Cities Index.
Minutes, regular meeting, second session

Bakersfield City Council
November 4, 2026

Document
Minutes, regular meeting, second session
Meeting
November 4, 2026
Body
Bakersfield City Council
Pages
223
Original file
413.1 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on pub-bakersfield.escribemeetings.com. That file is the official record.

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
impacts to be significant and unavoidable, the City failed to adopt all feasible mitigation. It improperly rejected measures such as enforcing diesel truck idling limits below five minutes, requiring particulate controls on under-fired charbroilers, and mandating CAPCOA commute trip reduction programs (Measures T-5 and T-6).

Major analytical omissions pervade the environmental document, including the failure to assess the need for offsite water infrastructure improvements, thereby concealing secondary offsite construction impacts.

Recirculation of the Draft EIR is legally mandatory pursuant to CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5 due to significant new information disclosed after circulation of the DEIR. The FEIR fundamentally reversed its biological baseline to acknowledge that the site provides suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox and Crotch bumble bee, inserting entirely new biological analysis and mitigation measures that were never subjected to public review.13 Furthermore, the City declined to adopt feasible mitigation for VMT, GHG, criteria pollutants, and Valley Fever without substantial evidence, and omitted foundational public health and utility analyses, depriving the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment on the Project’s true environmental consequences. Consequently, the Planning Commission cannot recommend Project approval or certification of the FEIR, nor make the required legal findings, and the City must revise and recirculate the Draft EIR prior to taking further approval action.

The City also lacks substantial evidence to support General Plan Amendment land use compatibility findings because the Staff Report entirely omits consideration of the adjacent Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park and its heightened exposure to air quality, health risk, and noise impacts.

CARE CA urges the Planning Commission to recommend that the City revise and recirculate the EIR to comply with CEQA before any further action is taken on the Project.14
13 FEIR, p. 3.4-16; pp. 2-15–2-18. 14 CARE CA reserves the right to provide supplemental comments at any and all later proceedings related to this Project. Gov. Code § 65009(b); PRC § 21177(a); Bakersfield Citizens for Local Control v. Bakersfield (2004) 124 Cal. App. 4th 1184, 1199-1203; see Galante Vineyards v. Monterey Water Dist. (1997) 60 Cal. App. 4th 1109, 1121.

October 1, 2026

Page 4 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
I. STATEMENT OF INTEREST
CARE CA is non-profit organization which advocates for protecting the environment and the health of their communities’ workforces. The organization’s members include the District Council of Ironworkers and Southern California Pipe Trades DC 16, along with their members, their families, and other individuals who live and work in the City of Bakersfield and in Kern County. These individuals and labor organization members may be adversely affected by the potential public and worker health and safety hazards, and the environmental impacts of the Project.

CARE CA seeks to ensure a sustainable construction industry over the long-term by supporting projects that offer genuine economic and employment benefits, and which minimize adverse environmental and other impacts on local communities. CARE CA members live, work, recreate, and raise their families in the City of Bakersfield and surrounding communities. Accordingly, they would be directly affected by the Project’s environmental and health and safety impacts.

Individual members may also work on the Project itself. They will be first in line to be exposed to any health and safety hazards that exist onsite.

In addition, CARE CA has an interest in enforcing environmental laws that encourage sustainable development and ensure a safe working environment for its members. Environmentally detrimental projects can jeopardize future jobs by making it more difficult and more expensive for business and industry to expand in the region, and by making the area less desirable for new businesses and new residents. Indeed, continued environmental degradation can, and has, caused construction moratoriums and other restrictions on growth that, in turn, reduce future employment opportunities.

II. THE FEIR STILL FAILS TO COMPLY WITH CEQA
A. The FEIR Still Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Potentially Significant Valley Fever Risks
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that it omitted discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever risks. Conversely, Dr. Clark submitted scientific evidence demonstrating that soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres could expose workers and residents to severe health hazards. These are risks that were not disclosed or mitigated in the DEIR. This risk is especially acute given that October 1, 2026

Page 5 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
Valley Fever is endemic to the area, with 1,848 cases reported in Kern County in 2026 alone.15
The FEIR dismisses this impact as less than significant by asserting that compliance with SJVAPCD Rule 8021 (which requires a Dust Control Plan to maintain visible dust opacity below 20 percent) will adequately control Valley Fever exposure.16 This assertion is contradicted when the City simultaneously claims that active dust monitoring is ineffective because there is “no direct correlation” between fugitive dust particulate concentration levels and airborne Valley Fever fungal spores.17 The City cannot logically claim on one hand that fugitive dust suppression measures reduce Valley Fever risk, while asserting on the other that dust concentration levels do not correlate with fungal spore exposure.18 The FEIR’s conclusions are not supported by substantial evidence.

As Dr. Clark explains, Coccidioides arthroconidia spores range in size from 2 to 5 micrometers (𝜇𝜇m), falling directly within the respirable range of fine particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10).19 Because these microscopic spores travel attached to fine airborne soil particles, fugitive dust concentration is the direct indicator of whether dust suppression measures are successfully containing spore dispersal.20 Furthermore, relying strictly on visual opacity criteria under Rule 8021 is insufficient; visual opacity measures are dominated by coarse soil particles, meaning fine respirable particles carrying fungal spores can escape off-site at dangerous, health-impairing levels without ever breaching the 20 percent visual plume threshold.21
The City also fails to account for unusually high local susceptibility and on-site soil contaminants. Under CEQA, environmental review must evaluate the sensitivity of the surrounding environment and the receptors exposed to potential project hazards.22 Here, the City failed to evaluate the project-specific factors that exacerbate the risk of Valley Fever infection and cumulative adverse health effects.

First, the FEIR contains no analysis evaluating how soil disturbance during earthmoving across the 46-acre site will impact the Green Acres Estates Senior 15 Clark Comments, p. 12.
16 FEIR, p. 2.0-44. 17 FEIR, p. 2.0-93; Clark Comments, p. 11. 18 FEIR, p. 2.0-91. 19 Clark Comments, p. 11. 20 Clark Comments, p. 11. 21 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-93. 22 CEQA Guidelines § 15125(a).

October 1, 2026

Page 6 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
Mobile Home Park, which is situated directly west of the site.23 Adults over the age of 60 represent a highly sensitive population facing a significantly heightened risk of severe, disseminated, and potentially fatal Valley Fever.24 The City’s continued failure to analyze and mitigate risks to this highly vulnerable adjacent demographic violates CEQA. Second, Valley Fever cases in Kern County remain extraordinarily high, with reported cases rising from 948 in 2001 to 3,873 in 2024, and continuing at elevated levels through 2025 and 2026.25 Disturbing 46 acres of dry soil in an area of extreme endemic prevalence presents a potentially significant public health impact.

The City attempts to excuse its lack of mitigation by citing California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) requirements under Title 8 (Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144) and Labor Code Section 6709.26 But an agency cannot satisfy its obligation to analyze and mitigate off-site public environmental impacts by pointing to workplace safety laws intended solely for employee safety.

Title 8 and Labor Code regulations apply exclusively to site workers and do not prescribe fence-line exposure limits, public health protections, or off-site airborne spore containment strategies for nearby residents.27
The FEIR must mitigate the Project’s potentially significant Valley Fever impacts before the Project can be approved. The City must evaluate feasible, low-cost conditions proposed in Dr. Clark’s comments to minimize Valley Fever and particulate transport, including:

1. Mandating watering of all disturbed areas at least three to four times per day, which CalEEMod calculates achieves up to a 74 percent reduction in PM10 and PM2.5 emissions.28

2. Implementing real-time upwind and downwind perimeter PM10 and PM2.5 monitoring equipped with actionable exposure thresholds to trigger additional watering or work shutdowns.29
23 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1. 24 Clark Comments, pp. 1, 13. 25 Clark Comments, p. 11. 26 FEIR, p. 2.0-44; Clark Comments, p. 13 27 Clark Comments, p. 13
28 Clark Comments, pp. 11–12. 29 Clark Comments, p. 12.

October 1, 2026

Page 7 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper

3. Suspending grading and excavation activities whenever sustained wind speeds exceed 20 miles per hour.30

4. Mandatory covering of haul loads, cleaning vehicles prior to site departure, and establishing project-specific medical and respiratory protocols under the Injury and Illness Prevention Program.31
Because the City’s finding of a less-than-significant impact relies on contradictory assertions, fails to account for site-specific hazardous soil contaminants and sensitive senior receptors, and omits feasible mitigation, the Valley Fever analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must prepare a revised EIR that quantifies fine particulate transport, evaluates public health risks, and incorporates enforceable mitigation measures prior to project approval.

B. The FEIR Still Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Health Risk Impacts From Project Operations

1. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Health Risks from the Project’s Operational Emissions
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrate that it fails to disclose, quantitatively analyze, and mitigate significant public health risks from exposure to TACs. The Project’s proposed fuel station, char broilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic will emit TACs, yet the DEIR relies on unsupported qualitative heuristics–rather than preparing a formal Health Risk Assessment (“HRA”)–to quantify operational health risk impacts.

The FEIR responds that the City’s operational health risk analysis is supported by substantial evidence because it relies on the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”) Air Quality and Land Use Handbook and rules established by the SJVAPCD.32 The City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways.33 This argument lacks merit, as the City is essentially arguing that a Project would not result in 30 Clark Comments, p. 12. 31 Clark Comments, p. 12. 32 FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 33 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32.

October 1, 2026

Page 8 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
significant health risks from mobile sources unless it generates a freeway’s worth of traffic. The land use compatibility screening criteria in the CARB Handbook are intended to kickstart land use planning, not serve as a substitute for project-specific health risk evaluations or detailed environmental review under CEQA.34
The FEIR also fails to respond to CARE CA’s comment that the same CARB guidelines recommend against siting new sensitive land uses within 1,000 feet of a distribution center accommodating more than 100 trucks per day.35 This Project would result in 751 daily VMT for heavy trucks, demonstrating that the Project would present similar health risks as a warehouse project.36 The City’s failure to even acknowledge this comment violates CEQA’s requirements for good faith responses to comments received during the public comment period.37 It also illustrates that the FEIR’s discussion of the CARB Handbook is arbitrary and entirely unsupported.

The FEIR’s defects are particularly severe given the immediate proximity of the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, located just downwind of the proposed commercial facilities and truck loading docks.38 Elderly residents represent a sensitive demographic with heightened susceptibility to respiratory and cardiovascular toxicity from exposure to DPM and TACs.39 By relying on broad screening buffers rather than modeling actual dispersion patterns, truck idling times, traffic volume, and localized meteorology, the City improperly assumes a less-than-significant impact without evaluating the real-world exposure levels at these senior residences.40

2. The FEIR Piecemeals Analysis of Health Risk Impacts
From the Project’s Stationary Sources
Regarding health risk impacts from stationary sources such as fuel dispensing and charbroilers, the FEIR reiterates the DEIR’s assertion that these 34 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 35 CARB, Air Quality And Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective, p. 4, available at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2023-05/Land%20Use%20Handbook_0.pdf. 36 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119. 37 Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 14, § 15088(c).
38 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, pp. 1, 11. 39 Clark Comments, p. 1. 40 Clark Comments, p. 11.

October 1, 2026

Page 9 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
sources would be controlled through the SJVAPCD permitting process.41 CARE CA previously explained that separating the Project’s emissions sources into categories and analyzing them separately constitutes piecemealing in violation of CEQA.

The FEIR “disagrees” that this legal standard precludes omitting stationary sources from its analysis of the Project’s health risks.42 The City argues that:
“[s]tationary sources were identified as distinct from the non-permitted sources to acknowledge the regulatory framework that exists for permitted sources within the SJVAPCD.”43 The City also relies on the SJVAPCD Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (“GAMAQI”) to argue that emissions from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements are per se not individually or cumulatively significant.44
These arguments lack merit because statutory compliance with local air district permitting rules cannot substitute for an EIR’s independent legal duty to evaluate total, combined health risks. CEQA mandates that an agency evaluate the total environment impact of the entire project, rather than evaluating individual emission sources in isolated silos. As previously explained, CEQA defines a “project” as “the whole of an action” that may result in either a direct physical environmental change or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change.45 CEQA mandates “that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large project into many little ones – each with a minimal potential impact on the environment – which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences.”46 When a single commercial development project introduces both stationary sources (such as fuel transfer emissions containing benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene) and mobile sources (such as heavy-duty diesel truck trips producing Diesel Particulate Matter), those pollutants reach neighboring sensitive receptors concurrently.

Splitting the sources apart allows the City to claim that mobile sources pass a high-level screening threshold while assuming stationary sources are exempt from CEQA scrutiny by virtue of future air district permits.
41 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59. 42 FEIR, pp. 2.0-59.
43 Id. 44 FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 45 14 Cal. Code Regs. Sec. 15378. 46 Bozung v. LAFCO (1975) 13 Cal.3d 263, 283-84; City of Santee v. County of San Diego (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1438, 1452; Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 151, 165.

October 1, 2026

Page 10 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
The FEIR’s piecemealed review also conflicts with SJVAPCD guidance. For development projects such as this one, “[t]he District recommends an AAQA be performed for ALL Criteria Pollutant emissions for which an ambient air quality standard exists when a development projects would result in an increase of 100 pounds per day screening level of ANY pollutant for any of the following categories:

Construction emission activities [,] Operational permitted source emission activities, or […] Operational non-permitted source emission activities.”47 SJVAPCD guidance also provides that “the assessment of operational emissions in the AAQA shall evaluate operational sources within the project boundary [such as “boilers, process heaters, etc.”] as well as project-related mobile emissions…”48 The City’s improper segmentation creates a severe analytical loophole that conceals potentially significant public health risks. Adjacent sensitive receptors, such as elderly residents located at the nearby Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, breathe ambient air that reflects the combined toxic load of all project operations simultaneously. CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(f) requires that an agency’s significance determination be supported by substantial evidence considering the whole project. By refusing to perform a unified, site-specific HRA that models the additive TAC exposures from both the gas station and heavy-duty delivery truck traffic, the City lacks substantial evidence supporting its less-than-significant health risk finding.

Compliance with SJVAPCD Regulation II rules does not relieve the City of its lead agency duty under CEQA to analyze and mitigate total off-site health impacts before Project approval. Because the FEIR improperly relies on piecemealed source evaluations to avoid assessing aggregate TAC concentrations, the FEIR’s operational health risk analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must revise its environmental review to include a comprehensive HRA that evaluates all stationary and mobile health risk impacts combined into a single, whole-project disclosure.

3. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Construction Activities
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City’s analysis of cumulative health risks during construction is contrary to law. A major issue is that 47 SJVAPCD, Project Ambient Air Quality Analysis Applicability Determination Under CEQA (June 2018), p. 5, https://www.valleyair.org/media/bo3hz35n/apr-2030.pdf. 48 Id. at 4-5.

October 1, 2026

Page 11 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
the DEIR asserts that any exceedance of a project-level threshold (cancer risk of 20 in one million) also is considered to be a cumulatively considerable effect, while health risks that fall below applicable project-level thresholds are not considered cumulatively considerable.49 CARE CA demonstrated that this approach fails to consider the Project’s cumulative effects with existing and proposed development near the Project site as required by CEQA.50 It also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.51
The FEIR responds that any project with health risks below the individual threshold is automatically not cumulatively considerable.52 The FEIR argues that SJVAPCD guidance provides that the 20 in one million cancer risk threshold was set at such a conservative level that no cumulative impacts could occur.53 This assertion does not appear to be supported, as AB 2588 (Air Toxics “Hot Spots”) and other air districts set a 10 in one million cancer risk threshold – twice as stringent as the SJVAPCD threshold.54 In fact, the SJVAPCD guidance was referring to a 10 in one million significance threshold, which was later revised to 20 in one million.55 This threshold also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.56 Thus, even if 20 in one million were a conservative significance threshold for a different area, it is possible that health risk impacts would be cumulatively considerable in this highly pollution-burdened area. 49 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”).
50 Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (1990) 221 Cal. App. 3d 692. 51 Clark Comments, p. 10. 52 FEIR, p. 2.0-60. 53 FEIR, p. 2.0-60. 54 See SCAQMD, South Coast AQMD Air Quality Significance Thresholds, https://www.aqmd.gov/docs/default-source/ceqa/handbook/south-coast-aqmd-air-quality-significance-thresholds.pdf?sfvrsn=f7601d61_25. 55 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, pp. 100, 110, 56 Clark Comments, p. 10.

October 1, 2026

Page 12 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper

4. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Operations
The FEIR does not include an operational HRA. The FEIR claims that an operational HRA need not be prepared because one was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County with more truck trips that did not result in significant impacts.57 But Dr. Clark explains that an HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project.58 That HRA also addressed truck emissions only, whereas the instant Project includes a gasoline station and charbroilers.59 Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.60 Therefore, the FEIR lacks substantial evidence to conclude that health risk impacts from operations would not be cumulatively considerable.

5. The FEIR Proposes Illusory Mitigation for Operational Health Risks
The FEIR describes a Condition of Approval (“COA”) to address health risks posed by possible under-fired charbroilers.61 The measure would require that a health risk assessment shall be required for any future charbroilers, and that mitigation be adopted to reduce health risks from the charbroilers if they exceed SJVAPCD’s 20 in one million cancer risk threshold.62 This mitigation is inadequate because it again piecemeals emissions from stationary sources from the Project’s other emissions sources. Operational health risks from the Project’s total operations may exceed the significance thresholds even if charbroilers are individually below the thresholds. Therefore, this mitigation would not adequately mitigate impacts from the whole of the Project. And by calling for an HRA for future charbroilers, the FEIR paradoxically requires more review for a single component of the Project than 57 FEIR, p. 2.0-60 (“As identified in response to the SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, an operational HRA was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498) that generates substantially more heavy duty diesel truck trips per day than the commercial uses associated with the proposed Project, which supports the conclusions in the Draft EIR that the proposed Project would not generate a substantial amount of truck trips that would warrant an operational HRA.”) 58 Clark Comments, p. 18.
59 Clark Comments, p 18.
60 Id.
61 FEIR, p. 2.0-61.
62 Id.

October 1, 2026

Page 13 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
included in the FEIR for the Project as a whole. The EIR must be revised to quantify operational health risks and analyze them along with cumulative sources of emissions.

6. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulatively Considerable Emissions of Criteria Air Pollutants
As with its analysis of cumulative health risks, the FEIR assumes that emissions of criteria air pollutants below adopted regionals significance thresholds could not be cumulatively considerable.63 The FEIR fails to analyze the Project’s emissions in combination with other existing or proposed sources of emissions in the area. The FEIR’s analysis conflicts with SJVAPCD’s guidance on cumulative emissions of criteria pollutants. SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides:

If a project is significant based on the thresholds of significance for criteria pollutants, then it is also cumulatively significant. This does not imply that if the project is below all such significance thresholds, it cannot be cumulatively significant. For instance, another measure of a project’s individual significance contained in the GAMAQI is the impact on criteria pollutant concentrations in the ambient air. If the concentration exceeds any of the federal health-based ambient air concentration standards or causes a worsening of areas already exceeding those standards, the project is considered to be individually significant. Lead Agencies should also consider the cumulative impact of multiple simultaneously proposed projects, located within the same area. If the combined impacts of such projects cause or worsen an exceedance of the concentration standards, the project would have a cumulatively significant impact under CEQA. For example, simultaneous proposals for two 3 ton per year NOx sources located in the same area are each below the 10 ton per year criteria pollutant significance threshold. In this hypothetical example, analysis of each project’s impact on ambient air quality shows that they do not individually cause an exceedance of any ambient air quality standard.

However, when their combined emissions are considered, air quality modeling determines that their combined impacts cause an exceedance. In 63 FEIR, p. 2.0-60.

October 1, 2026

Page 14 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
this hypothetical case, each of these projects would be considered to have a cumulatively significant impact.64
To comport with this guidance, the FEIR must be revised to analyze combined emissions with nearby proposed projects in Table 3-1 of the DEIR.65

7. The FEIR Fails to Disclose that the Project’s Operations Would Result In Exceedance of Ambient Air Quality Standards for PM2.5
SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides that a project would be considered to have a significant impact if it would contribute to a violation of an ambient air quality standard by exceeding any of the CAAQS, or any of the NAAQS.66 Here, the proposed Project would elevate PM2.5 concentrations above the 24-hour National AAQS and the annual National AAQS and California AAQS, but the FEIR fails to identify these exceedances as significant impacts.67 The FEIR reasons that because Project-generated PM2.5 concentrations would not exceed the SJVAPCD significant impact levels, the potential for operation of the Project to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would also be less than significant.68 This reasoning ignores the plain language of the SJVAPCD guidance stating that an exceedance of any AAQS constitutes a significant impact.69 The FEIR must be revised to disclose and mitigate this impact.

C. The FEIR Still Fails to Identify All Feasible GHG Mitigation The FEIR finds that emissions of GHGs would be significant and unavoidable.70 CEQA requires agencies to adopt all feasible mitigation before finding that a significant impact is unavoidable.71 The City violates this 64 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 107-108, https://www.valleyair.org/media/g4nl3p0g/gamaqi.pdf. 65 DEIR, p. 3-2. 66 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90 67 DEIR, p. Table 4.3-13. 68 FEIR, p. 2.0-64.
69 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90. 70 DEIR, p. ES-17.
71 CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2); PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883.

October 1, 2026

Page 15 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
requirement by ignoring feasible mitigation proposed in SJVAPCD’s and CARE CA’s comments.72
For example, CARE CA and SJVAPCD recommended reducing the permissible idling time of diesel trucks,73 but the FEIR fails to evaluate the feasibility of reducing the permissible idling period below the five minutes already required by law.74 The FEIR, merely responds that the Project would comply with the five-minute regulatory standard.75
SJVAPCD also recommended requiring installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers.76 The City fails to implement this measure, instead calling for mitigation for charbroiler emissions only if they would result in health risks exceeding 20 in one million.77 This measure is inadequate because the Project’s significant GHG impacts requires the City to implement all feasible mitigation; a measure that only requires mitigation if a different impact would be significant is invalid.

D. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Transportation Impacts

1. The FEIR Fails to Identify Feasible Mitigation For the Project’s Significant VMT Impact
The FEIR finds that the Project would result in significant and unavoidable VMT impacts.78 CEQA thus requires the City to adopt all feasible mitigation measures. CARE CA recommended that the Project implement CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, “Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary).”79 The FEIR responds that “[t]he proposed implementation of employer-provided services, infrastructure, and alternative transit incentives to reduce Project VMT is 72 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 18 et seq.
73 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
74 DEIR, p. 4.3-5.
75 FEIR, p. 2.0-66 (Response No. O2.31); 2.0-86 (“Because California Code of Regulations Sections 2480 and 2485 of Title 13 are codified anti-idling regulations and are legally binding, the underlying presumption is that the Project would comply with these two rules.”) 76 FEIR, p. 2.0-17.
77 FEIR, p. 2.0-18.
78 DEIR, p. 4.16-16.
79 FEIR, p. 2.0-70.

October 1, 2026

Page 16 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
practically infeasible” because “the Project Applicant possesses no legal mechanism to compel commercial tenants to implement, manage, or enforce employer-based transit programs.”80 This statement is incorrect, as the FEIR can include a measure requiring tenant lease agreements to include certain requirements.

Under Public Resources Code Section 21061.1 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15364, “feasible” means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, legal, social, and technological factors. When an EIR identifies significant, unmitigated impacts, the agency bears the affirmative legal burden under CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 to demonstrate, through substantial evidence, that proposed additional mitigation measures are actually infeasible.

A bare claim of infeasibility, unsupported by concrete evidence, constitutes a procedural and substantive violation of CEQA.81 In Los Angeles Unified School District v. City of Los Angeles,82 the Court of Appeal invalidated an EIR where the lead agency dismissed feasible noise mitigation measures based on vague statements of impracticality without providing supporting technical or economic data. Similarly, in Flanders Foundation v. City of Carmel-by-the-Sea,83 the court held that an agency’s infeasibility determination must be supported by actual, quantifiable evidence rather than mere assertions of difficulty or administrative preference.

The City’s response fails to meet CEQA’s standards by failing to identify actual factual, economic, legal, or technical justifications precluding implementation of Measure T-5. Factually and practically, CAPCOA Measure T-5 is fully feasible and well suited for commercial developments of this nature. As Mr. Marshall explains, CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5 establishes a proven framework to achieve up to a 4.0% reduction in VMT by incorporating voluntary commute trip reduction elements, including employer-provided infrastructure, incentives for alternative transit modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpools (Measure T-11), guaranteed ride home programs, and coordinated marketing and information services (Measure T-80 FEIR, p. 2.0-71. 81 City of San Jose v. Great Oaks Water Co. (1987) 192 Cal.App.3d 1005, 1017; Sierra Club v. County of Fresno (2018) 6 Cal.5th 502, 513.
82 (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1019, 1029–1031. 83 (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 603, 618–620.

October 1, 2026

Page 17 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
7).84 Given that the FEIR concedes the Project’s retail and medical office components generate significant, unmitigated VMT impacts, the City cannot legally ignore an established, standard mitigation measure published in CAPCOA guidance without providing specific facts and findings demonstrating infeasibility.

CARE CA also recommended that the City require CAPCOA Measure T-6 (“Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring”).85 These can reduce GHG emissions from employee commute VMT by up to 26%.86 The FEIR dismisses this measure without explanation. Response No.

O2.36 only includes legal boilerplate:

CEQA does not require analysis of every imaginable alternative or mitigation measure; its concern is with feasible means of reducing environmental effects. Section 21002 states in part that the intention of CEQA is ‘to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such significant effects.’” (Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Consequently, CEQA does not mandate implementation of mitigation measures where they would be ineffective as either inapplicable to a project element or purported impact. (Ibid.) Because the commenter has failed to present feasible mitigation that was not already considered in the Draft EIR or identify a significant new or intensified impact, recirculation of the Draft EIR is not legally required under CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.87 The FEIR both violates CEQA’s requirement to identify all feasible mitigation for significant impacts and CEQA’s standards for responses to public comments received on the DEIR. The EIR must be revised and recirculated. 84 Marshall Comments, p. 2.
85 CAPCOA Handbook, T-6. Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring)
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-6.pdf. 86 Id. 87 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.

October 1, 2026

Page 18 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
E. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Potentially Significant Public Utilities Impacts
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City failed to analyze whether the Project would require offsite water infrastructure to meet the Project’s fire flow demands. Construction of improvements to existing water infrastructure may be required because the Project proposes a large new development on a vacant site. Further, the Bakersfield system has historic low-pressure areas where the minimum normal operating pressure ranges between 25 and 40 psi.88 Upgrades to offsite water mains may be required to service the Project, potentially resulting in construction activities much closer to sensitive receptors than assumed in the EIR.

The FEIR fails to provide this omitted analysis, and the FEIR’s responses do not address the specific issues raised in CARE CA’s comments. The FEIR responds that the Project’s fire flow will be determined before construction of the Project.89 This results in a failure to analyze the Project’s public utilities impacts before Project approval. And although any offsite water infrastructure upgrades may be required to meet regulatory standards, there are no measures requiring mitigation for noise, air quality, and transportation impacts that may arise from this offsite construction. The FEIR thus lacks substantial evidence to find that the Project would not require extensive offsite public utilities upgrades to provide adequate fire flow, or that such improvements would not cause significant environmental impacts.

The FEIR’s approach conflicts with CEQA’s prohibition on deferred analysis.

CEQA requires that an environmental document disclose the severity of a project’s impacts and the probability of their occurrence before a project can be approved.90 In Sundstrom v. County of Mendocino,91 the First District Court of Appeal rejected a mitigation measure that required the applicant to submit hydrological studies subject to review and approval by a planning commission and county environmental 88 California Water Service, Capital Project Justification Bakersfield District, July 2021, p. 97, https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/SupDoc/A2107002/3862/393926055.pdf. 89 FEIR, p. 2.0-73. 90 14 CCR §§ 15143, 15162.2(a); Cal. Build. Indust. Ass’n v. BAAQMD (2015) 62 Cal.4th 369, 388-90 (“CBIA v. BAAQMD”) (disturbance of toxic soil contamination at project site is potentially significant impact requiring CEQA review and mitigation); Madera Oversight Coalition v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 82; Berkeley Keep Jets Over the Bay Com. v. Bd. of Port Comrs. (“Berkeley Jets”) (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1344, 1370-71; CEQA Guidelines, Appendix G. 91 (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 296.

October 1, 2026

Page 19 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
health department.92 The Court explained that the deferred analysis of hydrological conditions fails to meet CEQA’s requirement that an environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning:

By deferring environmental assessment to a future date, the conditions run counter to that policy of CEQA which requires environmental review at the earliest feasible stage in the planning process. (See Pub. Resources Code, § 21003.1; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 84.) In Bozung v. Local Agency Formation Com., supra, 13 Cal. 3d 263, 282, the Supreme Court approved “the principle that the environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning.” Environmental problems should be considered at a point in the planning process “‘where genuine flexibility remains.’” (Mount Sutro Defense Committee v. Regents of University of California, supra, 77 Cal. App. 3d 20,

34.) A study conducted after approval of a project will inevitably have a diminished influence on decision making. Even if the study is subject to administrative approval, it is analogous to the sort of post hoc rationalization of agency actions that has been repeatedly condemned in decisions construing CEQA. (Id. at p. 35; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 81; Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. Coastside County Water Dist. (1972) 27 Cal. App. 3d 695, 706 [104 Cal. Rptr. 197].)
Here, the FEIR provides no facts showing it would be infeasible to identify the Project’s fire flow requirements, determine whether existing infrastructure would need to be upsized, evaluate the impacts from construction of these upgrades, and include the results in the CEQA. The FEIR therefore fails as an informational document and is unsupported by substantial evidence.

III. THE EIR MUST BE RECIRCULATED
CEQA requires a lead agency to recirculate a DEIR when “significant new information” is added to the environmental review after public notice and comment, but prior to certification. Under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5, new information is deemed “significant” if the EIR is changed in a way that deprives the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect. Specifically, Guidelines § 15088.5(a) provides that recirculation is required under any of the following four circumstances:
92 Id. at 306.

October 1, 2026

Page 20 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper

1. A new significant environmental impact would result from the project or from a new mitigation measure proposed to be implemented.

2. A substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance.

3. A feasible project alternative or mitigation measure considerably different from others previously analyzed would clearly lessen the environmental impacts of the project, but the project’s proponents have declined to adopt it.

4. The draft EIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded.

Here, the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation of the EIR.

1. The FEIR Now Discloses that the Project Would Have
Potentially Significant Impacts on Special Status Species Habitat and Identifies New Mitigation
Under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(2), recirculation of an EIR is mandated when significant new information added to the report demonstrates that a substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance. In the DEIR, the City originally concluded that suitable habitat for both the Crotch bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) and the San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica, “SJKF”) was entirely absent on the Project site.93 However, in response to comments and substantial evidence submitted by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (“CDFW”) and other public commenters establishing that the site contains suitable habitat and that SJKF historically and recently inhabit the surrounding area, the FEIR fundamentally reverses its baseline position.94 Specifically, the FEIR introduces new factual determinations, acknowledging for the first time that while the site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for a majority of species, these conditions “do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox population and recent or historical occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land” and admitting that “[t]he open 93 DEIR, pp. 3.4-12–3.4-14; p. 3.0-10 (“There is no suitable habitat for this species present on the project site”); p. 2.0-5 (“The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) is absent on the Project site based on a single general wildlife survey conducted in November 2025.”). 94 FEIR, p. 3.4-16; pp. 2-15–2-18.

October 1, 2026

Page 21 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.”95 Furthermore, the FEIR incorporates admissions from the City’s biological consultant acknowledging “that Crotch’s bumble bee habitat cannot be conclusively determined during a non-blooming survey period and that SJKF may use disturbed urban areas for movement and denning.”96 This radical change in the EIR’s factual baseline triggers mandatory recirculation under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(1) and (a)(2) because the FEIR identifies previously undisclosed, significant potential impacts to special-status species and their active movement/denning habitats.97 To address these newly disclosed impacts, the FEIR inserts entirely new biological mitigation measures— including mandatory pre-construction survey protocols, avoidance buffer zones, potential natal den excavation requirements for SJKF, and species-specific foraging habitat preservation protocols for the Crotch bumble bee—that were completely absent from the DEIR.98
In Response A1.5, the lead agency attempts to avoid recirculation by claiming that these FEIR revisions merely represent “clarifications” or “amplifications” of the DEIR’s existing biological analysis.99 This argument fails as a matter of law because changing an impact determination from “habitat absent” in the DEIR to acknowledging active intermittent denning, movement opportunities, and potential special-status species habitat in the FEIR is a fundamental change in factual baseline rather than a minor clarification.100 By withholding the acknowledgment of suitable SJKF and Crotch bumble bee habitat until the FEIR and adding new mitigation measures after the close of public review, the lead agency deprived the public, CDFW, and trustee agencies of their legal right under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(4) to meaningfully evaluate and comment upon the adequacy, enforceability, and feasibility of these newly formulated biological protections.101 Because the FEIR relies on post-DEIR habitat acknowledgments and uncirculated mitigation schemes to assert that impacts to SJKF and Crotch bumble bee are reduced to a less-than-significant level, the lead agency must recirculate the revised EIR prior to project approval or certification.102
95 FEIR, Biological Resources, p. 3.4-17. 96 FEIR, pp. 3.4-19, 2-22. 97 FEIR, pp. 1-2, 3.4-20–3.4-22. 98 FEIR, pp. 3.4-23–3.4-28. 99 FEIR, p. 2-42. 100 FEIR, pp. 2-43, 3.4-17. 101 FEIR, pp. 1-3, 2-44. 102 FEIR, pp. 1-4, 3.4-30.

October 1, 2026

Page 22 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper

2. The DEIR (And Now FEIR) Omitted Major Analyses That
Precluded Meaningful Public Review And Comment
Under Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4), recirculation of an EIR is mandatory where the DEIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded. The record demonstrates that this DEIR suffered from profound analytical omissions that deprived the public and trustee agencies of a meaningful opportunity to evaluate the Project’s environmental consequences, triggering mandatory recirculation under Section 15088.5(a)(4).

As discussed above, a glaring analytical omission in the EIR is the complete failure to evaluate and disclose public health risks associated with Valley Fever exposure. Soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres in Kern County—a region where Valley Fever is endemic and where 1,848 cases were reported in 2026 alone—present a severe health hazard to local workers and nearby residents.103 The DEIR omitted discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever entirely.

The EIR further suffers from critical omissions regarding operational health risks from TACs. Rather than conducting a formal HRA to model exposure from heavy-duty diesel truck traffic, a proposed fuel station, charbroilers, and a car wash, the DEIR relied on broad qualitative screening heuristics from the CARB Handbook.104 By failing to perform a unified HRA that models additive TAC exposures, the lead agency omitted essential information necessary for meaningful public review.

In addition, the EIR improperly deferred the analysis of public utilities impacts in violation of CEQA’s prohibition against post-hoc environmental review.105 CARE CA demonstrated that the Project may require offsite water main upgrades to meet fire flow demands in a municipal system characterized by historic low-pressure areas.106 Rather than analyzing whether offsite construction would be required and evaluating the resulting air quality, noise, and traffic impacts on nearby receptors, the FEIR states that fire flow requirements will be determined 103 FEIR, p. 2.0-44. 104 FEIR, p. 2.0-52. 105 FEIR, p. 2.0-72. 106 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.

October 1, 2026

Page 23 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
prior to construction.107 Deferring environmental assessment to post-approval study deprives the public of the ability to comment on the true physical footprint and secondary construction impacts of the Project.108
Because the Draft EIR omitted critical disclosures regarding endemic Valley Fever, operational TAC exposures, and offsite utility construction, meaningful public review and comment were precluded. Consequently, the Planning Commission cannot recommend certification of the FEIR, and the City must revise and recirculate the EIR pursuant to Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4).

IV. THE CITY LACKS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO MAKE THE
PROJECT’S LAND USE APPROVALS
A. The City Cannot Certify the FEIR, Adopt a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and Adopt Findings of Fact Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council certify the FEIR, adopt an MMRP, and adopt findings of fact. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he provisions of CEQA, the State CEQA Guidelines, and the City of Bakersfield CEQA Implementation Procedures have been followed.”109 This finding is not supported by substantial evidence, as these comments demonstrate that the FEIR violates CEQA’s procedural, informational, and analytical requirements. The Project would have significant impacts concerning health risk, air quality, GHG, noise, public utilities that have not been adequately disclosed and mitigated, and the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation before the Draft Resolution can be approved. In sum, the Planning Commission lacks the evidence necessary to recommend certification of the FEIR, or adoption of Findings of Fact and MMRP.

B. The City Cannot Make the Requisite Findings to Approve the General Plan Amendment
Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council approve the Project’s General Plan Amendment. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he Project is compatible with the land use designations and development of surrounding properties and is 107 FEIR, p. 2.0-72. 108 FEIR, p. 2.0-73.
109 Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001, p. 2.

October 1, 2026

Page 24 ends

8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
internally consistent with the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan.”110 The City lacks substantial evidence to make this finding because the Project would result in potentially significant air quality, health risk, and noise impacts to senior residents at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which is situated directly west of the site.111 The Staff Report fails to mention this land use anywhere in its discussion of the Project’s consistency with the surrounding properties. Therefore, the Planning Commission lacks substantial evidence to approve the Resolution.

Conversely, substantial evidence in the record demonstrates that the Project’s construction and operation would impact the health and general welfare of residents near the Project site. Residents would be exposed to fugitive dust disturbed during construction activities, which may expose them to Valley Fever spores. Residents would be exposed to potentially significant concentrations of TACs during operations, but the FEIR failed to analyze this risk in a quantitative HRA.

Air quality and noise impacts to residents would be much higher than disclosed in the FEIR if the Project requires offsite construction to upsize water mains. The City cannot approve the General Plan Amendment until these impacts are analyzed and mitigated in accordance with CEQA.

V. CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, the FEIR for the Project remains wholly inadequate under CEQA. It must be thoroughly revised to provide legally adequate analysis of, and mitigation for, all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts.

These revisions will require that the EIR be recirculated for public review. Until the EIR has been revised and recirculated, as described herein, the City may not lawfully approve the Project. Further, the record does not support the findings necessary to make the Project approvals. CARE CA urges the Planning Commission to recommend that the City revise and recirculate the EIR before any further action is taken on the Project.

Sincerely,
Aidan P. Marshall
Attachments
APM:acp
110 Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001, p. 2. 111 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1.

EXHIBIT A
P a g e | 1
September 23, 2026
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080
Attn: Mr. Aidan P. Marshall
Subject: Response to the City of Bakersfield's Responses to Comments in the Final Environmental Impact
Report (FEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace
Commercial Project, City of Bakersfield, Kern
County, California (State Clearinghouse No.
2025101507
Dear Mr. Marshall:

At the request of Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo (ABJC), I have reviewed the City of Bakersfield (City) Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), dated September 2026. My review focused on the City's responses to my August 21, 2026 comment letter on the Draft EIR (DEIR), which the City reproduced as Appendix O2A and answered in Responses O2A-1 through O2A-14. I also reviewed the City's responses to the comment letter submitted by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD or District) (Comment Letter A2, Responses A2.1 through A2.14), the related responses to ABJC's letter that repeat or expand on the City's technical positions (Responses O2.12 through O2.28), and the revisions in the FEIR Errata (Section 3.0).

The City's responses in the FEIR do not resolve the deficiencies I identified in the DEIR nor do they address the District's comments.

Several responses introduce new figures that conflict with one another or with the DEIR. Others rely on screening tools and permit programs that were not designed to answer the questions raised.

The FEIR also confirms, for the first time, that total PM2.5 concentrations at nearby receptors would exceed the federal and state ambient air quality standards within the Project in operation.

Clark & Associates
Environmental Consulting, Inc.

OFFICE
12405 Venice Blvd
Suite 331
Los Angeles, CA 90066
PHONE
310-907-6165
EMAIL
[email protected]
P a g e | 2
My review of the materials in no way constitutes a validation of the conclusions or materials contained within the FEIR. If I do not comment on a specific item, this does not constitute acceptance of that item.

PART I. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO CLARK'S COMMENTS
Responses O2A-1 through O2A-3: Project Description and Environmental Setting The City noted the project description and setting comments without responding to the substance of my comment. The setting information is directly relevant to the impacts discussed below and should not be set aside as background.

First, the Project site is subject to a 2019 Land Use Covenant because on-site soils contain total petroleum hydrocarbons as diesel and motor oil, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), and Title 22 metals. Fugitive dust generated by grading and excavation across the 46-acre site can carry these contaminants off-site along with Coccidioides spores. This makes the City's reliance on visual opacity limits for dust control (Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12) a greater concern here than on an uncontaminated site.

Second, the FEIR itself identifies the nearest residential community to the west as the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park.1 This confirms my point that the nearest receptors include older residents, who are more susceptible to the effects of fine particulate matter and toxic air contaminants (TACs) and are at higher risk of severe Valley Fever. None of the City's responses account for the sensitivity of this population.
1 FEIR, Response O1.5, pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28.

P a g e | 3
Figure 1: Project Site and Surrounding Land Uses (DEIR Figure 2-2, Local Vicinity Map) Figure 2: FEIR Response O1.5, p. 2.0-28 (City identifies the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park)
Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8: Pollution Burden and CalEnviroScreen Results The City states that the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results were provided in the CalEEMod output files in Appendix B, that the adjacent census tract scores higher primarily because it contains State Route 99, and that the adjacent tract's score has no relevance to the Project. These statements do not address my comment.

P a g e | 4
Figure 3: FEIR Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89
First, placing percentile scores in model output files is not a full disclosure to the public regarding the potential impacts that currently exist nor does it provide the decision makers with adequate information for their review. The air quality section of the DEIR does not discuss them, and the FEIR Errata does not add them.

Second, the pollution-burden indicators I cited are for the Project's own census tract, not the adjacent tract: PM2.5 in approximately the 99th percentile statewide and ozone in approximately the 94th percentile. The City's explanation about State Route 99 and the adjacent tract's composite score does not speak to these values. The FEIR provides no indicator data for the adjacent tract to support its explanation. The Project would add approximately 14.6 tons per year of VOC and 10.3 tons per year of NOx (both ozone precursors), along with direct PM2.5, to a tract that already ranks near the top of the state for both pollutants.

P a g e | 5
Figure 4: CalEnviroScreen 4.0 Pollution Burden Indicators for the Project Census Tract (DEIR Appendix B)
Figure 5: Project Location and Adjacent SB 535 Disadvantaged Community (Tract 6029000507) Third, the City's own ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) confirms the concern. The FEIR states that, with the Project in operation, total PM2.5 concentrations would exceed the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS), the annual NAAQS, and the annual California Ambient P a g e | 6
Air Quality Standard (CAAQS).2 The City finds the impact less than significant only because the Project's increment falls below the District's significant impact levels (SILs). As a result, the Project would add PM2.5 at receptors where the standards are already exceeded. The FEIR does not report the size of that increment at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park nor does it report the size of the increase at the residences in the tract east of Coffee Road, and it does not identify any on-site measure to reduce the PM2.5 increases. Feasible measures that would lower the local PM2.5 increment include particulate controls on under-fired charbroilers and a designed vegetative barrier on the western boundary (see Part II, Responses A2.4 and A2.5).

Figure 6: FEIR Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-90 (PM2.5 standards exceeded with the Project) Finally, the City states that the District's health risk threshold measures incremental risk and does not consider existing ambient risk. I agree that the threshold is incremental. That is not a reason to withhold the existing pollution burden from decision makers, and in any case the Project's incremental operational risk was never calculated (see Response O2A-7).

I recommend that the CalEnviroScreen results for the Project tract and the adjacent SB 535 tract be presented in the air quality analysis, the Project's modeled PM2.5 increment should be reported at each sensitive receptor group, and on-site PM2.5 reduction measures should be adopted.

Response O2A-5: Reliance on the VERA and Lack of On-Site Reductions The City disagrees that operational emissions are addressed solely through the Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) in MM AQ-1, pointing to MM AQ-2 (low-VOC coatings) and MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7. This response does not change the conclusion in my comment, for the following reasons.
2 FEIR, Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89; Response O2.28, p. 2.0-64.

P a g e | 7
Figure 7: FEIR Response O2A-5, p. 2.0-81
• None of the greenhouse gas measures was quantified for VOC or NOx reductions. If those measures produced meaningful reductions, the mitigated operational emissions would reflect them. They do not. The Project still exceeds both thresholds before the VERA is applied, which is why the VERA is needed.
• The City does not dispute that the exceedances are driven by mobile sources. MM GHG-1 (all-electric buildings) specifically exempts commercial cooking, which is the largest natural gas use in a retail center of this type, so its NOx benefit is small. MM GHG-2 (carbon-free electricity) reduces emissions at off-site power plants, not local VOC or NOx.

MM GHG-3 (electric landscaping equipment) addresses a minor source. • The transportation measures (improvements at up to two bus stops, one end-of-trip shower facility, and CALGreen Tier 2 electric vehicle parking) would have a negligible effect on a project generating between 18,921 and 28,479 daily trips. None of these measures addresses delivery trucks which can be a significant source of criteria and toxic air contaminant pollutants.
• MM AQ-2 reduces VOC from architectural coatings, but the FEIR does not state how much. The VOC exceedance (14.6 tons per year against a 10 ton per year threshold) is driven by vehicle trips.

P a g e | 8
Figure 8: Unmitigated Operational VOC and NOx Emissions Compared to SJVAPCD Thresholds (DEIR Section 4.3)
The timing of the VERA is also a concern. As revised in the Errata at the District's request, MM AQ-1 now requires only execution of the VERA before building permits are issued.3 The District explained that the time required to achieve the reductions "may vary" and that verification "may occur after issuance of building permits." The revised measure contains no deadline for the reductions to be achieved and no requirement that they be in place before the Project begins operating. As written, the Project could operate for an undefined period with its VOC and NOx exceedances unmitigated.

Figure 9: SJVAPCD Comment A2.3, FEIR p. 2.0-17 (timing of VERA emission reductions) 3 FEIR, Response A2.3, p. 2.0-17; Errata, p. 3.0-4.

P a g e | 9
Figure 10: FEIR Errata, p. 3.0-4 (MM AQ-1 revised from "completion" to "execution") In addition, VERA reductions are achieved wherever the District funds emission reduction projects across the eight-county air basin. They do not necessarily reduce exposure in the Project's neighborhood. On-site measures do, which is why they should be applied first and the VERA used for the remainder.

The City's reference to the charbroiler Condition of Approval (CoA) in this response is not relevant to this comment. The CoA addresses health risk from individual tenants. It does not reduce VOC or NOx emissions.

Response O2A-6: The SJV Air Pollution Control District's Analysis Recommendations Item 1: Separate analysis of stationary sources
The City states that the District's NOP comment asked only that mobile and stationary sources be analyzed separately and did not require stationary sources to be quantified. A separate discussion that never estimates the emissions from the gasoline dispensing facility or the charbroilers is not an analysis of those emissions. The District's comment letter on the DEIR removes any question about what it intended: the District specifically asked for an operational health risk assessment (HRA) of the gasoline station, the fast food charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA (Comment A2.2). The City's use of the CARB Air Quality and Land Use Handbook as a substitute is addressed under Response O2A-7.

P a g e | 10
Figure 11: SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, FEIR p. 2.0-14 (District request for an operational HRA) Item 2: Heavy-duty truck trip length
The City states that the DEIR did not use the CalEEMod default truck trip length and instead calculated heavy-duty truck vehicle miles traveled (VMT) with the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional travel demand model. Accepting that correction, the truck figures presented in the FEIR are internally inconsistent, and the inconsistency affects both the NOx estimate and the AAQA.

Figure 12: FEIR Response O2A-6, Item 2, p. 2.0-84
The DEIR reports heavy-duty truck VMT of approximately 751 miles per day.4 The FEIR then presents three different daily truck counts:
• 23 truck trips per day (0.15 percent of 14,904 trips from the KernCOG fleet mix) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16);
• 29 to 44 truck trips per day (the same percentage applied to total weekday and weekend trips) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16); and
• approximately 191 truck trips per day (751 miles divided by the overall average trip length of 3.94 miles) (Response A2.2).

Dividing 751 miles by each count gives an average heavy-duty truck trip length of approximately 33 miles (23 trips), 17 miles (44 trips), or 3.9 miles (191 trips). The City describes the 191-trip figure as "overly conservative" because trucks delivering to the Project "would be traveling longer 4 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119, as cited in FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15.

P a g e | 11
distances on average" than customers. If trucks travel farther than 3.94 miles, then either the truck count is far lower than 191 or the truck VMT is understated.

Figure 13: FEIR Response A2.2, pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16 (truck VMT and truck trip estimates) Figure 14: Implied Heavy-Duty Truck Trip Length for Each Truck Count Presented in the FEIR A regional travel demand model counts only the miles traveled inside the model boundary.

Deliveries originating at regional distribution centers outside Kern County are truncated at the county line. The FEIR does not present truck trip generation based on the Project's actual land uses, including the market (which will receive refrigerated deliveries), the restaurants, the retail anchors, and fuel tanker deliveries to a 40-position gasoline station.

P a g e | 12
I recommend that the truck trips should be estimated by land use, with trip lengths based on the likely origin of deliveries, and the operational NOx estimate, the AAQA, and the truck component of an operational HRA should be updated using those values.

Item 3: Operational health risk
See Response O2A-7 below.

Item 4: Ambient air quality analysis
The AAQA relies on the same truck inputs discussed under Item 2. It also shows that total PM2.5 concentrations with the Project would exceed the 24-hour NAAQS and the annual NAAQS and CAAQS (see Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8 above). Where the standards are already exceeded at nearby receptors, on-site PM2.5 reductions should be required.

Item 5: VERA feasibility
See Response O2A-5 above.

Response O2A-6: The District's Mitigation Recommendations Item 1: Cleanest available off-road construction equipment The City declined this measure because construction emissions are below the District's thresholds.

Being below a threshold does not mean construction emissions are negligible. The District recommended this measure for this Project, the air basin is classified as extreme nonattainment for the federal 8-hour ozone standard, and construction will occur on contaminated soils within several hundred feet of a senior mobile home park. Tier 4 Final engines emit substantially less diesel particulate matter (DPM) and NOx than Tier 2 and Tier 3 engines and are widely available in the construction fleet. The measure is feasible and low in cost and should be adopted.

Item 2: Heavy-duty truck routing
The City relies on the CARB Handbook screening criterion of 100,000 vehicles per day for busy roadways. That criterion was developed for siting new sensitive land uses next to existing high-volume roadways. It was not developed to evaluate the effect of a new project's trucks on existing residents. The same Handbook recommends a 1,000-foot separation between sensitive receptors and distribution centers with more than 100 trucks per day, and the City's own estimate in Response A2.2 is 191 truck trips per day. Roadway screening also does not address truck activity on the Project site itself, including travel on internal drive aisles, idling at loading docks, and operation of transport refrigeration units (TRUs), which are the activities closest to receptors.

A routing measure costs little to implement: direct truck access to the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road driveways, prohibit truck use of the El Toro Viejo Road driveways, locate loading P a g e | 13
docks on the eastern portions of the site away from the mobile home park and residences, and post truck route signage.

Item 3: Cleanest available heavy-duty trucks
The City rejected a zero-emission truck requirement as infeasible because tenants will not own their own truck fleets. The District recommended the cleanest available trucks, not a zero-emission-only requirement. The following measures are within the control of the developer and tenants and are feasible:

Figure 15: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 3, p. 2.0-85 • lease provisions requiring tenants to request zero-emission or near-zero-emission delivery vehicles from carriers where available;
• zero-emission vehicles for all landlord-controlled service vehicles (maintenance, sweeping, and security);
• electrical hookups at the market and restaurant loading docks so TRUs can operate on grid power rather than diesel while parked; and
• electrical conduit and panel capacity at loading docks to support future medium- and heavy-duty truck charging.

Item 4: Anti-idling regulations
The City states that compliance with the state anti-idling regulations can be presumed because they are legally binding. The state regulations are enforced by field inspection, which is infrequent at any single location. Site-level measures make the limit visible and verifiable at the Project: posted no-idling signs at every loading dock and truck entrance, a 3-minute idling limit (stricter than the 5-minute state limit), tenant notification to carriers, a posted contact for complaints, and a limit on diesel TRU operation while parked. These are common conditions for commercial and industrial projects in the San Joaquin Valley and cost little.

Figure 16: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 4, p. 2.0-86 P a g e | 14
Item 5: Under-fired charbroilers
The City states that the presence of charbroilers is speculative because tenants have not been identified, and relies on a CoA that requires an HRA before a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler receives a tenant improvement permit. I disagree for three reasons.

Figure 17: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 5, p. 2.0-86 First, the Project description identifies drive-thru, fast casual, and sit-down restaurants on the outer pads,5 and the DEIR modeled restaurant land uses in CalEEMod for trip generation and energy use. The information needed to estimate a reasonable worst-case charbroiler emission rate using District emission factors is already in the DEIR. Estimating emissions from a known restaurant floor area is standard practice for a project at this stage.

Second, the CoA is applied one tenant at a time. Each HRA would compare a single tenant's charbroiler emissions to the 20 in one million threshold. The combined risk from several charbroiler restaurants, the gasoline station, and truck activity at the same receptor would never be calculated. A center with several such restaurants could produce a combined risk above the threshold even if every individual HRA shows a risk below it.

Third, the CoA sets no control requirement unless an individual HRA exceeds the threshold. The District recommended assessment and installation of particulate matter controls for new large restaurants with under-fired charbroilers, and is offering incentive funding that covers the full cost of purchase, installation, and maintenance for two years of operation (Comment A2.4). A control 5 FEIR, Comment O2.1 (summarizing the DEIR Project Description), p. 2.0-43.

P a g e | 15
requirement is therefore feasible at little or no cost to tenants and would also reduce the PM2.5 increment discussed above.

Response O2A-7: Operational Health Risk
The City states that SJVAPCD Regulation II is mandatory, that compliance may be presumed, and that reliance on it is therefore not a postponement of the analysis. Whether the gasoline station obtains a permit is not the issue raised. No analysis in the DEIR, the FEIR, or the permit process estimates the total operational health risk from the Project at the nearest homes.

Figure 18: FEIR Response O2A-7, p. 2.0-88
• Regulation II permits evaluate individual permit units at the time an application is filed.

They do not combine the risk from all Project sources at a common receptor. • Delivery trucks, on-site truck idling, TRUs, and under-fired charbroilers are not evaluated through the Regulation II permit risk review. The City added a separate CoA for charbroilers because permitting does not cover them.
• The District asked that operational risk from the gasoline station, charbroilers, and trucks be combined with construction risk and compared to the thresholds (Comment A2.2). That calculation has not been done.

The GAMAQI statement quoted in the FEIR, that emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements "are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant,"6 concerns criteria pollutant emissions that are controlled through Best Available Control Technology and offsets under Rule 2201. It does not address the combined health risk from permitted and unpermitted sources at the same receptor. 6 FEIR, Responses O2.16 and O2.22, pp. 2.0-55 and 2.0-59.

P a g e | 16
Figure 19: FEIR Response O2.22, p. 2.0-59
The FEIR misstates the CARB Handbook recommendation for gasoline stations The FEIR states that the CARB Handbook recommends a 500-foot separation between sensitive land uses and gasoline dispensing facilities, and that the nearest receptors are about 650 feet from the station.7 The Handbook does not recommend 500 feet for gasoline stations. It recommends avoiding new sensitive land uses within 300 feet of a large gasoline station (3.6 million gallons per year or more) and within 50 feet of a typical station. More importantly, the Handbook is a siting guide for placing new homes and schools near existing sources. It is not a method for estimating the risk that a new source will impose on existing residents, and it does not substitute for an HRA.

Figure 20: FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15 (City's statement of a 500-foot CARB buffer) Several additional problems with the City's reliance on the Handbook should be noted:
• The FEIR never states the station's expected annual throughput. A station with 20 dual-sided dispensers (40 fueling positions) is comparable in size to the high-volume stations at wholesale and discount centers, which the City itself describes as having average throughput of about 9 million gallons per year and a risk of 25 in one million at 50 feet.8 The permitted throughput for a station of this size could be higher still. 7 FEIR, Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15; Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54. 8 FEIR, Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54, citing CARB 2005.

P a g e | 17
Figure 21: FEIR Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54 (CARB Handbook gas station risk values) • The Handbook risk values were developed in 2005 using methods that predate OEHHA's 2015 Risk Assessment Guidelines. The 2015 Guidelines incorporate age sensitivity factors and higher breathing rates for young children, which increase estimated residential cancer risk, commonly by a factor of about three. Risk values taken from the Handbook therefore understate risk as it would be calculated today.
• The DEIR's construction HRA treated two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west of the site, across El Toro Viejo Road, as residential receptors. The FEIR does not explain whether the 650-foot distance was measured to those receptors or to the mobile home park, and it provides no figure showing the station's location relative to the receptors.

Figure 22: Conceptual Site Plan Showing the Fueling Station on the Western Portion of the Site, Nearest El Toro Viejo Road
P a g e | 18
As an illustration only, a high-volume station contributing about 5 in one million at 300 feet under the older Handbook methods could contribute on the order of 15 in one million under the 2015 methods. Adding construction risk (1.5 in one million), truck and TRU activity, and one or more charbroiler restaurants could bring the Project's combined risk close to or above the 20 in one million threshold. The District requested a quantified operational HRA for this reason. The FEIR does not include one.

Figure 23: Gasoline Station Cancer Risk by Distance from CARB Handbook Values Cited in the FEIR, with Illustrative Adjustment for OEHHA 2015 Methods
The Airport Commerce Center comparison is not an analysis of this Project In Responses A2.2 and O2.24, the City relies on an HRA prepared for a warehouse project elsewhere in Kern County, which reported a cancer risk of 8.88 in one million from 824 daily truck trips. An HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project. That HRA also addressed truck emissions only. It did not include a gasoline station, charbroilers, or construction. Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.

P a g e | 19
Figure 24: FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15 (Airport Commerce Center comparison) Responses O2A-9 through O2A-13: Valley Fever
The City acknowledges that ground disturbance can aerosolize Coccidioides spores and that risk is elevated in dry, windy conditions and in years following drought. It relies on the Rule 8021 Dust Control Plan, general Cal/OSHA requirements, and Labor Code Section 6709 training, and it rejects active particulate monitoring because dust monitors "cannot detect the presence of biological agents" and because there is "no direct correlation" between dust concentrations and spore levels.9
Figure 25: Valley Fever Cases Reported in Kern County (CDPH) 9 FEIR, Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12, pp. 2.0-91 and 2.0-93.

P a g e | 20
Figure 26: FEIR Response O2A-9, p. 2.0-91
The City's position on dust and spores is contradictory In Response O2A-9 the City states that "fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever." In Response O2A-12 it states there is no direct correlation between dust concentrations and airborne spores. If dust suppression reduces spore exposure, as the City relies on, then airborne dust concentration is the relevant indicator of whether suppression is working. Coccidioides arthroconidia are approximately 2 to 5 micrometers in size and are released and carried with disturbed soil. My comment did not propose that monitors identify spores. The purpose of real-time perimeter monitoring of PM10 and PM2.5 is to provide an objective trigger for added watering or a work stoppage when fine dust leaves the site. On this site, the same monitoring would also track off-site transport of the PCBs, PAHs, and metals identified in the Land Use Covenant.

Figure 27: FEIR Response O2A-12, p. 2.0-93
P a g e | 21
Figure 28: Size of Coccidioides Arthroconidia Compared to PM2.5, PM10, and Coarse Soil Dust Visual opacity does not detect fine particles
The City notes that Rule 8021 requires dust controls before, during, and after dust-generating activity, and that the 20 percent opacity limit is a ceiling rather than a trigger. That is correct, but compliance is still judged by visual observation. Visible opacity is dominated by larger particles.

Fine particles in the respirable size range, which is where the spores fall, can be present at levels of health concern without a visible plume. The rule's requirement to control dust "before, during, and after" activities does not specify a watering frequency or any way to confirm that the controls are effective at the fence line.

The specific measures in my comments were not addressed Response O2A-13 refers back to Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12 and does not respond to any of the specific measures I proposed. The DEIR's CalEEMod runs for Phase 1 and Phase 2 construction credit no dust mitigation. As noted in my comments, CalEEMod estimates that watering exposed areas twice per day reduces PM10 and PM2.5 by 61 percent, and three times per day by 74 percent. Converting these practices into Project conditions is feasible and inexpensive.

The following should be adopted as enforceable conditions:

Figure 29: FEIR Response O2A-13, p. 2.0-95 (entire response to the proposed Valley Fever measures) P a g e | 22
Figure 30: Fugitive Dust Reductions from Watering Calculated by CalEEMod • watering of all disturbed areas at least three times per day, increased to four times per day when visible wind-driven dust is present;
• suspension of grading and excavation when sustained winds exceed 20 miles per hour; • covered haul loads with at least six inches of freeboard, and cleaning of equipment and vehicles before they leave the site;
• a Valley Fever section in each contractor's Injury and Illness Prevention Program, with NIOSH-approved respirators for workers near earth-moving equipment, clean eating and hand-washing areas, and separation of work and street clothing; and • a written protocol with a local medical provider for evaluating workers who develop symptoms consistent with Valley Fever.

General worker safety requirements do not protect nearby residents Title 8 Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144 are general requirements. None of them prescribes Valley Fever-specific engineering controls, respirator use, or medical protocols for this Project, and Labor Code Section 6709 requires training only. More importantly, these requirements apply only to workers. The City's responses do not address off-site residents at all, including the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park. Adults over 60 are among the groups at higher risk of severe and disseminated Valley Fever. Perimeter monitoring and wind shutdown requirements would reduce their exposure.

P a g e | 23
PART II. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO THE SJVAPCD COMMENTS
The District is the agency that oversees air quality issues in the San Joaquin Valley and has the expertise to determine if the impacts from a Project’s construction and operational phases are impactful. Several of the City's responses to the District decline the recommendations or substitute a different approach. The City also states elsewhere in the FEIR that the District's comments "did not raise any objections or concerns" regarding the cumulative air quality analysis, and that the District did not request that the Project's modeled risk be added to background risk.10 These statements are not consistent with the District's letter. The District told the City that only a construction HRA had been performed, that an operational HRA should be performed and combined with it, and that these modifications "have the potential to cause the Project to exceed District health risk thresholds." The District recommended that the HRA be revised. The City did not revise it.

Figure 32: FEIR Response O1.9, p. 2.0-30
Response A2.2: Operational Health Risk Assessment
The District asked for an operational HRA covering the gasoline station, charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA. The City did not prepare one. It instead relied on the CARB Handbook separation distance, the Airport Commerce Center HRA, a set of truck counts, and a qualitative acute hazard argument. As explained under Response O2A-7, the Handbook distance is misstated, the Airport Commerce Center HRA does not model this Project, the truck counts conflict with each other, and the acute hazard argument relies on a pollutant (DPM) that has no acute reference exposure level. The City's statement that the Project "with 191 estimated truck trips per day would not result in exceeding the SJVAPCD's significance thresholds" is not supported by any calculation in the FEIR.

The District also recommended, as a mitigation approach, that TAC sources be located an adequate distance from residences. The FEIR does not show the location of the gasoline station, drive-thru 10FEIR, Response O1.9, p. 2.0-30; Response O2.24, p. 2.0-60.

P a g e | 24
lanes, loading docks, or likely charbroiler restaurants relative to the receptors, so it is not possible to confirm that this recommendation has been followed.

Response A2.3: VERA Timing
The City revised MM AQ-1 to require execution rather than completion of the VERA before building permits are issued. The District's explanation for this change confirms that the emission reductions may be achieved after construction begins and possibly after operations begin. MM AQ-1 should be further revised to (1) require that the VERA specify a schedule under which the reductions are achieved no later than the end of the Project's first full year of operation, (2) require the District's verification to be provided to the City, and (3) require the developer to fund any shortfall if the scheduled reductions are not achieved. On-site measures should be applied first, as discussed under Response O2A-5.

Response A2.4: Under-Fired Charbroilers
The District recommended "a measure requiring the assessment and potential installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers." The District's stated purpose was both to protect nearby neighborhoods during stagnant conditions and to help the Valley attain the federal PM2.5 standards.

The City's CoA addresses only the first purpose, and only when a single tenant exceeds the cancer risk threshold. Given that the Project tract ranks in the 99th percentile for PM2.5, that the AAQA shows PM2.5 standards would be exceeded at nearby receptors, and that District incentive funding covers the full cost of control systems for two years, the District's measure should be adopted as written.

Figure 33: SJVAPCD Comment A2.4, FEIR p. 2.0-17
Figure 34: SJVAPCD Comment A2.4, FEIR p. 2.0-18 (District incentive funding) Response A2.5: Vegetative Barriers and Urban Greening
The City states that the Project's ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover would assist in reducing pollutant concentrations. Ornamental landscaping is not a vegetative barrier. The District P a g e | 25
described a barrier that is tall, thick, and has full coverage. U.S. EPA's guidance on vegetative barriers for near-road air quality (2016) likewise calls for dense, continuous vegetation from ground level to the top of the canopy, of sufficient height and depth, with no gaps. Scattered ornamental plantings can channel pollutants through gaps and provide little reduction.

Figure 35: FEIR Response A2.5, p. 2.0-19
Recommendation: A continuous evergreen vegetative barrier should be installed along the western boundary facing El Toro Viejo Road and the mobile home park, and adjacent to the gasoline station and drive-thru queuing lanes. Species should be drought tolerant, low in biogenic VOC emissions, and suited to the Bakersfield climate, and the barrier should be subject to a maintenance requirement.

Response A2.6: Electric Vehicle Infrastructure
The City relies on the CALGreen requirements and the Tier 2 voluntary standards in MM GHG-7. Tier 2 is largely met through EV-capable spaces rather than installed chargers. The District recommended that chargers be installed, including Level 3 (DC fast) chargers, and offers incentive funding for them through its Charge Up! program. For a regional retail center with a 40-position fuel station, a firm commitment to a specific number of installed DC fast chargers is feasible and would reduce emissions from customer trips.

Responses A2.7 through A2.13: District Rules and Regulations The City responded to each of these comments by stating that they are not comments on the physical environmental impacts of the Project. Two of these rules bear directly on the adequacy of the air quality analysis.

Rule 9510 (Indirect Source Review) requires reductions in construction and operational NOx and PM10 emissions through on-site design features or fees. The District stated that, as of its August 28, 2026 letter, it had not received the required Air Impact Assessment application for the Project.11 The FEIR does not explain how Rule 9510 reductions relate to the reductions credited to the VERA under MM AQ-1. The two programs should be accounted for separately so that the same reductions are not counted twice.
11FEIR, Comment A2.9, p. 2.0-21.

P a g e | 26
Figure 36: SJVAPCD Comment A2.9, FEIR p. 2.0-21
Rule 8021 (Regulation VIII) is the City's primary basis for concluding that Valley Fever and fugitive dust impacts would be less than significant. The City's statement in Response A2.12 is inconsistent with its reliance on this rule in Response O2A-9.

CONCLUSIONS
The facts identified above and referenced in this letter lead me to reasonably conclude that the City's responses do not resolve the issues raised in my comments nor in the District's comments, and that the Project could result in significant air quality and public health impacts that are not disclosed or mitigated in the FEIR. An operational health risk assessment, a corrected truck trip analysis, and the mitigation measures identified above should be completed before the Project is considered for approval and a subsequent FEIR should be prepared.

Sincerely,
James J.J. Clark, Ph.D.

Clark & Associates Environmental Consulting, Inc.

EXHIBIT B
1 1295 Hartford Avenue #8
White River Junction, VT 05001
Norman Marshall, President
(802) 356-2969
[email protected]
September 25, 2026
Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
520 Capitol Mall, Suite 350
Sacramento, CA 95814
Subject: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Dear Mr. Marshall,
In August 2026, I reviewed vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and trip generation impacts of the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”) dated July 2026 and made the following findings:
1) Both the retail and medical office components of the project would have significant VMT impacts that would not be fully mitigated by the measures listed in the DEIR. 2) CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) would provide additional VMT mitigation.
3) The DEIR mispresents the pass-by trip reduction for the gasoline service station component of the project.
4) Trip generation and the pass-by percentage for the gasoline service station are highly uncertain because the proposed project with 40 fueling stations is significantly different than the sites in the database.
5) The gasoline service station’s unique characteristics could result in more additional traffic and VMT than other smaller gasoline service stations.

Now I also have reviewed the responses to these comments in the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) dated September 2026. As discussed below, the FEIR fails to adequately address my comments. 2 Significant VMT and VMT Mitigation (Comment Areas #1 and #2) I commented that the DEIR did not include all feasible VMT mitigation. In particular, I cited CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) be included. This measure would achieve an up to 4.0% reduction in VMT. The Handbook states:

Voluntary CTR programs must include the following elements to apply the VMT reductions reported in literature.
• Employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home. • Information, coordination, and marketing for said services, infrastructure, and incentives (Measure T-7).

The FEIR response is simply that: “the proposed additional mitigation measures are practically infeasible as supported by substantial evidence in the Draft EIR.” (FEIR, p. 2.0-69) The DEIR does not include this “substantial evidence.” Instead it just asserts that feasible mitigation is included. The DEIR states:

Per the VMT analysis prepared, the Project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies. (DIEIR, p. 4.8-23)
The VMT analysis (DEIR Appendix H) similarly states:

The project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies consistent with State guidance and best practices (DEIR Appendix H, p. 6) No evidence is presented in the DEIR, DEIR Appendix H, or in the FEIR that other mitigation is infeasible.

In particular, no evidence is given that incorporating CAPCOA Measure T-5 is infeasible.

Trip Generation and VMT (Comment Areas #3, #4 and #5)
My August 2026 comments identified a discrepancy in the DEIR regarding pass-by trips and diverted trips:

DEIR Table 4.16-2 (p. 4.16-10) shows that the gasoline service stations would generate 10,196 daily trips including 816 internal capture trips and 7,316 pass-by trips.

The Traffic Study, DEIR Appendix H, states that there would be only 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips, for a total of 7,316 pass-by + diverted trips. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 361 of 984)
In the first excerpt, the DEIR incorrectly lumps pass-by and diverted trips together. This is important because diverted trips generate VMT and pass-by trips do not.

The FEIR acknowledges: “pass-by and diverted trips are distinct types of trips.” (FEIR p. 2.0-67) The split between the two categories given in the second excerpt is based on Costco data, which the DEIR and FEIR argue is the best basis for estimating trip generation for the proposed facility because of the unique aspects of Costco facilities. Nevertheless, rather than correcting the deficiency identified in 3 my August 2026 comments, the FEIR introduces high pass-by trip percentages for gas stations given in ITE Trip Generation. (FEIR, p. 2.0-67) It is likely that most Costco customers are Costco members that are more likely to divert to a Costco gas station as compared to the general population that would more likely stop at the most convenient gas station across all brands. Therefore, the ITE pass-by rates are not applicable to the proposed facility.

The discrepancy should be corrected.

Sincerely,
Norman L. Marshall

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
1 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program
SECTION 1: AUTHORITY
This environmental Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) has been prepared pursuant to Section 21081.6 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.), and CEQA Guidelines (14 Cal. Code Regs. Section 15000 et seq.) Sections 15091(d) and 15097, to ensure implementation of and provide for the monitoring of mitigation measures required of the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), as set forth in the Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) prepared for the Project. This report will be kept on file in the offices of the CEQA Lead Agency, the City of Bakersfield (City).

As noted in the EIR, the Project has been designed to avoid sensitive resources, as reflected in Project design plans and in Project Design Features. The EIR also addresses the potential environmental impacts of the Project, and, where appropriate, recommends mitigation measures to avoid or substantially lessen significant environmental impacts. The MMRP detailed in the following matrix table is designed to monitor and ensure implementation of all mitigation measures that are adopted for the Project.

The City is the lead agency for the Project and assumes ultimate enforcement responsibilities for implementation of all mitigation measures listed in this MMRP. The City may assign responsibility for implementation or monitoring to appropriate designees such as a construction manager or third-party monitor. However, as the lead agency, the City remains responsible for ensuring that implementation of the mitigation measures occurs in accordance with this MMRP. In some cases, the City is required to secure permits or approvals from third-party agencies in order to implement a mitigation measure. In these cases, the City is responsible for verifying that such permits or approvals have been obtained in accordance with the conditions stipulated in the mitigation measure. The City’s existing planning, engineering, operations, and procurement review and inspection processes will be used as the basic foundation for the MMRP procedures and will also serve to provide the documentation for the reporting program.

SECTION 2: MONITORING SCHEDULE
Prior to construction, while detailed design plans are being prepared by City staff or its agents, City staff will be responsible for ensuring compliance with mitigation monitoring applicable to the Project construction, development, and design phases. Once construction has begun and is underway, monitoring of the mitigation measures associated with construction will be included in the responsibilities of City staff, who shall prepare or cause to be prepared periodic monitoring reports as appropriate. Regulatory agencies will have to harmonize CEQA mitigation with regulatory permit conditions and monitoring/reporting as part of the regulatory permitting process and will likely require submittal of formal monitoring reports. Once construction has been completed, the City will monitor the project as specified in the mitigation measures or as otherwise deemed necessary. At minimum, the City will prepare a mitigation monitoring status report prior to commencing construction, prior to commencing operations, within 90 days of commencing operations, and following completion of the first full year of operations.

Exhibit A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
2 SECTION 3: SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION
Findings and related documentation supporting the findings involving modifications to mitigation measures shall be maintained in the Project file with the MMRP and shall be made available to the public upon request.

SECTION 4: FORMAT OF MITIGATION MONITORING MATRIX
The mitigation monitoring matrix on the following pages identifies the environmental issue areas for which monitoring is required, the required mitigation measures, the time frame for monitoring, and the responsible implementing and monitoring agencies.

SECTION 5: DEFINITIONS
The following list provides definitions for acronyms used in the MMRP.

Acronyms/Abbreviation Description
BUOW ............................................. Burrowing Owl CALGreen........................................ California Green Building Standards Code CBB.................................................. Crotch’s Bumble Bee CDFW.............................................. California Department of Fish and Wildlife CDFG............................................... California Department of Fish and Game CESA................................................ California Endangered Species Act City.................................................. City of Bakersfield DEIR ................................................ Draft Environmental Impact Report HM .................................................. Habitat management HVAC............................................... Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning ITP................................................... Incidental Take Permit PG&E............................................... Pacific Gas & Electric PMR ................................................ Paleontological Monitoring Report ROW................................................ Right-of-way SJKF ................................................. San Joaquin Kit Fox SJVAPCD.......................................... San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District State................................................ State of California SVP.................................................. Society of Vertebrate Paleontology USFWS ............................................ United States Fish and Wildlife Service VERA ............................................... Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement VOC................................................. Volatile Organic Compounds Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
3 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)

AIR QUALITY
MM AQ-1: Prior to issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall enter into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) to mitigate regional air quality impacts associated with emissions of VOC and NOX generated by operation of the proposed project. At minimum, the VERA shall be crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department, that verifies, to the City’s satisfaction, execution of the VERA.

Project Applicant Prior to issuance of
building permits
Construction
Manager

SJVAPCD
MM AQ-2: The project proponent/developer shall use paints and coatings with a VOC content of 25 grams per liter or less for all initial and future exterior coating and recoating of structures including parking lot striping.

This reduced VOC content requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate construction documents (e.g., construction management plan) and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to start of
construction
During Project
construction
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department

BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
MM BIO-1: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Pre-Construction Surveys. Prior to the commencement of ground-disturbing or vegetation-clearing activities, the project applicant/developer shall retain a qualified biologist to conduct pre-construction surveys for BUOW (Athene cunicularia) in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Depending on the time elapsed between the focused surveys conducted in support of the analysis conducted as a part of the biological resource assessment and the start of construction, additional focused surveys may be required during the survey season immediately preceding construction. As specified in the 2012 Staff Report, one 30-day pre-construction survey is recommended; however, multiple surveys may be necessary prior to construction to determine presence or absence, and burrowing owls may Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to
commencement of
ground-disturbing
or vegetation-clearing activities
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
4 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
colonize a site following previous negative survey results. Therefore, the project site shall be monitored 30 days prior to ground disturbance to detect any occupancy prior to construction activities.

MM BIO-2: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls. In the event a burrowing owl or known burrowing owl den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b), shall be necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
During construction City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed
MM BIO-3: Nesting Birds. If ground disturbing and vegetation clearing activities cannot be avoided during the nesting bird season (February 1 through September 15), a qualified biologist shall conduct a pre-construction nesting bird survey within all areas of breeding and nesting habitat within and adjacent to the Project Site no more than 10 days prior to initiation of Project activities that would remove vegetation or otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to start of
construction, no
more than 10 days
prior to initiation of
Project activities
that would remove
vegetation or
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
5 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
equipment) of all areas of the Project Site that could be directly or indirectly impacted by construction activity.

If nesting birds are encountered, the qualified biologist shall establish a baseline for the behavior of any identified nests and shall continuously monitor the nests to detect changes in behavior. Should behavioral changes occur, the Project proponent shall halt construction work causing that change and consult with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for additional avoidance and minimization measure.

If continuous monitoring of the identified nests by a qualified biologist is not feasible, a qualified biologist shall establish an avoidance buffer zone around the nest, which shall be determined by the qualified biologist according to species involved. At a minimum, a no-disturbance buffer of 250 feet shall be established around active nests of non-listed bird species and a 500-foot no-disturbance buffer shall be established around active nests of non-listed raptors. No activities that would adversely affect the nest shall occur within the buffer zone until the qualified biologist has determined the nest is no longer active, breading season is over, or the young are no longer dependent on the nest.
otherwise disturb
nesting activity
MM BIO-4: San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF) Pre-Construction Surveys. Pre-construction surveys to assess presence/absence of denning San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) shall be conducted by the qualified biologist no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days prior to the commencement of any ground disturbance and/or construction activities or any project activity likely to impact the SJKF. Surveys shall identify kit fox habitat features occurring on the project site (if any are determined to occur during the surveys) and evaluate use by SJKF and, if possible, assess the potential impacts to the kit fox by the proposed activity. If a natal/pupping den is discovered within the project site or within 200 feet of the project site boundary, the appropriate agencies (e.g., California Department of Fish and Wildlife, City of Bakersfield) shall be immediately notified and under no circumstances shall the den be disturbed or destroyed without prior authorization. If the preconstruction survey reveals an active natal pupping or new information, the project applicant, construction contractor and biologist Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to start of
construction, no
less than 14 days
and no more than
30 days prior to the
commencement of
any ground
disturbance and/or
construction
activities or any
project activity
likely to impact the
SJKF
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
6 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
shall contact the appropriate agencies immediately to obtain the necessary take authorization/permit. Written results of the preconstruction surveys shall be submitted to the appropriate agencies within five days after survey completion and prior to the start of ground disturbance and/or construction activities.

MM BIO-5: SJKF Avoidance Buffer. Prior to the commencement of any ground disturbing activities, the project applicant, construction contractor and project biologist shall implement no-disturbance buffers as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites identified during the pre-construction surveys outlined in Mitigation Measure BIO-4.

Project Applicant
Construction
Contractor
Project Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground
disturbing activities
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
MM BIO-6: SJKF Take Authorization. If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in Mitigation Measures BIO-5 are not feasible, the project applicant and California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) shall discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, the project applicant shall obtain take authorization from CDFW by obtaining an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081, subdivision (b), in compliance with the California Endangered Species Act.

Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground
disturbing activities
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed
MM BIO-7: Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Habitat Assessment. Prior to the commencement of any ground-disturbing activities, the qualified biologist shall conduct an additional habitat assessment to determine if the project site and immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal nesting burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, and hollow logs shall be documented as part of the assessment.

Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground-disturbing activities
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
MM BIO-8: CBB Surveys. If potentially suitable habitat is identified during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, a qualified biologist shall conduct focused surveys for CBB and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground-disturbing activities,
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
7 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).
during habitat
assessment
MM BIO-9: CBB Avoidance. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses shall be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities occur during the overwintering period October through February), consultation with CDFW shall be conducted to discuss how to implement the proposed project’s construction-related activities and avoid take of the CBB. Any detection of CBB prior to or during project construction shall warrant discussions with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground-disturbing activities,
during habitat
assessment
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed
MM BIO-10: CBB Take Authorization. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the proposed project and avoid take of the CBB. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit, pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

Project Applicant
Qualified Biologist
Prior to the
commencement of
any ground-disturbing activities,
during habitat
assessment
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
CDFW, if needed

CULTURAL RESOURCES
MM CUL-1: Inadvertent Discovery of Cultural Resources. If suspected cultural resources are encountered during ground disturbance activities, all work within 100 feet of the find shall immediately cease and the area cordoned off until a qualified cultural resource specialist that meets the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards can evaluate the find and make recommendations. If the specialist determines that the discovery represents a potentially significant cultural resource, additional investigations may be required. If cultural resources are discovered that may have relevance to Native Americans, the specialist or Project Applicant shall provide written notice to the City of Bakersfield, Native American Heritage Commission, and any other appropriate individuals, agencies, and/or groups as determined by the specialist in Project Applicant
Qualified Cultural
Resource Specialist
During
construction, if
suspected cultural
resources are
encountered during
ground disturbance
activities
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Qualified Cultural
Resource Specialist
Native American
Heritage
Commission, if
needed
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
8 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
consultation with the City of Bakersfield to receive input regarding treatment and disposition of the resource, which may include avoidance, testing, and/or excavation to prevent destruction of the resource and/or to allow documentation of the resource for research potential. All reports, correspondence, and determinations regarding the discovery shall be submitted to the California Historical Resources Information System’s Southern San Joaquin Valley Information Center at California State University Bakersfield.

Other appropriate
individuals,
agencies, and/or
groups as
determined by the
specialist in
consultation with
the City, if needed
MM CUL-2: Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains. During construction, if human remains are discovered, further ground disturbance shall be prohibited pursuant to California Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5. The specific protocol, guidelines, and channels of communication outlined by the Native American Heritage Commission, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5, Public Resources Code 5097.97, and Senate Bill 447 shall be followed. In the event of the discovery of human remains, at the direction of the county coroner, Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5(c) shall guide Native American consultation. Unless otherwise required by law, the site of any reburial of Native American human remains or associated grave goods shall not be disclosed and shall not be governed by public disclosure requirements of the California Public Records Act. The coroner, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r), parties, and Lead Agencies, will be asked to withhold public disclosure information related to such reburial, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r).

Project Applicant
Qualified Cultural
Resource Specialist
During
construction, if
human remains are
discovered
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Qualified Cultural
Resource Specialist
Coroner, if needed

GEOLOGY AND SOILS
MM GEO-1: Paleontological Discovery and Monitoring. In the event paleontological resources, including fossil discoveries, are encountered during construction of the Project, work shall halt within a 50-foot radius of the find and the City shall be immediately informed of the discovery. A qualified paleontologist shall be retained by the Applicant to evaluate the find before restarting work in the area. A qualified paleontologist is a Project Applicant
Qualified
Paleontologist
During
construction, in the
event
paleontological
resources, including
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
9 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
paleontologist who meets the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP) standards for Qualified Professional Paleontologist, which is defined as an individual preferably with an M.S. or Ph.D. in paleontology or geology, who is experienced with paleontological procedures and techniques, who is knowledgeable in the geology of California (preferably Southern California), and who has worked as a paleontological mitigation Project supervisor for a least one year. The City shall require that all paleontological resources identified on the Project site be assessed and treated in a manner determined by the qualified paleontologist. The qualified paleontologist shall be empowered to halt or divert ground disturbing activities.

If the discoveries are determined to be significant, full-time paleontological monitoring will be recommended for the remainder of ground disturbance for the Project. Paleontological monitoring shall entail the visual inspection of excavated or graded areas and trench sidewalls. In the event that any additional paleontological resources are discovered, the monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert the construction equipment around the find until it is assessed for scientific significance and collected, if warranted. Monitoring efforts can be reduced or eliminated at the discretion of the project paleontologist.

Upon completion of fieldwork, all significant fossils collected shall be prepared in a properly equipped paleontology laboratory to a point ready for curation. Following laboratory work, all fossil specimens shall be identified to the most specific taxonomic level possible, cataloged, analyzed, and first offered to the Buena Vista Museum then offered to the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County for permanent curation and storage. At the conclusion of laboratory work and museum curation, a final Paleontological Monitoring Report (PMR) shall be prepared describing the results of the paleontological mitigation monitoring efforts associated with the Project. The report shall include a summary of the field and laboratory methods, an overview of the project area geology and paleontology, a list of taxa recovered, an analysis of fossils recovered and fossil discoveries,
are encountered
Qualified
Paleontologist
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
10 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
their scientific significance, and recommendations. A copy of the report shall also be submitted to the Buena Vista Museum in Bakersfield.

GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
MM GHG-1: The project proponent/developer shall design and construct the proposed buildings to be all electric, with electricity to be the only permanent source of energy for all nonemergency building energy needs, including but not limited to water heating; mechanical equipment; and heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) (i.e., space-heating and space cooling). All major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. The only exception to this measure shall be limited to commercial cooking uses.

Prior to issuance of building permits for development projects, project proponent/developer shall provide plans that show the aforementioned requirements to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify installation of the electric-powered EnergyStar or equivalent appliances.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to issuance of
building permits
Prior to issuance of
the certificate of
occupancy
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
MM GHG-2: Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division demonstrating enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, such as the Pacific Gas & Electric’s (PG&E) 100% Solar Choice plan, for proposed project building(s) if such plan is available. If a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available, the property owner shall enroll in an energy plan with the next highest carbon-free electricity until a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan becomes available.

Measures to achieve 100 percent carbon-free electricity use may include, but are not limited to, plans for 100 percent renewable electricity. If such carbon-free electricity energy plans are waitlisted, the property owner may enroll in an available energy plan in the meantime but shall sign up for the waiting list for and enroll in a carbon-free electricity energy plan when it becomes available.

Property Owner Prior to issuance of
the certificate of
occupancy
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
11 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
MM GHG-3: All landscaping equipment (e.g., leaf blower) used for property management shall be electric-powered only. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase, rental, and/or services agreement) to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify that all landscaping equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

Property Owner Prior to issuance of
the first certificate
of occupancy
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
MM GHG-4: Any off-road equipment (e.g., forklifts) used in daily business operations shall be electric-powered. The project proponent/developer shall disclose this requirement to all tenants/business entities prior to the signing of any lease agreement. In addition, the limitation to use only electric-powered off-road equipment shall be included in all leasing agreements.

Prior to issuance of a Business License for a new tenant/business entity, the project proponent/developer and tenant/business entity shall provide a signed document (verification document) to the City of Bakersfield noting that the property owner has disclosed to the tenant/business entity the requirement to use only electric-powered equipment for daily operations. This verification document shall be signed by authorized agents for the project proponent/developer and tenant/business entities.

In addition, if applicable, the tenant/business entity shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase or rental agreement) to the City to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that any off-road equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to issuance of
a Business License
for a new
tenant/business
entity
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
MM GHG-5: The project proponent/developer shall coordinate with Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements (e.g., bus shelter) of up to two bus stops. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the project proponent/developer shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that coordination with Golden Empire Transit has been initiated.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to issuance of
the first certificate
of occupancy
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
12 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
MM GHG-6: The project proponent/developer shall install an end-of-trip shower facility. This end-of-trip shower facility requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate building plans and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify the installation of end-of-trip shower facility.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to issuance of
the certificate of
occupancy
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division
MM GHG-7: The project proponent/developer shall design the parking areas to comply with the Tier 2 Nonresidential Voluntary Measures of the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen), Division A5.1, Planning and Design, Section A5.106.5.3.4. This requirement shall be identified on all prepared building and site plans. The project proponent/developer shall submit these building and site plans that note this requirement to the City of Bakersfield Building Division prior to the issuance of construction permits.

Project
Proponent/Developer
Prior to issuance of
construction
permits
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
City of Bakersfield
Building Division

TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION
TRAF-PDF-1: Construction Traffic Management Plan. The contractor would develop a detailed Construction Traffic Management Plan as part of the Project, including provision of construction worker parking in designated areas, temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public rights-of-way, street closure information, detour plans, haul routes, and staging plans among other provisions. The contractor would submit the Construction Traffic Management Plan to the City of Bakersfield for approval. The Construction Management Plan would include the following:
• Scheduling workdays to begin and end prior to the morning and afternoon peak hours, respectively, to the extent feasible so as to avoid worker trips during those peak hours.
• Coordination with various City departments and offices to ensure adequate access to the Project Site and land uses in proximity of the Project Site is maintained.

Project Applicant
Contractor
Prior to issuance of
construction
permits
City of Bakersfield
Development
Services
Department
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
City of Bakersfield
13 Mitigation Measures/Project Design Feature
Responsibility for
Implementation Timing
Responsibility for
Monitoring
Monitor
(Signature Required)
(Date of
Compliance)
• Scheduling pick-ups, deliveries, and exports of construction materials so as to occur during off-peak hours. Hauling shall be from 9:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M. weekdays, and 8:00 A.M. to 4:00 P.M. on Saturdays. No hauling shall be performed on Sundays and holidays.
• Reduce the potential of trucks waiting for extended periods to load or unload.
• Provision of worker parking on-site or in designated off-site private parking areas and prohibition of construction-related vehicle parking on surrounding streets, other than the streets adjacent to the Project Site.
• Temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public ROWs to improve traffic flow on public roadways (e.g., flag personnel) and to maintain access for land uses in the vicinity of the Project Site. Determine the number and location of flag personnel required during traffic rerouting and deliveries.
• Contractor to post advance bilingual notification to adjacent property owners and occupants of upcoming construction activities, including durations and daily hours of operation, at several locations on the Project Site.
• Establish requirements for storage of materials and loading/unloading on the Project Site.
• Worksite traffic control plans approved by the City would be implemented to route vehicles, bicyclist and pedestrians around the area during any parking, travel lane or sidewalk closures and provide for protective measures for the public.
• Identification of a construction manager and provision of a telephone number for any inquiries or complaints from residents regarding construction activities. The telephone number shall be posted at the site readily visible to any interested party during site preparation, grading, and construction.
1 Statement of Overriding Considerations and Statement of Facts and Findings for Riverview Marketplace Project General Plan Amendment No. 23-001

SECTION I - INTRODUCTION
An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) (State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507) has been prepared for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (“Project”) in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.) and the State CEQA Guidelines (California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Section 15000 et seq.). The City of Bakersfield, Development Services Department – Planning Division is the Lead Agency for the Project under CEQA.

CEQA requires that the Lead Agency, before approving a project, identify each significant environmental impact of the project and make one or more written findings for each such impact.

Public Resources Code (PRC) Section 21002 provides that “public agencies should not approve projects as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures available which would substantially lessen the significant environmental effects of such projects.” PRC Section 21081 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 provide that no public agency shall approve or carry out a project for which an EIR has been certified that identifies one or more significant environmental effects of the project unless the public agency makes one or more written findings for each of those significant effects, accompanied by a brief explanation of the rationale for each finding.

Pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091, for each significant environmental impact identified in the EIR, the Lead Agency must make one or more of the following three possible findings:

1. Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR.

2. Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency.

3. Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible the mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR.

The findings reported herein are based on substantial evidence in the entire record before the Lead Agency. The references set forth in these findings to certain pages or sections of the Draft EIR or Final EIR are for ease of reference and are not intended to provide an exhaustive list of the evidence relied upon for these findings.

Exhibit B
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
2 For each environmental issue area analyzed in the EIR, the following information is provided:
• Description of Significant Effect(s) - A description of the significant environmental effect(s) identified in the EIR.
• Project Design Features (PDFs) - A list of applicable Project Design Features that are incorporated into the Project.
• Mitigation Measures (MMs) - A list of applicable mitigation measures that are required as part of the Project.
• Finding - One or more of the three findings set forth above, as appropriate. • Rationale for Finding - A summary of the reasons for the finding(s).

With respect to a project for which significant impacts are not avoided or substantially lessened either through the adoption of feasible mitigation measures or feasible environmentally superior alternatives, a public agency, after adopting proper findings based on substantial evidence, may nevertheless approve the project if the agency first adopts a statement of overriding considerations setting forth the specific reasons why the agency found that the project’s benefits rendered acceptable its unavoidable adverse environmental effects (California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Sections 15093 and 15043[b]; see also PRC Section 21081[b]).

SECTION II - ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW PROCESS
The environmental review process for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project included the following key steps:

Notice of Preparation. Pursuant to Section 15082 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City circulated a Notice of Preparation (NOP) of the Draft EIR to State, regional, and local agencies, and members of the public for a 32-day public review period. The public review period began Friday, October 31, 2025, and concluded Monday, December 1, 2025. The purpose of the NOP was to formally notice that the City was preparing a Draft EIR for the Project, and to solicit input regarding the scope and content of the environmental information to be included in the Draft EIR. Four written comment letters were received during the scoping period.

Scoping Meeting: The City also held an EIR Scoping Meeting for the Project on Thursday, November 20, 2025. The purpose of the EIR Scoping Meeting was for the City to solicit input and written comments from agencies and the public on environmental issues or alternatives they believe should be addressed in the Draft EIR. A presentation explaining the Project was provided and potential attendees were given an opportunity to provide their comments on the scope of the Draft EIR. No members of the public attended the EIR Scoping Meeting, and no comments were received at the meeting.

Draft EIR. The Draft EIR was published on July 10, 2026, and is incorporated herein by reference in full. The Draft EIR was circulated for a 45-day public comment period in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15105. The Draft EIR is a “Project EIR” as defined by Section 15161 of the CEQA Guidelines, which examines the environmental impacts of a specific development project. A Notice of Completion and Availability (NOCA) was distributed on July 10, 2026, to all property owners within 300 feet of the Project, which informed them where they could view the document Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
3 and how to comment. The Draft EIR was available to the public at the City of Bakersfield, Planning Division offices and the following local library: Kern County Beale Memorial library. A copy of the document was also posted online at https://www.bakersfieldcity.us/environmental-documents.

Notices were filed with the County Clerk on July 10, 2026. The NOCA was also sent with the Draft EIR to the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research State Clearinghouse for distribution to State Agencies and notice was provided in notice was provided in the Bakersfield Californian newspaper of general circulation
Final EIR. The Final EIR was published on September 18, 2026, which is hereby incorporated by reference in full. The Final EIR constitutes the second part of the EIR for the Project and is intended to be a companion to the Draft EIR. The Final EIR also incorporates the Draft EIR by reference. Pursuant to Section 15088 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City, as Lead Agency, reviewed all comments received during the review period for the Draft EIR and responded to each comment in Section II, Responses to Comments, of the Final EIR. On September 21, 2026, responses were sent to all public agencies that made comments on the Draft EIR at least 10 days prior to certification of the EIR pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15088(b).

Public Hearing. A noticed public hearing for the Project was conducted by the City Planning Commission on October 1, 2026.

SECTION III - RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
For purposes of CEQA and these Findings, the administrative record of proceedings for the Project consists of those items listed in CEQA Guidelines Section 15091(e), and includes, but is not limited to, the following documents:
• The Draft EIR for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (2025101507) and all appendices thereto;
• The Final EIR for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (2025101507), including all responses to comments, corrections, clarifications, and additions; • The Notice of Preparation (NOP) distributed on October 31, 2025, and all comments received in response thereto;
• All technical reports, studies, memoranda, maps, and other documents relied upon or referenced in the Draft EIR and Final EIR;
• All written comments submitted by agencies or members of the public during the public comment period on the Draft EIR;
• The Mitigation Monitoring Program (MMP)
• All testimony provided at public hearings on the Project; • The California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.) and the State CEQA Guidelines (California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Section 15000 et seq.);
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
4 • The Resolutions approved and adopted by the City in connection with the proposed Project, all documents incorporated by reference therein, and comments received after the close of the comment period and responses thereto;
All other documents referenced in or relied upon in the preparation of the Draft EIR and Final EIR, including but not limited to the City of Bakersfield General Plan, Municipal Code and all applicable specific plans, ordinances, and regulations.

SECTION IV - PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Project Overview
The Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six-foot-tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells, electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles, and several dirt roads and mounds.

The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

The Project would feature new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience and provide shade. The Project would also include enhanced paving areas within small plaza areas in front of storefronts, and enhanced vehicular paving at entry points. The Project would include a detention basin on the northern portion of the Project Site that would be fenced and screened with landscaping. Near the detention basin would be a play area which would include landscaped mounds, benches, picnic tables, bike racks, and a lawn area.

Loading and unloading of delivery trucks for the major retail buildings would occur in the designated loading dock of that building, which are toward the rear of the buildings. For the tenants of the outlying building pads, loading and unloading of delivery trucks would occur in designated areas (within proximity of the tenants) that would not impede the internal vehicular circulation system. No loading or unloading activities would occur in the parking areas or non-designated loading/unloading areas. The discretionary entitlements, reviews, permits, and Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
5 approvals required to implement the Project include, but are not necessarily limited to, the following:
• Site Plan Review consistent with the Bakersfield Municipal Code Section 17.08.140. • General Plan Amendment (GPA) of the land use element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan) from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) • Tentative Tract Map
• Comprehensive Sign Plan
Project Objectives
The objectives of the Project are as follows:
• A Project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City. • An infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. • A Project that encourages and facilitates new uses of high-quality architecture and design. • A mixture of commercial uses that provides new activity and services to the area and is cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities nearby. • Creation of new and future employment opportunities.
• A circulation system responsive to the needs of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian travel. • New native and drought-tolerant landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter.
• A visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

V. NO IMPACT OR LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT WITHOUT MITIGATION Substantial evidence in the record supports the determination in the EIR that the Project would have no impact or a less than significant impact in the following areas without the need for mitigation measures. Based on the analysis contained in the Draft EIR, the City finds that the following environmental topics would not be significantly affected by the Project.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
6 No Impact or Less Than Significant
Aesthetics
The Project Site is not located in an area designated as scenic in the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan; it is not within the City’s Hillside Development Combining Zone and is not within a City-designated Class I or II Visual Resource Area, Viewshed, or Slope Protection Area. The Project is not situated in one of the areas the City has recognized as featuring scenic vistas or along a scenic route as identified in the City’s General Plan. Accordingly, the Project would not block a view corridor of a scenic resource.

The construction of commercial uses at the Project Site would be in character and compatible with existing urban land uses in the vicinity of the Project Site and is a natural extension of the urban growth occurring in the Project area. The Project, once developed, would improve the visual conditions on the Project Site. The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. Building materials would include, but not be limited to, cement plaster with stone veneer, aluminum wood siding metal canopies, and large display windows. Careful and judicial use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site. Along the Coffee Road frontage and Rosedale Highway frontages would run a “dry creek” feature composed of decorative cobbles, decomposed granite and crushed rocks. The Project would feature new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site.

Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian-oriented experience, and provide shade. Therefore, the Project would not have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista, and impacts are less than significant.

The Project Site is located within an urban area, surrounded by existing development. According to the Caltrans California State Scenic Highway System Map, the Project Site is not located within a scenic highway. The nearest eligible State scenic highway in Kern County is the Cuyama Highway State Route 166 (SR 166) located approximately 40-miles southwest of the Project Site.

Therefore, no impact would occur.

The Project would be consistent with the goals and policies of the General Plan as it relates to new commercial development. The Project proposes to transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would provide a visual improvement to the Project Site compared to existing conditions. The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. Buildings would have a maximum height of 90 feet (60 feet below the maximum building height for the M-2 zoning district). Accordingly, the Project, would comply with the applicable zoning requirements pertaining to scenic quality and impacts would be less than significant.

The Project Site is located in an urbanized area of the City, which includes nighttime lighting associated with the surrounding land uses. This includes street lighting, parking lot lighting, and lights from vehicles. Nearby light sensitive receptors consist of residential developments to the west, southwest, and north of the Project Site.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
7 Construction activities would be limited to daytime hours per BMC Section 9.22.050: 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Friday, and 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM on weekends and holidays.

Construction activities would not require nighttime illumination. Daytime construction equipment may produce temporary glare from metal surfaces; however, these effects would be short-term, intermittent, localized to the Project Site, and typical of construction activities in urbanized areas. As construction would not occur outside permitted hours and would not require nighttime lighting, construction-related light and glare impacts would be less than significant.

Operational lighting for the Project is intended to minimize light trespass and glare from the Project Site onto adjacent properties and to provide safety and nighttime visibility through shielded, focused, and directed illumination. Lighting would consist of exterior building-mounted light fixtures; interior lighting for the new building; lighting for pedestrian walkways and common gathering areas; lighting for the green spaces; ground-mounted decorative lighting for landscape and architectural features; signage lighting; lighting for the new parking areas, drive aisles, and loading dock areas; and security lighting.

All new light sources associated with the Project would be required to comply with the Bakersfield Municipal Code for exterior lighting standards, which prevent light spillover, glare, nuisance, inconvenience, or hazardous interference of any kind on adjacent properties and streets. Mandatory compliance with the Bakersfield Municipal Code would ensure that the Project’s light fixtures and signage would not introduce any design features that would cause artificial light or glare to an extent that would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area.

Thus, potential lighting and glare impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Aesthetics.

Agriculture and Forestry Resources
The Project site is located within an urban area, surrounded by existing development, and is not currently in use for agricultural activities or forest uses. Based on a review of the California Important Farmland Finder, neither the Project Site nor any adjacent land is designated as Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance. Instead, the Project Site and adjacent land are designated as “Vacant and Disturbed Land” and “Urban and Built-Up Land,” with the exception of an approximately 17-acre parcel of “Semi-Agricultural and Rural Commercial Land,” which is not considered protected farmland. As such, the Project would not convert any Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance to a non-agricultural use. Neither the Project Site nor its surroundings are zoned for agriculture or forest land.

The Project would not result in the conversion of farmland to non-agricultural use or the conversion of forest land to non-forest use. No impacts to agriculture and forestry resources. would occur.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact to Agriculture and Forestry Resources.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
8 Air Quality (Pollutant Concentrations)
The Project would develop retail and commercial (e.g., medical office, and health club) land uses.

Operation of the proposed uses could include occasional use of landscaping equipment and natural gas consumption for commercial cooking uses. However, air pollutant emissions generated from these activities would be nominal.

The Project would include a gas station with up to 40 fuel dispensers. CARB recommends avoiding siting gas stations within 500 feet of sensitive land uses to avoid exposing sensitive receptors to substantial concentration of air pollutants. The nearest potential sensitive land uses to the proposed gas station would be the two buildings across El Toro Viejo Road, approximately 650 feet to the west, which would be outside the 500-foot buffer. Furthermore, emissions of contaminants (TACs) from stationary sources that may be associated with the proposed uses (e.g., restaurant chain-driven char broiler), including the proposed gas station, would be subject to further study and health risk assessment prior to the issuance of any necessary air quality permits. Regulations would ensure that stationary source emissions (permitted sources) would be reduced or mitigated below San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD). significance thresholds of 20 in one million cancer risk and one for acute risk at the maximally exposed individual.

While the Project could generate heavy-duty truck travel along the local roadways, the Project would only incrementally increase average daily trips for all vehicle types along the local roadways. Because the Project would not have any warehousing uses and would primarily consist of retail, restaurant, and commercial uses, it is anticipated that Project-related traffic volumes would primarily consist of passenger vehicles associated with patrons. Thus, the incremental increase in vehicle trips that could result from implementation of the proposed Project would be below roadway volumes identified by the California Air Resources Board (CARB) land use siting screening criteria to avoid exposing sensitive receptors to substantial concentrations of air pollutants from vehicles traveling along roadway. Therefore, operation of the Project would not expose nearby off-site sensitive receptors to substantial concentrations of TACs. Potential impacts would be less than significant.

CO Hotspots
Areas of vehicle congestion have the potential to create pockets of CO called hotspots. These pockets have the potential to exceed the State 1-hour standard of 20 ppm or the 8-hour standard of 9.0 ppm. Hotspots are typically produced at intersections, where traffic congestion is highest because vehicles queue for longer periods and are subject to reduced speeds. However, emissions from motor vehicles, the largest source of CO emissions, have been declining since 1985, despite increases in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT), due to the introduction of new automotive emission controls and fleet turnover.

Furthermore, under existing and future vehicle emission rates, a project would have to increase traffic volumes at a single intersection to more than 44,000 vehicles per hour—or 24,000 vehicles per hour where vertical and/or horizontal air does not mix—in order to generate a significant CO impact. Overall, implementation of the Project would result in overall peak hour turning volumes Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
9 that would not produce the volume of traffic required to generate a CO hotspot. Therefore, implementation of the Project would not have the potential to substantially increase CO hotspots at intersections in the vicinity of the Project Site. Impacts would be less than significant.

Construction Health Risks to Off-Site Receptors
The maximum incremental cancer risk levels during the construction phase of the Project at the Maximum Exposed Individual Resident (MEIR) and Maximum Exposed Individual Worker (MEIW) are 1.5 per million and 0.3 per million, respectively, which would not exceed the cancer risk significance threshold of 20 in one million. For noncarcinogenic effects, the hazard index identified for each toxicological endpoint totaled less than one for the MEIR and MEIW.

Therefore, chronic noncarcinogenic hazards are within acceptable limits, and project-related construction activities would not expose nearby sensitive receptors to substantial pollutant concentrations. Impacts would be less than significant.

Air Quality (Objectionable Odors)
The type of facilities that are considered to have objectionable odors include wastewater treatment plants, compost facilities, landfills, solid waste transfer stations, fiberglass manufacturing facilities, paint/coating operations (e.g., auto body shops), dairy farms, petroleum refineries, asphalt batch plants, chemical manufacturing, and food manufacturing facilities. The uses proposed by the Project do not fall within these land uses.

During project-related construction activities, construction equipment exhaust and application of asphalt and architectural coatings would temporarily generate odors. However, any construction-related odor emissions would be temporary and intermittent. Additionally, noxious odors would be confined to the immediate vicinity of the construction equipment. By the time such emissions reached any sensitive receptor, they would be diluted to well below any level of air quality concern. Furthermore, short-term construction-related odors are expected to cease upon the drying or hardening of odor-producing materials. Thus, overall, construction and operation of the Project are not expected to generate odors that would adversely affect a substantial number of people. Impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Air Quality (Objectionable Odors and Pollutant Concentrations).

Biological Resources (Riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community) The Project site is highly disturbed. There are no wetlands or riparian habitats found on or near the Project Site. The November 2025 survey completed for the Project confirmed that there are no wetlands or riparian habitats found on the Project Site. Aerial images indicated and the November 2025 field survey confirmed that an underground stormwater feature exists near the east border of the Project Site. The feature carries water that flows from four culverts to the southeast of the Project Site from south to north. However, the General Biological Assessment determined that this stormwater feature exists underground and is not jurisdictional waters.

Therefore, no impacts to jurisdictional waters would occur from Project implementation.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
10 Accordingly, jurisdictional waters would not be impacted by Project implementation and no impact to any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community identified would occur.

Biological Resources (Wetlands)
The Project would not impact riparian areas, vernal pools or other jurisdictional aquatic resources because these features do not occur on or near the Project Site. As noted above, an underground drainage feature was identified underneath the Project Site, but this is not considered a protected wetland. Therefore, no impacts would occur.

Biological Resources (Wildlife Movement)
No wildlife movement corridors were found to be present on the Project Site. The Project Site is relatively flat and does not contain mountain canyons or riparian corridors nearby, which are typically used by wildlife for movement. There are no water features on the Project Site that would support the movement of native or migratory fish. Furthermore, the Project Site is an urbanized environment and is blocked off on the east end by railroad tracks and a residential area to the west. However, urban SJKF can move through disturbed open land between developed parcels. The open 46.16-acre Project area may therefore function as a local stepping-stone or permeable movement area. With the implementation of MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3, impacts to nesting birds would be avoided and impacts would be less than significant. To avoid impacts to Crotch’s Bumble Bee and the San Joaquin Kit Fox, MM BIO-4-10 would be implemented
Biological Resources (Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community Conservation Plan)
The Project Site is not located within the boundaries of an approved and active State or federal Habitat Conservation Plan. The Metropolitan Bakersfield Habitat Conservation Plan (MBHCP) and associated Incidental Take Permit (ITP) expired on January 1, 2023. As such, the Project must comply with direct requests from U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) or California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW).

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Biological Resources (Riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community, wetlands, wildlife movement, Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community Conservation Plan) Cultural (Historic Resource)
The records search conducted for the Project have revealed that 20 previous cultural resource studies have taken place, and 14 cultural resources have been identified within one-half mile of the Project Site. Three of the previous studies assessed portions of the Project Site for cultural resources, and one resource (a historic-period refuse scatter designated P-15-3290) was previously identified within the Project Site boundaries; however, during the field survey conducted as part of the Cultural Resources Assessment, the resource was not able to be located and assumed to be destroyed. Four additional historic-period cultural resources were identified and evaluated against the California Register. These identified resources were recommended not Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
11 eligible for the California Register and therefore are not considered a historic resource under CEQA consistent with CEQA Guidelines Section 15064.5. As such, impacts to historical resources would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Historic Resources.

Energy
To limit wasteful and unnecessary energy consumption from transportation, the construction contractors would minimize nonessential idling of construction equipment during construction in accordance with 13 CCR Article 4.8, Chapter 9, Section 2449, which limits nonessential idling of diesel-powered off-road equipment to five minutes. Moreover, all construction equipment would cease operating upon completion of the Project construction. Thus, energy use during the construction of the proposed Project would not be considered inefficient, wasteful, or unnecessary.

During operation, the Project would result in electricity demand; however, it would be designed and built to meet the current Building Energy Efficiency Standards and CALGreen, which would contribute to increasing energy efficiency. In accordance with the 2025 Building Energy Efficiency Standards, the proposed Project would install rooftop PV systems and battery storage systems.

Furthermore, compliance with CALGreen would contribute to reducing indoor water use, which would also contribute to minimizing electricity demand from the transport and distribution of water. Thus, electricity use from the operation of the proposed Project would not be considered inefficient, wasteful, or unnecessary. Development pursuant to the proposed Project would result in a net increase in natural gas demand. The proposed Project would be built to meet the current Building Energy Efficiency Standards and CALGreen, which would contribute to optimizing the energy efficiency of the proposed buildings.

While the operation of the Project would result in fuel usage, the Project Site is within a half mile of bus stops for three Golden Empire Transit bus routes and would be accessible from the existing surrounding sidewalks and class II bike lanes along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road. The proposed Project would also provide bicycle parking and lockers. These amenities could contribute to minimizing vehicle trips and VMT. In addition, fuel efficiency standards for automobiles are established nationwide under the Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards and ensure that vehicles produced in future years have greater fuel efficiency, and generally result in an overall benefit of reducing fuel usage by providing the population of the City and region with more fuel-efficient vehicle options. Thus, it is expected that operation-related fuel usage associated with the Project would not be considered inefficient, wasteful, or unnecessary.

The Project would be subject to the 2026 Building Energy Efficiency Standards and, in compliance with those standards, would install battery storage and rooftop PV systems. These systems would support the statewide transition to renewable energy. Therefore, implementation of the Project would not conflict with or obstruct plans for renewable energy and energy efficiency.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
12 Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Energy.

Geology and Soils (Excluding Paleontological Resources) The Geotechnical Investigation concluded that all geologic and seismic hazards, including fault rupture, seismic ground shaking, liquefaction, settlement, lateral displacement, landslides, flooding, tsunamis, erosion, and subsidence, present low risk with mandatory compliance with applicable regulatory requirements and incorporation of the recommendations included in the Geotechnical Investigation.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Geology and Soils (Excluding Paleontological Resources).

Hazards and Hazardous Materials
A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (Phase I ESA), a Soil Vapor Sampling Report (Soil Vapor Report) and an Engineering Review of Plugged & Abandoned Oil & Gas Wellbores “REID-KCL” #1 and #3 (Well Engineering Report), were prepared for the Project.

The Phase I ESA determined that there is one controlled recognized environmental condition (CREC) in connection with the Project Site, and no additional assessment is recommended at the Project Site. The PG&E Kern Power Plant was formerly present in the southern portion of the Project Site, which was demolished, assessed, and remediated under the oversight of the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board (CVRWQCB). The case was closed on June 3, 2019, with a recorded Land Use Covenant. Additionally, the Project Site had oil wells, which have been plugged and abandoned under CalGEM oversight. Additionally, as identified in the Soil Vapor Report, given the site-wide lack of detections and prior site closure, no further assessment is recommended for soil vapor at the Project Site. As such, no hazards currently exist on the Project Site that could affect construction.

All construction activities would comply with laws, regulations, and policies governing the use of hazardous materials, ensuring that Project implementation would not serve to increase public or environmental exposure to hazardous materials and preventing impacts related to accident or upset conditions. In addition, the City’s development review process ensures that land use compatibility as it relates to hazards is examined and enforced in the entitlement process.

While Valley Fever is associated with soil disturbance, impacts associated with Valley Fever are related to the Coccidioides fungal spore, which is a biological agent. In general, a CEQA-level air quality framework and analysis evaluate potential impacts associated with criteria air pollutants and toxic air contaminants, which are chemical pollutants. However, ground disturbing activities can aerosolize fungal spores present in project soils, creating a potential inhalation exposure pathway. Risk is generally elevated during dry, windy conditions and in years following drought (dry soil is more easily aerosolized), and disturbance of previously undisturbed or long-undisturbed soils poses higher risk than disturbance of soils that have been recently worked.

Fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever. Because the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
13 proposed Project is a non-residential project that would disrupt more than five acres of land, it would be subject to San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) Rule 8021 to minimize fugitive
dust during construction activities. Under Rule 8021, the proposed Project would be required to prepare Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project and submit a Dust Control Plan (DCP) to the SJVAPCD for approval. The DCP would be required to detail specific actions to ensure that visible dust emissions do not exceed 20 percent opacity. These actions can include watering areas of soil disturbance and use of dust suppressants. Compliance with Rule 8021 would help minimize generation of fugitive dust.

In addition, construction contractors would be subject to California Occupational Safety and Health requirements enforced through California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) oversight. Under Section 3203, Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (Title 8 CCR Section 3203), construction employers for the proposed project would be required to identify workplace hazards, implement a system to communicate occupation safety and health-related matters to employees, and implement a system to ensure employees comply with safe and healthy work practices. Title 8 CCR Section 5141 would require construction employers to implement appropriate engineering controls to control harmful exposure to employees while Title 8 CCR Section 5144 would oversee use of respirators for employers when necessary to protect their health. Because Kern County is identified as a highly endemic region for Valley Fever under California Labor Code Section 6709, construction contractors for the Project would be required to provide training and awareness on Valley Fever for the employees pursuant to the Section. Overall, implementation of SJVAPCD fugitive dust control measures and compliance with workplace occupational safety and health requirements and Cal/OSHA oversight would minimize potential Valley Fever exposure to construction workers and no significant impacts would occur.

Project operations would likely involve typical hazardous materials/chemicals such as cleaners, paints, solvents, and fertilizers and pesticides for site landscaping for most of the commercial uses, and regular use of hazardous materials during operation of the gas station and car wash.

Any routine transport, use, and disposal of these materials during Project operations would adhere to federal, State, and local regulations for the transport, handling, storage, and disposal of hazardous substances. Therefore, with adherance to these mandatory requirements, the Project would not pose a significant threat related to the release of hazardous materials into the environment. Impacts would be less than significant.

As identified in the Phase I ESA, the Project Site is neither on the Cortese List currently or historically. However, eastern adjacent property at 2152 Coffee Road previously operated as an oil refinery (Sunland Refining/ World Oil Corp.) and is associated with four open Cleanup Program Site cases, with potential impacts to soil, soil vapor, and/or groundwater. However, based on the distance to the remaining soil, soil vapor, and groundwater impacts (approximately 980 feet away), this site is considered a de minimis condition with respect to the Project Site. Accordingly, Project construction and operation would not create a significant hazard to the public or the environment. Impacts would be less than significant.

The Project is not located within two miles of a public airport, which would result in a safety hazard or excessive noise for people residing or working in the Project area. According to the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
14 California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE), the Project Site is not within or in proximity to a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone (VHFHSZ). The Project Site is located within a Local Responsibility Area and currently receives fire protection services through a Joint Powers Agreement with Bakersfield Fire Department (BFD) and Kern County Fire Department (KCFD).

Calls for service from the Project Site would be addressed by KCFD. No aspect of the Project would prevent the implementation of the Kern Multi Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan (MJHMP) and Emergency Operations Plan.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Hazards and Hazardous Materials.

Hydrology and Water Quality
The Project would be required to comply with all applicable federal, State, and local regulations pertaining to surface water and groundwater quality, including the General Permit requirements under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) program for stormwater discharges. Construction activities subject to the General Permit include clearing, grading, stockpiling, and excavation. To conform to the requirements of the General Permit, a Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) would need to be prepared that specifies Best Management Practices (BMPs) to prevent construction pollutants from moving offsite, as well as establish measures to reduce the potential for erosion.

The Project’s operational urban stormwater discharges are covered under the Central Valley Water Quality Control Board (CVRWQCB) National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit and Waste Discharge Requirements General Permit for Discharges from Municipal Separate Storm Sewer Systems (Order No. R5-2016-0040; NPDES No. CAS0085324) (MS4 Permit). The MS4 Permit mandates the implementation of a stormwater management framework to ensure that water quality is maintained within the City because of operational stormwater discharges throughout the City, including the Project Site. By complying with the General Permit and MS4 Permit, the project would not violate any water quality standards or waste discharge requirements, and impacts would be less than significant.

The Water Supply Assessment completed for the Project includes projections for 2025 through 2040 that show that the Project’s Domestic Water System can adequately meet the Project's demand without depleting groundwater or affecting its overall quality. Accordingly, the Project would not significantly impact local groundwater recharge or impede sustainable groundwater management of the basin.

The Project Site is located within Zone X, which denotes an area with reduced flood risk. While upon completion of construction, the amount of impervious surface on the Project Site would be increased when compared to existing conditions, the Project’s drainage facilities would be designed to ensure that all on- and off-site drainage and storm drain facilities would be adequately sized to accommodate runoff from storm events consistent with the recommendations included in the Drainage Study prepared for the Project. Additionally, the proposed Project would not alter the course of a stream or river that would result in flooding.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
15 Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Hydrology and Water Quality.

Land Use and Planning
The Project Site is surrounded by Rosedale Highway and the Northwest Promenade to the north; a PG&E electric substation and vacant land to the south; El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a PG&E electric substation to the west; and Coffee Road, Friant-Kern Canal, and a commercial retail center to the east. The Project would not include the development of new obstacles that would divide the existing community. Additionally, the Project would connect to the existing roadway system and other infrastructure and would not involve the reconfiguration of streets that could have the potential to alter the surrounding pattern of future development.

The Project’s proposed commercial center would be consistent with the surrounding commercial uses, as well as the amended General Plan designation and current zoning designation, thus implementing the City’s vision for the area.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Land Use and Planning.

Mineral Resources
The Project Site does not serve as an active mining site, nor is there any mining activity in the Project vicinity. Additionally, all wells located on site have been permanently plugged and abandoned. Moreover, the Project does not propose operations that would encroach upon existing oil operations The Project Site is not designated as Mineral and Petroleum (R-MP), which is a land use designation utilized for areas which contain producing, or potentially productive, petroleum fields and mineral deposits. Therefore, the Project would not result in the loss of availability of a locally important mineral resource recovery site and there would be less than significant impacts. No mitigation is required.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Mineral Resources.

Noise
Construction noise levels associated with the Project were modeled and were found to be below the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) thresholds for residential and commercial uses.

Therefore, Project related construction noise impacts would be less than significant. As concluded in the Noise analysis prepared for the Draft EIR, operational noise impacts that include operation of the car wash, commercial uses, unloading and loading, mechanical equipment, drive-thru, and related traffic operations were found to be less than significant.

Construction vibration levels would be below thresholds for vibration levels and any related architectural damage vibration impacts would be less than significant. Commercial uses would not be immediately adjacent to vibration-sensitive uses and no significant vibration impacts Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
16 would occur from vibration generated by operation of the Project. Therefore, Project related operational vibration impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Noise.

Population and Housing
The Project would not displace existing people. The Project proposes the development of a commercial retail center and does not include a residential component that would result in an increase of residents and population within the City. As such, the Project would not directly induce population growth.

Indirectly, the Project does not propose the extension of roads or existing infrastructure that would result in indirect growth within the City. The Project is expected to require 969 employees.

Although operation of the Project would provide employment opportunities in the local area, the Project would not require a specialized labor force that would draw large numbers of new employees to the area. Based on the existing unemployment rates in the City and County, any new employees would already be located within the City limits and would not relocate to the Bakersfield area specifically to obtain jobs associated with the Project. Thus, employees would likely be drawn from the existing population. Therefore, an increased demand for housing to accommodate workers would not occur due to Project operations. Impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Population and Housing.

Public Services
Project development and operation would result in an incremental increase in demand for fire protection services. However, as a proposed commercial development with no residential component, the Project is unlikely to have a substantial effect on the existing ratio of firefighters to residents and would result in a less than significant increase on the demand for fire protection services. Additionally, the Project would be constructed pursuant to code requirements and industry standards that include regulatory requirements that would aid in fire safety and support fire suppression activities, such as a fire protection system, automatic fire sprinklers, paved access, and required aisle widths that would be subject to review by the BFD and the KCFD.

Further, the Project would be subject to applicable development impact fees relating to fire protection. Accordingly, the Project would not result in the need for new or physically altered fire protection facilities, and any impact to fire protection would be less than significant.

As a commercial development, the Project development and operation could result in an incremental increase in demand for police protection services as the development would draw new customers and visitors to the Project that could result in increased amount of police demand. However, it is likely that individual stores would include security and anti-theft measures that would reduce calls for service. Therefore, it is unlikely the proposed Project would generate the number of calls necessary to negatively affect service ratios, response times, or Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
17 other police department performance objectives. Additionally, the Project would also be subject to applicable development impact fees that would fund police services and facilities to meet future demand. Accordingly, the Project would not result in the need for new or physically altered police department facilities, and any impact to police protection would be less than significant Regarding impacts to schools, the Project would develop a commercial development and would not require development of new housing. It is anticipated that future employees of the Project would reside within the City and immediately surrounding area. Therefore, the Project is not anticipated to result in substantial, unplanned population growth.

The State of California requires payment of development impact fees to mitigate project impacts to school facilities (CGC Section 65996; SB 50). All new residential, commercial, and industrial construction and/or an addition of covered or enclosed space are subject to the collection of developer fees. This fee is determined by the square footage of assessable space, which is measured from the perimeter of the structure. These fees pay for facility expansion and upgrades needed to serve new students. It is not anticipated that the proposed Project would generate any new students nor increase demand for school services. Moreover, payment of impact fees in compliance with State law would mitigate any impact to school facilities. Therefore, impacts would be less than significant.

It is anticipated that future employees would continue to use park facilities near their homes and use of parks or other recreational facilities close to the Project Site would be nominal.

Accordingly, the Project is not anticipated to affect service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for parks and would not require the construction of any new or altered park facility. Therefore, impacts to parks would be less than significant.

Kern County Library operates libraries in close proximity to the Project Site, including the Southwest Branch Library, located at 8301 Ming Avenue, approximately 2.6 miles southwest of the Project Site. As discussed, it is anticipated that future employees of the proposed Project would reside within the City and immediately surrounding area. The Project would not result in substantial unplanned population growth, affecting service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for other services such as libraries. Therefore, impacts to other services would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Public Services.

Recreation
Increase in the demand for existing neighborhood and regional parks or other recreational facilities typically occurs due to an increase in the residential population. The Project does not include residential components, and it is anticipated that future employees would reside within the City and immediately surrounding area. Accordingly, the proposed Project would not result in an increase in population and would not increase demand on existing recreational facilities to a degree that new or expanded recreational facilities would be required. Therefore, the Project would not require the construction of new or expansion of existing recreational facilities beyond Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
18 what is proposed on-site that could result in an adverse physical effect on the environment. Any impact would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Recreation.

Transportation, (Plan, Ordinance or Policy, Hazardous Geometric Design) The Project would be required to provide infrastructure improvements needed to meet the demand created by the development and provide off-site improvements designed to ensure the construction of the local and regional transportation networks to their ultimate classifications.

These improvements could be funded through a development fee payment towards adopted funding mechanisms such as the Metropolitan Bakersfield Regional Transportation Impact Fee (RTIF) program. If the improvements are not identified in the RTIF, they are considered local improvements, and the Project will pay its fair share contribution towards the cost of these improvements. All required improvements for the Project are already included as part of the design or would be funded by the Bakersfield RTIF program, which the Project applicant would be responsible for contributing to. Therefore, no additional improvements or mitigation would be required and the Project would be consistent with General Plan LOS requirements. As the Project would not conflict with a program, plan, ordinance, or policy addressing the circulation system, including transit, roadway, bicycle, and pedestrian facilities, impacts would be less than significant.

The proposed Project driveways and internal drive aisles would be constructed pursuant to the City’s design standards and subject to review by BFD and KCFD, which have an existing Joint Powers Agreement (JPA) to provide emergency services to the Project Site. Sight distance at each of the Project’s access point would be reviewed with respect to standard California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) sight distance standards at the time of preparation of final grading, landscape, and street improvement plans. In consideration of regulatory requirements and the improvements, the Project would not substantially increase hazards due to a geometric design feature or incompatible land use. Therefore, impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Transportation (Plan, Ordinance or Policy, Hazardous Geometric Design).

Utilities and Service Systems
As detailed in the Water Supply and Demand Analysis, Sewer Area Study and technical report addressing energy that were prepared for the Project, the Project’s potable water, wastewater, stormwater, electricity, natural gas, and telecommunications demands can all be met by existing municipal and utility infrastructure with only standard on-site connections or minor improvements in previously disturbed area, and without the need for new or expanded off-site facilities that could cause significant environmental effects, therefore, impacts related to utilities and service systems would be less than significant. In addition, adequate water, sewer, drainage, energy and telecommuting infrastructure exists to serve the Project. Furthermore, the Project Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
19 would not require or result in the relocation or construction of new or expanded water or wastewater treatment facilities.

Construction associated with the Project would result in solid waste associated primarily with grading activities. There would be limited construction demolition debris. CALGreen requires builders/owners to divert 65 percent of construction waste from landfills (by recycling, reusing, and other waste reduction strategies), consistent with the State’s solid waste reduction goals.

The Project also would be subject to compliance with applicable construction-related provisions of Chapter 8.32, Refuse, Solid Waste, and Recycling, of the City’s Municipal Code. As such, the Project would not generate solid waste in excess of State or local standards or otherwise impair the attainment of solid waste reduction goals, and impacts would be less than significant.

The Project would be served by the Metropolitan Sanitary Landfill/Bena Landfill, operated by the Kern County Public Works Department. This Class III municipal solid waste facility has a permitted maximum throughput of 4,500 tons per day and an estimated remaining capacity of approximately 22 million tons, equating to approximately 21 years of operation at current disposal rates.

Regarding the Project’s operation, the Project would generate an estimated disposal volume of 474 tons per year (1.3 tons/day). This generation represents approximately 0.03 percent of the landfill’s permitted daily throughput and an even smaller fraction of its remaining capacity. Given the minimal contribution of both operational and construction solid waste relative to available landfill capacity, the fact that the waste stream is accounted for in the County Integrated Waste Management Plan, and the Project’s compliance with all applicable waste reduction and diversion requirements, the Project would not generate solid waste in excess of state or local standards, exceed the capacity of local infrastructure, or impair the attainment of solid waste reduction goals. Therefore, impacts would be less than significant, and no further analysis is warranted.

The Project would not generate solid waste in excess of State and local standards, or in excess of the capacity of local infrastructure, and would comply with CALGreen, State regulations, and City regulations regarding solid waste management. Accordingly, any impacts would be less than significant.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Utilities and Service Systems.

Wildfire
The Project Site is not located in a State Responsibility Area (SRA) or lands classified as Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones (VFHSZs). During both construction and long-term operation, the Project would be required to maintain adequate emergency access for emergency vehicles as required by the BFD and KCFD. Because the Project is required to comply with all applicable City codes, including the CBC and California Fire Code, which has been incorporated into the City’s Municipal Codes, and is not located in a VHFHSZ, construction and operation of the Project would not increase the risk of fire, nor would it require the installation/maintenance of infrastructure Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
20 that would exacerbate fire risk. Furthermore, compliance with the California Fire Code and local ordinances would ensure that the Project would not impair an adopted emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan. Therefore, no impact would occur.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in no impact or a less than significant impact with respect to Wildfire.

VI. Less Than Significant Impacts with Mitigation
The EIR identified certain impacts that would be less than significant with implementation of mitigation measures. For each of the following impacts, the City makes the finding pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21081(a)(1) that changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the Project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment.

Air Quality (Air Quality Plan and Criteria Pollutant)
The SJVAPCD is responsible for reducing emissions from area, stationary, and mobile sources in the SJVAB to achieve the National and California Ambient Air Quality Standards (AAQS). A consistency determination with the AQs plays an important role in local agency project review by linking local planning and individual projects to the Air Quality Management Plans (AQMPs).

It fulfills the CEQA goal of informing decision makers of the environmental efforts of the project under consideration early enough to ensure that air quality concerns are fully addressed. It also provides the local agency with ongoing information as to whether they are contributing to the clean air goals in the AQMPs.

Kern Council Of Governments (KCOG) is one of SJVAPCD’s partners in the preparation of the AQMPs, providing the latest economic and demographic forecasts and developing transportation measures in Kern County. Regional population, housing, and employment projections developed by Kern COG are based, in part, on the City’s General Plan land use designations. These projections form the foundation for the emissions inventory of the AQMPs and are incorporated into the regional transportation plan/sustainable communities strategy (RTP/SCS) prepared by Kern COG to determine priority transportation projects and vehicle miles traveled in the Kern COG region. Because the AQMPs’ strategies are based on projections from local general plans, projects that are consistent with the local general plan are considered consistent with the air quality-related regional plan. Additionally, only large projects have the potential to substantially affect the demographic forecasts in the AQMPs.

The Project Site is designated as P and zoned as M-2. As part of the Project, the General Plan designation would be amended to change the designation from P to LI, which both allows for the Project’s use and aligns with its existing zoning designation.

Also, under CEQA Guidelines Section 15206(b), a proposed project is considered of statewide, regional, or area-wide significance if the project is a commercial office building of 250,000 square feet or more or employs 1,000 or more employees and/or a shopping center of 500,000 square feet or more or employs 1,000 or more employees. The amount of retail space proposed and the projected number of new jobs generated would be less than 500,000 square feet and 1,000 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
21 employees. Thus, the Project would not substantially affect demographic projections beyond what is accounted for in the AQMPs.

However, per SJVAPCD guidance, project consistency with the AQMPs is based on whether project emissions would exceed the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds. The Project would exceed the regional operation significance thresholds for VOC and NOX and would cumulatively contribute to the nonattainment designations in the SJVAB without mitigation.

The Project would implement Mitigation Measure (MM) AQ-1, which would require a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) for the Project; MM AQ-2, which restricts paints and coatings that can be used for the Project; and MM GHG-3, which requires landscaping equipment to be all electric. Implementation of these MMs, in addition to compliance with the Indirect Source Review program under SJVAPCD Rule 9510, would, at minimum, offset the amount of Project-related regional emissions of VOC and NOX that exceed their SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds. Implementation of MM AQ-1 would also ensure consistency of the proposed Project with the applicable SJVAPCD air quality plans and ensure that operation of the Project would not cumulatively contribute to the nonattainment designations of the SJVAB. . As such, impacts would be less than significant with mitigation incorporated.

Mitigation Measures
MM AQ-1 Prior to issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall enter into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) to mitigate regional air quality impacts associated with emissions of VOC and NOX generated by operation of the proposed project. At minimum, the VERA shall be crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department (City), that verifies, to the City’s satisfaction, execution of the VERA.

MM AQ-2 The project proponent/developer shall use paints and coatings with a VOC content of 25 grams per liter or less for all initial and future exterior coating and recoating of structures including parking lot striping. This reduced VOC content requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate construction documents (e.g., construction management plan) and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a less than significant impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to Air Quality (Air Quality Plan and Criteria Pollutant).

Biological Resources (Sensitive Species, Local Policies) The Project site is highly disturbed and located in a highly urbanized area. It does not provide suitable habitat to support these species. Accordingly, the Project would not have a substantial Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
22 adverse effect on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special-status species in local and regional plans, policies, or regulations, or by the CDFW or USFWS.

Additionally, as discussed above, migratory non-game native bird species are protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) and the California Fish and Game Code prohibits take of all birds and their active nests. The Western burrowing owl (BUOW) was approved by the California Fish and Game Commission as a candidate species for listing under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) in 2024 and, therefore, receives the same legal protection afforded to state listed threatened and endangered species. The Project Site does not contain suitable habitat for the BUOW and it was not present on the Project Site during the field survey. However, because BUOWs may become established on disturbed sites prior to construction, a pre-construction BUOW survey is recommended within 30 days prior to the start of ground-disturbing activities, as specified further in Mitigation Measure (MM) BIO-1. If BUOWs are detected, appropriate avoidance and minimization measures, including no disturbance buffers and monitoring, shall be implemented in consultation with CDFW as specified in MM BIO-2.

Additionally, the Project Site has shrubs that could be used by nesting songbirds during the nesting bird season. Therefore, the potential for the Project to impact MBTA protected birds exists. If vegetation removal and other ground disturbance activities can be conducted outside of the recognized nesting bird season, impacts to nesting birds are not expected. However, if work cannot be avoided during the nesting bird season, the Project would implement MM BIO-3, which require pre-construction nesting surveys prior to initiation of Project, should ground disturbance, vegetation clearing, or other construction activities that would otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy equipment). With the implementation of MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3, impacts to nesting birds would be avoided and impacts would be less than significant.

Additionally, in reviewing the applicable General Plan goals, policies, and implementation programs the Project would be consistent with the General Plan by avoiding impact to sensitive biological communities and species by creating a buffer around nesting birds protected by the MBTA and surveying and buffering the BUOW through the implementation of MM BIO-1 through MM BIO-3. To avoid impacts to Crotch’s Bumble Bee and the San Joaquin Kit Fox, MM BIO-4-10 would be implemented.

Accordingly, the Project would not conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources, and impacts would be less than significant with mitigation.

Mitigation Measures
MM BIO-1 Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Pre-Construction Surveys. Prior to the commencement of ground-disturbing or vegetation-clearing activities, the project applicant/developer shall retain a qualified biologist to conduct pre-construction surveys for BUOW (Athene cunicularia) in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Depending on the time Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
23 elapsed between the focused surveys conducted in support of the analysis conducted as a part of the biological resource assessment and the start of construction, additional focused surveys may be required during the survey season immediately preceding construction. As specified in the 2012 Staff Report, one 30-day pre-construction survey is recommended; however, multiple surveys may be necessary prior to construction to determine presence or absence, and burrowing owls may colonize a site following previous negative survey results. Therefore, the project site shall be monitored 30 days prior to ground disturbance to detect any occupancy prior to construction activities.

MM BIO-2 Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls. In the event a burrowing owl or known burrowing owl den (active or inactive) is detected, and the no disturbance buffers outlined in the 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Mitigation are not feasible, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b), shall be necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-3 Nesting Birds. If ground disturbing and vegetation clearing activities cannot be avoided during the nesting bird season (February 1 through September 15), a qualified biologist shall conduct a pre-construction nesting bird survey within all areas of breeding and nesting habitat within and adjacent to the Project Site no more than 10 days prior to initiation of Project activities that would remove vegetation or otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy equipment) of all areas of the Project Site that could be directly or indirectly impacted by construction activity.

If nesting birds are encountered, the qualified biologist shall establish a baseline for the behavior of any identified nests and shall continuously Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
24 monitor the nests to detect changes in behavior. Should behavioral changes occur, the Project proponent shall halt construction work causing that change and consult with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for additional avoidance and minimization measure.

If continuous monitoring of the identified nests by a qualified biologist is not feasible, a qualified biologist shall establish an avoidance buffer zone around the nest, which shall be determined by the qualified biologist according to species involved. At a minimum, a no-disturbance buffer of 250 feet shall be established around active nests of non-listed bird species and a 500-foot no-disturbance buffer shall be established around active nests of non-listed raptors. No activities that would adversely affect the nest shall occur within the buffer zone until the qualified biologist has determined the nest is no longer active, breading season is over, or the young are no longer dependent on the nest.

MM BIO-4 San Joaquin Kit Fox (SJKF) Pre-Construction Surveys. Pre-construction surveys to assess presence/absence of denning San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) shall be conducted by the qualified biologist no less than 14 days and no more than 30 days prior to the commencement of any ground disturbance and/or construction activities or any Project activity likely to impact the SJKF. Surveys shall identify kit fox habitat features occurring on the project site (if any are determined to occur during the surveys) and evaluate use by SJKF and, if possible, assess the potential impacts to the kit fox by the proposed activity. If a natal/pupping den is discovered within the Project Site or within 200 feet of the project site boundary, the appropriate agencies (e.g., California Department of Fish and Wildlife, City of Bakersfield) shall be immediately notified and under no circumstances shall the den be disturbed or destroyed without prior authorization. If the preconstruction survey reveals an active natal pupping or new information, the Project applicant, construction contractor and biologist shall contact the appropriate agencies immediately to obtain the necessary take authorization/permit. Written results of the preconstruction surveys shall be submitted to the appropriate agencies within five (5) days after survey completion and prior to the start of ground disturbance and/or construction activities.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
25 MM BIO-5 SJKF Avoidance Buffer. Prior to the commencement of any ground disturbing activities, the Project applicant, construction contractor and project biologist shall implement no-disturbance buffers as described in the USFWS’ “Standardized Recommendations for Protection of the San Joaquin Kit Fox Prior to or During Ground Disturbance” (2011) (USFWS Protocol) around potentially suitable or known SJKF den sites identified during the pre-construction surveys outlined in Mitigation Measure BIO-4.

MM BIO-6 SJKF Take Authorization. If the no-disturbance buffers outlined in Mitigation Measures BIO-5 are not feasible, the project applicant and California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) shall discuss how to implement the project and avoid take. If take cannot be avoided, the Project applicant shall obtain take authorization from CDFW by obtaining an incidental take permit pursuant to Fish and Game Code section 2081, subdivision (b), in compliance with the California Endangered Species Act.

MM BIO-7 Crotch’s Bumble Bee (CBB) Habitat Assessment. Prior to the commencement of any ground-disturbing activities, the qualified biologist shall conduct an additional habitat assessment to determine if the project site and immediate surrounding vicinity contain habitat suitable to support CBB. Potential nesting sites, which include all small mammal nesting burrows, perennial bunch grasses, thatched annual grasses, brush piles, old bird nests, and hollow logs shall be documented as part of the assessment.

MM BIO-8 CBB Surveys. If potentially suitable habitat is identified during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, a qualified biologist shall conduct focused surveys for CBB and their requisite habitat features following the methodology outlined in the Survey Considerations for California Endangered Species Act Candidate Bumble Bee Species (CDFW 2023).

MM BIO-9 CBB Avoidance. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, all small mammal burrows and thatched/bunch grasses shall be avoided by a minimum of 50 feet to avoid take and potentially significant impacts. If ground-disturbing activities occur during the overwintering period October through February), consultation with CDFW shall be conducted to discuss how to implement the proposed project’s construction-related activities and avoid take of the CBB. Any detection of CBB prior to or during project construction shall warrant discussions with CDFW to discuss how to avoid take.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
26 MM BIO-10 CBB Take Authorization. If CBB is detected during the habitat assessment conducted under Mitigation Measure BIO-7, consultation with CDFW shall be warranted to discuss how to implement the proposed project and avoid take of the CBB. If take cannot be avoided, take authorization through the acquisition of an incidental take permit, pursuant to Fish and Game Code Section 2081, subdivision (b) is necessary to comply with the California Endangered Species Act.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a less than significant impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to Biological Resources (Sensitive Species, Local Policies).

Cultural Resources (Archaeological Resources and Human Remains) Although neither the record search nor the field visit conducted as part of the DEIR identified archeological resources, ground-disturbing activities have the potential to reveal buried deposits not observed on the surface. Additionally, as some development occurred before the implementation of regulations related to the identification of archaeological resources, it is also possible that archaeological resources were present on the Project Site and were not recorded before or during development.

Therefore, the Project would implement Mitigation Measure (MM) CUL-1, which would require that field personnel be alerted to the possibility of buried prehistoric or historic cultural deposits prior to initiation of ground-disturbing activities. MM CUL-1 would also provide a process for treatment of any archaeological resources inadvertently discovered during Project implementation. Implementation of MM CUL-1 shall also require a cessation of construction activity and consultation with a qualified archaeologist to evaluate the Project Site and make the necessary findings. As such, with the implementation MM CUL-1, impacts to archaeological resources would be less than significant with mitigation incorporated. In the event that any human remains, or related resources are discovered, such resources would be treated in accordance with all applicable federal, state, and local regulations and guidelines for disclosure, recovery, relocation, and preservation, including State Health and Safety Code. If human remains are encountered during any project activities, State Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5 states that no further disturbance shall occur until the County Coroner has made a determination of origin and disposition pursuant to PRC Section 5097.98. As such, the Project would implement MM CUL-2, Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains, requiring a cessation of construction activity until the County coroner can evaluate the discovery and made the necessary findings, would provide a process for treatment of any human remains inadvertently discovered during Project implementation. With implementation of this MM CUL-2, impacts to human remains would be less than significant with mitigation incorporated.

Mitigation Measures
MM CUL-1 Inadvertent Discovery of Cultural Resources. If suspected cultural resources are encountered during ground disturbance activities, all work within 100 feet of the find shall immediately cease and the area cordoned Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
27 off until a qualified cultural resource specialist that meets the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards can evaluate the find and make recommendations. If the specialist determines that the discovery represents a potentially significant cultural resource, additional investigations may be required. If cultural resources are discovered that may have relevance to Native Americans, the specialist or Project Applicant shall provide written notice to the City of Bakersfield, Native American Heritage Commission, and any other appropriate individuals, agencies, and/or groups as determined by the specialist in consultation with the City of Bakersfield to receive input regarding treatment and disposition of the resource, which may include avoidance, testing, and/or excavation to prevent destruction of the resource and/or to allow documentation of the resource for research potential. All reports, correspondence, and determinations regarding the discovery shall be submitted to the California Historical Resources Information System’s Southern San Joaquin Valley Information Center at California State University Bakersfield.

MM CUL-2 Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains. During construction, if human remains are discovered, further ground disturbance shall be prohibited pursuant to California Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5. The specific protocol, guidelines, and channels of communication outlined by the Native American Heritage Commission, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5, Public Resources Code 5097.97, and Senate Bill 447 shall be followed. In the event of the discovery of human remains, at the direction of the county coroner, Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5(c) shall guide Native American consultation. Unless otherwise required by law, the site of any reburial of Native American human remains or associated grave goods shall not be disclosed and shall not be governed by public disclosure requirements of the California Public Records Act. The coroner, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r), parties, and Lead Agencies, will be asked to withhold public disclosure information related to such reburial, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r).

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a less than significant impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to Cultural Resources (Archaeological Resources and Human Remains).

Geology and Soils (Paleontological Resources)
The Project is situated in a highly disturbed environment and there are no unique geologic features located on or around the Project Site. According to the Palaeontologic Overview, the geologic units underlying the Project Area (one mile radius around the Project Site) are mapped primarily as alluvial fan deposits from the Holocene epoch. Holocene alluvial units are considered Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
28 to be of high preservation value, but material found is unlikely to be fossil material due to the relatively modern associated dates of the deposits. While the presence of any fossil material is unlikely, if excavation activity disturbs deeper sediment dating to the earliest parts of the Holocene or Late Pleistocene periods, the material would be scientifically significant. Excavation activity associated with the development of the project area is unlikely to be paleontologically sensitive, but caution during development should be observed. However, because the Project construction would require earthwork and removal of soil, there is potential for the discovery of unknown paleontological resources. Therefore, the Project would implement Mitigation Measure (MM) GEO-1, Paleontological Discovery and Monitoring, which outlines the process for discovery of paleontological resources. With implementation of MM GEO-1, impacts would be less than significant.

Mitigation Measures
MM GEO-1 Paleontological Discovery and Monitoring. In the event paleontological resources, including fossil discoveries, are encountered during construction of the Project, work shall halt within a 50-foot radius of the find and the City shall be immediately informed of the discovery. A qualified paleontologist shall be retained by the Applicant to evaluate the find before restarting work in the area. A qualified paleontologist is a paleontologist who meets the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP) standards for Qualified Professional Paleontologist, which is defined as an individual preferably with an M.S. or Ph.D. in paleontology or geology, who is experienced with paleontological procedures and techniques, who is knowledgeable in the geology of California (preferably Southern California), and who has worked as a paleontological mitigation Project supervisor for a least one year. The City shall require that all paleontological resources identified on the Project site be assessed and treated in a manner determined by the qualified paleontologist. The qualified paleontologist shall be empowered to halt or divert ground disturbing activities.

If the discoveries are determined to be significant, full-time paleontological monitoring will be recommended for the remainder of ground disturbance for the Project. Paleontological monitoring shall entail the visual inspection of excavated or graded areas and trench sidewalls. In the event that any additional paleontological resources are discovered, the monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert the construction equipment around the find until it is assessed for scientific significance and collected, if warranted. Monitoring efforts can be reduced or eliminated at the discretion of the project paleontologist.

Upon completion of fieldwork, all significant fossils collected shall be prepared in a properly equipped paleontology laboratory to a point ready for curation. Following laboratory work, all fossil specimens shall be identified to the most specific taxonomic level possible, cataloged, Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
29 analyzed, and first offered to the Buena Vista Museum then offered to the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County for permanent curation and storage. At the conclusion of laboratory work and museum curation, a final Paleontological Monitoring Report (PMR) shall be prepared describing the results of the paleontological mitigation monitoring efforts associated with the Project. The report shall include a summary of the field and laboratory methods, an overview of the project area geology and paleontology, a list of taxa recovered, an analysis of fossils recovered and their scientific significance, and recommendations. A copy of the report shall also be submitted to the Buena Vista Museum in Bakersfield.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a less than significant impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to Geology and Soils (Paleontological Resources).

Transportation (Emergency Access)
Construction
Construction of the proposed Project would be generally confined to the Project Site and would not physically impair access to the Project Site or the surrounding area. During both construction and long-term operation, the Project would be required to maintain adequate emergency access for emergency vehicles. Additionally, the Project would include the preparation and implementation of a Construction Traffic Management Plan as a Project Design Feature (PDF).

The Construction Traffic Management Plan would be submitted to the City for review and approval prior to construction and would identify construction haul routes; construction worker parking and staging areas; construction phasing and scheduling; procedures for on-site loading, unloading, and material storage; temporary traffic control measures; provisions for maintaining pedestrian, bicycle, transit, and vehicular access to adjacent properties to the maximum extent feasible; methods to avoid or minimize lane closures and sidewalk closures; advance notification procedures for nearby property owners and affected agencies; dust, debris, and mud track-out control measures affecting adjacent roadways; and procedures to maintain emergency vehicle access at all times during construction. Implementation of the Construction Traffic Management Plan would reduce the potential for temporary construction-related conflicts with emergency response by ensuring that access is maintained, construction traffic is managed in an orderly manner, and potentially disruptive activities are coordinated in advance with the City and emergency service providers.

Operation
The Project driveways and internal drive aisles would be constructed pursuant to the City’s design standards and subject to review by the City and Fire Department. BFD would review the Project for access requirements concerning minimum roadway width, access roads, fire lanes, signage, access devices and gates, and access walkways, among other requirements, which would enhance emergency access to the Project Site. Furthermore, compliance with the California fire Code and local ordinances would ensure that the Project would not impair an adopted Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
30 emergency response plan. Through compliance with access requirements and, adequate emergency access to the Project Site would be provided. Project impacts concerning emergency access would be less than significant.

Project Design Features
TRAF-PDF-1: Construction Traffic Management Plan.

The contractor would develop a detailed Construction Traffic Management Plan as part of the Project, including provision of construction worker parking in designated areas, temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public rights-of-way, street closure information, detour plans, haul routes, and staging plans, among other provisions. The contractor would submit the Construction Traffic Management Plan to the City of Bakersfield for approval.

The Construction Management Plan would include the following:
• Scheduling workdays to begin and end prior to the morning and afternoon peak hours, respectively, to the extent feasible so as to avoid worker trips during those peak hours. • Coordination with various City departments and offices to ensure adequate access to the Project Site and land uses in proximity of the Project Site is maintained. • Scheduling pick-ups, deliveries, and exports of construction materials so as to occur during off-peak hours. Hauling shall be from 9:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M. on weekdays, and 8:00 A.M. to 4:00 P.M. on Saturdays. No hauling shall be performed on Sundays and holidays.
• Reduce the potential of trucks waiting for extended periods to load or unload. • Provision of worker parking on-site or in designated off-site private parking areas and prohibition of construction-related vehicle parking on surrounding streets, other than the streets adjacent to the Project Site.
• Temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public ROWs to improve traffic flow on public roadways (e.g., flag personnel) and to maintain access for land uses in the vicinity of the Project Site. Determine the number and location of flag personnel required during traffic rerouting and deliveries. • Contractor to post advance bilingual notification to adjacent property owners and occupants of upcoming construction activities, including durations and daily hours of operation, at several locations on the Project Site.
• Establish requirements for storage of materials and loading/unloading on the Project Site. • Worksite traffic control plans approved by the City would be implemented to route vehicles, bicyclists, and pedestrians around the area during any parking, travel lane or sidewalk closures and provide for protective measures for the public. • Identification of a construction manager and provision of a telephone number for any inquiries or complaints from residents regarding construction activities. The telephone Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
31 number shall be posted at the site, readily visible to any interested party during site preparation, grading, and construction.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a less than significant impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to Transportation (Emergency Access).

Tribal Cultural Resources
Although no Tribal Cultural Resources (TCRs) were identified in the Project Site, ground disturbing activities have the potential to reveal buried TCRs not observed on the surface. Therefore, the Project would implement Mitigation Measures (MM) CUL-1 and CUL-2 discussed above. With implementation of MM CUL-1 and MM CUL-2, impacts to TCRs would remain less than significant with mitigation incorporated.

VII. SIGNIFICANT AND UNAVOIDABLE IMPACTS
The EIR identified the following impacts that would remain significant and unavoidable even after implementation of all feasible mitigation measures. For these impacts, the City makes the finding pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a)(1) that changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the Project which mitigate the significant effects, and the finding pursuant to PRC Section 21081(a)(3) that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make infeasible additional mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the EIR.

A. Greenhouse Gases (GHG)
Operation of the Project would generate GHG emissions from vehicle trips, water demand, wastewater and solid waste generation, area sources (e.g., consumer cleaning products), energy usage (i.e., natural gas and electricity), and refrigerants. The Project’s primary source of project-related emissions would be from mobile-source emissions generated from Project vehicle trips (e.g., employees and patrons). The next largest sources of emissions would be from energy usage, followed by the solid waste and water sectors. Overall, development of the Project would generate annual operational phase GHG emissions of 16,027 MTCO2e per year under full buildout year conditions and would not achieve net zero GHG emissions Implementation of MM GHG-1 and GHG-3 would contribute to supporting and encouraging use of electricity instead of natural gas or other liquid fuels, which would minimize on-site generation of GHG emissions. Implementation of MM GHG-1 and GHG-3 would reduce project-related GHG emissions by 102 MTCO2e/yr. However, these two mitigation measures would not reduce Project-related emissions to achieve net zero. Overall, the other mitigation measures would help contribute to reducing operation-related Project GHG emissions to the extent feasible.

For example, MM GHG-2 would contribute to increasing use of carbon-free renewable electricity and supplement the on-site renewable electricity generated by the proposed on-site PV systems.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
32 Additionally, MM GHG-5 and GHG-6 would result in active and public transit facility improvements and promote active transit and public transit use, which would contribute to reducing passenger VMT. Furthermore, MM GHG-7 would result in increased EV charging infrastructure improvements and support use and adoption of EVs. Overall, although implementation of reduction measures would reduce Project-related GHG emissions to the extent feasible, operation of the proposed Project is still anticipated to generate GHG emissions and would not achieve the net zero threshold. Thus, Project-related GHG emissions would have a substantial cumulative contribution to GHG emissions impacts. Impacts would be significant and unavoidable.

Per the VMT analysis prepared, the Project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies. The Project would include end-of-trip bicycle facilities such as bicycle parking and lockers. In addition, it also includes bicycle facility improvements as it proposes a new bicycle lane along Rosedale Highway, which would extend an existing facility and improve overall bicycle network connectivity. Furthermore, the Project includes pedestrian network improvements such as new sidewalks along its frontages. Aside from these Project-related design features, future commercial tenants of the proposed Project would be subject to the SJVAPCD Rule 9410 eTRIP rule. These Project improvements in addition to the SJVPACD eTRIP rule would contribute to reducing Project-generated VMT to the extent feasible.

Incorporation of MM GHG-5 and GHG-6, which would result in improvements for up to two bus stops and installation of an onsite end-of-trip shower facility, would also contribute to reducing project-generated VMT to the extent feasible by supporting public transit and bicycle use.

However, overall, the proposed Project would continue to be inconsistent with the Kern COG 2022 RTP/SCS. Impacts would be significant and unavoidable. No other feasible mitigation is available.

Mitigation Measures
MM GHG-1 The project proponent/developer shall design and construct the proposed buildings to be all electric, with electricity to be the only permanent source of energy for all nonemergency building energy needs, including but not limited to water heating; mechanical equipment; and heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) (i.e., space-heating and space cooling). All major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. The only exception to this measure shall be limited to commercial cooking uses. Prior to issuance of building permits for development projects, project proponent/developer shall provide plans that show the aforementioned requirements to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify installation of the electric-powered EnergyStar or equivalent appliances.

MM GHG-2 Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division demonstrating enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, such as Pacific Gas & Electric’s (PG&E) 100% Solar Choice plan, for proposed project building(s) if such Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
33 plan is available. If a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available, the property owner shall enroll in an energy plan with the next highest carbon-free electricity until a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan becomes available. Measures to achieve 100 percent carbon-free electricity use may include, but are not limited to, plans for 100 percent renewable electricity. If such carbon-free electricity energy plans are waitlisted, the property owner may enroll in an available energy plan in the meantime, but shall sign up for the waiting list for and enroll in a carbon-free electricity energy plan when it becomes available.

MM GHG-3 All landscaping equipment (e.g., leaf blower) used for property management shall be electric-powered only. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase, rental, and/or services agreement) to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify that all landscaping equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

MM GHG-4 Any off-road equipment (e.g., forklifts) used in daily business operations shall be electric-powered. The project proponent/developer shall disclose this requirement to all tenants/business entities prior to the signing of any lease agreement. In addition, the limitation to use only electric-powered off-road equipment shall be included in all leasing agreements.

Prior to issuance of a Business License for a new tenant/business entity, the project proponent/developer and tenant/business entity shall provide a signed document (verification document) to the City of Bakersfield (City) noting that the property owner has disclosed to the tenant/business entity the requirement to use only electric-powered equipment for daily operations. This verification document shall be signed by authorized agents for the project proponent/developer and tenant/business entities. In addition, if applicable, the tenant/business entity shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase or rental agreement) to the City to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that any off-road equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

MM GHG-5 The project proponent/developer shall coordinate with Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements (e.g., bus shelter) of up to two bus stops. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the project proponent/developer shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that coordination with Golden Empire Transit has been initiated.

MM GHG-6 The project proponent/developer shall install an end-of-trip shower facility. This end-of-trip shower facility requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate building plans and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify the installation of end-of-trip shower facility.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
34 MM GHG-7 The project proponent/developer shall design the parking areas to comply with the Tier 2 Nonresidential Voluntary Measures of the California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen), Division A5.1, Planning and Design, Section A5.106.5.3.4. This requirement shall be identified on all prepared building and site plans. The project proponent/developer shall submit these building and site plans that note this requirement to the City of Bakersfield Building Division prior to the issuance of construction permits.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a significant and unavoidable impact with mitigation incorporated with respect to GHG.

B. Transportation (Conflict or be inconsistent with CEQA Guidelines § 15064.3, subdivision (b))
The Project would exceed VMT significance thresholds for both retail and non-retail uses. The Project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies that are consistent with State guidance and best practices, including enhanced pedestrian connectivity, new and expanded bicycle facilities, and end-of-trip bicycle amenities. Consistent with California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA) methodologies, these measures are estimated to result in a cumulative VMT reduction of approximately 0.1 percent to 11.8 percent. These reductions would meaningfully reduce VMT associated with retail uses and employee commute trips and represent a good-faith effort to minimize vehicle travel to the extent feasible given the Project’s location and operational characteristics. However, the reduction in VMT from the design features would not reduce VMT impacts to a less than significant level. As such, the Project would result in a significant impact. No other feasible mitigation is available.

Finding: The City finds that, based on substantial evidence in the record, the Project would result in a significant and unavoidable impact with VMT.

VIII. ALTERNATIVES
CEQA requires an EIR to describe a range of reasonable alternatives to the Project that would feasibly attain most of the basic objectives while reducing or avoiding significant impacts (CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6). The analysis need not consider every conceivable alternative, but must consider a reasonable range. The lead agency may reject alternatives as infeasible.

A. Alternative 1: No Build/No Project Alternative
Impact Summary: Pursuant to Section 15126.6(e)(3)(B) of the CEQA Guidelines, Alternative 1, the “No Project” Alternative, represents the circumstance under which the Project does not proceed. Under Alternative 1, it is assumed that the existing state of the Project Site would remain as-is and no new development would be implemented. As discussed in Chapter 2, Project Description, of this Draft EIR, the Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six- Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
35 feet tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds.

Alternative 1 would avoid the Project’s significant and unavoidable impacts to Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHG) and Transportation. Alternative 1 would also result in no impact in all other environmental topical areas analyzed in the Draft EIR. As the No Build/No Project alternative would not include a development program, the Alternative 1 would not meet any of the objectives of the Project.

Finding: The No Project Alternative is rejected as infeasible because it would not meet the underlying purpose of the Project or any of the Project’s basic objectives.

B. Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative
Impact Summary: The Reduced Project Alternative assumes a 25% reduction of all proposed Project land uses. Accordingly, the total commercial square footage would be reduced from 405,531 square feet to approximately 304,148 square feet and the total number of dual sided fuel pumps would be reduced from 20 to 15. The buildings would be constructed in the same general arrangement as currently proposed and set forth in the site plan, but with a smaller footprint. The areas not covered by buildings would be used for surface parking for passenger vehicles and the site’s vehicular access would be the same general arrangement as currently proposed and set forth in the site plan. The development characteristics of this Reduced Project Alternative are assumed to be similar to those of the Project, including excavation and earth movement.

As the Reduced Project Alternative assumes a 25% reduction of all proposed Project land uses, less development would occur and some of the environmental impacts would be reduced.

However, this Alternative would not eliminate the Project’s significant and unavoidable impacts.

With less development, the Project would meet the following objectives:
• A Project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City. • An infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. • A Project that encourages and facilitates new uses of high-quality architecture and design.
• A mixture of commercial uses that provides new activity and services to the area and is cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities nearby.
• A circulation system responsive to the needs of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian travel.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
36 • New native and drought tolerant. landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter
• A visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

However, with reduced development, Alternative 2 would not meet the following objective related to employment and job growth to the same extent as the Project:
• Creation of new and future employment opportunities.

Finding: Alternative 2 is rejected as infeasible because it would not avoid significant and unavoidable impacts, nor would it meet the Project’s objective related to employment and job growth to the same extent as the Project.

C. Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative Under Alternative 3, it is assumed that the Project Site will be developed in accordance with the current Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (MBGP) land use and zoning designations. Thus, this alternative assumes the Project Site would be developed with a by-right use and no General Plan amendment or zone change is necessary. The Project Site’s current Public Facilities (P) designation, as well as the prohibitions in the deed restriction and restrictive covenant that encumber the property, significantly limit the types of uses permitted on the Project Site. Based on the site’s Public Facilities designation, the allowed uses are limited to the following:

Public Facilities (P): includes government buildings, hospitals, public utilities, cemeteries, sewage treatment plants, waste disposal sites and other publicly owned facilities.

For purposes of the analysis, the maximum allowable development of the Project Site is in accordance with the MBGP. Based thereon, Alternative 3 would consist of a municipal maintenance and storage yard that serves as the central deployment hub for a public works department. This alternative development includes facilities for fleet maintenance, material storage, and administrative offices. All existing on-site uses, except the transmission facilities, would be removed to accommodate this alternative.

Under Alternative 3, the Project Site would be developed with approximately 100,900 square feet of commercial uses, consisting of office space to accommodate multiple divisions within a public works department (i.e. parks & rec, streets, solid waste). The Project Site would also be developed with industrial uses, including a 128,000 square foot fleet services building, approximately 30 acres of construction, equipment, and stockpile storage space, a 58,000 square foot laydown with detention basin, and a 5,300 square foot fueling facility. The alternative will also include 335,000 square feet of employee parking.1
1 This alternative project was derived and scaled based on input from the City’s Public Works Department of desired improvements on a new 30-acre public works yard.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
37 Alternative 3, involving development of the Project Site in accordance with current land use and zoning designations, would reduce the Project’s significant and unavoidable VMT impacts and would reduce mitigation measures required for Air Quality. With the exception of Aesthetics impacts, all impacts would be reduced or would be similar to the Project.

However, Alternative 3 would not meet several objectives of the Project as it would not provide a new commercial development that would provide new activities, shopping, and services for residents. Alternative 3 would not generate new employment activitiesto the same extent as the Project, nor would it develop a new commercial development that would be harmonious with surrounding commercial development. Alternative 3 would not visually improve the Project Site to the same degree as the Project, as new landscaping, high quality commercial architecture, signage and other aesthetic improvements would not occur.

Therefore, the future municipal maintenance and storage yard uses on the Project Site would not meet the following Project objectives:
• A Project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City. • A Project that encourages and facilitates new uses of high -quality architecture and design.
• A mixture of commercial uses that provides new activity and services to the area and is cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities nearby. • New native and drought tolerant landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter
• A visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

Finding: Alternative 3 is rejected as infeasible because it would not meet several of the Project’s objectives related to employment and job growth, revitalization, and activity and aesthetic improvements to the same extent as the Project.

E. Alternative Rejected as Infeasible
Consideration was given to developing the Project, as proposed, on an alternative site within the City of Bakersfield. In considering this alternative, the following challenges were identified:

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
38 • The selection of any alternative site would have the same potentially significant impacts as the current Project site.
• Due to the Project Site’s unique characteristics, finding a comparable infill site of equal size is unlikely.
• An alternative site that is properly zoned and of equal size is not likely to meet the critical project objective of promoting favorable infill development. • An alternative site of adequate size would likely be outside of an established urban area, resulting in potentially increased impacts to traffic and greenhouse gas emissions. • The Applicant does not have ownership control of any alternative sites, rendering this alternative infeasible.

For these reasons, analysis of an alternative site was eliminated from further consideration in the EIR.

F. Environmentally Superior Alternative
CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6(e)(2) indicates that an analysis of alternatives to a proposed project shall identify an environmentally superior alternative among the alternatives evaluated in an EIR and that if the “no project” alternative is the environmentally superior alternative, the EIR shall identify another environmentally superior alternative among the remaining alternatives.

Selection of an environmentally superior alternative is based on comparison of the alternatives to determine which among the alternatives would reduce or eliminate the impacts associated with the Project to the greatest degree
Of the alternatives analyzed in this Draft EIR, Alternative 1 would be considered the environmentally superior alternative because it would not involve new development and assumes that the Project Site would remain vacant under existing conditions. Although Alternative 1 would not meet any of the Project objectives, it would avoid all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts and significant and unavoidable impacts and would have reduced impacts compared to the Project. However, as Alternative 1 is a “no project” alternative which is the environmentally superior alternative, the EIR shall identify another environmentally superior alternative among the remaining alternatives
Alternative 3, involving development of the Project Site in accordance with current land use and zoning designations, would reduce the Project’s significant and unavoidable VMT impacts and would reduce mitigation measures required for Air Quality. With the exception of Aesthetics impacts, all impacts would be reduced or would be similar to the Project.

However, Alternative 3 would not meet several objectives of the Project as it would not provide a new commercial development that would provide new activities, shopping, and services for residents. Alternative 3 would not generate new employment activitiesto the same extent as the Project, nor would it develop a new commercial development that would be harmonious with surrounding commercial development. Alternative 3 would not visually improve the Project Site Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
39 to the same degree as the Project, as new landscaping, high quality commercial architecture, signage and other aesthetic improvements would not occur.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
40 IX. SIGNIFICANT IRREVERSIBLE ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES
Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.2(d), an EIR must identify any significant irreversible environmental changes that would be caused by the proposed project should it be implemented.

The following significant irreversible environmental changes would result from implementation of the Project:

As stated in Chapter 6, Other CEQA Considerations, of the Draft EIR, the Project would necessarily consume limited, slowly renewable, and non-renewable resources that could contribute to irreversible environmental changes. This consumption would occur during construction of the Project and would continue throughout its operational lifetime. The development of the Project would require a commitment of resources that would include: (1) building materials, (2) fuel and operational materials/resources, and (3) the transportation of goods and people to and from the Project Site.

With regard to building materials and solid waste, construction of the Project would require consumption of resources including certain types of lumber and other forest products, aggregate materials used in concrete and asphalt, metals, and petrochemical construction materials. The Project Site is currently vacant and therefore, no solid waste is currently being generated at the site. The Project would be served by the Metropolitan Sanitary Landfill/Bena Landfill, operated by the Kern County Public Works Department. CALGreen requires builders/owners to divert 65 percent of construction waste from landfills (by recycling, reusing, and other waste reduction strategies), consistent with the State’s solid waste reduction goals. The Project also would be subject to compliance with applicable construction-related provisions of Chapter 8.32, Refuse, Solid Waste, and Recycling, of the City’s Municipal Code. During operation, using CalRecycle’s solid waste generation factor for commercial uses of approximately 13 pounds per 1,000 square foot per day, the Project’s 405,531 square feet of building area would generate approximately 5,272 pounds/day (2.6 tons/day), or 949 tons per year of solid waste. Consistent with State mandates (AB 939, AB 341, AB 1826, and SB 1383) and City programs, at least 50 percent of this material would be diverted through recycling and organics collection, resulting in an estimated disposal volume of 474 tons per year (1.3 tons/day) (Draft EIR, Section 4.18, Utilities and Service Systems, pages 4.18-15 through 4.18-17).

With regard to water, the Project is expected to increase water demand by 148,925 gallons per day. The Project’s contribution to the increase in water demand would fall within the available and projected water supplies reported in the City’s 2020 Urban Water Management Plan for the City for 2020 and the City’s projected 2040 water supply. Therefore, the Project would not result in a significant impact related to water supply.

With regard to energy consumption, during construction, fossil fuels would be consumed by on-road trucks and off-road construction equipment. Construction of the Project would not require electricity to power most construction equipment. The majority of construction equipment would be gasoline or diesel-powered. It is anticipated that the majority of electric-powered construction equipment would be hand tools (e.g., power drills, table saws) and lighting, which would result in minimal electricity usage during construction activities. Construction vehicles and Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
41 equipment would comply with CARB regulations and California emission standards. In addition, there are no unusual Project characteristics or construction processes that would require the use of equipment that would be more energy intensive than is used for comparable activities or equipment that would not conform to current emissions standards (and related fuel efficiencies).

During operation, would include heating, cooling, and ventilation of buildings; water heating; operation of electrical systems; use of on-site equipment and appliances; and indoor, outdoor, perimeter, and parking lot lighting. Operation of the Project would consume electricity for various purposes, including but not limited to cooling and ventilation of buildings; operation of electrical systems; lighting; and use of on-site equipment and appliances. Electrical service to the Project would be provided by PG&E through connections to existing off-site electrical lines and new on-site infrastructure. While the Project would result in electricity demand, it would be designed and built to meet the current Building Energy Efficiency Standards and CALGreen, which would contribute to increasing energy efficiency. In accordance with the 2025 Building Energy Efficiency Standards, the Project would install rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) systems and battery storage systems. Therefore, the Project would not cause wasteful, inefficient, and unnecessary consumption of energy (Draft EIR, Chapter 6, Other CEQA Considerations, pages 6- 1 through 6-3).

With regard to environmental hazards, construction of the Project would involve the use of hazardous substances in the form of paint, adhesives, solvents, and other substances typically used in building construction. However, all materials would be used, stored, and disposed of in accordance with applicable laws and regulations and manufacturers’ instructions. During operation, the use of hazardous materials would involve employing common maintenance and janitorial supplies, such as cleaners and solvents, paints and thinners for site maintenance, and other common chemicals. The limited quantities and nature of chemicals used by the Project for the generally commercial uses would not be considered significant. However, the proposed gas station and car wash would utilize hazardous materials regularly during operations. Gas station operations include the use of gasoline and diesel fuel, which are stored in underground storage tanks (USTs). During refueling, VOCs can be released as vapors, including benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene, xylenes, and naphthalene. Often, fuel additives are also utilized at gas stations.

Additionally, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde are produced by vehicles at the station.

Propane tanks (exchange cages), motor oil, lubricants, battery fluids, and hydraulic fluids can also be released due to the nature of regular uses by automobiles. However, gas stations are heavily regulated by hazardous materials laws focusing on leak prevention, vapor recovery, and fire safety, overseen primarily by the CUPA. Operations of the car wash would be required to comply with hazardous material regulations under federal, state, and local laws, focusing on water protection, chemical handling, and waste disposal. The Project would be required to comply with the RCRA, which mandates "cradle-to-grave" control over hazardous waste, including oil, sludge, and certain soaps. Additionally, the OHSA Hazard Communication Standard (29 CFR Section 1910.1200) requires proper labelling, handling procedures, and worker training for handling chemicals. And finally, operations of the car wash would be required to comply with CCR Title 22, which requires secondary containment for chemicals and specific disposal protocols for car wash sludge. The use of these materials would be in accordance with the manufacturers’ specifications for use, storage, and disposal of such products which have been formulated to avoid substantial Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
42 exposure hazards. Compliance with applicable federal, state, and local requirements concerning the handling, storage and disposal of hazardous waste would reduce the potential to release contaminants. Therefore, it is not expected that the Project would cause irreversible damage from environmental accidents associated with the use of typical, potentially hazardous materials (Draft EIR, Section 4.9, Hazards and Hazardous Materials, pages 4.9-12 through 4.9-13).

Based on the above, while Project construction and operation would require the irreversible commitment of limited, slowly renewable, and non-renewable resources, which would limit the availability of these resources for future generations, the consumption of such resources would not be considered substantial and would be consistent with regional and local growth forecasts and development goals for the area. The loss of such resources would not be highly accelerated when compared to existing conditions, and such resources would not be used in a wasteful manner. Therefore, although irreversible environmental changes would result from the Project, such changes are concluded to be less than significant, with the exception of the significant and unavoidable impact to GHG and VMT, and the limited use of nonrenewable resources that would be required by Project construction and operation is justified.

X. GROWTH INDUCING IMPACTS
CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.2(e) requires an EIR to discuss the ways a Project could foster economic or population growth or the construction of additional housing, directly or indirectly, in the surrounding environment. Growth-inducing impacts include the removal of obstacles to population growth (e.g., the expansion of a wastewater treatment plant allowing more development in a service area) and the development and construction of new service facilities that could significantly affect the environment individually or cumulatively. In addition, pursuant to CEQA, growth must not be assumed as beneficial, detrimental, or of little significance to the environment.

The Project Site is located in the northwestern portion of the City. The Project Site is an approximately 46.16-acre undeveloped L-shaped property situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway, north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road. The Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. There is no existing housing on the Project Site. The Project proposes to transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would create economic, retail and service opportunities in an area served with existing infrastructure and public services. The Project Site is surrounded by existing commercial uses to the north, west, and east.

As discussed in Section 4.14, Population and Housing, of the Draft EIR, the Project proposes the development of a commercial retail center and does not include a residential component that would result in residents and population within the City. As such, the Project would not directly induce population growth.

The Project would not include components such as the extension of roads or existing infrastructure that would result in the indirect population growth within the City. It is anticipated Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
43 that construction workers and future employees of the Project would reside within the City and surrounding area, and commute to work. Although the operation of the Project would provide employment opportunities in the local area, the Project would not require a specialized labor force that would draw large numbers of new employees to the area. Based on the existing unemployment rates in the City and County, any new employees would already be located within the City limits and would not relocate to the Bakersfield area specifically to obtain jobs associated with the Project. Therefore, the Project would not induce substantial unplanned population growth and would not eliminate impediments to growth. Consequently, the Project would not foster growth inducing impacts.

XI. STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS
The EIR identifies unavoidable significant impacts that would result from implementation of the Project. PRC Section 21081 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15093(b) provide that when a decision of a public agency allows the occurrence of significant impacts that are identified in the EIR, but are not at least substantially mitigated to an insignificant level or eliminated, the lead agency must state in writing the reasons to support its action based on the EIR and/or other information in the record. The City is required to balance, as applicable, the economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of the proposed Project, including regionwide or statewide environmental benefits, against its unavoidable environmental risks when determining whether to approve the Project. The CEQA Guidelines require, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15093(b), that the decision-maker adopt a Statement of Overriding Considerations at the time of approval of a project if it finds that significant adverse environmental effects have been identified in the EIR that cannot be substantially mitigated to an insignificant level or be eliminated. These findings and the Statement of Overriding Considerations are based on the documents and materials that constitute the record of proceedings, including, but not limited to, the Final EIR and all technical appendices attached thereto.

Based on the analysis provided in Section IV, Environmental Impact Analysis, of the Draft EIR, implementation of the Project would result in significant impacts that cannot be feasibly mitigated with respect to: GHG emissions and VMT.

Accordingly, the City adopts the following Statement of Overriding Considerations. The City recognizes that significant and unavoidable impacts would result from implementation of the Project. Having (i) adopted all feasible mitigation measures, including Mitigation Measures GHG-1 through GHG-7, (ii) rejected as infeasible the alternatives to the Project discussed in Section VIII of these Findings, (iii) recognized all significant, unavoidable impacts, and (iv) balanced the benefits of the Project against the Project’s significant and unavoidable impacts, the City hereby finds that each of the Project’s benefits, as listed below, outweigh and override the significant unavoidable impacts relating to: GHG emissions and VMT.

The below stated reasons summarize the benefits, goals and objectives of the Project, and provide the detailed rationale for the benefits of the Project. These overriding considerations of Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
44 economic, social, aesthetic, and environmental benefits for the Project justify adoption of the Project and certification of the completed EIR. Each of the listed Project benefits set forth in this Statement of Overriding Considerations provides a separate and independent ground for the City’s decision to approve the Project despite the Project’s identified significant and unavoidable environmental impacts. Each of the following overriding considerations separately and independently (i) outweighs the adverse environmental impacts of the Project, and (ii) justifies adoption of the Project and certification of the completed EIR. In particular, achieving the underlying purpose for the Project would be sufficient to override the significant environmental impacts of the Project.

1. The Project Would Create Jobs and Enhance City Revenues: The Project would advance the City’s goals to provide employment opportunities, grow the City’s economic base, and increase the City’s revenues. Project construction would generate temporary construction employment for the local workforce. During operation, the Project would require approximately 969 employment opportunities for area residents. The new commercial uses would generate sales tax revenue and property tax revenue for the City.

2. The Project Would Revitalize an Underutilized Site: The Project would transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would create economic, retail, and service opportunities in an area served with existing infrastructure and public services. The Project would provide a modern commercial development with a variety of tenants that responds to the existing and future needs and demands of Bakersfield residents. Careful and judicious use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site. Along the Coffee Road Frontage and Rosedale Highway frontages would run a “dry creek” aesthetic feature composed of decorative cobbles and decomposed granite and crushed rocks. The Project would feature 325,120 square feet of new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian-oriented experience, and provide shade.

3. Sustainable Development
The Project would be an infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. Compliance with state laws regarding water and energy conservation, including Title 24, would also result in increased efficiency and sustainability. Landscaping is anticipated to be native and drought-tolerant and would comply with the Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance (MWELO) per Section 17.61.060, Landscape Plan Requirements of the City of Bakersfield Municipal Code.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
45 2. Bicycle, Pedestrian, and Roadway Improvements: The Project would include several pedestrian and bicycle improvements. The Project provides end-of-trip bicycle amenities, including bicycle parking and lockers, new sidewalks along its frontages, and a new bicycle lane along Rosedale Highway, which extends the existing facilities in the future.

The Project would include off-site improvements, including modification to the existing signalized intersection of Coffee Road and Jet Way. Specifically, the improvements would include the installation of a new traffic light pole/structure at the southeast corner of the Coffee Road and Jet Way intersection and any necessary roadway improvements (i.e., modification to the existing raised median to provide a dedicated left-turn lane and roadway striping).

For the existing signalized intersection of Rosedale Highway and Northwest Promenade, which is the street that provides vehicular access to the commercial retail center north of the Project Site, no improvements or modifications to the traffic signal poles/structures would occur. However, a portion of the raised median on Rosedale Highway (the portion between Northwest Promenade and Coffee Road) would be modified to provide a dedicated left-turn lane for westbound traffic entering the Project Site at the signalized intersection. Other roadway improvements at this intersection would include striping.

The City finds that each of the Project benefits set forth above constitutes a separate and independent basis for overriding the significant and unavoidable environmental impact of the Project, which cannot be feasibly mitigated to less than significant. The City further finds that even if not every benefit identified above is achieved, each individual benefit is sufficient by itself to outweigh the significant and unavoidable impact. After balancing the specific economic, social, legal, and other considerable benefits of the proposed project, the City finds that the remaining significant and unavoidable environmental effects are acceptable due to the factors described in the Statement of Overriding Considerations above.

XII. GENERAL FINDINGS
• The City finds that the EIR for the Riverview Marketplace Project (General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001, Site Plan Review No. 22-0223, and Tentative Tract Map No. 7526; SCH No. 2025101507) was prepared in compliance with CEQA and the CEQA Guidelines. The EIR adequately addresses the environmental effects of the Project. • The City finds that it has independently reviewed and analyzed the EIR and that the EIR reflects the City’s independent judgment.
• The City finds that the responses to comments in the Final EIR adequately address the comments received during the public review period. To the extent that comments raised new environmental issues, those issues were addressed in the Final EIR. • The City finds that the Mitigation Monitoring Program (MMP) has been adopted for the Project. The MMP includes all mitigation measures and project design features identified in the EIR and establishes a monitoring program to ensure implementation and compliance.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Findings
46 • The City finds that the custodian of documents and other materials that constitute the record of proceedings upon which the City’s decision is based is the Development Services Department – Planning Division, 1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor, Bakersfield, California 93301.
• The City finds that the EIR provides adequate, good faith disclosure of environmental impacts as required by CEQA, including potentially significant impacts that cannot be feasibly mitigated to a less than significant level.
• The City hereby adopts these Findings in their entirety. To the extent that these Findings conclude that any proposed mitigation measure is feasible, the City hereby adopts such mitigation measures. Each of the mitigation measures adopted is enforceable through the MMP.

JET WAY

ESPRESSO DR

CAPPUCCINO
WAY

LATTE LN

SILVERLAKE DR

HOODSPORT AVE

COLVILLE AVE

STARSIDE DR

DELBERT ST
HENRY
LN
MOXEE
CT
NEAH
B
AY DR

CAPE FLATTERY DR

EL TORO VIEJO RD

SEABECK AVE

SUNCRISP LN

JENNA KATHRYN DR
ODESSA
CT

ICICLE CREEK DR

WOLF RIVER AVE

KENNEWICK LN

TELSTAR
AVE

LOON CT

GREENBANK
ST

COURTLAND
AVE

CRISPIN ST

PINK LADY
WAY

BELMAC AVE

HENRY LN

OLEO DR

ELZWORTH ST

STEAM CT

SEAVIEW DR

COFFEE FRONTAGE RD

SHOFNER AVE

LANGLEY RD

CHESAW CT

GREENACRES DR
MAX DR

MC INTOSH WAY

RIBSTON AVE

CHATTAROY ST

BOLERO AVE

CLAY PATRICK FARR WAY EL TORO VIEJO RD

GRANITE FALLS DR
COFFEE
RD

COFFEE RD

ROSEDALE HWY ROSEDALE HWY
SI
SI
SI
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
MC
P
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR

LMR LMR
LMR
LMR
LMR
HI

GC GC HI
SI
SI
GC
GC
HMR
LI
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
LMR/LR
OS-P
MUC
MUC
MUC
PS
MC
MC
LR
LR LR
ER
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
MUC
HI HI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
LI
P P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
GC
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
GC
GC
LI
LR LR
LR LR
LR
HMR
OS-P
LI
LI
LI
LI
LR
LR
LR
SI

GREENACRES
PARK
Fruitvale
Junior High
School
BaseEditor_MV
0 350 700
Feet
_
GPA 23-0001

CITY OF BAKERSFIELD
GPA 23-0001
FROM: P
TO: LI
CITY
COUNTY
LEGEND
(GENERAL PLAN

LAND USE)
RR Rural Residential

2.5 gross acres/dwelling unit
ER Estate Residential
1 dwelling unit/net acre
SR Suburban Residential
≤4 dwelling units/net acre
SR/LR
County: ≤ 4 dwelling units/net acre
City: ≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LR Low Density Residential
≤ 7.26 dwelling units/net acre
LMR Low Medium Density Residential
> 4 but ≤ 10 dwelling units/net acre
HMR High Medium Density Residential
>7.26 units but
≤17.42 dwelling units/net acre
HR High Density Residential
>17.42 units but
≤72.6 dwelling units/net acre
HC Highway Commercial
GC General Commercial
MC Major Commercial
OC Office Commercial
MUC Mixed Use Commercial
LI Light Industrial
SI Service Industrial
HI Heavy Industrial
P Public Facilities
PS Public/Private Schools
PT Public Transportation Corridors
P-SW Solid Waste Facilities
OS Open Space
OS-P Parks and Recreation
OS-S Slopes exceeding 30%
R-IA Resource -
Intensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
R-EA Resource -
Extensive Agriculture
20 acre minimum parcel size
80 acre min (Williamson Act)
R-MP Resource -
Minerals & Petroleum
5 acre minimum parcel size
UER Urban Estate Residential
Western Rosedale Plan

0.5 acre net minimum parcel size
WM West Ming Specific Plan
AE{
AEu
COUNTY
CITY
Exhibit C

AK: S:\03_Advance Planning\01_GPAs\01_Active\2021\21-0424_McCutchen Rd and Old River Rd\01_Hearing Documents

CITY OF BAKERSFIELD

PLANNING COMMISSION

STAFF REPORT
MEETING DATE: October 1, 2026 AGENDA CATEGORY: 6.a
TO: Chair and Members of the Planning Commission
FROM: Jennie Eng, Assistant Planning Director J. Eng
DATE: September 25, 2026
FILE: General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001
STAFF PLANNER: Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
REQUEST: A request for (1) Adopt California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Section 15091 Findings, CEQA Section 15093 Statement of Overriding Considerations, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and certify Final Environmental Impact Report; and (2) a General Plan Amendment (GPA) to change the land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) on 46.16 acres located at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road, to facilitate the development of the Riverview Marketplace 405,531 square feet commercial retail center. (Ward 4) APPLICANT: Coffee Road Ventures, LLC
4350 Von Karnman Avenue, Suite 200
Newport Beach, CA 92660

LOCATION: Southwest corner of Rosedale Highway at Coffee Road APN: 368-010-40
PROJECT SIZE: 46.16 acres CEQA: Environmental Impact Report STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends approval of GPA No. 23-0001, certification of the Environmental Impact Report, adoption of the Facts and Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations and recommend the same to the City Council.

EXISTING GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: P (Public Facilities) EXISTING ZONE CLASSIFICATION: M-2 (General Manufacturing) SITE CHARACTERISTICS: The project site consists of one (1) undeveloped parcel previously used for public utilities and now abandoned oil wells. Surrounding properties are primarily developed as: north – GPA No. 23-0001 Page 2
Rosedale Highway and commercial retail; east – Coffee Road and commercial retail; south – PG&E electrical plant; and west –commercial retail and single-family residential.

BACKGROUND AND TIMELINE:
• October 23, 1985 – City Council approved the annexation of the project site to the City of Bakersfield as part of Annexation No. 307 Rancho LaBorde (Resolution No. 135-85) • October 31, 2025 – City staff circulated for a 32-day public review period a Notice of Preparation (NOP) after determining an environmental impact report is required for the General Plan Amendment No. 23-0001 and Site Plan Review No. 22-0223 (State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507). • November 20, 2025 – City staff held an EIR Scoping Meeting to solicit input and written comments from agencies and the public on environmental issues or alternatives to be addressed in the Draft EIR. • July 10, 2026 – A Notice of Availability (NOA) of a Draft Environmental Impact Report was published in the Bakersfield Californian newspaper, sent to agencies, organizations, and interested parties, and posted on the City’s website of a Draft EIR (DEIR; State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507) for the project for a 47-day review period from July 10, 2026, which was extended to conclude on August 26, 2026.

PROJECT ANALYSIS:

The General Plan Amendment (“GPA”) request submitted by Coffee Road Ventures, LLC (applicant and property owner) is proposing a GPA to change the Land Use Element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial), or a more restrictive designation on approximately 46.16 acres located on the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road, in northwest Bakersfield [Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) 368-010-40].

The Riverview Market Commercial Project (Project) will involve the construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space, located on an approximately 46.16- acre parcel (Project Site). The Project Site is situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway (CA-58), north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road.

The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps. Other Project components include vehicular access and circulation improvements (both on- and off-site); surface parking areas and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; various landscape, hardscape, and lighting improvements; green space/park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility improvements.

Site Plan Review.

If the general plan amendment is approved as requested, the application for site plan approval will be considered by the Planning Director prior to obtaining building permits. Pursuant to BMC Section

17.08.060, no construction of any improvements that require a building permit for renovation of improvements shall be permitted without first obtaining site plan approval. The proposed development of a commercial retail center will require to undergo review by the Site Plan Review (SPR) Committee, as GPA No. 23-0001 Page 3
listed below, for compliance with City development standards. The Development Services Director may then approve, conditionally approve, or deny the site plan. There is no requirement for Planning Commission consideration unless the Development Services Director’s decision is appealed. • Development Services Department/Building Division
• Development Services Department/Planning Division
• Development Services Department/ Land Development
• Fire Department
• Water Resources
• Public Works Department/Traffic Division
• Public Works Department/Solid Waste Division
• Recreation and Parks Department (as needed)
Compatibility with Land Use Element. Staff has reviewed the proposal for compatibility with the applicable goals and policies contained within the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan Land Use Element and finds the following:

Goal 1: Accommodate new development which captures the economic demands generated by the marketplace and establishes Bakersfield’s role as the capital of the southern San Joaquin Valley.

The project is a new commercial development that captures the current commercial marketplace within the southern San Joaquin Valley.

Goal 4: Accommodate new development which channels land uses in a phased, orderly manner and is coordinated with the provision of infrastructure and public improvements.

The necessary infrastructure and public improvements are available to accommodate commercial developments or, if the project is approved, will be developed through the fair-share payment of impact fees by the property owner. Therefore, the project is consistent with this goal.

Policy 75: Provide adequate land area for the expansion of existing uses and development of new uses consistent with the policies of the general plan.

The project site is located on existing industrial zone land near commercial land uses. Therefore, adequate land is available for the project, and the project expands existing commercial land uses. Therefore, the project is consistent with this policy.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND DETERMINATION:

Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the City of Bakersfield is the Lead Agency for the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project). A Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) was prepared to evaluate the potential environmental impacts associated with implementation of the Project. The DEIR, State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507, was prepared in conformance with CEQA and the CEQA Guidelines and is intended to disclose information to the public and decision-makers regarding the potential environmental effects of the Project. The DEIR does not recommend either approval or denial of the Project; rather, it provides an independent and impartial analysis of the foreseeable environmental impacts associated with the proposed course of action.

GPA No. 23-0001 Page 4
In accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15082, the City of Bakersfield filed a Notice of Preparation (NOP) with the Governor's Office of Planning and Research, State Clearinghouse, and distributed the NOP to responsible and trustee agencies, other affected agencies, and interested parties to solicit input regarding the scope and content of the EIR. Comments received during the NOP process identified potential concerns related to construction and operational air quality emissions, biological resources, cultural and Tribal cultural resources, and blight.

In addition, the Lead Agency held a publicly noticed EIR Scoping Meeting on November 20, 2025, at the City of Bakersfield City Hall Council Chambers. At the Scoping Meeting, information was provided about the proposed Project, the intended scope of the EIR, and provided the opportunity for public agencies and members of the public to comment on the scope of environmental issues to be addressed in this EIR. No comments were received at the Scoping Meeting. Refer to the DEIR, Appendix A, for the NOP presentation and comment letters received.

Based on the analysis contained in the comments received in response to the NOP, a Notice of Availability (NOA) and DEIR were prepared for the Project in accordance with CEQA. The NOA/DEIR was circulated for a 45-day public and agency review period from July 10, 2026, to August 24, 2026, but was extended to August 26, 2026, due to delays in posting with the State Clearinghouse (DEIR: State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507). The DEIR, including its technical appendices, was also made available for review at the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department, Planning Division, and online through the City's Environmental Documents webpage. In response, the City received a total of six (6) comment letters from two state agencies, one law firm, one special interest group, and two public commenters. Please refer to the Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for the comment letters, a summary of the comments, and Lead Agency responses.

Comments. The six comment letters generally focused on the adequacy of the DEIR’s analysis and mitigation. The main issues raised were air quality and health risks, biological resources, traffic and circulation, greenhouse gas emissions, cumulative impacts, and infrastructure. Several commenters requested additional analysis or stronger mitigation, particularly for operational air quality, sensitive species, fuel station traffic and queuing, and climate-related impacts. The agency comments also emphasized compliance with applicable regulatory requirements and coordination with the appropriate agencies.

Project Objectives. CEQA Guidelines Section 15124(b) requires a statement of project objectives. The objectives of the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project are as follows:

A. Develop a project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City.

B. Promote an infill development that incorporates sustainable principles of smart growth.

C. Encourage and facilitate new commercial uses featuring high-quality architecture and design.

D. Provide a mixture of commercial uses that creates new activity and services for the surrounding area while remaining cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities.

E. Create new and future employment opportunities.

F. Provide a circulation system responsive to the needs of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian travel.

GPA No. 23-0001 Page 5
G. Incorporate new native and drought-tolerant landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter.

H. Create a visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

Identification of Impacts. The thresholds of significance used in the DEIR are based on the thresholds presented in CEQA Guidelines Appendix G, as applicable, and take into account applicable federal, State, and local regulations; City policies and ordinances; standards established by regulatory agencies; and the judgment of the technical experts that prepared the environmental analysis and supporting technical studies.

The following terms are used to describe the level of significance related to the physical conditions within the area affected by the proposed Project:

A. No Impact – The Project would not result in an adverse change to the physical environment.

B. Less-than-Significant Impact – The Project would result in an adverse change to the physical environment, but the change would not be substantial or potentially substantial and would not exceed the applicable threshold of significance.

C. Potentially Significant Impact – The Project could result in a substantial or potentially substantial adverse change to the physical environment that exceeds the applicable threshold of significance and requires the consideration of mitigation measures.

If impacts are identified as potentially significant, feasible mitigation measures are identified to avoid or substantially lessen the impact where possible. The following terms are used to describe the level of significance following the application of mitigation measures:

A. Less-than-Significant Impact with Mitigation Incorporated – The Project would result in a potentially significant impact; however, implementation of feasible mitigation measures would reduce the impact to a less-than-significant level.

B. Significant and Unavoidable Impact – The Project would result in a substantial or potentially substantial adverse change to the physical environment that exceeds the applicable threshold of significance, and feasible mitigation measures are either unavailable or would not reduce the impact to below a level of significance.

No Impact. Based on the environmental analysis contained in the DEIR, the Project would result in no impacts to the following environmental resource areas:

1. Agriculture and Forest Resources

2. Mineral Resources

3. Wildfire
Less-than-Significant Impacts. The DEIR determined that the Project would result in less-than-significant impacts to the following environmental resource areas without the need for mitigation:

1. Aesthetics

2. Energy

3. Hazards and Hazardous Materials
GPA No. 23-0001 Page 6

4. Hydrology and Water Quality

5. Land Use and Planning

6. Noise

7. Population and Housing

8. Public Services and Recreation

9. Utilities and Service Systems
Less-than-Significant Impacts with Mitigation Incorporated. The DEIR identified potentially significant impacts that would be reduced to a less-than-significant level through implementation of mitigation measures in the following environmental resource areas:

1. Air Quality

2. Biological Resources

3. Cultural Resources

4. Geology and Soils
CEQA requires lead agencies to identify and impose feasible mitigation measures that could avoid or substantially lessen significant adverse effects on the physical environment. Mitigation measures have been identified to address these impacts, including measures related to operational air emissions and volatile organic compounds; burrowing owl and nesting bird protection; inadvertent discovery of cultural resources and human remains; and the discovery and treatment of paleontological resources during ground-disturbing activities. These measures would be incorporated into the Project through the applicable approval and implementation process. Under Section 15091 of the CEQA Guidelines, a public agency cannot approve a project with significant environmental effects identified in an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) unless it adopts written findings of fact with a brief explanation for each significant impact
Significant and Unavoidable Impacts. CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.2(b) requires that an EIR disclose significant environmental effects that cannot be avoided if the proposed project is implemented. Based on the analysis contained in the DEIR, the Project would result in significant and unavoidable impacts related to:

1. Greenhouse Gas Emissions

2. Transportation (Traffic)
The DEIR identifies mitigation measures intended to reduce these impacts; however, even with implementation of the identified measures, impacts related to greenhouse gas emissions and transportation would remain significant and unavoidable. Under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15093, a Statement of Overriding Considerations (SOC) is a formal document a public agency must adopt if it decides to approve a project that will cause significant and unavoidable environmental impacts. When a project's negative environmental effects cannot be fully mitigated or avoided, the agency cannot legally approve the project unless it officially states that the project's benefits outweigh its environmental downsides.

Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15097, a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) will be prepared and adopted in conjunction with certification of the Final EIR to ensure implementation of the mitigation measures imposed as part of Project approval. The MMRP will identify the mitigation measures, responsible parties, timing of implementation, and monitoring procedures applicable throughout the appropriate phases of Project development.

GPA No. 23-0001 Page 7
Alternatives. CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6 requires an EIR to evaluate a reasonable range of alternatives to the proposed project that would feasibly attain most of the basic project objectives while avoiding or substantially lessening one or more of the significant environmental effects of the proposed Project. The DEIR evaluates three alternatives to the proposed Project:

1. Alternative 1 – No Build/No Project Alternative. Under this alternative, the Project would not proceed and the Project Site would remain in its existing condition. No new development would occur.

2. Alternative 2 – Reduced Project Alternative. This alternative assumes a 25 percent reduction in all proposed Project land uses. Total commercial development would be reduced from approximately 405,531 square feet to approximately 304,148 square feet, and the number of dual-sided fuel pumps would be reduced from 20 to 15. The buildings would generally maintain the same arrangement as the proposed Project but would have smaller footprints.

3. Alternative 3 – Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative. Under this alternative, the Project Site would be developed in accordance with its existing Public Facilities land use designation and applicable zoning and deed restrictions. For purposes of the analysis, this alternative assumes development of a municipal maintenance and storage yard, including public works offices, fleet services, equipment and materials storage, employee parking, a detention basin, and a fueling facility.

Environmentally Superior Alternative. As required by CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6(e)(2), the DEIR identifies an environmentally superior alternative. Alternative 1, the No Build/No Project Alternative, is identified as the environmentally superior alternative because it would not involve new development and would avoid the potentially significant and significant and unavoidable impacts associated with implementation of the proposed Project.

Because CEQA requires identification of an environmentally superior alternative among the remaining build alternatives when the No Project Alternative is selected, Alternative 3, the Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative, is also identified as the environmentally superior alternative among the build alternatives. Alternative 3 would reduce the Project's significant and unavoidable vehicle miles traveled impacts and reduce mitigation required for air quality impacts. However, Alternative 3 would not achieve several of the Project objectives, including providing a new commercial development, new shopping and services, and the same level of employment opportunities and visual improvements proposed by the Project.

Environmental Conclusion. As required by CEQA, the EIR includes appropriate review, analysis, and mitigation measures for the environmental impacts of the proposed project. The EIR has been prepared in accordance with CEQA Guidelines for certification. If the project were to be approved, a Statement of Facts and Findings, a Statement of Overriding Considerations, and a Mitigation Monitoring Program must also be adopted. If certified, the EIR could be utilized by other permitting agencies in their capacity as Responsible and Trustee agencies under CEQA. As required by Departmental procedures for processing an EIR, the applicant has executed an indemnification agreement. Following completion of the public review process and preparation of responses to comments, a Final EIR will be prepared for consideration by the City's decision-making bodies. The Final EIR, together with the DEIR, responses to comments, MMRP, and other supporting information, will provide the environmental record for consideration of certification of the EIR and the requested Project approvals.

PUBLIC NOTIFICATION:

GPA No. 23-0001 Page 8
Public notice for the proposed project and environmental determination was advertised in The Bakersfield Californian and posted on the bulletin board in the City of Bakersfield City Hall North, 1600 Truxtun Avenue, Bakersfield, California. All property owners within a 300-foot radius of the project site were notified by United States Postal Service mail regarding this public hearing in accordance with city ordinance and state law.

Comments Received. As of this writing, we have received no written comments in response to the Public Hearing Notice.

CONCLUSIONS:

Consistency with Surrounding Development. The project is designed to introduce additional economic opportunities by adding commercial uses to the vicinity.

Consistency with General Plan/Zoning Ordinance. The proposal is consistent with land use goals and policies as contained in the General Plan related to commercial development, as noted above. Should the applicant submit site development plans, they will be reviewed for compliance with requirements and regulations as set forth in the Bakersfield Municipal Code Title 17 (Zoning Ordinance) and City Development Standards.

Recommendation. Staff finds that the applicable provisions of CEQA have been complied with, and the proposal is compatible with the surrounding area, land use designation, and zoning ordinance. Based on information in the record, Staff recommends your Commission: (1) Adopt Resolution Adopting the California Environmental Quality Act Section 15091 Findings, CEQA Section 15093 Statement of Overriding Considerations, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and Certifying the Final Environmental Impact Report; and (2) Adopt Resolution Approving a general plan amendment to change the land use designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) to facilitate the development of a 405,531 square feet commercial retail center; and recommend the same to City Council.

ATTACHMENTS:

Attachment A: Map Set
• GPA/WAC Aerial
• GPA/WAC Zone Classification
• GPA/WAC General Plan Designation
Attachment B: Conceptual Site Plan
Attachment C: Environmental Impact Report with Attachments Attachment D: Statement of Fact and Findings and Statement of Overriding Considerations Attachment E: Planning Commission Draft Resolutions
• Certify EIR with Attachments
• Approve GPA with Attachments
Draft EIR
Riverview
Marketplace
Commercial
Project
July 2026
Prepared by
5 1 noimsun
"I v "f f
x
p.
y
6 k
4 3 92 "Aresn
gme —
ram
£
al V.V a
ir
d
2 pdst , "7
g’d *
% i
fn
Cu BAKERSFIELD —t 2 THE SOUND OF Gawelljinoy Belter
“Mu
e
e
0g
" “ . t - i
_ - . . - -
ttas ..“Susudem ‘2S,.-
-
Ym
Kimley»Horn
Expect More. Experience Better.

Draft Environmental Impact Report
Riverview Marketplace
Commercial Project
SCH # 2025101507
Prepared for:

City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department
Planning Division
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Prepared by:

Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
660 South Figueroa Street, Suite 2050
Los Angeles, CA 90017
P 213.261.4040
July 2026
Kimley»Horn

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-1
Executive Summary
ES.1 Purpose
This Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) has been prepared to evaluate the potential environmental impacts associated with the implementation of the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), State Clearinghouse No. 2025101507. This document is prepared in conformance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and the CEQA Guidelines.

The purpose of this Draft EIR is to disclose information to the public and decision makers about the potential environmental effects of the Project. This Draft EIR does not recommend either approval or denial of the Project; rather, it is intended to provide a source of independent and impartial analysis of the foreseeable environmental impacts of a proposed course of action. This Draft EIR describes the Project, evaluates its environmental effects, and discusses reasonable alternatives that would attempt to avoid, reduce, or minimize environmental impacts. The City of Bakersfield will consider the information presented in this document in making an informed decision regarding the Project.

This summary is provided in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15123. As stated in the CEQA Guidelines Section 15123(a), “an EIR shall contain a brief summary of the proposed actions and its consequences. The language of the summary should be as clear and simple as reasonably practical.” As required by the Guidelines, this section includes: (1) a summary description of the Project; (2) a discussion of the areas of controversy associated with the project; (3) identification of the alternatives evaluated and of the environmentally superior alternative; and (4) a synopsis of environmental impacts and recommended mitigation measures.

ES.2 Proposed Project
As described in Chapter 2, Project Description, of this Draft EIR, the Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six-foot-tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells, electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles, and several dirt roads and mounds.

The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space. The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time.

However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-2
The Project would feature new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience and provide shade. The Project would also include enhanced paving areas within small plaza areas in front of storefronts, and enhanced vehicular paving at entry points. The Project would include a detention basin on the northern portion of the Project Site that would be fenced and screened with landscaping. Near the detention basin would be a play area which would include landscaped mounds, benches, picnic tables, bike racks, and a lawn area.

Loading and unloading of delivery trucks for the major retail buildings would occur in the designated loading dock of that building, which are toward the rear of the buildings. For the tenants of the outlying building pads, loading and unloading of delivery trucks would occur in designated areas (within proximity of the tenants) that would not impede the internal vehicular circulation system. No loading or unloading activities would occur in the parking areas or non-designated loading/unloading areas.

The discretionary entitlements, reviews, permits and approvals required to implement the Project include, but are not necessarily limited to, the following:
• Site Plan Review consistent with the Bakersfield Municipal Code Section 17.08.140. • General Plan Amendment (GPA) of the land use element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan) from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) • Tentative Tract Map
• Comprehensive Sign Plan
ES.3 Project Objectives
Chapter 2, Project Description, describes the purpose of the Project and the Project’s underlying objectives. The objectives of the Project are:
• A Project that allows for the revitalization of the Project Site, adapting to changing market conditions and providing economic benefits to the City. • An infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. • A Project that encourages and facilitates new uses of high-quality architecture and design.
• A mixture of commercial uses that provides new activity and services to the area and is cohesive with established neighborhoods, businesses, and community amenities nearby.
• Creation of new and future employment opportunities.
• A circulation system responsive to the needs of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian travel.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-3
• New native and drought-tolerant landscaping that visually enhances the Project Site and surrounding perimeter.
• A visually harmonious development as viewed both internally and externally.

ES.4 Areas of Controversy
The following lists potential environmental issues or concerns raised in response to the Notice of Preparation (NOP), and where these issues are addressed in the Draft EIR:
• Impacts from construction and operational emissions, addressed in Section 4.3, Air Quality;
• Impacts to biological resources, addressed in Section 4.4, Biological Resources; • Impacts to Tribal cultural resources, addressed in Section 4.5, Cultural Resources, and Section 4.17, Tribal Cultural Resources; and
• Impacts from blight, addressed in Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning.

Appendix A includes a copy of the NOP, NOP Presentation, and the comment letters received in response to the NOP. The issues raised during the NOP are addressed as part of the Draft EIR in the respective sections listed above. As described in the respective sections, the Project would be consistent with issues raised in the comment letters.

ES.5 Alternatives to the Proposed Project
This section of the Draft EIR considers three alternatives to the Project. These alternatives include:
• Alternative 1: No Build/No Project
• Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative
• Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative Consistent with CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6(c), Alternatives 2 through 3 represent a range of reasonable “build” alternatives that could feasibly accomplish the project objectives discussed in Section 5.3, Project Objectives, and could potentially lessen the environmental impacts of the proposed Project. Per CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6(e), the alternatives analysis includes the required “No Build/No Project” alternative. The purpose of describing and analyzing the “No Build/No Project” alternative is to allow decisionmakers the ability to compare the impacts of approving the proposed Project with the impacts of not approving the proposed Project.

Each of the three alternatives is described in greater detail in Chapter 5, Alternatives. Each alternative is described and evaluated in sufficient detail to determine whether the overall environmental impacts would be less than, similar to, or greater than the corresponding impacts of the Project. Furthermore, each alternative is evaluated to determine whether the Project objectives could be substantially attained by the alternative.

ES.5.1 Alternative 1: No Build/No Project
Pursuant to Section 15126.6(e)(3)(B) of the CEQA Guidelines, Alternative 1, the “No Project” Alternative, represents the circumstance under which the Project does not proceed. Under Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-4
Alternative 1 it is assumed that the existing state of the Project Site would remain as is and no new development would be implemented. As discussed in Chapter 2, Project Description, of this Draft EIR, the Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by a six-foott tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds.

ES.5.2 Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative
Reduced Project Alternative assumes a 25% reduction of all proposed Project land uses.

Accordingly, the total commercial square footage would be reduced from 405,531 square feet to approximately 304,148 square feet, and the total number of dual-sided fuel pumps would be reduced from 20 to 15. The buildings would be constructed in the same general arrangement as currently proposed and set forth in the site plan, but with a smaller footprint. The areas not covered by buildings would be used for surface parking for passenger vehicles, and the site’s vehicular access would be the same general arrangement as currently proposed and set forth in the site plan. The development characteristics of this Reduced Project Alternative are assumed to be similar to those of the Project, including excavation and earth movement.

ES.5.3 Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative Under this alternative, it is assumed that the Project Site will be developed in accordance with the current Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (MBGP) land use and zoning designations. Thus, this alternative assumes the Project Site would be developed with a by-right use and no General Plan amendment or zone change would be necessary. The Project Site’s current Public Facilities (P) designation, as well as the prohibitions in the deed restriction and restrictive covenant that encumber the property, significantly limit the types of uses permitted on the Project Site. Based on the site’s Public Facilities designation, the allowed uses are limited to the following:

Public Facilities (P): includes government buildings, hospitals, public utilities, cemeteries, sewage treatment plants, waste disposal sites and other publicly owned facilities.

For purposes of the analysis, the maximum allowable development of the Project Site is in accordance with the MBGP. Based thereon, Alternative 3 would consist of a municipal maintenance and storage yard that serves as the central deployment hub for a public works department. This alternative development includes facilities for fleet maintenance, material storage, and administrative offices. All existing on-site uses, except the transmission facilities, would be removed to accommodate this alternative.

Under Alternative 3, the Project Site would be developed with approximately 100,900 square feet of commercial uses, consisting of office space to accommodate multiple divisions within a public works department (i.e. parks & rec, streets, solid waste). The Project Site would also be developed with industrial uses, including a 128,000 square foot fleet services building, approximately 30 acres of construction, equipment, and stockpile storage space, a 58,000 square foot laydown with Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-5
detention basin, and a 5,300 square foot fueling facility. This alternative will also include 335,000 square feet of employee parking.1
ES.5.4 Environmentally Superior Alternative
CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.6(e)(2) indicates that an analysis of alternatives to a proposed project shall identify an environmentally superior alternative among the alternatives evaluated in an EIR and that if the “no project” alternative is the environmentally superior alternative, the EIR shall identify another environmentally superior alternative among the remaining alternatives.

Selection of an environmentally superior alternative is based on comparison of the alternatives to determine which among the alternatives would reduce or eliminate the impacts associated with the Project to the greatest degree.

Of the alternatives analyzed in this Draft EIR, Alternative 1 would be considered the environmentally superior alternative because it would not involve new development and assumes that the Project Site would remain vacant under existing conditions. Although Alternative 1 would not meet any of the Project objectives, it would avoid all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts and significant and unavoidable impacts and would have reduced impacts compared to the Project. However, because Alternative 1 has been identified as the environmentally superior alternative, identification of another environmentally superior alternative is required.

Alternative 3, involving development of the Project Site in accordance with current land use and zoning designations, would reduce the Project’s significant and unavoidable VMT impacts and would reduce mitigation measures required for Air Quality. With the exception of Aesthetics impacts, all impacts would be reduced or would be similar to the Project.

However, Alternative 3 would not meet several objectives of the Project as it would not provide a new commercial development that would provide new activities, shopping, and services for residents. Alternative 3 would not generate new employment activities to the same extent as the Project, nor would it develop a new commercial development that would be harmonious with surrounding commercial development. Alternative 3 would not visually improve the Project Site to the same degree as the Project, as new landscaping, high quality commercial architecture, signage and other aesthetic improvements would not occur.

ES.6 Summary of Impacts
Based on the environmental analysis completed for the proposed Project and discussed in Chapter 4, Environmental Impact Analysis, significant and unavoidable impacts have been identified for the following environmental resource factors:
• Section 4.8, Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• Section 4.16, Transportation
Significant impacts requiring mitigation to reduce the impact to less than significant have been identified for the following environmental resource factors:
• Section 4.3, Air Quality
1 This alternative project was derived and scaled based on input from the City’s Public Works Department of desired improvements on a new 30-acre public works yard.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-6
• Section 4.4, Biological Resources
• Section 4.5, Cultural Resources
• Section 4.7, Geology and Soils
Less than significant impacts were identified in the following environmental resource factors:
• Section 4.1, Aesthetics
• Section 4.6, Energy
• Section 4.9, Hazards and Hazardous Materials
• Section 4.10, Hydrology and Water Quality
• Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning
• Section 4.13, Noise
• Section 4.14, Population and Housing
• Section 4.15, Public Services and Recreation
• Section 4.18, Utilities and Service Systems
No impacts were identified for the following environmental resource factors:
• Section 4.2, Agriculture and Forest Resources
• Section 4.12, Mineral Resources
• Section 4.19, Wildfire
ES.7 Review of the Draft EIR
Pursuant to Public Resources Code (PRC) Section 21161, upon completion of this Draft EIR, the City of Bakersfield prepared and filed a Notice of Completion (NOC) with the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research-State Clearinghouse to start the public review period. Concurrent with the NOC, the lead agency distributed a Notice of Availability (NOA) in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15087. The NOA was mailed to the agencies, organizations, and individuals who previously requested in writing. This Draft EIR was distributed to responsible and trustee agencies, other affected agencies, surrounding cities and municipalities, and all interested parties requesting a copy of this document in accordance with PRC Section 21092(b)(3). During the public review period, this Draft EIR, including the appendices, is available for review at the following location:

City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department – Planning Division
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Online: https://www.bakersfieldcity.us/279/Environmental-Documents Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-7
Agencies, organizations, individuals, and all other interested parties not previously contacted, or who did not respond to the NOP, currently have the opportunity to comment on this Draft EIR during the 45-day public review period. The written comments on this Draft EIR should be addressed to:

City of Bakersfield
Development Services Department – Planning Division
Attn: Ashley Knight, Assistant Planner
1715 Chester Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Email: [email protected]
Upon completion of the public review period, written responses to all substantive environmental comments will be prepared and made available for review at least 10 days prior to the public hearing on the proposed Project before the City of Bakersfield Planning Commission, at which the Final EIR will be considered and may be recommended for subsequent certification by the City of Bakersfield City Council. The comments received and the responses to those comments will be included as part of the record for consideration of the proposed Project.

ES.8 Summary of Environmental Impacts & Mitigation
Measures
Table ES-1, Summary of Significant Impacts and Proposed Mitigation Measures, is a summary of significant impacts and proposed mitigation measures associated with the Project as identified in this Draft EIR. Refer to Sections 4.1 through 4.19 in this Draft EIR for a detailed description of the environmental impacts and mitigation measures for the Project.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-8
This page intentionally left blank.

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 i
Table of Contents
ES EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...........................................................................................ES-1 ES.1 Purpose .........................................................................................................ES-1 ES.2 Proposed Project ...........................................................................................ES-1 ES.3 Project Objectives..........................................................................................ES-2 ES.4 Areas of Controversy .....................................................................................ES-3 ES.5 Alternatives to the Proposed Project ..............................................................ES-3 ES.5.1 Alternative 1: No Build/No Project.......................................................ES-3 ES.5.2 Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative..........................................ES-4 ES.5.3 Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative ......................ES-4 ES.5.4 Environmentally Superior Alternative..................................................ES-5 ES.6 Summary of Impacts ......................................................................................ES-5 ES.7 Review of the Draft EIR..................................................................................ES-6 ES.8 Summary of Environmental Impacts & Mitigation Measures...........................ES-7

1. INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................1-1

1.1 Overview of the Proposed Project.....................................................................1-1

1.2 Purpose of the Environmental Impact Report (EIR)...........................................1-1

1.3 Environmental Review Process.........................................................................1-1

1.4 Scoping Process...............................................................................................1-2

1.4.1 Notice of Preparation.............................................................................1-2

1.4.2 Scoping Meeting....................................................................................1-2

1.5 Organization of the Draft EIR ............................................................................1-2

2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION ...........................................................................................2-1

2.1 Environmental Setting.......................................................................................2-1

2.1.1 Project Location.....................................................................................2-1

2.1.2 Existing Conditions................................................................................2-1

2.1.3 General Plan and Zoning.......................................................................2-1

2.2 Description of Project........................................................................................2-7

2.2.1 Project Overview ...................................................................................2-7 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ii

2.2.2 Access, Circulation, and Parking .........................................................2-13

2.2.3 Pedestrian Access and Circulation ......................................................2-13

2.2.4 Loading and Deliveries ........................................................................2-13

2.2.5 Design Concept...................................................................................2-14

2.2.6 Open Space and Landscaping ............................................................2-14

2.2.7 Lighting and Signage...........................................................................2-21

2.2.8 Infrastructure Improvements................................................................2-21

2.2.9 Operational Hours ...............................................................................2-21

2.2.10 Sustainability Features ........................................................................2-21

2.3 Project Phasing and Construction ...................................................................2-22

2.4 Requested Permits and Approvals..................................................................2-22

3. ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING ......................................................................................... 3-1

3.1 Regional Setting................................................................................................3-1

3.2 Project Site Setting ...........................................................................................3-1

3.3 Cumulative Development..................................................................................3-1

4. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ANALYSIS......................................................................... 4-1

4.1 Aesthetics ..................................................

4.2 Agriculture and Forest Resources..........

4.3 Air Quality ..............................................

4.4 Biological Resources .....................................................................................4.4-1

4.5 Cultural Resources ........................................................................................4.5-1

4.6 Energy ...........................................................................................................4.6-1

4.7 Geology and Soils..........................................................................................4.7-1

4.8 Greenhouse Gas Emissions..........................................................................4.8-1

4.9 Hazards and Hazardous Materials .................................................................4.9-1

4.10 Hydrology and Water Quality .......................................................................4.10-1

4.11 Land Use and Planning................................................................................4.11-1

4.12 Mineral Resources.......................................................................................4.12-1

4.13 Noise ...........................................................................................................4.13-1

4.14 Population and Housing...............................................................................4.14-1 ..................................................... .........4.1-1 1 .........4.2-1
.........4.3-1
1 1
............................. .........
............................. .........
............................. .........
............................. .........

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 iii

4.15 Public Services and Recreation ...................................................................4.15-1

4.16 Transportation..............................................................................................4.16-1

4.17 Tribal Cultural Resources.............................................................................4.17-1

4.18 Utilities and Service Systems.......................................................................4.18-1

4.19 Wildfire.........................................................................................................4.19-1

5. ALTERNATIVES ............................................................................................................. 5-1

5.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................5-1

5.2 Project Summary ..............................................................................................5-1

5.3 Project Objectives.............................................................................................5-2

5.4 Project Impacts .................................................................................................5-2

5.5 Summary of Project Alternatives .......................................................................5-3

5.5.1 Alternative 1: No Build/No Project..........................................................5-4

5.5.2 Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative...........................................5-15

5.5.3 Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative .......................5-25

5.6 Alternatives Considered but Rejected .............................................................5-35

5.6.1 Alternative Site ....................................................................................5-35

5.7 Environmentally Superior Alternative ..............................................................5-36

6. OTHER CEQA CONSIDERATIONS................................................................................ 6-1

6.1 Significant and Unavoidable Impacts ................................................................6-1

6.2 Irreversible Environmental Changes .................................................................6-1

6.3 Growth-Inducing Impacts ..................................................................................6-3

7. REFERENCES................................................................................................................ 7-1

8. LIST OF PREPARERS.................................................................................................... 8-1

8.1 Lead Agency.....................................................................................................8-1

8.2 EIR Preparers ...................................................................................................8-1

8.3 Technical Subconsultants .................................................................................8-1 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 iv
Tables
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures ..................................................ES-9 Table 2-1: Proposed Uses........................................................................................................2-7 Table 2-2: Matrix of Project Approvals/Permits.......................................................................2-23 Table 3-1: Cumulative Projects List..........................................................................................3-2 Table 4.3-1: Ambient Air Quality Standards for Criteria Pollutants.........................................4.3-2 Table 4.3-2: Attainment Status of Criteria Pollutants in the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin ...4.3-18 Table 4.3-3: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Summary ........................................................4.3-19 Table 4.3-4: SJVAPCD Regional Criteria Pollutants Significance Thresholds .....................4.3-20 Table 4.3-5: Ambient Air Quality Thresholds .......................................................................4.3-21 Table 4.3-6: SJVAPCD Significant Impact Levels ...............................................................4.3-21 Table 4.3-7: SJVAPCD Screening Levels for Potential Odor Sources.................................4.3-22 Table 4.3-8: SJVAPCD Toxic Air Contaminants Incremental Risk Thresholds ....................4.3-23 Table 4.3-9: Annual Regional Construction Emissions ........................................................4.3-26 Table 4.3-10: Average Daily Construction-Related Emissions.............................................4.3-27 Table 4.3-11: Annual Regional Operation Emissions ..........................................................4.3-28 Table 4.3-12: Average Daily Operation-Related Emissions.................................................4.3-28 Table 4.3-13: Ambient Air Quality Analysis Summary .........................................................4.3-29 Table 4.3-14: Comparison of Concentrations to Significant Impact Levels ..........................4.3-29 Table 4.3-15: Annual Regional Operation Emissions With Mitigation ..................................4.3-30 Table 4.3-16: Construction Risk Summary ..........................................................................4.3-32 Table 4.4-1: Threatened, Endangered, Candidate, or 1B.1 Ranked Plant Species ...............4.4-8 Table 4.4-2: Threatened, Endangered, or Candidate Wildlife Species...................................4.4-9 Table 4.5-1: Recorded Cultural Resources at Project Site ..................................................4.5-16 Table 4.5-2: California Register Eligibility Evaluation...........................................................4.5-17 Table 4.6-1: Construction-Related Fuel Usage......................................................................4.6-8 Table 4.6-2: Project Electricity Demand ................................................................................4.6-9 Table 4.6-3: Project Natural Gas Demand...........................................................................4.6-10 Table 4.6-4: Project Annual Operation-Related Fuel Usage................................................4.6-11 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 v
Table 4.8-1: GHG Emissions and Their Relative Global Warming Potential Compared to CO2................................................................................................................4.8-12 Table 4.8-2: Project Operation GHG Emissions Inventory...................................................4.8-18 Table 4.8-3: Project Operation GHG Emissions Inventory With Reduction Measures GHG-1 and GHG-3 .............................................................................................................4.8-21 Table 4.9-1 Current Adjacent Land Uses ..............................................................................4.9-9 Table 4.9-2: Historical Land Uses .......................................................................................4.9-10 Table 4.11-1: General Plan Consistency...........................................................................4.11-10 Table 4.13-1: Typical Noise Levels .....................................................................................4.13-4 Table 4.13-2: Human Reaction to Typical Vibration Levels ................................................4.13-5 Table 4.13-3: Exterior Stationary Noise Standards..............................................................4.13-7 Table 4.13-4: Long-Term Noise Measurement Summary....................................................4.13-9 Table 4.13-5: Short-Term Noise Measurements Summary in A-Weighted Sound Levels ....4.13-9 Table 4.13-6: Groundborne Vibration Criteria: Architectural Damage ................................4.13-11 Table 4.13-7: Groundborne Annoyance Criteria ................................................................4.13-12 Table 4.13-8: Phase 1 Project-Related Construction Noise, dBA Leq.................................4.13-14 Table 4.13-9: Phase 2 Project-Related Construction Noise, dBA Leq.................................4.13-14 Table 4.13-10: Project and Cumulative Traffic Noise Increase ..........................................4.13-17 Table 4.13-11: Attenuated Noise Levels at Sensitive Receptors, dBA Lmax........................4.13.20 Table 4.13-12: Vibration Levels for Phase 1 Construction Equipment (in/sec PPV) ..........4.13-22 Table 4.13-13: Vibration Levels for Phase 2 Construction Equipment (in/sec PPV) ..........4.13.23 Table 4.13-14: Vibration Levels for Phase 1 Construction Equipment (VdB)......................4.13.23 Table 4.13-15: Vibration Levels for Phase 2 Construction Equipment (VdB)......................4.13.24 Table 4.14-1: Population Projections for Kern County and the City of Bakersfield ...............4.14-5 Table 4.14-2: Households in Kern County and the City of Bakersfield .................................4.14-5 Table 4.14-3: Kern County and City of Bakersfield 6th Cycle RHNA.....................................4.14-5 Table 4.14-4: Employment in Kern County and the City of Bakersfield ................................4.14-6 Table 4.16-1: Project Employment Estimation .....................................................................4.16-6 Table 4.16-2: Project Trip Generation................................................................................4.16-10 Table 4.16-3: Retail Land Uses Project VMT.....................................................................4.16-15 Table 4.16-4: Medical Office Land Use Project VMT .........................................................4.16-15 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 vi
Table 4.18-1: Project Water Demand.................................................................................4.18-11 Table 4.18-2: Current and Projected Potable Water Demands for the Domestic Water System (afy) ..................................................................................................................................4.18-11 Table 4.18-3: Current and Projected Potable Water Demands for the Wholesale Water System (afy) ..................................................................................................................................4.18-11 Table 4.18-4: Actual Water Supplies for the Domestic Water System (afy)........................4.18-12 Table 4.18-5: Normal, Single Dry, and Multiple Dry Year Supply and Demand for the Domestic Water System (afy)......................................................................................4.18-12 Table 5-1: Comparison of the Impacts of the Project and Alternatives ....................................5-37 Figures
Figure 2-1: Regional Location Map ..........................................................................................2-3 Figure 2-2: Local Vicinity Map..................................................................................................2-5 Figure 2-3: Site Plan ................................................................................................................2-9 Figure 2-4: Site Plan Phasing.................................................................................................2-11 Figure 2-5: Renderings ..........................................................................................................2-15 Figure 2-6: Landscape Concept Plan .....................................................................................2-17 Figure 2-7: Street Frontage Enlargements .............................................................................2-19 Figure 4.1-1: Photos of the Project Site from Coffee Road....................................................4.1-5 Figure 4.1-2: Photo of the Project Site from Rosedale Highway Viewing Southwest .............4.1-7 Figure 4.1-3: Photo of the Project Site from El Toro Viejo Road Viewing Northeast ..............4.1-9 Appendices
Appendix A: Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Comments Appendix A-1: Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Presentation Appendix A-2: Notice of Preparation Comments
Appendix B: Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, and Energy Technical Study Appendix C: General Biological Assessment
Appendix D: Cultural Resources Assessment
Appendix E: Geotechnical Investigation
Appendix F: Hazards and Hazardous Materials Supporting Information Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 vii
Appendix F-1: Phase I ESA
Appendix F-2: Engineering Review of Plugged and Abandoned Oil and Gas Wellbores Appendix G: Noise and Vibration Technical Study
Appendix H: Transportation Analysis and Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis Appendix H-1: Transportation Analysis
Appendix H-2: Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis
Appendix I: Utilities and Hydrology
Appendix I-1: Water Supply and Demand Analysis
Appendix I-2: Drainage Study
Appendix I-3: Sewer Area Study
Appendix J: Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Appendix K: Tribal Correspondence
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Table of Contents
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 viii
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-9
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
Section 4.1: Aesthetics
AES-1: Would the project have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
AES-2: Would the project substantially damage scenic
resources, including, but not limited to, trees, rock
outcroppings, and historic buildings within a state scenic highway?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
AES-3: Would the project, if in nonurbanized areas,
substantially degrade the existing visual character or quality of public views of the site and its surroundings? (Public views are those that are experienced from publicly accessible vantage point). If the project is in an urbanized area, would the project conflict with applicable zoning and other
regulations governing scenic quality?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
AES-4: Would the project create a new source of substantial light or glare which would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.2: Agriculture and Forestry Resources
AG-1: Would the project convert Prime Farmland, Unique
Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance (Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland
Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California
Resources Agency, to non-agricultural use?
None required No Impact N/A
AG-2: Would the project conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract?
None required No Impact N/A
AG-3: Would the project conflict with existing zoning for, or cause rezoning of, forest land (as defined in Public
Resources Code Section 12220(g)), timberland (as defined by Public Resources Code Section 4526), or timberland
zoned Timberland Production (as defined by Government
Code Section 51104(g))?
None required No Impact N/A
AG-4: Would the project result in the loss of forest land or conversion of forest land to non-forest use?
None required No Impact N/A
AG-5: Would the project Involve other changes in the existing environment which, due to their location or nature, could result in conversion of Farmland, to non-agricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use?
None required No Impact N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-10
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
Section 4.3: Air Quality
AQ-1: Would the project conflict with or obstruct
implementation of the applicable air quality plan?
MM AQ-1: Prior to issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall enter into a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) to mitigate regional air quality impacts associated with emissions of VOC and NOX
generated by operation of the proposed project. At minimum, the VERA shall be crafted and shown to mitigate project-related operation emissions to below the SJVAPCD regional significance thresholds for VOC and NOX. Prior to the
issuance of building permits, the project applicant shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department (City), that verifies, to the City’s satisfaction, completion of the VERA.

MM AQ-2: The project proponent/developer shall use paints and coatings with a VOC content of 25 grams per liter or less for all initial and future exterior coating and recoating of structures including parking lot striping. This reduced VOC content requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate construction documents (e.g., construction management plan) and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Development Services Department.

MM GHG-1
MM GHG-2
MM GHG-3
Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
AQ-2: Would the project result in a cumulatively considerable net increase of any criteria pollutant for which the project region is in non-attainment under an applicable federal or state ambient air quality standard?
MM AQ-1
MM AQ-2
MM GHG-1
MM GHG-2
MM GHG-3
Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
AQ-3: Would the project expose sensitive receptors to
substantial pollutant concentrations?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
AQ-4: Would the project result in other emissions (such as those leading to odors) adversely affecting a substantial number of people?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-11
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
Section 4.4: Biological Resources
BIO-1: Would the project have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or regional plans, policies, or regulations, or by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
MM BIO-1: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Pre-Construction
Surveys. Prior to the commencement of ground-disturbing or vegetation-clearing activities, the project applicant/developer shall retain a qualified biologist to conduct pre-construction surveys for BUOW (Athene cunicularia) in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012).

Depending on the time elapsed between the focused surveys conducted in support of the analysis conducted as a part of the biological resource assessment and the start of
construction, additional focused surveys may be required during the survey season immediately preceding
construction. As specified in the 2012 Staff Report, one 30- day pre-construction survey is recommended; however,
multiple surveys may be necessary prior to construction to determine presence or absence, and burrowing owls may
colonize a site following previous negative survey results.

Therefore, the project site shall be monitored 30 days prior to ground disturbance to detect any occupancy prior to
construction activities.

MM BIO-2: Burrowing Owl (BUOW) Avoidance Buffer. If
western burrowing owls or occupied or unoccupied burrows are detected during pre-construction surveys or at any time during construction, no-disturbance buffers shall be
established by the qualified biologist in accordance with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2012 Staff Report on Burrowing Owl Mitigation (CDFG 2012). Buffer
distances (50 – 500 meters) shall be based on the season (breeding or non-breeding), level of owl activity, and the type and intensity of proposed construction activities. These buffers shall remain in place until the qualified biologist determines that the burrow is no longer occupied, the owls have fledged and are no longer dependent on the burrow, or CDFW-approved passive relocation procedures have been
completed. The qualified biologist shall monitor compliance with the buffer requirements and shall have the authority to Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-12
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
halt work if project activities are causing disturbance to western burrowing owls.

MM BIO-3: Nesting Birds. If ground disturbing and
vegetation clearing activities cannot be avoided during the nesting bird season (February 1 through September 15), a qualified biologist shall conduct a pre-construction nesting bird survey within all areas of breeding and nesting habitat within and adjacent to the Project Site no more than 10 days prior to initiation of Project activities that would remove vegetation or otherwise disturb nesting activity (for instance, mobilization of heavy equipment) of all areas of the Project Site that could be directly or indirectly impacted by
construction activity.

If nesting birds are encountered, the qualified biologist shall establish a baseline for the behavior of any identified nests and shall continuously monitor the nests to detect changes in behavior. Should behavioral changes occur, the Project
proponent shall halt construction work causing that change and consult with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for additional avoidance and minimization measure.

If continuous monitoring of the identified nests by a qualified biologist is not feasible, a qualified biologist shall establish an avoidance buffer zone around the nest, which shall be
determined by the qualified biologist according to species involved. At a minimum, a no-disturbance buffer of 250 feet shall be established around active nests of non-listed bird species and a 500-foot no-disturbance buffer shall be
established around active nests of non-listed raptors. No activities that would adversely affect the nest shall occur within the buffer zone until the qualified biologist has determined the nest is no longer active, breading season is over, or the young are no longer dependent on the nest.

BIO-2: Would the project have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community identified in local or regional plans, policies, regulations or by None required No Impact N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-13
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
the California Department of Fish and Wildlife or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
BIO-3: Would the project have a substantial adverse effect on state or federally protected wetlands (including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc.) through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or other means? None required No Impact N/A
BIO-4: Would the project interfere substantially with the movement of any native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory wildlife corridors, or impede the use of native wildlife nursery sites?
None required No Impact N/A
BIO-5: Would the project conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources, such as a tree preservation policy or ordinance?
MM BIO-1
MM BIO-2
MM BIO-3
Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
BIO-6: Would the project conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community
Conservation Plan, or other approved local, regional, or state habitat conservation plan?
None required No Impact N/A
Section 4.5: Cultural Resources
CUL-1: Would the project cause a substantial adverse
change in the significance of a historical resource pursuant to § 15064.5?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
CUL-2: Would the project cause a substantial adverse
change in the significance of an archaeological resource pursuant to § 15064.5?
MM CUL-1: Inadvertent Discovery of Cultural Resources.

If suspected cultural resources are encountered during
ground disturbance activities, all work within 100 feet of the find shall immediately cease and the area cordoned off until a qualified cultural resource specialist that meets the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards can evaluate the find and make recommendations. If the specialist determines that the discovery represents a potentially
significant cultural resource, additional investigations may be required. If cultural resources are discovered that may have relevance to Native Americans, the specialist or Project Applicant shall provide written notice to the City of Bakersfield, Native American Heritage Commission, and any other
appropriate individuals, agencies, and/or groups as
determined by the specialist in consultation with the City of Bakersfield to receive input regarding treatment and
Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-14
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
disposition of the resource, which may include avoidance, testing, and/or excavation to prevent destruction of the resource and/or to allow documentation of the resource for research potential. All reports, correspondence, and
determinations regarding the discovery shall be submitted to the California Historical Resources Information System’s Southern San Joaquin Valley Information Center at California State University Bakersfield.

CUL-3: Would the project disturb any human remains,
including those interred outside of dedicated cemeteries? MM CUL-2: Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains.

During construction, if human remains are discovered, further ground disturbance shall be prohibited pursuant to California Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5. The specific
protocol, guidelines, and channels of communication outlined by the Native American Heritage Commission, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5, Public
Resources Code 5097.97, and Senate Bill 447 shall be
followed. In the event of the discovery of human remains, at the direction of the county coroner, Health and Safety Code Section 7050.5(c) shall guide Native American consultation.

Unless otherwise required by law, the site of any reburial of Native American human remains or associated grave goods shall not be disclosed and shall not be governed by public disclosure requirements of the California Public Records Act.

The coroner, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r), parties, and Lead Agencies, will be asked to withhold public disclosure information related to such reburial, pursuant to the specific exemption set forth in California Government Code Section 6254 (r).

Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Section 4.6: Energy
ENG-1: Would the project result in potentially significant environmental impact due to wasteful, inefficient, or
unnecessary consumption of energy resources, during
project construction or operation?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
ENG-2: Would the project conflict with or obstruct a state or local plan for renewable energy or energy efficiency?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.7: Geology and Soils
GEO-1: Would the project directly or indirectly cause
potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk of None required Less Than Significant N/A Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-15
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
loss, injury, or death involving rupture of a known earthquake fault, as delineated on the most recent Alquist-Priolo
Earthquake Fault Zoning Map, issued by the State Geologist for the area or based on other substantial evidence of a known fault or strong seismic ground shaking?
GEO-2: Would the project expose people or structures to potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk of loss, injury, or death involving seismic-related ground failure including liquefaction?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
GEO-3: Would the project expose people or structures to potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk of loss, injury, or death involving landslides?
None required No Impact N/A
GEO-4: Would the project result in substantial soil erosion or the loss of topsoil?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
GEO-5: Would the project be located on a geologic unit or soil that is unstable, or that would become unstable as a result of the project, and potentially result in on- or off-site landslide, lateral spreading, subsidence, liquefaction or collapse?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
GEO-6: Would the project be located on expansive soil, as defined in Table 18-1-B of the Uniform Building Code (1994), creating substantial risks to life or property?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
GEO-7: Would the project have soils incapable of adequately supporting the use of septic tanks or alternative wastewater disposal systems where sewers are not available for the disposal of wastewater?
None required No Impact N/A
GEO-8: Would the project directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological resource or site or unique geologic feature?
MM GEO-1: Paleontological Discovery and Monitoring. In
the event paleontological resources, including fossil
discoveries, are encountered during construction of the Project, work shall halt within a 50-foot radius of the find and the City shall be immediately informed of the discovery. A qualified paleontologist shall be retained by the Applicant to evaluate the find before restarting work in the area. A qualified paleontologist is a paleontologist who meets the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP) standards for Qualified
Professional Paleontologist, which is defined as an individual preferably with an M.S. or Ph.D. in paleontology or geology, who is experienced with paleontological procedures and
techniques, who is knowledgeable in the geology of California Potentially
Significant
Less Than
Significant with
Mitigation
Incorporated
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-16
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
(preferably Southern California), and who has worked as a paleontological mitigation Project supervisor for a least one year. The City shall require that all paleontological resources identified on the Project site be assessed and treated in a manner determined by the qualified paleontologist. The
qualified paleontologist shall be empowered to halt or divert ground disturbing activities.

If the discoveries are determined to be significant, full-time paleontological monitoring will be recommended for the
remainder of ground disturbance for the Project.

Paleontological monitoring shall entail the visual inspection of excavated or graded areas and trench sidewalls. In the event that any additional paleontological resources are discovered, the monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert the construction equipment around the find until it is assessed for scientific significance and collected, if warranted. Monitoring efforts can be reduced or eliminated at the discretion of the project paleontologist.

Upon completion of fieldwork, all significant fossils collected shall be prepared in a properly equipped paleontology
laboratory to a point ready for curation. Following laboratory work, all fossil specimens shall be identified to the most specific taxonomic level possible, cataloged, analyzed, and first offered to the Buena Vista Museum then offered to the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County for
permanent curation and storage. At the conclusion of
laboratory work and museum curation, a final Paleontological Monitoring Report (PMR) shall be prepared describing the results of the paleontological mitigation monitoring efforts associated with the Project. The report shall include a summary of the field and laboratory methods, an overview of the project area geology and paleontology, a list of taxa recovered, an analysis of fossils recovered and their scientific significance, and recommendations. A copy of the report shall also be submitted to the Buena Vista Museum in Bakersfield.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-17
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
Section 4.8: Greenhouse Gas Emissions
GHG-1: Would the project generate greenhouse gas
emissions, either directly or indirectly, that may have a significant impact on the environment?
GHG-1: The project proponent/developer shall design and construct the proposed buildings to be all electric, with electricity to be the only permanent source of energy for all nonemergency building energy needs, including but not
limited to water heating; mechanical equipment; and heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) (i.e., space-heating and space cooling). All major appliances (e.g., dishwashers, refrigerators, and water heaters) provided/installed shall be electric-powered EnergyStar certified or an equivalent energy efficiency where applicable. The only exception to this measure shall be limited to commercial cooking uses. Prior to issuance of building permits for development projects, project proponent/developer shall provide plans that show the
aforementioned requirements to the City of Bakersfield
Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify installation of the electric-powered EnergyStar or equivalent appliances.

GHG-2: Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division demonstrating enrollment in a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan, such as the Pacific Gas & Electric’s (PG&E) 100% Solar Choice plan, for proposed project building(s) if such plan is available. If a 100 percent carbon-free electricity plan is not available, the property owner shall enroll in an energy plan with the next highest carbon-free electricity until a 100 percent carbon-free electricity energy plan becomes available. Measures to
achieve 100 percent carbon-free electricity use may include, but are not limited to, plans for 100 percent renewable electricity. If such carbon-free electricity energy plans are waitlisted, the property owner may enroll in an available energy plan in the meantime but shall sign up for the waiting list for and enroll in a carbon-free electricity energy plan when it becomes available.

Potentially
Significant
Significant and
Unavoidable
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-18
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
GHG-3: All landscaping equipment (e.g., leaf blower) used for property management shall be electric-powered only. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the property owner shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase, rental, and/or services agreement) to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify that all landscaping equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

GHG-4: Any off-road equipment (e.g., forklifts) used in daily business operations shall be electric-powered. The project proponent/developer shall disclose this requirement to all tenants/business entities prior to the signing of any lease agreement. In addition, the limitation to use only electric-powered off-road equipment shall be included in all leasing agreements.

Prior to issuance of a Business License for a new
tenant/business entity, the project proponent/developer and tenant/business entity shall provide a signed document
(verification document) to the City of Bakersfield (City) noting that the property owner has disclosed to the tenant/business entity the requirement to use only electric-powered equipment for daily operations. This verification document shall be signed by authorized agents for the project
proponent/developer and tenant/business entities. In addition, if applicable, the tenant/business entity shall provide documentation (e.g., purchase or rental agreement) to the City to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that any off-road equipment utilized will be electric-powered.

GHG-5: The project proponent/developer shall coordinate with Golden Empire Transit and provide improvements (e.g., bus shelter) of up to two bus stops. Prior to issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, the project proponent/developer shall provide documentation to the City of Bakersfield Building Division to verify, to the City’s satisfaction, that coordination with Golden Empire Transit has been initiated.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-19
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
GHG-6: The project proponent/developer shall install an end-of-trip shower facility. This end-of-trip shower facility requirement shall be incorporated into all site plans and appropriate building plans and submitted to the City of Bakersfield Building Division. Prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy, the City of Bakersfield Building Division shall verify the installation of end-of-trip shower facility.

GHG-7: The project proponent/developer shall design the parking areas to comply with the Tier 2 Nonresidential
Voluntary Measures of the California Green Building
Standards Code (CALGreen), Division A5.1, Planning and
Design, Section A5.106.5.3.4. This requirement shall be identified on all prepared building and site plans. The project proponent/developer shall submit these building and site plans that note this requirement to the City of Bakersfield Building Division prior to the issuance of construction permits.

GHG-2: Would the project conflict with an applicable plan, policy or regulation adopted for the purpose of reducing the emissions of greenhouse gases?
MM GHG-5
MM GHG-6
Potentially
Significant
Significant and
Unavoidable
Section 4.9: Hazards and Hazardous Materials
HAZ-1: Would the project create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through the routine transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HAZ-2: Would the project create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through reasonably foreseeable upset and accident conditions involving the release of
hazardous materials into the environment?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HAZ-3: Would the project emit hazardous emissions or
handle hazardous or acutely hazardous materials,
substances, or waste within one-quarter mile of an existing or proposed school
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HAZ-4: Would the project be located on a site which is
included on a list of hazardous materials sites compiled pursuant to Government Code § 65962.5 and, as a result, would it create a significant hazard to the public or the environment?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-20
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
HAZ-5: For a project located within an airport land use plan or, where such a plan has not been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or public use airport, would the project result in a safety hazard or excessive noise for people residing or working in the project area?
None required No Impact N/A
HAZ-6: Would the project impair implementation of or
physically interfere within an adopted emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
None required No Impact N/A
HAZ-7: Would the project expose people or structures, either directly or indirectly, to a significant risk of loss, injury or death involving wildfires?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.10: Hydrology and Water Quality
HWQ-1: Would the project violate any water quality
standards or waste discharge requirements or otherwise
substantially degrade surface or ground water quality?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-2: Would the project substantially decrease
groundwater supplies or interfere substantially with
groundwater recharge such that the project may impede
sustainable groundwater management of the basin?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-3a: Would the project substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river or through the addition of impervious surfaces, in a manner which would result in substantial erosion or siltation on- or off-site? None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-3b: Would the project substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river or through the addition of impervious surfaces, in a manner which would substantially increase the rate or amount of surface runoff in a manner which would result in flooding on- or off-site? None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-3c: Would the project substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river or through the addition of impervious surfaces, in a manner which would create or contribute runoff water which would exceed the capacity of existing or planned stormwater drainage systems or provide substantial additional sources of polluted runoff? None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-3d: Would the project substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through the None required Less Than Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-21
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
alteration of the course of a stream or river or through the addition of impervious surfaces, in a manner which would impede or redirect flood flows?
HWQ-4: Would the project if in flood hazard, tsunami, or seiche zones, risk the release of pollutants due to project inundation?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
HWQ-5: Would the project conflict with or obstruct
implementation of a water quality control plan or sustainable groundwater management plan?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.11: Land Use and Planning
LUP-1: Would the project physically divide an established community?
None required No Impact N/A
LUP-2: Would the project cause a significant environmental impact due to a conflict with any land use plan, policy, or regulation adopted for the purpose of avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.12: Mineral Resources
MIN-1: Would the project result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that would be a value to the region and the residents of the state?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
MIN-2: Would the project result in the loss of availability of a locally important mineral resource recovery site delineated on a local general plan, specific plan or other land use plan? None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.13: Noise
NOI-1: Would the project result in generation of a substantial temporary or permanent increase in ambient noise levels in the vicinity of the project in excess of standards established in the local general plan or noise ordinance, or applicable standards of other agencies?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
NOI-2: Would the project result in generation of excessive ground-borne vibration or ground-borne noise levels? None required Less Than Significant N/A NOI-3: For a project located within the vicinity of a private airstrip or an airport land use plan or, where such a plan has not been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or public use airport, would the project expose people residing or working in the project area to excessive noise levels?
None required No Impact N/A
Section 4.14: Population and Housing
POP-1: Would the project induce substantial unplanned
population growth in an area, either directly (for example, by None required Less Than Significant N/A Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-22
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
proposing new homes and businesses) or indirectly (for
example, through extension of roads or other infrastructure)? POP-2: Would the project displace substantial numbers of existing people or housing, necessitating the construction of replacement housing elsewhere?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.15: Public Services and Recreation
PUB-1: Would the project result in substantial adverse
physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for fire protection?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
PUB-2: Would the project result in substantial adverse
physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for police protection?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
PUB-3: Would the project result in substantial adverse
physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for schools?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
PUB-4: Would the project result in substantial adverse
physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for parks?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
PUB-5: Would the project Result in substantial adverse
physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-23
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times, or other performance objectives for other services?
REC-1: Would the project increase the use of existing
neighborhood and regional parks or other recreational
facilities such that substantial physical deterioration of the facility would occur or be accelerated?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
REC-2: Would the project include recreational facilities or require the construction or expansion of recreational facilities which might have an adverse physical effect on the
environment?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.16: Transportation
TRA-1: Would the project conflict with a program, plan, ordinance or policy addressing the circulation system,
including transit, roadway, bicycle and pedestrian facilities? None required Less Than
Significant N/A
TRA-2: Would the project conflict or be inconsistent with CEQA Guidelines § 15064.3, subdivision (b)?
No feasible mitigation is available. Potentially
Significant
Significant and
Unavoidable
TRA-3: Would the project substantially increase hazards due to a geometric design feature (e.g., sharp curves or
dangerous intersections) or incompatible uses (e.g., farm equipment)?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
TRA-4: Would the project result in inadequate emergency access?
No mitigation required.

TRAF-PDF-1: Construction Traffic Management Plan.

The contractor would develop a detailed Construction Traffic Management Plan as part of the Project, including provision of construction worker parking in designated areas, temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public rights-of-way, street closure information, detour plans, haul routes, and staging plans among other provisions. The contractor would submit the Construction Traffic Management Plan to the City of Bakersfield for approval. The Construction Management Plan would include the following:
• Scheduling workdays to begin and end prior to the morning and afternoon peak hours, respectively, to the extent
feasible so as to avoid worker trips during those peak
hours.
• Coordination with various City departments and offices to ensure adequate access to the Project Site and land uses in proximity of the Project Site is maintained.

Less Than
Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-24
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
• Scheduling pick-ups, deliveries, and exports of construction materials so as to occur during off-peak hours. Hauling shall be from 9:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M. weekdays, and 8:00 A.M. to 4:00 P.M. on Saturdays. No hauling shall be
performed on Sundays and holidays.
• Reduce the potential of trucks waiting for extended periods to load or unload.
• Provision of worker parking on-site or in designated off-site private parking areas and prohibition of construction-related vehicle parking on surrounding streets, other than the streets adjacent to the Project Site.
• Temporary traffic controls during all construction activities adjacent to public ROWs to improve traffic flow on public roadways (e.g., flag personnel) and to maintain access for land uses in the vicinity of the Project Site. Determine the number and location of flag personnel required during
traffic rerouting and deliveries.
• Contractor to post advance bilingual notification to adjacent property owners and occupants of upcoming construction
activities, including durations and daily hours of operation, at several locations on the Project Site.
• Establish requirements for storage of materials and
loading/unloading on the Project Site.
• Worksite traffic control plans approved by the City would be implemented to route vehicles, bicyclist and pedestrians around the area during any parking, travel lane or sidewalk closures and provide for protective measures for the public. • Identification of a construction manager and provision of a telephone number for any inquiries or complaints from
residents regarding construction activities. The telephone number shall be posted at the site readily visible to any interested party during site preparation, grading, and
construction.

Section 4.17: Tribal Cultural Resources
TCR-1: Would the project cause a substantial adverse
change in the significance of a tribal cultural resource, defined in Public Resources Code § 21074 as either a site, feature, place, cultural landscape that is geographically defined in terms of the size and scope of the landscape, MM CUL-1
MM CUL-2
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-25
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
sacred place, or object with cultural value to a California Native American tribe, and that is listed or eligible for listing in the California Register of Historical Resources, or in a local register of historical resources as defined in Public
Resources Code section 5020.1(k)?
TCR-2: Would the project cause a substantial adverse
change in the significance of a tribal cultural resource, defined in Public Resources Code § 21074 as either a site, feature, place, cultural landscape that is geographically defined in terms of the size and scope of the landscape, sacred place, or object with cultural value to a California Native American tribe, and that is a resource determined by the lead agency, in its discretion and supported by
substantial evidence, to be significant pursuant to criteria set forth in subdivision (c) of Public Resources Code § 5024.1.

In applying the criteria set forth in subdivision (c) of Public Resource Code § 5024.1, the lead agency shall consider the significance of the resource to a California Native American tribe?
Section 4.18: Utilities and Service Systems
UTI-1: Would the project require or result in the relocation or construction of new or expanded water, wastewater
treatment, or stormwater drainage, electric power, natural gas, or telecommunications facilities, the construction or relocation of which could cause significant environmental effects?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
UTI-2: Would the project have sufficient water supplies available to serve the project and reasonably foreseeable future development during normal, dry and multiple dry
years?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
UTI-3: Would the project result in a determination by the wastewater treatment provider which services of may serve the project that is has adequate capacity to serve the
project’s projected demand in addition to the provider’s existing commitment?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
UTI-4: Would the project generate solid waste in excess of State and local standards, or in excess of the capacity of local infrastructure?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report Executive Summary
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 ES-26
Table ES-1: Summary of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Threshold Project Design Features and Mitigation Measures Level of Significance
Level of
Significance
After Mitigation
UTI-5: Would the project comply with federal, state, and local management and reduction statutes and regulations related to solid waste?
None required Less Than
Significant N/A
Section 4.19: Wildfire
WF-1: Would the project substantially impair an adopted emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
None required No Impact N/A
WF-2: Would the project due to slope, prevailing winds, and other factors, exacerbate wildfire risks, and thereby expose project occupants to pollutant concentrations from a wildfire or the uncontrolled spread of a wildfire?
None required No Impact N/A
WF-3: Would the project require the installation or
maintenance of associated infrastructure (such as roads, fuel breaks, emergency water sources, power lines or other
utilities) that may exacerbate fire risk or that may result in temporary or ongoing impacts to the environment?
None required No Impact N/A
WF-4: Would the project expose people or structures to
significant risks, including downslope or downstream flooding or landslides, as a result of runoff, post-fire slope instability, or drainage changes?
None required No Impact N/A
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 1-1

1. Introduction

1.1 Overview of the Proposed Project
The Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project) will involve the construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space, located on an approximately 46.16- acre parcel (Project Site) in the City of Bakersfield (City), California. The Project Site is situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway, north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road.

The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps. Other Project components include vehicular access and circulation improvements (both on- and off-site); surface parking areas and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; various landscape, hardscape, and lighting improvements; green space/park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility improvements. A detailed project description is provided in Section 2, Project Description.

1.2 Purpose of the Environmental Impact Report (EIR)
The proposed Project is subject to the discretionary approval of the City of Bakersfield. In accordance with Sections 15050 and 15367 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, the City has prepared this draft environmental impact report (EIR) to evaluate the potential environmental impacts of the Project. Under Section 21067 of CEQA, the City is responsible for processing and approving the proposed Project. Accordingly, the City will consider the information in this EIR, along with other information that may be presented during the CEQA process. The EIR will also be used in connection with other permits and approvals necessary for the construction and operation of the Project.

In accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15121, this Draft EIR is an information document that will inform public agency decision-makers and the public generally of the environmental effects associated with the Project, and ways to minimize any significant environmental impacts through mitigation measures or reasonable alternatives to the Project. Should the EIR find that significant environmental impacts cannot be mitigated to a level considered less than significant, impacts are considered significant and unavoidable.

1.3 Environmental Review Process
In compliance with the CEQA Guidelines, the City has taken steps to provide opportunities for participation in the environmental review process. This includes undertaking a formal scoping process. The following sections describe the scoping process in greater detail.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 1 Introduction
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 1-2

1.4 Scoping Process
As part of the preparation of the Draft EIR, an effort was made to contact State, regional, and local government agencies and interested parties to solicit comments and inform the public of the Project. This included the distribution of a Notice of Preparation (NOP) and a public scoping meeting.

1.4.1 Notice of Preparation
Pursuant to Section 15082 of the CEQA Guidelines, the City circulated an NOP of the Draft EIR to State, regional, and local agencies, and members of the public for a 32-day public review period. The public review period began Friday, October 31, 2025, and concluded Monday, December 1, 2025. The purpose of the NOP was to formally notice that the City was preparing a Draft EIR for the Project, and to solicit input regarding the scope and content of the environmental information to be included in the Draft EIR. Four written comment letters were received during the scoping period. A copy of the NOP and the written comment letters received by the City is provided in Appendix A, Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Public Comments, of this Draft EIR.

1.4.2 Scoping Meeting
The City also held an EIR Scoping Meeting for the Project on Thursday, November 20, 2025. The purpose of the EIR Scoping Meeting was for the City to solicit input and written comments from agencies and the public on environmental issues or alternatives they believe should be addressed in the Draft EIR. A presentation explaining the Project was provided and potential attendees were given an opportunity to provide their comments on the scope of the Draft EIR. No members of the public attended the EIR Scoping Meeting, and no comments were received at the meeting. The presentation from the EIR Scoping Meeting is provided in Appendix A, Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Public Comments.

1.5 Organization of the Draft EIR
Executive Summary. The Executive Summary provides an overview of the Draft EIR. It briefly describes the proposed Project (location and key Project features), the CEQA environmental review process, a summary of the Project impacts, a summary of the Project alternatives, and applicable mitigation measures.

Chapter 1. Introduction. This chapter provides a summary of the proposed Project, discusses the purpose of the EIR, including CEQA compliance requirements, and steps undertaken in the CEQA process, including the scoping process.

Chapter 2. Project Description. This chapter describes the proposed Project, including the Project location, surrounding land uses, existing conditions, Project objectives, Project use options, and the intended uses of the EIR.

Chapter 3. Environmental Setting. This chapter presents an overview of the Project’s environmental setting, including the regional setting, project site setting, and past, present, and probable future projects considered in the analysis of potential Project contributions to cumulative impacts.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 1 Introduction
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 1-3
Chapter 4. Environmental Impact Analysis. This chapter describes the potential environmental effects of the proposed Project. The discussion is focused on potential impacts to 19 environmental resource topics. This includes discussion of the regulatory and environmental settings, methodology employed in the analysis, the thresholds of significance used to determine impacts, level of impact, mitigation measures, if warranted, and level of significance of the impact after mitigation. The Draft EIR addresses potential impacts to these environmental issues:
• Aesthetics
• Agriculture and Forestry Resources
• Air Quality
• Biological Resources
• Cultural Resources
• Energy
• Geology and Soils
• Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• Hazards and Hazardous Materials
• Hydrology and Water Quality
• Land Use and Planning
• Mineral Resources
• Noise
• Population and Housing
• Public Services and Recreation
• Transportation
• Tribal Cultural Resources
• Utilities and Service Systems
• Wildfire
Chapter 5. Alternatives. This chapter describes a reasonable range of alternatives to the proposed Project. These alternatives include Alternative 1: No Project Alternative Project, Alternative 2: Reduced Project Alternative, and Alternative 3: Existing General Plan/Zoning Alternative. Chapter 5 presents an analysis of the environmental effects of the alternatives for each issue area, though not to the same level of detail as analyzed for the proposed Project.

Chapter 6. Other CEQA Considerations. This chapter includes a discussion of other issues required by CEQA that are not discussed in other sections of the Draft EIR.

Chapter 7. Acronyms and Abbreviations. This chapter includes a list of the acronyms and abbreviations used throughout the Draft EIR.

Chapter 8. References. This chapter includes bibliography of resources used in preparation of the Draft EIR.

Chapter 9. List of Preparers. This chapter lists the persons responsible for preparation of the Draft EIR.

Appendices
The Environmental Analyses in this Draft EIR are supported by the following appendices:

Appendix A: Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Comments Appendix A-1: Notice of Preparation and Notice of Preparation Presentation Appendix A-2: Notice of Preparation Comments
Appendix B: Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, and Energy Technical Study Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 1 Introduction
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 1-4
Appendix C: General Biological Assessment
Appendix D: Cultural Resources Assessment
Appendix E: Geotechnical Investigation
Appendix F: Hazards and Hazardous Materials Supporting Information Appendix F-1: Phase I ESA
Appendix F-2: Engineering Review of Plugged and Abandoned Oil and Gas Wellbores
Appendix G: Noise and Vibration Technical Study
Appendix H: Transportation Analysis and Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis Appendix H-1: Transportation Analysis
Appendix H-2: Vehicle Miles Traveled Analysis
Appendix I: Utilities and Hydrology
Appendix I-1: Water Supply and Demand Analysis
Appendix I-2: Drainage Study
Appendix I-3: Sewer Area Study
Appendix J: Urban Decay Analysis Technical Memorandum
Appendix K: Tribal Correspondence
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-1

2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION

2.1 Environmental Setting

2.1.1 Project Location
The Project Site is located the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield (Figure 2-1, Regional Location Map). The Project Site is 46.16 acres and consists of one legal parcel (APN 368-010-05), which is an undeveloped L-shaped property situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway, north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road.

2.1.2 Existing Conditions
Figure 2-2, Local Vicinity Map, provides an aerial photograph of the Project Site. Nearby uses include Rosedale Highway and a commercial retail center (Northwest Promenade), to the north; a Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) electric substation and vacant land to the south; El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a PG&E electric substation to the west; and Coffee Road, Friant-Kern Canal, and a commercial retail center to the east.

The Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six-foot-tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells, electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles, and several dirt roads and mounds.

The Golden Empire Transit (GET) District is the main transit agency servicing the City of Bakersfield. Currently, GET operates buses on the following three (3) routes within the vicinity of the Project: Route 61, Route 82, and Route 84. Nearby pedestrian facilities include sidewalks along both sides of Rosedale Highway, both sides of Coffee Road north of Jet Way, and the west side of Coffee Road south of Jet Way. Pedestrian crosswalks are provided at signalized intersections along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road. Existing Class II Bike Lanes are provided in both directions along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-2
This page intentionally left blank.

Source: Google Maps, 2024
FIGURE 1: Regional Map

RIVERVIEW MARKET PROJECT
N.T.S
Califor California State nia State
University, Bakersfield
Kern River
Bakersfield
Municipal Airport
Project Site
Rosedale Hwy
SOURCE: Google Maps, 2024
FIGURE 2-1: Regional Location Map
RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT N.T.S.

Shafter
Smith Corner
99 178

RIO BRAVO
Rio Bravo 178
99 Tarina Calders Corner:

Hillcrest
18 East Niles
W 1
SUNSET
58 58
Kayandee 58 Edison
SEVEN OAKS 184:

Stevens VENOLA
CAMPUS PARK Rexland Acres Fuller Acres
58 43
119
Lamont
Di Giorgio El Adobe
Alameda Weedpatch Lakeside
Kimley»Horn
Pumpkin
Center

MYRICKS
CORNER
Bakersfield

OLEANDER/
East
Bakersfield
Edmundson
Acres
T _
(204

CITY IN

THE HILLS
Rosedale

GREENACRES
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-4
This page intentionally left blank.

FIGURE 2: Aerial Map

RIVERVIEW MARKET PROJECT
N.T.S
Source: Google Earth Pro, 2024
Project Site RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL COMMERCIAL
COMMERCIAL The Promenade

COMMERCIAL

INDUSTRIAL
Coffee Rd
Coffee Rd
Patton Wy
Rosedale Hwy Rosedale Hwy
Langley Rd
Ribston Ave
Wolf River Ave
Bolero Ave
Pink Lady Wy
Mcintosh
Wy
Cirspin St
Granite Falls Dr
Downing Ave
Clay PAtrick Farr Wy El Toro Viejo Rd
SOURCE: Google Earth Pro, 2024
FIGURE 2-2: Local Vicinity Map
RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT N.T.S.

AY T 7— ou ' - T— —-
— 8 TOPA —
)
I "F“s, lo • /sii u A 1 '■ -i ‘egg
- t ; 4. as
(112 hr f 55 -

8. 2. 3wd R) Ti $ N " E “ • $m Oetm —1 B
5 117 aee. 4
V het* J d‘ f oe Enou.u 5 —= ' 4 n h A | % k-j taine hmt T,, — 1 C
4 res | 7 7m TTs f. • • i.... E rsten - Si D5a I’mns ky 2 f k wuat .SUH 1
J
1 ws "3" J Ereel 1 242 U M k. Ei -t 1 1
-
"tE
!
DIE. - ■ (
4 d an7:
t “us
“me
4 8. a wens S i
3w 1.9
( 452 ; 7 *
t
bii J 3 ’
I 7
E" % 98 n /
Th -
f • wit* 5 3 “1
LEs an4r21
* 2—
thee e.r "a g. I i -
l.. me -fe $ T,
sat 44 r L s
olnts t HreFt
MI allhla’s r
-
1 y t edg / hal 1 -*4,
" I e d. = / aesont it =
1 io “no t — 4 $
1 i
fit t
ft mn- 11- t a E res || - - L e
-
- - __La__ I 2 a. £ IO,
_ laf 4
_ n
KimleyHorn
(hire ms’", 4
Inas *
A-ABr,
g’l
"5
fE
5* V
_
।
।
. s va ,
312
1 5===
[I
cel in"
v he 62
I--- n» r F
t"Lhs
.7
3240 aasi
Lae
B 4 *-n5*3 lem
s w “eeee meant
2lsae 13/0391 ■I l; no Tin . IXj
tst 3
fl oy.
ooregi 1” I ha
1 T a
6 tin Fat -7
r-us -5
r.
eki
s.A
fa A as
Thy, -• L mgs
—*.2
V
>
(ape 2 ' w 00hmd
r
-0 If ats
Aot t "ice
prryopes so
Gw-222d
fp
ot
12 lj
IM
BAilir
‘shertyn ’ ET
-- teL “h wil —
4 : $
—
wr..."
■1
fa
g “hhr-.
/ —Ure piling
l Sgi(ss
Th A : W
"hed,l .
7 mit ri
536s tali R‘"4h4 J CTPN
u®
5g tx
—
|'
V
TW"PHP
Ss
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-6
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-7

2.1.3 General Plan and Zoning
The planning and regulatory plans that govern development and use of the Project Site are the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (updated January 20, 2016, per Resolutions No. 018-16 and 019-16) and the Bakersfield Municipal Code – Title 17 (Zoning Ordinance). The General Plan land use designation of the Project Site is P (Public Facilities). The Project Site is zoned M-2 (General Manufacturing). The Project applicant is seeking an amendment to the City’s General Plan, changing the Project Site’s designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial), to facilitate the Project Site’s proposed use and create alignment with the Project Site’s M-2 zoning designation, which under the City’s stacked zoning code allows, by right, all uses are permitted under the commercial designations. Therefore, to proceed with the Project and its proposed uses and to provide consistency with the Project site’s M-2 zoning designation, the LI designation has been determined to be the appropriate land use designation.

2.2 Description of Project

2.2.1 Project Overview
The Project involves construction and operation of the Riverview Marketplace, a commercial retail center that would encompass 405,531 square feet of total building space, as shown in Table 2-1, Proposed Uses.

The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

Table 2-1: Proposed Uses
Project Site Uses Square Feet/Unit
Retail (single and multi-tenant) 268,082
Restaurant (sit down and fast casual) 31,796
Restaurants (drive-thru) 16,495
Car Wash 4,100
Health Club 24,993
Medical Office 8,996
Bank 9,120
Public Storage 40,000
Gas Filling Station 20 dual-sided fuel pumps
Electrical and fire riser rooms 1,949
TOTAL 405,531 SF
New Landscaping Provided 325,120
sf = square feet
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-8
These uses are permitted uses pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 17.30 (M-2 General Manufacturing Zone), Section 17.30.020 (Permitted Uses) of the Bakersfield Zoning Ordinance.

Figure 2-3, Conceptual Site Plan illustrates the layout and location of uses for the Project.

Other Project components, which are described in more detail below, include vehicular access and circulation improvements (both on- and off-site); surface parking areas and drive aisles; pedestrian access and circulation improvements; various landscape, hardscape, and lighting improvements; green space/park improvements; site and tenant signage; and infrastructure and utility improvements. Project development is anticipated to be completed in two development phases, as illustrated in Figure 2-4, Site Plan Phasing.

N.T.S.

FIGURE 2-3: Conceptual Site Plan

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
T
T
T T T
T
T
S
S S
S
S

S S S S
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
V
141'-0"
33'-6"
19 CAR VACUUM STALLS

PROPOSED LEFT

TURN POCKET

EXISTING TRAFFIC
SIGNAL
20 18

PROPOSED

TRAFFIC SIGNAL
19 20

PARKING

SURPLUS A
31 11
14 TWR
TWR
TWR
TS
8 cw
5 6
27 23
16 19
92'-4"
1 12
10 2
C2 C1 C3
C4
A1
D1
C7
C9
C8

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE
10'-0"

SETBACK

PROPERTY LINE

PG&E SETBACK

PROPERTY LINE
10'-0"

SETBACK

EXISTING TRAFFIC
SIGNAL
G1
22 A2
18 18
6 8
23 23
23 23
15 39
42 ROSEDALE HIGHWAY

OPEN GREEN SPACE
10' SETBACK
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH

PG&E SETBACK

SETBACK
PG&E
25'-0"
49'-0"
30'-0" 22'-0" 25'-0" TYP.
25'-0"
25'-0"
55'-11"
30'-0"
25'-0"
124'-3"
26'-10"
245'-2"
30'-0"
30'-0"
30'-0" 25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP. 31'-0"
44'-1"
38'-6"
35'-5"
30'-0"
213'-0" 45'-0"
4 YD 4 YD
PAD 3

DT RESTAURANT
760 SF

NON-SPRINKLERED
PAD 4

DT RESTAURANT
4,277 SF

NON-SPRINKLERED
PAD 5

DT/FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANT
6,698 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 8
RETAIL
4,694 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 9
REST.
7,967 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 10

DT/FAST
CASUAL REST./
RETAIL
10,110 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 11
DT REST/RETAIL.
11,719 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 12
MED. OFFICE
9,129 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 13

RESTAURANT
6,533 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 14

REST/RETAIL
7,135 SF

SPRINKLERED
4 YD 4 YD
19 18
cw
14 PLAZA
10 176'-0"
61'-11"
25'-0"
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
14 141'-4"
238'-0"
SHOPS 2

RETAIL/FAST
CASUAL REST.
10,858 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR B
MARKET
34,971 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR A

HEALTH CLUB
24,993 SF

SPRINKLERED

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,740 S.F.
25'-0"
30'-0" 30'-0"
26 12
26 1
25'-0"
45'-0"
30'-0"
C5
C8

DRIVER CARTS

PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP

CARTS CARTS

CARTS CARTS
18 43
7 18
18 23
45 24 8
35'-11"

COFFEE ROAD
30'-0"
60'-0"
167'-8"
44'-6" 96'-2"
36'-0" 25'-0"
30'-0"
9 9
25'-0"
12 6
C5 C6
22 25'-0"
25'-0"
TYP.
10 5 10 10 54'-0"

SUITE A
RETAIL
±3,028 S.F. 4 YD 4 YD65'-11"
138'-6"
6 13
23 1
7 7
3 7 7
13 7
12 8 14
1 1 2
7 20
21 11
24 18

PG&E SETBACK
PAD 6

DT RESTAURANT
2,578 SF
NON-SPRINKLERED 34'-6"
13 5
12 C5 4 YD 4 YD STORAGE BLDG (±500 UNITS) ±40,000 SF SPRINKLERED

FUEL CANOPY
20 DUAL SIDED

DISPENSERS
PAD 2

CAR WASH
4,100 SF
PAD 1

DT /FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANT
8,224 SF

SPRINKLERED
12 3
15 19
30'-0"
DT.

REST
±1,720 S.F.
127'-9"
64'-0"
18'-0"
10'-0"
18'-0"
14 4
30'-0"
4 15'-5" 30'-0"
25'-0" 18'-0"
25 14
25'-0"
1 1
1 SUITE A
RETAIL
±2,482 S.F.

SUITE B
RETAIL
±2,496 S.F.

RETAIL
±3,498 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,646 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,659 S.F.

SUITE B
REST.
±1,844 S.F.

SUITE C
RETAIL
±1,520 S.F.

SUITE D
REST.
±1,794 S.F.

SUITE A
RETAIL
±3,042 S.F.

SUITE D
FAST CASUAL REST.
±1,762 S.F.

SUITE B
RETAIL
±2,023 S.F.

SUITE C
RETAIL
±2,081 S.F.

SUITE E
RETAIL
±1,950 S.F. 4 YD 4 YD 7'-6"
7 14
10 1
16 9
30'-0"
12'-0" 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
5 6
8 8'-0"4 YD 4 YD
4 YD 4 YD
7 10 10
55'-0"
12'-0"
124'-3"
7 10 10
PATIO
TRASH
STOP
STOP LANE 1 LANE 2

DO NOT ENTER
5 9
5 25'-0"
25'-0"
250 SF
25'-0"
510 SF

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,500 S.F.

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,296 S.F.

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
±4,226 S.F.

SHOPS 1
RETAIL
4,979 SF

SPRINKLERED
R10'-0" R20'-0"
27 12
5 REST
±2,400 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,400 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,201 S.F.
16 7
80'-0"
73'-11"
60'-0"
118'-11" PATIO
6 25'-0"
25'-0"
25'-0"
PAD 7
RETAIL
4,694 SF

SPRINKLERED
86'-11" 86'-11"
142'-0"
16 7
13 11
40'-0" 20'-0"
24'-0"
TYP.
9'-0"
18'-0"
8'-0"
8'-11"
30'-0"
Ø110'-0"
30'-0"
36'-0"
25'-0"
TYP.
14 7
5 10
4 12
6 7
23 6
9 62'-0"

ON-GRADE LOADING
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
8'-0"
PATIO
7'-6" 12'-0"

MENU BOARD
1 1
16'-0"
20'-0"
61'-0"
66'-4"
61'-0"
26'-0"
27'-0"
29'-10" 100'-0"
100'-0"
100'-0"
208'-0"

MAJOR C
10,000 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR D
RETAIL
10,000 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR I
RETAIL
25,013 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR G
RETAIL
15,562 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR H
RETAIL
19,221SF

SPRINKLERED
100'-0"

MAJOR E
RETAIL
25,047 SF

SPRINKLERED
234'-0"
187'-4"
110'-0" 116'-8" 100'-0" 110'-6"
136'-8"
156'-0"

MAJOR J
14,176 SF

SPRINKLERED
201'-4"
102'-0"

MAJOR F
RETAIL
18,012 SF

SPRINKLERED
100'-0"
196'-0"
176'-0"
253'-4"
134'-8"
16'-0" 30'-0"
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
4 YD
4 YD 4 YD
18 18
11 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
48'-10"
12'-0"
12'-0"
2 CONTROLLER
OFFICE
308 SF

CONTROLLER
/STORAGE
120 SF
76'-11"
92'-4"
14 PLAZA
14 SHOPS 2

RETAIL/FAST
CASUAL REST.
10,858 SF
30'-0" 30'-0"

SUITE A
RETAIL
±3,042 S.F.

SUITE D
FAST CASUAL REST.
±1,762 S.F.

SUITE B
RETAIL
±2,023 S.F.

SUITE C
RETAIL
±2,081 S.F.

SUITE E
RETAIL
±1,950 S.F.
7 5
10 16'-0"
20'-0"
61'-0"
66'-4"
61'-0"
100'-0" 100'-0"

MAJOR I
RETAIL
25,013 SF
100'-0"

MAJOR E
RETAIL
25,047 SF
234'-0"
213'-4"
110'-0" 116'-8" 100'-0"
110'-0"
168'-3"
156'-0"

MAJOR J
14,176 SF
201'-4"
102'-0"
100'-0"
196'-0"
176'-0"
253'-3"
132'-8"
16'-0"
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
4 YD
4 YD
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
48'-10"
30'-0"
30'-0"
30'-0"
222'-0"
ON-GRADE LOADING 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD

GROCERY TENANT AREA LIMIT

GROCERY TENANT AREA LIMIT

MAJOR C
10,000 SF

MAJOR D
RETAIL
10,000 SF

MAJOR G
RETAIL
15,562 SF

MAJOR H
RETAIL
19,221SF

MAJOR F
RETAIL
18,012 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
11,927 SF
TOTAL AREA:
21,927 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
12,927 SF
TOTAL AREA:
22,927 SF
TOTAL AREA:
25,329 SF
TOTAL AREA:
26,326 SF
TOTAL AREA:
23,927 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
7,317 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
10,764 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
4,706 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
10,260 SF
TOTAL AREA:
24,436 SF
30'-0"
FUTURE

EXPANSION
2,908 SF
FUTURE

EXPANSION
2,816 SF
30'-0" 4 YD 4 YD

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
2,861 S.F.

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
2,687 S.F.
6 8

PRELIMINARY

RETENTION BASIN
3 5
1 4
4 4 7
6 50
16 21'-3"
68'-0" 30'-0" 15' LANDSCAPE SETBACK
25'-0" 12'-0"
22'-0" 34'-0"
14'-11"
34'-0" 34'-0" 34'-0" 20'-0"
30'-0" 30'-0"
30'-0"
50 50
21 5
30'-0" 36'-0" 25'-0" 36'-0" 25'-0" 36'-0" 30'-0"
25'-0"
30'-0"
30'-0"
186'-9"
63'-0"
KEEP
CLEAR
8'-0" 51'-0"
21'-0"
5 25'-0"
9'-5"
16 10
25'-0" 25'-0"
15'-0"
15'-0"
25'-0" 4 YD 4 YD 12'-0"
15' LANDSCAPE SETBACK
24'-0"
12'-0" 18'-0"
25'-0" 41'-5"
25'-0"
12'-0" 12'-0"
N
0 SITE PLAN
SP-31
Scale : 1" = 80'
40' 80' 160'
N

LOCATION PLAN
NOTE: This information is conceptual in nature and is subject to adjustments pending further verification and Client, Tenant, and Governmental Agency approvals. No warranties or guaranties of any kind are given or implied by the Architect.

DATE:

MCG JOB #:

DATE REVISIONS

SWC ROSEDALE AND COFFEE

24.457.01 BAKERSFIELD, CA
C MCG ARCHITECTURE 2025 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

AREA RESERVED FOR

CITY STAMP
A-1.0
GENERAL NOTES:
- Buildings or structures shall require installation of an automatic fire sprinkler system where required by current California Building Code and City ordinance.
- The developer shall include fire resistive wall construction details with the final building plans for all exterior walls of any building that is within the distance as set forth in Table 602 of the California Building Code. - Prior to issuing a building permit, the Building Division will calculate and collect the appropriate school district impact fees.
- Prior to granting occupancy, the Building Division will verify that a water meter serving the development is in place. The developer shall contact the applicable water purveyor to inquire about their process for obtaining water service for the development as soon as possible (for water purveyor agency information contact: 1000 Buena Vista Road; 661-326-3715). - All fire lanes. Any modifications shall be approved by the Fire Department.

Fire lane identification signs shall be installed every 100 feet with red curbing when curbing is required. All work shall be completed before occupancy of any building or portion of any building is allowed. b. All fire hydrants, both offsite (nearest to site) and on-site. Include flow data on all hydrants.

Hydrants shall be in good working condition and are subject to testing for verification. Fire flow requirements must be met prior to construction commencing on the project site. Please provide two (2) sets of the water plans stamped by a licensed Registered Civil Engineer to the Fire Department and two (2) sets to the Water Resources Department (1000 Buena Vista Road, Bakersfield, CA. 93311; 661-326-3715). (Note: Show: 1) distance to the nearest hydrant; and 2) distance from that hydrant to the farthest point of the project site.) c. All fire sprinkler and/or stand pipe systems, fire alarms and commercial hood systems. These suppression systems require review and permits by the Fire Department. The Fire Department will issue guidelines for these various items as they may apply to this project. d. Project address, including suite number if applicable. If the project is within a shopping or business center, note the name and address of the center. e.

Name and phone number of the appropriate contact person.

N.T.S.

07.01.2025 A-1.0

FUTURE EXPANSION
SOURCE: McG Architecture, 2025
=
—I
atte) —
Iy
= A
t
X G
J I’ll III11II II..'111I II II Tim ♦
P IIIIT —
—n I in m IIIIIE =
55 E.......... ftiiiiiiiiiiliriiiiiaiiii TOTTI
_ EullulIId*
j
/ mlTt=Tf ===== T
I HHHHHHH5 smzr (HHHHHHH. 101a
|
IUMID All
-taidd oiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii: 10CHlIIIIITUepag
we 1 L sotmme __C___ * $p 1
i s 8
IE LL [
Equuo
-* 111111. ‘: 1—6 74 i
I
1111111111 la I
I
1 try H
i
।
7 I —CHE
yC i U.Oi [ HTHTH )G C T
1 /OH ,1
JC.THHTT
1 - — iiiiiiiiiiii iinyiiiiiO tL
iiiiiiimiii
1 J11 HR 11111 u QLL Le
Kimley»Horn
(
■■ I
I
I
777
//
i
i
i
i
|
i
—J
HHHHH WJ.TTTITTITTIT
1 S

IIIELIIIIIIIE
ZHuE
i
i
i ;
4 I
I
I
I
S
——
L
—
/
i.L.
|
11 *
iL
(Te
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-10
This page intentionally left blank.

N.T.S.

FIGURE 2-4: Site Plan Phasing
RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT 4 YD 4 YD
V
141'-0"
33'-6"
19 CAR VACUUM STALLS

PROPOSED LEFT

TURN POCKET

EXISTING TRAFFIC
SIGNAL
20 18

PROPOSED

TRAFFIC SIGNAL
19 20

PARKING

SURPLUS A
31 11
14 TWR
TWR
TWR
TS
8 cw
5 6
27 23
16 19
61'-0"
1 12
11 2
C2 C1 C3
C4
A1
D1
C7
C9
C8

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH
10' WIDE
10'-0"

SETBACK

PROPERTY LINE

PG&E SETBACK

PROPERTY LINE
10'-0"

SETBACK

EXISTING TRAFFIC
SIGNAL
G1
22 A2
18 18
6 8
23 23
23 23
15 39
42 ROSEDALE HIGHWAY

OPEN GREEN SPACE
10' SETBACK
10' WIDE

MULTI-USE PATH

PG&E SETBACK

SETBACK
PG&E
25'-0"
49'-0"
30'-0" 22'-0" 25'-0" TYP.
25'-0"
25'-0"
55'-11"
30'-0"
25'-0"
124'-3"
26'-10"
245'-2"
30'-0"
30'-0"
30'-0" 25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP.
25'-0"
TYP. 31'-0"
44'-1"
38'-6"
35'-5"
30'-0"
213'-0" 45'-0"
4 YD 4 YD
PAD 3

DT RESTAURANT
760 SF

NON-SPRINKLERED
PAD 4

DT RESTAURANT
4,277 SF

NON-SPRINKLERED
PAD 5

DT/FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANT
6,698 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 8
RETAIL
4,694 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 9
REST.
7,967 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 10

DT/FAST
CASUAL REST./
RETAIL
10,110 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 11
DT REST/RETAIL.
11,719 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 12
MED. OFFICE
9,129 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 13

RESTAURANT
6,533 SF

SPRINKLERED
PAD 14

REST/RETAIL
7,135 SF

SPRINKLERED
4 YD
4 YD
19 18
cw
14 PLAZA
11 176'-0"
61'-11"
25'-0"
4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
14 141'-4"
238'-0"
SHOPS 2

RETAIL/FAST
CASUAL REST.
10,858 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR B
MARKET
35,098 SF

SPRINKLERED

MAJOR A

HEALTH CLUB
24,993 SF

SPRINKLERED

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,740 S.F.
25'-0"
30'-0" 30'-0"
26 12
26 1
25'-0"
45'-0"
30'-0"
C5
C8

DRIVER CARTS

PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP PICK-UP

CARTS CARTS
CARTS
18 43
7 18
18 23
46 25 8
35'-11"

COFFEE ROAD
30'-0"
60'-0"
167'-8"
44'-6" 96'-2"
36'-0" 25'-0"
30'-0"
9 9
25'-0"
12 6
C5 C6
22 25'-0"
25'-0"
TYP.
10 5 10 10 54'-0"

SUITE A
RETAIL
±3,028 S.F. 4 YD 4 YD65'-11"
138'-6"
6 13
23 1
7 7
3 7 7
13 7
12 8 14
1 1 2
7 21
21 12
23 18

PG&E SETBACK
PAD 6

DT RESTAURANT
2,578 SF
NON-SPRINKLERED 34'-6"
13 5
12 C5 4 YD 4 YD STORAGE BLDG (±500 UNITS) ±40,000 SF SPRINKLERED

FUEL CANOPY
20 DUAL SIDED

DISPENSERS
PAD 2

CAR WASH
4,100 SF
PAD 1

DT /FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANT
8,224 SF

SPRINKLERED
12 3
15 19
30'-0"
DT.

REST
±1,720 S.F.
127'-9"
64'-0"
18'-0"
10'-0"
18'-0"
14 4
30'-0"
4 15'-5" 30'-0"
25'-0" 18'-0"
25 14
25'-0"
1 1
1 SUITE A
RETAIL
±2,482 S.F.

SUITE B
RETAIL
±2,496 S.F.

RETAIL
±3,498 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,646 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,659 S.F.

SUITE B
REST.
±1,844 S.F.

SUITE C
RETAIL
±1,520 S.F.

SUITE D
REST.
±1,794 S.F.

SUITE A
RETAIL
±3,042 S.F.

SUITE D
FAST CASUAL REST.
±1,762 S.F.

SUITE B
RETAIL
±2,023 S.F.

SUITE C
RETAIL
±2,081 S.F.

SUITE E
RETAIL
±1,950 S.F. 4 YD 4 YD 7'-6"
7 14
10 1
16 9
30'-0"
12'-0" 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD
5 6
8 8'-0"4 YD 4 YD
4 YD 4 YD
7 10 10
55'-0"
12'-0"
124'-3"
7 10 10
PATIO
TRASH
STOP
STOP LANE 1 LANE 2

DO NOT ENTER
5 9
5 25'-0"
25'-0"
250 SF
25'-0"
510 SF

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,500 S.F.

DRIVE-THRU

RESTAURANT
±2,296 S.F.

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
±4,226 S.F.

SHOPS 1
RETAIL
4,979 SF

SPRINKLERED
R10'-0" R20'-0"
27 12
5 REST
±2,400 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,400 S.F.

RETAIL
±2,201 S.F.
16 7
80'-0"
73'-11"
60'-0"
118'-11" PATIO
6 25'-0"
25'-0"
25'-0"
PAD 7
RETAIL
4,694 SF

SPRINKLERED
86'-11" 86'-11"
142'-0"
7 40'-0" 20'-0"
24'-0"
TYP.
9'-0"
18'-0"
8'-0"
8'-11"
30'-0"
30'-0"
36'-0"
25'-0"
TYP.
14 4
5 10
12 4
5 23
6 9
62'-0"
8'-0"
PATIO
7'-6" 12'-0"

MENU BOARD
1 1
16'-0"
20'-0"
61'-0"
61'-0"
61'-0"
26'-0"
27'-0"
29'-10"
16'-0" 30'-0"
18 18
11 4 YD 4 YD 4 YD 12'-0"
12'-0"
2 CONTROLLER
OFFICE
308 SF

CONTROLLER
/STORAGE
120 SF
76'-11"

GROCERY TENANT AREA LIMIT
30'-0"
30'-0" 4 YD 4 YD

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
2,861 S.F.

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS
2,687 S.F.
6 8

PRELIMINARY

RETENTION BASIN
3 5
1 4
4 4 7
6 32
16 21'-3"
68'-0" 30'-0" 15' LANDSCAPE SETBACK
25'-0" 12'-0"
22'-0" 34'-0"
14'-11"
34'-0" 34'-0" 34'-0" 20'-0"
30'-0" 30'-0"
21 5
30'-0" 36'-0" 25'-0" 36'-0" 25'-0" 36'-0" 30'-0"
25'-0"
30'-0"
30'-0"
186'-9"
63'-0"
KEEP
CLEAR
8'-0" 51'-0"
21'-0"
5 25'-0"
9'-5"
16 10
25'-0" 25'-0"
15'-0"
15'-0"
25'-0" 4 YD 4 YD 12'-0"
15' LANDSCAPE SETBACK
24'-0"
12'-0" 18'-0"
25'-0" 41'-5"
25'-0"
12'-0" 12'-0"
CARTS
32 31
19 32
25'-0" 36'-0" 30'-0"WB-67 - Interstate Semi-Trailer
3 19
5 3
3 100'-0" 100'-0"

MAJOR I
RETAIL
27,921 SF

MAJOR E
RETAIL
27,863 SF
239'-4"
239'-4"
110'-0" 116'-8" 100'-0"
110'-0"
239'-4"
239'-4"

MAJOR J
24,436 SF
102'-0"
100'-0"
253'-3"
253'-3"
239'-4"
253'-4"

MAJOR D
RETAIL
22,927 SF

MAJOR G
RETAIL
26,326 SF

MAJOR H
RETAIL
23,927SF

MAJOR F
RETAIL
25,329 SF

MAJOR C
RETAIL
21,927 SF
N
0 PHASING PLAN
SP-33
Scale : 1" = 80'
40' 80' 160'
N

LOCATION PLAN
N.T.S.

07.01.2026 A-1.1
NOTE: This information is conceptual in nature and is subject to adjustments pending further verification and Client, Tenant, and Governmental Agency approvals. No warranties or guaranties of any kind are given or implied by the Architect.

DATE:

MCG JOB #:

DATE REVISIONS

SWC ROSEDALE AND COFFEE

24.457.01 BAKERSFIELD, CA
C MCG ARCHITECTURE 2026 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

AREA RESERVED FOR

CITY STAMP
N.T.S.

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE
SITE PLAN GENERAL NOTES:
- REFER TO CIVIL DRAWINGS FOR ALL EASEMENT INFORMATION. - REFER TO CIVIL DRAWINGS FOR WELL INFORMATION.

W A
SOURCE: McG Architecture, 2026
i
T
■
fl
T
t
HL .
11111111 mupLij-l!l
AIIIIIIL CTmIIIIIIIIIT0
IIL
- I -1 - —x
2i IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIL 1l 1 QL
HHHTHH
1A E ।; Ul. 11111 1 111I11 nrU
5+0.. h... .

C.J. 11111 u 111 i HIH #
T
/
in । HI । m । m । HI । n | —0111071101 1
i:

I
i
i
II
I
X |

LLLLLLLLLLLLLL
111111111111111111111 g
0 SJ
n/1
n|H111111H11111111 ii i n
Li.i.11111111 in 11 ii । i । i U
L IntTTttTTttllWttTTttlJ
3 £
TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTJTTTATTTTTTn,

TTTTITTTTIITITTITII
XlXlllXlllXlllXl.il 11.
5 _ 0
UEtlTTtpeage= (HHHHHHH J .

SH/E
(IIDr
7 IZ
IE
1 =
IE

UHHHHHHHE
M
ft =
—
X
T
11 —
CD
Site Summary

TOTAL SITE AREA

PARKING REQUIRED

AREA(SF)

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR AREA

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR AREA

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR FOOTPRINT AREA

LAND TO BUILDING RATIO

BUILDING COVERAGE
APN: 368-010-05
ZONING USE: (M-2) GENERAL MANUFACTURING
LAND USE DESIGNATION: (LI-1) LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
REQUIRED SETBACKS:

Rear: n/a
BLba. HEiGHT: 90 RL Max.

PARKING DIMENSIONS: 9 Ft x 18 Ft
DRIVE AISLE WIDTH: 25 Ft
FIRELANE ACCESS WIDTH: 20 Ft Min.

LANDSCAPE SETBACK: 10 Ft Min.

TREE PLANTING: 1TREE PER 6 PARKING SPACES
Restaurant (Sit Down and Fast Casual)
carwasn
Health Club
Medical Office
Public Storage
2,057 Stalls
2,081 Stalls

5.13 /1,000Sf
2,010,574 Sf
405,531 St
PARKING PROVIDED______________

PROPOSED PARKING STALLS

PICK-UP WINDOW CREDIT
OVERALL PROPOSED PARKING STALLS:

PROPOSED PARKING RATIO:

Retail- Single Tenant
/Bank/Fitness/Office
Retail- Multi Tenant/Shops
Restaurants / D/T
Medical Clinic
Carwash
Public Storage
iuhmoy 11 f tai
II i: rrliiiiiir
7 ..... ..... IIIL
x
1 I
i
I
i
bTiiiTIiTiTU i
-
.. 1
II I
I
I
I
I
OO
I
I
I
I
I
LEGEND
PHASE 1 I
PHASE 2
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
)CA-58 & Coffee Rd, Rd,
Bakersfield, CA' 193312
Kimley»Horn
f
l
I HHthttII IIP -rr’rrhti
, I II J I I I 11 I I 11 I I -(HHHHHHs1 7/"E TJIHHHHHIU I Ji f 0111
w
III :
|)
I 11
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-12
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-13

2.2.2 Access, Circulation, and Parking
Vehicular access to the Project Site would be provided via a proposed driveway along El Toro Viejo Road; three right-in/right-out only driveways and a signalized driveway along Rosedale Highway; and two right-in/right-out only driveways and a signalized driveway along Coffee Road.

The signalized driveways would function as the main entries into the Project Site, with secondary access provided via the non-signalized driveways. Combined, the proposed driveways would provide a direct connection to the comprehensive drive aisle system proposed within the parking areas of the Project Site. The Project would include sidewalk improvements along Project frontages.

Proposed off-site improvements include modification to the existing signalized intersection of Coffee Road and Jet Way. Specifically, the improvements would include the installation of a new traffic light pole/structure at the southeast corner of the Coffee Road and Jet Way intersection and any necessary roadway improvements (i.e., modification to the existing raised median to provide a dedicated left-turn lane and roadway striping).

For the existing signalized intersection of Rosedale Highway and Northwest Promenade, which is the street that provides vehicular access to the commercial retail center north of the Project Site, no improvements or modifications to the traffic signal poles/structures would occur. However, a portion of the raised median on Rosedale Highway (the portion between Northwest Promenade and Coffee Road) would be modified to provide a dedicated left-turn lane for west-bound traffic entering the Project Site at the signalized intersection. Other roadway improvements at this intersection would include striping.

Parking for employees, customers and visitors would be provided onsite in dedicated surface parking areas throughout the Project Site. Pursuant to the parking provisions of the Bakersfield Zoning Code (BMC Chapter 17.58), 1,760 parking spaces would be required to serve the mix of uses and the Project would exceed that amount and provide 1,913 spaces. Additionally, pursuant to the provisions of the Bakersfield Development Code and the most current (2019) California Green Building Standards Code (CALGreen; Title 24, California Code of Regulations, Part 11), which are codified in Chapter 15 (California Green Building Standards Code) of the Bakersfield Municipal Code, parking spaces for handicap, van accessible, and clean-air vehicles would be provided among the 1,913 spaces.

2.2.3 Pedestrian Access and Circulation
Pedestrian access to the Project Site would be provided via public sidewalks (10-foot-wide meandering multi-use paths) along Rosedale Highway and along Coffee Road. Internal walkways would connect to the public sidewalks at key locations along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road.

The internal walkways would provide access to the various uses and areas of the Project. The internal sidewalks would also provide connectivity to the Project’s “play area” that would consist of landscaped mounds, benches, picnic tables, bike racks, and a lawn area. Also, striped crosswalks would be provided at key locations to allow for safe pedestrian crossing.

2.2.4 Loading and Deliveries
Loading and unloading of delivery trucks for the major retail buildings would occur in the designated loading dock of that building, which are toward the rear of the buildings. For the tenants of the outlying building pads, loading and unloading of delivery trucks would occur in Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-14
designated areas (within proximity of the tenants) that would not impede the internal vehicular circulation system. No loading or unloading activities would occur in the parking areas or non-designated loading/unloading areas.

2.2.5 Design Concept
The Project proposes to transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would create economic, retail and service opportunities in an area served with existing infrastructure and public services. The Project would provide for economic growth and revenue generation to the City through creation of a flexible, market-driven development that responds to the existing and future needs and demands of Bakersfield's commercial markets.

The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. (See Figure 2-5: Renderings). Buildings would have a maximum height of 90 feet. Building materials would include but not be limited to cement plaster with stone veneer, aluminum wood siding metal canopies, and large display windows. Careful and judicial use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site. Along the Coffee Road Frontage and Rosedale Highway frontages would run a “dry creek” aesthetic feature composed of decorative cobbles and decomposed granite and crushed rocks.

2.2.6 Open Space and Landscaping
The Project would feature 325,120 square feet of new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience, and provide shade. Within the parking lot area would be 443 trees and the Project would include 122 street trees (79 trees provided on Coffee Road and 43 on Rosedale Highway) plus 534 trees within the Project Site for a total of 656 trees. Types of trees would include Marina Strawberry tree, Western Redbud, Chinese Flame tree, Canary Island Pine, California Sycamore, Coast Live Oak, Holly Oak, Cork Oak, Interior Live Oak, Brisbane Box, Chinese Elm, and Majestic Beauty Indian Hawthorn. See Figure 2-6: Landscape Concept Plan and Figure 2-7: Street Frontage Enlargements.

The Project would also include enhanced paving areas within small plaza areas in front of storefronts, and enhanced vehicular paving at entry points. The Project would include a detention basin on the northern portion of the Project Site that would be fenced and screened with landscaping. Near the detention basin would be a play area which would include landscaped mounds, benches, picnic tables, bike racks, and a lawn area.

SOURCE: McG Architecture, 2025
FIGURE 2-5: Renderings

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
105
103 ROSEDALE HIGHWAY
bha
SoazLsoss ■ eD
At Copay | G9 SIERRA /Marshalls
— MA I* II
Si
—
EP I , .5.

IS
mm"
lm
-
M. uhl
01 04
"n: A-. ,at "FEs #*r“5 S3 B
EBI GPrcakFctoy
5 mi alutts PVe .2 wWa w
•J* J
“w.

L
as ep 417 sa
02 05
—
“"Ius uh wall
e-60 .7 J - i gand)
e. TAE-si,, a 857
• 4I
A
75 3
«
w
d ’ *
03 06
Kimley»Horn
• *
_ a

AREA RESERVED FOR

CITY STAMP
• “

LOCATION PLAN
N.T.S.
2,**
ErA==-a A
— A -je- ee.
=* '
tuinoon CEee na/ece
ETe-aann
(02
? (04
IS?
,= aa t -
Bi
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-16
This page intentionally left blank.

FIGURE 2-6: Landscape Concept Plan
RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT ROSEDALE & COFFEE RD - RIVERVIEW MARKET ©

SIGNATURE

L I CENSED LANDSCA PE ARCH I T ECT
MICHAEL A . LEDBETTER 5553

STATE OF CAL I FORN IA

RENEWAL DATE
DATE
L-1

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION LANDSCAPE CONCEPT PLAN
0 50’ 100’ 200’ LEGEND

TREE LEGEND

SHRUB LEGEND
CITY OF BAKERSFIELD LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS 17.61.030
ALL TREE TO BE 24” BOX AND 2” DBH
ALL SHRUBS TO BE 5 GALLON WITH SPACING APPRORIATE FOR PLANT SPECIES ALL GROUND COVERS TO BE 1 GALLON WITH AVERAGE SPACING OF 18” O.C.

DRIVE-THRU LANES AND STREET FACING PARKING SHALL BE SCREENED BY EVERGREEN HEDGE WITH MIN. HEIGHT OF 4’.

TOTAL NEW LANDSCAPE AREA PROVIDED: 325,120 SQUARE FEET
TREES IN PARKING LOT REQUIRED 1 TREE / 6 PARKING STALLS 1,977 STALLS / 6 = 330 TREES REQUIRED
443 TOTAL TREES PROVIDED
TOTAL PARKING LOT AREA: 503,853 SQUARE FEET

DOES NOT INCLUDE PARKING AREA BEING PROVIDED WITHIN THE PG&E EASEMENT 503,853 x 40% = 201,541 SQUARE FEET SHADING REQUIRED
203,800 SQUARE FEET SHADING PROVIDED (40.4%)
MINIMUM 30% OF PARKING LOT TREES REQUIRED TO BE EVERGREEN 443 TREES PROVIDED x 30% = 133 EVERGREEN TREES REQUIRED 245 EVERGREEN TREES PROVIDED (55.3%)

COFFEE ROAD STREET REQUIREMENTS
STREET FRONTAGES: (1) TREE TO BE PLANTED EVERY TWENTY LINEAR FEET TOTAL STREET FRONTAGE ON COFFEE ROAD: 1,560 LINEAR FEET 1,560 SQUARE FEET / 20 = 78 TREE REQUIRED
79 TOTAL TREES PROVIDED ON COFFEE ROAD
STREET TREES SHALL BE 70% DECIDUOUS & 30% EVERGREEN MIX TOTAL NUMBER OF STREET TREES PROVIDED ON COFFEE ROAD: 79 DECIDUOUS TREES: 55 (70%)
EVERGREEN TREES: 24 (30%)

ROSEDALE HWY STREET REQUIREMENTS
* STREET FRONTAGE REQUIREMENT CANNOT BE MET ON ROSEDALE HWY PER PG&E TRANSMISSION LINE REQUIREMENTS.

STREET FRONTAGES: (1) TREE TO BE PLANTED EVERY TWENTY LINEAR FEET TOTAL STREET FRONTAGE ON ROSEDALE HWY: 1,560 LINEAR FEET 2,300 SQUARE FEET / 20 = 115 TREE REQUIRED
43 TOTAL TREES PROVIDED ON ROSEDALE HWY
STREET TREES SHALL BE 70% DECIDUOUS & 30% EVERGREEN MIX TOTAL NUMBER OF STREET TREES PROVIDED ON ROSEDALE HWY: 43 DECIDUOUS TREES: 8 (7% OF TOTAL REQUIRED STREET TREES)
EVERGREEN TREES: 35 (30% OF TOTAL REQUIRED STREET TREES) 1 4
2 5
3 6

PLAZA AREAS TO INCLUDE ENHANCED

PAVING, OUTDOOR SEATING, ACCENT
PLANT MATERIAL AND LIGHTING.

STORE FRONT PAVING TO INCLUDE

ENHANCED PAVING, BANDING AND
ACCENT PLANTING.

TRUCK LOADING DOCK AREAS PER
ARCHITECT’S PLANS.

SHOPPING CENTER - MULTI-TENANT
MONUMENT SIGNAGE.

ENHANCED VEHICULAR PAVING AT

ENTRY WITH THEMATIC ELEMENTS (SEE

ENLARGEMENTS)

DETENTION BASIN WITH FENCING,

VEHICULAR ACCESS, AND LANDSCAPE
SCREENING.

ARBUTUS X ‘MARINA’

MARINA STRAWBERRY TREE

CERCIS OCCIDENTALIS

WESTERN REDBUD

KOELREUTERIA BIPINNATA

CHINESE FLAME TREE

PINUS CANARIENSIS

CANARY ISLAND PINE

PISTACIA CHINENSIS

CHINESE PISTACHE

PLATANUS RACEMOSA

CALIFORNIA SYCAMORE

QUERCUS AGRIFOLIA

COAST LIVE OAK

QUERCUS ILEX

HOLLY OAK

QUERCUS SUBER

CORK OAK

QUERCUS WISLIZENI

INTERIOR LIVE OAK
RHAPHIOLEPIS X ‘MONTIC’

MAJESTIC BEAUTY INDIAN

HAWTHORN

TRISTANIA CONFERTA

BRISBANE BOX

ULMUS PARVIFOLIA

CHINESE ELM
75 74
109
34 87
8 11
68 85
8 35
16 46

SHRUBS AND GROUNDCOVERS SEE
COMPLETE LEGEND ON SHEET L-5.

BOTANICAL & COMMON NAME QTY

EL TORO VIEJO RD

ROSEDALE HWY SEE ENLARGEMENT A
SHEET L-3

SEE OPEN SPACE ENLARGEMENT
SHEET L-4

PROPERTY LINE

PROPERTY LINE

PG&E POWER EASEMENT LINE

PROPERTY LINE

PROPERTY LINE

SEE ENLARGEMENT B
SHEET L-3

EXISTING PG&E

TRANSMISSION
STATION N.A.P.

STORAGE
BLDG

RESTAURANTS

CAR WASH

RESTAURANT

RESTAURANTS

MAJOR A

HEALTH CLUB

MAJOR B
MARKET

MAJOR C

MAJOR D
RETAIL

MAJOR E
RETAIL

MAJOR F
RETAIL

MAJOR G
RETAIL

MAJOR H
RETAIL

MAJOR I
RETAIL

MAJOR J

RESTAURANT

RESTAURANT
RETAIL
RETAIL

MEDICAL
OFFICE
DRIVE
THRU

RETAIL RETAIL
RETAIL
RETAIL
RETAIL
RETAIL
RETAIL
REST.

GAS STATION

COFFEE RD
1 2
2 3
3 3
4 5 5
6 RESTAURANTS
& RETAIL
R/W
R/W

R/W R/W R/W R/W
R/W
4 PG&E POWER EASEMENT LINE PG&E POWER EASEMENT LINE

PG&E EASEMENT

RESTAURANT
SOURCE: Kimley-Horn, 2025
IIIE"TIIIIIII
T
T
H ♦
Q%
——
H
Know whats below, Call811beloceyoudiy,
"" ht -a
Hh-HmHmnmr:

I 8y r"
Kimley>»Horn
10 1
—7
4 ■
t ’I
r
I
■ 1
■
. - --- - I£ 5 1 ■ —=?—2"—em
s
„ I
m=rsam
1 B OEE
C L t i ( J
006 0600060 090©
1 bq
t
JI
f
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-18
This page intentionally left blank.

SOURCE: Kimley-Horn, 2025
FIGURE 2-7: Street Frontage Enlargements
RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT ROSEDALE & COFFEE RD - RIVERVIEW MARKET ©

SIGNATURE

L I CENSED LANDSCA PE ARCH I T ECT
MICHAEL A . LEDBETTER 5553

STATE OF CAL I FORN IA

RENEWAL DATE
DATE
L-3

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION STREET FRONTAGE ENLARGEMENTS
LEGEND

SHOPPING CENTER - MULTI-TENANT MONUMENT SIGNAGE

EXISTING POWER POLE (PROTECT IN PLACE)

ENHANCED PAVING AT ENTRY DRIVE
8 FT CURVILINEAR SIDEWALKS, TYP.

ENTRY WALLS WITH PILASTER
BOULDER OUTCROP, TYP.

DECORATIVE COBBLE / DRY CREEK, TYP.

DECOMPOSED GRANITE / CRUSHED ROCK, TYP.

SCREENING FOR DRIVE-THRU / PARKING
(4 FT. HIGH PLANTING OR WALL)
PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE, TYP.

TENANT PATIO, TYP.

TRASH ENCLOSURE, TYP.

PG&E EASEMENT 1
2 6 10
3 7 11
11 4 8 12
5 9 A
0 10’ 20’ 40’
0 10’ 20’ 40’
9 9
3 3
5 5
1 6
6 7
7 8 2
10 4
4 12
A
B

FAST CASUAL

RESTAURANTS

ROSEDALE HWY FRONTAGE ENLARGEMENT

COFFEE RD FRONTAGE ENLARGEMENT

RESTAURANT

OVERHEAD POWER LINE ABOVE OVERHEAD POWER LINE ABOVE

ROSEDALE HWY

COFFEE RD

RESTAURANT

RETAIL RETAIL
RETAIL
A A
ed AP.9*PS
Es
d LQ
(• ■.
- 1
. i Jt Iw
s —4
IP
“ene aa..
57605588
w
CI
fa
---
wnt*
7 llils
YYg K
(O
JEAP
LO V
an
-a
aandees
1- - hy
■
-
*
" nuce
Soedet.

Th
I
ontszpt
kig
Hett) 50/86/90
LQ
i
■
8 ata
-c*—
1 ©
th
©
Kimley>»Horn
Tseumegry 3ewu
I
fun
A&AE
*
GlE
ETa Mall o
T
EE
II
me
1 I
5 -r
• • • •
s
• • • •• • • •
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-20
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-21

2.2.7 Lighting and Signage
Lighting for the Project is intended to minimize light trespass and glare from the Project Site onto adjacent properties and to provide safety and nighttime visibility through shielded, focused, and directed illumination. Lighting would consist of exterior building-mounted light fixtures; interior lighting for the new buildings; lighting for pedestrian walkways and common gathering areas; lighting for the green spaces; ground-mounted decorative lighting for landscape and architectural features; signage lighting; lighting for the new parking areas, drive aisles, and loading dock areas; and security lighting.

The Project is anticipated to require a number of sign types that would help identify and promote the Project and its businesses and tenants. Sign types would include multi-tenant pylon and monument signs, project identification monument signs, tenant wall signs, and on-site directional and legal signs.

2.2.8 Infrastructure Improvements
Water, Wastewater, and Drainage
Project development would include construction of all necessary on- and off-site infrastructure improvements to adequately serve the Project’s water, wastewater, and drainage needs. Water and wastewater services would be provided by the City. All proposed infrastructure and improvements would require City approval and where necessary, approval by the utility/service provider.

Solid Waste and Recycling Services
Solid waste and recycling generated by the Project would be collected and hauled away by and transported to/disposed of at the appropriate facilities. Enclosures with solid roof tops and swinging gates that would accommodate bins for solid waste, organic waste, and recyclable materials would be provided in various areas of the Project Site, generally to the rear of future commercial buildings in order to minimize views from parking areas and surrounding streets.

Utilities and Service Systems
Plans for utilities and service systems that would serve the Project include provision of electricity (PG&E), natural gas (PG&E), and telecommunications (AT&T and Spectrum). All new utility infrastructure would be installed underground or placed in enclosed spaces (e.g., utility closets).

2.2.9 Operational Hours
The anticipated operating hours of the businesses that would ultimately occupy the buildings are not yet known at this time. However, the hours of operation for each use would vary with some business opening and closing sooner than other uses, and others only being open during the week. For example, the major markets and retails use hours could be from 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday through Sunday, whereas the medical office use could operate from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Monday through Friday.

2.2.10 Sustainability Features
The Project would be an infill development that promotes the sustainable principles of smart growth. Compliance with state laws regarding water and energy conservation, including Title 24, Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-22
also would result in increased efficiency and sustainability. Landscaping is anticipated to be native and drought tolerant and would comply with the Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance (MWELO) per Section 17.61.060, Landscape Plan Requirements of the City of Bakersfield Municipal Code.

2.3 Project Phasing and Construction
Project development is anticipated to be completed in two development phases, as illustrated in Figure 2-4, Site Plan Phasing. The first phase would consist of development of 37.8 acres located at the north end of the Project, as well as associated off-site improvements. The second phase would result in development of the remaining 8.36 acres at the south-east end of the Project. It should be noted that the Project applicant may decide to accelerate or postpone the second phase depending on market conditions.

Project buildout is anticipated to occur over an approximately 20-month timeframe, commencing in late 2026 and ending in Quarter 2 2028. Phase 1 is anticipated to commence in late 2026 and be completed by late 2027, with Phase 2 commencing in late 2027 and completed by Quarter 2 2028. The Project would be consistent with the Bakersfield Municipal Code Section 9.22.050, “Noise during construction.” The City prohibits construction activities from 9:00 pm to 6:00 am Monday through Friday (including federal holidays), and before 8:00 am or after 9:00 pm on weekends that produce loud or unusual noise which annoys or disturbs a reasonable person of normal sensitivity.

2.4 Requested Permits and Approvals
The anticipated requests for approval of the Project are listed below in Table 2-2: Matrix of Project Approvals/Permits. The Environmental Impact Report would analyze impacts associated with the Project and would provide environmental review sufficient for all necessary entitlements and public agency actions associated with the Project. The discretionary entitlements, reviews, permits and approvals required to implement the Project include, but are not necessarily limited to, the following:
• Site Plan Review consistent with the Bakersfield Municipal Code Section 17.08.140. • General Plan Amendment (GPA) of the land use element of the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan) from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial) • Tentative Tract Map
• Comprehensive Sign Plan
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-23
Table 2-2: Matrix of Project Approvals/Permits
Agency Approvals and Decisions
City of Bakersfield Discretionary Approvals
Planning Commission • Certify or reject the Project’s EIR City Council • Approve, conditionally approve, or not approve the general plan amendment
• Provide direction to the Development Services Director whether to approve, conditionally approve, or not approve Site Plan Review
Development Services Director • Approve, conditionally approve, or not approve Site Plan Review
Subsequent City of Bakersfield Approvals
Development Services Director • Approve, conditionally approve, or not approve any subsequent Site Plan Reviews or modifications thereto
pertaining to the Project site.

Development Services Department and
Public Works Department
• Issue grading permits
• Issue building permits
• Accept public right-of-way dedications
• Approve road improvement plans
• Issue encroachment permits
• Approve proposed sewer connections and improvements
Other Agencies – Subsequent Approvals and Permits
Central Valley Regional Water Quality
Control Board
• Issue a Construction Activity General Construction Permit • Confirm Compliance with National Pollution Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES) Permit and Waste
Discharge Requirements
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control
District
• Approve and/or implement any Voluntary Emissions
Reduction Agreements (VERA) entered into by the Project Applicant
• Approve permits to construct and permit to operate (if such permits are required)
Kern County Flood Control and Water
Conservation District
• Approve proposed drainage infrastructure and
improvements
Pacific Gas & Electric • Approve connections to the electric distribution and natural gas distribution systems
California Water Service • Approve proposed connections to the domestic water system
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 2 Project Description
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 2-24
This page intentionally left blank.

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 3-1

3. Environmental Setting
CEQA Guidelines Section 15125 requires that an EIR includes a description of the existing environment. This chapter provides a general overview of the environmental setting for the Project, however detailed information on existing conditions for each environmental resource area evaluated in this Draft EIR is provided in Chapter 4: Environmental Impact Analysis. This chapter also provides an overview of related projects that are considered in the Draft EIR in evaluating cumulative impacts that could result from the Project together with other projects.

3.1 Regional Setting
Figure 1, Regional Map, depicts the proposed Project site in a regional context. The Project Site is located the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield (City), within Kern County. The City is approximately 112 miles north of the City Los Angeles. The City is bordered by Sequoia National Forest to the east and the Los Padres National Forest is located to the west. The Kern River runs through the City, south of the Project Site.

3.2 Project Site Setting
Figure 2, Local Vicinity Map, depicts the proposed Project site and immediate vicinity. The Project Site is 46.16 acres which consists of one legal parcel (APN 368-010-05) which is an undeveloped L-shaped property situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway, north of the railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road.

Nearby uses include Rosedale Highway and a commercial retail center (Northwest Promenade), to the north; a Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) electric substation and vacant land to the south; El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a PG&E electric substation to the west; and Coffee Road, Friant-Kern Canal, and a commercial retail center to the east. The Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six-foot-tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds.

3.3 Cumulative Development
Section 15355 of the CEQA Guidelines defines “cumulative impacts” as “two or more individual effects which, when considered together, are considerable or which compound or increase other environmental impacts.” This means that while the impacts of projects on their own may be insignificant, when analyzed in combination with impacts from other projects in the vicinity, they may be significant. CEQA Guidelines section 15130 requires EIRs to discuss the cumulative impacts of a project “when the project’s incremental effect is cumulatively considerable.” Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 3 Environmental Setting
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 3-2
Each impact analysis discussion provided in Section 4, Environmental Impact Analysis, includes a cumulative impacts discussion. Table 3-1, Cumulative Projects List, identifies the projects in the Project vicinity with potential to result in cumulative impacts.

Table 3-1: Cumulative Projects List
Project Location
VTPM 12376 - Proposing to divide a 9.65 acre site into a 3.00 acre parcel and a 6.71 acre parcel
7131 Charity Ave, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 32-20 an adjustment of lot lines resulting in a 10,753 sf lot, a 10,807 sf lot, and a 4.56 acre lot.
11709 Cactus Dr, Bakersfield, CA
PMW 3-21 - proposing to redefine Parcel 3 of PM 4690 for condominium purposes
2910 Gibson St, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 17-21 An adjustment of lot lines resulting in a 38,907 sf (gross) parcel and a 5.02 ac (gross) parcel
2932 Henry Ln, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 28-21 An adjustment of lot lines between two
parcels
2321 Wheeler St, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 28-21 proposed to adjust the lot lines between
three parcels resulting in a 9,536 sf (net) parcel and a 10,725 sf (net) parcel
2321 Wheeler St, Bakersfield, CA
TPM 12439 proposing to divide a 4.77 ac site into three parcels ranging in size from 0.50 ac (net) to 2.38 acre (net)
Northwest corner of Brimhall Rd and
Verdugo Ln
VTPM 12500 proposing to divide a 5.03 ac site into a

1.59 ac (net) parcel and a 3.31 ac parcel
3215 Fruitvale Ave, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 21-23 - An adjustment of lot lines to combine two
parcels resulting in a 1.79 ac parcel
10302 Holland St, Bakersfield, CA
LLA 37-23 An adjustment of lot lines to combine three
parcels resulting in a 36,179 sf parcel
9711 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA
TPM 12529 proposed the division of a 2.77 ac site into four parcels ranging in size from 17,745 sf (gross) to 17,753 sf (gross) and a 1.14 ac (gross) DR
10117 Meacham Rd, Bakersfield, CA
TPM 12512 Proposing the division of a 2.39 ac parcel into 4 parcels ranging in size from 13,000 sf (net) to 23,979.20 sf (net) and a 21,707.40 sf (net) designated remainder
9921 Shellabarger Rd, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102-23, DOPC, Christian Castaneda, Liquor License
Determination
4208 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA
PD, Map 102-29 for Two Medical Office Buildings 1710 Calloway Dr, Bakersfield, CA PD, Map 102-21 for Warehouse and Office Buildings 0 Downing Ave, Bakersfield, CA Zone Change 133, PD 72, Map 102 for Office/Medical
Building
Downing Ave, Bakersfield, CA
PD 66, Map 102 for PD Mod in Change in Use. 3230 Fruitvale Ave, Bakersfield, CA CUP, Map 102-26 - Auto Dismantling Facility 4100 Burr St Bakersfield, CA Map 102-30, CUP - Contractors Storage Yard 9935 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA A modification to PD 32, Map 102-21. A proposal to convert a carwash to an office/warehouse and construct a new 5,000 square foot warehouse.
3714 Coffee Rd, Bakersfield, CA
DOPC, Breakers, Map 102-30 10511 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA Map 101-24, PD 11709 Cactus Dr, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102-30, Determination Similar Use - Furniture Store 9935 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, Ca Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 3 Environmental Setting
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 3-3
Project Location
Map 102-21, ZV - Landscape Reduction KCPWD Patton Way
Road Yard
Rosedale Hwy and Coffee Rd
Map 102-21, PD - Office Warehouse;
Project: (a) A Precise Development Plan to develop six (6), 4,500-square-foot buildings for the following uses: three (3) buildings offering industrial services (Section 19.38.020.D.5), two (2) buildings offering indoor contractor storage (Section

19.38.020.E.2) and one (1) building offering indoor
manufacture/assembly uses (Section 19.38.020.E.1) with
associated parking and landscaping;
and (b) A Zone Variance requesting a reduction in parking for a total of 96 parking spaces where 111 spaces are
required (Section 19.106.040) on an approximate 2.38-acre parcel in a M-2 PD (Medium Industrial—Precise
Development Combining) District. Project is proposed to be constructed in phases.
3017 Fruitvale Ave, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102-30, PD 1 - Modification to Parking Stalls and Striping 10525 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-21, DOPC, Rosedale Station 6600 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-30, CUP - Residential Accessory Structure 10021 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-30, GPA - Change in designation from SR to HMR
on 4.77 ac;
ZCC from E (1/2) RS to R-2 CL on 4.77 acres
10021 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, Ca
PD-Trucking facility trailer drop off yard and 8,000 sq ft storage building accessory to trailer parking
7121 Charity Ave, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102, CUP 55
Modification Additional Truck Parking
7121 Charity Ave, Bakersfield, CA
CUP Map 101-24
Wells are contaminated with TCP and Nitrate, and treatment plant is needed to treat wells to bring levels down to lower than regulatory maximum contaminant level.
33592 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102-29, PD 24, Mod - Electrified Perimeter Fencing 8929 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA PD 73, Map 102; A Precise Development Plan requesting
construction of an approximate 3,720-square-foot
office and an approximate 4,500-square-foot warehouse with an associated roof-only canopy for storage
(Section 19.38.020.D.1 & Section 19.38.020.E.2) on an
approximate 38,029-square-foot portion of an
approximate 2.98-acre parcel in an M-2 PD District.

Wedding Ln, South Of Charity Ave
Map 102-30, CUP 31, 34, Mod - New Computer Lab Bldg 10218 Greenacres Dr, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-21, PD 48, Mod - Security System Fencing 3541 Alken St, Bakersfield, CA Map 101-25, PD 6, Mod - New Roof Canopy at Carwash 11921 Rosedale Hwy, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-21, ZCC - E(5) RS to M-1 PD- Closed 3500 Patton Wy, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-29, PD - New Dental Office Bldg. 2520 Calloway Dr, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-21, PD 40, Mod - Security Fence System 3611 Alken St, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-19, ZM - Accessory Structure Taller than Primary Residence;
PROPOSAL: A Zone Modification to construct a 23 feet 9- inch tall, accessory building where 20 feet is
authorized (Section 19.08.180.A.3) on a 32,670-square-foot acre parcel zone E (10) RS (Estate - 10
acres - Residential Suburban Combining) District.
10409 Meacham Rd, Bakersfield, CA
Map 102-21, CUP - KCPWD Household Hazardous Waste
Facility.
3611 Alken St, Bakersfield, CA
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 3 Environmental Setting
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 3-4
Project Location
Map #101 - PD 6- Mod to PD 6, Map 101, PD to add 22' x 72' covered solar structure over portion of KFC drive thru lane, on a C-2 PD zone.
11935 Rosedale Highway, Bakersfield, CA
Kern County Housing Element Implementation 2022; Various changes to existing land use designations to facilitate future higher density residential development as required by the adopted Kem County Housing Element. Proposed actions
include amendments to existing General and Specific Plan map code designations and changes to existing zone
classifications. A series of proposed Staff initiated changes to various land use designations on 56 parcels throughout
unincorporated Kem County. The proposed project includes necessary actions that would establish land uses suitable for future high-density residential development projects. At this time, the proposed project does not include any proposed development. This proposal only includes changes in land use designations to facilitate future residential
developmental ranging from apartment complexes to other owner-occupied higher density development
projects.
435 Panama Rd, Bakersfield, CA
ZCC from E(10) RS to E1/4 in a SR general plan designation to facilitate a future residential subdivision of 4 parcels and one remainder on 2.77 acres.
10117 Meacham Rd, Bakersfield, CA
ZCC from E(10) RS to E1/4 in a SR general plan designation to facilitate a future residential subdivision of 4 parcels and one remainder on 2.77 acres.
10117 Meacham Rd, Bakersfield, CA
ZCC to R-2 and E(1/4) 4112 Jewetta Ave, Bakersfield, CA CUP for transitional housing (16 residents) 10105 Laurie Ave, Bakersfield, CA Map 102-30, ZCC - Change in zone classification from E (2 1/2) RS to E (1/4) on 2.39 acres
9921 Shellabarger Rd, Bakersfield, CA
Zone modification for fence height of 8 feet 10809 Paul Ave, Bakersfield, CA CUP for cargo container 2430 Calloway Dr, Bakersfield, CA Source: City of Bakersfield Development Services Department City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4-1

4. Environmental Impact Analysis

4.1 Introduction
This chapter of the Draft Environmental Impact Report (Draft EIR) discusses the potential environmental effects of the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project). As discussed in Section 1.5, Organization of the Draft EIR, the discussion provided in this chapter is arranged by environmental issue analyzed:
• Aesthetics
• Agriculture and Forestry Resources
• Air Quality
• Biological Resources
• Cultural Resources
• Energy
• Geology and Soils
• Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• Hazards and Hazardous Materials
• Hydrology and Water Quality
• Land Use and Planning
• Mineral Resources
• Noise
• Population and Housing
• Public Services and Recreation
• Transportation
• Tribal Cultural Resources
• Utilities and Service Systems
• Wildfire
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4 Environmental Impact Analysis City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4-2
Discussion within each section is established as follows:

Regulatory Setting. The regulatory setting identifies the applicable federal, state, regional, and/or local laws, regulations, and applicable to the Project.

Environmental Setting. The environmental setting discusses existing conditions at the proposed Project site and in the surrounding area at the time the NOP was published. The purpose of the environmental setting is to describe the “baseline condition” the City of Bakersfield will use to compare to the Project for purposes of identifying whether the Project would result in significant impacts.

Impact Analysis. The impact analysis discussion describes the methodology employed to analyze the effects of the proposed Project on each environmental issue. This section also identifies the thresholds of significance employed to determine whether the proposed Project would produce a significant impact. Finally, potential project impacts are discussed per the threshold significance criteria.

Mitigation Measures. Mitigation measures are feasible actions, conditions, or project modifications identified to avoid, minimize, rectify, reduce, or compensate for significant environmental impacts that could result from implementation of the Project. Where applicable, these measures are incorporated to reduce impacts to a less than significant level and are identified with corresponding monitoring or compliance requirements.

Cumulative Impact Analysis. The cumulative impact analysis evaluates whether the Project’s incremental contribution to a cumulative environmental effect would be cumulatively considerable when viewed together with the effects of past, present, and reasonably foreseeable probable future projects, which are identified in Table 3-1 in Section 3.0, Environmental Setting, of this Draft EIR. This analysis considers the geographic scope and context of each resource topic to determine whether the Project would contribute to a significant cumulative impact.

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-1

4.1 Aesthetics
This section discusses impacts associated with the potential for the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project) to degrade the existing visual quality of the Project Site and its surroundings through changes in the existing landscape. Potential effects are evaluated relative to important visual features (e.g., scenic highways and scenic features), and the existing visual landscape and its users. Degradation of the visual character of the Project Site is usually addressed through a qualitative evaluation of the changes of the aesthetic characteristics of the existing environment. Information in this section is based, in part, on photos of the Project Site, the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan), the City of Bakersfield Municipal Code (Municipal Code) and the City of Bakersfield (City) Land Use Zoning Ordinance (Zoning Ordinance).

During the scoping period for the Project’s Environmental Impact Report (EIR), no comments were received in response to the Notice of Preparation (NOP) related to aesthetics.

4.1.1 Regulatory Setting
State
California Department of Transportation Scenic Highway Program The California Scenic Highway Program, maintained by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), was created by the State Legislature in 1963. The purpose of the State Scenic Highway Program is to protect and enhance the natural scenic beauty of California highways and adjacent corridors, through special conservation treatment. The State laws governing the Scenic Highway Program are found in the Streets and Highways Code, Sections 260 through 263. A highway may be designated scenic depending upon how much of the natural landscape can be seen by travelers, the scenic quality of the landscape, and the extent to which development intrudes upon the traveler’s enjoyment of the view. The State Scenic Highway System includes a list of highways that are either eligible for designation as scenic highways or have been officially designated. The status of a proposed state scenic highway changes from eligible to officially designated when the local governing body applies to Caltrans for scenic highway approval, adopts a Corridor Protection Program, and receives notification that the highway has been officially designated a Scenic Highway.

Local
Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan
The City’s General Plan, dated December 2002, was updated in January 2016 per Resolution No. 018-16 and 019-16. At the time this EIR was published for public review, the City was in the process of updating its Bakersfield 2045 General Plan, but it has not yet been adopted. The General Plan includes goals, policies, and directions to achieve the City’s vision of the community and future development. The General Plan includes 12 elements that focus on: Land Use; Circulation; Housing; Conservation; Open Space; Noise; Safety; Downtown Redevelopment; Public Services Facilities; Parks; Kern River Plan; and Historical Resources.

The General Plan is a policy document with land use maps and related information. It is designed to give long-range guidance to City staff and officials who make decisions that affect growth and resources in the metropolitan Bakersfield planning area. The General Plan helps to ensure that day-to-day decisions conform to the long-range program, which was designed to protect and Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-2
further the public interest as it relates to the City’s growth and development and mitigate environmental impacts.

The General Plan also serves as a guide to the private sector regarding the economy so that development initiatives conform to the City’s public plans, objectives, and policies. Information in the Land Use Element, Circulation Element, and Public Services and Facilities Element is relevant to the topic of aesthetics. Land Use Element goals and policies focus on establishing a built environment that achieves a compatible functional and visual relationship among individual buildings and sites, encourages high-quality design and landscaping, minimizes light pollution, and requires that new large retail commercial development projects be evaluated for potential urban decay impacts. The Circulation Element discusses providing and maintaining landscaping on both sides and in the median of arterial streets and on both sides of collector streets. The Public Services and Facilities Element states that street lighting should be installed in all new developments in accordance with adopted city standards and county policies. Goals and policies contained in the Public Services and Facilities Element that are applicable to the proposed Project include the following:

Land Use Element
LAND/CD-P-8. Require that commercial development provide design features such as screen walls, landscaping and height, setback and lighting restrictions between the boundaries of adjacent residential land use designations so as to reduce impacts on residences due to noise, traffic, parking, and differences in scale.

LAND/CD-P-25 Provide for infill of commercial land uses to be compatible with the scale and character of existing commercial districts and corridors.

LAND/CD-P-26 Encourage adjacent commercial uses to be of compatible height, setback, color and materials.

LAND/CD-P-28 Require that commercial development provide design features such as screen walls, landscaping and height, setback and lighting restrictions between the boundaries of adjacent residential land use designations so as to reduce impacts on residences due to noise, traffic, parking, and differences in scale.

LAND/CD-P-30 Street frontages along all new commercial development shall be landscaped.

LAND/CD-P-30.A Require new large retail commercial development projects to evaluate decay impacts on existing commercial uses as set forth in the implementation measures.

Public Services and Facilities Element
PS/SL-G-1 Provide uniform and adequate public lighting for all development and developing portions of the planning area.

PS/SL-P-4 Require developers to install street lighting in all new developments in accordance with adopted city standards and county policies.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-3
Circulation Element
CIRC/IMAGE 18: Provide and maintain landscaping on both sides and in the median of arterial streets within incorporated areas. In unincorporated areas, landscaping within road right-of-way may be allowed and shall be limited to low shrubs; blank irrigation conduit only will be provided within the median of arterial streets.

City of Bakersfield Municipal Code
The Municipal Code addresses specific issues regarding scenic and hillside areas, streetlights, parking lot lighting, lighting design and lighting for new development. Municipal codes that relate to the proposed Project include the following:

Section 17.08.140.G. Pedestrian Circulation.

1. For projects exceeding fifty thousand square feet of gross floor area, and/or five acres of net buildable area, meandering sidewalks at least six feet in width shall be provided along all sides of the retail development that abuts a local public street, and meandering sidewalks at least eight feet in width shall be provided along all sides of the retail development that abuts a collector or arterial public street.

Chapter 17.58 (Parking and Loading Standards). Chapter 17.58 establishes parking requirements and design standards for all development. Section 17.58.060 addresses parking lot lighting, requiring that lighting be designed to prevent glare and light spillover onto adjacent properties through the use of shields, baffles, and appropriate fixture selection.

Chapter 17.60 (Signs). Chapter 17.60 regulates signs and sign illumination. Section 17.60.060 places restrictions on floodlighting, neon tubing, exposed bulbs, flashing signs, and changeable copy signs. The section requires that illuminated signs be designed with shielded light sources directed away from streets, adjacent properties, and residential areas to prevent hazards and nuisances.

Chapter 17.61 (Landscaping). Chapter 17.61 establishes landscaping requirements for development projects, including requirements for drought-tolerant plants, parking lot shading, perimeter landscaping, and street frontage landscaping. The standards are designed to enhance visual quality, provide shade, and ensure compatibility with surrounding uses.

Chapter 17.71 (Outdoor Lighting). Chapter 17.71 establishes outdoor lighting standards for all development to promote safety, energy efficiency, and protection of the community’s night sky environment. The ordinance sets standards for placement, design, shielding, and intensity of outdoor lights to minimize glare, light trespass, and excessive illumination.

Section 17.71.030 (Lighting). Section 17.71.030 addresses light trespass, prohibiting illumination levels that extend beyond property boundaries and requiring that all outdoor lighting be designed and installed to prevent light from spilling onto adjacent properties or into the night sky. Light trespass to residentially zoned or designated properties is limited to a maximum intensity of 0.5 foot-candles at the property line, measured three feet above finished grade. This quantitative threshold provides an objective standard for evaluating light spillover impacts. Fixtures must be fully shielded or directed downward to confine light within the intended area.

Section 9.22.050 (Construction Hours). Section 9.22.050 regulates construction activities to minimize impacts on residential areas. Construction, including operation of Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-4
tools or equipment used in construction, drilling, repair, alteration, or demolition work, is permitted between:
▪ Monday through Friday: 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM
▪ Saturday, Sunday, and holidays: 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM
These restrictions ensure that construction activities occur during daytime hours when aesthetic impacts (primarily related to nighttime lighting) are avoided.

4.1.2 Environmental Setting
As described in Chapter 2, Project Description, of this Draft EIR, the Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) Kern Power Plant. The Project Site is currently secured on all sides by six-foot-tall chain-link fencing, with vehicular access provided via gated unpaved entry drives along Coffee Frontage Road and one concrete paved driveway along Rosedale Highway. Both Coffee Road and Rosedale Highway are improved with concrete curb and gutters, yet only Rosedale Highway is fully developed with a concrete sidewalk. A portion of Coffee Road is improved with a concrete sidewalk. Existing onsite features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds.

Figure 4.1-1: Photos of the Project Site from Coffee Road, Figure 4.1-2: Photo of the Project Site from Rosedale Highway viewing southwest and Figure 4.1-3: Photo of the Project Site from El Toro Viejo Road viewing northeast depict views of the Project Site from surrounding streets.

FIGURE 4.1-1: Photos of the Project Site from Coffee Road

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
Viewing west
Viewing northwest
1 efity
_cuor
— n cP 5
—
fr '
■ - - the
. —
r
F £
- [ i
rerperrew
an es — , • ■ lr
mnudih 2 5
eh ae
... ‘no- jsealleT
wea"
&
: emi ■- and ■ ■ ’
shicsnte
KimleyHorn
t
s a
L == — : "
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-6
This page intentionally left blank.

FIGURE 4.1-2: Photo of the Project Site from Rosedale Highway viewing southwest

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
R.ne
—e
-
aen, Ji )
/
<
p
11 । 51 A
aLHI
III
-
haeCr r u _ dke o -
- ■
e.
— wn
NW
■ws ..
. 1
- < weseshg
R ■
WW
A
w Jl
ullun
KimleyHorn
i
wttns MV
«1W98or 1
GarrelTuckness j 661 631 3811 1
J. Woods. I
j 661 6313907 I
Garret fockness
! 661 613411 I
a
"Ted
1»
4 -pgr
===== 1
ite : -----
R.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-8
This page intentionally left blank.

FIGURE 4.1-3: Photo of the Project Site from El Toro Viejo Road viewing northeast

RIVERVIEW MARKETPLACE COMMERCIAL PROJECT
i
E ’ I il..-
mpeu
.1' Wpmmppn “I I l
wtEb ft Jail Emi 1
e
/
_ -
ne
, < ft peogte V y VO07
A
■ a ng 9
: ht * ' (hatt ss -
yt cld1 X* < YI ft' see (
T . I . y 25), tore ter \ AAAwM ■
Ar — -. 4 — \ \
2 ylon.

Ege. -
l
hiatielui
KimleyHorn
WK -
Maa _Aatst
1-- a)
s
..
■
o
10"
Wale de iesol" Bel
5 —h J ' ;
J i, 2
, 7 374 —
“N Pel 1 " use vels
fhple
ewe
-y 7
5 — mornj, wECwel I' H^V ACahae A. 7
at
0 ...
wlliin —h
Pta
I \
"u.

Amoy g " Lo
t
VPWol, eurne dak : s Nk A ■' aEndR 22
Ww
..
e
a-eruti
. , '• lwd 5 .

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-10
This page intentionally left blank.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-11
Nearby uses include Rosedale Highway and a commercial retail center (Northwest Promenade), to the north; a PG&E electric substation and vacant land to the south; El Toro Viejo Road, commercial retail, and a PG&E electric substation to the west; and Coffee Road, Friant-Kern Canal, and a commercial retail center to the east.

The Golden Empire Transit (GET) District is the main transit agency servicing the City. Currently, GET operates buses on the following three (3) routes within the vicinity of the Project: Route 61, Route 82, and Route 84. Nearby pedestrian facilities include sidewalks along both sides of Rosedale Highway, both sides of Coffee Road north of Jet Way and the west side of Coffee Road south of Jet Way. Pedestrian crosswalks are provided at signalized intersections along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road. Existing Class II Bike Lanes are provided in both directions along Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road
The General Plan land use designation of the Project Site is P (Public Facilities). The Project Site is zoned M-2 (General Manufacturing). The Project applicant is seeking an amendment to the City’s General Plan, changing the Project Site’s designation from P (Public Facilities) to LI (Light Industrial), to facilitate the Project Site’s proposed use and create alignment with the Project Site’s M-2 zoning designation, which under the City’s stacked zoning code allows, by right, all uses are permitted under the commercial designations. Therefore, to proceed with the Project and its proposed uses and to provide consistency with the Project site’s M-2 zoning designation, the LI designation has been determined to be the appropriate land use designation.

4.1.3 Impact Analysis
Methodology
The following thresholds of significance are based on the Environmental Checklist contained in Appendix G of the CEQA Guidelines. The effects of the Project on aesthetics were qualitatively assessed. The effects of the proposed Project were considered in relation to existing aesthetic resources in the Project area, including scenic vistas and the architecture of surrounding buildings.

Thresholds of Significance
The City utilizes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, Appendix G, and thresholds of significance1to analyze the environmental impacts of the Project. Per CEQA Guidelines, an impact is considered significant if the Project would:
• Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista.
• Substantially damage scenic resources, including, but not limited to, trees, rock outcroppings, and historic buildings within a state scenic highway. • In nonurbanized areas, substantially degrade the existing visual character or quality of public views of the site and its surroundings. (Public views are those that are experienced from publicly accessible vantage point). In an urbanized area, the project would conflict with applicable zoning and other regulations governing scenic quality. 1 Association of Environmental Professionals (AEP). 2025. CEQA Guidelines Appendices, Appendix G: Environmental Checklist Form. Available at: https://www.califaep.org/docs/CEQA_Handbook_2025combined.pdf. Accessed January 2026.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-12
• Create a new source of substantial light or glare which would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area.

Project Impacts
Threshold AES-1: Would the project have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista? Impact Analysis
A scenic vista is considered a view that has remarkable or unique scenery or resources that are indigenous to a specific area. The Project Site is largely undeveloped and onsite features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds. The Project does not contain any special or unique scenic attributes, like rock outcroppings, native vegetation, or a substantial number of mature trees.

The Project Site is not located in an area designated as scenic in the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan, it is not within the City’s Hillside Development Combining Zone and is not within a City-designated Class I or II Visual Resource Area, Viewshed, or Slope Protection Area. The Project is not situated in one of the areas the City has recognized as featuring scenic vistas or along a scenic route as identified in the City’s General Plan. Accordingly, the Project would not block a view corridor of a scenic resource.

The construction of commercial uses at the Project Site would be in character and compatible with existing urban land uses in the vicinity of the Project Site and is a natural extension of the urban growth occurring in the Project area. The Project, once developed, would improve the visual conditions on the Project Site. The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. (See Figure 5: Renderings). Building materials would include but not be limited to cement plaster with stone veneer, aluminum wood siding metal canopies, and large display windows. Careful and judicial use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site. Along the Coffee Road frontage and Rosedale Highway frontages would run a “dry creek” feature composed of decorative cobbles, decomposed granite and crushed rocks. The Project would feature new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience, and provide shade. Therefore, the Project would not have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista, and impacts are less than significant.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
Less than significant with no mitigation required.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-13
Threshold AES-2: Would the project substantially damage scenic resources, including, but not limited to, trees, rock outcroppings, and historic buildings within a state scenic highway?
Impact Analysis
The Project Site is located within an urban area, surrounded by existing development. According to the Caltrans California State Scenic Highway System Map, the Project Site is not located within a scenic highway. The nearest eligible State scenic highway in Kern County is the Cuyama Highway State Route 166 (SR 166) located approximately 40-miles southwest of the Project Site.

Thus, implementation of the Project would result in no impacts associated with views from a State scenic highway. No impact would occur.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Threshold AES-3: Would the project, if in nonurbanized areas, substantially degrade the existing visual character or quality of public views of the site and its surroundings? (Public views are those that are experienced from publicly accessible vantage point). If the project is in an urbanized area, would the project conflict with applicable zoning and other regulations governing scenic quality?
Impact Analysis
Because the Project site is located in an “urbanized area” and is planned for urban uses by the City’s General Plan, this evaluation focuses on the Project’s compatibility with or potential conflict with applicable policies and regulations contained in the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan and Municipal Code. As discussed in Table 4.11-1, General Plan Consistency within EIR Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning, the Project would be consistent with the goals and policies of the General Plan as it related to new commercial development. The Project proposes to transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would provide a visual improvement to the Project Site compared to existing conditions. The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. Buildings would have a maximum height of 90 feet (60 feet below the maximum building height for the M-2 zoning district). Building materials would include but not be limited to cement plaster with stone veneer, aluminum wood siding metal canopies, and large display windows. Use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site.

Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience and provide shade. The Project would also include enhanced paving areas within small plaza areas, in front of storefronts and enhanced vehicle paving at entry points. Along the Coffee Road Frontage and Rosedale Highway frontages would run a “dry creek” feature composed of decorative cobbles and decomposed granite and crushed rocks.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-14
The Project would feature 325,120 square feet of new landscaping along the entire site perimeter and internal to the Project Site. Landscaping would include a variety of ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover that would help soften the massing of the buildings, provide for a pedestrian oriented experience and provide shade. Within the parking lot area would be 443 trees and The Project would include 122 street trees (79 trees provided on Coffee Road and 43 on Rosedale Highway) plus 534 trees in within the Project Site for a total of 656 trees. Types of trees would include Marina Strawberry tree, Western Redbud, Chinese Flame tree, Canary Island Pine, California Sycamore, Coast Live Oak, Holly Oak, Cork Oak, Interior Live Oak, Brisbane Box, Chinese Elm, and Majestic Beauty Indian Hawthorn. The Project’s landscape plan complies with BMC Chapter 17.61, including drought-tolerant plant selection.

Accordingly, the Project, would comply with the applicable zoning requirements pertaining to scenic quality and impacts would be less than significant.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
Less than significant with no mitigation required.

Threshold AES-4: Would the project create a new source of substantial light or glare which would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area? Impact Analysis
The Project Site is located in an urbanized area of the City, which includes nighttime lighting associated with the surrounding land uses. This includes street lighting, parking lot lighting, and lights from vehicles. Nearby light sensitive receptors consist of residential developments to the west, southwest, and north of the Project Site.

Construction activities would be limited to daytime hours per BMC Section 9.22.050: 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Friday, and 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM on weekends and holidays.

Construction activities would not require nighttime illumination. Daytime construction equipment may produce temporary glare from metal surfaces; however, these effects would be short-term, intermittent, localized to the Project Site, and typical of construction activities in urbanized areas.

As construction would not occur outside permitted hours and would not require nighttime lighting, construction-related light and glare impacts would be less than significant.

Operational lighting for the Project is intended to minimize light trespass and glare from the Project Site onto adjacent properties and to provide safety and nighttime visibility through shielded, focused, and directed illumination. Lighting would consist of exterior building-mounted light fixtures; interior lighting for the new building; lighting for pedestrian walkways and common gathering areas; lighting for the green spaces; ground-mounted decorative lighting for landscape and architectural features; signage lighting; lighting for the new parking areas, drive aisles, and loading dock areas; and security lighting.

The Project is anticipated to require a number of sign types that would help identify and promote the Project and its businesses and tenants. Sign types would include multi-tenant pylon and monument signs, project identification monument signs, tenant wall signs, and onsite directional and legal signs.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-15
All new light sources associated with the Project would be required to comply with the Bakersfield Municipal Code for exterior lighting standards, which prevent light spillover, glare, nuisance, inconvenience, or hazardous interference of any kind on adjacent properties and streets.

Mandatory compliance with the Bakersfield Municipal Code would ensure that the Project’s light fixtures and signage would not introduce any design features that would cause artificial light or glare to an extent that would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area. Thus, potential lighting and glare impacts would be less than significant.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
Less than significant with no mitigation required.

Cumulative Impacts
Impact Analysis
Potential cumulative impacts would occur if the Project, in combination with the identified cumulative projects, would result in significant effects to aesthetics. For purposes of this analysis, the geographic scope would be the viewshed or area surrounding the Project site within view of surrounding observers.

As discussed in Table 4.11-1, General Plan Consistency within EIR Section 4.11, Land Use and Planning, the Project would be consistent with the goals and policies of the General Plan as it related to new commercial development. The Project proposes to transform an underutilized site into an active infill commercial center that would provide a visual improvement to the Project Site compared to existing conditions. The Project would have a contemporary architectural design with articulated facades. Buildings would have a maximum height of 90 feet (60 feet below the maximum building height for the M-2 zoning district). Building materials would include, but not be limited to, cement plaster with stone veneer, aluminum wood siding, metal canopies, and large display windows. Use of landmark buildings, as well as signage, distinctive landscape palettes, and other such elements would provide an identity and cohesiveness to the Project Site.

The Project would be consistent with the height and uses of nearby development. In addition, the Project is not near a scenic highway. Furthermore, the Project would comply with the applicable zoning requirements pertaining to scenic quality. The Project would not impact scenic vistas, scenic resources, nor would result in degradation of the existing scenic quality or character of the surrounding area. The Project would introduce additional nighttime lighting; however, the proposed light sources would be consistent with existing regulations pertaining to lighting and signage. Regardless, as none of the cumulative projects are located within the viewshed of the Project there would be no cumulative impacts to aesthetic resources.

Mitigation Measures
No mitigation measures are required as impacts would be less than significant.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
Not applicable. Project-specific impacts would be less than significant and there would be no cumulative impacts related to aesthetics.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.1 Aesthetics
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.1-16
This page intentionally left blank.

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-1

4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources
This section discusses impacts associated with the potential for the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project) to degrade or result in the loss of existing agricultural uses, forest land, or timberland. Potential effects are evaluated relative to the Project’s potential to convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance for non-agricultural use; conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act Contract; conflict with existing zoning for, or cause rezoning of, forest land or timberland zoned Timberland Production; result in the loss of forest land or conversion of forest land to non-forest use; or involve other changes in the existing environment that, due to their location or nature, could result in conversion of farmland to non-agricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use.

Information in this section is based, in part, on farmland and Williams Act mapping provided by the California Department of Conservation (DOC), the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan (General Plan), and the Bakersfield Municipal Code – Title 17 (Zoning Ordinance).

During the scoping period for the Project’s Environmental Impact Report (EIR), no comments were received in response to the Notice of Preparation (NOP) related to agriculture and forest resources.

4.2.1 Regulatory Setting
Federal
Farmland Protection and Policy Act
The Farmland Protection and Policy Act (FPPA) (7 United States Code [U.S.C.] § 4201 et seq.), was enacted in 1981 to minimize the loss of prime and unique farmlands due to federal actions converting these lands to nonagricultural uses. It ensures that federal programs are consistent with state, local, and private programs and policies to protect farmland.

State
Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program
Pursuant to section 65570 of the Government Code, the DOC Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program (FMMP) compiles important farmland maps for the state. These maps combine soil survey and current land use information to provide an inventory of agricultural resources in each county. These maps are based on data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture and Natural Resources Conservation Service. The maps show urbanized lands and a qualitative sequence of agricultural designations. County, state, and federal agencies have established the following classifications of important agricultural land based on factors such as soil characteristics, climate, and water supply:
• Prime Farmland. This land has the best combination of physical and chemical features and can sustain long-term agricultural production. The land has the soil quality, growing season, and moisture supply needed to produce sustained high yields, and it also must have been used for irrigated agricultural production at some time during the four years prior to the mapping date.
• Farmland of Statewide Importance. Similar to Prime Farmland but with minor shortcomings, such as greater slopes or less ability to store soil moisture. The land must Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-2
have been used for irrigated agricultural production at some time during the four years prior to the mapping date.
• Unique Farmland. This land has lesser-quality soils used for the production of the state’s leading agricultural crops. This land is usually irrigated but may include non-irrigated orchards or vineyards. Land must also have been cultivated at some time during the four years prior to the mapping date.
• Farmland of Local Importance. Land of importance to the local economy, as defined by each county’s local advisory committee and adopted by its board of supervisors. This refers to all farmable lands in the county that do not meet the definitions of Prime, Statewide Importance, or Unique farmland. This includes land that is or has been used for irrigated pasture, dryland farming, confined livestock and dairy, poultry facilities, aquaculture, and grazing land.
• Grazing Land. This land has existing vegetation that is suited to livestock grazing. This category was developed in cooperation with the California Cattlemen’s Association, University of California Cooperative Extension, and other groups interested in the extent of grazing activities. The minimum mapping unit for Grazing Land is 40 acres. • Urban and Built-Up Land. This land is occupied by structures with a building density of at least one unit to 1.5 acres, or approximately six structures to a 10-acre parcel. This land is used for residential, industrial, commercial, construction, institutional, public administration, railroad, and other transportation yards, cemeteries, airports, golf courses, sanitary landfills, sewage treatment, water control structures, and other developed purposes.
• Semi-Agricultural and Rural Commercial Land. This land includes farmsteads, agricultural storage and packing sheds, unpaved parking areas, composting facilities, equine facilities, firewood lots, and campgrounds.
• Other Land. This land is not included in any other mapping category. Common examples of this type of land include low-density rural developments; brush, timber, wetland, and riparian areas not suitable for livestock grazing; confined livestock, poultry, or aquaculture facilities; strip mines or borrow pits; and water bodies smaller than 40 acres. Vacant and nonagricultural land greater than 40 acres and surrounded on all sides by urban development is mapped as Other Land.

Note that CEQA analysis focuses on impacts to three categories of mapped farmland - Prime Farmland, Farmland of Statewide Importance, and Unique Farmland. In this section, the term “mapped important farmland” refers to these three categories of farmland combined.

California Land Conservation Act (Williamson Act)
The California Land Conservation Act, or Williamson Act, (Gov Code §§ 51200 et seq.) was adopted in 1965. The Act was established to encourage the preservation of agricultural lands in view of the increasing trend toward their “premature and unnecessary” urbanization. The Act enables counties and cities to designate agricultural preserves (Williamson Act lands) and offer preferential taxation to agricultural landowners based on the land’s income-producing value. In return for the preferential tax rate, the landowner is required to sign a contract (Williamson contract) with the applicable county or city agreeing not to develop the land for a minimum of 10 years. The contract is renewed automatically on its anniversary date unless a notice of nonrenewal or petition for cancellation is filed. Any land held in a Williamson Act contract will have Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-3
to be filed for nonrenewal and the contract will have to be allowed to expire before any development occurs on it.

Local
Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan
The General Plan, Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan, dated December 2002, was updated in January 2016 per Resolution No. 018-16 and 019-16. At the time this EIR was published for public review, the City was in the process of updating its General Plan, but it had not yet been adopted. The General Plan includes goals, policies, and directions to achieve the City’s vision of the community and future development. The General Plan includes 12 elements that focus on:

Land Use; Circulation; Housing; Conservation; Noise; Safety; Downtown Redevelopment; Public Services Facilities; Parks; Kern River Plan; Open Space; and Historical Resources.

The General Plan established the following goal and , policies in order to protect the City’s agriculture and forestry resources.

Land Use Element
LU/G-P-77 Allow for the continuance of agricultural uses in area designated for future urban growth (I-1).

LU/G-P-80 Assure that General Plan Amendment proposals for the conversion of designated agricultural lands to urban development occur in an orderly and logical manner giving full consideration to the effect on existing agricultural areas (I-15).

Conservation Element
CON/SA-G-1 Provide for the planned management, conservation, and wise utilization of agricultural land in the planning area.

CON/SA-G-2 Promote soil conservation and minimize development of prime agricultural land as defined by the following criteria:
• Capability Class I and/or II irrigated soils
• 80-100 Storie Index rating
• Gross crop return of $200 or more per acre per year
• Annual carrying capacity of 1 animal unit per acre per year CON/SA-G-3 Establish urban development patterns and practices that promote soil conservation and that protected areas of agricultural production of food and fiber crops, and nursery products.

CON/SA-P-1 Determine the extent and location of all prime agricultural land within the study area (I-1).

CON/SA-P-2 Review projects that propose subdividing or urbanizing prime agricultural land to ascertain how continued commercial agricultural production in the project vicinity will be affected (I-2).

CON/SA-P-3 Protected areas designated for agricultural use, which include Class I and II agricultural soils having surface delivery water Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-4
systems, from the encroachment or resident and commercial subdivision activities (I-2).

CON/SA-P-4 Monitor the amount of prime agricultural land taken out of production for urban uses or added within the plan area (1-3).

CON/SA-P-8 Encourage agricultural uses to employ soil conservation measures to prevent erosion (1-4, 1-7).

CON/SA-P-9 Protect prime agricultural lands against unplanned urban development by adopting agricultural zoning, agricultural land use designations, and by encouraging use of the Williamson Act and the Farmland Security Zone Program and policies that provide tax and economic incentives to ensure the long-term retention of agricultural lands (1-5).

CON/SA-P-10 Encourage landowners to retain their lands in agricultural production (1-6).

CON/SA-P-14 When considering proposals to convert designated agricultural lands to nonagricultural use, the decision-making body of the City and County shall evaluate the following factors to determine the appropriateness of the proposal:
• Soil quality
• Availability of irrigation water
• Proximity to non-agricultural uses
• Proximity to intensive parcelization
• Effect on properties subject to "Williamson Act" land use contracts. • Ability to be provided with urban services (sewer, water, roads, etc.) • Ability to affect the application of agricultural chemicals on nearby agricultural properties • Ability to create a precedent-setting situation that leads to the premature conversion of prime agricultural lands
• Demonstrated project need
• Necessity of buffers such as lower densities, setbacks, etc. (1-8) CON/AQ-G-4 Reduce air pollution associated with agricultural activities.

City of Bakersfield Land Use Zoning Ordinance
The City’s Zoning Ordinance is included in Title 17 of the Bakersfield Municipal Code. The Zoning Ordinance implements the goals and policies of the General Plan, which serve to promote and protect the public health, safety, peace, morals, comfort, convenience and general welfare. The Zoning Ordinance assists in providing a definite plan of development for the City and to guide, control and regulate the future growth of the city in accordance with the General Plan. The Zoning Ordinance also is intended to protect the established character and the social and economic Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-5
stability of agricultural, residential, commercial, industrial and other areas within the city, and to assure the orderly and beneficial development of such areas.

4.2.2 Environmental Setting
As described in Chapter 2, Project Description, the Project Site is located in the northwestern portion of the City of Bakersfield. The approximately 46.16 acre Project site, which consists of one legal parcel (APN 368-010-05) and is an undeveloped L-shaped property situated along the south side of Rosedale Highway, north of railroad tracks, west of Coffee Road, and east of El Toro Viejo Road. The Project Site is located on a portion of a larger property formerly occupied by the PG&E Kern Power Plant. Existing on-site features include abandoned oil wells; electrical transmission lines on metal poles, towers, and wooden poles; and several dirt roads and mounds.

Development of the Project site would include construction and operation of a commercial retail center that would encompass approximately 405,531 square feet of total building space. The specific businesses and/or tenants that would ultimately occupy each of the buildings are not fully known at this time. However, it is assumed that larger interior anchor buildings within the Project Site, would be occupied by markets, retail uses, storage uses, and a health club. The outer building pads would be occupied by smaller retail tenants, a medical office, drive-thrus, fast casual and sit-down restaurants, a car wash, and a gas station with 20 dual-sided pumps.

The General Plan designates the Project Site as P (Public Facilities), and the Zoning Ordinance zones the Project Site as M-2 (General Manufacturing). The Project would include an amendment to the City’s General Plan, changing the Project Site’s designation from P to LI (Light Industrial), to facilitate the Project Site’s proposed use and create alignment with the Project Site’s M-2 zoning designation, which, under the City’s stacked zoning code, allows, by right, all uses permitted under the C-O (Professional and Administrative Office), C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial) and C-2 (Regional Commercial) zones. Therefore, the LI designation has been determined to be the appropriate land use designation.

The DOC FMMP prepares and maintains Important Farmland Series Maps, including the California Important Farmland Finder. As discussed under Section 4.2.1, Regulatory Setting, agricultural land is rated according to soil quality and irrigation status, where the best quality land is designated as Prime Farmland. In preparing these maps, the DOC considers all information collected or received on the amount of land converted to or from agricultural use, and between agricultural categories. According to the California Important Farmland Finder, the Project Site consists of land designated as “Vacant and Disturbed Land.” 1 The Project Site is generally
surrounded by land designated as “Vacant and Disturbed Land” as well as “Urban and Built-Up Land.” A parcel directly west of the Project Site contains land designated as “Semi-agricultural and Rural Commercial Land,” and a parcel directly south of the BNSF railroad is designated as “Grazing Land.” The closest protected farmland to the Project Site is an approximately 14-acre site designated as “Prime Farmland,” located approximately 1.75 miles southwest of the Project, separated by “Urban and Built-Up Land.” Notably, a large area of “Prime Farmland” and “Farmland of Statewide Importance” is located approximately 3.4 miles northwest of the Project Site, where the urban uses associated with the City of Bakersfield terminates.2 1 California Department of Conservation (DOC). 2022. California Important Farmland Finder. Available at:
https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/dlrp/ciff/. Accessed January 2026. 2 California Department of Conservation (DOC). 2022. California Important Farmland Finder. Available at:
https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/dlrp/ciff/. Accessed January 2026.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-6

4.2.3 Impact Analysis
Methodology
The effects of the Project on agriculture and forestry resources were assessed qualitatively. The analysis included identifying farmlands and timberlands employing mapping applications made available to the public by the State and assessing the potential effects of the proposed Project on these resources.

Thresholds of Significance
The City utilizes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, Appendix G, and thresholds of significance3to analyze the environmental impacts of the Project. Per CEQA Guidelines, an impact is considered significant if the Project would:
• Convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance (Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California Resources Agency, to non-agricultural use. • Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract. • Conflict with existing zoning for, or cause rezoning of, forest land (as defined in Public Resources Code Section 12220(g)), timberland (as defined by Public Resources Code Section 4526), or timberland zoned Timberland Production (as defined by Government Code Section 51104(g)).
• Result in the loss of forest land or conversion of forest land to non-forest use. • Involve other changes in the existing environment which, due to their location or nature, could result in conversion of Farmland, to non-agricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use.

Project Impacts
Threshold AG-1: Would the project convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance (Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California Resources Agency, to non-agricultural use? Impact Analysis
Based on a review of the California Important Farmland Finder, neither the Project Site nor any adjacent land is designated as Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance. Instead, the Project Site and adjacent land are designated as “Vacant and Disturbed Land” and “Urban and Built-Up Land,” with the exception of an approximately 17-acre parcel of “Semi-Agricultural and Rural Commercial Land,” which is not considered protected farmland. As such, the Project would not convert any Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance to a non-agricultural use. Therefore, there would be no impact, and no mitigation would be required.

Mitigation Measures
3 Association of Environmental Professionals (AEP). 2025. CEQA Guidelines Appendices, Appendix G: Environmental Checklist Form. Available at: https://www.califaep.org/docs/CEQA_Handbook_2025combined.pdf. Accessed January 2026.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-7
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Threshold AG-2: Would the project conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract?
Impact Analysis
The Project site is located within an urban area, surrounded by existing development, and is not currently in use for agricultural activities. As discussed above, the Project Site is zoned as M-2.

Its zoning district designation would not be modified as a result of the Project. Instead, the Project would require a General Plan Amendment (GPA) to change the land use designation to LI to align with its existing zoning. The M-2 zoning district permits a variety of manufacturing and production plants as well as all uses permitted under commercial designations.4 This zoning designation does not allow agricultural uses. Additionally, according to the DOC, the Project Site is not subject to a Williamson Act contract.
5 Therefore, the Project would not cause a conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract, and there would be no impact, and no mitigation is required.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Threshold AG-3: Would the project conflict with existing zoning for, or cause rezoning of, forest land (as defined in Public Resources Code Section 12220(g)), timberland (as defined by Public Resources Code Section 4526), or timberland zoned Timberland Production (as defined by Government Code Section 51104(g))?
Impact Analysis
As discussed under Impact AG-2, the Project Site is zoned as M-2. No portion of the Project site is zoned for forest land, timberland, or timberland production. The Project proposes to redevelop a currently vacant and undeveloped site into a new approximately 405,351 square foot commercial retail center with associated internal vehicle and pedestrian circulation improvements; surface parking areas and drive aisles; landscaping, hardscaping, and green space; and utility improvements consistent with the existing zoning. Therefore, the Project would not cause the rezoning of forest land or timberland, and no impact would occur. As such, no mitigation is required.
4 City of Bakersfield. 2025. Municipal Code. Title 17, Zoning. Chapter 17.30, M-2 General Manufacturing Zone. Available at:
https://bakersfield.municipal.codes/Code/17.30. Accessed January 2026. 5 DOC. 2024. Williamson Act Enrollment Finder. Available at: https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/dlrp/WilliamsonAct/. Accessed January 2026.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-8
Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Threshold AG-4: Would the project result in the loss of forest land or conversion of forest land to non-forest use?
Impact Analysis
As stated in Impact AG-3, above, the Project Site is currently zoned M-2, located within an urbanized area and is surrounded by existing development, and consists of vacant and disturbed land. Neither the Project Site nor its surroundings are zoned for forest land. Therefore, the Project would have no impact to forest land and no mitigation is required.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Threshold AG-5: Would the project involve other changes in the existing environment which, due to their location or nature, could result in conversion of Farmland, to non-agricultural use or conversion of forest land to non-forest use? Impact Analysis
As stated in Impact AG-4 above, the Project Site is in an urbanized area of the City. Additionally, the site is identified as vacant and disturbed land and therefore does not support agricultural resources or operations or forest uses. The Project would not result in the conversion of designated farmland to non-agricultural uses or forest land to non-forestland. There are no agricultural resources or operations, including farmlands, within proximity of the Project Site. As discussed above, the closest parcel designated as “Prime Farmland” is located approximately

1.75 miles southwest of the Project Site with intervening “Urban and Built-Up Land.” As such, the Project would not impact this parcel such that the uses on the parcel would be impacted.

Therefore, no impacts would occur, and no mitigation is required.

Mitigation Measures
None required.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
No impact and no mitigation required.

Cumulative Impacts
Impact Analysis
As discussed in Section 4.2.2, Environmental Setting, excluding the small parcel of “Prime Farmland” located approximately 1.75 miles southwest of the Project Site, the Project is located Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-9
within an area of Bakersfield that is largely designated as “Urban and Built-Up Land” by the DOC.

As previously discussed, large portions of the protected farmland located at the western edge of the City’s “Urban and Built-Up Land,” is approximately 3.4 miles northwest of the Project Site.

Additionally, there are no areas designated as forest land or timberland in the surrounding areas.

Neither the Project nor the cumulative projects are located within a mile of these agricultural areas and would subsequently have no impacts associated with conversion of farmland, conflicts with zoning for agricultural or farmland uses, or result in loss or conversion of forest land or timberland.

Accordingly, there would be no cumulative impacts to these resources.

Mitigation Measures
No mitigation measures are required as the Project would have no direct or cumulative impacts.

Level of Significance After Mitigation
There would be no Project-specific or cumulative impacts related to agriculture, forestland, or timberland.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.2 Agriculture and Forestry Resources City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.2-10
This page intentionally left blank.

City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-1

4.3 Air Quality
This section of the Draft EIR analyzes potential air quality impacts associated with the construction and operation of the Project. The information in this section is based on the detailed air quality analysis, Appendix B, Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, and Energy Technical Study.

During the scoping period for the Project’s EIR, comments were received from the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (District). These comments are included in Appendix A-2:

Notice of Preparation Comments, of this Draft EIR and are summarized below:
• Project Emissions: A more detailed preliminary review of the Project be conducted for the Project’s construction and operational emissions. The District recommends, to reduce impacts from construction-related diesel exhaust emissions, the Project should utilize the cleanest available off-road construction equipment. Operational (ongoing) air emissions from mobile sources and stationary sources should be analyzed separately. • An environmental review should adequately characterize and justify an appropriate trip length distance for off-site Heavy Heavy-Duty (HHD) truck travel to and from the Project site
• Emissions analysis should be performed using the California Emission Estimator Model (CalEEMod), which uses the most recent CARB-approved version of relevant emissions models and emission factors.
• Evaluate the risk associated with the Project for sensitive receptors (residences, businesses, hospitals, day-care facilities, health care facilities, etc.) in the area and mitigate any potentially significant risk to help limit exposure of sensitive receptors to emissions.
• An Ambient Air Quality Analysis (AAQA) uses air dispersion modeling to determine if emissions increases from a project will cause or contribute to a violation of State or National Ambient Air Quality Standards. The District recommends an AAQA be performed for the Project if emissions exceed 100 pounds per day of any pollutant. • A discussion on the feasibility of implementing a Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) is recommended.
• Evaluate HHD truck routing patterns for the Project, with the aim of limiting exposure of residential communities and sensitive receptors to emissions. • Use of cleanest available Heavy-Duty Trucks
• Ensure compliance of the state anti-idling regulation (13 CCR § 2485 and 13 CCR § 2480). • Under-fired charbroilers
• Vegetative barriers and urban greening
• Consider incorporating solar power systems as an emission reduction strategy for the Project.
• Electric Infrastructure
• Consider all available pertinent information to determine if the Project could have a significant impact related to nuisance odors
• District Rules and Regulations
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-2

4.3.1 Regulatory Setting
Federal and State
Ambient Air Quality Standards
The Clean Air Act (CAA) was passed in 1963 by the U.S. Congress and has been amended several times. The 1970 CAA amendments strengthened previous legislation and laid the foundation for the regulatory scheme of the 1970s and 1980s. In 1977, Congress again added several provisions, including nonattainment requirements for areas not meeting National Ambient Air Quality Standards (AAQS) and the Prevention of Significant Deterioration program. The 1990 amendments represent the latest in a series of federal efforts to regulate the protection of air quality in the United States. The CAA allows states to adopt more stringent standards or to include other pollution species. The California Clean Air Act, signed into law in 1988, requires all areas of the state to achieve and maintain the California AAQS by the earliest practical date. The California AAQS tend to be more restrictive than the National AAQS.

These National AAQS and California AAQS are the levels of air quality considered to provide a margin of safety in the protection of the public health and welfare. They are designed to protect “sensitive receptors” most susceptible to further respiratory distress, such as asthmatics, the elderly, very young children, people already weakened by other disease or illness, and persons engaged in strenuous work or exercise. Healthy adults can tolerate occasional exposure to air pollutant concentrations considerably above these minimum standards before adverse effects are observed.

Both California and the federal government have established health-based AAQS for seven air pollutants. As shown in Table 4.3-1, Ambient Air Quality Standards for Criteria Pollutants, these pollutants are ozone (O3), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), sulfur dioxide (SO2), coarse inhalable particulate matter (PM10), fine inhalable particulate matter (PM2.5), and lead (Pb). In addition, the state has set standards for sulfates, hydrogen sulfide, vinyl chloride, and visibility-reducing particles. These standards are designed to protect the health and welfare of the populace with a reasonable margin of safety.

Table 4.3-1 Ambient Air Quality Standards for Criteria Pollutants Pollutant
Averaging
Time
California
Standard1
Federal
Primary
Standard2 Major Pollutant Sources
Ozone (O3)
3 1 hour 0.09 ppm * Motor vehicles, paints, coatings, and solvents. 8 hours 0.070 ppm 0.070 ppm
Carbon
Monoxide (CO)
1 hour 20 ppm 35 ppm Internal combustion engines, primarily gasoline-powered motor vehicles. 8 hours 9.0 ppm 9 ppm
Nitrogen
Dioxide (NO2)
Annual
Arithmetic Mean

0.030 ppm 0.053 ppm Motor vehicles, petroleum-refining operations, industrial sources, aircraft, ships, and railroads.
1 hour 0.18 ppm 0.100 ppm
Sulfur Dioxide
(SO2)
Annual
Arithmetic Mean
* 0.030 ppm Fuel combustion, chemical plants, sulfur recovery plants, and metal processing.
1 hour 0.25 ppm 0.075 ppm
24 hours 0.04 ppm 0.14 ppm
Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-3
Pollutant
Averaging
Time
California
Standard1
Federal
Primary
Standard2 Major Pollutant Sources
Respirable
Coarse
Particulate
Matter
(PM10)
Annual
Arithmetic Mean
20 µg/m3* Dust and fume-producing construction, industrial, and agricultural operations, combustion,
atmospheric photochemical reactions, and natural
activities (e.g., wind-raised dust and ocean
sprays).
24 hours 50 µg/m3 150 µg/m3
Respirable
Fine
Particulate
Matter
(PM2.5)
4,6
Annual
Arithmetic Mean
12 µg/m3 9 µg/m3 Dust and fume-producing construction, industrial, and agricultural operations, combustion,
atmospheric photochemical reactions, and natural
activities (e.g., wind-raised dust and ocean
sprays).
24 hours * 35 µg/m3
Lead (Pb) 30-Day Average 1.5 µg/m3* Present source: lead smelters, battery manufacturing & recycling facilities. Past source:

Calendar Quarter combustion of leaded gasoline. * 1.5 µg/m3 Rolling 3-Month
Average
* 0.15
µg/m3
Sulfates (SO4)
5 24 hours 25 µg/m3
* Industrial processes.

Visibility
Reducing
Particles
8 hours ExCo
=0.23/km
visibility of
10≥ miles
* Visibility-reducing particles consist of suspended
particulate matter, which is a complex mixture of
tiny particles that consists of dry solid fragments,
solid cores with liquid coatings, and small droplets
of liquid. These particles vary greatly in shape,
size and chemical composition, and can be made
up of many different materials such as metals,
soot, soil, dust, and salt.

Hydrogen
Sulfide
1 hour 0.03 ppm * Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is a colorless gas with the odor of rotten eggs. It is formed during bacterial
decomposition of sulfur-containing organic
substances. Also, it can be present in sewer gas
and some natural gas and can be emitted as the
result of geothermal energy exploitation.

Vinyl Chloride 24 hours 0.01 ppm * Vinyl chloride (chloroethene), a chlorinated hydrocarbon, is a colorless gas with a mild, sweet
odor. Most vinyl chloride is used to make polyvinyl
chloride (PVC) plastic and vinyl products. Vinyl
chloride has been detected near landfills, sewage
plants, and hazardous waste sites, due to
microbial breakdown of chlorinated solvents.

Source: CARB 2024.

Notes: ppm: parts per million; μg/m3: micrograms per cubic meter * Standard has not been established for this pollutant/duration by this entity. 1 California standards for O3, CO (except 8-hour Lake Tahoe), SO2 (1 and 24 hour), NO2, and particulate matter (PM10, PM2.5, and visibility reducing particles), are values that are not to be exceeded. All others are not to be equaled or exceeded. California ambient air quality standards are listed in the Table of Standards in Section 70200 of Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations. 2 National standards (other than O3, PM, and those based on annual arithmetic mean) are not to be exceeded more than once a year. The O3 standard is attained when the fourth highest 8-hour concentration measured at each site in a year, averaged over three years, is equal to or less than the standard. For PM10, the 24-hour standard is attained when the expected number of days per calendar year with a 24-hour average concentration above 150 µg/m3 is equal to or less than one. For PM2.5, the 24-hour standard is attained when 98 percent of the daily concentrations, averaged over three years, are equal to or less than the standard.
3 On October 1, 2015, the national 8-hour ozone primary and secondary standards were lowered from 0.075 to 0.070 ppm. 4 On December 14, 2012, the national annual PM2.5 primary standard was lowered from 15 μg/m3 to 12.0 µg/m3. The existing national 24-hour PM2.5 standards (primary and secondary) were retained at 35 µg/m3, as was the annual secondary standard of 15 µg/m3. The existing 24-hour PM10 standards (primary and secondary) of 150 µg/m3 also were retained. The form of the annual primary and secondary standards is the annual mean, averaged over 3 years.
5 On June 2, 2010, a new 1-hour SO2 standard was established, and the existing 24-hour and annual primary standards were revoked. The 1-hour national standard is in units of parts per billion (ppb). California standards are in units of parts per million (ppm). To directly compare the 1-hour national standard to the California standard the units can be converted to ppm. In this case, the national standard of 75 ppb is identical to 0.075 ppm. 6 On February 7, 2024, the national annual PM2.5 standard was lowered from 12 μg/m3 to 9 µg/m3. The existing national 24-hour PM2.5 standards (primary and secondary), secondary annual PM2.5 standard, and PM10 standards (primary and secondary) were retained.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-4
California has also adopted a host of other regulations that reduce criteria pollutant emissions.

Assembly Bill (AB) 1493
Assembly Bill (AB) 1493, sometimes referred to as the “Pavley Bill,” established Fuel Efficiency Standards. Pavley I refers to clean-car standards that reduced greenhouse gas emissions from new passenger vehicles (light-duty auto to medium-duty vehicles) from 2009 through 2016. In January 2012, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) approved the Advanced Clean Cars program (formerly known as Pavley II) for model years 2017 through 2025.

Senate Bill (SB) 1078, SB 107, SB 350. SB 100, and SB 1020: Renewables Portfolio Standards.

A major component of California’s Renewable Energy Program is the renewables portfolio standard (RPS) established under SB 1078 (Sher) and SB 107 (Simitian). Under the RPS, certain retail sellers of electricity were required to increase the amount of renewable energy each year by at least 1 percent to reach at least 20 percent by December 30, 2010. Subsequent RPS requirements include a RPS of 40 percent by 2024 set under SB 350 and RPS requirements of 50 percent by 2026, 60 percent by 2030, and 100 percent by 2045 under SB 100. In addition, SB 1020 sets a RPS requirement of 90 percent by 2035 and 95 percent by 2040. Furthermore, SB 1020 also requires state agencies to procure 100 percent of electricity from renewable energy and zero-carbon resources by 2035.

Heavy-Duty (Tractor-Trailer) Greenhouse Gas Regulation. The owners of tractors and trailers subject to this regulation must either use EPA SmartWay-certified tractors and trailers or retrofit their existing fleet with SmartWay-verified technologies. The regulation applies primarily to owners of 53‐foot or longer box‐type trailers, including both dry‐van and refrigerated‐van trailers, and owners of the heavy‐duty tractors that pull them on California highways. These owners are responsible for replacing or retrofitting their affected vehicles with compliant aerodynamic technologies and low rolling resistance tires. Sleeper cab tractors model year 2011 and later must be SmartWay certified. All other tractors must use SmartWay-verified low-rolling-resistance tires.

There are also requirements for trailers to have low-rolling-resistance tires and aerodynamic devices.

California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 20: Appliance Energy Efficiency Standards.

The 2006 Appliance Efficiency Regulations (20 CCR Sections 1601–1608) were adopted by the California Energy Commission on October 11, 2006, and approved by the California Office of Administrative Law on December 14, 2006. The regulations include standards for both federally regulated appliances and non–federally regulated appliances. 24 CCR, Part 6: Building and Energy Efficiency Standards.

Energy conservation standards for new residential and nonresidential buildings adopted by the California Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission (now the California Energy Commission) in June 1977.
24 CCR, Part 11: Green Building Standards Code.

On July 17, 2008, the California Building Standards Commission adopted the nation’s first green building standards. The California Green Building Standards Code (24 CCR, Part 11), or “CALGreen,” was adopted as part of the California Building Standards Code. CALGreen established planning and design standards for sustainable site development, energy efficiency Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-5
(in excess of the California Energy Code requirements), water conservation, material conservation, and internal air contaminants.1 The mandatory provisions of CALGreen became effective January 1, 2011, and were last updated in 2025. The 2025 CALGreen standards became effective January 1, 2026.

Tanner Air Toxics Act and Air Toxics Hot Spot Information and Assessment Act Public exposure to toxic air contaminants (TACs) is a significant environmental health issue in California. In 1983, the California legislature enacted a program to identify the health effects of TACs and reduce exposure to them. The California Health and Safety Code defines a TAC as “an air pollutant which may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or in serious illness, or which may pose a present or potential hazard to human health” (Health and Safety Code Section 39655). A substance that is listed as a hazardous air pollutant pursuant to Section 112(b) of the federal Clean Air Act (42 US Code Section 112[b]) is a TAC. Under state law, the California Environmental Protection Agency, acting through CARB, is authorized to identify a substance as a TAC if it is an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or serious illness or may pose a present or potential hazard to human health.

California regulates TACs primarily through Assembly Bill (AB) 1807 (Tanner Air Toxics Act) and AB 2588 (Air Toxics “Hot Spot” Information and Assessment Act of 1987). The Tanner Air Toxics Act sets forth a formal procedure for CARB to designate substances as TACs. Once a TAC is identified, CARB adopts an “airborne toxic control measure” for sources that emit designated TACs. If there is a safe threshold for a substance (i.e., a point below which there is no toxic effect), the control measure must reduce exposure to below that threshold. If there is no safe threshold, the measure must incorporate toxic best available control technology to minimize emissions. To date, CARB has established formal control measures for 11 TACs that are identified as having no safe threshold.

Under AB 2588, TAC emissions from individual facilities are quantified and prioritized by the air quality management district or air pollution control district. High-priority facilities are required to perform a health risk assessment, and if specific thresholds are exceeded, they are required to communicate the results to the public through notices and public meetings.

CARB has promulgated the following specific rules to limit TAC emissions:
• 13 CCR Chapter 10 Section 2485: Airborne Toxic Control Measure to Limit Diesel-Fueled Commercial Motor Vehicle Idling. Generally, restricts on-road diesel-powered commercial motor vehicles with a gross vehicle weight rating of greater than 10,000 pounds from idling more than five minutes.
• 13 CCR Chapter 10 Section 2480: Airborne Toxic Control Measure to Limit School Bus Idling and Idling at Schools. Generally, restricts a school bus or transit bus from idling for more than five minutes when within 100 feet of a school. • 13 CCR Section 2477 and Article 8: Airborne Toxic Control Measure for In-Use Diesel-Fueled Transport Refrigeration Units (TRU) and TRU Generator Sets and Facilities Where TRUs Operate. Regulations established to control emissions associated with diesel-powered TRUs. 1 The green building standards became mandatory in the 2010 edition of the code.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-6
AB 617, Community Air Protection Program
AB 617 (C. Garcia, Chapter 136, Statutes of 2017) requires local air districts to monitor and implement air pollution control strategies that reduce localized air pollution in communities that bear the greatest burdens. In response to AB 617, CARB has established the Community Air Protection Program.

Air districts are required to host workshops to help identify disadvantaged communities disproportionately affected by poor air quality. Once the criteria for identifying the highest priority locations has been identified and the communities have been selected, new community monitoring systems would be installed to track and monitor community-specific air pollution goals.

In 2018, CARB prepared an air monitoring plan (Community Air Protection Blueprint), that evaluates the availability and effectiveness of air monitoring technologies and existing community air monitoring networks. Under AB 617, the Blueprint is required to be updated every five years.

Under AB 617, CARB is also required to prepare a statewide strategy to reduce TACs and criteria pollutants in impacted communities; provide a statewide clearinghouse for best available retrofit control technology; adopt new rules requiring the latest best available retrofit control technology for all criteria pollutants for which an area has not achieved attainment of California AAQS; and provide uniform, statewide reporting of emissions inventories. Air districts are required to adopt a community emissions reduction program to achieve reductions for the communities impacted by air pollution that CARB identifies.

Regional/Local
San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD) The state is divided into air pollution control districts/air quality management districts. These agencies are county or regional governing authorities that have primary responsibility for controlling air pollution from stationary sources. CARB and local air districts are also responsible for developing clean air plans to demonstrate how and when California will attain AAQS established under both the federal and California Clean Air Acts. For the areas in California that have not attained air quality standards, CARB works with air districts to develop and implement state and local attainment plans. In general, attainment plans contain a discussion of ambient air quality data and trends; a baseline emissions inventory; future year projections of emissions, which account for growth projections and already adopted control measures; a comprehensive control strategy of additional measures needed to reach attainment; an attainment demonstration, which generally involves complex modeling; and contingency measures. Plans may also include interim milestones for progress toward attainment. The San Joaquin Valley Air Basin (SJVAB) is managed by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD).

The primary role of SJVAPCD is to develop plans and implement control measures in the SJVAB to control air pollution. These controls primarily affect stationary sources such as industry and power plants. Rules and regulations have been developed by SJVAPCD to control air pollution from a wide range of air pollution sources. SJVAPCD also provides uniform procedures for assessing potential air quality impacts of projects and for preparing the air quality section of environmental documents.

Air Quality Management Planning
The EPA requires states that have areas that do not meet the National AAQS to prepare and submit air quality plans showing how the National AAQS will be met. If the states cannot show Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-7
how the National AAQS will be met, then the states must show progress toward meeting the National AAQS. These plans are referred to as the State Implementation Plans (SIP). CARB requires regions that do not meet California AAQS for ozone to submit clean air plans that describe measures to attain the standard or show progress toward attainment. The following describes the air quality management plans (AQMP) prepared by the SJVAPCD, which are incorporated by reference per CEQA Guidelines Section 15150:
• 2022 Plan for the 2015 8-Hour Ozone Standard. SJVAPCD adopted the 2022 plan for the 2015 8-hour ozone standard in December 2022. This plan satisfies CAA requirements and ensures expeditious attainment of the 70 parts per billion (ppb) 8-hour ozone standard. • 2016 Plan for the 2008 8-Hour Ozone Standard. SJVAPCD adopted the 2016 plan for the 2008 8 hour ozone standard in June 2016. This plan satisfies CAA requirements and ensures expeditious attainment of the 75 ppb 8-hour ozone standard. • 2014 Reasonably Available Control Technology (RACT) SIP. SJVAPCD adopted the RACT demonstration for ozone SIP in June 2014.
• 2013 Plan for the Revoked 1-Hour Ozone Standard. SJVAPCD adopted the 2013 Plan for the Revoked 1-hour ozone standard in September 2013. In 2013, the Valley had zero violations of the 1-hour federal ozone standard. On May 6, 2014, and July 13, 2015, SJVAPCD submitted formal requests that the EPA determine that the Valley has attained the federal 1-hour ozone standard. On July 18, 2016, the EPA published in the Federal Register a final action determining that the San Joaquin Valley has attained the 1 hour ozone National AAQS.
• 2009 Reasonably Available Control Technology (RACT) SIP. SJVAPCD adopted the RACT demonstration for ozone SIP in April 2009.
• 2007 Ozone Plan. SJVAPCD adopted the 2007 Ozone Plan in April 2007. This plan addresses the EPA’s 8-hour ozone standard of 84 ppb, which was established in 1997. • 2015 8-Hour Ozone Standard. The EPA set the National AAQS for 8-hour ozone at 70 ppb effective December 28, 2015. The EPA designated the San Joaquin Valley as Extreme nonattainment for this standard in August 2018, with an attainment deadline of 2037. SJVACPD was mandated under federal CAA requirements to develop a new attainment plan for the revised ozone standard by 2022. Despite the significant air quality progress that has been made in the Valley, addressing the 2015 8-hour ozone standard will pose a challenge for the San Joaquin Valley given the naturally high background ozone levels and ozone transport into the Valley. Significant further emissions reductions will be needed to come into attainment of the stringent new standard. This will require concerted ongoing effort by the SJVAPCD working closely with Valley residents, businesses, and other stakeholders to continue implementing effective and efficient air quality measures. The attainment plan for the 2015 federal ozone standard will build upon comprehensive strategies already in place from adopted SJVAPCD plans and CARB statewide strategies. The NOx reduction commitments from the recent 2018 PM2.5 Plan, 2016 Ozone Plan, and other ongoing measures will assist the Valley in meeting the 70 ppb federal ozone standard. Strategies for attainment of the 2015 8-hour ozone standard will be developed through a public process, building on decades of effective control strategies.
• 2018 Plan for the 1997, 2006, and 2012 PM2.5 Standards. SJVAPCD adopted the 2018 Plan for the 1997, 2006, and 2012 PM2.5 Standards on November 15, 2018. This plan Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-8
addresses the EPA federal 1997 annual PM2.5 standard of 15 μg/m³ and 24-hour PM2.5 standard of 65 μg/m³, the 2006 24-hour PM2.5 standard of 35 μg/m³, and the 2012 annual PM2.5 standard of 12 μg.
• 2016 Moderate Area Plan for the 2012 PM2.5 Standard. SJVAPCD adopted the 2016 Moderate Area Plan for the 2012 PM2.5 standard on September 15, 2016. This plan addresses the EPA federal annual PM2.5 standard of 12 µg/m3, established in 2012. This plan includes an attainment impracticability demonstration and request for reclassification of the Valley from Moderate nonattainment to Serious nonattainment. • 2015 Plan for the 1997 PM2.5 Standard. SJVAPCD adopted the 2015 Plan for the 1997 PM2.5 standard on April 16, 2015. This plan addresses the EPA’s annual PM2.5 standard of 15 µg/m3 and 24-hour PM2.5 standard of 65 µg/m3, established in 1997. • 2012 PM2.5 Plan. SJVAPCD adopted the 2012 PM2.5 Plan in December 2012. This plan addresses the EPA’s 24-hour PM2.5 standard of 35 µg/m³, which was established by in 2006.
• 2008 PM2.5 Plan. SJVAPCD adopted the 2008 PM2.5 Plan in April 2008. This plan addresses the EPA’s annual PM2.5 standard of 15 µg/m³, which was established in 1997. • 2007 PM10 Maintenance Plan. SJVAPCD adopted the 2007 PM10 Maintenance Plan in September 2007 to ensure the San Joaquin Valley’s continued attainment of the EPA’s PM10 standard. The EPA designated the Valley as an attainment/maintenance area for PM10.
• 2004 Revision to the California SIP for Carbon Monoxide. On July 22, 2004, CARB approved an update to the SIP that shows how the ten areas will maintain the standard through 2018, revises emission estimates, and establishes new on-road motor vehicle emission budgets for transportation conformity purposes.

SJVAPCD Local Rules and Regulations
Assembly Bill 170, Reyes
AB 170 was adopted by State lawmakers in 2003, creating Government Code Section 65302.1, which requires cities and counties in the San Joaquin Valley to amend their general plans to include data, analysis, and comprehensive goals, policies, and feasible implementation strategies designed to improve air quality. The elements to be amended include, but are not limited to, the elements dealing with land use, circulation, housing, conservation, and open space. Section 65302.1(c) identifies four areas of air quality discussion required in these amendments:
• A report describing local air quality conditions, attainment status, and State and federal air quality and transportation plans.
• A summary of local, district, State, and federal policies, programs, and regulations to improve air quality.
• A comprehensive set of goals, policies, and objectives to improve air quality. • Feasible implementation measures designed to achieve these goals.

Rule 9510: Indirect Source Review
On December 15, 2005, SJVAPCD adopted the Indirect Source Review Rule (or Rule 9510) to reduce ozone precursors (i.e., VOC and NOX) and PM10 emissions from new land use Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-9
development projects. Specifically, Rule 9510 targets the indirect emissions from vehicles and construction equipment associated with these projects and applies to both construction- and operational-related impacts. The rule applies to any applicant that seeks to gain a final discretionary approval for a development project, or any portion thereof, which upon full buildout would include any one of the following:
• 50 residential units.
• 2,000 square feet of commercial space.
• 25,000 square feet of light industrial space.
• 100,000 square feet of heavy industrial space.
• 20,000 square feet of medical office space.
• 39,000 square feet of general office space.
• 9,000 square feet of educational space.
• 10,000 square feet of government space.
• 20,000 square feet of recreational space.
• 9,000 square feet of space not identified above.
• Transportation/transit projects with construction exhaust emissions of 2 or more tons of NOx or 2 or more tons of PM10.
• Residential projects on contiguous or adjacent property under common ownership of a single entity, in whole or in part, that is designated and zoned for the same development density and land use, regardless of the number of tract maps, and has the capability of accommodating more than 50 residential units.
• Nonresidential projects on contiguous or adjacent property under common ownership of a single entity, in whole or in part, that is designated and zoned for the same development density and land use, and has the capability of accommodating development projects that emit 2 or more tons per year of NOX or PM10 during project operations.

The rule requires all subject, nonexempt projects to mitigate both construction and operational period emissions by (1) applying feasible SJVAPCD-approved mitigation measures, or (2) paying any applicable fees to support programs that reduce emissions. Off-site emissions reduction fees (off-site fees) are required for projects that do not achieve the required emissions reductions through on-site emission reduction measures. Phased projects can defer payment of fees in accordance with an Offsite Emissions Reduction Fee Deferral Schedule (FDS) approved by the SJVAPCD.

To determine how an individual project would satisfy Rule 9510, each project would submit an air quality impact assessment (AIA) to the SJVAPCD as early as possible, but no later than prior to the project’s final discretionary approval, to identify the project’s baseline unmitigated emissions inventory for indirect sources from: (1) on-site exhaust emissions from construction activities; and (2) operational activities from mobile and area sources of emissions (excludes fugitive dust and permitted sources). Rule 9510 requires the following reductions, which are levels that the SJVAPCD has identified as necessary, based on its air quality management plans, to reach attainment for ozone and particulate matter.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-10
• Construction Equipment Emissions. The exhaust emissions for construction equipment greater than 50 horsepower (hp) used or associated with the development project shall be reduced by the following amounts from the statewide average as estimated by CARB:
• 20 percent of the total NOX emissions
• 45 percent of the total PM10 exhaust emissions
• Mitigation measures may include those that reduce construction emissions on-site by using less-polluting construction equipment, which can be achieved by utilizing add-on controls; cleaner fuels; or newer, lower-emitting equipment. • Operational Emissions
• NOx Emissions. Applicants shall reduce 33.3 percent of the project’s operational baseline NOX emissions over a period of 10 years as quantified in the approved AIA. • PM10 Emissions. Applicants shall reduce of 50 percent of the project’s operational baseline PM10 emissions over a period of 10 years as quantified in the approved AIA.

Mitigation measures may include those that reduce construction emissions on-site by using less-polluting construction equipment, which can be achieved by utilizing add-on controls; cleaner fuels; or newer, lower-emitting equipment.

These requirements can be met through any combination of on-site emission reduction measures.

In the event that a project cannot achieve the above standards through imposition of mitigation measures, the project would be required to pay the applicable off-site fees. These fees are used to fund various incentive programs that cover the purchase of new equipment, engine retrofit, and education and outreach.

Rule 2201: New and Modified Stationary Source Review
SJVAPCD adopted Rule 2201, New and Modified Stationary Source Review, to control emissions from new stationary sources and all modifications to existing stationary sources that are subject to SJVAPCD’s permit requirements (i.e., “permit projects” for which the SJVAPCD is the lead agency). Permit projects that exceed the Source Performance Standards are required to install Best Available Control Technology to control emissions to the maximum extent practicable.

Regulation VIII: Fugitive PM10 Prohibitions
SJVAPCD controls fugitive PM10 through Regulation VIII, Fugitive PM10 Prohibitions. The purpose of this regulation is to reduce ambient concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 by requiring actions to prevent, reduce, or mitigate anthropogenic (human caused) fugitive dust emissions. • Regulation VIII, Rule 8021, applies to any construction, demolition, excavation, extraction, and other earthmoving activities, including but not limited to land clearing, grubbing, scraping, travel on-site, and travel on access roads to and from the site. • Regulation VIII, Rule 8031, applies to the outdoor handling, storage, and transport of any bulk material.
• Regulation VIII, Rule 8041, applies to sites where carryout or trackout has occurred or may occur on paved roads or the paved shoulders of public roads. • Regulation VIII, Rule 8051, applies to any open area having 0.5 acre or more in urban areas or 3.0 acres or more in rural areas and contains at least 1,000 square feet of disturbed surface area.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-11
• Regulation VIII, Rule 8061, applies to any new or existing public or private paved or unpaved road, road construction project, or road modification project. • Regulation VIII, Rule 8071, applies to any unpaved vehicle/equipment traffic area. • Regulation VIII, Rule 8081, applies to off-field agricultural sources.

Sources regulated are required to provide Dust Control Plans that meet the regulation requirements. Under Rule 8021, a Dust Control Plan is required for any residential project that will include 10 or more acres of disturbed surface area, a nonresidential project with 5 or more acres of disturbed surface area, or a project that relocates 2,500 cubic yards per day of bulk materials for at least three days. The Dust Control Plan is required to be submitted to SJVAPCD prior to the start of any construction activity. The Dust Control Plan must also describe fugitive dust control measure to be implemented before, during, and after any dust-generating activity.

For sites smaller than those listed above, the project is still required to notify SJVAPCD a minimum of 48 hours prior to commencing earthmoving activities.

Rule 4102: Nuisance Odors
The SJVAPCD controls nuisance odors through implementation of Rule 4102, Nuisance.

Pursuant to this rule,
“... a person shall not discharge from any source whatsoever such quantities of air contaminants or other materials which cause injury, detriment, nuisance or annoyance to any considerable number of persons or to the public or which endanger the comfort, repose, health, or safety of any such person or the public or which cause or have a natural tendency to cause injury or damage to business or property.”
Rule 9410: Employer Based Trip Reduction Program
The SJVAPCD has implemented Rule 9410, Employer Based Trip Reduction. The purpose of this rule is to reduce vehicle miles traveled (VMT) from private vehicles used by employees to commute to and from their worksites and, in turn, reduce emissions of NOx, VOC, and particulate matter (PM10 and PM2.5). The rule applies to employers with at least 100 eligible employees.

Employers are required to implement an Employer Trip Reduction Implementation Plan (eTRIP) for each worksite with 100 or more eligible employees to meet applicable targets specified in the rule. Employers are required to facilitate the participation in the eTRIPs by providing information to their employees explaining the requirements and applicability of this rule. Employers are required to prepare and submit an eTRIP for each worksite to SJVAPCD. The eTRIP must be updated annually. Under this rule, employers shall collect information on the modes of transportation used for each eligible employee’s commutes both to and from work for every day of the commute verification period, as defined by using either the mandatory commute verification method or a representative survey method. Annual reporting includes the results of the commute verification for the previous calendar year along with the measures implemented as outlined in the eTRIP and, if necessary, any updates to the eTRIP.

City of Bakersfield Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan The General Plan, dated December 2002, was updated in January 2016 per Resolution No. 018- 16 and 019-16. At the time this EIR was published for public review, the City was in the process of updating its Bakersfield 2045 General Plan, but it had not yet been adopted. The General Plan contains multiple goals and policies within the Conservation Element pertaining to air quality; relevant goals and policies to the Project are listed below:

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-12
Air Quality
Goals

1. Promote air quality that is compatible with health, well-being, and enjoyment of life by controlling point sources and minimizing vehicular trips to reduce air pollutants.

2. Continue working toward attainment of Federal, State, and Local standards as enforced by the SJVAPCD.

3. Reduce the amount of vehicular emissions in the planning area.

Policies

1. Comply with and promote SJVAPCD control measures regarding Reactive Organic Gases (ROG). Such measures are focused on: (a) steam-driven well vents, (b) Pseudo-cyclic wells, (c) natural gas processing plant fugitives, (d) heavy oil test stations, (e) light oil production fugitives, (f) refinery pumps and compressors, and (g) vehicle inspection and maintenance.

2. Encourage land uses and land use practices which do not contribute significantly to air quality degradation.

3. Require dust abatement measures during significant grading and construction operations.

4. Consider air pollution impacts when evaluating discretionary permits for land use proposals.

Considerations should include
a. Alternative access routes to reduce traffic congestion. b. Development phasing to match road capacities
c. Buffers including increased vegetation to increase emission dispersion and reduce impacts of gaseous or particulate matter on sensitive uses.

5. Consider the location of sensitive receptors such as schools, hospitals, and housing developments when locating industrial uses to minimize the impact of industrial sources of air pollution

4.3.2 Environmental Setting
Criteria Air Pollutants
The pollutants emitted into the ambient air by stationary and mobile sources are categorized as primary and/or secondary pollutants. Primary air pollutants are emitted directly from sources.

Carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOC), nitrogen oxides (NOX), sulfur dioxide (SO2), coarse inhalable particulate matter (PM10), fine inhalable particulate matter (PM2.5), and lead (Pb) are primary air pollutants. Of these, CO, SO2, nitrogen dioxide (NO2), PM10, and PM2.5 are “criteria air pollutants,” which means that AAQS have been established for them. VOC and NOX are criteria pollutant precursors that form secondary criteria air pollutants through chemical and photochemical reactions in the atmosphere. Ozone (O3) and NO2 are the principal secondary pollutants.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-13
Each of the primary and secondary criteria air pollutants and its known health effects are described below.

Carbon Monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless gas produced by incomplete combustion of carbon substances, such as gasoline or diesel fuel. CO is a primary criteria air pollutant. CO concentrations tend to be the highest during winter mornings with little to no wind, when surface-based inversions trap the pollutant at ground levels. The highest ambient CO concentrations are generally found near traffic-congested corridors and intersections. The primary adverse health effect associated with CO is interference with normal oxygen transfer to the blood, which may result in tissue oxygen deprivation. The SJVAB is designated as being in attainment/unclassified under both the California AAQS and National AAQS.

Nitrogen Oxides (NOX) are a byproduct of fuel combustion and contribute to the formation of O3, PM10, and PM2.5. The two major forms of NOX are nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2).

The principal form of NO2 produced by combustion is NO, but NO reacts with oxygen to form NO2, creating the mixture of NO and NO2 commonly called NOX. NO2 acts as an acute irritant and, in equal concentrations, is more injurious than NO. At atmospheric concentrations, however, NO2 is only potentially irritating. NO2 absorbs blue light; the result is a brownish-red cast to the atmosphere and reduced visibility. NO2 exposure concentrations near roadways are of particular concern for susceptible individuals, including asthmatics, children, and the elderly. Current scientific evidence links short-term NO2 exposures, ranging from 30 minutes to 24 hours, with adverse respiratory effects, including airway inflammation in healthy people and increased respiratory symptoms in people with asthma. Also, studies show a connection between elevated short-term NO2 concentrations and increased visits to emergency departments and hospital admissions for respiratory issues, especially asthma. The SJVAB is designated in attainment/unclassified under the National AAQS and attainment under the California AAQS.

Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) is a colorless, pungent, irritating gas formed by the combustion of sulfurous fossil fuels. It enters the atmosphere as a result of burning high-sulfur-content fuel oils and coal and chemical processes at plants and refineries. Gasoline and natural gas have very low sulfur content and do not release significant quantities of SO2. When sulfur dioxide forms sulfates (SO4) in the atmosphere, together these pollutants are referred to as sulfur oxides (SOX). Thus, SO2 is both a primary and secondary criteria air pollutant. At sufficiently high concentrations, SO2 may irritate the upper respiratory tract. Current scientific evidence links short-term exposures to SO2, ranging from 5 minutes to 24 hours, with an array of adverse respiratory effects, including bronchoconstriction and increased asthma symptoms. These effects are particularly adverse for asthmatics at elevated ventilation rates (e.g., while exercising or playing) at lower concentrations and when combined with particulates, SO2 may do greater harm by injuring lung tissue. Studies also show a connection between short-term exposure and increased visits to emergency facilities and hospital admissions for respiratory illnesses, particularly in at-risk populations such as children, the elderly, and asthmatics. The SJVAB is designated attainment under California and as attainment/unclassified under the National AAQS.

Suspended Particulate Matter (PM10 and PM2.5) consists of finely divided solids or liquids such as soot, dust, aerosols, fumes, and mists. Two forms of fine particulates are now recognized and regulated. Inhalable coarse particles, or PM10, include the particulate matter with an aerodynamic diameter of 10 microns (i.e., 10 millionths of a meter or 0.0004 inch) or less. Inhalable fine particles, or PM2.5, have an aerodynamic diameter of 2.5 microns (i.e., 2.5 millionths of a meter or 0.0001 inch) or less. Particulate discharge into the atmosphere results primarily from industrial, agricultural, construction, and transportation activities. However, wind action on arid landscapes also contributes substantially to local particulate loading (i.e., fugitive dust). Both PM10 and PM2.5 Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-14
may adversely affect the human respiratory system, especially in people who are naturally sensitive or susceptible to breathing problems.

The EPA’s scientific review concluded that PM2.5, which penetrates deeply into the lungs, is more likely than PM10 to contribute to health effects and at concentrations that extend well below those allowed by the current PM10 standards. These health effects include premature death and increased hospital admissions and emergency room visits (primarily the elderly and individuals with cardiopulmonary disease); increased respiratory symptoms and disease (children and individuals with cardiopulmonary disease such as asthma); decreased lung functions (particularly in children and individuals with asthma); and alterations in lung tissue and structure and in respiratory tract defense mechanisms. There has been emerging evidence that ultrafine particulates, which are even smaller particulates with an aerodynamic diameter of <0.1 microns or less (i.e., ≤0.0001 millimeter) have human health implications because their toxic components may initiate or facilitate biological processes that may lead to adverse effects to the heart, lungs, and other organs. However, the EPA and CARB have not adopted AAQS to regulate these particulates. Diesel particulate matter is classified by CARB as a carcinogen. Particulate matter can also cause environmental effects such as visibility impairment, environmental damage, and aesthetic damage (USEPA 2026a). The SJVAB is a nonattainment area for PM2.5 under California and National AAQS and a nonattainment area for PM10 under the California AAQS and an attainment area under the National AAQS.

Ozone (O3) is a key ingredient of “smog” and is a gas that is formed when VOCs and NOX, both by-products of internal combustion engine exhaust, undergo photochemical reactions in sunlight.

O3 is a secondary criteria air pollutant. O3 concentrations are generally highest during the summer months when direct sunlight, light winds, and warm temperatures create favorable conditions for its formation. O3 poses a health threat to those who already suffer from respiratory diseases as well as to healthy people. Breathing O3 can trigger a variety of health problems, including chest pain, coughing, throat irritation, and congestion. It can worsen bronchitis, emphysema, and asthma. Ground-level O3 also can reduce lung function and inflame the linings of the lungs.

Repeated exposure may permanently scar lung tissue. O3 also affects sensitive vegetation and ecosystems, including forests, parks, wildlife refuges, and wilderness areas. In particular, O3 harms sensitive vegetation during the growing season. The SJVAB is designated extreme nonattainment under the California AAQS (1-hour and 8-hour) and nonattainment under the National AAQS (8-hour).

Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) are composed primarily of hydrogen and carbon atoms.

Internal combustion associated with motor vehicle usage is the major source of VOCs. Other sources include evaporative emissions from paints and solvents, asphalt paving, and household consumer products such as aerosols. There are no AAQS for VOCs. However, because they contribute to the formation of O3, SJVAPCD has established a significance threshold for this pollutant.

Lead (Pb) is a metal found naturally in the environment as well as in manufactured products.

Once taken into the body, lead distributes throughout the body in the blood and accumulates in the bones. Depending on the level of exposure, lead can adversely affect the nervous system, kidney function, immune system, reproductive and developmental systems, and the cardiovascular system. Lead exposure also affects the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood. The effects of lead most commonly encountered in current populations are neurological effects in children and cardiovascular effects in adults (e.g., high blood pressure and heart disease). Infants and young children are especially sensitive to even low levels of lead, which may contribute to behavioral problems, learning deficits, and lowered IQ. The major sources of lead emissions have Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-15
historically been mobile and industrial sources. As a result of the EPA’s regulatory efforts to remove lead from gasoline, emissions of lead from the transportation sector dramatically declined by 95 percent between 1980 and 1999, and levels of lead in the air decreased by 94 percent between 1980 and 1999. Today, the highest levels of lead in air are usually found near lead smelters. The major sources of lead emissions today are ore and metals processing and piston-engine aircraft operating on leaded aviation gasoline. However, in 2008 the EPA and CARB adopted stricter lead standards, and special monitoring sites immediately downwind of lead sources recorded very localized violations of the new state and federal standards. The SJVAB is designated attainment under the California AAQS for lead and No Designation/Classification under the National AAQS. There are no lead-emitting sources associated with the Project, and therefore, lead is not a pollutant of concern for the Project.

Toxic Air Contaminants (TACs)
People exposed to TACs at sufficient concentrations and durations may have an increased chance of getting cancer or experiencing other serious health effects. These health effects can include damage to the immune system as well as neurological, reproductive (e.g., reduced fertility), developmental, respiratory, and other health problems. By the last update to the TAC list in December 1999, CARB had designated 244 compounds as TACs. Additionally, CARB has implemented control measures for a number of compounds that pose high risks and show potential for effective control. There are no air quality standards for TACs. Instead, TAC impacts are evaluated by calculating the health risks associated with a given exposure. The majority of the estimated health risks from TACs can be attributed to relatively few compounds, the most relevant to the Project being particulate matter from diesel-fueled engines.

Diesel Particulate Matter
In 1998, CARB identified diesel particulate matter (DPM) as a TAC. Previously, the individual chemical compounds in diesel exhaust were considered TACs. Almost all diesel exhaust particles are 10 microns or less in diameter. Because of their extremely small size, these particles can be inhaled and eventually trapped in the bronchial and alveolar regions of the lungs. Long-term (chronic) inhalation of DPM is likely a lung cancer risk. Short-term (i.e., acute) exposure can cause irritation and inflammatory symptoms and may exacerbate existing allergies and asthma symptoms.

Climate
The Project is in the central portion of the SJVAB. SJVAB consists of eight counties: Fresno, Kern (western and central), Kings, Tulare, Madera, Merced, San Joaquin, and Stanislaus. Air pollution from significant activities in the SJVAB includes a variety of industrial-based sources as well as on- and off-road mobile sources. These sources, coupled with geographical and meteorological conditions unique to the area, stimulate the formation of unhealthy air.

The SJVAB is approximately 250 miles long and an average of 35 miles wide. It is bordered by the Sierra Nevada in the east, the Coast Ranges in the west, and the Tehachapi mountains in the south. There is a slight downward elevation gradient from Bakersfield in the southeast end (elevation 408 feet) to sea level at the northwest end where the valley opens to the San Francisco Bay at the Carquinez Straits. At its northern end is the Sacramento Valley, which makes up the northern half of California’s Central Valley. The bowl-shaped topography inhibits movement of pollutants out of the valley.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-16
The SJVAB is in a Mediterranean climate zone, which is characterized by sparse rainfall, which occurs mainly in winter. Summers are hot and dry. Summertime maximum temperatures often exceed 100 degrees Fahrenheit (°F) in the valley. Winter-time high pressure events can often last many weeks, with surface temperatures often lowering to 30°F. During these events, fog can be present, and inversions are extremely strong. These wintertime inversions can inhibit vertical mixing of pollutants to a few hundred feet.

In addition, the SJVAB is influenced by a subtropical high-pressure cell for most of the year. The high-pressure cell is strongest during spring, summer, and fall and produces subsiding air, which can result in temperature inversions in the valley. A temperature inversion can act like a lid, inhibiting vertical mixing of the air mass at the surface. Any emissions of pollutants can be trapped below the inversion. Most of the surrounding mountains are above the normal height of summer inversions (1,500 to 3,000 feet).

Temperature
Solar radiation and temperature are particularly important in the chemistry of ozone formation.

The SJVAB averages over 260 sunny days per year. Photochemical air pollution (primarily ozone) is produced by the atmospheric reaction of organic substances (such as volatile organic compounds) and nitrogen dioxide under the influence of sunlight. Ozone concentrations are very dependent on the amount of solar radiation, especially during late spring, summer, and early fall.

Ozone levels typically peak in the afternoon. After the sun goes down, the chemical reaction between nitrous oxide and ozone begins to dominate. This reaction tends to scavenge and remove the ozone in the metropolitan areas through the early morning hours, resulting in the lowest ozone levels, possibly reaching zero at sunrise in areas with high nitrogen oxides emissions. At sunrise, nitrogen oxides tend to peak, partly due to low levels of ozone at this time and also due to the morning commuter vehicle emissions of nitrogen oxides.

Generally, the higher the temperature, the more ozone formed, since reaction rates increase with temperature. However, extremely hot temperatures can “lift” or “break” the inversion layer.

Typically, if the inversion layer does not lift to allow the buildup of contaminants to be dispersed, the ozone levels will peak in the late afternoon. If the inversion layer breaks and the resultant afternoon winds occur, the ozone will peak in the early afternoon and decrease in the late afternoon as the contaminants are dispersed or transported out of the SJVAB. Ozone levels are low during winter periods when there is much less sunlight to drive the photochemical.

Wind
Wind speed and direction play an important role in dispersion and transport of air pollutants. Wind at the surface and aloft can disperse pollution by mixing and transporting it to other locations.

Winds in the valley most frequently blow from the northwest, especially during summer. The region’s topographic features restrict air movement and channel the air mass towards the southeastern end of the valley. Marine air can flow into the basin from the San Joaquin River Delta and over Altamont Pass and Pacheco Pass, where it can flow along the axis of the valley, over the Tehachapi Pass, into the Southeast Desert Air Basin. This wind pattern contributes to transporting pollutants from the Sacramento Valley and the Bay Area into the SJVAB.

Approximately 27 percent of the total emissions in the northern portion, 11 percent of total emissions in the central region, and 7 percent of total emission in the south valley of the SJVAB are attributed to air pollution transported from these two areas. The Coastal Range is a barrier to air movement to the west, and the high Sierra Nevada range is a significant barrier to the east (the highest peaks in the southern Sierra Nevada reach almost halfway through the Earth’s Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-17
atmosphere). Many days in the winter are marked by stagnation events where winds are very weak. Transport of pollutants during winter can be very limited. A secondary but significant summer wind pattern is from the southeast and can be associated with nighttime drainage winds, prefrontal conditions, and summer monsoons.

Two significant diurnal wind cycles that occur frequently in the valley are the sea breeze and mountain-valley upslope and drainage flows. The sea breeze can accentuate the northwest wind flow, especially on summer afternoons. Nighttime drainage flows can accentuate the southeast movement of air down the valley. In the mountains during periods of weak synoptic-scale winds, winds tend to be upslope during the day and downslope at night. Nighttime and drainage flows are especially pronounced during the winter when flow from the east is enhanced by nighttime cooling in the Sierra Nevada. Eddies can form in the valley wind flow and can recirculate a polluted air mass for an extended period.

Precipitation, Humidity, and Fog
Precipitation and fog may reduce or limit some pollutant concentrations. Ozone needs sunlight for its formation, and clouds and fog can block the required solar radiation. Wet fogs can cleanse the air during winter as moisture collects on particles and deposits them on the ground.

Atmospheric moisture can also increase pollution levels. In fogs with less water content, the moisture acts to form secondary ammonium nitrate particulate matter. This ammonium nitrate is part of the valley’s PM 2.5 and PM10 problem. The winds and unstable air conditions during the passage of winter storms result in periods of low pollutant concentrations and excellent visibility.

Between winter storms, high pressure and light winds allow cold moist air to pool on the SJVAB floor. This creates strong low-level temperature inversions and very stable air conditions, which can lead to tule fog. Wintertime conditions favorable to fog formation are also favorable to high concentrations of PM 2.5 and PM10.

Inversions
The vertical dispersion of air pollutants in the San Joaquin Valley can be limited by persistent temperature inversions. Air temperature in the lowest layer of the atmosphere typically decreases with altitude. A reversal of this atmospheric state, where the air temperature increases with height, is termed an inversion. The height of the base of the inversion is known as the “mixing height.” This is the level to which pollutants can mix vertically. Mixing of air is minimized above and below the inversion base. The inversion base represents an abrupt density change where little air movement occurs.

Inversion layers are significant in determining pollutant concentrations. Concentration levels can be related to the amount of mixing space below the inversion. Temperature inversions that occur on the summer days are usually 2,000 to 2,500 feet above the valley floor. In winter months, overnight inversions occur 500 to 1,500 feet above the valley floor.

SJVAB Area Designations
The air quality management plans prepared by SJVAPCD provide the framework for SJVAB to achieve attainment of the State and federal AAQS through the SIP. Areas are classified as attainment or nonattainment areas for particular pollutants depending on whether they meet the ambient air quality standards. Severity classifications for ozone nonattainment range in magnitude from marginal, moderate, and serious to severe and extreme.

Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Environmental Impact Report 4.3 Air Quality
City of Bakersfield – SCH No. 2025101507 4.3-18
• Unclassified. A pollutant is designated unclassified if the data are incomplete and do not support a designation of attainment or nonattainment.
• Attainment. A pollutant is in attainment if the AAQS for that pollutant was not violated at any site in the area during a three-year period.
• Nonattainment. A pollutant is in nonattainment if there was at least one violation of an AAQS for that pollutant in the area.
• Nonattainment/Transitional. A subcategory of the nonattainment designation. An area is designated nonattainment/transitional to signify that the area is close to attaining the AAQS for that pollutant.

The attainment status for the SJVAB is shown in Table 4.3-2 Attainment Status of Criteria Pollutants in the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin.

Table 4.3-2 Attainment Status of Criteria Pollutants in the San Joaquin Valley Air Basin.

Pollutant State Federal
Ozone – 1-hour Severe Nonattainment No Federal Standard1 Ozone – 8-hour Nonattainment Extreme Nonattainment2
PM10 Nonattainment Attainment3
PM2.5 Nonattainment Nonattainment4
CO Attainment/Unclassified Attainment/Unclassified
NO2 Attainment Attainment/Unclassified
SO2 Attainment Attainment/Unclassified
Lead Attainment No Designation/Classification
Hydrogen Sulfide Unclassified No Federal Standard
Sulfates Attainment No Federal Standard
Visibility Reducing Particles Unclassified No Federal Standard Vinyl Chloride Attainment No Federal Standard
Source: CARB 2026a; SJVAPCD 2026c.
1 Though the Valley was initially classified as serious nonattainment for the 1997 8-hour ozone standard, the EPA approved Valley reclassification to extreme nonattainment in the Federal Register on May 5, 2010 (effective June 4, 2010). 2 Effective June 15, 2005, the EPA revoked the federal 1-hour ozone standard, including associated designations and classifications. The US EPA had previously classified the SJVAB as extreme nonattainment for this standard. The US EPA approved the 2004 Extreme Ozone Attainment Demonstration Plan on March 8, 2010 (effective April 7, 2010). Many applicable requirements for extreme 1-hour ozone nonattainment areas continue to apply to the SJVAB.
3 On September 25, 2008, the EPA redesignated the San Joaquin Valley to attainment for the PM10 National AAQS and approved the PM10 Maintenance Plan.
4 The Valley is designated nonattainment for the 1997 PM2.5 National AAQS. The EPA designated the Valley as nonattainment for the 2006 PM2.5 National AAQS on November 13, 2009 (effective December 14, 2009).

Existing Ambient Air Quality
Existing levels of ambient air quality and historical trends and projections in the vicinity of the Project Site are best documented by measurements taken by the SJVAPCD. The air quality monitoring station closest to the Project is the Bakersfield-5558 California Avenue Monitoring Station, which is one of 29 monitoring stations SJVAPCD operates and maintains in the SJVAB.

Data from this station includes measurements of O3, NO2, PM10, and PM2.5 and are summarized in Table 4.3-3 Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Summary. The most current five years of data from this monitoring station is included in Table 4.3-3 Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Summary and show regular violations of the state and federal O3, state and federal PM10 standards, and federal PM2.5 standards in the last five years.

← All documents from this meeting