommends revising the HRA to ensure the analysis accurately reflects the Project’s potential air quality impacts.

The District is available to review HRA protocols and analyses. For HRA submittals please provide the following information electronically to the District for review:
• HRA (AERMOD) modeling files
• HARP2 files
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-15
• Summary of emissions source locations, emissions rates, and emission factor calculations and methodologies.

For assistance, please contact the District’s Technical Services Department by:
• E-Mailing inquiries to: [email protected]
• Calling (559) 230-5900
Recommended Measure: Development projects resulting in TAC emissions should be located an adequate distance from residential areas and other sensitive receptors to prevent the creation of a significant health risk in accordance to CARB's Air Quality and Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective located at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/our-work/programs/resource-center/strategy-development/land-use-resources.

Response No. A2.2
Consistent with the SJVAPCD’s recommendation and as noted in Section 4.3, Air Quality, of the Draft EIR, potential health risk impacts associated with the proposed gasoline station were evaluated in the context of CARB’s Air Quality and Land Use Handbook (2005) siting recommendations.

CARB’s siting recommendations therein identify a distance of 500 feet between sensitive land uses (e.g., residences) and gasoline dispensing facilities to ensure that associated health risk impacts are less than significant. As discussed in Section 4.3 of the Draft EIR, the nearest potential sensitive receptors to the gasoline station are approximately 650 feet away, which would be outside CARB’s recommended 500- foot buffer. Moreover, the Project would be subject to District Regulation II, which would ensure that permitted stationary sources, such as the gasoline station, result in impacts below the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and one hazard index for acute risk at the maximally exposed receptor.

In addition, while the Project would result in some truck use for product and supply deliveries, because the Project is not a warehouse, distribution center, or another heavy-duty truck-intensive use, it is not anticipated to generate substantial truck traffic sufficient to result in health risk impacts that exceed the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds. As discussed in Section 4.3 of the Draft EIR, per CARB’s Air Quality and Land Use Handbook (2005) siting recommendations, the Project would not result in local roadway volumes that exceed levels sufficient to result in potentially significant impacts to nearby sensitive receptors.

Moreover, as evidenced by an Environmental Impact Report (2026) for the Airport Commerce Center Industrial Project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498), a project that generates 824 heavy-duty diesel truck trips per day, with 265 truck trips with transport refrigerated units, would result in a cancer risk of 8.88 per million and 0.002 hazard index at the maximally exposed residential receptor approximately 650 feet away. As shown on Page 119 of Appendix B of the Draft EIR, the heavy-duty truck vehicle miles traveled (VMT) total an estimated 751 miles per day for the project. Project-generated VMT including from heavy-duty trucks was determined using the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional traffic demand model, which is calibrated to account for travel specific to heavy-duty trucks. Project. When divided by the overall average trip length of 3.94 milesfor the Project, shown on Page 119 of Appendix B, this equates Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-16
to an assumed heavy-duty truck trip generation of approximately 191 trips per day. It’s important to note that this reflects an overly conservative assumption of assumed truck trip lengths as trucks delivering products and supplies to the Project would be traveling longer distances on average than an employee, customer, or visitor would. Furthermore, per the KernCOG regional model and the vehicle trip fleet mix it internally generated for the proposed project in its calculation of the proposed project VMT, project-related heavy-duty truck trips comprise only 0.15 percent (i.e., 23 average daily trips [ADTs] of 14,904 ADT) of total project-generated trips. When applied to the anticipated total weekday and weekend project-generated ADTs that would range between 18,921 ADTs to 28,479 ADTs, this fleet mix percentage results in 29 to 44 heavy-duty truck trips per day. Regardless, the project with 191 estimated truck trips per day would not result in exceeding the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds during operation.

As identified in Table 4.3-16 in Section 4.3 of the Draft EIR, the Project would result in a cancer risk of

1.5 per million at the maximally exposed receptor during construction. Therefore, the combined construction and operational health risk impacts resulting from the Project would not exceed the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds 20 in one million cancer risk and one hazard index for acute risk at the maximally exposed receptor. In addition, the hazard index for acute risk resulting from pollutant exposure is correlated with the pollutant type and maximum annual concentration thereof rather than continued long-term exposure. Because the Project’s pollutant of concern during both construction and operation would be diesel particulate matter, the Project would result in a hazard index of less than one during construction, and would result in substantially fewer truck trips during operation than a warehouse project that has the potential to generate substantially more truck trips, thereby resulting in an overall hazard index that would not exceed the SJVAPCD threshold of one.

The Draft EIR evaluated impacts based on the level of information available. No tenants have been identified within the proposed commercial shopping center. Therefore, it is speculative to assume, at this phase, the presence of charbroilers. At the request of the commenter, a Condition of Approval (CoA) of the Project site plan will be added to require a health risk assessment to be prepared prior to installation of any future under-fired charbroilers. Under the CoA, if it is determined that health risk impacts would exceed the District’s 20 in a million for cancer risk threshold and/or hazard index of 1, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these significance thresholds.

Comment No. A2.3
2) Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement
The District appreciates the City’s inclusion of a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) as a mitigation measure for the Project. As identified in Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1, the VERA would mitigate Project-related operational emissions of volatile organic compounds(VOC) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) to net zero, thereby reducing the Project’s air quality to less-than-significant level.

Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 also states that, prior to issuance of building permits, the Project applicant shall provide documentation to the City verifying “completion of the VERA.” The District would like to clarify that, once the VERA is executed and the required emission reduction fees are paid, the District will use the funds to achieve the required emission reduction through District emission reduction programs.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-17
The time required to achieve these emission reductions may vary depending on the types of emission reduction projects implemented and the time necessary to complete those projects. Once the required emission reductions have been achieved, the District will verify to the City that the mitigation requirements of the VERA have been completed. As a result, the verification of the required emission reductions may occur after issuance of building permits.

Therefore, to more accurately reflect the VERA process and avoid implying that all required emission reductions must be achieved prior to issuance of building permits, the District suggests revising MM AQ-1 to replace the term “completion of the VERA’ with “execution of the VERA.” This revision would ensure that the Project’s obligation to enter into the VERA is established prior to issuance of building permits, while recognizing that the implementation and verification of the resulting emission reduction projects may require additional time.

Response No. A2.3
At the suggestion of the commenter, Mitigation Measure AQ-1 was modified in the Errata to change the language of “completion of the VERA” with “execution of the VERA.” This edit does not constitute significant new information that alters the substance or efficacy of Mitigation Measure AQ-1. Thisrevision does not require recirculation of the Draft EIR. The modified measure has been adopted as part of the project approval and therefore does not satisfy the recirculation criteria under CEQA Guidelines section 15088.5(a)(3). Moreover, the revision refines a mitigation measure already evaluated in the Draft EIR and does not result in new significant information or substantially increase the severity of a previously identified impact. (Laurel Heights Improvement Assoc. v. Regents of University of Calif. (1993) 6 Cal.4th 1112, 1120, 1129-1130; 14 Cal. Code Regs. §15088.5(a).) Comment No. A2.4
3) Under-fired Charbroilers
The Project may have restaurants with under-fired charbroilers. Such charbroilers may pose the potential for immediate health risk, particularly when located in densely populated areas or near sensitive receptors.

Since the cooking of meat can release carcinogenic PM2.5 species, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, controlling emissions from new under-fired charbroilers will have a substantial positive impact on public health. The air quality impacts on neighborhoods near restaurants with under-fired charbroilers can be significant on days when meteorological conditions are stable, when dispersion is limited and emissions are trapped near the surface within the surrounding neighborhoods. This potential for neighborhood-level concentration of emissions during evening or multi-day stagnation events raises air quality concerns.

Furthermore, reducing commercial charbroiling emissions is essential to achieving attainment of multiple federal PM2.5 standards. Therefore, the District recommends that the DEIR include a measure requiring the assessment and potential installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-18
The District is available to assist the City and project proponents with this assessment. Additionally, the District is currently offering substantial incentive funding that covers the full cost of purchasing, installing, and maintaining the system during a demonstration period covering two years of operation. Please contact the District at (559) 230-5800 or [email protected] for more information, or visit:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/grants/restaurant-charbroiler-technology-partnership/ Response No. A2.4
While the Project could include high-turnover restaurant uses, future tenants which may occupy those spaces are unknown at this time and, therefore, any associated impacts are considered speculative pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15145. (14 Cal. Code Regs., §15145.) No tenants have been identified within the commercial retail building; and therefore, it is unknown whether these uses would be retail or restaurant, and if restaurant whether they would require use of charbroilers at all. While some fast-food restaurants that use under-fired charbroilers may ultimately occupy these tenant spaces, it is also speculative how much meat product, what cooking appliance type, and what emission generation would result from these activities. Therefore, the presence of charbroilers within the Project Site and any resulting impacts is considered speculative.

Nonetheless, a Condition of Approval to the site has been added as shown below.

Condition of Approval: Under-Fired Charbroilers
Prior to issuance of a Tenant Improvement permit for a new tenant/business entity that will install an under-fire charbroiler (as defined under Section 3.9 of San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) Rule 4692), the project proponent/developer and/or tenant/business entity shall prepare a health risk assessment (HRA). The HRA shall be prepared to evaluate the potential health risk impacts for the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) and shall be submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division and the SJVAPCD for evaluation.

The HRA shall be prepared in accordance with the policies and procedures of the State Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment and SJVAPCD. If the health risk levels exceed the SJVAPCD health risk significance thresholds of 20 in 1 million for incremental cancer risk of and/or

1.0 for the noncancer hazard index, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these significance thresholds. The identified measures shall be noted on all Tenant Improvement plans submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify implementation of the identified measures (if any).

Comment No. A2.5
4) Vegetative Barriers and Urban Greening
There are residential units located near the Project. The District suggests the City consider the feasibility of incorporating vegetative barriers and urban greening as a measure to further reduce air pollution exposure on sensitive receptors (e.g., residential units).

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-19
While various emission control techniques and programs exist to reduce air quality emissions from mobile and stationary sources, vegetative barriers have been shown to be an additional measure to potentially reduce a population’s exposure to air pollution through the interception of airborne particles and the update of gaseous pollutants. Examples of vegetative barriers include, but are not limited to the following:
trees, bushes, shrubs, or a mix of these. Generally, a higher and thicker vegetative barrier with full coverage will result in greater reductions in downwind pollutant concentrations. In the same manner, urban greening is also a way to help improve air quality and public health in addition to enhancing the overall beautification of a community with drought tolerant, low-maintenance greenery.

Response No. A2.5
As noted in Section 4.1, Aesthetics, of the Draft EIR, the Project would include landscaping consisting of a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover. These vegetative improvements would contribute to overall community beautification and assist in pollutant concentration reductions to offsite receptors.

This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.6
5) Electric Infrastructure
To support and accelerate the installation of electric vehicle charging equipment and development of required infrastructure, the District offers incentives to public agencies, businesses, and property owners of multi-unit dwellings to install electric charging infrastructure (Level 2 and 3 chargers). The purpose of the District’s Charge Up! Incentive program is to promote clean air alternative-fuel technologies and the use of low orzero-emission vehicles. The Districtrecommends thatthe City and project proponentsinstall electric vehicle chargers at project sites, and at strategic locations.

Please visit https://ww2.valleyair.org/grants/charge-up for more information.

Response No. A2.6
The Project would be subject to the electric vehicle (EV) charging requirements of the California Code of Regulations, Title 24, Part 11 (Green Building Standards Code; CALGreen). CALGreen will require the designation of EV capable spaces and installation of EV charging stations according to the parking assignments by occupancy type, which would support the accelerated deployment of EV charging infrastructure in the Project area. As noted in Section 4.8, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, of the Draft EIR, the Project would be required to implement Mitigation Measure GHG-7, which stipulates that the project comply with the applicable nonresidential voluntary EV charging standards of CALGreen, further accelerating the deployment of related infrastructure. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.7
6) District Rules and Regulations
The District issues permits for many types of air pollution sources, and regulates some activities that do not require permits. A project subject to District rules and regulations would reduce its impacts on air Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-20
quality through compliance with the District’s regulatory framework. In general, a regulation is a collection of individual rules, each of which deals with a specific topic. As an example, Regulation II (Permits) includes District Rule 2010 (Permits Required), Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review), Rule 2520 (Federally Mandated Operating Permits), and several other rules pertaining to District permitting requirements and processes.

The list of rules below is neither exhaustive nor exclusive. Current District rules can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/rules-and-planning/current-district-rules-and-regulations. To identify other District rules or regulations that apply to future projects, or to obtain information about District permit requirements, the project proponents are strongly encouraged to contact the District’s Small Business Assistance (SBA) Office at (661) 392-5665.

Response No. A2.7
Comments regarding District Rules are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the Project. Existing and future projects within the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SJVAB) that are subject to District Rules and Regulations would be required to comply with the applicable requirements.

This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.8
6a) District Rules 2010 and 2201 - Air Quality Permitting for Stationary Sources Stationary Source emissions include any building, structure, facility, or installation which emits or may emit any affected pollutant directly or as a fugitive emission. District Rule 2010 (Permits Required) requires operators of emission sources to obtain an Authority to Construct (ATC) and Permit to Operate (PTO) from the District. District Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review) requires that new and modified stationary sources of emissions mitigate their emissions using Best Available Control Technology (BACT).

This Project may be subject to District Rule 2010 (Permits Required) and Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review) and may require District permits. Prior to construction, the Project proponent should submit to the District an application for an ATC. For further information or assistance, the project proponent may contact the District’s SBA Office at (661) 392-5665.

Response No. A2.8
Comments regarding District Rules 2010 and 2201 are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the Project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Rules 2010 and 2201 would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.9
6b) District Rule 9510 - Indirect Source Review (ISR)
The Project is subject to District Rule 9510 because it will receive a project-level discretionary approval from a public agency and will equal or exceed 9,000 square feet of development space.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-21
The purpose of District Rule 9510 is to reduce the growth in both NOx and PM emissions associated with development and transportation projects from mobile and area sources; specifically, the emissions associated with the construction and subsequent operation of development projects. The ISR Rule requires developers to mitigate their NOx and PM emissions by incorporating clean air design elements into their projects. Should the proposed development project clean air design elements be insufficient to meet the required emission reductions, developers must pay a fee that ultimately fundsincentive projects to achieve off-site emissions reductions.

Per Section 5.0 of the ISR Rule, an Air Impact Assessment (AIA) application is required to be submitted no later than applying for project-level approval from a public agency. As of the date of thisletter, the District has not received an AIA application for this Project. Please inform the project proponent to immediately submit an AIA application to the District to comply with District Rule 9510 so that proper mitigation and clean air design under ISR can be incorporated into the Project’s design. One AIA application should be submitted for the entire Project. Information about how to comply with District Rule 9510 can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/permitting/indirect-source-review-rule-overview The AIA application form can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/permitting/indirect-source-review-rule-overview/forms-and-applications/ District staff is available to provide assistance and can be reached by phone at (559) 230-5900 or by email at [email protected].

Response No. A2.9
Comments regarding District Rule 9510 are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the Project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Rule 9510 would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.10
6c) District Rule 9410 (Employer Based Trip Reduction)
The Project may be subject to District Rule 9410 (Employer Based Trip Reduction) if the project would result in employment of 100 or more “eligible” employees. District Rule 9410 requires employers with 100 or more “eligible” employees at a worksite to establish an Employer Trip Reduction Implementation Plan (eTRIP) that encourages employees to reduce single-occupancy vehicle trips, thus reducing pollutant emissions associated with work commutes. Under an eTRIP plan, employers have the flexibility to select the options that work best for their worksites and their employees.

Information about District Rule 9410 can be found online at: https://ww2.valleyair.org/compliance/rule-9410-employer-based-trip-reduction/.

For additional information, you can contact the District by phone at 559-230-6000 or by e-mail at [email protected]
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-22
Response No. A2.10
Comments regarding District Rule 9410 are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Rule 9410 would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.11
6d) District Rule 4601 (Architectural Coatings)
The Project may be subject to District Rule 4601 since it is expected to utilize architectural coatings.

Architectural coatings are paints, varnishes, sealers, or stains that are applied to structures, portable buildings, pavements or curbs.

The purpose of this rule is to limit VOC emissions from architectural coatings. In addition, this rule specifies architectural coatings storage, cleanup and labeling requirements. Additional information on how to comply with District Rule 4601 requirements can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/tkgjeusd/rule-4601.pdf
Response No. A2.11
Comments regarding District Rule 4601 are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Rule 4601 would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.12
6e) District Regulation VIII (Fugitive PM10 Prohibitions) The project proponent may be required to submit a Construction Notification Form or submit and receive approval of a Dust Control Plan prior to commencing any earthmoving activities as described in Regulation VIII, specifically Rule 8021 – Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities.

Should the project result in at least 1-acre in size, the project proponent shall provide written notification to the District at least 48 hours prior to the project proponents intent to commence any earthmoving activities pursuant to District Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities). Also, should the project result in the disturbance of 5-acres or more, or will include moving, depositing, or relocating more than 2,500 cubic yards per day of bulk materials, the project proponent shall submit to the District a Dust Control Plan pursuant to District Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities). For additional information regarding the written notification or Dust Control Plan requirements, please contact District Compliance staff at (559) 230-5950.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-23
The application for both the Construction Notification and Dust Control Plan can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/fm3jrbsq/dcp-form.docx
Information about District Regulation VIII can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/dustcontrol
Response No. A2.12
Comments regarding District Regulation VIII are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Regulation VIII, including District Rule 8021, would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.13
6f) Other District Rules and Regulations
The Project may also be subject to the following District rules: Rule 4102 (Nuisance) and Rule 4641 (Cutback, Slow Cure, and Emulsified Asphalt, Paving and Maintenance Operations).

Response No. A2.13
Comments regarding District Rules 4102 and 4641 are not comments on the physical environmental impacts associated with the Project. Existing and future projects within the SJVAB that are subject to District Rules 4102 and 4641 would be required to comply with the applicable requirements. This comment is noted and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. A2.14
7) District Comment Letter
The District recommends that a copy of the District’s comments be provided to the Project proponent.

If you have any questions or require further information, please contact Ryan Grossman by e-mail at [email protected] or by phone at (559) 230-6569.

Response No. A2.14
This comment is noted. In accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15088(b), responses to written agency comments will be provided a minimum of 10 days prior to certifying the EIR. No changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-24
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-25
Comment Letter O1
Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D., Vice Chair
Sierra Club
P.O. Box 3357
Bakersfield, CA 93385
[email protected]
August 19, 2026
Responses to Letter O1
Comment No. O1.1
The Sierra Club offers comments about the above project, a proposed commercial retail center on

46.16 acres at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road in Bakersfield.

Response No. O1.1
The comment includes a general introduction to the overall comment letter and does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.2
As best we can tell, the DEIR does not explain or evaluate Tentative Tract Map No. 7526. The City must not approve a Tentative Tract without public disclosure and proper CEQA evaluation. However, inclusion of affordable high-density housing affordable to lower-income residents in the project via a tentative tract could be a potential additional benefit.

Response No. O1.2
The Draft EIR analyzes the Project based on the Conceptual Site Plan (Figure 2-3) of the Draft EIR, which consists of the development of commercial and retail uses. Residential development is not a part of Project and was not analyzed as a potential use. It should be noted that based on zoning, a restrictive covenant, and site conditions, residential development is not suitable for the Project Site. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.3

AIR POLLUTION
Bakersfield has arguably the worst air in the nation. According to the American Lung Association, Bakersfield ranks Number 1 in the nation among US cities most polluted by year-round Annual PM2.5 pollution. Bakersfield ranks Number 3 in the nation among US cities most polluted by short-term Daily PM2.5 pollution, and Number 3 in the nation among US cities for exposure to ozone pollution (Am. Lung Ass’n, State of the Air 2026 Report, https://www.lung.org/getmedia/32f0646d-c5de-4501-b0ac-07cd63c974d4/State-of-the-Air-2026-Report.pdf).

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-26
Specifically, according to CalEnviroScreen 4.0 | OEHHA, this project site area is in the 94th percentile for ozone exposure and in the 99th percentile for PM2.5 exposure. Since our extreme air pollution affects the health of many residents, the DEIR must thoroughly address the issue.

Our region is classified as a serious nonattainment area for the 1997 annual PM2.5 standard, a serious nonattainment area for the 2006 24-hour PM2.5 standard, and a serious nonattainment area for the 2012 annual PM2.5 standard. With respect to ozone, the Valley is classified as an extreme ozone nonattainment area for the 2008 8-hour ozone standard and an extreme ozone nonattainment area for the 2015 8-hour ozone standard.

California courts have ruled, “the greater the existing environmental problems are, the lower the threshold should be for treating a project’s contribution to cumulative impacts as significant.” In a region with arguably the dirtiest air in the nation and where large numbers of Kern County children have asthma, any air pollution additions must be considered significant and adequately mitigated. In the context of air quality in particular, our courts have cautioned that “The magnitude of the current air quality problems in the San Joaquin Valley cannot be used to trivialize the cumulative contributions of the shopping centers and the scope of the analysis cannot be artificially limited to a restricted portion of the air basin.” Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184, 1219 To this end, the DEIR should adopt a net zero threshold for air pollution impacts.

Response No. O1.3
Under CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(b)(1), the determination by a lead agency of whether a project may have a significant impact on the environment calls for careful judgement based on scientific and factual data. The Draft EIR utilized the regional significance thresholds developed and adopted by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD), which is the regional public agency that oversees the overall air quality for the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SJVAB), of which the Project Site is located.

Per the SJVAPCD Guidelines for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI), air quality impacts are cumulative by nature, as no single individual project within the SJVAB is large enough to cause nonattainment of the ambient air quality standards for the region. In general, the nonattainment status of the SJVAB is a result of past and present development. The SJVAPCD attainment plans provide a roadmap for the SJVAB to meet and achieve attainment of the ambient air quality standards. Growth projections are utilized by the SJVAPCD attainment plans to forecast cumulative development in the SJVAB. Therefore, the SJVAPCD attainment plans account for both existing and future cumulative development within the SJVAB. The regional significance thresholds are based on the SJVAPCD Rule 2201 New Source Review (NSR) offset thresholds and the SJVAPCD attainment plans demonstrate that project specific emissions below the NSR offset thresholds will have a less than significant impact on air quality.

Because the adopted regional significance thresholds are based on the NSR offset thresholds, they evaluate both project-level and cumulative impacts associated with a proposed project.

Overall, the adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds and their use are supported by substantial evidence under CEQA Guidelines Section 15384(b), which defines substantial evidence as, “facts, reasonable assumptions predicated upon facts, and expert opinion supported by facts.” Therefore, use of Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-27
the SJVAPCD regional significance threshold to evaluate regional air quality impacts is supported and appropriate. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.4
On page 4.3-27, The DEIR mistakenly states, “project-related construction activities would not cause or contribute to a violation of the ambient air quality standards”. As noted above, National Ambient Air Quality Standards are routinely violated in Bakersfield. The additional pollution generated by this project would certainly “contribute” to the cumulative impact of these ongoing violations. The DEIR is deficient in not having thoroughly addressed the project’s cumulative contributions to the city’s dirty air.

Response No. O1.4
See response to Comment O1.3 above for the discussion that use of the adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds is valid and supported by substantial evidence. The Draft EIR evaluated the Project construction-related criteria air pollutants against the regional significance thresholds for construction adopted by the SJVAPCD. The SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds evaluate whether a project cumulatively contributes to air quality impacts within the SJVAB. As shown in Table 4.3-9 of the Draft EIR, project-related construction emissions would not exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds.

As discussed on page 4.3-34 of the Draft EIR, because the Project would not exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for construction, the Project would not result in cumulative air quality impacts and would not cumulatively contribute to the nonattainment designations of the SJVAB. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.5
Fruitvale Junior High School is located less than 2600 feet southwest of the project site. Many children have asthma. Other existing sensitive receptors to the Project Site include the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park to the west along Rosedale Highway and single-family residential uses to the southwest along El Toro Viejo Road. With no discussion of the project’s operational criteria pollutant impacts on the schools and residences, the DEIR improperly concludes that “Impacts would be less than significant.” The DEIR is defective in not having thoroughly addressed this project’s operational criteria pollutant impact on these sensitive receptors.

Response No. O1.5
See Response to Comment O1.3 for the discussion that use of the adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds is valid and supported by substantial evidence. As discussed in Response to Comment O1.3, the adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds evaluate project-level impacts and cumulative impacts to the SJVAB. Therefore, the SJVAPCD’s regional significance thresholds reflect the level of emissions below which a project's individual and cumulative contribution to ambient air quality pollutant concentrations is not considered significant. The project’s incremental increase in air pollutant emissions evaluates whether the project cumulative contributes to air quality impacts the SJVAB.

As discussed on page 4.3-34 of the Draft EIR, the Project’s operational emissions would not result in emissions that exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds with implementation of Mitigation Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-28
Measure (MM) AQ-1. A project whose emissions fall below the SJVAPCD regional emissions thresholds is one whose incremental contribution to regional pollutant loading has already been determined not to be sufficient, on its own or cumulatively, to cause or contribute to a violation of the ambient air quality standards. Therefore, the Project would not result in long-term, adverse public health impacts to receptors at the Fruitvale Junior High School, Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, and the single-family residential uses to the southwest.

In addition, the Draft EIR includes an operational ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) to assess the Project operations on the ambient air quality. In accordance with SJVAPCD methodology, the receptor grid used for the AAQA modeling consisted of a 25 m fence-line grid spacing with three receptor tiers: 25 m spacing extending 100 meters from the project starting 25 m from the property line; 50 m spacing extending 150 meters from the project; and 100 m spacing extending 250 meters from the project. Overall, the AAQA evaluated concentration levels generally within about 500 meters (1,640 feet) of the Project Site. This modeled study area includes the single-family residences to the southwest and Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park. Because Fruitvale Junior High School is farther west at about 650 meters (2,132 feet) outside the modeled study area, it can be reasonably determined that it would be exposed to lower concentration levels of criteria pollutants than what was analyzed. As discussed on page 4.3-29 of the Draft EIR, operation of the Project would not result in concentration levels that exceed the SJVAPCD significance thresholds and the potential for operation of the proposed project to contribute to an ambient air quality standards exceedance would be less than significant. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.6
The DEIR is deficient in not having presented evidence regarding potential valley fever exposure. The project should be required to test the soil for Valley fever spores before drawing this conclusion, all the more important given the proximity to nearby residences and Fruitvale Junior High School and given the recent increase in cases. Kern County sees rise in Valley Fever; New push for awareness and testing Response No. O1.6
The commenter shares concern that evidence regarding potential Valley Fever has not been adequately disclosed in the Draft EIR, given the proximity of sensitive receptors.

While Valley Fever is associated with soil disturbance, impacts associated with Valley Fever are related to the Coccidioides fungal spore, which is a biological agent. In general, a CEQA-level air quality framework and analysis evaluate potential impacts associated with criteria air pollutants and toxic air contaminants, which are chemical pollutants. However, ground disturbing activities can aerosolize fungal spores present in project soils, creating a potential inhalation exposure pathway. Risk is generally elevated during dry, windy conditions and in years following drought (dry soil is more easily aerosolized), and disturbance of previously undisturbed or long-undisturbed soils poses higher risk than disturbance of soils that have been recently worked. Fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever. Because the proposed Project is a non-residential project that would disrupt more than five acres of land, it would be subject to San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) Rule 8021 to minimize fugitive dust during construction activities. Under Rule 8021, the proposed Project would be required to prepare Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-29
and submit a Dust Control Plan (DCP) to the SJVAPCD for approval. The DCP would be required to detail specific actions to ensure that visible dust emissions do not exceed 20 percent opacity. These actions can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants. Compliance with Rule 8021 would help minimize generation of fugitive dust.

In addition, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupation safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices. Title 8 CCR Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 CCR Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employers when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the proposed project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to the Section.

Overall, implementation of SJVAPCD fugitive dust control measures and compliance with workplace occupational safety and health requirements and Cal/OSHA oversight would minimize potential Valley Fever exposure to construction workers and no significant impacts would occur. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.7
Principally, the mitigation measures require this project to comply with weak San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District requirements that have not over the years adequately addressed our local pollution problem. Bakersfield and the surrounding San Joaquin Valley are designated nonattainment under both federal (EPA) and state (CARB) standards for ozone pollution (a major smog component). This means concentrations of ozone exceed allowable limits over time because existing plans and regulation have not been effective in reducing ozone levels to safe levels. Likewise, Bakersfield has historically exceeded federal and state standards for 24-hour PM2.5 annual PM2.5 concentrations. Accordingly, the City of Bakerfield’s reliance on SJAVPCD regulations and thresholds of significance is misplaced. If the City insists on relying on these thresholds, the City must at least explain why continued reliance on SJAVPCD thresholds is reasonable in light of the SJVAPCD’s inability to reduce ozone and PM2.5 levels to safe levels.

Response No. O1.7
See response to Comment O1.3 above.

Comment No. O1.8
On page 4.3-34, in the section meant to address the cumulative impact of the project, the DEIR concludes that since emissions of ROG, NOX, PM10, and PM2.5 associated with the construction and operation of the project would not exceed the SJVAPCD significance thresholds, therefore the project would not have Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-30
substantial cumulative impacts. The City illogically asserts that project-specific insignificance implies cumulative insignificance, violating the very meaning of cumulative impacts.

According to CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(3), ““Cumulatively considerable” means that the incremental effects of an individual project are significant when viewed in connection with the effects of past projects, the effects of other current projects, and the effects of probable future projects.” From page 107 and 108 of SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/g4nl3p0g/gamaqi.pdf):
• “If a project is significant based on the thresholds of significance for criteria pollutants, then it is also cumulatively significant. This does not imply that if the project is below all such significance thresholds, it cannot be cumulatively significant.” (Underline added) • “Lead Agencies should also consider the cumulative impact of multiple simultaneously proposed projects, located within the same area. If the combined impacts of such projects cause or worsen an exceedance of the concentration standards, the project would have a cumulatively significant impact under CEQA.”
Response No. O1.8
See response to Comment O1.3 above.

Comment No. O1.9
The City’s approach is inconsistent with CEQA’s requirement that the environmental documents include analysis of a project’s direct AND cumulative impact. Under the City’s proposed approach, the DEIR need not undertake any analysis of the project’s cumulative impact on air quality because the results would be identical to the direct impacts analysis. But the point of cumulative impact analysis is to understand the significance of the Project’s incremental impact in light of the magnitude of the environmental problem to which the project would contribute. The MND must “view” the effects of this project in connection with the effects of at least nearby projects.

Response No. O1.9
See response to Comment O1.3 above which discusses the cumulative nature of the adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds as described in GAMAQI. As described, the regional significance thresholds evaluate both project-level impacts and cumulative impacts for the SJVAB.

Moreover, the SJVAPCD, which is the regional public agency that oversees the overall air quality for the SJVAB, reviewed the Draft EIR. While the SJVAPCD provided formal comments on the proposed project in their letter dated August 28, 2026, the comments provided did not raise any objections or concerns regarding the Draft EIR’s cumulative air quality analysis. Due to the role of SJVAPCD as the public agency in overseeing and maintaining air quality in the SJVAB, its expertise in interpreting the GAMAQI which it prepared, and its participation in the review of the Draft EIR, not having any objections or concerns raised in their provided public comments comprise substantial evidence in support of the cumulative air quality analysis of the Draft EIR.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-31
Comment No. O1.10
The DEIR for this project is defective in that it has not computed or addressed the cumulative emissions from this and other planned projects, cumulative emissions which almost certainly would exceed air quality standards and should be considered significant. In the interest of public health, cumulative emissions computations must include emissions from other planned projects, not just from this project.

We include a cumulative list of several of the additional current proposed new projects in the Bakersfield area:
• Table 3-1 of this DEIR lists 51 projects in its list of cumulative projects. • The Bakersfield Commons project is beginning to build just to the south of this project. • Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7471 just across Morning Drive from this project • Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7427
• Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7495
• Vesting Tentative Tract Map Nos. 6839, 6840, 6841, 6842, 6843 and 6844 • Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7450
• Vesting Tentative Tract Maps 7408 and 7415
• General Plan Amendment/Zone Change No. 22-0128; General Plan Amendment No. 23-0345; and Planned Development Review No. 22-0073
• IPG Industrial Project in unincorporated Kern County. The DEIR for the IPG Industrial Park Project lists 51 projects in its list of cumulative projects.
• Expansion of the Wonderful Industrial Park on Seventh Standard Road • Tentative Parcel Map 12447
• General Plan Amendment No. 21-0424
• Conditional Use Permit Case No. 17, Map 121; Zone Variance No. 11, Map 121 (Kern County) • GPA#6, Map #122; ZCC #15, Map #122; PD Plan#11, Map#122 (Kern County) • Rosedale Ranch projects
• Malibu Vineyards warehouse project adjacent to Highway 99 just north of Bakersfield • Hageman Industrial Park
• Veteran’s Administration Outpatient Clinic
There are likely other such projects of which we are not aware.

The cumulative impacts of this project, of those listed above, and of other area projects on air pollution, traffic, energy, climate change, biological resources, and other issues must be thoroughly addressed, including performance standards that are mandatory, specifically defined, and enforceable.

Response No. O1.10
See response to Comment O1.9 above. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-32
Comment No. O1.11
Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 fails to address the cumulative impact of the project on air pollution.

Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 only requires the project to reduce operational VOC and NOX emissions to below SJVAPCD significance thresholds. 10 annual tons of VOC, 10 annual tons of NOx, particulate matter emissions, and construction emissions remain unmitigated. MM AQ-1 must be strengthened to require a VERA with all criteria pollutant emissions reduced to zero, not just below weak and ineffective SJVAPCD significance thresholds. Reducing project emissions to zero through a strong Air District contract would help address the potentially significant cumulative air quality impact of this project.

Response No. O1.11
See Response to Comment O1.9. No changes to the cumulative analysis in the Draft EIR are warranted.

The approach taken in the Draft EIR to evaluate cumulative air quality is supported. Therefore, no changes to MM AQ-1 are required. MM AQ-1 requiring that Project operational emissions of VOC and NOX be offset to a level below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds remains a valid mitigation measure. The Commenter's suggestion that any net increase in emissions, however small, must be treated as a significant cumulative impact is not supported by CEQA case law, agency guidance, or air quality science.

The numeric thresholds developed by SJVAPCD are based on technical and scientific data, rather than a "one molecule" rule. Therefore, the performance standard identified in MM AQ-1 is sufficient to result in less than significant impacts. Additionally, the formal public comments provided by SJVAPCD did not raise any objections to MM AQ-1 and its performance standard or the thresholds used in the Draft EIR to evaluate cumulative impacts.

Comment No. O1.12

BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
One of the basic purposes of CEQA is to “inform governmental decision makers and the public about the potential, significant environmental effects of proposed activities.” (CEQA Guidelines §15006(1).) Here, the DEIR fails to fulfill its informational mandate and does not adequately describe potential impacts on protected species by deferring protocol level surveys and formulation of appropriate mitigation measures.

Post-approval biological surveys do not satisfy CEQA’s informational requirements; the decision-makers need to know the results of the biological surveys in order to assess the Project’s potential biological impacts BEFORE deciding whether to approve the Project. Post-approval surveys cannot inform the City’s decision whether to approve the Project. Moreover, deferred mitigation measures violate CEQA because they lack performance standards to ensure the mitigation goal will be achieved. To address biological resource issues a biological survey and consultation with the USFWS and CDFW should be required before project approval.

Response No. O1.12
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-33
Comment No. O1.13
In the Cumulative Impact Section 5.2 of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (MBGP) Update EIR, it is stated, “MBHCP and implementing agreements and ordinances provide a method of collecting funds for the acquisition and enhancement of habitat lands for purposes of creating preserves. Development projects within the Planning area and County would pay mitigation fees that would be used to buy habitat lands.” Thus the 2002 MBGP depends upon the now-expired Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan (MBHCP) for its biological resource cumulative insignificance conclusion. Now that the MBHCP is no longer in effect, the City can no longer rely on the MBGP and must therefore conduct its own analysis of project impacts on protected species and find alternatives or another way to effectively mitigate significant loss of protected species’ habitat.

Response No. O1.13
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Comment No. O1.14
The DEIR is defective and violates CEQA in that it has not described and assessed the significance of the cumulative effects of ongoing urbanization and habitat loss on protected species. Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Moreover, now that the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan is no longer in effect, the City must find another way to effectively address the Project’s contribution to cumulative habitat loss. Many other current or proposed projects are urbanizing habitat for numerous species (see, e.g., the list in the previous section). Potentially significant cumulative impacts to biological resources and viable mitigation measures for these impacts (including purchase of replacement habitat) should be thoroughly studied and addressed in this EIR.

Response No. O1.14
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Comment No. O1.15
The project property seems to be on and adjacent to potential habitat for a number of species which could forage or exist on the project property. According to Appendix B of the May 2026 General Biological Assessment, regarding the endangered San Joaquin kit fox, “This species was observed during the field survey. This species is present.” The conclusion in Table 4.4-2 of the DEIR that no San Joaquin kit foxes are present on the Project site is clearly in error. Thus, the Project site is habitat for the federally endangered San Joaquin kit fox. The DEIR is defective and violates CEQA and ESA in that it has not addressed San Joaquin kit fox species preservation issues. Consultation with state and federal wildlife agencies must be required, not be left to the developer’s or the biologist’s option.

In the same Appendix B, in regard to the burrowing owl, “This species has the potential to be present.” Response No. O1.15
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-34
Comment No. O1.16
Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Mitigation for habitat loss and potential species take should include Incidental Take Permit acquisition and purchase of replacement habitat.

To help scientifically reinforce the determination that kit fox use the site, a qualified biologist should extract DNA from onsite potential San Joaquin kit fox scat samples, following a procedure published in 2014 by De Barba et al. (De Barba, M., Adams, J. R., Goldberg, C. S., Stansbury, C. R., Arias, D., Cisneros, R., & Waits, L. P. (2014). Molecular species identification for multiple carnivores. Conservation Genetics Resources, 6, 821-824). If the scat actually is kit fox scat, then clearly kit fox inhabit the site, and appropriate mitigation must be applied.

Response No. O1.16
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Comment No. O1.17
While many of these species may have been driven out of the project site by mowing and disking operations, the City should require reintroducing some of the native plant species by replanting them in project open space areas. The project’s landscaping should include drought-tolerant and/or native plants.

According to the publication Conservation Strategies for San Joaquin Kit Foxes in Urban Environments by Brian Cypher, Christine Van Horn Job, and Scott Phillips at http://esrp.csustan.edu/publications/pdf/cypher_etal_2012_urban_kitfox_conservation_esrp.pdf, “To the extent practical and possible, urban planners could design new developments in a manner that facilitates use by kit foxes.” The City should actually require this project to be designed with urban kit fox conservation measures in mind, perhaps including artificial kit fox dens and movement corridors as suggested in the above document. Such a requirement must include performance standards that are mandatory, specifically defined, and enforceable.

Response No. O1.17
This comment is noted for the record. Please see responses to Letter A1.

Comment No. O1.18

CLIMATE CRISIS
There is much important new information on climate change. For example:
• The IPCC AR6 synthesis report (https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/syr/ ) includes warnings that the world is approaching “irreversible” levels of global heating, with catastrophic impacts rapidly becoming inevitable; and that it is “now or never” to take drastic action to avoid disaster. • “A new study has revealed that the language used by the global climate change watchdog, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), is overly conservative - and therefore the threats are much greater than the Panel's reports suggest.” https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/03/190320102010.htm Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-35
• Annual Greenhouse Gas Index (AGGI) - NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory (https://gml.noaa.gov/aggi/) is also substantial and critically important new information. • Harmful tipping points in the natural world pose some of the gravest threats faced by humanity.

Environmental stresses could become so severe that large parts of the natural world are unable to maintain their current state, leading to abrupt and/or irreversible changes. Global Tipping Points | Home (global-tipping-points.org)
• The costs of climate change are enormous and affect every sector of the economy. https://www.law.berkeley.edu/research/clee/research/climate/california-climate-action/costs-of-climate-change/ • UN secretary general, António Guterres, said,” This is climate breakdown, in real time. We must exit this road to ruin, and we have no time to lose.” World endures 'decade of deadly heat' as 2024 caps hottest years on record | Climate crisis | The Guardian California courts have ruled, “the greater the existing environmental problems are, the lower the threshold should be for treating a project’s contribution to cumulative impacts as significant.” The climate crisis is inherently a cumulatively significant issue.

Response No. O1.18
The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.19
California courts have ruled, “the greater the existing environmental problems are, the lower the threshold should be for treating a project’s contribution to cumulative impacts as significant.” The climate crisis is inherently a cumulatively significant issue.

In presumably aligning itself with statewide strategies to reduce GHG emissions, the DEIR is deficient because it fails to acknowledge and analyze the impacts of the Congressional decision (H.J. Res. 88) to revoke the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Air Act waiver to California. Under this waiver, California was able to adopt its own vehicle emission rules in lieu of federal standards. Relying on the waiver, California mandated that beginning in year 2026, zero emission vehicles must constitute 35% of each auto manufacturer’s sales of new motor vehicles. According to California regulations, by 2035 sales of new, fully gas-powered vehicles would have effectively been prohibited in California. California’s waiver that led to the regulation of low-nitrogen oxide emissions from heavy-duty highway and off-road vehicles was also revoked.

Without the ability to gradually phase out carbon-emitting cars and trucks, California will not be able to meet its greenhouse gas emission targets, which in turn would require greater emission reductions from every other sector, which could only be implemented through increasingly strict GHG mitigation measures. The City’s reliance on these State measures is problematic. The DEIR fails to discuss the Federal Government’s revocation of California’s ability to set strict car and truck emission standards.

State energy requirements are under constant attack by the Trump administration (see, for example, Trump cuts nearly $8B in clean energy projects in targeted states | AP News ). The One Big Beautiful Bill Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-36
Act terminates the investment and production tax credits for wind and solar by the end of 2027. The City’s reliance on these energy measures is problematic. The DEIR fails to discuss the impact on state and local plans of the Federal Government’s attacks and revocation of funding for California’s renewable energy projects.

Since the City has shelved adopting a Climate Action Plan, it must be extra diligent in assuring that individual projects like this one satisfy state goals and regulations and legal requirements through adoption of feasible mitigation.

Response No. O1.19
The commenter’s summary of the recent actions under House Joint Resolution 88 (H.J. Res. 88) is acknowledged. Although the Draft EIR does not specifically identify H.J. Res. 88, it does discuss the actions it undertook by stating that the U.S. Senate voted to revoke the waiver granted by the Biden Administration for the Advanced Clean Cars II (ACC II) program through congressional resolution.

California is currently in litigation over H.J. Res. 88 in addition to H.J. Res. 89, challenging the legality of these congressional resolutions that were used to revoke the waivers for ACC II and other California regulations such as the Omnibus Low NOX regulation. Recently, in a separate lawsuit California brought against the US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), the US District Court issued an injunction against the US EPA prohibiting them from reclassifying four of California’s waivers as federal rules to allow these waivers to be reviewed by Congress under the Congressional Review Act. This injunction also prevents future attempts by the US EPA to reclassify other California waivers as federal rules.

Regarding any cuts on green energy investments that may be or were made under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, they would not affect the requirement of the proposed Project to comply with the Building Energy Efficiency Standards and the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen). Due to the ongoing litigation and general uncertainty surrounding the political landscape, it would be speculative to forecast the effect of this future litigation on future emissions models. No changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O1.20
SB 32 requires that statewide greenhouse gas emissions be reduced to 40% below the 1990 level by 2030.

Executive Order B-30-15 targets a GHG reduction of 40% below 1990 levels by 2030, codified in SB 32.

Executive Order S-3-05 sets an 80% reduction of GHG from 1990 levels in 2050 as a goal. The DEIR must address these requirements.

Response No. O1.20
The Draft EIR utilizes a net zero threshold to evaluate potential greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions impacts of the proposed Project. This net zero threshold approach aligns with the long-term year 2045 State neutrality goal under Assembly Bill 1279 and is a more stringent goal compared to the state reduction goals and targets under Senate Bill 32 and Executive Order (EO) S-03-05. By utilizing a net zero threshold, the Draft EIR directly addresses the requirements and reduction goals and targets of SB 32 and EO S-03-05.

Furthermore, the Draft EIR evaluates consistency of the proposed Project to the latest California Air Resources Board (CARB) Scoping Plan on page 4.8-22. The latest CARB Scoping Plan provides a roadmap for California to achieve the SB 32 GHG reduction target. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-37
Comment No. O1.21
The DEIR considers the project’s adverse project-specific and cumulative climate change impacts to be significant. Even after the required mitigation, the project will emit 15,926 MTCO2e annually according to Table 4.8-3. In order to satisfy CEQA requirements and not leave an overheated planet for future generations, the City must adopt all feasible mitigation to reduce this adverse significant impact. Feasible potential additional mitigation measures include:
• A requirement to purchase carbon offset credits incorporating recognized principles of GHG emissions reduction accounting in an amount equal to the estimated CO2e emissions for the life of the project. The credits should be issued by a CARB-approved registry using CARB-approved protocol.
• A requirement that all buildings contain enough solar photovoltaics (PV) and solar water heating to offset energy usage to the maximum extent feasible, with a capacity that matches the maximum allowed for distributed solar connections to the grid. • Green building measures should be required for all structures, including passive solar design and a requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards current when permits are pulled.
• Use all electric appliances, without any natural gas connections, and not use propane or other fossil fuels for space heating, water heating, or indoor cooking. (from CARB 2022 scoping plan) • Relax parking requirements as in the CARB 2022 scoping plan. • To help address the housing crisis, encourage public transit, and lower VMT, the project should include high density housing affordable to lower-income residents. (from CARB 2022 scoping plan) • A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production. • Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots. • To reinforce and clarify MM GHG-7 and in order to encourage the use of non-polluting electric vehicles, the City should specifically require parking lots for all facets of this project to include dedicated EV parking and charging, including tiers of multiple type fast charge Level 3 EV charging facilities. The stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project.
• A requirement that the developer contribute to tree planting and urban forestry projects. Tree planting plays an essential role in achieving the goal of reaching net zero GHG emissions. One recent study found that California’s working and urban lands have the potential to absorb up to 103 MMT CO2e additional per year by 2030. https://theclimatecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/The-Climate-Center-Setting-an-Ambitious-Sequestration-Goal-for-CA-WL-Jan-22.pdf • Facilitate and promote public transit by providing amenities such as contributing to public transit, facilitating ride-share programs, create incentives for ride-share and/or use of public transit.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-38
• A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere.

The environmental documents must evaluate these and other potential mitigation measures in order to require sufficient mitigation to substantially reduce the significant impact of the project on the climate crisis. Many of these measures serve as well for air pollution mitigation.

Response No. O1.21
The following provides responses to each of the recommended measures presented by the commenter.

1. A requirement to purchase carbon offset credits incorporating recognized principles of GHG emissions reduction accounting in an amount equal to the estimated CO2e emissions for the life of the project. The credits should be issued by a CARB-approved registry using CARB-approved protocol.

A carbon offset program for purposes of CEQA mitigation consists of several components. Voluntary carbon offsets must be purchased through a registry approved by CARB and the voluntary carbon offset credits made available by a registry must use CARB-approved protocols, or equivalent protocols if not CARB-approved. The voluntary carbon offset credits must also demonstrate that the GHG reductions they achieve are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, additional, and enforceable as set forth in California Health and Safety Code Section 38562(d)(1) and (d)(2) and Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations Section 95802(a). Furthermore, there should be a local geographical hierarchy preference (i.e., city, county, state, and country) from where a carbon offset originates.

Despite this stringent criteria, recent caselaw invalidated the use of voluntary carbon offsets for CEQA. (Golden Door Properties v. County of San Diego (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th 467.). Pursuant to this decision, use of voluntary carbon offsets created an unenforceable performance standard and improperly deferred and delegated mitigation. The “Compliance” market (i.e., CARB’s Carbon Offset Program) accounts for most of the carbon offset available in California. Thus, voluntary carbon offsets are likely to come from out-of-state or even out of the country. As a result, use of voluntary carbon offsets may not be considered to mitigate for GHG emissions in California and foreign markets may not have the same rigorous accounting protocols to ensure long-term enforceability of the voluntary carbon credits. For example, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD), which is the only air district to provide guidance on use of offsets in their 2022 CEQA Air Quality Guidelines, specifically states that GHG reductions be achieved by direct-GHG reductions and that reductions taking place outside of the community should be minimized (BAAQMD 2023). BAAQMD cited the findings of the Golden Door case, flagging concerns regarding offsets arising outside California and noting that such offsets, if permitted, should be subject to enforcement mechanisms at least as strict and enforceable as under California law. For these reasons, the City has determined that voluntary carbon offsets would not be an effective mitigation strategy for the Project.

2. A requirement that all buildings contain enough solar photovoltaics (PV) and solar water heating to offset energy usage to the maximum extent feasible, with a capacity that matches the maximum allowed for distributed solar connections to the grid.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-39
The proposed Project would comply with the photovoltaic and battery storage requirements of the Building Energy Efficiency Standards. The Draft EIR prescribes MM GHG-1, which, except for commercial cooking uses, would require buildings to be designed and built as all-electric, in addition to requiring that all major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. This measure would provide increased building energy efficiency compared to a standard mixed-fuel building.

Furthermore, the Draft EIR includes MM GHG-2, which requires the property owner to enroll in an available 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, or the next highest carbon-free electricity plan available if a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available.

3. Green building measures should be required for all structures, including passive solar design and a requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards current when permits are pulled.

As discussed above, the Draft EIR prescribes MM GHG-1, which, except for commercial cooking uses, would require buildings to be designed and built as all-electric in addition to requiring major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. This measure would provide increased building energy efficiency compared to a standard mixed-fuel building.

4. Use all electric appliances, without any natural gas connections, and not use propane or other fossil fuels for space heating, water heating, or indoor cooking. (from CARB 2022 scoping plan) The Draft EIR has prescribed MM GHG-1. Under this mitigation measure, except for commercial cooking uses, buildings would be designed and constructed as all-electric and major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. In addition, the Draft EIR includes MM GHG-2, which requires the property owner to enroll in an available 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, or the next highest carbon-free electricity plan available if a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available.

5. Relax parking requirements as in the CARB 2022 scoping plan.

While the proposed Project would comply with the standard applicable City of Bakersfield Municipal Code parking requirements, the Draft EIR prescribes mitigation measures that would encourage and support active and public transit in addition to electric vehicles. MM GHG-5 would require the Project proponent to coordinate with the Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements (e.g., bus shelter) for up to two bus stops. Additionally, the Draft EIR also prescribes MM GHG-6, which would require designing and installing an end-of-trip shower facility at the Project Site. Implementation of MM GHG-7 would require the Project to comply with the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) Voluntary Tier 2 electric vehicle (EV) parking standards, which would result in the installation of EV infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements.

6. To help address the housing crisis, encourage public transit, and lower VMT, the project should include high density housing affordable to lower-income residents. (from CARB 2022 scoping plan) Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-40
The property is bound by a legally recorded Covenant and Agreement to Restrict use of Property Environmental Restriction (Environmental Covenant), dated February 6, 2019, recorded as Document No. 219013583 in the Official Records of Kern County. Per this Environmental Covenant, residential uses are restricted under Section 4.01(2).

7. A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production.

As discussed, the proposed Project would comply with the photovoltaic and battery storage requirements of the Building Energy Efficiency Standards. The Draft EIR prescribes MM GHG-1, which, except for commercial cooking uses, would require buildings to be designed and built as all-electric, in addition to requiring major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. This measure would provide increased building energy efficiency compared to a standard mixed-fuel building.

Furthermore, the Draft EIR includes MM GHG-2, which requires the property owner to enroll in an available 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, or the next highest carbon-free electricity plan available if a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available.

8. Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots.

The proposed Project would plant up to a total of 656 trees onsite (534 trees) and on its frontages along Rosedale Highway (43 trees) and Coffee Road (79 trees), which would provide shading and cooling.

9. To reinforce and clarify MM GHG-7 and in order to encourage the use of non-polluting electric vehicles, the City should specifically require parking lots for all facets of this project to include dedicated EV parking and charging, including tiers of multiple type fast charge Level 3 EV charging facilities. The stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project.

In complying with MM GHG-7, the proposed Project would be dedicated to include a mix of 1 Level 2 chargers and 12 fast-charging Level 3 chargers. Additionally, and as discussed, the proposed project would be designed and built to the Building Energy Efficiency Standards and comply with its photovoltaic and battery storage requirements. Furthermore, the proposed Project would plant up to a total of 656 trees onsite (534 trees) and on its frontages along Rosedale Highway (43 trees) and Coffee Road (79 trees), which would provide shading and cooling.

10. A requirement that the developer contribute to tree planting and urban forestry projects. Tree planting plays an essential role in achieving the goal of reaching net zero GHG emissions. One recent study found that California’s working and urban lands have the potential to absorb up to 103 MMT CO2e additional per year by 2030. https://theclimatecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/The-Climate-Center-Setting-an-Ambitious-Sequestration-Goal-for-CA-WL-Jan-22.pdf As noted, the Project would plant up to a total of 656 trees onsite (534 trees) and on its frontages along Rosedale Highway (43 trees) and Coffee Road (79 trees).

11. Facilitate and promote public transit by providing amenities such as contributing to public transit, facilitating ride-share programs, create incentives for ride-share and/or use of public transit.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-41
The Draft EIR includes MM GHG-5, which would require the Project proponent to coordinate with the Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements for up to two bus stops. Additionally, the Draft EIR also prescribes MM GHG-6, which would require designing and installing an end-of-trip shower facility at the Project Site. Furthermore, as noted on page 4.8-18 of the Draft EIR, future individual businesses would be subject to the SJVAPCD Rule 9410 Employer Based Trip Reduction program. Under Rule 9410, businesses that meet the number of employee criteria would be required to achieve a minimum number of points under the Rule. These businesses would be required to prepare an Employer Trip Reduction Implementation Plan (eTRIP) and submit it to SJVAPCD. An eTRIP would be required to demonstrate how a business would meet its points obligations and also detail the specific transportation demand management measures available under Rule 9410 that would be implemented to achieve the requisite number of points needed. Available TDM measures under Rule 9410 include measures such as vanpool/carpool program, transit subsidy, and telecommuting program.

12. A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere.

The mitigation strategies in the Draft EIR prioritize feasible GHG reductions that would be applicable to the Project Site. The City is not the entity with the authority to establish a fund to reduce GHG emissions outside of the city boundary. A regional entity, like SJVAPCD would be the most appropriate agency to implement such a program. Furthermore, it is unknown whether the reductions from such a fee program would meet the rigorous criteria of CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(c)(3) that would result in GHG reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional. Therefore, the City has considered and rejected establishment of a GHG fee as mitigation for CEQA impacts.

Comment No. O1.22
Please place the Sierra Club on the distribution list for this project to receive any noticing of meetings, hearings, availability of documents, and to receive the environmental documents. We prefer email communications and electronic formatting of documents. Thank you for your consideration and for the opportunity to comment.

Response No. O1.22
The comment is noted for the record. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-42
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-43
Comment Letter O2
Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph and Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080-7037
August 26, 2026
Responses to Letter O2
Comment No. O2.1
We are writing on behalf of Californians Allied for a Responsible Economy (“CARE CA”) regarding the Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”) prepared by the City of Bakersfield (“City”) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507) (“Project”), proposed by DJM Capital Partners (“Applicant”).

The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center, that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space.1It is assumed that larger anchor interior buildings within the Project site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station. Discretionary approvals required to implement the Project include Site Plan Review, General Plan Amendment (“GPA”) changing the land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial), Tentative Tract Map, and Comprehensive Sign Plan.2
Footnotes:

1. DEIR, p. ES-1

2. DEIR. P. ES-2
Response No. O2.1
This introductory comment introducing the commenter and providing an overview of the Project Description is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.2
We reviewed the DEIR with the assistance of air quality expert Dr. James Clark3and transportation expert Norm Marshall.4The City must separately respond to these technical comments. CARE CA’s review of the DEIR demonstrates that the DEIR fails to comply with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”).

Footnotes:

3. Dr. Clark’stechnical comments and curricula vitae (“Clark Comments”) are attached hereto as Exhibit A.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-44

4. Mr. Marshall’s technical comments and curricula vitae (“Marshall Comments”) are attached hereto as Exhibit B.

Response No. O2.2
This commenter asserts that the Draft EIR fails to meet the requirements of CEQA. As demonstrated in the responses below, this assertion is not supported by any substantial evidence. This comment is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. The comment is acknowledged and no further response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.3
In summary, the DEIR fails to address potentially significant public health risks by omitting discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever risks. Soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres could expose workers and residents to severe health hazards, but the DEIR does not disclose or mitigate this risk. This risk is especially acute given that Valley Fever is endemic to the area, with 1,848 cases reported in Kern County in 2026 alone.5
Footnotes:

5. Clark Comments, p. 12.

Response No. O2.3
The commenter shares concerns that impacts related to Coccidioides Immitis (“C. Immitis” or “Valley fever”) have not been adequately disclosed and mitigated in the Draft EIR.

While Valley Fever is associated with soil disturbance, impacts associated with Valley Fever are related to the Coccidioides fungal spore, which is a biological agent. In general, a CEQA-level air quality framework and analysis evaluates potential impacts associated with criteria air pollutants and toxic air contaminants, which are chemical pollutants. However, ground disturbing activities can aerosolize fungal spores present in project soils, creating a potential inhalation exposure pathway. Risk is generally elevated during dry, windy conditions and in years following drought (dry soil is more easily aerosolized), and disturbance of previously undisturbed or long-undisturbed soils poses higher risk than disturbance of soils that have been recently worked. Fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impactsfrom Valley Fever. Because the proposed Project is a non-residential project that would disrupt more than five acres of land, it would be subject to San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) Rule 8021 to minimize fugitive dust during construction activities.

As discussed on page 4.3-20 of the Draft EIR, the Project would comply with SJVAPCD Rule 8021, which requires the preparation of Dust Control Plan that must be submitted to SJVAPCD prior to the start of any construction activity. The Dust Control Plan must specifically describe fugitive dust control measures to be implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity. Some of the control measures could include regular watering of the Project Site, limiting on-site vehicle speeds, and sweeping paved streets. Compliance with SJVAPCD Rule 8021 and the General Plan would control and minimize the potential release of Valley fever spores.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-45
In addition, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed Project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupational safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices. Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employees when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the Project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to this Section.

Overall, as set forth in the Draft EIR, implementation of SJVAPCD fugitive dust control measures and compliance with workplace Occupational Safety and Health requirements and Cal/OSHA oversight would minimize potential Valley Fever exposure to construction workers and no significant impacts would occur.

No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.4
The DEIR also fails to disclose, quantitatively analyze, and mitigate significant public health risks from exposure to Toxic Air Contaminants (“TACs”). The Project's proposed fuel station, char broilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic will emit TACs, yet the DEIR relies on unsupported qualitative heuristics– rather than preparing a formal Health Risk Assessment (“HRA”)–to quantify operational health risk impacts. Furthermore, the DEIR fails to analyze cumulative health risk impacts in conjunction with nearby planned projects and the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.6 Footnotes:

6. Clark Comments, p. 10.

Response No. O2.4
See response to comments O2.16 for the response addressing the comment regarding the Draft EIR’s operational health risk analysis and responses to Comments O2.26 through O2.28 for the response addressing the comment regarding evaluation of nearby projects and the existing environmental pollution burden for PM2.5.

Comment No. O2.5
In addition, the DEIR fails to identify all feasible mitigation for operational air quality impacts (VOCs and NOx). It improperly relies on a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (“VERA”) prior to exhausting all feasible onsite mitigation measures, such as requiring under-fired char broiler controls or enforcing reduced diesel truck idling limits. Regarding transportation impacts, the DEIR contains several errors that underestimate vehicle trip generation and fails to mitigate significant Vehicle Miles Traveled (“VMT”) Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-46
impacts. Despite finding significant and unavoidable VMT impacts, the DEIR fails to require all feasible VMT mitigation, such as Commute Trip Reduction programs in the California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (“CAPCOA”) Handbook. And regarding public utilities, the DEIR lacks analysis of the adequacy of existing infrastructure to provide adequate fire flow to the Project site.

Response No. O2.5
Regarding commenter’s assertion that the Draft EIR improperly relies on a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) (Mitigation Measure AQ-1) prior to exhausting all feasible onsite mitigation measures, the City disagrees with this assertion as explained in the Draft EIR. The Draft EIR prescribes MM AQ-2 in addition to MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7.
• Building and Energy-related Mitigation Measures that Reduce Emissions. Implementation of MM AQ-2 would require architectural paints and coatings to have a VOC content of 25 grams per liter or less, which would contribute to reducing VOC emissions. Under MM GHG-1, except for commercial cooking uses, buildings would be designed and constructed as all-electric. Thus, this measure would reduce onsite energy sector criteria air pollutant emissions, including VOCs and NOX, by reducing or eliminating onsite combustion of natural gas. Additionally, MM GHG-2, requires the property owner to enroll in an available 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, or the next highest carbon-free electricity plan available if a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available. Furthermore, MM GHG-3 requires landscaping equipment used in property management to be electric-powered only and would also contribute to reducing criteria air pollutant emissions.
• Transportation-related Mitigation Measures that Reduce Emissions. For transportation-related measures, MM GHG-5 would require the Project proponent to coordinate with the Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements for up to two bus stops. Under MM GHG-6, an end-of-trip shower facility would be installed at the Project Site. These two measures would help promote and encourage public and active transit and contribute to reducing single-occupancy vehicle trips.

Lastly, implementation of MM GHG-7 would require the Project to comply with the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) Voluntary Tier 2 electric vehicle (EV) parking standards, which would result in the installation of EV infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements.

Thus, the Draft EIR has identified meaningful mitigation measures that would contribute to reducing criteria air pollutant emissions and of which would be supplemented by the VERA under MM AQ-1. The commenter has not identified additional feasible mitigation measures that would meaningfully reduce project-related emissions. Additionally, use of a VERA is a generally accepted and recommended mitigation measure by SJVAPCD to address operation-related regional air quality impacts. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

To ensure that potential health risks posed by possible under-fired charbroilers do not result in a significant impact, a Condition of Approval to the site plan will be added to require that should a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler be proposed within the Project Site, a health risk assessment shall be required. Furthermore, if it is determined that health risk impacts would exceed the SJVAPCD’s 20 in a Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-47
million for cancer risk threshold and/or hazard index of 1, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these identified performance standards.

Comment No. O2.6
As a result of its shortcomings, the DEIR lacks substantial evidence to support its conclusions, violates CEQA’s analytical requirements, and fails to properly mitigate the Project’s significant environmental impacts. CARE CA urges the City to remedy the deficiencies in the DEIR by preparing a legally adequate revised DEIR and recirculating it for public review and comment.7 CARE CA reserves the right to provide supplemental comments at any and all later proceedings related to this Project.8 Footnotes:

7. We reserve the right to supplement these comments at later hearings on this Project. Gov. Code § 65009(b); Public Resources Code § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184, 1199–1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal.App.4th 1109, 1121.

8. Gov. Code § 65009(b); PRC § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal. App. 4th 1184, 1199-1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal. App. 4th 1109, 1121.

Response No. O2.6
This commenter asserts that the Draft EIR is inadequate but provides no evidence supporting this conclusory claim. Therefore, no further response or changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.7
I. STATEMENT OF INTEREST
CARE CA is non-profit organization which advocates for protecting the environment and the health of their communities’ workforces. The organization’s members include the District Council of Ironworkers and Southern California Pipe Trades DC 16, along with their members, their families, and other individuals who live and work in the City of Bakersfield and in Kern County. These individuals and labor organization members may be adversely affected by the potential public and worker health and safety hazards, and the environmental impacts of the Project.

CARE CA seeks to ensure a sustainable construction industry over the long-term by supporting projects that offer genuine economic and employment benefits, and which minimize adverse environmental and other impacts on local communities. CARE CA members live, work, recreate, and raise their families in the City of Bakersfield and surrounding communities. Accordingly, they would be directly affected by the Project’s environmental and health and safety impacts. Individual members may also work on the Project itself. They will be first in line to be exposed to any health and safety hazards that exist onsite.

In addition, CARE CA has an interest in enforcing environmental laws that encourage sustainable development and ensure a safe working environment for its members. Environmentally detrimental Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-48
projects can jeopardize future jobs by making it more difficult and more expensive for business and industry to expand in the region, and by making the area less desirable for new businesses and new residents. Indeed, continued environmental degradation can, and has, caused construction moratoriums and other restrictions on growth that, in turn, reduce future employment opportunities.

Response No. O2.7
This comment provides a background on CARE CA and their interests. The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.8
II. THE DEIR FAILS TO DISCLOSE, ANALYZE AND MITIGATE POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS An EIR must fully disclose all potentially significant impacts of a Project and implement all feasible mitigation to reduce those impacts to less than significant levels. The lead agency’s significance determination with regard to each impact must be supported by accurate scientific and factual data.9 An agency cannot conclude that an impact is less than significant unless it produces rigorous analysis and concrete substantial evidence justifying the finding.10 Footnotes:

9. CEQA Guidelines § 15064(b).

10. Kings Cty. Farm Bur. v. Hanford (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 692, 732.

Response No. O2.8
The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.9
Even when the substantial evidence standard is applicable to agency decisions to certify an EIR and approve a project, reviewing courts will not ‘uncritically rely on every study or analysis presented by a project proponent in support of its position. A clearly inadequate or unsupported study is entitled to no judicial deference.’”11
Footnotes:

11. Kings Cty. Farm Bur. v. Hanford (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 692, 732.

Response No. O2.9
The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-49
Comment No. O2.10
Moreover, the failure to provide information required by CEQA is a failure to proceed in the manner required by CEQA.12 Challenges to an agency’s failure to proceed in the manner required by CEQA, such as the failure to address a subject required to be covered in an EIR or to disclose information about a project’s environmental effects or alternatives, are subject to a less deferential standard than challenges to an agency’s factual conclusions.13 In reviewing challenges to an agency’s approval of an EIR based on a lack of substantial evidence, the court will “determine de novo whether the agency has employed the correct procedures, scrupulously enforcing all legislatively mandated CEQA requirements.”14 Footnotes:

12. Sierra Club v. State Bd. Of Forestry (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1215, 1236.

13. Vineyard Area Citizens for Responsible Growth, Inc. v. City of Rancho Cordova (2007) 40 Cal.4th 412, 435.

14. Id., Madera Oversight Coal., Inc. v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 102.

Response No. O2.10
The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.11
Additionally, CEQA requires agencies to commit to all feasible mitigation measures to reduce significant environmental impacts.15 In particular, the lead agency may not make required CEQA findings, including finding that a project impact is significant and unavoidable, unless the administrative record demonstrates that it has adopted all feasible mitigation to reduce significant environmental impacts to the greatest extent feasible.16
Footnotes:

15. CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2).

16. PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883.

Response No. O2.11
The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.12
The DEIR fails to disclose, analyze, and mitigate exposure to Coccidiodes Immitis (Valley Fever cocci) that may be disturbed during construction activities. The DEIR fails to include any discussion or mitigation of this impact, which poses potentially significant health risks to workers and nearby residences.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-50
Dr. Clark explains that when soil containing cocci spores are disturbed by construction activities, the fungal spores become airborne, exposing construction workers and other nearby sensitive receptors.17 Valley Fever is the initial form of coccidioidomycosis infection, and can develop into a more serious disease, including chronic and disseminated coccidioidomycosis.18 This puts workers and nearby residents at risk, particularly during earth-disturbing activities.19 Airborne spores could be blown into the residential communities near the Project site.

Valley Fever risks are potentially significant for development of this Project site because Valley Fever is endemic to the area and the Project would disturb over 46 acres. Dr. Clark reviewed data demonstrating that Kern County has among the highest rates of Valley Fever (coccidioidomycosis) in California, with 1,848 cases of Valley Fever reported just in 2026.20
Footnotes:

17. Clark Comments, p. 12.

18. Mayo Clinic, Valley Fever Overview, https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/valley-fever/symptoms-causes/syc-20378761.

19. Clark Comments, p. 13.

20. Id. at 12.

Response No. O2.12
Please refer to Response O2.3. The commenter identifies concern about potential exposure to Valley Fever spores during construction-related soil disturbance and provides general information regarding how construction activities can distribute Valley Fever spores and information of the number of cases in Kern County. No further response is required; however, this comment is noted for the record and has been forwarded to Project decision-makers for their review and consideration. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.13
The DEIR is inadequate as an informational document because it fails to disclose a significant effect on public health. CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(4) provides that the City is required to find that a project will have a significant impact on the environment if the environmental effects of a project will cause a substantial adverse effect on human beings.21 Workers’ and nearby residents’ potential exposure to Valley Fever from Project construction activities constitutes a substantial adverse effect on human beings.

Footnotes:

21. PRC § 21083(b)(3), (d); see Cal. Build. Indust. Ass’n v. BAAQMD (2015) 62 Cal.4th 369, 388-90 (“CBIA v.

BAAQMD”) (disturbance of toxic soil contamination at projectsite is potentially significant.

Response No. O2.13
As discussed on page 4.3-20 of the Draft EIR, the Project would comply with SJVAPCD Rule 8021, which requires the preparation of Dust Control Plan that must be submitted to SJVAPCD prior to the start of any construction activity. The Dust Control Plan must specifically describe fugitive dust control measures to Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-51
be implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity. Some of the control measures could include regular watering of the Project Site, limiting on-site vehicle speeds, and sweeping paved streets. Compliance with SJVAPCD Rule 8021 and the General Plan would control and minimize the potential release of Valley Fever spores.

In addition, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed Project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupational safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices. Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employees when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the Project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to this Section.

Overall, as set forth in the Draft EIR, implementation of SJVAPCD fugitive dust control measures and compliance with workplace Occupational Safety and Health requirements and Cal/OSHA oversight would minimize potential Valley Fever exposure to construction workers and no significant impacts would occur.

No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2.14
The DEIR also fails to accurately describe the environmental setting. CEQA requires that a lead agency include a description of the physical environmental conditions in the vicinity of the Project as they exist at the time environmental review commences.22 Use of the proper baseline is critical to a meaningful assessment of a project’s environmental impacts.23 By failing to disclose existing Valley Fever incident rates and failing to assess the potential for Valley Fever spores in soil at the Project site, the DEIR fails to accurately evaluate the likelihood of exposure to Valley Fever cocci.

Footnote:

22. CEQA Guidelines, § 15125, subd. (a).

23. Communitiesfor a Better Environment v. South CoastAirQuality ManagementDistrict(2010) 48 Ca.4th 310, 320.

Response No. O2.14
Please refer to Response O2.3.

Comment No. O2.15
The DEIR also fails to mitigate this potentially significant impact. Dr. Clark explains that compliance with standard dust control regulations such as SJVAPCD Regulation VIII / Rule 8021 does not meaningfully reduce Valley Fever risks.24 Conventional dust control measures do not prevent the spread Valley Fever Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-52
because they largely focus on visible dust or larger dust particles—the PM10 fraction—not the very fine particles where the Valley Fever spores are found.25 Dr. Clark proposes feasible and effective mitigation measures that must be considered in a revised DEIR that acknowledges the potentially significant risk of exposure to Valley Fever.26
In sum, the DEIR must be revised to disclose and mitigate this impact in a recirculated EIR.

Footnotes:

24. Clark Comments, p. 12.

25. Clark Comments, p. 13.

26. Id. at 13-16.

Response No. O2.15
Please refer to Response O2.3. In addition to the required Dust Control Plan, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through Cal/OSHA oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed Project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupational safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices. Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 of California Code of Regulations Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employees when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the Project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to this Section.

Comment No. O2.16
B. The DEIR Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Health Risk Impacts From Project Operations

1. The DEIR Fails to Analyze Health Risks from the Project’s Operational Emissions The Project proposes uses that would generate Toxic Air Contaminants (“TACs”).27 TACs would be emitted by a proposed fuel station, car wash, char broilers used in restaurants, and heavy-duty trucks.28 The DEIR finds that health risks from exposure to these emissions would be less than significant, relying on several qualitative arguments.29 The DEIR argues that health risks can be expected to be less than significant because the Project proposes retail uses, not industrial or warehousing uses.30 The DEIR also argues that the Project would not run afoul of CARB land use siting guidelines, which recommend against siting sensitive land uses within 500 feet of urban roadways and freeways with 100,000 vehicles per day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles per day.31 And the DEIR argues that stationary source emissions would be subject to further study when applying for air permits.32 These arguments do not rise to the level of substantial evidence and do not meet CEQA’s informational standards.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-53
Footnotes:

27. TACs such as DPM have been linked to a range of serious health problems including an increase in respiratory disease, lung damage, cancer, and premature death. SCAQMD, Classification of Diesel PM as a Carcinogen, https://www.aqmd.gov/home/rules-compliance/compliance/toxic-hot-spots-ab-2588/iws-facilities/dice/dice-b2; OEHHA, Health Effects of Diesel Exhaust (May 21, 2001), https://oehha.ca.gov/media/downloads/calenviroscreen/indicators/diesel4-02.pdf.

28. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

29. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

30. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

31. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

32. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

Response No. O2.16
The general summary provided by the commenter on the health risk analysis associated with the proposed fuel station, car wash, char-broilers, and heavy-duty trucks is acknowledged. However, the City disagrees with the assertion by commenter that the Draft EIR’s analysis does not rise to the level of substantial evidence and does not meet CEQA’s informational standards.

Overall, the operational health risk analysis starting on page 4.3-31 of the Draft EIR relies on guidance established by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) and regulatory requirements adopted by SJVAPCD. CARB is the state agency that oversees the overall air quality for the state and SJVAPCD is the regional public agency that oversees air quality for the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin of which the Project Site is within. The Draft EIR references the land use compatibility screening criteria for gas stations, warehouses, and busy roadways and freeways established in CARB’s Air Quality and Land Use Handbook (Handbook) (CARB 2005).

Under CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(b)(1), the determination by a lead agency of whether a project may have a significant impact on the environment calls for careful judgement based on scientific and factual data. CARB’s Handbook is a general reference guide for evaluating potential health effects associated with siting sensitive receptors proximate to sources of toxic air contaminants (TACs). It was developed by CARB, and the Handbook’s land use screening criteria (e.g., for gas stations, warehouses, and busy roadways) was derived based on health studies and data compiled by CARB.

Thus, in consideration of these two factors, the Handbook’s land use screening criteria is considered to be based on valid scientific and factual data. Furthermore, these two factors support that the Handbook’s land use screening criteria and its use is supported by substantial evidence under CEQA Guidelines Section 15384(b), which defines substantial evidence as, “facts, reasonable assumptions predicated upon facts, and expert opinion supported by facts.” Therefore, use of CARB’s Handbook in assessing potential operation-related health risk impacts associated with the proposed gas station and Project-related heavy-duty trucks is supported by substantial evidence and appropriate.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-54
Furthermore, the Draft EIR evaluated the specific conditions of the proposed Project to the CARB Handbook land use screening criteria. As discussed in the Draft EIR on page 4.3-31, the nearest sensitive receptors would be 650 feet from the proposed gas station location and would be beyond the CARB Handbook’s 500-foot screening distance for a gas station. Per the CARB Handbook, the risk levels for a gas station with an annual gasoline throughput of 3,600,000 gallons per year (gpy) is about 10 in a million at a distance of 50 feet from the fenceline and drops to less than 5 in million at a distance of 100 feet from the fenceline and near to 1 in a million at a distance of 500 feet from the fenceline (CARB 2005).

Additionally, the CARB Handbook also notes that the risk levels for gas stations associated with large wholesale and discount centers, which can have an average annual throughput of 9,000,000 gpy, is 25 in a million at 50, but decreases to 5 in a million at 300 feet (CARB 2005).

Additionally, the Draft EIR also evaluated the potential health risk impacts of heavy-duty trucks traveling along roadways to the CARB Handbook siting criteria for busy roadways and freeways. Pursuant to the CARB Handbook screening criteria for busy roadways and freeways, it is recommended that sensitive receptors should avoid being sited within 500 feet of urban roadways and freeways with 100,000 vehicles per day. As discussed in the Draft EIR (see pages 4.3-31 and 4.3-32), the highest projected roadway volume generated by operation of the proposed Project along the local roadways would be 5,934 average daily trips (ADT) for the segment of Coffee Road between Jet Way and Brimhall Road. This volume includes all vehicle types such as passenger vehicles and heavy-duty delivery trucks associated with operation of the proposed Project. Overall, Project-related roadway volume of 5,934 ADTs would be substantially below the CARB Handbook screening roadway volumes. Additionally, because the proposed Project would not have any warehousing uses and would primarily consist of retail, restaurant, and commercial uses, it can be reasonably anticipated that Project-related trips would primarily consist of passenger vehicles associated with patrons. Per the KernCOG regional model and the vehicle trip fleet mix it internally generated for the Project in its calculation of the Project VMT, Project-related heavy-duty truck trips comprise only 0.15 percent (i.e., 23 average daily trips [ADTs] of 14,904 ADT) of the total Project-generated trips. When applied to the anticipated total weekday and weekend Project-generated ADTs that would range between 18,921 ADTs to 28,479 ADTs, this fleet mix percentage results in 29 to 44 heavy-duty truck trips per day. Furthermore, when considering the total roadway volumes under buildout year with Project conditions that account for both ambient volumes and Project-generated volumes, the highest roadway volume, which would occur on the segment of Coffee Road between Brimhall Road and the Westside Parkway eastbound ramp, would be 62,948 ADTs and also fall below the 100,000 vehicles per day screening criterion.

Regarding potential health risk impacts associated with a land use development project, potential impacts may typically be associated with onsite stationary sources and/or from exhaust diesel particulate matter (DPM) generated from diesel-powered mobile equipment such as diesel-powered heavy-duty trucks and off-road equipment used for daily business operations. As discussed in the Draft EIR, the Project would develop primarily retail and non-warehousing commercial uses such as restaurants. While these uses would on occasion have vendor deliveries from diesel-powered heavy-duty trucks, they are not logistics land uses. Thus, the number of heavy-duty trucks associated with the Project would not be at the frequency or volume of a warehouse project.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-55
For stationary sources associated with the Project (e.g., fuel dispensing and charbroilers) that may contribute to health risk impacts, these sources would be controlled through the SJVAPCD permitting process as discussed in the Draft EIR and through compliance with SJVAPCD regulatory requirements.

It should be noted that the Project does not specifically include charbroilers. Tenants within the commercialshopping center have not been identified. The environmental analysis in the Draft EIR is based on the level of information available; the presence of charbroilers within the Project Site is considered speculative and therefore, not considered a potential impact. However, the following Condition of Approval would be implemented for new tenants:

Condition of Approval: Under-Fired Charbroilers
Prior to issuance of a Tenant Improvement permit for a new tenant/business entity that will install an under-fire charbroiler (as defined under Section 3.9 of San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) Rule 4692), the project proponent/developer and/or tenant/business entity shall prepare a health risk assessment (HRA). The HRA shall be prepared to evaluate the potential health risk impacts for the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) and shall be submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division and the SJVAPCD for evaluation.

The HRA shall be prepared in accordance with the policies and procedures of the State Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment and SJVAPCD. If the health risk levels exceed the SJVAPCD health risk significance thresholds of 20 in 1 million for incremental cancer risk of and/or

1.0 for the noncancer hazard index, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these significance thresholds. The identified measures shall be noted on all Tenant Improvement plans submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify implementation of the identified measures (if any).

Overall, the SJVAPCD Regulation II permitting process would be separate from the general occupancy permits issued by the City and would provide controls for emissions associated with any new stationary equipment associated with the Project that are subject to the regulation. The permitting process for stationary-source equipment would ensure that applicable emissions standards are met as stationary-source equipment subject to permitting that does not meet the applicable permitting emissions standards would not be issued a permit to construct and/or permit to operate by SJVAPCD. Additionally, per the SJVAPCD Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI) regarding permitted stationary sources, “emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with [New Source Review] requirements are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant” (SJVAPCD 2015).

Comment No. O2.17
CEQA requires analysis of human health impacts. CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(4) requires lead agencies to find a project will have a significant impact on the environment and prepare an EIR if the environmental effects of a project will cause a substantial adverse effect on human beings.33 The Supreme Court has also explained that CEQA requires the lead agency to disclose the health consequences that result from exposure to a project’s air emissions.34 Courts have held that an environmental review Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-56
document must disclose a project’s potential health risks to a degree of specificity that would allow the public to make the correlation between the project’s impacts and adverse effects to human health. 35 Footnotes:

33. PRC § 21083(b)(3), (d).

34. Sierra Club v. County of Fresno (2018) 6 Cal.5th 502, 516, 523.

35. Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184.

Response No. O2.17
See response to Comment O2.16.

Comment No. O2.18
In Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield, the court found that the EIR’s description of health risks were insufficient and that after reading them, “the public would have no idea of the health consequences that result when more pollutants are added to a nonattainment basin.”36 Likewise, in Sierra Club, the California Supreme Court held that the EIR’s discussion of health impacts associated with exposure to the named pollutants was too general and the failure of the EIR to indicate the concentrations at which each pollutant would trigger the identified symptoms rendered the report inadequate.37 Some connection between air quality impacts and their direct, adverse effects on human health must be made.

As the Court explained, “a sufficient discussion of significant impacts requires not merely a determination of whether an impact is significant, but some effort to explain the nature and magnitude of the impact.”38 CEQA mandates discussion, supported by substantial evidence, of the nature and magnitude of impacts of air pollution on public health.39
Footnotes:

36. Id. at 1220.

37. Sierra Club, at 521.

38. Id. at 519, citing Cleveland National Forest Foundation v. San Diego Assn. of Governments (2017) 3 Cal.5th 497, 514–515.

39. Sierra Club, 6 Cal.5th at 518–522.

Response No. O2.18
See response to Comment O2.16.

Comment No. O2.19
For development projects like this one, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment’s (“OEHHA”) risk assessment guidelines recommend a formal health risk analysis (“HRA”) for short-term construction exposures to TACs lasting longer than 2 months and exposures from projects lasting more than 6 months should be evaluated for the duration of the project.40 In an HRA, lead agencies must first Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-57
quantify the concentration released into the environment at each of the sensitive receptor locations through air dispersion modeling, calculate the dose of each TAC at that location, and quantify the cancer risk and hazard index for each of the chemicals of concern. Following that analysis, then the City can make a determination of the relative significance of the emissions. The DEIR provides that exposure to TACs would be significant if it would result in a cancer risk greater than or equal to 20 in a million and/or a Hazard Index greater than or equal to 1 for noncancer risk.41 Footnotes:

40. Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA), Risk Assessment Guidelines: Guidance Manual for Preparation of Health Risk Assessments, February 2015 (OEHHA 2015), Section 8.2.10:

Cancer Risk Evaluation of Short Term Projects, pp. 8-17/18; https://oehha.ca.gov/air/crnr/notice-adoption-air-toxics-hot-spots-program-guidance-manual-preparation-health-risk-0.

41. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

Response No. O2.19
This comment is noted for the record.

Comment No. O2.20
The DEIR’s qualitative discussion fails to meet these standards. The argument that the Project would not result in significant health risks by virtue of being a retail project fails because it is a mere heuristic that ignores the specific uses proposed by the Project. As explained in SJVAPCD’s comments on the NOP, the Project’s “charbroilers may pose the potential for immediate health risk, particularly when located in densely populated areas or near sensitive receptors.”42 These emissions would combine with emissions from the proposed fuel station, car wash, and heavy-duty trucks. The assertion that retail projects generally do not result in health risk impacts does not actually investigate the risks from this particular project, thus failing to meet CEQA’s informational and analytical requirements.

Footnotes:

42. DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.

Response No. O2.20
Refer to response to Comment O2.16. As stated in the response, while the Draft EIR provides a qualitative evaluation of possible Project-related operational health risk impacts, many of those possible impacts are too speculative at this time to provide further evaluation. The evaluation in the Draft EIR reviewed and considered the known specific components and conditions of the proposed Project and provided the appropriate level of evaluation of both potential impacts and mitigation. In addition, the Project would include a Condition of Approval to the site plan for under-fired charbroilers that would be implemented for new tenants.

Comment No. O2.21
Next, the DEIR’s reference to the CARB land use siting guidelines is misleading.43 The DEIR claims that whereas CARB recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-58
with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways.44 This argument is misleading because these vehicle trip thresholds concern “Freeways and High-Traffic Roads,” not trips generated by individual development projects.45 Significant health risk impacts can result from far fewer trips. For example, the same guidelines recommend against siting new sensitive land uses within 1,000 feet of a distribution center accommodating more than 100 trucks per day. This Project would result in 751 daily VMT for heavy trucks, demonstrating that the Project would present similar health risks as a warehouse project.46 Footnotes:

43. DEIR, p. 4.3-31.

44. DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32.

45. CARB, Air Quality And Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective, p. 4, available at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2023-05/Land%20Use%20Handbook_0.pdf.

46. DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119.

Response No. O2.21
Evaluation of the Project utilizing the CARB Handbook screening criteria for busy roadways and freeways was appropriate because the purpose of the analysis was to evaluate potential health risk impacts associated with Project-generated heavy-duty trucks traveling along the surrounding local roadways. As for potential offsite health risk impacts from Project-related onsite sources associated with the Project, refer to the response to Comment O2.16.

Comment No. O2.22
The DEIR’s argument that stationary source emissions would be analyzed separately at a later stage constitutes piecemealing in violation of CEQA. CEQA defines a “project” as “the whole of an action” that may result in either a direct physical environmental change or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change.47 CEQA mandates “that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large project into many little ones – each with a minimal potential impact on the environment – which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences.”48 Here, the DEIR attempts to piecemeal the health risk impacts of the stationary sources from the other sources, and does not contain a supported analysis of the Project’s total health risk impacts. This violates CEQA’s requirement that the whole of the action be analyzed. The promise of future study of the stationary sources does not correct this error.

Footnotes:

47. 14 Cal. Code Regs. Sec. 15378.

48. Bozung v. LAFCO (1975) 13 Cal.3d 263, 283-84; City of Santee v. County of San Diego (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1438, 1452; Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 151, 165.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-59
Response No. O2.22
The City disagrees with the commenter’s assertion that the Draft EIR attempts to piecemeal the health risk impacts analysis. Overall, the Draft EIR evaluated the potential health risk impacts associated with the various components of the Project, including the non-permitted sources and permitted sources.

Stationary sources were identified as distinct from the non-permitted sources to acknowledge the regulatory framework that exists for permitted sources within the SJVAPCD. As discussed in the Draft EIR, stationary sources are controlled through the SJVAPCD Regulation II permitting process.

Additionally, the Draft EIR acknowledges the SJVAPCD regulatory requirements the Project would be subject to. Future evaluation through compliance with SJVAPCD Regulation II for components of the Project that would be subject to this regulation would be regulatorily mandated. Compliance with SJVAPCD regulatory requirements would ensure that stationary sources are controlled. Permitted equipment would be required to comply with applicable SJVAPCD permitting emissions standards in order to be granted a permit to construct and/or permit to operate. Equipment that does not meet the permitting requirements would not be allowed to operate. Per the SJVAPCD GAMAQI regarding permitted stationary sources, “emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with [New Source Review] requirements are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant” (SJVAPCD 2015).

Comment No. O2.23
In sum, the DEIR fails to quantify sensitive receptors’ exposure to operational TACs and compare the impact to the City’s quantitative threshold. As such, no connection between the Project’s emissions and their direct, adverse effects on human health has been made.49 For these reasons, the City lacks substantial evidence to conclude that the significance threshold would not be exceeded. The potentially significant health risk impacts must be analyzed and mitigated in a recirculated EIR.

Footnotes:

49. Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184.

Response No. O2.23
See responses to Comments O2.16 through O2.22.

Comment No. O2.24

2. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts The DEIR fails to adequately analyze the significance of the Project’s cumulative health risk impacts. The DEIR asserts that any exceedance of a project-level threshold (cancer risk of 20 in one million) also is considered to be a cumulatively considerable effect, while health risks that fall below applicable project-level thresholds are not considered cumulatively considerable.50 The DEIR concludes that this Project’s health risk impact would not be cumulatively considerable because it would not exceed the project-level thresholds.51 This approach is unsupported. First, as discussed above, the DEIR did not actually quantify the Project’s operational health risks and compare them to the significance threshold. Thus, the City lacks substantial evidence to conclude that the quantitative threshold was not exceeded. Second, the DEIR’s Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-60
approach fails to consider the Project’s cumulative effects with existing and proposed development near Project site as required by CEQA.52
Footnotes:

50. DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”).

51. Id.

52. DEIR, p. 4.3-34.

Response No. O2.24
As discussed in Section 3.4, Air Quality, of the Draft EIR, a construction HRA was prepared to quantify the incremental health risk attributable to project construction activities. The HRA identified a maximum estimated cancer risk of 1.5 in one million at the maximally exposed individual receptor (MEIR), substantially below the SJVAPCD’s cancer risk significance threshold of 20 in one million.

The SJVAPCD's 20 per one million significance threshold evaluates the incremental cancer risk attributable to a project. The existence of other sources of toxic air contaminant (TAC) emissions in the surrounding area does not, by itself, mean that the Project would result in a cumulatively considerable health risk impact. Rather, as identified in the SJVPACD’s GAMAQI, “the [SJVAPCD] has established extremely conservative and protective health impacts on sensitive receptors. Because impacts from TACs are localized and the thresholds of significance for TACs have been established at such a conservative level, risks over the individual thresholds of significance are also considered cumulatively significant. No other cumulative risk thresholds apply.” Therefore, the commenter is incorrect in the assertion that the approach taken in the Draft EIR is not supported; the use of the project-level significance thresholds is directly supported by the SJVAPCD’s own guidance documentation. Moreover, the SJVAPCD reviewed the Draft EIR and did not identify a separate cumulative health risk threshold or request that the Project's modeled risk be added to ambient or background cancer risk.

As identified in response to the SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, an operational HRA was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498) that generates substantially more heavy-duty diesel truck trips per day than the commercial uses associated with the proposed Project, which supports the conclusions in the Draft EIR that the proposed Project would not generate a substantial amount of truck trips that would warrant an operational HRA. In addition, as discussed in response to the SJVAPCD’s Comment A2.2, the gasoline station would be sited farther from sensitive receptors than the CARB’s siting recommendations referenced by the SJVAPCD. Moreover, the Project would be subject to SJVAPCD’s Regulation II to ensure that permitted stationary sources, such as the gasoline station, result in impacts below the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and one hazard index for acute risk at the maximally exposed receptor. As discussed in response to the SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, the Project would not exceed the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds during operation. Accordingly, the Project's incremental contribution to cumulative health risk would not be cumulatively considerable, and the Draft EIR's less than significant conclusion would remain unchanged.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-61
Furthermore, as discussed in response to the SJVAPCD’s Comment A2.4, future tenants which may occupy those spaces are unknown at this time, and are therefore considered speculative pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15145, Speculation. Nonetheless, to ensure that potential health risks posed by possible under-fired charbroilers do not result in a significant impact, a Condition of Approval to the site plan has been added to require that should a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler be proposed within the Project Site, a health risk assessment shall be required. Furthermore, if it is determined that health risk impacts would exceed the SJVAPCD’s 20 in a million for cancer risk threshold and/or hazard index of 1, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these identified performance standards.

As such, the Project’s cumulative construction and operational health risk impacts would remain less than significant.

Comment No. O2.25
A leading case on this issue is Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford.53 In Kings County, the city prepared an EIR for a 26.4-megawatt coal-fired cogeneration plant. Notwithstanding the fact that the EIR found that the project region was out of attainment for PM10 and ozone, the city failed to incorporate mitigation for the project’s cumulative air quality impacts from project emissions because it concluded that the Project would contribute “less than one percent of area emissions for all criteria pollutants.”54 The city reasoned that, because the project’s air emissions were small in ratio to existing air quality problems, that this necessarily rendered the project’s “incremental contribution” minimal under CEQA.

The court rejected this approach, finding it “contrary to the intent of CEQA,” and that “[t]he EIR improperly focused upon the individual project’s relative effects and omitted facts relevant to an analysis of the collective effect this and other sources will have upon air quality.”55 Footnotes:

53. Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (1990) 221 Cal. App. 3d 692 (“Kings County”); see also, Friends of Oroville v. City of Oroville (2013) 219 Cal. App. 4th 832, 841-42.

54. Kings County, supra, at 719.

55. Id. at 721; see also People of the State of California v. City of Fontana, Case No. CIVSB2121829, Petition for Writ of Mandate, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2021/20210723_docket-CIVSB2121829_petition-for-writ-of-mandate.pdf (“The MND’s cumulative air quality impact analysis does not account for—or even acknowledge—the multitude of other warehouses near the Project. Rather than consider the environmental setting within which the Project will be situated, the MND simply states that the Project will not result in a cumulatively considerable increase in emissions because the Project’s individual air quality impacts will be less than significant. The MND even applies this reasoning to its analysis of health impacts from localized emissions, despite making no attempt to determine or disclose the severity of the existing health impacts from localized emissions in the community”)
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-62

56. People of the State of California v. City of Fontana, Case No. CIVSB2121829, Petition for Writ of Mandate, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2021/20210723_docket-CIVSB2121829_petition-for-writ-of-mandate.pdf.

Response No. O2.25
The Draft EIR did not employ the project ratio approach that was in question in the Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford court case referenced by the commenter. Instead, the Draft EIR utilized the regional significance thresholds adopted by the SJVAPCD. The regional significance thresholds for criteria pollutants were established by SJVAPCD to specifically evaluate potential impacts of an individual project on SJVAPCD’s ability to reach attainment for the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (GAMAQI). Overall, the regional significance thresholds are based on the SJVAPCD Rule 2201 New Source Review (NSR) offset thresholds. The SJVAPCD attainment plans demonstrate that project specific emissions below the NSR offset thresholds will have a less than significant impact on air quality (GAMAQI).

Comment No. O2.26
The City of Fontana was recently sued by the State Attorney General for failing to adequately analyze cumulative impacts.56 Citing Kings County, the Attorney General’s petition explained: “[t]o the extent that the 2003 SCAQMD White Paper asserts that any project with less than significant individual air quality impacts also necessarily has less than significant cumulative air quality impacts, it is inconsistent with CEQA.”57 The Attorney General’s litigation resulted in a in a settlement which requires compliance with an ordinance adopted on April 12, 2022 that establishes standards intended to address cumulative air quality impacts. 58
Footnotes:

56. People of the State of California v. City of Fontana, Case No. CIVSB2121829, Petition for Writ of Mandate, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2021/20210723_docket-CIVSB2121829_petition-for-writ-of-mandate.pdf.

57. Id.

58. Id., Stipulation For Entry Of Final Judgment On Consent, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2022/20220414_docket-CIVSB2121605- CIVSB2121829_stipulation.pdf.

Response No. O2.26
See response to Comment O2.27.

Comment No. O2.27
This DEIR’s analysis is similarly flawed because it improperly focuses upon the individual Project’s relative effects and omits facts relevant to an analysis of the collective effect this and other sources will have upon air quality. To begin with, the DEIR does not evaluate the significance of the combined emissions from the Project and other projects listed in Table 3-1 of the DEIR.59 Combined emissions from these projects may result in significant air quality and health risks, but this is not analyzed in the DEIR.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-63
Footnotes:

59. DEIR, p. 3-2, Table 3-1
Response No. O2.27
The Draft EIR prepared the air quality analysis based on the SJVAPCD’s GAMAQI. For regional air quality impacts, the Draft EIR compared the project construction- and operation-related criteria air pollutant emissions to the respective adopted SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds.

By its nature, air quality impacts are cumulative impacts as no single individual project within the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SJVAB) is large enough to cause nonattainment of the ambient air quality standards for the region. In general, the nonattainment status of the SJVAB is a result of past and present development. The SJVAPCD attainment plans provide a roadmap for the SJVAB to meet and achieve attainment of the ambient air quality standards. Growth projections are utilized by the SJVAPCD attainment plans to forecast cumulative development in the SJVAB. Therefore, the SJVAPCD attainment plans account for both existing and future cumulative development within the SJVAB. The regional significance thresholds are based on the SJVAPCD Rule 2201 NSR offset thresholds and the SJVAPCD attainment plans demonstrate that project specific emissions below the NSR offset thresholds will have a less than significant impact on air quality. Thus, because the adopted regionals significance thresholds are based on the NSR offset thresholds, they evaluate both project-level and cumulative impacts associated with a proposed project.

The Draft EIR evaluated the Project construction- and operation-related criteria air pollutants to the respective regional significance thresholds adopted by the SJVAPCD. The SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds evaluate whether a project cumulatively contributes to air quality impacts within the SJVAB.

As discussed on page 4.3-34 of the Draft EIR, the Project would not exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for construction and would not result in construction-related cumulative air quality impacts. Additionally, the Project operations would also not result in cumulative air quality impacts with implementation of Mitigation Measure AQ-1. Thus, because the Project would not generate criteria air pollutant emissions and will offset criteria air pollutant emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds, it would not cause a deterioration of regional air quality.

Regarding cumulative health risk impacts, per the SJVAPCD GAMAQI, the established thresholds of significance for health risk impacts associated with toxic air contaminants evaluate both project-level and cumulative impacts and there are no separate cumulative significance thresholds (GAMAQI).

Comment No. O2.28
Further, the DEIR does not consider existing pollution burden when evaluating the significance of cumulative health risks. The CalEnviroScreen 5.0 health screening tool shows that the Project would impact a census tract in the 99th percentile for PM 2.5 pollution.60 The Project would introduce new construction and operational sources of PM 2.5 that would increase health risks. Potentially significant cumulative health risks are unanalyzed in the DEIR, in violation of CEQA and the principles articulated in Kings County.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-64
In sum, the DEIR’s cumulative air quality impacts analysis fails to comply with CEQA. The City must prepare a revised EIR that properly evaluates and mitigates such impacts.

Footnote:

60. Clark Comments, p. 10.

Response No. O2.28
See response to Comment O2.27 regarding the cumulative nature of the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds and the Draft EIR evaluation of the potential regional air quality impacts of the proposed Project. Furthermore, the Draft EIR also prepared an ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) in accordance with the SJVAPCD CEQA guidelines. As shown in Table 4.3-12 of the Draft EIR, Project-related construction activities would not generate emissions that exceed the SJVAPCD ambient air quality screening threshold of 100 pounds per day and its potential to contribute to exceed the ambient air quality standard is less than significant.

In addition, an AAQA was also prepared for Project operation-related criteria air pollutant emissions. As shown in Table 4.3-13 of the Draft EIR and in accordance with SJVAPCD methodology, the concentrations (including PM2.5) compared to the ambient air quality standards (AAQS) include both the Project-generated concentrations plus the ambient background concentrations for the area. Per SJVAPCD methodology, while the proposed Project would elevate PM2.5 concentrations above the 24-hour National AAQS and the annual National AAQS and California AAQS, because Project-generated PM2.5 concentrations would not exceed the SJVAPCD significant impact levels, the potential for operation of the Project to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would also be less than significant.

Comment No. O2.29
C. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Significant Air Quality Impacts

1. The DEIR Fails to Identify All Feasible Air Quality Mitigation The DEIR finds that the Project would result in significant emissions of VOCs and NOx.61 The DEIR claims that these significant impacts would be fully mitigated through two mitigation measures: entering into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (“VERA”) with SJVAPCD (MM AQ-1) and requiring use of low-VOC paint (MM AQ-2).62 MM AQ-1 is not supported by substantial evidence because SJVAPCD regulations provide that VERAs should only be entered into after all onsite mitigation measures are implemented.63 Footnotes:

61. DEIR, p. ES-5, 6.

62. DEIR, p. 4.3-30, 31.

63. SJVAPCD, Emission Reduction Credits (ERC), https://www.valleyair.org/permitting/emission-reduction-credits-erc/ (“ERCs are required in addition to, and only after, establishing that the new emissions are controlled with the best available control technology (BACT) and will not cause a health risk to surrounding communities”); SJVAPCD, ISR Brochure, 2025, Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-65
https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/thuaubuq/isr-brochure-2025-web.pdf (“Developers are encouraged to reduce as much air pollution as possible through on-site mitigation, orincorporating clean air design measures into the project.”).

Response No. O2.29
The commenter references informational materials on the SJVAPCD Emissions Reduction Credits (ERC) program and Indirect Source Review (ISR) program in support of their statement that SJVAPCD regulations provide that VERA should only be entered into after all onsite mitigation measures are implemented.

Firstly, the ERC and ISR programs are established SJVAPCD regulatory programs separate from the VERA program, which primarily serves as a CEQA mitigation program as established by SJVAPCD. The ERC program is established for permitted facilities under SJVAPCD Regulation II, while the ISR program is established under SJVAPCD Rule 9510. Compliance with Rule 9510 for projects subject to the rule is mandatory and is a separate process from the CEQA entitlement process. Overall, use of a VERA is a generally accepted and recommended mitigation measure by SJVAPCD to address operation-related regional air quality impacts. For example, the SJVAPCD GAMAQI specifically identifies VERA as a recommended measure (GAMAQI, see page 121). As stated in response to Comment O2.5, the Draft EIR also prescribes other “onsite” mitigation measures such as MM GHG-1 and MM GHG-3 through MM GHG-7, which would contribute to reducing project operation-related criteria air pollutant emissions.

Comment No. O2.30
Specifically, this Project is subject to SJVAPCD’s Indirect Source Rule (“ISR”) 9510.64 The Project is subject to District Rule 9510 because it will receive a project-level discretionary approval from a public agency and will equal or exceed 9,000 square feet of development space.65 Rule 9510 provides that VERAs should only be entered into after all onsite mitigation measures are implemented.66 Here, the DEIR contains no evidence that the City identified all feasible air quality mitigation available for the Project before turning to a VERA. Therefore, MM AQ-1 is inconsistent with SJVAPCD regulations and is unsupported by substantial evidence.

Footnotes:

64. Available at https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/cjlnn0u1/r9510-a.pdf.

65. DEIR, Appendix A, p. 26.

66. SJVAPCD Rule 9510, Section 3.25, available at https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/cjlnn0u1/r9510-a.pdf (“Off-Site Emission Reduction Fee (Off-Site Fee): a fee to be paid by the applicant to the District for any emission reductions required by the rule that are not achieved through on-site emission reduction measures.”); id., Section 7.1.1.1 (“The applicant shall pay to the District a monetary sum necessary to offset the required construction NOx emissions not reduced on-site.”); Response No. O2.30
The commenter refers and provides citations to SJVAPCD Rule 9510 and is correct that the proposed Project would be subject to SJVAPCD Rule 9510 Indirect Source Review (ISR). However, commenter conflates any provisions that may exist under Rule 9510 with the VERA program. As discussed in response Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-66
to Comment 29, the ISR program is established as an SJVAPCD regulatory program and is a program separate from the VERA program, which is established by SJVAPCD to serve as a CEQA mitigation program.

Because Rule 9510 is an SJVAPCD regulation of which the proposed Project would be subject to, the proposed Project would be mandated to comply with all the requirements under the Rule as deemed necessary by SJVAPCD. Under Rule 9510, if the proposed Project does not comply with its requirements, construction permits would not be issued for the project without SJVAPCD approval. For the VERA program, SJVAPCD identifies it as a recommended and feasible CEQA mitigation measure and does not have requirements of when it may or may not be used for development projects that exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds (SJVAPCD 2015).

Comment No. O2.31
Feasible onsite mitigation measures are identified in SJVAPCD’s comments on the NOP.67 For example, SJVAPCD recommends reducing the permissible idling time of diesel trucks,68 but the DEIR fails to evaluate the feasibility of reducing the permissible idling period below the five minutes already required by law.69 SJVAPCD also recommends requiring under-fired char broilers, but the DEIR fails to identify this as a mitigation measure or demonstrate that it would be infeasible.70 The DEIR must be revised to identify and incorporate all feasible on-site mitigation measures before allowing excess emissions to be mitigated through a VERA.

Footnotes:

67. DEIR, Appendix A, p. 18 etseq.

68. DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.

69. DEIR, p. 4.3-5.

70. DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.

Response No. O2.31
See response to comments above including O2.5 and O2.16.

Comment No. O2.32
D. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Transportation Impacts

1. The DEIR Overestimates the Number of Pass-by Trips
The DEIR estimates that the Project’s gasoline service station would generate 10,196 daily trips, including 7,316 pass-by trips.71 This number of pass-by trips is a combination of 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips.72 Mr. Marshall demonstrates that the DEIR underestimates trips generated by the Project by conflating two different types of trips: “pass-by” and “diverted” trips.

Pass-by trips are trips where a driver is already driving right past the Project on their normal route, adding zero new cars to the surrounding neighborhood streets because they were on that exact road anyway.73 Diverted trips are trips where a driver goes out of their way specifically to visit the Project. Because they are driving extra miles on roads they would not normally use, they add new traffic and increase Vehicle Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-67
Miles Traveled (VMT).74 By erroneously treating these two types of trips as “pass-by” trips, the DEIR underestimates the Project’s vehicle trips. The DEIR’s analysis is thus unsupported by substantial evidence.

Footnotes:

71. DEIR, p. 4.16-10, Table 4.16-2.

72. DEIR, Appendix H, p. 361.

73. Marshall Comments, p. 3.

74. Id.

Response No. O2.32
The commenter states that the Draft EIR underestimates Project-generated traffic by combining pass-by and diverted trips and characterizing the combined 7,316 daily trips as pass-by trips. The commenter correctly notes that pass-by and diverted trips are distinct types of trips. However, this comment does not accurately characterize the overall methodology used in the traffic analysis or demonstrate that the Draft EIR underestimates the gross traffic demand associated with the proposed Costco fuel facility or lacks substantial evidence in support of that estimation.

The objective of the trip-generation analysis was to develop a reasonable and conservative estimate of traffic associated with this unique land use by considering both Costco proprietary traffic data and applicable Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation Manual rates that provide the closest available representation of the proposed facility and its surrounding land-use context. Because the proposed facility includes 40 vehicle fueling positions and is not collocated with a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center, no single published ITE land-use category precisely represents the proposed land use. Accordingly, multiple sources of available trip-generation and pass-by reduction information were considered to establish an appropriate basis for the analysis.

The proposed Costco fuel facility was estimated to generate 10,196 gross daily trips with 3,254 pass-by trips and 4,062 diverted trips. This data is associated with Costco facilities that include warehouses or Business Centers compared to the proposed facility that would operate as a standalone gas station within the Riverview Marketplace development that includes complementary retail and commercial land uses.

This difference was considered in developing the traffic methodology where an overall adjustment was applied in the technical study consisted of combining the 3,254 pass-by trips and 4,062 diverted trips for a total of 7,316 combined trips. The reasonableness of the overall traffic adjustment is further supported by the ITE comparable gas station land uses. ITE allows pass-by reduction of 76 percent during the AM peak hour and 75 percent during the PM peak hour. The combined pass-by and diverted-trip adjustments applied to the Costco data were 76 percent during the AM peak hour and 71 percent during the PM peak hour which are consistent with the AM peak-hour reduction allowed by the ITE and lower than the PM peak-hour reduction for comparable land uses.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-68
Comment No. O2.33

2. The Trip Generation Rate for the Gasoline Service Station is Unsupported The DEIR estimates the gasoline service station’s trip generation rate using the Costco transportation database, which contains data related to Costco fuel facilities.75 But the DEIR’s approach is not supported by substantial evidence. Mr. Marshall observes that the proposed gasoline service station is significantly different than the sites included in the Costco database.76 The proposed gasoline service station has more fueling positions, 40, than at any of the sites in the Costco database, and is also unique in that it is not collocated with a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site (located 3 miles away).77 The fact that this fuel station is not collocated with a Costco Warehouse means that there cannot be any combined gasoline/warehouse trips within the same site. As a result, the DEIR’s trip generation rate does not reasonably reflect the proposed gasoline service station’s trip generation and pass-by trip percentage.

Footnotes:

75. DEIR, p. 4.16-10.

76. Marshall Comments, p. 5.

77. Id.

Response No. O2.33
The commenter contends that the trip-generation rate used for the proposed Costco fuel facility is unsupported because the Costco transportation database includes facilities with fewer fueling positions that are collocated with Costco Warehouses or Costco Business Centers compared to the Project’s proposed standalone facility that would include 40 fueling positions. The commenter further states that the available Costco data do not reasonably represent the proposed facility's trip generation or pass-by characteristics. However, this assertion does not account for the methodology used to develop the trip generation estimate and conservative approach taken in the Draft EIR.

The objective of the trip-generation analysis was to develop a reasonable and conservative estimate for the proposed unique land use that the ITE Trip Generation Manual does not provide a specific land-use category for. Therefore, the analysis took into consideration both Costco-specific traffic data and the closest applicable ITE land-use categories. The ITE comparisons included Land Use 945, Gasoline/Service Station, and Land Use 955, Travel Center, which represent the closest available ITE land use and trip rates categories associated with gasoline sales and related commercial/retail activity.

Based on the characteristics of the proposed facility, ITE Land Use 945 was estimated to generate approximately 8,442 daily trips, 546 AM peak-hour trips, and 634 PM peak-hour trips, while ITE Land Use 955 was estimated to generate approximately 7,400 daily trips, 374 AM peak-hour trips, and 457 PM peak-hour trips. Costco provided data shows total trip generation of 10,196 daily trips, 570 AM peak-hour trips, and 819 PM peak-hour trips which is an additional 1,754 daily trips, 24 AM peak-hour trips, and 185 PM peak-hour trips when compared to ITE Land Use 945 and an additional 2,796 daily trips, 196 AM peak-hour trips, and 362 PM peak-hour trips when compared with ITE Land Use 955. Therefore, the Costco trip Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-69
generation provided was selected because it provides a more conservative estimate of the trips anticipated to be generated by the gas station.

It should be noted that the calculated 570 AM peak-hour trips, and 819 PM peak-hour trips were used in the evaluation of the Project driveways without the implementation of any trip reductions representing worst case scenario.

Comment No. O2.34

3. The DEIR Fails to Identify All Feasible VMT Mitigation The DEIR finds that the Project would result in an overall net increase in countywide roadway VMT and that the proposed medical office use would exceed the applicable VMT per employee threshold.78 The DEIR asserts that these significant impacts would be significant and unavoidable despite implementing feasible mitigation.79 The DEIR states that it has been designed to include enhanced pedestrian connectivity, new and expanded bicycle facilities, end-of-trip bicycle amenities, and that no other feasible mitigation is available.80 The DEIR states that these measures correspond to California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (“CAPCOA”) measures T-10, T-18, and T-19.81 However, Mr. Marshall identifies additional feasible mitigation for the Project which would result in considerable reductions in VMT.

Footnotes:

78. DEIR, p. 4.16-15, 16.

79. DEIR, p. 4.16-16.

80. DEIR, p. 4.16-16.

81. DEIR, p. 4.16-16; see California Air Pollution Control Officers Association Handbook for Analyzing Greenhouse Gas Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity (2021).

Response No. O2.34
The commenter acknowledges that the Draft EIR identifies mitigation measures to reduce VMT that align with California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA) measures T-10, T-18, and T-19. The commenter contends, however, that additional, available mitigation measures would substantially lessen the Project’s VMT impacts. This argument relies entirely on the assertions of a purported transportation expert, Norman Marshall, retained by the commenter to review the Draft EIR. Notwithstanding Mr.

Marshall’s assertions, the proposed additional mitigation measures are practically infeasible as supported by substantial evidence in the Draft EIR, and, as such, may be excluded from consideration under CEQA. (See Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Comment No. O2.35
CEQA requires agencies to commit to all feasible mitigation measures to reduce significant environmental impacts.82 In particular, the lead agency may not make required CEQA findings, including finding that a Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-70
project impact is significant and unavoidable, unless the administrative record demonstrates that it has adopted all feasible mitigation to reduce significant environmental impacts to the greatest extent feasible.83
Here, Mr. Marshall demonstrates that CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary), would be feasible and effective.84 Measures within the scope of Measure T-5 include employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8)), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home.85 The CAPCOA Handbook states that up to 20.4% reduction is possible with vanpooling (T-11) when the employer covers “the capital costs of vehicle acquisition and the labor costs of drivers, either through incentives to current employees or the hiring of dedicated drivers.”86
Footnotes:

82. CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2).

83. PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883.

84. Marshall Comments, p. 2; CAPCOA Handbook, T-5,
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-5.pdf.

85. Marshall Comments, p. 2.

86. https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-11.pdf.

Response No. O2.35
The commenter asserts that CEQA compels lead agencies to adopt all feasible mitigation measures to minimize significant environmental impacts and suggests that CAPCOA Measure T-5 represents a feasible and effective mechanism to achieve further VMT reductions. “CEQA does not require analysis of every imaginable alternative or mitigation measure; its concern is with feasible means of reducing environmental effects. Section 21002 states in part that the intention of CEQA is ‘to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such significant effects.’” (Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Consequently, CEQA does not mandate implementation of mitigation measures where they would be ineffective as either inapplicable to a project element or purported impact. (Ibid.) The statutory definition of "feasible" is set forth in Public Resources Code section 21061.1, which defines the term as "capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors." The CEQA Guidelines expand upon this definition by explicitly incorporating "legal" considerations into the feasibility assessment. (14 Cal. Code Regs. § 15364.) Furthermore, Public Resources Code section 21002 establishes Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-71
that where overriding economic, social, or other conditions render mitigation infeasible, a project may nonetheless be approved despite the persistence of one or more significant environmental effects.

The proposed implementation of employer-provided services, infrastructure, and alternative transit incentives to reduce Project VMT is practically infeasible due to the Project Applicant’s lack of enforcement authority. As the Project developer and ultimate lessor of the individual retail sites, the Project Applicant will maintain no on-site operational management or personnel. Furthermore, the Project Applicant possesses no legal mechanism to compel commercial tenants to implement, manage, or enforce employer-based transit programs. Because these suggested additional measures cannot be successfully enacted or enforced by the Project Applicant, they are facially infeasible under CEQA and require no further analysis.

Comment No. O2.36
The City should also assess the feasibility of Commute Trip Reduction programs pursuant to CAPCOA Measure T-6 (“Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring”).87 These can reduce GHG emissions from employee commute VMT by up to 26%.88 The Handbook states:

The mandatory CTR program must include all other elements (i.e., Measures T-7 through T-11) [T-7 Implement Commute Trip Reduction Marketing, T-8 Provide Ridesharing Program, T-9 Implement Subsidized or Discounted Transit Program, T-10 Provide End-of-Trip Bicycle Facilities, and T-11 Provide Employer-Sponsored Vanpool] described for the voluntary program (Measure T-5) plus include mandatory trip reduction requirements (including penalties for non-compliance) and regular monitoring and reporting to ensure the calculated VMT reduction matches the observed VMT reduction.

To meet CEQA’s requirement of reducing significant impacts to the greatest extent feasible, the DEIR must assess whether these and other CAPCOA measures would feasibly reduce VMT. Newly identified measures must be included in a recirculated DEIR.

Footnotes:

87. CAPCOA Handbook, T-6. Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring)

88. Id.

Response No. O2.36
The commenter further suggests that the City evaluate the feasibility of Commuter Trip Reduction programs under CAPCOA Measure T-6 to reduce employee commute VMT and contends that such analysis necessitates recirculation of the Draft EIR.
“CEQA does not require analysis of every imaginable alternative or mitigation measure; its concern is with feasible means of reducing environmental effects. Section 21002 states in part that the intention of CEQA is ‘to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-72
significant effects.’” (Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Consequently, CEQA does not mandate implementation of mitigation measures where they would be ineffective as either inapplicable to a project element or purported impact. (Ibid.) Because the commenter has failed to present feasible mitigation that was not already considered in the Draft EIR or identify a significant new or intensified impact, recirculation of the Draft EIR is not legally required under CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.

Comment No. O2.37
E. The DEIR Fails to Analyze Potentially Significant Public Utilities Impacts Under CEQA, a public utilities impact is considered significant if a project would “[r]equire or result in the relocation or construction of new or expanded water, wastewater treatment or storm water drainage, electric power, natural gas, or telecommunications facilities the construction or relocation of which could cause significant environmental effects.”89 The DEIR states that no impacts would result from connections to utilities.90 However, this conclusion is not supported by substantial evidence.

Footnotes:

89. DEIR, p. ES-25.

90. Id.

Response No. O2.37
The water/sewer infrastructure improvements needed to serve the Project would mainly occur within the confines of the Project Site. Off-site water infrastructure improvements would mainly be associated with connections/tie-ins to the water mains in the surrounding roadway (Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway), which would require some minor asphalt removal and soil disturbance in the existing roadways. The environmental and technical analysis conducted as a part of the Draft EIR (including air quality, noise, traffic, etc.) included any on-site and minor off-site water infrastructure improvements. For example, regarding air quality impacts and as addressed in the Draft EIR, the emissions generated from utility improvements would not be greater than the emissions generated during the project’s grading phase. The Draft EIR provides a conservative analysis of the maximum daily construction emissions that are generated by the Project.

Comment No. O2.38
For example, the DEIR fails to disclose the fire flow requirements for this Project, whether that fire flow would be met by existing infrastructure (once the Project is connected to it), and the environmental impacts resulting from construction of any necessary improvements. This information is necessary to evaluate whether upsized water mains and other offsite upgrades are required. Construction of improvements to existing water infrastructure may be required because the Project proposes a large new development on a vacant site. Further, the Bakersfield system has historic low-pressure areas where the minimum normal operating pressure ranges between 25 and 40 psi.91 Upgrades to the system may be required to service the Project. The DEIR omits analysis of these considerations.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-73
Footnotes:

91. California Water Service, Capital Project Justification Bakersfield District, July 2021, p. 97, https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/SupDoc/A2107002/3862/393926055.pdf.

Response No. O2.38
The Project would be constructed pursuant to California Fire Code (CFC) requirements and industry standards that include regulatory requirements that would aid in fire safety and support fire suppression activities, such as a fire protection system, automatic fire sprinklers, paved access, and required aisle widths that would be subject to review by Bakersfield Fire Department. Because the Project is located on a vacant site within a developed urban area, it would connect to existing adjacent water infrastructure.

The Project’s required fire flow is determined by the Bakersfield Fire Department in accordance with the CFC. Fire flow requirements are based on the final building size, construction type, and the presence of fire suppression systems (such as automatic sprinklers). The Bakersfield Fire Department will review the Project Site plans including flow requirements as part of plan review of the Project before construction of the Project.

Comment No. O2.39
If needed, construction of improvements to water infrastructure would have environmental impacts not analyzed in the DEIR. Construction activities may result in significant environmental impacts in several areas, including traffic, noise, vibration, and health risk. Impacts may occur closer to sensitive receptors than analyzed in the DEIR because construction of utilities improvements may occur offsite and potentially closer to sensitive receptors.

Response No. O2.39
The water/sewer infrastructure improvements needed to serve the Project would mainly occur within the confines of the project site. Off-site water infrastructure improvements would mainly be associated with connections/tie-ins to the water mains in the surrounding roadway (Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway), which would require some minor asphalt removal and soil disturbance in the existing roadways. The environmental and technical analysis conducted as a part of the Draft EIR (including air quality, noise, traffic, etc.) included any on-site and minor off-site water infrastructure improvements. For example, regarding air quality impacts and as addressed in the Draft EIR, the emissions generated from utility improvements would not be greater than the emissions generated during the project’s grading phase. The Draft EIR provides a conservative analysis of the maximum daily construction emissions that is generated by the Project.

Comment No. O2.40
By omitting analysis of these considerations, the DEIR fails as an informational document and fails to support its finding of a less-than-significant impact with substantial evidence. A revised EIR must be prepared to analyze these potentially significant impacts.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-74
Response No. O2.40
This comment is noted. This comment is not substantiated by any evidence and no revisions to the Draft EIR are necessary.

Comment No. O2.41
II. THE STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATION MUST CONSIDER WHETHER THE

PROJECT PROVIDES EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR HIGHLY TRAINED WORKERS The City concludes in the DEIR that the Project will have significant and unavoidable impacts from VMT and emissions of GHGs. Therefore, in order to approve the Project, CEQA requires the City to adopt a statement of overriding considerations, providing that the Project’s overriding benefits outweigh its environmental harm.92 An agency’s determination that a project’s benefits outweigh its significant, unavoidable impacts “lies at the core of the lead agency’s discretionary responsibility under CEQA.”93 Footnotes:

92. CEQA Guidelines, § 15043.

93. Laurel Heights Improvement Assn. v. Regents of University of California (1988) 47 Cal.3d 376, 392.

Response No. O2.41
Pursuant to applicable environmental regulations, the City has prepared a Statement of Overriding Considerations that carefully balanced the economic, legal, social, technological, and environmental benefits of the Project against its unavoidable environmental impacts to GHG and VMT.

Comment No. O2.42
The City must set forth the reasons for its action, pointing to supporting substantial evidence in the administrative record.94 This requirement reflects the policy that public agencies must weigh a project’s benefits against its unavoidable environmental impacts, and may find the adverse impacts acceptable only if the benefits outweigh the impacts.95 Importantly, a statement of overriding considerations is legally inadequate if it fails to accurately characterize the relative harms and benefits of a project.96 Footnotes:

94. Pub. Resources Code, § 21081, subd. (b); CEQA Guidelines, § 15093, subds. (a) and (b); Cherry Valley Pass Acres & Neighbors v. City of Beaumont (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 316, 357.

95. Pub. Resources Code, § 21081(b); CEQA Guidelines, § 15093, subds. (a) and (b)

96. Woodward Park Homeowners Association v. City of Fresno (2007) 150 Cal.App.4th 683, 717.

Response No. O2.42
Pursuant to applicable environmental regulations, the City has prepared a Statement of Overriding Considerations that carefully balanced the economic, legal, social, technological, and environmental benefits of the Project against its unavoidable environmental impacts to GHG and VMT.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-75
Comment No. O2.43
In this case, the City must find that the Project’s significant, unavoidable impacts outweigh the Project’s benefits to the community. CEQA specifically references employment opportunities for highly trained workers as a factor to be considered in making the determination of overriding benefits.97 Currently, there is not substantial evidence in the record showing that the Project’s significant, unavoidable impacts are outweighed by benefits to the community. For example, there is no evidence in the record that the Applicant has made any commitments to employ graduates of state approved apprenticeship programs or taken other steps to ensure employment of highly trained and skilled craft workers on Project construction, an action contemplated by CEQA Section 21081. Absent substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that the Project’s benefits outweigh its environmental costs, the City would not fulfill its obligations under CEQA if it adopted a statement of overriding considerations and approved the Project.

Footnotes:

97. Pub. Resources Code, § 21081, subds. (a)(3) and (b).

Response No. O2.43
The commenter asserts that the record lacks substantial evidence to support a Statement of Overriding Considerations, specifically citing a lack of commitments to state-approved apprenticeship programs or highly trained craft workers.

The City disagrees with the assertion that the record lacks substantial evidence of overriding benefits.

Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15093, the City, as the lead agency, is permitted to balance the economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of a proposed project against its unavoidable environmental risks. While Public Resources Code Section 21081 notes that employment opportunities for highly trained workers may be considered a benefit, it does not mandate specific labor commitments or apprenticeship agreements as a condition of CEQA compliance.

The administrative record contains comprehensive evidence of the Project’s public benefits, including the creation of jobs and enhanced City revenues, revitalization of an underutilized site, creation of a sustainable development and development of bicycle, pedestrian, and roadway improvements. The City Council will review the complete record, weigh these identified benefits against the Project's significant and unavoidable impacts, and make the final determination regarding the Statement of Overriding Considerations at the time of Project consideration. No changes to the Draft EIR are required.

Comment No. O2.44
We urge the City to prepare and circulate a revised EIR which identifies the Project’s potentially significant impacts, requires all feasible mitigation measures and analyzes all feasible alternatives to reduce impacts to a less than significant level. If a Statement of Overriding Considerations is adopted for the Project, we urge the City to consider whether the Project will result in employment opportunities for highly trained workers.

Response No. O2.44
This comment is noted for the record.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-76
Comment No. O2.45
III. CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, the DEIR for the Project is inadequate under CEQA. It must be revised to provide legally adequate analysis of, and mitigation for, all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts.

These revisions will necessarily require that the DEIR be recirculated for additional public review. Until the DEIR has been revised and recirculated, as described herein, the City may not lawfully approve the Project.

Thank you for your consideration of these comments. Please include them in the record of proceedings for the Project.

Response No. O2.45
The City has conducted a comprehensive environmental review of the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in full compliance with CEQA. The Draft EIR reflects a thorough, legally adequate analysis of all potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the Project. As demonstrated in the detailed responses to specific comments provided above, the analysis relies on substantial evidence, accurate data, and approved methodologies. The commenter has failed to provide sufficient and substantial evidence to why the Draft EIR is inadequate and would require recirculation.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-77
Appendix No. O2A
Comment No. O2A-1
At the request of Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo (ABJC), Clark and Associates (Clark) has reviewed the City of Bakersfield (City) DEIR for the above-referenced Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), together with its Appendix B (Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas, and Energy Technical Study) and Appendix F (Hazards, including the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment and supporting reports).

Clark's review of the materials in no way constitutes a validation of the conclusions or materials contained within the DEIR. If I do not comment on a specific item, this does not constitute acceptance of that item.

Response No. O2A-1
This comment is noted for the record and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2A-2

PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The Project proposes an approximately 405,531-square-foot commercial retail center on an approximately 46-acre site in the City of Bakersfield. As described in the DEIR, the Project would include, among other uses, a fuel/service station with 20 dual-sided fuel dispensers (40 fueling positions), a car wash, and restaurant and other retail uses. According to the State Water Resources Control Board’s (SWRCB’s) GeoTracker website, the Project site was the PG&E Kern Power Plant from 1948 until it was shut down in 1985. The Site consisted of two natural gas and oil burning power generation facilities, four above-ground fuel oil tanks, cooling towers, switchyards, substations, support buildings, and discharge pond. PG&E stored fuel oil in the four above-ground storage tanks and had a combined capacity of 10,150,000 gallons. Blowdown and wastewater generated during maintenance activities on the cooling system and during routine plant operations was discharged to a drainage pond. Previously the Site had cooling towers that were demolished and the surrounding area was remediated for soil contamination.

The 230-kilovolt substation that was added between 1956 and 1961 is still in operation. In October of 2001 the old incinerator and associated debris piles were removed and the soil underneath was remediated.

The Site is adjacent to the Former Sunland Refinery and has been impacted by their hydrocarbon plume.”1 The Site is also under a Land Use Control document (LUC) that was executed in February 2019. The LUC was executed due to the presence of hazardous substances and hazardous materials, as defined in Health and Safety Code section 25260, at the Property, the Regional Water Board has concluded that it is reasonably necessary to restrict the use of the Property to protect present or future human health or safety or the environment, and that this Covenant is required as part of the Regional Water-Board-approved remedy for the Property.

The LUC states that “Soil at the Property is contaminated with total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) as diesel (TPH-d), TPH as motor oil (TPH-mo), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), and Title 22 metals. The conditions at the Property are more extensively described in Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-78
the North Area Remedial Action Completion Report (approved by Regional Water Board on Dec. 6, 2016) and the South Area Remedial Action Completion Report (approved by Regional Water Board on Feb. 1, 2018). These reports and related documents are available on the State Water Resources Control Board's GeoTracker Database (Site ID# SL T5FP024290).”2 The site lies within the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SJVAB), which is designated nonattainment for ozone, PM2.5, and PM10, and is regulated by the SJVAPCD.

Footnotes:

1. SWRCB. 2026. https://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/profile_report?global_id=SLT5FP024290 accessed August 10, 2026.

2. SWRCB. 2026. Land Use Covenant.
https://documents.geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/regulators/deliverable_documents/1239606559/KP P_Recorded_L UC_20190206.pdf
Response No. O2A-2
This comment regarding the setting of the Project Site is noted for the record. No further response is required and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted. fJ YRICU
c.ou, c,
ha11 tr
RloBr.:i,o
Unr.,cnJty, B:ak_of!lhold $1!.~LN OAK$
CAMPUS PAIi(
Figure 1: Project Site Location
East
Bak•rnficld
Bakersfield Hillw~s1
UANOlRi

SIINSFT I
Kllrond«
CITV IN RI O BRA.110
~E t-l l LLS:
~,s,,n
@
TRrlna
Boken,fisl
Mtricipal Airport
PJ11pkin
cen·ff
El AdclJc
Fute-Paes
Lamon
@
Wccdpctch
DiCoo-gio
Edmurooon
.IICi,$
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-79
Comment No. O2A-3

ENVIRONMENTAL AND COMMUNITY SETTING
The Project Site is located in an urbanized area of northwest Bakersfield, on the south side of Rosedale Highway between El Toro Viejo Road to the west and Coffee Road to the east, north of the railroad tracks, on the former PG&E Kern Power Plant property (DEIR, Section 2 and Figure 2-2, Local Vicinity Map).

The land-uses immediately surrounding the Project Site are predominantly commercial and utility/industrial rather than residential. To the north are Rosedale Highway and the Northwest Promenade commercial retail center; to the east are Coffee Road, the Friant-Kern Canal, and a commercial retail center; to the south are a Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) electric substation, vacant land, and the railroad tracks; and to the west are El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a second PG&E electric substation. In addition, the former Sunland/World Oil refinery lies approximately 980 feet to the east. It is clear that the Project Site is ringed by a number of pollution-generating businesses, including two electric substations, an active rail line, the Rosedale Highway corridor, and a former refinery with open cleanup cases (see Comment 5).

Residential and other sensitive receptors are located a few hundred feet to roughly a quarter-mile from the Project Site, principally to the west, southwest, and north. As identified in the DEIR’s health risk analysis, the nearest off-site sensitive receptors include a mobile-home park approximately 750 feet to the west, single-family residences approximately 800 feet to the southwest, and single-family residences approximately 1,300 feet to the north, together with two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road that the DEIR conservatively assumes to be residences (DEIR, Section 4.3). The presence of a mobile-home park among the nearest receptors is notable, because mobile-home populations tend to include a higher proportion of elderly and lower-income residents; those groups that are among the most susceptible to air-pollution exposure.

Figure 2: Site Vicinity Map
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-80
Response No. O2A-3
This comment describing the Project Site area and surrounding land uses is noted for the record. No further response is required and no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. O2A-4
Although the census tract in which the Project is located is not a designated disadvantaged community, the adjacent census tracts are designated as SB 535 communities. According to the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results reported in Appendix B, the tract ranks in approximately the 99th percentile statewide for fine respirable particulate matter (PM2.5) and the 94th percentile for ozone (O3), with elevated burdens for drinking water (73rd percentile), traffic (67th percentile), diesel particulate matter (55th percentile), groundwater threats (60th percentile), and hazardous-waste facilities and generators (54th percentile).

The tract’s overall CalEnviroScreen 4.0 score is 30, and it is not designated under Senate Bill 535, Assembly Bill 1550, or Assembly Bill 617. That composite score is held below the SB 535 disadvantaged-community threshold primarily by the tract’s moderate socioeconomic and sensitive-population indicators (for example, poverty in approximately the 22nd percentile, housing burden in the 16th, education in the 30th, and asthma in the 21st) and not by its air quality. It must be pointed out that this community breathes some of the most polluted air in California even though its blended CalEnviroScreen score falls just below the disadvantaged-community cutoff.

This setting is directly relevant to the comments that follow. The DEIR’s failure to disclose the CalEnviroScreen results and this pollution-burden context (Comment 3), its omission of an operational health risk assessment for nearby receptors that include a mobile-home park (Comment 2), and its silence on the Valley Fever hazard (Comment 4) are each the more significant because they arise in a community already at or near the top of the State’s PM2.5 and ozone burden.

Response No. O2A-4
The commenter’s overview of CalEnviroScreen 4.0 data for the Project Site area is acknowledged. The commenter’s comments regarding pollution burden context is addressed in response to Comment O2A-8 below. Comments regarding an operational health risk evaluation is addressed in Response to Comment O2A-7. Comments regarding Valley Fever are addressed in response to Comments O2A-9 through 13.

Comment No. O2A-5

AIR QUALITY

1. The Project’s Operational Criteria-Pollutant Emissions Exceed SJVAPCD Thresholds and Are Offset Solely Through a VERA Payment, With No Feasible On-Site Reductions.

The DEIR finds that the Project’s operational emissions of VOCs (expressed as reactive organic gases or ROGs; approximately 14.6 tons per year) and oxides of nitrogen or NOx (approximately 10.3 tons per year) exceed the SJVAPCD operational significance thresholds of 10 tons per year each.3These exceedances are driven mainly by the mobile-source (vehicle trip) emissions.4 To offset the foreseeable exceedance, the DEIR relies on mitigation measure MM AQ-1, in which the proponent would enter an offset-based Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-81
Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the SJVAPCD. Critically, MM AQ-1 achieves the reduction entirely through a payment to the air district; it imposes no on-site emission reductions.

The DEIR should first identify all feasible on-site measures (for example, the measures the SJVAPCD itself recommended during scoping) and only rely on offset fees for the residual, unavoidable increment.

Relatedly, the SJVAPCD’s Notice of Preparation (NOP) scoping comments set out specific recommendations for the air-quality analysis and for mitigation.5 Footnotes:
3 San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD), Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI), which establishes operational significance thresholds of 10 tons per year for reactive organic gases (ROG/VOC) and 10 tons per year for oxides of nitrogen (NOx). 4 DEIR, Section 4.3 (Air Quality) and Appendix B (Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas, and Energy Technical Study), operational.CalEEMod output and mitigation measure MM AQ-1 (Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement).
5 DEIR, Appendix A (Notice of Preparation and scoping comments), SJVAPCD comment letter, at pp. 18 and 20.

Response No. O2A-5
The City disagrees with commenter’s assertion that project-operation emissions of criteria pollutants are being addressed solely through the Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) program prescribed under Mitigation Measure AQ-1 (MM AQ-1). In addition to MM AQ-1, the Draft EIR also includes MM AQ-2 in addition to MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7.
• Building and Energy-related Mitigation Measures that Reduce Emissions. Implementation of MM AQ-2 would require architectural paints and coatings to have a VOC content of 25 grams per liter or less, which would contribute to reducing VOC emissions. Under MM GHG-1, except for commercial cooking uses, buildings would be designed and constructed as all-electric. Thus, this measure would reduce onsite energy sector criteria air pollutant emissions, including VOCs and NOX, by reducing or eliminating onsite combustion of natural gas. Additionally, MM GHG-2 requires the property owner to enroll in an available 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, or the next highest carbon-free electricity plan available if a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available. Furthermore, MM GHG-3 requires landscaping equipment used in property management to be electric-powered only and would also contribute to reducing criteria air pollutant emissions.
• Transportation-related Mitigation Measures that Reduce Emissions. For transportation-related measures, MM GHG-5 would require the project proponent to coordinate with the Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements for up to two bus stops. Under MM GHG-6, an end-of-trip shower facility would be installed at the project site. These two measures would help promote and encourage public and active transit and contribute to reducing single-occupancy vehicle trips.

Lastly, implementation of MM GHG-7 would require the project to comply with the California Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-82
Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) Voluntary Tier 2 electric vehicle (EV) parking standards, which would result in the installation of EV infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements.

Thus, the Draft EIR has identified feasible mitigation measures that would contribute to reducing criteria air pollutant emissions and of which would be supplemented by the VERA under MM AQ-1. In addition, the SJVAPCD in its comments on the Notice of Preparation (NOP) for the proposed Project, identified the VERA program as recommended potential mitigation measure.1 Overall, SJVAPCD identifies the VERA program as a recommended and feasible CEQA mitigation measure and does not have requirements of when it may or may not be used for development projects that exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds (SJVAPCD 2015). In addition, a Condition of Approval (CoA) to the site was added to require a health risk assessment to be prepared prior to installation of any future under-fired charbroilers. Under the CoA, if it is determined that health risk impacts would exceed the District’s 20 in a million for cancer risk threshold and/or hazard index of 1, the HRA shall identify measures and demonstrate their effectiveness to reduce health risk impacts associated with the proposed under-fired charbroiler(s) to below these significance thresholds.

Comment No. O2A-6
Analysis Recommendations:

1. Performing a detailed review of construction and operational emissions, analyzing mobile and stationary sources separately. This was only partly done. The DEIR quantified construction and operational criteria-pollutant emissions in CalEEMod and analyzed the mobile-source component. The DEIR never separately quantified the operational stationary-source TACs (gas-station benzene, restaurant charbroilers), deferring them to Regulation II permitting. So the "analyze stationary operational emissions separately" instruction went unfulfilled for exactly the sources SJVAPCD flagged (Comment 2).

2. Characterize and justify an appropriate HHD truck trip-length. The DEIR failed to perform this step. The DEIR used the CalEEMod default 40-mile one-way trip length with no site-specific justification, despite SJVAPCD expressly asking for one. Asshown in Comment 2, that assumption understates operational NOₓ (a Building-1-type drayage scenario roughly doubles it), and it also feeds the AAQA below.

3. Evaluate risk to sensitive receptors and mitigate significant risk. The DEIR performed only half of the task. The DEIR performed a construction HRA (MEIR ≈1.5 in a million, below threshold) but never evaluated operational health risk to the identified sensitive receptors (the adjacent mobile-home park and residences) from the gas station and charbroilers. This is another example of the DEIR deferring analysis (Comments 2, 3).
1 Appendix A of the DEIR.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-83

4. Perform an Ambient Air Quality Analysis if emissions exceed 100 lb/day. This step was only partially met. The DEIR did an AAQA (Appendix D; AERMOD dispersion, triggered by operational CO ≈385 lb/day). But the AAQA used the unjustified 40-mile truck trip length from recommendation 2, so its inputs carry the same defect.

5. Discuss VERA feasibility. This was addressed in the DEIR but is incomplete. The DEIR adopted a VERA (MM AQ-1), but it went straight to an offset-only payment with no feasible on-site VOC/NOₓ reductions first, which is the sequencing problem in Comment 1.

Mitigation recommendations

1. Use the cleanest available off-road construction equipment. Not adopted in the DEIR. Because construction criteria-pollutant emissions came in below thresholds, the DEIR imposed no Tier 4 / cleanest-equipment construction requirement. This recommendation simply wasn't carried into a measure.

2. Evaluate HHD truck routing to limit exposure of residents/sensitive receptors. This measure was never performed. The DEIR only noted trucks would use the designated truck routes (Rosedale Highway, Coffee Road); it performed no routing analysis and adopted no routing measure to steer trucks away from the adjacent homes.

3. Use the cleanest available Heavy-Duty Trucks. This mitigation measure was not adopted. No requirement for recent-model-year, near-zero, or zero-emission delivery trucks; even though mobile sources drive both the NOₓ exceedance and the significant-and-unavoidable GHG impact (this is precisely the added mitigation urged in Comment 9).

4. Ensure compliance with the anti-idling regulations (13 CCR §§ 2485, 2480). Not adopted as a mitigation measure. These appear only in the regulatory-setting discussion, not as an enforceable, verifiable project condition.

5. Address concerns regarding under-fired charbroilers. No mitigation measures were adopted. The DEIR neither quantified charbroiler TAC/PM emissions nor required charbroiler emission controls (e.g., catalytic or flameless units); it deferred to permitting (Comment 2).

The DEIR should be reviewed for each instance in which it deviates from those recommendations. In particular they should be evaluated where the DEIR represents that its approach is consistent with SJVAPCD guidance; and for whether it adequately considered and adopted the on-site mitigation measures that the District recommended.

Response No. O2A-6
The following provides a point-by-point response to each of the “Analysis Recommendations” presented by the commenter.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-84

1. The SJVAPCD NOP comment referenced by the commenter appears to be Comment 1b from the SJVAPCD NOP comment letter dated November 25, 2025, and included as Appendix A to the Draft EIR. This Comment 1b specifically states, “[o]perational (ongoing) air emissions from mobile sources and stationary sources should be analyzed separately.” Contrary to the commenter’s assertion, Comment 1b only specified that mobile sources and stationary sources should be analyzed separately, but did not state that the Draft EIR was required to quantify stationary sources.

As recommended in Comment 1b, the Draft EIR did provide a separate analysis of the potential impacts associated with stationary sources on pages 4.3-31 and 4.3-32. The analysis relied on the land use compatibility screening criteria developed by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) for its Air Quality and Land Use Handbook (Handbook) (CARB 2005). CARB is the state agency that oversees the overall air quality for the state and the Handbook is a general reference guide for evaluating potential health effects associated with siting sensitive receptors proximate to sources of toxic air contaminants (TACs). The Handbook’s land use screening criteria (e.g., for gas stations, warehouses, and busy roadways) were derived based on health studies and data compiled by CARB. In addition to use of the Handbook to evaluate potential impacts, the Draft EIR references SJVAPCD Regulation II permitting process to note that it is the regulatory framework implemented by SJVAPCD to control potential air quality impacts associated with stationary sources subject to it, such as gas stations. The Regulation II permitting process for stationary-source equipment would ensure that applicable emissions standards are met as stationary-source equipment subject to permitting that does not meet the applicable permitting emissions standards would not be issued a permit to construct and/or permit to operate by SJVAPCD. Therefore, stationary sources subject to Regulation II would not be allowed to operate unless they meet the applicable SJVAPCD requirements.

2. The Draft EIR did not utilize CalEEMod defaults in determining heavy-duty truck travel distance.

Instead, and as stated on page 61 of Appendix B of the Draft EIR, vehicle miles traveled (VMT) associated with heavy-duty trucks were calculated using the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional travel demand model, which is calibrated to account for travel specific to heavy-duty trucks.

3. As discussed above and contrary to commenter’s assertion, the Draft EIR did evaluate operational health risks associated with stationary sources. The evaluation was based on the land use compatibility screening criteria from CARB’s Handbook in addition to reliance on SJVAPCD’s Regulation II permitting requirements for stationary sources subject such as gas stations and chain-driven charbroilers.

4. As commenter noted, the Draft EIR prepared an operation ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) (see pages 4.3-28 to 4.3-29). However, as discussed above, the VMT for heavy-duty trucks was based on the KernCOG regional travel demand model, which is calibrated to account for travel specific to heavy-duty trucks. Therefore, assumptions regarding the heavy-duty truck travel distance are supported and the operational AAQA is valid.

5. See Response to O2A.5.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-85
The following provides a point-by-point response to each of the “Mitigation recommendations” presented by the commenter.

1. The commenter correctly notes that Project-related construction emissions of criteria air pollutants would not exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines 15126.4(a)(1), because the Project would not result in generating construction-related criteria air pollutant emissions that exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds, no mitigation measures were identified as none would be necessary.

2. The Draft EIR evaluated potential health risk impacts to residents and other sensitive receptors associated with heavy-duty truck travel along roadways. As discussed on pages 4.3-31 and 4.3-32, the Draft EIR evaluated the potential health risk impacts of heavy-duty trucks traveling along roadways to the CARB Handbook siting criteria for busy roadways and freeways. The CARB Handbook screening criteria for busy roadways and freeways recommends that sensitive receptors should avoid being sited within 500 feet of urban roadways and freeways with 100,000 vehicles per day. As discussed in the Draft EIR, the highest projected roadway volume generated by operation of the proposed project along the local roadways would be 5,934 average daily trips (ADT) for the segment of Coffee Road between Jet Way and Brimhall Road. This volume includes all vehicle types such as passenger vehicles and heavy-duty delivery trucks associated with operation of the proposed project. Overall, the overall Project-related roadway volume of 5,934 ADTs would be substantially below the CARB Handbook screening roadway volumes.

Additionally, because the proposed Project would not have any warehousing uses and would primarily consist of retail, restaurant, and commercial uses, it can be reasonably anticipated that project-related trips would primarily consist of passenger vehicles associated with patrons. Per the KernCOG regional model and the vehicle trip fleet mix it internally generated for the Project in its calculation of the Project VMT, Project-related heavy-duty truck trips comprise only 0.15 percent (i.e., 23 average daily trips [ADTs] of 14,904 ADT) of total Project-generated trips. When applied to the anticipated total weekday and weekend Project-generated ADTs that would range between 18,921 ADTs to 28,479 ADTs, this fleet mix percentage results in 29 to 44 heavy-duty truck trips per day.

Furthermore, when considering the total roadway volumes under buildout year with Project conditions that account for both ambient volumes and Project-generated volumes, the highest roadway volume, which would occur on the segment of Coffee Road between Brimhall Road and the Westside Parkway eastbound ramp, would be 62,948 ADTs and also fall below the 100,000 vehicles per day screening criterion. As disclosed in the Draft EIR potential health risk impacts associated with heavy-duty truck travel along roadways would be less than significant. Therefore, no mitigation measure would be necessary.

3. A measure to require tenants/business operators to only use zero-emission medium-heavy duty and heavy-heavy duty vendor trucks was considered. However, this type of measure was rejected as infeasible due to the retail commercial nature of the proposed Project. It is anticipated that the tenants/business operators would not own their own truck fleets and thus, the types of goods delivery/vendor trucks received by the tenants/business operators would be dependent on third- Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-86
party truck fleet operators. Therefore, the types of trucks delivering goods to the tenants/business operators would not be in their control.

However, the Draft EIR includes Mitigation Measures (MM) GHG-5 through GHG-7, which are transportation-related measures that complement MM AQ-1 and MM AQ-2, in addition to MM GHG-1 through GHG-4. MM GHG-5 would require the Project proponent to coordinate with the Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements (e.g., bus shelter) for up to two bus stops.

Under MM GHG-6, an end-of-trip shower facility would be installed at the Project Site. These two measures would help promote and encourage public and active transit and contribute to reducing single-occupancy vehicle trips. Lastly, implementation of MM GHG-7 would require the Project to comply with the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) Voluntary Tier 2 electric vehicle (EV) parking standards, which would result in the installation of electric vehicle infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements.

From a regional air quality impact perspective, implementation of MM AQ-1, which would require the project to enter into a VERA with SJVAPCD, would offset Project-operation criteria air pollutant emissions remaining after implementation of the other prescribed mitigation measures to below SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds. Therefore, regional air quality impacts would be reduced to less than significant with incorporation of mitigation. In addition, the Draft EIR evaluated potential localized air quality impacts to offsite receptors near the Project Site from TACs and criteria air pollutants through assessment of potential health risk impacts and the ambient air quality assessment, respectively. These impacts were determined to be less than significant and therefore, localized air quality impacts would be less than significant.

4. Because California Code of Regulations Sections 2480 and 2485 of Title 13 are codified anti-idling regulations and are legally binding, the underlying presumption is that the Project would comply with these two rules.

5. While the Project would include high-turnover restaurant uses, future tenants which may occupy those spaces are unknown at this time and are, therefore, considered speculative pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15145, Speculation. No tenants have been identified within the commercial retail building; and therefore, it is unknown whether these uses would be retail or restaurant, and if restaurant whether they would require use of charbroilers at all. While some fast-food restaurants that use under-fired charbroilers may ultimately occupy these tenant spaces, it is also speculative how much meat product, what cooking appliance type, and what emission generation would result from these activities. Therefore, the presence of charbroilers within the Project Site is considered speculative.

Nonetheless, a Condition of Approval (CoA) will apply in connection with site plan approval that will provide that should a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler be proposed within the Project Site, a health risk assessment shall be required to ensure that project features would reduce risk levels to below the SJVAPCD performance standards.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-87
Comment No. O2A-7

2. The DEIR Fails to Quantify Operational Health Risk From the Gas Station and Restaurant Char-Broilers and Improperly Defers That Analysis to Permitting.

A construction-phase health risk assessment (HRA) was prepared, included as an appendix to the DEIR, and it reports a maximally exposed individual resident (MEIR) cancer risk of approximately

1.5 in one million—below the SJVAPCD threshold of 20 in one million—with a maximally exposed worker risk of approximately 0.3 in one million and a hazard index below 1.0.6 The operational phase, however, was not analyzed. According to the DEIR, “Because the proposed project would not have any warehousing uses and would primarily consist of retail, restaurant, and commercial uses, it anticipated that project-related traffic volumes would primarily consist of passenger vehicles associated with patrons. Thus, the incremental increase in vehicle trips that could result from implementation of the proposed project would be below roadway volumes identified by the CARB land use siting screening criteria to avoid exposing sensitive receptors to substantial concentration of air pollutants from vehicles traveling along roadway. Therefore, operation of the proposed project would not expose nearby off-site sensitive receptors to substantial concentrations of TACs.”7The DEIR does not quantify operational toxic air contaminant (TAC) emissions from the Project’s 40-dispenser gasoline dispensing facility (a known benzene source) or from the restaurant under-fired char-broilers. Instead, the DEIR states that operational TAC emissions are deferred to SJVAPCD Regulation II permitting. That deferral conflicts with SJVAPCD’s recommendation that operational emissions be included in the analysis (see DEIR, Appendix A, p. 20).

Fueling Station
Figure 3: Conceptual Site Plan
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-88
A 40-dispenser, high-throughput gasoline dispensing facility located adjacent to the restaurants and situated near sensitive receptors can generate meaningful benzene and other TAC exposures, and commercial char-broilers are a recognized source of particulate matter and TAC emissions (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs).

Footnotes:
6 DEIR, Section 4.3 (Air Quality) and Appendix B, construction-phase health risk assessment results (maximally exposed individual resident cancer risk of approximately 1.5 in one million; maximally exposed worker approximately 0.3 in one million; hazard index below 1.0), each below the applicable SJVAPCD thresholds (20 in one million; hazard index of 1.0). 7 DEIR Appendix B, Section 5.2.1 (Air Quality Impacts) at pp 69; DEIR Section 4.3 at pp 4.3-32.

Response No. O2A-7
The SJVAPCD Regulation II is an adopted mandatory framework and the established New Source Review program of SJVAPCD to oversee new stationary sources. Stationary sources subject to Regulation II must comply with and do not have the option to bypass Regulation II requirements. Thus, compliance with Regulation II and its requirements may be presumed and does not constitute a deferment. Overall, the SJVAPCD Regulation II permitting process would be separate from the general occupancy permits issued by the City and would provide controls for emissions associated with any new stationary equipment associated with the Project that are subject to the regulation. The permitting process for stationary-source equipment would ensure that applicable emissions standards are met as stationary-source equipment subject to permitting that does not meet the applicable permitting emissions standards would not be issued a permit to construct and/or permitted to operate by SJVAPCD.

Comment No. O2A-8

3. The DEIR Omits Analysis of Extreme Pollution-Burden Indicators in its Cumulative Impacts Analysis
Although the Project census tract is not designated as a SB 535 disadvantaged community (its CalEnviroScreen 4.0 score is approximately 30), and it is neither an AB 1550 low-income community nor an AB 617 community, it is, however, located immediately adjacent to a census tract that is a designated SB 535 disadvantaged community, and its pollution-burden indicators are extreme: PM2.5 in roughly the 99th percentile statewide, ozone in roughly the 94th percentile, and diesel particulate matter in roughly the 55th percentile (with drinking-water and traffic burdens also elevated).8The DEIR fails to analyze this these facts in its assessment of the Project’s cumulative impacts; the CalEnviroScreen determination is buried within a CalEEMod/technical appendix rather than addressed in the air-quality analysis.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-89
I recommend the DEIR be revised to disclose the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results, acknowledge the Project’s immediate adjacency to an SB 535 disadvantaged community, and analyze the Project’s incremental contribution of criteria pollutants and TACs to an area already bearing near-worst-case PM2.5 and ozone burdens. This is relevant both as informational disclosure and to the cumulative-impacts analysis, and should be included in a revised DEIR.

Footnotes:
8 OEHHA/CalEPA, CalEnviroScreen 4.0. State designations referenced: SB 535 disadvantaged communities (CalEPA), AB 1550 low-income communities, and AB 617 communities (CARB). The Project census-tract determination and percentile indicators appear only within the CalEEMod/technical appendix and are not disclosed or analyzed in the DEIR text.

Response No. O2A-8
As stated by the commenter, the Air Quality Technical Analysis (see Draft EIR Appendix B) provided the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 score, as well as identified that the site was not a Senate Bill 535 disadvantaged community in its technical appendix. Specifically, this information was provided in the California Emissions Estimator Model modeling output files (see Appendix B of Draft EIR). CalEnviroScreen boundaries are based on the U.S. Census Bureau census tracts. The primary reason the adjacent census tract has a higher CalEnviroScreen score is because that census tract includes Highway 99, which carries high volumes of heavy-duty trucks. Project-related roadway volume proximate to the Project Site have a maximum of 5,934 ADTs and carry a lower volume of heavy-duty truck traffic.

The fact that an adjacent census tract has a higher CalEnviroScreen score bears no nexus to the Project Site or emissions generated by the Project. Furthermore, an ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) was Figure 4: Project Location and Nearest SB 535 Community Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-90
prepared to evaluate potential localized impacts on nearby receptors from project operation-related criteria air pollutant emissions. The AAQA evaluates whether operation of the proposed project may adversely contribute to the localized ambient concentrations of criteria air pollutants for the immediate areas surrounding the Project Site (see pages 4.3-28 to 4.3-29 of the Draft EIR).

The AAQA includes a portion of westernmost area of the census tract referenced by the commenter, which is across Coffee Road east of the project site. As shown in Table 4.3-13 of the Draft EIR and in accordance with SJVAPCD methodology, the concentrations (including PM2.5) compared to the ambient air quality standards (AAQS) include both the project-generated concentrations plus the ambient background concentrations for the area. Per SJVAPCD methodology, while the proposed project would elevate PM2.5 concentrations above the 24-hour National AAQS and the annual National AAQS and California AAQS, because project-generated PM2.5 concentrations would not exceed the SJVAPCD significant impact levels, the potential for operation of the proposed project to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would also be less than significant.

Regarding health risk impacts from toxic air contaminants, based on SJVAPCD methodology, potential health risk impacts are based on the incremental risk resulting from a project and do not consider existing ambient risk levels.

Comment No. O2A-9

HAZARDS AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS

4. Valley Fever (Coccidioidomycosis) Is a Known Soil Hazard That the DEIR Does Not Address at All.

Kern County has among the highest rates of Valley Fever (coccidioidomycosis) in California. The disease is caused by inhalation of Coccidioides spores that are aerosolized when soils are disturbed and by windblown dust.9 Grading and excavation across an approximately 46-acre site in this setting can generate fugitive dust carrying spores, exposing construction workers and nearby residents.

The DEIR fails to address at all the known presence and significant risk of Coccidiodes Immitis (Valley Fever fungus) in Central California. Under California Labor Code Section 6709[e], Kern County is an area known to have a high endemic rate of Valley Fever. According to the California Department of Public Health Valley Fever Website10 the number of Valley Fever illnesses in Kern County ranged from 948 in 2001 (a rate of 139.5 per 100,000 population) to 3,873 in 2024 (a rate of 428.2 in 100,000). Based on the provisional reports from the CDPH for 2025, 1,872 cases were reported in Kern County to CDPH and in the first 8 months of 2026 1,848 cases of Valley Fever have been reported to CDPH. Since Valley Fever cases are directly related to the disturbance of soils in the area, the City must directly address the impacts that the Project’s construction phase will have on the community.

Footnotes:
9 California Department of Public Health, Coccidioidomycosis (Valley Fever) surveillance; Kern County reports among the highest incidence rates in California. Coccidioides spores are aerosolized by soil disturbance and windblown dust
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-91
10 https://www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CID/DCDC/Pages/ValleyFeverDashboard.aspx Response No. O2A-9
While Valley Fever is associated with soil disturbance, impacts associated with Valley Fever are related to the Coccidioides fungal spore, which is a biological agent. In general, a CEQA-level air quality framework and analysis evaluates potential impacts associated with criteria air pollutants and toxic air contaminants, which are chemical pollutants. However, ground disturbing activities can aerosolize fungal spores present in project soils, creating a potential inhalation exposure pathway. Risk is generally elevated during dry, windy conditions and in years following drought (dry soil is more easily aerosolized), and disturbance of previously undisturbed or long-undisturbed soils poses higher risk than disturbance of soils that have been recently worked. Fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever. Because the Project is a non-residential project that would disrupt more than five acres of land, it would be subject to SJVAPCD Rule 8021 to minimize fugitive dust during construction activities. Under Rule 8021, the proposed Project would be required to prepare and submit a Dust Control Plan (DCP) to the SJVAPCD for approval. The DCP would be required to detail specific actions to ensure that visible dust emissions do not exceed 20 percent opacity. These actions can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants. Compliance with Rule 8021 would help minimize generation of fugitive dust.

While the primary focus of Rule 8021 is to control fugitive dust particulate matter and not biological agents that may be mixed in with the fugitive dust, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed Project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupational safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices.

Title 8 CCR Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 CCR Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employers when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the proposed project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to the Section.

Overall, implementation of SJVAPCD fugitive dust control measures and compliance with workplace occupational safety and health requirements and Cal/OSHA oversight as discussed in the Draft EIR would minimize potential Valley Fever exposure to construction workers and no significant impacts would occur.

Comment No. O2A-10
Dust exposure is a primary risk factor for contracting Valley Fever (via Coccidiodes imimitis (cocci) exposure). When soil containing the cocci spores are disturbed by construction activities, the fungal spores become airborne, exposing construction workers and other nearby sensitive receptors. It is clear that the DEIR assumes that meeting San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District’s (SJV-APCD’s) rules regard construction (specifically Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities)) would be sufficient to control the impacts from Valley Fever exposure from the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-92
Project Site. District Rule 8021 requires limitation of fugitive dust emissions from construction, demolition, excavation, extraction, and other earthmoving activities, by implementing control measures such as pre-watering the Project site, phasing construction work to reduce the amount of disturbed surface at any one time, and applying water or other suppressants to unpaved haul/access roads and unpaved vehicle/equipment traffic areas. Rule 8021 relies on a visual-opacity reading for dust control and is insufficient to prevent exposure to Valley Fever spores. This rule is based on smoke-monitoring methods (U.S. EPA Methods 9 and 22) that require active monitoring by certified observers, rely on subjective observation, and are affected by variable such as lighting distance, and weather conditions. Due to these limitations, opacity readings do not provide accurate, continuous data on fine airborne particles Response No. O2A-10
Please refer to responses to Comments O2A-9 and O2A-12.

Comment No. O2A-11
It must be remembered that the most at-risk populations are construction and agricultural workers.11 Here, construction workers are the very population that would be most directly exposed by the Project.

A refereed journal article on occupational exposures notes that “[l]abor groups where occupation involves close contact with the soil are at greater risk, especially if the work involves dusty digging operations.”12 Footnotes:
11 Lawrence L. Schmelzer and R. Tabershaw, Exposure Factors in Occupational Coccidioidomycosis, American Journal of Public Health and the Nation’s Health, v. 58, no. 1, 1968, pp. 107–113, Table 3; available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1228046/?page=1. 12 Ibid., p. 110.

Response No. O2A-11
See response to Comment O2A-9. As stated, construction worker protections and safety would be managed through California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through Cal/OSHA oversight.

Comment No. O2A-12
To address these shortcomings, the City should require active monitoring with dust monitors (particle measuring devices) immediately outside of the facility and around its perimeter. Continuous particle measures would offer several advantages. It eliminates the subjectivity inherent in visual opacity readings, leading tomore reliable andconsistentdata. It allowsforreal-timetrackingofdustparticle levels, enabling prompt corrective actionsif thresholds are exceeded. Active monitoring also offers a robust data set that can be used for repeatability test and to validate compliance with air quality standards.

Incorporating active dustmonitoring systemswouldensure that air quality impacts are accurately assessed and mitigated, fulfilling the intent of the mitigation measures and conditions of compliance to protect public health and the environment
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-93
Response No. O2A-12
See response to Comment O2A-9. In addition, active monitoring does not provide any more effective control in potentially minimizing Valley Fever than the requirements under Rule 8021. In general, active dust monitors measure the mass or volume of airborne fugitive dust particles, but do not and cannot detect the presence of biological agents such as the Valley Fever fungal spore that may be embedded in the airborne fugitive dust. In addition, there is no direct correlation between fugitive dust particulate matter concentration levels and the levels of Valley Fever fungal spores that may be present in the air.

Furthermore, Section 6.3.3 of Rule 8021 requires active dust control measures (e.g., watering surfaces, use of dust suppressants, etc.) to be implemented before, during, and after any dust generating activity and not only when there is an exceedance of the 20 percent opacity criteria. The 20 percent opacity criteria is not a floor and does not set the trigger as to when control measures must be implemented.

Instead, it is the ceiling at which fugitive dust must be limited.

Comment No. O2A-13
The CalEEMOD analyses of Phase 2 and Phase 2 of the construction phase fail to include mitigation measures for dust suppression. Based on the conventional mitigation measures and modeling of dust movement in the CalEEMOD models watering exposes areas twice a day would reduce PM10 and PM2.5 emissions by 61 percent (61%). Increasing the watering frequency to 3 times per say would reduce PM10 and PM2.5 emissions by 74%. Conventional dust control measures primarily focus on visible dust or larger dust particles – the PM10 fraction –and fail to address the very fine particles that transport Valley Fever spore, which are approximately 5 times smaller than typical PM10 particles and remain airborne much longer.13 These fine particles, when disturbed by soil-disturbing activities, spread widely beyond site, posing a significant risk to both onsite workers and nearby communities.

California Labor Code Section 6709[e], requires awareness training on Valley Fever. The education component of Section 6709[e] would not protective enough to ensure worker safety. The City should require that the Proponent implement mitigation measures to actively suppress the spread of Valley Fever by:

1. Include specific requirements in the Project’s Injury and Illness Prevention Program (as required by Title 8, Section 3203) regarding safeguards to prevent Valley Fever.

2. Control dust exposure:
- Apply water to all disturbed areas a minimum of three times per day. Watering frequency should be increased to a minimum of four times per day if there is any evidence of visible wind-driven fugitive dust;
- Provide and require the use of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)- approved respirators for workers with a prior history of Valley Fever. - Require the use of half-face respirators equipped with a minimum N-95 protection factor for use during worker collocation with surface disturbance activities. Half-face respirators Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-94
equipped with N-100 or P-100 filters should be used during digging activities. Employees should wear respirators when working near earth-moving machinery. - Prohibit eating and smoking at the worksite, and provide separate, clean eating areas with hand-washing facilities.
- Avoid outdoor construction operations during unusually windy conditions or in dust storms. - Consider limiting outdoor construction during the fall to essential jobs only, as the risk of cocci infection is higher during this season.

3. Prevent transport of cocci outside endemic areas:
- Thoroughly clean equipment, vehicles, and other items before they are moved off-site to other work locations.
- Prevent spillage or loss of bulk material from holes or other openings in the cargo compartment’s floor, sides, and/or tailgate;
- Load all haul trucks such that the freeboard is not less than six inches when material is transported on any paved public access road and apply water to the top of the load and then cover haul trucks with a tarp or other suitable cover.
- Provide workers with coveralls daily, lockers (or other systems for keeping work and street clothing and shoes separate), daily changing and showering facilities. - Clothing should be changed after work every day, preferably at the work site. - Train workers to recognize that cocci may be transported offsite on contaminated equipment, clothing, and shoes; alternatively, consider installing boot-washing. - Post warnings onsite and consider limiting access to visitors, especially those without adequate training and respiratory protection.

4. Improve medical surveillance for employees:
- Employees should have prompt access to medical care, including suspected work-related illnesses and injuries.
- Work with a medical professional to develop a protocol to medically evaluate employees who have symptoms of Valley Fever.
- Consider preferentially contracting with 1-2 clinics in the area and communicate with the health care providers in those clinics to ensure that providers are aware that Valley Fever has been reported in the area. This will increase the likelihood that ill workers will receive prompt, proper and consistent medical care.
- Respirator clearance should include medical evaluation for all new employees, annual re-evaluation for changes in medical status, and annual training, and fit-testing.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-95
- Skin testing is not recommended for evaluation of Valley Fever.14 - If an employee is diagnosed with Valley Fever, a physician must determine if the employee should be taken off work, when they may return to work, and what type of work activities they may perform.

The City must adopt these evidence-based mitigation measures which have proven effective in similar constructionprojectsinendemic areasto ensure comprehensive protectionofpublichealth. Standard dust control measures are insufficient for preventing Valley Fever exposure, and only concrete, enforceable steps like those listed above will safeguard both onsite workers and surrounding communities. The requirements outlined above should be presented in a revised DEIR for the Project Site.

Footnotes:
13 See, e.g., Cummings and others, 2010, p. 509; Schneider et al., 1997, p. 908 (“Primary prevention strategies (e.g., dust-control measures) for coccidioidomycosis in endemic areas have limited effectiveness.”)
Response No. O2A-13
Please refer to responses to Comments O2A-9 and O2A-12.

Comment No. O2A-14

CONCLUSIONS
The facts identified and referenced in this comment letter lead me to reasonably conclude that the Project could result in significant impacts if allowed to proceed. A revised DEIR should be prepared to address these substantial concerns related to the construction and operational emissions from the Project that clearly were not identified in the DEIR.

Response No. O2A-14
Please see response to Comments O2A-1 to 13. Responses have been provided to address the comments and concerns of the commenter and demonstrate the overall adequacy of the Draft EIR’s analysis.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-96
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-97
Appendix No. O2B
Comment No. O2B-1
This comment is a copy of James J.J. Clark, Ph.D.’s resume.

Response No. O2B-1
The copy of the resume is acknowledged.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-98
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-99
Appendix No. O2C
Comment No. O2C-1
I have reviewed vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and trip generation impacts of the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”) dated July 2026 and make the following findings:
• Both the retail and medical office components of the project would have significant VMT impacts that would not be fully mitigated by the measures listed in the DEIR. • CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) would provide additional VMT mitigation.
• The DEIR mispresents the pass-by trip reduction for the gasoline service station component of the project.
• Trip generation and the pass-by percentage for the gasoline service station are highly uncertain because the proposed project with 40 fueling stations is significantly different than the sites in the database.
• The gasoline service station’s unique characteristics could result in more additional traffic and VMT than other smaller gasoline service stations.

Significant VMT Impact
The DEIR states that the project would have a significant VMT impact:

As demonstrated above in Table 4.16-3 and Table 4.16-4, the Project would result in a net increase in countywide roadway VMT under both existing and cumulative conditions, and that the Project’s medical office component would exceed the applicable VMT per employee threshold.

Accordingly, the Project would result in a potentially significant VMT impact under CEQA. (DEIR, p. 4.16-15 – 4.16.16)
The DEIR demonstrates that the retail component would have a significant VMT impact because it would result in higher County VMT.

The DEIR estimates that the medical office component VMT would exceed the significance threshold by

7.76%.

Response No. O2C-1
Please refer to response to Comments O2.34 through O2.36.

Comment No. O2C-2
More VMT Mitigation is needed.

The VMT mitigation listed in the DEIR includes: “enhanced pedestrian connectivity, new and expanded bicycle facilities, and end-of-trip bicycle amenities” drawn from the CAPCOA Handbook for Analyzing Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-100
Greenhouse Gas Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity (DEIR, p. 4-16.16) Nevertheless, the DEIR concludes:

However, the reduction in VMT from the design features would not reduce VMT impacts to a less than significant level. As such, the Project would result in a significant impact. No other feasible mitigation is available. (DEIR, p. 4.16-16)
There is other feasible mitigation available. I recommend that CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) be included. This measure would achieve an up to 4.0% reduction in VMT. The Handbook states:

Voluntary CTR programs must include the following elements to apply the VMT reductions reported in literature.
• Employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home.
• Information, coordination, and marketing for said services, infrastructure, and incentives (Measure T-7).

Response No. O2C-2
Please refer to response to Comments O2.34 through O2.36.

Comment No. O2C-3
DEIR misrepresents gasoline service station pass-by trip reduction DEIR Table 4.16-2 (p. 4.16-10) shows that the gasoline service stations would generate 10,196 daily trips including 816 internal capture trips and 7,316 pass-by trips.

The Traffic Study, DEIR Appendix H, states that there would be only 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips, for a total of 7,316 pass-by + diverted trips. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 361 of 984) The definitions of pass-by and diverted trips in DEIR Appendix H are consistent with standard usage, specifically:

Pass-by trips represent members (and trips) that are currently traveling on the surrounding street network forsome other primary purpose (such as a trip from work to home) and stop into the site enroute during their normal travel. As such, pass-by trips do not result in a net increase in traffic on the surrounding transportation system and their only effect occurs at the immediate intersections and site access driveways where they become turning movements.

Diverted trips are similar to pass-by trips in that they represent members (and trips) that are currently traveling on the surrounding street network for some other primary purpose and stop into the fuel facility site en route during their travel. However, as the name indicates, diverted trips divert from the normal roadways they would be traveling on to go to the Costco site. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 359 of 984)
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-101
The Institute of Transportation Engineers(“ITE”) illustration of these differencesisreproduced as Figure 1.

As shown in Figure 1, pass-by trips do not add traffic to other roadways, but diverted trips do add traffic to other roadways and add VMT. It is wrong to combine these and call all of these trips pass-by.

Regarding pass-by trips, DEIR Appendix H states:

Based on studies of customer surveys at Costco fuel facilities, an average of 30% and 29% of the members who purchase fuel during the weekday PM and Saturday midday peak hours, respectively, can be classified as pass-by trip capture from the surrounding street system (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 359 of 984).

Although the DEIR states that the diverted percentage also is based on Costco data (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 360 of 984), no backup information is given, including whether there is any mileage threshold for deviation from the primary route. Is a 1-mile diversion a diverted trip? What about a 5-mile diversion? Or 10 miles? Given this lack of documentation regarding diverted trips, the DEIR should report only the pass-by trips in Table 4.16-2.

Diverted trips add traffic to the street network and associated VMT, unlike pass-by trips, and they cannot be lumped together.

Figure 1: Primary, Poss-By and Diverted Trips
20 7
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-102
Response No. O2C-3
Please refer to response to Comments O2.32 and O2.33.

Comment No. O2C-4
Gasoline service station trip generation is highly uncertain The DEIR estimates the gasoline service station’s trip generation rate using the Costco transportation database, which contains data related to Costco fuel facilities. But the DEIR’s approach is not supported by substantial evidence. This is because the DEIR does not factor in that the proposed gasoline service station is significantly different than the sites included in the database. The proposed gasoline service station has more fueling positions, 40, than at any of the sites in the Costco database, and is also unique in that it is approximately 3 miles away from a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site. DEIR Appendix H states:

The Costco transportation database contains a large quantity of data related to Costco fuel facilities. Trip generation rates and trip type information for over 80 Costco fuel facilities located throughout the US are included. Costco has invested significant effort into developing this use-specific trip generation database because of the unique characteristics of Costco member travel that exist due to membership requirements and the nature of Costco sales. The transportation database consists of fuel facilities ranging from 12 to 32 fueling positions, at locations where the fuel facility is part of a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site. These unique elements apply to the trip generation for Costco warehouses, Costco fuel facilities, and the interaction of trips between the two.

For this Project, Costco is proposing a fuel station with 40 fueling positions as an independent facility where the nearest Costco Warehouse is located approximately 3 miles away. As such, the Project generated a need to assess site trip generation and queuing impacts based on a facility type that is outside the range of currently available Costco data. Despite a lack of empirical data for a site with 40 fueling positions and its unique characteristic as an independent fuel facility, the current database can still inform projections of trips and queues by investigating trends and through extrapolation. Just as the Trip Generation Manual is used by practitioners to estimate trips outside of available empirical data (through trend lines/regression curves), a similar approach can be taken with the available Costco data.

These differences mean that the trip generation rate does not reasonably reflect the proposed gasoline service station’s trip generation and pass-by trip percentage. In particular, there cannot be any combined gasoline/warehouse trips within the same site.

Response No. O2C-4
Please refer to response to Comment Nos O2.32 and O2.33.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-103
Comment Letter P1
Brian L. Cypher
[email protected]
August 21, 2026
Responses to Letter P1
Comment No. P1.1
I am providing comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project). My comments specifically address deficiencies in Section 4.4 – Biological Resources regarding the federally endangered and state threatened San Joaquin kit fox. This Section was largely based on the associated Appendix C: General Biological Assessment (GBA).

Response No. P1.1
The comment includes a general introduction to the overall comment letter and does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. P1.2
I have been observing San Joaquin kit foxes in Bakersfield since 1990 and have conducted research and conservation projects with the urban foxes since 1997. Most of this work was conducted while a research ecologist with and then Director of the California State University-Stanislaus, Endangered Species Recovery Program (ESRP). Although retired now, I still work with and assist the group that continues to work with urban kit foxes. Our collective experience with urban kit foxes sums to many decades.

Response No. P1.2
The comment outlines the commenter’s experience observing San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) in Bakersfield, and the commenter’s experience with research and conservation projects with urban foxes since 1997.

The comment is not directed at the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. P1.3
In Section 4.4 of the DEIR, the preparers conclude that kit foxes are not present on the Project site and that habitat for this species is not present. A further conclusion is that wildlife corridors are not present on the site. These conclusions apparently are based on a single site survey and assessment conducted by Hernandez Environmental Services, a group whose qualifications are unspecified. Based on the website for this group, they have no or little experience with San Joaquin kit foxes, particularly those inhabiting urban habitats in Bakersfield, or with San Joaquin Valley species and ecosystems in general.

Consequently, the conclusions presented in the DEIR and the GBA are patently incorrect on several accounts.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-104
Response No. P1.3
The commenter stated that the Draft EIR concluded that the SJKF and associated habitat is not present on the project site and that these conclusions were based on a single site survey conducted as a part of the GBA conducted for the project site. The commenter concluded that based on the biological resource consultant’s experience with SJKF, the findings of the Draft EIR and GBA are incorrect on several accounts.

In response to the commenter, a single survey is what is required for a GBA, and biologist qualifications can be submitted upon request. Please refer to responses provided to Comment Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the responses provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impacts to SJKF remain less than significant.

Comment No. P1.4
It is highly likely that kit foxes use the proposed Project site, if not regularly then at least on occasion. On a number of occasions, dead kit foxes have been found on Rosedale Highway or Coffee Road adjacent to the project site. These foxes in all likelihood were coming from or going to the Project site. Kit foxes also are routinely observed at the Northwest Promenade center and Lowe’s Home Improvement Center, both of which are just across the highway from the Project Site. During city-wide surveys using wildlife cameras, out group detected kit foxes in 2018, 2022, and 2024 in the storm water drainage basin on the west end of the Project Site (35.382275, -119.100788). In February of this year (2026) Lowe’s employees informed us that a kit fox we were trying to capture was going back and forth between Lowe’s and the Project site.

Response No. P1.4
Please refer to responses provided to Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the response provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impact to SJKF to remain less than significant.

Comment No. P1.5
Indeed, very recently (21 August 2026) a sick kit fox was captured directly across Coffee Road from the Project site along the Friant Kern Canal. Additionally, one or more reproducing kit fox family groups have been almost continuously present at the Central Valley Renewable Fuels facility less than a mile east of the Project site. The locations of the road mortality kit foxes as well as those that have been live-trapped for research or treatment purposes have been submitted to the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB). Granted, the CNDDB is woefully behind in entering submitted information. However, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) are aware of the locations. The standard procedure currently for surveying for kit foxes involves deploying and operating wildlife cameras for multiple days. It is unclear why the consultant performing surveys on the site for the project proponent did not employ this methodology. The failure to do so will most likely result in the CDFW and FWS rejecting the reported results and conclusions as blatantly inadequate.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-105
Response No. P1.5
Please refer to responses provided to the Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the response provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impact to SJKF to remain less than significant.

Comment No. P1.6
With regards to habitat, the disturbed ruderal habitat present on the Project site is one of the many types of urban habitat that kit foxes commonly use throughout Bakersfield. Use of this habitat has been abundantly documented in previous studies (see documents attached to the transmittal email). Also, extensive examples and evidence of use of this habitat could have been provided by any of the many environmental consulting groups that actually have experience with San Joaquin kit foxes in Bakersfield.

The California State University-Bakersfield campus, proposed Veteran’s Hospital site on Hageman road, and the Central Valley Renewable Fuels facility are all nearby examples (among many) of sites where kit foxes are using disturbed ruderal habitat. Again, CDFW and FWS are well aware of urban habitats used by kit foxes and will very likely reject this conclusion.

Response No. P1.6
Please refer to responses provided to the Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the response provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impact to SJKF to remain less than significant.

Comment No. P1.7
The conclusion regarding corridors further highlights the lack of experience and familiarity regarding kit foxes and San Joaquin Valley species in general. Clearly, there are no mountain canyons on the floor of the San Joaquin Valley. The logical conclusion is that kit foxes and other species in the Valley do not require such features for movement and dispersal. Also, kit foxes are adapted to arid lands and deserts and extensively avoid riparian corridors where their main predators, coyotes and bobcats, have abundant ambush cover. Kit foxes will move across any open space, such as the Project site. Indeed, we have documented radio-collared kit foxes moving over 12 kilometers (straight line) through the urban environment. They have an amazing capacity to get around, under, and through “barriers” such as fences and walls. They are able to squeeze through gaps as small as 3.5 inches. Thus, they would have no problem accessing the Project site.

Response No. P1.7
Please refer to responses provided to the Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the response provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impact to SJKF to remain less than significant.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-106
Comment No. P1.8
In summary, the Project site does indeed have habitat for kit foxes and kit foxes undoubtedly use the site and definitely traverse it. Given that, the assessments and conclusions regarding kit foxes and potential impacts to kit foxes require extensive revision, preferably by a group that actually has familiarity and experience with the species. Furthermore, the Project proponent definitely needs to obtain a 2081 Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from the CDFW and a 10(a)1(a) incidental take permit (aka Habitat Conservation Plan [HCP]) from the FWS. Failure to do so will most certainly result in litigation (and lengthy project delays) by one or more environmental groups, as has commonly occurred on other development projects in Bakersfield where project proponents failed to adequately assess impacts to kit foxes. Finally, applications for the ITP and HCP should include appropriate measures to avoid or mitigate impacts to kit foxes, in particular conducting proper surveys for kit foxes or their dens prior to any ground disturbance, proper excavation of any dens, exclusionary fencing (kit foxes commonly are attracted to construction sites; they were a daily occurrence on the recent Mercy Southwest Hospital expansion project), biological monitors on site during construction, and conservation measures such as the installation of artificial dens in quiet areas and fencing and walls that accommodate kit fox passage.

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the DEIR and GBA.

Response No. P1.8
Please refer to responses provided to the Letter A1 (CDFW comments). Based on the response provided to comment A1.5, and with implementation of the additional mitigation measures requested by CDFW (who is considered a trustee and responsible agency), any potential impact to SJKF to remain less than significant.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-107
Comment Letter P2
James Davis, Vice President of Real Estate
Jaco Oil Company
P.O. Box 82515
Bakersfield, CA 93308
[email protected]
August 24, 2026
Responses to Letter P2
Comment No. P2.1
Please accept these comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Study that was prepared for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project.

Response No. P2.1
This introductory comment introducing the purpose of the letter is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. P2.2
Trip Generation and Traffic Study for the future Costco Standalone Gas Facility with 40 fueling positions and carwash. Costco will be building a massive gas facility with 20 pumps and 40 fueling positions. The studies that were completed do not look consistent with similar studies that have been done for much smaller gas stations. For example, Fastrip had submitted a site plan to the City of Bakersfield to approve two driveway locations on Rosedale Highway for a future Fastrip gas station and convenience store located at the SEC of Rosedale and Calloway. The City of Bakersfield Public Works responded that Fastrip would only be allowed one driveway and would be required to install a 60-foot storage lane and install a Type A, ST3 driveway on the very east end of the property. This requirement would mean that Fastrip would lose almost 13 feet of property along Rosedale Highway. In addition, the single driveway and storage lane resulted in Fastrip losing parking spaces and significantly impacted onsite circulation. It should also be noted that there is a recorded agreement dated August 16, 2014 with the City of Bakersfield that stipulates that the City of Bakersfield will install 2 driveways along Rosedale highway at the corner of Rosedale and Calloway.

The Trip Generation Analysis and Traffic Study and the necessary mitigation measures appear to be inconsistent with how they have been applied to other shopping center projects in Bakersfield, CA. In addition, the Costco Fuel Facility Database was used in these studies, yet that database only provides data for Costco Fuel Facilities that are part of a Costco Warehouse. In addition, it appears that the data used was from Costco and not from an independent study.

Response No. P2.2
The commenter expresses concern that the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility, which would include 40 vehicle fueling positions and an associated carwash, has not been evaluated in a manner consistent Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-108
with smaller gasoline-service-station projects in the City of Bakersfield. The commenter specifically references access and driveway requirements applied to a separate proposed Fastrip gasoline station located at the southeast corner of Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive.

The proposed Costco fuel facility was incorporated into the Draft EIR transportation analysis (contained within Appendix H: Transportation Analysis and Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis) and evaluated based on the specific location, site characteristics, access opportunities, and circulation plan associated with the proposed development. The Draft EIR transportation analysis considered the anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed 40 fueling positions, site access, internal circulation, fueling-position queuing, and access-point operations.

The access and circulation requirements applicable to the separate Fastrip project referenced by the commenter do not establish that the same requirements are necessary or appropriate for the proposed Riverview Marketplace development. Each development is evaluated based on its specific site conditions, land use intensities, adjacent roadway characteristics, available right-of-way, traffic conditions, and circulation needs. The Project’s development includes a comprehensive circulation system and multiple access points that were evaluated as part of the Project traffic analysis, which is comparable to the existing Northwest Promenade shopping center.

The Project Site also provides adequate right-of-way along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road to accommodate an exclusive right-turn lane along the Project frontage, providing additional capacity and storage for vehicles entering and exiting the Project Site while minimizing interference with through traffic on the adjacent roadways.

Accordingly, the proposed Costco fuel facility and the overall Riverview Marketplace circulation system were evaluated based on the Project's site-specific characteristics and anticipated traffic conditions. The commenter’s comparison to access requirements applied to an unrelated gasoline-service-station project at a different location does not demonstrate that the Project traffic analysis or proposed access configuration is inadequate.

In addition, the commenter contends that the trip-generation analysis, traffic study, and associated mitigation measures are inconsistent with those applied to other shopping center projects in Bakersfield and questions the use of Costco fuel facility data because the available database includes facilities associated with Costco Warehouses.

The Project’sstandalone fuel facility was evaluated as part of the Project based on its specific location and site characteristics. Because the proposed facility includes 40 vehicle fueling positions and is not associated with a Costco Warehouse, no single published Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) land-use category precisely represents the proposed use. Accordingly, the trip-generation analysis considered both Costco-specific operating data and the closest applicable ITE trip-generation information to establish a reasonable and conservative estimate of traffic demand.

The Costco data provides actual operational information regarding customer and fueling characteristics at existing Costco locations with fuel facilities. In addition, the resulting Costco-based gross trip- Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-109
generation estimate was compared with the closest applicable ITE land-use categories to confirm the reasonableness and conservatism of the estimate used for the traffic analysis.

The proposed facility and overall Project development were evaluated based on the specific characteristics of the Project, including the anticipated traffic demand, access configuration, internal circulation system, and roadway conditions. Traffic analysis requirements and mitigation measures for other shopping center projects may differ based on site-specific conditions and therefore do not establish that the methodology or mitigation measures for the proposed Project are inadequate.

Accordingly, the analysis used available project-specific operational information together with applicable industry-standard trip-generation information and evaluated the resulting traffic conditions based on the characteristics of the proposed development. The commenter has not identified information demonstrating that the trip-generation methodology or traffic analysis is inadequate.

Comment No. P2.3
It is not clear if the fueling facility will have a Costco employee working there and assisting customers. In addition, it is not clear what the hours of operation will be at this specific facility. Will it be open 24 hours per day or limited to specific operational hours?
Response No. P2.3
The commenter requests clarification regarding whether the Project’s proposed fuel facility would be staffed and what its hours of operation would be, including whether the facility would operate 24 hours per day. The ultimate operating schedule and staffing arrangements for the proposed Costco fuel facility will be established by Costco and would be subject to applicable City requirements and approvals. The traffic analysis, however, evaluates the anticipated project peak traffic demand, which is not dependent solely on the facility's ultimate hours of operation or staffing arrangements.

Comment No. P2.4
Finally, was this particular section of the shopping center used for the Trip Generation Analysis and Traffic Study? Costco gas is known to have customers 5 or 6 cars deep, waiting for a fueling position to open up.

Was this taken into consideration in the Traffic Study that this particular section of the shopping center will experience significant onsite traffic issues? Is it possible that cars will be backing up on Rosedale Highway? If so, it would seem reasonable to require a dedicated right turn lane with 60 to 80 feet of storage.

Response No. P2.4
The commenter asks whether the proposed Costco fuel facility was specifically considered in the trip-generation and traffic analysis and expresses concern regarding potential queues at the fueling positions, internal circulation, and the possibility that vehicles could queue onto Rosedale Highway. The commenter also suggests that a dedicated right-turn lane with additional storage may be necessary.

The Project’s proposed Costco standalone fuel facility that includes 40 vehicle fueling positions, was incorporated into the Draft EIR’s transportation analysis (contained within Appendix H: Transportation Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 2 – Comments and Responses to Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

2.0-110
Analysis and Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis) and evaluated based on the Project and Project Site’s specific characteristics. The analysis took into consideration anticipated fueling demand, on-site pump queuing, access-point operations and queuing, and proposed internal circulation system.

The Project’s Site Plan provides approximately six-vehicle queue storage at the fueling positions, consistent with the queue conditions identified in the comment. Based on the Project’s queuing and circulation evaluation, the proposed internal circulation system provides adequate space and dedicated queue storage to accommodate vehicles waiting for access to the fueling positions. The purpose of this configuration is to allow potential fueling queues to remain within the Project Site and minimize the potential for queues to interfere with internal circulation or extend onto the adjacent public roadway system. Additionally, the Project’s Site Plan provides adequate right-of-way along Rosedale Highway to accommodate an exclusive right-turn lane along the Project frontage, which will provide capacity and storage space needed for vehicles entering and exiting the Project Site while minimizing interference with through traffic on fronting roadways.

Based on the transportation analysis results, the proposed internal circulation system and multiple access points do provide adequate capacity to address the anticipated ingress and egress demand associated with the overall Project, including the proposed Costco fuel facility without adversely affecting the operation of the adjacent public roadway system.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-1
Section 3.0 Errata to the Draft EIR

3.1 INTRODUCTION TO THE ERRATA
The Draft EIR for the Riverview Marketplace Project, dated July 2026, is hereby incorporated by reference as part of the Final EIR. Changes to the Draft EIR are further detailed below.

The changes to the Draft EIR do not affect the overall conclusions of the environmental document, and instead represent changes to the Draft EIR that provide clarification, amplification and/or insignificant modifications, as needed, as a result of public comments on the Draft EIR, or due to additional information received during the public review period. These clarifications and corrections do not warrant Draft EIR recirculation pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.

None of the changes or information provided in the comments reflect a new significant environmental impact, a substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact for which mitigation is not proposed, or a new feasible alternative or mitigation measure that would clearly lessen significant environmental impacts but is not adopted. In addition, the changes do not reflect a fundamentally flawed or conclusory Draft EIR.

Changes to the Draft EIR are listed by Section, page, paragraph, etc. to best guide the reader to the revision. Changes are identified as follows:
• Deletions are indicated by strikeout text.
• Additions are indicated by underline text.

3.2 CHANGES TO THE DRAFT EIR
Executive Summary
Page ES-10 through ES-13, Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures is revised as follows:

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-2
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance after
Mitigation
Section 4.3: Air Quality
AQ-1: Would the project
conflict with or obstruct
implementation of the
applicable air quality plan?
MM AQ-1: Prior to issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall enter into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) to mitigate regional air quality impacts associated with emissions of VOC and NOX generated by operation of the proposed project. At minimum, the VERA shall be crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department (City), that verifies, to the City’s satisfaction, completion execution of the VERA.

Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
BIO-1: Would the project have
a substantial adverse effect,
either directly or through
habitat modifications, on any
species identified as a
candidate, sensitive, or special
status species in local or
regional plans, policies, or
regulations, or by the
California Department of Fish
and Wildlife or U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service?
MM BIO-2: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls. In the event a burrowing owl or known burrowing owl den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b), shall be necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-4: San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF) Pre-Construction Surveys. Pre-construction surveys to assess presence/absence of denning San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) shall be conducted by the qualified biologist no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days prior to the commencement of any ground disturbance and/or construction activities or any project activity likely to impact the SJKF. Surveys shall identify kit fox habitat features occurring on the project site (if any are determined to occur during the surveys) and evaluate use by SJKF and, if possible, assess the potential impacts to the kit fox by the proposed activity. If a natal/pupping den is discovered within the project site or within 200 feet of the project site boundary, the appropriate agencies (e.g., California Department of Fish and Wildlife, City of Bakersfield) shall be immediately notified and under no circumstances shall the den be disturbed or destroyed without prior authorization. If the preconstruction survey reveals an active natal pupping or new information, the project applicant, construction contractor and biologist shall contact the appropriate agencies immediately to obtain the necessary take authorization/permit. Written results of the preconstruction surveys shall be submitted to the appropriate agencies within five days after survey completion and prior to the start of ground disturbance and/or construction activities.

MM BIO-5: SJKF Avoidance Buffer. Prior to the commencement of any ground disturbing activities, the project applicant, construction contractor and project biologist shall implement no-disturbance buffers as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites identified during the pre-construction surveys outlined in Mitigation Measure BIO-4.

Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-3
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance after
Mitigation
MM BIO-6: SJKF Take Authorization. If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in Mitigation Measures BIO-5 are not feasible, the project applicant and California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) shall discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, the project applicant shall obtain take authorization from CDFW by obtaining an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081, subdivision (b), in compliance with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-7: Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Habitat Assessment. Prior to the commencement of any ground-disturbing activities, the qualified biologist shall conduct an additional habitat assessment to determine if the project site and immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal nesting burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, and hollow logs shall be documented as part of the assessment.

MM BIO-8: CBB Surveys. If potentially suitable habitat is identified during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, a qualified biologist shall conduct focused surveys for CBB and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

MM BIO-9: CBB Avoidance. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses shall be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities occur during the overwintering period October through February), consultation with CDFW shall be conducted to discuss how to implement the proposed project’s construction-related activities and avoid take of the CBB. Any detection of CBB prior to or during project construction shall warrant discussions with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

MM BIO-10: CBB Take Authorization. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the proposed project and avoid take of the CBB. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit, pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

BIO-5: Would the project
conflict with any local policies
or ordinances protecting
biological resources, such as a
tree preservation policy or
ordinance?
MM BIO-1
MM BIO-2
MM BIO-3
MM BIO-4
MM BIO-5
MM BIO-6
MM BIO-7
MM BIO-8
MM BIO-9
MM BIO-10
Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-4
Section 2.0 Project Description
Project Objectives were listed and described in the Executive Summary and in Section 5.1, Alternatives, but we inadvertently omitted from the Project Description. These are listed below:

2.2.11 Project Objectives
• A Project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City. • An infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. • A Project that encourages and facilitates new uses of high -quality architecture and design. • A mixture of commercial uses that provides new activity and services to the area and is cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities nearby. • Creation of new and future employment opportunities.
• A circulation system responsive to the needs of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian travel. • New native and drought tolerant landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter
• A visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

Section 4.3 Air Quality

Page 4 ends
← All documents from this meeting