Cities Index.
Agenda packet

Rancho Mirage City Council
December 18, 2025

Document
Agenda packet
Meeting
December 18, 2025
Body
Rancho Mirage City Council
Pages
5,391
Original file
10.5 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on portal.laserfiche.com. That file is the official record.

Village South Specific PL {Prnposea) - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Annual Ode. 111202021 2.26'PM
tuNanwa7nps
WiehlcbTApa
ST_TR
STTil
4 8.19 3.75

44.30 92.49
UnOleilltSTIl 5T_TR 13.97 1x.74
.... 4 ........- I
mM1renleleT'a[e 9UTR €..a7 c
4▪ -- 1
Wilfshlclornw SU_TR • 086 I. '0
4 rONahla iTi1 BU ii 106 a S3
uahkaTriim .SL_trt la I.S4
tiMhicbfinps 9U_TR y G9.5
4 4
16NahIo•Tnps 51._710 77,18
l*NahicbTnpa i 54.'_TR # 24224
a
6=NahklmTri s 'h4_T1t • B.'J4
-4
4 ttM1hhkkTnps YN3_TR 6.86
-•
Ibrd+ehkleTrips WO TR 11.03
. ._..- tMelehkkTn 4 AD_TS
ttitifehleisT(0
4-
t8{Vehlelernpe
„ .,,.,., �rxltcarnp�
-4
WELTS
12715
6 17y
• 452i_TR
,,,,,..4 ..
4"X3_171

83.E6
1270
tttiVibatt5b7.^tm NueberCatalylc
MfolC.t se * • Ncrmlz rAltaly1c
•

4. 125

11.n
1711Wooctiovee N81ll9r"WncatahtbG
tti'dle rvrs • t{9I ,14cnwblytic i 45,77
4 taiWocKtgavee Wimiatmdaylaer 35.00
4-.. 4
125
Velf0.B2]Ya • 4fpcOsmrcbayTar 2 .®
. .....,....... .. .......•
tt600906INWS WtYomt•r4w.lottaasa
t�Wboc .'� • 117m e,4"aodAa� • 594611
74,01

6.x.9

4.13 841
65 10

3.21 82.64

9.43 aDD
0 Da
O .04
▪ Da
a.0a
CHM

2.0 Ernissions Sumrnary
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2899
04-25
Cont.

Pale 152 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1070

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CJIE FI.kad.2o16 3.2 Page 4 of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Prnpasea) - Las Angelee-Sauth Cost County, Annual 2t Overall Cnnstn,lrltnn
llrmlli6gaWw Col to k:lion
Dole. V12.0)21 2.26 PM
—
ks00
RY,'ri.
t.7
$ft
F.,pUre
Poll()
Eel ¢uel
P4710
WHO
Tn441
Fu61ie.

Pill
EAxui0l
P41
P1.1i`_?
o1
94n -COO

NEW- DX
Tula] OW
'011-14
k.QO
0100
Yew
lone r
f6T7
2001 •

0.11111 • I 11 4 • _ .5-- u - 41?a- • 01111
• r•M1
00117
O.4G5 • 01?011 • 0015.4
0 own., • 0x10704
410011.4 r J 041 • 070)0 •
'G
'GO
ass E.
:ss,,
0 5865' • 4 074 0
a r�s
rr 1 c • a11m
0 36rs
4rm� .141u25
1g1e4ss 1 !._.. • 6G�3 •1*i1BpF

• .=.a9
e 4
�
4 t.. 0..14..1_.411
a
4 5
;)023 •
06194 • 37&54 • 4.74;8
401.4' • 06�T
OWN
444th + Ct'�:u3 • 4961]
. .,
43199
. .... .
490GG • 1.5474.11

12.42041
,:
0 ,114 . 641994 •
..
1516.779
2 +
•
- ---iii
7031 .
u1692' • 9.1013 , C 0117

14.CC#I - • 6.0221
4a60 -
016.343 , 11117101 r 0.BPo47r
polio
QC7790 • 44.6046
_
41:119$5
7010110- + 9.01960 4
44,331f.
e . {
ON .
6119
1 103 f
CO
1 +
Imo" 1 P
9lai17um.
41092

1.4210

6.1646
410156
49999

1.11]
vatio

0.2619
01106
(LdG41
6,6009
4,113!66

1.419.454
01210

1.9006
*421.692
4 11
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2900
04-25
Cont.

Page 153 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1071

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CesE FlOod.2O16 3.2 Page 5 of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Prnpasea) - Las Ave lee -South Goat County, An11u31 2,1 Overall Conftruclton
fatialedit 1a11euuetian
Ogle. 1112)2021 2.26' PM
0147.3
R.1.N.
00 001
Tv4L
01/16
Gr¢u91
pMll2

8.1119
1281,91
Fa01lxe
712021
0,l.n1,1
P1421
PI,i24
Triu4
Pin -000
N[II- CO2
Tula]
&I4
1420
00 'fear
Deer
PA el,
AG,' •
Mil •
.:.-•.•."1
533
7431
•

0.1301 • l0211 • • .5-
.;31-•04- . 01141
00317

0.4668 a 01184 • 00154
02547

0.[12604 • �t10766I • :,'107551
I340C 041,,01
112)658
C97
I530.229
7 44.8311 T
454345 • 4 074 a E. `:.6.%�
•
"7 a ',.: -a9
`.
a•i'S
1 .iI faa Sm . 91E[9
$
0M11
9[999 .1 e1E1�4 •14i8S55
0 C.
i4--+: 4-

1. l5 • 996?] •I*75
_. r
-. --i
03149 • 32104 • 4.73 8
�<,
9014' • 04437
09481
0441 • 0....:13 . 49612
. .,
03199
.«.. + D• 13
'0.0&.3:
40044 • 1.342440 • 1..342.44-2
V
f
J u 115 • 60603 •

4.1692 • 9.1313 • [.2107
, {

6.09491 • 17.=1
694' ,
.333666-
0119
010.28! , 9,49U1a
1 603
r &.Shine-
f CO
46114
Q.CL99 • 44.3;54 •
1 • •
44:4354
I&MGo- • 4.41669 4
1 P
h amiTianl.
41912
40240

0.1644
04116
1114409
el 11Th
141:21
17519
411144
(L3631
0,01144

1.414-d6
0 1.4111453

11.1210
49M4
11421.12
1 0001
Co
4109
Fuldtha
9 -Eau[
731112
P1419
Tag
F—
FTR26
Evh
PI€24
PM2-3
Talal
Bid- 002
Taal 002
CH4
1330
0024
069
0,79

0.00 +109

01.04 0.1YI
l 06
0 01+4
4 -cc'
0412
44Q
003
0c.0
Wino'
Stars Vag
End Can
NaOawm unwripalett 4100.+N00 aing.'verrarf
ITram,.1 Obligated •ICG 4 IOU foam, ga1e•I
i
041.7981

11.}9.3421

1.1{0.
, .,791
2 12.s-2321
3-32.241eZ0
1 77.'4
..,...

I

1.0.2032
1902022
_. !.I -rig
i '493
J •
4- -211122

14.,11-2457
w 1 '.15'
: ' di":
3 -1.2022

11.',14-01742
,
0 12-1-0477
4-7$.017'3
1 r,-.7%,
. 4:'1,28
11-4-2095
4-34-04128 i
I
u r.,,_tl
10 491 •
9 5-)9923
1 3-1492 }
0'_L.:,, I
C°."1r1
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2901
04-25
Cont

Page 154 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1072

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CelE EIA0c1.2096 3.2

Page 6 of 44 ends

Wage South Spot MG Plan {Prnposea) - Las Angeles -South Coast Coulry, Annual Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
9 0_r. 2.]23
11 32 292?
09222

0.6F95
10 '2' 2613
I 2c202224
•
`^2757
2®?5T
11 — _�
5, 2113.1
'5,111-2822
1nwa_
117155

0.50591
2_4707
2037

2.2 Oven II Operational
4hirnItigtares? WalMtIO.tAl
Rog
5704
Ca
902
ivptrw
FM 2
F✓Yn.1
P4110
PF110
Tc11
20042
P12 0
1821.x...1
01125
P1.125
? 224
142, CO2 4Pf,.

CO.

TOINIM'
C1-4
1,120
C07
0202302!
Inno?
WA,
2422
o 5 :4.'17 - •1292 • 145444 ; 1 2J00, 00TI 1 00714 • • 0.5T1.1 • 00714
O.CGJ4 • 220 '40 • 220.6576 • 00201 • 57✓4): • 420030
9 I

I Y DLO
@ @
P W ,
1- 1 1 P
@ 1 1
•• En..6r
= 9r.7b6
12812 1 67116 7Cv5lXIo-
194Pty5 • 00105+ ; 00650 •
ONO
OM* tl 8.665UFO ,. 9.@65OFA• 01962. • 60186 79812.2119
....11041.
•
a 003 -
F
: 2 i 2 i i
2 E 1.5857
79712 : 19.1934 00$91
77679 0058 785 2.1275 c 0
21#1.1
46d76J. 7R3] 4081? K0.4081 0341 . 6406] i.
782.012.

M
• I
P ; P
1 6 1 8 1 P
1 2
..Moe

0. COCO •• 0000) . @ OM.
01)5)1
2[+1'5419 tl 9 O 247.5470 • 12281i , ISO 1514535+
r
r
.
i a r
i
2 r val.-
000[0 • 00067 a 1 0 C •
06]610
-1:2-1E32 . . 5591420 . 'x.56052 1 10194 69?55 7132379K Tda
50007

4.5223

34.9400
20214

7.7772

6.1366

1.2740
201125
542216
23114
41£.9712
12294.78

12.591215
,'x2904

0.17%0
22969.47
02 19
31 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2902
04-25
Cont

Page 155 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1073

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad Version: CJJE FI.kad.2O16 3.2 Page 7 o14A
Village South Spot.alc Plan {Prnposea) - Las Angelea-South Coast County, Annual

2.2 Overall Operahtonai
t•tirti}lai7 sl r.4titn3al
CJrde. 1112)2021 2.26PM
R47a

7.1,
4`7
SO;
fwpL?
P4410
L. mill
04714
43411
T5191
FJa4.k•
P424
5A..30
4142 0
P.412`_!
r *
130 0032
N13o, CO2
Tula] OW
-21-14
WO
CDa.

Col--pmy
loner
MTh,
• •
__.
a471j
E1Fr11y
A7dsia
01437 • 11:550 • 143454
16707.. a i 0.0714
UL
00114 . • 0.4014 •

0.0714
41 ]I4 • 2204•070 : > 1P5I4
J0271 • 314004 •.7.25930
rCb
5 2
"-144244
0",344 • !.'3i? + C^i7
76rt 14r 00309
033
0aa3e
. 0.09
• 00539
..0C,r..
21444
0029 .344507 92£14.6"3
:
1' 2 5r.m,9 73913.253
l- r • r.9562 • la.le3a
0 DK , • 7 7117
0 O
72140
2 M
0 M .r,45a.492. r 644.443
9 3 340
amrca3 .x0a'..rw
Mae
_.-

t
_
O.WaS
9050
• 'P axo

8.0144
2vr.4AY3". sows . use 14174

12.2F•b
alms 7
'r
aaam
aoW3
.
a '3goa •
acuaa-.1

29.102] .559.1422182343102.
30141 • 60715 Tffi5"667
f4440
6444.2
95233
30113463

6.604a
elfin
1F?26a
410244
Y6/9y..
02114

1.3114
256,44912
I2t244 01
41 13,661 15
912

0.1464
41340
4296343
69 R04.

ND•
t#
304
►vjli3.

FYih
5A-R3Jw
45610
1r514
Tie..
ru0i3r.

PaT.5
Exhwa
0M35
4642.5
TAN.
!iu•CO2
NElo•C133
x44..1444
am
Nib
GG3*
F.rean!
N+'I 1.11
WA
(1

0.30 &U4

0.116
0,09
450

0.44 1311

3.03 0130
4120

0.00 00a
U.0]

0.411

3.0 Construction Detail
GoCS4RUcti4n P
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2903
04-25
Cont

Page 156 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1074

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CeIE FM0(1.2416 3.2
Page El of 44
Village South Spocills Plan {Preposea) - Las Angela South Coast County, Annual D. I/122021 2.26 PM
vnage Mime
Phaee Type
:09TOlt.P4 iU1m4lIticri /91121721 114112/21721 !; 34,
4 e- -J —I -I— 4
•6rti x4104 rb]d13r2!O≥≥1 11115Y'..7L1 5. 2ti;.
-- —4-. 4......... ......... —......
iProsln9 f,11014n021 11r11Y.2tR2 1 51 AIN
r
II- i
t "MON 01S14.44ah dngCenstunto • "ii0122.122 -- ; 1x1201 — --� 5; 150D;I L. ..... ...... � ... 4............ .......-..• 0 "PRpina ,fin$.. IiS119r3Ui? I1Yv�C₹@4 dr 3b.
•
FArcndecturalCvaflr.4 ` .hrati,f—.IC..441142 "1a1/ 24 )�'1 4 # fi 5e t
Phase nose 1ian
+Sre Prere slim
..preying
Acres of Grading (Site Preparation Phase); 0
Acme of€3rading (Gracing Phase): 112,5
Acme ofPaving: 0
Residrnfiai Indoor 2,025.000; Rtslclen#al Outcioos 875,000, Non-Rtxltfenilel Indoor: 926,400; N©n-FRreedontlat Outdoor: 108,900, StrIped Parker) Area; 0 (Architectural Coating - tgt1J
0(
RRaod I:Cluvrnen1
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2904
0425
Cont.

Poe 157 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1075

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMad Version: CJJE FM0c1.2416 3.2
Page S of 44
Village South Specific Plan {PTapasea) - Las Angelee-Soutth Coast County, Annual C. 1112.'2021 2.26' PM
ptert e ttlItte
CAS PIrd EPI..0Ste t 'Rare Albers L
I LheLp....ir},I3 i iiryrt'e Prue] r Lie] Frctal
Demmer'
••.41"..06,1,4.ratnwl Saws 1
5Q0: H1: a.73

l7emolloon
g........ � ........... I —i.........
;E. Paraders 7
�
64D: 1,-3: 4:35
t]amulifon
•Rutesrlinrebemrs I- _
600. 247: 0 e
R,..
�.

See �Preperalbn
.........F..........�..
;Ruhher Tired iltseera•• •
. . .. � .... .
600: 247• 0ai1
-... .. ...
-iceDP
S`ie P sKaaslkm
.Trmetrsd---LuedersiBaethces ---
a 37
GraCMS
;EN.Sse
aOD: I56; 0,3d
naming
-t--
Grapes r I
1UQ+ 167: D.4T
��-.........
'.... ............................

C�adng
I-- F_.._�M__....�._
•Rubber Tired mIs l
BDO 247: D.4a
G:aaln9
-F' --
:Scrapers a _2.
......... ..._....
.68Dw •.749
BOO:
•____
C�idleg
�+Trethrs.LcederrEschtiter4 _
__
500. gin a.37
130101ng CareEaetien
WCrarree• e
I (ICI 271. 0.29
11 •FOrkaffi
6D0� E9� 0:25
BJIkIIng Carend- m
'•••.,• .. .
. :GlirreretOr
^
SeiSeitz 1
�,•
- EDO. I4 -0.74
B IklingCorc4.*'j Gcsn
__-_--- ___
____F
____I I ....

Bulltllna Crorse,.rcMan
•TraclnrTMLoaderaE Ptri0 t 3
.___
T00 DT: 0.37
601111(19 CxPEVLICtgn
:WeiceID C 1
BOO: 4®: 0.45
Paying
P ws F
1100 !00 0.42
.....................
�
- I---
800• 132; '11.30
Paying.

P3lIn11
R•on s F 2
D4D~ Qh39
ArButtGrmi Maing
*Air oomprassm 1 600. TS. f:a.46
Trim and VMT
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2905
04-25
Cont.

Pale .58 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1076

Responses to Comments
CalEEMad Version: Ce1E E=1.kad,2016 3.2

Page 10 ends

Village South Spot.glc Plan {Prnpasea) - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Annual Ode. 1112.'2021 2.26'PM
PPM* I"49 Rid
ammo
Q6,Irt
W oikE1 TriI7
Irlu nlxr
46i919r TnL 9,RUIPA 711E
h1Lr11Lef WI Iflt I
ihother Tip
Leng≤rl
rraot Tnp I H®unllenfl
Length Ldnoln
Vic ver64 I:&aII04' I Hsu6rg
G�ea Y®ritiediae Vehicle vus
Den& 1114641 6 1...—: ..-3,1 -..I.=:;• ',. n. t 3..: WOO 4.2_4lir 1F ?T_l,II I! +I -IL'.^ ate Prepantian 1 1340• 0 0 a.u1a; ID CIO ow. 20 00 L©_Mix IaS9T'A9®t '• HHL�T C 4Irg •F 8 247.40 001E 0.0P• 10.04 6E4rr 37.00 LO_Mlx Fgi7_61C% 99}HH0T LLikllrlp Ctlrz+f0 Low, - •I- gi sal our 143- XI. 0. 0801 20 CO LO 1Aix • H6T 1Ala 'HHDT '- -II- ----1 I --4- 1.....:- ---- ------ ---
Peving r2. T_.00• •D. .1x1 0] 0• 10.04. 6.971 30.4014©,•Mix •1177-M[x IHHEIT F- . -•--I I - 1 I t I •• • .
rWr[hteeLu el C©ettp : i• M90.00• 00%% 000• 1D00• 040; - 20. CO;L€1_k111r ,1-107 Ws • HHDT•a

3.1 Mitigation Measures Construction

3.2 Demolition -2021
VVmiltivittIJ. Qetslructilan C i4t
RROG
Na'ti
CO
SO2
FAA.

Ffd 10
Fi:,RR
FR+l1C'
FU O.

TRW
r-o9Nr:,e
FRCS
Ed, --..3
.%12:7
ANa.3
T.
454 4-�2
NBu-c9q
Fidel DO
CS.
---.
,.7.?..

Calupuy
•
lowdyr
r -T1.'
F41lkv I3, O�0�23 Pc•X9 • 0,1169 • 7.61471- • FIRM ' 7a`b 0 bas raT
••
PIS • 4.1ID:c. Jir:17c •
. :uW,.
-9 rr�a

30.0. 513r1P1
• Oir7ti o.- coo's • 0-4719 • 0 • S.RY"L i- • • noul • O.rQ1p • YW?re • RAM6 044
• • • • • • • •
• LLY-• 510017 0i te1? • 00194
•
f 0030 •
Tsui
.&0976.

0..&71&

0.3725
dT5i06c-
OM
�.04I
d4273
lLU] 4
T.5i00o-
000
00216.
a&
*ONO

51.0012

51.00F2

0.0141
00000
51+360.1
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2906
04-2r_
Cons

Page 159 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1077

Responses to Comments
CalEFMod'deonion: CJIEFMod.24163.2 Page 11 014.4
%loge South Spet.Slc Plan {Prnposett) - Las Ange lot -South Coast County, Arl1ual 3,2 Deinclilkal -2021
Unitittistaled Cons.lruetion OlfSit4
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
*04{
NO.

CO
S'Cr2
Fu1!=Ioe
py 11
L6i Y..31
rA.11O
PPM I0
Ymlil
F4a71ve

1.1.C:.

Sims'
*47.7
4141,4
r, 1

11.0 -02
Nth, IT,CC
Mil -00e
4 RYl43-
=de
Cetepoy
!ably-
Mier
Ili.IF1p
vwe..h4 ••
..-.. .,1'-
v, 4... ....mow-
w 1. r'34a9•
UCd

4.4:4 • 0.47411 • 1&.TL14 • 3P-4(0.-• 1011p44 • a. 13f.04 • 'I.Cd]I4 • I 4,104.1• ,, 1. TAXI.- 4CX b0! ups ON to u13 ON ; [C0
• +.7.585
174[6.E
1?1GCd- • CAWa9 .
•:Clt
174 8E-0
' ,
norm
9 •521i3
atom.
p. xa r�ry:pn . 0.020[ . 7 p002 • 017900 • V).O:CYI • OIS0:1 OWOt� . .7.080 11000[4 . Op370.

OClM10
R
scum . Dm
Cei
_i
730W. . a[O0Ga. . 2CCCia- • I /}If1.0G- • IDOOprr- • L.009t. • 4,33}Oc: • I Fj09pa- . {9Bppll- NI • CI' -U . :0 • NS . C7.5 • CO3 r 10+ • 0:6 • r•q1
0 W • 1.5361 i 92p4
.

OCCOCa- • 0.pWp •
C7R4 • i
Nol
! vim*.

CO3
UM.

9.42'!0
IIIWLIe.
bid
bAZII
1185
LJJ1OU
Stu
&tom.

NM

1.ltd .

Oils

1.110040•
Mt

1.F2We
etsl.

A11•90
1a.pal,

11..9E17
t.2l0aa.

OM
sum
1!101
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Sitt
aat
FMK
126
r3tG2
Fughe
i.1A M
[liana[!
F 1IO
Phil 0
10111
rilAVG
MU:.
e,_A
PR12.O
th•1:3
Trtal
Llu Gs2
HIND -tip
Idol =I
1144
WO
case
=boon
luscl3r
MCry
Y.. -
A.

FtgF.rA Dust
U R.=
t _- -.
•: • • • • • pgmge • OBC1a0 • .4.0166 • 7.Fi1474 • [Kam , 7,S1004- on ace .
•• •• ••
_ _ - - -- - Al

0.L®Cp • Q1�} 0.Ot00 • M OM • 0.0®0 . 40 .°0'
00475 • 0471E1 • 03;715- • 5801117 • 0.07!3 •
F704
• •

0.0213 • p4G'rb 30.'�Ifi •
•
01:1000 • O1❑011
•
STUD • 00144 • D0OM • 51aiOp
Total
41B47
DA7
@.377sn
p.7®41B41,3 1i
bid
O.O4I

4.21321 L
2i
T.01044.

MIS
1:0276

44.41 ,.0410

01.01111

51.01111

0.41144
DM=
81_iap0
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2907
04-25
Cont.

Page 160 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1078

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: CIF FMod.2416 3.2

3.2 DemcIitIo -21121
daMi tma ttad Construction Off -Si.

Page 12 ends

Village South Spot.glc Plan {Prnposea) - Las Ange let -South Coast County, Annual Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
41404
NO.

CO
aa2
Pul!=Int
ply 11
b• -Y..31
Pr.11O
PPilO
TrAryl
kW.,
..

Sims'
017.7
4142E
rmai
12YF CO2
ratio- CCQ
Ttlal-0fae
044
Rrl43-
6:(324
Col epuy
lu,Ny—
Mier
IiMM4
YwrJW
..-.
4Ta•F.n,
.«.
. IIgMX-
tc0
04:4 • 0.47411 • 17•415A.. • 3Pux?r. • 1tQGIl,. • a. 1pf7Cy • I CON* • IA744e• • 1.5841~ , 004 pps ON or3 mu x6+ 1 ¢aa
0c • 117.5113-,
174KsE
1?IGC+- • G.wDD .
cm
17 4516L
norm
9 &3id
a 0 OC{9
.. ..*
C 3X4 . r, P%:60 . 0.03(.1[ •. .7 F1002 • - 017900 • U11136 • G I D3 error . .7.080 •—C
,_
0 OmG . 0.037L1
omen
'wow • - G.0000
?204rio-
cCM
_{
730Wc� . ac�0p0¢. . 2.0:0114- . l /}IfY]G- • IDOp0a- . LC09t. • 4,33}Oc: • I FJ090a- . {.9116317 NI • rYIU . :i]: • 008 • {e.5 • 003 • 00+ • 0:6 • ud!
0 W • 15281 i 9:64
.
5[r]OCa- • O.p0ij0 •
OR6 • 1
17401
12,llOlk"
003
ultra#
lA2'J11

7.OP➢9e.
bid
bum.•
1185
LW40m
0tu
tariff.
005

1.11444.
000
two.

MA

1.F2we
9ca11.

UMW

14.Y&17
1p..9le7
1210!4=
KG
IJIT
1l.W161

3.3 Silo Preparation -211'21
ibr'1Tl tidaletl C.Ur lrauk:tii;rll 1741-5.tr
AOG
r,r3.,
CO
0-Gl2
Fupme
iPlyl l•3
borL.n
F 1IO
Phi ID
14111
r-aA,r
MU:.
tJmsl.

PR12.O
r.1:3
Trtal
Wt.- t%2
Idol OW
044
(920
Cate
C3ltp Ry
lu4cl3r
v
MTh,
Al
-+.E. 0usr :
•O116 Rai=
w
i i i i 0 .1@37 • 014300 •0.1ffi7 ; 6047]3 u 0g03Ti '14311 •
• •
••
=CI • Q03:1} acme • pA000 • 7.0070 v7'30C'0
••
di 111,
11 4 • 0.71r5 • 3MCC. • 0.0301 0.4'23+ • Rill 0!3165
W4 •
1 i • - • e _
OO0O0 • 33.4157
•

33.4457 • 00lce Lama] 3771161
• _
•
Total
Q.OCIf6
DAN* -
OAF
4E11p
exam!.

MA
4,16,17 •

0.07011
9-2011

9. MO
MOM
LL'1151
11O7eC

30.435i

33.4807
Melt
OAOZN
3b. 7041
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2908
04-25
Cont
Pale 161 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1079

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CJJE E1.13d.2416 3.2 Ngte 13 of 4A
Village South Spot .S]G Plan {Ploposea) - Les Angeled-South Coast County, Annual 3,3 Site Preparation -2021
Unmitigated ConaUuclion OffSik
Ode. 1112.'2021 2.26'PM
9Ot,
NO.

CO
ae2
PAW,
btA 11
L6r74.11
m11.,
Pkil I0
114,1
F40ave
P14
Sims'
x1..7
,1203E
rrn.1
1114. ec.2
Nth,-CCC
that COO
144
N27.
6::3214
Ceh$oy
14,Ny—
Mier
111MW
..--...s.....--
.,4 4.:.
030® . ai.rxO 147. EMU . II ''- • a3C07 . OW1P
OAa7o
DWI, 0 _OW , 1L
0132] ri.0io[.
0CCOa
o .30gr • aBlEw
0om1
.A OCtO
1 2MA
VG7 -.:af'
-------.4�----..— -,...--i.--.•
1O:ta7
6CN3 u{OOx; . '..:rC
00000 • comp
omen
Ci +:ThY. . G.0909
.-
w 83000. • • 1X9.• 4 2,7042 • 1.00[x7- . 1.34334- • . r1u0a- 031 . X901 • KO x WI, . NS , {7E1
-
1111X.1.
033
- --+---� . .. ..«a1...-

3.00C.Na • 1 70004. . = T47.

OP, • 0:6 ':171
....4.......--.. .........4............4..... e..

0.0➢C1 • I.2779 1 0
.
4 c.: 2 14- • 0.0009 .
((11 . ,
Not

9.7000.

Obi

4.3omae-
«4

43.'61"
MO
11M9e,
OM
1,246Pe•
003

1.41106.

WS
Otee x
tat
3,6000.
904

1.1k011
0115
Lrum .
107
u.0a+a
1ZZ

1.=
UMW.,
WS
mom
tffi4
Mitigated Construction On -Site
aet
r41Jx
Ct.
b
Fu@he
PM v3
b.fsnfil
ROM
Philp,
lath
Fuemr
PNQ.}
b,1 14
PR12.3
thi:3
Taal
tO4 I2
HIND- 1400
Idol OW
044
WO
0,33e
=ISOM
lutcr4r
MTh,
FtgI.rre Oust :

U R4413
• . . • 0.1417 • 0.1:•300 ffir 7 • 1.1 • 6000.1 • DOM . '10=

•• ••
439[0 • Q.43:13 acme • amo • 0.0070 0'30.'9
••
110300
• 0,354 • O.i}r5 . 3ADC41. • 01.307 0.0234 • OL1S& 101OS 007
• •
003Ca1 x 0242147

30.4357 • 001[45 00011 0370PA
•
Total
Q.Ciilil0
0,1091,
02110
371091.

VOA
,:1017
611001

9.2011
4WD
00124.•

0.'1181
R. CM

30.435F

33.430.'
0101118
02000

30.7090
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2909
O4-25
Cont_

Page 162 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1080

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod'deonion: CJIE FIkd,2O16 3.2
3,3 Silo Prrparatlon -2021
Mitigaded Consirvrnon Off -Silo

Page 14 of 44 ends

%loge South Spot MG Plan {Prnposert) - Las Angelo South Coast County, Annual Ode. 1112.'2021 2.26'PM
110G
NO.

CO
aa2

1.011.
14 11
L6a4..11

4.110
Plul IR
T $,4
7414t1.0
RV..
6i¢fasl
011V I'
14d:E
r, 1
Pst. C.02
N154- i.CC
tilffl ✓3OE
144
N2.1
LX3214
Cah-toy
lu,v6.—
r+lrer
I1JA
•••YrrlA

..--,..s..... —.4-------.4--..t,..--........-4—..
v, .k.. .+
0=0 . 0....X0 O. C17(RI . II . "- 430X1 . 0WOU
• •
ii woo
owl, [Lox. _1 k
0oro 0.000G
Ocow
o 0000 • rariu i
•
00r[11
.
.7+1�
..•
I �4
u Oro" . 03x04 ,3 au •.. 5oir .— , ----,
9"G1.. -.:af'

�^�:tA
-:
6r 1 a-i{Ca: '. 'C
-
QmGCi • comp
7OCNiO
Ci �:@Y� . Doom
14 i213.00o- 40o- • 4.lia. . 4 11414 • 1 . WOW-. 1.340]4'- + 1 COu0a- [rDA X931 . KO . at* . 09$ . ,X5
_
13O 00.c.
930
.. ,.._—: -
3 .0,0 a: . 100004. , _ T40.
99+ . 001 , x:.0,1
.. ..«a1..- 4.++i......---.•
0 . QOM • I= 10 ..
.
......r..+.......o.e+
4 Cl:4t1- . 0 DIM
((11 . ,
Nw
1 same.

Oai

4.3619..
404
4St9k.
affil
11 9e,
11k6
1,8400.•
994

1.0090..
006

1.rEva..
068
3,0000.•
401.
teams.
006
],romp•
101
UM
1ZZ

1.=
U10.ra.,
00S
mom
t:kfis4
3,4 Grading -2021
Urinitidated C. or'ti:rULAW.l1 011-5.to
It, -=la
..'3.

CO
01?2
F.0...c
004 XII
bi-0...l
FOlI❑
ft... 10
101.11
Fu1L,0
MU:.
41 ..._ A.

PW2:0
4,1O3
Taal
Bo- [x32
NIN.- 4C,0
Idol C:72
1044
000o
Cate
I
C31t0R4
'a.

ImalFr
..
- ai
MTh,
- -
-+;I:vsc nnr
• • 0.4Rta67
•
_ _
•i, i . i . 0.1711 . 4M90 . 3.1741 a arm] , DOM . 14GCC .
__.
tin CcC4 • Q11 ascot] • OA,TOo . 7A®0 'a MOO'
010780 • 084115 . 45di3 • 1 1200.. 0,0170 0.00117 . 114.34.7 004n7 0191
1 •
044m. • 100.5117
10350[19 • 017915 . 0141430 , 1]]4 Sig
Total
41107915

0.11011
0017
414!00..

Old

9.11111
Earn'

0.7113
CIBM3
00411
'01490
!10010
100.311&
103.1407
QA510

1.0000
104.070
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2910
04-25
Cont.

Page 163 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1081

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Versi0n: CJJE FMod.2O16 3.2 Note 15 of 44
Village South Spot Mc Plan {P1nposed) - Las Angola South Coast County, Annual

3.4 Orading -2021
Ursmdloyalyd Constiuclitril Off -Siff
Ode. 1112x2021 2.26'PM
ROCx
NO.

CO
aO2
Kti.L
1•M111
LWOW
7Q16
PW ID.

Told
7'040.'.

P1015
Sivarsi
14425
Ord: .t
Tax
@1[F 002
N;So- CCC
Tilffl l3]O
CH4
N2.1
=le
Cahyoy
7Q7•aj'
Mier
I1MW 6,
Y.;1:,4
'AA., 2O A.,
OCOM
171-!7[0 • O. COM • O. LluCC • UJC01 '• ❑C0IL. •. ii woo

O.OXO
II 0
,SFL
0CCO] • UM)
000X • O'7U7P • RENEW
'
0OCCd1
aocco
2,Y=
OIti0
rt
noxo 1 Oau O.RYC x6107 a 01:030. amac,
6l'ADl
0-:az
4 C:xYC
ama pm°
Ocm • Oinoz, • GM
. I. DGo-
OW
• r1.0003o- •
• 4701 •
00103 •
.
3[0[1•x- •
WI •
.„,,,..4„,„..,........4..
383X). ,4
DOS •
206. •
09 045 •
2afGGo.
x03
• -T Mrio
r a0+
2000I■-
606 •
....
. F. 3LCC1u .

COI
. —.4.--......-.4--...--4............4........,....4.......

OOOCG
• :.7001
•
26330 6
61]00
• [.- •
r 00& •
DMC
i
Nal
I 1.2201k,
662

11.W90a•
OGd

0.6118
S6901te
'Des
LEHI*•
II8
LI 1 We•
006
28lfa.
660
r,alw.,
nu.
iwme.
cos
r.ammo.
idM.
gum
t iIW
261160
WPM,.
663
1h004®
2 51O1
Mitigated Construction On•Site
itOG
r4ilx
15O
01e2
Fu@he
RAM
[liana!!
PM7❑
NJ I0
land
r,lAVG
Pr1Q.5
&ms1.

PRI2.]
7M':3
Taal
♦fo- [x32
HIND-ti.2
Idol O.3's'
O44
WC
1733e
=Isom
Ilnt6T
Mfr,
FugF.rA oust :

OMR.=
•
• • • • 0.1711 • 9M40 • 3 5.17,41 • °sou . Kali '' 10
•• ••
tin CcC0 . G'P(al accO • u.oxo • 7.0®0 ; O•S^0
✓]00780 • 0851® • OAT • 'I 1d001 • OAST? 6.0317 • 04147 30347 000.
• 1 - • • •
OOXL. • ICO.54m
103.0403 • 017935 • 1110013 . 104 2,775

T•Aal

0.07915

1.1616

0.660O
[1100.•
Old

9.17 1
09iITT

8.7113
46078
110147
' L1094
II!. Me
169.941
193.6442

0.6115
I.OOZN
1:1x7,770
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2911
D4-25
Cont

Page 164 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1082

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: -OWE EI.k1d,20163.2 P gre160(4d
%loge South Spot MG Plan {P7nposea) - Las Angelo South Coast County, Annual

3.4 Grading -2°21
Mitigated ConsUvctiorr OffSiie
Ode. 11122x2021 2.26'PM
ill00
NO.

CO
3a2
K..olt•'e
01%. ill
Ex.1.1
P 110
DW I O
Telal
Nan.

PM3.S
SiW'!i

1.11,425
Ord: t
Tax
@1[F 002
NPio- i.CC
nisi ms
CH4
N≥:].
k:(32C
Ce rFri
laraj'
Mier
I1JM W
Y.-,4.4
'NA.,
r. 0 [901
a 0000 0 M . 'O. '- a 301 . O W90 •. 0,90]9

0001,
0- 00u
_t 3 n L
0 [C00 E., MU
011'09 • 0']0'79 • 0.a1D0
a oare
a Goss
26M0.

4.=
rt
Coxo . O r78n ].07nC GM= a 01000 . nail)
o ixin
a -{.yam,
4 C:xYC
0 00ii comp
ocean . a cam . GM
. I.2ODG..

OW
r1.OX. - •
. 0F09 .
00103 •
.
3O0t0. •
50Ff .
...
383X). •
Oa8 .
....4..
100911..
{:46 .
29fGGo
atr3
• T_MY.
. V0+
20000■-
035 .
..
. 7 acco.

COI
.. ..4...,.H«..,.
000[0
:.9371
.
---s-..-....5....
25905
..1..,..,...,...ad
• 010002- •
. 0.16 .
0MC
i
-sto1
1 9.22000,
7aa
'MM.
664

0.0108
IMO, •
rors
LIMO!.

Liao
2,WNe.
cos.
lbtria .
coI
1,OOWa•
na4
219091.
ass
7,NOPe•
bra
WON
tiariir

2.r*W
Ne•
ms
sum
2111271
3,4 [Trading -2022
urn-litidalrrl construction On Sits
&,-•ts
Nil.:
nti
0 Fu@he
iPNl 1D
F 0..ol
KM
CN 10
1a101
ra0b.r
MU
e,.._.4.

PW2.]
x.9':3
Taal
k`o- [12]2
Neo-t%2
Mill OW
a64
ram
Cave
C314.0R0
lerxl3r
Mrly
-+;rvsc Dust i,
•
SA4Raian
•
•
. i i i OAF37 • 13.1:.:00 • 0.1)507 • 601$7 . OgOMi , 101NL •
orci0 • 0003} 0.131:01:1 • 0 01000 . 60®0 ] °]I0
•
001 12x0
2:
• 0 . 61017 • 037111• . 53 E 900 • 577.0.... . 5'1000.•• . 525030, WS ®. 013 003
,
000[1. . 100571

15.12871 . 017C.ra1• . 003_1 192149
®:

Total
•
&D'ID
6111*

0.1017
210411..

MA
Lem

4.72005.

PM
UMW

0.0180
12000a.

MS

0.1733

0.0040
190871

10.11111
61700a.
rd1.
0111100

11.2111
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2912
04-25
Cant

Page 165 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1083

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF FM0c1.2016 3.2

3.4 Orading -2022
Unanitigalyd Conssruclitlii OffSitp

Page 17 ends

Village South Spot MG Plan {Proposes) - Los Angeled-South Coast County, Annual Ode. 111202021 2.26'PM
it C,,
NO.

CO
aa7
PLOD,
01010
taeOW
PM90
Pkil ID.

Tmat
Fuegos
PM7.3
SiW'!i
14425
ore .t
Taa
@a. 002
Neu-CCC
nisi me
034
N1..1
C:02e
caet. i
Mslj'
Miry.

I1MW
Yarrsl
Wo•Aa
r. 00000
0!13(0 •• 0.COM • O.Imc-. a3O} a 00c0U •. 0,0070
OUOO IF090G
I 3FL
0 K U0=1 00000 i 00000 • RENEW
00000
namo
044100
• atc+c9
r.:xo ouzo . n.n3cc GM= ❑moo • 9.O:Cri
c�rrr3:i mwat,

7. 'IC
cteoo Doom ocean .._oonin •-u000u
• 21O40o- • 1:5:01. • I,40Do.. 1.00Cca- • 020004 • ❑4000 • 930004 • I 4005 • %MO COI • ON . KU • . W4 . • 001 . 004 .

I 4CC.0u
CO!
0 M • 0027
.
04^53 • 1.CO0N . 09000
. UUs .
-Nal
2100e.
104

1.0090e•
4104
1J10
003
19000.•
IM

0.4400..
004

0.4100
.h2AR
0419

7.#000.•
064
004904
1,4000..
0M

0.0090

0.4.sE3
94400(
tAWQe^
COs

4.11000
114.094
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Sitt
Obit
FMK
Ct•
01?
Fu@he
RAM]
bismal
PPM
Phil 0
1alal
ru9m,r
Pfea5
balms
PR72.O
th•1:3
Teal
♦]o-0 2
NE.-ti.2
Mai OW
044
MO
Cave
=ham
a rx9yr
r•SfN
Fuekn t Du -sr ••
• 0.0037 • 0.1:.:00 • .3.mir • 604$7 • KOMI 10109
••
•O0•R.=
L4
0 C9 • 0.09¢1 0.0{00 00 • 0.00 • Doom 30=
•
•
4092: • 01240 • 01017 • 3X11• • 5390lie. • 577(0•! • • 5'1.004• • 52503.• 004 ®. 003 0ro 000
00X[ te.0571 151.71 • 017CCdp • I.• INCE 19.2409
®:
•
• • • •
Total
&DID

0.1!11

0.11017
22000..
9A99i
4_T200P

9.0049
0010
12090a.
41733

0.0090
190971

19.0971
61700a.
0110444

11.2111

01.1 CM
009
MI
•
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2913
O4-25
Cont_

Page 166 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1084

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: CIF FPAsti.2016 3.2

3.4 0radiner - 2422
�14ilic�at�d' CulrsEruelior7 drFSita

Page 18 ends

Village South Spot 1111G Platy {Ploposea) - Las Angelo South Coast County, An1ual bode. 111212021 2.26'PM
RO,G-
•l3
CO
aa2
Puolt,
PM111
Ex.61.1
MMUS
PFIIQ.

TM I
F'OOal*,e
PR47.3
Siu•1•si
14425
orat, s
T1n9
x.,.00.2
NiNa-i.CC
nal✓3OE
f44
N2...
=de
C.1e0uy
iQnlj'
Mfye
11 .1,41
Y1eWI
.p-
4'u1•Aa
''••2100".
r.00W
0u000 0. C17k1 • alba_. a3007 a 09000 •. 9,0070
0WOO IMOD
J'XXL
01000 0,=0 00109 i 0,0PQ • 00IEW
0 00E4
.7+>�
04WD
r 0 mrn.

M
C 3X0 ouzo . ].OtYC 00000 a 017900 • O.O:Ca7
t •
01SD7 . 0�fi10t,
;.}YL
0 Ot9L soma ocean 0 Ct1Y1 • 0.00711
•
•
® 21000a- • 1:50}lo- • I,40Da • 1.00[Ga- • 029000.. • 90 ❑ 00 • 93000. • I.4D70c • %MU COI • ON • KU • • W! . • ON . W+ •
...

I +CCO.

CO!
.. ....t...® :

O.OOM • 0.027
.
.,,...MM.,.
014^83 • 1.00010- • I)MU
. DUs •
-Nai
OU

1.sOWe•
Nit

1.1I9N
OM
14•Mile•
OM
E,T400e•
t10l
tamOD
Adorer
MI

1.1000e.

MU
mum
l,4l00e.

Oa

0.00 0

0.,+.sE3
*!DELI
t. .
cos
MIXT
114,0 0

3.5 Budding Construction - 21722
Ur rmiti halal] Gclnslruction Ott -Ste
A0,1
ri::.:

Ct.
0+32
Fu@he
Mg AI
bismfil
F111❑
CNIO
1x1.1
F11Q13.C
MUD
ba+rma.

PRI2.]

4.1':3
Taal
k`o- G7;
HNC-te.2
Idol C:7's':
044
N241
Cave
C31cy6y
Itml,r
!My
OY.P.w7 0.1- .275+ • 200100 • 241tas• • O'ICI! '_ • y.',il > 41.:,-.C 27_C= • . 003
.701[ 2.1 1 1,1.. X22. • 21.7-.71.- ' ::',E03LG7 1.4 Lac,

'',uxl
4,:+1 SO
igi`L4
20700
16199x•
0I
li 1G?9
e.nl?S
LLL'Si3
e0`!:J
aal ti
Ar..l.i3'x9
liY3133.1
D.Rf/C2
1:.9100
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2914
04-25
Cant

Page 167 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1085

Responses to Comments
CaIEEl od Version: CesE FM0c1.2016 3.2 Page 15 of 4d
Village South Specific Plan {Proposes) - Las Angelee-South Coast County, Annual

3.5 Building Construction -2,022
Unlriitigaled Cons ti livti Off -Site
Ode. 111212021 2.26' PM
file.

NO.

CO
aa2
Ptioll,
I.M111
Emboss'
!MMUS
FWD
TM,iI
NOM,
PbC..

Sims'
*.i0]
1Q:E
r.mei
1111-S`A2
NiB-CLQ
t11al COs
SS44
N2O.

C:02e
Ceruri
t,ro1x
Ml
11MW
•••Yrrk„
LT.kn
.,
QOM] : U. -0X0 O.CCi01 • DIM( 03CW • C.[gO0
0,0000
0OEM B[Km '. UWE&
Ocala 9 K QECK i OIOOPO • aWFF9
0 WIE41
061400'
. 705;7? . -,E61 . 04300 .�aTG.-. 0.1 I1 •31000..
w . . .
00 . 1 } OG3
U.4, 1
0r,°70 144171.-• .iris
• 1
OT4I • 441 sus- 1-S4933. 04a y • GMTs}tE4f5-
. . 1
. 03.3.5I • 021.3.5 . 2=3 • F, 37Ces- • 07037 •.333902- . • . J0& . . 090.
47,3le
aIOW • 07400.- . 139.3t1
• WI .
0X0 • 0+$0034 033.E•0O • 0!01.17 • I) DEW .
. . . 1
y of
Can!
1912.5
leti2
0:0110
0A1W9
1411001n
CIS
IMO
ante
vole.
110%
02424
1100.511
i,10L1EF
1 1.1M. eV
1 0.0A441
aJ000
1,1,r,70a
9 Mitigated Conolruction On•Sitt
Ik2G

1.0x
C0
002
Eu@he
Mg 10
001.01
Fis11❑
NJ I0
1x1.1
r11Qmve
MUD
EJmsl.

F#72:]
non
Taal
Bo -000
H 1-002
Idol 0 2
044
N241
Cave
C312p6y
1 It..1r
PThi
al1P.w7 • 0:,-; ^-F5t • X700 • 24106,• 0'102'_ y.',= 41.:,..1,„ 2D,0= • • • 003 . 1
OCtCO • : ?,1 S'. ;x3.1371 . OA70C • =.3W7 14 0077
'.2.11

0.,1'.:0

1.07.11 0II001
14106.•
LI3
LL1G?9
II110.0
2Lail,
h10`0,J
OILitill
1tY.5.1111
H01331
a tOnst
1:.1110.50
211.147T
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2915
04-26
Cont.

Page 168 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1086

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: CIF FliAcu,2O16 3.2

3.5 Bonding Construction - 2022
!Ai tig trd Construction Off -Sits
P21go al of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Propose.) - Los Ave lee -South toast County, Annual Ode. 111.2021 2.26'PM
HOG
NO.

CO
aG•2
PL1011,
4M10
Emboss'
KAM
P0.110
Yawl
rupth'e
RV".
6i._.si
MIDI
1id2E
r.=x!
C}1[F "u72
Nth,- r..,cc
tilJl COs
044
N2O.

C:024
cnhgoy
t,ro1 r
MP).

IiJA
• • Y,r.. k.4 .�
.,,, .i i
QOM] . p,..X0 17.U1(KI . 0.Olt 030X) . C.[C0O
0,0700
0OEM I! OU . 9 WEE.
0 K 9 K PECK ! DOCOQ . aaFm
CQ0E11
-
4 7 E4lIS
CM 4001
0 C57? • -,E61 .. 04%0 . � 33.[.- . 0.1 I 1 • 3 1000..

9.1171
0 r..°.75 }7p 0,17,9.- • a oars
o ma• 441:0E,i9 1.6 4933 . 0 4a I. . G 0000 T
. 03.391 • O2r64 . 2=3 • ,37C0s- . 07M7 • 633004-

9.7,3 14
aIt.37 • 67..394- . 115.30
0 CM • SS MI6 603Ont • 0!5117 . I) DEW .

Nol
0 0I0
t0

2.06.I2
0-0110
Clara
1411001,
CIS

9.879!
sum
#.41094•
MS
12424
1tWa11
1,10Lver
1 1.100 ,9711
1 0.gp4H
0J1 I0

1.1!r,RO7
a

3.5 Building Construction - 21123
ln ti hale!! Construction On -S tr
R6G
`Y7x
Ct.

C
Fu@he
iPM XI
b0...n
FM7❑
Phi 10
1x1.1
EOOm+r
PNQ.^a
Eb l
PW12.I
*.173
Taal
♦]o- Gtl';
No. -t%2
1021C:7's'
044
NOO
oDt4
en RU17
01012
. 1;..7{4. •
2[001
. 132,t"e .
7LLM] 3.".Aa
r

0.12.1':
5Cel2
r., CCCE • 29::.27 B
mE..:Pe:,.

0.,16}1 2.3W7
2L., MI
'',ull
w

8.1942

9. Tre6
40001
3 1311-
9i3
0I0I11
11 .. I4.i"1
' 01815
11 1 17
01ei411
190.20

0.eiI1
0,0a...,0190,23191
0,0a...,0 4 i0
210_4
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2916
O4-25
Cont_

Page 169 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1087

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CIF FM0E1.2416 3.2 Page 21 014.4
Village South Specific Plan {Proposes) - Les Angelea-South Coast County, Annual

3.5 Building Construction -20.23
1rutli aaa1Md t`uasiLuQiit,:,, Off -Situ
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
000,
NO.

CO
ae5
Ptilfih
i•M10
F3iw1
PM16
PM IR
TP1ai
PulMtie
RV...,
Sims'
Oki 71
1142E
r.=x!
1114-CO2
Nth,-CCC
t{1a1 COO
X544
N22..0
k:(32t
C.alep ry
t,tlyr
Frirlye
HRltp
••• YrrJ4
..1'
L. 4.••
oco, . O'9500 041;l91 . 3. MCC. . a 31:03 • 0CpOO • !Loma 4Si 0m t .XU • 9.044
riCCQ9 47[1.00 0.MEC : o 0. n. 00PQ .
a l.
4185E0,
..
6,14199

00.41 -751'1 • 0 4t i • :..3.X..3- • 0111.3 • 14990x- • 1li:^, �
'7X15 . 000 , .
1 -4..............
0 ..4.900.- • 0.032.s �
' 'X4
4 -.a
0 O • 4.17',E80 1•.7.0030. 0'r 0d . E. 01109 •
<-
o2'a
• 010010 •
22039 •
.
441X- •
On .
97307 •
1 ar:00a- •
CO3 .
....
0874.

0.1300 •
,
.! MOO - .

L1f1 1
..20,4
.. ....'..-
0 00C
s -,l---
• 904.5a03
e
.-
624.5333
• D0,34 •
e
—4
rl]Lul1 1
yatal

4.1117
IWO

2.664E
0,:0110
LBW

7.51499t,.
4790.

IL11614
am+

4.4awa•
063
6454E
(Lam
imaLt3
4 1.942.929
4 9,413
0AWO
1,443.909
0 Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
set
NtIK.

Ct.
01e2
fu@he
iPrA 10
F.t•...0
F011❑
CNIa
101.11
rilA G
PN47.}
&Jmsl
PR12.0
t1:3
Taal
B -00/2
tow -002
1031002
044
000
00t4t
C3f..-gRy
IRrNp
!Mr
Or RU17 0101_' . 1.77{6 • 2X01911 • 313.00 . • 0LLagI • 3.00.4, • 0J2,l • 50515 -JOCCE .2E4.0rE0 Me.:Pa}. 0.ti£}+, • =2W7 8.3,14
[
'I,Cll
w 8.1943

9. rn9
4:0801
313944-
Ill0lfi

0..lalil
' a001I
II11 .610
E14i411
220 2'4
22 X.23615
41 0 161
1:0010'9
301J'911
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2917
04-25
Cont.

Page 170 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1088

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF FMort.2416 3.2 Page 22 of 44
Village South Spot .gln Plan {Proposett) - Les Ave lea-S€+uth Coast County, Annual

3.5 Bonding Construction - 2023
Mitigated Construction Off -Site
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
— 1DQG
NO.

CO
aG•2
Ptilfih

1.1W 19
F3iw1
PM10
YMIR
Trial
FulMtie
P.C.".

Sims'
Qa#71
1002E
r.=x!
1111E CO2
Nth,-CCC
tilal COs
CF44
N20.
k:t3$t
Celepoy
tollyr
Fr7r'ye
HRltp
0Ct•1'i • 90x0 0.99111 • 3.9mC. • 0-3930 • 01940 • 0,4099 00059 04000 1 swot
OGccc own) °cow i 000w • i-,,Biriu I.
0n.,.
•• •
Yrrk4
0oso • • 751'1 • 04tai :.. 3— . 0 * • 1494 .tc . 1 ti:^, T
0 �.,�^, .49fie- • a.0 0
0onto • 41? ,20 i r•-7.0000 . 0' 02 . E. ono .

Y
glow,
X003 IA . 9 , .
t -4............... �
' cos
4 -.a
.1'
v..kn
..

02.1.9499
....
02'99 • 01010 • 22034 • a9103a- . 97307 • aTd.4t.- • ,.at.

0.I MO . .! 49009- . 520,4
.. ..«4— s -,l--., —4. -_»-a4
01 0 • 004.!000 24.3333 . 401:}1 0[4[11 0
B1
.
.
foo .
.
004 .
,
U.0 :
•
e •
0 3601

0.2117
WI

2.$0l0
0:0110
94400

7.5179991
LL9694
am+

4..*3940.
lam!
tuna
100a
1J►13,529
9,493

0.9990
11143.01m
eoa
063
4 4
0 3,6 Paving -20623
ljrioi tidalell Cur lraUL N).li O11.S.te
Moo
'13,
Ct.
002
r-uptie
iPMvO
ext•...n
F011❑
Phil
10101
Nave
MU:.
tavhd
PRI2.0
*053
Taal
HIND -09'2
Td.al COI
d44
N88
032e
CaGcpq'0
lonc04r
MTh,
r
09 Read ..5.7144o- • 903E7 • 40040 • 1osoa • .-Lsoae- • }3X00. • . 3•30D9i. 0 399170.- 13 Ma • '30]173 130'70 • 42100e • ammo 17122.%
993 004 1744 953 503 1 473
•
003
• •
••PaH'Y _
099m ❑0000 • 0.03,313 • 93910 93141
000001 3(.1'00 0.064 00.40 • 0991.4 114010
• • • •
• • • • •. •
•
• •
Taal
'&71041.
[.64613
V.99.99
1503344.
73240..

Into.
-0.01400.
000490,.

Roam

13.0179

13.3170
421Wa.
91000

10.1331
093
4)61.

CM
003
OM
aa4
4103'
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2918
O4-25
Cont_

Page 171 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1089

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CJJE FMod•2O96 3.2

3.6 Paving -2023
Lr i6itigated eonslruetilm OffSitp

Page 23 of 4 ends

%Tinge South Spot.Slic Platt {Ptnposett) - Los Angelea-SOuth Coast County, Annual Ode. 1112o2021 2.26 PM
MOO,
NO.

CO
aG•'
K.•1Plt•'e
Pt. III
Lwow
F 116
PFIID.

Tnlal
Nip.

RA7.3
Slowsi
1,9125
OM: .t
Tad
Et. 002
NIS a-CCQ
nisi COs
034
N1O.
=de
Ca trWri
lat3ljr
Mier
111.1IFh1
Yx.rJW
.••• 4..• .•
r. CI CC® • 0!93[07 0 W • J. LI00_ a3OS w ❑4POU •. 9,0070

0. CV33 0_OW _,Dat
0[009 E0. I
0114)0 i 000PQ • DIEM
00841
C01ao
0txOd . C,i3C0 •. 0i7On 0.xYC 90 0 . 040x0 . II.O"%a7.- _ 0r 5 t aCL>i. T G•'•vr: OQtOG
0 N•
coop
ocean • x04Y1 • DM +YLx

2. MOW- • 1.OOOl. • 233GUo. • 1.0dt<m . TX.7 Q- . IM0D.. 7...X.. 1.x05Ja: • 1000911- . 20000.

COI . 9x1 . DOS x 046 . NI . C.C5 . 0x9 . 00+ . 03S . OM D.a M6 0.61@11 • 2.DOOQo- . DOOM
. . 006 .

Nol
I 21091..
too.

1.1010..

Drat
"Z. IRV,
x43
%MI5•
W.
tbP0t -
DU
151m&
0t6
taotr.
049.
1,40Wa.

Elk

1.OO%l.
006
149Oa0.

MI

0.00 0
DAM
Iwo
Lem-
006
4010➢®
06190
Mitigated Conxltuction On -Site
Oat
FMK
CO
012
Fuo e
RA XI
F •-•.A
F 1]O
CF/ 14
lad
t-axt C
RWZ.
e , _ A
PR72.O
M..1:3
Taal
♦fo- [C
Neo- t%2
14181 WI
044
Wm
Cave
C ygy
ImtljT
v
RIM,
R
OReAd .

PyA
•
.
x0

6.71110. • ILOSE3 . C 4® • 76Y4a • • v.soac.. • }320011. • • 30SECt . 1=0. 0013 004 oat x53 ace c73
• , • •
. r
6ffiCb • ',SJ317s 1217'75 • 421COe • Dixon is 122%
OM
•
dICG'm ❑0000 • x.07.70 • xiCCO Ja5G0-
• • • • • • •. •
0000110 O.x0aa3
•

0.CC60 000-I0 • WIWI] acll.x
• •
Total
671111.

OM
x.0643

0.91.79 I.%012.
801
0matur•
CM
LOOI
KO

3.410x11..•
000
MOOD ,.
a es
1001110
i101T6
13Jk17a
4310011.

OA)
0ODZi0
1d. UM
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2919
04-25
Cont.

Page 172 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1090

Responses to Comments
CalEEM6d'dernion: CeIE kld,2416 3.2

3.6 Paving .2623
c4ifis1alva Cu rstruuli[rr, orr-5ila

Page 24 ends

Village South Spot.glic Plan {PrOpasea) - Los AngeleA-SOuth Coast County, Annual Ode. 111212021 2.26' PM
ROG
'4:34
CO
aC•2
PuJOne
010111
''•sail
F 116
PWIO
Tmal
FIIp1r•'e
PI.41i
SiW'li
1,91,425
ore .t
Tali
@aF 002
NI9o-CCC
trial ms
CH4
NI..1
6:(321

0.411.90).
lmsljr
Mier
IiR41N
r. 0=47 • 01-.X0 06101 • 0.11]Y a3C01 w 0 0c414 •. 00190 0NI, IP _Mu _7Mt

UCCA UM)
017:00 ; oMPG • aWtM9
000[41
YrxlA
060.70 ,i0 0 . C C0 . 0ia ] • 5.67LC aNm7 . MOOD . 4• .4"%07 0r 1 x. Q.L 7.7[ T G•
Oa4tfi • GMOD
0CG10 • 001074 • DM
.7 mu,
I 4... _
•1.---,_.
4Ta•kn
--.e-=ws° ----:, � .. .-4-- .a
. 2l090o- • 1.a00a. • 233GUo. • 1.OOt4:- • TX.7.1a • 16000as .7...41. • 1.0057. • 10000a- • 2,70000 .. ..

OX
.....,...a4ss..”.
• O.N M6 Q.61N0 • 2.40702- • 40679
60160
w COI . 909 . DOS x QC* . I4 . CYS . ON . 00+ . 0:6 r ta4 . . PA . ,
Nol
ZUNI.

1.'9610..
=IV,
1061.•
t.1661e.
45110.
taw..
7,9600..

1.w%6lr.
2,wu1P,
am
Minn
Iiy1N
2946..

OJ1ND9
smart
Du
404.
043
bP5
OOd.
406
069.

NU
406
461
403
3,6 Paving -2624
lJr'iiitidalell C. r ltrs;6tiurl O1..S.te
&,'=la
'4.x
Ct.
0 Fu@he
r.Nl XI
On...n
PPM
CNIO
1a111
Nave
PNQ.5
&MA
PRI2:1
th,1'Z3
Thal
k10- [•72
Veto -t%2
Idol 001
044
N`651
Ci7:e
C31x9R0 •
Ims.yr
Mrry
On PwJ 00-40 • 61045 • 6709 • 26[16. • • ..✓:Isaac- • aluo., • x 4.74C0t• , 4.7467.- M.
6LtC0 • .2.042 Z16202 • 7 1Z41 • 74070 223073
7a+ ,270 073 ace 1 003
• • • • •
00]
• •
••p -
1y�
0r.an ❑MOD • II 00.70 • Odal70 6000-
000CL GIIIU 0.CCM OCO.0 • ULIOA , per'
• •
• •
•
• '
T•cRal
01100
61941

0.7609
16[01..

5.10016.05.10016.•
4970 14•

4.7490a.
4:7401a.
0}061 0
4217
22 MU
3Z
71X1.06.
059160
Z2173
1100.
663
06]
Ern
6:14
1121.1
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2920
O4-25
Cont_

Page 173 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1091

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: CIF FMort.2O16 3.2 Page 2.5 of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Prnposett) - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Annual

3.0 Paving -2024
Unmitigated Cern uelilm Off -Si
Ode. 111202021 2.26'PM
MOO,
NO.

CO
aa2
K..v.lt•'e
PM1O
'woad
PM9n
PFII I D.

Tnl.9
Ft Woe
P6415
.E.teri
66425
ore .t
Taa
a.002
NIN a-CCC
Tian COs
034
N2.1
=de
aeet.y
Imslj'
Mier
I1J.h
.,
YrrlA
.. - - ...r
LT•kn •+
r. 0 an
00000 . u. C!OM • II IW. • aJCOI • ❑4PUU •. 0,0070
• •,.

U. CI733 m _O0u i ,3CL
O[1:Oa • UM)
OCOX ; 00D'9p • DIEM
001041
..
.a co
fn �

9410@
: 0.s. -o
_ .._

0.3Ya . OMU . O. NYE -
. GG3o .-oiYGP . 3O"iO

4.---. -4--.. 4 '
- r- __
07 3 0_{�. . '}YO
.- 1111'
Damn . Gna7m
400.10 .-0,0.x..1 . GM .

0.la0aa-
. COI
. . T-4-., ...
2 noO1c- . 380-0Uo. • I.O6[<m • I ,2O - • IDOO6u • I _1,•1N.c. • 3.33Cf. • I an:e.- . 0 +0{00. 4101 • uoa . 400 . NS . OCS . OCi3 . mO+ • O35 . CO4
, . .. «1111- ...4.--......-4. ...—.4.--...........i........

OH • 1.000.0 10105. • 3:000.- • mnWO
. . l]UO .
174o
4,4 WAD,
O9

2.9mok'
604
amts.

OM
Coma..
013
1,2i1a.. I
mss

1.1[nle.
4O5

1.10,.•
0011
11,1OI
Ilk
1�09IA..
mob
1AOaw
664
ICJ:
1:0ma1
Lanes

1.919416•
ass

4.11000
1O1OO
Mitigated Conolruction On•Sitt
atilt
FMK
070
a
Fu@h a
iPNI XI
bisen n
FM7❑
NJ I a
tall
rll6m+r
RO'Z'
tallIA
PRI2.O
M..923
Taal
Bo- [o.•
Neo- t%2
'dal COI
044
N2o
Cave
C yqa
Imclyr
N1O1T
OIFReml .

P.A..) G'm
OD11® • 11901E • MEIN • 2.00.050 • • ..✓:Isaac- • 619:6. • • 1.74[09• . 1.7{Wrt- OG# oca 0011 001 COO
, •
•• ••
110[{0 • 22:''42 Za63m2 . 71=0c • Dimon . 11.3073
C{!7
•• ••
0O
00000 • II Dom • IhE000 nIXIX
• • • •
• •
00000 0
•

0.0000 OOLYY, • 000 1 600TH!
• • '
'Mal
11 @
191O 1O4T
0 a19O11
011001..

Bit

6.1001..

CO3

5. 010!.
0011

4.7400a.

OO1
4:7in0.•
600
!O C
22210
:

DM
3i.m
7-1201..
11O1
m.UOOG
=WE
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2921
04-26
Cont
Paps 174 of 548 Hi Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1092

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMeod Version: GelEFIA4cd.2016 3.2

3.6 Paving - 2024
!Ali Liu21 L Cullstrucli471`,orr-5ila

Page 26 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Praposea) - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Annual bale. 1/12)2021 2.26 'P M
ROG
'4:34
CO
S'Cr2
KWplt,
01$111
Exuu.1
P 113
PW IQ.

TRW
N em.

PFd.3
Ed 1.10.1
*11.0
ire.

Tad
h.002
NPio-i.CC
'CAC COs
044
N≥.7.
tX32t
C.e1e17oy
IQ421j'
Mier
H4144kh1
Yrrl1
•Li'.
4Ta•. e
r. 40000

0. 00.0 ••• O. COM • O. IY - aJO®"5 w 0OPO0 .. R0CCO

0.C 1, 0_.:00 I. 13CL
0UCUa UM)
00000 i o OEM . DIEM

0.80 .,.
.�O'S.-0T
1 4 C@
8'161
01YC0
w
F•
II 3X0— . omen 0. nYC -
. 00002 sOiYOP . 00"ta7
u . . I .
. �,
- r— __
0�2 O -SCE, . '}YC
.
*0-
00000 G0000
OaaelO . O!YaY.1 . GM �
44090a-
® C44
..y
2 YYAc� • 3SY-0Oo • I c X0 - • 12») - . 1 c090u . 1 �V1N. . 3.30510: e I axe. . 3 4ZC0l- r
001 . 9LG I 445 • 043 . OCS . 033 I 004 . 035 a 6G!
,. ..«.i+�._. .. ODO
0 X➢ 1 . DOE.4 I MCA • SAWN 0 •
. I 0.'4 •
u4ol

4.4990.•
4O4

2.97#0••.
-0O4
B,EfO4v.
am
tla14e•
4143
1,2.044•
am

1.WG0..
046

1.24641.•
408
8,0004..
net
I o9OQ..
006

7.4444,••
mit
imam
1:oaa1
1,0904
3O 0.
0015
110 'O
10133

3.7 Ai- decimal Coaling -2424
Unmitigated Construction On-Sstla
OCSt+.
r4110
Ct.
3 ?2
Fu@he
104.1 AI
bisenal
FM7❑
CNIa
1a3d
ruowe
RS4Z
1,.0 3
Pti12.2
n023
Taal
Bo- 1'2
He. -c%2
Idol col
4044
19251
12,22e
=Wall
Iu2c16T
MTh,
IMO
AlA
lAr�le. C` dibrq ^
4: 1272 • 1 . • . 0lK90 • .3 DTI) • • D M • OA�a
aLIXO • - C D= accoa . anxici . Dixon i OIS^0
••
011100062 .
310000• • 10213 • 00227 • SOMA. • • 1IMO.. • 4.070Q► • • 101000• • 10:175.• OOOCO 44 ISK 44807 • 2S.I_CA • 15 OWL • 44745
(0,3 cm as : 1133 0aa I a03
004
• •
. . i. I _ _
•. a •
•
• . _
Total
+.1404

0.0213
169017
comae,,
1m00f
107q.
1AC0O..

1.4704..

O1NF/0
4 *ME
4,4082
LOAM.,
M0000
414140
Old
000
603
004
443
061
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2922
04-25
Cont.

Page 175 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1093

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: COLE EI.lkd.2416 3.2 Page 27 4144
Village South Spelt.glc Plan {P1nposea) - Las Angell South Coast County, Annual

3.7 Archlleclural Cooling • 2024
Unmitigated Construction Off -Sift
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
1094
NO.

CO
aa2
O 4fi1 t
01010
Lwow
7474113
00310.

TnlaN
F',9t1.

PF415
Siowsi

1.4125
#41, t
Taa
@aF 002
NPia- OCC
t1Ial COO
CH4
N2..1
=de
cee.11Oy
1Qt.tj'
Mier
111403
Yr.k4
.......-. -...«r
v. 4...
r. CI 00130
4WOO .• 0 MX . J1.1X1 a30OI . ❑COOL. .. 94070

0.0071 0-_i0i• _t Dal.
0 K • UM)
04000 ; 9000P • D1317,0 •
00141
olio
17 1304
orrrn.
nolo:. 1 017u nrac 09m7 . CLOD . goy.)
4— r
01 3 t eD . 7.074
009041 coma
ocean . n99a00 . um .,a
-_t
7423c-
003
...,.tea.-.
4 .23C0o- . 00009 • 1. AM.' - • 03000 • 10000x- • 2.0011 431 . I ,IN . . co* .
4 „-4---...

5.00X, .. i +,410041- . 370000-
008 I 13.14 , LW
.. ..«.1w e.,w+..t+......w..4.,.,....
0013 • 41'1337 17.1391 • 40OOOo- • 00038 •
. . Cal . ,
Nal
1,41498.
tl09

4.'&103,.
04114
(10399
411499.
0114
MOM

1.90908,
001

9.9"111
1,9hd9e•
993

1.4909.
001
At099,.
144

0.0903
1P..Iar

17.10et
4:3030..
3041
99029

17.1394
Mitigated Con0lructiQn On•Sitt
x100
NtJx
Ct.
tl
Pugh a
PM vO
(10 ..ol
PPM
Phil o
1alal
ruOL.r
PA,¢5
tJmsl
PF32:3
X3:3
Taal
Bo- 1002
HIND - t%2
Idol Chia
044
002
Gate
CCygy
tmtM
414.

Mrly
Al
lAltle. it*n3 n
0443.= x
.

4.1372 . . •. • 09090 • a.01�- • . 043OM • 0A�0
[UM . -0033} 9.9[90 . 4191000 . 09®0 . 00 9
••
2150x41• • 00213 • 0173.7 . 503C(1tr . . -113701. •
003 035 003. .
• •
. i. I _ _

1.07C0 . . 191004• 1 1 CCEOR..
433 003 (CO
.. a •
00009 44-liK
•
44E12 • 75(1449• . 15110A • 44745
004
• .

To4al

4.1404

0.0213
019917
080090
Old
tom.
392
L3111t
003
191994.
904

1.12000.
114
0401340
I.4

4.4982
L4441o,
361
94040
44743
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2923
04-25
Cont_

Page 176 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1094

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: -OWE FM0E1.2096 3.2 Page 28 (3(44
Village South Specific Plant {Proposes) - Las Angola South Coas-t County, Annual

3.7 Arcll lieclural Ceiling -2o24
Mitigated Construction Off -Silt
Cue. 111212021 2.26'PM
IWO.

No.
co
302
14 tiro
Hy1a
Exo,,,I1
Pro 10
PP.11 a
rMaA
Noire
P0.C'1
6a._. si
*#8.7
IQ: E
r.,, 1
PsHF "u72
Nth,- CCC
ir1a1 CUE
aft
N2a.
t;62w
CeBQoy
'Emi '
Mrye
HM W
Yryk4
..--
.A. 4...
r. 0 CC®
U )I . O.C!UM • J 1.1,X1 d 30 i a 01,c0µ .. 0A070

l].001.1 (LOW, _,Jai
C [1:0a • E., =0
° COX ; D OCIPP . DIEM
O Foal
0 ate
.
17 lid.
7 CiCE
r
II 3X0 + 0 r`rial, 3 WE "1 a alma . 01000 . ITEM)
4--- r
_ O rS,11 , Q.Lx. .. 7'ova; •
o ma NMI)
O CUM . O.11X, • G.0900 ,
I

7.4190 -
COI
..,.,1..-..,.--d..
.33CC. • OCO • 1.,Y[Go- 0:41100 • I MOD.- • 9.0711
OE .
431 . . F.At . , COI .
4 ,_..,k...-- ,...

SOY. : • i ia00a- . 579O7 -
008 . ioi , MO
.. ..•ar... .,....MI........aS,
0 M • .1i 13V 17 IMF • 4J00Ca- • D DUNI
. . COI . ,
y voi
7,AWoe,
tltld

4.93 W.
£NK1

0.099E
tecaae.
414
a,0ae

1.WtiEe,
d104
40211
E,Ehdan
11ae

1.aum.
004

1.AxmP.
add
4 Witi
1P..Si;r

17.12et

4. u k•
o j.

RJ1a4G
'17.13'}1

4.4 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2924
X25
Cont.

Page 177 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1095

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CWWE EI.k3d.2OS6 3.2

Page 29 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Prnposea) - Las Angeled-South Coast County, Annual rn
Scz
r��7L,r ertasi MUM Pugh a CAy-d Wall" 1 O CeCts

4. CO2 MO' I 72 Taal CO! O44 NMFr,1 10 14µ11O TIM 1440_6 PML8 TIM 1rr.s.yr
MM.
=1 ufa • a MEI r rf 7Y'] LI LISIng r , LZISS 2144. LLLLW 9144_43 ; a344., 1.020 Ills •
unmrl Ld n I 71 2* 121034 00021 , 771;in •-----:,!,_-_-4-------1- 0A600 7B",.� • 2m. ,. �umuya. �31i34 00000 • 7,02PA98 7021441.. 0.'34W 00000 . T824010 •
R d 2

4.2 Trip Summary Information
a..4raipc DPI,/ 1 p Rk
Llnm.t:l^1cd
MlAipirel.

L3ny USN
V.,
Sag uMay
sl,lraaay
AnnualVIA'1
A�ru+rq:yN1°
Apurrnvit5Lcoh Rot
Apwln oI h1 Ria9 a
A!,.
444617^.5
If4,26,*
i•------•
i 3 3?5
1`54
?5 J
50#1127
13,680,D65 a
WO 27

13.660. 5
_
Cknerel Off ex. landrig
22!g5
81 755
,_. 31 U5
..;
7le.t
r�02..012
—•-•-•-.---. NighTurncrv9a{SN!1.+5vrnRe�unrdl •
43822/1
2;&3.52
391772
�
..3,413.337
4413 7
taeoo
la 50
F p
,6400
;
(57001 ;
445,,43
r • el
Clua5L7 Fdeaknurarf
1�,"y
c .1
3Il. 6=2
44113
7177.5&0
707,4139
R Donal 1rocprgCs -a. ..4...
u:�
861.44
357.84
• 1112=1
1,112^221
Iota
6 u_;:3ui,_;:gE
I E ICA.43

0.057.31
I 20)562,4.52 II

20.562,462
4,1 Trip Type Informaltr3 1
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2925
04-25
Cont

Page 178 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1096

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: C9:E EIkd,2O06 3.2

Page 30 ends

Village South Spot .6lo Plan ,(P7aposea) - Las Ar>,gele S0u0h Coast Coulry, Annual Trip 94
146160w
H -W o, C -'N'
H-4 of C -C
H-0 or C-�f•'.'
Apartments Lox Roe
• Name as 41h1615* w
H'A' of 0-11 H -S or C -C
NO al C-NW4

19.14 5'I'D ° 11.7: • 9r:'. 2) • 17.0{' dU 64 '

14.74 r 5.00 � �. 9.70 • • 402' - r
• 19.10 40:60 B8
1&.136 0 4 ° f 136 .•
Mee a da!GO ! --- 1G 00 • TT
•
HIU •Turrrgi.,Qr(St 60r1
ote 0
H l••
rl•.•
1560 i FIG r 9 * 050 • 72.54
. ..•

05.66 i 8.40 • 636 . 1940 • 61.80
126✓ 1( Raslaurart 10.06 • 8.40 1 8.SG
• •�
hRoau aura Shoppino Winter I

16.6:6 0.40 •• fi 9(1
• 11
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
Pew -hr
3 ii 3
11700 .+. 37 ,...... ....-, a3......
4 44
1000
1280 • loo oro [ 14.00
16500 '}
6470 ; 1400
311
64 a
is
36 4.4 Fleet Mix
L1914 1342
LEA I
LATI
MOM LHai i LH0 MHO HH17
Oars aqua '
0 0Y
1154
402.1416crts LouIi168 • 05430314, 0444214 020%71 0110369 Apartrnmis M1.7' 4064 _ • 0'543430# 0.04.4214 028:3071 0.114389 twrcr414:4"'rce 11xcbou # D641686; 6046.15 0206671 6119 Nigh Tunever (Sit I'1b8,n
Ficteurart)
Hotel
4 •e--
OSA06flr. 0144218' 02033971. 0118100.
4 • • 03430$6. 004421
♦
1?.r41ry Fk614Wt110t • 0543086, 04+44214
.4
Reglon.l5nop{mg Center • 0.54006364 0044214• 0.209471• 0110285'• 6414033 000&33".. 0 021148 0.033077 0.WWI 3 0701817 0 004240 0 000712 0 0008:21 0514020 0400832. 0.021141$ 1]:033.1377 0.00$13 0001017 0.000240 0,000712 00003221 0014033 0409',330 0 0211u0 0.03 77 0.3.5129t3 0.401917 01505,"400 0.000760 0 606021 4 01Arl33 4404032.0 021188. 0.063d7T. 0057013:-0401617. 8.083304, 0 000742, a mars[ + 0014002,
U 01403
0000332
U94d}32
0 021106

0.021 166
0,1133677

0.912333
0014032: 0 000312' 0 021140;
04010'17
0,001B1?

0.000421
0 [1008:1

0.03357. 0 3Q611: 0401817° 0 6152110 0 000712. 0 000621

5.0 Energy Detail
KRtorl�at Enalgy lk•= 'A

5.1: Mitigation Measures Energy
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2926
04-25
Cont.

Page 179 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1097

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CeWE El kdd.2416 3.2
P33ge 31 0144
Village South SpeEglc Plan {Prnposea) - Las Ar>.ge:et-S€+uth Coast County, Annual Ode. 1112,2021 2.26' PM
acz
aufL
Fula5
E_rrani
Ft��to
PAIR
1 e4
PEALA
8Pt24
ram
ME. CM
7421 {A7
044
nm
clacra
Cumcay
(16008 . .0.lE35
•
•
•
•
MrM
69090
09[90
fl LlnTaRi85 9.1396
• 2312 , Ri779 . 7.6'S9r° . . CJ>869. . 3.6896
COI
NammG:ac '91358 52313 97779 .. 7.6208e- . 10626& • 5.m136 Unmlpaktl 403
[1,0936 3486® •
4CaCG 2.712616 2312 M149 611832' • D11717 i 2321635
. 5 5 6
0909 .2512045 75126+8 0.1057 . 05215 25₹1035.
5 aQQI . t.065.12
T

1.383.425
0}7116 r [611254 1. 1.64T
a0009 . 553428 13a3.QET 60253 . 9.5224' I 51647
P
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2927
6425
Cont.

Pale 180 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1098

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF FM0E1.2016 3.2 Nghe 32 of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Prnpasett) - Les Angelea-South Coast County, Annual $.2 Energy by Land Use - Nalura1Gas
Utr✓;li4yarrd
Ode. 11102021 2.26'PM
I...L[448a
s Un1
Mali
451711
CC.
:ad2
Na41.e
VNSrli
6454451 -1
a 5119
Fnt'14

74.,4.1
rual1.q
P? 1.

E:.nncl
PM: 4
Pl,t.6
714111
Ma- ce2
Nan- cdt1
Tatar In-_
C1.16

1.120
GGa
LEM Use
d16T3111r
1,,r2,4
MUr
1664.6nest. 14.40 1
46x
:i.:4;;57:451.;17.99 ,
e.'sa
s46.6Ji]IM1_a .
9445640
3416E Yumover [Sri
Dom 9a.IrsC
Hotel
'
.....,.....
na.1 I
•L•ess..'aA
4••5194
■ 2.W4,2. • 4A11B
■ Lea
89'471- 1 1 51 44. •
4X;9 091
1 4T.455- • 1.536.,E 4 • 1s. 6 •.:=0
Gj9 OM i 00 :,1
49X647 1 71 ',4a} • 31.1 U a 431.704 1 I i'ii2* •
964 :04

31504

701 44�
i
MUMS
446 DM
045631
latt,J
432311
13i6134Z
i ,3'107'
3333/0704 •_
�167C4. . saw
°
_
02541 � 384ff1s _
i 003
. _
�7643, . 6G+87 a . -. -1.-- -. -a2'
e a
...

Vial" FE�,�464. 3�.9H84. nap, 1- .' f:13® •
•
44}14150
763'•5'.. • 9, MO
601
00543
1 KM, •
tu4
•
I . ,_,654- • I 667{4. • • I ; : ,ia
191 '0x3 4.- ---
•
990664 • 4241X563 • 2#.49('3 LI • 4 .£u r I .7�PJSo- •
6641 J.
•
ISM lag
46464
i 99416 te 40t2

9.5171
1' 44664- ,
47'73 i
0 431 a 4.(]019 7.6}19 : -, IU
i_ `. i
6A06U • 4423101 • 403054 .d9f.9, 'u 106174 •
s h 646 1 073 ;
,1 NIX&
•+.05
k
65&40 - • 4:0653
CO
00717 , 8.19904.

I 034. a
44 6t&X4 • •• 64E904- . 04809-
OM -a (K4 s i 4373 i 73)
60rA9 W4,2fi1 . 4a0MCI • j Mae . 5..96694-I
a e e 2114 i 9J3 i
, 6.n(ae
.033
_....,..
`k ,3VIM4 • 60095 I 90YBB 4352564 ° 16.666x14 r 8.45604- . r 98do6e- . 6B6dtx.- .. ���1
B6tt.) go 3152 + 523454 r 1 aMCbr I rtiM- 4
+ ° 041 9 X13 1
• P
-
kegc,tl , 911340
ea,MSanG 94-11. i

6..4.01, • 430[5:14
4701 . 603
, 45.4406
, MI

5.9t96o- •
005 •
1 3.11':911,-
i 071
. SAWA- •
w 6°14 i
y
. 8.49116,- • 14, 216•1-
i 0,74 991
69907 • 4,2311,8 4 1.31301 1 3.93311,- 4
OM i
1 17.0114117,- 4
605 1
ia•1,p
41990
t.23V

0.7116
7_6200,-
46,1
11419116
110014

0.0964
04006
60016)
1,363.426 1.2634426
11 4
60&63

6.1254
5321.607
8 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2928
04-25
Cont.

Page 181 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1099

Responses to Comments
CalEEMaod Version: CIF FMorl.2O16 3.2 Page 33 of 44
Village South Specific Plan {Prnposett) - Les Angelea-South Coast County, Annual

6.2 Energy by Land Use - Nolura1Oas
Mi tigaatld
Ode. 1112.'2021 2.26'PM
I;aferal6a
s Las
Mali
MO.
vC.
:ad2
F5841.e
sEIrl
k•`-•-1
a 011
F1,t10

76.,4.1
ruall.q
Pi.. 1.

Eanas6l
615417
64v`.6
Total
Ma- L502
Nan- cdt1
Tttal IX?_
Cal,

41.20 GGa
Land Use
M3T5.10r
'Pamir
MTnv
Apatmvt.64°w 1 4••5194
9536
.r. .:-3334
aipa:a+'w4dK L91 �
Msa
.
&wawa -ms .

66..11.11
..•...-. -r
-iI9F Yumov,r [5145
DomRe�.11aas4'
Hotel
'
.....,.....
na.1 I
•L•,1u..'a A
■
■ 2.W4,2. • 4A11B
45 Lea
b •
89'471- I 1 51 44. •
4X;9 QQI
I •
1 422 i1 - • 1.53764- 4 • 1 s..,..r. •.:=0
071 OM i 00 :,1
• • •
66X60 • 71 ,6.-,196} • 31.7:165 a 437,178 I I 'ii2* •
004 :0.5
a .
715034

701 44�
MUMS
. 446 DM
193. 1
lett,J
43261
13i6138Z
i ,33,,35
k......
446.160
3333/0704 •_
�167C4. . saw
°
62911 � 397fe8• _
i 003
.
7043, . 9G+d7 a . -. -1.-- -. -a2'
e a
_•
- it
9C0[G FE�,�969. 3 .9984. nap, 1- .' f:13® •
•
..........-4
76-3036. • 4S°Td0
1 .J..W.e.,.-4,.,...,..,
06591
14CIMlo- •
cka
•
..

I. ^-655- • I 667{6-'• I :^ .,3.a
061 'ox• 4.- ---
•
10000 • 241 563 • 240963 • 4L1.Cu rl. �,M. •
oui J.
•
ISM �p
,5451
'JI II 33
4Ug41 4:46

6.5171
._
1' 4,166,5- ,
67'73 i
- �.— �—
U.QS71 a 4,(]119 7.1}11 . -, IU
i_ `. i
14066 • 4423101 • M1..L4 .am. 'u 1,3111]6
s h 6,21 1 0173 ;
,1 NIl &
•+.05
k
6151.51 - • 1:0653
00^117 , 3.10 6e- .

I 0(5,'13 a
a 4a44r • 6.tbFx • •• a4a64r • 04806a-
Oat a (K4 s '' te3 i '731
60[00 rQ.42fi1 • aiNCd6 • �Oj 'e . 53391.-6,-
e e rrir} i 018 i
, 6in(ae
.683
_....,..
`k ,3 Tim, • 66035 1 6 66'41 4 44.56,- • 16 6C04r . 6.56612,- . . e 8Bc6e- • 6 B66ra. .. ���1
B G1.M ge 3152 105 3.54 r 1 a br- 1 , tilt - 4
+ ° 6145 9 X13 1
• P
-
kcgc,tl , 91140
ea,Moinl MTh.' i
-331301, • 45500,6
@0.1 . 450
• 1. M,
• Od1

5.31311,- •
0{e} •
1 1460th-
i 071
. 3.4 •
w 1°14 i
y
. 2.4141,- • 3.4,110-
i 0,14 %.,
117007 • 4,2311,8 1 1.31301 1 5.077.,- 4
086 i
1 fM.II6J3e- 4
DM, 1
ia•1s1
41910
I 23

0.7111
7-6200,-
4563.
6Q�Ai6
114114
41 MA
0 4006
10000
1,313.426 1.583,426
11 4
60363

1.1254
5321.647
8 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2929
04-25
Cont.

Page 182 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1100

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CeWE FMod.24t6 3.2

Page 34 ends

Village South Spar.glc Plan {Prnposea) - Las Angelo S€+uth Coast County, Annual L_3 Fnerrgy by Land Ilse - EIm:tr r_ity
tlrmitwa.1le4.
sue-1A,leor
total 3i2
O41
rua
u1�.
to tUx
I.Meir
M ,p
xaDornox.1.9`h .

Pose
74ptt+,.rda1.90
or's.

Gancral illlka
9vt1ha0
•-6-:lummar [en
own itida.irsYa'
-..,. ---- 1-L,.ix7'us
•••3ua r •,•
a ra
_. k.gml
"&uln i..a t. -t. i
10K1u
3L4 W.Z
.476
k
SUMO
■ 33 Trio • I law, • '+44r4•'l.- i
ti awl UC9
33aara
1,332585
a
-96010
346.1731.
41`33572
oil gun
291.7345
1 .`S.7 i87 • 505124 + 0C.10 7

1. .
r_ 1_ 4
I!:NM . TWO.

DC,S
17001. ,
WU

71.^64039.
.0(6
i+, 571:24;7° • 4.033
;

4.22057.
co
33Se211
1722319 • 724
MI
k it^n ■..f ebe..,

1.9055- ,
Cal
98tl40c ,
cci ,
7 IMIXN1
r 'R15710 • 5.'0t3f.'C r
+
W3 •
•
ZNM,
CM ,
Tool

2512.I1.B
a.a37
awn

2..321.433
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2930
04-25
Cont.

Page 183 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1101

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CJJE El k1d.24r6 3.2

Page 35 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Proposes) - Las Angola South Coast County, Annual

5.3 E=nerjy by Lamp use - Elentr r_ity
la4i lic�atac
sa5A.leor
taw ICOI
041
rat©
&1�.
to tUx
kilbeir
M ,p
.dkkrtmarnt1l .

Pose
14f;'f+'.w'6+190
fr's1
G14rral illlka
9u11hnb
•ilk 9umrrv.r [>»1
ow", illmtzurart.:
-+- i-idd ---17
• ......
uailr W
•l!'erata'A
-. k.gcntl
0fn in0 t•51. i
10K9u
3LIbiPat
.476
k
SUMO
o 53 Trio • I MCC.; :4045a- ,
■ 7J3 U.A
33lam,
1,332585
a
NE DM
346.17311
41'33}72
fr .11
.1191.734fi
I .`S.7 i87. 645194 + 01-..10 7
y .
r_ r_ 4
I!J•@ . TWO.

DM
17001. ,
WU

71.^64039.
.0(6
i 5a*. .: 4.033
;
422W» :
ci1:i i
cz ,me
M-Se211
1722289 • 92.13et
4415
117 4 : 1.

C@ MS

1.9055- ,
315
9&lane-,
7 ?MOM
• 20.1'67:1 • 4.t.13[C r
WI 1
ZDti50o-
MI 1
91y.p

2512,P.1I
a1M7
kW IS

2.521.11.36

6.0 Area Detail
G.i Mitigation Measures Area
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2931
04-25
Cont.

Pale 184 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1102

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CWWE El k3d.24l6 3.2

Page 0144 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Proposes) - Las Angola South Coast County, Annual 410
# 145'
330
au#IeI
PM IS
L 4vu.l
PIM
10001 -
PA66
¶041
039
ralnaa
041241
Tubb
PY4n
VT
Ode. 1112.'2021 2.26'PM
NM. COO
TOO! CC1Q
cone
N0411&4 r 31437 + 113993 • 133004 • 1.0760,•— • 0.3714 • 00SI4 + • ❑0110 • 04714 06006 • ZJO L=GoiG • 8.307° • 00231 • 374413,•- •.23.5935 061 473
•
Un-.44.144 51497 0.2092 103004 19707.- • 210.0714 • 00714 + •�! •40714 • 00714 46600, ••5U 9@70 2,I rO4i0' 00021 • 3.74+:0. SEIM • In
r • 1 1•
_ • • • + + • a

6.2 Area by Subcategory
Unrnitgated
O4-25
Cont.

Rb0
11,X'
OD
5+34
k. Lwe
P0l0
'Ekhausi
PR114
PRIM
TAP
FIIng},n,
0t25
eahnpl
0911x:9'-
P1025
Viii
an-
N21,- 002
TnWI0432
11 NW
Caps
&0C.alepora
10,30-
fire;
I
H 4Fe[Wrai n 44137 • 00303 • 00090 • r 0.0110 6!3]00
CCallrfl •
p
~46090 • 0.0003 • 6030 i 00606 • 64060 •
e A
Mesih 0621 0.1553 ! 6@00 1.9231,•- • Doran a 00143 • e 06843 • 0.0143 a I 003 • E r
01036 • 304 1100 1 204.1100 30110 • S: 7410,•- a
• i 1 Cal s IYL3 F
. Ldncbe+pr'g il]�
U.179+' I
16366+
1100).-
•
404 1
II 91057'!1
• 0567 • • 012373

0.4094 • [90.•04 •
16011 • 00101 •
(14111 03 •
Tad
01437
62009
100&}4
1;!864.-
081

0.071+
80714

0.+714
00714
00006

70.01020
E10-0570

0.0201
37410.-
003
)2010)
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2932

Page 185 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1103

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CWWE FMort.2416 3.2 Page 37 of 44
Village South Sparc c Plan {Plaposea) - Las Angelo South Coast County, Annual

6.2 Area by SlrbCalego y
Ode. 111212021 2.26'PM
—
R4oa
RY'.r..
60 515
fwplien
1610
to! ¢uel

1.4114
F1.410
T n41
Folive.

Pli21
Esl.&i¢1
P412
P6rn
7 01n- C,LY2
1000, CO2
TuIa13R
-"•I-I4
PJA1
CC>_Tr
r3_& 25tepm7
lode
Mriy
arzr'11`m,1r41 •
eambrd
aceosnal
1'miucn
Hash
Wn =aprc,
n
04137 •
i .

Ociccs
0006] •
0: cou 0.9961.
0-0000 • COMO ; 00005,
:1010 1.9 9 • 600 a

90000
[ cow' -
3@63165
......
.11.940
.12"...9898
[0 601
.70631 a
1 OMOO 0tYh0
0 rllam1 i 6[006
AM
1i3Y0 6.96677
0 U • U 1TG3 • GG730

1.11060- •
OVA
00143
•701]3 •
00143
06143
0 ONG • 20, 11100
Z44.1Al6
5L1C0o- • 37306c •
OM 1175
••
•16066 9.1157 + 1C. 3063
i

0.4000. •
[631 ,
0 DAV.

9.93?, •
i
gddh
t310i1
0_[596 • I6. S5 )4
1 .

19.0641

0.5161 6.06@3 771
i f
Talaf

5.1437
02560

16.3004

1.Me-

6.9174
014714

0.9714
014714
0,6406
2149670
326,9070

0.@20;1

3.74716e-
.27 HIS

7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2933
04-25
Cont.

Page 186 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1104

•
Ur.loks•sl r 5 061'
Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CIF FM ad.2416 3.2

Page 3 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Prnposea) - Las Ave lea -South Coast County, Annual rally •n7i
M',,ar
pKaa r ssc.em... 3 0153 cUTT5 Chi 7707

9.0153. • o.u7s5T PAY
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2934
O4-25
Cont.

Page 187 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1105

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CeWE FIJA0a2o16 3.2

7.2 Waler by Land Use
lkmnitiiga[.d

Page 39 ends

Village Soutar Spet.glc Plan (Praposea) - Las Anlgelo South Coast County, Annual Indka r:ax
dam Ike -
Tula' x=
Cal4 `

0.120.
ucC®
Bond Line
t.l
hrf,r
a.peleW'tl LON i'I
Aix ;
W.;;;. i."Edw
Misr
Goo OI11"cA
EN0liny .
dY} ^ h-i..- --lin
E`an Ne9du180:
__ ICI 1
'
• ? esmB1lr
Rexaura0t ;
Regional ,..1
$Inpoulmr 'NON :

G491 1 if 1r]0¢5
I C NlS a
4 007
I OI.Xn.

CU3
^ 7.471
. 4k O I W.
.
el Min
:
a Ifi'' K0
;
7COM
ti:
1 a1k116e
i
68 sas ,. 7
4Q1346.i
I
7 we:
r o
• 77`.ri�.94.5M I

4.W201
it
di u'r.:
t
0X31'
MOW.
0Q3
ion.=d
Gild 71K
T._

0.3,+13_:'
1 U:0. 0c-
EY13
ac5`lI
0 1+09 27
t5102J 9NIe IA900e-.
r ; 0173
4111.27) t il3sao II V , 100

6.16#995 i" a 093
tam ,1
r25.:5A
Vdantl L.13eU 71
•

3.4270,
993
raid
564,A452
3 MIR

4.9755
)83.750.3
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2935
04-25
Cont.

Page 188 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1106

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CJJE El bd.2416 3.2
7,2 Water by Land Use
Matti"

Page 400 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Proposes) - Las Angelo South Coast County, Annual Indair GA
dun-fJ
Tula' ix=
C 44
0,1 0.
ucC•e
Lard Ox
NSW
fdIW

0.pporsdre4 Low +'I
'ORE I is 1r]OCE&
007
I.7 J). , 17. 47I
Iliac „ 1Lalt$ w
D03
4 .ipxtr-nI+"Edw
Misr
r8ss52 i
4e lAIKII
b7`:..90G.'�r!

7.:i
. ma:
- ra 0573
• 4k '7&aq

[:oI OITII •
Esukiny a

4.:92,01
it
5i u .:
t
0X31'
0,0003.
003
, el 0007
".
-IIWr®Imuer1511r
100212;
E772,.._
LIZOIEa
IA9. Oc-
. E &4$2
E`en Re9Aursd?;
Gdti74K
1 1103
„
_ _ ICI
. " 075
d1 20034 J
<5 102J 0 041 03 I.0.300a-
'
0 1+0927 P 27
; 093
• (bmi1y .t

47.1127) t I-3 II Ft , 100
ti:
gexaurail „6.16#$95
L. „ 093
Regional
...imam.

27.ISMZ) 0.13W 71 3.420),
r 37:1400
VraimI.r4'NON : ^ ."50 5.
„
$93
,
raid
564,0452
3 WWI

4.9755
983.750.3

8.0 Waste Detail

8.i Mitigation Measures Waste
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2936
04-25
Cont.

Page 189 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1107

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF E1.kdd.2416 3.2
Categoryrfeat

Page 41 of 44 ends

Wage South Spot .glc Platt {Proposes) - Las Ange let -South Coast County, Annual 7a �I vn72

01. M'1K
ritka d
• •283. BIAS . 12_2tr11 . SMOG 17148i3it
i4r.dI d : ▪ 2a? SAM + 12.M11 T mom : ▪ 5148954
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2937
04-25
Cont.

Page 190 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1108

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF FM0c1.2416 3.2

0.2 Waste by Land Use
Lh1ujrgatnd

Page 42 of 44 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Prnpasea) - Las Ango lee -South Coast County, Annual 'Nast!.
n.. r1
Tglal L`E37
₹t4
N7()
Cc:Ce
L-4 Ux
'.x
WV
APWIrflaal I-VN .

Aix
.AB;;*11"la41
RIM
Gerigry amea 4
EN113M1y
1ph 6uriu•err311....

E`an Ae9aursd};
_
4kiel
timody •
Aexavail
kadeaal .
raapirra Canlar'

19.E
_ .:.r= 0.13K,, : 30967

4 -TI
.• [gall
2l55_I3

71. Odd.,
. +18.41811
. 115.7'09+
•
36712
i
r M1,5701
4455

64.S 55534 . 8006
if 41
545•'.7 6,•1371 • • 86963 •

1,22 4
. @S.11 7 613x1 . 6.UU68
i
5 : 2i MI
66679 II . 86066
i6 t 14aul 0are, i nut a

WA
1 11:63fe U.7634 '
6:U=
raid
237.667g
lam
&Dorm
5144154
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2938
tT42b
C 5r1i
Pale 191 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1109

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: GoIE EI.k1d2416 3.2
R.2 Waste by Land L S
niLitI lied

Page 43 of 44 ends

Village South Spot RIG Plan {Proposed) - Las Ar>,gelet-S€+u1h Coast County, Annual Wade,
har<na4
TID�2
u
0120
CGGis
Lar4 Ux
ram
rrir Syr
Aranr.r'di LOW 1
Aix
ArLi...*ilarA9
Mad
Gee...NM..

L'J13ny
-IphfurluerI511;
E vra Rei,a1r9111•
611W
el„alr, •
Aexa.m.

Radanul .
1'1.E. i _ _ 0.1 f1 : 30007
p
n 578]-1
hi-- 13
. 71.O IYI
•.=18.4100
I
. [].769+
06712
;

1. M.5701
'
•4485
y
h, 04.S 55534 . @11D11
;Aa
+025
545.7 0.5121 • @0007
` ,
4224 P.I*PP13

19.13a1 . 111.110110
Y
: 2i 7&
—4
GM. 03 7 . DOOM
t3 t 1411•11 PCNfe 1 noon .
{, a
N3,11
t I1.P06 0.F -7S4
UMW]
raid ]
1207.19117A
112,vn I
1►01 0
51:04354

9.0 Operational Offroad
EwFinentTrpt
hi natrel
HarinrrAy
Nvisitiorir
Fm1Thr
111 U SRatronary Equipment
Fire Purir5s and Ei rrt envy Genetatars
Enuvrno*. TIM
P14rnter Hair 1'n
-tr.:A^yE,:dr
H0,50 Pr [ Loa9 Factor
Fuel TYP9
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2939
O4-25
Cant

Page 192 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1110

User Definer] Et
uiPTent
Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: CIF EMod.2416 3.2

Page 44 ends

Village South Specific Plan {Prnpasea) - Las Angelee-South Coast County, Annual Ocle. II1202021 2.26'PM
l•Itb,ter [ lie'tiMpuLDar
}fit IrsL ( r
Galt Rosry I r-6is1Tppi: I
Ea ipmont T'y¢G

91.0 lie{itaUon
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2940
04,

Page 193 of 54 ends

11942
RTC -1111

Responses to Comments
CaIEErod Version: COIF El ad.2416 3.2 Page 1 of 35 0ale. 111212021 2.29'PMI Vi47age South Specllbo Plan IProposed) - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Summer 1liilage South Specific Plan 1Proposed)
Los Angeles -South Coast County, Summer

1.0 Project Characteristics
1,1 Land Usage
Lan] Llimc
Lnx1 ra 1 rlocrSr..f.ccitrim PEPLUitif
• 7Cf'
C»rroral O1 Bddi t 4600 - tG01`.•agR
• i 1- -- $
HO hrmnvFr ISt Ovavn RwF�rt} - 36:00 . 1,0X9it ▪ 293
Hphal i 50O0 - a.m. 1, 67 t
! 0------ +
$w Hy F?istaura�rt 3.90 t110041 '0 Sa 01
Aparbrneda Lew Rise
i ..-- {4 -• . -1
eB tni pd
36,900
O
6;0D7.on
• ?5L0 Ltiweling unit 1 5E 259Q0 02 -- ! 72
i t------- _-F 4
Apc.tmaatsMid Rigr 075, D3 L}Y.slhgUnir .5.c•' Ma OD 27769 Reponel6heppr. Caret, 58.00 19,1[0g0
1,2 Other Project charautensties
IJrbinual jpn Ut0aa
Genets 2cule 9
Uglily Coto pan Wrrdnern Cstiarmla E0s i
CC2 irtor.elly
II 014OJr)
Wind speed (rigs) 22
GH4 hrtemNpr
i khJl

1.3 User Entered Comments .1, Nan-Defauht Data
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
0 0000
Pr4clpkrvllcm Freq pays)
Operatiixtal ray
N2U inlsm9y
2941
0ree
04-25
Cont.

Page 194 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1112

In Fin.cra ps5
tt�lrepraree-
Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF Ftholl,2016 3.2

Page 2 of 35 ends

Village Smith Sp1ac1Ic Plan IPraaposed; - Los- Angeles-Souttl Cast County, Summed Pitied Chararterle c • -Consistent with 1he DEIR'a model:

Land Use - Sue SWAPE comment rcga:dinp residential and rrltal land LOGS.

Construction Phase - ',See SWAPE comment regarding Indiuklual csnalruction phase lengths Dernoltian- Consistent with the DEIRs modal. See SWIPE comment regarding demolition Vehicle Trips - Saturday trips cansielerk with the DEIR's model, See SWAPS comment raga rdeng weekday and Sunday trips Wcodsmues - UlAoodstmes and evn -turniing fireplaces consistent with the QEIR's :model See SWAPE corn -nett regardirrg gas fireplaces` Energy Use -
Cons4uction r'$ff{oad Equipment MiGgadon- Sae Siff 4PE comment on construction -related mitigation.

Area Mllgatson - Sea SWAPE or:miner* ragardtmg op.Drstbraa I rnlhgatlon meatraes.

Water Mltlgatlan -See SWAPE comrneni regarding clpeRalfonsl milagaban measures Trips. and VPAT- Local hire pro -Asian
Gdn,rnn Name
DIirtit Value
No•inroll.w
IflW1npD®rc
tt#inplatunr
1GRdlisArutlNr
IbrinpgAnrtl961-
4 Flurnheinbod - t9.75
. ••...........
• 14eifierTClrtergai •••••• Ua.l'6 e—=
4 W'orllerTripirrglh 1 1.1.70
4 l
141arrermixergar .
=RrpPrFWW363Nrars
PP1. eta ix
Nwnbmr'icad
t,014213 0l)]
t,O192O _ i . it r1O
A _
a
124
IGRni36061W41r
006
bG7

14.06 tem

14.70 14:00
lblrnpsArdlUV 14arkerTripleng-th
Imrrnpe D6'. Wr

16.70 16 70
11h1rnperodvLir
Do -Me 616eTrips
t61081-660Toli3
rgiverfteaTnpe
tot enn:err,ps
4 i
WortarTClplangth
STIR

14.70 7.16
`3T_,TR

6..39
BR
WOO
MOD
IIK0D
5'17

3.N
139
1663+ n.az
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2942
04-25
Cont_

Page 195 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1113

Responses to Comments
CalEE1od Version' CalE FI.kad.2{i16 3.2 Page 3 4135 Ode. 111212021 2.29PM Vi 1a South Speclbo Plan 1Pyaeposed) - Los Angelas-South Cost County, Sinner tuNanteg n-npa
tGAFehkleTApa
mlvariivaTnps
ST_TR
STTil
4 8.19 3.75

95.22 92.99
STNS
*3.97
mNen1e18T603 9U_TR
4 _
taNvhlcpTnw SU_TFR
058
mNahtalaTi1 9UT'Ft 105
4DMahklv7npc .SLtR 181.44
ti*ohlcb7K4 9U_TR y 59.5
4 4
16N9hICpTnp5 5U_T1R T2,15
i
1t1N4hisbTnpv # 25,2,
a
mNahk>mTnFs 'h4_TPt 6.'J4
-4
4 belie hicTnpm YY4TR 6.86
-•
tanhlshkkTrips WO T32 11.t73
. ._..- ItiVehleeTnm 4 41117 TOR
t6016hleinT60
4-
ttNvehleleTnpe
„ .441,
•, • • „ . MNu`ehlclaTrips
•
-4
Y.13_T1R
127 15
3 17y

1.X3_175
52 70
ttlWo5tt515• NueberCatatylc
C�65 * NumIze rAltalySc
•
1-
125

45.7 1
1771W00ctiovee NalelrerNanratay77
{.......
ltfdfrewiskrves t{alaemlcnwbAylc i 45,77
125
4-
w 4vaatlatwat laY1"aar 26 DJ
4-.. 4
Velf0.B2.103 • m pcElsarrebayreer zi.®
. .....,....... .. ....... 4
t�Wboc .'� Y47m �,4"aodAa� 594611
c
4 03
;3.2d
51,05

6.x.9

4.13 941

95.80 3.21

42.64 6.43
0 D3

0.43 0.07

0.02 ODD

4.04 0:43

2.0 Ernissions summary
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2943
04-26
Cont

Page 196 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1114

Responses to Comments
CaIEERA6d Version' CalE FM ad.2416 3.2 Page 4 of 35 C1ale. 11122021 2.29PM Vi fags South SpectIc Plan Proposed) - Los Angeles-Sauttl Cost County, Sumn, r 2t Overall ccrostr7,lrlton 1Maxlmum Daily Errrksskon)
ltrir71i6gatir Col tslruulion
-
koa

7.1, .
t.7
srs
F....

COI (1
Ed¢ual
104114
Fl.1110
Tm141
Fu61ly.

P1,129
Fxl.m:sl
PN2.5
1•d.12
-nkaf
64n. CA2
7,1010, DX
Tula] OW
-2-24
pj2Q
rrra.

Yes
Ithl ty
b1107
10'1
• ••, • •
r
• &..... 6....
5333
•.. •
. t • .
a
a.=Ei • .1Ei_4110 . .31 .44114 1 0 Pc25 • '15 2032
i
7645
20 ;11k4 • 6,0€06 : 1.!$,.11 •
118406
(IMO • 6.163.41$ .6 16x...4151 1 9v $ • 6'Oddl1 •
& ft
6,217.'143
H
1751&:57^.
6r
y
12174..5
10 Is
4,441 3's 3t.. I- . 4G ate, 1 ,,-,14,n ..
. 1
g. • S 4
.'a.l

10.zt16 • ,,. E'i56 1-ffiI •
a 6 .
4 -0.-- J.
514
60ffi6 • I7 49141 1 1446344, I1ti1.'F 606?7
• 1 1 , o
33 6"J 1
y. • .
d_
5153. • Z. 7,,1 • 23;.07
•
,11276
7 0t3E,
----...-4.

O71u2 • 117d76 • I.6N6 • 4.;136 •
.. »
271130
. .....p.. r
066 69 • 12,1+234611I, 160.43• 0Well • 60063
£rJ IA
T3r.Ezra • 0.5446

. I4.61142
{
464.'16
[.4771

6.4069
• 1264!5 . 6.32.`16
6 4
• 44$16 •^9:44.='
6 •

0.0410..241'3.10412313,1861
.
8 I

0.7114 . 6U060 .21131.4@0
al 1 66....,,
IlasaiTilirri
237.x'0
4d4116

44.6749
01246
g.2032
41496
2112411*
4,4676
¢1476
1110120

01.6966
12493.44
6a
1240.0.1-M
114
1_± !
60M6 jQti1&117
MI
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2944
04-25
Cont.

Page 197 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1115

Responses to Comments
CalEEMeod Version: CJIE FI.kad.2O16 3.2 Page 5 of 35 Ode. 111212021 2.29' PM Vi lagsSouth Spl3cat}c Plan Proposed) - Las Angeles -Sault Cost Caunty, Sumn, r 2,1 Overall Canstrucfion (Maximum Daily Errrksskon)
Mitigated Comrlruc io,
-
8470
IT.1
•`7
I
₹..yL?
Porn
to! anel
corn
FE010
N1.1
FJ(puak•
1,021
F1e ee."51
P142.9
Kid

7.*p
@inCO2
Nau CO2
TI1Ia1 MO
--I4
AjI0
bile
Yew
1t4E1m
tautly
;KIW1 a7 -E1 • .s6.1,110 • 31.9404 I 0.lxe6 • '1,.7037
70455

70.21{1!. • 10.FEFO • 1.M.211 • 11-3404
OUNO • 6,103416 • E. 1E?. 9151 1 04.76 • 0 D a 5.217.103 & B
0 .
crawl 3' K1- . 4G 271,, 1 .711.,,0 ?.::r
; a.l

10.zr10 • ',. 6'330 a 1-5062 •''51+nx
011300 • 1240,40 1-:463.4-ir ID...2.F ConaZ 712518,57
❑3 In • OT
a-..-.- • S 4
4 -0.-- a.

4. i. 4-
......•...
5373
4153. • 25.7068 • ?3;497
111270
7Ol?s5
-.m -a4,. .. .
0 750 • 7.7070 • 'I.eNO • 4:;130 • 27113E
. .....p..•
00000 • 12,150.4S 1 1I, 190.431 05.8@ • 000.'43 •
.... .
17174.4E
5rJ 00 is
Of
II
...iiii4. ••
nr cera • 0. 5446 . I4.01142
4Ur'.10
tYlt1

0.4208 . 120Y!5 . 0.32.`10 • IL4 10 • ^ 9144.='
4090 •7;57.161) 1 2310 100. 0.Y10a • 0.00@0
72431.00$
• i
.

F r 6 .
• 8 I B I
1 e 5
t aaxl
237: -

40.4,110
4Qar7b
ai24I
4astaa
21d .<2i
t"
3,9170

1._

11.2400
A0006
12493.44
12,102.‘i

1.476:
snow
v..510.6)
na
10 ni
RM
NOS•
CO
Bag
Foilrea
PN10
Ewhaila
MAID
PAM
TatY
FuRlikve
PrIRS
Eal auw

1.[25
P0120
Taal
13,0- C.02
14Sio{S18
Tma 0932
CH4
N20
CON
P.reati
Nniuetim
a as

0.04 kaa
au4
ace

0..00

0.00 O 00
0!3

0.00 4.00
0-00

0.00 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2945
04-25
Cont

Page 198 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1116

Responses to Comments
CaIEERAorl Version. CalE FMNrad.2416 3.2 Page 6 of 35 C1ale. 11122021 2.29'PMI Vi47age South Speclbo Plan 1P opused) - Los Angeles-Souttl Coast County, armlet

2.2 Overall Operational
Lean tiigatte Clv,ratiwlal
koa
7r.
t..7
2rt
₹,.ylY.c
u14I A
144au91
74116
WI
1,•94
Fu60'xe
P5121
F 1,...1.7
P.52
Y•I.12`_!
'•#9
Pan- C.[a7
Nelh CO2
Tula] .7t 2
'&I4
P420
rti.-
Cain.)
s'4 m
bAra ,

4.140
••, ••••••• .. 052.2
031154.

MMu
• -30 5C90 • 15.3144 • ;1,3 4437

0.0644 I y2 74
15024 • 1.5074 15274
"IMOD • 10.148 ^-L• . m145 )J . J -1S74 02593 .15;5,011 50 50
02 040a 039
7 • 0 706 n 3402 • 4 ;'..'3
00416 •
,
Oa%.�: , _ - 7, 5259 •-3s`743
•8:35580 '3 8 .983x3 :,t; • 61592 '.
2 68490 • 45.4759 • 1146405 . 0401' • 455507 63300
192361 • 127659
• 03116 • 1200".]
• 60,309.00.552.1:6.03. 7.1507 •'3.361.17
?obi

41.1108

0.22X2
211,r4it
(1S1f1

45.0403
14581
411.+1217
15,21M59
:4918
10x:78
4;9909
011811.18
45 (0,81"1.18
id
iY$2

0.45a2
Jr,921651
IS
hitl9ated_Oprratianal
302 116.0.:
f#i
.402
r.wrr.,
RA I@
td...,,,,
►910
F•5110 ,41
PPA]5
T
fo0lro
P'A26
Extma
,.5124
Ph' OA
Tula
�-,G2
Neap- CC,"
roll GO
t4 -I4.

N9+]
ttr•ic
C.1 nay 'Wt./
4>fil
I
M14
36 WM • '%.3905 • 3&4437 ,. 00044 • 1.5074 • 15571 1.5974 • 15574 • • •
••
_
6,0986 . 161...$ , • 18,148.59 , 11 4$74 , 6.3300 ..1S:-'512.111 ••
a4,.. 58
a
7236112
".Eni1 ,
•� Meal §
6}�

0.7497 • 4.2573 00418.
05222 63780
03 0.2110
f
5355902.0305.963'
a

6.1312 01572 •
0)4400

46.43 M74'
• 114:)407
• 0.4015

4.745432

0.375a
412s5?1
1 2'.2)20
02111 •
120072
•
30,36900.

90.300.02
2 1107 •
•
Tate1
413109
&_2262
$17,6417

4.0#79

49.950)

2.4079

40.1217
112)59
L4886

14.7320
50020
75,)11.15
49 70,01019
.11

23.82 6.4E52
77,528.93
10 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2946
04-25
Cont_

Page 199 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1117

Responses to Comments
CaIEErod Version' CeIE FD.kad.2016 3.2 Pag6 7 of 35 O. 1112.+2021 2.20'PMI Villege South Spec Re Plan Proposed) - Los Angeles -South Coast County, Sumner RfK
NOa
CII
5C3
i4ain'At
PM iP
E.rault
MEI
.M10
lead
Fug. tins
Plint
E1hffilP
19i2.6
FRU0
Tula)
Eia•C33
NEI¢{@
TooM QOY
GM
r1.2U
Q02u
Partin
aim
o..0}
' olio
e.es
OM
R,I1G
ciao
tr.9a
G.2
MG
COG
OLE
DM
COP
-390
a.ma
Ipadawlia

3.0 constructor Frail
Construction Phsst
FtN2e
NVroger
Fhtrae Naieru
r•r.av„-ypr.
rl Dale
E, r9 Data
Nun Cey& Nook
Nun Daps
Prgaa Dr :!ll.'rti.ri
:DemnIlion
;.9. tC Prepwatkan
IOt rg
... .t
4 :Bulking r ors nitli el
5 :Paving
. G.
1Aff lUrrutu lcnzarg
ale Prearalon
rudng
of .adllp cth- 1 clian
•
:PnYiny
:Arthtd 1Lt ICa2tlito
`U'p7C;'1 i1CIfIZ. 9_ 21
-1 ..----a --4-----4-4,................ ...... ......
116.,13/2021 Iiiar` 1 1 d 2D•
lliel Wel "1r11l2022 ' 6: Ora•
1111212932' 1' 1 ^x" 1 23 I 51 50b:
112.134O4. lotD4:4 a 5' 3 i
!,
# I -----
�9f3if�72-0 �YIEM2,324 5° 35•
Acr29 of grading (Site Preparation Phase): O
Acres of Grading (Grading Phase): 1 t2.5
Acme alPaving: 0
Residential Indoor: 2,025.000; Residential Outdoor: 675,004. Non Residential Indoor: 326.400: Non •Resldcntiol Outdoor: iDSS0O:Strip.

Parking Area: 0 (Architectural Col4tplg — agfi
OffRoad EauiQment
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2947
04-25
Cont

Page 200 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1118

Responses to Comments
CalEEMeod Version: CIE FIlhad.2OS6 3.2 Pagtr 8 of 35 bale. 1,0 2)2021 2.29' PM 11i lags South Spec1Ic Plan IProposed) - Las- Angeles-Souttl Coast County, armlet Pram %lite cowl EgL I1lsErit Type. Aim. E
I ussigst ri44IO i 41.titef7eR'1 r Laud F2ekor
Demmer' :Constt4e.lr19'aatrabl Sirs , 1
a00. al. 0.73
.,. ................h...............
_• "646t
........ 1,-3� �... ......

Demolition �21:cauaA ..
4:35
r7amoI Ln •lacJattrTlradT7amry _
BOO. 247•

0.4a
San�Pmpgraibn ;Ruhher Tired i7tscers•• • 3
BOO• 247•
. 4;a4
E- ..._��.,e d
S`ez PrsKaae1on •TrmetrzlLaaders18ar.,dem
....... 11.. ..
806. 7r
If i7
sYe&ai •
BOO; 95Q;
0,e
..[-_ F..........�.....

Galatia GrsOere r I
��....

BUD, 187:

CAC
•--
........
� _ . _............................

Grad F_...�M__.,..�._
Grading •u Rbber Tired �rtns � l
. 247:

BOO.

D.4a
_F.. -- -..--.—._--._A �2.
......_ --�-4_........
.s
•.7
r:aaln9 :Gernert a
BOO: 367•
•____
i@
CnC9rg •Treelnrsilmder alittt4 F
__4.37
640. 97'
13aarmng CareEuetien WCranee= a
..air.....-.,..-.._-----
0 C 2711

0.29 ..[.-.

BuI Ina Carl laetpn •Forlinta .......�,..�. a 3
BOO. BB:
4:24
i+,•
BalkangContatittion .,• •... ^Gerrerslar41B 1
- BB0 �,i
-0.74
____--- ___ ____
__.__r il ....

Bulltllnl7 Crorsla,.rcMan •TraclarakaaderaEaddi e t 3
T0Q• DT:
.___

4.37 Building Ourr#o.ctgn :Wek1I1 1
B.QQ• 4®:

4.45 Raying
I
B0G• 132;

0.3Q
P3lIn11 Rol1trs I• 2
6411~
039
uraiitttaml Catng •Air camprassus I noO• ra•
f:4.44
Trim and VINT
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2948
04-25
Cont

Page 201 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1119

Responses to Comments
CaIEErod Version: CJIE E=1.kad.2O16 3.2 Page 9 of 35 Ode. 111212021 2.29' PM Vi loge South Speolic Plan 1Propnsedi - Los Angelas-South Cost County, Summar PPM* 1"49 ne
J1115't Eod{{aP141
h9ffiIKPf Tnla
NU#L'HI'
". r,J9l lrw •o•JUIng1II
ICI .4LE4 W1 fl I
*Witt TIIV
Ler11#1,
'.rrear Trip I H®i1IIIIgTJIII
.Eng1h Len(!h
laGffter Veti t1t OH JIM I }IVA Kj
Giae1 'Alit%ehbete Vehicle :u s.

Denid19G41 6 1...-: .}.1 L=:;. ',. JL L:3,:: 37.W L'.7_t+plY. I,1 T_3,11R IHHD^ ate Prepantian 1 1340• 0 00 O.r%a1. 1p.o4 d&". 20 00 LC _Mb. IaS9T'49®t '• HHDT Glad' r� •F 4 247.40 00e. 4.402 14.44 6E4t` 37.00 ID_MII 1FCT_1,1L4 99}HHDT f3uldlrg Cardb 1x1IJI' • 01 641.Q0r 143-1{1. 4.001. 1D 00,1 6841 33.9{4 LO 9Aix i H6T 1Ala 'HHDT '- -II- ----1 r --4- 1.....:- ---- ------ --
Psving 4. 1_.00• 0 03 D. 11).44. 6.90•1 24.441Lj. © tx {HDT-Mfx IHHEIT F- ----I f - 4 1 I I •- --
far[hteeLualCelet#q : i• 164.00• O . 004• 1D06• &i11k• -20 I .0 1_410r ,FOT Ws • HI -a 3,1 Mitigation Measures Construction

3.2 Demolition -2021
urgritivittul. gIsnructiion C L i4t
IOC
f4a'ti
Co
SO2
FAA.

PIA 10
Fi:"w151

1.11C'
FM !O.

T+11a1
co4lAe
R•4.S
Ed,: -..4
.1,12:7
AN7.3
T.
1544_x7
N110- 0=q
Tidal E2
Cd°!3
--
-. .

C2luORry
'
Waal
-
C.,,,,,,
F-iak f 1 .9F`. 0rs,04� 9, 74 4 C!@ o-4 gS4x4 •
.

J We .- -• , ]414�f.
olt.rt as
-
31651 "3i .44IV • 21,5961 : 0aC1r�' 16,I41 • I.,`1412 • 1.4411 14411 •- •- • -
• 7 74? 144 3747144 • 10580 • '
97'4.317
• • • • • •
0 , 0 1
• • •
lad
.1.1161
1644{77

41.9160
A01
.1.3974
iS413
Letzler •
MOW

1.4411
14411

9.741444
',741.044
94443

3.77#.997
6 9
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2949
04-25
Cont.

Page 202 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1120

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version' CetE FI.kad.2016 3.2 Page 117 0(35 Ode: 111212021 2:29 Pm Vi tags South SpectIc Plan 1Pr41pos13d) - Los AngNas-Sauttl Coast County, Summer 3,2 Minolta= -2021
Unmitigated Cons.truetion Off -Site
0OG
NO.

CO
S'Cr2
PuWll,-
apo111
0-'-"1
Prole
P/.1!0
T41d
Fn014.-
PlYr.

E13.—..
*127
17,y4
r,1

12.,- CO2
Nl1PCCC
T.14.1002
C44
N22.
400
O111Foy
Wet 0
bMei
HR4tp
Y.rl1
4,. .k.,
. (11:23
4'3052 : O11 I : 11:0111 • 0.74341 • ❑ 01006 •. 0.7706
I3 07-Q • 00170 . 3Q 0
.
' 747 641 1 292 741 . 046'12 •
3 ]
I WA 433

•a
1170470
u 4rrtn.
0 3X04 . aman . O.01X0 • 70423 s 6MID • 2 il)
61'x,2] . BOMB ., a0:01

0.00013 aWan
-
00481
10010 . 042:2 • TI • 0 1141 • e3000a- • 3:1441
• • 40o • • 1:04 rO4 •
00303 • 40100■- . 0.4311
41N •
• 117.27110 117.21.'x,1
•
333X4. •
On •
74 al
4 I .17110

4.91294
1,4904
Agii1
1,001*
051126

0.4040
4114134
119129
0011117
1,4000!21
2 1,7.08,621
2 0(112

1.116101
0 Mitigated Conseuctieln On•Site
On
rim .
170
1000
Fu@he
1101 v0
104,..,1
141114
CN10
101].1
11oob+,
PI'1Q.5
1,_0
P0/12.2

4.1:3
Taal
♦]o- O3'2
Nei0-0002
Mal 1 0

0.4 0471
C-011•
Cabc0v0
FGkl .
tlAmy

4. • v1l:rst Oust r.
000(440

3.3074 • OMAD • 3.3074 • 68008 OOM 430E
•
• ••
• 4.0[00
.:1•:[0
11651
• 31.4447 • 215650 • 0.0382 I 5543 •
•
• •
t.5514 • 1 4411 • 1.3411
•
0C0Cd1. • 7 740944
0 2 T471 -4 • i4044, •
8 1
T400

5.11931

41.4487

21.0000
0:00'2!8

1.0004
10614.

4.B0I

0.0000.

1.4411
10411

4.09110
0,747.144
B
3,747144.
0 1.004*
3,774.347
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2950
04-25
Cont.

Page 203 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1121

Responses to Comments
CaIEERA6d Version. CetE E=1.kad.2016 3.2 Page 11 0'35 Clyde. 111212021 2:29PM Vi47aga South SpectIc Plan I -Reposed) - Los RngNas-Souttl Coast County, Summar

3.2 Demclition -21121
I1li tma titad Construction Off -Si.
dl C.

NO.
09 aG!2
TuWllnt
1rp 111
EXllv11
Prr11O
P/J!0
T,'l
Fn91ns
`.

Ed u•4si
04127
47,y3
r,721
12,0- CO
Nth,- CCC
tilalmc
C244
Gale -wry
We.t
bMe:l
H1/.dtp n 01:13
a?ail O.1 I • 11.111F • I 4 001'46 •. II. 7J56
❑.010) • VG1 V • 3
'747641 1+V0Q 740 • 1IO4 ? • , 1,84433
3 ]
• •

. ... ....,....e
u 4.7.00
- ..
03X06 . arm . 3. fiXE • 70003 s 6Grt06 • 33,7ia7
61'32]] . EOMB 0wol.

0.000a 0til'a70
- ',Aix. . -
YrrlA
0 OIAU
w�.,..._ 's.
l• _ ..
4Taik:1
00481
, -a. -s+« rte
00013 • 04 :2 • 1. 1 • 9 1141 • .2.0000.• 32:11+11
-+,a...•
Gun• 4EOCIII- • 00311
r+.
• i17.17Vai 117.21.03
---4--__
35200. •
1173011
N
• 903 r . ITCH •
r 'J-9 .
•
0223 r
3etal

4.17!6
RYA$

1.7414
3201'11

1.1M

11.01₹1
•0.5044,
111001
119129

11.111117
1,411021
tioniro
0,1!12
1,d1t101
2 2
d

3.� Silo Preparation -2021
ib1'1Tl tidaletl GcartaCrL;..1 o11 On is
1t, -=1a
r1 .,
Ct.
4;132
Fu@he
11401
Fx+,•..n
P1111❑
NJ I0
Taal
NIAve 6Jmsl.

PP1Q.5
P112.7
20,123
Taal
;2o- 300
NEW -1;20
trial 0.32
044
1320
4772e
C3Ix0R0
m
le r
,
11 ,m9
-+:1:vsc Llusr i, : i i i 10'O4M3 Ols766 1a.Wa iL93P7 o Ei0033 . 09.337 . accon : . i 0MV6 ..
....
• SA014461
•
••
1ESP:2 • 404411 • 21'.1363 • II (1 44 • 14320 • 1 Z£G1
200 • 2.!1446 •
• 3.484468 31010 638 • 1 1541'1 • 3711441
0 i 0 3
• -.- • • •
Total
220".52
MAIM
21 556
GABS
1611121!

2.0446
26:11419
40607
1115040

14.19146
3,215351
1/150.034

1.382)
37111417
I
I
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2951
04-25
Cont_

Page 204 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1122

Responses to Comments
CalEFIMarl Version' CalE FM011.2016 3.2 Page 12 of 36 Ode. 111212021 2.20'PNN Vi lags South SpectIc Plan Proposed) - Los Angeles-Sauttl Coast County, Summ r 3r3 Site Preparation -2021
Unmitigated CnnaUuc11ur1 OffSito
BC, ,
NO.

CO
aG!3
Pop,
Ma 10
bca1,31
awn
PMIO
Trani
Fn91ts
Mr:..

E.daud
ra73.7
1'rd2E
rma
111(0 CO2
N1la-CCC
Tt11lt00
114
N1.1
0X324
C0h0oy
l r
4'I'a1
I -WAN
•• •YrrlA •.
v....kn
0 L7OI
II 33,0 .. 0.0000 • 3. LULL U3030 9 00700 :BMW

0.[03, 3- _OW J 3 • i
:Q=0
4711'00
0 000 .
000Cd1
aorta,
I40841a
O,SCC
037,7[, • ❑00 00 • 3 B.MC . ,; * . .. ", -•C' ; nye,
t :; :.eYC
Or: 7 9'.xc. - 7.
s.

0.0aC0
0moo
ri+' ]0 . .
0Ai3zt
0 liar& . 00130 • 1.41C0s • 0I3'! Ia00a. • 3. lSEI
. Ca; • 007 .
awn . 104[01- . aor,.I
: 077 .
• 143.7104 I K.T3000
•
41 C4. • .

Y.13s .
37401
IKON
HAWS
0,513e
1410110.
463
d.n4v
Me
We
111IIh1
%on
Letaon
OM
1077}4
Vin, Me
14@x390

4.120(1e•
063
110J6114
Mitigated Construction O31 -Site
W6[i
N:Jz
C70
Lr1?3
Fu@he
RAI la
bisenal
701114
Phil 0
1x111
Fuave
00S1Z3
tavhsl
PW2.3
th,1':3
Tail
k`<o- 0012
HIND- 002
Trial 002
044
N20
002e
'C 'Oa0
Ps=
,
llama
� r:
- _
Fugkaa Oust
- • I - - - -- __ -
• 10,0033 • 00000 • 1""-" • 0.9377 Kan 0.9307
•• ••
_ - - _M
acme 170009
UDRt467
3488°1 • 41&4971 • 21104.3 • a MG • 20440 • 2.11416 • I6t09 • 1 SKS , 00000 • 3.OB448 0400048 • 1100 • 3710407
0 , 0 3
• -.- • • •
Tolal

3.00'
410 T 401
2t 1 40
0 .0050
16000!
20416
20:11(10
Sumer
12409

6.0110
7}94M0
3,010646
$809:@39

1.170}
3,710'.497
0 5
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2952
04-25
Cont_

Page 205 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1123

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMeod Version' CatE FM011.2016 3.2 Page 13 of 3 I0ale: 111212021 2:79 PM Vi47age South Specttto Plan 1Preposed) - Las AngNas-Sauttl Coast County, Sumner

1.3 Sire Prr par pion -2021
hfitigaded ConsUvrtiorr Off -Sits.
1loG
NO.

CO
aO2
Pop,
Pro 11
bc1.Yus1
Prxl16
PM I0
1'mal
rh4As
1 `
E...1..si
077.7
1id0t
r, 1
INYF CO2
Nth, -.7=
tail 00'.'
017.

N2..1
kX32t
embryo.'
lt..d. t
b?da1
HA41p
•••4..-0'4 •.
v, .i...,
0 ova
11330 . 0C X • I. LULL a 0007 • ❑COIL. •. 00090
a [473] 61.:441° J3=ri •
E., NO0
61CQI
I.](r.'Jfj •
a 00L41
0OI6
I40.!41 as
7G{C9
w
U-
3TCT, . ❑COM . 4. ri.I x ,; . "* .. :T '�-. ' lay.)
x • ,
Or ) G-TxYY�. . u:..IC
.

0.4IG0s
ocean
a"lax. •. .
006,34
.
a 6 . 06136 • 1.41C0s- • . I.. . IUUU . • a. EMI
• • 03: 003 •
0C0•f_"• • 1419p14- . aO3.%
x 077 .
• 14371.[4 1.4.TY.1
.
4s:,�7C . • .
106'1 •
Nol
496M1

0.42r4
0,3134
t4Ut1Q0.
043
O.13W

1.11663
We
-0.17H
0,03447
114{000•
loan
iki714
Cialtd!9
14,1 x356

4.1200°•
m6a
710.5.114
3,4 Grading -2021
ibr'1Tl tidalell Cur'.ti:rLik:tR:xll On-5.tr
1t. -,la
,1 .:

Ct.
41?2
Fu@he
iPM MI
F.c.•..n
ROM
Phi 10
101.11
r-u4mr
RSZ
aal sl.

PR72.O
N.,1:3
Tail
f4o- [+'2
Net. -t%.1
Mal C:7's'
d -U4
WC
.cute
C3lx4Qu 1
IGA9i..0
Way
„;rvsc Ws I'
• • Cob Rael
&#F]3 x OL9a6 • 9.6F30 • 36Ii6S IIDIMI 1KE.3
• •
{.6066 43113
.41312
• 4&,3 . 31 U7FI • 4..Q3EI • I UU3 • 1..SS5 • I e` ;. 16RI a • •
.L007 DO
4 •
UW Its • 1 Y'Ftd • , 6II&5013
{ 9
Total

4.1910
469463
3x.4164

41.3616
6,41.M

1.0'647
ROANI

2.4644
F_b70b
DAM

19.130:84.16
4 193'0T.6F3
4 1.4348
6l>MAfi
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2953
04-25
Cont_

Page 206 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1124

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version' CetE FMod.2016 3.2 Page 14 of 35 Ode. V1272021 2.29PM Villaga ;ion SpecltIc Plan iProposed) - Las AngNas-South Cost County, Summ r

3.4 Orading -2021
Ursmdtoyatrd Cons t['uclii ii OffSitp
kOCx
NO.

CO
aC•2
Pop,
PPp11
brans',
PM1r,
PMID
TMa1
HAW,.

Mt..
6dafasi
*.I7.]
4rd7t
r, 1
12YF "CO2
NM-CCC
islail .03'.
044,
N2.'T.
=de
CaBQoy
1a615 t
Wiwi
HMW
Yrrl9 •
Wok,,
•
r. G CCCD
u.33L0 ,, G. CCM • DUX._ 7JOO7 • ❑C0IL. •. D,D370

0.01117
DeCGu
-tDa
QM)
0,CLOO
Dl3p.x •
OWIE91
.A alma
..

M6AD34
OCL{,q.
w
r
C3d'{I . rl f%:O.^. ]I3LC oar= • ❑YLOL. • .D.O:ia7
• •. •
- r te„,•---
6rADl
Q-Cfif.
4 .7.SCG
• 0.0a1�
3CC'al0
-r,,-ax. . .

OO&1D
„, ..
1O I7 OOThG • 1.5'[92- • a.19O1 • 1.74aDs1- • 0.4]34
. . 41Fl3 . c •
.ter.

GCNOO • I ITC9a- . O.O{'la
• G122 .
......at... .
76 • ID3.3712 1 .3737
•
--4--.....4....

4.49OC'a- • .

C1pa • 1
1Nol
DZII413
LOW
IIJ, ]

1.44109,
en
D,16t1
7,1'PDOa
seas

0.15?4
O. 0404

1.1r[I
OM
1194119
1h6.aia
1{6.ara2

4.4*lue.
15111
TNADO4
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
Obt
FMK
Ct.

C
Fu@he
PFA 1a
F.•....n
FM]❑
Phil a
101.11
r11Dm+><
RWZ'
t,.._�.

PR12.]
x.1':3
Taal
7!o- G]'2
Nao-ti.2
Mai C:7's'
d4
ra:1
cOOe
--
Fugfrrnt ausl
OD R.=
&#733 • OLOG6 0.673 } • 36665 D9� . a'}�8
•
••
- O.D60G 4"e.'D
+ 1312
• 48,3 • 30.1706 • D.IR769 • 19,553 • 1..115 • I KIEL IBA • •
❑OCCE • a 077 04.2
4 •
617131' 047 • 104 • . D.U.5113
{ {
Total

4.1992
469YI6

83.1769
®.06113
{.a.m
1_A44O
MAW 37065

5.4274

7.4734
[LOON
D;D917.040
4 19SIOR.D43
4 1.4148
asaxDf3

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2954
04-25
Cont_

Page 207 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1125

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMad Version' CatE FPA ad.2016 3.2 Page 13 o13 IOale: V1212021 219 PM Vi lags South SpecltIc Plan 1Propased) - Las Ang2las-South Coast County, Summar

3.4 Grading -2°21
Mitigated ConsUvction OffS 1.
9nU
NO.
00 S'02
FuyI1 o
PP., 11
F rans1
Pl10
PMBIII
TMai
F09A..

Mt..

Gam
087.7
1187E
r, 1
5YF "CO2
NN0-CCC
toIiJ 'e
O4
N2.'T.

LX32a
Cah-Foy
1a615 t
53 OW,
HMW
... ..... -
Wed,. •
..
kn 41..
.
r. acC[ID

1.1,. 303 + U.C47k1 • J. IY - a-ODO . 00POU •. 70370
0000
11- OW
_t)Ii :QM)
05C
Ol30UU •
• „-,-..
aODE41
a+alma
.

M0.45M
GCL{,q.
9 - ..

C3d'{I •. rl {%:O.^. hr�SLC 0-0me • ❑YL00 • . any.)
. . . •
r .
6rADl
Q-Cfif.
4 .7.SCG
s.
• 0.3iG0
3CC'al0
fi[ ]G . .
. ,
0M.10
a � „1 -,1-1 .a
a0017 aal 19 • 1.5`041.- • a 571 • 1. 7400.- • 9.4734
1 . Clal . CM .
.....

GMO . I ITCOa- , a.G4'10
• 01} :
......at.- m
• 173.3732 176.3737
.

1.01- •--. .k..,.
4COCCo. • .
6101 . i
Nol
40149
aaO1Y
0,54'0]
1APuaa.
0101
a,16t1
%rm.
aas

0.1644
a06M

1.108a
Ma

0.41418
1h5.aisz
11&0

4.1*14 •
aaa
[email protected]
3,4 Grading -2O2
ibr1Tl tii;llatej Cor'ti:hLi., a,.il 011•S.
&,-,la
r,r,
C7o0
7;142
Fu@h a
00419
F0....n
001114
Phi I a
Taal
Foa0+r
PNG.}
t a 0
Pti12.5
th.1':3
Taal
f3a 002
NEo- ti0
trial 00''1
4354
WO
0,30e
C3tt9or9
F
a. 1 -._ _ - r:
,
Now
-
4E.Gushr.
• • C44 Roe"
•
&#733 i. 00900 • 0.6731} • 3.E.ES MOM • 15559
•
••
_ _ _- _ ... .
• G.acoo 17011.°0
35240 • 30.0079 . 79.1!415 • O.Oa'a1 101219 • A. 03401 • • 15041 0000 • • • •
.091141❑
E
elan 410. 1'&542 • 100 )015
E a
•
Total

3.0201

39.8##

8.0643
0:0081
'1,0.4'>'3
1 744
10:7908
:50900

1.1141
11@6

0.011.4111
9 5.011.,110
-5

1.144.2
5r.M.013
a
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2955

04.2 Cent

Page 208 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1126

Responses to Comments
CalEFMad 1delric is CetE FWEI.2016 3.2 Page 1r3 of,a5 Ode: 111212021 2.29PM Village Soi.t SpecltIc Plan IProposed) - Las Ang2las-Souttl Coast County, Summar

3.4 Orading -2022
Urxrkitiyatrd Corm L.c litnl Off -Si
AOS
NO•
CO
aG!2
Pop,
OM 11
`'a'„1
Prl16
P0.1Ia
rural
R 1...,
1':`
E..1 saa.'
x.17.]
*MILE
r, 1
1•0-CO2

NCI-CCC
ttlal W'3
OK
NIki
=de
CehYoy
lt.415 F
136h1
HMtp
YrrlA •
'A .' ,
0Maxi
11,,3-0 • 0.017k1 • J. MCC_ • 03007 • OOP00
6Aaoo
0Cal;
°-° ' • _•Dal
• a IND
OMQc
a13pv •
°OM11
�C:,-�•
.70�
TM G973
01Sf11
w
N-----.—.--
Caw. . .ice . ].65LC . ..
,. .:off
a 1 -
;OVA
OrAx3
4,
^
0-C+7f. . u3Y;
, 4
...... Paz-
••••• --
coma
p.-
JC8N10
nano .

A
- —4,—
OOFW • a03'9 • 00203 • 1.61COo- • '1 1571 • I..'3OD.
. • • e 0113 . 009
>,..,...
x.%324 • 0C420 • 113064- • ,70416
• • 032 1
.a..,. --:C. —..4.......
• ICA.97P•i NO 0.5, • 4: '3
1-6144
x6:3914
:.6967
t'Al1
01@4
g00a0
6,611.416
5)111.J1a

1..9442
401( 13
9 -5
9 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2956
04-25
Cont_

Page 209 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1127

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version' CalE FMO11.2O16 3.2 Page 17O135 Ode. 111212021 2.29'PMI Vi lagsSouth SpectIc Plan Proposed) - Los AngNas-Souttl Coast County, Sumn, r

3.4 0radiner - 2022
Milicwitd' CuelsErueli[rr orFSita
ROG
.-1:4
CO
S'C2
Pulp,
:4011
F31.Ynsl
Pr 110
PMla
TMaI
FAO...,
PB
Edu.si
OMV1
I:kt!S
r, .

Bla CO2
Nto-uQQ
nut O:7''
OK
N≥i
C:Cde
i.aleauy
Ia615 t
tor,
HR4hp
YrrlA
.A.k4
fll L4l7]
a+9A9 + t3.CMG • J. MCC • UJ ,—,...
a. M3,4 • 00434 • 11306x- . .70411a
• ari I
.s,-,. --:C.
• Iea.H71?4 1.100.5, • 4a4•Yc. • •
e • Lig •
010x1
it 9irt
a0271
0,60111
tataan•
ai6
MUM

1.taima
iadti
a15?4
until!
Livia..
a04
awe
mum'
1'Jaoliei
4244Pe-
,Ydz..
1i9JR113

3.5 Building Construction - 2fl2'2
4Jc10l tidatrll Gcltistrue1Q01 Ott -S. to
MOG
rig:.:

Ct.

C
Fu@he
PNl 1a
bs.ol
FM1❑
PN10
1x1.1
Faam+r
MUD
r<..._.l
PW2.0
1,1:3
Taal
Hew-ri.2
Mal C:7's'
d44
r.77)
C.:17•
Cats -gory
Ink= 0
Mow
CV F,37 I A007 _:0FA: . ; 10203a . 3gat. aLocc i .J.WJ4 • U E1_ an,:
• 3.554.323 :,561.333. !MM. 2;';F.'7 L'32
. e a •
.
-h,2.al
Ihid,
IS fiI'_c.
1fi. 36.16
Il U10
LLEl+9u
a .10110
' u751?
u1r,10
2,553533
2SSi.933.

0.8180
233611832
B
G
2 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2957
04-25
Cont_
Pale 210 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1128

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version' CalE EMSad.2416 3.2 Page 180135 Ode: 111212021 2.29PM Vi logeSouth Speolic Plan iProposed) - Las- AngNas-Souttl Coast County, Summer

3.5 Building Construction -2022
Ursraitigaled Constl'uclilri Off-Sitp
606,
NO.

CO
,4C2
Put*,
61%1111
Erulusl
t41N116
P0.110

7.1.1 Fugh+a
Pki'z
E.d61Y1
*1273
ore a
Tad
@1 002
N110- CCC
T.1a1 COE
CH4
N2O
t;62w
C.alepry
M 1
Wiley
HRRp
0 Cali
4tl3@7 U.CCrKI • x:6000 • a.;]UU3 . O.UVOU • 66000 • 4UU30 RaA00 1 3031:

U.6.U)
0I100 i 613(b.'JU .

0.0004,
W.ri:lul
01071
112= + 3 0391 . O.OL*i39 • 1 A'S; . ] 6'3'98 .. 4.4101 + 0 tlrr337 ' 3 2373 s. 3 tag ?:J8
3 9SA 512 • 0 =36 + ,
33002 :3tl
S .4.
4 -I.. I _-
.2
--.......4------4...........t.--....4..,,,,,,....
.mow —...,. •------4.........+h.--....4.»«.++.
a

24.20 -"_- � .- v .,.
t 607 • 3S. Nal • 8.6307 • 000 • 00443 • a. l4u • 1.61A3 RU4+}1 • I +151' 'AA.,
•0,60X53 0042304 • 6.1927 • ,0046.306
-.1 200
• • • . • • • i
• 0 , 4 . • , U
NW
*
1471111
24,1102
Limn
fVW
WJFI11
5,13635

1.1Y00
0 91

1.14312
3,300100
6366/1114
7 0.3143
364113367
4 Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
W73Ca
N'Jx
Ct.

C
Pu@he
iPiyl'n,1
eximai
FM1❑
NJ 10
10111
ril owe
8142
aa1bsl.

PP/12.3
th,1':3
Taal
♦]o- O•I22
HIND -t',0

10.41647'x'
4144
N241
133;0
C3Lipary
I
Mk= 1
11633,5,
-
OK P.w7 I,"OG; _,G 1_r:. , 1£2530 • 062{0: JLocc .0.14X4 • 0'01_ _ 77- 'I •
-30{{E - ,r 132, :,56.4,333• 6 3! .51 • 2.S61.•030
1 • r
.
9 , a
•
•
.
,-..,,,A w
i Me,
14 fi0'_c.
15-34 94
4'
4 •140
401+94

4.4010
' 00 1511
00 7 610
00/ 0144 1
2 .54.}33
2351.433.
661000
23112332+
6 01
2 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2958
04-25
Cont

Page 211 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1129

Responses to Comments
CalEFModVersion' CetEFMQ .20163.2 Page150t35 Ode. 11121"20212:29' PM Vi47age South SpectIc Plan ,Proposed) - Las AngNas-South Coast County, Summer

3.5 Bolding Construction - 2022
Mitigated Construction Off -Silt
— aBOC.

NO.

CO
,3C2
Put*,
1•M16
Er,a041
MMUS
P0.110
Tnlal
FUBBna
PMi'z
E.d61Y1
*12I
{re t
Tam
@a,. 2
NPio- COC
tilal CaO
0144
N2O t;62w
Cele6oy
ligda F
Wile,
1-11441p

04.41:5:1
S
'AA.,
Oat

0.0004 0. CC,(91 • 9: 000E • 0.7gD3 . acow • 3A10P • 000 RaA00 .. 300CE U.+7Mp
454.'00 i 1.Xl0cj .

7.OL'6
:3B
a
a040.B66
890711
I$Zi7:1"r + 3x391 . O.OL*i3• • 1 1,:55 . 04798 .. 9.Beea + 0 tlrr337 ' 3P373 4 -I.. I _-
s•3BuB 518
..w,.....—.4—.--.,w...........t.--....4.»«....
• 9,642de
38£11 SxB• 622+J3 + .33a62
.
0042 B0B • 6.199T • •
34'59
-"_- �..- v ..a

4.587'4 • 35.6961 • 0.608' • BEAU • 00403 • a.lam • 1.01A3 4U4+}1 • 140, Not
24710

14.1114

24.4148
B.61F1
},Q. 7
tiaMiI
to

1.6YOB
11441
t14BB
B,B2O1B4
7 91BdB,BB$
7 0 31113
B544dBBB
4 3.5 Building Construction - 21723
tyr'ltlitii;llated Construction On--
p6G
rio,, 4
Ct.

C
fimilive
PM vO
O,o.ol
ROM
PNIB
1x1.1
r4Boo
81420
t,._�
P0/12.3
non
Taal
Ffo- []2
New -t'2
trial 00'1
0144
N20
6394
C31:c6e'4
Mk= F
• - -
W,=•,, -•
i. '.
or P.w7
. Ia'

. 11 .3914 • 10 2141
• 0aze.: • ,
]u::U' .'J: , O:cxR ,
1-5' .I
.2.555=
6 : .=a6•
, n
0607,
• ,2,674406
,
l
.,2.11
157.0
144.3654

18.2,140
a 4e'd_r

- 04 41

4.440:

0.EXk1
4b '.1
2,555..807
B
9555.248
B
114974
B5744.10
1 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2959
O4-25
Cont_

Page 212 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1130

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: C9:E FIPhad.2O16 3.2 Page 20 0135 Ode: 111212021 2.29PM Vi lagsSouth SpectIc Plan iProposed) - Las AngNas-Souttl Coast County, Summar

3.5 Building Construction -20.23
Ir9rtli agaIIBd t`i5F1154LuQiit,:.. Off•Siru
114f.

NO.
0a
aC!2
Pop,
PP•111
brainy!
PIl10
PM13
1'mal
Fn40.s
PP,:
6d.-.si
O.i2'1
1id2t
r,mei

0.• CO2
Nth,-CCQ
tIil 0fS'e
ON.

N2%.7.
kX32t
C94$uy
106. t
bN9i
H751Pp
Yr..Ll
..
v, ...n «.
0,0571 • 0,3303 0.[011@ • a:090Q . 0 303 T 0 000 •. 00333

0.517'19 • 0_ow I. l3YL
_a37(i 3CL1m . 4.700Q .
a30Q11
_

52.6223
, -
. 0302' • a-0Pil . atto, . a03^x . 001x. • MOPS • 907,71 w . . F .
w _ .
••
-
07£32 O :. 11 ,.r 1 . '3270. +
i
_
2 ,:367.7 3773678• 010.52.... 237'8038
ry
n _
..7.:7.7.m. • 3%2& • 194002• 3 K.:, •n Tlie • ➢M70� • 0./411

1.P!n3 44#1 I , 1 •Yr.i

5.62 14 2� 6.6:I .22 • 0 Ids
Nol
! L21fa'
Hamm
T2,4RIt
Lona
ie11Uh1
taito

1. err
1,iTBe
07194
LH IVO
0 s.h8h.2th
d
O.SP11

0.044.956
4 Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
W6[i
f4tIK
Ct.

C
Fu@he
RA XI
Fx+,..al
ROM
PP/I8
10,11
FuOm+r
MU:.
t..._.A.

PW12.3
tfd':3
Taal
♦3o- [a3".+
Hew- te..1
tdal C:7's'
044
N$Q
c B
C3t...gR4
IN= tl
11,0m!1
OY. P.w7 la',73 • 11.381U ; le 24B0 • 3O,'.tt 3tn:.U• _. 0: xR 3»I r1 n{{E 2.5.5, :05 .r{{.=aOx 063' . ^2,674.196
'',ual
w 157iB
143654 '

16.2d10
0 Oa'd4'
LLl.ra•
e

4.0 —
' LLB EI
II .!..:44 flU �4I '
OI ll

2.555147
B
954!5.24 9
B
11 4974
2574006
7 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2960
C4-25
C,eni.

Page 213 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1131

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: CJJE FI.kad.2OS6 3.2 Page 21 of 9$ Ode: 111212021 2.29PM Vi47age South SpecltIc Plan Proposed) - Las AngNas-Sauttl Coast County, Summ r

3.5 Bolding Construction - 2023
mitigated Construction Off -Site
RO4i
NO.

CO
3•C!2
Pop,
Ppp 11
`'a'„1
Pl11
PMI0
T•1a{
FAO...,
Ft,:
6d¢fasl
072'3

14.42E
rmei
12YFCO2
Nth,-ucC
tail 4)3'.'
ON
N2...1
0 2t
emau i
lai t
bNa'i
I1L4tp
if
v, ...n «.
4I Mal • 0,33[27 0.0008 • O:OWE, • 43032 T 00100 •. 4110070 054339 • P_[IOU 1XEL

_0370 °m00 • 0a13.'Jfj •
3Oac11
_

52.2.5.225
..-
. 0307' • 016ii . alai, . 0., . 001x. • 0101'6 • 107'1
w _ .
••
-
07£32 9. . 11 1 . ,.r :°7a +

2 ,:3c7 3773678• 01A5T . 737'8830
n _
..7..77.m. • 352& • I9 4002 • 9 K.:, •n Die • ➢47 • 8.1411

1.5.!.53 • 4041 I . I •Yrd

5.22 1402 6.&2.1 19.2 • 0 Ids
Nol
PASCI1
11a84R
T2.9Rit

0.84!9
Pi1101t1

0.0.164

1.8dt2
iSr9B
6:72

4.9194
LHIV
n
9,G8B.2tI
a
O.S11{
BRP6OS5
4 3,6 Paving -2:623
ibl'1Tl tidalect C.or'lra tr ii Oft-5.tr
&,-,la
ruz,
Ct.

C
Fuo a
iPM v3
Fx+,•..n
PPM
NJ I O
10111
rilgra +e
MU:.
a ,.._ A.

PkI2.3
r.1':3
Tail
k10- G /2
Nu.- t%2
trial OW
044
NCO
032e
Y_1s4u Y IV=.F
P• limy
or Read 1 C673 • :0.1817 • 14111x4] •0 0220 • • OSt02 • 0.5102 • n{.25,.{ 14• 1 °
•• • •
:.'1' x:561 27137.514 • 0.7140 •
I , 1
• • ••
2= 433
e
.. ...... . O.u000 .
• • • PaN'Y •• 41 ❑ 2:100 • 111 i P ".3370
~ • • • • • •. •
. U.fa110
• • •
gam
Taal

1.0337

10.1317

11.98112
O:�
O_5OOI

8.51(12
14424

4.4{914
2,30 Kai
1 7}37.514
1 0.7140
!73'x433
n
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2961
04-26
Cont.

Page 214 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1132

Responses to Comments
1 CaIEEMod Version: CelE FM011.2O16 3.2 Page 22 0135 Ode: 111212021 2:20'PM Vi lags &matt Sp mils Plan 1P4opoaed) - LOS Angeles-Souttl Coast County, Summar

3.6 Paving -2023
Unmitigated eons truetil i Off -Silt
004
NO•
CO
002
PuWllnt
OM 111
`-'-"1
24111

1.4.1! la
1444•1
Fn17As
PII1r..

E.1.0•440
*12.7
ii400
r reel
0YF 622
Nth, .7,CC
Ttlal me
CI -14
1420.

L 37C
CeLQoy
11,14 t
b1mn1
I-IIMIN 4,
a.
0 C9®
9(1)00 . 0 000 • 01817_ • 13007 • O WOO •. 0,0070

0.(003 0.:000 3In: L
O63OO
017.'00 ; O 011.0 • i
a 0041
irvlA
01vrn
F;.swo . 00000 3.651[ 9DOW T.0MOP • 107.07

4.—»--r.4...
61`07? e.CcX. , Lair
1•
C..9]V
00Cal9 • 0MX. • .

I -
a0000
... . _... s
«r,-....._..- 1
4T•4.n
OCM31
--4+-..
6[1705 • 03QT3 • 1 . WOW- • 9 1 141 • 5.[0901- • aim
-+.—,...e
06'x'13 • d.19CM- . 609! 1
.— ,1s »—,.4:�.�......—e
• 163,91"�b 10661:0 • 2EWCa- • .
a,. 00
1COd895
• • $sb • a 4i F1# •
n C0l4 .
• • 06i • i

1.3401
48043
119014
0,x411
110110x•

11.114i
24W90e•
11111!

0.0001
ti000a•
ooYli
1tla10147
147.4140
Mau.
1710000
0111
061
Obi
063
Mitigated Conolruction On•Sitt
MOS
14410
SO
4;10?
Fugue
I41,4111

43..•.0
140114
2NIa
10111
r114mve
Peva5
ff.I.00.01
2472.]
*.1:3
Taal
Bo- G0';
New -to)
tdal0:≥
(144
N2O
C•32e
=WWII
104004
tlimy
0001010¢1 1C6p • 14.1077 • 14100- 1 • 6. Q2� • • 65100 • 0,51 • a{fie.{ 14000 6I®CO •0.M'.,, kB4 7701.504• 0.7114 •
2=14333

4. °
• •
I , t
• • •
e
raoty .`
P momm.

Z, 1.1337
❑uu6 u.9000 6,r.„� aexa�
• • • • • • •. • •

0.o-000
• • •
Pau1rt
T14011
11511117

11.99111
9:�
6!160
67160
6444.4

0.4424
1561190
2,000-214
7}07.514

0.7144
!73'x433
1 1
0 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2962
04-25
Cont.

Page 215 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1133

Responses to Comments
CalEFIMorl Version: C9:E FI.kad.2O16 3.2 Page 2 x135 Ode. 111242021 2.29PM Vi lagsSouth SpectIc Plan I -Reposed) - Las Angeles -Sault Cost Caunty, Summar

3.6 Paving -2023
�111115]dt LF Cullslrucli[rr orr-5ila
R VL--
'l3e
CO
aQ2
Pupa t
1,14111
EX llv11
Prw16

1.3J !G.
1,',
FhyA-
`.

Exlia432
OW I'
420
r., 1
134'0 "0,2
Nth,- I2CC
tilffl ✓3Ls
C44
Co pis
Wet 0
tOry
FiRlIN 4,
Yrrk4
... . _...
4b'•�.k:a
00W1

0.c o + 0 • 403a- a 30X1 • 0 0 •. 0,6wa

0.[o3] aL
u.0300
00000 : 0.X •
aOECO
a auto
e..
1rDd800
o xcc
rte-
r.2330 , 3 {7:60 3.0.1 9 010407 . 3 Car, •. ii arn7
•
1 4.—»--r..=s.-.
o exc.) e - 23X. . u Dar
1 C..SIT.
-
ocean . 0 MX. . .

I - a,.
-
00427
`..4 --.
6ffid5 . 434313 . 1.9•:09x- . 9 1 141 • 5.0696x- • a:li9} x10311.-
CO3L • d.1990a- , 0.C9! I
,1_ ........4...........4
. 10"i1.91"i 194 DIM • 2EWCa- • .
. of
404
il.0214
8900
1Ninths
601E

1.1141
WA uua
061
IL1itia

0. MO
timno.

ODA
Vail
iiii..Ovlo
ioa. 040
Milo.
0611
rnJimo
1,6 Paving -2024
ibr'1Tl tidalert r±Ur'IraL,L NAI 011.S.te
&,-,la
,1..:

Ct.
fiairre
PM Y]
Fi...ol
PM1❑
Phil D
10441
Fa1m+r
PHQ.}
&ms1.

PR72.-
N41':3
Tgal
0)o- G]';
new- 10:0
trial OW
044
N20
Cate
f_.14,7ay 1 113.49:..0
al0aay
—
.44 _ . . . -r
CMi.6W.ad 6$14 : • 8.54,45 • 11.6°$53Si I. • B. •'6.�' . 04695 • 0.4056 • R1316 , 0. c.315 • • • •
-- _
• ].,017647 7700.547 • 0.7144 • . 2=225
3 , 3 I 3
• • ••
••PaN'Y' - 001200
ill
013C00 • 11.00712 • 9df1Y1 6 �R:
• • 0
• • • • • ' . .

9.f1090 pOQ4
• 0
• • •

7.12,1 GAM
. 61010
1 l6Zis

14.1330

0.01210
(L4
ILA

414311
2,201.74T
3 2.241.047
2 7.714')
7729.330
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2963
04-25
Cant

Page 216 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1134

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CelE El kad,2016 3.2 Page 24 0135 Clime: 111212021 2.29PM Vi47ageSouth SpecltIc Plan 1Propas47d) - Las Ang2las-Sauttl Cost County, Summar

3.0 Paving -2024
Urimitigatjd eonstruetilm OffSilp
NOti
NO.

CO
aG•2
Pop,
Pr., 11
`ransi
Prl16
Pad la
TMaI
FAO...,
Fta1`
E Dab
*327

4.1425
r, 1
6aF CO2
Nl$o- CCC
t17al03O
I4
NI
0 2t
CaBQoy
1x615 t
WM,
HMW
Yrrl1
..

LTo•kn
r. 61CC®
17o9AO .. O. COM • J.1g17_ a30®5 • 0CCOU •. 00030

0.000 RG90O
J3ni_

0.0924
0CCX
000IPU •
awn'
•a
........
1QSMO]
773.7030:
. 0.vrn
03502 . i7.0a . 5.6502 . 00000 • 0.112130 .. OO:ia7
•
t —,---• 4•..
- 011,11 • 6dclOC�
4 ;.}"C[
0:0000=
t»
JGCMiO
'wax. . .
00403
0018 . 032B4 .1.0x00-. 11 1 141 •.90000-• a:11y}
• . COI . • CO4 •
00303 •8.1000x-
n D24
: 20
. ICC..G3b 1040+4137
....--.4-.............4
20220.• .
on .
1atol

6.000

0.401191
4i3a64
11FW9a.
063

2.1141

9.6668x•
804
IL11t$7

6.0005

#.1000x•
034
V001'1
4,B26a
1005.63x6
26386e•
r[4
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
W6[i

14.20 Ct.
002
fuone
Mv1111

0.•...4
PM1❑
PN10
1dal
Fa03,r
Pr1Q.5

0..._0.

P0/12.2
Non
Taal
♦]o- 002
Neo-0C33
trial OW
0744
N2.0
k332e
1 C 7q0
FG,Ga.F
-
Mow
24FRt�tl O$t7132. • 5 • 14.6258. • 8.02.0 • . 0.46B5 • 0.�8 • 04310 • 576210 • 41000 • 2.217547 771.%.047 • 0.7140 • . 2_12.205
• • • •
3 , 2 I 3
• • • '
Pa4'Yy�
:
0 012000 • LOMB• 0201Y1 6c0
• • • • • • • •

•
.0.1.1.00 }7001a}
• •
Ta0al
0!839'8
I.MS

14.11278
6:0128
00130
00697
44310

0.4310
OA=
2,331.347

2.107.047

0.7146
0229.380
I
2 3
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2964
0425
Cont.

Page 217 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1135

Responses to Comments
CalEEMorl Version' CetE r_rNrart.2416 3.2 Page 2S of 55 Clyde. 1112'2021 2.29PM V1I LIge South SpectIc Plan 1Proposed) - Las Angeles -Sault Cost Caunty, Summer

3.6 Paving - 2024
c4ilivaird' Cullstrucliur orf-5ila
ROG
.-1Z4
CO
a0•2
Pop,
Pp 11 '
`ransi
Prl1b
Pad la
TMa1
RAO...,
r?a1`
6dl
*I..]
47412E
rmei
12YF CO2
N1$o-ITCC
tUtl O:r.'
C144
N2.'1.

LX32t
C.ahQoy
l •
WM..,
1-1.0.1
V••Yl1
..

LTo.k:•
0[000

1.1 C•303 • 0 M • J. MCC_ • a3DOJ • OW00 • 0,0070
•
°WOO • 80900
JIFL
• U.+T`O(.1
90009
013(alrj • •
04Wd•
ea4
.... a ..
"IMM 2
. O�vrn
03}i{i. . i7.00 ].0OLC • 00000 •. OiYO❑ • . II MIL
•
a t
- 0rffi7 • DWI.
4 ;.}"GL-

0.00➢0=
w
OGCMiO
vox. .. - .
00403
.
..—,---. .1.............11...
0418 • 032B4 • 1.D3CO2- • 11 1 141 • d9000a- • a:111.9) • • 9i•& • • CO4 •
00353 • d. 10 C4M-
n Bd4
; ns. "
• 1E0.dG3d• I9@8030
•
...-..4-...........4
24][Go. • •
on •
1 Nol
cam

0.4193
46'34111
7lfWUa
eta
Y.1141
velum.

Ma
IL11t$!
GOOMG!
#.1504'•
Mat
U'JYI'1
IB41:5tIn
105.l3a1
Liam.

CM
•
7171A1B2

3.7 Archiieclural Coaling -2024
Unmitigated Cons hucho i On -Ste
MOS
rta.

Ct.
a;10?
Fu@he
PFJ119
F.•....n
P1111❑
Phil
1dal
raow+e
PV2.5
ta,
PR12.]
tro:5
Taal
k10- [a32
HIND-te.2
trial OW
054
WO
0132e
=ham
1GA9a.o
u v ,
- - -
1r.
lAr•the. Camnl o Zkn4110 • • ChCODP- •-0.6:CO • oOM Gl4mc III • • •
-
acme - 41"8.'0
OM1Rau9 •I' L 1898 .21415 • 18101 •"79drISp • pOFAfr • 0.0BCU • O'LIBrL a!33'.t5 • • • •
• F11:44$
38 e.4LLl • 00154 • • 2818493
•
Txal
Ts4R69i9
1L0

1.41101
23r0L..

MS
1121141:11. •
IBM

0.0541

0.4.97!
₹514151
1414411
0A144
Z31.544
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2965
04-25
Cent

Page 218 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1136

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version. CalE FI.kad.2O16 3.2 Page 28 of 35 Ode: 11121" 021 2.29' PM Vi lagsSouth SpecltIc Plan 1Preposed) - Las Angeles -Sault Cast Caunty, Summar r

3.7 Archllecluraf Cooling • 2024
Unmitigated Construction Off -Sift
.O0
ND.

CO
J02
PLIOl,
4•,4111 '
Exu.11
P1415,
P10!0
Trod
Fn91ns
51,421.

Ea L'fa l
*12.7
432
rr4r4

3.,- CO2
N17-C.C
is133ifa0
044
N2.2.
0:02e
Ca11$oy
144,15 t
b1mn1
I11MW
•Yrr.1:4'
«�
YT71•kn
r. 00l700
11+9X1 , 0.COM • 2.11— 03003 • ❑4400 •. 0.0079
0(023
0221 _XFL

0.4300

00.'013 i 3.303Q •
0(1-141.
arm
,.....,.
1,127458
a
u O'vra

3.33(0 . 0740 . 7.407 • 33(..3 • OYAOG • -0.4:(00
a _ I, 2•s
61200)
i.

Q Cal -
:xYr
�_. .
c..oro)n
• -
6cc�o • o7mc •
04,2(0
.
0241 • 20(130 • 0.0110 • 4.2171 • 0.43000- • I.22
• oaa •
----4—

0.2223 • 1419600- . 73310
• oce 1
.. ..,,.w.. »"..`t"
•1,12(2241 1125 ?}B• 0!3356 •
a , a
17441
I 44388
43741

3.4797
0:0110
1,3111
aaa.Du.
803
12244

0.74120
tA094e•
8[17
133111
1,130%48
a

1.125,749
a
0,4X0

1.127.969
a
Mitigated Con4lructiQn 04•Sitt
aac
14734
043
1;12
Fu@he
1343414
arsenal
P4111❑
CN ID
Taal
r117AVG
PNf2.D
tJmsl
PR02.2
41:3
Taal
0#o- [130.

HIND- 002
Mal 5,02
044
1420
17337
C WM!
11X90..4
. - - vi
,
13333,5,-
- —
a .. - -- - - -
)Ar e. Caffihl 31b'.a1i0 • • 007644 • ;l.Otm • RAO� 46101 •
••
-

6.0000 4"=3
❑MRe49 •" 41 18(131 .21013 • 18101 •"297C.C. • 0.0FAfr • 0.070 • 0'410(0) 00803 • • • •
00711. "1`31.044
3a e.4401 • 00154 • .70'4113443
•
Taal a
24(6919
12&1

1..101
134709"
811]

4.4406

9.1410.4
46749
44007
0}0040
1350.4441
221.414.1

0.0144
211044.0
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2966
C4-25
C'eni.

Page 219 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1137

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version. C9:E FI.kad.2OS6 3.2 Page 27 0135 Owe: 11121" 021 2.29PM V1I LIgeSouth Spe otIc Plan 1Roposed) - Los Angalas-South Cost County, Summer

3.7 Arch 11eclural Coaling - 2024
Mitigated Construction Off -Silt
1100
N0.

CO
J02
PUWI,-
OPOIll
Es.1. 1
WU,
P0.1, la
Tn119
FnyA-
C4,".

E•dumsl
MP-,
19d2D
I.:n.1
14H- CO2
Nth,-CCC
itLilCOE
CH4
N2
C 2w
CaBQuy
Wet t
bitte1
1140
•••YrrlA
d
YT:o.ka
r. 0=0
11,5311 , 47. COO . 0 MCC LI3CD7 w ❑COIL. .. nOO9

0.(017
it, OW 1YFL
Q0 47CL'IX i IocoQ .
[1 41([01
.9+SZC

1.12r C5a
J.
: ,C'vrn
s
F;.:000 , 0 006 i 5.Ri1C - . tlFJC07 .- OYAOG . O. G:ie} _ ii. - 1..........4.-
-
6l'A(

4. -
I-C+Yf. . :;:xY[
___
• CI9Y0 JCE%10 • 1:1•11:0 • ,
:
0422[
„
11241 • 1•213118 • 0.011'- 1.7.,171 • saaaom- • 1.2S�
co .
—........t.-

0.2220 • Sd9C0a- •. an,a
. ow 1
.. - ... .. ..-4.—...—.........4
•1:,12 224. 1 I ?}e• I!2200 • ,
a , a ,
Nol

4.429!
A2ei1
%OM
00110
9101
ACa4IT
aals
1234

0.3229
tA9UIm
rca
013114
1,12d.Td6
0 1.12B 11.6
3 0,12131

1.121.0 B
a

4.4 Operational Denali - Mrrhhile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2967

04.25 Cont.

Pale 220 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1138

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CJJE FI.kad.2OS6 3.2 Page 28 of 35 Ode. 111212021 2.29' PM Vi47ageSouth SpectIc Plan Proposed; - Las- Angeles-Souttl Coast County, Summar ,.1
Ir
nez
Pope,
Ff 411
14410
Ele uerl
FIJID
told
Pugh a
NM. CL!2
idtl {A7.
rim
ratnyr ,.y
AnnualvMT
4rr1,IVMT
... �. ....

Aputrne.gLS.1;1ry R,q4,
• .A!I.

If4,2 r
1`5401
541r1.227 j.
..... f>_r:. p7 ........

A
ApwlmemsN Rine a
422 7.5
3 73,?5
?5
4 13,860,165
1366i3OEE:
_
Cknerel Cffrr landri 1
29!45
*
81 755
,.. 31 U5
..;
717ft,95
r�OL 12
dig•Turrrc.+u{StCSvrnRe>�unldl •
Zara ad
2;,472.52
391772
�
�.
•
8413207
..•-•••••• .
_ .. 1- I
tae no 9
10 50
55700
;
..3413.337
5701 ;
445,,43
•
6uatfrh Fde ur aka ar k
1,_
611 E2
48113
707,4943
707,{69
R goonl daorprg�Cs-me,- .....
u:, •
6D1. 44
357.24
• 1112=1
1,112221
Tot.

I :;.0 I
E . ICA 42

5.057.31
I 20562,4.52 II

20.562,462
4,3 Trip Type informattra l
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2968
04-25
Cont.

Page 221 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1139

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version' CelE EIh061.2056 3.2 Page 25 '0135 Ogle: 111212021 2:29 PM Vi47Oga &O1.tlt Speclt93 Plan 1Proposed) - LOS Angeles-Souttl Coot Caunty, Summoner Trip
Lpnd Um
H -Wei C-49
H-8 ai C C
H-0 or C -PAY
Aparlinent919..Rim
Atmieseril i0 R19-, ;
•••-

19.7V 5.30 0.
✓ ---r
H'A' a1 941 li-0 95 C -C
I -I C or 3-1100 Plirr19ry D'r.+erxd Pedt-bie
4l'.'t3 • 12.i.C' 40 6x', i "so • i1
4-
•
IA 74 I 5.90 ; 6.70 403''0 i 19.70 40:60 . be 11
6cnerylCr6cepJ1771kJ ,4 1064 610 X130 •
. 33497 a 4040 1000 • TT 15 • 4
H.r.HOTurrlgieer(St c,o r 4 1660 i 940 ▪ r 91} * 650 ¢ 72.04'e 1990 •F•37' 3"1) ,43• •••• ..r ..r. r r ewe . 13
..
.. .,.. . + •.1r -`•--`4 •� t •, •...•
Hmal y 16.60 i 040 r 630 a 1940 • 61.60 I 10:90 " 54 • 36 • 4 f11•111 . • T - r. - I.
•
Molly daslaurart : it to r 5.10 , 9.99 12 GO Ow I 19.00 ppmL1 outer 16.611 9.40 • 4 SD 16.39 t SG70 1900
3 3e is . 44
64 a
1';

4.4 Fleet Mix
L9e101iige
LEA I 1Ar1
MOM 4HD1 LH04 MHO HOD
ass Ireus
uGY
b . 91l1wits Low Rise • 0343096 11 WA719 0 20%01 0 118369 Apartnrralls Mkt FCrra _ • 00430a0# 0.04.4210 0203071 0110369 GeNtral Office &mina ; 060060*, 64018 04iAIM b 118
♦ 1--
H1gh l.rrmer (SH Dom • 0443068: 0144218. 0124971. 0118100.

Rctam-am
.- a
Hotel
• •0 14300,63 004421

4.. }-`----'
O.utlry P00t4Wralt • 054:39116, 04+44219
-4
RegloneI Slapping Crater • 00400083 0044210• 0309971• 0110160• 9014011 000&32. 0 0211108 9.030077 0.002613 0901917 8 0)9099 0 000712 a 0)9621 00140113 0000832. 0.1:21100 0.033'376 9.00$13 0441017 0.009299 0,000712 00300331 9014033 09004632 0 020190 0.088077 0.6 028t3 0.401917 61505,"P8 0.1300700 0929021 0014440- Og08d92• •�0021149• 0.0@3419. 0003818-0901617'. 0.661soid; 00016712 6 00863', 0 11639
a 118000
0014011
00149413
0900333
0998}3,2
q 021100

0.1221 186
9,331677
[.332047
0014032: 0 000312' 0 021144+
000'10'17

0. 1017

0.300921

0.1000441

0.033577+ 000 01.3• 00018173 0 6052110 0 000712. 0 000621

5.0 Eneogy Detail
tiotorl al Energy Vie 'A

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2969
04-25
Cont

Page 222 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1140

U9mi.; d ..

Responses to Comments
CalEEl44a}d Version' CetE FI.kad.2016 3.2 Page 30 0(39 Clyde. 1112+2021 2.29PM Vi47ageSouth SpectIc Plan 1Propnsed) - Los Ang2las-South Cost County, Summ r 1r
noz
wgµ.c
FYA1D
Eleuerl
FrOle
PLAID
total
rugby.
t
!dal CO7
Mit
rm
Category
1 R.!d•1!
614ny
r1alu.aA3as . 07006
• OF.442 kP9T3 • 0:MIB .... ❑°2 i 0.52]2 i .... D.3992 O.. f17B • B7 • . T9 • B 4416 6 • DG107 . 11.5222 • D.5222 . lLS• • 8.355943 i 83(i59B]• D 1e0Ti I G!53.e i 9903 D3B
r9.355.4ffi 8355.113•.D.1002 O.1535 9X05 B3B
2 2 • t
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2970
04-25
Cant

Page 223 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1141

Responses to Comments
CalEEl44a}d Version' CatE F(t kad.2016 3.2 Page 31,0135 Clyde. 111212021 2.29'PM Vi47aga South Specllbo Plan 1Propased) - Las- Ang2las-Souttl Cost County, Summer L2 Energy by Land Use - NaluraiGas
[.Unmitigated
F•1•IuralCla e„11,ri
_. kegcntl
ej,nliMnp M: r•?
ISE# 8
r' OIS1, • 9.40''2
0 4013 4C,21l ;
:I- 1-
02%0 • 03003 +. • 0 Xia&" • 0.2Gfsd
• 4300 016 • a 21.01B 0•1_,T.7 r
• 52.1'042
0013& • 01232:
0 007 7A000o-
6 • Q,SIOir, 9A00o- • 0.0 -ACC.
+9 • 1 :1 • 22&MOu. `s..

IX11 J...3
I• •224011 • 7.311
oA7•13 'A0 : 0.0134
i
0 03E41 . 11.10043 • • 3.101 a'I; q
r a ..
4r 7.431 •.Let. 63. 00512-7 4-0101 :'1ieirt,
�' •a 2 i • a
•47067''
1014 • 0.40070
03820 0100 •2 .-1
0300• 0 a 0 O • • 0.01200 • 642366
36 40111 . 5_4249.100. 0 0 0104 • 0101 •'55442E2
• 50.4 `0
k •100 .1 • 04953 • 00100 1 73600, • 1 00002 • 00220 • • 0.051+ • 000 0 .......• 99 00000. 131 .00000 r 00100. , 7 6100 1590505 • "
. 251.010
i
. 21100e • 0.012+10 •
M . r
49:Q07
,

1.'0100, r
ON r
1 1.07100,
, NO
0 1,6707, •
OM :
0 1.01001, • 1.6200o-
i W OM
• 21.901k • 2401110 0 a.il)0e- 1
• r 024+ i
5:40113, .

Q0s
is of

0.70011
II31₹5
113373
410111
05102
00242

0.02 0`2'12
0355,193
2 1155.995
2 01002

0.1037

0.1.. 030
1 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2971
04-2'5
Cont.

Page 224 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1142

Responses to Comments
CaIEERA4d Version' CetE F(t kad.2016 3.2 Page 32 0135 Clyde. 1112+2021 2.29PM Vi47ageSouth SpectIc Plan 1Propnsed) - Los Angeles-Souttl Coast County, Sumner

6.2 Energy by Land Use - NaluraiGas
Mi tiga49d
F+hIa7+ICaz
s un
Ai[ad
0aba
336
-

45.02 f-0111.0
PM14
"__.._.

Pk11O
7x,114
7r•4l
F..411..

P? !1.

E:OaascY.

PM2 4
p4v`2i
147.1
alo- Cdl
Nk7o- -.•:"
- -
Land 115t
rUryr
ld1Caq
+t,tls3
44,0,M101. -LO. .

Pox
71pt r
. 1xn l91
.....-.....k.---.

Ga00sa1[n0ks .
9v10hn0
- -1un rCiiir.'-7N.iI
Dom Rmia.uar'i
I�
•,040•• .+lp,0105a75
•9aerata'1
1110.15
r 0910 • 4.103[
w
OL42a • p -00._ •
Mk •
.57100+6 • 9.-54]0.0 • • .531001 • 8.3404►
MI TO 90.3 0M
• 1216 • 131,EsaZ • :'BSI:. •
.. 014
32 I 1188d
540
G
561.1212
211 IEJ
3S 7243
t342
Z 0.11E1 . 3.3072
.+013 40211 ;
—.
0 2M • 05103 +. • Xi6.1 A 0.200E
• 431100G• a 21.415 0QL 'r
a ,
0013& • 01252:
01007 a 70CC4] -
004
..
0 e• 0+5lOiw 9AOOo- il^00[s
040 SKiS 093' 903
.--.-
+1 • 1 DOI Mu. `s..

U91 .W3
•22400 • -Z.3II
oI7A0 000134
i
0 IOEE . II5u 3 , • 3.11%39 a'Ilkq
•
r • a
••
417.534. 2.Eit535, 961712-70-0001 :'1iOW,
2a 2 i n y

4..7 +72
1•

10.14 • 9.4470
05020 . 2 aline -1
. ..0244 • 032366
Q 9556 a 0.0355
501 1136 . '5151.140 • 90104 r 9 0191 y
k •1iY 19 • 11.017 0 00043 1 2-3510,- 1 00157! r 0837: • 1 0.051+ . 06;71 �• •
I 993 n n • .
'
..... 199 05 10017Fx]..24000r 90100. 1 90140 .591500
i a
o

1. 0.170700 . 0.,53010
&ulnira Ge-..:
201004- • I.012+10 0
1!,0 . r
PJS97
i

1.00x010,- r
994 •
1 1.0710kr
. NO
0 1,010724 — .

OM i
0 1.070, • 1970111.
i 0 ? OM
• 21.7.31k • 2y?0I2l0 0 a.i7)tle- +
r 0Q+ i

6.416.411105-4p .

QJs
i••10p
47030
II3149
1,;0033
010111
05102

05."12

0.52•X
I0w.2"12
3;555,193.
2 1155.915
2 011052

0.1037

0.1"•',039
1 6.0 Area Detail

6.1 Mftlgalien Measures Area
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2972
O4-25
Cont.

Page 225 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1143

Responses to Comments
CalEFIMod Version' CetE FM ad.2016 3.2 Page 33 0135 Ode. 1112+2021 2.29 PM Vi cage South SpectIc Plan IP opnsed) - Los Ang2las-Souttl Cost County, armlet KEG
te0
,W
Fup 0.e
PN'16
L49061
04170
Mai ft
1164
1 CFIaJ•n
P►2b
10101.

Pin In

60. C,02
TnIal 'EGO
Y;I
ikrzo
4,7
1'4:1
Me4141e+1 317126 + :594511 • 084431] , u054e 159,41 • 10574 d 1 557 1551,1 01O]S • 1014835. le 14&59. 0.45,4 6]510 • 18. 51.t1 A ! A "11‘17.4 56
ily S"7 d T 6:
lln-. l.l .. 355{¢6 T+ 1541 x. 456 • 4437 . d 67W T "11‘17.4 135: 4 T •�I 6004 • 1 +�' � 100116 • 16:143 50 1 15 145 55 -0 4974 . 0.35+6] • 15 5 I I* sa as
M

6.2 Area by Subcategory
thirnitgated
₹D3
♦
s,3

5.2,2
131,9L,e
i.e 14
'Fidauaj
PL110
PlIV
Tptd
F11dtwr.

OM 5
&hall
PAi2:9-
P142
Tc6ili
Bar CO2
NP7tt CUP
,,2,10
191
k1SYa
CO27
&Y;31epo11

7.P1 q1
1etley
Ir,lltFe[Wral 224110 • •
t1 7 4
+ aWCO + Ol}lMI + r 2aW6
0:7]40
L• GEM P
1 4
017016
55706
l&7CL110
66 45.27442
+ Cglsmer + 24.1066 I
PTmueel. ,
O.a6W • a.o6W i dOW6
40760 ••
W •
I 0W + i •
I
aP
Mgsih 1.6976 t 10011 ! &DOM I 05760 + 114m t I 1460 + 1.1457 w 1 . i + P
w ,. + P
17460
10066 116.0.�W 16.576.001 -03.470 I 6,367 a
+ + . P
1 co i 66 + Y
La cimixrp - 2 760 • U.9493 -
924939
._
'd 3,049, 64579
� 046,4
• •
0 •04574
• 1 0 ;
48b.4674
116+6%5 •
0,1424 1 •
+
Told

90.6426

15.41414
67141420
110044

1.3674
1,54174

0.69774

6.5111,1
30406
1&14836
60 18140515

5.0 34574

6.55410
16751114
55 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2973
04-25
Cant

Page 226 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1144

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF FI.kad.2O96 3.2 Page 34 of 35 Ode: V121" 2021 2.29' PM Vi47ageSouth SpectIc Plan 9Propused) - Los Angeles -South Coast County, Summer

6.2 Area by Si bCalegory
Mdiaaild
R47a
RY. .
67 &rt
₹wylY.c
!eV iA
G3a.unI
P4iirJ
FR.A0
NIA
Fgave
PVJ21
!4
PM82
Mid`_'
'.#9
Pin.c.Cei
NEee CO2
Tula]
&4
PLO
rm. '
F3_dka rpary
.''d m
Vday
aReitiOe1I •
Comb re
Ce.wnu
...... A,...a
H.2-it I.MJip
Lan _aprg
2;5,0
0080]
00000 . F 0QOM 00[90
DMD
. 9Mee
E;itra
.TSl99.60
50 . loz1012
F
:1.1085
y t I 7 d
Of:Lc
)ClG]3 , own] 9®09
1_ .-_-I- . • •- - --. - - - --1 ,.. . .
09890

7.7 . 1.1008 • 5Dp89
0CMG
,,arA

1.149!0 .

I 89
-1.1

1.1489
0 004G . 12.Wd99. l8.worm
q 00
0342C . 93X0
arTeO 00400 ; tY2w:F7
{ 't
a.'SeGOr
b.Itira
• 4;+57r
F i
a4 4
J 74
-]4&.0 4. 1A&C65p
F

9.114 •
1 ralaf
3n 9
1'i949d
612.1410
R9e}4+1

9.>lpr4
esv>'a
L4071
T-3074
00400
tlela$34
50 1®.i1a:xa
50 -11.a1alra
02300
,a.tutii
42 7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water

8.0 Waste Detail
L1 Mitigation Measpres Waste

9.0 Operational Of road
Eg1181♦r ixPi le
ltru, C�,!N
rue, Tope.

Stationary Equipment
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2974
44-25
Cont_

Page 227 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1145

Responses to Comments
CalEEMorl Version' CalE FI.katl.2016 3.2 Page 35 a(35 [fete. 11122021 2.29'PNl Vi togaSouth Speclbo Plan 9Propnsed) - Los Angeles -South Coast County, Summer Fire nutrias urld Erite rgendw Generators
EPIParnerd Type
NLtntee
Iieurg a•y
HaersPeeor
Florae Power
Load Factor
FLaal Type.

I Ir[
Y-rruPreert Type
Nr.niher I I-Isxt p iU ' I tarok Irpi,t,Mexr
5ukr A.arng I FLeiType
U.ri Dr.firm:I i ;7..iudr,rrrI
Eppel -nerd Type
Number

11.0 Vegetation
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2975
04-2E
Con

Page 228 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1146

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CIF elika2O16 3.2

1.0 Project Characteristics

Page 1 ends

Village South Specific Plan IPrnpaseldi - Lns Angelus -South Camel Gouitty,'i a ter ViI ye South Spemcific Plan 1Proposed}
Los Angeles•Sou th Coast County, Winter
1,1 Land Usage
Lan] LJws Sea 1 Ibad4 1 1-1>"rreap I PAam 3ufa aAre2 PaiLla nti Csamral OtEr.o B ildla-y 45 tic ; tc01`.ygf ! 1 r,.' • 46'C }P rA 7 i a--- $ .�.�................

H4h Tiornst 1St Ova11 Reeaw.rrti W3 OP • 1,5•Nts7Pl • 0.93 36,%909 I SOA Haal P R.13.111 1.F 1. r 7P.600,00
I 4-----� #
$w Hy F?cshurrrrt S.ed t6litrgh a O 1'd 6,4121 op
r .._. s 4 -a
Apar9nedalew Rise 25.00
LYwelirvg unitt I-
i- 156 2 oco os
•.•Ap itmants Mid Rigr 97..07 Dwelhy Unir .5.c•' 'SOPP PO.

Reponsl 6heppr. CeMci 58.00 - 1�ri0Es It
1 P; J EE.:03 00
72 2769
1,2 Other Project characteristics
1J[ban,7ml rpn Urtraa
C®mate Zurit 9
UUIpY Company 5?rathern CeiiiarnLt easri
CC2 intermit',
riux4Wtw)
Wind Speed (rigs) 2P
GI -14 Interts
filatititkri

1.3 User Entered Comments 'Si Non -Default Data
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
00779
Pr(acrpRallos Freq pays)
Opereete it Yeti
N O inianslty
ilUkiri .r)
2976
Prue
04-25
Con1

Page 229 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1147

rh FUvplara
tr>trlrel�m�e-
Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CaIE El kdd24t6 3.2

Page 2 of 26 ends

Village South Specific Plan I;Prapaserll - Las Angeles -South Coast Goui ty,'Irtllrter Roiled Ckraracterisecs • fionsistenl with the ❑EIR'a model:

Land Use - Sue SWAPS comment regarding rrsade ntlal and retail Land LOGS.

Construction Phase - See SWAPE comment regarding Indeabelual construction phrase lea nt% Derrloliion- Consistent with the DEI R's model. Seer SWAPS cc rnment regarding dernoliiion Vehicle Trips - Saturday trips ccnsislertt with the DEIR's model, See SWAPS crei meri regarding weekday and Sunday hips Woodsmues - UTAcodstoves and ‘,../Docigturniirlig fireplaces consistent with the QEIR's :model See SWAPS corrmera regarding gas fireplaces` Energy Use -
Constiucticin r3ff{oad Equipment Mitigation- Sue :.ulr!mtdiPEcomment on construction -related mitgatiion.

Area Mignon - See SWAPS mmrrnent ragardtmg cparatioa I rnlhgatlen measurers.

Water Mltlgalkmn -See SWAPE cramrncrrl regarding opectikartal milagati an rreaoures Trips. oral VPAT- Local lire preulsicin
GdumnNartx
Eliratit Vales
Nrmklaalio
gr ephcaNbcdMaes
11:0010apfanas NmmmbnSSAmod
4 twimp4t..nr Nulnn:W.14 d 46.75 i aD7
. •• •••, , t4arialifirteruth ,,.,,,: 1a.ao a—= 14.06
4 I
'0314 20 OIp
1,01930 _: ...........

OM
A _
a

13.4 000
thRtiog1gullNr
IbrinprArrll$ir
IGrrni36001W4rr
WIorY0rTriplrrglh 1A.7a
4 fascia
14�FrrieITrlpLergr a 1A.70 14:40
rblrnpsAndmUV warkerTriplrngth
1604,6006 0.0.11-
werienripterigru

10.70 10.70
1171rnpe oolir
Do -We Mel —Mpg
t^61r161-06 PToli3
ti Wel0100Tnpe
ttr4ehh'lgrrmps
4 4
WYirklrTIItL00,435
ST_T4{
51,TR

14.70 I

7.16 6 39
BR
*du
MOD
WOO
6 17
1 39
16637 Pa.N
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2977
04-25
Cont_
Pape 230 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1148

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: COIF Fl 40',2016 3.2 Papa 9 4135 Dale: 1112.1 121 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan ',Prop .AO - Loa Angela's -Soul" Cal Gourty,Vdlrtar WiehkleTripa
totenittaTIl
ST_TR
STTil
�T�TR
mru rhleleTo109 SU_TR
taNvhlc≥oTnpG 5U_TFR
•

8.19 3.75

94.39 92.99
N.97
x:.07
86 tAFJ4hta7aT+IFis 9UTRR 105
tWahklv7ripc .Su_trt 1d 1.84
tt*ahlclaT7 j aU_TR y 59.5
4- 4
16NahIcpTopa SUT1 T2,15
taNahiFbTnpa # 24,2,
a
Nahk>mTnrs 'h4_T9l • 6.'J4
i
-4
4 IblVehic Tnps YN]TR 6.86
-•
GbillehkkTrips WO 132 11.03
. ._..- tLNehkkTn 4 AD_TOR
ttltifehteinT0ps
tBMehreieTnps
„ .441,
„ . MNu64hlcisTrips
•
-4
127 15
8 17
a27
ttiVi att56N^^^ems MarberCataryle
raihvat Yas * . N4P brrAltahrac
•
4 -
125

49.75 toteicortiovee NBiirenicrotahlk
4 - ....
ltdAtewistlaves t{gremn,icnwu,6-9; i 45,77
4-
yen Wtorlato adayttrar 23.00

4... 4
125
VINTIOCA]Ya M1fpcusmrcbayTar 23.®
•
t L4boc .'� v47m eWoo Aar • 594'0
c
1 15
a 03
77,05

6.x.9
gala

4.13 841
30 3.24

52.64 0 D

0.43 0 DO
0 D
0:W
003

2.0 Ernissions Sumrnary
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2978
04-25
Cont

Page 231 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1149

Responses to Comments
CalEFIIVod Version: Ce6E FM0I1.24s6 3.2 Page 4 of 35 Ode. 111272021 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan I,Prapnseldk - Lns Angeles -South Caaal Gourty,'I['Jlrter 2t Overall cnns ri ltlln IM.tiaxim9+m Daily Ernmsskon)

9.9fin1i97yaG147 C ri LruAiuii
(400
T.I.N.

C..7
2ft
fuyL?
01410
Ed¢uei
414714
F1.4110
1441
F4011x4
1,029
64651
4147.1
Y•kT15
T
Bin C.O2
Nair CO2
Tula] OW
- -I4
142117
CDa.

Yew
4YO.sy
May
;KU1 47971 • 45,4460 • 31.4053
.3 P525 • 157037
7945
20 2 • 6,6670 • 1.Sd211 11.0453
61000 •6,154.33716154.337
1014,;; 00093 •5+'24.910
r
5 3477
4 7560 • 648591 . 300339
+: 11 _. .
5'481
104918 • 56395 s 1.462
9140'.

X00[100 • 17.03534.17 O1934
10-03 • 0Ooral .17
CCEN
9 J-
- f
W : 441
.

I
Z
13 .......... .g.,..a.....,
5333 4
- . . . .

II 714 4.1
43 30 . 30.3048 • 37 5531
.31103
70035
--- -4.
07,54
.....9....-
77065 • 1.0700 • 5.7143
.• ...
2!0040
.....
40003 • 11,710.40. 11.710,45
O�W317
01100.3 •
00 IN
41 • •__31124 • .

Z3r.9593 • 0.5573 + 14.3392
4L.P116
[.1171

0.4064
126Th . 0.32.`'0 a Ii4 10
9:il2.'
2_1700 . ,5=307.981 . 23170961

0.7104
041020 ;2324.062.
1 7
. 7
f6B7 ilm.
2341.004

45.-5100.

1.0 BIM
"41710
W
2w90
241.
4,96670
UM

11.2490
010110
17,0%.9.4

12.39.11 1
s00e4
te,00O.110
a
44 19
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2979
D425
CC1nt_

Page 232 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1150

Responses to Comments
CalEE=l oil Version: {'+9:E E=MOd.2016 3.2 Papa 5 of 35 Ode. V1212021 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan I,Prapasedk - Lns Midas -Soul" Caasl Gourty, Winter ter
2,1 Overall Cornstructian (Maximum Daily Emksskon)
Affitic tad COrlil uc11011
- R47a
ti,'
5,0
SC.,g
Tvpl?re
P11110
Edauel

1.4714

8.410
Tni91
Fattlivre
P1/29

6.51 P142 il
Kid f
T
Bin. C.O2
Nair CO2
Tula] OW
- -I4
1420
CDa.
'Pow
lahlm
May
.9:1 47571 • 45.4460 • 31.1063

0.51.25 a 7.9.7032
7-9455

70.-x` • OW711 • 1.WIll a 11 biW

0.CO1I) • E,154. 337 a 6154.337
l stir; • PC0©0 • 5 W13.0$9
r
6 . . •
4'0G • 30 g5G1 • 323339
+: 1 rn
r.leI
104315 + 5639& 1.5063
5143x
gOG06 • 1343534 • 17 35534
I O ..7 • 40030
• 12 CF.i.6:1
r
. •

e s
•

4., 9 J
-
_
Z.
....•..... .a..•a.
5333
-030.1➢ • m.3518 • 3T.5031
-
011[2
FtH?s5
-r---4.
0 70D0
. ..-
7 7N5 • 1.57313 • 5.7143
.• .•
2J40
. ..,..•
00040 .11,710.45 • 11.715 40
OMIT
4LP55
• 19 ?d.au
93 IN
ki
...72....
. T3i99C0 • 0.557} , I4.5372'
0Cri..16

0.21P1

0.4505
1207!6 a 532.`'0 • 114$10
5:112'

0.05.39. •2500.9111 • 23170961

0.7154
I.U007 :
,,1 1111
• e
i 6
• ' • 7
B 7
I.
4t4444.

54.339
"n7'I4
4a.2072

2.4595
Mill*
3,91470
Ead7a

11.2490
A.0504
12054234

12.439.31
1:4732
SHOO
t?.OORI70
1235.00ao
40 1,1
R04#
NCS•
Co
443
Fg1110
PN13
9-aEtals[
>M413
PAM
TatY
r thio
FTIRS
Eal aua
P :25
P5120
Taal

8.2-0O2
141L a 4-02
Tat,. Cat
GH4
520
502a
P.remf
Rackatier

0.04 0.00
504
au5

0.03 0.33

0.50 0 00

0.51 0.00

4.00 ODD

5.50 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2980
0425
Cont

Page 233 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1151

Responses to Comments
CaIEEINod Version: {'+9:E FM0d.2416 3.2 Page 0(35 Clyde. 1112.12021 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan I;PropasaM - Lns Angda,s-Skull Caaal Gourty,'J'?r tar

2.2 Overall Operational
Unmlitiigatte Ciestatiwlal
kioa
7r.
t..7
if
₹.•ylrc
P14•li
E4mu91
94114
F7.09
r,•im
faul.Ne,
Pt, 1
Erol.Rd5l
141474
Kid"!
Trta1'
Bin Ca,
NEw CO2
Tula] +7tw"'
'&I4
P420
fn.,
COIeym7
4Ytlmy
Maly
,4749 • .39 K99 • 15.34:10
17$ 4430

0.06.44 • 1'174
15974 • • 1 567 4 • 1 56•'4
1•.[088 • I e 1 }3 ^-L• , 18 149 54 i 8 4$74 • 9.3393 • TS:1,4' 11 su 50
62 Eifar4y • 07669 67132
42e73
+]0419 • 652x,7
,1#237 a • O5= + 0L
• • 2.385 A3.7 os,,,.0163, 1 -r , 61'532 7a
40e d3a
••
d
,
•
7 @. MMu ..... 11...............-4.....

Pith.
51 0.2014
116-0422. .24@1 •4.14792 03373 482i.C5 112.7.,d.a 03 12,300 ....A...—.
•47.817X,.47,617.86 .. .
• •
,
•
• •
• •
•
545 •
98 ,
,
79 Tula
4iJ1M2
E17J9ti2
21Ft,742I
1fW4a
40,61193
14116

46.4231
1i,20aa
M
%Viol
Waco
1"4,iztV
74,42za7
2 5 I
9;482
84,101.44
'67
0?
17 I,titivaitg Or2tignal
263
UN
S:G
.$62
flprea
PR118
ta-ausa
P410
PPM d
Taal
Pu61r•t
P11;•8
EXI911.•I
PI'G.7
PI .t
late
Etn-CG2
NEIL,- C62
Taal OW
10-14•
N7+?
C[&5c
r=i+yoay Bra
itrtta0
I
M74
_
n W'9 • $.211:4 • '08.4431 .. 0 00.14 • 1.5870 • 1.0071 11,04 • 15674 9,68419 + 1811,0 `-9. 18 14e.sa , 9.4$74 • 0.2363 .1B2512. I I • •
•:
• _50 50
•
42 „.Enil
il78rm 93,07 + 4.75 T3 06418.E
6'12 • 03780 +

0.6222 • O.S 7
f
En 355 isa • 0905.003

0.1312 IF 157] •6
i6. 0220
2 7
•�Mo411e.-,
90213 • 43.9914 •1160422' 8.404• • 474692

0.373 : 4-03180: 12':2908

0.0137: • 1203
• 47.01780, 49.017 k7
2I91a • I.
17972.49
•
,
•
•
CO
65 •
76 Toe)
440111$
98,7$74
.021414
4043
49,9092

2.49419
413.4A81
12':$93
X4388

14.7349
{+,9900
74,42237
74,40337

2.0039

0.4002

77..637':44
97 9T
11 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2981
04-25
Cont

Page 234 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1152

Responses to Comments
CaIEFMod Version: GaIE FMhad.2O 6 3.2 Page 7006 35 Elute. 1'l2.^21 21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan iP apase4 - Las Midas -Soul" Coast Gourty, Winter RC6
NOK
CII
501
•4a in At
PM l7
E.rarR
MEI
.M10
Taal
Pup Ins
Pk12-h
EIrt•ZuP

IPIM ZS
PM7.h
Taal
Eia•CcE
NEI¢{@
TaoM LOY
GNP
roa
Cats
Partin
aim
co)
' 7:77
tcCU
OM
MCC
WI*
R.97

0.131

7.07 COG
OLE
7s77
O. M
GAO
OMB

3.0 constructor prim
Construction Phast
Fhtrae Kano
NVMger
r r.av„-ypr.

Marl Dale
Er9 Data
Nun I7eys
Gook
Nun Days
Prgaa DK-ClIl.'rti.r,
:nomnllion
;.9.tC 15RFesrdL n
. .I
4 :Bulking r ors nitliCel
5 :Paving
-•I
1Aff lUrrulu I c.a:iora
ale Prearalon
radng
of .adllp cth- 1 clian
•
:PeViny
11----�—.
:Arthtd 1Lt ICa37hYj
'U'p:CZ1 i1W12-2921 •
-I •----d —4-4-4. «........... ............
1101132021 i1L ` 1 1 a 2D•
VI I0r2021 O'1r11r2022 ' 5: 4r5•
• 1I121293≥ 112‘1.2M23 1 51 50b:
112r13 Iraa12D4:4 1 5' 3 i
1aQQ
:1/ 1fd]21 :3f1E1:.n24 5° 35•
Acr29 of grading (Site Preparation Phase): 0
Acres of Grading (Grading Phase)1 t2.5
Acres al' Paving: 0
Residential Indoor: 2,025.000; Residential Outdoor: 675,004. Non Residential Indoor: 326.400: Nori•Resldcntitil Outdoor: IDS S0O: Strip+ d Parking Area: 0 (Architectural Costing — sgfi
OffRoad EaunQment
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2982
O4-2 E
Cont.

Page 235 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1153

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIIVod Version: CSIE FI.iod.2416 3.2 Page $ of 26 Ode: 1112!2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan iPrapasaM - Lns Midas -Soul" Cnaal Gourty, Y['Jlrtar PIVK Nut* 0101}00EgiAVITIMItT a MIMI,E
I VL.41, iK.1,1l� iluree P7rXl ` r LAid Fueul
Demol4aA :Conesolte4r19'aatr it Sirs 1

1.120{ 01.

4.73 g
g........ ^. .........0.......----........
..........- I —i.........
l7enrol6on ;ENCauaton3 • 7
�
640; 1,-3;
4:30
[]amulifon •RuGiwrTlradTiemry _
R,..

B06• 297:

0.40 ..........F............�..Y
San�Prmpgnalbn :Rubber Tina! Naas•• •
I �........

0.00; '247• �
4 an
S`ie P sraaslkrn .Tro.etrsdLuaderslea--dild.ra---------- E._...._��_,e.._ d -ice-... .. ...
800. DP
q,37
G ,00 s[.Xr$a.wirg 6
806; I5a:
a
Gaming nta0elB r I
BUD, 167:

0.41 '..-. .................._.........R
C�adng •Rubber Tired keens � 1
BD6�
CIAO
-F' -- -�__'__-__'__._.
r:aOln9 :Scrapers a
I—
.i _...... .. ..

BOO; 367;
•____
�i9
G•Bd9q •Treelnrsmde cRlcrtI
__D.37
600i 97.
130101ng CareW)JeQBn :Cranes e
I Q10! 271.
0:29
BuleIlnq Carl•uetpn •Forid% u 3
ROD: 13,13:
4:29
i
t3ulklingConYlx'j t,&7'....,. .. •� •{arrersior Sere 1
9D0! DI;
-4.74
_________ ____F
....... ----I I ....

Bulltllna Gdr l.lctiran •TractralbaadersTadN10 t 7
70P• 09
.___

0.37 Building Cura0uctleo Viet 2n3 C 1

0.00: 4B�

0.45 Raying

1.40. 1:161
�

4.42 .................... .I---
504• 132;

4.30 Fisvins RoI E
E J11I 'n

0.39 rGlettLIMI Maing *Air Oomprasscr¢ I GOD. TV. f li :0.46 Trim and V INT
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2983
D4-25
Cont
Pale 236 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1154

Responses to Comments
CalEE=k4ad Version: {'+9:E ( Moll.2416 3.2 Page g 013{ Die: 1112t2021 2.331b PM Village South Specific Plan iPrapase4 - Lns Angd13s-Sleuth Cnaal Gouity,'J'Jlr^tar Prime Pane
J1r pDoddP1gTIBM lMraaihel'
.....20210-111V 1...ALM-A 71I
ICI •nh v N m I
Iha her TIITJ
Lenoli
'.'v 1521 Tr*
1-13.211120 TJlp
L6I1(,1111
4•ional vanilla Wager' I Hvurrg
G�ea VeltiiA90 es Vehicle :u s.

Dee019119G4i 6 15.LIL' -.-3.I w_v.Lti` 'L. JL G.9v ;.7:rco L'.7 MIr 1l4?T_MIR IHHDT atePrepxrYhn 71 MOIL 0 Oa a.aia; 10 00 &Xi 2O:Ofl L©_Mix II.IDT I,ILN HHDT ,..F_________--__+ =—=I_.._..---•� _----I--- _'___ .. 1. -___• Grading • 8. 247.40'. 12.00 0.00• 1D_O0 6.84. 37.00 LD_F11x iFCT_14r% HHDT • ._..___
9u M1ikVlrg COR1x1VA, • 91 - - eO1.Q0r 143-00 O.00t ID 00. 684. 2000 LO klix i FIDTMa •HHDT F -II- ----1- I ----4- 1- ------ ------
Paving 6. T_.OO• 0..03 4.0@• 1D.O4. 5.97. 20.4OiL©j.tt {HDT41IN IHHEIT F-. -••••1 I - 4 I I I •a--•.
rar[hteeLu el C©9Gh9 : i• 190.00• 0Da: 004• 10416• aall• - 24.00 iLT1_kk .HIT 1<!Iz • HHDT 3,1 Mitigation Measures Construction

3.2 1]ertanlitirn -2021
uflmiLttitabutl2lsnrueliion +Clrai41!
ROG.
rra'i
CO
ace
R.41rt
RAN)
Ei22151
1'4+11C'
Fr21 L.

T+:aa1
coIH1Ae

0.4.5 Ed,-..:
.%12:9
'W75
T.

L54 4_r7
hau-GAq
Tidal E2
Cd°!3
--
-. .

Calupury
11102.1
Low,' -

F -irk Chi
sNtit a1
. 2F'`. 0rncP 9, 74 4 C!@ o-5 gS4x4 •
JWc .- - ,
a414
97'4.317
1 -
3 1651 si an r1 U.lV • 31,5850 . ' . 1.5611 • 1'.;`{+19 • 1.4411 14411 • • • • • • • •
•— •- • -
• 7 24? 444 3 747 flax • 1 0444 • :
p i 0
• • •
lad
.1..1{41
3tNOT

51.9160
to
.1.3974
15413
4:9617
I1 WS
t4111
54411

9.74LY44
9 3.T47.IH1
9 6414441

3.77#.997
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2984
04-25
Cont

Page 237 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1155

Responses to Comments
CalEEM4d Version: C9:E FMoti.2016 3.2 Page 10 0(35 Clyde. 11122)2021 2.33O PM Village South Specific Plan 1;PrapasaM - Las Anielos-Sleuth Cnaal Caul tyl, Yrlllrtar 3,2 Deinclilkal -2021
Unmitigated Canaltruefian Side
ROG
N0.

CD
2Cr2
P.011,
99111
0X014+11
PI.110
PIWI9
TIM
W6114
RV..

E.161as1
01173
4911,E
r.,,1
&a C.02
N913- C.=
t1111022
C44
N2 1
3t
CehYoy
We. t
' Mei
1-1111401 01304
a 1 s_3 . 1.1210.2 • 11.0111 . 0.240`1 • ❑1)111 1. 0.7097 ❑.423.' 10,3127 204042
• --.251&44 1 055 i 1. . 1 Z:2 '25
5 Yrvk4 .,

0.XCLE
F;.31iO , 0UV] 4 7: DWG . 09902 • ❑YAOa • .0.3:237
6IXJ] . 0:41101.
•,, __
s
~�
r..11in accts • o4ma
❑ 3x4
•-
-
v, .k.,
�' 4433
-_��_.
.�eI101
WY.* + 03003 f 1. 11[41. . 0 1141 • 830004 . ,7li+pl

90.''13 • d.&'ia0a�1' 0_, !
..:
173.4?� 110.4'n77 • 33-x.
.,.,.
l 103640•
1 .
003 .
•
ce .
.
aJ1
i
r
.
. on .
,
,4w

0.1136

4.1169!
1,4144
anal
1,3614
(war
33934#
aim
64141
14 1100
1,3016123
taw aiz6
1107941

1.042.11114
2 2
1 Mitigated Conolruction On -Site
eot
FMK
C70
1 W@he
.141.3
114.41
P1)11❑
NAIL}
1313.1
FoAb+r
MU:.
tthtlel1
PR12.2
tl 3
Taal
♦3o- 113';
Hew -t02
Mal OW
044
1920
4732&
=WINN
11 .1
Mims
.- - - r:
- - - - -N
1-
F11 *.r. Oust r.

J: _

3.3074 • 0!4)00 • 3.3074 • 1(6196 • DOM 3.54E
•
••
• 0.0[00 u7'30C4
6314R.=
31651 • 31.442? . 21685111 • 9. ?BEE 15517 • 1.5515 • 14411 , 1.4411 . 00010. .7740944 2 T4711F4 • 10440 • :3774.311
• •
9 9 9
T00
&11931
324$3.1

21.9060
9:90

3.3094
t9313,

4.B•300
1(11900.

1.4{11

1.9411

9.9990

3.747:144
3,741.1944.

1..4444
3,774.317
4 0
4 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2985
04-25
Cont_

Page 238 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1156

Responses to Comments
CalEEM4d Version: {'+9:E FM031,2016 3.2 Page '11 4135 pole. i112a2Q21 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan I;Prapase4 - Dos Angalas-South Cnaal Gourty, lrlllrltar

3.2 Demclition -21121
111itioattg.1 CdnslrucLlorl
illOG
N0.

CO
aG!3
PuWllnt
OM 11
Exu 1
Win
P11I6
TRIM
WO..

PbC.

Ed.-'
1,2121
1142E
r, 1

13.0 C.02
Nth,- C.,CC
til6l COT
an
N20 G62t
Cale5oy
Wet t
bMei
HRltq
Yrrl1
4Ta�k n
c13C>4
..1x4 + 1.0.1H2 • 6.211+ ; 2.24afl w 2I)13C 1. 2.277
aor37. 243127

20.,544
1 --.75R3c4 12135 255. 110x472 • :1Z2"25
5 ❑+SZC
•1636SG�
f
u 4Cf+'y
�'
r;.aT,X1 , ,){3LO • DMZ . UP= • ❑Ya066 • .ilea)
•-
- 6 J] . GSGOC.
,•., TIC--
YL
~�
c59Y. OMNI • BOOM .
-
4 433
64ss3 + 43163 f
.�eI

1. 19C11[412 •
I I
9 1141 •
-_��_.
8_^UOao- .

A;li+}I

40.'.23 •
d.&'iO4a1'
1, ,
A:
. I e].g74'r
1y0.4 'h7F
• 33-�
1:kat

9.110.1
41IW!
1,4144
anal
0,31114
(IMO

11.5$42
alrlhy
62121
111121
1,3@13423
2 1]®4,320
2 2,0241

1.74:2.520
I

3.3 S1te Preparation -2f121
U.rinitidaletl C.ur:ti:rLk:1riJll ati.S.to
&,-,I1
r, .:

Ct.
0 Wip9ir a
is1M 111
an,,•..n
FM1❑
NJ I a
1a1i1
W 9t r
MUT
& Mad
P312.3

25.12 5
Taal
k10- 2 2
Hew- =I
Mal CO's'
0'04
N2O
Ct72e
C3lc91r4
lem.r
—n VA'
mm9 ,
�;rvsc Llusr .
. ... R..=

: i i 15`p4i3 0J:•}1100J:•}110 16.Wa __ 419367 u 6q6� 0.934' • 0.4005 ••
••
- -
: . . anima
111823 . 46.4911 . 95'.1343 • II lt31l3 • 2 D4411 . 2.1446 • 111211 • 1 ZEC6 • - • • •
• 3.884 4811 31165 939 • 1 1534 • 3713 942
9 , ! 3
Tolal
2,121
W49r1
2316!3

9.66!6•
1151075!
25416
26:1117
49661

1.5669

6.6116

3.562256
8 3,251.55E
5 1.122)
3,713427
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2986
04-25
Cont.

Page 239 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1157

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIM9d Version: CeIE FI 031.2416 3.2 P -age 12 of 35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan l;Prapaseldi - Lns Angeles-Soul"'Coaal Gauriy,'IrJlrtar 3,3 Site Preparation -2021
Unmitigated ConaUlacIs)11 OffSik
aOO
NO•
CO
33!2
Fuylint
1'N11 '

3.40.Yvs1

11..11
PRl!9
1441441
NOM.

PIWL',
Fa.3.s.
1]!]
1id33
rxYi
Par "072
NiSo-CCC
t•Lilms
CH4
N2.3 2w
094.$441

10.6. t
b09.91
HMW
Yrrl1
4Ta.k:.
•
0 G00
6!1300 • 0.CCM • 9:OCA7. • 9.[IgO:I . 6W9U •. 9,9110
03035 6:U7te :13=FL

0.717.
,
.met
O170.7p •

7.00135
0 9QA
TM 9496
u Orrin.

C 3Xb . !7 au 3900
-
61 3 9-T+YY�. . : :.e3:C
G.93Y7
J 66'.79
Fi+AXE . .
0,X49
110915 . 04799 • 1.33[9.- • -- : IaOfla:3. ..Eal
. • QM • 006 .

OC fs • 197[94.- . 993.:4
: 077 .
• 13.3.10 132.9946 • 3L}f7fa •
• • 005 •
174.1
4G19

9.9416

0.8299
JUIN).
meu

9.16W

1.1499a
Ma
.9.17b1
;WE$
1AlUDs
15a5
'11!7114
1ffi5l4e
11L6R4tl
UMW.

OM
1329919
Mitigated Construction On -Site
Obt
nJ3z
CN3
0 Fuo a
'9M'+6
Fx+,•..n
ROM
NJ 19
1alal
rilAVG
MU
tJmsl
R72]
t.1':3
Taal
k10- [932
HIND- ti.2
Mal C:7's'
044
MO
17379
hsmy
� r:
uAsi9
- _
Fu9kn t Oust
all.Rt467
- - - - - - -- __ -
• 19.91M3 • • 9L990 • 19.Wa • • C.9p97 [gam 6` ,'
•• ••
_ - - _9

9.6096 3
•
1E882 • 49.4971 • 91'.1163 • 9,11339 • 2D44S • ].11445 • IUDS 1 &SCA . • - .- • • •
00000 •3.199.5468 3 959• 1194:. • 371S 49Y
0 i 9 3
Total
320.52
4h49T-I
2t16.13

9.9339
16ll99!
29416
29:119F
tumor
tons

6.9:116
1561310
3,509.196
9 3,696:939
!

1.1112D
3,717':497
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2987
04-25
Cant

Page 240 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1158

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: CerE t=140d.2016 3.2 Page 13 9r 35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.34 PM Village South Specific Plan I;Prapas®Idl - Las Angelas-Skull, Cnaal Gouity, •IrJlntor 3,3 SriC PreparAtlan -2021
Mitigated ConsUvctiorr Off- it.

DOG
NO.

CO
aG!2
Kuylnt
prp 11 '
`'.1.1
PI10
PPJ!a
T•Mal
Wethe
PIWL'9,
F_d61asi
X427
1idLI3
rmei
&a Cat
NP$o-CQQ
Tilffl ✓3Os
CH4
N2O t
2w
Cah-poy

10.619 t
b,1131
H4413h1
ified.4
STa.ku
•
4 C9rin
9!:13(,1 9.WpR1 • 9:090, • 6.90X] • 0 W00 •. 0,0170

0.0173] 69.:0,1, J SFL

0.5170
47mac
917X,1' ( •

4.I)
0 CMS
TM 6646
u o rrtn.

C 3Xk . 3 au • 5 7[90 . „ '.'. .. '� ra:1f., : 3"30.7
9 9 37 6-T+YY�. . : :.e3:C -

0.6300
actor
ri o970 . .
owsa aod16
• 04769 • 1.33[9.- • -- . , WWI • a.aal
• • • 003 •
9Crrf_"• • I°DODD- • ao3.%•I
n 077 :
• I3.3i10 132.96{i1 • 3Lei_Co. • ,
• • 005 •
Nol
1 491101

13.13414,

0.8716
5,3diO.
6163
[.17W '

1.143310,
0666
.6.13!,1
;WS
t- l '
OM
ILi714
1alkAt
132!664®

11.1910,.

OM
1321646
3,4 Grading -2021
lJr'3Tlitidarerl C. r'ti:r ktRJll Oft-S.te
AcAs
rt3.,
Ck
0 Fu@h a
iPM AI
E.ta•..n
PNI1D
NJ I a
1all
r0 grave
RSZ
t ,..- A.

PR12.3
tfon
Taal
k10- Gtl'2
Neo- ti.2
Tdal C:7's'
0-64
WC
0133e
C31x1R5 1
>•
IG.GJ..0
r v
13,1325
� mow•
4,7. Ousr
r.
• • MRr.=
&#F]3 '• 0J:O10 • 3'.3733. • 36665 a10o� 3.3M03 •
• • •

0.131;00 • • 4"$'9
.41312
• 49,3 • 31.&]6,6 • 9.. DEGO • 1916fi3 • 1.5ffi5 • I `e:Iii, 16 a •
• 9577043
4 •
SW' 143 • 1 Y'Ftd • • 911+5 B13
{ 9
Total

4.1912
411.31riff•

83.1761

41.06193
'7,41.T''!

1.9333
M.&391
&5996
F-42363
3423E
e.oracws
4 60,}1.637
■

1.1+48
91>MAfi
1 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2988

04.25 Conk.

Page 241 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1159

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: COLE E1.13d.2U16 3.2 Page 14 40f 3S Clyde. 1112)2021 2 3O PM Village South Specific Plan I;Prapaselli - Las Midas -Soul" Coast Goul tyl,'ir4llrtar

3.4 Orading -2021
Ursmdtiyallyd Constiacli{Yli Off -Siff
kOCx
NO.

CO
aG•2
Pop,
OP., 11
r C.11v.1
morn
PRi!1

14.4.0 Wei Ne
PIWL.

Ed DD.'
X43]
4742E
rmei
Dsa OD2

MD', UGC
tdil Oa'e
'
ri2d
4:(328
Caft.ri

11.615.

DOD,
HMW
•••YrrlA
v, .i..:4
r. 0 C6®

11.33_0 .. O. CUIW • II DA:1 aJO7 • OIg1O : DD370
•
OCXO
DCCOu
, ]1C •
E., Ma)
pGCOD
O17(7plU •
a DOW
.netts
1474091•
a.tra
_
sato . .-.roan 3.11LC DDD_i3 • GA6n •-D.D"ia7
OrADO
eaxe,
R0GG6
• sato
ascot
ri,'o]C, . .
010706•-

0.C...672 . 0GU4 • I.45COo • D. I521 • 1.2461 - • 1.43]4 • . z i . . CO :
�
G0424 . 1 17011.- . 0.0{'IA•
• Dal 1
• 147.3141
.
147.243
4430X- • .

On . i
1 -No

9. 9Y91
[WW2
0,3224
141W,.
000
1,7RYi
1,17111n
DOHS

4.4514
9,044

1.109l
OM
594110
IOi.843
10,am

4.1l19.

MI
1041.4DDL
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Sitt
Obt
FMK
Ct.

C
Fu@he
PW119
Fx+,•..n
F 1]O
Phil 0
Tali,
WDL,?r
Prla.5
&,..-.�.

PRI2:]
t.1':3
Tad
k10- [a32
New-tti
Idol C:7's'
054
NiO
I73Oe
=ham
n.u.,.0

13.13%
FuDY.rnt Dust
OMR.=
&#F]3 • DL0D6 9.6F31} • 36D6S Dql� . a •'�F8 --
• •
••

0.6gD6 4"8.'1
a 1312
• 48,3 • 318.716. D. DEG • 19363 • 1.. 5 • Ie` ;. I8853 • •
D07L. .9077 11.3
4 •
BJ707143 • 14.418 • .DII+.5 Di
{ {
TAM

4.1992
461996
ES

9.0616

21.11M
1_31113
R@13697
&1995
LUDO. D.42AD
15041
6;®07.048
4 13.,9}7.14]
4 1.4148
9l>M 543

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2989
O4-25
Cont_

Page 242 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1160

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIMad Version: CaIE FMad.2U16 3.2 P' -age 15,0(35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan I;PrapasnM - Las An -galas -Soul" Coast Goul tyl, trifIntar 3,4 Grading -2°21
Mitigated ConsUvctiorr OffSiie
illOG
NO.
00 5Cr2
KuyI10
OM 11 '
h•na.1
Palla
Pal !a

14.4..1
Watt..

PMC'I•
F_d61asi
051V5
45115
rmei
Par"u72
NI70-CCC
tUil t,,Za
CM
Pita*. `4.(720
Ceh-95y

10.615.
bale1
HMW
r. OG000
ucoo + O. MIX • J. Ma_ 53000 • OW00 •. !Lain
•
q00Sr
OCOGi,
',0,1L
O+000(1
0CLOG
a.XIPO1 •
0 ODE41
V•e•k•
o0'vrn
aawo . arm O. art 99ao3 • G0a00 • aorta)
•
arta)
taxa,
aaorr
• sumo
ocean r,,:mo
. 1
aorta
.. -- .
.a..i.:1
'11,...5
f • 4.............4...
•
•ao.ex
1174071
007,3aa
. G6.U.1 • 14300- • 0. I521 • twat.- • atm,.

GMO . 1 17095-. �
, ao4'19
. ar
..... •...�
• 147.3141
140.2613
�..•-..ar-sr.�.
•430[5. • 1
Nol

0.0109
af1552
05294
t4sray.

MIRY'.

1.2155.1.

4.4514
O.a&M

1.1fUae•

11.94111
1147.840
141.39$7

4.Naae.
771.4551
Oa],
005
0u7
004
3,4 Grading -20
Urinal C•ur lraLk:1a..11 011.S.to
&,-,la
,1 .:
a0
0 ?0
Fu@h a
RA MI
O4.oI
P1111❑
Phi I a
101.5.1
Nave
PA,¢5
f•a i
PRIO.)
rfd'33
Taal
GO';
New- ti0
Mal 0.1r1
.154
WO
cute
C31t9R5
.
a. 1 r:
13,1515
Al
�;rvsc Mat
....

Ott Raa61
•
• &#F]3 '. 00010 • 9.6F31} • 36065 aq� . 159Efi
•
•• ••
Q0000 40.1^6
30240 • 30..5079. 2004 x9'3' 15 • a. 1 1 &219 • A. 5349 • 15041 15041 • • •
•5.51141❑
E
•
Binn410. 10542 • .9050015
5 a
•
Total

5.8549
MUM,•

29.4517
0:0081
Lana
1-6744
Pa. 39Ed

3.65,50
15,1.1
01@4

9.0.1.410
7 a) 1111.•110
-5

1..9440
5)05(017
a
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2990
0425
Cont.

Page 243 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1161

Responses to Comments
CalEEMod Version: C9:E E1.kdd.2U16 3.2 Page 1f3 of,a5 Oda. 1112212021 2.3O PM Village South Specific Plan l;Prapas®di - Loa An -galas -Soul" Coaal Goul tyl, trifInitar

3.4 Orading -2022
Urxreltiyallyd Conssiuclitni Off -Siff
106
NO•
CO
aO2
top,
OPO 11
'-uRi
P1 iio
PPJ!3
Tmal
WO..

PIWL.

F_d.- sl
01127
11425
rxla
Psa "u72
NPSo-CCC
tdil OfS'e
'
rt20
4:(328
Cetryoy
,M2, P
title,
IiJ4
YrrlA •
v, .k.,
0 M
II .33_0 + 0.417111 • J. 0]M 13007 • 0W3P
3,0090
0001.1
3eiJm -tDa
QM.
00003
017p1.Q • i
•
OMr11
,. ..

Cams
l#7J30T•
amt0
C 30:{1 . .2 CTS . 5 6 . 5LC . .. rrc
;gin
area
^•
eccM. c.IYT
~per
••••••, ...
comp
acci6
r,n c,
00540
x
00016 • 04611 • 1.43CG - • �.1 1571 • I.230Fo-
r ow • . U)O
-3 M-34,
0C4] • 1130M- . .50411
• OM a
• +42 120 1421207
e
4COY_Ga. • •
1701 •
yet;tl
40641
40114
emu
'LOA..
64S
U1421

1.TOtlut.

Ord
5,104
aerial

1.11tl%m
001
'Rime

11,.121)
14t121iI
4Aralo”
ees
152,125 1'
Mitigated Conxtructiern On•Sitt
ROG
rklac
Ct.

C
fughe
iPlyl 111
Fx+,...n
ROM
Philp
1a11
W3tr
Pr1Q.}
ta..-. .

PRI2.O
*In
Taal
k10- Gtl';
Ndi0-tiC
Idol C:7l
044
"7?_
C-Cr,
Catc5ory
IV= 0
way
.- 1 - -.- - - r.
�-v1l:ret Oust r.
_ - -.. -
&#F]3 • 0J:•030 • 9.6131} • 36Ii6S • 4q0� + .1�_EF4
• ••
••
— _ _. _...�
QQCG6 4"x°0
O14Rta61
20240 • 26.0479 • 2i 13415 : 0.39'3'1 1&219 • C. 0340 • I5O21 15041 , 0OM •0.01141❑ a011010• 10542 • 10[60015
• • • •
6 5 a
•
Total

5.0241
0684#

24.4417
0:3621

3.1111'3
1-6144
PLUME'
:54641

1.5414 -I

3. XGW
110140
3,311.410
4,011.411

1..(1442
5)01.0.019
9 -5
a
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2991

04.25 Cont.

Page244 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1162

Responses to Comments
CalEEl on Version: GEIIE SI.i3d.2O16 3.2 Page 17O135 Clyde. 1112)2421 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan I;Prapaseldi - boa Angeles -South Cal Gourty,'J'Jlrtar

3.4 Grading - 2022
14iticuaicd' <`e 771M1 UGl14N°, orr-sita
ROG
N3e
CO
aG!2
Puy-.,
atoll
'-u.11
PI iii
PPJ!e
Tmal
Weeva
PIWL.

Fdulrb
611127
43425
rmei
aa-CC.2
NNo-CCC
td1J ZI'.

Cm
rt
t:02c

4.alepay
12-612 t
Wile,
HRltp
YrrlA
- ..r
v, 4.4�
.1
flI Ma,
II.9A9 I t7. MX . J. MCC • a3G®J .. aW1G
e,ewa
coal,

°-° ' ,Dal
•
GM,
0MOe
e7Jprlr
•
a00E41
„_--..
7 .
1#7220?
. aCCC
_ _ __
R 34:{1 . �J au . a. ate . .. rrc
l
_
;gin
area
�.
eco�. c.IYT
4 .. ....-Y -_
c.ed�c
C.- t__
accio
R
enJc
*
40665
004'6 : 446111 .1.#3[02-: u.101 • I..'3Uea-
. . 1394 . . DM
a.%334
OG420 • 113004-. aW16�
a e32 a
. .-_--.-.-
• +42 120 142.!SU
e
...--,•A---
4C.XCc.. •
0:d .
y 740J
it ma
Di.il
e.1eal1
t ! Oa•
earl
5,1624

1.2madt.

Ma
DAM
aNM

1.11tle4•
um
'Rorie

110.32111
14t1211I
4A40x.
res
II2.2ali

3.5 Budding Construction - 2112'2
t1r'ltiitidalrli Construction Or-S.tte
i+nta
Nix
Ct.
a
Pu@he
PNI iJ
edism.n
ROM
NJIO
1x1.1
Wear
Pr1Q.5
taviddi.

PRI2:]
NA:3
Taal
k10- Gtl';
New-ri.2
'dill CO's'
044
Nc41
13325
C.:LCLary
Ink= F
nimy
CMt. P.w7
IA4G2

S.G Er:. ; IC J53a
n Je,'.tt
]c{fiC
.J.WJ4 1
U.el_
an,:
.

7..55 4313
e
:,564.333.
6 efi131
.
.
2;';F.'7 L'3J
•,2.2-1
1hid,
I6 fiE'_c.

Ifi. 2696
uu'.d�''
LLEl+9u

6.uli4P

' u7511
u7re17
2,4.53533
B
3Sii.Y33.

G
ae1Fb
23611632+
2 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2992
04-25
Cont.

Page 245 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1163

Responses to Comments
CalEEllr4cd Version: {:#IsE FI.iad.2416 3.2 Page 18 of 35 Clyde. 1112)2O21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan l;PrapasaM - Las Angeles -South Coast Goui ty,'J'Jlrtar

3.6 Building Canviruction -2022
Untl itigaled Cons II lil ii Off -Site
il0G
NO.

CO
aCr2
Pop,
Hp11 '
Exia 1
PI iii
PN!a
Tmal
WeINte
PPV.f,
F_d61a51
X127
1id3t
rmei
aYF *2
Nth,-d.CQ
tUtl tr.1
1}I4
N2.'3.

LX32t
Cnll$uy

1.415 t
tgary
11MF+q
YrW.I
4'.17 a
�A 474.31
"••I usai
006® : 0.003.31] a 0 413P . 9:Oil. . u7GD"J . 0W6G .. 6,0[130 . 0.510'19 • [MOD 1 'iGAi+- • • G.S174
476COQ
Q.lpClq .

OO-ra'.
3 9!►]9®Qtl

6 }+'- .197.3 , 3P1L5 . 3.0351 . GGISS • MSG +1'a 4a . x 02893 . 4,x4.5 1 42261•. x w . r . N
I 4
•'. 3.799 On
B
372&415
9 n mar ?3795423
3 --T . `dB7 •
. 'T
I 9 41544 •
r
case'
40rirN •
.
.d..
04!43 .
.
d./{T3 •
.

1.6143 •
.

DI1131
.
µ
T dE1'a
"". _ '� ""`�"�"'�
.9.�1}Y7
e •
'49f.439
A
D 'IdAQ .
.
,
,
?Nal
IaaaMo
.i].2Ya1
Calm
P,aurl
tu2'fa9
7,ora
l,iits
R9oge
!1461
B,a61_u10
4 eAds,B1a
•
o.estl
BA1PB.DOB
F
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Site
inG
Nr0%
Ct.

C
fAili a
Mg 1a
an..ai
PMi❑
NJ I a
tall
W 421+r
PNa.5
&hold
PW125
!,123
Taal
f3u [132
Hew- ti.2
Tdal C:7's'
044
NZ41
0i72e
Calr:a6y
I
ttJl1a F
-
L'd32y
OY. P.w7
1 ,9)52
_,GI_r:. , 1£ 2634
,
. 3 Da
JLocc
.JAfli4
a -e1_
_ 7-
30{CC .7 ,r 331
�,5-s.7.333
• 11.512p
•
::::e'..032
x
,..,,,A w
1 Me,
Ih..fiE'_c.

Ifi. 3636
U Qed4'
LLEl.BQ
!Lut a.
' R751?
LL7617
Olfl U

2.551.}33
E
2S54.B33.

G
4eiffi
23611.832
2 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2993
04-25
Cont.

Page 246 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1164

Responses to Comments
CalEElhr4ad Version: COIF FM32122016 3.2 Page 19 of 35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.3O PM Village South Specific Plan I;Prapaseldi - Los Angeles -South Caasr, Gounty,'JJIrRa'

3.5 Bolding Construction - 2022
Mitigated Construction Off -Silt
IWO
NO.

C9
5•Cr2
KuyUnt
DM 11 '
`'a'ns1
P1410
Mil

14.1•4
W4nve
PP -C..5
Ed61asi
X17!7
1Yd3E
rxYl
aYr "u72
Nth,- ucc
nu, DOD
43x6
N20.

LX32t
Cnigoy
114,15 t
bitle'i
11MF+q
YrW.I
.e'.:1.Aa
-.1 4.01101
O176m i 1.1005} x 3.49PD . 9:11473, . U3035 . 9 [4113 .. 9,1103 . 0.5.4'19 [MOD y 'iGAi+- o.a3ou
°CON
11t347G •
347ir.
3 9C9]9®Qtl

6 }+'- ,t9T.3 3P1L5 9.1135.1 49155^s OQPSfi • 94'.1'•' 02898 . 4,x.{5-.- 92.81•. . x
4 ".3.799573
8 3729475
9 rt=I ?3795428
2474.gi
. `.d57'T
19 4544 •
Baser •
5d1G3: •
•
.
❑at43 .
.

O.l{Yi •
.

1.5143
.
4^_Jxa
x
µ
T ddt'a
"". '� ""`�"�"'�
.9. 1439
. 4
'4Gf.439
4 D 'IdAQ .
.
,
,
'NW

14.BODO

25.Z71141 11311I53
},9 O
1131759
7,ora
4,47'91
1069e
tuft
B,46LP113
4 9Aai,614
•

4.esf1
94119,35@
F

3.5 Building Construction - 2B23
Llr'111itii:llatett Construction On-- to
I6Ca
tax
at,
F»
Wiptire
PFJ119
to,,...n
F 1]D
PNlIt
1x1.1
W4mr
MUD
tJmsl
PW12.5
x,1:3
Taal
k10- Gtl';
nen- tea
Td.al C47's'
O44
rtIO
auk
C31:c4Ry
Mr= F

12.tim!r
• - -
i. '.
or P.w7 x, Ia".9 . 11 .39411 • 16..21&3 • 1Etc . , 7u::111 _ : , 3: cxR , 1-3'2.I .2.555.17• :529:: E, 3501 . "2,671.186

4 4
r
'',2.11
157;0
1c21154

18.3,111
Q 3a'd4'
LLl.1ti Wt
e.4'J4r
itEXk1
u 4thvx.
2,555..209
9555.299
II497i
3570440
_
B
9 11
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2994
04-25
Cont

Page 247 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1165

Responses to Comments
CalEE11r4cd Version: {'+9:E S1.imd.2016 3.2 Page 200135 Ode. 111212O21 2.3O PM Village South Specific Plan I,Prapaseldi - Las Angeles -South Coati Coulty, li'l1rtar

3.5 Building Construction -20.23
Iru51e aa1Md Ctsn9Lrlacti .. Off•Siru
#OG,
No.
co
aQ!1
P.ta t
atoll
Ex..1
groin
01110
Tma1
Wome
Pr '1
Ed, -.A
tt171
1Yd2.E
r., i
Bra "772
Nth,- sOCC
Ttlal ila2
-
6K

..

C.ale9uy
We. t
13/77:

H1RItp
••••••••,•••
YIIeWI
'e'.13rAa
-•M 2.8217
00C• -xi
7::93:0 . 0.07pS:1 • 0:00170 • 73000 m 0.000 • 7,0000
.
00779 • 7.:O0L, I. 3,?bG
C.. 7714 47 CLAW • BOCC•0 •
000EG-
3,376641
r
7,4L7402.
0313
- -�• 70177' • :1.777
& :0 3.371 0.03:'_- . Q G1
07£34 07016 . 3771x7•
••••• •3.671400 7671770• BMX •
r 7

2..5031
•7073 • 17522.0 • 007de . .1072 • 00470 • 6.1411
•

1.4:.53 66:441 I+Y1-.1
•0.473797 d-0&3797. 7144` •
_kal
11490
i3.24Ila

0.94194
PAd6tl
401191

1.Mot
1,1149
6F35f
01161
9,'1131.171
1 a,irl4,ou
1 0.3+436
9,114447
7 Mitigated Clonxlruction On•Site
106
r4tIK

2.o
c1e?
Wipme
RAI 19
biaal

14.11❑
NJ I o-
1x1.1
W 1rt r
R01Z
1 4.

PR12.7
thin
Taal
F3o- 0417
Mao- tG2
tilill 63'r'
1744
WM
,sae
Cu1.9RN
IN= 0
11,604
OY. P.w7 la",73 • 11.3911) ; 14 2117 • 00,'.1:1: 7tn:.U• _. 0: xR 'J.-716 I •
- ;_q, 'T .=a7x 7g0 . •2,674406
r10{O[ _ .s..C •�
., , Q , 1
'',ual
. 15710
144.3654 '

14. 274,0
70174'
LL1.ra7
e

7.07fi
—
' ...EN:4
I6. 41 '
0176411

2.556147
B
9S£4.209
9 II ter%
65711409
1 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2995
04-26
Cont

Page 248 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1166

Responses to Comments
CalEFIVori Version: CeIE FI.i31i.2416 3.2 Page 21 of 35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.3) PM Village South Specific Plan I,Propaseldi - boa Angela's -Soul" Coaal Goulty, 4I'l1rtar

3.5 Bonding Construction - 2023
Mitigated Construction Off -Silt
— N0G
NO.

CO
2'02
P.ta.+e
114411
txvv11
PrO16
Pt:IP
TRIM
W4nve
P1 4401
F_do.si
12400
r.,,1
Psu-"472
Nth, 000
'Mal te.tP

0.44 N5.'1.

C.alepry
Wet 0
b!tla7
11la4tp
••••••••,••
YrW4
•,, •Aa
-. 216217
0 CG3i
0,93:0 . 0. • 7: axe • 4 -3007 m 00 400 • 7,0000
4 0030 • 4.:O0o I. 3 44E4

0.0.300 47 CC44 • 4 0070 •
0 00E4
3674/141
r
052•74411
0 3133
s
3 & :0• 371 3.431'_- • 7 G: - 7 5777 70177' • 711
r _ c _
07£35 07 3
116 • 7757•
••••• 07 •3. 140 413460 3671.35. 4 •
r 7
t+•�
25420
�vi•_
14073 • 17 24213 • 04750 • .1 EON • 00470 • 4.1411
•
4•

1.6:43 • 441;40 • '17+M•I
ma' �. ,
•5.423747 5423747• 41112 • X7,+187442
-x>s
10492

23.2111
2moil
1,00111
WW1 7.64
1,1129
IhFiSl'
1nei
216i.1se
1 11.154.41
1 5. 19
91K441
7 3.6 Paving -2Q23
lJ01TIitidahr[l Construction On -Sits
7012
r1.r:
470
fughvc
114 XI
114..4
Pr•11❑
NJ I4
laal
rd Owe ffthaell.

Pf••¢5
Pti12.2
*•4:3
Taal
24, [0 /2
H -0012
Mill O2
(144
N2,0
032e
Y_.Isgay IV= 0
2004
Cr Rudd 1 II1Z, • 14.1447 • 14 68+,1 , 4. Q2,g • . 0545: • 0,51132 • 1140.1 1{OW

2.1'7501 771}7.511{• 117144 •
2; 243,3
°
• • • •
I , r
• • ••
4 • • • Pa.f n 11 ❑ 0006 • 4.442. . 444.41 • 1'7370 •
• 054090
P [1324
~ • • • • • •. •
•
• • •
Taal

1.4337
1411117

11.59.42 4:�
65092
IL5147
44424

4.44441
2,806114
7}117.514

5.71411
273'x433
1 1
5 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2996
0425
Cont.

Page 249 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1167

Responses to Comments
CalEEMori Version: C9:E F1•imd.2016 3.2 Page 220'35 OOP.le. i1122Q21 2:30 PM Villa•3e South Specific Plan I;Prapase4 - Las Angers -South Caaal Coul tyl, Yrlllrtar

3.6 Paving -2023
Unmitigated Canstruetil i OffSitp
IlO4
NO.

CO
0O2
KuWant
a7i 19
E.-0,...1
24110
PN 14
TRIM
NW.,
PT.C10
Ed.-'
ot17II
14d1IE
r.,=a1
aYF CO2
Nth,- .7.'cC
tilal COs
C44
N2O
t;62w
CaIIWnY
WI, t
11Ale7
'.

HMIN
YrvlA
- ,.
4T:�kn
- •
•'
r. 0C9®
u !3010 •• 0 C17k1 • J. '°- 4:3033 • 0 COW •. 3,0679
0 [O3] I-x0L: J 3, CL
c )310
011'09
O 0030] •
O09CO

3cCLn
. .
1007003
. O'XCC
N
F
03X13 : omen . 3.6X1[ 00(.07 • OLrtGP • 10:i4'-
r 4 •
;, :sir
- Orfly. 4-� -
��-
n.n:e n
°.,. l----
ocean
hoax..

4..,
0[•137
«-4.--. -.
0412 • 3333➢ . 1.03L13x • g ills • 5.00003 • O.J14'
• . O7& • . 004 •
- e
303E • 4.1600- . 003!1
: CM •
.. -- -A-�
• I CO 5M1 1021605-• 270[[4- • .
r . On .
1Nol
40400
at=
11 U
tow.
443

9.Si4i
004904-
0031
IL111!
%win
*, 0I0I&
Mat
call,
100J F1
19"L042b

7.71443=
MS
17}..7143
Mitigated Con'ITuction On•Sitt
W6[i
FMK
126
4 Fu@he
My! 00
F4+,•.4'
2411❑
ON 14
101,1
Fu62VG
P(•,a.}
&MA
PI02.0
NA:3
Taal
k10- 000
Hew- to2
Mill OW
0144
ram
020
C: WIWI)
IlsH.i..I,
[limy
OIFFItatl
Pa4'Yy1 •`
Z, 1.0337
1Cpp • 101017 • 1{.604] • 0.02 • • 00102 • 0.5132 • 6{�•.{ 14001 °
•• • • •
al=•0.400001 0 7.0') • 0.7114 •
I i 1
• • ••
2=043,3
e
dl owe. 00000 . 6.6XD . 0ur.ri • p4LT.0
• • • • • • •. • •
a.M160
• • •
P601g'
Vela)
1101017

11.96114
0:0001
6510E
IL11e12
04434

0.4e04
,0009
2,200514
1 7207.504
1 0.7140
!73'x433
0 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2997
0425
Cont

Page 250 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1168

Responses to Comments
CalEE11r4a}d Version: {'+9:E t=Mdrad.2416 3.2 Page 23 0(35 Clyde. 1112)2O21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan l;Prapnseldi - Lao Midas -Soul" dal County, Yrl1r tar

3.6 Paving -2623
c4itittatva CullsErucli[rr dff-5ila
ROG
°l3
CO
a
P.411,
09,11
E...04,11

14.110
PIf19
TRIM
r-90bve
PT.C1'G
Ed oa••n
01170
1id2E
r.,,1
90- CO2
N9 o- CCC
tilalm2
au
N2o t;62w
CAte9oy
We. F
lb Or,
'.
ii.404
Yrvk4
-„..

41. .1..., .�
r. 0 C9®
0!.I000 0 M • 31)3CC. 0-3003 • 00900 •. 0,0000
0 CO3 0.:03 I3=FC
00310
011'09
0130.1.0 •
0 0013

., .
1CU7933
. O'XCC
.

F
03XO. 0rran . 0.6X10 • 00ra03 • 0Crt4r • 1E ia7
r 4 •
- 01 C0) 0-� -
0 -
°.,.
':
004
N
. —4.--. -.
0412 • 033a➢ . 1.03L0- • U I I I • 5.0009x • 0.J a
• . 414& • . a 4 •
'I.'— -
our. . d.1000a- . fiO3!I
: CIA •
..4---- ----4-.........4..,
• ICO,D M 1029625-• 2 7000 • .
r . 1`101 •
e 001
C.04b0
ILI.=
410 U
1,110le.
4b3
9,1141
%agape.
0000
IL11iw
0 U0
#:i000m
0014
00111
IIp,9dF4
19Z9928
2a19.39,
M3
17}..7943
1,6 Paving -2024
4Y111tl tidalerl C.UI-IraLC:Ir. it O11.S.to
&0,1
'1 .:

Ct.
4 f Kane
iPM v3
Fx+,•.al
Ph11❑
Phi 10
Taal
r-oA VG
PNQ.}
0Jms1.

PW12.3
Nh1':3
Taal
k10- [332
HIND-ti0
Idol OW
044
F0?")

C -C)',
Cut➢nro
—s
IG,m.q
r

12.9my
off-Re9I u
PAWN)
Ili
Ill
993 • 11Si • .{....,4.5 • 14.bZ59. • B.9.':� • • 0.4695 , .3. ,..515 • • LE 4319 , 48310 • • • • '
••
•7.20x S#7 ;.21:'i".Wr. 9.T14} . + ,.
3 . 3
• • ••
09 4 00
❑0[00 • ®.0006 • 07.111 06m¢
• • • 0
• • • • • • ' . .
.0 .0940 00'."
• 0
• • • '
I 414310
T 4
1 Q.43757
IOM
1+1.1279
0:f
#0
IL

64310
2,297A41
3 2291.047

0.7140
239.390
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2998
X25
DonL

Page 251 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1169

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIM9d Version: {'+9:E SI.iad.2016 3.2 Page 24 0135 Onto. 1112)2021 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan l;Prapas®ldi - Las Angeles -South Coast County, Yrl1r tar

3.0 Paving -2024
unmitigated eonstruetilm Off -Si
OOti
NO•
CO
aO2
KuyOnt
PM 11
'-uR1
Prom
PPl!0
TMai
WpINe
PP.V.f,
Fdur•51
1,41.42II
43425
r, i
Psa-CC. 0
Ntio- CCC
tdlal-0a
1344
NI
0:tde
Caft.ri

10.415 t
t?da1
I11MW
r. 000®
1793=o .. t7. CORI • J.Igl7_ 430X1 w ❑0400 •. ii moo
4[000 0OUO
JAFL
• ODIC

00.'09
O17P7G • 1.

CI 00E4.1
YrrlA
0C+GO

0..,1..0 • 0r3L11 • 7. RUC • 000[03 •s- MOO❑ • a.4-rn-
•
- 0Mil • DWI.

7..-0CC -
C.O•Ua
.7 coo
fi+20]0. . i
a cora
- 6- - -
4 :..,
-
... .
u 00444
_-4-- .4.............1...
411237 • 03114 • -00X43- • it 1141 • d7004a- • arm
00903 • 0 1000-
..CO
--,4_,- ,4 ,- -.
• 09.5040 02 51340
.........4-..........l...
24Tr.. a • .
yTo•ka
'
OS Am
• : 443 • , 441 •
. 4042
443 •
Not
410444 40444

0.904₹
43144
1LO1Ge.
111141

3.!0004.

Villa

6.Oa00
#.1004..
001'I'1

98.0049
ra.904a

0.40 e•
0!.41143
era
401

1104
463
Mitigated Conxlruction On•Sitt
Obt
r41Jx
Ct.
4;122
FuQNnc
PNl'4l
extim n
FM30
Phil D
Tali,
r -.4m r
MU.5
0Jm0
PR42.O
X9'23
Tgal
f1i 032
Hew- ted
Idol OW
0244
N20
Ci'32e
•
IWO! r

00.494..0
-
',hay
OI6Rcatl
P44100 0
90040. • 0.004'S • 14.6259. • 0.02.4 • . ❑.4695 • 4.40.55 • • 44310 1 516010 • • • •
••

0.0.000 • 2.007547 7700.547 • 0.0149 • . 2_02.005
3 i 3 : 3
• '
• ••
013000 • ILIUM • [HEW • 4:i cum .
• • • • • • • •
•
.0.0000 PII11.4
• •
'Mal

6.91030 I. 6.91030

0.0241

14.007E
0:013
9A'#7
414®3
04010
0:43111
OA=

2.300047
t

2..70T.047
2 0.7140
0724.400
3 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
2999
025
Cont

Page 252 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1170

Responses to Comments
CalEEM16d Version: C9:E FI.ka41.2016 3.2 Page 250'55 1rde. 1112a2Q21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan l;Prapase4 - boa Midas -Soul" Cal Gourty,'J'Jlrtar

3.6 Paving -2024
c>lilivaird' Cu lsErucli[rr dff-Sita
RV9-
'l3
CO
aG•2
KayOnt
149011

29.1.1.4.1 Prom
PPJ!(r
TMa9
Wethe
PIWL'.

F_d61a51
9,997!14
1T.ttt
[901
aYF *2
Ntio- UGC
tUil 034
C}I4
N2.'1.

LX32t
CD9r12.T
It9,45 a

1.0.2 I -WWII
... 44
Yrvk4
Wo.k..
•
r. 0 070
0,.X3 O. DODD • J. MCC a3DGJ • 0WOP •. 0,4wo
. . . .

0.0070 00006
.
_iAFL
• G.4296
0[x00
414000 •
0001,11
Ocam
... .

69.0194
0C+G9
r13wo . c. dill T. p6LC 4F1CA9 s2MOD • 0.4[[17-
•
- 6- - -
- 0rffi1 • 4021:0
4 -
;...x1,
:CIO-

4.,
.7 coo
ri6ax. . i
-
u 9644
_--I--'• .1..............1...

11.2.24.7 • 98114 • 7.g9CUks- I. 9 1141 • d8094s- • a:I'M • aaa : • CC* 1
9 Q342 • d. 10.99-
. 449
.,-,2
,.-"-1--- v
• 49.5445 iu..54142
. .........4-..........;..
2471X . • .
4as
e Nol
l 44444
D.D297
arm
tic. e,
903
U-1141
>i.5004eh
rod
h,1144
%MO

#.1909.•
Mat
LI.71 I'1

01.0041
tamer
Una.
032

4._1551

3.7 AT decimal Coaling -2024
Unmitigated Conshue16o-n On -Sit
Pala
NO.

Ct.

O
Fu@h a
RAI 19
bisenal
PM7❑
Phil a
1aal
W Qawe
Pr1Q.}
- ner.d.

PW12.2
th.1':3
Taal
k10- Gtl'2
HIND- ti.2
Idol OW
054
WC
032e
C 4all
IlsH.i..I.
_
way-
- - -
1r.

Anthe. Caffir•1 : Zkn4140 • • C 1:0001- • -a.4 • DOM Gl9rDG • •
-
acme - 4 OM
6@Ra99
• 211:44$1+.
3a [4431 • 46154 • . 281®493
•
Taal
2MMO
12in

1.4141
ZirWp
416

0.4gi

9.4592

0.0409
.44095
45444141
241.4441
401144
291.5440
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3000
04-25
Cont_

Page 253 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1171

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMa d Version: OB1E E=f•kad.2416 3.2 Page 2r6 of 35 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan 1;Prapaseldi - Los Angdes-Sleuth Goad County, •Irallrtar

3.7 ArciIleciurall Cooling • 2024
Unmitigated Construction Off -Sift
ill 00
ND.

CO
3cr2
P..,,J1,
pp., 11 '
Lanaal
PrW10
PP.!9
T•Mal
W51Me
PMC'1•
Ed.- .

X107
1adt1t
r, i
aYF022
Na-CCC
trial Clae
044
0Yl43-
0(328
CerFri
1x615 t
b4la0
I1MW
•••YrrlA
,.-.-..•S_.

.0..kn
r. 000M
00030 • 0. COVE • J. "- a3055 • 0 C40 •. 0 -WOO

00]17
0300u 133A
00030
P0000 i 017OPQ •
01041
0111

1.0920M1
0 0333^.

C3Xb . 0{%00 h.05LC 0 303 6._0iY0G : 010(0}
t _. ws
COOS)
i.
0-C+Yf. . 43110
• weal
E®w•+
(acme • 0007.1 • .C
•
E
04734
112710- . 13,2.0 • 0.010, • 4.101 • 0.4300x- • I:130S
• • • 090, •
•
----4-• •...

0.2220 • 409900- • 10310
n oce 1
w..�. a as aa
• 5,0913M 1L4f.3I • D.02% • .
• 5 E • • i
10401
14741
O.PNO
45O2211
A41t1Q
iliii
AM390uF
99Bs
t0d4

0.X29
Vivre.
936
a3319
1,091-lii
0 1!101.991
4 arm
1104:2;941
0 Mitigated Con4ITuction On•Sitt
W6t,
FMK
CO
C
Fu@he
4144 XI
tnee.a
PN11❑
PP/ ID
1ala1
r-oobo
R,2.2
1Jms1
PR12.2
th•1':3
T1aa1
k10- ['22
Neo-t %2
Idol CO3
044
1100
01320
=WM!
114204

13.1025
lAr e. Caffih7 2Zlb'.a1i0 • • OD'AP • -0.0002 • RAO� 49mG •• ••
a0000 • 4=0
❑I0-RCa,9 91001 .-}.165 • 18401 •..741020 ' • 0.0FAfr • 0.070 • 0Y17li . II(U 490
•
a •
• •
❑1100 • 761.0402'
3a 9.401 • 00154 • . 20141493
•
Taal
2006929
12&i

1.0501
24309".

OMS

0.114114

9.090E
0:0144
GAM
0000/0
₹51.44411
121.4411

0.4111.1,
Z31S42D
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3001
04-25
Cont_
'age 254 of 548 in Comment Letter 04
11942
RTC -1172

Responses to Comments
CalESMori Version: {'+9:E t=l kad.2496 3.2 Page 27 01 35 Clyde. II12)2O21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan I,Prapaseldi - boa Angeles -South Cal Goui ty,'J'Jlrtar

3.7 Arclllieclural Ceiling -2a24
Mitigtrd Construction Off -Silt
ilOG
NO•
CO
30412
KWi lot
PMY+I
Eana•nsY
14416

PM I II,
rMM
Rath.

Pt 'G
F_d61asi
041.77•
4:ld7.
rr,a
aYF CO2

NIP CCC
Tail me
CH4
N2O CI
2t
Cn1ruoy
r41.kda t
b4th0
HMW
•••YrrlA
'A .kn
r. 8 CC®
UC.030 •• 0.9101 • J. IYYC. d MO • ❑.Cg00 •. O,DC00

0.W33
11-.:03, _t"EL
041004
0 WOO i Dappo •
a00Ell
ooze
1A9 4 70Y
8 pCi+G9
113X0-1 .-.•r`f.80 ..OtYC 9F1CA0 6._6iY88 . -0.O:te}
OM))
0-C+Yf. . :;:x41[
• 0.✓1006
acme . Dorm . .
a4734
8271b • I= • 001107 • 1.: I?1 • *43111:1a- • I.223.1. O?22i. • • . 09tl, •
•
• Amon.- . .}3,0
n CXYJ 1
• 5,09136! 1L4l.ZSI • D.8367 • .
• 4 11 • • i
val
f47i1
L NIN
4421t
L t
9,101
AA Dint,
9880
tau

0.X29
i:A999e•
WS
ally]%
i,O9YU41
a
Lid,i.991
11 auk

I MAMMY
u

4.4 Operational Detail - Mobile

4.1 Mitigation Measures Mobile
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3002
6425
Cont.

Page 255 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1173

Responses to Comments
CalEEl9cd Version: CeIE F1+imd.2416 3.2 Page 215 of 35 Clyde. 11122)2021 2.30 PM Villar3e South Specific Plan i;Prapas®Idi - Las Angdaas-Sleuth Coaal Gourty,'IrJlntar 'i
1r
noz
oU1f t
FFAi9
E_r1a51
65110
Pfd la
Teti
14612._4

44.4.4 MLA

1.141O1
rum
I
IFI a,A:lc� 21.1",1 459914 110.422 • 11.1 1 4!59:52 • 0 .373 4023513 + 122959 @3132 12&Ei3 +4T51720I 47,51T MI 2.933 47917 05 limU,p n rW • 4SRa3 • 45 D914 11aD47'2+ 4'S6,2:. • ❑03173 . 493p7 + 124➢50 a D5172 : 1p.{1793 4791789 47 ftf7 SO• 2.1KM' 7—""'"7.) 974 BB •
•
•
15 4.2 Trip Summary Information
a».5ra{pc' CN1`; P-717 r4 .1 --F
LInm5t;'IMc.1
MI0D514d
La1n111M
Lr»s. dpy
.,alursy
9llnd3.y
Annual VIA'I
4rra. IVMT
... �. .... Apwrrnr,19Lo. l:m%Rr o
• .A.:.
1fd,26
154 co
:105127 ..
j... _... ta_1::. s7 ........

Apw7ne lsN Rine a
4,02,6 75
3 73,?5
?6 J
4 13,880,d65
136�i3OEE:
_
C3ereral Cffce 91t.1$1E1
20!45
*
81 755
,_.31
a';
71]0,95

00..12
ncry
dig,Tur u{SdiDamnRe�ursldl
380
. 1 613
2;$73.82
2517U572
�
�.
•
34132x7
•••-•••••••••
Impel
N2 no
1a750
I0L7470
;
_.3,413.937
445701 ;
445,+43
•
6uaaryydeainurarf
. e9
i.2
G416,2
441'93
• 7177,1541
707 Asa
R geonni 09c5!"g�Cermer._....

J,
861.44
357.04
• 1112,;;21
1,112x221
Tot.
6 :;.0 I
a. ii5d.43

5.057.21
I 20462,4.52 II

20.502,462
4,1 Trip Type inforrnallrtn
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3003
04-25
Cont

Page 256 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1174

Responses to Comments
CalEFIMa}d Version: COLE FM0ol.2O06 3.2 Page 2S 013,5 Clyde. 1112)2021 2.330 PM Villa•3e South Spoxiria Plan I,Prapasaa0i1- Las Midas -Sleuth Coast County, lrillrter ellen
Trip 9r.

Land Lm
H-WarC-46
li-3 or C C
H-0 al -W.'
H'A'naG44I H-asrC-C
H-4 Di C -I14'! Primary 00.-pried Past-l1/
Apartments. Lax Rae
• • •Areamrt'4111g1 .�' 4 M
Gcrrerat enta ?Jllairg :

19.7V 6.35 13.

IC. iiJ • 19.LP 40 60 • "so • i1 • 3

14.70 I ▪ S 00 ; 8.70 • • 40 M i 1.9:20 I 40:60 • 68 • 11 • .. 16 60 0.40 4.94 •
r 23.00 • 46.00 ! 113 00 • TT
HO TUrOgiegr(St Bm'+r, e r d ¢>•. 72341
¢] 1 15 60 ••. . P 40 • • @ } Ii 650 7F.54
Ha4e1 y 15.60 i B.40 •• 690 + a 1940 • 61.60 i 119:00
f11.111
19 90 37 20 r. 43
▪ 09 36• M 4
r

41. 'tdaslaurart 18.89 1 6.48 • 9.90 1350 al I 19.88 • 3e id ▪ 44 Roariaal ai ooiCant.r 16.611 9.40 •• 4.90 ,••16.31 6470 ; 1900 I 64 36 11 4.4 Fleet Mix
L9.1a 11010
LOA I
Wi-i
rMEN .H01 i LH04 MHO 4.11412
oeus Leaus '
OA 0Y
1 Lt5
841.1
Awn erds tow RK& • 0543066 0014:16 0200971 0110369 00113033 60136362. 0121166 0.033077 0.[]2613 0441617 0003206 0000712 00006:21 Apartments MOORya 4.• 0643069# 8.04.4218 13208rs71 0.118399 0514[33 6004832, 0.021190 0.063'377 0.04$13 0001017 0.[00201 6,000712 0000621 Cor4ralOOhce &.,wing ; • 04109090; 0.016.18 0208071 0.119009 0014063 0404',432 002'4106 -0.03.3577 0.W663 6.401017 61505,"066 0.0007413 80600:1 Hgrairriver(SHCden . ▪ 0442066. 8- 544210, II 2289111, 0118109. 64 4633 0a88di2 0021166• 0.863677• 8[)3413. nornil17'• 0.845366. 0000702• a0O0621 es ri uurar[)
Hotel
a'
• •6 3438611. 6 04421
♦.. 4.

Q.wNry R4016L16I1t • 0543006, 80.14210
-4
Raglan.' Slapping Center • 05430610. 60444210• 0.269971• 011025D; 0 1183136

0.1142400
6014000
U.0141 12
0009333
0!304.02
0 021160

0.1231 186
5,030}77
U.(A32E7Y
8014032.• 0000332• 0021146+

0.6018'17

0.001617

0.053.257
5,0066205

0.000021
0 [006;:1

0.03357+ 0 [07261.3• 0001617• 0 052110 0 000702. 0 000621

5.0 Energy Detail
I+Rtorli l Enargy tk"= 'A

5.1 Mitigation Measures Energy
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3004
04-25
Cont.

Page 257 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1175

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIrIAod Version: CeIE FMod.2016 3.2 Page 30 of 35 Ode. 1112'2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan I;PrapasaM - Lns Angdas-Skull Caaal Gourty,VJlrtar 1r
wg µc
FYAie
Eleuerl
Fr•,10

FIJI IF
113121
Pliag
MLA
. CM
!dal Lo7
M iY
•{ategay
1 R.!d1!
614ny
r1alu�aA3as . 07006
rogrei
• OF.442 kP9T3 • 0:MIB .... ❑°2 i 0.52]2 i .... D.3992 O..

YI.I..Y3j. f17B • B7 • . T9 • cam 6 • DGA2 . 11.3 ' • • 6.522'+ +3.52}2II U miKaterl ..
• 8.355943 i S3(i59B]• 11 IOW I 0!5a2 ! 9903 D3B
-
• 555.4ffi 83ES111x3• ®.1072 •• 6.10.2. B3B
2 2 • 7
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3005
04-25
Cont.

Page 258 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1176

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIIVori Version: GEIIE FM011.2016 3.2 Page 31 7l 35 Dole. ill 2a2021 2.34 PM Village South Specific Plan I,PrapasaM - Lns Anielas-Skull Coaal Gourty,'J'Jlrtar

6.2 Energy by Land Use - Nalura1Gas
Unmitigated
P+ lm -J.1 .
suss
9Gad
NO.•
MI
-
8472
Nria.e
MOP
" __.-.

PU16
R,t'11
TM"'
F�AI.q
F13. 1r
FahascY.

PM24
Pirt16
T+t1rl
ko- Ctal
NDo- -.•,:'
_,au �:�_
Z..a1
u.

GO.

Lend lire
4EITUfr
Id1Caq
,t,tls3
a ornit.Lo.

Pox
. 1116114
• 091 , • U. 1O3[
t±
['DUO • ki -09} •
40a •
g71 • 9.3WGa 34 • • .5 1 • 8 .3444►
MI TO CO 0M
•'ia16 • 151.ESU-!'' 1:. •
B
•. Ma
22 IC, . 1!824
Cr
516
X 1 d'I1
:54bx,hw'•1a C9tl
Gan¢a1SM.
9uliFal9
-iiir 1ummear[5rE
DomRe�.lr,•irGi
Fidel -r
• •,a0r
_. k ce eg tl
4 nliMn4 Cd t.?
357243
b
r' 03it$ . 9.40''2
x+011 4Caill ;
:I-
0iWEI • 02603 +. • Xia& A 0.2Gfsd
• 43m2.16. ..70.^4416 0QL r
L2t' 42
00134 • 01252:
01047 7AOOOo-�
041.1 6g0
D. MOW- . 0,5lOiw 9A00o- iln7Y0[e.
sr,F?• 063' 903
I1. WO II •• 22&MOu. `s.. •
caul .W3
r.'T'.709Er
I •3245 • 7.5711
o.l743 ': Altl131
i

7.102E . 9.1L , • 11t%i9 a1kq 2,9:7.534,.�eit.53,1,
r a•
661713-7 4-O4ai :'1i6$L�.540
�' a 2 i 1 a
47•567.'
,10-514 • 0,41570
03826 r ]8100:1
Q4?367 a 0.7ANS • . 0.+.C1f6 , 042366
MID,. i5IS9. I4 • IAICC4 r 60163 •56M112E2
• 56;"5k •1:'..1 • 0+6]8 • 6aa45 173664,• r ,5 OTT • 0859': i • 6.4537 • ;Sri '
....-..; 65 • Ix] ..WEI&r 661ea. 1 n1146 t59s
i 251L110
..
i
g IX3tr • 0.112+1! •
al
r�C4Y . .
6t'6 J7
i

1.'5(201„
ON ,
1 1.6700,
. NO
• 1,5706, •
OM i
• 1.&MI" , 1.8200e,
i W. OM
, O1.4'1e • zlnuI9 •.y, 1e-+
, Tj0• OW 1
.1155.995
3#043-1
04s
tool

4.T66d

9.3L₹5
1,;2333
4101119
tiSK2
4S n2

4.531a�
p52•82

9.3MAW
2 2

1.11302
n.1537
l.l'A•,6311
1 Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3006

04.25 Cont_

Page 259 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1177

Responses to Comments
CaIEEMod Version: {'+9:E FMod.2016 3.2 Page 32 of 35 pole. ii12a2Q21 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan I,Prapas®Idi - Lns Angda+s-Sleuth Coaal Gourty, Yrl1r tar

5.2 Energy by Land Use - Na1ura1Gas
Mi tisalod
hWulalell
s Un
1tCJd
NOI.
or
-
8472
r-a111.e
PMr4
E•11s..I
PUM
F1'&10
TM".

F�11.q
P? !
E:4ne.cY.

PM2 5
PI6t16
T+tni
910- Cta2
Nag- L22'
.._lac �:�_
:"

11..'.7
GO.

Land List
4EITUf r
Id1Caq
1t,tls3
+Ips5mrl•6a0 .

Pox
74ptx+. to l91
.....--..k....--.

Gan¢altl0ks .
aa4Ya19
•1IOhYumovur[al1.

DamRe�.uari
I�
na41•• •+I.9bN75
•l!erata'A
111015
r 00171 • 4.1O3r
t±
40730 • .5 -00} •
tXt1 •
9144[Aa • 9.34]06 • • .5341 1 8.3444►
703 TO CO OM •.
•'1216 • 121,613.U-O''BSI:. •
Ma
32 I 1!884
o
2114?0
357242
120142
Z alit$ . 3.1872
0+011 4tr211 ;
—.
0iMi3 r 02503 +. • Xia& A 0.2CAE
• 4319SIG., 21.415 0QY 'r
a ,
0013& • 41252:
01007 a 7A200o-
AA1
..

D. e• 0+5lOiw 2AOOo- • iln4c
671 SY,F7 003' 903
+1. 1 0011 • 22.0Xth. `s..
091 .W3
=A00
I •12644 • 7.311
o,l≥i43 :: 00130
i
-4---

0.10EE a 9.1Rai3 . • 7.14%19 Qilk.1
r a• a
9r7.S34 •.Let. 539+ 00512-700101 .'1i69L�0d0
�' a 2 i 1 y
1•47%72
10%14 • 04070
03020 , 2a120r
Q6206 a 0.0355 • . 043519. . 012366
Ri 1136. 5001100 • 001e0 r 50101 t55442E2
.4,1.51030
•2 7011 • !1.017 1 66751 17'957br 1 7o9Yf r 6867: • e 0.057! . 76;11 ••
1 9� n n • .
'
....- rM 00101 5Ex1..49ar 001 ea. 1 70100 45605550
i a
• o
Rcgcntl
ea,AMOn7 oe-o. ;
21150 - • 5.U20! •
P't41i . r
7JS57
,

1.MM.— r
OM r
1 1.0110kr
, 798.
0 IA1790•— •
7;d :
0 1.0700, . 1.a20ta
i W. 965
. 224.90E • 20011210 r a.i7)0e- 1
r 7w 1
04003 - 1
ca‘
14401
070311
&31₹5
020013
410111
05102
00712

0.52•X
I0w.2"12
1,355,1Y31
2 1155.995
2 01002

5.1037

1.124035
1 6.0 Area Detail

6.1 Mftlyalien Measures Area
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3007
04-25
Cont.

Page 260 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1178

Responses to Comments
CalEEM6d Version: C9:E FM0112016 3.2 Page 33 of 35 pole. ill 2a2021 2.30 PM Village South Specific Plan 1,PropasaM - Lns Midas -Soul" dal Gourty, Winter REG
teo
FX1F 0.e
PNI6

1.4110
PM II
743104
Pitt( P492.S
10124
Pi92 ❑
Nigro C07
Thud W
Y;I
Cole
1'1:1
4+1104
Ne4l41eJ M1 O2li . 159450 • 58 4431:1 I Li 0540 I95TA • 105,4 + 1_5514 155,4 ODOO6 • 1614855. 18.14859. 11.45,4 1!]5430 • 18. 5. t1 A! 110 ---‘------'• 56 I}2
Un-.1141.1 - 355{¢6 T+ 1541456• .4437 +1X14 • A 155?4 t 3574., �I9074 • •1+x'4 ,• 059116 18:14355' 1514055 -04974 • 63;70 15 5 t1* sa as _.

6.2 Area by Subcategory
llnpnitga ed
₹t)3
♦
s,3

3.2,2
14,9L,e
r'e114
aauaj
PLI16
Phil
TPtd
Fljdtwr.

OM 5
&hall
1442:.9
P6125

7.444.

Bar C62
Nets CO2
'NIA OCR
. 91
...X,
CO27
&KaleUo17
1^,11,,
1etley
IrTlItFeAWral 274116 • • + 0.0000 + Ol}1XID + r 2aW6
OI]WO
• L. GUM P 0x66
I ;
1 4
+ Cgl�ms + 24.1696 !I
U.G6W a a.3530 i OOW6
40760
le I GWW + i •
GCMG
a I
Algsih 1.6976 t 15441 4 &WOO I OW170 + P lgm t I IiOO + 1.14W I 7450
00006 .16.0.�W 10.W6 O2.ID0 A 6,367 a
l&7W 643
w w . A + P
w ,. + P
.O01
+ + . r
. 05 i 66 + Y
56 Lallbwprrp — • ._
2-1 760 • U.9493 . LC14139 • .13,049o- • 44579 � 0,4574 • 0.467+ •04674 • 14 .4 0 ; 146+6655 • 6,1424 1 A

15.21442
w I C41.4
+
T401
9p6425

15.414141
404.4420
4064

1.5474

4.5674,

9.1574

4.501.44
4,17400
& I148555

14.141-55

5.4514

0.5#00
06,]54111
NI
sa
a'
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3008
04-25
Cont.

Page 261 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1179

Responses to Comments
CalEElhr4cd Version: {'+9:E t=t kad.2016 3.2 Page 34.0135 Clyde. 111212421 2.330 PM Village South Specific Plan rPrapasaM - Lns Anielas-Skull Caaal Gourty,'J'Jlrtar

6.2 Area by Si bCategory
kna
RY. .
60 SC&
₹'.ylY.c
uI4iA
GtiaunI
74iir
FR.A0
Tnim
PVJ21
k 4
P142 i
Mid`_'
'.#9
Pan.c.C1i
NE., CO2
Tula] .7tw"'
'&I4
PLO
liar '
arulti'A]Ml •
Comb re
Ce.wnu
...... .....a
H.2-it 100110
Lai _aF1'S,
2;5,0
00tiC9
x]0000 . F °: at 0UMW

9.GM
. 99L09
. G0090
,.. . .
.TS1c0.00
90 . Icz1012
:1.1085
y t I 7 d
0f:L0
)ClG]3 , 0war] 0®09
4 00099
. 1.1940 • 59900
099W
tarA

1.149!9 .
-..-._.1..

I4DD
I 90
. .

1.1400
. ..
0004G . I0,00DCD. 11 woo
M 00
0342C . 03]{X3
a4TeB • 00400 ; e.2. aim
a.'Se93r
b.Itira
• 0.451

0.4044
J 74
.]4&.0 4. lA&C059

9.1124 •
ralaf
3n 9
1'10450
612.1410
R9e}44a

9.1rtr4
esvr4
L4071
T-3074
00400
l0,1a53§

5. 1®.'140:54
50 -11.alaa'4
02300
t3.z5atii
42 7.0 Water Detail

7.1 Mitigation Measures Water

8.0 Waste Detail

8.1 Miigation Meastres iniiste

9.0 Operational Offroad
EauwrcTiare
rxelLel
ltrn, C�,!N
rani T,0;.J
Stationary Equipment
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3009
04-25
Cont.

Page 262 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1180

Responses to Comments
CaIEEIhrlod Version: {'+9:E SMod,2016 3.2 Page 350'35 prole. 1112a2Q21 2.3O PM Village South Specific Plan Y,PraposaM - Das Angdas-Skull Cnaal Gourty,'A'Jlrtar Fire Plitt' OS and Erite rgertdw Generators
EPIX3rfierd Type
NLt,Aor
lieurgaay
HaersPeeer
Flare. Power
Laed F5olor
FLeal Type.

Rol If[.

Y-r1upreert Type
Nurher I 1-le:N putaey I i-d.r Irprt,Mexr
5ukr A.atng I FrelType
U.rr Dr finr.0 E;7.eiudr,rrrl
Equpined Type
Number

11.0 Vegetation
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3010
04-25
Cont.

Page 263 of 548 ends

11942
RTC -1181

Responses to Comments
Attachment C
Local Mire Provision Net Grange
Veit—Num Local Hire Provision
Total Cons truLtNJrI GHG Emissions AMT CO2e)

3.623
Arnortiz+ cl (MT CO2eivear)
1201.77
tti'ith Local Hire Provision
Total Construction uHG (misslons dM1 r; 12e[
AnifIrtiled (Nil COP,eivear)
Sri Decrease in a nstrurtion-related ONG FrlrissiOns
3,024

1.00.88 1 7%
04-25
Cont.

Page 264 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3011
11942
RTC -1182

Responses to Comments
EXHIBIT B.

Page 265 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3012
11942
RTC -1183

Responses to Comments
SWAPE
ra real riaraartrr onrtkt.lrru nnF!
- 4Ma'I in Mr Vwirrimnrt
SOII. WATER AIR PROTECTION ENTit64JRIISt.
1656 °tyth Street, Su to T.CI I
Sant. Manna, C.olrfornco 4ANO5
AIM Pond Rsarsf J I.1?fo r."
Mobil: (31%795 -?33:
£Iifiee. l3 704 .152-35,
Fet: f7410) .15 2.41,i
F rntl nratiearell9Tswancenn
Paul Rosenfeld, Rlk .
chemical Fate itnil Transport & flliqueslaa Aladdin .µ
Pnrrcipd EirourMagent.Ti i'hsmat kiskAssrasment & Her rcdiaLinn Specialist LLCildioll
Ph-©. Sail Chemistry, Urdre$lty ofihraahirigtoit I9Sr9. Dissertation on volatile organic compound filtration M SS Envirooli'anal Scream, UC. Berkeley, 15'95 Thesis on organic 96ftar w;tmaimirx.

Fl.A Emimnnantar San Iije r, c' Santa B0-Misra, 8991. Muria on wa.atewsttertreatmeni.

Prat'essional E 1perience
Dr Rosenfeld has over F 2S Years' expo -lame corb.'lucUng Chi']rnnmentatl investigations rind risk asseurnems for evahtatrng impacts to human health, property, and ecological receptors. His expertise focuses on the fate and transport port of environmental COnLilillillantt. 1ta17iart he,ylth nslr, exp 1, 1r Fa4a sa Th hL, uI1d ecological restoration .r)I Rosenfeld has evaluated and modeled missions Boren unconventional ciJ drdfing operations, ail spills, landfills, boilers and lneimtatr«rs, prnr:iss eludes. tboragc tank, confined animal, feeding capetali+.ens, cleftl many other indusinlal and agricultural sources His proJzril experience ranges trout monitoring raid itiodehng "1f pollution sourtvs to ,evaluating impacts of pollution an warkansat industrial lacihtieaand residents in surrounding commwrnes.

Dr Rosenfeld has investigated and designed remediatnn prngraanv and risk arses oink for canlaniinated sites containing lead, heavy metals mold, bacteria, ptlrnt:ulittr matt. petroleum hydrocarbnns. chlorinated solvents. pesticides, rafinaclive wage, dioxins and futons, semi- and volatile orktanir compounds, PCBs, FA1-1 perebltar;te. asbestos, per- and poly-tlui roalkcyl subsumes ITFOA/PFQS), unttvtud pe,lynters. Fuel oxymenares IMTBE), rntong o h r plalllnai is Dr Rosenfeld also has cparrens'e avnlualing graenh+aarregatx emissions from verfous projects and is an expert on the assesanient of odors from industrial and agricultural altos. as well as the evaluation of odor nataanee impacts and technologies tar abatement of odorous rmissrons. xis a pnncipal sctent]xt at SWAPE, 1]r. 1tasenfeld tlire Ts ATr daspers,-enn tnudchtig and o 1rs 1 ''-. m.tlen1a: lie has served as an OXperT Wilncs:'s and restifiesl abvul pollution sources causing nuisance ands- persona I injury at dozens of sates and has testified as an expert witness nn more than ten cases tow bang exposure lit air cnntnminonts from industrial sources Paul E Rosenfeld. ID

Page 1 ends

04-26

Page 266 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3013
11942
RTC -1184

Responses to Comments
Professional History.

Seel Water riir Protection Enterprise ( APE.)., 2003 to nrnent Principal and Ruffidaru,3 Partner UCLA School ofPublic Health:, 2[1(17 to 11)I l; lecturer (Axsrslnnt R rr:her) UCLA Schaaol of Public Ilcalth 2003 m 2305; Adjunct Prole -astir UCLA Envtr+_vrneemrtal Science ami Engineering Program; ?(I 2--2t)Ca=4;tyncwral intern t'uxrdmatnr UCLA institute ,f the Erwm riment. 2001-200C; Research Associate K mex 1laO Sciiyree, 2001 to 2003, Berrie)( Revmediaiion Scduntist Natiomul Groundwater Association, 2(M2 -20t1-1; Lecturer San Diego Starr University. 1999.2001: Adjunct Professor Antean Corp.. San Diego, 2LJG1}2OV11; I{.emedtation Project .Manager Ogden (now Amen San Diego. 2000-2IXAI; Retmediatinn Project Manager Bechtel, San Diey+re 1_'alifor iai, 1999 2tllx); Risk/assessor kiree County, Seattle, E 496 - 1399; Scientist
fames River Corp., Washingtian, I9')3-9+6; Scientisr
13ig Creel- Lumber, Davenpari, California, 199'5: Scientist Plurrras S'rrrp., Calf€Otrua used LISPS, Tahoe 1993-199!, Scienttlit Peace Corps and World Wildlife Fund, St. Kitts, Wart Itudier, 1991--1993; Scientist Publications:

Remy. L.L.,, Cloy T.. Byers, V., Re&enleld P, 11` (2019) FlrxtpisaI, ITealth. arid Community Burden Afti=r Oil Definer,' Fires, Richmond, (r lifurniu .:(a)? and 2(12. Grrtrrurnrr€rrrral fuel rk T 8:48 Simons, RA , Sao, 'sr Rosenfeld, P„ (20 I s) Medeling the Effect of Refinery Emission On Residential Property Value Journal of Real Estate Research. 27(3)J2I-34.*
Chen. J. A. Zapata A. R., Sutherland A 1., Molmen, LJ.k., [_how, R. S., Wu, L Rosrnacld. P. 1E , tirsse, RL [ _ (21112) Sulfur Dioxide and Volatile Organic Cnmpaund F:xpoaure To A Crinnturnity In T,exvs C'.ity Temi&livatuated Using Acrrerod and I=mpencal Data. .mere arrJonrnrai e+f'kmrirnnmenhaLcwnce. sd6i. 622-632 Rasenretd, P.E ,'k Fens. T (hitl I ). The Rtgks oflieg mows Warm- Amsterdam E14.41,ter Pub14thing.

C 1. seretrosrnafl„ N P...§= Rosenfeld, 1'.1 (2[111) flandbotoir rJfFrAtirthm Powentton and C caner Prrraiatctieam. Iles[ Practices lir tlan.abrraclaerniaaP Pndastny., Aan.terdam- Elsevier Publishing.

Gonzalez, J., Fen L . Sutherland. A.. Waller, V, Sok, 1-_, Wes R, Ro%cre.feld. P. (.101n) Trr`1is and Dittxins;Furanas in Attic Dull, Canceled Near ],armor PCS Production and Secondary Copper Facilities in Sauget_ Ptrace,L& Ein4r otance.raial Scaeatevx 113-12i
Fens, L. Wu, C., Tam. L , Sutherland, A.1 . ^Leal J J , Rnsenreki,, P.E, (20111) Ihatun and Fursn Blood Lipid and Allis: Dust C'_rsncenlraitiems in F'iripilatiFi s Living Tyner Friar Wrxtd Treatment Fatililins in the [Tided Stales. J irzed ofEkwirrommem of Fleenor 73(6) 24i —in
['hermit moIY` N.P., & Riminifeld, (20w10.) HHarrnes stl• ofPo,ifuGwv Prtimntren and Cleaner Prodercnon: Be,:

Prraat aaa err flea lfixad and Paaparfnduafties. Ams(erthrn el;vewiet PubLtshidg.

Ghereirrasmoff: N, P . Sti Romenteld, f',E- (31J('a9) Hern'irrs* r.?1Pollinton Prevenrrr)rt iarld Clenrpsr Pnxfarrao t: floe Pr echoes err the Petralrarm imiorsiry Arrtsleniarrr0 ElseSier Publish >lg , Tam, L , Clark, J„ Rrtsenfsltl, P 02['99). Dioxin and firm hlnocl lipid sacyncentraclom in p puln3isxns U''rn hear four wooii treatment facilities in the Unitnd Slates. r4'7i Trnrxai rpvna oar EeriGgy and the Em'fttmruaat, _ter P ut t 123 (171319•.;27
Nut Rona -lick. Ph
Page rat 10 brie 2I119
04-26
Cant_

Page 267 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3014
11942
RTC -1185

Responses to Comments
Taal_ K., Tdu uC CJ , Clark l 1. arid Ros feki, PJC (2J x'gl. A Statistical Analysis Of Attic Dual And Blood Lipid Caneentraticrrta Of Ti 1rruhlnrr -p-Dibe crndiosin (TODD) Toxicity. amov;iii ney Quotients (TT(a) In Tw Populations Near Word Treatment Facdin es. Orgemethalogen Compontar7.r. 70. 00.2252-01.1.225.5 Tama L. K.., Wu C. D.. Clark 1. J. and Rosenfeld. P.li. (2008). Methods I+'or Collect Samples For Assessing Dioxins And Other EtWaOnrricra it I:'ontanttoanAs In Attic Du;l A Review Orgrarrokiia'as un Con n , 7O, 000527- OUtJ53ll.

Hensley, AR A. ,crw+. J J J CIurk Rosenfeld, RE. (2X7). Attic Diost and Rowan Blood Samples i'ollected niatr F r lflea ArtiOd. Treatment Facility. 5m4rxr+rnrs ruaI Research. 10•x, 194-197.

Rosenfeld, P.E.. 1 J. .1 Clark, A. R. Ilensley., M. SSuf et. (2007). The Use of an Cdr 'MIMI Classification for E: rlvntion of Human Health Risk Criteria for 1 mipoat Fatcilitie% }Itrter,S'eeerrtte,* anlsagt, 55{5}. 345.357 Rosenfeld. P, F., M -off 1- (20117), The Anatomy Of Odom' l'aheels For 04mare Cll' Iriiikkne, Water,'Xiis;7awater, Coal -hp -4 And The 1Jrhran Rnvuntiment ii'saratr cixracte & TacJtruafrakv 55(5), 335.34 sully^am, P, 7 Clark, J,J.1.. Asardy. F l., Rosenfeld, N.F. f2txr7). 'Auk: Levey,. tvihrifc Foams an Me f'09l iif'nrnr, sariAir rn.vinaeric,:7nCities Baskin ktassitehuseris:.klsevier Puh9sxlhing Rosenfeld, Y.13., and SutTet f1£ 12094). C nrdrul of Compost Odor Using High Carbon Wood Ash Ware, Science ,nazi Teefinal -19(9), 171-17S
Rosenfeld P. E_, 1J. Clark, T F1 (Me1) Suf1e4 i'..10 hl). The Value of An CJdnt.Qnality.Whael Clasarl`tealaon Scheme For The ( ban Enviranrttwnl Water J2•mirorrrnerf Federation's r rrshnieof 1axhibihrrn and ConiQrente EFfriCi 2Jfl i 'kw (Orleans, (7ciober 2-6,1014.1.

Rosenfeld, F',Il, and SufTet, 1 IT (2(u 4) Llnd ratatrtimg Odorants Associated With Compost_ Biomass rn4 Bites. and the Land Application of Bius•.olids. Water Bassi-e.and 2reektsolew -19(9), I93-199.

Rosenfeld, P.E.« and Sufi t I.R (2[at}.4)_ Control of Compost Odor Using Hieh Carbon Wood Ash, Water S6 -Amer and Te'Jxrta) I -1"_h' 9), 17T-173.

Rosenfeld, R E.. Grey. M A.. Sae's—, P. 1?fJQ-1.) Meas.ureinnatt of Brosolids Odor and Odorant Emissions hom Windrow.,,, Stu ttrPile anti Bi01i]ter, rl r*, 7 4), 31ik-31� Rosenfeld, RE, (trey, M nncl Buffet, M. (2111)2), Con -rpm FFarnomiratttrsn Protect, Sacramento California Usnrg High-Cari+on Wood Ash to Control °dor at a Green Materials Composting Facility integrated ff'exec 44aanaagerrraent Board Publ'ic Affairs O, c. FuRicativns Clearinghouse (MS -6:k, Sacraneento. CA Publication dr4-12-92-0(18 Rosenfeld, P.E., and CI_ Henry (2001), Characterisation of odor etniasronsfiom three different krtosrsltds. ffafer SorltavJ,, rrPrailurirrrq, 137(1 4} 173.191
Rosenfeld. P.1+.-, and Hurry C L , (2IX$I) Wend ash control of odrx ern - .ions from Inirisol tie Appl icAkia,r Immo! o{ Eck irawarrrantaal lttali y., 23. 16(22 -lea
Rosenfeld, P.IL. C.L. ldenuy and D aermett. i;1101t1) Wastewater dewuterinp polymer affect on biosrrlicis rldar em s:kingandmicrobialBeltway Wafer E'rwrrnnrfrt rReaaauch 73W,3fi 347.

Rosenfeld, P.I , and C.L. 1lenry (?tllkl ) Activated Carbon and Wood Ash Sorption of Wo<5ttwater, Compost_ and Rrrm slide f Idrvaadz. Water E nvrrarovertt J4eeemoh. 73, 380.393 Rosenfeld. P.F., and 1-irxu-v C L, (200 B) High carbon wood ash effort on biosclids microbial activity and isdcr. lPurerErmiromr rim' iias ,urn Jr. I31(1 4), 247-262
Paul E Rosenfeld. Ph_l

Page 3 ends

04-26
Cont.

Page 268 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3015
11942
RTC -1186

Responses to Comments
cltolleck, T and P. Rosenfeld_ (19aS) Compost Amendment Handbook For Landscaping Prepared for and Jistnl*uled' } 3, the of Redmond, WashingIon Suite
Rosenfeld, P- F.. (I 99"_). The Mount Liaroniga Craw Trail Hollow Afogicine of'St Kit7,s, X2) Rosenfeld, P. E. (1993), High Y-chrtol Bi.agas Project to Prevent Detor-astation iUn Si. Kitts d3rtmmus'S ()sans hernwrvk, 7(1).

Rosenfeld, P. E. (I't`+R). Chanu;ttriaalion. Quantification. and Control of Odor Emistiona From Binsolidd Application To Forest Strrl, CacteraJ Thesis. University of Weshsn¢ton College of Forest Resources_ Rosenfeld, P. R. (1994): Potential Utilization of Small Diameter Trees out Sierra County Public Land. A-lasters thesis rep, inter by the Sierra !:rout(,' E+Cvnrtil ie ('riurw il. Sierra r'ouithe. California Rorer rdd, P. F. 0991) Flow to 19ulld o 1 romll Rural Anaerobic 17igtter & Islam, (11 Ftrogru In. The Fir^it And Third World Elrychel+art: Tlheeie IJnrver ttv^ of California.

Pr -4O1 J
Roscnf rL P,&, Sutherland, A, H, .*'e. R.; 7sapat . A (Garber 3.6, 7:013) Air dispersion mtxfaling of r'nlatiie organic cmiSsit ts: firm muhgala natural gars wells m Decant:, TX. 4441i Western fte; tunad Moiling. American Chem aicud Society. Lecture conducted from Sam& Clara. CA Sek, FI.L., Wtr'nller, C.C.. Few, L.; th,ri iez. J.; Sutherland, A.1., Wisdom -Stack, T., Sabin. ER., Hesse, R.C.; Rosenfeld, P.R. (June 20-23, 2rilil) Atraztnn: A Persistent Pesticide in Urban Drinking S'k'ater.

Urban ,tirrk rorrmuerrt.ri' Pollution Lecture conducted Inrm Euston, hJA Fettg, L . Connie?, 9.. Sole., H I: . h'uthetlrtrrd r .) . 44'aller, C' c; Wisdom -Stash. T. Rabid, RI , Ina, M., Hesse, R.C.. Rosenfelt), P.R, (lune 20,33, 20I Li). Bringing E. vie—ronental Justice En East St Lows.

Illinois r'.rhon riaten-none: I a( Pathit&tit Lecture conducted from Roston. MA.

Rrtaeoreld, F.E (April 19-23, 2rmil91 Perfluoroctruroare Acuff (PFC3A) and P'inilnnrrwhctanc Sulfnnatse (PECS) C'on'tnmmation in Drinking Winer From. the Use of. Aqueous Film Forming Foams (AFFF) at Airports to the Uniltxl States 2009' around Water Summit and 2(709Cirottnrf rreirem'PrwechcratConan! SprIng 4J'eehng. Lecture contluettsd from Tuscon, AZ.

Rastnreld, P.E (April 19.23, 2 19) Cost to Filuct Nirvana Contamination iinrrs Drinking ',Yaw in Lhc Unttcsi States" Coraitminutif?n in Drinking Writer From the Live of Aqueous Film Formng, Foams (ARID nt Airports in the Unrttel States 200P Ground lFtuwr Sunrrnir and 200Q Gramma Mater Frnrecnnn Coma( Spring -leering Lecture conducted from Tusu Win. AZ.

Tate. L . Clark. 1. Rtrmikid, P (2fr-?z July. :O)9) Dioxin rind Mina blfuod hpid eoncetrtrutieu in populations living rear four wood treatment facilities in. the !Coifed States. Brebbia, CA and Popov, V, eds_.Jmr Pollution .S'r d1: PriscOitelotg.i of ate Seterrree,rlh inrentatdorirrl enorehgnee calf ;!malehag, JGFrrtifGrrring ,tna Aftarrtrgcrratnr,e-.,rmr, Po:baritrrr Lecture GontltacCpcl from T'iillithr, Estonia Rosenfelt!. P, E. (()arils.: 15-18, 2(Y)71, Moss Point Community Exposure To Coetarttinants Ftom A Relsisntg Facility. The 23' _4lmprued dniernevrnrrp( CoOrurces on Soils Sed'r.nrsntanti Water_ Platform lecture rranducirel from I,iniversine of Massaehu aM. Arnhem* MA
Rosenfeld, R E. (October I5-16. 2cX ). The Repeated Trespass of Triaium-Contnmatated 'iVater Into A Surtounsting ).Community Farm Repeated Waste Spills Aunt A Nuclear !Prayer Plant, Thu 23' Artrfuaditi+errmarkmnrtl a"nrq'eres ces on &rig Sediment mai ):rafter. Platform lecture condar;.tedl from Unis ersity of Massachusetts,, Amherst MA,
Pout l= Rosenfeld, Ph_D
Fags; d of it) buoy 2I I I9
04-26
Cont.

Page 269 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3016
11942
RTC -1187

Responses to Comments
,tt
Rosenfeld. P. E, (October 15,13, 2007) 'Somerville Community Exposure Tn Contaminants From Wood Treatment Facility Enti.:sirrnr The _5'1.4nnuad Iniernartcmal Co Ore r;,AN on gds Sardannurcr and (firer Lecture conducted tiara University of Massachusetts, Amherst MA.

Rosenfeld P. E. Wert 2007). Production, Chemical Properties, Toxicology. & Treatment Case Studies of 1.2.3- Tnrcbinreproptene (ICY) The:Ia.•ccx7rrrrr n,dc rLmli t•rrm{mrod Health and &loves pLhlfSl.In rw! Alusrrng Let lure conducted from San Diego, CA.

Rosenfeld P, E (Marcie 20117> Blood and Attie Sampling for t) tnrFuran, MALI, not Metal. Exposure in Florala, .alabanta. Thee_4EFISrirururrf ifeenrrg. Leanne conducted. from San Diego, CA Hensley AR, Sco4I, A Rosenfeld P.E,, t: furl:, JJJ (August 21 - 25, 2O 3) Dioxin Contstn ng Attic Darn And Human Blood Utilities Collected Near A Fortner ti4'ntid Trtatmzttt Facility This 215 -:Jr irfteenann,imq .SIxtpa shots c+rr ficadr>f,ennred Persisrerrt O'rgtrrnc Pollutants - Dials hr2066. Lecture conducted from Radisaon SAS Scandinavia Hotel in Oslo Norway
Hensley A.R., Scott, k. Rosenfeld P.R., Clark, J.J.J {November 4-l. 24108). Dioxin Camtammg Attic Dust And Human Blood. Sam(+l€w egllacted (*Near A Forme! rrk'r+nd Treatment Facility, ,iPttel 13,4 rtrraarMrd ,Weetl'nrg & k -position. Lecture conducted from Boston Massachusetts. haul Rosenfeld Phi) (C )ember 24-25. 2tSIl5) Fate, 'Transport and Persistence of PFOA and Related Chemicals_ Lisle SrJaMe, Rrak & Erdhiiman Contemmxt Lecture etiruiucttul from The I2tttirrbouse Hotel, Philadelphia. T'A
Paul Roosenfeld PhD (SsTtetriber 19. 2945). Dmminatecl name Retardants in GroundwaterPathways to IIumin Jrrgkprrrr, P yft.ntugy and Rsnoerdreix"Prua f'fi34 A Errrersrrg amtamuirront C'.c+rllurerre,-e Lecture rneuluctnd from Hilton Hotel, Irvine California
Paul Rosenfeld PLR. iSeptemher I. 2005) Fate. Transport, Toxicity, And Persistence of L!3-TCP PEW lintovng Crrnrrrfdwarer Ct+r{,ferz•rrctr. LrxttrteccntJueled nom Ilillr>n floret in Irvine. Ciliifirnia.

Paul Rosenfeld Plan. (September 26-27, 2505), Fate, Tren port and Persistence cif ?DBEs. Sdeairy's-C.rratmeiwirler earldkrarce Lechers conducted from &Lila t'iirltdnLINDA. 14211113 Del Itay, Califnt-mal, Past Rosenfeld Ph,D (dune 7 -Li, 21105) Fate, Trianon and Persi.sunce of PFOA and Related t hi:nucals.

International Saclety of Em Iroaarrrmataf Forenso Poem On Emerging Contaminants. Lecture conducted from Sheraton 0czattircmt flmtel. Virginia Beach, Virginia
Paul Rosenfeld PhD. (July 21.2'`, 2iat5) Fata Transport, PersisIen.ce and Toxicology of PFOA and Related Pe rfluontehemira.ls. ?(Z5 ,V'atiouai f:rraxrrrirrttter .lsaacFatrcm Grimed Water And &'rnuiron n8ni Lrrw r on cremes.

Lecture conducted from 'Wyndham L3a (amore Inner Harbor, Baltimore Mary land.

Paul Rosenfeld Ph.D. (July 21-22. 2 x35). l3rommii cd Flatus Retardants in Groundwater Pathways to liuman IttgtotIon. Toxicology 1191d Iaeriuddtir>n ?rJ+9S ,''arinw4 flrrnrradwater :Js•+x'tarlra+s trrrrtan,f Water and k.mironinunial Law t'oryinince, Lecture coricu;.ted team'Wyndham 13altirneca Inner!-1arLrnr, ls.lttrnc,re h-larcland.

Paul Rosenfeld, F'b,IJ. and ,lamex Clark Phi] and Rob Hesse R G (May 5-5. 2004) 'Pert-htutyl Alcolsol nubility raid Taxicolag]', A National Problem anti Unrloantiited fuahilrty, ,V'atirancra' Cirrxrrrdtetttcr As samati°txt Environmental air ('onferanee r.ecture conducted Isom Congress P lazy lintel,t'.hiCaten Paul Rosenfeld, Phil (tyturcla NBA) Perchlorate Toxicology A:feeling if lite .4rrrrrivan e:Jreaandieacer Tow Lecture crjndu led f:'rom Phtxeni s Ariwna.

Haherrrivatt ltI F , Paul Rosenfeld, P5t_D. arid Raub Hesse (2t0(lJ). F'rredilt+rater Corium natitxn of the C.olorudn River A. -fading of trittrai representatives.. Denture conducted from Parker, AZ.

Paul E Rnzettfrltl, Ph_D
Rage 5 rr[ 1lM Jura.2.019
04-26
Cont.

Page 270 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3017
11942
RTC -1188

Responses to Comments
Paul Rosenfeld, Pti.la. ,[April 7, _4114) A Netting Damage Assessment Model Ear PCE and Dry Cleaner,.

Thyrikancr Sirorrpvistrarrir Carfrrrmrr Gmrrrxl Water Assort -Minot Lest uric conducted from Radison 1I real, Secrrtmrnh California
Rosenfeld, F, E. Grey, Id., (June 20O) Two stage btohltcr far biosolids t,omposttng odor control. Seventh larternuhe»ra hr Shit Anwar Stir Bioremehariorr Ya,,rnpvs(unr I}rtlaeClc ( olorarrarice Orlando, FL Paul Rosenfeld, Ihi.1). and. Jamei Clark Ph .l] (February 20-21, 21O 3) lindetraanding Historical Use, Chemical Pr;rperties, Toxicity and Itegtdaiory sluitlance of t,ar Dxasrrnt, N ti,ntalOront rfnatetrfrarrrtratdran g'aiirtira triFucra.r C gtapence_ innerSuppty alldErtierging Can rinrinaitrs:.. Lecture conducted from Hyatt Regence Mazola Arimona.

Pant Rosenfeld, ?E.ID. (February 4-7. 2O73) Underground Storage Tank Litigation and Rentedtation. Catrt`bmxara Lecture conducted Non Marriott Hotel. Anaheim Cit]tilnirtua, Paul Rosenfeld, Pb,1) (October 23, 20112) i)ndergtratald Strarnge Took I.itigannn and Rem¢diatssn F l i;sadergrrrunrt,'>Yrnrage Tank fiOrdrkihrhiC lecture conducted from Sacramento C itlifOniid.

R(rsetifelt4 P, E, acid SSuITet, ! 1. (DnInkree 7- 0. 2(X)2) Idndrxritrtnding Otlttf from Comprot. if'egrtrtwrttet and hintarsirral P"racessec Sixth .4nrrrxrl .°3ynxpa4um On Of Fi'utvrra in the Aquatic Ernnrnnaient. lniprmahonal Water ,;asst_ matt Lecture C nulueted from Barcelona Spirt
Rosenfeld, P. and Sailfet, M. fOctnbr•r 7- I{i,, 2(iri2) Using High Clubs) Woad Ash in rrontru't Compiost i3drr.

Set -at Amaral rsryaiirdav (Dip Car Floors to tier Aquatic tWit-+nni rr1. Int •mahrtrnal Winer AEsnrt:?ariicnn. Loctiire conducts! from Barcelona Space
Rosenfeld, P.V.. and Grey, M A (Sepses -ohm '"-14, 2002) Biocyck; rumps -Meng For Coastal Serge kedoration Morasses/ Eichsr d$.4.freragetrreru 4s aManorr. Lecture conducted from Vatnrnuver LL'avltingUara.

Rosenfeld, PE and Grey, kit A. iilrnrember 11-14, 26O21 Useig High -Carbon Wood Ash. to Control Oder at a Green Materials clonvostittg Facility. &ail Scilenc's• mot)., ill mow( Corf{arerrav Lecture conducted from huhanapoks, Maryland
Rosenfeld, P -E. (September I. 21)611). Torn Stage biofller for biosolidJa corm -ogling ntksr control Water &M r-pm-nem Federanon Lecture conducted from: Anaheim California.

Rosenfeld. P.E. {October 16, 20Ollj. Wood ash nail btoftk er- control aC compost odor. Bi est Lecture conducted from Ocdan Shares, California
Rogror d, P -E. (2(m I0) L-tiorerrtedintian Using Organic Soil Amendments Co,igfwrrda Resdorrrnr Ftcccn+e+}' 4ssoctataan. lecture rnndiiiicted from Saraamcnin California.

Bost i(1d, PA!. , t` L I- nry, R, Harrisen, (190 11) Oat and (Hass Seed (termination and Nitrogen acid Sulfur Emissions Following J3iosolids Incorporation With High -Carbon Wood -Ash. Water Environment Poderation I2th ••raanaaf Roblirtrix and i3Artxoluti Sfarurgerrrient Co4f-¢.rrnce Pemea M igR.. Lentrire conducted from Bellevue Washington.

Rotrentcld,'P.E., and C L- Henry (1999) An etalujiti,n of ash incorporation with biosolsda for odor miluctirm &'.' Scknce StmetytNAlmeria.] . Leann:conducted from Salt Lake City Utah Rosenfeld, Y.E , t` L Henry, k 1-lsmatm qI 99Kj. C mpanson of Mtr:rebia€ Activity and Odor Emissions [roar 11u e Different f1A itohdx Apphtad to Forest ;Soil Rp.m.rn and C'drid7wIL lecture conducted from &tattle Wsslinetjtaan.

Rosenfeld, P.E-. C L Henry 0994 Cheraetcrirnhim. Quentttieatron, and Control of Odor Emissions tram Biosolids Application To Forest Soil flrtfegt. Leta uric armducted from Lake Chelan Washingtrrn into[. E Rosenttkl, PItr)
Rage h ref 1lM Duna _111119

Page 271 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3018
11942
RTC -1189

Responses to Comments
Rosenfeld, P.E. CI_ Henry, IL Harrison. (1998) aitt and Grass Seed t7crmsnatton and Nitrogen and Sulfur Endirxfnns Following Tiosolids Incerptsrntirsn With T1igh-rarbnn Woad -dish Wader Entitntsment Federation I `th Annual Residuals and Biceolida Managimcnt CianliTrrteC Proceedings. Lecture eondueted from Bellevue 4'au,hinsfntri
Rosenfeld, P,4, C L. Henry, R. B Harrison, and R Dills (1997), f iamppairisen of ihlnr l±rnysrarms From Three Diileaent Etrosoluls Applied Io Forest Sail Soil Science Society of Antenna Lecture conducted from Anaheim Ca liforma
Teaching Lxperience:

UCLA Lcpartmenl +A' Ln4•rrnnmcntal Health r,Snmmer'_iii Ildo gh 2{ar1il1 Taught Erriircii]„ehtel Health Science LW to Students, inclvdnng undcrgrad, medical doctors_ public health grefitistonals end nurses Course focused oil ]he health 4rl'ecta 0!'ntyironmental contaminants
National Chtnind Water akssixa.atiun, Successful Itemethation Technologies. Caw= Course m Suite Ftc, No.

Mexico. May 21. 2IJU? Focused an fate and nwrapart of fuel contaminants associated with Underground stnrage tanIa.

National Ground Water Msrtciaticar. SiSuceeasful I, tnediation Technologies Curse in Chicago ilknsi . April 1. 2002. Focused on rate and transport of contaminants assnciated wrth Supertnnd and ltC 1tA sites.

California integrated Wave Management Bared, April and May, 'UKi1 Alternative Landfill Caps Seminar in San Diego, Ventura. amt San Francisco, Focused on both prescriptive and innovative landfill corNcrdesignn.

UCLA Department of Errtarnnmcirtal Jrngine ing, Pebruary 5, 2t.ti' Seminar on Successful kemediation TeclmnIngies focusing, an liroundwater Riariediaticm
University Of Washington, Sant Science Program 'ruching Assistant for several corpses including: Soil Chemistry, ( iteic Snii AnientltnevM; and Rod Stability
t! t' Berkeley, F.marnamental Scicnr prngran-i 'reaching Aseastant far ESnVprnnnAthtil Scrcnce 1.0 Academic Grants Awarded:

California Integrated Waste Management Board. 8'31.61Ut1 grantmar-clod to UCLA Institute of the Eiwinxtment.

Caul: To inv trgate eft -ea of high carbon wood ash aria'volatile org.in is emissions from compost2ia:if Syomen Technologies, Corona t'ralifnrnia &Iui,tliXU grant awarded to San Diego State Ulnivfirsity Goal: investigate effect of birtsolids for restoration and rernediation ril'degraded coastal sage sails. S+K'Ni.

I' -big County. Department of Ifeaei r h and Technology, Washington State $1 fita,th]rt gran, awarded m University Wtshingtcra. Goal.. 'Ca investigate odor emirsiorrs from rrirranlids application and the effect of polymers and ash or, VC(' emissions 199$
Northwest Binsolida Management A9aoelati0fri, Washington State 8213,1181G grant awarded in investigate effect of polymers awl Fish on VOC emamens- from hioanliwLs. 19'97 James River Corporation, Oregon $1fl,t:uxr gram su a awarded to rnvrestrgata the sucecsa.al'genotreally engine rid Paiplar trees w irh resistance ttr mound -up 1996
United Stale Forrest ;?eau ie4, Tams National Fa test fit 5» (I ward Me awsrdsxt to hnt•'migatirty fire ecology (If the Tahoe National Forest. 1 95
Kellogg Foundation. Ll:vx} noon t) C $5fF1 quint was awarded ns canslruet a lard anaerobic 1igkster or 3t h itte in West loth®. 1993
Pituti Rosenfeld,Ph_D

Page 7 of 16 ends

04-26
Ccr1t-

Page 272 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3019
11942
RTC -1190

Responses to Comments
Depolitiun lntllnr Trial Te.itimnnv.

In ilte United Slaws Di tr at I'aurt For The :Dasnaet cir 1reu, lerso Duarte et al, N itr nilf].3: vs. United States Metals Refining Company et mi. Diriforkkur& Case }a:r_17 �iihylLI-C'1!
Ratzeelltild ncrn,iitlon. ti -7-7i1,1 9
In the 1Jnited StatesTDistnct Court or Southern District .o(Ttsys Cialviston. Diu Islam

7.,1,'T (-aria Maerk, Phonti,i'x ws Conti ICh8_, SehitTahrts-GMBIT & t`ot. Maker KG MS -Conti. Pe'did Defi.ordenk
Cast No, .a 15 'V -1X11016 consolidated with 3:15-CV-IX3237 Rosenfeld Deposition 5-9-21119
In The Sups for Court rrfthe State ofCulifomia In And Fur Tic County Of Los Angus -Stuns Monica Cnrole-Tadden-J3utes et ai.- ts. Irian Khan et uL Defendants Case No, No. DC6156_46
Rosenfeld Deposition, I-25-2919
In The 5upr3iar Cnwi of the Stare of California La Aid For The Ccatnty Of LOS Aragon -- Satan Minion The San Gabriel Valley Cownril of Governments et al vs Cl Adobe Apra Inc et al,. Defendant i Case No.. No. BC646131
Rosenfeld Deposition. I1 --2J] s; Trial 3-7-19
In United Stares District Court For "Me Diemen of Colorado Bells rt a 1. Flaiintiftvs T'he 3'+1 Company et al . Defendants Case. No. 1: in -m-4'2531 -RAJ
Rosenfeld Deposition, "a-15.2111 i€ and 4.3-201 8
In -fhe District Court Di' Regan (`ount}y. Texas, k 1'-11' Jndic tat District Phallip Hales et al , Plaintiff'vs. Dow ,Adros4iences, I.I,C, etid. Defendants Cause No 192-3
Rir xnfeld Deposition. 11-17.7,1117
In The Superior Court at`tlae Static of California In And For The County Cif Contra Costa Simone �t tbl., pia' ntafi us. c'Ineani;m a otp:7ratlun, CI. ot. 17afett unls Cu'araNo Cl2_I1'1 4141
Rosenfeld Deposition, 11-20.2017
In The Circuit Curt CO' The Tuenuesh Judicial Ctreuti St Clair County, Illancais Mart it Custer et ul _ Plain iifl'irs Cenci Flow. Products. Ines. Defendants Case No.: Nil OD -L-2295
Rosenfeld DepoaitiotL 8-23-21)17
In Tilt Superior C°,.+drn nflhe State ofC,ali rm5ia, For 'Cht (Amity of Lom Angelem Lam Culbert and Penny Gilbert I']aintatl'vs. BM9,r of North Amzriw LL( Case No. LC 102019 (crw BC5g2 E 54)
Rt+seafeliJ Deposition. 8-16-2017. Troll 8-,2 .201
ht the Northern District Court c;fl4ti sis oippi, Citeenvilie Div loon L-Irenda 1. Cooper, et al., i'tarrrh(}s vs, Mentor loc., et ol., Defttalinis Cast Number: 4:16rcri-52-t fl3-IVIA
Routtfeld Depoccition: 9uly 21113
Pitut l= Rnzenfekl, Ph_D Pap n rrl 10
0426
Cc ri t -

Page 273 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3020
11942
RTC -1191

Responses to Comments
In The Sup:nar Court of the Staff of 3 ashrng*tc t. County of Snohomish Iirharl Davis and Julie D1 i''te el al . Plaintiff vs. t`cdar t mve Composting !DV , Defendants Case No No. 13-2-03987,5
Rosenfelal Deposition, FebruinN '_1117
Trial March 201 7
In The SuperiorCaurt ot'the State of California, County of Alameda Charles Spain., PIaintatf v . Thermo Ftsher Scientific, et al , L feridiintw C441.1 o R01,47111115
Rosenfeld Deposition, September 2[P15
In The kw District r'outt In And For Powestutk Caiirtty kunxo]1 Lr4'tnhurn et al . Plarntiffa va, Debi Hoitahergen„ et a1, 17eferttiint. (.'aae 1}a. - LA.LA.ts1.12187
R:nsenfalul Deposition, August Tra1
In' The Iowa District Court For Wapella County
Jetr' Dkr.'icrs, et al., Plaintiffs Va]1e5' View Sine LL.C. et ail., Defendants Law Ne. L,LAIi1314 - Division A
Rosirtfeld l t'pr +itiarn. Auactst 7,015
hs The Iirw t Tnstrict Court For Wapello Cowin?
Elsmig Packs. et n1., et al.. PJ. irttiffs vs Richard ihrurre.n.+rt Itl . Defendants Law No, LALA I GY5I+1+f . Division A
Rigierifeld Depoeitivn. Augrksl. 201.5
In The Circuit Court ai'Ohio Colmar. West Virginia
Robert A.ndrtw t, et al v Atttcr+a, eta]
Coal Aotian.N4. 1a-C-3i70btl
Rosenfeld Deposition, June r+JI 5
In The Third Judicial District County of Dona Ana, New Mexico rJ-env Gcmwske, at al. Plamtiffs vs Del Oro Dairy, Del (Jto %AI Estate LL(, Jerry Settles and Dewed DcRuyter, Defendants
Rorenfetd Deposition: Atty. 1'015
ht 'The Iowa Dia[rict Court For MuscatineCOunn•
Lamle Freeman et al. Plaintiffs a3. (irsio Processing Corporation. Dcfendnnt Caxe No 498O
Rosenfeld Deposition: May 21315
In the Circuit Court nfthe I7" At JicI 1 Crrcwit, In and For Brrwurd Craunty, Florida Walter Hinton, ct. al. Plaintiff, vs. City of Fart Lauderdale_ F1oride. s Municipality. Defendant.

Case Number CAC'hI 7f1:i+7,R R (2g)
Rosenfeld Llepowition: December 20i 4
In the United States District Coon Western District of Oklahoma Tommy McGarry, et at Plaintiffs, v. Oklahoma City Landfill.. LLt. d'bia Southeast (Jklahorna City I .and1111, et al Defendants
fuze No 5:12-ov-0' 152-C
Rosenfeld 1Deposition• Judy 'I 4
Pant E. Rosenfeld,Pli_D
Page9cal i( Itrac_1IlIu
04-26
Cant.

Page 274 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3021
11942
RTC -1192

Responses to Comments
In the County Courl Of Dallas County Te'tox
"AU Pnrr et aL Plamtr, . v,•. Aruha el al. DOneiawrt
Cuse Number cc- I I41,16?fi-L
Rnsenfukl D eprxi. ik n March and prPml er'_i113
Resenfekl Trial. April 2014
In the Court of Cotttmon Pleas of Tuscarawaa County Ohio John Michael Alucht, at al.. Y]urrrr4 , Republic lierricea.. Inc, et at., drrtt ettg.e Number :,l;ii)$ Cr 14J ti3.41 1i',on, a: o{iray['It' I II 4,987) Rosenfeld Deposition; October 3d1'
In the United States District Court of Southern Diamct cr Terms Galveston Division Kyle Cannon, Eugene Dannvan, (lenarn li mtrez Quo' I Semler. ar,J Harvey Walton, each ltt,Filvidually and on behalf of those atenilarh, seiunted_ vlt-i#,tiffa; vs. BP Products North America_ lac._ Defendant t: rare 3 l i t°-tli9f T
RhsenfeId Deporeiition: February ?i11
IttiMenfeld-r'riel: April 20B
(u the Ca-cuot Court of 13sltirnore Cnuntg Miir�' Iaaad I'hplip F f vaaq, IF et al , Pitt/M/13 vv Tut) Fat ueer [ne. rf +a Po Farrtt,+, Det-enilinfl3 €'nss Number 110-C-12-41124 7 ()T
► oveafetii Nnyition ,,pumber. 2013
04-26
Ccr1t-
Prtut Rmenf kl,PItD
Page10r+I' 1n June _21II9

Page 275 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3022
11942
RTC -1193

Responses to Comments

EXHIBIT C

Page 276 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3023
11942
RTC -1194

Responses to Comments
!MA PE

4.IMIU
— I
. +o:.i P. DM o[+rwr im
Matthew F. Ffagemann, �'. ., C.H., QSI, Q5p
t belt b St.., Suite 201 Santa
Santa Monrci, r'atliornra 90401
Tel: i;:i4yl Ckl7-wJ12.
frri,ail nth, igantTntup, apz.ytrit
Geologic and I lydnogetrlegic Charachrizatlsrn
Industrial Storm w alter Ci iuplivrse
Iiivt tigatinn and ilmediation Strategies
t.ilipatisrn Support and l'eslifving Expert
CEQA Review.

Education',
M.S. Degree, Geology, California State Uni versity Los Angeles. Los Angeles, CA. 19N.

B.A Degree, Geology. Humboldt Stale University, Arcata, CA, 1981 Professional Ccartificationsi
t;.al₹f'rnia Professional Geologist
California Certified Hydrogeologrst
Qualified SWPPI' Developer and I:inttrlilu+ner
I'rutess iunal l .tperience:

Matt has 25 ;years of experience in envlrolurental �w ew Inenr and remediation. TTa spent years with the U.S.EPA in the RCRA end Superfund programs and served as CPA'e Senior Sett.:s_t Policy Advisor to the Wratern Regional Office where he identified enireging threats to groundwater from perchlorato and!ATM While with EPA, Matt also serViAd. as a Senior tivdrogeolcaglsI in theovorstghl of the assessment of seven me.ot military facilities undergoing base closure. He lad numerous enforcement ecllors under provisions of the Resource CoConservatton and Recovery Act (RCRA) while also wort:ins with permit holders to In -Frew hydrogeelegic a haractertm liort and water quality monitoring.

Malt has worked closely with US EPA legal counsel and the Led -mural staff of several stela m the application and enforcement of RCRA, Safe 17rinking 1"1'aier Art and Glean Water Art regulations, Mail has tralnod the technical staff In the Staaaa of California, 1 lawati. Nevada. Arizona and the Teiiitury of Guam in the eorr.-tuct of investigations, grourndwa ter fundamentals, and sampling techniques Posy toms Matt has hold iratltide:
• F riing Partner, Soil! Water/Air Prolocticm [.rate+rprise 1SI APE)(2t3-prksmt). • -eology i retruclor,, Golden West College, 20111- 2014, • Senior Enwtronrani≥ntal Analyst, Komex I-l2O-ScOnce. Inc. ;2LXtl— ?;

Page 277 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3024
11942
RTC -1195

Responses to Comments
• Executive Director, Orange'Cciasl Watch (NCI - NIA);
• Senior S.-lerice Polio ' Advisor and 1- lydrogeoleg4.aL tl s. Enviroarnental Protection Agency (19,99- . • H}€inape�logist. tiali,�nal PRrL Sere lie. 4Valer� nut L ivisiori 19'3FS— Y111}, a Adttmet Faculty Member, San: Slate University, Department of Caos + nOu t1993 - i!3a3t3j;
Instructor, College of ul arin, Departmentof ScicnaCe (1. 0- 1995 l; • Geologist, U.S. Forest Service 1;19 —1'1981; and
▪ t geologist, LJania air Moore (19®.i-1€9t1Ei)
enior Regulatory mid Litigation Support Anal vitah,
With Slitt APE. Matrs responsibilities have mrluded;
• Lead zinalyet and teeLifying expert in the review of over 'LW environmental impact reports strre 3,103 under CEQA tlhatidentity signilicanl issues with regard to ham rdnum waste, water rissiyurerw, water quality, .itr quality, Valley Fay's... greenhouse gas emissions, and gLuk'gc hazards w1ge recommendations for atldlliortal mitigation mea ores lu lead agencies al the local and county level to Include additional characterization of health robs and Implementation of protective measures to reduce worker exposure to hazards from toxins and Valley Fever.
• Stcrmwatii analysis, sampling and best management practice evaluation at industrial facilities. • Manager of a project to provide Lechnic l assistarw,e in a community adjacent to a former Naval shipyard under a. grant from the LI.S. EPA.
• Technical assistance and litigation support for vapor intrusion concerns • Lead analyst and tc tifying expert in the review of environmental Issu,a In licerwe applications for large solar power plants before the Caltfarnra Energy Commission. • Manager of a project lo evaluate numerous formerly used military sites In the western LI • Manager of a comprehensive evaluation of potential sources of perrhlorcte contamination in Southern California driril:i tip, water wells.
• Manager and designated expert for litigation support under provtsi.iin of I'rop ssition 65 in the review of releases of gasoline to s iurcres drinking water at ma Dr refineries and h€uxlreiis of gas stalk -iris throughout California.
• Expert w[trc c on two w7ises involving Mi l7E lati.gahon a Expert witness and litigation support on the impact of air toxins and hazards al a school. ▪ Expert witness in litigation at a former plywood plant_ With l oinr'x IA 2O Science Inc.. Matt's duties included the fallowing. • Senior r author of a report on the extent of pet hlerato contamination that was used in testimony try the former U.S. EPA Administrator and General Counsel. • Servoor raiearclterinthedeeveilo,rrmentoFacomprehensive,elertronicallyuntil-active chronology of MTSE use. rciearch, and regulation.
• Senior researcher in the dovelopmerit of a comprehensive, electranuLally interactive chronalelty of perchl~ rate use, research, and regulation.
• Senior researcher in a study that estimates nationwide crisis for M'1'Bt remedLation and drinking water treatment. results of which were published in newspapers nationwide and In testltmaiy agairst provisions of an energy hill that Would limit liability for oh companies • Research to support lltiy tton Icy restore drinking water supplies that have been contaminated by MTBE in California ,and New 'Yon:.
2 04-27
Cant,
Rage 278 of 548 in Corrm- t HttiA 04
Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3025
11942
RTC -1196

Responses to Comments
▪ Expert w Ltrkss tcstitwny Ina cast -2 of oil rmductloritelatod oanLaintriat tin rn Ml ISSOSIrr * Lead authc+r fora mu7tl-vaauurt remedial investigation report for an operating sched in Los Angeles that met 5trictregalrtory requir.°rnyntsand rigorous de4dlines 04-27
Cant.
3

Page 279 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3026
11942
RTC -1197

Responses to Comments
• Development of strategic approaches for cleanup of contaminated sites In e'onsultattiOit with clients and rel uIato
fx'curise i)irecrnr.

As Executive Director with Orange CoaaSt Watch, Matt Id effort to restore water quality at Orange County beaches from multiple souroa, of contamination including urban runoff and the discharge of wastewater. In ['Toiling to a 3.oarii of Directors that Inetuwlecl represenl.a1kes from leading x;'range County tinivetsiti and bustness , Matt prepared ts,stio papers 10 the areas of trcatrnont and disinfection of wastewater arid control of the duarharge of grease to sewer systems. Matt actively participated in the development of countywide water quality permits for the control of urban runoff and permlis for the discharge of wastewater. Matt worked with other rnorrprafris to protect arid restore water quality, Including Surfrider, Natural Resources Defense Council and Orange County Coastl,eeper well as with busines- Institutions including the Orange County Business Council l-ly"dro fetrlag)'i
As a Senior Hydrogealogist With the U.S Erwtronmental Protection Agency, Mall led investigations lc characterize and cleanup dosing military baste, including Mlare Island Naval Shipyard, Hunters Pella Naval Shipyard. Treasure Leland Naval Station_ Alameda Naval Station laloifktt Field, Matter Arms' +ttrficlit, and Sacramento Army Depot Spedflc actIvItie* were as follows, • I.ed efforts rn model groundwater tow and contaminant rrar_eport, ensured adequacy of mono toning networks, and assessed cleanup alternatives hoe contaminated Wediritent. will, arid grourttwvater
• Initiated a regional program for evaluation. of groundwater sampling practices and laboratory analysis at mtlttary bases.
• Identified emerging tasv , wrote t4rchntcalguidance, and assisted rnpolicy and regulation development through work on four national U.S EPA worl:groups, including the Superfuncl L,roundwaterTechnical Forum and the Federal facilities Forw.n.

At the request of the State of Hawaii lvtatr developed a methodology to determine the vulnerability of groundwater to contamination on the Islands of Maul and Oahu. He used analytical models and a tltti to show zones of vulnerability, and the r tihs were adored. and published by the State of Hawaii arcs Countvof Maui
As a hydrogeologist with the Ft'A 4Tmundwvater Priie-tern Short, Matt worked with provisions of the bate Drinking Water Act and NEPA to prevent dnnktng water contantina Lion Specific activities included the following.
• Received an EPA Bronze Medal for his eiverihudon to the devetq. nierrtof national guidarsai for the protection of drinking water.
• Managed the Foie Source Aquife=r Program and protected the drinking sn'arer of two communitiie through ctesi-nahion under the Safe Drinking ng Waiter Act. lie prepared g olug,ic mars, corcluclec1 Public hearings, and nualxireied iii public turnout fs from residents wul'io were very concerned about rite irriraci of designation.
4 04-27
Ccnt.

Page 280 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3027
11942
RTC -1198

Responses to Comments
• Reviewed a number of Environmental Impact Statements for plrtntted major develcpmenbi. including large hazardous and solid waste disposal facilinw_s, mine r+ atxtation, and water transffer.
[ 1a tt terved as a hydrogeolOgl st with the RCRA Hazardous Waste program. Dutii were as follows:
• cnipervised the hvdruge010gic IirIVOSbpttionof hazardous w asle sites to determine compliance with Statlltle C requirements.
• Reviewed and wrote "part S" perrmts for the dispcsa l of hazardous waste. • Conducted RCF .A Corrective Aether Investigations of waste apes and led inspect' ors that formed the basis for significant enforcement actions that were devidoped in close coordination with td,5, EPA legal counsel
• Wrote contract s ilkalioreis and supervised contractor's Inv€stigations of ve..Bte sites With the National Park Service, Mati direered service -wide investigations of conlarninant sr,urc� to prevent degradation c,f water quality, orsd truing the Following tasks:
• Applied pertinent laws and regulations including CERCLA. RCRA. NEPA, NRDA, and the Clean l Water Act tocontrol military, mining, and landfill contaminants. • Conducted watersliied-scale investiyattirns of ct'ntaniinantsat parks. including Yellowstone and Olympic National Park.
• Identified high -levels of perchlorate in soil adjacent to a national park in New Mexico and advised park superintendent sin appropriate tesponse actions under CERCLA_ • Served as a Park Services representative on the Interagency Perchlorate Steering Committee, a national. workgroup
• Developed a Pia*rant to conduct environmental compliance audits of all Natl rsal Parks white serving on a national weorkgrnup
• Co-authored two papers on the potential for water contamination from the operation of personal watercraft and snowroobi les, these papers serving as the basis for the development of nation- wide policy on the use cif these vehicles in National Parks • Contributed lo the Federal M ul li-Agency Source Water Agreement under titre. Clean Water Action Plan -
Polio:

Served senior management as the Senior Science Policy Advisor with the 11,5. Enw'tronmental Protection Agency, 'Region 9, Activities included the following;
• Advised the Regional Adminisrratorand senior management on emerging issu.=ssuch as the potential for the gasoline additive MTBE and aimnsier,a ie perchlorateto contaminate drinking water supplies
• Shaped EPA's national response to these threats by serving on Iv orkgroups and by contributing to guidance, Including I, he Ofliceof Research and Development put'licatlon, Osy eenates In Water Critical information iuwt Research Needs.
• Improved the technical training of EPA's snentihe and engineering stab. • Earned an EPA Bronze Medal for representing the region's 3Ul scientists and engineers in negotiations with the Administrator and senior management to better integrate srouiitihe principles into the policy -making process
• F3lablisfed national protixxol for the peer review of scientiiiicdncurneits. 5 04-27
Co nt.

Page 281 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3028
11942
RTC -1199

Responses to Comments
Genic ge:

With the LI.S Forest Service, Matt led investigations to determine httl._clopr stability of areas proposed for timber !unrest in the,, ventral Oregon Coast Range.: pectfic activities were as follows • Mapped geolov it the field. and used aerial phi tograp hie interpretation and matherrIaii ai models to determine slope SlabiIlty.
• Coordinated his nasearch with community member_ who ware cetrsarrued with natural resource pro Leah tit,
• Characterized tly geolow of an argil fer that srveaast1iesolesourceofd1ekingwaterfirthe e:itycf Medford: Oregon,
As a consultant with Dances and Moore, Matt .led grr..loglc Investigations of two contaminated sites (later listed on the Superfund NPL) in tha Portland, Oregon, area arid a large hazardous waste site in eastern Oregon. Duties include the tell tiwvi ng:
• Superviseed year -lung effort for'r`tl and grr+ulidwaN7 sampling. ▪ Conducted aquifer teats,
• Inve=tigated aetivefaultsbeneath sibs proposed tor 1xamardouswaste d:ispe l !'cache t:

From 1999CJ t+ J99tk Matt taught at least orte course per semester at the COmmuruty cc,lle e and university levels'
• At San Francisz+ Hate University. sty, held an acifun7 faculty position and taught re'ufle5 environmental iL gv. oceanography raphy (lab and lecture). hyi trigeelc'ggy. arid grOundwatur c ntanwtnaHon
• Served as a 001111111110.7 menlb r for graduate and undergraduate students. • T,augl-tl llYttr5.e5 in erwLrr:'limental geolo yv drib oceanography at the College or Ma.rin.

Matt taught physical geology (lecture and bb and introductory geology it Golden West College in HuntingOn liuich, C'alifnrnia from ?fiii) to 2t114.
}lag•rnxrn, ?i1.k'., "r`C}Ei Disclosure c I-Ilazarilow Waste li.mikas uraJer CI QA . Praerttation to the Public Environmental Law Confemence, Eugene Oregon.

Flagentann, 11.1., 2tk1l}. Disclosure of Hazardous Waste Iisu under CEQA Invited presentation to LIS EPA Rcpsr , 5an Francisco, California.

Hagemann, M F 2lllr, Ltseo?f Electronic Database, in Environmental Regulation, Palmy Making and Public Parttcipatton. Bruwnfields?i)3 Denver. ColraJau.

Ilagernann, MI,F.?i)0#. Perchk'rate Cuntarntnativntf the Colorado River and Impacts to Dunking Water in Nevada and the Ssruthwa#ern U.S. Preseritahon to a meeting of the American groundwater Tribt, Las

5. NV (served onconferenrec1.rg,r ring zorimiittec:).

Iiagemann, M.l'.. ?C1t 4 Invited tesnni ny to a Caabroinia Senaw committee hearing on air'ruins at sehixil, in ecuthern i li.furnia, Los Angeles.

O4-27
Cc nt,

Page 282 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3029
11942
RTC -1200

Responses to Comments
Brown A., Farrow, J., Cray, A and l lagirntan:n, M., 2004_ Art Estimate of Costs to Address MTBL• Releases from Underground Storage Tanks and the Resulting Impact to Drinking Water Wells Prr nlaunn t4 the lround Water and R.nviTowne ntal Law Coe Cerenc> , National G round wager 1�9�eatIL+ri
1Iagenrann, M:F., 2(O1 Perchlorate C.ontarotnalion of the Colorado River arid impacts to Drinking Water in Arizona and the Sciuth+t'estern 11.5. Presentation to a rneeling of the American Groundwater ater Trout, I'hc ritir, AZ (served can i•confo.enLe organ' Ting committee) Hagemann, .tl_F_, Via Perchlorate L-L?ntanatriatitm or the Colorado River and Impacts to Drink ins Water in the Southwestern US, invited pri."'SetitabDO to a special oarrtlnittee muting of the Nattotw1 Aomdo_itry of Sciences, lrvtna, CA.

Hatgenrann, M.F., x113. Perchlorate Contamination of the Colorado River invited presentation to a tribal. ERA meeting, Pechanga, CA
Hagernano* MJ ., 21x3 Perchlorate Coniamtna1Jonof the Colorado River lnvi led presentation tip a meeting of tribal repesentalives, Parker, AZ.

Hagenrann, II1.F., 2L11i'1 Impact of Perchlorate on the Colorado Diver and Associated Priming Water Suppbes- Invited presentation to the Inter -Tribal Meeting. Tom Martinez Ttile.

Ilagemann, r,l:r., :.0F3. The Emerge a of Prrrhl.vrate as a Widespread Dnnkang Water Contain mint. invited presentation to the U.S. EPA Region 9.

I I ag noon, h1J• - 2LLt3 A D,edurbve Approach to the Assesarnent of P; rillikrate Contamination Invited presents Il.}n to the CaliforniaAssembly Natural Resources Comrrittee.

Hagemann,M.F,2[LkT Perchlorate ACold War LeggywDrtnkrr ,Water Prr.;entattontoameeting of the National GrauinlwaterAssL lation.
1l agemann, M.F., 21XJ From Tank to Trap: A Chronologyof Milli in Groundwater. Presentation to a trw'ctin;g i1f the National Groundwater Assaclatiun_
Flagernacm, l4i,F., 2,Xta. A Chronology of tr{TSE In GroundwahA and rtn Estimate of Cents to Add riNs Intpaccts to Groundwater Presentation to the annual meeting or the Sooctety of Environmental Journal isi s
Hagemann, h1.F.. 2001 art Lstiinate of the Cast to Addre≤s ht YLIE, CenI rnirarion in Groundwater (anil 'Alto 'V1°iid Pay) Presentation to a meeting of the National Groundwater Association.

I-lagcrnann, Nth, 2L1 An EStimato of CoSt., t,;'uldrrets'a1TElE Reltasin from Urtdageaund Storage 'Tanis and the Resulting Impact to Drinking Water Wells. Presentation to a meeting of the U.S. EPA and Sate Underground Storage Tank Program managers
Hagetnata, li1,F., rLIL11• From Tank to Tap; A C_hrLiitolog>y of MTEHE In Groundwater Unpublished repast
7 O4-27
Cant,

Page 283 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3030
11942
RTC -1201

Responses to Comments
Illag. :+rin, M.g., 2LIJi. Estimated Cleanup Cost for MTBE in Groundwater Usod a5 Drinking Water.

L:npubl[shed report
Iagernann, M.F'., 2Ci01. Estimated Costa to Asidrffs MiT111. I etea; from Leaking L Inderground Storage' Tanya Unpublished report
HagCnunn, AI,F„ and 4ranhlotrwwerik, M., 1950. Potential Water Quality Concerns Related to Snowmobile Usage. 1l raaterllecntircep Piy r;itNrt National Park riervice. Technical Report. k'ariMouwerhk, M. and Hagentann, "w•I.I 1999, Water Qutrllty Concerrs Related to Persona! Watercraft Osage. Water Res* grew Dtvisicn, National Park ervic€. Technical Report Flagenrann, Sit , 11)99. 1s Dilution the Solution i - Pollution in National Parks? f he Ueorge Wright -citify Biannual Meeting,, Asheville, North Carolina
Hagerman, M.F, 1737. The Potential rot MTBE to C ntaiswirvate Groundwater. U.S. EPA Stperfttnd Groundwater Technical Forum Annual Meeting, I as Vegas. Nevada.

Hagcxn:inrt, hi.F: and Gill,. M. 1996, Impediment: to InLriruik Remediath-'n. M.iiffelt Field Naval Air Station, Conierence on Intrinsic Rcmediatinn.nt Chlorinated Hydrocarbons. Salt I ke-City Flagernann, A.i.F'., l ukunaga, G- L., 191)6, The Vuilnerabilitytaf l•Gnxindwvater to Aniluopagenic ConLarntna.nI ore the Island of Maul, . Hawaii Hawaii Water Works Association A.nrtual Meeting, Maui, October 1996.

I -I atgentann, M. F., FuLwnaga, C. L„ 1'996, Ranking Groundwater Vulnerability in Central Oahu.

I-ia++aii Proceedings, Go3gralhic Info+tnrttron 5)N:terms in Environmental ResoUrOeS. Management, Air and S"r" s4te Management A suoiatron Publication VIP -6L Ilagcntann, A^t.F., 1994. Gnasonlwater CharacLertzalion anti Cleanup at Closing Military Bases in California. Prctc tin ,CaltforniaGrouudwaaterResources.rUsuciatlun Meeting.

Hagman*. M.P. arc] Sabol, M.A., 1991 Role of the L.S. EPA in thi2 1110 Plains Shatec t;rsrurrdsw'atu7 Recharge Demonstration Program Proceeding. Sixth Biennial Symposium on the Artificial Recharge tar Groundwater.

I Iageataran, M.I , 1993, LI5. EPA Policyon the Technical Impracticability of the Cleanup of DNAPL- c.aantamrrrated 4kundwater_ California Groundwater Resources A.tsociat.ion Meeting. 04-27
Cont.

Page 284 of 54 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3031
11942
RTC -1202

Responses to Comments
Hagen- M F . 1992 Dense Nranatueat Phase Liquid Cuntaminittlon Of Grouncluiater An Ounce of Prevention .. I'ro-x dings, Association or Engineering Cleolcigists Annual Meeting, v. 35. pHitt twerience4
lecre+i =ub3ect m-atx r expert foi- the t"aIitonlia (Professional C olegist licensing examination. 2.0133- 2011.

Page 285 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3032
11942
RTC -1203

Responses to Comments
EXHIBIT Il

Page 286 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3033
11942
RTC -1204

Responses to Comments
Transit Noise and Vibration Impact
Assessment Manual

FEDERAL TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION
U.S. Depar,nnent o} Trangpartctl©rt
Federal Transit Adminlsircldcn
SEPTEMBER 2018
PTA Report No. 0113
Federal Trial slL Ariminlstraal ii

PREPARED BY
Jahn A Volpe'NatIrn4l TrxnspnrrAtInn Systems Center
04-28

Page 287 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3034
11942
RTC -1205

Responses to Comments
04-28
Cont.

COVER PHOTO
Courier? of Edwin &imn Rodrrktuez Federal YrartisrtAdrnrrnktraion DISC L MEli
This document is Inseminated under the sporooi * a f the 1J.S. nepornnern of Trampartatwan rn the raterest of in prnk1thn ea' 'rouge The LIh&ed States Gnrrernroent rrssuntes nc tlaLnrl Cy far ixs coritorwts or at* _awed( The [oiled Stares Coverrrwrmfl does not endorse products or manufacture -is. Trade or mane ucarrxas' names appear herein sade♦y because they are considered immoral to the objecthie of that report ii

Page 288 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3035
11942
RTC -1206

Responses to Comments
Transit Noise and
Vibration Impact
Assessment Manual
SEPTEM8ER 2018
FTA l#ep4rt Na. O123
PR.EPARED BY
Antoinette Q+aagliata
Federal Transit Administration,
Office of Planning and Environment
Meghan Ahern
Eric . oeker
Christopher Roof
John A. Volpe National Transportation
Systems Center
Cambridge. MA02142
Lance Meister
Herbert Singleton
Cross Spectrum Acoustics
East Longmeadow, MA 01428
Uah: Salt Lake City. LIT 84142

SPONSORED RY
Federal Transit Administration
Office of Planning and Environment
Department of Transparla�&n
I2f 1 New jersey Avenue,. SE
Washington, DC 20594
04-28
Cant.
il1

Page 289 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3036
11942
RTC -1207

Responses to Comments
Maeric Gin Tatar
k el MgtMICU CO M' *Ar r Pr
sum
a.,
1•+.r
Orr
_ ""rte "I"
7 It
1 OhOWNI
11 Y: maws,
Ali tna up,.
011 .# wet*1
04-28
CCnt..
apilmr ONO
von 6014041ur
Wirt ao1vva rafts iM 731: i rtillM Own rI vn
=Pr law
i
4101
Orel We 0442) 44
ism• .1.64n4 rrrh
11114.144•00041040
t'dro+srt
4r 0 foul
+'M

Page 290 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3037
11942
RTC -1208

Responses to Comments
From kip 0.61B Ni)
I}1 a sa
the pee mpordni etedcn ter ads tellaadan•at iriorme:Ios ia'Mimared o axiom a Ma per eespeme. Irctrlet she ame far merman iaverern starching mew( den rearm, ladair,i sad msnerrina the deb needed add endee a ofd 'Wareing the wtecem of kt2naeeen.-Send manner* ngdhi VIII ba+dei ertamle er e f Man Wet&0114 OtltM?Onselai.:nillOn k,dv,.% SUMMON rar ndvart IN txrdan t4 Detwe,,,S ii Diervt, Watks'et>rnrfnaiat'arta+a$arra k ce-reaer ler Irdnrrven.

Opere ae and Rwsrrtr t1)104 -01M. 1215 f elenap Deal H¢w+i'. SAte I3'J4 Ariritm, VA IVIM-4301. Rorpaevla,re dic6d kw sine Net rrcwmhhrdrel MI oti, pi -maw of Ian no parlor. shall Rc eke:v. Mr.9' mate far Faig sa cempiy»Ul a sdknsm ofWdamneOng It don not ds(.1erasarendpmkt OMsem-ilmmhe PLEASE DONUT RETtN YOUR FORM T8 THE ABOVE ADORlS&

I, REPORT DATE
September Z0IS

2. REPORT TYPE
Final

3. DATES COVERED
4_ TITLE AND SUBTITLE
Transit Nola* mild Vibration, Impact Assessment llavinal Si CONTRACT NUMBER
SE. GRANT NUMBER
Sc PROGRAM ELEMENT
NUMBER
A. AU T )
Qdagllata, Antoinette (FTA)
Ahearn. Mewl iVO PE1
Bneiver, Erk VOL )( NE
Roo[ Christopher 1}'OLPQ
Meister, Canna (GSAi
Singleton, Herbert CSA)
- .RoieerNUMISER
TF49A I
Say. TASK NUMBER
NLJSe
Si WORK UNIT NUMBER
7, PERFORMING ORGAN[ rZATlON NAME(S) ANO AODIRESS(ES)
415 Department ulTransportatma
Volpe rrhtfesul Transportation Systems Center
SS Broadway
Cambridge. PIP d2I42
& PERFORMING

ORGANIZATION REPORT
NUMBER
FTA Report No, 0123

9. SP(SNSORINGfrONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 41,S Department sal Transpirrtuaan
Federal Transit Adminhtratbn
Office c.4 Planning said Erarh onnneclt
1$00 Now Imam/ Arenoq S.E.

Vdashitgton. DC X)3,90
1 0. SPONSORIMONITOR'S
ACRONYMkS)
FTA
I, SPOI+lSc7RlM€ t'1IT i'S

NUMBER(S)
ETA Repeat No. 0123

12. DISTIVERITIONIAVAILAsiLlTY SYATEMEN7
This document is tentillble di lough the FTA webslte Ilttgewam,Ira,dotgart, I3, SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
L. ABSTRACT
This report is the third edition of a guidance manner Oft,* Maned of I946. It includes clarifications to edging paltry and updates to au [dated reference where applicable. Topics presented rn this maroisal Include procedures for lnreitaeting and assessing noise and elhratiorr imparts ul proposed tratsat projects for different stages of project deve%panein and different levels of irulysis, Additional topics hrclede destHptlans cf Hake and vibration Indlgauon meatuses, construction noise and vibration, and 1 -ow to preserve these analgases In the Federal Transit Adreari tuatlon's env eronmentaldxuments, Thls guidance Fs for technkar specialists who conduct the analyses, as well as project sponsor stall, Federal agency rerive'read and one Where. rrl the general public who may be affected by the projects.

FS.. SLFBjECT PERMS
Transit raise and vibration analysis. noise and vibration imprt cr le:ra mew and vibration m irigation me,mµrm enailanmerrtal impact mammanen, Nation Environmental' Pokey Acs compliance_
I6. $ECURITI CLASSIFICATION OF
I7-

LIMITATION
Of

ABSTRACT
It.

NUMBER

OF PAGES
3Sy
I9a< NAME OE RESPONSIBLE PERSON
- REPORT
Untleseihed
h, ABSTRACT
tleelMeiinal
t:. THIS
PAGE
Ur.clasailod
Pit, TELEPHONE NUMBER
licrilde area wale)
V
04-28
Cont

Page 291 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3038
11942
RTC -1209

Responses to Comments
Tabie of Coro I i I
SECTION I: INTRODUCTION .................. �..............�...... .......... ................... . i I . I PURPOSE_........:_::...:_::......:,�......,....._...» I.2 .ORGANIZATION OF THE I AN AL::.., W . .,...... W.,..,... ., . .w W . .,..,... ., 2 SECTION 2: PROJECT CLASS OF ACTION AND PLANNING »,.».»..»... ..»....3

2.I PRcijEC:T CLA4S OF ACTION ..,....:..::._......... ....:........:.....:............. . . ...0 . ..... w.,.,..W 4. .......: 3

2.2 PROJECT PLANNING AHD DEVELOPMENT.._::.. .:4
2,3 MITIGATION FOLIO CC SIDER,ATIONS,.,..-:.......:..... .. ,., ., _ . ..,.,.:5 SECTION3: TRANSIT NOISE..,........,,.... »....,.... ,.......... ,........•........»., ». ,.., »,,..»,»...9

3. I NOISE METR:FGS
Ira

3.3 PATHS Of TRANSIT NOISE FROM SOURCE TO RECEIVER. ...„ I4

3.4 RECEIVER RESPONSE TO TRANSIT IG
SECTION 4: NOISE IMPACT ANALYSIS ................................ ...... I9

4. I DETERMINE NOISE IMPACT CRITERIA .:..... .. ..... _ _._._, ... _ ...._ ... _.._,......20 Stepd: ddenti-h, Print Type -.-._. ..,.,,._....e._, . .r...:...... ._._ .__.,...,..,..... ... ._._ .... ....... ...._. .... ....-...2 f Step 2: Choose Lend Use Category far FTA rfo _ __ . ...:.23 Step 3: Determine Appn prirste FTA Criteria .._,. �._...:.23

4.2 IDETERmitiE NOISE ANALYSIS LEVEE ....:,... _..,. 31

4.3 EVALUATE IMPACT: NORSE SCRIMPING PROCEDURE .........: ..... ,..:..:....... .,.,......_ 33 Step I: Identify Project Type 33
Step 2: Determine the Screening bistarx 33
Step 3: Identify Study Area: .::.34
Step 4: Lc true Noise.Sensflive Lund Uses__,_.._ .............. _. _,_ .,..........,..,. __...,.....,_.:..._._._.._._...........34

4.4 EVAALUATEIMPACT: GENEPALNOISEASSESSMENT _ 37
Step 0: Identify Noise-Scnsitfre Receivers 38
Step 2: Determine Project None Source Reference LevefS,Y.___ ._,_. _. 39 Step 3: Estimate Project Nose &post:re try Distance.. ..,..,_._.o,r_._._ . ...._....W__ Ww_. .,48 Step 4• Combine Noise Exposure from Ail Sources..................._,_,_._:__,:_..,._._._:_......,....:....__,._.........,,.,49 Step 5: Estimate Existing Noise Exposures._,_—_,...__
Step 6: Inventory Eloise Impacts,_:.._.._.._.__.__._._._.... _._ _.__.__ ___._.:,::_...52 Step7: Determine Noise Mitigation Needs .:W:.: :.,:d.........: : : :e: :.:: ::::: :.::aw........::.::.::.:: _:_:_:_:..:..:::::34

4.5 EVALUATE IMPACT: DETAILED NOFSE ANALYSIS .:... .:.,, ...:.64 Step i.!denmi&NoiSe-Sensnrrnf#ereiwers....,_,........................_._,_,..,.......,.................,.:,.., _,.,,_:_:.,..,.,... r6 Step 2: Delerrndne Project Noise Source Reference f_eveds:__.__:_ ._._...._. _.__._.-.-.._.:_:.____.....7A Step 3: Determine Propagation Characteristics ___................._._..__:_._._._...._e._.._:._.._._.._._._.._._:_;_.....84 Step4: Combine Noise Exposure from Ni Sources .................._,..,_:..:.::..,.....,:_,.:.,.:..,.:,..,....,.....,..,.....:......,... 91 Step 5: Determine F.xstingNorse Exposure 92
Step b: Assess Nokte dmpoct....__ .

Step 7: Determine Noise MitigationMeasteres._..._,_.._.._.___-__._.e._.n_.._ 47 SECTION 5: TRANSIT VIBRATION ...,... ,..., »,.. ..»....., 109

5.I GROUND -BORNE VItRATION AND NOISE METRICS ,..,..„ .,„. . .„ .....;..,.,_............: 110

5.2 SOURCES OF TRANSIT GROUND -BORNE VIBRATION AND NOISE..:....,.« ..... .... ........._,... . .:., 112

5.:3 PATHS OF TRANSIT GROUT BORNE VIBRATION AND NOISE. ..... ..... . ............................... .. .. I I6 vi
04-28
Cont.

Page 292 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3039
11942
RTC -1210

Responses to Comments

5.4 RECEIVER FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE GROUt-ID-BORNEVIBRATION AND I I7 5,5 HUMAN RESPONSE To TRANSIT GROUNO-noRNE VIIRATION AND Nom., .. .. .. . ...A., .,.,,..,. 117 SECTION 6: VIBRATION IMPACT ANALYSIS .... ..,.. I2I

6.1 DETERMINE VIBRATION ANAL'fSIS LEVEL —, ...m .,.......__.. ...,... �r. Iii 6,2 DETERMINE VIBRATION IMPACT CRrTERLA _ .. .._.. .................... .... .. _ . ... 123 ()pain A. General Vibration Assessin nt COrerira _,_, ,.,,.,,,, m,,,,,,,,,,,,,,_..._.. ,.,.,,.,,, d 23 Stepd: Lard Use Categries,.... ................_...,.._,.......,...,....,..._._,.,,.., ......_,_ _ ,..,_,.,....,..... r23 Step 2: lien . Event Frequeriey J 23
Step 3: dtnpact. Criteria by Land Use and Event Frequency-._...._._......_._._.__._ ................_.._._. d 23 Option 8: Vibraltron impact Criteria fur a Desaifed Vibration Analysis ,,,,,.,,.,_,.,,_, ,__, 30 Step2: Gxatrrid-home Noise n...._ ................— a_,..,,...,...,..._,_. , ,....,. ,..._. , . ._,.,.....,..,., 1.32

6.3 EVALUATE IMPACT: VIBRATION SCREE.NNtr 132
Step d: Clus 0 project vehicles d33
Step 2: Determine Prryect Type.,......_, ._..__,_,_,_ _.:.. ._:u,_._._,..,..._...... J34 Step 3: Determine 5icrceiling Miaow ................... ..,..,.,.. ......._, ,..,....._,..,..,. .......,.....,..... ,.., ,.,.. .,,..,., r3S Step 4: ddenaiht Vibrceian-Se+r Um( tJres_.. . ............ ....-,—_._.. ..,,_..,,__.._,._....,..,.,.,,, ..._.__..-.._._,.. dad

6.4 EVALUATE IMPACT: GENERAL VIBRATION AssEs5MENT..,==,.,., W __._.,.. I. 36 Step d: Select Bake Curve for Octant Surface Vibration Lever „_. ,_, _._,..... J36 Step2: Apply Ajjtrstmerars . . .. . ....:..........._.,, ,.,,....,,_,..,.,.. ..._..,..,,..,,,..,..._ ___...._,..,,_. . ,__._,.,..,..,...,- d39 04-28 Step 3: Inventory of Vtbrcr ion trnpa?¢.m, m_. ....:: _ .: M_ . ......,m., _ . ._m,_..,. i47 Ccrit. 63 EVALUATE IMPACT: DETAILED VIBRATION ANALYSIS 449
Step d: araracterrze Existing Vibration Conditions d 49 Step 2. iE.stirrrate Vibration Impact '152
Step 3: Assess Vibration dmperce _......................_.._, ....... .m. ._m :.,.,-.._..-..-._, ._..-. . , : . . . .. .-,.,.. d 65 Stepp 4: Determine Vibration Mitigation i 65
SECTION 7: NOISE AND 'VIBRATION DURING CONSTRUCTION..... ... ...... ........... 172

7.I CONSTRUCTION INOISE ASSESSMENT ........ .................... . ...... ......... ................... ......... ....._................ ..,., 172 Step d : Determine ,[ eved mF Cans-Lnuc iara Name Asscssriraettl ..-. —_ _................._ d 73 Step 2: Use a chtaitatine Carrsrruttdon Noise Assessment to E3 jute CoAstructio Noise ..... ..... d 74 Step 3: Use a 'Quantitative Construction Noise Assessment to Estimate Construction ,Noise ..,......, . 74 Step 4: Assess Construction Noise Impact._,_, ._.... ..,.,,.,.._ _. ._,.,...., d 78 Step 5 Determine C®nstsucainn Noise Ai/vow filetacmes___• ..,. ....-._.._ _ d 79

7.2 CONSTRICTION VIBRATION ASSESSMENT._.._.. ...... ........... _ .... ..__..... _...... -.__ _...._ _. I E2 Step d: Determine Level of Construction VibrationAssessment.___.___....._._._._.._.._._................_._._. d 82 Step 2: Use a Quca4totive COnStniction Vibration Assessment ._ ,d ................_, ,_,._,.,,.,, ,.,,..,__ v„ d 93 Step 3: L✓€e aQuantitative Construction Vibration Assessment _..... .. ................_._._................,..,... _..., d83 Strp 4: Rssr ss Caraslreectmn Vibrdxran impend _................ d&S Step S: Determine Construction Vibration Mitigation Meargtrrs__................................................._.__.. d86 SECTION 8: DOCUMENTATION OF NOISE AND VIBRATION ASSESSMENT,.......... I8R 8 ! ENVI NMNEN'rA.L DOCUMENT _,..,....._. .:. ..,_. �.., .:. ..,_. .,..,... _.., .:. ...., r'4 t Step d: Choose the information to IntLtdt d89
Step 2: Organize information in the fnvrronrnenaad Document. . d 90 8,2 TE;CHNuc t 1 EryKT ON NOISE AND VII3P ,taON 192
vii

Page 293 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3040
11942
RTC -1211

Responses to Comments
APPENDIX A G LOSSARY OF TERMS 195
APPENDIX B FUNDAMENTALS OF NOISE ... .............. ........... 200 B.I AMPtITUDE m .,,....,.. . .,,., ... 200
B.I.I DECIBEL 201
B,1.2 FREQUENCY 248
B,1.3 TIME PATTERN , ..,.., . <.,.,.A..,9.< . ,w .P < < A, .,,_,. . .. . 20$ R.1.4.1 A -WEIGHTED SOUND LEVEL THE BASIC NOISE UNIT... ,,.y.,._ W _....-. 206 B.1.4.2 MAXIMUM SOUND LEVEL {L .. } DURING A SINGLE NOISE EVENT ... . .......... . 207 f 1.4.3 SOUND ExPosLIRE LEVEL {SEL): EXPOSURE FROM A SINGLE NOISE EVENT .208 EQUIVALENT SOUND LEVEE a1 ..... ...:..... ..................... ...:..... .... ....... ..:. .:... .... .... 210 a 1.4,5 DAY -NI T SOUND LEVEL {L-..}: 24 -HOUR EXPOSURE PROM ALL EVENT. „. .. .. . 214 APPENDIX C BACKGROUND FOR TRANSIT NOISE IMPACT CRITERIA .....:.............217 C. I RELEVANT LITERATURE,,.. .... ....... ...................... ......., ...,..,....,. ... .. .... .. . .,....,. . .. ..... ... .,... 217 C-2 BASIS FOR NOISE IriPACTTCRITERIACURk+fS.-.-...... , ....... ....,....... 218 C-3 EQUATIONS FOR NOME IMPACT CAITERIA CURUEs........... __.......... __.... ._......... __... ,-__..... -...... ________ 219 APPENDIX D CLUSTERING RECEIVERS of INTEREST...... .. ........... .........................221

APPENDIX E DETERMINING EXISTING
APPENDIX F COMPUTING SOURCE LEVELS FROM MEASUREMENTS ,229 F. I HIGHWAY AND RAIL VEHICLE P .sEIrs 229
F.2 STATIONARY SOLACES 233

APPENDIX G NON-STANDARD MODELING PROCEDURES
AND METHODOLOGY .............. .. 237
04-28
Ccnt

Page 294 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3041
11942
RTC -1212

Responses to Comments
List of Figures
Figure3-1 Source.PatfraeeeiverFrain e out ................ e.....,.......,,.,,......., e...... .. .,..,, ..... e...............9 Figure 3-2 Sound Level Dependence on Speed 12
Figure 3-3 Attenuation Due to Distance 15
Figure 3-4 Atteriiradon due to Soft Ground. __,..- ��.. _. __._e lS Figure 3-5 Noise Barrier Geometry 16
Figure 3-6 Comm amity Reaction to New Noise, Relative to Existing Noise in a Residential Urban Environment.,,,,.,,,..,..,,.,,,,,...,,,,.,.,.,,,,.,,., . ..... ... .....„.,......,..,. .,. ,R ...,, .,..,..,,..,. .,. ....,...N .,.., 18 Figure 3-7 Cnmmurity Amayance Due eo Noise 18
Figure 4- I Noise Impact Criteria Flow Chart by Project Figure4.2 Noise Impact Criteria for Transit Proierts...........................,.................,..............,. 27 Figure 4-3 Increase in Cumulative Noise Levels Allowed by Criteria (Land Use Cat. 1 2 3ip Figure 4-4 Increase in Cumulative Noise Levels Allowed by Criteria (Land Use Cat Figure 4-5 Procedure for General Norse Assessment .-..._m ...__.e____ -.__m ....

Figure Curs far Estimating Exposure vs_ Distance in General Noise Assalsrrtent .........

Figure 4.7 Noise Impacts of Hypothetical Commuter Rail 57 Figure 4-8 Example of Project for General Noise Assessment; Siting of Transit Center in Mixed CommercralfReselential Area-.-._._....__..__..._ _..____.._..__..__...____...__......__..__...__--- _....64 Figure 4-9
Figure 4.OOi Guide to Selecting Noise Sensitive Receivers of Interest. _ m. _. n . _ 67 Figure 4- l I Flow Diagram for Determining Project Noise at 50ft..m, - .,,.,..,.. , .,.:,w,., .w. ,.,,70 Figure 4.12 Flat Ground,.

Figure 413 Source in Shallavv Gut_ B6
Figure 414
Figure 4-15 Source in Sloped Cut..., _ ... m m.,.: _ ... T R6 Figure 4'16
Figure 4-17
Figure 4-19
Figure 4.19 Recommended Microphone Locations for Eidsting Noise Measurements ...... ............ ....,..93 Figure 5-1 Promotion of Ground -Bonne "Vibration into Buldings..... ..... ..... ..._.,,,..,,... .,, I t!9 Figure 5-2 Vibration Signal in Absolute Units.., .,. ,,.,-.. ,, _..,..-,... w . .., P. , w ..,.., ., , 1 I I Figure 3.3 Vibration Signal Lri RMS Velocity Decibels......_ ...... . .. .... _........., 112 Figure 5.4 Typical Levels of Ground-Uorr Vibration ..... ,.... .......W.... . .. ........., I 13 Figure 5-5 Response to Transit -Induced Residential Vibration ......w. 19 Figure 6-1
Figure 6-2 Criteria for Detailed Vibration Analysis... „ .. _.- 131 Figure 6-3 Flow Chart of Vibiatiori Screening Pi o€€ss....,.... .. .. .. ..... ..... ... ...W_. .,.,. ..... ., 133 Figure 6-4 Generalized Ground Surface Vibration Curves .......... ............ 137 Figure Cry Ground -Borne Vibration and Noise Model n,,,, m 154 Figure 6-6 Typical Force Densitlm frar Rail Transit Vehicles, 4{7 mph 157 Figure 6-7 Typical Force Densities for LRT Vehicles. 40 rnph ..._„__._,__ _ _ _„,,.e__.... _,._.-_ ..._ -.....__. I 57 Figure 6.6 Test Configuration for Measuring Transfer Mobility ........ ........... . ............. . : . 15$ Figure 6-9 Example of Point -Source Transfer Mobility 159 Figure B -W Equipment Required for Field Testing and Laboratory Analysis 169 Figure 6-11 Analysis of Transfer Mobility ..._._._.______..._______..._._..____...________-__..____,______________ 161 Figure 6.12 Schematic of Transfer Mobility I leasurernFnts Using a Li ne oil Impacts ..... 16 2 Figure 6.13 Example of Llne-source Transfer Mobility ..................... ......... .. .. ......... .... .. . l63 Figure 4.14 Foundation Response for Various Types of Buildings „.,. n o....,. I64 Figure R -I
Source and Receiver Seiaarated by
is
04-28
Cant

Page 295 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3042
11942
RTC -1213

Responses to Comments
Figure B-2 Graph far Approximate Decibel Addition u d: 202 Figure B-3 Noise Spectrum of Transit Train on Curve and Dented Structure ..... .. .. . ...A., ... , 204 Figure B -S Typical A -weighted Sound Lames , m ..,,..,.._,-..- .., 207 Figure B-6 Typical Transit -Vehicle Passby w.,,..W...Y.....m. ..a.................Y.....m- .,... .......,..............._:___:....:. 2C8 Figure R-7 Typical FIxced,FacllityNokc+e Event 208
Figure B -B An Energy Vice of Noise Events . .. ........ .:.. 210 Figure B-, Typical Hourly L irrr's,..,,.,..,,.....,. .m........... ...... ..... .... ........... .. ..._........ .... . .... ........... .....- 21 Figure B -I0 Example A -weighted Srurtd Level Tune Histor es ____._._...---._._.......... ..... 212 Figure R -I I Typical Lens ., . 214
Figure D -I Example of Receiver Map Showing Ckreter Boundaries .............. .......................r,-.....,.—.,. 224 • I i !
s+t

Page 296 of 548 ends

Ritz -Carlton Rancho Mirage MND
November 2024
3043
11942
RTC -1214

Responses to Comments
List of Tables
Table 3-I Noise M€trics......,.....,..... .. . ....,......:. .. .... _ 10 Table3.2 Sources of Transit Noise............................... .. ... ............._ ...... ...,............,...,._,.. ... ..., 13 Table 44 Multlmodal Project Noise Factors
Table 4-2 Muffin -modal Project Assessment Methods.._ ..............._....._.__ ._ ..._._. _.._ ___._ ____._____ _.._ L2 Table 4-3 Land Use Categories and Metric for Transit. Noise Impact Criteria ..... ........ ... .... ....W.,.,23 Table4-4 Levels of Impact......................................................................... ...........,......,......„e... 2ya Table 4-5 Noise Levels Defining Impact for Transit Projects , , 2B Table 4b Noise Impact Criteria: Effect on Cumulative Noise Exposure Table 4.7 Screening Distance for NoiseAsssisments...... ......................... ... . _........ . _.., . ., 35 Table 4.0 Assumptions for Scfexenirg Distances for Noise Assessments......_..,...., 36 Table 4-9 Reference SEL's SO ft from Track and at 50 mph, One Vehicle 40 Table 414 Computation of Noise Exposure at 50 k for Fixed -Guideway General Noise Assixsment 42 Table 41 I Source Reference Levels at 50 It from Roadway. 50 mph _._ --._....______.._..___.__.._.....___.___ 43 Table 4-12 Computation,7f 4aidl and Ld,at 50 ft for MighwrayfTransit General Noise Assessment__,44 Table 4-13 Source Reference Levels at 54 ft From the Center of Site, Statuary Sources ..... ........., 45 Table 4-14 Computation of L,4Hie) and Le„ at SO ft for Stationary Source General Noise Assessment47 Table 4-I S Distance Correction Factor Equations for General Noise Assessment__ ......

Table 4-I6 ComputingTotalNoise Exposure ..

Table 4-I 7 Estimating Existing Noise Exposure for Gerd Nome Assessment........ ...:..........._.:o......., 52 Table 4-10 Land Uses of Interest 613
Table 419 Sources of Transit Noise 71
Table 4-20 Source Reference c at 50 ft: Fixed-Guldevvvay sources at SO mph_ W _._W___ __._ _73 Table 42I Computation of J- ',to and 1a, at 50 ft: Faced -Guideway Sources ..__. �. ....__._.._.7fi Table 4-22 Source Reference SELs at 50 ft Highw+ayfTransit sources at 50 mph..._.... . ...., .. 78 Table 423 Computation of LeKikl, and Ld, at 50 Fr HighwayfTr it Sous ........ ... ... . .... 6G Table 4-24 Source Reference SELs at 50 ft Stationary Source .... ............_._ . ,....r., _ .., ._W . __ :82 Table 4-25 Computation of Lirlio and Ld, at 50 it: Stationary S.xree _.._._. _......,., . .. _ B3 Table 4-26 Ground Factor G, for Ground Attenuation ..... ............. . .. .W_....... . ..... .... .. .W_....... ......... B6 Table 4-27 Distance Correction Factor Equations for Detailed Noise Analysis B7 Table 428 I3rrier I rrsertirxn Loss,. �,..,.,... .,
Table 4-29 Attenuation due to 6urding<c _ B9
Table 430 Attenuation due to Trees
Table 43l Calctriate Ld o, Ls i a .................... _... ....., .. . . ... _... ,..... .. . . .......... 9I Table 4-32 Computing Total Noise Exposure A ,.:, .:... ...: ..... ..:. .:. ,.91 Table 4-33 Transit Noise Mitigation Measures - Source Tre3tmerrts. .. ... ,,._..... n.,,.,..,.,.,— .... -, 97 Table 4-34 Transit Noise- i°litigatioor, Measures - Path Treatments .._....., . ..b_._..m. 104 Table 435 Transit Noise Mitigation Measures - Receiver Treatments ....... .. ... ...... .. ...............w....... lfyb Table 5-I Ground -borne Vibration and Norse Metrics _ 114 Table S-2 Factors that Influence Levels of Ground -Bone Vibration and Noise at the Source.,.. —n,. 114 Table 5-3 Factors that Influence Levels of Ground -borne Vibration and Noise along the Path -_.___. 117 Table 5.4 Factors that Influence Levels of Ground -Borne Vibration and Noise at the Receiver....... 117 Table 5-5 Human Response to Different Levels of Ground -Borne Vibration and Noise,...,.,...W.—... [20 Table 6-I Land Ilse. Categories for General Vibration Assessment Impact,Criteria I24 Table 6-2 Event Frequency Definitions l2S
Table 6-3 Indoor Ground -Borne Vibration (GeV) MCI Ground -Borne Noise (GBN) Impact Criteria for General Vibration Assessment I26
Table 6-4 Indoor Ground -Borne Vibration and Noise Impact Criteria for Special Buildings f 26 xi
04-28
Cont_

Page 297 of 54 ends
← All documents from this meeting