Agenda packet — Belmont City Council, March 12, 2024 (part 4 of 7)

APPENDIX H
212 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
686
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal

ALEXANDER PARK
SUBTOTAL $ 1,345,325
Soft Costs 25% 336,331 $
Contingency 30% $ 403,598
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 2,085,254

Page 3 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 213
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
687
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Refer to 2020 Conceptual Design Report

PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST

BARRETT COMMUNITY PARK
Implement the recommendations from the Barrett Community Center Conceptual Design Report (2020)

Page 4 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
214 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
688
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 300 SF $ 5 $ 1,500
Fitness equipment station 3 EA 15,000 $ $ 45,000
Concrete pad 300 SF $ 25 $ 7,500
Site preparation 500 SF $ 5 $ 2,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 500 SF $ 25 $ 12,500
Park sign 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Artful park sign 1 EA 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Wi-Fi 1 LS 30,000 $ $ 30,000
Site preparation 500 SF $ 5 $ 2,500
Concrete area pad 500 SF $ 25 $ 12,500
Alternative seating (seat pads, wall, etc.) 4 EA $ 4,000 $ 16,000 Picnic Table 2 EA $ 4,500 $ 9,000
Site preparation 3,300 SF $ 5 $ 16,500
Concrete path (72" wide) 3,300 SF $ 25 $ 82,500
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Native planting 500 SF $ 15 $ 7,500
Drip irrigation 500 SF $ 12 $ 6,000
Native planting 1,500 SF $ 15 $ 22,500
SUBTOTAL $ 310,750
Soft Costs 25% $ 77,688
Contingency 30% $ 93,225
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 481,663

BELAMEDA PARK
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included

4. Add native planting near entrance

5. Refresh planting around playground

1. Create walking loop extension
-. Increase seating opportunities (price per bench)
-. Maintain high-quality landscape condition across the site -. Add Wi-Fi access to site

3. Continue path to create a walking and learn-to-bike loop in land west of parking lot

2. Create a Teen Outdoor Space to complement offerings at the Belmont Library -. Increase entrance and connection opportunities to create better park access f. Add fitness equipment course along existing and extended walking path (Recreation Amenity)

Page 5 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 215
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
689
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 100 SF $ 5 $ 500
Bike repair station 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Concrete pad 100 SF $ 25 $ 2,500
Site preparation 4,000 SF $ 5 $ 20,000
Concrete pad 4,000 SF $ 25 $ 100,000
Shade structure (small) 1 EA 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Bench 6 EA $ 3,500 $ 21,000
Picnic table 4 EA $ 4,500 $ 18,000
Site preparation 11,250 SF $ 5 $ 56,250
Pump track (asphalt surface) 1 LS 500,000 $ $ 500,000
Site preparation 300 SF $ 5 $ 1,500
Fitness equipment station 3 EA 15,000 $ $ 45,000
Concrete pad 300 SF $ 25 $ 7,500
Site preparation 700 SF $ 5 $ 3,500
Relocate picnic table 1 LS $ 2,500 $ 2,500
Concrete pad 700 SF $ 25 $ 17,500
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Native planting 4,500 SF $ 15 $ 67,500
Drip irrigation 4,500 SF $ 12 $ 54,000
South Field - Site preparation 69,000 SF $5 $ 345,000
South Field - Synthetic sports field turf (base,
cork infill, grading, drainage) 69,000 SF $50 3,450,000 $ Marina Field - Site preparation 33,000 SF $5 $ 165,000
Marina Field - Synthetic sports field turf (base,
cork infill, grading, drainage) 33,000 SF $50 1,650,000 $ Interpretive signage 3 EA 8,000 $ $ 24,000

BELMONT SPORTS COMPLEX

7. Consider transitioning South Field and Marina Field to synthetic turf -. Increase seating opportunities (price per bench)

8. Add interpretive signage about marsh and bay ecology

5. Relocate picnic tables

3. Redevelop underutilized space with a Pump Track (Bike Park)

4. Add a Fitness Equipment Course around North Field path

6. Add native planting areas

1. Add bike repair station

2. Create an accessible Social Gathering Space to promote social interactions

Page 6 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
216 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
690
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal

BELMONT SPORTS COMPLEX
SUBTOTAL $ 6,610,500
Soft Costs 25% 1,652,625 $
Contingency 30% $ 1,983,150
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 10,246,275

Page 7 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 217
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
691
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Park design plan (large-sized park) 1 LS 200,000 $ $ 200,000 Site preparation 800 SF $ 5 $ 4,000
Park sign 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 800 SF $ 25 $ 20,000
Site preparation 860 SF $ 5 $ 4,300
Concrete path (48" wide) 860 SF $ 25 $ 21,500
Site preparation 2,600 SF $ 5 $ 13,000
Concrete stair and ramp 1 LS 500,000 $ $ 500,000
Concrete path (48" wide) 2,000 SF $ 25 $ 50,000
Site preparation 750 SF $ 5 $ 3,750
Concrete area pad 750 SF $ 25 $ 18,750
Accessory furniture for picnic area 1 LS $ 3,000 $ 3,000 Shade structure (small) 1 EA 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Picnic table 6 EA $ 4,500 $ 27,000
Demolish existing playground 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Playground structure (medium) 1 LS 225,000 $ $ 225,000
Playground safety surfacing 900 SF $ 45 $ 40,500
Demolish existing dog park 1 LS 10,000 $ $ 10,000
Fence, chain link (6') 750 LF $ 100 $ 75,000
Pedestrian entry gate 6 EA $ 5,000 $ 30,000
Synthetic surfacing dog park 26,000 SF $ 35 $ 910,000
Dog agility furniture 3 EA $ 1,500 $ 4,500
Dog waste station 3 EA $ 1,500 $ 4,500
Bench 6 EA $ 3,500 $ 21,000
Picnic table 4 EA $ 4,500 $ 18,000
Concrete pad 550 SF $ 25 $ 13,750
Shade structure (small) 1 EA 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625

CIPRIANI PARK

6. Redesign dog park area to better address community needs and surfacing best suited to use

2. Create ADA accessible path to all existing and new amenities

3. Rebuild entrance stairs and pathway from Buena Vista Ave

1. Formalize dog park entrance from school’s parking lot

5. Upgrade playground structure

4. Establish a Reservable Picnic Area, Small
-. Increase seating opportunities (price per bench)
-. Consider additional amenities in partnership with adjacent school -. Whole park redesign for better accessibility and space utilization with a Park Design Plan

Page 8 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
218 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
692
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal

CIPRIANI PARK
Tree (24" box) 3 EA $ 650 $ 1,950
Turf evalutation (determine extent of repair) 1 LS 10,000 $ $ 10,000 SUBTOTAL $ 2,366,250
Soft Costs 25% 591,563 $
Contingency 30% $ 709,875
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 3,667,688

8. Evaluate multi-use flexible lawn for turf improvement

7. Add trees around perimeter of fenced dog park area for shade

Page 9 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 219
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
693
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Demo existing paving 350 SF $ 10 $ 3,500
Concrete area pad 350 SF $ 25 $ 8,750
Site preparation 250 SF $ 25 $ 6,250
Bike rack 1 EA $ 1,500 $ 1,500
Bike repair station 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Road signage 2 EA $ 500 $ 1,000
Wayfinding signage 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Bench 2 EA $ 3,500 $ 7,000
Concrete pad 250 SF $ 25 $ 6,250
Wayfinding signage 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Playground fibar replenish 1,500 SF $ 3 $ 4,500
Demolish existing bench 2 EA $ 1,000 $ 2,000
Bench 2 EA $ 3,500 $ 7,000
Native planting 1,000 SF $ 15 $ 15,000
Drip irrigation 1,000 SF $ 12 $ 12,000
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650
SUBTOTAL $ 95,400
Soft Costs 25% $ 23,850
Contingency 30% $ 28,620
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 147,870

COLLEGE VIEW PARK

1. Assess paved surface for access and repair/replace as needed -. Consider creating and interconnected pedestrian and bicycle priority route between College View Park, Semeria Park, and Patricia Wharton Park
-. Plant trees to increase shade (price per tree)

2. Explore opportunities to connect to the NDNU Campus

5. Add planted area near picnic area

4. Replace benches

3. Continue to refill wood chips in Playground area periodically To-be-conducted by current department staff

Page 10 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
220 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
694
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Interpretive signage 2 EA $ 8,000 $ 16,000
SUBTOTAL $ 16,000
Soft Costs 25% $ 4,000
Contingency 30% $ 4,800
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 24,800
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included

DAVEY GLEN PARK
f. Add signage for a walking loop within the park (depicted path on ramp, around lawn, and stairs is 0.1 mile)
-. Continue to maintain the high-quality planting across the site

Page 11 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 221
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
695
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 100 SF $ 5 $ 500
Bench 4 EA $ 3,500 $ 14,000
Concrete pad 100 SF $ 25 $ 2,500
Park design plan (medium-sized park) 1 LS 150,000 $ $ 150,000 Accessibility study (park site) 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Site preparation 2,900 SF $ 5 $ 14,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 2,900 SF $ 25 $ 72,500
Demolish existing playground 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Playground structure (medium) 1 LS 225,000 $ $ 225,000
Playground safety surfacing 1,250 SF $ 45 $ 56,250
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650
Native planting 100 SF $ 15 $ 1,500
Drip irrigation 100 SF $ 12 $ 1,200
SUBTOTAL $ 592,850
Soft Costs 25% 148,213 $
Contingency 30% $ 177,855
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 918,918

HALLMARK PARK

2. Resurface and restripe Tennis Courts to include Pickleball (completed Spring 2022)

1. Evaluate paths’ accessibility and reconstruct as needed -. Plant trees to increase shade (price per tree)
-. Plant trees to replace declining existing trees across the site (succession planting) (price per tree) -. Whole park redesign for better accessibility and space utilization with a Park Design Plan -. Consider adding native planting areas

3. Update, expand, and consider relocating playground structure e. Create seating in shaded area (Multi-purpose Flexible Space) -. Increase seating opportunities (price per bench)
Current project, probable cost not included

Page 12 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
222 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
696
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Park design plan (small-sized park) 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000 Demolish existing paving 40 SF $ 10 $ 400
Curb ramp 1 EA 10,000 $ $ 10,000
Pavement markings for crosswalk 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Road signage 2 EA $ 500 $ 1,000
Playground fiber replenish 1,400 SF $ 3 $ 4,200
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Demolish existing fence 150 LS $ 30 $ 4,500
Retaining wall (3') 150 LF $ 450 $ 67,500
Site preparation 60 SF $ 5 $ 300
Fence, chain link (6') 30 LF $ 100 $ 3,000
Pedestrian entry gate 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Demolish existing playground 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Playground structure (medium) 1 LS 225,000 $ $ 225,000
Playground safety surfacing 1,400 SF $ 45 $ 63,000
Native planting 450 SF $ 15 $ 6,750
Drip irrigation 450 SF $ 12 $ 5,400
Interpretive signage 2 EA $ 8,000 $ 16,000
SUBTOTAL $ 546,300
Soft Costs 25% 136,575 $
Contingency 30% $ 163,890
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 846,765

1. Add crosswalk for connectivity to park and adjacent trailhead

4. Replace wood stake fence

8. Add interpretive signage to educate about native plants and open spaces

2. Replenish playground fibar

HASTINGS TOT LOT PARK

3. Replace and consider reorienting benches for eyes on the playground and sunset view (price per bench)

5. Create safety barrier between playground and adjacent Hasting Drive -. Park redesign for proposed park amenities

7. Create native planting area around playground

6. Update play structure

Page 13 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 223
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
697
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Site preparation 1,200 SF $ 5 $ 6,000
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) 3 EA 40,000 $ $ 120,000 Playground safety surfacing 1,200 SF $ 45 $ 54,000
Site preparation 1,500 SF $ 5 $ 7,500
Concrete area pad 1,500 SF $ 25 $ 37,500
Accessory furniture for picnic area 2 LS $ 3,000 $ 6,000 Shade structure (small) 2 EA 50,000 $ $ 100,000
Picnic table 6 EA $ 4,500 $ 27,000
Site preparation 500 SF $ 5 $ 2,500
Decomposed granite area pad 500 SF $ 12 $ 6,000
Bench 8 EA $ 3,500 $ 28,000
Park design plan (medium-sized park) 1 LS 150,000 $ $ 150,000 Parking lot ADA striping
Signage 1 EA $ 500 $ 500
Site preparation 3,500 SF $ 5 $ 17,500
Asphalt paving 3,500 SF $ 25 $ 87,500
Parking lot striping 1 LS 15,000 $ $ 15,000
Prefabricated restroom 1 LS 500,000 $ $ 500,000
Restroom utility connection 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Site preparation 300 SF $ 5 $ 1,500
Open Space gateway element 1 LS 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650

HIDDEN CANYON PARK
e. Add an Outdoor Classroom (Multi-purpose Flexible Space)

4. Add Open Space Gateway Element
-. Add shade (trees or shade structure) to seating areas (price per tree) c. Add Nature Play Element (Play Amenity)

1. Add ADA parking stall
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included
b. Add seating opportunities (Seating) (price per bench) -. Maintain native plantings
d. Add a small and shaded Picnic Areas (Picnic Opportunity) -. Remove non-native plants

2. Increase quantity of parking stalls to better accommodate current parking demand

3. Add restroom with water fountain
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included
See Recommendation 2. Re-stripe entire lot
-. Whole park design for amenities and accessibility with a Park Design Plan

Page 14 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
224 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
698
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal

HIDDEN CANYON PARK
SUBTOTAL $ 1,246,400
Soft Costs 25% 311,600 $
Contingency 30% $ 373,920
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 1,931,920

Page 15 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 225
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
699
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 1,200 SF $ 5 $ 6,000
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) 3 EA 40,000 $ $ 120,000 Playground safety surfacing 1,200 SF $ 45 $ 54,000
Park design plan (medium-sized park) 1 LS 150,000 $ $ 150,000 Accessibility study (park site) 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Site preparation 6,000 SF $ 5 $ 30,000
Concrete path (48" wide) 6,000 SF $ 25 $ 150,000
Site preparation 1,000 SF $ 5 $ 5,000
Concrete stair 1 LS 200,000 $ $ 200,000
Site preparation 750 SF $ 5 $ 3,750
Concrete area pad 750 SF $ 25 $ 18,750
Shade structure (large) 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000
Bench 6 EA $ 3,500 $ 21,000
Prefabricated restroom 1 LS 500,000 $ $ 500,000
Restroom utility connection 1 LS 25,000 $ $ 25,000
Remove existing storage container 1 LS $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Storage structure 1 LS 35,000 $ $ 35,000
Demo existing picnic table 3 LS $ 1,500 $ 4,500
Picnic table 3 EA $ 4,500 $ 13,500
Demo existing bench 1 LS $ 1,000 $ 1,000
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
McDOUGAL PARK
-. Create ADA accessible path to all existing and new amenities

1. Explore adding stair, ramp preferred, access closer to Solana Dr c. Add Play Element (Play Amenity)

2. Add an accessible Gathering Space to promote social interaction -. Whole park redesign for better accessibility and amenities proposed amenities with a Park Design Plan g. Utilize adjacent school for off-street parking during limited hours (Off-Street Parking) -. Increase seating opportunities (price per bench)

3. Replace storage containers

4. Replace picnic tables

5. Replace benches (price per bench)
No associated capital cost
h. Add permanent restroom (Permanent Restroom)

Page 16 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
226 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
700
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
McDOUGAL PARK
Arborist visit (park site, annually)
Site preparation 72,500 SF $5 $ 362,500
Syntheticsports field turf (base, cork infill,
grading, drainage) 72,500 SF $50 3,625,000 $
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650
SUBTOTAL $ 5,463,400
Soft Costs 25% 1,365,850 $
Contingency 30% $ 1,639,020
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 8,468,270

6. Consider transitioning Multi-use Athletic Fields to synthetic turf -. Evaluate condition of trees near entrance and remove or treat as needed -. Plant trees to increase shade (price per tree)
Conducted by City arborist

Page 17 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 227
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
701
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 750 SF $ 5 $ 3,750
Concrete area pad 750 SF $ 25 $ 18,750
Accessory furniture for picnic area 1 LS $ 3,000 $ 3,000 Shade structure (small) 1 EA 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Picnic table 6 EA $ 4,500 $ 27,000
Demolish existing BBQs 2 LS $ 1,000 $ 2,000
BBQ 2 EA $ 2,500 $ 5,000
Resurface court (1/2 basketball) 2 EA 18,000 $ $ 36,000 Court marking and hoops (1/2 court) 2 EA $ 7,500 $ 15,000 Site preparation 2,500 SF $ 5 $ 12,500
Concrete area pad 2,500 SF $ 25 $ 62,500
Shade structure (small) 1 EA 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Picnic table 4 EA $ 4,500 $ 18,000
Outdoor game furniture 3 EA 10,000 $ $ 30,000
Native planting 4,500 SF $ 15 $ 67,500
SUBTOTAL $ 401,000
Soft Costs 25% 100,250 $
Contingency 30% $ 120,300
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 621,550
-. Maintain high-quality landscape condition across the site

2. Replace BBQs
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included

O'DONNELL PARK

1. Establish a Reservable Picnic Area, Small
-. Refresh planting areas with native plants

3. Refurbish the existing half basketball courts

4. Add shade, tables, and outdoor games

Page 18 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
228 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
702
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 250 SF $ 250 $ 62,500
Bike rack 1 EA $ 1,500 $ 1,500
Bike repair station 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Road signage 2 EA $ 500 $ 1,000
Wayfinding signage 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Bench 2 EA $ 3,500 $ 7,000
Concrete pad 250 SF $ 25 $ 6,250
Demo existing bench 1 LS $ 1,000 $ 1,000
Bench 2 EA $ 3,500 $ 7,000
Alternative seating (seat pad, walls, etc.) 3 EA $ 4,000 $ 12,000 Native planting 500 SF $ 15 $ 7,500
Drip irrigation 500 SF $ 12 $ 6,000
SUBTOTAL $ 124,250
Soft Costs 25% $ 31,063
Contingency 30% $ 37,275
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 192,588
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included
-. Maintain high-quality landscape condition across the site

PATRICIA WHARTON PARK

1. Evaluate path’s accessibility and reconstruct as needed -. Consider creating an interconnected pedestrian and bicycle priority route between Patricia Wharton Park, Semeria Park, and College View Park

3. Add boulders or stumps as seating or play elements in center planter area

4. Add native planting to hillside

2. Replace seating
To-be-conducted by current department staff

Page 19 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 229
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
703
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Site preparation 400 SF $ 5 $ 2,000
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) 1 EA 40,000 $ $ 40,000 Playground safety surfacing 400 SF $ 45 $ 18,000
Site preparation 100 SF $ 5 $ 500
Concrete area pad 100 SF $ 25 $ 2,500
Picnic table 1 EA $ 4,500 $ 4,500
Site preparation 750 SF $ 5 $ 3,750
Decomposed granite area pad 750 SF $ 12 $ 9,000
Bench 4 EA $ 3,500 $ 14,000
Site preparation 1,800 SF $ 5 $ 9,000
Concrete path (48" wide) 1,800 SF $ 25 $ 45,000
Park design plan (medium-sized park) 1 LS 150,000 $ $ 150,000 Arborist visit (park site, annually)
Native planting 900 SF $ 15 $ 13,500
Drip irrigation 900 SF $ 12 $ 10,800
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650
SUBTOTAL $ 327,450
Soft Costs 25% $ 81,863
Contingency 30% $ 98,235
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 507,548
e. Add seating space (Multi-purpose Flexible Space)
-. Add native planting areas
-. Monitor trees and replace as necessary
-. Utilize trees as screening from Ralston Avenue and as wind protection (price per tree)

RALSTON RANCH PARK
c. Add Natural Play Element (Play Amenity)
f. Add walking path (Recreation Amenity)
b. Add benches (Seating) (price per bench)
d. Add individual Picnic Tables (Picnic Opportunity) (price per table) Conducted by City arborist
-. Whole park design for amenities and accessibility with a Park Design Plan

Page 20 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
230 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
704
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Interpretive signage 1 EA $ 8,000 $ 8,000
Site preparation 250 SF $ 25 $ 6,250
Bike rack 1 EA $ 1,500 $ 1,500
Bike repair station 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Road signage 2 EA $ 500 $ 1,000
Wayfinding signage 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Bench 2 EA $ 3,500 $ 7,000
Concrete pad 250 SF $ 25 $ 6,250
Re-orient existing trash receptacle 1 LS $ 1,500 $ 1,500 SUBTOTAL $ 44,000
Soft Costs 25% $ 11,000
Contingency 30% $ 13,200
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 68,200
Maintenance effort, probable cost not included

SEMERIA PARK
-. Consider creating an interconnected pedestrian and bicycle priority route between Semeria Park, Patricia Wharton Park, and College View Park
f. Add fitness signage (Recreation Amenity)
-. Maintain high-quality landscape condition across the site

1. Garbage receptable access from sidewalk

Page 21 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 231
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
705
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Refer to Twin Pines Master Plan

PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST

TWIN PINES
Implement Twin Pines Master Plan (2019)

Page 22 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
232 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
706
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 750 SF $ 5 $ 3,750
Shade structure (small) 1 LS 50,000 $ $ 50,000
Concrete area pad 750 SF $ 25 $ 18,750
Bench 4 EA $ 3,500 $ 14,000
Intepretive signage 2 EA $ 8,000 $ 16,000
Demolish existing paving 2,000 SF $ 10 $ 20,000
Asphalt path (48" wide) 2,000 SF $ 15 $ 30,000
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Park sign 1 EA $ 7,500 $ 7,500
Tree (24" box) 1 EA $ 650 $ 650
Native planting 1,000 SF $ 15 $ 15,000
Drip irrigation 1,000 SF $ 12 $ 12,000
Public Art 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000
SUBTOTAL $ 291,900
Soft Costs 25% $ 72,975
Contingency 30% $ 87,570
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 452,445
c. Create overlook opportunity (Identifiable Amenity)
-. Add native planting areas

WAKEFIELD PARK

3. Add entrance signage to increase park visibility
-. Public Art opportunity

1. Improve existing walking path(s)

2. Add benches (price per bench)
-. Plant trees to increase shade (price per tree)

Page 23 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 233
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
707
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 2,300 SF $ 5 $ 11,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 2,300 SF $ 25 $ 57,500
Demo existing 1 LS $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Site preparation 625 SF $ 5 $ 3,125
Bench 8 EA $ 3,500 $ 28,000
Concrete area pad 500 SF $ 25 $ 12,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 500 SF $ 25 $ 12,500
Site preparation 44,000 SF $ 5 $ 220,000
Synthetic sports field turf (base, cork infill,
grading, drainage) 44,000 SF $50 2,200,000 $
SUBTOTAL $ 2,550,125
Soft Costs 25% 637,531 $
Contingency 30% $ 765,038
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 3,952,694

2. Rejuvenate outdoor classroom space

3. Convert Multi-use Athletic Field to synthetic field to increase annual usable time

1. Create looped walking path around lawn
JOINT USE AGREEMENT:

CENTRAL SCHOOL

Page 24 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
234 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
708
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 35,500 SF $ 5 $ 177,500
Synthetic sports field turf (base, cork infill,
grading, drainage) 35,500 SF $50 1,775,000 $
SUBTOTAL $ 1,952,500
Soft Costs 25% 488,125 $
Contingency 30% $ 585,750
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 3,026,375
JOINT USE AGREEMENT:

FOX SCHOOL

1. Convert Multi-use Athletic Field to synthetic field to increase annual usable time

Page 25 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 235
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
709
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 135,000 SF $ 5 $ 675,000
Synthetic sports field turf (base, cork infill,
grading, drainage) 135,000 SF $50 6,750,000 $
SUBTOTAL $ 7,425,000
Soft Costs 25% 1,856,250 $
Contingency 30% $ 2,227,500
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 11,508,750
JOINT USE AGREEMENT:

NESBIT SCHOOL

1. Convert Multi-use Athletic Field to synthetic field to increase annual usable time

Page 26 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
236 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
710
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 5,000 SF $ 5 $ 25,000
Decomposed granite path (48" wide) 5,000 SF $ 12 $ 60,000 Site preparation 151,000 SF $ 5 $ 755,000
Synthetic sports field turf (base, cork infill,
grading, drainage) 151,000 SF $50 7,550,000 $
SUBTOTAL $ 8,390,000
Soft Costs 25% 2,097,500 $
Contingency 30% $ 2,517,000
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 13,004,500
JOINT USE AGREEMENT:

RALSTON MIDDLE SCHOOL

1. Update exterior path at property line to better connect to ropes course south of the school if former ropes course is activated for other use

2. Convert Multi-use Athletic Field to synthetic field to increase annual usable time

Page 27 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 237
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
711
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Enhanced planting 3,750 SF $ 20 $ 75,000
Drip irrigation 3,750 SF $ 12 $ 45,000
Site preparation 25 SF $ 5 $ 125
Bench 1 EA $ 3,500 $ 3,500
Concrete pad 25 SF $ 25 $ 625
Site preparation 3,500 SF $ 5 $ 17,500
Skate park (small) 1 EA 800,000 $ $ 800,000
Park design plan (small-sized park) 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000 Site preparation 500 SF $ 5 $ 2,500
Concrete path (48" wide) 500 SF $ 25 $ 12,500
Site preparation 3,250 SF $ 5 $ 16,250
Fence, chain link (6') 250 LF $ 100 $ 25,000
Pedestrian entry gate 2 EA $ 5,000 $ 10,000
Synthetic surfacing dog park 3,250 SF $ 35 $ 113,750
Dog waste station 2 EA $ 1,500 $ 3,000
Bench 3 EA $ 3,500 $ 10,500
Concrete pad 75 SF $ 25 $ 1,875
Site preparation 6,000 SF $ 5 $ 30,000
Native planting 1,600 SF $ 15 $ 24,000
Drip irrigation 1,600 SF $ 12 $ 19,200
Accessory furniture for picnic area 1 LS $ 3,000 $ 3,000 Bench 8 EA $ 3,500 $ 28,000
Picnic table 4 EA $ 4,500 $ 18,000
Site lighting 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000
Concrete pad 6,000 SF $ 25 $ 150,000
Public art 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000
-. Whole park design for amenities and accessibility with a Park Design Plan

3. Install Public Art piece
b. Add benches (Seating) (price per bench)
OPPORTUNITY SITE:

RALSTON AVE + OLD COUNTY RD *
c. Add Skate Park (Identifiable Amenity)

1. Add Dog Parklet

2. Add placemaking space to host community gathering, event space, pop-up business space, etc.
a. Create gateway planting as an entry for Belmont (Natural Environment) -. Create ADA accessible path to all existing and new amenities

Page 28 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
238 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
712
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
OPPORTUNITY SITE:

RALSTON AVE + OLD COUNTY RD *
SUBTOTAL $ 1,709,325
Soft Costs 25% 427,331 $
Contingency 30% $ 512,798
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 2,649,454
* All recommendations for the Opportunity Site at Ralston Ave and Old County Rd may be temporary

Page 29 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 239
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
713
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Native planting 250 SF $ 15 $ 3,750
Drip irrigation 250 SF $ 12 $ 3,000
Site preparation 75 SF $ 5 $ 375
Bench 3 EA $ 3,500 $ 10,500
Concrete pad 75 SF $ 25 $ 1,875
Site preparation 500 SF $ 5 $ 2,500
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) 1 EA 40,000 $ $ 40,000 Playground safety surfacing 500 SF $ 45 $ 22,500
Park design plan (small-sized park) 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000 Pavement markings 1 LS $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Road signage 1 EA $ 500 $ 500
Site preparation 665 SF $ 5 $ 3,325
Curb and gutter 190 LF $ 75 $ 14,250
Concrete path (48" wide) 665 SF $ 25 $ 16,625
SUBTOTAL $ 224,200
Soft Costs 25% $ 56,050
Contingency 30% $ 67,260
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 347,510
OPPORTUNITY SITE:

OAK KNOLL DRIVE
-. Encourage creation of a “safety circle” at the terminus of Oak Knoll Drive to highlight park use in center
c. Add Play Element (Identifiable Amenity)
b. Add benches (Seating)
a. Add native planting areas
-. Whole park design for amenities and accessibility with a Park Design Plan

Page 30 of 31 ends

APPENDIX H
240 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
714
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Site preparation 125 SF $ 5 $ 625
Bench 5 EA $ 3,500 $ 17,500
Concrete pad 125 SF $ 25 $ 3,125
Site preparation 900 SF $ 5 $ 4,500
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) 2 EA 40,000 $ $ 80,000 Playground safety surfacing 900 SF $ 45 $ 40,500
Park design plan (small-sized park) 1 LS 100,000 $ $ 100,000 Site preparation 540 SF $ 5 $ 2,700
Concrete path (48" wide) 540 SF $ 25 $ 13,500
Site preparation 600 SF $ 5 $ 3,000
Concrete path (48" wide) 600 SF $ 25 $ 15,000
Curb and gutter 90 LF $ 75 $ 6,750
Site preparation 100 SF $ 25 $ 2,500
Bike repair station 1 EA $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Concrete pad 100 SF $ 25 $ 2,500
Fence, ornamental iron (6') 60 LF $ 150 $ 9,000
Native planting 1,000 SF $ 15 $ 15,000
Drip irrigation 1,000 SF $ 12 $ 12,000
SUBTOTAL $ 333,200
Soft Costs 25% $ 83,300
Contingency 30% $ 99,960
PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $ 516,460
OPPORTUNITY SITE:

ALAMEDA DE LOS PULGAS
-. Add native planting areas

4. Add fence or protective barrier between play element and road

1. Add looped walking path(s)

2. Encourage creation of sidewalks along and connecting to park

3. Add bike repair station
c. Add Nature Play Element (Identifiable Amenity)
b. Add benches (Seating)
-. Whole park design for amenities and accessibility with a Park Design Plan

Page 31 of 31 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 241
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
715
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Accessibility study (park site) LS 25,000 $ $ -
Accessory furniture for picnic area LS $ 3,000 $ -
All-abilities playground structure (medium) LS 750,000 $ Alternative seating (seat pads, walls, etc.) EA $ 4,000 $ - Artful park sign EA 25,000 $ $ -
Asphalt path (48" wide) SF $ 15 $ -
Asphalt paving SF $ 25 $ -
BBQ EA $ 2,500 $ -
Bench EA $ 3,500 $ -
Bike rack EA $ 1,500 $ -
Bike repair station EA $ 5,000 $ -
Bocce court EA 200,000 $ $ -
Concrete area pad SF $ 25 $ -
Concrete pad SF $ 25 $ -
Concrete path (48" wide) SF $ 25 $ -
Concrete stair and ramp LS 500,000 $ $ -
Court marking and hoops (1/2 court) EA $ 7,500 $ -
Curb and gutter LF $ 75 $ -
Curb ramp EA 10,000 $ $ -
Decomposed granite area pad SF $ 12 $ -
Decomposed granite path (48" wide) SF $ 12 $ -
Demolish existing BBQs LS $ 1,000 $ -
Demolish existing bench LS $ 1,000 $ -
Demolish existing dog park LS 10,000 $ $ -
Demolish existing fence LF $ 30 $ -
Demolish existing paving SF $ 10 $ -
Demolish existing picnic table LS $ 1,500 $ -
Demolish existing playground LS 25,000 $ $ -
Dog agility furniture EA $ 1,500 $ -
Dog waste station EA $ 1,500 $ -
Drip irrigation SF $ 12 $ -
Enhanced planting SF $ 20 $ -
Fence, chain link (6') LF $ 100 $ -
Fence, ornamental iron (6') LF $ 150 $ -
Fitness equipment station EA 15,000 $ $ -
Open space gateway element LS 50,000 $ $ -
Interpretive signage EA $ 8,000 $ -
Mural on fence LS 15,000 $ $ -
Native planting SF $ 15 $ -
Outdoor game furniture EA 10,000 $ $ -

Page 1 of 2 ends

APPENDIX H
242 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX H DRAFT
716
Belmont PROS Plan DRAFT 6/26/2022
Opinion of Probable
Construction Costs
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Subtotal
Park design plan (small-sized park) LS 100,000 $ $ -
Park design plan (medium-sized park) LS 150,000 $ $ -
Park design plan (large-sized park) LS 200,000 $ $ -
Park sign EA $ 7,500 $ -
Parking lot signage EA $ 500 $ -
Parking lot striping LS 15,000 $ $ -
Pavement markings EA $ 5,000 $ -
Pavement markings for crosswalk EA $ 5,000 $ -
Pedestrian entry gate EA $ 5,000 $ -
Picnic table EA $ 4,500 $ -
Play element (independent play, swing, etc.) EA 40,000 $ $ - Playground concrete curb LF $ 60 $ -
Playground fibar replenish SF $ 3 $ -
Playground safety surfacing SF $ 45 $ -
Playground structure (large) LS 350,000 $ $ -
Playground structure (medium) LS 225,000 $ $ -
Playground structure (small) LS 150,000 $ $ -
Prefabricated restroom LS 500,000 $ $ -
Public art LS 100,000 $ $ -
Pump track (asphalt surface) LS 500,000 $ $ -
Relocate picnic table LS $ 2,500 $ -
Remove existing storage container LS $ 5,000 $ -
Re-orient existing trash receptacle LS $ 1,500 $ -
Restroom utility connection LS 25,000 $ $ -
Resurface court (1/2 basketball) EA 18,000 $ $ -
Retaining wall (3') LF $ 450 $ -
Road signage EA $ 500 $ -
Shade structure (large) EA 100,000 $ $ -
Shade structure (small) EA 50,000 $ $ -
Site lighting LS 100,000 $ $ -
Site preparation SF $ 5 $ -
Skate park (small, modular) EA 800,000 $ $ -
Storage structure EA 35,000 $ $ -
Synthetic sports field turf (base, cork infill, grading, drainage) SF $50 $ - Synthetic surfacing dog park SF $ 35 $ -
Trash receptacle EA $ 1,500 $ -
Tree (24" box) EA $ 650 $ -
Turf evalutation (determine extent of repair) LS 10,000 $ $ - Wayfinding signage EA $ 7,500 $ -
Wi-Fi LS 30,000 $ $ -

Page 2 of 2 ends

Probable Costs
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 243
Opinion of Probable Construction Costs assumed amenity quantities are for pricing purposes only, and do not imply, affect, or otherwise assume the quantity of improvements that will be implemented at a PROS site.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Probable Costs
717

THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
718
245

APPENDIX I
CITY OF BELMONT | PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES Community Outreach

APPENDIX I
719

APPENDIX I
246 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY
The online survey was open to the public for the entire month of April 2021. Over 2,800 responses were
collected, of which 49 percent were from Belmont
residents.

FOCUS GROUPS
In total, over 75 people participated across 11 focus
groups. The focus group dates and topic areas were:
• June 3, 2021. Youth + Teen
• June 4, 2021. District + Joint-Use
• June 8, 2021. Seniors
• June 8 + 15, 2021. Dog Owners
• June 24, 2021. Youth Sports
• June 29, 2021. Inclusion
• June 29, 2021. Schools
• October 18, 2021. Hidden Canyon Park
• October 20, 2021. Ralston Ranch Park
• November 18, 2021. Youth Advisory Committee

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
The Advisory Committee consisted of 18 Belmont
residents. The members and their bios are listed in
Appendix A. The Committee met five times over the
PROS Plan project duration.
• March 4, 2021. Project Initiation
• May 13, 2021. Community Input Summary
• September 30, 2021. Park-specific Recommendations
• April 5, 2022. Open Space Management Plan
• May 31, 2022. Open Space Management Plan

PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS
The Parks and Recreation Commission received
updates about the PROS Plan from the Parks and
Recreation Director on a monthly basis. Several public
presentations were provided at various meetings by
the consultants.

PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
• February 3, 2021
• June 2, 2021
• November 3, 2021
• May 4, 2022
• July 6, 2022
• January 10, 2024
• February 7, 2024

PLANNING COMMISSION
• April 6, 2021

CITY COUNCIL
• March 9, 2021
• November 23, 2021 (Study Session)
• March 22, 2022
• July 12, 2022
• March 12, 2024 *
* Presentation not included in the Appendix

PARK-SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATION COMMENTS
The Park-specific Recommendations were available
for public review and comment from September 2021
through March 2022. Approximately 60 comments
were collected on the project website.

EMAILS TO [email protected]
Over 950 emails were received at the PROS Plan
project email address from January 2021 to February
2024. Emails were posted to the project website on a
monthly basis.

EMAILS TO PARKS+RECREATION COMMISSION
Over 650 emails were received by the Parks and
Recreation Commission about the PROS Plan from
November 2020 to February 2024. Emails were posted
to the project website on a monthly basis.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
720
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 247

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS

QUESTION

QUANTITY OF RESPONSES
Total Resident Non-resident

1. How often do you or a member of your household visit a park, athletic facility or open space in Belmont? Select one frequency for each component of our plan.
2,790 1,296 46.5% 1,342 48.1%

2. What is the typical length of your visit to parks,
athletic facilities, and open spaces in Belmont? 2,776 1,290 46.5% 1,337 48.2%

3. Why do you visit parks, athletic facilities, and
open spaces? Check all that apply. 2,795 1,294 46.3% 1,345 48.1%

4. How do you usually travel to parks, athletic facilities, and open spaces in Belmont? Check all that apply. 2,790 1,294 46.4% 1,341 48.1%

5. For the parks, athletic facilities, and open spaces you visit in Belmont, please tell us how you would rate
the condition of that space? Select all that apply.
2,744 1,273 46.4% 1,328 48.4%

6. What factors limit your use of our parks, athletic
facilities, and open spaces? Check all that apply. 1,575 812 51.6% 694 44.1%

7. The following amenities or uses would greatly
enhance my experience with parks in Belmont. 2,609 1,294 49.6% 1,228 47.1%

8. The following amenities or uses would greatly enhance my experience with open spaces in Belmont. 2,709 1,267 46.8% 1,310 48.4%

9. The following programs or activities would greatly
enhance my experience with outdoor recreation
programs and activities in Belmont.
2,306 1,160 50.3% 1,076 46.7%

10. What factors limit your participation in outdoor programs and activities offered by the City of Belmont. Check all that apply. 2,159 1,081 50.1% 1,027 47.6% 11 In which neighborhood do you live? Select one. 2,646 1,298 49.1% 1,348 50.9%

12. What is your age? 2,733 1,289 47.2% 1,347 49.3%

13. Do you have children or youth in your
household? Check all that apply. 2,711 1,286 47.4% 1,333 49.2%

14. How would you describe yourself? Check all that apply. 2,670 1,271 47.6% 1,313 49.2%

15. What else would you like us to know about Belmont’s Parks? 548 -- -- -- --

16. What else would you like use to know
about Belmont’s Open Spaces? 1,334 -- -- -- --

17. What else would you like us to know about
Belmont’s Outdoor Recreation Programs (this
includes youth sports, outdoor exercise, etc.)?
253 -- -- -- --

18. Would you like to subscribe to our email list for the PROS Plan? If so, please provide your email address. 531 -- -- -- -- DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
721

APPENDIX I
248 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS

PARK ATHLETIC FACILITY OPEN SPACE
Total Resident Total Resident Total Resident Total
Daily 358 250 84 71 503 307 669
1 - 3 times per week 727 463 235 176 1161 584 1451
1 - 3 times per month 552 279 160 105 838 324 1171
3 to 5 times per year 362 154 186 123 492 142 788
I/we do not visit 90 28 489 247 40 22 524
I/we use facilities
outside of Belmont
575 237 331 139 674 281 839
Other (please specify) 61
Answered 2790
Skipped 16
QUESTION 1. HOW OFTEN DO YOU OR A MEMBER OF YOUR HOUSEHOLD VISIT A PARK, ATHLETIC FACILITY OR OPEN SPACE IN BELMONT? SELECT ONE FREQUENCY FOR EACH COMPONENT OF OUR PLAN.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
722
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 249

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 1. Other Responses
• Hiking trails throughout the county
• Mid-Penn Open Space
• Children not yet participating in sports
• various open spaces, county parks, state parks
• Once a year
• Edgewood and Pulgas Ridge
• Pacifica open spaces
• Mid pen open space
• MPOSD
• Hidden Canyon
• Bay and coast access
• MPOSD
• 2nd home, North Lake Tahoe and
San Mateo Athletic Club
• No dog parks in Belmont
• Edgewood, Sawyer trail, Bay trail
• Highlands Rec - Stanford RC fitness ctr
• Are used to walk at Waterdog on a daily basis
but because of the crowds and the bikes, I now
go elsewhere. I do this for two hours daily.
• we do not go any more after angry
meeting with bike rider on trail
• All over San Mateo county
• I am considering moving to Belmont
• Skeggs, Windy Ridge, Russian Ridge, Mt. Tam, etc
• between 2 kids probably 7 times per weel
• Bike trails ,(dirt and paved), BMX PUMPTRACKS
• Mountain bike trails!!
• I am a huge outdoor enthusiast and
use our parks, open spaces daily!
• All
• Skeggs
• Bay Meadows
• I am an NDNU alumni and used to
use the park twice a week.
• Water Dog Park
• Beaches, Ski Resorts/Areas
• Pulgas Ridge, Stulsaft, Windy
Hill, Montara Mountain
• Waterdog Lake Open Space
Park & Laurelwood Park
• Centro Chileno Lautaro (a non-profit organization)
is extremely fortunate to have found the beautiful,
large and secluded Redwood Grove in Belmont
Park. Our annual picnic draws the highest
attendance in our program and is a highlight in our
calendar for many years. We celebrate Nature, a
beautiful outdoor space with our multi-generational
families, old and new members and friends.

We share the barbeque, favorite Chilean foods
and wine, music, dance, games and the joy of
comradery. Our Scholarship Program also has a
special ceremony to present our qualifying university
students with their deserving Scholarship Awards
at that event. In the past, we have used a smaller,
cozy Cabin to host smaller luncheon events as well.
• Tennis and Pickleball
• Bay trail from Ralston to past Oracle 3 times/week
• swimming pool
• Bike routes
• I wish Belmont has a community
swimming pool. & athletic facility
• Hiking and walking
• Before the pandemic, I used to attend yoga
classes weekly at the lodge through parks
and rec. This does not reflect that usage.
• Pickle Ball courts in Foster City
• There are almost no athletic facilities in Belmont,
such as tennis courts or swimming pool
• Ice rink
• this is before Covid
• I used parks and athletic field extensively
when my children were young
• We walk the Bay Trails
• Pre-pandemic, my 3 kids were playing soccer
on the Belmont fields multiple times per week
• Woodside, Portola Valley, Mid Peninsula open space
• Serendipity School will use for outdoor activities
• Filoli, Coyote Point
• Tahoe Donner
• 4-7 times a week
• Mid pen open space, golden gate park
• Barrett community center’s outdoor space: daily
• Purisima Creek, El Corte de Madera,
Russian Ridge, Foothill
• Waterdog Lake Open Space / Park
• I visit Twin Pines park ~ once a year. I walk
past Patricia Wharton Park daily. (The trees
are in bloom now!!) Used to go to Cipriani
dog park--bad experience with large dog.
• Save waterdog
• Alameda
• Less since the pandemic began
and the trails got busier.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
723

APPENDIX I
250 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 2. WHAT IS THE TYPICAL LENGTH OF YOUR VISIT TO PARKS, ATHLETIC FACILITIES, AND OPEN SPACES IN BELMONT?

PARK ATHLETIC FACILITY OPEN SPACE
Total Resident Total Resident Total Resident Total
Less than an hour 399 283 159 92 152 107 569
1 - 2 hours 1089 624 390 277 1623 795 2025
More than 2 hours 407 158 129 82 1076 404 1191
Other (please specify) 19
Answered 2776
Skipped 30
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
724
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 251

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 2. Other Responses
• My husband refs soccer so during
soccer season it is all day.
• Go for a walk twice a day
• All day
• mountain biking
• San Mateo Athletic Club,
• Skatepark if there was one
• 2-4hours
• As an avid mountain biker and hiker
I enjoy long rides and hikes!int
• Half day
• I spent about 5-6 hours there for mtn biking
• Water dog Park
• Beaches, Ski Resorts/Areas
• Our Committee begins early, 9:00AM bring in
ice chests, carts full of every thing to decorate,
present and start getting the food, wine, drinks
ready for the BBQ Luncheon. The members
and friends start arrive ready for lunch and
stay entertained all afternoon. At 5:00, we
clean up and carry everything back to our
cars. We all had a wonderful and full day!
• I wish Belmont has a community
swimming pool. & athletic facility
• Do not live in Belmont currently
• Pickle Ball courts in Foster City
• See above. We don’t use Belmont OS.

There are far better options.
• During the week, I typically jog with my
dog in Waterdog daily. On weekends, our
family typically takes longer 1+ hr hikes
through Waterdog or Sugarloaf
• Serendipity School will use for outdoor activities
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
725

APPENDIX I
252 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 3. WHY DO YOU VISIT PARKS, ATHLETIC FACILITIES, AND OPEN SPACES? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

Total Resident
Exercise - individual 2588 1163 2588
Exercise - organized activity 841 359 841
Participate on a sports team 369 245 369
Connect with community 536 288 536
Peace and quiet 1315 716 1315
Commune with nature 1569 779 1569
Gather with friends and family 1135 603 1135
Work outside my home 61 41 61
Learn something new 197 101 197
Outing with children 997 586 997
Outing with pet 708 439 708
Caregiving for an adult 32 22 32
Other (please specify) 252 104 252
Answered 2795
Skipped 11
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
726
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 253

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 3. Other Responses
• Mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Volunteer - repair trails, remove litter,
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Senior Meals Program
• Events
• wildlife watching
• Mountain biking
• Summer concerts in the park!
• Mountain biking
• cycling
• Mountain Biking
• Ride my mountain bike!
• Mountain Biking
• mountain biking
• Enjoying life
• Playgrounds for children
• Mountain biking
• Multiple grandchildren’s baseball and soccer games.
• mountain bike with friends
• bike
• Mountain bike, hike.
• Biking
• Fun
• Mountain biking
• mountain bike trails that are legal
• Mountain biking/training to compete
• Mountain Biking in nature
• Biking at Water Dog
• Bike
• Cycling
• Non-exercise organized activity eg. Scouts
• Biking
• MOUNTAIN BIKING!!!!
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bike
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
727

APPENDIX I
254 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 3. Other Responses (con’t)
• Stress relief
• exercise and connect with friends and
community while mountain biking
• Biking with friends
• For fun
• Mountain bike at Waterdog Park
• Ride bike
• Mountain biking with friends and neighbors
• Mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Recreation
• Mtb riding water dog
• Mountain bilking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Bike
• Mountain Bike
• Ride mountain bikes
• Pedal Powered Mountain Biker
• Mountain biking
• We love to bike with friends. Which
is exercise (organized or individual),
participate in sports, connect, peace and
quite, commune and gather all in one.
• Mountain biking: this is one of the
few area for mountain biking.
• Bicycling
• Ride my MTB and/or my Electric MTB
• Mountain Bike / Run at Waterdog
Lake for the past 30 years
• Mountain bike
• Mountain Biking
• Bike Ride
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• mountain biking at water dog lake
park - keep it as is it is!
• Ride or hike with friends and family
• Mountain Bike
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking (no an e-bike).
• Mountain biking
• Hike
• Mountain biking
• Getting outside
• Riding mountain bikes on singletrack trails
• Watch baseball and soccer games
• Biker ride
• Mountain Biking
• Bike
• Looking for native plants and wildflowers
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bike riding
• Skateboarding
• skateboard
• Skate
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Biking
• Bike riding
• Cycling,jogging.
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Bike
• mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Riding bikes
• Mountain biking
• mountain bike with friends
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain bike
• small group bike rides
• Mountain bike
• MOUNTAIN BIKE
• Mountain Biking - Great trail system
• Mountainbiking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bike
• habitat restoration
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Bike
• Bike riding
• One of the best parts of living in the
bay area is our Open Spaces! Without
them I would simply wither away.
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Biking
• Mental health
• Mountain biking
• mountain biking
• Mountain biking with friends
• Biking
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
728
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 255

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 3. Other Responses (con’t)
• I mountain bike
• Mountain bike
• MOUNTAIN BIKING
• Explore flora and fauna
• Biking!
• Mountain Biking
• Biking
• ride mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• Mental therapy
• Riding my bike
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Bike
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bike with friends
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain biking
• bike
• Family mountain bike ride.
• hike & mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• Hiking
• Mountain Bike Waterdog
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Ride mtn bike
• Mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bikes
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain biking
• Mtn biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Bike
• Mountain bike
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain biking
• MOuntain Bike safely
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain bike
• Ride my Bicycle
• Mountain biking
• Mountain biking and running
• Mountain bike
• z
• Ride my mountain on trails
• Mt Biking
• mountain bike
• mountain biking
• Mtn biking
• cycling
• Mountain biking
• Bike
• Mtn Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Mountain Biking
• Biking
• Mountain bike
• Mountian bike
• mountain Bike
• mountain bike at WaterDog Park
• exercise for me, my boyfriend and dog Karma :)
• Mountain Biking
• tennis
• Senior Tennis Workout
• Enjoy trails and views!
• Relaxation/Stress Management
• community garden
• Community garden
• Mountain bike
• Mountain Biking
• Cycling
• Experiencing the presence of wildlife is important
and this cannot be done with biking on the trails.
• Mountain biking
• Bike Riding
• Mountain biking
• Mountain bike
• Tree
• Mountain biking trails
• Recreation
• Cycling
• Facilities not available elsewhere, such as biking
• Birdwatching
• Biking
• Ride a bike
• exercise with family and friends
• See above. We don’t use Belmont OS.

There are far better options.
• baseball
• Cycling in flat areas
• my office is in park
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
729

APPENDIX I
256 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 3. Other Responses (con’t)
• So that our kids can spend time playing
and interacting with their friends in
a playground environment
• Outdoor concerts, Line Dancing
• gardening in community garden
• My children PLAY in the parks
• Exercise with friends
• Bikes
• Mountain biking
• Cycling
• adventure and exploration!
• Ride bikes
• Mountain Bike on the trails
• Serendipity School will use for outdoor activities
• Mountain bike with son at Waterdog
• Wildlife
• Enjoy the scenic views, watch the wildlife
• Birding, photography
• MTB
• Picnic or other facility rental for Girl Scout events • Mountain Bike.
• Biking
• wildlife watching
• Mountain biking - PEDAL ONLY
• Photography
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
730
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 257

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 4. HOW DO YOU USUALLY TRAVEL TO PARKS, ATHLETIC FACILITIES, AND OPEN SPACES IN BELMONT? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

Total Resident
None of the above 0 0 0
Bike 1768 698 1768
Walk 1079 823 1079
Drive 1849 872 1849
Skateboard/Rollerblade 45 31 45
Public Transportation 31 11 31
Other (please specify) 43 26 43
Answered 2790
Skipped 16
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
731

APPENDIX I
258 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 4. Other Responses
• hike and trail running
• mountain biking
• Run
• Run
• Car
• Run
• car
• Electric bike
• Run
• Mountain bike
• hike, run
• run
• Moutain Bike
• Run
• Run
• Run from my home
• run
• Horse back ride
• Would love to walk to a diff park in my
neighborhood here in Belmont
• Run
• I was a bike/CalTrain commuter before
covid & it’s sad traffic has returned
• use spaces outside Belmont
• Scooter
• Sometimes we will drive if it’s a little further
away and we have kids and dogs
• Run
• mountain biking specifically
• drive but with electric vehicle if that matters!
• trail run
• Running
• Run
• run
• Bike
• .
• Run
• Tennis
• Run
• literally only bike to Waterdog; no other
good way for me to get there
• Run
• Car
• run
• See above. We don’t use Belmont OS.

There are far better options.
• scooter
• Kayak
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
732
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 259

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 5. FOR THE PARKS, ATHLETIC FACILITIES, AND OPEN SPACES YOU VISIT IN BELMONT, PLEASE TELL US HOW YOU WOULD RATE THE CONDITION OF THAT SPACE? SELECT ALL THAT APPLY.

EXCELLENT VERY GOOD SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY NO OPINION Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Alexander Park 61 29 177 107 151 117 18 16 1048 505 1455 Barrett
Community
Center Park
74 47 262 184 388 324 144 139 728 222 1596
Belameda Park 60 34 183 125 120 84 6 6 1048 507 1417
Cipriani Park
and Dog Park
82 43 254 162 274 215 82 74 848 356 1540
College
View Park
38 21 102 55 105 67 11 9 1123 580 1379
Davey Glen Park 96 71 193 134 113 77 20 17 999 469 1421 Hallmark Park 102 48 266 165 261 189 56 51 861 396 1546 Hastings Tot Lot 34 16 101 50 106 76 10 8 1117 573 1368 Hidden
Canyon Park
(undeveloped)
262 110 326 153 218 123 59 48 755 397 1620
McDougal
Field/Park
50 26 125 81 175 129 34 32 1029 490 1413
O’Donnell Park 47 29 85 53 90 64 6 4 1130 571 1358
Patricia
Wharton Park
59 45 120 85 119 89 12 11 1065 513 1375
Ralston
Ranch Park
(undeveloped)
86 41 114 52 121 63 37 26 1030 549 1388
Semeria Park 89 67 161 126 112 82 7 7 1010 466 1379
Twin Pines Park 240 177 516 374 295 234 47 40 594 154 1692 Wakefield Park 42 20 88 53 107 74 27 24 1079 547 1343
Belmont Sports
Complex
225 166 314 223 162 111 22 15 796 330 1519
Central School
Field
44 28 127 93 172 124 66 59 993 462 1402
Fox School Field 59 41 175 126 221 177 65 58 923 399 1443 Nesbit School
Field
38 23 112 75 178 142 61 54 1004 466 1393
Ralston Middle
School Field
61 39 180 120 236 188 82 74 877 373 1436
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
733

APPENDIX I
260 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS

EXCELLENT VERY GOOD SATISFACTORY UNSATISFACTORY NO OPINION Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Waterdog Lake
Open Space
(John Brooks.

Waterdog Lake
and Hidden
Canyon)
1098 399 1055 484 363 228 86 71 72 43 2674
San Juan
Canyon Open
Space
317 152 388 214 212 123 30 29 697 349 1644
Not aware of
Belmont’s parks,
athletic facilities,
and open spaces
19 8 32 11 27 18 9 4 730 343 817
Other (please
specify)
28 Answered 2744
Skipped 62
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
734
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 261

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
735

APPENDIX I
262 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 5. Other Responses
• Watershed, cross country trails
• destruction of natural area is through WD/HC;
city manages this open space as a bike park
and the bikers treat it like that w/illegal trails
& arrogant behavior (we built this trail, etc)
• sadly not many parks with swings for kids.
• Fox School field often has mole hills
• I am aware oof waterdog
• Sugarloaf
• Cipriani Dog Park users need to be restricted from
running their dogs on the lawn and in the lower
park. Frequently I have seen them also on the lawn
in front of the school and on the school property.

Perhaps put grass or and dog runs in the existing
dog area. Too much dog urination and pooping on
lawn and in the lower park. People let their dogs
run off leash as soon as they get to grass area.

This needs to really be addressed. Thank you.
• Notre Dame is private & ive missed
wandering up to their Chapel
• I do know most of the park in the area
• I live in East Palo Alto
• Waterdog and Hidden Canyon are the
most important and most awesome bike
friendly parks for residents around. They
are the jewel of our biking community.
• We need dedicated bike trails at Cipriana/dog park
• Keep mountain biking in all open spaces.

It is an activity many of us do frequently
as our primary means of exercise.
• love to mountain bike in Waterdog
• WE love Twin Pines, it is close to the
main roads close to Safeway, centrally
located. Parking can be found.
• Education about these parks....
this is the first map i ever saw
• I suggest to prohibit biking in Waterdog trails in the winter or when it’s wet. Tire tracks tear up the trails. • Reference is to problems with biking
in Belmont’s open space. Need to limit
biking or eliminate it entirely.
• Trails beyond Lake road are
dangerous and not safe for kids
• See above. We don’t use Belmont OS.

There are far better options.
• trail markings are confusing and often
missing in the waterdog open space
• san juan and waterdog-please leave it natural as
is, that’s the beauty (especially waterdog, please
stop the political flyers being posted in plastic and
completely duct taped to the gate and signs!)
• Cipriani lower fields are in disrepair. The grass
is never mowed and biting insects attack kids at
practices. Ppl constantly take their dogs off leash
in the grassy park areas where it’s not permitted.
• School fields are riddled with gopher
holes. The mounds and holes are just
asking for twisted in broken ankles.
• Ralston Ranch and Hidden Canyon
Park have been undeveloped for too
long! Would like to have parks there!
• undeveloped hidden canyon park
should be developed into a pump track
or other recreational amenity
• We love the multi-use open space
areas, as they are great for the whole
family (kids, bikes, dogs, etc.)!
• Sheep Camp trail, rate- unsatisfactory
as we appreciate trails where we can
bring our dog and ride our bicycles
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
736
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 263

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 6. WHAT FACTORS LIMIT YOUR USE OF OUR PARKS, ATHLETIC FACILITIES, AND OPEN SPACES? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

PARK ATHLETIC FACILITY OPEN SPACE
Total Resident Total Resident Total Resident Total
Travel distance is too great 201 77 126 65 285 74 426
Walking does not feel safe 77 62 41 32 139 118 177
Biking does not feel safe 153 108 92 69 173 122 245
Public transit is unavailable
or inconvenient
73 47 54 39 116 61 136
Lack of adequate parking 205 124 51 37 354 172 440
Safety concerns
at the location
50 34 20 11 116 89 139
Poor condition/maintenance 163 132 100 72 183 128 315
Does not accommodate
my needs
113 78 99 64 65 39 208
Lack of amenities
that interest me
183 142 173 120 76 55 314
Lack of restrooms 219 164 78 63 314 189 398
I do not have the time 187 101 126 77 225 92 316
Not aware of these facilities 95 50 144 82 53 37 193
Other (please specify) 157
Answered 1575
Skipped 1231
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
737

APPENDIX I
264 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
738
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 265

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 6. Other Responses
• Danger from bikes is my biggest concern and
tend to go to parks where biking is not allowed
• unsafe road access to the parks
- crossing busy streets,
• Tick infestation
• Nothing limits my use of the parks, everything
in Belmont is close enough to ride a bike to.
• Bikes make it dangerous for walkers!
• Bikes not allowed at some open space areas - this
is unfortunate as trails open to bikes get crowded.
• My only limitations is my time out of the office.
• enjoyment of nature is not possible due to bikers;
biking is not compatible with nature hiking which is
why it’s not allowed anywhere else on the Peninsula
• A Belmont shuttle which goes around to various
parks, open space, the library, the train station, and
maybe even to downtown san carlos would be great.
• The roads around the parks should
have more dedicated bike lanes that
are safe for families and kids.
• Lack of benches, particularly for older residents.
• Too many people
• Cyclists and hikers should have separate
trails at Waterdog. Hiking at Waterdog can
be dangerous because of the cyclists
• I avoid on weekend 1. Many no mask bike
riders 2. Disrespectful loud demanding bikers
• I primarily visit the open spaces to ride bikes with
my friends and families. I also visit to walk my dogs.
• Nothing really limits me
• Lack of time is primary reason I
can’t use these facilities
• No factor limit my use. I go to Waterdog often.
• Wild animals scare me having younger kids around.
• Two many bikers on the path, which
make me feel not safe.
• keeping open space open is key
• Poison Oak
• Trail user interaction
• Trails need repair/maintenance (and
widening in some cases). More signage.
• Signage. Visible reminders a park is there.
• Afraid of fast driving bikes that don’t warn you
• Nothing is currently limiting my use
• Water dog: No complaints! Safe, lovely
• Nothing limits my use of the Open Spaces, that is
unless the rules change in regards to bicycles...
• I used to work in RW City, so that
brought me to Waterdog. I live in SJ, so
only visit Waterdog occasionally
• We would like to see more parks/open
spaces with off-leash dog trails.
• Crowded with hikers so I try and go early.
• Nothing limits me from enjoying the spaces.
• If I didn’t work full time, I would utilize the
parks and open space 5-7 days a week
• Waterdog: Small trail system. More of an afterwork
destination. Go elsewhere on weekends.
• The high number of people (but this
is mostly a COVID reason)
• None of the above.
• Biking not permitted or lack of interesting riding trails • None of these apply, i am satisfied with the
level of attention the space preserve gets
• just not enough trails and access for cycling
• I’d be more likely to use the areas athletic
facilities if there was a pool available
• Need more access for dogs
• The lack of respect the hikers have for bikers. I
have been riding waterdog since 1992 when
it was only a handful of trails. Waterdog trails
were built by mountain bikers first. Hiking
is great also but it seems like some of these
hikers are very disrespectful and rude.
• The parks feel like a safe place to be
when you’re a biker or a walker.
• Not having access to biking trails
• We like parks much but Waterdog not safe any more
• Nine
• Hostility toward mountain biking and class 1 ebike
• you have completely skipped the elephant in
the room which is dog friendly parks. There are
extreme limitations on parks that will except dogs
off leash - Cipriani is a barren wasteland but
at least allows off leash when you can tolerate
the burning sun without shelter, Barrett Park is
perfect for those slivers of time when people are
allowed to bring their dogs into the safety of the
fenced in, green space but the times are way
too limited and from what I’ve heard the future
plans are to create a mini Cipriani that’s basically
a dog run and not a park that welcomes dogs.
• I do not make the time to visit these places. It is
all my bad; nothing to do with the infrastructure.
• None
• NO Probems
• danger of mt. biking
• Nothing
• Having enough free time to get to the park :-)
• i got stung by a bee once
• my schedule
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
739

APPENDIX I
266 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• I wish there was a local pool I could swim in
that was outdoors. Due to Covid, none were
available and there haven’t been any updates
about swimming pool availability to residents.

Question 6. Other Responses (con’t)
• Would like to see designated directions on
some trails for bike traffic and alternating use
on weekend days bike only vs hike only. Some
of the parks in Golden, Colorado had bikes
only on even weekend days and hikers only
on odd days, which helped prevent collisions
and allow both types of trail user to utilize the
space safely and to their own ability level.
• Have become very crowded during pandemic.
• None
• Bikes don’t belong in any natural area!
They destroy wildlife habitat!
• None of the above as I use our Parks
and Open Spaces all the time.
• Not inclusive to cyclists - especially with kids.

This is where we go for fun on bikes.
• UNDERDEVELOPED MOUNTAIN BIKE TRAILS
• Large crowds of maskless hikers in waterdog on
single track. Not a lot of space for either group
(hikers/bikers) to get out of each other’s way
• No factors
• I am only interested in mtn biking in the
waterdog hidden canyon area
• COVID
• There are no factors that limit my use of the
parks/athletic facilities/open spaces.
• Nothing limits my use of them really
• Happily use spaces when I have time
• Poison oak!
• Nothing
• Bikes are disallowed on most trails.
• Ticks, poison oak and heat in summer
• No limitations
• I very much enjoy the parks, especially
mountain biking with my niece and nephew
around Water Dog Open Space.
• Poison oak in water dog
• Why are all your choices asked in a negative tone?
• I feel like parks and open space is close,
accessible and has adequate facilities for me.
• I have many parks and open spaces
that are closer to my home, however
waterdog, I will make a special trip to.
• Please keep mountain biking at Waterdog Park
• Too many Mountain Bikes. I am extremely
concerned about the increasing amounts
of e-bikes destroying the trails
• Nothing limits my use
• not limited at all
• None apply - not limited
• I have no issue with getting to Belmont’s open
spaces as I live between them and access is easy
• i don’t live in belmont so i ride down
from sf to waterdog to ride.
• None, I go to water dog lake park
and other parks close by, daily
• I come to Waterdog for the singletrack mountain
bike trails (I haven’t visited the other parks)
• None apply.
• Weather conditions
• We Love wATER dOG pARK ...we hike and bike it
... love the trails and our dog Karma does as well :)
• public pool
• I have gone on my own and with a friend
to take a walk and we always feel safe
and enjoy our time outdoors.
• softball field at BSC is really undermaintained compared to the baseball field • We need more tennis court.
• Granting reservations to sports teams during
days & time appropriate for seniors without
authorization and notice to immediate residents.
• I would love to see more safe biking areas available
for younger children, particularly in the open spaces.
• Nothing. I am pleased with this great
resource of me and my family.
• Dogs not allowed in many places. No
public restrooms at school fields.
• do not feel I have any limitations
• Dangerous mountain bikers
• More than anything the open space at
Hidden Canyon has been ruined by
biking. This is a serious issue.
• Tennis courts ar Hallamark park are woefully
need resurfacing and the fencing repaired.
• Congestion on Ralston near El Camino
and near Notre Dame can be a huge
deterrent depending on time of day
• Pets not allowed
• Off-leash dogs and dog poop in
parks and school fields
• I enjoy the ooen space and do not feel limited
• I’ve not been going to Water Dog Lake and some
of the other trails because there have been
so many people there during the pandemic
• Don’t feel limited in use!
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
740
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 267

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• Poison ivy/oak
• Restrooms there but ICK or inoperable
• No limitations! I love our parks open for all activities, even those that I do not do such as biking
• The open spaces are wonderful for biking
• At times walking is scary becuz of
mountain bikes on same paths.
• N/A for all
• baseball field availability
Question 6. Other Responses (con’t)
• COVID quarantine
• I would walk the single paths below Hallmark
but the bike riders go very fast and speed
by me with little warning so I’ve given up
walking those beautiful single paths.
• Inadequate playgrounds
• El Camino does not even have pedestrian
for the most part, some parts where there is
pedestrian, they are not walking friendly at all
• Mountain bikers make me afraid to hike the canyon
trails. Maybe limit bikers to three days a week.
• I feel there are no limitations.
• my children are grown
• I would love to learn amount more parks
for my kids that I don’t know of, yet.
• Habits.
• I don’t feel limited in my use of any spaces
• getting anywhere is not a problem
• As a person living with Crohn’s Disease, I
can’t go too far anywhere without knowing
for sure that there will be restrooms AND
THAT THEY WILL BE UNLOCKED. Reliable
restroom hours would be greatly appreciated.
• I’m looking for equestrian access
• Athletic facilities: unaware of how to
schedule/reserve time for use
• Many of the Belmont school fields are in very poor
shape (safety issues for those playing baseball/
soccer there). Not enough easy access picnic
tables or garbage cans in our parks. Restrooms
were not always supplied or open (pre-covid).
• No factors limit my families use
of parks and open space
• I am responding on behalf of Serendipity School
- otherwise I do not use Belmont facilities
• Too crowded during COVID with some
people not wearing masks
• N/A
• People biking too fast and too close scare me
as I walk Waterdog (southwest of the lake, near
hidden canyon and San Carlos). Please don’t
allow electric bikes: it’s scary enough as is...
• Can’t bring my dog
• Mountain bikers in Open Space areas
• Playgrounds are very limited; would
love a Magical Bridge style park
• No factors limit my use of parks. Dog
poo all over waterdog open space is
annoying but it does not limit my use
• not all have options for off-leash dogs
• N/A
• E-bikes cruising fast
• often crowded since Spring 2020.
• there are no factors limiting my use
of any of the facilities i visit
• Too busy; overdeveloped; no hiking
• no factors limit my use
• Too crowded from visitors driving to
venue instead of staying within walking
distance of their own locations.
• Nothing limits my use of our parks,
open space or athletic fields.
• Mountain biking in Waterdog has been getting
pushed out of that area. As a resident I have
regularly worked and maintained these trails.

Most hiker and other people interaction have been
positive, however some have had a position that
bike riding doesn’t belong in waterdog. This is not
what I want my open spaces to turn into. We need
to find a way that we can all enjoy the open space.

If that means we make biking trails and hiking trails.
• Too many hikers to bike safely.
• Over zealous hikers stopping bikers
and spreading misinformation
• Alexander Park tennis courts need refinishing.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
741

APPENDIX I
268 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 7. THE FOLLOWING AMENITIES OR USES WOULD GREATLY ENHANCE MY EXPERIENCE WITH PARKS IN BELMONT.

STRONGLY

AGREE AGREE DISAGREE

STRONGLY

DISAGREE NO OPINION
Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Access to WiFi 137 101 231 154 438 220 576 263 535 237 1917 Add more
restrooms
308 197 994 497 230 117 65 33 469 199 2066
Add more
benches and
places to sit
218 162 826 472 272 134 64 25 606 231 1986
Add more shade 209 159 635 388 305 146 79 35 700 273 1928 Opportunities
to purchase
food or drinks
58 44 239 156 497 258 537 266 568 253 1899
Outdoor
exercise stations
113 79 519 304 395 215 204 106 679 282 1910
Add More
multi-use paths
in parks
716 307 799 422 135 80 89 56 362 176 2101
Add more
organized
sports fields
127 94 350 228 323 184 149 81 893 362 1842
Spray (water)
pad
137 104 356 237 269 137 174 93 924 391 1860
Add more
quiet areas for
connection
to nature and
relaxation
268 182 587 366 259 123 116 55 674 272 1904
An all-ability
playground
203 140 463 287 173 98 91 47 897 377 1827
Skate park 383 170 520 291 183 107 188 134 661 294 1935 Bike pump track 1156 393 520 238 124 95 145 118 369 239 2314 Archery 190 102 433 220 264 156 215 146 795 351 1897
Add more tennis/
pickleball courts
227 157 498 327 253 129 131 71 789 305 1898
Add more
basketball courts
123 85 419 259 265 156 141 79 888 378 1836
Volleyball courts 108 69 376 228 259 146 128 77 949 420 1820 Lacrosse fields 39 20 155 87 329 202 206 122 1062 492 1791 Public art
displays
216 137 634 364 210 110 125 75 687 292 1872
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
742
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 269

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS

STRONGLY

AGREE AGREE DISAGREE

STRONGLY

DISAGREE NO OPINION
Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Maintain and
enhance tree
canopy
537 326 909 480 71 38 40 20 430 166 1987
Aquatics 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
Teen space 175 119 520 321 166 91 95 53 869 370 1825
Add more
picnic areas
175 129 705 417 205 114 64 38 729 284 1878
Add more
reservable group
picnic areas
99 75 366 228 325 185 132 72 889 384 1811
Add more
community
gardens
256 174 610 340 188 108 66 36 753 317 1873
Add more trees 440 251 749 386 123 84 40 24 563 241 1915 Add more rental
facilities for
receptions/
special events
74 57 264 170 335 174 171 92 959 443 1803
Add wind breaks 130 100 393 263 266 125 102 53 932 402 1823 Aquatics 331 259 395 250 178 86 112 62 858 321 1874
Other (please
specify)
165
Answered 2609
Skipped 197
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
743

APPENDIX I
270 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
744
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 271

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 7. Other Responses
• Fewer Multi-use trails in Waterdog
and more hiking only.
• Develop trail system behind Twin Pines
Park; develop grass surface dog park
like Skyline Park in Burlingame
• More bike trails
• Nothing, leave them as is.
• More dog parks
• no wonder your theme is “build” your backyard ==
we need to UNbuild the open space; reduce trails;
keep bikes on fire roads only (it’s the standard)
• Need public pool
• Need a community lap pool
• community pool is needed
• More bike trails! Please!
• ice rink!!
• Ice rink for hockey
• Add more off-pavement bike trails
• More Mountain bike trails (fast
growing sport in the USA)
• Add more garbage cans
• Large grassy dog park areas!!!!
• Dedicated mountain biking trails
• Bike-only trails - this is safer for
everyone and would be unique
• Add more or even a mountain bike only trails
• build more legal mtb trails or even mtb only trails
• more bike trails
• better condition for athletic fields
• Mountain biking trails
• Build new mountain bike trails
• more bike trails
• Link bike paths
• Mountain bike trails
• Ice rink baby!
• Mountain bike opportunities
• trail maintenance in Waterdog to aid trail
usage, better maps and trail signs
• create bike only trails!
• trails for dogs, educate park users about
what you can expect from dog owners
(voice command, no jumping)
• More Mountain bike trails
• Mountain bike specific trails would be nice,
or at least trails where hikers would expect
to encounter mountain bikers and not be
startled or vocally complain about someone
going by slowly at a reasonable distance.
• Ensure mountain biking opportunities
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
745

APPENDIX I
272 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 7. Other Responses (con’t)
• Off leash dog areas
• recommend we remove not native
trees that obstruct the view
• After school programs for schools/ field trips/Art
centers/music/large fish ponds like Central Park
• Dog waste bags and bins at San Juan Canyon.
• More places to bike without fear of car obliteration. • Add More places to mountain bike
• please consider adding a community pool as
temps have risen so much over the years.
• hazardous fuel reduction is necessary.
• More multi use trails in the open space
• bike trails and bike lanes to and from
• More mountain biking access
• I am happy as they are
• A large space for RC hobbyists.
• Drinking Water
• When adding new facilities, please considerate
not to put neighborhood residents in
stress. There are too many bikers vehicles
nowadays concentrate in some areas.
• Keep mountain biking options at waterdog
• More paths to run
• Please leave nature alone!
• Install more mats for the playground
structure instead of wood chips
• Twin Pines has been ruined by both the South
Rd unnecessary bike path & removal of trees
• More bike friendly and bike specific trails!
• More biking trails
• I can’t answer most of these without knowing
what location you are talking about!
• Mountain Bike Trail (Including Class 1 E-Bike)
• DOG FRIeNDLY!!!!!!
• Add more dog poop bags
• Maintain mountain bike access.
• Belmont 100% needs a skatepark
• Bike parks have been an amazing addition to
family use of facilities in communities where
they have been added. Top of my list.
• Calisthenics stations/equipment: pull up bars, dips
• Mountain bike trails
• Maintain Mountain Biking Access
• More mountain bike only trails (technical
single track) give us our own trails
• More mountain bike access
• Disc Golf course pretty please
• specific biking and hiking trails. some
trails are very steep to walk on
• Disc Golf
• Mountain bike trails
• Ice Skating
• Stop Getting rid of and adulterating our biking
trails!! We have so little left to ride and this is the HOME of mountainbiking, and we drive it away!!
• More dedicated mountain bike trails!!
• Don’t allow bicycles in any natural area;
restrict them to paved roads.
• More mountain bike trails
• Add more Mountain Bike Specfic Trails to Waterdog.
• Expand Mountain biking trails
• More Mountain Biking space.
• A public pool would be nice
• Separate user groups on multi use trails in
water dog - build more single user group
trails for both groups, plant more trees
• Access for bikes in OSP
• Preserve and expand mountain bike trail networks
• Open spaces are excellent as is
• Off leash, fenced dog park area. Open all day.

Within walking distance of all our apartment
complexes with no lawns (western hills)
• Keep mountain biking in all open spaces.

It is an activity many of us do frequently
as our primary means of exercise.
• ice rink
• add more single tracks for mountain biking
• Mountain biking!
• Kid climbing walls
• I am very interested in new trails
open to mountain bikes.
• Allow for more mountain bike
enhancements to make the trails safer
and more accessible to all users.
• Continue allowing mountain biking
• Maintain waterfog access w Bikes
• More single track for hiking and mountain biking
• More mountain bike loops if there is
space at parks other than Waterdog
• outdoor music venues
• Often we have had to bring in more portable
tables and chairs to the Redwood Grove
to include all of our attending group.
• Pickleball badly needed!
• Aquatic is strongly needed!!!
• limit high-speed bike traffic and large
groups of cyclists; protect trails from erosion
and make bridges more foot-friendly
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
746
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 273

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 7. Other Responses (con’t)
• With Regard to Open spaces ( Waterdog): For
the safety of all users more signage at strategic
locations would be helpful to warn people
to pay more attention. There are exposed
areas and possible dangers and accidents
that can be prevented with signage.
• I vote for a bike track to separate the
bikes from the hikers at Waterdog.
• Access to atheletic parks for ad
hoc play (versus teams)
• Radically limit biking in Hidden
Canyon and Waterdog Lake
• Indoor basketball courts would be great, either
for walk-in use, rental, or league play.
• maintain mountain biking access
• More places to ride bikes
• belmont has few sidewalks in the hills;
we are worried about the kids biking on
the street without a designated lane
• Avoid costly and high-maintenance sporting
facilities that are not used by a majority of public
• Belmont need a public pool for lane swimming
• Off-leash dog areas
• Please replace trees on properties that
the city removes to update sidewalks and
streets. We lost 5 oak trees on Ralston and
we’re told to replace them ourselves after
you cut them down. Very unexceptable!!
• It’s not a matter of more, it’s a matter
of improving what we have!
• Waterdog and San Juan Canyon are fantastic as is.
• pickleball courts
• Safe and official access to Belmont
Creek in Twin Pines Park
• space for dogs offleash
• Mostly “no opinion” here because I think
the spaces are already really great.
• baseball fields for open use (beyond little league)
should be open to all and reservable for all
• I’d be interested in indoor aquatics, but it’s too
windy and cool for outdoor water activities.
• Please allow only walkers to use the single paths
in Waterdog and Hidden Canyon and NOT ALLOW
bikers to use those single paths.. People with
disabilities such as hearing, walking and even
having children should be limited to WALKERS.
• Costly to maintain
• Skating rink
• Ice rink
• Bike dirt jumps park, like one in Fosters
city by shell beach that was recently
closed, would’ve be awesome!
• Burton Park in San Carlos would
be a strong guideline
• Unique nature based play areas. Like
the wood stumps in twin pines.
• Parking for Waterdog
• Aquatics top priority
• For me, things seem ok as they are.
• Off leash dog areas
• Dog park with grass instead of dirt
• bocce ball court
• Upgrade the play structures in Twin Pines Park.
• A skate park, pump track and all abilities
playground would be amazing! I want my middle
schooler and his friends to have more outdoor
activity options that they can easily travel to.
• more trash receptacles would benefit each place
• Add more bike trails
• Public swimming pool is sorely needed. We
live in a cool location, so balance lovely shade
trees with our need for winter sun. Also,
Bocce courts should be a survey option!!!
• equestrian access
• more open space bike access
• More mountain bike trails.
• Upgrade Mcdougal softball fields
• bocce ball courts (belmont has
promised these for years)
• pump track and/or skate park
would be a great addition
• Repair/replace broken areas: swing hinges
at Twin Pines, Dry rockbed at davey glen
• Frisbee Golf
• I would like to have a town swimming pool
• My family drives to other local towns for skate
parks and pump tracks. Would be great to
have them here in Belmont. Plus, we could do
with more dog parks in Belmont. The closest
one to us is Laurie Meadows (San Mateo).
• Community pool please
• Add more dog parks/off leash areas
• safe dedicated (not shared) bike trails
• Dog park areas - and ones that are open
all day, year-round, with room to run
• Dedicated biking and walking trails
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
747

APPENDIX I
274 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 7. Other Responses (con’t)
• More shade is needed in the dog park--not
in the Open Space unless replacing dead
trees, or whatever the natural setting was.

A bike pump track is acceptable outside of
open space areas or Twin Pines Park.
• don’t want city pool.. continued availability
of carlmont pool is sufficient. since roads in
belmont are not great for kids to bike, need
more opportunities for them to bike.
• I think we should keep bikes at waterdog
• Continue allowing mountain bikers to use
Waterdog and Hidden Canyon- Strongly Agree
• Please enchance existing Mountain bike trails
and keep Ebikes and motorized bikes out
• More dog friendly spaces!
• Having some mountain bike only single track at
Waterdog and hidden canyon would be great
• A pump track must happen for Belmont. This will
support out youths and give them a place to grow
and realize that the community supports them.
• Bike only trails
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
748
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 275

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 8. THE FOLLOWING AMENITIES OR USES WOULD GREATLY ENHANCE MY EXPERIENCE WITH OPEN SPACE IN BELMONT.

STRONGLY

AGREE AGREE DISAGREE

STRONGLY

DISAGREE NO OPINION
Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Add interpretive
signage
wayfinding
signage (route
maps)
0 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
Add seating or
view areas
0 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 2
Reduce/limit
number of trails
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Expand parking
areas at trail
heads
0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2
Repair and
maintain
existing trails
1450 635 998 503 62 26 17 7 73 44 2600
Widen and
improve select
existing trails
582 300 696 373 523 214 337 125 266 134 2404
Reduce/limit
number of trails
70 56 65 49 572 316 1473 563 169 121 2349
Designate
certain trails for
certain uses
292 185 505 287 507 210 949 357 186 114 2439
Add additional
trails
1210 413 789 402 166 111 78 63 220 156 2463
Add security
patrol, call
boxes and/or
trailhead lighting
185 129 562 310 479 217 268 115 708 298 2202
Add ADA
compliant
features
142 88 468 236 309 160 215 100 994 448 2128
Prioritize habitat
protection
337 236 608 313 431 173 308 132 526 220 2210
Establish
use policies
(electric bikes,
trail speeds,
designated use
hours, etc.)
329 243 590 301 524 200 723 280 238 120 2404
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
749

APPENDIX I
276 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS

STRONGLY

AGREE AGREE DISAGREE

STRONGLY

DISAGREE NO OPINION
Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Add bike repair
stations
1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
Add more dog
waste stations
420 232 1121 541 162 72 71 38 489 216 2263
Expand parking
areas at trail
heads
316 180 868 388 387 195 158 87 520 226 2249
Add permanent
restrooms
347 200 997 478 272 135 119 69 510 207 2245
Add drinking
fountains
298 172 930 423 307 176 114 60 548 230 2197
Add exercise
stations
82 60 364 204 500 247 314 179 843 337 2103
Add bike repair
stations
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Add seating or
view areas
188 133 770 442 284 125 132 67 754 280 2128
Host guided
walks
89 66 337 214 413 217 288 137 952 392 2079
Add interpretive
signage
wayfinding
signage (route
maps)
294 192 940 482 210 100 108 50 592 222 2144
Add more
signage for
trail safety
and etiquette
460 237 1038 473 226 119 102 57 442 198 2268
Host classes
(e.g., yoga, plein
air painting,
junior rangers)
122 98 396 250 344 175 231 118 990 390 2083
Other (please
specify)
188
Answered 2709
Skipped 97
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
750
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 277

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
751

APPENDIX I
278 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses
• Electric bike should be banned. They
are mini motorcycles in disguise.
• I oppose closing waterdog to e-bikes
• The “use policies” question is too broad. I’d say no
to ebikes, but I’d be against trail speeds (because
what’s fast on one trail is slow on another) and
no to use hours, unless that’s to ADD access
• There are plenty of hiker specific trails all over
the Bay Area. MTB specific trails are needed!
• I hike and mountain bike and enjoy
using the trails for both activities
• Over use by so many cars parked
at Lake Road/Hallmark Drive
• Add an off leash dog trail or area.
• manage WD as an open space not as a sports
facility; people need to get back to nature; a place
to be quiet, enjoy the bird calls, be present
• Plant more trees if possible
• I’m happy with our multi use trails - I love
the mountain bike use, maybe restrictions
on especially bike use after heavy rains
tho? to prevent erosion? Plus not keen on
e-bikes, unless maybe for ADA use?
• Need public pool
• I would like to see some additional trails added
to create nicer loops that my kids can ride on
without doing the steepest climbs. We should
do native plant restoration on the sides of some
of the wider trails and make them narrower.
• Please don’t limit mountain bike access.

Make bells on bikes mandatory to
encourage friendly trail sharing,
• For safety dog lease law enforcement,
poison oak removal.
• Ban mountain bikes from narrow trails. This
is an accident waiting to happen. Many times
I have almost collided with a mountain biker.

It is frightening and ruins the experience
of enjoying Belmont’s open space.
• Keep trails open to bikes
• mountain biking needs to be preserved in
open space. It is all teens have to do here.
• More bike events!!!
• I am a huge advocate for directional mixed
multi use trails. The new Cotoni Coast
Dairy Project is a leader in this area.
• Please protect mountain bike trails
• More Mountain bike trails (fast
growing sport in the USA)
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
752
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 279

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses (con’t)
• More people are moving to bicycles to reduce
traffic and pollution. So we see more bike riders
in the open spaces. Please encourage this.
• Use policies are already established at trailheads
and while habitat does need to be protected, it
should also be enjoyed by everyone. Would love to
see more mountain-bike trails at Water Dog Park.

This place has wonderful single-tracks for biking!
• Mountain biking originated in the Bay Area
- please support it. Waterdog is unique and
special for bikes - please keep it open.
• Having lived in multiple places around the country,
parks which expand user trails but limit use to
one method (bike only, hiker only, etc.) have
more sustainable and enjoyable open areas. This
allows more targeted maintenance to address
use-specific issues and reduces unfavorable
interactions between users. Infrastructure can
also be targeted more efficiently to reduce cost.
• Keeping all trals open to mountain biking
• Maintain bike access
• More space for mountain biking would be excellent
• Do not limit use, ie. stop biking in Water Dog Park.

Instead engage the bikers in helping with trail
maintenance and education about trail etiquette.
• Dog stations so those people who pickup
pet waste and leave it on the side of a
trail for other users to step in...
• More mountain biking trails
• Please keep Waterdog Park open to mountain
biking. It is a staple park for our local mtb
community. The mountain biking community has
also done a lot for the park with respect to trail
upkeep and maintenance. It it one of the most
engaging and fun parks in the area for this activity.
• continue to allow all mountain bikes
• allow bikes
• GGNRA type signs: horses have
priority over hikers over bikers
• Please add bike specific/only trails
with technical trail features
• allow more biking
• Please keep mountain biking allowed in Waterdog!
• I love mountain biking at Waterdog.

Beautiful trails and friendly people.
• Improve and add trails ( not necessarily
widen) trails for mountain biking and
hiking. Single Tracks are great.
• Signage on trails for directions and navigation
• Directional trails
• Allow mountain biking. Single direction
trails or alternative days for bikes only.
• bike only trail!
• Maintain access to non electric bikes
• Mountain-bike specific trails - at least as
many as hiker-only, and built specifically
to be enjoyed by bike! (bermed turns,
optional technical sections, etc.)
• Please do not attempt to segregate bikes from
pedestrians, etiquette signage is more appropriate
• I very much like the multi-use aspect, with especially hikers and bikers interplay. The “tensions” are
over-reported. Both as a hiker (with family) and as
a biker, I almost always have positive interactions.
• Allow mountain bikes
• Increase mountain biking trails &
promote user awareness.
• I feel strongly that we should continue
to allow multi-use of open space trails
including biking and dog walking.
• More mountain bike trails
• Protect mountain bike access to Waterdog
park. Use restrictions advocated by a vocal
minority does not represent the community.
• off leash dog areas like at Pulgas Trails
• More acces for people on bikes in open spaces
and larger parks. Host guided bike rides.
• Allow safe mixed use of trails and do not
prioritize one group over another.
• please consider adding a community pool as
temps have risen so much over the years.
• Guided bike ride
• Ask hikers, joggers, and walkers not to
wear headphones in both ears, as it’s
dangerous on a multi-use trail.
• add more mountain biking trails
• Dog walkers are not always respectful leaving
their waste bag behind on trail. Also, it’s disgusting
that they are allowed in parks where people picnic
and play on the lawn. Especially for children.

Restrict dog access in family picnic/play areas.
• ADD MMANY MORE OFF LEASH DOG SITES!!
• Please keep Water Dog Lake Park as
it is and open for mountain biking
• Keep water dog open to bikes!
• prioritize multi use trails, specifically for mountain bikers who are often under represented. Limit
electric bike use to wide lanes and fire roads.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
753

APPENDIX I
280 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses (con’t)
• Biking has gotten out of hand. My use of parks
during covid has increased & im there for r&r,
not an EXTREME experience. Signage + bike
patrols issuing citations for everyone coming
into town (we are a destination) would help
• Bike access to more trails and parks
• no bikes on nature trails. bikes need to slow down.
• Mt bike access for 90% of trails.
• Keep mountain biking in Waterdog
• Add more Mountain Bike Trail
(Including Class 1 E-Bike)
• Although I am a hiker, the bikers created the
Waterdog trail system and have maintained many
of the trails. Electric bikes are not destroying
trails (they are electric assist just helping with
the hills). They do not tear up trails. Designate
one way trails (narrow too) for bikes as well as
hikers. Don’t limit bikes to wide trails (in general
without the features they like). I have lived here
for 35 years so I have watched the trails behind
my house grow. Please also reclaim trails where
people have moved fencing down and over the
trail (into open space). This is especially true
in the Belmont Heights area. Thank you.
• Please make every attempt to keep the open
space parks undeveloped and do habitat
restoration of native plants. Walking only,
please NO BIKES!! They are a threat to
hikers and destroy trails and habitat
• Please build a skatepark
• If ‘designate trails for certain uses’ means
‘designate the trails maintained by the mountain
bike community as mountain bike primary, others
welcome’, that is ok. If ‘hikers only’, that is not OK. • DOG FrIENDLY
• Please keep mountain biking access in
Waterfog. It is perfect just as it is!
• Keep water dog as a bike friendly park. There
are plenty of parks that are hiking only.
• None of the above as offerings are more than
adequate. People take care of needs.
• Additional trail access for bicycles
• thank you for allowing mountain bikes, one
thing I’ve seen work really well near my
parents in MI is one directional trails - so
hikers travel clockwise bikes travel counterclockwise. This greatly mitigates trail conflicts & works really well on loop trails
• Alternating use periods for cyclists/mountain
bikes should be implemented to better serve
both hikers and cyclists, this would alleviate
the concerns that both groups have in running
into the other at high speeds, and help control
erosion. For example odd days are cyclist
allowed, even days are closed to cyclist.
• Establish more trails for cycling and hiking!
• Increase capacity for safe mountain biking,
and better educating the locals about
trail etiquette and maintaining a healthy
relationship with hikers. One must be aware
of the others existence and respect it.
• E-bikes should be banned from trails.
• Keep the trails open to everyone.
• maintain or expand bike access to
trails. Consider means to improve the trail
experience for all types of trail users
• Keep Water dog and Hidden Canyon Bike
friendly! It’s the best place. I love it so much.
• Strongly support mountain biking at Water Dog.

This has been a wonderful activity for my family
for years in a super safe and beautiful setting.

IF we lost this there would be nowhere to go..
• All mountain biking and electric bikes
• More signage for trail safety is a great idea. I
understand some people are uncomfortable
with mountain bikes on the trails, but feel this
is purely an education issue. I’m a mountain
biker and am probably the most courteous
person on the trails--everyone could be so.
• Off Road/Mt Biking Trails
• You may want to add mountain bike specific
downhill trails that aren’t used for hiking, but
don’t limit mountain bikes otherwise.
• Stop Ruining bike trails!!!!!! Not everything
needs to be an ADA compliant road.

Some people accept that fact.
• Add two trail systems, one for hikers
and one for mountain bikers. (Mountain
biking trails can be dual use.)
• Cipriani/Dog park are world famously known
for the mountain biking trails, please add more
it will enhance the Belmont economy !
• More mountain bike trails!!!
• Waterdog would benefit from seperating Hiking and
Mountain biking on some of the narrower trails.
• more bike trails
• It is important to me that access remain
available for all open space users including
hikers, joggers, bikers, and dog owners.
• more mountain biking trails, please! (there is
already a huge shortage in the bay area)
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
754
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 281

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain biking is a key recreational activity
for healthy exercise and should continue
to thrive and expand in Water Dog.
• Ban e-bikes and actually enforce it
• leave the open space as natural as possible.
• Open spaces are excellent as is
• Keep mountain biking legal at water dog!
It’s a great park and an awesome resource
for people getting into the sport!
• Create more bike and ebike trails
• Please allow biking but limit electric bike.
• Add more MTB trails
• Keep Waterdog open for Hikers
and Mountain Bikers
• Keep mountain biking in all open spaces.

It is an activity many of us do frequently
as our primary means of exercise.
• keep trails as they are for mountain biking
• Please keep Water Dog open to all
users including Mountain Biking!
• Keep open space free and unregulated.
• Add more bicycle trails - single
or multi use for bicycles
• more mountain biking trial access
• Areas for bicycling with kids and friends
especially mountain but road also
• Mountain biking skills and trail etiquette
• I feel strongly that trails should remain multiuse. Adding at least one long circuit that is dog-friendly for urban hiking. Such as
making the Sheep camp trails open to dogs
so hikers can get over to Canada Rd.
• Keep mountain biking on trails
• I am a mountain biker, BUT Mountain Bike/ebikes utilization needs to be either eliminated or drastically policed. It is out of control!
• Belmont’s embracing of Mountain biking is
very special and is a great way to get the youth
invested in protecting and enjoying nature.
• ‘designate uses’ might be ‘designate
direction’ for things like finch which gets
narrow but is fun in bother directions.
• Better control of loose dogs.
• Allow multi-use including mountain biking on trails.
• Since our preferred Redwood Grove at Twin
Pines is so far from the parking lot...it would
help the “aging Committee members” if a
road could allow ‘some cars’ closer parking to
unload/load the equipment for our big event.
• limit high-speed bike traffic and large groups of bikes • As previously mentioned more signage would
be helpful; in particular, a good example is the
“three witches”, three consecutive hills. Here
there, is traffic coming up and down ( bikers
and hikers) and there is some exposure adding
to the safety concern. So, signage at the base
as well as the top of this section would remind
users to pay attention and exercise safety.
• More bike lanes on Belmont roadways
• Keeping the poison oak in check is key to enjoying
the open space. The trail crew has been doing
a good job at it for my last several visits.
• I suggest to prohibit biking in Waterdog trails in the winter or when it’s wet. Tire tracks tear up the trails. • Most important would be to severely limit
biking in hidden canyon and waterdog and
other places inappropriate to biking
• More mountain bike only trails
• please maintain mountain bike
access to waterdog park
• It is great to have access to great
mountain biking trails at waterdog,
please don’t get rid of mtb access!
• More bike access
• I believe establishing use policies are important,
but as presented in the examples it seems this
is targeted the exclusion of bicycling activities
• We go to open space to see nature, animals,
flowers, plants. Do NOT bring in distractions
from nature or encouage more dogs. Nature
education-docent led walks would be great.
• More bike paths / trails at parks and open
spaces as well as connect them to non-park
infrastructure (e.g., multiuse paths on the way
to parks and open space to safely bike there).
• We need limits on biking. My dog got hit
the other day by a mountain biker.
• This section sounds specifically geared towards
improvements at the Water Dog Lake / Hidden
Canyon Open Space. Unfortunately, COVID-19
has increased the use of this area significantly and
people are making demands for improvements.

This space is a jewel in the rough but let’s not
polish it to a luster - therein lies the beauty
of this wonderful resource. It is by no means
a pristine habitat ecologically but let’s make
an effort to not gussy it all up and disturb the
wildlife that call it their home and make it an
overly attractive destination that draws people
from all around the bay area. BTW - the new
signage is very nice so kudos there!Thanks!
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
755

APPENDIX I
282 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses (con’t)
• Again, I think the conditions & services are already
really great - no improvements needed IMO.
• Add trash containers for dog waste or other trash
• Ban E-bikes in open space areas. Enforce
park hours - no use after sunset.
• Remove invasive plants like ivy and oxalis
that climb over existing native trees. Take out
eucalyptus and replace with safer choices.
• Limit mountain bikers to three days a week.
• Weed control e.g. safely with goats
• enhance the wi-fi access so cell phones work
• Please don’t restrict dogs from trails,
like Sawyer Camp Trail does.
• multi use paths very hard for pedestrians
- I feel like I’m always about to get run
over. Also masking restrictions are not
consistent and people dont’ follow them.
• Particularly in open space, trail maintenance is
essential. While the efforts by certain groups
(biking) are very helpful, there are large areas of
trail where vertical trails have allowed water runoff
to severely rut the trail. I am all for volunteer efforts, and do want to participate myself, but some areas of
the trail esp at water dog need to be re engineered,
preferably with some professional advice
• Please do not restrict use to only walkers. That
would be a terrible loss to our children who
love to bike where they are safe from cars.
• Add more bike trails
• Guided walks are a great way to introduce
the public to lesser known open spaces—
learn to appreciate what we have
• Horse trails
• More open space for bikes
• Like the new trail signage in WD Open Space
• consider use hours / directions for multimodes - walkers and cycling • How has NorCal missed the memo on the
importance of posting trail operation and etiquette
signage - people can’t know what they don’t
know - THIS BEFORE ALL ELSE PLS!
• multi-use trails have been successful for
many years and should be kept that way
• “Exploration spaces” for kids would be great
- kid-oriented trails with lots to learn about
• It would be nice to keep our open space open
and available to all. I do not believe that all or
most open space trails should be required to be
ADA compliant. We DO need some trails that
are accessible (in open space, recreational, and/
or parks) but not every trail, everywhere.
• The open space is a beautiful multi-use open space
trail system, that should in my opinion continue to
be multi-use for the entire community of hikers,
bikers, dog walkers, and nature lovers. Of course
we want to simultaneously protect habitat, but
please note that our open space is designated as
recreational open space. it is not a nature preserve
and was intended for people to use it responsibly.
• Would love an off leash pet area in
one of the open spaces!!!
• Please leave open space trails narrow and
primitive. Narrow the wide trails to 2-3 feet
when possible. This gives a more intimate
and close experience with nature.
• All access for respectful mountain biking
• Stop e-bike use, limit number of bikes and their
speed so I don’t have to walk scared all the time
• Limit and enforce mountain bikes to selected trails
• I believe we should improve & add agenda
specific (including hiking, dog walking...) trails
but not widen existing. The current landscape
of many of the trails are too restrictive in
grade to reach a large population of hikers.
• Enforce lease law for dogs. Half of the dogs
are off lease in Water Dog Lake Open Space
• How about enforce existing policies - no motorized
vhicles, dogs on leash, pick up dog waste (curious
dogs not mentioned in “policies” above)
• There are existing policies, so education
around them is important. I wouldn’t want
to create additional restrictions.
• No E-bikes
• Trails are well maintained currently by an active
group of volunteers(and perhaps others).
• bike speed limits are more appropriate than
limiting ebikes.. it isn’t the bike that speeds,
it is the person riding it.. i ride a class 3 bike
and i turn off the motor on mulit use trails.. as
i get passed by cyclists on road bikes. i have
one of those too.. i keep my speed down.
• Designate uphill/downhill designated trails when
they are particularly steep/narrow/winding.
• Stop the gradual widening of narrow (singletrack)
trails and the safety risk to hikers by either
restricting their use to hikers only, as done in other
open space/parks in the peninsula region, or, as
a last resort, by adding regularly spaced stepout spots for hikers to allow bikes to safely pass, along with signs showing what is expected.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
756
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 283

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 8. Other Responses (con’t)
• Open spaces should be “open” to everyone.

Limiting their use - e.g. telling bikers they
can only ride on certain trails at certain times
is unfair. And I’m a hiker, not a biker.
• Prohibit bikes on narrow single track trails. Prohibit new trails made by bikers! Security patrol so
rules are followed would be good but no lighting.
• Eliminate bikes from single track trails. Have
monitors on trails to enforce rules. Currently
night riders are on trails after sunset.
• More off leash dog accessible trails
• 1. More dog friendly and off leash spaces. 2.

Please clean up Patricia Wharton Park. Much of
the year, it has dead plants and lots of weeds!
• Take out informal bike paths and clean up
trails, add trail signage, elminate water pollution
from bad maintenance activities by city
• No night bike riding on open space trails please.

Homes feel very exposed when people are on
the trails at night. We are supposed to because
at sunset and we need signage that states that.
• Bike riding in Waterdog needs to be prioritized
with the number of youths that ride there,
and people that use the area (precovid) it
has been primarily mountain bike riders, now
we have in influx of people here we need to
accommodate for all users by creating more bike
specifications trails to unclog the congestion.
• The section pertaining to usage guidelines
seems biased towards limiting bicycles, while
there are as many, if not more disobedient
hikers in open spaces. A mutually beneficial
approach here would be preferred.
• To improve the multi-use nature of the open
space, designated usage days could be an
option’ ‘Beginner Bike Saturdays’ (Promote bike
use, restrict hikers), ‘Strolling Sundays’ (promote
hiking, restrict bike use), ‘Mellow Mondays’ (restrict
all usage to allow the nature to recuperate).
• would designate Waterdog as cycling-focused
park and Edgewood/others as hiking-focused
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
757

APPENDIX I
284 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 9. THE FOLLOWING PROGRAMS OR ACTIVITIES WOULD GREATLY ENHANCE MY EXPERIENCE WITH OUTDOOR RECREATION PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES IN BELMONT.

STRONGLY

AGREE AGREE DISAGREE

STRONGLY

DISAGREE NO OPINION
Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total Res. Total More small
events
102 80 451 294 254 137 105 52 1133 466 2045
More large
events
67 52 228 157 408 224 242 123 1074 459 2019
More family
events (nature
walks, movie
nights)
206 157 668 414 192 98 88 40 915 351 2069
More adult
enrichment
programs (plein
air painting,
lectures)
101 76 433 308 252 130 109 51 1121 464 2016
More programs
for youth
(sports camp,
nature camp)
276 187 705 412 136 70 72 31 853 340 2042
More outdoor
recreation and
exercise classes
(boot camp,
yoga, etc.)
166 122 607 373 186 99 102 50 949 376 2010
Volunteer
opportunities
(trail work,
restoration, etc.)
704 309 936 499 44 27 36 21 476 228 2196
More nature
oriented
activities
336 203 786 454 111 49 45 23 757 301 2035
More reservable
group picnic
areas
1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
More outdoor
rental facilities
1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2
Other (please
specify)
54 Answered 2306
Skipped 500
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
758
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 285

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
759

APPENDIX I
286 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 9. Other Responses
• Those “volunteers” were not doing maintenance.

They modified trails to allow bikes to go
faster. They also built illegal trails.
• Understanding the need for quiet activities,
walking in nature, in our open spaces.
• how about environmental classes -- that
introduce different ways of looking at our
impacts to our world, environment, etc.
• Need a public pool
• More Mountain bike trails (fast
growing sport in the USA)
• More mountain bike trails and multi use trails.
• I would love to volunteer to do trail work
or even contribute to fund additional
mountain biking trails at Water Dog.
• More Mountain biking event for all ages
• Please preserve Waterdog trails and add more
trails for mountain biking where possible
• group biking
• More paths to ride bikes
• After school programs
• volunteer invasive plant removal projects
• More mountain biking options
• more single track mountain biking trails
• Local ecology walks/talks would be awesome, also
encouragement and signage to leave no trace.

Often I find garbage/trash that has blown onto trails,
we are all responsible and we should all work to pick
up and maintain these amazing public spaces which
we all benefit from. I would love for there to be
engagement and representation of community from
all aspects and uses, including mountain biking!
• The parcours course recently removed from
the path alongside Oracle was great. The
fitness stations by Design Tech are awesome.

Pp bring their stretch bands, rings, other
gear to max out exercise possibilities
• More bicycle specific trails
• Difficult to answer questions
without more specificity.
• already very busy don’t add more.

Make quiet for nature
• Mountain Biking events (Including Class 1 E-Bike)
• Skatepark!!!!!!!!
• Could also do alternating weeks of the month to
provide for longer periods of acces/ closure
• Youth Mountain Biking classes
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
760
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 287

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 9. Other Responses
• I would love to help with trail work. We have
amazing bike trails because bikers created
them. It takes a biker to make a good bike
trail. These trails also benefit hikers and
walkers. It would be great to get involved.
• Guided mountain bike rides at Water Dog.
• As a 3X weekly mountain biker, I’d
be happy to help with trail work
• Trail maintenance for mountainbiking
• Mountain biking trails!
• Habitat restoration (removal of non-native plants)
• teach kids to mountain bike
• Improve mountain biking trails and access
• More Mountain Biking Trails are needed.
• Open spaces are excellent as is
• It’s pretty good as is. Maybe more access
to e-bikes and mountain bikes.
• Mountain Biking Trail Association to
Support the Parks and help fundraise
• Limit group events. They clog up trails.
• Keep mountain biking in all open spaces.

It is an activity many of us do frequently
as our primary means of exercise.
• Waterdog Open Space could be utilized better
by the City with fun and educational activities.
• non-facebook information re volunteer opportunites
• More biking please!
• our family loves movie nights and Camp
SOAR, more summer programs for teens/
middle schoolers would be great
• Aquatics
• Recognize the damage biking
has done to open space
• Stop charging a fortune for teams to use a field
• Keep open spaces for nature only, not rec or
activities. Yes more non-sporting activities
in parks and sport fields for those who
don’t do sports. But not in open spaces
• Pickleball courts
• Food trucks or wine nights for adults
• I’m not very familiar with Belmont Parks
and Rec programs/activities
• More advertisements, as I am not
aware of these activities/programs
• Trail work not run or organized by biker groups.
• Civic group volunteers to Clean up
trash in parks, trails and creeks
• Community Gardening
• Natural system stewardship science activities
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
761

APPENDIX I
288 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 10. WHAT FACTORS LIMIT YOUR PARTICIPATION IN OUTDOOR PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES OFFERED BY THE CITY OF BELMONT? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

Total Resident Total
None of the above 530 206 530
Cost of activity or class 180 118 180
Time and/or day at which the activity is offered or facility is open 696 453 696 Maintenance or cleanliness of location 161 115 161
Travel distance is too great 261 63 261
Safety concerns at the location 63 46 63
Walking and biking does not feel safe 0 0 0
Lack of adequate parking 0 0 0
Lack of adequate parking 203 106 203
Not enough facilities 0 0 0
Public transit is unavailable or inconvenient 44 17 44
No restroom on site 227 144 227
Condition of equipment and furnishings 83 66 83
There is nothing offered in which I am interested 341 230 341 The facilities or classes do not accommodate my needs 90 68 90 I do not have the time 572 312 572
I attend programs outside of Belmont 264 109 264
Other (please specify) 108 74 108
Answered 2159
Skipped 647
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
762
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 289

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 10. Other Responses
• Dangerous walking with bikers on same trail.
• I am not aware of many outdoor
programs/activities offered
• Dangerous encounters with speeding bikers
• No
• greater variety of trails
• Not interested in organized activities.
• Hikers that go on trails not meant for hiking
• Vague rules about Ebikes
• Plenty of options already
• lack of places to lock bikes
• Nothing limits my use
• Don’t know about the outdoor programs/activities.
• Increased crowding at waterdog
• I am a mtn biker. I ride in Waterdog to
keep variety in my riding schedule
• Frankly, i just don’t know about them!
• I am not limited to access currently
• Would love to see more trail maintenance to
remove and repair ruts, improve trails for mountain
bikes, more habitat protection with narrower
trails and posted signs not to go off the trails.
• I don’t know what programs are offered.
• Unsafe for kids to get there by themselves (by
walking or biking across El Camino and/or Ralston)
• Areas for biking have become overcrowded with
hikers and joggers who don’t pay attention to others
on the trail, making it unsafe for anyone on the trail. • Would like access to the City Pool on
Carlmont Campus or have City build
another one at Barrett Comm. Ctr.
• I only use the open space for biking
• Water dog trails have gotten too
crowded on weekends. Difficult to
walk with bikes on narrow trails.
• live in san francisco. takes time to get down
there. We LOVE Waterdog park for hiking
and mountain biking with the family.
• I can’t bring my dog
• I wasn’t really aware of the programs offered.
• I’m a water aerobics kind of person
and yoga / sr classes all offered at 10-
11 am so am working by then...
• ADA
• Dog access
• No access for bikes
• we go with family. we do not do programs.
• No skatepark
• Too many mountain bikers making
hiking dangerous. Almost run over
by the on multiple occasion.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
763

APPENDIX I
290 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 10. Other Responses (con’t)
• Lack of internal motivation. Nothing
about the infrastructure.
• I spend time enjoying nature, but I would be more
present if there was a skateboarding space.
• Not really aware what programs and
activities are available but at the same
time I’m not seeking them either.
• I am often unaware of the offerings,
mostly my own fault for not staying on
top of the Parks & Rec calendar.
• not interested
• I don’t really know where to find informatikn
• Signage are not very good
• I love mountain biking! Especially
at Cipriani/dog parks!
• When I have a family, outdoor programs/
activities will be more relevant to me
• There is no Mountain Biking program
• No interest. I mountain bike and
play organized soccer
• I use the outdoors to be alone not in groups.
• Lack of well built mountain bike trails
• Unaware of the programs
• Hostilities from hikers on multi-use trails - I
no longer use Belmont parks during crowded
hours because there are too many maskless
groups with no awareness of others
• Need more mountain bike trails
• Hateful attitude towards cyclists and bikers
• Don’t know about them
• My daughter is just old enough to join classes
but have been hesitant due to covid
• Bikes are disallowed.
• lack of variety/quantity of open spaces
• Covid / family obligations
• facebook seems to be the only way
to get info for trail maintenance
• Not my style
• Not really aware of the opportunities available
• Now that ZOOM is available I did enroll in “Loteria”
game. Perhaps, I will enroll in an exercise class.
• swimming!
• Space availability
• The lack of available programs for youths in
2020 and 2021 (e.g. aquatics, holiday events,
youth classes) has dramatically reduced my
use of Belmont programming and I have had to
look to other city parks and recs for options..
• Bikes whizz around blind curves often
without warning or courtesy; large groups
are especially rude and dangerous
• Dog waste is a real deterrent
• Pandemic
• I am not familiar with outdoor activities
offered for adults by the city.
• Barrett is in need of a refresh--When?
The field at Central needs to be leveled
and the grass cut more frequently.
• Please put baby or any swings at College
View and Twin Pines parks....pleaseeeeee
• Events fill up fast, can’t join
• Need to keep nature preserve areas for
hiking only and do not make trails for
bikers or use these areas for activities that
would damage trails and hurt wildlife
• I’m handicapped, so my enjoyment of the parks is
limited, but my son and his family love the parks
• Traffic congestion along Ralston near El
Camino and near Notre Dame can be a
huge deterrent depending on time of day
• People trying to shut down my mountain bike trails
• Organized outdoor programs are
not necessary for me
• Kid activities in neighborhood parks like
nature ed, plants or creative arts
• Biking dangers.
• Additional advertising/promotion
• Don’t know about them!
• Overcrowding of limited number of trails
• The activities are not well advertised
• Limited availability by either too
few or not enough openings
• My age (86)
• as a senior with some stability issues i need to
have a level environment with multiple locations
with places to rest. most events are aimed at
younger or wheelchair mentality. i am neither
• Not well enough informed of classes and quality
• I love Belmont and all that it offers.
• I’m unaware of what outdoor programs
and activities are available and when.
• Not enough variety/options for my kids,
more educational/STEAM type kids classes
AFTER school, during summer.
• Not aware of these programs at all
• I don’t know about them
• I am not quite aware of the currently
available programs
• I do other volunteer work and do
not always have time.
• Unaware of such programs
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
764
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 291

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 10. Other Responses (con’t)
• Like to hike and bike with my own groups
• We forget to look at the class offerings because
we are so busy with kids, school, etc.
• I do not like organized events, however, I frequently use the Water Dog trails for mountain biking
• Classes fill before I register
• I like ot get out and walk with friends -
not participate in group activities
• I don’t participate in group exercises due to Covid 19 • Awareness and ease of registration
• I don’t feel safe hiking in the Waterdog
Open Space with bikes zipping by on
narrow trails. Please ban electric bikes.
• Covid
• my time, and my awareness
• Lack of awareness of programs
• I don’t know what’s offered
• Not aware of programs
• Not interested in organized activities
• 65+ older bicycle rides
• Too crowded
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
765

APPENDIX I
292 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 11. IN WHICH NEIGHBORHOOD DO YOU LIVE? SELECT ONE.

Total Resident Total
None of the above 1 0 1
Sterling Downs 0 0 0
Bayshore 36 36 36
Belmont Heights 311 311 311
Central Belmont 252 252 252
Cipriani 252 252 252
Downtown 87 87 87
Homeview 31 31 31
Western Hills 0 0 0
McDougal Park 86 86 86
Plateau - Skymount 54 54 54
Sterling Downs 68 68 68
Western Hills 121 121 121
Bayshore 0 0 0
San Mateo 251 0 251
San Carlos 202 0 202
Redwood City/Redwood Shores 222 0 222
Unincorporated San Mateo County 179 0 179
Other (please specify) 493 0 493
Answered 2646
Skipped 160
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
766
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 293

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses
• Near Western Hills in San Carlos.
• Outside belmont
• not in the area
• San Jose
• Hayward
• Palo Alto
• Fairfax
• Mountain View
• Right on the border between
San mateo and Belmont
• Los Altos
• South Lake Tahoe
• south bay
• Burlingame
• II
• Pacifica
• Millbrae
• San Jose
• I live in Pacifica but work in San Mateo
• Menlo Park
• San Jose
• Milpitas
• I do not live in this neighborhood,
but drive from San Jose.
• SF
• Travel from Santa Cruz County
• Los Gatos
• Santa Clara
• Sunnyvale
• mountain view
• Pacifica
• Menlo Park
• Los Altos
• I don’t live in San Mateo County
• Fremont
• N/a
• Los Altos Hills
• San Jose
• santa clara county
• Cambrian Park San Jose
• Sunnyvale
• South Bay
• Palo Alto
• Santa Clara County
• Mountain View
• Los Altos
• I work in the area
• South San Francisco
• Sunnyvale
• Hillsborough
• Sunnyvale
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
767

APPENDIX I
294 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain View
• Santa Clara County
• Mountain View - friend in McDougal Park
• Menlo Park
• San Jose
• san jose
• san leandro
• Redwood ciry
• San Jose
• Alameda county
• mountain view
• Los Gatos
• Close to these
• Salinas
• San Francisco
• oakland
• Outside the county
• San Francisco
• Sunnyvale
• Sunnyvale
• Sunnyvale
• Los Gatos
• Hillsborough
• Los Altos
• San Bruno
• Santa Clara county
• San Francisco
• SSF
• Fremont
• Elsewhere
• Menlo Park
• Alameda County
• Santa Clara
• San Francisco
• Menlo park
• San Francisco
• Sunnyvale
• Santa Clara County
• San Jose but drive up to Belmont to
mountain bike with friends.
• Los Altos
• SF
• Half moon bay
• Outside the county
• Palo alto
• San Jose
• San jose
• Oakland - Used to live in Western Hills
• San Jose
• Santa Clara
• Berkeley
• San Francisco (formerly San MateoBurlingame)
• CAMPBELL
• Santa Clara County
• Menlo Park
• Resident of San Mateo for 15 years, now
live outside the county but still like to
use the Waterdog area for biking.
• san francisco
• San Francisco
• San Jose
• Visit Belmont primarily to enjoy open space
• Half Moon Bay
• Palo alto
• Alameda
• San Francisco
• San Francisco
• Burlingame
• Palo Alto
• Sunnyvale
• Saratoga
• San Jose
• Outside Belmont
• San Francisco
• Rose Garden, San Jose
• Los Altos
• Los Gatos
• Cupertino
• Pacifica
• Newark
• Drive up from Los Altos for Waterdog
Open Space usage
• West San Jose
• San Jose
• San Jose
• Morgan Hill, but use the park after work
• San Jose
• Los Gatos
• San Jose
• Sunnyvale
• Neighboring town
• Pacifica
• Menlo Park
• San Jose
• San jose
• Pacifica
• outer area
• San Francisco
• San Francisco
• portola valley
• San jose
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
768
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 295

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• San Bruno
• Danville
• Other
• Visit from other locations
• San Francisco
• Neighboring city
• Santa Clara
• mountain vierw
• San Jose
• SF
• San Francisco but I grew up in
Redwood City/San Carlos
• San Francisco
• san leandro
• Hillsborough
• Pacifica
• Baywood Knolls San Mateo
• woodside
• Campbell
• Mountain View
• Union City
• San Jose
• San Mateo Highlands
• El Dorado Hills
• menlo park
• Campbell
• Menlo Park
• San Francisco
• San francisco
• San Francisco
• ssf
• Menlo park
• Los Gatos
• san francisco
• Mountain View
• Los Altos
• Hmb
• San bruno
• San Jose
• I lived in Central Belmont for some time,
but currently live outside the area
• San Francisco
• Oakland
• Menlo Park
• san francisco
• Concord
• San Carlos
• South San Francisco
• Palo Alto
• Alameda
• San Mateo County
• Menlo park
• Menlo Park
• Not a resident
• Burlingame
• Hayward
• Sf
• Menlo Park
• San Francisco
• Mountain View
• Reno
• San Francisco
• San Francisco
• Oakland
• San Bruno
• sonoma county
• Menlo Park
• Other
• Palo Alto
• Mountain View
• Santa Clara
• massachusetts
• I live in East Palo Alto
• Foster City
• I live on Hillsdale blvd.
• Cupertino
• Parents live in Mcdougal Park and visit often.
• East bay
• Sonoma county
• Palo Alto
• Redwood City
• Cupertino
• Palo Alto
• Mountain view
• Sunnyvale
• San Francisco
• San Leandro
• Foster City
• Mill Valley
• Shoreview
• Palo Alto
• SF Bay area
• San Jose
• San Bruno
• San Francisco
• Silicon Valley
• Los Altos, Ca
• menlo park
• Cupertino
• San Bruno
• Redwood City
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
769

APPENDIX I
296 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• Foster City
• San Jose
• Los Altos
• Formerly Redwood City, but now Pacifica
• Santa Clara
• Oakland
• Menlo Park
• South Bay
• Woodside
• San Francisco
• Portola Valley
• Sunnyvale
• Outside of town
• San Ramon
• Santa Clara
• Menlo Park
• San Carlos Border
• Fremont
• San Jose
• San Francisco
• Redwood city
• Palo Alto
• San Bruno
• Mountain View
• San Francisco
• Palo Alto
• San Francisco
• San Jose
• San Francisco
• El Cerrito, but I work on the
Peninsula so I ride after work
• I live just over the hill in San Mateo at 37/38th and ride my bike to Waterdog many times a week/month.
• not in belmont
• Alameda County
• I live in Palo Alto and bike at waterdog
• Woodside
• Sunnyvale
• Hillsborough
• South san francisco
• Santa cruz
• Berkeley
• I live outside of city limits but often
go there to meet friends etc.
• San Jose but work in the area
• Atherton
• Millbrae
• Palo alto
• Santa Cruz
• Santa Clara county
• Palo Alto
• Truckee
• San Jose
• Unincorporated Santa Cruz County
• Hillsborough
• Alameda county
• I love our of town but enjoy the park
• Palo alto
• Foster City
• Santa Clara
• Emerald Hills
• San Jose
• Half moon bay
• San Jose
• San Jose
• Santa clara
• San Francisco
• Burlingame
• Mountain view
• San jose
• Mountain View
• Parents live in Redwood City
• Hayward
• san rafael
• Burlingame
• Palo Alto
• Out of area.
• San Jose - I visit the open space
areas of Belmont often
• Foster City
• San Francisco
• San Francisco
• Burlingame
• Sf
• Pacifica
• Alamo
• Pacifica
• East Palo alto
• South San Francisco
• Santa Clara County
• Menlo park
• San Bruno
• Palo Alto
• San Francisco
• Hillsborough
• Santa Clara
• PAlo alto
• San Francisco
• Foster Citu
• City of Oakland
• NDNU alumni
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
770
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 297

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• San Bruno
• Half moon bay
• Sunnyvsle
• Los Altos
• Santa Clara
• South San Francisco
• Pacifica
• Pacifica
• Palo Alto
• Foster City
• Vallejo
• South Bay Area, but work/visit peninsula often
• Coast
• Millbrae
• Sunnyvale
• Fremont, but former Belmont resident
• Santa Clara county
• palo alto
• cupertino but have friends who
live in Belmont, so can visit
• Marin county
• San Carlos
• los altos
• San Francisco
• Menlo Park
• Los Gatos
• San jose
• San Francisco
• Pacifica
• sf but discovered waterdog when living in 7
• Menlo Park
• East palo alto
• Sunnyvale
• San Leandro
• Santa clara
• San Francisco
• Foster City
• This question should not be included.. its
basically saying if your not from the upper
scale areas your opinion wont matter
• Menlo Park
• San Mateo
• Hayward, CA
• Burlingame
• Palo Alto
• Hillsborough
• Menlo Park
• Burlingame Ray Park
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• I live outside Belmont. But In-laws live there
and friends who I do mountain biking with
regularly and play in parks with the kids.
• Centro Chileno Lautaro has members throughout
the bay area. It gathers at Twin Pines because
it is a central point for everyone. It offers great
September weather. It is close to the hi-ways and
roads and allows our large group the opportunity
to gather, easily meet and see each other. Close
by it offers a playground for the little children. The
bathrooms are visually within the area and there
are further tables for those wanting more quiet and
distancing. Twin Pines meets all of our criteria.
• Burlingame
• San Francisco
• Palo Alto
• Newark, CA
• San Francisco
• San Carlos
• San Mateo
• Burlingame
• Lafayette
• East Bay
• Menlo Park
• Menlo Park
• EPA
• San Francisco
• Live outside of Belmont
• Outside of Belmont
• I don’t live in Belmont but visit to use the
open spaces, particularly Waterdog
• Santa clara
• San Francisco
• Midtown Palo Alto
• Daly City
• San Francisco
• Santa Clara
• Santa Cruz
• Mountain View
• Menlo Park
• Marin county
• Sf
• Alameda
• Menlo Park
• San francisco
• San Francisco
• Burlingame
• San Francisco
• Santa Clara country
• Alameda County
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
771

APPENDIX I
298 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 11. Other Responses (con’t)
• Oakland
• Menlo Park
• Hillborough
• Santa clara county
• San JOse
• Menlo Park
• Belmont Shores
• San Bruno
• Plateau-Skymont - why isn’t this listed??????
• Oak Dell
• San Juan Blvd
• is Plateau-Skymont considered an
“other” neighborhood ??
• Plateau - Skymont (Why didn’t you offer
it as an option?????) Skymont isn’t even
included in your map - please don’t forget
we are a part of Belmont too!!!!
• Plateau-Skymont
• Mcdougle park and western hills
• Plateau-Skymont
• Marten Ave Top of Ralston.
• San Jose
• Plateau - skymont
• Oakland, CA
• SF
• Plateau Skymont? You missed this? ????
• yes
• SF
• Skymont
• Burlingame
• San Bruno
• Woodside
• Menlo Park
• San Carlos
• San Francisco
• san jose
• Santa Cruz
• Scotts Valley
• Plateau/Skymont
• Plateau-Skymount
• Outside area
• Woodside
• Sunnyvale
• Millbrae
• San Francisco
• Menlo Park
• Menlo Park
• San Jose
• Santa Clara
• Marin county
• Fremont, CA
• Plateau - Skymont? why is this
missing from the picklist?
• Plateau Skymont
• Foster City
• San Francisco
• Plateau - Skymont
• SF, work in Belmont
• San francisco
• Lived in redwood city for 8 years but
just moved south to san jose
• Plateau-Skymount
• Plateau Skymont
• San JOse
• Plateau - skymont
• 8 Plateau-Skymony
• I grew up and parents live in Belmont
• South San Francisco
• Menlo Park
• Daly city
• Plateau Skymont
• Mountainview
• Plateau skymont
• Berkeley CA
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
772
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 299

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 12. WHAT IS YOUR AGE?
Total Resident Total
Under 18 49 18 49
18 to 24 57 32 57
25 to 34 320 108 320
35 to 44 719 346 719
45 to 54 895 414 895
55 to 64 498 235 498
65 to 74 145 92 145
75 or older 50 44 50
Answered 2733
Skipped 73
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
773

APPENDIX I
300 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 13. DO YOU HAVE CHILDREN OR YOUTH IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

Total Resident Total
None of the above 1020 412 1020
Yes, ages 0-5 432 227 432
Yes, ages 6-12 763 422 763
Yes, ages 13-18 661 348 661
Yes, ages 19 and up 311 148 311
Other (please specify) 0 0 0
Answered 2711
Skipped 95
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
774
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 301

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
QUESTION 14. HOW WOULD YOU DESCRIBE YOURSELF? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY.

Total Resident Total
None of the above 1 0 1
White/Caucasian 1721 807 1721
Black or African American 33 19 33
Hispanic/Latino 131 66 131
Asian/Pacific Islander 446 221 446
American Indian or Alaska Native 21 12 21
Choose not to answer 437 209 437
Other (please specify) 37 17 37
Answered 2670
Skipped 136
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
775

APPENDIX I
302 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 14. Other Responses
• Persian
• half White half Indian Asian
• South Asian
• Hella Irish
• North African
• Multicultural
• Mixed between a lot of races
• American
• WE ARE ALL HUMAN
• Multi racial
• American
• Human
• Try
• Middle Eastern
• American Of Mexican Origin
• Middle Eastern
• Central Asian
• Filipino
• What does it matter?
• Scandinavian and German
• Middle Eastern
• O
• Latin and white
• Cuban, White, Polish Jewish
• I am an older person now, but still enjoy walking,
participating with others and going outdoors.
• Asian Indian
• Indian
• American
• Mixed race
• Middle Eastern
• South Asian / Asian Indian
• American of Asian Descent
• Eurasian
• Why in the world would you ask my race? Seems
very silly. Do you need my political affiliation,
sexual orientation, and favorite movies too?
• brazillian
• Middle Eastern American
• Other
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
776
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 303

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• I love the parks. Especially twin
pines and Water Dog.
• I used to use the neighborhood park at lot
more with young children. After they left
home, I prefer going to water dog.
• There is nothing in the survey regarding
community gardens so I’m not sure
why you are sending this to me.
• No tennis courts with lights
• Water dog lake should be left
open to dogs and bikers!
• Three new rogue trails have been created by
bikers at the parklet on the upper/Southern end
of Hallmark Dr. damaging the hillside and causing
erosion, just so that they can have quick access to
the existing trail below. Consider adding a fence,
down below and just above the existing trail, to
block access to the trail from that site, but not to
block the scenic view from the parklet benches.
• Community center seems pretty
run down and not inviting.
• Hoping that some changes happen
before my kids outgrow plans.
• N/a
• love waterdog open space for mountain biking,
has been a staple of mine since starting to
mountain bike 20 years ago, trails and hikers
and mountain bikers all in harmony
• A pump track would be fantastic!
• Not enough athletic sports court (new Barrett will
help). Need more basketball and tennis courts.
• I do not feel safe walking the trails at
Water Dog lake, especially on weekends
when there are so many bicyclists,
• I love mountain biking here. The most
accessible biking trail in the peninsula.
• Keep them clean and safe, please
• When I first moved to Belmont in 2003 with a
one and three-year-old I was disappointed in the
playgrounds. Coming from Redwood City where
there were many interesting options Belmont
had nothing new or oriented to that young age.
• Doesn’t feel like a place you can sit down and
relax, enjoy the sun or outdoor air. I don’t even
remember there is a place to sit down in Barrette
outdoor. Let’s not emphasize on outdoor picnic
or BBQ in the park, what about just for a group of
retired neighbors to sit around chatting, playing
chess, poker, what have you, so a gazebo may
be nice, a water fountain nearby maybe nice, and
make sure the bike path not to traverse the park,
maybe limited to the perimeter for bike. And I could
really use a swimming pool, either open the one
in high school for residents, or create a facility
like the one in Highland area of San Mateo.
• Why do we advertise Belmonts bike paths so
people drive from distant area (example East
Bay using gasoline=pollution ) to use our trails?
• Thanks for having great clean
parks to visit with my family.
• I love our parks and open spaces.
• I love them as they are, can see that water features
etc would make more fun especially when hot. i
traveled to san carlos and san mateo parks alot
when the kids were younger for more features
• It would be great if kids and a family could
safely ride bikes on dedicated bike paths
from the waterfront to laurelwood and
waterdog parks and past it to the connector
to canada road and sawyer camp trail.
• Hallmark Park tennis courts are in dire need of
surfacing (dangerous cracks caused by surrounding
pine trees which should be removed). Also the
playground at Hallmark Park is pretty sad and it
would be great if it were replaced with a picnic
area, pull up bars, and/or sand volleyball court and
maybe a small section of turf. Is there potential for
a public-private partnership to renovate the park?
• I see the neighboring parks with some amazing
play structures and multiuse areas. (Like
Bedsford park in San Mateo). Why don’t
we have a space like that in Belmont?
• Diversity is very important so any one of any
age of any interest can enjoy the outdoors and
have a place to enjoy life. Legal biking trails
need to remain and expand to more parks
Along with skate parks there should be an
equivalent facility to bikes and there should
be more skate parks and bike parks, period.

You are excluding a large number of the
community that have no place to go.

Another one of my hobbies/interest is offroad RC
racing. There should be at least 1 dirt track where
hobbyists can go to enjoy driving and racing their
cars. This is along the same lines as the skate park
and bmx/mountain bike needs. These demographic
groups have been ignored for the most part
QUESTION 15. WHAT ELSE WOULD YOU LIKE US TO KNOW ABOUT BELMONT’S PARKS? DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
777

APPENDIX I
304 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Please keep me posted on the plans for
improvement of Belmont’s parks.
• Note: I am a Mtn Biker. I have lived in several
places with shared use hiking/biking trails; Water
Dog struggles in this regard. We don’t need to
restrict trails to make them safe; just add rules of the road to make traffic predictable. Examples: specify
traffic directions on certain days (e.g., trails are
specified as downhill some days (MWF), then uphill
others (S-T-Thu). Mark the trailheads accordingly
(e.g., color codes) so hikers and bikers know which
way bike traffic is going. Require bells on all bikes
on all trails (city provides bells at every trailhead;
bikers borrow and return as they go on and off
trails - San Luis Obispo does this). Restrictions
aren’t what’s needed; what’s needed are clear,
simple, easy rules to make movement predictable
• The vista point on Ralston near
Christian dr needs repaving
• I do not support further changes to Twin Pines Park.
• Please keep Water Dog Open Space and
Hidden Canyon Open Space open to bikers
• We use the Belmont parks and open spaces
daily. We love walking the dog there or bringing
her to the dog park for exercise. Water dog
is an awesome place to hike together.
• Keep MTB in open spaces
• My family and I have been enjoying Water Dog for
biking and hiking for many years. I try my best to be
courteous, safe and friendly to others sharing the
trails. Would be very sad to see it prohibit biking.

It’s one of the few nearby places that I enjoy with
my family to get exercise and connect with nature.
• not many available at walking distance,
specially on the hilly area of downtown. streets
are very unsafe and kids can’t play even
outside the house. no side walks. not sure
where the tax dollar is used in Belmont.
• Need trails paved for use with walkers or canes
• Bicyclists are generally very friendly to hikers,
runners, walkers in WaterDog park.
• I love the parks I visit in Belmont and think
ya’ll are doing a great job. Also very glad
to have an open space (Waterdog Lake)
that’s walking distance from my home.
• I would like to see more overhead lights in the
areas of the parks where outdoor recreation
is used. During the summer months when
the weather is warmer. More people are
walking around in the summertime due to our
nice summer weather in the evenings.
• n/a
• Widening the trails so that runners do not
have to dive into the poison oak and bushes
to avoid bikers would be very nice.
• I love riding my bike there and I
hope to continue to do so!
• I think Belmont Parks should remain multi-use
spaces. Hikers, runners, bikes, and dogs should
be allowed. Trail etiquette signs would help with
this. Excluding bicyclists from trails is inequitable.
• I love them!
• Water Dog Park is one of the few remote
biking locations that I am willing to drive some
distance to access as it is such a good venue for
mountain biking. Please don’t take that away.
• Bike riding is an inclusive and therapeutic
activity for people with disabilities such as
my dad. Disallowing the use of bikes on trails
would take away the one thing my dad can
do that is active because he is disabled.
• My wife and I live in central Belmont and walk
through Twin Pines park every week as we do loops
through the neighborhood. We’ve enjoyed music
and cultural festivals there over the years as well.
• Hallmark Park should have at least a porta
potty. I used to include walk a around the tennis
courts in my route but just got disgusted with
human waste behind trees and bushes.
• The pandemic has been a challenging time for
everyone. A mask mandate has been in place
since last spring. I use a park or trail almost
every day. I’ve seen hundreds of people with no
mask because there’s been zero enforcement.
• great place to visit
• Little or no management.
• Keep mountain biking
• Keep them clean and safe
• Tennis courts at Hallmark park need work. School
fields used for youth sports are generally sub-par.
• Allow Mountainbiking in Waterdog park to continue
• I really look forward to taking my son to
the pump track once its complete.
• Need more dog parks - especially wide
open grassy areas for dogs to run.
• Too Little public art and every park
doesn’t need a sports field.
• Love the biking opportunities
• more BBQ areas
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
778
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 305

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Children play structures are not maintained
well. Hallmark park play ground desperately
needs to be upgraded/replaced!
• Belmont’s park can be more natural than
in many other places -- creeks, trees,
etc. Let’s embrace this, and let other areas
build parks of grass expanses and highly
build structures and landscapes.
• Another outdoor archery range in the Bay Area
would be great! There’s not much in the Bay
Area and spread out too far from each other.
• Love how hikers and bikes can all get along .
• In general these are wonderful gems adding
to the quality of living in our community. Some
upgrades in infrastructure will have tremendously
magnified positive improvement. I’m glad to
see these under consideration and look forward
to the implementation and enjoyment.
• Love the mountain biking trails at Waterdog!
• Bike trails
• Waterdog (and Carlmont Jumps) are the only places
in Belmont and the surrounding communities where
cyclists have access to local trails. It is a wonderful place for children to learn to ride and for an afterwork fitness ride. Waterdog’s trails were built by mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allowed us to give back to the community.
• Great job with Belmont Sports Complex.

I was a Belmont AYSO coach and ref
for a long time, then at Belmont United
Soccer Club. Nice to have good fields.
• There needs to be areas designated to bikers
and areas designated to hikers so that both
groups can enjoy themselves peacefully
• Simplicity goes a long way and helps keep parks
clean. In general, Belmont’s parks add lots of value.
• I love mountain biking At waterdog
• Belmont is great for mountain biking ! Let’s try to
add more trails for multi use bike / walk / run
• Please consider a community pool. There
are none that are open year-round for swim
lessons, lap swim, or recreational swim in
Belmont, San Carlos, or Redwood City.
• N/A
• Growing up mountain biking in waterdog
park and Carlmont hills had an immense
positive impact on my life.
• I don’t use them as much any more
with kids older / moved out. But was
very pleased with the parks as is.
• I think parks are very important and am
happy to see planning for the future.
• The playing fields at many / most of the
Belmont locations are in dire need of repair and
maintenance. With the exception of the new turf
at BSC, almost all fields have a grade (uphill /
downhill), have very inconsistent covering (spotty
coverage of grass, holes around irrigation, and
rodent damage), and are often closed during
precipitation. I have coached youth soccer for
years and have been disappointed by the condition
of our fields and have even seen injuries due to
the inconsistent coverage (ankle injuries, tripping,
etc.). It is expensive to cover every field with
turf. However, a couple additional fields should
be covered with turf to provide better playing
surfaces and alternatives to the BSC. Fields that
are not covered with turf need to be re-graded,
have new irrigation installed, and re-seeded.
• Love the parks!
• We love the parks! We need more bike
Lanes connecting the parks.
• We are a biking family that is always looking for
a safe space to ride bikes with our young child.
• The trail bikes make Waterdog lake a
dangerous place to walk & enjoy.
• I love riding Waterdog with my kids!
That is what brings us to Belmont.
• Love all the parks
• There are several I routinely pass
without knowing they’re there
• Keep the speeding bikes off the trails
• NA
• Keep it open to MTB use!
• Please open all bike trails to all bikes
including classs 1 Ebikes
• bikes need to continue to have access to the park
• I care strongly about preserving biking access
and dog access to Waterdog Park. Biking and
hiking at Waterdog park are why I moved to
Belmont and bought my first home there. It is the
first place I want to take my foster kids to share
my love of nature with them, and take my dogs.

It is the crown jewel of Belmont because of its
very open access and use policies. Restricting
that will diminish its value to the community.
• Nice place to spend time
• Working well for us at this point. A
bit of maintenance and signage and
we’re good. Don’t screw it up.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
779

APPENDIX I
306 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water dog is one of the best parks
in all of Northern California.
• Keep access for cyclists / mountain
bikers. We pay just as much in taxes as
others and deserve equal access.
• Please do not reduce the use of cycling in
Belmont. Waterdog is a nearby treasure
that my family enjoys riding on.
• Please preserve the mountain bike
• Need to continue to allow bikes in parks!
• How Belmont will be inclusive of all visitors/
activities and not excluding specific
activities (e.g. mountain bikers, eBikes)
• With the increased popularity of cycling and
mountain biking more trails are needed.

There is often a misunderstanding by hikers/
equestrians that mountain bikes just want to go
fast - not true - want fun flowy trails with turns,
not wide open straight down fire roads. Narrow
trails increase safety by reducing speed.
• I really like mountain biking in water dog park
• Please do not restrict biking
• The remarkable bike and hiking trails
are a great feature of town
Additional entertainment and activities catering
to the visitors seem to make sense
• Keep mountain bike trails open. Expand access
• Let’s make them better
• Keep mountain biking trails
• We need skate parks and pump tracks.
• Convenient location! There should
be SOME one way trails to lessen
confrontations between bikes and peds.
• We simply do not visit parks that are not dogfriendly. We have worked very hard to train our pup to be social, loving and respond to our
commands. We wish that more parks and trails
were off-leash for dogs under voice-command.
• For bike use I recommend alternating days of
access for different user groups, a bell box program,
directional trails, or realignment of problematic trails. • It would be nice to have a park similar to berresford or burton in our community. We have always gone
to these parks due to the amenities and options.
• Please keep bike access at waterdog! We
can and should get along, bowing to special
interests on this is anti-inclusion
• Stop changing them, they are
parks, leave them alone.
• I use the open space for mountain biking.
• If dog owners cannot make their dog’s excrement
vanish, they’re banned. Make it so.
• Make sure they have dedicated people
making sure they are kept clean.
• Please make it easier and safer to walk to the
parks by adding sidewalks and crosswalks.
• There’s overuse and not enough oversight. For
example, I use hidden canyon park where dogs
are not on a leash. I’ve seen people smoke
marijuana late at night, seen used condoms etc.
also, speed bumps are needed near the parking
spot because people fly through. Too many
bikers on the trails make it very difficult to have a
peaceful hike on a weekend with young children.
• We walk Belmont parks basically daily
one way or another. Especially love hiking
and biking Waterdog and Sugarloaf.
• Mountain biking is important to all that access
and maintain the trails in thebpark
• Need after school programs
• More access to trails for people on
bikes, more connected routes
• It’s the closest place for me to go out and ride
my mountain bike outside of San Francisco!
• We fully enjoy the parks. Glad they are multi use.
• nothing
• Mostly well maintained, warn against people
wanting to change too much or cater to access
at the compromise of raw & natural spaces
• Bicycle access should be expanded
• Allow bikes on trails
• If you are going to cut down trees as you did in
Hallmark Park last year, could you at least NOT
do that just at bird nesting season. Aside from
needlessly cutting down beautiful 30 plus year
old trees (when just minor repair of the pathway
would have solved the root invasion problem)
we lost birds that were just nesting. Even birds
in trees not directly cut abandoned their nest
from the disruption going on around them.
• Waterdog and Hidden Valley are the reasons why
we moved here (all the way from Singapore). We
value the opportunities it brings to us as individuals, to our children, as a family, and for the community.

It has been our haven and “playground” for many
years already, ranging from running, hiking, to
biking. We love it and take care of it every week!
• Too many dogs.
• Please keep open to mountain biking
• I enjoy mountain biking on the Waterdog trails,
please keep those accessible to mountain biking!
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
780
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 307

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Please do not restrict biking at Waterdog
park. It is an integral part of the community.

There are pure hiking and running trails
just across from it at Crystal springs
• We need more access bike-only trails.
• Water dog Park is great for Mountain
Biking. Many of the trails were created
and maintained by Mountain Bikers.
• Love biking and hiking there
• Myself and other mountain bikers are part of the
reason why the Open Space around WaterDog
Lake is so popular. I strongly object to efforts to
restrict mountain biking and completely support
improvements that benefit ALL trail users.
• Most parks have chipped paint, wood
splinters... It would be good to identify a
number to call at all parks to clean this up.
• Access for all.
• It’s wonderful Belmont allows mountain
biking at Waterdog. I can’t thank Belmont
enough for allowing this activity.
• Not enough designated areas for off leash
dog activities. Belmont NEEDS dog parks!
• Please keep singletrack singletrack! Mountain
bikers need Water Dog and will volunteer to
maintain it. If walkers complain, sell/require
bells on mtbikes to give more warning when
they’re coming, like Mt Sutro has done.
• The open spaces are the best thing
about living in Belmont for us, but their
maintenance does seem neglected.
• Too many bikes
• I take my dog every day to Waterdog park on
leash and we enjoy our hike and meeting other
dog lovers and friends. Please keep this park
open to all especially dog lovers and bikers.
• I love taking my dog on leash to water
dog and hallmark, it’s so quaint and a
beautiful place to enjoy nature
• We love being able to ride our bikes
through waterdog park and enjoy the
trails, peacefulness, and scenery
• Please designate certain trails within Waterdog for
biking. Please add signage that the parks an open
space are closed from sunset to sunrise. Please
add rattlesnake and mountain lion caution signs to
the Hallmark Park area. Please have Belmont PD
patrol the entrances to the park in the evenings. Do
not add trail leading this will encourage people on
trails in the evening time when they are closed.
• Some parks (Hallmark Park) need to be
better maintained. Some sidewalks at
the parks are uneven and could result
in someone tripping and falling.
• Please save mountain biking on multi-use trails!
• More dog friendly off leash areas (with grass).
• I didn’t know there were so many
• Mountain biking
• The Waterdog Lake area is becoming a
“zoo”. Too many bikers, riding in packs,
loud and lack curtesy towards others...
• Dog parks are needed with shade and grass.
• Keep up the good work.
• Adding a flow trail for mountain
biking would be very fun
• Please can a municipal indoor/outdoor pool
(like in Europe) be considered for Barrett or
elsewhere - Belmonters are either seniors or
families basically. Year round aquaexercise
for seniors can happen inside, like the Mills
Pool. Outside is a lap/rec pool. Perfect world:
a swim-thru section connecting both : )
• Please add more mountain biking trails. Also a
pump track will help. At the moment there are
very few mountain biking trails available and
one has to drive great distances for access.
• Enjoy biking.
• They are a treasure - water fountains always
appreciated, but often break down so something
more “water bottle” oriented might be hardier option.
• Oppose creating attractions with regional draw
• Archery range
• more dog access
• Continue to allow mountain bikes
access to Waterdog.
• Great system but the growth of mountain biking
means that more trails and access need to be added
• Used more of them extensively when
my child was young, and now less
often — but still appreciate them.
• Parks very nice but busy. We like quiet
and nature to teach children.
• General focus on improving fields (without
potholes) and existing areas (e.g. resurfacing
tennis courts or updating playgrounds where
applicable) would be my suggested first step.
• Our kids love the parks
• Contract out services/maintenance like
many other cities and SAVE money!
• Allow mountain biking
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
781

APPENDIX I
308 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Nothing but I would like to know...

What will happen to Barrett?
• While we like twin pines And fox elementary, we
sometimes find ourselves going more often to
San Mateo parks, which have more amenities.
• BIKE RIDING IS POWERFULL GOOD

FOR THE HEALTH OF PEOPLE AND THE

ECONOMY AND LOCAL CITY AND STATE
• They’re fun
• Barrett Park is under utilized by allowing
individual artist to use an enormous amount of
the public space. Also limiting the access of dog
owners for off leash exercise and interaction and
socialization is a real loss to the community
• We really enjoy the parks, it’s well maintained,
but it would be great to update the tan bark
to something newer like rubber floors.
• it would be great to have a
skateboard park in belmont.
• More skateparks please
• NA
• No skateparks or skate spaces is no bueno!
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• There are still so many I have yet to visit
• I love mountain biking at Waterdog. It’s
such a great way for me to get outside
with my friends and enjoy nature.
• They feel worn down compared
to neighboring towns
With exception of new at Fox & Cipriani
Davey Glen needs shade
• Please do not restrict mountain bike
access at Waterdog, thank you!
• keep mountain biking an option in waterdog!
• Bicycling and walking dogs is
very important in nature
• I wish there was a public swimming pool open
year-round for lap swimming and during warm
weather for recreational swim for kids.

Also, I wish that the Barrett playground had better
shade for the summer (and a better wind break for
the winter!)...that Park is nice during spring and fall but can be really cold/hot during winter/summer.
• Belmont parks are wonderful! I travel
from Redwood city to use the parks!
• Needs bike/ skate park.
• I am strongly opposed to any project that
allows mountain biking in natural areas.

The truth is that mountain biking is an antienvironmental, destructive, industry supported, self-centered activity that creates destruction where
it attempts to penetrate natural lands and the public
trust. Unlike the misinformation from proponents of
this invasion, it is clear to see this is an industry/
bike association/single-minded advocate agenda to
penetrate public programs, buildings, and natural
areas for self-centered gain, whether it be corporate
sales, association control, or self-centered thrills,
all with undue pressure/influence on local officials
and at the expense of unique treasures like local
parks and natural venues. It is a strategy that plays
out across the nation, poisoned by the mantra
of the privatized radical individual as opposed to
the common good and public trust. These spaces
are meant for all of the people, not the minority
of a few to pursue restricted single-use narcissist
adventure. Open space parklands remain places of
reflection and undisturbed connections with nature,
among the diverse animal and plant life, terrain,
and peace those things create. Objective national
research documents the destruction that mountain
biking wreaks on the environment as well as on
people who want to pursue passive recreation.

Despite their false P.R. promotional distortions,
mountain bikers are only interested in their
constant self-indulgent thrills at the expense of
nature and people. It is only about themselves
and their addiction, not about others, animals,
birds, plant life, the environment, nature or
anything beyond their myopia. It is a pathetic
mutation of what makes us truly human.

You must confront this intrusion and deny any use
of the park for mountain biking or similar restricteduse disruptive activity. Do you as a city want to turn every park into yet another industry-lobbied sports
complex? Parks and natural environments are not
gymnasiums, race tracks, sports complexes, or
circus adventure rides, despite the propaganda from
the industry and IMBA bike association partners,
replete with their websites, consulting, and talking
points, a 21st century snake-oil medicine show.

APPENDIX I DRAFT
782
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 309

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water dog park is a great place to hike and
mountain bike. Having mountain bike in WDP
for over 25 years and helped build and maintain
the trails both bikers and hikers can coexist
• Keep mountain bikes on trails at WDog.
• they are great!
• They are working fine. Dog
waste is the only problem.
• Belmont open space trails are treasures by
cyclists- please do not take access away. Cycling
groups are historically some of the most active
in maintaining trails and are happy to help their
community find ways to exist with other use groups.
• Kids enjoy playgrounds but will be outgrowing soon.
• Mountain Biking needs to be allowed
throughout Waterdog.
• N/A
• N/A
• Belmont could use more public tennis courts
• It’s important to keep access to mountain biking
• N/a
• They are a gem. I was introduced to them by my
Belmont resident friends, and the the Twin Pines
park in particular is just such a cool place to poke
around -- hiking and biking as well as picnicing.
• Patricia Wharton and Davey Glenn parks are
a joke due to their layout and offerings. Even
though these are small spaces, they could
have offered better facilities/play structures.
• I’d like them to be open to all users -
hikers, bikes, equestrians, whatever.

The more diverse use the better.
• It is nice to have parks to walk, hike, bike, and
enjoy nature. Allowing all the activities allows
the community to exercise and enjoy nature:
• Don’t disallow the bikers to enjoy
your open space areas.
• Belmont has some nice parkland for a small city. It
is one of the aspects I love most about the city.
• I love mountain biking at Waterdog...it’s a
recognized park for MTB enthusiasts
• Penalties for people who don’t leash their dogs.
• Glad we have them!
• Great parks. I like the dog stations.
• I think Belmont could use park rangers
and/or open space patrol.
• Keep WaterDog open and accessible for all. I
often travel to Belmont for lunches and since
my daughter lives there, take my mtn. bike!
• Please preserve multi use trails, maintain
mountain bike access to single track and fireroads.

Please create clear rules about e-bike use.
• Allow more mountain biking and electric bikes.
• Cycling is very important to me, sharing
trails with hikers and walkers and
others is very important to me.
• Keep Waterdog and other Belmont
Parks open to bikes
• Building a pump track would be a huge asset to the
community. Pumptracks offer kids of all ages safe
spaces to practice their skills. A paved pumptracks
is usable by bikes, skateboard s and scooters. See
the new pumptracks in watsonville for inspiration
• These places are best for young children and
family gatherings. Also runners and joggers.
• we need to preserve and take care of our parks.
• Please ban bicycles from all unpaved trails!
• Parks serve kids and adults but
could do better for teens.
• Thank you for the gift of over 20 years of Moutain
Biking at Waterdog. I also installed a Bench with
your help to commerate my good biking friend who
died too young at 50. We used to tide WaterDog
3 times a week together. Great memories.
• Please keep bike trails open
• The mountain bike access to Water Dog is both
unique and needed. There are essentially no other
areas nearby where mountain biking is legal on
singletrack trails. It should be maintained. Thanks!
• Irrigation and drainage issues can
limit use of park fields.
• The park systems have been my solace
during this world pandemic! Please do not
close the trails to cyclists. We put a lot of
sweat and tears working on those trails at
Waterdog. We are a very respectful group.
• They are a fantastic location to spend
time with my young child and spouse.

They have everything we need.
• We need more mountain bike access
• Waterdog and Laurelwood trails are terrific.

Thank you for investing in those and keeping
them open to mountain biking. It inspiring a new
generation of young riders in addition to those
of us who have been using them for decades
• Water Dog is the only local mountain biking option
that doesn’t create a lot of car pollution to get to.
• Bikers are tax payers and a group that places
greathello importance on park access.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
783

APPENDIX I
310 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Would like to see some (lighted) pickleball
courts. It’s one of today’s fastest growing
sports for people of all ages.
• Limiting trail use to cyclists would be a
huge mistake. Think of it this way, would
you consider limiting trail use to walkers?
What is the issue with cyclists?
• Hello. I am writing to ask you to PLEASE not cave
into pressure by some groups to limit access to
Waterdog and Hidden Canyon park to bikes. There
are a ton of people, myself included, who use the
parks on a very regular basis for exercise for myself
and my teenage son. It has been a critical aspect of
keeping our sanity during the pandemic, and one of
my primary sources of exercise and keeping healthy.

While there will always be a few people in any
sport who may not have great etiquette, the VAST
majority of mountain bikers are just people like
me -- middle aged professionals -- who consider
access to this park and it’s singletrack trails to be
a huge benefit to our mid peninsula community. I
have actually seen more situations of groups of
hikers who are walking 4-5 wide on the fire road
and get annoyed when I ring my bell and ask them
to go by, or who are wearing headphones and
can’t hear you coming up behind them, than I have
seen mountain bikers being “”rude”” to hikers.

Putting up additional signage to remind people
to be courteous and adding speed limit signs
are great ideas that have worked well at many
other regional parks. But I’ve heard that there
is a well organized set of individuals who are
trying to position mountain bikers as a menace
and that the best solution to a perceived
problem is to shut trails down to our usage.

I can’t stress highly enough that I believe that
is a horrible outcome. I use the trails myself,
and I introduced my son who has Aspergers
(ASD) to mountain biking on the trails. It would
be a tragedy if we lost access to this local
gem. I am happy to talk live any time, and if
there is an in person or Zoom meeting to hear
comments from the community, I would welcome
the opportunity to attend and share my point
of view. I know it is shared by many in the
cycling community. Thank you for listening.

Rene Larro
[email protected]
650.863.9405
• Anti-racist policy
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• I love riding mountain bikes at Belmont parks
and would hate to see them go. I ride there
anywhere from 5 to everyday if the week.
• Waterdog is an amazing asset. Mountain
bikers from the entire peninsula love it.

Please keep it open to mountain bikes.
• Water Dog Park is a blessing to have in
our area. I am an avid hiker & mountain
biker & use Water Dog frequently for both
activities. Love the multi-use trails!
• Get ppl to leash and clean up after their dogs.
• We value the ability to take our dogs out to your
parks as well as playing sports with friends.
• Nothing
• i love riding bikes and i want to keep being able to
• We moved here for the mountain biking
• I’ve been mountain biking in Belmonts parks for
more than 20 years. This past year has seen an
incredible increase in use and while that may be
frustrating for some it would be difficult to argue
that more people out enjoying nature in Belmont is
a bad thing. In addition to the great physical and
mental benefits it’s without question that cycling
also brings economic benefit to the community.

From an environmental perspective there are
countless scientific (not options) that have shown
mountain biking to be no more impactful to the
current status of the land than other activities.
• Waterdog is a great place for mountain
biking. Mountain bikers must have continued
access to all trails in waterdog
• Waterdog is a treasure. Keep it beautiful
and open to hikers and bikes.
• mountain biking is huge here and we should make
for features and designated mountain bike trails
• Great parks, well kept and great opportunity to
sustainably develop well built mountain bike trails
for many generations and economic benefits.
• Like to Mtn Bike Water dog
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
784
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 311

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Waterdog could be a better experience for everyone
if the user groups were separated - bikers should
be allowed to have more technical features and
trails without the potential danger of coming around
a downhill corner and into a group of people and
hikers should be able to enjoy nature and feel safe
without having to be aware of bikes. Multi use fire
roads around the perimeter and equal numbers of
group specific trails. Limiting the access of one just
fosters resentment and solves nothing, fostering
the separate desires of each group will make
waterdog a better park and improve an already
great place to spend an afternoon immeasurably
• Nice parks
• I go to Belmont & spend money in Belmont with
friends specifically to mountain bike @ water
dog. It’s such a unique place on the peninsula
• N/A
• Waterdog is for biking! Don’t let hikers take that
away from us, it has been a biking spot for 30 years
• Let the bikes ride in water dog park. The people
who are against it don’t even visit water dog park.
• Waterdog is a great place to mountain bike and
should continue to be available for bicycles
• Keep Mountain Bikers in Belmont! Keep the
Belmont Mountain Biking reputation!
• Pump tracks are incredibly beneficial to
youth development. They teach social skills,
a love for exercise and keeping kids out
of trouble. It did for a lot of my friends
• M
• Keep Trails open to bikes
• Love water dog for mountain biking. It is
my only source of exercise 2-3 days a
week and I frequent the park often
• Love to ride bicycle at waterdog Park area.

Please don’t close down trials for bike use.
• DO NOT CLOSE THE TRAIL FOR MOUNTAIN
BIKING. This is not the right choice and will
hurt the local businesses significantly
• Please keep the current multi-use purposes of trails
and expand number of biking trails where possible.
• Please preserve Water Dog for mountain bikers.
• I love the Belmont Parks and Open Spaces and
really enjoy mountain biking at Waterdog Park and
have also supported trail restoration days there. I
have also taken my youth biking program with youth
from Siena Youth Center of Redwood City and they
loved the park. It is one of the closest mountain
biking parks to us so we very much appreciate it.
• Great trail network for mountain biking and
ebikes. Live in San Jose and travel here to visit
the park and support local restaurants post ride
• Water Dog and Twin Pines have helped get me
through this pandemic. I ride my bike there, hike
there, meet up with friends there. Thank you.
• Keep and enhance all cycling opportunities
including mountain biking
• Keep Waterdog Park a park
• The mountain biking is excellent and the Bay
Area has a long history in this sport, going back
to the beginning of mountain biking itself.
• Really enjoy biking and walking
• I would love to see a pump track put into the
flat space at the back of Carlmont. Our entire
family absolutely loves being close to Waterdog
and Carlmont for the biking. We ride our bikes
thru there most days and the confidence I have
seen from my girls thru biking is incredible.
• Water do park is a hidden gem for mountain biking.

It is quite rare to find such good riding in a city.
• Twin Pines maintains a unique aura due it’s tree
canopy and creek system, a magical miniature
escape right from down town. A near perfect blend.
• love the mountain biking comraderie at
waterdog open space, hikers and mountain
bikers share the space quite nicely
• Keep trails open to all uses
• Love mount biking there
• My wife and I really enjoy the
mountain biking at Water dog.
• Mostly nicely kept
• Mountain biking is an important sport
and part of our peninsula identify
• There needs to be more access mountain
biking. Bike sales and purchases generate a
lot of sales tax income. I don’t like riding with
the kids on multiple use trails and having to
compete with hikers and horses. Biking deserves
its own trail network and accessibility.
• Keep water dog a premier place for mountain biking.
• Love the bike trails! My kids love going
out as a family and enjoying them
• Waterdog is such a great place to ride
bikes for people of all ages. I enjoy
riding there with my grandson.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
785

APPENDIX I
312 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water Dog should be about inclusion
to all users, not exclusive for those
with agendas to keep users from
Enjoying the open space. Water Dog is surrounded
by housing and development. There’s a Dam
creating the lake. It’s not a Nature Preserve, but
a large park in the middle of a small city. To ban
Mountain Biking due to preserving “nature” is not
a valid position as it relates to all current human
activity in and around Water Dog proximity.
• Coexist.
• The Waterdog trail system was a great place to
mountain bike while I attended NDNU. It would
be a shame to see the best mountain biking
within rideable distance from the university
taken away from the staff and faculty.
• Love Mountainbiking at Waterdog, the only park
reachable by bike from RWS. Think current
multi use should continue that everyone can
enjoy this park respectfully to other activities
• I love the mountain biking in waterdog park.

Its great to take kids into the outdoors.
• They are great
• Hand sanitizer stations would be great.
• Yes on skateparks and yes on pump
tracks. Give the kids more outdoors
options for creativity and exercise.
• When I lived in Belmont I rode my mtb at water
dog at least 3 times a week. It’s an important part
of people’s lives in Belmont and the Peninsula.
• Biking trails are necessary in these areas,
it’s a great way to encourage fitness
and bring communities together
• They are great and access for all activities
should be expanded so people have the ability
to enjoy the resource as they would like.
• Alexander park used to be so beautiful. Now
almost all of its trees have been removed. Also,
we should consider putting in a dog park.
• Please keep water dog lake park open to mountain
baking. There are many of us that enjoy a
reasonable mellow ride in this park. We are not
“crazies,” just like to enjoy nature from a bike.
• Water dog is some of the best mountain
trail system that is so close to home
• Mountain biking is an important part of my life
and waterdog park is an amazing mountain biking
location. I understand people are trying to remove
my rights to access this park for mountain biking
which is wrong. Mountain bikers deserve access
to this park just same as walkers and hikers
• Water Dog park is the best mountain biking
location in the entire Bay Area. I know of
people traveling from hours away to enjoy
it. The idea of removing mountain biking
from this park should not be considered.
• Need more mountain bike trails- hugely popular,
my entire family bikes and my grandkids and
i learned to bike at waterdog park in belmont.

Its great for family and community health!
• It’s great to be able to bike to Waterdog
and mountain bike with my 50+ year
old friends and then bike home.
• Let people continue to enjoy Waterdog Park/Hidden
Canyon with as few restrictions as possible. Allow
mountain bikers, runners and hikers to enjoy it.
• Various improvements have been done over
the years with landscaping, clean-ups, etc., but
those are then not maintained and soon plants
die, and improvements deteriorate. The City
should also prioritize walking and biking which
it has never done, so that people are generally
outside more and interacting as a community.
• When we lived in Belmont they were wonderful
resources for our family and (at the time) small child.

I still enjoy visiting them periodically when we return to see friends, and overall they are still excellent.
• Needs to be updated with more grass
areas that do not allow dogs.
• Please continue to allow all uses and increase
general respect of all users for other users.
• Please do not reduce multi-use trail access
particularly for cyclists. Trail maintenance,
education, and etiquette guidance are
ways for multi-activity users to coexist
well and keep trails in good condition.
• Great mountain biking and hiking. Brings
us there and we spend money in town
• Mountain bike trails are great. Thank you!
• I love the mountain bike trails at Water
dog! Please do not take that away.
• expand mountain biking footprint
• Do not restrict mountain bike access. Keep
mountain bike access as it is or expand access.
• Keep up the good work.
• Filling this out specifically to advocate for the
preservation of Waterdog park to continue
access for mtb’ers. It’s one of the few local
parks that allow riders. As such it’s a jewel of
a place to go-a closeby urban oasis for hikers
and bikers. Not many cities can boast that.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
786
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 313

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain biking is a feature of the parks
• I enjoy the multiple use of trails
and the open trail policy
• I love water dog lake park for its
mountain biking trails. Please continue
to allow mountain bike access!
• I have enjoyed Waterdog for mountain
biking for the past 25 years, it is my”happy
place” and gives me energy!
• Water dog lake park should continue letting
mountain bikers ride the trails, it’s the best
trail system around and a great workout for
all and it’s very easy to ride for all ages
• Please keep trails open to biking since water dog
is one of the best areas in the Bay Area for riding
• I am thankful that Belmont offers a diversity of parks • I use waterdog for mountain biking. It’s a
great place to ride. Multi use trails work when
people respect each other and the venue.
• How can we expand biking opportunities?
• Belmont parks are good but
need better maintenance
• rubberized pads instead of bark at twin
pines, maybe incorporate natural features
as part of playground like concrete hill
slide with stairs by the creekside hill
• Please repave the Alexander and Hallmark
Tennis courts. They are in disrepair
• Fire prevention: regular cleanup of dead
trees and other fuel that can start fires.
• Keep it open and keep it for everyone to enjoy.
• We visit Twin Pines and Alexander
the most and love those parks.
• The best way to stay updated on
activities/events in the park.
• I would love to see more investment in parks for
kids especially redoing barrett community center.
• The playground and tennis court at Hallmark
park really need maintenance and upgrade.
• Tennis courts in Hallmark park need resurfacing and overall improvement • The tennis courts at Alexander Park are in
shambles. They need to be redone ASAP.

Look at the courts at Dolphin Park in Redwood
City if you need an example of what a
proper tennis court set up looks like.
• Add swimming and more tennis
• Please continue to support and enhance bike use.
• We love the parks. They are worth investment !
• I love the views.
• The newer playground equipment at Semeria,
Davey Glen & O’Donnell is good. Keep it coming.

New bathroom @ Alexander is much better.
• They are very much appreciated
• I used to use them when I lived in
Belmont and I think they’re great.
• Happy w/current level of communication;
consider posting more to Nextdoor as well.
• I would love, love, love a bicycle pump track and
designated mountain bike trails with features.
• Best things about Twin Pines for our dog outings
are its natural undeveloped wooded areas
(in back) and creek access. Over-developing
with more facilities/amenities would likely
bring rules/restrictions that ruin it for us.
• They are fantastic. Great resource for
residents and welcoming to visitors.
• The field at Ralston should be regraded
and reseeded or replaced with turf.

Wind barriers would be great!!
• Y’all are doing a great job and I love the city’s parks. • Being able to walk from my home to
playgrounds and open space areas is
a big benefit of living in Belmont
• Try to keep the trees remaining in Twin
Pines Park - I hated to see so many of
them cut down for the bike path.
• I do occasionally enjoy the parks in Belmont, but
live here because of the Multi-Use trails in the open
space. I’m for any improvement to the outdoor
recreation opportunities in Belmont, but believe
that the recreation opportunities are limited to
‘drive my kids to the park’ in many instances. The
rec facilities across Hwy 101 are difficult to get
to on foot or via bicycle from across town, there
are no dedicated, protected bike lanes or walking
paths that allow for pedestrian or cyclist access
to / from locations. For instance: Ralston Ave. is
the only feasible corridor for east / west travel
from Western Hills, Plateau Skymont / Belmont
heights to downtown (Or east of 101 rec). Protected
bike and pedestrian lanes would hugely enhance
access and should be considered as vehicle vs
pedestrian or cyclist fatalities continue to rise.
• Lovely. Bereford, Twin Pines, Waterdog.Perfect!
• It would be great to have a pool in Belmont! I
have to join Bay Club or travel to San Mateo
for public swimming most of the year.
• Hidden Canyon is a gem and should
have options for bikers and hikers.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
787

APPENDIX I
314 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Belmont needs a good safe connection from upper
Ralston (by Fox and Ralston Schools) to the rest of
Belmont (Alameda, El Camino, 101). If there was a
safe route for biking that connected all of Belmont
it would greatly improve the use of Belmont Parks.
• Please replace trees that are removed.

Since we came to Belmont in 2006, there
have been 8 or 9 trees removed from
Alexander Park and only 4 replanted.
• I enjoy riding my mountaing bike several times
a year at Waterdog open space. I sometimes
ride with my wife and children. Somethimes
with a group of other advanced riders.
• Please put baby or swings in general at Twin
Pines and College View parks...they were
taken out and very much missed... also have
bubble days and other days added... plant many
more trees....also a map like on this survey - I
did not know about many of these parks
• Keep them accessible to mountain bikers, please!
• The parks need a restroom especially for kids.

Also, the play structures need much updating and
the parks need an overhaul. It would be nice if
parks can also have a space for kids to ride their
bikes/scooters as well. In the summer it can be
very hot, so it’s important to provide shade.

Additionally, it’s important that dogs do
not go where kids go as many owners
do not pick up their dog poop....
• Keep access to bikes!
• Too many tall trees. They look and sound
very dangerous during wind storm
• Soccer fields in schools like Central, Nesbit and
Ralston are ankle breakers. Same with Barrett
Community Center’s field. It will be nice if they can
be at least repaired or fixed to prevent accidents.
• I love Barrett and Twin Pines which I can
walk to. Will Barrett still be remodeled?
• more music
• I enjoy the parks and open space as they
are and don’t see a big need for changes
• We really enjoy the parks. Please keep it up!
• The tan bark in the play structure areas should
be replaced with a more rubbery surface.

Kids are filthy after they play there.
• Waterdog and Hidden Canyon are very dangerous
now due to inconsiderate mountain bikers
• I love the Organic Community Garden. It is a
wonderful place which provides opportunity for
social connection within the community and
puts into practice the idea of environmental
stewardship and sustainability.
• The fences at Fox are ridiculous.

Please take them down.
• Waterdog is a terrific local resource for
mountain biking for our children.
• Keep the trails open for hikers and bikers!
• Need better bigger playgrounds, like beresford park
• Not well known. Better use of space.

More vegetation, and more benches.
• What the future plans are now for
Barrett Community Center.
• We usually stick to parks around El Camino,
otherwise we stay in Redwood Shores.
• I love running at water dog - it’s been
over crowded during Covid though and
makes social distancing challenging.
• Who is charge? Needs more small local parks
and playgrounds where adults can socialize
and children play in their neighborhoods. How
about tables with chess boards, no place for
adults to meet in Ciprinani. It’s necessary to
have a dog to socialize with other adults
• The parks are so small that they aren’t
great for walking/running but even a
simple loop makes it more enjoyable.

I didn’t realise the schools had public parks not
about most of the other. Not sure if there is a section on the website describing them and their facilities.
• More multi-sport paths for bikes
• Please add aquatics like pools, water
fountain, sprinklers, etc for kids.
• Repair Barrett!
• A lot of trees have been removed from Twin Pines
Park. We require residents to do tree replacement,
the City should be required to do the same.
• Need a skate park
• They are very beautiful
• Restricted dog offleash hours at Barret
are a continuing frustration.
• love the ball fields
• More yoga in parks
• There are way more than I know about. Let
people know what great parks we have!
• Love water dog for mountain biking
• I’d love for you to maintain or
expand cycling access.
• Great and unique place e mountain biking
• None
• please maintain mountain bike
access to waterdog park
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
788
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 315

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• Do not restrict mountain bikes!
• Best part about the parks + open spaces is the
range of people who can use them, and the
varienty of things for which they get used
• Mountain biking is good
• Keep access for mountain bikers!
• Limit use to sundown
• Parks are great but too geared to sports
leagues. Kids who are more for arts and
science have few opportunities.
• Keep mtb trails in water dog
• Mountain biking is destroying the trails.
• Parks are great and give communities
a place to gather
• My wife children and I have been biking at
Waterdog since 2000 when I lived on Tahoe
Avenue in Belmont. I am disconcerted by the
effort to shut down biking at the Waterdog
trails. I have volunteered many many hours and
donated close to $1000 for trail maintenance
in the last 10 years. I believe that we should
foster a multi use environment that’s respectful
of all users. I understand that hikers are often
intimidated by bikers that maybe going too fast.

The answer is not to shut down trails but to
educate. We should put trail etiquette signs at the
trailheads and critical downhill areas. We should
work with Belmont are bike shops to influence
riders. I for one am happy to volunteer and help
lead these efforts. My email is given below.
• Mountain Biking in Water Dog is my
favorite pastime. My time in the Bay Area
would not be the same without it.
• Providing bike specific AND pedestrian
specific singletrack is a plus. It helps all
users and helps to avoid conflict.
• The condition of the bathrooms facilities (or
lack thereof) making going to Belmont parks &
playgrounds challenging. We usually go to San
Carlos or San Mateo because their bathroom
facilities are much newer and cleaner.
• Earlier mention that we have a lot of wonderful
parks and need to maintain / make improvements
to what we have. For the most part I believe this is
the focus of Park & Rec maintenance staff currently.
• Larger play structures would be nice, especially
at Barrett given the amount of use it gets.
• Please plant more trees. They cut noise from the
rail tracks and Ralston corridor from traveling
up and up and up. Provide shade and cool
temperatures in the summer. Cut winds all
year long. Definitely add more benches too!
• Twin Pines could use a little upkeep
w/ foliage and trimming trees.
• Please add more playgrounds.
• Tennis court reservations are often unavailable,
but go unused so courts are really available.

Perhaps a small upfront payment would
insure most use their reservation.
• We love the parks and would appreciate
more and better tennis courts.
• I would love for a community
garden or a rose garden.

Wakefield park seems like the ideal park
to transform into a specially park.
• Enjoy seeing the mixed use in our community
- dance school, Chinese school, childcare,
art studios - it really offers lots of different
outlets for various needs and interests.
• Understand that mountain bikers are the primary
users and resource to help build and maintain a
vibrant open space and healthy community. Water
dog is an amazing resource for hundreds of bikers
from the entire peninsula who specifically come to
Belmont to ride and spend money within the city.
• Enforce dog leash rules on Water
Dog trail! Not safe
• Love the outdoor events at Twin Pines Park
like concerts and movies and Earth Day
• Please resurface the tennis court at Hallmark
Park. It has large cracks and raised surfaces.

Someone, someday, is going to trip and
break a bone on its current surface.
• I LOVE Belmont’s parks & am super grateful for the
parks & recs programming & facilities. I think the
city does a great job maintaining diverse facilities
and keeping them accessible to everyone.
• I would like to have interesting and
newer playgrounds for kids.
• Field space use and reservations need to be
transparent, there seems to be preferential
treatment for certain sports / organizations
• My girls used to play softball at Barrett,
McDougal, & BSC. Although BSC is an
improvement, still in general, most other
cities have better facilities for their girls. The
same can be said for the soccer fields.
• more time needs to be spent by staff on
maintenance and on-going upkeep
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
789

APPENDIX I
316 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• parks are all really small. no place to
“picnic” while kids are playing. Better
play structures for middle schoolers
• Doing a great job
• Better playground facilities would be ideal.
• Reserve land for ice rink
• The Barrett Community Center should be torn
down and made into a new park with state of
the art play structures. It is in the heart of our
town and it is currently old and underutilized.
• Twin Pines can be creepy in the back
area. Have seen some sketchy people.

The play structure has terrible tanbark
• More police patrols
• There are only a few with playgrounds. Some
of the playgrounds also need to be redone
• Belmont has excellent parks, and I think they are
a huge part of what makes Belmont a great place
to live. I would like to see the city acquire more
land and use it to build more parks. Especially in
areas like Sterling Downs, where I live, and there
is so much concrete and traffic and less trees and
open space than in other areas like Cipriani or the
Western Hills. I would like to see the city keep cell
phone towers and antennaes out of the parks, as
I have seen this happen in other cities, like San
Carlos, to the detriment of the aesthetics and safety
of the park goers there. Along the water ways, in
Twin Pines for instance, I would like to see invasive
plants like ivy removed, where it can climb up trees
like Buckeyes and cause damage to the tree.
• We always want more & improved parks.
• Don’t overbuild Barrett when it is redone. Open field areas are nice. • I think the hidden canyon park that is now
undeveloped would be a great place for families
to picnic. Add some benches and leave the
area open for the children to explore.
• Grateful for Parks & Rec employees!
• cleanliness is an issue
• Add more water features! We need
places to cool off in the summer!
• We would really like a swimming facility.

The whole family would use it.
• Pretty good the way they are. Spend the money
elsewhere where it may be needed more.
• I’d like some wide open grassy areas to
walk my dog. The biggest drawback about
recreation in Belmont is that streets are
poorly paved and sidewalks are limited,
so we have to drive before we walk.
• Love them
• Belmont parks overall are great.

Keep up the good work.
• A dog park in twin pins would be awesome
• There are too many baseball/softball fields
in Belmont. Does every park have to have a
baseball field to the detriment of other sports?
The city could use a proper community pool
(Carlmont High’s is not truly accessible to
the general public), more Soccer turf fields,
Volleyball courts (beach and hardcourt),
BMX pump track and a skate park.
• More paths / sidewalks to the parks and/
or open space would be nice. Cutting down
on driving areas and making more walking/
biking spaces instead of car traffic.
• Crystal Springs CC Course isn’t mentioned
b/c it belongs to SF Watershed but I
use it every single day and love it. It’s
a huge part of my life satisfaction.
• Belmont Parks and Rec does a great
job maintaining our parks.
• Ralston field is a mess. I am afraid that
kids will get hurt running on the field.
• I love to go there with others
• Mountain bike access is critical
and needs to be expanded
• I love the Belmont parks! At different times
and different stages in parenting, the parks
maintained my sanity - giving my kids a terrific
place to play /expend energy; a social outlet for
me. I have literally spent thousands of hours
at Alexander park, Barrett, Cipriani and the
Belmont Library park over the last decade.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
790
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 317

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• As population density increases and our area is
surrounded by large protected areas further west
and south in the county, it is essential to have
local outdoor options that are well developed. The
parks and open spaces in Belmont are no longer
virgin wilderness, nor should they be returned to
that state. To minimize congestion on our crowded
roads, we should have well developed local options
for walking running biking and hiking to maximize
the wonderful spaces that were set aside. I am
concerned certain groups want to severely limit the
activities of other groups. I don’t think that would
be equitable, especially for activities that might
be “different” than one individual likes to pursue.

The virtues of tolerance and respect would be
admirable guiding principles for us all to keep in
mind as we continue to improve our local resources
and preserve for all and future generations.
• I mountain bike in water dog with my wife,
children and friends 3 times per week. It’s great!
• We use the current parks a LOT. For running,
walking, dog walking, biking. The kids hang
out at Barrett and Twin Pines a lot. We use the
dog park at Cipriani. So we (multiple of us) use
these multiple times per week (each). We like
using these parks and consider them a significant
asset to our home in Belmont. We would be
upset if things changed which limited our use.
• Would like to see better weed control
performed on the grass areas.
• They are awesome and super fun to
bring my kids. You are doing great!
• Get rid of the illegal Soho Bike trail.
• Please make more trails accessible and make at
least one park accessible to children with disabilities • Hallmark park is so sad.. please
upgrade it, tennis courts.
• Building community around our public parks is a
great idea. Without a true downtown area, Belmont
lacks the clear central destination that other
Bay Area communities enjoy. Hoping the plans
around El Camino will help change this vibe.
• Uses should remain open to all. Stop trying
to add restrictions or designations.
• Keep Waterdog open for mountain biking.
• Baseball game facilities are superior to girls softball • Please do not limit the very few mountain
biking opportunities (Waterdog for example)
in our city. I would really rather not burn fuel
to drive to riding locations outside the area.
• A skate park and a pump track would be great for
our older kids, we have plenty of playgrounds
• Please keep mountain biking at all
available parks, including Waterdog
• I’m not very familiar with parks in Belmont. I
tend to frequent parks that are within walking
distance to my home in San Carlos
• N/A
• We love our parks and open spaces...
it’s one of the reasons we moved here
• We have plenty of sports fields and
playgrounds for younger kids. We need more
amenities like skate parks or pump tracks
for middle school and high school kids.
• I think the parks are great. I take my kids three to
four times a week to Central and McDougal Parks.
• We love the parks in Belmont! It’s one of the
reasons we’ve lived here for the last 12 years.
• They are underdeveloped.
• Please fix the asphalt trail to Hallmark park
and the Cross Country Course. The tree
roots have broken up the asphalt and it is
an accident waiting to happen. This is a high
traffic area with tennis courts, playground and
many going to the cross country course.
• Dog friendly please!
• When are you bringing adult classes back.

Maybe outdoor until we can be indoor
again or by zoom like other gyms did.
• We have lots of tiny parks! It would be great to
have a bigger multi-use park w/walking paths,
seating areas and nice gardens/landscaping near
a food area (like San Mateo’s Central Park).
• It would be nice to have some grass and
shade trees at the Cipriani Dog park
• Electric bikes should be allowed wherever
bikes are allowed. The ADA allows for
people with health issues to use an electric
bike to exercise and get around
• I think Belmont has done a great
job managing there Parks.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
791

APPENDIX I
318 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• We have two city parks that are undeveloped, and
a great need for more park space. The space at
the end of Carlmont Drive should be developed into
something great for the city, such as a dog park
which is much needed, or a community garden, or
a bicycle feature such as a skills course or pump
track. We love the parks in the city and know
that cost is an issue for more parks. The carlmont
drive location could be made into a fantastic
amenity for the city for a relatively low cost if it
is bicycle oriented. It would create a safe place
for kids of all ages to hone their cycling skills.
• Swimming places!!!!
• Too many eucalyptus in Twin Pines - play areas
should have artificial turf (grass dies too quickly)
• Parking needed everywhere
• I love the new BSC turf field and go there for
workouts during the day on weekdays. Very
quiet at that time of day and high quality turf
that can be used year round. Thank you!!!
• I’d love a second dog park
• We need more fields, better quality fields,
better playgrounds but get rid of the tanbark.
• They are great, but we need to stay on it
and keep ahead of the curve by constantly
improving and adding features.
• I love Belmont parks - you are doing a great job!!
• NA
• We use and like LauriWoods a lot. It
is great for our grand children.
• Improve Ralston Middle school
field to turf, multi purpose
• More shade trees please. And more
areas to sit and relax outside.
• Please do not eliminate mountain
biking use at waterdog
• A treasure, and increased use is a blessing, not
a curse. Dialing up trail etiquette signage and
advocacy will do a lot for perceive conflicts
• They allow our children space to move,
interact with peers, and grow.
• It would be nice to have a perimeter walking
track at each of the elementary schools. That
would help alleviate pressure on the open
spaces, as some folks prefer to walk around
their community. Also, this would help with
running club at each school site that would
help students burn off much needed energy.
• I would like to attend more Council meetings. But a
the same small handful of people complain at the
Council meetings about bikers at Waterdog wastes
a large amount of time in each meeting discouraging
me to attend the meetings for other issues.

Please find some way to limit their complaints.
• Generally very happy with the types
and amounts of parks. Thanks!
• Belmont has such a wonderful small parks
spread across our little town. Unfortunately there
are none walkable from where I live and the
closest ones do not have any parking available.

TheNew park at Davie Glen is usually filled up
with apartment residence in the parking places
for that could be used for the park. Maybe
some time restricted parking so that people
who want to actually use the park and don’t live
within walking distance would be wonderful.
• We love them to death. Lets work to
preserve and repair what we have.
• The updated Belmont sports complex has
been great for multiple activities. Well done!
• I love the pocket park near my house. I walk there
daily with my dog and appreciate the plantings
(especially the cherry blossoms right now).
• Shade, fields and courts are
important for the community
• I would love to see the bike pump track
project resurrected. Our area needs it.
• Please put in a skatepark!!!
Sports fields (especially Central Elementary)
have lots of holes and need maintenance
to prevent injuries. I marked yes, for more
athletic fields, but perhaps we just need to
improve and maintain the ones we have.
• The playgrounds in particular do feel up to
today’s standards -- we go to Palo Alto, San
Mateo, and Los Gatos for playgrounds.
• Plant more tree and shrubs where appropriate.

Do NOT remove Eucalyptus trees or
other non-native trees if they are healthy.

Plant more Sequoia sempervirens.
• It would be great to have a place for youth bicycling/ skateboarding to get them outside. A bike pumptrack where we can teach children to ride in a safe environment would be a nice addition.
• Maintenance is poor- weeds everywhere, Benches
are sparse and or facing the wrong way
• Continue to create, enhance and
focus on multi-use trails
• Mixed use makes the most sense. Share all
open space. Offer opportunities to earn a
sticker for learning share the trail etiquette
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
792
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 319

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 15. Other Responses (con’t)
• None
• Twin Pines is a real gem
• While I love how Belmont has preserved
the natural surroundings and trails, the city
really needs to update our playgrounds and
community center. You can see how much
they are aging. It would be great if the Barrett
Community Center and Twin Pines Parks could
be updated to accommodate both younger
and older kids and have more water features.

Redwood City and San Mateo have wonderful
parks like Red Morton and Beresford Parks that
accommodate kids of all ages and interests.
• We love mountain biking at Waterdog
• Belmont Sports Complex is a good facility that
could be even better. We could expand its
facilities and make it a really great youth sports
complex for the city and the region. Most of the
parks could be modernized and optimized to
better use these great spaces and make them
more appealing. With Notre Dame de Na Mur
closing to undergrads, can we repurpose their
facilities for the cut of belmont and its residents?
• .Water dog open space is fantastic for
riding bikes with my teen daughter
• The regions open spaces and parks are a terrific
resource. I use them daily to hike. Waterdog
is one of my favorites; I’ve been going several
times a week for almost 20 years. I love that
it’s quiet and in a “natural” state. And I love
how polite and helpful the bikers are.
• Why did we add those exercise stations at
Barrett? They might be in use by adults, but
I’ve only ever seen kids play on them.
• Keep biking
• We enjoy the parks activities for kids
(play structures) and for being welcoming
places to meet with others.
• Please encourage SFPUC,SMCo Parks to allow
dog walking and bicycle riding on Sheep Camp
trail from St James rd all the way to Canada rd
• Make certain trails for bikes only, certain
trails for hikers only and certain bike trails
to be permanently single directional
• This is an amazing survey and full of
great ideas. I am so glad you’re spending
the time to do these improvements.
• Would like to see Patricia Wharton Park maintained.

It’s usually filled with weeds an dead plants
• I would love to see the city plant more trees!
• Please work to increase the number of
sports fields, and to also improve them.
• We love our Belmont parks and open
space areas! Thank you for all you do!
• Appreciate freedom of mountain
bikes and hiking at waterdog
• I’d love to keep Waterdog open for mountain
bikes, maybe adding some bike only trails
would help, and trail etiquette sessions for new
mountain bikers to be respectful to hikers and
other trail users in existing multi use trails.
• Belmont has some hidden bat area gems. Please
keep open space as undeveloped as possible.
• I appreciate all the work that goes
into trail maintenance.
• Please fix the water fountain for dogs at Semeria
Park. Please add poop bags the Cipriani dog park.
• Tennis court access is so limited in our fair town,
currently. It would be great if we had more options
or the courts at NDNU were made available to
the city. Alternatively, the courts at Alexander
Park (which are great) could use wind shields
and definitely are past due for refinishing.
• Love ‘em
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
793

APPENDIX I
320 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• We hiked for the first time at Hidden Valley Park
trails today and thought it would benefit from more
signage. At several points we couldn’t figure out
where we were on the map we brought along.
• I love the Open Spaces
• Over the year, I can see gradual deterioration of
water dog trails. Now the ruts and gravel surface
replaced the top soil making it hard to walk. I believe much of the erosion is caused by mountain bikes
as many other open spaces found out. I am sure it
is not due to water related soil erosion as we have
not had a good rain in years. We need to limit the
number of mountain bikes using open space and
designated the wide trails for them. The walking
trails are too narrow for them and I have seen them
widening the trails by riding on the vegetation. The
number of bikers have also increased dramatically.

Many of them dresses to kill in full armor outfit to
protect themselves in case of a bad fall. I almost
feel that I need to dress like them in case we have
a collision. I had too many close calls. I hope you
consider banning bikes on hiking trails and at the
minimum limit them to certain day of the week or
certain hours. I witnessed a hiker knocked down
by a bike, he zipped away in no time before we
got a good description of him. If the current trend
continues, I may not be going back to water dog.
• Mountain bikers at water dog open space has
made hiking and sharing the trail annoying
and sometimes dangerous. Recommend
disallow bikes on certain hike only trails.
• I enjoy living next to Water Dog. I hike there a lot.

On the weekend, it is not safe to hike in Water
Dog. There are too many bikers. My family would
rather drive to open spaces in the surrounding
community, hike there and eat dinner there before
coming home. Lately because of the pandemic,
there are a lot of bikers during weekdays also.

It becomes a safety problem for me. I would like
to see bikes restricted to riding on the wide trails
and leave the narrow trails for hikers to walk
slowly and appreciate the flora and fauna. Bikers
go so fast that they can only focus on the trails
or they might fall into the canyon. They go too
fast to appreciate any scenery. It is a waste of
scenery to have bikers going down the trails. My
suggestion is to ban bikes from narrow trails.
• Riding my bike in the open space is safer than
riding on the road. It has kept me healthy especially
during the pandemic. Please don’t take it away.
• My family really enjoys the open space for
bike trail riding. This is a very good activity
with proper social distancing and excercise.
• I would like to ban all bikes from Belmont Water
Dog Hidden Canyon Open Space. Bikes are noisy
and going too fast. They like to go off trails and
gradually creating new trails and bypass. They have
no respect and no appreciation for the environment.

They treat the open space as their amusement
park. They might have a lot of fun using the trails
for free. The environmental damage they created
will deprive future generations of Belmont residents
from enjoying natural surrounding that is close to
home. By the way, many of the bikers come from
all over the bay area. Why should they be able to
come and mess up our open space backyard?
• As a Mt Bike enthusiast I have helped maintain
and build trails. And I am a responsible,
courteous biker. Do not let the one bad
apple spoil it for the responsible people.
• We are very fortunate to have access to
trails so close to home that are available for:
hiking, mountain biking and trail running.
• I oppose restrictions on all kinds off
bikes in waterdog open space
• Keep them open to dogs on leash
• I learned to mountain bike at Waterdog Lake
around five years ago. Having just turned 60,
I fully appreciate biking in the open spaces.
• I feel sorry for the homeowners next to and within
a block of Lake Rd on both sides of Hallmark Dr
because of the massive increase of people using
the open space for hiking and mountain biking.

The narrow single-track trails should be for hikers
only as the bikers are causing safety problems
and environmental damage to the ecosystem.

Belmont police should patrol the area, at least
during the busy use times, and write citations to
bikers for deviating off of the six multi-use trails
onto the narrow trails that should only be used by
hikers to enjoy the nature, quiet and solitude.

QUESTION 16. WHAT ELSE WOULD YOU LIKE US TO KNOW ABOUT BELMONT’S OPEN SPACES? DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
794
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 321

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Open spaces promote the biodiversity of other
species which makes the earth habitable for all
life, most especially humans. Our open spaces are
being destroyed at an alarming rate by humans
transforming habitats for their own purposes, e.g.,
resource-extractive industry practices, like clearcutting trees, drilling for oil and gas, and mining; real-estate development in places that have been off
limits before; and overuse for recreation. Combined
with Climate Change our natural and necessary
open spaces are more threatened than ever, which
means their protection through conservation should
be prioritized. Our local open spaces should be
managed first and foremost for conservation and
recreation should managed around that goal.
• We are very fortunate to have access to
trails so close to home that are available for
hiking, mountain biking, and trail running.
• Maintain and continue mt. biking access
• We are very fortunate to have access to
trails so close to home that are available for:
hiking, mountain biking and trail running.
• We are very fortunate to have access so close
to home to trails that vary from wide dirt roads to
narrow technical single track that are available
for hiking, mountain biking and trail running.
• I love biking in Water Dog! I can bike there from my
home. It has been a saving grace for me during the
pandemic. I always try to be courteous, watching
my speed and yielding to hikers and never biking
on wet trails. It is a special, singular space.
• Leave Waterdog as it is and don’t limit it as
there should be different activities allowed.
• N/a
• It would be helpful to mountain bikers to limit dog
walking to the wider two-track trails, as not all dog
walkers pick up after their pets, and even fewer
adhere to leash rules. Both of these situations can
create safety hazards, especially with more trail
traffic. Horses leave the biggest messes that are
absolutely no fun to ride through, but dogs are much
more common. There are sadly few great sections
of single track on the peninsula, but Waterdog has
some for sure. I would love to see more support
for our sport and would love official opportunities
to help build and maintain trails for everyone to
enjoy the outdoors safely and responsibly. Thanks!
• keep mountain biking allowed on the trails,
genuine gem of the city of belmont, brings in
lots of neighboring riders of the city and includes
their stimulation of the local economy
• Please keep water dog open to mountain bikes!
• Bikes and walkers cannot share narrow
trails. We have come close to being hit by
speeding bikes at Hidden Canyon.
• I am a mountain bike user and appreciate
that ALL users are welcome.
• We have no trails near our neighborhood.
• The answer to avoiding trail conflicts in this
time of increased usage is education and
encouragement, not restrictions. A great example
is Fernandez Ranch, which has almost no rules,
but terrific and cheerful co-existence between
user groups. The mantra is “play nice”.
• MTB in Waterdog is considered one of
the best local resources for mountain
biking. Please do no limit access.
• Can Belmont coordinate with the PUC, the
City of San Mateo and others to create longer,
contiguous open space or trails connecting
many of the great open spaces that we have.
• Designate some trails to only-bikes or onlywalkers. Widen trails that are used for both to allow safer simultaneous passage.
• Beautiful. Right now, good balance for hikers/
bikers, etc. Lived next to Waterdog for 15
years and have not noticed environmental
problems that a few, highly vocal citizens
bring up. I do not mountain bike.
• I love mountain biking here. The most
accessible biking trail in the peninsula.
• I travel to Belmont to ride at Dog Park. It’s a
lovely park that is well suited for exercise by
mountain bike, and I would love to see that
opportunity preserved. It draws my family down
from Marin to visit Belmont and the peninsula. I
think it’s probably too small a park to rationalize
eBike trails--the distances are so small they’ll
wind up doing hot laps around the park.
• I was born and raised in Belmont and have been
visiting Belmont’s open spaces for as long as I
can remember. I have been riding the trails in
these open spaces for nearly 30 years, and the
condition has barely changes in that time. Hikers
and cyclists can coexist on the trails, everyone just
needs to remember to consider their neighbor.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
795

APPENDIX I
322 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain bikers on hiking trails are a big danger
and liability for the City of Belmont. It is not
safe to bring little kids there. The bikers are
going too fast around corners. I might have
to stop going there and visit San Carlos and
San Mateo parks and open spaces instead.
• Nature rules
• Waterdog is a convenient place to bring my
young children for outdoor and environmental
education without having to drive miles to
national parks. Mountain bikes are disturbing the
peaceful atmosphere. The bikers are speeding
down hill making it a safety issue. Their rude
behaviors are bad example for my kids.
• I hike and bike in Waterdog and San Juan weekly
and love, love them. I am very concerned about
a local group’s push to limit biking. Many of
us cyclists began to mountain bike due to our
interest in nature and preservation so these
are not at all mutually exclusive activities.
• I have seen the Water Dog Open Space degradated
over the year by mountain bikes. They damaged
vegetation along the trails. Seedlings of invasive
species were brought to Water Dog because
these mountain bikers come from all over the
Bay Area. I would like to see mountain bikes
banned from our trails. Additionally the bikers
are very rude and they ride too fast. It is a matter
of time before I get hit by a speeding bike.
• Why are mountain bikes allowed on all the
trails instead of just the wide trails? Hikers are
getting run over on the narrow trails and it is very
dangerous because bikers jump and speed so we
have to jump out of the way. Also, the hiking trails
are damaged by the bikes and need lots of repair.
• Do not block bicycle access. It is healthy both
for the individual and the environment.
• I am very sad to see the destruction and damage
to our open spaces in Belmont, and to our
wildlife due to mountain biking activities and
lack of respect for nature and anyone who’s not
on a bike. What is it going to take for the city of
Belmont to prioritize protecting its open spaces
and citizens over whatever it is that it is getting
in return for allowing the mountain bikers to do
as they wish with our trails and open spaces?
• Road erosion in Waterdog Lake, with more and
more trees that used to hold the road together
fell down, what are we going to do about it? I
wonder if biking there is to be blamed. Can we
plan new trees to replace the fallen ones?
• Keep mountain biking at Waterdog.
• Try to keep natural quiet for residents
use and for safe walking.
• Please continue allowing mountain bike access
in all the outdoor spaces. We need safe and
local spaces to exercise. more restrictions should
be placed on horses - and they should have to
pick up after themselves similarly to dogs.
• I love the fact there is a having and bike trail
right in our backyard. I bring my family on
hikes and come across all sorts of plants and
animals. I bike the waterdog trails and have
brought my small dog to the lake. Its a great
place and I would not change much about it.

Its 5 min away from busy life but once you
come in it feels like its miles from anything.
• We especially enjoy biking & hiking on the trails.
• too many bikes on narrow trails. too many
unleashed dogs in open spaces/trails.
• On a biweekly basis, I hop on my mountain bike
and ride over to Waterdog to enjoy the miles of
incredible shared open space trails. Recently,
I’ve gone with my 10 year old son and 12 year
old daughter and they both, especially the
former, love it. It’s one of the few activities they
enjoy involving the outdoors besides organized
sports (which are severely limited at the moment
due to Covid). And as you can imagine, any
hour spent away from their devices is an hour
towards good mental health and fitness.

When I ride, I always carry a bell and “ding” it
when I come around corners or hear people in the
distance. That said, I ALWAYS yield to pedestrians
and exchange pleasant greetings when we meet
each other on the trails. Waterdog is one of the few
places in public these days where I am reminded of
the vibrant community we have here in Belmont. I
have of course noticed that during the pandemic,
the trails have become more congested than before,
but almost everyone I see is cordial and friendly. I’m
sure there are aggressive bike riders who may give
a bad impression to a vocal minority. That said, I’ve
personally run into more issues with off-leash dogs
and bags of poop than I have seen involving riders.

I support keeping Waterdog Open Space an
accessible and sustainable place for recreation,
connecting with nature and building community. In
the new Master Plan, I request you to consider:

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
796
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 323

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Maintaining the trails, as they are, for multiuse for hiking, biking, dog walking, exercise, connecting with nature, etc., consistent with
best practices of other open spaces
• Continuing outreach and education to trail
users and groups to ensure safe and sustainable
use of our trails. Encourage riders to use
bells. Put up signs on riding/hiking etiquette
Please do not takeaway this passion of mine
and my kids. We love to hike, fish and bike
at Waterdog. It would be a shame to lose
the ability to enjoy the trails on our bikes.
• Waterdog is one of the best local Mountain
Bike areas on the Peninsula.
• I don’t like the mountain bikers
speeding down water dog
• The last 20 years has had a devastating impact
on the condition of the Waterdog/Hidden Canyon
open space -- increased trails, destruction of
riparian areas and habitat, dramatic reduction
in tree cannopy, wildlife reduction ... if we do
not implement measures to not only stop, but
REVERSE, this destruction we will not give our
children the same beautiful open space we inherited
... I’m ashamed that our generation made the world
a worse place -- this same destruction we are
doing in Belmont is being done on a global level
... everyone has their own excuse why they are
destroying the earth and environment. This is our
opportunity to reverse the destruction of WD/HC.
• Please separate bikes from hikers - it is
scary and dangerous to have them on
the same paths like at Waterdog.
• I thoroughly disagree with the ongoing initiative to
remove mountain biking from the open spaces.
• Again, i love them. love their wildness. love running there, love that my kids and friends can bike there.
• My 12 and 14-year-old kids love to ride bikes
at waterdog park. They have worked with us
to rebuild bridges and to improve drainage on
the trails. The outdoor community around the
park has been a great outlet and source of
inspiration for them, even during covid. It has
taught them about service and community.
• Open spaces need benches and restrooms, but
too much development destroys the character
and beauty of open space. I prefer open space
to parks and athletic spaces, mostly because
age. But we need all options to be inclusive.
• This is one of the few areas to slow biking in all of the bay area. Please do not reduce bike access
• Having access to Water Dog for MTB use
has been an excellent outlet for me to
destress during the pandemic. I love being
able to ride so close to my house.
• Regulations on mountain bike speed
while maintaining current access
• Belmont’s open spaces are a treasure on the
peninsula. They should be managed for the
enjoyment of all users and unfortunately there
are MTBers who do not practice good trail
etiquette and this affects the experience of other
users. I, as a MTBer myself would prefer some
management of the trails (even/odd days, limited
trail access) to a ban on bikes there as it is the
only weekday place to ride on the peninsula.
• Waterdog open space is the crown jewel! My
wife and I were just talking about how amazing it
is to be able to walk from our house with our kids
(and dog) and be able to access trails. There
are very few places on the peninsula where this
is feasible so Belmont should invest in keeping
the Waterdog trail system and hillsides wellpreserved for future hikers/runners/bikers. • DO not allow bike pump!!!
• I enjoy hiking, biking, and walking
my dog in the open space.
• Our entire family absolutely loves mountain biking
and hiking in Belmont’s open spaces. It was one of
the attractions for us to choose moving to Belmont.
• Hidden Canyon/Waterdog open space has been
a successful multi-use trail system for over 30
years. The trails are maintained in large part by
mountain biking groups who put in hundreds
of hours of labor per year, fixing bridges,
repairing trail damage, and drainage/erosion
management. The result is a vibrant multi-use
trail system that draws people from Belmont
and beyond. Please keep up this good work.
• Essential, increase please
• We should be able to let mountain
bikers use the open spaces.
• They should remain a place for ALL to enjoy
outdoor activity -- not just a select few.

This includes biking, hiking, trail running,
whatever the folks in the community enjoy.
• Multi use is critical!! My friends and
colleagues come from afar to mountain bike
Waterdog with me and then eat and drink
and be merry in local establishments.
• Please don’t ban MTB.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
797

APPENDIX I
324 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Waterdog needs to seriously combat the over use
of mountain bikers. They come from outside our
city because it is one of the few places that allows
them to get away with the destruction and dangers
the present. I urge you to please change the rules
that will deter these people from destroying our
natural environment. The bikers add illegal trails
and scare the daylights out of hikers. I look forward
to the days when my family and I can safely
hike through Waterdog without fear of injury.
• See above
• The combination use of Waterdog trails for hikers
and bikers is VERY dangerous. I have almost
been hit numerous times by mountain bikers who
are riding fast around corners on narrow trails.

Frankly, I am amazed I haven’t been hit yet.
• I would like to preserve mountain biking use in
our open spaces. It is a wonderful option for
people and can be done in concert with hikers.
• We really enjoy mountain biking at Water
Dog Open Space with family and friends. It
is a short ride from our house, so we don’t
have to get in the car to get there to enjoy the
beautiful trails around the lake and beyond!
• I mountain bike regularly at Hidden Canyon
and Waterdog Park - LOVE IT.
• Bikers are too aggressive and riding too
fast. I almost got run over several time. They
should be prohibited from open space.
• Bicyclists are generally very friendly to hikers,
runners, walkers in WaterDog park.
• Make open space safe for hiking and nature walk.
• Members of the ROMP mountain bike community
(led by Dave and Becky Orr, Berry Stevens) handbuilt a significant number of the Water Dog Lake Open Space trails during the period of 2001 -2004
with the understanding that these multi-use trails
would be permanent features of the preserve. The
City of Belmont needs to honor that commitment,
as hundreds of volunteer hours (if not more)
removed old trash and debris, along with poison
oak from what was an informal trash dump. Policy
enforcement, NOT exclusion needs to be embraced.
• Parks are great way to get kids of the cell
phone and into nature. The only way I can get
my nephews out is on a mountain bike. The
more trails, the better for our community. Bike
safe trails should be a priority for the kids.
• People off trail a lot destroying natural habitat.

Bikers do not yield to walkers they yell coming
thru as they barrel downhill on very narrow trails.

Leaving you to jump in the brush. Many times
there are 4or more in a row. Often i have gone
for some peace and quiet only to have a walker
or biker playing loud music with no earphones.

Its a hot mess of stuff on weekends and
evenings. Everyone does whatever they want
• I would like to keep the open space trails
we have today open to dogs and bikes.
• Keep mountain biking access open and
allow to continue to use single tracks
• Love the area where I live, but would like to
see less traffic in my area due to Hallmark Park
close by and Water Dog Trail. Not sure if we
could ever build a parking facility for people
to park and then walk to their destinations.
• Waterdog is a great space for everyone to enjoy
(hikers, bikers, etc) and I think with proper trail
maintenance and education to those using this
space we all can continue to use it together
• I love biking and bike with family every month. But
some areas of Waterdog trail is too narrow and full
of blind corners. Some (not all) mountain bikers
chase a fast speed, now making the waterdog no
longer safe for Pet, children, and local family walk.
• Save the mountain bike trails!
• The mountain biking is really great, and I
hope to have this activity continued.
• Waterdog is one of the premiere mountain bike
riding destinations in the Peninsula. I would
love to see these riding areas preserved.

As user base has increased, adding multi
direction trails and signage could be key.
• I think Belmont’s Open Spaces should remain multiuse spaces. Hikers, runners, bikes, and dogs should be allowed. Trail etiquette signs would help with
this. Excluding bicyclists from trails is inequitable.

Can’t we all learn to use the space together?
• If you have volunteer opportunities
I’d love to help out!
• There are many parks for walking a group
sports but few for real trail riding. Let’s Make
Water Dog a excellent place to ride instead
of taking the one place we have away.
• The opportunity to be able to mountain bike in
water dog is a really amazing resource. A lot of
people value it, use it responsibly for that purpose
and love that it is so close to their neighborhoods.
• Would love to see more MTB legal trails!
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
798
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 325

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Bike riding is an inclusive and therapeutic
activity for people with disabilities such as
my dad. Disallowing the use of bikes on trails
would take away the one thing my dad can
do that is active because he is disabled.
• Waterdog & Hidden Canyon Open Spaces have
been a godsend for me during the pandemic.

I mountain bike there every week, and it is for
me a ‘moving meditation’. I take friends hiking
there as well--it’s a tremendous local amenity.
• Keep Waterdog open to mountain biking
• Open spaces like Water Dog in Belmont have
been an amazing part of my life. Having a area
near my house to progress my biking skills with
my Dad and younger brother was amazing.
• Having regular and fairly easy access to parks
and open spaces has been a privilege during this
unprecedented and challenging time. The facilities
have been heavily used by local residents and
tax payers as well as a lot of people from outside
the area. I’ve been a resident and tax payer in the
area for more than 20 years. While it’s important
we welcome visitors when and where we can, my
experience is that the City government seems to
work very hard trying to accommodate the needs
and wishes of people who either don’t live in the
area or don’t pay taxes (or both), frequently to the
detriment of residents and tax payers. I hope this
plan reflects the long-term needs of those who
live here and pay the taxes that make it all work.
• Please keep them quiet and relating to nature.

Please do not allow any sport activities within
open space. Keep the atmosphere serene
for the sake of animals and humans. Where
else can one go to expect such solitude?
• Belmont currently provides fantastic mountain
bike trails for the community. Many of these
trails would not exist without the active
participation of the mountain bike community.

Please keep the trails open to mountain
bikes in the Waterdog open space area.
• the more opportunitiea people can have to apend
more of their lives outdoors, the better our society is. • I have lived in Belmont since I was 5 years
old (25 now). I became interested in mountain
biking at a very young age, and having access
to the wonderful trails in the Waterdog Lake
area helped spark this interest into a life-long
passion for mountain biking, outdoor recreation,
hiking, and in general, appreciation for nature.

I think it is very important to preserve access to
this unique and amazing trail system for all uses
(biking, hiking, etc.) for generations to come.
• As a mountain biker and trail runner,
these open spaces are awesome!
• How you work with privately owned open space that
is adjacent/borders public space but users do not
know that and end up causing damage (bike riders)?
• I’d like to see the trails remain open to mountain
bikes (non-electric). Belmont has beautiful
open spaces and it’s a pleasure to enjoy them,
even from as far away as Menlo Park.
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and
the surrounding communities where cyclists
have access to local trails. In particular, it is a
great location for singletrack, technical trails.

It is a wonderful place for children to learn
to ride and for an after-work fitness ride.
• I am both a hiker and easy-level/intermediate
mountain biker. At Waterdog though, I am primarily
a hiker although I have biked there too. Please do
not limit or prohibit mountain biking at Waterdog.

All the bikers I’ve countered for over 3 years now
are polite, show etiquette, they will wait for me
when I’m hiking. We can all co-exist and have fun
at Waterdog. And especially for youth, the only
other mountain biking option would mean driving
which young people may not be old enough to
drive yet or may not have a car. It is such a healthy
sport that builds character and perseverance. I
would be willing to contribute to a Waterdog fund
if meant mountain biking could stay exactly as it
is. I would be willing to go do trail maintenance if
that meant it could stay as is. California was the
birth place of mountain biking but more and more,
it seems people who don’t understand the sport
are turning against it. We can’t let that happen.
• Please continue to permit Mtn biking in
Waterdog. There should be equity foe all
parties who use the park. Think outside of the
box. If there is a concern, have alternate day
use. Eliminating bike use would not be fair.
• Waterdog’s rustic qualities are wonderful!
• Walking should be acomodated.restrict
by cycles out of area users.
• Bike riding should continue to be
allowed along with dogs.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
799

APPENDIX I
326 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• The mountain biking in Waterdog is super fun but
could definitely use some work to make it safe for
everyone that uses the trail system. Organizing
and rallying the community for volunteer days
to improve conditions would be awesome.
• Access to trail systems for mountain bikers is an
essential component of maintaining interest in
the outdoors in our area. Please don’t further limit
access to trails for cyclists, it’s already difficult to find places close to home to enjoy our sport and passion
• Keep it wilderness. No facilities like skate parks,
bike bump tracks, etc. Allow official trails only.

Reserve certain trails for walking only. Ban
motorized vehicles. Adequately fund and staff
for vigilant maintenance. Enforce regulations.
• more access for bikers on trails
• Allow us to continue mountain biking in Waterdog
• Water Dog should ban all biking. Most
of the bikers are from out of our area
and are a menace on the trails.
• It is a great place to go for a bike ride and
due to the variety of trails and option I can
vary my ride based on time and energy.
• I feel very strongly that outside interest groups
(i.e. the Sierra Club) have no business in telling
county residents how they should engage in healthy
outdoor exercise (i.e. biking) in county parks. It’s
absolutely hypocritical that they bemoan the lack
of interest in younger people in the outdoors,
then actively work to block young people from
engaging in outdoor sports like mountain biking.
• Remove bikes from the open spaces. they
destroy trails and cause trip hazards that
could result in the city being sued.
• Segregate areas for peaceful hiking
from mountain biking.
• As an older biker I try to be an ambassador for
mountain bikers. I do wish more trail were open
to those of us who just want to view the trail just
as the hikers are able. Bikers feel penalized
because we are allowed to ride certain areas.
• Waterdog is a great place for Mountain Biking,
and it would be a shame if access was reduced.
• Please keep Water dog open to biking.

Water dog is a legacy park for biking
and should not be reclassified.
• I frequent Waterdog twice weekly to mountain bike.

I have done volunteer work on these trails. I am a
safe, courteous rider who yields to hikers/runners
and other trail users. Most mountain bikers do the
same. There will always be some bad apples but
this also includes hikers and runners who have
headphones on and do not hear the bikers who
are using their voices loudly to let them know we
are coming up on them. So if they are startled that
is because they have earphones in. Also, a lot
of runners/hikers have their dogs off leash which
also is dangerous to cyclists. So I understand trail
conflicts but we can all do a better job at making
the trails safer. It is not just mountain bikers that
can create tension out there. I love this area to
bike in. I do what I can to help maintain these
trails. It helps decrease my stress and gives me a
chance to connect with nature. Please do not close
these trails to cyclists. If anything, I would prefer
that we all come together to work on strategies
to mitigate trail conflicts instead of just closing
it to a segment of the population. Thank you!
• More BBQ areas
• Great place to go riding. Have taken my 2
year old daughter to ride on the flat dirt area
before trail. She loves it. Great place to relax
• Water Dog park is a gem; When moved here in
2014 didn’t know about it, but has been my go to
when I want to get a quick bike ride in. No need
to jump in the car and add traffic and pollution.
• Mountain Biking is a family sport that promotes
a healthy lifestyle. It brings revenue to the city.
• more single track mountain bike trails
• These are a rare resource. First, please
protect them. Second, please make room
for bicycling -- this is the future.
• I do not think mountain bike use in Water Dog
Lake open space should be restricted or limited.

Also, open spaces should be for recreation, not
just “contemplation” of nature. Let’s move away
from the old, exclusive way of thinking about
our community, and welcome people from all
backgrounds to use our parks and open spaces.
• Biking at Water Dog Lake is a great afterwork
ride on the way home. If I could afford to
buy a house adjacent to it I would.
• I have travelled to Waterdog Lake specifically
for mountain biking with friends living in Belmont
for years, both while living in San Mateo County
and living elsewhere in the bay area. I hope that
it’s excellent multi-use trail system continues
to be a safe place to hike and mountain bike
for residents and visitors alike, as it’s location
provides easy access for those living on the
eastern side of the hills of the peninsula.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
800
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 327

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I have been riding my mountain bike at
Waterdog for over 10 years and really
enjoy the trails it has to offer.
• Waterdog is incredible! It’s key to my mental health
to have somewhere to bike and be forced to fully
embrace the present moment. It’s my meditation!
• Please keep Waterdog open for mountain biking :)
• These are a major factor in why we love living
in Belmont so much. Our open spaces are
truly essential to our community and sprit and
need to remain open to all including bicycles.

As we have seen during the pandemic- these
areas offer true natural outdoor refuge under
local control. Maintaining the open spaces I
believe is of utmost importance to the future
health and well being of our community.
• Love riding Waterdog. Please do not
greatly restrict cycling there.
• My family use waterdog for biking and
as part of my commute. If biking were
limited it would lose my support.
• Keep the mountain biking trails!!
• I love the open spaces! Keep them open
and awesome! I also love mountain
biking in the open spaces.
• Belmont is a great place to enjoy the outdoors.

Keeping trail access available for ALL trail
users is the only way to provide a chance
for everyone to enjoy them. Furthermore,
expanding trails and the existing trail network
would alleviate crowding and provide volunteer
opportunies for those looking to serve.
• I have enjoyed mountain biking at Belmont’s Water
Dog Open Space for many years. It is the closest
Open Space to where I reside and has some of the
best legitimate single-track trails in the Bay Area.

As a female mountain biker, I have found
most hikers and mountain bikers there to
be very friendly and encouraging. I always
try to be very courteous to hikers, watch my
speed, and give them the right of way.

Water Dog is where I can get away and
enjoy nature and the peace and quiet while
getting exercise 2-3 times a week. It would
be extremely upsetting if trails were not open
to bikes. Please keep them multi-use.
• What trails there are and what they’re like
• Having access to mountain biking in Belmont has
given my teenage son and his friends a healthy
outlet to exercise, be in nature, and improve their
riding skills. They have proper trail etiquette and
yield to hikers (and horses, elsewhere.) They
are respectful of the trails and the people who
use them. It is because of local accessible trails
like these in Belmont, that these teenage boys
are growing up healthy and having fun, (I.e. not
needing to turn to drugs or other illegal things.)
Instead, they have been able to acquire and
hone skills and an activity (mountain biking),
that they will take with them to college and
through life! Please keep these trails open to mtn
biking to give our youth (and adults) a healthy outlet. • Access to open space within city limits is
very important and not every city has it
so I believe that access to locations like
Waterdog for everyone is critical.
• Waterdog Park has been singly responsible for
fostering my kids love of mountain biking. Due to
its proximity we are able to ride there frequently.

My hog school kids and their friends who also
ride there recently organized a bike donation for
distribution to underprivileged children of San
Mateo County. They have learned comprehensive
bike repair and building as a result of their passion
for riding. They have gained independence by
learning to ride to and from Waterdog end ride
responsibility without parental supervision. They
have learned to appreciate nature and litter
management on trails. The reason I mention all
of this is it’s all traceable back to Waterdog Park
and the passion and life lessons it’s fostered
• Waterdog park is a really amazing place to ride
and I feel it is very important to keep it open for
bikers and add more trail signage so that speed
limits and trail usage is understood better.
• Waterdog park is a great resource
for mountain biking
• I volunteer with a local high school mountain
bike team, and kids having access to local trails
they can ride their bikes to is critical in times like
this with COVID and way too much screen time
etc. Please add more trails with mountain bike
access and continue to maintain the waterdog
trails with volunteer trailwork so the kids have local
places they can engage with and volunteer at
that is connected to something they care about.
• Waterdog is special for mountain bikes - unique
even. Please keep it open for mountain bikes.

Harness the energy of the local mountain
bike community - we will help to build and
maintain trails, clean the open space, etc.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
801

APPENDIX I
328 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water Dog lake is why I took this survey - to
express my strong support for it to remain
open for mountain biking. In addition to being
good for hiking, it is a great place for both
mountain biking and trail running. The Carlmont
track and cross country teams train there
regularly whether as a team or individuals,
and I think it is a big part of their success.
• Water dog park should be enjoyed by all:
walkers, runners and mountain bikers.
• Maintain multi-use access and activities to best
meet the needs of the whole local and greater
communities. Belmont offers unique outdoor spaces
around SF Bay that many people enjoy in a variety
of ways, and that are readily accessible before and
after work on weekdays in addition to weekends.
• Even though I live in San Jose, I work in San
Mateo and found Waterdog Lake Open Space as
a convenient place to get in a quick ride on my
mountain bike before work. I’ve also encountered
many teenagers from the local area who tell me
they ride at Waterdog Lake Open Space because
it allows them to mountain bike without the need to
have their parents drive them to the mountains.
• The trails are well used by students getting
into mountain biking and practicing for
races. Please don’t take this space away
from them. This is one place they can get to
without needing parents to drive them.
• The mountain biking resource that is Waterdog
dog is of immense value to the cycling community.

Have been enjoying for 20 years and the benefits
to my health and happiness are immense.

There is no other mtb trails system nearby.
• Access for all to Open Spaces critical. Mountain
biking community is under-served in Peninsula, yet
is fastest growing segment of Open Space use
• More mountain biking access please not less
• I like the biking trails.
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and San
Mateo County where cyclist have access to
local trails. It is a wonderful place for children
to learn to ride their bikes and for an afterwork fitness ride. Waterdog’s trail were built by mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• There needs to be areas designated to bikers
and areas designated to hikers so that both
groups can enjoy themselves peacefully
• I am firmly in support of mountain bike access at
Water Dog Open Space. Reducing trails and limiting
access is not the answer; building multi-use climbing
trails and responsibly-built single-use descending
trails is a great path forward for this particular area.

I would also like to see more trail stewardship in
Water Dog, as many of the trails are rutted and
in need of repair. Volunteering events and paid
professional stewardship are top of mind for me.
• Love the bike trails and riders should be
encouraged to follow trail entiquete
• Open spaces need to be open to all users. That
includes hikers/walkers, equestrian, and bikers.
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and San
Mateo County where cyclist have access to
local trails. It is a wonderful place for children
to learn to ride their bikes and for an afterwork fitness ride. Waterdog’s trail were built by mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• I strongly oppose limiting mountain biking in
any form - walker/hiker complaints can be
handled with awareness campaigns that target
everyone. As a mountain biker, I sometimes also
encounter disrespectful mountain bikers - but also
disrespectful hikers, dog wakers, joggers, etc. But
that is a minority, and we, the decent majority, can
influence and educate those less mindful of their
surroundings without municipal bureaucracy.
• Belmont’s open spaces are truly their strong
point. I grew up riding bikes in the various open
spaces along the peninsula and was formed by
the passionate group of riders I met through the
trail systems. When Passion Trail Bikes used
to host trail maintenance days, I learned how to
effectively perform trail maintenance to make
enjoyable bike trails that were sustainable in the
local environment. I believe the open spaces
can be improved by incorporating more single
use trails to improve biker and hiker enjoyment
while sustaining the local ecosystem. One form of
enjoyment doesn’t have a larger impact that the
other, simply different impacts. Single use trails
allow more targeted approaches to trail creation,
maintenance, and use which improves everyone’s
satisfaction. It also gives the community a greater
say in their own interests, and potentially brings
in more volunteers. Not every trail needs to be
rideable by everyone, having a variety of trail types
and difficulties reduces negative interactions and
leaves everyone with a more satisfying experience.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
802
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 329

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• people who come here to ride mountain bike trails
also stop and eat and drink nearby after riding.
• I love mountain biking At waterdog
• LOVE Waterdog
• My sons, friends, family and I use Waterdog Lake
Park for regular mountain biking, and have for
years. I also use the trails for hiking and walking
with my dog. I understand that there is a movement
to remove biking from this open space. This is
where my sons grew up biking with their friends,
and where I learned to bike with my son and his
bike team. These kids still frequent the park for
training, and can ride there from their homes. If
access is denied, where will the kids go biking,
especially the younger ones who cannot drive?
What will they do with their time when they are
bored, and usually decide to take to the trails?
Should they sit inside and play video games
instead? Or hang out and get high behind grocery
stores? Remember who uses those trails, and
how they use them, and what will happen to
those groups of people when the trails are taken
away. Is this really better for the community?
• Belmont has a strong and growing mountain
bike community and we are lucky to be one of
the few cities that allow younger kids to enjoy
nature by riding bikes. Middle school and high
school students are not likely to use these trails
on their own unless they are into mountain biking
and this should be encouraged in the city.
• Waterdog is a great park for mountain biking
with friends and family while enjoying nature
and still being close to everything. All open
spaces should allow bikes on all paths.
• Please maintain bike access at Water Dog
• I love mt. biking at Waterdog park. Over the
years I have volunteered to help maintain and
helped to build the new trail around the lake. I
hope you maintain mt. biking access to the
park as it is one of my favorite places to ride.
• They are great, and a light touch would be better.

Trails are extensive enough, not looking to the city
to drive increased usage or increase amenities.
• Open spaces are critical for cycling. Having local
open spaces that kids can get to without parents
being required to drive is so important for kids to
get outside and have fun. Limiting open space
or trails would be a major negative in my eyes.
• I really enjoy mountain biking in Waterdog
Open Space and would be very
disappointed to see changes made that
preclude me from that enjoyment.
• Our family loves mountain biking at Water Dog.

It’s a wonderful community and affords a unique
option for us to ride as a family. It’s very important
for our kids and our own recreational welfare
and enjoyment of nature near our home.
• Waterdog is one of the few places to go mountain
biking. It would be great to expand the trails
for that purpose, as there aren’t many places
available to mountain biking in the bay area.
• In Waterdog Open there has been destruction of
parts of singletrack trails. I am unsure of whether
it was a poorly guided initiative by the city or one
by someone trying to illegally modify the trails on
their own accord but it has ultimately worsened
the trail system. An example of this is on upper
creek trail in hidden valley where one part of a
fork in the trail was destroyed and the consequent
rubble left the remaining lower fork dangerously
narrow. It isn’t unfortunate to see the quality
of these trails ruined for no apparent reason
• One of my favorite things to do from home is to ride
my bike to Waterdog for mountain biking. Belmont
has a unique resource at Waterdog that provides
an outlet for a quick trail ride from home and that
does not require a car trip for many users. I do this
alone and with my entire family a couple times per
week. There is a strong community of mountain
bikers in Belmont and the surrounding area who
treasure this accessible and amazing resource.
• Please preserve Waterdog trails and add more
trails for mountain biking where possible
• Designating the park as a wildlife preserve makes
little sense. The park is surrounded by all sides
by residential development. The wildlife that
habitates there has adapted to the presence
of humans. There is no need to designate this
300 acre park as a wildlife preserve when there
is a 23,000 acre wildlife preserve just on the
other side of 280, the San Francisco Public
Utilities Commission Peninsula Watershed.

During COVID-19 the demand for trails increased
significantly and they have become more crowded
and there is a clear demand for more trails.

I am glad that more people are going outdoors
which is amazing for public health. Informing people
who may not have gone outdoors as much prior
to COVID-19 about trail etiquette may be good.
• Plans to increase open space
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
803

APPENDIX I
330 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Keep waterdog open to all users! Expand
access as much as possible.
• These are such an amazing public resource for
multi-use activities, please do not add any new
restrictions on how these spaces can be used!
• The multi-use access is great. I take full
advantage of Water Dog Park, walking with our
dog, hiking, trail running and mountain biking.

It would be a shame to limit use and access
due to the voice of a small vocal group.
• I love WaterDog. The Trail Stewards have done
an unbelievable job creating and maintaining
the trails for mountain bikers. Without their
work over the last 10-20 years, we would not be
blessed with such an incredible local/ close/ fun/
accessible resource to mountain bike locally.

Truly a gem, and so lucky our community has it.
• How mountain bikers have been dedicated for
trail building and maintenance at Water Dog Park.

The volunteers have spent significant time.
• My family has lived in Belmont for over 50
years. My kids and I love to bike and hike
the Waterdog Open Space. Please keep
all the trails in the Waterdog Open Space
accessible to mountain biking. Thank You!
• More trails for ALL user groups, multi use trails.
• Please maintain multiuse trails for biking/Mtn Biking • Love the open space. Love that we can bike but
we need more green bike Lanes in Belmont
• We are a biking family that is always looking for
a safe space to ride bikes with our young child.
• Waterdog is a treasure and I love
it for hiking AND biking!
• I enjoy biking the trails at WaterDog weekly.

Belmont is unique among Peninsula cities with
the amount of well maintained trails for riding.
• Biking is very important
• please keep open space open to all and
promote proper trail adequate to all
• I am adamantly against a “controlled
burn” of the open space.
• Multi-use pathways and/or calendar dayspecific use would help mitigate trail conflicts. • these are vital to the community and why I enjoy
Belmont, these spaces should be kept open to
all activities and not limited to select users.
• More bike trails are needed.
• Keep mtb trails open
• The bike trails are an amazing place for people to
socialize while getting healthy exercise. Save them:)
• Belmont has the best mountain biking trails around
• Please keep Waterdog Park open to mountain bikes.
• Would love louder announcement of waterdog
maintenance volunteer opportunities
• The trail network for mountain biking is great,
but I think it may be time to have designated
directional trails. I.e downhill only trails. Lots
of other areas I cycle have these rules. Simple
signage helps. As well as signs to remind others
to keep their ears open for oncoming cyclists. It’s
a group effort to keep everyone safe and keep
these spaces open to ALL who enjoy them.
• Waterdog Park is a gem for mountain biking and
should continue to be. Additional signage for trail
etiquette could help with reminding people how to
use trails politely, but, in my many, many visits there, both for cycling and hiking, I have never felt unsafe.
• Mountain biking on singletrack trails in Waterdog Is
spectacular. It should be welcomed and expanded
for kids and adults. Too many people drive long
distances to mountain biking trails, limiting access
to the sport. Waterdog is a gem for mountain-biking
Belmont residents and everyone in the Bay.
• Water dog is a gem for Bay Area mountain bikers.

I use to live right near the park and loved riding
and hiking in there. I still enjoy visiting from SF.
• Reducing biking access will lead to riders poaching
trails and increased conflicts with hikers. Increase
access for all trailer users is the best option.

They’re plenty of hike-only trails throughout the
Bay Area. Multiuse trails must remain available.
• Please keep tails open for mountain bikers.

Mountain bikers as a whole are very keen on trail
etiquette, safety, community, and respecting nature.
• Waterdog is SUCH a gem on the peninsula,
it would be a shame to limit its offerings
• Keep them open for bikes!
• continue to allow mountain bikes in the open space,
it’s one of the few places available in the area
• Variety of activities means it is inclusive
• My entire family of 4 loves to bike at Waterdog.

We really encourage you to consider enhancing
the biking opportunities in this open space
for bikers of all ages. A rolling park / pump
track area with picnic tables at the base
has been a valuable asset in many other
communities for kids and adults of all ages.
• Please open all trails to all bikes
including class 1 Ebikes
• bikes need to continue to have access to the park
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
804
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 331

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Some of the best biking is at Waterdog
Lake. It is a treasure and I hope it will not
be taken away. There are few other good
biking trails that don’t require a drive.
• I love Waterdog Park and the current
freedom for all users to enjoy it.
• I love water dog park, I run there all the time,
I appreciate the lack of restrictions that lets
everyone enjoy the park, I’ve never had bad
experiences with any of the different users
• Safer bike routes to Belmont parks and open
space would be great. Especially the corridor
between the bike bridge to Twin Pines Park. I
have been hit by a car while riding my bike across
Old County Road at Masonic and I have seen
others get hit at the same intersection. Crossing
El Camino on a bike or on foot is downright
dangerous and scary. Light up cross walks when
you push the walk button would be a HUGE
safety improvement for relatively little cost.
• This is the one place that I can come and connect
with nature on my bike. This has helped me
improve my fitness and recuperate with my spinal
injury and asthma. Please don’t take it away.
• We enjoy biking Water Dog :-)
• Maintaining bike access at Water Dog is essential!
It’s the reason I still come back to visit Belmont,
to ride with friends and family at Water Dog and
then visit the tavern afterwards for lunch!
• Waterdog park should remain open to bikes
• Love using the space for mountain biking
• Working well for us.
• Water dog is great! It doesn’t need to change, just
needs to be maintained. I am always respectful on
my mountain bike and hiking with my dog. We have
never had or seen an issue I’m in the last 4 years.
• Please continue to allow biking on the trails in
Waterdog park so everyone can enjoy the area in
multiple ways. I find the cyclists to be courteous,
cautious, and respectful of the hikers on the trails.
• keep them open. water dog is one of
the few places with decent mountain
biking trails around the peninsula.
• Please continue to allow mountain bike
access as well as improve trails. If possible
expand trails for all of us to use.
• I bike frequently at Water Dog and find it to be an
incredibly valuable resource. I find that trail users
of all types (hikers, runners, bikers) get along well.

One recommendation to consider would be use of
bells on bikes. I ride with a bell on my bike and I get lots of thank yous from other trail users. We could
consider having “loaner” bells at the trailheads that
riders without bells could attach to their bikes. San
Luis Obispo County has done something along
these lines: https://www.cccmb.org/bells4bikes
• Belmont maintains some of the very few parks and
open spaces that allow cycling. Cyclists helped build
and maintain many of the trails in the parks they
have access to (example: Lake Loop at Waterdog),
and are an important asset to parks systems.
• I would like to see more Mountain Biking trails
• Need to continue to allow bikes in open spaces
• Increase opportunities for mountain biking
• We love mountain biking! Ketchum, Idaho is
a great case study for excellent management
of multi-use trails to benefit all.
• Waterdog park as a mountain biking venue is
one of the best places on the Peninsula, I have
considered moving my family to Belmont just
for this reason. Please do not limit or restrict
mountain biking in Waterdog Park in favor of other
so-called “more compatible” activities, since that
is just a subjective point of view. Instead, focus
on making it a place where all families can do all
sorts of activities with a minimum of conflict.
• Please keep Waterdog available as a biking area.
• water dog is a treasure. please preserve
access for mountain biking
• Thank you for providing great outdoor spaces!
Given the strong increase in mountain bike
participation over the last few years, I suggest
we add additional trails in the Open Spaces so
we avoid user conflicts. Simply banning bikes
will not solve the issue of insufficient space.
• There is an organized group trying to use this
survey to get you to limit mountain bike access
to the open space. you should not consider
the survey a ‘vote’ no matter how many of the
same sort of comments you get it should be
considered on the merits. One great insight is
worth more than a thousand terrible ones
• How will Belmont make the parks
and trails open to all visitors.
• Having trails that allow mountain bike
access is attractive and brings me to
Belmont regularly to ride my bike.
• Have loved cycling in WaterDog park
for years, it is a rare gem and access
to all users should be protected!
• Keep Mountain Bike access open
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
805

APPENDIX I
332 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Preserve the open space. There’s is plenty
of room for everyone and all activities.
• Keep them open to bicyclists.
• I’d like to maintain cycling access to
Waterdog Lake - it is one of the very few
areas where mountain biking is allowed.
• Water Dog park is one of the only places I
can mountain bike and take my dog - many of
the places in Palo Alto do not allow animals
and are too far to travel. In the pandemic,
mountain biking is crucial for my mental and
physical health as my preferred sport - please
keep Water Dog bike and dog friendly!
• The water dog mountain biking community
(eg trailkeepers) is a great group.
• I really enjoy the open spaces! I wish some of
the bicyclists would not go so fast, but overall I
feel safe. Most of them are very responsible.
• I LOVE the bike trails
• Maintain biking access to waterdog park,
one of the best in the peninsula.
• Please keep mountain biking access open!
• Our entire family loves to mountain bike at
Waterdog open space. It is such a wonderful
asset for Belmont. The space is well used and
maintained. It is our favorite part of Belmont!
• Water Dog is a gem! Love the multi-use trails for
hiking, dog walking, and especially mountain biking.
• I strongly support multi-use in the open spaces.

This includes cycling and hiking together. I’m
sure each group can find people misbehaving
in other groups, but as someone who regularly
does both activities (as many do), I am really
against outright limits/restrictions rather than
encouraging good behavior during shared use.
• The hikers have a problem with mountain
bikers in Belmont more than anywhere else.

No reason why they cant share the trails
just like every city in California does.
• Please do not ban mountain biking at Waterdog.

This has been a great place for me and my kids
to enjoy biking together safely. Thank you.
• Please keep Waterdog open to mountain bikes.
• Having Waterdog as a local, ride from the
house, mountain bike option is a unique
and amazing option that adds housing
value and supports local bike shops.
• It would be a shame to exclude mountain
bikes from waterdog because of a few bad
interactions. Whenever I ride there I see ten
friendly encounters for every bad one and that
is much better than it was 10 years ago when
I lived closer and rode there more often.
• I appreciate the multi-use trails you’ve
made available to the community. As a
result I and many of my friends visit local
restaurants and small businesses.
• Please do not restrict biking at waterdog
• All trails should be multiuse. If crowding becomes
a factor, allow mtn biking on odd or even days
(as is done on some other high traffic trails).
• Please allow use of electric bicycles
as OPDMD (Other Personal Disability
Mobility Device) on all trails.
• How can we build/access/advocate
for more mountain bike trails?
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and the
surrounding communities where cyclist have
access to local trails. It is a wonderful place
for children to learn to ride and for an afterwork fitness ride. Waterdog’s trail were built by mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• Keep mountain bike trails open. Expand access
• Waterdog is an amazing local trail network
that has provided hundreds of hours of use for
myself, friends and family. When there, I typically
purchase goods from local Belmont shops. I’m
a biker and hiker and am upset to hear about
the initiative to limit biking there. Trail etiquitte
is the best cure for these backlashes, everyone
needs to be aware that bikers are present.

If the trail network was expanded to the other side
of 280 (where the cross country course is) there
wouldn’t be as much congestion in Waterdog.
• Keep OS open to all ages and activities, post
trail etiquette signage. Perhaps recommend
limited group sizes? As a mountain biker
who frequently visits Waterdog and San Juan
OSPs, large groups of hikers or e-bikers can be
annoying. If I could, I would revise trail etiquette
to recommend small groups of no more than 6
individuals. Large groups of hikers and e-bikers
seem to cause the most trail blockage and
stoppages. Groups of hikers block the trail and
large groups of e-bikers force you to stop and pull
over to let them pass. Same could be said for large
groups of analog mountain bikers, I suppose!
• The mountain biking at Waterdog is what brings me
to Belmont. I like grabbing lunch there afterwards.
• Save the environment
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
806
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 333

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I’m against turning Waterdog into a Preserve which
would limit access and activities in the open space.
• Please preserve mountain bike access in Waterdog
• Through the pandemic, mountain biking has been
a saving grace for my family. We would love to
have more opportunities for riding mountain trails
• More trails for hiking, biking, and allow
dogs on leash. Shaded trails are good.

All ability trails. Not generally in favor of
ebikes, except on one way/ wider trails
• Keep mountain biking trails
• The mountain biking paths are quite high quality and
I feel very fortunate to have such good mountain
biking paths so close to my home (2 miles)
• We need more dedicated bike trails.
• Mountain Biking is not a CRIME
• Belmont is a great place to live due to access
to trails and nature for both myself and my
family. If mountain biking were limited I would
100% consider moving out of Belmont.
• Maintaining trail access for all kinds of users
is important. Waterdog is a widely enjoyed
mountain biking spot for users of all skill levels.

Safe trail usage does not need to exclude
any type of usage, it requires communication
and understanding amongst all users.
• They need better parking lots with restrooms
• Some of the trails used in multiple ways (Bike,
Run, Hike, Horses) could be time-shared (eg.
even/odd days of the month) if there is too
much conflict. I don’t think that needs to be for
all trails, just those that see a lot of multi-use.

Other ways to mitigate conflict are: singledirection trails, required use of bells on bikes.

Some or all of these measures can be
applied with sufficient forethought on the
impact to the user’s enjoyment.

Trail design and maintenance is critical for the
environment as well as our enjoyment. There
are groups that specialize in this and should
be consulted (eg. Mountain Bikers of Santa
Cruz have a great reputation for creating both
hiking and biking trails in the bay area).
• I really appreciate the effort to send the survey out and capture the community’s feedback! Thanks all.
• There are municipalities all across the US (and
world) that very successfully manage/operate
mutli-use trail systems in open space areas
with little to no user conflicts. I would hope that
Belmont in the heart of Silicon Valley could also
be a leading example of a modern approach to
multi-user trails. There’s no reason to reinvent
the wheel here - simply copy the strategies
and tactics from some of the best managed
trail system municipalities in the country.
• We love to bike with our dog in Waterdog Lake Park
-- It is fantastic. The recent trail work is marvelous
and we would love to support it in any way we can.
• Please maintain bike access in
Belmont’s open spaces.
• Waterdog is a a great outdoor space for all sorts
of activities - please keep it open to all. and a
bike pump track would be a super addition.
• Waterdog shall remain open to bikes!
• The main exercise my 11 year old and
I got during Covid was mountain biking
and Water Dog is a favorite.
• Belmont’s mountain biking trails bring me so
much joy and help me stay fit. The canyon
is so beautiful and challenging. When I ride
I always use a bell so that hikers hear me
coming... Hikers often thank me for the bell.

Requiring bell use could be one way to ensure
bikers and hikers can use the trails safely together.
• Waterdog played a part in my learning to
mountain bike, and it’s a great place for
riders, new and experienced, to enjoy nature
together and share memorable experiences
• I visit Waterdog to mountain bike. It’s some of
the best urban-adjacent mountain biking on the
peninsula, and it would be a tremendous loss if
mountain bike access were restricted or revoked.
• Waterdog Park should remain open to mountain
bikers. It was our go-to site when I was teaching
my son MTB riding skills. User conflict on the trails
and high usage can be mitigated. Measures could
include: alternating days of access for different
user groups, a bell box program, directional
trails, or realignment of problematic trails.
• Please keep these open to mountain
bikes and dogs. We can all coexist!
• Please keep bike access at waterdog! We
can and should get along, bowing to special
interests on this is anti-inclusion
• Please keep Waterdog open to bikes. I’ve
been riding it for the past 20 years and it’s a
special place. Put effort into a respectful riding
outreach program if necessary, but please don’t
ban bikes. It provides a unique and accessible
location for easy access to outdoor exercise.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
807

APPENDIX I
334 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Please keep waterdog accessible to bikes.

Limiting e-bikes is probably a good idea.
• Stop Villainizing cycling from the complaints
of a few people who don’t understand.
• Biking and hiking at Waterdog openspace
is very nice. The trails are well
maintained and welcoming for all.
• Please keep open spaces open to Mountain bikes
• Love Waterdown open space. Mountain biking
is great, fantastic trail network and overall very
nice people I have encountered there. Also hike
and walk the dog in many trails there. A fantastic
mixed use park that is close to home and fun.
• Water Dog open space is a critical part of my
weekly routine. I ride my bike there at least once
a week and would be very sad to lose the fitness
/ de-stress / nature viewing it is has to offer.

Please keep these trails open for multi-use.
• Water dog park is a fantastic gem. My
family and I have ridden bikes and hiked
there for 20 yeast. Fantastic!
• Fantastic mountain biking opportunities
right in our backyard.
• I believe the trails should remain multi use trails
and be able to have pets(dogs) with you on
the trails. I’ve been on the trails at Belmonts
open spaces for almost a year. There has been
zero issues with dogs and mountain bikers. I
know we can all coexist like we have been.
• The community of mountain bikers has
created a space where folks can gather,
get exercise, reduce work stress and find
nature. More of these opportunities would be
welcome, especially for the youth although
at age 49 I value riding trails at the top.
• Please keep Belmont’s open space available
for dog walking and biking. That and the
quality of schools are the main reasons
we moved to Belmont 7 years ago.
• Please keep trails open for mountain biking
• I think there should be better signage to limit/
advise electric mountain bike speeds, and limit all
activities that may damage dirt roads after a rain.
• It is critical to keep open spaces open and
not limit their use to certain activities.
• Biking and hiking at Waterdog is my
primary use of open space in Belmont
• Waterdog should remain available to all bikers,
hikers and walkers. They all cohabitate just
fine now. None of these three groups seem
to have a detrimental effect on the open
space. All should be able to enjoy it.
• Please retain equal access for all
users, hikers and bikers alike.
• Preserving mountain biking access
is extremely important to me
• Don’t let greedy developers take over
• Please maintain bike access on the trails.
• Would like to maintain shared trail use. Has been
a great integral local trail system for mountain
biking and would be disappointed if that were lost.
• Our open spaces are too crowded with mixed use
visitors – especially on weekends. Allowing our
citizens to ride bikes in our open spaces creates
safety, noise and privacy issues that require
supervision, policing. Riding bikes also can cause
environmental degradation. All of these negatives
come with costs to our city, including maintenance,
habitat restoration and surveillance. We have a
finite amount of money to spend on the needs of
our residents. Adding these costs will definitely
require additional city funds. Where will we get
these additional funds? If we cannot find additional
funds what city expenditure are we willing to trade
off for the right to ride a bike in our open space?
Speeding down a mountain side is definitely not
the best or safest way to enjoy nature. Speeding
bike riders are not compatible with families walking
along a trail. Mixing these two groups will only
lead to dangerous accidents and possible injuries.

Given these issues, I do not see any benefit of
allowing people to continue to bike in our open
spaces. Additionally, I do not understand why we
are allowing people from outside our city to bike in
our open space without charging an access fee to
cover the costs of the above problems that occur.

Finally, I don’t understand why we would need
lighted trail heads. I don’t agree with this, since
people should only be allowed to walk or hike on a
trail during daylight hours. One should carry a flash
light if one expects to be out during nighttime hours
or might get lost and need lighting to find their way.
• Please keep the trails as multi use. It should
continue to be shared so everyone has
access for recreation and for emotional
well being. No one should be excluded.
• My family loves Water Dog. We enjoy
walking, biking and walking our dogs.

Please don’t limit access to anyone.
• Maintain multiuse
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
808
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 335

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• use water dog often and appreciate the
ability to hike, bike and run with our dog
• I’d like to be able to continue to
mountain bike in Waterdog park.
• Need Art
• Waterdog Lake, Hidden Canyon & San Juan
Canyon are fabulous multi-use resources. Do
not be swayed by the activists who want to limit
access to trails by mountain-bikers, the very
people who established and maintain these trails.
• More bike trails!
• More access to trails for people on
bikes, more connected routes
• We believe that the Belmont Open Spaces
should remain open to all patrons including
bikers and dog walkers. Residents should not
be limited in their emjoyment of nature.
• Please do not consider restricting
usage at waterdog lake.
• Waterdog Lake is a wonderful and unique
open space. I love it just the way it is!
• Love it as is
• Enjoy mountain biking and hiking
and the friendly atmosphere.
• Open space needs to stay open to everyone.
• Keep Waterdog open for Mt. Biking!
• Mostly well maintained, warn against people
wanting to change too much or cater to access
at the compromise of raw & natural spaces
• I often feel that Water Dog Lake Park and other
open spaces in Belmont are designed for the
enjoyment of people who live near there, but not
for those of us who live in lower Belmont. Part of
the reason is that Ralston Avenue is the only way
to get there. It’s just not easy or safe to bike from
lower Belmont to upper Belmont, and parking near
the entrances is a pain, otherwise our family might
make outings to Belmont’s open spaces more often!
• Mountain Biking is very important at Water Dog.

There is abundant support to do trail work under
supervision and management by the city.
• preserve waterdog for mt bikers it is well known
and respected I have been riding there for past
twenty years and hiking for past 40 years
• I use WaterDog open space to walk my dogs,
to hike, and my kids ride their bikes there. We
all enjoy it immensely and have never had any
problems with the mountain bikers on the trails. In
fact, they are often extremely polite and cautious.
• As a former Boy Scout, an Eagle Scout & leader,
we have coordinated several Eagle projects at
Water Dog Park to improve the trails for multiuse hiking and mountain biking throughout the years. Waterdog has been one of the view parks
in Northern Silicon Valley where trails allow and
encourage outdoor exercise, Mtn biking, trailing
running and are well maintained. It would be
unconscionable and detrimental to the community
around Belmont and the valley to limit the use
of this park and restrict the Mtn biking that the
community has embraced over 3 decades.
• Let’s stop the anti biking rhetoric. You will
always have bikers and it’s fun. Instead of
creating animosity, why not simply designate
right of way to bikers on certain downhill tracks.

Easy. Bike braking bumps aren’t destroying
the world so everyone should calm down
instead of creating issues that aren’t there.
• Waterdog should stay open for everyone
• Bicycle access should be expanded
• I learned to ride a proper mountain
bike at Waterdog.

The trails are so accessible, and I don’t even
need to drive to get there, that is unheard of.

Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and San
Mateo County where cyclists have access to
local trails. It is a wonderful place for children
to learn to ride their bikes and for an after-work
fitness ride. Waterdog’s trails were built by
mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• The multi trail use at Waterdog is awesome,
so great to see the kind sharing of space
between hikers, bicyclers, joggers...
• Allow bikes on trails
• Waterdog has been hugely successful and is widely
used because it welcomes all trail users. Limiting
access to any group would be very disappointing.
• please keep waterdog open to mountain
bikers. I’ve been enjoying the trails for 27
years and have helped maintain them.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
809

APPENDIX I
336 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Open spaces need to be protected and preserved
with respect for the natural ecology. Without
such protection, the canyons and open spaces
will not be able to support the plants and wildlife
that are critcal for their survival. Cutting trees,
carving illegal and too numerous trails, running
over wildlife and building thrill seeking slaloms for
speed by bikers is destroying our beautiful canyon.

There is also the safety issue for those hikers
who have to jump off the trail to avoid speeding
bikers. We need to stop this destruciton before it
is too late. Walking and hiking are great forms of
recreation too and do not do the type of damage
the bikers are doing in the name of recreation.
• The mountain biking community treats waterdog
with respect and the utmost care. it is unfair for a
group to trry to take away decades of involvement
in the area just because they began to hike and find
it inconvenient for them. For any locals, these trails
have been a common meeting place for mountain
bikers all around the area and it would be a shame
to let a group dictate the culture of the area.
• Keep waterdog open for biking and hiking.

It’s a great space and enjoyed by many.
• These are the only trails available to cyclists in
Belmont and San Mateo County, which makes
them a precious resource to the community,
including anyone who enjoys riding a bike.
• More bike specific trails
• Belmont open spaces and the opportunity to
trail run and bike in them are one of the primary
reasons we moved to Belmont. There is a strong
local community of dedicated trail users on
foot and on wheels that cares about multi-use
access and thoughtfully developed tails. They
are an underutilized resource for the town and if
encouraged by an updated master plan, would
be significant stewards of the open spaces.
• I grew up riding water dog lake with friends for
15 years about 15 years ago. I sometimes make
it down there to enjoy the scenery and trails
I rode as teen. I love water dog trails! I rode
amateur cross-country mountain biking back
in the day and attribute that to be able to train
and develop in the water dog open space
• Waterdog open space is a local jewel to escape
into a natural environment. Historically, it has
been a multi-use destination. Over the last couple
of decades, the mountain bike community has
organized in cooperation with the city to build
and repair trails. These trails have been used by
runners, dog walkers, walkers, and cyclists. A small
minority has built unapproved trails. These trails are
poorly constructed and encourage erosion and trail
user conflict. In my opinion, they should be retired.

Furthermore, the advent of e-bikes has complicated
user conflicts and erosion. Given their power and
speed, e-bikes should not be allowed in the open
space. Overall, though, the multi-use nature of the
trails works well and should continue into the future.
• Please keep trails open for mountain bikes
• Please continue to allow mountain biking at
Water Dog. I have been biking there for 20 years,
always respected the multi use trails, and have
never had anything but positive interactions with
other trail users (hikers, bikers, everyone).
• We enjoy the Belmont Open Spaces. The mix
use trails can be challenging at times. It would be
great to have dedicated trails for bikes, hikers etc.
• Please keep Water Dog and other Open
Spaces multi-use. Its the best bonding
moments and time I have with my children
in the immediate area. Thank you
• Make sure you give the bikers access to good
trails. I am a hiker and don’t mind the bikers
if they have a bell so I know they are coming.

Some parts of the trails are too narrow for a
hiker and biker to pass without great care. Bikers
usually yield to hikers but the trails should either
accommodate both or maybe have a single
use bike trails separate from hiker trails.
• Water Dog Lake park is the best mountain biking
on the peninsula, and it’s readily accessible by
transit + bike unlike most mountain biking trails
which require long drives up to Skyline boulevard.
• I want to know that mountain biking is welcome
and encouraged within the community.
• I think the Open Spaces are a key area for Mountain
bikes, hikers, and runners on the Peninsula. In my
experience, which includes numerous runs in the
Waterdog Lake area, the three groups have been
respectful of each other, and protective of nature.
• Maintain mountain biking trails at Waterdog
• Bike access to trails if very important for the
residents and users of the park. The recent push
to get bikes banned is distressing and will greatly
reduce the appeal of living in the area and this park
in general. There are plenty of spaces where bikes
arent allowed, lets keep some areas where it is.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
810
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 337

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain biking trails at Water Dog are an important
community asset, not only for Belmont residents
but for residents of the larger area. They also bring
business to Belmont shops and restaurants.
• Bikers helped build the trails in Waterdog and are
an active user group which needs to be supported.
• Water Dog is an incredible location for mountain
biking, a sport that is increasingly being limited in
the Bay Area. We should help to preserve the sport
by keeping water dog open space bike friendly.
• Looking towards the future, more people
will be needing space to for recreation. I
believe a combination of growing, maintaining
existing, and/or creating new facilities will be
the key to having a place for everyone to do
what they love and are passionate about.
• Bikes are already banned from so many trails in
the Bay Area. If we could raise awareness about
better trail etiquette for both bikers and hikers/
joggers, we could share multi-use trails more safely.
• They have become dangerous with speeding
and reckless mountain bikers. The bikers have
“cleared” trails and cut down tree branches. They
should have their own designated spaces where
families, hikers and walkers will not be disturbed.
• I use Belmont open spaces mostly for
trail running. Open space trails are very
convenient for this. Keep up the good work.
• I have been proud to volunteer to maintain and
build trails at water dog park, as a mountain biker
and hiker, I feel strongly that these trails are
best kept multi-use; there is simply no other trail
system most of us can ride to on our bikes for
mountain biking; and mountain biker stewardship
is one of the primary reasons this space has
been so well maintained and successful.
• Waterdog has been a tremendous help physically
and emotionally, specially during the pandemic. I
love riding my bike here and have started bringing
my 2 girls to ride their bikes here as well.

It’s a treasure to the community
• Love mountain biking there. Would be
great to have mountain bike specific
trails to avoid conflicts with hikers.
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and San
Mateo County where cyclist have access to
local trails. It is a wonderful place for children
to learn to ride their bikes and an after-work
fitness ride. Waterdog’s trail were built by
mountain bikers and volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• I greatly appreciate the opportunity to take my
dog on hikes with me in Waterdog OS. The
Peninsula has few such places compared to
many other counties around the Bay Area. This is
a huge benefit to me for continuing to live in this
town after having raised my two children here.
• I enjoy mountain biking at Water dog park. It’s
a great place to connect with nature and get
exercise while ride a bicycle. Please do not
limit access to Waterdog park for mountain
bikers. Please keep water dog park open so
all can use it for exercise and recreation.
• Please keep Belmont Open Space’s open for
mountain bikers! We love mountain biking there.
• Use of the trails at Waterdog for mountain
biking is something that should be maintained.

This offers a great way for people like myself
to exercise in the middle of the day, taking a
break from work and getting a nice outdoor
experience so close to the office. I think etiquette
is key, bikers, hikers, walkers, etc. can all use
trails equally and share such great spaces.
• Great space - need to have more
volunteer days to do trail
Maintenance - we use to help
thru bike shop in Belmont.
• Keep forever, expand, control, maintain
• I love the ability to Mountain Bike at Waterdog
• Myself and other mountain bikers are part of the
reason why the Open Space around WaterDog
Lake is so popular. I strongly object to efforts to
restrict mountain biking and completely support
improvements that benefit ALL trail users.
• I have been mountain biking at Waterdog Open
Space for 15 years. It is my primary form of
exercise and stress relief. The location of the park
allows for me to ride there every week. Other
mountain biking locations are distant drives away.

Waterdog is a key destination for many local
mountain bikers. I typically see 3 to 5 bikers on
the trails whenever I ride. We need to preserve
the ability to ride mountain bikes at Waterdog
Open Space for this active community.

I am concerned about the health of the plants
at Waterdog. I have seen the terrain drying
out over the last 10 years. Oaks are dying and
the brush is tinder dry. Please establish a plan
to reduce the fire hazard in the space. I am
very willing to assist in working on trail repair
or vegetation management. Happy to help!!
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
811

APPENDIX I
338 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Don’t close Waterdog to mountain biking!
• We need mountain biking access, though
courtesy signs for etiquette would be welcome.
• Preserve - enhance access to mountain
bikes, gravel bikes please
• Water Dog Open Space is a fantastic place
to take my family for mtn biking and we love
taking our dog there for hikes and swims.
• I have run, hiked with my dogs, mountain biked
at water dog for last 15 years and it’s a gem to
our community to have this open for multi use
• keep mountain biking in hidden canyon please
• Please keep WaterDog open to multi use.
• Belmont open spaces is probably one of the
last places in this entire area we can ride our
mountain bikes on dirt. Please support this sport.
• Access for all.
• Waterdog is a terrific and well respected multiuse activity that works well for all users. • Water Dog Lake Park is a great
place to safely mountain bike.
• Please don’t restrict mountain biking at
Water Dog park. Also consider class 1 e-bike
usage if they’re currently not allowed.
• I strongly oppose any efforts to limit bike
access to Waterdog Open Space.
• The mountain biking is fantastic, I use it
every week, and was a decisive reason
I moved to the area 10 years ago.
• Please don’t limit the mountain biking trails.

They are popular because they are terrific!
• It’s amazing that a small city like Belmont
has such great Open Space areas!
• I have been mountain biking at Water Dog for over
a decade. It’s such a joy and privilege to be able
to bike from my house to the trails. All the other
options involve driving 30 minutes or more each
way. Thanks for maintaining this excellent resource.
• Love the mountain biking at Water
Dog. Please preserver and expand
options to ride bikes on the trails.
• Our entire family loves mountain
biking and hiking at waterdog
• Please keep open space trails multi use
• Bikes should be limited to Wide fire trails
and excluded from narrow trails.
• Belmont Open Spaces need to be appreciated
and preserved for future generations.

Currently, they are being severely eroded
by too much mountain biking traffic.
• More trail running amenities. Trail running
is very unique in this area and it would be
great to foster the community In Waterdog
• Open spaces need to include designated
areas for off leash dog parks
• Water Dog Lake park is one of the best mountain
biking locations in the SF Bay Area, please
do not change it. I go there every week.
• I live in Belmont Heights near Hallmark Park and the
open space here (including waterdog lake) is a huge
bonus to living here. Every day I go hiking on the
trails here with my dog and it is just a really special place to have right in your backyard. What makes it
not special are mountain bikers who zip and zoom
up and down the trails and do not get off to walk
when there are hikers. I have had to jump out of the
way with my dog and my toddler to not get run over.

I think we need clear signs that limit mountain bikers
on the trails, and definitely not widening the john
brooks trail. that goes right behind many houses
in the belmont heights area and is better suited to
hikers enjoying the views. Whatever you plan to do
please do not make a bike pump course or anything
to attract more mountain bikers to the waterdog
lake area. It’s a fragile ecosystem and bikers
are just not very careful with their surroundings.

A better place for a bike course would be at a
sports center, not in our fragile open space area!
• Just discovered them biking retrains
and they are wonderful.
• I am in favor of a halt to trail development at
Waterdog. Maintain existing trails, and prevent
creation of new ones. Rules of the road signage
would be helpful. I am also supportive of “feet
only” hours when hikers don’t have to watch for
bikes. I am strongly against restricting cycling
to wide trails. Mountain bikers build most of the
single track, and have as much right to use as
anyone. Teach courtesy and responsibility first.
• There is a lot of frustration among residents in our
neighborhood with mountain bikers who visit the
water dog and hidden canyon open spaces but ride
at dangerous speeds and do not give right of way to
hikers, often on electric bikes (ie motorized vehicles) • Too many bikes
• I love the open space preserves and using the
trails for cycling. I’ve used them many times
• I am extremely disappointed that adding items
to the open space is MUCH more prevalent in
your survey than is maintaining and improving
the natural habitat and beauty of these spaces.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
812
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 339

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I believe it is very important to preserve open
space in its natural state so that EVERYONE
can enjoy the beauty of Belmont and appreciate
our community and nature together.
• Again please keep Waterdog park open and
same for the Hallmark cross country. Everyone
runs these trails including me and I enjoy meeting
my running friends and enjoy the beautiful
well kept space. Let’s keep the space open for
the community to enjoy in its natural state.
• I mountain bike in Waterdog every day. its
an amazing mountain biking location!
• Please create a master trail map. I would
utilize belmonts parks and open spaces more
often if I had maps (preferably online and in
apps like AllTrails) and knew where to go
• Please designate certain trails within Waterdog for
biking. Please add signage that the parks an open
space are closed from sunset to sunrise. Please
add rattlesnake and mountain lion caution signs to
the Hallmark Park area. Please have Belmont PD
patrol the entrances to the park in the evenings. Do
not add trail leading this will encourage people on
trails in the evening time when they are closed.
• Prohibit bikes on Waterdog Lake Open
Space hiking trails. Bikers present a risk
of bodily injury or death to hikers on the
narrow hiking trails in that open space.
• Please keep allowing mountain biking at
Waterdog. The vast majority of us follow the
rules and are courteous to other trail users.
• Support biking on Waterdog trails
• I love mountain biking at Water Dog and generally
find my fellow bikers are respectful of hikers and
nature and am a big proponent of multi use trails.
• There are too many bike riders on narrow trails
in the open space. I have almost been run over
several times by bike riders going fast. The narrow
trails are not suitable for both hikers and bike riders. • Please save mountain biking on multi-use trails!
• Mountain bikes are sometimes an issue on narrow
trails so some strategies to allow for both biking and
hiking would be welcome (like designated trails)
• I didn’t know about San Juan
• Save mountain biking trails and access
• I would like mountain bike access for
my children and myself at waterdog. To
take that away would be a shame.
• I love and have been mountain biking in Water dog
park for years. It is very unique in offering such
wonderful trails open to biking right in our backyard.

Love sharing with all (hiking, groups, biking, etc.)!
• Waterdog is a great hiking and biking
trail. Please keep it that way. We need
more multi use trails not less.

Please do not reduce the number
of mountain biking trails.
• Keep cycling open to all users and groups
• Waterdog Park and open space is very well kept.
• Waterdog Mountain Biking is
accessible, fun and enjoyable.
• Multi-use trails are the way.
• Keep access for bikes and please do not
remove trail features or widen trails
• Please curtail mountain biking. It should’ve
been regulated earlier. The hills behind CHS
w/jumps & bumps is awesome for them.

Courtesy levels are pretty low elsewhere.
• The entire purpose of Water dog is bicycling.

Is it a GREAT local resource to improve ones
gravel and mountain biking climbing and
descending skills on. Do NOT let the crazy
NIMBY haters-of-everyone steal that.
• Please add more mountain biking trails. Also a
pump track will help. At the moment there are
very few mountain biking trails available and
one has to drive great distances for access.
• I’m not a trail biker but they need more than
simply access to broad open flat trails - could
more trails be created to give THEM that range
of challenges that are part of their sport and a
smaller set dedicated to hikers as the riding groups
have been so active in maintaining the trails?
• I love Belomont open spaces because it is a great
place to go on bike rides with my family. Belmont
open spaces is great because it is open to bikers
and walkers, and should stay that way. San Carlos
or redwood city does not have many places to go
biking and if you close down biking in Belmont open
spaces there won’t be any close places to bike at.

It is really important to keep biking open to all.
• Oppose creating attractions with regional draw
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
813

APPENDIX I
340 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• The shared use of Waterdog has been a great
example of a community sharing its resources.

Opening up more shared outdoor space will ensure
a distribution of use as opposed to closing places
for single use which would put undo stress on other
locations. City’s, humans and nature thrive with
caring diversity and teaching younger generations
that respect for environment while using it is how
we thrive and thus we can all share its resources
and protect them as opposed to limiting them and
teaching that caring for nature means being kept
out. We should all be a part of it and care for it.
• Make additional Mt Bike trails to separate
bikes from hikers on SOME sections
• Continue to let us mountain bike at waterdog please.
• Waterdog is a great park and wonderful
place to Mountain Bike
• more dog acess
• Belmont Open Spaces are an excellent
place to promote health and wellness in our
communities. We have to do our part to keep
our communities healthy by having easy access
to parks and open spaces. We should not
discriminate on what activities are accessible.
• There is a rising popularity in mountain bikes and
this is a good opportunity to draw people In to parks
• Please add more mountain bike access
• Waterdog has been my backyard for nearly 40
years.. The increased bike traffic, particularly groups of bikers, has detracted from my enjoyment of it.
• I love the bike trails at water dog.
• As a daily hiker, I have stopped going to Belmont’s
open spaces because of overcrowding and
bikes. I now go to Edgewood Park, Windy Hill,
Montera Mountain, Purissima, and other open
spaces which are much better and safer. It’s a
shame to see what has happened to Belmont’s
open spaces over the last two decades.
• Save mountain miking. So many
trails for hiking and equestrian.
• Don’t break something that’s working. The
open space is great and works. Keep up with
maintenance of bridges but that’s about it. No
need to change, redirect, restrict or (shudder)
remove any trails. I ❤️ Belmont OS.
• I’ve stopped goi g to water dog to hike
the canyon because of the issue of bikers
on the trail being too reckless.
• Too busy and activities. Sad to
see damage of nature.
• Bikers are ruining Water Dog Lake and the
surrounding paths in Belmont Heights. I would
strongly like to see their number and use of
those spaces and trails reduced or banned.

Preferably banned. I don’t mind outside residents
to use our parks and trails, but the bikes must
be stopped in ruining once was a peaceful,
safe place to hike with children and animals.
• REMOVE BIKES FROM SENSITIVE TRAILS. The
only trail safe for biking is Lake Road. Bikes should
be banned from all other trails for safety to both
hikers and the hillsides. Cyclists are damaging
the environment and pushing hikers off the trail.
• Bike access enhances the outdoor experience
• The trails are amazing and best when
shared by all who love them!
• It is pertinent that mountain bikers restrain access
to Water Dog Open Space. It is a great sport
that provides recreational experiences that are
enjoyed by many people, for which the extent is
only increasing. On the whole, mountain bikers
are very considerate to hikers so it would be
very disappointing if a small group of anti biker
advocates paints an inaccurate image of us in
an attempt to limit access. As in your mission
statement, access should only be widened and not
narrowed in order to provide access to the greatest
number of people across different backgrounds.
• We have lived in Belmont Heights for 35 years.

The primary reason we purchased our home
was the natural beauty and serenity of the open
space surrounding us. The trails offer a sense
of peace, and the ability to appreciate and enjoy
nature’s gift of an undisturbed natural habitat
that protects our wildlife and vegetation.

To incorporate and encourage mass public foot
or bike traffic into our open spaces would destroy
the rare beauty and serenity that helps define the
City of Belmont. Bikers have already damaged
and modified our trails without permission, and
present safety hazards for trail walkers.
• I have been enjoying mountain biking in water dog
park and open space for years and now enjoy it
with my kids. I am very appreciative of the trail
system and respect it’s mixed use needs. Thank
you for maintaining it and keeping it mixed use.
• Keep Mountain Biking alive!
• I use the open spaces on a regular basis.

It’s close to my work and regularly access
Waterdog for lunchtime rides as well as
cutting through on my commute home.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
814
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 341

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Should be open for all uses
• Keep Mountain Bike Trail (Including
Class 1 E-Bike) access at Waterdog!
Please expand the access as well.
• I primarily go to Watertdog because I
can cycle and walk my dogs there.
• The John brooks trail sits behind my back yard.

I rarely use any of the water dog trails. They do
not feel safe with the proliferation of mountain
bikers who often have no regard for walkers
or runners. I love to walk in the neighborhood
on the streets, at the.xcountry trail or to drive
yo sawyer camp. But sadly water dog trails
just do not feel like a good option. I am also
greatly concerned about the destruction of the
natural habitat caused by these cyclists.
• More bike friendly trails and access.
• Please reclaim areas that have recently been
fenced off that belong to the City. People are
trying to make their yards bigger....this is illegal!
• Waterdog Open Space is an outstanding
open space for multi-use. Mountain biking
there is such an amazing space to use.
• STEWARTSHIP LIKE TRAILWORKERS,COM

AT WILDER RANCH IN SANTA CRUZ,CA
• What are the plans for keeping this as natural
as possible? Multi use trails are NOT safe and
40 years of trying to make this work has been a
failure with cyclists continually speeding, making
illegal trails and hitting hikers and equestrians
• Offers an exceptional opportunity
for off road cycling.
• Please put a skatepark keep kids out of trouble
• Skate parks
• The Belmont Open Spaces set a high quality
example of welcoming users of multiple types
(e.g. MTB, hikers) which others should aspire.
• more dog friendly
• Keep access open for us responsible mountain
bikers who also volunteer time to care for the trails
• Love the open spaces, however, there are
way too many mountain bikers who have
come too close to hikers. Please BAN the
mountain bikers from using the trails.
• Please limit the mountain biking at hidden
valley and water dog and the area near water
dog from Geraldine and village dr. it’s quite
dangerous for hikers. Enhancing the park
facilities would be great as well. San Carlos
parks have a lot more features (water pad).

A swimming facility would be great as well!
• Water Dog is great just as it is. There is no need
to make extensive changes there, except maybe
to manage the poison oak in certain sections. I
have been mountain biking there for over 20
years and am truly grateful to have it so close
to home. I would love to participate in some
trail maintenance opportunities for the park.
• More trails for hiking
• Thanks for the survey. I’m a hiker, trail runner, dog walker, and mountain biker. I filled out this survey
with mountain biking Waterdog in mind. It seems
lately, after over 20 years of riding Waterdog, that
hikers are upset and seem to feel that we are
unwelcome pests. There has been increased trail
use with COVID of course, and an increase in the
popularity of mountain biking. I’m hopeful that we
can all work together to share these great trails.

I’ve heard there is a vocal group that would like to
ban mountain biking within the park. I hope this
isn’t true and that you all understand that these
trails can easily be shared and loved. Thanks!
• Need to maintain mountain biking
access. Need to restrict e-bike use.
• NA
• Keep the open spaces - they are
the best thing about Belmont
• Mountain biking at Waterdog with my son has
been a profound experience. It has provided
an activity that bonds us, something that he
can improve at and be proud of, and gets us
doing something intensely physical and skilful
in nature. It is the antidote to screens.
• Preserve all forms of activity,
including biking and skating.
• Water Dog has always been bike friendly.

That’s where my kids learned to mountain
bike too. A vocal minority should not
change what has always worked fine.
• Same for Open Spaces
• I enjoy mountain biking at waterdog and fully
support that we maintain access to mountain
bikers along with hikers. I do not agree with
reducing access to mountain bikers, because
many people will ride even if it’s prohibited
and that would cause more tension between
mountain bikers and other park users.
• Please keep these spaces open for bike usage.

They are a true gem and rarity on the peninsula.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
815

APPENDIX I
342 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Thank you for allowing mountain bike
access! Keep working with the mountain bike
community to keep access open to all.
• We adore Water Dog park. My son rides there
with his friends at least 3x a week. It has
been a gift to have such an amazing resource
for his friends and him for outdoor exercise
within riding distance from our house.
• Keep waterdog open space open to mountain biking
• The trails are great. Would love to see more,
and more time spent building new ones!
• Please do NOT block mountain bike access to this
park, this is a popular destination for mountain
bikers. Mountain bikes do not damage or harm
the park any more than hikers or dog walkers
• Cycling in Waterdog is a great pleasure, and
one of the limited spaces available to cyclists
within short drive of San Francisco.
• Continue to allow bike access in Water
Dog Lake Park and open Space, and
in The Hidden Canyon Park!
• Bicycling and walking dogs is
very important in nature
• water dog is an excellent resource as it is. I would
not change a thing. The mountain biking folks
have done a LOT to make the space better.
• I have been mountain bike riding in the Waterdog
Lake Open Space since the 1990’s. Back then
there were far fewer trails to ride as there are
now. Over the years, trails have been added and
maintained by mountain bikers. So when I hear of
opposition to mountain bikers riding in Waterdog,
it disappoints and concerns me. Mountain bikers
should be credited with some of the trail expansion
and maintenance over the past few decades. I
am not blind to the fact that there are some
mountain bikers that ride with excessive speed
and poor etiquette. I have also witnessed hikers
and dog walkers that are guilty of poor etiquette
as well. But in all my years riding and hiking in
Waterdog, those folks are in the minority. Yet it
appears they have the loudest voices. I think
we all just need to get along, take a deep breath
and remind ourselves of the beauty we have
access to at Waterdog Lake Open Space.
• I was directed to this survey because apparently
there is a small but very vocal anti-recreation
group lobbying to limit access to open spaces
by restricting bikes. Whether or not this is true,
I’m hear to say how much I enjoy having these
trails to hike and ride right in my backyard. I
would also like to reiterate the PROS Guiding
Principles of “equitable access” and “inclusion”
and a reminder that people lobbying for
restrictions go against those principles. Thanks!
• Please keep waterdog fully open to cyclists. It is one of the few local opportunities for mountain biking.
• Biking on the trails is one of the
best parts of the open space.
• Biking is my daily exercises there after work for my
coworkers and friebds. Please don’t take it away.

We have been courtesy to all hikers and trail users.
• I go to Waterdog Lake at least once a week -- love it! • Open spaces should be available for mixed
use. Waterdog park especially is a fantastic
park for both biking and hiking and walking.

Widening trails and increasing signage and safety
information would be beneficial to everyone
who frequents the park and would make the
space safer and enjoyable for everyone.
• I love to mountain bike on your trails
• Access to mountain biking in waterdog is a
tremendous benefit to everyone who lives
from RWC to San Mateo - it’s the only place
like it and the only place many people can get
to routinely. Really enjoy and appreciate the
effort that goes in to providing such a luxury!
• Ensure an inclusive environment for all outdoor
enthusiasts i.e. continue to allow mountain
biking at Waterdog Open Space. We can all
get along and respect each other’s activity.
• Mountain biking deserves to have
access to the fun trails in your area
• Please continue access to mountain
biking at Waterdog!
• Please keep the open spaces
open to biked and dogs
• Keep single track at waterdog open
to mountain biking please
• Having Waterdog as an area close to home to
introduce kids to mountain biking is invaluable
• Waterdog lake is spectacular, providing a
place to mountain bike so close to home adds
excellent value to the area, I would pay a day
use fee or annual usage pass to keep the
mountain bike trails open at water dog lake.
• Please keep open for mt bikes
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
816
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 343

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I am strongly opposed to any project that
allows mountain biking in natural areas.

Do you really want the invasion of this destructive,
dangerous, and restricted self-centered activity for a
few with its consequent documented national history
of future expansion, destruction, and danger to
people (with permanent injuries and lawsuits against
the city), or do you value something more: a place
of reflection and connection with nature, others, and
oneself, giving us our full humanity, nature’s gift to
us all for generations past, present, and future?
• More trails for mountain biking at water dog please!
• Waterdog Lake is a beautiful preserve. I’m an old,
slow biker, and I love to ride from Crestview down
to Alameda Las Pulgas through the park on the fire
road. Please don’t take that route away from us.
• thank you for allowing bikes. I loved helping
build the lake loop in 2010. Though I didn’t
love all the poison oak I came home with!!!
It’s fun to see it being used as intended.
• Keep mountain bikes on trails at WDog.
• Waterdog and Hidden Canyon are full-on gems
for mountain biking in the area. With some
routine trail maintenance the area could be an
amazing and sustainably built which may help
address all the concerns that are being brought
up around that recently. The mountain biking
scene is known for being very interested in
volunteering for trail building and maintenance
(see santacruztrails.org) , but with little to none
of these opportunities in Belmont Open Spaces
where cycling is permitted, this creates much
more of a cost/overhead to the parks department
to do so and blame on the cyclists themselves.
• Keep them open to multi-use
• I currently live in Seattle and am planning a move
to the bay area for a new job (we are still house
hunting), and my wife and I were specifically hoping
to be close to Belmont since it seems like a great
neighborhood for our family, and because I love
to mountain bike and I heard Water Dog park is a
great place to enjoy the outdoors on a bike. I am
also unable to walk for long distances on uneven
ground due to knee troubles so a mountain bike is
the only way I can really enjoy the outdoors. I was
really sad to hear that the community is considering
banning mountain bikes please reconsider banning
what many people find as an important part of their
life and ability to enjoy time outside in nature!
• Our family enjoy the hiking and biking trails.
• They are great as is. Dog waste
is the only real problem
• Belmont open space trails are treasures by
cyclists- please do not take access away. Cycling
groups are historically some of the most active
in maintaining trails and are happy to help their
community find ways to exist with other use groups.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
817

APPENDIX I
344 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Bike access at Waterdog should continue... There
are far more parks in the area that prohibit biking
(Pulgas, Edgewood, etc) than allow it... Waterdog
is special and the access should be preserved.
• Multi-use trails that allow my kids and I to
mountain bike, hike. Hiking and biking with
parents. Kids are progressing with bicycle
skills and translating to everyday use.
• Keep Mountain Biking alive and well in Waterdog
• I love Belmont open spaces and would
love to see more trails for hiking and
mountain biking use! Thank you!
• Mountain biking in an incredibly sacred aspect
of Belmont’s overall culture, and remains an
excellent form of exercise, connection with nature,
and social activity that has transformed my life,
as well as that of countless others. Limiting it or
abolishing it entirely will simply bring many of your
park and open space goers elsewhere, negatively
impacting not only your reputation but also local
economy. Further, mountain bikers have been
responsible for much of the maintenance of their
own trail systems, so why not let them continue
a harmless act of community betterment?
• Belmont has amazing places to bikes and really
helps the Belmont library with book-a-bike!
• I have been a home owner in Belmont for 31 years
and have been an avid mountain bike rider and
a Waterdog trail maintenance and trail creator
with local bicycle stores for these 31 years. As
a Waterdog mountain biker I have volunteered
dozens of hours to park and trail maintenance.
• It’s important to keep access to mountain biking
• Water dog is great for mountain biking and
Carlmont is great for dirt jumping (on bikes). Kids
and I love having access to those activities
• N/a
• I use Waterdog as a place I can ride my bike to
keep up my cardiovascular health as I am unable
to run so biking is less impactful on my body. I am
in my 60’s and enjoy riding my bike at Waterdog.
• Keep to trails open and accessible to
everyone, except ebike riders.
• I love the biking availability in water dog
and surrounding open spaces
• Allow bike access!!!
• With local friends, mtn biking in Waterdog has been
the highlight of my year. It is challenging! Great
for learning skills, fun, and small and accessible.

I know of nowhere else in the Peninsula with it’s
varied and interesting terrain. I’ve learned a lot
here and enjoy every visit. I do limit my visits to
weekdays to avoid tthe higher use times. I’ve
been impressed that most folk are courteous
and happy! I have many fun places to hike, but
none approaching anything like Waterdog for
mountain biking. If you don’t bike here, you may
not realize what an incredible place this is for us.
• It needs more Mountain Bike Specific trails
made for and by with input from mountain
bikers. Skills development areas as well
• Please continue to allow full access to mountain
bike riders in open space areas such Waterdog
Lake Open Space. It is an amazing resource to
have both an excellent hiking, biking and family
friend space in the heart of the SF Bay Area. To
lose its mixed use would be a terrible shame.
• With all that open space, we should add
a mix use a disc golf course that shares
space with the hiking/biking trails.

Also, we should not limit the trail use further,
especially at Water Dog. I have a back injury
that prevents me from walking/running/hiking
but I am still able to get exercise by riding
my bike. Those trails (with their elevation)
are very important to my physical health.
• Bike trails in Waterdog are amazing and have
been well maintained by bikers for years, removing
access to them would be a giant mistake.
• Waterdog is a vital multi-use open space that is
enjoyed by mountain bikers, hikers, dog walkers and
runners. We must keep this open space open to all.
• It is nice having multi-use trails
for everyone to enjoy.
• Don’t disallow the bikers to enjoy
your open space areas
• Mounting Biking at water dog is a great
asset and should be expanded.
• Please allow us to continue mountain
biking at Waterdog, it has the best trails in
the area and the community is great.
• Open spaces are for all people. Let’s keep the trails open to all forms of recreation so that we can enjoy
the outdoors as a community not as adversaries.
• Biking and hiking waterdog with my family
has been a welcome respite during these
particularly tough times recently.
• We visit Water Dog Lake all the time and
feel very lucky to have this open space
to enjoy and appreciate nature.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
818
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 345

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• It’s so nice to have Waterdog
nearby for mountain biking!
• Please keep access to all, and do not limit trail use. • More trails needed.
• I mountain bike and I hike extensively on all
trails in Belmont. This activity on these trails
is the most important aspect of my personal
health. I will be happy to volunteer to help
preserve the trails for both activities.
• Beautiful trails that have been a so popular
to mountain bikers for years. Easy to access
for the local bike enthusiasts. Keep it open
for people who enjoy the sport and healthy
lifestyle by riding in open spaces.
• They are a treasure, between Water Dog Open
Space and San Juan, the habitat seems to be
thriving (aside from draught), and I think it is due to the sheer size. Can we talk to SF Water to remove
fences to allow even better wildlife passage?
• Bicycle and running trails are super important
and encourage outdoor exercise
• Please continue to support multi-use trails at
all open spaces. Please also support eBike
access. This helps the aging mountain bike
community and as long as they obey speed
limits should not be considered different
than conventional bikes. Thank you
• Waterdog is a treasure for multi-use. The
mountain bike community has had a great
relationship with the city and community.

Don’t let a small vocal minority wreck it.
• we LOVE mountain biking here.
please keep it open to us!
• I am in support of mountain biking at Waterdog.

It is a valuable resource to provide access to
mountain biking close to to where people live
• Penalties for people who don’t leash their dogs.
• Waterdog is a great and safe place to mountain
bike where I typically see families mountain biking
together. Most fellow mountain bikers I cross paths
with are friendly and courteous to other mountain
bikers and hikers. We always give hikers the right
of way. I’ve never seen any mountain bikers going
unsafe speeds, especially since we know that it’s
a popular park for bikers and hikers at all times.
• I love mountain biking with my dad at Waterdog.

Its an incredible space to get exercise and
with so many limited options for mountain
biking within city limits it makes this park
truly unique. Please don’t limit access!
• Glad we have them!
• The ability to ride my bike in Waterdog is one
of the best parts about living in Belmont!
• Waterdog and Hidden Canyon are the best
bike trail open spaces on the peninsula.

They truly are amazing and world class trails.

Please keep them the way they are.
• Strongly support mountain biking at Water Dog.

This has been a wonderful activity for my family
for years in a super safe and beautiful setting.

IF we lost this there would be nowhere to go.
• As an avid hiker, jogger, and mountain biker, I’ve
really enjoyed utilizing Belmont Parks and also open
spaces such as Water Dog. Open spaces is one
of the main reasons I moved into the area a couple
years ago, and has absolutely been a god-send
during the pandemic for me and my twin boys. I
know there has been some brewing debate over
whether to keep them multi-use or not, and I can
say that this is critical to me. I hike/jog about 50%
of the time, bike the other 50% of the time. In terms
of trail etiquette, I’ve had run in’s hiker to hiker as much as I’ve had biker to hiker, and even biker
to biker. (Note: I’ve also been harassed twice by
hikers while riding my bike!) My point is, it’s mutual
and we’re all in this together. Volume is up bc of the
pandemic, and I can only imagine nerves are frayed
and people are bumping into each other more
now (hopefully, we get back to a normal soon!). I
think more posted signs with positive reminders
of common courtesy, to mask up when around or
approaching others, and just common sense rules
of engagement would honestly go a long way! This,
vs unilateral or one-sided decisions with long-term
negative ramifications pitting one group vs another.

I’d be willing to volunteer to man educational
booths at the trail heads as well! Thank you!
• I think Belmont could use park rangers
and/or open space patrol.
• keep access open to biking in waterdog. limit
access to ebikes on all off-pavement areas.
• Keep and expand human powered
mountain bike access
Prohibit e-bikes on all singletrack
trails and on most dirt trails
• Enjoy mt biking at Water Dog
• Family interest is high to support
a bicycle pump track
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
819

APPENDIX I
346 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Waterdog Park is one of the very few mixed
use open spaces available on the east side of
280 on the Penninsula, which allows mountain
biking. This is an activity enjoyed on an intergenerational basis and is especially important for youth in the area that otherwise would be
unable to get to more distant trails for biking. In
my experience the trails are shared with other
users courteously, and the mountain biking
community has historically invested countless
volunteer hours in creating and maintaining trails
in the Waterdog open space. It is a unique gem on
the peninsula for riders to enjoy mixed use trails
with other members of the outdoor community.
• I as a minority love going to the park and feel even
safer when I see young kids riding their bikes their.
• Belmont needs to expand its open space
trail system making it accessible to bikes and
hikers. A good way to create harmony between
uses is designate trails one way and put up
signage as a reminder to be courteous.
• Our whole family enjoys use of the open space,
particularly the hiking and mountain biking at
Water Dog. It’s a great neighborhood amenity
and one that should be open to all uses.
• I’ve been grateful to mountain bike in Waterdog
for a number of years. It’s a treasure for those
“of a certain age” who now need E bikes, and
can find few places on the peninsula where
they are allowed. Please keep Waterdog
Park E Mountain Bike accessable.
• Allow more mountain biking and electric bikes.
• Continued access to mountain biking is very
important to me. I think that mountain bikers
have been generally very involved in trail
creation at Waterdog. I would be willing to
help with trail maintenance, brainstorming
about appropriate signage, etc.
• I love being able to mountain bike. Taking that
away would severely impact my opinion of my
city and home. There seem to be a few angry
non-athletic types that are hell-bent on ruining
life for the rest of us. Please don’t take away an
activity that my family is passionate about.
• Mountain bikers built and maintain those trails.

Please don’t limit them to hikers. We have always
coexisted just fine. If necessary, we can make
bike-only or hiker only sections of trails (there
are spots we ride that they cannot walk).
• Waterdog is a great place to mountain
bike and there aren’t enough such areas
in the Bay Area. It’s okay to make trails
one way if that makes folks feel safer.
• I would like you to know that inside Water
Dog Open Space, there are premier mountain
biking trails that have been shared with hikers
for over 20 years. Trails such as Rambler,
Elevator, Chaparral, John Brooks, etc. These
trails should be kept as combined hiking,
running, and mountain biking trails.
• Mountain biking needs to stay open at Waterdog.

This is a great local resource and people have been
riding there for many years. You would need to drive
a long distance to mountain bike somewhere else.
• Water Dog and Hidden Canyon owe their origins
to mountain bikers. Crowds during pandemic have
made things a bit tighter with hikers. Pandemic
will end. Biking’s impact on mental health is
huge and has driven bike industry shortages
during the pandemic. We should be looking
for ways to accommodate bikes and facilitate
smoother hiker encounters rather than baning.
• Please keep Waterdog open to recreational use for
hiking, running, and mountain biking. It is one of
the few places to easily access mtn biking without
a car. It’s a gem for car-free, teenagers, etc.
• Please keep Waterdog open to all trail users please!
• We should be able to keep mt biking and trail usage
for multi use as long as we maintain and care for
them. Most mt bikers I’ve met are courteous and
use proper trail etiquette. We can be a community
policing/enforcing community in Water Dog.
• The park is an extremely valuable resource
for the cycling community with very few local
trails open to bicycles. Its a place where
people can recreate safely after work on well
designed trailed trails. There is also very little
confrontation with other users because the trails
aren’t particularly dangerous or high speed and
it is very easy to share the trail with others.
• Please distinguish between the various classes
of E bikes when defining policies, class 1 E bikes
should not be treated the same as class 2 and 3
• Please maintain access to mountain
bikes! In face potentially expand the
number of trails for mountain bikers.
• Cycling is very important to me, sharing
trails with hikers and walkers and
others is very important to me.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
820
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 347

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water dog Park is a refuge from the hustle and
bustle of our daily lives. Please maintain equal
access for all existing trail users- hikers, jogger,
mountain bikers, dog walkers. It is important
to be inclusive, and have trails open to all.
• Cycling on the trails is a very important activity
for many people. When I bike at Waterdog, I see
lots of people showing up after work with their
bikes to enjoy the trails, which is made easier by
the proximity of their residences to Waterdog.
• Keep Waterdog and other Belmont
Parks open to bikes
• Less adulteration of biking trails. you already force us to a 15mph speed limit and now you want to rip
out anything that not flat or wheelchairr accessable.
• Please don’t band mountain bikes. Its a
large friendly community. Mountain biking
communities and organization help build
many trails, even hiker only trails.
• Please let mountain bikers be part of the priority
when planning access and maintenance
• Mountain Biking at Waterdog is an essential activity
• Please keep open spaces all inclusive. Recreation
and exercise of all types is extremely important.

Waterdog is one of the few places to quickly get
a mountain bike ride in near me, a vocal minority
should not dictate access to an area that has
been key to my health for so many years.
• Please do not close open spaces to mountain
bikes. This would be a huge disservice to a
large community. Instead I would focus on
educating all trail users on etiquette, invest
in smart trail design and increase volunteer
opportunities for trail maintenance
• This is where my kids learned to ride mountain
bikes, I hope this uniquely accessible land
remains accessible to families on bikes.
• Keep WaterDog open for mountain biking. It’s
one of the major benefits of Belmont and a
great location for outdoor biking close to home
with no car travel required to get there.
• Ciprian/Dog parks are my favorite places to
mountain bike. I also love the natural habitats.

I wish there are more bike specific trails.

The natural wildlife should not be disturbed
by large gatherings or construction.
• Waterdog is a gem for bicycling.
• Keep Waterdog open to bikers
• Please don’t limit or restrict
mountain biking in Belmont.
• Waterdog is a gem and haven for mountain biking.
• Keep bicycle access at Waterdog trails!
• Please ban bicycles from all unpaved trails!
• They are for everyone, and I fully support
MTB activities in those spaces.
• Trail conflict can be reduced with education so
one side does not feel they own a space over
another e.g mountain biker over hiker or vice Vera
• Let’s keep trails for mountain biking - great way
for kids to get moving and be outside. Waterdog is
a gem of a park that is unique in urban settings
• Please keep Waterdog open space
open to Mountain bikes.

Mountin biking is a popular way of experiencing
the bay area parks and open spaces. There a
many Mountain bikers of all ages in the community
and Water dog is a cherished park for us.
• Waterdog is valuable venue for mountain biking for
older riders such as myself (56yo) due to proximity
and to avoid driving to other peninsula preserved
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Waterdog is a gem. It is essential to keep
the open space accessible for multiuse including mountain biking! • Bike trails are great
• We appreciate single track riding in
Waterdog Lake Open Space.
• Mountain biking is an essential activity to many
of our families here in Belmont. It’s crucial we
continue to build and grow with our neighbors
this active lifestyle of mountain biking.
• Same as above :)
• Belmont’s Open Spaces are very rare and
special to me because of their mountain biking
trails. That is how I unwind, spend time with
my young son, and spend time with friends
and family. There are no other mountain
biking options that I can ride my bike to.
• Open spaces like Waterdog should
not be turned into a Nature Preserve
and take certain activities away.
• The mountain bike trail access at Waterdog lake
was one of the deciding factors when deciding
to purchase a home in the area. It is important
that we keep this trail open to all users!
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
821

APPENDIX I
348 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• It is important that we keep trails open to biking.

It brings people from all over the peninsula to
our town and helps businesses thrive in the local
community. Whether it’s to purchase bike related
products, a meal and beverage after the ride or
just running some errands in the neighborhood,
mountain bikers contribute to the local community.
• Bikes make the open space a more friendly and
lively environment. The more bikes the better!!
• I ride my bike about once a month in Waterdog.

I ride there from Mountain View. I’m a strong
proponent to keep Waterdog open to bikes, as
it is one of the few areas where bike riding in an
open space is permitted. I’m a strong believer
in multi-use open space recreation, which mean
walking, hiking, biking,... can all co-exist next to
each other. However, each group should follow
behavior etiquette rules, e.g. as a bike rider
I’m always extra courteous to hikers. However,
I also experienced that not all bike riders are
like this, so there is need for education. As well
as education for hikers, as I experienced very
often that despite several announcement calls
of me about to pass, hikers either move to the
wrong side of the path, not move at all, or occupy
the whole path. We all want to enjoy the open
spaces, which means each side needs to stick
to behavior rules, and respect each other.
• Please keep them multi-use (ie. allow MTB)
and also allowing eBikes. Posting trail sharing
etiquette signs will help but there’s no need to
ban MTB or try to turn Water Dog into something
it never was (ie. some kind of nature preserve).
• Open Spaces/Parks should be inclusive of all
levels of ability and all types of sports/activities/
exercise. Biking is a form of exercise for many
people in our area and we need to maintain mutiuse trails and respect different forms of exercise. • I absolutely love Waterdog for hiking,
trail running, and biking.
• We need mountain bike access
• Waterdog, Hidden Valley, and San Juan Canyon
are all tremendous gems for the Belmont and
surrounding communities. They allow for easy
access to nature for exercise, reflection and provide
an opportunity for us to introduce our children to
nature and to outdoor exercise such as hiking
and biking. It is wonderful that these areas are
accessible to all trail users. My children love biking
and hiking in Waterdog and it is great to have a
safe, car-free area for them to ride and walk.
• The fact that hikers and bikers
can share and get along.
• Please keep trails open to all users. My whole
family enjoys Belmont’s Open Spaces whether
it’s on foot or on 2 wheels. As one of the last
places on the peninsula open to bicycles, it is up
to Belmont to set an example of how multiuse
trails can be a valuable asset to the community.
• The allowance of mountain bikes on this trail
makes this open space treasured and a source
of pride. To limit or eliminate bikes on trails
due to a small number of users, relative to
bike riding users would be grossly unfair and
counterbalance the true user majority voice.
• Waterdog is one of the best Mountain Biking
locations in the Mid Peninsula region.
• Please don’t ban mountain bikes in any of the open
spaces, especially Waterdog and San Juan Canyon.
• Please do not restrict Mountain Bike access in
Belmont. Mountain biking is already over regulated
on the peninsula and Belmont is a gem/privilege
that we don’t take for granted. Let’s work together
to maintain the land and keep the trails safe so
that ALL trail users can enjoy the trail space.
• Please keep them Open to all multiuse
activities, unlike Foothills park in Los Altos.
• My Family, Friends and I have been riding
bikes at Waterdog and hidden canyon for
a decade. It is a wonderful frail system that
should stay open and friendly to mountain
biking as there are very few locations like it.
• Multi use is important.
• Please don’t ban biking, I love biking in Belmont.

It has been a godsend during COVID
• Please preserve mountain bike access at
Waterdog. Also engage mtb community
to assist with trail maintenance. Ok to ban
ebikes, or limit their use to specific trails.
• Mostly use Waterdog for family exercise with our
dog and mountain biking. Enhancing this area
for these activities are most important to us.
• Water dog park and the open space surrounding
it is a piece of mounting biking history and brings
the community together. Our local mountain
bikers are very respectful of the land and maintain
it better than any organized trail crew could.

This park is known throughout the country for
its mountain biking and must be protected.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
822
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 349

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• If you want to be inclusive, you need to allow
mountain bike access. For whatever reason,
there is a small but vocal group of people who
seem to think mountain biking isn’t a valid form
of recreation, but we could not disagree more.
• Mountain biking in Water Dog Park is awesome!
Let’s keep it open for mountain bikes.
• Please don’t restrict bike access to waterdog.

There are very few nearby trails open to bikes.
• Water Dog is ideally situated to continue to offer
some of the best mountain biking trails in the region.

Mountain biking is a healthy form of exercise and
should continue to thrive and expand in Water Dog.
• Leave Waterdog open to mountain biking. Maybe
designate mtb specific trails and directions.
• Mountain biking in Water Dog lake park is my
favorite use of the open space in Belmont.
• Belmont open spaces are important to local
mountain bikers. Mountain biking needs
an appropriate setting. Other activities that
can occur anywhere/everywhere should not
take priority over activities like mountain
biking that need certain conditions. Please
keep the cycling community in mind.
• I ride these too on my mountain bike that I recently
got and am trying to improve there I don’t go to any
other places so I’m praying it doesn’t get destroyed.
• There should be no changes to mountain
bike use in Water Dog. It is a good mix
today, and I use it for biking as well as hiking
and see no issues with mixed use.
• Ppl to leash and clean up after their dogs.
• We mountain bike at Waterdog and more guidance
would be nice. If we could have select trails
where hikers yield to mountain bikers and also
max speeds that would increase safety a lot.

Community build days would also allow hikers and
bikers to work together to maintain trails, taking
some effort off of the city and park to do so.
• Please don’t restrict bone access to waterdog.

It’s a great park and such a great place to ride.

I have never had any issues there or seen any
bad interactions between bikers and hikers.
• Keep Waterdog open to biking!!!!
• I really enjoy meeting with friends in the
summer evenings to bike at Waterdog and
then have dinner after in Belmont
• Nothing
• Nothing
• Do not limit mountain biking from Waterdog open
space. There are very limited places for mountain
bikers and this community should allow for different
outdoor activities and not limit to only a few.
• Bikes are needed and the majority of people
upswing open space are riding bikes
• Continue mountain bike access at waterdog
• I have health limitations and am unable to
go on extended hikes. I am able to bicycle
as long as I can use my electric assist
bicycle. I hope to continue to ride at Water
Dog and not have Belmont close it to me.
• Please don’t restrict access for bikers! Biking
is the one thing that has kept me (and many
others) sane during the pandemic. Please
maintain trail access for all users.
• Please keep this open to cyclists. Waterdog
is an amazing place to ride and closing it to
cyclists would crush so many people.
• More bike trails, or bike specific trails
• Mountain biking in Waterdog is a great
location and form of exercise.
• I enjoy hiking and Mountain Biking
at Waterdog mostly.
• Rumor is a group is trying to eliminate mountain
biking in water dog. I’ve been a regular biker
there since the early 90’s it would be a shame
to loose access to this wonderful place.
• Needs more mountain bike trails
built by professionals.
• Keep Water Dog open for mountain biking!
• The mountain bike trails are very important to me
both as a cyclist and hiker. I think keeping multi user access to the water dog trails is very important
• Water dog is a great resource for everyone.

There is no reason to change current rules.

Trails should CONTINUE to get shared by all.
• keep open, NO DEVELOPEMENT. You
keep widening the trails for the bikers, you
are turning nature trails into streets, Turn
the open space into nature preserves.
• Nice open space
• It’s my understanding the vast majority of trails in
the water dog open space preserve were created
by cyclists so it’s frustrating to hear residence
with more money are trying to curtail the use
of these trails to cyclist. I’m disappointing the
Belmont would entertain such a ridiculous Idea
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
823

APPENDIX I
350 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I moved to Belmont because of the biking trails
and it saddens me to see the hostility prevalent
recently. I think the additional pressure of the
pandemic has added to the numbers of users and
we could all do a better job of being nicer to each
other. I have a bell and I slow down for hiking
groups and still get uncomfortable comments.

On top of that, trails are getting wider and less
fun. I think we could improve the situation for
everyone by separating the user groups and
allowing volunteers from each user group to take
a larger role in trail maintenance and stewardship
• Please do not limit mountain bike access
to Waterdog Open Space. Mountain
bikers are great stewards and spend
lots of time maintaining local trails.
• N/A
• Opportunities to recreate in open spaces is very
important. Trail access must be equitable for
different user groups including mountain biking.
• Mt bike riders have only one accessible place
to ride in the mid peninsula, Waterdog/John
Brooks. For years we have enjoyed this space
without conflict, and have worked to maintain
trails. During the pandemic, the use by hikers
has increased resulting in some conflict, and
apparently, a well funded group lobbying to
prohibit mt biking. I urge the planning committee
not to give in to this group and consider the long
history of use and stewardship by mt bike riders
• We need to keep Waterdog as multi-use
including cycling. It is the mountain bikers who
volunteer and work on the trails, not the hikers.
• I recently discovered the sport of mountain
biking and it is an amazing way to connect with
the city as well as nature. I wish there were
more opportunities to help trail building!
• Do not restrict mountain biking
• Please keep mountain bike access!!!!! It is
a healthy option fort people if all ages!!!!
• Please respect the history of trails in waterdog/
hidden canyon areas that were created by mtn
bikers with layout help from park rangers. Keep
these trails open for mtn biking with no restrictions
• Keep water dog lake park bike trails
• Limiting mountain biking is a mistake. Mountain
biking brings sustainable revenue and access to
a significant number of Trail Stewards to assist
in sustainable maintenance of trail systems.
• Waterdog is for biking! Don’t let hikers take that
away from us, it has been a biking spot for 30 years
• Please keep mouNtain bike acccess to water dog
• Mountain biking in water dog open space is a
great way to get together with friends. Really
glad it’s so accessible from neighborhoods
and workplaces in the peninsula.
• Maintain access to open spaces for
mountain bikes! Safe, healthy exercise!
• Keep mountain biking at waterdog please
• Add more trail systems for bikers. Keep
Waterdog park open for mountain biking and
multi-use (walking, running, dog walking)
• I think mountain biking is a great sport that gets
people of all ages out in nature and exercising.

The sport is growing fast and is great for the
community. Not just for health but and for the town
economy. Lost of people visiting spending money
• Great local mountain bike area, good
stress reliever for me after work
• N/A
• Waterdog needs to stay open to mountain bikers.
• Please keep mountain biking a part of Water Dog.

There are so few accessible mountain bike parks
in the Bay Area and this one is a rare gem.
• I love mountain biking!
• Please keep open to mountain biking.
• Keep mountain biking at waterdog, it’s a gem!
• Water dog rocks! I have been riding Waterdogs
trails on my mountain bike with friends and
family for 15 years and enjoy that it is so close
• Multi use open spaces for hiking, walking,
running, mountain biking, etc. are perfect.
• Mountain biking in Belmont open spaces is
one of my favorite things to and that is one
reason I live as close to Belmont as I can
• We love to Mountain Bike through
Waterdog. It’s just around the corner and
a unique open space in the city.
• Belmont is best known for its
mountain biking so why ban it?
• Mountain biking trails are amazing and I use
them all the time and donate money and
volunteer hours for their maintenance
• Keep it open to bikes including ebikes please! But
ok having a speed limit if pedestrians feel unsafe.
• Watedog park is one of the few area available
to ride mountain bikes (ebike and anonlogy)
in Belmont only have had positive interaction
with other hikers and bikes using the trails
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
824
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 351

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Most mountain bikers are hikers too, and we want
to share these parks/open spaces! We always try
to follow good trail etiquette and I’ve never had
any issues with other Trail users. There are only so
many parks and open spaces available for mountain
bikes, it’s important to protect ongoing access!
• Have more trails to mountain biking, it’s
a great sport, my son lost 15 pounds by
doing mountain biking and he loves it.
• Reference the Mid-Pen policy for e-Bikes
& people with mobility disability. Maybe
have a small laminated placard (like
handicap placards for vehicles) which can be
attached to the handlebar of the e-Bike.
• I love the mountain bike trails.
• Great place to ride mountain in the middle of an
urban area. It is a gem for trails and riding.
• Water dog is an amazing space for recreation.

As an avid trail runner, hiker, and mountain biker,
I appreciate it’s proximity to my house - I can
run and bike from my front door! I am in strong
support of keeping water dog available to multiuse, it’s an important asset to our community, and it drives people local businesses in the area
as a result of it being a mid-week destination
for trail runners, hikers, and mountain bikers
• Keep trails open to bikes
• Set the paths as one direction, like demo
or skegs- it will keep riders and bikers
safer using the trails together
• We need to keep these open to all activities. Recent
limitation on biking and ebiking is excluding a large
segment of Belmont residents. Open spaces should
be accessible to all residents and all activities
• As part of the plan, I’d like to request that mountain bikers retain access, particularly at Water Dog. It’s
a beautiful area and provides mountain bike riders
with a great way to get exercise and enjoy nature.
• I primarily use Belmont’s open spaces while biking
on the Peninsula. They’re a treasured space and
I value the ability to bike through open spaces like
Waterdog. I believe we can both maintain access to
Waterdog but also preserve its natural character.
• Please keep trails open to mountain bikes
• do not close the trail for mountain biking.
this is discriminatory for people who
live far from other available trails.
• Please keep the current multi-use purposes of trails
and expand number of biking trails where possible.
• The effort to limit or bar mountain bikers from
Waterdog Park is incredibly unfair to those of us
who are responsible and considerate riders, and
who enjoy and respect the beauty of the open
space. I have been visiting the park and riding the
trails since the early 90’s. It is especially unfair to consider limiting access given that many of the
trails were built by mountain bikers. Without them,
the park trail system would not be what it is today.

Perhaps the key is education and posting of “rules”
that many long time riders are very familiar with
— yielding or slowing for hikers, yielding to uphill
riders, not riding in wet conditions, etc. We should
all be able to share the trail system and do it in
a way that is safe and enjoyable for everyone.
• Please keep access open to mountain bikes!
• Keep open to all users (walkers,
dogs, cyclists, hikers, etc).
• More mountain biking trails would be nice.
• My whole family loves mountain biking
at Waterdog! Fun spot... thanks!
• Strongly feel that bicycles should have more
access to open space areas. During the
pandemic there has been an increase in bicycle
and this will continue in the future I believe.
• Keep building more trails for the youth
they truly love getting out there.
• One of few places in the Bay Area that has easy
access to mountain bike trails without long drive
into the mountains. More communities should
expand biking in these city parks for this reason
and makes Belmont an area I would like to
live in. Reduction of mountain bike access in
Belmont parks would limit accessibility to those
who do not have means (car/bike rack/etc) or
time to go to more remote trail networks.
• I love being able to step into nature so easily!
• Keep and enhance all cycling opportunities
including mountain biking
• Waterdog is a gem of an open space and to be
able to ride my bike to mountain biking trails
like these is a big joy in my life of fitness.
• Keeping trails open for hikers mountain
bikers and pets is very important
• Waterdog is an absolute gem, including for
gravel and mountain bike use. If anything,
it would be great to further expand the
number of trails for bike access.
• love Waterdog for mountain biking. Wish the
Cross Country Trail was open to bikes.
• Keep Waterdog open to mountain
biking and multi-use
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
825

APPENDIX I
352 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Water dog is truly a gem for the
mountain bike community.
• Keep bikes alive
• Keep the mountain biking!
• Consider a Mountain Bike Steward
program for open space to help educate
and teach proper trail etiquette.
• Keep bike access to trails in waterdog park!!
• Waterdog park is one of the best mountain
biking/running trail network around.

Please keep biking available
• Really enjoy biking running and walking
at Hallmark and Waterdog
• Love mountain biking at Waterdog.

Please limit electric bikes.
• Love MTB at waterdog!
• We should allow for all activities for hiking biking
and walkers. We all deserve an outdoor space!!!
• Water Dog is where I first learned to mountain bike,
and how I made new friends in the area. I’m thankful
that the city keeps this space open to bikes, and
am happy to be a part of the volunteer maintenance
group to help maintain the trails for all users.
• I would love to see an increase in Mtn bike trails
throughout the open space. There are so many Mtn
bikers and not enough space. All of our friends are
into it and we have friends that come from miles
around to ride with us. I think it’s a great opportunity to drive business in Belmont, similar to Santa Cruz
• Biking in Waterdog is one of the great trails in the
Bay Area. Please keep this open to all! Bikers
and hikers together make it a great open space
• Waterdog is a gem amongst the peninsula,
especially for it’s unique accessibility to all groups
from small children in strollers (lake road) to
mountain bikes. This inclusivity is amazing.
• Keep Waterdog Open for Hikers and Mountain
bikers. We’ve been riding, coexisting, and
showing respect to each other for over 10 years.
• We love Waterdog! Keep it open
for hiking and biking.
• love the mountain biking comraderie at
waterdog open space, hikers and mountain
bikers share the space quite nicely
• Mountain biking trails are popular and most
bikers are considerate of hikers and walkers.

More singletrack trails will help ease the traffic
on more popular hiking/walking trails.
• Keep waterdog accessible to biking. It
is just as important as walking.
• Biking at water dog has saved my sanity. As a new
mother I was so grateful to have a place to mountain
bike so close to home where I could exercise
without spending hours apart from my baby driving
to skyline. It has need a great place to walk after
work and introduce my child to hiking and biking. It
is something so special and unique (first drove from
sf to bike back when I lived there) that not many
communities have. With so many other hiking and
jogging options I hope this park stays bike friendly.
• More information about mountain biking trails
• Do not limit trail use
• I only discovered Waterdog during the COVID
shelter-at-home orders last year, and I am so
thankful that this place exists. I have taken
my family there for biking many times and it
has helped to keep my family both physically
and mentally healthy during this pandemic. In
addition, when we visit Waterdog we also stop
at the nearby Carlmont Village shopping area for
lunch and coffee and I have started shopping at
Belmont Bikes. Keeping Waterdog accessible
to bikers and hikers helps Belmont’s economy.

With the pandemic, there are many new
users to the open space and they need to be
educated on proper trail etiquette, posted signs
and outreach will help to keep it enjoyable for
both experienced users of Waterdog as well
newcomers to the benefits of Waterdog.
• Keep it accessible to everyone
• They are open to all people . Close
enough to take my family on hikes and bike
riding. And how to appreciate nature
• Please retain mountain biking use at Water Dog,
it’s the only area close to me that I frequent often.
• My wife and I really enjoy the
mountain biking at Waterdog.
• It would be great to see expanded access to
mountain biking and more mountain biking
trails in Belmont’s open spaces as that is our
family’s primary activity, and the primary use
activity for many families that we know.
• Preserve multi-use trails
Require all mountain bikes to use a bell on
handlebars to announce their approach
Ban e-bikes - too dangerous. No
different than “lite” motorcycle
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
826
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 353

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Belmont Open Space has been a gem of a
spot for access to mountain biking. As an avid
mountain biker and a lover of the outdoors, I
expect the trails to be remain as multi-use for
all to enjoy. Mountain biking is not a crime. It
is merely another form of outdoor activity.
• world class mountain biking. point of city pride
• Though many of the trails were built by and
maintained by mountain bikers, Waterdog
Lake is one of the few open spaces in the
area where all trail users are welcome. We
should resist the urge to limit use, however
motor vehicles do not belong on the trails
(E-Bikes). The trails are well built for 25-30 lb
bikes, but not for 50-60 lb motorized vehicles.
• Keep access to mountain bikes. Engage
the Mt. Bike community to build trails.
• Keep Waterdog available to mountain
bikers. Do your share to provide space for
riders. There are so many places for hikers
already. We can all coexist easily.
• I’m a hiker, trail runner, dog walker, dad, and
mountain biker. I’ve been doing all of these
activities at waterdog for 20 years. Myself, and
countless other mountain bikers have spent
many hours working on these trails, going
back to Passion Trail Bike days long ago.

I feel like lately, perhaps with the increase in users
since COVID, and the increase in the popularity of
mountain biking, that people are angry every time
they see a bike on the trail. I’m polite, and always
yield to hikers. Many of these individuals are new to
the outdoors and are unfamiliar with mountain bikes.

Please don’t let these people try to limit or
end our use on bikes. Waterdog is one of
the only areas around that allows bikes.

Thank you for listening and thank you for the survey!
• I strongly support the use of bikes at
Waterdog Park. My experiences with shared
use on the trails has been positive.
• Water Dog / Hidden Canyon is one of the great
peninsula MTB resources. There are very few local
MTB trails anywhere on the peninsula that offer
the same level of mountain biking challenge.
• Expand mountain biking access
• It’s known in the peninsula as a mountain bike
destination with friendly locals. Mountain bikers
are known to be very active in maintaining
the trails and keeping it beautiful
• Waterdog is a treasure and the mountain biking
community gives back a great deal to maintaining
the trails here. I take my family mountain biking
here all the time and it’s perfect for them.
• Mountain biking could be easily expanded and
many volunteers/collectives would assemble to help.
• The open spaces are an amazing asset for all local
residents to get out enjoy and the outdoors and
some exercise. I have been mountain biking at the
trails at waterdog park for 15 years and appreciate
having this amazing space in my backyard. I find
riders to be very thoughtful , respectively sharing
the trails with all users. I have heard recently
that a small group wants to restrict or completely
prohibit mountain biking at water dog - that
would be a mistake and unfair to a group that
has been a good steward of the open space..
• Keep mountain biking in all open spaces.

It is an activity many of us do frequently
as our primary means of exercise.
• It is a great resource for mountain bikers, and I
hope it stays that way. I am willing to help with
maintenance, and I always make an effort to be
considerate to hikers so we can all enjoy the space.
• For 25 years I have been riding mountain bikes in
the Waterdog Open space preserve(back when
the lake had waterdogs in it). I have spent days
building permitted trails and have many riding
friends who have done the same. It is the best
urban mountain biking trails in the bay area located
in our backyards. It makes me sad to think some
would to take these trails, a lot of them built and
maintained by many bikers, away from us. It also
is a destination place. bringing many to support
local restaurants down the street, not to mention
our new bike shop “Belmont Bikes” which has
made Carlmont shopping center a destination
center itself. With the disappearance of local ice
rinks, I do not believe we need to narrow our
choices of recreation. There are many of us, why
can we keep our choices of recreation open.
• Please do not close trails to mountain bikes.
• It’s special because it is a multi-use open space.

My family and I hike and bike there often.
• I love that I can walk and mountain bike right
from my house and get peace and quiet, nature,
exercise and a challenging ride. I see people
using the trails for many different reasons and
respecting each other and getting along.
• Waterdog Open Space is a valuable
resource for me for after work bike rides.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
827

APPENDIX I
354 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• There needs to be more access mountain
biking. Bike sales and purchases generate a
lot of sales tax income. I don’t like riding with
the kids on multiple use trails and having to
compete with hikers and horses. Biking deserves
its own trail network and accessibility.
• Leave trails open for multi use!
• Have really enjoyed mountain biking at
Waterdog with friends and would like to
continue to come to Waterdog in the future.
• Please keep all bike trails and add more if possible.

We need more trails to enjoy the outdoors and
be respectful and responsible with nature
• Many Respectful Mountain Bikers visit
Water Dog and spend time and money at
Belmont due to the trails. Please do not
limit Mountain Biking at Water Dog.
• Please preserve mountain biking at Waterdog
Lake Park, it is one of the few easily accessible
trail networks in the area for locals and its
generally well maintained by volunteers
• Keep and maintain the mountain biking trails!
• I ride mountain bikes with my two sons multiple
times a week at Waterdog. I work in San Carlos. My
two sons go to school in Belmont. It is a fantastic
open space that is close to home and work.
• Waterdog is a local treasure that has allowed
me to get at least 5 non-active people out on
mountain bikes and become nature people.
• Keep mountain biking at water dog
• Waterdog open space is a hidden gem! I
often visit to bike and hike the trials either
with friends or family (I live in Foster City).

The trials must remain open to all.
• We love mountain biking here. Everyone
enjoys nature a different way. For us it’s
biking. Don’t take away my nature time.
• please keep Water Dog open to mountain biking
• Please keep them open to mountain bikes, it is
one of the few places left to ride in the area.
• I’ve been riding my mountain bike at waterdog for
about 5 years now. It’s a great form of exercise
and my friends and I are very respectful of all
other hikers and bikers. In my opinion the bikers
actually outnumber the hikers by a great margin
and I think it’s ridiculous that this small group
of individuals think they have the right to close
down the parks to all mountain biking. I see
mountain bikers of all ages enjoying the trails and
I hope to still be riding there for years to come!
• Waterdog is an amazing place. I use it
once a week for a mountain bike ride with
friends and it a highlight of my week.
• Mountain biking at waterdog is so much fun!!!
• Allowing mountain bikers at Waterdog is beneficial
for the broader community. Mountain bikers maintain
trails and look out for people/animals/nature in
distress. Mountain biking promotes health and
well being, and is a positive experience for young
people. Without activities like mountain biking young
people turn to crime, drugs and antisocial behavior.
• Please keep mountain biking open
in belmont open spaces
• I wish there was more mountain biking allowed.
• I mostly use Waterdog to mountain bike and
walk my dog. I would like to see the dog leash
requirement a actively enforced. I would estimate
that 4 out of 5 people with dogs on the trail
have their dog off leash. At minimum signs
should be posted that dogs must be on leash.
• Water dog is one of the best mountain biking
trail systems on this side of the peninsula. It
offers a rare opportunity for hikers and bikers
to recreate in nature so close to an urban area.

The outdoor recreation use here needs to be
preserved so many can enjoy the wonderful trails.
• I’d like to advocate for safe mtn biking.
• Before taking drastic measures to appease
minor, yet vocal, opposition to shared trail use,
please consider small measures to increase
awareness and respect amongst trail users.

The term “stewardship” is a good one that the
trail community has been using more regularly
in the area. Trail users are, in general, all out
for the same reason, and with respect and
awareness trails can be enjoyably used by all.
• Try are great
• These are the only local mountain bike
trails. Please do not take them away.
• The open space areas of Belmont are what
makes Belmont such a great and unique place
to live. Being able to run/walk/bike to one of
the opens spaces is a great way to get outside,
exercise, and spend time with the family. I don’t
understand the constant chatter about bikers/
hikers not getting along. I’m out there as a runner,
hiker, and biker...and I’ve never experienced
any hostilities from either side in my 16 years
of living here. It really baffles me. Most times
is actually quite the opposite with everyone
being polite and friendly to one another.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
828
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 355

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I strongly support cycling at WaterDog. For the past
12 years I have frequented those trails with friends
and family on our bikes for both fun and exercise.

It’s a great spot to ride to and enjoy the trails from
the house without having to drive. I encourage the
commitment to cycling at WaterDog and would
love to see Belmont embrace an already strong
base of cyclists in the area who enjoy this space.
• I mountain bike at Waterdog a few times a week
and appreciate that I can get there from my home
in San Carlos without having to drive! My son
also learned how to mountain bike at Waterdog,
as it has a wide range of trails for both beginners
and seasoned riders, so it is a good place to
learn and to improve! I love it and have been
going there regularly for the past 15 years!
• Please maintain bicycle access to
Waterdog Lake Open Space.
• We need more access for bicycling. More trails,
and pumptracks. There are so few places to
ride trails that everyone has to go to the same
trails. More trails that are close to residential
areas so people dont have to drive to the trail
head. Please dont take away biking access from
any open space. Open more trails please.
• Access for mountain biking is very important to
me. I have lived here for 19 years and this has
always been a safe and accessible recreation for
me and my family. Please do not ban mountain
biking at Waterdog. This has been a peaceful
coexistence of hikers and bikers and everyone
who enjoys the open space. I hope we can
find a way to preserve access for everyone.
• As a family, we very much appreciate Waterdog
and the biking/hiking available there. Thank you!
• Keep the legendary Waterdog open to mountain
bikes. Perhaps not e-bikes though.
• Keep em open
• Biking trails are necessary in these areas,
it’s a great way to encourage fitness
and bring communities together
• Waterdog is the best for biking! So grateful
to have a biking spot so close to home.
• Mountain biking access is critical. Currently
mountain biking in Waterdog area is a
fantastic experience, which I have used for
years. I have friends who live in Belmont and
we all enjoy it. Restricting access due to a
loud minority pushing an agenda would be
a true disservice to your constituents.
• I’d love to see mountain biking eliminated
at waterdog. I hate watching our trails keep
being rutted by bikers in the rain muds.
• Continue to allow use by bikers,
hikers and runners. Limit dogs
• keep open spaces open to mountain bikes
• Please keep water dog park open to bikes and
prioritize trail maintenance and etiquette for all
user types rather than closing anything down
• Please allow and expand mountain biking at
water dog! Some hiking only trails combined
with some biking only trails could work well.
• Waterdog is a special place for mountain
bikers and families. Many places in the bay
area have open space that safely and sensibly
share the trails for riders, hikers, families.
• Water Dog Open Space is a wonderful
place for mountain biking, one of the few
on this side of the mountains, an even on
the peninsula. It has the potential to be a
wonderful mixed use area for everyone.
• I would really advocate for keeping mountain
biking at Waterdog, it’s great to have a local
park where we can do this activity. (I”m a middle
aged woman, and yes, I mountain bike too)
• The trails take continuous maintenance to
prevent erosion and maintain rideability
• Mountain bikers are a vital part of the northern
California outdoor community, and Belmont
open spaces are a great opportunity for
mountain bikers to access and enjoy nature.
• Mountain biking is Belmont’s biggest draw for me.

I usually get food at a local restaurant after rides.
• I love Waterdog for not only hiking/dog walking
but mountain biking. I am disappointed to hear
there is a vocal minority out there that is opposed
to mountain biking/multiuse of this beautiful area.

Unfortunately, having roots in the north bay this
is not a new phenomenon to me but I guess
I naively expected better from my peninsula
neighbors. Please do not bow to these elitists.
• They are fantastic and let people enjoy them
with as few restrictions as possible.
• Mountain bikers are respectful of the space. Please
oh please don’t limit our access. I beg of you.
• Waterdog has always been taken care of,
and loved by mountain bikers. It needs to
remain open for mountain bikers. More places
to ride means less crowded trails, trails in
better shape, and more opportunities.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
829

APPENDIX I
356 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Waterdog Canyon is an amazing resource and an
absolutely beautiful place to escape the noise of
hectic Bay Area life. I feel like the trails are wellmaintained, though there may be too many - its quite the maze. Trail signage is not clear, and
does not include a “You are here” indication.

These trails should remain multi-use! There are so
little biking trails, or trails that allow dogs - these activities need to remain accessible to residents.
• Please preserve, maintain and improve the
mountain and road bike access to open
spaces. The cycling community is a large
part of the soul of the Penninsula.
• I’ve been My biking in Belmont open
spaces for over 20 years and would hate
to see this right be taken away.
• due to the pandemic Waterdog is one of the
places where I can easily maintain my mental
health by MTbiking around. I’ll be happy to
help in maintain and restore the trails
• Waterdog Park is a relatively hidden gem and
a wonderful resource for trail biking that was
riding distance from our home in Belmont (unlike
most places that are still legal to ride), and an
easy ride from parking at shopping areas. The
trails are a great place for riders of all ages to
learn to love mountain biking without the risk
and difficulty of the bigger places that still allow
bikes, such as Corte Madera (aka Skeggs).

When we lived there I, like many other cyclists,
helped build and maintain those trails. There are
so few places left to ride a bike in the woods in
the Bay Area, particularly for relative novices
or younger riders, and it would be an immense
tragedy to close them to the cycling community,
who care as deeply about experiencing nature
as those who prefer to enjoy the trails on foot.
• Need to forbid mountain bikes as they are
greatly damaging the trails and are very
dangerous to hikers, especially the electric
bikes. Way way too many bikers that do
not live in Belmont are frequently coming to
waterdog to bike. Most are going too fast
and do not watch out for kids or hikers.
• I mt bike in Waterdog often as it’s one of a few
trails that is close to home (<20 min drive), but is
one of the more enjoyable technical trails. A lot of
inner city trails are dumbed down, i.e. Arastradero
is paved now. There’s no other nearby trails that
offer similar experience to really being out in the
mountains. It’s easily accessible after work. I like
going on Mondays when Off the Grid is scheduled.

When I ride, I use a bell, Timber bell to be exact.

This constantly alerts others that I am coming
around the corner. I don’t try to ride to set KOMs.

I’m cautious about other trail users. My experience
is riders hear the bell with no problem, even as
they approach at speed. Hikers on the other hand,
act like they don’t hear it. They act surprised
like they didn’t see me, but they do, and they still
don’t get out of the way. I’m polite to stop and let
them pass. I understand where they’re coming
from. There are other riders that are pure dicks
who just want to ride for speed. But there are also
ignorant hikers who aren’t considerate to move out
of the middle when others (riders or hikers) want
to pass. I’m for signage to emphasize sharing the
trails and proper etiquette. I’m also for promoting
bells for all users. It would be nice to have 1 or
2 downhill designated trails for both hikers and
riders to avoid approaching traffic. I think this may
help all have fun. And if they’re having fun, maybe
they’ll consider pitching in to maintain the trails like some MTBers do. I don’t see hikers pitching in.
• Having Waterdog trails built for multiuse
over the past few decades has been a
wonderful use of this space. I mtn bike
for over 30 yrs, so I love having trails.
• Local MTB access is crucial! It is one of the greatest amenities of Belmont’s park/open space system.
• Would ask not to remove mountain bike
access. There are so few legal trails and with
the sport’s growth in popularity and helping
people to get outdoors and exercise, removing
access would not be a good answer. Would
suggest for multi-use setting up days for different
activities. For example, odd days are for
hiking and foot traffic, even days for bikes.
• We love open spaces. Spaces
that are open to all uses.
• We have plenty of accessible preserve space
in the region. I want to see Belmont continue
to use Waterdog and its associated areas
for outdoor recreation, particularly biking.
• Bike trails are great
• Mtn. Biking should be open to trails in Water
Dog open space. Do not limit or ban biking.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
830
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 357

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Please do not reduce multi-use trail access
particularly for cyclists. Trail maintenance,
education, and etiquette guidance are
ways for multi-activity users to coexist
well and keep trails in good condition.
• Keep mountain biking
• Keep bicycle access in all parks
• Maintain bike access at waterdog
• Mountain bike trails are great. Thank you!
• Belmont Open Spaces must be
designated as an Open Preserve.
• All trails currently open to mountain biking need
to remain that way. We bought a home in Belmont
for access to these mountain biking trails
• There’s no perfect world for anyone, we
all want to enjoy the open space and may
do so through different activities. Mutual
respect and helpful resources to facilitate
everyone’s enjoyment seem the best way to
address concerns from distinct groups
• nothing, i love you guys man
• Do not make rules about open space access
that are more restrictive than current. A vocal
minority does not represent the current users.
• Water Dog is one of the nicest Mountain
Biking areas on the peninsula, especially midpeninsula. I’ve been riding at Water Dog Park for 10+ years and have never encountered
an issue with other riders or with hikers. Both
coexist very well. It would be an absolute
tragedy if mountain biking was to banned. I
see all ages and ethnicities riding the park.
• My primary use of Belmont’s open spaces
is to mountain bike and is the sole reason I
visit Belmont. While I am in town I purchase
fuel, shop, and visit restaurants.
• I want to encourage the continued shared use of
open spaces allowing cyclists, hikers, e-bikers and
others to coexist as they have for the 15 years I’ve
lived in Belmont. Bikers at Waterdog have organized
and have helped maintain trails for over a decade.

New generations of kids growing up in Belmont
love to cycle and are taught to be respectful of
others. Allegations of conflict/accidents with hikers
or environmental degradation aren’t based on facts.

Helping everyone coexist by creating etiquette
guidelines and signage and encouraging bells on
bikes, discouraging headphones on everyone,
etc. could be helpful, but after riding for 15 years
I feel confident in my many interactions that we
are all able to share our resources happily.
• Keep them open for bikes
• It is critical to maintain unrestricted mountain
bike access to Waterdog Park. It’s one of the
few excellent areas to ride on the Peninsula.
• Waterdog is a premier biking location in the
area and it is critical to a bunch of us to keep
it open to biking. I wear a bell on my bike
and am always courteous to pedestrians.

Please keep biking options open on trails.
• Please continue to embrace mountain biking it is the
beat way to get the youth invested in preserving and
loving nature while involved in an exciting activity
• Mountain bike advocates built the trails in
Waterdog and should not be restricted.
• I really enjoy mountain biking in the open
space on the weekends. It’s one of my favorite
things about living here. As a father of 3
it’s an amazing amenity for our family.
• Please continue to provide trail access for
mountain bikes. Trail access is very difficult to
come by in the Bay area without having to drive
a car to it. Cyclists can ride to Waterdog Park
from their homes and ride trails. This is better
for our society’s collective carbon footprint.
• Mountain bike trails and access are very important
to the community - I have ridden at Waterdog as a
youth as mountain biking started in the 1980’s - this
is an important open space that is important to the
community and a mountain biking community that
maintains trails the park and other members equally.
• belmont was an amazing place to come mountain
bike after school growing up. i’ll never forget
the bonding my father and i were able to have
on easily accessible trails. one of the benches
now resides in his name, and i come back
now and again to visit him and remember.
if you were to remove mountain biking from
this place, i would loose a part of my family
• Waterdog Park was instrumental in the
development of my love of mountain biking and
building a strong community of bike friends.
• Keep mixed use! Do not restrict bikes.
• As I age my ability to enjoy the outdoors becomes
more limited. In particular, I cannot walk for more
than about a mile... but I can ride a mountain
bike a much further distance and this allows me
to continue to enjoy the outdoors. I’m very much
opposed to limiting access to mountain bikes
because it limits my ability to enjoy the outdoors.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
831

APPENDIX I
358 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I’ve been riding Belmont’s open spaces for
the past 20+ years. It is an amazing place in
my back yard. Please do not change that.
• Wonderful
• We LOVE biking the trails in Waterdog.
• Rare to find this in the bay and in particular,
so amongst the neighborhood
• The open spaces are an excellent way to be in
nature and to exercise either through mountain
biking, running, or hiking. There’s plenty of space
for all and they NO impact on the environment.
• I love the open spaces and get most of my weekly
exercise and some of the family exercise there too.

The number of loose dogs in Waterdog is a
concern though, many owners have them offleash on the trails, scaring wildlife, causing near encounters with bikers and scare kids that might
not be comfortable with large loose dogs up close.
• We love mountain biking at Water Dog! It is where
my son learned to ride trails. It is a treasure
and it’s shared use should be preserved.
• Keep the bureaucrats out of the park
• Its extremely important to keep access to a wide
variety of uses. Limiting our Open space to fit the
needs of a minority of users will hurt our community.
• Waterdog Lake is my favorite place to mountain
bike, locally. It’s amazing. Hours and hours
of volunteer work have made the place a
wonderful (MULTI-USE) playground.
• I like to ride my bike at Waterdog Park frequently.
• Please keep water dog open to all users
who use it right now. Bikers, Hikers, Dogs,
etc. Improve it, do not go backwards.
• Mountain biking saved my mental health.

Please keep water dog open for bikers
• Keep Waterdog accessible to bikers!
• Expand into more spaces if
possible and connect them
• Mountain biking is a huge economic boost.

Please take advantage of its massive growth
over the last few years and it’s huge potential.
• Love mountain biking at waterdog, it is
the only reason I go! Best place to do it.

Please continue and expand use
• I love water dog lake park for its mountain bike
trail! It is the only place I can ride after work and
is a wonderful place to ride. I’ve only had positive
interactions with other trail users and would
love to keep that access or even expand it!
• Love to hike and bike in water dog park. It is great
to have such a nice open space so close to home.
• I have built trails and mountain biked Waterdog
for the last 20 years. Waterdog is an important
mountain biking destination and most of the trails
exist because of the hard work the mountain biking
community put in there. I do hope that this plan
will continue to allow access to this great local
resource to the mountain biking community.
• Please keep Waterdog open space open for bikers.

It’s is a place my family and friends use for exercise
and learning the sport of biking. The trails are
challenging and a great learning environment.
• Leave for the mountain bike riders.
• Waterdog Openspace is one of the best
opportunities for outdoor recreation on the
peninsula, and since the recent resurgence of
volunteerism (and Belmont Parks collaboration
with volunteer groups) it’s gotten even better.

For all the negativity I’ve heard in the townhalls
and public meetings I’ve never had an _actual_
negative experience while recreating in the park
(aside from the occasional Poison Oak rash). This
space is well loved by residents and visitors alike
and should continue to be an example of open
space land stewardship to the whole bay area.
• Hikers sometimes walk in very large groups
• Waterdog is a gem
• Keep mountian bike access at water dog
• Water dog lake park should continue letting
mountain bikers ride the trails, it’s the best
trail system around and a great workout for
all and it’s very easy to ride for all ages
• Keep cycling in Waterdog open. It’s
fun and accessible for those of us on
the Peninsula and in Belmont.
• Walkers and mountain bikers have been
coexisting and sharing trails in Waterdog
park for many, many years. I strongly support
continued shared use of all trails in Waterdog.
• I love Waterdog! I am a mountain biker and I
have taught other women how to mountain bike
at Waterdog. It’s fun, easy to get to, beautiful,
challenging, safe, friendly --- I just love it.
• Bicyclists are committed to maintaining
and improving trails
• I am thankful these spaces remain protected
and will not be developed into more housing
• Really enjoy the Waterdog trails,
Hallmark cross country course
• It’s important to maintain equitable access
for mountain biking in Waterdog Park
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
832
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 359

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• I love mountain biking at water dog. We
selected our home to be within riding distance
to the park. Never had an issue with people
walking or walking myself. Please don’t ban.
• I love mountain biking at Waterdog. Please
continue to allow mountain biking.
• My main reason for visiting Belmont is to
mountain bike at Waterdog. It’s extremely
valuable to have great trail access in such an
accessible location. I regularly visit by myself,
with other friends and with my family.
• mountain bikers are generally courteous
- and great citizens of the park and
open space- maintaining trails etc
• mountain Biking in open space
is very important to me.
• What are plans to expand biking opportunities?
• Please keep mountain biking.
• Please keep WaterDog open to
Mountain bikes, thank you!
• We love what we have. We want to keep multi-use
trails multi-use and inclusive. There are a few bad
apples out there who make it their mission who if
they had it their way would want it only for Belmont
residence and not make it multi-use or severely
limit the multi-use aspect to the point it would add
no benefit for those other multi-use groups.
• Open spaces are one of the reasons we chose
to live in Belmont. Waterdog and San Juan are
fantastic multi use spaces that we use every
day for dog walking, biking and hiking and
the space is unique and should be preserved
for use for everyone and for all activities
• I’ve been responsibly riding my mountain bike in
Belmont Canyon for 15+ years. I ride the trails
1-2x/week. I’ve never once witnessed any bad
behavior from anyone, quite frankly. I’d be happy
to testify on this point at any open public hearing.
• I taught my two daughters to ride their bikes at
Waterdog. They love riding on the trails. They love
to do “bikenics” where we ride and then picnic.
• Mountain biking is a key activity
that needs to be preserved.
• Are you going to add any new trails for
riding and hiking at Water Dog Park?
• For the past 20+ years I have enjoyed the
open space in Belmont. Specifically Water
Dog and I continue to travel 40+ minutes to
go there and spend time Mountain biking and
going to parks with family and friends.
• ‘Love waterdog’ is great outreach
• It would be really great if we could have something
like the Pulgas Open Air Reserve where a portion
of the trails are open for dogs to be off-leash.
• Water Dog Lake trails are great for walking but
don’t like all the bicyclists as a safety issue.
• Few parks in the Bay Area offer a large, open
area for an organized group such as ours.
• A couple friends have asked me to speak
out to continue allowing bikes at Waterdog. I
think mixed use is OK but more signs about
etiquette and trail speed would help.
• The best way to stay updated on activities/
events in the open spaces?
• We love the open spaces. They
are worth investment!
• More trails would help disperse trail users.
• More mountain bike areas please.
• Dog waste receptacles are much needed
for Open spaces where dogs are allowed
with weekly pick-up of waste.
• Great places
• They should be protected from erosion by constant
creation of accessory roads for bike riders
• Why did you let these trails become almost
impossible to hike on? With proper maintenance
and usage these parks could be beautiful.
• I don’t go too often but I love and strongly
support mountain biking in Water Dog. I am
sad to see gradual erosion over the sixteen
years that I’ve been visiting the park... I’d
support the city putting a bit more resources
into repair and maintenance of the trails.
• Ongoing developments at Waterdog.
• More signage and safety precautions would be
helpful as preventive measures. As I stated, “Three
Witches” is a section of concern as well as other
areas with exposure. The reason for my concern
is that while people seem more aware on the trails
now ( an improvement), there still are people that
don’t pay attention. I continue to use a Bell and
yell “heads up” when I approach blind areas, while
people thank me for the warning, I do notice people
who wear earbuds and are still not paying attention.

Luckily my antennas are always on high alert and I
anticipate issues out of concern for my safety and
others. However, I think it’s inevitable that if this is not addressed there could be some serious injuries.
• How do I learn more about plans for the donated
land within Upper Lock and Belmont Canyon Rd?
Is this being considered for an Open Space?
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
833

APPENDIX I
360 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Same as above but even more so: better left
alone in natural (rugged) state like its been
forever than developed with facilities that bring
increased regulation and encroachment.
• I strongly support mountain bike access in
Belmont’s open spaces. Waterdog Park is a
great place for weekday riding in the Bay Area.
• Special resource that are vital for
residents and local community.
• Bike lanes need to be improved along
Ralston and parts of alameda. It is
dangerous riding along Ralston to get to
the bay trail or to the middle school.
• We love Waterdog but the bikes can be a nuisance
for hikers. Would LOVE a pool and indoor
basketball court at the new Barrett Rec Center!
• I also really appreciate the city’s open spaces - they are incredible and were a huge factor in me moving
here. I most often hike, run, walk my dog, and ride
my bike in Waterdog/ Hidden Canyon. I believe
expanded signage would go a long way in making
the spaces more enjoyable for more people. I also
advocate a restriction against any sort of motorized
bikes (including e-bikes) in the spaces. Lastly, I
would like to see extended use hours for the open
spaces. I would enjoy being able to have a picnic
dinner with the sunset from the top of Waterdog.
• Being able to walk from my home to
playgrounds and open space areas is
a big benefit of living in Belmont
• I would like it if there could be set hours for hikers and other hours for bikers on the Waterdog-Hidden
Canyon trails, or have differentiated trails. The
trails are so narrow and winding that it is hard for
hikers to step aside to let bikers go by, even though
the bikers have been very courteous and alert.
• People are and have always been
friendly on the trails and I’d like to keep
that atmosphere above all else.
• Belmont’s open spaces are small and surrounded
on all sides by development. There are dedicated,
large nature preserves within minutes of either
of the open spaces. Trail users of all types have
gotten along on the trails here for 20+ years without
incident and households / families rely on having
a safe place within riding / walking distance where
they can be in nature getting some exercise.

There are plenty of opportunities to expand the
trail systems at both parks to accommodate
more users while keeping the ‘wild’ flavor of the
parks that make them so fun and popular.

The primary thing diminishing my enjoyment of
the open spaces is the small group of activist
agitators who have made turning the open
spaces into hiker-only nature walks their cause.

Whatever happens with the PROS plan, I hope
that the City will finally clarify the future of the
trails system so that we can either rest easy
and continue enjoying the parks, or move.
• Belmont needs more bike lanes on
roads connecting our parks.
• Belmont needs a good safe connection from upper
Ralston (by Fox and Ralston Schools) to the rest of
Belmont (Alameda, El Camino, 101). If there was a
safe route for biking that connected all of Belmont
it would greatly improve the use of Open Spaces.
• I’m tired of the complaining from the same 3
people about mountain bikes in Water Dog. My
condolences to city staff and commissioners,
that you have to listen to them all the time! I
have been hiking in Waterdog weekly for 14
years and have had 1000 positive interactions
with bikers and maybe 1 negative one. Bikes
are not the scourge that these people seem to
think. Please keep Waterdog open to bikers.
• I would like to know that Belmont values MTB
recreaction and will keep the trails open.
• Please keep them safe and cared for...
have and hold clean up days for the
community - we will get out there and at the
end serve ice cream ot something...
• Same as above
• Please keep trails open to bikes. My main
usage is biking, the trails are great for it, I
worry this will limit access to trails on bike.
• Not enough space. Looks crowded at time. Full
of wood chips. Which could give a splinter
• Water dog is by far the best mountain
biking experience available without using
a car to haul my bike somewhere
• I love that dogs are allowed at Water
Dog, thank you. I would be interested in
volunteering to help with that space.
• My husband and I use open space trails 1-3
per week. Current signage needs immediate
attention due to either missing or unreadable
signage. We are often letting other hikers know
where to go since trails aren’t clearly marked.

Along with trail markers, trail area maps in key
places would also be helpful to navigate.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
834
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 361

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Concern over the health of Water Dog Lake . It
seems to continually draining water yet it was
used as a water source for a fire in the San Juan
Canyon in 2020. I have been unsuccessful in
finding out any information on the Lake. Thanks
• I suggest to prohibit biking in Waterdog trails in the winter or when it’s wet. Tire tracks tear up the trails. • I bike waterdog several times a week. I love it there! • We LOVE the open spaces. Please do
not develop them with artificial structures
and continue to preserve nature.
• Trails are in terrible condition due to neglect and
biker activity. Not safe hiking in Water Dog.
• fix/upgrade existing open spaces,
especially Hallmark park.
• San Juan canyon trails have been over used and
not well maintained- and people keep making new
ones. Please let nature and animals live herewe’ve already had to deal with the new construction of houses - and have significant decrease in animals
and foliage over the past 5 years. It’s very sad.

In addition, fire departments are using sugarloaf
mountain as training and absolutely demolished the
trails last summer. I know that’s not Belmont open
space but it connects to it and is same canyon.
• We are appreciative of the many
trails and options in Waterdog.
• Bicycles are dangerous to us. I can’t afford to
get hit. Jumping out of their way is also risky.

Motorized bicycles should be banned obviously;
they travel faster and are heavier.

Ideally bicycles would be banned on
certain days so we could walk safely.
• Please, please, please. Leave the open trails
as they are. Do not change anything. Let us all
share them! Mountain bikers, people who go for
a walk, to exercise and to be by themselves. Stop
bugging bikers. We should be all nice to them
and to each other and share all the roads
• Obviously, my central concern is with the damage
done by biking in the last two years. It is severe
at Hidden Canyon/Waterdog and the park and rec
people refuse to recognize this. We have attempted
to make our concerns known to NO avail. Instead,
the city has over-accommodated bikers. Please
leave nature preserves for walkers who do not
damage the area or wildlife. No other municipality
allows such destructive use on their nature trails.

Many hikers have stopped walking in the Western
Hills area because of the bikers, including myself
and I live on Carlmont Drive! Most bikers also
come from outside the community and don’t care
what they are doing to the trails and wildlife, or
what they do to the general feeling of peaceful and
sustainable open space, which has been impacted
negatively by their presence. Open space in the
Western Hills has thus become inhospitable to
hikers. It is important to note that the bikers are
almost exclusively male, between 20-40, which is a
very small, select group that leaves everyone else
out. Yet still Belmont parks & rec caters to bikers
more than other users of these trails by making
it easier for bikers to park, clean themselves and
their bikes, and so forth. Bikers also often ride in
packs, which is even worse on the trails than single
riding, and their yells and general clamor destroys
the peaceful ambience of natural spaces, not to
mention making the trails dangerous for walkers.

I watch big trucks with multiple bikes in them, as
well as groups of bikers, go up and down Carlmont
Drive all day long on their way to and from the
Hidden Canyon area. Bikers run on and over large
rock outcrops destroying them, they’ve made the
meadow into a sand trap gutted with erosion and
wheel tracks, they create an unfriendly environment
for wildlife, which has caused wildlife to leave the
area, and they create deep ruts in trails that make
it hard for walkers to navigate. I’ve also seen bikers
spraying pesticides on poison oak along the trails.

I’ve watched as bikers do “pump track” exercises in
the open meadow (in groups); I’ve even seen them
bring into the meadow pump track ramps to use for
this purpose. And yet walkers’ concerns about these
issues have been completely ignored by parks and
rec over the past two years. Indeed, we have even
had a serious problem with bikers at night in the hills at Hidden Canyon. Police have been called many
times but nothing is done. The biking situation has
become outrageous and even tragic for the natural
environment. Many of us feel that our environment
has been badly treated and our concerns about this
are not only unheard by Belmont city government
but actively thwarted. At Hidden Canyon the parking
lot is widened for the big trucks the bikers drive in,
a bike cleaning apparatus is erected, and an ugly
outhouse is stationed at the trailhead for bikers who
assemble there in large groups--groups composed
of all men of a certain age. Early evening at Hidden
Canyon often finds women hikers having to walk
through a crowd of men stripping themselves of
their sweaty clothes after biking as they gather in
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
835

APPENDIX I
362 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
pseudo parties around their trucks. Meanwhile,
there has been no attempt at rejuvenation of Hidden
Canyon’s ruined areas. Whose open space is this?
• More trails would be nice
• Water Dog park is an excellent place for hikers
and bicyclists. Trail etiquette signage would help
both users be more considerate to the other.
• Please preserve, and ensure accessibility.
• Need to keep Waterdog park open to mountain
bikers and invest in maintenance.
• Are there nature talks for all ages!
• They are hidden gems. Need better signage
(there was none in San Juan). Good thing I
printed out a map before I left home, but I still
wasn’t quite sure if I was going the right way.
• Waterdog and Hidden Canyon are one of the few
local open space where locals can mountain bike.

Mtn bikers and hikers can co-exist and I have
always found the interaction friendly between the
two. Please keep these open spaces open to biking.
• I love Belmont for its trees and
open spaces - keep them!
• They should stay based in nature and not
be expanded into big attractions with a lot
going on all the time. Being so close to nature
is incredible and should be treasured.
• More multi-sport paths for bikes
• They are great
• They provide a wonderful resource for my kids
and I to mountain bike. Unfortunately there
are few legal options for narrow trail riding in
the Bay Area. It’s nice to have these so close
by and accessible to everyone. It would be a
loss to the bay area if cyclists were excluded
from even more of our open space.
• I like the suggestion of guided hikes/interpretive
hikes. Need to do a better job in marketing the open
spaces. So many people not even aware it’s there.
• Access to excellent mountain bike trails is so
essential for promoting personal and famil health
and wellness, while also promoting community
and environment-preservering transportation.
• Need more bike trails
• The mountain bike trails need more work
• The trail bikes are out of control(dangerous)
At Water Dog Lake there are too
many off leash dogs(sorry)
• Keep bike access to Waterdog
• more signage on trails, more permanent restrooms
• Please continue to allow biking access to Waterdog.
• please continue to allow mountain biking
in water dog park. it is the only good
place to ride this side of skyline rd.
• Should accommodate all users. Should
increase trails to accommodate increased
usage. It is a false choice that we can
have recreation or nature but not both.
• Please do not remove mountain bike access to
Waterdog. Absolutely the wrong decision and
would severely limit close mountain bike access.
• Kicking mountain bikers out of Belmonts open
spaces will merely encourage illegal trails,
as well as alienating a large user class who
frequently performs maintenance on said trails.
• Bike trails bring more business to the area.
• Waterdog is the only place I can ride my
mountain bike without having to drive. It’s
one of my favorite things to do after work.
• Improve mountain biking trails and access.
• Please keep open for biking! It is an important
part of our lives for so many of us.. Thank you!
• Please keep Waterdog bike accessible.
• I’d like for you to maintain or expand cycling access. • Mountain biking is a wonderful, healthy, fun
way to get outside and enjoy nature. Mountain
bikes and bikers can coexist wonderfully
with hikers etc. on mixed use trails.
• Waterdog open space preserve trails are fantastic.

There are no other trails like them that are so
easy to reach. I used them when I worked in San
Mateo county - I was able to bike to them from
work. I still visit them regularly from San Francisco.

They are well built, interesting, and pack a great
ride into a small distance. Signage could be
improved - they are a little confusing at first.
• I love being able to make a quick escape and go
for a quick mountain bike ride in Water Dog
• Water Dog is the rare open space where cyclists
can actually ride their bikes to and from the trail
head, it’s a unique gem and should be open
to all users to enjoy safely and responsibly.
• Keep trails open to mountain bikes!
Mountain biking is not a crime!
• As a mountain biker Belmont’s got one of
the few mountain bike accessible outdoor
spaces that doesn’t require many hours of
driving. It’d be a huge loss losing that.
• Please keep mountain bike access!
• Please keep the trails open for
mountain biking at water dog
• Do not restrict mountain bikes!
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
836
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 363

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Add bike only directional trails
• Accessibility for bikes and mountain bikes
• I love biking through Belmont’s open spaces.
• I enjoy occasional trips to Waterdog to go
mountain bike riding. It is a fantastic area for
riding. Maintaining and even expanding access
for mountain biking is a good goal to have.
• Best part about the parks + open spaces is the
range of people who can use them, and the
varienty of things for which they get used
• Biking is an important community activity
• Bicycling at Waterdog is a great local
resource for the surrounding communities. I
believe with the proper park support and
signage that bicycling at Waterdog can be
safe and respectful to all user groups.
• Please maintain full bike access to Waterdog
• Please keep things bike friendly.
• Please do not remove mountain bike access to
Waterdog! We can all share the trails and get along.
• Waterdog is a wonderful place, and I think with
proper etiquette we can all share the trails.

I would love the opportunity to give back to the
place I enjoy by volunteering for trail work days.
• We frequently use the open spaces that are
available for cycling that’s separate from traffic
and have had nothing but polite and respectful
interactions with other hikers and wildlife. Would
greatly appreciate keeping this space available
for current and future generations of cyclists.
• These are unique biking trials in the Bay Area
that make weekday rides accessible without
having to travel all the way to state parks.

It’d also be useful to have designated trail
directions, or alternating biking/hiking only days.
• I love the open spaces especially the opportunity’s
for getting out and exercising via mountain
bike riding! I would love to see more trails!
• Keep water dog open to mountain bikes
• I ride the trails here regularly from my home.

It would be a huge loss to not have trails
which can be accessed by bicycle.
• Please keep open spaces available
for mountain bike use
• It is extremely important to me that Waterdog Park
is not closed to mountain bikers. Waterdog is one of
the only mountain biking locations on the northern
peninsula, and if bikers are not allowed there it will
no longer be possible for me to exercise before
or after work. Riding at Waterdog is a cherished
and treasured activity for me and I love having
the ability to mountain bike close to my home.
• Keep access for mountain bikers!
• Limit use to sundown.

Provide trails for mountain bikes riders
Widen trails
• We need more active bicyclist, mountain biker trails.

Mountain biking is quickly growing and the
community needs more places to ride.
• We moved here for the open spaces for kids but
are disappointed in the condition. Bikers make
trails unsafe for kids, environment is damaged
so the only lesson we teach the kids is how
humans are thoughtlessly hurting the earth.
• Improved bike access (for ebikes and regular bikes)
to and in the open spaces would be fantastic!
• Keep mtb trails in water dog
• Mountain biking is fantastic, not many towns
have similar trails in close proximity.
• Bike access on trails is an amazing resource,
restricting this would be a serious loss for the
peninsula. Waterdog is the reason I visit Belmont.
• Do not close waterdog trails to biking!
Designate them as mixed use.
• Please do not remove access for bikes. It is a
great way for people to exercise while spending
time with friends and family. Many of us use timber
bells which switch on and off to let people know of
their presence on the trail. This isn’t to get the right away, but to make everyone feel safe. Knowing
someone is coming your direction far ahead of
time helps everyone have a safe experience out
there. I wouldn’t even want e-bikes banned since
i see many people in their 50s and 60s on them
having a blast. They are not blowing past people
being unsafe. e-bikes allows them to make the
climbs they can’t otherwise. This also allows them
to spend time with grand kids and younger family
members while bonding in a hobby/sport they enjoy
• Keep access open for all activities. I may not bike
but I want bikes to be able to use open spaces.
• Belmont’s Waterdog Lake park is a gem
for the Peninsula. Keep trail access
open to all users, including bikes.
• Expanding multi-use access would encourage more
people to get out into nature, thereby fostering
better health, a better sense of community and
more appreciation for nature within Belmont.
• Please keep Waterdog open to mountain
biking and preserver the single track trails.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
837

APPENDIX I
364 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mountain Biking in Water Dog and Laurelwood
is something I cannot live without.
• I’ve always felt that different trail users (hike,
runner, cyclist) get along very well in Waterdog.

I don’t always have the same experience
in other locations. I think users really value
what Waterdog Open Space provides.
• Being able to take kids to ride mountain bikes
at Waterdog has been super rewarding for
both myself and seeing the kids grow. I’d be
very sad to see this option removed and one
avenue for teens to get out disappear.
• The Open Spaces are a wonderful treasure.

They provide excellent opportunity to get close
to nature right in an urban backyard. In the
many years I’ve been visiting the Belmont Open
Spaces I’ve encountered nothing but pleasure
and fulfillment, both in terms of my ability to
enjoy the space and my interactions with other
users. Other than keeping up with maintenance
(and adding a trail here and there) I wouldn’t
change anything. Even the “unofficial” trails are
excellent and I wouldn’t remove them. When
making decisions please keep in mind these are
city Open Space, not a Wilderness Preserves.
• I love Waterdog, but I no longer walk or
run there because I’m startled by too many
mountain bikers. If there some trails that were
exclusively for hikers, that might be helpful.
• See note in “other” for number 8.
• More trails would be great. And more trail signs/
maps around hidden canyon and water dog lake.
• Love Waterdog for mtb
• There are many open spaces in the Peninsula
where bikes are not allowed. Waterdog and San
Juan Canyon offer some of the best single track
biking in the Bay Area and I hope The city of
Belmont will keep them as multi-use. Thanks.
• Please plant or preserve trees and bushes.

They cut noise. Provide shade and cool
temperatures in the summer. Cut winds all
year long. Definitely add more benches too!
• I love running to San Juan Canyon and Waterdog.
• Open space for bikers and dogs is very
valuable for me and my family
• Our family mountain bikes in Waterdog every
week and it is one of our favorite things
to do on our neighborhood. Please keep
open spaces open to mountain biking!!
• I really love mountain biking and hiking at Waterdog
park, and think it’s a great place for both, and it
shouldn’t get closed to biking. I’m also excited
for the possibility of a pump track!! It would be
a good opportunity for younger kids to develop
their skills, and fun for older kids and adults.
• It is important to my family that open space
trails remain multi-use. We have hikers,
bikers and joggers in our household.
• Keep it available for mountain biking.

Put up signs warning new users that
some trails are moderately diificuly
• The City has done an excellent job
keeping mountain biking open in city
open space. Keep up the good work.
• Animal waste is an on-going issue
• I’ve used Water Dog Park to mountain bike before
and after work for years. It is an escape for me
and I have only ever had positive experiences
with other trail users. I have been told that a
small minority of trail users are trying to use this
process to eliminate bicycle use on the singletrack
at Water Dog. I love these trails. Please do not
take these experiences away from people like
me in order to serve a vocal minority. Different
user groups can and do share trails in peace, as
they have for the last 20+ years at Water Dog.
• I LOVE Water Dog lake - this is a gem of a
park. I heard that some people want to prevent
mountain biking and would be sad if that was
restricted. While our family doesn’t mountain
bike there, we hike there a lot and truly don’t
mind sharing the trails. Our neighbors mountain
bike here frequently & would hate to see them
restricted from it. Our experience has been that
most trail users are respectful & courteous.
• I would prefer open spaces to have restrooms.
• I’ve lived in Belmont for 50+ years. I’ve been
going to Waterdog since before the city even
paid any attention to the area. Do not take
away the ability to ride mountain bikes at
Waterdog! It’s wonderful exercise and I have
been riding there for years. The amount of
hikers there will decrease as the pandemic
goes away. Bikers and hikers can get along.
• Volunteer opportunities for
maintenance and improvement.
• Please
Keep the cross country trail open,
maintained, and no dog/bike(s).
• Keeping them open and accessible to mountain
biking is a great activity for the family.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
838
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 365

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Please close illegal trails, ban bikes from
narrow single trails, invest in native plant,
education and species protections,
• Enjoy the cycling on the fire road and trails in
Waterdog. Seems to be a lot of families enjoying
the activity and looking forward to taking my
girls with me when they are a little older.
• Didn’t even know there was so much open space.

Would be great to get a trail map via email or in mail
• They are treasures that should be available
to many user groups. Exclusion of classes
should not be a priority. Belmont residents
are lucky to have these areas.
• Doing a great job
• We love waterdog and have recently discovered
hidden canyon after 10 years in Belmont.
• They are beautiful and we are lucky to
have them for both biking and hiking.
• Water Dog is great resource that brings me
to Belmont to mountain bike and patronize
local businesses. Please do not limit
mountain bike access to Water Dog.
• Regulate Waterdog trails for no ebikes!
• More police patrol
• Bikes in open space must be restricted
to certain trails or times
• It would be nice to put more trail maps and
signage on the trails for navigation
• I would like them to be fortified against wildfire
through innovative approaches like controlled burns.
• Love them, continue to encourage bikers
& hikers to co-exist together.
• More areas for leashed dogs
• Please maintain the level of offroad cycling
options within the Belmont open spaces like
Waterdog. This is one of the great things
about Belmont that other cities don’t have.
• I’m worried that the activities that are
important to me (e.g. mountain biking) will
no longer be allowed because of a very
small yet very vocal group of people.
• I love the open spaces and always
think we should have more.
• I don’t think the trails should be designated
for use as either walking or scootering
(children) or mountain biking.
• Do not add restrictions.
• cleanliness is an issue
• Waterdog Open Space is a tremendous
resource and widely used. Please allocate
sufficient resources to better maintain it,
please enforce dog poop rules, and please
continue to allow mountain biking.
• Please keep open space
• I LOVE the open spaces in Belmont!
• Pretty good the way they are. Spend the money
elsewhere where it may be needed more.
• Water Dog Lake is awesome! Please restore and
update the trail signage, especially the mountain lion
safety signs and the trail name signs. Also, please
add signage to unlabeled secondary trails. Thanks!
• General guidelines
• Love them; wish bikes were more controlled
• Belmont has a great open space area’s
that should be shared by all. There
should be a little give and take.
• It needs to be protected and left alone. There is
little sacred living space left for the animals.
• Hallmark Trail/Cross Country: can not be
lost, closed or sold for housing. Stunning
area for our community to enjoy.
• Maintain bike access. It’s nice to have
a place to ride offroad without cars
• Our Open Spaces are the jewels in Belmonts
Crown. Expanding/maintaining and improving
them would be a benefit to the community.
• Same as #15
• Please keep Water Dog as perfect as it
is. Please do not add a skateboarding
ramps or anything else that will ruin it. It is
perfect as is. Please keep the CSM space
above Belmont Heights just the way it is.
• Waterdog Lake is an amazing open space used
extensively by a wide mix of people. Mountain
biking is one of the important activities that the open space hosts. While there have been complaints by
a few specific people about biking, the vast majority
people easily share the trails, follow trail etiquette
and are polite, friendly and respectful of people
enjoying mixed use trails. Please do not let a few
unhappy people take away an unique and wonderful
recreational resource. More etiquette signage
and even some activity specific trail restrictions
could alleviate conflict. Thank you Belmont!
• multi use paths very hard for pedestrians
- I feel like I’m always about to get run
over. Also masking restrictions are not
consistent and people dont’ follow them.
• I am very concerned that a small group of
outspoken protagonists are trying to eliminate
mountain biking from water dog area.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
839

APPENDIX I
366 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Great to have nice nature close by.
• Open Space needs to be available for all users.
• Desperately need more trails, dedicated use to
prevent conflict between bikes and hikers.
• Mountain bike access is critical
and needs to be expanded
• I love Waterdog and Sugarloaf/San Juan Canyon.

It can be challenging, because all of the trails
have intermittently become impacted over the last
few years, but I strongly believe that restricting/
limiting trail use is the wrong approach.
• More bike specific trails.
• I mountain bike in water dog with my wife,
children and friends 3 times per week. It’s great!
• Mostly just parking. But that’s a tough one to fix.
• Our (I live in Belmont) Open space is a gem for
me personally. I can walk my dog there, I can
ride my bike there, I can invite my friends there
for a group hike. Lots of way for me to utilize.
• We LOVE Waterdog. Please don’t take away the
joy of riding the trails. My kids ride daily. This has
benefited them tremendously during the pandemic.
• I love taking my children bike riding at water
dog park it is great exercise and so much safer
than riding on asphalt or dealing with autos
• Please keep open for biking
• It’s the reason why I moved my
family to be near Sugarloaf.
• Waterdog is a fantastic mtn. biking spot! Please
help keep it open to bikes, if we need more rules,
so be it! I would strongly urge you to ban ebikes.
• They are great the way they are. They are
a unique treasure on the peninsula.
• Please preserve trail access at Waterdog for biking.
• Please keep Water Dog trails open for bicycling.
• The water dog park is unique in its quality
of mountain biking trails. Expanding
the network would be great.
• In general, I think the open spaces are great.

Easy to visit, limited crowds, nature-focused. I
don’t want to lose the “get away” aspect of them.
• One of the best things about belmont is biking
at water dog. It’s one of the few activities I can
still do that doesn’t aggravate my knees.
• love trail running, hiking with kids and biking!
• I appreciate Water Dog being one of the
FEW mountain biking areas in the Bay
Area that allow dogs. My pup loves it!
• LOVE Waterdog park, wouldlove it if had WIFI
Coverage or at least cell service in the park,
for emergency usage, and to listen to music/
podcasts while walking. Also please weed
the poison oak more please. More love to the
Cross Country trail behind the HallMark park
would be awesome too - it’s neglected .
• Please keep mountain bike access open!
• Mountain biking has been a part of the open
space for this long without issue, is unjust the
opinion of a select few threaten to close the
only reason why I would visit Belmont.
• Waterdog Park is a wonderful resource and a great
example of a successful and sustainable multi-use
trail system. Perfect spot to introduce young people
to mountain biking and a love of the outdoors!
• Uses should remain open to all. Stop trying
to add restrictions or designations.
• it’s great for mountain biking for all age groups
• Need more mountain bike trails
• Open space and trail access for multiple user
groups (running, biking, hiking, walking, etc) is
paramount. Adding directional or biking only trails
could greatly improve the ability of the open space
areas to accommodate a diverse and growing
user group and minimize trail conflicts. Enhancing
the frequency of trail work days and working to
improve and restore habitat along trails allows
multiple benefits for the community and ecosystem.
• I love that I can go to a spot that is close by
to enjoy nature and to exercise outdoors.

Trail Running, Hiking, and Biking.
• This is a vital resource for the rapidly growing
local community of cyclists. More and more
people are picking up biking, and this is great
for public health and community resilience. The
open spaces are great for this! Please don’t
enact changes that take this away or decrease
the benefit of the open spaces for cyclists.
• More open space for bikes
• I appreciate having an option to mountain
bike within the 280 corridor.
• appreciate the multi use and natural feel
• Please don’t let a vocal minority of trail
users drive policy for all residents.
• Waterdog has a great trail network that
is easy to access and convenient for
most. Let’s keep the trails open for all!
• Like to see continued access for
Mountain biking in waterdog park.
• Appreciate the trail connections from sheep
camp trail; I ride from Canada entrance
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
840
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 367

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• We enjoy mountain biking there and
want to keep it open for all users
• Please keep mountain biking at all
available parks, including Waterdog
• I am so grateful that the city of Belmont has been
working closely with the Waterdog Trailkeepers
to keep Waterdog safe for all participants alike,
environmentally focused, and welcoming.
• Waterdog has a great and storied mountain
biking history. It is a valuable resource to the
community. Please preserve this resource and
outlet for teens and community members.
• Please keep open to cycling.
• WaterDog park is an absolute treasure. I appreciate
that it is a mountain biking mecca. If I felt safer
hiking those trails on foot I would do it more
often, but dealing with bikes can be stressful.

Is there any tracking of accident locations and
causes? Perhaps some specific danger spots
could be addressed. Some parts of the trail could
be widened to allow for peaceful coexistence.
• There is not enough open space in teh
bay area. With it’s limited quantity it
needs to be made accessible for all users
in a way that reduces trail conflict.
• How did we completely miss the
mark on trail use signage?
• Waterdog park is the perfect place for kids to ride
mountain bikes. My children often demand to go
to Waterdog to ride bikes as it is safe, fun, and
well scaled to riders, walkers, and hikers of all skill levels. I strongly endorse multiuser access for all
human powered activities, biking and hiking both.
• Keep Waterdog open to mountain
bikes like it is today
• I love the Belmont Open Spaces. The trails are
wide and excellent. And I’ve enjoyed the lower
density the times I’ve visited. I travel from San
Carlos to visit Belmont’s open spaces as they
are far superior than those in San Carlos.
• I have been using Water Dog/Hidden Valley for
years to trail run, walk and exercise my dog - it is
the closest open space to my house. Bikes have
never been a problem in the past, however, since
Covid, this has been a serious issue. The number
of mtn bikers has increased 10x and many do not
follow the park rules. I have been nearly taken
out multiple times as they exceed safe speeds on
steep and narrow trails. They are also the least
likely to follow social distancing or wear a mask.
• I’ve been riding my mtn bike at Waterdog for 30
years and it’s a great local area for the community.

Love the trail systems and they could be expanded.
• I primarily visit Waterdog to ride my bike and
always really enjoy it. It’s unique to most open
space on the peninsula because of the way its
surrounded by development on the ridgelines.

Being so accessible to so many people makes it
a real treasure. The challenge seems to be how
encourage all people who want to experience
the park to share it with one another.
• We love Waterdog and it’s bike/hiking trails
• Mountain biking and bird watching in waterdog
lake park is amazing. I love this little oasis.
• Waterdog Open Space is a fantastic multi-use
recreation area that supports a broad group
of enthusiasts. In particular, the opportunity to
get kids on bikes and off the roads (which have
gotten more and more dangerous over time) is
essential. There simply are not enough areas
they can ride, particularly for those who aren’t old
enough to drive. Riding bikes at Waterdog is a very
important part of my family’s exercise and bonding
routine and has been for well over a decade.
• I love the multi-use trails at Waterdog.

Please maintain access for biking.
• the trails are doing well thanks to volunteer efforts from mountain biking groups and it it vital that
multi-use access be preserved to keep this going
• I support keeping the trails open to hikers,
bikers, dog walkers - basically everyone.

The trails have been multi-use for decades,
and the system is working well.
• I use Waterdog for Mountain Biking several times
a week. I’d like the city to help maintain the trails
but overall I think the conflicts are minimal and can
be managed to allow all users to enjoy the park.
• Belmont’s parks, water dog lake specifically is what
got me into mountain biking 6 years ago. The skills
I learned over years of hard work turned me into the
cyclist I am today. This year, I traveled to Germany
to race cross country mountain bike. I was the
only American, racing against people from all over
Europe, including the world champion and multiple
national champions from all over Europe. I wouldn’t
be the cyclist I am today if it wasn’t for waterdog.
• They are underdeveloped. Opportunity to
optimize the resource for all to enjoy.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
841

APPENDIX I
368 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Love the mountain biking at Waterdog. Have been
helping trail maintenance, and hope the trail stay
open for mountain biking. Would be acceptable with
me to prohibit bikes with motors if that helps with
avoiding issues. I will get an electric bike someday,
but think they and non-ebikes are not the same.
• keep them well maintained and open to everyone.
• Love the new trail marking signs!
• Please protect. Very disappointed and disturbing
to see what bike riders and electric bikes,
night riders and what some have done to the
trails.I see groups of the bicycle community
coming out of the trails.with shovels and saws
who are making their own trails and tearing
out plants and trees to carve out new trails
destroying the walking trails and open space.
• Love them!
• Pls widen trails and remove poison oak. I’d use
the trails a lot more with my dog if not so much
poison oak right at the edge of narrow trails.
• Please reduce the yellow jacket population with
environmentally safe traps, in the early spring
• I’ve lived in Belmont for 35 years and very much
enjoy the Multi use open space that Belmont has.

My entire family enjoys biking and hiking in these
open spaces. My hope is they remain multi use.
• Would like to know of any development proposals
in these areas, especially San Juan Canyon where
there are still numerous privately owned lots.
• The open space in Belmont is amazing and our
family is there all the time. continuing the multi-use
nature of these trails is the highest priority for us,
as we hike there, walk the dog there, and ride our
bikes there. We moved to Belmont because of the
multi-use trails. We can all get along and the entire
community should benefit from this great asset.
• Is there a chance of keeping cyclists
off the Lake Loop Trail?
• Both bikes and walkers should be
able to use the open space
• I love to bike, hike, dog walk and run at Waterdog,
Hidden Canyon and San Juan open spaces.

Let’s keep those trails open to all users that
use them respectively and follow the rules,
which is the vast majority of the users. One
or two new, well built and designed trails in
WDLP for mixed use would really be nice!
• Please keep them open for leashed dogs
• Belmont really lacks bigger open spaces
compared to neighboring cities.
• They are great, but we need to stay on it
and keep ahead of the curve by constantly
improving and adding features.
• I think generally they are working very well.
• Trail use is perfect as is, a vocal minority
is the source of complaints. We do not
need more rules and regulation.
• Waterdog Park has been an excellent example
of a multi-use park, that accommodates bikers,
hikers, dog walkers, etc. for years. The local
mountain bike community has been a huge
advocate and steward of Waterdog and has
helped develop the trail system there. As past
residents of Belmont, now San Carlos, Waterdog
has always been our “backyard” mountain bike
ride and should continue to be for years to come.
• There is a limited number of parks that allow
mountain biking. Building on this activity in Water
Dog could increase the city appeal to many visitors.
• Love the bike trails in water dog! It’s nice
that they are accessible without having
to drive 20+ minutes up to skyline.

Also great that you can ride from house to
trail. Having more options like this and more
trails would be amazing for the community and
kids. As parent’s not having to worry about
them riding on busy streets would be great!
• Specifically, there are people who want to limit
the ability to ride mt. bikes at Waterdog. The
misinformation surrounding “mt. biking destroys
natural habitat” is disturbing. Waterdog is a mt.
bikers gem in the middle of the massive suburban
expanse that is Silicon Valley. If restricted in
any way, Waterdog should be made a mt.
biker-only park as there are PLENTY of other
places nearby where bikes are not allowed at
all. Best option is to keep is shared use and not
to impose other restrictions on bikers there.
• I want you to consider that we are doing a
15 year forward-looking exercise here during
a pandemic where our Open Spaces are
seeing (I suspect) all time high usage areas.

I don’t want high traffic to turn into reduced
access in response to high trail traffic.
• The open space area’s should be for all
to enjoy not just a specific group.
• Twin Pines is great
• Please continue mixed use for all Open Spaces.

We hike with our dog and also mountain bike, and
would love to be able to continue to do both.
• Add Cross Country Trail into Belmont’s care
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
842
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 369

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Limit bicycle use on the trails or widen them.

The current trails are too narrow for bicycles and
make it dangerous for walkers and runners.
• Please do not eliminate mountain
biking use at waterdog
• Increased use is a blessing, not a curse.

Dialing up trail etiquette signage and
advocacy will do a lot for perceive conflicts
• They were a significant factor in our decision to
move to Belmont. I would not like them limited.
• Keep open and maintain
• Water dog is a treasure for mountain biking and
it’s history should be celebrated. Expansion
of this city asset is highly encouraged.
• Trail signs
• The sharing of narrow trails with bikes and hikers
is totally unsafe. If is hasn’t already happened,
someone will be killed or seriously injured because
the trails are too narrow to accommodate bikes
and hikers. On the wide main trails, bikes are
often going 20 to 30 mph downhill. Whether on
narrow or wide trials going too fast is common and
dangerous. thank you for sponsoring this survey
• Belmont Open spaces should be available
to all mountain bikers and hikers. It is a way
for many families to get out and exercise,
as well as keep student’s out of trouble.
• I want to make sure EVERYONE has the ability
to use the parks. I know there is a group of retired
people who are actively trying to ban bikers from
the open spaces. That is exactly what we should not
be doing. Encourage safe considerate joint usage.
• Please give more recognition to all the volunteer
groups that maintain Waterdog and let the public
know how these volunteer groups use the park.
• I bike and hike in Waterdog, being able to
go there by bike rather than having to drive
is a real Godsend. It has been especially
important during lockdown. Thanks for
your work on these open spaces.
• I think we should designate Waterdog and Hidden
Canyon as cycling-focused open space. We
already have so many hiking-only spaces (Big
Canyon, Cross Country Course, Edgewood,
Huddard, the list goes on) yet cyclists have no
designated open spaces for cycling. This is not
fair. If the hikers don’t want to share with cyclists
- fine - then let’s designate some trails for cyclists
only. This would include most the single track at
WD. Hikers can keep to Lake Road and Lake Loop.
• Waterdog is great for mountain biking. many of
the trails have been improved the last few years
by volunteers from MTB community. Waterdog is
not a “natural” environment as some like to think.

It needs management to help resolve issues of
erosion and fire danger due to unnatural thick
brush. Waterdog is one of the only close biking
areas on the peninsula. Hundreds of bikers per
week access it by riding to it locally. Many teens use
this area for biking, who would not be interested
in just hiking there. Don’t give in to the selfish
neighbors who want Waterdog all to themselves
without bikes. The biking community has a lot
of potential to make Waterdog better for all. The
new trail signs are a great start. I use a bike bell
and other users really thank me for it. I would
suggest setting up some “ borrow a bell” stations
at entrances for MTBers. This could be a good
Eagle Scout project or other youth driven project.

Much of the erosion prone areas have been like
that for 30 plus years. Not caused recently by bikes.

Waterdog could be the crown jewel of Belmont if it’s
us embraced as the awesome biking resource it is.
• Limit bikes to be used only on large fire road trails. • Belmont open spaces and parks are one of
the main reasons this area is so great!
I love the volunteer opportunities to maintain
the trails (walking & bike trails)
• I mostly walk & hike, but Belmont needs
to adapt its parks and open space to offer
more unique activities, and less of the
common ones we can do anywhere.
• Waterdog has been a blessing as my son
and I have gotten into mountain biking and
found it to be an amazing community in a
time needed especially for my son.
• I wish you could remedy the damage done
by bikes to hiking trails (ruts, etc.)
• Keep Waterdog open to mountainbiking. And keep
the trails as they are with challenges to tide on.
• Being able to mountain bike at Waterdog is
amazingly special and unique. A true gem
• It’s scary to hike on trails because of danger of
getting hit by speeding bikes, trails are really
rutted and trashed from so many bikes
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
843

APPENDIX I
370 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Having safe, legal places to let my dog run offleash are very important to me. One of the things my dog and I miss most is having mountain bike
trails we can enjoy together; we used to live in
Bend, OR where dogs are allowed on most all
trails. Barrett Community Center and Cipriani
park are great, but expanding off leash access at
Waterdog/Hidden Canyon would be awesome,
and a perfect place to have off leash areas.
• Dangerous to hike on trails because of speeding
bikers, there are to many trails for small amount
of area, wildlife is being decimated by biking
• Mountain biking is an essential use of
Water Dog park and should continue
to be allowed without restriction.
• Convenient and generally well maintained. Only
issue is the conflict between mountain bikers and
hikers/walkers on narrow trails. Very difficult to pass or be passed when the poison oak is in full bloom
(so to speak), as you can’t really step off the trail.

Plus, mountain bikers often seem to feel they have
the right of way, which I don’t believe they do.
• I love to mountain bike at water dog! So
thankful this is in my back yard.
• Love cycling!
Love to walk dog
• The parks are crowded since COVID.

We need more trails and cycling-specific
trails, to spread out the people better.
• The parks & open space is for all, not the few,
particularly those that make websites to promote
hate or sabotage the trails with derbies in the
name of their view. It is irresponsible not to
plan for increased usage stemming from the
increased housing developments over the last
many years. Pls More Trees & More Trails.
• So grateful for Waterdog!
• People running dogs off leash, like at
Water Dog, make me less likely to visit
• Should remain multi use areas for all to enjoy
(bikers, hikers, dog walkers-if they can follow
the rules, etc). Should prioritize & enforce
existing policies rather than create more (dogs
on leash, no electric vehicles, pick up after your
dog). Should add new trails or at least leave in
place existing trails rather than block them as
has recently taken place. Forcing the same, or
more trail users (as has been the case during
Covid) onto fewer trails does not improve safety.
• There is a clear miscommunication between
cyclists and hikers using the open spaces, and
a method needs to be used to please both
parties; something that preserves bikers’ access
to all single track but also satisfies hikers’
complaints of trail erosion and damage.
• The most important thing you can do for the future
is to provide, maintain and increase your trails and
open space areas. They will be used (walking,
jogging, biking) by more of the population over time.
• Continue to improve the trails against water
erosion, they get better every year. Additional trails
1-2 designated for bikes only would be great.
• Erosion prevention and control
needs to be better addressed
• The parking and pedestrian situation needs
to be improved at the Hallmark Drive water
dog trail head. Very dangerous to both
Hallmark area residents and visitors.
• We love mountain biking at Waterdog, bought
our first home because of the location.

Thank you for maintaining the trails, please
don’t widen them or make them easier for
riders. I hope E-bikes can be banned.
• I would like to see trails remain multi-use and
signage / education on trail etiquette. I would
also love to see more multi-use trails and more
organized trail maintenance activities. My family and
I get a lot of pleasure, fitness and stress relief from hiking and biking in Belmont Open Spaces. I know
there is a lot of controversy about biking vs. hiking. It would be very sad to see biking eliminated from the
Open Spaces. Recent issues are due to increased
crowds and education. Thanks very much!
• Keep them open to mountain bikes.

Consider directional trails.
• Continue to create, enhance and
focus on multi-use trails
• I love riding my bike on challenging trails.
• Keep them open and available for all to use
• Why renavatiuons are being made to trails
that benefit hikers more than bikers
• My family loves Belmont Parks and the winding city
streets, but they are not safe places for my children
to ride bicycles, so we travel to other cities for them.

They have ridden pump tracks before, and would
absolutely love to have one closer than Santa Cruz.
• Thanks for setting up the survey for us to provide
feedback! :) Here’s my opinion as someone
who lives in Hillsdale but come to Waterdog
weekly for hiking and mountain biking:

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
844
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 371

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)

1. Trail use is likely going to increase year over
year. It’s more realistic to think about how to
accommodate growing number of visitors. Making
trails more restrictive is only counterproductive.

2. Some trails are too rutty because of rainfall,
corrosion, and footprints/wheelprints. There are
existing solutions applied at other open spaces to
alleviate corrosion. Example: upper Elevator trail
in Hidden Canyon could use some maintenance.

3. Some trails are too narrow or
“blind” for hikers and bikes.

4. Trail signage and trail etiquette are very
necessary to educate and guide all users of the
open spaces. As a hiker and mountain biker I can
see why it’s annoying if someone “speeds” on
the trails. It’s like drivers who speed too. Simple
gestures like slowing down when passing and
trail bell can make passing more friendly.
• Please persevere these spaces and make
sure we protect our environment.
• Would love more trails and signs
in the rugged areas.
• We need to keep the Water Dog Lake park open
as it provides multi use space (biking, hiking,
jogging, running, dog walking, relaxation, etc)
• A bike pump track would be a great
addition. Living in Cipriani there is no safe
place for kids to ride a bicycle nearby.

Waterdog should remain a multi use park. This is
a great resource for all users. More trails would be
good and I am sure that mountain biking community
would be willing to volunteer for trail building
• San Juan canyon open space presents
a great opportunity to polish a local gem
and get the most out of the space.
• Would be nice to develop a hiking/biking trail on the Cranfield easement, in conjunction with San Carlos.
• I know mountain biking has become a bit of a
controversial topic. I understand it has some
downsides such as trail wear, and safety concerns
for hikers. If there is consideration about banning
mountain biking, I would love if some middle ground
could be found, perhaps removing biking from some
trails, while labeling others as bike only, or hike
with the knowledge that bikers may come. I think
information about trail etiquette as well as volunteer
events to help maintain the trails could really
help educated mountain bikers on both respect
for the trails and respect for other users. I know
somethings may seem obvious, but if we don’t take
the time to educate users, we can’t expect them to
know everything. Educating others is part of being
a good steward of the activity you participate in.
• Having recently moved from out of state, one
of the reasons where my partner and I chose
our home was it’s proximity to Waterdog Open
Space. We both love hiking, running and cycling
in Waterdog. It is such a great space and a jewel
that most cities wish they had. That being said,
there is a lot of discussion about banning bike from
the park. We think there is room for everyone to
co-exist within the park. As someone who runs
almost as much as rides in Waterdog, I feel there
needs to be more awareness and education about
trail etiquette from all users of the space. I really
don’t think banning one group will solve anything
and could potentially cause more issues of illegal
trail building & poaching. That would be the
worst thing for Waterdog as it would create more
erosion and damage to the amazing open space.

Please don’t let a small group of people dictate
and close this wonderful space off to cyclists.
• The trail keepers and volunteers are doing
a great job at Waterdog! Thanks.

Please do not take biking away from
Waterdog based on the opinion of a few.
• I consider an Open Space to be similar to a
National Wilderness area, that is, no motorized
vehicles (including electric bikes), very limited
amenities, focused on preservation of the natural
environment. This is different from a National Park.
• If the balance of Waterdog trails for bikes and hikers needs to be further addressed, it’s likely due to
the large increase in traffic of both since 2020. I
highly recommend doing a free or “encouraged
donation” reservation process, and occasionally do
an enforcement. The Tamarancho trail park in Marin
County does something similar and it’s worked well.
• the open spaces are wonderful.. and so
improved since i moved here 30 years ago. i
really appreciate the mountain bike community
for their upkeep of the trails.. i remember when
it was challenging to hike.. i got lost a few times
because the trails weren’t well marked. i also feel
safer walking around on the “”single track”” since
there are more people around with the bikers...

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
845

APPENDIX I
372 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• The trails around Waterdog Lake are an incredible
resource for Belmont and the neighboring cities.

When my wife and I were looking to move to the
area 11 years ago, access to this open space
and trail network for riding mountain bikes was
high on the priority list. As our family grew to
include 2 young boys, we enjoy using this park as
a family on and off the bike. What would make
Belmont even better is if they had an all ages
/ abilities bike park like the new Ramsay Park
pump track that just opened up in Watsonville.

Thank you for your time and consideration!
• They’re great. Been mountain biking here since
1998 and in some ways has saved my life.
• Water Dog is by far the most accessible place on
the Peninsula for singletrack mountain biking. It
is used by high school teams and adult riders for
exercise, exposure to nature, and for enjoying
an activity that promotes health and getting
outside! The complaints about biking at WD by
a vocal minority can easily be addressed through
signage, education, and smart trail design and
maintenance- even something as simple as
designating trail directionality, or promoting the use
of bells on bikes. These have been implemented
successfully in communities across the country!
• The 15 year Master Plan seems like a great
time for prioritizing habitat preservation,
trail quality and safety for the enjoyment
of visitors. To do so will take more active
management and money than in the past.
• The regions open spaces and parks are a terrific
resource. I use them daily to hike. Waterdog
is one of my favorites; I’ve been going several
times a week for almost 20 years. I love that
it’s quiet and in a “natural” state. And I love
how polite and helpful the bikers are.
• I have been biking here for my whole life and
I know that there is a big movement to ban
bikes from trails. Bikers have been the people
that mostly maintain the trails and keep them in
good condition. Please don’t ban bikes here.
• Is there too much use of the waterdog bike trails?
I’m honestly not sure if mountain bikes are pushing
out vegetation in the area. The other is the drainage
along the side of the fire road in waterdog seems
to be getting deeper every year. Is that expected?
• Important to alot. Creates a community
• Please don’t cave to the vocal anti-bike minority.
the trails are for everyone and the space is
plenty big to accommodate all. And why prevent
night riding??? just let people ride, the more
they ride at night the less they will ride during
the day when hikers/walkers abound.
• The hiking trails and all of waterdog
lake area are one of belmont’s most
unique and welcoming features.
• Really appreciate an open space for biking that is
close to where I live and doesn’t require driving,
• I feel that the nature, wildlife and humans have been threatened by bikers and made the open space
very unsafe. They race by with disregard to wildlife
and humans. They have carved out many trails
and made some existing ones unsafe by wearing
them down and making them slippery. I no longer
feel safe bringing my grandkids on the trails as I
did with my own children. I have almost been hit
several times by bikers in the last twelve months,
• I like biking in them
• Bikers have caused the trails in
Water Dog to be unsafe.

The use of bikes has threatened wildlife. Bikes
should be banned from the Open Space. The
trails are no longer a place where a individual
can take a peaceful walk or hike. Many people
including the elderly and parents with small
children now avoid the Open Space as it has
been over run by disrespecting bikers.
• None
• I love biking on water dog’s trails with my brother
• We love them. We use them 3-4 times per week.
• Absolutely love biking, running and
hiking with my dog. And I would love
to help with trail maintenance. I
• Waterdog is excellent for mountain biking
(and hiking). Please keep it multi use.
• Parking and traffic at Waterdog Lake entrances
on weekends is out of control during peak
times. Interferes with nearby residents.
• At Water dog and surrounding trails there has
been a plethora of new E-bike riders and the trails
are not safe enough to allow them to use. My
main concerns are with their speed and etiquette.
they do not slow down for other trail users and
often cause more damage to the trail systems
due to most E-bikes ranging from 50-80lbs where
most normal mountain bikes max out at 30lbs.
• I would love to see the city plant more trees!
• I love Belmont Open Spaces!
• The open spaces are regional assets that deserve
care appropriate for their incredible value.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
846
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 373

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 16. Other Responses (con’t)
• Mtn bikes should only be allowed on wider trails,
not narrow hiking trails due to hiker and biker safety.

Illegal trails such as “Labor of Love” trails built by
thrill seeking bikers should be closed because they
are too narrow for hikers and bikers to share safely.
• By encouraging folks outside of Belmont to hike
our trails we have severely increased the number
of people who are accessing the trails and it has
caused an issue in our neighborhood with parking,
trash, safety and people abusing the trails. Please
put up signs that the trails are closed from sunset to
sunrise. There’s also crime and drugs at the bottom
of sheep camp trail. Which starts starts in Belmont.

Please monitor Waterdog, CSM cross country trail
and Sheep Camp more. Putting up dog stations,
trash cans and new signage and leaving up the
old signage and not taking it down is making the
neighborhood look junky and less desirable. There
should be more signage that goes out to the open
space in the Belmont Heights area that warns of
rattlesnakes and mountain lions. During Covid so
many kids just running off trails and into the bushes
and someone’s going to get her at some point.
• Please keep the Open Spaces as multi-purpose
recreational areas that are currently being used as.
• Please do not limit, ban or restrict the use
of bikes in Waterdog Park. One of the
reasons we moved to Belmont was to be
close to Waterdog for mountain biking.
• We appreciate both hiking and biking in the open
space areas. We have been able to safely do
both for the last three decades, and are strongly
against those who wish to limit access to others.
• It’s wonderful for mt bikes it one of our
only places to enjoy close by
• Keep Waterdog open to bikes and support the
needs of mountain bike riders in Waterdog.

Create more bike specific trails and pump track.
• I’d love to see the steep trails on the belmont
side of laurelwood worked on a bit to be easier
to go up and down. Also I’d walk to it if we
didn’t have the bizarre custom of blocking
sidewalks by parking on them. It sucks.
• It seems that the past year has been very hard on
the trail systems at the open spaces. Lots of wear
and tear from increased use, both hiker and cyclist,
and lack of trail maintenance shows. The trails
need a major refresh to remain safe for all users.
• The Belmont parks are a huge part of my children’s
lives and I would like to see the open space, trails,
and bike access to see continued investment.
• Belmont’s Open Spaces are a jewel, and
Waterdog and it’s multi-use nature (biking, hiking,
etc...) was one of the main reasons I decided
to settle in the area. I would really like to see
Waterdog’s multi-use nature maintained.
• Designated use trails and more trails to ensure
that there are enough for everyone would go
a long way to allowing me to use the trails I
used to love so much before the pandemic
made them unsafe due to increased use.
• Really appreciate the work done recently
at Waterdog/Hidden Canyon; have been
mountain biking here for 13 years and
appreciate the city’s recent improvements
• There are Belmont residents who harass
bikers and spread misinformation about the
effects of biking on the environment and are
working to ban bikes from water dog lake.
• I would recommend we designate Waterdog as a
cycling-focused park and keep the trails narrow
and somewhat primitive. Hikers can recreate at one
of the many no-bikes regional parks (Edgewood,
Cross Country Course, Big Canyon, etc). Cyclists
have limited open space choices and and
inadequate recreational resources for their needs
• Arbitrarily limiting access to Waterdog to a specific group based on fear and prejudice is really lame. I
am deeply disappointed with these residents who,
instead of offering a real solution to the problems
we face, want to take the ball and go home. There
is much more that we could do to improve relations
between all users, including posting reminders
to yield to other users (bikes yield to runners/
hikers) and reminders to hike on the right. I’ve
been riding/running/hiking in Waterdog since 1991
and have never seen more angry and entitled
Karens walking around the space as I have seen
lately. They don’t wear masks, are standing in
the middle of the trail, and scream at cyclists to
“slow down” regardless of our pace. They are
looking for a confrontation to justify their anger and
entitlement and shouldn’t be accommodated.
• Love ‘em
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
847

APPENDIX I
374 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• Lacking compared to neighboring towns
of San Carlos and San Mateo
• N/a
• no opinion
• While I glance at the park and rec activity
guide (now that my sons are adults), I am
not aware of outdoor programs for adults.
• You have programs for seniors and youths, but
nothing for working professionals. The hours the
programs offer are in the working hours, and there
is nothing of interest to the working professionals.

I understand it could be difficult to find qualified
instructors or facilitators for the programs, but I
haven’t seen any public call of recruitments either.
• Great for recreational sports fields!
• Keep doing what you are doing. I love
the updates you made to the Softball /
Soccer Fields at the Sports Complex.
• Please add more pickleball courts with lights
that are open all day and in the evening
• You need to create SAFE bicycle lanes in Belmont
that are not shared with a traffic lane (as in
downtown Belmont). You need a protected bike
lane west of Cipriani on Ralston where cars are
going 40+ mph and there is no shoulder. Ralston
Middle School kids would be able to safely ride
to school, and the general public would not be
taking our lives in our hands any time we wanted
to go for a recreational ride. San Carlos, Foster
City, and San Mateo have managed to increase
their bicycle safety routes; why not Belmont!?
• Yeah, Sports complex is great now
- more turf would be good!
• Oitdoor lap swimming pool.
• I grew up with a neighborhood pool where a kid
could get a membership for the summer and go
play all summer. Having only Carlmont’s pool
available during work days for 2 or 3 hours isn’t
very useful for the community and it is expensive!
• With the exception of Belmont Sports Complex, our
fields are often in poor shape. More maintenance
needs to be performed to keep them up.
• Is the track at Carlmont HS open to the public?
• pricey for the tax paying residents. $5 price
difference between resident and non-resident
pricing. the barrett community centre building is fall
apart. again don’t see the tax dollar being used
• I do not participate too much in recreation
programs due to my work schedule. But I
like the idea of outdoor tour guides maybe on
the weekends at some of our beautiful open
spaces. Maybe a volunteer program to clean
up and plant native gardens in some areas of
Belmont. Also bring back the music groups in
Twin Pines park for Sunday’s. Maybe more
events at Twin Pines park would be nice.
• n/a
• I think it’s great!
• Bike riding is an inclusive and therapeutic
activity for people with disabilities such as
my dad. Disallowing the use of bikes on trails
would take away the one thing my dad can
do that is active because he is disabled.
• All sports activities should be
included in these locations.
• I think it is important that you not exclude people.

Belmont has done an amazing job of balancing
biking and hiking. That should be celebrated -
there are room for improvements, but please don’t
over regulate. Biking is booming and Belmont
can lead the way on sharing off-road access.
• My son would love to participate in kids’ cycling
classes at the pump track once it’s complete.
• Allow classes to use space for free
if they are free classes.
• We enjoy these programs with all ages and
members of our family and look forward to more.
• It’s been many years since I’ve participated in
outdoor programs, but I believe there’s value
in these programs. I believe a community
trail crew/maintenance team would be
popular and allow people to build what they
want out of their outdoor experience.
• Expand class offerings for youth and
adults. Also, there doesn’t seem to be
much of anything for tweens (10-13).
• Youth mountain bike teams are in cities all around
California and are a great way for kids to get
involved and get outside. I wish Belmont had one
when I was in middle school or high school so I
could have improved my skills. The trails of Belmont
make many people great riders and I myself just
recently competed in a national championship for
mountain biking and it all started on Belmont trails.
• We would love to see access to public swimming.
• N/A
QUESTION 17. WHAT ELSE WOULD YOU LIKE US TO KNOW ABOUT BELMONT’S OUTDOOR RECREATION PROGRAMS (THIS INCLUDES YOUTH SPORTS, OUTDOOR EXERCISE, ETC)? DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
848
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 375

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• Our kids love these and want more
opportunities to participate
• Need more opportunities for youth to
engage with our community.
• You should put up a banner before summer
camp enrollment opens up, to drive web traffic.
• The National Interscholastic Cycling League is
a fantastic youth sports opportunity for nearby
students, who could train at Waterdog.
• NA
• bikes need to continue to have access to the park
• More outdoor education opportunities
for youth would be great.
• No opinion
• These can change the feel and crowding
of a natural area like Waterdog. It would
be a negative for me and my family.
• no need for these. there are plenty
of other options in the area
• Please keep trails maintained and
do not restrict usage access
• I’d like to know when outdoor rec program
will include mountain biking classes through
the Belmont parks and rec. Thx!
• Keep mountain bike trails open. Expand access
• Make more of it!
• Keep mountain biking trails
• Where are the mountain bike classes?
• I would like to know that cycling access to open
space remains a priority within San Mateo
and I would like you to know that other forms
of recreation can coexist with cyclists.
• Waterdog lake presents an important opportunity
for the youth of this community to engage in
fun outdoor activities, such as mountain biking.

Restricting access to waterdog lake for this
activity would force us to drive further away to
places like San Jose. There are not many places
that provide this opportunity mid peninsula.
• Biking and hiking at Waterdog is my
primary use of open space in Belmont
• Need more activities for the middle aged and elders
• More programs
• N/A
• nothing
• Exercise isn’t just physical..it is mental. Having a
free Waterdog park to be able to ride a bike with my
kids or go for a run on extensively well maintained
trails that our own scouts have volunteered
countless hours from Troop 42 and other troops in
the area would not just be sad and disappointing,
it would be selfish, self-serving, limiting and
frankly, criminal on the level of those few who are
selfishly trying to shut down this popular mountain
biking and exercising Mecca...one of the very
few, well maintained ones left in Silicon Valley.
• Waterdog is the only place in Belmont and San
Mateo County where cyclist have access to
local trails. It is a wonderful place for children
to learn to ride their bikes and for an afterwork fitness ride. Waterdog’s trail were built by mountain bikers and the volunteer opportunities
allows us to give back to community.
• Allow bikes on trails
• Please more youth programs!
• We don’t use these.
• please consider adding a community pool as
temps have risen so much over the years.
• Permanent Outdoor Pickleball Courts
• Needs to include lap swimming access for the
community, and reliable access to tennis courts -
the only City-only court I know of is the single courts at Alexander and Hallmark Parks. Would like to
know the official status of Carlmont courts - are they
a community resource? same with their pool. These
are the major swim and tennis resources available.

After the JCC left Belmont in the early 2000’s,
these kinds of resources were never replaced.
• These are always at weird times that don’t
accommodate parents that work. Please have
some classes that start after work ends.
• Teach people to value health and nature and
their responsibility to protect and support nature
for a healthy and sustainable environment to
be enjoyed by many future generations.
• Thank you for the abundant access to parks
• Keep the spaces open for all. It’s a beautiful
way for our community to stay together.
• Expand youth activities
• Local parks and open space should be open and
inclusive to all. Excluding certain groups is not fair. • More mind/body offerings like yoga & Tai
chi in the evening. We are on the Silicon
Wheel hamster wheel & business hours
are impossible to join anything
• Oppose creating activities with regional draw
• Belmont Sports Complex has been a
treasured gem for my son to use and us
parents to watch. We’re lucky to have it.
• You do a great job of management
of the parks and open space
DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
849

APPENDIX I
376 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• Build some tennis courts and fix the ones
up off of Hallmark. Please do NOT make
the tennis courts as duel use with pickleball
courts they are two incompatible activities.
• Nothing
• The brsll program is outstanding. We need to
have the Nesbit baseball field upgraded. We
also need a community swimming pool.
• LET US EXPAND THE PROGRAMS
• Skate parks
• N/a
• NA
• We need a real youth center with an
indoor basketball court. There is no
reason you can’t put one at the BSC.
• The youth needs skate parks or skate spaces
• Will try some classes
• Bicycling and walking dogs is
very important in nature
• Mountain biking uses
• I am strongly opposed to any project that
allows mountain biking in natural areas.

DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
850
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 377

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• Belmont is severely lacking in adequate
sports facilities compared to anywhere else
in the Bay Area. The grass fields are mostly
terrible and even dangerous to play sports
on. I do prefer grass fields over artificial
although realize artificial is easier all round
• Allow more mountain biking and electric bikes.
• Ice Skating should be encouraged
to return to Belmont.
• Best those programs are held at recreation
centers and park areas with dedicated trails for
walking and play. The wildlife in open spaces
can be dangerous due to predators such as
mountain lions and rattlesnakes and those
animals should also be protected from curious
children and dangerous of construction.
• Same as above.
• Belmont should start a youth Mountain
Bike weekly ride in Waterdog Open
Space/Hidden Canyon trailhead.
• Please keep parks open to multiuse activities.
• Would love to have the opportunity to do educational
hikes with naturalists, mycologists, historians, etc.
• Increase number of program. Have trained
volunteer leading the program.
• n/a
• Nothing
• Nothing
• Do not capture economic growth of mountain biking.
• N/A
• More bike lanes and implementation of safety
expert recommendations for Ralston Ave
• I’ve been hiking and mountain biking in Hidden
Canyon/Water dog for 25 years. It has been my
primary exercise destination during that time.
• Please prioritize mountain bike access to trails
• Make it all inclusive for ALL people.
• Do not close the trails for mountain biking.

My kids love biking around here and need
the space for outdoor experiences.
• Keep and enhance all cycling opportunities
including mountain biking
• HS Mtn bike teams?
• Keep area open to all uses
• Mountain biking
• The new turf at the recreational center
makes it one of the best fields in the area
• A skate park would be greatly appreciated
by the kids as well as parents.
• Many of the Mountain Biking Community
welcome the opportunity and are involved
in maintaining the trails at Water Dog.
• in keeping with the master plan’s stated goal of
equity and inclusion, mountain bikes should be
allowed on all recreational multi-use trails.
• They are great
• Important to keep mountain biking
access to waterdog park
• Build a paved pump track or 3!
• It would be interesting to attend a small
yoga class at an open space
• Mountain bike youth camps please!!!
• Having a youth mtn bike club / team that is city
sponsored would be wonderful & a great way
to educate youth on bike safety/etiquette
• na
• I have not partipated in any of the programs
• N/A
• I cannot comment on this
• What are plans to expand biking opportunities?
• more open swim times in summer
• Maybe update the summer concert series at
Twin Pines to attract younger participants.
• Please build Pickleball courts... it is
the fastest growing sport in America.

Foster city did an amazing job!
• The best way to stay updated on
activities/events for the ORP.
• The tennis courts at Hallmark Park need
to be resurfaced and skirted around to
prevent debris getting into the courts.
• More facilities and classes for sports
and recreations would be great!
• what is timing of expanding Belmont’s
outdoor recreation programs again?
• Not interested.
• More mountain bike programs please.
• New turf field @ BSC is great. Would be nice if
Belmont United could use the area outside of the
baseball fence for practices when baseball is there/
not there. It’s been empty many times I’ve been
there & BU is playing on sloped, crappy fields.
• Ongoing updates about development at Barrett
and master plan. Activity guide was important part
of our yearly planning; looking forward activities
resuming and there being enough space.
• I would also like to add, Belmont should offer
a First Aid class. Maybe they already do?
• There should be a focus on mountain biking.
• More yoga and Zumba classes on
weekends and late afternoons.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
851

APPENDIX I
378 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
• Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• We don’t use these programs
• I’d like to hear more about the cities
programs. The things that are available are
not necessarily on our radar or we’re not
subscribed to the correct places to see them.
• Some fields should have soccer nets
available outside of organized team
sports. All nets locked up otherwise.
• Belmont needs a good safe connection from
upper Ralston (by Fox and Ralston Schools)
to the rest of Belmont (Alameda, El Camino,
101). If there was a safe route for biking that
connected all of Belmont it would greatly improve
the utilization of Recreation Programs
• Not much for teens to do in Belmont. Once
they age out of AYSO and Little League, then
what? Need sports activities for the nonvarsity kids. A skate park would be fantastic. • Nothing at this time. Thank you.
• Have reasonable fees or if a resident free -
use our tax dollars for our community ….have
bands in the summer again, and offer classes
on the green grass areas if not inside.
• Dedicated outdoor spaces for exercises. Nature.
• I wish Belmont has a swimming pool and a athletic
facility like Highland Rec Center in San Mateo.
• Nice job on belmont sports complex
• All of the Park and Rec activities (especially
the exercise classes) are offered during the
day when people are working or in the evening.

Please offer more adult and senior classes on
the weekend (and not limited to early morning).
• It would be great to have a nice recreation
center like the PJCC in Foster City, something
that can work for everyone. Low cost!!!!!!!!
• More would be nice
• Facilities outdated and not very inviting. Would
hesitate to leave children there for an activity.
• Mountain bike lessons for families. This is becoming
a popular sport for families and need more training.
• We love Belmont United.
• A running track would be great. Carlmont
HS has a track but it is very unclear if/
when that is available for public use so
even clarifying that would be helpful.
• I don’t participate in rec programs.
• The parking lot is challenging at Barrett. Tough
getting in and out for vehicles and pedestrians.
• Bie and skate parks.
• I do not use these services
• More dancing classes and yoga classes
• Aquatics programs would be a huge addition
for our family. Right now we have to go
to the highlands pool in San Mateo.
• More publicity would help.
• You should not be charging money to use fields that
sit empty most of the time. We want to play soccer
at lunch on weekdays, but instead we stay inside.
• None
• organized activities aren’t for me, but not opposed
to them unless they substantially detract from
everyone else’s ability to bike, play, walk, etc.
• So much emphasis on sports leagues and not
enough about learning and creating in the outdoors.
• More programs for youth are helpful. Homework
club and after-school hangouts help keep the
community out there and interacting with each other
• It would be great for Belmont to add a
skatepark and bicycle pump track.
• I love them. I love biking in Belmont.
• Waterdog lake needs permanent
restrooms at both ends.
• For years when our kids were little and played
competitive sports we pushed for turf fields so way
to go on finally getting some of these in place! The
Sports Complex looks great and I only wish my kids
could’ve used these but happy for those who can.
• A pool would be a fantastic addition
for Belmont. Hopefully this is still in
the works for the Barrett update.
• Add more tennis and running programs.

Think of road bike programs too. Huge road
bike community here in a Belmont (always
escaping to Woodside or Hillsborough...)
• We very much appreciate these programs and use
them extensively. Thank you for offering them.
• Would like to encourage more
outdoor sports for youth
• Would like to know what programs are
available in a timely manner.
• Would like swimming, tennis courts,
kids after school activities
• Love camp soar.
• Adding swimming for kids and families. Classes,
camps, recreational, family splash times, etc....
• N/A
• We need pickleball courts!!!
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
852
Community Outreach
CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD 379

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• Many of the youth activities are much more
expensive than surrounding communities (for
example, the Redwood City soccer program
is half the price, which is why we chose
it, despite being a Belmont resident)
• Our teen LOVED the hiking club program
run by Brandon. More of those types of
programs please. Broken into age groups
• I think the Outdoor Recreation Programs
are very high quality, thank you.
• Not really interested in these.
• Youth sports are so important and
offering them at the rec level is essential.
thank you for offering them!
• Please offer more swimming options in
Belmont. We need our kids to be water-safe.

Please open up swim lessons for kids!
• Pretty good the way they are. Spend the money
elsewhere where it may be needed more.
• Any possibility of a community pool at Barrett?
• We love Camp SOAR and hope it comes back
for Summer 2021! Also, we’d love to see more
all-sports or multi-sports classes so our kids
can experience a lot of different sports and
figure out what they like and don’t like.
• Free events and general guidelines
• ice skating rink would be so great
• More adult outdoor classes please.
• A swimming pool/aquatics would
be a wonderful addition.
• -I wish that we had a community pool that
was more accessible to kids (Carlmont pool
has very limited hours for free swim and is
overcrowded by campers when it is open).
-I want to reiterate my sentiment that the
trails should be open to all (even e-bikes).
• We used to use these, mostly at Barrett, but as
the kids get older less. Still we know a lot of
people who use these. They are important.
• More aquatics programs for kids - after school
and on weekends, summer time camps.

More STEAM/educational programs.
• community pool would be great
• Construct Bocce ball courts as
the City has promised!!
• It would be nice to see more outdoor
recreation programs for tweens and teens
• I am not aware of any such program. I’ve
lived here for two years and have not seen
any information on any programs.
• N/A
• My son is in BRSLL so we’ve practiced at Nesbit
and Ralston. I’d love to see the city have a
better plan for Barrett Community center.
• Underdeveloped. The Belmont Sports
Complex in general could be further
developed for more fields and parking.
• More things for youth or ways to
get to know others your age.
• Bring some classes back.
• I’m sure you know this... it is always hard
to find fields/spaces to play sports.
• I believe a community pool like the one in
Highland center would help the community
• Swimming pools needed
• BRSLL and local AYSO are great but our kids no
longer playing organized sports. Fully support
these programs, though and want there to be
plenty of fields for the next generations.
• I haven’t seen much of what’s on offer, more
publicity or signage would be a good idea.
• Good job balancing needs between
sports and individual users!
• NA
• Do you have mountain biking camps for kids? Most
outdoor programming seems to be for team-based
skill sports, as opposed to mountain biking, or
endurace-based sports which a) can be a lifelong
sport (unlike most team sports), and b) can instill
in kids a deep love of outdoors, hopefully leading
to children with a passion for sustainability and
stewardship of our precious outdoors and habitats.
• Keep funding to insure that our youth
have a place to learn and enjoy
• More drop in adult exercise classes would
be great! We need a community pool.
• Please do not eliminate mountain
biking use at waterdog
• Needs by far the most focus is the poor condition
of fields and recreation facilities at the schools.

In general, they are poorly maintained. This is
by far where resources should be directed. The
grass fields are okay a few months a year only.

The outdoor basketball courts are antiquated.
• Better restrooms at fields.

Swimming pool.

DRAFT | Final February 2024
DRAFT Community Outreach
853

APPENDIX I
380 PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES

ONLINE SURVEY QUESTIONS
Question 17. Other Responses (con’t)
• The city of San Francisco just partnered with
Outward bound to run a ropes course. We
have one in our backyard and it would be nice
if our community is able to use this resource.

Perhaps, we can also partner with Outward
bound to make this community connections.
• More basketball courts please
• A pump track would be great for
young kids starting to ride.
• Keep up the good work!
• So many of the recreation programs for individuals
who are older than 55 are offered during the
day. Many individuals who are over 55 are still
working and would still like to take part in the
recreation programs that park and rec‘s offers.
• You guys do a great job!
• Would be nice if the lake were stalked with fish
occasionally for kids to experience fishing.
• The top youth sports priorities for our
family are softball and swimming.
• We love movie nights!
• I started working with groups to improve youth sport
fields when my kids were 6 & 4. They are now 21
& 19 & just last year the sports complex got turfed.

This took WAY TOO LONG! Too much bureaucracy!
Prioritize these projects and get them done!
• It is very important to maintain an adequate
budget for future maintenance of our facilities,
including buildings, structures, play equipment,
lighting, etc. And do not forget to increase City
maintenance staff as you add facilities to the
Department. This includes park landscape
maintenance staffing, equipment and supplies.
• I love the idea of more outdoor exercise, also
would love to see a large community garden
where we can teach children (and adults) the
how to grow food, the importance of eating
local, importance of pollinators, birds, etc.
• NA
• I would really love to see swimming classes and a
pool, either to be able to use the high school pool, or build one at Barrett or wherever else there is space.
• None
• It would be great if Belmont offered more
programs so we don’t have to go to other cities
for tennis or soccer camps or dance lessons!
• Yoga sounds nice
• Mountain biking at waterdog is big
• None
• Teen activities
• love the youth programs, especially
dance for my daughters
• Love ‘em
DRAFT | Final February 2024

APPENDIX I DRAFT
854
381

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
Youth & Teen Focus Meeting
June 3, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
What Are We Doing Today?
○ Overview of Project Efforts to Date
○ Discussion:
■ Existing Likes
■ Existing Challenges
■ Potential Improvements
belmontprosplan.com PARKS & FACILITIES
● 16 developed parks
● 11 athletic fields
● 300+ acres of open space
● Recent improvements:
855
382

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Set the framework for decision makers in the
planning, maintenance, development, and/or
rehabilitation of Belmont’s parks and open
space system and related recreational
programming for a 15 year horizon.

PURPOSE MASTER PLAN GOALS & GUIDING PRINCIPLES
○ Provide equitable access to resources and activities across the entire city ○ Promote inclusion to people of all backgrounds, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic position or physical/cognitive ability ○ Offer services and activities across a range of interests, abilities, and ages ○ Reflect our commitment to environmental resilience and sustainability ○ Respect the beauty and importance of our natural resources ○ Advances community health and well-being
○ Foster a sense of community and encourage social interaction ○ Are well maintained and actively managed over time
○ Can adapt to changing conditions and needs
○ Utilize transparent community process to inform decisions

TIMELINE EXISTING SITE ASSESSMENT
856
383

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS
(2% under 18)
Question #5
For the parks, athletic
facilities and open
space you visit in
Belmont, please tell us
how you would rate the
condition of that
space?
Question #5
For the parks, athletic
facilities and open
space you visit in
Belmont, please tell us
how you would rate the
condition of that
space?
Question #3
Why do you visit parks,
athletic facilities and
open spaces?
857
384

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT

EXISTING LIKES & CHALLENGES
Twin Pines Park Waterdog Lake Belmont Sports Complex
Semeria Park
Davey Glen Park Cipriani Park

POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS

THANK YOU
[email protected]
858
385

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
District Focus Meeting
June 4, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
belmontprosplan.com
What Are We Doing Today?
○ Overview of Project Efforts to Date
○ Discussion:

Current Joint Use
● Who is using what and where
● Any issues with continuing joint use
● Any unmet needs
Potential Joint Use
● Additional recreation needs
● Other joint use opportunities

PARKS & FACILITIES
● 16 developed parks
● 11 athletic fields
● 300+ acres of open space
● Recent improvements:
859
386

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

TIMELINE EXISTING SITE ASSESSMENT
860
387

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS ATHLETIC FIELDS
What Are We Doing Today?
Current Joint Use
● Who is using what and where
● Any issues with continuing joint use
● Any unmet needs
Potential Joint Use
● Additional recreation needs
● Other joint use opportunities

NESBIT SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement
861
388

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT

CENTRAL SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

RALSTON MIDDLE SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

FOX SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

BELMONT SPORTS COMPLEX
862
389

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
CIPRIANI PARK McDOUGAL FIELDS

POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS

THANK YOU
[email protected]
863
390

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024 FOCUS GROUPS - BOARDS FOR SENIORS + DOG OWNERS
1 Alexander Park
2 Barrett Community Center
3 Belameda Park
4 Belmont Sports Complex
5 Central School*
6 Cipriani Park / Dog Park
WHAT DO YOU THINK OF YOUR PARKS?
2 3
4 5
6 20
17 7
21 8
16 10
11 12
13 23
22 9
18 19
1 14
15 CIPRIANI PARK

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD

BELMONT PARKS & FACILITIES MAP
13 McDougal Park
14 Nesbit School*
15 O’Donnell Park
16 Patricia Wharton Park
17 Ralston Middle School*
18 Ralston Ranch Park
7 College View Park
8 Davey Glen Park
9 Fox School*
10 Hallmark Park
11 Hastings Tot Lot
12 Hidden Canyon Park
19 San Juan Canyon
20 Semeria Park
21 Twin Pines Park
22 Wakefield Park
23 Waterdog Lake
Dog Park
Park
Open Space
WHAT DO YOU THINK OF YOUR PARKS?

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADD YOUR PARKS?
OTHER IDEAS?
1 Alexander Park
2 Barrett Community Center
3 Belameda Park
4 Belmont Sports Complex
5 Central School*
6 Cipriani Park / Dog Park
2 3
4 5
6 20
17 7
21 8
16 10
11 12
13 23
22 9
18 19
1 14
15 BELMONT PARKS & FACILITIES MAP
13 McDougal Park
14 Nesbit School*
15 O’Donnell Park
16 Patricia Wharton Park
17 Ralston Middle School*
18 Ralston Ranch Park
7 College View Park
8 Davey Glen Park
9 Fox School*
10 Hallmark Park
11 Hastings Tot Lot
12 Hidden Canyon Park
19 San Juan Canyon
20 Semeria Park
21 Twin Pines Park
22 Wakefield Park
23 Waterdog Lake
Dog Park
Park
Open Space
SURVEY
SAYS...

APPENDIX I DRAFT
864
391

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD FOCUS GROUPS - BOARDS FOR SENIORS + DOG OWNERS

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADD YOUR PARKS?

SHADED SEATING

SYNTHETIC TURF AREA

LOG TUNNEL

MORE DOG WASTE STATIONS

LEASH HOLDER

DOG WASH

WATER FEATURE

AGILITY FEATURES
OTHER IDEAS?

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADD YOUR PARKS?

MORE TRAILS / MULTI-USE PATHS

MORE EXERCISE STATIONS

MORE TREES

MORE DOG WASTE STATIONS

MORE SIGNAGE & WAYFINDING

MORE PUBLIC ART

COMMUNITY GARDENS

MORE RESTROOMS
OTHER IDEAS?
DRAFT Community Outreach
865
392

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024 FOCUS GROUPS - BOARDS FOR SENIORS + DOG OWNERS

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD

PARKS, RECREATION, AND OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
2 3
4 5
6 20
17 7
21 8
16 10
11 12
13 23
22 9
18 19
1 14
15 BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
1 Alexander Park 7 College View Park 13 McDougal Park 19 San Juan Canyon 2 Barrett Community Center 8 Davey Glen Park 14 Nesbit School* 20 Semeria Park 3 Belameda Park 9 Fox School* 15 O’Donnell Park 21 Twin Pines Park 4 Belmont Sports Complex 10 Hallmark Park 16 Patricia Wharton Park 22 Wakefield Park 5 Central School* 11 Hastings Tot Lot 17 Ralston Middle School* 23 Waterdog Lake 6 Cipriani Park / Dog Park 12 Hidden Canyon Park 18 Ralston Ranch Park BELMONTPROSPLAN.COM

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
BELMONTPROSPLAN.COM

GUIDING PRINCIPALS

W E H AV E B I G G OA L S F O R O U R PA R K S A N D

RECREATION MASTER PLAN AND NEED YOUR INPUT
COMING THIS FALL...

DRAFT MASTER PLAN RECOMMENDATIONS

ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING

FOCUS GROUPS

A LWAYS ACC E P T I N G CO M M E N TS O N O U R P R O J E C T

WEBSITE
Provide equitable access to resources and ac tivities across the entire cit y Promote inclusion to people of all backgrounds, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic position or physical/cognitive ability Offer services and activities across a range of interests, abilities, and ages Reflect our commitment to environmental resilience and sustainability Respect the beauty and importance of our natural resources Advances community health and well-being
Foster a sense of community and encourage social interaction Are well maintained and ac tively managed over time
Can adapt to changing conditions and needs
Utilize transparent community process to inform decisions

PARKS, RECREATION, AND OPEN MASTER PLAN

APPENDIX I DRAFT
866
393

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD FOCUS GROUPS - BOARDS FOR SENIORS + DOG OWNERS
WHAT DO YOU THINK OF YOUR PARKS?

CIPRIANI PARK

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD

BARRETT COMMUNITY CENTER

BELMONT, CALIFORNIA
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN
LET’S BUILD

OUR BACKYARD
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADD YOUR PARKS?

SYNTHETIC TURF DECOMPOSED GRANITE
OTHER IDEAS?

WOOD CHIPS

SURFACING

DOG WASH FOUNTAIN PERIMETER FENCING

AMENITIES

JUMPING FEATURES NATURAL OBSTACLES WEAVE

AGILITY FEATURES

SHADED SEATING WATER PLAY VARIETY OF SEATING OPTIONS
DRAFT Community Outreach
867
394

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Youth Sports Focus Meeting
June 24, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
What Are We Doing Today?
○ Overview of Project Efforts to Date
○ Discussion: Any unmet needs
belmontprosplan.com PARKS & FACILITIES
● 16 developed parks
● 11 athletic fields
● 300+ acres of open space
● Recent improvements:
868
395

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
Set the framework for decision makers in the
planning, maintenance, development, and/or
rehabilitation of Belmont’s parks and open
space system and related recreational
programming for a 15 year horizon.

TIMELINE EXISTING SITE ASSESSMENT
869
396

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS ATHLETIC FIELDS
What Are We Doing Today?
Current Use
● Who is using what and where
● Any issues with this use
Future Use
● Unmet needs
● Field improvements
● Other opportunities

NESBIT SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement
870
397

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

CENTRAL SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

RALSTON MIDDLE SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

FOX SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

BELMONT SPORTS COMPLEX
871
398

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
CIPRIANI PARK McDOUGAL FIELDS

POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS

THANK YOU
[email protected]
872
399

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
Inclusion Focus Meeting
June 29, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
What Are We Doing Today?
○ Overview of Project Efforts to Date
○ Discussion:

Existing Conditions
● Who is using what and where
● Feedback about current amenities? programming?
● Any unmet needs?
Opportunities for improvement?
● Additional recreation needs?
● Other amenities or opportunities?
belmontprosplan.com PARKS & FACILITIES
● 16 developed parks
● 11 athletic fields
● 300+ acres of open space
● Recent improvements:
873
400

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

TIMELINE EXISTING SITE ASSESSMENT
874
401

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS
● Open Spac
● Parks: I do
● Athletic Fie
that interes
● Maintain and enhance tree
canopy
● Add more multi-use paths in
parks
● Add more restrooms
● Add more trees
● Add more benches and
places to sit
● Bike pump track
● Add more quiet areas for
connection to nature and
relaxation (res. only)
● Add more shade (res. only)
● Add more picnic areas
● Add more community
gardens
Question #3
● Strongly Agree: Bike pump track, maintain & enhance tree canopy, add more multi-use paths in parks
● Agree: Aquatics (by a lot), public art.
● Disagree: Opportunities to buy food or drink.
● Strongly Disagree: Access to WiFi, food/drink, lacrosse fields, and more rental spaces.

Question #5
● Strongly Ag
in parks
● Agree: Aqu
● Disagree: O
● Strongly Di
Question #8
875
402

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
● Strongly Agree: Bike pump track, maintain & enhance tree canopy, add more multi-use paths in parks
● Agree: Aquatics (by a lot), public art.
● Disagree: Opportunities to buy food or drink.
● Strongly Disagree: Access to WiFi, food/drink, lacrosse fields, and more rental spaces.

Question #9 ATHLETIC FIELDS
What Are We Doing Today?
Existing Conditions
● Who is using what and where
● Feedback about current amenities? programming?
● Any unmet needs?
Opportunities for improvement?
● Additional recreation needs?
● Other amenities or opportunities?

POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS
876
403

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

THANK YOU
[email protected]
877
404

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

PARKS & FACILITIES
● 16 developed parks
● 11 athletic fields
● 300+ acres of open space
● Recent improvements:
belmontprosplan.com
Schools Focus Meeting
June 29, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
What Are We Doing Today?
○ Overview of Project Efforts to Date
○ Discussion:

Current Joint Use
● Who is using what and where
● Any issues with continuing joint use
● Any unmet needs
Potential Joint Use
● Additional recreation needs
● Other joint use opportunities

APPENDIX I DRAFT
878
405

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS

TIMELINE EXISTING SITE ASSESSMENT
Set the framework for decision makers in the
planning, maintenance, development, and/or
rehabilitation of Belmont’s parks and open
space system and related recreational
programming for a 15 year horizon.

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

NESBIT SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement
What Are We Doing Today?
Current Joint Use/ Shared Space
● Who is using what and where
● Any issues with continuing joint use?
● Any unmet needs?
Potential Joint Use
● Additional recreation needs?
● Other joint use/shared space opportunities?

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS ATHLETIC FIELDS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
880
407

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS

FOX SCHOOL BELMONT SPORTS COMPLEX
Joint Use Agreement

CENTRAL SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement

RALSTON MIDDLE SCHOOL
Joint Use Agreement
DRAFT Community Outreach
881
408

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

CSUS FIELD POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS
CIPRIANI PARK McDOUGAL FIELDS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
882
409

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS

THANK YOU
[email protected]
DRAFT Community Outreach
883
410

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Focus Group
Hidden Canyon Park
October 18, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
1 Purpose To discuss park-specific DRAFT recommendations for Hidden Canyon Park Introductions + Schedule
Efforts to Date
Hidden Canyon Park DRAFT Recommendations
Next Steps
Discussion (Q+A, comments)
AGENDA
2 GOALS & GUIDING PRINCIPLES
The Master Plan will
● Provide equitable access to resources and activities across the entire city ● Promote inclusion to people of all backgrounds, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic position, or physical/cognitive ability
● Make all users feel welcome and safe
● Offer services and activities across a range of interests, abilities, and ages ● Reflect our commitment to environmental resilience and sustainability ● Respect the beauty and importance of our natural resources ● Advance community health and well-being
● Foster a sense of community and encourage social interaction ● Provide well maintained and actively managed facilities ● Adapt to changing conditions and needs
● Utilize transparent community process to inform decisions 3 PROCESS
Push out 1
4 884
411

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
Push out 1 month
BelmontPROSplan.com [email protected]
5 EFFORTS TO DATE
● Existing Conditions
● Community Engagement
○ Online Survey
○ Focus Groups
● Benchmarking + Trends
● Park Typologies
6 COMMUNITY INPUTS: SURVEY
Top 5 Reasons to Visit a park, recreation, or open space 90%
60% 55% 47% 45%
Top 6 Amenities positively-rated To Enhance the Belmont Park Experience 65% 58% 56% 51% 51% 51%

BELMONT RESIDENTS ON PARKS
7 COMMUNITY INPUTS: FOCUS GROUPS

DOG OWNERS
More shade
More seating
More gathering and
social spaces
More waste bins
Water fountain

SENIORS
More seating
More shade
Generally happy with
existing parks
YOUTH
Hang-out space for
youth/teens
Add seating
Larger-sized play
equipment
Community tables
Game areas

INCLUSIVITY
Inclusive play elements
sized larger (not just for
small children)
Sensory and tactile play
Protected spaces, but
with multiple sightlines
and access points

SCHOOL DISTRICT/

YOUTH SPORTS
Incentivize school field
improvements
Continued growth in
sports field demand
Interest in synthetic turf
8 885
412

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
AMENITIES: BELMONT IDEAL
Benchmarked Amenity
2021 2035
All-Abilities Playground + 1 0
Basketball Court (Full) 0 + 2
Basketball Court (Half) 0 + 2
Multi-Use Athletic Field + 1 + 2
Play Element + 3 0
Playground 0 + 2
Reservable Picnic Area,
Small + 2 + 1
Reservable Picnic Area,
Large + 1 0
Tennis Court + 2 + 1
Priority Amenity
2021 2035
Community Garden + 1 0
Dog Park + 1 0
Dog Parklet + 2 0
Pump Track (Bike Park) + 1 0
Skate Park + 1 0
Water Play, Pool + 1 0
Water Play, Spray Park + 1 0
Secondary Amenity
2021 2035
Fitness Equipment Cluster + 1 0
Handball Court / Wall Ball 0 + 1
Horseshoe Pit / Bocce Ball
Court 0 + 1
Outdoor Classroom + 1 0
Performance Space 0 0
Teen Outdoor Space + 2 0
Volleyball Court + 1 0
Priority Amenities were highly
ranked in community outreach 9
To maintain the high level-of-service, Belmont will need to add (based on population):

RECOMMENDATIONS SPECTRUM
Existing
Master Plan
Minor
Improvements
Upgraded or
New Amenity
Park
Redesign
Undeveloped
Parks
New Park
Opportunity
Master Plans
recently created
Extensive
community input
Recommendation:

UNDEVELOPED PARK
11 Amenity:

Basketball Court *
Multi-use Athletic Field *
Playground *
Reservable Picnic Area
Tennis Court *
AMENITIES: BENCHMARKED

0.0 AMENITY 1.0

AMENITY

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach

AMENITIES
All abilities bike
playground
Multi-use
lawn
Trees + Shade Natural Environment Multi-use Paths
Multi-use Flex Space All-Abilities Play Dog Park Pump Track Seating
Pickleball
13 Gathering Area
DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: HIDDEN CANYON
OPTION A: NATURE-ORIENTED

UNDEVELOPED PARK

3. Community
Garden

4. Outdoor
Classroom
b. Seating /
Gathering Space

1. ADA Parking : 2. Parking : 6. Play Element
Accessible : Seating : Planting : Shade
d. Picnic Area
c. Play + Outdoor
Experience
Entrance

5. Permanent
Restroom
14 DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: HIDDEN CANYON
OPTION B: DOG PARKLET

UNDEVELOPED PARK

2. Parking 4. Permanent
Restroom 3. Dog Parklet
d. Picnic Area

1. ADA Parking
Accessible : Seating : Planting : Shade
c. Play + Outdoor
Experience
Entrance
15 b. Seating /
Gathering Space QUESTIONS + COMMENTS
16 887
414

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Upcoming Community Input Opportunities
○ Online Comments and Feedback
○ Neighborhood Focus Group Meetings: mid-October
○ Parks & Rec Commission Meeting: November 3
○ City Council Meeting: November 23
PROS Plan: Implementation
○ Prioritization
○ Action Plan
e

NEXT STEPS
17 Comment and
provide feedback at
BelmontPROSplan.com
[email protected]
All Park-Specific Recommendations available on PROS Plan website.

Upcoming Meetings
○ Focus Groups (May)
○ Council of Cities Presentation May 27 at 6 pm
○ June Commission Meeting; Focus on Parks (not Open Space) data, priorities ○ July and August Commission Meetings Combined (third week in July) Previous Meetings:
○
○ April 6, Planning Commission
○ March 29, Belmont Rotary Presentation
○ March 9, Belmont City Council Meeting
○ March 3, PROS Advisory Meeting
○ March 2, BRSSD Superintendent Meeting
○ Feb 3, Park and Rec Commission Meeting
■ Survey live for 4 weeks (end April 30th) another constant contact the week before PROS Groups - Wednesday May 19th 9-10:45am June Commission and Focus Groups findings update/progress, next AC Meeting

DRAFT RECOMMENDATION FEEDBACK
18 NEIGHBORHOOD FOCUS GROUPS
delineate
not have been
ral near open
ark or
location and
focus group
but an area
ity
Neighborhood:

HIDDEN CANYON PARK
Mon Oct. 18, 6:30pm
Meeting will be Virtual
Neighborhood:

RALSTON RANCH PARK
Wed Oct. 20, 6:30pm
Meeting will be Virtual
Register to participate at BelmontPROSplan.com 19
THANK YOU!
20 888
415

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
Focus Group
Ralston Ranch Park
October 20, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
1 Purpose To discuss park-specific DRAFT recommendations for Ralston Ranch Park Introductions + Schedule
Efforts to Date
Park Typologies + Amenities
Ralston Ranch Park DRAFT Recommendations
Next Steps
Discussion (Q+A, comments)
AGENDA
2 GOALS & GUIDING PRINCIPLES
The Master Plan will
● Provide equitable access to resources and activities across the entire city ● Promote inclusion to people of all backgrounds, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic position, or physical/cognitive ability
● Make all users feel welcome and safe
● Offer services and activities across a range of interests, abilities, and ages ● Reflect our commitment to environmental resilience and sustainability ● Respect the beauty and importance of our natural resources ● Advance community health and well-being
● Foster a sense of community and encourage social interaction ● Provide well maintained and actively managed facilities ● Adapt to changing conditions and needs
● Utilize transparent community process to inform decisions 3 PROCESS
Push out 1
4 889
416

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Push out 1 month
BelmontPROSplan.com [email protected]
5 EFFORTS TO DATE
● Existing Conditions
● Community Engagement
○ Online Survey
○ Focus Groups
● Benchmarking + Trends
● Park Typologies
6 CITY-WIDE PARK PROXIMITY
1/8 mile
1/4 mile
1/4 mile
1/4 mile
1/2 mile
Park or JUA School
Trailhead
7 Park Access Radii
Neighborhood Park Tier 1
Neighborhood Park Tier 2
Schools (JUA)
Trailhead
Community Park
School School
School School
EXISTING CONDITION: RALSTON RANCH

UNDEVELOPED PARK
8 890
417

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
COMMUNITY INPUTS: SURVEY
Top 5 Reasons to Visit a park, recreation, or open space 90%
60% 55% 47% 45%
Top 6 Amenities positively-rated To Enhance the Belmont Park Experience 65% 58% 56% 51% 51% 51%

BELMONT RESIDENTS ON PARKS
9 COMMUNITY INPUTS: FOCUS GROUPS

DOG OWNERS
More shade
More seating
More gathering and
social spaces
More waste bins
Water fountain

SENIORS
More seating
More shade
Generally happy with
existing parks
YOUTH
Hang-out space for
youth/teens
Add seating
Larger-sized play
equipment
Community tables
Game areas

INCLUSIVITY
Inclusive play elements
sized larger (not just for
small children)
Sensory and tactile play
Protected spaces, but
with multiple sightlines
and access points

SCHOOL DISTRICT/

YOUTH SPORTS
Incentivize school field
improvements
Continued growth in
sports field demand
Interest in synthetic turf
10 AMENITIES: BELMONT IDEAL
Benchmarked Amenity
2021 2035
All-Abilities Playground + 1 0
Basketball Court (Full) 0 + 2
Basketball Court (Half) 0 + 2
Multi-Use Athletic Field + 1 + 2
Play Element + 3 0
Playground 0 + 2
Reservable Picnic Area,
Small + 2 + 1
Reservable Picnic Area,
Large + 1 0
Tennis Court + 2 + 1
Priority Amenity
2021 2035
Community Garden + 1 0
Dog Park + 1 0
Dog Parklet + 2 0
Pump Track (Bike Park) + 1 0
Skate Park + 1 0
Water Play, Pool + 1 0
Water Play, Spray Park + 1 0
Secondary Amenity
2021 2035
Fitness Equipment Cluster + 1 0
Handball Court / Wall Ball 0 + 1
Horseshoe Pit / Bocce Ball
Court 0 + 1
Outdoor Classroom + 1 0
Performance Space 0 0
Teen Outdoor Space + 2 0
Volleyball Court + 1 0
Priority Amenities were highly
ranked in community outreach 11
To maintain the high level-of-service, Belmont will need to add (based on population):

RECOMMENDATIONS SPECTRUM
12 Existing
Master Plan
Minor
Improvements
Upgraded or
New Amenity
Park
Redesign
Undeveloped
Parks
New Park
Opportunity
Master Plans
recently created
Extensive
community input
Recommendation:

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
Amenity:

Basketball Court *
Multi-use Athletic Field *
Playground *
Reservable Picnic Area
Tennis Court *
AMENITIES: BENCHMARKED

0.0 AMENITY 1.0

AMENITY

0.50 AMENITY
BELMONT Burlingame San Carlos Saratoga California National Population Range
* includes amenities at Belmont’s Schools (JUA) sites
per 1,000 RESIDENTS
No CA or National benchmark
13 PARK TYPOLOGIES
14 Community Park Neighborhood Park
Tier 2
Neighborhood Park
Tier 1
● Generate the most visitors
● High use intensities
● Accessed by foot, bike, or car
● Large capture area (1/2 mile radius)
● Interacting with nature, gathering, and
recreation
● Local and nearby neighborhoods
● Accessed by foot, bike, and car
● Medium capture area (1/4 mile radius)
● Interacting with nature or gathering
● Local neighborhood
● Mainly accessed by foot or by bike
● Small capture area (1/8 mile radius)

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES
A. Natural Environment
B. Seating
C. Play Amenity
D. Picnic Opportunity
E. Multi-purpose Flexible Space
F. Recreation Amenity
G. Off-Street Parking
H. Permanent Restroom
I. Multi-use Athletic Field or Community
Facility

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES
A. Natural Environment
B. Seating
C. Play Amenity
D. Picnic Opportunity
E. Multi-purpose Flexible Space
F. Recreation Amenity

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES
A. Natural Environment
B. Seating
C. Identifiable Amenity

AMENITIES
All abilities bike
playground
Multi-use
lawn
Trees + Shade Natural Environment Gathering Area Multi-use Paths Multi-use Flex Space All-Abilities Play Dog Park Pump Track Seating
Pickleball
15 DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: RALSTON RANCH

UNDEVELOPED PARK
d. Picnic Tables
f. Dog Parklet 1. Walking Paths
b. Seating c. Play Element
e. Gathering Space
Accessible : Trees : Planting
16 892
419

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT Community Outreach
QUESTIONS + COMMENTS
17 Upcoming Community Input Opportunities
○ Online Comments and Feedback
○ Parks & Rec Commission Meeting: November 3
○ City Council Meeting: November 23
PROS Plan: Implementation
○ Prioritization
○ Action Plan
Upcoming Meetings
○ Focus Groups (May)
○ Council of Cities Presentation May 27 at 6 pm
○ June Commission Meeting; Focus on Parks (not Open Space) data, priorities ○ July and August Commission Meetings Combined (third week in July) Previous Meetings:
○
○ April 6, Planning Commission
○ March 29, Belmont Rotary Presentation
○ March 9, Belmont City Council Meeting
○ March 3, PROS Advisory Meeting
○ March 2, BRSSD Superintendent Meeting
○ Feb 3, Park and Rec Commission Meeting
■ Survey live for 4 weeks (end April 30th) another constant contact the week before PROS Groups - Wednesday May 19th 9-10:45am June Commission and Focus Groups findings update/progress, next AC Meeting

NEXT STEPS
18 Comment and
provide feedback at
BelmontPROSplan.com
[email protected]
All Park-Specific Recommendations available on PROS Plan website. e

DRAFT RECOMMENDATION FEEDBACK
19 THANK YOU!
20 893
420

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS
Push out 1
BelmontPROSplan.com [email protected]
4 PROCESS
Push out 1 month
3 Purpose To discuss park-specific DRAFT recommendations & public response to-date Introductions + Schedule
Efforts to Date
Park Typologies + Amenities
Park-Specific DRAFT Recommendations
Park Opportunity Sites DRAFT Recommendations
Next Steps
Discussion
AGENDA
2 Youth Advisory Committee
November 18, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
1 APPENDIX I DRAFT
894
421

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS

ASSESSMENTS
● Existing Conditions
● Community Engagement
○ Online Survey
○ Focus Groups
⎼ Park-specific: Hidden Canyon 10/18, Ralston Ranch 10/20 ● Benchmarking + Trends
● Park Typologies
8 CITY-WIDE PARK CONNECTIVITY

BICYCLISTS
Source: 2016 Comprehensive
Pedestrian and Bicycle Plan
Class I
Class II
Class III
7 CITY-WIDE PARK CONNECTIVITY

PEDESTRIANS
Source: 2016 Comprehensive
Pedestrian and Bicycle Plan
6 CITY-WIDE PARK PROXIMITY
Neighborhood Park Tier 1
Neighborhood Park Tier 2
Schools (JUA)
Trailhead
Community Park
1/8 mile
1/4 mile
1/4 mile
1/4 mile
1/2 mile
Park Access Radii
Park
Trailhead
5 DRAFT Community Outreach
895
422

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS
Amenity:

Basketball Court *
Multi-use Athletic Field *
Playground *
Reservable Picnic Area
Tennis Court *
AMENITIES: BENCHMARKED

0.0 AMENITY 1.0

AMENITY

0.50 AMENITY
BELMONT Burlingame San Carlos Saratoga California National Population Range
* includes amenities at Belmont’s Schools (JUA) sites
per 1,000 RESIDENTS
No CA or National benchmark
11 PARK TYPOLOGIES
Community Park Neighborhood Park
Tier 2
Neighborhood Park
Tier 1
● Generate the most visitors
● High use intensities
● Accessed by foot, bike, or car
● Large capture area (1/2 mile radius)
● Interacting with nature, gathering, and
recreation
● Local and nearby neighborhoods
● Accessed by foot, bike, and car
● Medium capture area (1/4 mile radius)
● Interacting with nature or gathering
● Local neighborhood
● Mainly accessed by foot or by bike
● Small capture area (1/8 mile radius)

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES

1. Natural Environment

2. Seating

3. Play Amenity

4. Picnic Opportunity

5. Multi-purpose Flexible Space

6. Recreation Amenity

7. Off-Street Parking

8. Permanent Restroom

9. Multi-use Athletic Field or Community
Facility

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES

1. Natural Environment

2. Seating

3. Play Amenity

4. Picnic Opportunity

5. Multi-purpose Flexible Space

6. Recreation Amenity

STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES

1. Natural Environment

2. Seating

3. Identifiable Amenity
12 COMMUNITY INPUTS: FOCUS GROUPS

DOG OWNERS
More shade
More seating
More gathering and
social spaces
More waste bins
Water fountain

SENIORS
More seating
More shade
Generally happy with
existing parks
YOUTH
Hang-out space for
youth/teens
Add seating
Larger-sized play
equipment
Community tables
Game areas

INCLUSIVITY
Inclusive play elements
sized larger (not just for
small children)
Sensory and tactile play
Protected spaces, but
with multiple sightlines
and access points

SCHOOL DISTRICT/

YOUTH SPORTS
Incentivize school field
improvements
Continued growth in
sports field demand
Interest in synthetic turf
10 COMMUNITY INPUTS: SURVEY
Top 5 Reasons to Visit a park, recreation, or open space 90%
60% 55% 47% 45%
Top 6 Amenities positively-rated To Enhance the Belmont Park Experience 65% 58% 56% 51% 51% 51%

BELMONT RESIDENTS ON PARKS
9 APPENDIX I DRAFT
896
423

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS

Implement Master
Plan
Parks recently
developed or in
very good
condition
Minor
improvements to
maintain
high-quality
Current park
functioning well
New amenity to
meet identified
needs
Upgrade existing
amenity to meet
identified needs
No
change-in-use
Rethink
accessibility and
park layout
Park Master Plan
process
Existing parks are
undeveloped
Proposed
recommendations
to amenitize site
City-owned property
To fill gaps in park
proximity
Proposed
recommendations to
amenitize site
Barrett Community
Twin Pines
College View
Davey Glen
Patricia Wharton
Semeria
Wakefield
Alexander
Belameda
Belmont Sports
McDougal
O’Donnell
Cipriani
Hallmark
Hastings
Hidden Canyon
Ralston Ranch
Ralston & Old County
Oak Knoll
Alameda de las Pulgas
Belmont Village
Specific Plan
16 AMENITIES: BELMONT IDEAL
Benchmarked Amenity
2021 2035
All-Abilities Playground + 1 0
Basketball Court (Full) 0 + 2
Basketball Court (Half) 0 + 2
Multi-Use Athletic Field + 1 + 2
Play Element + 3 0
Playground 0 + 2
Reservable Picnic Area,
Small + 2 + 1
Reservable Picnic Area,
Large + 1 0
Tennis Court + 2 + 1
Priority Amenity
2021 2035
Community Garden + 1 0
Dog Park + 1 0
Dog Parklet + 2 0
Pump Track (Bike Park) + 1 0
Skate Park + 1 0
Water Play, Pool + 1 0
Water Play, Spray Park + 1 0
Secondary Amenity
2021 2035
Fitness Equipment Cluster + 1 0
Handball Court / Wall Ball 0 + 1
Horseshoe Pit / Bocce Ball
Court 0 + 1
Outdoor Classroom + 1 0
Performance Space 0 0
Teen Outdoor Space + 2 0
Volleyball Court + 1 0
Priority Amenities were highly ranked in community outreach 15

AMENITIES
Nature Gathering Nature Gathering Recreation
Amenity
Trees /
shade
relax gather Multi-use
path
All abilities dog bike
playground
Multi-use
lawn
Trees + Shade Natural Environment Gathering Area Multi-use Paths Multi-use Flex Space All-Abilities Play Dog Park Pump Track Seating
Nature + Play
+ Gathering
Play Amenity Recreation
Amenity
Recreation +
Play Amenity
??? Amenity
Pickleball
14 STANDARD BASELINE AMENITIES

NEIGHBORHOOD PARK
Tier 1
a.

Natural
Environment
f.

Recreation
Amenity
g.

Off-Street
Parking
i.

Athletic
Field OR
Community
Facility

NEIGHBORHOOD PARK
Tier 2

COMMUNITY PARK
e.

Multi-Use
Flex Space
b.

Seating
d.

Picnic
Opportunity
h.

Permanent
Restroom
c.

Identifiable
(Play)
Amenity
13 DRAFT Community Outreach
897
424

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: BELMONT SPORTS

UPGRADED/NEW AMENITY

6. Synthetic
Athletic Fields

3. Fitness
Equipment 2. Pump Track

4. Picnic Tables 5. Planting Areas

1. Gathering
Space
Seating
19 DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: O’DONNELL

UPGRADED/NEW AMENITY

3. Spray Element

2. BBQs 1. Reservable
Picnic Area
Planting : High-Quality Landscape
20 DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: BELAMEDA

UPGRADED/NEW AMENITY

1. Multi-use Path

3. Learn-to-Ride
Loop
f. Fitness
Equipment

2. Teen Outdoor
Space
4 + 5. Planting
Areas
Seating : Planting : High-Quality Landscape
18 RECOMMENDATIONS: BARRETT COMMUNITY

EXISTING MASTER PLAN

10. Trees + Shade

3. Pool 4. Splash Park

7. Synthetic
Athletic Field

2. Dog Parklet

6. Community
Center

1. Parking : 5. Playground : 8. Multi-use Sports Court : 9. Picnic Area 17 APPENDIX I DRAFT
898
425

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: RALSTON RANCH

UNDEVELOPED PARK
d. Picnic Tables
f. Dog Parklet 1. Walking Paths
b. Seating c. Play Element
e. Gathering Space
Accessible : Trees : Planting
24 PUBLIC RESPONSE: HIDDEN CANYON ○ Poor maintenance condition noted currently, and more of a concern if increased amenities at site
○ Concerned about vehicular access (traffic volume and speed, parking) ○ Many participants voiced support to keep the space natural and quiet ○ Phased implementation supported in order to manage traffic concerns ○ Picnic tables, seating, and child outdoor play amenity generally supported 23 VIRTUAL FOCUS GROUP MONDAY 10/18
DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: HIDDEN CANYON
OPTION B: DOG PARKLET

UNDEVELOPED PARK

2. Parking 4. Permanent
Restroom 3. Dog Park
d. Picnic Area b. Gathering Space
+ Seating

1. ADA Parking : Accessible : Seating : Planting : Shade c. Play + Outdoor
Experience
Entrance
22 DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS: HIDDEN CANYON
OPTION A: NATURE-ORIENTED

UNDEVELOPED PARK

3. Community
Garden

4. Outdoor
Classroom
b. Seating /
Gathering Space

1. ADA Parking : 2. Parking : Accessible : Seating : Planting : Shade d. Picnic Area
c. Play + Outdoor
Experience
Entrance

4. Permanent
Restroom
21 DRAFT Community Outreach
899
426

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS
DRAFT OPPORTUNITY: RALSTON & OLD COUNTY

INTERIM PLACEMAKING OPPORTUNITY

1. Dog Parklet 2. Placemaking
a. Gateway
planting b. Seating c. Skate Park Skate Park

3. Public Art
Accessible : Planting
27 DRAFT OPPORTUNITY: OAK KNOLL

NEW PARK OPPORTUNITY
b. Benches c. Play Element
Accessible : Planting
28 PARK OPPORTUNITY SITES
Ralston Ave +
Old County Rd
+ Belmont Village
Specific Plan
Oak Knoll
Alameda de las
Pulgas
Park Proximity Map
26 PUBLIC RESPONSE: RALSTON RANCH
25 VIRTUAL FOCUS GROUP WEDNESDAY 10/20
○ Walking paths and seating supported by multiple participants ○ Neighborhood residents generally against a dog-oriented amenity ○ Maintain and increase trees
○ Respect natural environment in any proposed changes
○ Traffic, specifically exiting Ralston Ranch Rd, considered negative to residents ○ Child play element supported

APPENDIX I DRAFT
900
427

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

FOCUS GROUPS
Comment and
provide feedback at
BelmontPROSplan.com
[email protected]
All Park-Specific Recommendations available on PROS Plan website.

Upcoming Meetings
○ Focus Groups (May)
○ Council of Cities Presentation May 27 at 6 pm
○ June Commission Meeting; Focus on Parks (not Open Space) data, priorities ○ July and August Commission Meetings Combined (third week in July) Previous Meetings:
○ April 6, Planning Commission
○ March 29, Belmont Rotary Presentation
○ March 9, Belmont City Council Meeting
○ March 3, PROS Advisory Meeting
○ March 2, BRSSD Superintendent Meeting
○ Feb 3, Park and Rec Commission Meeting
■ Survey live for 4 weeks (end April 30th) another constant contact the week before PROS Groups - Wednesday May 19th 9-10:45am June Commission and Focus Groups findings update/progress, next AC Meeting

DRAFT RECOMMENDATION FEEDBACK
32 Upcoming Community Input Opportunities
○ Online Comments and Feedback
○ City Council Meeting: November 23
PROS Plan: Implementation
○ Prioritization
○ Action Plan
e

NEXT STEPS
31 PUBLIC RESPONSE: RECOMMENDATIONS
30 PUBLIC COMMENTS RECEIVED OCTOBER 2021
○ Multiple comments in support of Pump Track (Bike Park) at Belmont Sports Complex (requests to include and exclude bike amenity at Hidden Canyon) ○ Positive response to proposed park at Alameda de las Pulgas (Opportunity Site) ○ Seating and Permanent Restroom for Hidden Canyon, add bike repair station ○ Request for more Youth- and Teen-oriented spaces
○ Splash park (water play) at O’Donnell not encouraged
○ Yes to Bocce ball (multiple locations)
○ Request for dog-oriented amenities, limited support for proposed sites ○ Maintain natural environs on undeveloped parks
○ Neighbors support park creation at summit of Oak Knoll Drive DRAFT OPPORTUNITY: ALAMEDA DE LAS PULGAS

NEW PARK OPPORTUNITY
b. Benches c. Play Element

1. Walking Paths
Accessible : Planting
29 DRAFT Community Outreach
901
428

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

FOCUS GROUPS
THANK YOU!
35 BelmontPROSplan.com
[email protected]
36 COMMENTS
from General Public
20 minutes allotted for comments on agenda items
Speaker time will be limited based on number of persons wishing to comment Questions will not be answered live in this meeting
Visit BelmontPROSplan.com or
email [email protected]
to comment and provide feedback
34 QUESTIONS + COMMENTS
from YAC
33 APPENDIX I DRAFT
902
411

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Advisory Committee Meeting
March 4, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE

MASTER PLAN
- CASEYS NOTES - DONT PRINT
- Should be built on data
- Skate parks
- Option to remove items from parks
- Could ask if we need dedicated trails for each
- Do people think there is conflict?
- Additional trees?
- Quantitative approach that then becomes more qualitative Introduction of Advisory Committee Members
Introduction to Project
Project Scope
Goals & Guiding Principles
Role of Advisory committee
Outreach Plan
Draft Survey
Open for Public Comment
Future Meeting Dates
AGENDA BelmontPROSPlan.com WELCOME
[email protected]
DRAFT Community Outreach
903
412

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Gates + Associates PROS Committee
Avery Lyford
Karl Mittelstadt
Craig Michaels
Brigitte Shearer
Daniel Ourtiague
Michael Moran
Peter Meier
Casey Case
Linda Gates
Kelley Lotosky
Melonie O’Sullivan

INTRODUCTIONS
Advisory Committee
Abby Sanders
Karen Haas-Foletta
Bob Stahl
Nelson Corteway
David Braunstein
Scott Sisemore
Susan Wright
Donna Sanchez
Dean Wilson
Lynn Bell
Sergio Raddaverro
Dan Deguara
Rui Bao
Set the framework for decision makers in the
planning, maintenance, development, and or
rehabilitation of Belmont’s Parks and open space
system and related recreational programming for a 15
year horizon.

PURPOSE

GOALS & GUIDING PRINCIPLES
Develop a Master Plan that:
○ Provide equitable access to resources and activities across the entire city ○ Promote inclusion to people of all backgrounds, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic position or physical/cognitive ability ○ Offer services and activities across a range of interests, abilities, and ages ○ Reflect our commitment to environmental resilience and sustainability ○ Respect the beauty and importance of our natural resources ○ Advances community health and well-being
○ Foster a sense of community and encourage social interaction ○ Are well maintained and actively managed over time
○ Can adapt to changing conditions and needs
○ Utilize transparent community process to inform decisions

PROCESS

APPENDIX I DRAFT
904
413

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Benchmarking of 3 comparable
Cities
○ San Carlos
○ Saratoga
○ Burlingame
City Staff Park Usage Study
○ Open Space – Waterdog
○ Community Parks – McDougal
Park & Athletic Fields, Belameda
Park
○ Neighborhood Parks – Cipriani,
Alexander Park, Hallmark Park
EFFORTS TO DATE: BENCHMARKING EFFORTS TO DATE: EXISTING SITE

ASSESSMENT
EFFORTS TO DATE: OUTREACH
Outreach to date:
- Brand (Logo/Tagline)
- Project Website
- Identify Community Enhancers
- Selected Our Channels
- Developed Our Questions for Round
#1 Survey
EFFORTS TO DATE: OUTREACH EVENTS
- Presentation at BRSSD
Superintendent Meeting March 2, 2021
- The Belmont Park and Recreation
Commission Meeting February 3, 2021
- The Belmont Park and Recreation
Commission Presentation February 3,
2021
DRAFT Community Outreach
905
414

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Round #1 Round #2 Round #3
Where are we now?
What do we want?
Identify Key Issues
Input on unmet needs
How can we meet our
needs?
Deeper dive on trends
from round #1
Park Recommendations
What are our priorities?
Master Plan
recommendations and
criteria for prioritization

OUTREACH STRATEGY COMMUNITY OUTREACH
- Advisory Committee Meetings (4 Total)
- Community-Wide Survey
- Stakeholder Focus Group Meetings (6 Total) - User Group or Topic (Open Space, Teens, etc., …)
- Neighborhood Meetings (6 Total)
- Community Pop Up Events (3 Total)
- Community Workshops (2 Total)
- Parks and Recreation Committee Presentation (4 Total) - Planning Commission Meeting
- City Council Presentation (3 Total)

ADVISORY COMMITTEE
● Role:
○ Insights: represent a diverse perspective of interests and ideas ○ Outreach: gather feedback and serve as community liaison to Master Plan team ○ Advise: review and provide input on the Master Plan process

DRAFT SURVEY
● General Information Requested:
○ Who are you? Age and Neighborhood
○ Frequency of park, open space and outdoor recreation program use ○ Opinion on park, open space and outdoor recreation program spaces visited
○ Types of improvements desired for:
■ Parks
■ Open Spaces
■ Outdoor Recreation Programs

APPENDIX I DRAFT
906
415

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS

NEXT STEPS
- PROS Advisory Committee
March 4th, 2021 7 Pm
- PROS Plan Presentation to City
Council March 9, 2021
- Planning Commission Presentation
April 6, 2021
DRAFT Community Outreach
907
416

APPENDIX I
PARKS | RECREATION | OPEN SPACE MASTER PLAN APPENDICES DRAFT | Final February 2024

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS
Belmont PROS Plan Advisory Committee Meeting
May 13, 2021

PARKS, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE
MASTER PLAN Introductions
Survey Results Overview
Focus Groups
Questions and Comments from Advisory Committee
Comments from General Public
Next Steps
AGENDA

INTRODUCTIONS
Gates + Associates PROS Committee
Brigitte Shearer
Daniel Ourtiague
Michael Moran
Casey Case
Linda Gates
Kelley Lotosky
Melonie O’Sullivan
Grant Hudson
Advisory Committee
Karen Haas-Foletta
Bob Stahl
Nelson Corteway
David Braunstein
Scott Sisemore
Susan Wright
Dean Wilson
Lynn Bell
Sergio Raddaverro
Dan Deguara/Rui Bao
Karl Mittelstadt
Ulla Foehr
Austin Lee
Caroline Pyrz
Eli Latimerlo
Abby Sanders

ADVISORY COMMITTEE
● Role:
○ Insights: represent a diverse perspective of interests and ideas ○ Outreach: gather feedback and serve as community liaison to Master Plan team
○ Advise: review and provide input on the Master Plan process

APPENDIX I DRAFT
908
417

APPENDIX I
DRAFT | Final February 2024 CITY OF BELMONT | LET’S BUILD OUR BACKYARD

ADVISORY COMMITTEE PRESENTATIONS

SURVEY DEMOGRAPHICS
● Barrett Community Center
● Waterdog Open Space
● Cipriani park
● Twin Pines Park
● Ralston Middle School
● Hallmark Park
● Fox School Field
● Nesbit School Field
● Central School Field
● Hidden Canyon Park

RESIDENTS
Ranked worst to best
- Only show
unsatisfactory ranking
- Separately show
excellent - two distinct
data pieces
unsatisfactory
Legibility of
names
Important to
demonstrate that
not that diff if
non-belmont are
removed
Sep out OS info
*Resident only data
Question #12,13
munity Center
pen Space

Park
dle School
rk
Field
ol Field
ool Field
yon Park
to best
w
ctory ranking
ly show
t - two distinct
es
unsatisfactory
Legibility of park
names
Important to
demonstrate that data
not that diff if
non-belmont are
removed
Sep out OS info
Can we tease ap
“othr”?
- Make the “
category n
- Group tog
similarly c
the non-B
groups
- Resi
- non-
- People in
use OS an
outside of
and may b
those who
to Belmon
amenities
Question #11
DRAFT Community Outreach
909
418

Belmont City CouncilMarch 12, 2024

Belmont City Council
March 12, 2024