Cities Index.
Minutes, regular meeting, third session

Bakersfield City Council
November 4, 2026

Document
Minutes, regular meeting, third session
Meeting
November 4, 2026
Body
Bakersfield City Council
Pages
223
Original file
412.7 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on pub-bakersfield.escribemeetings.com. That file is the official record.

RESOLUTION NO.

RESOLUTION OF THE BAKERSFIELD CITY COUNCIL ADOPTING AN

AMENDMENT TO THE LAND USE MAP DESIGNATION OF THE

METROPOLITAN BAKERSFIELD GENERAL PLAN FROM P (PUBLIC

FACILITIES) TO LI (LIGHT INDUSTRIAL) OR A MORE RESTRICTIVE

DESIGNATION GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF ROSEDALE HIGHWAY AND COFFEE ROAD (2401 COFFEE ROAD) (GPA NO. 23-0001).

WHEREAS, Coffee Road Ventures, LLC (property owner and applicant) is requesting approval of (1) General Plan Amendment (GPA) of the Land Use Element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) or a more restrictive designation; and (2) approval of California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Section 15091 Findings, CEQA Section 15093 Statement of Overriding Considerations, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and certification of a Final Environmental Impact Report for the Riverview Marketplace project on approximately 46.16 acres located at 2401 Coffee Road (southwest corner of Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway) to facilitate the development of a 405,531 square feet commercial retail center (the “Project”); and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on October 1, 2026, where individuals provided testimony in support and opposition, and approved Resolution No. 62- 26, which recommended that the City Council approve the Project; and WHEREAS, the Clerk of the City Council set Wednesday, November 4, 2026, at 5:15 p.m. in the Council Chambers of City Hall, 1501 Truxtun Avenue, Bakersfield, California, as the time and place for a public hearing before the City Council to consider the approval of the amendment as required by Government Code Section 65355, and notice of the public hearing was given in the manner provided in Title 17 of the Bakersfield Municipal Code;and WHEREAS, the City Council certified an Environmental Impact Report for the Project; and
WHEREAS, during the hearing, the City Council considered all facts, testimony, and evidence concerning the Administrative Report, and the Planning Commission’s deliberation and action.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Bakersfield City Council as follows:

1. The above recitals, incorporated herein, are true andcorrect.

2. The Planning Commission's findings as contained in its Resolution No. 62-26 are hereby adopted.

3. The Project is hereby approved located on the map as shown in Exhibit A, of which is incorporated herein.

Page 2 of 2 ends

4. The Project approved herein is hereby made part of the 4th amendment to the Land Use Element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan for calendar year 2026 in accordance with Government Code Section 65358 (b). o0o
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing Resolution was passed and adopted by the Council of the City of Bakersfield at a regular meeting thereof held on the 4th of November 2026 by the following vote:

AYES: COUNCILMEMBER: _ Arias, Gonzales, Weir, Smith, Koman, Bashirtash, Kaur NOES: COUNCILMEMBER:

ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBER:

ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBER:

JULIE DRIMAKIS, MMC
CITY CLERK and Ex Officio Clerk of
the Council of the City of Bakersfield
APPROVED:

By

KAREN GOH
Mayor of the City of Bakersfield
APPROVED AS TO FORM:

VIRGINIA GENNARO
City Attorney
By:

VIRIDIANA GALLARDO-KING
Deputy City Attorney
Exhibit A: General Plan Amendment Map
AK |S:\03_Advance Planning\01_GPAs\01_Active\2023\23-0001_2401 Coffee Rd and Rosedale_Commercial Center\01_Hearing Documents & Noticing Documents\City Council\CC 11.4.26\04_Council GPA Resolution No 23- 0001Final.docx

JET WAY

ESPRESSO DR

CAPPUCCINO
WAY

LATTE LN

SILVERLAKE DR

HOODSPORT AVE

COLVILLE AVE

STARSIDE DR

DELBERT ST
HENRY
LN
MOXEE
CT
NEAH
B
AY DR

CAPE FLATTERY DR

EL TORO VIEJO RD

SEABECK AVE

SUNCRISP LN

JENNA KATHRYN DR
ODESSA
CT

ICICLE CREEK DR

WOLF RIVER AVE

KENNEWICK LN

TELSTAR
AVE

LOON CT

GREENBANK
ST

COURTLAND
AVE

CRISPIN ST

PINK LADY
WAY

BELMAC AVE

HENRY LN

OLEO DR

ELZWORTH ST

STEAM CT

SEAVIEW DR

COFFEE FRONTAGE RD

SHOFNER AVE

LANGLEY RD

CHESAW CT

GREENACRES DR
MAX DR

MC INTOSH WAY

RIBSTON AVE

CHATTAROY ST

BOLERO AVE

CLAY PATRICK FARR WAY EL TORO VIEJO RD

GRANITE FALLS DR
COFFEE
RD

COFFEE RD

ROSEDALE HWY ROSEDALE HWY
SI
SI
SI
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
P
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
HI

GC GC HI
SI
SI
GC
GC
HMR
LI
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
OS-P
MUC
MUC
MUC
PS
MC
MC
LR
LR LR
ER
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
HI HI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
LI
P P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
GC
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
GC
GC
LI
LR LR
LR LR
LR
HMR
OS-P
LI
LI
LI
LI
LR
LR
LR
SI

GREENACRES
PARK
Fruitvale
Junior High
School
BaseEditor_MV
0 350 700
Feet
_
GPA 23-0001

CITY OF BAKERSFIELD
GPA 23-0001
FROM: P
TO: LI
CITY
COUNTY
LEGEND
(GENERAL PLAN

LAND USE)
RR Rural Residential

2.5 gross acres/dwelling unit
ER Estate Residential
1 dwelling unit/net acre
SR Suburban Residential
≤4 dwelling units/net acre
SR/LR
County: ≤ 4 dwelling units/net acre
City: ≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LR Low Density Residential
≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LMR Low Medium Density Residential
> 4 but ≤ 10 dwelling units/net acre
HMR High Medium Density Residential
>7.26 units but
≤17.42 dwelling units/net acre
HR High Density Residential
>17.42 units but
≤72.6 dwelling units/net acre
HC Highway Commercial
GC General Commercial
MC Major Commercial
OC Office Commercial
MUC Mixed Use Commercial
LI Light Industrial
SI Service Industrial
HI Heavy Industrial
P Public Facilities
PS Public/Private Schools
PT Public Transportation Corridors
P-SW Solid Waste Facilities
OS Open Space
OS-P Parks and Recreation
OS-S Slopes exceeding 30%
R-IA Resource -
Intensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
R-EA Resource -
Extensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
80 acre min (Williamson Act)
R-MP Resource -
Minerals & Petroleum
5 acre minimum parcel size
UER Urban Estate Residential
Western Rosedale Plan

0.5 acre net minimum parcel size
WM West Ming Specific Plan
AE{
AEu
COUNTY
CITY
Exhibit A
1 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

MEMORANDUM
To: Ashley Knight, Assistant City Planner
City of Bakersfield, Development Services Department
From: Jessie Barkley
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.

Date: October 19, 2026
Subject: Response to comments on the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project EIR provided by James Davis, Vice President of Real Estate, Jaco Oil Company; Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D, Vice-Chair, Sierra Club; and Aidan P. Marshall Adams Broadwell Joseph and Cardozo This Memorandum provides responses to written comments on the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project. These comments were provided after the Draft EIR and Final EIR were circulated.The comments to the three letters are labeled 1-1, 1-2, 2-1, 2-2, 3-1, etc., respectively, and the responses to each comment letter are correspondently numbered. A copy of the comment letters and appendices is provided in Attachment A to this Memorandum.

As set forth in the responses, the Comment Letters challenge the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project Draft and Final EIR under the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”). For the reasons that follow, the Comment Letters fail to meet the Commenters’ burden to establish that the Draft and Final the requirements of CEQA or that the Project requires recirculation. To the contrary, substantial evidence in the record supports the certification of the Draft and Final EIR. 2 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Commenter Letter No. 1
September 28, 2026
James Davis, Vice President of Real Estate
Jaco Oil Company
3101 State Road
Bakersfield, CA 93308
Comment No. 1-1
Please accept these comments regarding the Environmental Impact Report prepared for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project. I have concerns regarding several aspects of the traffic analysis, trip generation analysis, and proposed mitigation measures, particularly as they relate to the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility.

Response No. 1-1
This comment is noted for the administrative record and will be forwarded to the decision makers for review and consideration. As described in more detail below, the Commenter’s claims lack factual support.

Comment No. 1-2

1. Trip Generation and Traffic Analysis – Costco Standalone Fuel Facility The proposed Costco standalone fuel facility is a substantial development consisting of 20 pumps and 40 fueling positions, in addition to a carwash. Given the size of this facility and the anticipated volume of vehicles it will generate, I believe the trip-generation and traffic analyses warrant additional review.

The studies presented in the Environmental Impact Study do not appear to be consistent with the manner in which similar traffic issues have been evaluated for smaller gas station and convenience store projects in Bakersfield.

For example, Fastrip previously submitted a site plan to the City of Bakersfield requesting approval for two driveway locations along Rosedale Highway for a proposed Fastrip gas station and convenience store located at the southeast corner of Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive. The City of Bakersfield Public Works Department determined that Fastrip would be permitted only one driveway and required a 60-foot storage lane, along with a Type A, ST3 driveway located at the extreme east end of the property.

These requirements resulted in Fastrip losing nearly 13 feet of property along Rosedale Highway. The single driveway and required storage lane also resulted in the loss of parking spaces and significantly affected onsite circulation.
3 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response 1-2
The Commenter raises concerns regarding the evaluation of the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility, including the 40 fueling positions and associated carwash, and compares the Project with access requirements previously applied to a separate proposed Fastrip gasoline station and convenience store at Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive.

As previously responded in the Final DEIR (Responses to Letter P2, pages 2.0-107-110), the Project’s proposed Costco fuel facility was incorporated into the Draft EIR’s traffic analysis and evaluated based on the specific location, site characteristics, access opportunities, anticipated traffic demand, and circulation plan associated with the Project. The analysis considered the anticipated traffic demand associated with the proposed 40 fueling positions, site access, internal circulation, fueling-position queuing, and access point operations.

The access and circulation requirements applied to the separate Fastrip project referenced by the Commenter do not establish that the same requirements are necessary or appropriate for the Project.

Individual development projects are evaluated based on their specific site conditions, land use characteristics, adjacent roadway conditions, available right-of-way, traffic conditions, access configuration, and circulation requirements. The Project includes a comprehensive internal circulation system and multiple access points that were evaluated as part of the Draft EIR’s traffic analysis. The Project Site also provides adequate right-of-way along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road to accommodate an exclusive right turn lane along the Project frontage, providing additional capacity and storage for vehicles entering and exiting the Project site while minimizing interference with through traffic on the adjacent roadways. Accordingly, the proposed Costco fuel facility and the overall Project circulation system were evaluated based on the Project specific characteristics and anticipated traffic conditions. The access and storage requirements previously applied to an unrelated gasoline service station project at a different location do not demonstrate that the Project traffic analysis or proposed access configuration is inadequate.

Comment No. 1-3
It is also important to note that there is a recorded agreement dated August 16, 2014, between the City of Bakersfield and the property owner that addresses the installation of two driveways along Rosedale Highway at the Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive intersection. This history should be considered when evaluating how access and traffic impacts are being addressed for the Riverview Marketplace project.

Response No. 1-3
The recorded agreement referenced by the Commenter for the Fastrip property does not alter the Draft EIR’s analysis of access and circulation for the Project. No further response is necessary. 4 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Comment No. 1-4

2. Consistency of Trip Generation and Mitigation Measures The Trip Generation Analysis, Traffic Study, and proposed mitigation measures for the Riverview Marketplace project appear to differ from the manner in which similar traffic impacts have been addressed for other shopping center and gas station projects in Bakersfield.

I believe the City should explain the basis for these differences and identify the specific methodology and criteria used to determine the appropriate trip-generation rates, access requirements, storage requirements, and mitigation measures for the proposed Costco fuel facility.

Of particular concern is the use of the Costco Fuel Facility Database in the traffic analysis. My understanding is that this database primarily contains information regarding Costco fuel facilities that are associated with Costco warehouse locations. A standalone Costco fuel facility may have substantially different traffic characteristics from a fuel facility that is integrated with a Costco warehouse.

Additionally, it is unclear whether the data used in the analysis was collected or independently verified by an independent traffic consultant, or whether it was provided directly by Costco. The source, methodology, and reliability of this data should be clearly identified so that the public and the City can understand the basis for the conclusions reached in the study.

Response No. 1-4
The Commenter raises concerns regarding the trip-generation methodology, traffic analysis, mitigation measures, and use of Costco specific fuel facility data, including whether data from Costco fuel facilities associated with Costco Warehouses is appropriate for evaluating the proposed standalone fuel facility.

As previously responded in the Final DEIR (Responses to Letter P2, pages 2.0-107-110), the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility was evaluated as part of the overall Project based on its specific location and site characteristics. Because the Project includes 40 vehicle fueling positions and is not associated with a Costco Warehouse, no single published Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) land use category precisely represents the proposed use. Accordingly, the trip generation analysis considered Costco specific operating data together with the closest applicable ITE trip generation information to establish a reasonable and conservative estimate of traffic demand.

The Costco data provides actual operational information regarding customer and fueling characteristics at existing Costco locations with fuel facilities. The resulting Costco-based gross trip-generation estimate was also compared with applicable ITE land use categories to confirm the reasonableness and conservatism of the estimate used in the traffic analysis.

The source and methodology used for the Costco specific information were considered as part of the Draft EIR’s traffic analysis, and the resulting traffic demand was evaluated in conjunction with the proposed access configuration, internal circulation system, and adjacent roadway conditions. The 5 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

analysis also considered the Project specific characteristics rather than applying access, storage, or mitigation requirements from unrelated projects.

Traffic analysis requirements and mitigation measures for other shopping center or gasoline service station projects may differ based on site specific conditions and therefore do not establish that the methodology or mitigation measures for the proposed Project are inadequate.

Accordingly, the traffic analysis used available project specific operational information together with applicable industry standard trip generation information and evaluated the resulting traffic conditions based on the characteristics of the proposed development. The Commenter has not identified information demonstrating that the trip generation methodology, traffic analysis, or resulting mitigation measures are inadequate in the Draft EIR, therefore no further analysis is required.

Comment No. 1-5

3. Hours of Operation and Onsite Staffing
The Draft Environmental Impact Study does not appear to clearly identify the proposed hours of operation for the Costco fuel facility or whether Costco employees will be stationed at the fueling facility to assist customers.

These factors could affect traffic volumes, circulation, queuing, and the timing of peak traffic conditions.

The final analysis should clearly identify the anticipated hours of operation and staffing levels and explain how these factors were incorporated into the traffic analysis.

Response No. 1-5
The Commenter requests clarification regarding the proposed hours of operation and staffing of the Costco fuel facility.

As previously responded in the Final DEIR (Responses to Letter P2, pages 2.0-107-110), the ultimate operating schedule and staffing arrangements for the proposed Costco fuel facility will be established by Costco or other facility operator and would be subject to applicable city requirements and approvals.

The traffic analysis contained in the Draft EIR, however, evaluates the anticipated project peak traffic demand, which is not dependent solely on the facility's ultimate hours of operation or staffing arrangements. Accordingly, the requested operating and staffing information does not affect the conclusions of the traffic analysis. No further analysis is required.

Comment No. 1-6

4. Queuing and Onsite Circulation at the Costco Fuel Facility Another significant concern is whether the specific portion of the shopping center containing the Costco fuel facility was adequately evaluated for onsite traffic circulation and vehicle queuing. 6 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Costco fuel facilities can experience substantial queues, particularly during peak periods. It is not unusual for multiple vehicles to be waiting for an available fueling position. With 40 fueling positions proposed at this location, the potential for significant onsite queuing should be specifically evaluated.

The analysis should identify the anticipated maximum queue length during peak periods and demonstrate that sufficient onsite storage is available without interfering with internal shopping center circulation, access to adjacent businesses, pedestrian movements, or access to and from Rosedale Highway.

The City should also evaluate whether vehicle queues could extend beyond the Costco property and potentially back up onto Rosedale Highway. If the analysis indicates that there is any reasonable possibility of vehicles queuing onto Rosedale Highway, appropriate mitigation should be required to prevent this condition.

One potential mitigation measure would be a dedicated right-turn lane from Rosedale Highway into the project, with approximately 60 to 80 feet of storage, or whatever length is determined to be appropriate based on an independent queuing analysis.

Response No. 1-6
The Commenter reiterates concerns regarding vehicle queuing at the proposed 40 fueling positions, internal circulation, potential queues extending onto Rosedale Highway, and the need for a dedicated right-turn lane and additional storage.

The proposed Costco standalone fuel facility was incorporated into the Project traffic analysis and evaluated based on the site specific characteristics of the Project. The analysis took into consideration anticipated fueling demand, on-site pump queuing, access-point operations and queuing, and proposed internal circulation system.

The site plan provides approximately six-vehicle queue storage at the fueling positions, consistent with the queue conditions identified in the comment previously provided by the commenter. Based on the Project Site’s queuing and circulation evaluation, the proposed internal circulation system provides adequate space and dedicated queue storage to accommodate vehicles waiting for access to the fueling positions. This configuration is intended to allow fueling queues to remain within the Project Site and minimize the potential for queues to interfere with internal circulation or extend onto the adjacent public roadway system.

In addition, the Project Site provides adequate right-of-way along Rosedale Highway to accommodate an exclusive right-turn lane along the Project frontage. This improvement will provide additional capacity and storage for vehicles entering and exiting the Project Site while minimizing interference with through traffic on the adjacent roadways.

Based on the traffic analysis results contained in the Draft EIR, the proposed internal circulation system and multiple access points provide adequate capacity to address the anticipated ingress and egress demand associated with the overall Project, including the proposed Costco fuel facility, without adversely 7 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

affecting the operation of the adjacent public roadway system.

It should be noted that the right turn storage suggested by the Commenter is already included as part of the Project, and the traffic analysis supports a conclusion that it will provide adequate storage to accommodate anticipated project-related traffic, consistent with the queuing analysis conducted for the Project.

Comment No. 1-7

5. Request for Additional Analysis
Given the size of the proposed Costco fuel facility and the potential traffic and circulation impacts associated with 40 fueling positions, I believe additional analysis is warranted before the environmental document is finalized.

At a minimum, the City should consider:
 Providing the source and methodology for the Costco-specific trip-generation data used in the analysis.
 Explaining why data from Costco fuel facilities associated with Costco warehouses is appropriate for evaluating a standalone Costco fuel facility.  Providing an independent evaluation of the anticipated trip generation and queuing associated with the proposed facility.
 Clearly identifying the proposed hours of operation and staffing.  Evaluating maximum onsite vehicle queues during peak periods.  Demonstrating that sufficient onsite storage is available to prevent vehicle queues from extending into Rosedale Highway.
 Evaluating whether a dedicated right-turn lane and additional storage should be required on Rosedale Highway.
 Explaining why the access, storage, and circulation requirements applied to this project are appropriate when compared with requirements previously imposed on other, smaller gas station and shopping center projects in Bakersfield.

The purpose of these comments is to ensure that the potential traffic and circulation impacts associated with the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility are fully evaluated and that appropriate mitigation measures are incorporated into the project before the environmental review process is completed.

Response No. 1-7
The Commenter reiterates the request for additional analysis regarding Costco specific trip generation data, the applicability of Costco Warehouse fuel facility data, independent evaluation of trip generation and queuing, hours of operation and staffing, onsite queue storage, potential queuing onto Rosedale Highway, and comparison with access requirements applied to other Bakersfield projects. Please refer to Response to Comment 1-4.
8 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Based on the completed traffic and circulation evaluation, no additional analysis or mitigation beyond that identified in the Project’s Draft EIR traffic analysis is warranted in response to these comments. The Commenter has not identified information demonstrating that the conclusions of the traffic analysis or the proposed access and circulation improvements are inadequate. No further analysis is required. 9 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Commenter Letter No. 2
September 30, 2026
Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D, Vice-Chair
Sierra Club
P.O. Box 3357
Bakersfield, CA 93385
Comment No. 2-1
The Sierra Club offers comments about the above project, a proposed commercial retail center on 46.16 acres at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road in Bakersfield, comments meant to supplement those of our August 24 letter on the DEIR. A lack of reply to some of the City’s responses to our earlier submission should not be interpreted as Sierra Club’s agreement with the City’s responses.

Response No. 2-1
This comment is noted for the administrative record and will be forwarded to the decision makers for review and consideration. As the Commenter does not raise any issues related to the EIR, no further response is required.

Comment No. 2-2
Regarding Biological Resources, we quote the submission from highly regarded research scientist and San Joaquin kit fox expert Dr. Brian Cypher:
“In summary, the Project site does indeed have habitat for kit foxes and kit foxes undoubtedly use the site and definitely traverse it. Given that, the assessments and conclusions regarding kit foxes and potential impacts to kit foxes require extensive revision, preferably by a group that actually has familiarity and experience with the species. Furthermore, the Project proponent definitely needs to obtain a 2081 Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from the CDFW and a 10(a)1(a) incidental take permit (aka Habitat Conservation Plan [HCP]) from the FWS.”
MM BIO-6 is heavily compromised by several conditions that would allow the developer to proceed without obtaining an ITP from CDFW. According to Dr. Cypher, this property is clearly kit fox habitat.

Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Our earlier submission listed dozens of new projects on potential kit fox habitat. For that matter, the Bakersfield Commons project, on similar habitat adjacent to the south of this project, is beginning to build. Cumulative habitat loss must be addressed.

Moreover, now that the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan is no longer in effect, the City must find another way to effectively address the Project’s contribution to cumulative habitat loss.

Mitigation for habitat loss and potential species take should include Incidental Take Permit acquisition and purchase of replacement habitat.
10 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response No. 2-2
The Commenter readdress concerns regarding San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) (SJKF) habitat, take authorization, and cumulative habitat loss.

As noted in the Final EIR, disturbed ruderal habitat is within the SJKF species’ urban range and may support denning, foraging, or movement. The Project’s biological evaluation therefore does not rely on a categorical finding that disturbed land provides suitable SJKF habitat, or that the absence of an observed animal establishes absence of the species.

The updated General Biological Assessment (GBA) indicated no SJKF was observed during the most recent November 2025 site visit, and the inconsistent appendix entries were corrected in the Final EIR.

Even if a kit fox had been observed during a previous visit, that observation alone does not conclude the site to be an occupied den, or have a resident population on the property. Evidence of occasional foraging or passage is considered; however, it does not automatically conclude the site has active dens or an unavoidable take impact. The Project measures apply from CDFW based on potential occurrence and do not depend on disproving prior or intermittent use.

Intermittent use or detection of the Project Site by SJKF does not automatically require an Incidental Take Permit (ITP). Work may only start or resume after the biologist documents that applicable avoidance requirements have been satisfied, including any required agency coordination. If in the pre-construction survey or during construction an active SJKF den is found and measures were not enacted that result in take, the applicable authorization must be obtained before those activities proceed under state or federal law.

The Final EIR per CDFW recommendations recognizes potential SJFK use and implemented the following: preconstruction kit-fox surveys, den-protection buffers, construction precautions, and CDFW procedures and avoidance measures.

Given its disturbed condition and urban setting, the Project Site was determined to have limited quality SJKF habitat and found unsuitable for SJKF, and hence, impacts are less than significant. This Project Site would most likely not (according to CDFW’s banking guidance) have any areas considered suitable for permanent compensatory SJKF mitigation site thus, compensatory habitat mitigation will most likely not be warranted. Still, deferring to CDFW as the responsible agency, the Final EIR incorporates additional mitigation measures to ensure impacts remain less than significant. Mitigation requirements are not required simply due to potential or intermittent SJKF presence.

Comment No. 2-3
According to Dr. Cypher, the developer needs to obtain a federal Endangered Species Act section 10(a)(1)(B) permit from the USFWS. Under section 10(a)(1)(B), the purpose of the ITP supported by a habitat conservation plan (HCP) is to authorize take that is incidental to carrying out otherwise lawful activities and minimize and mitigate the impacts of the anticipated incidental take for the San Joaquin kit fox, in this instance. The anticipated conservation outcome of implementing the HCP is fully offsetting the impacts of the taking. The FEIR is deficient in not having addressed this federal ESA issue in 11 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

consultation with USFWS.

Response No. 2-3

See response to Comment No. 2-2 above.

Comment No. 2-4
Regarding Air Quality, we quote from the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District submission:
“The District appreciates the City’s inclusion of a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) as a mitigation measure for the Project. As identified in Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1, the VERA would mitigate Project-related operational emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOC) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) to net zero, thereby reducing the Project’s air quality to less-than-significant level.” (underline added)
The Air District’s expectation that these pollutants will be mitigated to net zero is contradicted by the minimal requirement of MM AQ-1 to emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX, allowing up to 10 tons/year of these pollutants. This discrepancy must be clarified in the FEIR.

Were the current MM AQ-1 10 tons/year precedent allowed to stand, in ten years this project alone will have emitted 100 tons of both NOx and ROG. As an example of the potential harm from this precedent, it is likely that at least 9 other large new projects will adopt this same precedent so that in 10 years this precedent-setting mitigation measure would allow at least 1000 tons of both ROG and NOx into our already crucially dirty, unhealthy air, deepening the difficulty of attaining Clean Air Act national ambient air quality standards. To this end, in order to address the cumulative impact of dozens of new projects on air pollution and community health, the FEIR should adopt a net zero threshold for air pollution emissions.

Response No. 2-4
The Commenter is incorrect in the statements regarding the suggestions requested by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District's (SJVAPCD) and the requirements of Mitigation Measure (MM) AQ-1 contained in the Draft and Final EIR. MM AQ-1 does not require operational VOC and NOX emissions to be reduced to “net zero”.

MM AQ-1 requires the Project to “… mitigate project-related operation emissions to below SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX.” The VERA program would ensure that Project-related operational emissions are mitigated to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX " (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30, as revised in Final EIR p. 3.0-4). Neither CEQA nor MM AQ-1 requires that the Project achieve net zero emissions. The Draft EIR's less-than-significant conclusions for Impacts AQ-1 and AQ-2 are, in part, based on the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds.

The SJVAPCD only requested revision to MM AQ-1 concerned replacing "completion" with "execution" 12 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

of the VERA, because the SJVAPCD verifies the emission reductions after the agreement is executed and funded (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR pp. 2.0-16 to 2.0-17). The City made that revision in the Final EIR (Response No. A2.3; Errata p. 3.0-4). As stated in Response No. O2.30 (Final EIR p. 2.0-66), the SJVAPCD identifies the VERA as a recommended and feasible CEQA mitigation measure for development projects that exceed its regional significance thresholds.

As discussed in the SJVPACD’s Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, SJVAPCD is required by the federal and State Clean Air Acts to implement programs and regulations through attainment planning. As part of its attainment planning efforts, SJVAPCD has established CEQA thresholds of significance, which are based on the SJVAPCD’s New Source Review offset requirements for stationary sources, as explained in more detail in FEIR Response No. O1.3. Moreover, as explained in FEIR Response No. O1.4, the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds represent a level, which if exceeded by a project may result in cumulatively considerable air quality impacts. Therefore, the reference to the SJVAPCD’s regional significance thresholds in MM AQ-1 is appropriate and supported with substantial evidence.

Comment No. 2-5
Also from the Air District letter:
“Per Section 5.0 of the ISR Rule, an Air Impact Assessment (AIA) application is required to be submitted no later than applying for project-level approval from a public agency. As of the date of this letter, the District has not received an AIA application for this Project. Please inform the project proponent to immediately submit an AIA application to the District to comply with District Rule 9510 so that proper mitigation and clean air design under ISR can be incorporated into the Project’s design.” Without an AIA, neither the public nor the decision-makers can judge the effectiveness of this “proper mitigation and clean air design“ on air pollution impacts of this project. The EIR must be revised to include AIA mitigation and design features.

Response No. 2-5
Rule 9510 is an SJVAPCD regulation that applies to the Project independently of the CEQA process.

The Draft EIR describes its requirements, including submittal of an AIA that establishes the Project's baseline emissions inventory and the on-site measures or off-site fees needed to achieve the required reductions (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-9 to 4.3-10; Appendix B pp. 20–22). The Project applicant submitted an AIA application to the SJVAPCD (Application No. 20260259 submitted September 22, 2026).

Compliance with Rule 9510, including any on-site measures or off-site fees required to achieve the rule’s emission reductions, will be determined by the SJVAPCD through its review of that application (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-9 to 4.3-10; Response No. O2.30, Final EIR pp. 2.0-65 to 2.0-66).

Moreover, the Draft EIR quantified the Project's construction and operational emissions (Tables 4.3-9 and 4.3-11, Draft EIR pp. 4.3-26 and 4.3-28). It compared those emissions to the SJVAPCD thresholds and identified MM AQ-1 as necessary to reduce impacts, which requires the VERA to reduce operational VOC and NOX emissions to below the adopted thresholds (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). The operational 13 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

emissions on which MM AQ-1 is based credit only MM AQ-2 and MM GHG-3; no reduction from Rule 9510 compliance is credited to support a health- and environment-protective analysis of potential impacts (Table 4.3-15 and note 3, Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). Because the Draft EIR's significance conclusions do not depend on reductions under Rule 9510, the results of the District’s review of the AIA are not needed to evaluate the Project’s impacts, and revision of the EIR is not required.

Comment No. 2-6
Regarding the Climate Crisis, the FEIR considers the project’s adverse project-specific and cumulative climate change impacts to be significant. Even after the required mitigation, the project will emit 15,926 MTCO2e annually according to Table 4.8-3. In order to satisfy CEQA requirements and not leave an overheated planet for future generations, the City must adopt all feasible mitigation to reduce this adverse significant impact. We listed numerous possible feasible mitigation measures in our earlier submission, many of which were improperly rejected in the City’s response. For example:
 A requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards current when permits are pulled. The City’s response did not address this possibility.  Relax parking requirements as in the CARB 2022 scoping plan. The City responds that “the proposed Project would comply with the standard applicable City of Bakersfield Municipal Code parking requirements” without specific consideration of scoping plan suggestions.  A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production. The City’s response did not address this possibility.
 Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots, a measure that many proposed warehouses statewide are adopting. The City’s response did not address this possibility.  Some parking stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project. Many entities, both public and private, have included solar canopies in their facility. The City’s response did not address this very feasible measure.
 A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere. The City rejects this proposal because it seems too difficult to effectively implement. The Air District has implemented VERA programs in the past that have resulted in air pollution reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional, and it is likely that the Air District would implement a GHG VERA, if asked. Other entities like the Rose Foundation have experience implementing an effective such program. This is a feasible measure that the City should implement.

The adverse impact of climate change is significant. The City should adopt all feasible mitigation.

Response No. 2-6
The Draft EIR determined that the Project's GHG emissions would be significant and unavoidable after implementation of MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7 (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-21 to 4.8-23). These measures require all-electric buildings, except for commercial cooking, and ENERGY STAR or equivalent 14 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

appliances (MM GHG-1); enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan where available, or the next-highest carbon-free plan (MM GHG-2); electric landscaping equipment (MM GHG-3); electric off-road equipment, through lease provisions (MM GHG-4); improvements at up to two transit stops (MM GHG-5); an end-of-trip shower facility (MM GHG-6); and compliance with the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen) Tier 2 nonresidential voluntary electric vehicle (EV) standards (MM GHG-7).

In addition, the Project includes on-site photovoltaic (PV) systems that are anticipated to generate 1,201,933 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of renewable electricity per year. The Project also includes battery storage (Draft EIR pp. 4.6-9, 4.8-16, and 4.8-22), bicycle facilities, a new bicycle lane on Rosedale Highway, and new sidewalks (Draft EIR p. 4.8-23).

As shown in Tables 4.8-2 and 4.8-3 (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-18 to 4.8-21), vehicle trips by employees and patrons account for approximately 93 percent of the Project's 15,926 MTCO2e per year after mitigation.

Building energy accounts for 677 MTCO2e per year, or approximately four percent of the Project’s total GHG emissions after mitigation. The Draft EIR considered implementation of MM GHG-1 in these Tables but did not quantify additional reductions from MM GHG-2 that "would contribute to increasing use of carbon-free renewable electricity" (Draft EIR p. 4.8-20).

The following provides responses to each of the recommended measures presented in the comment.

A requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards currently when permits are pulled. The City’s response did not address this possibility. The Project's buildings must comply with the Building Energy Efficiency Standards (Title 24, Part 6) in effect when building permits are issued. MM GHG-1 requires buildings to be all-electric, except for commercial cooking uses, with ENERGY STAR or equivalent appliances (Draft EIR p. 4.8-19). The Project's on-site PV systems offset an anticipated 1,201,933 kWh of electricity demand per year (Draft EIR p. 4.8-16). MM GHG-2 requires enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan where available, which would further reduce the GHG emissions associated with the Project's remaining electricity use (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-19 to 4.8-20). With these measures in place, building energy-related emissions were reduced from approximately five percent of the Project’s total GHG emissions to approximately four percent of the Project's remaining emissions (Draft EIR Table 4.8-3). Approximately 93 percent of the Project's total GHG emissions come from vehicle travel, which building energy efficiency does not affect. A further efficiency requirement would overlap with Title 24 compliance (Draft EIR p. 4.8-22), MM GHG-1, the Project's on-site PV, and MM GHG-2, all of which already reduce building energy-related emissions. For these reasons, the City is not agreeable to adding a requirement exceeding Title 24 by 25 percent, which would be largely ineffective for addressing the major source of the Project’s GHG emissions. Moreover, the City provided a response to this proposed measure in Response No. O1.21, stating that MM GHG-1 would provide increased building energy efficiency when compared to a standard mixed-fuel building.

Relaxing parking requirements as in the CARB 2022 Scoping Plan. The City responds that “the proposed Project would comply with the standard applicable City of Bakersfield Municipal Code parking requirements” without specific consideration of scoping plan suggestions. As explained on Draft EIR page 4.8-22, the Scoping Plan is applicable to state agencies and is not directly applicable to cities, counties, or individual projects. The Project's parking is governed by the Bakersfield Zoning Code 15 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

(Bakersfield Municipal Code [BMC] Chapter 17.58), which requires 1,760 spaces for the Project's mix of uses. The Project proposes 1,913 spaces (Draft EIR p. 2-13). The Draft EIR addresses vehicle miles traveled (VMT) through the Project's VMT- and trip-reducing features and mitigation. For example, pedestrian improvements, a new bicycle lane on Rosedale Highway, and end-of-trip bicycle facilities were evaluated in the Draft EIR in relation to California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA) Handbook Measures T-10, T-18, and T-19 (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-23 and 4.16-16). Moreover, transit stop improvements are prescribed in MM GHG-5, and an end-of-trip shower facility requirement is prescribed in MM GHG-6. In addition, future employers at the Project with 100 or more eligible employees will be subject to SJVAPCD Rule 9410, Employer Based Trip Reduction, which requires an employer trip reduction implementation plan (Draft EIR p. 4.3-11). Moreover, the City provided a response to this proposed measure in Response No. O1.21, stating that MMs GHG-5, GHG-6, and GHG-7 would require the Project to implement VMT- and trip-reducing measures, as described above.

A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production. The City’s response did not address this possibility. The Project includes rooftop PV systems that comply with the requirements of the Building Energy Efficiency Standards. The PV systems are anticipated to generate 1,201,933 kWh of renewable electricity per year, which the Draft EIR credited against the Project's electricity demand (Draft EIR pp. 4.6-9, 4.8-16, and 4.8-22). The Project's remaining grid electricity is subject to MM GHG-2. The Project's site layout, shown on the conceptual site plan, places buildings in relation to the Project's driveways on Rosedale Highway, Coffee Road, and El Toro Viejo Road, its internal circulation, the PG&E setback, and the detention basin (Draft EIR pp. 2-13 to 2-14; Figures 2-3 and 2-6). The Project already provides on-site solar generation meeting code requirements, and MM GHG-2 further reduces emissions from the Project's remaining electricity use. A building orientation requirement to situate the buildings such that it would maximize rooftop solar production would overlap with these measures. For these reasons, the City does not propose an additional building orientation requirement. The City's CEQA Findings will address this measure.

Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots, a measure that many proposed warehouses statewide are adopting. The City’s response did not address this possibility. The Project would plant 656 trees with 534 of those on-site, including 443 in the parking lot areas and 122 along the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road frontages (Draft EIR p. 2-14; Response O1.21, Final EIR p. 2.0- 40). The preliminary landscape plan provides approximately 40.4 percent shading of the parking lot area, consistent with the City's 40 percent parking lot shading requirement under BMC Section 17.61.030 (Draft EIR Figure 2-6; the calculation excludes parking within the PG&E easement). For these reasons, the City does not propose an additional cool pavement requirement as it would not result in quantifiable reductions in GHG emissions and affect the GHG emissions impact determination.

Some parking stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project. Many entities, both public and private, have included solar canopies in their facility. The City’s response did not address this very feasible measure. The Project's rooftop PV systems and battery storage (Draft EIR pp. 4.6-9, 4.8-16, and 4.8-22), together with MM GHG-2's carbon-free electricity plan requirement, reduce the Project's electricity-related GHG emissions. Additional on-site generation from parking canopies would overlap with these measures, which already address the Project's electricity-related emissions. However, this measure would not address the vehicle travel emissions that make up approximately 93 percent of the Project's total GHG 16 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

emissions (Draft EIR Table 4.8-3); therefore, further reductions to the energy-source emissions sector would not substantially reduce the Project’s total GHG emissions. The Project's parking areas are also designed to meet the City's parking lot shading requirement with tree canopy (Draft EIR Figure 2-6). MM GHG-7 further requires the parking areas to comply with the CALGreen Tier 2 nonresidential voluntary EV standards, which result in EV infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements (Draft EIR p. 4.8-20; Response No. O1.21, item 5, Final EIR p. 2.0-39). For these reasons, the City does not propose an additional solar canopy requirement.

A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere. The City rejects this proposal because it seems too difficult to effectively implement. The Air District has implemented VERA programs in the past that have resulted in air pollution reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional, and it is likely that the Air District would implement a GHG VERA, if asked. Other entities like the Rose Foundation have experience implementing an effective such program. This is a feasible measure that the City should implement. CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(c)(3) identifies "off-site measures, including offsets that are not otherwise required," as a means of mitigating GHG emissions.

Section 15126.4(c) requires that such measures be feasible, supported by substantial evidence, and subject to monitoring or reporting. Response No. O1.21 (item 1, Final EIR pp. 2.0-38 to 2.0-39) explains the considerations the City applied in evaluating carbon offsets, including the use of CARB-approved registries and protocols, the criteria in Health and Safety Code Section 38562(d), the enforceability concerns associated with offsets originating outside California, and the guidance of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) that GHG reductions be achieved through direct reductions where possible. As explained in Response No. O1.21 (item 12), the City's GHG mitigation strategy prioritizes reductions that would be achieved by the Project itself, with MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7.

The City does not administer a GHG reduction program outside its boundaries. As Response No. O1.21 noted, a regional entity such as the SJVAPCD would be the appropriate agency to administer such a program. However, the SJVAPCD does not have an established program that accepts payments to fund GHG reductions as CEQA mitigation. As stated in Response No. O1.21 (item 12, Final EIR p. 2.0-41), it is unknown whether reductions from such a fee program would meet the criteria of CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(c)(3) for reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional.

Comment No. 2-7
The City seems to have a de facto policy to oppose Sierra Club suggestions (a notion reinforced by the vicious verbal attack by Planning Commissioner Oliver at the May 7 Bakersfield Planning Commission hearing, an attack “dittoed” by Commissioner Martin, an attack that has not been disclaimed by the City).

Our suggestions are serious, based on many decades of planning experience, and with community benefit in mind. They should not be rejected out of hand.

Please place the Sierra Club on the distribution list for this project to receive any noticing of meetings, hearings, availability of documents, and to receive the environmental documents. We prefer email communications and electronic formatting of documents. Thank you for your consideration and for the opportunity to comment
17 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response No. 2-7
The Commenter’s description of activities that took place in a prior Planning Commission meeting that was not related to the Project has no relevance to the Draft and Final EIR and as such does not warrant further response. The Commenter’s preferences electronic communications and formatting for future noticing is noted for the record.
18 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Commenter Letter No. 3
October 1, 2026
Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph and Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080-7037
Comment No. 3-1
On behalf of Californians Allied for a Responsible Economy (“CARE CA”), we submit these comments on the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507) (“Project”), including the Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) prepared by the City of Bakersfield (“City”). The Project’s FEIR and land use approvals will be considered as Agenda Item 6.A at the October 1, 2026, Planning Commission hearing.

Response No. 3-1
This introductory comment is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. 3-2
CARE CA submitted comments on the Draft EIR (“DEIR”) on August 24, 2026, accompanied by expert comments, showing that the DEIR failed to comply with the requirements of CEQA1 by failing to accurately disclose and mitigate significant health risk, Valley Fever, air quality, climate change, transportation, noise, and public utilities impacts. We reviewed the Staff Report, the FEIR, and its technical appendices with the assistance of air quality expert Dr. James Clark2 and transportation expert Norm Marshall.3 The FEIR contains responses to CARE CA’s comments. However, it fails to meaningfully address or correct major flaws CARE CA and its experts identified in the DEIR.

Footnotes
1 Public Resources Code § 21000 et seq.; 14 Cal. Code Regs. (“C.C.R.”) §§ 15000 et seq. 2 Dr. Clark’s technical comments and curricula vitae are attached hereto as Exhibit A. 3 Mr. Marshall’s technical comments and curricula vitae are attached hereto as Exhibit B.

Response No. 3-2
The Commenter asserts that the Draft EIR fails to meet the requirements of CEQA and that the Commenter’s previous letter was not adequately responded to in the Final EIR (Comment Letter No.

O2.1). As demonstrated in the responses below, this assertion is not supported by any substantial 19 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

evidence. This comment is noted for the record and will be made available for the decision makers for their review and consideration. The comment is acknowledged and no further response is necessary; no changes to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. 3-3
As explained herein, the FEIR still fails to satisfy the core mandates of CEQA. Soil-disturbing activities across the 46-acre site pose severe Valley Fever risks, particularly given the 1,848 reported cases in Kern County in 2026 and the site’s immediate proximity to sensitive elderly residents at Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park.4 The FEIR fails to mitigate this impact, inconsistently claiming that that San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (“SJVAPCD”) Rule 8021 dust suppression would control exposure while simultaneously claiming dust levels do not correlate with fungal spore dispersal.5 Footnotes
4 Clark Comments, p. 12.
5 FEIR, p. 2.0-44.

Response No. 3-3
The Commenter shares concerns that impacts related to Coccidioides Immitis (“C. Immitis” or “Valley fever”) have not been adequately disclosed and mitigated in the Draft EIR. See Response No. 3-11.

Comment No. 3-4
The Project’s fuel station, charbroilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic would emit hazardous Toxic Air Contaminants (“TACs”) like benzene and Diesel Particulate Matter. The City fails to analyze risks from exposure to these pollutants in a Health Risk Analysis (“HRA”).6 Instead, the City unreasonably assumes that because the Project would generate fewer vehicle trips than a freeway, health risks would be less than significant.7 The FEIR also piecemealed its health risk analysis by improperly segmenting stationary source TAC emissions from mobile sources to avoid evaluating combined health exposures.8
Footnotes
6 FEIR, p. 2.0-52.
7 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32 (the City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways). 8 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59.

Response No. 3-4
Based on the Project's land use type, screening criteria from CARB’s Air Quality and Land Use 20 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Handbook (Handbook), and guidance from SJVAPCD, an operational health risk assessment (HRA) is not warranted (see Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-32; Table 4.3-16, Draft EIR p. 4.3-32). See also Response No. 3-12.

CARB Handbook. The Commenter is incorrect; the Draft EIR did not compare Project traffic to freeway traffic to make a determination that an operational HRA is not warranted. The Draft EIR applied screening criteria from the CARB’s Handbook, because it “is a general reference guide for evaluating potential health effects associated with siting sensitive receptors proximate to sources of toxic air contaminants.” The land use screening criteria in the Handbook were developed by CARB from health studies and data compiled by CARB; in turn, the criteria is substantial evidence and use in support of the conclusions in the EIR is appropriate(Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-53; CEQA Guidelines Sections 15064(b)(1) and 15384(b)).

Project Type. The Draft EIR explains that the land uses that have the potential to generate substantial quantities of TACs are industrial (permitted stationary sources) and warehousing (truck idling) uses, which the Project does not include. Emissions sources associated with the Project that have the potential to generate TACs were evaluated under Threshold AQ-3, which include the gas station, commercial truck deliveries, and construction activities.

Permitted Sources – Gas Station. The Handbook data cited in Response No. O2.16 show that cancer risk from a gas station at a large wholesale or discount center, with an average throughput of 9,000,000 gallons per year, attenuates to 5 in a million at 300 feet (Final EIR p. 2.0-54). The nearest sensitive land uses are approximately 650 feet to the west (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31), which means that cancer risk at the nearest sensitive receptor would be substantially less than 5 in a million for the Project. Moreover, the proposed gas station is regulated under SJVAPCD Regulation II, which would ensure risk does not exceed the SJVAPCD thresholds (see Responses No. O2.16 and No. O2A-7, of the Final EIR pp. 2.0- 55, 2.0-88). It should be noted that the Project does not specifically include charbroilers. Tenants within the commercial shopping center have not been identified. The environmental analysis in the DEIR is based on the level of information available; the presence of charbroilers within the Project site is considered speculative and therefore, not considered a potential impact. Furthermore, chain-driven charbroilers are also regulated under SJVAPCD Regulation II.

Commercial Delivery Trucks. The Project is a retail center, not a logistics use. Heavy trucks make up less than one percent of the Project’s VMT and trips. For the qualitative evaluation, Draft EIR applied the Handbook’s roadway screening criterion to evaluate if the Project would result in roadway volumes that trigger the need for a quantitative evaluation of health risk (Response No. O2.21, Final EIR p. 2.0- 58). However, the highest projected roadway volume with the Project would fall substantially below the volume identified in CARB’s Handbook or 100,000 vehicles per day that would trigger the need for a quantitative analysis (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-32; Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54).

Furthermore, at the request of the Commenter, the Traffic Engineer has provided the maximum number of daily truck trips generated by the Project. The Project would generate a maximum of 44 trucks trips per day (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54), which is also substantially below the 100 truck trip threshold identified in CARB’s Handbook that would trigger the need for an onsite operational HRA to 21 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

quantitively evaluate cancer risk1.

Construction. For construction, in which off-road diesel equipment and vendor and haul trucks are the primary TAC sources, the Draft EIR quantified cancer risk and chronic hazards at the maximally exposed receptors (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, pp. 4.3-32 to 4.3-33).

The Draft EIR evaluated all these components of the Project in its determination of significant impacts, consistent with the definition of "project" in CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(a). The Draft EIR described the gas station and the Project's truck and passenger vehicle traffic as parts of a single Project (Draft EIR p. ES-1) and evaluated the Project's operational TAC sources under Threshold AQ-3 (Draft EIR pp.

4.3-31 to 4.3-32). Given the operational characteristics of the Project, and all its sources combined as outlined above, the Project does not have the potential to exceed the 20 in a million threshold adopted by SJVAPCD, and hence, a quantitative operational HRA is not warranted.

The City did not divide the Project into separate projects for environmental review. As Response No.

O2.22 explained, "the Draft EIR evaluated the potential health risk impacts associated with the various components of the Project, including the non-permitted sources and permitted sources," and stationary sources "were identified as distinct from the non-permitted sources to acknowledge the regulatory framework that exists for permitted sources within the SJVAPCD" (Final EIR p. 2.0-59). Per the SJVAPCD Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI) regarding permitted stationary sources, “emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with [New Source Review] requirements are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant” (SJVAPCD 2015).

Comment No. 3-5
Operational emissions will also elevate PM2.5 concentrations above state and national 24-hour and annual Ambient Air Quality Standards.9 This is clear evidence of a significant impact, but the FEIR improperly dismisses these exceedances because they do not also exceed separate SJVAPCD thresholds.10 Furthermore, the FEIR fails to adequately analyze cumulative health risk and air quality impacts, incorrectly assuming that impacts below individual project thresholds are automatically not cumulatively considerable.11 This ignores the local pollution burden where the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile statewide for PM2.5 pollution.12 Despite finding greenhouse gas (“GHG”) and VMT impacts to be significant and unavoidable, the City failed to adopt all feasible mitigation. It improperly rejected measures such as enforcing diesel truck idling limits below five minutes, requiring particulate controls on under-fired charbroilers, and mandating CAPCOA commute trip reduction programs (Measures T-5 and T-6).

Footnotes
4 Clark Comments, p. 12.
5 FEIR, p. 2.0-44.
1 As evidenced by an Environmental Impact Report (2026) for the Airport Commerce Center Industrial Project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498), a project that generates 824 heavy-duty diesel truck trips per day, with 265 truck trips with transport refrigerated units, would result in a cancer risk of 8.88 per million and 0.002 hazard index at the maximally exposed residential receptor approximately 650 feet away.
22 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

6 FEIR, p. 2.0-52.
7 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32 (the City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways). 8 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59.
9 DEIR, p. Table 4.3-13; Clark Comments, p. 1.
10 FEIR, p. 2.0-64.
11 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”).
12 Clark Comments, p. 10.

Response No. 3-5
The PM2.5 exceedance is an existing exceedance, based on the existing background conditions disclosed in the Draft EIR. Draft EIR Table 4.3-13 (Draft EIR p. 4.3-29) compares background concentrations, the Project's modeled contribution, and their sum with the California Ambient Air Quality Standards (CAAQS). Background PM2.5 concentrations of 37.2 micrograms per cubic meter (µg/m³) (24- hour) and 12.90 µg/m³ (annual) already exceed the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) of 35 µg/m³, the annual CAAQS of 12 µg/m³, and the annual NAAQS, including the 9 µg/m³ national annual standard adopted February 7, 2024, which the Draft EIR's regulatory setting discloses (Draft EIR Table 4.3-1, Draft EIR p. 4.3-3). The Draft EIR states that "background concentrations of NO2 (Annual), PM10 and PM2.5 already exceed the AAQS" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-29). The Final EIR therefore did not disclose a new exceedance; it discussed values already reported in the Draft EIR (Responses No.

O2.28 and No. O2A-8, Final EIR pp. 2.0-64, 2.0-90).

The Project does not cause the exceedance. Where a standard is already exceeded, the question is whether the Project's contribution would worsen it significantly. The SJVAPCD answers that question with its significant impact levels (SILs), which it "developed … to determine whether a project's contribution would contribute significantly to an AAQS exceedance" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-21). The SILs are therefore not a separate test that displaces the AAQS; they are the SJVAPCD's measure of a significant contribution to an AAQS exceedance. The Project's maximum PM2.5 increments, 1.07 µg/m³ (24-hour) and 0.48 µg/m³ (annual), are below the SILs of 2.5 and 0.63 µg/m³ (Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29).

Responses No. O2.28 and No. O2A-8 applied this method and concluded that the potential for Project operation to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would be less than significant (Final EIR pp. 2.0-64,

2.0-90). Mitigation for this impact is therefore not required (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

The Draft EIR did not assume that impacts below individual thresholds are automatically not cumulatively considerable. For health risk, it applied SJVAPCD guidance under which, because TAC impacts are localized and the thresholds are set at a conservative level,"risks over the individual thresholds of significance are also considered cumulatively significant. No other cumulative risk thresholds apply" (Response No. O2.24, Final EIR p. 2.0-60). For criteria pollutants, the SJVAPCD regional thresholds "evaluate whether a project cumulatively contributes to air quality impacts within the SJVAB" (Response No. O1.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-27), and the ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) added the Project's modeled 23 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

concentrations to monitored background concentrations that reflect existing ambient conditions (Draft EIR Table 4.3-13, p. 4.3-29). Refer also to Responses to Comments 3-20 through 3-25.

The measures the comment lists are addressed in Responses to Comments A15 (idling), CA16 and A27 (charbroiler), and Comment 3-32 (Measures T-5 and T-6). Refer also to Responses Nos 3-27 through 3-31.

Comment No. 3-6
Major analytical omissions pervade the environmental document, including the failure to assess the need for offsite water infrastructure improvements, thereby concealing secondary offsite construction impacts.

Response No. 3-6
Water/sewer infrastructure improvements needed to serve the Project would mainly occur within the confines of the Project Site. Off-site water infrastructure improvements would mainly be associated with connections/tie-ins to the water mains in the surrounding roadway (Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway), which would require some minor asphalt removal and soil disturbance in the existing roadways. The environmental and technical analysis conducted as a part of the Draft EIR (including air quality, noise, traffic, etc.) included any on-site and minor off-site water infrastructure improvements. For example, regarding air quality impacts and as addressed in the Draft EIR, the emissions generated from utility improvements would not be greater than the emissions generated during the project’s grading phase. The Draft EIR provides a conservative analysis of the maximum daily construction emissions that are generated by the Project.

Comment No. 3-7
Recirculation of the Draft EIR is legally mandatory pursuant to CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5 due to significant new information disclosed after circulation of the DEIR. The FEIR fundamentally reversed its biological baseline to acknowledge that the site provides suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox and Crotch bumble bee, inserting entirely new biological analysis and mitigation measures that were never subjected to public review.13 Furthermore, the City declined to adopt feasible mitigation for VMT, GHG, criteria pollutants, and Valley Fever without substantial evidence, and omitted foundational public health and utility analyses, depriving the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s true environmental consequences. Consequently, the Planning Commission cannot recommend Project approval or certification of the FEIR, nor make the required legal findings, and the City must revise and recirculate the Draft EIR prior to taking further approval action.

Footnote
13 FEIR, p. 3.4-16; pp. 2-15–2-18.

Response No. 3-7
24 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The Final EIR did not include any new information regarding the Project or Project Site. The clarifying information provided with respect to the potential for the SJKF and Crotch Bumble Bee species to occur on the Project site does not constitute “significant new information” that mandates recirculation of the Draft EIR. (See Cal. Public Res. Code, §21092.1.) The legal standard for determining when recirculation is required is whether the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity “to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect of the project or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect (including a feasible project alternative) that the project's proponents have declined to implement." (14 Cal. Code of Reg. §15088.5.) In this instance, the clarifying information and associated mitigation measures added to the Final EIR were in direct response and deference to comments received from CDFW, the very agency responsible for managing the State’s plant, fish and wildlife species and their habitats.

Based on CDFW’s recommendations, the City agreed to include the suggested mitigation measures to further ensure the avoidance of an incidental take. Contrary to the commenter’s assertions, the biologist’s findings from the site assessment and resulting conclusions did not change. It remains, based on the site assessment, that the disturbed site and distance from DNDBB-recorded SJKF sightings made this site unsuitable for SJFK. There is no change in the factual baseline or any new potential impacts.

The mitigation measures were added, out of an abundance of caution and deference to CDFW, to provide additional protections to the SJKF and Crotch Bumble Bee in the event these sensitive species are found on site prior to ground disturbance so that potential impacts remain less than significant. The addition of this information alone does not trigger the obligation to recirculate the DEIR. There is no indication that the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s potential biological impacts and, therefore, recirculation is not warranted.

Regarding the Commenter’s assertion that the Draft EIR and Final EIR did not include feasible mitigation measures for VMT, GHG, criteria pollutants, and Valley Fever, the City has conducted a comprehensive environmental review of the Project in full compliance with CEQA. The Draft EIR reflects a thorough, legally adequate analysis of all potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the Project.

As demonstrated in the detailed responses to specific comments provided below, the analysis relies on substantial evidence, accurate data, and approved methodologies. The Commenter has failed to provide sufficient and substantial evidence to why the Draft EIR is inadequate and would require recirculation.

Comment No. 3-8
The City also lacks substantial evidence to support General Plan Amendment land use compatibility findings because the Staff Report entirely omits consideration of the adjacent Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park and its heightened exposure to air quality, health risk, and noise impacts.

Response No. 3-8
25 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The comment letter does not provide any substantial evidence, nor show an absence of substantial evidence, demonstrating a deficiency in the Draft or Final EIR. As discussed in Response No. 3-14, the Commenter is incorrect that the Draft EIR did not adequately analyze the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park. The Draft EIR identifies "the elderly" among the sensitive population groups and treats residences and retirement facilities as sensitive receptors (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). It identifies the nearest off-site sensitive receptors to the Project Site as the mobile-home park residences approximately 750 feet to the west and two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road, which it conservatively treats as residences (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). The mobile-home park is the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which the Final EIR identifies to the west along Rosedale Highway (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28). It was identified as a sensitive receptor and potential impacts were analyzed in the Draft EIR.

Comment No. 3-9
CARE CA urges the Planning Commission to recommend that the City revise and recirculate the EIR to comply with CEQA before any further action is taken on the Project.14 Footnote
14 CARE CA reserves the right to provide supplemental comments at any and all later proceedings related to this Project. Gov. Code § 65009(b); PRC § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v.

Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal. App. 4th 1184, 1199-1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal. App. 4th 1109, 1121.

Response No. 3-9
This comment is noted for the record. The Commenter has failed to provide sufficient and substantial evidence, nor show an absence of substantial evidence, demonstrating the Draft EIR is inadequate and would require recirculation.

Comment No. 3-10
I. STATEMENT OF INTEREST
CARE CA is non-profit organization which advocates for protecting the environment and the health of their communities’ workforces. The organization’s members include the District Council of Ironworkers and Southern California Pipe Trades DC 16, along with their members, their families, and other individuals who live and work in the City of Bakersfield and in Kern County. These individuals and labor organization members may be adversely affected by the potential public and worker health and safety hazards, and the environmental impacts of the Project.
26 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

CARE CA seeks to ensure a sustainable construction industry over the long-term by supporting projects that offer genuine economic and employment benefits, and which minimize adverse environmental and other impacts on local communities. CARE CA members live, work, recreate, and raise their families in the City of Bakersfield and surrounding communities. Accordingly, they would be directly affected by the Project’s environmental and health and safety impacts.

Individual members may also work on the Project itself. They will be first in line to be exposed to any health and safety hazards that exist onsite.

In addition, CARE CA has an interest in enforcing environmental laws that encourage sustainable development and ensure a safe working environment for its members. Environmentally detrimental projects can jeopardize future jobs by making it more difficult and more expensive for business and industry to expand in the region, and by making the area less desirable for new businesses and new residents. Indeed, continued environmental degradation can, and has, caused construction moratoriums and other restrictions on growth that, in turn, reduce future employment opportunities.

Response No. 3-10
This comment provides a background on CARE CA and their interests. The comment does not outline any comments on the technical adequacy of the Draft EIR or the Final EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary.

Comment No. 3-11
II. THE FEIR STILL FAILS TO COMPLY WITH CEQA
A. The FEIR Still Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Potentially Significant Valley Fever Risks CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that it omitted discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever risks. Conversely, Dr. Clark submitted scientific evidence demonstrating that soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres could expose workers and residents to severe health hazards.

These are risks that were not disclosed or mitigated in the DEIR. This risk is especially acute given that Valley Fever is endemic to the area, with 1,848 cases reported in Kern County in 2026 alone.15 The FEIR dismisses this impact as less than significant by asserting that compliance with SJVAPCD Rule 8021 (which requires a Dust Control Plan to maintain visible dust opacity below 20 percent) will adequately control Valley Fever exposure.16 This assertion is contradicted when the City simultaneously claims that active dust monitoring is ineffective because there is “no direct correlation” between fugitive dust particulate concentration levels and airborne Valley Fever fungal spores.17 The City cannot logically claim on one hand that fugitive dust suppression measures reduce Valley Fever risk, while asserting on the other that dust concentration levels do not correlate with fungal spore exposure.18 The FEIR’s 27 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

conclusions are not supported by substantial evidence.

As Dr. Clark explains, Coccidioides arthroconidia spores range in size from 2 to 5 micrometers (𝜇𝜇m), falling directly within the respirable range of fine particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10).19 Because these microscopic spores travel attached to fine airborne soil particles, fugitive dust concentration is the direct indicator of whether dust suppression measures are successfully containing spore dispersal.20 Furthermore, relying strictly on visual opacity criteria under Rule 8021 is insufficient; visual opacity measures are dominated by coarse soil particles, meaning fine respirable particles carrying fungal spores can escape off-site at dangerous, health-impairing levels without ever breaching the 20 percent visual plume threshold.21
The City also fails to account for unusually high local susceptibility and on-site soil contaminants. Under CEQA, environmental review must evaluate the sensitivity of the surrounding environment and the receptors exposed to potential project hazards.22 Here, the City failed to evaluate the project-specific factors that exacerbate the risk of Valley Fever infection and cumulative adverse health effects. First, the FEIR contains no analysis evaluating how soil disturbance during earthmoving across the 46-acre site will impact the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which is situated directly west of the site.23 Adults over the age of 60 represent a highly sensitive population facing a significantly heightened risk of severe, disseminated, and potentially fatal Valley Fever.24 The City’s continued failure to analyze and mitigate risks to this highly vulnerable adjacent demographic violates CEQA. Second, Valley Fever cases in Kern County remain extraordinarily high, with reported cases rising from 948 in 2001 to 3,873 in 2024, and continuing at elevated levels through 2025 and 2026.25 Disturbing 46 acres of dry soil in an area of extreme endemic prevalence presents a potentially significant public health impact.

The City attempts to excuse its lack of mitigation by citing California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) requirements under Title 8 (Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144) and Labor Code Section 6709.26 But an agency cannot satisfy its obligation to analyze and mitigate off-site public environmental impacts by pointing to workplace safety laws intended solely for employee safety.

Title 8 and Labor Code regulations apply exclusively to site workers and do not prescribe fence-line exposure limits, public health protections, or off-site airborne spore containment strategies for nearby residents.27
The FEIR must mitigate the Project’s potentially significant Valley Fever impacts before the Project can be approved. The City must evaluate feasible, low-cost conditions proposed in Dr. Clark’s comments to minimize Valley Fever and particulate transport, including:

1. Mandating watering of all disturbed areas at least three to four times per day, which CalEEMod calculates achieves up to a 74 percent reduction in PM10 and PM2.5 emissions.28

2. Implementing real-time upwind and downwind perimeter PM10 and PM2.5 monitoring equipped with actionable exposure thresholds to trigger additional watering or work shutdowns.29

3. Suspending grading and excavation activities whenever sustained wind speeds exceed 20 miles 28 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

per hour.30

4. Mandatory covering of haul loads, cleaning vehicles prior to site departure, and establishing project-specific medical and respiratory protocols under the Injury and Illness Prevention Program.31 Because the City’s finding of a less-than-significant impact relies on contradictory assertions, fails to account for site-specific hazardous soil contaminants and sensitive senior receptors, and omits feasible mitigation, the Valley Fever analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must prepare a revised EIR that quantifies fine particulate transport, evaluates public health risks, and incorporates enforceable mitigation measures prior to project approval.

Footnotes
15 Clark Comments, p. 12.
16 FEIR, p. 2.0-44.
17 FEIR, p. 2.0-93; Clark Comments, p. 11.
18 FEIR, p. 2.0-91.
19 Clark Comments, p. 11.
20 Clark Comments, p. 11.
21 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-93.
22 CEQA Guidelines § 15125(a).
23 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1.
24 Clark Comments, pp. 1, 13.
25 Clark Comments, p. 11.
26 FEIR, p. 2.0-44; Clark Comments, p. 13
27 Clark Comments, p. 13
28 Clark Comments, pp. 11–12.
29 Clark Comments, p. 12
30 Clark Comments, p. 12.
31 Clark Comments, p. 12.

Response No. 3-11
As explained in the DEIR under Rule 8021, the Project is required to prepare and submit a Dust Control Plan (DCP) to the SJVAPCD for approval. The DCP would be required to detail specific actions to ensure that visible dust emissions do not exceed 20 percent opacity. These actions can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants.

Compliance with Rule 8021 would help minimize generation of fugitive dust. Fugitive dust controls address soil constituents and spores in the same way, and they do not depend on the opacity limit. The Rule 8021 Dust Control Plan must include control measures implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity, independent of the 20 percent opacity limit (Draft EIR p. 4.3-11; Response No.

O2A-12, Final EIR p. 2.0-93), and Regulation VIII also governs bulk material handling, transport, and 29 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

trackout (Draft EIR p. 4.3-10). Because these controls limit soil from becoming airborne and from being carried off site, they also limit the off-site transport of any residual soil constituents or Coccidioides spores that the soil may contain.

Regarding Valley Fever training, Kern County is identified as an area where Valley Fever is highly endemic. Project construction employers shall comply with California Labor Code Section 6709, including providing the required Valley Fever awareness training annually and before employees begin work reasonably anticipated to cause substantial dust disturbance. The training shall address potential exposure, protective practices, recognition of symptoms, and the importance of seeking appropriate medical attention.

With respect to potential exposure associated with soil disturbance near the Green Acres Estates senior mobile home community, the Project applicant shall prepare and implement a Dust Control Plan (DCP) before construction begins, pursuant to Rule 8021. As discussed in Response No. O2.3, the DCP must identify the fugitive dust control measures to be implemented before, during, and after dust-generating activities.

For this Project, in addition to whatever other measures are required to obtain SJVAPCD approval, the following dust-control requirements shall be incorporated into the DCP:

1. Watering and increased dust suppression. The contractor shall pre-wet soils before disturbance and apply water to active earthwork areas, disturbed surfaces, and unpaved haul routes. Watering frequency and application rates shall be increased when weather conditions, construction activity, visual observations, or perimeter monitoring indicate that additional suppression is needed to maintain compliance with applicable SJVAPCD dust-control requirements. Water application shall be managed to avoid runoff and erosion.

2. Real-time perimeter dust monitoring. Real-time particulate monitoring shall be conducted during grading, excavation, and other dust-generating earthwork at representative upwind and downwind perimeter locations, including the Project boundary facing Green Acres Estates. Monitoring results shall be evaluated together with wind conditions and background particulate concentrations to identify potential construction-related dust increases and initiate corrective actions. Corrective actions shall include increased watering, adjustment or reduction of contributing activities, and temporary suspension of affected activities when required dust-control standards cannot be maintained. Monitoring shall supplement visual dust observations, and monitoring results and corrective actions shall be documented.

3. Covered haul loads. Trucks transporting soil, sand, or other dust-generating bulk materials to or from the Project Site shall have securely covered loads during off-site transport. Cargo compartments and tailgates shall be maintained to prevent spillage, and empty cargo compartments shall be cleaned or covered before trucks leave the site, consistent with applicable Rule 8031 requirements.

These measures shall be implemented together with applicable requirements for vehicle speed limits, 30 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

surface stabilization, and removal of tracked material from paved streets. As explained in the DEIR, preparation and approval of the DCP, along with the other measures outlined therein, shall mitigate any potential impacts to less than significant.

Additionally, regarding the Commenter’s comment that, “The City cannot logically claim on one hand that fugitive dust suppression reduces Valley Fever risk, while asserting on the other than dust concentration levels do not correlate with fungal spore exposure…”. Dust particles act as a vector for the Valley Fever spore. However, not all dust particles may carry the Valley Fever spore. Therefore, as explained in the DEIR and prior responses to comments, fugitive dust suppressants would contribute to minimize both fugitive dust emissions and Valley Fever spores. Valley Fever effects are incorporated within the air quality and hazards analyses, which are supported by substantial evidence in the record.

The assertion that potential Valley Fever impacts must be addressed separately is incorrect.

Comment No. 3-12
B. The FEIR Still Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Health Risk Impacts From Project Operations

1. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Health Risks from the Project’s Operational Emissions CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrate that it fails to disclose, quantitatively analyze, and mitigate significant public health risks from exposure to TACs. The Project’s proposed fuel station, char broilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic will emit TACs, yet the DEIR relies on unsupported qualitative heuristics–rather than preparing a formal Health Risk Assessment (“HRA”)–to quantify operational health risk impacts.

The FEIR responds that the City’s operational health risk analysis is supported by substantial evidence because it relies on the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”) Air Quality and Land Use Handbook and rules established by the SJVAPCD.32 The City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways.33 This argument lacks merit, as the City is essentially arguing that a Project would not result in significant health risks from mobile sources unless it generates a freeway’s worth of traffic. The land use compatibility screening criteria in the CARB Handbook are intended to kickstart land use planning, not serve as a substitute for project-specific health risk evaluations or detailed environmental review under CEQA.34
Footnotes
32 FEIR, p. 2.0-58.
33 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32.

Response No. 3-12
31 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Refer to Response No. 3-4. The Draft EIR evaluated operational health risk qualitatively under Threshold AQ-3 (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-32), and the record supports its less-than-significant conclusion.

First, the land uses that typically generate substantial TACs are industrial uses with permitted stationary sources and warehousing uses associated with truck idling. Neither type of use is proposed with the Project. The Project consists of retail and commercial uses, such as medical office, self-storage, and a health club (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). Its uses "would on occasion have vendor deliveries from diesel-powered heavy-duty trucks," but "the number of heavy-duty trucks associated with the Project would not be at the frequency or volume of a warehouse project" (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54).

Heavy trucks account for 751 of the Project's 102,637 daily VMT, or approximately 0.73 percent of total Project VMT (Appendix B PDF p. 119), and the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional model's fleet mix attributes 0.15 percent of Project trips to heavy-duty trucks (Responses No. A2.2 and No. O2.16, Final EIR pp. 2.0-16, 2.0-54). Heavy-duty diesel trucks are the vehicle source that makes warehousing one of the land uses the Draft EIR identifies as typically generating substantial quantities of TACs, primarily through on-site truck idling (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). Because heavy trucks make up less than 1 percent of the Project’s VMT and trips, the Project’s traffic would not concentrate diesel truck activity near receptors the way a warehouse can and would generate an estimated 29 to 44 truck trips per day (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54), which would not exceed the Handbook’s 100-trucks-per-day screening level for potentially significant health risk impacts.

Second, TAC emissions from stationary sources that may be associated with the Project, "would be subject to further study and health risk assessment prior to the issuance of any necessary air quality permits under SJVAPCD Regulation II," which requires those emissions to be reduced or mitigated below the SJVAPCD's cancer and acute risk thresholds before a permit is issued (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31; Response to Comment 3-4).

Third, the Project’s traffic would be distributed across the local roadway network. The largest volume of Project-generated vehicle trips on any roadway segment would be 5,934 average daily trips, on Coffee Road between Jet Way and Brimhall Road (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54). The highest total roadway volume with the Project, which includes both Project and non-Project traffic, would be 62,948 average daily trips, on Coffee Road between Brimhall Road and the Westside Parkway eastbound ramps under horizon year 2046 conditions, which is below the Handbook’s 100,000-vehicle-per-day screening criterion for high-traffic roads (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54).

Fourth, the construction HRA, prepared pursuant to the 2015 Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) recommended methodology, estimated a maximum incremental cancer risk of

1.5 in one million at the maximally exposed individual resident and a chronic hazard index of 0.003, against SJVAPCD thresholds of 20 in one million and 1.0 (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, pp. 4.3-32 to 4.3-33).

Together, these facts are substantial evidence that the Project's operations would not expose sensitive receptors to substantial TAC concentrations. The SJVAPCD's recommendation for an operational HRA (Comment No. A2.2, Final EIR p. 2.0-14) was considered and responded to in Response No. A2.2 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16).

Comment No. 3-13
32 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The FEIR also fails to respond to CARE CA’s comment that the same CARB guidelines recommend against siting new sensitive land uses within 1,000 feet of a distribution center accommodating more than 100 trucks per day.35 This Project would result in 751 daily VMT for heavy trucks, demonstrating that the Project would present similar health risks as a warehouse project.36 The City’s failure to even acknowledge this comment violates CEQA’s requirements for good faith responses to comments received during the public comment period.37 It also illustrates that the FEIR’s discussion of the CARB Handbook is arbitrary and entirely unsupported.

Response No. 3-13
Commenter’s prior comments were acknowledged and responded to in the prior responses to comments. Response No. O2.21 within the Final EIR explained why the Handbook's roadway criterion was used for Project trucks on local roadways and referred to Response No. O2.16 for on-site sources (Final EIR p. 2.0-58). Response No. O2.16 within the Final EIR explained that the Project's truck activity "would not be at the frequency or volume of a warehouse project" (Final EIR p. 2.0-54), and Response No. A2.2 explained that "the Project is not a warehouse, distribution center, or another heavy-duty truck-intensive use" (Final EIR p. 2.0-15).

The Project does not include warehousing uses and consists primarily of retail, restaurant, and commercial uses (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-32). Deliveries to the major retail buildings would occur at loading docks "toward the rear of the buildings," and deliveries to the outlying pads in designated areas near each tenant (Draft EIR p. ES-2). Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road are designated truck routes under Bakersfield Municipal Code Section 10.44.060, and Project truck travel is expected to occur primarily on them (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31).

The 751 daily heavy-truck VMT figure measures miles traveled, not truck visits. From the KernCOG model's fleet mix, Responses No. A2.2 and No. O2.16 estimated 29 to 44 heavy-duty truck trips per day (Final EIR pp. 2.0-16, 2.0-54), which is below the 100-trucks-per-day screening level in the Handbook's distribution-center recommendation. Response No. A2.2 also divided the 751 truck miles by the 3.94- mile average length of all Project trips, which yields approximately 191 trips per day; that conversion assumes trucks travel no farther per trip than employees and customers, and Response No. A2.2 described it as "an overly conservative assumption" because delivery trucks would travel much longer distances, as is typical with goods movement and deliveries (Final EIR pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16). Comments on the truck trip estimates are addressed in Response No A8.

For these reasons, and for the reasons in Response No. 3-12, the Handbook's distribution-center siting recommendations does not indicate a potentially significant health risk from the Project, and the Final EIR's includes analysis and explanation of use of the criteria in the Handbook, providing substantial evidence for the conclusions in the EIR.

Comment No. 3-14
The FEIR’s defects are particularly severe given the immediate proximity of the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, located just downwind of the proposed commercial facilities and truck loading 33 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

docks.38 Elderly residents represent a sensitive demographic with heightened susceptibility to respiratory and cardiovascular toxicity from exposure to DPM and TACs.39 By relying on broad screening buffers rather than modeling actual dispersion patterns, truck idling times, traffic volume, and localized meteorology, the City improperly assumes a less-than-significant impact without evaluating the real-world exposure levels at these senior residences.40 Footnotes
34 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-58.
35 CARB, Air Quality And Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective, p. 4, available at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2023-05/Land%20Use%20Handbook_0.pdf. 36 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119.
37 Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 14, § 15088(c).
38 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, pp. 1, 11.
39 Clark Comments, p. 1.
40 Clark Comments, p. 11.

Response No. 3-14
The Draft EIR identifies "the elderly" among the sensitive population groups and treats residences and retirement facilities as sensitive receptors (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). It identifies the nearest off-site sensitive receptors to the Project Site as the mobile-home park residences approximately 750 feet to the west and two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road, which it conservatively treats as residences (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). The mobile-home park is the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which the Final EIR identifies to the west along Rosedale Highway (Response No.

O1.5, Final EIR pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28).

The record addresses each exposure factor the comment lists. For dispersion and meteorology, the operational AAQA used AMS/EPA Regulatory Model (AERMOD) dispersion modeling with meteorological data obtained from SJVAPCD for the nearest meteorological station to the Project Site (Draft EIR p. 4.3-28; Appendix B PDF p.944); its receptor grid extends about 500 meters (1,640 feet) from the site and includes Green Acres Estates (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-28); and the Project's maximum air pollution contributions on that grid are below the SJVAPCD SILs (Draft EIR Table

4.3-14, p. 4.3-29). For truck idling, diesel trucks delivering to the Project may not idle more than five minutes (California Code of Regulations [CCR], Title 13, Section 2485; Draft EIR p. 4.3-5). For traffic volumes, the highest total roadway volume with the Project, 62,948 average daily trips, is below the Handbook's 100,000-vehicle-per-day criterion (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54; Draft EIR p.

4.3-31).

Moreover, the Green Acres Estates property was considered a residential receptor type in the construction HRA, which followed the 2015 OEHHA guidance and assumed that exposure for the maximally exposed resident begins in the third trimester of pregnancy, with an infant born during the approximately 1.34-year construction period. Consistent with that guidance, the calculated risk for exposure from the third trimester to age 2 was multiplied by an age sensitivity factor of 10, and risk for 34 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

ages 2 to 16 by a factor of 3, to account for the greater sensitivity of early-life exposure. Because the entire construction period falls within the earliest age range, all of the calculated construction risk for the maximally exposed resident reflects the factor of 10 (Appendix B PDF pp. 944, 948–949). Therefore, the construction HRA considered a heightened susceptibility to respiratory and cardiovascular toxicity from exposure to DPM and TACs at all residential locations, including those at the Green Acre Estates property.

See Response to Comment 3-12 for further explanation of the reasons the City concludes that operational health risk would be less than significant.

Comment No. 3-15

2. The FEIR Piecemeals Analysis of Health Risk Impacts From the Project’s Stationary Sources Regarding health risk impacts from stationary sources such as fuel dispensing and charbroilers, the FEIR reiterates the DEIR’s assertion that these sources would be controlled through the SJVAPCD permitting process.41 CARE CA previously explained that separating the Project’s emissions sources into categories and analyzing them separately constitutes piecemealing in violation of CEQA.

The FEIR “disagrees” that this legal standard precludes omitting stationary sources from its analysis of the Project’s health risks.42 The City argues that: “[s]tationary sources were identified as distinct from the non-permitted sources to acknowledge the regulatory framework that exists for permitted sources within the SJVAPCD.”43 The City also relies on the SJVAPCD Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (“GAMAQI”) to argue that emissions from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements are per se not individually or cumulatively significant.44 Response No. 3-15
Refer to Response No. 3-4, which explains that the Draft EIR evaluated the whole of the Project and that distinguishing permitted from non-permitted sources does not remove either from the analysis (Response No. O2.22, Final EIR p. 2.0-59).

The SJVAPCD Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI) statement quoted in Response No. O2.22 of the Final EIR, that "emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with [New Source Review] requirements are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant" (Final EIR p. 2.0-59), is the air district's guidance on emissions from sources permitted under that program. The Final EIR cited it together with the Regulation II health risk requirements and the other information described in Response to Comments Nos 3-4 and 3-12; it was not the sole basis for the health risk conclusion.

Comment No. 3-16
These arguments lack merit because statutory compliance with local air district permitting rules cannot 35 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

substitute for an EIR’s independent legal duty to evaluate total, combined health risks. CEQA mandates that an agency evaluate the total environment impact of the entire project, rather than evaluating individual emission sources in isolated silos. As previously explained, CEQA defines a “project” as “the whole of an action” that may result in either a direct physical environmental change or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change.45 CEQA mandates “that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large project into many little ones – each with a minimal potential impact on the environment – which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences.”46 When a single commercial development project introduces both stationary sources (such as fuel transfer emissions containing benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene) and mobile sources (such as heavy-duty diesel truck trips producing Diesel Particulate Matter), those pollutants reach neighboring sensitive receptors concurrently.

Splitting the sources apart allows the City to claim that mobile sources pass a high-level screening threshold while assuming stationary sources are exempt from CEQA scrutiny by virtue of future air district permits.

Footnotes
41 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59.
42 FEIR, pp. 2.0-59.
43 Id.
44 FEIR, p. 2.0-58.
45 14 Cal. Code Regs. Sec. 15378.
46 Bozung v. LAFCO (1975) 13 Cal.3d 263, 283-84; City of Santee v. County of San Diego (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1438, 1452; Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 151, 165.

Response No. 3-16
Refer to Response No 3-4, which explains that all components of the Project are described and evaluated in one EIR as a single project (CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(a)), so the Project has not been divided into smaller projects in the manner the comment's quoted language describes.

Stationary sources were not treated as exempt from CEQA review. The Draft EIR identified them, described their emissions as TACs, and evaluated them under Threshold AQ-3 (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31).

CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.7(d) recognizes that an agency may use an environmental standard, including a performance requirement in an adopted air district rule that applies to the project, in determining significance, where the agency explains how the standard's requirements reduce project impacts to a less-than-significant level. Regulation II is mandatory and requires permitted-source emissions to be reduced or mitigated below the SJVAPCD thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and one for hazard index (acute risk) before a permit is issued (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). The Draft EIR relied on Regulation II as one element of its evaluation, not as a substitute for it. 36 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Receptors are exposed to all of the Project's sources at once, and the Draft EIR's conclusion under Threshold AQ-3 considered permitted and non-permitted sources together (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3- 32; Response No. O2.22, Final EIR p. 2.0-59). Response to Comment No. 3-12 explains why substantial evidence in the record supports the conclusion that the Project as a whole would not expose sensitive receptors to substantial TAC concentrations.

Comment No. 3-17
The FEIR’s piecemealed review also conflicts with SJVAPCD guidance. For development projects such as this one, “[t]he District recommends an AAQA be performed for ALL Criteria Pollutant emissions for which an ambient air quality standard exists when a development projects would result in an increase of 100 pounds per day screening level of ANY pollutant for any of the following categories: Construction emission activities [,] Operational permitted source emission activities, or […] Operational non-permitted source emission activities.”47 SJVAPCD guidance also provides that “the assessment of operational emissions in the AAQA shall evaluate operational sources within the project boundary [such as “boilers, process heaters, etc.”] as well as project-related mobile emissions…”48 Response No. 3-17
As quoted by the Commenter, the SJVAPCD guidance recommends an AAQA for “Criteria Pollutant emissions for which an ambient air quality standard exists” when the 100-pound-per-day screening level is exceeded, and the Draft EIR followed this guidance. As shown in Table 4.3-10 of the Draft EIR, construction of the Project would not exceed 100 pounds per day of any pollutant; therefore, an AAQA was not prepared. However, an AAQA was prepared for operational emissions because average daily operational carbon monoxide (CO) emissions exceed the SJVAPCD's 100-pound-per-day screening level (Table 4.3-12, Draft EIR p. 4.3-28). It used AERMOD dispersion modeling (Draft EIR p. 4.3-28) and modeled NO2, CO, SO2, PM10, and PM2.5 concentrations (Draft EIR Table 4.3-13, p. 4.3-29), and the Project's maximum modeled increments are below the SILs (Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29).

Gasoline dispensing emits volatile organic compounds (VOC), which are criteria pollutant precursors rather than criteria pollutants for which ambient air quality standards have been established (Draft EIR p. 4.3-12; Draft EIR Table 4.3-5, p. 4.3-21). No tenants have been identified within the proposed commercial shopping center. Therefore, it is speculative to assume, at this phase, the presence of charbroilers (Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18). Health risk from the Project's TAC sources is a separate assessment, evaluated under Threshold AQ-3 and addressed in Response Nos 3-4 and 3-12.

Comment No. 3-18
The City’s improper segmentation creates a severe analytical loophole that conceals potentially significant public health risks. Adjacent sensitive receptors, such as elderly residents located at the nearby Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, breathe ambient air that reflects the combined toxic load of all project operations simultaneously. CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(f) requires that an agency’s significance determination be supported by substantial evidence considering the whole project. 37 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

By refusing to perform a unified, site-specific HRA that models the additive TAC exposures from both the gas station and heavy-duty delivery truck traffic, the City lacks substantial evidence supporting its less-than-significant health risk finding.

Response No. 3-18
Refer to Response No. 3-16, which explains that the Draft EIR's conclusion under Threshold AQ-3 considered the gas station and other permitted sources together with the delivery trucks and other non-permitted sources. The Green Acres Estates residences are approximately 750 feet west of the Project Site (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19), within the AAQA receptor grid on which the Project's maximum increments are below the SILs (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-28; Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29), and TAC exposure at that location is addressed in Response No. 14. The Draft EIR's significance determination is therefore based on the whole Project and supported by substantial evidence in the record (CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(f)), for the reasons stated in Response Response No 3-12.

Comment No. 3-19
Compliance with SJVAPCD Regulation II rules does not relieve the City of its lead agency duty under CEQA to analyze and mitigate total off-site health impacts before Project approval. Because the FEIR improperly relies on piecemealed source evaluations to avoid assessing aggregate TAC concentrations, the FEIR’s operational health risk analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must revise its environmental review to include a comprehensive HRA that evaluates all stationary and mobile health risk impacts combined into a single, whole-project disclosure.

Footnotes
47 SJVAPCD, Project Ambient Air Quality Analysis Applicability Determination Under CEQA (June 2018), p. 5, https://www.valleyair.org/media/bo3hz35n/apr-2030.pdf. 48 Id. at 4-5.

Response No. 3-19
Refer to Response Nos. 3-4, 3-14, 3-16, 3-18 and A17. Response No. 3-12 addressed the less-than-significant conclusion without an operational HRA, Response to Comment A17 addresses the request for a combined operational HRA, and Responses Nos. 3-14 and 3-18 address exposure at the nearest residences.

Comment No. 3-20

3. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Construction Activities
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City’s analysis of cumulative health risks during construction is contrary to law. A major issue is that the DEIR asserts that any exceedance of a 38 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

project-level threshold (cancer risk of 20 in one million) also is considered to be a cumulatively considerable effect, while health risks that fall below applicable project-level thresholds are not considered cumulatively considerable.49 CARE CA demonstrated that this approach fails to consider the Project’s cumulative effects with existing and proposed development near the Project site as required by CEQA.50 It also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.51 Footnotes
47 SJVAPCD, Project Ambient Air Quality Analysis Applicability Determination Under CEQA (June 2018), p. 5, https://www.valleyair.org/media/bo3hz35n/apr-2030.pdf. 48 Id. at 4-5.
49 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”).
50 Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (1990) 221 Cal. App. 3d 692. 51 Clark Comments, p. 10.

Response No. 3-20
This comment restates FEIR Comment O2.24, which Response No. O2.24 addressed (Final EIR pp.

2.0-59 to 2.0-61). The Draft EIR applies the SJVAPCD's TAC incremental risk thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and a hazard index of 1.0 (Table 4.3-8, Draft EIR p. 4.3-23). Under SJVAPCD guidance, those thresholds evaluate both project-level and cumulative health risk, and "[n]o other cumulative risk thresholds apply" (Responses No. O2.24 and No. O2.27, Final EIR pp. 2.0-60, 2.0-64).

The Draft EIR did not use the ratio approach at issue in Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (Response No. O2.25, Final EIR p. 2.0-62). The construction HRA estimated a maximum incremental cancer risk of 1.5 in one million and a chronic hazard index of 0.003 at the maximally exposed individual resident (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-32). The Commenter's points on the threshold and the existing pollution burden are addressed in Responses Nos. 3-21 and 3-22.

Comment No. 3-21
The FEIR responds that any project with health risks below the individual threshold is automatically not cumulatively considerable.52 The FEIR argues that SJVAPCD guidance provides that the 20 in one million cancer risk threshold was set at such a conservative level that no cumulative impacts could occur.53 This assertion does not appear to be supported, as AB 2588 (Air Toxics “Hot Spots”) and other air districts set a 10 in one million cancer risk threshold – twice as stringent as the SJVAPCD threshold.54 In fact, the SJVAPCD guidance was referring to a 10 in one million significance threshold, which was later revised to 20 in one million.55
39 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response No. 3-21
The City applied the TAC risk thresholds currently adopted by SJVAPCD (Draft EIR Table 4.3-8, p. 4.3- 23). A lead agency may use thresholds adopted or recommended by other public agencies where its choice is supported by substantial evidence (CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.7(c)). Therefore, the City applied SJVAPCD’s adopted significance thresholds. SJVAPCD uses its health risk thresholds to evaluate both project-specific and cumulative impacts (Response No. O2.27, Final EIR p. 2.0-64).

Operational health risk is addressed in Response No. 3-12.

Comment No. 3-22
This threshold also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.56 Thus, even if 20 in one million were a conservative significance threshold for a different area, it is possible that health risk impacts would be cumulatively considerable in this highly pollution-burdened area.

Footnotes
52 FEIR, p. 2.0-60.
53 FEIR, p. 2.0-60.
54See SCAQMD, South Coast AQMD Air Quality Significance Thresholds, https://www.aqmd.gov/docs/default-source/ceqa/handbook/south-coast-aqmd-air-quality-significance-thresholds.pdf?sfvrsn=f7601d61_25. 55 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, pp. 100, 110, 56 Clark Comments, p. 10.

Response No. 3-22
Refer to Responses No. 3-5 and A4. For health risk, the SJVAPCD's thresholds measure the incremental risk resulting from a project (Response No. O2A-8, Final EIR p. 2.0-90), and the Project's quantified risk is well below them (see Response to Comment 20). The Commenter's statement that a cumulatively considerable impact is "possible" does not identify evidence that the Project's incremental risk would be cumulatively considerable; argument, speculation, and unsubstantiated opinion do not constitute substantial evidence (CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(f)(5)). More importantly, substantial evidence in the record supports the conclusion that impacts will be less than significant.

Comment No. 3-23

4. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Operations The FEIR does not include an operational HRA. The FEIR claims that an operational HRA need not be prepared because one was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County with more truck trips that did not result in significant impacts.57 But Dr. Clark explains that an HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project.58 That HRA also addressed truck emissions only, whereas 40 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

the instant Project includes a gasoline station and charbroilers.59 Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.60 Therefore, the FEIR lacks substantial evidence to conclude that health risk impacts from operations would not be cumulatively considerable.

Response No. 3-23
Refer to Response No. A20. Truck activity close to receptors, including on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation, is addressed in Response No. A13. The gas station and charbroilers are addressed in Responses Nos. 3-4, A16, and A18, and cumulative health risk in Responses Nos. 3-20 through 3-22.

Comment No. 3-24

5. The FEIR Proposes Illusory Mitigation for Operational Health Risks The FEIR describes a Condition of Approval (“COA”) to address health risks posed by possible under-fired charbroilers.61 The measure would require that a health risk assessment shall be required for any future charbroilers, and that mitigation be adopted to reduce health risks from the charbroilers if they exceed SJVAPCD’s 20 in one million cancer risk threshold.62 This mitigation is inadequate because it again piecemeals emissions from stationary sources from the Project’s other emissions sources.

Operational health risks from the Project’s total operations may exceed the significance thresholds even if charbroilers are individually below the thresholds. Therefore, this mitigation would not adequately mitigate impacts from the whole of the Project. And by calling for an HRA for future charbroilers, the FEIR paradoxically requires more review for a single component of the Project than included in the FEIR for the Project as a whole. The EIR must be revised to quantify operational health risks and analyze them along with cumulative sources of emissions.

Footnotes
57 FEIR, p. 2.0-60 (“As identified in response to the SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, an operational HRA was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498) that generates substantially more heavy duty diesel truck trips per day than the commercial uses associated with the proposed Project, which supports the conclusions in the Draft EIR that the proposed Project would not generate a substantial amount of truck trips that would warrant an operational HRA.”)
58 Clark Comments, p. 18.
59 Clark Comments, p 18.
60 Id.
61 FEIR, p. 2.0-61.
62 Id.
41 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response No. 3-24
Refer to Response No. A16 and FEIR Response No. O2.24 (Final EIR p. 2.0-61). A separate HRA for the Project as a whole is not required because the record for the Project's other operational sources supports the less-than-significant conclusion, as explained in Response to Comment No 3-12. The condition applies to every new tenant that will install an under-fired charbroiler and addresses both cancer risk and the noncancer hazard index (see Response to Comment No, A26). Regarding piecemealing and combined risk, refer to Responses No s. 3-4, 3-16, and A17. No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. 3-25

6. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulatively Considerable Emissions of Criteria Air Pollutants
As with its analysis of cumulative health risks, the FEIR assumes that emissions of criteria air pollutants below adopted regionals significance thresholds could not be cumulatively considerable.63 The FEIR fails to analyze the Project’s emissions in combination with other existing or proposed sources of emissions in the area. The FEIR’s analysis conflicts with SJVAPCD’s guidance on cumulative emissions of criteria pollutants. SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides:

If a project is significant based on the thresholds of significance for criteria pollutants, then it is also cumulatively significant. This does not imply that if the project is below all such significance thresholds, it cannot be cumulatively significant. For instance, another measure of a project’s individual significance contained in the GAMAQI is the impact on criteria pollutant concentrations in the ambient air. If the concentration exceeds any of the federal health-based ambient air concentration standards or causes a worsening of areas already exceeding those standards, the project is considered to be individually significant. Lead Agencies should also consider the cumulative impact of multiple simultaneously proposed projects, located within the same area. If the combined impacts of such projects cause or worsen an exceedance of the concentration standards, the project would have a cumulatively significant impact under CEQA. For example, simultaneous proposals for two 3 ton per year NOx sources located in the same area are each below the 10 ton per year criteria pollutant significance threshold. In this hypothetical example, analysis of each project’s impact on ambient air quality shows that they do not individually cause an exceedance of any ambient air quality standard.

However, when their combined emissions are considered, air quality modeling determines that their combined impacts cause an exceedance. In this hypothetical case, each of these projects would be considered to have a cumulatively significant impact.64 To comport with this guidance, the FEIR must be revised to analyze combined emissions with nearby proposed projects in Table 3-1 of the DEIR.65
42 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Footnotes
63 FEIR, p. 2.0-60.
64 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 107-108, https://www.valleyair.org/media/g4nl3p0g/gamaqi.pdf.
65 DEIR, p. 3-2.

Response No. 3-25
A comment letter from the Sierra Club quoted the same SJVAPCD guidance in FEIR Comment No.

O1.8, and the City responded in FEIR Responses No. O1.3 and No. O1.8 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-26 to 2.0- 30). The request to evaluate combined emissions with the Table 3-1 projects was addressed in Responses No. O2.25 through No. O2.27 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-62 to 2.0-64). As explained there and in Response No. 3-5, the SJVAPCD regional thresholds are based on its New Source Review offset thresholds, and its attainment plans use growth projections that account for existing and future cumulative development, so the thresholds evaluate both project-level and cumulative impacts (Response No. O2.27, Final EIR p. 2.0-63).

The guidance example the comment quotes concerns ambient concentrations. The Draft EIR evaluated the Project's concentration impacts in the AAQA, which added the Project's modeled concentrations to background concentrations for the area and compared the Project's increments with the SILs, which the SJVAPCD "developed … to determine whether a project's contribution would contribute significantly to an AAQS exceedance" (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-21, 4.3-29). The Project's maximum increments are below the SILs (Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29). The SJVAPCD, which prepared the guidance, reviewed the Draft EIR and did not comment on its cumulative criteria pollutant analysis (Response No. O1.9, Final EIR p. 2.0-30; Response to Comment A23). No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. 3-26

7. The FEIR Fails to Disclose that the Project’s Operations Would Result In Exceedance of Ambient Air Quality Standards for PM2.5
SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides that a project would be considered to have a significant impact if it would contribute to a violation of an ambient air quality standard by exceeding any of the CAAQS, or any of the NAAQS.66 Here, the proposed Project would elevate PM2.5 concentrations above the 24-hour National AAQS and the annual National AAQS and California AAQS, but the FEIR fails to identify these exceedances as significant impacts.67 The FEIR reasons that because Project-generated PM2.5 concentrations would not exceed the SJVAPCD significant impact levels, the potential for operation of the Project to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would also be less than significant.68 This reasoning ignores the plain language of the SJVAPCD guidance stating that an exceedance of any AAQS constitutes a significant impact.69 The FEIR must be revised to disclose and mitigate this impact.
43 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Footnotes
66 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90 67 DEIR, p. Table 4.3-13.
68 FEIR, p. 2.0-64.
69 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90.

Response No. 3-26
Refer to Response No. 3-5. Table 4.3-13 of the Draft EIR shows that background PM2.5 concentrations already exceed those standards before any Project contribution is added; the "Project + Background" totals exceed the standards because the background concentrations alone do (Draft EIR Table 4.3-13, p. 4.3-29). The statement in Response No. O2.28 that tCe commenter cites (Final EIR p. 2.0-64) refers to those totals. Where background concentrations already exceed a standard, the SJVAPCD's SILs are its measure of whether a project's contribution "would contribute significantly to an AAQS exceedance" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-21), and the Project's maximum PM2.5 increments are below them (Draft EIR Table

4.3-14, p. 4.3-29). Mitigation for this impact is therefore not required (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)). No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment No. 3-27
C. The FEIR Still Fails to Identify All Feasible GHG Mitigation The FEIR finds that emissions of GHGs would be significant and unavoidable.70 CEQA requires agencies to adopt all feasible mitigation before finding that a significant impact is unavoidable.71 The City violates this requirement by ignoring feasible mitigation proposed in SJVAPCD’s and CARE CA’s comments.72 For example, CARE CA and SJVAPCD recommended reducing the permissible idling time of diesel trucks,73 but the FEIR fails to evaluate the feasibility of reducing the permissible idling period below the five minutes already required by law.74 The FEIR, merely responds that the Project would comply with the five-minute regulatory standard.75
Footnotes
70 DEIR, p. ES-17.
71 CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2); PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091;Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883. 72 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 18 et seq.
73 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
74 DEIR, p. 4.3-5.
75 FEIR, p. 2.0-66 (Response No. O2.31); 2.0-86 (“Because California Code of Regulations 44 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Sections 2480 and 2485 of Title 13 are codified anti-idling regulations and are legally binding, the underlying presumption is that the Project would comply with these two rules.”) Response No. 3-27
Refer to Responses to Comments A14 and A15. For the Project's significant and unavoidable GHG impact, the Draft EIR incorporates MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7 (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-19 to 4.8-23).

Comment No. 3-28
SJVAPCD also recommended requiring installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers.76 The City fails to implement this measure, instead calling for mitigation for charbroiler emissions only if they would result in health risks exceeding 20 in one million.77 This measure is inadequate because the Project’s significant GHG impacts requires the City to implement all feasible mitigation; a measure that only requires mitigation if a different impact would be significant is invalid.

Footnotes
76 FEIR, p. 2.0-17.
77 FEIR, p. 2.0-18.

Response No. 3-28
The SJVAPCD recommended these systems to control particulate matter. Its comment explained that cooking meat can release carcinogenic PM2.5 species and that reducing commercial charbroiling emissions is essential to attaining the federal PM2.5 standards (Comment No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0- 17). Particulate control systems address PM2.5 and health risk as opposed to GHG emissions. CEQA directs an EIR to describe feasible measures "which could minimize significant adverse impacts" (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(1)), and a particulate control system is not a measure that would reduce the Project's GHG impact. The Project's PM2.5 and health risk impacts are less than significant, so these systems are not required as mitigation for those impacts (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3); Responses Nos. 3-5 and A26). The condition of approval addresses health risk from possible under-fired charbroilers and is not offered as GHG mitigation (Response to Comment A16).

Comment No. 3-29
D. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Transportation Impacts

1. The FEIR Fails to Identify Feasible Mitigation For the Project’s Significant VMT Impact The FEIR finds that the Project would result in significant and unavoidable VMT impacts.78 CEQA thus requires the City to adopt all feasible mitigation measures. CARE CA recommended that the Project 45 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

implement CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, “Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary).”79 The FEIR responds that “[t]he proposed implementation of employer-provided services, infrastructure, and alternative transit incentives to reduce Project VMT is practically infeasible” because “the Project Applicant possesses no legal mechanism to compel commercial tenants to implement, manage, or enforce employer-based transit programs.”80 This statement is incorrect, as the FEIR can include a measure requiring tenant lease agreements to include certain requirements.

Footnotes
78 DEIR, p. 4.16-16.
79 FEIR, p. 2.0-70.
80 FEIR, p. 2.0-71.

Response No. 3-29
The Commenter reiterates its previous comment that CAPCOA Measure T-5 represents a feasible and effective mechanism to achieve further VMT reductions. In turn, the commenter objects to the City’s response that a mitigation measure requiring the imposition employer-sponsored transit programs is facially infeasible under CEQA.

As previously established, the Project Applicant is the ultimate lessor of the individual retail sites and will have absolutely no control over the implementation, management or enforcement of employer-based transit programs. The commenter argues the proposed mitigation measure can be accomplished by requiring future lease agreements to impose certain requirements on the tenant. However, this suggestion completely ignores the unreasonable restraint this would have on future transferability in violation of the Project Applicant’s fundamental property rights. (See Civil Code, §711.) It is entirely reasonable to conclude that imposing such requirements on future tenants will have an impact on the Project Applicant’s ability to attract and maintain quality tenants, resulting in excessive vacancy rates.

Legal and economic considerations render the suggested mitigation measure infeasible.

Comment No. 3-30
Under Public Resources Code Section 21061.1 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15364, “feasible” means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, legal, social, and technological factors. When an EIR identifies significant, unmitigated impacts, the agency bears the affirmative legal burden under CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 to demonstrate, through substantial evidence, that proposed additional mitigation measures are actually infeasible.

A bare claim of infeasibility, unsupported by concrete evidence, constitutes a procedural and substantive violation of CEQA.81 In Los Angeles Unified School District v. City of Los Angeles,82 the Court of Appeal invalidated an EIR where the lead agency dismissed feasible noise mitigation measures based on vague statements of impracticality without providing supporting technical or economic data. Similarly, in Flanders Foundation v. City of Carmel-by-the-Sea,83 the court held that an agency’s infeasibility 46 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

determination must be supported by actual, quantifiable evidence rather than mere assertions of difficulty or administrative preference.

Response No. 3-30
The Commenter generally discusses Public Resources Code Section 21061.1 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15364 which requires lead agencies to adopt all feasible mitigation measures to minimize significant environmental impacts. Pursuant to applicable environmental regulations, the City has prepared a Statement of Overriding Considerations that carefully balanced the economic, legal, social, technological, and environmental benefits of the Project against its unavoidable environmental impacts to GHG and VMT.

Comment No. 3-31
The City’s response fails to meet CEQA’s standards by failing to identify actual factual, economic, legal, or technical justifications precluding implementation of Measure T-5. Factually and practically, CAPCOA Measure T-5 is fully feasible and well suited for commercial developments of this nature. As Mr. Marshall explains, CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5 establishes a proven framework to achieve up to a 4.0% reduction in VMT by incorporating voluntary commute trip reduction elements, including employer-provided infrastructure, incentives for alternative transit modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpools (Measure T-11), guaranteed ride home programs, and coordinated marketing and information services (Measure T-7).84 Given that the FEIR concedes the Project’s retail and medical office components generate significant, unmitigated VMT impacts, the City cannot legally ignore an established, standard mitigation measure published in CAPCOA guidance without providing specific facts and findings demonstrating infeasibility. 47 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Footnotes
81 City of San Jose v. Great Oaks Water Co. (1987) 192 Cal.App.3d 1005, 1017; Sierra Club v.

County of Fresno (2018) 6 Cal.5th 502, 513.
82 (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1019, 1029–1031.
83 (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 603, 618–620.

Response No. 3-31
The Commenter states that the City’s response has failed to properly justify why implementation of Measure T-5 is infeasible and otherwise argues the effectiveness of the alternative transit modes listed by CAPCOA. The effectiveness of the commute trip reductions measures is not being questioned.

Rather, it has been sufficiently demonstrated that the imposition of these measures is infeasible based on the factual circumstances of this Project. A determination of infeasibility is justified when the conclusion can be reasonably inferred from the information provided and a fair argument can be made to support the conclusion. (14 Code Cal. Reg §15384). Based on the information provided, it is entirely reasonable to conclude that requiring all future leases to include provisions obligating tenants to implement employee sponsored alternative transit incentives would be nearly impossible to enforce, have an unjustifiable impact on the owner’s property rights and would severely impact the economic viability of the Project.

Comment No. 3-32
CARE CA also recommended that the City require CAPCOA Measure T-6 (“Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring”).85 These can reduce GHG emissions from employee commute VMT by up to 26%.86 The FEIR dismisses this measure without explanation.

Response No. O2.36 only includes legal boilerplate:

CEQA does not require analysis of every imaginable alternative or mitigation measure; its concern is with feasible means of reducing environmental effects. Section 21002 states in part that the intention of CEQA is ‘to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such significant effects.’” (Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Consequently, CEQA does not mandate implementation of mitigation measures where they would be ineffective as either inapplicable to a project element or purported impact. (Ibid.) Because the commenter has failed to present feasible mitigation that was not already considered in the Draft EIR or identify a significant new or intensified impact, recirculation of the Draft EIR is not legally required under CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.87 The FEIR both violates CEQA’s requirement to identify all feasible mitigation for significant impacts and CEQA’s standards for responses to public comments received on the DEIR. The EIR must be revised and recirculated.
48 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Footnotes
84 Marshall Comments, p. 2.
85 CAPCOA Handbook, T-6. Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring)
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-6.pdf. 86 Id.
87 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.

Response No. 3-32
The Commenter challenges the City’s refusal to implement CAPCOA Measure T-6 to reduce GHC emissions from employee commute VMT. The Commenter asserts that that the City improperly dismissed the measure without proper explanation; however, it has been sufficiently demonstrated that Measure T-6, similar to Measure T-5, is infeasible under the circumstances. The imposition of mandatory trip reduction programs poses the same challenges and result in the same disproportionate legal and economic impacts to the Project as the imposition of voluntary programs under Measure T-5.

For the same reasons stated in response to Comment Nos. 3-29 and 3-31, Measure T-6 is not feasible and can be dismissed from further consideration. All feasible mitigation has been considered in the DEIR and recirculation is not warranted under CEQA.

Comment No. 3-33
E. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Potentially Significant Public Utilities Impacts CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City failed to analyze whether the Project would require offsite water infrastructure to meet the Project’s fire flow demands. Construction of improvements to existing water infrastructure may be required because the Project proposes a large new development on a vacant site. Further, the Bakersfield system has historic low-pressure areas where the minimum normal operating pressure ranges between 25 and 40 psi.88 Upgrades to offsite water mains may be required to service the Project, potentially resulting in construction activities much closer to sensitive receptors than assumed in the EIR.

The FEIR fails to provide this omitted analysis, and the FEIR’s responses do not address the specific issues raised in CARE CA’s comments. The FEIR responds that the Project’s fire flow will be determined before construction of the Project.89 This results in a failure to analyze the Project’s public utilities impacts before Project approval. And although any offsite water infrastructure upgrades may be required to meet regulatory standards, there are no measures requiring mitigation for noise, air quality, and transportation impacts that may arise from this offsite construction. The FEIR thus lacks substantial evidence to find that the Project would not require extensive offsite public utilities upgrades to provide adequate fire flow, or that such improvements would not cause significant environmental impacts.

The FEIR’s approach conflicts with CEQA’s prohibition on deferred analysis. CEQA requires that an 49 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

environmental document disclose the severity of a project’s impacts and the probability of their occurrence before a project can be approved.90 In Sundstrom v. County of Mendocino,91 the First District Court of Appeal rejected a mitigation measure that required the applicant to submit hydrological studies subject to review and approval by a planning commission and county environmental health department.92 The Court explained that the deferred analysis of hydrological conditions fails to meet CEQA’s requirement that an environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning:

By deferring environmental assessment to a future date, the conditions run counter to that policy of CEQA which requires environmental review at the earliest feasible stage in the planning process. (See Pub. Resources Code, § 21003.1; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 84.) In Bozung v. Local Agency Formation Com., supra, 13 Cal. 3d 263, 282, the Supreme Court approved “the principle that the environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning.” Environmental problems should be considered at a point in the planning process “‘where genuine flexibility remains.’” (Mount Sutro Defense Committee v. Regents of University of California, supra, 77 Cal. App. 3d 20, 34.) A study conducted after approval of a project will inevitably have a diminished influence on decision making. Even if the study is subject to administrative approval, it is analogous to the sort of post hoc rationalization of agency actions that has been repeatedly condemned in decisions construing CEQA. (Id. at p. 35; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 81; Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. Coastside County Water Dist. (1972) 27 Cal. App. 3d 695, 706 [104 Cal. Rptr. 197].)
Here, the FEIR provides no facts showing it would be infeasible to identify the Project’s fire flow requirements, determine whether existing infrastructure would need to be upsized, evaluate the impacts from construction of these upgrades, and include the results in the CEQA. The FEIR therefore fails as an informational document and is unsupported by substantial evidence.

Footnotes
88 California Water Service, Capital Project Justification Bakersfield District, July 2021, p. 97, https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/SupDoc/A2107002/3862/393926055.pdf. 89 FEIR, p. 2.0-73.
90 14 CCR §§ 15143, 15162.2(a); Cal. Build. Indust. Ass’n v. BAAQMD (2015) 62 Cal.4th 369, 388-90 (“CBIA v. BAAQMD”) (disturbance of toxic soil contamination at project site is potentially significant impact requiring CEQA review and mitigation); Madera Oversight Coalition v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 82; Berkeley Keep Jets Over the Bay Com. v. Bd. of Port Comrs. (“Berkeley Jets”) (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1344, 1370-71; CEQA Guidelines, Appendix G. 91 (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 296.
92 Id. at 306.

Response No. 3-33
The water/sewer infrastructure improvements needed to serve the Project would mainly occur within the 50 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

confines of the Project Site. Off-site water infrastructure improvements would mainly be associated with connections/tie-ins to the water mains in the surrounding roadway (Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway), which would require some minor asphalt removal and soil disturbance in the existing roadways. The environmental and technical analysis conducted as a part of the Draft EIR (including air quality, noise, traffic, etc.) included any on-site and minor off-site water infrastructure improvements. For example, regarding air quality impacts and as addressed in the Draft EIR, the emissions generated from utility
improvements would not be greater than the emissions generated during the project’s grading phase.

The Draft EIR provides a conservative analysis of the maximum daily construction emissions that are generated by the Project.

The Project would be constructed pursuant to California Fire Code (CFC) requirements and industry standards that include regulatory requirements that would aid in fire safety and support fire suppression activities, such as a fire protection system, automatic fire sprinklers, paved access, and required aisle widths that would be subject to review by Bakersfield Fire Department. Because the Project is located on a vacant site within a developed urban area, it would connect to existing adjacent water infrastructure.

The Project’s required fire flow is determined by the Bakersfield Fire Department in accordance with the CFC. Fire flow requirements are based on the final building size, construction type, and the presence of fire suppression systems (such as automatic sprinklers). The Bakersfield Fire Department will review the Project Site plans including flow requirements as part of plan review of the Project before construction of the Project.

Comment No. 3-34
III. THE EIR MUST BE RECIRCULATED
CEQA requires a lead agency to recirculate a DEIR when “significant new information” is added to the environmental review after public notice and comment, but prior to certification. Under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5, new information is deemed “significant” if the EIR is changed in a way that deprives the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect. Specifically, Guidelines § 15088.5(a) provides that recirculation is required under any of the following four circumstances:

1. A new significant environmental impact would result from the project or from a new mitigation measure proposed to be implemented.

2. A substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance.

3. A feasible project alternative or mitigation measure considerably different from others previously analyzed would clearly lessen the environmental impacts of the project, but the project’s proponents have declined to adopt it.

4. The draft EIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded.
51 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Here, the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation of the EIR.

Response No. 3-34
The Final EIR did not include any new information regarding the Project or Project Site. The clarifying information provided with respect to the potential for the SJKF and Crotch Bumble Bee species to occur on the Project site does not constitute “significant new information” that mandates recirculation of the Draft EIR. (See Cal. Public Res. Code, §21092.1.) The legal standard for determining when recirculation is required is whether the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity “to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect of the project or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect (including a feasible project alternative) that the project's proponents have declined to implement." (14 Cal. Code of Reg. §15088.5.) In this instance, the clarifying information and associated mitigation measures added to the Final EIR were in direct response to comments received from CDFW, the very agency responsible for managing the State’s plant, fish and wildlife species and their habitats.

Based on CDFW’s recommendations, the City agreed to include the suggested mitigation measures to further ensure the avoidance of an incidental take. Contrary to the commenter’s assertions, the biologist’s findings from the site assessment and resulting conclusions did not change. It remains, based on the site assessment, that the disturbed site and distance from DNDBB-recorded SJKF sightings made this site unsuitable for SJFK. There is no change in the factual baseline or any new potential impacts.

The mitigation measures were added, out of an abundance of caution and deference to CDFW, to provide additional protections to the SJKF and Crotch Bumble Bee in the event these sensitive species are found on site prior to ground disturbance so that potential impacts remain less than significant. The addition of this information alone does not trigger the obligation to recirculate the DEIR. There is no indication that the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s potential biological impacts and, therefore, recirculation is not warranted.

The Draft EIR reflects a thorough, legally adequate analysis of all potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the Project. As demonstrated in the detailed responses to specific comments provided below, the analysis relies on substantial evidence, accurate data, and approved methodologies. The Commenter has failed to provide sufficient and substantial evidence to why the Draft EIR is inadequate and would require recirculation.

Comment No. 3-35

1. The FEIR Now Discloses that the Project Would Have Potentially Significant Impacts on Special Status Species Habitat and Identifies New Mitigation Under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(2), recirculation of an EIR is mandated when significant new information added to the report demonstrates that a substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance.

In the DEIR, the City originally concluded that suitable habitat for both the Crotch bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) and the San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica, “SJKF”) was entirely absent on the Project 52 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

site.93 However, in response to comments and substantial evidence submitted by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (“CDFW”) and other public commenters establishing that the site contains suitable habitat and that SJKF historically and recently inhabit the surrounding area, the FEIR fundamentally reverses its baseline position.94
Specifically, the FEIR introduces new factual determinations, acknowledging for the first time that while the site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for a majority of species, these conditions “do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox population and recent or historical occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land” and admitting that “[t]he open site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.”95 Furthermore, the FEIR incorporates admissions from the City’s biological consultant acknowledging “that Crotch’s bumble bee habitat cannot be conclusively determined during a non-blooming survey period and that SJKF may use disturbed urban areas for movement and denning.”96 Footnotes
93 DEIR, pp. 3.4-12–3.4-14; p. 3.0-10 (“There is no suitable habitat for this species present on the project site”); p. 2.0-5 (“The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) is absent on the Project site based on a single general wildlife survey conducted in November 2025.”). 94 FEIR, p. 3.4-16; pp. 2-15–2-18.

Response No. 3-35
The Project Site is and remains in urban disturbed ruderal habitat. Based on CDFW’s recommendations, the City agreed to include the suggested mitigation measures to further ensure the avoidance of an incidental take. Contrary to the Commenter’s assertions, the biologist’s findings from the site assessment and resulting conclusions did not change. It remains, based on the site assessment, that the disturbed site and distance from DNDBB-recorded SJKF sightings made this site unsuitable for SJFK. There is no change in the factual baseline or any new potential impacts.

SJKF may use the area for denning, foraging, or movement but the Project Site isn’t an established high-quality habitat. Nevertheless, the revised Biological Assessment contained in the Final EIR recognizes SJKF potential use despite the unsuitable habitat.

Intermittent use or detection of the project site by SJKF does not automatically require an Incidental Take Permit (ITP). Work may only start or resume after the biologist documents that applicable avoidance requirements have been satisfied, including any required agency coordination. If in the pre-construction survey or during construction an active SJKF den is found and measures were not enacted that result in take, the applicable authorization must be obtained before those activities proceed under state or federal law.

For Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB), per CDFW recommendations, the Final EIR includes Mitigation Measures MM-4, MM-5, MM-6 and M M-7 that identify habitat assessment, focused surveys where nectar patches are present, avoidance measures, and coordination with agencies if “take” cannot be 53 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

avoided. The conclusions within the Draft and Final EIR and revised Biological Assessment remains the same and do not document any confirmed any CBB occupancy; only note that CBB surveys will be necessary if host plants are found in preconstruction surveys Comment No. 3-36
This radical change in the EIR’s factual baseline triggers mandatory recirculation under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(1) and (a)(2) because the FEIR identifies previously undisclosed, significant potential impacts to special-status species and their active movement/denning habitats.97 To address these newly disclosed impacts, the FEIR inserts entirely new biological mitigation measures—including mandatory pre-construction survey protocols, avoidance buffer zones, potential natal den excavation requirements for SJKF, and species-specific foraging habitat preservation protocols for the Crotch bumble bee—that were completely absent from the DEIR.98
Response No. 3-36
The clarifying information provided with respect to the potential for the SJKF and CBB species to occur on the Project Site does not constitute “significant new information” that mandates recirculation of the DEIR. (See Cal. Public Res. Code, §21092.1.) The legal standard for determining when recirculation is required is whether the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity “to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect of the project or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect (including a feasible project alternative) that the project's proponents have declined to implement." (14 Cal. Code of Reg. §15088.5.) In this instance, the clarifying information and associated mitigation measures added to the Final EIR were in direct response to comments received from the CDFW, the very agency responsible for managing the State’s plant, fish and wildlife species and their habitats.

Based on CDFW’s recommendations, the City agreed to include the suggested mitigation measures to further ensure the avoidance of an incidental take.

Contrary to the Commenter’s assertions, the biologist’s findings from the site assessment and resulting conclusions did not change. It remains, based on the site assessment, that the disturbed site and distance from DNDBB-recorded SJKF sightings made this site unsuitable for SJFK. There is no change in the factual baseline or any new potential impacts. The mitigation measures were added, out of an abundance of caution and deference to CDFW, to provide additional protections to the SJKF and Crotch Bumble Bee in the event these sensitive species are found on site prior to ground disturbance so that potential impacts remain less than significant. The addition of this information alone does not trigger the obligation to recirculate the Draft EIR. There is no indication that the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s potential biological impacts and, therefore, recirculation is not warranted.

Comment No. 3-37
In Response A1.5, the lead agency attempts to avoid recirculation by claiming that these FEIR revisions merely represent “clarifications” or “amplifications” of the DEIR’s existing biological analysis.99 This argument fails as a matter of law because changing an impact determination from “habitat absent” in the 54 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

DEIR to acknowledging active intermittent denning, movement opportunities, and potential special-status species habitat in the FEIR is a fundamental change in factual baseline rather than a minor clarification.100 By withholding the acknowledgment of suitable SJKF and Crotch bumble bee habitat until the FEIR and adding new mitigation measures after the close of public review, the lead agency deprived the public, CDFW, and trustee agencies of their legal right under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(4) to meaningfully evaluate and comment upon the adequacy, enforceability, and feasibility of these newly formulated biological protections.101 Because the FEIR relies on post-DEIR habitat acknowledgments and uncirculated mitigation schemes to assert that impacts to SJKF and Crotch bumble bee are reduced to a less-than-significant level, the lead agency must recirculate the revised EIR prior to project approval or certification.102
Footnotes
95 FEIR, Biological Resources, p. 3.4-17.
96 FEIR, pp. 3.4-19, 2-22.
97 FEIR, pp. 1-2, 3.4-20–3.4-22.
98 FEIR, pp. 3.4-23–3.4-28.
99 FEIR, p. 2-42.
100 FEIR, pp. 2-43, 3.4-17.
101 FEIR, pp. 1-3, 2-44.
102 FEIR, pp. 1-4, 3.4-30.

Response No. 3-37
See response No. 3-36 above.

Comment No. 3-38

2. The DEIR (And Now FEIR) Omitted Major Analyses That Precluded Meaningful Public Review And Comment
Under Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4), recirculation of an EIR is mandatory where the DEIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded. The record demonstrates that this DEIR suffered from profound analytical omissions that deprived the public and trustee agencies of a meaningful opportunity to evaluate the Project’s environmental consequences, triggering mandatory recirculation under Section 15088.5(a)(4).

As discussed above, a glaring analytical omission in the EIR is the complete failure to evaluate and disclose public health risks associated with Valley Fever exposure. Soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres in Kern County—a region where Valley Fever is endemic and where 1,848 cases were reported in 2026 alone—present a severe health hazard to local workers and nearby residents.103 The DEIR omitted discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever entirely.

The EIR further suffers from critical omissions regarding operational health risks from TACs. Rather than 55 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

conducting a formal HRA to model exposure from heavy-duty diesel truck traffic, a proposed fuel station, charbroilers, and a car wash, the DEIR relied on broad qualitative screening heuristics from the CARB Handbook.104 By failing to perform a unified HRA that models additive TAC exposures, the lead agency omitted essential information necessary for meaningful public review.

In addition, the EIR improperly deferred the analysis of public utilities impacts in violation of CEQA’s prohibition against post-hoc environmental review.105 CARE CA demonstrated that the Project may require offsite water main upgrades to meet fire flow demands in a municipal system characterized by historic low-pressure areas.106 Rather than analyzing whether offsite construction would be required and evaluating the resulting air quality, noise, and traffic impacts on nearby receptors, the FEIR states that fire flow requirements will be determined prior to construction.107 Deferring environmental assessment to post-approval study deprives the public of the ability to comment on the true physical footprint and secondary construction impacts of the Project.108
Because the Draft EIR omitted critical disclosures regarding endemic Valley Fever, operational TAC exposures, and offsite utility construction, meaningful public review and comment were precluded.

Consequently, the Planning Commission cannot recommend certification of the FEIR, and the City must revise and recirculate the EIR pursuant to Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4).

Response No. 3-38
The Commenter makes claims that the Draft and Final EIR are inadequate and did not provide the public and agencies of an opportunity to evaluate potential environmental effects. These claims by the Commenter are not based on any substantial evidence, nor do they identify any lack of substantial evidence in the record in support of the conclusions in the EIR.

Regarding public outreach, pursuant to Section 15082 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City circulated an Notice of Preparation (NOP) of the Draft EIR to State, regional, and local agencies, and members of the public for a 32-day public review period. The public review period began Friday, October 31, 2025, and concluded Monday, December 1, 2025. Four written comment letters were received during the scoping period. The City also held an EIR Scoping Meeting for the Project on Thursday, November 20, 2025.

The purpose of the EIR Scoping Meeting was for the City to solicit input and written comments from agencies and the public on environmental issues or alternatives they believe should be addressed in the Draft EIR. A presentation explaining the Project was provided and potential attendees were given an opportunity to provide their comments on the scope of the Draft EIR. No members of the public attended the EIR Scoping Meeting, and no comments were received at the meeting.

The Draft EIR was published on July 10, 2026. The Draft EIR was circulated for a 45-day public comment period in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15105. Six comment letters were received on the Draft EIR (two agencies, two organizations and two individuals). These comment letters were responded to in the Final EIR. Based on CDFW’s recommendations, the City agreed to include the suggested mitigation measures to further ensure the avoidance of an incidental take. The biologist’s findings from the site assessment and resulting conclusions did not change. 56 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Regarding the Commenter’s assertation that an operational HRA was required as described in Response No. 3-4, given the operational characteristics of the Project, a quantitative operational HRA was not warranted because the Project, and all its sources combined as outlined above, does not have the potential to exceed the 20 in a million threshold adopted by SJVAPCD.

Regarding water upgrades and off site construction impacts, the water/sewer infrastructure improvements needed to serve the Project would mainly occur within the confines of the Project Site.

Off-site water infrastructure improvements would mainly be associated with connections/tie-ins to the water mains in the surrounding roadway (Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway), which would require some minor asphalt removal and soil disturbance in the existing roadways. The environmental and technical analysis conducted as a part of the Draft EIR (including air quality, noise, traffic, etc.) included any on-site and minor off-site water infrastructure improvements. For example, regarding air quality impacts and as addressed in the Draft EIR, the emissions generated from utility improvements would not be greater than the emissions generated during the project’s grading phase. The Draft EIR provides a conservative analysis of the maximum daily construction emissions that are generated by the Project.

The Project would be constructed pursuant to California Fire Code (CFC) requirements and industry standards that include regulatory requirements that would aid in fire safety and support fire suppression activities, such as a fire protection system, automatic fire sprinklers, paved access, and required aisle widths that would be subject to review by Bakersfield Fire Department. Because the Project is located on a vacant site within a developed urban area, it would connect to existing adjacent water infrastructure.

The Project’s required fire flow is determined by the Bakersfield Fire Department in accordance with the CFC. Fire flow requirements are based on the final building size, construction type, and the presence of fire suppression systems (such as automatic sprinklers). The Bakersfield Fire Department will review the Project Site plans including flow requirements as part of plan review of the Project before construction of the Project.

Regarding Valley Fever, fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever. Because the Project is a non-residential project that would disrupt more than five acres of land, it would be subject to SJVAPCD Rule 8021 to minimize fugitive dust during construction activities. Under Rule 8021, the Project would be required to prepare and submit a Dust Control Plan (DCP) to the SJVAPCD for approval. The DCP would be required to detail specific actions to ensure that visible dust emissions do not exceed 20 percent opacity. These actions can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants. Construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the Project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupational safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices.

Title 8 CCR Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 CCR Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employers when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified 57 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the proposed project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to the Section.

Comment No. 3-39
IV. THE CITY LACKS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO MAKE THE PROJECT’S LAND USE

APPROVALS
A. The City Cannot Certify the FEIR, Adopt a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and Adopt Findings of Fact
Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council certify the FEIR, adopt an MMRP, and adopt findings of fact. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he provisions of CEQA, the State CEQA Guidelines, and the City of Bakersfield CEQA Implementation Procedures have been followed.”109 This finding is not supported by substantial evidence, as these comments demonstrate that the FEIR violates CEQA’s procedural, informational, and analytical requirements. The Project would have significant impacts concerning health risk, air quality, GHG, noise, public utilities that have not been adequately disclosed and mitigated, and the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation before the Draft Resolution can be approved. In sum, the Planning Commission lacks the evidence necessary to recommend certification of the FEIR, or adoption of Findings of Fact and MMRP.

Response No. 3-39
The commenter reiterates the Commenter’s belief that the Draft EIR and Final EIR fail to meet the requirements of CEQA. Specific issues raised by the Commenter in the letter are addressed in Response to Comments Nos. 3-1 through 3-38. For all the reasons set forth therein, the Draft EIR adequately analyzed the Project’s potential environmental impacts as required by CEQA. The comment letter does not provide any substantial evidence demonstrating a deficiency in the Draft or Final EIR. The Final EIR did not include any new information regarding the Project or Project Site. There is no indication that the public was deprived of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s potential biological impacts and, therefore, recirculation is not warranted.

Comment No. 3-40
B. The City Cannot Make the Requisite Findings to Approve the General Plan Amendment Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council approve the Project’s General Plan Amendment. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he Project is compatible with the land use designations and development of surrounding properties and is internally consistent with the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan.”110 The City lacks substantial evidence to make this finding because the Project would result in potentially significant air quality, health risk, and noise impacts to senior residents at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which 58 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

is situated directly west of the site.111 The Staff Report fails to mention this land use anywhere in its discussion of the Project’s consistency with the surrounding properties. Therefore, the Planning Commission lacks substantial evidence to approve the Resolution.

Footnotes
103 FEIR, p. 2.0-44.
104 FEIR, p. 2.0-52.
105 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.
106 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.
107 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.
108 FEIR, p. 2.0-73.
109 Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001, p. 2.
110 Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001, p. 2.
111 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1.

Response No. 3-40
The comment letter does not provide any substantial evidence, nor show a lack of substantial evidence, demonstrating a deficiency in the Draft or Final EIR. As discussed in Response No. 3-14, the Commenter is incorrect that the Draft EIR did not adequately analyze senior residents. The Draft EIR identifies "the elderly" among the sensitive population groups and treats residences and retirement facilities as sensitive receptors (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). It identifies the nearest off-site sensitive receptors to the Project Site as the mobile-home park residences approximately 750 feet to the west and two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road, which it conservatively treats as residences (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). The mobile-home park is the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which the Final EIR identifies to the west along Rosedale Highway (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28). The park was identified as a sensitive receptor and potential impacts were analyzed in the Draft EIR.

Comment No. 3-41
Conversely, substantial evidence in the record demonstrates that the Project’s construction and operation would impact the health and general welfare of residents near the Project site. Residents would be exposed to fugitive dust disturbed during construction activities, which may expose them to Valley Fever spores. Residents would be exposed to potentially significant concentrations of TACs during operations, but the FEIR failed to analyze this risk in a quantitative HRA. Air quality and noise impacts to residents would be much higher than disclosed in the FEIR if the Project requires offsite construction to upsize water mains. The City cannot approve the General Plan Amendment until these impacts are analyzed and mitigated in accordance with CEQA Response No. 3-41
The comment reiterates the Commenter’s belief that the Draft EIR and Final EIR fails to meet the requirements of CEQA. Specific issues raised by the Commenter in the letter are addressed in Response 59 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

to Comments Nos. 3-1 through 3-38. For all the reasons set forth therein, Draft EIR adequately analyzed the Project’s potential environmental impacts as required by CEQA.

Comment No. 3-42
V. CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, the FEIR for the Project remains wholly inadequate under CEQA. It must be thoroughly revised to provide legally adequate analysis of, and mitigation for, all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts.

These revisions will require that the EIR be recirculated for public review. Until the EIR has been revised and recirculated, as described herein, the City may not lawfully approve the Project. Further, the record does not support the findings necessary to make the Project approvals. CARE CA urges the Planning Commission to recommend that the City revise and recirculate the EIR before any further action is taken on the Project.

Response No. 3-42
The Commenter’s claims are meritless. As noted in the responses above, the Draft EIR adequately analyzed the Project’s potential environmental impacts as required by CEQA, and the record provides substantial evidence in support of the analysis and conclusions. The comment letter does not provide any substantial evidence, nor show a lack of substantial evidence, demonstrating a deficiency in the Draft or Final EIR. The Comment falls far short of meeting its burden to show any error in the Draft or Final EIR. The Draft or Final EIR proposed for approval is valid and fully compliant with CEQA and there is no substantial evidence to support revising or recirculating the EIR for the Project. 60 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Exhibit A
Clark & Associates
James J.J. Clark, Ph.D.
12405 Venice Blvd, Suite 331
Los Angeles, CA 90066
Comment A-1
Dear Mr. Marshall:

At the request of Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo (ABJC), I have reviewed the City of Bakersfield (City) Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), dated September 2026. My review focused on the City's responses to my August 21, 2026 comment letter on the Draft EIR (DEIR), which the City reproduced as Appendix O2A and answered in Responses O2A-1 through O2A-14. I also reviewed the City's responses to the comment letter submitted by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD or District) (Comment Letter A2, Responses A2.1 through A2.14), the related responses to ABJC's letter that repeat or expand on the City's technical positions (Responses O2.12 through O2.28), and the revisions in the FEIR Errata (Section 3.0).

Response A-1
The comment provides an introduction to the appendix. No further response is needed.

Comment A-2
The City's responses in the FEIR do not resolve the deficiencies I identified in the DEIR nor do they address the District's comments. Several responses introduce new figures that conflict with one another or with the DEIR. Others rely on screening tools and permit programs that were not designed to answer the questions raised. The FEIR also confirms, for the first time, that total PM2.5 concentrations at nearby receptors would exceed the federal and state ambient air quality standards within the Project in operation.

My review of the materials in no way constitutes a validation of the conclusions or materials contained within the FEIR. If I do not comment on a specific item, this does not constitute acceptance of that item.

Response A-2
This comment is noted for the record. As described in the responses below, the Commenter does not raise any substantial evidence, nor show a lack of substantial evidence, that that demonstrates in any deficiencies in the analysis in the Draft or Final EIR.

Comment A-3
PART I. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO CLARK'S COMMENTS
Responses O2A-1 through O2A-3: Project Description and Environmental Setting The City noted the project description and setting comments without responding to the substance of my comment. The setting information is directly relevant to the impacts discussed below and should not be set aside as background.
61 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

First, the Project site is subject to a 2019 Land Use Covenant because on-site soils contain total petroleum hydrocarbons as diesel and motor oil, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), and Title 22 metals. Fugitive dust generated by grading and excavation across the 46-acre site can carry these contaminants off-site along with Coccidioides spores. This makes the City's reliance on visual opacity limits for dust control (Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12) a greater concern here than on an uncontaminated site.

Second, the FEIR itself identifies the nearest residential community to the west as the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park.1 This confirms my point that the nearest receptors include older residents, who are more susceptible to the effects of fine particulate matter and toxic air contaminants (TACs) and are at higher risk of severe Valley Fever. None of the City's responses account for the sensitivity of this population. 62 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-3
Comments No. O2A-2 and No. O2A-3 in the Final EIR described the site's history, its Land Use Covenant (LUC), the surrounding land uses, and the nearest sensitive receptors (Final EIR pp. 2.0-77 to 2.0-79).

They did not identify a deficiency in the Draft EIR, which contains and relies on that setting information. It describes the LUC and the site's remediation status (Draft EIR p. 4.9-10) and identifies the nearest sensitive receptors, including the mobile-home park residences approximately 750 feet west of the Project Site and 63 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

the two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road that the Draft EIR conservatively treats as residences (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). Responses No. O2A-2 and No. O2A-3 therefore noted the comments for the record.

As described on page 4.9-10 of the Draft EIR, an LUC was recorded for the former PG&E power plant site, including the Project Site, and required preparation of a Soil Management Plan (SMP), "which was prepared for the Project area and approved by the CVRWQCB (Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board).

After remediation, residual concentrations of contaminants of concern in soil and soil vapor are below the commercial/industrial Water Quality Control Board Environmental Screening Levels, the former power plant is considered a controlled recognized environmental condition, and the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment recommended no additional assessment (Draft EIR p. 4.9-10).

Fugitive dust controls address soil constituents and spores in the same way, and they do not depend on the opacity limit. The Rule 8021 Dust Control Plan must include control measures implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity, independent of the 20 percent opacity limit (Draft EIR p. 4.3- 11; Response No. O2A-12, Final EIR p. 2.0-93), and Regulation VIII also governs bulk material handling, transport, and trackout (Draft EIR p. 4.3-10). Because these controls limit soil from becoming airborne and from being carried off site, they also limit the off-site transport of any residual soil constituents or Coccidioides spores that the soil may contain. Valley Fever is addressed further in Response No. 3-11.

The Draft EIR identifies the elderly as a sensitive population group and treats residences and retirement facilities as sensitive receptors (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). Its analyses evaluate exposure at the nearest receptors through the construction HRA (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-32) and the AAQA, whose receptor grid includes Green Acres Estates (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-28). The susceptibility of older residents to operational air pollution is addressed in Response Nos. 3-14. Their susceptibility to Valley Fever is addressed in Response No. 3-11.

Comment A-4
Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8: Pollution Burden and CalEnviroScreen Results The City states that the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results were provided in the CalEEMod output files in Appendix B, that the adjacent census tract scores higher primarily because it contains State Route 99, and that the adjacent tract's score has no relevance to the Project. These statements do not address my comment. 64 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Figure 3: FEIR Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89
First, placing percentile scores in model output files is not a full disclosure to the public regarding the potential impacts that currently exist nor does it provide the decision makers with adequate information for their review. The air quality section of the DEIR does not discuss them, and the FEIR Errata does not add them.

Second, the pollution-burden indicators I cited are for the Project's own census tract, not the adjacent tract:

PM2.5 in approximately the 99th percentile statewide and ozone in approximately the 94th percentile. The City's explanation about State Route 99 and the adjacent tract's composite score does not speak to these values. The FEIR provides no indicator data for the adjacent tract to support its explanation. The Project would add approximately 14.6 tons per year of VOC and 10.3 tons per year of NOx (both ozone precursors), along with direct PM2.5, to a tract that already ranks near the top of the state for both pollutants. 65 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

66 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Third, the City's own ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) confirms the concern. The FEIR states that, with the Project in operation, total PM2.5 concentrations would exceed the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS), the annual NAAQS, and the annual California Ambient Air Quality Standard (CAAQS).2 The City finds the impact less than significant only because the Project's increment falls below the District's significant impact levels (SILs). As a result, the Project would add PM2.5 at receptors where the standards are already exceeded. The FEIR does not report the size of that increment at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park nor does it report the size of the increase at the residences in the tract east of Coffee Road, and it does not identify any on-site measure to reduce the PM2.5 increases. Feasible measures that would lower the local PM2.5 increment include particulate controls on under-fired charbroilers and a designed vegetative barrier on the western boundary (see Part II, Responses A2.4 and A2.5).

Finally, the City states that the District's health risk threshold measures incremental risk and does not consider existing ambient risk. I agree that the threshold is incremental. That is not a reason to withhold the existing pollution burden from decision makers, and in any case the Project's incremental operational risk was never calculated (see Response O2A-7).

I recommend that the CalEnviroScreen results for the Project tract and the adjacent SB 535 tract be presented in the air quality analysis, the Project's modeled PM2.5 increment should be reported at each sensitive receptor group, and on-site PM2.5 reduction measures should be adopted.

Response A-4
The CES 4.0 results for the Project's census tract are part of the Draft EIR's technical appendix. The CalEEMod output in Appendix B reports, for that tract, PM2.5 at about the 99th percentile statewide, ozone at about the 94th percentile, and DPM at about the 55th percentile, with an overall CES 4.0 score of 30; the tract is not designated a disadvantaged community under SB 535 (Appendix B PDF pp. 172, 175). The adjacent tract east of Coffee Road, which the comment identifies as an SB 535 disadvantaged community, is discussed in Comment and Response No. O2A-8, and its westernmost portion is within the AAQA receptor grid (Final EIR pp. 2.0-88 to 2.0-90).
67 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

These indicators describe the existing pollution burden from all sources in the area, and the DEIR's analysis accounts for that burden. The monitored background concentrations used in the AAQA already exceed the PM2.5 standards (Draft EIR Table 4.3-13, p. 4.3-29). The SJVAPCD's thresholds measure the Project's incremental contribution against that existing condition: its mass emissions against the regional thresholds (Draft EIR p. 4.3-20), its concentration increments against the SILs (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-21, 4.3-29), and its health risk against the incremental risk thresholds (Response No. O2A-8, Final EIR p. 2.0-90). The Project's regional VOC and NOX emissions, which the comment notes are ozone precursors, are mitigated to below the SJVAPCD thresholds by MM AQ-1 (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). Because the analysis already measures the Project's contribution against the existing pollution burden, presenting the CES indicators in the air quality section would not change any significance conclusion.

Refer to Response No. 3-5, which explains that the PM2.5 standards are exceeded by background concentrations before any Project contribution, that the Draft EIR disclosed those values, and that the Project's maximum PM2.5 increments are below the SILs (Draft EIR Tables 4.3-13 and 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29).

Refer also to Response No. 3-26. Table 4.3-14 of the Draft EIR reports the maximum increment at any receptor on the AAQA grid, which includes Green Acres Estates (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-28) and the westernmost portion of the tract east of Coffee Road (Response No. O2A-8, Final EIR p. 2.0-90).

The Project's increment at each of those locations therefore does not exceed the maximum values in Table

4.3-14, which are below the SILs, so reporting the grid maximum discloses the highest Project contribution at these receptor groups.

The SJVAPCD's health risk threshold measures incremental risk (Response No. O2A-8, Final EIR p. 2.0- 90). Operational health risk is addressed in Responses Nos. 3-4 and 3-2. Because the Project's PM2.5 contribution is less than significant,on-site PM2.5 measures, including the charbroiler controls and vegetative barrier the comment mentions, are not required as mitigation (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

Comment A-5
Response O2A-5: Reliance on the VERA and Lack of On-Site Reductions The City disagrees that operational emissions are addressed solely through the Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) in MM AQ-1, pointing to MM AQ-2 (low-VOC coatings) and MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7. This response does not change the conclusion in my comment, for the following reasons.
68 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

• None of the greenhouse gas measures was quantified for VOC or NOx reductions.

If those measures produced meaningful reductions, the mitigated operational emissions would reflect them. They do not. The Project still exceeds both thresholds before the VERA is applied, which is why the VERA is needed. • The City does not dispute that the exceedances are driven by mobile sources. MM GHG-1 (all-electric buildings) specifically exempts commercial cooking, which is the largest natural gas use in a retail center of this type, so its NOx benefit is small.

MM GHG-2 (carbon-free electricity) reduces emissions at off-site power plants, not local VOC or NOx. MM GHG-3 (electric landscaping equipment) addresses a minor source.
• The transportation measures (improvements at up to two bus stops, one end-of-trip shower facility, and CALGreen Tier 2 electric vehicle parking) would have a negligible effect on a project generating between 18,921 and 28,479 daily trips.

None of these measures addresses delivery trucks which can be a significant source of criteria and toxic air contaminant pollutants. • MM AQ-2 reduces VOC from architectural coatings, but the FEIR does not state how much. The VOC exceedance (14.6 tons per year against a 10 ton per year threshold) is driven by vehicle trips.
69 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-5
The Project's VOC and NOX exceedances are driven by mobile sources (Draft EIR p. 4.3-27), and the on-site measures produce modest reductions. The Draft EIR quantified those reductions and did not claim that the on-site measures alone would eliminate the exceedance. With MM AQ-2 (low-VOC coatings) and MM GHG-3 (electric landscaping equipment), full buildout operational emissions fall from 14.56 to 14.27 tons per year of VOC and from 10.29 to 10.28 tons per year of NOX; Table 4.3-15 reports the MM AQ-2 reduction together with MM GHG-3 (Draft EIR Table 4.3-15, p. 4.3-30). The Draft EIR did not credit MM GHG-1 or MM GHG-2 with VOC or NOX reductions (Draft EIR Table 4.3-15). MM GHG-1 excepts commercial cooking, and MM GHG-2, which requires enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan where available, or the next-highest carbon-free plan, acts on electricity generation rather than on-site emissions (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-19 to 4.8-20; Response O2A-5, Final EIR p. 2.0-81).

The measure that reduces the remaining exceedance is MM AQ-1, which requires a VERA with the SJVAPCD that is "crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX " (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30; Errata pp. 3.0-2, 3.0-4). A VERA "provides pound-for-pound mitigation of air pollutant emissions through a process that funds and implements emission reduction projects through the SJVAPCD emission reduction incentive grant program" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). The on-site measures are credited first, and the VERA addresses the exceedance that remains: 4.27 tons per year of VOC (14.27 compared with 10) and 0.28 tons per year of NOX (10.28 compared with 10) (Draft EIR Table 4.3-15, p. 4.3-30). Because MM AQ-1 is defined by a performance standard reflecting the SJVAPCD’s significance thresholds, it addresses the mobile-source emissions, including those from delivery trucks, that the on-site measures do not; heavy trucks account for 0.73 percent of daily VMT (Appendix B PDF p. 119). With MM AQ-1, the regional VOC and NOX impacts are "less than significant with mitigation incorporated" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). 70 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Comment A-6
The timing of the VERA is also a concern. As revised in the Errata at the District's request, MM AQ-1 now requires only execution of the VERA before building permits are issued.3 The District explained that the time required to achieve the reductions "may vary" and that verification "may occur after issuance of building permits." The revised measure contains no deadline for the reductions to be achieved and no requirement that they be in place before the Project begins operating. As written, the Project could operate for an undefined period with its VOC and NOx exceedances unmitigate 71 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

In addition, VERA reductions are achieved wherever the District funds emission reduction projects across the eight-county air basin. They do not necessarily reduce exposure in the Project's neighborhood. On-site measures do, which is why they should be applied first and the VERA used for the remainder.

The City's reference to the charbroiler Condition of Approval (CoA) in this response is not relevant to this comment. The CoA addresses health risk from individual tenants. It does not reduce VOC or NOx emissions.

Footnotes
1 FEIR, Response O1.5, pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28.
2 FEIR, Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89; Response O2.28, p. 2.0-64. 72 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

3 FEIR, Response A2.3, p. 2.0-17; Errata, p. 3.0-4.

Response A-6
MM AQ-1, as revised in the Final EIR Errata (Errata pp. 3.0-2, 3.0-4), is adequate mitigation. The change from "completion" to "execution" was made at the SJVAPCD's request, to reflect how the VERA program works. As the SJVAPCD explained, "once the VERA is executed and the required emission reduction fees are paid, the District will use the funds to achieve the required emission reduction through District emission reduction programs"; "[t]he time required to achieve these emission reductions may vary depending on the types of emission reduction projects implemented"; and "[o]nce the required emission reductions have been achieved, the District will verify to the City that the mitigation requirements of the VERA have been completed" (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR pp. 2.0-16 to 2.0-17). The District requested the revision to "more accurately reflect the VERA process and avoid implying that all required emission reductions must be achieved prior to issuance of building permits" (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR p. 2.0-17), and the City has relied on the District's description of its own program.

The measure is enforceable as written. The VERA must be "crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX " (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30). It must be executed, and the City must receive documentation verifying execution, before building permits are issued (Errata p. 3.0-4), so the obligation is fixed before construction and operation.

The SJVAPCD administers the funds through its emission reduction incentive programs and verifies completion to the City (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR pp. 2.0-16, 2.0-17; Draft EIR p. 4.3-30).

VERA-funded reductions may occur anywhere in the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin, and the impact MM AQ-1 mitigates is regional. VOC and NOX are ozone precursors, and NOX is also a precursor to particulate matter (Draft EIR p. 4.3-27). The SJVAPCD's regional thresholds gauge a project's contribution to the basin's nonattainment designations (Draft EIR p. 4.3-20), so reductions elsewhere in the basin address the regional impact. Local exposure is evaluated separately through the AAQA (Draft EIR Tables 4.3-13 and

4.3-14, p. 4.3-29) and the health risk analysis (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-33), and those local impacts are less than significant (Response Nos. 3-5, 3-12, and A4). The on-site measures are credited before the VERA (Response to Comment A5; Response No. O2A-5, Final EIR pp. 2.0-81 to 2.0-82).

Response No. O2A-5 noted the charbroiler condition of approval in addition to the mitigation measures it listed (Final EIR p. 2.0-82); it did not describe the condition as a VOC or NOX reduction measure. The condition is a health risk measure: it requires a tenant-specific HRA before a Tenant Improvement permit is issued for any tenant that will install an under-fired charbroiler (Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18).

Refer also to Response to Comment 3-24.

Comment A-7
Response O2A-6: The SJV Air Pollution Control District's Analysis Recommendations Item 1: Separate analysis of stationary sources
The City states that the District's NOP comment asked only that mobile and stationary sources be analyzed 73 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

separately and did not require stationary sources to be quantified. A separate discussion that never estimates the emissions from the gasoline dispensing facility or the charbroilers is not an analysis of those emissions. The District's comment letter on the DEIR removes any question about what it intended: the District specifically asked for an operational health risk assessment (HRA) of the gasoline station, the fast food charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA (Comment A2.2). The City's use of the CARB Air Quality and Land Use Handbook as a substitute is addressed under Response O2A-7.

Response A-7
SJVAPCD’s Comment No. A2.2 recommended an operational HRA covering the gasoline station, charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA (Final EIR p. 2.0-14). The City considered that recommendation and responded to it in Response No. A2.2 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-15 to

2.0-16).

The Draft EIR's discussion of stationary sources is an analysis of how their health risk is controlled. As explained in Response Nos. 3-4 and 3-12, it identifies the Project's potential permitted sources, including the gas station and, for example, a restaurant chain-driven charbroiler, and explains that each must undergo a health risk assessment, and reduce or mitigate its emissions below the SJVAPCD's cancer and acute risk thresholds, before an air quality permit is issued (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). That review evaluates each source's emissions and risk when the equipment is proposed. Whether, and which, restaurants would operate charbroilers is not known (Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18). The Draft EIR combined that evaluation with its evaluation of the non-permitted sources and the quantified construction HRA (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31 to 4.3-33). The role of the Handbook is addressed in Response Nos. 3-4. 74 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Comment A-8
Item 2: Heavy-duty truck trip length
The City states that the DEIR did not use the CalEEMod default truck trip length and instead calculated heavy-duty truck vehicle miles traveled (VMT) with the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional travel demand model. Accepting that correction, the truck figures presented in the FEIR are internally inconsistent, and the inconsistency affects both the NOx estimate and the AAQA.

The DEIR reports heavy-duty truck VMT of approximately 751 miles per day.4 The FEIR then presents three different daily truck counts:
• 23 truck trips per day (0.15 percent of 14,904 trips from the KernCOG fleet mix) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16);
• 29 to 44 truck trips per day (the same percentage applied to total weekday and weekend trips) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16); and
• approximately 191 truck trips per day (751 miles divided by the overall average trip length of 3.94 miles) (Response A2.2).

Dividing 751 miles by each count gives an average heavy-duty truck trip length of approximately 33 miles (23 trips), 17 miles (44 trips), or 3.9 miles (191 trips). The City describes the 191-trip figure as "overly conservative" because trucks delivering to the Project "would be traveling longer distances on average" than customers. If trucks travel farther than 3.94 miles, then either the truck count is far lower than 191 or the truck VMT is understated.
75 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

A regional travel demand model counts only the miles traveled inside the model boundary. Deliveries originating at regional distribution centers outside Kern County are truncated at the county line. The FEIR does not present truck trip generation based on the Project's actual land uses, including the market (which will receive refrigerated deliveries), the restaurants, the retail anchors, and fuel tanker deliveries to a 40- position gasoline station.

I recommend that the truck trips should be estimated by land use, with trip lengths based on the likely origin of deliveries, and the operational NOx estimate, the AAQA, and the truck component of an operational HRA should be updated using those values.
76 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-8
The mobile-source emissions associated with the project-generated heavy-duty trucks are based on the total daily heavy-duty truck VMT of 751 VMT per day, which was determined through use of the KernCOG regional travel demand model. As previously stated in Response No. O2A-6 of the Final EIR (p. 2.0-84), the KernCOG regional travel demand model is calibrated to account for travel specific to heavy-duty trucks.

Thus, overall, the total daily 751 VMT modeled for project-related heavy-duty trucks is the estimated total daily miles traveled for heavy-duty trucks that would be generated by the project. Because the emissions modeling also assumed daily heavy-duty truck VMT of 751 VMT per day, it does not underestimate project-generated heavy-duty truck VMT.

Furthermore, as discussed in Response No. O2.16 of the Final EIR (p. 2.0-54), per the KernCOG regional travel demand model, project-related heavy-duty truck trips would comprise only 0.15 percent of total project-generate trips. When applied to the anticipated total weekday and weekend project-generated ADTs that would range between 18,921 ADTs to 28,479 ADTs, this fleet mix percentage results in 29 to 44 heavy-duty truck trips per day. Because CalEEMod internally assumed average daily heavy-duty truck trips of 191 trips per day based on the overall project average trip length of 3.94 miles per trip to internally calculate and be consistent with the daily 751 VMT for project-generated heavy-duty trucks, the emissions modeling assumed a conservative estimate of heavy-duty truck trips.

As stated, the KernCOG regional travel demand model is calibrated to account for heavy-duty truck travel as it includes a dedicated truck model component designed to estimate truck trip-making patterns and truck VMT in the region. The truck model consists of truck trip generation and truck distribution components that estimate the number of truck trips as well as how those trips are distributed between origins and destinations. The truck model component has been calibrated and validated against truck traffic counts, similar to auto calibration and validation in a travel demand model. It should be noted that although some truck trips associated with the project may extend beyond the County boundary, project related truck travel also includes trip occurring entirely within the County. The average truck trip length provided by KernCOG reflects the full range of truck trips. Furthermore, per the CalEEMod model, the project is not located in an area for which default trip purpose splits and trip lengths are available from the local Metropolitan Planning Organization or Regional Transportation Planning Agency.2 Therefore, the default trip lengths provided are from the 2015 California Statewide Travel Demand Model (CSTDM). However, per CalEEMod, the default trip lengths can be replaced by project-specific information, if available.3 Because the KernCOG regional travel demand model is customized and calibrated for the region, its use and use of its estimated VMT for the proposed project would be more refined compared to the CalEEMod defaults and would be appropriate per CalEEMod guidance.
2 This notation appears within the CalEEMod program under the Operations>Mobile Sources>Vehicle Data module.
3 Ibid.
77 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Comment A-9
Item 3: Operational health risk
See Response O2A-7 below.

Response A-9
The comment cross-references discussion of Response No. O2A-7 and raises no new point. See Responses Nos.-A17 through -A20.

Comment A-10
Item 4: Ambient air quality analysis
The AAQA relies on the same truck inputs discussed under Item 2. It also shows that total PM2.5 concentrations with the Project would exceed the 24-hour NAAQS and the annual NAAQS and CAAQS (see Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8 above). Where the standards are already exceeded at nearby receptors, on-site PM2.5 reductions should be required.

Response A-10
The AAQA's mobile-source inputs use Project VMT calculated with the KernCOG regional travel demand model, which "is calibrated to account for travel specific to heavy-duty trucks" (Response No. A2.2, Final EIR p. 2.0-15); they do not depend on a truck count. Comments on the truck inputs are addressed in Response Nos. A8. Refer to Response Nos. 3-5 and A4, which explain that the PM2.5 standards are exceeded by background concentrations before any Project contribution and that the Project's maximum PM2.5 increments are below the SILs at every receptor on the AAQA grid (Draft EIR Tables 4.3-13 and 4.3- 14, p. 4.3-29); therefore, on-site PM2.5 reductions are not required as mitigation (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

Comment A-11
Item 5: VERA feasibility
See Response O2A-5 above.

Response A-11
The comment cross-references discussion of Response No. O2A-5 and raises no new point. Refer to Responses Nos. A5 and A6.

Comment A-12
Response O2A-6: The District's Mitigation Recommendations Item 1: Cleanest available off-road construction equipment The City declined this measure because construction emissions are below the District's thresholds. Being below a threshold does not mean construction emissions are negligible. The District recommended this measure for this Project, the air basin is classified as extreme nonattainment for the federal 8-hour ozone 78 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

standard, and construction will occur on contaminated soils within several hundred feet of a senior mobile home park. Tier 4 Final engines emit substantially less diesel particulate matter (DPM) and NOx than Tier 2 and Tier 3 engines and are widely available in the construction fleet. The measure is feasible and low in cost and should be adopted.

Response A-12
Construction impacts would be less than significant without mitigation for each pollutant the comment identifies. Maximum annual construction emissions are about 1 ton per year of VOC and NOX and less than 1 ton per year of PM10 and PM2.5, against SJVAPCD thresholds of 10 tons per year for VOC and NOX and 15 tons per year for PM10 and PM2.5 (Draft EIR Table 4.3-9, p. 4.3-26). The SJVAPCD's regional thresholds are the measure of a project's contribution to the basin's nonattainment status, including for ozone (Draft EIR p. 4.3-20). Average daily construction emissions are well below the SJVAPCD's 100-pound-per-day ambient air quality screening level (Draft EIR Table 4.3-10, p. 4.3-27). For DPM, the construction cancer risk at the maximally exposed individual resident is 1.5 in one million and the chronic hazard index is 0.003, against thresholds of 20 in one million and 1.0 (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-32), and those values account for the maximally impacted receptors, which considers the residences to the west (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19).

The District's recommendation was considered in Response No. O2A-6, and mitigation is not required for effects that are not found to be significant (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3); Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR p. 2.0-85). In addition, SJVAPCD Rule 9510 requires that exhaust emissions from construction equipment greater than 50 horsepower be reduced by 20 percent of total NOX and 45 percent of total PM10 exhaust compared with the statewide average, which may be achieved with less-polluting construction equipment, add-on controls, cleaner fuels, or newer, lower-emitting equipment, or by paying off-site fees (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-9, 4.3-10). Soil-related concerns are addressed through dust control (Response No. A3).

Comment A-13
Item 2: Heavy-duty truck routing
The City relies on the CARB Handbook screening criterion of 100,000 vehicles per day for busy roadways.

That criterion was developed for siting new sensitive land uses next to existing high-volume roadways. It was not developed to evaluate the effect of a new project's trucks on existing residents. The same Handbook recommends a 1,000-foot separation between sensitive receptors and distribution centers with more than 100 trucks per day, and the City's own estimate in Response A2.2 is 191 truck trips per day.

Roadway screening also does not address truck activity on the Project site itself, including travel on internal drive aisles, idling at loading docks, and operation of transport refrigeration units (TRUs), which are the activities closest to receptors.

A routing measure costs little to implement: direct truck access to the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road driveways, prohibit truck use of the El Toro Viejo Road driveways, locate loading docks on the eastern portions of the site away from the mobile home park and residences, and post truck route signage.

Response A-13
Refer to Response No. 3-4, which explains that the Draft EIR used the Handbook roadway criterion as one screening factor in its evaluation of health risk from Project traffic, together with the Project's land use type, its limited truck activity, and Regulation II review of permitted sources (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31, 4.3-32; 79 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR p. 2.0-85). Refer also to Response to Comment 13, which addresses the distribution-center recommendation and explains that the 191-trip figure is a conservative conversion of truck miles into trips, not a count of truck visits. Comments on the truck trip estimates are addressed in Response No. A8.

The record also addresses on-site truck activity. Loading and unloading for the major retail buildings would occur at docks "toward the rear of the buildings," deliveries to the outlying pads would occur in designated areas near each tenant, and no loading or unloading would occur in parking areas (Draft EIR p. ES-2).

Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road are designated truck routes under Bakersfield Municipal Code Section

10.44.060, and Project truck travel is expected to occur primarily on them (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). Idling is limited by the state anti-idling regulation (Draft EIR p. 4.3-5). Whether any tenant would receive refrigerated deliveries depends on tenants that are not fully known (Draft EIR p. ES-1). Because operational health risk would be less than significant (see Response No. 3-12), the proposed routing, dock placement, and signage measure is not required (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

Comment A-14
Item 3: Cleanest available heavy-duty trucks
The City rejected a zero-emission truck requirement as infeasible because tenants will not own their own truck fleets. The District recommended the cleanest available trucks, not a zero-emission-only requirement.

The following measures are within the control of the developer and tenants and are feasible:
• lease provisions requiring tenants to request zero-emission or near-zero-emission delivery vehicles from carriers where available;
• zero-emission vehicles for all landlord-controlled service vehicles (maintenance, sweeping, and security);
• electrical hookups at the market and restaurant loading docks so TRUs can operate on grid power rather than diesel while parked; and
• electrical conduit and panel capacity at loading docks to support future medium- and heavy-duty truck charging.
80 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-14
For air quality and health risk, the Project's truck-related impacts are less than significant: its regional VOC and NOX emissions are mitigated to below the SJVAPCD thresholds by MM AQ-1, and its localized criteria pollutant and TAC impacts were determined to be less than significant (Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR p.

2.0-86; Draft EIR pp. 4.3-29 to 4.3-32). Additional truck measures are not required to address those impacts (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

The measures would also bear on GHG emissions, an impact the Draft EIR found significant and unavoidable, and the record provides reasons bearing on each. Regarding carrier requests, tenants "would not own their own truck fleets," and the types of trucks delivering to them "would be dependent on third-party truck fleet operators" and "would not be in their control" (Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR pp. 2.0-85 to 2.0-86), so a requirement that tenants request such vehicles would not ensure that any reduction occurs.

Regarding landlord service vehicles, the Project already requires electric-powered landscaping equipment for property management (MM GHG-3) and electric-powered off-road equipment for daily business operations (MM GHG-4) (Draft EIR pp. 4.8-19, 4.8-20). Regarding TRU hookups and truck charging readiness, the Project's tenants are not fully known, and whether any would receive refrigerated deliveries, and at which docks, would depend on the tenant (Draft EIR p. ES-1); heavy trucks account for 0.73 percent of daily VMT (Appendix B PDF p. 119) and 0.15 percent of trips in the regional model's fleet mix (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54). The Project's electric vehicle infrastructure commitment is mandated through MM GHG-7 (Draft EIR p. 4.8-20).

With MM GHG-1 and MM GHG-3, mobile sources account for 93 percent of the Project's GHG emissions (14,894 of 15,926 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per year; Draft EIR Table 4.8-3, p. 4.8-21), and passenger vehicles account for 89 percent of the Project's daily VMT (Appendix B PDF p. 119). Because the Project’s GHG impact is significant and unavoidable, the City will make findings on these measures in the CEQA Findings it adopts when it acts on the Project (CEQA Guidelines Section 15091(a)(3)), and the Statement of Overriding Considerations will address the Project’s remaining significant GHG impact (CEQA Guidelines Section 15093). No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment A-15
Item 4: Anti-idling regulations
The City states that compliance with the state anti-idling regulations can be presumed because they are legally binding. The state regulations are enforced by field inspection, which is infrequent at any single location. Site-level measures make the limit visible and verifiable at the Project: posted no-idling signs at every loading dock and truck entrance, a 3-minute idling limit (stricter than the 5-minute state limit), tenant notification to carriers, a posted contact for complaints, and a limit on diesel TRU operation while parked.

These are common conditions for commercial and industrial projects in the San Joaquin Valley and cost little.
81 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-15
Diesel trucks serving the Project are subject to the state anti-idling regulation for diesel commercial vehicles (13 CCR Section 2485), which limits idling to five minutes (Draft EIR p. 4.3-5). Compliance is mandatory, and the Draft EIR may presume compliance with a binding regulation (Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR p.

2.0-86); the frequency of field inspection does not change that. The SJVAPCD's Notice of Preparation comment on idling, as summarized in the Draft EIR, asked the City to ensure compliance with that regulation (Draft EIR p. 4.3-1).

The signage, carrier notice, complaint contact, and TRU elements are tools for implementing an idling limit.

For health risk, the Project's truck activity is limited (Response No. 3-13), and operational health risk is less than significant (Response No. 3-12), so these elements and a three-minute limit are not required as mitigation for that impact (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)). For GHG emissions, the five-minute limit already applies to every diesel truck serving the Project, the Project's uses "would on occasion have vendor deliveries" at less than "the frequency or volume of a warehouse project" (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-54), and passenger vehicles, not trucks, account for most of the Project's VMT (Response No. A14). Refer also to Response No. 3-27. The CEQA Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations will address these elements, including a limit shorter than five minutes (CEQA Guidelines Sections 15091(a)(3), 15093). No revisions to the Draft EIR are warranted.

Comment A-16
Item 5: Under-fired charbroilers
The City states that the presence of charbroilers is speculative because tenants have not been identified, and relies on a CoA that requires an HRA before a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler receives a tenant improvement permit. I disagree for three reasons.
82 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

First, the Project description identifies drive-thru, fast casual, and sit-down restaurants on the outer pads,5 and the DEIR modeled restaurant land uses in CalEEMod for trip generation and energy use. The information needed to estimate a reasonable worst-case charbroiler emission rate using District emission factors is already in the DEIR. Estimating emissions from a known restaurant floor area is standard practice for a project at this stage.

Second, the CoA is applied one tenant at a time. Each HRA would compare a single tenant's charbroiler emissions to the 20 in one million threshold. The combined risk from several charbroiler restaurants, the gasoline station, and truck activity at the same receptor would never be calculated. A center with several such restaurants could produce a combined risk above the threshold even if every individual HRA shows a risk below it.

Third, the CoA sets no control requirement unless an individual HRA exceeds the threshold. The District recommended assessment and installation of particulate matter controls for new large restaurants with under-fired charbroilers, and is offering incentive funding that covers the full cost of purchase, installation, and maintenance for two years of operation (Comment A2.4). A control requirement is therefore feasible at little or no cost to tenants and would also reduce the PM2.5 increment discussed above.

Footnote
5 FEIR, Comment O2.1 (summarizing the DEIR Project Description), p. 2.0-43.

Response A-16
The Draft EIR's land use inputs establish the size of the restaurant pads, not the cooking equipment a future tenant would install. No tenants have been identified, and it is not known whether any restaurant would use 83 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

an under-fired charbroiler, how much meat would be cooked, or what cooking appliance type would be used (Response No. O2A-6, Final EIR p. 2.0-86; Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18). An estimate built on assumed charbroilers would rest on unsupported assumptions, and CEQA does not require an EIR to engage in speculation (CEQA Guidelines Section 15145; Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18). The Draft EIR instead addressed chain-driven charbroilers as permitted stationary sources subject to Regulation II (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31).

The condition remains as described in Response No. A2.4 (Final EIR p. 2.0-18): before a tenant improvement permit is issued for a tenant that will install an under-fired charbroiler, an HRA must be prepared in accordance with OEHHA and SJVAPCD procedures and submitted to the City and the SJVAPCD, and if risk would exceed 20 in one million or a hazard index of 1.0, the HRA must identify measures that reduce risk below those thresholds, which the City would verify before a Certificate of Occupancy is issued. The condition provides a tenant-specific review when the information needed for it becomes available, to ensure that possible under-fired charbroilers do not result in a significant impact (Response No. O2.24, Final EIR p. 2.0-61). The less-than-significant conclusion for the Project's other operational sources, and for their combined risk, is further described in Response Nos. 3-12 and 3-16.

Refer also to Response Nos. 3-24 and 3-28.

The Project's PM2.5 increments are below the SILs (Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3-29) and its operational health risk is less than significant, so additional mitigation is not required (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)). The SJVAPCD's incentive funding for charbroiler control systems (Comment No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18) is available to future restaurant tenants.

Comment A-17
Response O2A-7: Operational Health Risk
The City states that SJVAPCD Regulation II is mandatory, that compliance may be presumed, and that reliance on it is therefore not a postponement of the analysis. Whether the gasoline station obtains a permit is not the issue raised. No analysis in the DEIR, the FEIR, or the permit process estimates the total operational health risk from the Project at the nearest homes. 84 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

• Regulation II permits evaluate individual permit units at the time an application is filed. They do not combine the risk from all Project sources at a common receptor. • Delivery trucks, on-site truck idling, TRUs, and under-fired charbroilers are not evaluated through the Regulation II permit risk review. The City added a separate CoA for charbroilers because permitting does not cover them.
• The District asked that operational risk from the gasoline station, charbroilers, and trucks be combined with construction risk and compared to the thresholds (Comment A2.2). That calculation has not been done.

The GAMAQI statement quoted in the FEIR, that emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements "are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant,"6 concerns criteria pollutant emissions that are controlled through Best Available Control Technology and offsets under Rule 2201. It does not address the combined health risk from permitted and unpermitted sources at the same receptor.

Response A-17
SJVAPCD Regulation II is mandatory, and equipment that does not meet its requirements would not be issued a permit to construct or operate (Response No. O2A-7, Final EIR p. 2.0-88). The Draft EIR relied on it, as explained in Response Nos. 3-4 and 3-16, for permitted sources only (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). However, the Draft EIR did not rely on Regulation II for delivery trucks. It evaluated the non-permitted sources, mainly retail delivery trucks and passenger vehicles, through the Project's land use type, its truck activity, and the roadway volumes it would generate (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-31, 4.3-32), together with the quantified construction HRA (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-32). Delivery trucks are limited in number for a retail center (Response No. 3-13), idling is limited by state regulation (Draft EIR p. 4.3-5), and TRU operation would depend on tenants receiving refrigerated deliveries, which are not currently known (Draft EIR p. ES-1). Under-fired charbroilers are addressed in Response No. A16, the District's recommendation for a combined operational HRA in Response Nos. 3-12 and A7, and combined exposure at a common receptor in Response Nos.

Comments 3-16 and 3-18.

The GAMAQI statement quoted in Responses No. O2.16 and No. O2.22, that "emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with [New Source Review] requirements are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant" (Final EIR pp. 2.0-55, 2.0-59), addresses emissions under the New Source Review program, as explained in Response No. 3-15. The health risk of permitted sources is addressed through Regulation II health risk requirements (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31), and the reasons the City concludes that the Project's combined operational health risk would be less than significant are discussed in Response 85 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

No. 3-12.

Comment A-18
The FEIR misstates the CARB Handbook recommendation for gasoline stations The FEIR states that the CARB Handbook recommends a 500-foot separation between sensitive land uses and gasoline dispensing facilities, and that the nearest receptors are about 650 feet from the station.7 The Handbook does not recommend 500 feet for gasoline stations. It recommends avoiding new sensitive land uses within 300 feet of a large gasoline station (3.6 million gallons per year or more) and within 50 feet of a typical station. More importantly, the Handbook is a siting guide for placing new homes and schools near existing sources. It is not a method for estimating the risk that a new source will impose on existing residents, and it does not substitute for an HRA.

Response A-18
The Final EIR describes the Handbook as a siting guide (Response No. O2.16, Final EIR p. 2.0-53), and the Draft EIR did not rely on a Handbook distance to calculate the gas station's risk (Response No. 3-4).

Its evaluation of the gas station rests on two pieces of information (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). The first is separation; the nearest potential sensitive land uses are the two buildings across El Toro Viejo Road, approximately 650 feet west of the gas station location. That separation is greater than both Handbook distances the comment cites (300 feet and 50 feet; Exhibit A p. 16) and greater than any gasoline station distance discussed in the Final EIR, so the conclusion does not change. The second is Regulation II permitting; the gas station "would be subject to further study and health risk assessment prior to the issuance of any necessary air quality permits under SJVAPCD Regulation II," which requires its emissions to be reduced or mitigated below the SJVAPCD's cancer and acute risk thresholds (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31), and equipment that does not meet the permitting requirements would not be issued a permit to construct or operate (Response No. O2A-7, Final EIR p. 2.0-88).
86 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The Handbook distances are used as screening criteria. The station's risk is determined in the project-specific Regulation II health risk assessment, and its emissions must be reduced or mitigated below the SJVAPCD thresholds for it to be permitted. That assessment, not the Handbook, is the basis on which the station's risk is controlled (see Response No. 3-12).

Comment A-19
Several additional problems with the City's reliance on the Handbook should be noted:
• The FEIR never states the station's expected annual throughput. A station with 20 dual-sided dispensers (40 fueling positions) is comparable in size to the high-volume stations at wholesale and discount centers, which the City itself describes as having average throughput of about 9 million gallons per year and a risk of 25 in one million at 50 feet.8 The permitted throughput for a station of this size could be higher still. • The Handbook risk values were developed in 2005 using methods that predate OEHHA's 2015 Risk Assessment Guidelines. The 2015 Guidelines incorporate age sensitivity factors and higher breathing rates for young children, which increase estimated residential cancer risk, commonly by a factor of about three. Risk values taken from the Handbook therefore understate risk as it would be calculated today.
87 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

• The DEIR's construction HRA treated two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west of the site, across El Toro Viejo Road, as residential receptors. The FEIR does not explain whether the 650-foot distance was measured to those receptors or to the mobile home park, and it provides no figure showing the station's location relative to the receptors.

As an illustration only, a high-volume station contributing about 5 in one million at 300 feet under the older Handbook methods could contribute on the order of 15 in one million under the 2015 methods. Adding construction risk (1.5 in one million), truck and TRU activity, and one or more charbroiler restaurants could bring the Project's combined risk close to or above the 20 in one million threshold. The District requested a quantified operational HRA for this reason. The FEIR does not include one. 88 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Footnotes
6FEIR, Responses O2.16 and O2.22, pp. 2.0-55 and 2.0-59. 7 FEIR, Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15; Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54. 8 FEIR, Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54, citing CARB 2005.

Response A-19
The Draft EIR does not specify the station's annual throughput. The station would have 20 dual-sided dispensers (40 fueling positions) (Draft EIR p. ES-1; Response No. O2.32, Final EIR p. 2.0-67). Response No. O2.16 reported the Handbook's values for "gas stations associated with large wholesale and discount centers, which can have an average annual throughput of 9,000,000 gpy", which showed 25 in one million at 50 feet, decreasing to 5 in one million at 300 feet (Final EIR p. 2.0-54). The nearest potential sensitive land uses are approximately 650 feet from the station (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31), more than twice the 300-foot distance at which the Handbook reports 5 in one million for that category. The station's throughput, and its associated risk, are addressed in the Regulation II permitting process (Response No. A18), which requires its emissions to be reduced or mitigated below 20 in one million cancer risk and one for acute risk at the maximally exposed individual (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). Whatever throughput the station is permitted for, its risk at the nearest receptors must be below the SJVAPCD thresholds.

The Handbook's values predate the 2015 OEHHA guidelines. The construction HRA used the 2015 OEHHA guidance (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-33), and the station's risk is assessed in the Regulation II health risk assessment required before a permit is issued (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31).

The 650-foot distance is measured from the proposed gas station to "the two buildings across El Toro Viejo 89 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Road" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). Those are the same two buildings the Draft EIR describes as "approximately 200 to 450 feet west of the Project across El Toro Viejo Road" and conservatively treats as residences, although "it is uncertain whether these two buildings currently house residents" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19). The two distances measure different things. 200 to 450 feet is the distance from the Project boundary to the buildings, and 650 feet is the distance from the gas station, which is set back from those buildings within the Project Site, to those same buildings. The mobile-home park residences are approximately 750 feet west of the Project Site (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19), and therefore farther from the station. The station's location is shown on the conceptual site plan (Draft EIR Figure 2-3), which the comment reproduces (Exhibit A p. 17, Figure 22).

The comment's illustration applies a general adjustment factor to a Handbook value for 300 feet, while the nearest potential sensitive land uses are approximately 650 feet from the gas station, and the station's actual risk is subject to a health risk assessment and the 20-in-one-million limit before it may be permitted (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). The Project's truck activity is that of a retail center, not a logistics use (see Response No. 3-13), and the charbroiler condition of approval requires a tenant-specific HRA before any under-fired charbroiler is installed (see Response No. A16). An illustration built on assumed inputs does not show that the Draft EIR's conclusion lacks substantial evidence. The District's recommendation for an operational HRA is addressed in Response Nos. 3-12 and A7.

Comment A-20
The Airport Commerce Center comparison is not an analysis of this Project In Responses A2.2 and O2.24, the City relies on an HRA prepared for a warehouse project elsewhere in Kern County, which reported a cancer risk of 8.88 in one million from 824 daily truck trips. An HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project. That HRA also addressed truck emissions only. It did not include a gasoline station, charbroilers, or construction. Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.

Response A-20
The Airport Commerce Center HRA does not estimate this Project's risk, and the City does not use it that way. Response No. A2.2 offered it as comparative context, illustrating that a project generating 824 heavy-duty diesel truck trips per day, including 265 truck trips with TRUs, reported a cancer risk of 8.88 in one 90 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

million and a hazard index of 0.002 at a residential receptor approximately 650 feet away (Final EIR p. 2.0- 15). The comparison illustrates the scale of risk reported for a truck-intensive use. It is not the basis for the City's conclusion, which rests on the Draft EIR's analysis of this Project (see No. 3-12). Refer also to Response No 3-23. Truck activity close to receptors at this Project, including dock location, truck routes, idling, and TRU operation, is addressed in Response to Comment A13.

Comment A-21
Responses O2A-9 through O2A-13: Valley Fever
The City acknowledges that ground disturbance can aerosolize Coccidioides spores and that risk is elevated in dry, windy conditions and in years following drought. It relies on the Rule 8021 Dust Control Plan, general Cal/OSHA requirements, and Labor Code Section 6709 training, and it rejects active particulate monitoring because dust monitors "cannot detect the presence of biological agents" and because there is "no direct correlation" between dust concentrations and spore levels.9 91 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The City's position on dust and spores is contradictory In Response O2A-9 the City states that "fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever." In Response O2A-12 it states there is no direct correlation between dust concentrations and airborne spores. If dust suppression reduces spore exposure, as the City relies on, then airborne dust concentration is the relevant indicator of whether suppression is working. Coccidioides arthroconidia are approximately 2 to 5 micrometers in size and are released and carried with disturbed soil. My comment did not propose that monitors identify spores. The purpose of real-time perimeter monitoring of PM10 and PM2.5 is to provide an objective trigger for added watering or a work stoppage when fine dust leaves the site. On this site, the same monitoring would also track off-site transport of the PCBs, PAHs, and metals identified in the Land Use Covenant.
92 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

• watering of all disturbed areas at least three times per day, increased to four times per day when visible wind-driven dust is present;
• suspension of grading and excavation when sustained winds exceed 20 miles per hour; • covered haul loads with at least six inches of freeboard, and cleaning of equipment and vehicles before they leave the site;
• a Valley Fever section in each contractor's Injury and Illness Prevention Program, with NIOSH-approved respirators for workers near earth-moving equipment, clean 93 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

eating and hand-washing areas, and separation of work and street clothing; and • a written protocol with a local medical provider for evaluating workers who develop symptoms consistent with Valley Fever.

Response A-21
Refer to Response No. 3-11, which addresses Valley Fever. Responses No. O2A-9 and No. O2A-12 address different questions and are consistent. Spores become airborne with the soil particles that carry them, so measures that reduce the amount of soil that becomes airborne reduce the number of spores that can be released; that is the point of Response No. O2A-9 (Final EIR p. 2.0-91). Response No. O2A-12 explains why a dust monitor reading is not a measure of spores. A monitor measures particles of all kinds and "cannot detect the presence of biological agents such as the Valley Fever fungal spore," and "there is no direct correlation between fugitive dust particulate matter concentration levels and the levels of Valley Fever fungal spores that may be present in the air" (Final EIR p. 2.0-93). Less airborne soil means fewer airborne spores, but a dust reading does not show how many spores are in the air.

Monitoring proposed as a trigger would not change when controls apply, because SJVAPCD Rule 8021 does not wait for one. The Dust Control Plan must describe control measures "to be implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-11), and the 20 percent opacity limit is "the ceiling at which fugitive dust must be limited," not the trigger for those measures (Response No. O2A-12, Final EIR p. 2.0-93). Those controls, which "can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants" (Responses No. O1.6 and O2A-9, Final EIR pp. 2.0-29, 2.0-91), act on the soil surface before particles become airborne and apply whether or not a plume is visible; the CalEEMod watering reductions the comment cites apply to both PM10 and PM2.5 (Exhibit A p. 21). The Dust Control Plan is subject to SJVAPCD approval before construction begins (Draft EIR p. 4.3-11; Final EIR pp. 2.0-29, 2.0-91), and the SJVAPCD enforces compliance. Rule 8021 sets the required measures through the District-approved plan rather than a fixed watering frequency. Soil constituents subject to the LUC are addressed in Response to No. A3.

The construction PM10 and PM2.5 estimates do not take credit for fugitive dust controls; the CalEEMod reports for both construction phases and the off-site improvements show that no earthmoving control strategies were applied (Appendix B PDF pp. 168–169, 205, 228, 258). Even without that credit, the Project’s construction PM10 and PM2.5 emissions are well below the SJVAPCD’s annual regional thresholds and its 100-pound-per-day ambient air quality screening level (Draft EIR Tables 4.3-9 and 4.3- 10, pp. 4.3-26, 4.3-27). The Project must nonetheless comply with Rule 8021, which requires a Dust Control Plan to be submitted to the SJVAPCD before construction begins and control measures to be implemented before, during, and after dust-generating activities (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-10 to 4.3-11; Response No. O2.13, Final EIR pp. 2.0-50 to 2.0-51). Because those required controls were not credited in the modeling, actual construction dust emissions would be lower than the values reported in the Draft EIR.

Response No. O2A-13 referred to Responses No. O2A-9 and No. O2A-12 (Final EIR p. 2.0-95), which explain the Rule 8021 controls and the limits of perimeter monitoring on which the City relies. Construction PM10 and PM2.5 impacts are less than significant without credit for dust control, so the proposed measures are not required as mitigation for those impacts (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)). Regarding 94 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

watering frequency and a wind-event shutdown, the Rule 8021 controls, which can include watering and dust suppressants, apply before, during, and after all dust-generating activity whatever the wind conditions, subject to the opacity ceiling (Draft EIR p. 4.3-11; Final EIR pp. 2.0-29, 2.0-91, 2.0-93). Regarding haul loads and equipment cleaning, Regulation VIII governs the outdoor handling, storage, and transport of bulk materials (Rule 8031) and carryout and trackout onto paved roads (Rule 8041) (Draft EIR p. 4.3-10).

Regarding the IIPP and medical protocol, construction employers must maintain an IIPP under Title 8, Section 3203, implement engineering controls and respiratory protection under Sections 5141 and 5144, and provide Valley Fever training under Labor Code Section 6709 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-45, 2.0-91).

Comment A-22
General worker safety requirements do not protect nearby residents Title 8 Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144 are general requirements. None of them prescribes Valley Fever-specific engineering controls, respirator use, or medical protocols for this Project, and Labor Code Section 6709 requires training only. More importantly, these requirements apply only to workers. The City's responses do not address off-site residents at all, including the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park. Adults over 60 are among the groups at higher risk of severe and disseminated Valley Fever.

Perimeter monitoring and wind shutdown requirements would reduce their exposure.

Response A-22
Refer to Response No. 3-11.

Comment A-23
PART II. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO THE SJVAPCD COMMENTS
The District is the agency that oversees air quality issues in the San Joaquin Valley and has the expertise to determine if the impacts from a Project’s construction and operational phases are impactful. Several of the City's responses to the District decline the recommendations or substitute a different approach. The City also states elsewhere in the FEIR that the District's comments "did not raise any objections or concerns" regarding the cumulative air quality analysis, and that the District did not request that the Project's modeled risk be added to background risk.10 These statements are not consistent with the District's letter.

The District told the City that only a construction HRA had been performed, that an operational HRA should be performed and combined with it, and that these modifications "have the potential to cause the Project to exceed District health risk thresholds." The District recommended that the HRA be revised. The City did not revise it.
95 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-23
The City considered and responded to each of the SJVAPCD's comments in Responses No. A2.1 through No. A2.14 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-14 to 2.0-23). CEQA requires a lead agency that does not accept an agency's recommendations to explain why, with a good-faith, reasoned analysis (CEQA Guidelines Section 15088(c)); it does not require the lead agency to adopt each recommendation. The City's reasons are stated in those responses.

Both statements the comment cites are accurate as to their subjects. The SJVAPCD's letter (Comment Letter A2) did not comment on the Draft EIR's cumulative criteria pollutant analysis and did not ask that the Project's modeled risk be added to background risk (Final EIR pp. 2.0-14 to 2.0-23). Its recommendation for an operational HRA combined with the construction HRA, and for revision of the HRA (Comment No.

A2.2, Final EIR p. 2.0-14), concerns a different subject, which the City addressed in Response No. A2.2 (Final EIR pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16). The two statements therefore do not conflict with the District's letter.

The City's conclusions on cumulative criteria pollutants and health risk rest on the Draft EIR's analysis: the SJVAPCD regional thresholds and SIL method for criteria pollutants (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-20 to 4.3-22, 4.3-29,

4.3-34) and, for health risk, the SJVAPCD's risk thresholds and the evaluation described in Response to Comments 4, 5, and 12. The reasons the City did not prepare a quantitative operational HRA are addressed in Response Nos. 3-12 and A7. Refer also to Response No. 3-20 through 3-25.

Comment A-24
Response A2.2: Operational Health Risk Assessment
The District asked for an operational HRA covering the gasoline station, charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA. The City did not prepare one. It instead relied on the CARB Handbook separation distance, the Airport Commerce Center HRA, a set of truck counts, and a qualitative acute hazard argument. As explained under Response O2A-7, the Handbook distance is misstated, the Airport Commerce Center HRA does not model this Project, the truck counts conflict with each other, and the acute hazard argument relies on a pollutant (DPM) that has no acute reference exposure level. The City's statement that the Project "with 191 estimated truck trips per day would not result in exceeding the SJVAPCD's significance thresholds" is not supported by any calculation in the FEIR.

The District also recommended, as a mitigation approach, that TAC sources be located an adequate distance from residences. The FEIR does not show the location of the gasoline station, drive-thru lanes, loading docks, or likely charbroiler restaurants relative to the receptors, so it is not possible to confirm that this recommendation has been followed.

Footnotes
9 FEIR, Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12, pp. 2.0-91 and 2.0-93. 10 FEIR, Response O1.9, p. 2.0-30; Response O2.24, p. 2.0-60.

Response A-24
The City considered the District's recommendation and responded to it in Response No. A2.2 (Final EIR 96 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16), and the reasons the record supports a less-than-significant finding without a quantitative operational HRA are set out in Response No 3-12. The Handbook distance is addressed in Response No A18, the Airport Commerce Center comparison in Response No A20, and the truck figures in Response No 3-13. Comments on the truck trip estimates are addressed in Response No A8.

Regarding acute hazard, the Draft EIR addresses acute risk from permitted stationary sources, such as the gas station, through Regulation II, which "would ensure that stationary source emissions (permitted sources) would be reduced or mitigated below SJVAPCD significance thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and one for acute risk at the maximally exposed individual" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31). The comment's statement that DPM, the principal TAC from construction equipment and delivery trucks, has no acute reference exposure level (Exhibit A p. 23) does not identify an acute hazard from the Project's diesel sources.

The statement in Response No. A2.2 that 191 truck trips per day would not exceed the thresholds is a conclusion drawn from the factors described in that response and in Response No 3-12, not from a separate risk calculation. The Project is a retail center, not a truck-intensive use such as a warehouse; the 191-trip figure is a conservative conversion of truck miles into trips (see Response No 3-13); the Project's quantified construction risk is 1.5 in one million (Draft EIR Table 4.3-16, p. 4.3-32); and Response No. A2.2 offered the Airport Commerce Center comparison as context.

The District's recommended measure was that projects with TAC emissions be located an adequate distance from residences in accordance with the Handbook (Comment No. A2.2, Final EIR p. 2.0-15). The locations of the Project's buildings, pads, gas station, car wash, and drive-thru’s are shown on the conceptual site plan (Draft EIR Figure 2-3). The gas station is approximately 650 feet from the two buildings across El Toro Viejo Road (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31); those buildings are approximately 200 to 450 feet, and the mobile-home park residences approximately 750 feet, west of the Project boundary (Draft EIR p. 4.3-19); and loading docks for the major retail buildings are toward the rear of the buildings (Draft EIR p. ES-2). The AAQA receptor grid, which extends about 500 meters from the site, includes Green Acres Estates and the single-family residences to the southwest (Response No. O1.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-28). The restaurant tenants, and whether any would use under-fired charbroilers, are not known (Response No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0- 18); any under-fired charbroiler is subject to the tenant-specific HRA described in Response No. A16.

Comment A-25
Response A2.3: VERA Timing
The City revised MM AQ-1 to require execution rather than completion of the VERA before building permits are issued. The District's explanation for this change confirms that the emission reductions may be achieved after construction begins and possibly after operations begin. MM AQ-1 should be further revised to (1) require that the VERA specify a schedule under which the reductions are achieved no later than the end of the Project's first full year of operation, (2) require the District's verification to be provided to the City, and (3) require the developer to fund any shortfall if the scheduled reductions are not achieved. On-site measures should be applied first, as discussed under Response O2A-5.

Response A-25
MM AQ-1, as revised in the Final EIR Errata, is adequate and enforceable for the reasons in Response No. 97 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

A6. Regarding a schedule, the SJVAPCD administers the VERA and funds emission reduction projects through its incentive programs, and the time required to achieve the reductions depends on the projects implemented (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR p. 2.0-17); the City has relied on the District's administration of its own program, under which the obligation to enter into the VERA "is established prior to issuance of building permits" (Comment No. A2.3, Final EIR p. 2.0-17; Errata p. 3.0-4). Regarding verification, the VERA process already includes District verification to the City once the required reductions have been achieved (Comment No. 2.3, Final EIR p. 2.0-17). Regarding a shortfall, MM AQ-1 requires that the VERA be "crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX," through "pound-for-pound mitigation" under the District's emission reduction incentive grant program (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30); the obligation is defined by the reductions required, not by a fixed payment. Regarding on-site measures, they are credited before the VERA, which addresses only the remaining exceedance (see Response No. A5).

Comment A-26
Response A2.4: Under-Fired Charbroilers
The District recommended "a measure requiring the assessment and potential installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers." The District's stated purpose was both to protect nearby neighborhoods during stagnant conditions and to help the Valley attain the federal PM2.5 standards. The City's CoA addresses only the first purpose, and only when a single tenant exceeds the cancer risk threshold. Given that the Project tract ranks in the 99th percentile for PM2.5, that the AAQA shows PM2.5 standards would be exceeded at nearby receptors, and that District incentive funding covers the full cost of control systems for two years, the District's measure should be adopted as written.

Response A-26
Both purposes are addressed in the record. For neighborhood health, the condition of approval remains as described in Response No. A2.4 (Final EIR p. 2.0-18) and Response No. A16, and the Project's operational health risk is less than significant (see Response No.3-12). For PM2.5 attainment, the 98 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Project's regional PM2.5 emissions are below the SJVAPCD's regional threshold (Draft EIR Table 4.3-11, p. 4.3-28), its maximum modeled PM2.5 increments are below the SILs (Draft EIR Table 4.3-14, p. 4.3- 29), and the SJVAPCD's thresholds gauge a project's contribution to the basin's nonattainment status (Draft EIR p. 4.3-20). The tract's existing PM2.5 burden and the AAQA results are addressed in Response Nos. 3-5 and A4.

Because the Project's PM2.5 and health risk impacts are less than significant, additional mitigation is not required (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)). The SJVAPCD's incentive funding for charbroiler control systems (Comment No. A2.4, Final EIR p. 2.0-18) is available to future restaurant tenants. Refer also to Response Nos. 3-24 and 3-28.

Comment A-27
Response A2.5: Vegetative Barriers and Urban Greening
The City states that the Project's ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover would assist in reducing pollutant concentrations. Ornamental landscaping is not a vegetative barrier. The District described a barrier that is tall, thick, and has full coverage. U.S. EPA's guidance on vegetative barriers for near-road air quality (2016) likewise calls for dense, continuous vegetation from ground level to the top of the canopy, of sufficient height and depth, with no gaps. Scattered ornamental plantings can channel pollutants through gaps and provide little reduction.

Recommendation: A continuous evergreen vegetative barrier should be installed along the western boundary facing El Toro Viejo Road and the mobile home park, and adjacent to the gasoline station and drive-thru queuing lanes. Species should be drought tolerant, low in biogenic VOC emissions, and suited to the Bakersfield climate, and the barrier should be subject to a maintenance requirement.

Response A-27
The SJVAPCD suggested that the City "consider the feasibility of incorporating vegetative barriers and urban greening as a measure to further reduce air pollution exposure on sensitive receptors" (Comment No. A2.5, Final EIR p. 2.0-18). Response No. A2.5 noted that the Project's landscaping of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover would "assist in pollutant concentration reductions to offsite receptors" (Final EIR p. 2.0-19), and the Draft EIR states that this landscaping would extend along the entire site perimeter (Draft EIR p. ES-2). The City does not describe that landscaping as an engineered vegetative barrier, and its conclusions do not depend on any reduction from it.

The Project's operational health risk and PM2.5 impacts at nearby residences, including those to the west, 99 kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

would be less than significant without a barrier (see Response Nos.3- 5, 3-12, and A4), so a vegetative barrier is not required as mitigation (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4(a)(3)).

Comment A-28
Response A2.6: Electric Vehicle Infrastructure
The City relies on the CALGreen requirements and the Tier 2 voluntary standards in MM GHG-7. Tier 2 is largely met through EV-capable spaces rather than installed chargers. The District recommended that chargers be installed, including Level 3 (DC fast) chargers, and offers incentive funding for them through its Charge Up! program. For a regional retail center with a 40-position fuel station, a firm commitment to a specific number of installed DC fast chargers is feasible and would reduce emissions from customer trips.

Response A-28
MM GHG-7 requires the Project's parking areas to comply with the CALGreen Tier 2 Nonresidential Voluntary Measures, Section A5.106.5.3.4 (Draft EIR p. 4.8-20). As the Final EIR explained, Tier 2 compliance "would result in the installation of EV infrastructure above the standard CALGreen requirements" (Response No. O2A-5, Final EIR p. 2.0-82), and "[i]n complying with MM GHG-7, the proposed Project would be dedicated to include a mix of 1 Level 2 chargers and 12 fast-charging Level 3 chargers" (Response No. O1.21, Final EIR p. 2.0-40). Therefore, a specific number of installed fast chargers resulting from MM GHG-7 is identified. The District's Charge Up! incentive program (Comment No. A2.6, Final EIR p. 2.0-19) is available to the Project proponents.

GHG emissions are a significant and unavoidable impact, and mobile sources, mainly passenger vehicles, account for most of the Project's GHG emissions (see Response No. A14). The CEQA Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations will address the request for an additional charger commitment as part of the findings on the significant and unavoidable GHG impact (CEQA Guidelines Sections 15091(a)(3), 15093).

Comment A-29
Responses A2.7 through A2.13: District Rules and Regulations The City responded to each of these comments by stating that they are not comments on the physical environmental impacts of the Project. Two of these rules bear directly on the adequacy of the air quality analysis.

Rule 9510 (Indirect Source Review) requires reductions in construction and operational NOx and PM10 emissions through on-site design features or fees. The District stated that, as of its August 28, 2026 letter, it had not received the required Air Impact Assessment application for the Project.11 The FEIR does not explain how Rule 9510 reductions relate to the reductions credited to the VERA under MM AQ-1. The two programs should be accounted for separately so that the same reductions are not counted twice.

Response A-29
In Comments No. A2.7 through No. A2.13, the SJVAPCD described District rules and regulations that may apply to the Project; those comments did not identify a deficiency in the Draft EIR's analysis (Final EIR pp.

2.0-19 to 2.0-23). Each of Responses No. A2.7 through No. A2.13 confirms that projects subject to the rule 100
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

"would be required to comply with the applicable requirements" (Final EIR pp. 2.0-20 to 2.0-23). Where those rules influence the analysis, the Draft EIR addresses them. For example, Regulation II in its treatment of permitted stationary sources (Draft EIR p. 4.3-31), Rule 9510 in its regulatory setting and operational emissions discussion (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-8 to 4.3-10, 4.3-30), Rule 9410 in its air quality regulatory setting and GHG analysis (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-11, 4.8-18, 4.8-23), and Rule 8021 in its regulatory setting (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-10 to 4.3-11), which supports the construction dust conclusions (see Response Nos. A3 and A21).

The Project is subject to Rule 9510 (Response No. O2.30, Final EIR p. 2.0-65). Under the rule, each project submits an AIA to the SJVAPCD "as early as possible, but no later than prior to the project's final discretionary approval" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-9). The District's statement that it had not received an AIA application as of its August 28, 2026 letter (Comment No. A2.9, Final EIR p. 2.0-21; Exhibit A Figure 36) concerns the timing of the applicant's compliance filing. The Project applicant submitted an AIA application to the SJVAPCD (Application No. 20260259 submitted September 22, 2026). Compliance with Rule 9510, including any on-site measures or off-site fees required to achieve the rule’s emission reductions, will be determined by the SJVAPCD through its review of that application (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-9 to 4.3-10; Response No. O2.30, Final EIR pp. 2.0-65 to 2.0-66).

The two programs are already accounted for separately. MM AQ-1 requires a VERA that mitigates operational emissions "to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds" (Draft EIR p. 4.3-30), measured against the exceedance remaining in Table 4.3-15 (see Response No. A5). Those values credit only MM AQ-2 and MM GHG-3 (Draft EIR Table 4.3-15, p. 4.3-30); the table's mobile-source emissions are the same with and without mitigation, and no Rule 9510 reduction is credited. The Final EIR explained that the Indirect Source Review program "is a program separate from the VERA program" (Response No. O2.30, Final EIR p. 2.0-66), and the Draft EIR describes both as applying to the Project. The Draft EIR identifies compliance with Rule 9510 as applying in addition to MM AQ-1 (Draft EIR pp. 4.3-25, 4.3-30). Because MM AQ-1’s performance standard is measured against emissions that include no Rule 9510 reduction, the VERA by itself must reduce the exceedance to below the thresholds, and any reductions achieved under Rule 9510 would be in addition to those the VERA provides. The less-than-significant conclusion rests on MM AQ-1's performance standard and does not depend on Rule 9510 reductions, so the same reductions are not counted twice.

Comment A-30
Rule 8021 (Regulation VIII) is the City's primary basis for concluding that Valley Fever and fugitive dust impacts would be less than significant. The City's statement in Response A2.12 is inconsistent with its reliance on this rule in Response O2A-9.
101
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Response A-30
Figure 36 (Comment No. A2.9, regarding the Rule 9510 AIA application) is addressed in Response No.

A29. The City's reliance on Rule 8021 is consistent with Response No. A2.12. Comment No. A2.12 described the rule's notification and Dust Control Plan requirements; it did not identify a deficiency in the Draft EIR's analysis (Final EIR pp. 2.0-22 to 2.0-23). Response No. A2.12 confirmed that projects subject to Regulation VIII, "including District Rule 8021, would be required to comply with the applicable requirements" (Final EIR p. 2.0-23). That is the same compliance obligation on which the City's construction dust conclusions rest (see Response Nos. A3, A21, and A29). Refer also to Response No. 3-11, which addresses Valley Fever.

Comment A-31

CONCLUSIONS
The facts identified above and referenced in this letter lead me to reasonably conclude that the City's responses do not resolve the issues raised in my comments nor in the District's comments, and that the Project could result in significant air quality and public health impacts that are not disclosed or mitigated in the FEIR. An operational health risk assessment, a corrected truck trip analysis, and the mitigation measures identified above should be completed before the Project is considered for approval and a subsequent FEIR should be prepared.

Response A-31
As shown in the responses above, the Draft EIR and Final DEIR and associated technical reports adequately analyzed potential air quality and public health impacts. The comment letter does not provide any substantial evidence, nor show a lack of substantial evidence, demonstrating a deficiency in the Draft or Final EIR. The Draft and Final EIR proposed for approval is valid and fully compliant with CEQA and there is no substantial evidence to support revising or preparing a subsequent FEIR. 102
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

Exhibit B
Norman Marshall, President
Smart Mobility
1295 Hartford Avenue #8 White River Junction
VT 05001
Comment B-1
In August 2026, I reviewed vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and trip generation impacts of the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”) dated July 2026 and made the following findings:
1) Both the retail and medical office components of the project would have significant VMT impacts that would not be fully mitigated by the measures listed in the DEIR. 2) CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) would provide additional VMT mitigation.
3)The DEIR mispresents the pass-by trip reduction for the gasoline service station component of the project. 4) Trip generation and the pass-by percentage for the gasoline service station are highly uncertain because the proposed project with 40 fueling stations is significantly different than the sites in the database. 5) The gasoline service station’s unique characteristics could result in more additional traffic and VMT than other smaller gasoline service stations.

Now I also have reviewed the responses to these comments in the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) dated September 2026. As discussed below, the FEIR fails to adequately address my comments.

Response B-1
The Commenter provides an introduction and overview of the prior comments provided on the Draft EIR which were responded to in the Final EIR. The comment is acknowledged and no response is necessary.

Comment B-2
Significant VMT and VMT Mitigation (Comment Areas #1 and #2) I commented that the DEIR did not include all feasible VMT mitigation. In particular, I cited CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) be included. This measure would achieve an up to 4.0% reduction in VMT. The Handbook states:

Voluntary CTR programs must include the following elements to apply the VMT reductions reported in literature.
• Employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), 103
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home.
• Information, coordination, and marketing for said services, infrastructure, and incentives (Measure T-7).

The FEIR response is simply that: “the proposed additional mitigation measures are practically infeasible as supported by substantial evidence in the Draft EIR.” (FEIR, p. 2.0-69) The DEIR does not include this “substantial evidence.” Instead it just asserts that feasible mitigation is included. The DEIR states:

Per the VMT analysis prepared, the Project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies. (DIEIR, p. 4.8-23)
The VMT analysis (DEIR Appendix H) similarly states:

The project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies consistent with State guidance and best practices (DEIR Appendix H, p. 6) No evidence is presented in the DEIR, DEIR Appendix H, or in the FEIR that other mitigation is infeasible.

In particular, no evidence is given that incorporating CAPCOA Measure T-5 is infeasible.

Response B-2
The Commenter argues that the City failed to set forth substantial evidence for concluding Measure T-5 under CAPCOA is infeasible to implement as mitigation for the Project’s VMT impacts.

In general, lead agencies are given considerable deference in how they respond to a public comment, and courts look not for perfection but for adequacy, completeness, and a good faith effort at full disclosure. (See Friends of the Eel River v. Sonoma County Water Agency (2003) 108 Cal. App.4th 859; SW Reg’l Council of Carpenters v. City of Los Angeles (2022) 76 Cal. App.5ht 1154.) Recirculation of the DEIR is only required when the lead agency, in responding to a comment, adds "significant new information" to the EIR that deprives the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental impact or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect. (See Laurel Heights Improvement Assn. v.

Regents of Univ. of California (1993) 6 Cal. 4th 1112.) Only when the agency's response involves adding new substantive information to the EIR — information that reveals a new significant impact, a substantially increased impact, a feasible alternative the proponents decline to adopt, or that the DEIR was fundamentally inadequate — is recirculation required. (See King & Gardiner Farms, LLC v. County of Kern (2020) 45 Cal. App. 5th 814.)
This comment is otherwise noted for the record. Please refer to Responses Nos. 3-29, 3-31 and 3-32.

Comment B-3
Trip Generation and VMT (Comment Areas #3, #4 and #5)
My August 2026 comments identified a discrepancy in the DEIR regarding pass-by trips and diverted trips:

DEIR Table 4.16-2 (p. 4.16-10) shows that the gasoline service stations would generate 10,196 daily trips including 816 internal capture trips and 7,316 pass-by trips. 104
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

The Traffic Study, DEIR Appendix H, states that there would be only 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips, for a total of 7,316 pass-by + diverted trips. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 361 of 984) In the first excerpt, the DEIR incorrectly lumps pass-by and diverted trips together. This is important because diverted trips generate VMT and pass-by trips do not.

The FEIR acknowledges: “pass-by and diverted trips are distinct types of trips.” (FEIR p. 2.0-67) The split between the two categories given in the second excerpt is based on Costco data, which the DEIR and FEIR argue is the best basis for estimating trip generation for the proposed facility because of the unique aspects of Costco facilities. Nevertheless, rather than correcting the deficiency identified in my August 2026 comments, the FEIR introduces high pass-by trip percentages for gas stations given in ITE Trip Generation. (FEIR, p. 2.0-67) It is likely that most Costco customers are Costco members that are more likely to divert to a Costco gas station as compared to the general population that would more likely stop at the most convenient gas station across all brands. Therefore, the ITE pass-by rates are not applicable to the proposed facility.

The discrepancy should be corrected.

Response B-3
This comment restates the Commenter’s previous comment to the Draft EIR regarding the methodology and reporting of the estimated trip generation for the gas station facility. As stated in previous responses within the Final EIR, the objective of the trip-generation analysis was to develop a reasonable and conservative estimate for a unique land use for which no single ITE Trip Generation Manual land-use category provides a precise match. Accordingly, the analysis within the Draft EIR considered both Costco-specific operating data and the closest applicable ITE land-use categories. The ITE comparisons included Land Use 945, Gasoline/Service Station, and Land Use 955, Travel Center, which represent the closest available ITE land use and trip rates categories associated with gasoline sales and related commercial/retail activity. Importantly, the full 10,196 gross daily trips were used to evaluate the Project driveways, with no trip reduction adjustment applied. This approach provides a conservative evaluation of the maximum potential traffic demand entering and exiting the Project Site because every vehicle accessing the Costco fuel facility must use a Project access point, regardless of trip classification. 105
kimley-horn.com 660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2100, Los Angeles, CA 90017 213-261-4040

APPENDIX A
Outlook
Riverview Marketplace Public Hearing on General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 and Environmental Impact Report - Public Comments
From James Davis <[email protected]>
Date Mon 9/28/2026 11:33 AM
To Ashley Knight <[email protected]>
CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking links, especially from unknown senders.

Please accept these comments regarding the Environmental Impact Report prepared for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project. I have concerns regarding several aspects of the traffic analysis, trip generation analysis, and proposed mitigation measures, particularly as they relate to the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility.

1. Trip Generation and Traffic Analysis – Costco Standalone Fuel Facility The proposed Costco standalone fuel facility is a substantial development consisting of 20 pumps and 40 fueling positions, in addition to a carwash. Given the size of this facility and the anticipated volume of vehicles it will generate, I believe the trip-generation and traffic analyses warrant additional review.

The studies presented in the Environmental Impact Study do not appear to be consistent with the manner in which similar traffic issues have been evaluated for smaller gas station and convenience store projects in Bakersfield.

For example, Fastrip previously submitted a site plan to the City of Bakersfield requesting approval for two driveway locations along Rosedale Highway for a proposed Fastrip gas station and convenience store located at the southeast corner of Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive. The City of Bakersfield Public Works Department determined that Fastrip would be permitted only one driveway and required a 60- foot storage lane, along with a Type A, ST3 driveway located at the extreme east end of the property.

These requirements resulted in Fastrip losing nearly 13 feet of property along Rosedale Highway. The single driveway and required storage lane also resulted in the loss of parking spaces and significantly affected onsite circulation.

It is also important to note that there is a recorded agreement dated August 16, 2014, between the City of Bakersfield and the property owner that addresses the installation of two driveways along Rosedale Highway at the Rosedale Highway and Calloway Drive intersection. This history should be considered when evaluating how access and traffic impacts are being addressed for the Riverview Marketplace project.

2. Consistency of Trip Generation and Mitigation Measures The Trip Generation Analysis, Traffic Study, and proposed mitigation measures for the Riverview Marketplace project appear to differ from the manner in which similar traffic impacts have been addressed for other shopping center and gas station projects in Bakersfield. 10/19/26, 3:13 PM Riverview Marketplace Public Hearing on General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 and Environmental Impact Report - Public Com… about:blank?windowId=SecondaryReadingPane12 1/3
I believe the City should explain the basis for these differences and identify the specific methodology and criteria used to determine the appropriate trip-generation rates, access requirements, storage requirements, and mitigation measures for the proposed Costco fuel facility.

Of particular concern is the use of the Costco Fuel Facility Database in the traffic analysis. My understanding is that this database primarily contains information regarding Costco fuel facilities that are associated with Costco warehouse locations. A standalone Costco fuel facility may have substantially different traffic characteristics from a fuel facility that is integrated with a Costco warehouse.

Additionally, it is unclear whether the data used in the analysis was collected or independently verified by an independent traffic consultant, or whether it was provided directly by Costco. The source, methodology, and reliability of this data should be clearly identified so that the public and the City can understand the basis for the conclusions reached in the study.

3. Hours of Operation and Onsite Staffing
The Draft Environmental Impact Study does not appear to clearly identify the proposed hours of operation for the Costco fuel facility or whether Costco employees will be stationed at the fueling facility to assist customers.

These factors could affect traffic volumes, circulation, queuing, and the timing of peak traffic conditions.

The final analysis should clearly identify the anticipated hours of operation and staffing levels and explain how these factors were incorporated into the traffic analysis.

4. Queuing and Onsite Circulation at the Costco Fuel Facility Another significant concern is whether the specific portion of the shopping center containing the Costco fuel facility was adequately evaluated for onsite traffic circulation and vehicle queuing.

Costco fuel facilities can experience substantial queues, particularly during peak periods. It is not unusual for multiple vehicles to be waiting for an available fueling position. With 40 fueling positions proposed at this location, the potential for significant onsite queuing should be specifically evaluated.

The analysis should identify the anticipated maximum queue length during peak periods and demonstrate that sufficient onsite storage is available without interfering with internal shopping center circulation, access to adjacent businesses, pedestrian movements, or access to and from Rosedale Highway.

The City should also evaluate whether vehicle queues could extend beyond the Costco property and potentially back up onto Rosedale Highway. If the analysis indicates that there is any reasonable possibility of vehicles queuing onto Rosedale Highway, appropriate mitigation should be required to prevent this condition.

One potential mitigation measure would be a dedicated right-turn lane from Rosedale Highway into the project, with approximately 60 to 80 feet of storage, or whatever length is determined to be appropriate based on an independent queuing analysis.

5. Request for Additional Analysis
Given the size of the proposed Costco fuel facility and the potential traffic and circulation impacts associated with 40 fueling positions, I believe additional analysis is warranted before the environmental document is finalized.
10/19/26, 3:13 PM Riverview Marketplace Public Hearing on General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 and Environmental Impact Report - Public Com… about:blank?windowId=SecondaryReadingPane12 2/3
At a minimum, the City should consider:

Providing the source and methodology for the Costco-specific trip-generation data used in the analysis.

Explaining why data from Costco fuel facilities associated with Costco warehouses is appropriate for evaluating a standalone Costco fuel facility.

Providing an independent evaluation of the anticipated trip generation and queuing associated with the proposed facility.

Clearly identifying the proposed hours of operation and staffing.

Evaluating maximum onsite vehicle queues during peak periods.

Demonstrating that sufficient onsite storage is available to prevent vehicle queues from extending into Rosedale Highway.

Evaluating whether a dedicated right-turn lane and additional storage should be required on Rosedale Highway.

Explaining why the access, storage, and circulation requirements applied to this project are appropriate when compared with requirements previously imposed on other, smaller gas station and shopping center projects in Bakersfield.

The purpose of these comments is to ensure that the potential traffic and circulation impacts associated with the proposed Costco standalone fuel facility are fully evaluated and that appropriate mitigation measures are incorporated into the project before the environmental review process is completed.

Jim Davis
Vice President of Real Estate
Jaco Oil Company
3101 State Road | Bakersfield | CA 93308
[email protected]
10/19/26, 3:13 PM Riverview Marketplace Public Hearing on General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 and Environmental Impact Report - Public Com… about:blank?windowId=SecondaryReadingPane12 3/3
1 P.O. Box 3357
Bakersfield, CA 93385
September 30, 2026

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department
1715 Chester Avenue
Bakersfield, California 93301
Re: Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for Riverview Marketplace Project; General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001, Site Plan Review No. 22-0223, and Tentative Tract Map No. 7526
Dear Planners:

The Sierra Club offers comments about the above project, a proposed commercial retail center on 46.16 acres at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road in Bakersfield, comments meant to supplement those of our August 24 letter on the DEIR.

A lack of reply to some of the City’s responses to our earlier submission should not be interpreted as Sierra Club’s agreement with the City’s responses.

Regarding Biological Resources, we quote the submission from highly regarded research scientist and San Joaquin kit fox expert Dr. Brian Cypher:
“In summary, the Project site does indeed have habitat for kit foxes and kit foxes undoubtedly use the site and definitely traverse it. Given that, the assessments and conclusions regarding kit foxes and potential impacts to kit foxes require extensive revision, preferably by a group that actually has familiarity and experience with the species. Furthermore, the Project proponent definitely needs to obtain a 2081 Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from the CDFW and a 10(a)1(a) incidental take permit (aka Habitat Conservation Plan [HCP]) from the FWS.” MM BIO-6 is heavily compromised by several conditions that would allow the developer to proceed without obtaining an ITP from CDFW. According to Dr. Cypher, this property 2 is clearly kit fox habitat. Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Our earlier submission listed dozens of new projects on potential kit fox habitat. For that matter, the Bakersfield Commons project, on similar habitat adjacent to the south of this project, is beginning to build. Cumulative habitat loss must be addressed. Moreover, now that the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan is no longer in effect, the City must find another way to effectively address the Project’s contribution to cumulative habitat loss. Mitigation for habitat loss and potential species take should include Incidental Take Permit acquisition and purchase of replacement habitat.

According to Dr. Cypher, the developer needs to obtain a federal Endangered Species Act section 10(a)(1)(B) permit from the USFWS. Under section 10(a)(1)(B), the purpose of the ITP supported by a habitat conservation plan (HCP) is to authorize take that is incidental to carrying out otherwise lawful activities and minimize and mitigate the impacts of the anticipated incidental take for the San Joaquin kit fox, in this instance.

The anticipated conservation outcome of implementing the HCP is fully offsetting the impacts of the taking. The FEIR is deficient in not having addressed this federal ESA issue in consultation with USFWS.

Regarding Air Quality, we quote from the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District submission:
“The District appreciates the City’s inclusion of a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) as a mitigation measure for the Project. As identified in Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1, the VERA would mitigate Project-related operational emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOC) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) to net zero, thereby reducing the Project’s air quality to less-than-significant level.” (underline added) The Air District’s expectation that these pollutants will be mitigated to net zero is contradicted by the minimal requirement of MM AQ-1 to emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX, allowing up to 10 tons/year of these pollutants. This discrepancy must be clarified in the FEIR.

Were the current MM AQ-1 10 tons/year precedent allowed to stand, in ten years this project alone will have emitted 100 tons of both NOx and ROG. As an example of the potential harm from this precedent, it is likely that at least 9 other large new projects will adopt this same precedent so that in 10 years this precedent-setting mitigation measure would allow at least 1000 tons of both ROG and NOx into our already crucially dirty, unhealthy air, deepening the difficulty of attaining Clean Air Act national ambient air quality standards. To this end, in order to address the cumulative impact of dozens of 3 new projects on air pollution and community health, the FEIR should adopt a net zero threshold for air pollution emissions.

Also from the Air District letter:
“Per Section 5.0 of the ISR Rule, an Air Impact Assessment (AIA) application is required to be submitted no later than applying for project-level approval from a public agency. As of the date of this letter, the District has not received an AIA application for this Project. Please inform the project proponent to immediately submit an AIA application to the District to comply with District Rule 9510 so that proper mitigation and clean air design under ISR can be incorporated into the Project’s design.”
Without an AIA, neither the public nor the decision-makers can judge the effectiveness of this “proper mitigation and clean air design“ on air pollution impacts of this project.

The EIR must be revised to include AIA mitigation and design features.

Regarding the Climate Crisis, the FEIR considers the project’s adverse project-specific and cumulative climate change impacts to be significant. Even after the required mitigation, the project will emit 15,926 MTCO2e annually according to Table 4.8-3. In order to satisfy CEQA requirements and not leave an overheated planet for future generations, the City must adopt all feasible mitigation to reduce this adverse significant impact. We listed numerous possible feasible mitigation measures in our earlier submission, many of which were improperly rejected in the City’s response. For example:
 A requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards current when permits are pulled. The City’s response did not address this possibility.
 Relax parking requirements as in the CARB 2022 scoping plan. The City responds that “the proposed Project would comply with the standard applicable City of Bakersfield Municipal Code parking requirements” without specific consideration of scoping plan suggestions.
 A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production. The City’s response did not address this possibility.  Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots, a measure that many proposed warehouses statewide are adopting. The City’s response did not address this possibility.
 Some parking stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project. Many entities, both public and private, have included solar canopies in their facility.

The City’s response did not address this very feasible measure. 4  A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere. The City rejects this proposal because it seems too difficult to effectively implement. The Air District has implemented VERA programs in the past that have resulted in air pollution reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional, and it is likely that the Air District would implement a GHG VERA, if asked. Other entities like the Rose Foundation have experience implementing an effective such program. This is a feasible measure that the City should implement.

The adverse impact of climate change is significant. The City should adopt all feasible mitigation.

The City seems to have a de facto policy to oppose Sierra Club suggestions (a notion reinforced by the vicious verbal attack by Planning Commissioner Oliver at the May 7 Bakersfield Planning Commission hearing, an attack “dittoed” by Commissioner Martin, an attack that has not been disclaimed by the City). Our suggestions are serious, based on many decades of planning experience, and with community benefit in mind. They should not be rejected out of hand.

Please place the Sierra Club on the distribution list for this project to receive any noticing of meetings, hearings, availability of documents, and to receive the environmental documents. We prefer email communications and electronic formatting of documents. Thank you for your consideration and for the opportunity to comment.

Sincerely,
Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D.

Vice-Chair
[email protected]
661-872-2432
8343-007acp
KEVIN T. CARMICHAEL
CHRISTINA M. CARO
THOMAS A. ENSLOW
KELILAH D. FEDERMAN
RICHARD M. FRANCO
TANYA A. GULESSERIAN
RACHAEL E. KOSS
AIDAN P. MARSHALL
Of Counsel
DANIEL L. CARDOZO
MARC D. JOSEPH

SACRAMENTO OFFICE
520 CAPITOL MALL, SUITE 350
SACRAMENTO, CA 95814-4721
TEL: (916) 444 - 6201
FAX: (916) 444 - 6209

ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH & CARDOZO A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION

ATTORNEYS AT LAW
601 GATEWAY BOULEVARD, SUITE 1000
SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94080 - 7037
___________
TEL: (650) 589 - 1660
FAX: (650) 589 - 5062
amarshall @adamsbroadwell.com
printed on recycled paper
October 1, 2026
Via Email and Overnight Mail
City of Bakersfield Planning Commission
C/O Julie Drimakis, City Clerk
1715 Chester Avenue
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Email: [email protected]; [email protected] Via Email Only
Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
Email: [email protected]; [email protected] Re: Comments on Agenda Item 6.A – Comments on the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507)
Dear Planning Commission Members and Ms. Knight:

On behalf of Californians Allied for a Responsible Economy (“CARE CA”), we submit these comments on the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507) (“Project”), including the Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) prepared by the City of Bakersfield (“City”). The Project’s FEIR and land use approvals will be considered as Agenda Item 6.A at the October 1, 2026, Planning Commission hearing.

CARE CA submitted comments on the Draft EIR (“DEIR”) on August 24, 2026, accompanied by expert comments, showing that the DEIR failed to comply with the requirements of CEQA1 by failing to accurately disclose and mitigate significant health risk, Valley Fever, air quality, climate change, transportation, noise, and public utilities impacts. We reviewed the Staff Report, the FEIR, and its technical appendices with the assistance of air quality expert Dr. James Clark2 and transportation expert Norm Marshall.3 The FEIR contains responses to CARE CA’s comments. However, it fails to meaningfully address or correct major flaws CARE CA and its experts identified in the DEIR.
1 Public Resources Code § 21000 et seq.; 14 Cal. Code Regs. (“C.C.R.”) §§ 15000 et seq. 2 Dr. Clark’s technical comments and curricula vitae are attached hereto as Exhibit A. 3 Mr. Marshall’s technical comments and curricula vitae are attached hereto as Exhibit B.

October 1, 2026

Page 2 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
As explained herein, the FEIR still fails to satisfy the core mandates of CEQA. Soil-disturbing activities across the 46-acre site pose severe Valley Fever risks, particularly given the 1,848 reported cases in Kern County in 2026 and the site’s immediate proximity to sensitive elderly residents at Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park.4 The FEIR fails to mitigate this impact, inconsistently claiming that that San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (“SJVAPCD”) Rule 8021 dust suppression would control exposure while simultaneously claiming dust levels do not correlate with fungal spore dispersal.5 The Project’s fuel station, charbroilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic would emit hazardous Toxic Air Contaminants (“TACs”) like benzene and Diesel Particulate Matter. The City fails to analyze risks from exposure to these pollutants in a Health Risk Analysis (“HRA”).6 Instead, the City unreasonably assumes that because the Project would generate fewer vehicle trips than a freeway, health risks would be less than significant.7 The FEIR also piecemealed its health risk analysis by improperly segmenting stationary source TAC emissions from mobile sources to avoid evaluating combined health exposures.8
Operational emissions will also elevate PM2.5 concentrations above state and national 24-hour and annual Ambient Air Quality Standards.9 This is clear evidence of a significant impact, but the FEIR improperly dismisses these exceedances because they do not also exceed separate SJVAPCD thresholds.10 Furthermore, the FEIR fails to adequately analyze cumulative health risk and air quality impacts, incorrectly assuming that impacts below individual project thresholds are automatically not cumulatively considerable.11 This ignores the local pollution burden where the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile statewide for PM2.5 pollution.12 Despite finding greenhouse gas (“GHG”) and VMT 4 Clark Comments, p. 12.
5 FEIR, p. 2.0-44. 6 FEIR, p. 2.0-52. 7 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32 (the City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways).
8 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59.
9 DEIR, p. Table 4.3-13; Clark Comments, p. 1.
10 FEIR, p. 2.0-64. 11 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”). 12 Clark Comments, p. 10.

October 1, 2026

Page 3 ends
← All documents from this meeting