Agenda packet — Rancho Mirage City Council, December 18, 2025 (part 13 of 32)

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2250
RTC -421

Responses to Comments
CalEEMoci Vat'sIons Cj1EElhad,20193.2 Page 20 of 35 Date. 1/62021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (iropnsedi - Los Angeles -South Coast Courtly, larder

3.$ BuilldtngConstruction -2023
IJntnitiaaled Cons.uuetien Off-$iti

94.=
'f.'-.

CO
90,[2
five
PM 1U
b.Yeaem
1h!1G
►11110
TA
Fupbi
1412.3 I
Piptsmell
010125
P1a9
Tale
E]C12
1960-Cd2
1Fmill 001
DM
WO
cur
i
,,; aieq"7
11411
-1iJ4'y7 ooze . ¢oma i acme . OWED
D WO) a ram . n Drsn
sae)) acoac : co3raa
D. MOO i almD : D .xn7 : o u[R6 •
1'Yndu .,
03767 : 2:7128 3377I • a�7rOM* 881%
. a a122 . :¢�,.'
_
¢.21,776 3DOB . fl.7162
••
•-3.in+1 a,3f 367'4.430• LI 30,dE ,i,SnGk1
r e .
. .
e
1 V e
Y
4 6
i l p._ .- t
-t—
t —1 _
'��'.Nr i372d} i 71 $ty 31.6P"i 24 a OK.
19651 { a72d2t 9:¢291 a 2-345 7cl r . 7131
726,7797. 1120X•
.7.273.7261
.. WA 770
1 Y
r Y

. 11
a
! J
an,.
.17111
Ig, 195S
N3E(51

9.t1Y
II1
6dlrq
'1-2,141
2,41}11
011715
27e7j1 I
11,553.{7 11;115.16
¢0151

11.00},511
25 45
t14
miLivated Construction On•Sett
v
SO2
RIP7oa.

PMh7
€Jdam4s
PM10
P'qi Ia
lane
Fusin*
P17,7
E.Nerm

1.447,5
PM 5
4010,
0,i, 002
1119. cell
Tdal 0,02
014
WO
_ T,
may
E.'Is1
-- - -
klar,
O¢.Rsati
_ I a ,.
+ 3D.] ,
IC 2,,a
• 79260 .
,3 ECU 770,"47 .
1 ,:,1%,-.
_ Lx
esX _�
MMD;
3fOM
t _
.:ra.3':,
Taal
1577E
I

14.3B41
1E241D
¢.D2b44__
LE T
01E4.5.2
¢0594
mf.•S4
DCR32J
2,5SE2m2
2 2555.202
7 D DOM
2'336172
e
01'25
Cont.

Page 134 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2251
RTC -422

Responses to Comments
CalEEMed'Version* Ca1EEI*41,2O193.2 rage 21 or 35 Date. 14912021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Argelas-Snasth Caasl Courtly, l+I iter

3.$ Building Construction - 2423
Mitioateti Construction Off -Site
A4u
Wfl.

G4
9132
rugiboe
4X11•.1
tram,.

WM r
PROI1
I,tee
luip?,
@CA_'ti
tom,'
645.12•..

F•1,'

n+0ra2
P1 Ca.2
tmlll otn
;am
41261

03. —
,
IT.- a .•I7
I6III'I
-lsJth$ • t7.ri7m a 6.7.7]0 •i OCI]OG a 6�Q4 • C,.
r . .
-. -Modal
o ,.. . e :)CL--•
L.- .• : 0COM.. • 60S,0
•
•
:OOM] I OCHE Y 43003 1
:.. i...
-

11.ia4,su�
1}y
_ w- 03len • 5:22 . 33T? I . 0:II.'] . C i�lii
Pi e . . e
'N
30122 . IIII2'
e
a.2rE'i IOU • 42752
> e
I.
•�•3.WI a,3G 367I.4 71. IY'
7 I e
R14<ke6' . 53766 ,I• 11 $K i 31. 24
e• 4.
4W4e .
e r
8533 . 013562 I 11211
i ii
23745 ?41#.67 . Ss31
e
•?.663.831
. 1!
rf167731•
I 4
6215E
,

11..I1
5-54r5 I2105S'
• 0.6

2.31111
C,114.5C,114.5
II

9.5en
7-11481
241#81
245
27tg111 I
ii,555.13
25 11.165.ti
25 &1$S-I

3.6 Paving - 2023
Urr1111galma ti n On -Sala
z_
Sal
wGbw
R]
•ahweir
Mlle
PM la
Trde
+,,pies
PIII:5
E. ...

FM?
PA:5
Tres
t __-'_
t16a CO2.

T 1JCel
O4
,420
_..M
ca lin, 1 E'.srT
limy
Off-Rwd
I care a I4 S°.3 • D4225 • . 0$902 • 4 51c1 • . 44554 • I! a •• i e w w i•
727554 22CQ 584 • 4.7144
w 1 f
1 /
2:2-S 433
6 OD
one •
•

1 CI MEW
nmrre
3a341t
•
cam• -
a
Told
t.137!
I6:i617

14.56422

0.(R23
45152

4.51•22

5.4654

4.4484
2,2➢1.5N
2347.654

6.7144
3,22'433
a
01-25
Cont
Page135 of 548 irl Cernnent Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2252
RTC -423

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMad'Verslan Ca1EEldc?d.2OVv 3.2 Page 22 01'35 Dale. V .2O21 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (iraposedp - Los Angeles -South Coast Courtly, larder

3.5 Paving -2923
IIrin tiaated Cans.uuction Off -Site
Moles
No. I
c,:
not
,r-ogbee
PIA s'1
3!. Mint
PM1r
►R1I0
l,Md
FuPlIm
tsga;:5
i,xal•>e
1'M'!3
Wia.11 r
TO
E]C12
N$ - CC1.2
trim CU2.

DM
WO
Cot:
i
.,:.leq''),
ulriy

11.010,
-liJl'y#

1...Ekr
1 O Li
l A.
.7G 7'_
JT_QY
L'S7JJ
aum :COOED . BUM) i, arla3c. : P.BSA

0. G.UWO O.1:13eO 1D
Ii JX
a7iU0

1.14.1443
1 TA9.ggi!'.
aMOD
E.:,3Lo
.3 Ma IG..gfio5
l
amu{V atom CfliL17 'S C17DG GC.'•'0
_
6Ol1EEtt'1_I omoo : atom , i
- -- 4
_...,.,
45tIka ... 4.1= 11,3420
!
1 0 441
134i0r
=I
016x7

. ' altar. 0 UM • 1;14+5 , Init. • ecoao
1 r ,.r • Iii
- . e $.:191
.

1.95150,t1.

3.dh,3Ca-
944 1

3..nrJ
4pl'Ibt
gd1{13
TI.id83
tggga..
illy
q,$7i
1,Zf[4s•
0D?
'4-1Ha'1
Ik.11H5

1.1TUO -
e.53

4.6j3TM
I44-A4*'1
1425gpi
?.4404-
143
MiLivated Construction On•51t1d
P._,,
.. ,
CC
so:<
walr.a.

RAN]
€ltuua
Rolle
Pqt Id
lane
fusin.e
RC, 0
E;saa
PM: S.

Mt:5
4uu
Da CO2
+t6a ccrz
a .ar
014
WO
C '
I
CdMaAotV
r
RNmT
klar4
Y
on-R.d
ils
Pif.lflp -
1 (a , [email protected]
i
I.1 MU • {I fl776 , x3103 • n slim . s 11.0364 u 4404
t ; w s
• •
011394 x . 79 561 i 20' 5134 • 0.7144
w t r
,
'
413
-
a 9u9c
` a srm
• ,
❑ mmo .
,
a a9rd
:
.
a auc
• comn
•
a
Told •
t.6171!
IO.te17
14,7642

43.9221.43.9221. .
45112

9.09AH
_ AM90J
L4W

11.f30g0
3,3➢7.Yl9 234i.tit11
1 0.7t+1n
22775.433

O1 -25 -
Cant.

Page 136 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2253
RTC -424

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMori VaraIan Ca1EEldc4t1,2Of63.2 page 23 of 35 15ate. 1{1912O21 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (Prnpnsedp - Las Angeles -South Coast Courts., Winter

3.5 Paving -2923
Miti4ated Construction Off -Site
9C
KY. I
L4
not
Trine
IN nil
&sla14
FWD
MU
too
Fuptrz
MCI
1h15aPl
P§123
iea.k r
TO.
- CrJ2
Pala CC2
FabI CU2.

DM
M2U
coo
i
..,ley'='1
4 tLMfY
15401 0,
rIiJ...2
1'ssdll
.-
0MOE.
l =_.[
.7G 7'_
� T_QY
L'S7JJ
aC+Jla • fl . B.30:10 • ✓J.CIDG . 50X.0 G.UWO
00300 1D
1 ouLCL.y
t GCMG
444....
140540
1 7J9.1141!'.
0MOD

E.'t3C0
.CG}.
1 flt}1G
IG..DODO
4 JmQ{V II 55000 '7 CMG L.w.�
1 a -II
p.QQ(►7 x117700 . D ,
- I
_ .,.,..a
YIANka a at=
!
II04X1
1 a+IBP7
I SLi6r
W?
C 161'
• ":11@04- 9 UM • 1;14+5 + 1ni4 • i704N#
+ 01.41 • 1)
4-
• x10 5{151
•
149"551
• 3,49)Cr
• I,:.5?I,:.5? 1

3.1.1IJ

4.=
fl nob

0.4417
tWI..
alel

4.$ 7
1,2t1t4a
OM
'b.tbial
a.I,H5

1.17U9,~
NU
II
l4**k
US 5561

7.t'•901k-
NO

3.6 Paving • 2024
Unmitigated Construction On ,Site
+.

CC
SGc
RlQhoa.

PM50
€rul{r
R•110
Pq{ 10
lane
-r-451w4
Pr+42.5
Ei#,a•m

17.12:'
Mt2 5
VrAr
Da - CO2
1115. CO2
Tdal COS
CJ.4
WO
COa '
may
802,0
t m y
- — -- .
r i
05 -Read
Pafrn4
`
025212
II.—
5,5246 + 1y. G5.9 n 5,U25 • , Q.{6Q5 • Q {€66 • + 24710 • Q#310 • r
a i 1 a f
• •
• 2 MP 547 2.$R.fi47 • U.71iG •
r
2 1
• •

2.U.S MB
a eraaQ
a a'
CUM . a 03rd : 21:95E. • c,m,
• r • P

0. •
•
Told
— 5.9552
Q;7N6
1{,rgaa.

Q:>Q5.92211 •
I145556

5.4.551$ •
•
a4.311:1a4.311:1 44310
3,3C7.44r
239P.647

0.71+IQ
'aa3`.3BQ
o1-2
Cora_

Page 137 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2254
RTC -425

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaci VeTslans Ca1EEMed,20193.2 Page 24 of 35 Dale. 1,16i2O21 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (iraposedi - Los Angeles -South Coast Cuurt1y, Mahar

3.5 Paving -2924
IIrin tiaated C6ns.uuction Off -Site
Mors
N17. I
ca
9r[2
tuptrre
PIAv1
V..14a19
mins
PPM
TWO
1,upas
P19:3
irxa••o
FY,123
P4r?.N r
TO.
ha CrJ2
N$le-Gd2
trim CU2.

C}M
WO
ciao
,,:.ie9''P
u.1r.y
6e010,
•
-12,0,4 e.acui • 1,}'
.
'now • Damp • DIM)
O DOM • 11r3M • BUM) • 1.CID1 : 50370
G.167P , Q1De0 Y 1 ]QT :
6 JXt
aita
111 F dT
7'deakr a1 5tit%O
.

I -
a111L' • 9 50,75 . C: MAO
- 1-- I---
0 M a cOWD 1C01ir • COXID
6 _ 6

1.5500 all= . 1amo ,
i- 1- i
41�Ica . 410226
i LL6 N.
114384 e 1 4,555.-•
•
L' 1647
': UJr p trcri: •. 1;14,5 a 151194 . 61166
•
• [44.6766
144.144 m 3 51'10a..
•

3..n.J
COMM
44th
44 !4'x00..
eta
L1I77
1,2611N•r
463
•4.1H44
a.{w45
LIMN -
104
.1i
t1 3a
1,11.17% 7 R7%

1.14 44
b#70%.

OM
,.45:4117
Live Ltd ConntrLich on On•Srtr@
a i._
11 1
CC
SGc
waa.a.

PMW
€rur{a
Rolle
PM{ IQ
Iota
fuplt+f
144.'.1
Ei#a.m
P}•I::'
Mt: 5
4rAr
Da - CO9
116. CO'.

Si.l L0i
CFc4
WO
Caaa '
I-
A
I
OII.Rwd
• • P-Ihrl
O.'2652
•
1,5245 • 14.5:5.9 • 11776 . 0 465 Y • 1{€66 • s 14711 • El 4310 . r
• • ,
7'=4A a9 MP 547 'a.99127.fik7. 17.714B ,
.
• •
2Z`53.1Q
a trm
aMIX
31:91)E. �
❑ m11 : 1 m`df GO Cf -
• • • r • • P
a.L3l QO
^ • • '
Told `

5.9572
_
4+741

14, 16
_
1:01.4
I
114998

1.1696•

5.4310
v
44316
1-_

1.6651
3,717'-.447
Y
739P.647
i
117146
2,257.313B2,257.313Bt

01.25 Cont

Page 138 of 848 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2255
RTC -426

Responses to Comments
CalEEMed'Version CatEEMocl,2O163.2 Page 25 of 35 15Me. 1d9121321 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (iroposedi - La's Angeles-Soxlth Coast Courts., larder

3.5 Paving -2024
Miticaled Construction Off-5lte
9C
KY. I
L4
sot
thine
IN dl
3!.W4art
win
PM Ill
TWO
kuptr.:e
PIG
tx•sau1
PNII23
Peas r
TO.
b. CrA
148W- CC1.2
FdI CU2.

DM
WO
coo
,..,ieq''Y
ILMf}
1,4010,
.42,14,p e. , C,}TY
.
acox , Damn , 611°7)
000M , COMB , a41330 r, ✓J.CIDG : P.BSA
G.U67] , a. CUE : +7 ]EDT :
.i —Xt
a:aux
,4,1 F dT
1'indrl a 8inOCI
.
•3 Mile • 0 C: MAO
0 D • 8 :84.17 1CCrk • COXID
•
• [l.a41m ama8 , aa[us ,
S- -
Wolter . 6r1A75 •. ea7N+
G.1784 •. I V_" , L' 16'7 ', ID'Ir n 1.5H., •. 1:71225 a 16118.8 �. G0183 ' W : , ma
, 444IIM
,
1-0.1..871:18 • 3579Ca- ,
, rJaa ,

1.n1.1 -
-a.ty5,
newt
An:15i
t4,508..
04 L:$E77i
f ' 1,M*,
IXO
•4.16jn1
It. WI

1.1%OW-
vCd
.1•84.i.

14.8.1704
.44888
gip-
4816
win .85,8).
32 Anchdlectural Coaling - 2024
Linnallfdalwd Construction On -Site

sc'
FIIPaoa.

PMh2
€Jdlals
Rolle
P6l Id
lore
fupltI
MUD
6Aa.m
PM: S.

Ion 5
4ritr
8-0 C+32
NIS. cC2
SdaI c"T2
0144
WO
_ ,.,
s
Cliti r
b'.1
-
Wm}
#hn Cs:alnp : 733.41",5 :
•
CI GUM , MOM . 11.[,1_ C :Ii1i
30480
•
:+%::
r. M184.3

• OftfRCOO aTr.9 • I2IM • 1Ern I • 247LGs
. e r , ]3:.
aLen • 0MD • 70EL'6 •• Ga.,-r.

MI 4431
MI 4421 rr. 301 +
-
Told
74134.43
12 8
m

1.8121

7.57 .
1 1131

11.x®
LIMES
A9888
{.41675
261.44.r
7£1.4481
,
a.111*
72-1.64+8

01.25 Cont
Page139 of 548 it Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2256
RTC -427

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod'Ve•rsIan' Ca1E ENtocl,2016 3.2 Page 26 or 35 Date. 144312021 1:49 PM ',linage South Specific Flan (Proposal* - Las Angeles-Sallth Coast Courtly, tVL iter 3,7 ,4rchrlecturdl Coaling • 2(124
Vilmitiaaled Construction Of -Site
ROG
CO
9C[7
ru4trNr
49•1
tram,.

WI
PRI I1
I...0
ku4lwe
MC.,
t'JAELS
6%.1T"..
r"1,'
fl - e42
MSc- Cti.2
tdr 001
DM
WO
CG
7,,,,, n:b
. ..
tell
.IFJth$
-.-..„,...w
us,aQ ..

Z
t9G1
• a 69186
1 .

I x1115+ . 96124 •t 1.4]91.

I 1
•a (LAU:. WIZ! . 51.4447
1 1.95315E
0 1 1 6W..23e • f1.aVt( •.
i 9 . .
10,1
4wbo
1 axis
.Mitt`
*MSS

1.rIti '
64114
tale

0.1TM1s
A tm173
4014
s1.54411.1
O
9,i#.1►4
o
aWd?
INi,1i44
2 Mil Ina Ltd Con nrructlon On•SII
•.
-
s _
Sac
F:14trw
Fly, -,3
,ahw1a
Ft111C
PiA la
Trde
--u41i.c
P4
"r�Citio.

MT?e
PC S
Trnr
f .:"7.,2
tl6a CO2
"%NI c a
O-4
wo
c-2,
.=s!€ . r
Ina , --
_ Wm}
FrJln Cs;u1tlq 73&41".5 :
i r
u
GO GO 9 GC . O GG . ]Cfe1_ i1i� t� 0Q60
w
3 3CC
12151/5443
Of-Rcoa 471'..0 • 129.64 • IH+II D _VILE.,
w e . . 'A;.

Q Len • 33E� • 2GEQG • COBLE,
0 MOD •,I 44.51
914415 I • 33-1 +
e

Told
TFE5113
121261

1.1101
l4TE9..
ou3
i194.061
UMW
acme
COWS
F.96411
241.4489
761.14151
G.il144
I

51.1443
01-25
Cont_
Page140 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2257
RTC -428

Responses to Comments
CiIEEMadV2rslon Cj1EEMiad,20163.2 Pape 27 or 05 Dale .1/9120211:49PM Village South Specific Flan (iroposedh - Les Angeles -South Coast Courts., lVL iter 3,7 Archflectural Caalang • 2024
Miticated Conalruction Off -Site
NOG
v.). I
L4
Mr[2
Puphre
nlils'1

3.Ysat4
num
■AIO
TAM1r
kuir$'e
PIGS
temps
PM23
Prfl.1 r
T.1
E]r2
MEG-GC2
lrbll CU2.

O41
1420
coo.
,..,ieq.oj
riyjy
bell
-1iJL'y# • a:TA1G
tedeal .

L ',AK.
a CAAA . A ETAS
L' ek7C., o CWA a A ACrI'a
G WOO t ,7 cam. . G bSA
O 8000 1 a 0130 Y a Qom
rJ iLC{:
1 0DIX.C
• 184=3
i 2 .
0MOD
..+
C.'s'a�
amok' . stIGGG
. .-
GOOD} a6d0A AfC1ii
e
•_
6U,A'10 1 CaGt C.vT77
e
•.-•, ••
.
.1.6452 ,
,

Malt 6m6A • BMX •
'OA:akat tlaii�i5
u,'Ag . ,IVIDU . ?Jtt0
in + . 00111 •
ky

1.1091.

0.443 4.9123
• 4 41,8
•
!15
0 1
IbIb Me.
a
10371.
,
1 ed., -
_ 0 rof. i
o ?OM
V.nr:iu
o. of SA
e.16i1 a
fP9ai
t.1159Y1 '

0.A141
I

14.1f 41
1,544.2*
i,145.1*a
4,03711
I44t,216

4.0 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
of -25
Cont.

Page 141 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2258
RTC -429

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaci VersIan Ca1EEM44,20f63.2 Page 25 of 35 Dale. 1,42021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Angeles -South Coast Courts., larder yo.
co
see
cup .<
PM `7
R,R 71"
Pki11
1!11S
,*
P4421,
eulsr eci
Ctw
emit
Unrrmine
a y1] • .129nIJ !�Jmv Jug_ _.1.� J_. J a J..

H.TS7. 4001+T11'4O4 4. ®.{6491•'46 .57Z 77;37] ;..29534 37374.727.m 1 as C8 Tit
•47Di7� 47317110. 2.1959 • -• 44.9— DO
05 Or} •
•

4.2 Trip Summary Infarriration
ay®1z�a_'Url.�'T_�rPTmr'---
uo111 _e_ac
Mitped:
•. L rlli'U91O
wash dar
rM1n11Qr'
itindey
h1111�Y1VM'F
— AtrialV
Ap1tl11PO11t4k. PM R1g1r
liFgtlllnerlMi 4910 iii me •
,,renal rx or ra.fi 1e
:: 'OW II Hest I6V2M: a-
„

1.4,R, 1
34-:�
1 .3p 515,[27
iOi$'aO ....... 13,,65u,o55
3145 ;,..,.,. las.a1,4 ,
41? t: • 3.413,5,37,
9O ' OD • 4.4,143 +
461 20 . 7,97,4110
35754 • 111_' 1
5[1422F'

13.4950,0e
742417
?03,539 ..
448,709
707.46S
T, 1x2221
d,Qf696 I
5; 7'r325
•.1. 79645 w
6756
_
«369 �6,3
Ill 37.

N_�
197.4}
• 6] 1 14. 2
611. §_
• 5211611 •

1fr31. 44
' ];.0
11 96L 43
a 457.31 19 °.57.152 1
249 552.45'2

4.5 Trip Typo fnfomiation
41-2s
Cora_

Page 142 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2259
RTC -430

Rol mat Shopping Coley,.

Responses to Comments
CalEEMati VaraIons Ca1EEMad,20163.2 Pape 29 of 35 Date. 1/62021 1 49 PM Village South Specific Flan (irnpesedh - Los Angeles-Samrth Ceasl Ceur61y, Miter Thole,
Laid U 6
h.W f4 -W
N-& Dr C -C
H -D of C. FM
HWdGY1
LS711CC
tentf.p-trw
41partrrern Lori Rau a 147: '.- &-0 • 40 TD r 10:20 40 b0 • 3E 11• •
Apertmel%9 MIa Floe # 1470 r 4. • 'i• ,�•.•••.-_•••• • 6.70 • 40 2D 1920 . 40 b4 de 11 rcneral C+Alce Bldklllp 1660 E. 40 e 610 • 3100 4600 i 921 77 19 --`--`--# x--
Jntamour iSAdow°••�*, 1690 614 6.A0� f 960 72'.56 ,.f� ....37 . ^4 $011• •▪ 18.110 ' ▪ 644 . aS17 : 1140 i 81.64 1300 .p ▪ 'F 7 ':a�.a11, ��x r.: • 1d.00 x 646 ' 6.40 : 1240 a 99106 1900 L'. b& 44 16+:90 s L40 990 1690 ,F 0420 ; 1400 54 34 11

4.4 Fleet hSlz
sr 1 Uee
LC'T1 LI-172 r Mild LI+D1 JM1Y1 64410
H:1D 4243US
LIOUH
M•CY
SOUS
HH
Apanmserls Laity waft., W O'Yk3i761Y, D 04471e 020ENFY1 011a366 00140is.. D1;. 3.-s= 071106 0.031677 063219 L3 0CMS 17 00092651 0766x71? Oi,CF:-71 4 filpaRxnaisMkt Rim : 0.549 11. 0.04421G 0269071 6[16390 641xkG32 0.01302372 0.621 fed 0.091677. 6.6210 L9 6.1361617 0 AMIGO 6.060712 6. r7Ln116_1 , i 4--
r�alpA•cc&dcleyb 05i23dN 0044216 02155071 0546396 0013030 4.006;322, 0021168 0 03957 O.ODD 15 0.401917 0.005366 0,1100752 040:15.1 ,ova+ :Sit ®4wrr : 0,34.9099; D 4x16 0 2tElVea` 6116394. D014022, ¢x00612: 0Crl 1frs 002:1as 1 0.00 13! 0 IC% 00052119: 0a0trn: 0mE'$21 inira r r11} + .
i
Holliil a 0.54305e; Q.Ou21b 0XOS-77 4Ile.24} 0.014030. 0.4116332 0621166 0014gar 4.00:613 0.{61817 4.WSa60 0.004717 0: W0e71 Meaty Res1aurar4 t 4643066'_ dsaaat2le 6 Atlar1 9 rinar 01}1411317 D4LAa3.5- L. ,J,',1 lee 0.IX13t577 0.0x)2653 6671917' amnia 0604752 4 • 0543:k9A• ID414421Gr 0203971: 6519'-gdr
O-01.1UX0 DOFC.w:'
0604611
.7:1166,, 0.631.577+ 0IXYZG 00016"+ 00.16296+ 0904.12: 06?^.021 LO Energy Detail
Fi1torbal Energy Usti: N

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
01-25
Cont.

Page 143 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2260
RTC -431

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMaci Velment-is Ga1EEMiad.20V93.2 Page 30 of 35 Dale. 1/9.2021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan pRropnaedp - Las Angeles -South Coast Courtly, Winter ,PIC,
no.
1 area
Nap.tive
PM
er...s
PIA In

0.1/11t1
Imo
rugiw.

PM k
Emewri
Pub
P.ei.3
Imo
j se.=
wkrie-too
tdm=
ttiw
ott
cage
.:me405,
emy
6laeey
r u.a. y J OWE I areal . 3.823 • a OF1e, a2t9 01282 . ¢ . e a3Mi paean jams EEO .a3ae9e awn : aim 9•IGt ma
rar.am.ea
n■wman. a ansili -AasT7 vfl+ie ' 'a` am aa�i "Zia.'
t}nmEedad
. 3•
]
. a.a aa3 �. e3ea.ea3. �a tarp aea3a . eioaese`
2 2 r
01-25
Cont

Page 144 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2261
RTC -432

Responses to Comments
CalEE_ EM414i Version' Ca1EElhad,2016 3.2 Page 31 of 35 Date. 1,42021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed* - Las Argelas-Smith C4asi Caurtiy, later

5.2 Eri-ergy by Land Use - NattirdIGOIS
UrlmIli aatrd
Molds to
• Llsn
4174
Me
Ci.
;.84
I=.ayl..•
laa il'.
rv1MAra
pkg.0
Pu,I la
rat.,
la,vl,.r
1-'1x3 i
rwhaasi
PM2 5
AM!!I
T,iwl
no- Cl2
dNna-G62
tddl.662
GN
21X1.

CC75y
laayuu,.

I TI.I.,,,.
eB11!j'
W.kki}

1.41441rnern.La.

A '4•leieis k9d
Rmre i
,....... 4. .6-4-.4._.

Gs-m.:6S7as
&Adnp
.....x.i,rtr
-I,�T�In,nMA 4Yu7v
t1:xalY AeeCel+aror
w�
• Milady
R.egaua:d
Ragmen -
;rrl ,tl 00!1x,-;
e HIV I9
Ilv
p� , J 84.11 lu3 o
•
f
•: ,•
v
^.J 1L
/ir)
a CC.

ACC.

On
. ]4 - v 6341-ter 41844"
b C.t
DO3 EX35
i 1] 14 131. 04I2 • 2f52131.. 2 al Me. 'M 1 444113Rao
001 ; 0.13 ,1
, 35700.3
, 1-387112
`
4}'696 5-.26-C
1 -1G35
9 4; Y
0 Mal
27,362
a 023W a (12552
4 + 4::58 810 , .236 Oil. 110207 , 0.6772 . 42,4 233
a 4 , . a • a G
t- 1
4015!. . 4.OM
.
-.. }_.
0,957
_}.
73C06r
W.
1 �_...
_ .4444._
bake-
1X3
_ _.. .
?5caril.w.
tit?
, e4tWL� , aMIA.-
i ,
IR13 04�
..
o...y--z._ .;,_
. 1090811 , 150.6811E 2.aliak . 273130. • 151 Maa
y Y
a OW a 1357:
® --4, _.
`'�.IYf1i!.
22714,
`
414-_=
SlilSl} a ?-n'!}i+l s lol'I�J . i1,513.1 ,
i M a i
5 {710 1
911j� ill ._"•.li lr'tll +
r
.

EAT? :�.%aT QQ5ai ; 9 1. }2 :11}
2 i 2 : i Y D
arr
� ua
a4e7S o-� , a3 , 2ar6o-t
8ag . +10+1022o
a:o-ax. oa7}3�
......4..........4..........._..

Sei.li�. ner.lrae
• U ..
o-oi5b S-4153113 • • ea,ir7o-...

F 'i le
i1-
4O4
9#99& 44159 , 2Sklar 1
i ma
a 8037T . ah3Tt . v n 971- (inn
. 6830.50. sg1: fate _
a
0 olit 111414143 45.30 eo 00
r
--
, 251.615
;?7r99c
Le)
91�i..;7 v
•
a
al=i
1l9iAs-:
r 060
!
,
+
1 ie'hiWo-
003
. 1 Valk,
; on
"e n
:

I. War,
, o3 ,
Ib7Li!
4015
+�'�:b516
•
•
s ,795@P4
• bi�589s
" 06s ;
ft..
co.

Cabal a
i 7g 3730
e,d9a..h7d
7 Yeinr
v filch
el 1.41
il- 373

4.416441
as2v2
II510

41. TArx
a
8335.483
2 !.333.6$3
2 9,44102
D1-25
Cont.:

Page 145 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2262
RTC -433

Responses to Comments
CaIEE_ EMoti WersIans Ca1EEMPI2016 3.2 Page 32 of 35 Dale. 14912021 1:49 FM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Angeles-Saalth CoasI Cour61y, later

5.2 En-ergy by Land Use - Natilralaas
int. I'd
htatalba
•4y.
004
Me
c.
;.t'
1=.4y1..•
Rla al'.
rr;rara
PU1b
+'AAla
.'re.,
toi1..r
r' Vi
rwamma
PP425
.NI -2 !I
Tehal
Bo- Cl
1 --(-.CA2
Ulm' 662
c}ua
w]!Ll
m--
Liayuu•.
',am.).
aBYliy
ao.9rty

4.ji3aia'tt Lv.

Rao
AN'araals k4d
alto
Germal W a ...,--4—
r>.d,...
ti•AP T.a,r�.ea iM
ta.xMY Adm.} 4*O
ReoRr
Betel
• • Moody __r
A ergivaal
Reopens r1125181,1 2xr21,62e 0
R
;tra tl Cmt>7.:
a 1 1141r'
]5 1'g13
I x742
t =215£0
Y1 F39i4
. al Feliqi
a.75'7a
p = I_ o
A•
.. ,•
f
v
5 ]4]M
.14
ACC.

On
. a34L •- a 6341 -ter
UJ3 4r15
i 1] 1v 131. 64I2 • 2fv''Cde. 2 I1iU
M1 ; TO e
13 4/tla
42'4 333
G
ib� 680+.
t.
2�5�n}
2 D
9 }S9i- , �":
� aG15
1102-1

_
u �
0 �"a&'
Ll 2iG 4
r
. . .
}
T 1::00 816. a�,'6.4Y.4 . Sr'6Ar v 0.4F"/'
+ r
17 4136 •~ 4.OM
r
0 1497
- i
7 MM.-
WI
_
4 Mae-
'14.1
WA,
'ic7
, e 4 000- ti L•
r Y
RJ3 xXS3
ao.. '
MOW, !�1406,011 :1.alI . F7,73 1
w i MI i 403
4 ! l
. ,
, r
,I ."u11 , Z j}11 , 1 Wall . �0 4131
i w a i
rj 1699
' - Ir7F
4 vr.+� • r, 193y 1r1a1
r
• .t

2.It7}' Wsa .. EAT? A:9t * 00541 . 4114P1
4 i 2 i
t IOVA
4467S w DMA , 2 &M9, r , s . 0.026
r otte

. 0:83"5. • 02ti41
• SS1. 14360 b91. 9436
Sal% . 4-0183 •
o
6344702
533 aSa3
297713
. a OS46
ti
44996 0t1a9 , 236We-, a 80377 075re + . L74377 a., 0MT:
r m4 ; 1a
' 7.56.s'302,34 _
0 alit fl0109 i
r
•"__^ .
r
rf.t,
G24t v
; ;
r0=2 .,-1!4'As-:
r 046
-
a
; i

1.61KWo-
an
r 9 BJCUc
; 4L0
"e r•
:

I. GY79ak
: kW .1
I b74fic
Me
a
20:6416
s 299@P0
. 8.70rJ4o- .

GrFi a
. .

S444r.Ar .
474
o.,..,
v. ilia
l.7443

1.2471
COMM
Mtn,.
015742
aY. a9q.^
O'tia117
Iki35.4t3
2 L.133.010
2 4.4642
04311
r.t4a.Nt
7 6.0 Area Detail

6.1 Mitigation Measures Area
01-25
Cont.

Page 146 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2263
RTC -434

Responses to Comments
CaIEEM9d WersIan' Cj1EEMPc1,20VS 3.2 page 33 of 35 Dale. 1/62021 1:49 PM 11141age South Specific Flan (Proposed* - Las Argelas-Sntrth Caasf Cuurty, Vardar Pula
twu61
W11a
PIM*
Tai1i
Pstis
Tap
ea- c
064
%lir/
1311150839
Ur1n41pata9
N.
. 396Spt 1.5 4t1.s ae 4437 . 96&44
4 T1.1474� • I54'74. 0nam . le,ms it 14..57# 04874 . olati0 Ttda4. t1+

6.2 Area by SubCategary
Unmitigatedt
w9.3
1dG:
]
1Ai�
hgV•'
Putr,
'LF!_th
w:lra
9410
T.

F112J,
rods s
11 ',NUS
Otrtil
TeW
_
ti. tiCl2
-. _- o
ML4m [03
' _ _�
rM� C'P-`:
. —
�
_._- t
n;�6
cc
ubcsrkpnq
Lie uY
WO

74.¢rylertuCal
9xoginp
Congurier .'.'OM
Pi -4..41.4
. 2;970 .
{ { {
OMB i Qp[a1p . 9C®® aim
I
s DOOM
vim—
a 9=9
1 Ocli4
e
.
'
I.

0.00 . 9DOM
I 11
t
. 0CUW . 90400 \
{* -
F (now e .
-
1 p
hl t. n ®
p

1. 1
! , 6 W® i 0 MIMI

1.1460 6 1 1494
t
• 1 14170
i 1.1440
1 30000 • .6 DM CO • I6 [0606 . II 0339040 . 03d .
. IX. ' a :
i
16 1C4 H9
1 51!
.
1 'ti#.:
-
IAr al1� 24M
r
GB..ck ,
62 4•M .:47QpQ�
091.
04674
, 04574
_
•
(14.¢74
• 04574
• 110..6.- MA$16al :01424 .
+
To, al
vven

11.4Mi1
811A4]0
CIMil

1.5074
tS9T4
l
ll

1.61174
66 664.1.1.1474

10.14E39
so
1L 142.5i
s6
04874

0..3n6
1i. Mal
III
01`25
Cont,

Page 147 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2264
RTC -435

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMoti WersIan Ca1EEM41,20V63.2 page 34 of 35 15ate. 14912021 1:49 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposal:4 - Las Angeles -South Coast Courts., Vardar €,2 Area by Sut}Categaty
M i tia ateii
Ruv
N--,
Z

o,;Ffl4'2
wµ1+1
¢m'ause
K00
.11IU
Tmi
FvFew
Vµ; 1
EsOo s
FF•1: i
ISM27
'sa-
IN- C.02
Wgo- CC,2
TCUIl CAS
0,.4
redo
CO3e
il •..-.i 14.1
belle.,
lout,
✓,',11E3 !u111 IN 2mx6•
i
•
a O.mUJ 0 000 . 041ULL id 10pl
UWIk7 I r
GCMG
doom
Id ICON
69 1 44 52 .2

7, -...sus, :A 1035. • ,
1,0fi_ 1. i
-t-
s DUMB . 01:00G ;
Y
Got1� OWED
Y

to a F
Y
, 4 -,
1-..,..11, 10006 . 44 IMF , 44tl+AJ r 000M
1, won . I144,1 .
9 •
11400 x.1+0!
0151:4. .•6.00000. 1600000 i U1460 . 113X0
rn k rap 1 !
Ise :sr a .49,911 • 116 0 , ei4s'JO
!
.4a4tp„- •
1 Ca
04574 , ,1447 4 •
, .
04674 . 04874
. 146`, 61).14468511 . II 1444 •
Tod
3:8_400
115.414W
L[ -N69
CAM

1.6674
tfr47-

1.41O4
'1W4
D.Of79
IL146.19
M

18.111.5.1
60 Mtf1
IIIM
tl,36&tt
L2

7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water

8.0 Waste Detail

8.1 Mitigation Measures Waste

9.0 Operational 0tfrlaad
zrainere Tfpe
HourU,Gup
4<sc rn„e-
Lbil1 FA -IC

10.0 Stationary quipmertt
01-25
Cont
Page148 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2265
RTC -436

ens
Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Versions Ca1EEMod,20193.2 Page 35 of 35 Date. 1/62021 1:49 PM Village South SpecInc Flan (Prapasedi - Las Angeles -Smith Ceasl Caurty, Winter Fire Purnos and Erneravncw Generators
Number
HaulerUa}
Hours/Yes,
Horse Power
Load F➢Choi
Fuel Type
Numtel
kciff
hFpr4iOti}
Held. b ismati
Stoke
Fuol Type
User Defined Rini -omen(
Equpmenl Tyoe
rq uiYibe+

11.0 Vegetation,
O1-25
Cont.

Page 149 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2266
RTC -437

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMaIi'Verslan' Ca1EEMad,20163.2 Page 1 of 44 Date: 111212021 226PM Vglags South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Angeles. Saint' Coast Carney, Annum Village South Specific Plan (Proposed)
Los Angeles -South Coast County, Annual

1.4 Project Characteristics

1.1 Land Usage
Lard Unms
I
[xrmnl Office l3,rideyi di DD 100%01
i .: f -1
sgnlunmver{ pxoFesmaasfl 3400 1(1(rattl tip 1G,see CM3
r
Mee 5aj 0D Ratter s 1 67 _+ 72 EIM.00
Lai Arrraggr
• i a- — s. « a
Ow Rrt56Lurard B.00 10013,41 Opp•} fits • 6,mom
Apeitme Le Rise ± 26 DD }• I 1.0111 k 156 ,_!� �2 4 DI? a a l -t
Apartments. Mir: Rim 973. D4 O,NllfV Linn 25.Be 975,430.3D Z.799 •
i 4---
Ressomi Swizipng Cum- 56 OD 1340641 ii 139 56. DOG
1r
Floor SerlSraD Ann Pnpealdn
455'07 OD t1

1.2 Other Project Characteristics
Urhani2atiorr i_ rtiy:

CBar3rt4Zotra 5
urlley Company Southern Gs. forma E4,een
C102 Viton$ ' 702.49
COD rh
Wind 9]peed
elite eremite,

1.3 User Entered Comments & Non.Defauft Data
a;u
Pre. 1ph,elloa Free Maly*.

Opiratlarol Year
x14 Intamlty
33 20.15

01.25 Coot

Page 150 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2267
RTC -438

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad Version' Ca1EEMod.ZOts 3.2 Page 2 or 44 Liate: 111212021 224 PM Vglage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Lcs Angeles. South Coast Grrniq., Annual Project Characteristics • Consistent with the DEIR'e model Land Lisa • See SWAPE comment regarding residential and rated land uses Construction Phase - Sae -SWAPE comment regarding individual construction phase lengths Clem°It m • Consistent 'writ tlne L EIR's dal See S'VAPE comment regarding demolition Vehicle Triers • Saturday tripe consistent wilt the DEIR's model. Sea SWAPE eorranart regarding weekday and Sunday trips Woodstaves - Vtroodstuvr_v and wood -turning firepbres consistent with the ❑EIRE modal. See SWAPE corranent regarding gas fireplaces..

Energy Use -
Construction 4 -road Equipment Mitigation - See SWAPE comment.= rJoordiruction-teialed m rtlg:rtbn Area Mitgatian - See SWAP comment regarding operatronat mitigation maestros Water Mitigation - See SWAPE comment regarding operational mitigation measures Tripe and VMT - local biro premien
X11.25
Cont.

Page 151 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2268
RTC -439

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod'V2rsians CalEEM41,20163.2 Pegs 3 of 44 Date: 111212021 224 PM Vglage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Las Angeles - Sault' Coast Camr1Py, Annual tcrweme,rrp,
cavehici9Trpe
=T_TR
8T_TR
eTe 3.75
• 9i. 8
a-«
NWINVERTrgs 5T_TR • 49 97
• •
89P/Er9E₹TPps 3ULTR • E 0
TbrkterhiGkTnpi+ SUy TR , 5F.
r, .., .... ivwa�o�
•, tM1NTls4topi a Sli_11{ 1 en —® 1
......... a• .. ........ 4 . ........ i• ....... . 1 • . 884MehkYTnp SQTR• • .. 12T L1
}DN
a.16
1 15
4 8t/hlehk:leT s 914 114
4 WNeiTii,,T r'Fi slr_TR
a
mNeriiNei5pe 8U_TR
4 @+d4lhiciTrga WL7_TR
ttommi writs a WD_TR
4 d1MlhkleTr_a 1 WQ_TR

4..
tbrlterarieTnp• Yd5_TR :
hi 4-4
mNehieleTrFe WVP_TR
4 { 6sNeincleTrps WDL7R
I1f15Aer,icl8T 1 pa WG_TR
i
traW sriTt3iei KenberCitalrk
5 ad
•
1a
24 6 a5

11.53 127 15
69 95
42 712

12. tENr41Uv 8? Nimterea}31y4c
•
tt1%'i 71rmi
4 .s"
Islam608Ng11car.eiic
Vic.dilwati4yierir
1rmccain elayYmr
CalWeattunws Waa ue Woreleass.
86 75
1 25
9 64

0.00 7121

3.20 9.33

9.63 4.13
▪ 4T
8565 BB
62841

41.43 9.90
993

9.93 ▪ Ce
G.5]
O 173

03.51 2.O Emissions Summary
01-25
Cont

Page 152 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2269
RTC -440

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod'VeraIans Ca1EEMod,20163.2 Pegs 4 nr 44 C7ate: 911212021 224PM VElage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Las Angeles - anal Coast County, Annual

2.1 Overall' C4nstruttrr n
Onmitiaated CcnstruWtk rI
eoT-i
I
1J.:.
co
3C_
r.; yr.e
.' NI'i
'Lollies*
Plato
4,711{1
Tate
Fug',
P.1 7
C,,s„.4
FR4`i
SIM27

9.4:
ler C.07
WM- CO7
Iere' C 2
Gee.
n
LO7e
WF
YfA1j1'
r', I : v
I
e a 1.54

1.5234 o 1 95
. ?B6]4 • G4 I41 0. Del: r 0 44410 • L'.» ' utiI'
i' •:EO • 71, '554 . 210 iii r Jt•u 1 o;L7]J
I :17:RJ1
3II3
w O'.t67
w
472+47 ' 5 47oC
t
00155 • GRIM 0.117'2 ' 1rraL9 , C 251 a1Ir.4, , ., 7r, -.a < •
. 1
.40747 1• -
aiA[4 .e4i3 {{gr9.49E B55 P.13'5 • LCTA7u
r
• • 4 r 4 : •
.I42'ri2
1 b
*:-y a O51WA
x.247O I 470111 o 03166
51497 O.0@1'1 r OW89. • L2S3 ' 0O2"2
0019)0 •'342 ♦49 i 14 .3 .4411 0.1155 • 00707 ''14,5.
226
w
I
r
._d
2 b 2 1 •
e•-•
, s, .,5?,.i
'•.:1 - 61642 • @73121 • O2597 •} • a#Y2Y Ikar€1 1 JI 5b79'fr,-...=5 .16- •
d1.099dr . 44 •: 44 5505 .76',1C1ir• roxrt*°I
d
,
! A • (7Jfi 1 L4'7
1 •
• 6 1 027 d
•
■fteetore
4,17$•2
tp3
eorale
ems
h'091D.
won
LAMS

4.25t1

4.1t�
O7&i
16434
7etlie0e
T.471-4577
tt21S

0.Deee
t421.442
4 4
7 O1'2
Cont

Page 153 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2270
RTC -441

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod'Version' Ca1EEMod.2 I 3.2 Page 5 of 44 Cate: 111212021 226PM VElage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. SautJ1 Coast Gault", Annual 2,1 Overall C4nslructrrm
Mitigated Cons lructl*n
I I400
-WA i
c
12 ,..g.V.e
OM I''4.
rEldaull
PkI10
ahllD
T
Fv9EWE
PM`IS
rwriGs
FMii
1!M27
,.t...t, .-
©I!- C.02
NI9o- CL37
Vt. C12
CPA
N 0
CD2e
]Y3. •
w

04.:

Iy233I, a 119 Tr
2MOOR.

Y>3
01141 O.OBI: 1 a4 I L".-» 1 0Ow ..- �r-
!ir.EO r71', . iI1 f=9s9 �90 C,l U tJ C . 01033

17.1226'1B
CILW ..r5,
•
O'.665
:

3.2094 . 7090 . 0011'
1 r r
Y
-'-_
,
I. P� .. 00101 . 01,461 2 L 3 ! 005 r2 03166
o
CIOXO , ,. j,4� +4 1_]42.,yla P.1,L6 . BWL•p
p P •
u
.v.:, - .15(r2 • i1 0 IPi5t 239T
• } WON,
[: •:I; 1 r:366 ✓11'x•36 • '+b71'n.,-
6la.luu..ni
..15,52

4.0240

6.1545
4$95,0
&5,•A*

0.1P7!
tA61t1

4.4517
II1

0.1447
ablal
r03630 ,
CAMEO
0 ¶41L -!is!
0 ,4}'295,
0 500

1.12-1.053
RO0
NO.

CO
Fowl.

PM1ii
Exir,
PMic
17114
Tall!
Fr.op;!11
PM2:5
E.11 ..0
Pill
PM2.5
Trmo4
am-co3
Nei -CO3
Taal C4T
CH4
run
i-02..

NI Loll,
Redlr`t,..
uuu
ON
n: ;^ry
u.Bll
P :to
u Do
ulna
u'un
B. NO
0uii
,7ne
1{.7
u OP
00C
Orti

0.nlf
{wawa
Sow Dm*
El'd Diet
41Ywmolm LivimQIkmad NOG . No3X Il li.111W'IMI

47..111.4..,47 64t15tttii' 943u . NDOf Ioum!9tur1411
1 9-1-2431

11.37.2021
,..!
Q ,'
.,2.1,2921

7.2822022
'!"!..Z..3
a _,
r.7.2bV
— S.?T•2022 I
o ..di
..
a
t•-1-:Nk22
lQ4.-2n72 �
1 !q5'r
• •1 5
wY-]14.37
11-k-2023
1,1%
,
B -
a2:.-053,
2-mswu I
1 o.7.B
o ?s
r
3-f-293'3
S21-Nlk1
r
6wS49
y.

CsnBB
5 s -Y-2023
9i61.252a
09E31
L9re31
01-25
Cont

Page 154 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2271
RTC -442

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMa-a'Verslan' Ga1EEMstl,ZOI 3.2 Page 6 of 44 Date: 9112!2(.821 226PM Vglage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles. Sault' Coast Gcinty, Annual 0^7.2017
1130.7027
00705

7.0705
VT I
12'.2029 `
249.2024
20757
2075T
71 1^9.2U2+'
}11.2071
9 6759
r 6799
{(pure.
76757
24757
22 Overall Operalionai
itmlili atud—C24t[aticw,al
— 900
WV
CCU
552
'Nairn,
1'5'11.8 `
r Eeh■uY
N190
M4 I6
T
p,�7twtt
FM25
Ellouy
MC -5
Pkr:S
Tot.

Be. CO2
4Bn, ea:

Tula Chi
C3+'+
04273
COI.

Cir�y N
1ar{Y
--
A,a
...,
fur
Mc7i2w
5143T 02057 . 9r.-4790+ . 11703., . • 9 NIA, . 90?1< ^ 9MI< 00714 i. 0d
Z--- -- 1- i 4 -I i - (- I 1 I -
O 9+x71 • 223 il57 fi, 2=a 66711 . 60201 • 37,9T..
, 03'3
t t

7..`.5.835
i»... .
:1612 1
9-
w 49189 + 11973 �. (}7774 • VBt6trm• a 04609 ? 90699 , : 00696 r 4.0499 41 4 1
..
...,,
40509 . 2.685971 I. 569.On, 91569 4.4+04
9 .00©979
17457 b 72952 i 1¢189+ • 0(7677 . 77679 945fl 2.5 4 7 '4 , 7i16F15 0{0 7 0. 7tk� •
i : t i
,7Elm +76biF,ErID 14A• 09+971' r 44040
0 : 4 i i
rF.6 ,01$7
2 • 271555.
r 02 7,507,50:,S
•• • Ntd6a • 4.c.co 44496 4_,844 • 4.9.194
e '
202 Ian ., 4W44 • 191'.1079 • 122411 94(94
01 VaYYr 1 4.466a r qM r a 0 (7100 $ GO=

•
2 r

55.. 4 7 5-810057 r 30763 I 46755
79,1919{7
75481
+50097

6.5773

99.5407
1460)71

7.7670
10790
10245
7-.6905
— --1-
897i6

7.5111
7'981717
17,7➢+.90
117

13.591.95
-me
15,7164
01240
lll
fl i? -t47
51 O1-25
Cont.

Page 155 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2272
RTC -443

Responses to Comments
CalEEMa version' Ca1EEMod,20163.2 Page 7or44 Date: 111212021 2:26 PM Vglage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Las Ange{es. SQlrt91 Coast Courtly, Annual 2,2 Overall Operational
Mitigated O erationa
RIT.3

03. CO
uG-
t•.Isrt'R
IEIt'iaue
MI I9
Fupetz
rwt9us

14.12 7
LN- co
,413,9- CO:

VI. G112
0,4
7f%10
t o
Cm e9611,
ilrob'
r7",..
!-'(a 4. 9143,
C;DYJ
P 10 RUH
10;000.

O. D719 , 307N 00; I. 33:11
iC..:(o . O5,, , TO .
titre
3;77.783
0'MZ. t19
6 ' SYA IL9$4
. t.JEM1 7507
Eni+9v F. -, 1:P6
' 23:.

Co 777,
'OTEls-..
0TM Q10G[S. . 0Ar49 owes
acoca .2It99:0- `'_r 913[. . 453
4Ym it -.
w
'ar_
31971
,3 =I . 7AIN ,3 OM . TWO . 2Al5 . Q9639 i 21+
o
o,34 aCaeo .7:Ageh ,Ts 9 0 499, 3907 . WO
4 N
.v,.a.�
,
90017) ; a09779' G9694 44690
i i
, I F
:{Y7 .�. : , . . . ., ..,+a 19.4(K0
.

Ytaw_
_,..-

0.0909 :. 0 0000 . : 0 COM ,30096
_
29 192 . 903 t, 4`L . `•'' 9092
3 0 MS . 6 CMS
TUIJl
, 45.44912
9572`.

70. WI.'
(1037,1
—
7'.T ,979.

0.1~190
aAND
29995
0#319
27 {14
2110012
1ZY!U 19.

IIf
17SIt1ib
'19
19704
I1U
I?vmJU
01 !439
N9t..

CD
UN
K711glre.
i41.1 to
CO.:KM
I•M1ll
PIN lm
Taw
Nolo,
7992?
Calw,asl
rT4e..ti
M,42,6
r+Jlal
111a•c02
N UF- 2
!MA CO2
Cr 4
N20
c4G2.
l•N [ 0111
4whnnim

0.011
III 40
U.IkI
9I]II
lI 01
1 1111
0 DC
U 011

9.00 U.UU

0.00 0.40

0.00 7.99
U 0

3.0 Construction Detail
Con4Lructio_n F ti75B
01-25
Cont.

Page 156 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2273
RTC -444

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMori Version' Ga1EEMod.20I63.2 Page S of 44 Gate: 111212021 226 PM Wage South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Angeles - Sinai Coast Cowry, Annual Number
INDDrzs Name
F�1^r Prapanliri
rarirq
atYmT
i
ENd Dile Ihfalmi MO 01601 Blip
Ares
Ler,IDIthOri ^3,.17_Cti1 1i%112U121 3P:
u_ -- _ _ I .. 1,
*SOPreRreuri ilorisrir,14' 117 -". ,,,. . nil
ii•rad"rB r� - 11711;02141 1; 1 191'0422 : 5: a .:
:431+DdiniDOneekliNDOD I raidng Cpradtc;rrrl 1.15?1733V. 11,'adi2rd¢;r5 6) 6001 nvmg ill.. .
�F� 112I11 -- 173C5 .... t5`i4 6; 15.

I a ,~-- F
:Architectural Coating :Arrtdachrai Cueing 11r317201'1 ,9rrA':[Cd 6r 55+ 4 Acres of Grading {Sire Preparation Phase)_ D
Aces of Grading (Grading Phasey 112,6
Acres of Paving. 0
Residential Indoor 2,025.000: Residential Outdoor 6755,000: Non -Residential Indoor. 326;486: Non -Residential Outdoor 1DB,&00 Striped Parking Area: D (Architectural Coating — sot!)
OffRaad €quapment
01-25
Cont

Page 157 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2274
RTC -445

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnIi Version' Ca1EEMPd.ZO163.2 Page 5 of 44 Date: 111212021 2:26PM V0lage South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Angeles - Sault' Coast CarrmIty, Annual PTaic Taunt
1 O9leed Ecitgetrieit Type
,4mdutt8
Lltacm Hash 1I
Hmx Pctrrtt I Lied Fade,.,

1.-ori
., mr-nm:lrahoProl Sa
} 1

3.00..
51" 373
,i4,a!i
----- .----4
E.vavd1w
.....- 3
�
.._-
(1.39
nrnwlton
.Rubber read Maws
bop,
247:
a 4
'Aaflep4rinon
-PxdwerTlntdWiwi .
a 3
a001
247°
a 4
s414Plaradatlmr
----i
4 E98.

17. 537
r=.racm!p
:E,wi4vaLv:s
l, :1
EAaq
this,....
,1D as
lrao9p
•cranes
1 8 013,
R7,
0:411
Gratre'v
R 4lx! rind 4nte!e
}_—.._'___.—.___ 1
7a
i
_a-
_.._,• 13.40
•
Gras._____ --------- ____......

Gracing
:rradaralLeadereBultrcea
73Y
_.

ET.

Puilriw•+g Cenatuttiun
:Crones -�
i
' . i; :
,1:

3.29 I
I-- -3----
1 ----- .- ---
- -I
. ._ . . . . _, _..
0 0..------.---.-.-,..r----.--E
------ ----,--,.------
..
.TrecturalthadirarBackivai
r 3
--- .,__..._I
` G:
.-

57. ----- -....

Q.37
I
IF_-

I. ---
- __ --
1 a 45
..
1 :niaves 2
130:'« .......042
w
w..�-.--.----'------
-
.-.-
"wing
;P.vft2 Equprnank
2 .
3 901
122
Q.36
Pawing
ollpliya
2 e0o3
{1pi_

0.35 A fi'IEC[[1ur91 Ca41ngy
yA IrCn1p $T9
•
1' no..
13:
0 a
Trills and MT

01.-2.57
Cont.

Page 158 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2275
RTC -446

Responses to Comments
CAIESMod'VersIan' Ca1EEM•k 120163.2 Page 10or44 Cate: 1112.2021 226 PM Vw]loge South Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Angeles -Sault' Coast County, Annual rt ' or iker Dip V tklet TI•
Alumter reutetts
wWlto III
MuT0,01
YI1 Talp
VlYRlisr T
•1r . llhe Trip
LDP
Weiler VMtI!
Gies§
NeuriN
1MI1cre Cla%.

Da•nor0on ISC,Jr
• -Ih I
Sts PcyxaArJn • Tw 1 °. JS'
g� 12 ry-i

9.�cJ tS CUB 1!
Der 9 m�
6901
I amity,' carkarxrain • 91 .001. DC.r •43 C0 0.00•
• ice_,... Viiii .. ,.r.,.i
PPYn1,0 Fl 10 Oar 090
II I 1
P. [hlrectural Coating
tea
19 09

10.00 —1
=. ?_k11x
r'HDT
ie 901 3J-47iLD_Vlot ?MDT Mix �}IHDT
19 DO
0 00i 19 90
0 90 090? 10.09!
6 990 20.WILr;_kr.e 'I- it„ -. . 'HD?
I 1 1
5001 20000.D'- saes .11-1.7 k10. IHHDT
16 t991 10 W.i Lf>!„'klas rt]'1'MIA -_. HHDT
9-99! a10 00! LD_W
'}Ftii7i

3.1 Mitigation Measures Construction

3.2 Demolition - 2031
unnrtiaaated Conalrur=tion on -5d
I
403
HO•.

CO
SCO
FLI{IN*
PFA19
EYT.Wst
P14110 Teel
PM13
fug1M
MD
EFS .•a
Pbl]5
RA75
?.,=re
S.- Vat
HE. G07
THAI C9.1 P
420
CL2R
-airy-+,
1>•°r•IY•
Mr*
c,.jn•.a rm.1
•'?R -Rae •'
r
• . 11'0{0'3 . 0 WO ' 010150 •'513A-♦ 00410 • 7510,01-. 00} r OM
g9091J, • 944,+] , awar r, germ + 999;71
' 00.01{1 '.
51 W..LI
'
0005
• 0Vier •
r .
x1.12:.5
• 5E90,t 9 •
: 004 •
'
01:x33 •
•
99431
• • OC•701
•
• 00;1n3
90079 • 5'19917
.
, 51.981,1
• 0.0144 • • 9.0099
•
'
T 1+0'
40475
arms
0:7795
swam,
004
soi@' R
$0233

0.0700
75100. - Will
WU,
IR
Lent w
0110@1}

51.0017

51.0012

0.0131

0.0000
513001
01-26a
Con'
Page159 of 548 I Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2276
RTC -447

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMota Version' Ca1E00w:1,20163.2 Page 11 of 44 Date: 111212021 2:26PM Vilage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Snud1 Coast County, Annual 3,2 Demolition - 2021
yntnititisted Construction Off -Sits
R I u
N 1
CO
O1O
I-vg71f+{
AgPa
i'iea14
Pull r.,
FM I'1
1*F
t007f.{
SRt;y
IiA2l¢R
[va?i
1±52.?,
.,n.
1141- .7,112
MI6- COr2
1F.dll CO2.

DM
WO
CO2
I
,.:.I,y'.Y

11.4.01•
Wry
-1452'51
w I.ItY,48= . 641038 !10:80 . I ba3O 3'04alkc r s 000%6 . 4 13050. 1 ;1yp01. 0 1 501300 .
1 2000a
:, 55$51 + q 1 4[S] 11 45430 121CC18• O DLOli
I: 403.14
CC4 744 : DO C(.1 :10)
00? 141
[ya3
.X13 ;
1'isdll
-V.. 00100 . 60000 . 000IC . 00005. • 00000 . 04000 . SI= 101217 t %COW
COMB
O.GOO:
. G.0000 000110 • Burr. . 00070
0 XVI
',,•..Ne
.. ?lima, . 5. KIX, , 5.0059s . 20001R . row.- . ! win, . I.1111143 460.75.- . 0000., . 4RCM.
0 C
. 1.57111 15$1 . 6.(1}3143 . 00005
' 1'x1+3
X.14
. 004 1 01
a
" 5C4. f 0011 , f745 053
051
r 045 1 sat
.
005 q
1 1ae.i

1.63011*-
9-4,01
650205
Z0000-
5� t(4-
'2.000 s.
51400s-

1.5000.-
1 OM.-'
I.TSEO.a
Amp
l% R�
%war

1.10.-
5, 0001
1y,ne01.

CO3
Oi.M.
000
e0f
003
005
0¢11.
003
003
Ova Led ConntrUctlon On•SFta@
L -, .v.

CC
501
R100oa.

PMh3
OOsull
Rolle
PM 143
1,t.

FAO.*
PM2.0
E:4
F.I25
14 5
4411
0a- CO2
141ia CO2
1'r]el 4301
C11.4
M10
COZI
i ��
MAID, 1

3.143435.

F.r,O•;e 0411
OTI Read
w
00405 OG000 • 114140 • 751008- lrrrt3 • 751430►
. 010 f 003
00000 • 0111103
343
30 3[000 • 3 00 . 00000
. 0 0000
51354343
30475
•
54714 r 43775 • 55004► . . 0G233 • ➢433.1 • ]1:510 • 443315 r • ON . r . .
0❑OC4 a 543011
.

51.0011 • 1143144 a 00030
• ,
Told

0.4415
04314

0.11330
_
i0510e.
5107
004011

0.0Z115

4.07 0.7104.-
003
3302)0
__
GAM

0.90@0.
_.
51:0011

51.0011

11.0144
-,

0.0000
513000
O1-2611
Cont
Page150 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2277
RTC -448

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMo v2rsion'Ca1EEMad.20t03.2 Page 12 of 44 Date:111212021226PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles -South Coast County, Annual

3.2 Demolition - 2021
Jltitioated Construction Off -Silt
90C.

N13
C4
OLC
I -14.0,e
PH NJ
f.1'aaW
P..111
.81,11 1
Iota.
..p1,
11-i c
I >A

64.174
t•IR7.5
m.
n-,- q42
POW- CC1.3
tdr 001.

OW
WO
CUB
"v''Y
Iten.q'
Mrer
1 -ISJ1,0 .
1'ssEa< . M.

I.0300er . [0031 06:.01 • I613006. 3'0400.7 I .LAM. . 4'I3C0e.

CU3 I:034 DO 4o1 :o3
.39009. . .501141.. . MOB..
u03 a2. ...'S
.I,_fj7[ . 1I. ir8'J Ii 4500 MCC®• Daum
i 033
I: &gal
. ]4a& 0
, 1' 7
0 Ecce . C 437 . SCOW• 715 . 600177 • 07000 . 0
.
- .. .1 _. -._ }. -.

MCC 00337 I SC . COMO
_ _
00 1X,
c11(XM
. 7.0005 00000 . 6300G , 70070
k
---.._..- . ;..2
Y1A 9k IS --- -o-
:r14
.
. 5.3061'7 SpIWs
{47-0 1
'
_CO010- . 15r4`.a- I .1714#Jt . I5A00r • 4.6Q7Je-
r 544 . 0."(3 I 4"45 90-3 y 0114
. wow di.�p40r
. 0X6 4151
• 1.5781
.
1 S$1 . 6.000Ce.. 000'}'J
. 0US

1.n.1
MM. -
0013
MA*
(4 -20.1
$11070.-
left!
.5410.+
003
ktMI0r
Cei
7#296441•S4p1E-
903
09S
1, MP.-
q15.

L77.).

00.3 4. -.N
lkttlt47
% OW

1.240a.-
003

6.IaAA
1-aint

3.3 Site Preparation -20.21
Barn ragMed Constructions, On -SIN
s-
Sac
Ra40.9.
4 150
F.Ywt10
PM1C
1'0.110
"film
+-74!2.7
PM:,5
"r,Ciriom
MR
PC
T41.
1 __2
NB. SC.2
idal CO3
C}4M
MD
=..M
t,a9v.. D,11t
O5PRco0
— 01007 I 00000 • 01037 • 5.0513 3Cf.1_ C.,JX-
w °r w i
•

e•i75C- . 700 )3
50760
3 X50 . 000)0

;1 t4iG
. 377551
0:.730'2 • 6.x353 . 0.3115 • 35000.- . 711204 • 57334. • 3C..82 • 70151 - . . CD. • . • e •
. •
074[0 ,, 314357
.

31.4357
37107 0115
, I
n®101 GAM
Q0 044
042

0.211E
111000..
034
01007
002B4

7.7611

6.01145.
4 045&

0.1151

0.0040.

33.4307
'5 .4357

0.0-1{6
00000
1 33.7001
01-25
Cont,

Page 161 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2278
RTC -449

Responses to Comments
CaIE Etib6ti Version' Ca1E EMaii201S 3.2 Page 13 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VIlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Li3s Ange{es. Soudl Coast County, Annual 3,3 Sae Preparation • 2021
IJnrnitiaaled Construction Off -Sits;
Moles
NIT* . I
LQ
not
tUQo
Lh1•0
ta-aeru
Penn,
.Rhi l 'R
Iota.
'u3.li-•
11-i c
16 151

64.174
Wkl7 .r1 '
m.
n--cri
N$N,Lt12
1Fdr001.

OM
M�1`
CUB
-ukim 0 + .
•_ ' LC,
1 Lui'_ J 4191, • 0 WO) O DOM it ilait, : L :1::: ..n_ . :_ l=Cti J 4701 ONO] 0 03130 • 0 100 I) 1000 ,.._Ll.

V
-.-Weala<• -
.
%l
0O�tiF
.O 01
.Ci1 - 3 :DM • C. 0000 • 0Co00 • a. . D0W?:, ]CSGC . 0.}7] a.Ol• .• 0. 11400 9.[490 • 0MUG , 0OU37 •
,]OII
V1h.k44 • • .
- I.,)-‘,04,
4 311., , 4 ow, . ! ¢Ym.. • I.34O4e- • • 00S1 - 1011
I .- •• OWN, 3. , 0490. • 3 7000.
h 003) • 1104 12225 1 0 4.411]00. • 0 0000
• 1=7.4
. 404
a. • SR"3 !44 sos , 095 403 a 644
006 . 4104
• . OM y
1 T.041t
4 .-
ka0a
445141.--

4..41114.
i.0aa0..

1.3444

1.1.11a00. t.3.500.: 1. 0.

13.500.-e

1.94Ft
f.a46B
a.TC44.-
a.0aF1

4.1.-
t122.4 CI4.440,1,0 t3

4.4 17118 -a
1)0011
i0,i
004
:1 :1
Inks
has
-.

0.i
Mei
604
636
0011 I
at s
Mil Ina Ltd Conntructlon On•SI[a
s -
Sac
Rauh-
F1l 0
f:Ahauar
PM1C
Fmk] f--u41i.o
Ida.

P143,0
"O1)00 .

MR
PC 5
inns
t .-.,:"..2
NB. 1010
id..I CO3
C}aM
f.±0
CG.,
t,,;nh.. D,nt - S I007 • aGO00 • 331,537 • 0:0003 3CCe1_ • C ]-s_".

4.471- • 001474
CI I:1260
3IMO . DOOM • 3,-0:i:
w °r w i
•
•
OPR
O G00
4002 a5%3 • 0.3115 • 34001.- . 00 9 204 • L :04. • 30142 • 130102 MOD D . 311367

31.4307
3]102 00039 -•
307174
. • . 'fie • •
• • e
t
Told
Q'93ta
I1404i
03110
1W00..

00..10@7
EMU
113011

6.004}.

PAM

4.1151

0.0019
331307

0.435!

0.1100

0.0000 I
t

43.7000
LOA
I 11
471.25
Cont
Page162 of 548 in Comment Letter 0
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2279
RTC -450

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMota Version' Ca1E EMot1,2015 3,2 Page 14 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM ? Tlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Lrs Ange{es. South Coast County, Annual 3,3 Site Preparalwn -2021
Mitigated Construction Off -51e
llOu
Wflt
CO
502
r -u0 ..
am 0
Ciea14
will,
FM I'1
NO.
tulane
SRt; 4
0I4 405
PM
F42,?
.m.
flat- •7,.42
ION, Cd2
FtI 092.

DM
WO
CO2
i
,: •ley°oy
t6tiNJr
UPI.
-12,0,42 oazai
5;44416
➢Lui'_ • J ilC, • C:FJ7J 05006 • 00� • 00 1 ,, 4.Cm1 • t;Oxo II LOX • 9. Mal 9 Q.YVI • 3Mx, 1 I) 0134341 •
09CU,
' 0000C
r
LI tea.
%'sari . 0xa
yl. _
C.:43C0
.Cis+. • 3.`4]31 . 1:02144 r ocean . a. • 50033 1C4GG • G.0300 9.4405 4- -l- 4 s
r C.II009 GOM0 • 0300D q 00570
9 Wolter r 5.93 1.1,-
- ;C4
4 .76.a
(0.,
i kippe . 1100313w ., 1316'x- r . I020i - . 11192,(I..- • 3.416'3x- Qi n 4X4 • 102 , 02 . 4R@ r 50'4
• MEW • 3 704k-
a' . o

0502) : 12225 1 X. • 4.01X.
• 075 e
05000
l.nw �-5.94111+1
400
c.7Raln-
44,1
' a.9a4[o-
005
;908)..
965
t.ljs6•. '
7193

1.01h¢t-
0-
* C]i9Px-
eta
0:p4p>f
560

1.A05M-
ros
'MON- i
soli
s99F1

4.172.5
tYX1a
R4s9tMMe-
405
op09n
i.7'r5e
Id Grading - 2021
Unmitigated Construction On
Rataa

19. CC
502
FUPSre
FM 0
ld•.1s
PMIO
P5110
lam
-Fusin.*
PM2.0
Ei#a•m
PM: S.

F.,12 5
trots
RC CO2
11144 002.
'Pia] 003'
CI -4
4420
401
C _0Ja.4
Pu'44W 1
-
PAT 2W
x.5.14. [...lit
Oft Rcua
-
C 1041 , 3G900 • 0174, • 51'.119 .. 015171E • 50;23.
i w r
r
00X0 • 00070 70000
3 vv. • 00075
, O0400
• 14132?'0
33709?'
r
T
0-89;4 r 00010 • 11500.- • 9G3, --r • 01007 0 I? 9]337
• 703 • • -
0 003 • .[45495 1415435
7413E r 0110 I

Told
Q.OtO
0 4111 7

9.0!07
liana,
01741
41477
112115
4005110
A53+11

0.1044
_ 4.0100
400.5401
157.0+100

0.6 376

0.11 000
404.317iD41
01-2€
Cont

Page 163 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2280
RTC -451

Responses to Comments
CaIEEtibDti Version' CalE EPAPPL2016 3.2 pate 15 of 44 Date: 111212021 224PM VIlags South. Specific Flan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Soud1 Coast County, Annual

3.4 Grading - 2821
yntnitiaated Construction 0ff-Si1
ROG
N6r.

CO
502
tt34,e
IRA .0
ta-aeru
P1. r.-
Rbi I 'R
Iota
•a61.-•
li-i c
lioduom

64.174
RP,2A '
= mr
G., 002
. - CC1.2
tthic02.

OM
WO
CC/2.
a,-1
itdibgr .. . _ . ..
tiny
Y
-ukim
V d51W x
'1 J'-
=.Ur.
➢ L.y7'_ J)Ic . LI 43D) iJ&Oi NuCCE,.

LJ•J:.:
..n_.
. :_.J=Cc.

JLOS ODOM OCHE . 37033 0Dlr7rJ
V
,.._CL
...X.:4,
:I:420
0MiC
C.:a0

7. CCU': 3iF3CG . C:0003 . DDOQQ . aims
6030.7
3CCU
COMO
a. MOD . 511000 6IOQ . ilex's q DBUM •
:.+.Nn - I.2a14
Z. S
0 DO.e—...
'66i
it ORD
. 3 CM* .
. Q4
20305.,- 1 [Me- .

QDi l ees
21ROOR- . IKON-
V 554
:COW. • P .00Sgr
Gr.R 4,a1
•
4 O TZ . 2 NM
.
19000
. O.0:CO.- L. 01Y1J •
5 sorri

4.zss -
366
@.?6!-
Ad
0:090.1

3.Ma .

A65
24:04-
0M! I
240630.
0i15
8p00.r
AO!
1404r>-
0M

2.5555.-
_
'7.ty00.- i
Mt
A3m0

7.066!

2.51011
L4045 -
365
srn.m,
5sirlc
Mil Ina Led Construction On•Si[a
~
-
.
s -
SO2
Rah,.

RAW
Eutain9
PM1C
PN113
Tut..
+-u41i.c
R12,5
Efirua
R.R `-
PC 5
1l41s

7.-02
N60. CO2
rd..' CO2
014
MD
C-2,
c1!€4. r
rumor
6Rrya
r -vv.. DJ -a

OOPRGOO
-
C
SIis I . DG0 G0 . 0 171, . QIMI 3Lair. s7L
•
3 i:ox . 0674 CI MO 000 . 3x.00 . D4
3%v
104 3;75
it QM
r
Q-89ie r Js4] • I iiLLs
. 305
CI . ➢a37d 3L3ii T• 07337
. •
04GQ . °035403 Im5473 33'.3E r OOa
Told _

4.5I
6001P 7
710007

1.1LU0s
301
0,17'41
40077
021150
64043.
76301
161014 -_.

0.0006
700.6141
105.6963

0.4170
_
011555
404.317n i
01-25
Cont.

Page 164 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2281
RTC -452

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMool VatsIans Ca1EEMod.20103.2 Page 10 of 44 Date: 111212O21 224PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Lcs Angeles -South Coast County, Annual

3.4 Grading -2021
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
IOC,
NO
C4
013.2
1--wthe
P1A•-0
CaI-aeru
Pia1G
Rbii1
Iota.
'a01._•

11.1 c
Iry

64.174
IAR7.5 '
= m,
n+WSJ]
IOW- CC1.2
tdr 001
DM
WO
CG
y,,

10.r.h. .. _ . ..

Mr,
-ukim
Vte.dr
Y
0 J'-
=-L.1
➢ CO,'_ JiLCY4 . LIinD) iJ&Oi •0 gal].

LJ• .:
..n_.
m :_.J=Cc,
JLOA 0 N dC000 . D7000 ri(HIM
V
,.•-LL
.r O:rA•
_' -:0.
x 0MCC
C.:a0

7. CCU. 70070 h 0:DOM , auxin . atom
-f
50007
4k:

OCC0C
0070.0
a. MOD . OHM 0.0010 . aaxo . 00BOL .
4N;aker'-1 I.20110o-
4043

0.YJ04:e
415407 r 10C00r .
a 0L.6
=Ma- d 1CO
ain i 096-
2i 2 Magr- •F7.6WO
000 y 1104
00000• • P.00Sgr
r C.r., 4]4
•
000X. • ,24034
.
1',!000
. &M 0, 1J01YX, .
0:6
laid

1.1+46 --®MM.-'
a61
084
twee
_1001)0.-
m s
't.tg lia-
MS M6

2.feaa
MOO*.

CM
140t.t.-
061
'2.Si Mi-
CM
t. OF i
rrr

4..M.
241104

7.' 9
M0 0a -
CM
,nr m
asrl0

3.4 Grading -2022
Unmitigated Cunstructlnn 13n -Sate
s -
54c
Rauh-.

R ,0
=,a.....,o
Pf.11C
Pula
Trde
+-u41i.c
P!4 5
adman
P1.R `_
PC 5
1!uaa.
_ _ _,

NIIa CO2
TallTLC
47-4
,f.±1
CG.,
..
�_a!€9i 1
. lowyr
- _ Mrs
t,a;nh.. D,nt
OfPRe00
..
- . 04677 . 7CC00 . 00607 • C21,0 1CUL • C01L,C
w r
1•iYB . 0 W
70-60 • ammo . DOMB
00GCti
. 107-t'•
] 1.7. 111 DEO . J 4017 • .200.0-- . 57200► ..57200► • S:1OOa • 5 3i174s . . ]04 : . 000 . W6 D00 . 776
0005 . 140871

10.0871 • 517DCa . 0661`1
. an .

Told
0997A
glass 7

9.10I!
17LOM
033 067

0.0001

0.72-30s. 40
6 0
(HMO0≥1'�

4.3000-•
043
40433

0.00@0.
140871
4!.-871

8.17000
W3
00 0.06
102144 1
O1.25
Cont.

Page 165 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2282
RTC -453

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMati Version' CalEEMOtl,2016 3,2 Page 17 of 44 Date: 111212021 224 PM VTlage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles - Sault' Coast County, Annual

3.4 Grading - 2822
yntnitinated Construction Off-Si1
ROG
11e.
co
OCQ
r-ug,..

PM•a
Geary
pr 1r.

FM I
taL
uP6.{
SRt;
lios,auv
[va?i
F.42.?,
.,n.
rim- .M,2
MN, Cd2
FdI C92.

DM
WO
CI0a
-12,0,44 a 02IEL • C 9,0CO
0 COpM • a flAS
0 6330 . 0J C-0Oa • 00306 D arum.arum. iX • BU 0 • [m • GOT° i ( • 0 . Mil 9 00C • 0 D • 0 DIM 9 CC99
i..-Ydrakr
-_
.
0kc00 . aoxo
aE 0. a a
6011] • aa00a + a . DOWD a CCM • C:O7CO -
-
a 3000 +.. 911000 9 040 • 00009 90900
a cca
.
•
• ,
;.. . R
! t t� h
d 1
1 v
W,:6, 7..1. • I .Da,
7,.4

1.?CIR. • I.OIOGOr r 6,2r10aa- amp 33U3Ga• i I 4309. 94Y_rra . 74+XJUr libel � ? 1 am QUO
aQPSG . 0.56!7 a+151 -p . T.StlfYa a000a
WS 77X
4+'.'8U
41a
•
[
tl • f " X
•

1.rna
a, IP.,i.-
I •amll.-
1, x900 -
l0611O.•

5.2.P...

0.6100
94600*-
1, 1
14tA4B*
LOW-
620710
adirr
Or40i0
10814,- p
60Ottll
0X'000
j
OW
and
003
003
MIL
Otis
003
66l
0045 II7II
MiLi aced Construction On•SFle
...... ,_
•v.

CC
SCa
NOM
FM -r0
Id•a1s
PM10
MA 10
lam
Fusin..

IS'
P. 0
E.N .6
PM: S.
1••,L' 5
Auu
RC CO2

1.030 002
-Pau oaa
C1,4, Xi:O
COZI
Caa+J,;3r
MAID,
µ7,5e
F.rnrn 0,lcr
OfPRG00
- i i • 0467' , OG000 • aM01 • 60130 . x0000 • 9.0169 000U 4 w i
• 0 061
30000 . OMOCi 00€10 0
• 30000
. 19=+1-..
oar" 61350 . 94017 • ,211700`. • E_T [11 • i7 O • 519001r •' 04s 5 3i . • • ]G4 • + 000 . 000 000 • 370
00000 a 140&71
IQ 9B71 • 517[02 • 006.11'
• an
j
Told
0997A
T

0.438@
fIL109!
27LOSM,
MK
UM!
Q7'900s
Om

0.0 6

0.0≥'�0

6.30116 •
44433

6.@�0.

1400J1 `
if 6081
a1T00a I
VD l

4.0000

14.Na4 `
O1-25
Cont

Page 166 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2283
RTC -454

Responses to Comments
CCIEEMnta'Version Ca1EEMad,20183.2 Page 18of44 Dale: 111212021226PM VTlage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - LOS Angeles - anal Coast CcintPy, ArMnuaI

3.4 Grading -2022
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
IOU
N 3
01 not
rltpdhe
PH.9
tiea14
PGA1r,

FM I''J
N#F
KUPn.e

1.1:1; 1
1105.4.1v
PM
F42,?
.m.
on- •7,A2
MSc- c C2
tmir otrl
GFu
WO
CGS
t-
-12..i yk
.-1'sdk
411: -
D04
#P.IOD

4.4.44x-
.#4
BtlGfrt
Ux40t
'WWI
t.t00r
We
#40011
#000

3.8 Building Construction -2022
Unmitigated Construction On -Site
~
z -
SCa
waaoa.

F.M.-0
€ruler
FM10
MA IO
lore
FusiM
FI12.0
E.N...

Raid S.

1.,12 5
Vv....

E.a CC_'-
-4E.c, '..- 2
rw1a11."]2
Cl.4
4110
_ ,.,
Gawp elt'
104x.
- MIfp

06.Rsatl
0 Z I.`x•
w
t-: u, - •'I99w .
.7 ,023
0 102'?
•
J R!
-.I-x-•
t .7x- • 2Q].1374
201.-3:'....
• 3 37CC +1662]
-.A bet
Tae]

0.2151
1tir44
2J17➢0
14102-
I»2
O10Q3

0.1u•^3
66%3
0f105.1
OCR390
143.23;4
243:49411

0.0'7W
46609
2W.1118
O1-25
Cont.

Page 167 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2284
RTC -455

Responses to Comments
CaIE EM9d'Version' Ca1E EM=1,2016 3.2 Page 19 of 44 Date: 1112!24.721 226 PM VTlags South. Specific Flan {Proposed} - Los Angcies. SnlrtJ1 Coast County, Annual

3.$ BuildmgConsiructfon -2022
Unrnitiaaled Cons.uuctien Off -Sift
90,_
'r•.'-.

CO
9r[2
A'-rg1bee
PH •ZI
tieary
P1.11r,
FM I'1
II ',Po
°Par,{

1.1:1; 1

11.4,am
PM
wr2.P, '
. m.

Pi. M2
Nbia- Cd2
Fdll {U2.
um
WO
ci3..7.
,, •lp9°oY
1rl4N)T
Dater _
-12.41 15 0 033] . 9,1770 i 0 COM . a OCiP' . 0 WO) ; 0 0-000 d MOD
9'6,'00 GCID9 : G0300
.1 LODE G. 901] a. QIDO . 9 ML ; f1999.J
:.. i...
-._...- -,
--
x44034
1'erakr ., 43157.^, . Sd l , .3 4613,E . 4, SELZ .. @.1144 , 3AeM. . 411 . Pau
0117,
-
LC5-3.261 3NMI,.. COM61
996
_ --- -- -- T
.3 MOD • 441.KOS x1.0655 '. 0214 • 0BUM
:Our . d39d. . 92104 , 2=7 . 7.3599. , 9 753"
, 42363.• 8741A
4273.7
A
6?CM .= . 46
4OP1G • Molten
trIlo934.

UAW , ODOM .

T.egl
4W11
'405
t.9954
4,411@
0YW4.
9,454f+
000
*JIM

0.21406

4.71160+
006
42+44
49n#4
1,•189-#7P
i
1,1010,17
N
CLAW

0.4904.1
1,141,+d7
9 MiLivaLed Construction On•51tt
-
v.
z _
sc'
8411,1.

RAN]
€rulra
FM10
Ph110
Iota
frrplM
PPS f'.0
E4-aua
FM: S.

Ion 5
7, rim,
IS, {._'-
.14., CC'1
rd.] coz
Cl.4
SRO
= ,.,
CM4euat,
',wog.
r. .a
r
P.1rryr
ctl Rtati 21.`x' . i ..,...i._ _ +199w. . 3 ,025 • O IRe? •i R! - ,A.. a 27x-
. 14].13:1 MS `3:I • 7 7740 +1092] _.r e7.
'
_

•
L
"
¶ 1
P1

1.0 F.444
70700
34100.-

13 0.1013 111c1.73
.11.^3.
99%3
99%
II
scull
O r4000
223.4.371
83:1921
067U)
6 0000
8 4.797.
�._ .21M

11.2 01-25
Corlt

Page 168 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2285
RTC -456

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnd'Version' CalEEMat42046 3.2 Page 20 of 0.4 Date: 111212021 226PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. SDutn Coast County, Annual

3.$ Building Construction - 21722
Mitioatrd Construction Off -Site
IOC,
Wfla
G4
V3,2
rwthe
.1,44.4
tY.aW
pun,
.-'hi II
ima.
'40.1._•
PI ,
Lem".

64.174
1417.11 '
T m.r
n-- crn
MSc -L!]2
tdr Cal
DM
WO

0.-
--`,,
110405. .. . _ . ..
1/rfrl
I 'FAIN; 4.00[)0 . 6,1770 i 0 CCU : U130133 . 0 WO) 1 J DOM 4 7041.

C .:
... n_ .
m _E :, .
: „.700 • 0.667] OCHE . 6 MX. 1 0 66M
:.. i...
1'ssE1 M_ 03115:. . ad1761 .346130 • 43SCOe. • 6.1144 ' 318171.

A 1175
Ci13,2d
'. 6.G7e• .]'se
-
T •__ •

0.605715 , 441.88]6 4-41.fi63§ . OL'44 . 606117 '
-;:-07;35
•
Si e , a
tih I 6w
;
_
G2tio fa t a?Am., . fazes
,.
el= � 66390.01,6 $55003® 0.+71,67 a 0WM
vi 4PN
.'
•
, 0,214 .
4511 .
=

Laiat
4#te
j1.Atfs
tddLO
0:4110
611p`1
D.1t00,
atm)
on%
t71140a~

0.2i24
dMel•
1,'149-4TP
1:1pl477
d1Y51
dageel

1., iet,I0

3.5 Building Construction - 2023
Unmitigated Construction, On -Site
s _

50.1 Rah,'
PM50
F.Ywtm
PMIC
."0.113
Trde
f-,4,1 pc
PIII:5
F,....

MT?
PC 5
Arts
t :,:..2
1164 cUa
rd..'TLC
0,4
,4120
Cal,
Cata0854
rn.w
rot,.

O11.Rsati
,71i,:
-,
::tiiw,I
__306.. .
- _
3CM4 5 ass.. II
3013
• •-:l_!3
e.1}1.. • :3362'

:*,..."2756
• ] X,S,
600]]
_.. .'
Taal 4.1542
T. TRd
L60fi1
11100.-
PM
600fi4
67167
66833
40$11
6Ca360
2ffi.2TB
738.2386
6191

6.MOM
773.604

01.25 Cont
Page169 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2286
RTC -457

Responses to Comments
CalEEtib ti Version' Ca1EEMad,20163.2 Page 21 of 44 Dale: 111212021 226PM Vfilage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles. Sault' Coast Ccirlty, Annual

3.$ Building Conslructwn - 21123
IJnrnnitiaafed Cons.uuctien Off -Sift

94.=
'4'.'.

CO
MCC
r-upt re
PHNI
CaI'.,teW
pun,
.-'hi 1 'R
ima.
'u3.li_•
Ill c
ligsaiAl

64.174
Wkf2.11 '
m.
fig-CXJ2
MSc- CCI.2
t dui 001

DM
M�1`
CUB
--yr_f
ItYrIhr• - -
carer
-lsJth$
1'esllar
N lr kwk
n 0:x171 • 6•?736 1 0 cam • 6 • 0 5360 6 CC6G • 0 3001.• 1: .: 71:03C. • C J7ti
:' •]X

0.0673 0.17160 Y 0.303D 1 0 DOJO
u, aril,
•16503:
' b., G+9+A
x 0,Q_g+ 3 • E 2511 + Od611. • i.3ry,+Un • 0.11'1} + h #O�PJo- + a 11:
r • •
y. 3 -
CGz I :{pp(lo. • . �+��

0.�
a

41. 7d≥� s97.0657 • 0= + u0636--.�
•
...
'SWIMS
w
• 0, 1616 2367.5 all
• i
Y106 - • 11731?
• 7KKi
E, 'V We- •
• 1%3.1
(111.1-16
S 1664 6 i64M 93: . • 11:
e
4 0050
b3•51,
414 tIXl3 • lial,54 •
UMW.,

7.+iet
¢0177

3. Yb7E1
MN]
410117
084:.8

7.3Pt[4•
41-154+1
47:21
1LC4X4.r
4P0#.
8MN,
7,11,42:.3'43

1.1077,328
Iran
0,410,30
1011,5tui
f•11t117ated Cont iuctlon On•Sita;
~
s _

50.1 R66•a.

RAM
F.Ywtm
PT•110
PN113
Tut..
+-,u,Ips
PIII:5
E. 1..

MT?
PC 5
T41D
t 7:02
t16!a cU2
rall Cat
0-4
9P.O
C-24
C�i7e74
1WJIET
Mr
Otl Rsati
.71:33
• -,
• '
3:601
• 2.350a,
763 •
- --
,3 Ce-G4 50Eo• II
5CE1
.-:l=,1
e.a}y: • :36 27'M
:*,...7755
• 3Zs+S:
n
6661]
,
:: s:E+E
¶,441

0.1543
S.7Rd
M*61
13300.-
0@7
110(51
UI 1
60833
40%11
01XO0 •
2ffi.2Tffi
74116.2715
00691

0.6000
277.0841
01-25
Cont
Page170 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2287
RTC -458

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMOd'V2mIans Ca7EEMad.ZOf63.2 Page 22 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. SDutn Coast County, Annual

3.$ Building GE7nslructlwn - 2223
Mitioateci Construction Off -Site
IOC,
Off.

Cf.?
M.C
r-opli re
MA NI
CaI'.,teW
pun,
.-'hi 1 'R
Iota.
'u3.li_•
Ill c
ITV

64.17 4
Ww.40.11 •
T m.
n+CSJ2
N$6- La.2
ltdr Cal.

DM
WO
CGS
--`a"'1
I4Crcr7• .. . - -
Mrer
-lsJth$ a: me • cum) 1 acme • 0 • 0IMO 0DOM • 43C
L .: I1:03C • CJ7ti
: •]]C
G. MOO 0.17100 Y 0D 1 000JO
.7 arCL
•16503:
' b.`a 3-030
1'er•drl x O,�+g3 • E 251 I + Od611. • i3fY+Uf ' 0.11'1} r h #O�PJo- + a 11:
.1 II e •
3 -0737' -
CGz I :{pp(lo.. �+��

0.�
a
41 i�30 s97.0P57 • 0= + OOIXYi .�
T •
ilkrk..- ii... J2
t
0 1610
I I
'
67 23 .5
• Orin. •
E 0434
E 41dJc
r OM

0.741/1 attea
04000.0 4 03214
a 0C3
•41=
riad"� X53
414 5303 • 0,2004 •
. r
0W7Y.

J
i.,ea7
4}177

1.0120

2.EUl
0,4117
It HUM

7.5Pt*M•

71.5'001
snip
s6741P.-
iLti.l.
8 COW
7,11•17:.3'13

1.047,j7M
40777
5007171
i 6•01,EArd

3.6 Paving - 2023
Unrrl Med Construction On -Sate
-
.

Sal
RetTOra.

FMW
FaMwtla
PT•11C
PN113
Trde
+-u41i.c
PIII:5
"r�Cirio.

FM?e
P1425
700.
t __2
tl6a cU2
Tall Cal
044
f.±0
=..M
C1,6 -4i r
r -
a -
- MTh.
-
Qe.Read . e T100a • 00053 • CLIME • I. SOOOr • r 3.2 1. • 53146.• • 3. Cs•i1.- • .i..a.- 033 y. 00.4 * Di p [ cm
• •
)u.)3C- . •13'75
130175
42IX - • 0003•'7
cal
13 ....
. DWG

Pi•rW0 OSfL' Or'A00 • 0 OSE : 3DOM T c]34O
• • • • • •
BOWL :GUM
0 070 + I) 01233
'Mal
finale,
too
LL4063 -4.

0.09@0

1.40 i1.
tlwi
'

3.7300s
G!7
D36:13
Wi
-
IMOD.

WE
I Mee.-
WO
O.Q0r0
11017E

13.61P5
4211.1.=
OW

0.0000

13.1327 `
471.25
Cont
Page171 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2288
RTC -459

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMCti Version' Ca1EEMotl,20163.2 Page 23 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Lcs Ange{es. SnutJi Coast County, APMnuat

3.5 Paving -2923
IInnnitiaaled Can.uuction Off -Site
MOTs
401
CO
502
Iu11Urc
PH
Cleary
pr1r,
FM I
L*L
t00at.{
St;
L9�Men
PM7i
F42.t•
,..

Plc, .7,A2
IRS Gd2
1EthI 002.

DM
hI20
CO2<
I
.I,,y"Y
thrihr,
UPI.
-IlaJi y7 0:X • 0030
in
.1 L0L 7iJeAS
06100 . J OG L-0 • 000%
L ?lJ 7LCGL . G0000
JiAA 0.007) 9Q.'{1Q • aaD% 1 00. 01
0L.000
. a.ourz,
awt16
.... --.........
1'.akr .: aaxe • oesoa
.
am. - 3XCG
0:PCaa . orals , o. nom 0
—
0 7Cat . C.OMO

a. o00G • G.Q000 amoa • paxic , 00010
- .
. 20 .
iXJUe. I J9ti:4, . 1 0(!r • I ',Pas-
slGu : W+ . 003 100
r YJif.a- . .- IFJICit . 110MJa- • I ,OOSF.la-
-00. 045 004 . 00+
i
005
•
•
. 00.4

•
0 . 005 .
1_
1med
11009.-
81100811009.-,..

A5
t aerr,..-
050
7 l30Z1-
:121
i Id00..
055
P.i999•.

KU
i.a000 -
943-
ra. a.
i 11
,.0[1r,�.-
r 50
i.am,-
106
Low, axmt
90i

0.R15A

0.0.100

2.110.76..-
1095
S 50,
,
u 01b II
i•11LivaLtd Cons &Uctlon On•SFte
o:_
.. .

CC
002
FUPh.a
FM,13

1...Js
FM10
Pl Id
Ian
fupu+f
FTC

60..m

2.17:5
10512 5
PrAi
IM - CO2
t16a GC2
1 505 cos
CI -4
.i2C
0172
CA, tyli3-,,
I-
M IO,
A
NFFF,
CO.Read . 07100. • 00053 • Q V • I. `5W1. • . 3.3700. • 519IIM 2C Xa• • i6ECQ..

C.B y. 004 * L0ii7 001 p [ 001
•
00➢:C • nl?'175
130075
42IQam• . QQQdo i
£05
13 f::'
a "fir:
• • F F1 a •rm' • • a 0010 • L OMB ] 0150 T 00040
• •
• • • •
. •
0 OWL • a C 0810
•
00300
1 700E .j 00033
-
7eitl
4M00e
030

0.5061

0.69@0

1.5000..
tlwi
—

3.7300.
9W
15500•
003
b.0000 -
901

3.0001 :-
906 I
QA0f 0.

110175
�_
i1.01P5

4.150 .. I
KW

0.05 0

13.137? 1
01-25
Cont
Pa 172 of 548 In Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2289
RTC -460

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version' Ca1EEMP0,20163.2 Page 24 of 44 Date: V1212021 226PM VTlags South. Specific Flan {Proposed} - Lcs Ange{es. Saute Coast County, Annual

3.6 Paving -2023
Miticated Construction Off -Site
9C,
NO I
CO
aIJ2
rutibee
area
f_lea1F
RrAlr.

FM I
NO.
tupn.{
561; y
1105.,auv
PM? -A
F42.?,
.m.-
n.- ,M,2
MSc-Gd2
1Ebll 002
CFA
WO
CO2
I
,,:.I.y"Y
Iirr.h.

UPI.
-1 iJl'y7
.... —..,......
5'endo<
414<keF
0,3201 . C 00(0
o EOM . a ETAS
0 0700 1 J DOM . A 00%
L ?l0 7 CCGL . G JSi
J LODE O. IMUJ 0 CCM . 0 MX 1 a ttt i
a r1QHS
4 axes.
t 55155
., aaxe . 0000
r
oceso . a -. .
cram . ocean , a=
-
o 2W 3Cat . G.O000

3. -
anat. . once Scam . oaocc . o00a'
4 . 2drYlor Il. I iXL —
;Cu , Km
L100r . I cone
IYa3 . 54fi
r 3)m- . .. IF01#Jr . 1300005- • I,pJ[P,)Q-
K. , SK -5 '554 . 504
`
. SedK1e•
045
• 1etr1'4a-
. 554
a0P}'i . 0:1F50
.
06F60
. 2.000r. 555%
e 555 e
1 1w
- —
t1r41d.-
5%
• 1-m1.-
aoa
.474.40., '•
063
t5%54.
obi
j• mei,
naa
,Ei11 - '
5%
f5l5Sa-"
IF I
e.(iart10,-
5%
tom.,
636
%ON,- '
__
0 u397
[Dili.
am

2.119186..-
OM

5.115%
ui160 ,

3.6 Paving -2024
Unn4dtigaled Conslruchen Co .See
0•=.G

10. CO
5Gc
Foultol.

PAM
1;'
Rolle
PM IS
111.
fuplM
PF42.0
E - N...

27.12:`
1'M5
ArAs
RC - CO2

1.50, CO2
rd.]tai
CH -4
M20
Cm, '
Caegruy
1WYYIp
MT,Se
011-FU:.4 09900 • 51545
mean • 55W1 e,• .al S gsdks • i ISM. •
I 2.00.4• • I 7155..

OOooO + 71.3:A2 I 1510555 . *12X4. • 00 =OM
MU 1011 5511 p
•
5 ore
CQ.5
Pif.lfll
germ
00000 ' ➢1W11
3Om'C- • • COI.* 0❑OCL•
a 20430 GLOM • 01155 . 00017
4 -a 0r111F
.
•
• '
.
•
Told
6 01041

0.7600
l5CO
6150Do
OO3
5 45*
1"0
003
1� -
N00.
009
1_740IM-
0O]

0.00@0.
72 5312
05 .0202
5513:10,. 00000
551
M3MalinOµ
-
_
_

01.25 Cont

Page 173 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2290
RTC -461

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMoti Version' CalEEMaii2016 3.2 Page 25 of 44 Date: 911212021 224 PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Sow Coast County, Annual

3.5 Paving -2024
Untmitielated Cons.uuction Off -Site
90 NIT* . I
Li?
9r[2
rwthe
1,44•-0
t•15.. 5
pnlr
..1,11 R
Iota.
.a91• •
li-i ..

I g

64.174
YW2.5 •
m.
fi'-�XJ2
I - CCI2
Imbri WI
OM
WO
CUB
,,_,
1muy _
woe
Y
-lsJih$
Weeal r
0 . + ..
a •:C.P
0 EOM • a a0C 4
0 WOO 1 0 rm0 N JOU. • L :1::: ..n_ . __ l.Cc,
J LODE 0 . IMJ 0 05Cal • 0 7010 1 I) IIRxJ
,.._LI,
. ,] R q.
• I9100
05155.,
. ,3 XIS
r
5,100
0 DOM • G IIOOG
•1.0005.

C.DX0 . Soma n 9 • sex. 3 CSGc . expo
a. ODD r C. moo 0 M • ti woo q 0 BUM
. +.N . 4i - •10055
Ge4
X0e 2@
W3 ;
L1-
30tOG.-
ooa
•
a 014
+23004- Welk- • 131905- ••3.790FJr ,00004• • 7A00k-
007 r 596- • = M 554 096 0:44 ! f
1 CM
4O • 1
•
•
1UNN
• 3.0•]Oeg
595 •
, IJp9'YJ
'
oo
14001.-
fiat
1154
8 0.-
045
73100.
009
10400.•
540

1. 009

4.40044.
009
IL 2400*-
003
S,90Frl-1
404
f.0094.-
008

9. 4004•
004
05,900

4.0554.
t1001

7.14094-"
40S
0O
Mil Ina Led Conntructlon On•SIL

4. -
.

S42
ROU.4.

FMS
MaNsits
PM1C
Pm lS
Trde
f, pc
P14 ,5
"r�Ciriom
MR
ISIL'5
inns
t __2-
NB. SO2
ia41CCa
C}04
V20
=..M
05Read 09100
Pif.lfll
• 0.1045
- a 1000 • 2 W( - • S ``SM.. • O15CIe- •
mu 033 MO p
•
4 :,A& • •I f45.

GIFJ
J• -'..70C- • 2133.: I .Ti.005o • *1212C4. • MECO
73 ]!Xd'a
S ac
`
-
•
• ;
90000

BMW 000110
•
C0005 -
•
110041
a 601179
000M
• 21000 ., 00037
•
T
•
��
Told
09190
1111140

0.91400
200004.
804

5.1OOOr
1909
&.11904•
900
4,51110.-
090
•1_ M 54 .-
pal

4.0010
729312
21 031I

7.1190.
94x4
ODOC7
1 2S O11r3
01-25
Cont

Page 174 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2291
RTC -462

Responses to Comments
CaIE EM9ti'Version' Ca1E EMod,2016 3.2 Page 26 of 44 Cate: 911212021 226 PM Vilage South. Specific Flan {Proposed} - Los Angeles - Sault' Coast County, Annual

3.5 Paving -2024
Miticated Construction Off -Site
MCC,
NO I
L4
913!2
tUQ4, a
P!A•-0
ta-aaW
pus,
.-'hi 1 'R
Iota
• a61,•
li-i c
Imo.

64.174
11,43.5 '
m.
fig- WSJ]
I - CCI.2
1'dr COs.

DM
WO
CUB
y,_
io,W _
ore",
-Uklih$
VMdar ..
•
Y
.1 J+..
. ',AK.
4 EOM • 9 MJID
0 070JJ I 0 DOM 0 OWL, • l, a �1:.: . n_ . __ J:Cc,
J LOS[ 0 . IMJ 0 MCC 9 MX. 1 I) (HIM
,.._Ll.
, ,] q.
i o�uu
aX.CC
C 100
aC060 . aI130G
CI. .D005 . 70006 . aims• coax, 5CS9C . [001.0
F - 1
a. CS,7G , Dmoo 4.[490 . ti woo q u0037
- •; .+404.
a
solo
2 seta¢ •
ooi ,
36ruorr
093
. I CMOs-
!
, aw
+ .-'� :1 - . a.aGa�
ass 1 005 1 744 : 994
,
. MOW . 1 �Ima�-
DX 0P4
� oo>r.: 110104
v u.
� a.aw4e
1 17.15 .
r, alrrJ

1..1 6,1401.-
Col
2 sgio,
044
242
*MI

9. 0460.-
405
'IWO +
00S

9.00 446

1.100.• 49*-
409

3.700r> -
001

1.4490.-
036
3AM.,
0011
2 C.2*$
149404'.

11.4t11.4t.*0

7.0009.-
OS
4,0400
'N.Q1uaT ,
32 Archdlectural Coaling • 2024
Unntitltdaled Construction On -Ede
0 _
160
Rath.

P S
aNsult
PM1C
Fni 10
Id..
f..01i.c
P!4 ,0
s:..

MT?e
PC 5
0a
t :,:..2
NB. SOS
rd.' COO
0}04
40O
CG.,
Ar_hn Ct.. % : ..1377 •
! 1
0 00 00 . Main• 3[091 • c-30
! ! f
•i_XO. . 00860 00500
3X755
69040 •
700titi
4 4745
O0 RCOG . 3. 1.I'i5 • 05210 . OMT . soma.,
CM • . . 705
01141.• :.01141.• . 1 0709.E • I U7 0M. • I !2700.- -
: ma • 603 • cos • 004
0 OO1 . 4 ..-aa2 4625

2 a4CGr
407
00525
Told

4.1451

0.0213

5.od1'.0

5.5260e.
406
I.ID'09r
440
t$I90F
000

1.177900
0M

9.0700.-
009

0.0000.

4.4535
44065

1.5400..
404

0.1000
•
44145
01-25
Cont

Page 175 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2292
RTC -463

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version' Ca1EEMlad.20t63.2 Page 27of44 Date: V1212021 224f M VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles -Scud Coast County, Annual

3.7 Arc.I rleclurdl Cvalffig • 21M24
Vnmitiaaled Construction Off-$itg
1 1Q.•
,r%
co
ni3.2
twihe
MA•I
ta-aaW
pull,
Rbi1 R
Iota
.u3li-•
li-i c
Iii

64.1 7 4
10441)
rm.
n--Cxi
N$w-tC2
tdll001
DM
WO
CUB
f
-lsJth$
us,aQ
,J _0.i:

C =:lC• : :313!x_ 9 MID ! 04170)
3 DOW] ! 4 3CCC. ! L 1•10., ...n_ .
. :_ )_CU
) LODE 6.007] OC00 : ,3,X.3) r..OI M
V
,.._tl.

I a 13uc
. 3-xrn
c,Axo . r.; 3MOD • 03s)
0600 3aCED • cI.LIC4i 3ccsr
e.ara
3xx
0 cw
c.0600 C1MOO • 6:rr. • uBUM
4 W.:* 1 1. • 4tea r
4 03O1r ,
000 V
tin:60@
. I r
!
. OOi[fi . e ma- .
1 ! OW !
O.0211
. 6.6bCrJo- 1011604. • 0 T'.06r
I OM f1111 r1
. up,
.
1712fIT !-.0.32.0. .
, r 1
O O9YJ
J
too -
-T.400a.-
473
4 •01[51,.:

00.1 - 0:07*i1 '.ti3]a0.,

40.1 U27F
UMW*,
Int
OA211
15410*;:.

NO
CO14Yl.--S.
rat
.- '
OC6
CM

11.1211
tj1jP
4snaM•
004
a0k m
0 1$'t
Mil Ina Led Conntruction On•SI[a
s _

50.1 RIOLL.a.

RV -0
:Ji,all.,v
PM1C
."0.113
Tide
--4.1e.c
P!F',5
r� o.

FM?e
PA:5
T41.
t _ _2
t!6. CO2
TLC
47-4
U73
=..M
C1,6-41 , ...
1fYSlyf -•
- Mfryr
Al':hn Cs do4 : 4.1377 0 00 00 . OLEm . 1C0.1£ Xv- C- . •- XC- . 00IX70 00100
3000.

DIN= 3CSC3
! 1 ! ! f
••
Oft Read .+ 11.E1.. • 00213 • OMIT • 50000`- . :.BOO` • 107DOi • 41720Om • I!]7U*- - OOW: - . 4+Od2 - 4620
2a9CG
0001`1
• 44745
003 . , . 705 . : f700 . 301 . Cal . 006
061
Told

4.1404
D0211
CUM '.I
50001.
1Nilo
t0r00F
1)7791).

1.0709*

0.00@0.
4 450
44063

5.54004.

0.0000
I
4 Ore
093
WO
000
_
OO3
OM
Y
O1-25
Cunt

Page 176 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2293
RTC -464

Responses to Comments
CalEE_ EMntiVersions CalE EMoil,2016 3,2 Page 28 of 44 Date: 111212021 224 PM VElage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Les Angeles - anal Coast County, Annual 3,7 architectural Coaling • 2024
Miticated Construction Off -Sits

91.3.7,
Mc. i
C4
not
nuan,,e
' "1!
fAvanix
Ru1r.

FM I'1
t*F
°gm,
561iy
lirolv
Pm?i-'
F42 3,,
Tr..
on- CFA]
MN, CC2
FVhI C{i2.

DM
WO
caaa
l
,: aley.vy
IV_naAyr
M4010
V
.420,4
1'ssdu
J11:CT,
L"AC0 OCOOL
9Ulm . dF7pJ
6 3DWG . 6 in06 a 66660 ,, 6.CIDr. a COTO
3COA G. Mil 9Q.Y16 a 670X1 1 0 41130411 1,,
6CCU
00CCC
1!
ta:33Cfi
E.:,-,,,, 7 Cpl:
- _ _ 1
nmm . 6:6C00
l--
•7 n[66 . 6 CICED a n6U1n 9COX a CO1100
# -i---- o- _m____--3
- a XR
UQP70
a G.d6Ef6 9.®66 • 13 woo a 00B00
s G l _
'eW.xkar •• Nato,-
403
433 A- CICsB9
497 r
t 66 . ' d(194)e- • stall .B MON-
, + r CO4 r no
19tWde, a d Male
r4>• 403
a 11.1267
Ir.1201 •a C31Yw
WM .
06696
iM
?.iMnie'
IVO
4-lnd6n-
11U.1.

Ttnstan
t1096.

AM
' UM

1.x494..
dal
414111
s ~
C$1
S. . -
MI
luNIO
A 1.1217
ijt2C7' '
4-X11691•
d. OA
Ir i:+ui

4.0 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
01-26
Cont.

Page 177 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2294
RTC -465

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMati'Versians Ca1EElh1ad,ZOf63.2 Page 29 of 44 Cate: 911212021 226PM VTlags South. Specific Place {Proposed' - Lcs Ange{es. Snud1 Coast County, Annual +roe
ca
see
wM
1•PA'•3
e�•1r
pM1fd
F'M14
Trig
amobra
FTffi9
ti
lln�'mPaetl '1.7451' 4• -7-.7ca 71 -1"i5474:7 -a074. 737774. 7.8 9 T2 I 003111 • 2.313{. • 70aW nulsr cc2
9dn
bra
corn.
•
• 7 430 ,o3 ,, 7 320 3030 . e0 i.ar • L.-ma0'? 7 x.01 B 4 • 7

4.2 Trip Summary Information
.. lar1d1J1w
V•1•0
Sawa fir' `�Sulday
!1rtI Y T

0.rraa1 VkI1
L
•
ApArarern4 S. P1ti'ZKiM
IiP Oyrti A116 Om •
.... a
.^•oral rxce B.:1 1e
:::+awn Fiestau-anry a-
„
a
14!•18 1
134 .e..•
9•,14 yo 5.15 T
a47sa, - 13,,65S,oe5
.J.......
3145 i,..,.,. '7'315.91' ,.
41? t: * 3.413,SO7.
14444 .. •43,143
163.217 • 7',97,486
35754 • 111_' 1
...a
..
a
'A6 i
13:6W,466
MS 17
3#13,539 .
.1-t5,T43
7317463
T,112221
d,Qf696
_ I
1 3.'7'x325
. 79645 w
6253
_

2.Nea 1I
21513 W.

N_
• 19244,u-1
191.1,0
6]112
611.§_
• 52864 •

1`x11.44
' ];.0 k5
R ^8L 43
a 057.21
6°•52152
1-
26 553,45'3

4.5 Trip Typo fnfumtatrau
01-25
Cunt

Page 178 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2295
RTC -466

Responses to Comments
CaIE EMoti Version' 991E EM0i12016 3.2 Page 30 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles. Saud' Coast County, Annual rwa
Laid Lae
KwVmw
KS at c,,0
•091C,FRY
KSa11 0-C
H=0 9, C -MW PalAiiry Dedn'029
nase. .

Apartlrtrxg Lem Rase
14 79
6_u.+ 5 4019 a 1920 40x0 09
-,r
APertmerds Mia Fist 1470 c1W " +}._. ...._...'...,
9274 aP 20 a 182'.0 1060 77 --E 11
+-ener®I CrAlce B�k9ri 16 60 . E,V4 E90 3100 . 4B00 i 5 3r F 7+ 14 _ -- 3h 1 mouriSl[own�� + 1690 9 I 6.A0 ' f 160 1- 72A I ,.f, 37 . '4 x. * •..r.. 9- ... ..

IEolot •
. 10.00 ' 6:00 4113 9940 07.60 1000 .° 'P.
11 19.40 646
16:40 s 140
090 : 1260 i 9911, s 1400
490 1690 t '1470 1400 54 34
39 0
,2222>_ '
3 4
44 11

4.4 Fleet Mix
s ! Use
LC1"67 L172 r M944 OHO
We -ID .1313kis
Ld9US
M•CY
SOUS
MW
Apanmenta L. ow 4rra
W 91433610, '0 044719 9 006201 9 110106 0 0146G? D.17.01117 0 971106 0.0391577 0 gaols 0 0101017 0 009.299 0 00991? 0 p oO.' 1 a}
p,pamneds4lai Rine , 0.543006 -9.044216 0209071 0x10230 9014632 0.01k7'332 0.021196 0.631377. 0.6019922 6.061017 0.005260 6.000712 6.09':31!_1 # 4-- ............ re ��
r� al t}ffcc Bsideyb 0543099: 0044210 020x71 0 x90566 0013033 0.000:32 00219518 0 03367₹' 0.03512 0.401417 0.005216 0. 07x2 0 00:4:1 ...>., • ,:.- 4,.,...>J.....--....e. �....�..-.+222 .«�..+ .. ,...>, .. ,a4l4 5dt0 ; 0013.9089; 0044210: 0206011 0019364. 901392'' 00090 cl:,1;f�s 0903477/ 0.60$15: 001017! 0995206! 01500 a:, 0607021 eptawArw} + . . . . . . . .

HDt+al * 0543009 0.044010
4~--
0tanyFpC'3iiLlr'J1•1 " 0%3039: 0114#'?I0
a
: 6 5mu.: 0 044714: 0 203971: 6 119265:

Rol
Mmak Shopping C. rndr
0:09171
0 291$171
00109 1
0 110290
0 4141!3!
0014033

0.90037
' 66LA3�.s
0 091166
Li 1:1 143
0' 933,77' 0.03:613

0.91'477 0.002913

0.901817

0.03520@6
6 061017

0.0652ia

0.000792
06047x0
9014022 09943:'
0 036671
0000611
321e96,, 0.063577, 9 60963`s. 00010j7: 00.10296" 01504.12: 0 000621

5.0 Energy Detail
liotorlal Energy Usti: N

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
01-25
Cont.

Page 179 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2296
RTC -467

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMed'VersIan' Ca1E 00w:1,2016 322 Page 31 of 44 Cate: 111212021 226 PM Vfilage South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Ange{es. SnAr1 Coast County, Annual var
law
Pq2.5 072
7 ordir
wry
F]rs_niolp
Meetnelp
Uemhgeh.•E
0460 33315
• 9 959 . -0 905
•
nom . 9.05'1, { ➢DC .2317040.-972 0141 • ate 09719 2.521 035 J 5 5 9
9399 9.35 2.5,12.NM. 972.646 91037 09215 2521.535
Me1o•V3es
9 1360
Ilel.r•a•iad 0 1759
Unr.mgN•!• ..
• 22312 071"x6 Y 7 (YV9e- Y i S 9@6e i 9 ik1P1
35 •
•2312 4 9,Tr9 . 75'269RT ti T 910/59 • SEEM
5 7[060 00999 9 [mu . •.3-03 ami 1 257 426 9,M+a5 09251 i 1.361 041, •I 6
53,30 T G 9319 7.931; • •.367 aa• ' -'1 1357.426 • 9 5+65 T 99254 -. 1361.547 1 7 6
O1-25
Cont

Page 180 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2297
RTC -468

Responses to Comments
Carr_ EMoli Version' Ga1E EMetl,2016 3.2 Page 32 or 44 Date: 111212021 224 PM Vfilage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles - anal al Coast Comity, Annual

5.2 Energy by Land Use - Natl,lralGas
UntnitnAvd
htaturalbit
• 4yn
11174
Me
c.

StV
I•gpl..•
pull'
:.rasa
P 110
.'Fa la
rm.,
lap..r
KV i
t',Mai s,
PMJ2 5
+'M2 O
T Owl
I
lair ci=
dNea-C.C12
tdtal. or32
OR
wZi.
ctc5
i..1
F3aTI.I.yv
1,...ir
rpfryr
A♦iillmtt"E4 Lea to
Rsa
Awl., Eras k1d
Rx
... ,... .-...

Gs-,� om�
&Ad.,0
. ......y
-mrt 7.F.,.er,S1
t1tTM1 Reftuarti
• • e • ` ..

FidlN
---_. mlY
Ragaua:d
R W ones •
Er tl Ce•t.r
I.yy3{.4
. , 30413.
+461
• o_160
. Ias4ea
k.,.,_.
09137.",11,1
` 01%
t.. .
. 1 NOM,
.470
.?S e, 717151. o 6OIS , 9S1AE
0'Yl COI CO

1.1FJOw 16e�A. I!fo 48 IC�A..
4P3 i On r e 003 " 8t4
r
00fSO " 11 ram ; 2i AWE' ; 4S:We. IalfAs
;18. ; Caa a
21 WU
7�t1. 43
25 .011I
y,
415 * Mt,
4 83.4551
7 G' 4 • 0.8016 a 02901 . 3 68:06,
(rsi
— 1 t
C .-8 % 0.041.7 e 0. a4 7 • 0 7si£,
,

1. d..
pomp . ESE 9OS3 • 696.13160 . 0 n I34 . C 0' I.1 •
6 Imo• ;
.- .
�hrsar . uuAa f Galva . , u`r� ,
SK71 i 0Gl
4-- a— .
.
. ."a:weM- I r�x- , r.raaar ; 1 ��c1�
rf10 i MO r 4n am
— .y. _ _d �.
._
4 unocw 24 NZ , Z,,, UM . a eon , r+�..� •
oral 00a
y c }._ _ _

90.46 . 0472 • 03.21 24. .
, M i U0 r

i 1 l
rt11Y0 • d0114 94510 " 0".1}15
i . r
F _
moo aad112i. 4-41112,.. n`1 O, 1019fQ,
; WI f ate .
f F
i
M Yet
9 4
lb
-
0,0563 • 40117 • d 10046• •
DX
6CIO* • 64600o • • d 4S Onne- 4.9eCa
805 6 883 ' 009 1104
w • „...

0.+JE00 . 07.0026
I3;.scan
17,1006- • I.70mr •
....In 1.79
1 .9.e6Ee
.006
meow
:
9 ,3e-
o4-..

DEEM OJT • 54LQae- • d 66 • e 61.178,1- W M 6Mork— eaMnbr y i 004 a aaa i an a a03 8f11

6.88[3.3 510193
ea 1639
I83C le- a r apLL3r ;
n . 013.9 .
99 1.97
/ 0601
5 u084r
CO.
+w ^ace
Kt}
. 3?Wile- •
bbd :
1, =Mk-
096
: 1
. 1
S. 100011 •
894
31]040 e
: Mt

:
• 3 400um-
" Wr ,
+T 140M.

ON :

0.0800 a
"
.O080

4.9806
• BOZO.
001. :

T E'00034- ,
®55 .

Tong
81364
..23#
Oft RI
i.. 02,30.-,
OW
16d4rin
ni2t46

0..0011
�0.aIM1

0.4404
1,503,al
2 i,3f3,i38
e
6U16$
4 G
,341. eal
a
O1-26
Cont

Page 181 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2298
RTC -469

Responses to Comments
CalEEMegl Versions Ca1EEMocl,2Of63.2 Page 33 of 44 Date: 1112.72021226PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Lcs Ange{es. Soutrl Coast County, Annual 15,2 Errergy by Land Use - NaturalGas
Mi tistaierr
Matrabt
•4yn
7704
Me
GC.
$64
1=utr1, !
PH, I'
ref Yaea
P110
,'1-,1147
im1
ra•l1..
r'lxii
rwha,,81
P.425

40.5 7
Td1e
138- CA2
sle.,- (-a7
totni DOI
046
.121.
ccr7e
L ?.y.1r
Fla TI.I.Iv
1 1
far
kl fa
Ajt fl - L,r I
Rs•
A1Fs'6•I84 kid
41x .

Gs-,1� om�
evadn9
-mrt 7:7.•,07,84
11,,,,,r, Reco,ra t,`
• •1-40!4 • `
Y. _ _ _
Regau3:d
R W on es •
S}, -.A• ,,tl Cl>.t•r
,IL5a4.i
• , 346Th
.411
• ans.ea
• 4X1710
,r,
r + r
4,XEr5 4.4 512.4 . 4451134. a Tga4 167X15,+,
; F WI 1 05,1 .
8 0 70444•
661
00883 • 40717 • d 100!4• •
DX
8 45048 • 0 4600o • • 8 4S®6a- 5 4I 4.
895 651 • On 667
•
COMO . 57.4475
'5740•]4
172004- • 1.747. •
on 179
r 1 &Mee
.1
W
41040
:
4 14I0e-
CJi6
C R9T 0 01 • 5 5L00e- • 4 0. Mire- a a 8,8080- W M 4141 - a Mate- e
y 7 I MI a ate i ob a 461 8011
0000 • BS 0:199
9d 5171
I.83{4 e- • r a ati ;
441 LID

1. 91 31
4 Sy.I
5 7.647
7374
4 _7OEC
IA*
a 10000e- 17
Cod I
MOO,
co
• '+
a
e 1
&M4. 1140068
47}4
e
: 654

:
• 34000.
• 68s "
T 1.4016806
cos

4.0600 a
"
q.4(g4

4.6846
• El 004:04
: 001 :
i 0'044[14- ,
015 :

Toot
471354

1.231#
5 ff70

1..61040-
OW
1,04770
1C§tl6

0..0045

4.Qi
Mail
40 1703415
a
43 1.! 1X4
e
407!13 0
GM

1.X41. eat
a
111-26
Cont.

Page 182 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2299
RTC -470

Responses to Comments
CiIEE'Mola Version' Ga1EEMod,20163.2 Pape 34or44 C ele: 111212021 226PM VIlage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Soule Coast CcrnIty, Annual 5,3 Errergy by La rid Use - leGtru ity
Ursmitiaalvd
it'd: o t
U,a
-1 I coa
en.
11211
4`aa
Ia,a u..,
MraM'P
MTr17
Asa dm are. U., . L
Rs,:
• Nistra is SId ,
Rye
• ,Gew_ 4rnuQ
p r! 1
Bfddn4
493, T:mm.er iD1
µ1W •
• -------
Uum1Y-___M
•. RWaxns- ,.

Shnopng G431:r
100441
344F6'a
+VA
Fa _
' Mak%
33 Mt, f 1,30CCs• , 2.SIM.

M 903 6X1

I 33.847&
I.,E4'.WS
9 Ile O. Ct..
5401-..I.,
I?3 ,_W^
11: 9•.ail
i Ni 7ain
,
1 M'. 3437 • 0 e616, , 44”07
Y
yp—NV f 7.a}9CC4 f 1 $111714
41:4 ; 013.3
• 15090,,In
6-4,0:6 1733XG
x
Wien • UM. +324it
4 • T?94C+ f 9..767•Y
X6;4 1 6X3
303120
1It• Di SI I, 4.40Wr- 900,3.nr
7'SQYA
;
2i46:T78. •
B.BWXCr +
9h3 a
2XIrr^Ille-
6G3
TANI
2M2.6ae
S
ri tug
YWia
? ,',1 i nis
i
01-25
Cont_
Page. 183 of 548 In porrymWit Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2300
RTC -471

Responses to Comments
Carr-EMoriVersion' Ca1EEMcaL2OI63.2 Page 35or44 Cate: 1112.12021226PM VIlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angeles - anal Coast Cowry, Annual

5.3 En€rgy by L.4 nod Use - Electricity
htitiaal rj
minot
Ump
Ytiy GO7
tn.
il2n
OD
La,-4u.p
ww^P
MTV
Aja nm are. La. +
Rap
74;;;;lr;;;11 1.3-9377,Z;
Rye
. 'ewral 6InCQ
p
L'
B+ddn4
,1+13, T:mm+er iDI
14"W .
num7}.___I.

Amiga -a d
Rwon-e;'-
ernerraa
r
1079.¢
.0Al
Fa
r 5IIES0,0
331 O + I32C[a + 2. RIM.
6 9R3 coo
x.
j 33.847&

1.2E4'.WO
9 Ile O.Ct..
,51.1 1. 1,
I?3 tn^
11: 9'.+I
T 2:1 ;,ay
,
6f 137 se:, • aosis +f- onN6r
Y
I&3 d� r 7. Ce- , 1$10714
a4 ; 013.3
r 1.50),1n
'SSri;!
NO3?22 ; 0 K a 32`Nr-
4 1 3366
7 + 74C . + IMRE.
3x3126
r 1Its i M.• 4elN3De- 9603Ek-
ati3 1 to+
rvioaa
2401.1111 r
r
se
dm
+ z6&ol4
ua1
'1m++

2.S1.6,4
S
it It F:
arktia
a. sal min
a

6.0 Area Derail

6.1 Mitigation Measures Area
01-25
Coat

Page 184 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2301
RTC -472

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMOd'Version' Ca1EElh1ad°20163.2 Page 36or44 Date: 111212021 226 PM 1VElage South. Specific Fri {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Soultl Coast County, Annual MOO
ta]
arn
avud
P41d
P141u
Tsui
C17�y
PNC2.'�
AAA
TEMP
Nor Ct3]
'NB1u- L'CY3
Tmto Cif
0,4
Cotk
rxflsea 1.ir • utmU li 34304 1 I anrr •
i.

Ua+,droare oo 51437 G.2030 • 103804 + 167We
• ray
oar 14 a°714.. Ta nb 4f- •q:91T1L' Oi?> al I'A
'L7.10
p;110
4dID
T..

Fspt-e
rage ,
EihM+f
',MI6
PArltS
Tail
CYt tid2
ML4m [°3
Pa4f'C'0`.—
C1'++
ny,..O
cc,.,
;+ ►oa]
rmyr
P411} -
M1,841 ortural E.

CMau6n

0.4137 • 4.0003 , 00036 • 0L®® 0ala6
+• l
000CO r 80303 s D® . 11.COM
0=
r 0Cffi7
f emu
On 3266

1.•7; 1
+3G66
. + , !
1 r •
O.n�O • 0A3IJ3 + 0 M eime-C4V
, • + r
OnOXa -• aaa;71 : atomi nano°
r' ,
68890
'
Mach
Ir�a{'rj7
0 001.11
G 1703 • 0TOO , 1 1 -Mile- •
, 094. -

0.0P.0 • 00143 , 08x43 00113
1 '
3C'OM • 234 1766 • IDi 1066 • 1WC°,
° i Con
3Vit
033
1'1
1'1187 . 10 Ms4
6aD - • 40672
- °0672 •
+
04672
• 00572
0iY94d • re @...-1: vs Phew
II 01a"
ry4Pru •

7..41
11437

4.70.50 10.3869

1.88034-
4439

8.6T14

4.4714
l
8421E I
Ill
60714
88810
72Affi76
7180678

11.32ul

3.71 PX13

73.5575
Page185 of 548 iri Cornnent Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2302
RTC -473

Responses to Comments
CaIEE_EMntaVersion' Ca1EEMPI20163.2 Rage of 44 Date: 111212021226PM VElage South Specific Plan {Proposed] - Los Angeles - anal Coast County, Annual €,2 area by Sul}Categry
Mitinated
A17v
N.:-.-,
C.C. fugmc
PM r6
Edaub
rWIQ l,
I .M10
T...
r.,19E•.e
U171
tosum
WV
Nk72.!
Tdi
be- CA2
Nbo- Gt1?t,
Toe! f�^

0.4 fl
Cote
,,.il •..-m.14.1
Mabelf
MT77r
...,-..,...11 01117
0 OMB r 0 000D a i 0 COCC I 001110E
r
-0.CQL15 . 00787 a o ono i u coca
GUM r
°CND
0Cuw
Ts51245
I .' ;S41.9
•C.;rf.,muv a3:9B
00407 0494E . . 00W10 4GTO
4ras. a 0MOO . DODO . OCCCO
0610) .

Hg,11, ,. (ICING . d 1761 l 0[1+6a r $ 120'66
w.
w 1 r r -Y}7
_ �. _ .._�. — a^i

0.0143 r 04141 . i 0Gr43 ` 4g1i3
. 1
. ___ _._. . —
_ . . _ .. _.�_-r�0ts72
0MC4 a ]�N 110$1, 71E4. $npq 7•d'1:.r
F . C1
) 4,),,,,—i'

61.1 I. -,,,,F7.. 03N14 011,5! WMTM71 r 1040'
r 1 1
,fie i]57g 00672 ,,- 00574-
a 1 f
_
4(1 tom �a eb DN. • leg 666" • II me.-
. 1 1
i Pdr 7�
•
Teu1
5,1177

11.21:47.0

74.360{

7.6!00.-
6a7
6A1U
41,511
6A241
tIon4

46.P6b
M11.96Fd
22'1 7U

0.02(11

3.F1d4a-
(1413
X5635

7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water
O1-26
Cont

Page 186 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2303
RTC -474

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version' Ca1E 00w:1,2016 3.2 Page 36 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VIlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Angetas-Souln Coast County, Annual Tidal Ci
ai
w7o
cenect
Pettus 8 r 7W, iQi ].716.3 GUM "5r.

UroNigand w ,7E6 R: 7.7163 GQ?% Taw
nay
01-25
Cent.

Page 187 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2304
RTC -475

Responses to Comments
CalEEMata Version' Ca1EENted.ZO163.2 Page 3 of 44 Date: 111212021 226PM VTlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Snuln Coast County, Annual 7,2 Waller by Land Use
Unmitinated
Ih, moue
d,sE U..
tool O
O.s
WO.

CdR
1 #..1.11 U+e
PAW
!OW
hparmle•af LOMB , I �@e DDI
ib9Cl 0:755 . I I4]3e. 12 6471
%ea ; 1 02F14O1
113
1 +yr95srh•M1Yd 5i5I55d
Al.... ; W.4Ma
I
0}.0P•0 0 0202' . 0 900
0144'0
KO &V ; .104351
i IMP;1
'Iqn ewnl...0 1911, 10 PM .1
51 270Q • 11^gar`l� .Oea
*2641.

Doom R.Mwiw ]; 0OW402 iw
1 U0.1 1
4 . .kleu
V A
• 7 "0570
+129034 .1
0 1033 0 Q610 . 1:03013e
', 4.14002f
a ad x
Chalky ab 62,211
11 31#31 , 5 7:3' . 1 Brace 13 916)
Weeemean ', 0.10.1006
113
I5apolorl T4, 14040.
2152200 0 15"A3 v J. 4250e
£ 311400
Shine GeAa ; 2 91220
; 099 1
1 1
'NW
515S A
}y1a7
40H0
#43 Peel
01-25
Cont_
Page188 of 548 it Cornrnent Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2305
RTC -476

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnd Version' Ca1E Empd,2016 3.2 Page 40 of 44 Date: 1112!212.21 226 PM VTlags South. Specific Flan {Proposed' - Los Ange{es. SDuln Coast County, Annual 72 Wailer by Land Use
Mitatakill
i.amA71a
tia, UJae
ill L'd2
O.s
h2cr
cdR

IAN WPM
MOH
NIT
Aprtme't. Law
.use
+yr95srh-M1tld-
elle
' I 0156e)
; tO
a[&J D35 -it i I ]4776.
1 003
, R697I i
,

2.52555
L
82Ot02
e
. 7MTh,
,
535252i
; W.4Ma
3 0}.0P•0 . 0202' . O.09000
s 04;1
'rah e,rmA...0 e911+10
Doke) S. r.. 3;
e........,..1
IWalr.

C@72 !
0OF7t62 iw
012100 . 11, * O&NOT-
1 002
V A
•120741

4.1i092f
01033 aQi10 . 1:03736
ii 003
4wMy b 4Z61i!
Fles.dan a 0.1602105
113e74 , 07:30 . i rsao.
e Din
13 sem
£
3194aa
,
e` I5apma.l T 4,14040i
Shine Coil:- ; 2'31210
1 210200
0 12.2. L,
;
1 J. 42000
OW
Patel
AK MA
04107
et 011.111
SOP 4501

8.0 Waste Detail

8.1 Mitigation Measures 4^Jaste
01-25
Cont.

Page 189 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2306
RTC -477

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod versIons CalEEMPI2016 3.2 Page 41 of 44 Date: 111212021 226PM V1lage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Lcs Ange{es. Snuln Coast County, Annual r4IlmDryIYeir
7 1Co I 014 wr
moored e FR- 0171 : _;eie DORM 71-.
•
01-25
Coot

Page 190 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2307
RTC -478

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnd WersIans Ga1EEMPc1,20163.2 Page 42 of 44 Date: V1212021 224PM VElage South. Specific Plan {Proposed' - Los Ange{es. Sculn Coast County, Annual 1-..2 Waste by Land less
Unmftiaate
WE ft!
fNG-.w4
TE421Ma
i7ii
n2a
Cale
1 1+iy1 u,
Un;
MT1gt
hpi mleRf LO
; 1'I 5
r tae U 1GS
DOOM
5:10.4
225ii17
. 21
I i1:54I. 1
« 1-}7146.1
! ]etc
« 23 61ti
+reM;;;;P:81d r 4tl.5 I.
'Mtge i
Pi 114'5 . S:1504.

GUM
Genera afire } .1 ae
13ild1p
a 46 i D 3Gyn • G Uurxl
r
1 ;
« no -am
i
TaJI>/
AV i nIll
lit Mil
r5.WIWI
ma.p761

01.25 Cont.

Page 191 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2308
RTC -479

Responses to Comments
CaIEE'Mnd'VersIan Ca1EEMatl,20163.2 Page 43or44 Cale: 111212021226PM VIlags South. Specific Plan {Proposed] - Les Ange{es. Snutrl Coast County, Annual

8.2 Wasle by Land Use
Mi tiaateri
Mist!
fNG-.w4
t5bI Ma
i7ii
f11Ge
to?,
1 1+.w1 LA.

UM
MT1gf
hpirmlBRf Lao.
tee
+pa95snh"M1Ntl
a1x
1'I 5
r 44.5-..
1 rLr
r lae U 13S
G5011i1
, 5. '4
2255 ii17
• 21 41E41
213+L+311
1 . 137eMA
3 arc
235'ta
Pi 114,5 , 5:x504.

Co 5(15,3
General 4 froce
13x1a>•q
'ignikrnty,911•
Paw) Awisureril;
..Mctal alru
-
. +41 65
51882 . 05,121 . 0 6443

, 1.a
P`.111i1.7 51"19 . 0firap€1
a
. 7f35
t 555711 U;'£6 A aom11
Oueay
W[YLRIi
,IlepwQl�
S11Llirrp Garay
t
1 aim nave,, OUP

. 56.8
1 118.1W
. o ,, om
. noteo
i
tall/
AV an -t0
11517X11

5.5101
h1Alid41

9.0 Operational Offroad

10.0 Stationary Equipment
Fire Rumps and Emergency Generators
'JI. lilie'I
:H-wrdYSar
Hama Foam
I.O3,1 Foetal
•=1y61 type -.
01-25
Cont.

Page 192 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2309
RTC -480

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnd'Version' Ca1E Elwad.2016 3.2 Page 44 of 44 Date: 111212021 226 PM VIlage South. Specific Plan {Proposed} - Los Ange{es. Snuln Coast County, Annual Boilers
Niuntier Heelinpartpay i linthwputiTear Bain Hal p ( n.ral'TYRe I User Deffned €gyi9menr
iuer nnq type
Ner Da'

11.0 Vegetation
01-25
Cont
Page193 of 548 in Cornnent Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2310
RTC -481

Responses to Comments
CalEEMoci VaTslons CalE EM3c1,20163.2 Page t or36
Village South Specrflc Plan (Proposed) - Las PogeLes-South Mast County, Summer Village South Specific Plan (Proposed)
Los Angeles=South Coast County, Summer

1.0 Pr©Ject Characteristics
Dale. 1='12.2021 2::29 PM

1.1 Land Usage
Larri Joan
lsgh turravoorISC DOW. Ftesmumsrfl
4500
1 IOCitag71 103 45'3'P.7 OD
L
Lai ar_raa3r
Floor Sularai #.rra PopMation
3400 7(1Qat11 s 0.0 34 co) 03 0
.
• HOW t- 5800
Ow* Re ra 8.011 - 1001krel' "are IS= CC
apartmleot4 CaFF Rene
Apoutments.mid aim
R eporu J Snoapr.g Cerny
2640 oweilllrg mit E 759

4.. F
973. DO 0,4.6844 llnfl ?5.B8 - 975,490.00 a9
4 4 t i
58 00 1000441 139 56 COO 6O
.* - .... ..... ...... 1 _`__.a . WO OD
. .... ..... .. .......

1.2 Other Project Characteristics
Urhanioaticrr.

ClItnaua Zrtra 5
urllr7y Company Southern CareormU Eereun
C612 Iraorm*" 702.47
Wind 31.ad
magma
(I�'hiWhaI

1.3 User Entered Comments & Non Defauft Data
rhea 1ph,elioo Free dtbJl�l
OparaNarol Yrs
31m ¢moray
014.6.110
33 01-25
Cont.

Page 194 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2311
RTC -482

Responses to Comments
CalEEModVersion Ca1EEM L2O1S3.2

Page 2 ends

Village South Specoltc Peen (Proposed) - Los Pogates-South Mast County, Summer Project Characteristics • Consistent with the DEIR'e model Land We • See SWAPS 00mmont rogardirsg re010011 raI and rotaiil tend uses Construction Phase - See SWAPE comment regarding individual oori Burton phase lengths l iennlrliion • Consistent wah 4he CiEIR's modal See SWAPE comment regarding demolition Vehicle Trots • Saturdaytrlpa consistent with the DEIR's model. See SWAPE comment regarding weekday and Strrlday trips Woodsteves - Whsodstow>_v and ur •od-trrurnirag fireplaces consistent with the DEIRS model. Sea SWAPS conrnerlt regarding gas fireplaces..

Energy Use -
Cons4uttion JR{oad Equipment Mitigation- See SWAPS comment on Coorisirtlehen-reiatcai mitlgetbn Area h4tgataon - See SWAP commend regarding operatronat rrithgatian rneasures Vatter Mitigation - See SWAPE comment regarding operational mitigation measures Trips and VMT - local biro provision
inrilnn Narrae
DonutYalue
New irali*
11 irepq&rzea
thiFirer e:
4 ilAreriarar4 Numta rftxt0
4 tbAniplalsa
=iiiripecroirpotlirlare
1,011726
Numtur45 000
a
1,61926
1 1'
4e 73
ihrrp.A.M. MT 1PkariatTnpi.cr{Ith
4 tUrti'piMrdy7►1t Wormr1rtptelyih
INT44104hir ; War!ktrTnptNlgih
IbF nTrAnPJMT 4 WdriieiTripLcrrth
4 II —1444,ilh'iAT ▪ 1M1lrleiTnpt.em1n
1:,Fi a .-ereuT worrieinittenpri a
IL 7[,
a
1470
14 70

14.70 1i;
•
•
_,7 T•R •
4 f -
ST Tri r s
•
4 4-
, :h rrpE. St_Ta : iF
^;:IVnnrrlofr�
!! ?T

0.0.1 903
0w
000
1800

10.00 MOO

16.00 1000

5.17 ?,7
I 3g

01.25 Cont

Page 195 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2312
RTC -483

Responses to Comments
CalEEM0d eTslarr Ca1EEM L2Ot63.2
Paget3of35
Village Smith Spectrc Plan (Proposed) - Las Pogigos-South Mast County, Summer Odle. 1/1212021 2.29 PM
ttrvemekrr ps.
aT_TR
4 -1
saveN et-Ir a gT_Tii
a-«
lbM1INUCtETrgs 5T_11 49 4F
4 ----- . -
BOftiEntEtTPps SU_TF • F 0
...... ...4...y......•... .-......-
EUN•hlGkTrp•+ SUy TFtLL ° 51,
r, .., .... ivwa�o�
•. 6hNehle4tntas Sli_fli 1 en —® 1
.......... ..... -.4--. a.. .
� mNehkl iEr p • � i • tu_TR• • t at L1 1 •
E to 3.T5
3e 63.97
}DN

6.t0
1 15
RT>wllehk:laTrgs
4 t5b41-iclei rya•
rarverltcrrnpe
3 EtIti tiCiTtp•
•_•••• ••' WINMItelETicii
EENMkleT}ra
4 ttrtvenraeTtp• 'ND_TR
hi 4 win/ender nder, wp_FR
4 { 6sNehterTrps WELYR
4 tlfNehicl•Tr pe WD_TR
4 4

91.9 TR
8{J_TR
WD_TR
3 NimbMCrnelyk
ktat4"Auar a4 Nimterea}31y4c
teh 'oackaaves 4 NurtterNontataytic
4 -
NrvmMxNglw-almop sc
.4
Vutpdslwatt4ylear
4+/aGelnlnnDay Yam
X44 5hhetkia ya t0dA m,
talWootinstrvets WandstoutrWErtrdiss
•
596

0.01 x127

3.2a

6.33 9.63

4.18 EtIT
65 ID

1.641
62641

9.00 900
403
407
ft 03
0OP

0.00 2.0 Emissions Summary
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2313

01.-255
Cont.

Page 196 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -484

Responses to Comments
CarEEMool VorsIons ca1EEMott.2Ot63.2 Pagel or35
Village South Spectrc Plan (Proposed) - Los Au -gates -South Mast County, Sunnier 2,1 {#veralt canstritslian (NMaxlmurn Dally Emission)
Unmitiaat€d Construct' On
Odle. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
RCM

11..

C.0
D2
9,:4,104!
wMI II
Extant
p7.ltp
.h1I {I
T*.

F,19Iwe
741, .5
r•ty0.1
F9.47:i
1NMT 7
A:i.-
©t!- C{12
H919- C412
iota! Clb

0.4. fl
L02•
k...
4951.7
emu),
'1

4. er
ADA: • 9!4119 : 4:49, 00679
'9.113: a 20199 l 2024961 li Yin I.1c2J
I'!!W.i_
J C4300 1649}1164'9. 1i X10 I •4,15 1 0ID3)
I a
r921 :72
-•.
'•
x
1504.* . 955311 1 405.x-.5 I 0 I49
C9ZSE., 1_g3II 1 10 -6= '_,3aJ I ',EL;

5. 14._:
0174CG •.`Y..E344• 12463.N I SAES • G C030
1 • 1
e Its 0.Y 1 Y
Y TZ0F79.57
e
07 ni.,
sI67i Z, ...ME • 3..4 rig; 1 4799 . 7_SEE• C. t,:' • •VV.) , { •I V. . :,LW.. (ICM° .•9.15448. 1r. 156: AI. UVALI . 0; C.40.3 02174:45 r •1
Y • , 1
173 1 RE I
1 PS
.i. l
7,
,. I-_;rp 4.. , 14 DIM I ()Ma . t 3171 7410• a 40$75.. • 0Kra VL91EI 0.4,M1 dl.tiY'90 . 2.1 03104•, 2319 104, 07140 . 0-0{KIO
,233i:bit
1 {
Y 11
117•'•414•{
F 9 1
6 ff
Ma.n
,r
2572315
AS.Y419
1627'75
d 1749
1112732
ZOOS
ip
9,907, ,
l.�
*-0 10
x9896
'4 #
t*

6.61.00 1i.S1LBY

I
1 U
01-25
Cont.

Page197 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2314
RTC -485

Responses to Comments
CalEEMedVersions Ca1EElhocl.2Or'6 3.2 Page 6IA' 36 C1aie: 1='12.2021 2:20 PM Village South Specofic Ran (Proposed) - Los Puigates-South Mast County, Summer

2.1 Overall conslru lton (Maximum Dally Emission)
mitigated Cons lrueti*n
R,.73
145.
b
-
,..grr.e
'N41'1
6rtAust
P+f.9IG
.1110
T--
1-uptwe
P411',:.1
!muse
P..4;4,
114712
Tai
bo-cA3
Aibo- co2
foci ma
{1.4
fl
LO2e
Y..
'.b41
woo),
'1 • 41' • 4•544 l5 . 61' 401.14 0 0530 •.9.:.433". ., 20490 .206 • C'. X307-3 1421J 11&1141 O. CAC 9}1 1 6 • 6f 16:9.0110 11.4:°5 • 01"133) r 921 :03

4. 120
I 9
,
P.
.•- ••
x $5 fl, . 8611 . 40 IT -76 . 01240
09 31_gdl . 10 3_ -0. 53aa ' I£ C57

5. I4_9
OCKOCI •`2.4$344.1..463.4.' I SAES d 6:100
. 72 6,9 57
• Its . 04 0P '
_ryry p s l!- '�' i•35O 616 T4DT ' 4190 . 9�KI8.5 d. ,:, , vv,1 , { 1 w . :,AM. 1 9Md0 • 42,1544d.1115049. LI 5704 , 05804 T2174;+D'
.
: 4 4
• Y • , 1
. 04 00
1 1S
. T;K9 wti•• P547& , I45042 ' 415215 • 12171 041174 . i?$'PS.. • I`b•.ld VL91E1 0 21 d1.5k90 • 21C3104• 2319 400, 0715 . 00005
,203t DU
J
• l J
Y 8
i 8 i
e 6
/1.16.1uux11
237A37D

48.4415
44'49779

9. IMO
111.2022
3!.6198
ip
$%7D

1.1 -Flow
wawa
134 lI44
p,ADIA41
t1185
06400

13.51@5,
I
OS
IL]
111
R04
505.
00 902
Fu11Pl.0
PM"fu
Ex1194:4,
PM 40
114110
Taw
PAW.

PM2:5

EA ILILFAI
MU
P142.5
70u41
lus-CCU
1419.1..E.09
Taal CO3
OHI
N711
C07r
Pr IA.

P041501,5,,
1114
,.CS
0141

11.011
5iu.
u.uu
'x00
1155
u. 09

9.05 oiie

14.1 15115
000
I1 CG

11.111'
01-25
Cont

Page 198 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2315
RTC -486

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMool Vorslons Ca1EEMTad.2Ot63.2 Page 9 or 35
Village South Specrfc Plan (Proposed) - Los Puigates-South Mast County, Simone( 2,2 Overall Operational
Unrniticiated Operational
Oa1e. 11'12.2021 2::29 PM
R47.5

43. CO
T,dprt'.e
Qrl I+l
[EAmust
PU10
.r.1Ia
TdkA
Fv9Ew
PM S
rwnus
Pm; 4.,
0kR7
l;i.r
@M -0O2
IINIo- CO2
Tura i21:12
0,4
fl O
COie
Carl.p>ry Miley
tlIMa7

1. -ad � • •- 5=1,1V1 • EE 4431 Of&11
Y
18074 i 1"9174 Ii57a
1 Soil
al COOD • `. E. I$i Cart• 10. 140.56 U45't1 037.70 •
1 Ja 54 •
16 F�1I
-may
7 all
£nc+9v El u7/-59 U'+63 .?3 004 10
7 -I- i
_ . .
06IfG' • 03...'53- i G67lv°.
d- i
w52Sr2
••• -•.2.3S
•
•
tooT•.e 355.963 x1502 • D= •1496
r 2
( j.
i
5,1m1a w 40499 •w 40. M ;140409
• 1
• 04412
45852 h,3:1R1 • 40.b§k •y 13. 90 • ,
} . • i
44219
1 il0a'7r1
1 •'.•15.33044 *.tolietie.
34 k 34
1,1139
• 1
i .20364.12
P
I.
111'451

47.M. filr.5i0a
jl
' fl4TTM
WW2
TAM
444217
S2i50
2,430
et 7'3,11
amp
FAUU11.4
ie
740141-1,4
ie
24212
$8132

77.$234,1
Be
Mitlaate.d°nee:AInr I
ROO
Wu.

GO
802
Faeg4:9
PM12
F$Lt1e
rJr10
F141a
TOW
Faill,a
PMZ5
=_trJ••%
H.Gt4
PM25
Total
elc. CO2
:1Bo- CO2
ITalal CO2
a -.s
r o_I
;... .
,
U:i,:

Vday
Mtn,
r
Alta a 335034 • 15%,109 •I ea 4437 I 00044 •. I.5714 k 15474 1307. t 15074 �. i. 1
411x76 • ka 1.4850. 1914057• -0,,17 .4 4 • 4339.3 • 1 .:.`_,-,, sa i 90 r
II
04 0404 £39
•
• 5430.' 17
'
.£uriun. :
mewl a
070 7 : £?tfv 11473 a 03#59 • a 05777 • 0522 32 • • 0570 • 05793 • • • •• e355flL'. • &36€.493 • ,a. la32 • 01532
85+199 450341
+207.5417
114.A.�9 j
GMT
• 49.4902 1
• 4.12:09

12. 0341,1
r T 0
341 • 6¢. 0.04
,
• 70.med0
• 2.1001 •
r '
Total
411197

97.IMI

0.IL7

46.9547

2.4020

19.4217
4 13 00
24395

14.7.130
a9[e9
T4911 I
1e
MI -nil
1e

2.91 . 0'+2
24932

77.C2L91
an

01.25 Cont

Page 199 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2316
RTC -487

Responses to Comments
CalEEMoel Version Ca1EElfpd.2O163.2
Pegs 7of35
Viriage So lh Specific Plan (Proposed) - Los Angates-Soutta Mast County, Summer Odle. 1='122021 2::29 PM
Fvo
nor
CD
SED2
klpnun
Ki119
E,'I'd93?l
FDIC
ny 14
T,.q
r i,-..
aN?±
E,I1,r.F,
um',i
r113.II
TnIA
19 .131:12
WeueC172
T9ta1002
GF11
N1
C@9
ms can
caa
,t,N

0.04 }.Oa
n 5
Ii on
.-
li-.i,
n,n„
a.u-i,
a06
4-X

0.DD
D.Od
DOE

0.09 rl«hcloon
30 Constructron Detail
Construction Phaso
� c
er
Maw Nina
F9rw rrnu I SU R Offte
End Pate 'Wien Cwo
MO.
pl-, 9e _- 4;oI7Spr1
'::9rem 'bon '6�rn9ohon 4ri s(' 9 , ItOllitOl`1 ' :�e�a :Sar Prxpeaba,' plift Pmairun /a rt C1 113/2C2.T 1140 21 0 l'-'''' 20,. ----.FGrarSn - aSr p NiitICl^.d2t i111 1Y22 a 61 4
'131ead1 y, GrTltetridldl •&tltlMp Cnnshnic3Dn • .-Y 1l1^1'2022 12,1253323 . 5t 5iFI?:
5 .P¢41nit .PireinFl 11211.202:+ 1+3CP2t2 _ .. 5: - -15t ...... i i -
6 :Ars#Mfst6BI CC nc :A.It114t![ru-io colon :1i,rie7,2i ;3'1 arp':q 5. 35.

Acres of Grading {Site Preparation PFias4 0
Acres 4f Grading (Grading Phase). 112,4
Acres of Paring: 0
Residential Indoor; 2,025,000: Residential Outdoor: 575.000: Non -Residential Indoor: 325.400, Non-Resi lontial Outdoor: 1,]6.800; Striped Parking Area: 0 (Architectural Coating — spit)
OtrRoad Eet ipmen t
D1-25
Cont.:

Page 200 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2317
RTC -488

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad'V2rsion' Ca1EEMad•2O163.2

Page 8 ends

Vir1aQe South Specofic Plan (Proposed) - Los P1legates-South Mast County, Summer Llaie. 1='12.2021 2::29 PM
PFreic taunt 1
011P444 EgwQment Type .4mdure
L 9-- Hash Halm Hx Paner Li es� ed F1
•:, tan
:ConcwtaAnGuvCrwl 5i,o.4 1

5.QQ• 51+
ms....
37?
:Ilan
—.--- ----4-----.------.-----•
Et e
a-----
001 153:
(1.39
+Rubber ined maw, r ,�
A30. ?a7•

0.45 I- 1..v —s.
�
... -
a00: 24.1
'Mu Pnapananan
:P llwerTirwl0 54r4. a 3
a.ac
414 Plappafatlan
•^TradarliLciackroitlacktona -__ 4
E-98+ 17+
Q37
Gratin
;Ewca4vahvs ` 7
6*IN I e13+•_••
03a•
1rb
nr366r3 1
8 013, r97r
0:41
• ra I1
farv i
�lxi r roateie
7a -L-
_.._,• 6.49
3rednQ•-
'SCrapars 7
•
• ..0. ^F7:
l'+F9
.G racing . _ _.---------
_ .........1--.........-....... :TreadaralLeadereBa:clOhm _.

ET:
7 37
Pullsm•tig Let - but 333
:Crime's .� . 1
P --- -..--_ tea..
' . i; : ,1:

3.29 . .. ::.Ic1t,:i
-:n rl• t
..' F.rl:
0233
1--
L
-5
R "-- ------ .-.,--
nrnmati Se r 1
- -I
. _ ! n
7 . .- . . . . -, _..

6._____...._-_.-_.,_.r-_--.-.,t.------ ------------
..
,TrelcturerLoederar®acMon r 3
---- -,__..._I .-
` 0. 57+
----- -....
1}.37
IF_- _ _ _ _
___ ______ t R _.___
__ __
I-
.•Wanders 1
6 00 46
0 4
_,. .. . _.
_____
.
r-.,r,q
+naves 2
1301'« .......
04 -----
- ��
.--.
^aving
;Pnnnp Egr�rnent 2 .
3 132
Q.36
I-_ r-- --____---_
Paving
*Roam
Arn[ac[tural [a41ngy
!Air C mPrWSa*s 1' ES '4' 10:
p.ae
Trills and MT
O1-25
Cont.:

Page 201 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2318
RTC -489

Responses to Comments
CAIEEMata V eTslarr CalEEMPc1,20163.2 Page 9 of 35
Village South Specific Plan (Proposed) - Los +oigates-South Mast County, Sunmei C1aie: 1/1212021 2.:29 PM
Ptmse Name
OffitmlErpoperawl Via Nat T+up VerviM Ttlp
rymlA'1 Worker *f 144511§r
Hthilre Tap
Numbal
'IhbII . Tnll]
Ve.a r Top
eitl,Inq Trip Wallin 'Wide
Length Carta
Ve4lacri Mauling
vatrrr Calm
V h curia.
r's+notaon 6 6 15 00; Q -.i4 a59 L0; 1'0 DO 690 .V L3 L�_M:x .r._ MIK MtiDT Ste Pcr;raArsn 18}3 063 QRQ� 19004 rg 9Q.. . _ 23 rJ3ILf_Mrx 1M?T Mix tilr3T 1. __
Gradcg 6. 29 09 409 0.00 10.04 f 690. W 3. iL:,_kln II -7 - '+ . ]FtM[}T Ei�N31tj1 t.+51e3L+41[Ik115 ~9 803.U9t t43:L{I 0.f10+ i900C E 2Q.g0rLi7. ],1ik 1Fi•-_any.. dI+r1LTr Parlrl) F. 14 0a, 044 0 4d+ 1St 94 694; 20 00 i Ltt„illoas thabt MIA 'HFi@T {r3 WLiF P. chtliWr c al crating
! 1' tea 00; 404 0174+ 10. Q«F+ G, 3O. , _444* 4IVT. Mix ;111-1 Jr

3.1 Mitigation Measures Construction
01-25
Cont

3.3 Demolition .21121
Unmiticoted Conatructr,3n On -5+t@
Roc,'
Ha.
co
sco
Fupl *
PIA 74
sat.i.t
PM11.,
p4410
Taal
•Fugd.M
Mr.,s
EEO..

ReLls
1,407 9
T.E.
13,, CLta
44Ev: GO2
TaAI C
C 4
13Q
GGb
=.1,1-41,,,
a.
414.1
G6.t.r
FAA,. CAW
a
ORFEv1d
• a or7a i 9 r1g44 PI 3]]74 !i PS4raC . 4 9940 0 `,,';c.4 r r . r
i a k -,rum
,1 1-p-
5ti15;
-
• :I •••••)7 ,
-
,'r $n59
• 447
1 .14 r
1 13
•
1aa•[ • I•t,I
•
.]7a7 p71. -4 i i'u+=d ,:e+S X47:'+]d-
imam
3LIRS1

11.4 T

71.383q
L1474
7,3311
4AM

9.34GR
1,4111
t 4119

3..7-07444
4 3 7,17.a.1-4
4 i. 06.14
1,774.3tT
7

Page 202 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2319
RTC -490

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMDd Version Ca1EE 4,21}163.2 Page 10 of 05
Village South Specoric Plan (Proposed) - Los P37geLes-South Mast County, Summer 3+2 Demolition -2021
Unmitigated Construction Of -Sits
Oldie. 1='12.2021 2;29 PM
AWI
NiN
CO
9r[2

4.700e
01,,4 .7i
i.YP„>aru
P1.11r
+=Y.11'R
I.
.u3.li_•

11.3 ..

L6saw45

64.17-
Fa I
n-,-�SJ2
N$,Lc12
1F.dll{Ue.

Q.*
WO

0..I.74
vol
a,:%IY
bdil,
lsJth$
_. _. _,ar ..--._
1�ss tlrl
31773 • +OZ: 1 13 W3r1] 33110

0 :"%3 rJ D1:-0 .0274

1.332 • YI.D1rl:+ • E0,EL'4'
• I.351-2Df1 13Sd2. 241
! 3
_
:+i-I:.-

--.; .,-;--
- + . I•
aunu e DiY3UG 1 3Dm: . LOCGD
1 e.33a3 Lcc43 , LtDii
-
s:73 amOG • carca
y t-
. D.00E13 4®0o
y® k
axr.•:.
....St
'Wlhiklr . �I'OiRT
e. Y
i 11,431311,4313 • Lem . I1500r
V • W3

5.1111 a Mac •
F

5.1781
�«
44303 6l4titla• 4D311
N I coo
• $12,14.2
•
11T.2nu

3.S,tCa.
an V
+
sow
soon

1.ltas
Bait
1,(413'1

1.31101
ao1!!
4:.1444
1).4112L

4.01121
411141
MIAMI
3 1A40.52•I
2 COM
1 311. 'III
3 rat Llyated Conti IUctlon On•S11
s-
Sac
FOPUw
RLIW
I;i1wes
R..110
P1113
T11
+-uow.

P!F',7
r�Ci2L.

MR J:

P,L'5
Ares
__-'-
NII. CO2
"%IL COI
O14
1430
=..1
r',vv.. D AL
411P •
Rem
I.

2.3274 0 G900 • 33374 • 11.0035
w
r •
11200E • 3. •lh7r
3 13300
L Ctii3
3 774 317
2tw a 2,.1-•37
.'0'47:50 • UL.
1 D4L2 1 5=_ i4
I .4411 14111
U Cclx a 1' 47. '1.14 374+.0+4• 10644 +
Told
!.1551
bt#Y3J

21.5640
4:031A

3.!071

1.4141!
;:Bsda

17.51350
L1411
tM1!

0.@014
b; ]42.4}+1
&'Txr.Oa+
I 04441
l.iT{.31T
0125
Cont

Page 203 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2320
RTC -491

Responses to Comments
CalEElibad'Version Ca1EEMat1,20153.2 Page 11 or 35
Virtage Sough Specifrc Peen (Proposed) - Los PDTg Les -South Mast County, Stmme(

3.2 Demolition - 2021
Miti4ated Construction Oif411c
C1ai °: 1='12.2021 2::29 PM
'Inc,
•4Kh I
G4
LP[2
IhuQtrxr
01,01,1
il•r- -u
Pt.11r
.1,1 I 'I
I.
.a6.11-•
1i-1 ..

L6sarz

64.17-
la I
n+iXJ]
IRS 0172
Fdr 001
DM
WO

0.72.-
. ,,,,
67<J4Y
,bail,,
-ukim
_. _. _,... ..--._

1...al l r
0177 • •I 0162 1 0Y•A: • ]0111!
626.50 1 0 D124 .11279
I. 1132 F Y1L91XC • 505.3
i 1. 22lI 17d'i. Is I
3 3
_
:"•-I:.-
-
a • eB0.7.0 . O Em: • 0 J0.0
i - 0
C.OG04 0 fa.60 , a mii
4 �. -
r. axe %MX • c
y i
• [7.682,5 402130
3,••• ••••.- k
S Ad.I:.
_
T
....St
9Ym1k1r •1 4 Nal
i 84013 1 0 e=2 • 11808.

F V • 494

0.1141 a ‘,5,004.1c-
F 11 i

8.1161
- •
440[3 i 141340.• • 40311
I coo
• 113.2,40
•
11t2314

3.-3,00.
oio V
sisia
4ite0
,. ,245

1.3411
h313'1
836114
0 i313
4:.1{4!8

6.il1Ta
40129

4.116'1
I,ddi.421
3 1A96.324
2 20111
I Ill ruil
5 3.3 Site Preparation - 2021
tlnrrl abed Curia tructtvn, On -Silt.
-
s _
542
R10trw
R1I0
,Lit.....

R.110
•"0.113
Tfdle
--uaLi.a
P!F',7
"E. ..,.

Rate
PC 5
Trnr
:-.7..2
N6a LU2
rdnl CO2
0-4
100
'
t,r•nM D,nt -•
Pon Rei
'80553 , 00000 • 190!82 • 5ti 7 ]EEL1c 4..3)7
' ••
00060
3C.3iG
3715a5t
-
3-'.3= • 46x.671 • 3 111543 • a L1- • 3fii+II 274-05 • I6)36 • 16915, w . • • r e •
•
• ] 66E 556 362,E 655• I.1u3C•
• 0 , a •
Told
0_182
�_
484971

81.1413
_

9.0348
__

18.0953
10410
80110.

9.930,
_
'ASH
1t4P14
_.

3.655696
6 3944.056
a
i t1,193
--.
].f1AA4F
_ d

01.25 Cont

Page 204 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2321
RTC -492

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod VotsIons Ca1EENIcitl.20163.2 Page 12 of 35
Village South Specrfo Ran (Proposed) - Los P9Tgates-South Mast County, Simonet 3,3 Sate Preparation • 201
Vnrnitiaaled Construction Off -Site
L1ate: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
ROG
N111 I
CO
OGQ
1`ugiboe

01.4••1
tomere .1.l
W.ilr
I 'I
I.
• a0..f.•
li-i ,
Lemur,

64.17-
!" 1,'
n+.J42
N$ - cC2
tmIll 001.

L}M
WO
OW,
- al -;,_y
r:l. .. . _ . ..
hell,
-ukim
---Ta
Weak..
0:3IM
L = (.r.
'3COC • 9 LIMO • 8W00 1 0 Ma] I 0 OWL, : [ its: .. n_ . • :_ .y_[0

0.130497 GONE . 0 9033 •
,. •_tl.
,a owl],
1417.5414
+1AoMti9+
a
C a
06 aC0 • aIn30 • 94X.30 • atom , a ., C609a 9COGC
L.?77W
T
[.00549 9.1540 : a
Worker 9!01354
09975 1 U91]9
V
a 1+1169[- • 6.136p a 17400[ •
! 'W' ! . 1I •

9.33331
a @97Ps9 : 19090x.. 49711
Y P !
: 1497'93D
140.7261:1� 42:12C.- .
a V
T.4.J
g. lY
4-515

0.513E
R4 .1..
fal
VINO
COW*
003
4-t *1
MAO

1.05051+~
trti
!

41.0354
4Ee:TxS1
14415.59
L'tt44.-
IX*
Ina Ltd Conta iuctlon On•SiL
w.
-
s _
Soo
RUPOw
F54..9
Li,alter
Mlle
PM la
Tfde
--,+0t1irG
RF',5
E. 3...

Rate
PC 5
Tw.
i 7.-02
NB. GG:.

T 1l Caa
0-.4
49a0
=..M
cw.N. f
E-....., -
EAa}
1,5.0+.4 D,nt
on IR
- '80641 . 9 [009 • 19 993! • Ii4:'w7 a CC8C • 1,a);
••
a Ma
3 ,.......-0
.3713457
-
3 • 40..671 + :.115a3 • aO1L • 20445 27445 • 13800 • 13915, •
w + • • , e •
004Q. .3635556
• 0

3.52E 655• I.1US-
a •
.

Toltl
1-91:52
�_
40:4971

81.1943
_

9.99•. 187853 1.0410
-

801105

9.9377
t.2300
Yt3P15

5.99@0 .7,550:956
_. _.
a
3550.055
9 +4933
_

3.715.457
3 01.25
Cont
Page205 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2322
RTC -493

Responses to Comments
CalEEMnd'Version Ca1EEMdc120 03.2 Page 13 of 05
4illage South Spect c Ran (Proposed) - Los Angetes-South Mast County, Sunnier 3,0 Sate Pre paralton -2021
Mitigated Construction Off -*rile
C1ai1°: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
AQu
Wfl1
c4
0r[2
Ptlphwe
DM ..ti
biI¢ii9
PM10
PMta
TOW
:R4plh!
PP,Gs
4IIrlla!
',Fez
Ped.N r
TO.

DM- 1]
N -cd2
SEsll p32.

DM
WO
coa
I

4. d
-IiJL'y#
. Ydrakr .
u.rii70ii
C _. X•-_,
•] Goa . a 31110 • U 070:• •o Ci]Pa • a ar3�, . 000:10 3.CIDG : 6.0000

0.8633 o ow Y a 3w° : I
,6 3113
,]XC
. 14Q444114,14Q444114,'•N;tke
a
u., -..x,
aCffiC . amin • 00x03 • 30000 , atom: cf1W17 1C001 •_L. •
•' _ - 1_.. _ _. _. -_. "t. _ -t __.
•�. [q.600a o®6P : BMOC ,
_ _ ..
. tl9C•SI
-
04 4,'.• • U0,3B

I+I100r . 6 1 3114 • 17MpJtr . P 116• • x93.3
r , VA
147560.. •+ PION..

Oq
- • a80 Mi.
•
140.7190, 42:120n- •
MO 1
1„1w

4.pspl
9-W75

0.$13E
ca1aE.-_
1143
4:1}d{.

Ill
I claw,—
aaa
votT
n4}4s
testa.-Ta
CO
goo '
140.2154P'1141554 i,

0!-
«1O
./.Yuh1L4'
Id Grading - 2021
UnrItigatod Cclnstrucbgn On -Sate
31010
erica
cc
s0c
F 11O31.
fir. -0
€ruur
PM10
P'qi lU
late
frrp6.,
PI '.0
Ei#s•m
Pf•120

1.42 5
VO]
all CO2
146a cc12
Sd.] coo
cjc4
1�.

GOZI '
I
Camay
R.'Aa ,
WM),
-
F.rn•.r1:40 -
Oft.-
Rem
w
• • S&'.35 , ODOM • &FM
1 3siSSi s 10{01 • 3`&304 •

30000
3f4Cv
5055513
-1
a I.o13
4630{' • X. BIBS • 00520 • : 151853 1L 3
r • • r e
T
!30 S I835i
•
.,0,125,0.3 4111 033• 188 +
n 1 , d :
. 5055.51.3
Told

4.1012
461039
[email protected]
_

0.0530
_
,4} L6
_

1.44111
'UMW
_ _
15Pbi

1.6260
_ _
14834
_
_
0,007_@1{
4 69»7.043
5 I942e
+
8 01.25
Cont

Page 206 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2323
RTC -494

Responses to Comments
CalEEtAnriVnrslon• G91EENtscl.20163.2 Page 14 of 35
Village South Spectrc Plan (Proposed) - Los AngeLes-South Mast County, Sunnier

3.4 Grading -2021
Unmitigated Construction Off -Silo
Onto. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
9C
+
CO
90[2
ItuPtrxr
84,1••3
it Y- i-U
RAIr
+=f.l1• l
I.
.pint
Ii-i c
IiYseets

64.171
FaI
n.,-CO2
POW- CCI2
1F.dr042.

CI,..

WO
CU
. .. +
-ukem
... - ..ae.�
'esstlar
.3 MA; n i.
.' - J iY_QY
9 4373
,3 C41Uli .0 i1Cib
1 L .:

R4.4, .
m ._)-_-(40
• 00000 I 40190 Y 1.3030 :

,1 OCC.
• 1'934541
via 16111,'
Y 4M3C • 0C.:11:0 0 3?0
.
{ . _.

CO). - 3Ri79
-. -
r :i!•
:70099 1 , aimp
n99P3
3CG9C
C•OTO
•....
• 0.7994
• 9443 fi'r
40300 • imam am +

...._.,.,.,,
. 45�Iker 4461@
M
Y 9911E + 447/ti
Y 1
f
e 15790r
Y PM
.

C15r1
r WA— '2 •
C Y

9.13 1 09
. 174

19 • 1 ae
f ^
04415
1543731, 4.4g794.64C44-Y
1 T.y4t
9-%4*

13.4&I7
$5745
t5T55.•
5W

4.1621

1.2m,
444
•4-1#41
Ir:[AIL

1.1705.-
MI
@i15 I
355.7x#
1 43142
44445.• p
863 I,I
Mil hip Lod ConstrLich on On•SiLt
s_
110
F:19trw
FM -43
ai>,wia
FM111
PrAIa
Tufo
--4.1i.c
91:,4
.., ..

MT?e
P'.L'5
4rns
__-'-
NII. 1U2.
rail CO2
O4
9f2n
=..M
--_
r',5n+.4 D,nt
44PRem
- a [IMOD . 09 . 8 E73
i
t
r
3"0%5 3Cffi0 . 75]IK

40Q90
3 ,....X.::
•fi0d&fi43
4 •• I.,,2 • 48,10:7,1 • M i.78S • 7.51534 • 19853 iCf�-9 . s . • r e
Ifi`59 •T• I$3fii
•
0445 a5,0}T @3,3 9 00 .Oi3• 1 11 +
n 1 , 4 . n .

Told

4.1917
46394
:9.6764

9.9671}
SAM

1.4933

50.111 1
1458*

1.92155

9.4834

7.9987.

5.477_@4{
i
994!.943
a
194711

5.466616
I

01.25 Cont

Page 207 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2324
RTC -495

Responses to Comments
CalEEtibad Versions Ca1EEMPI24163.2 Page 15 of 05
Virlage South Specr5c Pten (Proposed) - Los ,e3tgates-South Mast County, Summer

3.4 Grading - 2021
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
Odle. 1/1212021 2.29 PM
000
N0
co
90[2
rugtree
PM n5
&hare
PM1C
►14110
`TIIM
:R4phw
Pry.3
4b454.vJ
ee.2'$
PINCIA r
T.I.
- C 12
14#442- Cd2
1'bll {U2.

DM
M20
Cur
I
,,: •ie4'='1
s
tLMfY
13,101y
V
-!..0.44
1 deakr .
0moG . C.=AIc.
r C.ii'_ JIIIQY
Ii e430) 0 COMO . QU3iP
0,0000 0.CmQ . 6.0000A
0 W QCelO . 11D
Oif_c1:
a ixec
Ile.. 4404
+ a40,11'
a MOE • E.:,100
1 COY. 3 3CC.C
c r.co) ocean , 0=
1 - . -
_
65000 7 C i • C. -
t
• 6.6600
...5537-5•
'
.

GCMG • exec .

Walter ., 4.45.44.45.4@
M
, e'I
119.11711F 0L . Vale-
Y a • 4r
L' .1 X31
,
'. 2.piyje QN✓31 S.QgQs
Dr Y
� mak. . c04,5 +
, f ^
•
1543731, 4.64C44-,
• t 1

7.,no.I

4.454*
get 1I
0011,1

1.WI.-
Iaha
•.'11521

1.27044,
484
•4.4541
it:4su4

4.1705.•
455
04615 I
455.7x#
1431 2
44406.-
Ma

3.4 Grading - 2022
Unmitigated Construction On -Sate
...-_,B
•va
CC
SOC
Fs l0 .

RAN]
€5iaarr

8.110
Pg4IQ
lam
flrplt,*
PIE'S
E44,,44
FO0
1•N:5
'To.

Da - CO2
0164 CO2
"[dal CO2
CFc4
C71a '
-
-
_ ---
F.rn+n Dnt
'flA I
i i. • 1.4733 I ODOM • 4-E733 • 35461 . soma 2&e65
Y r s w w
a • •
••
30080
f4CG
.0CEO 010
e
.1. .18 • 305410 a 3i 0410 1110 1EClI 103441 I 504 • I 301 •
• . . . . • .
aQ,C!ril0 5014 410
5 , 5
141000 +
a
IOW 1'!445
366!}5
80400
Q.0l41
L0170 1.5345

40.30!4
104104

1.91811
64096
4,Q11h
6414A14
i 1440
,--
1 680P.01
01-25
Cont

Page 208 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2325
RTC -496

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod VeTsIons Ca1EEMsd.2O163.2 Page 15 or 05
Village South Specorlc Plan (Proposed) - Los PogeLes-South Mast County, Summer

3.4 Grading - 2022
Vnmitiaated Construction Orr4ito
CIai9 : 1/1212O21 2::29 PM
RDo
Nee
00 not
✓ugtve
Mine
bi1¢ii9
Mil
►M1O
Tins
Xtriphn•
MG 0
3I'Irlreg
PN,r2.$
Pv2 r
l'em
CC12
14#4.2- CO.2
1'thI002.

DM
WO
coa
I

4.,ieq°o3
4—
tLMfY
lives
-1iJL'y7
1'05E11 •.
7:33
L..1,0 ➢LxIJ'_
• � IC • Ii 00J 0Ci1116 • 000136 6dd33
a.CmG • G033U
G. 6830 0Met Y 07033
'O 000.
00OE
. 1So NI 3
:7 MCC
coo
3 COY. • aJ07e 0:001 . ama0 . a.=
•
00XJ0 1CCGi • C.CCGO
e
• 6.6030 033130 • P700G , .
_.
73"0 + UC?97 . 151G0r • L•.15i1
• '7 o •
^. 2200. 41531 e.040t
' 0330 y r
• 10O3e . 00415
o-
•
• "666JN 150 eit4 • argrA.
. . 174? "
l.Ee,.l
l lace
Il uSrw'
40 01,
100130.-
101021

1.2000 •
0 1000
3:4/ii

1.15 +
[ isS10,
w
10000 'w
1#e.$154 '
114,0.-
1554419
i•11 LivaLed ConnCrLich on On•Si [o
o o.=
•v._
CC
002
iu0hoa.

PM.0
€tour
wale
P00110
lam
Fusin..

P4000
0004.

PM: =

14.42 5
110
Da = CO2
ha. 0010
0411000
OA,
1020
GOO!
cave,
1440m.
ems
—
F.rn+n D.K.I.
'fl00 0
— i 6&7.33 . 0D000 • 11E730 • 35a6i .. 1CC0{• • 3`ldGi
1 s w w
• • •
• 30600
0?:4CG
X00000 CIfi
e
�680P.0151
.1. 49 • 30.00.4 + 3i CA10 • 0093' i93m6 19340 14001 110001 • + • . • e .
•
0091X "Q,C!fm10 0011 mil
9 , 9
19+-0,7 +
•
Tow
10240
-
366!}5
_

8.6113
_

0.11!49
__
66233
_

1.6310

40.30!6
i5666i

1.91811

5.1066

6.03000
10011_410
10 6611A16
°
F644i
�
9 01.25
Cont
Page209 of 548 In Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2326
RTC -497

Responses to Comments
CalEEfibad Versions Ca1EENtod.2O163.2 Page 17 of 05
Vif1age South Specific Ran (Proposed) - Los Aagates-South Mast County, Summer

3.4 Grading -2022
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
C1aie: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
IOU
Vat
G4
not
➢ugbee
;lll"
4! kin.

Fh1r
OVA
Two
:Ru1MNe
Prt7.5
Nr3aaia
KC
WId.11 r
TO.
b. CC13
N$e- CC1.2
F.dI CU2.

DM
WO
claa
i
,..,leq.'r
4 a1Mfy
tx111y
-1iJi'y#
'Yeah .'
.e
..

O:T . L="AIG
➢f_xlJ'_ �T_CIY a 11 430) aCr]18 a d
1111000 w mpg . dOSA
G.9670 0AD01 Y 0]000 :
,J, i1s1:
]CfCti
, 1 1.13
',31
0MCC . Ci3:O
e
t
C:0_ ]J07e 1:IKA0 r 019].-10 . d.
e
t 4- +
06 70 Cart . CC13G7
e
t S _ @
" . 0.10610 dUd1 O:rrr.

Wolter ., 41; , . InVe,
x UC,7113 . 151G4r a e 152, r ',TAD.. 91 L I. C'J�44 , laDe . 60415 e , cam : 6cs
. •6011'51 , 1%IlT5,. a 4d e. ,
;G
" n4a "
1 w -
_- 41 I
1fi3Ti

6.110

1.51116.-
803,
d.19

1.21M4,-
443
'4.14}4
It.liet4

[email protected]
044
tie$15, mars.
1;4.14154
1-1440*-
644
15dPgf9

3.5 Building Construction - 2022
Unmitigated Construction On -Site
v
Su'c
FdOh.e.

RAM
EItuli1<'
FT.110
P6d Id
llta
-Fusin.*
PA17,1
Ei#a.m
R•T7,5
1'r,L' 5
'Puts.
18-0 002
1413. CCl2
T.]Ll X02
CI -I4
WO
_ ,.,
wM4gar
Waal, -
Ie4a}
OH.Rsatl
- I:.z3
_. .- IC 3E3=
. 333GG a
,a MC • 9D'Si. •
?+t•._
y _
Da333.
2M-4 133
• 3313E ,,
Taal

1.7[083
95:fi15E,
1E3S34

8.12&4
698U1
d BM,
RTF12
I1TS13
2,551-333
1 2561.595
1 11.5126
25€4545:
2 01.25
Cont

Page 210 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2327
RTC -498

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaci VeTsIons Ca1EEMud+2Ot63.2 Page 18 or 35
Village South Specrfic Plan {Proposed) - Las A'rlgates-South Mast County, Simmer

3.S Building Construction - 2022
LInrnnitiaaled Cons•uuctien Off -Site
C1ale. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
9u.--
'4'.'.

CO
9r[2
4-ugdNe
i•1
it Y'.•e1-U
PI.11r
+=Y.11'R
I+ra
''on- .
li,a c
1_6saus

64.17 FaI
Ili 0712
Mu, CC2
Idll{UI.

DM
WO
CUB
- el y+_f
1-u
Well
-ls 11,4 a OCCE . 60.703 t scow . aeons Y
J L4] % • •u i7CCrn
6 300_, 3 C1:136 . 6!710
• 0.667] 0 C6e0 . 0.7p_,Ci v

• oiti,
• 3932138
4 'Grla4 DU
f
15 Meal r w RI 8O76 . 13.2532 . 34341 . 0.1862 F L0P°
Si
y} I 4 i_ Y
2MIR . D Wad
4 C.76Mi 36777 . 6.2d73
l i
• 3.sou sae 3366.621 • 8.2235 •
2 2

1. 1i4111er •• 2 4241i
w
i I0.0lra . :I UM r
F V
r 690C" Y
tl I
6UV:.
0 D : 4.14'15
Y

1.0103 09404
a
N 1.14417
.
.4.4122354
V 6
0O42 440 . 0INP :

I 5 1
_
Told
243 r1
1i.1I*
244-3412

4.447+0
}.1?0R.
40Y11
2+A{$
i.tll9fl
40411
lima s,gnpiie
409i.lie
no, ,nn
nt9r�1.
1 Nsn
Minya Led Construction On•SIt
v
s-

50.1 wG6w
FhdW
,ahwes
Ft411C
PM 1,1
"NM
+-u41i.c
PlIT5
"..Citio.

R.T?e
P'.L+5
Tres
a __-'-
NB. CO2.

T 11 CO2
M
900
=..M
Gawp d4
Wail, -
Wm}
OII.Rsati
I : s:
.- _
+ IC3E].
. .
® 3365
•] 6t6C • 3 f�^�,'{� .
�
'. +t•. _
. ' -: i_
• y
e•1}b: . .' 733.
3313E +
Taal
7[0

1. 83

14.6156
1E1E3614. 62&4

8. 8868
6 d BM,
IL702
117112
6C474J
2,55+4-253
6 2451.593
6 !!.5176
25€4832
2 01-25
Cont

Page 211 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2328
RTC -499

Responses to Comments
CalEEM6ti Votslons Ca1EEM L2Ot63.2 Page 19 of 05
4iflage South Specorrc Peen (Proposed) - Los Angates-South Mast County, Summer

3.$ Building Construction - 20Z2
Mitioatrd Construction Off -Site
Lime: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
AOu
Wfl•
G4
V3.2
1huQbrt
411.4.7

3.26-•-3
R.7•r
.111'R
I.ra
•.31•_•
li-t c
Lesaus

64.17^
Fa 1,'
a
n+sxa2
POW- Gd2
F4bl oal
-
um
M}U
0,.
-I4 RV 06i7m • 60.703 i nuns • sumo :

J La •D Jai
6 330_, 3 MUG • 6_,710

0.11673 0 33)11 • 0 30.3• i
• 0:iL
•36.32135
4 • 00,5 E:lQ
: f
1491 itna
1'4.1# •• 0 P • f3.3032 • 343.1 • 0.1861 •. 5DI: °•
mi
y} I 4 i_ t
30343 • D 040
4 0 N '3=7 . 0. 73
l i
•3.au654 3266.5411• 11 21135 •
2 1

1. 1YaPker •• 24264i
w
i 1504 • 21 00 P
F V
r 0000"

Y BULL'.
•
'3 DM ; 0.14]6
Y

1.1103 09404
•
N 1iEB7
•
• 4.W135d
V S

0.04200 • 0 KW ;
I 5 F •
_

1. 4.41
1 H13d

74.4442
n.GFP'7
T.1) .'
4071
LOIN '
iVfl
40I1
lima
s,gnprddP
oil
noi•7nn
nwo1.

3.5 Building Construction - 2023
Unmitigated Construction, On -Ste
s _
6O4
R•46..4
Fh•W
iwt+r
Ft4110
P l I ]
Te;e
+-.413.4
P11 5
r......

MT?
PC 5
Arts
t :.•:"..2
t16a cU2.
"%IL CJ' a
ta44
11f2O
Cal,
di
1745.. _-
- !•m.,
OQ.Rsati
I L _'l
.35•] •
le 2,,a
• 63263 •
-
,3b6ti'� _,.
t .
_ .x
_�
3C:3D•
3687E
.:r.:;5:,
Taal
1 537E

14.3&11
1E241

5.11263
6640P
311363

0.115.54
411•mod
1,S55_2411
e
2336.333
a
D 5071 2'33fl4Q5
Y

01.25 Cont
Page212 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2329
RTC -500

Responses to Comments
CalEEMosl Votslons Ca1EEMPfl+2fyl63.2 Page 20 of 35
Village South Specorrc Plan (Proposed) - Los Pogetes-South Mast County, Summer

3.$ Building Construction - 21123
Untnnitimated Coniuuctien Off -Silt
Llaie. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
94+=
'i'.'.

C0
002
Iulh'wtr;
i.YP.al-U
PI.IIr
+ III'R
I+ra
'u3.11_•
li-, c
1 6sa•s

64.17..

FaI
n+0x12
POW- Cdi
Fbll{0i.

DM
WO
OW,
-Ilona-
. - sstlu
.1 _CCl: C Iv33 Oman • 0IIAI • 0 di.",
o ,.. —
: )CC
L. .: 1LmG. : F.aiti
G. U67] 00000 • 0.70-004 .
:.. i...
1'
0307.1 0I'C+ e1 341013 . 0326' :. ?ei 08I
3 C=:,E
DEW'
sow. x.2.747—
•. _ •, e 3. TM WE 3.772.E76. 91.2.7. .
);7"-5E00
C
1 1. -! + 1- 4 4
- 4- - 4 L w
•
ayl
'•ka4hher w 711101. 4}1(j� 110 4002 - U9Ed'1 E.Ock3. Y 941E 0.7#11 1,11181 OA7#t 1.iEtlbi b 1 tl Y Y b h
+Atli ldTl'43,T• 0.15
1 .6.E�T
4 w
Y 1
Y 1
' Y
Y
P
;
1 1
a 1
4 Try
azor
i15161

22.5441
414th
14911
44415
2AK2
1:15411 I
44547
44754
4449.27.
114415,272
25151
544+4555
I
4 D
a
Mil Ina Led Cont:truction On•SIt
s _
533.2
Fuotrw
Fly, -,0
:;.hater
Ft211C
'"0.113
T•fo
--.414..2
FTF',0
r�Citio.

MT?
PC 5
Arts
t 7:02
tllLa CO2.
'En' CO2
43-4
9802
Cal,
OM Rsa0
w I a'_1
. • -I 30,4 '
It 24,a
• 6 3265 .
__
__Taal
'
3 EE0', . ','
:
tki,Z1,
• ,x-,
,..:01. _
M 23D
. 3##076
t _
.:'3 ::e:,
1 572E
I

14.3544
1E241

0.025_0.
0E401
05_441

0.E5D-1

0.4.51 6.0000
2,355_202
a
2355.200
a
D WTD
2'330.405
Y
O125
Cont

Page 213 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2330
RTC -501

Responses to Comments
CalEEMataVersions Ca1EEl ud.20163.2 Page 21 or 35
Vittage South Specrrlc Peen (Propossad) - Los AlTgates-South Mast County, Summer

3.6 Building Consiructlon - 2423
Miticated Construction Off-5lte
L1aie: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
IOU
Wfl4
G4
9032
IuQtrxr
ME • I
it Yeah+
P1.1er
.111'R
I...
.uall•
li-• ..

Lesants

64.17..

F. 1,'
n+0x17
I Gd2
lEmdll CU2.

L}M
WO
CG.
— y,_,
G—Yr
6d61y
-lsJth6
1'eRda
'SF
o ter
LACO : acme • BMW Y CJY•
o ,.. -
:ACC
L 4.: 2l:me. : Gatti
• a1W0 a. OGEE • 6SOOi •
•
:.. i...
];TLc3a
C
, ,5
4 ,3362
4-
,611 I.51 • 11[1, . GM: • DB I?ei
t - 1
3C=:Ic
0 11. 7'
D2T-_ se7It X2747
F 4 4
•. - •, •
-
•5521•U33
.

3.773E93 3.773.576: d 102.3 , .
. 2
- 4- - -1 L
414 'IITan CO2.

Tdml Cel
O4
.e2O
CC -24
cameo, 1 E'.srT
lA9iy
On -Fwd
.aze:wp-
1 (5.7, C I4 S° .a • 5fl776 • . cram • a 51[04 • . 114,354 • t .S0.1 i t w w s•
3 7.075@o1 22LQ 384 • 13.714G
w 1 E
1 1
- :ZS .:3
a
OD
a=
1 CI LIME
11 DUG
ME
cam• -•

a[
Told
t.6171
Ilk tB17
14,5542
OA=
45182

9.51•52

11.46&1

9.443•4
3,342.354
7347.6!4
11-7148

4.22'433
a
O1-25-
Cont.

Page 244 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2331
RTC -502

Responses to Comments
CalEEM4ti Version: Ca1EEMod.2O163.2 Page 22 oF35
Village South Specrf4c Plan (Proposed) - Los , TgeLes-South Mast County, Simmer

3.6 Paving - 2923
IInlr4itiaaled Cans.uuction Off -Site
Crate: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
{oC.7
NIT* . I
CQ
9432
IhuQbrt
11{1••9
i'Y- ,-u
PI.1lr.
.1.I I 'I
I.
' dip .li_•
li-i c
ILImurs

64.17-
r. 1,'
Il,�X.I2
POW- CCI.2
FdaI c43
DM
WO
CG,
. --yny
n:ky
tell,
-ukim
_ . - Weal r � e
r

0.cnr . L _.X
n C.091
n fIIFm Y U anna ,J oaw .0 XC&
L r 4., .....
. •_ a=m
3 0.1147] OCHE 2 Q 00513 .
..._e�
,] 7EG
Ir ,Cd@q
a MOD r USX,[+
e
-: CON:CON: 31I
. 6476] r ] [KM .• 0.

Y .

BIM.) 9 CCGC
4•]740
T
❑.06115 4[400 Y : r1,503079fe '. •
e
'Wlhiklr •• 404V
i 11.0.,6 • 036'1]
I 7:00s-•

0.I II.I ' WOW*.•

0.1194
OQ3Q3
gym., . 44311
. •001117@ 1
lIZQUM • 2.dd00 . i
•
%oral
tor
MO
a.3{3-1
OW*
an

0.1141
O.IW7aw.
era
a.1I1t
ti. min
LINOS-
COI
ISOiil
11W.fI
irdI 3
&No .
q66
1d0.MR0
Mil Ina Ltd Construction On•SIt
z _
Sal
RIQmw
ROW
1;41wtp
R+11C
PRA I0
Trde
+-u4li.c
912
r�Citio.

MT? 65
PC 5
4rns
.V:..2
NB. IU2.
idnl CJ' a
caki,
IRO
CC -24
ilt.iimy
E.k34
lAaly
o6-Rwd
l • PZNwp -
14"a C 14 S°.3 • 0fl776 . ' 0$903 • 0S.= • .. 04014 • le4 1 i t w w ;
' • • +
• _ . +:21:17514 22CQ 084 • 0.714G 1
r w 1 I r ,
Y ,
_ :ZS .:3
0 0 Dom
O s[fl}
I
• ,
r
❑ 019.05 .
,
11119[!..
:
9 411'4
P
O.m.
4 woo
•
Told
t.1:6171 .

ItiB17
1{56P2
B.
46182
459.00
I
4{6W
4+44&4

0.M10{0
2,207.W
2347.ti64

0.714Q

3.22'433
a
01-25
Cont
215 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2332
RTC -503

Responses to Comments
CaIEE'Mod Version Ga1ED 44[120103.2

3.5 Paving -2923
Miti4ated Construction Off-5lte
Pate 23 of 35
Village South Spectrrc Peen (Proposed) - Los Angates-South Mast County, Sunnier Cia1P: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
ROC,
N3 I
C4
9r[2
IhuQboe
0{1°•1
torart•
PI.1ir
+=Y.1 I 'I
I.
. dip .li.•
li-i c
I e•al•s

64.17-
Fa 1,'
n+iXJ]
14 - cti2
l'em otn
um
WO

0.72. . --yny
n:ky
15401,
-ukim
_ . -1...al r
....a
Y1Mks
e

6..2.0;1: • L _>3cr
n C091
3 W2 • 6670) J 0alli .0 gal].

L 3.: .....
•_ J_m
3 0.11033 OCHE • 3 .303I3 •
..•_e�
,] 7Eo
Ird+l:y@4
Q 0006 . 0.a"a:90
I
-: C•:•]."
m
QO0Id • 60330 r o 0300 • 0. MI.
1 a•
5-650.11 3 COGC
4 -
C O7Cea
f
D11500 9=0. 25020'. T
.- _ + _- r .. 4 s,
•• 004V
e
• 6112•`'8 • own
Y V
IMO.- •
0I Ii.I . pC'006r •
: •

0.1100
04X4.?
- ,
6X000, • Germ
R ON
•
• •0801X6
V
icQuft • 2.dE0Qr •
CC*
.
'reed
•-ter
MO
d. {3-1
OW*
On

0.1.11 O.IWOM.

0.11'x0

6.4fat1
t04CM1s-
On
II.5111
11W.01
1rdI 3Q
Uwe*
CM
1d0.MR8
l6 Paving •2024
Unrrl eted Cunstructign On ,Sete
.L.:

Sal
FuDOw
R]
1;i1ws
FM1C`
PM is
Trdle
f•gp1i.c
FT4 5
r� o.

MR 65
PC 5
4rns

2.02 t16a CO2.
"%NJ CO2
M
1f2O
CC -24
ca�ay
•
E.k34
- t•19ry
OII-Read
Fafrnp
o.lEi:

Li 5,.%1.6 . 13 6.21.8 • Q0726 • 01605 • 0V65¢ • 04780 ta31C • • • • ;
•
_9PSi7 2.54.547. 0.7146 •
1 • •
:05 '!Jy
a Qrdo-
a
• CI CUM. Q 03rd : a acQc •cam, -
• ••
• r • •
(i.CQQ9
^ • '
Told
— 5.9552
9;7N6

14.5255

42.92211 •
I14555 •
1L4
•

5.43111
44316
-

3.3QL44r
2 A34P.647
2 Q.7140
'aa3` .380
3 01-25
Cont.

Page 216 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2333
RTC -504

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaci Version Ca1EEI*41.2Ol63.2 Page 24 of 35
Village South Specs c Plan (Proposed) - Los , TgeLes-South Mast County, 3i .nme(

3.5 Paving -2924
Untmitielated Coneuuction Off -Site
LIa1e: 1/1212021 2::29 PM
{OIL
Kh. I
Cit
90[2
1huQlert
E{1••0
i•Qrall•
Pr.1Ir
.1.1 I 'I
I.
• dip .lt.•
li,a c
LYsamm

64.17..
ra 10'
0,�XJ2
IOW- t C1.2
1F.dll t4:19
DM
M�1`
CU
-lsJrh$
Ws, du
9M1�Ik� •r
0:T X _ =00
3 COT_ J LICO5
L' e4JJ) 0 C€O J gore
L 0rJ::: .. n_ .
• ,—)14)
• 0 NW 0 0'000 Y 0 ]0T ••
,].irxq.

IX 45,09
765.Rr142'
�P SCC • 0'2•."a:C.
5 COY.COY. ]0000
0:0063 r 0 D • 0 ID))
1100)] ]CCOC

0..?7Ce7
T
C.QQEfS 0[000 s BMOC .
00403
i 06371 • 0T144 • 10.706•
C lid . 69QOL1! .

0.1184
a 5Ma!
E100Ea, • 45311
• •05,18734
141935E • 144760• •
i.yt
Win
50235
000 1
-7.0> 4hIhs
ho)
hi .11,11 sc1)Mh,.
nit
•411$5
1643W
t14Ery -
OpY.

I¢.Q311
l *1t$
IC431331

2.1104-
DS3
Mil Ina Led Con iitrUctlon On•S1t

0.:
04)0
F 1QIfw
RiI0
1;d a

8.110
P1110
Trda
f•cl.1 pc
P!F',7
"r.. ....

Pe171
PC 5
1llaa
i
:':'o
Nil. 002.
" %L CO9
0174
14)0
CC -24
-
QE.Rratl
• • 1.1,...4p
• 0• .'2552
G. 5)40 . la 6..01 I D.M5 • . 0.1000 • 04000 • • 0{380 • (I 431C- .

Y i y Y 4 Y
• • ,
.C9P10? 2.54.547• 0.71{G •
7 I 2 ; ii
• 1 •
:o0 )00
0 C1l130
• 0 srm'
❑ CUM • Q 0110f 31:95E. • 07A0
• • • • • • •

0.01166
• •
Told `
Q9893
_
0;72{6

1{,8208
_

42.92211
I

41.4001

0.4684
•v

5.4411
44316
I-_

8.11 41

2.21:12.541. 9..1•9T.5+7
Y
i

0.7140
$ 8-755

O1-25
Cont

Page 217 of 54 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2334
RTC -505

Responses to Comments
CaIEE'Med Version. Ca1EEly L2O163.2

3.5 Paving -2924
Mitioaled Conetructian Off-5tte
Pate 25 of 05
Village South Specrrlc Peen (Proposed) - Los Au -gates -South Mast County, Summer Odle. 1/1212021 2.29 PM
MCC,
N0* I
C4
9C[7
IhuQ4xr
OIA"•7
itn0,-+
RAW
+=Y.1 I 'I
I.
.u611.•
li-i r
LOA.",

64.17-
10'
n,CSJ2
IOW -t02
tthI {U2.

DM
WO
CUB
. --yny
n:ky +
1•401'V
1&ARV
Wee.du
Y:
.. .. .a
Y1�Ik�
0 MIX _ 200
➢ L+J7-_ J LICOL4
L'e1J0J 0La% 001100
14 J:.: ...n_ .
m :_.014i
• 0 NW 0 C06 1 0 4303 •
,].irxq.
171342.
1t5.Ailln'
�0 SCC • C'.•."a:'0
r
-- _ €
COY,. ]t1640
m _
0:0000 r 3[400 . II
* t--
1100 ) ]CCGC
i --

0..?7Ce7

4 T
C.Q6Ef5 4[460 Y s ll e +

k I
. 404[81
M
i 6ti1231 , 0TA,
Y I
. IC803.

Y O•
C 1 1+I 4 66DIX1r
i 644 i

4.1160
a 44305
Y
- 1
A10034, • 44311
r M.
..
. Y06,A446
y
14163511 • 2-4470[4.
.M

i..yyr

4.0/110
lI023,'
4]'4114
tru¢¢11s
II
n.tr-11 sci¢Kle.
nu

3.4 1$6
16¢dW
t1611¢+r
0p1.

I¢rQ511

495-4t16
IC41331

2.190¢!-
119
32 Arrhdlectural Coaling - 2Q24
Linnallgat®d Construction On -Slur
11 30.1
walr a
Phial
.•atales
R.110
P111a
110.1
--,roles
P142,1
mss: m
MR 1.

PC 5
1llna•
:.•:"..2
NM. CO2
T0L CO2

0.4 1400
C,024
csi€ili ,.

Wm,. --
_ 1114y

41.318 Cs;Y1np 23fl41".5 :
i r
C. MEW r 116006 ]CCe1C t5i1i
w
00600
31442
r 2611443
�• 011-RCCC 0 1E09 • 12114 • 1000 1 • 04110.
0 Lenr I' • 301146 • GOOLE,
711 4401
2014411 .. 0010 +
-
Told
T716I1o1
Alm!

1.6101

7.6700..
091
114]6
.6.665!9
06 0476
A 06
4 261.4417
761.1961

6.0146
I

51.6443
01-25
Cont.

Page 218 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2335
RTC -506

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod'V2Tsion Ca1EEM;41,24163.2 Page 26 of 35
Village South Spectre Plan (Proposed) - Los ,hl7geLes-South Mast County, Strome(

3.7 Arc.I,rleclural Coaling • 21M24
Vnmitivated Cw , rl-Irustion Off -Sift
Chia: 11'12.2021 2::29 PM
RAG
'r%
CO
not
tuglree
Pill nil
binarIP
PM1C
►M1a
Tons
:)40bt•
Iss,s
4b4sarle
Kul
WLd.11 rhig-CrA
TO.
44#41c-Cd2
FabI 001.

DM
WO
czar
i
4 .149''7
9L+rf}
IlVdtV
,
.42,0,427
1'ssd.. w
rN;4kn A
O::ID . 007000
0Cc . 'J LEC0
I137UJ 00 0CL 4 030E0
0WOO a. cox. : C.0030U

9.9007 , 0[090 . 3,D
'0 if-Xt
0 aux
F 1.1� .456
I 9
4 axe . a'moo
I
o CieZ. . 3 ₹130
4 !
9:9+704 , amen . atom
. 4
i- t-
coma 5 ccst . Caro
e
— -- 4 9
a
r
r
0NCO 4®99 • 0 . ,
"_ '
P�
0+369
i 9241 . 3 O
r r
a 09117
r
121T1 015!%14 i 1 • Of=
r 94.A r
EOM', • 43315
e coo
•
: 4.129.?M
7 112 rSB
, 7
. 9.54234 .
r r
1,n1,A.. COW

9.1.1 t, I
MOM

1.2171

0.680
9d7
to d
it.3 e "
tears.-
on 5
.1.591:1.1.591:1 4.,i�8.7S4
1:139,740
S
B44410
1,127,;411
3 frliLivaLtd ConntrLicaon On•S4tst
i,_
.. .

CC
SC,c
Foult.4.

FM.3
€rurlr
PM10
P l l4
lots
fusin*
PM7.0
E.N .44
PM:.S.
4,4.12 5
'Puts
Da - CO2
1119. CC2
Sdal C"Tz
C}c4
WO
Caa '
C lty,;•r
It•m7
—
Wm}
r A
Ar:hn Ls;Wnry 736.1145•. OGo00 . Ohm . 9CffiL . 40110
i 4 w
u •
i
• .70990
1 3f4C-C
M124a.3

�• 01-E09 •T 471.5 • 114.91 • 29733.•
• 00. Ram 4[(!19 • 3aE0D • 3LEC9 • C0FG5
'A;.
w . . . .
900CL. •,1.4"a1
M1 i40I • 901 ffl,"

Told
7)65973
Al !
m

1.9101

7. 4T99.,
WI

0.0!0.0

9.09910
AMR

0.9679

0.0040
z41.44a1
7s 1.441!-I
.

9.0146
1 7t.OS 1 +9
O125
Cont

Page 219 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2336
RTC -507

Responses to Comments
CaIEE_ EMoti Wersian Ca1EEI*4t1.20t6 3.2 Page 21 of 35 Oaie: 7='12.2021 2:29 PM Village South Specofic Plan (Proposed) - Los Angetes-South Mast County, Summer 3,7 Archfleclurdl Coaling • 2024
Miticated Conglruction Off -Site
9OG
v.). I
L4
sot
tutOree
;0.04
&kin.

PINK

04.1113
Ti.M
:Ruptlre
1M7.3
gpfsamil
KC
WIQ.N r
TO.
ba C]C12
N - 632
trim {U2.

DM
WO
caaa
,.,leq.oj
q y,1y
bd[y
-ia,0•
Ydrakr w
w
eN;eke A
5 u -iii:

C _=AM
J O:NT_
in", : I.; 4.00) 0 CW6 :COOED
13W00 a. cox. : & x31

6.6m] , 4[660 e 6 D
'0 -61s1:
soca
•, 1 .1 .458
, 7 .
0 M
unoo
0CY9."
03307 • 6:6069 r 66069 . 9 MI.
e
- +--_.
603!0 06066 a 6O1100
e
.� _ •
e e
a
.4,-.
"

6.6664 4®66 • 6 y .
. . i
4+SB9
17 X81 • 7606tl • 99117 .
i ee e
12171 prspx e 1 e 6T�151
i 9C�1 a y
,
E991R1e, • 47]15
r 9G8
•
�
,.129..M
0 1121.59•
l 7

11.9234 .
led.,
-4,172,
,12..dm
- Mt*N
4A113

1.2171

4.006
947
$22V
4ltPN
464134.-
tl5d

4.]713
i.,2�8.754
2 t.131I,750
S
6-
t,127.i@7
9 4.0 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
01-25
Cont.

Page 220 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2337
RTC -508

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod e'rolorr Ca1EEMP41,2O163.2

Page 25 of 35 ends

Village South Specific Rion (Proposed) - Las AngaLes-South Mast County, Summer Odle. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
NS.
ico
SO2
rupn,e
*OA �
ergs
PMH3
PR17 9
info
ruptra ti
.5 r'l.ii3
Yt�
eu9 ta2
Crw
ecr

16.c1p
Lich}
lleempoafl BBCD 7.-..1374-1.:1;177171417,4;'@i4319'{' '6 B'''jr 7WICi;FA& a "29 7 ©31�n 0 • 77937.0 • 71 -..+
• 5{,,71B 7C ' 50 3621,.90 • 2 1M7 •
34 W

4.2 Trip Summary Irrforrn lion
4,,si
a __ T_O
4`_ . _
�n
— !.
larla'Uaa
Wash
7M1nd1Fy
1 O.inday
MT
- AinaIVMT

4.pacuroi174t. PM Rao.
• 14!. 7n •
1a4-
15444 "
5,1§,2."7
U1:15.22T
Aporri tt46.1616kiae •
a
d.a26 YO

3.In 25 _-
40i$'a5 .. j......
13,'659,0611„ ......
� 13.$55.05.5
:-,,,oral xre&Akins
. 79645
6756
3145 i,..,.,.
7411,913
7136$13
:: 'OW ri riestau-ani: a-
_
«369 M'
2513 N.
41? t:
,
. 3.413,3117.
303,539

4. N_
19240 �u-1
161.1'0
969.40 •
•4,143 +
..
445,749
.. .
• 6] 1 1 2
511. §_
163.20
. 757,411A
71)7 45S
• 5211611 •

1`x11.114
357 o4
• 111_'--1
T,112 221 - . .
i ];U kS
11 ^B+..439
5 057 2,1 f
a 52 1-
26552,45'2

4.3 Trip Type fnfc,rmatiorl
01-25
Cont
Pap221 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2338
RTC -509

Rogan& Shopping Cn»r
Responses to Comments
CaIEEM46a VeTslons CalEEMPc1,2163.2 page 29 of 35
Village Smith Specn c Ran (Proposed) - Los P61g4Les-South Mast County, Summer Tress.

Woe
Lim 900
r[.wm4-w
HZ GC
H•D or 4, NW
HW xGW
r6S D1 C -C
Oa1e: 7='12.2021 2::29 PM
H°®Sr C -NW Pf9miry [Memo Dues. by
Apartlrorn Lorr Rau
14 70
AA9r mert9 Mho Dot 14 74
r enersl CrAke EUding ; 10 64
3h7arn .14(5Abw+r * 9604 614 ! 6.90 r0a0 ?2Sd • d 37 • ,4 ... ....1 -Mot ; 10.00 ' ▪ 6 44 696 1914 41 64 1 1000 .° ; 3P. 4 r_ & Ar,Y.2CY " 10:24 AObP • 3E: ▪ 11
4 DO • • �Y 4.......�...............!

0.74 • 4024 a 19.24 a 4400 4 11
6 44 I. 690 3.104 1640 + 5 x 7+ 19 • I
':a�.ait, ��9 r.: • 10.04 " 646 " 0.46 : 12690 a 9940 " 1400 16:190 L10 043 1600 ,-7B470 1400 54 ▪ 3fi 11

4.4 Fleet M11i1[
_3,.-9 use
LL -1171 L4772 r MiW LI+D1 tM151 44410
H1D MUD
UBUS
FACT
SeuS
MH
Apanmwnls L9M N.rro ; 0,4[33567, '0044217 4209471 0110340 00140D? 9100.11s_ 671146 9633'677 000x913 00191097 0.009290 00009'1? Oros:n.79 4 }-
fi4paRmYwlsl.4441Rim : 0.543080. 0.044210 0264471 0x10304 6414932 0.01)0-332 6.621106 0.431577. 0.909D L9 0.401417 te5iso 0.000712 5mai.ai , 4 4--
ra al Offce Buick" 4543006: 40.14219 0202571 O 096596 0414036 4.004:3,2 00211688 0 03307'9' 0.03512 0.401017 0.0052116 0904792 0 X21 *A+6rrt64Dom ; 01[4.94189; 4044914 0214419: 6919394. 0014033' 000512: D.1:,1;fe 00a:167i; 0.40$i3n, 0Mi9071 00352b9: 0 400772: Ot661421 iii 0r0r11} + . Y
i
HWgl a 0543046; 4.044716 0:0 *7i 9 91020 0.4144033. 0004332 0321166 0' 0336TO 9.03:613 0.{010i7 0.1760260 0400712 0:000671 Molly Res1aumar4 t o.s434a6'_ 40443Io 07665.74 4x1636H-0014113r 60L435 Li1:1. lee 6.0107 4.442613 0011917' 0.60x2613 0644712 4 : 6543.^.149• IC, 04421C4, 0203971: 9116?W4
04149"99 D004;11:4
0 4006.'21

0.7:1106+ 0.022977+ 0 46=03`3" 047418"': 0 011x208 0400792: 0 020x921 LO Energy Detail
liotortal Energy Usti: N

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
01-26
Cont

Page 222 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2339
RTC -510

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad otslons Ca1EEMod.20163.2

Page 30 of 35 ends

Village South Spectrc Ran (Proposed) - Los , geLes-South Mast County, Summer Odle. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
IIC,
Nor
k:[f
1 5(a
NOD.

PM xi
tAceis
Fula
1•9/11tI
Imo
Fuglare
Kill
livA
PIl28
putt
Tmi
tre. =
Wbrie tG'2
Tdm Ci.2'
ttiw
mkt
cz2e
•.xe4
elk 1�
time)
r .,..-a.�a a e.res
a.sia • la Min a 0= • : a3m2 • rtaa2
` :e:seeeem,s3ae.mu; mean : 0 10 8 •Itei an
s-.
a■turel3ee a.a nt+
win
.... t."---- "
`iiau� vfl+ie' `a` a: a02'-ei c"
LR.-._4 T...an..�- ....4.. ...
.17 —ria3. 07.5 o.e :e�os.isir
2 2 r
01-25
Cont.

Page 223 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2340
RTC -511

Responses to Comments
CaIEE_EMasl Va'slon Ca1EEM4ad.2O163.2 Page 31 or 05
Village South Specoric Ran (Proposed) - Los P43gigas-South Mast County, 3i .rimer

5.2 Errergy by La rid Use - Nab44ral6as
Urlm I II LI AY:9t
Odle. 1/1212021 2:29PM
64attralb1
• Li..1
0174
Mt
c.
;.t'
I=•1-,71..•
R7ydi1-
E.r..la
PUib
Pm I41
r,..,
to i1. -r
1-'9x1 i
rwhil.l
P112 5
aM! 6
Ttllal
no- ca=
NEM-Ga2
talal 662
CJN
612.

R7t
...NMI..

I TI.I.1r
ab,1..5
Wkki}
A♦iidmae3Ln-
Ray
A '4•Inits k9d
Rani i
Go-maa1: 016as
B•ddnp
....,...i.1-
-I,�T41!vwMA 4'tu7v 6
taaxnlY AeiCri+1-'Or
k
• Molly
Re laua:e
- -
RWaln6 -
;p, ,4 ea, -45-;
• Ills) I4
Ilv
p� 84.11. 4 J lu3 o
•
f
•: ,•
v
^.J 1L
iir!
AM.
aM.

On
bC
. 34E. - v 6341-ter 41124"
DO3 Dr13
i 1] 14 131.04 I2 • 2f5211M. ffi 2 il s
001 ; 4:13 °
ORO 1M
412„4 333
G
1516811••+.

6.4 4.

D
• 35731.3
• 1-287
`
t1-
4}'656 5-.29-C
-1G35
1102 1
0 2G31
0 a 0 2ri a 4 ZUS
• 4 200 816 , .216. PG. 40507 v 4.4772 •
a , . a a
4015!. . 4.1353.
.
-.. }_.
41447
_}.
734+344
607
1 �_...
_
450)4,-
MI
.., A.,
tit?
• e4t1q.� a 8'dB4Cr
1 .

ISJ3 =3
_"..li
. 1%0'311 • 150.6811E 11101. i 277144,- •
y Y
r On a 137:
`2IYfti �.
`
. 47iD?1'
ii-__
SlilSl} a ?-n'!}i+l . 1451^1 r i4 O1}3 ,
i o a i
O10✓31I
411 fl l$Oy lr'tll •
r
• • !R 2dTT:9�14 4Q5ai ; 4441.
2 i 2 : i Y
t 41'1-11
4 467'S • 0741 • 2 dtle4.r- •
• 434

, scam 1 40355
. 0: I • 02ti41
561.1136 • 591.9416
40148 • 4-g143 •
631176.E

5.333363
i 23 1713
. 5351 16
i1-
4 OS46
41965 • 29 441.
4#996 64
i UG4�
a 4m7S nh3Ti . v 7431- 4 :n
.6697.56. 5s1: _
i
4 0117 • ft IT1f19 4
r
`*
--- 1,
• X1.614
27r44c
u:0
•
_
941;7 v
•
a

0.4101
i 1141As-
r 064
_
:
!
,
+
1 1 6'RWo-
646
. 1 VIM.
; 6C0
_
"e n
:

I. SPX,
Ikt3 ,
I b7Li!
4113
+�'�:6416
•8135.413'
_
•
s ,794@P4
b?5O4s
" Ohs ;
ft. 411113e-
601 •
a
TAW
47471
Il.mot4
1357

4.6LL49
as79Y
65182
tl. a9q.^
ti L
2 k:ga.6$
2 4.4662
4:4837
r..14a.I13d
7 of -25
Cont

Page 224 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2341
RTC -512

Responses to Comments
CnlEE_ EMnti vlersIon Ca1EEI*41,2016 3.2 Page 32 of 35
Virlage South Specrrlc Plan (Proposed) - Las Angates-South Mast County, Sunnier

5.2 Energy by Land Use - Nab1.IralGas
!Bli lin.BiB J
Odle. 1/1212021 2:20 PM
r4AurAGe
• U .r
19133
Me
c.

Bt'2
Noe,
01,da1',.
rrrYat'a
PJIO

0.110
.'.b1
r.rl.0
r'1..2 i
YWha.a11
P142 B
0M! 0
74441.4
430- GO2
942m- %a2
tdd1 1302
OR
113.

CC15y
I4,141•.

IdT1.1.,,.
.ao.y.

46.4.40. A0iam80. Ln.

Ray
AN'araals Md.
et 54
Ga-•1A Drat
rw.,...
-mlri T.a,r�.eai�
t1:0n1YRden e• d
WAA
• •Gnarly __•7.75"76.

Reg4ua3A
RWalati
;64 11 No.,
r 1 1141.'
• ]5 1'g13
, I L1142
?17390
. 4 726ed
A • I_ o
4,
•.. ,•
f
v
574116,
rrrl
il
a CC..
07,1
. 8 C.t 344i-ter344i-ter30 - v G 3
DO3 003
. 1] I B4 2 131.0452 • 2452433. 2410ris •
004 ; TM 1
13 440a
42'4 33]
G
151 Babe
2�B�tl}
6 9 }S9i- , �":
;
1'
� 4023
00241

_
. .
0 �
0 �"a&'
0 25G> 0
r
. . .
}
T• 4:So e16. 4206 040 • Sr'6Ar v 0.07"/'
: + : :
r
B0134 0.139a
r
01027
7 30130..
k4l
4 _
4 MD,-
17443
WA],
0:0
• e 4tW1.� 112.03C42-
r RJ3 eX43 9G7
Y
a- - --
d11 r�150401 l:1.�yI .277
w i MI i 003
el 2456 • 2 231 16y43 • 015131 •
. -
i w a i et
.51698
. - 17.7E
81eAr rn • u193b 1r'k>H�
r

2.1Yf�'Wsa .. EAT? :RSa* 94040 • 6MP1 •
x i 2 i i2
t 01? 4
0 4675 w 030 , 3 MIA, • , B r 0.028
r 036

. 0:83.4. . 0.2DM
• 561.1436 r [email protected]
00400 . 0-0107 •
•
*4;4;02
mama
29 rTia
0 OS43
ti
04996 04169 , 296We-Y a B 0370 • B0390 1 • 11037? 1 0330 1 Dal
a 585MSS . vylotte_
J
a 0114 *0109 I53a
y
•"__^ .
• IF251815
:
r
2 . 1443044
7�fj
• G 0•42 v
;
0=17
i OIAs-
;1l 401
: _ a
i

1.21.30e-
040
r 9 Valle,"e
; 00J
n

1.67137,2
kW 4es3
I b70fic
a
206016
s 290@P0
. b.7fXJ0o- .
w a
. .

S460rir .
077
'r..

A. Ma

0.0446
11373
416016
us7HY
II5107

44.4743
II 0710

18.735.4.3
2 6:053.063
2 0102
09570

1.4604.4134
7 6.0 Area DeFaid

6.1 Mitigation Measures Area
01-26
Cont.

Page 225 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2342
RTC -513

Responses to Comments
CalEEM9d Version Ca1EElkad•20163.2

Page 33 ends

Village South Spect c Ran (Proposed) - Los A17gaLes-South Mast County, Summer Oale. 1/1212021 2::29 PM
*kV
PhriD
mon
PHIS
Tuft
PpV
elr.tnr
Pstts
Tm1
tfn- O02
014
%lir/
1311150839
Ur1,Il0atad
N.
.. 306= ,n.0440.. 66 4439 . 9 6&94
4 7;0707+ + ..
* 00 00 4 6 i l ID
T1.6074� • I54'74. atom . tams 18..14d.IP. 04574 . osa 0 . Isms ft,. £.2 Area by SubCatego.ry
Unmitigated!
w9.3
1dG:
]
'wavy
Putr,
OF!_th
MVO
T.

Fs12J,
rasa s
',NUS
S
Otrtig
TAW
_
@u tiQ2
-. ._- o
Mam [03
' _ _�
ru4Y C'C".
. -
�
_._- t
n;36
cc,.,
Lie uY
t.tay
74Miltrtural
C 'R
Congurier .'.'OM
rh-y..tJ4
. 2;970 .
{ { {
DEMO i Qpra10 . 9C®® 00115
I
s 0MEI
vim—
a 9COM
l�
6 ODRA
6 .
'
i.

0.MT . 0D0M
I 11
6 \
. OCUW r WNW F
{* -
09000 e .
-
Heat 11.1. 10®0
p
11900 , 60J . 0OJ00

1.1660 a 1 1490
t
• 1 14170 . 4I7 1.1 L
1 3000 00 • 16.0 90. 1500606 . 9 3+ W c9 . 039 .
. Iii ' 00 ; '
1 _.....
161C409
6 w.:
.1 32 1113:,!
-
Idr a11.-.1 24780
r
GB..ck ,
62 4•M .:47407'[
i ma
04574
, 04574
_
•
(14.¢74
• 04574
• 110..6.- MA$16al :01424 .

Tog!
vven

13.rM46
@8.1450
4L61r4
�-150746
tS9T4
l
ll

1.1!074
Li174
664.1.1664.1.1 id
14666
59 11.!40.56
hail
04874

0..3n6
1i. Mal
111
01-25
Cont.

Page 226 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2343
RTC -514

Responses to Comments
calEEMod VeTsIons Ca1EEr 41,21}163.2 Page 34 or 35
Village South Specr c Ran (Proposed) - Los Angates-South Mast County, Summer €,2 Area by SubC•HtegAcy
Mi tin ateii
Oaie. 1/12.2021 2::29 PM
R113
I+...
..0
5�
IF¢orkve
NM1.D
Ed'9LL1t
P+i1O
.44 19
Taal.

Yr19M
!PM7!
Errau1
WV t,
Nh12.5
T44
bo- CA2
Mb,. CC,?
Tora Gfl!
I`
0,4
fl
COte
R'L`e1o[!u131 4. 2ACr0 1 i
a G.mW I a 000 r
1 GLIOLU 1 11 zlillC,
r 011309 r r
!
GCMG
�] rAm,
181OD Oa'.
79 •C.,..,mx1 2, 1[3.5 . ,
bt s1,11 i
Y O.UMB r a.Q4Ca ;
, G ONE .10f.Cen
• • • r G WED
H..,..1I' IcEIJ r 1i IMF 1 501+81 r aCOM
1,1471 r 11404 .
1 . .. •
I 1 14 J t1.4:43
1 1
94X19 l c&OpG OOl 1E OOGWO. 03wLW r (AUX.:, .
rn M P4 ! 1
#1524.2
I rr,l:nf-Y 2d➢Ijfi
OW 1
!

15.91% 1
I

8.1.O0 Aarytpq-.
1 tij•3
i �
4574
rI 4...
1 ! °.Y,i7+Y n 0.4.57.4 ! 146`,
1 f
I)^144600, 014.4 .

F 1 ! 1
Total 1390

11.4430
CAM
I

1.3974
L t a I
L
turn
tem
Homo
ILuB.49
M

18.111.5.1
641

11.4 .10
&Ind
•ia2112.tt
92 7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water

8.0 Waste Detail

8.1 Mitigation Measures Waste

9.0 Operational Ctfrcead
c spinere Type
rJu-.I el
iourE,Gup
_v1— 5't it
I-4:sc rmr-
LWI1F rIC
Tot
1iM.[1! Stationary l quiptylent
01-25
Cont

Page 227 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2344
RTC -515

Responses to Comments
CelEEtibad Versions Ca1EEM L201$3.2

Page 35 ends

Village South Spectrlc Plan (Proposed) - Las , gates -South Mast County, 3i .rimer Ele—P—ktEral-aadirDSIStenda Generators
LIa1e: 1='12.2021 2::29 PM
Equternsoit Type
ir 119reett,
Horse Power r Load FaM
Fuel Type
Sr!
ECILoOnIgnitTiype I Ntrntel
Heil op iero
Sow' Rating
cum Typt
User Defined Emil -men(
Equomenl Ttpe

11.0 Vegetation
O1-25-
Cont.

Page 228 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2345
RTC -516

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod VersionCa1EEMsd.Z0163.2

1.0 Project Characteristics
Paget of 35 (5aie: 1,12.2021 2.30PM
Village South Specific Plan (Proposed} - Los Angeles -South Coast Courts., later Village South Specific Plan (Proposed)
Los Angeles -South Coast: County, Winter

1.1 Land Usage
Lane ueas
Snit
L l 4=r4-4.30
Genii Office t3+eidena ti 060 1114.3401 t 1 60:s
e.
1411,Iur aveer{$ Warn l'esmumerrl ; 33500 1(10Gft111 053 15sttI 00 r
Meal 5800 ReErir M 1 67 7.�t1.p6
Quality RrtStlurard ; 6.600 ; 16CAa�'1 r fl 1D 6,60460.6060 Apeltre.43 LW RBA 215 OD CiwNllnp grin E 7 rag X25 OW 01? 7Z } t-
ApnitmenttMid 9,ee ; 973DO r 0w,ellheit gin 25.B6 975,030.0D ao i
Regent,. SeDepng Crew 5600
Floor Sea -rem err Pap. lion
a50O30D
0 1 39
56 1)3 DO

1.2 Other Project Characteristics
Urhanieetee. i_ reJ..
aerate Zee,. 5
utility car pony Southern CarpumU E4esen
CO2 Ir*orr$KJ 702.49
tb h
Wind 9Ppred Dee.'.

CIO le* molly
(lev'xiWhal

1.3 User Entered Comments & Non.Defauft Data
Frectph,allorr Free {Day*.

Opera9anal Year
JJ2a Inlarra6y
014.6.110
33 2a6
DDos
O1-25-
Cont.

Page 229 of 948 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2346
RTC -517

Responses to Comments
CalEEtibad Version Ca1EEMod.ZOIS 3.2 Page 2 of 35
Village South Spectfc Plan lProposedr - Las Angeles -South Coast Courts., Mister LJa1e: 111212121 2::34 PM
Project Characteristics • Consistent with the DEIR'e model Land Case • Soo SWAP oommont regarding residential and rotm3 kind uses Comstructlan Phase - See -SWAPE comment regarding individual construction phase lengths l ienna Consistent%nth 4he DEIR's modal See SWAPS comment regarding demolition Vehicle Trips • Saturday Mae canstslent with the DEIR's model. See SWAPE comment regarding weekday arnd'Strnday trips trio -oust -eves - Wrfoodstuwes and wood-bcrrnirng firegrtaces consesiant with the ❑EIR's modal. See SWAPE conanent regarding gas fireplaces..

Energy Use -
Conshuttion OR -road Equipment Mitigation- See SWAPE tamme tian rJoorrsirtlehon-teiatcai mitigation Area h4 Nation - See SWAP commend regarding operatonat mitigation rneasures Water Mitigation - See SWAPE comment regarding operational mitigation measures Tripe and VMT - local taro provision

01.25 Cont

Page 230 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2347
RTC -518

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad WersIan' C91EEMPL2o163.2 Page 3 or 35 Llate: V1212021 2;3Q3'N! 'Mop South S cFlel6c Plan (Proposed} - Los Atgeies-Samith Coast Cuur61y, larder CcrMen,ekrr pa 4 r_PR 1 e. 79
4 _ -;
WVthicrT.Nam gT_T38 .:8
WVt ICIBTrge �▪ ,• ST_T1i i•--`-' • 49 97 —
• ▪ ----- . 8011/44.4n4Tr'ps 3ULTR E 0
•
4ph ,011 ,,Tnp + •SUy TRILL . 5F.
r..., .. ,. 4, ivwa�o�
•, tMlehl tents SU_TRi 1 085 —® 1
.......... - •• .......-. Ir .. ....... i• • .....--•.. . [bMehkkTnp IL+_4R�• 12T fii 1 •

7.75 61919
}DN

6.16 1 15
.y
tt/dlehk:laTrp 914 174
4 WN4I-KhaI nps sU_TR
4 mNeilicrrr,p 8U_TR
4 el4114hieiThga A111_13R
a
47414111414T.7911 WD_TR :
4 97MehkleTr_a 1 WD_TR
•
4 ittrilterfideTtp. 'ND_d14 :
hi 4-4
mNehieleTrps W4p_TR
4 { 65Nein leTrrr 4YD_TR
11fIUehlcr T l pa WD_TR
i
traW s[1213,,ei Niin Ci elyk
596
66 11.05
127 15
69 05
4271!

12. tENr41U9 8? Nimterea}31y9c
,. 10/0:44343,42*
3i1 .
y NunterNwlcataylk
•
t11h4U9csrr 9mts
4 .s"
N4,n194Nkncet,N9c
4'4'DaderwarJ.Ty Yapr
4+/m,1elnre8]ay Yam
X44 5hhatkig aM'!c9,111, r
16,1Wentinnws Wotaistnue,Wcoldiss
46 75
1 25
969 69

0.04 75.21

3.25 6.39

9.63 4.13
4T
65 BB

1.64 6264

9.43 GAM

9.93 9 Da
407

03.911

2.O Emissions Summary
O1-25
Cont.

Page 231 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2348
RTC -519

Responses to Comments
CaIEE'M4ti Version CalE EI*41,2016 3.2 Page 4 ❑r 35
Village South Specific Flan (i opnaedp - Las Angeles-Setlth Coast Ceur61,, lVL iter 2,1 OveraIP Cgnstrtrutrrm it&ximum Daily Em9sstan)
Unmitiaat€d CSanstrt3utiort
O011°: 1.12.Y2r721 2:34 PM
RO3
'43.
.L
.:I -,
r:rll .,
. r.11'I
![Reuel
x.110
.h1Ia
Tv1r
FvFew
IN, I
r4t9u9
Pm:i
t•tr23
Tds
31,1- C.,O2
NLIu-CC,2
fora CA

0.4 fl
LO2,e
MCI
S.Q
•.Z,"2 • .6 ■Y4a I J• +UM • 00676
'.9.:.433.". 2 N r 202.11!6 • 8.61„�J I+,C.XJ
I, SA,.
dOrX43 •619433`x5 954 J3 -I I'i•* 0alOu r9
7 C.15
a
R64a:6a
13 I772441
67 252 002
�*
174 i4 • 95 lid -Y, , Si 3339 , 4 7965
-WO
6 92_, In 1.6341 • 94. Wl6 • 1.61`!1 , 17ir
°
'�. F.,--7—
v fACCI • •2;63534 r 1a.Q+B3t I 5-...E2 • 011332 r
• 45 • 46
Tin F, hi • L`I65M 1 3.75311 1 41762
Y
_ P _—

7.aa58 67x6! a 7,74116 • x.6711 l 47442
a • I
�581G
i�wt
44404 •ny7144,3 , 11. OD 44 r 95!5':7 • 6444rt1 •
• •
• 60 Y k
_ s
�.
,•'• ,, - •'37 x}31,50! • 65;,31 14 9972 , 4172'79
•
u 1 1
w
7 3771 444₹, r inn • DIM •• 04119 rw 1
r d 1
x eaa ,

4.444dr • 2307491 • 2147 LAI 07050 • 19004@ •
• •
• 7 Y ; 1 1
is.lnunl
237.3459

19.4416

36.9339
411196
ill SE02

2.6169
263483
$9371
-

1.>�
t $IU
41a4aa
--
1'~67!5.34
4xl
13,433 31
as
t$412
616036
6a
10 01-25
Cont

Page 232 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2349
RTC -520

Responses to Comments
CalEEM4da WeraIons Ca1EEMOd,2O163.2 Page 5 or 35 15ate: 11122021 2:30PM Village South Specific Flan 9Proposadp - Las Angeles-Sarlth C4asl Cuur61y, lVL iter

2.1 Overall Cgnsenrulurn MA.4axrrnum Daily Em9ssean}
Mitigated Cons lrueti*n
N173
N[.
b
3622
1=.r6rt`.
'61.11'.1
IEelaust
P16116 T
.61I{I
F-uy ESE
PM;
rwtws
Pm +, 1:11
1110•27
!7r!- C{1}
1101m- 037
-kW Gl2
Ott
N%10
LOie
171
� .,
.4

6.76:1 . 66 toe : J. 6611 1 0CCM
14110332 .. CA76 120.24661 C'. 6673 .,. PJ
11064_
I,XC, 1, •,;1 =..
1_A 1i-, Iiii= 00TJOu
I9 C.15
--
, t2436:C6
•11724*
i 67
, 2a4n en
6 7
a;r.Ge • 95 se+ X6335 at9Es
C9 1.6341 . 14.46F�9 , 1FJ3`li +7c�
4Tr23
--
�. Ik_tl
.1-,
0iA0Q1 •ao-xs-�
I'• �o-�6 I vsL'.2 , G➢1t14
I. y
- ------- ro-
•1.., -
ism . 2535% 1 ].75!11 141762
__ __, _-
l

7.4453 67x6! a 7761 r -37b6 I 4764•2
:
2166{1

i
LC.:O .01.7111 ar
BR

,
... 9 1 • 65;:8 14 8972 1 41,•21711
s2 x1_
u r 1
�wt w
_ 6 2171 4 44₹6 •.. . 1 MI •! DIM , 44118 0444
r e 1
x ea. .f............---,-
dICKCO a 2377
! 7
, '0 01 4 713,1 , 40048
1 I !
Mt..11NLKil
237.03511
I& -*4l1

38.113311
411695
111.2032

2.6666
2LLZ1B0
$%F6

1.E
*141610
IMO
12,35#-31
dr

11.0033:33
111
t$432
616006
171011-3AN
11 Rr14
NO.

CO
SO2
Fowl. E0101.u11
PMtli
Pl1 11111
17114
Tall,
F,J00 .r1
7732:5
E.11d•nl
PM.35
PM2.6
Ttm1l
am-ca1
41131u -E03
Taal C137, CH-1
Non
i1J11-
[
Pr L'mY
uilu
10°_4
0-w
u.011
0 iu.

U.LR1
u00
u'uu
LINO
1d[r0
6, 611
U{:]
ur.D

0.110
ij
u.56,
Redrr`u,J,

01.255
Cont

Page 233 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2350
RTC -521

Responses to Comments
CaIEEtMIod'Varalens Ca1EEMPI20163.2 Page 6 or 35
Village South Specific Flan I ProposE - Los Angeles -South Coast Cour61y, lVL iter 2,2 Overall Operational
Unrnitioated Operational
L1 a1 e: 1=' 12.•21021 2:30 P M
R47+-i

43. CO
7,10,0.0
41r,11+1
Exroust
P1410
••M I0
Tdao
FvFew
VP,121
rwt9us
Pm; 4

P?r4
n7o
LOY
Care7ary iNa7
Colo}
1'aJ x 33 5C0.4 • 10 ed 4.i , EE a43] 001:.1 . 18074 i 11It4 195 a Sd11 J. COCC, •` E. 147 Gr3. 10. 140.54 U4i?4 037910 •
l
1a 2�1I
41 Endo arum • 15.7152 • 4Ti73 r Q04 0 • 0 6162 r IOU a E.MQ • • 2.355 103 • 9 3'50 DO a IIGT.S; • o IRM' •
al ites.ma
.11
•_ . .e
i
�+S
r
-. _
_'IAoIDde�•
45237 • 48324044;9700472•
s . 1
04604
•
, `. . .

Osa" 6.3JY] 1G.dT6 •
Ir
'
73:3YJ
Ov-172
• 126B3T
•
... ,•
.41,7170U�i74PPA41•
. 06

7.146} • a₹47368me
• •
•
•re
f...I
A01,12
Pm"
26#2411
CN0r1

4.1442

2.4549
414211
11230
USN
147141
ir9456

71.47147
74425.1:
1$I
41!32
74 0744
p
47 97
Mitlgatrrd°nee:AInr I
Rene
17Co.
1}7
SW.

Fadted
men
&.+melt
4110
FI410
TOW
FTvpr+m
1•k135
EarJ•.1
Firma
FM20
TOO
ad CO2
:Jao- CO2
II Talc cot
F.}+4
M3o _I
;... .

U:,,:

Vday
&tom
Ada
- 33 5034 • '00401 1 0£.4477 I C 0044 . 1.5714 • I g074 1.507. r 15474 • i • r
0 mw • 9914858. 10140 50 • 0.4E+4
30 0 00 r
L]305
1_. :le 1 1
03 a4C6 E30
7 ..... _. _
.5T 012.00
S9
am
..... . ..

Lima.
• -, k. 2
e,
❑:LEO 97+83 4757! r 0W'0 08207 •• OSa37' • 0527.^ 4
1 1_ i 4- i
••• •0355 itta •E.30E 063• 4.10952
7 2 :
4 01532

1. ,00237 • 43 X14 . 410.4437
•
• •
r 44PA•11
. 40 MEM •
'

0.3273

40.1"•°8 • ?''.2000
r •
. 03P,T3
•
.
,
• T29
•
r
• 41,4171.0 r a: 0'..00
• 05 • 05
•
• 3.1063
•
Total
4I 10.7UA7
OF.7#F2
I827131

0. O13

40.0543

3.4540

41.471

13.356
24301

44.7340
00[49
TAI,#2137
41/
7474A22.17•
0e
211417
114U2
74 4OT44
+It
01-25
Cont.

Page 234 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2351
RTC -522

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Varglons Ca1EEMcad.20IS3.2
Pe 7of35
➢ Mtge South SpeolHo Plan lProposed - Los Angeles-Soxith Coast County, Wintar (Sale: V1222O21 2.30PM
Fvo
nor
G12
5122.2
F`gi11Ab
OM Ell
E,'nd93?l
PE11r1
ny 14
T,.,,
Fu rl,.n -
PMa-5
E'el'a.IF,
4,1"1..i

1.1122
Tnld
Ir1 - 002
Ifille-C,02 I
T9Til CO2
Ghl
NM
12@N
M1r cal
E00

00.1 0.00
}.00
0"IC
n."i'o
.-
0-0
n,n„

2..u-i,
a09
4-X,
0 .DD

0.0d
0 E

0.09 rrTi1Pc Dm
30 Gonstrractron Detail
L_cnstrurtloti Phasq
� c
a1.

Pliws Nuns
Filrw rrnu I SU R Offte
End Pate 'Mari Cwo
1 MO.
pl-, 9e _- 4;oIriprl
'::ann'bon .11k mnuh�n 4ri s(' 9 l IOnli.+15.`1 ' A,
:541r Prxpeaba,' plift Pm -puma) d ra3/1 Ci 11 02.T 11421 21 0 l'-'''' 20,. ----.FGratSn - .Stating iitiCi202t 2.12.11.=•L 2 1 61 #.:
• s '13lendt y,GH/tOtrls�ldl &tltlMp Cnnshnic3rwn • .-Y 1l1^1�'022 121.12!3023 . 5t 5iFI?:
5 .P¢41nit .PireinFl 112M .2022 1+3CP2t2 _ .. 5: - -15t ...... s rdernrest60I CA 1.I :A.r2114t![ru-2.o GWilhy :tral.r17,2i ;3'1 N1.4':.4 s. 35.

Acres of G rading {Site Preparation PFias4 0
Acres 4f Grading (Grading Phase). 112,4
Aores of Paring: 0
Residential Indoor; 2,025,000: Residential Outdoor: 576,000: Non -Residential Indoor: 325.490, Non-Ree lontial Outdoor: 11.]6.800; Striped Parking Area: 0 (Architectural Coating — soft)
OfrRpad Evuipment

01.-25
Cont

Page 235 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2352
RTC -523

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod'VeraIan Ca1EEMdcl.2Of63.2 Faga S of 35 LJale: 111212021 2:30 PM 11141age South Specific Flan (Proposed], - Las Angeles-Salrth Coasl Cuurty, larder PREic Hamt
I
01livid Et1u!prne^tl Type
Amount
Usage Irieun
Flax, newer
Lrred Facmr
Eremanaan
:47nrceseerineuvr4I Sawa
+ 1
a 00
51:

X773
••• A••• a+,............•... . E. ----e a..... ..:.
nem • ENSMII
•__
-�. ......
...
a 041:
. .....
..
153:
(1.39

Llimortion
:FIU rrind ilnl7rs•.••
*
fou.,
247:

J4C
,Slbflapala#irna
-Y±�.ruenrTbEaibGrerJr.
1,
A001
14'7
04s
Sde fiitraietlmn
-Tract�edLoadaal9mclEloai
-__ _ 4
E98.
r.
a 37
Saming
:E.440alcrs
i 7
EAoq
t13 ....
^a 3@

l.__.._ ....... �...... �_._-
�—�'
-
1 @!]91 97.
4rai9p
.Gistiet
Dail
GratEtty
:0,11.4..., rind ooteie
}_—.._�___._.___ 1
70 7.
_.._,•

6.49 *
n _.

E7.

Gra
:rrearra1Leseers Beelerces
0 3
Burton Cana9alttiun •
•Cranes
I 1
' . i;
221:
,g. 29
P
P..
_
_.. .,...�.._�___
BIIIIoi{g GerratucW n
F:In rl
a.!
..'
03: .0200
I
I
I,-
I
I
L
- ,...,,.
-------. ,
r 1
-
. _
0a•
€l illj..g Cureuarcuon
Warns- rlor Stts
alra
r-----------------
I.------------------...... .
_ _ . .. _ I
•
....-. -
Builanp Cci7s uctgn
..
•TrectoterLeadera.Backl es
— —
I 3.
....... .,
-
` G,
.

ET.
.�..... ..
1}.37
I
I---
_ _ _ _
__ __. _
p
--- - _
L7ullars; Carlseuctlnn
:Welders
1 BOO:

48. N:4@
Pa41n i
•Pr+ws
:
99Oy
1301
a 4
.........._,._
._d . .. .
t...�..._..._--- ....

Paving
;Pavinp Eauprnanf
2 .

8.901--73 :-
sJ. 36
cif
.
•
Fang
844444
2 e y7tl3
{1Qi
G13Q
'AIVIECIthl nil a4ing
'!Ahr Compeoesenr

1. 6 ,
.
_.••_•••�-#.A9
Trills and MT
471-26
Cont.

Page 236 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2353
RTC -524

Responses to Comments
CalEEM001 VeTsIons Ca1EEI*41,20163.2 Page 9 of 35 bale: 7='122021 2.30 Village South Spectro Plan PProposadl - Los Angeles -South Caasl Courty, l+J1T1tar Ptmse Nitre
47RaY If Etpril reel
CALMS
vrt;ikrr Trop
Alunleel
Vendor Tt4
liwnt5er
Okrnbell
wiling rryp
'W,Il . Tnlp
LLrr�i
YrYrcr T1p
Length
e1r•,Ilho Trip
Length
Wh5111ly +i1!htle
c,es3
ti' 11 Heutlilg
varrrr Calm Vahoe Clay.

Cemomon
Sts P•cyxae.trn • 1. JS'
1-- -- -- 1
t-----} I
i Eid@9 og t.+Srklinznin • 9. 801.091
P7Y1312 F. 1'3 00r
II I 1
ATIAp[G1raI Coating : 1• ream;
v

3.1 Mitigation Measures Construction

3.2 Demolition - 26121
unntrticaten Construetion On -5d
IS. r 000 1.:.y W 1900
I>3-.-
•� r97
'43 DJ'
O 00
a DO+ 1909e ego 3J-47iLD_VIox lH?T Qeiix IttHDT

0.0P} 19.00 6901 20.WiLC_ki•r. '1- �+,. 1 HHDT

0.00+ 19041 E170. 20.09 rLD'-tiik �Fi•- kn�.. IHHDT
f?3 131 09' 191 la as Lf? ,'1�las It5177 MIA HH@T
1 O 00 0 001 10.00: e -g0" 2O. 0:111.0_%4 ,vr. hiLK 'dltiiJr 403
HOE
C;•O
Sd7
FeriiIr.N
PM 44
1=Y7:•1t,i }7
4181rt 097
St1al LCIA1
FA4'
M;0
ClQ!
_.i,.-3r
h7.y ,
hid
r•..3n... [614.1
•L11.R.4)
'3. 5074_.# 44044 3]]74 ; P$4 4 0 0094 0 `,.,rk
i 13.33511
+7 coo
317
5104,-.
3'4417 +
31 Y+49
• 4 'AI
1X47
15513
•
1�-f1r • 1.11-
• 3 747 441
13747 I.
• 11.45 +
.3774
T4..11
L1651

11.4407
7f,5050
t.fl!ffi

7.3075
13§13

5.45557

6.5004
1,4111
t941p
6 3,74794+1
4 3747,yµ
0 f. rf4
].,771L3f7
4 O1-25
Cont

Page 257 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2354
RTC -525

Responses to Comments
CalEEM9di WersIans Ca1EElfcad.20163.2 Pape 10 of 05 Oale 1;122021 2 3a;}t M Village South Specific Flan (Proposal* - La's Angeles -South Coast Courts., lVL iter 3,2 Demolition - 2021
Unmitigated Construction Qrr-116
110G
Nh..
co
003
IruQtrxr
4X11•.7
t.Irr-14
1>f.11r
MI I7
Il..
fu64,,e
6'13_'.,
t<A1A¢4
6%.12•..
e"I
fl--X72
MI6- CCI.3lrthI
otn
c}.4
M2G1
OG,
-lsJth$
1'ar•tlrl
1 01204 a14d
1L702
J 711•'
9295W .J IL420 • 02741,
I._ ':' 707.3 • OJ.c•'.+
•1.3!10 b"11 1 2EV.II5,5• 0 ]pfyr
! 5
_ ' _,
.;,J,;r9
flu. o
43[00 •. 047]G
e
34 h
soar.
0ttaiG
coax •00199 , 4f)Dii
•
--- -4 1
_
G_:e'A 7C170G . C
e
y t..f—,,.,:
. sum 9.[490 07LY{
_ 1-- -
Water . d19523
.

MOW
9769]
111GGk-
0C.q.

5.1111 Ii OOOLlr •
F 1'Ai 1
r

4.115,1
44343
41400.•
t 094
• 40311
,,....=y
• 1111.474E
r
1104191 • 3.3v,...e
. IT.P.

3.4,r
11135

1.4105b
13143
au,14

0.531,0
atr1a7
n wq

5.#3i
310171
dkN#
imams
]
#.sta,a$11�0-Il
2 I
19#t.STt
1 Ml Ina Ltd Construction On•SIL
,y.

Val
Fuotrw
Fly, -,0
Miwtip
R•110
PAl 10
Tufo
+- 0,1i.c
P4 5
r... ,.

F'.5,"_
PC 5
!rns
t .:..7.,_,
1164 CO2.
relli CO3
O-4
wo
CG..,
r,ren+.. Dnt
00 R0
[0
-
330`# CI GOO • 33074 • 11.6630
w
•
RISME • LL•CEE.
013250
3CtiiG
3774317
•1
4tw '• • ],.1-•O
. •
.'t '47: 1: 50 • ] cc
•
1 Set] 1.iiS
r • •
•

1.4411 14111
•
0❑4CG .. 2.74?.i..44. 37-4 044• 17644. +
e 6 , 4
Told
!.1551
It4.40/
__

21.5000
._
9:031A
__

3.3024

1.14413
;:ssea
- -
11606E
_.

1.4411
iM1!

9.Q0f0
_
b; ]47.6}+1
_ 1
&77r.B41
I1
r 05,14
Y
5/M21Y'
i

01.25 Cont

Page 238 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2355
RTC -526

Responses to Comments
CalEEM4ti Version' Ca1EEM L2 IS3.2 page 11 or 35 (sale: 1]122021 2 JO Pi41 Village South Specific Flan (irapasedi - Las Angeles-Sat&th Coast Cuurt1y, lVL iter

3.2 Demolition - 2021
Jwtitioated Construction Oif51tc

90.7,
,,
cfJ
0P[2
TuOboe
4X11 •.1
trr.a14
WI r
PRI I1
I ,..0
Tagil,
MC .,
t<A1A¢4
M.15 •..

F. 1,'
f - CX.,2
NC I. d2
lrthI cdl2
cim
wa
OG .
t
-ukim
1'sstlrl
i. e
}}
J I?L.e 4IL'•i
I L•J12
J 4.111 I:
03753 .J IL42C • 02741,
I._ ':' 707.3 • EOM.,
•1.x191Y11 12,3.155 . 0 79fJp
5 5
' ' _,
_;,J,;rC
flu. ,.,k,
52500 •. awes
F
suer.

3.1CCCr

9.730} :7 WE , 4=
•
--- -4 1
0_:cx) 3CCOG . C
e
t 1.x,4..,.,:
a 6.9098 i aMC : 0-;36.34:
_ 4-- -
Metter .
5995
• MOW
t
CI 3541.1
111GGk-.
3(S

0.1111 • 590IX]r •
i 931 a
•

4.115!
54342

AMOK.

I. 094
• 4591
,,....=1
• 115#79'
r
1154521 • 5.av,...e
953

9.ai 1
Uj
L
i.4y60

1.i1ai
Bu d

9.1 g10
fl911+
1?(MI
d.#sL
417#
4N#
119ta3
7 1.]�Q,#t1
2 �B pl1
19#t.fi7G
#

3.3 Site Preparation - 2021
Unmitigated Cunstructtmi, Ott -Silt.
-
s _
542
FUPbw
Fly, -,0
,chat r
Mlle
PRA la
Tide
+-u41i.c
RF',9
r�Citio.

ReT2a
PC 5
Tins
t :,:"..2
t10+. CO2.
"%1J CO2
O4
.0:2
CC -24
r,rrene.. D,nt
OTI R[90
- '80653 , 0C•3OC • 19 OEM • 5.4 i. OLCBL • Ld3P7
!•
• •
x0000
3,-9:5
3 715 a5F
-
2C4 I 6 • I &WO
.13= • 49 x.971 • 2'4 154 1 3 • 7 3L • 7 74-05 t:ffi
•
. . • • r e •
• ] 690 55 .E@E 6 3 655 • 11u2G
e 9 , 9 •
Toltl
7_91:52
10:.4971

81.1513

9.1540
187933

1.0,415
80110r

9.9334
L4900
1t4P14

3.955!490
7944.050
-, 21}1!3

3.ftbA4F
0125
Cont
Page239 cif 548 In Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2356
RTC -527

Responses to Comments
CalEEMoti WersIan Ca1EEMsd.201S 3.2 Page 12 of 35 f5ate: 1112,21)21 2:3O PM Village South Specific Flan (iraposedi - Las Argeies-Soxlth Coast Cuur61y, Vardar 3,3 Site Preparation • 2021
IJnntitiaaled Construction Off -Site
90,7,
411-4 I
CO
sot
ruglree
DM dl

3.Yaa1V
mils
owns
limo
Fisiori '
Put,s
am...

P§123
W1Q.N r
TO
b. CC12
N$, LCE2
1EthI Cur.

DM
WO
cza
i
,..,leq.'r
14Mfy
tell,
-12.1.'51
ue,alr .
semi]
Lczr
.3 CODE • a LIMO • oWO) aCam • COOED • BMX a(ODE • aom(

13.9W9 I amm 1 09(013
r1st
04Cr,4
. 1M9 .9
1st klAn,
aunu
9'sr4
ac a9 : saws . 99903 + ama9 , as : DOOM Scam • c.axa
t(. i_ _. __. 1. _._ _ _t __. . -1
• 979 F7 {1.03013 . 9.3030 4 .
.. ,,. .. a
'•N; 5.A5±
3 01-25
cont

Page 240 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2357
RTC -528

Responses to Comments
CalEEMeti VeroIons Ca1EEM L2 IS 3.2 page 13 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposal:4 - Las Angeles -South Coast Courts., Airrtar 3,3 Site Pre paralton -2021
Mitigated Construction Off -51e
Onto. 1=12.2021 2.34 PMt
AQu
Wfl,
c4
sot
rugtree
IN dl
&m14
win
Ionia
1,hM
tutu.

R 4 1
ern..

P§A23
Pal.N r
1n1
i'1ia- CrJ2
N$te-LC2
trim 001.

DM
WO
coo
l
,.,leq.'7
r4ealy
hell,
-1iJL'4
.. Ydrakr
41 0;<km
aiscm
c czr
a cam . 4 EMI, • B moo a cum • 4 nm . m4M7 4.CIDG : coo

4. UW7 I a.M44 1 7 i000 :
n MUG
• a
F 11744_
tirt66dc8+
. a MOD
C�s'y.4�
al: u . saw . 44.104 • aman , a . 64o3n 1COX •_L.

1.C. i_ _. __. .t. _._ _ _• --- - . { #
••e awe aCa46 • UMW,

1.J am
Q4+119
4+174.! -• 1.i113611s- •
"y 493 •
a 1706 P 116• •
G.134P • ' 0934a
DA
+4YSWa 40711.

Cq
..,... -. • g2.5!11F
,
13254+IQ
�gP,ta. ,
ON r
1 _ --
arruq
l 4.061#
411'•51
11,100.

OM
sins
claw,
4011
son
14R}1ts
testa.-
OM
u.41t4
112.5540
Ilt511,M4
aUrear.-
On
Id Grading - 2021
Unrnitlgatod Construction On -Sate
A1X
le,.
cc
s0c
NOM
I.M.-0
€ruur
Rolle
MA I4
lane
FAO.*
Fr17.B
E4 -arm
R,12:'
1a,L' 5
4rAr
all CO2
t16a CO2
SdaI L0i
CFc4
WO
COZA '
I
Camay
R.Aa ,
wan
-
,.g.+.. Od1[ -
R.=
OR. -R.=
w
• • A 0Q44
44 AIMS , 34d • lI FM
1 •
3 MEd s 1C{QI • 3`l3Gi
•
• C
3 Call
, 6 053 513
-1
a IJ13

4.3 {' • X. BI BS • 7.315'6• • : 151653 1 131.
6 r • • r e
T
I B s 18356
•
• axe, ay7 A [07 11;3 • 1 &US +
n 4 , d r :

Told
-4.1912
463239
[email protected]

0.46314
!,6731

1.441213
'UMW'UMW 5463
11 t6264

4.4730
4,.447_@4{
IS
444a
+
5 0355.41.3
01-25
Cont.

Page 241 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2358
RTC -529

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMori Vnrnlons Ca1EEM L2Ot63.2 Pape 14 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposed.- Los Argelos-Soxlth Coast Court.), larder

3.4 Grading - 2021
Unmitigated Construction Off-S1lp
Onto. V1212O21 2 3 } t M
BAG
Nd.
co
5r[2
r; 0e
RHO .0
ter am
WI
PR111
1,,..0
Iu04r,
M1_'.,
t<A1A¢4
6%.1T•..
ra l
fl-- 47,C,I2
MI6- CC1.2
Sr dl orn
5244
too
CGS
-ukim
1'sstlar
WNIcef

1. o M • c =ae• • o G077 • 9 MW • O x4703 ,J La% .0 XC
r n.:
i..... .
. :_ �_m
O.IMDJ o mm . 7 7733 .
..•_zi
... 17 X*
11: 4761'
a a 9a . 7 33LG a 937L' . 13001 • 941.3 • 34479 , 9
M 1- — 3 -1- - t-- 4- _ --I-
G34P3
3 CGOC
4 #

4.?717gi

c.uma i ouzo . ll � i{
-- 1
.
. 0.5701
M
i 4416:

Y 1
. 06234
a 14✓lOOr •
Y sk}

7.1531
:
r •. 2r110e- •
can i

9.1334

0.9174
11rOae • 44415
f ^
• x43.14]
1 147.3143 • 4.4100
•? 1 1
F
sopa
?07110
9 -91St
46241
t4039.-
1101
81521

1.2x44,
403
•4-4#}I
1 01414

1.1799.-
699
46416 I
•147,2143
147.2143
44500,
167
14 7.11154
Mil Ina Led Conntruction On•Srt
s _

10.1 Fu44w
43,IW
1;h ers

1.1.410
1'0.113
Tufo
+-u41i.c
P4 5
E. ...

MR
PC 5
illna•
t :,32
t16a COZ•
"%1J CJ' a
O-4
wo
= ..M
--_
t,r•n+.4 Dnt
01 Ram
- 8._9?35 • 31999 • 8 E73
1 t
r •
35,165 3Cffit . 3.5]IK
•
0133130
:I ,....X.::
• 505E 540
4 + I.,,: • 4131 i' • M 1.785 • 7.515'6• • 15863 i 7fi
. • r • • r e
T

I EMS I EMS
•
7 ❑I}7L a 0.017 713 9 007 .7;3 • 1 P4Td +
n 1 , 1 . n i
Told

4.1412
41,3059
:4.6764

4.9637•
tee

1.4433
t7.614rr
15P15

1.1255

9.4334

7.9404.

4.777_@41
i
194x.043
4 114711
5,063.113
4 01.25
Cont
Page242 of 548 In Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2359
RTC -530

Responses to Comments
CalEEMataVersions Cj1EEl, L2O1O3.2 Page 15 of 05 t5 ate: 1112x2O212:3OPM Village South Specific Flan (iropaaedi - La's Angeles -South Coast Court's., Miter

3.4 Grading - 2021
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
AQu
NO,
C4
sot
ruglree
PIAv1
1!.614a,Y
Pace
PM Ill
rur,1
ku PP'2'
PIGS
66!,1P1
Ph423
Palik r
TO.

El. C
NEW- G 2
1'a11I 002.

DM
WO
coo
6 4.,ieq°oy
t6341y
tell,
,
-Ia=_a se=
.
ec-xr
aCOW • Qmm P • tm) grad • Qaam
some. .ome. • CoMu
:DD OCHEB000 OCHE : Q3033
r, st.
sores
+ 11 , autd
117.1e¢4'
1'endrl a MOD
; -
EWOG
- — i
aMCC • a CWOO • acme atom
-a- - 1-- 4- _ - 4-
60000 1C i • COXIDgi
#
, sumo OUZO . exec +
4 AI 4'Wolter
. ELME
0Q463 4676+1
• 11✓lOOr •
r'
01521 r ^. a. NIA— Q 1534
61444
, 1410a, • 44415
•
• r47.2QV,]
1+17.3643 • 4.4290.-
lenrti - —_41a700
saw
E.MI
t4i99.,
501
81521
�1.2'100r
OM
•4-4416 '
demi

4.1700.-
MI
46415 I
547,21143
117.2P43
4450E,
rAl

31.4 Grading - 2022
Unmitigated Constructlon tan -Sala
,G
•va
CC
Sac
RPQ1oa.

PM.0
•EduPs'
Rolle
Pqi IQ
lane
futpt,*
RAVE
E;Sa•m

8.12!'
pr,1y5
4rAr
Da - CO2
141i. c02
SdaI c"T3
Gc4
WO
C73a '
cal ypv,
r a.y i
Wm}
F.ra+n Dnt
ildcoa
i i. 6&'.33 I QtldW b_a'TS3 • 35➢6i s 1[{4{• 3`ldGi
w r s w w c
• • • •
30QR0
:, f4CE
S VEVi C15
5:'Li6
• 3885.4,
7ii 0515 I Pe1EC,
•
453.4
1634P
Iai'i41
• iS7+41
aQ,C„AIL,
5014 41B
1eY-1C +
a
•
'
1d11
_—
1'A45
366!}5
__
75L 12413
-
Q.OR9
�_-
66T3A
-

1.6314

40.30!4
35%9
-

1.5641
610116
4,911h
5 6011A10
-- 5
F6a-4i
�_..
_
G944.015�
9 01-25
Cont.

Page 243 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2360
RTC -531

Responses to Comments
CaIEEtAeti Vnrslons CalEENtscl,20163.2 page 16 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Praposecti - Las Angeles -South Coast Court..), later

3.4 Grading -2022
Vninitiaated Construction Off-S11p
LJ ate: V1212021 2.341' N!
91S.7fi
NOr.
co
not
Puptree
;Nine
&Katt
win
►M I E
lf9M
tuptrz
ne;.i
ilxaim
eid2s
rffi2.9 r
TO.
ha CC12
14ft- Cd2
trim 002.

DM
WO
Cur
i

4.,ieq°'7
tLMfY
tell,
�
-I2._11'49
El
.. Ydrar .
_...
aeon]
L))
a COW • BERM • EORCra Bum • 0001:6
a u0no a.Cme • Corr,
C, IMO i OCHE : E 3033
r i1rt
0 000C
•, 147227, 9
i
0MOD
t-
0,ay4,
-
au& • a • Pnoco • amen , a2.
- - - •- '1-
_
60050 BCCGi • C.ar7
- -{•
• NUM amain • UMW • .
-. _
-.. !-
•N;9ke . ad096
;
0x1117
t
! I- 3.
x4061 Id3e9r • K'.1501
e OL6 •
a ^. e3:&'}r 01531
• 090 y

0.047<
• 10070.+ 44415
:
-`• r42. tiI
•
142,22.19,
i
...e.X0e
r KIP? i
9,nw
0{5185

0.84f0
44151
tl;O -
006

0.9021
two.-
CM

0.ista
nttsli
two.--
0448
un119
442.1447
142.1207
MOW-
WS
ilY:72nr
i•ti Liva Ltd Construction On •Sf t�
•...-
CC
SGc
F f•e.

Fn
€ruur
Rolle
Phi I0
lane
Fusin..

RC
E.N.a
R•12:'
1+42.2 5
Auu
Da - CO2
9113. CCl2
Tdal LOi
CI- 4
441'1
G07m
cave,
140.y
Wm}
—
F.ra+n Dnt
ildetO
- i • 3 AIMS . ODOM • e_E7 • 3MEd s acme. • 3`ldGi
i s w w
• • •
• 0CMG
7, CCa
•fiUN1 CIS
�6860.e151
...1 1- • 3885.4 • • AG15 • PSKdY• 1 E344 19340 Ia5'i91 • iS7+41 •
emS aQ,C11 AIL, 501f min
1Ed47
•
Tale!
1'lad6
-
366!}5
_
80497'
_

0.17609
__
6623A
_

1.63.44 40.30!4
45%9

1.91811
61046

7.Si000
4,01 t4
i 9
6019Aie
°
Fiq-4i
�
6 Q1-25
Cont

Page 244 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2361
RTC -532

Responses to Comments
CalEEMed VumIons Ca1EE1,ted20103.2 page 17ot35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposed. - Los Angeles -South Coast Court.., larder

3.4 Grading - 2022
Mitigated Construction Off -Sits
L1ate. 1=12.2021 2.343t M
IOU
Va
C-0
M[2
A1gTbrt
4X11•.1
two's,.

P1.11r
PA I1
I...

Auipwe
MC.,
t1JAELS
M%.IT-.

F"1
fl — XJ2
NC I. C2
lrthI orn
ciao
M2G1
CGS
.Is_im
1'sstlll
a
c =ae,
a CMG . a MW ; DIM) J DU u XCL
L 3_4.,
4444,
•_ a=m

0.1167] ahem . a aom •

...x�
,]XVI
, 142i2]�'
ammo
}
C.:.:•.,,
I-
aCOW : a 1100 . mnoco . ocean , at
S 1 1 -I
6 -IMO
3C00C
-
4 4

4.37CO
T

7.IPIE1ii 4568 (LOOM +
- k 1 w
- al
Worker . 0.4990
w
i 69411 , 04401
! 1
e I 4777r . m. 1521
! 4C4 .
..239.3. •
090 i

0.1334

5.9174
. 131134, . 44415
f rC} -
•
.,.
. r42. tzar
.
1+12',747 ,, .C17
I 1
4 7r e. 1
Y 444 .
r,,i,i
4444M
5 44 45
44 451
t43O -
04 5.7041

1. 21(0.,
CM
4404
[4 Mt

1.1455.-
4:0
[4415
442.1447
142,IZCT
4,1494,,
OM
CI 2.2201

3.8 Building Construction - 2022
Unmitigated Canslructtnti, On -Site
s_

50.1 FUPSw
R]
malt.

Ft211C
74119
Te;e
+-u41i.c
912 5
F�.*,tio.

MR
P'.L+5
Arts
t __2
NB. CO2.

"%1J CO2
O.4
wo
'
CMNoar
Wail,,
-
Wm}
O5.Rsatl
- I :.e
,, IC 3E2.
. 73366 .

OWE • 5fD,'C- •
�
'. +t•._
y _
Da33?
244]33.
33I3E .
25€45!2•
2 Tama

1.7[083
15:fi15.6
1E3834
ELM..
5e8Ir9
9 BM,
57FY2
117112
2,554.393
II
2561.595
9 45176
O1-25

Page 245 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2362
RTC -533

Responses to Comments
CalEEM¢ta Werslan' Ca1EEI*41,21yfv 3.2 page 15 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposal:4 - Las Angeles -South Coast Courts., later

3.$ BulildingConsiruction -2n22
IJntntitiaaled Coniuuetien Off -Sift
Lime. 1='12.2021 2.34i Mt
94�_
�r._.-.

CO
51[2
Pugfrre
WV •,0
PA1r'
1 blears
MA I ¢
TAW
Fuel6.t•
842.5
CI!mid
PhRS
PlatS.t
TOO
t1r C0.2MEG-0d2
F:ml {U2.

DM WO CllZ:
i
,.:.eq"Y
RMf.
11,414
-1iJL'y1
1'ssdll
r
m..0Cm . ¢6380 1 .7¢U¢¢ . 8»OO) 1 ¢fy]oa aum 1 nersn
1 ¢ago 7.rmc. : r;axrt
G.Uety] OCHE exno
nr,>aGc
,17815028
1 0
4 t •
1 0494418
CI AMA 11-57 • 3EMS • 78364 • 08155 OUSE • 88412
a Y [ 1
e .

F 3 S
¢.7830 70.-45 • 92a51
w e
e
•3..798 WS 3.7 ..5E1175• 8 W •
a Y e
B 8
'�.'.Ne 2E5a1•
egp'YT
b 1
Y 1
fli.7t88
1144tr
tl Y
V 1
ti1U3
f �c1a7 • n1+n
tl
• ,elay
Y
# ',Nit.' 'obi:
•
W4636
A
98PB:995,
{

9.ve5₹ •
: 1
*s44r53an

1.rna
x'7w'.1
1Lt150
23,21DA
tong
toc
BAIA4
I Meg

1.8 40314
10191k
4;4e911A1
A
1A*L 11l
A
C1.7F1f

1.11 Liva Led Construction On •SI tt
sc'
waaoa.

1.M.9
€7daats
PM10
MA I7
lane
-Fusin.*
PM2,9
E;sa.m
PM: ,5
1'64' 5
4rAr
Etn CO2
1119. CO0
S]AI C,"TO
J.4
WO
_ ,.,
Gawp nu, v
► elp
—

1.1m}
O¢.Rsati
I :A:
r IC 3E]_
.- -
. .
83308

,]iWC • 6B�3i. .
+t•._

. '.,_
y
'-° - - .' 733.
3313E +
ri,441

1.7[183

14.5156,
1E3834

8.8788
88888
8BM,
8702
117112
41?388
2,554353
8 2451.595
8 8.51.70
25€48!2
2 01-25
Cont

Page 246 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2363
RTC -534

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMata ilerslanCa1EEMod,20163.2 Page 19 of 35 Crate: 111212021 2:30 PM Village South Specific Flan (iropasedp - Las Angeles -South Coast Caurey, Motor

3.6 Building Consiructlon - 2022
Mitioateci Construction Off -Site
BOG
woo
ca
scat
ruglr;e
IV+0
1&Kara
Pfd1G
1•4111:1- fuol�e
Tu
1~42.5
feel
P44C1.5
P1r5.b
TAO
t7e-
MEG- cd2
smlcU2.

DM
MX]
Cum
-IaJl'y7 •1•39M a ¢67]0 i OCCe1G a BBOW a Dd47O7 OCOMO a 9aSO D7000 acox. a 96,370

6. MOO , 9.11190 Y aatm 1
:.. s...
i
1's+dor 04264 ,119 73 32iA9 • alt~&+ • 891.5 • OUSE • 0 1141 r e r a [ e
� — - 't S - - -

6.21430 76-5 • ai
w 4
6 _ T
n7..798a75 ].T�r.H7`5. BMW' •
a
t 7
' ..
- -- • _ �'.
414<ker ;; E5a1•
,3
i 4@5rT
.
• 114.44288
a a95te �

9.#193 •
--
0 0493
Q. 1425
E- 1,5IQ4
# %r,?L7+ 1661:
• 7 MIT e»

9.8PB.996
• H"9E5₹
1 n -
8§t61
1,1.-M I
tins
stole
TAgi1;
ad₹49

7.r 'h9
',AIM
rtCiWu
+81af
oitisfe
A
tAN,445i
A

4.?Fllf
a nail.

3.5 Building Construction - 2023
Linnkiti{ at4ed Construction On -Sets
v
Su'c
FUPf.p.

PM.D
f a4s
PM10
P l Id
lane
Fusin*
PICr7
Ei#a a
P1ai2!5
pr,1.' }
4411
B-0 002
4419. CC12
Trial C,02
Cic4
WO
= ,.e
may
b.'mp
-- - -
lAmep
O9.Rsall
I a _I.
+39+D .
e
IC 3448
• 63260 a
--
0Ea, Ort47 •
e -.
_ Lx
_"..

MMD•
3fA76I t _
Taal
1 537E

14.3&41

16.24111

9.11298

9.E491.
aE4k➢
9E59J

9.958.d
2,555299
8 2355.2811
a
D 7079
2'336495
e
01-25
Cont

Page 247 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2364
RTC -535

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod'derolon' Ca1EEMud,2O163.2 Page 20 of 35 15ate: 1112.2021 2:3OPM Village South Specific Flan (iroposedt - Los Angeles-Soxlth Coast Courts., larder

3.5 Building Conslructwn - 21323
IJntntitiaaled Cons.uuctien Off-$iki

94._
,r._.-.

CO
56[2
ruvhwe
IN dl
#_.mean.

PM1b
MOW
't•1d
kD01F2
MKJ:5
1t�65av1
Me 3
Pans r
TO.
ha CO2
N60-Cd2
'3,0134i 003
DM
WO
coo
i

4.,ieq°=y
1LMfY
14011,
-1iJL'y#
.. • r
tedeal
0ri7m • 6.1770 i a COX • a OfdP,
L' WO) a Ce]DD • d 00136
D0.300 a fQ1G. : 381120

0. U670
9 400 : D'3[no :

6 i1LVlY
-- •-�
35'S Gat
5447 a:7=
43163 . 6:3125 . 33771 . 33543 3'3156
r a 642 • 1301:

D.2 55 a.0i4B • a2' 2
•�•3.3014Y
Y
36`1.346• a3/aE
'•N:At 5
i 150!3 .
17, UZIr 033613
6413.2
• 3GI r4 • 11141, • 1.1167 1041 • 16604
•--i
•0403. MP
531!,7 NI . Ill I.:- ,
1„.,
1 r
42 ,
1'IATt14

71.2541
4,t+Y12
' 3AY,�M 1
41i*1l

7.foat

1.47ta
j_
48167
g644
4,, t•tte
�P.156,444
1 8}514-
I_
o{w, 045
MiLivated Construction On•Seta;
v
sc'
P0Pho1.

PMh3
€Jdaa4a
PM10
Pld 10
Iota
-3-40.4
PI '.0
Ei#aum
P•12!'
Fon 5
4rAr
B-0 002

1.03. CO2
SdaI ."32
CJ.4
WO
_ ,.,
may
E.'eap
-- - —
klar,
OB.Rsati
la -1.
433,3 .

IC 2,,a
• 63263 •
,33404 33:-6.7 .
1 1'
_.x
e1X -5
MMID
; 3fA°D
t _
.:ra 4y:,
Tidal
1522E
I

14.3B41
1E2443

0.0234--
6340
13443
66544
II 1.314
038300
2,55§203
a
2355.230
a
D DOTS
2'370.4W
P
01-25
Cont

Page 248 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2365
RTC -536

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMnti VaraIans Ca1EEMiltl.ZOi63.2 Page 21 or 35 sate: 111212O21 2.35}PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Angeles-Samtth Caasl Cuurty, larder

3.$ Building Consiructton - 2423
Mitioateti Construction Off -Site
IOU
WSI..

L4
sua
111,0hwe
prom
&Imre
win
PM1tt
moo
:R4plhi•
PN73
4bIsnoso
r+rrYl'$
W1Q.N r
TO.

Ng-Crl]

1.16.2- CC1.2
1'bll{U2.

DM
WO
Cur
i
,, •ieq°'Y
tLMfY
64010,
y
rliJl'y7
. .dedrl
'V
'•N;1ke
-
•.
a.am] • Game i a WOG • a LIMO
L' 1k777 0 6G CC • G DOOM
6 0.7000 a 1:03C 6.53D0CGG : 8SA
6670 0. emu] Y a33.30
a ii0CCL.
•1676631
1 9.467.64:
03163 • S: ii6 • 337+1 • 0,a
6'6136 • a a122 • tl07
_
C.2,26 a.0i16 • d® 77G=
• 3.671.0C 3671.46 .• O. •
Y t
-2[1
i I San .

17.!!20
a 09666
6:643.'.
. •own 91411
'OHO

9.044! • 1.
• 6.463.747
3413 T47 • 3.,14.4 e
,
1Mw
I. VII
1`IA
Mil,

21.2543
4,01•12
TOM

4.36311

7.0301 '
'AIM
aris7
33$56
"Atli
1 7,196AM•
1 34:43t

31.61.343

3.6 Paving • 2923
UrrrlArc ater Cuns4ructlgn On-Sde
,.

C-
SGc
waaoa.

RAN]
€ruur
R•110
PlI9
lane
Fusin..

RC, 0
E4 -arm
PM: S.
r'H125
4uis
Da - CO2
116. G02
Sill COZ
Cl-,4
3120
C
'
r
A
Y
06 -Read
Ps
ase:w6 •
1 (0.0 . 141017
i

14.ia642 • {Ifl776 , 03162 • 91101 . • a4�4 93964
t ; w s
• 272; SS4 2204 6B4• 6.7146
• 1 4
,
'
.
a
433
c
•
` a srm
• •
❑ ma9
• •
Dille
•
31:966
• ca0.336
•
a
Told •
t.1337171
Niel
14,9642

6.9224
46142

9.1946
_ 9.461

9.4433.44
2,31:11.56#

2.310.7.6114.
1 6.7149
777

133
01-25
Corot

Page 249 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2366
RTC -537

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMadW2rslon Ca1EEMAvd.2Of63.2 Page 22 of 35 ID ate: X12.20212:30PM Village South Specific Flan (RToposedi - Los Angeles -South Coast Courts., lVL iter

3.5 Paving -2923
IInfr4itielated Cans.uuctitln Off -Site
{Ord
+is7. I
CQ
9r32
4-1.07,,e
RIDea
i'.y1PAist
P1.11r
PM Itl
I ,fle,
Aual*ye
M1_'.,
tIJAALS
PA.IT+.
r•I:,
I7+CSJ2
MI6- d21tbal
C{72.

DM
WO
CG.

Vde.dar
'
.7 C.,),7_

J ,ICOL,,
L' 4377 , ,7 C41Uli r .p gait;
L .: '.. n-..
m , J:60
. 0.MOO Q. CU e a 3030 •
: .:..-
s-.,.
.,ca:ry
I0.: Mtl3
Lla2.7ial,
. aacoe
U.,,X,{,
aC,_b:
oPXG
c:oa7ca . aooQ{V , a MI.

B-6000 9CCU
Mi.•]]G]-
.: G.BQEFT 1 QmQ6 B,70:{
'
'ekxleer .. aDM
w
QQ=
aMAD
a l eYRs
9 .I
e 474
Q I,I.I . Wank.-
, Q44 e
+
it 1194 •a(MEI
r
6 40311
a
. "62.Qai5
'
II2aS A

• 2Mt.,
! CO)
.
304
A31?liii
RAYPRi

0.35AA
lei O
On
Lf M1
W..

SAW..
,ale
•a ,i.pa
inxu
tip1
COI
MAIM '
14C AIM
e1gd. 14n

2.72.78:1,a,d
iq?
Mil Ina Ltd Conntruction On•Srt
z-
54s
RIQtrw
ROW
,,Lit1ter
Mlle
PRA la
Tr[e
+-gpli.c
PPF',5
"r� o.

MT? ,5
rN735
Arts
t __-'_
NB. CO;!
"%Inl CJ'a
awl,
SRO
'
CAlkiltly
E.k3y
lAaly
06 -Raw
•.aze:wp •
1 Qk"'7 '. 1: : . I4 S°.3 n 8,M26 , ; 0$103 ° a 51dT • .. 114,364 • t 4 1 i t w w ;
_io - ..: 7117 SEA 2202 584 • o.714G ,
r w 1 I 1 i
_ :2!.
a
aQrao-
QJE

I
• ,
r
❑mQo
QQCrd
2auc
P
cams
3 •
Told t.AAp.!
ItiB17
1{,564
Q.glg
A161I2
4E1QH

4{6&1
44 4

6.010{6
2,2oL56A
L2Q7.ti64
o.714Q

3.221{33
a

11.25 Cont.

Page 250 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2367
RTC -538

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMota WersIans Ca1EEI*4t1,20f63.2 page 23 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposedp - Las Angeles -South Coast Cuurey, later

3.5 Paving -2923
Miticated Construction Off -Site
(5aie: i'12.2021 2.34PMt
9Cn7
KY. I
L4
sot
PoglIve
;0,4%4

3.Yaa1V
win
P1JIIa
l.{M
fI1p6+L,
nwl
tom.,
PM23
W1Q.N r
TO
h. CrJ2
N#5e-Cd2
FabI CU2.

DM
WO
ciao
i
,..,ieq.'P
4 neajy
tell,
•
-12,0 y1
1'ssdu ..
0:T . L _.3110
e
.7 Lui'- J IEU
L' e420) S COM • C UST1
a'am5 a cox, . COSA
G. MOO 81:131313 5 .3(.313 Cr
ICU;;
sores
IO: h523
a 4O06 • awns
.;
0 CAM'. - 2, 3545
C
x:5:03 , 2 MU , 4.60

54.353 O CODG • C.CCCD
• sum- I GCMG . limas i .
-..
.,,,,-ke, ;� O{OQ
•'
114 3
055.0
I UPear
. 0123
O. I 11. 1 .5 WOW- 41160 • 04347
, aa4 ; 3
,. i7OSAI� a milli
r5pl
- • •a5.4Qa.
112.3 BM
• 2TCUCa- •
• Germ ;

1.Enw
tr.Et1W
4+p'Pi3
,19

0.37 '
t$700.,.
093
M}601
...151... 9p(...

Me
i, iivi
a.uxu
E
COI
u.iiii
�in.RDI
lEd.N•74N

2.78:15.- L

05.1 ir72.7d11h

3.6 Paving • 2024
Unmitigated Construction On ,Site
-:_
+.

CC
SGc
waa.a.

PM.5
€ruI{r
PMie
RM I4
lane
FAO.*
Fr+42,5
Ei#a.m
R•12:'

14.42 5
vuu
Da - CO2
115. cC,2
SdaI COS
CI -4
W.

Casa '
may
802,0 1
t+m y
- — -- i
r i
C41 -Read
asenp
`
025212
5,5246 + 1y.55.9 . 5,U25. . 5.{6QS Y • Q {€66 • + 11.131.1111.131.11 • Q#710 . .
• •
• 2 MP 547 2.$R.S47 • 13.714B .
.
• •
2Z`S 2,15
a arm
a a'
❑ CUM. a aow : a Om'G cam,
• r • •
a.
•
•
Told
— 5.9552
Q;7N6

14.5255a
Q:>Q5.9225. •
4L4

5.4641$ •
•
A9715
1L4310
3,3aL44r
2343.647
a.71+I4
'aa3`.3BQ
O1-25-
Cont.

Page 251 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2368
RTC -539

Responses to Comments
CalEEMOta'V2rslon' Ca1EE d.2O163.2 Page 24 of 35 Ciate: 1112.2021 2:30PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposal: - Las Angeles-Saaith Coast Cour69y, tVL iter

3.5 Paving -2924
IJntmitielated Cans.uuction Off -Site
{oaf
+is7. I
La
Sat
1huQbrt
01•1••1
two's"
Wm
PRI I 1
I ...e.
rual*ye
MC..
t<A1E¢4
LA.IT+.

F•^I
!I,Cf.J2
IOW-Ld2
1'x.111002.

DM
WO
CG
-lsJth$
a
--- ssEar e

1. sows
• •
0:T E
c •.fin]
a COI_ J LICOLy
5 400) ; .] r,'y9i- .0 i1C4L"•
L .: n...
. r-‘ oTA
• G. 5030 0 t c • O ]OM •
• i* 4'E133
altos
.
_
E WOO
000M : 3 [A)1G
_
• C.:900a . 3G]Q•5 • Q.a
_,_ _.

CG'Tita 9CiGC
•5.•]7C�
T
- G11500T 4[•5•5•5 : Imam;
_
-•
- . - _ , ,
Wlhakrf �.• •5•5444 •i
!
11•5357
1 9311,'
C055e-
a
Y ca)
•11.
• III Ili 1 •d 66t%ir } •5.1194 • 043•53
1 . cot • !
glom, 419319
R GQ•
Y5.5Q45
.
ta.5L45 . 2.ocCa..
ova x
%ow-
$1[1444
5 O
{4111
ti@99a•
an
9'.1141 ,
dearth,
nu
n.i1-t
' il Wei,
RANO,
Dpi.
— 4(411
al sine
gesso

2.4F05,
QQa
' AP 45055
% ilpaLed Construction On•Sit
..
.L.:

Sal
F:1QUw
R]
I;hwta
Mlle
PIA I3
Ufa
+-ugli.G
rT4 5
E. .,.

MT?e
Pmt 5
rams
t .:.02
9'1ri+a CO2
"%1J CO2
ia-.4
ams
CC -24
C11€il. r
- E-...., _-
- !wry
aft -Read
••fWrwp
• 0.'11382
G. 5;3a • la a,9 n QQ335 •• •5.16&5 • Q V655 • • 81•78[ • 4 a39C- 1 i 1 i 4
• ,
••
• _�x' 8'P 547 2.54.547 • 9.71{G 1
I 2 I a ; ii
• 1 •
:'05 20L••
0[!1311
• Qsrm'
LIMN • AOl : 21:91)E.. T 1103X+
" • P

0.COM
^ '
Iola `

5.9552
_

5.524+5

14.5255
_

42.92211 •
I
11{55[1
1L4 ••
2{410
v
44310
1-_
QC4451

3.3•57' 4r
s
2307.5+7
i

5.7140
2gII3.3BQ

01-25
Cont.

Page 252 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2369
RTC -540

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMari Version* Ca1EEM1ad.Z0163.2 Page 25 of 35 Crate: 1112.2021 2.30Pt+A Village South Specific Flan (iroposedh - La's Angeles -South Coast Courey, lVL iter

3.5 Paving -2024
Miticated Construction Off -Site
MCC,
KY. I
L4
502

PIIA'IQ
bilese4
PIAle
FMIa
Tee
Fusee
PNG.5 I
elemeil
Pens
Pe
Tale
Se- CrA
N$e-LtE2
'ter CUs.
um
WO
Cliff
4 -
-1iJL'y7
.
.... --.. .e. tl._
1 de,Ekr
r
.-.. _...,,
0 MOE.
l =:a [
.7 COT_
JLICOLy
L' 7iJ7J a C4]Ofl e d
G'Oe'DO d.fmG. : F.OSA

011033 a mM . a 7017
,. •_Li,
o.) -..x
A. Nan
- -
0 arm
- ___--
e acoo
- ___
. .
a cam
__
a [F7aE+
.. .r
_ r .

C:ROca own d
.

I
- _ ... _. -_._-
._
c9m�o 9 Caafr • GaS.7
e
__. -
T
OHM 9.IFS9l1 . name +
y
_ - _
Worker .. 0 WA
11017
07"14 . I Y,iCM -
I: I I 4 I I d WWI- * '¢ 11% I. 01,33
---i
d flea 40311
•
. u4.5W" iD y; 45 . 2 411;f�- .
1 w
_- 9.9441
[7927

3.aiii a'ti50Jdll-
II03

3.1.41 42[1191.-
ohs

9.1150
Il¢d¢1

4.11501).-
0pe.
4 311
^
X14550
$451)45
1449-.-
f1}1
I®sfe¢3
32 Architectural Coaling - 2024
Unmitigated OEMs rrucbon On -Sete

sc'
8411...

PMW
€rull4
FM10
Pty110
lore
frrWt+e
Pri7.6
EAmail
P4.I75
r.d75
7, rim,
Esn E+32
1419. c02
T.i.l c02
CN-4
WO
=...,
taleyr6.r
rk'mp
-

1.1m}
#Jln Cs1Vnp : 733.41",5 :
i r
44004 . MOM . 7ffe1_ t:ii1i
w
OMB
I:+%::

M124..3

�• Oil Read 01032 • I2IM • 10,01 • 247LGs
. . ]3:.

OLEO] • d9OD • 3LEC4 • 4001.0
MI a4"51
MI 4481 .. 001 +
a
Told
716.5473
Al !
m
tel 101
lH O..
1171

0. 0

6.0045
A11AWN ekEee
261.44CI
2e1.446i
i

0.9146
+
X64+ 1. 3

01.25 Cont
Page263 cif 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2370
RTC -541

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad VaraIons Ca1EEltocl,2O163.2 Page 26 of 35 Oate:1112.20212:30PM Village South Specific Flan (iap:mei:4 - Las Angeles -South Canal Courty, lVL iter 3,7 ,4rchrle[lurdl Coaling • 2424
Vrlmiliiated Construction Off -Sinn
.1OG
CO
9r[2
4-...gdNe
OM•5
twat.
1,1.11r
PA11.1
I,..

1.ugilwe
@CA -'ti
DOsat4
r%.IT•.

F. 1
f1, �SJ2
IOW- C C11
ImIlI CU2
ciao
coo
0,7.
-lsJrh$
1'en4rl
•� .•_�...
i. +a.•
.AO, '_ ..“1-06 1.h.00J .JUAN, ; Li -Jai,.

I— 4.
.n_. =_._ .Cc.

9.44. I OQAO 63030 ;
I ] 900G
P
. 1 C42 D.1
1 4
w 4 776
C.110
0 COO - 3 3CCG • 93505 . 5 CCM . 3
1 1 i
6030,1
F
'.'. • :: J7C17
d
T
, 9.9990 4®99 6,39
Y I
.;
'etheker .. 4#734
w
9]x43

3.329
a 091137 .
e e
1]171 . 6,13t1'Jr • 1 . Of=
1 901 e e
4999'!a .3 3315
Cat e
-t
. 1,96E 367
e 6
- 1101.391..

I 11

91.3:@7 .
e.

To*et
$4734
9:Pr43
13239

0.0196
1$771
'018471,,
Cox
'L23114
fL3V'1
imam.-
or
(IS41S

7,x67,}'7
4 1Ai1,5111
6 914161
tpb4.46t
a
Mil Ina Ltd Con ntructlon On•SII
•.

50.1 wGtrw
Fly, -,3
1;41....1¢
FM10
P1la
Trd16
-..g1pc
PITZ5
E. ...

R.T?e
P425
1!414•
i =_-'-
NB. GG2.
rd.. COZ
O4
1f'4'1.
...'1
c.ny, r
Wm,. _-
_ l.13.,
Fr_hn Cs;106C • 73941",5 •
i r
u
MOD. 06006 . ]Cfe1_ t i1i� �
w
•
39990
OCC
. 24164.3
O4-RCo0 O 1-ECE • 12Ia5 + 1E+131 • _4700.
w . + . 001
QLen • 96OD • ]CEC9 • GOOLE,
6❑OLL. • `u•1 a7"a1
MI 4481 • 691 +
e

Told
774.5211
Alm!

7.6761

7.4799..
77arb
BAWD
.6.665!9
awe
4719176

6.0649
161.44E1
761.1461

6.711x6
1 S1.6J1!3

01.25 Cont

Page 254 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2371
RTC -542

Responses to Comments
CalEEEMoti Versions Ca1EEM;4 1,20163.2 Pape 27 or 35 Oats 1=122021 2 34PMt Village South Specific Flan (iroposedh - Les Angeles -South Coast Court, lVL iter 3,7 Architectural Coaling • 2024
Miticated Construction Otf4ile
90G
v.). i
L4
V3,2
✓Fuphre
I'll!q
#716aty
num
RM Ill
tort
1,uptI2
MG S
temps
eM23
r91a.r r
TO.

E]r2
N$ - CCIL2
titri 001

0.4 WO
coo
,,,leq.oj
gyjy
bAt,y
IIjJL
- -1'ssdar '••:. I. Qs3_CL
u :OA: . L _ :UC,
a EOM . 4 MUD . L' WO) a DOM :COOED
I3000O a.cox. : &WOO
6 N a.O940 . 4,SIQo
V
6 UM,
saux
I C4.2 G,,
G
. C:t3JG
aCGL : > C:9's:} . arwb{V , a.
d — 1 --I
c0tfl0 1CQrC ._c..
t- t - * - - '
•Te all(180 GIME Iramo . ,
-4- 1--
'�.'.Ne i �,°:la . G _Yt3
i:i2G . 44910+ . 92171 , NV30!k 1 y 4 O.xr2u i44tiAa• • 43315 Mil ". r e DX( '
- --t
. 9.0013!1
, 4
- 1d9 1.301..
1 A
limo. , ,
,
l nrd., -1-4413.1
—163113 *
k9Y3n
uuie!-

1.2171 *9138(G,.r
4d6
$.7,016
R7tt91
ORION-
MO

16.]713 I
1,44!!/1
7 14114.111
I
EOM
9ue2.4iv
n

4.0 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
01-25
Cont

Page 255 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2372
RTC -543

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod'Verolon' Ca1EEI*41,ZO16:3.2 Page 25 of 35 Crate: 1I12t2021 2:30 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Angeles -South Coast Courts., larder 'Dni
yo.
co
see
Pup ..<
PM `7
R,R 71"
p4ai.4
TM*

60. OG3
n46r [ci
bra
UnnmInse.
a y1] . �^. 9n IJ !�Jmv Jug_ J 7 a J..

H.TS7. 8001+T114O4 4. ®.4$a'.1TT 46.572 7;104; e..2 J 33171 •73i+:oo. 1 as r8 Tit
•47D17 47317190. 2.1959 • -• 9.. DO
08 Or}

4.2 Trip Summary Information
ay®1z�aJil�t TQPTmr'_--
unnl ert
Mrtp ed:
•. L rllr'U911
woo
Dandily
h1111�Ytwor
- Miami
Apintmelrots.PM RdPR
14!.,%R 1 34-:�
1 VO
515.[27
5[1422F'
AporrinrIlit910 iii me •
d.Qf69'3 5; 7'r325
1Oi$'aO
....... 13, ,055

13.555.055
7 -.^roar rxce ra. re
•.i. 79645 w 6756
3145 ;,..,.,.
7,96,®1
'7x2,817
:: 'OW II Fiestau-ant: a-
_
«369 �5U 21N19'37.
41? t: •
,
i613,5,d7,
703,539
N_�
96C, OD
..1.4 ,143 +
..
tl-48,1(33
„
a
6] 1 12 511. §_,
463.217 .
7,97,4&0
7117 45S

• 521104 • Ifr31. 44
35754 •
111_' -1
T,112 221
i ]5.0 IS 96[..43
a 057.31
0°.53152 1
20 55[.45'2

4.3 Trip Typo fnfomiatiorI
D1-25
Cont.:

Page 256 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2373
RTC -544

Rrgnruk Shopping C e»r
Responses to Comments
CalEEMad VaraIans Ca1EEMad,20163.2 Pape 297f 35 Cate. 1112/2021 2.343 M Village South Specific Flan (Proposed* - Los Angeles-Salrth Ceasl Cuurlty, lVL iter VI IA

11.110 ti
Laid Uot
h.W f4 -W
H-0 orC Wi

HW IC -IN
K -S 711CC
elpartrores LOW Rau a 147: r- &-9 • 4420 • 10:29 4460 • 3E 11 • '0.A011rAFl%9 Mla RISC # 1A70 r 4A{r 'i. ,�•�•••••-•••� • ' 8.74 • ▪ 4024 . 1920 . a 4064 51 11 general Ma Bldklllg i 1660 . E,44 : 690 • 3100 4BM i 92r 77 19 --`--`--4 x--
3hTumour 6SAdow°.• * 1690 640 6.id' 's 860 1 VA' i ,.f. .37 . ^4 . e •.r.. ...
k9Clw •
. 18.84 i 6 44 a SO. * 1140 i 81.64 1300 .p ▪ 'F 4
a�art.� F r ••• 1d. 00 646 ••695 *� 1200 1 9000••.. •e 1901 31. b& 44 16:130 440 090 • 1690 , F X04 70 , 000 • 54 35 11

4.4 Fleet IA
-sr-J Use
WTI Li -1772 r Mild 11+D1 11,432 WID
H1D QaJ
UBUH
M•Cr
uS
HH
Apartments Lcona4rr. W O'Yk3i161Y, '0544717 426001 0110366 001440is. 010ni3,-s_ 0.3 1146 0033077 000715 L3 0401657 0.4012156 0760/'1? Ocm= .7i 4 p,pamnedsled Rim .1 0.543089• 0.544216 020907'1 0r182M0 00/4532 0.6130333: 1).62118e 0.03 77. 6.6010 92 6.601dt7' .005A6 0.000712 6.63,'37!'"1 .
xr�nlOffemBsddey' 05i33dN 0x`4421. 0260"571 5116366 0013033 4.000:32, 6221168 003357'/ 0ODD 43 0.401817 0.b05W96 0,000712 000:4-11 *3NoertSilt t?.v+r1 ; 05+9 B% DS -14 1 02M.?i` 6/19364. 4614023, 6!00933/: C' 1:,1leE, 003:6721; 0.00 15! 060il1l7t 0/5037619: 55007n; 6 td61421 11r r11} i . r r o . . . . .• i
Holleel a 0343506; 0.5+4216 0:Mr e 9116251 0.014033. 0.006332 0671766 00r33dt7' 4.43:613 0.{61817 0.000260 0.004717 0:000671 Molly Reslaurar4 ? a -30x6'_ 05.4'?IE O ATY1.71 0 rinar 041411312 0 01,011.5,, Li 7:1. lee 0.IX33t37 0.0026+13 60111917' amnia 0604752 i
• 0543:1149• 60.4215: 0:03971: 6110265:
001010 0.2.111.7r
0 604611
.7:1168+ 0.002gi7, 006=633. 06018"+ 0152I115! 0{104.72: 000O5Z1 LO Energy Detail
Halertal Energy Usti: N

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
071-25
Coot

Page 257 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2374
RTC -545

Responses to Comments
CalEEMoiiWersIan Ca1EEMPf1,2O163.2 Page 30 of 35 ID ate: 212021 2:30 PM Village Saute Specific Flan (Proposed* - Las Angeles-Salith Coasi Cuurty, to ter eoe
co
sez
Porptive
'
*OA
t�rvus
PMir
DM1h
iaea
ruptra
0,42.1.

TM,
Bo. CM
Mew-
tte4
car
neheaklee 6.7449} • 67.32 . 1%2571 • 6#16 T• ••• ¢6.6 0 .5d'2' + � a 65. 1 4•J i'L'aaiS• • U5J . , ry „ ,4 o AlUCI
2 6.' 99 ®3e6.6li3T 07e.37 4F63Z �®dW.�,a
2 2
O1-26
Cont..

Page 258 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2375
RTC -546

Responses to Comments
CalEE'Moti W2rsIons Ca1E00w:1,20163.2 Page 31 or 35 Crate: V1212021 2:30 PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposal* - Les Angeles-Salrth Coast Courtly, later

5.2 Errergy by Land Use - NattirdIGOIS
UrlmIli aatrd
Nahargba
• 11}
41774
Me
c.
;.t'
I=.ryl..•
Ia1,a,C
r,T1ara
Km,
Pm I
.',b1
rail,,
r'14 i
towasl
F712 5
aM! 3
T..,
no- ca=
lido- .1-42
taw. Clb$
CMS
.120.

R7t
laayuuy
I TI.I.,,,.
teed.ej'
,y,lr3y
A♦eadma •La-
Rao
Al,rl•;;; za
be-Nol 0.01as
B.ddnV
-I,� nsO T�I MAYu7
4v
Za F
e Ili) I9
Ilv
. arfaii
, 1-387
`
p� g.11e J lu3 o
.
f
•: ,•
v
^.J 1L
/i4
aM.

AM.

On
. ]i - v 6341 -beer
b C.t
ILJ3 X35
1] I Alie4"e 131.04 I2 • 2fv''Cde. 2 ilir.
001 ; 0:13 °
'M 1 i/tl0
1511i8!!••+
}2 :11}
alma i 3-.26-C
423
4021
0 Meal
a7,664
02•, 4
+4:.7m e13, .;aI6.0Y.6. S.'6,Ar , 4.97"/2 .42'4335
4015!. . 4.1353.
.
0,957
7SC44r
604
1 4SQ!1l@t
17143
-.., A,
tit?
, e4NA* a U'dB4Cr
IR13 04�
i ,
. 1690911 . 150.0611E 2.UlNer i 27700. •
y I
. 6W 1 1337:
`IYf .
' 1- 6'
°
,
41 200. a 222,14 s 1D1'I�J r 11,513.1 {7
i o a i
10✓ I
411j�� fl l "•.li lr'tll
r
,
+
'� 1i EAT? :.%aT 9450; 4 4 1.
2 i 2 i i YD
t 4rY 1J
44!73 w 67626 231-446- . 0� . 405
, 9!o-
• 0:051 • 02ti41
......4..........4____4___j___4, •
• Sei.1433. 311.,arae
a 1111 .....
3GISb S.Di53 •
334 rt6

5.333633
i 79 1-443
. 'i I3
i1-
4 awl,
9#99& O&M, 2 saga, 1 a 4m7r 04570 . • 0971- I [inn, +663:I.53• 1 oda
911:rrt ai _
a
40116 • it Ih1 N
r
`*
-- _.4.
, 251.613
;
27r99c
Le)
_
• 91�i..;7 v
•
a

6.C4O7'
i 1191As-:
r 061-
_
a
, 1
1e'hiWo-
04®
1 �1'4 � 6c
; 4L0
_
"e n
:

I. fYF9T
, 03 ,
Ib7Li!
4115
+�
•
_
20b516
s ,795@P4

• ,5113CO2.
" N. ;
ft. {949c
666
a
Yell
ea filch
el H1 .3
17 4106
%248 a
95112
ti
4 4i2
8335.403
2 !333.613
2 9.4162
9:a537
e.39?..h7d
7 O1-25
Cont.

Page 259 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2376
RTC -547

Responses to Comments
CalEE_EMod'VersIansCa1EEM L20f63.2 Page 32 of 35 Llate:1I12.20212.30PM Village South Specific Flan (Proposed} - Los Angeles-Soalth CoasI Cuur61y, toter

5.2 Energy by Land Use - Nattiral ass
Lin..ii'd
7AaatrarAba
• 4144
1104
Me i
C.&
;.t'
1=varstr c
Plait'
•:•414•4 •A
Km,
.'Y2la
.'. 4i
luau,
r' V i
rwha asi
P412 5
aM! !I
TtlYaa
no- Cl2
1 - r.CA2
tal1.1562
044
4120.
me5
Laay4•r
',am.).
ratiiay
4ahr4S
A♦ialln,674Lns
Rao
Ales'arn[s k9d
Gs- &Mat
rw.,...
ti•AP T.a•••�.eai�
Reas
GAMY Adm..1�
HMN
• 4 Malay _ _
R.egaaua-d
flagonsflagons
;tra tl 011r4.J
v 1 1141r'
• 351@2013
•• I L1142
• ?173914
• 4 746•Ii
p • I_ o
4•
•.. ,•
f
v
5 ]411.
'41
.. aACe
On
• 8 44 ]4,_ •- v
U37
S34Lis 43VT
0443
i 1] I v 131.0442 • 2f52133.. • 2 w1iU

00.3 ; 403 e
13 446a
42'4337
ib� 680+.
2��n}
6 9}S9i- , E•-•2
4423
40;'Y
_
C• 2444
Olfx
025G> El 55E-
. . .
}
T• 1::00814. 4214.4Y.4• 40207 v 0.47"/' •
r
a • 4.1390
r
01447
754034-
4W
_
44aJ4r
Ma
WA,
•'in
• ••54:4 UL
' RJ3 ""XS6
r Y
ao.. '
947 011 r�1504BA1:1.�yI . 27,
w i 6W i PA7
�a."u.1 • Zj}11 , 14713 . X06161 •
• - r
i l a i
rj 1499
4vr.+ • u.93b .
r
- ir7F
1r1a1
2,at77 Wa .. EAT? B$4, 00541 . 4114P1
4 i 2 i
t 305,4
04675 w 034 • 2 aril, • , 8 r 4.0]86
r 7.ta
• 0:43x• •
02ti43
• 541.1434. 941.1434
Mal% . 4-4147 •
5414732
593 Mae
297710
• 0.437'75
. a 054'L
ti
4 4994 01149 • 2 96We- • a 8 a37r • 4 4571 + • 0 4377 1 r Mai
07577
+683 01SE • sal, Date _
a
11111120 • 00'1x9 N
y
•"__^ .
• 4425141M4425141M4425141M 21,1194,21,1194,
:
r
2x
fj54
• 0 41;7 v
; ;

0.4107
•,- dAs-
r 1l 0620
: _ a
; i

1.61KWo-
640
r 1 BJCUc
; on
"e n
:

I. 67074e-
t 03 .1
I b74fic
0 65
a
'1146316
s 190@PO
• 8.71XJ4o- •
• r 6620 • 601
S444rir •

1..
v.7i14a

9.744}
1,2371
Q4/i4
aVVa1Y
!I57dQ
3i-ak3
15335.943
2 4.333.4445
2 4.4662
V53 31
NA0341a4
7 6.0 Area Derail

6.1 Mitigation Measures Area
O1.25
Cont.

Page 280 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2377
RTC -548

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version' Ca1EEM 20163.2
Paine nor 35
Village South Specific Flan (Prapesedi - Las Angeles-Sarlth Coast Courty, later L1aIe. 4'12.2021 2.30 M
PupWm
PrilD
twug RAW
PM,
Tura
Phr24
tx.wr
FM24
Pstis
Tao
ea- c
Mtlw Ctl2
Taw c•tv2
CanLill
Whim
1311150839
Ur,,11114md
N.
▪ 30 6@6 • 13 64t 1. r 66 4437 .0 0544
4 1.e®34 . _I7R74 + ..
. Itg7a� 4.•I'S4'7'4. 66xe :,L ms 16.14,1.511# 04.574 • olaio . lam* t1+ !b6 Itp

6.2 Area by SubCategary
Unmitigatedt
w0.3
1dG:
]
PMtr,
PP$AI'
'L7iio
w:11a
9410
T.

Fs 12J,
rasa s
E�+f
',NUS
Otttil
TeWI
_
tic '.Q2
-. _- o
ML4m [03
' _ _�
rM� C'1.-`:
. —
�
_._- t
n;�6
..

CGic
Lie 0,
'May
M1.¢,11ertuCal
Obatinp
Cs4aunRr .
. 2;9r0 •
{ { {
0 M i 0.0G>0 . OW® GM=
I
s DOOM
vim—
a 0=9
1 0DIM
'.'OM .

1. 00:

0.00 • 0. m
I 11
• 0CUW .602103.602103. 00 \
{* -
F 6W66 e .
- -
10 Mph n ®
p
L 1c r • 6W® . 00�

1.140 6 1 1446
t
• 1140 • r. 144„6
I
0 C.000 .• W 0 :6.OW • I600600 . 3440 • 03.70 .
. 6<3 ' 44 l'
i _.....
161C4 B9
, 51t
.1 32 1113:,!
-
IAr al1.-.1 24M
r
“'4`o3 ,
Qi 4431' .:47QI]Q�
004.
04574
, 6+574
_
•
(14.¢74
• 04574
• 140 ..66 14A $61,44 :61474 .
+
'role
xwen

13.4Mi6
88A4]0
Q6144
�-15074,
tS974
l
ll

1.1!111.4
Li174
61466
id 14E39
so
1L 140.64,
s6
0 .1.3n64874
.3n6
1i. A5i.11
tl3
01-25
Cont.

Page261 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2378
RTC -549

Responses to Comments
CalEE141nta Vamlons Ca1EEMAtr,20163.2 page 34 of 35
Village South Specific Flan (Proposedp - Los Angeles -South Coast Courts., t+lJfnter €,2 Area by SoliCategocy
M i tin ateii
Oaie. 1=12.2021 2.30 PM
Ruv
N--,
..0
,„om!t'.'2
wµ1+1
,E!d'aust
pi110
.11I i1
T *.

F-uy Eye
Vµ; 1
rwnus
Pm i
IpkR7
,t a^
15r- C{]}
Wgo- CC.?t
Tof3l can

0.41 redo
LOie
o 4,1441
belle.,
tinny
7, ',11E3,141 IN 22ciO
•.
a 6.mUJ 600011 . i 017L1LL 'AWOL
00309 • r
6CCVbJ
-0- C.003-
le IC41 VI
613

1.54 Vo..2.

•7,—..,nln :1035 • .

I,t a1�,1. i
__ _4-_ ---t- _ — i-- _
Y DUMB • a.Q00G •
0 0611 Bf.YC[

UMW
4 1
H4..1h iimao . II I M6 . 54117.1 . 4COM
Z.
--t 4--

1. 14175 . I140,1 .

I-

11.1M, 1.1X+6
p
•
fic•X .'6.(MOO.. 16 MO N i LINO . 67X!3 •
rn 1 4U 1•
-;

1.r�1:nr-7, o .49 . 11'040 . e1 NN
!
t-
. 4 MD, •
1 Ca .

C.4%74 . 114.4'74 . . 04074 . 04472
1 . 1
. _
. 145 13 . 44500 4 (1 1444 •
Ted
3L.1 l6

15.W46
6i�.W660

1.6674
t.S47-
isr14
W4

0.6016
11,14114
C.
t6.1ILS6
641

6.Izt4
Lib
MAR *1'
52 7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water

8.0 Waste Detail

8.1 Mitigation Measures Waste

9.0 Operational 0tfr3ad
-w.t e rrx
Ju 5x1
nourarnit
1Llt sc r•I,,,e-
LWr1 Fati'

10.0 Stationary quipmeret
01-25
Cont.

Page 262 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2379
RTC -550

Responses to Comments
CelEEMod Veaker: CWEEPAQI2Q16.3.2 Page 35 ar 35 Dale 1;12'2021 2 30 t M Village South Spec[Fc Plan LFroposedi - Los Argeles-Sofitlh Coast Courts., Vardar Fire Pumas and Emergency Generators
Equiceneet Type
Nattier
Haulae:Su
Hours/Ye ,
Horse Power
Load F➢choe
Fuel Type
ers
E41eernstiTye.

Numtel
kciff
hFpr4iOtir
Neel epe mania
Senfe4
Fuol Type
User Defined Erma -omen(
Equpmenl Tyoe
rf Obit+
11,E Vegetation
01-25
Cont

Page 263 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2380
RTC -551

Responses to Comments
Attach Twill C
Lflcil Hire PIovisoon Net Change
,
Without Local Hire Provision
Total Construction GHG Emissions {MT CO2ie)
Amortized (MT CO2e/year)
3,623
120 77
With Local Hire Provision
Total Construction GHG Emissions (MT CD2e)
Amortized (M'I CO2efvear)
% nerrerise in (Construction -related GI -16 tmfsstaris 3,[}24
IICM1ttO
17%
01-25
Cont.

Page 264 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2381
RTC -552

Responses to Comments
EX h I IT B

Page 265 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2382
RTC -553

Responses to Comments
SWAPE
Tethnictl canaMlMlan, DamAJIlysis afa
LJilaatian Sumars tar the Environment
NOM WATER MR PROTECTION EST[REMISE
lt5 5@"=^]th Yuen, Suer 2il i
Sonia rd mom, t:oLferrua'iO1ft
Mt. Paul Rssmichi, Pro.R.

Mobil: t3 ]'tr) 795,2333
Celli v;. (311)1452-355,
F'nx:f3]itl•142$"
t:wntltyresanteli a'iwace,mia
Pauli Ruseveehis Ph.D.
( Bonne ul Fate and Transport 8 Air i leperslan Madden 1, Pnrrcipai &`mirrznnacrrt el t hsnuasl kink Asseposmont 8 Re>nicdia Lion Specialist f ducritio n
Plt©. Soil chemistry, University of l4'aabingtnit 1999. Diascrt;3rion on vnlatste organic compound filtration, 1u1,Si Environmental Science, 1J.C. Berkeley, I 5 Thesis on organic waeste eciraarmirs:

B . F,nvn»nmerlatat °":n I. :a ' Santa Rath art, 85x91. pietist on waitewntertreatment.

Prrt't .girrnal Ex.Rcrience
01-26
17r Ralsafald has over 2S years' experience cnmJuct:mg emarnnmental investigations and risk assessments for evaluating iinpacta to human health, property, and eon -topsail receptors- lies expertise focuses on the fate and transport of anviimernenatil contaminants. human health rsak, exposure assessment, and ecologlcoil restoration .Di Roaetnteld has evaluated and madeled emissions firm uncomer tonal -oil drilling operatiorss nil spills, landfills; boilers and Incinerators. pines sbutks, storage tanks, confined .trains]. ta[x]ing operalioria, said many i'1hwi industrial ainl agricultural sources Hi project experience ranges from monitoring :mil it delang of pollution sources to vmulunttng impacts of pollution an mockers at irtelustrial (hest:ties.and maidens m serrnundine communmes.

Dr Rosenfeld has investigated end designed renlaerhatwm programs and ris1; assessments for contaminated sites. containing lead, heasy metals.. mrrld, bacteria, particulate mats~_ petroleum hydrocarbons. chlorinated solvents. pesticides, raslinawtiwe waste. dioxins and forma, semi- and volatile (twine erimpounns, PCBS, PAdis perehlorate. ftsbmi1N, per- and poly-tlnaroal'kvl sob:sun:es ITFOA/PFQS1 unusual pleasances. fuel shy erases fMTBE), rim -crag otlto puallanants Dr, Rosenfeld aIrtn .11M. wtpeneiwe evailuaaing greenhouse gas emissions f om vinous propecte and is an expert en the assessment of odors from industrial anal agrseultuni I sites. as step as the evaluatten of odor nuLaance impacts and technologies tar abatement of odorous rrniwnnmy. As a principal scientist al 9WAFE, 1Jr. Rosenfeld diem air dlis} Tins modeling and experturc abc,Fayrnen14 He has acrt`cd as in, expert witness and Testified about pollution sourtes causing nuisance said; ur personal injury at dozens of aatca and has testifies as an expert WARMS nn twee Ihiin ten cases mien Iving expnsute In us cnntaminonts from industrial sources PaulE Rosenfekd,Ph_D

Page 1 ends

Page 266 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2383
RTC -554

Responses to Comments
Processional Hlktor*a:

Sod 9yats Air Protection Gnterprisc (SIV A:PF): 21103 to preAcnt: Principal and Fnundins Partner UCLA St;hrxel ra1"P ibite 'Health; 2y(I7 to v1J I I. 1..ecturer (Assistant Ruswri her) UCLA Sehaol of Pune llcalih: 20O13 to 2e)9t;; Adjunct P€ciessnr UCLA Envmorm enal Science and Enginct-ring Prsxgrani, 24102-21.144; Doctoral Fntem C`urardmatot tJCL.A, histitute of the Environment, 200.1-2,OO2; Research Assaciate Korncs 1120 Settmee, 21d0 I to No, Senior Rerneditaiion Scientist National Cuntmdwater Association, 21h?2-2t)Ckt. Lecnlrer San Diego State University, 1999.2001; Adjunct Pnifessor A stein Corp., San Diego, 2UOU-2001; kemedration Project :�thmcgtr Cgden 4nnw.amec), San Diego. 2000-20()(I; Retnediatian Project Manager 3echtel, San Diego. t_lnliforniti, I999 2.0 X), Risk Assessor piece County, Seattle, E P9G - 1999: Scientist
lames Rimer C:orp., Washington, I9r9s-96; Scientisr
13%. Creek Lumber, Davenport, California, 191}5: Scientist Pun Corp., Calofanain and LISPS, l'altoe 1993-1995, Scietttrxc Pence Corps and World Wildlife Fund, St, Kitts, Wen Inxiu+ , 1991-1993: Skientist Publication g:

Remy. L . ,, Clay T.. Evenit, V., RorrentrekI P. CC (2019) lie,spita1. Health. anal 4,'o-rnmunity Burden f 'r Oil Refinery Fires, Richmond C.alifomda 2)I)7 and 2r)12. flnniruaarrenrtat Iiaatrh 18:x8 Simons RA , Sao, Y Rosenfeld, P (2{115) Modeling the Effect of Reimer). Emission On Rent dentin F'roperty Value. Journal of Real Entate Research. 27(3)-321-31 '
Chen. J. A. Zapata A- R., Sutherland A_ J., Ma1r1, n, D.k., Chess, E. S.. Wu, L , Rosenfeld, P. F:., Hesse, I?,. C- {'21112) Sulfur Dioxide and Vnfati le Organic C':nmpnund Fxpinsure To A Cruumunirty in Texas City Texas Evaluated Using Arnaud and Empirical Data. .anrea icnnJcanrnai tf'lsinRnanrrreaahalScience. N{6), 6224532 R eser eld, P.E &: F. T. (:nl I ). The Rik oflloga»dews [3cure. Amst edam Elsevtae Puhltshin ChfraniamolL N P., .ye Ratocnkeld, P.F (2D11) Ilatufrook nfPeAtui'nat Pri¢v ttt.te»t and eletrnrr Prcuiuche n• t4exv f'rarn'cgs in the Agrractlernicait 1ndha.sr.7, Amsterdam Elsevier Publishing, Gonzalez, d_ Fong_ L. Sutherland, A., 'Nailer, r', Sgt, I1.. B�tssc R, Raaertteld. P. (2019 P(`13s and Dioatins+Furann m Attic Dust C.`nllcnted Near harmer PCF3 Production and Secondary Copper Facilities in Sauget_ IL Prr3u'dw F.'rn:.r rar atnratu1 Scaairaa x 113-12:'
Ft , L. Wu, C. Tam. L., Sutherland, A.II . lrtr4� J J , Rtrsettlelki, P.F., 21i111,i Ihmun and Furan Blood Liptd and Attic Dust Concede-stun-inim Pipulritirnts Tiring Near Error Wood Treatment Fatih'ica in Ihe. [Tailed Stairn. Journal M' Eavir-tunnentall-re ith 73(61,
Cherern riali;.N.P:. Rosenfeld, RE (MID) D) Flrarrc nok. o,P Perllar8wr Prtttenikn Asa Clemer Proettacrican Best Prtactrow opt fries Wood rr d.Poperinatrast lo sIer iron. Eltw.v.wr Publishing.

Ch renusm f, N,P,. 44 Rnimidekt, Y.N. (31,(.19) fforrr,o * r.'af'Po$Urror) Froetrenrroto unit Clralmr Prookrnoot; flow P+ncrrees in the Perrolorana Than Vri. AmMerdarn• Elsevier Publishing Wu, (:'., 7'atn, L-, Oa*, rk, J., Refenteld, P (2ra.o9l. Dioxin and furnn binr.J lipid concentrations in l *pulniis n. living near four wood treatment facilities in the United States. rfIT Trorrsenrtiwna uaa Ecniozo, and the Environment, An, Prrtlraianxr7. 1 23 (11).319-327
Nut Resenfeltl,FItD

Page 2 ends

01-26
Cant_

Page 267 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2384
RTC -555

Responses to Comments
Tam L K Wu C © , Clark l I. and Rosenfeld, P.E, (1,X[8). A Statistical Analysis Of Attic Dusi And 13tlaod Lipid Ccmeentratinnw c'if Teirachlorc+-p-Dihetrdudin;cin (TCDD) Taxitilti Equivalency l uniienss (EQ) In Two Popudatinns Near Broad Treatment Factliti s. Qrganah lager CompOGIridt'. 70, 0002"252-00.2255 Tam L. K.., Wu C. D.. Clark J. IL and Rosenfeld, P.E. 3:2098). Methods Per Collect Samples For Assesamg Dioxins And Other Lnvttanmental I:'ontumnania Lei ,attic Dust A Review, CJrgarrokilogcra i;'ti+nrxrrarsi5„ 711, r.X.10527- 00053 j.
llenwley, AR A Som. J I 1 d;'Iatk lintenfeld, if .E. (21I(r7) Attic ErtisT anti 11umon Blind 3amp]ee ('asserted n u FvnmerWood .TrcamtGntFacility. Environmental Research 143, 39--197.

Rosenleld, P.E., 1 J. I_ Clark, A. R. Hensley. M. Suffet. (2007). 'lie Use of an 'Odor Wheel Classification for F:w tllufti,;n a1 Hi matt[ Health Rr k Criteria For I— ilitie% liarerScoerro;e dt Tcclrrirlo, y 96f5), ,ta4.357 Rosenfeld, P. F, hi $afTti. (2Oill), The Anatomy OfCidnur Wheal Frw Orbnure Of Drinking. Water, l'1''avesvater, Conspom And lite khan F iv'unitmetit li'sarer Schearcc & Tccllnrifr3,pt' 55(5), 335.3.4. r'ulltvAn. P, k ['.lark, I,J.J., ,Astedy, F J. Rataen3eld, N.F. (2(X'7) Tosto fzg, 7 Wtnthertx Toian' an the FcH41, Water, atnc/Air-in.imaet-ie,:7nCities Roston Mossusehuselts:lscatterPalrlsahing Rosenfeld, P.F,, and Suffer LH (2004). ennuis! of Compost Odor Using High ('arbnn Wood Ash Wale- Scierscc and Techmoli 4i -19f,19,171 -1N
Rosenfeld P. E, J.J. Clark, I.A. (Mel) Sufi (100.4) The Value of An Cador.Qnalitv.Wheel C]assif cation Scheme For The l:riinn Environment. Winer Frndromrmeit Fe [motion's Technical 1Ak i mhan rimf r anOrem,e 111-Lyf rite.-) :+Jfl4. New c:hleana ( ic4aber 2-b, N.1f1$.

Rosenfeld, P,F{., ,ind Suffer, 1 IL (20 40 Undti+tsaanding, t`sidr*rantx Assuncialed W'sth Cnttrpi a_ tii+im.ax Fn iliGex. and the Land Application eE Bic3soiids. Water Selen,:e and Te hrrn(ew-i9(9), I93-199.

Rosenfeld, P.E., and Sufct l.l-L (2004X Control of Compost Odor Using Hach Carbon Wood Aah, Water .7,6-terce ,arae%Teshrrokji -floe; 9)• 171-173.

Rosenfeld, P. I .. Crreq. M A.. Sasses', P. (2004). Measurement of Bioscfid's Odor and Odorant Emissions lima W mdrrrM's,.:Suitt Pile and Bic fi]ter, R'wrar lfrntironmentRocarr:Jr, 7601), 311)-315 Rosenfeld, ?.E Gray, M and 64ffat, M. (2102), compntsi Dmott nitom 2rojeet, 4.'icrurnen o C:aliifornta [!sing High -Carlton Wand Asst to Cntrtrod. Odor at a Greets Materrals Compcstmg Facilrry Integrated lf'ask Management Board Public Af airsOffice, Publications Clearinghouse (MS -6), Sscrarrient+i.CA.Publacatian:tt-1-T? '2-005 Rosenfeld, P.E, and C_L Henry (20(1)• Characterization of odor emissions from three different biasolsds. Water, ,tioq rrPoiirman, I27(Iml),.175.191
Rosenfeld, P.lr, and Hwmry C L , (2000) Wood exib unntrs?I trf adoi ernmiona from Nom -lids apps Ir?4GIit9 Journal

41.$;,rvironrrrentat {J.irahtt. 29.1662-16U
Rottenfeld, P.E., C.L. Hrru-y" and D aemnett. (and Wastewater dewaterittg polymer affect nn hinsnlida r!d,r rmisai,tns enJ niiicrnhsal activity Water bYn'irnmmenf Rematch 730), 363.367.

Rosenfeld, PS—, and C. 1_ 1-]eiry (2illtl ) Actiwuted Carlton aril Wand Ash Seirpttan ofWo<5tewater, courant_ and f3irm.;I LI { idol -sons. Water .Fert ,' timrrrtl4r.;,rifrill, 73, 335.393 Rosenfeld, P.E., and 1-tenry C. L . I fI() ) FIiedro carbon wood anti effort on Istosoltds microbial activity- mil odor. 11 "0167 E"rr„ frarrarcnr l aware$ p 3 t t i -4). 247-262 Paul F Rn%sn:ieltl. Ph D

Page 3 ends

O1-26
Ccnt.

Page 26 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2385
RTC -556

Responses to Comments
+C'hohack, T and P, Rosenfeld_ (1991) Comptast AlrLitachnont Handbook For Landscaping Praeparca{ for and distil l+utrd hy' the City +4f Redmond, Washington Slate Rosenfeld, I'- E. (1942) The hduutil Liatnui a Crater Trail, Hrnrcn„w Afogccine uf'St1:114, X2) Rosenfeld, P. E. (199.8 fhigh k3chi or I3iogas Project to Prevent Deforestation Cu. 3t. Kitts &amass 4.sa.3 Network, 7(1).

Rosenfeld, P. Il„ (1't`a8). Chorrrrteriuition. Quantification, and C.antral of ()due Emis icros From Dionolida Application To Forest Anil, Doctoral Thesis. University of Washington College of Forest Resources_ Rosenfeld, P. E. (1594). Potential Litthntuoon of Small Diameter 'Trees on Sierra County Public L.and. Masters thews reprinted by the Sierra L',od;rtty F:eanontrc C l+s+r I{ -I8, 2007), My�ass, Point Community Cxp<rsur+e To Coritantinants Ft rm A fee eeaserrg Facility. The 214 _4nnuar frvierncrraor f CogArnnccs on ,Soils '.aect:me rr and Water_ Platform lecture eonducird from LinivKrsity (if MunehL4etts. Amherst MA
Rosenfeld, P. E. (Oetober li-1f. 2CYr7). The Repeated Trespass of Tritium-Cantemtttated Water Into A $urrounding, Uommuntru horn( Repealed Waste Spills From A Needier F'ntser Flnnt., I'h+a 23"r,artrrrraIlttrerrruriorrrkd t'orrfareaces on Soils Snstrnent rrua' ,Pater. Platform lecture cond+r.-ted from University of Massachusetts, Amherst MA
Paul Rosenfelt. Ph D Page 4rel10
Junr "''Ii 19
01-26
Cont.

Page 269 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2386
RTC -557

Responses to Comments
Rosenfeld. P. L (October 1538. 2.Cr1)7) Somerville Community Exposure To Contaminants From Woad Treatment Facility Erni:snanr The 23`4.4roureal lrtlenrntOcxrutl 4":iryeronsaN urt V'c.Nis Sa'da wn$ and Kwon Lecture c ndvria+H tiara Lrniveraity €tf hissse chusetts, Arrsherst l4IA
Rosenfeld P. E. (March 2007). Production, Chemical Properties, Toxicology. & Treatment Case Studies of L,2.3- 1neblaroptoNne (fCP) The As . .trehr n,farEnwroini wile Fl aith otter Sc ences piE IS ntarirt k1'aerrng Lecture conductei trom San Diego, CA.

Rosenfeld P, (Mardi 2007> Leland and Attic Sampling for Dioxtn'Furitaa, PAIL, and Metal Exposure rn Flnrala, Ablabanua. The. EI'Srimtru€af Meetrng. Lecture conducted. from i San Vega, CAL 'Hensley A.1Z, Scott, A., Rosenfld P.F...Clark, J_J.J. {August 21 - 25. 20 06) Dioxin Contatmgg Attic Dust And Human Blood Samples 4,N)Ilecterdi Neal ,A Former ti5`ood Treatment Facility Tint' 'Frlr boreera on,u' ny'rupotdrulJ ran ffaalogencated Persist -ma O'rgarric Poldutaarits - Di al:7h"2066. Lecture conducted from Radisson SAS Scandinavia Hotel is s: asLa Norway
Hensley A.13., t4cott, A. Rosenfeld P.E..Clark, J.J.1 (November 4-t. 21yi16)_ Drnxin Contammg Attar Dust And Human Blookt SampIFw Collected Nat A Former World Tr mart Pa illit' .1 PHA f3,t ,dnnutrl !Welting it' 'xftrasi¢rnrx Lccturc cored acted flum Boston h•laseachosetts.

Paul Rosenfeld Ph.I1 (Detnf 2_4-2'i, 200.) ) Fate, Transport and Persistence of PFOA and Related C=hemicals. 1�xlt p n C'S.PF(A. &sa tae, Rtant d'e iitf}wtion Con e.veneet Lecture. axirt4uctmt from 'Me Ratumbouse Iicrtel, Ruindclpltnn. PA
Paul Rosenfeld PhD (Seiptember I. 20(.15}. Liam( naI d Flame Retardants in GroundwaterPathways In Human Jrror.itccan 7'rxtirrvalr7pa arra Reurceih rr n Pla1.L-1 E.nrwre mnr Camera, mated C"rarJluremw Lecture canductnil from 1 -ii 'ton Rotal, Irvine California
Paul Rosenfeld FLD. (September I9. 22005} Fate, Transport, Toxtetty, And Persistence of L23-TCI' PEM.

EEmerpr'g CunhPrarreacvar C-orifervrrr,a. Lwa,trectndeeted lion] Milton Hotel in Irvine. Caiiifamua Paul Rosenfeld PhD. (September 26-27, 2C.)5) Fate, Transport and Persiate:nce. oi'MBEs. . Meaky's Grraa'andwufer CC¢rf ice. Lecture cc+ndtutrd from Rns 1.,trlkstnlintel. Marina Del Ray . Galifnttua, Paul Rosenfeld Ph,D t:fun T.la, 2005'). Fate, Transport and Pensizicvne of PFOA and Related Chemicals. boo -notional Socaery £mT•rcyamreaarair F'orxmas : Fixes Ora EiusrSrn5 Caulammacmrts. Lecture esuducfc,i from Sheraton Oceanfront Motel, Virginia Beach, Virginia
Paul Rosenfeld Pb-D. (July 21.2x, 2Ini5)• Fates Transport, Persistence and Toxicology of PFOA and Belated PerilunmshemmaLs. 2005 ,''adroit Grorrr mtar As aci emit Ground Water And &'arrire+amemtnt Law C'cnifemaac:e..

Leese concluded from Wyndham Baltimore aster Harix r, Baltimore Maryland.

Paul Jdosenfcld Ph.D. (July 2-1_22. 24.0 5). l3rarmmtcd Flume Retardants m Grounduaier Pathways to liutrran Ingm,hott. Tax-Jet-4OK and Rernediatirtn ?09S ,''ariontid ( nurnndtvarer Anorrrntra,a Croar,f traroe' and k:mrrzaarmeerteaf Law Corgi -mace, Lecture crmdnr.icJ from tr4'yndltarn Baltimore inner 1-larbor, Batten ore Maryland.

Paul Rosenfeld, F"b,Ii. and „lames (lark P J] auai Roth Hesse RC; (May S-6. 200.4) Tent-huiyt Alcohol Liability and Toxicology-, A Nahanni Problem and IJnquantil'u,ad Iaol ilriy. 'a'rriiramra Oremerduizisr Asseacaattim. Environmental am Coofeiericc r.,taturrp eranaucte*J frn[n Congress Plain Hn441, Chicly.' Illinois Paul Ro,seed'ekd, Ph..f)- (March 20114) Perehlotate Taajleoludyhberlow elf LJtn Anerr4•ure tb,raaa;lweater Lecture crrnduoed from Phoenix Arizona
Hoffmann. h4 F.. Paul Rosenfeld, PicD. and Rob Hesse (20KI-4). F'erchl.cwnte Crmtruntnatiron dare Colorado Rive r Mooing oftrdregrepresentai ue.LccLureconductedfromParker, AZ.

Ptlal E Razesrfakl. PhD Pape ₹s car 16
Irma 21:119

Page 270 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2387
RTC -558

Responses to Comments
Paul Rosenfeld, Ph.D.. (April 7, _4114) A National Damage Asacasmcnt I dux l Par TC'E anal Dry Cleaners. yc;i arwrSi iron e h a-rna C:rnwrad tf aaar rsne ctfie+w. Lecture errnducted from Rat9ition lintel, Saeramenlo.

California
Rosenfeld, F, E. Grey. (Ju re 200) Two wage braliltcr fur biosohds composting odor acrntzn1. S' i h inr-ernannnor far ,Sine otnd On Sew likvameriaarr,oat aNar,(rrrsfunr J3rNrclle { ofororeen't Orlando, FL Paul 110ACJIYoki, I1a.1). and Jnmer Clark Ph .l7 (February 20-2C. 2003) Undemanding Hittorteaal LI$e, Chemical Pr ry =a Iiex, Totis an ;end 1ta u]ari x4' Cluidance cwf I,3 Dumont. )Jr�tt wiselOtowl fwa,rerrlsarc>cra$drz,t g'r °t(tw at irurfr+x Corrrs`rense. 3 eaterSnapp o and Emerging CarRarrtrnvaars.- Levurre conducted from Hyatt Regency Phoenix Ari2ana.

Paul Rosenfeld, Yk,DD. (Fehniary d-7, 2{073} Underground Storage Tank Lrtigation and Runedraton. Catii`runia 4-7;e1 Forum, Lecture cri iducted from Marriott Hostel. Anaherm ( aliintrua, Paul R.owrir ld, Pb-In (Clctnber 23. 20r12) IJndergtound F:torrge Trarl Litigation and Remediatinn P4 r: aderground Mnr- a Tank Homo] ta57e. Lecture conducted from SAMItritilta California.

Rae cnl"cld, P F';. and Suffe1, O-)ctober 7- 6r.}. 2rrt12), Undecitandiny Odut from Cnrnpast. iS'rra ewaru aru4 InLiarsrrial 1'+'aeeksas. Sixth Armand Symposium Orr Off rulaysars rn the Aquatic 1i'mtiranmenf. hnernarionai 14J'rarsr .i.v.rah-rutuart. I.r aute eranduatted grant f3andlirna'Valn.

Rosenfeld. P.F. and Suffer., M. (October 7- I0, ≥r !2) (?rung Hip Corbin Wood .dale to Control Cnmpaat Odin Strife _Jrrrwar SnrrJa?+yirraa On Off Plrirte+ra err hire Aquara'w' l: �raa§raannaa'nr. 7aararrnartramd Water Ararkiaderer. Looser eorrducta d Fero Barceiona Spann
Rosenfeld, P:R.. and Grey, M A (Sepia -oho- 22-24, 7.00) Flrocycic rnmprxdnnil Fur Coastal Sage kra9+mrtiran .h'are's. ttwstSiasrxf dfr.fimt{ amrnt 4rSaeWatarr. Lecture canducted boot Vancouver liVadungton..

Rosenfeld, RE and Grey_ N1. A. (November 11-14, 21kI,2) Using High -Carbon Wood Ash ID Control Ceder ut a C: room Materia]s t 'mpoatiag F cilia. Skari B`oome'r Society el Fume Cor1{errertve LecWae coculucted from Indianapolis, Maryland
Rosenfeld, P -E. {ettember I. 2+MI)). Two dap biofilier for hiikse]irla nampusling mkt control Wri'r Enxrrxaarrncva.r Feaatarrta]orr Lecture conducted floor Anaheim C ,] farniu.

Rosenfeld. P.E, {Octalacr 3£r., 200U) Wood ash and Haofilter control of compost odor. Br eat. Lecture conducted from,c_n saShares,California
Rosenfeld, P -E. aim) L-tioremediatian Using, Organic Sorel Amendments etTt+,farrata RegavrVe Remus} :Issor-rarirrn. Lecture conducted from Sarzarncnut California.

Rosenfeld, P.E , ' L Henry, R. Harrison, (1!9 ) Oat and C3razas Seed ieertrvnalion and Nitrogen and Sulfur Emrssiona Following ldiowlids tncorparatian With High-Carhnn Wood -.Ash. Water EnvrrornnreirtYeakrarion 12th ,'(retool 1'ietodnafe and rgarruorn,ts Alanaagenrent Canferrr?x-r PeweenIng,s. Lecian crnritteted- from Bellevue Washington.

Rosenfeld, P.E., and C 1-.- Henry 199.0) An evaluation ofaxh incorporation wiih biaaolada fns odor reductrna Stni &w ice Srrc.'+ery re America. Lecture eanductdd Boon SAIL Lake City Utah Rosenfeld, Y.li , t` t. Henry, R. Roraima (199S).. Comparison of Mtn roibial Activity and Odor Emtablfan6 Goon Thl Itrll-clout floo-w h k Alrpl. i to Forest Sord. Ftnnr,ru and r:ard-. L # eCture canducicr] from Sa ettle Vies rhinsion.

Rosenfeld, P.F,-. C L Homy (199Fi). Characterization. Quantlftcalron, and Control al' OJT Emission tam ]3iosaGds AppLicalinn To Faster. Soa fikArr, Lewttve conducted from Lake Chelan_ Washing(tnt Rua E Rnzentfekl,PhD
Page h err 10 iono 19
O1-25
Cont.

Page 271 of 54 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2388
RTC -559

Responses to Comments
Rosenfeld, P,E. C.L Henry, R. Harnsan. I;19P8) Coat and Grass Seed Germination and NiLr. n and Sulfur Cmissaana Following fiosolids Incorporation With High -Carbon Rand -Ash Water 11nvirrntment Fedemlion 12th Annual Residuals and Biesal ds Management Conference Froceeettngs. Lecture conducted Born Bellevue W sshiasIon
Rosenfeld, 1',E., t! L. Henri, R. B. Iinrrisarn, and R Bills. (19971, C amparLarn of ihlnr I=niiSSi n$ From 'hues Different Eloasolids Applied to Forest Sail Sera[ Suence Zenith.' 0. - /sera= Lecture conducted Gore Anaheim CpIi orann
Teaehin2 Experience:

UCLA Department of Environmental health (Stammer 2Cna3 homier 2001011 aught Environmental Health Solent, 100 to 9tUdents. including undcrgrad, medical doctors. public health proiesssonals and nurses Course focused on the health effects of centirutunental cnntalminrmt
Nominal Ctrtaund Water ALTSgtitvltiUn, Succeutful ketnediatiran Terhnnlogiics. Custom Course m Sante Fe, bie5.

Mexico. May 31. 2O92. Focused an fate and transport of fuel cnrdam ii ants associated with underground storage tanks
National Ground grater Mszsciatian, Successful Retnediatirsn Technologies Curse In Cheese Illinois. April 1. 2002. Focuses. on hate and transport of -contaminants assnciated'Rath Sipe -Hand and RCRA sites.

California Integrated Waste Managetnent Board, April and May, 'tNJ1 Altematiue Landfill Caps Seminar in San Liege, Ventura, and San Francisco. Focused on bath prescriptive and tatavat rue landfill saver design:

UCLA Department of F_'marnnmcntal 133ngicieurmg, February 5, 2iX,C. Seminar an 5ucougsfnl RemediatJm Technolositm focusing nn Groundwater Rlureediattim
Unnreratty Of Washington, Sad. Science Program- Teaching Assistant for several courses including: Soil ChttnE9tryr, t.1rscatic SITII Amendments, acid Soil Stability
Rerizeley. F•nttrrinmentel 41Cktil5fifi Prngram Teaching Assistant for Environmental Seienee lit 1laadernie Grants Awarded:

CaIttornia 1ntegrated Waste l.lanugement Board. $41,001,1 grant ss'aaded to UCLA Institute of the Environment.

Clod. To inveansate effect of high carton w,x5d ash .am vnliatile organic ems -nom foam compost 25511 S magus Technas[ngiea, Cairo= California $1 ti,0Ctil grant awarded to San 13ic. n Slott 1. nivtraity Goa].: investigate effect al brim hd.s for resteratran and Temedration af degraded coastal sage sails. ?rlf'gr gins t'rounly. Department of Research and Technology, Washington Stine $1111009 grant awarded re Unmet -airy of Washington : Gail. fa investigate actor erlissitaets from bi+aacrlids application and Lhe effect of polymers and ash nn 4{3r emissions 19911.

Northwest Bassett& lvtamagen1en1 AAssociatiom, Washington State $211,KIG grunt awarded is investigate etliat al poly'mern rand >Lth nn VOC emamens from hiotailiah. 1997 Juries Rtycr Corporation. Dre-gan $i 1i 7r)l grant was awarded to investigate the suede of genetically cnsineusxt Poplar trees with resistance to round -up 1996
United State Forest ,Sea -vice, Tahoe IJationak. F,rrMst S15,1600 grant was at+•arknrl so investigating fire ecology of the Talmo National Forest. 1995
Kellogg. g. Fnundatinn, Wash nisi= 17.C. $590 grant was awarded to constrtet a large anaerobic digester on lt, T<ilte in West Inches. 1993
Pant F Rosenfeld. Ph D
Rage 7 car 11} Jime'I I19
01-26
Cont

Page 272 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2389
RTC -560

Responses to Comments
Depolition anWar Trial Testimon}t
In the United Suites District rem For The lksasr1 ofNew Jersey Duarte et al, Plaintiffs Vs. United Stales Metals Refuting Company et al. Deputing Caaseho 21 Ci2 { SCM
Rtuenfuld Depolillrm. 6.7.2n) 9
In the United Steles District.Court ur Southern District ref Tc 2 CTalvt4str�n. Dvdl_~tun h T Carla hfsetak, PI'ciintrlrs. vs CrSnti I6R-, SchitTahrt - r'v1DIT & CO. Nike KG iS " C& iti Perdido' Dejrorriant
Cam, No. 3 15 -CV -0,0106 consoiidaced with 3:15 -CV -40^37 Rosenleki Dept't ition. 5-9 1119
hi The Srapoicrr C.nratt rfthe Stale of California In And For Tilt: County Onus Angelus - Banta Mutt a Cauole-Tadden-otes ct al.. v's. liana khan et at.. Defendants ease Kt7 No. 1 156:46
Ra4aifeld Deposition, I-6-2919
!n The Superior Court of the State of California Ln And For The County Of Los Angeles -- Santa hiunica The San Gabriel Valley Council of Gm,•entrnents et al vs Cl Adobe tttptti Inc et al„ Defendant.% Case No.. Nn. BC 57
Rosenfeld Deposition. I L -0-291 S; Trial 3-7-19
1n United States District Churl For The District of Colorado 13ellx et all, k iaintiffv+ The 3,,1 Company et al . Defendants CCase. N61:1C- -112131-kffl
Rirseslffkl I3epasition, ."a45-2018 and 4-3.2ii18
In ht L]Istnee, Carat Dir.Regan County. -.l"exras, k 121 Judie La1 Di n-ict I'httlip Hales et al , Plaintiff'ex Dow Attroseiences. I F r. et.ul . Defendant, Cause No 1923
Rosenfeld Deposition„ I1-17.21117
In The Superior t own ot`the State of California In And Far The Country OfCCnntm Costa Simians et al., Hai nUffa vs. Cheviot! Corporation, et al., 12efen+inrds Cause No C12-01411
Rosenfeld Di_To titian, 11-20.21117
In The Circuit Court Of The Twentieth Judicial Circuit, St Clair Counts', T1ii La 'viarllru Custer et ul . Plat i iil rs x C rrao Flaw Products, Mae.. fkfcndions Case Na.: No. 0t9 -L-2_295
Rosenfeld D.00611011, 8-23-a) I 7
In 'Hit Sumiur C,.+wt nftl>e SIAI OfC_aIif ia, For The Cowtiv c.f Loss Anselea Morn at lbert and Penny Clilber, Plaintiff vs. B.M9,r of North America LLt" Cos& No. LC 102019 (c w LiC582 t54)
Rosenfeld Dyer nsition. 8- L 6-2(l17. Trail 8-.2 -2.01.8 ht111- Northern IDLStrtCiCourt Oreem'ille Di4'is'm
Urania J. Cooper, et aL.. rtes., rs Mentor 1ne., et at., beiWanis Case Number: 4:I.6Pev-52-t fl3-Ji+M
Rnaianfeld JULY 21117
Rini L R.�x,enfeld. Ph D

Page 8 ends

01-26
Cent.

Page273 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2390
RTC -561

Responses to Comments
In The SupamorCourt of the Stair aliWasltrn tan. County of Snoihomtsh 4licharl Davis ant] Julie D lviN et al. Plaintiff Mss. Cedar (trim Compoqing Inn , Delenulank Care No No 1:3.2.03957.5
Rolenfakl DepNSitkOn, Febrwaty 1)17
Trial Much 2017
La The Superior Court of'the State of California, County of Alameda rhrirlea Spain., Plaintiff vs. Thetrna Fisher Seientifie, et.al , l)efendtn44 Cue No R014711115
Rosenfeld Deposition, September 20015
In The Lows District Court In And For Powesltttk County Ruetw]I [). Wrnhutnt et al . Plaintiff vs. D ups Hnicubergen, et a1, 1Jefendant,d Case loo . L 41 w4j2 8�1
R:nsenfeld Depr)cr]tion, ugun 31i
In 'file lows District C in Por W pella County
Jetty' Doctors., et al., PlamtifTh vas. VsIley View Sine [IC, et ml.. Defef1Attnt1 Late No,: LA.LAIO3144- Division A
Ro u ftfeld Th-Tailition, August 10115
Tha Iowa Tnstrict Court For Wspells County
Dug i'auls. et nl,. C1.41.. Plaintiffs vs Richard Warren. of rtl . Defendants Law No, L&LAW5144 . Division A
Rosenfeld Depc*itioa. Augorxl. 201.5
In The Circuit Court of Ohio Conity, West V irginw
Robert Andrews, etal v Amens, et al
Cwi1 Action Nil ]-1-C-3t1i30d
Rosenfeld Deposition, krie 24)1
In The Third Judicial District County of Duna Tina, NCI' Mexico FJott}' Gcnriali`t et I. Plaintiffs via Del Ono Du , Del (Jrr. Real auto LLC, Jerr}' Sete -sand Deward DeRuyter. Defendants
Rosenfeld Deposition: July ?r115
In The low District Court For Muscatine County
Laurie freeman at. al. Plaiutitl's vs. Gram Pnxessing Corporation, Defendant C7se No 498.0
Rosenfeld Deposition: h.fay 2ii15
In the Circuit t.N:aartufihe I 7' tudiclal Circuit, In and For Fitoiword County, Florida Walter Hinton, et. I. Plaintiff, vs. City of Fort Lauderdale_ Florida. a Municipality. Defendant. a't+e Number C CEit7irli7i N ['-'ti)
Rosenfeld Deposition: December 2014
In the Dolled Slates District Court Wesiern Distract of Oklahoma roomy McCarty; et al., Plaintiffs, v. C.lklaleoma City Landoll LLC d"h'a Southeast Oklahoma City I,,and1i11, 4 aL Defendants
Case Iko 5:12-ov-tai 152-C
Ros.Yrteld f7Gprrait in• Jn[y 2n14
Paul E Rosenfeld. PhD

Page 9 ends

01-26
Cont.

Page 274 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2391
RTC -562

Responses to Comments
In the County Court of Dallas County Texas
T. Pnn- Aruba ei aI, Ehyinedunt,
Case Number cc- l I •Ult45(I-E
Raseurehl Deposition March and Septearrl?et 2013
Ftosenfekl Trial. April 20114
In the Court of Common Fleas of Tuscarnw as County Ohio John Michael Abichs, za al. Piiviari.tft. as Republic I3ervicea. lnc, et al.. r.)*Wants a."c se Numb*.ZCii)€ Cr JO J74I i7'0t 54: 21:109 CV I II 0,387) Rosenfeld Deposition: October 21312
In rha United Stains District Court of Southern Drsmct of Texas 'Galveston Division Kyle Cantina, Eugene Donovan. an. Genie() RS tnrtez C"p0, l S.!aelet, niiJ Honey Walton, eaeh Indn iduall ;sii L on behalf of those similarly seluand. Plaivrrgfr, vs. BP Produces Nosh .rtimerisa_ 1nc,_Deyirriirint Croic 3 I I I -CV -4'I[622
Rosenfeld ] epeaition: Febru ry 2.I112
Rosenfeld trial: April 211 I3
Iry the Circuit C'ouu nt'13altrrnore Cnimt} Mary
Philip F. Cvack, 11 et 0,1 JPka ntrlf vv Tv' Faruna, Inc. J'f,. u Playa' Furls, Del -0.'1021.11u 1`nvc Number U3 { -17-112=31i 7 &'T
Roaenl'ald [ *pswitdnSeFuernber 2)13
01-26
Cont
pull! F l"tci-.0,I. uI Jhr:

Pagel rrl' lI1 Juno 21119I

Page 275 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2392
RTC -563

Responses to Comments
EX h I IT C

Page 276 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2393
RTC -564

Responses to Comments
SWAP E
hems* Canulatl8n. Dora Anew and
t uymon sum, tar the EP.Iinanzasnt
Matthew F. II-lagemann, P.G-, C: -Hy-, QSI, QSP
1640 9b St.., Suite 314 Santa
Santa Monica, ra.tltornta 90401
l 9'l 8'237-Jofi
Email ✓ L7R5ntanazijape.��t,L
Gerthigiir and I lydrogeulogic Characieritatiun
Industrial Storm ater0 mphvrsr
Inv tigation and itemediation Strategies
tJlygatlt®n Support and Te Iifying I:apert
CEQA Review
L'ducaLon
MS. Degree, Geology, Cali forma State IJtvvetsity Los Angeles. Lens Angeles, CA. I%fl-l. t3.A. D ire€, Geology. l-lumboldt State Univetsity, Arcata, CA.1981 profntsafmaal Certiflr aiitm
California Professional Geologist
Caitfornla Certified hydrogeok gist.

Qualtf 1 SWPPla Developer and Practitioner
Professional I.xperlenre;
Matt has 2:t e<•ril" of experience in envtr nnitental policy OSS 5meeit and reinaliatio+n- He spent khans with the U.S. EPA in the RCRA and SuF erfund programs and served as EPA's Senior Scieno:

Policy Advisor in the Western Regional Office where he identified emerging, threats k groundwater from perdrkarate and MTBE While with EPA. Matt also served as a Senior Hydrograa1:ogisI in theevzrsLght of the assessment ;f seven Inapt military facilities undergoing haw closure. he led numerous ent'ctrcerrient actions under prt3vasiinv Of the Resource t: onservatton and Recovery Act (.RCRA) while also working w i t h permit holders b Improve hydrogeologic c haracteri..i Lion and water quality monitoring.

Matt has worked closely w th US EPA legal counsel and the Lechrus--al stair of several states m the application and enforcement ,d RCRA, Safe 17rinking Water Asti and Clean Water Act regulations. Detail has trained the technical staff In the States of California Hawaii. Nevada, Arizona and the Territory of &ram in the conluct of investigations, grountwe ter fundamentals, and sampling technique Positions ]Matt has hokf include:
• I4wriling, Partner, Sltl;'i'4'ater,'Air Protc_tkiryEnterprise ISW PUI(20L3-pa nay, • Geology Irrtructor, Golden laiest College,, '2!010 - 2014. • SeniorEnv trc}ninc*ntaI Analyst, Komexl-t2O"Science. Inc I21.100 -11t16); 01-27

Page 277 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2394
RTC -565

Responses to Comments
• Executive Director, Orange Cost Watch (24X11 - 2R14); • S• nior `-iii ire EeliojrAdvisor ,end Hydreigec+lttig St tl . Environaterital Protection Agency f1SiRr 9P9- 1938),
• Hy'drngeologiist. ' t.-n:-iI Parkgert-lye, Water ResaurcesL ivisirm if199R -2tlt[?}, • t' dluni:t Faculty k41 m1?Er, Sdn f rarLcist'l Slate" University, Depertiriont of Ciitie'd netts - 15198),
• Instructor, College cyfMann D≥parhnentofSetencet999X3-S5 5p; • Geologist, Lt.S. Forest Serviced 1 -1''9 ); and
▪ L eologi5L Dens Vr lciooreI1L®.i-1£9ati).
eniar Regulatory and I litigation Support Analvgt.

With 45X"+', PF.. Matt's respnnsihtlihe# have included; • Lead analyst aril tes lifvi ng expert in the review of over tI 1 environmental upped. reports sierre aim under+CIRQiA thalidentity sigtiilicanl issues with regard to ham Mous wash, water resources, tooter quality, .air yciality, Valley Foii.yr. greenhouse gas emt* ions, and geulo c hazard i• Make recurn lendatlorvfrr ad dint:mai mitigation nie cares to teed agremilesat the local rind ccnrnty level to include additional characterization of haalth risks and Iniplententalion of protective measures to reduce worker exposure to hazards frond toxins and Valley Fever.
• Storm wati. analysis, sampling anti hest rrnan.1 • meat practice evaluation at in dustri.al fadllti • Manager of a proper!: to provide technical assistance to a mniunity adjacent to a I ormar Naval shipyard under a grant from the LI.S. F1='!S.
• Technical assistance and litigation support for vapor intrusion ca..r eri s • Lind analyst and ti tifying expert to the review of environmental issues In liege aj?plicattc+ris for large solar power plants before the C.itlifarma Energy Corrtmi55Ion, • Manager of a project to evaluate numerous former!), used military sites In the ivestiarn LI.S. • M,izrager of a unripretten5ive evalu+ition of potential source's of perchlnrate contamination in Sc uihem Cali:forriia drinks rig water wells.
• Manager and designated expert for litigation support under provisiems Prapcsition CAS in the review of releases of gasoline t sinutes drinking water at major refineries and hundreds of gas stet to is throughout California.
• Expert witness on two i35i'5 involving h'ITF.3E litigaion • Expert soars ss and litigation support un theimpact crf air toxtris and hazard at aschool. ▪ 1C.xpert itmss to IItigahonata former plywood plant_
With Koii,r'x 1420 S.-ience Inc., Mart's duties included the following.

Senior author of a report can the extent of peruth]orate contamination that was used In kiatiilmny by the farmer U.S. EPA Administrator and General Counsel. • Senior rNearcher iro the de've'1cIrment oFa omrrehenstve, electronically inkvai'tive chronol€>gy of MTBE use, ri search, anti regulation,
• Senior researcher In the dkvelopmer t of a comprehensive, electnnlcl ly interactive chronology cif perchlc+rate ace, research, and regulation,
• Senior researcher in a study that estimates nationwide costs for M'CB'E remediatiun a rid drinking, water treatment. result§ cot wlilch were puhlIshtti in newspapm nationwide ,imd to trStlm icy' against provisions of an energy Intl that would limit liability f,ar oil companies • Research Ica support litiy ltron to restore. drinking water supplies that have been contaminated by MTBE in Cal [forma and New York,
2 01-21
Cant.

Page 278 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2395
RTC -566

Responses to Comments
• i_K}'CIL wrtrac4s tc_¢Lim 'rl}' in a. cas-0 of oil rh' ducal ri-relat it coriIi introhon Cri Ml Ississirri * Lead author fora mu]LL-volume remedial investigation report for an operating wiled in Los Angeles that au,' siri r regulatory re.juirernera5 arul rigorous deadline4 01-27
ant.

Paige 279 of 548 in Comment Letter 01
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2396
RTC -567

Responses to Comments
• Development of strategic approaches for cleanup of contaminated sites in oonsultatirait with chess and rehTul3t.:rs.
tteculir-e E}ircctar.

As Executive Director with Orange Court ;'Butch, Matt loud efforts to restore water quality at Orange County beaches from multiple sour a, of e'ontarivmatiurt including urban runoff and the discharge of wastewater In reputing Ito a Ikart1 of Directors that lit:Iucfe€I representitives from leadirty Orange County univittsi tiiN and bust nes es, Matt prepared Issue papers to the antes of treatment and disinfection of wastewater and control of the discharge of grease to sewer 93,s terns Matt actitely participated ut the development of countywide water quality perrnils for the control of urban runoff and pet mlis for tits discharge. of wastewatter. Matt work d tvtthother nunprefirts to protect and rasttru water quality, inducting Surfrider, Natural Resources Defense Council and Orange County CoastKe er as well as with business Institutionsiatcludtngthe Orange County ESusirtass ovnctE.

J iy^dratetthrgyi
pis a Senior Hydrogeologist with Leto L.ti Environmental Protection Age c'. Matt led investigations to chtractx:rize aril cleanup closing military bases, including Mare Islanel Naval Shipyard: I -turner~; Point Naval Shipyard, Treasure Lklattei Naval Station_ Alameda Naval Station. Moffett Field, Mather Army Airfield, .and Sacramento Army Dept Speuiilc at-tivItest were as follows, • l.ed efforis to rnodel groundwater Clow and contaminant transport, ensured adequacy of mom terinly networks, alai assessed cleanup alternatives for contaminated sediment still, atxl groundwater
• initiated a regional progriien Foal evaluation of grourrclw Met sampling practices and. lalx story analysisit military bases.
• Identified emerging issues, wrote technical guidance, arulamctsted in policy regulation development through work can four nation[ LT.'S EPA wort:groups, including the Superfurtd CiroundwaterTechnical Forum and the Federal Facilities rorutn_ At the recita tt of tt.e State Lf 1lawatt .Elate developei_t a tmethodolugy' to determine the vulnerability of groundwater Iw contamination on the Islands of Maul and [taliu. He used analytical models and a (1S to show zones of vulnerability, and the results were adopted and publlshs,s1 by the State of Hawaii and Celerity of Maui
As a hy~drogessingist witty the EPA Crntrndwalrr Pail d nn Section, Matt w rkc i with i.nrovisihans or the Sete Drinking Water Art and T'~ EPA t' prevent dnnktng water oantanunit Coat Specific activities included the following.
• Received an EPA Bronze Medal for his contribution to the development of national guadan.-e for the prutectao>n of dunking water.
• Managed the le Source Aquifer Program and protected rio drinking seater of No coratniiinriiiN through designation wider the Safe Driuki.ng Water Act. l le prepared gaologicblvf6s, conducted public hearings, and reSirontled to public corninenis from residents who were very conzerned abet t the impact of designation
4 01-27
Cc nt.

Page 280 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2397
RTC -568

Responses to Comments
• Reviewed a number of Envitonmenlal Impact Statements for planned major development.. including large hazard ow and :in waste disposal ta-iltoes. mine reclamation. aril wafer transfer.

Mat served as a hy[lrogeol o ,l st with the RCRA Hazardous Waste program. Duties were as follows:
• Supervised the hydragetalugtc invastig tionof hazardous vu ante sites to determine compliance with Subtitle C requirements.
• Re!vtew ark -1 wrote "part 1}" permits for the dispnsa l of hazardous waste. • Conducted RE R.A Corrective Action InvestrgaiIons ,of we to sites and led inspeci I ors that formed the basis for six: ifte ant cndn n nroent c dens rha i were devrili-ped in close wzaord'narlon with l'.5, EPA legal court -w1
• Wrolecont tact specifications And Supervised Ctln:Ir actiJr's Investigations of ve.wte sites With the Notional Park Service, Matt directed service -wide investigations of - nlamtnant sources to prevent El cgradation cif wat i quality, including It following tusks:
• Applied pertinent taws and regulations including CERCLA. RCRA. VEPA NRDA, and the CI■^a�n tl aier Act to control military, mining, and landfill contaminants. • C.ond tided watershed -Kale InvestIRatlans of contaminants at parks. including Yellowstone and OIymptc Natknal Par&.
• Identified high -levels of perdhlerate In soil adjacent to a national- park in New Mexioo and advised park superintendent un apprupriate response actions tinder CEi:CLA_ • Served as a Park Service representative con the Interagency Perchlorate Steering Committee, 3 naliunal workgroup
• Devoiciped rcogram in aunaiucl environmental crampltance audits srf all National Parks while Forcing on a national workgroup
▪ Co-authored two papers on the potential for w atet contamination from the up€aatiort ui personal watercrall arms snowmobiles, t h--cse papers serving 35 the. basis for the development of nation- wide policy on tit t i+f liaise vehicles to National Parks • Contributed to the I'eder l M it li-Agency Source Water Agreement under the Clean Water Action Plan.

Served serli jr Irranageim iit as the. Senior Science PolicyAdvisor with the LI;S. EnvtrQtunental Protection Agency. Region 9. Acttw'i ties included the following:
• Advised the Regional Adrninistratrirand sirnlcr mtwlaagement on emerging i su such as the potential for the garciHne additive hMTBE and ammonium perehtwrite era contaminate drinking water Stipp les.
• shaped EPA's national response to these threats bv ser+,ing art vw orkgroups and by contributing to guidance, including the Office of Research and Develop avert puLltcattcwn, Oxygenates In Water.. Critical information and Research Needs..
• Improved the. technical training of EPA's scientific and engineering staff. • Barred an EI'A Bronze Medal for representing the region's 3Ll,] scientists and engineers in negotiations with the Adrninistrator rind senior manag m*2M to bitter integrate scientific principles into the policy -making process
• ERA -dished national protocol for thepeer review of scientific -documents. 5

Page 281 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2398
RTC -569

Responses to Comments
�Geal+ng;�:

With the U.S. Forest Service, lvtatt led inveattgattors ha determine hills lope stability cif areas proposed for timber hercest to the ventral Oregon Coast RangeSpecific achvrtte5 were as follows:
• Mapped geologgi• in the field. and used aerial photographic interpretation and tnetherrfaiial models to detsrmane elope eiabilily.
• Coordinated leis rnearrl-s with community members Mau were concerned with natural resource protection
• Characterized thegesaloegyofanaquiterthat eervee as the sole source of drinking water firthe city of Med foril, Oregon
As a c.resultant with Dances and Moore, Matt led geologic Investigations Qr two contaminated sites hater listed on the Superfuru NPL) in the 1'orilara%, {Jregon, area and a large hazard ans waste site in eastern Oregon. Duties included the following:
• Supervised year -long effort for <oiI and groundwater sampling. • Contiuoted aquifer teats.
• lnvextl gated ertt es ftultsb 'etlh oteS pr,,,I' nod for lie rnrdous weele L.le?a'541 1 earitinp-
From 1'99tJ to 1998. Matt taught at least one curse per semester ;at the community college and university levels
• MSan Francisco RateUniversity, heldanadlurrrtIecutLywpositionandlaughtc,irsasin environmental geology, oceanography (lab, arid lecture), ltydtog€ ]c'gy. and groundwater contantinatinn
• Served as a committee member for graduate and undergraduate students. • Taugdwt course na envtrr:mntental geology anti oceanography at the College or Mann.

Matt taught physlal geology (lecture and lab and inuicxtuctory geology at Aden West College in HuniIri icnBeach• California Iran 2C11L7to31114.
liptlktdTesthnony, Repots,. Pap liP+ Pr'+ ] PDE
Hageenann, M.F, 21.08 Disclosure of Hazardous Waste hues tinder CEQA- €Yeserttaricml to the Public Environmental Law Conference, Eugene, Oregon
lagein.em, hi.F„ 2i1t11}. Disclosure of Hazardous Waste IMuE under CEQ 1. Invited presentation to U.S EPA Re on , San Francisco, California.

Hagemann,M.F.,?x"tl'?S. Use ofElectronic Dahiliast-is in Environmental Regulation. Policy Making and Public Participation. Brownfields 2t?Q!, Denver. Coloradan. lagersrarm, M.F., iSttd. Perchlorate 'Contanttnation of the Colorado River and 1i-opact* to Drinking Water in Nevada and the Southwestern U.S. Preseritation to a meeting of the American C,roundwater Thirst, Las Vegas, NV [served on conference nrgant ring zonnnttree.).

I l aggemanrt, ht_i .. t1t11 IrwiLed ter-rir rm • to a Cali fnrnia Seniele committee hearing nrr, air toxins at schcsls in'outherit California, Los Ai-gelees.
01-27
Cc nt,

Page 282 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2399
RTC -570

Responses to Comments
Blown. A, farrow, J., Gray, A_ and Ilagema.,n, M., 2004 Mt EStTrnat of Cue-ts to Address MTBE.

Ref r. from Underground Storage Tanks and the Resulting Impact to Dunking Water Wells Presentation t4, thetIroond Water and P.nwronlrmnMI raw t'onli=rero,z. National C.;roundwater Aascictattoa
lla man% &;f,, •?illy Perchlorate Cotltamtnalion of the. C.oTorado River and I.mpacrs to Drinking Watr in Arizona and the Sciuthwestern 115, Presentation t+ a nieeLing of tlae A[nertcan Groundwater Trust P1 ' riix, AZ 1s rued on conference rrrganrzing committee). klagernann, %I.F_, 21't13. Perchlorate Lorttami. nabon of the Colorado River and Impacts Io 13rinIcins We ter In the Soul hw(sten U.S. Invltrxd prtisontateon to z special cx rntrattee meeting of the National Atmdlrny or cier:r es. Irvine, CA.

Hagemann, hi,F , 7.14T3. Perchlorate Contamination of the Colorado River Invited pre. oration to a Tribal. EPA imeetinF. Pa:hangar CA
Hagemam, 41J , 2103 Peai9elorate ConL ri1Ir ati.on of the Colorado River. Invited preservation. to a itiootmgof tribal repes`ntatives, Parker, A.

Flagemann, M.F..2L1LE3 Impact of Perchiorateon thet2olorado River and Associated Drinking 1r4'ater Suppbes- Invited presentation ro the Inter -Tribal Meeting, Torres Martinez Tribe. 01-21
lagemann, 41:L.. _I:s11 The E mergeire of Perchlorate as a Widespread Dnnkarig Water l.ontamt r ani. invited presentation to the U.S. EPA Region 9.

I I agemann, A{i 2L' 3 A Deductive Approach to the ,4 wwtmartt of Perchlorate Contamination. Invited rimier -rota lion to the California rni Assembly Natural ftlesktinces Committee.

Hagetnann, 41.F. ?L113 Perchlorate: A Cold War Legacy in Drinking Water Presentation try a meeting of the ati nil Groundwater Association.

H agemann, M1i.F., 2i%Y? Err~ n lank to Tap: A Chronology of Mt'l3F in Groundwater. Presentation to a meeting of tile National Groundwater Association_
Hagcmam, M.F., 21,1a1 A Chronelc+gyo f MTBE in. Groundwater and on Estsmare of Lo>`ts to Adder Iml*,tcts to Groundwater Presentation to the annuli meeting cif the Saeiely of Env'i.ronme.ntal Jour nalisls
Hagemann, tal.F. 2102 \n Estimate of the Cost to Add rem With Conlanninatic,nin'Groundwater (Anil Who WIL'1 Pap PrL'sentatien le a meetings f the National Groundwater Assiz,c:iatlun.

FIagentanrt, M F., 2L1Li2 An Estimate f Cot'; to A41dr _ AdTEIE RdOdt_cc from Linde -ground Storage 'T'anls and the Resulting Impart to Drinking Water Wells. Presentation k, a meeting ti3f the U.S. EPA and State: L'rvdeerground Storage Tank Program n gees
Hageramin, 1GI,F., 2001, Frc+rn Tank to Tap. A CIiimology of MTBE in Groundwater Unpublished repast
T
Cant.

Page 283 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2400
RTC -571

Responses to Comments
Ilagen artn, M.1., 2Lat11. fsttrnatM Cleanup Celt far MTBE In Groundwater Used as Drinking Water.

Unpublished sport
lagenaan t, ryi.F'•, 2001. kstimated d ce..ts to Adds s MTIIE. Releases from leaking, l!ndergrnurrd S1,01 -at Tanks. Linpublished report
Hagrrah,tnrh, 1I,F., and VanMotrwerik, \l, 1999. Potenital a l e r Quality Co cerrs Related to Snowmobile t [sage. Will rerEPSCIUn Division. National Park 5cr-s'ioe, Technical Report, Van,Mc i werik, M. and Hagetnann, 1999, Water Quality Concerns Related In Personal Nr'atercrail Usage. Water Rearturces Dtviaicri, National Park Service. Technical Report Hageorann, lui.lF., 1999.. Is I?il.uii n the !solution to Pollution in National Parks? I1+e Uecrge Wright Society Biannual Meeting Asheville, North Carolina
Hagetn nn, Mi, 1997. The l'otenlial for MTBE in Contaminate Crowl1water. 115. EPA Superfund C,rnurulwaier Technical Forum :annual Mtieetrng, I.as Vegas_ Nevada Hagrtn.riri, hl.F , and Gill, M , 1996, ImpraIi mn t_o In Inrrrrteic Re necllathnn. Moffett Field Naval Mr Station, C"nnlerence n Intrinsic Rernerhathnn of Chlorinated Hydrocarbons, Salt I .ake Citrt Hag entann, I.I , Ful unaga, CL.. 199 The V'ulneraMliry.of Cnaundwater to Antbropogenie Contamtna.nter on the Islam! of Maul Flaw all Hawaii Water. Works AssE.s-.tatian Annual Meeting, Maul, October 199&.

I 1,1. I. FukinaFe, G. L., 1996, Ranking Groundwater Vulnerability in Central Oahu, Ha,•;,rii Proceedings, t_:+xrographic Information 5ysterrrs m Envtrontnental Resources Managenienr. Air and W.tete hlanagentent Associatbon Publication VIP -6L Ilagetaiann, Mi'., 1994_ Crowxlwaief Characterization and Cleanup at Closing Military Sae in California. Prr. cestiling , S`a L#onva Groundwater Resources Association Meeting.

Iiigemann, M.F. and Sabel. M.A., 1993. Role of the 11 5. EPA in th11 lligh Plains States Groundwater Recharge Demonstration Prowarn. Prweedings, Sixth B.rerr n& Symposium on the Artificial Recharge of t. rowtdwntec,
flagetnann M I 1993. U.S. EPA Polic on the Technical Impracticability of the Cleanup of DNAPL- contamirrated Groundwater_ California Crnundwater resources Arssociail.on Meeting.

Page 284 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND 11942
November 2024
2401
RTC -572

Responses to Comments
Ha eimmia, ; i.F , 1992. CCense Nonaqueuus Phase Liquid Cunianllnatlon of Grokunthe.aler An Ounce of Pre ration-., f rot lings. AFseciatioora of Engineering C,Ecrl: ,is4s Annual Nieating. v. 35.

T)titer tiWerii1is 4
IVrrrxi i subiect matter expert for the Cali(rnia Prefeswrial t;n"I•egi t lacewing exarnlnateon 200P- 2011 .
01-27
Cont.

Page 285 ends

Rancho Mirage City CouncilDecember 18, 2025

Rancho Mirage City Council
December 18, 2025