767
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 3 PmNG & TRAFFIC
CONT'D Juan Martinez, 10246 San Jose Avenue thanked City Council for accepting their petition and helping the residents.
Robert Avila, 10309 San Jose Avenue thanked City Council for accepting their petition and helping the residents.
Mario Dominguez, Jr., stated he did not see any presentations.
Having no one else come forward, Mayor Avalos closed the audience portion,
Vice Mayor Hurtado motioned to move forward and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
Council Member Barron stated living in a preferential parking district and recommends it to everyone.
Council Member Davila, Council Member Rios and Mayor Avalos commend the residents on San Jose for uniting and requesting preferential parking.
ROLL CALL: Mayor Avalos, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes.
Mayor Avalos thanked Public Works Department for having this procedure.
City Attorney Salinas stated living at 10222 San Jose Avenue from 1967- 1985.
COMMENTS FROM THE
AUDIENCE-NON-AGENDA
ITEMS Reza Neamati, President of RN Development stated being in a financial difficulty due to the actions of Griffin Construction management team and the city management team since February 2022.
Danielle of RN Development stated the city was forced to shut down the Urban Orchard Project. The project is eighty percent done. She also mentioned this is causing financial difficulty.
Eddie Barker of RN Development stated this was to make the Council aware of the situation. RN Development is asking for the Council's help.
George Duarte, owner, and founder of Roocket Fitness. They have been open for 10 years in different cities. He stated two years ago he has had issues with the city due to parking.
768
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 CO(!IMENTS FROM THE
AUDIENCE - NON-AGENDA
ITEMS CONT'D Lizette Ruiz, Kauffinan Avenue spoke on pet and animal welfare. She has volunteered as part of the trap-neuter-returii program coordinated by FixNation in Sun Valley. She is a cofounder of a local group called SELLA Trap-Neuter-Return feral cats in the Southeast LA area. Ms. Ruiz is asking Council to bring back programs. She la'iows there used to be a mobile spay clinic at the park.
Employee of RN Development. He oversees transportation and reiterates financial difficulty.
Kevin, employee of RN Development. He is a carpenter and reiterates financial difficulty.
Milagros Diaz, 10001 Frontage Road, stated that many of the seniors at Thunderbird Villa were excited about the Urban Orchard Project. Ms.
Diaz stated the seniors are now disappointed.
Ari'nando Velasquez, Independence Avenue hopes this project gets resolved. Mr. Velasquez thanked the city for having the Kiwanis Club at the Centeru'iial celebration. He stated the club will be participating in the Homeless Count tomorrow. He invited everyone to the monthly Kiwanis cleanup on February 1 8'h at the Willow Elementary School. They are launching two bingo nights for the senior citizens on February 3rdand February 23rd. A major event will be held at the South Gate auditorium on February 4'h for all Kiwanis Clubs to elect district and state leaders.
Frank Rivera, 9700 block of McNerney Avenue congratulated the residents on San Jose for establishing their preferential parking. Mr.
Rivera reminded the city of the 2019 Parking Study. Mr. Rivera is requesting Council agendize an update report.
Mario Dominguez, Jr., stated that if the city is not going to implement the parking study, then forget about it. Mr. Dominguez asked if the NR Development has to do with Item 8. He asked the city to finish the Urban Orchid Project.
Jocelyn Panduro, Student Body Vice President at South Gate High School is requesting a donation of $2,000 for their All Student Body (ASB) class to purchase custom jerseys to wear at events to represent their ASB and school.
Thomas Buckley stated that a resident that resides in Elizabeth and Southern is still waiting for an update on tlie street light issues. Another complaint is about UWS and prefers Waste Management. Mr. Buckley stated that on January 21s' was a murder that happened in bright daylight
769
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023
COMMENTS FROM THE
AUDIENCE - NON-AGF.NDA
ITEMS CONT'D on State and Illinois. Mr. Buckley thanked South Gate PD and Sheriff's for investigating and hopes the suspect or suspects will be captured.
Cyndi Esquivel thanked the city and coini'nittee that oversaw putting together the Centennial celebration.
Jacqueline attended last month's Council Meeting and is asking for status if the city has infon'ned the community of vehicle thefts.
RF.PORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS Chris Jeffers, City Manager stated for the student that called in for the ASB donation. He is asking the student to call the Chief and make an application to the Youth Coinmission for funding. His response to Mr.
Rivera regarding the 2019 Park Study. The item was not presented to the Council until 2021. There were over 180 recoi'nmendations with different criteria to implement.
Arturo Cervantes, Director of Public Works stated that there are several lighting outages impacting the city. He mentioned circuit 37 as an example is a Southern California Edison issue.
Mr. Jeffers to Ms. Ruiz staff will look at the mobile clinic and provide Council with an update on that process. To Mr. Duarte that was one of the areas that Council took affirmative action to reduce parking requirements.
Mr. Jeffers stated that the Council is aware the county issued a stop notice on the Orchard Urban Project until the city obtains a notice called a closure permit. It is impacting the contractor and the city. The Council will be having a special meeting in a week or two for a thorough report on this project. Mr. Jeffers told everyone that the project will get done.
Chief Arakawa stated that the investigation is ongoing. The police department is working with the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department on the incident that happened on January 21s'.
Arturo Cervantes, Director of Public Works aru'iounced that the public works department is getting ready to start the fire hydrant flushing maintenance program. It begins on January 29" and it will take four months to complete.
Tina Fierro, Deputy Director of Parks & Recreation gave a recap on the Centeru'iial event.
Meredith Elguira, Director of Coinmunity Development stated that the rental assistance program started today. A cornrnunity meeting was held with regards to the Draft EIR for the Patata Project.
770
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D Yodit Glaze, City Clerk thanked all the city employees, volunteers, vendors, and performers that were present at Saturday's event.
Jose De La Paz, City Treasurer stated the coini'nunity would like to know the city's stand on streets vendors. The second item is a timeline on the Tweedy Boulevard resurfacing and when it will occur. The third item is for the Council to place an item on the agenda adding cameras to our chambers for future Council meetings. Lastly, he will attend the bingo and the next clean-up.
Kris Ryan, Director of Administrative Services provided infomiation to the public and residents on the UWS and how they are going to start housing in city hall to assist customers with any issues.
Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Resources enjoyed the Centennial event. Mr. Hamilton stated new jobs flyers are posted regularly on the city's website.
Chief of Arakawa reported ten (10) police explorers participated at the 25'h Annual Chandler, Arizona tactical competition. He also stated the police department are in the infantile stages of planning the next citizen academy which will take place in Marcli.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager extended his gratitude to the employees and departments that participated in the Centennial event. Also, to the corni'nittee that helped organize the event. Mr. Jeffers stated it will be a full year of activities and ending with the reburying of the time capsule next January. The staff is diligently working to present the items that were inside the time capsule to the public. Mr. Jeffers stated Giselle is currently working on the City's E-Newsletter for residents to sign up and get the latest news.
Mr. Jeffers asked Mr. Cervantes if he would speak on the Tweedy Mile resurfacing.
Mr. Cervantes stated that the schedule is currently under design. It will probably be completed in the next four or five months. The project is federally funded. The outreach is forthcoming in the next month or so.
Mr. Jeffers mentioned that street vendors are allowed in certain areas because state law requires it under certain conditions.
Council Member Davila stated that it has been an honor being on Council during the Centennial. Everyone that attended the event had a great time.
She thanked the coinmittee, employees, vendors, agencies, and clubs/organizations for participating. Virginia Johnson will be missed.
771
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023
REPORTS AND COMMF,NTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D Council Member Barron stated the Centeru'iial was a great event. He thanked the cominittee and Parks Department for their hard work. He also thanked the clubs/organizations for their participation.
Council Member Barron attended the ICA meeting on January 12'h and met Mrs. Davenport CEO of Los Angeles County. She provided infonnation about what the county is trying to do to aid the homeless.
Council Member Barron stated that he has the South Gate Police Departments app on his phone and asked Chief Arakawa to speak on it.
Chief Arakawa encourages everyone to be active and be a neighborhood watch captain. We can have infon'nation on the social media pages and on the app.
Mr. Jeffers mentioned the Chief will be presenting the annual crime statistics.
Council Member Barron understands the police department must be careful what infon'nation is available on the app because criminals can have that app too.
Council Member Rios stated the Centennial was a great event. He thanked the committee and everyone that participated. He is looking forward to the other activities during the year.
Council Member Rios assured NR Development and the others that were impacted that we care deeply about this project, and we want to resolve it.
Council Member Rios mentioned the spring semester is starting at ELAC.
Vice Mayor Hurtado doesn't understand when the mass shooting will be under control. He reached out to the congresswoman's staff asking for help regarding street light issues. He also reached out to State Senator Lena Gonzalez and Assembly Member Anthony Rendon.
Vice Mayor Hurtado stated the Centennial was a great event.
Mayor Avalos thanked the departments and community for celebrating the city's Centennial. She thanked her colleagues for giving her the opportunity to be the mayor for the 100"I celebration.
Mayor Avalos attended the LA Sanitation meeting and the new directors in March to enlighten us as to what exactly is that they do. She also attended the HUB Cities meeting and they reviewed their annual budget.
772
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D Mayor Avalos stated that it is heartbreaking to hear of all the mass shootings.
CONSENTCALENDAR Agenda Items 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, and 15 were approved by motion of Mayor Avalos and seconded by Council Member Rios.
ROLL CALL: Mayor Avalos, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes (recused for Items 5 and 8); Council Member Barron, yes, Council Member Davila, yes, Council Member Rios, yes.
4 CITY COUNCIL
APPOINTMENTS The City Council unanimously approved items A, B & C during the Consent Calendar:
a, Ratified the nomination by City Council Member Joshua Barron of Ms. Daisy Prieto to the Planning Coinmission; and
b. Ratified the request by Mayor Avalos to unappoint Ms. Liz Ruiz of the Parks & Recreation Commission and accept the nomination of City Council Member Joshua Barron of Ms. Liz Ruiz to the Parks & Recreation Coini'nission; and
c. Ratified the nomination by Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado of Ms. Andrea Martinez to the Citizens Advisory Committee.
5 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council approved items A, B, C & D during the Consent Calendar:
a. Addendum No. 1 to Resolution 2021-66-CC relating to the Transfer Agreement No. 2021RPLLARO5 between the City and the Los Angeles County Flood Control District for the Safe, Clean Water Program - Regional Fund Program ("Transfer Agreement") to receive the Fiscal Year 2022/23 funding allocation of $2.2 Million awarded for the Urban Orchard Project;
b. Appropriated the $2.2 Million in Measure W Funds to be transferred to the Urban Orchard Project and authorizing the Director of Administrative Services to make any budget adjustments needed to carry out this recommended action;
c. Authorized the Mayor to sign Addendum No. 1; and
d. Authorized the City Manager to execute and submit all other documents pertaining to Addendum No. 1.
773
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 6 FINANCIAL SERVICES Tlie City Council unanimously approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Amendment No. 2 to Contract No. 2022-52-CC witli MV Cheng & Associates through June 30, 2023, for temporary professional staffing services in an amount not-to-exceed $76,800; and
b. Authorized tlie Mayor to execute Amendment No. 2 in a fonn acceptable to the City Attorney.
7 FINANCIAL MGMT The City Council unanimously approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Ai'nendmentNo.2toContractNo.3218,ProfessionalServices Agreement with Bank of the West, extending the banking services contract for an additional one (1) year through December 31, 2023, and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 2 in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
8 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Amendment No. 6 to Contract No. 3352 with The Trust for Public Land to fund additional engineering services required to comply with Los Angeles County Department of Health requirements and to extend the contract term to December 31, 2023 for the Urban Orchard Project, City Project No. 539-PRK, in an amount not to exceed $250,000; b. Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 6 in a form acceptable to the City Attoi'ney.
9 STREETS/SmEWALKS/
LAND8CAPING
The City Council unanimously approved items A, B & C during the Consent Calendar:
a. Approved an Agreement (Contract No. 2023-04-CC) with Z&K Consultants, Inc., for construction management and inspection services for the East Alameda Street Sidewalk Improvements Project, City Project No. 660-ST, in an amount not-to-exceed $110,442; b. Appropriated$l30,442inMeasureRFundstoAccountNo.311-790- 31-9584 to fund construction management and inspection services inclusive of a $20,000 contingency; and
774
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 9 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING CONT'D c. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
10 STRF,ETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council unanimously approved items A, B, C, D & E during the Consent Calendar:
a. Agreement (Contract No. 2023-05-CC) with Sequel Contractors, Inc., to construct the East Alameda Street Sidewalk Improvements Project, City Project No. 660-ST ("Agreement"), in an amount not-to-exceed $903,361, inclusive of the $493,157 Base Bid and $410,204 Additive Alternative Bid;
b. Authorized the City Manager to approve contract change orders up to a cumulative amount of $100,000 to avoid delaying construction and payment of invoices involving change order work;
c. Appropriated $544,894 in Measure R Funds to fully fund the East Alameda Street Sidewalk Improvements Project, City Project No. 660- ST;
d. Approved the Notice of Exemption under Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 15301 of the California Environi'nental Quality Act ("CEQA") for the construction of the East Alameda Street Sidewalk Improvements Project, City Project No. 660-ST and directing the City Clerk to file it with the Los Angeles County Registrar Recorder's Office; and
e. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
PARKING & TRAFFIC The City Council unanimously approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Agreement (Contract No. 2023-06-CC) with KOA Corporation ("Agreement") for construction monitoring and inspection services necessary to oversee traffic signal improvements taking place at the intersection of Atlantic Avenue with Chakemco Avenue and Wright Road, in an amount not-to-exceed $70,200; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
775
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 LAW ENFORCEMENT The City Council unanimously approved items A, B, C, D & E during the Consent Calendar:
a. Agreement (Contract No. 2023-07-CC) with ENL Building Services, Inc. ("Agreement"), for the construction of South Gate Police Department Detective's Bureau Remodel Project, City Project No. 642-GEN ("Project"), in the amount not-to-exceed $185,045; b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney;
c. Purchase order with Western Office to purchase office furniture for the project through the OMNIA Partners cooperative purchase program, for an amount not to exceed $113,390;
d. Authorized the City Manager to execute the documents necessary to purchase the furniture in a fon'n acceptable to the City Attorney; and e. The Notice of Exemption under Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 15301 of the California Envirom'nental Quality Act ("CEQA") for the construction of the South Gate Police Department Detective's Bureau Remodel Project, City Project No. 642-GEN and directing the City Clerk to file it with the Los Angeles County Recorder's Office.
PARKS The City Council unanimously approved items A, B, C & D during the Consent Calendar:
a. Approving Contract Change Order No. l to Contract No. 2022-84-CC with NR Development, Inc., to supplant the construction of decomposed granite with rubber surfacing for the perimeter pathway on the Hollydale Coinmunity Park, City Project No. 607-PRK, in a net amount of $55,365.12;
b. Authorizing the Assistant City Manager/Public Works Director to execute Change Order No. I ;
c. Authorizing the City Manager to approve contract change orders up to a cumulative amount of $400,000 to avoid delaying construction and payment of invoices involving change order work; and
d. Authorizing the City Manager to approve pre-payments of construction progress payments for the construction contract to meet compliance with state legislation that requires payments within 30 days.
776
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 14 DEEDS & EASEMENTS The City Council unanimously approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Accepted a Grant Deed from GSI South Gate Owner, LLC., to secure right-of-way for street puiposes as part of the development located 9830 Atlantic Avenue, at no cost to the City; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Certificate of Acceptance in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
15 MINUTES The City Council unanimously approved items A, B, C, D & E during the Consent Calendar:
a. The Regular Meeting minutes of October 11, 2022;
b. The Special and Regular Meeting minutes of October 25, 2022; c. The Special Meeting Closed Session minutes of November 10, 2022; d. TheSpecialMeetingminutesofNovemberl0,2022;and
e. The Special Meeting minutes of November 29, 2022.
16 PROCLAMATIONS/
MEMOIIIAMS The City Council considered whether the City should provide a special recognition in honoring Ms. Virginia Johnson for her 20-years of civic engagement of through her attendance at City Council meetings and public comment participation during those meetings.
Mayor Avalos motioned to approve a plaque to be placed on the bench inside the Council Chambers and seconded by Council Member Davila.
ROLL CALL: Mayor Avalos, yes; Vice Mayor Huitado, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes.
17 FmANClAL AUDITS The City Council unanimously received and filed the City of South Gate Fiscal Year ended June 30, 2022, annual audit, and the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report ("ACFR"). No forinal council action is required by motion of Council Member Davila and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
ROLL CALL: Mayor Avalos, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes.
777
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JANUARY 24, 2023 gRECESS Prior to the conclusion of item 17, the City Council recessed for five (5) minutes.
WARRANTS The City Council unanimously approved the Warrant Register for January 24, 2023, by Council Member Davila and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
Total ofChecks: $2,204,744.22
Less:Voids $ (8,075.50)
Less: Employee Payroll Deductions $ (345,865.23)
GrandTotal: $1,850,803.49
Cancellations: 99458, 99672
ROLL CALL: Mayor Avalos, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes.
ADJOURNMF,NT Mayor Avalos unanimously adjourned the meeting in memory of Adjournment in memory of Virginia Johnson, Citizens Advisory Cornrnittee member and Steve Masushige, son of Sylvia Masushige, longtime South Gate residents, Catherine Anne McHugh, mother of South Gate employee Deborah McEvilly, eleven (11) individuals from Monterey Park, seven (7) individuals from Half Moon Bay, Oakland & our city limits at 10:06 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Davila.
PASSED and APPROVED this "1 day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
778
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 28, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor called a Regular City COunCil Meeting tO order at 6:52 p.m.
INVOCATION PastorAnthony Kidd, Coinrnunity of Faith Bible Church
PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE Fabiola Salceda, Housing Specialist
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina
Mayor Avalos requested that slie be allowed to attend the City Council Meeting via zoom because she is sick. The request was approved by Motion of Vice Mayor Hurtado and seconded by Council Member Davila.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA At this time, there being no objections, MayorAvalos stated that item 13 would be considered out of its regular agenda order.
13 HEALTH SERVICES The City Council continued this item to the March 14, 2023 City Council Meeting by motion of Mayor Avalos and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes. a. Approving the Professional Services Agreement with AltaMed for a three-year Behavior Health Pilot Program at three South Gate Middle Schools not to exceed $460,718;
b. Reallocating $460,718 of Ai'nerican Rescue Plan Act funds set aside for possible Pocket Parks projects to the Mental Health Services account; and
C. Authorizing the Mayor to execute the agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
15 779
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023
EXCUSED FROM
MEETING Mayor Avalos was excused from participating for the remainder of the City Council meeting and departed from the Council Chambers.
COMMENTS FROM THE
AUDIENCE- NON-AGENDA
ITEMS A prospective business owner (9722 San Antonio Avenue) requested that the City Council place an item on agenda to review the conditions of the CUP approval process.
Mr. Dominguez commented on the 45-minute time limit for the non-agenda items.
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS Meredith Elguira, Director of Cominunity Development reported that the first CAC Meeting of the year will be Wednesday and Coffee with Code will also be on Wednesday at Starbucks at Long Beach Boulevard. The Community Development Department did apply for the Cal Home Grant for 5 million dollars to be used to fund twenty-three (23) affordable housing units for sale.
The Corni'nunity Development Department will be hosting a Planning Study session to help the new Plai'ining Commissioners, and everyone is welcome to attend. Ms. Elguira infon'ned Council that staff may be bringing back the Housing Element for adoption.
Steve Costley, Interim Director of Parks and Recreation reported on the upcoming Azalea Festival.
Art Cervantes, Director of Public Works announced that there will be several construction projects starting throughout the city and more infori'nation posted on the City's webpage.
Kris Ryan, Director of Administrative Services provided an update on the budget process.
Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Resources provided an ripdate on the open positions for the city.
Darren Arakawa, Chief of Police attended the first LA County fentanyl task force meeting and reported on the enforcement of the drug dealers.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager asked if the City Council could call their CAC Coinmissioners to remind them of the importance of attending the meetings.
Mr. Jeffers attended a meeting hosted by Supervisor Hahn's Office regarding transportation needs.
Yodit Glaze, City Clerk reported that the City Clerk's Office continues to process passports Monday - Thursday from 9:00 a.m. - 12 noon by appointment only.
16 780
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D Jose De La Paz, City Treasurer complimented the Public Works Department on the clean up work that they did a'fter the ston'n.
Council Member Davila also thanked the Public Works Department for their work during the storm.
Council Member Barron attended the neighborhood watch meeting at the East Los Angeles Coinrnunity College center. Mr. Barron thanked Sean Palos for advocating for our corninunity with the program. He continued by congratulating South Gate High School's Girls Soccer team for their win in the division two championships along witli the Aztec Girls Cheerleaders for their success at Jamz Tournament.
Council Member Rios echoed Council Member Barron compliments on the youth's Cheerleading teams and their involvement in the coi'nu'nunity. Mr. Rios took the time to thank Chris Jeffers for their infonnative delivery of the midyear budget. He also noted that Council Member Davila and he will be attending "Read Across Aanerica" event at Willow Elementary School. Council Member Rios hinted at the possibility of creating a plan for redevelopment on the west side of the city by East Los Angeles Community College campus to reduce traffic. He also mentioned how the state's Governor will be limiting the emergencies for Covid-19.
Vice Mayor Huitado congratulated the South Gate High School's Boys Basketball team and Legacy High School's Softball Team for their accomplishinents. He continued by showing gratitude for Steve Costley and the Park's staff for hosting an incredible swim meet along with the upkeep of the park. He encouraged our community to try out the Shop local gift card program and noted the importance of helping our local businesses. He took the time to also thank the Public Works Department for their work during the storm. Mr. Hurtado brought to council's attention the change of time for CAC meetings to meet the needs of residents and council members.
CONSENT CALENDAR Agenda Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 were approved by motion of Council Member Davila and seconded by Council Member Rios.
ROLL CALL: Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes (recused for Items 1 and 7); Council Member Davila, yes, Council Member Rios, yes, Council Member Barron, yes; Mayor Avalos, excused.
l
STREETS/SmEWALKS/
LANDSCAPmG The City Council made a finding and adopted Resolution No. 2023-08- CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, State of California, declaring an emergency still exists and authorizing repair, Page3of7 17
781
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023 1 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING CONT'D replacement or maintenance activities of public facilities related to the Urban Orchard, City Project No. 539-PRK, without public bidding, pursuant to the emergency contracting procedures of the South Gate Municipal Code and the California Public Contract Code were approved during the Consent Calendar.
PERSONNELADMIN The City Council adopted Resolution No. 2023-09-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, Califonnia, amending Resolution No. 6454 (Salary Resolution and Position Classification Plan) to update the job specifications of the Police Officer, Police Officer Lateral and Police Recruit positions in the Police Department during the Consent Calendar. 3 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council adopted Resolution No. 2023-10-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, initiating the annual proceedings for the levy of the Fiscal Year 2023/24 assessments and ordering the preparation of an Engineer's Report for the Street Lighting and Landscaping Maintenance District No. 1 during the Consent Calendar.
WATER The City Council approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Resolution No. 2023-11-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, amending Resolution No. 2020-04- CC updating Rule Four (Policy On Discontinuation of Residential Water Service for Non-Payment) of the Rules and
Regulations governing the Water Division, the Water Customer Service Division and all Water Development and distribution activities, functions and systems of the South Gate Municipal Water Works System to clarify language pertaining to the alternate payment arrangements in compliance with Senate Bill 998; and
b. Directed staff to post the updated policy on the City's website (translated into multiple languages) as required by Senate Bill No. 998. 5 TRANSPORTATION
SERVICES The City Council approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Amendment No. 1 to Contract No. 3430 with Fiesta Taxi Cooperative, Inc. dba Fiesta Taxi/Ride Yellow ("Fiesta Taxi") to provide Dial-A-Ride services for the residents of South Gate for an additional one (1) year through and including June 30, 2024; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 1 in a form acceptable to the City Attomey.
18 782
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023 6 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council approved items A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H during the Consent Calendar:
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-14-CC) with Sequel Contractors, Inc. ("Agreement"), for the construction of Garfield Avenue Complete Street Project, City Project No. 564-ST, in an amount not-to-exceed $5,052,943, which is inclusive of the $2,793,750 Base Bid and $2,259,193 Additive Alternate No. 1 ;
Change Order No. 1 to reduce the concrete quantities from 62,200 SF to 20,000 SF which will be replaced with irrigation and landscape improvements that are a part of the scope of work for Additive Alternate No. 1, for a total contract reduction amount of $548,600; Appropriated $600,000 in Measure W Funds from the fund balance to the Garfield Avenue Complete Street Project, City Project No. 564-ST; Authorized the City Manager to approve change orders
administratively up to a cumulative amount of $500,000 to avoid delaying construction if change order work is needed;
Authorized the City Manager to approve pre-payments of construction progress payments for the construction contract to meet compliance with state legislation that requires payments within 30 days; Declared the Garfield Avenue Complete Street Project, City Project No. 564-ST Categorically Exempt under Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 15301 of the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA");
Notice of Exemption for the construction of the Garfield Avenue Complete Street Project, City Project No. 564-ST, and directing the City Clerk to file it with the Los Angeles County Registrar Recorder's Office; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
19 783
RF,GULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023 7 WATER The City Council approved items A & B approved during the Consent Calendar:
a. Agreement (Contract No. 2023-15-CC) with INTERA
Incoiporated to prepare design and construction documents, provide hydrogeological and construction support services on the Well No. 30 at Hawkings Reservoir Site City Project No. 605-WTR, in an amount not to exceed $399,000; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
8 LAWENFORCEMENT TheCityCouncilapproveditemsA&BduringtheConsentCalendar:
a. Purchase Order Agreement with Champion Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram Fiat for the purchase of one vehicle for the Police Department, in the total amount of $50,720.65; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Purchase Order in a fon'n acceptable to the City Attorney.
9 DATA PROCESSING
SERVICES The City Council approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. A purchase order for ten (10) mobile data computers in the amount of $88,703.75; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Purchase Order Agreement in a fon'n acceptable to the City Attorney.
10 DEEDS & EASEMENTS The City Council approved items A & B during the Consent Calendar:
a. Accepted a Grant Deed from 3420 Firestone, LLC., to secure right-ofway for street purposes as part of the development located 3420 Firestone Boulevard, at no cost to the City; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Certificate of Acceptance in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
Page6of7 20
784
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF FEBRUARY 28, 2023 11 CITY COUNCIL APPOINTMENTS/
RISK MANAGEMENT The City Council approved items A, B & C during the Consent Calendar:
Affirming the appointment of City Council Member Maria Davila to serve as the City's delegate to the Governing Board of ICRMA; Appointing Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Resources, to serve as the alternate delegate; and
Adopting Resolution No. 2023-12-CC entitled A Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate appointing a delegate to the governing board of the Independent Cities Risk Management Authority (ICRMA).
12 INVESTMENTS The City Council received and filed the Quarterly Investment Report for the quarter ended December 31, 2022, during the Consent Calendar. 14 WARRANTS The City Council approved the Warrant Register for February 28, 2023, by motion of Council Member Davila and seconded by Council Member Rios.
Total of Checks:
Less Voids:
Less Employee Payroll Deductions:
Grand Total:
Cancellations: 96244, 99973, 100007
$3,675,308.49
$ (18,074.14)
$ (330,374.22)
$3,326,860.13
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, excused.
ADJO[mNMENT Council Member Davila adjourned the meeting in memory of Maria del Rosario Cornejo, longtime resident at 8:58 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Barron.
PASSED and APPROVED this f'l day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
21 785
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
REGULAR MEETING AGENDA
MINUTES
TUESDAY, MARCH 28, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor called a Regular City Council Meeting to order at 6:38 p.m.
JNVOCATION Pastor Ernesto Trejo, South Gate Church of Christ
PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE Salvador Campos, Recreation Coordinator
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del PilarAvalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salinas ABSENT City Treasurer Jose De La Paz
l
CD/HOUSING The City Council unanimously approved A and B by motion of Council Member Rios and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
a. Resolution No. 2023-15-CC entitled - A Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California approving Substantial ArnendmentNo. 1 to the FY 2021-2022 Annual Action Plan approving the HOME-ARP Allocation Plan due to HUD by March 31, 2023; and authorizing the City Manager, or designee, to submit to HUD, in a fori'n approved by the City Attorney; and b. Appropriated $387,686 from the HOME-ARP funds to an account deteri'nined by the Director of Administrative Services to 'fund the administration of the HOME-ARP program.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
Carol Averell, Housing Manager, provided a presentation on this item.
Council Member Hurtado asked if there are any numbers showing how many are at risk of becoming homeless.
Ms. Averell stated that the money has already been allocated from HUD and they do follow a fon'nula that is based on the population of the city.
Mayor Avalos asked if there could be a map that shows which areas of South Gate would fall under these qualifications.
22 786
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
CD/HOUSING CONT'D Chris Jeffers, City Manager stated that at this point we are designating which programs the funding will be used for. The city will need a process to verify income to see if applicants qualify and review what exactly the program allows.
Mayor Avalos opened the public hearing and asked if anyone in the audience wishes to speak on this item. Seeing no come forward, Mayor Avalos closed the public hearing.
Council Member Baron clarified that this item is to accept the allocation offunds.
Ms. Averell stated that Council Member Baron is correct, and that the distribution of funds will come later.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA At this time, there being no objections, MayorAvalos stated that item 12 would be considered out of its regular agenda order.
WASTEWATER MGMT The City Council received and filed the presentation on the Sewer Rate Study. The City Council requested that staff bring back information on Option No. 2 (5-year Financial Plan Revenue Adjustment) by motion of MayorAvalos and seconded by Council Member Hurtado.
a. Received and filed a presentation on the Sewer Rate Study; and b. Provided the City Manager with direction on next steps, if any, as it relates to the fiscal sustainability of the City's Sewer Fund.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA At this time, there being no objections, Mayor Avalos stated that item 2 would be considered out of its regular agenda order.
2 STREETS/SIDEW,"iLKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council adopted Resolution No. 2023-16-CC entitled - A Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California declaring an emergency still exists and authorizing repair, replacement or maintenance activities of public facilities related to the Urban Orchard, City Project No. 539-PRK, without public bidding, pursuant to the emergency contracting procedures of the South Gate Municipal Code and the California Public Contract Code by motion of Council Member Barron and seconded by Council Member Davila
23 787
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
2 STREETS/SIDEW,kLKS/
LANDSCAPING con'r'n ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, recused; Mayor Avalos, yes.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA At this time, there being no objections, MayorAvalos stated that item 5 would be considered out of its regular agenda order.
PARKS Tlie City Council approved A and B by motion of Council Member Barron and seconded by Council member Davila
a. Ai'nendment No. 1 to Contract No. 3485 with David Volz Design (DVD) to extend the ternn of the contract through June 30, 2024, and to provide design and construction support services on the Circle Park Renovation Project, City Project No. 609-PRK, for an amount not to exceed $99,085; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 1 in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, recused; Mayor Avalos, yes.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA Mayor Avalos provided her report before having to leave the City Council Meeting.
Mayor Avalos attended that AltaMed recognition by Congresswoman Barragan presenting a check for 2.5 million dollars for their residency program. She also participated in making a video with Council Member Rios in support of mental health and the Multi-Cultural Woman's Club Women's Day acknowledgement. The County Sanitation District will host an Earth Day Event on April 22 in Whittier.
EXCUSED FROM
MEETING At 7:51 p.m., Mayor Avalos was excused from the meeting and departed from the Council Chambers.
COMMENTS FROM
THE, A[mIENCE Ai'ny Lu, Leland Weaver Community Library shared information about the Reading Stars program.
Andrea asked if Code Enforcement checks the placement of residential trash cans and overgrown lawns.
24 788
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
COMMENTS FROM
THE AUDIENCE cosrin Mario Dominguez requested that at the April 13I'I Parks and Recreation Meeting would like to place the mural project on tl'ie agenda including and emailing the public photos of the sample art.
Bash, Tweedy Mile Association tlianked the City Council and Staff for their support of the Azalea Festival Car Sliow.
Thomas Buckley supported the decision of the city to close the carnival on Friday night but does disagree with the closure on Saturday and Sunday.
He stated that the city did a poor job of coini'nunicating with the coininunity as to what was going on.
Ana, Chamber of Commerce invited everyone to attend a meet and greet with the Mayor on April ls'. She also encourages everyone to check out the gift card program that is continuing. There are about 25 businesses that are participating in the program and the city is matching the amount purchased for each card.
Cyndi Esquivel stated that if the carnival was shut down due to public safety, she agrees with the decision, but the city didn't communicate the reasons with the community.
RF,PORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS Meredith Elguira, Director of Community Development, reported that City received a grant for the site assessment at 13050 Paramount Blvd. Last week was Co Op with Code for the cleanup of the United Pacific Railroad tracks.
Steve Costley, Interim Director of Parks and Recreation, reported on the Azalea Festival events. Since the beginning of 2021 the city has hosted a COVID testing site at South Gate Park. Los Angeles County has decided to close many of these testing sites and March 31stwill be the last day for this site.
Kris Ryan, Director of Administrative Services, reported that the Finance Department is moving forward witli the budget and should have an item coming before the Council shortly.
Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Resource announced the open positions for the City of South Gate.
Darren Arakawa, Chief of Police, received a 26-foot DUI trailer from the Office of Traffic Safety by a grant awarded to the city. Baker to Vegas run starts next weekend.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager, reported that on Friday night at the carnival approximately 150 teens became unruly, in fact, I juvenile was arrested with a gun. The situation escalated and the city could no longer guarantee Page4of9 25
789
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS the safety of participants at the event. The event ended at 9:30 p.m. a half an hour before the scheduled time. The decision to close the carnival on Saturday and Sunday was based on the number of available staff that the city could provide on sliort notice. The City Managers priority is that the coini'nunity is safe.
Mr. Jeffers explained that Mr. Dominguez did liave the opportunity to address the Parks and Recreation Corninission regarding the graffiti style writing being suggested for the mural. There was a presentation by TPL that included pictures. Mr. Dominguez did address the commission both orally and in writing. The Commission is made up of 5 residents and they reached the decision that the general painting was good, but the style of lettering was not appropriate and requested that additional fonts be presented.
Yodit Glaze, City Clerk reported that slie attended the Multi-Cultural Women's Club conference. She was a judge for the Miss Azaelita Contest, the Miss South Gate Pageant, and tlie Azalea Festival Car Show.
Council Member Davila thanked the participants of the Multi-Cultural Women's Club conference, the Miss South Gate Pageant, and the Miss Azaelita Contest. Council Member Davila supported the decisions of the City Staff to close the carnival.
Council Member Barron supported the decisions of the City Staff to close the carnival but was glad to liave these conversations and recognizes that the city might have been able to communicate better with the residents.
Council Member Rios attended the Azalea Festival Car Show and spoke on participating in the making of the video for the video in support of mental health programs. He supports the decisions of the decisions of the City Staff to close the carnival but would like to see us offer more programs for youth to take part in.
Vice Mayor Hurtado spoke about the recent school shooting in Tennessee and agrees with staff about closing the carnival. He stated that he received messages from people saying that they knew this was going to happen because their kids where about it in school and that society tries to excuse their behavior by saying there is not enough programs for the youth, but it really comes down to family. The Vice Mayor said that the City needs to improve communication with the residents and needs to continue to enforce our own rules.
cousnn'rcatbsn,=m Agenda Items 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 were approved by motion of Council Member Rios and seconded by Council Member Barron. Items 2 and 5 were pulled for separate discussion.
790
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
CONSENT CALENDAR
CONT'D ROLL CALL: Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes (recused for Item 9); Council Member Davila, yes, (recused for Item 3 and abstain for Item 11), Council Member Rios, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Mayor Avalos, excused.
PARK{NG & TRAFFIC The City Council approved A and B duiing the consent calendar.
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-35-CC) with Fountainhead
Consulting Corporation (Fountainhead) to provide construction management and inspection services for the construction of the Tweedy Boulevard Signal Synchronization Project, City Project No. 514-TRF, in an amount not to exceed $175,290; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a fonn acceptable to the City Attorney.
WASTF.WATER MGMT The City Council approved A and B during the consent calendar.
A+'nendment No. I to Contract No. 2020-53-CC with John L.
Hunter and Associates, Inc. to extend management services for the Industrial Waste Program and Fat, Oil, and Grease Control Program for one year, not-to-exceed amount of $56,760; and Authorizing the Mayor to execute Ai'nendment No. l to Contract No. 2020-53-CC in a form approved by the City Attomey.
PARKING&TRAFFIC TheCityCouncilapprovedA,B,CandDduringtheconsentcalendar.
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-36-CC) with Servitek
Electrical Inc., for the Replacement of Damaged Traffic Signal Poles, City Project No. 655-TRF ("Agreement"), in an amount notto-exceed $351,857; Appropriated $315,170 in Proposition C Funds to fully fund the Replacement of Damaged Traffic Signal Poles, City Project No. 655-TRF ("Project");
Notice of Exemption for the Project, pursuant to Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, Existing Facilities Section 15301 Class and directing the City Clerk to file it with the Los Angeles County Registrar Recorder's Office; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
791
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTF,S OF MARCH 28, 2023 7 PERSONNEL-MOU BETW
ci'ry.xgmt,nucgot+ps TheCityCouncilapprovedAandBduringtheconsentcalendar. a. Resolution No. 2023-1 7-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, approving the SGMEA MOU (Contract No. 2023-37-CC) and the SGPMMA
MOU (Contract No. 2023-38-CC) for the teri'n of July 1, 2021, through June 30, 2024; and
b. Authorized the Mayor to execute the comprehensive successor Memorandums of Understanding in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
8 PERSONNEL RECRUITMENT
& SELECTION The City Council adopted Resolution No. 2023-18-23 entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, amending Resolution No. 6454 (Salary Resolution and Position Classification Plan) by approving the job classification specifications for the following positions during the consent calendar.
a. Electrical Supervisor;
b. Facilities Maintenance Specialist;
C. Facilities Maintenance Technician II;
d. General Maintenance Foreman;
e. Water Distribution Foreman;
f. Water Distribution Operator I;
g. Water Distribution Operator II;
h. Water Lead Worker;
Water Meter Reader II;
Water Operations Foreman;
k. Water Pump Operator I;
1. Water Pump Operator II; and
m. Water Quality & System Lead Operator.
28 792
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
9 SCHOOLS/EDUCATION The City Council approved A, B and C during the consent calendar.
Appropriated $375,000 in American Rescue Plan Act ("ARPA") 'funds for an agreement with the Southeast Coininunity Foundation ("SCF") to continue tutoring services for the spring, suinrner and fall sessions at three (3) sites in South Gate and internal costs for monitoring the agreement by staf'f;
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-39-CC) with SCF for the tutoring program as outlined in Attachi'nent A (Scope of Work) in an amount not to exceed $345,171 ; and
Authorized the Mayor to sign an agreement with SCF in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
10 LAWENFORCEMENT TheCityCouncilapprovedA,BandCduringtheconsentcalendar.
Purchase Order Agreement witli ATV Corp for the purchase of one Prowler C4XM police off-road utility vehicle for the Police Department, in the total amount of $50,340.15;
Appropriated $2,397.15 from the Asset Forfeiture Fund to cover the full cost of the vehicle; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Purchase Order in a fonn acceptable to the City Attorney.
11 MIa+TES The City Council approved A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H during the consent calendar.
The Regular Meeting minutes of November 22, 2022;
The Recessed Meeting minutes of November 29, 2022;
The Regular Meeting minutes of December 13, 2022;
The Special Meeting minutes (Closed Session) and Special Meeting Minutes of January 10, 2023;
The Regular Meeting minutes of January 10, 2023;
The Special Meeting minutes of January 24, 2023;
The Special Meeting minutes of February 6, 2023; and
The Special Meeting minutes of February 14, 2023.
793
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MARCH 28, 2023
EXCUSED FROM
MEETING At this time, 10:02 p.m., Council Member Davila was excused from the meeting and departed from the Council Chambers.
13 CITY COUNCIL The City Council will decide if direction should be given to staff to present a project and program tl'iat would pennit the video/streaming of City Council meetings.
Tliis item was continued to the City Council Meeting of April 11, 2023 by motion of Council Member Barron and seconded by Council Member Rios.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, absent; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, absent.
14 WARRANTS The City Council approved the Warrant Register for March 28, 2023, by Council Member Rios and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
Total of Cliecks:
Less: Voids
Less: Employee Payroll Deductions
Grand Total:
Cancellations: 99840, 100210, 100400
$2,203,667.53
$ (1,356.29)
$ (327,650.74)
$1,874,660.50
ROLL CALL: Council Member Baron, yes; Council Member Davila, absent; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, absent.
ADJOURNMENT Vice Mayor Hurtado adjourned the meeting at 10:07 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Rios.
PASSED and APPROVED this ' day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del PilarAvalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
794
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, APRIL 25, 2023
CAJ,LTO ORDER Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor called a Special City Council Meeting to order at 5:17 p.m.
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila and Council Member Al Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina LATE Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado arrived at the dais at 5:56 p.m. l
CERTIFICATES The City Council issued a Certificate ofAppreciation to JoshuaAlvarado for receiving a $50,000 college scholarship from Southern California Edison.
2 CERTIFICATES The City Council issued Certificates of Appreciation to Girls Scouts of Troop 16325 in recognition of receiving the Presidential Volunteer Service Award and completing over 100 service hours during the 2022 Girl Scout year.
3 PROCLAfV)[ATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring the month of May 2023, as Older Ai'nericans Month.
4 PERSONNEL RECRUITMENT
& SELECTION The City Council received and filed the list of new 'full-time employees hired during the month of March 2023.
CLOSF.D SESSION The Council Members recessed into Closed Session at 6:14 p.m. and reconvened at 6:44 p.m. with all Members of Council present. City Attorney Salinas reported the following:
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - PENDING
LITIGATION
Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(a),
54954.9(b)(3)(C)
a. NR Development v. City of South Gate
b. Silvia Gonzalez v. City of South Gate
31 795
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
Item 1(a) was not discussed in closed session.
On item l(b) the City Attorney provided a report with respect to tlie outcome of tlie trial that occurred in that case. The report was that the city had prevailed in the defense of that civil litigation.
2. CONSIDER THE EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF A
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957(b)(1)
a. City Manager
Tliere was a brief discussion on item 2(a) and that item will be discussed further after the conclusion of the Regular City Council meeting.
MayorAvalos asked if anyone in the audience and zoom wished to speak on this item.
Mario Dominguez, Jr. requested background information on the Silvia Gonzalez case.
Thomas Buckley asked for the case number and courthouse for the NR Development case. He also asked if the city is paying for legal services.
Having no one else come forward, Mayor Avalos closed the audience portton.
City Attorney Salinas stated that NR Development is pending in Los Angeles Superior Court, Norwalk branch. The claim was filed a year ago seeking a change order regarding the recovery of dirt taken off site by the contractor. The city disputes as to whether the additional charges for the removal of dirt are inside or outside of the contract.
City Attorney Salinas stated that Ms. Gonzalez sued the city claiming that she tripped on a city sidewalk and suffered personal injuries. The city took the position that it is not responsible for the injuries she sustained because the area of the sidewalk where she fell was trivial in nature and could not have been the approximate cause, as a matter of law, for her injuries. The city went to trial on that matter at the Van Nuys Branch of the Los Angeles Superior Court. The trial lasted approximately 3 days. The city requested that the judge split the trial in parts, which he did. The first part was a request to the judge that he rule whether or not the condition of the sidewalk, as a matter of law, was a trivial defect. The city prevailed during the trial and the remainder of the case was dismissed. Judgement will be entered in favor of the City of South Gate and no money will be paid in connection with that claim.
32 796
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
RECESSED At this time, 6:51 p.m., MayorAvalos recessed the Closed Session meeting in order that tlie Council might hold the Regular City Council meeting. The Closed Session meeting was reconvened at 9:15 p.m. with all the Council presents.
CLOSED SESSION The Council Members recessed into Closed Session at 9:15 p.i'n. and reconvened at 10:38 p.m. with all Members of Council present. City Attorney Salinas reported the following:
2. CONSIDER THE EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF A
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957(b)(1)
a. City Manager
There was no reportable action taken on item 2(a).
ADJOURNMENT Vice Mayor Hurtado unanimously adjourned the meeting at 10:39 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Rios.
PASSED and APPROVED this day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
Page3of3 33
797
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, APRIL 25, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Maria del PilarAvalos, Mayor called a Regular City Council Meeting to order at 6:51 p.m,
INVOCATION Steve Costley, Acting Director of Parks & Recreation
PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE Nicholas Iturriaga, Police Officer
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council MemberAl Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina
l
COMfVnJNITY DEV/
HOUSING Following the conclusion of tlie Public Hearing, the City Council unanimously approved A, B & C by motion of Council Member Rios and seconded by Council Member Barron:
a. Adopted Resolution No. 2023-20-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, receiving and approving the Fiscal Year 2023-2024 Annual Action Plan; b. Authorized the City Manager, or designee, to submit to the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development the Fiscal Year 2023-2024 Annual Action Plan; and
C. Authorized the City Manager or his designee to enter into agreements with eligible subrecipients in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
Meredith Elguira stated that Ms. Carol Averell will be presenting the item.
Ms. Averell stated that each year an Annual Action Plan must be prepared with the five-year consolidated plan. This shows how the city will spend the allocations for CDBG and HOME Funding. The consolidated plan was adopted in 2020 and the FY 2023-2024 is the fourth year of the five-year consolidated plan.
34 798
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
I
COMMUNITY DEV/
HOUSING CONT'D Ms. Averell stated that on March 8"] a meeting with the Citizens' Advisory Committee was held and the coini'nittee and City staff made recomi'nendations.
Ms. Averell explained the chart.
For Administration under CDBG we have a 20% cap. The total amount allocated for administration is $263,705. They are required to provide Fair Housing funding administration, so the recomi'nendation is $24,000. The total amount for Program Administration and Planning is $239,705.
For Public Service Grants we have a 15% cap. The total amount allocated is $197,779. The recommendation by the Citizen's Advisory Committee to Compatior Counseling Center is $25,000; $22,779 to Family Violence Prevention Program, $11,000 to South Gate Police Explorers; $9,000 to the Home Modification Program.
For Non-Public Service which has no cap. We are recommending the remaining balance of $857,043. We are recoinmending $500,00 to the Commercial Fagade Program; and $357,043 to start a Neighborhood Revitalization Grant Program.
Ms. Averell stated that the additional recommendation from staff is to reallocate the $25,000 and split the amounts equally between Family Violence Prevention Program ($35,279) and South Gate Police Explorers ($23,500).
For the HOME Funding Allocation, we received $740,613. This year there is an exception, there is a waiver that can be filed and request to use 20% of the entitlement for Administration which is $148,122. Allocating $80,000 for Affordable Housing Development (Azure Development 7916 Long Beach Blvd) and $512,491 to the Affordable Housing Development for future projects.
MayorAvalos asked if anyone in the audience and zoom wished to speak on this item.
Mario Dominguez, Jr., inquired if his mother could apply for the Neighborhood Revitalization Grant Program.
Thomas Buckley is concerned the city is referring to and/or using an antiquated newspaper.
Having no one else come forward, Mayor Avalos closed the audience portion.
799
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
1 COMMUNITY DEV/
HOUSING CONT'D Meredith Elguira, Director of Community Development stated that for a resident to qualify for this program, the city would have to qualify them income-wise. There are other programs, and the city needs to appraise their homes to quali'fy for CDBG.
City Attorney Salinas stated that the County of Los Angeles recognizes the Wave as a newspaper for general circulation.
Council Member Barron asked if the Neighborhood Revitalization Grant Program is a new program.
Ms. Elguira stated that yes, it is a new program.
Council Member Barron asked if any publications have been posted.
Ms. Elguira stated not yet because it requires Council approval first. And guidelines are required to be approved by HUD.
Council Member Davila asked if any resident could apply.
Ms. Elguira said yes.
Vice Mayor Hurtado inquired about the total amount for the Graffiti Abatement.
Ms. Elguira stated that currently the city is allocating $130,000.
Arturo Cervantes, Director of Public Works does not have the exact amount but it's close to $450,000.
Vice Mayor Hurtado asked if that amount does not include the $130,000.
Mr. Cervantes stated that it includes the $130,000.
Vice Mayor Hurtado asked if the city has any programs to educate people as to the negative impacts of graffiti. It seems the city spends over $100,000 every year.
Mr. Cervantes stated the city does not have a graffiti abatement outreach.
Vice Mayor Hurtado asked if the city penalizes anyone getting caught.
Darren Arakawa, Chief of Police is not prepared to answer statistically what the consequences are. However, in years past when someone was arrested the judge would send a letter to the city asking how much the restitution would be.
800
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
1 COMMUNITY DEV/
HOUSING CONT'D Council Member Rios stated that often it's the young people and we need to find a way to help them become good citizens.
Mayor Avalos asked if the Affordable Housing Development is a new program.
Ms. Elguira stated that it is to be deten'nined. As the city receives proposals for affordable housing development then we can use this fund.
Mayor Avalos stated that this project is for developers not for the coini'nunity. She would prefer this item to be for first-time home buyers in the coinmunity.
Ms. Elguira stated that we used to have the first-time home buyers' program. The city is still receiving revenue from the first-time home buyers that are paying off their loans, selling or refinancing.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager stated that the program originally started through tlie Coinrnunity Redevelopment program so the guidelines are much different than HUD. HUD is more restrictive.
Vice Mayor Hurtado asked if a person qualifies for the first-time buyer program must they live in it or are they allowed to rent the home. Are they allowed to build an ADU?
Mr. Jeffers stated that staff would need to check with HUD.
Mayor Avalos requested a CDBG of $10,000 to help residents.
Council Member Barron asked if this item can be approved with the recommendations from staff.
Council Member Davila asked from where are the $10,000 coming from.
Mayor Avalos suggested $5,000 from Family Violence and $5,000 from Police Explorers.
Council Member Davila disagrees. The city has provided enough money for Compatior. The council has yet to receive any information that was requested. She suggested moving with the staff's recorni'nendations.
Council Member Barrons agrees with Council Member Davila.
801
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEF,TING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023 COMMENTS FROM THE A[mIENCE
NONAGENDA ITEMS Mario Dominguez, Jr. is requesting the Council speak with Congresswoman Nanette Barragan and Senator Lena Gonzalez to speak with Janice Hahn about the LA River project.
Alex Cueto, designer for Art Design Services, is present tonight with a client. Mr. Cueto stated that in January 2022 the planning department for an ADU or any type of submittal was $231. Three months later it was $269. In August was $1,085. The City of South Gate is taking longer than any other city in the State of California to approve ADU's and the fees are higher.
Juan Gonzalez has 50 years living in the City of South Gate and is complaining about street vendors.
Vanessa Cruz from the Office of Congresswoman Barragan stating the congresswoman is holding a small business resource session on Monday, May 1, 2023, at 5:30 p.m. in the city of Paramount.
Thomas Buckley stated receiving complaints from residents regarding encampments and trees being cut down between Hildretli and the pool.
REPORT AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS Meredith Elguira, Director of Community Development, responded to Mr.
Cueto's statements stating that it is true the planning division is behind.
There are two planners working on ADU's and that was prior increasing the fees last year. Five applications are being processed per week. The department was able to hire planning consultants. She also stated explaining to Mr. Cueto's son of the fees.
Mayor Avalos asked Ms. Elguira how many planning consultations are checking the ADU's plans.
Ms. Elguira stated there are two additional consultations.
Ms. Elguira stated that the department is providing more notices of violations.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager stated the Chief will follow up on the homeless issues. The trees were being worked on at the South Gate Park that are problematic. Vanessa from Congresswoman Barragan's Office called the City Manager's Office regarding the small business resource session, and it was posted on the City's website. The city is in discussions with the City's Prosecutor and staff on bringing a revised ordinance addressing vendors.
802
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
REPORT AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT1D Council Member Rios is concen'ied that the new tree vendor will be cutting down trees that provide shade.
Arturo Cervantes, Director of Public Works stated tliat this year is the first cycle of the four-year tree triinming program. Some trees have been identified to be problematic.
Council Member Barron had the pleasure of sitting on the Parks & Recreation Commission for about 5 years and stated that Glen Massey from the Parks Department loves trees. Mr. Massey will work with tlie arborist.
Steve Costley, Acting Director of Parks & Recreation stated that Assemblymember Rendon is having a biking event this Saturday at Hollydale Regional Park and an earth day event. On May 5I'1 we will be holding our next centennial event at the golf course area. The next Saturdaywill be the JAA openingdayfor theregularbaseballseason@ 10:00 a.m.
Arturo Cervantes, Director of Public Works stated taking the first-year cycle trim for all the trees on the public right-of-way, trimined over 2,800 trees in the comi'nunity and done removal and other treatments. On the fire hydrant flushing program, we have completed thirteen of the sixteen zones. We have flushed nearly 1,000 fire hydrants.
Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Services reported on the positions tlie city is recruiting.
Darren Arakawa, Police Chief highlighted upcoming community events.
Kris Ryan, Director of Administrative Services stated that the city will be transitioning to a new phone system this Friday.
Yodit Glaze, City Clerk stated that the passport services in the City Clerk's Office is opened for the public. She also stated that two hourly positions will be hired.
Jose De La Paz, City Treasurer wished Vice Mayor Hurtado a Happy Birthday.
Chris Jeffers, City Manager congratulated Public Works Department for an excellent job during earth day this past weekend.
Raul F. Salinas, City Attorney had nothing to report at this time.
803
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OFAPRIL 25, 2023
REPORT AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D Council Member Davila wished Vice Mayor Hurtado a Happy Birtliday.
She attended earth day which was very well attended. She coinrnended Public Works Department for a job well done during earth day. She also attended Stanford Elementary School's Career Day and visited three classrooms. At the last city council meeting, she and Mayor Ayalos were in Sacramento advocating for our city. The League of California Cities are working on housing and homelessness. The state is asking all cities to build eight thousand houses but there is no funding. The League of Califoniia is asking the state for three billion dollars for the housing. Tliey did meet with the legislatures asking for an amendment on how many houses need to be built, especially in the city of South Gate. Another issue was homelessness.
Council Member Davila attended a workshop on safety, and she spoke to City Manager about having an active shooter scenario. She stated that the City of Paramount had an active shooter scenario at Paramount High Scl'iool. She asked to adjourn in memory of Cecilia Martinez wife of Ted Noudis (a long-time resident of South Gate and former business owner of T and C's Restaurant on Tweedy Blvd) who passed away this Sunday.
Mayor Avalos stated that while they were at the capital there was an active shooter at the capital. The active shooter left the capital and then went to the city of Roseville where he was captured.
Council Member Barron had the opportunity to attend Coffee with a Cop on April 13Ih. He is asking to get ahold of the local schools and ask if they are trained in using Automated External Defibrillator (AED). He infori'ned Mr. Gonzalez that the city is working on updating the ordinance regarding vendors. He infon'ned Mr. Cueto that he too built an ADU, and it is stressful and hopes there will be an improvement on the waiting list. He had the pleasure of meeting with the Community Development Department and thanked the director for setting up the meeting.
Council Member Rios stated that the city of Bell Gardens improved their ordinance and made certain all vendors have licenses and permits. He stated that the active shooter topic was discussed at the college he works at. He had the pleasure of going to the International Studies Learning Center and hearing some of the senior projects. He too attended the Earth Day event. He will be attending on May 4' the Southern California Associates of Government and will be the delegate for the city. Also on May 4fhis National Prayer Breakfast at South Gate Park.
Vice Mayor Hurtado stated that the South Gate JAA will be having its opening day on Saturday, May 6I'l and everyone is invited to attend and Ken Landreaux the former baseball player for the Dodgers will be present.
He too attended the Earth Day event. He received notifications of large
804
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
REPORT AND COMMENTS
FROM CITY OFF4CIALS
CONT'D gatherings at Hollydale Park without penuits. He attended the Coffee with the Principal at South Gate Middle School and street vendors and homeless were brought up. He thanked everyone for tlie birthday wishes.
Mayor Avalos attended the League of California Cities advocating for our coinmunity to bring in resources. One of the issues discussed was the building of homes and building up. She had the privilege of attending the Women's Club conference on May 17k'l and Stanford Elementary School's 2ndAnnual Career. She thanked Mr. Gonzalez for bringing up the vendor issues in the city. She understands the urgency of ADU's and hopes they can expedite the corninunity members. She also attended The Wall Las Memorias conducted by Janice Hahn and Jackie Goldberg in the city of Bell. She also attended HUB Cities. She mentioned Compatior was honored to receive the mentored interiiship program grant which is a component of the California Department of Mental Health Services Behavior Health and Workhorse Department. Compatior is going to partner with Loyola Marymount, East LA College and LA Trade Tech to mentor students that are in the field of opioid addiction and substance use.
Council Member Davila requested an update from staff regarding East LA College.
Council Member Rios stated the college needs to vacate the building by June 24. The building across the street is expected to be built by the fall of next year.
CONSENT CALENDAR Agenda Items 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 were approved by motion of Council Member Davila and seconded by Vice MayorAvalos.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes (recused for Items 2 and 5); Mayor Avalos, yes.
2 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council made a finding and adopted Resolution No. 2023-21- CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, State of California, declaring an emergency still exists and authorizing repair, replacement or maintenance activities of public facilities related to the Urban Orchard Project, City Project No. 539-PRK, without public bidding, pursuant to the emergency contracting procedures of the South Gate Municipal Code and the Califomia Public Contract Code, during Consent Calendar.
805
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
3 STREETS/SIDEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council unanimously approved A & B during Consent Calendar:
Resolution No. 2023-22-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of Soutli Gate, Califomia, preliminarily approving the Engineer's Report required for the proceedings of the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Anu'iual Levy and Collection of Assessments for the Street Lighting and Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 ; and
Resolution No. 2023-23-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, declaring the City's intention to levy and collect assessments under the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Annual Levy and Collection of Assessments within the Street Lighting and Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 and setting a Public Hearing for May 23, 2023.
GENF,RAL PLAN The City Council unanimously approved A & B during Consent Calendar:
Amendment No. 1 to Contract No. 2020-85-CC with Veronica Tam and Associates, Inc., for Professional Services to update the Housing Element for the 6th Planning Cycle 2021-2029; and Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 1 in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
WATER The City Council approved A, B, C, D & E during Consent Calendar:
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-54-CC) with Unified Field
Services Corporation for the construction of the Hawkins North and South Tank Rehabilitation, City Project No. 645-WTR in an amount not-to-exceed $3,432,764;
Appropriated $3,791,207 in Water Funds from the unrestricted balance of the Water Fund to fully fund the project;
A finding detennining the Hawkins North and South Tank
Rehabilitation, City Project No. 645-WTR as categorically exempt under Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 15301 and the projects are categorically exempt under Existing Facilities Section 15301 Class (c) Existing highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities (including road grading for the purpose of public safety)
806
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
WATER CONT'D and to be categorically excluded under Section 326 of amended Chapter 3 of Title 23, United States Code (23 U.S.C. e)326) without significant impacts on the environment as defined by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA);
Authorized tlie Mayor to execute the Agreement in a fornn acceptable to the City Attorney; and
Notice of Exemption for the construction of tlie Project and directing the City Clerk to file it with the Los Angeles County Registrar Recorder's Office.
6 STRF.ETS/SmEWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council unanimously approved A & B during Consent Calendar:
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-55-CC) with Garu'iett Fleming Inc., to provide construction management and inspection services for the construction of the Long Beach Boulevard Street
Improvements Project, City Project No. 515-ST, Federal Project Nos. ATPL-5257(033) and HSIPL-5257(037) in an amount not to exceed $468,241; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
7 ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY CONTROL The City Council unanimously approved A, B & C during Consent Calendar:
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-56-CC) with Steams, Conrad and Schi'nidt, Consulting Engineers, Inc., to provide environmental engineering services in an amount not to exceed $399,093 for a two-year and six-month term beginning May 2023 to October 2025;
Appropriated $399,093 from tlie US EPA 2023 Coini'nunitywide Brownfields Assessment Grant; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a fon'n acceptable to the City Attorney.
807
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
8 COMMUNITY DEV/
HOUSING The City Council unanimously approved A, B & C by motion of Vice Mayor Hurtado and seconded by Mayor Avalos:
a. Authorized the City to join the Gateway Cities Affordable Housing Trust;
b. Resolution No. 2023-24-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California, approving the Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement (Contract No. 2023-57-CC) for the membership to the Gateway Cities Affordable Housing Trust; and C. Authorized the Mayor to execute the Joint Powers Agreement with the Gateway Cities Affordable Housing Trust in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
CITY COUNCIL The City Council gave guidance to staff to present a project and program that would pennit the video/streaming of City Council meetings and bring the item back at the second meeting in May.
WATER The City Council unanimously authorized the Assistant City Manager/ Director of Public Works to submit a Protest Letter objecting to the proposed Replenishment Assessment increase of $35 per acre-foot (approximately 8.5% for FY 2023-24) by the Water Replenishi'nent District, by motion of Mayor Avalos and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
WffiS The City Council unanimously approved the Warrant Register for April 25, 2023, by motion of Mayor Avalos and seconded by Council Member Rios.
Total of Checks:
Less: Voids
Less: Employee Payroll Deductions
Grand Total:
$3,956,510.64
$ (586.67)
$ (406,947.05)
$3,548,976.92
808
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF APRIL 25, 2023
11 WARRANTS CONT'D Cancellations: 94513, 94556, 94754, 95085, 95124, 95452, 95472, 95486, 95528, 96628, 96661, 96672, 96715, 97149, 97274, 100015, 99776 ROLL CALL: Council Member Batron, yes; Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes.
ADJOURNMENT Mayor Avalos unanimously adjourned the meeting in memory of Theresa Rodriguez, mother of Tweedy Mile Advisory Board Member Adolfo Varas, Cecilia Martinez wife of Ted Noudis (a long-time resident of South Gate and fon'ner business owner of T and C's Restaurant on Tweedy Blvd), Ada Livia Hernandez, passed away last week at the age of 86, South Gate resident since 1961. She leaves behind four children and a husband of 92 years old, Javier Elizalde Via, lifelong resident of South Gate, Vedovina Pulido, lifelong resident of South Gate and in memoriam of Detective Alexis Gonzalez at 9:15 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Davila.
PASSED and APPROVED this day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
809
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, MAY 9, 2023
CALL TO ORDER 'Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor called a Special City Council Meeting to order at 5:19 p.m.
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina
l
CERTIFICATES The City Council issued Certificates of Appreciation to the South Gate Police Department's Citizen Academy.
2 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring May 2023 as Wellness and Mental Health Awareness Month.
3 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring May 9, 2023, as National TeacherAppreciation Day, and May 7 - 13, 2023, as National Teacher Appreciation Week.
4 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring the week of May 21 27, 2023, as National Public Works Week.
5 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring the week of May 15 21, 2023, as National Police Week.
6 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring the week of May 6 - 12, 2023, as National Nurses Week.
CLOSED SESSION The Council Members recessed into Closed Session at 6:17 p.m. and reconvened at 6:55 p.m. with all Members of Council present. City Attorney Salinas reported the following:
46 810
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - PENDING
LITIGATION
Pursuant to Governinent Code Section 54956.9(a),
54954.9(b)(3)(C)
a. NR Development v. City of South Gate
b. Gabriela Perez Negrete v. City of South Gate
c. Deonesia Abreau, Latoya Simpson, and Sanaa Ellis v. City of South Gate d. Erich Hellebrandt v. City of South Gate
Item 1(a) was not discussed in closed session.
Item 1(b) is a slip and fall on a city corner near Firestone and Garfield.
The city participated in mediation and received a proposed settlement offer in that case. Staff presentation was made in closed session. On a motion made by Vice Mayor Hurtado and seconded by MayorAvalos and on a vote of 5-0, the City Council moved to recommend approval of that settlement subject to the approval of the city's insurance cooperative. The amount of that settlement is still pending and thus cannot be disclosed at this time.
Item 1(c) involves a collision with a city vehicle and the subsequent lawsuit against tlie city in connection with that accident. There was a motion made by Vice Mayor Hurtado and seconded by Council Member Davila and on a vote of 5-0, the City Council authorized the City Attorney's Office to defend that matter.
Item 1(d) was a slip and fall on a driveway apron in a residential section.
The matter was set to go to trial at tlie end of the month. There were settlement discussions and there was a recommendation by the City Attorney to propose a settlement which has not yet been accepted by Mr.
Hellebrandt's attorney. The motion to recorni'nend settlement was made by Council Member Davila and seconded by Mayor Avalos and the vote was 5-0.
2. CONSIDER THE EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF A
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957(b)(1)
a. City Manager
There was a discussion concerning the evaluation and perfornnance in association with the Office of the City Manager. Upon completion of that discussion, there was no reportable action taken.
Mayor Avalos asked if anyone in the audience and zoom wished to speak on these items.
Page2of3 47
811
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
A South Gate resident and a coalition of businesspeople, cornrnunity people and people involved with non-profit organizations provided City Council for their review a portion of the signatures that read as follows:
We the undersigned request that the South Gate City Council not renew the contract with Chris Jeffers for City Manager.
Mario Dominguez, Jr., was surprised to hear people want Mr. Jeffers out of the position as City Manager. He requested cost amounts for these cases.
Thomas Buckley requested informing participants on zoom that Council are in closed session. He called the courthouse inquiring on the NR Development case and the court clerk was not able to locate the case. He is asking for the case number once again.
Having no one else come forward, Mayor Avalos closed the audience portion.
Raul F. Salinas, City Attorney stated that he does not have NR Developments case number. It is pending in the Norwalk court. He will provide the case number to Mr. Buckley and the audience.
Mr. Salinas stated that the cost to the city in these cases varies depending on the nature and extent of the physical injuries.
Mr. Salinas stated being a City Attoniey for the past 20 years, along witli Council Member Davila. We are on the seventh city manager. The city has always used an outside consultant (search firm) specializing in searching for city managers. The city is on notice already that Mr. Jeffers has one additional year.
ADJOURNMENT Council Member Rios unanimously adjourned the meeting at 7:09 p.m. and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
PASSED and APPROVED this day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del PilarAvalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
Page3of3 48
812
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, MAY 9, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor called a Regular City Council Meeting to order to 7:09 p.m.
INVOCATION Steve Costley, Acting Director of Parks & Recreation
PLEDGE OF
ALLEGIANCE Manuel Arana, South Gate Police Lieutenant
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attoi-ney Raul F. Salina
COMMENTS FROM
THE AUDIENCE Bill DeWitt, 5485 Gardendale reported that the trash hauler didn't pick up the green waste can. When Mr. DeWitt went to the office, he was told there was nothing they could do about it unless he wanted to go to their main office in Whittier. He requested a meeting with the City Manager to discuss the budget and has not received any response yet.
Andrea Paulino, Area 5 asked what the position is of the city on jugglers.
There is one on Imperial and Garfield. What are the rules for mobile car detailers. If residents cannot wash their cars on the street how is this allowed. She stated that elected officials do not respond to their emails, and they don't even acknowledge when they receive emails.
Joe Pacheco, Illinois Avenue is concerned with the homeless situation in the city.
Bishop Juan Carlos Mendez spoke on the people spreading lies and tumors,
Thomas Buckley spoke on the freedom of speech and that the City of Cudahy has a three-minute time limit on their Council Members when speaking during the Council Meetings. He also spoke on street vendors and the comments made at a City of Cudahy Council meeting concerning this matter.
Mario Dominguez spoke about how difficult it is to corninunicate with elected officials. He spoke about attending the Parks Com+'nission Meeting regarding the mural project.
Resident spoke about a video on social media regarding truth and transparencies. 49
813
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
COMMENTS FROM
THE AUDIENCE CONT'D Candice Esquivel spoke about the Public Coinments section during the Council Meetings being used to attack people and not focusing on City business.
Kimberly spoke about her concenns with street vendors selling in the City of South Gate.
Alice spoke about her concerns with street vendors selling in the City of South Gate. She also has been having problems with the organic waste pick up.
Yodit Glaze, City Clerk read into the record an email fromAlicia Flores.
She wants to know what is being done about the smell near Circle Park and Area Five.
Raul F. Salinas, City Attorney responded to comments stating that these items that are brought before the City Council by tlie public during this part of the meeting are items that are not on the agenda. Under law the City Council is not able to respond substantially to those items.
Art Cervantes, Director of Public Works provided the public with an update on the varies traffic signal projects throughout the city.
The Mayor asked staff about regulations that would affect street jugglers and mobile car washing.
Darren Arakawa, Chief of Police stated that the proper way to report the street jugglers is to report them to Dispatch. The Department does send out officers when reported and cite when it is appropriate
REPORTS AND COMMENTS
pgouciryoppici.ys ArtCervantes,DirectorofPublicWorksannouncedthestartofthe Garfield Avenue Complete Streets Project.
Council Member Davila requested that the City Manager set up a meeting with Mr. DeWitt, Mr. Ryan, and herself to discuss Mr. DeWitt's budget concerns.
Steve Costley, Interim Parks and Recreation Director reported on the activities at the Parks.
Meredith Elguira, Director of Community Development reported that the city received a grant from the California Energy Coinrnission for $60,000 to implement a solar app program.
Jon Hamilton, Director of Human Resource announced the available positions with the City of South Gate.
814
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
RF,PORTS ,=USIDCOMMENTS
FROM CITY OFFICIALS
CONT'D ChiefArakawa announced two recruits graduated from the academy. The Chief is part of a cottu'nittee for the CCJCC where they are discussing the infantile structure of the 911 to 988 system (County Mental Health Hotline).
Council Member Davila attei'ided the National Day of Prayer and the JAA Opening Day. Eco Rapid Transit will begin hosting coinmunity meetings and Council Member Davila would like to have this information posted on the website when available.
Council Member Barron attended Coffee with the Cop, Movie Night in the Park and the JAA Opening Day.
Council Member Rios attended the JAA Opening Day, the Southern CaliforniaAssociation of Governrnents, and Eco Rapid Transit meetings.
Tliere are two upcoming suini'ner intense bridge programs at East Los Angeles College.
Vice Mayor Hurtado attended the National Day of Prayer. The Vice Mayor requested the City Manager to set up a meeting with South Gate Youth Football to discuss and bring before the City Council to consider options. Vice Mayor Hurtado spoke about the JAA and the way the snack bar operates.
Mayor Avalos attended the autism event hosted by the Police Department, the National Day of Prayer, the Food Truck Event at the Park, the LAUSD Meeting that was held in the Girl's Clubhouse discussing district resources and a HUB Cities meeting to discuss the opening of their offices.
CONSF.NTCALENDAR Agenda Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14 were approved by motion of Council Member Rios and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Davila, yes (recused for Item 6); Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes (recused for Items 1 and 8); Mayor Avalos, yes. 1 STREF,TS/Sn)EWALKS/
LANDSCAPING The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-25-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California declaring an emergency still exists and authorizing repair, replacement or maintenance activities of public facilities related to the Urban Orchard, City Project No. 539-PRK, without public bidding, pursuant to the emergency contracting procedures of the South Gate Municipal Code and the California Public Contract Code during consent calendar.
815
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
2 PERSONNEL
3 PERSONNEL
4 PERSONNF,L
5 PERSONNEL
The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-26-CC CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California giving notice of the City's intention to approve an amendment to the contract between the City and the Board of Administration of the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) to provide employee cost sliaring of 1% for local miscellaneous members in the South Gate Municipal Employees Association, South Gate Professional MidManagement Association, and South Gate Division Management Association, and 1% for classic local police members in the South Gate Police Officers Association begiru'iing Fiscal Year 2023-24 during consent calendar.
The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-27-CC CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California amending Resolution No. 6454 (Salary Resolution and Position Classification Plan) approving the retitling of the General Maintenance Lead classification to Facilities Maintenance Lead Technician and respective job classification specification, and updating the salaiy pay table during consent calendar.
The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-28-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California amending Resolution No. 6454 (Salary Resolution and Position Classification Plan) to approve the amended job classification specification for the Principal Civil Engineer classification during consent calendar.
The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-29-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California amending Resolution No. 6454 (Salary Resolution and Position Classification Plan) approving the retitling of the Deputy Director of Administrative Services/Human Resources & Risk Management to Deputy Director of Human Resources and approving the update to the job classification specification and salary pay table during consent calendar.
816
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
6 TWEEDY MILE/COMMERCIAL
ASSESSMENT The City Council approved A and B during Consent Calendar. a. The Tweedy Mile Advisory Board's Annual Report for
Fiscal Year 2023/24; and
b. Resolution No. 2023-30-CC entitled Resolution of tlie City's Council of the City of South Gate, California declaring the City's intention to levy and collect assessments for Fiscal Year 2023/24 for the Parking and Business Improvement Area (known as the Tweedy Mile Business District) Business License and scheduling a Public Hearing for June 13, 2023.
WASTEWATERMGMT TheCityCouncilapprovedAandBduringConsentCalendar. a. Received and filed the 2023 Sewer System Management Plan dated January 30, 2023, and a presentation; and
b. Resolution No. 2023-31-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California to certify the 2023 Sewer System Management Plan as required by tlie State Water Resources Control Board in their "Statewide General Waste Discharge Requirements for Sanitary Sewer Systems, Order No. 2006-0003-DWQ as amended by "WQ 2013-0058-EXEC".
STREETS The City Council approved Resolution No. 2023-32-CC entitled Resolution of the City Council of the City of South Gate, California to approve entering into a Cooperative Agreement 2023-72-CC with Caltrans as an initial step for the City to receive $5 million in grant funds for the construction of the Urban Orchard Project during Consent Calendar.
STREETS The City Council approved A and B during Consent Calendar. a. Amendment No. 2 to Contract No. 2020-10-CC with Tetra Tech to provide additional design services in the amount of $97,461 and extending the term of the contract tmough June 30, 2024, retroactively effective beginning January 1, 2023, to provide construction support services on the GarfieldAvenue Complete Street Improvement Project, City Project No. 564-ST; and b. Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 2 in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
817
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
PARKS
11 PARKING &
TRAFFIC
CD/HOUSING
The City Council approved A and B during Consent Calendar.
Amendment No. 1 to Contract No. 2022-82-AC with David Volz Design Landscape Architect, Inc., to provide additional construction support services for the construction of the Hollydale Community Park Renovation, City Project No. 607-PRK, at a cost not to exceed $41,298, and extending the contract term through December 31, 2023; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute Amendment No. 1 in a forin acceptable to the CityAttorney.
The City Council approved A, B and C during Consent Calendar.
Agreement (Contract No. 2023-60-CC) witli KOA Corporation to prepare design and construction documents for the Traffic Improvements at Intersections along CaliforniaAve and Southei'n Ave, City Project No. 681-ST, in an amount not to exceed $197,647;
Appropriated $53,000 in the Highway Safety Improvement
Program funds and $14,000 in the Road Mitigation Funds to fund the proposed Agreement and staff time for the Traffic
Improvements at Intersections along CaliforniaAve and Southern Ave, City Project No. 681-ST; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
The City Council approved A, B and C during Consent Calendar.
Agreement (ContractNo. 2023-61-CC) with Craig
Communications to provide cornrnunity engagement services in the amount not to exceed $52,810 for a two-year and six-month term;
Appropriated $52,810 from the US EPA 2023 Cornmunitywide Brownfields Assessment Grant; and
Authorized the Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
818
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
13 DATA PROCESSING
SERVICES The City Council approved A, and B during Consent Calendar. a. Approved a firewall license renewal with NUMA Networks for a one-year teim in the ainount of $58,615; and
b. Authorized the issuance of a Purchase Order to NUMANetworks for the license renewal.
14 PURCHASING The City Council approved A, and B during Consent Calendar.:
a. Authorized the purchase of a 2024 Ford F-750 Gas Regular Cab Boomtruck from Nixon-Egli Equipment Co., through the
Sourcewell Co-Opt Purchasing Program, in an amount not-toexceed $358,322, for the Electrical Division and appropriating $55,967 in Capital Asset & Equipment Replacement Funds to fully fund the purchase; and
b. Authorized the City Manager to execute the documents necessary to purchase the Boomtruck in forms acceptable to the City Attorney.
DEVIATE FROM
THE AGENDA At this time, there being no objections, Mayor Avalos stated that item 16 would be considered out of its regular agenda order.
16 WARRANTS The City Council approved the Warrant Register for May 9, 2023 by motion of Council Member Davila and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Davila, yes; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, yes; Mayor Avalos, yes
Total of Checks:
Less: Voids
Less: Employee Payroll Deductions
Grand Total:
$1,603,389.99
$ (14,557.54)
$ (368,193.69)
$1,220,638.76
Cancellations: 94565, 96134, 96548, 97786, 97822, 97927, 97934, 98150, 98322, 100468, 100928
EXCUSED FROM
MEETING At 8:41 p.m. Vice Mayor Hurtado was excused from the meeting and departed from the Council Chambers.
819
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 9, 2023
15 SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT The City Council received and filed a presentation from Universal Waste Systems (UWS) on the transition of residential and commercial solid waste, recycling and organics recycling collection services by motion of Council Member Barron and seconded by Mayor Avalos.
ROLL CALL: Council Member Davila, absent; Council Member Barron, yes; Council Member Rios, yes; Vice Mayor Hurtado, absent; Mayor Avalos, yes.
EXCUSED FROM
MEETING At 9:09 p.m. Council Member Davila was excused from the meeting and departed from the Council Chambers.
ADJOURNMENT Mayor Avalos adjourned the meeting in memory of Jeremiah Aviles, son of former Street Forman Omar Aviles, and Patricia Glaze, mother-in-law of City Clerk Yodit Glaze at 9:41 p.m.
PASSED and APPROVED this 'h day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
820
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, MAY 16, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Maria del PilarAvalos, Mayor called a Special City Council Meeting to order at 5:34 p.m.
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Mayor Maria del PilarAvalos, Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Joshua Barron, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Treasurer Jose De La Paz, City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina
CLOSED SESSION The Council Members recessed into Closed Session at 5:39 p.m. and reconvened at 8:38 p.m. with all Members of Council present. City Attorney Salinas reported the following:
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - ANTICIPATED
LITIGATION
Pursuant to Governi'nent Code Section 54956.9(d)(4)
One (1) - Potential Case
On item 1, the City Council received a presentation and upon completion of that presentation there was no reportable action taken.
2. CONSIDER THE EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF A
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
Pursuant to Governi'nent Code Section 54957(b)(1)
a. City Manager
On item 2(a), the City Council received a presentation and upon completion of that presentation there was no reportable action taken.
ADJOURNMENT Council Member Davila unanimously adjourned the meeting at 8:41 p.m. and seconded by Vice Mayor Hurtado.
PASSED and APPROVED this day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
57 821
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, MAY 23, 2023
CALL TO ORDER Gil Hurtado, Vice Mayor called a Special City Council Meeting to order at 5:21 p.m.
ROLL CALL Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
PRESENT Vice Mayor Gil Hurtado, Council Member Maria Davila, and Council Member Al Rios; City Manager Chris Jeffers, City Attorney Raul F. Salina LATE Council Member Joshua Barron arrived at the dais at 5:40 p.m.
ABSENT Mayor Maria del Pilar Avalos and City Treasurer Jose De La Paz l
PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation honoring one of South Gate's own for accomplishi'nents made in the field of Sociology and achieving the status of a Tenured Professor.
2 CERTIFICATES The City Council issued Certificates of Appreciations in recognition of the South Gate High School Girls Cheer Team winning the 2023 CIF Championship.
3 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring May 29, 2023, as Memorial Day.
4 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring June 2023, as LGBTQ+ Pride Month.
5 PROCLAMATIONS The City Council issued a Proclamation declaring June 2023, as National Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Month.
6 PERSONNEL RECRUITMENT
& SELECTION The City Council received and filled the list of new and promoted fulltime employees hired or promoted during April 2023. 58 822
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 23, 2023
CLOSED SESSION The Council Members recessed into Closed Session at 6:20 p.m. and reconvened at 6:56 p.m. with four (4) Members of Council present. Mayor Avalos was absent. City Attorney Salinas reported the following:
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUISTSEL - PENDING
LITIGATION
Pursuant to Governi'nent Code Section 54956.9(a),
54954.9(b)(3)(C)
a. Jirni'ny Torres and Susana M. Corcios v. City of South Gate, et al.
Item 1(a) is a car v. car lawsuit involving one of the city's employees.
There was a motion made by Council Member Davila and seconded by Council Member Barron and on vote of 4-0, the City Council authorized the City Attorney to defend the action.
2. CONSIDER THE EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF A
PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957(b)(1)
a. City Manager
On item 2(a), the City Council received a presentation from an outside consultant and upon completion of that presentation, guidance was given with respect to the City Manager and there was no further action taken in closed session.
ADJOURNMENT Council Member Davila adjourned the meeting at 6:58 p.m. and seconded by Council Member Barron.
PASSED and APPROVED this day of 2023.
ATTEST:
Maria del PilarAvalos, Mayor Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
823
CITVMANAGE'R'S OFF/CE
JUN2 1 2023
lO:o@A-w' Cil of South Gate
Item No. 18
CITY COUNCIL
AG-E,NDA JBI[LL
Department Director:
For th
Ori
ar Meeting of: June 27, 2023
Department: Public Works
City Manager:
effers
SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF ALTERNATIVE N0. 2 RATE LEVEL
ADJUSTMENT FROM THE SEWER RATE STUDY REPORT AND AGREEMENT WITH NBS FINANCIAL GROUP FOR SUPPORT SERVICES FOR PROP 218
PROCESS
PURPOSE: To select an alternative from the Sewer Rate Study to propose changes to the Sewer Rate Stnicture and undertake the required Proposition 218 process. An agreement with NBS Financial Group is recommended to provide support services for the Prop 218 process and public outreach.
RECOMMENDED ACTIONS: The City Council will consider:
a. Receiving and filing the Sewer Rate Study Report;
b. Selecting Alternative No. 2 of the Sewer Rate Study for the proposed sewer rate structure changes and directing staff to initiate the Proposition 218 process; c. Approving an Agreement with NBS Financial Group (NBS) in an amount not to exceed $32,500 to conduct the required Proposition 218 process, including educational material development; and
d. Authorizing tlie Mayor to execute the Agreement in a form acceptable to the City Attorney.
FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact to the General Fund. The costs associated with Proposition 218 process, including the proposed agreement with NBS is in the amount of $32,500 which will be 'funded with Sewer Funds budgeted in the Fiscal Year 2023/24 0perating Budget.
The sewer operations are classified as an Enterprise Fund, which usually requires such business operations to be fully supported by charges to customers of the service. Currently, the rate structure for the Sewer Fund generates approximately $1.17 million, aru'iually. The total costs for the Sewer Fund, annually, are about $2 million, with other funds (including the General Fund) subsidizing those costs. In addition, the current rate structure does riot allow for the funding of major capital improvement projects which would fall upon the General Fund to provide funding.
Revenue for the Sewer Fund is generated by a sanitary sewer service charge that appears on the monthly utility bills. The existing sewer rate is currently $0.35 per hundred cubic feet based on 1 824
70% of the total water consumed, which generates an annual revenue of approximately $1.17 million.
ANALYSIS: The Sewer Fund has been operating in an annual deficit which is subsidized by the General Fund. For the Fiscal Year 2021/22, the Sewer Fund received approximately $768,000 in subsidy from both the General Fund and Water Funds to cover expenses. Over the next five years, tlie fund balance deficit is expected to increase to approximately $2.08 million based on the current rates. The 5-Year Financial Forecast for the Sewer Fund, as currently structured, is summarized in Table 4 at the end of this report.
A Sewer Rate Study was prepared to assess the Sewer Fund and identify three feasible alternatives for changing the sewer rate structure and increasing the sewer rate to eliminate the deficit and General Fund subsidy. On March 28, 2023, the City Council was presented with the three alternatives. Based on input, there was consensus that it was necessary to further consider proceeding with the proposed sewer rate structure changes and with Alternative No. 2.
Each alternative proposes to increase rates as well as change the billing structure. The current billing structure is based on a variable rate that consists of a set sewer rate ($0.35) for all property types multiplied by the customer's water usage (Sewer Bill = Sewer Rate x Water Usage). The less water used, the lower the sewer bill is for a customer. The current rate was established in 2010 and has not been adjusted since that time.
The recoinmended proposed rate structure includes a fixed rate plus variable rate [Sewer Bill = Fixed Rate + (Sewer Rate x Water Usage)]. As proposed, the continuation of the variable rate allows residents to control their bill based on actual usage. The fixed rate provides revenue needed for the City's fixed operating cost which remains the same regardless of water usage.
Staff is recommending selecting Alternative No. 2, shown on Table 2 below. Alternative No. 2 proposes a rate increase of 100% in Fiscal Year 2022/23, and a 10%, 10%, 5% and 2% rate increase in Years 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively. A typical residential property monthly bill would increase from $3.50 to $6.49 in the first fiscal year and then up to $8.58 over a 5- year period. While this alternative provides the largest rate increase in the first year, it results in the lowest overall rate increase to $8.58 over the 5-Year period as compared to $10.08 and $8.61 for Alternatives Nos. 1 and 3 shown on Tables 2 and 3, respectively at the end of this report. The impact of the rate increase to commercial properties would depend on their water consumption.
Alternative No. 2 (Table 2)
Classification
Existing
Sewer
Rate
Proposed Sewer Rate Increases and Rates
FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
100% 10% 10% 5% 2%
Single Family Residential Properties (Fixed + Variable Usagi=) Fixed $3.29 $3.62 $3.99 $4.19 $4.28
Variable $0.35 $0.32 $0.36 $0.40 $0.42 $0.43
Sample Billing* $3.50 $6.49 $7.22 $7.99 $8.35 I $8i58
2 825
Non-Single Family Residential Properties (Variable Usage) Multifamily Residential $0.35 $0.74 $0.82 $0.91 $0.96 $0.98 Commercial $0.35 $0.74 $0.82 $0.91 $0.96 $0.98
Industrial $0.35 $0.83 $0.92 $1.02 $1.08 $1.11
Other $0.35 $0.83 $0.92 $1.02 $1.08 $1.11
The City conducted a brief rate comparison with eight cities which include the cities of Long Beach, Norwalk, Lynwood, Whittier, and other cities in LA County. The City's current sewer rate was the lowest. Further, with the recommended Alternative No. 2, the proposed sewer rate increase will result in the City's rates still being the lowest at the beginning of implementation.
At the end of five years of rate increases, the City's sewer rate would be the third lowest of the cities surveyed, even presuming that no other surveyed city would raise their rates over the next five years, which is unlikely.
In suininary, the sewer rate study identifies an estimated deficit in the Sewer Fund starting at $1.02 million this fiscal year and increasing to $2.08 million in Fiscal Year 2026/27. Due to the deficit, the City does not have sufficient Sewer Funds for priority needs such as for a reserve fund, fully funding operations and funding capital projects. The study presented three alternatives to restructure and increase the sewer rate. The general consensus was that the City should consider proceeding with a proposal to change and increase the sewer rate structure. The City Council directed the City Manager to begin finalizing the sewer rate study and to further consider initiating the Prop 218 process to change the sewer rate structure and increase rates.
Proposition 218
At this time, the City Council is not being requested to approve changing the sewer rate structure and adjusting rates. Staff is recommending that the City Council take action to proceed with the proposal for changes to the sewer rate structure through the Proposition 218 process. The process includes Selecting Alternative No. 2 of the Sewer Rate Study for the proposed changes to the sewer rate structure and rate adjustments; awarding an agreement for consultant services; and receiving and filing the Sewer Rate Study Report.
Implementing a rate adjustment requires approval through the Proposition 218 process. In order to increase the sewer fee rate, the City must engage in a process mandated by the California State Constitution. In 1996 voters adopted Proposition 218, which added Articles XIII C and XIII D to the State Constitution. Those new Articles say that most propertyrelated fees constitute taxes, which may not be created or increased without certain public approvals. Although sewer fees fund a critical health service, sewer fees cannot be raised if a majority of the property owners served by the sewer system object. In order for a local government to increase a sewer fee, it must follow these procedures established by Proposition 218:
1. A public hearing before the City Council must be scheduled. At least 45 days prior to the public hearing, the City must mail a notice to the record owner of each parcel of real property served by the sewer system and affected by the proposed fee increase.
The notice must specify the proposed fee increase, the total amount chargeable to all of the parcels, the amount chargeable to the owner's particular parcel, the duration of the fee increase, tlie reason for the fee increase, the basis upon which the amount of 3 826
the proposed fee increase was calculated, and tlie time, date and location of the public hearing on the proposed fee increase. The notice must also contain a ballot on which the property owner may indicate his or her name, identify the owner's parcel, and indicate the owner's support or opposition to the proposed fee increase. The notice must include, in a conspicuous place, a summary of the procedures applicable to the completion, return, and tabulation of the ballots, including a disclosure statement that the existence of a majority protest will result in the fee increase not being imposed.
2. At the Public Hearing, the City Council shall consider all protests against the proposed fee increase and tabulate the ballots. The City may not impose the fee increase if there is a majority protest. A majority protest exists if, upon the conclusion of the hearing, ballots submitted in opposition to the fee increase exceed the ballots submitted in favor of the fee increase. In tabulating the ballots, the ballots shall be weighted according to the proportional financial obligation of the affected property.
3. If a majority protest does not exist, the legislative body may then approve and adopt the rate increase by resolution. It is important to note that only ballots/statements cast by the property owner or legal representative are valid.
To proceed with the proposed rate structure changes, staff will need consultant services. The City Manager's Office received two proposals to provide assistance to comply with the Proposition 218 process including the required community outreach.
Consultant Fee Proposal
Harris and Associates $16,000
NBS Financial Group $32,500
A selection coinmittee was assembled to interview and rank the consultants, which included the Administrative Services Director and the Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works.
Interviews were conducted on May 24'h to allow each fin'n to present their proposed methodology for community outreach and engagement and present their la'iowledge of compliance requirements. While both firms are able to guide and consult the City on Prop 218 compliance, NBS was ranked higher for their community engagement.
NBS's and Harris' proposals varied noticeably with NBS offering Prop 218 support services and an extensive public outreach program. Harris' proposal mainly includes Prop 218 support services and minimal outreach, thus, the difference in fees. It is recommended to proceed with NBS since the outreach services will be essential to educate residents of the need for a rate increase. NBS proposes to use its proprietary software CivicMic to engage and inform the community regarding the proposed increase. Additionally, NBS proposes to have multilingual workshops to address any residents and business concerns.
Based on the legal requirements under the state constitution, should the City Council decide to move forward with seeking approval of the sewer rate adjustment, we would likely be asking the City Council to approve the Resolution of Intent in July whicli would set the Public Hearing in 4 827
September.
BACKGROUND: The City owns and operates a municipal sanitary sewer system which provides services to properties citywide. The sewer system is comprised of nearly 120 miles of sewer mainlines, 19,500 sewer lateral services and 2,400 manholes. The Public Works Department is responsible for the management of the sewer system. The maintenance and operation generally requires daily staffing, equipment, vehicles and contract services.
The sewer system is managed in accordance with the 2006 state requirements which are outlined in the State Water Resources Control Board Order No. 2006-0003-DWQ titled Statewide General Waste Discharge Requirements for Sanitary Sewer Systems (State Order). The State Order standardizes the requirements to facilitate proper funding and management of sanitary sewer systems, by requiring a system-specific Sewer System Management Plan (SSMP). SSMPs must include provisions to provide proper and efficient management, operation, and maintenance of sanitary sewer systems, while taking into consideration risk management and cost benefit analysis. In Section 9 of "D. Provision," the State Order stipulates "The Emollee shall allocate adequate resources for the operation, maintenance, and repair of its sanitary sewer system, by establishing a proper rate structure, accounting mechanisms, and auditing procedures to ensure an adequate measure of revenues and expenditures."
The condition of the sewer system was evaluated in the 2019 Sewer Master Plan (Master Plan).
The Master Plan is a comprehensive capital needs assessment of the sanitary sewer system. The plan identified several priority projects such as repairs to prevent sewage spills. It identified $3.5 Million in funds needed to repair and upgrade the existing sewer system, which are now estimated at over $4 Million. However, the City has received ARPA funds of which $600,000 are programmed for sewer improvements in FY 2022/23. It is the intent of staff to allocate more ARPA funds toward sewer projects over the next 18-months if they can be designed and bid with the timelines stipulated in the federal regulations. Initial estimates are between $1.5 Million to $2.0 Million. Using these funds is assisting in lowering the rate increase needed to ensure the sewer infrastructure remains intact.
The City established the sewer enterprise fund to address costs due to the maintenance and improvement of the sewer system. Since 1965 the City has collected fees from residents based on water consumption to contribute to the maintenance and operation of the City's sewer system.
The City is required to provide the current sewer system service and maintain its continued operation throughout the City. The sewer fund obtains its revenue based on a $0.35 charge per 100 cubic feet of water or 748 gallons used by residents, businesses and industry. The last modification to the City's rate was conducted in 2010.
There are three alternative scenarios in the Sewer Rate Study. Each alternative proposes to increase rates as well as change the billing structure. The current billing structure is a flat sewer rate to all property types based on the usage of water (Variable Rate). The proposed rate structure includes a Fixed Rate plus Variable Rate. The Variable Rate proposed allows for residents to control their bill based on actual usage. The Fixed Rate provides revenue needed for the City's fixed operating cost which remain the same regardless of water usage. The proposed billing structure allows for the variable rate charged to be less while still securing an equitable contribution to the Sewer Fund to fully fund the City's needs. 5 828
The rate increase is proposed to meet the needs of the sewer program over the next five years.
The rates would provide for eliminating the projected operations and maintenance deficits previously shown in the 5-year projection.
The three alternatives are surni'narized in Tables 1, 2 and 3. It should be noted that the impact on all users will vary depending on their water consumption but single-family households will also have a fixed fee.
Alternative No. I (Table l)
Classification
Existing
Sewer Rate
Proposed Sewer Rate Increases and Rates
FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
50% 30% 30% 10% 8%
Single Family Residential Properties (Ftied + Variable Usage) Fixed $2.47 $3.22 $4.19 $4.61 $4.98
Variable $0.35 $0.24 $0.32 $0.42 $0.47 $0.51
Sample Billing* $3.50 $4.87 $6.42 $8.39 $9.31 $10.08
Non-Single Family Residential Properties (Variable Usage) Multifamily Residential $0.35 $0.55 $0.72 $0.94 $1.04 $1.13 Commercial $0.35 $0.55 $0.72 $0.94 $1.04 $1.04
Industrial $0.35 $0.62 $0.81 $1.06 $1.17 $1.27
Other $0.35 $0.62 $0.81 $1.06 $1.17 $1.27
Alternative No. 2 (Table 2)
Classification
Existing
Sewer
Rate
Proposed Sewer Rate Increases and Rates
FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
100% 10% 10% 5% 2%
Single Family Residential Properties (Fixed + Variable Usagi=) Fixed $3.29 $3.62 $3.99 $4.19 $4.28
Variable $0.35 $0.32 $0.36 $0.40 $0.42 $0.43
Sample Billing* $3.50 $6.49 $7.22 $7.99 $8.35 i $8i58
Non-Single Family Residential Properties (Variatile Usage) Multifamily Residential $0.35 $0.74 $0.82 $0.91 $0.96 $0.98 Commercial $0.35 $0.74 $0.82 $0.91 $0.96 $0.98
Industrial $0.35 $0.83 $0.92 $1.02 $1.08 $1.11
Other $0.35 $0.83 $0.92 $1.02 $1.08 $1.11
Alternative No. 3 (Table 3)
Classification
Existing
Sewer Rate
Proposed Sewer Rate Increa.ses and Rates
FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
75% 30% 10% 2% 2%
Single Family Residential P roperties (Fixed + Variable Usage) Fixed $2.88 $3.75 $4.13 $4.22 $4.31
Variable $0.35 $0.28 $0.37 $0.41 $0.42 $0.43
Sample Billing* $3.50 $5.68 $7.45 $8.23 $8.60 I $8.61
Non-Single Family Residential Properties (Variable Usage) MultifamilyResidential i $0.35 i $0.64 iI $0.84 I $0.93 I $0.95 I $0.97 6 829
Commercial $0.35 $0.64 $0.84 $0.93 $0.95 $0.97
Industrial $0.35 $0.72 $0.94 $1.04 $1.07 $1.10
Other $0.35 $0.72 $0.94 $1.04 $1.07 $1.10
* Billing assumes 10 HCF (Hundred Cubic Feet) which is an average for single family residence in South Gate. 5-Year Financial Forecast for Sewer Fund Without Rate Increases (Table 4) l FY2021/22 I FY2022/23 I FY2023/24 I FY2024/25 I FY2025/26 I FY2026/27 Ann-ial Revenue
Existing Rate Revenue $1,171,006 $1,171,006 $1,171,006 $1,171,006 $1,171,006 $1,171,006 Other Revenue $14,925 $14,954 $14,983 $15,012 $15,042 $15,073 Total Revenue $1,185,931 $1,185,960 $1,185,989 $1,186,018 $1,186,048 $1,186,079 Annua Expenditures
Employee Services $413,126 $492,936 $510,723 $529,192 $548,374 $568,296 Supplies and Services $790,590 $781,858 $821,009 $862,124 $888,086 $914,838 Debt $0 $337,779 $337,808 $713,969 $713,938 $714,096
Vehicle Replacement $200,000 $41,200 $98,133 $661,100 $674,958 $520,366 Depreciation Expense* $550,000 $550,000 $550,000 $550,000 $550,000 $550,000 Capital Outlay
Funding not available for planned capital projects, emergency projects or funding reserves.
Reserves
TotalExpenditures l $1,953,716 l $2,203,773 l $2,317,673 l $3,316,385 l $3,375,356 l $3,267,596 Pro,iectedDef'icit l ($767,785)l ($1,017813)l ($1,131,684)l ($2,130,367)l ($2,189,308)l ($2,081,517) *Depreciation eXpenSeS is an account process to identify the appropriate funding to be set aside for reinvestment in the capital infrastructure to ensure it maintains its full usefulness.
ATTACHMENTS: A. Proposed Agreement with NBS Financial Group.
B. NBS Financial Group Proposal
C. Harris Proposal
D, Final Sewer Rate Study
E. Sewer Study Presentation
IB:lc
830
Attachment A
AGREEMENT FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES FOR COMMUNITY
OUTREACH AND PROPOSITION 218 CONSULTING SERVICES
BETWEEN THE CITY OF SOUTH GATE AND NBS GOVERNMENT
FINANCE GROUP
This Agreement for Professional Services for Comt'nunity Outreach and Proposition 218 Consulting Services ("Agreement") is made and entered into on June 27, 2023, by and between the City of South Gate, a municipal corporation ("City"), and NBS Governrnent Finance Group dba NBS, a California corporation ("Consultant"). City and Consultant are sometimes hereinafter individually referred to as a"Party" and collectively as "Parties."
RECIT ALS
WHEREAS, City desires to retain a qualified provider for certain services relating to community outreach and consulting services to comply with Proposition 218 as it relates to sewer rate increases;
WHEREAS, Consultant warrants to City that it has the requisite skills, knowledge, qualifications, manpower and expertise to perform properly and timely the Professional Services under this Agreement; and
WHEREAS, based on such representation, City desires to contract with Consultant to perform the services as described in the Scope of Services attached hereto as Exhibit "A" of this Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, the Parties hereby agree as follows:
1. SCOPE OF SERVICES. City hereby engages Consultant, and Consultant accepts such engagement, to perform the services set forth in the Scope of Services as described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made part of this Agreement. The Scope of Services may be mutually amended from time to time by both Parties in writing.
2. COMPENSATION FOR SERVICES. The total amount of compensation for this Agreement shall not exceed the sum of Thirty-Two Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($32,500) as described in Consultant's proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "A." City shall pay Consultant for its professional services rendered and costs incurred pursuant to this Agreement. No additional compensation shall be paid for any other expenses incurred, unless first approved in writing by the City Manager or his/her designee.
2.1 Consultant shall be required to attend meetings at City Hall as necessary in the delivery of the projects. Travel time between Consultant's office and City Hall shall not be billable. Consultant may request an exemption on a case-by-case basis, which shall be subject to City approval.
2.2 Consultant shall be paid in accordance with the schedule included in Consultant's proposal attached hereto as Exhibit "A." City shall pay Consultant within thirty (30) 5116863.1-L235.0 (Fonn Rev. 9/8/21)
831
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
days of receipt of the invoice.
2.3 No payment made hereunder by City to Consultant, other than the final payment, shall be construed as an acceptance by City of any work or materials, nor as evidence of satisfactory perfornnance by Consultant of its obligations under this Agreement.
3. TERM OF AGREEMENT. This Agreement is effective as of July 1, 2023, and will remain in effect for a period of one year from said date or until project completion, unless otherwise expressly extended and agreed to by both Parties in writing, or teri'ninated by either Party as provided herein.
4. CITY AGENT. The Director of Public Works ("Director"), or his/her designee, for the purposes of this Agreement, is the agent for the City. Whenever approval or authorization is required, Consultant understands that the Director, or his/her designee, has the authority to provide that approval or authorization.
5. CONFLICT OF INTEREST. Consultant represents that it presently has no interest and shall not acquire any interest, direct or indirect, in any real property located in the City which may be affected by the services to be performed by Consultant under this Agreement.
Consultant further represents that in performance of this Agreement, no person having any such interest shall be employed by it. Within ten (10) days, Consultant agrees that it will immediately notify City of any other conflict of interest that may exist or develop during the term of this Agreement.
5.I Consultant represents that no City employee or official has a material financial interest in Consultant's business. During the term of this Agreement and/or as a result of being awarded this contract, Consultant shall not offer, encourage or accept any financial interest in Consultant's business or in this Agreement by any City employee or official.
6. GENERAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS.
6.1 Termination for Convenience. City may terminate this Agreement at any time without cause by giving fifteen (15) days written notice to Consultant of such teri'nination and specifying the effective date thereof. In that event, all finished or unfinished documents and other materials shall, at the option of City, become its property. If this Agreement is ternninated by City as provided herein, Consultant will be paid the total amount of its costs as of the termination date. In no event shall the amount payable upon ten'nination exceed the total maximum compensation provided for in this Agreement.
6.2 Termination for Cause.
6.2.I City may, by written notice to Consultant, terminate the whole or any part of this Agreement in any of the following circumstances:
832
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
a. If Consultant fails to perfori'n the services required by this Agreement within the time specified herein or any authorized extension thereof, or b. If Consultant fails to perfori'n the services called for by this Agreement or so fails to make progress as to endanger performance of this Agreement in accordance with its terms, and in either of these circumstances does not correct such failure withing a period of ten (10) days (or such longer period as City may authorize in writing) after receipt of notice from City specifying such failure.
6.2.2 In the event City teri'ninates this Agreement in whole or in part as provided above in Subsection 6.2.1, City may procure, upon such terms and in such manner as it may deem appropriate, services similar to those terminated.
6.2.3 If this Agreement is terminated as provided above in Subsection 6.2.1, City may require Consultant to provide all finished or unfinished documents, data, studies, drawings, maps, photographs, reports, films, charts, sketches, computations, surveys, models, or other similar documentation prepared by Consultant. Upon such termination, Consultant shall be paid an amount equal to the value of the work performed. In ascertaining the value of the work performed up to the date of termination, consideration shall be given to both completed work and work in progress, to complete and incomplete drawings, and to other documents whether delivered to City or in possession of Consultant, and to authorized reimbursement expenses.
6.2.4 If, after notice of termination of the Agreement under the provisions of Subsection 6.2.1 above, it is determined, for any reason, that Consultant was not in default, or that the default was excusable, then the rights and obligations of the Parties shall be the same as if the notice of termination had been issued pursuant to Subsection 6.1. above.
6.3 Non-Assignability. Consultant shall not assign or transfer any interest in this Agreement without the express prior written consent of City.
6.4 Non-Discrimination.
6.4.1 Consultant shall not discriminate against any employee, subcontractor, or applicant for employment because of race, creed, gender, gender identity (including gender expression), color, religion, ancestry, sexual orientation, national origin, disability, age, marital status, family/parental status, or veteran/military status, in the performance of its services and duties pursuant to this Agreement and will comply with all applicable laws, ordinances and codes of the Federal, State, and County and the City governments. Consultant will take affirmative action to ensure that subcontractors and applicants are /O833
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
employed, and that employees are treated during employment without regard to their race, color, religion, ancestry, sex, national origin, disability, or age.
Consultant will take affirmative action to ensure that all employment practices, including those of any subcontractors retained by Consultant to perform services under this Agreement, are free from such discrimination. Such employment practices include, but are limited to: hiring, upgrading, demotion, transfer, recruitment, recruitment advertising, layoff, termination, rates of pay or other fortns of compensation, and selection for training, including apprenticeship.
6.4.2 The provisions of Subsection 6.4.1 above shall be included in all solicitations or advertisements placed by or on behalf of Consultant for personnel to perfon'n any services under this Agreement. City shall have access to all documents, data, and records of Consultant and its subcontractors for purposes of determining compliance with the equal employment opportunity and nondiscrimination provisions of this Section, and all applicable provisions of Executive Order No. 11246 (relating to federal restrictions against discriminatory practices) is available for review and on file with the City Clerk's Office.
6.5 Insurance. Consultant shall submit to City, certificates indicating compliance with the following minimum insurance requirements no less than one (l) day prior to beginning of performance under this Agreement:
6.5.1 Workers Compensation Insurance as required by law. Consultant shall require all subcontractors similarly to provide such workers' compensation insurance for their respective employees.
6.5.2 Comprehensive general and automobile liability insurance protecting Consultant in amounts not less than $1,000,000 for personal injury to any one person, $1,000,000 for injuries arising out of one occurrence, and $500,000 for property damages or a combined single limit of $1,000,000, with an aggregate of $2,000,000. Each such policy of insurance shall:
a. Be issued by a financially responsible insurance company or companies admitted and authorized to do business in the State of California or which is approved in writing by City.
b. Name and list as additional insured the City, its officers and employees. c. 8pecify its acts as primary insurance.
d. Contain a clause substantially in the following words: "It is hereby understood and agreed that this policy shall not be canceled except upon 834
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
thirty (30) days prior written notice to City of such cancellation or material change."
e. Cover the operations of Consultant pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
6.6 Indemnification. Consultant agrees to indeinnify, defend and hold harmless City and/or any other City agency, including other employees, officers and representatives, for/from any and all claims or actions of any kind asserted against City and/or any other City agency arising out of Consultant's (including Consultant's employees, representatives, products and subcontractors) negligent performance under this Agreement, excepting only such claims or actions which may arise out of sole or active negligence of City and/or any other City agency, or any third parties not acting on behalf of, at the direction of, or under the control of Consultant.
6.7 Compliance with Applicable Law. Consultant and City shall comply with all applicable laws, ordinances, and codes of the Federal, State, County and City governrnents, without regard to conflict of law principles.
6.8 Independent Contractor. This Agreement is by and between City and Consultant and is not intended, nor shall it be construed, to create the relationship of agency, servant, employee, partnership, joint venhire, or association, as between City and Consultant.
6.8.1 Consultant shall be an independent contractor and shall have no power to incur any debt or obligation for or on behalf of City. Neither City nor any of its officers or employees shall have any control over the conduct of Consultant, or any of Consultant's employees, except as herein set forth, and Consultant expressly warrants not to, at any time or in any manner, represent that it, or any of its agents, servants or employees are in any manner employees of City, it being distinctly understood that Consultant is and shall at all times remain to City a wholly independent contractor and Consultant's obligations to City are solely such as are prescribed by this Agreement.
6.8.2 Indemnification of CalPERS Deterinination - In the event that Consultant or any employee, agent, or subcontractor of Consultant providing services under this Agreement claims or is determined by a court of competent jurisdiction or CalPERS to be eligible for enrollment in CalPERS as an employee of City, Consultant shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless City for the payment of any employee and/or employer contributions for CalPERS benefits on behalf of Consultant or its employees, agents, or subcontractors, as well as, for the payment of any penalties and interest on such contributions which would otherwise be the responsibility of City.
6.8.3 Business License Required. According to Title 2.08.40 of the South Gate 835
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
Municipal Code, a business license will be required prior to doing business within the City, even if the business is located outside of the City. Verification of a valid South Gate business license will be required prior to start of work and any fees associated with the acquisition or maintenance of such business license shall be the sole responsibility of Consultant.
6.9 Consultant's Personnel.
6.9.1 All services required under the Agreement will be performed by Consultant, or under Consultant's direct supervision, and all personnel shall possess the qualifications, permits and licenses required by State and local law to perform such services, including, without limitation, a City of South Gate business license as required by the South Gate Municipal Code.
6.9.2 Consultant shall be solely responsible for the satisfactory work performance of all personnel engaged in performing services required by this Agreement, and compliance with all reasonable performance standards established by City.
6.9.3 Consultant shall be responsible for payment of all employees' and subcontractors' wages and benefits and shall comply with all requirements pertaining to employer's liability, workers' compensation, unemployment insurance and Social Security.
6.9.4 Consultant shall indemnify and hold harmless City and all other related entities, officers, employees and representatives from any liability, damages, claims, costs, and expenses of any nature arising from alleged violations of personnel practices or of any acts of omissions by Consultant in connection with the work perfon'ned arising from this Agreement.
6.10 Copyright. No reports, maps or other documents produced in whole or in part under this Agreement shall be the subject of an application for copyright by or on behalf of Consultant.
6.11 Legal Construction.
6.11.1 This Agreement is made and entered into in the State of California and shall in all respects be interpreted, enforced, and governed under the laws of the State of California without regard to conflict of law principles.
6.11.2 This Agreement shall be construed without regard to the identity of the persons who drafted its various provisions. Each and every provision of this Agreement shall be construed as though each of the parties participated equally in the drafting of same, and any rule of construction that a document is to be construed against the drafting party shall not be applicable to this Agreement. 836
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
6.11.3. The article and section, captions and headings herein have been inserted for convenience only and shall not be considered or referred to in resolving questions of interpretation or construction.
6.11.4. Whenever in this Agreement the context may so require, the masculine gender shall be deemed to refer to and include the feminine and neuter, and the singular shall refer to and include the plural.
6.12 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts and, as so executed, shall constitute an agreement which shall be binding upon all Parties hereto.
6.13 Final Payment Acceptance Constitutes Release. The acceptance by Consultant of the final payment made under this Agreement shall operate as and be a release of City from all claims and liabilities for compensation to Consultant for anything done, furnished, or relating to Consultant's work or services. Acceptance of payment shall be any negotiation of City's check or the failure to make a written extra compensation claim within ten (10) calendar days of the receipt of that check. However, approval or payment by City shall not constitute, nor be deemed, a release of the responsibility and liability of Consultant, its employees, sub-consultants and agents for the accuracy and competency of the information provided and/or work performed; nor shall such approval or payment be deemed to be an assumption of such responsibility or liability by City for any defect or error in the work prepared by Consultant, its employees, subconsultants and agents.
6.14 Corrections. In addition to the above indemnification obligations, Consultant shall correct, at its expense, all errors in the work which may be disclosed during City's review of Consultant's report or plans. Should Consultant fail to make such correction in a reasonably, timely manner, such correction shall be made by City, and the cost thereof shall be charged to Consultant.
6.15 Files. All files of Consultant pertaining to City shall be and remain the property of City. Consultant will control the physical location of such files during the teri'n of this Agreement and shall be entitled to retain copies of such files upon termination of this Agreement.
6.16 Waiver; Remedies Cumulative. Failure by a Party to insist upon the performance of any of the provisions of this Agreement by the other party, irrespective of the length of time for which such failure continues, shall not constitute a waiver of such Party's right to demand compliance by such other Party in the future. No waiver by a Party of a default or breach of the other party shall be effective or binding upon such a Party unless made in writing by such Party, and no such waiver shall be implied from any omissions by a Party to take any action with respect to such default or breach. No express written waiver of a specified default or breach shall affect any other default or breach, or cover any other period of time, other than any default or breach and/or period 837
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
of time specified. All of the remedies permitted or available to a Party under this Agreement, or at law or in equity, shall be cumulative and alternative, and invocation of any such right or remedy shall not constitute a waiver or election of remedies with respect to any other pen'nitted or available right of remedy.
6.17 Mitigation of Damages. In all such situations arising out of this Agreement, the Parties shall attempt to avoid and minimize the damages resulting from the conduct of the other Party.
6.18 Severability. If any provision in this Agreement is held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, void, or unenforceable, the remaining provisions will nevertheless continue in full force without being impaired or invalidated in any way.
6.19 Attorneys' Fees. The Parties hereto acknowledge and agree that each will bear his or its own costs, expenses and attorneys' fees arising out of and/or connected with the negotiation, drafting and execution of the Agreement, and all matters arising out of or connected therewith except that, in the event any action is brought by any Party hereto to enforce this Agreement, the prevailing Party in such action shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees and costs in addition to all other relief to which that Party or those Parties may be entitled.
6.20 Entire Agreement and Amendments. This Agreement constitutes the whole agreement between City and Consultant, and neither party has made any representations to the other except as expressly contained herein. Neither party, in executing or performing this Agreement, is relying upon any statement or information not contained in this Agreement. Any amendments, changes or modifications to this Agreement must be made in writing and appropriately executed by both City and Consultant.
6.21 Notices. Any notice required to be given hereunder shall be deemed to have been given by email transmission with confirmation of delivery and depositing said notice in the United States mail, postage prepaid, and addressed as follows:
TO CITY:
City of South Gate
Arturo Cervantes, P.E.
Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works
8650 Califorriia Avenue
South Gate, CA 90280
Email: acervantes@,sogate.org
TEL. (323) 563-9500
WITH COURTESY COPY TO:
City Clerk's Office
Yodit Glaze
City Clerk
8650 California Avenue
South Gate, CA 90280
Email: yzlaze@,sogate.org
TEL: (323) 563-9510
6 838
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
TO CONSULTANT:
Danielle Wood
NBS
32605 Temecula Pkwy Suite 100
Temecula, CA 92592
[email protected]
(800) 676-7516
6.22 Warranty of Authorized Signatories. Each of the signatories hereto warrants and represents that he or she is competent and authorized to enter into this Agreement on behalf of the Party for whom he or she purports to sign.
6.23 Consultation with Attorney. Consultant warrants and represents that it has consulted with an attorney or knowingly and voluntarily decided to forgo such a consultation.
6.24 Interpretation Against Drafting Party. City and Consultant agree that they have cooperated in the review and drafting of this agreement. Accordingly, in the event of any ambiguity, neither Party may claim that the interpretation of this Agreement shall be construed against either Party solely because that Party drafted all or a portion of this Agreement, or the clause at issue.
7. EFFECTIVE DATE. The effective date of this Agreement is July 1, 2023, and will remain in effect through and until project completion, unless otherwise terminated in accordance with the terms of this Agreement.
[Remainder of page left blank intentionally.]
839
Agreement for Professional Services
NBS
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties hereto have caused this Agreement to be executed and attested by their respective officers thereunto duly authorized.
CITY OF SOUTH GATE:
B7:
Maria del Pilar Avalos, Mayor
Dated:
ATTEST:
B7:
Yodit Glaze, City Clerk
(SEAL)
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
B7: og4Fi
Raul F. Salinas, City Attorney
NBS
By:
Michael Rentner, President
Dated:
840
Attachment B
(DNBS
32605 Temecrila Parkway, Suite 100
Temecula, CA 92592
Toll free: 800 676.7516
www.nbsgov.com
April 24, 2023
Chris Jeffers
City Manager
City of South Gate
1232 Washington Street
South Gate, CA 94515
Submitted electronically via [email protected]
RE: Outreach and 218 Services for a Sewer Fee Increase
Dear Chris,
NBS is committed to providing comprehensive outreach services to the City of South Gate (the "City") for the proposed sewer fee increase and the Proposition 218 process. Our experience working with numerous agencies has equipped us with a unique understanding of local government and the importance of building trust through effective community engagement.
Outlined below are our qualifications, proposed scope, project team, and fees for these outreach and 218 efforts. By implementing this comprehensive outreach strategy, NBS aims to facilitate a transparent, compliant, and inclusive process that addresses the unique needs and demographics ofthe community.
Through our efforts, we will ensure that all community members have equal access to information and opportunities to participate in the decision-making process related to the proposed sewer fee increase and the Proposition 218 process.
We look forward to working with the City of South Gate to effectively engage the community and address their concerns throughout this important process. Thank you for considering NBS' qualifications for these services. Please feel free to reach out to me at any time with questions about our proposal or to move forward with a professional services agreement.
Sincerely,
r5.',4catc-e!
Danielle Wood
Director
helping communities fund tomorrow since 1996
ff841
COMPANY OVERVIEW
AT-A-GLANCE: HEIPING COMMUNITIES FUND TOMORROW
In
l /" Business
100'6 NBSisalOO%
ESOPemployee-owned S-Corporation
NBS HEADQUARTERS
32605 Temecula Pkwy l Suite 100
Temecula. CA 92592
SAN FRANCISCOREGIONAI OFFICE
870 Market Street l Suite 1223
San Francisco, CA 94102
I CONTACT
Danielle Wood l 800.676.7516 mi!aai
[email protected]
Finance Group
DBA
NBS
tlrll"11{ 1.I I -
Michael Rentner. President
Since 1996, NBS has supported
municipalities with outreach, public
engagement and the implementation
and ongoing administration of local
funding tools.
While the firm originally focused on the
formation and administration of special
assessments and taxes, we have evolved
with our clients' needs and now provide a
full range of consulting services We focus
on public engagement, collaborative
governance, utility rate programs, cost
allocation plans, cost recovery, and legally
justified fee design Across all practice
areas, we have worked with more than
500 public agencies to date, including
cities, counties, school districts, utilities,
and special districts
CivicMic
A podium for the people.
As communication is paramount, the NBS team developed the CivicMic platform, which focuses on providing collaborative governance services including outreach, public engagement, and adaptive management, bringing citizen voices into the governance process. Through our customized approach, we engage residents of diverse backgrounds for unique perspectives using social media and other collaborative activities.
G%88cityotsouttusateoutreachservices Page 2
842
SCOPE OF SERVICES
The following describes the proposed Work Plan for completion of this Scope of Services:
INITIAL RESEARCH - KICK-OFF MEETING, PROJECT SCHEDULE
NBS will:
We will meet with City staff, legal counsel, and other interested parties to:
* Establish lines of communication,
n Clarify specific project goals and criteria.
* Resolve any special circumstances regarding the engagement process. * Develop an engagement schedule for effective interaction with all involved parties.
STRATEGIC MESSAGING SUPPORT
NBS will:
# Interview City staff and stakeholders to determine key talking points and develop a focused and compelling message.
* Define your audience, agree on methods for communicating about the topic, outline expectations, and determine the best way for City staff to connect with your rate payers. n Enable City staff, elected officials, and stakeholders to approach the topic with a united message by attending one study session to discuss messaging.
MULTILINGUAL FACTSHEET
NBS will work with City staff to create a multilingual factsheet (in up to two different languages including English and Spanish), decide on layout and content, focusing on the benefits and timeline of the proposed sewer fee increase, as well as future engagement opportunities for the community.
The multilingual factsheet will:
* Focusoneducatingthecommunityontheneedfortheupdatedrates,andhistoryofexistingrates and infrastructure.
* Be used to encourage people to join civicmic.com to use the rate calculator or view their updated rates.
* Emphasize the availability of bilingual information to ensure that all community members have equal access to important information.
COMMUNITY MEETINGS
a. Initial Community Meeting
NBS will:
* Host one online meeting to allow community members an opportunity to learn about the proposed sewer fee increase and the Proposition 218 process. # Lead the meeting with objectives created with the City before the meeting.
O%88ocityorsouthcateoutreachservices Page 3
20 843
* Develop future action items and subsequent discussion topics based on feedback received. b. Subsequent Community Workshop
NBS will:
# Host one in-person workshop to allow community members to discuss items ofimportance and build a sense of community.
* Create and post community meeting notices on various outlets. * Lead meetings with objectives created with the City before the meetings. * Create English and Spanish audio and visual content for the workshop. * Design the workshop layout and talking points.
* Develop action items based on feedback received at community meetings.
WEBPAGE CREATION - CMCMIC.COM
NBS will:
# Develop and deploy content to a dedicated webpage.
* Include a rate calculator.
* Post information on background for proposed increased rates, history of use of current funds available to the City, calendar of anticipated events, legislative updates, meeting announcements, and recorded meetings.
EMAIL CAMPAIGN - ESTABIISHMENT OF AN EMAIL LIST
Using the current rate payer email and the CivicMic platform, NBS will:
* Establish an email contact list for participants in this engagement. * SendcontentpostedtotheCivicMicwebsitedirectlytoallemaillistparticipants. * Share ways to sign up for CivicMic.com on meeting announcement postcards and at community meetings.
PROPOSITION 218 PUBLIC NOTICING
NBS will create a mailing list using the most recent County Assessor secured roll data available, combining that with the City's customer database. Duplicates will be removed to create a comprehensive mailing list.
NBS will also draft the Notice to property owners subject to the proposed Fee. Final form of the Notice will be reviewed and approved by legal counsel and City staff.
NBS will work with City staff to answer any questions that come up and guide you through the adoption process. The key technical tasks will be to prepare a draft and final Prop 218 Notice and provide the proposed rate tables included in the notices. NBS will work with City staff to review the draft and final notice prior to public release. The City should have legal counsel review all notices for legal compliance with the provisions of Prop 218, such as wording related to pass-throughs.
NBS will also develop and design a detailed fact sheet to be mailed to community members. The fact sheet will include historical information that will help educate the community on the current project needs. The fact sheet will be translated into up to two languages based on community census data. 4;S)j%l88-cityotsouthcateoutreachservices Page 4
844
PROJECTTEAM
The following provides an overview of NBS professional staff that would be assigned to this project.
Project Organizational Chart
S;ath
(,ateCity's Stakeholders, Management and Staff
Danielle Wood Sara Mares
Project Manager
Michelle Argerich-Valentine
Engagement Consultant
Nick Dayhoff
Prop 218 Senior Consultant
Client Services Director
John Savage
Communications Specialist
DANIELLE WOOD, PROJECT MANAGER
Role and Responsibilities: As the lead consultant on public engagement, Danielle Wood will communicate directly with City's staff to discuss engagement milestones, create and adjust engagement approaches and lead community meetings on behalf of the City's. Danielle will serve as the primary contact for this effort.
Work Experience: Danielle has more than two decades of experience as a Director at NBS. As one of the developers of CivicMic.com, an online outreach and collaboration tool, she is a seasoned professional in outreach, public engagement, collaborative governance, special financing district formation, and administration.
Education:
Bachelor of Science, Business Administration/Finance, California State University San Bernardino Advanced Public Engagement for Local Government Program, Pepperdine School of Public Policy Planning for Effective Public Participation Program, International Association for Public Participation O%85 CityofSouthGateOutreachServices Page 5
845
MICHELLE ARGERICH-VALENTINE, ENGAGEMENTCONSULTANT
Role and Responsibilities Michelle will work with the City'ss project manager to develop strategies for engaging the public. She will lead and facilitate meetings and communication on behalf of the City's.
Work Experience: Michelle has more than seven years of experience with community engagement and outreach.
Education:
Bachelor of Arts, Theater and Performance Studies, University of California, Berkeley Associates of Arts, Communications, Mt. San Jacinto College
NICK DAYHOFF, SENIOR CONSUIT ANT
Role and Responsibilities: Under the direction of the project manager, Nick Dayhoff will be available to provide Proposition 218 consulting services for the project.
Work Experience: Nick Dayhoff has been with NBS for more than 17 years. As a Senior Consultant, he is actively involved with new Special Financing District (SFD) formations, including Assessment Districts and Community Facilities Districts, parcel tax modeling, bond issuance/refunding analyses, fiscal impact analyses, and feasibility studies. Nick is a registered Municipal Advisor.
Education: Bachelor of Arts, Finance, California State University, San Diego
JOHN SAV AGE, COMMUNICATIONS SPECIALIST
Role and Responsibilities: John Savage will work closely with the project manager to develop content that will be used to educate the community. He will create dedicated web pages and targeted content on CivicMic.com, monitor and record community meetings, and develop engagement materials such as surveys to promote a high level of community engagement and participation.
Work Experience: John is an experienced communications specialist with more than a decade of professional experience in public engagement, qutreach, project management, and relationship management.
Education: Bachelor of Arts, Liberal Arts, California State University Channel Islands
SARA MARES, CLIENT SERVICES DIRECTOR
Roles and Responsibilities: Sara Mares will act as a representative of our corporate commitment to providing the highest level of service. She will ensure that the City's"s fundamental objectives are being met at all times.
Work Experience: Sara Mares is a Director with NBS with more than 22 years of experience with NBS. She forms and administers Special Financing Districts (SFDs), including Community Facilities Districts, 1913 Act Assessment Districts, Landscape, and Lighting Districts, and Benefit Assessment Districts. She has experience working with all aspects of the formation process, including planning, project management, budget analysis, development of assessment methodologies, and preparation of Engineer's Reports and public presentations.
Sara also has significant experience with ongoing special district administration including working with troubled districts, annual levy submittal, delinquency management, and continuing disclosure. She is a Registered Municipal Advisor.
Education: Bachelor of Arts with honors, Economics, Mills College.
Oj%l8So CityofSouthGateOutreachServices Page 6
846
PROFESSIONAL FEES
OUTREACH SERVICES
Initial Research, Strategic Messaging Support, and Multilingual Fact Sheet: S8,000 * Initial Research - Kick-Off Meeting, Project Schedule, and Strategic Messaging Support * Multilingual Fact Sheet (English and Spanish)
Community Meetings Bundle: SI0,000
* Initial Online Community Meeting:
* Subsequent In-Person Community Workshop
Webpage Creation, Email Campaign, and Prop 218 Noticing: S15,500 * Webpage Creation with Rate Calculator
* Email Campaign
* Prop 218 Services
Total Fee: S32,500 plus expenses
Please note that the costs of printing and mailing flyers are not included in the fees above and will be on additional expense. Mailings are estimated at about Sl per piece.
EXPENSES
Customary out-of-pocket expenses will be billed to the City at the actual cost to NBS. These expenses may include, but not be limited to, mailing fulfillment, postage, reproduction, telephone, travel, meals, and various third-party charges for data, maps, and recording fees.
TERMS
Public Engagement services will be invoiced monthly. Expenses will be itemized and included in the next regular invoice. If either party prematurely terminates the project, NBS shall receive payment for work completed. Payment shall be made within 30 days of the submittal of an invoice. If payment is not received within 90 days, simple interest will accrue at 1.5% per month. Either party can cancel the consulting contract with 30 days written notice.
O%88-cityorsouthcateoutreachservices Page 7
847
APPENDIX: PROJECTTEAM RESUMES
O%88ocityorsouthcateoutreachservices Page 8
25'848
DANIELLE WOOD I Project Manager
4QNBS
hluonlpdlnloamcoo,m,onniW nllles
EDUCATION BIOGRAPHY
Bachelor of Science, Business
qdministration/Finance,
California State University San
Bernardino
Advanced Public Engagement for
Local Government Program,
Pepperdine School of Public
Policy
Planning for Effective Public
Participation Program,
International Association for
Public Participation
HIGHLIGHTS
Skilled public engagement
specialist
Experienced communications
professional
Seasoned consultantin Specia
Financing District (SFD) formation
and administration
Outreach
Public Engagement
Collaborative Governance
Adaptive Management
Two decades of experience
AFFILIATIONS
California Public Information
Officials (CAPIO)
California Society of Municipal
Finance Officers (CSMFO)
Municipal Management
Association of Southern California
(MMASC)
Women in Public Finance (WPF)
Danielle Wood is a Director with NBS where she provides public engagement, outreach, and collaborative governance client services and project management efforts for a number of our clients. She has two decades of experience working with local governments and communities across California.
RELEV ANT PROJECT EXPERIENCE
Downtown San Mateo
Association District Public
Engagement Services for PBID
Renewal. Public Engagement
services for the renewal of a new
Property Business Improvement
District (PBID). Created a
framework for outreach efforts
that resulted in increased
cooperation from business
owners. Developed a
comprehensive website to better
inform business owners about the
District's initiatives and how they
can benefit from them.
Interviewed business owners via
phone and online surveys,
allowing for tailored and
consistent messaging.
City of Oxnard Ongoing Longterm Outreach, Public
Engagement and Collaborative
Governance Services. Public
engagement plan development
for the evaluation of existing land
secured financing districts that
includes items such as a
dedicated webpage, email
campaign, advisory committee
formation and collaborative
governance program. There are
more than 21 communities that
have participated in our surveys,
community meetings and ongoing
development, and complete
restructuring of the Landscape
Maintenance Districts. Project
started in 2019 and is ongoing.
City of La Habra Heights Ongoing
Public Engagement Services.
Community engagement for a
recently formed Benefit
Assessment District (BAD),
including a public engagement
plan, webpage development, web
maps, and other engagement
services. Project started in 2018
and is ongoing.
City of San Leandro Outreach and
Public Engagement Services.
Outreach and public engagement
services to gauge overall property
owner support for the formation
of an Assessment District. Public
engagement efforts have included
items such as the creation of a
dedicated public engagement
webpage, multiple information
releases, surveys, recorded
meetings, and community
participation web maps. Project
started in 2019 and is ongoing.
City of Culver City Outreach
Services. Outreach and Public
Engagement services for the
formation of a new Property
Business Improvement District for
a very unique community within
the City. Outreach services
included an area profile analysis,
a public informational mailer and
survey, and in person and virtual
public meetings. Project started in
2018 and is ongoing.
CGW"Weeagllrdeeatsllyreatp0pl:evceiaWteelyloaundrftohlrlolVwefu0p;tfhoellogw G%8S CityofSouthGateOutreachServices
( if)' ai,' (-).i rri ii d
849
EDUCATION BIOGRAPHY
Bachelor of Arts, Theater and
Performance Studies, University
of California, Berkeley
Associates of Arts,
Communications, Mt. San Jacinto
College
HIGHLIGHTS
Skilled public engagement
professional
Strong interpersonal skills
Community outreach
Diversity & Inclusion
Project management
Michelle Argerich-Valentine is an Engagement Consultant with NBS. She works to assist local government agencies in developing innovative ways to engage the public with digital and traditional public engagement methods. Michelle prides herself on creating interpersonal connections with the communities and individuals she serves, searching for ways to integrate valuable insights and turn them into plans of action.
RELEV ANT PROJECT EXPERIENCE
Ocean Avenue Community
Benefit Business District: Aid in
the renew and extension of the
District by facilitating community
engagement and outreach
opportunities, such as surveys,
interviews, and informationa
mailings and meetings
West Contra Costa School
District: Lead district elementary
schools in implementing inclusive
play programs at their school
sites. Developed and facilitated
training for school district
employees; mediated project
issues with school staff, and
community members; served as
the primary contact for school
administrators; consulted with
schools in achieving project
outcomes.
City of Diamond Bar: Facilitate
community outreach and public
engagement opportunities for the
proposed dissolution and
formation of an assessment
district.
Oakland Unified School
District: Facilitated
implementation of new recess
programing in district elementary
schools. Including informational
meetings, community events and
ongoing project management.
City of Fairfield: facilitated
community outreach and public
engagement opportunities for
participation in the collaborative
governance process regarding the
budget and service reductions for
City's Landscape and lighting
maintenance districts.
Stanislaus County: Facilitate
community outreach and public
engagement opportunities for
determining ARPA fund uses for
the county of Stanislaus. Public
engagement services include
surveys, community workshops,
Informational flyers, and
postcard creation.
ONBS CityofSouthGateOutreachServices Page 10
2?-850
TEAM FliSuM&
NICK DAYHOFF I SeniorConsultant
(;'}NBS
hlu:l:lnlogmaoO+TomWtiniilai
EDUCATION BIOGRAPHY
Bachelor of Arts, Finance,
California State University, San
Diego
HIGHLIGHTS
17 years with NBS
Highly experienced with ongoing
District/SFD/Sewer Charges
Administration
Breadth of experience with
District/SFD Formation
NPDES Administration
Continuing Disclosure
Proposition 218 Compliance and
Notification
l'/ really appreciated
the touch-base
meeting we had
recently, and look
forward to working
with you in the
coming fiscal year."
C-rt i rPi t LI IVl[ll aig( b f7tl ) la
Nick Dayhoff is a Senior Consultant with NBS where he forms and administers many types of Special Financing Districts (SFDs). Nick works with multiple agencies as their Sewer User Charge Administrator. This includes processing water consumption data, matching water meter numbers/service addresses to assessor"s parcel numbers, and calculating the sewer charges based upon water consumption and user category. He has also helped several of those agencies transition their rate structure from flat fees per parcel to volumetric based charges.
RELEV ANT PROJECT EXPERIENCE
City of Culver City, Sewer Charge
Administration: NBS provides
annual sewer charge
administration for the City,
placing the charge on the LA
County tax rolls.
City of San Mateo, Sewer Service
Charge Tax Roll Billing: NBS
calculates the City's annual sewer
service charge for all 27,500
parcels within the City. EachVeari
NBS calculates the appropriate
change for placement on the
County tax rolls. Relevant water
charge data from three service
providers are obtained, tracking
the currently active parcels.
Additionally, NBS provides a tollfree num ber for property owners requiring additional information
about the charges. NBS also
provides noticing services.
City of Sausalito, Tax Roll Billing
Services for Stormwater and
Sanitary Sewer Charges: Since
2009, NBS has consulted the City
on various parcel charges placed
on the County tax rolls. In
particular, NBS has responsibility
for their stormwater and sanitary
sewer charges, which are
calculated based on various
parcel attributes. The sewer
charges are based on winter
water usage data. NBS also
prepared their sewer utility rate
study, which was called out by
the Grand Jury of Marin County as
an exemplary study.
Ross Valley Sanitary District: NBS
was selected to administer their
annual sewer service charges.
Nick manages the annual process,
encompassing thousands of
parcels in varying rate-based fee
structures. The charges are
calculated based on winter water
use and submitted to the County
each summer.
G%86-cityotsouthcateoutreachservices Page 11
851
TEAM RffiStJMi
JOHN SAVAGE I CommunicationsSpecialist
(3NBS
hlu:lpdliilggmeQO(niQinwUnll Is
EDUCAnON BIOGRAPHY
Bachelor of Arts, Liberal Arts,
California State University
Channel Islands
EXPERTISE
Adobe CC
Photoshop
Illustrator
InDesign
Premiere and After Effects
Microsoft Office, G Suite
Constant Contact
Mail Chimp
Infusionsoft
Harvest
Basecamp
Teamwork
WordPress
Zoom
GoToWebinar
Google Meet
John Savage has a decade of professional experience in public engagement, outreach, project management, and relationship management. An experienced writer, editor, and designer, he is adept at content creation for web and print media.
John's approach is centered around cultivating authentic relationships with target communities and key stakeholders and using meaningful data acquired about the target audience to develop strategic and effective messaging to build trust and promote engagement.
RELEV ANT PROJECT EXPERIENCE
County of Stanislaus: Facilitate
community outreach and public
engagement opportunities for the
investment of ARPA funds in the
infrastructure of unincorporated
communities. Identify suitable
venues to host community
workshop series, working directly
with County staff and community
members. Public engagement
services include surveys, targeted
content updates, neighborhood
walks, community workshops,
participation web maps, and a
comprehensive report of findings
and recommendations.
City of Fairfield: Facilitate
community outreach and
engagement with residents in
Landscaping and Lighting
Maintenance Districts to gather
feedback, questions, and
concerns. Public engagement
services include surveys,
informational postcards, and
community meetings.
City of Pomona: NBS attended
public meetings, developed
outreach materials, and conducted
the ballot proceedings for 3,291
parcels regarding a Prop 218
balloting increase for the Phillips
Ranch area of Pomona. The original
assessment rates had not changed
since 1994 and the most recent
attempt to increase the rates in
2008 failed. Facing significant
shortfalls in funds available to
maintain the improvements and
changes in legislation that required
entirely new compliance standards,
NBS assisted the City in developing
a new assessment district. The
Engineer's Reportincluded a full
benefit analysis of the community
and improvements to meet current
rigorous requirements.
Oj%l8S CityofSouthGateOutreachServices Page 12
852
Attachment C
u
€€! € Hams&Associates.
May 2, 2023
Chris Jeffers
City Manager
City of South Gate
8650 California Avenue
South Gate, CA 90280
Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings
Dear Mr. Jeffers:
Harris & Associates ("Harris") appreciate the opportunity to work with the City of South Gate (the "City") for the implementation of an increased fee for the City"s sewer district. This proposal includes our qualifications and experience, work plan, staffing, references, and estimated fees. The Harris team has assisted public agencies with more than 500 annual financial proceedings while working with more than 100 public agencies throughout California. Our staff have a thorough understanding of Proposition 218 and the requirements to comply with Article Xlll D. As your partner, our team offers the following advantages:
Skilled Project Team. Each of our team members has more than 10 years of special financing experience. They thoroughly understand the provisions and implications of Prop. 218.
Proven Success. Our team has a portfolio of successfully completed financing projects which include Proposition 218 analyses, establishments and noticing. Through this experience, they have developed a reputation for providing complete and thorough reports and meeting aggressive project deadlines and legally required timeframes.
Firm Stability. For more than 25 years, Harris & Associates has been serving the specialized needs of public agencies. We pride ourselves with our ability to expand our services to meet the needs of our clients, such as providing expert assessment engineering and financial services.
PROJECT UNDERST ANDING
The City of South Gate created a sewer fee to cover the cost for the operations, maintenance, and capital replacement for the City's sanitary sewer system. Currently, the annual fees are not sufficient to cover the full cost for these expenses. The City commissioned a Sewer Rate Study in March 2022 to assess the financial status andtoprovideamechanismforfundingthefullcostsoftheexpensesrelatedtothesanitarysewersystem. Using the scope of work outlined in this proposal, Harris will help the City to set the appropriate fee and implement those fees within the City by adopting an amended Sewer Fee. 1401 Willow PassRoad,Suite 500, Concord, CA94520 a (925) 827-4900 N WeAreHarris.com 853
Our scope includes the following tasks:
Task 1: Project Orientation
Harris will attend a virtual meeting with City staff to confirm the project scope of work, project schedule, task assignments for both Harris and the City, format of the public notice and lead times for City review of documents and docketing on City Council agendas. During this meeting, the City will provide to Harris all pertinent information related to the Prop. 218 noticing for the sewer fee, including, but not limited to, the most recent approved sewer rate study, prior sewer fee increase resolutions, if any, the sewer fee ordinance, and prior sewer fee increase notices, if any.
Deliverables: Meeting minutes, including task assignments, and updated project schedule Task 2: Prepare Database
Harris will obtain the most current data available from the Los Angeles County Assessor's Office for all the parcels within the City"s sewer district. Harris will review and scrub the data to eliminate duplicate mailing records and will format owner name and address files to produce a mailing address file. Prepare a draft mailing list for review and approval by the City.
Deliverables: Draft mailing list
Task 3: Preparation and Mailing of Notice of Public Hearing Harris will prepare the Notice of Public Hearing for review by City staff and qualified legal counsel, as required by the Article XIIID of the California Constitution (Proposition 218), the Proposition 218 0mnibus Implementation Act (GovernmentCodeSection53750-53758)andHealthandSafetyCodeSection5470-5474. Oncefinalized,Harris will prepare and coordinate printing and mailing services to mail individual notices and protest forms to all property owners subject to the sewer fee, as required by the above laws.
Deliverables: Draft public hearing notice, final public hearing notice, final cost estimate from the mailhouse Task 4: City Council Approval to Send Notice
Harris will assist City Staff in preparing the resolution of intention to increase the sewer fee and setting a public hearing date and the City Council staff report, if any. Harris will attend the City Council meeting to assist the City StaffinaddressingtheCityCouncilonthepublicnoticingprocess. Draftingofthesewerordinanceisnotincluded in this scope of work and it is assumed such ordinance will be prepared by City staff and the City's legal counsel.
Deliverables: Draft Resolution of Intention, if any.
Task 5: Public Hearing
Harris will attend the required Public Hearing and assist the City Staff in addressing City Council and community member questions related to the public noticing process. Following the close of the Public Hearing, Harris will tabulate the protests. The tabulating results will be prepared summarizing the total protest received in terms of parcel count and percentages. If less than 50% of the total parcels within the sewer district have protested (if there is no majority protestl then the City Council may approve the desired action and levy the sewer fee for collection on the property tax bills.
Harris & Associates, Inc a Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 2 of 7 J/ 854
Optional Task A: Limited Public Outreach
Harris will coordinate with City Staff in providing background information that is needed to inform property owners of the sewer district's financial status, facilitate communication and feedback, and educate property owners of the potential solutions. It is important to provide materials to facilitate communication and feedback from community members on their options and paths forward. Such materials will include for the following:
* Harris will prepare one (1) information flyer that will include a Frequently Asked Question section. This will be included with the mailing of the public notice and will not be a separate mailing. @ Harris will provide information to the City for City Staff to add the City's website. @ Harris will respond to inquiries and information requests from community members. This task will be billed on a time and materials basis.
* Harris will provide information for public outreach presentations and attendance at in-person community meeting(s). Meetings will be attended on a time and materials basis.
Optional Task B: Full Public Outreach
If the City decides on that a full public outreach campaign is necessary, the City will contract with a professional public relations/public outreach firm either through a separate contract or as a sub-contract to Harris. The scope of work and fee to be determined at time of request for this optional task.
Responsibilities of the City
a. Designate a project manager to manage and coordinate the project. b. Provide legal review of all documents.
c. Make available records and documentation and any other available information necessary for the project. d. Schedule meetings, as required.
e. Take the lead on public outreach efforts.
Harris & Associates, Inc @ Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 3 of 7 22,-855
Harris has prepared the following fees to complete the work based on the scope above and our experience with similar projects.
Task I through Task 5
Harris will bill a lump sum in the amount of S16,000. This amount does not include mailing expenses. Mailing expenses are estimated below.
Optional Task A
The fee for the Optional Task A will be a combination of fixed fees and the lump sum provided below. The tasks for responding to inquiries and information requests from community members and attendance at a community meeting, will be billed on a time and materials basis, based on the Hourly Rates shown it the table below * Lump sum in the amount of S5,000.
* Time and materials not to exceed 51,500 to respond to inquiries and information requests from community members. This includes an allowance for eight (8) staff hours. If fees for this task exceeds Sl,500, a contract amendment will be required.
* Time and materials for providing information for public outreach presentations and attendance at inperson community meeting(s).
Note: Thiscostproposalrncludesall drrectcosts,suchastravel,equipment,computers,communrcations,andreproduction. Hourlyrates effectrveuntH December31,2023andaresubjectto a 3%annualescalatronfactor onJanuary1" eachyearthereafter.
Mailing Costs
The costs for printing and mailing the Notice of Public Hearing will be billed from a third-party mailing house directly to the City and it not included in the lump sum fee above. If Harris is to cover these costs, a handling fee of 15% will be added to the costs for printing and mailing. An estimate of the printing and postage expenses are shown below.
Postage - First-Class: S9,765 for approximately 15,500 notices Printing, Sorting, Mailing, Handling: S19,500
Total Estimated Fee S29,265
The final fee will be based on the cost to produce and mail the final approved public notice, based on, but not limited to, the number of pages, printing on both sides, the number of colors, the type of envelope, pre-printed return envelopes, and return postage.
Harris & Associates, Inc N Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 4 0f 7 856
Hourly Rates
Any additional services outside of the agreed upon Scope of Services will be billed on a time and materials basis.
Our hourly rates reflect our 2023 rates and will be adjusted by the consumer price index (CPI) on January first of each year.
& !a B u 5
ax
1,
k
I
I !n[
I
I % J] (
Alison Bouley S285.00
Donna Segura 5265.00
Dennis Anderson S260.00
GIS Specialist/Senior Analyst 5160.00
Analyst 5145.00
Following are some example Sewer District projects that Harris has worked on. References can be provided upon request.
Landscaping and Lighting Assessment District
City of Benicia
Harris has assisted the City in the district engineerin@ for their assessment district and associated five zones. The work includes the creation of new district engineer's reports and administration of Proposition 218 hearings to increase the assessments in all five districts in Benicia, incorporatin@ an automatic index for future increases.
Sewer Rate Update and Wastewater Utility Billing
City of Stanton
Harris has been placing the City's wastewater charges on the Orange County property tax roll for collection for over 15 years. Since the City does not provide water service to its residents and is only responsible for the maintenance of the wastewater collection system, its wastewater charges were originally based upon parcel size for non-residential parcels. Harris recently assisted the City in restructuring the City's wastewater charges to comply with the requirements of Proposition 218 by basing the City's wastewater charges upon average wastewater discharge rates by business type. The measurement is 1,000 per building area based upon data developed by the Orange County Sanitary District, which is responsible for treatment. The recommended wastewater rates provide the City with the revenue needed for maintenance of the wastewater collection system, as well as provide funds for capital improvements based upon the City's recent sewer master plan update. As part of the update, Harris also prepared and coordinated the mailing of the required notices to property owners/rate payers of the change. Harris also prepared the required resolutions and ordinance revisions for implementation of the new rate structure. The new rate structure modified the existing rate structure to confirm that the rate charged to parcels was proportional to their use of the system as required by Proposition 218.
Harris & Associates, Inc N Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 5 of 7 M857
Citywide Wastewater Billing for Sewer District
City of La Mesa
Harris serves as the Assessment Engineer to administer their residential wastewater utility billing which had been a bimonthly billing but is now placed on annual property tax roll. Services include providing Prop 218 notification support, updates of the city database with water district consumption, San Diego County Assessor data updates, pre-billing letters to customers, calculation of charges, and applyin@ the annual levy to the tax roll for each parcel with sewer service within the boundaries of the City. Members of Harris" MDF team have been working with the City of La Mesa since 2012.
PROJECT TEAM
Project Director - Alison Bouley, PE, will be the Project Director. Alison is a registered engineer and is a Vice President in charge of our Municipal and District Finance team. She has over 23 years of experience in managing the programming and financing ofinfrastructure improvements consulting to cities, counties and special districts throughout the State. She has assisted agencies with the analysis of special benefit from various types of improvements, in accordance with the requirements of Article Xlll D of the California State Constitution (Proposition 218). She has also assisted in the formation and administration of Assessment and Mello-Roos Community Facilities Districts as well as impact fees and sewer service charges. Alison is also responsible for quality control and assurance.
Project Manager - Donna Segura, will be the Project Manager and will be responsible for coordinating all aspects of the project, maintaining a close liaison with the City and ensuring the City's satisfaction with the services. Ms.
Segura has over 23 years ofspecial district formation and administration experience consulting to cities, counties and special districts throughout the State of California. She has assisted agencies with the analysis of special benefit from various types ofimprovements, in accordance with the requirements of Article XIIID of the California State Constitution (Proposition 218). She has also performed formation and annual administration services for Mello-Roos Community Facilities Districts, and various other fee and special tax districts.
Technical Advisor - Dennis Anderson, will serve as a Technical Advisor on the project. He has over 30 years of financial engineering experience consulting to cities, counties and special districts throughout the State of California. Dennis has assisted agencies with feasibility studies and the analysis of special benefit or approximate use from various types of improvements in accordance with the requirements of Article XIIID of the California State Constitution (Proposition 218) and the various fee, assessment and special tax acts within the State Codes.
He has prepared Engineer's Reports and Special Tax Rate and Method of Apportionments, Boundary Maps and Assessment Diagrams, staff reports, and resolutions, and has assisted with presentations to agency boards and property owners, the preparation and mailing of notices and ballots, and ballot tabulation. He has also managed the annual administration of both bonded and maintenance districts, including facility acquisition and reimbursement. Early in his career, Dennis was an employee for 2 adjacent sanitary sewer districts in San Diego County which shared staff. In addition to preparing public notices related to sewer charges, he was responsible for calculating connection charges, issuing sewer connection permits, preparing conditions of approval for new development, calculating annual sewer charges, placing charges on the annual property tax bills for collection, and responding to inquiries related to the sewer ordinances.
The project team will be supported by additional members of Harris' Municipal and District Finance group as needed.
Harris & Associates, Inc ffi Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 6 of 7 J"858
Harris has the experience, ability, and professional excellence to make your project successful. We look forward to working with the City of South Gate. If you have any questions regarding our proposal, please feel free to contact us, our phone number and emails are included below.
Sincerely,
Harris & Associates, Inc.
Alison Bouley, PE
Vice President, Municipal and District Finance
101 Progress, Suite 250
Irvine, CA 92618
949.536.2510
Alison. [email protected]
Donna Segura
Director, Municipal and District Finance
101 Progress, Suite 250
Irvine, CA 92618
949.536.2512
[email protected]
7 0f 7
J6=
Harris & Associates, Inc H Sewer Rate Increase - Prop 218 Proceedings 859
Attachment D
CITY OF
South Gate
Sewer Rate Study
Report / June 12, 2023
RAFTELIS 6S6ffth Gate'
J7- 860
RAFTELIS
June 12, 2023
Mr. Arturo Cervantes, P.E.
Assistant City Manager/Director of Public Works
City of South Gate
8650 California Ave,
South Gate, CA 90280
Subject: Sewer Rate Study Report
Dear Mr. Cervantes:
Raftelis Financial Consultants, Inc. (Raftelis) is pleased to provide this Sewer Rate Study Report (Report) to the City of South Gate (City) to address current financial challenges the City is facing and to establish sewer rates that are equitable to its customers.
The major objectives of the study include the following:
@ Develop a financial plans for the sewer enterprise to ensure financial sufficiency, meet operation and maintenance (O&M) costs, ensure sufficient funding for capital replacement and refurbishment (R&R) needs, and improve the financial health of the enterprises * Develop sound and sufficient reserve fund targets
* Review current rate stnictures for the wastewater enterprise The Report summarizes the key findings and recommendations related to the development of the financial plans for the sewer utility and the development of the updated sewer rates.
It has been a pleasure working with you, and we thank you and the City staff for the support provided during the course of this study.
Sincerely,
Xwr
Sud Pardiwala
Executive Vice President
Lindsay Roth
Consultant
227 W. Trade Street, Suite 1400
Charlotte, NC 28202
www.raftelis.com
i! 861
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS 4
1.1. LIST OF TABLES 6
I .:?. LIST OF FIGURES 6
1.:3. LIST OF APPENDICES 6
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1
1.1. STUDY BACKGROUND 1
1.2. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY 1
1.3. SYSTEM BACKGROUND 1
1,4, CURRENT RATES I
I .s. PROCESS AND APPROACH 1
I .e. LEGAL REQUIREMENTS 2
1.7. ORGANIZATION OF THE REPORT 2
I .s. FINANCIAL PLAN 3
I.g. COST OF SERVICE ANALYSIS AND RATE CALCULATION 5
I.IO. PROPOSED SEWER RATES 5
1.11. CUSTOMER IMPACTS 6
2. FINANCIAL PLAN 7
2.1. SYSTEM BACKGROUND 7
2.2. CURRENT RATES 7
2.3. ACCOUNT USAGE AND ASSUMPTIONS 7
2.3.1. Water Use 8
2.4. INFLATIONARY AND OTHER ASSUMPTIONS 8
2.5. FINANCIAL PLAN 8
2.5.1. Projected Revenues 9
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 862
2.5.2. Projected O&M Expenses g
2.5.3. Debt service 10
2.5.4. Capital Improvement Plan 10
2.5.5. Status Quo Financial Plan 10
2.5.6. Proposed Financial Plan and Revenue Adjustments 12
3. COST OF SERVICE ANALYSIS 18
3.1. COST-BASED RATE-SETTING METHODOLOGY 18
3.1.1. Calculate Revenue Requirement 18
3.1.2. Rate Design and Calculations 18
3.1.:3. Rate Adoption 18
3.2. COST OF SERVICE ANALYSIS 18
3.2.1. Allocation of Functionalized Expenses to Cost Components 19
3.2.2. Revenue Requirement Determination 19
3.2.3. Cost of Service 19
4. RATE DERIVATION AND BILL IMPACTS 21
4.1. EXISTING RATE STRUCTURE AND RATES 21
4.2. RATE CALCULATION 21
4.3. PROPOSED RATES 21
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STLIDY REPORT 863
i.i. List of Tables
Table I : Current Rate
Table 2: Recommended Revenue Adjustments
Table 3: Proposed Rates
Table 4: Bill Impacts
Table 5: Current Rate
Table 6: Customer Accounts
Table 7: Projected Water Use
Table 8: Inflationary Assumptions.
Table 9: Calculated Rate Revenue at Current Rates
Table 10: Projected Revenue at Current Rates
Table 11: Projected O&M Expenses
Table 12: Existing Debt Service
Table 13: Capital Improvement Plan
Table 14: Status Quo Financial Plan
Table 15: Proposed Rate Adjustments.
Table 16: Proposed Financial Plan
Table 17: Revenue Requirement
Table 18: Sewer Generation Calculation
Table 19: Unit Cost Calculation
Table 20: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Table 21: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Table 22: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Table 23: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Table 24: Bill Impacts
1.2. List of Figures
Figure 1: Projected Financial Plan
Figure 2: Capital Improvement Plan
Figure 3: Ending Fund Balances
Figure 4: Status Quo Financial Plan
Figure 5: Status Quo End Balances
Figure 6: Projected Financial Plan with Rate Adjustments Figure 7: Projected Fund Balances with Adjustments
Figure 8: Projected Fund Balances with Adjustments
i.3. List of Appendices
APPENDIX A: OTHER TREATMENT SURCHARGE RATE DESIGN
CITY OF CHARLOTTE W ATER AN D W ASTEW ATER FINAN CIAL PL AN STUDY RE PORT 41864
This page intentionally left blank to facilitate two-sided printing.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 42-865
1. i.i. Study Background
The City of South Gate (City) engaged Raftelis Financial Consultants (Raftelis) to conduct a comprehensive financial plan and develop cost-of-service sewer rates for implementation for the five year period in fiscal years (FY) 2023 through FY 2027. This report documents the resultant findings, analysis, and proposed changes that were developed with input firom City staff. This executive summary provides an overview of the study and includes findings and recommendations for wastewater rates.
1.2. Objectives of the Study
The major objectives of the study include the following:
1. Ensure revenue sufficiency to meet the operation and maintenance (O&M) and capital needs of the City's sewer utility.
2. Ensure that rates are fair and equitable and are based on the cost of service guidelines used in the industry.
3. Plan for rate and revenue stability to prevent spikes and provide adequate operating and capital reserves and the overall financial health of the sewer utility.
i.3. System Background
The City is located in Los Angeles County south of the downtown area. South Gate covers approximately 7.5 square miles and is bordered by the cities of Huntington Park, Cudahy Bell, Downey, Lynwood, and Paramount.
The City's Public Works Department manages a sewer collection system with approximately 120 miles of gravity sewer pipelines that serve the City's population of about 100,000. The collection system primarily discharges into County Sanitation Districts of Los Angeles County (LACSD) facilities for treatment and disposal. i.4. Current Rates
The City has not increased its rates for a number of years, and the current rate stnicture includes a uniform variable rate per hundred cubic feet (hcf) of water use for all customer classes. Table I shows the current variable charge.
Customers are charged monthly.
Table 1: Current Rate
I All Customer Classes $0.35
i.5. Process and Approach
Raftelis held several meetings with City staff to discuss and understand the objectives, characteristics, and challenges of the City's sewer utility to provide the recommendations and results detailed in tis report. Raftelis confirmed various assumptions and inputs and used an iterative process to view several scenarios to determine the recommended financial plan and sewer rates for service. City staff discussed the capital project requirements over a 5-year horizon, which is an essential driver of the future revenue needs of the utility. 866
The proposed fu'iancial plan detailed in this report follows industty standards for long-term financial planning. The financial plan relies on reasonable assumptions based on industry indices, such as general inflation based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and input from City Staff. Raftelis worked closely with City staff to determine the most accurate methodology to project future revenues and expenses to reinforce sound fiscal management practices.
The fu'iancial plan includes the current FY 2022 and the five-year period between FY 2023 to FY 2027. The cost of service analysis and resulting sewer rates are developed using the principles established by the Water Environment's Federation's (WEF) Matzual ofPracticeNo. 27. i.6. Legal Requirements
Proposition 218, reflected in the California Constitution as Article XIII D, was enacted in 1996 to ensure that rates and fees are reasonable and proportional to the cost of providing service. The principal requirements, as they relate to public wastewater service, are as fonows:
1. A property-related charge (such as wastewater rates) imposed by a public agency on a parcel shall not exceed the costs required to provide the property related service.
2. Revenues derived from the charge shall not be used for any purpose other than that for which the charge was imposed.
3. The amount of the charge imposed upon any parcel shall not exceed the proportional cost of service attributable to the parcel.
4. No charge may be imposed for a service unless that service is actually used or immediately available to the owner of the property.
5. A written notice of the proposed charge shall be mailed to the record owner of each parcel at least 45 days prior to the public hearing when the agency considers all written protests against the charge.
Water and wastewater rates and charges should be recovered from classes of customers in proportion to the cost of serving those customers. Proposition 218 makes clear that wastewater rates cannot be "arbitrary and capricious," meaning that the rate-setting methodology must be sound and that there must be a nexus between the costs and the rates charged. Raftelis followed industg standard rate-setting methodologies set forth by the Water Environment Federation (WEF) to ensure that the City's wastewater rates do not exceed the proportionate cost of providing wastewater collection services.
1.7. Organization of the Report
This Report includes three sections in addition to the Executive Summary and this Overview. A brief description of the remaining sections follows:
1. Financial Plan - describes the long-range financial plan for the sewer utility and overall revenue requirements from rates used to determine the costs of service and rates during the study period.
2. Cost of Service - describes the sewer cost of service methodology, which includes allocating costs to sewer parameters and determining unit cost.
3. Rates and Bill Impacts - includes the derivation of sewer rates and customer impacts resulting from the proposed rates.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT -ff-867
i.8. Financial Plan
In order to determine the revenue adjustments required to meet the ongoing expenses of the City and provide fiscal stability, Raftelis projected the revenue requirements, including operations and maintenance (O&M) expenses, capital improvement expenditures, debt service costs, reserve requirements, etc., for the study period FY 2023- 2027. O&M expenses include the cost of operating and maintaining the collection system lines as well as the cost of providing technical services such as engineering services and other administrative costs of the sewer system such as billing and customer service. O&M projections are based on the City's FY 2022 budget using a set of key inflationary factors starting in FY 2023 to project all O&M expenditures related to general expenses, salaries, and benefits. Figure I shows the projected sewer financial plan, including O&M expenses, and revenues under the current and proposed rates over the planning period.
Figure 1: Projected Financial Plan
Financial Plan
O&M Expenses Debt Service i PAYGO CIP
Reserve Funding ffi z z Current Revenues Proposed Revenues S3.5
53.0 52.5
S2.0
S1.S
S1.O
!90.5
50.0 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
(50.5)
In addition to the operating expense, the City has planned capital expendiffires over the next five years (FY 2023- 2027) totaling approximately $3.1 M (adjusted for inflation). The sewer utility does not have any existing debt and does not anticipate issuing new debt during the study period. The City expects to receive grant funds of $1.15 million to fund the sewer capital projects. Figure 2 shows the inflation-adjusted sewer CIP funding plan over the planning period, rounded to the nearest thousand.
868
Figure 2: Capital Improvement Plan
Capital Financing Plan N PAYGO N Grant Funded Unfunded
S700
o
; 5600
S500
5400
5300
S200
SIOO
SO
esszk 5661j( 5675k
5608k
S200k
s
5520k
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
To ensure the City will have adequate revenues to fund sewer operating and capital expenses and to maintain sufficient reserves, Raftelis recommends the revenue adjustments in Table 2 in accordance with the financial plan.
These increases are required to fu'iance the capital and operating expenditures, inclusive of inflationary pressure.
Table 2: Recommended Revenue Adjustments
V 45 al la
1 FY 2023 100%
2 FY 2024 10%
3 FY 2025 10%
4 FY 2026 5%
5 FY 2027 2%
Figure 3 shows the resulting fund balance for the sewer utility, given the revenue increases listed in Table 2. The dark blue line represents the total fund balance target, which is composed of operating and capital reserves targets consistent with industry standards. Financial reserves for the sewer fund are established by several criteria for various reserve components. The operating reserve target is set at 25 percent of the operating expenses to provide working capital and meet unanticipated operating expenses. The capital reserve target is set at 100 percent of annual capital expenditures to provide funds for capital projects. Under the proposed financial plan the utility will meet its target reserves in FY 2027.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 4k 869
Figure 3: Ending Fund Balances
Fund Balance Ending Balance Reserve Target
51.2 51.0
S0.8
S0.6
S0.4
50.2 50.0
(S0.2)
(S0.4)
FY2024 FY2025 FY2026 FY2027
(S0.6)
1.9. Cost of Sece Analysis and Rate Calculation
To calculate fair and equitable rates so that users pay in proportion to the cost of providing service, Raftelis performed a cost allocation of the total revenue requirements consistent with industry standards. This Report was prepared using the principles established by WEF, which establishes commonly accepted professional standards for cost-of-service studies. The general principles of rate stnucture design and the objectives of the Report are described further in section 4. Costs to serve different customer classes are determined; rates are then designed to recover the costs equitably from different customer classes.
1.10. Proposed Sewer Rates
The City's current rate stnicture consists of a single uniform commodity rate for all customer classes. Raftelis recommends that the City change its rate structure to a fixed plus variable rate stnicture for single family residential customers and a variable rate stmcture for all other customers, but subject to a minimum charge to recover the fixed costs of the wastewater enterprise. This rate stnucture is more consistent with the cost of service, is more equitable between customer classes, and allows for more revenue stability. Table 3 shows the proposed rates for FY 2023 through FY 2027. These rates are effective on May 1, 2023, and in January of each subsequent calendar year.
Table 3: Proposed Rates
Proposed Proposed Proposed Proposed Proposed
I
2 3
4 5
6 SFR - Fixed
SFR - Variable
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
$3.29
$0.32
$0.74
$0.74
$0.83
$0.83
$3.62
$0.36
$0.82
$0.82
$0.92
$0.92
$3.99
$0.40
$0.91
$0.91
$1.02
$1.02
$4.19
$0.42
$0.96
$0.96
$1.08
$1.08
$4.28
$0.43
$0.98
$0.98
$1.11
$1.11
m
870
i.ii. Customer Impacts
Table 4 shows the impacts of proposed rates on each customer class using their average montMy water use. The average single family residential customer will see an impact to their monthly bill of about tbree dollars. Due to rounding in the calculations, some values may not compute to the penny.
Table 4: Bill Impacts
Average Monthly Current Proposed
TTc- /khR n:1l T2-all
Difference
/el
I
2 3
4 5
Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
10 28
38 165
59 $3.50
$9.80
$13.30
$57.75
$20.65
$6.49
$20.72
$28.12
$136.95
$48.97
$2.99
$10.92
$14.82
$79.20
$28.32
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT f
871
2. Financial Plan
This section of the report describes the sewer fund and the proposed financial plan. To develop the financial plan, Raftelis projected annual revenues and expenses, modeled reserve balances, and projected capital expenditures to estimate the amount of additional rate revenue needed each year. Numbers shown in the tables of this section are rounded. Therefore, hand calculations based on the displayed numbers, such as summing or multiplying, may not equal the exact results shown.
2.1. System Background
The City is located in Los Angeles County south of the downtown area. South Gate covers approximately 7.5 square miles and is bordered by the cities of Huntington Park, Cudahy Bell, Downey, Lynwood, and Paramount.
The City's Public Works Department manages a sewer collection system with approximately 120 miles of gravity sewer pipelines that serve the City's population of about 100,000. The collection system primarily discharges into County Sanitation Districts of Los Angeles County (LACSD) facilities for transportation, treatment, and disposal.
2.2. Current Rates
The City's current sewer rates were implemented several years ago and include a uniform variable rate per hundred cubic feet (hcf) of water use for all customer classes. Table 5 shows the current variable rate. Customers are charged monthly.
Table 5: Current Rate
I All Customer Classes $0.35
:2.3. Account Usage and Assumptions
Table 6 shows the estimated number of sewer accounts for the study period. No growth is anticipated in the number of accounts served since the City is almost entirely built out. The number of accounts is used to forecast the amount of water usage and fixed revenue the City will recover in the proposed rates presented in section 4.
Table 6: Customer Accounts
A
T ;fiJl rvvc+yz'xtir Jalacc
1$ L LJ 'fl t (T
'T?V')(l')') liV')n")l VVI(l')A T::V') €1'} € TrV') €1')A Tru'}n'}') I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family
Residential
Multi-Family
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
10,618
3,607
1,443
87 10
15,765
872
2.3.1.WATER USE
Table 7 shows the projected water use for the study period by customer class. The projections are based on demand in FY 2022 and are estimated to remain at that level for the study period.
Table 7: Projected Water Use
TiV ')(ll"l T;'V ') €11A nu Irll'l
I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
1,307,926
1,200,749
651503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
2.4. Inflationary and Other Assumptions
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
This section describes the assumptions used in projecting operating and capital expenses as well as reserve coverage requirements that determine the overall revenue adjustments required to ensure the fu'iancial stability of the City's utility. Revenue adjustments represent the average increase in rates for the utility as a whole. Rate changes for individual classes depend on the cost of service analysis described in section 3.
To ensure that fumre costs are reasonably projected, it is necessary to make informed assumptions about inflationary factors and water use. Table 8 shows the inflationary assumptions approved by staff and incorporated in the five-year financial plan. O&M projections are based on the City's FY 2022 budget using the inflationary factors to project all O&M expenses related to general expenses, salaries, and benefits.
Table 8: Inflationary Assumptions
V'V Itll'J
I
2 3
4 5
6 General
Salary
Benefits
Utilities
Capital
Reserve Interest Rate
2.5. Financial Plan
5.0%
3.0%
5.0%
4.5%
3.Oo/o
1.O%
5.0%
3.0%
5.0%
4.5%
3.0'!"o
1.0'/o
The assumptions shown above are incorporated into the five-year financial plan. To develop the financial plan, Raftelis projects annual expenses and revenues, models reserve balances and capital expenditures, and calculates debt service coverage ratios to estimate the amount of additional rate revenue required each year. This section of the report provides a discussion of the projected revenue under existing rates, O&M expense, the capital improvement plan (CIP), reserve funding, and the revenue adjustments needed to ensure the fiscal sustainability and solvency of the City's sewer utility.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 873
2.5.1.PROJECTED REVENUES
Table 9 shows the calculated rate revenues for FY 2023 through FY 2027 based on the City's current sewer rates.
The projected annual rate revenue is determined by multiplying the annual water usage with the uniform rate for each customer class.
Table 9: Calculated Rate Revenue at Current Rates
T ;1l11 raL'au1ai+oJ T2 atei D oiirtit'mx 'T::V 'H1I € T,'V InJ"l I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
$457,774
$420,262
$230,126
$60,365
$2,479
$1,171,006
$451774
$420,262
$230,126
$60,365
$2,479
$1,171,006
$457,774
$420,262
$230,126
$60,365
$2,479
$1,171,006
$457,774
$420,262
$230,126
$60,365
$2,479
$1,171,006
$457,774
$420,262
$230,126
$60,365
$2,479
$1,171,006
Table 10 shows the sewer utility's projected revenues for the Study period. City staffprovided budgeted revenues for FY 2022. Other non-rate revenues were projected throughout the Study period. Sewer rate revenues are equal to the calculated rate revenues at current rates for FY 2023 and beyond. Miscellaneous, non-rate revenues are inflated using the corresponding revenue escalation factor. Interest income is calculated based on the reserve interest rate and projected fund balances.
Table 10: Projected Revenue at Current Rates
rst rsiwrusv Th * T'V 7nji T'V ')n7A
I
2 3
4 5
6 7
Industrial Waste Permits
Interest Earnings
Mkt Value - Gain/Loss
Utility Service
Utility City Statement Fee
Transfers In
Total
$13,500
$0
$0
$1,171,006
$1,454
$0
$1,185,960
$13,500
$19,178
$0
$1,171,006
$1,483
$0
$1,205,166
$13,500
$16,202
$0
$1,171,006
$1,512
$0
$1,202,221
$13,500
$14,035
$0
$1,171,006
$1,542
$0
$1,200,084
$13,500
$10,863
$0
$1,171,006
$1,573
$0
$1,196,943
2.5.2.PROJECTED O&M EXPENSES
The City's FY 2022 0&M budget and projected O&M expenses are shown in Table 11. The fu'iancial plan study period is from FY 2023 through FY 2027. The O&M budget incorporates the inflationary factors shown in Table 8.
O&M expenses include the costs to operate and maintain the collection system, including sewer lines, as well as the costs ofproviding technical services such as engineering services and other administrative and operating costs.
The expenses also include costs associated with billing and customer service.
Table 11 : Projected O&M Expenses
(SRrk/T ('at TIi'V "n71 IiV 1(ll €
I
2 3
4 5
Employee Services
Supplies and Services
Other
Capital Outlay
Total O&M Expenses
$413,126
$790,590
$0
$0
$1,203,716
$492,936
$781,858
$0
$0
$1,274,794
$510,723
$821,009
$0
$0
$1,331,732
$529,192
$862,124
$0
$0
$1,391,316
$548,374
$888,086
$0
$0
$1,436,460
$568,296
$914,838
$0
$0
$1,483,134
874
2.5.3.DEBT SERVICE
The wastewater utility has two existing lines of debt service. Table 12 shows the payment schedules for the existing debt during the Study period. The first is the sewer share of a 2019 water revenue refunding bond with debt service payments starting in FY 2023. The second is a utility authority sewer lease with service payments also starting in FY 2023. It is important to note that the sewer lease payments are not included in the debt coverage calculations and will therefore be listed under O&M expenses in the cash flow.
Table 12: Existing Debt Service
I
2019 Series A and A-T Water Revenue
Refunding Bonds - Sewer Share
South Gate Utility Authority Sewer
Lease
Total
$337,779 $337,655 $337,808 !5337,539 $337,508
$0
$337,779
$0
$337,655
$0
$337,808
$376,430
$713,969
$376,430
$713,938
2.5.4.CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
Table 13 details the City's sewer capital improvement plan. City staff provided CIP through FY 2024 based on current year dollars. CIP expenditures related to vehicle replacements are shown for FY 2025 through FY 2027.
From FY 2023 onward, CIP costs are inflated using the expense escalation factor for capital.
Table 13: Capital Improvement Plan
A ICDEF
Liiie CapitalInnprovementP!an FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 FY2026 FY2027 I
2 3
Sewer Lining Program
Vehicle Fleet Replacement
Total
$566,500
$41,200
$607,700
$583,495
$98,133
$681,628
$0
$661,100
$661,100
$0
$674,958
$67 4,958
$0
$520,366
$520,366
2.5.5.STATUS QUO FINANCIAL PLAN
Table 14 shows the projected financial plan based on revenues at existing rates with no adjustments or the "status quo" scenario. Revenues are from Table 10. Note that the revenues from interest income in the status quo scenario are lower due to a decrease in fund balances. O&M expenses are from Table 11. Existing debt service is from Table
12. CIP is from Table 13.
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT
52.875
Table 14: Status Quo Financial Plan
T ;via
Revenues
Revenues from Existing Rates
Revenue Adjushnents
Total Rate Revenue
Interest Earnings
Other Revenue
Total Revenues
O&M Expenses
Employee Services
Supplies and Services
Other
Capital Outlay
South Gate Utility Authority Sewer Lease
Total O&M Expenses
Net Revenue
Debt Service
Existing Debt Service
Proposed Debt Service
Total Debt Service
CIP Expenditures
PAYGO
Total CIP Expendihires
Net Surplus/(Deficit)
Beginning Balance
Grant Proceeds
Ending Balance
Target Reserve Balance
Operating
Capital
Total Reserve Target
$1,171,006
$0
$1,171,006
$0
$14,954
$1,185,960
$492,936
$781,858
$0
$0
$0
$1,274,794
($88,835)
$337,779
$0
$337,779
$607,700
$607,700
$1,171,006
$0
$1,171,006
$0
$14,983
$1,185,989
$510,723
$821,009
$0
$0
$0
$1,331,732
($145,743)
$337,655
$0
$337,655
$681,628
$681,628
$1,171,006
$0
$1,171,006
$0
$15,012
$1,186,018
$529,192
$862,124
$0
$0
$0
$1,391,316
($205,298)
$337,808
$0
$337,808
$661,100
$661,100
$1,171,006
$0
$1,171,006
$0
$15,042
$1,186,049
$548,374
$888,086
$0
$0
$376,430
$1,812,890
($626,842)
$337,539
$0
$337,539
$674,958
$67 4,958
$1,171,006
$0
$1,171,006
$0
$15,073
$1,186,080
$568,296
$914,838
$0
$0
$376,430
$1,859,564
($673,484)
$337,508
$0
$337,508
$520,366
$520,366
($1,034,314) ($1,165,027) ($1,204,206) ($1,639,338) ($1,531,358) ($217,785) ($102,098)
$1,150,000 $0
($102,098) ($1,267,125)
($1,267,125) ($2,471,331) ($4,110,669)
$0 $0 $0
($2,471,331) ($4,110,669) ($5,642,027)
$318,699
$607,700
$926,399
$332,933
$681,628
$1,014,561
$347,829
$661,100
$1,008,929
$359,115
$674,958
$1,034,073
$370,783
$520,366
$891,149
Net revenue is equal to total revenues, less O&M expenses. Net cash flow is equal to net revenue less debt service and cash-funded CIP. Beginning balances for FY 2023 are negative because the utility is currently operating in the red. Ending,balances are calculated by adding beginning balances to the net cash flow. The reserve target is 25% of aru'iual operating expenses and 100% of annual capital expenditures. Under the status quo scenario, the sewer fund will continue to operate in the red and never meet reserve targets. 53 876
Figure 4 shows the projected status quo fu'iancial plan in graphical format. The bars represent the sewer utility's cash needs: O&M expenses (dark green), debt service (light green), capital projects (yellow), and reserve funding (blue). The solid line represents the current revenues, which is below the stacked bars for all years, signifying that the City's sewer revenues are not sufficient to fund its costs.
Figure 4: Status Quo Financial Plan
Financial Plan
fflDebtSerViCe iPAYGOCIP
xxzCurrentRevenues ProposedRevenues
S4.0
S3.0
S2.0
S1.O
SO.O
(S1.O)
(52.0)
Figure 5 shows the projected fund balances under the status quo scenario for a 5-year period. The light green bars represent the ending balances of the sewer fund, and the solid line represents the reserve target amounts. The sewer fund will fall deeper into negative fund balances kough FY 2027.
Figure 5: Status Quo End Balances
Fund
(S1.O)
(S2.0)
(S3.0)
(S4.0)
(S5.0}
(S6.0)
Balance
FY2022
2.5.6.PROPOSED FINANCIAL PLAN AND REVENUE ADJUSTMENTS
The proposed revenue adjustments help ensure adequate revenue to fund operating expenses and execute the capital improvement schedule. The fu'iancial plan model assumes the revenue adjustment occurs on May 1, 2023,
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 877
and in January of each subsequent year. The proposed revenue adjustments will enable the City to execute the CIP and build sufficient reserves by the end of the five-year study period. The proposed revenue adjustments represent the increase to total rate revenues required to recover the water utility's costs and not the expected impact to each customer class.
Table 15Error! Reference source not found. shows the projected revenue adjustments applied to the sewer rate revenues.
878
Table 16 shows the proposed financial plan with the revenue adjustments ftaom Table 15. Revenues from interest income are greater than those shown in the status quo scenario due to additional cash from the proposed adjustments. O&M expenses, debt service, and cash funded CIP are the same as the status quo scenario. Net cash flow is positive in FY 2024 and beyond, which means the City will be funding its reserves in those years. Net cash flow is negative in FY2023, which means that the city will be drawing down its fund to pay for its expenses.
Table 15: Proposed Revenue Adjustments
I
2 3
4 5
FY 2023
FY 2024
FY 2025
FY 2026
FY 2027
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 879
Table 16: Proposed Financial Plan
ABCDEF
Line FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 FY2026 FY2027
I
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 II
12 13
Revenues
Revenues from Existing Rates
Revenue Adjustments
Total Rate Revenue
Interest Earnings
Other Revenue
Total Reyenues
O&M Expenses
Employee Services
Supplies and Services
Other
Capital Outlay
South Gate Utility Authority
Sewer Lease
Total O&M Expenses
Net Revenue
Debt Service
Existing Debt Service
Proposed Debt Service
Total Debt Service
CIP Expenditures
PAYGO
Total CIP Expenditures
Net Surplus/(Deficit)
Beginning Balance
Grant Proceeds
Ending Balance
Target Reserve Balance
Operating
Capital
Total Reserve Target
$1,171,006
$195,168
$1,366,174
$0
$14,954
$1,381,127
$492,936
$781,858
$0
$0
$0
$1,274,794
$1,171,006
$1,288,107
$2,459,113
$4,464
$14,983
$2,478,559
$510,723
$821,009
$0
$0
$0
$1,331,732
$1,171,006
$1,534,018
$2,705,024
$3,855
$15,012
$2,723,892
$529,192
$862,124
$0
$0
$0
$1,391,316
$1,171,006
$1,733,675
$2,904,681
$6,014
$15,042
$2,925,738
$548,374
$888,086
$0
$0
$376,430
$1,812,890
$1,171,006
$1,834,276
$3,005,282
$8,061
$15,073
$3,028,416
$568,296
$914,838
$0
$0
$376,430
$1,859,564
$106,333 $1,146,827 $1,332,575 $1,112,847 $1,168,852
$337,779 '5337,655
$0 $0
$337,779 $337,655
$607,700
$607,700
$681,628
$681,628
$337,808
$0
$337,808
$661,100
$661,100
$337,539
$0
$337,539
$674,958
$67 4,958
$337,508
$0
$337,508
$520,366
$520,366
($839,146) $127,544 $333,668 $100,351 $310,979
($217,785)
$1,150,000
$93,069
$318,699
$607,700
$926,399
$93,069
$0
$220,613
$332,933
$681,628
$1,014,561
$220,613
$0
$554,281
$347,829
$661,100
$1,008,929
$554,281
$0
$654,632
$359,115
$674,958
$1,034,073
$654,632
$0
$965,611
$370,783
$520,366
$891,149
6f 880
Figure 6 shows the projected financial plan with the proposed revenue adjustments. The dotted line represents the proposed revenues with adjustments applied.
Figure 6: Projected Financial Plan with Rate Adjustments rFinancial Plan O&MEXpenseS DebtService PAYGOCIP
zReserveFunding zzzCunentRevenues xProposedRevenues
53.5 S3.0
52.5 52.0
S1.5
51.0 S0.5
50.0 : (50.5)
FY2024 FY2025 FY2026 FY2027
Figure 7 shows the projected fund balances with the proposed adjustments in Table 2 applied over a 5-year period.
The City's sewer fund is expected to meet the reserve target in FY 2027.
Figure 7: Projected Fund Balances with Adjustments
Fund
S1.2
51.0 S0.8
S0.6
50.4 S0.2
50.0 (S0.2)
(S0.4)
(S0.6)
Balance
FY2024 FY2025 FY2026 FY2027
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT g 881
Figure 8 summarizes the projected inflated CIP. The City will fund part of its capital projects through the American Rescue Plan ACT (ARPA) grants of $1.15 million, as shown by the dark blue bars. The remaining CIP will be funded through rate revenue (light blue bars). Total CIP is shown at the top of each bar for each fiscal year.
Figure 8: Projected Fund Balances with Adjustments
Capital Financing Plan aSewerFunds i ARPA
S800
5700
5500
5400
S300
5200
5100
SO
S682k 5661k !5675k
5608k
5200k
s
5520k
FY2022 FY2023 FY2024 P12025 FY2026 FY2027
882
3. Cost of Sexice Anailysis
3.t. Cost-Based Rate-Setting Methodology
This section discusses the allocation of O&M expenses and capital costs to sewer functions, cost components, and the determination of unit costs and rate calculation by customer class. The proposed sewer utility costs of service for the City weredevelopedconsistentwith the guidelines detailed in T)VEFManual ofPractice No. 27.
To develop utility rates that align with Proposition 218 requirements and industry standards wMe meeting other emerging goals and objectives of the utility, there are four major steps discussed below:
3.1.1.CALCULATE REVENUE REQUIREMENT
The first step in the cost-of-service analysis is distributed among customer classes commensurate with their service requirements. A cost-of-service analysis involves the following:
1. Functionalize O&M and capital costs into functions: since the City's wastewater utility is a collection only system, the only function is collection.
2. Allocate the costs from each function to cost causation components: Our only component for the City is flow.
3. Establish the wastewater flow by each customer class
4. Calculate the unit cost component rate by dividing the total cost in the collection component in Step I by the flow in Step 2
5. Calculate the cost by each customer class by multiplying the unit cost components in Step 4 by the flows established in Step 3.
3.1.2.RATE DESIGN AND CALCULATIONS
Rates do more than simply recover costs. Within the legal framework and industry standards, properly designed rates should support and optimize a blend of various utility objectives, such as affordability, revenue stability, and equity among customers, amongst other objectives. Rates may also act as a public information tool in communicating these objectives to customers.
3.1.3.RATE ADOPTION
Rate adoption is the last step of the rate-making process. Raftelis documents the rate study results in this Study Report to help educate the public about the proposed changes, the rationale and justifications behind the changes, and their anticipated financial impacts in lay terms.
3.2. Cost of Sece Analysis
The principles and methodology of a cost of service analysis were described in the preceding section. A cost of service analysis distributes a utility's revenue requirements (costs) to each customer class. After determining a utility's revenue requirements, the next step in a cost of service analysis is to functionalize O&M based on the City's current O&M classification. Since the sewer service only provides collection, all O&M costs are allocated to the collection function. The functionalization of costs allows us to better allocate the functionalized costs to the cost causation components
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT 883
3.2.1.ALLOCAT10N OF FUNCTIONALIZED EXPENSES TO COST COMPONENTS After functionalizing expenses, the next step is to allocate the functionalized expenses to cost causation components. Since the primary cost function is conection, all system costs are allocated to a flow cost causation component.
3.2.2.REVENUE REQUIREMENT DETERMINATION
Table 17 shows the revenue requirement derivation with the total revenue required from rates. The total shown in the "Operating" and "Capital" columns are the total O&M and capital revenue requirements, respectively, that are allocated to the cost component.
Table '17: Revenue Requirement
Thvn1
I
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 II
12 13
14 15
16 17
FY 2023 Revenue Requirement
O&M Expenses
Debt Service
Capital Ptqiects (Rate Funded)
Total Revenue Requirements
Less: Revenue from Other Sources
Interest Income
Other Revenue
Total Revenue from Other Sources
Less: Adjushnents
Annualized Rate Increase
Transfers from/(to) Reserves
Total Adjustments
Costto be Recovered fromRates
$1,274,794
$0
$0
$1,274,794
$0
$0
$14,954
$14,954
$0
($975,839)
$272,646
($703,193)
$0
$331779
$41,200
$378,979
$1,274,794
$331779
$41,200
$1,653,773
$0
$0
$14,954
$14,954
$0
($975,839)
$272,646
($703,193)
$1,963,033 $378,979 $2,342,012
Raftelis calculates the revenue requirement using projected FY 2023 expenses, which include O&M expenses and funded capital expenses. To arrive at the rate revenue requirement, we make adjustments for annual cash balances.
Since the proposed rate adjustment will not take place at the start of the fiscal year, we have to annualize the rate increase, which will lead to an increase in the revenue requirement. The adjustments are subtracted to arrive at the total revenue requirement from rates. This is the amount that the rates are designed to collect.
3.2.3.COST OF SERVICE
Our end goal is to proportionately distribute the costs to each user class. First, we must determine a cost allocation basis. To do so, we use the estimates of sewer generation for each user class. The sewer generation by customer class was sourced from the 2019 Sewer Master Plan. Table 18 shows the sewer generation percentages (also called reffirn to sewer) by class. Single family customers have higher irrigation usage, which is why their generation percentage is the lowest. Other customer classes have higher sewer generation percentages because they have more indoor usage as a percentage of total usage.
884
Table 18: Sewer Generation Calculation
Estimated Estimated % Attributable
I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
915,548
960,599
526,002
155,225
6,374
2,563,748
Table 19 shows the unit cost calculation per hcf of wastewater generated. This unit cost is then multiplied by the wastewater produced by each customer class (reference) in Table 18 to determine the total revenue to be recovered by each class. Table 20 shows the total revenue requirements allocated to each customer class.
Table 19: Unit Cost Calculation
I
2 3
4 5
O&M Expenses
Capital Expenses
Total - Cost of Senice
Total WW Flow
Unit Cost ($/hcf ww)
$1,963,033
$378,979
$2,342,012
2,563,748
$0.91
Table 20: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
$836,363
$877,518
$480,509
$141,800
$5,823
$2,342,012
CITY OF CHARLOTTE WATER AND WASTEWATER FINANCIAL PLAN STUDY REPORT ?2,- 885
4. Rate Derivation
Impacts
4.t. Existing Rate Structure and Rates
The City's existing rate stmcture consists of a uniform variable charge based on a customer's water use for all customer classes. All customers are billed on a monthly basis. The current sewer rate can be seen in Table 5.
4.:2. Rate Calculation
Since customers are charged per hcf ofwater use, rates are calculated by dividing the proposed revenue by the projected water use for each customer class. This calculation is shown in Table 21. To increase revenue stability, and cover a portion of the fixed costs, the City decided to recover half of the single family residential revenue through a montMy fixed rate. Table 22 shows the calculation of the fixed and variable rates for single family customers. 50% of the proposed revenue will be recovered by each rate. This revenue was divided by the number of accounts and by 12 months to calculate the monthly SFR rate, and the other half was divided by the projected water usage to calculate the variable rate.
Table 21: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Proposed
'D z---- -
Water Rate $/hcf
I
2 3
4 5
6 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
Total
$836,363
$877,518
$480,509
$141,800
$5,823
$2,342,012
1,307,926
1,200,749
657,503
172,472
7,082
3,345,732
$0.64
$0.73
$0.73
$0.82
$0.82
Table 22: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
I
2 3
4 SFR Fixed Revenue
SFR Accounts
SFR Fixed Rate
$418,182
10,618
$3.28
5 6
7 SFR Variable
Revenue
SFR Water Usage
SFR Variable Rate
$418,182
1,307,926
$0.32
4.3. Proposed Rates
The proposed rate for single family customers will be revised to include a fixed charge to collect a portion of the revenues from fixed charges. The balance of the revenue requirement will be collected from the variable rate. Since 886
most of the sewer costs are fixed, this ensures that all customers pay at least a minimum cost to cover the expenses.
The remaining customers, including multi-family, commercial, and industrial customers, will continue to be charged a variable rate based on the wastewater they generate. However, they will be subject to a minimum fixed charge, which is the same as the fixed charge for single family customers, if their charge calculated based on the variable rate falls below that minimum fixed charge. The proposed rates for FY 2023 through FY 2027 are shown in Table 23. The rates after FY 2023 are increased by the revenue adjustments shown in Table 15Error! Reference source not found..
Table 23: Proposed Revenue by Customer Class
Current Proposed Proposed Proposed Proposed Proposed
VV Ill')A
I
2 3
4 5
6 SFR - Fixed
SFR - Variable
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
$0.35
$0.35
$0.35
$0.35
$0.35
$3.29
$0.32
$0.74
$0.74
$0.83
$0.83
$3.62
$0.36
$0.82
$0.82
$0.92
$0.92
$3.99
$0.40
$0.91
$0.91
$1.02
$1.02
$4.19
$0.42
$0.96
$0.96
$1.08
$1.08
$4.28
!50.43
$0.98
$0.98
$1.11
$1.11
Table 24 shows the bill impacts for each customer class using the average monthly water use. The average single family residential customer's monthly bill impact will be about tbree dollars.
Table 24: Bill Impacts
Average Montlxly Current Proposed Difference
1 2
3 4
5 Single Family Residential
Multi-Family Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Other
10 28
38 165
59 $3.50
$9.80
$13.30
$57.75
$20.65
$6.49
$20.72
$28.12
$136.95
$48.97
$2.99
$10.92
$14.82
$79.20
$28.32
CITY OF CHARLOTTE W ATER A N D W A STEW ATER FI NA N CIAL PLA N STU DY RE PORT VF887
Sewer Rate Study
Financial Plan, Cost of Service and Rate Review
City Council Meeting
June 27, 2023
m
888
Sewer Rate Study
- Evaluate Sewer Enterprise Fund.
- Develop a 5-year Financial Plans for the Sewer Enterprise Fund. > Prepares City to meet all operating, debt, capital, and reserve requirements For the Sewer Enterprise Fund.
- Propose sewer rates that capture the full cost of serving customers that are consistent with industry standards.
889
Employee Services
Supplies and
Other
Capital Outlay
Debt
CIP & Vehicle Repla
Depreciation Expenses
@* lSl,171,006 §i,izi,oos Sl,171,006 Sl,171,006 5i,izi,oos Sl,185,931 Sl,185,960 Sl,185,989 Sl,186,018 51,186,048
S413,126 S492,936 S510,723 S529,192 S548,374
!50 50 50 SO 50
§O S337,779 5337,808 §713,969 5713,938
5sso,ooo 5sso,ooo 5sso,ooo 5sso,ooo 5sso,ooo
5i,izi,oos
Sl,186,079
S568,296
50 §714,096
5sso,ooo
890
Proposed 5-Year Financial Plan - KeyAssumptions
Projected Expenditures - CIP and Vehicle Replacement
$3,500,000.00
$3,000,000.00
$2,500,000.00
$2,000,000.00
$1,500,000.00
$1,ooo,ooo.oo
$500,000.00
FY 2022/23 FY 2023/24 FY 2024/25 FY 2025/26
s Sewer Funds a ARPA Funds
FY 2026/27 FY 2027 /28
A total of $4 Million dollars in ARPA (American Rescue Plan Act) is being programmed over FY 2022-23, 2023-24 and 2024-25, to fund sewer relining projects.
891
Proposed Rate Structure
Single-Family Pi0opci-lies
- Fixed + Variable
Fixed - Provides funding for fixed expenditures (O&M).
Variable - Charges customers based on 70% or water usage. - Provides immediate stability because a portion of the sewer expenditures are fixed and helps cover the fixed costs.
Single-family customers provides 36% of revenue,
a Provides saving for water conservation by providing the variable rate component.
892
Proposed Rate Structure
Non-Single-Family Residential Properties
- Variable
a Charges customers based on 80% to 90% of water usage. - Customers have widely varying water use patterns; therefore, recommend retaining the current Variable Rate structure.
- Non-single-family properties include multi-family, commercial and industrial properties.
893
Alternative No. :i
5-Year Financial Plan Revenue Adjuslunent
Rate Adjustment
50% 30% 30% 10% 8%
Single-Family Rate
Fixed
Variable
Non-Single-Family Rate
Multi-Family
Commercial
Industrial/Other
SO.OO
S0.35
S0.35
S0.35
S0.35
S2.47
50.24 S0.55
50.55 S0.62
S3.22
S0.32
50.72 S0.72
S0.81
S4.19
S0.42
5o.gq
50.94 S1.06
54.61 S0.47
S1.04
S1.04
S1.17
S4.98
S0.51
S1.13
S1.27
S1.27
Avei-age Bill by Sector
Single-Family
Multi-Family
s A : I # ,.'!
10 hCf S3.50 S4.87 S6.42 S8.39 59.31 910.08
28hCf S9.80 S15.40 S20.16 S26.32 S29.12 S31.64
38 hCf S13.30
894
Alternative No. 1- Revenue Adjustment
Sewer Fund Reserves
Fund Balance Ending Balance Reserve Target
FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027
Note: Reserve target reached in FY 2026-27.
895
Alternative No. 2
5-Year Financial Plan Revenue Adjustment
Revenue Adjustments
10% 10% 5%
Single-Family Rate
Fixed
Variable
Non-Single-Family Rate
50.00 S0.35
S3.29
S0.32
S3.62
50.36 S3.99
S0.40
54.19 S0.42
S4.28
S0.43
Industrial/Other S0.35 S0.83 S0.92
Average Bill by Seclor
S1.02 S1.08 91.11
Single-Family Rate
Multi-Family
Commercial
Industrial/Other
10 hcf S6.49 S7.22 S7.99 S8.39 S8.58
38 hcf S13.30 S28.12 S31.16 S34.48 S36.48 S37.24
896
Alternative No. 2 - Revenue Adjustixient
Sewer Fund Reserves
Fund Baance Ending Bafflance Resewe Target
510
6C14
{SO2)
(SO4)
FY 2027
(SO6)
Note: Reservetarget reached in FY 2026-27.
897
Alternative No. 3
5-Year Financial Plan Revenue Adjuslunents
Revenue Adjustments
Single-Family Rate
Variable 50.35 S0.28 S0.37 S0.41 S0.42 50.43
Multi-Family
Co
Industrial/Other
S0.35 S0.64 50.84 S0.93 S0.95 S0.97
S0.35 S0.72 S0.94 51.04 S1.07 51.10
Single-Family Rate
Multi-Family
Commercial
Industrial/Other
Average Bill by Sector
10 hcf S3.50 S5.68 S7.45 S8.39 S8.42 S8.61
38 hcf 513.30 S24.32 S31.92 S35.34 S36.10 S36.86
ll
898
Alternative No. 3 - Revenue Adjustuient
Sewer Fund Reserves
Fund Balance EndlngBafflan.ce ResenreTarget
SO6
!;04
5.02 SOO
(SO2)
(Sa4)
FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026
(SO6)
Note: Reserve target reached in FY 2026-27.
899
Alternative No. 2 Recommended
Revenue Adjustments
Single-Family Rate
Variable
Non-Si
Multi-Family
S0.35
S0.35
50.32 90.74
S0.36
S0.82
S0.40
90.91 S0.42
S0.96
50.43 S0.98
Industrial/Other S0.35 50.83 S0.92
Average Bill by Scclur
51.02 51.08 51.11
.Use/Bill Yearl Year2 Year3 Year4 Year5
Single-Family Rate
Multi-Family
10 hcf S3.50 S6.49 S7.22 S7.99 S8.39 S8.58
Commercial 38 hcf S13.30 S28.12 S31.16 S34.48 S36.48 S37.24 Industrial/Other 165 hcf S57 75 S136 95 S151 80 S168 30 S178 20 5183 15 900
Sewer Rate Survey FY 2022-2023
South Gate (Existing Rates) Monthly SO.OO S0.35 hcf 53.50 South Gate - (Proposed Year 1 Increase) Monthly S3.29 S0.32 hcf S6.49 Torrance
Norwalk
Monthly
Monthly
S3.65
S7.58
50.33 SO.OO
ccf S6.95
S7.58
South Gate - (Proposed Year 5 Increase) Monthly S4.28 S0.43 hcf S8.58 Long Beach
Lynwood
Whittier
Redondo Beach
Monthly
Monthly
Annual
Monthly
S0.39
SO.OO
S1.11
SO.OO
hcf
ccf
Pomona
Manhattan Beach
Bi-Monthly
Bi-Monthly
S7.44
511.34
S0.67
S16.25
S11.19
S11.12
S0.83
51.27 hcf
hcf
S11.34
S11.34
S11.77
S16.25
S19.49
S23.82
Note: South Gate rate increase based on Recommended Alternative No. 2. 901
Rate Survey with Comparative Cities
Residential Monthly Sewer Bill Comparison
$40.00
$35.00
$30.00
$25.00
$20.00
$15.00
$10.00
$5.00
$0.00
southeatesoulhca'e
Current - Proposed Scenario 1
Avg Total Bill $3.50 $10.08
aVariable Rate $3.50 $5.10
a Fixed Rate $0.00 $4.98
SouthGateSouthGate Redondo
-Proposed-Proposed Beach
Scenario 2 Scenario 3
$8.58 $8.61 $16.25
$4.30 $4.30 $0.00
$4.28 $4.31 $16.25
Long
Beach Pomona Torrance Norwalk Lynwood Whittier Man"a"an Beach $11.38 $13.90 $6.99 $7.58 $11.34 $11.77 $18.26
$3.94 $8.30 $3.34 $0.00 $0.00 $11.10 $12.70
$7.44 $5.60 $3.65 $7.58 $11.34 $0.67 $5.56
Bills calculated using South Gate average SFR use of 10 hcf/month 902
Prop 218 Process to Increase Rates
o Sewer rate increases are subject to Prop 218. Sewer rates are property-related fees which constitute taxes, which may not be increased without certain public approvals. a Section 6 ofArticle Xlll D, pertaining to "Property Related Fees and Charges" outlines requirements to increases fees.
> Mailing a notice to all property owners with pertinent information (proposed increase, structure, reasoning, and time and place for the Public Hearing). > Hold Public Hearing and consider all testimony given and accept all protests filed by written notice or testifying at the public hearing.
> If a majority protest exists (50% plus one), rates may not be increased by Council action.
> If a majority protest does not exist, Council may adopt a rate increase. 16 - There are approximately 15,526 parcels within the City; therefore, it would take receiving approximately 7,7ei4 votes in opposition to a fee increase. 903
Sewer Rate Study
Questions
17 904
apChkLst
06/07/2023 8:27:45AM
CnYMANMa4Walsms FORCOUNCILMEETING6/27/2023
JUN40 2023 FinalCheCkLiSt
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
PARTI
Page: 1
Invoice
AMERICAN FIDELlTYASSURANCIBen315940
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
101448 6/8/2023 00002417
Voucher:
101449 6/8/2023 0011469
Voucher:
101450 6/8/2023 0012107
Voucher:
101451 6/8/2023 00000438
Voucher:
101452 6/8/2023 00002138
Voucher:
101453 6/8/2023 00002421
Voucher:
101454 6/8/2023 00000335
Voucher:
101455 6/8/2023 0011466
Voucher:
101456 6/8/2023 0011467
Voucher:
101457 6/8/2023 00003152
Voucher:
101458 6/8/2023 0011468
Voucher:
101459 6/8/2023 00000334
Voucher:
CALIFORNIA DENTAL NETWORK, Ben315936
CALIFORNIA STATE DlSBURSEMFBen315950
POLICE MANAGEMENTASSOClABen315944
POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATIOThBen315948
PRINCIPAL LIFE INSURANCE CO. Ben315928
UNITED WAY OF GREATER LOS ABen315938
SUPERIOR VISION SERVICES, lNBen315932
SOUTH GATE POLICE EXPLOREFBen315942
COLONIAL INSURANCE CO.
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD
RELIANCE STANDARD
12 checks in this report.
Ben315934
Ben315946
Ben315930
Inv Date Description
6/8/2023 AMERICAN FIDELITY (ABT): PAYf
Amount Paid
219.22
6/8/2023 CALIFORNIA DENTAL NETWORK 3,028.85
6/8/2023 CA STATE DISB. UNIT: PAYMENT 529.37
6/8/2023 COLONIAL INSURANCE CO: PAYI 2,466.04
6/8/2023 GARNISHMENT - FRANCHISE TA 393.57
6/8/2023 POLICE MANAGEMENT ASSOC. 2,125.00
6/8/2023 POLICE ASSOCIATION DUES: PA 6,375.00
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
PRINCIPAL DENTAL PPO (MISC):
LONG TERM DISABILITY: PAYME
32,371 .25
5,275.15
6/8/2023 SGPD EXPLORER YOUTH PROG 675.00
6/8/2023 SUPERIOR VISION MISC.: PAYME 4,078.98
6/8/2023 UNITED WAY: PAYMENT 34.33
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST:
Grand Total All Checks:
Check Total
219.22
3,028.85
529.37
2,466.04
393.57
2,125.00
6,375.00
32,371 .25
5,275.15
675.00
4,078.98
34.33 57 571 .76
Page: 1
905
WARRANT REGISTER FOR COUNCIL MEETING 6/27/2023 PART II
apChkLst
06/07/2023 1:57:10PM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 1
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
101460 6/7/2023 0012980
Voucher:
1C11461 6/7/2023 00004934
Voucher:
101462 6/7/2023 00004869
Voucher:
101463 6/7/2023 00004578
Voucher:
101464 6/7/2023 00004865
Voucher:
1 €)1465 6/7/2023 00001280
Voucher:
Invoice Inv Date Descriotion
CHARTERCOMMUNICATIONS 116996701052123 5/21/2023 5/21/23-6/2/23:ACCT#116998701 GAS COMPANY 11379803536 06/2 5/25/2023
1379803627 06/23 5/24/2023
08340765364 06/2 5/23/2023
GOLDEN STATE WATER COMPAN63744100007 05/2 5/26/2023
537 441 00008 05/2 5/27 /2023
INTERWEST CONSULTING GROU80696 8/15/2022
77432 4/1 3/2023
79802 6/22/2022
SO CALIF EDISON 6/2/2023 6/2/2023
WILLDAN
101466 6/7/2023 0013664 YIFTEE,INC
Voucher:
00337180 1/11/2023
00337307 2/17/2023
00337179 1/11/2023
00337043 12/7/2022
4950 5/30/2023
BILLING PRD- 04/01/23-04/12/23
BILLING PRD- 04/01 /23-05/01 /23
BILLING PRD- 04/20/23-05/19/23
BILLING PRD- 4/04/23 -05/02/23
BILLING PRD- 4/04/23 -05/02/23
7/1/22-7/31/22 10420-10510 ATLAt
10420-10510 ATLANTIC AVENUE
6/1/22-6/30/22 10420-10510 ATLAJ
BILLING PRD MAY 2023/& OBF IN
11/28/22-12/31/23 CIP MANAGEM
1/3/23-1/27/23 CIP MANAGEMENT
11 /28/22-1 2/30/22 CIP MANAGEM.
11/2/22-11/5/23 CIP MANAGEMEN
YIFTEE, INC DIGITAL GIFT CARD
Amount Paid
2,698.25
8,429.61
8,174.96
36.60 206.66
204.66
24,644.04
5,851 .00
5,612.00
123,605.30
24,960.00
18,910.00
8,580.00
7,410.00
240,000.00
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST:
Check Total
2,698.25
16,641.17
411.32
36,107.04
123,605.30
59,860.00
240,000.00
479,323.08
7 checks in this report. Grand Total All Checks: 479,323.08 Page: 1
906
WARRANT REGISTER FOR COUNCIL MEETING 6/27/2023 PART Ill apChkLst
06/1 5/2023 7:14:1 4AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 1
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
101468 6/14/2023 00003529
Voucher:
101469 6/14/2023 0012980
Voucher:
101470 6/14/2023 0010237
Voucher:
101471 6/14/2023 00004934
Voucher:
101472 6/14/2023 00004869
Voucher:
101473 6/14/2023 0008655
Voucher:
101474 6/14/2023 00004578
Voucher:
101475 6/14/2023 00004865
Voucher:
101476 6/14/2023 00001848
Voucher:
Invoice Inv Date Description
AT&T 960 449-6558-06/; 6/1 /2023
CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS 0044267052723 5/27/2023
FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS 209-057-1084-067; 6/1/2023
GAS COMPANY 094 300 7500 3 6/: 6/5/2023
HYDROSCIENTIFIC WEST
GOLDEN STATE WATER COMPAN73744100006 6/23 6/5/2023
637441000076/23 6/5/2023
33744100000 06/2 6/5/2023
53744100008 6/5/2023
290074473106/23 6/5/2023
2048 1/18/2023
2050 2/8/2023
20441 /3/2023 1 /3/2023
2052 2/8/2023
2049 1tr6/2023
2046 1/10/2023
INTERWEST CONSULTING GROU87620 5/12/2023
SO CALIF EDISON 6/5/2023 6/5/2023
VERIZON WIRELESS 9930870494 3/23/2023
BILLING PRD- JUNE 2023
MAY 2023: # 8448 20 899 004426?
BILLING - 06/01 /23-06/30/23
BILLING PRD- PAST DUE 09/16/2:
BILLING PRD- 05/02/23-06/02/23
BILLING PRD- 05/02/23-06/02/23
BILLING PRD- 05/02/23-06/02/23
BILLING PRD- 05/02/23-06/02/23
BILLING PRD- 05/02/23-06/02/23
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
AS-NEEDED CONTRACT SCADA
APR 2023: 10420-10510 ATLANTI(
BILLING PRD MAY/JUNE 2023/& (
BILLING PRD- 02/24/23-03/23/23-
Amount Paid
i ,095.35
311.46
161.87
833.29
159.81
1833.11
281 .07
241 .87
79.90 6,820.00
4,590.00
2,550.00
2,330.00
2,126.25
1 ,805.00
218.50
78,601 .49
8,415.29
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST:
Check Total
1,095.35
311.46
161 .87
833.29
2,595.76
20 ,221 .25
21 8.50
78,601 .49
8,415.29
112,454.26
9 checks in this report. Grand Total All Checks: 112,454.26 Page: 1
907
WARRANT REGISTER FOR COUNCIL MEETING 6/27/2023
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
101477 6/27/2023 0012450
Voucher:
101478 6/27/2023 00001467
Voucher:
101479 6/27/2023 00004372
Voucher:
101480 6/27/2023 0011577
Voucher:
101481 6/27/2023 0013987
Voucher:
101482 6/27/2023 00000018
Voucher:
101483 6/27/2023 0011339
Voucher:
101484 6/27/2023 00000201
Voucher:
101485 6/27/2023 0009040
Voucher:
101486 6/27/2023 0010585
Voucher:
101487 6/27/2023 0011336
Voucher:
Invoice
129 BUILDERS INC 301
AIRGAS USA, LLC
ADMINISTRATIVE SERV. CO-OP 16024
16214
16406
9138278327
9138196678
ALL PHASE ELECTRIC SUPPLY C 0946-1064059
0946-1066095
ALL STAR GLASS LLC 1HAO30750
AMERICAN RENTAL INC.
AQUA FLO SUPPLY
531310
529173
530376
531385
S12115920
ATLANTIC LOCK & KEY 00674
ATLAS BACKFLOW
AUTOZONE STORES, INC.
AVANT-GARDE INC.
41586
41585
41656
5488124714
5488062618
5488137669
5488127093
5488081837
5488083468
5488062620
8441
8529
8528
8272
8350
Inv Date Description
5/25/2023 REPAIR AT 4100 FIRESTONE SE(
2 /28/2023
3 /31 /2023
4 /30/2023
5 /22/2023
5/1 8/2023
5/2/2023
5/26/2023
4/21/2023
5/30/2023
4 /27/2023
5 /26/2023
5/26/2023
5/24/2023
FEB 2023: FIESTATAXI- FOOD IN
MAR 2023: FIESTATAXI- FOOD H'
APR 2023: FIESTATAXI- FOOD Ih
DISTRIBUTATION OF SPECIALTY
DISTRIBUTATION OF SPECIALTY
ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, MATE
ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, MATE
AUTOMOTIVE GLASS REPAIR Ah
MISC EQUIPMENT RENTAL
MISC EQUIPMENT RENTAL
MISC EQUIPMENT RENTAL
MISC EQUIPMENT RENTAL
MEDIAN WATER CONTROLLER II
5/22/2023 SPECIALIZED KEYS FOR THE DE
5/1 /2023
5/1 /2023
5/25/2023
5/23/2023
3/22/2023
6/5/2023
5/25/2023
4/1 0/2023
4 /1 3/2023
5 /1 5/2023
5/1 5/2023
3/6/2023
3/20/2023
MISC
MISC
MISC
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
APR 2023: PSA WITH AVANT GAF
APR 2023: CDBG- ADMIN P/S
APR 2023: CDBG- ADMIN P/S
JAN 2023: PSA WITH AVANT GAR
FEB 2023: PSA WITH AVANT GAP
Amount Paid
1 ,g!)o.oo
596.20
576.40
605.50
837.11
221 .06
480.25
467.18
294.04
829.13
427.06
1,139.75
875.00
9,951.18
259.08
1 ,350.80
698.99
520.00
65.13 103.62
122.38
58.92 54.57
-187.41
-103.62
10,620.00
9,907.50
1 ,476.25
2 20.00
4,272.50
PART IV
Page: 6
Check Total
1 ,950.00
1,778.10
1,058.17
947.43
294.04
3,270.94
9,951.18
259.08
2,569.79
113.59
26,496.25
Page:6
908
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 7
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor
101488 6/27/2023 0014027
Voucher:
101489 6/27/2023 0011066
Voucher:
101490 6/27/2023 0012979
Voucher:
101491 6/27/2023 00004202
Voucher:
101492 6/27/2023 00000759
Voucher:
101493 6/27/2023 0013228
Voucher:
101494 6/27/2023 0008684
Voucher:
101495 6/27/2023 0006239
Voucher:
101496 6/27/2023 0005839
Voucher:
101497 6/27/2023 0012980
Voucher:
101498 6/27/2023 00005090
Voucher:
101499 6/27/2023 00001364
Voucher:
101500 6/27/2023 0013322
Voucher:
Invoice Inv Date Description
BARBER, SUZANNE Ref000316l27 5/23/2023
BARNETT, RHONDA
BRENNTAG PACIFIC INC
CALIFORNIA FRAME & AXLE
BP1331262
BP1331260
BP1331261
BP1331263
73368
CANON SOLUTIONS AMERICA 1N1148390008
CAPIO 18317
CENTRAL FORD 27738
27628
27 443 (27 432)
31857
27573
32029
27546
CHAMPION CHRYSLER JEEP DO1689455
689243
CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS 0439993052023
5/11/2023
5/11 /2023
5/11 /2023
5 /11 /2023
6 /5/2023
UB REFUND CST #00064499 - 10!
FORFIT FEE (NESTOR GARCIA-E
FORFIT FEE (MIGUEL VIDAL-CLL
FORFIT FEE (ARMANDO RODRI(
PROPOSAL 50346 - CONVERGETh
SODIUM HYPOCHLORITE 12.5%
SODIUM HYPOCHLORITE 12.5%
SODIUM HYPOCHLORITE 12.5%
SODIUM HYPOCHLORITE 12.5%
GARAGE REPAIRS
4/26/2023 PLOnER PRINTER PAPER & IN}
5/23/2023 2024 CAPIO MEMBERSHIP DUES
6/5/2023
5/31 /2023
5/31 /2023
5/22/2023
5/1 9/2023
5/24/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
5/20/2023
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
DEALER PARTS FOR CHARGER
DEALER PARTS FOR CHARGER
MAY-JUN 2023: ACCT# 5448 30 0a
CITY OF PARAMOUNT
CLEAN FUELS INC.
5/24/23WATER 5/24/2023 3/14/23-5/15/23:13652GARFIELD
23-1355 6/5/2023 CLEAN DIESEL FUELTANKS
COLUMBIA CAPITAL MANAGEME1231000001 5/25/2023 APR 2023: COLUMBIA CAPITAL V Amount Paid
i38.80
70.00 70.00
60.00 2,257.98
1 ,021 .96
1 ,218.04
359.12
925.30
110.00
178.72
400.00
282.39
71 .og
166.03
759.58
195.00
1 ,801 .21
127.82
411.84
185.68
134.99
74.24 5,381 .93
2,000.00
Check Total
138.80
200.00
2,257.98
3,524.42
110.00
178.72
400.00
3,403.12
597.52
134.99
74.24 5,381 .93
2,000.00
Page:7
909
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 8
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check# Date Vendor Invoice InvDate
101501 6/27/2023 0011922 CONCENTRAMEDICALCENTERE79188471 5/3/2023 Voucher:
101502 6/27/2023 00005110 COUNTYOFL.A.DEPTOFPW RE-PW-23050806:5/8/2023 Voucher:
101503 6/27/2023 0013893 CPACINC.COM Sl-1296878 4/14/2023 Voucher:
101504 6/27/2023 00001303 CPRS 5/5/2023 5/5/2023
Voucher:
101505 6/27/2023 00003660 CRAFCO,INC. 9402861015 1/17/2023 Voucher:
101506 6/27/2023 0013773 CROSSTOWN ELECTRICAL & DA-4900-OC11 4/19/2023 Voucher:
101507 6/27/2023 0013718 CSI FORENSIC SUPPLY LLC SOUTHGATEPD-C 5/25/2023 Voucher:
101508 6/27/2023 00001423 DAILY JOURNALCORPORATION B3703675 5/25/2023 Voucher:
101509 6/27/2023 0010459 DANCOTOOL&SUPPLY 6613 5/18/2023 Voucher: 6614 5/18/2023
101510 6/27/2023 00000314 DAPEERROSENBLIT&LITVAKLL21203 1/31/2023 Voucher: 21526 4/30/2023
21331 2/28/2023
21430 3/31/2023
101511 6/27/2023 00000175 DOOLEYENTERPRISES,INC. 65692 5/31/2023 Voucher:
101512 6/27/2023 00004129 EMERGENCY RESPONSE CRIMET2023-377 5/30/2023 Voucher:
101513 6/27/2023 0013901 EMP: CASTANEDA, GERARLD 6/6/23 D3 CERTIF 6/6/2023 Voucher:
101514 6/27/2023 0014019 EMP:FETULI,ALEXANDER ORD-1089 5/23/2023 Voucher:
101515 6/27/2023 0010017 ENTERPRISEFMTRUST FBN4770463 6/3/2023 Vpucher: FBN4770402 6/3/2023
101516 6/27/2023 0013810 EXECUTIVEMANAGEMENT,SECI23-146 4/24/2023 Voucher: 23-130 4/11/2023
Descriotion AmountPaid
05/03-05/082023MEDICALSERV 1,570.00
APRIL 2023 TRAFFIC MAINT DDG
APC SMART UPS SRT 3000VA BA
CPRS MEMBERSHIP FOR RECR(
EMERGENCY COLD PATCH FOR
WRIGHT RD & PENDLETON AVE.
FINGERPRINT SUPPLIES, PROPI
CUP #854 CHILD DAY CARE FAC
PNEUMATIC WRENCH FOR TRAF
EQUIPMENT MAINTENANCE AN[:
MUNICIPAL CODE COMPLIANCE
MUNICIPAL CODE COMPLIANCE
MUNICIPAL CODE COMPLIANCE
MUNICIPAL CODE COMPLIANCE
AMMUNITIONS
CRIME AND TRAFFIC BIO HAZAFi
REIMB: D3 CERTIFICATION
REIMB: IMSATRAFFIC SIGNALTI
JUN 2023: PD LEASED VEHICLEJUN 2023: PD LEASED VEHICLE4/9/23-4/22/23 24-HR SECURITY ( 3/26/23-4/8/23 24-HR SECURITY" (
509.10
8,154.09
q,:go.oo
5,593.74
16,624.00
44.25 150.00
2,805.00
583.00
10,315.76
4,145.33
7,872.96
7,553.50
5,198.94
750.00
90.00 550.00
q,979.94
3,097.89
10,080.00
10,080.00
Check Total
1 ,570.00
509.10
8,154.09
I ,:go.oo
5,593.74
16,624.00
44.25 150.00
3,388.00
29,887.55
5,198.94
750.00
go.oo
550.00
5,077.83
20,160.00
Page:8
910
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 9
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor
101517 6/27/2023 00001988
Voucher:
101518 6/27/2023 00000619
Voucher:
101519 6/27/2023 00002026
Voucher:
101520 6/27/2023 0014024
Voucher:
101521 6/27/2023 0010354
Voucher:
101522 6/27/2023 0005303
Voucher:
101523 6/27/2023 00002304
Voucher:
101524 6/27/2023 0013185
Voucher:
101525 6/27/2023 0010016
Voucher:
101526 6/27/2023 00002890
Voucher:
101527 6/27/2023 00002568
Voucher:
101528 6/27/2023 00002577
Voucher:
101529 6/27/2023 0011526
Voucher:
101530 6/27/2023 0014025
Voucher:
Invoice
FAIR HOUSING FOUNDATION
FALCON FUELS, INC.
8-2023
10-2023
59150
59121
FEDERAL EXPRESS CORPORATl8-069-65328
8-136-57269
8-135-93197
8-006-55499
8-107-97918
FLORES, PABLO Ref000316l23
FRlnS FORD FO3206
FO3190
FULLERENGINEERINGINC 148283A
GENERALPUMPCOMPANY 27315-R
14403-RET
GILMAN CONSTRUCTION MEDIA 2472
GRAINGER
GLOBAL PARATRANSIT INC. 112223-09
112223-10
9679952516
9697451244
9679952508
HAAKER EQUIPMENT COMPANY C1 A5GW
HACH COMPANY 13302433
HASA, INC.
HERRERA, BRENDA
889356
889353
889354
889355
Ref000316l24
Inv Date Description
3/7/2023
5/9/2023
5/31 /2023
5/31 /2023
5/16/2023
5/1 9/2023
5/1 9/2023
1/13/2023
3/21 /2023
5/23/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
4/al2/2023
5/1 /2023
5/1 /2023
4/30/2023
3/31 /2023
4 /30/2023
4 /1 9/2023
5/4/2023
4/1 9/2023
5/25/2023
2/2023 CDBG SUBRECIPIENT- F/)
4/2023 CDBG SUBRECIPIENT- FA
ULTRA LOW SULFUR DISEL & S/'
REGULAR UNLEADED FUEL & S/
FEDEX PRIORITY OVERNIGHT
FEDEX STANDARD OVERNIGHT
FEDEX STANDARD OVERNIGHT
FEDEX PRIORITY OVERNIGHT T
FEDEX STANDARD OVERNIGHT
UB REFUND CST #00064710 - 84-
ELECTRICAL SUPERVISOR TRU(
ELECTRICAL SUPERVISOR TRU(
CHEMICALS SUPPLIES FOR PO(
RETENTION ON PO #0004970 INI
RELEASE OF RETENTION - PO #
PROVIDE GCMEDIA 4K CONSTR
MAR 2023: PROVIDE TRANSIT SF
APR 2023: PROVIDE TRANSIT SE
SPECIALTY HARDWARE
SPECIALTY HARDWARE
SPECIALTY HARDWARE
SPECIAL SEWER EQUIPMENT
10/25/2022 ANALYZER MAINTENANCE AND I
5/25/2023
5/25/2023
5/25/2023
5/25/2023
5/23/2023
WATER TREATMENT CHEMICALE
WATER TREATMENT CHEM1CAL5
WATER TREATMENT CHEMICALE
WATER TREATMENT CHEMICALE
UB REFUND CST #00063600 - 92
Amount Paid
1 ,882.52
1 ,947.90
4 ,023.52
5 ,583.03
9.03 97.23
8.17 8.74
9.73 18.11
56,386.94
58,058.33
1,272.17
1 ,728.75
8,932.25
339.00
58,511 .82
57,394.57
598.00
223.21
528.30
453.88
4,039.00
1 ,047.53
793.50
1 ,047.53
1 ,018.72
2 5.09
Check Total
3,830.42
9,606.55
132.90
18.11 114,445.27
1,272.17
10,661 .00
339.00
q15,906.39
1 ,349.51
453.88
4,039.00
3,907.28
25.09 Page: 9
911
apChkLst Final Check List Page: 10
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor Invoice Inv Date Description
101531 6/27/2023 00000268
Voucher:
101532 6/27/2023 0011882
Voucher:
101533 6/27/2023 0013857
HOMEDEPOTCREDITSERVICESO374712 5/22/2023 MISCSUPPLIES
6343302-2023 5/16/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
8343369 5/24/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
2362550-2023 5/30/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
0374703 5/22/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
0343431 6/1/2023 STREETSUPPLIES
1374574 5/1/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
5374548 4/27/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
5374669 5/17/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
5374670 5/17/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
7354462 5/15/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
1374626 5/11/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
1374628 5/11/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
1374629 5/11/2023 GENERALMAINTENANCE-MISC
2374775 5/30/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
9343358 5/23/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
7362534 5/25/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
6374745 5/26/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
1373920 1/31/2023 MISCSUPPLIES
INLANDROUNDBALLOFFICIALS50351661-FORFIT5/19/2023 FORFITFEE(JOSEPHCHAVARR 49243998-FORFIT 5/19/2023 FORFIT FEE (ALEJANDRO HERN
INTERAINCORPORATED 04-23-233 5/16/2023 3/1/23-4/30/23:ENGINEERINGDE Voucher:
101534 6/27/2023 00004578 INTERWEST CONSULTING GROU87619 5/12/2023 APR2023:SOCALGASMAINREI Voucher:
101535 6/27/2023 0013816 JO GO TOOLS LLC 05022334185 5/2/2023 PROVIDES AUTOMOTIVE SPECI/ Voucher:
101536 6/27/2023 0005586 JOE A. GONSALVES & SONS 160760 5/17/2023 JUN 2023: LEGISLATIVE STATE L Voucher:
101537 6/27/2023 00000430 JOHN L. HUNTER AND ASSOC1ATSG1UOR12304 5/13/2023 APR 2023: MANAGEMENT OF TH Voucher: SG1MS412304 5/31/2023 APR2023:PROFESSIONALSER\ Amount Paid
1,127.61
386.57
81 .20
165.67
72.37 142.84
q'i4.49
30.46 567.70
532.50
60.52 64.74
47.66 384.70
191.37
90.75 36.63
21 .92
177.08
70.00 70.00
26,652.00
5,625.00
392.49
2,500.00
937.50
12,764.70
Check Total
4,356.78
140.00
26,652.00
5,625.00
392.49
2,500.00
13,702.20
101538 6/27/2023 0012510 KILEY & ASSOCIATES, LLC SG230531 5/31/2023 MAY2023:AMENDNO2TOCON' 3,333.33 3,333.33 Voucher:
Page: 10
912
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 1l
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor
101539 6/27/2023 0007294 KOACORPORATION
Voucher:
101540 6/27/2023 0008150
Voucher:
101541 6/27/2023 0006905
Voucher:
101542 6/27/2023 00000488
Voucher:
101543 6/27/2023 0013343
Voucher:
101544 6/27/2023 0011962
Voucher:
101545 6/27/2023 0013778
Voucher:
101546 6/27/2023 00004093
Voucher:
101547 6/27/2023 0013848
Voucher:
101548 6/27/2023 0013562
Voucher:
101549 6/27/2023 00000447
Voucher:
101550 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101551 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101552 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101553 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101554 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
L.N. CURTIS & SONS
Invoice
JC2100-3
JCffl 48-13
JC36051-1
JCffl48-12
1NV706304
Inv Date Description
5/1 9/2023
5/1 0/2023
2/27/2023
4 /i 3/2023
5 /1 8/2023
APR 2023: PROFESSIONAL SER\
APR 2023: PROFESSIONAL ENGI
1 /30/23-2/26/32:6509 SG INSPECT
2 /27/23-4/2/23: PROFESSIONAL E
UNIFORM AND ACCESSORIES
LA COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTA232996BL 5/12/2023 FOODFORTHEJAIL LINDE GAS & EQUIPMENT INC. 32557033 11/22/2022 SPECIALTYPOOLPARTS LITTLEJOHN COMMUNICATIONS,06012023 6/1 /2023 MAY 2023: SERVICES FOR INMAMCA DIRECT
MEDINA, FRANCISCA
MELAD & ASSOCIATES
MICHAEL ALAN HEIDER
2023044
Ref000316125
SG23-12
SG23-13
SG23-14
01 5/31/2023 ARCHVALRECORDPAPER
5/23/2023 UBREFUNDCST#00045379-49:
5/11 /2023
5 /11 /2023
6 /1 /2023
5/24/2023
3/9/23: T.I. FOR SGPD DETECTIVI
5/10/23: T.I.SGPD DETECTIVE BU
MAY 2023: MELAD & ASSOCIATE
MAY 2023: CONSULTING SERVIC
MIKE CABRERA CORPORATION INV-0000255 5/24/2023 QUARTERLY PRINTING OF CONr
MISC - BLDG PERMITS
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
222275/223255 5/25/2023 REFUND: 2443 ILLNOIS AVE. & 8
13455-VALDEZ i/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 255358-MARTINE. 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 288583/307861 4/26/2023 ETRAK CREDIT MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 13276-PEREZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 250710-PLASCEN 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT Amount Paid
4,036.08
30,472.64
692.00
30,320.51
195.46
540.25
115.41
100.00
269.89
55.21 375.00
150.00
19,815.02
7,966.00
17,518.00
97.60 198.00
164.00
160.00
128.00
128.00
Check Total
65,521 .23
195.46
540.25
115.41
100.00
269.89
55.21 20,340.02
7,966.00
17,518.00
97.60 198.00
164.00
160.00
128.00
128.00
Page: 11
913
apChkLst
06/19/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 12
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
1 €)1555 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101556 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101557 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101558 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101559 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101560 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101561 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101562 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher
101563 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101564 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101565 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101566 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101567 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101568 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101569 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101570 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101571 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
(Continued)
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
Invoice
13586-AVILA
Inv Date Description
1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
251167-DOTOR i/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
13458-RUIZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
250748-SANCHE2 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
26942al-SANCHE2 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
286256-HENRIQU 4/25/2023 ETRAK 286256, 290486, 295616 F 282506-PARADA 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
240732-DELGAD( 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
240665-ESPARZA 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
13580-MARGAROi 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
274488-RAMIREZ 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
244614-VALDEZ-( 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
293599/300323 4/26/2023 ETRAK REFUND
238807-GUZMAN 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
281999-GOMEZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
275369-LEON 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
282532-ZARATE 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
Amount Paid
108.00
100.00
gg.oo
gg.oo
99.00 90.00
68.78 64.00
64.00 64.00
64.00 64.00
60.00 60.00
55.00 55.00
55.00 Check Total
i08.00
100.00
99.00 99.00
gg.oo
go.oo
68.78 64.00
64.00 64.00
64.00 64.00
60.00 60.00
55.00 55.00
55.00 Page: 12
914
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
101572 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101573 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101574 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101575 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101576 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101577 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101578 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101579 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101580 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101581 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101582 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101583 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101584 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101585 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101586 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101587 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
101588 6/27/2023 00000170
Voucher:
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
MISC - PKS & REC REFUND
(Continued)
Invoice Inv Date Descriotion
266093-BARRON[ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
238962-BERNAL 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
12744-GONZALEZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
275212-MENDEZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
12226-PONCE 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
13440-RODRIGUE 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
12738-ROMAN 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
239827-SALAS 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
243949-VASQUE2 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
12364-DAVILA-RUI 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
244632-DELEON 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
274612-PERZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
282033-ORTIZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
243486-HERMOSI 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
12797-MOLINA 1/27/2023 ETRAK CREDIT
276530-MENDEZ 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
244360-MARTINE. 1/27/2023 ETRAKCREDIT
Page: 13
Amount Paid
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 49.50
49.50 48.00
45.00 39.00
38.00 32.00
30.00 Check Total
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 50.00
50.00 49.50
49.50 48.00
45.00 39.00
38.00 32.00
30.00 Page: 13
915
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 14
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check# Date Vendor Invoice InvDate
101589 6/27/2023 00000170 MISC-PKS&RECREFUND 27440BARAJAS 1/27/2023 Voucher:
101590 6/27/2023 00000170 MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 247970-GUTIERR 1/27/2023 Voucher:
101591 6/27/2023 00000170 MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 248001-PAREDEE: i/27/2023 Voucher:
1C11592 6/27/2023 00000170 MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 274487-ANGUIAN 1/27/2023 Voucher:
101593 6/27/2023 00000170 MISC - PKS & REC REFUND 258494-SOLORZ)- 1/27/2023 Voucher:
101594 6/27/2023 00003664 MISC-SETTLEMENTS HELLEBRANDT 6/1/2023 Voucher:
101595 6/27/2023 0014030 MONROY, CARIDAD Ref0003l6130 5/23/2023 Voucher:
101596 6/27/2023 0006941 MOSTDEPENDABLEFOUNTAINSINV73211 5/17/2023 Voucher:
101597 6/27/2023 00004969 NATIONALREADYMIXEDCONCFi861920 5/18/2023 Voucher:
101598 6/27/2023 00003591 NORTHSTARGRAPHICS 1957A 5/10/2023 Voucher: 1957 5/10/2023
101599 6/27/2023 0009134 NORTHGATEMARKET 96912 3/26/2023 Voucher:
101600 6/27/2023 0012202 NUMANETWORKS 34553 6/1/2023
Voucher:
101601 6/27/2023 0013096 0FFICETEAM 61922387 4/27/2023
Voucher: 61951407 5/3/2023
61877572 4/18/2023
61961213 5/8/2023
61978044 5/9/2023
62C)12521 5/16/2023
62045510 5/23/2023
61877570 4/18/2023
61922388 4/27/2023
61951410 5/3/2023
Description
ETRAL CREDOT
ETRAK CREDIT
ETRAK CREDIT
ETRAK CREDIT
ETRAK CREDIT
PAYMENT OF SEnLEMENT AMC
UB REFUND CST #00063874 - 95:
REPAIR PARTS FOR DRINKING F
CONCRETE, SAND AND AGGRE(
EMBLEMS FOR VEHICLES
DECALS/GRAPHICS FOR PD AU1
MAR 2023: FOOD INSECURITY P
JUN 2023: BACKUP AND DISASTI
W/E 4/21 /23: ROBERT HALF TALE
W/E 4/28/23: ROBERT HALF TALE
W/E 4tl 4/23: ROBERT HALF TALE
W/E 5/8/23: ROBERT HALF TALETh
W/E 5/5/23: ROBERT HALF TALEi
W/E 5/12/23: ROBERT HALF TALE
5/19/23: ROBERT HALF TALENT E
W/E 4/1 4/23: ROBERT HALF TALE
W/E4/21/23: ROBERTHALFTALI
W/E 4/28/23: ROBERT HALF TALE
Amount Paid
24.75 24.75
24.75 24.75
21 .00
40,000.00
156.75
2,234.44
1,126.97
181.91
716.63
11,300.74
2,000.00
960.00
1 ,:so.oo
1,120.00
1,152.00
1 ,440.00
1 ,680.00
1 ,920.00
1 ,860.00
I ,soo.oo
1 ,g:o.oo
Check Total
24.75 24.75
24.75 24.75
21 .00
40,000.00
156.75
2,234.44
1,126.97
898.54
11,300.74
2,000.00
15,132.00
Page: 14
916
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 15
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor Invoice
101602 6/27/2023 0007984
Voucher:
101603 6/27/2023 0014026
Voucher:
101604 6/27/2023 0014028
Voucher:
101605 6/27/2023 00002769
Voucher:
101606 6/27/2023 0010825
Voucher:
101607 6/27/2023 0009862
Voucher:
101608 6/27/2023 00004142
Voucher:
101609 6/27/2023 00004713
Voucher:
O'REILLY AUTO PARTS
ORIHUELA, JESUS
3063- 15973
3063- 02152
3063- 4810
3063- 4043
3063- 4919
3063- 4908
3063- 5765
3063- 5780
3063- 09286
3063- 14902
3063- 11125
3063- 09860
3063- 14684
3063- 15058
3063- 15761
3063- 03957
3063- 09415
3063- 10100
3063- 14026
3063- 14955
3063- 14964
Ref000316126
PADILLA, MARLON & ERIKA Ref0003l6128
PARIS LASER PRINTER REPAIR 29359
PD: BETETA, ISAAC 1-3665
PD: MEZA - MEDRANO, SARA 1-3665
PD: NAVARRO, RICARDO 1-3664
PETTY CASH- PARKS & REC.DEP5/1 0/23-6/1 /23
6/6/23-6/7/23
Inv Date Description
5/31 /2023
3/1 /2023
5/23/2023
5/1 8/2023
5/24/2023
5/24/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
4 /17/2023
5/24/2023
4/28/2023
4 /20/2023
5/22/2023
5/25/2023
5/30/2023
5/23/2023
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
AUTO PARTS
REPLACEMENT TRANSMISSION
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVOI
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVO
CREDIT: CORE RETURN, INVOIC
UB REFUND CST #00064646 - 92:
5/23/2023 UBREFUNDCST#00056809-10-
5/18/2023 REPAIRS FOR PRINTER - BUILDI
6/2/2023
6/2/2023
6/2/2023
6/6/2023
6/7/2023
REIMB: MILAGE - MAY 8-9,2023 -
REIMB: MILAGE - ,AY 8-9, 2023 IC
REIMB: MILAGE & PER DIEM - AF
5/1 0/23-6/1 /23: PETTY" CASH PAR
6/6/23-6/7 /23: PETTY CASH PARK
Amount Paid
80.18 83.55
42.56 14.85
39.55 52.40
38.94 135.49
54.70 198.44
15.42 7.46
59.52 31 .53
3,528.00
- 80.58
-26.76
-293.02
-163.22
-31 .45
-22.00
92.07 141.15
293.37
192.57
192.57
187.62
346.26
435.28
Check Total
3,765.56
92.07 141.15
293.37
192.57
"i92.57
187.62
781 .54
Page: 15
917
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 16
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor Invoice
101610 6/27/2023
Voucher:
1CY611 6/27/2023
Voucher:
101612 6/27/2023
Voucher:
101613 6/27/2023
Voucher:
101614 6/27/2023
Voucher:
1C11615 6/27/2023
Voucher:
101616
101617
101618
101619
101620
101621
101622
101623
101624
101625
101626
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
6/27/2023
Voucher:
00004714
00002335
0011257
ooog:r3
0013659
00003721
00003736
0014029
00000416
0013627
0012962
00004773
0008275
00001840
00004776
00000495
0006505
PETTY CASH- POLICE DEPT. - 6/5/23-6/6/23
PITNEY BOWES MAY2023
PK: GUILMEnE, ROBERT RGspring0523
PK: MARTINEZ, GILBERT 2023-JULY
PK: SANCHEZ, ROCIO RGspring0623-1
PLUMBERS DEPOT INC. PD-53711
PD-53712
PD-53713
R.P. LAURAIN & ASSOCIATES 10041
RAMIREZ, HERMINIO Ref000316129
RAPID-O-PRINT 28381
RED WING BRANDS OF AMERICA20230510109693
REGIONALTAP SERVICE CENTE16019452
RET: ALMANZA, JOSEPH A JUNE 2023
RET: AROCHA, FRANCIS X. JUNE 2023
RET: BLASKA, WILLIAM MIKE JUNE 2023
RET: CARTER, LLOYD B JUNE 2023
RET: CHAVEZ, ANTHONY A JUNE 2023
RET: CORBET, RONALD JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/6/2023
6/5/2023
6/5/2023
6/1 2/2023
6/5/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
5/30/2023
4/27/2023
5/23/2023
5/30/2023
4/1 5/2023
4/30/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
2/24/23 -5/22/23 PETTY CASH Pa
MAY 2023: RESERVE ACCOUNTI
4/17/2023-5/10/2023 YOGA CLASE
SOUND SYSTEM OPERATOR FO
5/1 5/23-6/5/23 ZUMBA CLASSES
REPLACEMENT OF SEWER CAM
GAPVAX REPAIR AND PARTS
GAPVAX REPAIR AND PARTS
APPRAISAL FOR 3948 TWEEDY E
UB REFUND CST #00062882 - 93:
PERSONNELTRANSACTION FOF
SAFETY FOOTWEAR PROVIDER
APR 2023: TAP BUS PASES
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
Amount Paid
175.82
2,500.00
880.00
2,000.00
700.00
12,597.68
574.29
574.29
6,000.00
154.89
624.02
248.02
1 ,350.00
132.25
1 ,358.28
2 50.00
250.00
132.25
1 ,367.90
Check Total
175.82
2,500.00
880.00
2,000.00
700.00
13,7 46.26
6,000.00
154.89
624.02
248.02
1 ,350.00
132.25
1 ,358.28
2 50.00
250.00
132.25
1 ,367.90
Page: 16
918
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 17
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
RET: KOOPMANS, WILLIAM O. JUNE 2023
RET: GARCIA, VMAN M.
RET: GOMEZ, JOSEPH C.
RET: DELEON, RUBEN
RET: GALVAN, RAY A.
RET: HAMMOND, DONNA
Check # Date Vendor
101627 6/27/2023 00004777 RET: DAY, ROBERT A
Voucher:
101628 6/27/2023 0008746
Voucher:
101629 6/27/2023 0011326
Voucher:
101630 6/27/2023 0013282
Voucher:
101631 6/27/2023 0006508
Voucher:
101632 6/27/2023 0006509
Voucher:
101633 6/27/2023 0010881
Voucher:
101634 6/27/2023 0010410
Voucher:
101635 6/27/2023 00003833
Voucher:
101636 6/27/2023 00003798
Voucher:
101637 6/27/2023 00000458
Voucher:
101638 6/27/2023 00000459
Voucher:
101639 6/27/2023 00004127
Voucher:
101640 6/27/2023 0012665
Voucher:
101641 6/27/2023 0007637
Voucher:
RET: LEO, FRANK
RET: MOOMEY, STEVEN
RET: SEWELL, ELAINE
RET: RANGEL, ARMANDO
RSG, INC
RS SCREEN PRINTING &EMBROISGateSoftball23 5/30/2023
RIGEL PRODUCTS AND SERVICE4245
RET: SEWELL, KENNETH R
Invoice
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
1010103
1010041
1009923
1010281
1009688
1009654
1009535
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETlREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
5/24/2023 REPLACEMENT OF COBRA-COM
3/31 /2023
2/28/2023
1 /31 /2023
4/30/2023
12/31/2022
11/30/2022
10/31 /2022
STAFF UNIFORMS/ADULT SPORMAR 2023: EPA GRANT ASSISTAI
FEB 2023: EPA GRANT ASSISTAI'l
JAN 2023: EPA GRANT ASSISTAh
APR 2023: EPA GRANT ASSISTAf'
DEC 2022: EPA GRANT ASSISTAi
NOV 2022: EPA GRANT ASSISTAi
OCT 2022: EPA GRANT ASSISTAi
Amount Paid
250.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
132.25
150.00
150.00
150.00
518.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
6,984.34
3,996.21
3,775.00
3 ,760.00
4 ,472.50
3,661 .25
1 ,277.50
13,165.00
i116.25
Check Total
250.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
132.25
150.00
150.00
150.00
518.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
6,984.34
3,996.21
31 ,227.50
Page: 47
919
apChkLst
06/'1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 18
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check# Date Vendor Invoice
101642 6/27/2023 0009447 RWCGROUP XA301120346:01
Voucher: XA301122094:01
101643 6/27/2023 0012589 S&LINTERNATIONAL,INC. 69826
Voucher:
101644 6/27/2023 0013470 SAASSOCIATES WMR-PH1-07
Voucher:
101645 6/27/2023 00000322 SAM'SCLUB 002875
Voucher:
101646 6/27/2023 00004834 SECURITYSIGNALDEVICESSYSCM-817333 Voucher: S-01100566
S-01101409
101647 6/27/2023 0007073 SERGIO'SAUTOUPHOLSTERY 2974
Voucher: 2969
101648 6/27/2023 0012098 SOCALCOMPTONPIPESUPPLY1165
Voucher: 1158
101649 6/27/2023 0013837 SOFIVE,INC. SSCW1NTER223
Voucher:
101650 6/27/2023 00al4031 SRPSLP Ref000316131
Voucher:
101651 6/27/2023 00001068 STATE CONTROLLER'S OFFICE FTB-00005959 Voucher:
101652 6/27/2023 0009017 STATEWIDETRAFFICSAFETYANO2031661 Voucher:
101653 6/27/2023 00004908 STATUSONEMEDICALINC 66710
Voucher:
101654 6/27/2023 0013656 SUPERIORVISIONINSURANCE,1719037 Voucher: T14324
101655 6/27/2023 00003795 TANGENTCOMPUTER,INC. S1112863 Voucher:
101656 6/27/2023 0008109 THEORIGINALGOODIE'SUNIFOF9618
Voucher: 9588
9508
9580
101657 6/27/2023 00003851 THOMSONREUTERS 848jH2207
Voucher:
Inv Date Description
5/24/2023
4/28/2023
CREDIT: RETURNED ITEM, INVOI
SERVICE HEAVY DUTY TRUCK A
BARRACUDA EMAIL PROTECTIO
5/24/2023 3/1/23-4/30/23: WATER MAIN REP
5/18/2023 MISC SUPPLIES
5/7/2023
5/al 5/2023
5/26/2023
5 /24/2023
6 /1 /2023
5/25/2023
2/23/2023
CREDIT FOR OVER PAYMENT. IN
REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE NOREPAIR AND MAINTENANCE NOAUTO REPAIR
AUTO REPAIR
LINE PIPE & SERVICES LINE PAF
LINE PIPE & SERVICES LINE PAF
WINTER 2023: PROVIDES YOUn
5/23/2023 UB REFUND CST #00064942 - 95
5/18/2023 2022: FTB OFFSET FEES CALEN
4/20/2023 TRAFFIC SIGNS, BARRICADES,C
4/24/2023 FIRST AID SUPPLIES
4/20/2023
3/20/2023
11/4/2022
5/25/2023
5/24/2023
5/22/2023
5 /24/2023
6 /1 /2023
APR 2023: ADJ FOR ACTIVE SW(
MAR 2023: ADJ FOR ACTIVE SW(
TANGENT HOSTED INBOUND El
UNIFORM AND ACCESSORIES
UNIFORM AND ACCESSORIES
UNIFORM AND ACCESSORIES
UNIFORM AND ACCESSORIES
MAY 2023: WEST INFORMATION
Amount Paid
-208.44
300.00
44,358.00
17,224.75
33.05 -60.24
189.00
243.11
509.39
762.86
320.45
gor .26
2,882.88
204.28
2,900.74
750.00
164.88
99.50 -5.91
1 ,578.50
650.00
239.57
650.00
493.53
722.29
Check Total
91 .56
44,358.00
17,224.75
33.05 371 .87
1 ,272.25
1 ,221 .71
2 ,882.88
204.28
2,900.74
750.00
164.88
93.59 1 ,578.50
2,033.10
722.29
Page: 18
920
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 il:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 19
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor
101658 6/27/2023 0011640
Voucher:
101659 6/27/2023 0010699
Voucher:
101660 6/27/2023 0013584
Voucher:
101661 6/27/2023 00004964
Voucher:
101662 6/27/2023 0013792
Voucher:
101663 6/27/2023 0010265
Voucher:
101664 6/27/2023 00003928
Voucher:
101665 6/27/2023 00001848
Voucher:
101666 6/27/2023 00002634
Voucher:
101667 6/27/2023 00004423
Voucher:
101668 6/27/2023 00000028
Voucher:
101669 6/27/2023 0013958
Voucher:
101670 6/27/2023 0010476
Voucher:
101671 6/27/2023 0009526
Voucher:
Invoice
TIREHUB, LLC 34623380
34639672
TRANSYSTEMS CORPORATION 0004110128
TRUE NORTH COMPLIANCE SER23-05-22
Inv Date Description
5/24/2023
5/25/2023
5/1 7/2023
6/1 /2023
UNDERGROUNDSERVICEALER122-2304114 6/1/2023
520230200 6/1 /2023
UNIFIRST CORPORATION CSGO523 6/1/2023
CSGO423 5/26/2023
CSGO253-CM
UNITED PACIFIC SERVICES, 1NC.23-0323-2R 3/23/2023
23-0518-3 5/18/2023
US BANK TRUST N.A. 788757000-JULY/: 7/1/2023
TIRES PURCHASE
TIRES PURCHASE
APR 2023: 1-710 FIRESTONE BLV
MAY 2023: TRUE NORTH- PLAN (
DIG ALERTS
DIG ALERTS
PROCUREMNT OF CITY-ISSUED
PROCUREMNT OF CITY-ISSUED
RETURN CR
3/2/23-3/22/23: ANNUALTREE SE
5/11-5/15/23: TRIMMING OF PARH
JULY 2023-COSG 2005 PENSION
VERIZON WIRELESS 9935478204
VULCAN MATERIALS COMPANY 73665290
73662401
73659636
73656122
WALTERS WHOLESALE ELECTRIS122845850.001
WATER REPLENISHMENT D1STR122-12-T22-007
WATERWISEPRO TRAINING LLC 2023-al5
WECK LABORATORIES INC
5/21/2023 APR-MAY2023:ACCT#87080433
6/5/2023
5/31 /2023
5/31 /2023
5/26/2023
5/1 0/2023
6/1 /2023
ASPHALT, BASE, EMULSION PRC
ASPHALT, BASE, EMULSION PRC
ASPHALT, BASE, EMULSION PRC
ASPHALT, BASE, EMULSION PRC
ELECTRICAL SUPPLIES
JUL 2022-DEC 2022: TITLE 22 GR
5/17/2023 5/17/23:PWW-WATERTRAININ(
5/1 9/2023
5/1 9/2023
5/30/2023
5/25/2023
WATER QUALITY" SAMPLING
WATER QUALITY SAMPLING
SUPPLIES LIGHTS,PARTS AND E
SUPPLIES LIGHTS,PARTS AND E
Amount Paid
670.28
708.19
38,640.42
2,680.54
209.67
521 .00
9,544.86
20,709.01
-2,989.04
5,475.00
15 ,800.00
16 7,445.71
3,436.69
111 .42
m9.41
:q 3.90
591 .52
444.39
15,030.00
4,500.00
250.00
240.00
471 .76
1 ,218.82
Check Total
1,378.47
38,640.42
2,680.54
730.67
27,264.83
21 ,275.00
167,445.71
3,436.69
1 ,026.25
444.39
15,030.00
4,500.00
490.00
1 ,690.58
Page: 49
921
Check Total
apChkLst
06/19/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 20
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor Invoice Inv Date Description Amount Paid 101672 6/27/2023 00000032
Voucher:
WEST COAST MAILERS 347
348
354
318
312
309
316
311
307
314
310
315
349
346
313
317
308
101673 6/27/2023 0013923 WESTERLY METER SERVICE C0. 7312 Voucher: 7246
101674 6/27/2023 00000561 WESTERN EXTERMINATOR COM 44934062 Voucher:
101675 6/27/2023 00000058 XEROXCORP
35628315
44933635
44938035
44936033
44939078
44936354
44936355
44934063
44933636
44934061
44934060
018877684
Voucher:
101676 6/27/2023 00000062 ZIEGLER'S HARDWARE& SUPPL'T1688 5/15/23 5/10/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 7 SERVICE
5/10/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 10 SERVIC
5/10/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 5 SERVICE
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLS 3 &4 SVC 1
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLES 3 & 4 SVC
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLES 3 & 4 SVC
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLES 5 & 6 SVC
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLES 5 & 6 SVC
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 5 & 6 SVC :
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 7 & 812/8/:
3/28/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 7 & 81/12/;
3/29/2023 CYCLE101/1/23-1/31/23JOB#2-
5/10/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 1 SERVICE
5/10/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 3 SERVICE
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 1 SERVICE
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 1 & 2 SER\i
3/29/2023 WATER BILLS CYCLE 1 & 2 SER\i
4/21/2023 METERTEST-16347147
1/23/2023 METERTESTS-1/12AND3/4
5/10/2023 CMCCENTER-FY22-23ANNUA
4/28/2023 MAIN OFFICE - FY 22-23 ANNUAL
5/10/2023 SENIORCENTER-FY22-23ANN
5/10/2023 PARKMAINTYARD-FY22-23AN
5/10/2023 SGAUDITORIUM-FY22-23ANNi
5/10/2023 DOG PARK - PEST ABATEMENT 2
5/10/2023 POLICEDEPT-FY22-23ANNUAI
5/10/2023 POLICEDEPT-FY22-23ANNUAI
5/10/2023 CITYHALL-FY22-23ANNUALPE
5/10/2023 SPORTSCENTER-FY22-23ANTh
5/26/2023 MAIN OFFICE/WHS - FY 22-23 AN
5/26/2023 MAIN OFFICE/WHS - FY 22-23 AN
5/11/2023 APR2023:METERREADNETCC
5/15/2023 MISC HARDWARE
2,075.18
179.60
2,386.01
2,156.35
2,261 .94
2,261 .94
2,384.70
2,385.35
2,384.70
2,072.57
216.83
180.20
2,802.62
2,267.81
2,694.70
2,815.68
2,801 .97
35.00 105.00
4 6.50
151 .50
295.50
56.00 82.50
375.00
227.15
76.45 121 .00
275.00
42.00 i51.50
42.11 19.78
34,328.15
140.00
r,goo.io
42.11 Voucher: 1713 5/19/2023 MISC HARDWARE 19.81 39.59 Page: 20
922
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 li:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 21
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
5312023 5/31/2023 00004309
Voucher:
AMERIFLEX
(Continued)
Invoice
05312023
Inv Date Description
5/31 /2023 MAY 2023 - ACH DEBITS BOW
Amount Paid
5,170.99
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST:
Check Total
5,170.99
1,162,864.83
284 checks and 1 wire transfers in this report. Grand Total All Checks and Wire Transfers: 1,162,864.83 Page: 21
923
WARRANT REGISTER FOR COUNCIL MEETING 6/27/2023 PART V
apChkLst
06/1 2/2023 4:34:25PM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 1
Bank : botw BANK OF THE WEST
Check # Date Vendor
2506 5/11/2023
Voucher:
2522 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2523 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2524 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2525 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2527 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2528 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2529 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2530 6/8/2023
Voucher:
2531 6/8/2023
Voucher:
00004708
00000004
00002370
00001186
00004836
00000343
00004996
00000437
00004988
0009920
Invoice
PERS HEALTH PLAN Ben314661
NATIONWIDE RETIREMENT SOLLBen315952
INTERNALREVENUESERVICE Ben315954
EMPLOYMENT DEVELOPMENT DBen315956
SEIU LOCAL 721 CTW CLC-2390OBen315958
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETlREMErBen315962
SEIU-COPE LOCAL 721, LA/QC CI Ben315964
AFLAC Ben3l5966
CHILD SUPPORT ON-LINE, STATEBen315968
OCSE CLEARINGHOUSE SDU Ben315970
Inv Date Descriotion
5/11/2023 MEDICALHMOANTHEMSELECT
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
6/8/2023
DEF COMP NATIONWIDE: PAYME
MEDICARE: PAYMENT
SDI: PAYMENT
SEIU DUES: PAYMENT
MILITARY SERVICE CREDIT: PAY
SEIU- COPE LOCAL 721 DEDUCT
AMERICAN FAMILY LIFE INS. PA
CHILD SUPPORT-ONLINE: PAYMI
GARNISHMENT - AR CHILD SUPF
Amount Paid
450,8alO.57
67,669.50
178,925.06
62,159.96
3,016.10
252,646.32
41 .00
530.86
1,166.99
324.00
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST:
Check Total
450,810.57
67,669.50
178,925.06
62,159.96
3,016.10
252,646.32
41 .00
530.86
1,166.99
324.00
1 ,017,290.36
10 wire transfers in this report. Grand Total All Wire Transfers: 1 ,017,290.36 Page: 1
924
WARRANT REGISTER FOR COUNCIL MEETING 6/27/2023 PART Vl
apChkLst
06/19/2023 11:45:03AM
F-tnal Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: I
RET: ADAMS, PAUL L.
RET: ALONZO, ANTHONY
RET: AUSTIN, BYRON A.
RET: AVILA, VINCENT
RET AVILES, OMAR ADOLFO
Bank : efbotw BANK OF THE WEST EFT
Check # Date Vendor
2726 6/27/2023 0012466
Voucher:
2727 6/27/2023 0005570
Voucher:
2728 6/27/2023 0012843
Voucher:
2729 6/27/2023 0005813
Voucher:
2730 6/27/2023 0013775
Voucher:
2731 6/27/2023 0012982
Voucher:
2732 6/27/2023 00001265
Voucher:
2733 6/27/2023 0006324
Voucher:
2734 6/27/2023 00i2844
Voucher:
2735 6/27/2023 00000817
Voucher:
2736 6/27/2023 00003408
Voucher:
2737 6/27/2023 0013163
Voucher:
2738 6/27/2023 00001776
Voucher:
2739 6/27/2023 00003973 RET: EADS, KENNETH P.
Voucher:
2740 6/27/2023 00003853 RET:FANNIN,ZONA
Voucher:
2741 6/27/2023 0008820
Voucher:
2742 6/27/2023 00004403
Voucher:
Invoice
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
RET: BONILLA CLAYTON, YADIRA JUNE 2023
RET: BRASSFIELD, CHARLES R JUNE 2023
RET: BURBACH, MAUREEN JUNE 2023
RET CAMACHO, EDWARD JUNE 2023
RET: CHRIST, DOUGLAS F JUNE 2023
RET: DAMRON, ROGER V JUNE 2023
RET: DAVIS, RANDALL JOHN JUNE 2023
RET: EADE, JOANN JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
RET: FERNANDEZ, CARLOS JUNE 2023
RET: FIELD, GARY JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/"13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
Amount Paid
1,299.14
689.04
1,209.74
1 ,361 .42
300.00
150.00
250.00
150.00
1 ,367.90
250.00
250.00
1,196.68
132.25
689.04
148.68
1 ,367.90
150.00
Check Total
1,299.14
689.04
1 ,209.74
1 ,361 .42
300.00
150.00
250.00
150.00
1 ,367.90
250.00
250.00
1,196.68
132.25
689.04
148.68
1 ,367.90
150.00
Page: 1
925
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 2
Bank : efbotw BANK OF THE WEST EFT
Check # Date Vendor
2743 6/27/2023 0006507
Voucher:
2744 6/27/2023 0013564
Voucher:
2745 6/27/2023 00000605
Voucher:
2746 6/27/2023 0005355
Voucher:
2747 6/27/2023 0011186
Voucher:
2748 6/27/2023 00000496
Voucher:
2749 6/27/2023 0013121
Voucher:
2750 6/27/2023 00003940
Voucher:
2751 6/27/2023 0006328
Voucher:
2752 6/27/2023 0006510
Voucher:
2753 6/27/2023 0006329
Voucher:
2754 6/27/2023 0013216
Voucher:
2755 6/27/2023 0012845
Voucher:
2756 6/27/2023 00004784
Voucher:
2757 6/27/2023 0009521
Voucher:
2758 6/27/2023 0008058
Voucher:
2759 6/27/2023 00004785
Voucher:
(Continued)
RET FIGuEROA, GLORIA A.
Invoice
JUNE 2023
RET: FLAD, MICHAEL JUNE 2023
RET: FORRESTER, BOB L JUNE 2023
RET: GALBREATH, RUSSELL JUNE 2023
RET: GAMBOA, OSCAR JUNE 2023
RET: GEORGE, RONALD P JUNE 2023
RET: GONZALES, LORE'nA JUNE 2023
RET: GONZALEZ, HIRAM JUNE 2023
RET: GUTIERREZ, MANUEL JUNE 2023
RET: HERNANDEZ, MARIA JUNE 2023
RET: HOMSHER, HUGH JUNE 2023
RET: HUFFMAN, EDWARD RAYM(JUNE 2023
RET HUGAR L., JAMES JUNE 2023
RET: HUNTRODS, RICHARD F JUNE 2023
RET: HUPP, KEITH JUNE 2023
RET: INMAN, RONALD JUNE 2023
RET: IRISH, TERRY F JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
Amount Paid
150.00
1 ,339.68
250.00
269.02
150.00
250.00
150.00
150.00
1 ,367.90
i32.25
1 ,325.58
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
239.00
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
250.00
Check Total
150.00
1 ,339.68
250.00
269.02
150.00
250.00
150.00
150.00
1 ,367.90
132.25
1 ,325.58
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
239.00
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
250.00
Page: 2
926
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 3
Bank : efbotw BANK OF THE WEST EFT
Check # Date Vendor
2760 6/27/2023 00ffl10
Voucher:
2761 6/27/2023 00004787
Voucher:
2762 6/27/2023 0005356
Voucher:
2763 6/27/2023 00ffl11
Voucher:
2764 6/27/2023 0009946
Voucher:
2765 6/27/2023 00004789
Voucher:
2766 6/27/2023 0012707
Voucher:
2767 6/27/2023 0012927
Voucher:
2768 6/27/2023 0005633
Voucher:
2769 6/27/2023 0006511
Voucher:
2770 6/27/2023 0009453
Voucher:
2771 6/27/2023 0013398
Voucher:
2772 6/27/2023 0007656
Voucher:
2773 6/27/2023 0013777
Voucher:
2774 6/27/2023 00003328
Voucher:
2775 6/27/2023 0011895
Voucher:
2776 6/27/2023 00003239
Voucher:
(Continued)
RET: JOHNSON, GERALD
Invoice
JUNE 2023
RET: KENNEDY, GARY E JUNE 2023
RET: KEY, ANDREW JUNE 2023
RET: KOOMEN, SHERI L. JUNE 2023
RET: LEFEVER, STEVEN A. JUNE 2023
RET: LILLEY, RAYMOND E JUNE 2023
RET: LLOYD, BRUCE W. JUNE 2023
RET: LONG, PENG JUNE 2023
RET: LOPEZ, ALFONSO JUNE 2023
RET: LOPEZ, RAMON A. JUNE 2023
RET: LOPEZ, VERONICA JUNE 2023
RET MARIN, SANDRA JUNE 2023
RET: MATSUKIYO, DAVID JUNE 2023
RET: MONTANEZ JR., ABELINO JUNE 2023
RET: MOSBY, DOROTHEA S JUNE 2023
RET: MUNOZ, ALFREDO JUNE 2023
RET: NASSAR, SAMI R JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALI!
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
Amount Paid
150.00
250.00
1 ,272.92
150.00
200.00
250.00
150.00
150.00
590.37
148.68
150.00
150.00
1 ,324.82
300.00
132.25
1 ,367.90
200.00
Check Total
150.00
250.00
1 ,272.92
150.00
200.00
250.00
150.00
150.00
590.37
148.68
150.00
150.00
i ,324.82
300.00
132.25
1 ,367.90
200.00
Page: 3
927
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 4
Bank : efbotw BANK OF THE WEST EFT
Check # Date Vendor
2777 6/27/2023 0012468
Voucher:
2778 6/27/2023 0012467
Voucher:
2779 6/27/2023 0011522
Voucher:
2780 6/27/2023 00005237
Voucher:
2781 6/27/2023 0010733
Voucher:
2782 6/27/2023 00004794
Voucher:
2783 6/27/2023 0006326
Voucher:
2784 6/27/2023 0006327
Voucher:
2785 6/27/2023 0011967
Voucher:
2786 6/27/2023 0011978
Voucher:
2787 6/27/2023 0012837
Voucher:
2788 6/27/2023 0012682
Voucher:
2789 6/27/2023 00ffl12
Voucher:
2790 6/27/2023 0013274
Voucher:
2791 6/27/2023 0009865
Voucher:
2792 6/27/2023 0011521
Voucher:
2793 6/27/2023 0013273
Voucher:
(Continued)
RET: ORTIZ, JULIAN
Invoice
JUNE 2023
RET PATINO, IGNACIO M. JUNE 2023
RET: PELLERIN, ROBERT JUNE 2023
RET: PEREZ, SUSAN JUNE 2023
RET: PIXLER, DAVID JUNE 2023
RET: POWELL, ROBERT K. JUNE 2023
RET: RAMIREZ, VIRGINIA JUNE 2023
RET: RASCO, ANGELA JUNE 2023
RET: RIVERA, FRANK J. JUNE 2023
RET: RIVERA, HANNAH TELLEZ-CJUNE 2023
RET: RODRIGUEZ, ANNA JUNE 2023
RET: RUIZ, NELLIE JUNE 2023
RET: SALDIVAR, MARIO M. JUNE 2023
RET: SAUCEDO NEVAREZ, LUIS AJUNE 2023
RET: SCHRADER, GEORGE R. JUNE 2023
RET SCOTT, DAVID JUNE 2023
RET: SEKIYA, JONATHAN M JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETiREEMEDICALll
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETlREEMEDICALli
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALli
Amount Paid
603.64
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
132.25
1 ,367.90
250.00
132.25
150.00
605.21
605.21
132.25
150.00
1 ,367.90
150.00
1 ,217.00
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
Check Total
603.64
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
132.25
1 ,367.90
250.00
132.25
150.00
605.21
605.21
132.25
150.00
1 ,367.90
150.00
1,217.00
1 ,367.90
1 ,367.90
Page:4
928
apChkLst
06/1 9/2023 11:45:03AM
Final Check List
CITY OF SOUTH GATE
Page: 5
Bank : efbotw BANK OF THE WEST EFT (Continued)
Check # Date Vendor
2794 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2795 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2796 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2797 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2798 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2799 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2800 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2801 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2802 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2803 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2804 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2805 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2806 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2807 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2808 6/27/2023
Voucher:
2809 6/27/2023
Voucher:
0006513
00000869
00004796
00002147
0008313
0006512
0012960
0005357
0012959
00003573
0013776
00003959
0007655
00004379
00000498
0008821
RET: SHETTER, RANDOLPH M.
RET: SMITH, CHARLES R
RET: SPEELMAN, PATRICIA L
RET: SPROWLS, KENNETH C
RET: SULLIVAN, DARREN
RET: TAnl, WILLIAM P.
RET: TAYLOR, TOM C.
RET: TODD, ROBERT M.
RET: TREJO, RAMONA M
RET: VAN LIEROP, MARTIN G
RET: VARGAS, ALEX J.
RET: WADE, RICHARD
RET: WELLS, GREGORY
RET: WHALEN, HARVEY
RET: WILLIAMS, GALE M
RET: WILLIAMS, TIMOTHY
Invoice
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
Inv Date Description
6/13/2023 JUNE2023-RETIREEMEDICALII
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
JUNE2023 6/13/2023
MAR-MAY 2023 Al 6/1 3/2023
JUNE 2023 6/13/2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
JUNE 2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
6/1 3/2023
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
MAR-MAY 2023 ADJSTMNT- RETI
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL It
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
JUNE 2023- RETIREE MEDICAL II
Amount Paid
150.00
250.00
250.00
250.00
1 ,272.92
150.00
450.00
150.00
1 ,358.28
150.00
2 69.02
3 00.00
269.02
603.64
148.68
250.00
1 ,361 .42
Sub total for BANK OF THE WEST EFT:
Check Total
150.00
250.00
250.00
250.00
1 ,272.92
600.00
150.00
1 ,358.28
150.00
2 69.02
3 00.00
269.02
603.64
148.68
250.00
1 ,361 .42
49,361 .95
84 EFTs in this report. Grand Total All EFTs: 49,361 .95 Page: 5
929
WARRANT REGISTER SUMMARY
CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF 6/27/2023
TOT AL PARTI - PAYROLL-RELATED CHECKS
TOTAL PARTII PREPAIDCHECKS(6/7/2023)
TOTAL PARTIII-PREPAIDCHECK(6/15/2023)
TOT AL PART IV - ACCOUNTS PAY ABLE CHECKS & WIRE TRANSFERS
TOTAL PART V - PAYROLL-RELATED WIRE TRANSFERS
TOTAL PART Vl - ACCOUNTS PAYABLE EFTs
SUB-TOTAL
LESS: VOIDS
LESS: EMPLOYEE PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS
57,571 .76
479,323.08
112,454.26
1,162,864.83
1,017,290.36
49,361 .95
2,878,866.24
0.00 (414,527.57)
GRANDTOTAL 2,464,338.67
930
SOUTH GATE CITY COUNCIL
WARRANT APPROV AL AND CANCELLATION
Warrant Number jQjg to Warrant Number inclusive, plus WireTiansfeis and EFTs totaling , as 1isted on the accompanying Accounts Payable Warrant Register of JUNE272023 are approved as presented, with the exception of the following voided and replacement warrants:
Voided
Check Number Vendor Check Date Amount Reason for Void or Replacement TOTAL OF VOIDED CHECKS $
" TOT AL OF REPLACEMENT CHECKS $
100975 SUNBELT RENTALS 5/9/2023 $ 14,828.55
LOST IN MAIL. ISSUED
REPLACEMENT CHECK# 101467
' Replacement :hecks reported in previous warrant registers have no impact to the grand total.
DIRECTOR OF ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
Pursuant to action of the City Council on JUNE 27 2023 at a regular or adjourned meeting, the City Treasurer was ordered to pay and/or cancel the above warrants, wire transfers & ETFs, as approved. 931