Cities Index.
Minutes, regular meeting, second session

Bakersfield City Council
November 4, 2026

Document
Minutes, regular meeting, second session
Meeting
November 4, 2026
Body
Bakersfield City Council
Pages
223
Original file
413.1 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on pub-bakersfield.escribemeetings.com. That file is the official record.

MM AQ-1 Prior to issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall enter into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) to mitigate regional air quality impacts associated with emissions of VOC and NOX generated by operation of the proposed project. At minimum, the VERA shall be crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department (City), that verifies, to the City’s satisfaction, completion execution of the VERA.

Section 4.4 Biological Resources

Page 4 ends

The Project Site consists primarily of non-vegetation and is entirely categorized as a disturbed ruderal area habitat type with paved sidewalks along the edges. The Project Site also consists of unvegetated roadways and some areas with little to no vegetation. If vegetation is present, the dominant species are downy chess (Bromus tectorum) and tumbleweed (Salsola tragus). Other plant species observed include red brome (Bromus rubens), California croton (Croton californicus), and silverleaf nightshade (Solanum elaeagnifolium).1 Additionally, the Project Site is not located within any designated federal critical habitat. 1 City of Bakersfield. 1994. Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan, S. Summary. Available at:
https://docs.bakersfieldcity.us/weblink/0/edoc/625001/Metropolitan%20Bakersfield%20Habitat%20Conservation%20Plan.pdf. Accessed February 2026.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-5
The site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for majority of species, but do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) population and recent or historical occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land. The open site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.

Page 4 ends

Table 4.4-2 – Threatened, Endangered, or Candidate Wildlife Species Common Name Scientific Name Status
Habitat for specifies
Species on Project
Site?
Species present
on Project Site?
1 Tricolored blackbird Agelaius tricolor Candidate Endangered (State); CSSC
No No
2 Nelson's (San Joaquin)
antelope squirrel
Ammospermophilus
nelsoni
Threatened (State) No No
3 Crotch’s bumble bee Bombus crotchii Candidate Endangered (State)
No1 No
4 Swainson’s hawk Buteo swainsoni Threatened (State) No2 No 5 Monarch - California
overwintering population
Danaus plexippus pop.1 Candidate Species
(federal)
No No
6 Valley elderberry
longhorn beetle
Desmocerus californicus
dimorphus
Threatened (State) No No
7 Tipton kangaroo rat Dipodomys nitratoides
nitratoides
Endangered (federal);
Endangered (State)
No No
8 Blunt-nosed leopard lizard Gambelia sila Endangered (federal); Endangered (State)
No No
9 Buena Vista Lake ornate
shrew
Sorex ornatus relictus Threatened (federal);
CSSC
No No
10 San Joaquin kit fox Vulpes macrotis mutica Endangered (federal); Threatened (State)
No3 No

1. No individuals were observed, but the general biological survey occurred outside the primary blooming and detection period. Potential foraging can occur on site. This species has the potential to occur.

2. No nesting habitat occurs onsite; however, the site may provide limited foraging habitat. This species has a low potential to occur.

3. Not observed during the survey. Disturbed ruderal and urbanized areas are known habitat for SJKF movement, foraging, and denning. This species has the potential to occur.

Source: Hernandez Environmental Services, 2025.

Page 4 ends

Wildlife movement corridors link together areas of suitable habitat that are otherwise separated by rugged terrain, changes in vegetation, or human disturbances. The Project Site was evaluated for its function as a wildlife corridor that species would use to move between wildlife habitat zones. Usually, mountain canyons or riparian corridors are used by wildlife as corridors. The Project Site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby, and Furthermore, the site is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and a residential area to the west. However, urban SJKF can move through disturbed open land between developed parcels. The open 46.16-acre Project area may therefore function as a local stepping-stone or permeable movement area.

Page 4 ends

With the implementation of MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3, impacts to nesting birds would be avoided and impacts would be less than significant.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-6
Crotch’s Bumble Bee
Potential seasonal floral, nesting, and overwintering resources were not found in the survey. However, if there is ground disturbance, vegetation removal, during the blooming period then Crotch’s bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) (CBB) habitat assessment will occur to determine whether the site provides nesting, overwintering, and floral resources. If habitat is present, multiple rounds of CBB focused surveys will be conducted. If CBB are observed, site-specific measures will be implemented to avoid take, such as establishing a minimum 50-foot avoidance area around occupied habitat features and coordinating seasonally to minimize disturbance during overwintering. CDFW will be consulted to obtain an ITP if CBB take cannot be avoided during project activities.

San Joaquin Kit Fox
Before the City issues a grading permit and before any activity that could result in take, the Project applicant shall provide the City with written evidence that it has initiated project-specific coordination with CDFW and USFWS. The applicant shall implement all agency-approved avoidance and minimization conditions. If CDFW determines take cannot be avoided, the applicant shall obtain an incidental take permit under Fish and Game Code section 2081(b) before take, and if federal take may occur, the applicant shall obtain incidental take coverage through Endangered Species Act section 7 (if there is a federal nexus) or section 10(a)(1)(B), as applicable.

A focused preconstruction den survey will be required. A biologist shall survey the entire Project area and buffer no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days before ground or vegetation disturbance. The survey shall identify and map potential or known natal/pupping dens and document signs. If work does not begin within the validity period, if work lapses, or if site conditions change, the survey shall be repeated as directed by the agencies.

Potential dens shall receive at least the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; known dens shall receive the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; and agencies shall be contacted regarding any natal/pupping den. There will be a 50-foot buffer for potential dens and 100-feet for known dens. No known or natal/pupping den shall be destroyed without required take authorization. Any monitoring, partial plugging, excavation, or den closure shall be performed only by an agency approved qualified biologist and in accordance with the applicable authorization.

Before site entry, all workers shall receive kit fox awareness training. A qualified biological monitor shall have stop-work authority for a kit fox, suspected occupied den, entrapment, injury, or mortality. Daytime on-site speeds shall not exceed 20 miles per hour and nighttime speeds shall not exceed 10 miles per hour; nighttime work shall be minimized. Excavations deeper than two feet shall be covered at day’s end or provided with escape ramps and inspected before backfilling. Pipes/culverts at least four inches in diameter and other den-like materials shall be capped or inspected before movement; stacked materials shall be elevated where feasible. Food waste shall be secured; pets and firearms shall be prohibited; rodenticide/herbicide use shall be minimized and agency restrictions followed. New detections, injury, or mortality shall be reported promptly to agencies as required.

Before final site-plan approval, a qualified biologist shall review perimeter fencing/walls, drainage structures, lighting, landscaping, and high-traffic conflict points. Agency-approved design features shall maintain safe kit fox passage where feasible and shall not create entrapment hazards. If necessary artificial dens, specialized fencing gaps, exclusion fencing, or other passage features shall be installed only where Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-7
required or approved through agency consultation/permit conditions and supported by a maintenance and monitoring plan.

With implementation of MM BIO-4 through MM BIO-10 impacts would be less than significant.

Page 4 ends

MM BIO-2 Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls. In the event a burrowing owl or known burrowing owl den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b), shall be necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-4 San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF) Pre-Construction Surveys. Pre-construction surveys to assess presence/absence of denning San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) shall be conducted by the qualified biologist no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days prior to the commencement of any ground disturbance and/or construction activities or any Project activity likely to impact the SJKF. Surveys shall identify kit fox habitat features occurring on the project site (if any are determined to occur during the surveys) and evaluate use by SJKF and, if possible, assess the potential impacts to the kit fox by the proposed activity.

If a natal/pupping den is discovered within the Project Site or within 200 feet of the project site boundary, the appropriate agencies (e.g., California Department of Fish and Wildlife, City of Bakersfield) shall be immediately notified and under no circumstances shall the den be disturbed or destroyed without prior authorization. If the preconstruction survey reveals an active natal pupping or new information, the Project applicant, construction contractor and biologist shall contact the appropriate agencies immediately to obtain the necessary take authorization/permit. Written results of the preconstruction surveys shall be submitted to the appropriate agencies within five (5) days after survey completion and prior to the start of ground disturbance and/or construction activities.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-8
MM BIO-5 SJKF Avoidance Buffer. Prior to the commencement of any ground disturbing activities, the Project applicant, construction contractor and project biologist shall implement no-disturbance buffers as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites identified during the pre-construction surveys outlined in Mitigation Measure BIO-4.

MM BIO-6 SJKF Take Authorization. If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in Mitigation Measures BIO-5 are not feasible, the project applicant and California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) shall discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, the Project applicant shall obtain take authorization from CDFW by obtaining an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081, subdivision (b), in compliance with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-7 Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Habitat Assessment. Prior to the commencement of any ground-disturbing activities, the qualified biologist shall conduct an additional habitat assessment to determine if the project site and immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal nesting burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, and hollow logs shall be documented as part of the assessment.

MM BIO-8 CBB Surveys. If potentially suitable habitat is identified during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, a qualified biologist shall conduct focused surveys for CBB and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

MM BIO-9 CBB Avoidance. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses shall be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities occur during the overwintering period October through February), consultation with CDFW shall be conducted to discuss how to implement the proposed project’s construction-related activities and avoid take of the CBB. Any detection of CBB prior to or during project construction shall warrant discussions with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

MM BIO-10 CBB Take Authorization. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the proposed project and avoid take of the CBB. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit, pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-9
Section 4.6 Energy

Page 4 ends

Table 4.6-3: Project Natural Gas Demand
Land Use Electricity (kWh/year) (Natural Gas kBTU/year)1,2 Regional Shopping Center 3,280,464
Medical Office 364,604
Convenience Mart/Gas Station 14,278
Fast Food Restaurant w/Drive Thru 2,109,444
Automated Carwash 167,987
Public Storage 213,366
Parking Lot 0
Project Total 6,150,142
Source: Appendix B
Note: kBTU = kilo British thermal units
1 Based on information provided by the project applicant. 2 Accounts for total natural gas use from proposed buildings. See Appendix B Appendix C: General Biological Assessment (see also Appendix of the FEIR)

Page 1 ends

This updated September 2026 GBA is in response to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), Brian L. Cypher and Sierra Club. The revision clarifies there was no San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) sighting, reevaluates the November 13, 2025, General Biological Assessment and adds species-specific impact conclusions and enforceable avoidance, minimization, mitigation and authorization measures. HES was contracted to prepare only a General Biological Assessment; protocol-level focused surveys were not included in the original findings. Portions of the site were inaccessible due to fencing and were evaluated from accessible vantage points using binoculars. HES recognizes that Crotch’s bumble bee habitat cannot be conclusively determined during a non-blooming survey period and that SJKF may use disturbed urban areas for movement and denning. Accordingly, the revised analysis incorporates CDFW’s comments and includes appropriate surveys, avoidance measures, and agency coordination. These limitations and protective measures are reflected in the revised conclusions and recommendations.

Page 2 ends

The MBHCP is expired and any project approved prior to January 1, 2023 was required to be under the MBHCP and associated ITP until the expiration date of June 1, 2023. To ensure take of covered species does not occur after the expiration date, fees were required to be paid no later than January 1, 2023 and all covered activities were required to be completed by the MBHCP expiration date of June 1, 2023.

Page 3 ends

The site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for a majority of species, but do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) population and recent or historical Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-10
occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land. The open site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.

Page seven, second paragraph is revised as follows:

Crotch bumble bee
Crotch bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) is a state Candidate Endangered species. It is found in coastal California east to the Sierra-Cascade crest and south into Mexico. This species food plant genera include Antirrhinum, Phacelia, Clarkia, Dendromecon, Eschscholzia, and Eriogonum. There is no suitable habitat for this species present on the project site. No plant species within the general area identified by CDFW as preferred Crotch’s bumble bee foraging plants or suitable overwintering habitat were observed in the survey. Since the survey occurred outside the primary blooming and detection period, the presence or absence of the Crotch’s bumble bee cannot be conclusively determined. A habitat assessment during the appropriate blooming period is recommended if construction occurs during that time. This species has the potential to be present.

Page seven, third paragraph is revised as follows:

Swainson’s hawk
Swainson’s hawk (Buteo swainsoni) is a state listed Threatened species. This species favors open grasslands for foraging but also occurs in agricultural settings. It relies on scattered stands of trees near agricultural fields and grasslands for nesting sites. Its habitats include great basin grassland, riparian forest, riparian woodland, and valley and foothill grassland. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species. CDFW identified potentially suitable foraging land on and near the Project and potential nesting/perching substrates in the vicinity and noted that the species may forage many miles from a nest. No active nest was documented in the GBA. There is limited habitat for this species, however a pre-con nesting bird survey recommend outside the nesting bird period as raptors are known to have longer/delayed nesting seasons. This species is not expected to nest on the Project Site but has the potential to forage.

Page eight, fifth paragraph is revised as follows:

San Joaquin kit fox
San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) is a federally Endangered and state Threatened species. It is found in annual grasslands or grassy open stages with scattered shrubby vegetation. It needs loose-textured sandy soils for burrowing, and suitable prey base. This species is not present. The Project is within the species urban range and known to utilize ruderal and disturbed habitat. This species has the potential to occur and recommendations are written below in Section 5.4.

3.7 Wildlife Movement Corridors
Wildlife movement corridors link together areas of suitable habitat that are otherwise separated by rugged terrain, changes in vegetation, or human disturbances. The Project Site was not originally identified as a formally designated regional wildlife linkage. Usually, mountain canyons or riparian areas are used by wildlife as corridors. The project site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby and. Futhermore, the site is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-11
a residential area to the west. However, urban SJKF can move through disturbed open land between developed parcels. The open 46.16-acre Project area may therefore function as a local stepping-stone or permeable movement area. The Project Site was evaluated for its function as a wildlife corridor that species would use to move between wildlife habitat zones. Usually, mountain canyons or riparian corridors are used by wildlife as corridors. The Project Site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby. Furthermore, the site is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and a residential area to the west. No wildlife movement corridors were found to be present on the Project Site.

Page 10 ends

4.1 Impacts to Habitat Types
The proposed Project will impact the entire 46.16 acres of land consisting of approximately 46.16 acres of disturbed ruderal land onsite (Figure 5). Impacts may include SJKF movement corridor for intermittent foraging, denning/burrow habitat.

Page 10 ends

4.2.1 Impacts to State or Federally Listed and CNPS Listed Plants No state or federally listed plants or CNPS listed plants are expected to be impacted by the proposed Project. Given the Project severely degraded, predominantly non-native plants and unsuitable soils focused rare plant surveys are not warranted. Direct impacts to the listed/CNPS plants evaluated in the GBA are not expected.

Page 12 ends

5.2 Nesting Birds
Project activities could disturb passerine or raptor nests in the vicinity and would convert open land that may provide foraging habitat. This Project should have a pre-construction survey regardless if it’s done after the nesting season (February 1st- September 15). CDFW encourages that Project ground disturbing activities occur during the non nesting season; however; if ground disturbing or vegetation activities occur during the nesting season (February 1st – September 15th), the Project applicant is responsible for ensuring that implementation of the Project does not result in violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act or relevant Fish and Game Code sections as referenced above.

Page 12 ends

5.3 Crotch’s Bumble Bee
Potential seasonal floral, nesting, and overwintering resources were not found in the survey. However, if there is ground disturbance, vegetation removal, during the blooming period then Crotch’s bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) (CBB) habitat assessment will occur to determine whether the site provides nesting, overwintering, and floral resources. If habitat is present, multiple rounds of CBB focused surveys will be conducted. If CBB are observed, site-specific measures will be implemented to avoid take, such as establishing a minimum 50-foot avoidance area around occupied habitat features and coordinating Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-12
seasonally to minimize disturbance during overwintering. CDFW will be consulted to obtain an ITP if CBB take cannot be avoided during project activities.

5.4 San Joaquin Kit Fox
Before the City issues a grading permit and before any activity that could result in take, the Project applicant shall provide the City with written evidence that it has initiated project-specific coordination with CDFW and USFWS. The applicant shall implement all agency-approved avoidance and minimization conditions. If CDFW determines take cannot be avoided, the applicant shall obtain an incidental take permit under Fish and Game Code section 2081(b) before take. If federal take may occur, the applicant shall obtain incidental take coverage through Endangered Species Act section 7 (if there is a federal nexus) or section 10(a)(1)(B), as applicable.

A focused preconstruction den survey will be required. A biologist shall survey the entire Project area and buffer no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days before ground or vegetation disturbance. The survey shall identify and map potential or known natal/pupping dens and document signs. If work does not begin within the validity period, if work lapses, or if site conditions change, the survey shall be repeated as directed by the agencies.

Potential dens shall receive at least the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; known dens shall receive the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; and agencies shall be contacted regarding any natal/pupping den. There will be a 50-foot buffer for potential dens and 100-feet for known dens. No known or natal/pupping den shall be destroyed without required take authorization. Any monitoring, partial plugging, excavation, or den closure shall be performed only by an agency approved qualified biologist and in accordance with the applicable authorization.

Before site entry, all workers shall receive kit fox awareness training. A qualified biological monitor shall have stop-work authority for a kit fox, suspected occupied den, entrapment, injury, or mortality. Daytime on-site speeds shall not exceed 20 miles per hour and nighttime speeds shall not exceed 10 miles per hour; nighttime work shall be minimized. Excavations deeper than two feet shall be covered at day’s end or provided with escape ramps and inspected before backfilling. Pipes/culverts at least four inches in diameter and other den-like materials shall be capped or inspected before movement; stacked materials shall be elevated where feasible. Food waste shall be secured; pets and firearms shall be prohibited; rodenticide/herbicide use shall be minimized and agency restrictions followed. New detections, injury, or mortality shall be reported promptly to agencies as required.

Before final site-plan approval, a qualified biologist shall review perimeter fencing/walls, drainage structures, lighting, landscaping, and high-traffic conflict points. Agency-approved design features shall maintain safe kit fox passage where feasible and shall not create entrapment hazards. If necessary artificial dens, specialized fencing gaps, exclusion fencing, or other passage features shall be installed only where required or approved through agency consultation/permit conditions and supported by a maintenance and monitoring plan.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-13
Appendix B, Wildlife CNDDB Presence/Absence Table is revised as follows:

Scientific
Name
Common
Name
Taxon
Group
Federal List State List Other Status Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/Absence Athene
cunicularia
burrowing
owl
Birds None None BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_LC-Least Concern
| USFWS_BCC-Birds of
Conservation Concern
Coastal prairie |
Coastal scrub |
Great Basin
grassland | Great
Basin scrub |
Mojavean desert
scrub | Sonoran
desert scrub |
Valley & foothill
grassland
Open, dry annual
or perennial
grasslands, deserts,
and scrublands
characterized by
low-growing
vegetation.

Subterranean
nester,
dependent upon
burrowing
mammals, most
notably, the
California ground
squirrel.

No habitat for this species
is present on the project
site. This species has the
potential to be present.

No burrows were
observed during the
survey. The disturbed
open habitat may have
new burrows and the
species could occupy the
site before construction.

This species has the
potential to be present.

Bombus
crotchii
Crotch
bumble
bee
Insects None Candidate
Endangered
IUCN_EN-Endangered Coastal California
east to the Sierra-Cascade crest and
south into
Mexico.

Food plant genera
include
Antirrhinum,
Phacelia, Clarkia,
Dendromecon,
Eschscholzia, and
Eriogonum.

No habitat for this species
is present on the project
site. This species is not
present. No individuals
were observed, but the
general biological survey
occurred outside the
primary blooming
and detection period.

Potential foraging can
occur on site. This species
has the potential to
occur.

Buteo
swainsoni
Swainson's
hawk
Birds None Threatened BLM_S-Sensitive |
IUCN_LC-Least
Concern
Great Basin
grassland |
Riparian forest |
Riparian woodland
| Valley & foothill
grassland
Breeds in
grasslands with
scattered trees,
juniper-sage flats,
riparian areas,
savannahs, and
agricultural or
ranch lands with
groves or lines of
trees.

Requires adjacent
suitable foraging
areas such as
grasslands, or
alfalfa or grain
fields supporting
rodent
populations.

No habitat for this species
is present on the project
site. This species is not
present. No nesting
habitat occurs onsite;
however, the site may
provide limited foraging
habitat. This species has a
low potential to occur.

Taxidea
taxus
American
badger
Mammals None None CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_LC-Least
Concern
Alkali marsh | Alkali
playa | Alpine |
Alpine dwarf scrub
| Bog & fen |
Brackish marsh |
Broadleaved upland
Most abundant in
drier open stages
of most shrub,
forest, and
herbaceous
habitats, with
friable soils.

Needs sufficient
food, friable soils
and open,
uncultivated
ground. Preys on
No habitat for this species
is present on the project
site. This species is not
present. Not observed
during the survey.

Badgers are known for to
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-14
Scientific
Name
Common
Name
Taxon
Group
Federal List State List Other Status Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/Absence forest | Chaparral |
Chenopod scrub |
Cismontane
woodland | Closed-cone coniferous
forest | Coastal
bluff scrub | Coastal
dunes | Coastal
prairie | Coastal
scrub | Desert
dunes | Desert
wash | Freshwater
marsh | Great Basin
grassland | Great
Basin scrub |
Interior dunes |
Ione formation |
Joshua tree
woodland |
Limestone | Lower
montane coniferous
forest | Marsh &
swamp | Meadow
& seep | Mojavean
desert scrub |
Montane dwarf
scrub | North coast
coniferous forest |
Oldgrowth |
Pavement plain |
Redwood | Riparian
forest | Riparian
scrub | Riparian
woodland | Salt
marsh | Sonoran
desert scrub |
Sonoran thorn
woodland |
Ultramafic | Upper
montane coniferous
forest | Upper
Sonoran scrub |
Valley & foothill
grassland
burrowing
rodents. Digs
burrows
use loose soils seen on
site, however surrounding
development and
disturbance reduce
suitability. This species
has very low potential to
occur.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-15
Scientific
Name
Common
Name
Taxon
Group
Federal List State List Other Status Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/Absence Vulpes
macrotis
mutica
San
Joaquin kit
fox
Mammals Endangered Threatened Chenopod scrub |
Valley & foothill
grassland
Annual grasslands
or grassy open
stages
with scattered
shrubby
vegetation.

Need loose-textured sandy
soils for
burrowing, and
suitable prey
base.

This species was
observed during the field
survey. This species is
present. Not observed
during the survey.

Disturbed ruderal and
urbanized areas are
known habitat for SJKF
movement, foraging, and
denning. This species
has the potential to
occur.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Final Environmental Impact Report Section 3 – Errata to the Draft EIR City of Bakersfield September 2026

3.0-16
Chapter 5: Alternatives

Page 5 ends

Biological Resources
Under the No Build/No Project Alternative, the commercial improvements would not be constructed. No ground-disturbing activities, vegetation removal, or construction operations would occur on the Project Site. The Project Site would remain in its current condition. As discussed in Section 4.4, Biological Resources, no special-status species under CEQA or designated critical habitat were found on the Project Site.

The Project Site does not contain suitable habitat for the Western burrowing owl (BUOW) and it was not present on the Project Site during the field survey conducted for the DEIR. However, because BUOWs may become established on disturbed sites prior to construction, under the Project, a pre-construction BUOW survey is recommended within 30 days prior to the start of ground-disturbing activities, as specified further in MM BIO-1. If BUOWs are detected, appropriate avoidance and minimization measures, including no disturbance buffers and monitoring, shall be implemented in consultation with CDFW as specified in MM BIO-2.

Additionally, the Project Site has shrubs that could be used by nesting songbirds during the nesting bird season. Therefore, the Project would implement MM BIO-3, which require pre-construction nesting surveys prior to initiation of Project, should ground disturbance, vegetation clearing, or other construction activities that would otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy equipment).

The Project would implement MM BIO-4, MM BIO-5, and MM BIO-6 to ensure that potential impacts to the San Joaquin Fox would remain less than significant and MM BIO-7, MM BIO-8, MM BIO-9, and MM BIO-10 to ensure potential impacts to the Crotch Bumble Bee remain less than significant.

Therefore, biological resource impacts under the No Build/No Project Alternative would not occur, which is less than the Project’s impacts, which range from no impact to less than significant with mitigation (MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3 10). Impacts would be less than the Project.

Page 5 ends

Biological Resources
As Alternative 2 would require the same development footprint as the Project and is in the same location as the Project, impacts would be similar. Project Mitigation Measures MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3 MM BIO-10 would remain applicable under Alternative 2. Impacts would be the same as the Project.

Page 5 ends

Biological Resources
As Alternative 3 would require the same development footprint as the Project and is in the same location as the Project, impacts would be similar. Project Mitigation Measures MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3 MM BIO-10 would remain applicable under Alternative 3. Impacts would be the same as the Project.

II
Appendix A
Unbracketed Letters
Kim/ey»>Horn
Letter A1 Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE
August 26, 2026
Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
City of Bakersfield
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd floor
Bakersfield, California 93301
(661) 326-3673
[email protected]
Central Region
1234 East Shaw Avenue
Fresno, California 93710
(559) 243-4005
wildlife.ca.gov
Subject: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project) Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR)
State Clearinghouse No.: 2025101507
Dear Ashley Knight:

GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
MEGHAN HERTEL Director
The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) received a DEIR from the City of Bakerfield (City), as Lead Agency, for the above-referenced Project pursuant the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and CEQA Guidelines. 1 Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments and recommendations regarding those activities involved in the Project that may affect California fish and wildlife.

Likewise, CDFW appreciates the opportunity to provide comments regarding those aspects of the Project that CDFW, by law, may be required to carry out or approve through the exercise of its own regulatory authority under the Fish and Game Code.

CDFWROLE
CDFW is California's Trustee Agency for fish and wildlife resources and holds those resources in trust by statute for all the people of the State (Fish & G. Code, §§ 711.7, subd. (a) & 1802; Pub. Resources Code, § 21070; CEQA Guidelines § 15386, subd. (a)). CDFW, in its trustee capacity, has jurisdiction over the conservation, protection, and management of fish, wildlife, native plants, and habitat necessary for biologically sustainable populations of those species (Id., § 1802.). Similarly, for purposes of CEQA, CDFW is charged by law to provide, as available, biological expertise during public 1 CEQA is codified in the California Public Resources Code in section 21000 et seq. The "CEQA Guidelines" are found in Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, commencing with section 15000.

Conserving California's Wildlife Since 1870
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 2 ends

agency environmental review efforts, focusing specifically on projects and related activities that have the potential to adversely affect fish and wildlife resources.

CDFW is also submitting comments as a Responsible Agency under CEQA (Pub.

Resources Code,§ 21069; CEQA Guidelines, § 15381). CDFW expects that it may need to exercise regulatory authority as provided by the Fish and Game Code. As proposed, for example, the Project may result in "take" as defined by State law of any species protected under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) (Fish & G.

Code,§ 2050 et seq.), related authorization as provided by the Fish and Game Code will be required.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION SUMMARY
Proponent: DJ M Capital Partners
Objective: The Project proposes to construct and operate the Riverview Marketplace; a commercial retail center located on a 46.16-acre parcel in northwestern Bakersfield.

The Project would encompass approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space and would include market, retail, and storage uses, as well as restaurants, a medical office, a health club, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

Other Project components would include vehicular access and circulation improvements on and off the site; surface parking and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; landscape, hardscape, and lighting features; green space and park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility upgrades.

Location: The Project site is located on approximately 46 acres in the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield. The Assessor's Parcel Number associated with the Project is: 368-010-05.

Timeframe: Project buildout is anticipated to occur over an approximately 20-month period, beginning in late 2026 and concluding in the second quarter of 2028.

COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CDFW offers the following comments and recommendations to assist the City in adequately identifying and/or mitigating the Project's significant, or potentially significant, direct and indirect impacts on fish and wildlife (biological) resources.

Editorial comments or other suggestions may also be included to improve the DEIR prepared for the Project.

CDFW submitted a comment letter on December 1, 2025 (2025 NOP Letter; Attachment 1) in response to the Project's Notice of Preparation (NOP). The 2025 NOP Letter provided recommendations to identify and mitigate the Project's significant or potentially significant direct and indirect impacts on biological resources. Specifically, CDFW Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 3 ends

recommended mitigation measures for the State threatened and federally endangered San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica); the State threatened Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsom); the State candidate western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea), and State candidate Crotch's bumble bee (Bombus crotchil); the State Species of Special Concern American badger (Taxidea taxus) and Bakersfield legless lizard (Annie/la grinne/11); and the State species of special concern and federally proposed threatened western spadefoot toad ( Spea hammondil). CDFW would like to note that as of August 13, 2026, the California Fish and Game Commission approved western spadefoot toad (WESP) as a candidate for potential listing as a protected species under CESA and is in the process of publishing the Notice of Findings. As such, when the Notice of Findings is published, WESP will be a candidate under CESA and receive the same legal protection afforded to an endangered or threatened species (Fish & G. Code, §§ 207 4.2 & 2085).

Based on a review of the DEIR, CDFW has concerns about the ability of some proposed mitigation measures to reduce impacts to less than significant and avoid unauthorized take for several special-status species, including San Joaquin kit fox, western burrowing owl, and Crotch's bumble bee. CDFW also has concerns regarding the DEIR's cumulative analysis for biological resource impacts. As such, CDFW recommends the following:

San Joaquin Kit Fox
The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) is absent on the Project site based on a single general wildlife survey conducted in November 2025. It does not appear that focused SJKF surveys and analyses were completed within the Project site and vicinity to inform this conclusion. As a result, no species-specific mitigation measures are included in the DEIR.

As discussed in the 2025 NOP Letter, Bakersfield is home to a significant urban population of SJ KF, and this population has been recorded to utilize anthropogenically altered habitats throughout the Bakersfield area (Cypher 2013). There are numerous historical and recent SJKF occurrences within the Project vicinity (CDFW 2026), including known occurrences at the Northwest Promenade Center and Lowes Home Improvement Center, as well as the California State University, Bakersfield, which are all in close proximity to the Project, and there is the strong likelihood that SJ KF would den and/or forage within the Project site prior to, during, and after construction.

Additionally, the DEIR contains conflicting information regarding the potential for SJKF presence. The DEIR and General Biological Assessment (GBA) state that SJKF is not present; however, the GBA's species list and special-status species table both note that SJKF was directly observed during surveys. CDFW strongly recommends the City further confirm and clarify within the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) whether Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 4 ends

SJ KF were detected during the biological surveys that were conducted to inform the DEIR.

As discussed in the 2025 NOP Letter, given the Project's anticipated construction activities and duration, the site's location within urban Bakersfield, CDFW's knowledge of the Bakersfield urban population of SJKF, the many historical and recent SJKF occurrences within the Project site and proximity, and the strong likelihood for SJKF to den and/or forage within the Project site, CDFW strongly recommends that the Project proponent consult with CDFW to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take.

CDFW recommends the Project proponent acquire take authorization through the acquisition of an Incidental Take Permit (ITP), pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) to comply with CESA. CDFW also recommends the DEIR be revised to incorporate an adequate discussion and analysis of SJKF impacts, specifically evaluating the Project's individual and cumulative impacts on SJKF denning, foraging, and movement within the Bakersfield area.

In addition to these more general recommendations, CDFW recommends incorporating the following mitigation measures within the DEIR:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 1: SJKF Preconstruction Surveys CDFW recommends assessing presence/absence of denning SJKF by conducting focused den surveys for the species prior to the initiation of Project ground disturbance activities. Specifically, CDFW recommends conducting these surveys over the entirety of the Project site no less than 14-days and no more than 30-days prior to beginning of ground and/or vegetation disturbing activities.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 2: SJKF Avoidance Buffer CDFW recommends implementing no-disturbance buffers, as described in the USFWS' "Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance" (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJ KF den sites.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 3: SJKF Take Authorization If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in the USFWS Protocol for SJKF is not feasible, CDFW recommends that consultation with CDFW occur to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, CDFW recommends the Project proponent acquire take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) to comply with CESA.

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 5 ends

Western Burrowing Owl
The DEIR includes mitigation measures MM 810-1 and 810-2 to mitigate for potential significant impacts to western burrowing owl (BUOW). MM 810-1 and 810-2 requires a qualified biologist to conduct surveys and implement avoidance measures following the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). CDFW concurs with these measures and recommends MM 810-2 be modified to note that, in the event a BUOW or known BUOW den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

Crotch's Bumble Bee
The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for Crotch's bumble bee (CBB) is absent from the Project site and no species-specific mitigation measures were included to avoid unauthorized take or mitigate potentially significant impacts. This conclusion is based on a single survey conducted in November 2025 and was not timed appropriately during the plant blooming period to adequately assess potential suitable habitat. Additionally, no species-specific surveys were conducted during the active period of February through October (CDFW 2023). As the DEIR did not include an adequate habitat assessment or surveys for CBB, CDFW recommends incorporating the following mitigation measures within the DEIR:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 4: CBB Habitat Assessment CDFW recommends a qualified biologist conduct a habitat assessment to determine if the Project site and the immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, dead trees, and hollow logs would need to be documented as part of the assessment. This habitat assessment should be timed during the appropriate blooming period.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 5: CBB Surveys
If potentially suitable habitat is identified, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct focused surveys for CBB, and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 6 ends

Recommended Mitigation Measure 6: CBB Avoidance
If CBB is detected, then CDFW recommends that all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities will occur during the overwintering period (October through February), consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement Project activities and avoid take. Any detection of CBB prior to or during Project implementation warrants consultation with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 7: CBB Take Authorization If CBB is detected, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

ENVIRONMENTAL DATA
CEQA requires that information developed in environmental impact reports and negative declarations be incorporated into a database, which may be used to make subsequent or supplemental environmental determinations (Pub. Resources Code, § 21003, subd. (e).) Accordingly, please report any special-status species and natural communities detected during Project surveys to the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB). The CNDDB field survey form can be filled out and submitted online at the following link: https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Submitting-Data .

The types of information reported to the CNDDB can be found at the following link:
https://www .wild I if a.ca.gov /Data/CN DOB/Plants-and-Animals.

FILING FEES
The Project, as proposed, would have an impact on fish and/or wildlife, and an assessment of filing fees is necessary. Fees are payable upon filing of the Notice of Determination by the Lead Agency and serve to help defray the cost of environmental review by CDFW. Payment of the fee is required in order for the underlying project approval to be operative, vested, and final (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 14, § 753.5; Fish & G.

Code, § 711.4; Pub. Resources Code, § 21089).

CONCLUSION
CDFW appreciates the opportunity to comment on the DEIR to assist the City in identifying and mitigating Project impacts on biological resources. More information on survey and monitoring protocols for sensitive species can be found at CDFW's website (https://www. wild I if a.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 7 ends

A Mitigation and Monitoring Program (MMRP) (Attachment 2) is included to assist the City with incorporating the recommended mitigation measures provided above. If you have any questions regarding this letter or further coordination, please contact Evelyn Barajas-Perez, Environmental Scientist, at the address provided on this letterhead, by telephone at (805) 503-5738 or [email protected].

Sincerely,
lrDocuSigned by:

L~F:::.

Julie A. Vance
Regional Manager
Attachments
Attachment 1 - 2025 NOP Letter
Attachment 2 - MMRP
ec: State Clearinghouse
Land Use and Climate Innovation
[email protected]. gov
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)
Justin Sloan
Justin_ [email protected]
United States Fish and Wildlife Service
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
August 26, 2026

Page 8 ends

REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Game. 2012. Staff report on burrowing owl mitigation.

Sacramento, California, USA.

California Department of Fish and Wildlife. 2026. Biogeographic information and observation system (BIOS). https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/BIOS. Accessed 22 July 2026.

California Department of Fish and Wildlife. 2023. Survey considerations for California Endangered Species Act (CESA) candidate bumble bee species. Sacramento, California, USA.

Cypher, B., S. Phillips, and P. Kelly. 2013. Quantity and distribution of suitable habitat for endangered San Joaquin kit foxes: conservation implications. Canid Biology and Conservation 16(7): 25-31.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2011. Standard recommendations for the protection of the San Joaquin kit fox prior to or during ground disturbance. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Sacramento, California.

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Attachment 1
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 fjjiijif'-li!Mi State of Califorria - Natural Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE
Central Region
1234 East Shaw Avenue
Fresno, California 93710
(559) 243 - 4005
www.wildlife.ca.gov
December 1, 2025
Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
City of Bakersfield
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd floor
Bakersfield, California 93301
(661) 326 - 3673
[email protected]
Subject: Riverview Market Commercial Project (Project)
Notice of Preparation (NOP)
State Clearinghouse No.: 2025101507
Dear Ashley Knight:

GA VIN NEWSOM. Governor
CHARLTON H. BONHAM, Director
The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) received a NOP from the City of Bakersfield, as Lead Agency, for the above-referenced Project pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and CEQA Guidelines. 1 Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments and recommendations regarding those activities involved in the Project that may affect California fish and wildlife.

Likewise, CDFW appreciates the opportunity to provide comments regarding those aspects of the Project that CDFW, by law, may be required to carry out or approve through the exercise of its own regulatory authority under the Fish and Game Code.

CDFWROLE
CDFW is California's Trustee Agency for fish and wildlife resources and holds those resources in trust by statute for all the people of the State (Fish & G. Code, §§ 711.7, subd. (a) & 1802; Pub. Resources Code, § 21070; CEQA Guidelines § 15386, subd. (a)). CDFW, in its trustee capacity, has jurisdiction over the conservation, protection, and management of fish, wildlife, native plants, and habitat necessary for biologically sustainable populations of those species (Id., § 1802.). Similarly, for purposes of CEQA, CDFW is charged by law to provide, as available, biological expertise during public 1 CEQA is codified in the California Public Resources Code in section 21000 et seq . The "CEQA Guidelines" are found in Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, commencing with section 15000.

Conserving Ca{ifomia's Wi{d"{ife Since 1870
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 2 ends

agency environmental review efforts, focusing specifically on projects and related activities that have the potential to adversely affect fish and wildlife resources.

CDFW is also submitting comments as a Responsible Agency under CEQA (Pub.

Resources Code,§ 21069; CEQA Guidelines, § 15381). CDFW expects that it may need to exercise regulatory authority as provided by the Fish and Game Code. As proposed, for example, reasonably foreseeable future projects may be subject to CDFW's lake and streambed alteration regulatory authority (Fish & G. Code, § 1600 et seq.). Likewise, to the extent implementation of reasonably foreseeable future projects may result in "take" as defined by State law of any species protected under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) (Fish & G. Code, § 2050 et seq.), related authorization as provided by the Fish and Game Code will be required.

Nesting Birds: CDFW has jurisdiction over actions with potential to result in the disturbance or destruction of active nest sites or the unauthorized take of birds. Fish and Game Code sections that protect birds, their eggs and nests include, sections 3503 (regarding unlawful take, possession or needless destruction of the nest or eggs of any bird), 3503.5 (regarding the take, possession or destruction of any birds-of-prey or their nests or eggs), and 3513 (regarding unlawful take of any migratory nongame bird).

Unlisted Species: Species of plants and animals need not be officially listed as Endangered, Rare, or Threatened on any State or federal list pursuant to CESA and/or the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) to be considered Endangered, Rare, or Threatened under CEQA. If a species can be shown to meet the criteria specified in the CEQA Guidelines (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, Chapter 3, § 15380), it should be fully considered in the environmental analysis for the Project.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION SUMMARY
Proponent: Coffee Road Ventures, LLC
Objective: The Project proposes the construction and operation of a commercial retail center that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. The Project would construct market, retail, and storage space, restaurants, and a gas station, car wash, and health club. Other Project components will include vehicular access and circulation, various landscape, hardscape, and lighting improvements, green space/park improvements, site and tenant signage, and infrastructure and utility improvements.

Location: The Project site is located on approximately 46 acres in the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield. The Assessor's Parcel Number associated with the Project is: 368-010-05.

Timeframe: Approximately 20 months commencing in early 2026 and ending in 2027.

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 3 ends

COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CDFW offers the following comments and recommendations to assist the City of Bakersfield in adequately identifying and/or mitigating the Project's significant, or potentially significant, direct and indirect impacts on fish and wildlife (biological) resources. Editorial comments or other suggestions may also be included to improve the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) prepared for this Project.

Special-status Species
Aerial imagery shows the Project site contains vacant, undeveloped land com prised of regularly tilled ruderal vegetation and annual grasslands, with internal dirt paths and staging areas for equipment and /materials. The Project site is bordered by a Pacific Gas and Electric Company power generation site on the west and south portions of the Project site; a commercial development and vacant undeveloped land is located to the east; and commercial development is located north of the Project site. The Kern River Parkway is approximately one mile south and California State University, Bakersfield is approximately two miles south of the Project site.

Based on a review of the NOP, aerial imagery, the surrounding habitat, and California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB) records (CDFW 2025), the Project is within the range of several special-status animal species including, but are not limited to, the federally endangered and State threatened San Joaquin kit fox ( Vulpes macrotis mutica); the State threatened Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsom); the State candidate western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia hypugaea) and Crotch's bumble bee (Bombus crotchil); the State Species of Special Concern American badger (Taxidea taxus) and Bakersfield legless lizard (Annie/la grinnelfl); and the State species of special concern and federally proposed threatened western spadefoot toad ( Spea hammondit).

To adequately assess potential Project related impacts to biological resources in the DEIR, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist perform relevant database reviews and other research of the Project area, then conduct focused habitat assessments and/or focused biological surveys during the appropriate survey period(s) in order to determine whether any special-status species may be present within the Project site.

CDFW recommends this initial work be documented and used to inform further efforts that may be needed thereafter including the need for additional protocol surveys and/or the development of avoidance, minimization, and/or mitigation measures. This information and analysis may then be used to consider the development of modified or new Project alternatives to avoid and minimize potentially significant environmental impacts on the biological environment. This information is critical to make an informed decision during the CEQA process and to ensure Project compliance with CESA, Fish and Game code, and other applicable State and federal laws and regulations.

San Joaquin Kit Fox
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 4 ends

Based on aerial imagery, the Project site and the vacant parcels surrounding the site contain suitable habitat for San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) denning and foraging. The Project site is within the known geographic range of SJKF, and there are multiple recent and historical nearby occurrences listed on CNDDB (CDFW 2025). Bakersfield is home to a significant urban population of SJ KF and this population has been recorded to utilize anthropogenically altered habitats (Cypher 2013). San Joaquin kit fox may be attracted to both construction materials (pipes, etc.) and construction footprints due to the type and level of activity (excavation, etc.) and the loose, friable soils that are created as a result of intensive ground disturbance. SJKF will readily use shipping containers, portable buildings, and stacks of materials (e.g., I-beams, wooden boards) with spaces within or underneath them for denning, in addition to pipes and culverts (Cypher et al. 2023), and it is likely that these materials would be present within the Project site, prior to, during, and after construction. Therefore, CDFW recommends thoroughly inspecting all construction materials or structures with sufficient spaces for SJKF, in addition to pipes and culvert-like structures, before these materials are used or moved in any way during Project implementation. To deter SJKF from creating dens under construction materials, CDFW recommends elevating materials one foot or more off the ground using k-rails or similar structures. Additionally, CDFW recommends a qualified biologist conduct on-site worker awareness training and inspect all construction materials for SJ KF before use. Any pits or trenches created should be sloped or covered to prevent inadvertent capture or entrapment (take).

In addition the general recommendations above, as SJKF have a high potential to den and/or forage within the Project site and have been documented within the Project vicinity, CDFW strongly recommends that the Project proponent consult with CDFW to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take, or, if take cannot be avoided, to acquire SJKF take authorization through the acquisition of an Incidental Take Permit (ITP), pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b).

Additionally, CDFW recommends adding the following as mitigation measures within the DEIR:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 1: SJKF Preconstruction Surveys CDFW recommends assessing presence/absence of denning SJKF by conducting focused den surveys for the species prior to the initiation of Project ground disturbance activities. Specifically, CDFW recommends conducting these surveys over the entirety of the Project site no less than 14-days and no more than 30-days prior to beginning of ground and/or vegetation disturbing activities.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 2: SJKF Avoidance Buffer CDFW recommends implementing no-disturbance buffers, as described in the USFWS' "Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 5 ends

Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance" (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJ KF den sites.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 3: SJKF Take Authorization If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in the USFWS Protocol for SJKF is not feasible, CDFW recommends that consultation with CDFW occur to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, CDFW recommends the Project proponent acquire take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) to comply with CESA.

Swainson's Hawk
Swainson's hawks (SWHA) are known to breed within the Central Valley of California and pref er to nest and forage in alfalfa, fallow fields, field crops, and grassland habitats with a sufficient source of small mammals (CDFG 1994). Several large parcels of lands to the south and east of the Project site may be utilized for foraging and infrastructure such and power and light poles in the Project vicinity may be utilized for perching.

SWHA are known to travel up to 18 miles to forage and are also attracted to ground disturbing activities such as disking because these activities make prey vulnerable by reducing cover (Estep 1989). CNDDB occurrences are noted within this 18-mile distance of the Project site. SWHA exhibit high nest-site fidelity year after year and lack of suitable habitat limits their local distribution and abundance (CDFW 2016).

As suitable SWHA foraging and nesting habitat appear to be present within the Project site and vicinity, and SWHA have been documented within the surrounding area, CDFW recommends surveys for SWHA be conducted as part of the biological technical studies conducted in support of the DEIR by a qualified biologist following the survey methods developed by the Swainson's Hawk Technical Advisory Committee (SWHA TAC 2000).

In addition to conducting SWHA surveys, CDFW recommends the DEIR include the following measures:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 4: SWHA Surveys Prior to Construction Depending on the time between the initial survey efforts conducted in support of the DEIR and Project construction, CDFW recommends that additional surveys, following the survey methodology developed by the SWHA Technical Advisory Committee, be repeated the survey season immediately prior to any ground disturbing activities that occur as part of this Project.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 5: SWHA Avoidance Buffer Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 6 ends

If Project-specific activities will take place during the SWHA nesting season (i.e., March 1 through September 15), and active SWHA nests are present, CDFW recommends a minimum ½-mile no-disturbance buffer be delineated and maintained around each nest, regardless of whether it was detected by surveys or observed incidentally. These buffers would remain in place until the breeding season has ended or until a qualified biologist has determined that the birds have fledged and are no longer reliant upon the nest or parental care for survival, to prevent nest abandonment and other take of SWHA as a result of Project activities.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 6: SWHA Take Authorization CDFW also recommends that in the event an active SWHA nest is detected, and a ½-mile no-disturbance buffer is not feasible, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 7: SWHA Foraging Habitat Mitigation Finally, CDFW recommends compensation for the loss of SWHA foraging habitat as described in CDFW's "Staff Report Regarding Mitigation for Impacts to Swainson's Hawks" (CDFG 1994) to reduce impacts to foraging habitat to less than significant. The Staff Report recommends that mitigation for habitat loss occur within a minimum distance of 10 miles from known nest sites. CDFW has the following recommendations based on the Staff Report:
• For projects within 1 mile of an active nest tree, a minimum of 1 acre of habitat management (HM) land for each acre of development is advised. • For projects within 5 miles of an active nest but greater than 1 mile, a minimum of¾ acre of HM land for each acre of development is advised. • For projects within 10 miles of an active nest tree but greater than 5 miles from an active nest tree, a minimum of½ acre of HM land for each acre of development is advised.

Western Burrowing Owl
The California Fish and Game Commission (FGC) approved BUOW as a candidate for potential listing as a protected species under CESA on October 10, 2024, and published these findings in the California Regulatory Notice Register (Notice Register) on October 25, 2024. As such, BUOW is now a candidate under CESA and receives the same legal protection afforded to an endangered or threatened species (Fish & G. Code, §§ 207 4.2 & 2085).

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 7 ends

The Project site is within the known geographic range of BUOW and there are multiple historic and recent occurrences located within five miles of the Project site (CDFW 2025). BUOW inhabit open grasslands and desert scrublands containing small mammal burrows, a requisite habitat feature used by BUOW for nesting and cover, and they are known to forage in agricultural lands. Based on aerial imagery, the Project site and adjacent lands contain suitable habitat for BUOW nesting and foraging.

As BUOW are known to occur within the Project vicinity and suitable nesting and foraging habitat is present within the Project site, CDFW recommends assessing presence/absence of BUOW by having a qualified biologist conduct surveys following the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012) as part of the biological studies conducted in support of the DEIR. In addition to conducting surveys for BUOW, CDFW recommends the DEIR include the following measures:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 8: BUOW Pre-construction Surveys Depending on the time between the initial survey efforts conducted in support of the DEIR and Project construction, CDFW recommends that additional focused surveys, following the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (2012 Staff Report) (CDFG 2012), be conducted the survey season immediately prior to construction. Please note that the 2012 Staff Report necessitates multiple surveys prior to the initiation of construction.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 9: BUOW Avoidance Buffer Should a BUOW or known BUOW den (active or inactive) be detected, either during pre-construction surveys or construction activities, CDFW recommends that no-disturbance buffers, as outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012), be implemented prior to and during any ground-disturbing activities. CDFW also recommends that these buffers be implemented for both wintering and breeding BUOW.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 10: BUOW Take Authorization If a BUOW or known BUOW den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no-disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

Crotch's Bumble Bee
The Project site is within the known geographical range of Crotch's bumble bee (CBB ), and several recent occurrences have been documented within three miles of the Project site (CDFW 2025). CBB are known to inhabit areas of grasslands and scrub that contain Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 8 ends

requisite habitat elements for nesting, such as small mammal burrows and bunch/thatched grasses, and these habitat elements may be present within the Project site and Project vicinity.

As the Project site is within the known range for CBB and suitable nesting and foraging habitat may be present within the Project site and vicinity, CDFW recommends a qualified biologist conduct a habitat assessment as part of the biological technical studies conducted in support of the DEIR to determine if the Project site and the immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, dead trees, and hollow logs would need to be documented as part of the assessment. If potentially suitable habitat is identified, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct focused surveys for CBB, and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023). If suitable CBB habitat is identified during the habitat assessment, CDFW recommends the DEIR include the following measures:

Recommended Mitigation Measure 11: CBB Surveys
Depending on the time between the initial survey efforts conducted in support of the DEIR and Project construction, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct additional focused surveys for CBB, and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

Recommended Mitigation Measure 12: CBB Avoidance
If CBB is detected, then CDFW recommends that all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities will occur during the overwintering period (October through February), consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement Project activities and avoid take. Any detection of CBB prior to or during Project implementation warrants consultation with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 13: CBB Take Authorization If CBB is detected, consultation with CDFW is warranted to discuss how to implement the Project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an ITP, pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081 subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with CESA.

State Species of Special Concern
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 9 ends

The Project is within the geographic range of species of American badger (AM BA), Bakersfield legless lizard (BLL), and western spadefoot (WESP), and suitable habitat may be present within the Project site. As such, CDFW recommends a qualified biologist conduct a habitat assessment to determine if the Project site and the immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support AM BA, BLL, and WESP. If suitable habitat is determined to be present, CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct focused surveys for these species as part of the biological technical studies conducted in support of the DEIR. In addition to conducting habitat assessments and surveys for AMBA, BLL, and WESP, CDFW recommends the DEIR include the following measures.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 14: Surveys
CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist conduct focused surveys, using appropriate survey methodologies, for the special-status species referenced above prior to any ground disturbing activities that may occur as part of the Project.

Recommended Mitigation Measure 15: Avoidance
Avoidance whenever possible is encouraged via delineation and observance of a 50-foot no-disturbance buffer around dens or burrows/refugia of these species. If these species are observed on the Project site, CDFW recommends that Project construction activities in their immediate vicinity cease, allowing individuals to leave the Project site on their own accord.

Editorial Comments and/or Suggestions
Nesting birds: CDFW encourages that Project ground-disturbing activities occur during the bird non-nesting season; however, if ground-disturbing or vegetation-disturbing activities must occur during the nesting season (February 1st through September 15th), the Project applicant is responsible for ensuring that implementation of the Project does not result in violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act or relevant Fish and Game Code sections as referenced above.

CDFW further recommends that a qualified biologist conduct a pre-construction survey for active nests no more than 10 days prior to the start of ground or vegetation disturbance to maximize the probability that nests that could potentially be impacted are detected. CDFW also recommends that surveys cover a sufficient area around the Project site to identify nests and determine their status. A sufficient area means any area potentially affected, either directly or indirectly, by the Project. In addition to direct impacts (i.e., nest destruction), noise, vibration, and movement of workers or equipment could also affect nests. CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist establish a behavioral baseline of all identified nests. Once Project activities begin, CDFW recommends having a qualified biologist continuously monitor nests to detect behavioral Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 10 ends

changes resulting from the Project. If behavioral changes occur, CDFW recommends halting the work causing that change and consulting with CDFW for additional avoidance and minimization measures.

If continuous monitoring of identified nests by a qualified biologist is not feasible, CDFW recommends a minimum no-disturbance buffer of 250 feet around active nests of non-listed bird species and a 500-foot no-disturbance buffer around active nests of non-listed raptors. These buffers are advised to remain in place until the breeding season has ended or until a qualified biologist has determined the birds have fledged and are no longer reliant upon the nest or on-site parental care for survival. Variance from these no-disturbance buffers is possible when there is a compelling biological or ecological reason to do so, such as when the Project site would be concealed from a nest site by topography. CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist advise and support any variance from these buffers and notify CDFW in advance of implementing a variance.

Project Alternative Analysis: CDFW recommends that the information and results obtained from the biological technical surveys, studies, and analysis conducted in support of the Project's CEQA document be used to develop and modify the Project's alternatives to avoid and minimize impacts to biological resources to the maximum extent possible. When efforts to avoid and minimize have been exhausted, remaining impacts to sensitive biological resources should be mitigated to reduce impacts to a less than significant level, if feasible.

CNDDB: Please note that the CNDDB is populated by records through voluntary submissions of species detections. As a result, species may be present in locations not depicted in the CNDDB but where there is suitable habitat and features capable of supporting species. A lack of an occurrence record in the CNDDB does not mean a species is not present. In order to adequately assess any potential Project related impacts to biological resources, surveys conducted by a qualified biologist during the appropriate survey period(s) and using the appropriate protocol survey methodology are warranted in order to determine whether or not any special-status species are present at or near the Project site.

ENVIRONMENTAL DATA
CEQA requires that information developed in environmental impact reports and negative declarations be incorporated into a database, which may be used to make subsequent or supplemental environmental determinations (Pub. Resources Code, § 21003, subd. (e)). Accordingly, please report any special-status species and natural communities detected during Project surveys to the CNDDB. The CNDDB field survey form can be found at the following link:
https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Submitting-Data. The completed form can be mailed electronically to the CNDDB at the following email address:

[email protected]. The types of information reported to the CNDDB can be found at the following link: https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CNDDB/Plants-and-Animals.

Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 11 ends

FILING FEES
The Project, as proposed, could have an impact on biological resources, and an assessment of filing fees is necessary. Fees are payable upon filing of the Notice of Determination by the Lead Agency and serve to help defray the cost of environmental review by CDFW. Payment of the fee is required in order for the underlying project approval to be operative, vested, and final (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 14, § 753.5; Fish & G.

Code, § 711.4; Pub. Resources Code, § 21089).

CONCLUSION
CDFW appreciates the opportunity to comment on the NOP to assist the City of Bakersfield in identifying and mitigating Project impacts on biological resources. A Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (Attachment 1) is included below to assist the City of Bakersfield with incorporating the recommended mitigation measures provided above.

More information on survey and monitoring protocols for sensitive species can be found at CDFW's website (https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Survey-Protocols). If you have any questions regarding this letter or further coordination, please contact Marile Colindres, Environmental Scientist, at the address provided on this letterhead, by telephone at (559) 974-3452, or by electronic mail at [email protected].

Sincerely,
Julie A. Vance
Regional Manager
ATTACHMENT 1: Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program ec: State Clearinghouse
Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation
[email protected] mailto:State.Clearinghouse@opr .ca. gov Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
December 1, 2025

Page 12 ends

REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Game. 1994. Staff report regarding mitigation for impacts to Swainson's hawks (Buteo Swainsom) in the Central Valley of California. California Department of Fish and Game, Sacramento, California, USA.

California Department of Fish and Game. 2012. Staff report on burrowing owl mitigation.

California Department of Fish and Game, Sacramento, California, USA.

California Department of Fish and Wildlife. 2016. Five-year status review for Swainson's Hawk (Buteo swainsom). California Department of Fish and Wildlife, Sacramento, California, USA.

California Department of Fish and Wildlife. 2023. Survey considerations for California Endangered Species Act candidate bumble bee species. California Department of Fish and Wildlife, Sacramento, California, USA.

California Department of Fish and Wildlife. 2025. Biogeographic information and observation system (BIOS). https://wildlife.ca.gov/Data/BIOS. Accessed 13 November 2025.

Cypher, B., S. Phillips, and P. Kelly. 2013. Quantity and distribution of suitable habitat for endangered San Joaquin kit foxes: conservation implications. Canid Biology and Conservation 16(7): 25-31.

Cypher B., E. Noel, E. Kelly, T. Westall, N. Deatherage, and A. Gabaldon. 2023.

Response of San Joaquin kit foxes to road construction sites. California State University-Stanislaus - Endangered Species Recovery Program, Turlock, California, USA.

Estep, James A. 1989. Biology, movements, and habitat relationships of the Swainson's hawk in the Central Valley of California 1986-1987. State of California, The Resources Agency, Department of Fish and Game, Wildlife Management Division.

Swainson's Hawk Technical Advisory Committee. 2000. Recommended timing and methodology for Swainson's hawk nesting surveys in California's Central Valley.

Swainson's Hawk Technical Advisory Committee.

United States Fish and Wildlife Service. 2011. Standard Recommendations for the Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Sacramento, California. 2 Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Attachment
Docusign Envelope ID: 99463F4F-018E-817D-8004-F51894983C54 Attachment 2

CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE

RECOMMENDED MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (MMRP)
PROJECT: Riverview Market Commercial Project (Project)
Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR)
SCH No.: 2025101507

RECOMMENDED MITIGATION MEASURE STATUS/DATE/INITIALS
Before Disturbing Soil or Vegetation
San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF)
Recommended Mitigation Measure 1:

SJKF Preconstruction Surve s
Recommended Mitigation Measure 3:

SJKF Take Authorization
Crotch's Bumble Bee CBB
Recommended Mitigation Measure 4:

CBB Habitat Assessment
Recommended Mitigation Measure 5:

CBB Surveys
Recommended Mitigation Measure 7:

CBB Take Authorization
During Construction
San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF)
Recommended Mitigation Measure 2:

SJKF Avoidance Buffer
Crotch's Bumble Bee (CBB)
Recommended Mitigation Measure 6:

CBB Avoidance
August 28, 2026
Ashley Knight
City of Bakersfield
Development Services
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Project: Draft Environmental Impact Report for Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
District CEQA Reference No: 20260846
Dear Ms. Knight:

The San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (District) has reviewed the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) from the City of Bakersfield (City) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project. Per the DPEIR, the project consists of a 405,531 square foot commercial retail center (Project). The Project is located on the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road, in Bakersfield, CA.

The District offers the following comments at this time regarding the Project:

Health Risk Screening/Assessment
The District reviewed the Health Risk Assessment (HRA) for the Project and have the following comment:

Only a construction HRA was performed to evaluate health impacts from the Project to nearby sensitive receptors. An operational HRA should also be station, fast food charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel from deliveries. The risk scores from the operational HRA should be combined with the construction HRA and compared to District health risk significance thresholds to confirm the significance determination presented in the DEIR.

Letter A2
■ San Joaquin Valley - AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT HEALTHY AIR LIVING™ 1)
•
performed to evaluate the health risk from the Project's proposed gasoline Northern Region
4800 Enterprise Way
Modesto, CA 95356-8718
Tel: (209) 557-6400 FAX: 12091 557-6475
Samir Sheikh
Executive Director/Air Pollution Control Officer
Central Region (Main Office)
1990 E. Gettysburg Avenue
Fresno, CA 93726-0244
Tel: 1559) 230-6000 FAX: 1559) 230-6061
www.valleyair.org www.healthyairliving.com
Southern Region
34946 Flyover Court
Bakersfield, CA 93308-9725
Tel: (661) 392-5500 FAX: (661) 392-5585
Prinledonrecycledpaper. O
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 2 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
Modifications to the HRA based on the comments listed above have the potential to cause the Project to exceed District health risk thresholds. Therefore, the District recommends revising the HRA to ensure the analysis accurately reflects the ential air quality impacts.

The District is available to review HRA protocols and analyses. For HRA submittals please provide the following information electronically to the District for review:

HRA (AERMOD) modeling files
HARP2 files
Summary of emissions source locations, emissions rates, and emission factor calculations and methodologies.

For assistance, please contact the Dist
E-Mailing inquiries to: [email protected]
Calling (559) 230-5900
Recommended Measure: Development projects resulting in TAC emissions should be located an adequate distance from residential areas and other sensitive receptors to prevent the creation of a significant health risk in accordance to CARB's Air Quality and Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective located at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/our-work/programs/resource-center/strategy-development/land-use-resources.

Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement
The District appreciates
Agreement (VERA) as a mitigation measure for the Project. As identified in Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1, the VERA would mitigate Project-related operational emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOC) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) to net -than-significant level.

Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 also states that, prior to issuance of building permits, the Project applicant shall provide document
required emission reduction fees are paid, the District will use the funds to achieve the required emission reduction through District emission reduction programs. The time required to achieve these emission reductions may vary depending on the types of emission reduction projects implemented and the time necessary to complete those projects. Once the required emission reductions have been achieved, the District will verify to the City that the mitigation requirements of the VERA have been completed. As a result, the verification of the required emission reductions may occur after issuance of building permits.

Project's pot
•
•
•
•
•
rict's Technical Services Department by:
2) -----------
the City's inclusion of a Voluntary Emission Reduction
zero, thereby reducing the Project's air quality to less ation to the City verifying "completion of
the VERA." The District would like to clarify that, once the VERA is executed and the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 3 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
Therefore, to more accurately reflect the VERA process and avoid implying that all required emission reductions must be achieved prior to issuance of building permits, the District suggests revising MM AQ-1 to re completion obligation to enter into the VERA is established prior to issuance of building permits, while recognizing that the implementation and verification of the resulting emission reduction projects may require additional time.

Under-fired Charbroilers
The Project may have restaurants with under-fired charbroilers. Such charbroilers may pose the potential for immediate health risk, particularly when located in densely populated areas or near sensitive receptors.

Since the cooking of meat can release carcinogenic PM2.5 species, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, controlling emissions from new under-fired charbroilers will have a substantial positive impact on public health. The air quality impacts on neighborhoods near restaurants with under-fired charbroilers can be significant on days when meteorological conditions are stable, when dispersion is limited and emissions are trapped near the surface within the surrounding neighborhoods. This potential for neighborhood-level concentration of emissions during evening or multi-day stagnation events raises air quality concerns.

Furthermore, reducing commercial charbroiling emissions is essential to achieving attainment of multiple federal PM2.5 standards. Therefore, the District recommends that the DEIR include a measure requiring the assessment and potential installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers.

The District is available to assist the City and project proponents with this assessment. Additionally, the District is currently offering substantial incentive funding that covers the full cost of purchasing, installing, and maintaining the system during a demonstration period covering two years of operation. Please contact the District at (559) 230-5800 or [email protected] for more information, or visit:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/grants/restaurant-charbroiler-technology-partnership/ Vegetative Barriers and Urban Greening
There are residential units located near the Project. The District suggests the City consider the feasibility of incorporating vegetative barriers and urban greening as a measure to further reduce air pollution exposure on sensitive receptors (e.g., residential units).
place the term " of the VERA'
with "execution of the VERA." This revision would ensure that the Project's 3) ------
4) -----------
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 4 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
While various emission control techniques and programs exist to reduce air quality emissions from mobile and stationary sources, vegetative barriers have been shown pollution through the interception of airborne particles and the update of gaseous pollutants. Examples of vegetative barriers include, but are not limited to the following: trees, bushes, shrubs, or a mix of these. Generally, a higher and thicker vegetative barrier with full coverage will result in greater reductions in downwind pollutant concentrations. In the same manner, urban greening is also a way to help improve air quality and public health in addition to enhancing the overall beautification of a community with drought tolerant, low-maintenance greenery.

Electric Infrastructure
To support and accelerate the installation of electric vehicle charging equipment and development of required infrastructure, the District offers incentives to public agencies, businesses, and property owners of multi-unit dwellings to install electric charging infrastructure (Level 2 and 3 chargers). The purpose of th Charge Up! Incentive program is to promote clean air alternative-fuel technologies and the use of low or zero-emission vehicles. The District recommends that the City and project proponents install electric vehicle chargers at project sites, and at strategic locations.

Please visit https://ww2.valleyair.org/grants/charge-up for more information.

District Rules and Regulations
The District issues permits for many types of air pollution sources, and regulates some activities that do not require permits. A project subject to District rules and regulations would reduce its impacts on air quality through compliance with the regulatory framework. In general, a regulation is a collection of individual rules, each of which deals with a specific topic. As an example, Regulation II (Permits) includes District Rule 2010 (Permits Required), Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review), Rule 2520 (Federally Mandated Operating Permits), and several other rules pertaining to District permitting requirements and processes.

The list of rules below is neither exhaustive nor exclusive. Current District rules can be found online at: https://ww2.valleyair.org/rules-and-planning/current-district-rules-and-regulations. To identify other District rules or regulations that apply to future projects, or to obtain information about District permit requirements, the project proponents are strongly encouraged
Assistance (SBA) Office at (661) 392-5665.
to be an additional measure to potentially reduce a population's exposure to air 5) ------
e District's
6) --------
District's
to contact the District's Small Business
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 5 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
District Rules 2010 and 2201 - Air Quality Permitting for Stationary Sources
Stationary Source emissions include any building, structure, facility, or installation which emits or may emit any affected pollutant directly or as a fugitive emission. District Rule 2010 (Permits Required) requires operators of emission sources to obtain an Authority to Construct (ATC) and Permit to Operate (PTO) from the District. District Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review) requires that new and modified stationary sources of emissions mitigate their emissions using Best Available Control Technology (BACT).

This Project may be subject to District Rule 2010 (Permits Required) and Rule 2201 (New and Modified Stationary Source Review) and may require District permits. Prior to construction, the Project proponent should submit to the District an application for an ATC. For further information or assistance, the (661) 392-5665.

District Rule 9510 - Indirect Source Review (ISR)
The Project is subject to District Rule 9510 because it will receive a project-level discretionary approval from a public agency and will equal or exceed 9,000 square feet of development space.

The purpose of District Rule 9510 is to reduce the growth in both NOx and PM emissions associated with development and transportation projects from mobile and area sources; specifically, the emissions associated with the construction and subsequent operation of development projects. The ISR Rule requires developers to mitigate their NOx and PM emissions by incorporating clean air design elements into their projects. Should the proposed development project clean air design elements be insufficient to meet the required emission reductions, developers must pay a fee that ultimately funds incentive projects to achieve off-site emissions reductions.

Per Section 5.0 of the ISR Rule, an Air Impact Assessment (AIA) application is required to be submitted no later than applying for project-level approval from a public agency. As of the date of this letter, the District has not received an AIA application for this Project. Please inform the project proponent to immediately submit an AIA application to the District to comply with District Rule 9510 so that proper mitigation and clean air design under ISR can be incorporated into . One AIA application should be submitted for the entire Project.

Information about how to comply with District Rule 9510 can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/permitting/indirect-source-review-rule-overview 6a)
project proponent may contact the District's SBA Office at 6b)
the Project's design
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 6 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
The AIA application form can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/permitting/indirect-source-review-rule-overview/forms-and-applications/ District staff is available to provide assistance and can be reached by phone at (559) 230-5900 or by email at [email protected].

District Rule 9410 (Employer Based Trip Reduction)
The Project may be subject to District Rule 9410 (Employer Based Trip Reduction) if the p
employees at a worksite to establish an Employer Trip Reduction Implementation Plan (eTRIP) that encourages employees to reduce single-occupancy vehicle trips, thus reducing pollutant emissions associated with work commutes. Under an eTRIP plan, employers have the flexibility to select the options that work best for their worksites and their employees.

Information about District Rule 9410 can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/compliance/rule-9410-employer-based-trip-reduction/.

For additional information, you can contact the District by phone at 559-230- 6000 or by e-mail at [email protected]
District Rule 4601 (Architectural Coatings)
The Project may be subject to District Rule 4601 since it is expected to utilize architectural coatings. Architectural coatings are paints, varnishes, sealers, or stains that are applied to structures, portable buildings, pavements or curbs.

The purpose of this rule is to limit VOC emissions from architectural coatings.

In addition, this rule specifies architectural coatings storage, cleanup and labeling requirements. Additional information on how to comply with District Rule 4601 requirements can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/tkgjeusd/rule-4601.pdf
District Regulation VIII (Fugitive PM10 Prohibitions)
The project proponent may be required to submit a Construction Notification Form or submit and receive approval of a Dust Control Plan prior to commencing any earthmoving activities as described in Regulation VIII, specifically Rule 8021 Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities.
6c)
6d)
6e)
roject would result in employment of 100 or more "eligible" employees. District Rule 9410 requires employers with 100 or more "eligible" San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Page 7 of 7 District Reference No: 20260846
August 28, 2026
Should the project result in at least 1-acre in size, the project proponent shall provide written notification to the District at least 48 hours prior to the project proponents intent to commence any earthmoving activities pursuant to District Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities). Also, should the project result in the disturbance of 5- acres or more, or will include moving, depositing, or relocating more than 2,500 cubic yards per day of bulk materials, the project proponent shall submit to the District a Dust Control Plan pursuant to District Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities). For additional information regarding the written notification or Dust Control Plan requirements, please contact District Compliance staff at (559) 230-5950.

The application for both the Construction Notification and Dust Control Plan can be found online at: https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/fm3jrbsq/dcp-form.docx Information about District Regulation VIII can be found online at:
https://ww2.valleyair.org/dustcontrol
Other District Rules and Regulations
The Project may also be subject to the following District rules: Rule 4102 (Nuisance) and Rule 4641 (Cutback, Slow Cure, and Emulsified Asphalt, Paving and Maintenance Operations).

District Comment Letter
Project proponent.

If you have any questions or require further information, please contact Ryan Grossman by e-mail at [email protected] or by phone at (559) 230-6569.

Sincerely,
Mark Montelongo
Director of Policy and Government Affairs
Daniel Martinez
Program Manager
6f)
7) -------
The District recommends that a copy of the District's comments be provided to the Letter O1

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department
Attention: Ashley Knight
1715 Chester Avenue
Bakersfield, California 93301

EAHCHAPTER
P.O. Box 3357
Bakersfield, CA 93385
August19,2026
Re: Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for Riverview Marketplace Project; General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 , Site Plan Review No. 22-0223, and Tentative Tract Map No. 7526
Dear Planners:

The Sierra Club offers comments about the above project, a proposed commercial retail center on 46.16 acres at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road in Bakersfield.

As best we can tell, the DEIR does not explain or evaluate Tentative Tract Map No. 7526. The City must not approve a Tentative Tract without public disclosure and proper CEQA evaluation. However, inclusion of affordable high-density housing affordable to lower-income residents in the project via a tentative tract could be a potential additional benefit.

AIR POLLUTION
Bakersfield has arguably the worst air in the nation. According to the American Lung Association, Bakersfield ranks Number 1 in the nation among US cities most polluted by year-round Annual PM2.5 pollution. Bakersfield ranks Number 3 in the nation among US cities most polluted by short-term Daily PM2.5 pollution, and Number 3 in the nation among US cities for exposure to ozone pollution (Am. Lung Ass'n, State of the Air 2026 1 Report, https://www.lung.org/getmedia/32f0646d-c5de-4501-bOac-07 cd63c97 4d4/State-of-the-Air-2026-Report. pdf).

Specifically, according to CalEnviroScreen 4.0 I OEHHA, this project site area is in the 94th percentile for ozone exposure and in the 99th percentile for PM2.5 exposure. Since our extreme air pollution affects the health of many residents, the DEIR must thoroughly address the issue.

Our region is classified as a serious nonattainment area for the 1997 annual PM2.5 standard, a serious nonattainment area for the 2006 24-hour PM2.5 standard, and a serious nonattainment area for the 2012 annual PM2.5 standard. With respect to ozone, the Valley is classified as an extreme ozone nonattainment area for the 2008 8-hour ozone standard and an extreme ozone nonattainment area for the 2015 8-hour ozone standard.

California courts have ruled, "the greater the existing environmental problems are, the lower the threshold should be for treating a project's contribution to cumulative impacts as significant." In a region with arguably the dirtiest air in the nation and where large numbers of Kern County children have asthma, any air pollution additions must be considered significant and adequately mitigated. In the context of air quality in particular, our courts have cautioned that "The magnitude of the current air quality problems in the San Joaquin Valley cannot be used to trivialize the cumulative contributions of the shopping centers and the scope of the analysis cannot be artificially limited to a restricted portion of the air basin." Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v.

City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184, 1219
To this end, the DEIR should adopt a net zero threshold for air pollution impacts.

On page 4.3-27, The DEIR mistakenly states, "project-related construction activities would not cause or contribute to a violation of the ambient air quality standards". As noted above, National Ambient Air Quality Standards are routinely violated in Bakersfield. The additional pollution generated by this project would certainly "contribute" to the cumulative impact of these ongoing violations. The DEIR is deficient in not having thoroughly addressed the project's cumulative contributions to the city's dirty air.

Fruitvale Junior High School is located less than 2600 feet southwest of the project site.

Many children have asthma. Other existing sensitive receptors to the Project Site include the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park to the west along Rosedale Highway and single-family residential uses to the southwest along El Toro Viejo Road.

With no discussion of the project's operational criteria pollutant impacts on the schools and residences, the DEIR improperly concludes that "Impacts would be less than significant." The DEIR is defective in not having thoroughly addressed this project's operational criteria pollutant impact on these sensitive receptors. 2 The DEIR is deficient in not having presented evidence regarding potential valley fever exposure. The project should be required to test the soil for Valley fever spores before drawing this conclusion, all the more important given the proximity to nearby residences and Fruitvale Junior High School and given the recent increase in cases. Kern County sees rise in Valley Fever: New push for awareness and testing Principally, the mitigation measures require this project to comply with weak San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District requirements that have not over the years adequately addressed our local pollution problem. Bakersfield and the surrounding San Joaquin Valley are designated nonattainment under both federal (EPA) and state (GARB) standards for ozone pollution (a major smog component). This means concentrations of ozone exceed allowable limits over time because existing plans and regulation have not been effective in reducing ozone levels to safe levels. Likewise, Bakersfield has historically exceeded federal and state standards for 24-hour PM2.5 annual PM2.5 concentrations. Accordingly, the City of Bakerfield's reliance on SJAVPCD regulations and thresholds of significance is misplaced. If the City insists on relying on these thresholds, the City must at least explain why continued reliance on SJAVPCD thresholds is reasonable in light of the SJVAPCD's inability to reduce ozone and PM2.5 levels to safe levels.

On page 4.3-34, in the section meant to address the cumulative impact of the project, the DEIR concludes that since emissions of ROG, NOX, PM10, and PM2.5 associated with the construction and operation of the project would not exceed the SJVAPCD significance thresholds, therefore the project would not have substantial cumulative impacts. The City illogically asserts that project-specific insignificance implies cumulative insignificance, violating the very meaning of cumulative impacts.

According to CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(3), ""Cumulatively considerable" means that the incremental effects of an individual project are significant when viewed in connection with the effects of past projects, the effects of other current projects, and the effects of probable future projects."
From page 107 and 108 of SJVAPCD's Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/g4nl3p0g/gamagi.pdf):
• "If a project is significant based on the thresholds of significance for criteria pollutants, then it is also cumulatively significant. This does not imply that if the project is below all such significance thresholds, it cannot be cumulatively significant." (Underline added)
• "Lead Agencies should also consider the cumulative impact of multiple simultaneously proposed projects, located within the same area. If the combined impacts of such projects cause or worsen an exceedance of the concentration standards, the project would have a cumulatively significant impact under CEQA."
The City's approach is inconsistent with CEQA's requirement that the environmental documents include analysis of a project's direct AND cumulative impact. Under the 3 City's proposed approach, the DEIR need not undertake any analysis of the project's cumulative impact on air quality because the results would be identical to the direct impacts analysis. But the point of cumulative impact analysis is to understand the significance of the Project's incremental impact in light of the magnitude of the environmental problem to which the project would contribute. The MND must "view" the effects of this project in connection with the effects of at least nearby projects.

The DEIR for this project is defective in that it has not computed or addressed the cumulative emissions from this and other planned projects, cumulative emissions which almost certainly would exceed air quality standards and should be considered significant. In the interest of public health, cumulative emissions computations must include emissions from other planned projects, not just from this project. We include a cumulative list of several of the additional current proposed new projects in the Bakersfield area:
• Table 3-1 of this DEIR lists 51 projects in its list of cumulative projects. • The Bakersfield Commons project is beginning to build just to the south of this project.
• Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7471 just across Morning Drive from this project • Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7427
• Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7495
• Vesting Tentative Tract Map Nos. 6839, 6840, 6841, 6842, 6843 and 6844 • Vesting Tentative Tract Map 7450
• Vesting Tentative Tract Maps 7408 and 7415
• General Plan Amendment/Zone Change No. 22-0128; General Plan Amendment No. 23-0345; and Planned Development Review No. 22-0073 • IPG Industrial Project in unincorporated Kern County. The DEIR for the IPG Industrial Park Project lists 51 projects in its list of cumulative projects. • Expansion of the Wonderful Industrial Park on Seventh Standard Road • Tentative Parcel Map 12447
• General Plan Amendment No. 21-0424
• Conditional Use Permit Case No. 17, Map 121; Zone Variance No. 11 , Map 121 (Kern County)
• GPA#6, Map #122; ZCC #15, Map #122; PD Plan#11, Map#122 (Kern County) • Rosedale Ranch projects
4 • Malibu Vineyards warehouse project adjacent to Highway 99 just north of Bakersfield
• Hageman Industrial Park
• Veteran's Administration Outpatient Clinic
There are likely other such projects of which we are not aware.

The cumulative impacts of this project, of those listed above, and of other area projects on air pollution, traffic, energy, climate change, biological resources, and other issues must be thoroughly addressed, including performance standards that are mandatory, specifically defined, and enforceable.

Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 fails to address the cumulative impact of the project on air pollution. Mitigation Measure MM AQ-1 only requires the project to reduce operational VOC and NOX emissions to below SJVAPCD significance thresholds. 10 annual tons of VOC, 1 O annual tons of NOx, particulate matter emissions, and construction emissions remain unmitigated. MM AQ-1 must be strengthened to require a VERA with all criteria pollutant emissions reduced to zero, not just below weak and ineffective SJVAPCD significance thresholds. Reducing project emissions to zero through a strong Air District contract would help address the potentially significant cumulative air quality impact of this project.

BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
One of the basic purposes of CEQA is to "inform governmental decision makers and the public about the potential, significant environmental effects of proposed activities." (CEQA Guidelines §15006(1).) Here, the DEIR fails to fulfill its informational mandate and does not adequately describe potential impacts on protected species by deferring protocol level surveys and formulation of appropriate mitigation measures.

Post-approval biological surveys do not satisfy CEQA's informational requirements; the decision-makers need to know the results of the biological surveys in order to assess the Project's potential biological impacts BEFORE deciding whether to approve the Project. Post-approval surveys cannot inform the City's decision whether to approve the Project. Moreover, deferred mitigation measures violate CEQA because they lack performance standards to ensure the mitigation goal will be achieved. To address biological resource issues a biological survey and consultation with the USFWS and CDFW should be required before project approval.

In the Cumulative Impact Section 5.2 of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (MBGP) Update EIR, it is stated, "MBHCP and implementing agreements and 5 ordinances provide a method of collecting funds for the acquisition and enhancement of habitat lands for purposes of creating preserves. Development projects within the Planning area and County would pay mitigation fees that would be used to buy habitat lands." Thus the 2002 MBGP depends upon the now-expired Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan (MBHCP) for its biological resource cumulative insignificance conclusion. Now that the MBHCP is no longer in effect, the City can no longer rely on the MBGP and must therefore conduct its own analysis of project impacts on protected species and find alternatives or another way to effectively mitigate significant loss of protected species' habitat.

The DEIR is defective and violates CEQA in that it has not described and assessed the significance of the cumulative effects of ongoing urbanization and habitat loss on protected species. Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Moreover, now that the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan is no longer in effect, the City must find another way to effectively address the Project's contribution to cumulative habitat loss. Many other current or proposed projects are urbanizing habitat for numerous species (see, e.g., the list in the previous section). Potentially significant cumulative impacts to biological resources and viable mitigation measures for these impacts (including purchase of replacement habitat) should be thoroughly studied and addressed in this EIR.

The project property seems to be on and adjacent to potential habitat for a number of species which could forage or exist on the project property. According to Appendix B of the May 2026 General Biological Assessment, regarding the endangered San Joaquin kit fox, "This species was observed during the field survey. This species is present." The conclusion in Table 4.4-2 of the DEIR that no San Joaquin kit foxes are present on the Project site is clearly in error. Thus, the Project site is habitat for the federally endangered San Joaquin kit fox. The DEIR is defective and violates CEQA and ESA in that it has not addressed San Joaquin kit fox species preservation issues. Consultation with state and federal wildlife agencies must be required, not be left to the developer's or the biologist's option.

In the same Appendix B, in regard to the burrowing owl, "This species has the potential to be present."
Loss of habitat is a major reason for species decline. Mitigation for habitat loss and potential species take should include Incidental Take Permit acquisition and purchase of replacement habitat.

To help scientifically reinforce the determination that kit fox use the site, a qualified biologist should extract DNA from onsite potential San Joaquin kit fox scat samples, following a procedure published in 2014 by De Barba et al. (De Barba, M., Adams, J. R., Goldberg, C. S., Stansbury, C. R., Arias, D., Cisneros, R. , & Waits, L. P. (2014). Molecular species 6 identification for multiple carnivores. Conservation Genetics Resources, 6, 821-824). If the scat actually is kit fox scat, then clearly kit fox inhabit the site, and appropriate mitigation must be applied.

While many of these species may have been driven out of the project site by mowing and disking operations, the City should require reintroducing some of the native plant species by replanting them in project open space areas. The project's landscaping should include drought-tolerant and/or native plants.

According to the publication Conservation Strategies for San Joaquin Kit Foxes in Urban Environments by Brian Cypher, Christine Van Horn Job, and Scott Phillips at http://esrp.csustan.edu/publications/pdf/cypher etal 2012 urban kitfox conservation e srp.pdf, "To the extent practical and possible, urban planners could design new developments in a manner that facilitates use by kit foxes." The City should actually require this project to be designed with urban kit fox conservation measures in mind, perhaps including artificial kit fox dens and movement corridors as suggested in the above document. Such a requirement must include performance standards that are mandatory, specifically defined, and enforceable.

CLIMATE CRISIS
There is much important new information on climate change. For example:
• The IPCC AR6 synthesis report (https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/syr/ ) includes warnings that the world is approaching "irreversible" levels of global heating, with catastrophic impacts rapidly becoming inevitable; and that it is "now or never" to take drastic action to avoid disaster.
• "A new study has revealed that the language used by the global climate change watchdog, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), is overly conservative - and therefore the threats are much greater than the Panel's reports suggest."
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/03/19032010201 0.htm • Annual Greenhouse Gas Index (AGGI) - NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory (https://gml.noaa.gov/aggi/) is also substantial and critically important new information.
• Harmful tipping points in the natural world pose some of the gravest threats faced by humanity. Environmental stresses could become so severe that large parts of the natural world are unable to maintain their current state, leading to abrupt and/or irreversible changes. Global Tipping Points I Home (global-tipping-points.org) • The costs of climate change are enormous and affect every sector of the economy.
https://www.law.berkeley.edu/research/clee/research/climate/california-climate-action/costs-of-climate-change/ 7 • UN secretary general, Antonio Guterres, said," This is climate breakdown, in real time. We must exit this road to ruin, and we have no time to lose." World endures 'decade of deadly heat' as 2024 caps hottest years on record l Climate crisis l The Guardian
California courts have ruled, "the greater the existing environmental problems are, the lower the threshold should be for treating a project's contribution to cumulative impacts as significant." The climate crisis is inherently a cumulatively significant issue.

In presumably aligning itself with statewide strategies to reduce GHG emissions, the DEIR is deficient because it fails to acknowledge and analyze the impacts of the Congressional decision (H.J. Res. 88) to revoke the Environmental Protection Agency's Clean Air Act waiver to California. Under this waiver, California was able to adopt its own vehicle emission rules in lieu of federal standards. Relying on the waiver, California mandated that beginning in year 2026, zero emission vehicles must constitute 35% of each auto manufacturer's sales of new motor vehicles. According to California regulations, by 2035 sales of new, fully gas-powered vehicles would have effectively been prohibited in California. California's waiver that led to the regulation of low-nitrogen oxide emissions from heavy-duty highway and off-road vehicles was also revoked.

Without the ability to gradually phase out carbon-emitting cars and trucks, California will not be able to meet its greenhouse gas emission targets, which in turn would require greater emission reductions from every other sector, which could only be implemented through increasingly strict GHG mitigation measures. The City's reliance on these State measures is problematic. The DEIR fails to discuss the Federal Government's revocation of California's ability to set strict car and truck emission standards.

State energy requirements are under constant attack by the Trump administration (see, for example, Trump cuts nearly $8B in clean energy projects in targeted states l AP News ). The One Big Beautiful Bill Act terminates the investment and production tax credits for wind and solar by the end of 2027. The City's reliance on these energy measures is problematic. The DEIR fails to discuss the impact on state and local plans of the Federal Government's attacks and revocation of funding for California's renewable energy projects.

Since the City has shelved adopting a Climate Action Plan, it must be extra diligent in assuring that individual projects like this one satisfy state goals and regulations and legal requirements through adoption of feasible mitigation.

SB 32 requires that statewide greenhouse gas emissions be reduced to 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. Executive Order B-30-15 targets a GHG reduction of 40% below 1990 levels by 2030, codified in SB 32. Executive Order S-3-05 sets an 80% reduction of GHG from 1990 levels in 2050 as a goal. The DEIR must address these requirements.
8 The DEIR considers the project's adverse project-specific and cumulative climate change impacts to be significant. Even after the required mitigation, the project will emit 15,926 MTCO2e annually according to Table 4.8-3. In order to satisfy CEQA requirements and not leave an overheated planet for future generations, the City must adopt all feasible mitigation to reduce this adverse significant impact. Feasible potential additional mitigation measures include:
• A requirement to purchase carbon offset credits incorporating recognized principles of GHG emissions reduction accounting in an amount equal to the estimated CO2e emissions for the life of the project. The credits should be issued by a CARS-approved registry using CARS-approved protocol. • A requirement that all buildings contain enough solar photovoltaics (PV) and solar water heating to offset energy usage to the maximum extent feasible, with a capacity that matches the maximum allowed for distributed solar connections to the grid.
• Green building measures should be required for all structures, including passive solar design and a requirement that buildings be at least 25% more energy efficient than Title 24 standards current when permits are pulled. • Use all electric appliances, without any natural gas connections, and not use propane or other fossil fuels for space heating, water heating, or indoor cooking. (from CARS 2022 scoping plan)
• Relax parking requirements as in the CARS 2022 scoping plan. • To help address the housing crisis, encourage public transit, and lower VMT, the project should include high density housing affordable to lower-income residents. (from CARS 2022 scoping plan)
• A project design requirement that buildings be situated to maximize rooftop solar production.
• Use cool pavement material on new streets and parking lots. • To reinforce and clarify MM GHG-7 and in order to encourage the use of non-polluting electric vehicles, the City should specifically require parking lots for all facets of this project to include dedicated EV parking and charging, including tiers of multiple type fast charge Level 3 EV charging facilities. The stalls should be covered with solar canopies both to protect parked vehicles from heating and to generate clean energy for the project.
• A requirement that the developer contribute to tree planting and urban forestry projects. Tree planting plays an essential role in achieving the goal of reaching net zero GHG emissions. One recent study found that California's working and urban lands have the potential to absorb up to 103 MMT CO2e additional per year by 2030. https://theclimatecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/The-Climate-Center-Setting-an-Ambitious-Sequestration-Goal-for-CA-WL-Jan-22.pdf 9 • Facilitate and promote public transit by providing amenities such as contributing to public transit, facilitating ride-share programs, create incentives for ride-share and/or use of public transit.
• A requirement that the developer contribute a GHG fee to an appropriate entity to be used to fund projects that would reduce GHG emissions elsewhere.

The environmental documents must evaluate these and other potential mitigation measures in order to require sufficient mitigation to substantially reduce the significant impact of the project on the climate crisis. Many of these measures serve as well for air pollution mitigation.

Please place the Sierra Club on the distribution list for this project to receive any noticing of meetings, hearings, availability of documents, and to receive the environmental documents. We prefer email communications and electronic formatting of documents. Thank you for your consideration and for the opportunity to comment.

Sincerely,
~ki.71)/f
Gordon L. Nipp, Ph.D.

Vice-Chair
[email protected]
661-872-2432
10 Letter O2

ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH & CARDOZO
KEVIN T. CARMICHAEL
CHRISTINA M. CARO
THOMAS A. ENSLOW
KELILAH D. FEDERMAN
RICHARD M. FRANCO
TANYA A. GULESSERIAN
RACHAEL E. KOSS
AIDAN P. MARSHALL
ALAURA R. McGUIRE
Of Counsel
DANIELL. CARDOZO
MARC D. JOSEPH

A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION

ATTORNEYS AT LAW
601 GATEWAY BOULEVARD , SUITE 1000
SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO , CA 94080 - 7037
TEL : (650) 589-1660
FAX : (650) 589 - 5062
a mars ha I l@adams broad we 11. com
August 26, 2026
Via Email and Overnight Mail
Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department Planning Division
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Email: [email protected]

SACRAMENTO OFFICE
520 CAPITOL MALL, SUITE 350
SACRAMENTO, CA 95814-4721
TEL : (916) 444 - 6201
FAX: (916) 444-6209
Re: Comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507) Dear Ms. Knight:

We are writing on behalf of Californians Allied for a Responsible Economy ("CARE CA") regarding the Draft Environmental Impact Report ("DEIR") prepared by the City of Bakersfield ("City'') for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (SCH# 2025101507) ("Project"), proposed by DJM Capital Partners ("Applicant").

The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center, that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. 1 It is assumed that larger anchor interior buildings within the Project site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station. Discretionary approvals required to implement the Project include Site Plan Review, General Plan Amendment ("GPA") changing the land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial), Tentative Tract Map, and Comprehensive Sign Plan. 2
1 DEIR, p. ES-1.
2 DEIR, p. ES-2.
8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 2 ends

We reviewed the DEIR with the assistance of air quality expert Dr. James Clark3 and transportation expert Norm Marshall. 4 The City must separately respond to these technical comments. CARE CA's review of the DEIR demonstrates that the DEIR fails to comply with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA").

In summary, the DEIR fails to address potentially significant public health risks by omitting discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever risks. Soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres could expose workers and residents to severe health hazards, but the DEIR does not disclose or mitigate this risk. This risk is especially acute given that Valley Fever is endemic to the area, with 1,848 cases reported in Kern County in 2026 alone. 5 The DEIR also fails to disclose, quantitatively analyze, and mitigate significant public health risks from exposure to Toxic Air Contaminants ("TACs"). The Project's proposed fuel station, char broilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic will emit TACs, yet the DEIR relies on unsupported qualitative heuristics-rather than preparing a formal Health Risk Assessment ("HRA'')-to quantify operational health risk impacts. Furthermore, the DEIR fails to analyze cumulative health risk impacts in conjunction with nearby planned projects and the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution. 6 In addition, the DEIR fails to identify all feasible mitigation for operational air quality impacts (VOCs and NOx). It improperly relies on a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (''VERA'') prior to exhausting all feasible onsite mitigation measures, such as requiring under-fired char broiler controls or enforcing reduced diesel truck idling limits. Regarding transportation impacts, the DEIR contains several errors that underestimate vehicle trip generation and fails to mitigate significant Vehicle Miles Traveled (''VMT") impacts. Despite finding significant and unavoidable VMT impacts, the DEIR fails to require all feasible VMT mitigation, such as Commute Trip Reduction programs in the California Air Pollution Control Officers Association ("CAPCOA'') Handbook. And regarding public utilities, the DEIR lacks analysis of the adequacy of existing infrastructure to provide adequate fire flow to the Project site.
3 Dr. Clark's technical comments and curricula vitae ("Clark Comments") are attached hereto as Exhibit A.
4 Mr. Marshall's technical comments and curricula vitae (''Marshall Comments") are attached hereto as Exhibit B.
5 Clark Comments, p. 12.
6 Clark Comments, p. 10.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 3 ends

As a result of its shortcomings, the DEIR lacks substantial evidence to support its conclusions, violates CEQA's analytical requirements, and fails to properly mitigate the Project's significant environmental impacts. CARE CA urges the City to remedy the deficiencies in the DEIR by preparing a legally adequate revised DEIR and recirculating it for public review and comment. 7 CARE CA reserves the right to provide supplemental comments at any and all later proceedings related to this Project. 8
I. STATEMENT OF INTEREST
CARE CA is non-profit organization which advocates for protecting the environment and the health of their communities' workforces. The organization's members include the District Council of Ironworkers and Southern California Pipe Trades DC 16, along with their members, their families, and other individuals who live and work in the City of Bakersfield and in Kern County. These individuals and labor organization members may be adversely affected by the potential public and worker health and safety hazards, and the environmental impacts of the Project.

CARE CA seeks to ensure a sustainable construction industry over the long-term by supporting projects that offer genuine economic and employment benefits, and which minimize adverse environmental and other impacts on local communities. CARE CA members live, work, recreate, and raise their families in the City of Bakersfield and surrounding communities. Accordingly, they would be directly affected by the Project's environmental and health and safety impacts.

Individual members may also work on the Project itself. They will be first in line to be exposed to any health and safety hazards that exist onsite.

In addition, CARE CA has an interest in enforcing environmental laws that encourage sustainable development and ensure a safe working environment for its members. Environmentally detrimental projects can jeopardize future jobs by making it more difficult and more expensive for business and industry to expand in the region, and by making the area less desirable for new businesses and new residents. Indeed, continued environmental degradation can, and has, caused 7 We reserve the right to supplement these comments at later hearings on this Project. Gov. Code§ 65009(b); Public Resources Code § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184, 1199-1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal.App.4th 1109, 1121.
8 Gov. Code § 65009(b); PRC § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal. App. 4th 1184, 1199-1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal.

App. 4th 1109, 1121.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026
Page4
construction moratoriums and other restrictions on growth that, in turn, reduce future employment opportunities.

II. THE DEIR FAILS TO DISCLOSE, ANALYZE AND MITIGATE

POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS
An EIR must fully disclose all potentially significant impacts of a Project and implement all feasible mitigation to reduce those impacts to less than significant levels. The lead agency's significance determination with regard to each impact must be supported by accurate scientific and factual data. 9 An agency cannot conclude that an impact is less than significant unless it produces rigorous analysis and concrete substantial evidence justifying the finding. 10 Even when the substantial evidence standard is applicable to agency decisions to certify an EIR and approve a project, reviewing courts will not 'uncritically rely on every study or analysis presented by a project proponent in support of its position. A clearly inadequate or unsupported study is entitled to no judicial deference."' 11
Moreover, the failure to provide information required by CEQA is a failure to proceed in the manner required by CEQA. 12 Challenges to an agency's failure to proceed in the manner required by CEQA, such as the failure to address a subject required to be covered in an EIR or to disclose information about a project's environmental effects or alternatives, are subject to a less deferential standard than challenges to an agency's factual conclusions. 13 In reviewing challenges to an agency's approval of an EIR based on a lack of substantial evidence, the court will "determine de novo whether the agency has employed the correct procedures, scrupulously enforcing all legislatively mandated CEQA requirements." 14 Additionally, CEQA requires agencies to commit to all feasible mitigation measures to reduce significant environmental impacts. 15 In particular, the lead agency may not make required CEQA findings, including finding that a project 9 CEQA Guidelines§ 15064(b).
10 Kings Cty. Farm Bur. v. Hanford (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 692, 732. 11 Berkeley Jets, 91 Cal.App.4th at 1355.
12 Sierra Club v. State Bd. Of Forestry (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1215, 1236. 13 Vineyard Area Citizens for Responsible Growth, Inc. v. City of Rancho Cordova (2007) 40 Cal.4th 412,435.
14 Id., Madera Oversight Coal., Inc. v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 102. 15 CEQA Guidelines§ 15002(a)(2).
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 5 ends

impact is significant and unavoidable, unless the administrative record demonstrates that it has adopted all feasible mitigation to reduce significant environmental impacts to the greatest extent feasible. 16 A. The DEIR Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Potentially Significant Valley Fever Risks
The DEIR fails to disclose, analyze, and mitigate exposure to Coccidiodes Immitis (Valley Fever cocci) that may be disturbed during construction activities.

The DEIR fails to include any discussion or mitigation of this impact, which poses potentially significant health risks to workers and nearby residences.

Dr. Clark explains that when soil containing cocci spores are disturbed by construction activities, the fungal spores become airborne, exposing construction workers and other nearby sensitive receptors. 17 Valley Fever is the initial form of coccidioidomycosis infection, and can develop into a more serious disease, including chronic and disseminated coccidioidomycosis. 18 This puts workers and nearby residents at risk, particularly during earth-disturbing activities. 19 Airborne spores could be blown into the residential communities near the Project site.

Valley Fever risks are potentially significant for development of this Project site because Valley Fever is endemic to the area and the Project would disturb over 46 acres. Dr. Clark reviewed data demonstrating that Kern County has among the highest rates of Valley Fever (coccidioidomycosis) in California, with 1,848 cases of Valley Fever reported just in 2026. 20
The DEIR is inadequate as an informational document because it fails to disclose a significant effect on public health. CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(4) provides that the City is required to find that a project will have a significant impact on the environment if the environmental effects of a project will cause a substantial adverse effect on human beings. 21 Workers' and nearby residents' 16 PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines§§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883. 17 Clark Comments, p. 12.
18 Mayo Clinic, Valley Fever Overview, https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/valley-fever/symptoms-causes/syc-20378761 . 19 Clark Comments, p. 13.
20 Id. at 12.
21 PRC § 21083(b)(3), (d); see Cal. Build. Indust. Ass'n v. BAAQMD (2015) 62 Cal.4th 369, 388-90 ("CBIA v. BAAQMIJ') (disturbance of toxic soil contamination at project site is potentially significant 8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 6 ends

potential exposure to Valley Fever from Project construction activities constitutes a substantial adverse effect on human beings.

The DEIR also fails to accurately describe the environmental setting. CEQA requires that a lead agency include a description of the physical environmental conditions in the vicinity of the Project as they exist at the time environmental review commences. 22 Use of the proper baseline is critical to a meaningful assessment of a project's environmental impacts. 23 By failing to disclose existing Valley Fever incident rates and failing to assess the potential for Valley Fever spores in soil at the Project site, the DEIR fails to accurately evaluate the likelihood of exposure to Valley Fever cocci.

The DEIR also fails to mitigate this potentially significant impact. Dr. Clark explains that compliance with standard dust control regulations such as SJV APCD Regulation VIII/ Rule 8021 does not meaningfully reduce Valley Fever risks. 24 Conventional dust control measures do not prevent the spread Valley Fever because they largely focus on visible dust or larger dust particles-the PM10 fraction-not the very fine particles where the Valley Fever spores are found. 25 Dr. Clark proposes feasible and effective mitigation measures that must be considered in a revised DEIR that acknowledges the potentially significant risk of exposure to Valley Fever.26
In sum, the DEIR must be revised to disclose and mitigate this impact in a recirculated EIR.
impact requiring CEQA review and mitigation); Madera Oversight Coalition v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 82; Berkeley Keep Jets Over the Bay Com. v. Bd. of Port Comrs. (''Berkeley Jets'? (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1344, 1370-71. 22 CEQA Guidelines, § 15125, subd. (a).
23 Communities for a Better Environment v. South Coast Air Quality Management District (2010) 48 Ca.4th 310, 320.
24 Clark Comments, p. 12.
25 Clark Comments, p. 13.
26 Id. at 13-16.
8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 7 ends

B. The DEIR Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Health Risk Impacts From Project Operations

1. The DEIR Fails to Analyze Health Risks from the Project's Operational Emissions
The Project proposes uses that would generate Toxic Air Contaminants ("TACs"). 27 TACs would be emitted by a proposed fuel station, car wash, char broilers used in restaurants, and heavy-duty trucks. 28 The DEIR finds that health risks from exposure to these emissions would be less than significant, relying on several qualitative arguments. 29 The DEIR argues that health risks can be expected to be less than significant because the Project proposes retail uses, not industrial or warehousing uses. 30 The DEIR also argues that the Project would not run afoul of CARB land use siting guidelines, which recommend against siting sensitive land uses within 500 feet of urban roadways and freeways with 100,000 vehicles per day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles per day. 31 And the DEIR argues that stationary source emissions would be subject to further study when applying for air permits. 32 These arguments do not rise to the level of substantial evidence and do not meet CEQA's informational standards.

CEQA requires analysis of human health impacts. CEQA Guidelines Section 15065(a)(4) requires lead agencies to find a project will have a significant impact on the environment and prepare an EIR if the environmental effects of a project will cause a substantial adverse effect on human beings. 33 The Supreme Court has also explained that CEQA requires the lead agency to disclose the health consequences that result from exposure to a project's air emissions. 34 Courts have held that an environmental review document must disclose a project's potential health risks to a 27 TACs such as DPM have been linked to a range of serious health problems including an increase in respiratory disease, lung damage, cancer, and premature death. SCAQMD, Classification of Diesel PM as a Carcinogen, https://www.agmd.gov/home/rules-compliance/compliance/toxic-hot-spots-ab-2588/iws-facilities/dice/dice-b2; OEHHA, Health Effects of Diesel Exhaust (May 21, 2001), https://oehha.ca.gov/media/downloads/calenviroscreen/indicators/diesel4-02.pdf. 2s DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
29 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
30 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
31 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
32 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
33 PRC § 21083(b)(3), (d).
34 Sierra Club v. County of Fresno (2018) 6 Cal.5th 502, 516, 523. 8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 8 ends

degree of specificity that would allow the public to make the correlation between the project's impacts and adverse effects to human health. 35 In Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield, the court found that the EIR's description of health risks were insufficient and that after reading them, "the public would have no idea of the health consequences that result when more pollutants are added to a nonattainment basin."36 Likewise, in Sierra Club, the California Supreme Court held that the EIR's discussion of health impacts associated with exposure to the named pollutants was too general and the failure of the EIR to indicate the concentrations at which each pollutant would trigger the identified symptoms rendered the report inadequate. 37 Some connection between air quality impacts and their direct, adverse effects on human health must be made. As the Court explained, "a sufficient discussion of significant impacts requires not merely a determination of whether an impact is significant, but some effort to explain the nature and magnitude of the impact." 38 CEQA mandates discussion, supported by substantial evidence, of the nature and magnitude of impacts of air pollution on public health. 39
For development projects like this one, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment's ("OEHHA'') risk assessment guidelines recommend a formal health risk analysis ("HRA") for short-term construction exposures to TACs lasting longer than 2 months and exposures from projects lasting more than 6 months should be evaluated for the duration of the project. 40 In an HRA, lead agencies must first quantify the concentration released into the environment at each of the sensitive receptor locations through air dispersion modeling, calculate the dose of each TAC at that location, and quantify the cancer risk and hazard index for each of the chemicals of concern. Following that analysis, then the City can make a determination of the relative significance of the emissions. The DEIR provides that exposure to TACs would be significant if it would result in a cancer risk greater 35 Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184. 36 Id. at 1220.
37 Sierra Club, at 521.
38 Id. at 519, citing Cleveland National Forest Foundation v. San Diego Assn. of Governments (2017) 3 Cal.5th 497, 514-515.
39 Sierra Club, 6 Cal.5th at 518-522.
40 Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA), Risk Assessment Guidelines:

Guidance Manual for Preparation of Health Risk Assessments, February 2015 (OEHHA 2015), Section 8.2.10: Cancer Risk Evaluation of Short Term Projects, pp. 8-17/18; https:// oehha.ca. gov/ air/ crnr/notice-adoption -air-toxics-hot-spots-program -guidance-manual-preparation -health-risk-0. 8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 9 ends

than or equal to 20 in a million and/or a Hazard Index greater than or equal to 1 for noncancer risk. 41
The DEIR's qualitative discussion fails to meet these standards. The argument that the Project would not result in significant health risks by virtue of being a retail project fails because it is a mere heuristic that ignores the specific uses proposed by the Project. As explained in SJVAPCD's comments on the NOP, the Project's "charbroilers may pose the potential for immediate health risk, particularly when located in densely populated areas or near sensitive receptors." 42 These emissions would combine with emissions from the proposed fuel station, car wash, and heavy-duty trucks. The assertion that retail projects generally do not result in health risk impacts does not actually investigate the risks from this particular project, thus failing to meet CEQA's informational and analytical requirements.

Next, the DEIR's reference to the CARE land use siting guidelines is misleading. 43 The DEIR claims that whereas CARE recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways. 44 This argument is misleading because these vehicle trip thresholds concern "Freeways and High-Traffic Roads," not trips generated by individual development projects. 45 Significant health risk impacts can result from far fewer trips. For example, the same guidelines recommend against siting new sensitive land uses within 1,000 feet of a distribution center accommodating more than 100 trucks per day. This Project would result in 751 daily VMT for heavy trucks, demonstrating that the Project would present similar health risks as a warehouse project. 46
The DEIR's argument that stationary source emissions would be analyzed separately at a later stage constitutes piecemealing in violation of CEQA. CEQA defines a "project" as "the whole of an action" that may result in either a direct physical environmental change or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change. 47 CEQA 41 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
42 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
43 DEIR, p. 4.3-31.
44 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32.
45 CARB, Air Quality And Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective, p. 4, available at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2023-05/Land%20Use%20Handbook 0.pdf. 46 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119.
47 14 Cal. Code Regs. Sec. 15378.
8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 10 ends

mandates "that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large project into many little ones - each with a minimal potential impact on the environment - which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences." 48 Here, the DEIR attempts to piecemeal the health risk impacts of the stationary sources from the other sources, and does not contain a supported analysis of the Project's total health risk impacts. This violates CEQA's requirement that the whole of the action be analyzed. The promise of future study of the stationary sources does not correct this error.

In sum, the DEIR fails to quantify sensitive receptors' exposure to operational TACs and compare the impact to the City's quantitative threshold. As such, no connection between the Project's emissions and their direct, adverse effects on human health has been made. 49 For these reasons, the City lacks substantial evidence to conclude that the significance threshold would not be exceeded. The potentially significant health risk impacts must be analyzed and mitigated in a recirculated EIR.

2. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative
Health Risk Impacts
The DEIR fails to adequately analyze the significance of the Project's cumulative health risk impacts. The DEIR asserts that any exceedance of a project-level threshold (cancer risk of 20 in one million) also is considered to be a cumulatively considerable effect, while health risks that fall below applicable project-level thresholds are not considered cumulatively considerable. 50 The DEIR concludes that this Project's health risk impact would not be cumulatively considerable because it would not exceed the project-level thresholds. 51 This approach is unsupported. First, as discussed above, the DEIR did not actually quantify the Project's operational health risks and compare them to the significance threshold. Thus, the City lacks substantial evidence to conclude that the quantitative threshold was not exceeded. Second, the DEIR's approach fails to 48 Bozung v. LAFCO (1975) 13 Cal.3d 263, 283-84; City of Santee v. County of San Diego (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1438, 1452; Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 151, 165.
49 Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. City of Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1184. 50 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 ("projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.").
51 Id.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 11 ends

consider the Project's cumulative effects with existing and proposed development near Project site as required by CEQA. 52
A leading case on this issue is Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford. 53 In Kings County, the city prepared an EIR for a 26.4-megawatt coal-fired cogeneration plant. Notwithstanding the fact that the EIR found that the project region was out of attainment for PM10 and ozone, the city failed to incorporate mitigation for the project's cumulative air quality impacts from project emissions because it concluded that the Project would contribute "less than one percent of area emissions for all criteria pollutants."54 The city reasoned that, because the project's air emissions were small in ratio to existing air quality problems, that this necessarily rendered the project's "incremental contribution" minimal under CEQA. The court rejected this approach, finding it "contrary to the intent of CEQA," and that "[t]he EIR improperly focused upon the individual project's relative effects and omitted facts relevant to an analysis of the collective effect this and other sources will have upon air quality." 55 The City of Fontana was recently sued by the State Attorney General for failing to adequately analyze cumulative impacts. 56 Citing Kings County, the Attorney General's petition explained: "[t]o the extent that the 2003 SCAQMD White Paper asserts that any project with less than significant individual air quality impacts also necessarily has less than significant cumulative air quality impacts, it is inconsistent with CEQA."57 The Attorney General's litigation resulted 52 DEIR, p. 4.3-34.
53 Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (1990) 221 Cal. App. 3d 692 ("Kings County"); see also, Friends of Oroville v. City of Oroville (2013) 219 Cal. App. 4th 832, 841-42. 54 Kings County, supra, at 719.
55 Id. at 721; see also People of the State of California v. City of Fontana, Case No. CIVSB2121829, Petition for Writ of Mandate, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2021/20210723 docket-CIVSB2121829 petition-for-writ-of-mandate.pdf ("The MND' s cumulative air quality impact analysis does not account for-or even acknowledge-the multitude of other warehouses near the Project. Rather than consider the environmental setting within which the Project will be situated, the MND simply states that the Project will not result in a cumulatively considerable increase in emissions because the Project's individual air quality impacts will be less than significant. The MND even applies this reasoning to its analysis of health impacts from localized emissions, despite making no attempt to determine or disclose the severity of the existing health impacts from localized emissions in the community") 56 People of the State of California v. City of Fontana, Case No. CIVSB2121829, Petition for Writ of Mandate, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2021/20210723 docket-CIVSB2121829 petition-for-writ-of-mandate.pdf. 51 Id.
8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 12 ends

in a settlement which requires compliance with an ordinance adopted on April 12, 2022 that establishes standards intended to address cumulative air quality impacts. 58
This DEIR's analysis is similarly flawed because it improperly focuses upon the individual Project's relative effects and omits facts relevant to an analysis of the collective effect this and other sources will have upon air quality. To begin with, the DEIR does not evaluate the significance of the combined emissions from the Project and other projects listed in Table 3-1 of the DEIR. 59 Combined emissions from these projects may result in significant air quality and health risks, but this is not analyzed in the DEIR.

Further, the DEIR does not consider existing pollution burden when evaluating the significance of cumulative health risks. The CalEnviroScreen 5.0 health screening tool shows that the Project would impact a census tract in the 99th percentile for PM 2.5 pollution. 60 The Project would introduce new construction and operational sources of PM 2.5 that would increase health risks. Potentially significant cumulative health risks are unanalyzed in the DEIR, in violation of CEQA and the principles articulated in Kings County.

In sum, the DEIR's cumulative air quality impacts analysis fails to comply with CEQA. The City must prepare a revised EIR that properly evaluates and mitigates such impacts.

C. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Significant Air Quality Impacts

1. The DEIR Fails to Identify All Feasible Air Quality
Mitigation
The DEIR finds that the Project would result in significant emissions of VOCs and NOx. 61 The DEIR claims that these significant impacts would be fully mitigated through two mitigation measures: entering into a Voluntary Emission 58 Id., Stipulation For Entry Of Final Judgment On Consent, available at https://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/case-documents/2022/20220414 docket-CIVSB2121605-CIVSB2121829 stipulation.pdf. 59 DEIR, p. 3-2, Table 3-1.
60 Clark Comments, p. 10.
61 DEIR, p. ES-5, 6.
8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 13 ends

Reduction Agreement (''VERA'') with SJV APCD (MM AQ-1) and requiring use of low-VOC paint (MM AQ-2). 62 MM AQ-1 is not supported by substantial evidence because SJV APCD regulations provide that VERAs should only be entered into after all onsite mitigation measures are implemented. 63 Specifically, this Project is subject to SJV APCD's Indirect Source Rule ("ISR") 9510. 64 The Project is subject to District Rule 9510 because it will receive a project-level discretionary approval from a public agency and will equal or exceed 9,000 square feet of development space. 65 Rule 9510 provides that VERAs should only be entered into after all onsite mitigation measures are implemented. 66 Here, the DEIR contains no evidence that the City identified all feasible air quality mitigation available for the Project before turning to a VERA. Therefore, MM AQ-1 is inconsistent with SJV APCD regulations and is unsupported by substantial evidence.

Feasible onsite mitigation measures are identified in SJV APCD's comments on the NOP. 67 For example, SJV APCD recommends reducing the permissible idling time of diesel trucks, 68 but the DEIR fails to evaluate the feasibility of reducing the permissible idling period below the five minutes already required by law. 69 SJVAPCD also recommends requiring under-fired char broilers, but the DEIR fails to identify this as a mitigation measure or demonstrate that it would be infeasible. 70 The DEIR must be revised to identify and incorporate all feasible on-site mitigation measures before allowing excess emissions to be mitigated through a VERA. 62 DEIR, p. 4.3-30, 31.
63 SJV APCD, Emission Reduction Credits (ERC), https://www.valleyair.org/permitting/emission-reduction-credits-erc/ ("ERCs are required in addition to, and only after, establishing that the new emissions are controlled with the best available control technology (BACT) and will not cause a health risk to surrounding communities"); SJVAPCD, ISR Brochure, 2025, https://ww2. valleyair .org/media/thuaubuq/isr-brochure-2025-web. pdf ("Developers are encouraged to reduce as much air pollution as possible through on-site mitigation, or incorporating clean air design measures into the project.").
64 Available at https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/cjlnn0ul/r9510-a.pdf. 65 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 26.
66 SJV APCD Rule 9510, Section 3.25, available at https://ww2.valleyair.org/media/cjlnn0ul/r9510- a.pdf ("Off-Site Emission Reduction Fee (Off-Site Fee): a fee to be paid by the applicant to the District for any emission reductions required by the rule that are not achieved through on-site emission reduction measures."); id., Section 7.1.1.1 ("The applicant shall pay to the District a monetary sum necessary to offset the required construction NOx emissions not reduced on-site."); 67 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 18 et seq.
6s DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
69 DEIR, p. 4.3-5.
10 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 14 ends

D. The DEIR Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate
Transportation Impacts

1. The DEIR Overestimates the Number of Pass-by Trips
The DEIR estimates that the Project's gasoline service station would generate 10,196 daily trips, including 7,316 pass-by trips. 71 This number of pass-by trips is a combination of 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips. 72 Mr.

Marshall demonstrates that the DEIR underestimates trips generated by the Project by conflating two different types of trips: "pass-by'' and "diverted" trips.

Pass-by trips are trips where a driver is already driving right past the Project on their normal route, adding zero new cars to the surrounding neighborhood streets because they were on that exact road anyway. 73 Diverted trips are trips where a driver goes out of their way specifically to visit the Project. Because they are driving extra miles on roads they would not normally use, they add new traffic and increase Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT). 74 By erroneously treating these two types of trips as "pass-by'' trips, the DEIR underestimates the Project's vehicle trips.

The DEIR's analysis is thus unsupported by substantial evidence.

2. The Trip Generation Rate for the Gasoline Service
Station is Unsupported
The DEIR estimates the gasoline service station's trip generation rate using the Costco transportation database, which contains data related to Costco fuel facilities. 75 But the DEIR's approach is not supported by substantial evidence. Mr.

Marshall observes that the proposed gasoline service station is significantly different than the sites included in the Costco database. 76 The proposed gasoline service station has more fueling positions, 40, than at any of the sites in the Costco database, and is also unique in that it is not collocated with a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site (located 3 miles away). 77 The fact that this fuel station is not collocated with a Costco Warehouse means that there cannot be any combined 71 DEIR, p. 4.16-10, Table 4.16-2.
12 DEIR, Appendix H, p. 361.
73 Marshall Comments, p. 3.
74/d.
75 DEIR, p. 4.16-10.
76 Marshall Comments, p. 5.
77 Id.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 15 ends

gasoline/warehouse trips within the same site. As a result, the DEIR's trip generation rate does not reasonably reflect the proposed gasoline service station's trip generation and pass-by trip percentage.

3. The DEIR Fails to Identify All Feasible VMT Mitigation The DEIR finds that the Project would result in an overall net increase in countywide roadway VMT and that the proposed medical office use would exceed the applicable VMT per employee threshold. 78 The DEIR asserts that these significant impacts would be significant and unavoidable despite implementing feasible mitigation. 79 The DEIR states that it has been designed to include enhanced pedestrian connectivity, new and expanded bicycle facilities, end-of-trip bicycle amenities, and that no other feasible mitigation is available. 80 The DEIR states that these measures correspond to California Air Pollution Control Officers Association ("CAPCOA") measures T-10, T-18, and T-19. 81 However, Mr. Marshall identifies additional feasible mitigation for the Project which would result in considerable reductions in VMT.

CEQA requires agencies to commit to all feasible mitigation measures to reduce significant environmental impacts. 82 In particular, the lead agency may not make required CEQA findings, including finding that a project impact is significant and unavoidable, unless the administrative record demonstrates that it has adopted all feasible mitigation to reduce significant environmental impacts to the greatest extent feasible. 83
Here, Mr. Marshall demonstrates that CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary), would be feasible and effective. 84 Measures within the scope of Measure T-5 include employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure 78 DEIR, p. 4.16-15, 16.
1s DEIR, p. 4.16-16.
80 DEIR, p. 4.16-16.
81 DEIR, p. 4.16-16; see California Air Pollution Control Officers Association Handbook for Analyzing Greenhouse Gas Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity (2021).
82 CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2).
83 PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883. 84 Marshall Comments, p. 2; CAPCOA Handbook, T-5,
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-5.pdf. 8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 16 ends

T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home. 85 The CAPCOA Handbook states that up to 20.4% reduction is possible with vanpooling (T-11) when the employer covers "the capital costs of vehicle acquisition and the labor costs of drivers, either through incentives to current employees or the hiring of dedicated drivers." 86 The City should also assess the feasibility of Commute Trip Reduction programs pursuant to CAPCOA Measure T-6 ("Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring''). 87 These can reduce GHG emissions from employee commute VMT by up to 26%. 88 The Handbook states:

The mandatory CTR program must include all other elements (i.e., Measures T-7 through T-11) [T-7 Implement Commute Trip Reduction Marketing, T-8 Provide Ridesharing Program, T-9 Implement Subsidized or Discounted Transit Program, T-10 Provide End-of-Trip Bicycle Facilities, and T-11 Provide Employer-Sponsored Vanpool] described for the voluntary program (Measure T-5) plus include mandatory trip reduction requirements (including penalties for non-compliance) and regular monitoring and reporting to ensure the calculated VMT reduction matches the observed VMT reduction.

To meet CEQA's requirement of reducing significant impacts to the greatest extent feasible, the DEIR must assess whether these and other CAPCOA measures would feasibly reduce VMT. Newly identified measures must be included in a recirculated DEIR.

E. The DEIR Fails to Analyze Potentially Significant Public Utilities Impacts
Under CEQA, a public utilities impact is considered significant if a project would "[r]equire or result in the relocation or construction of new or expanded water, wastewater treatment or storm water drainage, electric power, natural gas, or telecommunications facilities the construction or relocation of which could cause 85 Marshall Comments, p. 2.
86 https://www .caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-l l. pdf. 87 CAPCOA Handbook, T-6. Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring)
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-6.pdf. 88/d.
8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 17 ends

significant environmental effects."89 The DEIR states that no impacts would result from connections to utilities. 90 However, this conclusion is not supported by substantial evidence.

For example, the DEIR fails to disclose the fire flow requirements for this Project, whether that fire flow would be met by existing infrastructure (once the Project is connected to it), and the environmental impacts resulting from construction of any necessary improvements. This information is necessary to evaluate whether upsized water mains and other offsite upgrades are required.

Construction of improvements to existing water infrastructure may be required because the Project proposes a large new development on a vacant site. Further, the Bakersfield system has historic low-pressure areas where the minimum normal operating pressure ranges between 25 and 40 psi. 91 Upgrades to the system may be required to service the Project. The DEIR omits analysis of these considerations.

If needed, construction of improvements to water infrastructure would have environmental impacts not analyzed in the DEIR. Construction activities may result in significant environmental impacts in several areas, including traffic, noise, vibration, and health risk. Impacts may occur closer to sensitive receptors than analyzed in the DEIR because construction of utilities improvements may occur offsite and potentially closer to sensitive receptors.

By omitting analysis of these considerations, the DEIR fails as an informational document and fails to support its finding of a less-than-significant impact with substantial evidence. A revised EIR must be prepared to analyze these potentially significant impacts.

II. THE STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATION MUST

CONSIDER WHETHER THE PROJECT PROVIDES EMPLOYMENT

OPPORTUNITIES FOR HIGHLY TRAINED WORKERS
The City concludes in the DEIR that the Project will have significant and unavoidable impacts from VMT and emissions of GHGs. Therefore, in order to approve the Project, CEQA requires the City to adopt a statement of overriding considerations, providing that the Project's overriding benefits outweigh its s9 DEIR, p. ES-25.
90 Id.
91 California Water Service, Capital Project Justification Bakersfield District, July 2021, p. 97, https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/SupDoc/A2107002/3862/393926055.pdf. 8343-005acp
Qprinted on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 18 ends

environmental harm. 92 An agency's determination that a project's benefits outweigh its significant, unavoidable impacts "lies at the core of the lead agency's discretionary responsibility under CEQA."93
The City must set forth the reasons for its action, pointing to supporting substantial evidence in the administrative record. 94 This requirement reflects the policy that public agencies must weigh a project's benefits against its unavoidable environmental impacts, and may find the adverse impacts acceptable only if the benefits outweigh the impacts. 95 Importantly, a statement of overriding considerations is legally inadequate if it fails to accurately characterize the relative harms and benefits of a project. 96
In this case, the City must find that the Project's significant, unavoidable impacts outweigh the Project's benefits to the community. CEQA specifically references employment opportunities for highly trained workers as a factor to be considered in making the determination of overriding benefits. 97 Currently, there is not substantial evidence in the record showing that the Project's significant, unavoidable impacts are outweighed by benefits to the community. For example, there is no evidence in the record that the Applicant has made any commitments to employ graduates of state approved apprenticeship programs or taken other steps to ensure employment of highly trained and skilled craft workers on Project construction, an action contemplated by CEQA Section 21081. Absent substantial evidence in the record demonstrating that the Project's benefits outweigh its environmental costs, the City would not fulfill its obligations under CEQA if it adopted a statement of overriding considerations and approved the Project.

We urge the City to prepare and circulate a revised EIR which identifies the Project's potentially significant impacts, requires all feasible mitigation measures and analyzes all feasible alternatives to reduce impacts to a less than significant level. If a Statement of Overriding Considerations is adopted for the Project, we urge the City to consider whether the Project will result in employment opportunities for highly trained workers.
92 CEQA Guidelines, § 15043.
93 Laurel Heights Improvement Assn. v. Regents of University of California (1988) 4 7 Cal.3d 376, 392. 94 Pub. Resources Code,§ 21081, subd. (b); CEQA Guidelines,§ 15093, subds. (a) and (b); Cherry Valley Pass Acres & Neighbors v. City of Beaumont (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 316,357. 95 Pub. Resources Code,§ 21081(b); CEQA Guidelines,§ 15093, subds. (a) and (b) 96 Woodward Park Homeowners Association v. City of Fresno (2007) 150 Cal.App.4th 683, 717. 97 Pub. Resources Code, § 21081, subds. (a)(3) and (b). 8343-005acp
()printed on recycled paper
August 26, 2026

Page 19 ends

III. CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, the DEIR for the Project is inadequate under CEQA. It must be revised to provide legally adequate analysis of, and mitigation for, all of the Project's potentially significant impacts. These revisions will necessarily require that the DEIR be recirculated for additional public review.

Until the DEIR has been revised and recirculated, as described herein, the City may not lawfully approve the Project.

Thank you for your consideration of these comments. Please include them in the record of proceedings for the Project.

Attachments
APM:acp
8343-005acp
Sincerely,
Aidan P. Marshall
Qprinted on recycled paper

EXHIBIT A
Letter O2A
0 To
Too
Clark & Associates
Environmental Consulting, Inc.

OFFICE
12405 Venice Blvd
Suite 331
Los Angeles, CA 90066
PHONE
310-907-6165
EMAIL
[email protected]
August 21, 2026
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080
Attn: Mr. Aidan P. Marshall
Subject: Comment Letter on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace
Commercial Project, City of Bakersfield, Kern
County, California (State Clearinghouse No.
2025101507)
Dear Mr. Marshall:

At the request of Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo (ABJC), Clark and Associates (Clark) has reviewed the City of Bakersfield (City) DEIR for the above-referenced Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), together with its Appendix B (Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas, and Energy Technical Study) and Appendix F (Hazards, including the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment and supporting reports).

Clark's review of the materials in no way constitutes a validation of the conclusions or materials contained within the DEIR. If I do not comment on a specific item, this does not constitute acceptance of that item.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The Project proposes an approximately 405,531-square-foot commercial retail center on an approximately 46-acre site in the City of Bakersfield. As described in the DEIR, the Project would include, among other uses, a fuel/service station with 20 dual-sided fuel Page ll
dispensers ( 40 fueling positions), a car wash, and restaurant and other retail uses. According to the State Water Resources Control Board's (SWRCB's) GeoTracker website, the Project site was the PG&E Kem Power Plant from 1948 until it was shut down in 1985. The Site consisted of two natural gas and oil burning power generation facilities, four above-ground fuel oil tanks, cooling towers, switchyards, substations, support buildings, and discharge pond. PG&E stored fuel oil in the four above-ground storage tanks and had a combined capacity of 10,150,000 gallons.

Blowdown and wastewater generated during maintenance activities on the cooling system and during routine plant operations was discharged to a drainage pond. Previously the Site had cooling towers that were demolished and the surrounding area was remediated for soil contamination. The 230-kilovolt substation that was added between 1956 and 1961 is still in operation. In October of 2001 the old incinerator and associated debris piles were removed and the soil underneath was remediated.

The Site is adjacent to the Former Sunland Refinery and has been impacted by their hydrocarbon plume." 1
The Site is also under a Land Use Control document (LUC) that was executed in February 2019.

The LUC was executed due to the presence of hazardous substances and hazardous materials, as defined in Health and Safety Code section 25260, at the Property, the Regional Water Board has concluded that it is reasonably necessary to restrict the use of the Property to protect present or future human health or safety or the environment, and that this Covenant is required as part of the Regional Water-Board-approved remedy for the Property.

The LUC states that "Soil at the Property is contaminated with total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) as diesel (TPH-d), TPH as motor oil (TPH-mo), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs ), and Title 22 metals. The conditions at the Property are more extensively described in the North Area Remedial Action Completion Report (approved by Regional Water Board on Dec. 6, 2016) and the South Area Remedial Action Completion Report (approved by Regional Water Board on Feb. 1, 2018). These reports and related documents are 1 SWRCB. 2026. https://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/profile report?global id=SLT5FP024290 accessed August 10, 2026.

Page 12 ends

available on the State Water Resources Control Board's GeoTracker Database (Site ID# SL T5FP024290)."2.

MYR,CKS
CORNER
S~ fler
SmithCoJe,
Figure 1: Project Site Location
GS

SHEN OAKS
CI\MPUS PARK
East
Bakersfiel-0
Hillcrest
Municipal Airpon
Re, land Acres
Pumpkin
Center'
El Adobe
Alameda
Fuller Acres
Lamont
@)
Weedpatch
Tarina
Oi Giorgio
Edmundson
Acres
The site lies within the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SN AB), which is designated nonattainment for ozone, PM2.s, and PM10, and is regulated by the SN APCD.

ENVIRONMENTAL AND COMMUNITY SETTING
The Project Site is located in an urbanized area of northwest Bakersfield, on the south side of Rosedale Highway between El Toro Viejo Road to the west and Coffee Road to the east, north of the railroad tracks, on the former PG&E Kem Power Plant property (DEIR, Section 2 and Figure 2-2, Local Vicinity Map).
2 SWRCB. 2026. Land Use Covenant.
https://documents.geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/regulators/deliverable _ documents/1239606559/KPP _Recorded_ L UC_20190206.pdf

Page 13 ends

The land-uses immediately surrounding the Project Site are predominantly commercial and utility/industrial rather than residential. To the north are Rosedale Highway and the Northwest Promenade commercial retail center; to the east are Coffee Road, the Friant-Kem Canal, and a commercial retail center; to the south are a Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) electric substation, vacant land, and the railroad tracks; and to the west are El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a second PG&E electric substation. In addition, the former Sunland/World Oil refinery lies approximately 980 feet to the east. It is clear that the Project Site is ringed by a number of pollution-generating businesses, including two electric substations, an active rail line, the Rosedale Highway corridor, and a former refinery with open cleanup cases (see Comment 5).

Residential and other sensitive receptors are located a few hundred feet to roughly a quarter-mile from the Project Site, principally to the west, southwest, and north. As identified in the DEIR's health risk analysis, the nearest off-site sensitive receptors include a mobile-home park approximately 750 feet to the west, single-family residences approximately 800 feet to the southwest, and single-family residences approximately 1,300 feet to the north, together with two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west across El Toro Viejo Road that the DEIR conservatively assumes to be residences (DEIR, Section 4.3). The presence of a mobile-home park among the nearest receptors is notable, because mobile-home populations tend to include a higher proportion of elderly and lower-income residents; those groups that are among the most susceptible to air-pollution exposure.

Page 14 ends

Figure 2: Site Vicinity Map
Although the census tract in which the Project is located is not a designated disadvantaged community, the adjacent census tracts are designated as SB 535 communities. According to the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results reported in Appendix B, the tract ranks in approximately the 99th percentile statewide for fine respirable particulate matter (PM2.s) and the 94th percentile for ozone (03), with elevated burdens for drinking water (73rd percentile), traffic (67th percentile), diesel particulate matter (55th percentile), groundwater threats (60th percentile), and hazardous-waste facilities and generators (54th percentile). The tract's overall CalEnviroScreen 4.0 score is 30, and it is not designated under Senate Bill 535, Assembly Bill 1550, or Assembly Bill 617. That composite score is held below the SB 535 disadvantaged-community threshold primarily by the tract's moderate socioeconomic and sensitive-population indicators (for example, poverty in approximately the 22nd percentile, housing burden in the 16th, education in the 30th, and asthma in the 21st) and not by its air quality. It must be pointed out that this community breathes some of the most polluted air in California even though its blended CalEnviroScreen score falls just below the disadvantaged-community cutoff.

Page 15 ends

This setting is directly relevant to the comments that follow. The DEIR's failure to disclose the CalEnviroScreen results and this pollution-burden context (Comment 3), its omission of an operational health risk assessment for nearby receptors that include a mobile-home park (Comment 2), and its silence on the Valley Fever hazard (Comment 4) are each the more significant because they arise in a community already at or near the top of the State's PM2.s and ozone burden.

AIR QUALITY

1. The Project's Operational Criteria-Pollutant Emissions Exceed SJV APCD Thresholds and Are Offset Solely Through a VERA Payment, With No Feasible On-Site Reductions.

The DEIR finds that the Project's operational emissions of VOCs (expressed as reactive organic gases or ROGs; approximately 14.6 tons per year) and oxides of nitrogen or NOx (approximately

10.3 tons per year) exceed the SN APCD operational significance thresholds of 10 tons per year each. 3 These exceedances are driven mainly by the mobile-source (vehicle trip) emissions.4 To offset the foreseeable exceedance, the DEIR relies on mitigation measure MM AQ-1, in which the proponent would enter an offset-based Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the SN APCD. Critically, MM AQ-1 achieves the reduction entirely through a payment to the air district; it imposes no on-site emission reductions.

The DEIR should first identify all feasible on-site measures (for example, the measures the SN APCD itself recommended during scoping) and only rely on offset fees for the residual, unavoidable increment.

Relatedly, the SN APCD's Notice of Preparation (NOP) scoping comments set out specific recommendations for the air-quality analysis and for mitigation. 5 Analysis Recommendations:
3san Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SN APCD), Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (GAMAQI), which establishes operational significance thresholds of IO tons per year for reactive organic gases (ROGNOC) and l O tons per year for oxides of nitrogen (NOx).
4DEIR, Section 4.3 (Air Quality) and Appendix B (Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas, and Energy Technical Study), operational CalEEMod output and mitigation measure MM AQ-1 (Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement). 5DEIR, Appendix A (Notice of Preparation and scoping comments), SN APCD comment letter, at pp. 18 and 20.

Page 16 ends

1. Performing a detailed review of construction and operational emissions, analyzing mobile and stationary sources separately. This was only partly done. The DEIR quantified construction and operational criteria-pollutant emissions in CalEEMod and analyzed the mobile-source component. The DEIR never separately quantified the operational stationary-source TA Cs (gas-station benzene, restaurant charbroilers ), deferring them to Regulation II permitting. So the "analyze stationary operational emissions separately" instruction went unfulfilled for exactly the sources SN APCD flagged (Comment 2).

2. Characterize and justify an appropriate HHD truck trip-length. The DEIR failed to perform this step. The DEIR used the CalEEMod default 40-mile one-way trip length with no site-specific justification, despite SN APCD expressly asking for one. As shown in Comment 2, that assumption understates operational NOx (a Building-I-type drayage scenario roughly doubles it), and it also feeds the AAQA below.

3. Evaluate risk to sensitive receptors and mitigate significant risk. The DEIR performed only half of the task. The DEIR performed a construction HRA (MEIR :::::I.5 in a million, below threshold) but never evaluated operational health risk to the identified sensitive receptors (the adjacent mobile-home park and residences) from the gas station and charbroilers. This is another example of the DEIR deferring analysis (Comments 2, 3).

4. Perform an Ambient Air Quality Analysis if emissions exceed 100 lb/day. This step was only partially met. The DEIR did an AAQA (Appendix D; AERMOD dispersion, triggered by operational CO :::::385 lb/day). But the AAQA used the unjustified 40-mile truck trip length from recommendation 2, so its inputs carry the same defect.

5. Discuss VERA feasibility. This was addressed in the DEIR but is incomplete. The DEIR adopted a VERA (MM AQ-1 ), but it went straight to an offset-only payment with no feasible on-site VOC/NOx reductions first, which is the sequencing problem in Comment 1.

Mitigation recommendations

1. Use the cleanest available off-road construction equipment. Not adopted in the DEIR. Because construction criteria-pollutant emissions came in below thresholds, the DEIR imposed no Tier 4 / cleanest-equipment construction requirement. This recommendation simply wasn't carried into a measure.

Page 17 ends

2. Evaluate HHD truck routing to limit exposure of residents/sensitive receptors. This measure was never performed. The DEIR only noted trucks would use the designated truck routes (Rosedale Highway, Coffee Road); it performed no routing analysis and adopted no routing measure to steer trucks away from the adjacent homes.

3. Use the cleanest available Heavy-Duty Trucks. This mitigation measure was not adopted. No requirement for recent-model-year, near-zero, or zero-emission delivery trucks; even though mobile sources drive both the NOx exceedance and the significant-and-unavoidable GHG impact (this is precisely the added mitigation urged in Comment 9).

4. Ensure compliance with the anti-idling regulations (13 CCR§§ 2485, 2480). Not adopted as a mitigation measure. These appear only in the regulatory-setting discussion, not as an enforceable, verifiable project condition.

5. Address concerns regarding under-fired charbroilers. No mitigation measures were adopted.

The DEIR neither quantified charbroiler TAC/PM emissions nor required charbroiler emission controls (e.g., catalytic or flameless units); it deferred to permitting (Comment 2).

The DEIR should be reviewed for each instance in which it deviates from those recommendations.

In particular they should be evaluated where the DEIR represents that its approach is consistent with SN APCD guidance; and for whether it adequately considered and adopted the on-site mitigation measures that the District recommended.

2. The DEIR Fails to Quantify Operational Health Risk From the Gas Station and Restaurant Char-Broilers and Improperly Defers That Analysis to Permitting.

A construction-phase health risk assessment (HRA) was prepared, included as an appendix to the DEIR, and it reports a maximally exposed individual resident (MEIR) cancer risk of approximately

1.5 in one million-below the SN APCD threshold of 20 in one million-with a maximally exposed worker risk of approximately 0.3 in one million and a hazard index below 1.0. 6 The operational phase, however, was not analyzed. According to the DEIR, "Because the proposed project would not have any warehousing uses and would primarily consist ofretail, restaurant, and 6DEIR, Section 4.3 (Air Quality) and Appendix B, construction-phase health risk assessment results (maximally exposed individual resident cancer risk of approximately 1.5 in one million; maximally exposed worker approximately 0.3 in one million; hazard index below 1.0), each below the applicable SN APCD thresholds (20 in one million; hazard index of 1.0).

Page 18 ends

commercial uses, it anticipated that project-related traffic volumes would primarily consist of passenger vehicles associated with patrons. Thus, the incremental increase in vehicle trips that could result from implementation of the proposed project would be below roadway volumes identified by the CARB land use siting screening criteria to avoid exposing sensitive receptors to substantial concentration of air pollutants from vehicles traveling along roadway. Therefore, operation of the proposed project would not expose nearby off-site sensitive receptors to substantial concentrations of TACs."7 The DEIR does not quantify operational toxic air contaminant (TAC) emissions from the Project's 40-dispenser gasoline dispensing facility (a known benzene source) or from the restaurant under-fired char-broilers. Instead, the DEIR states that operational TAC emissions are deferred to SN APCD Regulation II permitting. That deferral conflicts with SN APCD's recommendation that operational emissions be included in the analysis (see DEIR, Appendix A, p. 20).
; I
d:;-=== :.:±=- ---- -- ----------- -- - --- >- -- '
Fueling Station
Figure 3: Conceptual Site Plan
7 DEIR Appendix B, Section 5.2.1 (Air Quality Impacts) at pp 69; DEIR Section 4.3 at pp 4.3-32.

Page 19 ends

A 40-dispenser, high-throughput gasoline dispensing facility located adjacent to the restaurants and situated near sensitive receptors can generate meaningful benzene and other TAC exposures, and commercial char-broilers are a recognized source of particulate matter and TAC emissions (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs).

3. The DEIR Omits Analysis of Extreme Pollution-Burden Indicators in its Cumulative Impacts Analysis
Although the Project census tract is not designated as a SB 535 disadvantaged community (its CalEnviroScreen 4.0 score is approximately 30), and it is neither an AB 1550 low-income community nor an AB 617 community, it is, however, located immediately adjacent to a census tract that is a designated SB 535 disadvantaged community, and its pollution-burden indicators are extreme: PM2.s in roughly the 99th percentile statewide, ozone in roughly the 94th percentile, and diesel particulate matter in roughly the 55th percentile (with drinking-water and traffic burdens also elevated). 8 The DEIR fails to analyze this these facts in its assessment of the Project's cumulative impacts; the CalEnviroScreen determination is buried within a CalEEMod/technical appendix rather than addressed in the air-quality analysis. 8OEHHA/CalEPA, CalEnviroScreen 4.0. State designations referenced: SB 535 disadvantaged communities (CalEPA), AB 1550 low-income communities, and AB 617 communities (CARB). The Project census-tract determination and percentile indicators appear only within the CalEEMod/technical appendix and are not disclosed or analyzed in the DEIR text.

Page llO
Figure 4: Project Location and Nearest SB 535 Community I recommend the DEIR be revised to disclose the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results, acknowledge the Project's immediate adjacency to an SB 535 disadvantaged community, and analyze the Project's incremental contribution of criteria pollutants and TA Cs to an area already bearing near-worst-case PM2.s and ozone burdens. This is relevant both as informational disclosure and to the cumulative-impacts analysis, and should be included in a revised DEIR.

HAZARDS AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS

4. Valley Fever (Coccidioidomycosis) Is a Known Soil Hazard That the DEIR Does Not Address at All.

Kern County has among the highest rates of Valley Fever (coccidioidomycosis) in California. The disease is caused by inhalation of Coccidioides spores that are aerosolized when soils are disturbed and by windblown dust. 9 Grading and excavation across an approximately 46-acre site in this 9califomia Department of Public Health, Coccidioidomycosis (Valley Fever) surveillance; Kem County reports among the highest incidence rates in California. Coccidioides spores are aerosolized by soil disturbance and windblown dust.

Page Ill
setting can generate fugitive dust carrying spores, exposing construction workers and nearby residents.

The DEIR fails to address at all the known presence and significant risk of Coccidiodes lmmitis (Valley Fever fungus) in Central California. Under California Labor Code Section 6709[e], Kem County is an area known to have a high endemic rate of Valley Fever. According to the California Department of Public Health Valley Fever Website 1°, the number of Valley Fever illnesses in Kem County ranged from 948 in 2001 (a rate of 139.5 per 100,000 population) to 3,873 in 2024 (a rate of 428.2 in 100,000). Based on the provisional reports from the CDPH for 2025, 1,872 cases were reported in Kem County to CDPH and in the first 8 months of 2026 1,848 cases of Valley Fever have been reported to CDPH. Since Valley Fever cases are directly related to the disturbance of soils in the area, the City must directly address the impacts that the Project's construction phase will have on the community.

Dust exposure is a primary risk factor for contracting Valley Fever ( via Coccidiodes imimitis (cocci) exposure). When soil containing the cocci spores are disturbed by construction activities, the fungal spores become airborne, exposing construction workers and other nearby sensitive receptors. It is clear that the DEIR assumes that meeting San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District's (SN-APCD's) rules regard construction (specifically Rule 8021 (Construction, Demolition, Excavation, Extraction, and Other Earthmoving Activities)) would be sufficient to control the impacts from Valley Fever exposure from the Project Site. District Rule 8021 requires limitation of fugitive dust emissions from construction, demolition, excavation, extraction, and other earthmoving activities, by implementing control measures such as pre-watering the Project site, phasing construction work to reduce the amount of disturbed surface at any one time, and applying water or other suppressants to unpaved haul/access roads and unpaved vehicle/equipment traffic areas. Rule 8021 relies on a visual-opacity reading for dust control and is insufficient to prevent exposure to Valley Fever spores. This rule is based on smoke-monitoring methods (U.S. EPA Methods 9 and 22) that require active monitoring by certified observers, rely on subjective observation, and are affected by variable such as lighting, 10 https://www .cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CID/DCDC/PagesN alleyFeverDashboard.aspx

Page 112 ends

distance, and weather conditions. Due to these limitations, opacity readings do not provide accurate, continuous data on fine airborne particles.

It must be remembered that the most at-risk populations are construction and agricultural workers. 11 Here, construction workers are the very population that would be most directly exposed by the Project. A refereed journal article on occupational exposures notes that "[l]abor groups where occupation involves close contact with the soil are at greater risk, especially if the work involves dusty digging operations." 12
To address these shortcomings, the City should require active monitoring with dust monitors (particle measuring devices) immediately outside of the facility and around its perimeter.

Continuous particle measures would offer several advantages. It eliminates the subjectivity inherent in visual opacity readings, leading to more reliable and consistent data. It allows for real-time tracking of dust particle levels, enabling prompt corrective actions if thresholds are exceeded.

Active monitoring also offers a robust data set that can be used for repeatability test and to validate compliance with air quality standards. Incorporating active dust monitoring systems would ensure that air quality impacts are accurately assessed and mitigated, fulfilling the intent of the mitigation measures and conditions of compliance to protect public health and the environment.

The CalEEMOD analyses of Phase 1 and Phase 2 of the construction phase fail to include mitigation measures for dust suppression. Based on the conventional mitigation measures and modeling of dust movement in the CalEEMOD models watering exposed areas twice a day would reduce PM10 and PM2.s emissions by 61 percent (61 %). Increasing the watering frequency to 3 times per day would reduce PM10 and PM2.s emissions by 74%. Conventional dust control measures primarily focus on visible dust or larger dust particles-the PM10 fraction-and fail to address the very fine particles that transport Valley Fever spores, which are approximately 5 times smaller than typical PM1oparticles and remain airborne much longer.13 These fine particles, when 11 Lawrence L. Schmelzer and R. Tabershaw, Exposure Factors in Occupational Coccidioidomycosis, American Journal of Public Health and the Nation 's Health, v. 58, no. 1, 1968, pp. 107-113, Table 3; available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles!PMC 1228046/?page= 1. 12 Ibid. , p. 110.
13 See, e.g., Cummings and others, 2010, p. 509; Schneider et al., 1997, p. 908 ("Primary prevention strategies (e.g., dust-control measures) for coccidioidomycosis in endemic areas have limited effectiveness.").

Page l13
disturbed by soil-disturbing activities, spread widely beyond site, posing a significant risk to both onsite workers and nearby communities.

California Labor Code Section 6709[e], requires awareness training on Valley Fever. The education component of Section 6709[e] would not protective enough to ensure worker safety.

The City should require that the Proponent implement mitigation measures to actively suppress the spread of Valley Fever by:

1. Include specific requirements m the Project's Injury and Illness Prevention Program (as required by Title 8, Section 3203) regarding safeguards to prevent Valley Fever.

2. Control dust exposure:

Apply water to all disturbed areas a minimum of three times per day. Watering frequency should be increased to a minimum of four times per day if there is any evidence of visible wind-driven fugitive dust;
Provide and require the use of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)-approved respirators for workers with a prior history of Valley Fever.

Require the use of half-face respirators equipped with a minimum N-95 protection factor for use during worker collocation with surface disturbance activities. Half-face respirators equipped with N-100 or P-100 filters should be used during digging activities. Employees should wear respirators when working near earth-moving machinery.

Prohibit eating and smoking at the worksite, and provide separate, clean eating areas with hand-washing facilities.

A void outdoor construction operations during unusually windy conditions or in dust storms.

Consider limiting outdoor construction during the fall to essential jobs only, as the risk of cocci infection is higher during this season.

3. Prevent transport of cocci outside endemic areas:

Page 114 ends

Thoroughly clean equipment, vehicles, and other items before they are moved off-site to other work locations.

Prevent spillage or loss of bulk material from holes or other openings in the cargo compartment's floor, sides, and/or tailgate;
Load all haul trucks such that the freeboard is not less than six inches when material is transported on any paved public access road and apply water to the top of the load and then cover haul trucks with a tarp or other suitable cover.

Provide workers with coveralls daily, lockers (or other systems for keeping work and street clothing and shoes separate), daily changing and showering facilities.

Clothing should be changed after work every day, preferably at the work site.

Train workers to recognize that cocci may be transported offsite on contaminated equipment, clothing, and shoes; alternatively, consider installing boot-washing.

Post warnings onsite and consider limiting access to visitors, especially those without adequate training and respiratory protection.

4. Improve medical surveillance for employees:

Employees should have prompt access to medical care, including suspected work-related illnesses and injuries.

Work with a medical professional to develop a protocol to medically evaluate employees who have symptoms of Valley Fever.

Consider preferentially contracting with 1-2 clinics in the area and communicate with the health care providers in those clinics to ensure that providers are aware that Valley Fever has been reported in the area. This will increase the likelihood that ill workers will receive prompt, proper and consistent medical care.

Respirator clearance should include medical evaluation for all new employees, annual re-evaluation for changes in medical status, and annual training, and Page I 15
fit-testing.

Skin testing is not recommended for evaluation of Valley Fever.14 If an employee is diagnosed with Valley Fever, a physician must determine if the employee should be taken off work, when they may return to work, and what type of work activities they may perform.

The City must adopt these evidence-based mitigation measures which have proven effective in similar construction projects in endemic areas to ensure comprehensive protection of public health.

Standard dust control measures are insufficient for preventing Valley Fever exposure, and only concrete, enforceable steps like those listed above will safeguard both onsite workers and surrounding communities. The requirements outlined above should be presented in a revised DEIR for the Project Site.

CONCLUSIONS
The facts identified and referenced in this comment letter lead me to reasonably conclude that the Project could result in significant impacts if allowed to proceed. A revised DEIR should be prepared to address these substantial concerns related to the construction and operational emissions from the Project that clearly were not identified in the DEIR.

Sincerely,
14 Short-term skin tests that produce results within 48 hours are now available. See Kerry Klein, NPR for Central California, New Valley Fever Skin Test Shows Promise, But Obstacles Remain, November 21, 2016; available at http://kypr.org/post/new-valley-fever-skin-test-shows-promise-obstacles-remain.

Page I 16
James J. J. Clark, Ph.D.

Principal Toxicologist
Toxicology/Exposure Assessment Modeling
Risk Assessment/Analysis/Dispersion Modeling
Education:

Ph.D., Environmental Health Science, University of California, 1995 M.S., Environmental Health Science, University of California, 1993 B.S., Biophysical and Biochemical Sciences, University of Houston, 1987 Professional Experience:

Dr. Clark is a well recognized toxicologist, air modeler, and health scientist. He has 20 years of experience in researching the effects of environmental contaminants on human health including environmental fate and transport modeling (SCREEN3, AEROMOD, ISCST3, Johnson-Ettinger Vapor Intrusion Modeling); exposure assessment modeling (partitioning of contaminants in the environment as well as PBPK modeling); conducting and managing human health risk assessments for regulatory compliance and risk-based clean-up levels; and toxicological and medical literature research.

Significant projects performed by Dr. Clark include the following:

LITIGATION SUPPORT
Case: James Harold Caygle, et al, v. Drummond Company, Inc. Circuit Court for the Tenth Judicial Circuit, Jefferson County, Alabama. Civil Action. CV-2009 Client: Environmental Litgation Group, Birmingham, Alabama Dr. Clark performed an air quality assessment of emissions from a coke factory located in Tarrant, Alabama. The assessment reviewed include a comprehensive review of air quality standards, measured concentrations of pollutants from factory, an inspection of the facility and detailed assessment of the impacts on the community. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Clark & Associates
Environmental Consulting, Inc
OFFICE
12405 Venice Blvd.

Suite 331
Los Angeles, CA 90066
PHONE
310-907-6165
FAX
310-398-7626
EMAIL
[email protected]
Letter O2B
3 2
0 10 100
Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Rose Roper V. Nissan North America, et al. Superior Court of the State Of California for the County Of Los Angeles – Central Civil West. Civil Action.

NC041739
Client: Rose, Klein, Marias, LLP, Long Beach, California Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to multiple chemicals, including benzene, who later developed a respiratory distress. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare an exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to respiratory irritants. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: O’Neil V. Sherwin Williams, et al. United States District Court Central District of California
Client: Rose, Klein, Marias, LLP, Long Beach, California Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to petroleum distillates who later developed a bladder cancer. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a quantitative exposure assessment. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Summary judgment for defendants.

Case: Moore V., Shell Oil Company, et al. Superior Court of the State Of California for the County Of Los Angeles
Client: Rose, Klein, Marias, LLP, Long Beach, California Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to chemicals while benzene who later developed a leukogenic disease. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a quantitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to refined petroleum hydrocarbons. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Raymond Saltonstall V. Fuller O’Brien, KILZ, and Zinsser, et al. United States District Court Central District of California
Client: Rose, Klein, Marias, LLP, Long Beach, California Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to benzene who later developed a leukogenic disease. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a quantitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to refined petroleum hydrocarbons. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Richard Boyer and Elizabeth Boyer, husband and wife, V. DESCO Corporation, et al. Circuit Court of Brooke County, West Virginia. Civil Action Number 04-C-7G.

Client: Frankovitch, Anetakis, Colantonio & Simon, Morgantown, West Virginia.

Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of a family exposed to chlorinated solvents released from the defendant’s facility into local drinking water supplies. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a qualitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to chlorinated solvents. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: JoAnne R. Cook, V. DESCO Corporation, et al. Circuit Court of Brooke County, West Virginia. Civil Action Number 04-C-9R
Client: Frankovitch, Anetakis, Colantonio & Simon, Morgantown, West Virginia.

Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual exposed to chlorinated solvents released from the defendant’s facility into local drinking water supplies. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a qualitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to chlorinated solvents. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Patrick Allen And Susan Allen, husband and wife, and Andrew Allen, a minor, V. DESCO Corporation, et al. Circuit Court of Brooke County, West Virginia. Civil Action Number 04-C-W
Client: Frankovitch, Anetakis, Colantonio & Simon, Morgantown, West Virginia.

Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of a family exposed to chlorinated solvents released from the defendant’s facility into local drinking water supplies. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a qualitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to chlorinated solvents. The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Michael Fahey, Susan Fahey V. Atlantic Richfield Company, et al. United States District Court Central District of California Civil Action Number CV-06 7109 JCL.

Client: Rose, Klein, Marias, LLP, Long Beach, California Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to refined petroleum hydrocarbons who later developed a leukogenic disease. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a qualitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to refined petroleum hydrocarbons.

The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of plaintiff.

Case: Constance Acevedo, et al., V. California Spray-Chemical Company, et al., Superior Court of the State Of California, County Of Santa Cruz. Case No. CV 146344
Dr. Clark performed a comprehensive exposure assessment of community members exposed to toxic metals from a former lead arsenate manufacturing facility. The former manufacturing site had undergone a DTSC mandated removal action/remediation for the presence of the toxic metals at the site. Opinions were presented regarding the elevated levels of arsenic and lead (in attic dust and soils) found throughout the community and the potential for harm to the plaintiffs in question.

Case Result: Settlement in favor of defendant.

Case: Michael Nawrocki V. The Coastal Corporation, Kurk Fuel Company, Pautler Oil Service, State of New York Supreme Court, County of Erie, Index Number I2001-11247
Client: Richard G. Berger Attorney At Law, Buffalo, New York Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of an individual occupationally exposed to refined petroleum hydrocarbons who later developed a leukogenic disease. A review of the individual’s medical and occupational history was performed to prepare a qualitative exposure assessment. The exposure assessment was evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to refined petroleum hydrocarbons.

The results of the assessment and literature have been provided in a declaration to the court.

Case Result: Judgement in favor of defendant.

SELECTED AIR MODELING RESEARCH/PROJECTS
Client – Confidential
Dr. Clark performed a comprehensive evaluation of criteria pollutants, air toxins, and particulate matter emissions from a carbon black production facility to determine the impacts on the surrounding communities. The results of the dispersion model will be used to estimate acute and chronic exposure concentrations to multiple contaminants and will be incorporated into a comprehensive risk evaluation.

Client – Confidential
Dr. Clark performed a comprehensive evaluation of air toxins and particulate matter emissions from a railroad tie manufacturing facility to determine the impacts on the surrounding communities. The results of the dispersion model have been used to estimate acute and chronic exposure concentrations to multiple contaminants and have been incorporated into a comprehensive risk evaluation.

Client – Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy (LAANE), Los Angeles, California
Dr. Clark is advising the LAANE on air quality issues related to current flight operations at the Los Angeles International Airport (LAX) operated by the Los Angeles World Airport (LAWA) Authority. He is working with the LAANE and LAX staff to develop a comprehensive strategy for meeting local community concerns over emissions from flight operations and to engage federal agencies on the issue of local impacts of community airports.

Client – City of Santa Monica, Santa Monica, California Dr. Clark is advising the City of Santa Monica on air quality issues related to current flight operations at the facility. He is working with the City staff to develop a comprehensive strategy for meeting local community concerns over emissions from flight operations and to engage federal agencies on the issue of local impacts of community airports.

Client: Omnitrans, San Bernardino, California
Dr. Clark managed a public health survey of three communities near transit fueling facilities in San Bernardino and Montclair California in compliance with California Senate Bill 1927. The survey included an epidemiological survey of the effected communities, emission surveys of local businesses, dispersion modeling to determine potential emission concentrations within the communities, and a comprehensive risk assessment of each community. The results of the study were presented to the Governor as mandated by Senate Bill 1927.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Summarized cancer types associated with exposure to metals and smoking. Researched the specific types of cancers associated with exposure to metals and smoking. Provided causation analysis of the association between cancer types and exposure for use by non-public health professionals.

Client: Confidential, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Prepared human health risk assessment of workers exposed to VOCs from neighboring petroleum storage/transport facility. Reviewed the systems in place for distribution of petroleum hydrocarbons to identify chemicals of concern (COCs), prepared comprehensive toxicological summaries of COCs, and quantified potential risks from carcinogens and non-carcinogens to receptors at or adjacent to site. This evaluation was used in the support of litigation.

Client – United Kingdom Environmental Agency
Dr. Clark is part of team that performed comprehensive evaluation of soil vapor intrusion of VOCs from former landfill adjacent residences for the United Kingdom’s Environment Agency. The evaluation included collection of liquid and soil vapor samples at site, modeling of vapor migration using the Johnson Ettinger Vapor Intrusion model, and calculation of site-specific health based vapor thresholds for chlorinated solvents, aromatic hydrocarbons, and semi-volatile organic compounds. The evaluation also included a detailed evaluation of the use, chemical characteristics, fate and transport, and toxicology of chemicals of concern (COC). The results of the evaluation have been used as a briefing tool for public health professionals.

EMERGING/PERSISTENT CONTAMINANT RESEARCH/PROJECTS
Client: Ameren Services, St. Louis, Missouri
Managed the preparation of a comprehensive human health risk assessment of workers and residents at or near an NPL site in Missouri. The former operations at the Property included the servicing and repair of electrical transformers, which resulted in soils and groundwater beneath the Property and adjacent land becoming impacted with PCB and chlorinated solvent compounds. The results were submitted to U.S. EPA for evaluation and will be used in the final ROD.

Client: City of Santa Clarita, Santa Clarita, California Dr. Clark is managing the oversight of the characterization, remediation and development activities of a former 1,000 acre munitions manufacturing facility for the City of Santa Clarita. The site is impacted with a number of contaminants including perchlorate, unexploded ordinance, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). The site is currently under a number of regulatory consent orders, including an Immanent and Substantial Endangerment Order. Dr. Clark is assisting the impacted municipality with the development of remediation strategies, interaction with the responsible parties and stakeholders, as well as interfacing with the regulatory agency responsible for oversight of the site cleanup.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of perchlorate in environment. Dr. Clark evaluated the production, use, chemical characteristics, fate and transport, toxicology, and remediation of perchlorate. Perchlorates form the basis of solid rocket fuels and have recently been detected in water supplies in the United States. The results of this research were presented to the USEPA, National GroundWater, and ultimately published in a recent book entitled Perchlorate in the Environment.

Client – Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Dr. Clark is performing a comprehensive review of the potential for pharmaceuticals and their by-products to impact groundwater and surface water supplies. This evaluation will include a review if available data on the history of pharmaceutical production in the United States; the chemical characteristics of various pharmaceuticals; environmental fate and transport; uptake by xenobiotics; the potential effects of pharmaceuticals on water treatment systems; and the potential threat to public health. The results of the evaluation may be used as a briefing tool for non-public health professionals.

PUBLIC HEALTH/TOXICOLOGY
Client: Brayton Purcell, Novato, California
Dr. Clark performed a toxicological assessment of residents exposed to methyl-tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) from leaking underground storage tanks (LUSTs) adjacent to the subject property. The symptomology of residents and guests of the subject property were evaluated against the known outcomes in published literature to exposure to MTBE. The study found that residents had been exposed to MTBE in their drinking water; that concentrations of MTBE detected at the site were above regulatory guidelines; and, that the symptoms and outcomes expressed by residents and guests were consistent with symptoms and outcomes documented in published literature.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Identified and analyzed fifty years of epidemiological literature on workplace exposures to heavy metals. This research resulted in a summary of the types of cancer and non-cancer diseases associated with occupational exposure to chromium as well as the mortality and morbidity rates.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Summarized major public health research in United States. Identified major public health research efforts within United States over last twenty years. Results were used as a briefing tool for non-public health professionals.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Quantified the potential multi-pathway dose received by humans from a pesticide applied indoors. Part of team that developed exposure model and evaluated exposure concentrations in a comprehensive report on the plausible range of doses received by a specific person. This evaluation was used in the support of litigation.

Client: Covanta Energy, Westwood, California
Evaluated health risk from metals in biosolids applied as soil amendment on agricultural lands. The biosolids were created at a forest waste cogeneration facility using 96% whole tree wood chips and 4 percent green waste. Mass loading calculations were used to estimate Cr(VI) concentrations in agricultural soils based on a maximum loading rate of 40 tons of biomass per acre of agricultural soil. The results of the study were used by the Regulatory agency to determine that the application of biosolids did not constitute a health risk to workers applying the biosolids or to residences near the agricultural lands.

Client – United Kingdom Environmental Agency
Oversaw a comprehensive toxicological evaluation of methyl-tertiary butyl ether (MtBE) for the United Kingdom’s Environment Agency. The evaluation included available data on the production, use, chemical characteristics, fate and transport, toxicology, and remediation of MtBE. The results of the evaluation have been used as a briefing tool for public health professionals.

Client – Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of tertiary butyl alcohol (TBA) in municipal drinking water system. TBA is the primary breakdown product of MtBE, and is suspected to be the primary cause of MtBE toxicity. This evaluation will include available information on the production, use, chemical characteristics, fate and transport in the environment, absorption, distribution, routes of detoxification, metabolites, carcinogenic potential, and remediation of TBA. The results of the evaluation were used as a briefing tool for non-public health professionals.

Client – Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) in municipal drinking water system. MTBE is a chemical added to gasoline to increase the octane rating and to meet Federally mandated emission criteria. The evaluation included available data on the production, use, chemical characteristics, fate and transport, toxicology, and remediation of MTBE. The results of the evaluation have been were used as a briefing tool for non-public health professionals.

Client – Ministry of Environment, Lands & Parks, British Columbia Dr. Clark assisted in the development of water quality guidelines for methyl tertiary-butyl ether (MTBE) to protect water uses in British Columbia (BC). The water uses to be considered includes freshwater and marine life, wildlife, industrial, and agricultural (e.g., irrigation and livestock watering) water uses. Guidelines from other jurisdictions for the protection of drinking water, recreation and aesthetics were to be identified.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared physiologically based pharmacokinetic (PBPK) assessment of lead risk of receptors at middle school built over former industrial facility. This evaluation is being used to determine cleanup goals and will be basis for regulatory closure of site.

Client: Kaiser Venture Incorporated, Fontana, California Prepared PBPK assessment of lead risk of receptors at a 1,100-acre former steel mill.

This evaluation was used as the basis for granting closure of the site by lead regulatory agency.

RISK ASSESSMENTS/REMEDIAL INVESTIGATIONS
Client: Confidential, Atlanta, Georgia
Researched potential exposure and health risks to community members potentially exposed to creosote, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, pentachlorophenol, and dioxin compounds used at a former wood treatment facility. Prepared a comprehensive toxicological summary of the chemicals of concern, including the chemical characteristics, absorption, distribution, and carcinogenic potential. Prepared risk characterization of the carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic chemicals based on the exposure assessment to quantify the potential risk to members of the surrounding community. This evaluation was used to help settle class-action tort.

Client: Confidential, Escondido, California
Prepared comprehensive Preliminary Endangerment Assessment (PEA) of dense non-aqueous liquid phase hydrocarbon (chlorinated solvents) contamination at a former printed circuit board manufacturing facility. This evaluation was used for litigation support and may be used as the basis for reaching closure of the site with the lead regulatory agency.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Summarized epidemiological evidence for connective tissue and autoimmune diseases for product liability litigation. Identified epidemiological research efforts on the health effects of medical prostheses. This research was used in a meta-analysis of the health effects and as a briefing tool for non-public health professionals.

Client: Confidential, Bogotá, Columbia
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of the potential health risks associated with the redevelopment of a 13.7 hectares plastic manufacturing facility in Bogotá, Colombia The risk assessment was used as the basis for the remedial goals and closure of the site.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive human health risk assessment of students, staff, and residents potentially exposed to heavy metals (principally cadmium) and VOCs from soil and soil vapor at 12-acre former crude oilfield and municipal landfill. The site is currently used as a middle school housing approximately 3,000 children. The evaluation determined that the site was safe for the current and future uses and was used as the basis for regulatory closure of site.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Managed remedial investigation (RI) of heavy metals and volatile organic chemicals (VOCs) for a 15-acre former manufacturing facility. The RI investigation of the site included over 800 different sampling locations and the collection of soil, soil gas, and groundwater samples. The site is currently used as a year round school housing approximately 3,000 children. The Remedial Investigation was performed in a manner that did not interrupt school activities and met the time restrictions placed on the project by the overseeing regulatory agency. The RI Report identified the off-site source of metals that impacted groundwater beneath the site and the sources of VOCs in soil gas and groundwater. The RI included a numerical model of vapor intrusion into the buildings at the site from the vadose zone to determine exposure concentrations and an air dispersion model of VOCs from the proposed soil vapor treatment system. The Feasibility Study for the Site is currently being drafted and may be used as the basis for granting closure of the site by DTSC.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive human health risk assessment of students, staff, and residents potentially exposed to heavy metals (principally lead), VOCs, SVOCs, and PCBs from soil, soil vapor, and groundwater at 15-acre former manufacturing facility. The site is currently used as a year round school housing approximately 3,000 children. The evaluation determined that the site was safe for the current and future uses and will be basis for regulatory closure of site.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of VOC vapor intrusion into classrooms of middle school that was former 15-acre industrial facility. Using the Johnson-Ettinger Vapor Intrusion model, the evaluation determined acceptable soil gas concentrations at the site that did not pose health threat to students, staff, and residents. This evaluation is being used to determine cleanup goals and will be basis for regulatory closure of site.

Client –Dominguez Energy, Carson, California
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of the potential health risks associated with the redevelopment of 6-acre portion of a 500-acre oil and natural gas production facility in Carson, California. The risk assessment was used as the basis for closure of the site.

Kaiser Ventures Incorporated, Fontana, California
Prepared health risk assessment of semi-volatile organic chemicals and metals for a fifty-year old wastewater treatment facility used at a 1,100-acre former steel mill. This evaluation was used as the basis for granting closure of the site by lead regulatory agency.

ANR Freight - Los Angeles, California
Prepared a comprehensive Preliminary Endangerment Assessment (PEA) of petroleum hydrocarbon and metal contamination of a former freight depot. This evaluation was as the basis for reaching closure of the site with lead regulatory agency.

Kaiser Ventures Incorporated, Fontana, California
Prepared comprehensive health risk assessment of semi-volatile organic chemicals and metals for 23-acre parcel of a 1,100-acre former steel mill. The health risk assessment was used to determine clean up goals and as the basis for granting closure of the site by lead regulatory agency. Air dispersion modeling using ISCST3 was performed to determine downwind exposure point concentrations at sensitive receptors within a 1 kilometer radius of the site. The results of the health risk assessment were presented at a public meeting sponsored by the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) in the community potentially affected by the site.

Unocal Corporation - Los Angeles, California
Prepared comprehensive assessment of petroleum hydrocarbons and metals for a former petroleum service station located next to sensitive population center (elementary school).

The assessment used a probabilistic approach to estimate risks to the community and was used as the basis for granting closure of the site by lead regulatory agency.

Client: Confidential, Los Angeles, California
Managed oversight of remedial investigation most contaminated heavy metal site in California. Lead concentrations in soil excess of 68,000,000 parts per billion (ppb) have been measured at the site. This State Superfund Site was a former hard chrome plating operation that operated for approximately 40-years.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Coordinator of regional monitoring program to determine background concentrations of metals in air. Acted as liaison with SCAQMD and CARB to perform co-location sampling and comparison of accepted regulatory method with ASTM methodology.

Client: Confidential, San Francisco, California
Analyzed historical air monitoring data for South Coast Air Basin in Southern California and potential health risks related to ambient concentrations of carcinogenic metals and volatile organic compounds. Identified and reviewed the available literature and calculated risks from toxins in South Coast Air Basin.

IT Corporation, North Carolina
Prepared comprehensive evaluation of potential exposure of workers to air-borne VOCs at hazardous waste storage facility under SUPERFUND cleanup decree. Assessment used in developing health based clean-up levels.

Professional Associations
American Public Health Association (APHA)
Association for Environmental Health and Sciences (AEHS) American Chemical Society (ACS)
California Redevelopment Association (CRA)
International Society of Environmental Forensics (ISEF) Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) Publications and Presentations:

Books and Book Chapters
Sullivan, P., J.J. J. Clark, F.J. Agardy, and P.E. Rosenfeld. (2007). Synthetic Toxins In The Food, Water and Air of American Cities. Elsevier, Inc. Burlington, MA.

Sullivan, P. and J.J. J. Clark. 2006. Choosing Safer Foods, A Guide To Minimizing Synthetic Chemicals In Your Diet. Elsevier, Inc. Burlington, MA.

Sullivan, P., Agardy, F.J., and J.J.J. Clark. 2005. The Environmental Science of Drinking Water. Elsevier, Inc. Burlington, MA.

Sullivan, P.J., Agardy, F.J., Clark, J.J.J. 2002. America’s Threatened Drinking Water:

Hazards and Solutions. Trafford Publishing, Victoria B.C.

Clark, J.J.J. 2001. “TBA: Chemical Properties, Production & Use, Fate and Transport, Toxicology, Detection in Groundwater, and Regulatory Standards” in Oxygenates in the Environment. Art Diaz, Ed.. Oxford University Press: New York.

Clark, J.J.J. 2000. “Toxicology of Perchlorate” in Perchlorate in the Environment.

Edward Urbansky, Ed. Kluwer/Plenum: New York.

Clark, J.J.J. 1995. Probabilistic Forecasting of Volatile Organic Compound Concentrations At The Soil Surface From Contaminated Groundwater. UMI.

Baker, J.; Clark, J.J.J.; Stanford, J.T. 1994. Ex Situ Remediation of Diesel Contaminated Railroad Sand by Soil Washing. Principles and Practices for Diesel Contaminated Soils, Volume III. P.T. Kostecki, E.J. Calabrese, and C.P.L. Barkan, eds. Amherst Scientific Publishers, Amherst, MA. pp 89-96.

Journal and Proceeding Articles
Tam L. K.., Wu C. D., Clark J. J. and Rosenfeld, P.E. (2008) A Statistical Analysis Of Attic Dust And Blood Lipid Concentrations Of Tetrachloro-p-Dibenzodioxin (TCDD) Toxicity Equialency Quotients (TEQ) In Two Populations Near Wood Treatment Facilities. Organohalogen Compounds, Volume 70 (2008) page 002254.

Tam L. K.., Wu C. D., Clark J. J. and Rosenfeld, P.E. (2008) Methods For Collect Samples For Assessing Dioxins And Other Environmental Contaminants In Attic Dust: A Review. Organohalogen Compounds, Volume 70 (2008) page 000527 Hensley A.R., Scott, A., Rosenfeld P.E., Clark, J.J.J. (2007). “Attic Dust And Human Blood Samples Collected Near A Former Wood Treatment Facility.” Environmental Research. 105:194-199.

Rosenfeld, P.E., Clark, J. J., Hensley, A.R., and Suffet, I.H. 2007. “The Use Of An Odor Wheel Classification For The Evaluation of Human Health Risk Criteria For Compost Facilities” Water Science & Technology. 55(5): 345-357.

Hensley A.R., Scott, A., Rosenfeld P.E., Clark, J.J.J. 2006. “Dioxin Containing Attic Dust And Human Blood Samples Collected Near A Former Wood Treatment Facility.” The 26th International Symposium on Halogenated Persistent Organic Pollutants – DIOXIN2006, August 21 – 25, 2006. Radisson SAS Scandinavia Hotel in Oslo Norway.

Rosenfeld, P.E., Clark, J. J. and Suffet, I.H. 2005. “The Value Of An Odor Quality Classification Scheme For Compost Facility Evaluations” The U.S. Composting Council’s 13th Annual Conference January 23 - 26, 2005, Crowne Plaza Riverwalk, San Antonio, TX.

Rosenfeld, P.E., Clark, J. J. and Suffet, I.H. 2004. “The Value Of An Odor Quality Classification Scheme For Urban Odor” WEFTEC 2004. 77th Annual Technical Exhibition & Conference October 2 - 6, 2004, Ernest N. Morial Convention Center, New Orleans, Louisiana.

Clark, J.J.J. 2003. “Manufacturing, Use, Regulation, and Occurrence of a Known Endocrine Disrupting Chemical (EDC), 2,4-Dichlorophnoxyacetic Acid (2,4-D) in California Drinking Water Supplies.” National Groundwater Association Southwest Focus Conference: Water Supply and Emerging Contaminants. Minneapolis, MN.

March 20, 2003.

Rosenfeld, P. and J.J.J. Clark. 2003. “Understanding Historical Use, Chemical Properties, Toxicity, and Regulatory Guidance” National Groundwater Association Southwest Focus Conference: Water Supply and Emerging Contaminants. Phoenix, AZ. February 21, 2003.

Clark, J.J.J., Brown A. 1999. Perchlorate Contamination: Fate in the Environment and Treatment Options. In Situ and On-Site Bioremediation, Fifth International Symposium. San Diego, CA, April, 1999.

Clark, J.J.J. 1998. Health Effects of Perchlorate and the New Reference Dose (RfD).

Proceedings From the Groundwater Resource Association Seventh Annual Meeting, Walnut Creek, CA, October 23, 1998.

Browne, T., Clark, J.J.J. 1998. Treatment Options For Perchlorate In Drinking Water.

Proceedings From the Groundwater Resource Association Seventh Annual Meeting, Walnut Creek, CA, October 23, 1998.

Clark, J.J.J., Brown, A., Rodriguez, R. 1998. The Public Health Implications of MtBE and Perchlorate in Water: Risk Management Decisions for Water Purveyors.

Proceedings of the National Ground Water Association, Anaheim, CA, June 3-4, 1998.

Clark J.J.J., Brown, A., Ulrey, A. 1997. Impacts of Perchlorate On Drinking Water In The Western United States. U.S. EPA Symposium on Biological and Chemical Reduction of Chlorate and Perchlorate, Cincinnati, OH, December 5, 1997.

Clark, J.J.J.; Corbett, G.E.; Kerger, B.D.; Finley, B.L.; Paustenbach, D.J. 1996.

Dermal Uptake of Hexavalent Chromium In Human Volunteers: Measures of Systemic Uptake From Immersion in Water At 22 PPM. Toxicologist. 30(1):14.

Dodge, D.G.; Clark, J.J.J.; Kerger, B.D.; Richter, R.O.; Finley, B.L.; Paustenbach, D.J. 1996. Assessment of Airborne Hexavalent Chromium In The Home Following Use of Contaminated Tapwater. Toxicologist. 30(1):117-118.

Paulo, M.T.; Gong, H., Jr.; Clark, J.J.J. (1992). Effects of Pretreatment with Ipratroprium Bromide in COPD Patients Exposed to Ozone. American Review of Respiratory Disease. 145(4):A96.

Harber, P.H.; Gong, H., Jr.; Lachenbruch, A.; Clark, J.; Hsu, P. (1992). Respiratory Pattern Effect of Acute Sulfur Dioxide Exposure in Asthmatics. American Review of Respiratory Disease. 145(4):A88.

McManus, M.S.; Gong, H., Jr.; Clements, P.; Clark, J.J.J. (1991). Respiratory Response of Patients With Interstitial Lung Disease To Inhaled Ozone. American Review of Respiratory Disease. 143(4):A91.

Gong, H., Jr.; Simmons, M.S.; McManus, M.S.; Tashkin, D.P.; Clark, V.A.; Detels, R.; Clark, J.J. (1990). Relationship Between Responses to Chronic Oxidant and Acute Ozone Exposures in Residents of Los Angeles County. American Review of Respiratory Disease. 141(4):A70.

Tierney, D.F. and J.J.J. Clark. (1990). Lung Polyamine Content Can Be Increased By Spermidine Infusions Into Hyperoxic Rats. American Review of Respiratory Disease. 139(4):A41.

EXHIBIT B
Letter O2C
smart
mobility
1295 Hartford Avenue #8
White River Junction, VT 05001
Norman Marshall, President
(802) 356-2969
[email protected]
August 24, 2026
Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
520 Capitol Mall, Suite 350
Sacramento, CA 95814
Subject: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Dear Mr. Marshall,
I have reviewed vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and trip generation impacts of the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Draft Environmental Impact Report ("DEIR") dated July 2026 and make the following findings:
• Both the retail and medical office components of the project would have significant VMT impacts that would not be fully mitigated by the measures listed in the DEIR. • CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) would provide additional VMT mitigation.
• The DEIR mispresents the pass-by trip reduction for the gasoline service station component of the project.
• Trip generation and the pass-by percentage for the gasoline service station are highly uncertain because the proposed project with 40 fueling stations is significantly different than the sites in the database.
• The gasoline service station's unique characteristics could result in more additional traffic and VMT than other smaller gasoline service stations.
1 Significant VMT Impact
The DEIR states that the project would have a significant VMT impact:

As demonstrated above in Table 4.16-3 and Table 4.16-4, the Project would result in a net increase in countywide roadway VMT under both existing and cumulative conditions, and that the Project's medical office component would exceed the applicable VMT per employee threshold. Accordingly, the Project would result in a potentially significant VMT impact under CEQA. (DEIR, p. 4.16-15 - 4.16.16) The DEIR demonstrates that the retail component would have a significant VMT impact because it would result in higher County VMT.

The DEIR estimates that the medical office component VMT would exceed the significance threshold by

7.76%.

More VMT Mitigation is needed.

The VMT mitigation listed in the DEIR includes: "enhanced pedestrian connectivity, new and expanded bicycle facilities, and end-of-trip bicycle amenities" drawn from the CAPCOA Handbook for Analyzing Greenhouse Gas Emission Reductions, Assessing Climate Vulnerabilities, and Advancing Health and Equity (DEIR, p. 4-16.16) Nevertheless, the DEIR concludes:

However, the reduction in VMT from the design features would not reduce VMT impacts to a less than significant level. As such, the Project would result in a significant impact.

No other feasible mitigation is available. (DEIR, p. 4.16-16) There is other feasible mitigation available. I recommend that CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) be included. This measure would achieve an up to 4.0% reduction in VMT. The Handbook states:

Voluntary CTR programs must include the following elements to apply the VMT reductions reported in literature.
• Employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home. • Information, coordination, and marketing for said services, infrastructure, and incentives (Measure T-7).
2 DEIR misrepresents gasoline service station pass-by trip reduction DEIR Table 4.16-2 (p. 4.16-10) shows that the gasoline service stations would generate 10,196 daily trips including 816 internal capture trips and 7,316 pass-by trips.

The Traffic Study, DEIR Appendix H, states that there would be only 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips, for a total of 7,316 pass-by+ diverted trips. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 361 of 984) The definitions of pass-by and diverted trips in DEIR Appendix Hare consistent with standard usage, specifically:

Pass-by trips represent members (and trips) that are currently traveling on the surrounding street network for some other primary purpose (such as a trip from work to home) and stop into the site enroute during their normal travel. As such, pass-by trips do not result in a net increase in traffic on the surrounding transportation system and their only effect occurs at the immediate intersections and site access driveways where they become turning movements.

Diverted trips are similar to pass-by trips in that they represent members (and trips) that are currently traveling on the surrounding street network for some other primary purpose and stop into the fuel facility site en route during their travel. However, as the name indicates, diverted trips divert from the normal roadways they would be traveling on to go to the Costco site. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 359 of 984) The Institute of Transportation Engineers ("ITE") illustration of these differences is reproduced as Figure 1. As shown in Figure 1, pass-by trips do not add traffic to other roadways, but diverted trips do add traffic to other roadways and add VMT. It is wrong to combine these and call all of these trips pass-by.

Regarding pass-by trips, DEIR Appendix H states:

Based on studies of customer surveys at Costco fuel facilities, an average of 30% and 29% of the members who purchase fuel during the weekday PM and Saturday midday peak hours, respectively, can be classified as pass-by trip capture from the surrounding street system (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 359 of 984).

Although the DEIR states that the diverted percentage also is based on Costco data (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 360 of 984), no backup information is given, including whether there is any mileage threshold for deviation from the primary route. Is a 1-mile diversion a diverted trip? What about a 5-mile diversion? Or 10 miles? Given this lack of documentation regarding diverted trips, the DEIR should report only the pass-by trips in Table 4.16-2.
3 Figure 1: Primary, Pass-By and Diverted Trips
Figure .2. Primary, Pass-Hy, and Diiverted Tri1ps
Shopping Ce ter ·Office
--~ r----------~--
1 Home I ·-, • ~ '-----' .__ __ ..., Primary Trip
0 lffl
r-- ---~-- I
Home I
r-.--.. . ..._ _ ___, ~--~ .._ __ _, a!>:5-ByTrip
Offic.e
l~Sl!!I
------1
DivertiedTrlp
- - - ·- - ·- - - ,.,. rf1)rm:il Rout~· Without D v~lop mt ---- Route With De'lelopment Sou ,ce: Tr~ Ganeirafio Handbook, 3rd Edifio , lns.tiMe ,o· Tran~pcmati E gineers, Wa ington. DC , 017.

Diverted trips add traffic to the street network and associated VMT, unlike pass-by trips, and they cannot be lumped together.
4 Gasoline service station trip generation is highly uncertain The DEIR estimates the gasoline service station's trip generation rate using the Costco transportation database, which contains data related to Costco fuel facilities. But the DEIR's approach is not supported by substantial evidence. This is because the DEIR does not factor in that the proposed gasoline service station is significantly different than the sites included in the database. The proposed gasoline service station has more fueling positions, 40, than at any of the sites in the Costco database, and is also unique in that it is approximately 3 miles away from a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site. DEIR Appendix H states:

The Costco transportation database contains a large quantity of data related to Costco fuel facilities. Trip generation rates and trip type information for over 80 Costco fuel facilities located throughout the US are included. Costco has invested significant effort into developing this use-specific trip generation database because of the unique characteristics of Costco member travel that exist due to membership requirements and the nature of Costco sales. The transportation database consists of fuel facilities ranging from 12 to 32 fueling positions, at locations where the fuel facility is part of a Costco Warehouse or Costco Business Center site. These unique elements apply to the trip generation for Costco warehouses, Costco fuel facilities, and the interaction of trips between the two.

For this Project, Costco is proposing a fuel station with 40 fueling positions as an independent facility where the nearest Costco Warehouse is located approximately 3 miles away. As such, the Project generated a need to assess site trip generation and queuing impacts based on a facility type that is outside the range of currently available Costco data. Despite a lack of empirical data for a site with 40 fueling positions and its unique characteristic as an independent fuel facility, the current database can still inform projections of trips and queues by investigating trends and through extrapolation. Just as the Trip Generation Manual is used by practitioners to estimate trips outside of available empirical data (through trend lines/regression curves), a similar approach can be taken with the available Costco data.

These differences mean that the trip generation rate does not reasonably reflect the proposed gasoline service station's trip generation and pass-by trip percentage. In particular, there cannot be any combined gasoline/warehouse trips within the same site.

Sincerely,
Norman L. Marshall
5 Resume
NORMAN L. MARSHALL, PRESIDENT
[email protected]
EDUCATION:

Master of Science in Engineering Sciences, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, 1982 Bachelor of Science in Mathematics, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, 1977 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE: (39 Years, 25 at Smart Mobility, Inc.) Norm Marshall helped found Smart Mobility, Inc. in 2001. Prior to this, he was at RSG for 14 years where he developed a national practice in travel demand modeling. He specializes in analyzing the relationships between the built environment and travel behavior and doing planning that coordinates multi-modal transportation with land use and community needs.

Regional Land Use/Transportation Scenario Planning
Portland Area Comprehensive Transportation System (PACTS) - the Portland Maine Metropolitan Planning Organization. Updating regional travel demand model with new data (including AirSage), adding a truck model, and multiclass assignment including differentiation between cash toll and transponder payments.

Loudoun County Virginia Dynamic Traffic Assignment - Enhanced subarea travel demand model to include Dynamic Traffic Assignment (Cube). Model being used to better understand impacts of roadway expansion on induced travel.

Vermont Agency of Transportation-Enhanced statewide travel demand model to evaluate travel impacts of closures and delays resulting from severe storm events. Model uses innovate Monte Carlo simulations process to account for combinations of failures.

California Air Resources Board - Led team including the University of California in $250k project that reviewed the ability of the new generation of regional activity-based models and land use models to accurately account for greenhouse gas emissions from alternative scenarios including more compact walkable land use and roadway pricing. This work included hands-on testing of the most complex travel demand models in use in the U.S. today.

Climate Plan (California statewide) -Assisted large coalition of groups in reviewing and participating in the target setting process required by Senate Bill 375 and administered by the California Air Resources Board to reduce future greenhouse gas emissions through land use measures and other regional initiatives.

Chittenden County (2060 Land use and Transportation Vision Burlington Vermont region) - led extensive public visioning project as part of MPO's long-range transportation plan update.

Flagstaff Metropolitan Planning Organization - Implemented walk, transit and bike models within regional travel demand model. The bike model includes skimming bike networks including on-road and off-road bicycle facilities with a bike level of service established for each segment.

Chicago Metropolis Plan and Chicago Metropolis Freight Plan {6-county region)- developed alternative transportation scenarios, made enhancements in the regional travel demand model, and used the enhanced 6 model to evaluate alternative scenarios including development of alternative regional transit concepts.

Developed multi-class assignment model and used it to analyze freight alternatives including congestion pricing and other peak shifting strategies.

Municipal Planning
City of Grand Rapids - Michigan Street Corridor- developed peak period subarea model including non-motorized trips based on urban form. Model is being used to develop traffic volumes for several alternatives that are being additional analyzed using the City's Synchro model City of Omaha - Modified regional travel demand model to properly account for non-motorized trips, transit trips and shorter auto trips that would result from more compact mixed-use development. Scenarios with different roadway, transit, and land use alternatives were modeled.

City of Dublin (Columbus region) - Modified regional travel demand model to properly account for non-motorized trips and shorter auto trips that would result from more compact mixed-use development. The model was applied in analyses for a new downtown to be constructed in the Bridge Street corridor on both sides of an historic village center.

City of Portland, Maine - Implemented model improvements that better account for non-motorized trips and interactions between land use and transportation and applied the enhanced model to two subarea studies.

City of Honolulu - Kaka'ako Transit Oriented Development (TOD) - applied regional travel demand model in estimating impacts of proposed TOD including estimating internal trip capture.

City of Burlington (Vermont) Transportation Plan - Led team that developing Transportation Plan focused on supporting increased population and employment without increases in traffic by focusing investments and policies on transit, walking, biking and Transportation Demand Management.

Transit Planning
Regional Transportation Authority (Chicago) and Chicago Metropolis 2020 - evaluated alternative 2020 and 2030 system-wide transit scenarios including deterioration and enhance/expand under alternative land use and energy pricing assumptions in support of initiatives for increased public funding.

Capital Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Austin, TX) Transit Vision - analyzed the regional effects of implementing the transit vision in concert with an aggressive transit-oriented development plan developed by Calthorpe Associates. Transit vision includes commuter rail and BRT.

Bus Rapid Transit for Northern Virginia HOT Lanes (Breakthrough Technologies, Inc and Environmental Defense.) - analyzed alternative Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) strategies for proposed privately-developing High Occupancy Toll lanes on 1-95 and 1-495 (Capital Beltway) including different service alternatives (point-to-point services, trunk lines intersecting connecting routes at in-line stations, and hybrid).

Roadway Corridor Planning
1-30 Little Rock Arkansas - Developed enhanced version of regional travel demand model that integrates TransCAD with open source Dynamic Traffic Assignment (DTA) software, and used to model 1-30 alternatives.

Freeway bottlenecks are modeled much more accurately than in the base TransCAD model. 7 South Evacuation Lifeline (SELL) - In work for the South Carolina Coastal Conservation League, used Dynamic Travel Assignment (DTA) to estimate evaluation times with different transportation alternatives in coastal South Caroline including a new proposed freeway.

Hudson River Crossing Study (Capital District Transportation Committee and NYSDOT)-Analyzing long term capacity needs for Hudson River bridges which a special focus on the 1-90 Patroon Island Bridge where a microsimulation VISSIM model was developed and applied.

PUBLICATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS (partial list)
DTA Love: Co-leader of workshop on Dynamic Traffic Assignment at the June 2019 Transportation Research Board Planning Applications Conference.

Forecasting the Impossible: The Status Quo of Estimating Traffic Flows with Static Traffic Assignment and the Future of Dynamic Traffic Assignment. Research in Transportation Business and Management 2018.

Assessing Freeway Expansion Projects with Regional Dynamic Traffic Assignment. Presented at the August 2018 Transportation Research Board Tools of the Trade Conference on Transportation Planning for Small and Medium Sized Communities.

Vermont Statewide Resilience Modeling. With Joseph Segale, James Sullivan and Roy Schiff. Presented at the May 2017 Transportation Research Board Planning Applications Conference.

Assessing Freeway Expansion Projects with Regional Dynamic Traffic Assignment. Presented at the May 2017 Transportation Research Board Planning Applications Conference.

Pre-Destination Choice Walk Mode Choice Modeling. Presented at the May 2017 Transportation Research Board Planning Applications Conference.

A Statistical Model of Regional Traffic Congestion in the United States, presented at the 2016 Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board.
8 21 August 2026
City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department Planning Division
Attn: Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
SUBJECT: COMMENTS ON THE DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT

FOR THE RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
To Whom It May Concern:

I am providing comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project). My comments specifically address deficiencies in Section 4.4 Biological Resources regarding the federally endangered and state threatened San Joaquin kit fox. This Section was largely based on the associated Appendix C: General Biological Assessment (GBA).

I have been observing San Joaquin kit foxes in Bakersfield since 1990 and have conducted research and conservation projects with the urban foxes since 1997. Most of this work was conducted while a research ecologist with and then Director of the California State University-Stanislaus, Endangered Species Recovery Program (ESRP). Although retired now, I still work with and assist the group that continues to work with urban kit foxes. Our collective experience with urban kit foxes sums to many decades.

In Section 4.4 of the DEIR, the preparers conclude that kit foxes are not present on the Project site and that habitat for this species is not present. A further conclusion is that wildlife corridors are not present on the site. These conclusions apparently are based on a single site survey and assessment conducted by Hernandez Environmental Services, a group whose qualifications are unspecified. Based on the website for this group, they have no or little experience with San Joaquin kit foxes, particularly those inhabiting urban habitats in Bakersfield, or with San Joaquin Valley species and ecosystems in general. Consequently, the conclusions presented in the DEIR and the GBA are patently incorrect on several accounts.

It is highly likely that kit foxes use the proposed Project site, if not regularly then at least on occasion. On a number of occasions, dead kit foxes have been found on Rosedale Highway or Coffee Road adjacent to the project site. These foxes in all likelihood were coming from or going to the Project site. Kit foxes also are routinely observed at the Northwest Promenade center and Lowe , both of which are just across the highway from the Project Site. During city-wide surveys using wildlife cameras, out group detected kit foxes in 2018, 2022, and 2024 in the storm water drainage basin on the west end of the Project Site (35.382275, -119.100788). In February of this year (2026) Lowe employees informed us that a kit fox we were trying to capture was going back and forth between Lowe s and the Project site.

Letter P1
's Home Improvement Center
's
Indeed, very recently (21 August 2026) a sick kit fox was captured directly across Coffee Road from the Project site along the Friant Kern Canal. Additionally, one or more reproducing kit fox family groups have been almost continuously present at the Central Valley Renewable Fuels facility less than a mile east of the Project site. The locations of the road mortality kit foxes as well as those that have been live-trapped for research or treatment purposes have been submitted to the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB). Granted, the CNDDB is woefully behind in entering submitted information. However, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) are aware of the locations. The standard procedure currently for surveying for kit foxes involves deploying and operating wildlife cameras for multiple days. It is unclear why the consultant performing surveys on the site for the project proponent did not employ this methodology. The failure to do so will most likely result in the CDFW and FWS rejecting the reported results and conclusions as blatantly inadequate.

With regards to habitat, the disturbed ruderal habitat present on the Project site is one of the many types of urban habitat that kit foxes commonly use throughout Bakersfield. Use of this habitat has been abundantly documented in previous studies (see documents attached to the transmittal email). Also, extensive examples and evidence of use of this habitat could have been provided by any of the many environmental consulting groups that actually have experience with San Joaquin kit foxes in Bakersfield. The California State University-Bakersfield campus, proposed Veteran s Hospital site on Hageman road, and the Central Valley Renewable Fuels facility are all nearby examples (among many) of sites where kit foxes are using disturbed ruderal habitat. Again, CDFW and FWS are well aware of urban habitats used by kit foxes and will very likely reject this conclusion.

The conclusion regarding corridors further highlights the lack of experience and familiarity regarding kit foxes and San Joaquin Valley species in general. Clearly, there are no mountain canyons on the floor of the San Joaquin Valley. The logical conclusion is that kit foxes and other species in the Valley do not require such features for movement and dispersal. Also, kit foxes are adapted to arid lands and deserts and extensively avoid riparian corridors where their main predators, coyotes and bobcats, have abundant ambush cover. Kit foxes will move across any open space, such as the Project site. Indeed, we have documented radio-collared kit foxes moving over 12 kilometers (straight line) through the urban environment. They have an amazing capacity to get around, under, and through barriers such as fences and walls. They are able to squeeze through gaps as small as 3.5 inches. Thus, they would have no problem accessing the Project site.

In summary, the Project site does indeed have habitat for kit foxes and kit foxes undoubtedly use the site and definitely traverse it. Given that, the assessments and conclusions regarding kit foxes and potential impacts to kit foxes require extensive revision, preferably by a group that actually has familiarity and experience with the species. Furthermore, the Project proponent definitely needs to obtain a 2081 Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from the CDFW and a 10(a)1(a) incidental take permit (aka Habitat Conservation Plan [HCP]) from the FWS. Failure to do so will most certainly result in litigation (and lengthy project delays) by one or more environmental groups, as has commonly occurred on other development projects in Bakersfield where project proponents failed to adequately assess impacts to kit foxes. Finally, applications for the ITP and " "
HCP should include appropriate measures to avoid or mitigate impacts to kit foxes, in particular conducting proper surveys for kit foxes or their dens prior to any ground disturbance, proper excavation of any dens, exclusionary fencing (kit foxes commonly are attracted to construction sites; they were a daily occurrence on the recent Mercy Southwest Hospital expansion project), biological monitors on site during construction, and conservation measures such as the installation of artificial dens in quiet areas and fencing and walls that accommodate kit fox passage.

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the DEIR and GBA.

Sincerely,
Brian L. Cypher
[email protected]
Management and Conservation of San Joaquin Kit Foxes in Urban Environments
Brian L. Cypher and Christine L. Van Horn Job
Endangered Species Recove1y Program, California Slate University-Stanislaus, Bakersfield, California ABSTRACT: The San Joaquin kit fox is listed as federally Endangered and California 1l1reatened, primarily due to habitat loss from agricultural, industTial, and urban developments. However, a population ofl<lt foxes estimated at 200-400 persists within the city of Bakersfield, CA. This population appears to be demographically robust with a high probability of persistence. Thus. tJ1is population potentially could contribute to range-wide conservation and recovery efforts. ll1c presence of this population in an urban environment creates management challenges. Management issues include human and pet safety, dens in inconvenient locations, and carcass dis-posal. Resolution of these issues gencmlly is not difficult. Conservation challenges include roads and vehicles, rodcnticidcs and other toxins. sports netting, den destruction during routine maintenance operations, inten;pecific competition and disease transmission, movement conidors. and regulatory policy. Although the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan provides protective measures for kit loxes duting new conslniction, such measures do not extend to operatio11s, maintenance, and other routine acLivitics.

Fut1hermore, formal policies regarding management and conservation of urban kjt foxes have not yet been developed by the U.S.

Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Pish and Game, resulting in inconsistent responses to urban kit fox issues.

Based on a public opinion survey. Bakersfield residents generally support conservation orw-ban kit foxes. Successful resolution of management issues will minimize conflicts and enb,rnce efforts to conserve kit foxes.

KEV WORDS: conflict management, conservation, dens. endangered species, intcrspecific competition, San Joaqu.in kit fox, urban environmenL Vulpes macro/is 11111tica
lNTRODUCTfON
Tht: San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) is
endemic to arid sluubland and grassland habitats in the San Joaquin Valley region of central Califomia. Although hunting, trapping, and predator control programs may have contributed to declining numbers in the past, the primary threat to lcit foxes has been and continues to be profound habitat fragmentation, degradation. and loss, largely result-ing from agricultural, industrial, and urban development.

Of the over 3.9 million ha of historical habitat in the San Joaqujn Valley (e.g., grasslands. shrublands, wetlands), ap-proximately 50% was converted to agricultural, urban, or industrial uses by 1945, and approximately 70% by 2004
(Kelly et al. 2005). Much of the remaining habitat is frag-mented and degraded and subject to adverse impacts such as off-road vehicle use, trash dumping. rodent poisoning, and domestic dogs (USFWS 1998). Consequently, the
San Joaquin kit fox was listed as Federally Endangered
in 1967 and as California Tlu·eatened in 1971 (USFWS
I 998). The remaining number of individuals is unknown. but because of continuing habitat loss, kit fox numbers are assumed to still be declining (USFWS 2010).

Although urban development is one cause of kit fox
decline, ironically, kit fox populations occur in several ur-ban areas in the San Joaquin Valley (Figure I). Extensive research conducted in the city of Bakersfield since 1997 indicates that urban kit foxes appear to be faring well both demographically and ecologically (Cypher 20 l 0). Surviv-al and reproductive rates among urbao kit foxes are signif-icantly higher than rates among non-urban foxes. Based on casual estimates, the kit fox population in Bakersfield could be as large as 200-400 animals. Kil foxes forage
347
Proc. 25'" Vertebr. Pest Conf. (R. M. limm. Ed.)
Published at Univ. of Calif., Dayis. 20U. Pp, 347-352,
and create dens in undeveloped lands ( e.g .. vacant lots, fallow crop fields), stonn water catchment basins (sumps). industrial areas (e.g., manufacturing facilities, shipping yards), commercial areas (e.g., office and retail facilities), manicured open space (e.g., parks, school campuses, golf courses), and linear rights-of-way (e.g., canals, railroad ,
□ Taft
0 20 40
Kilometers 0
Figure 1. A viable population of San Joaquin kit fox is found in urban Bakersfield, in the southern San Joaquin Valley.
con-il.lor.s. power line cotTidors). Only high-density resi- dential areas with their abundant funces, w::ills, and dogs appear Lo be uvui<letl. Also. food is abundant and includes rotlt:nls (particul.1rly pocket gophers. Tl10111omys bottae, and California grouud squirrels, Spemwphilus beeclteyi), birru;, insec1s, anu a 111ultin1de of antJu·opogenic ttems in-cluding uash, food lctl oul for feral cats, and handouts.

Cnm,l.'qln:ntly, lhe Bakersfield kit fox population appears robust, wicfo-spread. aml persistent, and therefore consei:- vatiun elfo1 ls an: wan.mled.

Urban kit lox f)l)pulaiions c.an contribute lo conse1va-tion a11d recowry cOons for the species in a number of ways (Cypher 20 I 0). Thi:sc populations add to die lotal nutnbc1 or pup11l.1tions and number uf surviving kit foxes, and increas1.: Ille gendic diversity of San .Joaquin kit foxes r:mge-widc. Utb.in e11vironrnents are less prone lo lhc en-vironmental variation observed in natural habitats (::;uch as annuul rninfoll tluctuatio11s a11d lhe resulting effects on prey availability) and lltus, urban populalions appear more stable and could serve as a ·'hedge" against catastrophic eve11ts (e.g., disease epidemic) among non-urban popula-tions. Urban populations can also provide individuals to repopulate dthcr existing nanrral lands after a catastrophic 0vcnl or restored habitats within tlte species' range. An additional benefit or urban populations is increased pub-lic r1wnre111.!ss amt interest by local residents due Lo more freqw.!11L obscrvauons or encounrers \\ ith kit foxes. Based on survey results. Bake1-slicld residents v.ho had observed kit foxes had greater appreciation and knowledge of them and expressed greater supputt for conserving both urban nnd nou-urlnu1 foxes (Bjurli11 :md Cypher 2005).

Our ol~jectives arc 10 I) idenLify urban kit fox 1nanage-111cnt issues and potential mitigation measures, 2) identify potential challenges for conserving urban kit foxes, and 3) ofler recom111011<la1ions for strategies to manage and t:on-servc kit foxes i11 urban environments.

MANAGEMENT ISSUES
For u carnivore residing in an urban environment, San
Joaquin kit lbxe~ gent.:ralc few conflicts. They are small, secretive, m)c:!u1n,1I, virtuully silent, unaggressive, and n1rely eausl! n11y da111age or nuisance situations. The most common comrluinl is from goiters who claim that loxes
residing on goll' courses run out mid steal their balls! The most sig11ilkttlll managemcn1 issues are probably I) con- 1.:erns regarding human and pet salety, 2) dens in incon-vetiienl locations, and 3) collection and disposal of dead loxes.

Allhough safety is valid coucern when a c.-muvore is
living in clusc proximity to people. humans are at mini-mal 1isk from kit foxes. We are a wan: of only 2 instances of people being bitten by kit foxes. and in both cases the individuuls billcn were n·ying to handle foxe:; (one fox was e11l:mgh.:d in c1 soc<.!er goa l net. anc.J the other lox was corn1:red am! captured at a school). Similarly, we are not awnrl! of any vcrilfod attacks on pcls or livestock by kil foxes. Kit loxes carrying dead kiUens have been reported but not substantiated. Domestic cal hair occLuTed in 2 or 180 urban kit fox seals in one study (Cypher and War-rick 1993) a11d I out or 2,08 1 scats in another study lB, L.

Cypher, unpubl. data). However, il is unknown whether
the:,1:: occt11TcI1ces represent preclatio11 or scavenging, or whi!!hcr LJiey involved companion or teraJ cats.

Kil fox <lens in inconvenient locations li_kd) constitute rhe most c1.1m111011 conflict issue. In these situations, rlw presence of the den impedes some activity, creates a haz-ardous situation, or creates n nuisance situation. Kil lox dens on cons1111ction sites are an example of an impedeJ activity. ln some instances the dens are present prior to Lite ini1iation of construction, ant.I in other instances fo;1.~s create dens on :ictive construction sitt:s, where they may be attracted by easy c.ligging in distLu·bed soil or fooiJ dropped b) wo1 kers. Kit loxes occasionally have t•ve11 cren1ed dt>ns in partially constructed buildings. Cunstruc-tion activities in Lhe immediate vicinity of a den cannot proceed while the Jen is occupied by the fox. Hazardous situ:itio11s result when a dc.:11 is in a location where n person might ai.:citlcntally step iu Lhe den, causing them an injury.

Examrles include some dens (m golf courses, ,vhere grass may obscure lhe d'-'ln entrance, and dens on athletic: fields or ureas with heavy root 1rnfiic cm schuol campuses. Nui-siu1ce situations are those that are 1101 dangerous but create an undesirable result. Examples include dens in which
the excavated dirt lands 011 a sidewall( (in one i11stanl'.c, ,1 door to a business was partially blocked by excavall:!d dirl from a den). On one occasion. foxes constructed dt!ns in a golf course sand bunker requiring repair of the bu11- kcr. Another example im olws dens under homes, par-ticularly mobile homes, an<l portable classroom buildings on school campusc.s. Nuisance problems resulting from
these de11s include fecal material on sidewalks, odors, Ilea infestations, and noise.

The mitiga1ion strntegy for a den in un inconvenient
location is to remove 1he den, and LJierc a1e protocols es-tablished by tJ1e U.S. Fish & Wildlife Ser. ice (USFWS) and the California Deparrment of Fish ant.I Game (CDFU) for doing so. Typically, a den is monitored for fox activity either by using tracking media or using an automated fidtl camera. 0111.:c lhe den exhibits no sign of use by lbxes for 3 nights, rltcn it can be carefully excavated (in a manner that would allow any foxes inside to escape), collupsecl, and compacted. In situations where rime is rnore critical, a one-way door uan be installed on a den to prevern tuxes from reentering aner they kave the den. Once it is certain that all loxes have exiled lhe den, it c.u, be excavated nnd collapsed. Foxes typically have multiple Jens within their home range, and therefore lhe loss ofone den usually does not achcrsely aflecl a fox. Natal dens with pups are more problematic, as no disturbance of such dens is allowed un-til the foxes leave the dens on U1eir own, whicb could be a matter of weeks. When fox dens are removed, the loss can be mitigated by installi11g arlifkial dens {see below).

Another more recent management issue in Bakersfield
is the collection and disposal of fox carcasses. WitJi tht:
large number of animals in the Lu·ban enviromnent, foxes are nm uncomn1only struck and killed by vehicles whik
crossing roads. City and County A11iJnal Conb·ol staff are responsibk for collecting road-killed animals. but 1hesc organizations are reluctant to pick up dead kiL foxes be-cause they are an endangered species. This has resulted in lh1strntions on the part of individuals when a malodorous, unsightly carcass lies outside lhcir home nr business for multiple days.

Table 1. Causes of mortality for 78 radio-collared San
Joaquin kit foxes found dead in Bakersfield, CA, 2001-
2004. Total number of foxes monitored was 229.

Cause of Mortality
Vehicle
Predator
Entombment
Poison
Drowning
Pellet gun
Entanglement
Birth complications
Undetermined
I Number
27 17
4 4
22 CONSERVATION CHALLENGES
Conserving populations of desirable wildlife, pa1ticu-larly a rare species. in urban environments is inherently challenging. Particular challenges for conseJVing urban populations of San Joaquin kit foxes are described below.

Roads
Vehicles arc lhe primary cause of mortality for urban
kit foxes (Table 1; Bjurlin cl al. 2005. Cypher 20 I 0). The pervasive nature of roads in urban environments makes
them difficult l'o avoid, particularly for a highly mobile species like kit foxes. Furthem1ore, because kit foxes use so many different areas within urban environments, they rarely use well defined road crossing areas. Consequent-ly, common strategies for reducing vehicle strikes (e.g., warning signs, reduced speed limits, crossing strnclures) have low probabilities of success. Also, kit foxes seem to have an inherent reluctance to use under-road cross-ing structures. particularly small ones where foxes may fear mnbush by larger predators (Brenmer-Han·ison et al. 2007, Clevenger et al. 2010). Thus, mitigating vehicle
mo11ality is diffi.cull In situations where a natal den is located in close proximity to a road, temporary signage to encourage slower speeds or at least be alert for foxes may be helpful.

Toxins
Various substances toxic lo kit foxes and other wild-1 ife arc present in urban environments. Rodenticides are a particular concern. First-generation ( e.g., warfarin, cholorphacinonc, cliphacinone) and more toxic second-generation (e.g., brodifacoum, difethialone, bromadio-lone) anticoagulant rodenticides are commonly used in w·ban environments to control commcnsal rodents (rats,
mice) and ground squirrels. These materials arc used by professional pest control applicators and also have been available in over-the-counter products for use by non-professiona ls. They typically are dispersed in stations consisting of a container with holes that allow rodents to access toxin-infused food within. First-generation antico-agulants require multiple feedings before they are fatal, while second-generation compounds can be lethal with a
single feeding. With both compounds. death is not im-mediate and rodents are potentiaUy able to move consider-able distances from bait stations before dying.

Of 30 liver samples collected from foxes found dead
in Bakersfield, 27 (90%) contained residues or at leasl one anticoagulant (MeMillin et al. 2008). II is unknown wheLher the exposures arc primary (i.e., foxes conswning baits) or secondary (i.e., foxes consuming dead or <lying rodents). At least 3 foxes are µresumed to have died di-rectly from exposure LO anticoagulants. based on residue levels in their livers and other post-mortem evidence (e.g .. profuse intc111al bleeding). Other foxes may have died di-rectly from these toxins, but laboratory and necropsy re-sults were not conclusive. Also unknown is the number of foxes for which ilJness associated wi1.h rodenticide expo-sure predisposed them to death by ,mother agent, such a<: a vehicle or predator. Fim1lly, adverse sublethal effects, in-cluding neonatal mo1tality (e.g., Munday and Thompson 2003), have not been invesliga1ed.

Strychnine poisoning bas been con.finned among 4
kit foxes found dead in Bakersfield (S. MeMillin, CDH.1. pers. commun.). TI1e likely source of Lhe poison is strych-nine-infused grain bait used to control pocket gophers. /\s with the anticoagulants, it is unknown whelhcr the poison-ing was primary or secondary, although grain wa,; found in the stomach of one fox.

Rodenlicides cmTcnlly do not appear to be a limiling
factor for the urban fox population in Bakersficl<l, bul the high exposure rates are a cause for concern. Recent limi-tations on access to second-generation anticoagulants by non-professional applicators imposed by lhe U.S. Envi-ronmental Protection Agency (McMillin et al. 2008) and a ban on use of strychnine baits in Bakersfield (R. Arroyo.

Kern County Dept. of AgriCLL[turc, pcrs. commun.) hope-r ully will help mitigate adverse impacts to ki1 foxes from rodenticides.

Sports Netting
In a vcty urban-specific situation, kit fo xes have been found entangled in sports netting on least 29 occasions that we are aware of (CSUS Endangered Species Recov-ery Program. unpubl. data). This neuing includes soccer goals, portable and pem1anent baseball batting cages. and a low-hanging volleyball nel. Most of the entanglements have occurred on high school or college campuses. The
foxes have died in at least 12 of these instances. and the badly damaged hind leg of a fox had Lo be amputated in
another. Because they arc nocturnal, kit foxes are as~umed to have superb night-vision, and therefore th~ n:ason Co,· U1ese entanglements is puzzling.

Den Destruction
Kit fox dens in urban environments can be destroyed
through a number of routine activities. The loss of a (kn in itself may not be a significant impact because kit fox-es typically have multiple dens wiU1in their home range.

However, a significant impact obviously occurs if a den is destroyed while occupied by one or more kit foxes, pmtic-ularly if it is a natal den harboring yOLmg. In Bakersfield, new constrnction involving earth disturbance requires :1 permit that is issued under the Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan (MBHCP). Requirements ~-
sociated with these permits include monitoring ,1nd clos-ing kit fox dens per established protocols (MB HCP 1994 ). and therefore the risk to foxes is minimized.
349
A number of routine mainlenance and operations ac-tivities are not covered under lhe MBHCP and therefore ar.: not subject to the den closure requirements. These activities include maintenance or sumps, maintenance or canals, weed control, and landscaping. During these ac-Livities, ground is bladed, dug, or disked to cont om surfac-es, rcpair erosion damage, and i-cmove vegetation. These earth-c.listw·bances can close or collapse dens. Destruction or dens during these activities frequently is unintcnlionol, and indeed, individuals conducting the activities may not even be aware dial dens arc present. Surveys for dens arc not required prior to initiating these activities and there-fore such surveys are rarely conducted. Consequemly, a number of instances of den desu·uction have occurred
(Cypher 20 I 0). Adult foxes commonly are able Lo vacate dens prior to destruction, but young foxes may be unable or too inexperienced to leave, resulting in entombment.

Interspecitic Competiuon
Non-native red foxes (V11/pes vu/pes), srriped skunks
(Mephitis mephitis), feral cats, opossums (Diclelphis vir-ginianu), and raccoons (Pro9,011 lotor) all commonly occur in urban environmen1s inhabited by kit foxes, and these species potentially engage in interspecific compe-tition with fo.>.es. These spt.:cics could compete with kit foxes for resources such as food and dens (i.e., exploitative competi1ion), or polemially could kill kit foxes or spatially exclude them (i.e., interference competition). Kit foxes have ,;eportedly been killed by the larger red foxes (Rolls and White 1995, Clark et al. 200.5), but no such morla li-t1cs have been detected in Bakersfield (Bjurlin et al. 2005). where both are commonly observed in close proximity. lt is unclear whether red foxes spatially exclude kit foxes, although red fox~ have been observed using dens previ-ously used by kit foxes and dieta,y overlap between lhe two species is high i11 the urban environment (Cypher
2010, unpubl. data). Thus, some competition may occur
between these 2 species, ahhough it dol:!s not currently ap-pear lo be a limiting factor for kit foxes. The other species probably do not engage in intt:rference competition with kit loxes, but do use kil fox dens and likely overlap in diet Fi.:rol cars and striped skunks have been observed using kit fox dens (Cypher 20 I 0, Harrison et al.2011 ).

Another significant threat to kit foxes from these sym-patric species is the potential for disease transmission. Be-cause of space limitations in urban environments, tl1ese species all occur in close pro.>.imity. For example, all of tht: species have been observed, sometimes concurrently, at or near feeding stations established for feral cats (Har-rison cl al. 2011 ). Also, as menl ioned previously, sever-al of the species have: been obse1ved using kit fox dens. lmked, radio-collared striped skunks and kit foxes were detected together in <li.:ns on 4 occasions (Harrison el al. 2011 ). Thus, the potential for the transmission of diseases Lo kit foxes is high. Of particular concern is rabies, which is highly lethal and could significantly impact urban kit fox populations. A rabies epidemic in striped skunks may have contributed to the marked decline of a non-urban kit fox population (White et al. 2000).

Movement Corridors
Various urban landscape reatures could i:mpeJe or even
constitute barriers to movements by kit foxes. Although foxes can and do cross roads and occasionally movl!
through residential areas, both of these features present higher risks for kit foxes. and Lillis sometimt!s constitute batTiers. Fences and particularly walls also present barri-ers to movements. ln addition lo impeding movements, kit foxes potentially could be u·apped up against ba1Tiers when fleeing from larger predaLors or when crossing roads.

Regulatory Issues
The applicability of endangered species regulations to
urban kit foxes is somewhat unclear because these popu-lations are deliberately inJ1abiting landscapes allered and dominated by humans. CurTenlly, few regulations afford
protections to urban kil foxes and no official policies ex-ist that promote conservation of these populations. lntcn-tional "taking" (e.g., d~arh, injury, capture) ot' kit loxes is prohibited under the Federal and California Endangered
Species Acts. However, whether any policies or rcgula-tjons concerning incidental taking or harassmc.!nt of foxes apply in urban environments is uncertain. The MBJ JCP
mandates the careful e.>.clusion of kit foxes prior LO the de-struction of known dens, but Onl) for projects requiring an eruth grading pennit from the City of Bakersfield or Kem Courtty (MBHCP 1994 ).

The USFWS and CDFG are the two agencies primar-ily responsible fur endangered species protection. To date, neither has taken a lead role in promoting urban kit fox conservation, although this likely is partly due to the fad that the conservation potential of l11ese populations has only recently become evide111, and both agencies have lim-itt:d resources. These agencies are becoming more active in urban kit fox conservation as they are able. Other enti-ties that also potentially could assume lead roles include the City of Bakersfield, conse,vation organizations, aud citizen groups, but none have stepped forward to date. As regulatory and other enti1ics consider strategies for con-serving urban kit fox popula1ions, an imponanl issue will be determining whether measures will be mandatory or
volunta1y. Mandatory measures may ensure greawr com-pliance and may be appropriate for protecting kil foxes from ham1 or adverse impacts. Voluntruy measures may
be more appropriate for encouraging proactive ct1nsl."!rva-tion actions, such as the installation of a1tificial dens and permeable fences or walls. The minimization of manda-tory requirements may help to enhance and maintain pub-lic suppon for conserving kit foxes.

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Generally, urban kit fox populations appear LO be
tlu·iving, despite tl1c management issues and conserva-tion challenges dest:ribed above, the high potential for hu-man impacts, and the current lack ol"specific conservation measures. However, this siluaLion easily could change bt.!- cause of the inherent difficulty o[ controlling and manag-ing condicions in a dynamic, human-dominalt!d landscape.

T11us, any actions implememed, particularly proactivdy, to facilitate the conse1vation of urban kit fox populations will contribute toward the goal of enhancing the prob-ability of persistence and viability of these populations.

The following recommendations are offered Lo assisL in
achieving this goal.
350
Conservation Measures in New Habitat Conservation
Plan
The cun-cm MB HCP is due LO expire in 2014 and work
has begun on the preparation of a new Habitat Conserva-tion Plan (1 ICP). tentatively refc1Ted to as the Bakersfield Regional HCP. We recommend thc1L this HCP include
decisive, proactive conservation measures for urban kit foxes. These measures should include the following:
l. Required stu·veys for kit fox dens for ::ill projects pem1itted under the HCP, with no exceptions.

2. r-undin~ for n biologist who can deal with kit
fox isstTcs and conflicts, help interested parties
implement conservation measures. and conduel
out,·each nnd education efforts.

3. Maintenance of connectivity within urban pop-ulations through fox-friendly urban landscape design.

4. Encouragement of voluntary conservation mea-sw-es by developers including open spaces con-nected by corridors, rox-permeable walls and fences, and artificial dens.

5. Conducting out,-cach programs to enhance
awareness and education.

Development of a Disease Prevention/Response Plan
A team that includes. among others, wildlife biologists, wildlife epidemiologists, and public health officials should be Conned lo develop a plan to minimize U1e potential for and the impacts of a fatal disease epidemic among urban kit foxes. Con~iderations in such a plan should include l) preventative measures such as proaclive vaccination of foxes. probably via oral baits, in selected areas where such efforts might be feasible; 2) monitoring for the presence of diseases; 3) idcnlilYing miligation and trcatmentslrntegics in the event of an outbreak; 4) protecting public health in the event ol'a zoonotic disease outbreak (e.g., rabie.s); and 5) identifying possible population recovery strategies in the event that population impacts arc catastrophic.
lrnplementation of Earth-Moving Guidelines to
Protect Dens
Such guidelines should include required surveys for
kit fox dens prior t"o earth-moving, protocols for protecting dens or for eliminating them wilhout harming foxes, nnd restrictions on activil'ies nenr active natal dens.

Rcshktions on Rodenticide U,;c
Measw·es to forU,cr restrict access by foxes to roden-ticide baits and dead/dying rodents should be developed and implemented.

Sports Nt>tting Mitigation
Through regulation or at least , igorous outreach tar-geting schools ill pm1icular, standard prn.;tices should be implemented to remove sports netting when not in use or at least elevate it (0.5 m minimum) Lo help avoid entangle-ment by kit r oxes.

Barrier Permeability
Some ba1Tiers, such as fences and walls. are easily ren-dered pcm1cablc lo kit roxes. Gaps as smal I as 10-15 cm wide will pem1il passage by loxes. Permeable struclmes
35 1
can bec: i11stalled initially or retroactively modi lied to nllow passage by kit foxes.

Kit Fox Accommodation in Urban Landscape
Planning
Kit fox population facilitation should be a consid-eration incorporate<l into urban planning in cities with resjdenl kit fox populations. Non-rcsidcnlial areas, par-ticularly golf courses, parks. sumps, campuses, and other open space, are oil areas commonly used by kit foxes. In designing urban landscapes, efforts to connect these areas with movement corridors, such as canals, power line ;incl railroad right-of-ways, green belts, and recreational trnils, will help maintain connectivity and facilitate movcmcntc; by kit foxes between areas thus enhancing genetic; and de-mographic exchange.

Outreach and Education
Outreach and education programs will help improve
community awareness regarding kit foxes and their con-servation needs. Such programs can he llmdcd by public or private sources, and should include infonnation ab()ut urban kit fox identification. biology, threats, and conserva-tion measures. These programs can target city managers and maintenance staff, property owners, urban planners. developers, golf course managers. canal operators. con-struction crews, educators, school children, and the gen-eral public.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Ft1nding for urban kit fox research nnd conservntion ha~ been rm-vided by the U.S. Burc.1u of Reclamation, California 1Jepmt111c111 (If Fish und Game. California Dcpa11111en1 of frJnsponatio11, Gre--11 V:llley Center. ARCO Western Energy. and Clll"\ ron l lSA. Wr apprcdall" .is-sistance provided for this project by S. Phillip~. C Bjurlin . .I. ~tori,.:. C'.

Wing.:rt. S. Bremner-Harrison, S. 11:mi~on. A. Rrown. J. 1'.lurdoch. F.

Tennant.. 1111d F,. Kelly.

LITERATURE CITED
BJURLIN, C. D .. and B. L. CYPllr.R. 1005. Encounter frequency with the urbanized San Joaquin kit fox coll'clatcs with p11hlic beliefs and altitudes toward the species. Endangered Spe-cies Update 22: 107-115.

I3J\1RI IN, C. n .. B. L. CYPllr:R. C. M. W1N(;1 Rr. and C. L. VAN HoRN Jo11. 2005. Urban roads and the endangered San Joa-quin kit fox. California Stale University-Stanislaus. [ndan-gcrecl Species Recovery Program. Fresno, Cl\. 47 pp.

BRFMNt.:R-HAR1USON, S .. 8. L. Cvrurn. C. M. Fin 11 1 it .. A. P. Ctn-FN01'k, and n. [lAcKf.R. 2007. U:-c o r highway nossing structures by kit foxes. California Stale U11i\'ersilv-S1an-islaus. Endangered Species Recove1y Program. Fre._1;0. CA. 45 pp.

Ct.ARK, H. 0 .. fa .. G. D. WARR1c 1,.. B. L. CYP11rn, P. J\.. Kw,. D.

I•. W11.LIAMS, and D. E. Gm inns. 2005. Compt:titive intt'rnc-Lions between endangered kit fo:\CS an<l nonnall\-C red foxes.

West. No.A.mer. Nalwnlist 65:153-16~.

CLEVl,NGt,R.A. P., Konot.FK, A. v., and ll. L. CvPIII.R. 2010. er- feels of four-lane highways on desert 1-.it lo:-. and ~wili ti,:-.:
lnfercnces for the San .loaquio kit fox population. Western Transportation fnstilulc. Montana Stn1c Univcrnity. Boze-man, MT. 66 pp.

CYPHbR, 8. L. 2010. Kit foxes. Pp. 49-60 in: S. D. Gehri, S. P.

D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher (Eds.). Urban Carnivores: Ecol-ogy, Conflict, and Conseivation. The Johns Hopkins Uni-versity Press, Baltimore, JvlD.

CYPHER, B. L., and G.D. WARRICK. 1993. Use ofbmnan-de-rived food items by urban kit foxes. Trans. West. Sect. The Wildt. Soc. 29:34-37.

HARRISON, S. W. R., B. L. CYPHER, S. BREMNER-HARrusON, and C. L. VAN HORN Joa. 20 I l. Resmu-ce use overlap between urban carnivor~: implications for endangered San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mulica). Urban Ecosyst. 14:303- 31 J.

KELLY, P.A., S. E. PH!LLIPS, and D. F. W!LL!AM3. 2005. Docu-menting Ecological Change in Time and Space: The San Joaquin VaUey of California. Pp. 57-78 in: E. A. Lacey and P. Myers, Eds. Mammalian Diversification: From Chromo-somes Lo Phylogeography. Publications in Zoology Series, Univ. of California Press, Berkeley, CA. 383 pp.

McM1LuN, S. C., R. C. HosEA, B. F. F INLAYSON, B. L. CYPHER, and A. MEKEaru. 2008. Anticoagulant rodenlicide exposure in an urban population of the San Joaquin kit fox. Proc. Ver-tebr. Pest Conf. 23:163-165. 352
MB.HCP (METROPOUTAN B AKERSFIELD HAJJJTAI' CONSERVATION PLAN). J 994. Metropolitan Bakersfield Ha bi.tat Conserva-tion Plan. Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Coaservatiou Plan Steering Committee, Bakersfield, CA
MUNDAY, J. S., and L. J. THOMPSON. 2003. Brodjfacoum toxico-sis in two neonatal puppies. Vet. Pathol. 40:2 16-219.

RALLS, K., and P. J. WHITE. 1995. Predatio11 of San Joaquin ki1 foxes by larger canids. J. Mammal. 76:723-729.

US:FWS (U.S. F1sH AND WtLDLIFE SERVICE). 1998. Recovery plan for upland species of the San Joaquin VaUey, Cali fomia.

U.S. Fish and Wildljfe Service, Region l, Po1iland, OR.

USFWS (U.S. FtSH AND WlLDLIFE SERVICE). 2010. s~m Joaquin kit fox (Vufpes macrotis mutica) 5-year review: Summary and evalua6on. Sacramento Fish and WiJdlife Office, U.S.

Fish and Wildlife Service, Sacramento, CA. 121 pp.

Wt-uTE, P. J., W. H. BERRY, J. J. EuASON, and M. T. HANSON. 2000. Catastrophic decrease in an isolated population ofkii foxes. Southwest. Nat. 45:204-211 .

CSIRO PUBLISHING
Pacific Conservation Biology, 2021, 27, 256-266
https://doi.org/10.1071/PC20059
Urban landscape attributes affect occupancy patterns of the San Joaquin kit fox during an epizootic
Nicole A. Deatherage G A,o , Brian L. Cypher\ James Murdoch 8 , Tory L. Westall\ Erica C. KellyA and David J. Germano 41D c AEndangered Species Recovery Program, California State University, Stanislaus, One University Circle, Turlock, CA 95382, USA.
8Wildlife and Fisheries Biology Program, Rubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA. cDepartment of Biology, California State University, Bakersfield, 9001 Stockdale Highway, Bakersfield, CA 93311, USA (Retired).
0 corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Abstract. The federally endangered and California state threatened San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) persists in relatively high density in the urban environment of Bakersfield, California, USA. Coyotes ( Canis latrans), red foxes (V. vulpes), and gray foxes (Urocyon cinereoargenteus) are natural competitors of San Joaquin kit foxes, and their presence in Bakersfield potentially impacts kit foxes. We used annual camera survey data in 111 randomly selected l-km2 grid cells to investigate the influence oflandscape attributes and the presence of canid competitors on San Joaquin kit fox occupancy from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield. Of 59 candidate models, our results indicated that occupancy patterns of urban kit foxes were driven primarily by a selection for campuses ( e.g. schools, churches, and medical centres), followed by an avoidance of paved roads. Presence of other canids was associated with kit fox presence during surveys but did not have a discernable effect on occupancy, possibly due to a relatively low number of detections. Kit fox occupancy was estimated to have declined by 40% in Bakersfield over the 5-year study, likely due to sarcoptic mange ( canis variety skin mite, Sarcoptes scabiei) disease as evidenced by a 37-49% extinction probability as a result of mange. Despite mange, the San Joaquin kit fox population in Bakersfield is one of the largest remaining populations. Awareness of the selection for campuses and avoidance of paved roads by San Joaquin kit foxes can help to develop effective land management and mitigation policy for kit foxes affected by urban development.

Keywords: fox, Kem County, multi-season occupancy modelling, paved roads, San Joaquin kit, single-species occupancy modelling, urban development, Vulpes macrotis mutica.

Received 30 July 2020, accepted 4 December 2020, published online 12 January 2021 Introduction
The San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) is a federally endangered and California state-threatened canid species in the USA, imperiled primarily due to habitat loss as a result ofhuman development (Cypher 2010). The San Joaquin kit fox is a sub-species of kit fox ( V. macro tis), which ranges throughout flat, semiarid, open desert, shrubland, and grassland habitats in southwestern North America (McGrew 1979). San Joaquin kit foxes (hereafter kit fox) are endemic to the San Joaquin Valley of Central California (Cypher et al. 2001). They select for open saltbush (Atriplex spp.) scrub and use subterranean dens for shelter from climatic conditions and to escape predators such as coyotes (Canis latrans), golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos), and red foxes (v. vulpes; Cypher 2003; Cypher et al. 2001, 2013).

The kit fox population in the city of Bakersfield, California constitutes one of the largest remaining populations of kit foxes, and as such is important to the recovery of this subspecies Journal compilation © CSIRO 2021
(Cypher and Van Horn Job 2012). More recently, the Bakers-field population has dramatically declined due to a sarcoptic mange epizootic caused by a highly contagious skin infestation of the Canis variety of skin mite, Sarcoptes scabiei (Cypher et al. 2001 ; Pence and Ueckermann 2002; Cypher et al. 2017).

The disease has been studied extensively in red foxes in which mortality can occur 3-4 months following infestation (Stone et al. 1972) and due to the similar biology of red foxes and kit foxes it is likely that time-to-mortality is similar for kit foxes, with data indicating the disease is 100% fatal in untreated kit foxes (Cypher 2003; Cypher et al. 2017).

Urbanisation as a result of human development creates new environments dominated by infrastructure ( e.g. buildings and roads) and characterised by an increase in temperature and noise, year-round water, diverse microhabitats, and non-native wildlife (Grimm et al. 2008; Gehrt 2010). Urban landscapes possess hard, linear boundaries, with features such as roads and www.publish.csiro.au/journals/pcb
Urban San Joaquin kit fox occupancy patterns
walls that act as wildlife barriers resulting in fragmentation, isolation, and edge effects on natural habitat (Crooks 2002; Riley et al. 2010). Conversely, urban environments can offer increased resource availability for wildlife including pet food or intentional feeding of wildlife, food refuse, planted fruits and vegetables, permanent water sources, and human-built struc-tures that provide shelter (Harrison 1997; Fuller et al. 2010).

This has led to range expansion into urban areas by opportunistic species that readily adapt to human-modified environments, including kit foxes and other canids (Ditchkoff et al. 2006; Cypher 201 O; Bateman and Fleming 2012; Lombardi et al. 2017).

In Bakersfield, kit foxes are sympatric with three other canids - coyotes, red foxes, and gray foxes ( Urocyon
cinereoargenteus) - with which they share spatial, dietary, and temporal requirements, resulting in the potential for inter-ference competition (Cypher et al. 2001 ; Nelson et al. 2007; Cypher 2010; Soulsbury et al. 2010). Interference competition can lead to predation, harassment, spatial exclusion, or interspe-cific killing of smaller, less dominant fox species by larger, more dominant foxes and coyotes, thereby limiting species distributions or encouraging niche differentiation (Case and Gilpin 1974; Kitchen et al. 1999; Cypher et al. 2001). In some non-urban areas in the San Joaquin Valley, kit foxes make greater use of less optimal habitat with lower food availability due to prominent use of optimal habitat by coyotes, indicating habitat partitioning to reduce competition (Cypher et al. 2001 ; Nelson et al. 2007).

Landscape attributes and relative density of urban develop-ment may have a stronger effect on carnivore spatial dynamics than temporal activity of competitors or human activity (Bateman and Fleming 2012; Moll et al. 2018). Additionally, larger predators are often less tolerated by humans and subjected to higher human-caused mortality than smaller carni-vores. This can create areas where larger predators are absent, thereby providing spatial refuge for smaller species and facili-tating competitor sympatry within the urban landscape (Lesmeister et al. 2015; Moll et al. 2018). Past studies indicate that coyotes need larger, connected open space, and are regu-larly observed in areas within urban environments with more natural habitat (Crooks 2002; Gehrt et al. 2009; Gese et al. 2012). Red foxes avoid coyotes by being better adapted to intermediate human-modified habitats (i.e. suburbs with house densities of <20 houses/ha; Gosselink et al. 2003; Lesmeister et al. 2015). Gray foxes tend to select for urban edges or more natural, tree-covered areas (Riley 2006; Mathewson et al. 2008; Lesmeister et al. 2015). In the Great Basin Desert of western Utah, USA, desert kit foxes (V. m. arsipus) in urban areas foraged and denned near highly developed areas that afforded protection from coyotes (Kozlowski et al. 2008).

Kit foxes in Bakersfield are commonly observed using dens in undeveloped lots, storm water catchment basins and canal banks, industrial areas, commercial areas, landscaping features, and powerline and railroad corridors (Cypher and Van Hom Job 2012). These dens are often earthen but may also be constructed in culverts, pipes, rubble piles, or under infrastructure (Frost 2005; Cypher 2010). Radio collared kit foxes have been found to utilise undeveloped lands and water catchment basins dispro-portionately more than residential areas (Frost 2005); however, it is largely unknown how heterogeneous urban landscape Pacific Conservation Biology 257
features (e.g. water availability, vegetation cover, land use, and building and infrastructure density) and the presence of competitors drives kit fox occupancy patterns in the city.

We investigated whether specific urban landscape attributes, including the presence of a competitor canid species, affect kit fox occupancy patterns in Bakersfield. We used 5 years of camera trap data from an annual city-wide survey conducted from 2015 to 2019 combined with a suite of urban landscape attributes in occupancy modelling. Although assuming kit fox occupancy would decrease over time due to mange, we pre-dicted kit foxes would continuously select for open spaces within the urban environment while avoiding the outer edges of the city where more natural habitat and dominant canid species may occur. Understanding kit fox associations with specific landscape features in the urban environment will help in developing effective management, mitigation, conservation, and recovery strategies for kit foxes in urban areas.

Materials and methods
Study area
The city of Bakersfield is located in Kem County, in the southwestern portion of the San Joaquin Valley (35.37329°N, - 119.01871 °W). The area is generally flat, with elevations roughly between 30 and 183 m above sea level (Stachelski and Sanger 2008). Hot, dry summers, and cool, wet winters char-acterise the desert climate, with average daily maximum tem-peratures ranging from 14°C in December to 37°C in July and average daily minimum temperatures ranging from 4°C in
December to 21 °C in July (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2020). Annual precipitation averages 16.4 cm but varies greatly between years (National Oceanic and Atmo-spheric Administration 2020). Land use is comprised of oil and gas production, grazing, agriculture, natural, conserved, and urban lands (Cypher et al. 2000).

Bakersfield is a heavily urbanised city with a growing
population of 380 000 people (United States Census Bureau 2019). The city is surrounded by natural habitat, including saltbush scrub, grassland, and riparian areas on 25-30% of its boundary with agriculture on the remainder (Cypher 2010).

Bakersfield encompasses a variety of urban land uses including residential areas ( e.g. single family homes, apartment buildings, townhouses, and nursing homes), commercial developments, recreational areas, preserved green spaces, industrial centres, agriculture, and campuses ( e.g. schools, churches, and medical centres). The Kem River runs through the middle of the city though only portions of the river corridor contain water year-round due to water diversion for agricultural purposes (Shigley 2010). Vegetation in the city consists primarily of a mix of planted native and non-native ornamental trees, shrubs, and flowering plants.

Study design
We conducted annual surveys from 2015 to 2019 using
camera traps to monitor sarcoptic mange in the Bakersfield kit fox population, and used these data to investigate kit fox occupancy patterns. We set camera traps in 111 randomly selected 1-km2 grid cells located throughout the 368-km2 city, thus covering approximately 30% of the city. We selected cell 258 Pacific Conservation Biology
size such that each kit fox mean home range of 1. 72 km2 (Frost 2005) potentially included two cells to maximise our ability to detect kit foxes, as they could likely readily access any feature, including camera locations, within cells (Westall and Cypher 2017). We selected camera locations within cells based on amount of human activity, accessibility by personnel, and accessibility for kit foxes. We secured Cuddeback Black Flash E3 or C3 digital trail cameras (Cuddeback, Green Bay, WI, USA) to t-posts, fences, or vegetation at a height or angle appropriate for capturing images of kit foxes and other canid species via motion sensors. We baited camera traps with a punctured can of commercial cat food secured approximately

1.5 m in front of the camera and added several drops of Carman's Canine Call carnivore lure (Minnesota Trapline Products Inc., Pennock, MN, USA) that can be detected up to

1.6 km away by canid species (Westall and Cypher 2017). With a few exceptions due to human disturbance, camera locations remained consistent over the 5-year sampling period. Because

97.1 % of kit foxes are typically detected at camera stations within 6 nights (Westall and Cypher 2017), we ran cameras annually for 1 week in mid-summer, outside of the kit fox breeding and whelping season that might affect activity. We reviewed images captured by the cameras each year and
recorded the number of species detections and if kit foxes appeared to be infested with mange. To test for an association between kit fox and other canid presence, we completed a two-way contingency table and Chi-square test for the total cells and total survey days in which the species occurred across the 5-year sampling period.

We used satellite imagery maps to quantify a suite of urban landscape attributes in all cells to use as covariates in occupancy models. We overlaid cells with a 10 x 10 m point grid in Google Earth Pro, resulting in a total of 100 points/cell. We used imagery dated 26 April 2018 at an eye altitude of 300-m above ground level to characterise grid points and camera locations scaled to 1.0. We characterised each point by the landscape that best described the location of the point (i.e. the land use type on which the majority of the point was located), and recorded ifany portion of the point fell on a mature tree or paved road. If a point appeared to fall equally on two different landscape types, we split the proportion of the point between the attributes (0.5:0.5).

If a point fell on a water body we characterised it as the closest terrestrial landscape and made note of the water source and additionally noted the presence of other stable water sources within cells. Counts approximated percentages of 13 landscape attributes and whether water was present within each cell.

Landscape attributes consisted of paved roads, mature trees, high-density residential areas, low to medium density residen-tial areas, commercial areas, industrial areas, campuses, unde-veloped lots, agriculture, parks and green spaces, median or side of roadways, other open spaces, and the Kem River corridor. We tested pairwise correlations between landscape attributes using Spearman' s Rank tests and adjusted the resulting ?-values using the method proposed by Legendre and Legendre (1998) to
account for the inflated risk of a type I statistical error when running multiple tests. Two-way contingency tables, Chi-squares, and correlation tests were completed in Minitab 19 statistical software and analysed at a = 0.05 for statistical significance.

N. A. Deatherage et al.

Occupancy modelling
We first estimated raw kit fox occupancy as,
A X t/1 = - , s
where i is the estimated probability of kit fox occupancy, x is the estimated number of sites occupied by kit foxes, ands is the number of sites surveyed, i.e. grid cells (MacKenzie et al. 2018).

To account for detection uncertainty, we used single-species dynamic occupancy modelling to produce probability estimates of kit fox occupancy, defined by the equation,
A SD
t/JMLE = (s'* ) , P MLE
where i MLE is the maximum-likelihood estimate for the proba-bility of occupancy of a kit fox, i.e. the value for kit fox occupancy that maximises the likelihood function given the observed data; sD is the number of cells at which a kit fox was detected using survey detection histories (h); and sft:LE is the maximum-likelihood estimate for the probability of detecting a kit fox at least once during a survey (k), given kit foxes were present (MacKenzie et al. 2018). We estimated relationships between kit fox occupancy and landscape attributes, the pres-ence of a stable water source, and the total number of canid competitors detected in cells as covariates, defined by the linear regression equation in the logit function,
i; = exp(f:Jo,+ {J 1~n) ,
1 + exp(/30 + /31xn)
where i; is the estimated probability of kit fox occupancy at cell i; {30 is the estimated intercept term; fJ I is the estimated slope of the effect of covariate 1; and xn is the value of the continuous predictor variable, i.e. the value of covariate 1 at cell i (MacKenzie et al. 2018). We determined estimated probability of kit fox occupancy in subsequent seasons following season 1 in multi-season modelling, defined by the equation,
t/11+1 = t/11(1 - E1) + (1 - t/1,)Yt,
where t/11+1 is the probability of kit fox occupancy in the season following season t; E1 is the extinction probability, i.e. the probability an occupied cell in season t is unoccupied by kit foxes in season t + I; y1 and is the colonisation probability, i.e. the probability that a cell unoccupied in season t is occupied by kit foxes in season t + I (MacKenzie et al. 2018). Cells occupied by kit foxes the following season, t + I, are a combination of cells occupied in the given season, t, where kit foxes did not go locally extinct, t/11(1 - E1) , and cells that are currently unoccu-pied by kit foxes that are colonised before next season, ( 1 - t/11 )y 1 (MacKenzie et al. 2018). We assumed no unmodelled heterogeneity in our data, that occupancy state at each site did not change over surveys within a sampling season, and that target species were never falsely detected (MacKenzie et al. 2018).

We treated each year of the study as individual seasons (T = 5) and each day camera stations were run in cells within seasons as individual surveys (K = 7).

We developed a set of 59 candidate models that included combinations of covariates in cells (Table 1 and see Supple-mentary Material l; MacKenzie et al. 2018). Covariates that Urban San Joaquin kit fox occupancy patterns Pacific Conservation Biology 259 Table I. Covariates used in candidate occupancy models for San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica) from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA
Covariate Description
oc
water
tree
road
HDR
LMDR
com
ind
Total number of other individual canids ( coyote, red fox, gray fox) recorded in cell Presence of a stable water source in cell
Percentage of mature tree cover in cell
Percentage of paved roads in cell
Percentage of cell characterised by high-density residential land use ( single family homes) Percentage of cell characterised by low to medium density residential land use (apartment buildings, nursing homes) Percentage of cell characterised by commercial land use (shopping and service areas, businesses) Percentage of cell characterised by industrial land use (pipe yards, oil fields, factories, junk yards, lots under construction, solar panel lots, large storage lots)
camp
UL
KRC
ag
PGS
MSR
OOS
Percentage of cell characterised by campus land use ( schools, churches, medical centers, and large corporations) Percentage of cell characterised by undeveloped lots
Percentage of cell characterised by the Kem River corridor Percentage of cell characterised by agriculture land use ( row crops and orchards) Percentage of cell characterised by parks and green space land use (golf courses, parks, cemeteries, large lawns) Percentage of cell characterised by roadway median or side of roadway land use Percentage of cell characterised by other open space land use (natural areas, airport runways, canals, water catchment basins, powerlines, dirt roads)
Table 2. Total number of grid cells (no. of cells), survey days (no. of surveys), and cells and surveys with San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica, kit fox) or other canids (includes coyotes, Canis latrans; red foxes, V. vulpes; and gray foxes, Urocyon cinereoargenteus), as well as the number of cells in which San Joaquin kit foxes possessed sarcoptic mange disease (canis variety skin mite, Sarcoptes scabiez) each season (year) from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA
Season (year) No. of No. of No. of cells No. of surveys cells surveys with kit fox with kit fox
I (2015) 105 735 68 226
2 (2016) 111 775 52 180
3 (2017) 109 763 39 133
4 (2018) 110 770 28 89
5 (2019) 110 763 18 62
1-5 (2015-2019) 545 3806 205 690
were correlated based on significant P-values were never included in the same multi-covariate model (Burnham and Anderson 2002; Lesmeister et al. 2015; Lombardi et al. 2017).

We fit models first with no occupancy covariates (null model), followed by each covariate individually, as well as with combi-nations of covariates following four a priori modelling catego-ries representing various degrees of urban development and prominent city characteristics: (1) less development and/or the presence of other canids, (2) heavy development, (3) high density of paved roads, and (4) high density of vegetation and/ or the presence of other canids (see Supplementary Material 1 ).

We included other canids in the first and fourth categories as they are more likely to be occurring in less developed or highly vegetated areas within the urban environment. While we were primarily interested in estimating occupancy probability, the inclusion of mange presence in cells as an extinction covariate allowed us to partly control for the population wide effects of mange across the 5 years of the study (MacKenzie et al. 2018).

We held extinction, colonisation, and detection parameters constant across seasons and survey occasions.

No. cells No. surveys No. cells with No. of surveys with No. cells with other with other kit fox + other kit fox + other with kit canids canids canids canids fox mange
8 14 4 1 9
11 22 4 3 7
8 18 0 0 6
9 20 1 0 5
7 14 3 3 2
43 88 12 7 29
We used Akaike's Information Criterion adjusted for small sample sizes (AI Cc, number of cells surveyed/maximum number of model parameters <40; Burnham and Anderson 2002) and 13 values to rank each model in the set (MacKenzie et al. 2018).

The lower the AI Cc value and the larger the AI Cc weight ( w, the measure of support for the given model being the best model of the data), the better the model explained the data (MacKenzie et al. 2018). We considered models strong descriptors of the data when the LiAICc value between the best fit model and the given model was <2.00, and moderate descriptors of the data when

2.00 :s; liAICc < 4.00 (Burnham and Anderson 2002). All models were run in PRESENCE 2.12.34 (Hines 2006).

Results
We detected kit foxes at 38% of the total cells and during 18% of the total surveys over the 5-year sampling period (Table 2). The number of kit fox detections was highest in season 1 (2015) and consistently declined through season 5 (2019), resulting in a 74% decrease in the number of cells and 73% decrease in number of surveys in which kit foxes were detected (Table 2). 260 Pacific Conservation Biology
Table 3. Number of grid cells characterised by a majority percentage of urban landscape attributes, as well as with > 20% paved roads or mature trees and the presence of a stable water source out of 111 cells from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA
Landscape characterisation
% High-density residential
% Undeveloped lot
% Commercial
% Industrial
% Agricultural
%Campus
% Parks and green space
% Other open space
% Kem River corridor
% Low to medium density residential
% Median or side of roadway
>20% mature trees
>20% paved roads
Stable water source present
Nwnber of cells

73.5 18.5

8.0 5.0

2.0 1.5

1.0 1.0

0.5 0.0

0.0 28.0

33.0 70.0
Similarly, we observed kit foxes with mange in 14% of the total cells in which kit foxes were detected over the 5-year sampling period with the number of cells with mange highest in season 1 and slightly declining through season 5, resulting in a 2% decrease in the number of cells with kit foxes possessing mange (Table 2). Our cameras detected kit foxes in 4.7 times as many cells and 7.8 times as many surveys as other canids combined, with kit foxes occurring with another canid in 6% of total cells and 1 % of total surveys in which kit foxes were detected (Table 2). Kit fox presence was not associated with other canid presence in cells (X2 = 2.182, d.f. = 1, P = 0.140) but was associated with other canid presence on survey days across the 5-year sampling period (X2 = 6.283, d.f. = 1, P = 0.012).

Occupancy modelling
The dominant landscape attribute in most cells was high-density residential (66% of cells; Table 3). Campuses, parks and green spaces, other open spaces, and the Kem River corridor were dominant in ::s l % of cells and low to medium density residential and median or side of the roadway attributes were not dominant in any of the cells (Table 3). Fewer than half of the cells had > 20% paved roads or mature tree cover (30 and 25% of cells, respectively), and more than half had a stable water source ( 63% of cells; Table 3). We found eight positive correlations and 12 negative correlations between landscape attributes (Table 4).

Apart from the best ranking model, six models had strong empirical support with liAICc <2.00, including the null model (Table 5). Roads, campuses, low to medium density residential areas, the presence of water, and parks and green spaces were the covariates represented respectively in the six models (Table 5).

Of the six models, two were additive models, one including both roads and low to medium density residential covariates and one including both water and campuses as covariates, respectively (Table 5). Roads and campuses were the only two covariates to appear in two of the six models (Table 5) with roads the only negative predictor of kit fox occupancy (Table 6). Two addi-tional models were supported with liAICc < 2.00 (see Supple-mentary Material 1) although they were excluded from our N. A. Deatherage et al.

Table 4. Correlated pairwise habitat attributes including Spearman correlation test statistic (t) and Spearman correlation coefficient (r.) values for a total of 111 survey grid cells from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA
Degrees of freedom= 109 and ?(adjusted) <0.001 for each correlation Habitat attribute correlation r.

Tree X HDR 10.064 0.694
RoadxMSR 5.806 0.486
UL xOOS 5.469 0.464
RoadxHDR 5.173 0.444
lndxOOS 4.382 0.387
Tree x PGS 3.965 0.355
LMDRxcamp 3.863 0.347
Tree x road 3.838 0.345
Tree x UL -9.604 --0.677
HDRxUL -7.224 --0.569
HDRxOOS -5.775 --0.484
Tree x ind -5.394 --0.459
HDRx ind -4.818 --0.419
Roadx UL -4.748 --0.414
LMDRxUL -4.625 --0.405
Tree x OOS -4.516 --0.397
HDRxcom -4.449 --0.392
ULxPGS -4.289 --0.380
RoadxOOS -4.029 --0.360
LMDRxOOS -3.600 --0.326
analysis as all had covariate beta 95% confidence intervals that encompassed 0 for one or more occupancy parameters, providing insufficient evidence to conclude an effect on kit fox occupancy (13 range= 0.02 to 0.17, 95% CI range= -0.35 to 0.48).

Four models had moderate empirical support with 2.00 ::s liAICc < 4.00, which included the presence of water, mature trees, and commercial areas as individual covariates and an additive model including low to medium density residential and commercial areas (Table 5). Of the four models, commercial areas were the only negative predictor of kit fox occupancy (Table 6). Twenty-five other models were supported with 2.00 ::s liAICc < 4.00 (see Supplementary Material l) although they were excluded from our analysis as all had covariate beta 95% confidence intervals that encompassed 0 for one or more occupancy parameters (13 range = <---0.01 to 0.32, 95% CI range = ---0.52 to 0.89).

The best ranking model in our set included an additive
combination of paved roads and campuses in cells (Table 5).

Paved roads had a negative effect on kit fox occupancy and campuses had a positive effect, with campuses having a slighter larger effect on occupancy than paved roads (Table 6). Occu-pancy probability increased from 0. 73 with 0% campus to 0.94 with 100% campus while holding roads at 0% (Fig. 1 ). Occu-pancy probability decreased from 0.73 with 0% roads to 0.30 with 100% roads while holding campus at 0% (Fig. 1 ). Across the study area, probability of occupancy was highest near campuses and lowest near large roads when considering the effect of both parameters across the 5-year sampling period (Fig. 2). Mean occupancy probability across cells declined 40% overtime from 0.66 in2015 to 0.26 in 2019 with raw occupancy estimates following a similar pattern and declining by 49% over time from 0.65 in 2015 to 0.16 in 2019 (Fig. 3). The best model Urban San Joaquin kit fox occupancy patterns Pacific Conservation Biology 261 Table S. Model selection results for occupancy modelling of San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica) from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA
The candidate model set includes 59 models and those with strong to moderate empirical support (8A!Cc < 4.00) are shown Model ranking Model name K
lj,(road + camp );y(),s(mange ),p()
2 lj,(road), -y(),s(mange ),p()
3 lj,( camp), -y(),s(mange ),p()
4 lj,(road + LMDR),-y(),s(mange),p()
5 lj,(water + camp),-y(),s(mange),p()
6 lj,(), -y(),s(),p()
7 lj,(PGS),-y(),s(mange),p()
8 lj,( water), -y(),s( mange ),p()
9 'I' (tree), -y(),s( mange ),p()
10 lj,( com),-y(),s(mange ),p()
11 lj,(LMDR + com),-y(),s(mange),p()
predicted a 0.15 colonisation probability (95% CI = 0.11 to

0.20) and a 0.46 detection probability (95% CI = 0.43 to 0.48), meaning over the course of the seven surveys within a season we had a 98. 7% chance of detecting a kit fox.
7 6
6 7
7 4
6 6
6 6
7 Mange presence in kit foxes was a negative predictor of extinction in the 11 supportive models (Table 6). The best model predicted a 0.49 extinction probability (95% CI = 0.40 to 0.57) in sites where mange was not present in kit foxes over the 5-year sampling period and an 0.37 extinction probability (95% CI= 0.24 to 0.50) in sites where mange was present, meaning there was a 12% greater chance ofkit fox extinction at sites that did not already have mange present. The number of other canids was a negative predictor of occupancy in all 18 models fit with other canids as a covariate, although these were excluded from our analysis as all had covariate beta 95% confidence intervals that encompassed 0 (13 range= --0.04 to --0.01, 95% CI range= --0.1 I to 0.07).

Discussion
The high number of kit fox detections relative to those for coy-otes, red foxes, and gray foxes demonstrated that kit foxes may be better adapted to highly developed urban environments. Although they may exhibit preferences, kit foxes are frequently observed using many urban landscape types unlike coyotes, red foxes, and gray foxes. In general, mammals with smaller body sizes are more likely to fare better in urban environments (Crooks 2002) because larger canids may have more limited utilisation of these areas due to greater open space requirements, lower human tolerance, and other factors (Gehrt and Riley 2010; Riley and White 2010; Soulsbury et al. 2010).

With campuses and paved roads the two most important
landscape attributes in our modelling, our results most closely align with our third a priori modelling category, that kit fox occupancy would be affected by urban areas with high densities of paved roads. Campuses may be the most important single landscape attribute for kit fox occupancy. Campuses were a positive predictor of kit fox occupancy which was consistent with our prediction that kit foxes would select for open space areas within the urban environment. Campuses have large landscaped grounds ( e.g. sports fields, courtyards, quadrangles, lawns, and walkways) that offer open space for kit foxes (Cypher and Van Hom Job 2012). Campuses also offer abundant AICc dAICc w -2LogL
2634.38 0.00 0.0698 2619.29
2634.68 0.30 0.0601 2621.87
2634.88 0.50 0.0543 2622.07
2635.44 1.06 0.0411 2620.35
2635.76 1.38 0.0350 2620.67
2635.85 1.47 0.0335 2627.47
2636.19 1.81 0.0282 2623.38
2636.41 2.03 0.0253 2623.60
2636.57 2.19 0.0233 2623.76
2636.86 2.48 0.0202 2624.05
2637.84 3.46 0.0214 2622.75
and inviting denning opportunities for kit foxes underneath large storage containers, modular buildings, sheds, garbage dump-sters, and other man-made structures or debris (Frost 2005).

Additionally, campuses often have food courts, cafeterias, or picnic tables where patrons drop food or feed kit foxes and other animals directly (Cypher 2010), and these spaces support populations of kit fox prey including California ground squirrels ( Otospermophilus beecheyi), valley pocket gophers ( Thomomys bottae), birds, and insects (Cypher 2010). Further, campuses commonly have security measures or fencing which may limit human activity overnight when kit foxes are most active and help to exclude larger terrestrial predators such as coyotes.

It can be assumed that the number of campuses will increase as the human population continues to grow (Chen et al. 2014), which may continue to support urban kit fox populations.

Human-kit fox conflict on campuses include concerns that kit foxes may attack people, leave abundant faecal matter, spread disease or parasites, damage property by digging dens, or have implications for property owners when a protected species resides on their property (Cypher and Van Hom Job 2012); however, actual incidents are rare. Property owners may be more tolerant of foxes residing on campuses given education and outreach efforts that provide information on minimal risks, established protocols to aid landowners with handling fox nuisance issues, and appropriate response actions during a kit fox encounter (Cypher 2010; Cypher and Van Hom Job 2012).

One significant risk to kit foxes associated with school campuses is that they may tangle themselves in sports nets ( e.g. soccer nets, batting cage nets, and tennis nets), leading to stress, exhaustion, or suffocation when trapped in a net for an extended period of time (Cypher and Van Hom Job 2012). To-date, there have been 57 reported occurrences and 22 kit fox fatalities in Bakersfield due to sport net entanglement (B. L. Cypher, unpubl. data). This issue could also be addressed through education and outreach by informing schools of the conse-quences of leaving sports nets out overnight or posting signage reminding personnel to tie nets off the ground when not in use.

Nonetheless, paved roads were also an important negative predictor of kit fox occupancy and as urbanisation increases, the abundance of paved roads will also increase (Bjurlin et al. 2005). An increase in paved roads not only presents risk to kit 262 Pacific Conservation Biology N. A. Deatherage et al.

Table 6. Parameter estimates with 95% confidence intervals for best Table 6. (Continued) ranking occupancy models of San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica) from 2015 to 2019 in Bakersfield, California, USA Model Model and parameters 13 Lower Upper The candidate model set includes 59 models and those with strong to ranking CI CI moderate empirical support (aAICc < 4.00) are shown
E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13
Model Model and parameters 13 Lower Upper E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.84 - 0.17 ranking CI CI p() ---0.18 ---0.23 - 0.12
9 lj,(tree);y(),E(mange),p()
lj,(road + camp);y(),E(mange),p() "' 0.23 ---0.18 0.63
"' 1.01 0.54 1.49 lj,(tree) 0.03 <0.01 0.05
lj,(road) ---0.04 ---0.06 ---0.02 -y - 1.72 - 1.90 - 1.54 lj,(camp) 0.05 0.02 0.08 E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13
-y -1.72 -1.90 -1.54 E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.84 - 0.17
E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13 p() ---0.18 ---0.23 - 0.12
E(mange) ---0.51 ---0.84 ---0.17 IO lj,( com), -y(),E( mange ),p() p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12 "' 0.82 0.55 1.09
2 lj,(road),-y(),E(mange ),p() lj,(road) ---0.02 ---0.03 <-0.01 "' 1.34 0.89 1.78 -y - 1.72 - 1.90 - 1.54
lj,(road) ---0.04 ---0.06 ---0.02 E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13 -y -1.72 -1.90 -1.54 E(mange) ---0.51 ---0.84 ---0.17
E ---0.04 ---0.22 0.13 p() ---0.18 ---0.23 - 0.12
E(mange) ---0.51 ---0.84 ---0.17 11 lj,(LMDR + com),-y(),E(mange ),p() p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12 "' 0.70 0.41 0.98
3 lj,( camp ),-y(),E(mange ),p() lj,(LMDR) 0.04 <0.01 0.09 "' 0.37 0.11 0.63 lj,(com) ---0.02 ---0.03 <-0.01
lj,(camp) 0.05 0.02 0.09 -y -1.72 -1.90 -1.54
-y -1.72 -1.90 -1.54 E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13
E ---0.05 ---0.23 0.12 E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.84 ---0.17 E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.83 ---0.17 p() ---0.18 ---0.23 - 0.12 p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12
4 lj,(road + LMDR),-y(),E(mange),p()
"' 1.23 0.78 1.67 fox survival, but also reduces the amount of suitable kit fox lj,(road) ---0.04 ---0.07 ---0.02 habitat within the urban environment. Roads are inhospitable to lj,(LMDR) 0.05 0.01 0.09 kit foxes and are the main source of mortality in urban areas -y - 1.72 - 1.90 - 1.54 (Bjurlin et al. 2005). Additionally, roads are characterised by E ---0.05 ---0.22 0.13 increased noise pollution, development, disturbance, and human E(mange) ---0.51 ---0.84 ---0.17 activity which likely discourages kit foxes from utilising areas p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12 near paved roads (Bjurlin et al. 2005). In San Diego, California, 5 lj,(water + camp),-y(),E(mange),p() "' 0.07 ---0.30 0.43 USA, gray foxes were similarly found to be negatively associ-lj,(water) 0.51 0.08 0.95 ated with the presence of roads (Markovchick-Nicholls et al. lj,(camp) 0.05 0.02 0.09 2008). A high proportion of paved roads in urban areas that also -y - 1.72 - 1.91 - 1.54 support campuses may benefit from cautionary signage, reduced E ---0.05 ---0.23 0.12 speed limits after sunset, or road crossing structures or corridors E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.83 ---0.17 that support kit fox movements between open space habitat p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12 patches. Kit foxes have been observed using culverts and 6 lj,(),-y(),E(),p() bridges to move under roads, and kit fox specific crossing "' 0.65 0.44 0.86 structures (incorporating open landscaping, fencing to keep -y - 1.73 - 1.91 - 1.54 larger predators out, and denning structures) may benefit kit E ---0. I 9 ---0.34 ---0.04 p() ---0.18 ---0.24 ---0.13 foxes (Frost 2005; Cypher 2010). 7 lj,(PGS), -y(),E(mange ),p() Low to medium density residential areas, a continuous water "' 0.49 0.25 0.73 source, and parks and green spaces were also considerable positive lj,(PGS) 0.06 0.01 0.10 predictors of kit fox occupancy. We considered low to medium -y -1.72 -1.9 -1.54 density residential areas to include apartment building or nursing E ---0.05 ---0.23 0.13 home style living situations and parks and green space to include E(mange) ---0.50 ---0.83 ---0.17 golf courses, cemeteries, large lawns, and other parks. These areas p() ---0.18 ---0.23 ---0.12 keep open, landscaped spaces in the form of yards, recreation 8 lj,( water), -y(),E( mange ),p() areas, and walkways which also provide open space for kit foxes "' 0.32 0.00 0.65 similar to campuses. Kit foxes are adapted to meet their metabolic lj,(water) 0.54 0.11 0.97 -y -1.72 -1.91 -1.54 water needs through their prey and therefore do not need to consume water, although they may drink water if it is readily (Continued) available (Morrell 1972; O'Brien et al. 2010; Hall et al. 2013a).

Urban San Joaquin kit fox occupancy patterns

1.00 0.90

0.80 ~ >, 0.70 (.)
C:
<ti

0. 0.60 ::,
(.)
(.)
0 0.50
0 ~ 0.40
:c
<ti 0.30 .0
e
a..

0.10 Paved roads(%)
Pacific Conservation Biology
25 14
6 Campus(%)
Fig. 1. San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) occupancy probability estimates (I),) as a function of percentages of paved roads and campuses in Bakersfield, California, USA, from 2015 to 2019.

Road
Surveyed cell
Low : 0.27
Fig. 2. Mean San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) occupancy probability (I),) in Bakersfield, California, USA across years from 2015 to 2019. City-wide occupancy probabilities were calculated and interpolated from San Joaquin kit fox detection/non-detection data as a function oflandscape attribute data in 111 randomly selected 1-km2 grid cells located throughout the city. 263
Consuming free water may reduce time and energy kit foxes spend searching for prey, also reducing the likelihood of encounters with competitors or predators, and may compensate for extra water loss by females during lactation due to milk production (Hall et al. 2013b), thereby benefiting kit foxes residing near free water in urban areas.

The least important, albeit still considerable, landscape attributes for kit fox occupancy in our study were mature trees, 264 Pacific Conservation Biology
~ 0.80
{)' 0.70 C
<ti
a. 0.60 :J
(.)
(.)
0 0.50
0 ... ~ 0.40
ii f <ti
..c 0.30 i + e
a.

C 0.20 <ti ... Q)
:i: 0.10
1 (2015) 2 (2016) 3(2017) 4 (2018) 5 (2019)
Season (year)
Fig. 3. Mean San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) occupancy probability ( lj,) across survey sites by season (years 2015 to 2019) in Bakersfield, California, USA. Probability estimates from a model of occupancy as a function of percentages of paved roads and campuses in cells (i.e. adjusted for detection probability, squares with 95% confidence intervals) and raw occupancy calculations (triangles) are included. which were a positive association for kit foxes, and commercial areas, which were a negative association for kit foxes. While mature trees are not a typical landscape feature in natural kit fox habitat, kit foxes are opportunistic foragers and have been observed climbing trees on rare occasions, perhaps to forage for insects (Murdoch et al. 2009). Scattered trees may assist with thermoregulation by shading areas in the summer and insulating areas in the winter or provide concealing protection from predators (Hall et al. 2013b). Conversely, commercial areas such as shopping areas, service centres, and businesses are dense with paved roads, vehicular traffic, and human activity that often extends past nightfall when kit foxes are most active which may discourage kit foxes from commercial areas.

Because mange prevalence in kit foxes remained mostly
consistent over the 5-year study, the drastic decline in kit fox abundance likely reflects the strong negative effect of sarcoptic mange on the urban kit fox population. Mange resulted in high kit fox extinction probabilities at sites, which was at least 22% higher than the kit fox colonisation probability at sites. This confirms that sites are becoming unoccupied by kit foxes at a faster rate than they are becoming occupied. Because mange transmission between foxes may be frequency-dependent as opposed to density-dependent (Devenish-Nelson et al. 2014; Carricondo-Sanchez et al. 2017; Scott et al. 2020), the higher probability of extinction at sites not displaying mange compared with sites confirmed to have mange over the 5-year study may be due to healthy foxes spending more time foraging, interacting with other individuals, or dispersing due to better body condi-tions (Newman et al. 2002; Carricondo-Sanchez et al. 2017).

Increased activity of healthy individuals compared with already sick individuals may increase the likelihood of infection and therefore extinction at a previously healthy site (Devenish-Nelson et al. 2014; Carricondo-Sanchez et al. 2017; Scott et al. 2020). While multi-state occupancy modelling may have been an alternative method to assess the effects of mange on kit fox occupancy, we used a less robust multi-season analysis due to relatively low sample size and mange occurrence compared N. A. Deatherage et al.
with the relatively high number of parameters used in multi-state modelling (MacKenzie et al. 2018).

Current occupancy modelling techniques are not sensitive enough to accurately estimate occupancy probability for extremely small detection rates, as we observed for coyotes, red foxes, and gray foxes (MacKenzie et al. 2018). Addition-ally, effects of species interactions in multi-species modelling cannot be accurately assessed if detection rates differ substan-tially (MacKenzie et al. 2018) as they did in our study.

Although our modelling results suggest that other canid effects on kit fox occupancy were negligible, there was an association between the presence of kit foxes and other canids during surveys. Issues of sample size and other factors that can affect competition not measured in this study ( e.g. prey abundance) create uncertainty about the extent of co-occurrence and impacts on distributions.

In summary, kit foxes are highly urban-compatible species with the ability to use small, moderately developed habitat patches such as campuses while avoiding paved roads. Although kit foxes show preferences for or against certain urban landscape characteristics, none of the covariates used in our analysis produced overwhelming evidence towards kit fox occupancy.

The generalist tendencies of kit foxes may make it difficult to find a covariate or model with great support for kit fox occupancy. Nonetheless, an understanding of local kit fox occupancy dynamics and how they are affected by changes in habitat can lead to effective conservation or management policy when planning urban development mitigation and identifying suitable areas for kit foxes within cities. Informed decisions and planning can facilitate the long-term sustainability of kit fox populations in urban environments and contribute to the recov-ery of this endangered species.

Conflicts of interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements
The Endangered Species Recovery Program (ESRP) of California State University, Stanislaus, provided preliminary data as well as equipment and funding to complete camera surveys for our analysis. ESRP personnel Larry Saslaw and Christine Van Horn Job assisted in data collection and analysis, Dr Carl T. Kloock of California State University, Bakersfield assisted with data analysis and edited drafts ofthis manuscript, and Olga Rodriguez with U.S. Geological Survey assisted with GIS mapping. Further funding for this study was generously provided by the San Joaquin Valley Chapter of The Wildlife Society and the Western Section of The Wildlife Society.

References
Bateman, P. W., and Fleming, P.A. (2012). Big city life: carnivores in urban environments. Journal a/Zoology 287, 1- 23. doi:I0.l l ll/J.1469-7998. 2011.00887.X
Bjurlin, C. D., Cypher, B. L., Wingert, C. M., and Van Hom Job, C. L. (2005). Urban roads and the endangered San Joaquin kit fox. California Department of Transportation, Endangered Species Recovery Program Final Report Contract No. 65A0136, Fresno, CA
Burnham, K. P., and Anderson, D. R. (2002). 'Model selection and multimodal inference: a practical information theoretic', 2nd edn. (Springer-Verlag: New York, NY, USA.)
Carricondo-Sanchez, D., Odden, M., Linnell, J. D. C., and Odden, J. (2017).

The range of the mange: spatiotemporal patterns of sarcoptic mange in Urban San Joaquin kit fox occupancy patterns
red foxes (Vulpes vulpes) as revealed by camera trapping. PLoS ONE 12, e0l 76200. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0176200
Case, T. J., and Gilpin, M. E. (1974). Interference competition and niche theory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 71, 3073-3077. doi: 10.1073/PNAS.71.8.3073 Chen, M ., Zhang, H., Liu, W., and Zhang, W. (2014). The global pattern of urbanization and economic growth: evidence from the last three decades.

PLoS ONE 9, el 03799. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0103799
Crooks, K. R. (2002). Relative sensitivities of mammalian carnivores to habitat fragmentation. Conservation Biology 16, 488- 502. doi:10.1046/ J. l 523-l 739.2002.00386.X
Cypher, B. L. (2003). Foxes. In 'Wild mammals of north America: biology, management, and conservation', 2nd edn. (Eds G. A. Feldhamer, B. C.

Thompson, and J. A. Chapman.) pp. 511- 546. (John Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Cypher, B. L. (2010). Kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis). In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, conflict, and conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher.) pp. 49-57. (Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Cypher, B. L., and Van Hom Job, C. L. (2012). Management and conserva-tion of San Joaquin kit foxes in urban environments. In 'Proceedings of the vertebrate pest conference'. pp. 347-352. (University of California:

Davis, CA, USA.)
Cypher, B. L., Warrick, G. D., Otten, M. R. M., O'Farrell, T. P., Berry, W. H., Harris, C. E. H., Kato, T. T., McCue, P. M., Scrivner, J. H., and Zoellick, B. W. (2000). Population dynamics of San Joaquin kit foxes at the Naval Petroleum Reserves in California. Wildlife Monographs 145, 1-43.

Cypher, B. L., Howard, C. 0 . J., Kelly, P. A., Van Hom Job, C., Warrick, G. D., and Williams, D. F. (2001). Interspecific interactions among wild canids: implications for the conservation of endangered San Joaquin kit foxes. Endangered Species Update 18, 171- 174.

Cypher, B. L., Philips, S. E., and Kelly, P. A. (2013). Quantity and distribution of suitable habitat for endangered San Joaquin kit foxes:
conservation implications. Canid Biology & Conservation 16, 25- 31.

Cypher, B. L., Rudd, J. L., Westall, T. L., Woods, L. W., Stephenson, N., Foley, J. E., Richardson, D., and Clifford, D. L. (2017). Sarcoptic mange in endangered kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica): case histories, diagnoses, and implications for conservation. Journal of Wildlife Dis-eases 53, 46-53. doi:10.7589/2016-05-098 Devenish-Nelson, E. S., Richards, S. A., Harris, S., Soulsbury, C., and Stephens, P. A. (2014). Demonstrating frequency-dependent transmis-sion of sarcoptic mange in red foxes. Biology Letters 10, 20140524. doi:10.1098/RSBL.2014.0524
Ditchkoff, S. S., Saalfeld, S. T., and Gibson, C. J. (2006). Animal behavior in urban ecosystems: modifications due to human-induced stress. Urban Ecosystems 9, 5- 12. doi:10.1007/Sl 1252-006-3262-3
Frost, N. (2005). San Joaquin kit fox home range, habitat use, and move-ments in urban Bakersfield. M.Sc. thesis. Humboldt State University, Arcata, CA, USA.

Fuller, T. K., Destefano, S., and Warren, P. S. (2010). Carnivore behavior and ecology, and relationship to urbanization. In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, conflict, and Conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher.) pp. 18-19. (Johns Hopkins University Press:

Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Gehrt, S. D. (2010). The urban ecosystem. In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, conflict, and conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L.

Cypher.) pp. 6-9. (Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.) Gehrt, S. D., and Riley, S. P. D. (2010). Coyotes (Canis latrans). In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, conflict, and conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P.

D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher.) pp. 79-96. (Johns Hopkins University Press:

Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Gehrt, S. D., Anchor, C., and White, L.A. (2009). Home range and landscape use of coyotes in a metropolitan landscape: conflict or coexistence? Journal o/Mammalogy 90, I 045- 1057. doi: 10.1644/08-MAMM-A-277. l Pacific Conservation Biology 265
Gese, E. M., Morey, P. S., and Gehrt, S. D. (2012). Influence of the urban matrix on space use of coyotes in the Chicago metropolitan area. Japan Ethological Society and Springer 30, 413-425. doi: 10.1007/Sl0164- 012-0339-8
Gosselink, T. E., Deelen, T. R. V., Warner, R. E., and Joselyn, M. G. (2003).

Temporal habitat partitioning and spatial use of coyotes and red foxes in east-central Illinois. Journal of Wildlife Management 67, 90-103. doi: 10.2307 /3803065
Grimm, N. B., Foster, D., Groffman, P., Grove, J. M., Hopkinson, C. S., Nadelhoffer, K. J., Pataki, D. E., and Peters, D. P. (2008). The changing landscape: ecosystem responses to urbanization and pollution across climatic and societal gradients. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environ-ment 6, 264-272. doi:10.1890/070147 Hall, L. K., Larsen, R. T., Knight, R. N., Bunnell, K. D., and McMillan, B. R. (2013a ). Water developments and canids in two North American deserts:
a test of the indirect effect of water hypothesis. PLoS ONE 8, e67800. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0067800
Hall, L. K., Day, C. C., Westover, M. D., Edgel, R. J., Larsen, R. T., Knight, R. N., and McMillan, B. R. (2013b). Vigilance of kit foxes at water sources: a test of competing hypotheses for a solitary carnivore subject to predation. Behavioural Processes 94, 76-82. doi:10.1016/J.BEPROC. 2012.12.007
Harrison, R. L. (1997). A comparison of Gray fox ecology between residential and undeveloped rural landscapes. Journal of Wildlife Man-agement 61, 112- 122. doi:10.2307/3802420 Hines, J.E. (2006). PRESENCE - Software to estimate patch occupancy and related parameters. Available at https://www.mbrpwrc.usgs.gov/soft-ware/presence.html [ accessed 1 September 2019].

Kitchen, A. M., Gese, E. M., and Schauster, E. R. (1999). Resource partitioning between coyotes and swift foxes: space, time, and diet.

Canadian Journal of Zoology 77, 1645- 1656.doi:10.1139/Z99-143 Kozlowski, A. J., Gese, E. M., and Arjo, W. M. (2008). Niche overlap and resource partitioning between sympatric kit foxes and coyotes in the Great Basin Desert of western Utah. American Midland Naturalist 160, 191- 208. doi: 1 0. l 674/0003-0031(2008)160[191 :NOARPB]2.0.CO;2 Legendre, P., and Legendre, L. (1998). 'Numerical ecology', 2nd edn. (Elsevier Science B. V.: Amsterdam, Netherlands.)
Lesmeister, D. B., Nielsen, C. K., Schauber, E. M., and Hellgren, E. C. (2015). Spatial and temporal structure of a mesocarnivore guild in midwestem North America. Wildlife Monographs 191, 1--61. doi:10.1002/WMON.1015
Lombardi, J. V., Comer, C. E., Scognamillo, D. G., and Conway, W. C. (2017).

Coyote, fox, and bobcat response to anthropogenic and natural landscape features in a small urban area. Urban Ecosystems 20, 1239-1248. doi: 10.1007/Sl 1252-017-0676-Z
MacKenzie, D. I., Nichols, J. D., Royle, J. A., Pollock, K. H., Bailey, L. L., and Hines, J.E. (2018). 'Occupancy estimation and modeling, inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence', 2nd edn. (Academic Press: San Diego, CA, USA.)
Markovchick-Nicholls, L., Regan, H. M., Deutschman, D. H., Widyanata, A., Martin, 8., Noreke, L., and Ann Hunt, T. (2008). Relationships between human disturbance and wildlife land use in urban habitat fragments. Conservation Biology 22, 99-109. doi: IO.J ll l/J.1523- 1739.2007.00846.X
Mathewson, P. D., Spehar, S. N., and Cooper, D. S. (2008). An initial carnivore survey of Griffith Park, Los Angeles, California. Bulletin of the Southern California Academy of Sciences 107, 57--67. doi: I 0.3160/ 0038-3872(2008)107[57:AICSOG]2.0.CO;2
McGrew, J. C. (1979). Vulpes macrotis. Mammalian Species 123, 1--6. doi:10.2307/3504038
Moll, R. J., Cepek, J. D., Lorch, P. D., Dennis, P. M., Robison, T., Millspaugh, J. J., and Montgomery, R. A. (2018). Humans and urban development mediate the sympatry of competing carnivores. Urban Ecosystems 21, 765- 778. doi:10.1007/Sl 1252-018-0758-6 266 Pacific Conservation Biology
Morrell, S. (1972). Life history of the San Joaquin kit fox. California Fish Game 58, 162-174.

Murdoch, J. D., Ralls, K., and Cypher, B. L. (2009). Two observations of tree climbing by the San Joaquin kit fox. The Southwestern Naturalist 49, 522-523. doi: IO. l 894/0038-4909(2004)049<0522:TOOTCB>2.0.

CO;2
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. (2020). Bakersfield climate. Available at https://www.weather.gov/hnx/bflmain [accessed 28 June 2020].

Nelson, J. L., Cypher, B. L., Bjurlin, C. D., and Creel, S. (2007). Effects of habitat on competition between kit foxes and coyotes. Journal of Wildlife Management 71, 1467-1475. doi: 10.2193/2006-234
Newman, T. J., Baker, P. J., and Harris, S. (2002). Nutritional condition and survival ofred foxes with sarcoptic mange. Canadian Journal ofZoology 80, 154-161. doi:10.1139/Z0l-216
O'Brien, C. S., Waddell, R. B., Rosenstock, S. S., and Rabe, M. J. (2006).

Wildlife use of water catchments in southwestern Arizona. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34, 582-591. doi: 10.2193/0091-7648(2006)34[582:WUOWCI)

2.0.CO;2
Pence, D. B., and Ueckermann, E. (2002). Sarcoptic mange in wildlife.

Scientific and Technical Review of the Office International des Epizoo-ties 21, 385-398. doi: 10.20506/RST.2 l .2.1335 Riley, S. P. D. (2006). Spatial ecology of bobcats and gray foxes in urban and rural zones of a national park. Journal of Wildlife Management 70, 1425-1435. doi: 10.2193/0022-541X(2006)70[1425:SEOBAG]2.0.CO;2 Riley, S. P. D., and White, P. A. (2010). Gray foxes (Urocyon cinereoargenteus) in urban areas. In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, con-flict, and conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L.

N. A. Deatherage et al.

Cypher.) pp. 197-198. (The Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Riley, S. P. D., Gehrt, S. D., and Cypher, B. L. (2010). Urban carnivores, final perspectives and future directions. In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, con-flict, conservation'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher.) pp. 223-232. (Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.) Scott, D. M., Baker, R., Tomlinson, A., Berg, M. J., Charman, N., and Tolhurst, B. A. (2020). Spatial distributionofsarcoptic mange (Sarcoptes scabiei) in urban foxes (Vulpes vulpes) in Great Britain as determined by citizen science. Urban Ecosystems 23, 1127- 1140. doi:10.1007/Sl 1252- 020-00985-5
Shigley, P. (20 I 0). Bakersfield hopes to restore water to Kern River.

Planning; Chicago 76, 8.

Soulsbury, C. D., Baker, P. J., Iossa, G., and Harris, S. (2010). Red foxes (Vulpes vulpes). In 'Urban carnivores, ecology, conflict, and conserva-tion'. (Eds S. D. Gehrt, S. P. D. Riley, and B. L. Cypher.) pp. 63- 75. (Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.)
Stachelski, C., and Sanger, G. (2008). The climate ofBakersfield, California.

NOAA Technical Memorandum NWS WR-281.

Stone, W. B., Parks, E., Weber, B. L., and Parks, F. J. (1972). Experimental transfer of Sarcoptic mange from red foxes and wild canids to captive wildlife and domestic animals. New York Fish and Game Journa/19, 1-11.

United States Census Bureau. (2019). Bakersfield City, California. Avail-able at https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/bakersfieldcityca-lifornia# [accessed I July 2020].

Westall, T. L., and Cypher, B. L. (2017). Latency to first detection of kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis) during camera surveys. Canid Biology and Conservation 20, 32- 37.
www.publish.csiro.au/journals/pcb

SAN JOAQUIN KIT FOX HOME RANGE, HABITAT USE,

AND MOVEMENTS IN URBAN BAKERSFIELD
by
Nancy Frost
A Thesis
Presented to
The Faculty of Humboldt State University
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Master of Science
In Natural Resources: Wildlife
December 2005
iii

ABSTRACT
San Joaquin kit fox home range, habitat use, and movements in urban Bakersfield Nancy Frost
Habitat destruction and fragmentation has led to the decline of the federally endangered and state threatened San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica). Kit foxes in the San Joaquin Valley occur in and adjacent to several urban areas. The urban kit fox population in Bakersfield has the potential to contribute to recovery efforts, however, little is known about habitat use in the urban environment. Habitat use in the urban landscape was examined in 28 radiocollared adult kit foxes between 1 May 1997 and 15 January 1998.

The area of the urban environment needed to meet kit foxes’ ecological requirements varied among the sexes and fluctuated throughout the year. Mean home range size was 1.72 km2 (100% minimum convex polygon estimate) and mean concentrated use area (core area; 50% fixed kernel estimate) size was 0.16 km2. Females had a greater median number of core areas than did males, but core area size did not differ between the sexes. Mean home range size was significantly larger during the dispersal season than during the pair formation and breeding seasons. Home range size was greater for males than females during the breeding season.

To assess the extent to which kit foxes were concentrated around limited resources, the percentage of overlap between adjacent kit foxes’ home ranges and core areas was determined.

Mean home range overlap was greater than 71% for family group members and less than 16% for unrelated individuals, which was less than that reported for the nearby rural population. Overlap of adjacent kit foxes’ core areas indicated that kit foxes were concentrated around key urban habitat patches. Core area overlap was greater for members of the same family group than core area overlap of neighboring males and females or neighboring males. iv
To determine which attributes of the urban environment were used by kit foxes and may support the population over time, habitats used disproportionately were compared to what was available in home ranges and the urban landscape. Kit foxes used open and sump (water catchment basins) habitats more than their availability in both the home range area and study area. There was more open and sump habitat in home ranges than in the study area. Kit fox core areas contained a disproportionately high amount of sumps that had food and den sites and restricted public access.

Sump and open habitats were more suitable for denning and consequently, were used more than their availability in the study area. Kit foxes primarily used subterranean dens but also used pipes and other man-made structures. Dens were located farther from roads than expected and in habitat patches that were larger than the median habitat patch in the study area.

To identify which urban habitats kit foxes used for resting, foraging, and traveling, kit fox movements and travel paths through adjacent habitat patches were examined. Kit foxes moved an average speed of 1.33 km/h. Minimum speed for females was greatest from approximately 0330 - 0730 h and for males was greatest from approximately 1830 - 2230 h. Kit foxes used sump and open habitats for resting. Kit foxes also foraged in these habitats, as well as in transition and commercial habitats. Habitats used for traveling included manicured open and open habitats, in which total distance traveled per movement session was longest. Overall median speed was greatest in residential habitat. Kit foxes were observed crossing roads and using culverts and bridges to move under roads.

Demographic characteristics and weights of the kit foxes that were captured were used to assess habitat quality. Two of the 28 radiocollared kit foxes died during 6,036 days of active radiotransmitters. Radiocollared kit foxes had 15 litters, comprised of 2.8 + 0.45 (range = 1 – 7) pups. Urban kit fox weight was similar to that for rural kit foxes. -
v
The availability of sump and open habitats appeared to shape the distribution and abundance of the urban population. Therefore, retaining sump and open habitats throughout Bakersfield may promote the continued existence of the urban kit fox population. vi

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank all those who contributed to the successful completion of this research project, especially my advisor, Dr. R. T. Golightly, for sharing with me both his advice and expertise. In addition, I thank my other committee members, Drs. T. L. George and D. W.

Kitchen for their support and constructive comments that greatly improved the quality of this thesis. My thanks go out to my professors and fellow students at Humboldt State University who contributed greatly to my educational growth. I would like to thank the San Joaquin chapter of The Wildlife Society for the research grant and the Eureka Rotary Club and the Stockton Sportsmen's Club for scholarships.

I would like to thank the California Department of Fish and Game, especially M. Potter and R. Reed, for assisting with this project by providing a vehicle and hiring three scientific aids, T. Chilton, J. Storlie, and R. Siebdrath, whose hard work, dedication, and willingness to learn contributed immensely to this project. I appreciate the volunteer efforts of M. Otten, G. Warrick, B. Vanherweg, B. Cypher, J. Hinshaw, and K. Brown. I thank the Department of Energy, Chevron USA, and Enterprise Advisory Services, Inc., especially J. Killen and B. Cypher, for the loan of telemetry equipment, radio collars, kit fox handling equipment, and traps. I would also like to thank P. Hoffman from the City of Bakersfield Water Resources Department and A. Abe from the City of Bakersfield Recreation and Parks Department for arranging access to city sumps and parks, respectively. Furthermore, I wish to thank J. Tobar, with the City of Bakersfield's Management Information Services Department, for the City of Bakerfield geographic information system coverages. I thank Dr. C. Hammans of the Coffee Road Animal Hospital and D. Kroger from the California Living Museum for their generous participation in the successful rehabilitation of an injured kit fox pup. I wish to acknowledge the Bakersfield SPCA for vii
"rescuing" one of my study animals that made its way to the third story of a parking garage and could not find the exit. My thanks go to A. Sullivan, J. Redmond, and M. Cantrell of the Sundale golf course, D. E. Keith Trucking, and K. S. Fabrication for allowing access to their property for implementation of the study. I wish to acknowledge Kelly Pipe Company for their cooperative efforts in helping me retrieve a kit fox pup that went for an unexpected "ride" in one of their pipes that was delivered from Bakersfield to Santa Fe Springs, California.

Special thanks go to my husband, S. Telthorst, for his tremendous support, encouragement, and participation in this research project. Finally, I dedicate this thesis to S.

Telthorst and my late mother, S. Castle, whose support and lifelong example of patience, perseverance, and persistence imparted me with the skills necessary to pursue and fulfill my dreams.

The United States Fish and Wildlife Service, California Department of Fish and Game, California Department of Transportation, and Humboldt State University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (protocol #96/97.W.62) issued the necessary permits and memorandum of understanding for this project.
viii

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ABSTRACT .........................................................................................................................iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS....................................................................................................vi LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................................x LIST OF FIGURES ...............................................................................................................xi LIST OF APPENDICES .......................................................................................................xii INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................1 STUDY AREA ......................................................................................................................5 METHODS............................................................................................................................9 Trapping ....................................................................................................................9 Locations...................................................................................................................9 Home Range ............................................................................................................12 Habitat Use ..............................................................................................................15 Movements ..............................................................................................................17 Demographics..........................................................................................................19 RESULTS............................................................................................................................21 Trapping ..................................................................................................................21 Locations.................................................................................................................21 Home Range ............................................................................................................21 Habitat Use ..............................................................................................................23 Movements ..............................................................................................................30 Demographics..........................................................................................................42 ix

TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONTINUED)
DISCUSSION......................................................................................................................43 Demographics..........................................................................................................43 Locations.................................................................................................................45 Home range..............................................................................................................46 Habitat use ...............................................................................................................50 Movements ..............................................................................................................53 MANAGEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS...........................................................................57 REFERENCES.....................................................................................................................59 x

LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
1 Habitat types and their descriptions used to typify the urban setting and kit fox habitat use in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. ....................... 7 2 Home range (100% minimum convex polygon) and core area (50% fixed kernel) size for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. .........................................................................................................24 3 Seasonal home range (100% minimum convex polygon) size for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. ..............................25 4 Ranked radiocollared kit fox habitat use based on habitat availability at the study area and home range area scale, in Bakersfield, California between May 1997 to January 1998. Habitat types used similarly (p > 0.05) are grouped by column............28 5 Mean difference between the mean proportion of habitat available in the study area and kit fox home ranges (e.g., there was 16.7% less open habitat in the study area than within home ranges), and kit fox home ranges and core areas in Bakersfield, California between May 1997 to January 1998.......................................29 6 Influence of sex, movement session time, and their interaction on minimum, maximum, and mean speed and total adjusted distance moved for 10 radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. .....................................................................................................................36 7 Movement session time, type of movement, and habitat associations for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998. .........................................................................................................39 8 Rural kit fox and swift fox cause-specific mortality rates reported within their geographic range for comparison to that for urban kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998...............................................................44 9 Kit fox home range size reported within various habitats within their geographic range for comparison to home range size of urban kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998...............................................................47 xi

LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1 The study area in Bakersfield, Kern County, California for investigations of kit fox habitat use from May 1997 to January 1998......................................................... 6 2 Behavior exhibited by directly observed kit foxes at independent daily locations (n = 2,087) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.......................22 3 Percentage of home range overlap and core area overlap for pairs of radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE. .............................................................................................26 4 Mean percentage of each habitat type in the study area, which bounded the available habitat, and radiocollared kit fox home ranges (n = 27) and core areas (n = 58) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Different letters above the bars indicate a significant difference in habitat use versus availability. ............................................................................................................27 5 Mean number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, and people in the same habitat patch as radiocollared kit foxes at all daily locations (n = 4,824) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE....................................................................................................................31 6 Number of dens used by radiocollared kit foxes in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998............................................32 7 Percentage of available habitat in the study area compared to percentage of habitat used by radiocollared kit foxes for denning in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. .............................................................................33 8 Minimum speed per movement session for male and female radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998. .....................35 9 Mean distance radiocollared kit foxes traveled in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE.......37 10 Mean speed radiocollared kit foxes traveled in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE.......38 xii

LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix Page
A Sites of live-captured kit foxes, domestic cats, and opossums between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California..............................................................69 B Kit fox location data and estimates for home range size, core area size, and time to independence for 28 radiocollared kit foxes that were monitored between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California. ....................................................70 C Weight, hind foot, and ear measurements for captured adult, subadult, and pup kit foxes in Bakersfield, California between May 1997 and January 1998...................73 D Area-observation curves using the 100% minimum convex polygon home range for 27 kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.................74 E The percentage of all radiocollared kit fox daily locations (n = 4,824) and passing vehicles documented in linear habitats during each hour in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998......................................................75 1 INTRODUCTION
The kit fox (Vulpes macrotis) is the smallest North American member of the family Canidae, with an average weight of 2.1 kg for adult females and 2.3 kg for adult males in California (Morrell 1972). Kit foxes range throughout the western United States in shortgrass prairies and other arid areas (Whitaker 1998). The San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica; hereafter kit fox) was described by C. H. Merriam in 1902 (McGrew 1979) and is the largest California subspecies in skeletal measurements, body size, and weight (Grinnell et al. 1937). Kit foxes inhabit arid habitats with flat to sloping terrain (Morrell 1971).

The kit fox historically ranged in the San Joaquin Valley of California, north of Tracy, west to San Joaquin County, east to La Grange, Stanislaus County, and south to Kern County (Grinnell et al. 1937, Morrell 1975). In the early 1900’s, the kit fox population started to decline (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1983), and by 1930, its range had been reduced by more than half, with the largest portion remaining in the southern and western parts of the San Joaquin Valley (Grinnell et al. 1937). In 1969, the kit fox was known to range from Los Banos, Merced County, east to White River, Tulare County, south to Kern County, and west to San Luis Obispo County (Morrell 1975). Currently, the largest remaining populations of kit foxes occur in western Kern County and in the Carrizo Plain Natural Area, San Luis Obispo County (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998).

In 1967, the San Joaquin kit fox was listed as a federally endangered subspecies (United States Department of the Interior 1967), and in 1971, it was designated a State threatened species (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998). The destruction and fragmentation of its native habitat has been a limiting factor that has led to the decline of the kit fox population (Knapp 1978, Spiegel 1996, United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998). This habitat fragmentation 2 has been due mainly to agriculture, urban development, and oil production (Morrell 1975, Spiegel 1996, United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998). In 1993, the San Joaquin Valley Biological Technical Committee estimated that only about 1 - 5% of the original habitat of the kit fox remained.

Kit foxes in the San Joaquin Valley occur in and adjacent to several urban areas including the cities of Taft (Zoellick et al. 2002), Tulare, Visalia, and Porterville (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998), and Bakersfield, where kit foxes have been observed throughout the city (Morrell 1975, Murphy 1992, Cypher and Warrick 1993, Bjurlin and Cypher 2003). Kit foxes are known to use the Kern River Parkway in Bakersfield (Murphy 1992, Beedy et al. 1992) for denning, foraging, and traveling, despite the fact that it is bounded on the north and south by urban and industrial development and receives intensive public recreation use (Beedy et al. 1992).

Additionally, urban kit foxes have been found to den close to human activities and structures (Murphy 1992), including water sumps (catchment basins) in and adjacent to urban development in Bakersfield (Stafford and Murphy 1992).

Urban habitats may be marginal for kit foxes, because the urban environment has a high level of disturbance and consists of a patchy mosaic of habitats (Morrell 1975). While urban developments negatively impact kit fox habitat, kit foxes may still survive in or near them if there are adequate den sites and prey base (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998). Positive attributes of urban habitats may include a constant source of water from sumps, canals, and lawn sprinklers (Murphy 1992) that could lead to a more stable prey population. While fewer natural predators, such as coyotes (Canis latrans) and bobcats (Lynx rufus), are found in the urban environment, domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) occur in greater abundance. Food may be available on a more consistent basis due to the presence of refuse, which constitutes part of the kit fox diet in Bakersfield (Murphy 1992, Cypher and Warrick 1993). Such use of human-derived foods suggests that kit foxes may be able to adapt to the urban setting. 3 Smaller canid species, such as coyotes and foxes, often do well in human-altered environments because they scavenge and forage individually on a variety of small food items and are able to utilize new food sources (Kleiman and Brady 1978). If kit foxes are adaptable enough to persist in urban environments, as are coyotes (Quinn 1995, Romsos 1998, Grinder and Krausman 2001) and red foxes (Vulpes vulpes; Harris 1977, Kolb 1984, 1986, Harris and Rayner 1986, Doncaster et al. 1990, Lewis et al. 1993, Sallee 1998, Kamler and Ballard 2002), the urban kit fox population could contribute to recovery efforts (Cypher and Warrick 1993). Urban kit fox populations could protect against extirpations in rural areas, and serve as a source of animals for reintroduction efforts (Cypher and Frost 1999). Favorable habitat features in urban areas also could serve as linkages or corridors between natural lands, which may minimize local extinction and genetic isolation of fox populations in fragmented habitats (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998, Wandeler et al. 2003).

It is important to understand how kit foxes use landscapes in all areas where they exist, including urban settings. Unfortunately, little is known about the urban kit fox population.

Morrell (1975) noted that a study should be conducted to gain a better understanding of kit fox ecology in areas other than natural habitat. As part of the recovery strategy in the San Joaquin Valley Multispecies Recovery Plan (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998), it was recommended that better demographic information be collected for kit foxes living in residential and industrial areas. The San Joaquin Valley Biological Technical Committee (1993) expressed concern that urbanization threatens the remaining kit fox habitat and listed several kit fox research needs including further studies of mortality rates and causes, diet, distribution, home range requirements, and movements. Due to the continual loss of natural habitat, more information on urban kit fox space use, movements, survival, and reproduction may contribute to their recovery (Cypher and Warrick 1993).
4 Canid home range size is influenced primarily by food abundance, and also food distribution and availability of adequate denning sites (Kleiman and Brady 1978). In order to understand the ecological factors that facilitate habitat use, it is important to identify the areas of concentrated use (hereafter core areas) within the home range (Samuel et al. 1985). Optimal habitat conditions for a species may be identified by evaluating if and how core areas are used disproportionately (Ables 1969). Core areas likely have dependable food sources and rest sites (Samuel et al. 1985) such as dens, the availability of which limits the presence of kit foxes (Golightly 1981, Spiegel et al. 1996). If kit foxes are concentrated around limited resources, the home ranges and core areas of adjacent kit foxes may have substantial overlap (Golightly 1981).

If sufficient food and den sites are available, mortality is minimal, and reproduction occurs at reasonable rates, then urban habitat should support viable kit fox populations. The goal of my project was to determine which attributes of the urban environment were successfully used by kit foxes and may support the population over time. To identify the attributes of the urban environment that kit foxes used most, areas and habitats used disproportionately were compared to what was available in the urban landscape. The quantity and type of urban habitat needed to meet the ecological requirements of urban kit foxes (i.e., that used for denning, foraging, and traveling) was identified. To understand habitat use, kit fox home range size, core area size, spatial distribution of kit foxes in the urban landscape, habitat and den use, and movements were evaluated in relation to habitat type, time of night, and human activity. Assessment of habitat quality should be based on the survival, reproduction, and density of the species occupying the habitat (Van Horne 1983). Therefore, I also reported the demographic characteristics of captured urban kit foxes.
5 STUDY AREA
The study was conducted within the city limits of Bakersfield (Figure 1), at the southern end of the San Joaquin Valley, California. The average elevation of Bakersfield was 124 m (United States Geological Survey 1981) and in 1997, had a human population of 221,700 (State of California, Department of Finance 2002).

Bakersfield has an arid climate with an average annual precipitation of 14.5 cm (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1997) that occurs mainly between October and April.

Total precipitation during the study was 10.9 cm, 3.0 cm higher than normal (Meadows Field Weather Station; National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1997, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1998). Summers are hot and dry, while winters are cool and moist.

During the study, average temperatures ranged from 7.9 C in December to 27.2 C in July and annual mean temperature was 19.6 C, which was -14.3 C lower than normal (Meadows Field Weather Station; National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1997, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1998).

Vegetation in the study area varied by land use and was composed mostly of introduced and exotic species. Manicured open, commercial, and residential habitats were planted mainly with non-native grasses and shrubs (Table 1). Conversely, open, industrial, and some linear habitats, such as the Kern River Parkway, had a mix of introduced and endemic grasses, forbs, and shrubs. Sumps were primarily barren on the sides, often contained standing water, and had scattered native and non-native vegetation near the upper edges. In addition, sumps were distributed throughout the city, fenced, and closed to the public. Sumps had sloping sides and ranged from 0.01 to 0.03 km2 in area.
0 0
0 0
C a
S t o c kd a l e H i gh w a y
I n te r s ta te 5 F r e e w a y
H igh w a y 178
F r e e w a y 9 9
G o s f o r d R o a d
F ree w a y 58

S T UDY A R E A
B a k e rsfi e l d
K e rn R iv e r
3 0
N
Figure 1. The study area in Bakersfield, Kern County, California for investigations of kit fox habitat use from May 1997 to 7 Table 1. Habitat types and their descriptions used to typify the urban setting and kit fox habitat use in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Habitat type Description
Commercial Office buildings, hotels, medical facilities, and their associated parking areas.

Transition Areas in which residential, commercial, or industrial construction is in progress or has recently been completed.

Industrial Areas of industrial use not generally open to the public, such as manufacturing plants and shipping yards.

Linear Kern River Parkway, canals, roads, railroads, and highway and power line right-of-ways.

Manicured Open Parks, schools, and golf courses.

Open Vacant lots and fallow agricultural fields.

Residential Apartments and single-family housing developments.

Sumps Water catchment basins used to contain urban run-off and rainwater. 8 Kit fox predators, including bobcat, coyote, and domestic dog (Cypher et al. 2000), were observed at the study site. Bobcats and coyotes were only observed in the Kern River Parkway (personal observation). California ground squirrel (Spermophilus beecheyi), Botta's pocket gopher (Thomomys bottae), and desert cottontail (Sylvilagus audubonii) (all urban kit fox prey; Cypher and Warrick 1993), were observed at the study site. Domestic cats (Felis catus) and opossums (Didelphis virginiana), which utilize some of the same food resources as urban kit foxes and red foxes, were observed in the study area (Catling 1988, Golightly et al. 1994, Read and Bowen 2001) (Appendix A).
9 METHODS
Trapping
Between 3 May and 18 July 1997, wire-mesh live-traps (38 x 38 x 107 cm; Model 208, Tomahawk Live Trap Company, Tomahawk, WI) were set in sumps, parks, the Kern River Parkway, and privately-owned land in Bakersfield. Traps were covered with canvas tarps to protect captured animals from sun and inclement weather, and baited with canned mackerel.

Trapping frequency and trap placement was opportunistic. The trapping was limited to areas in southwest Bakersfield where kit foxes or their sign (i.e., tracks, scat, and dens) were observed.

Captured kit foxes were transferred from traps to heavy cloth bags for handling. Each animal was sexed, eartagged, weighed (+ 3%), measured (+ 1 mm; right ear and hind foot length), and released at the capture location. Uniquely-numbered metal eartags (Model 1005-4, National Band and Tag Company, Newport, KY) were affixed to the right ear for females and left ear for males. Kit foxes were aged based tooth eruption and wear (Harris 1978). Individuals with partially erupted teeth were classified as juvenile, and those with permanent teeth were classified as adults. Young of the year were classified as puppies until 14 July, and subadults from 15 July to 30 November, after which they were considered to be adults.

Locations
I attached 50-g collar-mounted radiotransmitters (Model 80, Telonics, Mesa, AZ) to captured adults. Radiocollars were equipped with mortality sensors that pulsed approximately twice the normal rate if there was no movement for four hours. Between 14 December 1997 and 15 January 1998, all but four study animals were captured and had their radiocollars removed. 10 Radiocollared kit foxes were located using portable receivers (Model TR-4, Telonics, Mesa, AZ), an omni-directional antenna affixed to a car, and a hand-held 2-element yagi antenna.

Kit foxes were located between 1630 and 0900 h because they were primarily active at night (Egoscue 1956, Golightly 1981, White et al. 2000). At the onset of the study in May 1997, nine study animals were randomly monitored to verify that they were not active during daylight hours.

With the exception of delineating the study area, only locations obtained between one hour before sunset and one hour after sunrise were used in analyses. Each kit fox was systematically located approximately once per night (hereafter referred to as daily locations) but rotated in the schedule each night. Although sampling effort for each study animal was equal at study end, every kit fox could not be found during each sampling period. When a kit fox could not be found, the area where it was previously located was searched for at least 30 min and then, if not located, it was searched for elsewhere in the study area concurrent with searches for other kit foxes.

The transmitted signal was followed until the kit fox was observed (sometimes with the aid of a flashlight) or tracked to a den, or the habitat patch from which the signal was emitted was encircled (White and Garrott 1990). This technique ensured that the location of and habitat used by each kit fox was classified without error (Samuel and Kenow 1992). I tried to stay at least 100 m from the study animals, so as to not alter their behavior (i.e., cause them to move from one habitat patch to another). To assess if this technique created a sampling bias by altering their behavior, each animal was classified as resting/walking, trotting, or running at the time of observation. When this technique was not feasible (e.g., the habitat patch was not accessible), kit fox locations were determined with triangulation, based on three bearings taken as close as possible (< 300 m) from the loudest signal source (Springer 1979). Immediately after a kit fox was located, the observer plotted the location on a 1996 City of Bakersfield street map (scale 1:29,000, Compass Maps, Inc., Modesto, CA) and recorded the number of people that were visible (i.e., not in buildings or large habitat patches) in the same habitat patch as the kit fox. -
11 Mapped kit fox locations were digitized into a geographic information system (GIS; ArcView 3.2 with Spatial Analyst 2.0, ESRI, Redlands, CA), and displayed over the City of Bakersfield's 1997 GIS file titled “Land Status Land Condition Land-use,” as a background for guidance during digitizing. This GIS file was developed through the input of bearing and distance measurements (taken by land surveyors) to define parcel boundaries (i.e., the coordinate geometry method; Amos, R. 2005. Personal communication. City of Bakersfield, GIS Department, 1501 Truxtun Avenue, Bakersfield, CA 93301). Using methods in Romsos (1998), I characterized the urban landscape and described urban kit fox habitat use by collapsing similar urban landscapes into eight categories (Table 1).

To verify the accuracy of the habitat types and boundaries depicted in the GIS, maps generated from the GIS were compared to the actual location of habitat patches throughout the study area. When habitat was not correctly represented in the GIS, a global positioning system (GPS Pathfinder Pro XR, Trimble, Sunnyvale, CA) was used to obtain the geographic coordinates of the edges of each habitat patch. These coordinate data were differentially corrected using the GPS Pathfinder Office program to improve accuracy to within + 1 m, imported into the GIS, and used to digitize polygons representing the correct habitat patches.

The accuracy of the habitat types and boundaries depicted in the GIS was further verified by comparison to aerial photographs (Farm Services Agency, USDA, Bakersfield, CA) of the study area that were photographed in June 1997, at the beginning of the study, and in June 1998, after the study concluded. This comparison was done primarily to identify habitats that were classified as open in 1997 but were in transition or residential in 1998. In these instances, the date each house was built was determined by consulting Kern County public records data. Any habitat patch that was open in the June 1997 aerial photograph, on which a house was built prior to the end of the study, was classified as transition habitat. -
12 Home Range
Home range estimates were obtained using the GIS to generate the 100% minimum convex polygon, which defined the bounds of the area used (Mohr 1947, Hooge and Eichenlaub 1997). Use of kernel-based estimators may be important to identify disjunct areas of activity in urban landscapes where habitat may be fragmented (Grinder and Krausman 2001). For comparison to other urban canid studies (Romsos 1998, Grinder and Krausman 2001), home range was also estimated using the 95% fixed kernel, a probabilistic model that identified the most probable area of utilization (Worton 1989, Seaman and Powell 1996). To represent the core area for each study animal, I used the 50% fixed kernel, which identified the areas that encompassed 50% of the animal’s locations (Calhoun and Casby 1958, Jennrich and Turner 1969, Anderson 1982). Large bodies of water (e.g., Lake Truxtun) were removed from the estimates of home range area and available habitat (White and Garrott 1990).

Probabilistic home range techniques (e.g., fixed kernel) are sensitive to serial autocorrelation (Anderson 1982, Hooge et al. 1999). The minimum convex polygon home range estimator assumes that location data are not time correlated (Anderson 1982, White and Garrott 1990), but are robust to violation of this assumption. Only statistically independent data (i.e., the data point provided no indication of the category for the next data point) were used to estimate home range and core area size. Time to statistical independence between successive locations was based on the time it took each kit fox to cross its home range (White and Garrott 1990, Lucherini et al. 1995, Harrison 1997). To derive this estimate, I divided the mean speed for each of 10 kit foxes that were located approximately every 15 - 30 min during two to six 3 - 5 h movement sessions (hereafter referred to as sequential locations), by the longest axis of their 100% minimum convex polygon home range (Jenness 2003).

Area-observation curves were used to determine the minimum number of kit fox locations necessary for home range estimation (Odum and Kuenzler 1955). To do so, I iteratively 13 estimated the 100% minimum convex polygon home range for each kit fox, beginning with the first 10 locations and adding one consecutive location at a time. The area of each 100% minimum convex polygon was plotted against the number of locations from which it was estimated. The point on the curve at which each 10 additional locations did not increase the home range estimate by 10% was the minimum number of locations needed to estimate home range.

Because home range size may vary with sex (Burt 1943), a 2-sample t-test was used to determine if home range size differed between males and females (Hintze 1999). For comparison to rural kit fox studies in Arizona (Golightly 1981) and California (Zoellick et al. 1987, White and Ralls 1993, Koopman 1995), the 100% minimum convex polygon home range estimate was used for this analysis. All data were checked for normality and equal variance, and data that could not be normalized by transformation were analyzed with non-parametric tests. Significance level (α) was 0.05.

Home range size may also vary by season (Burt 1943). To assess if the area of the urban environment needed to meet kit foxes’ ecological requirements fluctuated throughout the year, I determined if home range size varied with biological season for urban kit foxes, as it did for rural kit foxes (Zoellick et al. 1987). Because kernel-based estimates from small sample sizes (e.g., from subsetting the data by season) tend to overestimate home range sizes (Seaman and Powell 1996), seasonal home ranges were estimated using 100% minimum convex polygons, which is more robust than other techniques when sample size is small (Harris et al. 1990). Data were normalized with a square-root transformation and analyzed with a 2-way analysis of variance (Winer et al. 1991, Hintze 1999) to compare mean home range size for male and female kit foxes during three biological seasons: dispersal (1 June to 30 September); pair formation (1 October to 30 November); and breeding (1 December to 15 February; Zoellick et al. 1987, Reese et al. 1992, Koopman et al. 1998). A Fisher's least significant difference multiple comparison test (Hintze 1999) was used to determine what factors (i.e., season and sex) in the analysis of variance were 14 significantly different. Study animals were located too seldom to estimate home range during the pup rearing season (16 February to 31 May).

The presence of food-rich habitat patches within territories may allow additional group members. Macdonald (1983) predicted that the home range of a mated pair of red foxes may overlap and support other foxes if there were sufficient resources. However, if food is evenly-dispersed among habitat patches, a larger home range would be required and the tolerance of additional adults in the territory of a pair would be predicted to be less. I predicted that if kit foxes were concentrated around limited resources, home ranges and core areas of adjacent kit foxes would have a high percentage of overlap. The GIS was used to identify the percentage of overlap between a) adjacent 100% minimum convex polygon home ranges and b) adjacent core area polygons between kit fox pairs comprised of a) mated pairs or family groups, b) adjacent females, c) adjacent males, and d) adjacent but unpaired males and females.

It was assumed that habitats that were used disproportionately more than available contained key resources. To assess if habitats with key resources (i.e., denning and foraging sites) were equally-dispersed or conversely, concentrated, the mean percentage of area of each 100% minimum convex polygon that the core area represented was determined. If areas of habitat use were concentrated, then the 50% fixed kernel should encompass less than 50% of the area used by each kit fox. If areas of use were uniform rather than concentrated, the 50% fixed kernel would comprise half of the area within the 100% minimum convex polygon. To assess if use of key resources differed among the sexes, the median number of core areas for females and males was compared with a Mann-Whitney U-test, and the mean core area size for males and females was compared with a 2-sample t-test.
15 Habitat Use
For those kit fox locations determined from triangulation, the likelihood for habitat misclassification increased with animal proximity to habitat edge and decreased as habitat-patch size increased (Samuel and Kenow 1992). To assess the probability of habitat misclassification, the GIS was used to determine the distance between each triangulated location and the nearest habitat-patch edge (Jenness 2004a). I reasoned that triangulated kit fox locations less than 100 m from the nearest habitat-patch edge may have had misclassification of habitat type. The 100 m value was selected because urban coyote studies that used similar methods to study habitat use, had average telemetry errors of 46 m (Grinder and Krausman 2001) and 102 m (Romsos 1998).

Use of habitat is considered selective if it is exploited disproportional to its availability (Johnson 1980). Habitat selection can occur at a variety of scales (Wiens 1973, Orians and Wittenberger 1991, Litvaitis et al. 1996, Apps et al. 2001). I analyzed habitat use within the individual kit fox home range and core area and for the kit fox population in the study area. To determine if kit foxes used urban habitat types (Table 1) with a frequency proportional to their availability, the independent locations that fell within a) the study area and b) each home range were selected. To delineate the study area, a 100% minimum convex polygon was generated using all daily, sequential, and trapping locations for all study animals (Litvaitis et al. 1996, Romsos 1998, Kamler et al. 2003). For comparison to other urban canid habitat use studies (Romsos 1998, Grinder and Krausman 2001), the 95% fixed kernel was used to represent the home range of each kit fox. The area of each habitat type in the study area and each home range was summed, and use of habitat types in each was compared with a Friedman's test (Alldredge and Ratti 1986, Hintze 1999; individual kit fox was the blocking factor, habitat type was the treatment factor, and the ranked numerical difference between the proportion of habitat used and the proportion of habitat available was the response variable). To determine which habitat types 16 were used significantly more than their availability, a Fisher's least significant difference procedure (Alldredge and Ratti 1986, Hintze 1999) was used.

How kit foxes used urban habitats was determined at two scales: within each home range in proportion to what was available in the study area; and within each core area in proportion to what was available in the corresponding home range. For each habitat type, I compared the proportion a) within each home range and the study area and b) within each core area and corresponding home range. Prior to analysis, the proportion data were arcsine transformed (Winer et al. 1991) and analyzed with a matched-pair t-test, or a Wilcoxon signed-rank test if data could not be normalized (Hintze 1999).

Fox habitat use may also be influenced by human presence (Lucherini et al. 1995); therefore, I treated human activity as an attribute of habitat. After each kit fox was located, an index of human activity was gained by counting the number of vehicles and pedestrians that passed by an imaginary line that was perpendicular to the nearest road in a 15 second period. The number of people that were visible (i.e., not in buildings or large habitat patches) in the same habitat patch as the kit fox was also recorded. To determine if human activity (i.e., the number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, and people in the same habitat patch as the kit fox) varied among the habitat types, a Kruskal-Wallis 1-way analysis of variance was used, followed by a Kruskal-Wallis multiple comparison test to determine what factors in the analysis of variance were significantly different.

Relative to some rural landscapes that have uniformly-distributed resources (Koopman 1995, Kamler et al. 2004), urban landscapes are highly fragmented, have isolated, clumped resources (Grinder and Krausman 2001), and consist of a patchy mosaic of habitats (Morrell 1975). Some urban habitats may be more suitable for denning and consequently, are used more than their availability in the study area. If certain habitats were selected for denning, the spatial 17 arrangement of home ranges would be influenced by the availability of the selected habitat types (Golightly 1981, Hardenbrook 1987).

The geographic coordinates of each den (i.e., refugia receiving repeated use by the study animals) were determined using a GPS and imported into the GIS. Dens were categorized as subterranean, culvert (or pipe), or man-made structure. To understand if den sites influenced habitat use, a 1-proportion z-test (Winer et al. 1991, Hintze 1999) was used to determine if habitats were used for denning in proportion to their availability in the study area.

Using the GIS, I generated random points (with a uniform distribution) equivalent to the number of dens in the study area (Hooge and Eichenlaub 1997). To assess if road proximity influenced den locations, the GIS was used to determine the distance of each den and random point to the centerline of the nearest road (Jenness 2004a). A Mann-Whitney U-test was used to determine if den sites and random points differed with regard to distance to the nearest road. A Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to determine if the median size of habitat patches within which dens were located differed from the median habitat-patch size in the study area.

Movements
Canid movement behavior may indicate use of habitat for resting, foraging, and traveling (Ozoga and Harger 1966, Laundré and Keller 1981, Romsos 1998). Between 8 September 1997 and 7 January 1998, a randomly-selected subsample (five females and five males) of radiocollared kit foxes was examined for movements and travel paths through adjacent habitat patches in order to identify which behaviors were associated with each habitat type. Based on behavior-specific movement types for canids in Ozoga and Harger (1966) and Laundré and Keller (1981), I categorized kit fox movement as resting/walking (i.e., inactivity at low speeds between 0 - 0.8 km/h), trotting (i.e., potentially searching for food at intermediate speeds between 0.8 - 1.8 km/h), and running (i.e., traveling from one point to another at high speeds greater than 1.8 18 km/h). Movements were assessed during three nocturnal sampling periods, approximately 1830 - 2230 h, 2230 - 0330 h, and 0330 - 0730 h. Each kit fox was followed two to six times during each of the three sampling periods.

While following kit foxes, sequential locations were determined approximately every 15 - 30 min during the sampling period. Movement sessions with more than one hour between any two successive locations were deemed incomplete and repeated on another day. The locations identified during each movement session were plotted on a 1996 City of Bakersfield street map (scale 1:29,000, Compass Maps, Inc., Modesto, CA). Time, habitat type, kit fox activity (e.g., resting/walking, trotting, running), and number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, and people in the same habitat patch as the kit fox were recorded.

GIS was used to digitize kit fox locations and generate a line from the set of sequential location points for each movement session. Each line was then intersected with the habitat types through which it passed (Jenness 2004b). Kit fox speed (the distance between two sequential locations divided by the time elapsed) was regressed against the number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, and people in the same habitat patch to examine the influence of humans on kit fox habitat use. A multivariate analysis of variance was used to determine if sex and movement session time influenced minimum travel speed, maximum speed, mean speed (using all speed estimates except when the kit fox was at a den or resting), and total distance moved per movement session (Woodruff and Keller 1982). Because movement session length varied, total distance moved was standardized by multiplying the distance measure by the ratio of 1) the length of time elapsed during the shortest movement session to 2) the length of time elapsed during the movement session with which the distance measure was associated.

To determine if total distance moved per movement session varied by habitat type, I used a Kruskal-Wallis 1-way analysis of variance (Zoellick et al. 1989). A Kruskal-Wallis 1-way analysis of variance was used to determine if overall median speed was influenced by habitat 19 type. Kruskal-Wallis multiple comparison tests were used to determine what factors in these analysis of variance tests were significantly different.

A loglinear model was used to examine correlations between type of movement, frequency of relocations per habitat type, and time of movement session. To identify the habitat type and movement session (i.e., evening, middle of the night, and early morning) within which kit foxes rested/walked, trotted, and ran, standardized residuals were used to identify the greatest deviations from expected for kit fox movements.

Demographics
Reproduction and mortality in radiocollared kit foxes were measured to determine if demographic parameters of urban kit fox populations were similar to those for rural kit fox populations, and assess habitat quality in the urban landscape (Van Horne 1983). Kit foxes with a radiocollar in a mortality mode were immediately located and necropsied to assess cause of death.

This information was used to determine sources and rates of kit fox mortality, which were compared to data for rural kit fox populations. I determined the number of radio-days since each kit fox was radiocollared and the survival rate for that time interval, described by Heisey and Fuller (1985) as the interval survival rate. Paired tooth puncture wounds associated with subcutaneous hematomas on the carcass were indicative of a predator kill, and if the carcass exhibited massive trauma and was located near a road, the cause of death was determined to be vehicular impact (Spiegel and Disney 1996).

The number of pups incidentally trapped or observed with radiocollared adult kit foxes and their mates were identified. Additionally, as part of a concurrent study (Storlie 1998) of juvenile kit fox dispersal and mortality, trapping effort was conducted in areas where pups were captured or observed. Capture data from both studies were used to estimate litter size for kit 20 foxes in the study area. The annual reproductive success rate was based on the percentage of radiocollared females that produced pups.
21 RESULTS
Trapping
Between 1 May 1997 and 15 January 1998, 107 (30 adult males, 31 adult females, and 46 juveniles) kit foxes were captured in all habitat types in which traps were placed (Appendix A).

Mean adult kit fox weight was 2.47 + 0.05 (x¯ + 1 SE) kg for males and 2.16 + 0.03 kg for females.

Locations
Radiocollars were attached to 28 adults (13 males, 15 females). Each radiocollared kit fox was located 5.1 + 0.3 days each week. Of the 35 kit foxes located between 0900 and 1600 h, 34 were stationary (e.g., resting) or in a den. In 252 study days, a total of 1,882 sequential locations (during 111 movement sessions) and 4,824 daily locations were determined for the 28 study animals. Of these locations, 4,249 were independent, of which 2,898 (68%) were considered to be exact and the habitat types in which they occurred were correctly classified, based on being tracked to a den (n = 811) or directly observed (n = 2,087). Directly observed kit foxes were classified as stationary for 52% of the observations (Figure 2). Of the 1,351 triangulated locations, 66 were > 100 m from the nearest habitat-patch edge. The remaining locations were on average 31.3 + 0.6 m from the nearest habitat-patch edge.

Home Range
Based on the area-observation curves (Odum and Kuenzler 1955; Appendix D), the average number of locations needed to estimate a 100% minimum convex polygon home range was 27 + 1.7. All sequentially-located kit foxes could cross the longest axis of their 100% 22 0
10 20
30 40
50 60
Resting/Walking Trotting Running Other
Behavior Type
Observations (%)
Figure 2. Behavior exhibited by directly observed kit foxes at independent daily locations (n = 2,087) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

I I I I I I
23 minimum convex polygon home range in less than four hours (range = 1.23 - 3.89 h; Appendix B). Therefore, four hours was used as the time to independence between kit fox locations.

The 100% minimum convex polygon home range size for all study animals combined was 1.72 + 0.19 km2 and was larger for males than females (Table 2). Average 95% fixed kernel home range size for all study animals combined (excluding one outlier) was 1.2 + 0.19 km2 (range = 0.04 – 2.78). Excluding one outlier, core areas comprised 9.1 + 1.2% (range = 1.9 –

19.6) of the 100% minimum convex polygon home range. Kit foxes had an average of 2.15 +

0.23 distinct core areas, and females had more than males. Mean 100% minimum convex polygon home range size was significantly larger during the dispersal season than during the pair formation and breeding seasons (F = 7.79, df = 2, p < 0.001) and for males than females during the breeding season (F = 4.47, df = 1, p = 0.04), and there was no interaction between season and sex (F = 2.38, df = 2, p = 0.1) (Table 3). The percentage of home range and core area overlap between kit foxes was highest for family group members (Figure 3).

Habitat Use
The study area was 76 km2, and had 3,908 habitat patches that averaged 0.01 + 0.001 km2 (range was < 0.01 - 2.03, except for a 17.88 km2 patch that comprised all interconnecting linear features that was excluded from this calculation). Kit foxes used urban habitats disproportionate to their availability in the study area (Q = 103.5, df = 7, p < 0.001) and within home ranges (Q =

91.36, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 4). Open and sump habitats were used more than their availability in both the study area and in home ranges (Table 4). There was less area of residential habitat but more area of open and sump habitats in home ranges than in the study area.

Area of transition, commercial, manicured open, linear, and residential habitats were less, but area of sump habitat was greater, in core areas than in home ranges (Table 5).

Table 2. Home range (100% minimum convex polygon) and core area (50% fixed kernel) size for radiocollared kit foxes in California from May 1997 to January 1998.

All Males Females Males vs. F
Measurement x¯ SE Range x¯ SE Range x¯ SE Range Statistic Home range size (km2) 1.72 0.19 0.31 - 4.49 2.12 0.31 0.31 - 4.49 1.36 0.21 0.36 - 2.71 t = -2.08 Core area size (km2) 0.16a0.03 0.01 - 0.5 0.18 0.05 0.01 - 0.5 0.15 0.04 0.02 - 0.43 t = -0.57 Core areas per kit fox 2.15 0.23 1 – 6 1.85 0.37 1 - 6 2.43 0.27 1 - 4 z = -1.98 a
Excluding one outlier (the male with two distinct home ranges). 25 Table 3. Seasonal home range (100% minimum convex polygon) size for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Home range (km2)
All Males Females
Season x¯ SE x¯ SE x¯ SE
Dispersal 1.24 0.11 1.32 0.16 1.17 0.15
Pair formation 0.77 0.11 0.79 0.16 0.74 0.16
Breeding 0.66 0.12 0.95 0.16 0.38 0.16
26 0
20 40
60 80
Family Group Male-Female Male-Male Female-Female
Pair Type
Overlap (%)
Home Range
Core Area
Figure 3. Percentage of home range overlap and core area overlap for pairs of radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE.
0 5
10 15
20 25
30 35
40 Residential Linear Commercial Open Manicured
Open
Industrial Sum
Habitat Type
Area (%)
a
c
b
b
a
a
b
a
b
a
b
a
b
Figure 4. Mean percentage of each habitat type in the study area, which bounded the available habitat, and radiocollared k 27) and core areas (n = 58) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Different letters above the bars i difference in habitat use versus availability.

Table 4. Ranked radiocollared kit fox habitat use based on habitat availability at the study area and home range area scale, California between May 1997 to January 1998. Habitat types used similarly (p > 0.05) are grouped by column.

Study Area Home Range
Habitat Types
Statistically Similar in Use
Mean
Rank
Habitat Types
Statistically Similar in Use
Open 2.1 Sump
Sump 2.6 Open
Transition 4.0 Transition
Industrial 4.0 Industrial
Manicured Open 4.4 Manicured Open
Commercial 5.4 Commercial Comme
Linear 5.6 Linear Linear
Residential 7.8 Residen
29 Table 5. Mean difference between the mean proportion of habitat available in the study area and kit fox home ranges (e.g., there was 16.7% less open habitat in the study area than within home ranges), and kit fox home ranges and core areas in Bakersfield, California between May 1997 to January 1998.

Study Area and Home Range Home Range and Core Area
Habitat Type Percent
Difference Statistic p
a Percent
Difference Statistic p
b
Commercial -1.3 t = 0.89 0.38 2.8 t = -2.79 <0.01
Industrial -1.2 z = 1.43 0.15 -2.2 z = 0.05 0.47
Linear 2.5 t = 1.47 0.15 4.3 z = -2.25 0.01
Manicured Open -6.2 t = -0.59 0.56 3.7 z = -1.77 0.02
Open -16.7 t = -3.83 <0.01 -7.5 t = 1.46 0.16
Residential 25.8 z = 4.52 <0.01 6.4 t = -5.5 <0.01
Sump -1.9 z = -2.88 <0.01 -7.6 z = 2.19 0.01
Transition -1.0 t = -0.66 0.51 0.2 t = -2.30 0.01
a,bBecause the analysis used multiple t-tests, the probability of at least one false rejection of the null hypothesis was 1 – 0.958 = 0.34 (Winer et al. 1991). 30 Number of people in the same habitat patch as the kit fox varied between habitat types and was greatest in manicured open habitat (H = 285.7, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 5). Industrial and linear habitats had a higher incidence of passing vehicles than all other habitats (H = 355.1, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 5). A greater number of pedestrians were observed along roads near sumps than all other habitats (H = 136.8, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 5).

The study animals used 190 dens, comprised of 159 subterranean dens, 17 culvert or pipe dens, and 14 man-made structure dens (e.g., metal storage containers, modular office buildings, junkyard debris, a shed, and a garbage dumpster), most of which were located in open, sump, and linear habitats (Figure 6). Sump (z = 45.74, df = 1, p < 0.001) and open (z = 11.47, df = 1, p <

0.001) habitats were used for denning more than their availability in the study area (Figure 7).

Residential (z = -10.5, df = 1, p < 0.001) and commercial (z = -3.67, df = 1, p < 0.001) habitats were used for denning less than their availability in the study area. Linear (z = -1.24, df = 1, p =

0.19), manicured open (z = -0.53, df = 1, p = 0.59), industrial (z = -0.3, df = 1, p = 0.76), and transition (z = -0.45, df = 1, p = 1.0) habitats were used for denning in proportion to their availability in the study area.

Dens were located farther from roads (0.10 + 0.01 km, range = 0.01 - 0.5) than randomly-generated points (0.06 + 0.01 km, range = 0.0001 - 0.55; z = 8.17, df = 378, p < 0.001). The median size of habitat patches within which dens were located (0.03 km2) was significantly larger than the median habitat-patch size in the study area (0.004 km2; z = 10.56, df = 1, p <

0.001).

Movements
Movement sessions (n = 100) lasted from 184 to 315 min long. Kit foxes moved at an average rate of 1.33 + 0.02 km/h. Minimum speed during each movement session was influenced Vehicles Passing on Nearest Road
0 0.5
1 1.5
2 2.5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Vehicles/15 s
Pedestrians Passing Along Nearest Road
0 0.1

0.2 0.3

0.4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Pedestrians/15 s
People in Habitat Patch
0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8 Linear Industrial Residential Sump Commercial Open Manicu Open
Habitat Type
People/15 s
Figure 5. Mean number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, and people in the same habitat patch as radiocollared kit f locations (n = 4,824) in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998. Vertical bars represent + 1 SE. 0 10
20 30
40 50
60 70
Open Sump Linear Manicured
Open
Industrial Commercial Reside
Habitat Type
Number of Dens
Figure 6. Number of dens used by radiocollared kit foxes in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to 0 5
10 15
20 25
30 35
40 Residential Linear Commercial Open Manicured
Open
Industrial Sum
Habitat Type
Habitat (%)
Figure 7. Percentage of available habitat in the study area compared to percentage of habitat used by radiocollared kit foxe Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.
34 by the interaction of sex and time of night (Figure 8, Table 6). The regressions of kit fox speed and the number of passing vehicles (r2 = 0.0077), passing pedestrians (r2 = 0.0016), and people in the same habitat patch as the kit fox (r2 = 0.0002), respectively, indicated that these variables (all of which could not be normalized through transformation) were not related to kit fox speed. The distance traveled during each movement session was longer in manicured open and open habitats than all other habitats (H = 125, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 9). Overall speed was faster in residential habitat than all other habitats (H = 111.6, df = 7, p < 0.001; Figure 10).

There was a significant interaction between kit fox movements, movement session time, and habitat type ( 2
= 61.48, df = 28, p < 0.001). Kit fox resting/walking movements deviated most from expected from 1830 – 2230 h, during which linear habitat was used more than expected and from 2230 – 0330 h, during which residential habitat was used less than expected (Table 7). Kit fox trotting movements deviated most from expected from 2230 – 0330 h during which open habitat was used more than expected, and from 2230 – 0730 h during which sump habitat was used less than expected. The greatest deviations from expected kit fox running movements were from 2230 – 0330 h during which open habitat was used more than expected, and from 0330 – 0730 h during which industrial habitat was used less than expected.

Between 27 September and 4 October 1997, a male kit fox moved > 5.9 km from his previously-established home range to another part of the study area, where he remained until the end of the study. Kit foxes were observed crossing roads (up to four lanes), but also used culverts to move under roads. One study animal was observed to use a 0.46-m in diameter culvert to cross under a State Route 99 offramp and a 4.26 m wide by 3.66 m high vehicle access road to cross under State Route 99. Other kit foxes were observed to cross under the State Route 99 bridge over the Kern River and use a foot bridge to cross a canal.
'X
35 0

0.05 0.1

0.15 0.2

0.25 0.3

0.35 0.4
1830 - 2230 2230 - 0330 0330 - 0730
Time Period
Minimum Speed of Travel (km/hr)
Males
Females
Figure 8. Minimum speed per movement session for male and female radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998.

Table 6. Influence of sex, movement session time, and their interaction on minimum, maximum, and mean speed and total moved for 10 radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Males Females Males vs. Females
Movement Session
Time
Measurement x¯ SE Range x¯ SE Range F-Ratio df p F-Ratio df p Minimum
Speed (km/hr2) 0.26 0.03 0.02 - 0.75 0.27 0.03 <0.01 - 1.16 0.05 1 0.82 0.58 2 0.56 Maximum
Speed (km/hr2) 2.19 0.13 0.26 - 4.65 2.17 0.22 0.32 - 9.06 0.1 1 0.75 2.5 2 0.09 Mean Speed
(km/hr2) 1.39 0.03 0.02 - 4.65 1.25 0.03 <0.01 - 9.06 1.32 1 0.25 1.08 2 0.34 Total Adjusted
Distance
Moved (km) 1.76 0.11 0.12 - 3.34 1.62 0.15 0.13 - 4.77 0.88 2 0.35 1.81 2 0.17 0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8 1

1.2 Manicured
Open
Open Residential Linear Industrial Commercial Transitio Habitat Type
Mean Distance Traveled (km)
Figure 9. Mean distance radiocollared kit foxes traveled in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from September 19 Vertical bars represent + 1 SE.

T
l
T
l .. ..

T
l
...
0 0.2

0.4 0.6

0.8 1

1.2 1.4

1.6 1.8
2 Residential Manicured
Open
Commercial Sump Industrial Open Line
Habitat Type
Mean Speed (km/hr)
Figure 10. Mean speed radiocollared kit foxes traveled in each habitat type in Bakersfield, California from September 199 Vertical bars represent + 1 SE.
-
T
- l.
-
T T - .L l. T
l T "T"
- .l rl ....
-
-
-
-
-
Table 7. Movement session time, type of movement, and habitat associations for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, Ca 1997 to January 1998.

Movement Type Movement Session Time (h) Habitat Type Observed FrequencyaStandardized Resid Resting/Walking 1830 - 2230 Sump 11 -5.19
Transition 18 -4.16
Residential 19 -4.02
Commercial 30 -2.40
Industrial 58 1.71
Manicured Open 107 8.91
Open 185 20.37
Linear 205 23.30
2230 - 0330 Residential 6 -5.93
Transition 12 -5.05
Sump 13 -4.90
Commercial 28 -2.69
Manicured Open 76 4.36
Industrial 78 4.65
Linear 89 6.27
Open 194 21.69
0330 - 0730 Commercial 15 -4.60
Residential 15 -4.60
Transition 26 -2.99
Sump 35 -1.67
Industrial 38 -1.23
Manicured Open 57 1.56
Open 164 17.28
Linear 174 18.75
Table 7. Movement session time, type of movement, and habitat associations for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, Ca 1997 to January 1998 (continued).

Movement Type Movement Session Time (h) Habitat Type Observed FrequencyaStandardized Resid Trotting 1830 - 2230 Sump 12 -5.05
Transition 12 -5.05
Residential 25 -3.14
Industrial 29 -2.55
Commercial 33 -1.96
Manicured Open 45 -0.20
Open 96 7.29
Linear 105 8.62
2230 - 0330 Sump 6 -5.93
Transition 13 -4.90
Residential 14 -4.75
Industrial 25 -3.14
Manicured Open 30 -2.40
Commercial 41 -0.79
Linear 94 7.00
Open 115 10.08
0330 - 0730 Sump 6 -5.93
Transition 20 -3.87
Industrial 25 -3.14
Commercial 28 -2.69
Manicured Open 29 -2.55
Residential 46 -0.05
Linear 72 3.77
Open 97 7.44
Table 7. Movement session time, type of movement, and habitat associations for radiocollared kit foxes in Bakersfield, Ca 1997 to January 1998 (continued).

Movement Type Movement Session Time (h) Habitat Type Observed Frequencya Standardized Resid
Running 1830 - 2230 Sump 6 -5.93
Industrial 14 -4.75
Transition 16 -4.46
Commercial 19 -4.02
Linear 50 0.54
Manicured Open 54 1.12
Residential 61 2.15
Open 64 2.59
2230 - 0330 Transition 6 -5.93
Sump 7 -5.78
Industrial 25 -3.14
Residential 27 -2.84
Commercial 35 -1.67
Manicured Open 38 -1.23
Linear 53 0.98
Open 66 2.89
0330 - 0730 Industrial 2 -6.51
Sump 4 -6.22
Transition 6 -5.93
Commercial 8 -5.63
Linear 21 -3.72
Manicured Open 24 -3.28
Open 30 -2.40
Residential 30 -2.40
aNumber of times a kit fox movement path intersected each habitat type, separated by movement type and movement sessi b Negative values indicate that a habitat was used less than expected and positive values indicate that a habitat was used mo If the value is > + 2.00 (2 standard deviations), it is significant. 42 Demographics
During 6,036 days of active radiotransmitters, two of the 28 radiocollared kit foxes died and the interval survival rate was 0.92. One female was hit by a vehicle and another female was likely killed by a coyote or domestic dog, based on 30 to 35-mm paired puncture wounds on the torso of the intact, unburied carcass (Spiegel and Disney 1996). It was unknown if another female that could not be located after 3 September 1997, died, dispersed, or had a malfunctioning radiocollar.

Pups were detected with 15 family groups, comprised of 22 radiocollared adult kit foxes.

Eleven of the 15 radiocollared females reproduced during one breeding season. Four of these 11 females had radiocollared mates. An additional four radiocollared males had uncollared mates that also reproduced in the same breeding season. Kit fox litters averaged 2.8 + 0.45 (range = 1 – 7) pups. The litter of 7 pups was observed denning with two radiocollared females, of which one exhibited reproductive condition and one did not.
43 DISCUSSION
Demographics
The urban kit foxes had lower mortality and similar reproduction and body weight compared to rural populations (Morrell 1972). Conversely, Cypher and Frost (1999) found that kit foxes in Bakersfield (i.e., females in winter and juveniles) were heavier than their counterparts in a nearby rural population. Urban kit foxes’ normal weights may be attributed to good nutrition. The constant source of water from sumps, canals, and lawn sprinklers in Bakersfield (Murphy 1992) may provide a more stable prey population. Like urban red foxes in Orange County, California (Lewis et al. 1993) and Toronto, Canada (Rosatte et al. 1991), urban kit foxes were supplementally fed (i.e., anthropogenic sources of food, including bread and burritos) by people and observed opportunistically foraging on both anthropogenic and natural food items (personal observation).

Urban kit foxes in Bakersfield may have lower mortality rates than rural foxes (Table 8).

Of 22 adult kit foxes from a nearby rural population that were radiocollared prior to or during late November and December 1995 through September 1996, 15 (68.2%) died and two were lost (Enterprise Advisory Services, Inc. 1997). Of 35 adult kit fox mortalities (including the two from this study) in the Bakersfield area from 1997 to 2003, 23% were due to vehicular impact (Bjurlin and Cypher 2003). The interval survival rate for urban kit foxes (0.92) was much greater than that for rural kit foxes (0.58; Ralls and White 1995; 0.44; Cypher et al. 2000).

Coyote predation may be more likely if a fox is far from its den (Kitchen et al. 1999) or in the peripheral areas of its home range (Sovada et al. 1998, Olson and Lindzey 2002). The majority of swift fox (Vulpes velox) deaths were due to coyotes and occurred outside the 85% Table 8. Rural kit fox and swift fox cause-specific mortality rates reported within their geographic range for comparison to in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Cause-Specific Mortality Rate (%
Reference Species Location Predation Vehicular Impac
Cypher et al. 2000 Kit Fox Kern County, CA 48.5 5.0
Ralls and White 1995 Kit Fox Carrizo Plain, CA 78.0 4.0 Hardenbrook 1987 Kit Fox Churchill County, NV 60.0 10.0 Spiegel and Disney 1996 Kit Fox Kern County, CA 66.7 1.7 Standley et al. 1992 Kit Fox Monterey and San Luis Obispo Counties, CA 75.0 6.3 Kamler et al. 2003 Swift Fox Dallam County, TX 33.0 42.0 Matlack et al. 2000 Swift Fox Sherman and Wallace Counties, KS 45.0 36.0 45 (Kitchen et al. 1999) or 95% (Sovada et al. 1998, Olson and Lindzey 2002) isopleth of the fox’s home range and more than 1 km from the den that the fox most recently occupied. Likewise, the urban kit fox that died as a result of coyote or dog predation was located outside the 85% isopleth of her range.

Production of young exceeded the number of kit foxes that died, which may have indicated that the urban kit fox population was demographically healthy during the period of study and habitat was of sufficient quality to support a source population (Van Horne 1983, Pulliam 1988, Noss et al. 1997). Seventy-three percent of radiocollared females produced pups, more than that observed for rural kit foxes in southwestern Kern County (64%; Spiegel and Tom 1996; 61%; Cypher et al. 2000). The mean number of pups per litter was within the range of that for rural populations: 2 (White and Ralls 1993) to 4 (Morrell 1971, Cypher et al. 2000).

Kit fox reproduction has been positively correlated with prey availability (White and Ralls 1993). Raccoons and skunks in Toronto, Canada weighed more and had higher reproductive success than their rural counterparts, which Rosatte et al. (1991) attributed to abundant and varied natural and human-derived food sources in the urban setting. The results of a supplemental feeding study indicated that kit fox survival and reproductive success were influenced by food availability (EG&G Energy Measurements 1993). Supplemental feeding by humans and the availability of refuse may contribute to the demographic health of urban kit foxes.

Locations
During daylight hours, urban kit foxes were found to be resting or in dens on all but one occasion. Like rural kit foxes in California (Morrell 1971, Morrell 1972, White et al. 2000), Utah (Egoscue 1956, O’Neal et al. 1987, Arjo et al. 2003), and Arizona (Golightly 1981, Golightly and Ohmart 1983) and urban red foxes in Orange County, California (Sallee 1998), urban kit foxes 46 were almost entirely nocturnal. Similarly, urban coyotes in Orange County, California (Romsos 1998), Seattle, Washington (Quinn 1995), and Tucson, Arizona (Grinder and Krausman 2001) were less active during daylight than at night. Urban kit foxes were primarily nocturnal and limited their daytime activity to the immediate vicinity of the den, similar to rural kit foxes (Morrell 1971, Morrell 1972), rural swift foxes (Kilgore 1969, Kitchen et al. 1999, Kamler et al. 2004), and urban red foxes (Voight and Macdonald 1984). Urban canids may benefit from being active only at night when interactions with humans are less likely.

Home range
Knowledge of home range size and spatial distribution can be used to manage urban habitat for the benefit of kit foxes. Home range estimates were much smaller than those for rural kit foxes (Table 9), but consistent with observations that foxes (Voight and Macdonald 1984, Murphy 1992) and raccoons and skunks in urban areas have smaller ranges than their rural counterparts (Rosatte et al. 1991).

Macdonald (1983) and Doncaster et al. (1990) attributed the tendency for red fox home ranges to be smaller in cities (e.g., Oxford) than in rural areas, to the spatial and temporal patchiness of food dispersion. Red foxes in Orange County, California had smaller home ranges where they were supplementally fed (Sallee 1998). Ables (1969) noted that the smaller home ranges for red foxes in south-central Wisconsin may have been due to habitat richness (i.e., a high interspersion of habitat types and abundant wild fruits and berries). Artificial food sources associated with urban and oilfield development may have led to decreases in the home range size of kit foxes in southwestern Kern County (Zoellick et al. 1987, Spiegel and Bradbury 1992).

Conversely, kit fox home ranges increased in size during times of low prey availability (White and Ralls 1993) and were negatively correlated with prey density (Morrell 1971, White and Garrott 1997). Thus, the small size of urban kit fox home ranges indicated that abundant food Table 9. Kit fox home range size reported within various habitats within their geographic range for comparison to home ra foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Reference Location Habitat Estimator Range Typ
Knapp 1978 Kern County, CA Agriculture 100% Minimum convex polygona Home Rang Koopman 1995 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 100% Minimum convex polygon Home Rang Zoellick et al. 1987 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 100% Minimum convex polygon Home Rang White and Ralls 1993 Carrizo Plain, CA Grassland 100% Minimum convex polygon Home Rang O’Neal et al. 1987 Great Basin, UT Saltbush scrub 100% Minimum convex polygon Home Rang Spiegel and Bradbury 1992 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 97% Minimum convex polygonb Home Rang Spiegel and Bradbury 1992 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 95% Minimum convex polygonb Nocturnal R Hardenbrook 1987 Churchill County, NV Greasewood Modified Minimum Area Method Home Rang Arjo et al. 2003 Tooele County, UT Salt playa 95% Adaptive Kernel Home Rang Arjo et al. 2003 Tooele County, UT Greasewood 95% Adaptive Kernel Home Rang Arjo et al. 2003 Tooele County, UT Sagebrush 95% Adaptive Kernel Home Rang Koopman 1995 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 75% Harmonic Mean Core area Spiegel and Bradbury 1992 Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 50% Hamonic Meanb Core area Zoellick et al. (2002) Kern County, CA Saltbush scrub 50% Hamonic Mean Core area aMay have been underestimated due to small sample size. b Estimates using non-independent data may have been inflated, as demonstrated in Koopman (1995). 48 resources were concentrated in key urban habitats around which home ranges were configured.

Further evidence of this was that urban kit foxes’ core area size constituted only 9% of the home range size, whereas that for rural kit foxes constituted 17% of the home range (Spiegel and Bradbury 1992). This may be because suitable denning habitat for urban kit foxes was concentrated around sumps and undeveloped lots.

Female urban kit foxes had a greater median number of core areas than did males, indicating that females had a higher number of distinct denning sites. Female kit foxes in Arizona (Golightly 1981) and Nevada (Hardenbrook 1987) spent more time near their dens than males. Fenced sumps in core areas provide denning habitat that may ensure safe reproduction in the urban population.

The home ranges and core areas of adjacent kit foxes may have substantial overlap if kit foxes are concentrated around limited resources (Golightly 1981), such as food-rich habitat patches (Macdonald 1983). Mean home range overlap was greater than 71% for family group members and less than 16% for unrelated individuals, which was less than that for the nearby rural population (Zoellick et al. 2002, Spiegel and Bradbury 1992).

Core area overlap was greater for members of the same family group (61%) than core area overlap of neighboring males and females (29%) or neighboring males (11%), similar to that for rural kit foxes (Spiegel and Bradbury 1992). Unpaired male and female urban kit foxes had a higher percentage of core area overlap than home range overlap. Because core areas were centered around denning sites, male and female kit foxes’ home ranges may have overlapped in a central denning area, as was the case for kit foxes in Arizona (Golightly 1981) and Nevada (Hardenbrook 1987). Kitchen et al.’s (2005) findings that male swift foxes spent more time on the boundary of the home range, while females spent more time in the group core area, may explain why female urban kit foxes had the least home range overlap and no core area overlap. 49 Overlap of home ranges and core areas indicated that kit foxes were concentrated around key urban habitat patches and food resources were not evenly-distributed. It was likely that urban kit foxes were able to find foraging and denning habitat in close proximity because of uniformly-distributed sumps, which may be important to the success of the urban kit fox population.

Due to refuse and human-derived foods, urban kit foxes may be able to meet their resource needs in a smaller area than rural kit foxes. The presence of these food resources distributed among disjunct habitat patches may explain why urban kit foxes had smaller and less overlapping home ranges than their rural counterparts. Given the constant and widespread availability of human-derived food in the urban landscape, suitable denning habitat may be a limiting factor for the urban kit fox population. This is consistent with Golightly’s (1981) conclusion that kit fox den sites in rural Arizona were limited by soils suitable for denning.

Estimates of 100% minimum convex polygon home range size were greater for males than females, perhaps due to fewer seasonal movements by females and increased foraging requirements for males during pup-rearing (Spiegel and Bradbury 1992). While Golightly (1981) found that male kit foxes in Arizona had much larger home ranges than females, home range size for other rural kit fox (Zoellick et al. 1987, Spiegel and Bradbury 1992, White and Ralls 1993, Koopman 1995), swift fox (Kitchen et al. 1999, Kamler et al. 2003), and Blanford’s fox (Vulpes cana; Geffen and Macdonald 1992) populations did not differ among the sexes.

Because home range size may vary with season (Burt 1943), the quantity of urban habitat needed to meet kit foxes’ ecological requirements may fluctuate over time. Home range size was greater for males than females during the breeding season, but did not differ between the seasons for kit foxes in Utah (Arjo et al. 2003), swift foxes (Kitchen et al. 1999), Blanford’s foxes (Geffen and Macdonald 1992), and culpeo foxes (Pseudalopex culpaeus; Salvatori et al. 1999).

In order to search for a mate during the breeding season, male foxes may increase their number of exploratory movements, which may be especially pronounced in the urban environment where 50 patches of habitat suitable to support kit foxes are small and disjunct. Home range size may have been underestimated during the pair formation and breeding seasons, because fewer kit foxes were located during this time. This may explain why mean home range size was significantly larger during the dispersal season than the pair formation and breeding seasons.

Habitat use
Habitats were known to be correctly classified for 68% of all independent locations, which were obtained by following the transmitted signal until the animal was observed or tracked to a den. It was unlikely that visually observed kit foxes were behaviorally pushed from one habitat to another, because kit foxes were resting or walking 67% of the time. However, distance between the animal and the radio-receiver, as well as broken topography, can increase telemetry error (Harris et al. 1990). Telemetry error was a concern because correct assignment of habitat use required accurate locations. Based on average telemetry error in urban coyote studies (Romsos 1998, Grinder and Krausman 2001), triangulated kit fox locations less than 100 m from the nearest habitat-patch edge may have been misclassified. The remaining 32% of locations were determined by triangulation or encircling the habitat patch. These locations averaged 31 m from the nearest habitat-patch edge and may have included some misclassification.

Like urban kit foxes, rural kit foxes do not use habitat within their home range in a uniform manner (Golightly 1981, Hardenbrook 1987) and have distinct core areas of concentrated activity (Koopman 1995). Kit foxes used open and sump habitats more than their availability in both the study area and in home ranges, and there was significantly more open and sump habitat in home ranges than in the study area. Likewise, urban red foxes (Sallee 1998) and coyotes (Romsos 1998) in Orange County, California used vacant field habitats more than expected. The higher vegetative cover in vacant fields may facilitate predator avoidance and support a more abundant prey base (Adams and Dove 1989) than the other less used urban habitats. Likewise, 51 sumps had marsh vegetation, which provides food and cover for wildlife and facilitates use by terrestrial wildlife (Adams and Dove 1989). Therefore, sumps may serve as artificial urban wetlands that provide denning habitat with their sloping sides, foraging opportunities based on the abundance of active small mammal burrows (personal observation), and a constant source of water, which I observed an urban kit fox drinking. In hot environments, such as Arizona, rural kit foxes meet their water needs through prey consumption (Golightly and Ohmart 1984). With the availability of free-standing water in the urban environment, kit foxes may require less food.

The number of people in the same habitat patch as the kit fox was lowest in open and sump habitats. While the greatest number of pedestrians observed along roads were near sumps, the fencing around sumps provided a physical and visual barrier between kit foxes and passing pedestrians. The shelter and security that the fenced perimeters provided may also explain why Stafford and Murphy (1992) found kit fox dens in 10 of the 95 sumps that they surveyed in Bakersfield. Likewise, urban red foxes disproportionate use of industrial habitats may be attributed to security personnel and perimeter fencing, which limited intrusion by humans and their pets (Sallee 1998).

There was significantly less residential habitat in urban kit fox home ranges than in the study area; the opposite was true for urban coyotes in Tucson, Arizona (Grinder and Krausman 2001). Harrison (1997) found that gray foxes (Urocyon cinereoargenteus) in New Mexico avoided high-density residential subdivisions. Urban coyotes (Romsos 1998) and red foxes (Sallee 1998) in Orange County, California avoided high-density residential and commercial habitats, perhaps due to a greater possibility for human and domestic animal interactions.

Likewise, Lucherini et al. (1995) found that red foxes used habitats with less human access and disturbance.

Industrial and linear habitats had a higher incidence of passing vehicles than all other habitats. This may be because industrial habitats tend to occur along major roads. In linear 52 habitat, from 1800 to 1859 h and 0700 to 0759 h, both the number of kit fox locations and number of passing vehicles peaked (Appendix E). However, during these times, 84% of the kit foxes using the linear habitat were located in dens that sheltered them from the disturbance of the passing vehicles.

The kit fox is one of the few canids that utilizes an underground den throughout the year (Berry et al. 1987, Koopman et al. 1998). Because dens are used for whelping and rearing pups, for escape cover from predators (Grinnell et al. 1937), and to minimize water loss and heat stress in summer and metabolic costs in winter (Golightly 1981, Golightly and Ohmart 1983), kit fox presence is limited by the availability of (Spiegel et al. 1996) or their ability to build dens. Like rural kit foxes in California (Knapp 1978, Berry et al. 1987, Reese et al. 1992) and Utah (Egoscue 1956, Arjo et al. 2003) and swift foxes (Kilgore 1969), urban kit foxes primarily used subterranean dens. However, they also used alternative dens, including pipes. Use of pipes that are known to interfere with radio signals, may have caused an underestimation of the number of alternative dens used in this study (Berry et al. 1987, Spiegel et al. 1996, Koopman et al. 1998).

Like Golightly (1981), I found that kit foxes did not randomly select den sites. Because kit foxes selected sump habitats for denning, there was more area of sump habitat in core areas than in home ranges. Sumps may also be used for denning because they are fenced and not accessible to the public. Likewise, most urban red fox dens occurred within fenced areas that may have isolated dens from human disturbance (Sallee 1998). Stafford and Murphy (1992) found that the majority of sumps used by urban kit foxes for denning were adjacent to undisturbed habitat, which likely has a low human presence.

Furthermore, I found that urban kit foxes denned in open habitats more than their availability in the study area. Likewise, rural kit foxes in California (Morrell 1971, Morrell 1972), Utah (Egoscue 1956, Egoscue 1962), and Arizona (Zoellick et al. 1989) and urban red 53 foxes (Lewis et al. 1993) frequently denned in flat, open areas. Kit foxes may be less vulnerable to coyote and bobcat predation on flat or rolling grasslands (Warrick and Cypher 1998).

Linear habitats (i.e., along canals, railroads, freeway embankments, and powerline right-of-ways) were used in proportion to their availability for denning. Like swift foxes, urban kit foxes utilized dens in road right-of-ways (Matlack et al. 2000). However, urban kit foxes denned near roads less than expected and in larger habitat patches than expected. Similarly, red foxes used habitats with less human access and disturbance for resting (Lucherini et al. 1995).

Movements
Kit foxes moved at an average rate of 1.33 km/h, nearly identical to that for kit foxes in southwestern Kern County (1.35 km/h; Koopman 1995) but slower than that for kit foxes in Arizona (males: 2.73 km/h; females: 1.49 km/h; Golightly 1981) and faster than that for swift foxes (males: 0.68 km/h; females: 0.59 km/h; Kitchen et al. 1999). Between dusk and dawn (i.e., approximately 10 to 14 h, depending on time of year), rural kit foxes in Arizona moved an average distance of 14.3 km for males and 11.8 km for females (Zoellick et al. 1989) and in southwestern Kern County, moved an average distance of 9.8 km for males and 10.9 km for females (Zoellick et al. 1987), yielding average movement rates similar to that for urban kit foxes.

The average distance that captured urban red foxes, raccoons, and skunks in Toronto, Canada moved from the point of release was less than that for their rural counterparts, which indicated that food and habitat in the urban environment were not limited in availability (Rosatte et al. 1991).

Males, which had larger 100% minimum convex polygon home ranges than females, may travel at higher rates of speed during the early part of the evening to cover their larger territory.

In Arizona, kit fox activity peaked in the early evening and a few hours before sunset, and males spent twice as much time out of the den, traveled 3.6 times farther, and maintained home ranges 54 2.6 times larger than females (Golightly 1981). However, in the urban setting, I did not detect a difference between sexes, movement session times, or their interaction with regard to maximum speed, mean speed, or total adjusted distance moved during each movement session. Similarly, lengths of nightly movements did not differ among sexes for rural kit foxes (Zoellick et al. 2002) and Blanford’s foxes (Geffen and Macdonald 1992). Compared to Arizona, where male kit foxes spent much time by the boundaries of their territory to defend a non-uniformly distributed resource base (Golightly 1981), urban kit foxes were able to meet their resource needs within small home ranges and did not need to travel far due to the concentration of resources within distinct habitat patches in the urban landscape.

Kit fox movement speed was not correlated with the number of passing vehicles, passing pedestrians, or people in the same habitat patch. This is consistent with the findings in Lewis et al. (1993), which indicated that urban red foxes were tolerant of humans. Nevertheless, kit foxes may have attempted to avoid human interactions by traveling at a high rate through residential, manicured open, and commercial habitats, all which had a high incidence of people.

Sump and transition habitats were typically small patches that were free of people at night when kit foxes were active. Kit foxes were observed foraging in and caching food scavenged from construction sites. Furthermore, the remains of several species that live in sumps, including bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana), burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia), duck (unidentified species), pocket gopher, squirrel, and opossum, were observed on kit fox dens in sumps (personal observation). Use of sump and transition habitats for hunting or scavenging refuse may explain why kit foxes traveled short distances at low speeds in these habitats.

Kit foxes used linear habitats (i.e., the Kern River Parkway, canals, and right-of-ways for highways, railroads, and powerlines) as corridors to move throughout their home range. Because highway, railroad, and powerline right-of-ways were fenced to prohibit public access, kit foxes may not have been compelled to move quickly through this habitat type. Kit foxes moved long 55 distances quickly through manicured open habitats, perhaps because this habitat had a high occurrence of humans and was used mostly as a corridor for traveling, similar to urban red foxes’ use of golf courses in Toronto, Canada (Rosatte et al. 1991).

Kit foxes in urban areas may have shorter nightly movements due to anthropogenic food sources (Zoellick et al. 1987). Consequently, movement distance may be influenced by foraging efficiency. Movement distance was less in commercial habitats (where kit foxes were observed foraging in parking lots and trash dumpsters) and transition habitats, both which tend to have an abundance of discarded food items (personal observation). Conversely, kit foxes moved longer distances in open, grassland habitat. This may have been because small, insectivorous prey of kit foxes and swift foxes tend to be evenly distributed in grassland habitats (Kamler et al. 2004).

Similarly, Koopman (1995) noted that food resources were uniformly distributed in rural kit fox home ranges.

Movements of kit foxes differed with regard to habitat type and time of night. From 1830 – 2230 h, linear habitat was used more than expected for kit fox resting/walking movements. This was probably because 23% of kit fox dens were in linear habitat. From 2230 – 0330 h, kit fox trotting and running movements were higher than expected in open habitat, which was likely used for foraging and traveling. From 2230 – 0330 h, kit fox resting/walking movements were less than expected in residential habitat, in which only one den was located. Kit foxes’ high rate of speed through residential habitat indicates that they used this habitat type as a means to get to a more used habitat. From 2230 – 0730 h, kit fox trotting movements were less than expected in sump habitat, which may be used primarily for denning rather than foraging.

From 0330 – 0730 h, industrial habitat was used less than expected for kit fox running movements. Kit fox speed may have been lower in industrial habitats during these hours due to the absence of humans or the presence of refuse.
56 Urban habitat was of sufficiently high quality to support kit foxes with low mortality and normal weight and offspring production. This was likely due to the widespread availability of natural and human-derived food sources and protected (i.e., fenced) areas with cover. Kit fox core areas contained a disproportionately high amount of sumps, which had food and den sites and restricted public access. The availability of sump and open habitats, which kit foxes selected for denning, may shape the distribution and abundance of the urban population. Portions of the urban landscape without these prime denning habitats may not be able to support kit foxes. 57 MANAGEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS
The kit foxes in Bakersfield had low mortality, similar weight and mean litter size, and high reproductive success, compared to that for rural kit foxes. Urban kit foxes appeared to have adapted to urban conditions and resources, and may contribute to the San Joaquin Valley metapopulation.

Urban kit foxes were observed crossing roads (up to four lanes), but also used culverts and a bridge to move under them, which may help explain the relatively low mortality. Vehicular mortality should be monitored around sump and open habitats. If increased mortality is observed, additional culverts may need to be placed and maintained under roads, along with animal-proof fencing to direct kit foxes to the culverts (Ng et al. 2004). Mid-sized mammals’ (i.e., raccoons and skunks) use of culverts is positively correlated to culvert length and negatively correlated to culvert area (Ng et al. 2004). Small diameter culverts (i.e., 0.5 m) may serve a dual purpose by providing a place for urban kit foxes to hide from larger predators and facilitating kit fox movement in a fragmented landscape.

To promote the continued existence of kit foxes in urban settings, such as Bakersfield, habitat will need to be retained and managed to meet their needs. Urban kit foxes denned farther from roads than expected in habitat patches that were larger than expected, and thus, may benefit from the retention of larger open and sump habitat patches for denning. Urban kit foxes had less spatial overlap and smaller home ranges and core areas than their rural counterparts. The greater presence of anthropogenic food sources in cities may enable urban kit foxes to meet their energetic needs in a smaller area than kit foxes in rural, grassland habitats, where food resources may be more dispersed (Kamler et al. 2004). Kit foxes utilized open lots and sumps more than all other urban habitat types.
58 Golightly (1981) concluded that dens were important to kit fox energetics and a consideration in the management of this species. If kit foxes are to be retained in Bakersfield, open lots, to provide foraging and denning habitat, and uniformly-distributed, sumps that are fenced and closed to the public, to provide kit fox denning habitat, will need to be maintained throughout the city. Sump maintenance (e.g., grading or paving) may be a potential hazard to kit foxes (Murphy 1992) and should be avoided. With sensitivity to kit fox presence in the urban environment, much protection can be afforded at a low cost.

The kit fox recovery strategy identified that “connections need to be established, maintained, and promoted between populations to counteract negative consequences of inbreeding, random catastrophic events (e.g., droughts) and demographic factors” (United States Fish and Wildlife Service 1998). Urban kit foxes used the Kern River Parkway to move throughout their home range. The Kern River Parkway should be maintained and managed to facilitate kit fox movement. In addition, dog management may be required because dogs may pose a threat to urban kit foxes as they have for rural kit foxes (Ralls and White 1995, Cypher et al. 2000).

Like urban red foxes in Great Britain (Kolb 1984) and Toronto, Canada (Rosatte et al. 1991) that use railroad corridors to move throughout their home range, urban coyotes (Romsos 1998), red foxes (Lewis et al. 1993, Sallee 1998), and kit foxes used canals (including foot bridges over canals) and railroad, highway, and powerline right-of-ways for moving and denning.

The continued existence of these right-of-ways, which are fenced to prohibit public access, will facilitate kit fox movement throughout the city. Kit foxes can persist in urban areas if an adequate mosaic of habitat is conserved and managed appropriately. 59 REFERENCES
Ables, E. D. 1969. Home-range studies of red fox (Vulpes vulpes). Journal of Mammalogy 50:108-119.

Adams, L. W. and L. E. Dove. 1989. Wildlife reserves and corridors in the urban environment: a guide to ecological landscape planning and resource conservation. National Institute for Urban Wildlife. Columbia, Maryland. 91 pp.

Allredge, J. R. and J. T. Ratti. 1986. Comparison of some statistical techniques for analysis of resource selection. Journal of Wildlife Management 50:157-165.

Anderson, D. J. 1982. The home range: a new nonparametric estimation technique. Ecology 63:103-112.

Apps, C. D., B. N. McLellan, T. A. Kinley, and J. P. Flaa. 2001. Scale-dependent habitat selection by mountain caribou, Columbia Mountains, British Columbia. Journal of Wildlife Management 65:65-77.

Arjo, W. M., T. J. Bennett, and A. J. Kozlowski. 2003. Characteristics of current and historical kit fox (Vulpes macrotis) dens in the Great Basin Desert. Canadian Journal of Zoology 81:96-102.

Beedy, E. C., V. K. Getz, and D. A. Airola. 1992. Status of the San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) in the urban Kern River Parkway, Bakersfield, California. Pages 47-54 in D. F. Williams, S. Byrne, and T. A. Rado, editors. Endangered and sensitive species of the San Joaquin Valley, California. California Energy Commission, Sacramento, California.

Berry, W. H., T. P. O'Farrell, T. T. Kato, and P. M. McCue. 1987. Characteristics of dens used by radiocollared San Joaquin kit fox, Vulpes macrotis mutica, Naval Petroleum Reserve #1, Kern County, California. United States Department of Energy, Topical Report, EG&G/EM Santa Barbara Operations Report No. EGG 10282-2177, Santa Barbara, California. 32 pp.

Bjurlin, C. D. and B. L. Cypher. 2003. Effects of roads on San Joaquin kit foxes: a review and synthesis of existing data. Pages 397-406 in C. L. Irwin, P. Garrett, and K. P. McDermott, editors. 2003 Proceedings of the International Conference on Ecology and Transportation. Center for Transportation and the Environment, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina.
60 Burt, W. H. 1943. Territoriality and home range concepts as applied to mammals. Journal of Mammalogy 24:346-352.

Calhoun, J. B. and J. U. Casby. 1958. Calculation of home range and density of small mammals.

United States Public Health Monograph 55, United States Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C.

Catling, P. C. 1988. Similarities and contrasts in the diet of foxes, Vulpes vulpes, and cats, Felis catus, relative to fluctuating prey populations and drought. Australian Wildlife Research 15:307-317.

Cypher, B. L. and N. Frost. 1999. Condition of San Joaquin kit foxes in urban and exurban habitats. Journal of Wildlife Management 63:930-938.

Cypher, B. L. and G. D. Warrick. 1993. Use of human-derived food items by urban kit foxes.

Transactions of the Western Section of the Wildlife Society 29:34-37.

Cypher, B. L., G. D. Warrick, M. R. Otten, T. P. O'Farrell, W. H. Berry, C. E. Harris, T. T. Kato, P. M. McCue, J. H. Scrivner, and B. W. Zoellick. 2000. Population dynamics of San Joaquin kit foxes at the Naval Petroleum Reserves in California. Wildlife Monographs 145. 43 pp.

Doncaster, C. P., C. R. Dickman, and D. W. Macdonald. 1990. Feeding ecology of red foxes (Vulpes vulpes) in the city of Oxford, England. Journal of Mammalogy 71:188-194.

EG&G Energy Measurements. 1993. Effects of supplemental feeding on survivorship, reproduction, and dispersal in San Joaquin kit foxes. United States Department of Energy, Topical Report, EG&G/EM Las Vegas Operations Report No. EGG 111265- 2059, Las Vegas, Nevada. 28 pp.

Egoscue, H. J. 1956. Preliminary studies of the kit fox in Utah. Journal of Mammalogy 37:351- 357.

Egoscue, H. J. 1962. Ecology and life history of the kit fox in Tooele County, Utah. Ecology 43:481-497.

Enterprise Advisory Services, Inc. 1997. Endangered species and cultural resources program, Naval Petroleum Reserves in California, Annual Report FY96. Report 97-1, Enterprise Advisory Services, Inc., Tupman, California. 56 pp.

Geffen, E. and D. W. Macdonald. 1992. Small size and monogamy: spatial organization of Blanford’s foxes, Vulpes cana. Animal Behaviour 44:1123-1130. 61 Golightly, Jr., R. T. 1981. The comparative energetics of two desert canids: the coyote and the kit fox. Ph.D. Dissertation. Department of Zoology, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona. 174 pp.

Golightly, Jr., R. T., Faulhaber, M. R., K. L. Sallee, and J. C. Lewis. 1994. Food habits and management of introduced red fox in southern California. Pages 15-20 in W. S.

Halverson and A. C. Crabb, editors. Proceedings of the 16th Vertebrate Pest Conference.

University of California, Davis, California.

Golightly, Jr., R. T. and R. D. Ohmart. 1983. Metabolism and body temperature of two desert canids: coyote and kit foxes. Journal of Mammalogy 64:624-635.

Golightly, Jr., R. T. and R. D. Ohmart. 1984. Water economy of two desert canids: coyote and kit fox. Journal of Mammalogy 65:51-58.

Grinder, M. I. and P. R. Krausman. 2001. Home range, habitat use, and nocturnal activity of coyotes in an urban environment. Journal of Wildlife Management 65:887-898.

Grinnell, J., J. Dixon, and J. Linsdale. 1937. Kit foxes. Pages 399-420 in J. Grinnell, J. Dixon, and J. Linsdale, editors. Fur bearing animals of California. Vol. 2. University of California Press, Berkeley, California.

Hardenbrook, D. B. 1987. Habitat usage and den sites of kit foxes in west-central Nevada.

Master’s Thesis. Department of Wildlife, Humboldt State University, Arcata, California. 83 pp.

Harris, S. 1977. Distribution, habitat utilization and age structure of a suburban fox (Vulpes vulpes) population. Mammal Review 7:25-39.

Harris, S. 1978. Age determination in the red fox (Vulpes vulpes) – an evaluation of technique efficiency as applied to a sample of suburban foxes. Journal of Zoology 184:91-117.

Harris, S., W. J. Cresswell, P. G. Forde, W. J. Trewhella, T. Woollard, and S. Wray. 1990. Home-range analysis using radio-tracking data - a review of problems and techniques particularly as applied to the study of mammals. Mammal Review 20:97-123.

Harris, S. and J. M. V. Rayner. 1986. Urban fox (Vulpes vulpes) population estimates and habitat requirements in several British cities. Journal of Animal Ecology 55:575-591.

Harrison, R. L. 1997. A comparison of gray fox ecology between residential and undeveloped rural landscapes. Journal of Wildlife Management 61:112-121.

Heisey, D. M. and T. K. Fuller. 1985. Evaluation of survival and cause-specific mortality rates using telemetry data. Journal of Wildlife Management 49:668-674. 62 Hintze, J. L. 1999. User's guide - NCSS statistical system for windows. Number Cruncher Statistical Systems, Kaysville, Utah. 777 pp.

Hooge, P. N. and B. Eichenlaub. 1997. Animal movement extension to ArcView. Version 2.0.

Alaska Biological Science Center, United States Geological Survey, Anchorage, Alaska.

Hooge, P. N., B. Eichenlaub, and E. K. Solomon. 1999. Using GIS to analyze movements in the marine environment. United States Geological Survey and National Park Service, Gustavus, Alaska. 20 pp.

Jenness, J. 2003. Longest straight line extension for ArcView 3.x. Version 1.3. Jenness Enterprises, Flagstaff, Arizona.

Jenness, J. 2004a. Nearest features extension for ArcView 3.x. Version 3.8a. Jenness Enterprises, Flagstaff, Arizona.

Jenness, J. 2004b. Alternate animal movement routes extension for ArcView 3.x. Version 2.

Jenness Enterprises, Flagstaff, Arizona.

Jennrich, R. I. and F. B. Turner. 1969. Measurement of non-circular home range. Journal of Theoretical Biology 22:227-237.

Johnson, D. H. 1980. The comparison of usage and availability measurements for evaluating resource preference. Ecology 61: 65-71.

Kamler, J. F. and W. B. Ballard. 2002. A review of native and nonnative red foxes in North America. Wildlife Society Bulletin 30:370-379.

Kamler, J. F., W. B. Ballard, E. B. Fish, P. R. Lemons, K. Mote, and C. Perchellet. 2003. Habitat use, home ranges, and survival of swift foxes in a fragmented landscape: conservation implications. Journal of Mammalogy 84:989-995.

Kamler, J. F., W. B. Ballard, E. M. Gese, R. L. Harrison, S. Karki, and K. Mote. 2004. Adult male emigration and a female-based social organization in swift foxes, Vulpes velox.

Animal Behaviour 67: 699-702.

Kilgore, Jr., D. L. 1969. An ecological study of the swift fox (Vulpes velox) in the Oklahoma panhandle. American Midland Naturalist 81:512-534.

Kitchen, A. M., E. M. Gese, and E. R. Schauster. 1999. Resource partitioning between coyotes and swift foxes: space, time, and diet. Canadian Journal of Zoology 77:1645-1656. 63 Kitchen, A. M., E. M. Gese, S. M. Karki, and E. R. Schauster. 2005. Spatial ecology of swift fox social groups: from group formation to mate loss. Journal of Mammalogy 86:547-554.

Kleiman, D. G. and C. A. Brady. 1978. Coyote behavior in the context of recent canid research:
problems and perspectives. Pages 163-188 in M. Bekoff, editor. Coyotes: Biology, behavior, and management. Academic Press, New York, New York.

Knapp, D. K. 1978. Effects of agricultural development in Kern County, California, on the San Joaquin kit fox in 1977. Final Report, Project E-1-1, Job V-1.21, Non-game Wildlife Investigations. California Department of Fish and Game, Sacramento, California. 48 pp.

Kolb, H. H. 1984. Factors affecting the movements of dog foxes in Edinburgh. Journal of Applied Ecology 21:161-173.

Kolb, H. H. 1986. Some observations on the home ranges of vixens (Vulpes vulpes) in the suburbs of Edinburgh. Journal of Zoology 53:636-639.

Koopman, M. E. 1995. Food habits, space use, and movements of the San Joaquin kit fox on the Elk Hills Naval Petroleum Reserves in California. Master’s Thesis. Department of Forestry and Resource Management, University of California, Berkeley, California. 41 pp.

Koopman, M. E., J. H. Scrivner, and T. T. Kato. 1998. Patterns of den use by San Joaquin kit foxes. Journal of Wildlife Management 62:373-379.

Laundré, J. W. and B. L. Keller. 1981. Home-range use by coyotes in Idaho. Animal Behaviour 29: 449-461.

Lewis, J. C., K. L. Sallee, and R. T. Golightly. 1993. Introduced red fox in California. California Department of Fish and Game, Nongame Bird and Mammal Section Report 93-10, Sacramento, California. 70 pp.

Litvaitis, J. A., K. Titus, and E. M. Anderson. 1996. Measuring vertebrate use of terrestrial habitats and foods in Research and management techniques for wildlife and habitats.

Pages 254-274 in H. S. Mosby, R. H. Giles, Jr., S. D. Schemnitz, and T. A. Bookhout, editors. Research and management techniques for wildlife and habitats. The Wildlife Society, Bethesda, Maryland.

Lucherini, M., S. Lovari, and G. Crema. 1995. Habitat use and ranging behaviour of the red fox (Vulpes vulpes) in a Mediterranean rural area: is shelter availability a key factor? Journal of Zoology 237:577-591.

Macdonald, D. W. 1983. The ecology of carnivore social behavior. Nature 301:379-384. 64 Matlack, R. S., P. S. Gipson, and D. W. Kaufman. 2000. The swift fox in rangeland and cropland in western Kansas: relative abundance, mortality, and body size. Southwestern Naturalist 45:221-225.

McGrew, J. C. 1979. Vulpes macrotis. Pages 1-6 in Virginia Hayssen, editor. Mammalian species. American Society of Mammalogists, Northampton, Massachusetts.

Mohr, C. O. 1947. Table of equivalent populations of North American small mammals. American Midland Naturalist 37:233-249.

Morrell, S. 1971. The life history of the San Joaquin kit fox. Master’s Thesis. Department of Biological Sciences, University of California, Santa Barbara, California. 67 pp.

Morrell, S. 1972. Life history of the San Joaquin kit fox. California Fish and Game 58:162-174.

Morrell, S. 1975. San Joaquin kit fox distribution and abundance in 1975. California Department of Fish and Game, Wildlife Management Branch Administration Report Number 75-3. 27 pp.

Murphy, T. D. 1992. Kit fox distribution and activity in Bakersfield, California. Page 380 in D. F.

Williams, S. Byrne, and T. A. Rado, editors. Endangered and sensitive species of the San Joaquin Valley, California. California Energy Commission, Sacramento, California. (abstract only).

Ng, S. J., J. W. Dole, R. M. Sauvajot, S. P. D. Riley, and T. J. Valone. 2004. Use of highway undercrossings by wildlife in southern California. Biological Conservation 115:499-507.

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration / National Weather Service. 1997. Local climatological data - Meadows Field Weather Station. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Climatic Data Center, Asheville, North Carolina.

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration / National Weather Service. 1998. Local climatological data - Meadows Field Weather Station. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Climatic Data Center, Asheville, North Carolina.

Noss, R. F., M. A. O’Connell, and D. D. Murphy. 1997. Species and habitats. Pages 1-18 in R. F.

Noss, M. A. O’Connell, and D. D. Murphy, editors. The science of conservation planning: habitat conservation under the Endangered Species Act. Island Press, Washington, D. C.

Odum, E. P. and E. J. Kuenzler. 1955. Measurement of territory and home range size in birds.

Auk 72:128-137.
65 Olson, T. L. and F. G. Lindzey. 2002. Swift fox survival and production in southeastern Wyoming. Journal of Mammalogy 83:199-206.

O’Neal, G. T., J. T. Flinders, and W. P. Clary. 1987. Behavioral ecology of the Nevada kit fox (Vulpes macrotis nevadensis) on a managed desert rangeland. Pages 443-481 in H. H.

Genoways, editor. Current mammalogy. Volume 1. Plenum Press, New York, New York.

Orians, G. H. and J. F. Wittenberger. 1991. Spatial and temporal scales in habitat selection.

American Naturalist 137:S29-S49.

Ozoga, J. J. and E. M. Harger. 1966. Winter activities and feeding habits of northern Michigan coyotes. Journal of Wildlife Management 30:809-818.

Pulliam, H. R. 1988. Sources, sinks, and population regulation. American Naturalist 132:652-661.

Quinn, T. 1995. Using public sighting information to investigate coyote use of urban habitat.

Journal of Wildlife Management 59:238-245.

Ralls, K. and P. J. White. 1995. Predation on San Joaquin kit foxes by larger canids. Journal of Mammalogy 76:723-729.

Read, J. and Z. Bowen. 2001. Population dynamics, diet and aspects of the biology of feral cats and foxes in arid South Australia. Wildlife Research 28:195-203.

Reese, E. A., W. G. Standley, and W. H. Berry. 1992. Habitat, soils, and den use by San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes velox macrotis) at Camp Roberts Army National Guard Training Site, California. United States Department of Energy, Topical Report, EG&G/EM Santa Barbara Operations Report No. EGG 10617-2156, Santa Barbara, California. 36 pp.

Romsos, J. S. 1998. Home range, habitat use, and movements of coyotes in a southern California urban environment. Master’s Thesis. Department of Wildlife, Humboldt State University, Arcata, California. 60 pp.

Rosatte, R. C., M. J. Power, and C. D. MacInnes. 1991. Ecology of urban skunks, raccoons, and foxes in metropolitan Toronto. Pages 31-38 in L. W. Adams and D. L. Leedy, editors.

Wildlife conservation in metropolitan environments. National Institute for Urban Wildlife, Symposium Series 2, Columbia, Maryland.

Sallee, K. L. 1998. Spatial land use of urban red fox. Master’s Thesis. Department of Wildlife, Humboldt State University, Arcata, California. 70 pp.

Salvatori, V., G. Vaglio-Laurin, P. L. Meserve, L. Boitani, and A. Campanella. 1999. Spatial organization, activity, and social interactions of culpeo foxes (Pseudalopex culpaeus) in north-central Chile. Journal of Mammalogy 80:980-985.
66 Samuel, M. D., D. J. Pierce, and E. O. Garton. 1985. Identifying areas of concentrated use within the home range. Journal of Animal Ecology 54:711-719.

Samuel, M. D. and K. P. Kenow. 1992. Evaluating habitat selection with radio-telemetry triangulation error. Journal of Wildlife Management 56:725-734.

San Joaquin Valley Biological Technical Committee. 1993. A biological framework for natural lands and endangered species in the southern San Joaquin Valley. San Joaquin Valley Biological Technical Committee, Turlock, California. 26 pp.

Seaman, D. E. and R. A. Powell. 1996. An evaluation of the accuracy of kernel density estimators for home range analysis. Ecology 77:2075-2085.

Sovada, M. A., C. C. Roy, J. B. Bright, and J. R. Gillis. 1998. Causes and rates of mortality of swift foxes in western Kansas. Journal of Wildlife Management 62:1300-1306.

Spiegel, L. K. 1996. Studies of San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed areas: an overview. Pages 1-14 in L. K. Spiegel, editor. Studies of the San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed areas. California Energy Commission, Environmental Protection Office, Sacramento, California.

Spiegel, L. K. and M. Bradbury. 1992. Home range characteristics of the San Joaquin kit fox in western Kern County, California. Transactions of the Western Section Wildlife Society 28:83-92.

Spiegel, L. K., T. C. Dao, and M. Tom. 1996. Characteristics of San Joaquin kit fox dens at oil-developed and undeveloped sites in southwestern Kern County, California. Pages 15-38 in L. K. Spiegel, editor. Studies of the San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed areas, California Energy Commission, Environmental Protection Office, Sacramento, California.

Spiegel, L. K. and M. Disney. 1996. Mortality sources and survival rates of San Joaquin kit fox in oil-developed and undeveloped lands of southwestern Kern County, California. Pages 71- 91 in L. K. Spiegel, editor. Studies of the San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed areas, California Energy Commission, Environmental Protection Office, Sacramento, California.

Spiegel, L. K. and J. Tom. 1996. Reproduction of San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed habitats of Kern County, California. Pages 53-69 in L. K. Spiegel, editor.

Studies of the San Joaquin kit fox in undeveloped and oil-developed areas, California Energy Commission, Environmental Protection Office, Sacramento, California.

Springer, J. T. 1979. Some sources of bias and sampling error in radio triangulation. Journal of Wildlife Management 43:926-935.
67 Stafford, R. W. and T. D. Murphy. 1992. Use of water sumps as denning sites for San Joaquin kit fox. Page 383 in D. F. Williams, S. Byrne, and T. A. Rado, editors. Endangered and sensitive species of the San Joaquin Valley, California. California Energy Commission, Sacramento, California. (abstract only).

Standley, W. G., W. H. Berry, T. P. O'Farrell, and T. T. Kato. 1992. Mortality of San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes velox macrotis) at Camp Roberts Army National Guard Training Site, California. United States Department of Energy, Topical Report, EG&G/EM Santa Barbara Operations Report No. EGG 10617-2157, Santa Barbara, California. 19 pp.

State of California, Department of Finance. 2002. Revised Historical City, County, and State Population Estimates, 1991-2000, with 1990 and 2000 Census Counts. State of California, Department of Finance, Sacramento, California.

Storlie, J. T. 1998. Sources of mortality, survivorship, and dispersal of juvenile San Joaquin kit foxes in an urban environment. Senior Thesis. Department of Wildlife, Humboldt State University, Arcata, California. 21 pp.

United States Department of the Interior. 1967. Federal Register 32, 4001.

United States Fish and Wildlife Service. 1983. San Joaquin kit fox recovery plan. United States Fish and Wildlife Service, California/Nevada Operations Office, Portland, Oregon. 84 pp.

United States Fish and Wildlife Service. 1998. Recovery plan for upland species of the San Joaquin Valley, California. United States Fish and Wildlife Service, California/Nevada Operations Office, Portland, Oregon. 319 pp.

United States Geological Survey. 1981. Geographic Names Information System (GNIS). United States Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia.

Van Horne, B. 1983. Density as a misleading indicator of habitat quality. Journal of Wildlife Management 47:893-901.

Voight, D. R. and D. W. Macdonald. 1984. Variation in the spatial and social behaviour of the red fox, Vulpes vulpes. Acta Zoologica Fennica 171:261-265.

Wandeler, P., S. M. Funk, C. R. Largiade’r, S. Gloor, and U. Breitenmoser. 2003. The city-fox phenomenon: genetic consequences of a recent colonization of urban habitat. Molecular Ecology 12: 647-656.

Warrick, G. D. and B. L. Cypher. 1998. Factors affecting the spatial distribution of a kit fox population. Journal of Wildlife Management 62: 707-717. -
68 Whitaker, Jr., J. O. 1998. National Audubon Society field guide to North American mammals. 2nd edition. Alfred A. Knopf, Inc. New York, New York.

White, G. C. and R. A. Garrott. 1990. Analysis of wildlife radio-tracking data. Academic Press, Inc. San Diego, California.

White, G. C. and R. A. Garrott. 1997. Factors regulating kit fox populations. Canadian Journal of Zoology 75:1982-1988.

White, P. J. and K. Ralls. 1993. Reproduction and spacing patterns of kit foxes relative to changing prey availability. Journal of Wildlife Management 57:861-867.

White, P. J., K. Ralls, and D. B. Siniff. 2000. Nocturnal encounters between kit foxes. Journal of Mammalogy 81:456-461.

Wiens, J. A. 1973. Pattern and process in grassland bird communities. Ecological Monographs 43:237-270.

Winer, B. J., D. R. Brown, and K. M. Michels. 1991. Statistical Principles in Experimental Design, 3rd edition. McGraw-Hill, Inc. New York, New York.

Woodruff, R. A. and B. L. Keller. 1982. Dispersal, daily activity, and home range of coyotes in southeastern Idaho. Northwest Science 56:199-207.

Worton, B. J. 1989. Kernel methods for estimating the utilization distribution in home-range studies. Ecology 70:164-168.

Zoellick, B. W., C. E. Harris, B. T. Kelly, T. P. O'Farrell, T. T. Kato, and M. E. Koopman. 2002.

Movements and home range of San Joaquin kit foxes (Vulpes macrotis mutica) relative to oil-field development. Western North American Naturalist 62:151-159.

Zoellick, B. W., T. P. O'Farrell, and T. T. Kato. 1987. Movements and home range of San Joaquin kit foxes on the Naval Petroleum Reserves, Kern County, California. United States Department of Energy, Topical Report, EG&G/EM Santa Barbara Operations Report No. EGG 10282-2184, Santa Barbara, California. 38 pp.

Zoellick, B. W., N. S. Smith, and R. S. Henry. 1989. Habitat use and movements of desert kit foxes in western Arizona. Journal of Wildlife Management 53:955-961. 69 Appendix A. Sites of live-captured kit foxes, domestic cats, and opossums between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California.

Species captured
Habitat type Trap-nights Kit foxes Domestic cats Opossums Residential 5 1 0 0
Commercial 11 6 2 0
Industrial 41 13 5 0
Linear 84 19 3 1
Manicured open 53 21 0 0
Open 54 23 3 0
Sump 327 128 33 2
Total 575 211a46 3
a
Includes recaptures but excludes 32 captures which occurred when the number of traps in use was not recorded.

Appendix B. Kit fox location data and estimates for home range size, core area size, and time to independence for 28 radio were monitored between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California.

Kit Fox Locations Home Range (km2)
Eartag Sex Sequential Daily Independent 100% MCP a 95% Fixed Kernel 50% Fixed Kernel
Core Area (km2) Ti
3468 F - 166 149 1.17 0.41 0.05
5468 F 190 193 166 1.36 0.94 0.08
5702 F 190 196 184 0.72 0.40 0.06
5703bF - 8 7 - - -
5705 F - 183 163 2.71 2.70 0.20
5708 F 133 164 151 1.89 1.67 0.32
5713 F - 162 131 2.19 1.59 0.28
5723 F - 190 161 0.93 0.41 0.02
5741 F 166 181 174 1.32 0.66 0.08
5742 F - 213 177 2.69 2.78 0.43
5747 F 165 187 173 0.38 0.28 0.04
5752 F - 182 155 0.59 0.52 0.03
70 Appendix B. Kit fox location data and estimates for home range size, core area size, and time to independence for 28 radio were monitored between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California (continued).

Kit Fox Locations Home Range (km2)
Eartag Sex Sequential Daily Independent 100% MCP a 95% Fixed Kernel 50% Fixed Kernel
Core Area (km2) Ti
5753 F - 198 162 1.07 0.67 0.06
5754 F - 79 64 1.63 2.75 0.32
5756 F - 189 164 0.36 0.35 0.07
5674 M 167 181 168 3.33 2.69 0.46
5701 M - 206 178 0.86 0.22 0.02
5704 M 230 203 193 2.16 2.40 0.39
5707 M - 179 160 2.70 2.50 0.50
5710 M 187 153 145 1.21 0.37 0.05
5711 M - 180 164 2.60 0.15 0.05
5712 M - 167 137 1.90 1.30 0.11
5721 M - 185 158 2.02 1.70 0.27
Appendix B. Kit fox location data and estimates for home range size, core area size, and time to independence for 28 radio were monitored between May 1997 and January 1998 in Bakersfield, California (continued).

Kit Fox Locations Home Range (km2)
Eartag Sex Sequential Daily Independent 100% MCP a 95% Fixed Kernel 50% Fixed Kernel
Core Area (km2) Ti
5743 M 219 186 165 2.13 1.14 0.09
5744 M - 190 156 2.72 2.27 0.22
5746 M - 176 147 0.31 0.04 0.01
5755 M 163 168 154 1.11 0.30 0.03
5757 M - 159 143 4.49c15.58d4.00d
Total 1810 4824 4249 - - -
Mean 181 172.3 151.75 1.72 1.2 0.16
SE 9.04 7.62 6.89 0.19 0.19 0.03
aMinimum convex polygon.
b
Located too few times to be included in the home range and habitat use analyses. c
Sum of two distinct home ranges in the southeastern (3.19 km2) and northwestern (1.31 km2 ) parts of the study area, appr
apart.
d Outlier that was excluded from calculation of x¯ + 1 SE.

Appendix C. Weight, hind foot, and ear measurements for captured adult, subadult, and pup kit foxes in Bakersfield, Calif 1997 and January 1998.

Male Female
Body Measurement Age n x¯ SE n x¯ SE Statistica
p
Weight (kg) Adult 29 2.47 0.05 32 2.16 0.03 t = -5.53 <0.001 Subadult 7 2.09 0.11 6 1.87 0.14 t = -1.29 0.22
Pup 20 1.73 0.04 13 1.44 0.05 t = -4.25 <0.001
Hind foot (mm) Adult 27 125.5 1.0 31 119.8 0.8 t = -4.4 <0.001 Subadult 6 121 1.2 5 118.4 0.9 t = -1.67 0.13
Pup 18 121 1.2 9 112.2 1.4 t = -4.36 <0.001
Ear from notchb (mm) Adult 28 81.4 0.6 31 78.6 0.7 z = 3.28 <0.001 Subadult 6 82.5 0.6 5 78.4 1.3 t = -3.04 0.007
Pup 19 80.1 0.8 10 75.3 1.1 t = -3.65 <0.001
Ear from rearc (mm) Adult 28 84.4 0.7 31 81.5 0.7 t = -2.81 0.002 Subadult 6 84.8 1.1 5 81.2 2.2 t = -1.56 0.15
Pup 19 80.8 0.8 10 77.1 1.1 t = -2.6 0.007
a
I used a 2-sample t-test to determine if means differed between the sexes. For data that was not normally distributed, I used a Mann-Whitney U-test to determine if medians differed between the sexes. b
Tip of ear to notch at anterior base.
c
Tip of ear to posterior base.
73 74
Appendix D. Area-observation curves using the 100% minimum convex polygon home range for 27 kit foxes in Bakersfield, California from May 1997 to January 1998.

Females
0 0.5
1 1.5
2 2.5
3 3.5
4 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180
Home Range Area (km
2 )
3468 5468 5702 5705
5708 5713 5723 5741
5742 5747 5752 5753
5754 5756
Males
0 2
4 6
8 10
12 14
16 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200
Number of Locations
Home Range Area (km
2 )
5674 5701 5704
5707 5710 5711
5712 5721 5743
5744 5746 5755
5757
I M
* -h.
.. ~ .. • ------ --+--
---+---
--+-
~
---e--
--a--
□
0 ---¼- ---¼-
--+--
---¾- ---+-
----- ----
Appendix E. The percentage of all radiocollared kit fox daily locations (n = 4,824) and passing vehicles documented in lin hour in Bakersfield, California from September 1997 to January 1998. 0 2
4 6
8 10
12 14
16 1500-15591600-16591700-17591800-18591900-19592000-20592100-21592200-22592300-23590000-00590100-01590200-02590300-03590400-04590500-05590600-06590700-07590800-08590900 0959
Time
Percent
Kit Fox Locations in Linear Hab
Vehicles Passing on Nearest Roa
75 1~_-·
-.. _
-♦- ,♦---♦---,
Letter P2
From:

To:

Subject:

Date:

James Davis
Ashley Knjght
Fw: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project - Comments on Draft Environmental Impact Report Monday, August 24, 2026 2:10:30 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking links, especially from unknown senders.

Hi Ashley,
I should have included a delivery confirmation but can you let me know that you've received the email below?
Thank you,
James Davis
From: James Davis <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, August 24, 2026 2:08 PM
To: Ashley Knight <[email protected]>
Subject: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project - Comments on Draft Environmental Impact Report
Ashely,
Please accept these comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Study that was prepared for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project.

Trip Generation and Traffic Study for the future Costco Standalone Gas Facility with 40 fueUng positions and carwash. Costco will be building a massive gas facility with 20 pumps and 40 fueling positions. The studies that were completed do not look consistent with similar studies that have been done for much smaller gas stations. For example, Fastrip had submitted a site plan to the City of Bakersfield to approve two driveway locations on Rosedale Highway for a future Fastrip gas station and convenience store located at the SEC of Rosedale and Calloway. The City of Bakersfield Public Works responded that Fastrip would only be allowed one driveway and would be required to install a 60-foot storage lane and install a Type A, ST3 driveway on the very east end of the property. This requirement would mean that Fastirp would lose almost 13 feet of property along Rosedale Highway. In addition, the single driveway and storage lane resulted in Fastrip losing parking spaces and significantly impacted onsite circulation. It should also be noted that there is a recorded agreement dated August 16, 2014 with the City of Bakersfield that stipulates that the City of Bakersfield will install 2 driveways along Rosedale highway at the corner of Rosedale and Calloway.

The Trip Generation Analysis and Traffic Study and the necessary mitigation measures appear to be inconsistent with how they have been applied to other shopping center projects in Bakersfield, CA. In addition, the Costco Fuel Facility Database was used in these studies, yet that database only provides data for Costco Fuel Facilities that are part of a Costco Warehouse. In addition, it appears that the data used was from Costco and not from an independent study.

It is not clear if the fueling facility will have a Costco employee working there and assisting customers. In addition, it is not clear what the hours of operation will be at this specific facility. Will it be open 24 hours per day or limited to specific operational hours?
Finally, was this particular section of the shopping center used for the Trip Generation Analysis and Traffic Study? Costco gas is known to have customers 5 or 6 cars deep, waiting for a fueling position to open up. Was this taken into consideration in the Traffic Study that this particular section of the shopping center will experience significant onsite traffic issues? Is it possible that cars will be backing up on Rosedale Highway? If so, it would seem reasonable to require a dedicated right turn lane with 60 to 80 feet of storage.

Thank you,
James Davis
Vice President of Real Estate
Jaco Oil Company
0 : 661-393-7000
PO Box 82515 I Bakersfield I CA 93308
ia [email protected]

Appendix B
Revised General Biological Assessment

Kim/ey >» Horn

GENERAL BIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
FOR

ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER
368-010-05

CITY OF BAKERSFIELD

KERN COUNTY,

CALIFORNIA
Prepared By:

Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, California 92530
(909) 772-9009
Prepared for:

Roque Nino
City of Bakersfield
1715 Chester Avenue
UPDATED: SEPTEMBER 2026
Hernandez
Environmental
Services
APN 368-101-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | i September November 20265
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................................................i

1.0 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................1

1.1 PROJECT LOCATION...........................................................................................................1

1.2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION.....................................................................................................1

2.0 METHODOLOGY..........................................................................................................................2

2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW.......................................................................................................2

2.1.1 Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan .............................................. 2

2.2 FIELD SURVEY ...................................................................................................................2

3.0 RESULTS ........................................................................................................................................3

3.1 ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING ............................................................................................3

3.2 SOILS .....................................................................................................................................3

3.3 HABITAT COMMUNITIES ..................................................................................................4

3.3.1 Disturbed Ruderal Habitat ....................................................................................... 4

3.4 THREATENED, ENDANGERED, AND SENSITIVE SPECIES......................................4

3.4.1 Threatened, Endangered, and Sensitive Plants........................................................ 4

3.4.2 Threatened, Endangered, and Sensitive Wildlife..................................................... 6

3.5 CRITICAL HABITATS ........................................................................................................9

3.6 NESTING BIRDS.................................................................................................................9

3.7 WILDLIFE MOVEMENT CORRIDORS............................................................................9

3.8 STATE AND FEDERAL JURISDICTIONAL STREAMS..................................................10

4.0 PROJECT IMPACTS.................................................................................................................10

4.1 IMPACTS TO HABITAT TYPES ......................................................................................10

4.2 IMPACTS TO STATE OR FEDERALLY LISTED PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES OR CNPS LISTED PLANTS..........................................................................................................................10

4.2.1 Impacts to State or Federally Listed and CNPS Listed Plants........................................10

4.3 IMPACTS TO CRITICAL HABITAT ..................................................................................10

4.4 IMPACTS TO NESTING BIRDS ......................................................................................10

4.5 IMPACTS TO STATE OR FEDERAL STREAMS............................................................ 11

5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS...............................................................................................................11

5.1 BURROWING OWLS.......................................................................................................................11

5.2 NESTING BIRDS ................................................................................................................12

6.0 CERTIFICATION......................................................................................................................15

7.0 REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................16 APN 368-101-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | ii September November 20265
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

FIGURES
Figure 1 – Location Map
Figure 2 – Vicinity Map
Figure 3 – Project Plan
Figure 4 – Habitat Map
Figure 5 – Impact Map

APPENDICES
Appendix A – Species List
Appendix B – Presence/Absence List
Appendix C – Site Photographs
Appendix D – Soils Map
Appendix E – Senior Biologist Resume
APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 1 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

1.0 INTRODUCTION
Hernandez Environmental Services (HES) was retained by Placeworks to perform a General Biological Assessment (GBA) on a 46.16-acre site comprised of the northern portion of Assessor Parcel Number (APN) 368-010-05. The purpose of the GBA is to document the presence/absence of sensitive resources that may be present on the site and 500-foot buffer around the site, to document existing habitats, and generally address biological questions that may be needed for project approval. This GBA will present the results obtained from the November 13, 2025, field survey and will provide recommendations that may be needed to mitigate potential biological impacts from project activities.

This updated September 2026 GBA updates is in response to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), Brian L. Cypher and Sierra Club. The revision corrects there was no San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) sightings, reevaluates the November 13, 2025, general biological assessment and adds species-specific impact conclusions and enforceable avoidance, minimization, mitigation and authorization measures. HES was contracted to prepare only a General Biological Assessment; protocol-level focused surveys were not included in the original findings. Portions of the site were inaccessible due to fencing and were evaluated from accessible vantage points using binoculars. HES recognizes that Crotch’s bumble bee habitat cannot be conclusively determined during a non-blooming survey period and that SJKF may use disturbed urban areas for movement and denning. Accordingly, the revised analysis incorporates CDFW’s comments and includes appropriate surveys, avoidance measures, and agency coordination. These limitations and protective measures are reflected in the revised conclusions and recommendations.

1.1 PROJECT LOCATION
The proposed Project site is located south of Rosedale Highway, west of El Toro Viejo Road, east of Coffee Road, and north of BNSF Main Line, in the City of Bakersfield, Kern County, California (Figures 1 and 2). Specifically, the project site is located within Section 16, Township 29 South, Range 27 East, San Bernardino Base Meridian (SBBM), on the Oildale United States Geological Survey (USGS) 7.5-minute topographic quadrangles. The Project site center point latitude and longitude are 35°26’56.2733” North and 119°05’39.3122” West.

1.2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The proposed project involves the construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace (“Project”) that will encompass a total of approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space (Figure 3). The proposed project includes restaurants, car wash, health club, medical office, gas APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 2 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
station, public storage, convenience store, and associated parking lots/sidewalks and landscaping.

Outside of the project boundary, roadside improvements and proposed traffic signal will be developed, impacting Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road. The proposed project is anticipated to result in impacts to the entire 46.16-acre project site.

2.0 METHODOLOGY

2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW
HES conducted a literature review and reviewed aerial photographs and topographic maps of the project location and surrounding areas. The following USGS quads were used to query the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB): Oildale, Rosedale, Famoso, North of Oildale, Knob Hill, Oil Center, Lamont, Gosford, and Stevens. The United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) County Endangered Species Lists, and CNPS's rare plant lists were reviewed to obtain species information for the project area.

2.1.1 Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan As of January 1, 2023, the proposed project site is currently not within any state or federal Habitat Conservation Plans. The Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan (MBHCP) and associated Incidental Take Permit (ITP) expired on January 1, 2023. The City will no longer act as a permittee to projects that were approved/permitted after Friday, December 30, 2022. Urban development permits issued after the 2023 expiration date will be required to comply directly with requests of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW).

The MBHCP is expired and Aany project approved prior to January 1, 2023 was required to be under the MBHCP and associated ITP until the expiration date of June 1, 2023. To ensure take of covered species does not occur after the expiration date, fees were required to be paid no later than January 1, 2023 and all covered activities were required to be completed by the MBHCP expiration date of June 1, 2023.

2.2 FIELD SURVEY
On November 13, 2025, HES conducted a field survey of the approximate 46.16-acre project site and a buffer area around the project site, which is described below. Ambient temperature at 12:00 PM was 82° Fahrenheit, cloudy, with winds ranging from 0 to 12 miles per hour from the south.

The purpose of the field survey was to document the existing habitat conditions, obtain plant and animal species information, view the surrounding uses, assess the potential for state and federal waters, assess the potential for wildlife movement corridors, and assess for the presence of critical habitat constituent elements.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 3 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
The entire 46.16-acre project site, and a buffer area around the site was surveyed (refer to Figure 1 for the surveyed area and buffer). As shown in Figure 1, the buffer areas surveyed included accessible areas (areas that were not fended off by security fencing) that abut the project site to the south and west. The width of the buffer areas varies as shown in Figure 1 but extended to a maximum of 500 feet. Linear transects approximately 50 feet apart were walked for 100 percent coverage. All species observed were recorded and Global Positioning System (GPS) way points were taken to delineate specific habitat types, species locations, state or federal waters, or any other information that would be useful for the assessment of the project site. A comprehensive list of all plant and wildlife species that were detected during the field survey within the project site is included in Appendix A. Sensitive plant and wildlife species with the potential to occur within the project area are listed in Appendix B. Representative site photographs were taken and are included within Appendix C.

3.0 RESULTS

3.1 ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING
The project site consists primarily of non-vegetation and disturbed ruderal areas. The project site is bordered by various developments including commercial and residential uses to the west, a Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) electric substation, railroad tracks and vacant land to the south, a commercial retail center to the north, and commercial retail uses and vacant land to the east. The project site is relatively flat with elevations on the project site ranging from 377 feet above mean sea level (AMSL) to 407 feet AMSL.

The site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for majority of species, but do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) population and recent or historical occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land. The open site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.

3.2 SOILS
According to the USDA Web Soil Survey, soils at the project site are classified as Granoso loamy sand (125), 0 to 2 percent slopes and water (257) (Appendix D).

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 4 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

3.3 HABITAT COMMUNITIES
One habitat type was observed within the approximately 46.16-acre project site, including 46.16 acres of disturbed ruderal habitat (Figure 4).

3.3.1 Disturbed Ruderal Habitat
Approximately 46.16 acres of disturbed ruderal habitat occur within the project site with paved sidewalks along the edges. These areas primarily consist of unvegetated roadways and some areas with little to no vegetation. If vegetation is present, the dominant species are downy chess (Bromus tectorum), and tumbleweed (Salsola tragus). Other plant species observed include red brome (Bromus rubens), California croton (Croton californicus), and silverleaf nightshade (Solanum elaeagnifolium).

3.4 THREATENED, ENDANGERED, AND SENSITIVE SPECIES
A total of eighteen sensitive species of plants and thirty sensitive species of animals has the potential to occur on or within the vicinity of the project location. These include those species listed or candidates for listing by the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) and California Native Plant Society (CNPS). All habitats utilized by these species was evaluated during the site visit and a determination has been made for the presence or probability of presence in this report. This section will address those species listed as Candidate, Rare, Threatened, or Endangered under the state and federal Endangered Species laws or directed to be evaluated under other state, county, or municipal regulations. Other special status species will be reported in Appendix B.

3.4.1 Threatened, Endangered, and Sensitive Plants
A total of twelve plant species is listed as state and/or federal Threatened, Endangered, Candidate, or 1B.1 listed plants on the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. The following is a description of these species:

Horn’s Milk-Vetch
Horn’s milk-vetch (Astragalus hornii var. hornii) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS rare plant inventory.

It is typically found in alkali playa, meadow, seep, and wetland habitats. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Bakersfield smallscale
Bakersfield smallscale (Atriplex tularensis) is state Endangered and ranked 1A in the CNPS rare plant inventory. This species is generally found in chenopod scrub and alkali seep habitats. It is APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 5 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
typically found historically in valley sink scrub or with saltgrass. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

California jewelflower
Payson’s jewelflower (Caulanthus californicus) is a federally Endangered, state Endangered species and is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant inventory. It is found frequently in chenopod scrub, valley and foothill grassland, pinyon, and juniper woodland. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Hispid salty bird's-beak
Hispid salty bird's-beak (Chloropyron molle ssp. hispidum) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS rare plant inventory. This species is generally found in meadows and seeps, playas, valley and foothill grassland. Its habitat includes damp alkaline soils, especially in alkaline meadows and alkali sinks with Distichlis. There is no suitable habitat present on the project site. This species is not present.

Kern mallow
Kern mallow (Eremalche parryi ssp. kernensis) is a federally Endangered species and ranked 1B.2 in the CNPS rare plant inventory. It is found on granitic soils, steep hillsides, and mesic sites. Its habitat includes chaparral and coastal scrub. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Tejon poppy
Tejon poppy (Eschscholzia lemmonii ssp. kernensis) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is generally found in Joshua tree woodland and Mojavean Desert scrub.

Its habitat includes sandy soils, washes and roadcuts. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Comanche point layia
Comanche point layia (Layia leucopappa) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is generally found in chenopod scrub, valley and foothill grassland. Its habitat includes dry hills in white-grey clay soils, often with weedy grasses. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

San Joaquin woollythreads
San Joaquin woollythreads (Monolopia congdonii) is a federally Endangered species and ranked 1B.2 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is typically found in Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill grassland. Its habitat includes alkaline or loamy plains; sandy soils, often with grasses APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 6 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
and within chenopod scrub. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Piute Mountains navarretia
Piute Mountains navarretia (Navarretia setiloba) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory.

This species is typically found in Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill grassland. Its habitat includes red clay soils, or on gravelly loam. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Bakersfield cactus
Bakersfield cactus (Opuntia basilaris var. treleasei) is a federally Endangered, state Endangered species and ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is typically found in chenopod scrub, valley and foothill grassland, cismontane woodland. Its habitat includes Coarse or cobbly well-drained granitic sand on bluffs, low hills, and flats, within grassland. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Oil neststraw
Oil neststraw (Stylocline citroleum) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is typically found in chenopod scrub, coastal scrub, valley and foothill grassland. Its habitat includes flats, clay soils in oil-producing areas. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Mason's neststraw
Mason's neststraw (Stylocline masonii) is ranked 1B.1 in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory. This species is typically found in chenopod scrub, pinyon and juniper woodland. Its habitat includes sandy washes. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

3.4.2 Threatened, Endangered, and Sensitive Wildlife
A total of eleven wildlife species are listed as state and/or federal Threatened, Endangered, or Candidate species. Sensitive species which have a potential to occur will also be discussed in this section. All sensitive species within a 5-mile radius of project area were reviewed and a complete list of those species are discussed in in Appendix B.

Tricolored blackbird
Tricolored blackbird (Agelaius tricolor) is a state listed Candidate Endangered species and listed by the CDFW as a Species of Special Concern. Its habitat includes freshwater marsh, marsh and swamp,and wetland. This species is largely endemic to California and is most numerous in and around the Central Valley. This species requires open accessible water, protected nesting substrate, APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 7 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
and foraging area with insect prey within a few kilometers of the colony. There is no habitat for this species on the project site. This species is not present.

Nelson's (San Joaquin) antelope squirrel
Nelson's (San Joaquin) antelope squirrel (Ammospermophilus nelsoni) is a state Threatened species. The most favorable breeding habitat for this species consists of Western San Joaquin Valley from 200-1200 ft elevation on dry, sparsely vegetated loam soils. Its habitat includes widely scattered shrubs, forbs, and grasses in broken terrain with gullies and washes. There is no habitat for this species on the project site. This species is not present.

Crotch bumble bee
Crotch bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) is a state Candidate Endangered species. It is found in coastal California east to the Sierra-Cascade crest and south into Mexico. This species food plant genera include Antirrhinum, Phacelia, Clarkia, Dendromecon, Eschscholzia, and Eriogonum.

There is no suitable habitat for this species present on the project site. This species is not present.

No plant species within the general area identified by CDFW as preferred Crotch’s bumble bee foraging plants or suitable overwintering habitat were observed in the survey. Since the survey occurred outside the primary blooming and detection period, the presence or absence of Crotch’s bumble bee cannot be conclusively determined. A habitat assessment during the appropriate blooming period is recommended if construction occurs during that time. This species has the potential to be present.

Swainson’s hawk
Swainson’s hawk (Buteo swainsoni) is a state listed Threatened species. This species favors open grasslands for foraging but also occurs in agricultural settings. It relies on scattered stands of trees near agricultural fields and grasslands for nesting sites. Its habitats include great basin grassland, riparian forest, riparian woodland, and valley and foothill grassland. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species. This species is not present. CDFW identified potentially suitable foraging land on and near the project and potential nesting/perching substrates in the vicinity and noted that the species may forage many miles from a nest. No active nest was documented in the GBA. There is limited habitat for this species, however a pre-con nesting bird survey recommend outside the nesting bird period as raptors are known to have longer/delayed nesting seasons. This species is not expected to nest on the project site but has the potential to forage..

Monarch - California overwintering population
Monarch - California overwintering population (Danaus plexippus pop. 1) is a federally listed Candidate Species. It is found in roosts located in wind-protected tree groves (eucalyptus, Monterey pine, cypress), with nectar and water sources nearby. The project site does not contain APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 8 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
suitable habitat for this species. This species is not present.

Valley elderberry longhorn beetle
Valley elderberry longhorn beetle (Desmocerus californicus dimorphus) is a state listed Threatened species. This species is typically found in only in the Central Valley of California, in association with blue elderberry (Sambucus mexicana). Prefers to lay eggs in elderberries 2-8 inches in diameter; some preference shown for "stressed" elderberries. No habitat for this species is present on the project site. This species is not present.

Tipton kangaroo rat
Tipton kangaroo rat (Dipodomys nitratoides nitratoides) is a federally Endangered and state Endangered species. It is found in saltbrush scrub and sink scrub communities in the Tulare Lake Basin of the southern San Joaquin Valley. Its habitat needs soft friable soils which escape seasonal flooding. Digs burrows in elevated soil mounds at bases of shrubs. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species. This species is not present.

Blunt-nosed leopard lizard
Blunt-nosed leopard lizard (Gambelia sila) is a federally Endangered and state Endangered species. This species is found in sparsely vegetated alkali and desert scrub habitats, in areas of low topographic relief. This species seeks cover in mammal burrows, under shrubs or structures such as fence posts; they do not excavate their own burrows. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species. This species is not present.

Buena Vista Lake ornate shrew
Buena Vista Lake ornate shrew (Sorex ornatus relictus) is a federally listed Threatened species and a CDFW Species of Special Concern. Its habitat includes marshlands and riparian areas in the Tulare Basin. It is most commonly prefers moist soil. Uses stumps, logs and litter for cover. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species. This species is not present.

San Joaquin kit fox
San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica) is a federally Endangered and state Threatened species. It is found in annual grasslands or grassy open stages with scattered shrubby vegetation.

It needs loose-textured sandy soils for burrowing, and suitable prey base. The project is within the species urban range and known to utilize ruderal and disturbed habitat. This species has the potential to occur and recommendations are written below in Section 5.4.This species is not present.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 9 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
Western Burrowing Owl
Western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) was approved by the California Fish and Game Commission as a candidate species for listing under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) on October 10, 2024, and therefore receives the same legal protection afforded to state-listed threatened and endangered species (Fish & G. Code §§ 2074.2 and 2085). Burrowing owls inhabit open grasslands and desert scrublands containing small mammal burrows, which are required for nesting and cover, and may also forage in agricultural lands. The project site does not contain suitable habitat for this species, and the species is not present. However, because burrowing owls may become established on disturbed sites prior to construction, a pre-construction burrowing owl survey is recommended within 30 days prior to the start of ground-disturbing activities. If burrowing owls are detected, appropriate avoidance and minimization measures, including no-disturbance buffers and monitoring, shall be implemented in consultation with (CDFW), as described in Section 5.0.

3.5 CRITICAL HABITATS
The proposed project site is not located within any designated federal critical habitat.

3.6 NESTING BIRDS
Migratory non-game native bird species are protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act.

Additionally, Sections 3503, 3503.5, and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code prohibit take of all birds and their active nests. The entire 46.16-acre project site has shrubs that can be used by nesting songbirds during the nesting bird season of February 1 to September 15.

3.7 WILDLIFE MOVEMENT CORRIDORS
Wildlife movement corridors link together areas of suitable habitat that are otherwise separated by rugged terrain, changes in vegetation, or human disturbances. The project site was not originally identified as a formally designated regional wildlife linkage. Usually, mountain canyons or riparian areas corridors are used by wildlife as corridors. The project site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby and . Furthermore, the site is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and a residential area to the west. However, urban SJKF can move through disturbed open land between developed parcels. The open 46.16-acre project area may therefore function as a local stepping-stone or permeable movement area. The project site was evaluated for its function as a wildlife corridor that species would use to move between wildlife habitat zones. Usually, mountain canyons or riparian corridors are used by wildlife as corridors.

The project site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby. Furthermore, the site is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and a residential area to the west. No wildlife movement corridors were found to be present on the project site.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 10 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

3.8 STATE AND FEDERAL JURISDICTIONAL STREAMS
No federal or jurisdictional streams occur onsite. After observing aerial images and visiting the project site, it was determined that an underground stormwater feature exists near the east border of the project area. The feature carries water that flows from four culverts to the southeast of the project site from south to north. This feature does not qualify as state or federal jurisdictional waters.

4.0 PROJECT IMPACTS

4.1 IMPACTS TO HABITAT TYPES
The proposed project will impact the entire 46.16 acres of land consisting of approximately 46.16 acres of disturbed ruderal land onsite (Figure 5). Impacts may include SJKF movement corridor for intermittent foraging, denning/burrow habitat.

4.2 IMPACTS TO STATE OR FEDERALLY LISTED PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES

OR CNPS LISTED PLANTS

4.2.1 Impacts to State or Federally Listed and CNPS Listed Plants No state or federally listed plants or CNPS listed plants are expected to be impacted by the proposed project. Given the project severely degraded, predominantly non-native plants and unsuitable soils focused rare plant surveys are not warranted. Direct impacts to the listed/CNPS plants evaluated in the GBA are not expected.

4.3 IMPACTS TO CRITICAL HABITAT
The project site is not located within designated federal critical habitat. No impacts to critical habitat would occur.

4.4 IMPACTS TO NESTING BIRDS
Migratory nongame native bird species are protected under the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act.

Additionally, Sections 3503, 3503.5 and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code prohibit take of all birds and their active nests. If vegetation removal and other ground disturbance activities can be conducted outside of the recognized nesting bird season (February 1 through September 15), impacts to nesting birds is not expected.

If work cannot be avoided during the nesting bird season, prior to initiation of project activities that would remove vegetation or otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy equipment), work associated with project activities have the potential to impact nesting APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 11 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
birds.

4.5 IMPACTS TO STATE OR FEDERAL STREAMS
The approximately 46.16-acre project site does not contain any state or federal streams. The stormwater feature exists underground and is not CDFW, USACE, or RWQCB jurisdictional. No impacts to jurisdictional waters would occur from project implementation.

5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
Based upon the findings of this report, it is recommended that the following measures be implemented as part of the project to avoid, minimize, or compensate for the anticipated impacts from project activities:

5.1 BURROWING OWLS
Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Pre-Construction Surveys
Prior to the commencement of ground-disturbing or vegetation-clearing activities, the project applicant/developer shall retain a qualified biologist to conduct pre-construction surveys for BUOW (Athene cunicularia) in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Depending on the time elapsed between the focused surveys conducted in support of the analysis conducted as a part of the biological resource assessment and the start of construction, additional focused surveys may be required during the survey season immediately preceding construction. As specified in the 2012 Staff Report, one 30-day pre-construction survey is recommended; however, multiple surveys may be necessary prior to construction to determine presence or absence, and burrowing owls may colonize a site following previous negative survey results. Therefore, the project site shall be monitored 30 days prior to ground disturbance to detect any occupancy prior to construction activities.

Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer
If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 12 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed.

The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls.

5.2 NESTING BIRDS
Project activities could disturb passerine or raptor nests in the vicinity and would convert open land that may provide foraging habitat. This project should have a pre-construction survey regardless if it’s done after the nesting season (February 1st- September 15).CDFW encourages that Project ground-disturbing activities occur during the non-nesting season; however, if ground-disturbing or vegetation-disturbing activities occur during the nesting season (February 1st -
September 15th), the Project applicant is responsible for ensuring that implementation of the Project does not result in violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act or relevant Fish and Game Code sections as referenced above.

CDFW further recommends that a qualitied biologist conduct a pre-construction survey for active nests no more than 10 prior to the start of ground or vegetation disturbance to maximize the probability that nests that could potentially be impacted are detected. CDFW also recommends that surveys cover a sufficient area around the Project site to identify nests and determine their status. A sufficient area means any area potentially affected, either directly or indirectly, by the Project. In addition to direct impact (i.e., nest destruction), noise, vibration, and movement of workers or equipment could also affect nests. CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist establish a behavioral baseline of all identified nests. Once Project activities begin, CDFW recommends having a qualified biologist continuously monitor nests to detect behavioral changes resulting from the Project. If behavioral changes occur, CDFW recommends halting the work causing that change and consulting with CDFW for additional avoidance and minimization measures.

If continuous monitoring of identified nest by a qualified biologist is not feasible, CDFW recommends a minimum no-disturbance buffer of 250 feet around active nests of non-listed bird species and a 500-foot no-disturbance buffer around active nests of non-listed raptors. These buffers are advised to remain in place until the breeding season has ended or until a qualified biologist has determined the birds have fledged and are no longer reliant upon the nest or on-site parental care for survival. Variance from these no-disturbance buffers is possible when there is a compelling biological or ecological reason to do so, such as when the Project site would be concealed from a nest site by topography. CDFW recommends that a qualified biologist advise and support any variance from these buffers and notify CDFW in advance of implementing a variance.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 13 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

5.3 Crotch’s Bumble Bee
Potential seasonal floral, nesting, and overwintering resources were not found in the survey.

However, if there is ground disturbance, vegetation removal, during the blooming period then Crotch’s bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) habitat assessment will occur to determine whether the site provides nesting, overwintering, and floral resources. If habitat is present, multiple rounds of CBB focused surveys will be conducted. If CBB are observed, site-specific measures will be implemented to avoid take, such as establishing a minimum 50-foot avoidance area around occupied habitat features and coordinating seasonally to minimize disturbance during overwintering. CDFW will be consulted to obtain an ITP if CBB take cannot be avoided during project activities.

5.4 San Joaquin Kit Fox
Before the City issues a grading permit and before any activity that could result in take, the Project applicant shall provide the City with written evidence that it has initiated project-specific coordination with CDFW and USFWS. The applicant shall implement all agency-approved avoidance and minimization conditions. If CDFW determines take cannot be avoided, the applicant shall obtain an incidental take permit under Fish and Game Code section 2081(b) before take If federal take may occur, the applicant shall obtain incidental take coverage through Endangered Species Act section 7 (if there is a federal nexus) or section 10(a)(1)(B), as applicable.

Focused preconstruction den survey. will be required. A biologist shall survey the entire project area and buffer no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days before ground or vegetation disturbance. The survey shall identify and map potential or known natal/pupping dens and document signs. If work does not begin within the validity period, if work lapses, or if site conditions change, the survey shall be repeated as directed by the agencies.

Potential dens shall receive at least the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; known dens shall receive the current USFWS minimum exclusion distance; and agencies shall be contacted regarding any natal/pupping den. There will be a 50-foot buffer for potential dens and 100-feet for known dens. No known or natal/pupping den shall be destroyed without required take authorization. Any monitoring, partial plugging, excavation, or den closure shall be performed only by an agency approved qualified biologist and in accordance with the applicable authorization.

Construction practices and biological monitoring. Before site entry, all workers shall receive kit fox awareness training. A qualified biological monitor shall have stop-work authority for a kit fox, suspected occupied den, entrapment, injury, or mortality. Daytime on-site speeds shall not exceed 20 miles per hour and nighttime speeds shall not exceed 10 miles per hour; nighttime work shall APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 14 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
be minimized. Excavations deeper than two feet shall be covered at day’s end or provided with escape ramps and inspected before backfilling. Pipes/culverts at least four inches in diameter and other den-like materials shall be capped or inspected before movement; stacked materials shall be elevated where feasible. Food waste shall be secured; pets and firearms shall be prohibited; rodenticide/herbicide use shall be minimized and agency restrictions followed. New detections, injury, or mortality shall be reported promptly to agencies as required.

Before final site-plan approval, a qualified biologist shall review perimeter fencing/walls, drainage structures, lighting, landscaping, and high-traffic conflict points. Agency-approved design features shall maintain safe kit fox passage where feasible and shall not create entrapment hazards. If necessary artificial dens, specialized fencing gaps, exclusion fencing, or other passage features shall be installed only where required or approved through agency consultation/permit conditions and supported by a maintenance and monitoring plan.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 15 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

6.0 CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that the statements furnished above and in the attached exhibits present the data and information required for this biological evaluation, and that the facts, statements, and information presented are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.

Date 9-3-2026 Signed

PROJECT MANAGER
Fieldwork Performed By:

Carissa Gomez

ASSOCIATE BIOLOGIST
Sarah Vasquez

BIOLOGIST/ PROJECT MANAGER
APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 16 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530

7.0 REFERENCES
American Ornithologists’ Union. 1983 (and supplements 1985, 1987, 1989, 1991, 1993, and 1995). The A.O.U. Check-List of North American Birds. 6 th ed. Allen Press. Lawrence, Kansas.

Burt, W.H., and Grossenheider, R.P., 1980. Peterson Field Guides, Mammals. Houghton Mifflin Company. New York, New York.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 1988a. California’s wildlife, Volume I:

Amphibians and Reptiles. State of California Resources Agency. Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 1988b. California’s Wildlife, Volume II: Birds.

State of California’s Resource Agency. Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 1988c. California’s Wildlife, Volume III:

Mammals. State of California Resources Agency. Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 2014 (October). Natural Communities List.

The Resources Agency of California, Department of Fish and Game, Natural Diversity Data Base.

Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 2014 (October). Endangered and Threatened Animals List. The Resources Agency of California, Department of Fish and Game, Natural Diversity Data Base. Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 2014 (October). Endangered Threatened and Rare Plants. The Resources Agency of California, Department of Fish and Game, Natural Diversity Data Base. Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 2014 (October). Special Animals List . The Resources Agency of California, Department of Fish and Game, Natural Diversity Data Base.

Sacramento, California.

CDFG (California Department of Fish and Game). 2015. RareFind On-line program. Data Base Record Search for Information on Threatened, Endangered, Rare, or Otherwise Sensitive Species California Department of Fish and Game, State of California Resources Agency. Sacramento, California.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 17 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
CDFW (California Department of Fish and Wildlife). 2018. CNDDB MGS Data. The Conservation Strategy for the Mohave Ground Squirrel. The Resources Agency of California, Department of Fish and Wildlife, Natural Diversity Data Base. Sacramento, California.

Department of the Army. 1986 (Nov 13). 33 CFR Parts 320 Through 330, Regulatory Programs of the Corps of Engineers; Final Rule. Federal Register 51(219):41206-41206.

Department of the Army. 2000 (Mar 9). 33 CFR Parts 320 Through 330, Regulatory Programs of the Corps of Engineers; Final Rule. Federal Register 65(47):12818-12899.

Department of the Army. 2002 (Jan 15). 33 CFR Parts 320 Through 330, Regulatory Programs of the Corps of Engineers; Final Rule. Federal Register 67(10):20020-2095.

Hickman, J.C. 1993. The Jepson Manual: Higher Plants of California. University of California Press. Berkeley, California.

Holland, R.F. 1986 (updated 1996). Preliminary Descriptions of the Terrestrial Natural Communities of California. Non-game Heritage Program. California Department of Fish and Game. Sacramento, California.

Munz, P.A. 1974. A Flora of Southern California. University of California Press. Berkeley, California.

Sawyer, J.O. and T. Keeler-Wolf. 1995. A Manual of California Vegetation. California Native Plant Society. Sacramento, California.

Spencer, W.D., P. Beier, K. Penrod, K. Winters, C. Paulman, H. Rustigian-Romsos, J. Strittholt, M. Parisi, and A. Pettler. 2010. California Essential Habitat Connectivity Project: A Strategy for Conserving a Connected California. Prepared for California Department of Transportation, California Department of Fish and Game, and Federal Highways Administration.

Stebbins, R.C. 2003. A Field Guide to Western Reptiles and Amphibians. 2nd ed. Houghton Mifflin Company. Boston, Massachusetts.

Tibor, D.P. 2001. California Native Plant Society’s Inventory of Rare and Endangered Plants of California. California Native Plant Society. Special Publication, No. 1, 6th ed.

Udvardy, M.D. 1994. National Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Birds. Alfred A.

Knopf, Inc. New York, New York.

APN 368-010-05
General Biological Assessment
P a g e | 18 September 2026 November 2025
Hernandez Environmental Services
17037 Lakeshore Drive
Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
USFWS (United States Fish and Wildlife Service). 2008. Draft revised recovery plan for the Mojave population of the desert tortoise (Gopherus agassizii). U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, California and Nevada Region, Sacramento, California. 209 pp.

USFWS (United States Fish and Wildlife Service). 1993 (Sep 30). Plant Taxa for Listing as Endangered or Threatened Species; Notice of Review. Federal Register 50 CFR Part 17. U.S.

Department of the Interior. Washington, D.C.

USFWS (United States Fish and Wildlife Service). 1994 (Nov 15). Endangered or Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Animal Candidate Review for Listing as Endangered or Threatened Species.

Federal Register 50 CFR Part 17. U.S. Department of the Interior. Washington, D.C.

USFWS (United States Fish and Wildlife Service). 1997c (Oct. 31). Endangered or Threatened Wildlife and Plants. Federal Register 50 CFR Part 17. U.S. Department of the Interior.

Washington, D.C.

FIGURE 1
Eucalyptus Avenue
Edison Avenue
Euclid Avenue
N
Palm Avenue
Kendall Drive
Cajon Blvd
Figure 1
APN 368-010-05
Kern County, California
Location Map
Rosedale & Coffee
Legend
Survey Area
Surveyed Buffer - t Environmental
FIGURE 2
Eucalyptus Avenue
Edison Avenue
Euclid Avenue
Legend
Property Boundary
N
Palm Avenue
Kendall Drive
Cajon Blvd
Vicinity Map
Kern County, California
Rosedale & Coffee
APN 368-010-039
Project Location

1.0 km 3.0 km
..
" Ii
~
'D
" Ii
;i
..

5.0 km
.,,
" i
" -,
t
" "
:M, .. ,1•
.
'Ii
"
;;l
i
.i .... , L•
Stot:lo.d_,• Hl¥J'
~
\
" \
t ;;
:i:
"
..
0:
.
<
,
Bakers fi eld
.
~
i
:>
•
E C llfOflU.l A,,,11
t
Cotumbu !i\
Environmental
Services
0 FIGURE 3
0 50' 1 00' 200'
SCALE: 1" = 100.00'
I I I
I I
I I I
I
E9
NORTH
I
ac 11CC1 m:::m nee nee nee nee ace
!&Cl !ICCI !ICCI IICD IIClD IIClD IIClD !!!El IICICI IICCI IICICI IICICI IICICI IICICI 334'-8

MAJOR A
RETAIL
88,220SF l
111111111111 H 1111111 rD
I I

MAJOR BI RETAIL
7,680SF ~llllftl~ ~8rtlhl~ m
------'---,-------'------1..----"1,,-----=:::::.J-:=:. ::.=-=.::s.::.=.==::==-?:.-=~,.=~-'i-"s=§~~ I •
I
f. 1·· Iii
..
f,.
-
.....
"' I I
. .,
... ...
•
,.pp
rr---
"'
111111111 m
QI I I I I I I I I l'D
142'
MAJORC

HEALTH CLUB
25,000SF
·
-
.-~
•PP I I --7
I
•

I I I I

I I I I I
I I
I
I I
I I I
50'-0"
cOCICD C1CD CICD
,------,
12 SHOPS/

REST'S D
7,440SF
/"----......__
210'

MAJOR E
MARKET
43,000 SF
/ ' I \
I @ I SHOPS/ REST'S
F \ I \ I ' , ___ ____ /
I 9,670SF 125'-4
MAJORG
RETAIL :e
9,500 SF
170'-8

MAJOR H
RETAIL
25,000SF
206'
MAJORJ
RETAIL
25,000 SF
220'

MAJOR K
B RETAIL 33,000SF
220'

MAJOR L
RETAIL
30,381 SF
220'
MAJORM
RETAIL
30,000SF
174'-8

MAJOR N
RETAIL
22,000SF
re

SWC ROSEDALE & COFFEE

BAKERSFIELD, CALIFORNIA
3,000 SF
=
1 l·H 11 t 11 t t 11 t 1111 rD
ltl ltHtl ltl ltl IV
0Tl I ltl ltl It I ltl ltl rTI B '-----'
6Tl t 11 t 11 t m PAD 14 I ltl ltl ltl ltl m
ltl ltl ltl ltm~-~~_0JtJ_,~
• •
11 ltl 11 ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl rw 11 ltl 11 ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl rD I ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltrD I ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl I w 450
I ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltrD I ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl ltrD I ltl ltl ltl ltl ltl I~ =
N'D 10
CQFFEE
lli-l+-t1fi DIRlv't-THRU
EST1URANT
I I ~f SF
~----____, I I IPI T°WRu
E. RANT
3,:ISF
I
I
I
I
PL.A J ..,.,.WS DEVELOP.EB'S PLAN FOR Tlj!E CONFIGL.R6.TION OF THE ASeF~ DATEOFT~SITEPLAN, ONLY. IT ISONLYA PLAN, AND IT
BE DEEMED TO BIND Qe/ELOPER AS TO:
•
(~ . Em= ANY PARTICULAR1Bil.llLDING OR Sf'ACE DEPICTED HEREON, OR; (Bl JHE CONFIGURATION, LOCATl©!'JI OR FLOOR AREA OF /J.NYPARTlCUL.AR BUILDING 0~ SPACE DEPICTED HEREON OR r THE PROP0SED USE OR 06ct:JP.ANCY OF PARTICULAR BUILDING OR SPACE D!:PIC1:ED HEREON.

PHASE LINES AND NUMBERS, IF ANYi, ARE FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY. PHASE LINES MAY BE REDRAWN. Pf:IASE NUMBERS MAY BE REASSIGNED, AND THE CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE!!"Q~ u-m PHASES MAY NOT NECESSARILY FOLLOW THE NIJMEBICP..L SEQUENCE OF TH5Wffi DEPICTED HEREON, ALL AT I HE SOLE

DISCREIION OF DEVELOPER

BUILDING AREAS AND LAND COVERAGE ARE PRELIMINARY AND SUBJECT TO ADJUSTMENT. ANY PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT IS SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF GOVERNMENT! OR OTHER AGENCIES HAVING JURISDICTION. ALI; DIMENSIONS AND SITE CONDfTIONSARE SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION.
3837 BIRCH STREET
NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660
949.954.6100

VICINITY
"'
' ' ' s
ZONING

GENERAL PLAN
ZONING:

SETBACKS:

FRONT (STREETS):

SIDE:

REAR:
f
l
•
C MIDc
u nJ•"'"
"""''~'"'
Olloal•

SAKERSF IELO

P (PUBLIC FACILITIES)
M-2 (GENERAL MANUFACTURING)
REAR (ADJ. TO RESIDENTIAL ZONE):
10'
O' O'
20'
MAXIMUM BUILDING HEIGHT: MAXIMUM BUILDING COVERAGE:
150'
N/A

PROJECT SUMMARY
LAND AREAS:

WEST END COMMERCIAL:

SURPLUS PARKING AREA:

EAST END SHOPPING CENTER:

TOTAL LAND AREA:

9.53AC (415,262 SF±l 3.00AC (130,717 SF±

33.63 AC (1,464,822 SF±

46.16AC (2,010,801 SF±)

WEST END COMMERCIAL
BUILDING AREA: RETAIL:

RESTAURANT: EXPRESS CARWASH:

TOTAL BUILDING AREA:

BUILDING COVERAGE (FAR.):

PARKING (BMC 17.58):

REQUIRED PARKING:

GEt~EML RETAIL (1.300}.

RESTAURANT (1 :75):
95,900 SF
3,600 SF
4,125 SF
103,625 SF

25.0%
928 S:FALLS
EXPRESS CARWASH (1: EMPLOYEE)
48 STALLS
5 STALLS
TOTAL PARKING REQUIRED: TOTAL PARKING PROVIDED:

PARKING STANDARDS:

STANDARD PARKING STALL:
373 STALLS
401 STALLS
BUMPER OVERHANG ALLOWED:
9' X 18'
2'-6"
12' X 25'
25'
LOADING AREAS:

DRIVE AISLE WIDTH:

EAST END COMMERCIAL
BUILDING AREA:

SHOPPING CENTER:

DRIVE-THAU/ RESTAURANT PADS (FREESTANDING):
268,756 SF
21,561 SF
3,000 SF
4,872 SF
BANK PAD:

CONVENIENCE STORE PAD:

HEALTH CLUB:

TOTAL BUILDING AREA:

BUILDING COVERAGE (FAR.):

PARKING (BMC 17.58):

REQUIRED PARKING:
25,000 SF
323,189 SF

21.1%

NIGHBORHOOD/ REGIONAL SHOPPING
CENTER:

UP TO 35,000 SF (1 :200~. 175 STALLS IN EXCESS OF 35,000 S (1 :250): 935 STALLS DRIVE-THAU/ RESTAURANT PADS (1 :75): 288 STALLS BANK (1 :300): 10 STALLS CONVENIENCE STORE (1 :200): 25 STALLS
HEALTH CLUB (1:300): 83 STALLS
TOTAL PARKING REQUIRED: 1,516 STALLS TOTAL STALLS PROVIDED: 1 ,533 STALLS DRIVE-THAU STACKING CREDIT: 14 STALLS
GAS PUMP CREDIT: 16 STALLS
TOTAL PARKING PROVIDED: 1 ,563 STALLS
PARKING STANDARDS:

STANDARD PARKING STALL: 9' X18'
BUMPER OVERHANG ALLOWED: 2'-6"
LOADING AREAS: 12' X 25'
DRIVE AISLE WIDTH: 25'

CONCEPTUAL SITE
PLAN
SCHEME Jv1

SWC ROSEDALE & COFFEE

BAKERFIELD, CA
GKPA PROJECT #21135.01
31 MAY 2022
~PIERCE

ARCHITECTS
3 OVERTURE
ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656
T 949.344.2710
F 949.344.2720
©GK PIERCE ARCHITECTS. INC. 2022
FIGURE 4
Eucalyptus Avenue
Edison Avenue
Euclid Avenue
Legend
Property Boundary
N
Palm Avenue
Kendall Drive
Cajon Blvd
Ruderal Habitat (47.19 Ac.)
Habitat Map
Kern County, California
Rosedale & Coffee
APN 368-010-039
Project Location
Om 100 m
,..----------------------~---- _,..._ __ ------------- I I
t
I
I
I
I

I ,-----'
t
·-----------------------------------------
200m 300m 400m
:-·-·-··
L , _ , _,_:

I
' ' t
' I
I
I
' ' ' I
I
I
' ' I
' ' ' I
I
I
I
--------------
t Environmental
Services
FIGURE 5
Eucalyptus Avenue
Edison Avenue
Euclid Avenue
Legend
Limits of Impact (47.19 Ac.)
N
Palm Avenue
Kendall Drive
Cajon Blvd
Limits of Impact Map
Kern County, California
Rosedale & Coffee
APN 368-010-039
Om 50m 100m 150 m 200m 250 m ••
-•-•-
l.1.i.KlR L
AFT• .....
t Environmental

APPENDIX A
Observed Species List
Plant List
Scientific Name Common Name
Acacia Salicina Willow acacia
Astragalus kentrophyta Spiny milkvetch
Bromus rubens Red brome
Bromus tectorum Cheatgrass
Croton californicus California croton
Hordeum sp. Barley sp.

Hirschfeldia incana Shortpod mustard
Kali tragus Prickly Russian thistle
Rumex sp. Dock sp.

Solanum elaeagnifolium Silverleaf nightshade
Wildlife List
Scientific Name Common Name
Buteo jamaicensis Red-tailed hawk
Charadrius vociferus Killdeer
Columba livia domestica
Vulpes macrotis mutica
Feral pigeon
San Joaquin kit fox

APPENDIX B

WILDLIFE CNDDB PRESENCE/ABSENCE TABLE
Scientific Name Common Name Taxon Group Federal List State List Other Status Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/ Absence Agelaius tricolor tricolored blackbird Birds None Threatened BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_EN-Endangered |
NABCI_RWL-Red Watch
List | USFWS_BCC-Birds of
Conservation Concern
Freshwater marsh | Marsh & swamp |
Swamp | Wetland
Highly colonial species, most numerous in
Central Valley and vicinity. Largely
endemic to California.

Requires open water, protected nesting
substrate, and foraging area with insect
prey within a few km of the colony.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Ammospermophilus nelsoni Nelson's (San Joaquin)
antelope squirrel Mammals None Threatened BLM_S-Sensitive |IUCN_EN-Endangered Chenopod scrub Western San Joaquin Valley from
200-1200 ft elev. On dry, sparsely
vegetated loam soils.

Dig burrows or use k-rat burrows. Need
widely scattered shrubs, forbs and grasses
in broken terrain with gullies and washes.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Anniella grinnelli Bakersfield legless lizard Reptiles None None CDFW_SSC-Species of Special Concern
Southern San Joaquin Valley. Known from
two disjunct areas: the east side of the
Carrizo Plain and portions of the city limits
of Bakersfield.

Microhabitat of this species is poorly
known. Other legless lizard species occur
in sparsely vegetated areas with moist,
loose soil. Often found underneath leaf
litter, rocks, and logs.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Anniella spp. California legless lizard Reptiles None None CDFW_SSC-Species of Special Concern
Contra Costa County south to San Diego,
within a variety of open habitats.This
element represents California records of
Anniella not yet assigned to new species
within the Anniella pulchra complex.

Variety of habitats; generally in moist,
loose soil. They prefer soils with a high
moisture content.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Arizona elegans occidentalis California glossy snake Reptiles None None CDFW_SSC-Species of Special Concern
Patchily distributed from the eastern
portion of San Francisco Bay, southern
San Joaquin Valley, and the Coast,
Transverse, and Peninsular ranges, south to
Baja California.

Generalist reported from a range of scrub
and grassland habitats, often with loose or
sandy soils.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Athene cunicularia burrowing owl Birds None None
BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_LC-Least Concern |
USFWS_BCC-Birds of
Conservation Concern
Coastal prairie | Coastal scrub | Great
Basin grassland | Great Basin scrub |
Mojavean desert scrub | Sonoran
desert scrub | Valley & foothill
grassland
Open, dry annual or perennial grasslands,
deserts, and scrublands characterized by
low-growing vegetation.

Subterranean nester, dependent upon
burrowing mammals, most notably, the
California ground squirrel.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species has the
potential to be present. No burrows were
observed during the survey. The
disturbed open habitat may have new
burrows and the species could occupy
the site before construction. This species
has the potential to be present.

Bombus crotchii Crotch bumble bee Insects None Candidate Endangered IUCN_EN-Endangered
Coastal California east to the
Sierra-Cascade crest and south into
Mexico.

Food plant genera include Antirrhinum,
Phacelia, Clarkia, Dendromecon,
Eschscholzia, and Eriogonum.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.No individuals were observed,
but the genera biological survey
occurred outside the primary blooming
and detection period. Potential foraging
can occur on site. This species has the
potential to occur.

Buteo swainsoni Swainson's hawk Birds None Threatened BLM_S-Sensitive | IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Great Basin grassland | Riparian forest
| Riparian woodland | Valley &
foothill grassland
Breeds in grasslands with scattered trees,
juniper-sage flats, riparian areas,
savannahs, and agricultural or ranch lands
with groves or lines of trees.

Requires adjacent suitable foraging areas
such as grasslands, or alfalfa or grain fields
supporting rodent populations.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present. No nesting habitat occurs onsite;
however, the site may provide limited
foraging habitat. This species has a low
potential to occur.

Danaus plexippus plexippus
pop. 1
monarch - California
overwintering population Insects Candidate None IUCN_EN-Endangered |USFS_S-Sensitive Closed-cone coniferous forest Winter roost sites extend along the coast
from northern Mendocino to Baja
California, Mexico.

Roosts located in wind-protected tree
groves (eucalyptus, Monterey pine,
cypress), with nectar and water sources
nearby.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Desmocerus californicus
dimorphus
valley elderberry longhorn
beetle Insects Threatened None Riparian scrub
Occurs only in the Central Valley of
California, in association with blue
elderberry (Sambucus mexicana).

Prefers to lay eggs in elderberries 2-8
inches in diameter; some preference shown
for "stressed" elderberries.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Dipodomys nitratoides
nitratoides Tipton kangaroo rat Mammals Endangered Endangered IUCN_VU-Vulnerable Chenopod scrub Saltbrush scrub and sink scrub
communities in the Tulare Lake Basin of
the southern San Joaquin Valley.

Needs soft friable soils which escape
seasonal flooding. Digs burrows in
elevated soil mounds at bases of shrubs.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Elanus leucurus white-tailed kite Birds None None
BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_FP-Fully Protected |
IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Cismontane woodland | Marsh &
swamp | Riparian woodland | Valley &
foothill grassland | Wetland
Rolling foothills and valley margins with
scattered oaks and river bottomlands or
marshes next to deciduous woodland.

Open grasslands, meadows, or marshes for
foraging close to isolated, dense-topped
trees for nesting and perching.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Emys marmorata western pond turtle Reptiles None None
BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_VU-Vulnerable |
USFS_S-Sensitive
Aquatic | Artificial flowing waters |
Klamath/North coast flowing waters |
Klamath/North coast standing waters |
Marsh & swamp | Sacramento/San
Joaquin flowing waters |
Sacramento/San Joaquin standing
waters | South coast flowing waters |
South coast standing waters | Wetland
A thoroughly aquatic turtle of ponds,
marshes, rivers, streams and irrigation
ditches, usually with aquatic vegetation,
below 6000 ft elevation.

Needs basking sites and suitable (sandy
banks or grassy open fields) upland habitat
up to 0.5 km from water for egg-laying.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Eremophila alpestris actia California horned lark Birds None None CDFW_WL-Watch List | IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Marine intertidal & splash zone
communities | Meadow & seep
Coastal regions, chiefly from Sonoma
County to San Diego County. Also main
part of San Joaquin Valley and east to
foothills.

Short-grass prairie, "bald" hills, mountain
meadows, open coastal plains, fallow grain
fields, alkali flats.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Eumops perotis californicus western mastiff bat Mammals None None BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern
Chaparral | Cismontane woodland |
Coastal scrub | Valley & foothill
grassland
Many open, semi-arid to arid habitats,
including conifer and deciduous
woodlands, coastal scrub, grasslands,
chaparral, etc.

Roosts in crevices in cliff faces, high
buildings, trees and tunnels.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Scientific Name Common Name Taxon Group Federal List State List Other Status Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/ Absence Gambelia sila blunt-nosed leopard lizard Reptiles Endangered Endangered CDFW_FP-Fully Protected | IUCN_EN-Endangered Chenopod scrub
Resident of sparsely vegetated alkali and
desert scrub habitats, in areas of low
topographic relief.

Seeks cover in mammal burrows, under
shrubs or structures such as fence posts;
they do not excavate their own burrows.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Gonidea angulata western ridged mussel Mollusks None None IUCN_VU-Vulnerable Aquatic Primarily creeks and rivers and less often
lakes. Originally in most of state, now
extirpated from Central and Southern
California.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Helminthoglypta
callistoderma Kern shoulderband Mollusks None None IUCN_EN-Endangered Aquatic | Sacramento/San Joaquinflowing waters Known only from Tulare and Kern
counties, along the lower Kern River
Canyon.

Has been collected from dead vegetation
along the water's edge.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Lasiurus cinereus hoary bat Mammals None None IUCN_LC-Least Concern Broadleaved upland forest |
Cismontane woodland | Lower
montane coniferous forest | North
coast coniferous forest
Prefers open habitats or habitat mosaics,
with access to trees for cover and open
areas or habitat edges for feeding.

Roosts in dense foliage of medium to large
trees. Feeds primarily on moths. Requires
water.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Lytta moesta moestan blister beetle Insects None None Valley & foothill grassland Central California.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Lytta morrisoni Morrison's blister beetle Insects None None Valley & foothill grassland Inhabitant of the southern Central Valley of California.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Masticophis flagellum
ruddocki San Joaquin coachwhip Reptiles None None CDFW_SSC-Species ofSpecial Concern Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothill
grassland
Open, dry habitats with little or no tree
cover. Found in valley grassland and
saltbush scrub in the San Joaquin Valley.

Needs mammal burrows for refuge and
oviposition sites.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Onychomys torridus
tularensis Tulare grasshopper mouse Mammals None None
BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern
Chenopod scrub Hot, arid valleys and scrub deserts in the southern San Joaquin Valley.

Diet almost exclusively composed of
arthropods, therefore needs abundant
supply of insects.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Perognathus inornatus San Joaquin pocket mouse Mammals None None BLM_S-Sensitive | IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Cismontane woodland | Mojavean
desert scrub | Valley & foothill
grassland
Grassland, oak savanna and arid scrubland
in the southern Sacramento Valley, Salinas
Valley, San Joaquin Valley and adjacent
foothills, south to the Mojave Desert.

Associated with fine-textured, sandy,
friable soils.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Phrynosoma blainvillii coast horned lizard Reptiles None None BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Chaparral | Cismontane woodland |
Coastal bluff scrub | Coastal scrub |
Desert wash | Pinon & juniper
woodlands | Riparian scrub | Riparian
woodland | Valley & foothill grassland
Frequents a wide variety of habitats, most
common in lowlands along sandy washes
with scattered low bushes.

Open areas for sunning, bushes for cover,
patches of loose soil for burial, and
abundant supply of ants and other insects.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Sorex ornatus relictus Buena Vista Lake ornate
shrew Mammals Endangered None CDFW_SSC-Species ofSpecial Concern Marsh & swamp | Riparian scrub Marshlands and riparian areas in the TulareBasin.

Prefers moist soil. Uses stumps, logs and
litter for cover.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Spea hammondii western spadefoot Amphibians None None
BLM_S-Sensitive |
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_NT-Near Threatened
Cismontane woodland | Coastal scrub |
Valley & foothill grassland | Vernal
pool | Wetland
Occurs primarily in grassland habitats, but
can be found in valley-foothill hardwood
woodlands.

Vernal pools are essential for breeding and
egg-laying.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Taxidea taxus American badger Mammals None None
CDFW_SSC-Species of
Special Concern |
IUCN_LC-Least Concern
Alkali marsh | Alkali playa | Alpine |
Alpine dwarf scrub | Bog & fen |
Brackish marsh | Broadleaved upland
forest | Chaparral | Chenopod scrub |
Cismontane woodland | Closed-cone
coniferous forest | Coastal bluff scrub |
Coastal dunes | Coastal prairie |
Coastal scrub | Desert dunes | Desert
wash | Freshwater marsh | Great Basin
grassland | Great Basin scrub | Interior
dunes | Ione formation | Joshua tree
woodland | Limestone | Lower
montane coniferous forest | Marsh &
swamp | Meadow & seep | Mojavean
desert scrub | Montane dwarf scrub |
North coast coniferous forest |
Oldgrowth | Pavement plain |
Redwood | Riparian forest | Riparian
scrub | Riparian woodland | Salt marsh
| Sonoran desert scrub | Sonoran thorn
woodland | Ultramafic | Upper
montane coniferous forest | Upper
Sonoran scrub | Valley & foothill
grassland
Most abundant in drier open stages of most
shrub, forest, and herbaceous habitats, with
friable soils.

Needs sufficient food, friable soils and
open, uncultivated ground. Preys on
burrowing rodents. Digs burrows.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present. Not observed during the survey.

Badgers are known for to use loose soils
seen on site, however surrounding
development and disturbance reduce
suitability.This species has very low
potential to occur.

Vulpes macrotis mutica San Joaquin kit fox Mammals Endangered Threatened Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothill grassland
Annual grasslands or grassy open stages
with scattered shrubby vegetation.

Need loose-textured sandy soils for
burrowing, and suitable prey base.

This species was observed during the
field survey. This species is present. Not
observed during the survey. Disturbed
ruderal and urbanized areas are known
habitat for SJKF movement, foraging,
and denning.This species has the
potential to occur.

PLANT CNDDB PRESENCE/ABSENCE TABLE
Scientific Name Common Name Taxon Group Federal List State List Rare Plant Rank Habitats General Habitat Micro Habitat Presence/ Absence Astragalus hornii var. hornii Horn's milk-vetch Dicots None None 1B.1 Alkali playa | Meadow & seep | Wetland Meadows and seeps, playas. Lake margins, alkaline sites. 75-350 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Atriplex tularensis Bakersfield smallscale Dicots None Endangered 1A Chenopod scrub | Meadow & seep Chenopod scrub, alklai seep. Historically in valley sink scrub or with saltgrass. 90-110 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Calochortus striatus alkali mariposa-lily Monocots None None 1B.2 Chaparral | Chenopod scrub | Meadow
& seep | Mojavean desert scrub |
Wetland
Chaparral, chenopod scrub, Mojavean
desert scrub, meadows and seeps.

Alkaline meadows and ephemeral washes.
70-1600m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Caulanthus californicus California jewelflower Dicots Endangered Endangered 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Pinon & juniper
woodlands | Valley & foothill
grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland, pinyon and juniper woodland. Sandy soils. 65-1860 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Chloropyron molle ssp.
hispidum hispid salty bird's-beak Dicots None None 1B.1 Alkali playa | Meadow & seep |Wetland Meadows and seeps, playas, valley and
foothill grassland.

In damp alkaline soils, especially in
alkaline meadows and alkali sinks with
Distichlis. 5-155 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Coastal and Valley
Freshwater Marsh
Coastal and Valley
Freshwater Marsh Marsh None None Marsh & swamp | Wetland This is not present.

Delphinium recurvatum recurved larkspur Dicots None None 1B.2 Chenopod scrub | Cismontane woodland | Valley & foothill grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland, cismontane woodland.

On alkaline soils; often in valley saltbush
or valley chenopod scrub. 3-790 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Diplacus pictus calico monkeyflower Dicots None None 1B.2 Broadleaved upland forest | Cismontane woodland
Broadleafed upland forest, cismontane
woodland.

In bare ground around gooseberry bushes
or around granite rock outcrops. 180-1280
m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Eremalche parryi ssp.
kernensis Kern mallow Dicots Endangered None 1B.2
Chenopod scrub | Pinon & juniper
woodlands | Valley & foothill
grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland, pinyon and juniper woodlands.

On dry, open, sandy to clay soils; usually
within valley saltbush scrub; often at edge
of balds. 60-1295 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Eriastrum hooveri Hoover's eriastrum Dicots Delisted None 4.2 Chenopod scrub | Pinon & juniper
woodlands | Valley & foothill
grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland, pinyon and juniper woodland.

On sparsely vegetated alkaline alluvial
fans; also in the Temblor Range on sandy
soils. 50-915 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Eschscholzia lemmonii ssp.
kernensis Tejon poppy Dicots None None 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothillgrassland Valley and foothill grassland, chenopod
scrub.

Little information available on habitat.
135-1355 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Great Valley Cottonwood
Riparian Forest
Great Valley Cottonwood
Riparian Forest Riparian None None Riparian forest This is not present.

Great Valley Mesquite Scrub Great Valley Mesquite Scrub Riparian None None Riparian scrub This is not present.

Imperata brevifolia California satintail Monocots None None 2B.1 Chaparral | Coastal scrub | Meadow &
seep | Mojavean desert scrub |
Riparian scrub | Wetland
Coastal scrub, chaparral, riparian scrub,
mojavean desert scrub, meadows and seeps
(alkali), riparian scrub.

Mesic sites, alkali seeps, riparian areas.
3-1495 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Layia leucopappa Comanche Point layia Dicots None None 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothill grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland.

Dry hills in white-grey clay soils, often
with weedy grasses. Does not reliably
appear every year. 100-315 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Monolopia congdonii San Joaquin woollythreads Dicots Endangered None 1B.2 Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothill grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland.

Alkaline or loamy plains; sandy soils,
often with grasses and within chenopod
scrub. 55-840 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Navarretia setiloba Piute Mountains navarretia Dicots None None 1B.1 Cismontane woodland | Pinon &
juniper woodlands | Valley & foothill
grassland
Cismontane woodland, pinyon and juniper
woodland, valley and foothill grassland.

Red clay soils, or on gravelly loam.
180-1645 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Opuntia basilaris var.
treleasei Bakersfield cactus Dicots Endangered Endangered 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Cismontanewoodland | Valley & foothill grassland Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland, cismontane woodland.

Coarse or cobbly well-drained granitic
sand on bluffs, low hills, and flats, within
grassland. 85-550 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Stylocline citroleum oil neststraw Dicots None None 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Coastal scrub | Valley & foothill grassland
Chenopod scrub, coastal scrub, valley and
foothill grassland.

Flats, clay soils in oil-producing areas.
50-400 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Stylocline masonii Mason's neststraw Dicots None None 1B.1 Chenopod scrub | Desert wash | Pinon & juniper woodlands
Chenopod scrub, pinyon and juniper
woodland. Sandy washes. 100-1200 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Tortula californica California screw moss Bryophytes None None 1B.2 Chenopod scrub | Valley & foothill grassland
Chenopod scrub, valley and foothill
grassland. Moss growing on sandy soil. 45-750 m.

No habitat for this species is present on
the project site. This species is not
present.

Valley Saltbush Scrub Valley Saltbush Scrub Scrub None None Chenopod scrub This is not present.

APPENDIX C
Disturbed habitat with sparse vegetation on
site where impacts will take place. View
looking west.

Disturbed habitat followed by Rosedale
Highway and commercial businesses in the
distance. View looking north.

Non-native vegetation including prickly
Russian thistle (Kali tragus) followed by
storage containers on site. View looking
northeast.

Environmental
Disturbed habitat followed by Coffee Road
along eastern border of site in the distance.

View looking northeast.

Center of project site with grading lines
followed by intersection of Coffee Road and
Rosedale Highway in the distance. View
looking east.

Disturbed habitat followed by Rosedale
Highway along northern border of site in
distance. View looking north.

Environmental
Services
Development directly south of project site in
the distance. View looking southeast.

Disturbed habitat where impacts will occur.

View looking south.

Drill on the northwest corner of project site.

View looking north.

Environmental

APPENDIX D
Soil Map—Kern County, California, Northwestern Part
Natural Resources
Conservation Service
Web Soil Survey
National Cooperative Soil Survey
12/15/2022

Page 1 of 3 ends
← All documents from this meeting